TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2014

Trails Committee

· recording 2 hr 26 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

302 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 No returns. There he is. I hope so. Folks, sounds like we're still waiting. I'm Granicus, so we're going to wait a couple more minutes before we get started. I might have it. Is this thing on?

5:36 Okay, I'm going to go ahead and call this meeting of, the regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee open. So if we don't have Granicus at this time, I'll just go ahead and say that right now, but hopefully by the time we get through presentations, consent agenda, and public comment, not in that order, that we will have Granicus up and running. Steve, you think? We'll see. Okay. At this time, why don't you go ahead and take a roll call, please. Here.

6:08 I am present. Thank you. Public comment. This is the time when we ask anyone to come forward and address an item that would not otherwise be on the agenda. If there's any public comments, now is the time. Laura, Friends of the Inyo. This is related to an agenda item, but I just wanted to take a minute and introduce

6:45 Two of our trail system stewards from last summer, Casey Penn and Chris Niebuhr, who are here with us today. Thanks very much for making their positions possible. Okay, thank you. Hi. Hi. Roy Moyer, Tamarack Lodge and Resort. I'm here to, first of all, say I love the trail system, and it's been very good in the summertime and things like that. The activities are great. We see more and more people up there recreating. In the wintertime,

7:22 It's grown to be such a popular event that it's starting to create problems for the cross-country ski center that I operate as well as, you know, it's really an access corridor for lots of different activities. You know, we see lots of people bringing dogs up. The dogs basically have feces all over the place. My staff has to pick it up or the really nice blue bags that people put their poop in.

7:51 And then throw it in the woods. It's starting to be another problem. You know, we used to have a lot of backcountry skiers, and that's not an issue going up there. In the past, what we've done is we groomed the trails, and then just to help people to stay on the access corridor, we groomed an area for them to go. Now it's advertised as a groomed activity. It's creating conflicts with people walking on which trail.

8:22 Despite the signing, they walk on our ski trails as they walk on the access border. We've had confrontation with backcountry skiers, you know, saying they can go anywhere they want. Insufficient parking is a big issue this past Christmas. We had a lot of people coming up to hike and walk because we didn't have an adequate snow season up there. From the Twin Lakes Road all the way to Tamarack, we had people parking all over there.

8:52 To create a one lane road. That one lane road, we would not be able to have a fire department vehicle get through there. So that was another issue. We just don't have sufficient parking for the activities that are going on up there. Let me see. In the website itself, it says a featured destination. The problem is we don't have enough parking for that whole area.

9:22 So it's a feature area with not enough parking. We need to have some additional parking made or developed over there before we start calling that a feature. Sledding. It's promoted as a sledding place for people to go up. What happens is people sled on the hill, slide into the skiers that have paid for a lift or a trail pass, and so we've had problems with people getting hit by sledders. That's another issue. Back to the dogs, we've had dog bites where people let their dogs run.

9:53 And then they go bite people. We've had a few instances that I've talked to John about as well with employees getting bit. So we just need to manage this a little bit better. So I wanted to bring it to your attention. Hopefully we can work together and develop some systems in the wintertime as well as how popular it is in the summer. But we need a little help in the wintertime to manage this. We do the grooming.

10:20 And, you know, it's tough when the grooming is destroyed by people just walking all over the trails, especially when it's soft snow. They post hole through and then it creates a bad experience for my guests. So, thank you. Okay, thank you very much. Roy, I just had a brief question. So, you've actually been grooming in addition to your normal groom track. When you go up the hill, up Lake Mary Road, our trails are on the right-hand side.

10:50 The access quarters on the left. We do have signage throughout, and we've even started roping it to kind of give people a clue. People go and, you know, start up the one trail and then lose. Okay. We don't have to groom them. Right, I didn't think so, right. You know, that's something that we did just to alleviate the problems we had in the past and it worked pretty well. But when you have, you know, now it's tenfold what we used to have. You know, a lot of it's the visitor center sending people up. A lot of it's the website.

11:24 It's just more popular, but it's a problem. It's growing. And I'm sure some of it was a lack of snow, and people are going skiing because it wasn't as good as it had been in the past, but it's a place to walk your dog, and now we have a big issue. That was going to be my question. How much year over year has that grown? Is this a problem that may well go away itself if we have reasonable snow next year? And we will have, I promise.

11:54 Yeah. Take that to the bank, huh? No, we've had problems before, Bill. Yeah. It's just gotten worse. And it could be two, three years ago when we didn't have much snow, it wasn't as big an issue. You know, this year was just really hard. Yeah, but this year we haven't virtually moved across country until just the last few weeks that changed. Yeah. That's an issue. Do you guys have any potential recommendations to go with the issues of the problems?

12:25 We'll probably put a person, we'll post a person on the trail where we haven't, we've been doing it depending on the budgets, depending on what the weather was like, we post a person out there. I think we'll have to do it full time next year. But you know, the problem is people go back past the, we'll call it a welcome center, and then they'll disregard once they go past that.

12:49 It sounds like a, thank you for bringing this to our attention. Some things we might be able to address fairly quickly with regard to what the website didn't last, but essentially kind of look towards the future and thank you for bringing these concerns to us. That's why I'm here today. Okay. So by next year we can get it worked out. Okay. And I've been in contact with John as well. Yeah, I just want to say, Roy, thanks for bringing it to my attention. Roy's been letting me know some of these issues going on all winter long.

13:14 And I think when you see the website presentation today, you'll see that some of the analytics you can tie the website a little bit to the use that we're seeing up there, which is, you know, we should just celebrate that. I think this is a good example of how our efforts to promote the Mammoth Lakes Trail System have direct impacts in management issues, management implications on the ground that we have to think very critically about, whether that means changing regulations, increasing patrols,

13:44 Or just promoting better education and awareness in the area. All of those things are potential solutions, but ultimately the decision on what uses will or will not occur will rest with the National Forest, the U.S. Forest Service up in that area. And I think we'd like to talk with the MLTSCC about what your ideas are, but it may be that not everything can happen in the same place all at once. We may need to segregate the uses a little bit up there to protect safety and to protect the interest the ski area has in that area.

14:15 Comments? Thanks. Yeah. Thanks. Steve, let's make a note to agendize that for a future meeting. It doesn't probably need to happen until later this summer, but certainly so that we're addressing it for next year. Okay, any other comments? Any other public comments? Okie doke. Let's go ahead and close public comments. This time, we are going to have a presentation by MLTS, MLTS Website Management Report.

14:50 Thank you very much. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. We're currently the website content manager. One thing just to follow up what Roy said. I know that you guys are investing in the environmental for the SHARP document. The Sherman Working Group spent a lot of time focused on exactly the problems that Roy is talking about up there at the Lake Mary Spur. It's one of the recommendations in SHARP. John, I'm sure, is aware of it. It might be something to refer to when you start having your discussion.

15:17 What the rationale and the discussions came out of the Sherman Working Group. We've already got a good planning thing, left brain kind of a planning thing, but something's there. You might want to refer to that when you bring it up later. So, with no further ado, I'm going to make this pretty short. I know you guys have a lot of work to do today. And this is a presentation that was given to the MLTS website partners on Friday. Nicole Montano, who's the webmaster, was going to make this presentation today, but she's a little under the weather, so I volunteered to fill in.

15:46 So this is reporting on website activity from November through April. And as you can see, there's about 8,000 unique visitors to the site with about 35,000 page views. It's important to keep in mind that the numbers for last summer, Mammoth Lakes Tourism did a very good job promoting and marketing the website. They were confident in the content that was available on the site for summer activities.

16:12 Going into this fall and winter, the content was not as sufficient as it was for the summer. I think it's better now. We've built those 190 webpages and we've done what we could for the winter photography. But there was not a lot of marketing from Mammoth Lakes Tourism for the website during this period. And that was because the content wasn't, they didn't want to be pushing people to something that wasn't, that they didn't feel was quite up to snuff. The thing to think about also is that despite that, I mean, you just heard Roy Moyer saying it is,

16:39 And John Kestmerski has hit it right on the head. This is a critical and should be a valuable management tool to help direct people where you want people to go, feature things that you want to feature and tell people to go where they want to go. But in any event, so it was about 8,000 visitors, 35,000 page views. And the overview of the visits, visits, unique visitors, page views. This is just basic Google Analytics. There are no...

17:05 Campaigns that went on during this process. This is just what the basic traffic of the site was over the last, you know, six or so months. And the question then is, well, how are people finding this site? How are they getting there? Organic search means someone went into Google and searched and said Mammoth Lakes Trail System or Mammoth Trail, something like that. That's the primary way that people are finding it. And then the referrals, directs in social media and email, I'll talk a little bit in a second about.

17:34 Where these referrals are coming from. So again, you can see at the top where it says Google Organic. Google went through something a couple years ago where they're not allowed to do it from a referring website. You can see Visit Mammoth at about 1100. The town was about 300. MLTPA about 300. Yahoo Organic Long and the Forest Service is right there. Forest Service is cracking the top 10. We're all very excited about that. And so those are the sources of the traffic. Again, this is without a

18:03 The kind of really expert marketing muscle that Mammoth Lakes Tourism can put behind this stuff. But even without that, this is how the site's being visited and used. So in the partner meeting, we also talked about the transition we're going to make from the winter content now into the early spring and summer content. And it should be pointed out that we have some content now for fall, fall color viewing and things like that. So in the summer to fall transition, there's content to go to. We're lean on the content of winter to sort of the spring.

18:33 Into the summer. And I think what we typically have up here is the high country is going to be in snow, but there are going to be things in the low country that mountain biking and hiking and things like that that people can do. That content is an area that could use some further development going forward. But we're going to make the transition going from the winter into the summer season. All the content is there for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. They do a great job this summer of pushing this site. They're very confident in all the content that's there that's now available. They can pull all their stops out and do what they want to do.

19:02 And these recommendations were reviewed with the Forest Service and the town of Mammoth Lakes Tourism on Friday, and we all feel pretty good about that. We'll be making the transition over here pretty soon, pretty shortly. So that's what I've got for the moment. Again, I wanted to make this brief because I know you guys have a lot of work to do. If you have any questions, I'd be more than happy to answer them, and if John has any insights or anything, I'm more than happy to answer. Any questions? I just have one clarification, John. I'm sorry, can you interrupt me? Sure.

19:36 Yes. Yes. Thank you very much. Okay. Okay, thanks. Do we have Granicus yet? Yes, I've been informed that it's been reporting all the time, but there's a problem with this particular computer connecting to that, so I can't take notes on the computer, but I can do it old school. Old school it is. Continue on. Greg, could you get our lights again? He was heading out with me. Uh-huh. Buddy heard me. Thank you. Thank you, Greg.

20:14 Consent agenda. Would anyone like to have anything pulled from the consent agenda? I will make a motion to approve consent items 1, 2, 3. And I'll second. Got a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Just a comment. I really appreciate Steve's breakout. I think of, for so often...

20:36 So long we were having everything called administration. It was general administration when a lot of times it was really project management and contract management. So I really appreciate that second sheet which shows that a lot of it is project management and contract management that's being charged to measure our... That was also related to the recreation commission. Exactly. I know that there was some confusion in the recreation commission. I think this has probably clarified it a lot, huh? Okay, great. Comment noted.

21:05 No further discussion. Those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Agenda passes. Real quick, before we get into the business matters, I am going to really make sure that we are moving things along, so hopefully we've all done our homework and are able to, once we're able to have the business matter presented and discussed, that we'll essentially just take turns with comments, but let's just keep it to one round each, please.

21:35 And I'm going to try and hold us to that. Thank you. Okay, business matter number four, discuss and take action regarding soft surface trail maintenance, basin stewards program, and et cetera. I do have a handout I'd like to pass out as we go through this. You may remember that these items have been on our agenda for the last at least two, three months.

22:03 We've had discussions about them. We've asked for information coming back from nonprofits to help us put together estimates as to what a proper budget might be. We've gone through and evaluated different event scenarios for you, and I'm going to pass out my current recommendation for a general item number four, having to do with socks with Australians, Australians days, Lake Fish and Stewart program, and also winter grooming. Are we going to take them one at a time?

22:34 Are we going to take them one at a time? Let's actually put it all together. I think that they're both similar if there's something that needs to be broken out. They're three separate budgets. Yeah. They do tie in well together. I mean, Sandy, if you'd like, what we can do is if you want to bring out specific, something specific. Well, I was going to point out actually in Steve's PowerPoint, too often people seem to think that the Lakes Basin stewards and the SOS days are one thing and they're two separate.

23:08 Totally separate programs. You know, one is a partnership one, but the other one is totally separate. So I think we need to make sure we try to keep some of these so we don't confuse the public. What we've done in the packet is included the Friends of the Inyo proposals and budgeting for summer stewardship. There's an explanation about program, budget, and some options. That two-page sheet is followed by

23:42 A number of scenarios for cost reduction. They're all included in that. And so my recommendation at this point is to have five events and to take the Friends of Inyo reduced leader option, and that would establish then a maximum budget of $12,675 for those five events on the trust for Friends of Inyo type.

24:12 The second is to provide options for our review and consideration. The estimate at this point for five events, which I am recommending, is for an estimated cost not to exceed $20,943, and I include with that a recommendation to remove the purchasing of new hats, t-shirts, banners,

24:46 And removing the 10% contingency for a savings of $3,800. So that's my current recommendation to you for this summer's soft service trail maintenance, our project number 511. Okay. At this point, let's go ahead and take some questions. Sandy, you want to start? Yeah, actually, I went through and did a kind of an analysis of the two budgets because it's two partners' budgets.

25:17 And I have a handout also. It was based on the original one. But I am, you know, I'm very happy to see the MLTPA recommendation because actually that was one of the things that looks like hats, t-shirts, banner, contingency, some of those could come off as hard costs. The Friends of the Inyo one, I worry about the reduced leaders option, but I assume built in there is the number of, you would allow so many, just so many participants. Is that correct? Yes.

25:47 Okay, that's what I thought. So I want this analysis, I know we've talked about this over and over again, but my background, of course, for years as a district ranger, I was brought a lot of projects to analyze, and some of the questions that I first always asked was, what's absolutely essential to do this project, what are the nice to do's, and what are the bells and whistles? And those are the kind of things that I would look at and say, well,

26:13 You know, you've got to have this, you've got to have that. So all I did in these two analyses, I'll pass out first the Friends of the Inyo one, and all I did was just took their format, but I dropped off a couple of categories. You'll see, Steve. And if you want to pass out, I've got only about four or five here for the others. Maybe give one to John and pass that out there. But I just used their format, because I thought their format was pretty simple. That's just the same one you'll find in the packet.

26:43 And what I did is I dropped out the volunteer hours, okay, because probably both of you are claiming volunteer hours out there. And the total category value, I dropped that one out also because really the Forest Service also is a partner in here and they give staff time. Keith Dolly's always out there, I know, things like that. So all I did was just look at what's the measure I request and what's given for in-kind and matching funds.

27:14 And what's cost per event? And looking at the friends of the annual one, okay, I looked at what they're doing, okay, the salaries and benefits. These are for crew leaders, which you have to have. I looked at, and I think we've got plenty of volunteer time from the executive director and from others, whatever.

27:41 But you pretty much have to have those folks out there. They're trained crew leaders, they're certified. Forest Service isn't going to allow this to go on without folks like that, is that correct? We appreciate having training folks. Basically trained that you've certified. Okay, so in other words, that's a necessary, those salaries and benefits. I haven't heard him say necessary as much as I heard him say appreciated. Oh, I'm sorry, okay. Would this go on without certified folks leading the crews?

28:07 We need that out there, so yes, it's necessary. I think if you wanted to talk about different approaches to training volunteers, we could do that, but to get all these people who just show up one day trained up and have them perform the tasks that we're asking to do safely, this level of oversight is required. Okay, thank you. Because they give the tailgate safety session and, you know, job hazard analysis, all that kind of stuff that's for service requires. The publications and outreaches,

28:36 $500 is contributed, so I don't even look at that. Tools and supplies, absolutely necessary. They finish all the gloves and the, you know, all of the tools, whatever, replacement. As a matter of fact, there, there's over a 50% match, it looks like, that comes from their own budget. Insurance, they carry the majority of the insurance, which is also required. I'm sure they require the Forest Service to be additionally, additional insured. That's usually a...

29:02 Condition, okay. So your total measured R cost is $13,875, and this is for the original one, not the limited one. Excuse me, can I call a point of order, please? Sure. What my intent today, and for the committee, and I think what the chairman and I discussed, we need to do is establish budgets. This is not an element of a contract proposal. I think the detail we're getting down to.

29:27 Absolutely. Absolutely. Well, I'm just pointing.

29:54 Again, I hope we can keep this a little bit higher. Right, and I have a second sheet that's exactly the same, that shows the other side, so you can compare apples and apples. Because over what's happened in the last three discussions, it seems like we constantly ask a lot of cuts, and we ask a lot of in-kind contributions, but we don't from the other side. So let me, okay, the cost per event to measure R, from that one,

30:20 But my concern, Sandy, and I think actually Steve is well heard that, you know, what we're trying to do is actually look at overall budgets and then get into detail. So I'm not sure if this is something that should maybe be discussed after a motion is considered. Well, I think. I mean, are we trying to, are you getting to a motion at this point? Yep, I could. Okay. We haven't had a chance for the other committee members to ask any questions yet. Right.

30:49 So if you could just, you know, kind of, I hate to say it like this, but. Yep, get to the point. Make the point. Okay, make the point. The second sheet will make the point, I think, what we're looking at. And again, all I did here was take MLT, I just put them in the same format, so you can compare. Okay, so what do I look at? We're looking at the total measure, our cost per event. Okay. Okay, the first one is what I consider the essentials, and the second one, and I'm very happy to see John cutting some of the, what I would call the bells and whistles out.

31:19 You know, the banner, the hats, and the things like that. Basically, I just wanted to have a good comparison, so we see what it's costing per event, Measure R, one, for essential services, and two, for maybe the nice to do's and the bell to do's. So what you've presented here is essentially your summary that it costs MLTPA $20,900 to do an event, and Friends of the Inyo $13,800 to do an event.

31:48 Well, I think the bottom cost per event is below that. Okay, I'm sorry. That would be five events. Yeah. And so I guess what I'm saying is I would like to see a little bit more match perhaps from MLTPA and salaries, and I really appreciate the fact of dropping a lot of, and I would suggest dropping some of the ads and publications and things like that because I think at this point our word of mouth is fabulous. We're getting, I mean, it's wonderful to see the

32:14 The people come in that we get. It's 50% probably, I heard, of returnees. So, you know, maybe we don't need quite as many ads, quite as many postcards, things like that. Maybe those are additional cuts. Because what I've heard from the committee is we want to see cuts. All right. Any further questions? No. Not on those. Just take a look at the figures. I'm trying to figure out how to present it so we can look at the two contracts. It's apples to apples. Okay.

32:43 Peter, any questions? Well, two things. The first thing is that the budget from the Friends at Inyo

33:21 Was requested for an increase because so many people are showing up. And I think you have to make the assumption that the reason so many people are showing up is because you guys have invested in marketing. That's why people are there. If you want to cut back on all that marketing, you can certainly do that. It'd be interesting to kind of find out what happens with the numbers of the people that show up at the events, but that's within your purview and you can do what you want to do. I think, Peter, to your point that the volunteers appreciate

33:47 The hats, the T-shirts, they wear them. You know, as I mentioned, John Kazmerski had a hat that showed up in a Patagonia catalog for further marketing of the program and that we have this great trail system up here. There's a lot of sort of unanticipated things that happen if you do that kind of stuff. The second thing is if we have to start getting into a position of selling these things, then we have to have someone who's handling money and dealing with money and all this other kind of stuff that might – we wouldn't be able to save costs on the staff side of having to have that kind of capacity in place.

34:16 I think it's very important. Mammoth Mountain Skier just went through something with their MVP passes where there was this thing about everybody's going to get $200 and apparently all kinds of chaos ensued. We've established a certain level of expectation for a volunteer. When they show up, they get well fed. We've already raised $1,000 from the Sunrise Roadway Club to cover all the costs of the meals for the summer. People have a certain expectation of what it is they're going to find when they show up there. You guys are obviously within your discretion to do whatever it is you want to do.

34:45 But I would just, it's probably good to just kind of game it out a little bit and see what might happen with the expectations of the folks that show up. That's all I can say. Thank you. Just keep moving things. Peter, any further questions? Okay, I've got some follow-up questions to that. Bill? On the T-shirts and hats, I'd love to see us go out and get corporate sponsorships of those, put their logo on it, put Trail Days on it. I think that's a great solution to that. If I was Tony and Phyllis, Tony, are you listening? I'd sponsor.

35:17 Hats and T-shirts for an event or two. I just think that's a great combination and it adds to our marketing without adding to it. I'm going to make the same comments I always make. This is an awful lot of money for two projects that primarily exist in one place. If we spend that percentage of our budget there, and I'm going to recommend we do this year, I'm going to go along with Steve's suggestions because it has been so successful and we haven't found another way to do it.

35:44 Last statement being, we need to find a better way, maybe it's going to be MLR, I don't know, we need to find a better way of pulling these off so that we can have these events without this kind of cost. You give me all the money to spend on this and I can just about hire professionals to take care of the work being done. So that's, my recommendation is going to be to go with the recommended funding levels that Steve has put out here. And I would even make that a motion if you want.

36:14 Not yet, because I do have just a couple of questions, but, you know, if there is a lot of pressure on me to keep these meetings going along in such a way that we're asking questions first, then we are actually taking motions second and then discussing the motion at that time. So the questions that I have is, would the Forest Service have any problems if MLTPA or Forest Friends of the Inyo goes out and gets shirts from corporate sponsors that has their logos on it, but that at the same time promotes summary stewardship or

36:44 Trails Days? I don't think there's any issue with promoting some of our stewardship or trails days, but the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, we've got to be careful about corporate sponsorship of the trail system versus the event. So I believe the event would be fine as long as the advertising and the way it was, you know, on the t-shirts or hats or whatever clearly showed that those sponsors were supporting those events and not the trail system itself. Fair enough. Well, John, Laura, come see Mammoth Company then.

37:13 You know, what do you, and this is a question more for John and Laura, I am concerned a little bit about the reduced advertising because I think that that actually has been some of your best success in getting people out and I'm wondering if you can speak to anything further about that. You know, what do you think the effect is going to be if you're not able to do, or I guess I should say have to really be more cost conscious with your advertising? Well, there's a couple things.

37:44 The print advertising is about as minimal as we could possibly do it. They're very small ads. I think there's two in the sheet and one in the Mammoth Times. The radio advertising is a very good value. It's not that expensive, but it tends to get out to a lot of people. And it gives our friends, Dino and us, a chance to participate in the community shows and that kind of stuff. I think if, again, the town has a proposal for an intellectual property program for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, which I don't believe has been acted on yet,

38:10 But if John can give you some sort of anecdotal advice about, okay, we can attach logos or things like that to T-shirts and things like that, maybe we can take those out of this budget, but find a way to go out and get those sponsors to make it happen, those are things that could probably help. I think it would be great if the Mammoth Trails Program was still being funded by this committee. We've got money from Marno County to go out and have these meetings and try to bring folks together to do it, but typically we look for a business sponsor for each event, for those, you know,

38:40 Mammoth Brewing, all kinds of people have provided sponsorship. Sunrise Rotary will this year. And then we also look to the user groups to provide the volunteers to make these things happen. Not having that capacity in place makes it a little bit challenging, but that might be a way to be proactively investing and bringing capacity without having to do with actual dollars.

38:58 The marketing is probably pretty thin. It covers all the bases, but again, it's up to you guys. If you want to say, look, this is too much. We want to try and experiment. Let's cut back with everything and let's try a word of mouth promotional campaign this summer and see how it works. We could try that. But I'd hate for you to be investing and having friends of the Inyo up there with their tools all ready to go and four people show up. So it's a balance. You're a businessman. You know how this stuff works.

39:27 To start with, your baseline is what's been done to date has delivered the kind of success that you're seeing. So if Frenzendino needs more people to handle more people, okay, well, something's working, and then just it's almost like a business perspective. You've got to figure out, okay, well, if we cut back here, how are things going to balance out? It's an art much more than a science. Ask the people at General Motors in Detroit about that kind of stuff. I'll tell you the same thing. Well, and I'm just looking at the fact that there's none.

39:59 Is there? I mean, is there any budgeted right now for print advertising at all? Oh, yeah. Yes. Absolutely. I'm looking at the wrong... MLTPA proposals. Yeah. It's pretty heavy. Oh, I'm looking, I'm sorry, I'm looking at MLTS stewards. Yeah, I think you'll find that the only marketing that's been cut out... Sorry, I was looking at the wrong one. ...t-shirts and the hats, and $600 for ads that was in the FOI budget, is that right, Steve?

40:27 Didn't I see that somewhere? But that's contributed. And it's contributed. So I guess, you know, to me, if they're matching it and contributing it, it's not a big deal. But it's where I see us being charged, in other words, the taxpayer. So just a quick rundown of what the hard advertising costs are. The sheet...

40:50 Two ads the week before and the week of. Mammoth Times, one ad. Radio advertising. I think it's about 20 or 30 ads that run in the week or two before the event. A postcard that we take out that you'll see in the Sweet Z. We distribute those all over town. Flyer distributions for each event. We've got a flyering list. We go around town, put the flyers up. And then T-shirts, hats, and the banner printing. But the promotional stuff is those first five lines on top. I will add that last year we saw a

41:22 37, little over 37% increase in participation in the program. Thank you. Do you want to make that motion? I will make the motion that we accept the proposed budget provided to us by Steve on the 511, 472, and 551. That makes sense. That's my motion. I can second. Okay. Okay.

41:58 If there's any further discussion, now's the time. Now's the time. Right, right. One of the things I'd like to see is some sort of contribution by MLTPA staff because you see a huge contribution. I think it's 41% is the match by Friends of the Inyo. And the only match that I see that's offered by MLTPA is some patches. And I don't understand. Are those patches in stock, John?

42:26 Couple things. The first thing is, just a point of clarification, Steve. In your proposal, just before you vote on this, you've got $20,943, savings of $3,800. Is the amount that they're voting on $20,000 less $3,800? Which I think that's your intent, right? Okay, good. Just go ahead. Okay, I'm just reading this. I just wanted to make sure that we're clear on that. MLTPA, you know, Sandy, you made a point at the last meeting that somehow we managed to spend all of our budget last year, which is correct.

43:04 We're in the same position that Friends of the Inyo is. All the extra work, the extra hours, all the things that we have to do, we provide for free, we do it. We don't maybe document it the same way that Friends of the Inyo does. We could if you'd like. But I think that MLTPA staff has made an ongoing and pretty significant contribution to this program. If that's something that you'd like us to see documented, we can. I don't generally go to my staff and ask them to work for free.

43:30 Typically, if the free hours come, they come from me. I'm the person who puts in the extra work and makes sure that the project gets done within the budget. And I'm not sure if that's how you guys typically want to contract for things, but I think if there's a budget and there's an agreed-upon amount of money for a series of events that are going to happen, we're going to commit, we're going to show up, and we're going to make them happen, and we always have. Thank you. Yeah, my question about the patches, John, are those in stock? Is that what, or, because it seems like $1,000 for patches. No, we had a contribution from a donor.

44:00 And so we had spoke with Frangeno about doing this, and there's a local embroidery shop that I've been trying to get a prototype out of that we're willing to contribute up to $1,000 for patches that the stewards could wear, the volunteers could wear, something like that, if that's something that would be desired by the committee. It's available if you want it, if you'd like to have it, it's available, but I'm not going to just make $1,000 worth of patches, they're not going to get used. No, that was my question. So if there's $1,000, would that donor...

44:29 Be willing to just donate it to the cost of, we could, we could do that, again, I just, we could take off another thousand is what I'm looking at. Well, that's, that's one way to do it, but is there another way to get better value, I don't know. Are these patches, patches that we're going to use to identify the stewards and stuff out on the trails, MLTFCC workers? Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Yeah. It would be, it would be a branding attempt to use it so that when the stewards are out there in the field, you can say Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Again, it's, it's a, it's a,

44:58 It's something that the committee could use to enhance the program. If you thought it would be better just to take it off the budget, I guess we could do that, but I think maybe it's a better idea to use it for something you guys might think is a good idea to use a lot. Is this a straight-up cash donation or an in-kind donation? It was a cash donation. So it could be used elsewhere. That's my main... Yeah, if you want to... Again, we offered it to the committee and to the trail system as a way to maybe bring some value to some of these programs. I like it. The cash donation? No, I like the...

45:28 Patches that people can wear to identify and to brand the trips. A thousand dollars worth of patches is what bothers me. That's okay. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion from this dais? Any comments from the audience? One thing that you might want to consider is I noticed a lot of money was allocated for photography, and I think perhaps once you do one summer stewardship event in the summer,

46:02 I don't know that you need to document each and every event. Perhaps that's a way to save a little bit of money for consideration. Again, I think, Mr. Chair, sorry I'm speaking out again. We're looking to set a budget here and not do a line item. We can always come back and take out more if necessary. But I am very comfortable with the figures that have been brought forward in terms of moving those forward in the budget.

46:30 Yeah, for purposes of expedition here, thank you for reminding me that this is not a line item discussion as much as an overall budget. But thank you for your point and comment, Pat. Any further comments? Okay, we've got a motion and a second, so I think it's time to take a vote. Let's roll call this. Thanks, Bill. Steve, you want to go ahead and roll call? Sandy Hogan. No, with a comment, but I think that there are further cuts that would make a lot of sense because I believe the non-essentials,

47:02 Are costing more than the essentials. Yes. Yes. Chairman Schott Turner. Yes. Motion passes. Three to one. Thank you. Thank you both. Getting to the next business matter, number five. Yeah, so the next item is also within the information that Friends in Inyo has provided with the cover letter.

47:45 Well, if you get into the document, the first three or four pages or so, you'll see Mammoth Lakes Trail System Stewards, Project 472, again, is a rationale, a history, some recap of the events of 2013, a budget statement, also a talk of the total value of the program, and then options for cuts are mentioned there as well in the text.

48:15 Following that, there are spreadsheets then for our consideration for budgets with various reductions ranging, the budget amounts ranging from $35,800 down to $33,400. Hey, Steve, before you go any further, it sounds like there's some confusion. Did I not make a motion that covered putting your suggested

48:43 Amounts in for 511, 472, and 551? You're absolutely correct. I apologize. Okay, so we can now draw your attention to an agenda item number five. So that puts the number four to rest with that vote. Number five is discuss and take action regarding proposed projects to be determined items and proposed funding.

49:10 For the Maniflase Trail System Coordinating Committee Master Project and Budget Tracking List, Participator 14 and 15. And so here, the handout that I gave you earlier addresses agenda item number five with a list of project types and funding that are appropriate with that. And that goes along with, again, the master tracker form that's in your packet.

49:37 So if I can draw your attention to the first item, which is two-thirds of the way down the first page of your capital projects and planning, project number 412. Actually, there's a bit of a name change there. We're going to call it a challenge cost share agreement with the U.S. Forest Service. This is developed scope, standard budgets, and deployment of Mammoth Lakes Trail System's soft surface trail system.

50:05 And the current recommendation that staff is making is for a $5,000 budget to cover that work, that coordination with the Forest Service, that negotiation, and putting together the costs that go into the cost share agreement, the scope, and again, getting that agreement into full compliance and agreement by all parties.

50:32 That's why we want to do these one at a time. Well, I think we probably need to have a few details, right? You get Johns to go through them all. Yeah, once you go through them all and then let's take some notes and then come back to individuals. Right, because we're going to get some questions answered. Yeah, I think we want to have John's comments. It's a great tone to cross. It's a new item 146. It's over snow vehicle NEPA review. We've had discussions in the past with Forest Service about the issues and concerns for this.

50:59 The latest information that I have from the Forest Service is that they would be going after a grant to help write this. The value of that grant may be as much as $66,000 gross. And my suggestion is that the committee participate at a recommended level of $20,000, which reduces then the Forest Service at $46,000. The next project that I have great talent on the second page,

51:28 It is about a third of the way down, and that was Project 331.02, known as the Sharp Ferris Construction Funding. And what I suggest here, along with down towards the bottom two-thirds of the page, is Project 441, which is our capital reserve fund, is to take then the net balance of all the recommendations that I've made,

51:57 And to bind them in half between these two projects so that we do end up with a round number of even a $300,000 allotment that we are given to work with by council. Now, we do have an opportunity here that we may want to think about, and I've got some information on the board over there in about five minutes.

52:26 CIP Project, known as the Waterford Gap Closure Project. Now, my understanding is that moving forward tomorrow with the rec commission will be a proposal for a special measure allocation to provide some additional funding to that project to add on some complementary aspects to it to make it a robust project.

52:49 So what I'd like to suggest is if for some reason that measure of our proposal does not go through, then we have the ability to take these two funds, the Sharp Trail Construction Fund that we'll put capital balance in and our capital reserve fund, bind those two together and make those funds available to augment the Waterford Gap closure. And again, Waterford Gap is one of our key Mammoth projects. It falls in line exactly with what

53:19 Trail System Master Plan requires for our high priorities, which is to complete our bumps and linkages throughout. And then the final part of item number five is I recommend to the committee that they accept all other 2014-15 staff recommendations for funding and again pointing out that these are engineer's estimates and these are budget figures that are presented on this latest version, April 7th.

53:48 2014 Trail System Mastermind Boarding Committee, Master Project of Tracking List. Again, this will be finally, these recommendations will be carried forward to the Recreation Commission for their approval, and then finally on to the Town Council, and that work should begin, mainly with their budget. But other than that, I'm available for any other questions, I'll be particularized. Okay. So again, what I think we're going to try and do here is essentially just keep, in the next few minutes,

54:20 Dedicated to just questions about the proposal that Steve just outlined, then seek motions and then go into discussion. I think we almost need to go through these one at a time as he did. As far as questions, yeah. As far as we go to the actual motion or the motion should be all one in terms of questions and coming up. That's fine. Yeah, just to clarify, clarifying questions, right? Peter, should we start down there with you, your questions? Okay, actually 412.

54:51 John? So I think that the idea with this one, and John and I can talk a little bit together, is currently the measure of our requirements really is own or manage. And so this is really developing a document that helps the Forest Service and the town manage jointly some of the projects that we're working on, particularly in lakespace. It's kind of a stepping stone for what we might do in the Sharps area.

55:18 For soft surface, but essentially that was the idea of this to develop that document so that it can be adopted and then we're in compliance with the measure of our requirement to either own or manage the facilities that we're spending money on. Okay. Is that a question about the change in the special use permit? Well, it's actually developing a document which would likely be a challenge cost share agreement which then the liability doesn't.

55:47 Change hands. I was going to say, yes, that was going to be my question, yeah, because the special use permit, I don't think the town, yeah, we don't want to put itself at risk that way. There you go. So we've talked about that at length in multiple other presentations I've made and discussions we've had as far as if we're in partnership on what's called the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, that's done one of two ways, through a special use permit or through a challenge cost share agreement to co-manage those trails. The MLTS MOU establishes expectation that we'll work together.

56:16 To promote and maintain the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, under a special use permit, your MUPS, your multiple use paths, the liability and the requirement to maintain those trails lies 100% with the town of Mammoth Lakes, with Forest Service supporting it in any way that we can, but the responsibility is with the town. Under a challenge cost share agreement, we can look at the soft surface trails that are a part of this system and discuss how can we

56:45 Work to maintain those trails together. And so it's just taking the idea that we've had the last year and a half and really putting it down in paper, it would be a supplemental to the master challenge cost share agreement that we've established. And the $5,000 that's being requested, I believe, would go to support staff time to see that that agreement is put in place. I am too. I am more comfortable with the challenge cost share than I am with the special use. Exactly. That was my big question.

57:18 Yeah, so we line out special use permit, and CC, Challenge Costure takes place. Sounds good to me. So the consultant... Did you have any other questions with regard to the other line items? What I think we should do here is just to... is... is... if you have questions with regard to each of the line items, let's hear all your questions first, as much as we are trying to tackle these things individually. No, I don't have questions about the others. I support the... developing a budget for the...

57:50 I support the, you know, developing a budget so that we can build some of the facilities that we've got planned. My questions on 146, the OSV NEPA review is coming about because someone filed a lawsuit, a great way to manage our lands with lawsuits. This 20,000 we're talking about here wouldn't preclude you from asking for the whole 66 from Green Sticker, I'm assuming. This would be

58:20 Just in case we need it or? Let me just clarify a little bit about these statistics because Steve had to deal with me talking over his cell phone while trying to do three other things while I was giving him his numbers. So the grant that we asked the state for

58:38 I believe, I don't have it in front of me, I believe it was just under $300,000 in total that we're asking the state for. And I believe it's actually $86,000 that we have slated as a match that we have to come up with in order to leverage that other $277,000. So the whole project total is in excess of $300,000. We are trying to find that match.

59:04 And so instead of 66, use the number 86 because I'm pretty sure that's the match number that we're targeting. We're asking the town to support the Forest Service in less than 25% of that match, $20,000. Now what I told Steve is that's kind of covering the bare bones to move the status quo OSB system kind of into a proposed action. Now when we go through this over snow vehicle NEPA process,

59:32 That'll kind of be our starting point is what are we doing today that we want to continue to do? But there are also, you know, I think the town needs to think about what are the things that aren't happening now that perhaps the town would like to ask the Forest Service to consider for motorized over-snow vehicle use in the future.

59:52 And if we were to look at other ideas that have been thrown out in this group in the past, such as connecting the Sherwins to Shady and via a trail or something, that's going to require a little bit more work. And I think we would then, the Forest Service would then come back to the town and say, okay, well that's kind of a proposal you're bringing forward that's going to complicate the analysis and therefore cause the cost to go up and we therefore would expect you to contribute more to the match or to the project in total.

1:00:19 So the $20,000 is really a baseline to move the status quo forward. Since this affects Mono County as well as the town of Mammoth Lakes, because this is a NEPA process for the entire forest, what is the chance of us going to other agencies and asking them to help with this match as well? The Forest Service hasn't made a formal request to anyone else at this point. We have discussed it with the county and with our special use permit holders.

1:00:51 Yes, because it affects them. We will be looking at commercial use, commercial OSV use in this analysis as well, as we stated in our grant request to the state. That being said, Mr. Chair, I have no problem moving with $20,000 in the budget to cover that. John, I see you've got a question, but I really want to take questions from the dias first, and we'll come back, okay? I just want to know where the public, what are the options of policy?

1:01:17 Yeah, here's what we're going to do is I'm going to take questions from Sandy and myself. Again, this is just question time. Then I'll be able to take, if you have a question from the audience, we'll need to do a motion, just if I'm, correct me if I'm wrong, Steve. And then once we have a motion and a second, then we'll be able to have discussion on that. We're actually going to do it as a whole, which is what we're doing right now. So take notes on which item you want to question.

1:01:47 Is that accurate, Steve? I think what you might want to do is have questions on the dais, if that's satisfied, then go to the public and ask them for questions, then give a motion. Okay. Get a second. Have a final discussion, then vote. That's what I was trying to say. Okay. I don't know if I said it that way or not. Sounds good. I'll take your suggestion then. Yeah. Because your motion could be one or it could be all. That's true. Until someone makes it, you're not going to know. That's correct. Sandy. I have no problem with it.

1:02:17 Okay. And you both asked the questions I was going to ask. So at this time, John, do you have questions? I was born to ask questions. So on the first item, number 412, I'm pretty sure I understand what this is about, and I think I understand the value of it. A question I have to the Forest Service, you've heard the committee here debate the costs and the values associated with basically a volunteer kind of a trail stewardship program. Does the agency look at the summer stewardship program as something that is,

1:02:49 Substantially sufficient to address soft surface trail maintenance needs going forward with the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. In other words, is the committee in the town making a smart investment by investing in this kind of program that down the road, if we build trails and sharpa kinds of things, that this is the kind of capacity you can be looking for to maintain these trails? Well, I wouldn't just separate into soft surface trail maintenance. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System is a combination of

1:03:16 Mupps and Soft Surface Trails, and we have said facilities that support the use of those trails. And so I actually would say that the Forest Service values the stewardship component of the SOS and the Lakes Basin Steward Program, that we're bringing people, we're bringing the public into the management of the National Forest Trails in the National Forest. We highly value it. I do not believe it's sufficient.

1:03:46 A sufficient contribution from the town for the overall maintenance of the trail system. No. Okay, so my question is, because we're making a big investment in the NEPA for the trails out in the Sharps, we're investing a lot in the stewardship program, when is the town and the Forest Service going to start specking out what that maintenance program is going to look like and what those obligations are going to be? Because we're investing a lot of money going forward. I think everybody would like to know that we're investing things that are leading to a capacity to maintain the system.

1:04:14 We're not going to have any surprises down the road. I think that's exactly why we're talking about having this conversation and the staff time to engage with the agency to discuss what are those possibilities, what's needed, how can we co-manage the maintenance needs of the soft surface trails in the future as part of this discussion. So is it fair to say that a deliverable coming out of these discussions would be a representation of what the maintenance needs are going to be needed going forward? I'm sorry.

1:04:42 Yeah, that's a fair question because I'm asking the same thing. I think the committee is going to have to look at the options that the Forest Service staff and town staff come up with. We're going to have to say here are some ways to move this maintenance program forward and there will be costs associated with it and the committee is going to have to take those costs and options into consideration. However, John, if I'm getting what you're saying correct here, the $5,000 is staff cost.

1:05:11 To hammer out an agreement of some type so that we are covered to work on soft-service trails out of Measure R. It may not cover the cost, and we may have to come back to that well. It may not cover the cost to come up with a maintenance program for them as well. And to add to that, if we look at the last page of the proposed budget, item 611, 3-by-12, Dr. J. O'Brien.

1:05:42 The budget has $7,500 in that in addition. So that starts to get that more robust program that I think John was alluding to and the Forest Service is alluding to. So that's built into the budget as well. So it's not just the agreement, but also we have funding in there to start developing the program.

1:06:05 So my fundamental question is, are all these things converging into a maintenance program for the Mammoth, for the soft surface trails, that's going to make sense? And I'm assuming that's what this is about. The way I see this is that we're looking at the whole picture. We're looking at everything. We're looking at what we're doing today with the current programs that are being funded and how those weave into the future, if they're a part of the future, or if there's other ways to go about.

1:06:35 Tackling the maintenance responsibilities that the Forest Service believes the town has because we're in partnership to deliver this trail system. Okay, so I'm assuming that, and correct me if I'm wrong, it's fair to say that this $5,000, a deliverable coming out of that is going to be some kind of a recommendation between the town staff and the Forest Service staff of what a maintenance program is going to look like for the soft surface trails. That's what I envision. Glad I asked it. Well, this is for the challenge cost share agreement. And then as I just pointed out,

1:07:05 Later on in the budget recommendation, there are $7,500 recommended for putting together the Adopt-A-Trail Program and the Multi-Use Path Payments Program. So in combination, I think we get to answer your answer, your answer is yes. Okay. But the $5,000 is to create a challenge cost share.

1:07:27 Understood. But I'm just hoping these things are converging somewhere. That's kind of my point. The second thing is on this NEPA thing. I have to echo what Chairman, Chair Souser said. We've had, there's been an ongoing discussion about exactly what is the physical extent and range of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. This winter we put pages up for the OSV trails that go, you know, way out, all kinds of places not represented on the maps. I think it's, I think the public would be really disappointed if somehow

1:07:53 This committee and measure our Mammoth Lakes are perceived to be the proverbial well. We've got regional problems. We've got regional issues. Well, let's just go to Mammoth, and Mammoth's going to pay to do all this stuff. I think we've got to really work as effectively as partners. Marmont County's got a lot of stake in this. A lot of your special permit holders have a stake in this. And I appreciate coming forward and getting this ball rolling, but when the money starts flowing for these grants and moving this NEPA forward, it's got to be a multi-partnered effort. Is there a question involved there? No, it's a comment. It's an observation.

1:08:23 Trying to keep it at questions right now. So having said that right now, I guess I'm looking for a motion so that we can discuss it further. I would make a motion that we move the amounts forward on all of the items in agenda item 5. That'll be 412, 146, 33, 331.02, 441, CIPTR07.

1:08:56 I would second that. Did that include that last part? That includes the last, except all 14-15 suggested engineers estimate budget figures as presented in the MLT SEC master budget tracking plan dated today. Okay, I would second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, Sandy Hogan. Well, once again, is there any for the discussion from the dais? Yeah, on the other items. What's that? On the other items? No, not for me. I was okay with all of them. Can you go to the discussion?

1:09:28 Okay, now is the time for comments or discussion from the audience. On the other items, right. No, on the motion that's before us. Seeing none, let's do the roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:10:04 Okay. On behalf of your support staff, thank you very much. I look forward to doing this thing together and bringing it into the Regulation Commission's consideration. Thanks, Steve, for all your work on it. Very good. I was missing around to see if Hayes has just walked in there. Outstanding. So maybe this is a good time for just a short recap.

1:10:30 To help you understand about the Waterford Gap Closure Project. And I have some graphics that are on the board over there. And following that, we will go into new projects. All right. John, did you have a comment about... I just had a question about for the summer stewardship, now that that's approved.

1:10:58 It's an administrative item, but I'm curious as to what the expectation of staff is for the next steps. I heard something about an RFP going out, or what exactly the process is. Both friends in the UN MLTPA, we've put a lot of time, volunteer time, in a meeting and trying to get things figured out. It sounds like we want to move forward, and I'm just wondering what the expectations are for doing that. I've got an idea, but I'll let Steve answer that. What's that? We can have a separate conversation. Today's attempt was to get the budget.

1:11:27 Done. Approved. Right. And then we have a part of the processes. And to be clear, the Recreation Commission needs to have approval tomorrow first, correct? Absolutely. And then the Town Council needs to approve it as well. So we're just establishing budget at this point and contracting will come in. Yep. Okay. So just to be clear. So with that, we're going to back up to the Waterford Gap.

1:11:49 Yes, just for a brief moment, I have a thesis here, and you can give five minutes to explain what the added attributes are to the project and what its current status is. We're helping to close it very quickly. So I'm not really sure what was discussed or where we at with the conversation. Could we give an overview of what the project is and what the additional attributes might be? And we've all agreed that if the measure of our application

1:12:16 Okay, so I don't have to sell a bridge right now? Okay, so the background story on this project is the town wrote a BTA grant application to fill the gap between Majestic Pines and Waterford.

1:12:41 Specifically with either two bridges and a connection, some paths or something along those lines. When we got into the design process, it was really clear that building a single bridge would be cheaper, easier, and have significantly less environmental impacts. So when we started looking at that design, it became apparent that we need to also look at that dilapidated old creosote bridge that kind of spanned right at the top of the cul-de-sac and majestic pines.

1:13:09 So we incorporated that design into the overall design for the project. We never actually had the funding to do that, to construct that bridge, but it seemed right at the time to just do the whole product at once. Once we got through all that, I was just chatting with Steve and he thought it might be a good idea just to bring this project forward to you guys to have a discussion about it. I have, those are the plans for the entire project from the cul-de-sac to cul-de-sac.

1:13:38 And that's actually the 240-foot bridge that will span the gap. So what we were coming to you guys for would be funds to construct a 30-foot bridge to replace the dilapidated creosote bridge, and also to provide some funding for interpretive displays and some obviously website enhancements that would accommodate those.

1:14:05 This also provides an emergency access, doesn't it? That is correct. So that bridge is more expensive than a typical bridge because it is designed to hold EMS vehicles. Right, because if you ride your bike down into, or you drive down into Majestic Pines, the cul-de-sac, it's only one way out.

1:14:22 From there, is that correct? Yes, this would, it's designed to actually work as an emergency access. It will be, there will be bollards, it's not going to, you know, cars won't be able to drive across it, but in an emergency, we'll be able to open it up, it'll be 14 foot wide, which is wider than our typical bridges, and it'll be, they're actually designed for the loads of the full size fire equipment. Fire truck, that's what it's going to, yeah. Okay. Okay, so at this point, this is just information? Yeah. Yeah.

1:15:04 Any other questions? That's it. Just to clarify, the discussion tomorrow's Recreation Commission meeting is about whether or not to do an opportunity award for measure for the president. We then have to go to the council to find out if we can do that since we have stopped all action on R&U. Good point. Which we won't know for another week plus. All right. Thanks. Hais, thanks for your time.

1:15:44 Okay, now we're going on to business item number six. New projects. Are there any new items from this committee to be put on to for consideration, discussion, and recommendations to the master tracker list? Let me get on my list here. Not today. Okay, not today. Then we're going to move right on from business item number six. Let's talk about business item number seven.

1:16:19 The early opening late fall closure, project number 571. I had conversations with Bill Taylor, and I'm impressed that he couldn't be here today, but he had bits of the balls in his court to put together a draft letter to the town manager coverage at Iowa. So we'll probably have an update at next month. And since I was part of that committee, we've been kind of failing emails back and forth. Evidently, everything I write is not getting to him. He's twice a verse, I don't know.

1:16:51 Steve, my question for him was, and for Kaz since he's here, the dumpsters that are going to remain that are going to be locked down. I didn't see anything in his proposal that would put a sign on those showing people where the open dumpsters were. And that was my only concern with the whole proposal. Because we had talked earlier about having maps not just on the bathroom, which is covered in his proposal. And I don't know if I missed it because our...

1:17:22 Or if that was there. We kind of left that up in the air because we weren't sure if we're going to move all those dumpsters that would be locked. If we move them, there's no need for signs. Absolutely. But if we leave them in place, then yes, you're right, there would be a need for signs. And as you know, that would be my preferred alternative would be all the clothes with blue. Right. They don't make an attractive nuisance that way. Yeah, and CLM is fine with it as long as they're put back in place. Right. So there's just a cost to DMV. The solution that I would prefer.

1:17:48 Thank you. So as far as the spring, spring is here, and, you know, the dumpster situation won't be fixed. We can think about some maps, but the Forest Service will be doing what we've been doing the last couple years is for the bathroom, showing where the open bathrooms are until we can get our water systems turned on, until the campground's open. So we'll continue to do what we've been doing the last couple years, and hopefully people will read the signs. So the plan actually will be probably for the late fall closure than the thing that we'll be discussing in...

1:18:20 Bill and Bill's report or the letter to the town manager? Okay. And so the request is to keep, pull out all the dumpsters that are stored up there in the winter and bring them into town? And leave some there in the popular locations that are unlocked and then the town would pay for the trash to be removed out of those any time they get food or just before the campgrounds open so the concessionaire isn't responsible for emptying that extra trash.

1:18:50 And then maps on the bathrooms. I'm just wondering if there's going to be an extra charge, though, to take all the dumpsters back down to the storage yard versus... Well, we actually said we would do, and there will be some cost involved in doing this, but we would consolidate them in locations in the lake space and maybe even pick one campsite per campground and just put all the dumpsters in that site. And so we're not actually...

1:19:13 Going through the expense of getting them out of the lake space, and it's just putting them in a place where we don't think the public will necessarily try to use them when they're locked and leave bags outside of them. But there will be some cost associated with doing that, and that's what the proposal, I think, consists of, how to cover some of those costs. And that's really, I think, what the love of the town manager is about. Not for permission to move it forward, but is there a stream other than this one to pay for that since it's not really a trails issue?

1:19:42 Yeah, I think the town manager indicated that the town would pay for the pickup of the trash and spraying those early loads, but I don't think we discussed moving all of the others, consolidating those into one location. We did in one conversation with Dan, but I don't know how far that went. It didn't come down to me? Yeah. Okay, but we can further that discussion. Perfect, thank you. Especially in light of Roy's comments earlier. Yeah, it's a lot that goes into that. Okay.

1:20:11 Yeah, I do consider this a trails-related issue. I mean, I don't know, a letter to the town manager to try to get general fund money. Is that what I'm hearing? Yeah, he would. Yes. We basically said that we could cover the spring pickup prior to the overall campgrounds being opened with the pickup. But the discussion didn't include moving all of the others to one location. When Bill and I talked to town manager, we talked about the spring pickup.

1:20:42 And the potential need to dump in the fall just before the closure. And that would be covered too. Right. We're not talking about a huge amount of money. Yeah. Just like, yeah. General fund, I just wonder, you know, what else is we going to give up out of the general fund? Hopefully not. Well, we're working on a franchise agreement also. And I would not mind seeing the money coming out of the general fund, that's for sure. No. Okay.

1:21:07 So this business item is just an update and a discussion. Well, actually, there is the opportunity to take action, but I'm not sure what that is. Was that just put in there? In case we had the opportunity to tell. Yeah. But it sounds like there's no action to be taken at this time. Pending, I think. Any other questions, comments, or can we move on? Got a comment from the audience? And there's our town manager. Yeah, this is a comment. I just, I want to echo what Chair, Committee Member Sazer saying. I've really struggled to find a nexus between this program and the trail system.

1:21:40 It's important. This has got to get done. There's a lot of things that got to get done, but moving dumpsters around all the residents, I'm just, I don't, I can't see the nexus. If it's at a trailhead, if it's on a trail, fine, but if it's just general maintenance of that area, thank you. Let's move on. Business item number eight. In your packet, you'll find a two-sided sheet with a Gmail printout from Hayes, and on the back is a timeline.

1:22:09 This has to do with the status on the interpretive seven signs that were passed and are under construction. We reviewed them last month. They were on the table. So this is just an FYI handout, current status. And again, my understanding is that this project in total is moving along per the estimated time frames and also well within budget. So there may be monies coming back.

1:22:39 To our funding that aren't spent out of the $84,000 that was set aside for this particular project. So something to keep in mind that we may have some additional dollars. Great. So that's, again, the pass out, the handout is more of your information. So, Ms. Chairman, is it possible to publicly copy? I'm just wanting to get a copy of that handout, that's all. It's on Granicus and posted. It's not on Granicus right now.

1:23:12 You can take Steeves. So the approval is going to be designed tomorrow at the Recreation Commission, is that correct? Or it just says April 8th? Is that something that's coming before the Recreation Commission? I'm looking at the timeline for completion on the back. Okay, that's just the date that's chosen. I wasn't sure if that was something that was coming before the Recreation Commission. Okay, so this is just an update then. Looks good. Any further questions on this item?

1:23:53 Item number nine, discuss and take action regarding projects on the current master project and budget tracking list. This is an opportunity that I've asked the Forest Service to come and give a brief update and description about the status of 2.1 U.S. Forest Service Shark Project and also Project 132, the Sarbanes update. So I have a handout here for you as well as

1:24:24 Okay, so this is 10 minutes, right? 10 minutes? Okay. Can you do it? Thanks. Well, so you all want to know the results of the resource surveys that were done. I know we've been trying to find time to discuss this.

1:24:55 And so what I was going to propose we do is go through the Sherwins Working Group and then the Lakes Basin project areas kind of in a east to west direction or something like that and talk about some of each project and some of the findings. It's going to take longer than 10 minutes. I want to make sure you're prepared to do that. How long do you think it's going to take? I think the conversation could take a half hour to 45 minutes.

1:25:20 It's up to you all. I'm also happy to give you the 10-minute synopsis if you would prefer that. Well, one thing I might point out is that we don't have much left on the agenda. I can make the staff report very quickly. You've already seen it once before. So I would suggest that it's 3 o'clock now. Let's give post-service as much time as they need.

1:25:45 I feel that's important. Is there any further? No, I would agree. I want to hear it. I think that's fine, John. I think the public needs to hear it, too. Yeah. Let's keep it at 45 minutes. Sure. I think we can do that. Okay. So in the summer of 2013, there's a challenge cost share agreement with the U.S. Forest Service to fund the resource surveys and then the NEPA to move these project ideas forward in the environmental review process.

1:26:13 And ultimately for John Regalberg of the District Ranger to make a decision on what of these project ideas he may decide to actually construct. I'll say at the forefront, I think we want to focus on the results of the resource survey and how we're going to move these things forward. But I'll say at the start of this, one of the things the Forest Service is now concerned about is the MLR and how that affects the commitment to

1:26:43 Moving Trails Projects Forward. I think we have heard various things over the past with Measure R and Measure U, and I know the town is now trying to figure out exactly how MLR can move forward along with some of these other commitments that have been made, including to the MLTSCC. And, you know, our big concern is if we're going to move these projects forward, are they going to actually be built?

1:27:10 And John Regelberg isn't interested in completing NEPA on a project that may sit on the shelf and get stale that we may have to go and do NEPA over again if the project isn't built within the shelf life of the project. So that's a conversation that we need to have with the town and to try to figure out what funds are available to move these forward. And we're not talking, the Forest Service recognizes that

1:27:40 The town wants to leverage Measure R and Measure U dollars in grant opportunities. And so we factor that in. That's part of the conversation is what money is set aside, not just to fund the NEPA, not just to fund the construction, but also to leverage the money needed to complete these projects. So it's kind of a bigger discussion, but let's focus on the resource information that was gathered.

1:28:07 I said east to west, but let's start with what we've all called in the past in the Sherwins Working Group the backbone of the proposal. The number one, the staging area. Number seven, the trail from the staging area to Tamarack. Number six, the trail from the staging area over to the Hayden Cabin. So it's a multiple use path, large trailhead facility. There were minor

1:28:36 Resource issues found along number 7 to Tamarack Street. We've got resource issues that we believe could be mitigated throughout that area. And so I can't talk specifically about a lot of the cultural resource issues because I can't really reveal the locations, especially in a public setting. If the town is interested in seeing the cultural sites that were identified, some of the sensitive plants that were identified,

1:29:06 We can sit down and reach an agreement, a confidentiality agreement where those sites can be shared, but we have responsibility to protect those sites, and therefore I can't tell you exactly where they were found. So I'll be talking in some generalities here, and if you have questions, I'll do my best to answer them within those constraints. So along number seven, there are some heritage resource concerns that I think could easily be mitigated by moving trail alignment.

1:29:31 And then there are some resource concerns when you get down into the Mammoth Meadows area with construction through riparian, the need for elevated boardwalk to maintain hydrologic regimes. So number seven, I think the Forest Service is fairly comfortable moving forward. The whole borrow pit staging area, it's a borrow pit. Really no resource concerns there. Whatever we can do out there to improve that area.

1:30:00 Pardon the area as a trailhead. We're doing a favor to the aesthetics of the area. We're also providing a service that's already clearly in demand given the level of traffic that we see out there for people using the trails. The number seven, one thing worthy to point out is that is a road now. That is a road that...

1:30:20 In our travel management decision, it was a level one mitigation, which means it was closed until mitigated. We never actually closed the road. We went out and did some of the mitigation. We completed the mitigation last summer, which was to harden the road through Cary Meadow.

1:30:35 So that is a road on our travel management system that if this project were to move forward, we would be closing a road in it. And there obviously are concerns. Some members of the public who may not want to see that vehicle access limited in the future. So just so you all are aware of that. Let's move on to number six, the trail from the borrow pit over to the Hayden cabin. There are resource concerns in that area that would be very difficult to avoid.

1:31:04 And if we were going to put a paved path in there, there would be some additional, some, you know, some costs that we'd have to incur, my guess is in the $40,000 to $80,000 range, to dig some test pits to mitigate cultural resource concerns in the area. From there, let's see, I think the easiest thing to do would be to kind of move through the Sierra Meadows and the Mammoth Creek area.

1:31:35 And I'll go kind of from north to south. Number 10, just so you know, kind of connecting out to Shady Rest, that was kind of a conceptual idea that it was never really an alignment charted on the map. And so we didn't send specialists out on number 10 to look on the ground and do resource surveys. So that one really didn't move forward. I think it would actually warrant a lot more discussion.

1:32:05 Then to just before we send people out and actually study it further. So number 11, on the north side of the creek, there's significant resource concerns that would prevent really anything but maintenance and mitigation of existing impacts to occur. So I don't really think there's opportunity to construct new trail on the north side of Mammoth Creek, but there certainly is opportunity to continue to promote the access that the public has demonstrated with their feet they want along that creek.

1:32:34 And with, and also to limit the erosion that we're seeing from some of the vehicle use in the area. With that being said, then, basically saying we're going to need to fish in the path alone. Yeah. Would that be, okay, without it being a formalized path, is there still an opportunity to do some way finding on that? Yeah, so I think what we would want to do there, Bill, is look at, you know, number 11, the way it's drawn on the map and the way it was written up in the Sherwin's Working Group,

1:33:07 The write-up is really, it was to consolidate the trails, but consolidation means kind of new trail construction too, to kind of connect and consolidate. I don't think the connecting piece is really possible. I think the consolidating, hardening the existing, and doing what you said, maybe having some signs to direct traffic and limit people from creating new impacts would be highly desirable. So 11 is maybe a modified project. Can I ask one more on that?

1:33:35 The 11 were the way it's on the map here, it's right on top of the creek. Did 11 in the sharks, and I don't remember, you know, sort of a part of it, did that include the trails on the south and north side? So I'm going to address the south side separately here, because south side has some similar resource constraints, but they weren't as concentrated. So I think some of it is a result of there's more intensive use already on the south side.

1:34:04 What we see in that whole area, 9B, 9A, there's a lot of equestrian use, of course, from the Sierra Meadows Ranch. The only place we're really seeing resource concerns from that cross-country or multi-braided trail system is really near the creek where we have concerns about erosion. And I think there's opportunity there to continue to provide what the equestrian and the foot users are demanding there is access to the creek.

1:34:32 But that we may need to really think about hardening it in some way that limits erosion and limits multi-trailing when you're in the areas where sediment can contribute directly to the creek. Once you get outside there, there really were no resource concerns in all that sagebrush out there with continuing to allow use to occur the way it is today. I think the user...

1:34:57 My personal opinion is the user could benefit from some more established trails in the area that are signed and would help people navigate that area. The equestrian users know where they're going, the people who frequent that area, but the visiting public who wants to travel north to south and walk some trails or the new equestrian user may benefit from some hardening and better signing in that area. So that's kind of the whole 9B.

1:35:25 Ten, again, we didn't really look at going down there because it's so conceptual, so we didn't study ten all the way down. All right, so I'll jump up to Solitude Canyon. That's another area we didn't send boots on the ground, but we did do some preliminary resource studies based on other projects that we've done back in that area and also sending wildlife folks out there again this year or this past year. And there are some resource concerns in that area.

1:35:53 That we have to pay attention to. I don't think they would prohibit development, but we didn't study specific trail alignments in that area. We'd want to pay close attention to coming out of Solitude Canyon, how it may impact its wildlife, I can tell you, its wildlife resources in that area. We didn't study the exact trail alignment. Now we did look at the 9B connector. Some of that trail is already on the ground.

1:36:23 Again, there are some wildlife concerns in that area, but perhaps could be mitigated with the types of use and the season of use in that area. 13, we've studied that very thoroughly. That project actually, I think, as the budget referenced, is a project that we may be able to move forward this summer based upon the way

1:36:51 There's new legislation that allows the Forest Service to move that trail project forward under a categorical exclusion because, well, for us here in the district, it's an existing trail. It's pretty low risk. It's not really adding to the trail system. It's just mitigating the impacts of an existing trail and that we would be able to move that forward. And there are resource concerns in that area. There are a bunch of invasive plant species and when we do that project, we have to be very careful not to spread those invasive plants down towards the

1:37:21 The Barrow Pit. Let's see. On up to 18. 18, we determined that's the connector from Mammoth Rock Trail down to Mammoth Meadows. There's no way to build that trail sustainably. So that's not a trail project the Forest Service is interested in moving forward. It would involve a significant amount of switchbacks on that steep slope to put that trail in and would likely, you know, have some pretty serious visual ramifications if we were to put in those.

1:37:57 The switchbacks, it would also, if you built that trail to spec, it would be very expensive and it would be very costly to maintain. And even the steepness, there could be some safety issues. So, I think there are other options further down the Mammoth Rock Trail, kind of where the 9B intersects to develop a trail on a more natural slope that exists there that we could look at in the future.

1:38:25 18, where it was spec'd out and where the current user trail is really is just a not a feasible location. And there is a current user trail there, is that correct? Yeah, it's a long skid mark. So number eight is in the Mammoth Meadows taking the existing user trails. That whole area in there, it was really the number one concern is maintaining hydrologic function.

1:38:52 There already are some neat little bridges and stuff, but I think we'd have to improve upon the structures in that area to add it to our system and to make it so we know we're maintaining the hydrology of the area. When we get into some of the willowy areas, we also need to be careful about the level of construction in relation to the willow flycatcher. It is habitat for the willow flycatcher.

1:39:19 We would need to study that a bit further, but nobody seemed to think it would preclude further adding that trail to our system and doing the enhancements that would need to be done to bring it onto our system. So two, that's on private property, just we didn't go and analyze the trailhead on Tamarack Street. 5A, we took a look at. Again, this is a trail that's in some very steep,

1:39:51 Rugged land that would be very expensive to build to standard and very difficult to construct and very costly to construct. So it's not one that we see as, we don't think it, you know, we understand the need to have connectivity from the Mammoth Meadows, another option to get people up into the lakes basin and old Mammoth area.

1:40:17 But that area may not be the best place to put that trail. I know groups have gone out on the ground and looked at other ways to connect it, and that was determined to be the most likely place or the best place to go. But we had a number of specialists. Well, our hydrologist was fairly concerned about that.

1:40:42 I'll get into maybe, we'll talk about 5A a little bit more. I'm not saying we take that off, that alignment off the list right now, but it's not exactly our highest, the Forest Service's highest priority right now. Same with kind of 16 and 4 in that area, because we know there's controversy in that area based on work that the Trails Technical Committee did and letters that were submitted and other comments and phone calls that we've received. We know that there's a lot of opposition up there in the bluffs.

1:41:11 To doing anything in that area. And I think we've got some issues to work through there, through up there. And I'm not sure that we would want to weave that into our package of our first round of projects, given, you know, it could upset some folks. Not to say that, you know, that's a reason not to do it, but perhaps it's a reason to not do it in the first round and to study it further.

1:41:37 And see if there's other alternatives and maybe explore the concerns of those residents in a little bit more detail. So let's see, 26 Mammoth Rock, we're very concerned about the safety of that trail past Mammoth Rock. We think that there are a number of things you could do to improve access up to Mammoth Rock from the Mammoth Rock Trail and that that user created trail system could be hardened and we could

1:42:07 Do some work to get up to the top of Mammoth, or near the top of Mammoth Rock. But once you get beyond Mammoth Rock, you're talking about constructing a trail on some pretty steep, difficult terrain that really isn't something that we're interested in exploring right now. The old Mammoth Trailhead, Mill City area, there's a significant amount of resource surveys that have been done throughout the whole Mill City area because of the fuels reductions work that has been done in the past.

1:42:37 And there are opportunities to construct trail in there. However, there are some constraints up in there given historical resources and also some potential need to address some of the past mining issues up in that area.

1:43:01 I think that area has to be further explored if we're going to be putting new trails that connect down to the Mill City. We've had to look at it in a little bit greater detail, and I think that after we do conduct the final thinning project in that area, that's when it will be ripe to really study, as the Sherwin Working Group recommended that Panorama Dome, that area, be studied further. And I think that's what I'd recommend for the Mill City area as well, that we don't really look at specific alignments, but we look at doing a

1:43:29 A really robust trail study for the entire Panorama Dome, Mill City area. We took a hard look at the trail alignments 5B on both sides of Old Mammoth Road, and there are a number of resource constraints along those corridors. You get into some riparian on the south side of Old Mammoth Road, you have tons of historical, cultural resources in that corridor.

1:43:55 It would be very difficult to build trail along those alignments without impacting many of those resources. And the Forest Service is suggesting that we take a look at other options to accommodate the use in that area. Old Mammoth, and this is something that's really just an idea at this point. It's not something that, just to be clear, John Regalberger has said he wants to do in any way. It's just an idea that's been thrown out to us that I think was worthy of...

1:44:23 Mentioned and worthy of consideration. One weighing old mammoth out of the lakes basin. The road is degrading. There haven't really been many accidents on the road, to be fair, but it is a steep road, windy, and, you know, you have vehicles that encounter one another and have to back up and figure out who's going to let who through.

1:44:45 It's not a severe safety issue, but safety could be improved by one weighing out of Old Mammoth so that if there ever was an emergency, it would be pretty clear which direction to go and head out of the lakes basin. So it's an idea, and then you could also have trails on one side or the other of Old Mammoth, pedestrian or even an equestrian trail that is adjacent to the road.

1:45:09 So it's an idea that I think we need to look at and because of the resource constraints with the trail alignments that are proposed, it may be an idea that we need to explore. Sorry, which idea? The idea of one-waying old mammoth out of the lakes basin and putting trails adjacent to the road rather than off in the forest or up in the sagebrush.

1:45:34 I've got a comment on that, but I don't know if that's the right time. It's up to you, but it's definitely something that has to be explored. There are probably a lot of comments and concerns and ideas on it. Exactly. Yeah, keep going. 17 we looked at, and the number one concern up there is crossing private land and crossing areas where we have open mines exposed. Just how to mitigate

1:46:04 User Safety in that area and educate people to stay out of the areas where they could potentially get into trouble. Once you get up there, you may be able to direct the traffic away from the mine sites, but it's also difficult to keep people from going where they see interesting things. So it's something that we need to talk to the mining company about.

1:46:28 And the mine areas that aren't being used look at closing them up and improving the public safety in that area, which is something the Forest Service is continually working on. That's really what the resource specialists looked at this year. We've already looked at 12B, the whole panorama, the idea of a staging area that would address perhaps some of the parking concerns up there. That area has already been surveyed. We know that there are some

1:47:01 Hydrology concerns, where we'd want to potentially put a parking lot up there. We've got a little wetland area. And other than that, there's also a historic, the foundation of a historic structure up there we'd have to avoid. Probably wasn't supposed to say that specifically, but anyway, there are some issues up there that we'd have to work around, per se. Is that the area that Roy was commenting on earlier, as far as parking? Yeah, just, you know, if we were to...

1:47:31 Sharp looked at this kind of flatter area up at the entry to Panorama Dome where we could potentially establish a large parking area for winter use. And, you know, that's an option we can think about in the future. So, from the Forest Service's standpoint, you know, we really see the backbone and the trailhead as something to move forward in consolidating, working in the area along Mammoth Creek.

1:48:00 And the Sierra Equestrian Center. Perhaps connecting up into the Sherwins Lake Trail through the 9B. All of those are good projects that we feel like there's good reason to move them forward. It'd be an enhancement to the trail system. It would further mobility in the community, which I know has been an objective of the town. It would also help improve the aesthetics of the area out there. So those are all really good.

1:48:29 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:49:01 And also I would assume that that includes 7 and 8, the Mammoth Meadow area? Yes, yes, yes. Okay, okay, so actually would be pretty much the lower elevation portions for sure is what I heard with a lot of the higher elevation looking at as your second tier. In other words, do the NEPA on this. Well, I mean, that's an option, yeah. I think the old Mammoth issue, like I said, we'd have to really discuss it.

1:49:30 It sounds like, yeah. Yeah, and maybe that would be part of the panorama study. I don't know. That's what I was actually getting to because it sounds like the panorama and the higher elevations might be the second, and that's when you'd be addressing the one-waying, say. Yeah, that would probably be a logical way to package it up. Right, right. Okay. Okay. That's it. I just want to kind of make sure I got geographically what you were talking about, and I think it was basically lower elevations.

1:49:59 You were talking also about the north side of the creek. I think we could, that's, you know, we want to talk about what we want to look at consolidating. It's really about resource, mitigating existing resource impacts over there is what we've been trying to do. Okay, that was all mine. Peter? No, they've expressed interest in using it.

1:50:31 To my knowledge, they haven't used it. The road has gotten past where it's closed. It's gotten used more in the last year. So we were wondering if they'd used it. We haven't spoken with them because they have talked to us about using it. And there are some mitigations that would need to be put in place as far as crossing the creeks in that area to get to the well. So as far as I know, they're using Tamarack Street only.

1:51:16 That's mainly, yeah, 9B, I walk part of it, it's mainly equestrian use, I think it's very sandy and silty, you wouldn't want to walk it far, frankly, I think the horses use it, it's a good equestrian trail, existing pretty much. That's pretty much what we found too. Yeah, yeah, not fun. Until you get up towards, um, behind, uh, or by the motocross track, it kind of starts, the soils start changing a little bit in there. Yeah, it's not fun. It's pretty messy up there.

1:52:12 Being equestrian only doesn't scare me at all. I'd still like to see the trail there. We need to consider all trail users, not just change my hour. I'm just saying it's not fun, Bill. You can walk it, but who wants to? After I think part of it exists on the original mine road there. Yeah, well, no, that goes up behind 29 there is the mine road there. Yeah. And Sandy made mention that number 8 was included, but if I heard you correct.

1:52:40 You've got some heritage and resource issues with number eight, so what might not be one that you need to go real quickly? The way the specialists wrote their concerns, they seem to be things we'd have to study, the impacts to willow flycatcher, and then maintaining the hydrologic regimes, what structures would need to be put in place, bridges, water bars, things like that. There's a lot of concern about if you build trail in that area and you start funneling, it's a pretty, the area is very well engineered already.

1:53:07 And if we go and do things to harden the trail and increase use, we need to make sure we're maintaining the hydrologic system that we've engineered at this point. Yeah, and my concern there was that there are already existing free trails that go out to hit lake. Right. We're still going to hike out there, so we need to at least identify one. I think the idea is to add them all to the system.

1:53:30 But we just have to figure out the proper way to do that and determine, you know, maybe there's a trail that goes through a whole bunch of willow that we could get out of the willow and realign it in a way that would minimize potential impacts to willow flycatcher.

1:53:46 I believe I saw Blue Diamonds on some of those trails. Yeah, there are. Yeah, so it's a nice little cross-country potential in the future. Yeah, so we're saying move that one forward. That's part of the thing that we're interested in seeing move forward. We just have to study those potential impacts and how to mitigate those resource concerns a little bit, which we've done. We've got a lot of that information now. Now it's going back to those specialists and saying, all right, tell us what to do. The question that I would have would be on 11 from the south side.

1:54:16 Because I obviously deal with Cleveland on the south side of the creek. Even if no trail is built there, you've done the work to be known and allowed to do whatever maintenance is necessary on the fishermen's trail that aren't there. You've got to carry people to the museum. It's interpretive. It would be a great asset to us so that we're not afraid when we go out and remove a broken limb or clear a line of sight so that people stay on a single trail. Even if it's not a fishing trail.

1:54:44 To come up with a set of rules allowing some maintenance of that. I actually think that it would be best to add trails in that area to the system. That's my personal opinion, and I don't think that the resource concerns on the south side of the creek would limit us from doing that, given that the trails already exist. It's kind of like the north side. Leave the trails there, add into the system, and try to keep people on those trails rather than creating new trails and impacting those resources in the area even more.

1:55:17 I just had a couple of questions. Old Mammoth Road up there, is that a town road or is that a Forest Service Road past the Bluffs subdivision? Past where? Right past the Bluffs subdivision is where it changes. I think it's right there at Mill City. Right near the gate. Yeah, just below the gate maybe. Yeah, the comment I was going to make is the previous community that I was a member of in Point Richmond, California. We have a lot of very narrow roads and there was discussion about making them one way.

1:55:47 And we chose to keep them two-way just because it encouraged interaction between drivers that you have to recognize. Now, come on forward, that kind of thing. Anyway, but at the same time, I know this road is steep and that there are emergency evacuation concerns there. It's purely an idea at this point. I wouldn't want anybody to think that the Forest Service is proposing or anything like that. It's a complete idea that has to be thought through and studied. Yeah, of course.

1:56:16 I have one other question, but I didn't write it down, and so since I can't remember it at this time. Okay. Not very, no. We looked at that. Yeah, it's, if you're going to put in a MUP, the level of ground disturbance anywhere in that area is going to require that we do some test pits. God bless.

1:56:58 Yeah, I think that that's just you've got to build it into the cost of the project if we're going to do it. I mean, especially when we're talking about a MUP, you know, it's not significant. It's money that we have to spend that we don't have, but it's not adding to the project significantly. And potential for grants, other grants with a MUP. Anytime we get a MUP, we've got that potential to go after other grants. Yeah. Yeah, and I think there's interest in replacing that bridge, correct? Yeah.

1:57:28 We want that to be, we, so that's the type of stuff that, you know, once, once we now move this forward and we say, here's what we're going to move forward, here's what we want to analyze in the NEPA document, we can start getting into the specifics, like replacing the bridge, and there will be a need for some further resource studies on things like that, but we've gotten the broad,

1:57:51 Paintbrush picture of this whole area of what exactly is out there that we need to be concerned about and how does that frame up our options. So now we're ready for the next step. Let's decide what we're moving forward. That's great. Comments or questions from the audience? Hi. Thank you very much for that presentation. So a couple questions. This was not on the agenda for today. Is that right? Yeah, I was just noticing that as well. So essentially this is just an update. Is that correct, Steve?

1:58:26 So I'm interested in what exactly should this should be referred to as kind of a progress update or something? It was a progress update and I believe now what we need to do is the Forest Service is going to be talking to the town outside of this committee about what projects they want to move forward and want to commit to funding to construct in the future.

1:58:56 With the idea that the Forest Service is not interested in proposing to the public that we build something that won't actually get built. Okay, so a couple of quick things. One is, as I think you know, we've gotten this, MLTPA has gotten a small grant from Monro County to do these sort of Mammoth Trails public meetings. Just as a formal invitation, be interested in picking someday in the next couple of weeks or the next, before June 30th, it would work for you to...

1:59:21 Get some folks together. You can just kind of walk people through, give them kind of a progress update the same way you have today. I just want to extend the invitation to you if you're interested in doing that. I mean, you don't have to say yes or no now, but I'm extending the invitation. I think I'd like to talk to the town first, but yeah, I want to, before we get ahead in our saying that we're doing anything, I want to make sure we are in agreement. So, yeah, I think that's a good opportunity. Okay. And the second thing is I'm just a little, it's a little fuzzy to me in terms of where

1:59:48 What you've made this verbal representation with today, how that falls in terms of the agreement that the town has with you in terms of doing NEPA and doing all that kind of stuff moving forward. It sounds like what you're saying is you want to go consult with the town and the town staff to figure out what is going forward. And I just, it would be helpful for the public to understand what the relationship of those conversations are with the scope of work, with the signed agreements, with the money that's going forward so that

2:00:13 You know, it's just clear, everybody kind of understands what's happening. Yeah, so it's just like any project that a proponent would bring to the Forest Service. If somebody says, I want to build a skyscraper, and we say, okay, we're going to go out and see where the possible locations could be to build that skyscraper and do some initial resource surveys and see what obstacles may be in the way or what concerns we may need to, mitigations that we may need to put into place.

2:00:41 And now we're at that point of having that conversation with the town. Here's what we found. Here's, you know, here are your options. Here's what you can move forward with. What do you want to actually build? And so that's what we're asking the town now. And, you know, it's because of a lot of other things going on in the town right now, the Forest Service is going to have some higher level talks with the town about exactly what commitments can be made.

2:01:06 We don't want to move this project forward and frame up any expectations on the Forest Service's end or on the Town's end that the Town or the Forest Service can't fulfill. Okay, so is there going to be any kind of a written documentation of what we just heard today in terms of this initial? Because it sounds like you've come to some, not necessarily some conclusions, but you've found some things in the field.

2:01:27 You're going to take the results of those findings, discuss it with the town. Is this going to be written or documented anymore? What we'll ask the town to do is to submit to the Forest Service, you know, kind of a modified proposal of what they want us to analyze in the NEPA document, and then we'll respond back with how we'll move that forward. Okay. So you're asking for a modified proposal from the town based on... We will be asking. Okay, but based on your initial findings or something like that? Yeah. Okay. And would that...

2:01:57 Do these initial findings be written down or documented anywhere? We have resource survey reports, but I can't make those public because they contain sensitive information. Well, they're not all, the concerns aren't all archaeological. I mean, there's some things that could be publicly shared. Botanical concerns are also sensitive, so. There may be some information we can release. I'll have to talk to John. Okay. And then...

2:02:19 It'll all be referenced in the NEPA work once it's done as well. And so you expect who from the town or what capacity the town are you expecting to provide you with this proposal? We'll be talking to the town manager and his staff about that. Okay. I think it's ultimately up to Dan to decide how he wants to move this forward, whether it's solely through MLT SCC or some other means. We need to have those discussions. Okay. Just wanted to reiterate the invitation to...

2:02:49 Come and make this presentation as Mammoth Trails, folks. Thank you. I'm sure the Sherman's working group people love to hear about it. Thank you. John, thank you, and again, I appreciate those questions just in the sense that what I heard out of it is that it's going to be going through Dan and that he'll be funneling it to the proper people. Yeah, and I think that this group, I'm not, I don't want to tell you guys what to do. I think you guys need to decide, but I would suggest that you consider the information I gave you today and maybe make some recommendations to Dan.

2:03:17 As far as what you'd like to see packaged up and move forward and have some conversation with Dan and the town staff as far as how that moves forward in the town side. If you decide, if it comes back to this committee, great. If it rests somewhere else, so be it. But I would like to hear back from the committee, I kind of have a little bit now, what you guys think as far as our packaged ideas, the concerns.

2:03:41 What package you want to see move forward? I also wanted to share with you some information on the lake space and the Sarbanian studies too, but we can do that after we're done closing this up. Thank you very much. I'd like to make a statement on some of that if I might. Okay. Sir. The reality is that Dan, being a nice guy and being the head of the town, actually doesn't move this forward. The council moves it forward. From my position sitting here on the MLT SCC and being...

2:04:07 Actually, one of the people responsible for getting this body created through the Recreation Commission until the council tells us that we are no longer the town's advisory body on trails. I would expect the town, until council takes that action, to bring this back to the MLT SCC. It would behoove Dan or any other employee of the town to move through the channels that have been created until the council says they're going to change that.

2:04:36 I realize that there's some heartache out there about what MLR is going to be, but it as of yet has not been commissioned or put forward, and until that point in time, unless the council tells me different, I would expect this body to be the representative, not decision maker, but recommendation maker to the council on all things trails. So I hope this comes back through us until such time as the council chooses to change how that's moving forward.

2:05:01 Well stated. Well said. I think one of the things that we can do once this group says here's the package is we can start pricing out the cost of building this. I think then you can take a look at what the MLTSCC has as far as available resources and see if there are other entities that you need to bring into the dialogue if you're going to commit to moving these projects forward. Do you have enough money to do that? I think would be a question I would guess. Absolutely. And I agree with that.

2:05:31 Thank you. And just to follow up, this would be a normal process, a little bit more than normal because we're talking about in a public setting, but when the town puts together a proposal of this many trails, we would expect that, at least in engineering, that all of the trails are not necessarily feasible. So this would be just a normal part of the process, and eventually it will come back to the MLTSCC to prioritize the projects. Yep, okay.

2:06:01 All right, any further? Yeah, finally on this agenda item, Ken Ruski has a little bit more to say about the start of the make-up day, if you'd like to hear that, or we can move on to the staff report. Can you do it in five minutes? Yeah, I'll give you the nutshell. So in the lake space, and we looked at, we basically went all the way around Lake Mary, from Poconoby to George to the intersection of

2:06:30 So we surveyed this whole area here. So everything on the northwest side of the road we surveyed. The idea when the surveys project was written up,

2:07:11 It was basically kind of parallel to the road, was the idea. There are some terrain features I think that will make that challenging. There's also some campsites in the immediate area. So we also looked at kind of going further out towards Water Library Lodge, kind of coming back in as an option, which would increase the cost of implementation, but it would also perhaps deal with some of the campsite terrain obstacles that we have.

2:07:42 So in that area, there are minimal resource concerns. The biggest concern is some of the overlap with pack stock trails, the pack station uses in there. We have to take a closer look at. And then once you get to the outlet of Lake Mary, you've got some historical structures in there. And there's also some resource concerns that we just have to mitigate. But getting across another crossing of that screen corridor is possible.

2:08:12 What John Roethlberg is interested in doing is trying to get that trail all the way back up to Lake George, which we didn't do the complete resource survey to go all the way to the top. It's been a couple hundred feet more and more trail-in-speed, or more forest-in-speed surveyed. We'll get that done this year for the fuel technology. But it increases the cost of the project. I think that we can sit down with Peter and talk about.

2:08:41 Pricing out the different alignment possibilities and seeing what kind of funding gap you may or may not have to have. But that's Salvanes' implementation. Just sounds like you are going to be doing the Lakes Basin Fuels Resource Surveys. Yes. So you guys, everybody in the community will start hearing a bit about that. Great.

2:09:09 Late Spring, Early Summer. Those projects were getting the studies out of the way. Possible implementation of students 15 to 16, more likely. We really want that's a high priority for us. Now, second question. Sarbanes actually have two portions. Were you able to survey the rest of Lake? Yes, I was going to go. If you guys have any questions about what we need to work on. Actually, for the benefit of the public, I was just going to kind of...

2:09:38 Refer to what we actually have. So a few years ago, the town did receive an FTA grant, and essentially it's a transit to public lands grant to build a connector, what we call the Lake George Connector, and it did a few other things, include some bus stop improvements. It's pretty flexible as far as the scope goes, as long as it performs the ultimate goal, which is to increase pedestrian access and transit access at Lakes Basin.

2:10:08 With that, we also received a planning grant which looked at the overall circulation around the lake, Lake Mary, and so to try to figure out what's the best best route around the lake and how that interfaces with traffic. And it's, you know, over a $2 million grant, fully funded. The town's operation of the transit facilities that makes it free was what matched the grant, so it's pretty exciting, pretty good award.

2:10:37 Yeah, so, can you get, well, this picture around the back of Lake Mary, everybody knows it too, cold water. We basically took a look at anywhere we could possibly squeeze on a trail in that area. And I'll start from the Lake George, Lake Mary intersection, really minimal resource concern until you get up close to the pit toilet that's back there.

2:11:03 So that's something that will be a major issue for this project, because I'm not certain where that listing is going, but even without knowing where that listing is going, we don't have a result of the project that goes to that area.

2:11:31 Once you get to the rec residences, you know, you're talking about a pretty steep slope of the rec residences, and while there are some heritage concerns in that area, I think it's more of a practicality of a steep terrain, it really points to doing something more on the road, given the cost of these sites.

2:11:59 Once you get to the Coldwater Creek intersection, you start getting to the much more hydrological and there's going to be tethering issues. We've got a lot of water coming off the ridge there down towards Sheene, down towards Lake Erie. So we're not just talking about stream corridors. We're talking about throughflow in the forest and a path in that area could really interrupt the water flow.

2:12:23 So even though you can build bridges and culverts over the stream, you have to figure out a way to make sure we're maintaining the hydrologic integrity in that whole back area. So the hydrologic studies in the area were pretty eye-opening to realize how much the roof load is coming down to.

2:12:48 All the way back in here, all the way back full water.

2:13:19 We've got a number of historical resources. One of the options would be to kind of put a path adjacent to the old ditch, adjacent to those resources, and produce interpretations and mitigations. The State Historical Reservation Office would probably be okay with. So the main obstacle is building a bike trail back there. It's trying to figure out how to deal with hydrology in the area. And if you think that's really costly mitigations as far as elevating the trail.

2:13:52 A trailhead, parking, a day-use parking facility at Pine City Campground is something we looked at, taking Pine City, which aren't really the nicest campsites in the lakes basin, and turning it into a day-use parking site to alleviate parking issues in the area. No real problems doing that. The biggest problem is reducing the number of campsites by 8 or 10. And what we looked at is here at

2:14:21 So right here is Pine City. There's potential, there's a nice area here where we can do some walk-in tamp pads that we can do that parking lot to facilitate. And then the other idea was to look at building, there's no group campsites, the entire lake space, and establishing some group campsites back where that pit toilet is behind the mirror, using that pit toilet for restrooms for at least one.

2:14:47 Thank you. Thank you. Staff reports.

2:15:12 Just to give a reminder, in your handout package, you should find a notice of decision on the Shady Rest OSCE-OHB from the District Ranger, including your packet, also an invitation to the special meeting Wednesday the 16th at 3 p.m. Also in the packet, there's some information on the cost of a piston pulley for the rooming, and I have some

2:15:41 There's a similar type of machine, a little bit different in its track, and the proposals are the... I didn't know they were still making Tuckers. Oh yeah, better than ever. Better than ever, huh? Also, a handout to you, which is a staff report for tomorrow's Recreation Commission being a recreational grant opportunity.

2:16:09 Okay, thanks. FYI. Steve, when you talked to these guys, did you tell them you were comparing it to a, uh, uh, uh, uh, the Castle Bore 100 series? Yes, correct. And then, uh, finally, um, I have a, uh, PowerPoint for you. This is, uh, a, uh,

2:16:45 Final version then of our progress report that I intend to carry on forward to the town council along with our master project tracking and budget risk efforts approved by the continuous recreation commission. The recreation commission has seen the draft of this report. I'll quickly go through the PowerPoint and discuss the various slides.

2:17:12 Comments slide by slide or at the end? You've already made comments. I've made those adjustments and presented it to the recognition. Incorporated your comments. Right, so we've had the chance to review this. I'm just wondering, is there going to be, did you have additional comments or comments already incorporated? Well, I couldn't see that Bill's were on slide number two because he talked about getting rid of the minutia and really hitting the big,

2:17:43 Yeah, so what I did there was here combining one and two together. These were two separate slides previously. Three and four were two separate slides previously. Five and six wasn't validated previously. And I changed your email address. I've added a little bit more information on the webpages that were developed. I've also added some cost information to the...

2:18:13 Well, I know. I think the comment on the under-accomplishments, splitting out the trail days and the summer of stewardship, that's all on one slide, and it sounds like it's all one thing.

2:18:42 And then like grooming has its own, but I would just break out, if you can, you know, the summer of stewardship from the Lakes Basin Stewards or from the Stewards Program because they are two totally separate different programs and very important ones. Kind of a... Yeah, kind of like that they're on the same page just because it shows some of the things that we're doing as far as service oriented. So I can see both sides of that.

2:19:12 Yeah, but they're two separate programs, I guess is what I'm saying. I mean, it's a separate program. In other words, the stewards program is separate, just like the winter grooming is separate, and the SOS is a, you know, this is a partnership one between MLTPA and Friends of the Inyo, and it's, you know, they are separate. Too often you find people thinking that these are the same, and they're really not. Well, but their bullet pointer is two separate, so.

2:19:41 I don't really have any issues with that. Any other comments? The thing that I've done is on this page adds a little bit more information about what the projects are. Ongoing? Yeah. Yeah. I did have a comment under the Sarbanes. It sounds like Sarbanes that

2:20:16 MLTSCC is contributing 89,000. And, you know, I think Sarbanes needs to be pointed out. It's 100% funded by the federal government. I don't think you want anybody to be thinking that 89,000 is coming out of, see this one right here? Yeah, I mean, it's not. Well, if that's accurate? It's not accurate. I know what I'm saying, sorry, is if Peter's...

2:20:54 Back me up on this. Let's see. That's what we just heard from John. 100%. It's not, nothing's coming out of Measure R. I, you know which one I'm talking about? I understand. Yeah, okay. I don't have the knowledge, I got the information. Yeah, yeah, you don't want anybody thinking that we're funding part of that when it's 100% funded. The Trails Committee has no involvement.

2:21:26 Well, no. I think that's providing input to the process of the project. Maybe, I think we can re-identify the funding sources. Yeah. Yeah, identify the funding sources. Yeah, it's a FTA grant, is it? It's a FTA. FTA grant. Fully funded, yeah. And you just, but we do have, with any of our partnership. Yeah, we always have examples. There's a challenge cost share and whatever, but the fact is that it's...

2:21:55 No money comes out of this, out of Measure R. Let me ask a question this way. Has the committee worked on SAR rains as an accomplishment, as a task item that we can make it over the process? Sure, it's part of, because NEPA is... What is that then? The NEPA part, the resource surveys, but I mean, in other words, it's a trail. So in that sense, yes. Just like we do any CIP project or whatever,

2:22:25 So maybe here I just remove the valuation of the spectrum?

2:22:30 Yes, I would say so.

2:22:32 And maybe put in fully funded.

2:22:34 Fully funded by?

2:22:35 Fully funded by FDA.

2:22:36 Fully funded by FDA, yeah.

2:22:41 Okay.

2:22:44 What was the initial name?

2:22:46 FTA.

2:22:46 Any comments on the staff report?

2:23:06 Attaboy.

2:23:07 A lot of work there.

2:23:08 Do you want to say anything about the decision?

2:23:10 You guys have heard it all before. I'm very disappointed. I said going in that this was going to be the result, and I was told, now hold on, Bill, that's not true, you know, we're going to go through this, and it came out exactly as I assumed it would in the first place. Closed snowmobile access back to 203. I don't think there's adequate reason for it. I'm extremely disappointed.

2:23:40 It adversely affects one more type of recreation that our town needs to be financially successful. So that's, you guys have heard it all before. I didn't mean to push you forward there. No, no, that's fine. If you want me, I can go on for about a half an hour on it. I think what I've said is probably adequate. Fair enough. Any other comments on the staff report from here? John, did you have something you want to say?

2:24:12 Yes, two things. Real quick, there was a presentation for the Water District at the last Mammoth Trails meeting about the fact that the Water District is taking issue with some things happening on Shady Rest. And there's a letter that MLTPA has written that you can sign on to if you want to. I would encourage you to get in touch with me. You can read it. You know, I'm not convinced that that's, you know, the secret hasn't been approved yet. The Water District is going to be raising some significant concerns.

2:24:39 So I think Shady Rest is not a done deal yet at this point. I would encourage you if you want to get in touch with me and sign a letter, that's something. However, the Forest Service has separated out the trailhead, and the reason for it going out there is because of the STEAM project, but they've separated that out from the other environmental, so. Understood, but there are a lot of other recreation concerns out there that we could, you know, get involved in. The other thing is I just got handed this document from Steve having to do with the QR codes and the website, and there's an item in here about

2:25:08 Complete site template build out on server and just doing some things on the website. I'm sure that Steve will do his best to make sure that the efforts of this group, if they start working with the website, that they will communicate with us or managing the website to make sure there's no communications, there aren't any inadvertent surprises or potential damage to the website itself as this project is going forward. The contractor, I believe, is a guy named Dave Titus, but I'm just hoping that we'll have the necessary level of technical coordination so no unintended

2:25:38 Snafu is ensued. Thank you. Okay. Are we there? We're there, so move. I've got a motion to adjourn. Second. Second. Anything for the discussion? What's in favor? Bye. See you next time. All right. Thanks, John. That was a good one.