Parks & Recreation Commission · 2014
Parks & Recreation Commission Formation meeting
· recording 3 hr 3 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
321 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 We're waiting for John, Urdi, and Rick, but I think we can go ahead and get started. I know that they'll be coming in the door any minute now, so let's go ahead and call a meeting to order, Shannon. Okay. For this afternoon. Secretary Bacon? Here. Committee Member Ferney? Here. Committee Member Erdi? Committee Member Stelick? Yes.
0:30 Committee Member Turex? Here. Committee Member Wood? Vice Chair Armstrong? Yes. Chair Stroud? Here. Thank you. Thank you. So we'll go ahead and start with any public comments. I'll open it up to the floor if there is anybody from the public who would like to address the committee. I ask that you do so using the podium and provide us with your name and residence and location. If there's anything not on the agenda that you would like to bring up today.
1:01 All right. I'm not hearing or seeing any. Anybody from the committee have a public comment at this time? No. Okay. No public comment. Then let's go ahead and move into our first couple of items. We have notes that have been distributed both from our April 9th meeting and from our April 14th meeting. And specifically, just as a reminder, on the 14th, the meeting on the 14th, we had asked that those
1:32 We get an abridged version, which Sharon was able to go back and do, and so it represents most of the discussion, but we're using Andy's memo as our guideline document, so we're not duplicating or confusing any issues. So what you see in front of you from our April 14th meeting is truly... And April 9th. I'm sorry, April 9th is the abridged version. So we want to...
2:09 I'll move to accept the evidence from both. I'll second it. Betsy moved. Joe seconded to accept the notes from April 10th and from April 14th. Any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Again, Sharon, thanks for taking time to go back and change the reorganized notes. All right. Item number three is the legal ad hoc body put together and made the legal clarifications that we received.
3:02 Memo. And I'm going to turn it over to Joe and Teri to take us through this, like this, in your packet. We'll advise you what we did in this matrix, and so we're going to focus on this one first. Essentially, we took the 20-plus questions, and as we went through them, we were following whether or not they were policy or legal, and on the legal ones, most of them related to either Measure R and U. So we tried to summarize.
3:41 Everything we had. And we felt like something was a repeat of an earlier one. In fact, it's even funny in some places. And he said, this is the same as number. We go, yeah, we agree. And so essentially what we end up with is what we think is our understanding of all of the questions asked. And so it's the 20 questions that were on the original form, including the blue type. And then Pat Agnich's are just numbered A12345.
4:10 So if you're trying to read through, it's almost like you have to look at both documents at the same time because it switches back and forth between the policy ones. But essentially, we went through and tried to summarize where they were the same or where they were different.
4:28 And we do have a few questions that are still going to come up, and that will be a theme we hear today as we go out to other things, specifically number 19 about the interested parties and representing other groups, all of that kind of thing is still an open question. I'm going to presume that everybody at least looked at it so that it's just a question. Does anybody have any questions?
4:59 on what we put together so far, other than we know number 19 has to go back. So, looking at this matrix so that you understand how to use it, over on the left-hand side we've got reference to the questions that were asked during the conversation, and then we've got a category for measure R answer, and we've got a category for measure U answer, because the two ordinances are different. We try to show the differentiation, you'll see as we go through it. Where we use the word yes and
5:34 And no, it's basically to the question that was asked, you know, is it a good idea to segregate the funds? Yes for Measure R, yes for Measure U. This is taken directly from Andy's memo that he provided, so against it all. I think there's a couple of differentiations in places where there's a yes for R and a no for U. Or a different answer. Or a different answer for R and a different answer for U, and I want to draw your attention to those first.
6:07 Over here, the third box down, number four and number 18, the question that was asked about the recommending body. And in Measure R, the Recreation Commission is the recommending body to town council on allocations unless that expenditure plan is amended. The point that Andy was making in there is that there's a possibility for conflicts of interest. Over here for Measure U, a different body, or the Recreation Commission does not have to be the funding.
6:38 Recommending body, but also it's not prohibited from having a different body, but he also referenced the Measure U would require the amendment, because the expenditure plan is R, can be changed by the council. It's an ordinance amendment, so the council changed it. What we're saying is the expenditure plan can be changed by a majority of the council, or Andy. Measure U is just as straight as.
7:15 Within the ordinance, exactly. They both have a different way. There's a different mechanism for both. Then if we go to page two, questions number ten, does the measure restrict spending to town-owned or managed facilities and programs? Measure R, yes, has that restriction. Measure U does not have that. That's two very different points within each of those measures. And then we go down relative to the ordinance, the discussion that we just had.
7:53 Question number 14, we referenced public vote. The ordinance would be changed. If the ordinance were to be changed, it would have to go to a public vote, except for Measure U, ordinance change would have to go to a public vote. So is it within the ordinance? And then question 20 and question A4 were related to the bylaws, and we've got questions in to Andy on that one. Specifically, question 20 had to do with does the
8:38 Procedure for the apply with Andy's laws, if you will, or the governance of the town. Initial response back was that there's no conflict that's formed is how it's formed and there's no legal authority for it, but he is going to provide us with some additional. So, do we kind of understand what this matrix is and how we're going to use this matrix or intend to use it moving forward? Any questions from the committee?
9:26 Any questions from the public on the ordinance matrix? Measure matrix. Sorry. Sorry. Ordinances. They're the same. Yeah. Any questions from the community on that? Okay. Then the second document that you had in this was the policy questions. This was the next page in your pack. If you remember, Andy took our questions and divided them up into policy legal. So this is the matrix for the policy questions.
10:04 These are his answers. Yeah. Oh, sorry, if you guys help me. Yeah, so it's in front of the other matrix. If you have any questions about it, but again, I think we as this body might be looking at what policy questions we want to include in communication that we send to the council for the May 21st meeting. If there's anything that is burning that should be a policy-level discussion and decision that goes with that May 21st.
10:48 So if you have any thoughts on that, if there's anything that you see that, and I'm kind of looking at Joe and Rick also on this, if there's anything on here that you think has really got to be a part of that May 21st packet, and any recommendation that this body might have a policy decision to the council.
11:24 Certain ones in here, like the second box, the 7, 9, and 11 one, you know, does the town council want to control the other funds? Does one place limits on the use of funds that MLR raises, et cetera? Those kind of fall into the contract negotiations, I think. You know, so several of them are going to get answered in other ways. I think that we will do things like, I would suggest that we recommend that finally, after a number of years, the actual terms,
11:53 Be defined. So we're not arguing for another 10 years about what any of the particular terms in the ordinances are, which I presume would become a council policy. Now, let me clarify, is that something that you're saying should be part of May 21st? No, no, no, no, no. I'm going to say that we would recommend that that be done. No, no, that's not more work for the 21st, but just recommend that those be done. You know, so a lot of these really are things that are going to come out in the contract negotiations, I see.
12:23 Well, but we'll also be recommending certain things on May 21st. Is that what you're going to say? Yeah. Yeah. So let me sort of think out loud on that because there are those in the community who somehow think that we're rushing to judgment here, which in my view, sometimes perception is as good as reality. My objective on 21st is to move this forward in a way that council or council public objected.
13:21 It's a legislative priority. This council owns it as it should. And I want to move as forward as we can on the 21st. I haven't really looked at these within the context of the question that you posed, which is what discussion, what's going to actually be included in the agenda bill. Maybe we haven't looked far enough out to think about what the details have to be. But I think we need to think about that.
13:53 I just bring it up because if there are some policy level points that this body would like to bring forward in some type of a recommendation to the council, I think
14:21 This document serves as a good jumping off point for us to look at because these were policy level questions that Andy raised for us. Or he assigned them as policy level questions. So if there were any that should be integrated into that May 21st, this is a document that we can certainly use. Well, if that's going to be the primary focus of the next meeting? May 12th, yeah. Well, then I'll give us the thought.
14:52 It seems to me important to decide what we actually want to accomplish. So does anybody have any, you guys at the committee, do you have any questions about how this is arranged or how this is organized? Do you see anything that's missing or anything that doesn't show up that you thought you saw? I think our intention was to essentially ask Andy to take a look at the matrix and make sure that our understanding of his answers were
15:26 That way because this would then become a USA Today version of a cheat sheet on how to handle the two sources of funds. Again, something that maybe could have been defined many years ago. So unless anybody has questions, I think that would be our intention to ask him to make sure it lines up with his answers. Any questions from the public about the policy question discussion?
16:01 One item through both the legal and policy side of things that kind of keeps coming up and tends to be what we might call a bit of a sticking point has to do with this funding recommending body. If we remember correctly, Andy advised that it would not be allowed for MLR to serve as the RNU recommending body
16:31 and recommend funding itself through Measure R.N.U. MLR could not serve that purpose. And during the workshop on the 16th, Andy was here, and while he was helping support that workshop, afterwards there was a joint meeting between the Planning Commission and the Council. And while you guys were having your joint meeting,
17:01 I actually had an opportunity to chat with Andy a little bit about how can this be resolved? How do we resolve this MLR funding recommendation issue? And so what you have in front of you that was a handout today is this little document that is two-sided, and it's intended to be an alternative, if you will, for how to address this MLR funding recommendation issue.
17:31 The context behind this really is that we would start to try and change how we look at putting together funding and projects and priorities and who is playing what role and where. So this is my little attempt at trying to explain the conversation that I had with Andy.
17:59 I will let you know that Andy reviewed this and his response back was, yes, this captures the conversation that he and I had in the hallway. It captures the email communication that he and I had. It also, as he references, it's an alternative. It's certainly an alternative that is legal and viable and could certainly work. So if you will indulge me a few minutes, I'd like to take you through this. Again, realizing that MLR can't be the funding recommendation.
18:31 recommending body. This places an emphasis on town council, sitting at the head of a lot of things, providing some leadership and some direction and some playing a perhaps different role than it's played in the past. The two arrows on the right and left hand side of the document represents the MLR board and if you realize that MLR board will have its own contract with the town for services, that is a contract that it executes through the town.
19:04 Over on the right-hand side, there's the town staff and the role that they play. They are the keeper of the CIP, which is our capital projects list. They're the keeper of the adopted plans that have come through that include everything from RecStrats to the Parks Master Plan, Trails Master Plan, to, as I said, RecStrats. Everything, every plan that exists is kept over here. They're pointing to the middle towards the projects list.
19:37 This is where this collaboration between the MLR board staff, identified bodies, and the town staff would collaborate to come together and create this projects list. The projects list would be based on a variety of things. Certainly it would have to be on the CIP list. For any type of implementation, it needs to show up on the CIP list. MLR would have the input talking about where there's additional funding that might be available, where there's a
20:08 and I use the word feasibility for lack of a better word, but this really speaks to
20:37 Nothing gets on the list unless we really know construction costs, we know design engineering costs, construction costs, we know true maintenance costs, we know future encumbrance. This is intended to be, if it's on the list, it's been vetted out completely, and it gets on that list. If it hasn't been vetted out, it doesn't go on to that. It just really can't go on that. Staff and the board, MLR board, creates this list. That list then goes down to the Recreation Commission on your chart.
21:11 It goes to the Recreation Commission. The Recreation Commission serves as the recommending body to the town council for expenditure of R&U funds. They take this list. The meeting is held, public meeting, to receive feedback and input as one of the responsibilities of the Recreation Commission. Through that public meeting, they get feedback, and they prioritize this project's list and send back to the council.
21:40 The recommended funding of RNU for projects that have been prioritized and sent back to the council for approval. Council then has the ability to take that recommendation and approve it or not. Ultimately, it's the town council's prerogative to make that decision. There is not an application process. This does away with an RNU application process.
22:11 It goes back to what's on the CIP list and the projects that have been identified to be on that CIP list. And so there's not an application process. One question there is because if MLR is working, and okay, guys, it is a joke. Joe's climbing wall on the backside of bonds, and I don't know, whoever does that kind of equipment has come along, and we're working on something.
22:41 that isn't even on town property but might be eligible for RRU funding. What do you do about the fact that that wouldn't be on the town CIP? I think that's part of the conversation that has to occur with the board and the staff about completing one of those feasibility documents that identifies the project, the cost, the maintenance, you know, goes through that exercise to then put it on.
23:09 Okay. The list. The list. This project list. I don't think because it's not specifically on the town-owned property or it's on the town-owned CIP list that it can't go on the projects list. But in order to go on the projects list, and this is just conceptually, it has to have one of those feasibility documents attached to it. It's not a, oh, we think this is a good idea, let's go do it.
23:36 It's a, this is a good idea, this is the cost, this is the resource, this is the commitment, this is the long-term ability for us to manage and maintain this thing, now let's talk about it. So if it was on a RecStrats list. It was on a RecStrats list. And has a feasibility that can still go through. Yeah, I think my concern with this is just saying CIP list, because some of the things that are on the current town CIP list wouldn't be compatible with R&U funding. They would be things that I personally would consider supplanting.
24:05 Repairs to Park, Structures, and it's a pretty long list currently, so I don't know if we want to maybe define that a little bit further. And I guess maybe what the deal here is, what I'm understanding is, it doesn't have to be on a CIP list, that MLR can come up with their priorities and projects, the town can come up with their priorities and projects, and they may come up with something that lives on CIP or not, but it has to fit within the R or U
24:35 If you're going to use R&U funding, it's going to have Mito-U. Right. Mito-U. We have much larger CIP than R&U, obviously. Right. Sure. CIP is reference that it's particularly from a town side, that it's not randomly, let's just throw something out here because somebody walked in our door and said this is a good idea. I think that the point that I was trying to make is the second page, third bullet point up from the bottom.
24:59 That this is focused on strategic implementation by having this list that's collaboratively decided upon and we know what it's going to be. That it's not whoever came in the door last or first or whatever. That this really is intended to create focus and priorities for it. And that we now move into implementation mode. That's the other part of the context of this document is that we move into implementation.
25:27 I've read off several plans, and I know I'm missing a few plans that are existing out there that are sitting in a lot of spots. And we haven't, as a community, we haven't pulled together to get these projects out of those plans into implementation mode. And the attempt for this is to get a focus on implementation moving forward. So it's a concept. So this is a concept. It's an alternative. It addresses the potential who should be or could be the funding recommending body for this.
25:57 It involves counsel at a very high decision-making level. It involves collaboration between staff and MLR. It gives the Recreation Commission a very specific role to play in this world right here, in addition to all their other responsibilities. I guess my only question or concern is that when we first started the process with Carl and Michael, one of the biggest things that I had mentioned was a very important thing is consistent funding.
26:27 I'm not sure that this model shows consistent funding because it's a very moving target. It's a very variable. I would hate to have us form something that one year has a million-dollar budget and the next year has a $200,000 budget. I think that's because, again, with MLT, we know our budget is going to be somewhere between $1.9 million and $2.3 million in Measure A. We know that it's going to fall somewhere in there, and we can work within that.
26:54 But if you told me that it was going to be somewhere between $400,000 and $2.4 million, that's a little bit of a swing. Yeah, exactly. Well, that's it. And so I don't want to get to the point where we go through this whole effort and we don't have the sustainable funding for the right person to come into this position, for one, but also to accomplish what this group wants to accomplish.
27:18 Over here under the MLR is intended to be that consistent level of funding. That's the placekeeper for that funding to be identified for MLR. And what's certainly not on here either is that outside funding that is a part of the makeup of MLR moving forward as well. So this was very specific to the R&U recommending body funding issue.
27:45 There's this agreement over here, this contract with the town that is intended to provide that base funding, level of funding, these are the services that you're going to be providing, and for that, this is the funding that you will be getting from the town. And that's the town council executed.
28:11 Right. And the council makes the decision. Yeah. And the council makes the decision. Right. So when we go into the next few things like the scope of work and everything, if it is agreed within the contract that MLR's job is to go out and find the money for Joe's climbing wall, then after that happens it ends up on a later project list. Right. So there's still that other, there's all that other stuff that would happen.
28:40 in the contract between the town and the law. Yeah, I guess I just want to make sure the base funding is there at the very least so that we don't see it. And actually that gets discussed even in a later one of today's sub-base, right? Yeah, understood, but I think that's... No, and I think that gets the base funding. I think the biggest challenge that I look at is when you're talking about it being annual renewal.
29:33 Then it starts to still even get to the point of, you know, when I came here, we had an interim contract because of everything that was going on, and then we went to a month-by-month contract, then we went to no contract, and now we have a five-year contract. So at least we know that we have that commitment. I guess my fear is when we put something like this together, and it's a year, it's an annual review of where we're going, I guess that...
29:56 That's always a challenge. Reading ahead in our, when we get down to talking about the contract, there's just suggesting a three-year agreement to start. I just want to make sure, I mean, annual review of funding is fine, but as long as there's a commitment that says this organization will be here between, and again, as long as it sets a baseline or a minimum threshold of revenue that will be committed to the program, so at least whoever we're bringing on board knows that they have enough funding to do X, Y, and maybe Z, but maybe not one, two, and three. Well, that's, and that goes back to the whole,
30:26 The first point when we had Michael here, I said, you know, I wouldn't, had I been told that we weren't going to have funding on an annual basis, I wouldn't have come. And it's just, you can't expect somebody to pack up and come here for that. This is probably, there's the bigger picture of, this was, this is the capital side of things. With that focus on the implementation to begin. So the, if you will, the administrative side of it, the baseline side of it, you know, has to be executed through that board.
30:56 Dan has pointed out, you know, there's got to be a recommending body, but in the end, council gets to make that decision also. That's a council level decision. Well, that's a policy question. I mean, our baseline is pretty clear. It's 2.5 points of TOT, and it's all of business license tax. I mean, that's very clear to me that, again, my risk is that it's a bad winter and we end up at 1.9 versus a good winter where we end up at 2.3.
31:25 So that's my risk, and I'm willing to take that risk because I know that I'm probably not going to drop too far below even 1.7 I could put forth. But if it's wildly varied from $400,000 to $2.2 million, that's a little harder than I'd be comfortable with. Well, the second point that I would make, and it's important that we ultimately get that result and get ourselves on our way on the 21st.
31:57 It feels like it's going to be easy. And of course, the proposal for the three-year deal takes care of. The other thing is the language on the back with respect to the strategic decision-making somewhere in here. That's really important. For me, the most important piece of this process, which is that we
32:34 Yeah. And actually that was going to be a question I was going to ask because you know we
32:51 Don't want the commission to get mired in the detail either. I mean, there's contract negotiation later. I mean, when you're talking about a feasibility document of these costs, that's still somewhat high level. I mean, we're not going to have somebody going through and asking, well, how many stripes do they put on the track? That's up here. Yeah. That's this discussion right here. I just wanted to make sure. Yeah, that's not down here at this level. That happens here in order to get it up here. Those specifics need to be decided upon at this level. Okay.
33:21 At least in the scenario that I'm looking at. And again, this was based on having just gone through with Andy on legal issues, and this was a sticking point, and I had the opportunity to chat with him in the hallway.
33:39 As a result of that, I was trying to write down what we talked about. It's a concept. It's three-dimensional on a two-dimensional piece of paper. Exactly right. I think that's important is that it tests the, it will test the influence of MLR. And it will also provide some assurance to those who have accountability questions that the talent at this level.
34:07 Will remain, will be actively involved in, you know, the formulation of the projects list. I like that. It seems to serve both interests. Yeah, I really like that collaborative, you know, guarantee that comes from that. I think the only thing that was...
34:29 that I see, and when we were talking about this a little bit in our legal subcommittees, there's really a dotted line between those two arrows, you know, there's a totally dotted line between NLR and the town staff. Sorry, I'm way rapidly challenged.
34:49 This is something to be done differently than the way we've done it in the past. So the danger is that we slip back to the old way, which hasn't proven, at least in my mind, to be as productive as it otherwise could, at least with respect to how we spend our money with our values. So those who are purists, and I tend to be more on the purist side, sort of bristle at having to
35:18 You know, having these two arrows on the same level, because I want MLR to have more influence. But, if you look at the big chart that I had put up some weeks ago, it had a collaborative, it had a dotted line between the town and MLR, which suggested collaboration. I also want to point out, it's in my notes somewhere, I didn't get onto this document. This is, I think it's sitting here somewhere.
35:48 Reporting requirements for R&U will also be refined to show transparency of use of funds. Just because there's not an application process does not preclude a reporting mechanism that has to come into play also in order for the public to see very clearly and understand very clearly how R&U funds were used for these particular projects. Again, realizing that those applications
36:17 The document that we got, they don't even include those applications in the R&U reconciliation. But just because there's a recommendation to eliminate those applications does not mean that there's not a public accounting for how those funds are expanded in Brockport. Sorry, wanted to point that out. And I was thinking of this and kind of, you know, going back and forth with us and sitting on the recognition.
36:45 If this is going to the Rec Commission right now, the Rec Commission position on the board is an ex officio position. And I think that it would be beneficial that if the Rec Commission is going to be this recommending body to the council, that the Rec Commission either has a regular seat, voting seat on the board, or they would have to have some type of a collaborative committee that includes the Rec Commission when they're putting this together.
37:14 And so, you know, I would almost ask if I say that I think that that one ex officio would be a full voting position because then you have that one person within the rec commission that's involved in the process and then is able to take it back to the commission for any information that they might need. Or maybe not that because that almost gives them two votes.
37:39 Yeah, it's, I think Exoficio is still the way to go. Yeah. Because that way they're participating, you know, that way they understand. Yeah. I think what would be careful, too, you don't bifurcate the non-profit status to the capital point of recognition. Yeah. Because of that, they're two different bodies with different purposes to some degree.
38:01 If you remember in the other one, we have the dotted line of the discussion went on with the Recreation Commission, but I think the voting membership might get difficult just because you're talking about an appointed body of the council that in and of itself doesn't have anything to do with the board of the non-profit, even though we have said the collaboration, the partnership and stuff is there. I think this would accomplish it.
38:27 Yeah, so I don't know how we make it, get a fourth dimension in there, but I think there's a certain amount of understanding that if the MLR board has the ex-official person who is part of this interplay and coming up with the projects list, but it'd be right, if they voted there, then voting again would be a problem. I'm still a little concerned with the legal questions, because it seems like there's a conundrum here.
38:56 Measure, our funds can only be used on our projects. MLR cannot recommend on our projects because of conflict of interest. Our money cannot be used, so therefore other money. It seems like this would limit is that administration position. It seems like that we miss about it. So we could interpret the scope of work as all we could look at it and interpret it as. I think the you have does move strategic.
40:45 But I'm just concerned that it would be a fundraising, innovation product. It all comes with funding. Let's remember that MLR is not just R&U. And so your point about the scope of work goes beyond. And probably what's missing over here underneath that MLR arrow are those types of programs and services and activities and facilities that MLR would be responsible for outside of anything specific to R&U.
41:42 You know, some of the things that while you were talking, John, I was thinking we were talking about the trail system, we're talking about the arts and culture center and that collaboration between the foundation over there. We're talking about the high altitude training center. Those are the types of things that I think are living over here under the MLR umbrella that are some of R&U but also outside of R&U.
42:11 And I think the test, the contract elements, look at those nine contracts, and they're pretty detailed.
43:09 The test would be standards. The policy level decision would go to R&U, and that puts places of value, nine elements, those initial nine elements, places of value of R&U funds. Somebody's got a place of value. R reflect this, move a balance on a conundrum. So, again, this was part of the legal conversation specific to the recommending body conundrum that kind of popped up because it had been presumed that MLR
44:34 And I think what we can do as we prepare ourselves for May 12th, if we can take this and any additional alternatives that are out there that should integrate it into a May 12th discussion.
45:34 So trails and rec commissions, how those, what's that part of it? It seems like some ML taking over, but if it doesn't take over, how do those become streamlined? I think you bring up a really good point, that maybe that's part of our conversation and our scope of work, that we identify the role that the UR plays that then may inform what rec commission, U committee,
46:58 I think one of the discussion points that we've had over the time has been this there's so many committees out there and there's so many commissions and there's so many so much time at the staff level and at the volunteer level that is being spent in all these various bodies and committees so if I'm hearing you John you know through this are we helping to streamline
47:28 By any of these types of recommendations or suggestions or scenarios that we're coming up with? Or where are we keeping in mind how to streamline? We need to keep that in mind? Yeah. It needs to flow more efficiently, more efficiently. Recreation Commission members need to fulfill that it's easy. Yeah, it brought it up about all the Recreation Commission, and I was hoping that the Recreation Commission would have...
48:09 Provided some insight during your joint meeting as to what role that they thought they wanted to be playing. But, you know, one of this, you know, there's this last bullet point on here talks about this Recreation Commission focused on issues related to municipal recreation programming and policy, certainly outside of just a R&U recommending body. But in thinking about that role that Recreation Commission and those policy level things that they can be focused on now.
48:40 Because there's been a lot or a U Committee, at least in this scenario, if you will, or be absorbed into the Recreation Commission, that's a decision to be made somewhere. But there wouldn't be a need for a U Committee in this scenario because there's not applications and you're looking at the Recreation Commission, that role. But again, that's a policy level decision. The council appointed the U Committee. The council wouldn't need to make that decision.
49:21 As far as MLTSCC goes, I think along the way there's been discussion that MLR absorbs that management and implementation and oversight of that Mammoth Lakes Trail System holistically. And I think that was in the recommendation and I think that's what we've been talking about. But again, that's a policy level decision about where MLTSCC falls.
49:50 Yeah, that's what he's saying, is that we would have a recommendation. Yeah. Yeah. I expect we will. You know, really what you've done is elevated the role and the responsibility of the record envisioned, and necessarily if you need to state it. We always ask the question, irrespective of your view, you follow the policy that is handed down and the direction that is given by the position, but the commission looks at the direction we have that all the time. And so, again, if we can,
50:46 You know, really, and initiatives, and then following, because ultimately, they're to the council and say, all right, you've told us what you want. Now, what we recommend, I think it can work. I'm thinking about it sort of in theory, and I, you know, again, I've said it over and over again, I want to try to take some of the politics out of things, and I guess you never really do. To the extent that it's in one place, instead of our appointing a lot of people to a lot of commissions, some of whom overlaps and screwed on some commissions and committees.
51:29 Having it one place makes some sense to me. It creates a pretty, as I think about it, as I think about it today, a pretty powerful, potentially powerful commission as opposed to one that's relegated to sort of a lesser standard. I don't know if that was your intent when you put that together, but that's what it's like. Well, and of course, all this formation committee would be doing is suggesting to the council that they look at it differently, but because it is an election year.
52:05 Some of the positions on the rec commission would be coming up, and there is an opportunity to suggest that it be incorporated in a different way so that it does cover all the areas within the appointments consolidated that I think is the perfect timing for that to happen. So if I understood what John said and kind of what Rick said is that we would want to make recommendations on rec, even though we said, well, that will be figured out over time.
52:46 We already got to discuss. I think a lot of the things that my personal opinion is I really want this in mind. And, you know, this, I think the other piece we're going to get to is this does address. Not particularly. I just, I really like the way that this satisfies the ordinance. And it just, it also just guarantees that ongoing conversation. Because as I think about the list of things, you know, that the town has and the things, you know, that MLR will have and just making sure that.
54:29 And I kind of see this as a piece, you know, not that MLR is going to be all R and U, but that it's a piece for them to understand, oh, well, these are the other needs that we need to be finding the funding to achieve. So, yeah, it works for me. I was kind of thinking about the most recent plan your parks scenario. And so, you know, here's an exercise. There's, you know, projects and there's, you know...
54:57 Somebody's talking about bonding and whether you're going to go out and do all this stuff. And I was kind of struck by, well, you know, there's a role that, yeah, there's a role that both entities play in. And I, you know, I think I see Plan Your Parks, you know, coming into this little projects list here, that there's a, you know, discussion and a collaboration about what makes sense to put onto that list. And that it requires a discussion to be
55:28 and that MLRs come into the table with resources.
55:58 The town is coming together with some resources and that independently they're not off doing their own thing. I see a greater coverage. Certainly, but it would be a shame for, at least from my perspective anyway, it would be a shame for the Plan Your Parks document to take off and go this way and construct something that maybe MLR had the ability to go out and generate some additional funding for.
56:28 Or rather than being the $2 million facility, maybe it could have been the $5 million facility if MLR is at the table with that discussion also. So to me, that's what I see. Operational issues that you have to work through here just to determine who's staffing what. No, there's no community, because here's the deal. Every single one of those plans, including planning parks, trail system master plan, parks recreation master plan, rec strats.
57:52 They've all gone through a significant public vetted process that received significant public input and there's recommendations that are attached to each of those that have kind of been languishing in various spots. The point there is let's get those recommendations down onto this list here that now we can start to move into implementation. It does not mean that every single recommendation ends up on this list. You know, there's, I use Jim Smith all the time. He was the one during the Measure U Committee that said
58:20 Look, not everybody gets to be first. Sometimes somebody has to be second, third, and in some cases last. But the point is you get it onto a system that now we're moving into implementation. There is no more public vetting. We've got every plan imaginable that's been approved and ready to go. Design. We're going into design and implementation.
58:43 You have to have another public vetting of these processes. No, no, no, no, no, no. The Recreation Commission has to hold a meeting to make a recommendation back to the council. That's the only, that's the public meeting. I hate to say this this way. You don't need the other processes on top of that to make that happen. Now, for MLR, will we dive in and have a project almost, if we're doing it, just do it. I'm not saying that. No, no, no. I guess the only challenge I see here is if we,
59:27 If this is not on both sides viewed as a bigger picture thing, if these remain siloed, then all of a sudden council is going to become the referee because, you know, it's, I'll use the concept of free land. The Amazon gets cut down because nobody owns it and everybody cuts it down as fast as they can. So if CIP is only a million dollars available, I don't want to see one side saying, well, we need 800,000, screw you. No, we need 800,000, screw you, and we don't end up getting anything done because these two can't work to the greater good of
59:56 You know, what is going to benefit the community the most and understanding that it's a collaborative effort. And that's the only piece that I'm concerned about is that those silos get formed because, well, we need this much money. Well, no, we need this much money. And then all of a sudden, council starts to become the referee that says, all right, then we're going to have to assign who's going to get what. And it's just, it's, I don't want to see that. I think was part of the process initially. I see that coming back in. I hate to say that. I see that coming back in. There's some faith.
1:00:26 That the two arrows that are pointed at one another are going to come to it. Hey, and let's be honest. This is just a scenario. This is a concept. This is a scenario. The conundrum was R&U funding recommendation. And the realization that MLR can't play that role, so now what do we do? Well, the question becomes, what's the funding structure for MLR, Dave? There's other ways to see it. Sure, sure. Is that too? Yeah. Any other questions from this body?
1:00:57 I don't know. You're eager? I mean, yeah. I mean, we got... But John's point goes, what infound staff have greater weight? I see that the arrow is doing the work. The arrows do the work. Send it to the Recreation Commission. They send it back up. That list of priorities is approved. And then MLR goes and plans it. It strongly incentivizes MLR to go out and, you know, get the money for their stuff.
1:01:51 Well, it also incentivizes MLR to exert its influence. In other words, not to say, all right, well, we're, you know, MLR, we're the appointed body. We're the board, and we're going to go out and do, or we need to do a direction of council, but instead, you're very proactive. John, you're very proactive. Your board is very proactive. I would envision the same. And this isn't, the only way to make it pure is to eliminate the town. You can't do that. And that's clear.
1:02:23 That's clear from his memorandum. Correct. So it can't be pure, and so it's got to be a hybrid, and hybrid means collaboration. I guess, you know, the test, it will be tested by time. And what this does strategically is it actually gets all the things being discussed at the same time. So we're not all of a sudden something kind of, oh, well now we can go spend this money. Well, no, if you did, you know, it really...
1:02:51 Focuses it, and it says at a strategic level, which we have not done in the past. Yeah, I agree. That's maybe the biggest single benefit. It goes to the commission that they package, comes back up to council as a matter of, as a priority. It's just, you know, we've had conversations about this. Town staff has publicly stated that they don't have the capacity to do it. So, in some way, shape, or form, there needs to be some level of support.
1:03:24 and work in conjunction between these two entities because MLR cannot exist without the town and vice versa. I mean, we continue to have this siloed approach as we're talking about. And the reality is, you know, the town staff has to do the CIP anyway. The Recreation Commission's been working on their stuff all this time. You've got the planning parks. You've got those kinds of things going on. And they have to be folded in, but they need to be folded, which is what I think. I guess I just look at the pot of money and I look at the...
1:04:10 Amount of potential grant funding that's been discussed from matching funding is a huge number. And, you know, I just don't want to see these get siloed to the fact that, no, in order for us to accomplish these five projects, we need all the money to match grants that are going to do that, and it leaves MLR with nothing. Because, again, in the perfect world, that would be the way it would work, is that MLR would recognize that these are the most important things we need to do, and all the money goes this way, and it puts MLR kind of almost out of business before they're in business.
1:04:39 Those are the things that I guess, because everybody's got their priorities, and it's difficult not to assert your priorities, and I just don't want it to end up banging heads. MLT, we have funding. I'm not competing with funding. I'm not challenging Stuart that he shouldn't be spending money on something because it's a common pot. It lets us get things accomplished. I'm just concerned that both sides are going to have very...
1:05:08 Valid arguments as to why Project A versus Project 1 are the most important thing. And just getting to that point where they actually can come to agreement on it. I'm just always concerned when you're trying to, especially when you're dividing up money. People like to have their money. But ultimately, the arrows are not dividing the money, it's the Recreation Commission that make the Recreation Commission. Right. Okay.
1:05:39 If you get a recommendation to the Recreation Commission. I don't know that you do. Maybe you've got these competing things. There's a giant box and they're all in there. So are they both putting their proposals to the Rec Commission? I mean, maybe they're talking to each other about it, but are they both putting in separate proposals? No, no. No, I understand. But again, it then...
1:06:04 The recommendation is going to come to the – from these two arrows, it's going to come to the recommendation with their recommendation. But, again, my concern is them getting to a consensus. But with those caveats below, like, you know, feasibility documents and the inmates hop to plans. But just some of that's good. The question there is going to be – I'll be honest on that. If you turn around and say that level of feasibility work, a lot more – It's going to be hard to fund anything. You're not going to fund that in front of you. Here's $50,000, $100,000 or more to get to what you're talking about to make a decision of a priority complaint.
1:06:33 Well, I'm going to disagree with you, Dan, because funding of defeasibility projects has been done with R&U money already. But what I'm hearing initially was that's not what the funding is going to do. No, no, I don't think that's true. I mean, it's not. I mean, it's not. Here's the deal. I would hate to see that somebody says, oh, let's go build a rec center.
1:07:02 And that project goes down here and we're going to need $6 million to build a Rec Center. And there's not been any feasibility that's been done with it that talks about the programming, the ongoing maintenance, the operations, the functionality of that. To me, that doesn't go on that list just yet. But if in this discussion, these two are saying, you know what, Rec Center is the top of our list. The first thing that we need to understand is, what's our programming, what's our operation, what's all of this? Let's get that done first. And you come down to the commission and say,
1:07:31 This is the first thing that we're doing. This is the only thing that we're doing. Line up. I say that so much partially, but it's giving a direction. We've heard it. It lives somewhere. Or it says, you know what? The rec center that we're looking at over here is way, it's the Cadillac. We don't need a Cadillac. This discussion says we don't need a Cadillac. We can't afford a Cadillac. Here's what we can afford.
1:07:58 And this body goes into it. And if you have to do that feasibility, if you really have to have that information, that's the first step that you do. That's the priority for that year. That's the priority for that. Because next year, the intention is to break ground somewhere.
1:08:35 I think the point is we're trying to move this to a more strategic level, which this achieves. We're also trying to look at viable alternatives that are legally passable, which this is. So I think it's the charge of this body moving forward before the 21st to look at other viable alternatives, and this is one. So what do we like about this? What do we not like about this?
1:09:02 And kind of compare it to other alternatives, which we don't have sitting in front of us right now. But this is a viable alternative to this floor. And are there other viable alternatives to bring forward? And that's a May 12th meeting discussion. So between now and May 12th, there are these other alternatives that you, using this or using your own, that we want to come forward with, let's have that discussion on the 12th. Because in the end,
1:09:31 At the 12th, we have to make that recommendation what goes forward to the council. I don't see any of these nine items that are on there. On the contract elements, yeah. I'm going to, is there any, are there any comments from the public on the funding recommendation? Yeah, any comments from the public on this handout? Okay, so.
1:10:08 Our to-do then is between now and May 12th. You can take this, fine-tune this, come up with your own alternatives, but we will be making a decision on May 12th to take to account address our allocation. Okay, move on. We have draft bylaws that are being presented by the bylaws ad hoc committee. And this is a, your bylaws ad hoc committee with Rick and Joe and myself. The bylaws that are in front of you consist of some cutting and pasting.
1:10:46 Really well done articles, excuse me, bylaws from other organizations in town. And so we want to present them today for your input and review. Our intent today is to take this to Andy so that he can have a quick glance through it to make sure that he's okay with it. We believe that he is because he was okay with the initial elements that we provided him. We want to take you to our bylaws.
1:11:21 Rick or Joe, do you want to... Essentially, it incorporates the things we talked about at the last meeting, but they're not, you know, so like Article 3 is the part about no members, etc. On the bottom of the second page, though, you'll notice that the restriction on interested persons as directors is one of the questions that we have. That's also question 19 from the legal questions about, you know...
1:11:47 Being an individual who's an interested party versus being someone who's representing a different group and whether or not you can have the contract. So that whole piece still has to be worked on. A lot of the rest of it is boilerplate. Page 3 has the qualifications and things that we talked about before with just some tweaking to the language. So I'd ask everybody to take a look at section 4.8.
1:12:16 4.7 and 4.8. Yeah. Can I go back to 4.3 for just a second? Sure. That's on page 2. 4.3, Authorized Number of Directors, where we talk about the appointed position between a town council designee and a representative of one of the tourism. Does MLR board retain the ability to accept
1:12:59 Who that person is? For which? So if MLT says, you know, John, you want to be a, does MLR need to say, okay, we accept John? I think it comes like with us. The lodging association tells us who they want on there.
1:13:21 Yeah, okay, yeah. They, they, they benefit. The appointment is there, there is a clause, I believe in the bylaws, that if there's a disruption with a board member or there's an issue or something, so they're not able to run their business, they would be able to ask them to, to go back to the, to the, I think, I think that's, yeah. Yeah, so somebody, yeah. Right.
1:13:48 Yeah, so I think we have it covered. Right. But I think it's just mostly it's like it's accepted. It's like who we appoint to ESTA. This is who we appoint to the Local Transportation Commission. Those kinds of things. Yeah. Yeah, 4.7, 4.8 are key. This committee, in my absence last night, went over the proposed draft. Yes. And so this is just now all wrapped together.
1:14:32 So that's, for example, when you get back to page 9, where we, the full group wanted to call them president, secretary and treasurer, so we went back to that. We did have some discussion before about this idea of non-crumming residents, whether we restrict that to a certain number, or are we comfortable just keeping that as non-resident? Well, I think that's one of the things the board will do in their nominating.
1:15:01 procedures really consider what does that mean. Right now I think on the commission you have to, I think there's only one position that can live outside of town. Yeah, well it's different depending on which of the different commissions and advisory boards. For example, with the building advisory group, we actually changed the number to be higher because there weren't that many of them living in.
1:15:29 the town limits anymore. So it could be set or we could leave it open. I just wanted to follow that. Yeah, yeah. Can we discuss the kind of planning conditions? Well, and I think on planning conditions it may even be statutory. But are you asking the question, do we want to limit the number? Do we want to limit it to two? We talked about it, but I didn't see that we came up. We didn't come up with any, there was not a
1:15:59 Consensus recommendation. Right, so I just wanted to circle back to that because it was discussed. I kind of think that that might be another way to go, not more than one or two. I'd say two. Yeah, two leaves you the opening. Okay, not more than two do not have to be a permanent resident. Yeah. Because you don't really, you know, you might have. And this is an executive board and there could be.
1:16:31 You know, arms that go outside of that. This is just the executive board. Right. Correct. Well, yeah, so the nominating committee is, as we discussed, where there might be others helping it. When you get back to committees, which I'm trying to find, okay, on page six, when we start talking about committees, there's a 5.11 to allow a committee to have advisory participation.
1:17:00 No, right. That's going to depend on what the whole issue is. When my climbing wall is being built, we may want to have some people helping out the subcommittee on that. God, no climbing wall, please. No.
1:17:28 Not more than two. No more than two. Up to two. Then there's another section because there's a whole bunch of stuff. If you have somebody who's like, the CEO of Patagonia wants to come and sit on the MLR board.
1:18:00 Okay, so now we're saying not more than three.
1:18:29 Correct.
1:18:42 Okay, then there's a whole bunch of stuff that is totally boilerplate until you get to page 13. That's technically the minimum requirement. However, there will probably be monthly meetings or more often.
1:19:10 But that's how they're written in the Corporation Code. It keeps you from after violation. You don't meet every month. It's like how you're violation of the bylaws. Yeah. As long as you meet once a year, you're... Right. It's likely there would be a monthly meeting, but yeah. So this is setting the minimum? Yeah. This is the annual meeting. The only other thing I had on page 9 when we were talking about the election of officers, you know, it's left open here. I just want to make sure we don't have in here anywhere,
1:19:41 You know, we're running into some challenges with the MLT board where we're losing some of our core executive committee people and the bylaws talk about the fact you have to be a board member for a year before you can fill a position. And we have a lot of new board members that have, you know, Tom Cage has not even been here for a year and, you know, I think we've got Kurt Schaubmeyer just on the board. He hasn't been there for a year. So we're actually, it's an interesting situation of how we're going to fill the positions. Teri's vice chair, she's leaving in June.
1:20:08 Where do we put her? Matthew Lehman is secretary. He's leaving in June. Yeah. You know, do we have, we're literally, it's down to, okay, you're the only person that can fill that position. Congratulations. That's why this is a little more open. Well, that's why I just want to make sure it's not written anywhere. Okay. Well, I don't recall, and I'm looking for it now, that a qualification of being an officer was that you'd be able to afford. Oh, yeah. I don't see it. No, it, well,
1:20:37 I don't think so. We did 6.2 as directors. Okay. Yeah. Agreed. I think it was one of those. So the issue you're running into is just that time restriction.
1:21:06 Yeah, and we don't have that in here, but... Right. Right. I think you need to put, show me a member of the MLR board. And also repeat it in 6.3. Okay. That's all I have. Thanks. That was good. 6.3 also? Yep. Yeah. We have a meetings question. Terry did. So the board can schedule, can adopt it.
1:21:45 Yeah, and so there's the intention, and actually that kind of gets us to the part I wanted to talk to you about on page 13, which is called Article 9, Governance. This is actually borrowed from Friends of the Library, and it's an attempt to not...
1:22:10 Clutter your bylaws with a lot of procedural types of things so that essentially you have a set of standing rules which are all your operational guidelines so you approve a policy that says you're going to meet on the first Monday of every month at whatever time, those kinds of things that can be easily updated. That's also where you might put into things like how many people sign a check and more of those
1:22:36 Detail-related things. Then what I'm willing to share with NLR is
1:22:43 Friends of the Library has also put together a legal requirements handbook, which is the guidelines for meeting on your local, state, and federal legal requirements so that you have a listing and everybody knows what has to be done. I mean, in the case of Friends of the Library, it reminds us to apply for a business license each year and, you know, all those kinds of things. Pay your taxes. Pay our taxes. Well, we don't pay taxes, but we do have a night night. File your paperwork anyway. File your state stuff, so on and so forth.
1:23:09 And then we also created what's called a governance handbook, which is a guideline for actions that was done to answer the three and a half pages that are on the Form 990 of questions, do you have this, do you have that? So you've got your whistleblower policy, you've got your conflict of interest, and all those kinds of things are contained in these other handbooks rather than being thrown into the bylaws.
1:23:35 I think there's conduct in there somewhere. So the idea is that
1:23:59 What we have here in each case is those shall be adopted and amended by resolution approved by the majority of the board, which means that they do not have to be in place when the bylaws are adopted, but as you build them, you build all that detail as you go along. And then another one that's not often in them because it's often in your articles incorporation, but
1:24:27 that the friends put in was just both a reminder about political activities and prohibited activities right in the bylaws. So that there, so in a way it's, but you haven't seen any articles yet. And also clearly stating about the dedication of assets since that can be a huge issue when things have to change. So any comments or questions, concerns?
1:24:56 You know, before, before, okay, so we have two weeks until our next meeting. I'm wondering if we ask everybody to get back to me with any other things they have questions on by the end of the day on Wednesday so that then we can have a copy to send off to Andy on Thursday. So then in case, I know, if you need to sleep at night, you can be there. This Wednesday. Yeah, this Wednesday. The 30th. It would be the 30th.
1:25:26 So any... Or anything that pops out when you read it for the 400th time. We still have a few more days. We're still in April. We're still in April. And then the intent is we would take this draft to get his... Right. So my tasks following are... These are good. These are much meatier than the first ones we saw. And I like, too, that they include...
1:26:29 You know, the things about, you know, open meetings and the Brown Act and, you know, because I think those, you know, speak to some of the questions of transparency. Correct. And so example, probably one of the first things that would go into one of the other documents or handbooks mentioned is what are the Brown Act requirements, you know, to make sure that everybody knows that and they've adopted them so we know about post-it meetings and da-da-da. Yeah. But, yeah, but you don't have to put that whole thing in your violence.
1:26:57 So I'm not going to ask for an approval at this point. We provide Joe with feedback. By the 30th, we'll send it to A on the 1st, and then we'll endorse them because it will actually be the Transition Board who approves them in the incorporation. So we will endorse them as whole. Do your board members still inform some of them? I think, though, well, because I know for Recreation Commission, it's only things within the border of town that we, so I think it's
1:27:52 Different, depending on which. And that's part of that whole getting it clear with Andy about the interested parties and the, yeah, what are the requirements. But even if it's outside of the, you know, place. Yeah. If it's outside of the region, it's outside of the town. Yeah. But like I don't have to report my house in New Hampshire. Yeah. Yeah. And I didn't have to. Business and real estate. Yeah. But that's a, that's a point that we'll ask Andy to clarify for.
1:28:20 And the questions are pretty broad on the Form 700, too. It's like a range of... If we owned a home here or a business here and they were elsewhere, then they would... Yes. So, again, our takeaway here is April 30th, which is Wednesday. Close the business to Joe. Any thought? And we're sending it to Andy on the 1st. And then on the 12th, we will... Any comments from the public on these proposed bylaws?
1:29:13 Yeah. Since the ones that we were looking at had legal review, we were pretty confident with the cutting and pasting, and that's where Rick went back to make sure there wasn't something egregious that we either included that we shouldn't have or didn't include that should have been there.
1:29:49 Okay. I just think it's a corporation. Correct. And that would be transition. Yeah. Okay. Questions? Larry, would you mind coming to the podium? Sorry. I need to capture your voice. Hi. Thanks. I just had a question on the analysis of physical and mental demands. On what page are you looking at? What section? It's the qualifications. And it says you have to walk 500 yards daily.
1:30:23 Oh, we're not on that one yet. We're on bylaws. We're still on bylaws. We're reading ahead. Okay. All right. Moving on. No other questions about bylaws. Moving on to number five, the MLR scope of work presented by our scope of work ad hoc committee. Betsy, Joe, or Betsy, Joe, and John. Uh-huh. And we'll let you guys take us through this. Okay. And for that, we're looking at this document, the MLR scope of work, and then there's an attachment to it, which is the analysis.
1:30:54 And we'll get to that as a part of the conversation. We're looking at these two documents. Okay. So the three-page document essentially was taking what we looked at last time in a grid that we had the consensus on and turning it into a narrative document of what the MLR scope of work would be as it relates to anything we do connected with the TEM.
1:31:25 So essentially the working concept would be that MLR enters into a contract with the town with accountability oversight similar to MLT and MLH. Town council retains ultimate responsibility for the allocation of RNU funds, which goes back to the scenario we talked about. MLR will operate under indirect supervision by the town council through scope of work and deliverables identified in the contract.
1:31:51 So the scope of work is a higher level than we're going to talk about when you actually see the contract. Oversight is also maintained through one MLR board member being a council member. Further, it's critical that MLR, MR, and MLT work closely to develop a strong synergy between recreational offerings and the promotion of those offerings. Is MR, is that the municipal? That's the municipal recreation. Sorry, it was up there before then, somewhere. I forgot where it is, but it's up there. Okay. Yeah.
1:32:22 Or maybe it didn't end up in this copy. I'll make sure that it gets in there. I thought it was. MLR will also interface with their key partner organizations, including public and private sector organizations, non-government, all that stuff we all saw before. So then, in discovering that when we went from the town recreation plan into the goals, visions,
1:32:49 Strategies, Goals, and Programs, things got repeated. So this is taking them and using what was on the first page of the things like pursue emerging recreation trends and putting all the tasks, kind of combining them, whereas they might have been in all five strategies within the town rec plan. So this was just kind of pulling all the like things together. So you have the pursuing of the emerging recreation trends. We'll come back to that.
1:33:18 details like leveraging funds, distributing information, providing viscerine and recreation, partnerships, and then specific approach prioritization of R&U, which is essentially in line with, it would meet, it describes in another way what we just had in the scenario that Dan was. So, well that's what happens when you're on more than one subcommittee, you're aware.
1:33:44 You spend all your time writing this stuff. So essentially this was pulling pieces that were in the five different strategies in TML together. I don't know if we want to go through them individually or how you guys want to proceed at this point. Because it was, it's the wording we talked about before, they're just slotted differently. I think, yeah. Just consolidated. Just consolidated, yeah. So I'm going to ask the committee, this captures the essence and the direction of MLTPA.
1:34:29 Yeah, it tries to explain the strategies with some specific tasks now assigned to what we need rather than just, yeah. It seems to capture the recreation outcomes and finalized strategies. That was the intent, yeah. And the work from the last year or so. Yeah, it was basically the boiled down version of all that. It's a synced version in place.
1:35:15 You have implement down here. I would appear in partnerships to collaborate with TAN and designing a comprehensive connected system with facilities and trails. Is there implementation in there also? You talked about implementation down below. Yeah, when we pulled it together, that's what I say, when they were pulled from the five different strategies, there were ones that talked about collaboration. There were other ones that talked about implementation. So they're not usually excused.
1:35:42 Mutually exclusive, but there is the intention to implement. So above there's designing, then there's the implementation down below. Right. What about any... I mean, the order can be changed. Is the word management, programming, functionality, operation? Is that a...
1:36:12 Planning, Programming, and Administration. Well, you know, we've been talking about the system, we talked about high-altitude training facility, I mean, in thinking about the role of MLR and some of those, you know, we use the track as an example. So if MLR is engaged in some type of programming for the track, is that captured in...
1:36:38 Is there another verb that we need to use in here? Well, and the thought was, and actually I think that's where this kind of leads into the contract one, so we're all starting to think about it. If you look at the heading of Provide Visitor-Oriented Recreation Programs and Activities, it's tasked to be project-specific and identified as projects are approved.
1:36:58 Rather than trying to guess what they are here. So it keeps it very general? Yeah. I'm just looking for that. I'm just seeing where it plugs in. I think it plugs in because then if we go back to that final page and you go with, well, here's the particular things that might be in the first contract that they'll all still fit under these strategies.
1:37:19 A little more specific? Is that what we're saying? And this can provide a guideline for it? And then you have a strategic approach of deliver project-related programming as identified in front of it, right? Yeah. So I think it's all covered there. And it's almost like this almost becomes the mission and vision. This scope of work, this piece, is more of a...
1:37:40 Here's everything it can do, part of which is the problem John mentioned earlier while we're trying to go on. Are we talking about the NLR organization? Are we talking only about what the town contracts with? And so trying to separate those out, I think that this is still somewhat umbrella-ish, but I think everything's covered that's in the later document about the, what's it called? Contract framework. Yeah, contract framework. Yeah. I think that's what we were trying to accomplish.
1:38:10 Yeah. Yeah. The Recreation Commission took those elements and now they're, you know, kind of unified. Yeah. So if you take the five strategies on the first page and then you say, here's what it might look like. There would have to be a couple changes on the third page because we were not talking about recommending.
1:38:41 Or maybe we are. We'll work that out. Still a moving target. Still a moving target. Still a moving target. There's a role for it. Correct. So we know we'll have to make it here. Somehow associated. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. The priorities, right. Yeah.
1:39:10 So some of the things you were asking about, you know, delivering act on projects, deliver project-related programming as identified and funded, it's made more sense to put that under there than under the other. Any other questions from this body? Do you want to share that? The word does not say funding. Right. Well, if we go back to that, that this was supposed to go down here to prioritize and go back up. This right here,
1:40:04 Gets the projects on the list, and these, I think it's, I think it's all three that are there, because they're carrying forward what these, what you have to be able to do with them. Are they? Oh, yeah, they have to be their own thing, sure, sure, sure, sure. But back to this point that you made earlier about the influence of these two arrows to this up here as well. I mean, that scenario would test it.
1:40:42 Both of these arrows have influence up there also. And now he's doing an in-run around your commission, so. Well, you know, this is, but that goes back to the silos and the trust and the priority. That's my version. We're talking about doing things differently. That's what. Well, that's what this has to be doing, doing things differently, and I slip back. Right. There's some discipline that goes with it. You're right. Yeah. Well, Joe can't come in and apply for the climbing wall now. No, I won't be applying for that climbing wall. That's the difference.
1:41:15 It's just a thought. It's just a thought. You have to look at it. You have to come up with the alternatives. Understood. So I don't think... Are you concerned that there's a question about... No, I'm not concerned about it. In my mind, it raised the issue. I was trying to understand the distinction between recommending priorities and then the funding recommendation. So people would say, here's our recommendation for priorities. The council says, great idea.
1:41:45 I wouldn't see MLR going to have that conversation with the town council without having gone through and exercised with town staff to set up that list first. That's my scenario. I wouldn't see MLR going off on its own.
1:42:10 To go up here and say, here's our priorities, and now we're going to go down here and try and figure out what the towns are. Yeah, but what you see is that they're going to go to the Recreation Commission, which may act and will. Independently, they have every, they have every, but if the documentation is provided, says here's the feasibility for it, here's where the money's coming from, here's where we have the finances for these projects, this is the recommendation, and the commission chooses to go off and do something else because
1:42:37 They've come up with a different idea that goes against what the town staff recommended and what MLR said. That's their prerogative, but ultimately, it's this body that's making the decision. So if they're going to go off and do their own thing, there should be some rationale for it. And I think the other thing we're trying to do is make it all more strategic so it is not a commission or a committee sitting there and nickel and diming down to 47 cents type of thing. It's that that, if council says, yes, we are going ahead with Joe's claim and wall, then
1:43:07 Then the finite things and all the contract negotiations are happening, not other structure. The town council will be saying, you know, town manager, make it so. Well, I guess my concern is what happens before that. Yeah, okay. Where you have a conflict, what priorities that may be different from these who occupy the arrows are really sound, strategic initiatives. Because you're going to have staff support going in the direction.
1:43:46 No, no, no. That would not even happen. That wouldn't happen. That wouldn't happen at all. So the Rec Commission wouldn't be on its own? Not to make that kind of a decision, not to go down that path. But that's where the Rec Commission, as an ex-official member of MLR, could be involved in discussion and reporting back. They don't have any kind of reporting anyway. Do they? Yes.
1:44:30 Concern that Terry brought up as well, and that's not, you know, that's not what the goal is. But if the recommendation can't, they're going to be meeting on their own, because they're going to deal with other issues that are falling into it. Can they make a recommendation, say, we really should be, or... Couldn't they make that recommendation here to the town staff, and then that compensation occurs? Or to MLR. Yeah, or to MLR. I say, that'll happen. Sure. You have three bodies in here. Yeah. I'm just trying to think it back to the streamlining process. Sure. I'm not sure we've gotten there yet. Sure, no, a discussion.
1:45:15 And the struggle that I have is that currently this scenario that we just talked about is happening. And what we're not getting to is implementation anywhere. And so where there's the opportunity to look at this and find out where the sweet spot is for implementation is where we have to go. Well, but let's also, and I would also just offer up to you, and I want to go back.
1:45:48 Hit this thing up again. But I would also offer up, there's an opportunity to redefine people's roles and responsibilities as well. And I think that's a part of the discussion too. And creating the expectation for what those roles and responsibilities are in a scenario that might look something like this. But could I come back, I guess, to the strategic approach? That MLR. Via the commission. Otherwise, why would we hate? MLR makes a recommendation. Commission takes it to council. Yeah, right.
1:46:23 Or else you're just... Because they have to be the governing body. They have to be the governing body. Right. Okay. Yeah, so that one. I did put that pretty uncomfortably. I think, please, you have to. That's my biggest concern. Because an appointed board is really different from all getting along real well or maybe not functioning as well as they could. Maybe there's a dissident member of a commission. I'm not suggesting that, you know, all commissions should be...
1:47:34 You know, the vanilla flavor, and everybody should come and do it. I mean, counseling, but I'm really speaking to, you know, sort of the functionality, if you will, and we're talking about streamlining. I don't know. This is a problem, because for me, what's happening here is that we're taking a step back in a direction that I'm not thrilled with, but we're, because everybody's getting along. Well, let's remind ourselves, too.
1:48:10 Think of the context of this. This was specific to the issue of who is the recommending body for Measure R and U. And that's a little different than priority projects. Well, and that was why I kind of go back to the idea or the question of are they going to end up, is MLR going to make their recommendation?
1:48:39 The municipal's going to make their recommendation, and then it's going to be Rec Commission has to decide where it goes. Oh, the recommendation. Versus the collaboration. I mean, I want to say that there's going to be the collaboration that says, hey, we agree with you that that's an important project. We defer to the $400,000 request that you have to go into the recommendation. That's the perfect world. So the question is, in the Rec Commission, if you make your own recommendation, now it's not both of you. We can strive for the perfect world, but again, if the Amazon isn't the perfect world, it gets mowed down every day because of nobody having control.
1:49:07 Well, yeah, I don't know where it is, yeah. Yeah. Maybe this is, I don't want to suggest this. Yeah, maybe. I know that it meets one legal requirement that we've still been trying. That we've been challenged. So, that we've been challenged. And I don't have better suggestions, so. Well, yeah, yeah, you don't have, good deal, you don't have. Collectively, I think we can come up with a better solution, but that's, we get the opportunity to go through.
1:49:38 Well, remember, too, I don't want to get stuck in this, but, you know, this is just talking about the R and U, you know, priorities. So, you know, the money that MLR goes out and generates on its own, you know, it will factor into that process, but this process is really specific to the R and U monies. Correct. A few months of it's existence. Yeah, it's going to be the biggest risk. That could be all ahead. I see it becoming less of an issue. Or the error of the line. Yeah, that's funny, because I can. Right. But down there, it's just down and down.
1:50:30 I don't know. Did we get a consensus? I wasn't suggesting it's trying to figure out how it's going to work. It's the right thing to do. Questions on this? Just for clarification, on the 12th, did we come back with anything that's final that will be included in the May 21st Council agenda?
1:51:32 You know, I don't know, because at what point do we step back? Because, you know, what's going to council again is a potential contract between and the town, which needs to be informed by this information, but the guiding document, I think, coming out of that is going to be whatever we're calling the contract negotiation stuff, which is more specific to particular tasks to be. So this is still somewhat global. I think it's there, but I think the real focus is on
1:52:03 Well, what would you do in the first three years, whatever we're going to say at that point. So I think this informs it, and that's why we can, you know, we can wordsmith some things if you, but we won't really know that until we decide our other structure piece. So I guess it could come back as it is, and then we could make any final changes before the agenda. I think it's there. I think it's there, yeah. Let's leave it open, and then on the 12th we finalize it.
1:52:38 Any questions from the public on the MLR final draft scope of work? Yes, Sandy Hogan. And I think, you know, what I hear you struggling with is what my comments on this part were also.
1:53:01 Because it works fine when everybody's holding hands and singing kumbaya or whatever. But the reality is what was missing for me, and I had written quite a while ago, was I don't see any leads here. And I think you do need to articulate perhaps when does MLT have the lead in some of these tourism things. Because I went down and I was kind of trying to assign some of that. When does MLR maybe have a lead in some of the things? And when does your staff?
1:53:31 Or when does your rec commission? And I think if you will spell those out a little bit more, and I think you were talking about it, Dan, in terms of roles and responsibilities, at least maybe I was reading that into it, because if you don't spell out who really kind of has the lead, all of a sudden if you have a real aggressive one, he's going to start doing John's job, and John all of a sudden is not going to want to sing Kumbaya. He's going to get frustrated.
1:53:55 And so these are the kind of things, and the same type of thing, if MLR, somebody in MLR says, oh yes, I've got the expertise to do this, and you've got professional staff engineering that's saying, oh wait a minute, and they bring you something that really isn't worth anything, we've wasted taxpayer dollars. So taking a little time to try to look at this from the point of view, who really brings the expertise here, you know, to this particular part, I think if you break that down,
1:54:25 And then the Rec Commission is more of the advisory part of it because they're not going to bring the expertise necessarily. Anyway, that was just what was missing for me and I kept looking for it back in the contract also. And then, of course, when you get into that a little bit later on, what was also missing for me was metrics, but I'm assuming that will go in the contract because you have to have something you can measure because otherwise what I see is a lot of meetings. You can measure those.
1:54:52 We have both. You may have more of them than we ever have, you know. I mean, those are the kind of things that, you know, getting into the specifics will help prevent the problems, but it also will tell us is this successful or not. Okay. And three years contract is kind of what went up there yet. Thank you. You know, on that note real quick, if we go back to 5.0, the MLR 5.0, I remember a lot of tips in there about communicating. Yeah. And to me that's where...
1:55:26 Doing things differently, communication between these entities that are, you know, starting to work together. And I'm not saying specifically, but I just remember that there was an emphasis on that level of communities breaking up, that comment earlier about, you know, and so I think that communication element has an overarching throughout this whole thing, not specific to a scope or into a contract, as much as it is conceptually, it's about communication.
1:56:11 I think what it leads to is that there should be a deference
1:56:51 You know, MLR should always defer as far as in matters of tourism to tourism. And they should defer to professional expertise when they have it. And then if, in other words, their main function is fundraising or whatever, then the others defer to that. But out of that comes respect. If it's not, and I'm looking at, you know, years as a district ranger where
1:57:17 You know, yeah, originally we were siloed and then we went into self-managed teams where a lot of times it was the great idea, everybody, you know, it all got along but it didn't happen sometimes. And then you got into the situation where you actually looked at your roles and they were clearly understood and respected. And that's what you're asking for. You want groups that work together well and one doesn't try to take over the other because that's when the competition's going to come in.
1:57:48 Well, and I was just going to say, too, when we sat down to do this, you know, and we went through the recreation plan, and we actually, you know, went through and said, okay, you know, this is tourism, and this is, you know, town, and so, and we basically just sort of took those out to formulate this, but, you know, we could maybe do something with that. Color code again. Yeah. Well, but I think that for this level of document, that doesn't have to be able to.
1:58:15 You know, that's going to change. And I don't, oh, okay. I don't want us to. No, and I don't want to go back and duplicate a document that exists. But I did just let you know that that was, you know, something we considered as we went through. And in developing these partnerships, those types of agreements are in place. And those types of assignments, do this and you go do that. And that's the level. From the public. I don't know if this is the right time to bring this up, but I'm curious about partnership with the Forest Service.
1:58:57 I know earlier on there was concern on their part about how the two agencies would work together and there was going to be follow-up and I'm just curious if that's happening or if it has happened or if you can fill us in on that. The meeting is tomorrow. Okay. Okay. There were too many people who got to go out of town other than me so it didn't get stuck until tomorrow. We're not looking over there. Okay, so any other comments from the public on the scope of work document?
1:59:29 Okay, so the salary and benefits ends up being not as simple to try and spread out as you possibly could think. So it's a question of what we're going to use this for and how much further we want to go with it because essentially
1:59:58 It lays out retirement and health insurance and salary, which are big pieces across four different types of looking at it. There are some other differences that start to make in, whether they're not through Social Security or if there's some Social Security alternative, how much is the value of paid leave and things like that. I didn't know if we really wanted to go there.
2:00:27 I guess the kind of the question is, is this enough or does it give us something because, and there were certain things like presumably, you know, workers' compensation is likely to be the same with any of the organizations, payroll taxes, that kind of thing, because those are set by outside sources. So it's a question of, in looking at this, what are we going to do with it? What more, you know, and like some of it is still a little bit incomplete.
2:00:56 I don't have the deductible. I think the initial question, for $100,000, what do we get? What's the true cost? What does somebody get? Yeah, but is it, and I guess it's, is it a total compensation true cost where you do put in the value of all the paid leaves and things like that? Yeah. Yeah. Well, it is, even with disability, we don't have short and long term disability with MLT, we don't have life insurance, I don't know if that's something that is part of the town. Okay, so you want it flushed out?
2:01:35 Well, I mean, it's not. I think we get to the point where, obviously, I don't want to get down to nickel and diming, but if it's $10,000, it's $10,000. And I don't know that. I think we've covered the big ticket items here. And I don't know that we need to get too much into the minutia of, you know, I have no idea what short-term and long-term disability.
2:01:54 It's, you know, life insurance is a thousand bucks a year or whatever it is. I don't think those things are going to, I don't think those are going to tip the scales in any way. The only piece that we don't pay is MLT or private. Except then there's that Social Security alternative and then it gets even cute. But I don't think MLT or private can't do the alternative. Correct. I think the other place, though, that you would probably see a significant difference is in the value of paying. Yeah, and I have no idea what your stuff is.
2:02:44 It's pretty extensive. Yeah, ours is... Yours is probably... Yeah, so I don't know whether, you know, if you want me to go back and put that stuff in. Four holidays? Six days. We have six days now. The town's been... I didn't read that part of the contract when I came here. Oh, I can talk about that. Whatever, you can just talk about that. This is maybe not the best time to make this case. Or is it okay to leave it out here and just say what we didn't do?
2:03:22 Yeah. I think this shows the comparison. This is, you know, gives us that general idea of the difference. Any comments from the public on the salary and benefits comparison? Just a question. In your town of Mammoth Lakes, new to PERS, does that include at-wills or is at-will a separate category? New to PERS just means you're not. But it's a permanent employee you're talking about. Yeah, yeah, if you're eligible for retirement.
2:03:59 Would there be any value in having an at-will category? No. It would be an at-will position. It doesn't change the cost at all. A lot of at-wills don't have necessarily paid leave or anything like that. No, you can negotiate that with somebody. But retirement, we don't get to negotiate. Hers tells us what it's like. If they're eligible for retirement. So if it's a temporary part-timer, then we don't have that. An at-will. Is that the same as an at-will? I'm not familiar with that.
2:04:32 Okay. Okay. Okay.
2:05:24 Okay, yeah, I will get, yeah, we'll get, we'll get, right, yeah, okay. Just a thought, it would seem like you, what's important here is that bottom line, and if you say, okay, we're only going to spend $125,000, and however the person comes to you, that person comes to you, he'll have a lesser salary if he wants to be the prior purse.
2:06:02 You see? Yeah, or he comes to you as a new person, you know, or if he comes to you as a private business. So it's all the same cost in the end to the organization. Do you have any questions? Any questions? Thanks, you guys, for this. You'll have the Social Security and we'll just have this as a reference document. Yes. Propose MLR staff description as presented by our staff ad hoc community, Armstrong and Colin. Colin and I worked on this together.
2:06:40 There are some points in creating, and some, the main thing we wanted to talk about in the roles in the response organization, qualifications and abilities, we haven't included, as mentioned earlier, the ability to lift 35 pounds at 500 yards. Partly, it's an area that it's going out of venue that is now put in that restriction of receiving measure of funds. So there you have it.
2:09:49 We're receptive to... I actually have just a couple of qualifications on the second bullet. I think that after public administration, it should probably read non-profit management, not just non-profit. Which section? Qualifications, second bullet, on page two. Yeah. So we're talking about resort management, and I thought non-profit management, you know, because, yeah, I could have been a member of the Sierra Club, but that doesn't mean that I'm really ready to run.
2:10:25 And then under working hours, I wasn't sure what you meant by exempt position, but if the town HR person can look at it, because were you thinking Fairly the Standards Act? You were thinking FLSA? Oh, okay, FLSA exempt, okay, because it didn't say that. I inferred that, but I think you, yeah. As we often put down the working hours for X to Y, but X to hours. Correct, correct. I just wanted to make sure we were talking FLSA.
2:10:56 And then under supervisor responsibility, my only suggestion would take out the part-time in front of employees because we don't know yet. If we just say we'll have supervisor responsibility over employees, then we're not limiting ourselves to presuming that everybody else is a part-timer for the next hundred years. And I guess we're still stuck, you know, that first bullet committee structure is still pending out there. What do you want to do about it? What do we want?
2:11:39 It goes back to whether or not we decide we're accepting this scenario or looking at other alternatives. I think I think you could put something in there that they're able to manage committees. You're going to have committees within MLR, you're going to have other, I mean, instead of calling out the R, you put the Rec Commission to which you could change his name, if you will. I think managing committees of diverse groups and stuff would be a skill set you want. Okay, so I could make that a generic manage committees. Yeah, support committees. Yeah. Manage and support committees.
2:12:13 I was just getting into the specific of that first bullet point that this person would not be responsible for that. No, that would be them managing those groups and I don't see that. But to be responsible for the output of other people that aren't directly reporting to you is...
2:13:06 Well, no, it's overstepping our boundaries. It's overstepping MLR's boundaries. Well, that's kind of why I'm looking at it as being responsible for somebody else's output is, you know. That's not something we can do, but. That'd be like me being responsible for the Planning Commission's output. Sure, but there is a responsibility that goes with that communication and coordination. Correct. Among all those. So maybe that changes. Right, coordination, responsible for. So the ability to manage and support. I thought we were thinking about that. Responsible for work product. Yeah. How are we going to talk about the sign? Okay, let's take it all out.
2:13:34 Facility, management, support committees related to the field. Yeah. So we don't know what the committees are going to be. Yeah, right. We've spoken about consolidation. Yeah. So I think we would replace that with a coordination effort. Communication, coordinate, manage. Yeah. That looks good. Dan, do you want to or can you take the
2:14:03 Physical and Mental Demand Analysis and run that through a... Yeah, I would turn around and say the... But you have to have a statement in here that you have to be able to... Like, for example, I had a building inspector once that was in a... And he went out and expected jobs all the time. And they had a company... But that goes to, John, your point earlier that...
2:14:29 This document is not necessarily the advertised position, it's not necessarily the interview panel questions, and it's not necessarily the specific job description, but it's got to be combined on these other positions. If I can't walk that many yards, therefore I will apply. Well, if they can walk up to a wheelchair or other uses, then you have to provide legal accommodation for these things. So can you have Sarah suggest some language? Yeah, I guess I should take that out.
2:14:58 Should there be anything in here about grant writing? There's in there about written language ability. It's okay, I can write, I just can't write grants. I thought I saw it. Well, I thought that the second bullet under fiscal management covered that.
2:15:35 Obtains and manages contributions, sponsors, contracts, grants. Is that close enough? Developed funding? I was looking at their abilities. Developed funding, I think, is correct. That's a good point, John. And that fiscal management bullet point would become part of an interview list of questions or checkpoints. I like that you guys are here.
2:16:18 I think this question, though, is where in the timeline does a salary range get discussed? Is that by the transition board? Through the budget. Well, that's what I'm asking. So there's not a budget attached to this scope of work, but you've got to...
2:16:40 Through the Transition Board. Yeah, through the Transition Board. It's established with a salary. Correct. And then I just wanted to make sure that was everybody else's understanding because, you know, it's not like we're producing a budget for May 21st, I don't believe. We're going to have a suggested list of tests that we're going to have is, yeah, we're not, yeah. I just wanted to make sure that everybody else was thinking the same thing. The salary is one of the things that we were looking at a comparison to other. Correct.
2:17:09 Not for profits. Just a comparison to say, you know, based on an organization managing a budget this size, the executive director is, you know, $80,000 to $120,000 position range. So that we have some comparison to say.
2:17:24 Okay, so are we going to pull out some comparisons? I think that's what we need to do. In the budget subcommittee is doing that? Okay. That's awesome. No, I think it was all part of our conversation at the beginning. So let's be clear on that. We're not coming forward with the proposed budget for the 21st, but we will show a comparison of the salary for this type of a position as a part of this. We'll have that by the 12th.
2:17:54 We'll have that by May 12th. We'll have the comparison of comparable, if you will, Chief Recreation Officer.
2:18:03 We need to talk about that. We have examples of that both in the region that we can tap into as well as outside of the region too. So we have that. But that will be a part of the May 21st packet that you will include with this description.
2:18:31 Teri, you can bring up a point about the name, the title. I just think that it's cumbersome. I don't know that it really identifies what this organization. Well, since whoever has been calling themselves the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Executive Director, I think they get the recreation part. Yeah, but just think that it, yeah. Yeah.
2:18:56 It's cumbersome. Well, no, we still have our, yeah, go ahead. Well, I was just going to say, we still have our recreation manager, and it's just, it's confusing. You have your, your, it's an executive officer. Ossifer. Ossifer. Ossifer. I like that. I like executive officer. I think that was Jim's point. Yeah. Check that. What's, what's an LH?
2:19:17 Executive Director. Yeah, I was just writing it down as ED in my notes. So whether we get this finalized or not, sorry, I'm laughing at ossification. Are we going to provide this document as part of the 521 or is this just for internal working purposes, the job description?
2:19:46 What's your recommendation? Do you have one? Because personally, I have an opinion, but I'll let you guys... I think we include it. I think we include it. I think we include it. Okay. It's all that work. The question is, what do we do? What are they going to do? This lays it out. This is very clear. I think it's a part of it. I think it's a part of it. Anything we feel is finalized, I think we present. Yeah. Yeah.
2:20:13 I think, too, in the public domain, if somebody looks at that, is this a real job description or is this just fluff? No, it's real. It's real work. It's real work. It's another way of explaining what it is that is going to be going on. Yeah, the scope of work and this and the job description and the contract elements need to have a, they need to hold hands pretty close. Yes. It's all pretty much the same stuff, going from a bit of concept to detail, but it's all the same.
2:20:43 Right. Dan, will you communicate with John the feedback that you get from your HR person about the HR requirements there under the physical and mental demands? And then, John, you'll make a couple of tweaks that we recommended here. We'll have a draft ready to go when we get the feedback from Dan, and we'll bring it forward on the 12th.
2:21:07 It'll be a part of our packet that we were talking about. And kind of the same thing. Everybody has a chance to go through this. Right. Any comments from the public on the job description? Christy Osborne. I would just recommend coming from a nonprofit background and having written grants and lost a lot of them. And one,
2:21:39 a couple of them that if it is a priority for this position to write grants that you spell that out specifically in their job description and when you're interviewing them that you're asking them to demonstrate that they've won grants because having strong writing skills and winning grants are two very different things. Could it be another bullet under product development?
2:22:07 Or does it need to be grant writing on its own? I think if it's going to be a major part of the position, I think to our point, it needs to stand alone to be called out. So it's not an afterthought or an also ram. It's an important position to point. Can it be added under your fiscal management point where we're obtaining and managing in there specifically? Maybe another bullet that's just a new bullet that just specifically speaks to grant writing?
2:22:34 Proven history. Proven success. Proven history of grant writing. Successes. Because I can also write grants. I just can't. Yes. I'm sick of writing the airport when I lost it every year. It's been four months to write the thing. I know. No, there's always that. Any other public comment on the executive director position? Thank you. Thank you.
2:23:02 Okay, on to number seven, we had a report from the Contract Framework Ad-Hoc Committee. This document, it says key elements of the contract between Mammoth Lakes and Town Mammoth Lakes. That was John Armstrong and myself. John Urdi is on that committee too. Out of town, we communicated, so John will get a crack at it as we move forward. These were what we felt were elements that needed to be included.
2:23:32 So, John, are you thinking that you'd go back to the
2:24:51 Broad Measurements that were in the 5.0 report and try to make them more specific? They have to be quite a bit more as a concept of the measure. Effective measurements is long to measure. So just looking at these first eight points, 0.9 is determined contract, but the first eight points is that. Is that what MLS should be trying to do? The test to come back? We report monthly, but we do a year-end review.
2:26:29 But we do a monthly report. But then was it more frequent in the first years? No. It was actually less frequent. It was once a year, and then we've just always done monthly, so we do a pretty extensive monthly report. But that's just... I'm comfortable with quarterly in a beginning part. That doesn't mean that that can't be changed in a later part, because there's going to be so much still going on.
2:27:25 It may be different. Adjust that as needed. Well, I also think that there's the opportunity with just general public comment to be able to give updates independently of when the quarterlies are due. If there's a big win or there's a big grant that's been won or an event that's been secured or, you know, something that's the opportunity to ring the bell. I'm just wondering, because going back to our prior conversation, he talked about the fact that we're going to be as far as the state. We'll meet. Yeah. Just the director.
2:28:09 Yeah. Less about the board. It's more about the director. And I, at least for the beginning, I'd like to see it be that visible, because one of the things we're talking about is the transfer, where right now we don't hear from the committees except when they've got recommended. So am I reading this? For the term of contract. But I'm having a little trouble with the rest of that sentence, and I'm not sure. Is it meant to be on the state of the play on recreation products? Or is that supposed to be planned?
2:29:00 Yeah, both. Oh, okay. I liked State of the Play, but I want to make sure that's what you're saying. Yeah, it's trying to ramp all of the elements that are going on with committees, commissions, planning groups, different organizations, and bring it into, say, what is recreation? Okay. And one organization, one person can say, this is everything. I was prompted by the editorial of the paper.
2:29:43 And not to take anything out of lending a hand to pull on that road. Yes. So that it's, the pieces are wrapped together so that a new guest, everything, and it's very close to that already. I think the one thing that's missing here, the major thing that's missing here is the funding source. And I know it's not defined, but I think we need to have it here as a placeholder because that needs to be, I mean, that's part of our contract is that we're 2.5 points of TOT.
2:30:36 You're talking about that stable baseline or whatever? Well, just whatever it is. As far as the contract? Baseline funding is a right. That's the process. That's 1A. We're getting a return. What tools do we have with which to do this?
2:31:22 On number eight, I like the setting, the schedule, but I would actually like to see it go beyond that and actually have a round of, I don't know, you know, if we're going back to our neat little diagram, because essentially what you're talking about is getting to a projects list, if I understand number eight. Is that what you're saying in number eight, is getting to a projects list? Yes, this is to set whatever schedule needs to be put in place where there is,
2:31:56 The development of that list moves forward. So the setting of the schedule is by the executive director or not? They've got to reach out to the town staff. With town. Okay, but I guess to me that sounds like do we not? You've got to reach out and talk to the town staff. No, I understand. Yeah, I'm just thinking doesn't it go beyond setting a schedule to actually create the list? Yeah, that's what I'm saying. It's not just saying. Or establishing. Yeah, okay.
2:32:24 So, and establish the list. Yeah, well, what we want to say is that a deliverable is the first list. Is the list. Okay. Yeah. Schedule, so maybe you put with the appropriate, you know, or whatever, everyone is supposed to. And establish. As opposed to naming a specific entity. Right. Somebody else other than just the. Yeah. Yeah. Establish list. Yeah. Okay. Yeah. And it says, Sue, whatever that defines.
2:33:08 Right. Whatever that is. That's fine. Who thoughts? Well, and I think it is really important in November 4 is to talk about the websites and stuff. I think it's important. Well, there's that, but there's, yeah, management websites. Then I'm just looking at MLTS as a whole, MLTS Trail System, as a separate. What do we expect to get done on MLTS in a... Yeah.
2:33:46 That's kind of over there. So I think that question, yeah. Can we pull that out separately? I think so. Because the websites is one thing. Yeah. But actually what we're going to do with, you know, because this would then cover the last two, you know, is the understanding if we're recommending a three-year one, that covers the last two years of the first five-year commitment to MLTS.
2:34:17 I think we're talking about mammothtrails.org, not MLTS. And I think that should be crossed out and said mammothtrails.org. But then separately, I think we need to have a number about what we anticipate doing with MLTS. And they have their continuing. So there's two pieces there. Because there's information. Bullet point number four is specific to information. But then there's a separate point about MLTS.
2:34:46 Yeah. Right. Yeah, it was a such as. Yeah. And that's supposed to be, that's Mammoth Trail. Yeah, but I think we specifically need to speak to, because there is that still, those two years. MLTS. MLTS, well, MLTS and the CC, yeah. Do we need in here to make annual recommendations to your rec commission for funding? I think number eight.
2:35:33 I think number eight is good enough for now because some of that is also going to get worked out in contract initiation. Yeah, whatever that define, you know what? Let's define it and then we can put it in there. Let's get through the exercise of defining it and then we can do what John said and actually plug it in. Any other thoughts? We're missing anything.
2:36:16 John, we're going to bring it back again on the 12th, and John will have had another chance to look at it also because he's fresh off of the MLT contract, and lessons learned from that one as well. If there's a contract MLH that you'd want us to consider also if there's anything that's relevant to what's included in that that makes sense to think about including LR to you for that, if it's relevant.
2:36:56 And also on the 12th. Yes. Well, yeah, because everybody's coming back with recommendations. We're going to have a whole list of options for that one. Bring your sleeping bags. I'm challenging you all. And that's the one meeting I'm missing? Well, no, there's three of us. There's three people missing it, because John is missing it, or John is going to be there for the first hour on the 12th. And then Colin is missing it also. So we've got three missing, that and May 12th one.
2:37:25 But I think we're doing our work up front, and the documents will reflect that work, and we'll just be able to make some decisions. Any other comments on the contract elements? Okay. For any information you might have, John, we'll get together. Thanks. I'm being mindful of the time. Is that you? Yes, it's me. I thought it was going to go away sooner. Yeah, Sandy Hogan. I think number seven is probably the major...
2:38:01 Thank you very much. Thank you.
2:38:31 You know, these are fine as long as these are the kind of projects that I voted for as a voter for Measure R and Measure U. So if you're talking about funding this organization with Measure R and Measure U to produce some of this stuff, you're going to hear from people like me saying, I didn't vote for that. I voted for the facilities, the things that we can do right now and that we know we can do and that our committees have actually been working towards.
2:39:00 I can tell you number five, deliver concise briefings to the town of Mammoth Lakes County on a quarterly basis, and we would be paying Measure U and Measure R for these concise briefings. We did that once before with a contract, a two-year contract with MLTPA, and I believe those briefings cost us over $2,000 per briefing. I think it was over $20,000, but I could be wrong. It could be $19,000 or $18,000. Those are the kind of things I don't want to see my voter
2:39:30 Approved Measure R, Measure U going for. I think you need some really specific stuff here. This is still very, very fuzzy. And if the metrics are going to be the numbers of meetings, you know, and the quality of the research paper, is it a 10-pager, a 15-pager, a 30-pager, you know, I mean, these are the kind of things that are going to be the heart of it. But if this is an organization that brings in its own money and does this,
2:39:59 I'm fine with it. Because then they can leverage. They can do number seven, which is what we're saying this should be. Your metrics, you know, I guess, and the baseline funding. And, you know, Rick, when Rick said, oh, yeah, let's just give them all the Measure R and the Measure U to start this off, and we're going to do a three-year contract? Scary. I will have much more prepared comments. You know, but please just accept my comments. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
2:40:32 Because there will be more on that, and that's all I'm asking, because I think these will be serious ones. I know, let's not debate it. They're noted, and we're in draft mode, we're forming, so thank you, thanks for sharing your thoughts. Part of it is, I'm sure you understand, I came from an organization where the targets I was delivered, you know, in other words, the ones I had to meet.
2:40:54 We're acres of this and numbers of that and what, you know, I mean, numbers of fires put out and all that kind of stuff. So I come from an organization that came that really looked at hard deliverables. And that's kind of where you have to understand where I'm coming from when I make these comments because there are other people like me that want, you know, they want something. You know what, Sandy, I would just comment too that I don't think there's a person around this room who hasn't been involved in anything that hasn't had solid metrics.
2:41:21 So I think we can all take our experiences from where we've had to deliver very specific goals and objectives and measurable metrics that go into it and use that experience in helping to draft this and fine tune this. So I think I appreciate your comment. I think we've got a lot of experience around the table also delivering metrics and bringing those forward as well. We've all had to function into that type of an organization. So there's a lot of experience that goes into that as well. And I'm sure there is. I'm just saying it's not expressed here.
2:41:47 Okay. And I'm saying that's going to be one of the challenges. Okay. Thanks. Teri? I know, you know, we're not going to debate this, but in those Measure R and U right now and projects that happen, there are reports that come. It's a requirement, isn't it? Actually, in Measure R and Measure U that they have to report back what they've done with that funding, so that's built into it as well. It's built into the agreement that they have. They're accountable for coming back with it. Yeah, so it's in there. Question.
2:42:17 Since we had the two different subcommittees working, we had the scope of work working and the contract, do we also want to give ourselves a day or two to get comments back to see if there's things when you try to put the two up together, if there's something missing, forgotten, or whatever? Yeah, when we compare them. I think John and myself as ad hoc committee, we're going to get together before the 12th.
2:42:46 No, I meant the same thing of getting comments in by the 30th. So if you have comments on this one, send them to John. John A. He's the keeper of the document. So any comments and then we'll collectively pull those together. Any other public comments on the element contract from the committee? If we have any, we'll send them over to John. And I'm being your clock watcher just reminding you that people have...
2:43:15 All right. So that's the framework. Item number eight. So there's your R&U reconciliation report, and we're not going to spend a lot of time discussing this. It was distributed at the Tink joint meeting, and you also received an electronic copy from Dan following that meeting. I think that there are some, at least from our perspective, your legal ad group took a look at them. There are several. We had a recommendation,
2:43:52 The request that was sent to the town manager that we were requesting that we have Joe and Terry have the ability to go into the town office, work with the finance person to go through and try and make some sense. There's, from the legal ad hoc perspective, there are several things missing out of it. And the request that we have for Joe and Terry to go in, and for instance, Whitmore Species Study.
2:44:24 $715 overage on that. Well, where's the backup for all of it? How do we get to a point where we go through and pull the backup on that? We believe that all of that exists because that's how this report was generated. So we believe it should be fairly simple. But the exercise that is being looked at is let's get that backup into it. It's all sitting there, yeah. So it's all sitting there. So Joe, Terry, if you guys want to comment on that. And if the committee has any questions about it.
2:44:58 And we haven't set a date for that meeting, but there were several things in here, like there's a total approved project list amount, which looks like it's a total rather than a line, but it's added in. There's a number of things like that when you look at it from, what do they call them, forensic accountant's perspective. There's a lot of questions. There's a lot of things that...
2:45:29 were different than items that the Recreation Commission has been given previously, so it was like, step back, outside of the MLR process, Teri and I will meet with staff and figure it out and try to get it, because at this point, we still do not have a reconciliation. To go to the bottom line, we couldn't even get the bottom line to make sense. Teri, you were the best one on this for me.
2:46:00 When we were trying to, the point of the exercise was to determine obviously expenditures and then also what's been encumbered and basically what's unencumbered in R&U as this moves forward. Teri, you were able to point, you were able to say we took the 949, there was allocation, I think in the end we figured there was maybe 300,000 that's unencumbered or?
2:46:26 Help me. Help. Let's just say this. We couldn't get to it. There wasn't. No. That was the problem. So in my mind, this is exactly the award of Measure R and Measure U until the reconciliation actually occurred. When I saw this, I had no question as to why there had been a suspension, and I hope that that answered questions of others as well, because there still isn't a known dollar amount for what is not unencumbered as this moves forward.
2:47:06 Dan, I know you probably are able to interpret it for us, but I think that there's backup and more information that goes into this recognition. No, no, but that's why we were saying we were going to volunteer to go in and actually look at it and be able to come back because it's not even separated by a word cycle thrown together. Yeah, there is a different filing of it. No, but since somebody's been working on it for a year, it's still not done.
2:48:18 But you just changed your date range. It is over years, yeah. So from this body, so I guess the report to this body is that we will not know by May 21st, because I just can't, there's still so much, we will not know how much of the future year stuff is uncovered. So what is the catch-all approved project list?
2:48:44 That's what I meant, is you can't tell. That's the breakout you were asking about. Yeah, there's things like that all through it where if you can see the detail and sort it in different ways, you know, sort it by award and things like that, we'll be able to figure it out. Yeah, because, yeah, there's amounts in here and there's negatives, and so the question is, well, why do we even have negatives? Why did somebody get to overcharge? Some of those are a measure you'd transfer. Other ones are, wait a minute, how did we overspend?
2:49:13 It didn't make sense. And who authorized the overages? And this is where the reporting comes back. Is that reporting should have been taken care of? I'm sure it's in there somewhere, hopefully, but this is to me exactly why there was a suspension requested by the council. Any questions from the public on this, on what we're doing with this reconciliation report? All right. Thank you.
2:49:42 We've had ad hoc committee reports from all the committees. Betsy, I've been giving you an opportunity if there's anything you want to add from the community outreach group. I don't think so, not from me, because I've been away. One question I did want to ask is, do we want to have something beyond the chairlift speech? Do we want to have a one-pager FAQ document? Do we think that's worthy now that we have scope of work, now that we're closer on a lot of these items?
2:50:13 You know, my thought is that when we meet the next time when we're really talking about what we're putting into the agenda packet, if we're putting the detail of something into an agenda packet, like a job description, I don't think it helps us to have an FAQ that says, yes, we developed a job description. So I don't know if maybe we table that until the next meeting and figure out, is there anything else that goes on a cheat sheet, a two-page cheat sheet or something like that?
2:50:43 Or an executive summary or that kind of stuff because I don't want to suggest anybody do extra work. Well, I think all of us are comfortable talking about the work that we've been doing over the past nine months. I think there's an opportunity through an executive summary, though, to maybe call out some of the questions that we anticipate or we can point somebody here in the document where we've addressed it or we can start to identify we know that these are the issues that were asked.
2:51:13 the first time around. So I think that would be part of the executive summary. Yeah, yeah. With the question, here's the answer. Yeah. So that was Teri and Betsy who did the review of the 219 comments. Who did the 219? Yeah. Teri's going, no. You and I did. Oh, it was usual. Okay. We did not. So maybe that kind of becomes an FAQ.
2:51:43 I do have one outreach to report on this. I went to the Alliance meeting last week, and Juliana asked most of the questions. So the same things that were in her list from 219 were there about funding for special events.
2:52:03 Put some culture on the board probably. Yeah, you know, the same things that, because I went back and looked at your questions after that. It was really funny because most of the other members wanted to ask other questions where I just kept turning to Peter. So he'd be asking me about, you know, the street signal over here. And I'd go, uh, Peter? Because he's part of that group. I was like, why aren't you guys asking this all the time? You wait until I get here to ask me why the signal doesn't work. Or why, no, actually, okay, we're still alive, but I'm sorry. But someone's father telling us about.
2:52:32 He doesn't like how long the signal is at one point, and so he just decides it's his signal and drives ahead if he doesn't see anybody coming. Uh-huh. Yes, it was the meridian and minaret light. He doesn't like the cycling. I know. I'm there at Canyon. Canyon and Lake Mary is the same way. Yeah, and as mentioned earlier, we're meeting tomorrow.
2:52:59 With tomorrow afternoon with the Forest Service, we're probably going over there on that one. Okay. Any other community outreach? Is there any way to report out prior to the report? Like, read the sentence? Do you have an email? Through staff? No. That's a Brown Act problem if we report to everybody. You get it on the 12th. So on the 12th, then it would be adopted. Can you send an email to the community, to the body as a whole, without any response from anybody?
2:53:28 Well, I mean, you're putting out communication that way, I give it, and then you can make a bail to the public, but it actually happens, so it's hard to, and then you say later, well, I got it, I like this, and if you give it, it just touches. Now, if Joe just gives that information to Colin. No, I can't. Well, yeah, we could have one more person, because Rick and I will be there. But there's nothing wrong with, well, wait a minute, Rick, there's nothing wrong with us reporting out on it in the May 7th council meeting, right? Sure.
2:53:58 Then it's public. So May 7th, well, you'll be gone. I'll be here. So I can see you on the 7th, you can call in. Yeah, we can hear it. All right. That's fine. Yeah. Okay. Any other community outreach, places where you've been, discussions, opportunities? Okay. All right. Anything else? Oh, I was just wondering if you guys wanted to share anything for anybody who wasn't at the April 16th.
2:54:28 One thing that really resonated with me was the members of the
2:55:05 You know, Commission and the Committee saying that, you know, they kind of felt like with MLR that, oh, well, you know, no one said, well, you know, you're doing a bad job. And so I think we need to think of this not so much as that, you know, we're changing, you know, we're trying to become more strategic, not because anyone's done anything bad with this money or that, you know, people haven't adhered to the processes that were in place, but just because it's time to kind of
2:55:30 You know, adopt the more strategic, you know, implementation approach now that we realize that, you know, in 10 years, what will we have spent our $18 million on? And so I just, I just wanted to, just to make my comment because I think that the other, you know, the other people did, you know, kind of feel like, you know, they have given a lot of time and, you know, and no one has done a bad job. It's just that we're, we're just sort of refining our approach. Yeah.
2:56:09 Defend it, naturally. Reinvested in it. And given that it was not known then what it's going to look like, it's maybe known a little more what it's going to look like and how it's going to feel, there was some real very natural defensiveness. So I expected that and we got it.
2:56:42 It was informative for me, it was educational, but it also really illustrated to me why it is that a moral shake-up is a good thing. I'm quite impressed with the way it's occurred in the last couple of weeks. You know, for three hours just thinking about the struggling amount of work, because it's a tale, a thought, it's a thoughtless or a rushed approach, you know, I'm very impressed.
2:57:21 I think we got what I expected out of that meeting, and I took the comments seriously, and unfortunately we're not going to satisfy everybody who occupies a position now that even may not exist later or may look over the event. Teri, do you want to add anything you were able to take? Yeah. No, that was my comment that I was going to bring up. It was just the, you know.
2:57:52 The understanding of, no, it doesn't mean that that was a wasted effort. I don't know how many times we thank them for that. We've got to this point. It's just a different process. Okay, it's a transition. Okay, request for future agenda items. On May 12th meeting, we're coming back with a few homework assignments. But if there's anything that you think is missing that you want to add to that,
2:58:22 Let's make sure we can add it. You don't have to say today, but if there's something that you want to, we can make it an item. But everything we reviewed today, we're coming back with to finalize and to make a recommendation to the town council. And then we'll spend a little bit of time on the 12th, not too much, but a little bit of time.
2:58:43 We will have to spend some time on the 12th thinking about that agenda bill, what elements are going into the agenda bill, and what communication we're having with the board.
2:58:54 Excuse me, with the council as it relates to what is being presented on the 21st. We will have an opportunity on our meeting on the 19th to review the agenda bill, to review the packet, probably do the same thing that was done for the presentation back in February where people had different assignments and we might kind of structure it a little bit on the 19th, but the 12th is where we're going to spend some time. These are the documents that are moving forward and this is the information that the council is going to get.
2:59:23 The 12th is a Monday. The packet has to come out on that Friday, which would be the 16th. So I was just thinking for those not there at the meeting, what would be able to see if we can route anything for any? And in the past, we'd had a smaller committee that had actually reviewed the agenda bill and things like that.
2:59:56 And I don't know. Now, John, you're out of town the rest of that week? Until Wednesday night. So I'm here on Thursday. I wonder if the three of us as the temporary officers, whatever the heck our titles are, could plan to meet that Thursday morning just to make sure that everything is in the packet as we expect it to be, what it all looks like when it's together? You can do that. As chair, vice chair, secretary?
3:00:25 So there'd be some time on the, yeah. I can let Jamie know if he has her. Correct. So that's what I'm thinking. If we met first, you know, early Thursday morning, finally say, you know, because sometimes when you think you've got something and then you look at it, you go, oh, wait a minute. This should be, and part of that is our discussion of, you know, how we want to make this work. Right. So Jamie puts it out at 3 o'clock on. Well, I say get to her by Thursday. She has to make copies. Yeah, right. Okay. So if we get it to her by 3 o'clock on Thursday, that's plenty of time for her.
3:00:58 Or can you let her know? Okay, so by 3 o'clock on Thursday, she'll have the ML, anything else to go into the MLR? Correct. So, Dan, since you're going to be done, who's going to be writing the agenda bill? What does that mean, he's done? He's gone. Oh, gone. I thought you said he's done. No. No. Okay.
3:01:40 Yeah, we're going to have these. Yeah, there'll be a lot of attachments, which hopefully then means it's a kind of a short agenda bill. The agenda bill won't, the staff report itself won't be that big. Right. But it has to have the recommendations in it. Mm-hmm. And so that's part of our conversation on the 12th is to make sure. We have everything in the recommendations. You know, we've got, you know, we've got, like I said, we're going to discuss. Right. Okay. All right. So we know what we're doing on the 12th.
3:02:21 This is 12th at 3. 12th is at 3. And then the 21st is a council meeting that begins at 6. Right. And we don't know where we are. Not the general, not the regular budget. Yeah, that's a, that's a work. So, what's, what's the ability, what's the opportunity to get MLR discussion early on that meeting? That's up to your mayor who sets the agenda. Yeah, just put it on a consent agenda. And then gets somebody to pull it. Wouldn't that be? We will have that.
3:03:06 Yes, the mayor gets to set the agenda. It would be great to move it up a little, just because it might go a little. Okay, good. Any other comments? We all have our takeaways, homework to do, and we have responses to give back to each other by the 30th, close of business. Okay, we're done. We're close. Dan, I may have to miss the notification.
3:03:36 We're setting up a meeting with the last Caroline, so I can get back.