Town Council
· recording 3 hr 11 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
411 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:01 I will now call to order the regular meeting for Town Council for Wednesday, August 20th. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. We will have John lead us in a salute to the flag. Please all rise, face the flag, and place your hand over your heart. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation,
1:35 Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice fraud. We will now proceed with public... It's in the on position. Thank you. I didn't think it sounded like it was on either. Yeah, it doesn't sound like it. Just yell. Just yell. Just talk loud. Project. Project.
2:07 We will now move on to public comments for items that are not on this evening's agenda. If you have something that you would like to announce, please come forward to the podium. Andrew. Good evening, Town Council. Mrs. Mayor. Andrew Castor with the Mammoth Track Club, and I'm here tonight to promote the cold water trails cleanup on Saturday the 23rd. There's a big, swag giveaway.
2:34 According to Mr. Wentworth here. I have some literature here. Basically, Mammoth Medical Missions and the Mammoth Track Club and MLTPA are partnering up. We did this last year. We had a great turnout. It's going to be food provided by Old New York Deli for breakfast, Blue for lunch, and just a lot of fun up there restoring and cleaning up.
3:03 The Coldwell, I'm sorry, the Coldwater Trails up at Coldwater and George Trailhead. So I want to announce that for this weekend. Hope to see everybody there. Bring gloves and closed shoes and boots. Thank you. Thank you, Andrew. You didn't mention the time, so I'll add that it's 8.30. It is 8.30 to 1.30, yes. And also I wanted to mention that
3:28 There are a variety of levels of skills needed on these trail days. You can choose picking up trash, painting picnic tables, or putting in water bars. So there's something for everybody. Thank you. Hello. My name's Jim Tabb, and I teach Adapted PE in all the Mono County schools. And I'm here to advocate for the all-inclusive park on behalf of Mike Ramirez and his family, as well as our population of folks with disabilities locally and guests that come up that...
4:05 Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you.
4:40 Good evening. My name is Dana Stroud. I'm the current president for Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and I would like to apprise the council and members of the public of a few recent activities that MLR has undertaken. The first one has to do with our designation and determination by the IRS as a 501c3 charitable organization. We received that notice in the mail last week from
5:07 From the IRS. So contributions will be now tax deductible for those who make the contributions, which leads me to the next announcement that MLR will begin its 100 for 100 capital campaign to reach out to our community for some donations to help.
5:26 Thank you so much. Thank you. Thank you.
5:55 Which leads me to the third point. We are now, if you will, soliciting for interested parties to submit an application to be considered as a board member for MLR. We have an application form posted on the MLR website, and that website is mammothlakesrecreation.org. That's all one word.
6:20 And the application asks interested parties to provide some basic information such as your history in the area, why you're interested in joining the MLR board, what your experience is serving on a board, and if you are currently involved in a board participation. The deadline for submitting the applications will be Friday, September 19th at 5 p.m.
6:44 And we will accept those electronically or you are able to submit them via mail to our PO Box, which is 8562 Mammoth Lakes. So I would encourage those who are interested in being considered for the MLR Board that you submit an application for review. We will have a nominating committee that will go through those applications and start to determine.
7:09 Those that will be considered for inclusion and to be voted upon for the MLR board. As a point of clarification, any current members that are serving on the MLR board, they will be required to submit an application as well if they are interested in continuing and serving on the permanent board. We anticipate that the board election will take place at our annual meeting scheduled for October 27th.
7:35 So I just encourage anybody who is interested to go on to our website and to consider downloading an application and submitting it for your review. I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have. Actually, Dana, would you mind just giving a quick, brief summary of the discussion that we had at the MLR board meeting on Monday about convening a discovery session? Sure. Since that came up already? Sure.
8:06 To address the previous speaker about the consideration for an inclusive playground development in Mammoth Lakes, the MLR board approved our role in reaching out to Shane's Inspiration Foundation that has developed a model for developing inclusive playgrounds in communities throughout California and throughout the United States, actually.
8:31 We will be reaching out to representatives from Shane's Inspiration to come to Mammoth Lakes for a discovery meeting that will include identified stakeholders who have expressed an interest in being a part of the development of an inclusive playground. It's at that discovery meeting that the roles and responsibilities will be addressed as well as what the requirements are for such a program to move forward.
8:59 And giving Shane's Inspiration Foundation an opportunity to present the role that they can play and the resources that they bring to the table. So MLR approved us to serve as the convener of that discovery meeting. We are targeting the mid to late September time frame when Mike Ramirez is back from Australia, and he'll be here for a few weeks, so we're targeting that time frame so he can participate. Some of the interested stakeholders that we will be reaching out to include
9:28 Mono County Health, the Mono County Office of Education, the Kern County Special Services, the first five of Mono County, the Mammoth Unified School District, and a few others that are on that list to participate in the discussion. Thank you, Dana. Thanks. Good evening, Mayor and members of the City Town Council. Charlene Wardlow with ORMAT. And you may have seen these flyers around town.
10:06 Tomorrow afternoon in this room from 1.30 to 3 is a public workshop on the Long Valley Caldera, and I actually have a copy of the actual agenda for each of you. It involves an overview of the Long Valley Caldera, the Volcano Hazards Program by the USGS, a geology overview of the Long Valley Caldera. I'll be giving an overview of the history of geothermal energy utilization here. Dan Leister will be giving a history of the Long Valley Caldera.
10:35 Hydrologic Advisory Committee. Pat Hayes will be giving an overview of the aquifer system and the groundwater system that the town uses. And then the BLM will be talking about the proposed groundwater monitoring program for our proposed CD4 project. It will be recorded. So if someone cannot make it to the meeting tomorrow afternoon, they'll have the opportunity to review it at another time. So we hope we had done one of these about two years ago and didn't have a big turnout. And so we've been trying to really reach out. It's been in the newspapers.
11:04 And these are posted around town. So we hope to have a good turnout and just have an educational meeting about this incredible place called the Long Valley Caldera. Any questions of surname? No. Thank you. Is there any further public comment? I'm Michael Lish from Community Skis. When the T-bid went through, we really didn't have a concern because my background is 35 years in manufacturing. We thought we'd be exempt. We engaged in a conversation with John Urdi.
11:46 And he subjected us to a sniffing test with his board to review our thought that we would be and should be exempt. We spent a considerable amount of time, and during that time we were receiving bills for the TBIN and we were incurring the penalties because we were insistent that we shouldn't be paying it. That was a considerable amount of time in a business that was just trying to find its way here in Mammoth.
12:12 After about maybe seven or eight months and a considerable fine along with the base that we were supposed to be paying, we talked to Town Finance. Within two days they reclassified us as a manufacturer, which in fact exempted us from the T-bid. Perfectly happy. We wasted a lot of time. It was contentious. Created a lot of stress on our company. Recently we found out we were visited by the Town Finance Director and he had expressed a concern that
12:40 John Urdi was questioning or had some issues revolving around our reclassification. I have to say, as a new company in town, that puts a really big black mark on our calendar. We're coming up against a major ski season, hopefully, and again, our focus is being redirected to dealing with John Urdi. Now, that's a big problem for our company. It's not the T-bid. We have no issue with it. So what we've decided to do is we've
13:08 Because of the T-Bid and because we've been outspoken in regards to how it's being administered, we've attracted some really smart people. We're going to do something in about two or three weeks where we bring in tax specialists, legal experts, somebody down from south who's actually been in litigation regarding the T-Bid to actually look at our situation and understand the town's position and the law as it was written. Putting all that aside, our concern is that we were reclassified by the town, which we thought was...
13:38 With due diligence, the correct thing to do. That John Urdi is back, it seems to be, in that office in a contentious role trying to get us back into the fold or expressing his disdain for our reclassification, again, puts us in that stress mode. So I just wanted to bring it to the town's attention and then also bring it to the town's attention that we will be holding a consortium of professionals and experts to review our case in particular, but the TBID in general. So, thank you.
14:06 Thank you, Michael. Any further public comment? Matthew is a member of the public. You wouldn't expect to be in here for a while. Kind of hoping to take a longer sabbatical. I'm here actually as a member of the MLT board, and I'm just here really to defend Mammoth Lakes Tourism and their position on this matter. I think we have a person.
14:41 That's, you know, they're paying into the T-bid because they're also paying a sales tax. They're selling retail. And I'm assuming that part of the argument is that they're trying to be a wholesaler when, in fact, I don't think that they are. Maybe there's a portion of them that are, but there's also a retail component. So in defense to John Urdi and in defense to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, you know, I look at the last three years, our summers, which are a period of time where
15:11 They're not necessarily affected by drought or winter. And we've seen three of the best years in the town's history and three of the worst periods of time in the town's history. So with that, I think that a little more credit needs to be given to Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the efforts that John Urdi is going through because our town, in my opinion, is very fortunate to have him on board. And that's all I wanted to say. Thank you.
15:40 Thank you, Matthew. I'm shorter than Matt. My name is Paul Rudder. I'm also a member of the MLT board. And I would just like to clarify a couple of things. First off, I want to say that personally I'm very fond of Michael. He is a great member of the community, has a terrific business that is a credit to this community, and we should do everything we can to encourage him. I think the lack of clarity becomes
16:13 Michael does wholesale and manufacture skis. And in that regard, the T-Bit is not entitled to any tax on his operation. It's when he retails skis to the public here in Mammoth that the T-Bit comes in and only there. And it's not really John Urdi that's doing this. It is the MLT. It is the ordinances that created it. The MLT board has been informed about this and have been involved in this. In fact,
16:41 When the hearings were held regarding Mike's business and how it was supposed to be treated, those hearings were not before John Urdi. They were before a subcommittee of the board. So it might be a little unbalanced to say this is all John's doing. It's not. But primarily, we need to be transparent in our dealings. We need to be fair to everyone. We have to have a level playing field. It may be.
17:11 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
17:32 But primarily, you know, I want to say to the Town Council and to Michael, hey, we have an obligation to be transparent and to treat everyone, his business, everyone's business, fairly and evenly, and that's what we're trying to do. To the extent that Michael wants to come in and look at what we're doing and have experts from out of town look at what we're doing, that's perfectly fair and perfectly fine. There may be somebody out there who can explain to us how we could do a better job of what we're trying to do.
17:59 And we should welcome that kind of input. I certainly would. Because if we can find a way to make the MLT more effective and do a better job for Mammoth, hallelujah, that's what we're here for. So I just wanted to throw that out for your consideration. Thank you. Thank you, Paul. Any other public comment? Seeing none, we will move on to Councilmember reports. Colin, could he start with you tonight? Sure, thank you.
18:32 We did reach an agreement.
19:03 With their employees, which was very positive. And just coming, what is relevant to the Mammoth community is just some pushes from us in regards to the transit service in our community. We're trying to continue to work with ESTA to improve in a couple of areas. I think ESTA's done a pretty fantastic job to this point. But there's a couple of areas I'd personally like to see improved.
19:32 And our town staff and MLT are in talks with ESTA about increasing service during our peak events. We've had some issues this summer where they've just been overwhelmed by the volume of people we've had coming up to the Village for the Fourth of July fireworks and Village Fest and those type of events. So really looking to plan for the future for how we can appropriately address all of our local and guest needs with the transit.
20:01 We are in a test period right now with adding a third bus certain weekends to the Lake Mary bike route. The issue up there has not really been capacity of visitors. It's more been the bike racks. So there's been some significant wait times for people that just want to get on with a bike. So we're going to kind of test that and see how that third trolley helps out with that situation.
20:29 And the last piece that we discussed was really trying to get NextBus functioning properly. The money that was provided to them has been expended, but, you know, I've experienced and heard throughout the community that there are some areas that we need to work on with that. So those are some things we provided to the board, and we'll have more update on that. I don't know if you have anything else to add, Michael. Sure. Do you want me to go next? Sure. Okay.
20:57 Yeah, just to follow up with what Colin had said about our estimating, one quick note, Memorial Weekend Ridership to Reds Meadow was up 35% over last year, so we saw a significant increase. You already touched base about adding a third trolley. We did that for three weekends, and we improved frequency to every 20 minutes, and we're looking at adding a third trolley with trailers.
21:24 for next summer, and I support, hope that we all support doing that and making that happen. And on the trolley basis down to Lakes Basin, it's set to end September 14th, and I raise the question to look to add the trolley services for one more week for the following weekend since we have kamikaze bike games coming in, and hopefully we can look at achieving, adding that with all the riders coming into town.
21:49 He already touched on the issues with special events. We're going to work on that as well to better provide service to accommodate the crowds. Also, I attended an MLT meeting. Our Las Vegas flight has been confirmed and is now booked, not booked, loaded into Alaska's system. So you can book that online. Those flights start January 15th.
22:12 They run Monday and Thursdays. There's an introductory fare for $59 one way, so it's really affordable, and you can book those now. And lastly, the winter air pack, this kind of air pack program that we launched should go on sale in October, and this year it's going to include Los Angeles, San Diego, and Las Vegas. So hopefully we'll be announcing the pricing on that very shortly. That's all I have. Thank you, Michael. Shields.
22:42 Yeah, that sounds really exciting, Michael. It does. I hope that people can afford coming back. $59 run away. Well, if you've already purchased your ticket. All right, good point, good point. Okay, I attended the TOT Task Force meeting yesterday morning, and it was my first meeting that I attended for the task force. And I want to give props to Dan Izzo and his crew.
23:11 You know, in running a business, you want to know where you are financially so you can make decisions. He and his crew are making that happen. And from the people that have been going to these meetings, they were very excited that, you know, some things are actually happening where they are getting good information, information that they can count on. So I'm really excited that this group is doing the job that they are.
23:40 And I'm excited to be a part of it and look forward to being able to bring some information forward in hopefully the near future that we know exactly where we are financially. Thank you, Shields. John? Thank you, Madam Mayor, fellow council members. I've been busy working a lot of things that will be bearing some fruit here for the communities and for your advisement.
24:09 In the near future, some regional issues, I think some recreation concerns, I think tied into the forest plan revision. The annual forest plan revision is, I'm assuming they're working along, there were supposed to be some documents and some maps and some things coming forward, nothing's come forward so far. They have announced a meeting on September 18th, which will tie in with the notice of intent, the beginning, the initiation of the NEPA process for the forest plan revision.
24:37 And this is something that this community, everybody in this region is going to have a very important voice in that process. I'm looking forward to getting to that when that comes forward. The SNC board meeting is having a, the board is meeting up in Bridgeport, the first part of September. And I'll hold off on any future things until we've got some more concrete things to talk about. So thank you. Okay. Thank you, John. Dana covers most of the MLR news that I was going to pass along, but I did want to let you know that
25:05 Terry Stelick and I are continuing to work with Dan Holler on the reconciliation of Measure R, and that will be on the September 3rd agenda. We'll have that piece done. Next up would be reports from commissions or departments, and does Stuart want to go first? Since everybody says he's distracting everyone. He's not hearing me, so go ahead, Grady.
25:33 Thank you, Grady Dutton, Public Works. I just want to give you a quick update on the Lower Canyon Project. We finished all but the last lift of paving on the south side of the street. We're working on the north side now. Almost all the curb and gutter is already complete and preparing to put in the sidewalk.
25:49 Overall, it's gone very well. I'd say with just a couple of minor exceptions, the homeowners there have worked with us and actually looked forward to what we're doing there. We've gotten some good compliments. So it's going very well and should still be complete towards the end of September, early October. Madam Mayor, Grady, could you give an update on some of your post-Labor Day projects? The Waterford...
26:14 Project perhaps, maybe in others that are going to be racing the gun against that first big blizzard that's going to happen in the first week of October. Actually on Waterford Bridge Project, the first subcontral will be out on site on Monday.
26:26 Doing some of the foundations for the piers out in the middle of that project. So it will start on Monday. The majority of the work will start about two weeks after that. And we're still very confident that will be done in time. On the bluffs, we actually put it off for about 10 days because, again, looking at the asphalt and looking at a surveying issue, we need to...
26:46 Schedule putting in the monuments when we're done with that. But that also will be complete. The actual work itself will only take about three days. So again, towards the end of September, we still expect to complete that one as well. Thank you. We had a question on the canyon project. I didn't see any tubes out there for geothermal for the sidewalk. Is that not part of the plan or is the project? No. In fact, we're working from Hillside Drive.
27:13 Still to the west, and there isn't any of that in that area. For the portion down below anywhere we're disturbing the sidewalks where there's already tubes, we'll take care of that, but there aren't any additional being added that I'm aware of. Nothing's going in the entire project. It's really just on the south end, or excuse me, on the very lower portion where they're already in place.
27:32 They'll be there. I was thinking that we were doing that, you know, in all new projects for future. No, due to the cost. Yeah. Okay. Thanks. And we did just one other mention on the canyon project. Myself and Hayes, the engineer, were out just earlier this week looking at that crosswalk situation, and it's...
27:51 It's going to be tough to fix, very frankly, because the biggest issue is the bus locations. But we're looking at a couple of options on that, and hopefully we will be able to include some improvements there in this project. The crosswalk right now happens to be between where three buses park, and it's just very difficult to get pedestrians out on the road between buses in the winter and do it safely. So we are looking at some options on that, and we should be able to report back at our next meeting. Thank you, Craig. Dan.
28:25 Honorable Mayor, members of council, just two items I'd like to bring to your attention. The council on June 4th did allow the Mono County investment pool to be added to our policy. We have reviewed, me and Dan Holler have reviewed all the information for the past year on our cash flow. We've reviewed all their information from Mono County investment pool for a year also.
28:49 We are at this point in time moving approximately, well, $3 million from the LAF fund, which is the state investment fund, into that Mono County. We're in the process of moving that right now, probably moved by this Friday. Again, the reason we're doing that is they're 50 basis points above LAF, and we're going to earn additional interest income from that point. Now, we're only moving $3 million. Why? Because we are leaving enough in LAF to handle the day-to-day transactions that we already have.
29:18 For payroll, deposits, expenses. The remaining monies in LAFCO will be sufficient to handle everything for the year. The $3 million really is an investment type. It will be put in one, that sold dollar amount will pull the interest off it during the year. The second item.
29:35 Is the RFP for IT. That has been completed. It's about 47 pages long. We are going to be advertising that in the very near future and we are already sending that to the vendors that could be responding that provide services in this area. The schedule we're looking at is advertising for the 30 days. The third week is September. Then during October we'll take questions and we'll have demonstrations given to us. Hopefully
30:04 By the first meeting or second meeting of November, we will bring it to you for a recommendation on who is the winner. Hopefully by December 1st, the city or town attorney will go ahead and make the contract. Seven months from there, July 1, 2015, we hope to have an implemented system and then run parallel for a quarter for three months. That's the basic schedule that we're looking at right now for the RFP to replace all IT.
30:33 Applications that is used by finance, used for public works in regards to project management, used for building and planning for their permit issuance. So it's going to replace every application we own, trying to bring this up to the 21st century. But that's what's on the schedule right now, and we're moving forward on that. In regards to the earlier discussion regarding
30:54 The amount of money is coming in from TOT. Just so you – and it's being put on the website as we speak. It's been shared with the TOT committee, with Dan Holler, is that we – for the month of June alone, June 2014 is 32 percent higher than June 2014. So, yeah, there is a significant change in the amount of money earned during summer. We can't give you the July figures yet because they're not due until tomorrow. But –
31:21 Jim did show that much of a change from the previous year. That's all I have. Any questions? Go ahead. Dan, a couple of quick questions. I'm assuming the risk exposure in Mono County is similar to where the funds are currently invested? Can you give me that again? Well, the $3 million you transfer into Mono County, the risk exposure, that kind of stuff, is the same? I can tell you what they told me. They are 100% covered.
31:49 And, you know, dollar for dollar, every dollar we put in there is 100 percent covered. It's not FDIC at 250. Right. It's 100 percent. Right. There's no doubt Lafe has more security than mono. But, again, mono meets all our requirements completely. Lafe is about triple. Okay. They – every dollar is covered by about three more dollars. So that's the difference between – it's a higher level of security. But, again, I don't believe there's any risk in putting the money in mono. Okay.
32:15 And the RFP, this is for the financial system, correct? This is replacing all financial systems of the city.
32:21 And including in that is project management and including in that is the replacement of the permit issuance. We're looking at all applications right now to replace everything we own to bring us up to the 21st century. Okay. And the relationship of that to the contract that we have for Mono County IT, is it they're not, they're two different things. Correct. This is the financial side of the house. It's not something that they would be coordinating with us on the implementation. And that's the Mono County contract, that's a whole different scope in dealing with this? Okay.
32:48 Modern County basically is preventing our hardware and connectivity to all facilities. That's their job. The applications is what we, the end users, are going to be using. They're in charge of the other side. Got it. Okay. Thank you very much. All right. Anything else? All right. Thanks, Dan. Mayor, Councilmembers, good evening. Just a quick update on the personnel and risk management side of the House.
33:15 We have just hired a new revenue specialist as well as a new permit tech. The permit tech is relocating from down south. They're going to be starting in the next month. The revenue specialist is starting on Monday. They're going to be helping out with TOT enforcement. I'm also hitting the ground running with the police chief recruitment. By Friday, I should have everything posted on all the different advertising websites we're planning on doing. I'm going to be advertising in the local newspapers for Labor Day weekend in case any visiting police chiefs.
33:45 As well as one of the police officers may be retiring in the fall and we may have open recruitment for police officers as well. Additionally, I'm in the process of updating some of our administrative policies. Many of them I think were written with a typewriter. Easy now.
34:04 So we're going to bring them up to the 21st century, to use Dan's quote. And additionally, this week, tomorrow actually, we're having a meeting with a consultant to begin the process for a compensation and classification study. The goal is to complete it by the end of the year, give or take. And we're going to be holding meetings starting tomorrow with representatives from every employee association. My personal goal for this process
34:31 Is to ensure that it's collaborative, inclusive, and transparent. Any questions? Sorry. Go ahead. Just on the last side, what is the deliverable coming out of that effort that you're talking about at the end? So we're comparing our compensation schedule of all of our different positions to about 10 different cities. Okay. And we're going to look at where we lay on that chart. And that, there'll be deliverable coming out of that, that'll be publicly available at some point? Yes. Okay, thank you. Thank you, Sarah.
35:13 Evening Mayor Bacon, Councillors, Public, I have a few items to present to Council this evening, those being a couple of short videos for your viewing pleasure. But before I do, I really want to thank certainly the Mayor, the entire Council, Councillors Fernie and Richardson for joining us on the dunk tank. Thank you. We sold more dunk tanks than water that evening, thanks to you both, so congratulations.
35:39 But I do want to thank, obviously, the entire council, our sponsors, our booth vendors, our donors, our cupcake donors, supporters, and certainly the public for helping us celebrate the town's 30th anniversary on August 15th at Shady Rose Park. Hope we all had a great time. This evening I have a couple of short videos. The first is right here. It's really a recap of the Mammoth Half Marathon that was held in June.
36:07 We had, well, they had just over 1,500 people, I believe. It was a proclamation brought to council in the last meeting. This is just a short video of everyone's excitement. So I'm just going to run that. It's a little bit ghetto, this whole setup here, so we'll see how we do. And then the second video is just a short compilation of a day in the life of a summer camper, and that was put together by a recreation supervisor, John Connolly, but I'll obviously stop.
36:36 Before we move on to that one. So I'm not just sure how the lights are going. So what do you guys think? Are you guys going to be able to see that? Do you want us to turn? Turn some more. Oh, there we go. Perfect. Did you turn them back on too? Okay. Yeah, I feel like chariots of fire. That was perfect. I'm not too sure it was actually supposed to be that slow. But Andrew tells me the winning time was just around an hour 10 for the half marathon. So pretty quick. The next little movie to the 80s theme.
39:42 Carrying on our tradition here in 1984. We've got a couple of videos. So this year what we did, just for the benefit of the public, we worked with Sierra Wave and we had a little 30-second promo run as well. That's been running on Sierra Wave all summer. That's on the home page of our recreation site here. We also have a movie compilation of a day in the life of a summer camper. And then we also have a short video on our very popular Wave Wave skateboard camp. So if you really want to jump in and see what we do.
40:15 We invite you to jump on our website, mammothrecreation.com. So this video here is a compilation and a day in the life of, put together by Recreation Supervisor John Connolly. Hopefully you'll recognise the music. Great. Just so you know, you're not too old for summer camp. So if you had a good time watching that video, we can squeeze you in. Always looking for some good counsellors. Just to...
42:49 Give you some highlights for summer. We're obviously collating all this information right now. We'll present to the Recreation Commission shortly and then be back to the council with a larger overview. But just really quickly in summer highlights, we offered 23 summer camps. We had over 350 participants, 150-plus swim lesson participants down at the Whitmore Pool, 23 summer softball league teams. They're playing right now. They have playoffs next week. So if you want to get out there and support our local teams, we'll have barbecues running Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday next week.
43:19 We had four adult soccer league teams. We've had over 4,000 plus visits at the pool, about 300 visits at the rec zone, and we had 29 little sluggers playing in the springtime. The other programs we've got going this year is tennis lessons, dropping tennis lessons with Kyle at the community centre. He's done a lot of privates as well. Gymnastics has obviously been super popular. We also introduced a free mountain parkour course and peak bagging from Dave Titus and adult dodgeball.
43:48 He's coming back to the rec zone this fall. A few housekeeping items. The Show Boat Youth Theatre performances are Friday and Saturday. Friday is the Mammoth Lakes Arts Centre, and that is Free to Be a Family at 7, and then Mamma Mia is on Saturday, the 23rd. The Whitmore Pool closes for recreation swimming this Saturday, but lap swim is still available through September 5th for the lap swimmers out there.
44:14 We talked about dodgeball. That starts on September 3rd. Team fees are only $84, so it's a very affordable program. We just want to kind of get some folks out there and inspired about dodgeball at the rec zone. It should be fun. It'll be under lights with music. And that's all I had. Drop-in tennis lessons, as we talked about, continue through September 11 as well. Everything's on mammothrecreation.com, and I've probably spent more than enough time here at the Dyers.
44:39 Just a question for you. Did you say that the open swimming at Whitmore ends before Labor Day? Lap swimming continues through September 5th, so we close after Labor Day. Thank you. We also do a lot of special events and groups down there as well through those periods of time. One quick question for Stuart. Stuart, are you tracking the calendar of your programming in terms of the summer season for visitation? Are you finding any things where you're
45:08 Starting too early, ending too early, starting too late. Are you sort of tracking how you're syncing up with the visitation that's happening with these very big summers that we've been having? We'll be looking at that. We'll drill down some statistics and probably pull some of that out, but our calendar is really tight when school gets out. We start straight away that probably day of, and then we finish. Actually, we're still going while the kids are back in school, so our window is really short.
45:32 What we did notice a lot this year with the web-based system is a lot of our camps sold out a long time in advance than previously before. And most of our camps, if not all of them, had waiting lists. So we're really at a problem where we have more demand than supply, so we're going to be looking at how we can get more kids in our programs, introduce more programs, slip them up, things like that. Yeah, I think going forward as summer, it's one of the priorities we've got on our list is to start really getting all these things tied together. Yeah, I appreciate some.
46:01 Yeah, and possibly looking at starting a little earlier with the school schedules changing. We'd love the school schedule to change if you want to talk about it. Probably not right now. Might be beyond our purview. Thank you very much. Just a quick comment, if I may. Sounds like a good problem to have, so that's good news. I just wanted to comment real briefly. I did run the half marathon after training for about a week.
46:30 And as a runner I've run multiple marathons and half marathons and the thing that I thought was shocking in addition to how much my quads hurt for a few days was there were tons and tons of people during the race that actually pulled off in the middle of the race to take photos. And granted I wasn't running a 110 for the half marathon but the group of people I was surrounded by
46:57 I've never seen that before where people were just so compelled by the beauty that they were in that they had to actually stop in the middle of the race to take a photo. Usually people wait until the end. So that was a really cool thing for me to see, especially up in the lake space and there were a lot of people just pulling over to the side of the road and snapping pictures and then jumping back in. So that was pretty cool. Excuse for a break.
47:18 Yeah. I do want to say, if I can, Mayor, it hasn't been touched on this weekend, but the Vulcan Brothers Skateboard Wave Rave competition is on Sunday at the Vulcan Brothers Skatepark. That's August 23rd. And then another big event coming up, we're talking about the half marathon, is the 4th Century Gran Fondo. That's 5th and 6th of September. So there'll be 1,500, 2,000 plus cyclists around the area. So another big weekend. And summer keeps going. Thank you. Thank you.
47:48 Any other departments or commissions? Are you ready, Deanna? Yes. Next up, we have a presentation from Deanna Doolin, Superintendent of Devil's Postpile National Monument, regarding the Preferred Alternative for General Management Plan. Thank you, everyone, Town Council members and audience here, for this opportunity to finally bring to you our draft Preferred Alternative for the Devil's Postpile General Management Plan.
48:37 As some of you may recall, we did start this process five years ago in 2009 with scoping and outreach and gathering of issues and sharing our ideas about the purpose and significance and value of Doubles Postpile National Monument. And we really appreciate the tremendous amount of support we've gotten from the town of Mammoth Lakes, both during this process but also in our ongoing
49:04 Continuing providing services to our visitors and our gateway community residents here. And just a quick aside, we sure love how you guys plow the road down to Red's Meadow for us every June or every May when we need to get down there and get ready to open. So kind of in that spirit of a long-term ongoing partnership, we're really excited to share our draft preferred alternative with you tonight and share a couple little statistics along the way too.
49:32 Amanda Kaplan is our project manager and she'll be providing the substance to the presentation. But I also wanted to kind of draw a little attention to today is Founders Day, which celebrates the beginning of the idea of the National Park Service. And throughout our country now we have 401 National Park Service units.
49:55 But although I'm a little biased, I do think Devil's Postpile is one of the best. It's the green gem on the other side of the mountain, and I really am very excited to be part of working at Devil's Postpile National Monument and working here with the community. So at Devil's Postpile National Monument, we host about 100,000 visitors a year between June and mid-October, and as you know, snow's often closed the road. And the park service, we recognize that
50:24 We really are in partnership with our gateway communities that you all provide services to the visitors who come to visit us. And so in order to kind of recognize that kind of give and take that we share in taking care of our visitors, the Park Service has done a money generation model of the projected revenue that our 100,000 visitors bring to the gateway communities and that would be in particular Town of Mammoth Lakes.
50:53 The projection for 2012, I did put a press release out, March 3, 2014, the university analyzed this, and their projection is that Devil's Post-Portal National Movement brings over $5 million to the town of Mammoth Lakes and generates 65 local jobs. And that was our 2012 statistics. So, anyway, kind of on that note of our shared value of the ecotourism,
51:22 And the clean green energy that Devil's Postpile provides to the local economy and also the joy that we all see in our visitors happy. We're going to launch our delivery of what we see as the draft preferred alternative and we welcome your comments.
51:40 I'm going to let Amanda Kaplan, who's been working diligently on this project for five years. I did mention it's a five-year process. We did have a little hiatus there when we had a little windstorm come in in 2011 in November. It took us about two years to kind of get things back to normal so we could proceed on this plan, but it's just the right time to bring this to you here today on the anniversary of the Founder's Day of the National Park Service.
52:07 Thank you, Deanna. Thank you, everyone. So as Deanna mentioned, the goal of our presentation today is to introduce you to the draft general management plan that we've prepared for Devil's Post-Powl National Monument. We'll start with a brief overview of the monument just to provide some context for the planning effort. We'll talk briefly about general management planning in the National Park Service so you understand what the general management plan is intended to do. And then we'll present some of the highlights and key recommendations of the preferred alternative.
52:36 In the draft plan for Devil's Postpile. And lastly, we'll end with talking about how people can engage in the remainder of the planning process.
52:47 Devil's Postpile was established by Presidential Proclamation in 1911, so as many of you know, the monument is a little over 100 years old, and many of you participated in the centennial celebrations not too long ago, and the purpose of Devil's Postpile is to preserve and protect the glacially exposed columns of the Devil's Postpile, the scenic Rainbow Falls, and the wilderness landscape of the upper middle fork of the San Joaquin River here in the Sierras for scientific value, public interest, and inspiration.
53:18 Realizing that many of you are familiar with the monument, but just some key facts to highlight that, again, provide a little bit of the setting or the backdrop for planning for Devil's Post Pile. It is approximately an 800-acre national monument, and it is rectangular in shape, and the monument is completely surrounded by the Inyo National Forest, and the image on the bottom shows the monument outlined in white, completely surrounded by the Inyo.
53:43 Eighty-five percent of the monument is designated wilderness. It's part of the Insel Adams Wilderness, and it is actually the gateway to over two million acres of wilderness and a much larger recreational experience here in the Sierra, providing many front country services to those wilderness travelers.
54:01 Sections of both the John Muir Trail and Pacific Crest Trail, which are both internationally recognized trails, go through the monument, and it's often the entry and exit point and or exit point for many of those JMT and PCT users. There are also numerous trail connections down in the valley that link up here with the extensive trail system in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
54:22 Road access, as Deanna mentioned, is typically mid-May through October in those heavy snows that you experience, forced winter road closures, but those shoulder seasons have really been fluctuating a lot in recent years. The monument does collaborate with the Inyo National Forest on a shuttle system, which runs during the peak season, which is typically mid-June through Labor Day weekend, and it's actually the longest-running mandatory shuttle system on public lands in the country.
54:50 Average annual visitation, as Deanna mentioned, is about 100,000 visitors, which given that relatively short operating season is a pretty significant visitation number. And that money generation model does show that the monument is a significant contributor to the local economy, specifically here in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
55:12 General management plans. So what is a general management plan? General management plans are broad, long-range programmatic plans that essentially serve as a blueprint that the National Park Service intends to follow in managing the monument for about the next 15 to 20 years. They are required by law. It's the National Parks and Recreation Act of 1978 that requires the Park Service to have a comprehensive plan for every unit in the national park system. And essentially the GMP answers the question,
55:40 What kind of place do we want this park to be? So the GMP articulates desired conditions for both natural and cultural resources that we protect. It will help guide future decisions about levels and types of visitor activities and experiences that we want our visitors to have provided to them. And GMPs also evaluate the facilities and infrastructure that should be developed to support both visitors and park operations.
56:07 Because the GMPs tend to set broad direction, future implementation planning often occurs for specific recommendations and that implementation planning tiers from that direction provided in the general management plan. Everything that is in the plan has to be consistent with the purpose and significance of the monument and also consistent with the Organic Act for the National Park Service.
56:29 GMPs also have to comply with the National Environmental Policy Act, or NEPA, and so we've provided and prepared an environmental assessment to support the general management plan for Devil's Post Pile. Devil's Post Pile and the Inyo National Forest collaborate on a number of operational issues in addition to the shuttle operation. They jointly staff the check station there at Minaret Vista.
56:54 The monument actually helped fund the interpretive panels that you see in the bottom left image. That's the viewpoint and overlook at Minaret Vista, which is Forest Service land, but we were able to work together collaboratively and provide some interpretive panels there. And the two agencies also co-locate their headquarters together here in the town of Mammoth Lakes over by the Mammoth Welcome Center. So with the GMP, we really took that history of collaboration at the operational level and really elevated it to planning for the future.
57:23 So the Inyo National Forest is actually a cooperating agency under NEPA on the plan in EA. And early on in the process, we developed a memorandum of understanding between the two agencies really specific to this general management planning process. So we really had an interagency team working on this project from the very beginning.
57:42 Working together has really given us the flexibility to look at both issues and opportunities at really the appropriate scale of planning. You see there from the map on the right that it really is a single and an integrated visitor experience from Minaret Vista down through the valley. And so by working together we've been able to find opportunities for operational efficiency and also really develop a shared vision for the future for the experience down there.
58:08 With this interagency team, the GMP also includes some recommendations for the Inyo National Forest that really evolved out of this collaborative effort and the many conversations we had and really were formulated to complement the proposed actions in the general management plan that the monument would undertake.
58:26 So it is important to just point out and note that these really are just recommendations. In actual implementation, we'd be dependent on the Forest Service choosing to adopt some of those recommendations through their own planning and decision-making processes. This next slide highlights the general management
58:47 Planning process that we followed as well as some of the formal opportunities for public involvement that have been available throughout the planning process. As Deanna mentioned, we started this project back in 2009 and conducted our initial projects.
59:00 Project scoping at that point, looking to seek input in terms of goals and issues that needed to be addressed in the plan. We then developed preliminary alternatives for the planning process and really consciously timed the review of those initial alternatives before we had a preferred alternative.
59:17 To be delivered to the public around the centennial. We knew that with the centennial celebration there would be a lot of additional attention on the monument. We thought that was a wonderful opportunity to sort of gather input into some of the initial ideas we had.
59:32 For the general management plan. We then went back and as Deanna mentioned there was a little windstorm that happened in there. We also spent a lot of time revising and refining the alternatives, completing all the environmental analysis necessary to support the planning document and went through our own internal agency reviews and policy checks. And so now we are here in 2014 with the complete draft.
59:58 General Management Plan and Environmental Assessment and we're seeking public involvement on the complete document at this time which now includes the identification of a preferred alternative.
1:00:08 And just to highlight for you, we've prepared two documents. We have the complete draft plan and environmental assessment, and we've also prepared a newsletter. We've done a number of newsletters through the process. And what this newsletter essentially does is provide the executive summary of the document, recognizing that a lot of people don't have time to comb through the entire document, but we want to make sure that the information is really accessible to people. So we also prepared an executive summary newsletter for broad distribution.
1:00:37 Both of those documents are available online electronically. The website is posted both in the newsletter and the document, and it will also be available at the end of the presentation. Before we talk about specific alternatives and the preferred alternative, there are a number of topics that we addressed in the general management plan, but the recommendations were really common to all alternatives, so I won't spend a lot of time talking about them during the presentation, but did want to mention them briefly just so people don't feel like we missed something in the planning process.
1:01:09 Natural and cultural resource management as well as science and research would continue to be a high priority in the monument. The monument would continue to monitor and respond to the effects of climate change and really work to improve sustainability in park operations. The general range of visitor activities will also be maintained. There are no activities that are currently available that would be discontinued through the planning process.
1:01:34 We would also work with the Inyo National Forest to maintain the mandatory shuttle system that exists during the peak season and there is no additional road access that is being proposed down into the valley. We would also continue to coordinate and collaborate with the Inyo and other partners for managing both resources and visitors down in the valley. Also common to all alternatives is continued partnering with traditionally associated American Indian tribes and groups to further educational opportunities for tribal youth.
1:02:07 To expand preservation activities and interpretation of cultural connections with the park, and also develop opportunities for traditional and non-recreational access in public youth. And the photos below highlight one of the programs that the monument is really proud of. It's called the First Bloom Project, and it began in 2009 as a partnership that really focused on native plants.
1:02:29 National Park Stewardship, and it's sustained every year since then due to both the commitment of tribal partners as well as the park service. So it's really a model that we hope to sustain into the future.
1:02:43 So now moving on to the general management plan alternatives. We developed three alternatives for the general management plan that we really feel is a reasonable range of alternatives given the scale of the planning area and also comments we received throughout the public involvement processes that we've done thus far that really focused on not changing too much, not over planning the area and not making a planning process any more complicated than it needs to be.
1:03:08 So I briefly want to mention the no action alternative, which is alternative A, and it outlines the continuation of current management, and it's an alternative that's actually required by the NEPA process and really serves as a baseline for comparison of the relative impacts and merits of the different alternatives.
1:03:26 The concept for Alternative B is to place greater emphasis on managing and promoting visitor understanding of the monument within the context of the larger watershed, and the focus in this alternative really is on Minaret Vista as a primary destination for telling the story of the watershed and the role of the monument within that watershed.
1:03:45 Alternative C, which we call Connecting People to Nature and Heritage, is our preferred alternative, and it highlights in that alternative that we'll focus on for the remainder of the presentation. Before I move to that, though, I just want to point out that a lot of the differences between Alternative B and Alternative C are actually subtle in some places, and they tend to focus more on some of the proposals that we have for specific facility recommendations rather than a radical change in management.
1:04:17 So the concept behind the preferred alternative is that it really emphasizes key features with national significance for resource protection and connecting visitors with nature and heritage. And heritage really being more inclusive of the human history of the area and encouraging us to connect visitors with more than just the geology and waterfalls that we're so known for.
1:04:37 The monument and the corridor from Minaret Vista down through Reds Meadow Valley would be managed as a gateway to a greater wilderness, providing those really time-honored and traditional park experiences along the way. An additional emphasis would be placed on partnerships with the Indian National Forest and the community here in Mammoth Lakes. So the theme of...
1:05:04 The preferred alternative with respect to facilities is really trying to limit development down in the valley. We need to meet the needs of both the public and our own staff, but we really want to try to emphasize and focus on cleaning up what we already have, especially the facilities that people really like and are attached to, rather than overdeveloping the area. And this idea is really consistent with what we heard from public comments throughout the process.
1:05:30 So in the preferred alternative, we propose maintaining the existing ranger station in the monument. It's the image on the top right there with some modest improvements to it, such as expanding the exterior deck space for better circulation, potentially adding a service window where you could have a ranger on the inside speaking to more visitors on the outside. And the reality is this is a really small building that's trying to do a lot of things and serve a lot of people down there. But we really think additional exterior space, especially with the
1:05:59 Good weather that is typically available throughout most of the operating season will help improve access, including ADA access in and around that building. The preferred alternative does focus on increasing depot's presence and the National Park Service presence in the town of Mammoth Lakes as a way to solve some real issues while still helping us limit that development footprint in the valley.
1:06:22 So through the preferred alternative, we recommend expanding our presence here in town, preferably on the Inyo National Forest, to try to really reach more visitors, particularly those visitors who are here during the shoulder and winter seasons when access to the monument is difficult. But there are both visitors and community members here, and especially school groups, who have an interest in the monument and around and available. But as time moves on through the calendar, that access to the monument itself can be difficult.
1:06:52 So the priority would be for us to lease additional space in town versus new construction. And we're really seeing that area around the Forest Service campus there and around the Mammoth Welcome Center as really being more of an all-inclusive hub of information and activity.
1:07:10 I think it's also important to note that the monument has long identified a need for a better maintenance building, and through this process, we are proposing a joint interagency maintenance building down in the valley, preferably on an already disturbed location, on forest land.
1:07:26 Forest Service land that would allow us both to be sited on land that would be out of the floodplain, which is really hard to do in the limited development area space we have in the monument, and also allow us to really minimize any scenic or visual impacts from a new structure down there in the valley.
1:07:47 The general management plan also does propose maintaining the campground down there in the monument for overnight camping, but we do include a recommendation for a site plan for redesigning the campground and the day use area.
1:08:01 This would likely be an implementation plan, one of those implementation plans where the actual design drawings would be completed in the future, but we have some very specific recommendations in the GMP that we're looking for, such as removing some of the drive-in campsites and parking that are really close to the river and almost on the riverbank, and that will help us address some resource impacts and riparian concerns that we have, and also really help to improve the riverfront day use and experience. So instead of that...
1:08:30 Riverfront area feeling like you're in the backyard of someone's campground in more of a private area, making that much more publicly accessible. We would also look at converting some of those sites to walk-in sites versus drive-in sites and really trying to separate those types of uses in the campground, walk-in users versus drive-in users.
1:08:50 We also propose fixing the circulation and parking around the campground, the day use area, the ranger station, and the administrative area to improve the overall experience and fix some of the congestion that's down there, especially with the large buses that come in and offload large numbers of people and unload large numbers of people. It can be pretty crowded down there, but we think we have some room there to just make some improvements through enhanced site planning.
1:09:20 We're also looking at some improvements to several viewing areas. At the post pile itself, we're looking to reconfigure some of the interpretive panels to alleviate some of the congestion in the viewing area at the base there. And also really work to improve the ADA viewing experience. We, through the preferred alternative, are recommending evaluating, making the trail to the post pile from the ranger station ADA accessible. And if we can't actually meet those ADA standards, we would be sure to provide some kind of alternative ADA experience down there.
1:09:50 We would also look to implement some more formal resource protection measures for monitoring the glacial polish that's at the top of the post pile there that so many people value and appreciate. Also for Minaret Vista, Minaret Vista, as you know, is just one of the best, most accessible views in all of the Sierra. You can see into the monument, you see into Yosemite, you really get that sense of the watershed and where you are with the west side versus the east side influences.
1:10:20 So the preferred alternative provides some recommendations for really better integrating that experience at Minaret Vista with the rest of the experience in the valley. We're not looking at any kind of staffed visitor contact facility there. It's under heavy snow for a large part of the year. Really the emphasis is more primarily on a self-guided experience with improved exterior exhibits that really could also provide a key staging or gathering area for
1:10:45 Improved interpretive or educational programs that you might want to have or include there. We also recommend some improvements for the site design at Minaret Vista, such as separating the parking that's right there on the edge of the overlook from the viewing areas and redesigning that parking and restroom placement.
1:11:03 Also looking at including an ADA interpretive trail. There are some really great potential trail alignments that the team has walked up there on numerous occasions. And also considering adding a shuttle stop at Minaret Vista. It's possible that it could become shuttle stop number one on that shuttle route. Currently there is no transit connection there to Minaret Vista.
1:11:27 Rainbow Falls, as many of you know, Rainbow Falls is a key destination for many visitors to the valley and to the monument, and it is actually in designated wilderness. The levels of visitation can be high there on peak weekends, but we have really current user capacity studies and research to show that we aren't actually exceeding the overall carrying capacity of the area. So the preferred alternative does still seek to improve some of the...
1:11:50 So we would maintain the existing trail alignment to provide for the current capacity, but really strive to soften the trail design and the edges of the trails to really be more compatible with a wilderness trail design.
1:12:09 We would also look at maintaining the viewing platforms that are there but look at removing potential development that doesn't really need to be there within the wilderness boundary such as considering relocating some of the interpretive panels that are there just outside the wilderness boundary. We also do propose maintaining the equestrian use to the area including the commercial day rides that are currently managed under permit with the Inyo National Forest at their current levels.
1:12:38 Also through the general management planning process, there was a previous wild and scenic river eligibility study that had been done for the entire reach of the river through the watershed, so spanning both the Forest Service and Park Service lands. With the general management plan, we updated the wild and scenic river eligibility study with current information and also completed suitability, which is the other half of that equation, for the stretch of the river that is included within Devil's Postpile National Monument.
1:13:06 The middle fork of the San Joaquin River is one of the few remaining completely free-flowing high Sierra rivers, and man-made intrusions along the river are really minimal.
1:13:17 So based on public comments that we've received throughout the general management planning process, we believe that the entire stretch of the river within the monument itself is suitable for wild and scenic river designation, so we'll be including that recommendation in the preferred alternative. It is, however, important to note that actual designation requires an act of Congress.
1:13:42 General management plans are actually also required by law to look at the adequacy of a park's boundary for resource protection critical to park purpose and also to address operational and management issues. So there is a boundary adjustment that's proposed in the preferred alternative that we've actually developed in very close collaboration with the Inyo National Forest. And I'm sorry, the colors on the image here on the screen are not quite as crisp and clear as they are in the document.
1:14:08 The adjustment that we're proposing primarily accomplishes including more of the actual post pile formation, specifically the summit of the post pile, within the monument boundary, as well as the trail that connects Devil's Post Pile and Rainbow Falls, two key features that are called out in our enabling legislation, and bringing that trail connection all within the National Park Service boundary.
1:14:33 It's important to note the monument would continue to provide access on the trails within this area as they're really part of an extensive trail network and system that supports many popular visitor activities and really provides important access to a much larger landscape and recreation experience beyond the monument.
1:14:51 The boundary adjustment in total is approximately 275 acres, and it is a proposal that the Indian National Forest finds acceptable to advance in the general management plan. They recognize it supports our needs, some real operational and management concerns that we have, in addition to simply our requirement to look at this issue and study this issue in the GMP process.
1:15:12 And they really feel it adequately addresses some of the concerns they've raised throughout the process. Specifically, their concerns about not having the boundary adjustment take in too many of the specific facilities that they have. So there's actually a little call-out bubble there around a water tank that they're concerned about. So we've worked very closely with them on this proposal. Similar to the Wild and Scenic River, in the general management plan, we can recommend a boundary adjustment, but the actual change in boundary itself would require congressional legislation.
1:15:46 So with that, we're very interested in public comments and feedback at this point, and there are multiple ways that people can provide us with their thoughts and ideas. We do have a website. The website address is available here, and the website is actually our preferred method for people to comment. The documents are available online, and there is also
1:16:07 A mechanism through which you can simply enter your comments online. There are three questions to guide you through the comment process. And you can simply right there from the website enter your comments.
1:16:17 You can also write a letter to the superintendent. The address is in the document as well as the newsletter. A very conventional letter to the superintendent is perfectly acceptable. We actually just concluded an open house over at the library with three hours of good discussion. And for those people who missed the open house at the library, Deanna and her staff will also be doing tabling sessions.
1:16:40 in the monument throughout the rest of the season. And that's also part of our goal to really capture sort of that average visitor that's just passing through who might not, you know, get the information to come to an open house at the town library. But those are still very important visitors to us and their ideas are equally important.
1:16:58 The comment period ends September 30th, so it began August 1st, and we will formally conclude that comment period September 30th, and after that we'll be working very diligently to review all the comments we receive, make any necessary changes to the document, and our goal is to have the document complete by the end of the calendar year. And with that, that concludes our presentation, and we're welcome to any comments or questions you may have. Do you have any, John?
1:17:30 I know you do. I do, actually. I'll try to be brief, unless council members have something else I'd like to lead with, but I've got a couple. Amanda, welcome back to Mammoth Lakes. It's nice to see you again. I didn't know if we'd ever see you again, but it's good to see you back here. I had a baby in the interim, too, so there was a little bit of a high end there, too. Good. I'm up here. I used to be down there, so lots of things have changed.
1:17:56 So a couple, I'll try to keep these kind of high level sort of specific kinds of questions. I'm wondering if the town of Mammoth Lakes, and I've talked to the town manager about this, has an agency of record relationship with the monument and the National Park Service. It's something that I'm, or maybe it's called by a different name that we would have at the Union National Forest whereby we're an agency such that you distribute internal, when you distribute to your internal kind of agency partners,
1:18:25 It might be coming to the town as well. And Dan, I don't know if that's... I think it's the cooperating agency status, so you'd be equal in terms of some of the process. I don't know if that's even eligible with the monument. We don't currently have anything like that on record. And as we mentioned, we just kind of started launching this process of really outreaching and engaging with our local communities, stakeholders, other agencies. So it will be something that...
1:18:52 Would be a good discussion and exploration in the future. But is that something that's available to the town with your agency? We really have to consult with the solicitor. What's a solicitor? A lawyer. The National Park Service has a lawyer. Yeah. She's pretty busy, though. Okay. We can follow up on that, too. Yeah, I think that's probably something. I mean, certainly if you're identifying and you're preferred alternatives.
1:19:21 A level, kind of an enhanced level of partnership, maybe enhanced presence here in the community, I think if it would be appropriate for maybe the town to establish a certain kind of maybe a higher level relationship with the monument. As you know, the Indian National Forest is going through their forest plan revision. In terms of the recommendations coming out of your alternative here, how do you anticipate
1:19:48 Your recommendations and your preferred alternative being advocated for in the international forest process. It's an interesting process. So the forest planning that they're going through in our general management planning, while they're both kind of long-range plans, some of our recommendations might be at a level of detail that is more specific than what the forest planning is doing right now. So my hope and what I foresee is that that overall vision of
1:20:19 You know, kind of the experience in the valley would be mirrored in that plan, but some of the more specific recommendations that are included in the Devil's Postpile general management plan are probably at a level of detail that you wouldn't see in a forest plan, but it would be at their next level.
1:20:37 Okay, so I'm just, again, I'm concerned that things don't fall through the cracks. And I'm assuming you guys have a very close working relationship with the INEO, but I would want to make sure that going forward it's clear who's going to advocate for these things in the forest planning process. And I'm assuming you're going to be available through the coming months if that question comes up. We can get in touch with you and make sure we're coordinating these things properly. Absolutely. And I think, I mean, to that point, I think the history of collaboration between the monument and the INEO at the operational level is a real testament to the...
1:21:06 The potential for those recommendations to go forward. If they had no history of working together, it would seem, you know, more of a concern, less likely, but I think their history of working together so closely on so many issues is bodes well for the future. Good. Okay. Two final questions. The Mineret Vista. The town, I think with some auto money, we did a project up at the Twin Lakes Vista.
1:21:35 Sort of the gateway up to the Mammoth Lakes Basin. And prior to that improvement, it looked somewhat like what Minerate Vista looks like now. Decaying asphalt, certain neglected bathrooms, not a very pleasant place to go. The increase in visitation and the qualitative increase to the visitor experience has been just monumental. Every day there's people parked up there taking pictures and all that kind of stuff. And so I think as a community, I think we're very interested in the Minerate Vista project.
1:22:03 And are there recommendations, I mean, is there any anticipation for actual on-the-ground infrastructure improvements, or is it kind of a general recommendation for what the site might look like? Do you anticipate any on-the-ground opportunities there? It would have to go through a much more detailed site planning analysis where those kinds of drawings and designs were laid out, and it would likely be accompanied by a more site-specific NEPA analysis to support that type of decision.
1:22:30 I think all of that, what the general management plan does is it provides the recommendation for the overall vision and some of the pieces that would ideally be considered in that type of implementation planning effort, but it doesn't go so far as laying the drawings or even schematic drawings on the ground. Okay, so that may be the kind of thing for the community to follow up on going forward. And I think finally, if you, in terms of the boundaries of the monument itself,
1:22:58 If your management plan is accepted and finalized, do you anticipate, how would the management program work pending congressional designation or changing the boundaries around? Would you be managing it to the existing boundaries or to the proposed new boundaries? We'd manage it to the existing boundary. We wouldn't manage to the proposed new boundary until we had... Until it was congressional action. Okay. I guess finally on the question of the road, I'm assuming that you guys in the area are talking about the road, and there's probably a fair amount of discussion about that in the plan itself.
1:23:28 The discussion in the plan specifically is about continuing to collaborate and coordinate on the road and talking about the importance of safe vehicular access and the desired kind of driving experience and things like that. But in terms of specific projects, those are not outlined. Okay. So, Madam Mayor, those are my questions for now. But I think in terms of as a town, as a community, we've got several big federal...
1:23:54 Efforts coming our way. I think it's going to be important for the town to be engaged as a commenter on these plans. And I sort of coordinate that with Dan and with local groups in the community. I think it's been very important to have our voices heard. But it's been a very interesting process. Thanks for all your time and the standards of the National Park Service have surely evidenced this plan. So thank you very much. Okay. I think that final comment stands for the rest of us. It does. Thank you so much. Thank you so much for the time this evening. Thank you.
1:24:22 We also have, before the, we do have additional copies. I know there are a number of people in the room. We do have additional copies of the newsletter available on the back table. And we also, Deanna, have additional copies of the full document that are available at the monument upon request. Great. Thank you very much. One last invitation for you all outside of the general management plan. This Friday evening at 7 p.m., we're having a special celebration of the Wilderness Act.
1:24:51 At the Mammoth Lakes Forest Service Auditorium about stopping the road, the road that was proposed back in the 1950s from Fresno to Mammoth Lakes. And the local community activists that were both business people and the packers and the environmentalists all got together and worked for 30 years to
1:25:09 Stopped this road from making Mammoth a pit stop but retaining the destination character. So it's a great story. Jack Fisher wrote a book on it. He's going to be the moderator inviting many of the road warriors that really were engaged in this effort for a significant part of their life. So if you'd like to join us, there'll be a book signing. It's sponsored by the U.S. Forest Service and New National Forest, Devil's Postpile, and Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association. So 7 p.m. at the Mammoth Lakes.
1:25:38 Auditorium on Friday night. Hope to see you there. Thank you. Thank you. Next on the agenda is council presentation for outgoing commissioners. Pat Agnich, Recreation Commissioner, is not able to be here tonight, so I'd like to start with just saying that
1:25:59 The community owes her thanks and gratitude for her passion and for how hard she worked as a recreation commissioner. She was involved in several of the subcommittees. She was active in the MLR formation process. And we do thank her for her service. She'll be receiving a certificate of appreciation. Next, I'd like Colin to join me down by the podium and Rhonda to come up. You should dress nice.
1:26:42 Now, I won't say anything about the number of years, but I believe we had one of our senior members of the Planning and Employment Commission that I was fortunate to get to work with for a while, and so was Colin, leading us after a long but very thankful, very productive series. And then one of our nurse commissioners who did seven that I heard and kind of graduated.
1:27:06 I do just want to say, Rhonda, that one of the things that I think you've helped us through most is getting economic development as part of the idea. The Dr. SEDS documented so many of the things that we worked on. And, Colin, I know that you've dealt with some good issues. Thank you for the work on this. Let me go to Dave and all of that that you did. So, both of you, thank you so much for your service that I was planning for the Commission. It's my pleasure. That brings us to the consent agenda.
1:27:57 Are there any items that a council member wishes to pull from consent? I would just like to pull item five. Okay. And are there any from the community? Seeing none, I'll entertain a motion. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. Council approve items three, four, and six. Second. With a motion and a second, could we have a roll call vote, please, Jamie? Yes. Yes.
1:28:29 Yes. Yes. Yes. Excuse me. Motion passes 5-0. That will take us to item number 5, which is the contract for construction of Meridian Boulevard Rehabilitation Project. Colin? Totally comfortable with everything. Just wanted for the benefit of the public. Maybe if Dan or Grady could just go over a few of those details. I've heard some questions. The project itself runs along Meridian Boulevard on the north side.
1:29:10 From Minaret down to Old Mammoth Road. There's a couple of small pieces east of Old Mammoth Road. We're actually fixing up the handicap ramps at both the intersections to the east side of that. The majority of the project, though, and what the public will see is that we're now, Bridian coming down is basically four lanes, and if anybody who's driven it knows, people will go pretty fast.
1:29:33 They don't really pay much attention to the speed limit signs. In the future, it will actually be just three lanes, one in each direction and a two-way turn lane in the center. This is funded mostly by almost predominantly, almost completely, in fact, by the Safe Route to Schools program. So along the north side, you'll see a sidewalk that starts just east of where the Utalis entrance is, connecting with the path there, and a sidewalk running all the way down to Old Bammoth Road along that side. We are doing...
1:30:02 Some other improvements for better bus turnouts and better protection for people there. There is a bus shelter that is planned for up to the west end towards Tallis there that we're working with the developer there on the final funding for that. It'll happen at a later date. But we do expect the project to begin this year. We have to admit we got the...
1:30:23 The notification that we got the funding, I believe it was July 3rd in the agenda sheet. We advertised the project on July 11th. We had to get it out as quickly as possible to make sure that we secured those funds. We will be working with space construction on the actual schedule. If we're not confident, and I know weather is always an issue, if we're not confident that we're going to have at least three weeks of weather,
1:30:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:31:11 And that would include the sidewalk portion or no? That's correct. In fact, most of the project is sidewalk and is concrete. There's some paving, but most of the paving work has to do with just the edge condition and the striping to change it from, again, a four-lane street down to three lanes with that turn lane in the middle. Most of it is concrete, and that's a little bit different than working out in the street in the asphalt. But, again, we're not going to start unless we're confident we can leave it in good condition for the winter. Thank you. Any other questions?
1:31:40 I would also like to state for the record that I live on Meridian Boulevard, but that because this type of a public works project, I am not required to recuse myself on this vote. Any other questions on it? Are there any questions from the public on this one? No. Thank you for that. I'll make a motion to approve item 5 on the consent agenda. Second. With a motion and a second, could we have a roll call vote? Please, Jamie. Council Member Perry? Yes. Council Member Richardson? Yes. Council Member Weber? Yes.
1:32:11 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. I have a request for an exactly five-minute break at this time before we get into the next item. So we'll take that and I will gavel us back in five minutes. Okay.
1:32:53 All right. In that case, we'll move on to our policy matter, which is to approve the Town Council priorities and strategies. Dan, do you have any introductions? Yeah. Real, real brief was going to be you have a draft write-up that came out of the workshop of August 7th. Bill Davis, who did the facilitation of the workshop, is here to kind of walk through the report. Again, this evening now is designed to come back and present the information that came out of that.
1:33:23 A lot of this is to ask the council, did we capture everything that you wanted to see captured? Bill will walk through part of the process that got us to kind of those strategies and commitments. And the focus of this evening is really looking at are these the core areas in terms of your priorities and goals that we'll be working through going forward? Are there any questions on these items where there needs to be clarifications or modifications in terms of the writing and stuff?
1:33:51 The request from staff then is either to modify the report, adopt it as presented, or have it modified and brought back again. The validity of the items that are there and the details of a number of them really isn't designed for the discussion this evening, but it's more of here's a list of work projects and items that we would be focusing on, and on purpose we structured over a longer period of time, 18 months.
1:34:16 That ties to fiscal years and calendar years. But a lot of things would be started to work through within that time frame, obviously. So with that, what I'd like to do is have Bill kind of walk through the process that Scott is here and then really coming back based on council input and public comment on the strategies and the items there. Have we captured those? Is there additions, subtractions, modifications that we can go forward with in helping?
1:34:44 Kind of scope out what would be Council's and staff's core work program related to these along with the other day-to-day stuff we have going every day. So with that, unless there's particular questions, I'll turn it over to Bill Davis to kind of walk through how we got here and then come back ultimately to Council for additional discussion. Actually, Dan, I have one thing I'd like you to explain is then once these priorities are set is how does this develop into a work plan?
1:35:13 Once Council adopts it, we'll be walking through these. There's a lot of elements. Some of them are pretty straightforward that are underway in some cases, i.e., you heard tonight, the new finance software. And then we would start the staff process working through these. Some of them will need more detail and more actually action items at the staff level that implements that. And then we would bring that back to Council and work through those areas. If there's areas that definitely have a higher priority from Council to tackle, that's good to know. Don't need it.
1:35:42 Tell us how, but just the what, and then we'll figure out how to bring those items back in a timely fashion. Thank you. Bill. Mayor, Councilmembers. For the record, in benefit of the public, Bill Davis, W.R. Davis Collaborative from Davis, California, and consultant hired to design, facilitate, and document.
1:36:08 Your meeting, your priorities and strategies meeting on the 7th of this month. I'm pleased to be in front of you to formally present this to you and also be here to answer any questions you may have in terms of process or the content of the document. And so my intention is basically to set the context, provide some clarification on some of the nuances of definitions.
1:36:37 Just to assure that we don't get kind of in the weeds in some areas that aren't really the critical parts of this to be taking a look at, that we're more of a process to get to the key outcomes that you generated. So I basically have the document here in the image form, and I'm just going to take a few steps through this, but be very brief. In terms of the executive summary on page three, I just want to remind you
1:37:05 We covered a lot of ground on that day. I kept you very busy and focused. And if you recall, we transported ourselves out into the future, actually five years in one day, turned around and looked back on the day five years in the future and identified what it was that we saw. That's how we came up with the vision or basically the horizon.
1:37:30 And I'll go into a little bit more detail about the definition of that as we proceed through this. Then we stepped back to 18 months and one day in the future and turned around and identified what it was we saw 18 months out if and when we were wildly successful in terms of implementing our strategies and priorities. Then we came back to today and
1:37:59 We conducted what we call a current reality exercise, which is different than the standard SWOT, or strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats that you might find in a lot of strategic planning. And the major difference is that the strengths and weaknesses were associated directly with this council, with the town of Mammoth, and also with the community partners in terms of implementing priorities.
1:38:28 We looked at our victory through the lens of the current reality and then started to identify what are our priorities and then we rolled those priorities up in terms of identifying what are the strategies that these priorities are representing. So on page four, this is an overview of the key consensus elements.
1:38:56 That we identified in that work. And this is, I'm going to come back to this, but I just want to hit on it really briefly. The only recommendations I make in this report, above and beyond what it was that you came up with in the meeting, is down in the little yellow box on the left-hand side, which is keeping on track, and a recommended schedule for remaneuvering, updating, and making adjustments to this strategy.
1:39:25 The next page, page 5, is the practical vision. And in terms of the vision, these elements A through G are really the important things that you need to key on for that vision. This is the level that we reached consensus. And so if we turn to page 6, I just want to point out that the consensus was reached at the column headings or in the blue on the report.
1:39:55 The bullet points in the white row are not items of consensus, but only brainstormed items that were used to uncover what it was that your common vision was at the top. So a big mistake a lot of times is people come back and say, oh, look at bullet number three. We said we were going to do that. No.
1:40:22 This was just a tool to get us to that level of consensus and understanding what it is the elements are for our vision. I also want to highlight that on page 7, these victory items were a brainstorm about being wildly successful what it is that we see. And once again, this is a tool to help us down the line identify what it is that our priorities are. And then on page 8,
1:40:55 Is where we identify the strengths, weaknesses, benefits, and dangers. And I already spoke to that in terms of it's the strengths of the council, the town, and the community partners in terms of implementing these strategies and achieving these priorities. And then the benefits and dangers to the council, to the town, and to the community partners from being successful.
1:41:24 So they're not dangers to success, dangers from success. And then on my next slide actually includes pages 9 and 10, which is verbatim captured also on page 4. And this is where we came up with the priorities and then the strategies. I want to be very clear that I try very hard not to call the vision elements goals.
1:41:55 Because that confuses down the line what I consider goals in the strategic planning process, which are SMART, that's the acronym, specific, measurable, what is it? Achievable, and then also time bound.
1:42:27 And these, the smaller letters within the larger outline of the capital letters there are the goals. And then the bolded with the capital letters are the strategies that we identified were coming up because of the goals. And once again, this is captured, I believe, completely on page four as well.
1:42:58 And then in more detail in the appendices here is outlining a little bit more what I'm referring to on page four in terms of keeping the plan on track and a strategy to keep the plan updated. So if we could go back to page four, this is really a good page to either blow up, make a copy of, put it in the slip sheet in the front of your binder because
1:43:31 Really, this is the real meat of the issue here. We have the practical vision. Once again, not goals, but vision elements. And then we have in the green box there on the left, the strategies and the commitments. And the commitments are synonymous with goals. And the real important thing about that is that we're saying, hey, this is what we intend to achieve.
1:44:00 I really like folks to not hedge on this, but to keep to, we would really like to achieve this within that time period. A lot of times people try to hedge on it. It's not a goal if you don't set that timeline and really attempt to reach that. So my recommendation would be that we confirm the 18-month
1:44:29 Goals or commitments and then also the strategies. Make any modifications or clarifications that at this time after having some time to sit with it you might think are indicated. And then I would recommend that you approve the whole report, basically adopting these as your strategies and goals. And I'm available for any questions. Are there questions with Bill?
1:44:59 Could you turn the slides back to the one where it showed them against the white background? I know it's a little bit small, but for the purposes of discussion, I think, no, that one. No, it was our pages 9 and 10. Yes. That one. Yeah, just so as we're speaking, the whole audience can see the goals that we're talking about. Yes, and I understand that this report is available online as well. Correct, but not everyone in the audience might not have a copy in front of them. No, I understand.
1:45:28 Okay. All right. Thank you, Bill. What I'd like to do next is since it's been about 10 days since we discussed that is I would first like to ask any council member if there's something that is at the goal level that might have been overlooked before we take public comment so public comment can be on that as well. Bill, I compliment you on this work in
1:46:00 Giving back to us what I think when we left the room. This is all the stuff that I think we talked about. This is a very excellent documentation of all that stuff. And to the senior members of the council, this is the most comprehensive goal-setting list I've seen since I've been here since 2000. I think that's probably true. And I want to just commend the leadership of the previous council for initiating a process like this, for setting goals for the previous years.
1:46:26 And I'm going to assume that the goals from the previous council incorporated into this. And I believe we even – Colin, you made that comment during the workshop, didn't you, that you had checked them back and forth and that, yes, they were more or less all here. Okay. Yeah. I mean, that was something I was definitely paying attention to is trying to keep the momentum moving from last council, and I think they fit in pretty well to this. Yeah, I think we've done that. So that was my – those are my thoughts. Okay. Anyone else?
1:46:56 Okay, before we take the public comment, I just want to reiterate a couple of the things that Dan and Bill said, is that we're looking at strategies and particularly focusing on goals of the work that's going to be accomplished in the next 18 months. We have a number of items on here, and they are all at a somewhat high level at this point.
1:47:22 They are all things that this Council sees as important to accomplish by early 2016. So with that in mind, we will take public comment. If you're going to make a comment, please come up to the podium, state your name. And there is a five-minute limit, but with the number of people who may want to speak, if you can be more concise, that's also appreciated.
1:47:53 So if there's anyone who would like to step forward to start this, if there's anyone who has comments on our strategies or the goals. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Council. My name is Dana Stroud. I'm the current chair for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And at our board meeting that we held Monday, we had the opportunity to review the document, and we would like to also commend the work that you did, Bill. It was very comprehensive and very clear, and we really appreciated what you put into it.
1:48:32 Tonight we would like to offer up a few comments as it relates to your strategies, priorities, goals, and commitments that sit on page 9 and 10 of the document that Bill prepared for us. My comments are no particular priority from us. I'm just going to go in order of A through E on the document. Excuse me, A through G. The first one is you had enhanced community amenities.
1:48:58 And underneath that, you've had specifically a strategic plan for use of Measures U and R revenues just to advise you that Mammoth Lakes Recreation in its negotiations with the town has identified that as one of the deliverables that we will be responsible for. So we wanted to just remind you that MLR will be playing a role in that and that we look forward to helping to set that plan for how those funds will be used in the future. Number two, under letter E,
1:49:28 It's solve parking challenges. And while we certainly respect the need for potential additional parking, we would like to recommend that you consider adding enhanced transit as a part of that discussion under solving parking challenges. Because perhaps through enhancing your transit system and expanding it, it might help address some of the parking challenges that you face in the community. So we would just recommend
1:49:54 That you consider adding transit to that topic and to that item and think about where you can expand and enhance. And then on page 10 of the document under letter F, it's Diversify Economic Development. Very specifically letter B, partner on a May to October summer of 2016. We understand that to be kind of a larger coordination of how we transition from
1:50:22 Summer to Fall to Winter to Spring and Snow to No Snow Seasons and you identify a few different partners in there. We would like to remind you that MLR would probably be playing a role in that effort as well and that we would look forward to participating in any discussions that you might have with our other partners to help this transition be a bit smoother and also to think about expanding based on
1:50:50 Climate Change and where we're going to have either more snow or no snow and where we collectively work together to make that transition happen sooner to the benefit of the community and all involved. And with that, I'll answer any questions you might have of the MLR comments. Thank you, Dana. Just a quick question regarding enhanced transit. Are you talking specifically about
1:51:15 Town trolleys and bus service or a broader representation of transit? Well, I think it's a combination. Certainly there is in town the opportunity to expand the service schedules and, as mentioned earlier, Colin, the equipment that is used for the transit where there's opportunity to start thinking about some additional rolling stock to help accommodate some of the capacity issues relative to the number of buses that are running.
1:51:41 I made this comment the other day in the MLR meeting. It wasn't that long ago when grants were being submitted to purchase rolling stock, and we sat around as town staff and scratched our heads and said, gosh, that seems to be a lot of buses. Are we ever going to be able to fill them? And here we are, not that many years later, facing a challenge. So we're thinking expanded as far as rolling stock and increase and then the equipment that goes with it to accommodate the needs of the users.
1:52:10 I.e. the bike trailers and the opportunity to expand on how those are used. But then, in addition,
1:52:16 We would also think about some regional transportation as well. You certainly have YARTS that has the ability to start to expand and help with access into other parts of our region, including Yosemite. And then certainly ESTA outside of Mammoth has the opportunity to bring people in and out on a much more frequent basis. And then I would also include the Inyo National Forest on that because they look at how they're able to use transportation to get folks to their trailheads, to get to their recreation amenities.
1:52:45 And they might have an opportunity to help with some of that capacity and thinking about some regional transit issues. Thank you. Dan, would it be wrong to maybe put the enhanced transit, which I agree with you on, maybe up in A, it's in a community amenity? Because parking is, I think, a stand-alone issue around town.
1:53:13 And I think transit is actually a mobility, it's an amenity for our town, going to trailheads or whatever. So I agree with you. I think it's something that should be included, but I think it should be up in so-called A. I will defer to what you guys decide as a council. I would just remind us that while transit is an amenity, it is also a service and it serves not just our visitors but our local residents alike.
1:53:38 Right. And where we have the opportunity to put some emphasis behind it. I fully appreciate the idea to include it as an amenity, but I hope that it doesn't get lost because it goes a bit further beyond just being an amenity as well. Thank you. Thanks. Any other questions of MLR? No. Thank you. Thank you. Excuse me. Madam Chair, just a process question.
1:54:00 Should we just all be keeping individual notes and we'll come back and kind of sum it up at the end? Right. When we get done with the comments, I will go through and say, you know, this was suggested as a consensus to add it. Really? Okay. All right. Thank you. Ron Cohen, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Just wanted to come out today to thank you for doing this work and commend you on a job well done. You know, as you all are well aware, as everybody here is well aware,
1:54:30 The last several years in the town have been spent firefighting. And we've been mired in financial problems and litigation and dealing with drought. And, you know, we've had some voices, many voices who are here now out there saying, let's keep on track to think about the future. That's where the good things come from. You talk a lot about transit. ESTA is an example of that, putting the investment in.
1:54:57 For many years of building, thinking strategically about the future to the point where the bus system that used to be run by Mammoth Mountain Ski Area is now part of a broader joint government agency that now we're able to pay into to fund a lion's share of that and provide a significantly leveraged service for the community. We're about two or three weeks away from the one-year anniversary of the TBIT.
1:55:26 And notwithstanding the issues with some of the implementation on a small scale.
1:55:31 The broad success of that a year later and the revenue that's being generated by that to really help sell our community abroad in all advertising markets and get people here, that's a great success on a strategic basis for the town. So we had a hard-fought general plan with many voices that were involved in it, the state's very high-level goals as to where we'd take the town.
1:56:00 We've worked on specific elements of that. And now you're building on that. You're building on some great ongoing efforts, things like the downtown neighborhood district plan that are ongoing and are sort of at the work level, I think, at this point. And what it seems you're doing is looking forward now.
1:56:19 What are we going to do 18 months? What are we going to do three to five years? And like John said, that's very encouraging, I think, from all of our perspectives, certainly from the ski area's perspective, to see that kind of thought going on. So appreciate it and thank you. Thank you, John. My name is Greg Martino. I'm a resident. I'd like to thank the council, too, for the hard work you guys did in going through that exercise. It took a long time. It took a lot of effort on both parts.
1:56:57 And I understand tonight that really what you're going to be doing is not necessarily voting on any particular item, although just voting on the list of your priorities. So I understand that. I think all the priorities, I think, are good. And I think they, as the Representative Mountain just said, move the town forward. They give the town hope. They make it look to be a better place if those things are accomplished. I think they're ambitious, and I hope they do get accomplished.
1:57:26 There is one item, though, as you probably know since you've seen me before, that I think shouldn't be on this list. I think the item regarding single-family rentals and opening them up to the nightly rentals in the single-family zone is not an item that the council should be focusing on the most in the next 18 months. I think the next 18 months you have a lot of other items that are more important that are moving the town forward. As you've seen by...
1:57:51 What went on through the campaign, as well as various letters you've gotten, as well as letters to the town, to the various newspapers, this is a very divisive issue. I think it will continue to be divisive. I think the town, the council focusing on that in the next 18 months is going to bring you away from the areas that you should be focusing on that are better for the town and moving it forward. I think, in my opinion, this is such a dramatic change if the zoning is actually changed.
1:58:20 That it shouldn't be something the council should be voting on. It should be something the community should vote on. And then we live with that decision. But I don't think three or four people on the council should be changing the overall, in my opinion, livability of the town and the nature of the single-family residential neighborhoods. There's been a lot said about Matt Lehman's survey. I pulled it up again tonight. And despite what Matt may think, if you look at the numbers,
1:58:49 The two categories that he listed as far as people that are opposed or mostly opposed is 70% of the people that responded. 17.6% of the people that responded are in favor of it. If you add to that the people that are in favor of it with conditions, which we believe is considering the conditions of the status quo where they're allowed only in certain residential areas, you get up to 80%.
1:59:14 I think it's an item that shouldn't be on the priorities now. I think it's something that should be
1:59:41 Either put aside entirely or push down way further down the road. Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Sandy Hogan, a 19-year resident. And allow me to put this up because I think it may help illustrate a lot of what some of the letters talk about because I think a lot of folks aren't really aware of zoning. So let me put this up. And I'd like to start off by saying I do want to compliment you. I sat through that six-hour meeting, as you know.
2:00:40 And we've got some great and ambitious, expensive, but wonderful future ahead of us. So that's really great. I'm going to speak directly to the single-family home, that's number G issue, because I don't think it's a positive goal. All of your other ones are very positive. This one, as people have noted in all of the writings I've seen,
2:01:10 It's divisive. It's not going to bring us together. Is it perfect, what we have? No, but it's far better than most resorts, and I have to tell you that, because this is surfacing in many resorts right now and in many cities, a lot of these issues, and part of it's because lack of zoning, lack of CCNRs, and the emerging and booming technology that's happened in the last 15 to 20 years, or maybe it's only about 10 years, whatever. A little bit of history.
2:01:39 We celebrated being 30 years old last week. Fabulous. One of the great things about being young is that we finished our zoning, really, I think it was 1992. I saw drafts from 91 and I saw it looked like a final from 92. Our general plan has an emphasis on two things, and it's what makes us great, unlike other communities. We don't need to be like other communities.
2:02:06 One, emphasis on tourism. We know that's our business, our mountain, everything. I mean, we know that. TOT reflects that. It's almost 70 percent of our income. The second thing is community, and our zoning and our general plan has always emphasized that. And I think we need to congratulate ourselves on being so farsighted as to have good zoning, recognizing that we have resort areas.
2:02:36 In areas where transient rentals are absolutely appropriate and needed and a great part of our economy and the other ones that take care of us, the community. This map shows it. If you take a look at that map, you'll see that the yellow areas are what people are asking you to preserve. That's what we think is wonderful. Those are the RSF, the single family residential areas that we live in and where
2:03:05 Actually, your transient rentals of single-family homes are prohibited by zoning and by our TOT ordinance also. They're just not allowed to do it there. But the zoning says no. So if you looked at a recent article in the sheet, you saw Jackson. They ignored their law for a number of years and they realized things are falling apart. Now they're going to enforce it.
2:03:33 That sounded like something that was actually, I think, suggested in one of the sheet letters. Park City is like us. Park City has certain areas that are zoned for rentals and others that are not. If you look up here, all of the pink and all of the orange, well, I should say practically everything, well, not the blue, but practically everything other than yellow is open to
2:03:59 Single-Family Rentals if there are standalone homes. We call them standalone homes so that people will know that they can rent them. There are a few places in the pink like Starwood that has a master development restriction there so it's not legal there. But look at that pink. I have gone out and counted over 150, more than that now because we've got about a dozen approved or building of standalone homes that are legal to rent. So we don't have a supply-demand problem.
2:04:28 That's one of those myths that's out there. People are going elsewhere. Uh-uh. Maybe we have a marketing problem. We need to kind of figure out how to better market them. So that inventory is there. Anyway, I guess the main thing all I can see is that people are talking about bringing in more TOT revenue. Well, we've got a task force that is far beyond anybody else. Our task force is working, and it's successful. We just have to keep it going.
2:04:57 And staffed. I personally have talked to the enforcement person in South Lake Tahoe because I am a property owner up there and they wish they had their, we are CCNRs and they wish we had, they have our zoning. They don't have it. So all you need to do is just support that task force, put this, put this apart. This is divisive. Sandy, can I ask you to wrap it up, please? I will. We have wrapped this up several times in our history, including back into the 90s. I hope that you will.
2:05:27 Actually set it aside and realize we have a great system. So let's not be like other resorts. Thank you. Is there anyone else that wishes to speak? Good evening, Council. Terry Stelick, citizen. One thing that would be nice when you guys, I think that this is great. I like the outcome for most of this. It would be nice to have it if it's recorded. I was unable to attend, unfortunately. And I think that some...
2:06:08 If we were able to hear some of the discussion that went on behind some of these items, it might help us as a community understand where your thinking was and why something may have gone the direction that it went. I'm just going to kind of go down. I think it's a great start. I think it's, like John said, one of the best starts that we've had and where we actually looked.
2:06:31 Five years out and then are working towards that goal. And if you look at all of those items that are within, I think the six items as far as you guys went and then listed probably about 10, 15 things under each one, that's great. One of the things that I saw under that but I didn't see anywhere else is plan for deferred.
2:06:56 Maintenance, bringing up our own facilities and amenities. And so I didn't see that in the short list. I saw that in the long list. So I'm glad to at least see it there. Not sure what you guys mean by item D and then little letter B, the comprehensive community action plan and elevation or conceptual plan bringing to life in a visual way what the future town may look like, roll up of all plans. I don't know if you're just trying to pull everything off the shelf and see what we have and try to implement those.
2:07:24 And this is where if we actually heard anything that it would probably help. The implement economic development strategy. I don't know if that's Dr. Seds that you guys are looking at. I think all of these other items are great. I think H, the customer service academy in partnership with the chamber. I think that needs to be business to customer. I think it also needs to be our municipal government to our businesses. And I think that that.
2:07:53 We need to work on that as well. And then I think the issue with G, I mean, what is G? Tackle single-family resident short-term rental decision on a town-wide basis. I think we've done that time and time again. So what does it really mean? There's no specific tasks that are listed. You know, so to me, I think you guys have gotten some pretty passionate emails because basically that tells me that, you know, hey, we're going to, you know, go and we're just going to do a town-wide opening.
2:08:22 And there's a lot of passion both ways. So, you know, irregardless of how somebody feels on the issue, one thing that I'm really disappointed that I didn't see in here is the enforcement and the education. So, irregardless of your position, we need a foundation. This entire government and municipal and this town needs a foundation.
2:08:50 And without that foundation, I don't think we can move forward with something as large as a town-wide opening of single-family residence. Being on the TOT Compliance Committee, right now you have a finance department that's reorganizing. And so they're currently undergoing and going through all their ordinances, going through their department. There's things that are changing.
2:09:14 We need to go over all of our ordinances and policies again and clean up anything that's needed and change those things first. We need to enforce legal and illegal activity. We need education. There's still, as people are buying properties, they have no idea what rules and regulations, what the ordinances are out there. So we need to get the towns, total towns, foundations stable.
2:09:40 We need that vision. We need to know what the development of this community looks like and where that puts us. So what is our product base? What are we going to bring forward? We need to be stewards to Mammoth Lakes and our visitors' experience while maintaining our community because sitting through the general plan, that was a key element in our general plan that we wanted to make sure that we keep our community. And that is also within your...
2:10:08 Long-term future is to build our community and have a strong community. And I'm not sure that opening up a single-family rentals does that. I mean, I've had people ask me recently, you know, hey, do you know any houses that are for rent? And I says, well, you know, there's this, that, or the other. And they're like, well, they don't want to be necessarily in a condo with all of the transient rentals that go on. They wanted to have a house where their family can have a yard.
2:10:37 And they can have that sense of community. And it's a struggle for people to find that right now. So there's a lot that goes into this decision. So to see this as a standalone item to tackle this, you know, because I really have a hard time with actually even the verbiage on this thing. It's pretty, I think it's pretty poor compared to the rest of your document. So tackle single-family resident short-term rental decision on a town-wide basis. So like I said, what does that mean?
2:11:08 Thank you, Terry. Thank you. Not as a general response to that, but Shields, could you give a really quick description of the Comprehensive Community Action Plan just for the benefit of someone who wasn't there? Right. Item D, little B. Terry, what you said is, you know, you want to have a vision. You know what the town's going to look like? Well, that's what this is. If you envision a blueprint, okay,
2:11:38 of a house, you'll see the blueprint of a house and you'll see where the bathroom's going to go and all the different things, but you don't know what the elevation, what's actually going to look like when it's done, and that's conceptually what I want to do. There's a lot of different plans out there. There's a downtown plan, there's the old Mammoth plan, there's the village plan, there's the parks plan. We've got all these individual plans. What I, my thought was, hey, let's roll them all together and say, okay, God, if we do all this,
2:12:07 What is this going to look like? What is our community going to look like? And from that, do we have the policies in place, the ordinances in place, the foundation in place to make all that happen? So it's a visual of the future. I won't go into the single family deal right now, but I know that's going to be, we'll talk all about that.
2:12:32 But that's what that means. Well, being somebody that sat in on a lot of these different plans, I'm glad to see that we're going to blow the dust off of them and actually pull them out and hopefully see if they're still relevant and how they might work within our community. Exactly. But I think you have a general plan that we also really need to look at. And I think some of this goes against what your general plan said. Well,
2:12:59 We'll get into that later. Yeah, I was just saying, you know, the general plan is, you know, still the document, but it doesn't give, you know, specifics. It doesn't roll into the visual of what it's going to look like. That's why they've done those downtown plans and what have you. So I'm just saying, let's roll all that up and see what it looks like. Thank you. Is there anyone else that'd like to speak? I'll try to be very, very brief. My name is Paul Rudder. I'm a 34-year resident of Mammoth Lakes.
2:13:34 I think the Town Council is exactly the right forum to discuss this single-family rental problem. I think the time has come when it needs to be thrashed out. I'm not here to suggest to you that I know which way you should decide or what's best for the community. I think that will be the product of many, many people coming before you, of many studies, of looking at this thing every which way.
2:14:01 I think one of the things the community has to recognize, however, is that the previous town councils over a number of years saddled you with an enormous financial problem and enormous other problems that have to be dealt with. To say we're going to look at any one problem or we're going to refuse to look at problems because they're too big a problem, I don't think that actually solves anything and the purpose of the council is to give the community that guidance.
2:14:28 I think that when we get all through looking at it and you've exercised the judgment for which we elected you, we'll end up with a solution that will be good for this community. But we won't get there by ignoring things. We have to deal with them head on and do our level best to give everybody an opportunity to tell you what they think and why they think that so that you can make the best educated decision you can.
2:14:54 I think then we'll get to the Mammoth of the future that we'd all like to envision. Thank you. Thank you, Paul. Thanks, Paul. Mary Canada, resident. Well, Paul threw sort of a little wrench into my point, but I'm going to stick with it. I've been attending public meetings for the 30 years that Mammoth's been incorporated, and the importance...
2:15:28 I would like to mention that there's an economic aspect to this. When I was on school board, we often were asked questions by potential
2:15:57 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:16:26 Yes, the community should. I think on – I haven't read this document, so I can't speak to it, but there was a heading, Enhance Community Pride. I think single-family nightly rentals will work against that. Thank you. Thank you, Mary. Is there anyone else who'd like you to speak? Just take the tissues. Hi, my name is Tom Gott. I've lived here 40 years.
2:16:57 It was just going to be for ski season, so I don't know how that worked out. But anyway, in that 40 years, I've seen the town council make great decisions, mediocre decisions, and as we know, some really bad ones. And a single family resident, making that a priority. I live in a wonderful community, in a wonderful neighborhood, where I've raised my three kids, got a new generation of kids and families there. This single family residence thing would literally destroy you.
2:17:26 I just can't see any reason for this. Anyway, that's all I really have to say, and I hope you take that into consideration. Good evening. My name is Robert Calvert. I've got quite a bit going on here in town. I just want to thank the council for your efforts. It's not a glorious job, but thank you.
2:17:59 I came in real late, so if I'm repeating myself, I apologize, I just got out of a meeting, but I wanted to be here, it was important, so I don't have a specific agenda that I'm going to talk about, but I had a renter living next door to me for the last six years, and it was pure hell. It was pure hell. But I'm in favor of what you guys are doing and putting this on the agenda, because I'm a believer, I have three businesses that I'm running in town, and I'm on the board for Little League and lots of things, but...
2:18:29 I believe the more information you have, the better decisions you can make. So it's my understanding, this is about gathering more information. And so thumbs up to you guys, gather the information. I've lived in a lot of ski towns, lived in Colorado for many years. I've spoken with a couple of you, but I'm not going to name any names. But I'm in favor of single family, nightly rentals. Let's give it a shot. I don't have a crystal ball. I don't want one.
2:19:01 If I had a crystal ball, I'd tell you what's going to happen. But let's give it a shot. The discussion's been going on for a long time, so my hat's off to all of you and the staff and the supporting members that are putting in the time that you don't earn any gold stars here. And I read the letter about a couple of your businesses being attacked.
2:19:26 And I was explaining to one council member today that it's worse than elementary. I used the word elementary. And I was like, you know, it's worse than that. So let's all grow up here. You know, we're a lot of business members. We're a lot of business owners here. We're working hard. Go for it. Appreciate your time. If there's anything I can do, I know, Michael, you got my contact number. Let me know what I can do. Thank you. Thank you, Robert. Is there anyone else? Hi, my name is Lee Gosch.
2:20:11 I have a few things that I would like to talk about that I feel that should be priorities. One of them is being handicapped accessible in our town. We're not handicapped accessible. Kathy Copeland wants to have a wounded warrior center. I have talked to the building inspector about it. When people, businesses remodel, they need to have handicapped ramps. They need to be handicapped accessible. This town is not ready for a wounded warrior center. It needs to be handicapped accessible a lot more than it is.
2:20:40 The second thing is I do believe that we need to be more wildlife stewards in our town. There's not enough outreach in educating people. When it comes to second home rentals, I am against it. We need to have more police officers who are going to have it. We need to have them patrolled more. They don't understand having bears and all that stuff in our area. They park in your driveway. Then the loader driver can't come. I live in Sierra Valley sites where the working people live. We are an asset to this town.
2:21:09 And we are the ones that basically keep this town running. And Sierra Valley Sites has a lot of drugs, a lot of alcohol, and a lot of issues. You do not want to have somebody rent in Sierra Valley Sites because the word of mouth will spread, Sierra Valley Sites, where Mammoth isn't a good place to rent. You don't want that. And I can understand people when they buy it in an area and it's quiet. They want a quiet area. That's why they came here. That's why we have condos. They have swimming pools. They have jacuzzis.
2:21:38 They have tennis courts. There's all kinds of things they can use. And I'm against it because it will put a hinder on the residents of this town that work here. And they can't get up in the morning to go to work when they're partying all night next door. Because we want to be polite to our guests, not rude to them because we're so tired. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Is there anyone else who'd like to speak?
2:22:11 Hi, I'm Gail O'Sullivan. Can you pull the... Thank you, Gail. Now we can hear you. My name is Gail O'Sullivan. I've lived here since 1984. I raised my two children here. They went through the high school, and they loved it. We love the quality of life here. We love the access to the wilderness. I agree with everybody who's come up here before. We were actually moved here the year that...
2:22:39 Everybody was incorporated. And so we've seen it through the entire 30-year existence. I would like to emphasize that we would like Mammoth to remain Mammoth. We don't want to be in Aspen. We don't want to be in Incline Village. We don't want to be Squaw Valley. We want to be Mammoth. We want to retain our own identity, a little bit hidden away, but so beautiful that once you get here, you...
2:23:09 Can't believe it's this gorgeous. And we like the fact that it's not crowded. And we like the fact that the people all come on the weekends and then we can enjoy each other. But I have an issue that I'd like to bring up because it happened to me personally. I live in the Knolls and the house next door rented their house.
2:23:36 to a construction company from Los Angeles. And the construction company supposedly let their employees and their clients use the home. And so they were cleaning, it would change hands twice a week. And sometimes there would be five or six cars in the driveway, sometimes there would only be two or three. But it was used like an overnight rental.
2:24:02 And what happened is the normal thing, the traffic, the congestion, the trash, the people's ignorance as to the bears, and the bears, I've lived here for 30 years, and the bears have never tried to enter my house until the last two years. And we all know they're more aggressive, that being said. But the people from Los Angeles don't understand. You have to close, you can't leave your Starbucks cup in the front holder.
2:24:29 Or the bear's going to break in. You can't leave your cooler in the back seat. They don't understand that. So long story short, we've had screaming and yelling on the deck at 2.30 in the morning on a weeknight. I've had to call the police. It's been mostly irritating, but some of the people are very nice. You know, you get the good with the bad. But one day, I'm looking out the back window.
2:24:56 And there are three children climbing on my wood pile. Now, if it was a split wood pile, I wouldn't have been too upset. I would have just asked them to leave. No, it was rounds. And they were stacked very nicely 30 feet away from the building. Now, three little children climbing on rounds of timber is not safe. I can just imagine if one of them had fallen off, broken a leg,
2:25:25 And then they've gone to some slip and fall attorney from Los Angeles who's going to sue my pants off. I don't want that happening. I fought in this neighborhood so that my children would have a backyard to play in and I could have peace and quiet. So I think the unintended, you have to look at before you, I would recommend to the town that you fix what you have now. Fix what's broken.
2:25:54 Enforce the regulations you already have in effect. And you won't even have to consider converting. And I think it would drastically change the demographics of this town, which I don't want to see. I want Mammoth to stay Mammoth because it's all a special place to us, and I hope it is to you as well. So thank you for listening. Thank you, Gail. Good evening. My name is Jay Cole, Councilmembers.
2:26:30 I'm a resident here. My family and I and my wife have owned property here since 1972. One thing I would like to get across is that I actually am in favor of SFRs, and I think it can really enable the town to grow. Our town and the culture of our town is about visitors. Giving visitors more options will help everyone. We talk about
2:26:59 The people coming in on the weekends and leaving during the week, I think our business owners would actually prefer to have a consistent business. So from an economic standpoint, I think having a stronger economy, this will help towards that. Also, I just ask that we look through the rhetoric and the speculation and just look at the facts.
2:27:27 Someone had mentioned earlier that TOT is a great contributor to our annual revenue source. Great. So if we can collect more, even better. And I don't think it's a real necessarily an issue for the character of our neighborhoods. We live in a great neighborhood. It's quiet. I appreciate it. I don't want a bunch of maniacs next to me either. But as it was just mentioned, we do have regulations.
2:27:54 We have regulations for noise. We have regulations for trash. We have regulations for cars parked on city streets during the winter. And it's easy to make these things. So let's exercise our regulations and have an open mind about increasing the options for our visitors. It all boils down to our visitors. Visitors come. They're happy. They tell other friends. They come. They're happy. They bring their money to our economy and our townspeople. Thank you.
2:28:23 Thank you. Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers. I'm Tim Flynn, and I'm a 20-year resident. Not that it even matters. And I could go on and on about how long my family has lived here and the development that they've done and on and on. It doesn't matter. Well, I can really appreciate, you know, what has been done here in this. And I attended part of that meeting and, I mean, I went to sleep. I'm sorry.
2:29:02 You know, the priorities and, you know, the sort of wherewithal that you guys put forth and the time and effort, you know, that's going into this list I think is great and, you know, obviously I'm here to speak to the single family home rental issue.
2:29:24 You know, and I couldn't put it any more eloquently than, you know, Paul did. I think it needs to be discussed. I think it needs to be rationally looked at. I think we need to set aside our fears. I mean, it's never, you know, there are areas in town that it's legal. I'm building my own 3,000 square foot house in the trails right now. I have fire sprinklers in my house. I mean, the new construction stuff that's going on. I put soundproofing in my house.
2:29:51 I'm also a local contractor, business owner. I have a real estate company as well. I see huge opportunities to this. I have a two-year-old son. I need for this town to be able to grow, to spread its wings and fly and grow. I think adding another thousand beds to the tax rolls is not a bad idea. I really don't. I think that if we looked at that another thousand beds on the tax rolls,
2:30:20 Do we really need these high-density, high-rise projects in these close – I mean, look at Telluride. I mean, there's a lot of communities out there. I was just Googling while I was sitting here. There's a lot of communities out there that do this, that do it successfully. There's no reason why we can't look at these communities and see how they're doing it and follow the direction that they're taking. You know, I just –
2:30:46 I just really wish we would set the ignorance aside. And I mean, the huge elephant in the room, you know, $40 million, $40 million judgment. I asked the public to look at the demographic of the opposition for single-family home rentals. Where were you guys when the appeals were going down here? When you elected to vote these council members back into positions to appeal this judgment?
2:31:14 To put us into this position, we could have settled that judgment, first and foremost, but we put those same people back in that kept appealing and kept appealing. We spent millions in attorney's fees. Where were you guys then? Why were you standing here then? I mean, we have a resource now to maybe pay this off early. I mean, we have to look at this revenue source. I mean, my son will be 22 years old when that last payment is made at this rate. 22 years old.
2:31:41 I don't think a lot of you will be even around at that, with all due respect. So, I'm just, I just, it irritates me to watch this happen. You know, the opposition has really gotten loud and boisterous and attacked business owners and written letters to the sheet and all this. It's just, it's so unnecessary. Let's all sit down at the table and discuss it rationally. You know, and make...
2:32:10 A decision based on an informed community. Thank you. Thank you, Tim. Good evening. I'm Sharon Clark. And, Tim, it's very likely I won't be around when it's paid off. And for your information, I didn't keep putting the same people back on the council. In 1997, my... Tim, please.
2:32:50 On my first trip to Mammoth, we felt the warmth, the connectivity of the community. Everywhere we went, people were friendly. Pioneer Market was our grocery of choice. Everyone bubbled over with helpful information about the great village and the trees. Since I'd never heard of protecting trees, I was awed by the majestic trees in Mammoth. I understood why the town treasured them.
2:33:18 This town has a genuine soul. Folk cared about each other. We bought property, built a house, and moved. Slowly but surely, time has taken its toll on our little paradise. We've made drastic mistakes. Our community has been wounded and fractured from numerous battles. It's pretty obvious tonight. We're pretty divided. Scars have not healed from the lack.
2:33:46 of parking in North Village, the airport fiasco, the T-bid. Hopefully, maybe, the tide has turned. We have an almost brand new town council. Mr. Raimondo came in in 12 and three more, we elected three more of you. On August 7th, you spent hours in a planning session deciding now and what you want to do.
2:34:13 Thank you. I was there for part of it, and you worked hard. Your leadership and decisions should help us come together to create a Mammoth Lake that is vibrant, unique, and special. We need you to select the strategies and goals that engage and challenge every one of us. Items A through F will do just that. They will reconnect.
2:34:43 The last and lone item G on your list should be discarded. If you pursue such a divisive issue as renting rental residential homes 24 hours at a time anywhere in town,
2:35:13 Once again, our community will rupture and split. We do not need that. We need to join hands, increase communication and cooperation. We need to pursue goals we all support. We need to see the light at the end of the tunnel that we've come through. Please do not plan to divide us. Plan to unite us. Thank you very much.
2:35:42 Thank you, Sharon. Good evening, Town Council. Nicole Godoy, 14-year resident. I don't do this too often, so excuse me. Raising a family here, yes, I do. Let me go back. First again, A through F, great ideas. I'm so excited to see what's going to happen with our town for my kids. G, as is a very big issue, has been brought up many times, and that's why I'm even here. I got a last-minute call saying, can you please come talk about it?
2:36:14 We need to move forward with the survey. We need to put this to bed once and for all. We need better options besides an absolutely no or an absolutely blanket yes. There are other options out there. There are things that other towns have done that can help both sides do the right thing, and we need to find them, and that's going to be by going and tackling and finding out and doing a survey to visitors, single-family homeowners, condo owners, et cetera. Thank you.
2:36:43 Thank you, Michael. Is there anyone else? Madam Mayor, I have a letter I'd like to read that was sent to me. I'd like to be read for the record from an anonymous 18-year-old 18-year resident. Dear Town Council and to whom may concern, I'd like to share my thoughts on single-family nightly house rentals. I've done this with previous counsels some of you have spoken to personally, regardless of which way the decision goes, it needs to be made.
2:37:14 Personally, I like to be selfish and to say we shouldn't have nightly rentals of all houses. Who would want different people staying in the neighborhoods? The reality, though, is in the big picture, I think the benefits outweigh the negatives. The positives, I believe, relate to better maintained properties, which trickled down to all property managers, home care, maintenance, and construction companies, permit fees, property values, et cetera, would therefore increase, not to mention TOT gains, which could collect
2:37:41 Which we could collect in a positive way instead of a negative way. I believe we've budgeted for the collection of illegal rentals. As it is, let's get as much as we can. It seems mostly the negative centers around the impact of the neighborhoods, the random people threatening us, not knowing our rules, making noise, etc. I have a serial rental right behind my house. We hear noise. We've had to call the police several times through the years due to excessive late-night noise. I also have had long-term rentals on my street. Be careful for what you wish for.
2:38:10 In the 18 years I've owned my house over 13 full-time, I've found a long-term rental is much more disrupting and disrespectful than any renters or owners of guests. With strong controls, we can minimize the impact to our community. Limiting and controlling the number of beds and cars is important. I think it would be good to even have a limit to the nights per month one can rent, requiring a local property manager would increase the control over rental properties. Educating renters on the parking and barrier issues is critical.
2:38:40 Too many violations or police calls or whatever would result in the loss of a license. Rentals are happening now and will continue either way. Let's control the situation and make it work to our advantage. Some think there is no market for house rentals. I strongly disagree. I can't tell you how many times friends have called to ask where they can rent a house. I tell them they can't. Sometimes they go elsewhere. Sometimes they come. I and many of my friends prefer to rent a house when we vacation, especially for trips longer than three to four days. Isn't our goal as a resort community to get visitors here for the longest?
2:39:09 Period possible. Resort community, that's what we are. We are a community within a resort and a resort within a community. Both must be considered for both to prosper. You can say quality of life will be hurt, but it really depends on what your quality of life is. It could mean presumably quieter, safer neighborhoods. Quality of life could also mean sidewalks, pool, rec centers, more kids, programs, more police, for example. We all know this is a controversial topic in town. Most of the people I've spoken
2:39:37 Two are in favor of allowing single family nightly rentals. I feel bad for you as town council to have to get the wrath on both sides. It's what you've signed up for, though. However, what I think is wrong is when people try to organize boycotts of your businesses, making it personal. It's one thing to disagree and voice your opinion. It's another to make it personal. You all went out on a limb giving up lots and lots of personal time for this position. Thank you. Okay.
2:40:05 Let's bring it back to us. I'd like to go through the list of everything that's been suggested and we can decide whether to add them as a goal or not. The first, just in order they were brought up, was to somewhere add enhanced in-town and regional transit. I'm fine with Shields' suggestion of putting that in column A.
2:40:31 The other thought that I had immediately after that suggestion was to put it in column B, which would be improve or enhance regional transit and air service. I think they can fit together decently. I thought that was a great suggestion. That's something that I personally have been working on. That was my rationale for getting on the ESTA board. I think that's a really important piece to the whole puzzle.
2:40:58 I appreciate that comment because I would like to see that included. I think that was, we missed that. Is Shields any comment on that? No, I agree. I'm fine with adding that to A or B. Okay. I think that Dana brought up a very interesting concern that I think we missed, which is that we front-loaded and put parking in front.
2:41:28 But I think the relationship of parking to transit but also to feet first I think is very important. So I think if we went parking, if we made parking the priority but didn't put parking as it relates to a feet first goal and as it would integrate into our transit, we'd miss something. So I'm not, you know, if we put it up in B, wherever you want to put it, that's fine, but I think we need to put the feet first and the transit.
2:41:57 You know, driving what our parking needs are rather than the other way around because then the parking will dictate what those two things are looking like or it could. Yeah, I just look at, like, the village as an example. You know, you're going to go park up at the village. You don't need transit necessarily. So, I mean, I agree with the feat first. So I just look at parking as a standalone. That we've got to tackle standalone.
2:42:19 Well, okay, and then so what if we had H, which was a stand-alone of the in-town and regional transit in the feet first? Rather than trying to, you know, then just signify itself? Yeah, I mean, I don't try to. That's a reason why we can't do that. I don't care where it's put, honestly. It was an oversight, so I appreciate the suggestion. Yeah, that's fine. Yeah, that's fine. I mean, the kind of, once these things become actionable, they're going to, all these issues are going to come up, so I don't.
2:42:51 Or another option is just to add it and let town staff recommend back to us when they're giving us the work plan where it fits. Yeah, I mean, you can stick it in each of those items. I'd probably suggest up in that community amenities and or if you want to add air service and expand transit. When you talk about town-wide parking solutions, I mean, that's transit. It's parking. It's whether you structure it, whether it's paid, whether it's free. It's walkability. It's connections.
2:43:20 You know, all of those start to go into that parking solution mix, and what you're really doing is picking out one piece at this point and dropping it down and making a focus out of it. So I'd rather see it at a little higher level than saying it's part of either that amenity that services both guests and visitors in a broader picture, or it's part of a larger transit area of, you know, here's how we move people once they get here, whether they fly, drive, hitchhike, however they get here, here's a way for them to get around town. So I would probably suggest it go up in one of those.
2:43:49 Probably in the amenity level, because I think it services residents, businesses, and visitors, and it's part of a lot of the other pieces and probably doesn't stand alone underneath parking. Okay, so if we were to add transit and feet first as to be principal considerations with the solutions of these issues, then I think...
2:44:11 Yeah, we can drop it into there, into the parking element, or it can be a standalone under an amenity issue that we work with. I was going to say, rather than a wordsmith, which is what's gotten. Right. We see that it should be a goal, and staff can tell us exactly. Put it somewhere. Put it somewhere. Put it somewhere. I wanted to say one thing that I didn't mention earlier, that on item B, air service, I'd like to consider adding financial commitment to that. We talk about...
2:44:39 Improve air service by, you know, the new terminal, expanding the flight, so forth and so on. We really didn't tie a financial measure to that. So somehow I'd like to word something of a financial commitment to item B. Consideration of a financial commitment. Yeah, expand on that if you would, Michael. What do you mean by? Well, I mean, we're talking about, you know, improving air service, getting behind this new terminal.
2:45:06 To build it, well, we're not talking about how we're funding it. We've got a large potential, I should say, support grant from the FAA of $20 million and change, but we have to put our match into that. We don't talk about, you know, how we're going to do that. And I don't want to get into how we're going to do it. I just want to tie in a potential financial commitment to the item.
2:45:31 I kind of presume that was in if you had an air terminal plan to accommodate it, it would include financial, so maybe just to say including financial. Yeah, I just, however you guys can word it, I'd just like to say that to look at financial. Including financing. Okay. And I'd just like to reiterate what John said, making sure we tie the feet first in with transit, because I actually don't really see that called out in here, and that's a huge priority for me. The next one that I had was,
2:46:00 I think Dana was right that we just, the wording on this one is troubling. If you, number F, letter F, excuse me, little letter B, I don't think that appropriately captures what we were really trying to talk about there. So just maybe a rewording of that statement to just clarify that we're looking to expand offerings, opportunities.
2:46:31 Marketing. If I remember, we were talking about a complete, coordinated. 365-day plan. Season, yes. Correct. Yeah. And Dana's point was inclusion of MLR in the list. Yeah. Yeah. If you wanted that, I mean, we can continue to list all the partners out, or you can just say, by working with community partners, and it's all inclusive versus specific of you all. But I still think it needs to be clearer that what we were partnering on is a coordinated, collaborational
2:47:00 Series of activities. Right. Yeah. Coordinate expansion of offerings. Yeah, because it says Summer 16, but other than calling it Sweet 16, we don't know what else we might want to do. Yep. Okay. The next one I have was the issue on both sides of whether or not to keep G there or remove it. I've got just one more ahead of that, if I may. Okay. I appreciated the comment on
2:47:31 Just focusing as a community on being more handicap accessible. I think it all ties into really what we're trying to do with a Wounded Warrior Center, an all-inclusive park. I mean, really pushing our community in a direction where it can be at the forefront of that type of recreation. So I'm not exactly sure where that fits, but I think that may be something that I would consider calling out as well. To add it to work.
2:48:01 Enhanced community amenities, potentially. Or is it part of this comprehensive community plan? Yeah, I think it is. Either one. And I don't want to presume consensus on that, but that's something that I thought was a valid comment as well. We should put it in somewhere. I mean, legally, we have to be handicapped, assessable, don't we? Well, and I was actually going to ask Andy at this point, because most of the regulations, ADA is a federal law, and then there's all kinds of state laws which we can encourage people to follow.
2:48:31 But we're not directly. Do we have any direct involvement? We do at both levels. Yeah, we enforce the building codes. We end up with both a federal and state level for handicap accessibility issues. Okay. We don't necessarily have to require people to retrofit. I mean, if they are upgrading their building, then we might enforce the code there. But an existing building, you know, it's not really our barrier. We just tell people what's good. Yeah, because I was hearing the comment is a little bit different. He's trying to.
2:49:01 Be ADA accessible friendly, if that's even, you know, hyphenated. We are, correct me if I'm wrong, we are kind of working towards that process with new building, retrofitting, those type of things. It's something that we have an eye on now is making sure that we're cognizant of that. We actually have, but you guys recently, the council recently adopted a transition plan for the town that deals with the public infrastructure side, as Grady mentioned earlier.
2:49:26 Talking about some of the improvements intersections at the handicapped ramps, those types of things. As you have public infrastructure, we're very aware of that. New facilities, new buildings, absolutely. Larger remodels and stuff. There's some, you know, working with people as they come in and cost elements and stuff. But in terms of those types of improvements, I think it's correct. If you're looking at that idea of enhanced facilities to attract, accommodate, and work with handicapped individuals,
2:49:54 That might be more of a narrowing it down or better say, yeah, the inclusive playground areas, enhancing these other multiple use type facilities that cater to the full range of our population. That could come under a couple different areas. I'm not necessarily suggesting that. I'm more saying as we talk about moving to a feet first community, we could also be cognizant of being an ADA.
2:50:19 Accessible community. And maybe it doesn't fit in the priorities. I mean, I'm willing to... I think it's one of those underlying things that we know is there, but I don't know that it's necessarily... Necessary to call it out. Okay. That's fine. I just, you know, I thought that was a valid comment. I just wanted to discuss that a little bit. All right. So do we want to deal with everything else except G first? Because I did have... There were some other ones. There was also the suggestion about wildlife stewards and more education.
2:50:50 I suppose it would make sense to me to kind of deal with... Well, to me, that's one of those underlying things that's already there, and I believe that between a wildlife officer and everything else, we are there. I think Steve's working hard. And I think it's also in F.I., the Customer Service Academy parts for the chamber, these become program owners for that. Correct, correct. It's a kind of customer academy.
2:51:11 The other ones I had besides G is Terry brought up the issue of deferred maintenance. I had that as well, yes. And I heard that as well. I'm assuming that I know the REC Commission has done a lot of work on this. I know that the CIP is a priority for staff. And I have an expectation.
2:51:33 That inventory process has been going on for a long time. And we haven't really seen it in a definitive fashion. I'm assuming that we're going to see that. So I wouldn't want to put it on top of everything else. I'm assuming it's something we're going to see. Well, and then I have the benefit, of course, of being on the MLR board. And in reality, I see that...
2:51:54 Between finalizing the prioritized list and strategic plan for you measures R and U, we end up with recognizing the deferred maintenance within those. Yes, and I think also if there's been discussion about what is the charge to the Recreation Commission, what kinds of things they're doing, their focus is now exclusively on community recreation. I'm expecting and hoping to get serious recommendations about life cycles, deferred maintenance needs, recommendations for infrastructure and that kind of stuff.
2:52:24 I agree. That was the last one I had, actually. Thank you. I had another one that about... So it sounds like the... Let me find it here again. F little I, Customer Service Academy, is not just business to customer, but business to government to customer, educating on bears and all those things. I think we... Do we anticipate all that? It's already in there.
2:52:54 The name customer service?
2:52:56 Well, I must, this is a, this is a, something that the, the, uh, MLT is taking on with the chamber, I'm not, I think, and they're talking about something like this or no?
2:53:03 Yeah, I think, you know, I don't know what the scope is.
2:53:05 From our perspective, Joe, I think you're correct, when you talk about a customer service, it's who's your customers in the business, the business customers are there, our hotel customers, our residents, our customers, I think it's a broad issue in terms of, uh, that definition as you get into it, you can tailor training.
2:53:21 Frankly, to each of those elements fairly straightforwardly in those types of programs. Then the last one that I had listed here was Terry also suggested TOT enforcement and education. To that one, I'd like to mention that from my perspective, it didn't carry over from the forward list because of all the steps we made forward and the level that it's at right now.
2:53:47 It's not a presumption, just like carrying on the political commitments, just because we didn't restate it doesn't mean it no longer happens. It's funded, it's working, it's moving forward. I agree. Yeah, a lot of those are built into our work program already. You see what the finance department's doing, what's been discussed. So those are ongoing work programs of town staff and direction consistently from council.
2:54:11 And when we see whatever work program relates to this, we'll also get an ongoing work program as well, right? Because I know the new council members probably haven't seen one of those yet, to find out the myriad of things that our staff is accomplishing on a daily basis. Okay, then that brings us down to G. I've got one last item. Oh, sorry. Climate change. And I think that...
2:54:38 You know, Dan and I have had some discussions about how the town, how we would engage with things like forest planter vision, National Park Service stuff, larger kind of things that are maybe outside of our universe but affect us. The issue of climate change and what kind of opportunities if the state starts, you know, ski areas in California, you're being impacted by this stuff. Here's some mitigating funds. Here's some opportunities to be participating in that. I don't know if that's something we just track.
2:55:05 If we track as council members, if we track as staff, if these things come up, we maybe send them over to Dan. But I think it's something that we don't have to burden staff with doing that, but I think it's something we need to keep our eye on. Because I think there may be opportunities coming out of that that we should keep our eyes on for sure. So I wouldn't ask the list, but I'm thinking it's something we need to do. Yeah, I think that's a watch list type of item. Yeah, sure. And of course, as you know, any council members welcome to bring forward the items of any particular interest when they occur or when we think they might occur.
2:55:35 Okay, any others before? Yeah, I'm going to jump in here. Okay. Back on page 7, we put private investment is occurring in town. I just want to make sure that we understand that's a priority. There's going to be investors hopefully coming into town. And I don't know if that's a, I think that's a priority that,
2:56:06 Get us ready. And there's a lot of places in here that, you know, start answering that question. But, you know, the next wave of investment that comes into our town, we have to be ready for it. And so we are, I mean, part of this is, you know, the financial, a functioning financial system is a key component to that. And improved air service is a part of it. I just don't know that, you know.
2:56:35 Whether we should include that someplace on here as a goal, you know, getting ourselves ready for a future investment. I would suggest as part of that whole economic development strategy, what key elements do you start to look at that enhances that level of investment and works towards that when it happens? Because some of that will be obviously outside of our control in terms of private investment.
2:57:00 Yeah, it's also going out there and marketing ourselves, too. Yeah, it transcends a few of these places. So, I mean, it could be added to F, I mean, if you want. Well, I think what Dan is saying is it's part of F little a right now. When you're implementing an economic development strategy, that's the place where you pull those in. And there's particular pieces in there as we deal with those issues of highlighting areas, and that would come out through that process. Okay. I'm good with that.
2:57:29 Okay. Michael, anything else? No. Okay. All right. Gee. Sure. I'm happy to start. You know, first of all, I want to thank Bill for running us through this process. I thought the end result is great. It very well represents a lot of my goals for this community. Certain things are higher priorities than others, but...
2:58:01 I think this document very well encompasses how I feel and what I'd like to see with this community. So I really enjoyed myself in that process. For me personally, it felt like kind of the starting of our council where we can really sit down and address what we're looking to do. As has been kind of mentioned tonight, I'm very excited by the fact that we're no longer in defense mode. I applaud the last council for kind of getting us through those
2:58:28 Murky waters. And I'm excited to be on a council where we can really start to think about the priorities for this community moving forward in a positive direction instead of playing defense all the time. So I think that's an exciting thing for us. As far as A through F, I agree with a lot of the statements tonight. Those are things that I really think are going to be a very positive thing if we can implement them for our community. In regards to G, which is obviously kind of a separated thing tonight,
2:58:58 That absolutely stays on the priority list for me. I think it's very well evidenced tonight that this is something that we need to deal with. I don't have much of an interest in just passing on this. The amount of engagement that we've had with the community on both sides of this issue means that this is something that I think this council needs to address. By no means am I presuming what's going to be the outcome.
2:59:25 And as I've said in the past, my ultimate vote on how we handle that will be based on the facts presented, the conversations that we have through staff, through council, through the community. But I think we need to tackle this. That's consistent with the viewpoint I had on the planning commission years ago, that this is something that we need to address. I don't think it's something we can continue to ignore. I just have one request to the community.
2:59:55 I want you to know that I am listening
3:00:21 So, A through G.
3:00:48 Stay on this priority list for me. And I think that's something that I want to tackle personally. I agree with you, Colin. I think G should stay on there. But to Terry's point, maybe the wording wasn't right there. The concept here in the background on our discussion about this is this is something that has just been kind of laying around. And I know some people think it's a done deal or it has been a done deal.
3:01:21 Before I became on council, or I came on council, I heard about it. So I think the concept here is to work through it, not saying whether we're going to do a town-wide single family or do away with it all. I don't think any decision like that has been made. But it has to be answered. It has to be something that we work through.
3:01:51 I think to add to this issue is our codes have to be updated one way or the other. It doesn't matter whether we have single-family rentals or condo rentals. I think our codes have to be updated. I think they have to have some teeth in them. I believe they have to be more enforceable. We have to find out who's going to enforce them. I think those are questions that are a part of this G.
3:02:21 So it's not just single family rentals I'm looking at. You know, that's part of it. It's our code enforcement for all rentals. You know, it doesn't matter. We had a couple people tonight, and I've read numerous emails about bad renters. Bad renters happen whether you're a nightly renter or an annual renter or a monthly renter. We can't tolerate that type of action.
3:02:49 By those people. So we have to put some teeth into our codes. So that's what this was all about. So I believe it should stay on there. Like Colin, I have a very open mind about it. I'm open for discussion with anybody. I've had numerous conversations with individuals. I know you know how to get in touch with me because I've gotten a lot of emails from you guys. So if you want to have a meeting with me, yeah, just let me know.
3:03:19 I'll try to accommodate you. Thank you. John. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Tackle single-family residential short-term rental decision on town-wide basis. I have no idea what that means. But in this particular circumstance, I'm more than happy to embrace the ambiguity of it because it gave a lot of people in the community all kinds of opportunities to let them know
3:03:48 Let all of us know and everybody else know how they feel about a whole wide range of issues. My preliminary exploration of this is that these challenges are specific to every community. There's no one-size-fits-all solution to this. And I certainly appreciate folks who have been here a long time and may have an idea or an image of what this thing means.
3:04:17 And I think that even in the last two years with the rate that technology is changing, the underlying questions and policy challenges of this have, the entire ground has changed under our feet. So I absolutely respect the need to ensure that this community and the values of this place as a community is respected and will endure with all the great challenges and opportunities coming our way.
3:04:46 But we need to get into this. And one of the things I ran on in the campaign is taking pride in our local government. And I think the TOT committee folks have struggled valiantly. They've had staff redirected. They've had all kinds of challenges going their way. We, as a council, have an obligation to the committee to be able to deliver the things that only the government can do. And one of them is a credible enforcement and a credible single-family rental program for the current stock that we have right now.
3:05:15 And I don't think we have that. And I think we've got, you know, addressing these kinds of solutions and these kinds of issues is fundamental to our success as a government, as a council. And so, yeah, let's tackle single-family residential short-term rental decision on a town-wide basis. Fine, let's do it. But I think a credible effort knows where it's got to start, and it needs to start with being a credible effort. So I support A through G on this item. Thank you.
3:05:43 Thank you. I want to thank our facilitator, Bill Davis. A lot of work. It was tiring. It was good. Dan, a lot of work. My colleagues. So, you know, there's lots of positives to do on the list. I believe it'll take strong leadership and discipline from this council as we work our way through the list of priorities. You know, I want to reiterate that it's the fiscal responsibility of this council to govern
3:06:12 The entire community and not for one group or self-interest. There will be many challenges and difficult decisions this council must and will make going forward. I believe this council has been challenged to get things done for the community and I strongly believe we'll do just that. With that being said, I strongly support our priorities as stated and amended. Thank you. Okay, just a couple of comments. First also, thank you to Bill.
3:06:38 Coming into that meeting and knowing each of the council members who are new in other realms, I think you're right, Colin, that I was surprised at the amount of consensus and the way we were able to work through the issues. I support all of them and I kind of agree with John that maybe we didn't say it correctly and that there is a slight football in there and I'm tackling something.
3:07:05 But it is important. I've been in the public realm since 2006, first as a planning commissioner and then as a council member. And yes, it is a divisive issue, but if we ignore it, we're just not really dealing with it and not being the leaders. Yes, there are many, many, many aspects to it. It's an entire program. We've made great steps in the last couple of years towards the enforcement of the
3:07:33 Legal ones and the illegal ones, but it's a piece of the puzzle that has to be decided. On the other hand, I am also totally understanding of quality of life and community. I was one of the people who fought for a lot of what's in the general plan and getting it written in a way that it reflected the community. So it's not, going forward with it is not ignoring any of those points of view. It's saying, let's deal with it. Right.
3:08:01 My only question from staff on that is whether or not the wording is fine. If you want us to wordsmith that a little bit, we can talk about addressing single-family residential short-term rental issues or questions, but that's up to the council. If you're happy with the... I think John wants to leave with the way it is. Don't touch it. I mean... I can't wait to hear all the versions of it in the papers this week. Maybe we can pull a tackle out, potentially, address.
3:08:28 Or you could just put the word address in there if you don't like the word tackle. Sure. That's fine. Just looking for head nods. Tackle's fine. Tackle's fine. Well, you know, based on what Colin said about going into it rationally, tackle sounds a little more violent than we may want to do, but I, you know.
3:08:50 We, I think we know it is, as we work through it, as we see the work plan, the community will get to understand it, so. We're going to tackle it. We're going to tackle it. We're going to tackle it. All right, well, I can get us some youth football pads and we can. Okay, then, now, I just wanted to ask one more question of staff, is if we, if we approve them, the priorities and strategies, goals, etc.,
3:09:19 I'm a little concerned that we did not have any time to discuss an appropriate time for a revisit of it, so I'd like to exclude that part at this point in any kind of a motion about when's the appropriate times for us to look at it again. Yeah, because what we attempted to do real quick on that was for the keeping on track, I'm not sure if you're looking at detail here, but the keeping on track, we tried to tie that into the February, which kicks into the budget year, and then kind of the same time frame a year from now again.
3:09:48 Following February ties to the budget year and then similar time frame. So we tried to break it out in some logical thought processes when it would come back as a total review. We would have some other ongoing, obviously, work that need to be done. Yeah, and my feeling is that I'm okay with adopting the strategies, priorities, goals, and commitments as we've amended them, but I don't think I want to commit us to something.
3:10:12 Because the minute you say yes to something that everybody expects, on that date something's going to happen, such as the revisits and things. And I would just add, I don't know if the rest of you guys, I got an email from Alex Padilla this evening talking about the statewide, the bill for the statewide disposable bag thing. And so I don't, I would have questions about who's tracking on this list.
3:10:37 You know, are we only going to go back to in six months? But there's a couple, there's a lot of questions about implementation of this, how we went in. Oh, sure. Right, which I think come back to us as part of the work plan, but I think the work plan can suggest appropriate times for revisiting. Right, we were trying to just nail down a timeline to keep us, you don't want to just come back 18 months to now see what we do. No, no, no, no, no. Trying to build this. But that came back section actually goes beyond 18 months. Correct, it runs just past that, yeah.
3:11:05 We can leave that out if you like. So what would be taken out in the wording of the draft? If we just adopt the draft policies and strategies. As presented and amended? Yeah. I'll make a motion to Council approve item 7 to adopt the draft policy priorities and strategies documents as presented and amended. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
3:11:37 Yes, motion passes 5-0. We will now go into closed session on which is a conference with labor negotiators. Thank you.