Trails Committee
· recording 1 hr 44 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
220 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Here's Bill. Here he is. She did? Okay. Civil engineer? He's just there camped out for a couple weeks in there. Spend a few more weeks, but they're just traveling.
0:39 Okay, since we're all here, let's call to order this regular agenda, this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Roll call, please. Sandy Hogan. Here. Bill Souser. Here. Peter Bernasconi. Here. Vice Chair Bill Taylor. Here. And Chairman Sean Turner.
1:11 And I am present. Are there any public comments from the audience? Do we want to remind microphones, everybody? Thank you. Now it's time for public comments. If it doesn't otherwise appear on this agenda. Anyone from the audience? Okay, fair enough. Before we get started, I just want to say real quick is I'm aware that this may be
1:35 The last meeting of MLTSCC. I want to be clear that Town Council has not formally disbanded this body, so we are going to go forward today. I understand that emotions may be a little high here and there, certainly with myself. I've got a few feelings going on as well. The most important thing that we can do is make sure that this body, if it is the last meeting, does have a smooth transition.
2:01 And can certainly support the next entity to the best of our ability. So having said that, let's go into our meeting. Do we have a presentation? Before starting, though, could I add just one statement? Maybe it's more appropriate toward the end, but I just want to say, even if it isn't our last meeting, I know it's going to be our last meeting with Steve. And I have to just say,
2:29 What a privilege and an honor it has been to work with him. We have been so fortunate because Steve developed, was one of the prime developers of the Park and Rex plan, of the Trails Master Plan. He worked for the government but has worked in the private sector, knows how to develop contracts, monitor contracts, close them out. I mean, I don't know how we could have had anybody better.
2:56 And so if an LR can get somebody even half as good, well, that's a step forward. But it'll never be the same as Steve. And I just want to say how great it's been to work with you. Hear, hear. Thank you. I was going to say that for the end, but it's fine as well. As we go through. Yes, we can each one say it, I'm sure. I'll say it again at the end. His hat won't fit now already. Exactly. Exactly. That's true. We'll have to get him a new hat. Okay. That was a presentation. Okay, now.
3:27 Good afternoon. I don't know if I need a mic on or how this works. Is it on? It's on. Just speak into it. Oh, I see. I'm Courtney Weike. I'm a planner at Mono County. I actually came to this group about maybe two or three months ago. There was some interest in just...
3:57 Coordinating our efforts in the trail planning process that I think maybe Stephen heard some of the stuff that was going on with Long Valley and June Lake specifically and tying in kind of maybe some interregional trails. So I came to you guys a couple of months ago. Not a whole lot has changed. This group's probably pretty familiar with...
4:21 The trails take a long time to build, so a lot hasn't changed in the last couple of months, but I could just give you kind of an update on where things are with the county. Our big thing that's happening in the next couple of weeks is our June Lake Trails Day. I believe this is our fifth annual Trails Day. I think it was, our first one was in 2009, which was our really exciting one where we actually built a trail, which was the trail that went around Goal Lake.
4:50 It took quite a few years to do, and so that's kind of our baby. So since then, we've just decided to continue, even though we haven't actually constructed trails since then, just to continue this Trails Day effort where we go to various trails working with Friends of the Inyo and the Forest Service and identifying projects and trails that need cleanup, walking the trails to...
5:16 Cut brush, move rocks, and then trash. We had like 40 pounds of trash last year that we got. So that is June 21st at 8.30. June Mountain as well as Mammoth Mountain are both donating season pass. We tend to have...
5:36 So many prizes at the end, we have a kind of a raffle, that there's so many of them that everybody walks away with a prize, and that kind of incentivizes you a little bit if you have an interest in going. At the end, around 12.30, we do the raffle, and then Double Eagle is catering the event with kind of hamburgers, hot dogs, barbecue style. Our biggest goal with the June Lake Trail Committee, which June Lake Trails is kind of our
6:03 Model Trail Committee for the county. We're getting a lot of interest from other communities, Long Valley, Bridgeport, a little bit actually up in the North County, Antelope Valley, and they're looking at June Lake Trails as their model committee. And one of our larger projects right now that we've been trying to work on for quite a few years, we're finding it's got some environmental concerns and possibly some issues with
6:33 The trail getting close to property owners and whatnot is we want to have a trail system within June that's connected. And starting with the Goal Lake Trail, we want people to be able to get from the village to Goal Lake and then to be able to go down all the way to Double Eagle and then eventually on to Silver Lake and then possibly beyond. But our big segment, priority segment, is the Down Canyon Trail.
7:01 At this point, it's kind of on hold. We have to do a lot more outreach. Talk to the property owners. What are the issues? Establish maybe some potential alternatives, and then we'll start moving forward with that. We were really hoping we might, I think our goal or what we were hoping for was this year to actually be breaking ground and actually be digging the trail, but I think we're a good year away from that.
7:30 I also reported last time on what was once considered the Mono-Yosemite Gateway Trail, and that was in Lee Vining, and the original effort or objective was to try and get a trail that connected Lee Vining all the way up to the Indian Station.
7:46 It's kind of morphed into more of a mono basin trail plan at this point, kind of levining. There was a lot of concerns specifically with the Native American community with the alignment going all the way up to the entrance station because there's some important areas along the creek that they just weren't very comfortable with.
8:12 Putting it on a map. It's one thing. It is there. It's kind of already an established trail, but putting it on a map somehow, you know, that kind of evokes a little bit more, obviously, publicity, and so we still have to work on that portion. But we do have it going up at least a little bit past the for-service station.
8:31 Going up 120. And then there's a few trails within Lee Vining, connecting the Visitor's Center, the Community Center, the Community Center to school, and then also the proposed trail to the Mobile Mart so that people have a safe way to stay in Lee Vining and then walk to the Mobile Mart, decreasing all that additional parking so people don't get in their car and drive from the motel to go there on Sunday for the...
8:59 The show. So that's kind of in the works. We've got our draft kind of trail plan at this point and are planning to take it to the Mono Basin RPAC and then also doing additional outreach to all the different agencies. So that'll be kind of coming together, I would think, in the next couple of months. Long Valley is, they're more focused on the regional trails. I think I talked to you about that last time.
9:28 We did a lot of outreach and surveys. We're going through a general plan update at the county. And so they updated their area plan and looked at trails. There was a lot of, originally we were wanting to have trails within the community. I think that was still kind of one of those things where let's take the low-hanging fruit at this point where there was some controversy. Again, that whole fear of having people walking near your home. And so they were a lot more comfortable with the concept of
9:58 A trail around Crawley Lake, and then connecting potentially some sort of bike trail or just trail from Long Valley up to maybe even the geothermal plant, which potentially, you know, there's been talk of, you know, an interpretive center there, and then connecting into Mammoth. So that would be our, you know, maybe our regional trail that you guys would have an interest in. And then Bridgeport's also working on some trails that they're kind of go up, they're
10:26 Doing it kind of outside of really planning at this point. They're kind of their own committee, it sounds like, from the planner that I talked to in that committee. She just doesn't have the staff time, and she said, go for it. So they're just looking at establishing what is existing.
10:43 Biking Trails, ATV Trails, Road Trails. And so I think once they get their package together, then they'll come to us and then we'll start looking at actually memorializing it and having a plan for Bridgeport. Antelope Valley's kind of similar. They're looking at, they've got a big ATV draw there as well. Similar situation where they're not a formalized committee, but they are starting to have some interest. And then lastly, we have
11:11 We've actually been working with Haislip at the town here on a, we received a grant to hire a consultant to what is titled a Main Street Character Inventory and Design Guidelines to eventually kind of have this idea book.
11:29 It was originally supposed to be a component in order for us to try and qualify for that scenic byway designation. The funding for that dropped, but we still have the grant program for this document, which was just a component of us kind of working towards that designation. But it's still great and an exciting project. We just hired them. It's Opticos is the firm.
11:55 They're the same ones who did the Bridgeport Main Street Revitalization Project. They're not looking at probably doing anything as dramatic as what happened in Bridgeport with decreasing the lanes or anything, but more signs, wayfinding, facade improvements. So there's already been some that have happened in Bridgeport. The bakery has kind of seen that.
12:24 Idea that they had and went, I like that, I'm just going to go with that and then hired someone to construct it and pretty much exactly what they had proposed work. So that's what the firm is looking at doing, primarily focusing in June Lake and then also North County, Antelope Valley, Walker, Colville area. But there are some components to 203 because it is on the 395 as well as 158.
12:54 The thought is to try and have this consistent corridor in telling the story and although at the same time having recognized that each community is very different from each other. So gateway signage is part of it. June Lake's really interested in getting kind of
13:15 Maybe not quite as large as Mammoth's, but a sign that is on the highway that is a little bit more prominent than what exists right now, and actually they're moving forward with that. And the point of me telling you that, I guess, is just that some of the wayfinding components that we're asking them to do is identifying trails. So, you know, having consistent signs that say Rock Creek is this way or Convict Lake or...
13:45 The airport, or those sort of things. So Haislips, who's working with us on some of the town-related areas or the areas that they're going to be looking at, and then hopefully we'll have a pretty neat product at the end that you get on 395 and you know you're still missing a corridor. I think that's pretty much it for Trails End of the County.
14:13 Yeah, I just had a question about your item number seven there, the main street one. Now, is that pretty much designed to be outside the town limits? You know, we have a huge wayfinding project. Yeah. I didn't know quite how that integrated with it. No, yeah. That's why Mammoth's kind of piece up just a little bit in there. Okay, okay. You saw the opportunity that there could be some potential. I think it's still not totally sure what.
14:39 And how involved they'll be. Okay. What sort of impact. Because definitely you guys have that program for the main street. So they'll be focused probably primarily in June Lake, Walker, Colville, because Bridgeport's been done and Lee Bining's had a ton of work as well. So, yeah. Just a little follow-up. For each of the communities, there may be projects related to tourism stops, maybe some restroom facilities.
15:07 Those kinds of things. And so having the town within that group, we'll have some projects, maybe some enhancements at the Welcome Center, the charging stations that have been discussed over the years, those kinds of things. Oh, good. Okay. I was wondering how integrated. Yeah, absolutely. And I think I'm kind of taking this project on from another planner that has moved on. So I don't have all the history, but I know a component of it was that they went out and GIS mapped all of the
15:34 Picnic tables and restrooms. So I think there's this idea that eventually it might be an app that, okay, run on the 395 corridor and then you'll know where to go. And Mammoth was definitely included in that. Okay, here's a park facility. Maybe they weren't planning on going to Mammoth. They see that there's a park in Mammoth and they turn off and come to the community park. So I think that's kind of the bigger, broader picture. This is just a component of it. Great.
16:01 Any other questions? No more? No, that's good. I was just very quick. I was curious who you were using as a consultant on the design work. Who we were using as a consultant? Opticos. Opticos. Yeah, I think they're based out of Berkeley. Okay. Any questions? Okay. Courtney, thank you very much. Thank you. Yeah. I'll try to tie that in at this time, but thank you for the presentation. Yeah. Okay, consent agenda.
16:35 This includes the minutes in the staff report. Is there anything that would likely be pulled from the consent agenda? I have one question on the minutes. Okay. Let's go ahead and pull that for discussion. Anything else? Want to take that up? Yeah. I just was looking at the minutes where we were talking about the order of priority. And for this is on, let's see, page three of the minutes down at the bottom of the listing of trails.
17:06 And did we vote on the order of priority? I remember Bill bringing it up, but I don't remember any discussion of it or a vote on the order of priority. No, when I went through Veronica's bill, I looked for that to see if that was, and really it was more or less of a consensus, because Bill made the listing, and then Peter, I think, was asked, and he concurred, but I did not see where it was an actual
17:36 Motion to put them in that order, and that's part of today's agenda, of course, is to actually do that. The reason I said it is because I don't recall that I actually agreed or disagreed. No, I don't think your name's in here. It says Vice Chair Bill Taylor agreed also. Oh, no, it says voted no. I can change that if you'd like to.
17:59 Well, I'm looking at page two. It wasn't a priority listing, I think is what you're saying, right? It was just a listing. Well, but the bill did suggest an order of priority. And I don't mind that the minutes reflect that. I don't think we ever voted on it. I don't recall. We actually had any discussion. And the minutes imply that those priorities were, in fact, approved either by consensus. And I don't think we quite got there.
18:28 So, maybe if you just agreed, just deleted the agreed also, and so I just said that I suggested another public meeting to gain input, I think that would be fine. But, or just delete that whole reference and just end with the sentence beginning with Member Peter Berners-Gummy. I'm okay with that change. Any other comment on that? Well, that was just a, was it? Yeah, just. Just a clarification. It wasn't really, yeah. I mean, there was a motion. I'll strike the agreed also. Yeah.
19:01 There was a motion to move them forward, but it wasn't for prioritization. It was just to move them forward, and we did vote on it, and we moved them forward. But that's why I'm saying removing the priority may be the right word, because they really weren't in priority order. And this item actually continues on page four, correct? Exactly. Actually, you're bringing up a, well, let's settle this item first.
19:32 Okay. The other thing that I think I would like to point out in the minutes of last time, especially in light of the news that you shared with me, Steve, that we're going to get to in the next business matter, the part there about Chairman Sean Turner requested a summary letter from the U.S. Forest Service uplining their position. I think, well, I know what I was requesting was that we were due a summary letter in response to the sharp document that was submitted to them in writing and that they are supposed to be replying in writing in kind.
20:01 And I think that in the minutes, and I'm pretty sure that I was clear at that time that the reason why I was asking for a response in writing is because we had presented the sharp document in writing and that they are to reply in like kind. So I don't think it's inappropriate for the minutes to reflect that the summary letter from the U.S. Forest Service outlining their position in response to the sharp documents, I think that's appropriate.
20:29 Where's that? And that's actually in the minutes, isn't it? Well, this is at the top of line four, but I just want to make it clear that they were, we were expecting a response because we had proposed a writing, because we had submitted the sharp document to them in writing and that they were required to reply in like kind. So it's not that I was requesting a summary letter outlining their position, but just that we had not yet received anything in writing. So I just want the minutes to be clear.
20:59 So how would you like that to read? Yeah, I think what I would like it to read is requested a summary letter from the U.S. Forest Service outlining their position in response to the sharp document that was submitted to them, whatever the date was. Did we submit the letter? Does that make sense? Yeah. And I'm not sure what the date was, Steve. Yeah, we submitted a formal package to them a year ago.
21:27 Oh, that one. Oh, a long time ago. That's what I'm saying. That's what I was asking for the summary letter to be. That's what I was asking for the written summary to be a response to. We do read for a written letter that would show the trails that they didn't want to build in Ryan. That's correct, because John Kazmiercki very graciously did do a verbal presentation, but because our package was in writing,
21:53 We are expected to receive something in writing, and I would like the minutes to reflect that. So, Steve, if you could add this line, I guess, and I'll take any comments from this committee. It helps me word this. Request a summary letter from the U.S. Forest Service outlining their position in like-kind response. Is that part of the minutes, though? Well, that's what I'm saying, is I'm asking that it be amended in the minutes. Was...
22:21 I guess I would say if... It seems like that's a... Maybe we just have Steve review the... ...Granicus, and then he can make the changes if necessary and appropriate. Because we can't change the... Right, that's fine. These are our visits, and I think that your thought was captured. I just wanted to be clear is that... I'll check wording. We're asking for this letter not because I'm requesting it, but because we should expect that because we submitted...
22:50 Package in writing. I'll check the wording and make a revision as required. Well, I know. We are going to talk about that here in the next business matter. But with regard to the minutes, I really do feel they should reflect that. If they're in there. If they're in there. Thank you very much. If they're in there, yeah. Okay. Okay, we'll do. All right, thank you. You're welcome. So having the minutes from April 7th put back on the consent agenda,
23:22 At least with the corrections that you're going to confirm should be in there. I think, Mr. Chair, you need to bring that back at the next after he looks at Granicus and makes the case. Is that the way that it's done? Of course, there won't be a next. But ideally, that would be it. We've not received that from Town Council yet, but at the same time...
23:42 We do need to submit. We think we're going to. So then, you know, I'm going to take direction here. What's the best way to do with these minutes, then, since we can't add in the comments that I just made? Let me add this, that I think that I can go back easily enough and check Granicus for the proper wording. And I will make that revision. And then I have both hard copy and electronic copies of minutes.
24:06 From all our meetings in my files, and I'll just make those available, so the record will show. Thank you. Okay, I'll move that, let's see, as amended by bill, would that be the, as amended, okay, as amended, and then, I was just thinking in terms of your comment, deleting the agreed also. I'll check that one again. Okay, and also, and as you check it, yeah, as you check that one,
24:40 To me, the priority, I think we agreed that they weren't in a priority order, so maybe just check that one. So, I'll move that we amend the minutes as amended. As amended. I'll second. Okay. Okay, any motion and a second? Any further discussion? Those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Okay.
25:11 Steve would check to lead us into business item number four. I think that the motion was just for the minutes of the consent agenda. There are two other items on consent agenda, which are the staff recaps. I'm sorry, I assume that was included. You're right. Yeah, I assumed that as well. Essentially what was happening was that the consent, that the minutes were being re-added to the consent agenda.
25:35 Motion that I just heard was for the consent agenda. Oh, I'm sorry. That includes the amended minutes. So I think we just passed the entire consent agenda. Thank you for the clarification. That was my intent. Okay. Okay. Okay, the next item on the agenda is business item number four, discuss and take action regarding projects on the current MLTSCC master project.
26:08 And Budget Tracking List. And the first project we'll be taking on is A, which is SHARP, and that discussion has to do with next steps, proposed action discussions, and giving direction to the U.S. Forest Service. So we will review and comment on the U.S. Forest Service SHARP letter if received. It has not been received. My understanding is that that letter...
26:35 We'll first need to have a procedural discussion between the district ranger, John Roggebergi, and the town manager prior to the letter being drafted and submitted to the town. And Steve, can, my understanding was that Forest Service chose not to be here until that conversation happens? No, the Forest Service was called out on a mandatory training
27:03 Training session today, and both Sarah Tomsky and John Kazmierski were called away to that meeting. Okay, thank you for clarifying that. Okay. The next part is to review and comment and make recommendations to edits to the draft Town of Mammoth Lakes letter to the Forest Service regarding Sharp proposal, and it was to include the priorities below. Before we get into that, I would like to...
27:31 Pass out a piece of information here to each one of the committee members. This is a highlighted partial two page of the challenge cost share supplement agreement that we have with the Forest Service in regards to SHARP. So the intent of this is to provide background to you showing in highlights the current
28:08 Challenge cost share agreement supplement. The title, of course, being Mammoth Lakes Trail System, in particular, Sherwins Trail additions, planning, and decisions. And then under responsibilities, the town shall, number three, present to the Forest Service a prioritized list of projects proposed to be added to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and identify the level of development and any facilities associated with each project. So that's really what we're going to be focusing on today is trying to meet that requirement.
28:37 of the Challenge Cost Share Agreement. It goes on on page two, backside, the U.S. Forest Service shall provide under number two highlighted guide decision making process and number three assess trail project proposals for their feasibility, practicality, recreation, opportunity, and potential resource and social impacts and make recommended adjustments as necessary. So I would see that the Forest Service has been
29:06 Helping guide our decision making to this point. And then once this letter or final proposal is put together, they will take on B3, as I just read. So I provide that to you for a little background information. What I've prepared for you in this is a staff report, agenda item number four. And the purpose of this is to direct staff to finalize a letter with the Forest Service outlining the Sharp Trails projects, priorities as listed.
29:36 and Trails Projects for Further NEPA Consideration and Decisions. So this is presented as a draft at this time and I have included on the second page per our May 5th discussions the last listing of order of importance so if there are any changes to that or revisions we'll need to discuss that.
30:06 And then our recommendation, and again, this is all predicated on receiving a letter, is to recommend that the committee choose option one, approve the draft letter dated June 4th as written and sent to the Forest Service outlining the Sharps trail project, priorities listed, and trails project for further NEPA consideration and decisions. So,
30:31 Unfortunately, we can't complete this task, but I guess at this point, if you want to comment about the letter, the structure of the letter, or the procedures, we can go ahead and do that at this time. Sandy, sure, let's start with you. Okay, one of them, if I would just note on the first paragraph of the Sharpe's plan,
31:00 A decision for the first phase of the overall sharps plan for the trails projects listed below as described in sharp because it sounds like they wanted a little bit more of a description and I believe the description in sharp was pretty good. You know, what to do with the borrow pit. In other words, what to do with number six MUP. I did have a question with the paved versus unpaved. I think we were talking about going with the gravel layer first and then potentially, wasn't that it?
31:30 With that one and with the number seven backbone trail potentially going with a gravel layer first or a hardened layer, I should say. I think it just depends on what the funding is. Some fundings would require it to be paved, basically, and some funding sources. Yeah, see, I'm just thinking in terms of how to describe it in this letter because the paved versus unpaved wasn't really clear to me, whereas I believe in our discussion before we talked about one of them.
31:58 I think they even asked John, would it be okay to go with the hardened one first before it was actually paved, and he said that would be fine. Yeah, probably versus is the wrong word. It should be paved or unpaved. Yeah. So that, because it's a choice. Yeah. And based on, and or, it's a choice based on finance and at the time it's built. And I'm thinking perhaps one of the suggestions might be to move up number 13, the Mammoth Rock Trail, to the Borough Pit staging area, maybe move that right up next to.
32:26 Or even in front of borrow pit staging area. Because that's the one that potentially could be pulled out as a categorical exclusion. It's the only one that's an actually restoration project. So it could be done with a CAD-X and potentially even be done this year. Then on the back side of page two, I wasn't sure that you needed to repeat this.
32:55 In the first paragraph there, since its inception about the tracking numbers and this and that, I mean, some of that's in the staff report, I think, but I wasn't sure that that was a necessary part of the letter. And then just the last part, the last paragraph, just collapse that, remove the space between the lines. That's just a formal thing. And add to Dan Holler's name. Those are mine pretty much. Okay, thank you. Pretty much.
33:33 A couple things. First one, minor one, should probably be dear Mr. Regalbrugge, not dear John. In following up on the discussion that Mr. Kazmierski and I had, so we keep our Johns clear, Mr. Kazmierski and I had last time, I'm still concerned that we've kind of gotten ahead of the public on the identification of the projects we pursue. And I do understand
34:01 The need to keep the list manageable, not to have everything thrown in there so that we wind up wasting a lot of time on projects we'll never build. But going back and looking at, again, the input we got and looking at where this sits in the process, these projects will now go into scoping. And so there's still an opportunity to
34:31 Put a project in, scope it, and then if as a result of the completion of the scoping project it's infeasible, then take it out. So my first reaction was, well, let's put them all in, but that's probably a waste of everybody's energy. But I would like to see 5A and the four 16 connectors included, just again because those were the ones.
34:58 That was the one section of trail we heard from the public on that they thought was important. So I'd like to add, well, it's now on this letter, but I'd like to make sure it stays there because it wasn't in Kazmierski's original list of projects. Sorry, which one was it? I'm just appreciating the fact that 5A and 16 are on here because they weren't in the Forest Service original list of projects, but I think they're important. And thank you for including that in the letter.
35:26 And so just I wanted to reiterate that I don't think that creates a hardship. It doesn't run into the issue that I had originally proposed, which was having a project eliminated at the time of decision because John Kaye clearly showed why that was not an appropriate way to go. So with that, I think I'm okay with this. I just would like to make sure that those are. This was the one that concerned about.
35:52 The residence is correct? Yes. And if we could actually, once again, we're kind of suddenly up against a deadline, but if you look at 5A, it has some connectors that effectively have to cross private land to get to Laverne Street. And if I was trying to design a project to avoid the...
36:20 Some of the neighborhood conflicts, I'd probably just connect 5A to 16 where they meet and stop it there so that the Mammoth Rock Trail 16 form a complete loop. So go Mammoth Rock Trail 16 and 5A and back down to the meadow and connect with 8. But absent the ability to kind of make those tweaks, I just ask that 5A and 16 do remain on the letter.
36:49 Thank you. See, now, Bill, I was coming at the scoping from a different angle because I was going to say, you know, probably want to drop those off here and allow the public to put them forward in scoping because what we've had is pretty much a discussion with the Forest Service. What they see is the best ones. We agreed on all of those, you know, the first six, and I know you discussed 5A and 16, and there's some reluctance there, and I believe, you know, that's the kind of thing where
37:18 If the public wants to bring it forward in scoping, that's what scoping's about. You know, they could bring it forward. Yeah. So, you know, so we're just looking at scoping differently. I'd say if we didn't have it in our master document, if we hadn't done the background resource work on it, I might actually agree with that. But given that it was part of our proposal as the town.
37:48 And that we have heard that it's an important piece. I would like to go ahead and make sure that it's at least included. Now that may not, I mean, obviously there are three others here, so that would be fine. Well, I think Bill brings up a good point. As a trail in the future may need to be revised in its alignment to avoid a habitat area or an archaeological resource area,
38:17 So, too, may it need to be slightly revised to not go through private property or not have the condition of needing an easement to go through. So that particular troubling section could possibly be dropped out through the environmental review as an option to say, well, a mitigating measure is to reroute it to avoid. Weren't there some comments about that potential trail, though, from the public originally?
38:46 Yeah, if you look at the Sharp Document, there is an appendix in the back that contains emails from property owners that are up in that area that are concerned about the trail, concerned about whether or not it's an appropriate use in the area or whatnot. So there is and are those concerns that have been put forward and are part of the Sharp Document.
39:14 But again, I think Bill brings up a point that if it's getting too close to private property, if a portion requires another easement across private property, then through the environmental review process, part of that is trying to evaluate impacts. And if there are mitigation measures available, then they can be put into the proposal, and then the decision can so reflect those mitigation measures to avoid those.
39:44 Conflicts, be they natural or man-made. It's just something that we have to be aware of, as Sandy points out, you know, you can look in sharp and you can see those emails and see who they're from and the properties that feel that they are affected by it. It's part of the documentation. So anyway, basically I don't have any other than changing the Dear John, I don't have any other suggestions. I just would like to ask that 5A and 16 stay up. Yeah, I think your point is well taken. Peter?
40:14 One thing, I see these not as a priority in any order. These are just the first phase of the group of trails that we're looking at out in that area. So moving at higher or lower for number 13 doesn't really matter because it's part of the whole group. I think the 5A16, it might be good in the text maybe, just a short paragraph that says,
40:44 The alignment may be adjusted related to right-of-way needs for the project. That would be good. Actually, I have to say, to break it out and make a comment. That would be the best way to present it, I think. Yeah. So just a short session or two. In addition, you know, we would suggest this one, but yeah, that's a good idea. And that might soften the sentence below the list. Yeah. Yes. With an asterix or no asterix? That'll soften the discussion because this lot will be public.
41:11 Soften that discussion. We're not saying it's going to be a right-of-way take through somebody's yard unless they want it. It'll be looked at as far as the environmental process. And we have lots of examples where trails go through people's, next to people's houses, through their yard with easements, those kinds of things. And I don't know that we've got huge complaints after the trails are in. There's been lots of concerns before they go in, but not huge complaints after they've done it.
41:38 John, let me get through the rest of this. I can't hear anything anybody's saying. So if you guys, it's an important discussion to have you speak up or turn the microphones on, we just can't hear anything. Yeah, microphones are on. Can you hear me now, John? Thank you. They're on. Okay. Okay. That's funny. Thank you, Bill. For waking me up.
42:03 I didn't sleep at all last night, so I'm falling asleep at all. Peter, any other comments on the line? No, that's really what I had. Okay. My comments are similar to Pete's, although I think we should prioritize these. But I've gone through many prioritization processes before. Because we set in importance doesn't mean that they're going to be completed in that order. Because you take the low-hanging fruit.
42:31 If one is going to be a negative deck and we can do it, regardless where I see it on the importance list, I would expect us to pull it out of order and complete that trail. 5A and 16, I think that we've heard the people say they really want that connector. I understand it. It creates loops. And having designed other trail system, loops are hugely important in the success of a trail system.
42:59 So I would like to see them stay in there and maybe that explanation as well. In terms of more public meetings on these, man, that Sharps process took a heck of a long time. And we're pretty sure that these are the trails with 5A and 16 in there that the public's looking for. When I was talking about public involvement, and this is where I think John Kay and I
43:27 Weren't communicating. I was not talking about more workshops and more meetings. I was talking about making sure that this process is appropriately publicized and listed so that the public has the ability to have. And the concern was that, you know, initially the list had come back from the Forest Service to us, and the way in which it was presented, we just didn't have the chance for.
43:56 interested parties really to review, comment, and come back. It was just, this is where the written response really should have come in because the action was really embedded in our minutes and the public wouldn't necessarily know to go read our minutes to find out what the proposal was. Right. Well, I don't have any additional comments to what's already been said here, but what I'm hearing is consensus.
44:23 That the 5A and 16 need to stay in, but that a paragraph understanding that the alignment may actually need to change is important. Okay, great. Further, you know, again, without the response from District Ranger John Rutger, it makes it difficult to fully, in my mind, feel comfortable with this letter being sent without the written response. No, this letter will not be sent. This will be,
44:53 If with revisions, we can make this letter then available as a draft to the town manager for his further discussions and reply to the meeting that he will have with John Wugelbergie about moving forward with Sharp. So this is just some background, I think, to help in that discussion. At least then the town manager and the district ranger will understand the position.
45:24 Yeah, Sean, I can't remember which letter you're talking, are you talking about the one way back when, a year ago, when we proposed moving forward with Sharp? Well, that's what we presented to U.S. Forest Service, when I say we, the town. Right, and the response to that was the development of the challenge cost share, so that was the written response. I mean, they don't, generally, at this stage, I wouldn't see a ranger writing back because what,
45:54 Staff, John Kazmiercki, told us was, these are the ones we see, and so we're making the formal proposal, this is what we'd like to move forward with, but a response. However, John Kay also said that, here's our response, and if you'd like it in writing, we can do it in writing also. He did say that. And we said that we would love to see it in writing. He did say that. And now we're sort of being told, no, instead of doing it in writing, that the head of Mammoth and the head of the Forest Service are going to get together and do it in an office.
46:23 So even after that meeting, I'd love to see it in writing so the public understands how the process came down to whatever the product is in the end. That's my issue. It's now going behind the town manager and the district ranger's closed door for fulfillment. And I'm uncomfortable with that. I share your concern. And especially because I want to be clear here that while we've not been
46:53 Disbanded by Town Council. So, for all intents purposes, I would have expected the letter, and I share your concern that instead of receiving that letter, that we're being told that, that's right, the head of the forest, local head of the forest service model and the head of the town need to meet before he feels that he can send us that letter. And if I may, that record keeping is critically important if we are truly done. It is going to MLR.
47:22 They're going to need to somehow understand how we got to where we are without that letter of clarification. Or unless the whole MLR board is going to sit in with that meeting with the town manager and the Forest Service, they aren't going to know how we got here. So I view it as really important. So all we're doing at this point is just stating that there's no necessarily action. Wait, where's my agenda? Well, I think we want to make a formal. Thanks.
47:50 We want to make a formal recommendation on the letter. Yep. Sorry, just checking my agenda to make sure exactly what we're charged to do with. Is it directions to staff on that with these changes? Yeah. Yeah, just directions. That's what we're doing. Through a motion, though? Yes. So you want to read through all of the amendments and everything like that, all the wording? I can take a shot at it. Would you like to craft our motion? So, okay. I will move that we recommend sending...
48:23 Recommended the, and I don't know, would it be the town manager? Who are we recommending to? I guess it's the town manager. Would be the town manager. Receive the draft letter. Well, we recommend that he submit the letter to the Forest Service as written with the following edits. One, there should be, I won't bother with the, uh, comment, that's, that's just, uh, editorial. Um, let's see.
48:56 One in addition to paragraph one immediately prior to the colon saying trails slash projects listed below as described in sharp to the second edit is on number six paved or unpaved and or paved and or
49:19 Well, I don't know how you have paved and unpaved. Because you're going to have unpaved first, and then you're going to have paved, and if there's an environmental thing to be reviewed in one condition or the other, we'll want to make sure it's covered. So it's and or. And or. Okay. Then let's see. A sentence or a paragraph following the list clarifying that the 5A and 16 alignments may be adjusted to accommodate easement or right-of-way issues.
49:58 And then the last one that I have is the third from the last paragraph referring to environmental resource work and there is just delete the tracking number references. Were there any other edits? Just adding Dan Holler's name as town manager. Bill, I want to be clear on the motion that I just heard. Is that you, the motion is saying that town manager actually submit this letter before receiving
50:30 The written response. It does not say before or after. This is just our recommendation to the Forest Service. The town manager may choose to meet with the district ranger first. He may edit the letter. I'm not sure what he will do. We are just, this is the letter that we want to send. I'd say we may or may not get a letter from the Forest Service. Yeah, we may or may not receive a letter from the Forest Service. There's a draft out there that he's reviewing. But my sense is that while
50:57 For public record purposes, I would very much have liked to have received a formal response so that it's clear to the Forest Service, both the staff who's there today and any staff that may be there in the future and to town, same thing, what the agreements and understandings and suggestions and recommendations were. Okay. But whether that happens or not, I want to see this continue to move forward. Okay. And so I would like to recommend that this letter gets sent.
51:26 Okay. It will be up to the town manager to decide. Thank you. I just wanted to clarify what your motion was. I now have a second. Therefore, I can take on discussion. Is there further discussion from Ms. Dias about that? Any comments from the audience? Please approach the building. I'd just like to be clear what this is actually what you're actually proposing right now. There's a formal letter.
51:59 It is what you guys are suggesting are the priorities from sharps going forward to the Forest Service. And with that proposal, that formal proposal that you guys are sending forward, it is then giving town manager that ability to move forward with Mr. Reggelberger prior to coming back to anybody else or having anything in writing. And so this is really...
52:29 Moving these segments of trails forward, we hope, at this point as a formal proposal. The NEPA. They are already a formal proposal in the SHARP document. And it's the NEPA. I understand that, but you're making a formal proposal here saying this, as MLTSCC and as the town, this is what we want to see have happen on the SHARP's project. This is actually a response to the... Understand, this is the NEPA. Yeah.
52:58 This is a response to a suggestion from the Forest Service at our April meeting. They're ready to move forward with the next phase of NEPA. And they, after doing their initial field work, said, here are the projects we think should be evaluated in the NEPA document. We were responding to that saying,
53:26 Actually, we agree with the projects you selected, but we'd like to add two more. Correct. And so then now it goes, if it goes forward, it goes into their program. Okay, and then with that, once they receive this, they can move forward without it coming back to anybody else again, because that's no negotiation with the town. Okay, because it's my understanding that you guys were supposed to give suggestions today, but then this was coming back to the MLR board?
53:56 I don't think this one, this one's, you know, this is the money that was already budgeted. This is that $150,000. And remember when we discussed projects not stopping, this is a critical step to keep these moving forward. And so if in our earlier discussion I wasn't clear, I was assuming that this would go forward from here through the town. Any further discussions, actions?
54:26 Questions, Comments, then I presume would go back to town staff and they would bring it to the MLR board from this point forward assuming that we're disbanded. Yes, but I'm not hearing that here. I'm hearing that it's going directly from here to the Forest Service and that there's nothing that's coming back to MLR at all.
54:51 Go ahead. I'm sorry. Go ahead. Terry, I assure you're concerned, and that's why I was being clear on what your motion was, and since we're actually in discussion mode right now, you know, because back in the April meeting, I heard John Kazmierski tell us that the decision's kind of already been made. It was implied that these projects minus the 5A and 16 were going to be going forward. Is that...
55:18 Am I accurate in what I heard? Only if we authorize them to go forward. Correct. We the town, not necessarily the same LTSCC. And I think that the reason why we were asking for a response in writing was so that we could be clear. It's on Granicus, it's in the minutes, the verbal presentation, but at the same time, because we made a written presentation with the sharp...
55:42 Project initially, we were expecting that. My concern with the way the motion reads right now, and I can see both sides of this argument, is that we want these to go forward. We don't want to miss the boat on this. At the same time, I'm concerned that we're sending this regardless of receiving any kind of written response, because as Peter just pointed out, we may very likely not receive any kind of written response to the Sharp Project. Is that what you were saying?
56:12 You know, we haven't received one yet. We've received a verbal update. I think John Kazmierski drafted a letter. Regulabuga's reviewing it, and he's going to meet with town manager. One other thing, so we have a three-year agreement with them on the cost-share agreement, and they are staffing for that. And so if we don't give them authorization to pre with something, we will lose that opportunity, and they will not have staff, and we won't have a project.
56:41 I'd like to point out one other thing too. In the motion it is recommendation. So we are making a recommendation to the town manager. So if the town manager feels that he doesn't want to take our recommendation, he has all that power in the world to do so. If he feels that he wants to get input from MLR prior to finalizing it, he can do that. So all we're doing is making a recommendation to him, Terry. We're not...
57:06 Understood. We're not forcing his hand, we're not driving direction, we're just trying to keep things moving. It wasn't presented in that manner, and at this point in time, MLR is not under contract with the town. Exactly. Anyways, but it's that communication and how we make sure that MLR, because the intent is, and it may not go through, that is the intent, and if the intent is there, then there needs to be that communication.
57:33 And we just had a meeting on Monday, and that wasn't communicated at that time that this was the process that was going through. It was communicated that MLTSCC was going to suggest recommendations that would be brought back to the next MLR board, which is next Monday. So anyways, I'm just trying to make sure that we're all on the same page. Okay, yeah, I was under the impression that we were supposed to just continue on doing the work.
58:00 For the town and making our recommendations on projects that were already underway, and this is a project that's already underway. Big time. Unless I'm hearing that MLR doesn't want these projects to move forward for whatever reason, I see no reason why we wouldn't continue down the road. Okay. John? Yeah, just a couple comments. I fully appreciate the need to move projects forward this summer. However, I think there are two important concerns.
58:32 One is that by you guys making a recommendation to the town manager to consider moving these projects forward, you are not precluding all of the other projects in SHARP, which theoretically are to be analyzed through this, through whatever the process is. And I recommend that you add language to the motion perhaps that says that this is an initial phase, this is a first phase of recommendations. Something to that effect so we don't get into it.
58:59 Unfortunate situation where all of a sudden these projects become all the projects and the money gets eaten up and there's a problem with that. That would be the first recommendation to the motion. The second thing is we were, I personally, MLTPA was very involved with those discussions with those folks up in the bluffs and just in case you guys aren't clear, all of those trail alignments are on public lands. There's no private property component of any of those recommendations up there, just for your understanding. So that may be.
59:28 Folks concerned about things happening on public lands but does not affect their private property. And I think also just as a general comment that I can appreciate the Forest Service saying we don't want to open up for more public discussion about sharp projects and all this other kind of stuff. I understand all that. But from your responsibilities and the town's responsibilities in terms of what is being recommended on behalf of the public,
59:51 Back to the Forest Service. I think it's important to find a way to say, look, this is the work that we've done, this is where we're at, these are things we're recommending. In an initial phase, we have a, I very much appreciate Chairman Turner's concern about having things in writing. It's just so important to be able to, for people to go back and look at a paper record that says, this is what happened, back and forth, it's critically important for that. That, whether it's the MLTSCC,
1:00:18 You know, where MLR or whoever can go back to the public and say, okay, everybody, this is what's been going on the last couple of years. This is where we're at. And I think we're getting into a position of being maybe a little bit too far removed from all that. That's just an observation. John, part of the first sentence here, which is sort of a long sentence, is to move forward with additional NEPA and development decision for the first phase of the overall SHARP plan per the trails projects listed. So it clearly says first phase already.
1:00:45 Fine. As long as that's very clear. Is that in the packet, that letter, the draft of the letter? Yes. Is it? Okay. It's the second line. All right. Thank you. Yeah, but I think there is one amendment I would make response to what John said and where it says, I'm writing this letter to serve as, I guess, a formal proposal or the formal proposal by the town of Mammoth Lakes regarding the U.S.
1:01:15 To move forward with additional NEPA. Somewhere in there we should, maybe we need to break the sentence into two or it'll be already getting a little run on, but I would like to make it clear that it's in response to the recommendations made by the Forest Service to this committee on April 7, 2014. That'd be good. So that somehow there's a
1:01:40 A way to track, since we don't have a written response, that at least somebody knows where to go and look and see what was submitted. Sandy, will you accept that? You bet. I think that's a good amendment. So, you know, I'm being very formal today because this may be our last meeting, and I want to be very clear with minutes going forward if that does, in fact, happen. So, Steve, I'm going to ask you to re-read that motion back to us. Sorry, buddy.
1:02:13 If you need a few minutes to rework that first sentence so that it makes sense. I think we're understanding. I have a motion by Bill Taylor, second by Sandy Hogan. Recommended, recommend to town manager, submittal of the revised letter to the U.S. Forest Service to include, and then it's, I've got the inclusions on the page here, but paraphrasing that we will.
1:02:42 As a formal proposal, we will have and or instead of versus on paving. We will say as described in the sharp letter referring to the list below. We'll make reference to the April 7, 2012 verbal presentation by the U.S. Forest Service. We'll have a separate paragraph outlining 5A and number 16 alignment may need to be revised to avoid easements or right away dedication. I'll do further research based on what
1:03:12 Mr. Wentworth just said, and elimination of the last few sentences on the paragraph on the back side, giving the project numbers, and add Dan Holler's name as town manager. Were you proposing to insert the reference to John Kazmierski's presentation? In the first paragraph. Do those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Thank you.
1:03:41 Thank you. Okay, before we go on to the next item, what I would like to do is provide you with a couple of handouts having to do with our master tracker and our project. What's come to me lately is a two-page front and back having to do with our trail days. So this is part of the advertising effort and the establishment of the schedule on the back.
1:04:12 That was approved by Council. The second item that I would like to hand out for the record is a resolution from the Town Council adopting the Mammoth Lake Standard Plans for Public Works dated April 2014. Two page document again. The purpose of this is to show that our
1:04:52 Public work standards having to do with signage and trails have now been revised and adopted by council. So moving forward, you may remember in the past there was a lot of discussion about whether or not entities would know what the town's position is that now has clearly been adopted. And my understanding is in the next two weeks or less, these standards will be posted to the website.
1:05:21 So anybody from the outside who's interested in our standards will be able to go to the town's website under Public Works and find those standards that include signage, wayfinding, and trails-related standards for Public Works. Okay. Any questions on either one of those? Not anymore. I was going to ask you, actually, the status of that, because I knew. I reviewed it a long time ago, that Chapter 6, but good.
1:05:50 Okay. Any further questions on the handouts? Okay, the next item B then. Steve, I've got a comment. Oh, if I could, Mr. Chairman, just on the summer search of Trail Day, the first event, I'm sorry, I missed the public comment, I was getting a sandwich. Everything's on track for this Saturday morning. Tamarack parking lot, Tamarack's providing a yurt to meet in. Eastern Sierra Nordic Ski Association has partnered up, it's not reflected on the
1:06:29 On the flyer, we had kind of a crunch in terms of the contracting of when we actually had the contracts signed and start pulling everything together. But everything is on track for this Saturday. Hope to see you all up there. If you have any questions, please get in touch with me. Thank you. Okay, the next item is the MLTSCC Project Number 552, a winter corridor route for OSV and non-motorized users from Shady Rest Park Trailhead via the tunnel at SR203.
1:07:01 To the south side of Meridian Boulevard Tunnel, this is a town council approved agenda item number 11 from 5-21-2014. In your packet is a reduction of that agenda item. It's two-sided, four panels per page to save space. And you'll notice then under the options that it was town council.
1:07:26 Direct staff to, one, coordinate with U.S. Forest Service on making modifications to special use permits or development of a challenge cost share agreement in order to obtain OSV access between the open lands to the north of the industrial park and the north end of the Shady Rest Park by way of existing MUPS, tunnel under Highway 203 and Sawmill Cutoff Road.
1:07:54 And number two, return to council for further direction following initial consultation with U.S. Forest Service. Goes on to read, direct the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, MLT-SCC, to make this OSV access a top priority and allocate up to $18,998 from the proposed Mammoth Lakes Trail System budget under the Capital Reserve Fund for fiscal year 2014.
1:08:23 2015. And that was passed, as I recall, as a 3-2 vote. So it's before you today, again, to make it a top priority and to direct staff action. Okay. Yeah, this was an interesting subject. Let's start down here. Bill, do you want to go first? Sure. I did not ask for this to come forward. A lot of people think I did. This was brought forward by a member of council on his own.
1:08:55 I'm glad it came forward. This is the third time Town Council has directed staff by a vote to pursue this, and it has never been pursued in the past. Now that we have MLTSCC and MLR coming on board, my hope is that we finally can take this thing forward. This is an important link for the snowmobile user in the wintertime to link the Sherwins riding area
1:09:25 With the groomed trail system riding area to the whatever direction that is, north or east, it's an important piece. We worked very hard to bring that community into town for their vacations and everything else. At one point in time, we were ranked in the top 10 of destinations in the west. We don't make the top 100 anymore.
1:09:54 Because those snowmobilers feel like we have alienated them. We have taken away the access they had to the RV park. We have chopped the areas up. We have told them pretty much, in a nutshell, we don't want you here. As a resort community, we pretty much need to get any legitimate recreationists here we can. For this group, this would go a long ways towards healing some of that and maybe bringing some of those tourists back to town that have stopped coming.
1:10:25 From that crowd, so I am hugely in favor of it. Council has seen fit to pass it on to us and ask us to make it a priority. I would like to see us do so. Quick, excuse me, if I might a question on that. So that's a budget priority out of the fiscal year 14-15 funds? Yeah, it would allocate some set aside that we had made the 18,000 something was
1:10:57 That's right. A sort of a leftover that we put into a CIP kind of account. And that's the funds that they have allocated to start the process with. Right. Of course, we could change that and fund it from somewhere else. We could make that recommendation back to them. But at this point, I think it's a good starting point. Yeah, it's going to moot. Okay. Yeah. Peter? I think it, as a snowmobile lawyer personally, provides that other opportunity.
1:11:29 To cross the highway versus the 395 crossing, which is really unsafe, especially on Sunday afternoons. When you're darting across five lanes of traffic, pretty difficult. It's illegal, although the trail stops at either side of the highway. My thought is, since I've been staffed for some time, is that the reason I really never moved forward before was it wasn't a funding mechanism. And so this provides that ability.
1:11:59 Essentially, it would go back to Council, like they've discussed, and it could be that it's included in one of the existing plans that they have going on, or it's its own NEPA document. And I think this discussion is really to develop that scope of work of what we might ask for the Forest Service to do, I think is what this early discussion is for. In the end, it'll be an MLR discussion, I believe.
1:12:28 Can I make another comment on that? Yeah, I will. Hang on. Is it relevant to what Peter just said? Yeah, go ahead. It's relevant to the overall thing. My preferred alternative here, as we stated before as a committee, would be to have the trail from the tunnel out to the Shady Rest Trailhead exist on the west side of the Shady Rest Road. Steve and I, in fact, worked on a proposal that we...
1:12:54 Gave to the Forest Service when they were accepting comments that could accommodate that. In their proposal on the trailhead in that Shady Rest corridor, they came through with a position not to allow that, not to allow snowmobiles back. So unfortunately the only way to accomplish that would be to open up that MUP, the special use permit, to ask for a change in that special use permit so the MUP could be used for OSVs, which is legal.
1:13:24 From the tunnel to Shady Rest, it's not my preferred alternative. But if that's the only way we can accomplish it, this is an important piece for that group. The group brings an awful lot to the area already. It pays for the grooming of 100 miles of trails that are widely used by motorized and non-motorized alike. They created the need, they created the...
1:13:50 Inertia at Shady Rest. Shady West wasn't being used until the grooming came along. They deserve at least some consideration. Bill? No, Bill. No, I just was going to comment on the sort of circularity of the proposal where the council is directing us to recommend back to them a funding that they could have just gone ahead and done on their own at the time. So, I mean, it looks to me as though
1:14:21 It's already done. They're the approving body, not us. We made an initial recommendation. They modified it. I'm not sure what action we need to actually take. Just to add it into our... We'll just make note of it. I would certainly, based on this, recommend that we modify the budget to reflect the allocation of the $18,998 to this project.
1:14:47 But it's not up to us to allocate it or not allocate it. It's really up to the council. They're asking for a recommendation. Well, it doesn't look like they're asking for a recommendation. They're really asking for us to amend our budget. To amend our budget, right. In which case we should do that. There is the language to make this OSV access a top priority. So I think it goes beyond just allocating our budget. And so maybe, again, to...
1:15:16 Reinforce the staff action that the council is requiring or suggesting that something from the committee. But I think effectively by funding it, we do make it a top priority. It's noted as bucket number one, which is priority, right? So I think we're there. Yeah, I don't think there's much discussion that's needed here. Sandy, did you have any comments? Pretty much bills. I mean, it's a done deal.
1:15:45 I mean, you know, so they directed and I think, you know, I looked at it. I saw the bucket number one, which means it's high priority. I saw the funding there. So if we need to make a motion to accept the council direction, we can do that. Well, I think we just make a motion to amend the budget to reflect that allocation of funds. Sounds good. And I'll make that motion. And I'll second. I got a motion and a second.
1:16:16 Any further discussion here? Any comments from the audience? Okay. Those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Okay. Passes. Okay. While we're talking about the master tracker then, are there any other projects that need to be discussed? And the other part of it is,
1:16:43 Being that this is my last meeting, I wanted to make sure that the master tracker list was complete as possible showing our previous years with contract signed, funds paid out, carry over and so forth. So whereas in the past we were trying to shrink this accordion to make it fit in a box, now I've expanded it back out again so that
1:17:07 Trying to make it as clear as possible where these monies are, where they've come from, where they've gone, and have been working with Terry and Joe Bacon to try and get some reconciliation on these figures as well. So that's the purpose of seeing this in this expanded format again. Are there any other comments about this at this time? And I'm not sure, again, because of status, where we're at, how much we want to take up. My only concern is any ongoing contracts.
1:17:39 Well, that kind of was what my comments that I had in going through these. You know, we could discuss a whole bunch of them. They're all in an approved budget, and I would think they need to keep moving forward, whether it's under contract or not. You know, and my question was, does the staff continue to work? In other words, is there a transfer of staff work from...
1:18:07 You know, from Steve to the town staff, or do we have to get MLR input and approval on everything, and if so, what is the process? I hate to just see these things stall. I mean, the question about NEPA. There is a response to that, so is it Peter? Well, we have had a meeting with the transition team. The chair, vice chair also had a discussion. And so I think Public Works will still staff the contracts, and we'll be working and coordinating with the...
1:18:39 Ongoing Transition Team of MLR. And staff would then write new contracts as necessary to live up with this budget. To support the projects moving forward on the budget. Part of the projects are on new agreements with the Forest Service, which is actually timely because their fiscal year stops in October. So by providing them early information about things that we'd like them to do in the next fiscal year,
1:19:09 They can appropriately look at what their staffing needs are and hopefully try to accommodate that so that they can either bring on another staff person and allocate resources to accommodate our needs. Technically, we've migrated into item four. But I think you're right. And I think that's fine. You're correct. I'd like to just reiterate that at the MLR meeting, I did suggest that
1:19:39 There should be a formal, I mean the issue is of course we're losing Steve which means we lose a lot of continuity and so just knowing who at the town staff is responsible for overseeing the trail system really as a whole I mean there should be one point of contact on the trail system we'll start getting five or ten points of contact we're going to lose control and whoever that individual is should be providing regular reports back to the MLR
1:20:08 As they move forward, recognizing that they have no formal jurisdiction or authority yet, but with the anticipation that they will. Yeah, and I think that's really important because one of my other questions also was how does the public know which projects are moving forward? How do they give input? Is this maybe a standing agenda item for MLR? Maybe that's a good answer to it that the staff would give because
1:20:36 Really, it isn't just the stuff that's under contract. We have a lot of stuff that has been moving slowly, you know, they move at different speeds, but there's a whole, if we were to go through this item by item, I mean, we'd be discussing an awful lot of these. That's why I think it's critical that the MLR transition certainly continue to copy us as individuals, again, if this body is disbanded, that...
1:21:02 Continue to seek our counsel and advice just because we have been involved in this process for so long. And I've heard indication that that's exactly what would happen going forward. Yeah, I've heard they will consult you two. That's what I've heard. But, you know, there's a lot of background behind a lot of these things that I think all of us, every one of us, has been involved in implementation of projects. You know, I mean, over the years, every one of us has kept a lot of balls moving in the air. And so,
1:21:32 This may look real simple, but it's really not a simple process. I would like to formally request, and I don't know how we do that, but whatever distribution exists for the MLR agendas, that the members of this committee all be included on that distribution list so that we have the opportunity to see what's coming back and with the idea that we can provide support.
1:22:01 That's not to be a critic, but to assist MLR in any way that we can to move these projects forward and keep them happening. We have migrated into business item number four here. Actually, I'd like to make a correction on the agenda. It's number five, actually. We were talking about number four. But I would like to talk still about number our spreadsheet, because there were a couple of projects I think we did. But I think that's appropriate under here. When I looked at how the...
1:22:29 Oh, okay. However it's laid out. Well, how would you like to take this on? Because in some ways, you know, discussing further on, well, I guess that's not the case. We are discussing the master project tracking list. Is there anything else, any other comments? Just let's close out business item number four and move into number five, although they do kind of cross over a lot. Yeah.
1:22:58 But is there any other comments or anything specific to the master tracking list that needs to happen so that we can close that business better? Yes. You know, I won't start on page one, but just I know that on some of the things like on page two, 331.02, which is the Sharp Trails Construction Fund, this is one of those items where we specifically put money in there.
1:23:25 Because we were, the pending USF discussions is actually pending NEPA as well, and ideally we were hoping that Mammoth number 13 would be broken out if NEPA goes forward fast enough that it could be broken out in a categorical exclusion and actually be funded for this year. Because I know the Forest Service also had money for restoration, and this project could be broken out because it's not really a new one. It's a total, pretty much, restoration project.
1:23:53 So those are the kind of things where I don't know. You may want to expand the note on that because I think it just looked like to the reconciliation folks that that was money that was there to be chased. And it's really we set it aside for purpose of construction to contribute into actual construction of a project if we could break it out of NEPA fast enough. Oh, I think that's what it says, doesn't it? No, it doesn't. It just says pending.
1:24:21 Let me ask you this, Sandy. How many do you have that you want to comment on? Well, I would have gone the whole first page, but I'm not. But that was an important one, I think. Pending, depending. Can you just give me an answer? Is it going to be five, ten? Just a couple. It's not that much. Okay, because I'm wondering the best way to deal with these and essentially what you're asking that we get out of this. Yeah, I just hope, well, I assume that this is going to be
1:24:49 Pass to the MLR folks, and nobody's going to be around to explain it to them unless the comments are clear, and the comments are pretty darn clear on most of them, but that was one that was really, I thought, important. Now might be a good time to hear from Terry. Terry Scott, speaking for MLR.
1:25:11 The 331.02 that Sandy was discussing, actually we understand is a reserve item specifically for the construction of sharp trails. And it is put into that category for reserve. Excellent. Excellent. Okay.
1:25:27 Stand by. No, you can have a seat, but I just, that's why, I kind of proceed really, I wanted to, you know, Sandy asked, what's your goal in approaching these? Well, making sure that it's clear. Okay. Yeah, and something like that, because what I heard at Monday's meeting, it didn't sound like, it sounded like it was just. Are there any others that you want to discuss the action or notes? We did do number 552 already, the 551, which is the winter grooming program.
1:25:56 That one, you know, that is definitely, is going to need a contract before the snow falls, and it needs a lot of, you know, those are the kind of things that you don't want to get held up. Okay. So. That one's got a little bit of time, but. Yeah, so there is time. Yep, yep, yep, exactly. Let's see. Some of the ones in the back were just, were pretty minor. There's maybe, mainly mixed action notes.
1:26:32 And I think one of them you already talked about, 2.11, the MTLS Standards Manual Update. That is a completed action in the Public Works Standards Update, I believe, that's Chapter 6. So that can be noted. Is that right? What page is that? Page 4. First grouping there, last one. Isn't that one that we just addressed, Steve, that you handed out the action? I think so.
1:27:02 I'm still not finding it. It's on page 4? Page 4, bottom of the first, number 211. What is the number 2? Number 211. So, I mean, yeah, I mean, let's face it, that was, it was just done. Well, this is a basis. We never funded it. It's just a descriptor.
1:27:28 It's good, or like the signs, if they need changing or whatnot, so. So that has nothing to do with the Public Works Standards, Chapter 6? Not directly, only if there's something needed. I think it originally, sorry, I think it originally discussed it. We provided funding. Well, anyway, you can note Chapter 6's update, it's been approved, and no update should be needed for a long time, I would think. The one thing, the next one down, next block.
1:27:57 Number 141, the last one there, the Shady Rest off-highway vehicle, over-snow vehicle staging area project, that one you might make a notice that the decision notice was signed this spring, so that, you know, grants, they'll probably go after grants for that, I would think, but decision notice was signed, that's completed. So this is something that you're asking me to put in the notes? So that people know. Okay. Yeah, exactly. I mean, that's important to know that the...
1:28:27 Decision to sign and move to the next steps. And on the front page, most of my comments, I think, just have just keep these things going, you know, even if they weren't under contract, the key is to keep them going. I think that's recognized. Yeah. All right. I hope. Okay. Okay. Good. Because all I heard, if they were under contract, they were. All right. Let's, you know, the best advice that's been given to me lately is trust in the process. And I think that right now, especially since it's been captured,
1:28:58 Here in Granicus that since we've got a member here, I think we're okay. Good. Well, you were the notes that, actually, your little quote there is what I was thinking about when the NEPA process for the Sharp was being questioned. I went, you know, trust in the process. This is a three-year, and we want to keep it rolling. Same thing. John, a quick comment? Yeah, I just want to thank staff, Steve Spidell.
1:29:25 For all the work that he's done with this master tracker list. As you may know, it's not really material, but this original list came from MLTPA from a contractor, provided the MLTSC. Steve wasn't working at that time, but Steve's infinite genius. He was able to pick this thing up, appreciate the logic and reorganization of it. He's applied an enormous amount of work and fidelity.
1:29:50 To that document, to that organizational scheme, I think the fact that you guys have been meeting now for a couple of years, and we've got a couple of minor comments on the list, but you've got a good inventory of all the work that's been done. It's eminently portable. It can go to MLR. It can go anywhere. But I wanted to just give a shout out to Steve for the work that he's done and for the committee for sticking to that program. That was a critical part of one of the things we delivered. We just want to thank you for doing that. Thank you. Thank you. You're going to get some orations today. Okay.
1:30:21 If we can, let's move on. All right, to number five. Yes, that's where I want to be. Okay, so, but we are complete in business number four, just to be clear. Yeah. Thank you. Number five, we've asked to receive an update by MLR on the MLR process, and also at the time we wanted to get a little bit of a discussion about the dissolution and termination of the MLTSCC. So, Terry's here to provide that, I trust? Thanks for being here, Terry.
1:30:54 No, actually, I was not. I didn't realize that was on your agenda. So it was discussed at one point in time. But MLR isn't dissolving anything or terminating anything. That's not our purview. So, but as far as MLR is concerned, it is active. We're working on, we have our state number. We're working on our federal ID number for the official nonprofit number.
1:31:22 Right now, we're still in the nuts and bolts, so we're still looking at, we're putting together the checking account and all of the different things that we need to formalize. There's many ad hoc committees that are working on all of these items. There's an ad hoc committee that we'll be working with for the contract for MLR to present to council, and that'll be council's purview, whether they accept that or not.
1:31:51 And so right now things are still rolling forward. So what we've asked as far as MLTSCC goes, it's quite clear that MLR does not have the authority at this point in time because they are not under contract to make those decisions that go to council. However, we've asked that the MLTS
1:32:21 Be a standing item on each of our agendas, which will be held every two weeks. And so that gives staff opportunity to bring anything back that has to do with MLTS and the Mammoth Trail System. And so that there can be some input, understanding, and a comprehensive program moving forward. And that there isn't anything that falls through the cracks or anything that isn't able to move forward.
1:32:50 I don't know if that helps. I think that helps a lot. Do you have any questions of Terry? That helps me a lot. I just want to see these things keep moving. And all the things that you said, Sandy, we actually, like the last one, we have on the current contract and one of those things that we know is moving forward right now.
1:33:14 And then the other items, we have a whole reserve list that we understand is earmarked specifically for those projects. Okay, great, great. That makes me feel better. Thank you. Any other comments from this bias right now about essentially the potential distillation and termination of this body? Well, I just want to make sure that as we're discussing transition, that any of the important documents
1:33:43 You know, you put together that really nice framework for decision making and the checklist that goes with it. I don't know, just make sure that there's a package that's put together that essentially encapsulates how we were managing things that can go forward to provide a point of departure for MLR as they start reviewing things. I'm not suggesting that they need to follow
1:34:10 Exactly, step by step, what we did, but I think it will give them at least a starting point. What I've done, too, as a matter of fact, this morning is I spent some time organizing all my hard files, putting them into five three-ring binders, and then putting a cover slip that talks about each one of the tabs within it, and then turned that over to Peter with a complete description of each one of the tabs, and that information that you are referring to is within the governance section.
1:34:39 So we have that hard copy as well as I transmitted to Peter the URL address or whatever it is for the server so that all that electronic information as well, all our meetings, all that background is there. So I'm anticipating a fairly smooth transition from my work back to the Town of Mammoth Lakes and staff. Thank you. I really appreciate that. Really.
1:35:04 And I just stood back up here to say that we absolutely welcome all that, because obviously you guys have put in a lot of work. There's a lot of information out there, so having all of that come forward would be great. Thank you guys. Thank you so much. Okay, any other comments at this time? I think what I'd like to do is, if I may, on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes, is present this Certificate of Appreciation to our...
1:35:36 Coordinator, Steve Spidell, for all the work that you've done for Mammoth Lakes and for this committee and for the partnership that exists between the Forest Service. So, thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Pleasure. Steve, pleasure. Steve, pleasure. All right. Oh, good sound.
1:36:04 How do you want to do this? Okay. Oh, this is good. This is good. Okay, yeah. Move in, guys. We'll slide in here. Okay, good, good, good. Oh, yeah. Just keep smiling. I'm sure one of those will work. Yeah, one of these. Yeah. My phone's better than your phone. Smile, kids. You're updated, right?
1:36:34 Perfect. Good. Yeah. Thanks, you guys. All right, Steve. No, John, all I have to do is tell my camera to take a picture and it takes it. I don't have to push the button. Well, since you, Steve, thank you very much for all the time that you and I have had a chance to meet privately to organize these meetings and all the work you've done on your own, of course, and this entire committee. Yep.
1:37:02 We're not officially disbanded yet, but having said that, I don't see any staff reports. No, I do have one other item, though, that's in your packet. I'll draw your attention to it. It's probably the last one. It's from the U.S. Forest Service, and they are reinitiating their need-to-change process for the update on the forest plan. So I've included that information, you may recall, before that Peter Bernasconi and some staff put together a letter to Deb Schweitzer.
1:37:32 So this is, again, a follow-up. I think, John, if you'll correct me if I'm wrong, it was a strategic delay. What was the term that was used? Something like that. Anyway, that strategic pause has now ended, and so they're looking forward to some more input. And my understanding is it's Thursday, June 19th.
1:38:00 Five to nine down at Bishop at the Community College. So if you're interested and I suppose that you might be able to direct staff. So I'll follow up on this or? I'll be on vacation during that time. I believe the town manager will attend as well as maybe our new public works director. And Steve, I appreciate you saying for staff because it is really critical that someone from the town that has the technical ability to
1:38:30 Report back on these things. I listen to them and get very upset but don't have the technical skills to make appropriate comments. So to have someone from staff report back to MLR, MLTSCC for comments and then include those in the report, to me, is huge. Not just they take it as a staff project on its own, but that it goes back to the rec commission, whatever body it needs to go back to.
1:38:58 For town recommendations to be added into that is huge. Unfortunately on that night I'm going to be feeding some 75 writers from a writers conference at the Hayden cabin. I think you are. One of the things that happened on the last one was the comments were due the following day of the meeting. So we kind of had to have our draft and write the letter quickly.
1:39:20 If I could, Mr. Chairman, we had, MLTPA had one of the series of Mammoth Trails meetings. Deb Schweitzer, the Public Affairs Officer for the Forest, came up. Steve was in attendance in the meeting. One of the key things for this meeting on June 19th is the Forest Service is requesting that people bring 8 1⁄2 by 11 photographs that document what an individual or an organization believes to be a testament to something that either needs to change or needs to stay the same.
1:39:48 So they're looking for a very specific tool by which they can start articulating those things. So if any of you have an idea of a Mammoth Lakes Trail System sign that's a picture of a documentation of an effective partnership or things that aren't going so well, this is the tool that they're using as part of their process. But again, June 19th, this whole thing picks back up where it started. It's complicated, it's interesting, but it should be a whole lot of fun.
1:40:17 Syracuse College, Syracuse College of Bishop. A whole lot of fun. I don't know about that one. So all we can do really is accept this back then? Yes, and ask staff to report back to whatever group is taking our place, or us if we're still here, so that we can then have staff tell us what it all means, so that we can then make appropriate comments.
1:40:49 To the plan as a town. Well, conceivably, this would be the day after we're terminated. Yes. Well, the, yes, the, but there's still going to be a rec commission. There's going to be an MLR. There's going to be an avenue for the town to comment back. As anyone who's been involved for a long time knows, I've been pushing both the town and the county to get involved in making comments on forest planning issues because they affect the town and county.
1:41:17 And the town is finally stepping up to the plate and doing that. We've got contracts in place with the Forest Service for the first time beyond the scope of just a use permit for a trail. And it behooves us to continue to do that. Then what would be the best wording to follow up on this document coming out of this committee? I think you've already done that by...
1:41:43 Peter's going to carry it forward. And our new Public Works Director is sitting here in the audience shaking his head or his fist or something at me. I think the other thing you could do is bring it up at your Recreation Commission meeting and then through that process have a further discussion with
1:42:06 Directing staff to provide that input on behalf of the town. Could we ask our new Public Works Director to introduce himself? I was wondering, I thought, well, who is this? I thought maybe it's a friend of Steve's who's wanting to get a photo of it. All right. New Public Works Director I started on Monday. Specific to the meeting on June 19th, I know that Peter's going to be in Alaska and seems to be back in Washington, correct?
1:42:30 And I certainly can't speak after two and a half days for the town manager, but I'm going to ask him, say, look, this is to me, and I certainly think I should attend, not only something I might be involved in full, you know, through everything, but certainly to meet the people that are involved and get involved because it's certainly an interest of mine individually as well as everything else. It's certainly something the town needs to stay on. So I'm going to suggest back to him that certainly the town be represented.
1:42:56 In what form, we come back with comments and notes. We'll work on that. But you guys have done an awful lot of work for a long time. And if nothing else, you deserve that. That responds to know that things are moving forward. And as well, I was going to turn around in a moment and introduce myself to the director folks, the new public works director, because I'm sure that we'll be working closely with, you know, your records and the fine job that Steve did and them moving forward. So I expect to be there June 19th. I saw it when I saw the package. I know where it is down in Bishop.
1:43:26 I plan on being there, and hopefully I can put together a package we can distribute to all of the afterwards. Thank you. That satisfies my concerns. Yeah, that's super. Thank you. Yeah, welcome. Nice to have you here. Okay, I think we've completed all our business items. I'll make a motion. Wait, are we ahead of ourselves? I was thinking since we aren't dissolved, we probably need to adjourn to our next regular meeting of July 7th, unless...
1:43:56 So if that's what you're going to do, that'd be great. Yeah, all I'm going to make a motion to adjourn this meeting. Nothing. Okay. To our next regularly scheduled meeting. I'll second. Sandy, go ahead. Of course. Sandy said it first. So I've got a motion second. Any further discussion? Who's in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you very much for your time, Peter.