Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2014
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 23 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
162 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Quite a turnout. Thank you for being here. This is a public workshop. So this is basically for dissemination of information. No decisions will be made today. There's no convening authority or regulatory agency that's sponsoring this. So we'll proceed. But before we begin, my name is Dan Leister. I'm retired from the Mono County Energy Management Department and more recently from the Economic Development Department for the county.
4:34 And we need to take over a little housekeeping because we have more than three members of the Board of Directors of the Community Water District here. So I'm going to let Tom come up and take care of that business first, then we can proceed. Good afternoon. Tom Smith, President of the Board of the Mammoth Community Water District. And in accordance with the Brown Act, we just need to officially notice, we have noticed, a special meeting, and I would like to call the Water District's Board, part of that meeting, to order.
5:07 And we have in attendance right now three board members, and I understand two others will be showing up. So we are officially calling our special meeting to order at this point in time so that we can participate and listen as well. Thank you. Okay, before we begin, is there any other announcements or anything? Anybody wants to say? All right. Like I said, the purpose of this meeting is information. And the first speaker we have with us today, and we've had this meeting in the past. Last year we had it, I think it was in June.
5:41 And we had a pretty good turnout, not quite as much as this one. Seems like there's more contemporary issues going on this year. So without further ado, I'm going to introduce William Evans. We call him Bill for short. He's a research chemist, also soon to be retired, from USGS in Mendel Park. He's going to give you an overview of the California Volcanic Observatory here in the Long Valley Caldera. Thanks, Dan.
6:09 Well, what a turnout. Thank you all for coming. I'm going to take just about five or ten minutes and go through the role of the USGS Volcanic Hazards Program here in the area. The USGS has a congressional mandate to monitor volcanoes and issue timely warnings of any hazards. To do this, we're broken into five observatories. There's a screen here. Maybe some of you can see that screen.
6:38 Alaska Volcano Observatory, AVO, Hawaii Volcano Observatory. The observatory that covers this area we're in now is CALVO, the California Volcano Observatory, headquartered in Menlo Park. Where are the volcanoes we monitor? They're shown in blue here. And if you can't really read much of this, I hope you can see these orange stars.
7:06 that are listed after the volcano name. Those are all volcanoes that have erupted in the last 1,000 years. So we don't get a lot of volcanic eruptions, but they do happen from time to time, and in a person's lifetime, it's conceivable that we could have an eruption in California. The other thing to notice in the blue type,
7:29 It talks about the amount of energy that's generated from geothermal power at these volcanoes. The same magma that causes the danger is also a source of power. So we have eruptions. Everybody knows a volcanic eruption that blows up. But we have to worry about a lot of secondary hazards, too, with volcanic eruptions. A volcanic eruption onto a lot of snow can create a mud flow. There are ash problems that some of you may remember from
7:59 The Mount St. Helens eruption of 35 years ago, fires, and here in the area where we are, there's a particular hazard that's a little more unusual, that's the volcanic gas, and I think many of you probably know about the CO2 tree kills up at Horseshoe Lake, and there are others around Mammoth Mountain. But the good news is warnings are possible.
8:28 And this is because as magma comes up from great depth in the earth, it deforms the earth and we can detect this deformation, releases gas to the surface, carbon dioxide, we can detect that, causes a lot of earthquakes. It takes some time for that magma to get all the way to the surface and erupt. So if we're really monitoring these things, we should be able to predict it a long time in advance.
8:56 This graph at the bottom right shows that volcanic eruptions are somewhat unique among natural hazards. They can persist for years, or their secondary effects can persist for years. But unlike, say, floods and earthquakes, we hope to be able to get out warnings of impending volcanic activity weeks to months in advance, so offsetting the long duration.
9:23 We hopefully have a long warning period. That's our goal. Here's a satellite image of the Long Valley caldera. It's got the white dotted line around it. And I hope you can see all the little marks on there. There's red triangles and yellow diamonds and blue diamonds. Those are all areas that we monitor for one parameter or another. Earthquakes, deformation, hydrology.
9:52 Whatever it is. So there's a lot of monitoring that goes around this general area that we are in. And this is the results of the seismic monitoring. There's nothing here really to make a big point about, except that as we scroll through time, on the left-hand side, each one of those yellow-orange circles is an earthquake that occurred between 1978 and 1983.
10:21 On the right-hand side are earthquakes in the subsequent five years. And you see that there are areas where a lot of earthquakes occur, such as in the southern mode of the caldera and further south of the caldera in the Sierra and Block. But you also see moving from the left to the right-hand side, you'll see that Mammoth Mountain itself became seismically active. As we just scroll through time,
10:48 Again, there's not really a point to make here, except that you see that earthquake activity kind of strengthens and wanes as you go through time, and it tends to move from place to place around the caldera. And the seismologists use this. They study this information very carefully to try to get at what's happening with magma at death. Should we be concerned about this?
11:15 Another thing I think you probably most of you know is that the resurgent dome out in the center of the caldera was actually pushed upward almost a meter in the early 1980s and that because of that uplift there was concern that perhaps magma was on the rise. So these are the types of signals that we track and the reasons that we track them.
11:42 We do other work, and this is work that I'm more directly involved with. As you heard, I'm a chemist, not a seismologist. So we go out and study gases and waters around Mammoth Mountain and around the caldera. This particular image here is from an area of hot ground out in the caldera. The little maps below that, contour maps with the dots.
12:10 Our places where we make all of our measurements. We take that data and compile it into a contour map that tells us what the total heat and gas output of this particular site is. We study these sites because remember our congressional mandate to look at volcanic unrest and provide warnings. But some of this type of unrest isn't related to magma or volcanism particularly closely.
12:39 Some of it could be related to geothermal production. It could be related to drought. There are many possible causes for some of this. And our goal is to separate what is probably a geothermal effect from what might be a magnetic effect so that we can dedicate our resources more closely, not wearing my Calvo hat, to monitoring actual volcanic unrest.
13:07 Another thing we do is we do temperature profiles in geothermal wells. We do them over time. We look for signs that things are heating up or cooling down. This slide is probably a little hard to see, but it shows temperature versus depth in a thermal well. And if you can't quite make it out, this is a well that's cooled slightly over the time of study. So when we're looking for signs of magma, we think we're going to look for signs of things heating up.
13:35 Here is an instance where we see the opposite effect. So what am I really getting at? This is a cross-section view of runs through Mammoth Lakes, the town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Mountain and the caldera. This is what we think is below our feet. The black circles are all earthquakes. The purple kind of long ellipses are what we think might be basaltic magma.
14:04 And the red blob underneath the caldera might be a partial melt. Even among our group, there's a lot of discussion and disagreement about exactly what's there. But the point for today is it's miles down to magma at the present time, no matter whose interpretation we're going to take. So that type of information tells us we think we have a long time ahead.
14:32 to issue a timely warning if anything really starts to move up and create a serious danger. Who do we interact with? Well, we interact with emergency managers. We interact with a lot of agencies that will need to know and need to plan in the event of any kind of volcanic unrest in the area. I'm not even sure this is a complete listing, but these are the main groups that...
15:05 And for more information, you can always contact Maggie Mannigan. She is the scientist in charge of the California Volcano Observatory. I've left some of her business cards there, or you can easily find her. We have a web page that talks about volcanic unrest in California, and you don't need to remember any long web address if you just type usgs.gov and work your way in through the menus.
15:35 You can find out what's happening with all California volcanoes. I have some other handouts of interest on this table and a poster, too, if you have questions after the meeting. Thanks a lot, Bill. The USGS has been involved in the Long Valley Caldera since the 70s, and our next speaker hasn't been here quite that long, but he's old enough to have been.
16:14 Gene Sumnick has been coming to the Long Valley Caldera since its employment with Unical. So he has seen a lot here. He's a bright guy. And he's looking at me now, so I'm not going to say anything else. Come on up, Gene. And he's with EGS Services Incorporated. He's in the consulting field. Excuse me for a second.
17:41 I've changed the speed that the computer runs at. Thanks for your patience. This area has been a key to geologic understanding of an awful lot of things, whether it's how the western margin of North America evolved. Okay, thanks. Whether it's the evolution of the western margin of North America or how
18:24 Glaciation or any number of things including volcanism. This area has been extremely, extremely important in the background geologic knowledge. The Long Valley that we refer to has been studied as a caldera system for a long period of time. For a very long period of time calderas were sort of misunderstood but a couple of very, very smart USGS geologists, Bob Smith and Roy Bailey who
18:53 Spent most of his career here and did most of the geology in this area. Essentially invented the idea of collapsed calderas and massive volcanic eruptions from whole cloth, mostly from studying things around here in New New Mexico and around Yellowstone. So I named the three active calderas in the western U.S. So a caldera eruption is a very, very large geologic event and it puts out a large volume of material.
19:24 And it causes a large piece of crust to collapse. So in this image, we're looking at the outline of Long Valley Caldera right here in rather poor red, but nonetheless red, if you can imagine for a minute. And this is the same outline that Bill used in a number of his slides. For reference, here's Mona Lake and the town of Bishop right here. So you can see that this is a rather large feature. It measures about 10 miles north-south.
19:53 And about 20 miles east-west. That's a really large volcanic system. And when you say volcano, most people think of the cone-shaped volcanoes like Mount Fuji, Mount Shasta, any number of those sorts of volcanoes. But in reality, volcanoes are like a family. There's all kinds of different members to the family. There's some small, childlike members that pop off occasionally.
20:17 There are large members that, like Mount Shasta, that blow off extensively and have a relatively long life and are very impressive, very impressive mountains. But then there are members of the family, kind of like your 350-pound uncle who comes home Saturday night, smashes the car through the garage and sets the house on fire. And that's Long Valley. So how large an event are we talking about? Well, in this...
20:49 Boy, those colors, sorry. The eruption of Long Valley is about this size, and some of you may remember the eruption of Mount St. Helens, which is pictured here, and this is a satellite image similar to the one that Bill showed of the Long Valley area, Lana Lake, here's Lake Crowley. So, to give you an idea, Mount St. Helens put out massive material, and it was a very impressive eruption, but it put out about
21:18 About a quarter of a cubic kilometer of new magmatic material. To give you an idea, Long Valley put out almost 2,000 times that amount of material. So in a very short order, that eruption dwarfed anything that Mount St. Helens put out. So you can see the difference in the two sizes. If you're young enough not to remember Mount St. Helens, let me put it another way. In one single, one week span of time,
21:49 Long Valley, this caldera feature, put out more material than Los Angeles Department of Water and Power consumes in one entire year. 800 times more than what LADWP consumes. It's a very large eruption. Such a large eruption has big consequences. And one of the most important consequences is for geothermal systems, that's a very ready source of heat because that eruption occurred at 760,000 years ago.
22:21 Geologically, that's extremely young. To a geologist, 5 million years ago is relatively recently. So 760,000 years ago means you have a very active heat source. And there's a lot of residual magma left in the crust. And Bill showed a cross-section with a sort of blob of magma. The thing that decades of study of geology have shown is that an eruption like Long Valley only put out about 10% of the available magma in the crust.
22:50 So that's a huge amount of magma left in the crust, more than 15,000 cubic miles. And the eruptions have continued for continual magma input right up to historic time. And many of you are familiar with a number of these features on Mona Lake, Pehoa, and Naked Island, and some of the features here in the Inyo Domes. These are historic eruptions. The Inyo Domes eruption is probably one, as the USGS says, the best.
23:19 documented prehistoric eruptions ever. It seems to have happened all in one very short span of time about 560 years ago, which is very, very young. So we've got a large magmatic system with such massive withdrawal of material from the crust, the crust collapsed, and that's what formed the ring fracture system and the subsided block of the magma, excuse me, of the caldera. But all of that
23:48 Massive ash outflow didn't necessarily fall far away from the caldera. Most of it formed an ash hurricane at about 1,500 degrees Fahrenheit that just blasted across the landscape and destroyed almost everything. You can see it outside of the town of Bishop. There's a pumice quarry outside that's the sort of toe of that ash fall. And that's why it's called the Bishop Tuff because it's so well exposed in Bishop. So we talked about
24:21 Some requirements for a geothermal system, and one of them is a heat source, and that's what's here in Long Valley. We have a very active heat source, a very long live heat source, but that's only one part. We also require water, fluid, because that's the means of moving heat and making the resource accessible. And we also need permeability, some way of moving fluid through the rock to mine heat out of the rock.
24:50 And to continually replenish the heat that's flowing in the system. But you notice a number of things within this diagram. You'll notice that a lot of the deep recharge here winds up getting heated around the heat source. And this is relatively distant from the system. One of the things that happens for local recharge is that a lot of this cold water is excluded from the system, either by the units that have been erupted in the caldera to fill the caldera in.
25:20 Or through alteration, because all of this hot water flowing up tends to mineralize the rocks around it, and it tends to cap geothermal systems. An active, viable geothermal system could not exist if it had too much of an influx of cold water, because the system would be quenched. So what makes it renewable? What makes it a renewable resource? Well, for a geothermal system to exist, almost 90% of the heat has to remain in the rock.
25:50 And the produced fluid, the volume of hot water, is only only 7% of the heat. So you can return the water to the system and heat it up again, and it's a renewable resource. It's a conservative, not a consumptive process. All of the water that's produced is returned to the system. It has to be, because if you're not returning the water to the system, you're in essence going out of business. And that's not a viable business model. It's not a viable...
26:20 Model for a geothermal development. All of that flow of hot water, totally washed out, so let's try this one. All of that flow of hot water produces the hot springs that we see at the surface. All of the hot springs that are so prominent in and around Long Valley, including here, Hot Creek and the Fish Hatchery, and to a certain extent, the funerals on Mammoth Mountain are related to outflow of that geothermal system.
26:50 And that's one of the direct evidences of heat. It's one of the things that drew exploration to this area because there was an active outflow of hot water. For reference, the Casa Diablo development area is this right here. And the very vigorous humerals at Casa Diablo were the prime driver for initially drilling to evaluate the geothermal system. This is a
27:15 General overview of all of the geothermal wells that have been drilled within the caldera. So these open circles here are deep geothermal wells, the ones with little T in them are temperature gradient holes. So they're shallow to intermediate depth holes, intermediate how deep? Say 3,000 feet to evaluate the temperature regime in the caldera. A lot of the exploration that was done here in the Casa de Ablo area
27:45 was very important in identifying the fact that a lot of the anticipated relationship between the central magma body of Long Valley and the geothermal system was not exactly the system that you were looking for. That system peaked at about 300,000 years and began to decline. And after about 100,000 years, it began to be re-fired at about 50,000 years in the western margin of
28:15 of the caldera. So a number of these wells are deep enough to penetrate the entire whole section of the caldera. These darker colors are ones that go all the way into the floor of the caldera, the roof of the magma chamber. So they're very deep. The deepest one is right here, almost 9,000 feet deep, drilled by the USGS and the Department of Energy. The temperatures at the bottom of that hole are about 200 degrees F.
28:41 That's very clearly not as hot as a geothermal system that's at 400 to 500 degrees F. So the core of the geothermal system is not here related to the central part of the caldera. It's in the western part of the caldera. So one of the things, I'll bypass this, one of the things that's important in looking at the stratigraphy that I mentioned that screens the geothermal system from all the upper part of the caldera
29:13 is this whole section here of Bishop Tuff that ponded in the caldera, that's the principal geothermal reservoir, but all of this material through here, material that was erupted almost immediately after the caldera collapse, about 600,000 years ago.
29:29 So part of the
29:58 Mountain Range to the south in the direction of Mount Morrison and Bloody Mountain collapsed into the caldera and this forms an impermeable block over the top of the geothermal reservoir, at least in the southern part of the caldera. We've already done this. So let's look at just the wells in the shady rust area that are the focus of the new development in the caldera. Here at 6625 and 5725, those two wells
30:31 Produce fluid to Casa Diablo. They contribute at least 50% of the fluid to Casa Diablo and they have since 2006. The M1 well right here is a deep well almost 6,000 feet deep that was drilled at Casa Diablo and essentially established that the geothermal system was not located at Casa Diablo but was somewhere here in the region north of the town of Mammoth Lakes or in the direction of Mammoth Mountain. So let's look at this in cross-section.
31:02 What we wind up seeing is the Bishop Tuff here, the principal geothermal reservoir in the caldera, that landslide block that I mentioned, and then all of this material that's labeled QER, it's geologically referred to as early rhyolite, early because it erupted early after the caldera collapsed. And it's widely distributed throughout the caldera. Also on this are isotherms, about 200 degrees C or about 450 degrees F.
31:31 And outflow of about 150 degrees C or about 350 degrees F. So here at Casa Diablo, the production is from this entirely from this relatively shallow horizon. The production wells at Casa Diablo are relatively shallow, about 600 feet. Excuse me, about, yeah, about 600 feet. And all of the other hot springs that go way, way in the direction of Hot Creek and Lake Crowley are outflow. They're related to this.
32:01 Co-mingled plume of geothermal fluid and the cold groundwater system to the east, but not necessarily to the west, because we don't see a whole lot of hot springs and a whole lot of outflow to the west. It used to, back 100,000 years ago, it used to, but a lot of that's been sealed off and captured by older flow paths to the east, to lower elevations. So, the reservoir in a geothermal system.
32:43 And this is what the Bishop-Tuff Reservoir is there at Shady Rest. That's what the water flows through. And that's what allows movement of heat in the system. And it's productive to the premises. But the rocks above that early rival look like this. They're impermeable. The separation between the system here is roughly about 1,000 feet.
33:20 That's a thousand feet of impermeable material over the top of the geothermal system that separates it from all of the cold groundwater system that lies above in these units. So, in three dimensions, the source of the geothermal system is here, in the western mode of the caldera. Here's Mammoth Mountain, right here, and the Mammoth Knolls are right here.
33:45 So this is a blob of the core of the geothermal system in the western mode of the caldera at about 200 degrees C or at about 500 degrees F. And as we look at evolution of the system, we see the outflow to the east. So in three dimensions, we wind up seeing this deeper geothermal system that's separated from all the rest of the part of the caldera flowing out to the east where it becomes much more commingled.
34:14 with the groundwater system. Gene? And as Gene pointed out when he was talking about elements needed for geothermal systems, and he mentioned water, well, the reason that we think that the bottom hole temperature down at the Long Valley Exploration Well at 9,000 feet was just that groundwater coming in at a certain strata and downfalling and quenching some of the lower strata.
34:52 It's a complicated system. I don't think anybody contends or portends to have all the answers here in a young solicit caldera that has been studied by many, many people and still no one, probably Roy Bailey and Bob Smith were the closest understanding it in the degree of complexity that it is. Right now we have, I can't see, Charlene Wardlow.
35:18 is going to come up and talk about geothermal energy utilization in the Long Valley Caldera. Charlene is with ORMAT. Well, good afternoon. I work for ORMAT, and I've been in the geothermal industry for 30 years, and I've been working down here for eight. So I'd like to tell you a little about ORMAT, and then specifically the history of geothermal energy development here in the Long Valley Caldera.
36:11 Ormat is a publicly traded company. We are in the New York Stock Exchange under ORA, or you can go to ormat.com if you'd like more information. And our corporate office is located in Reno, Nevada. Ormat is a 50-year-old company. We're unique to the geothermal industry around the world in that we have the capability to do it all. We have our own geologists. We have our own drilling company. We engineer and design our own power plants. We build our own power plants.
36:40 We do engineering procurement construct for our own projects as well as other companies. We just finished a 100 megawatt project in New Zealand last year. And then we also operate projects here at Mammoth, for example. We have projects at Imperial County. If you're driving into Reno, the projects right there as you're coming into town are operated by ORMAT as well. And so we've supplied a lot of equipment around the world besides our own facilities. And we have about 500 employees here in the United States.
37:09 Well, geothermal energy development's been going on a long time here in the Long Valley Caldera, both on public lands, so Inyo National Forest, and private lands as well. So in the Inyo National Forest, the Bureau of Land Management has jurisdiction for the resource, and they work closely with the Inyo National Forest on leasing, exploration, and development. The original work, and I'll let you read the days, actually started in 1973. The Department of Interior issued an EIS, Environmental Impact Statement,
37:37 Under the National Environmental Policy Act for review of leasing, exploration, and development here in the Mono Valley, known geothermal resource area. And this area was designated by the USGS as a potential geothermal area. Union Oil Company at that time drilled the first well in 1976. Multiple other wells and reviews were done over the years.
38:03 In 1990, the BLM approved one of our power plants over at Casa Diablo called PLES-1. We now call it G3 for 15 megawatts. In 2003, we permitted and drilled the WET-2 producing wells over at Shady Rest Park, and that pipeline was built to take the fluid from those wells back to Casa Diablo, and they were connected in 2005, and so they've been providing fluid, as was mentioned, to Casa Diablo for eight years.
38:33 The history on the private land goes back a lot further, back to 1959 to 1962.
38:39 Magma Power Company actually drilled the nine wells that are at Casa Diablo, and they wanted to build a power plant then, but the binary technology that's now used at that power plant didn't exist. And it wasn't until 1984 that the county issued a conditional use permit for what's now called the G1 power plant. It's been operating 30 years. We just didn't overhaul. Not only was it the first power plant in the eastern Sierra Nevadas, but it was the first binary power plant in California.
39:09 Again, and then in 1990, concurrent with the power plant approved on the federal parcel, the county also issued a conditional use permit, went through the California Environmental Quality Act and permitted the power plant called MP2 or G2. I might have got the numbers back. And then in 2012,
39:29 Mono County issued a CUP for the M1 Replacement Project. That just finished litigation earlier this year. And then 2013-2014, the BLM, the Forest Service and the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District, have now approved the CD4 project, which is in litigation. So again, G1, 1984.
39:52 was 14 gross megawatts when it was built, and then the MP2 project and pluses one projects were both 15 megawatts, and then the CD4 project is permitted as a 33 megawatt project. We have the capacity for about 29,000 homes right now. We have power purchase agreements with Southern California Edison and Pacific Gas and Electric that goes out onto the grid here.
40:15 Mammoth Lakes actually gets the electricity from that power plant. We are not legally allowed to sell to individual parties, but the way the transmission system works is the electricity from that plant goes to the point of first interconnection, which is Mammoth Lakes, and whatever happens to be left over goes further out onto the grid.
40:34 2005, I mentioned those wells, and then 2010, 2011, maybe some of you remember, we drilled two more wells out in the Shady Rust Park area, and those wells are sitting there idle pending completion of the CD4 power plant. So I mentioned binary technology. What does that mean? If any of you are familiar with the geysers in Sonoma and Lake County, it's a steam-dominated resource, so steam literally flows out of the ground like an artesian water well, and it goes through a steam turbine.
41:03 The great thing about binary technology and most of the new plants being built not only in the United States but around the world are binary. And so what we do is we pump the fluids out of the ground, they go to the power plant and the heat is transferred to another fluid. In this case it's either pentane or butane that boils at a much lower boiling point, maybe 85, 90 degrees Fahrenheit. And then it's that fluid that's transferred that vaporizes and turns the turbine.
41:30 So the great thing about the binary cycle also is that we inject all of the fluids back into the geothermal resource. There is no consumption of fluid with a binary project. So again, so here we pump the fluids out of the ground. They go into the power plant. These are closed-loop systems. The heat is transferred from the geothermal brine to what's called a motive fluid. That vaporizes, turns the turbine.
41:57 And down here at Mammoth, it goes through an air condenser where the vapor is condensed and comes back through the cycle. The geothermal brine then goes back into the geothermal resource to sustain the resource. And I'll tell you, injection wells are really almost more critical than production because you don't want cold water breakthrough. You need to be able to continue to extract the heat from the rock.
42:21 So an overview of CD4, we submitted the permit applications to the agencies in February of 2010, so about four and a half years ago, it went through the National Environmental Policy Act review, California Environmental Quality Act review, some of you were probably at the public scoping meetings, there were many, many, many, many comments on the draft environmental joint environmental impact statement, joint environmental impact report. The BLM and the Forest Service have issued their separate records of decision last August.
42:51 The Forest Service decision was specific to the transmission interconnection and road use only. And then the BLM, who has jurisdiction over the resource under the Geothermal Steam Act of 1970 and the leases that we have with the BLM, they also issued a record of decision.
43:07 The Forest Service denied the appeals in December of 2013. The BLM is on appeal at what's called the Interior Board of Land Appeals. It's an individual judge that takes everybody's document, reviews the document, and will make a decision at some point on the adequacy of the NEPA review.
43:26 The EIR was just recently certified by the Air Pollution Control Officer. The appeal period just ended and that EIR is now under litigation by the Mammoth Community Water District and the LIUNA Labor Unions International. CD4 is unique in development in that we have wells that have been reducing fluid for eight years to actually analyze the resource and determine adequacy of that resource and that's what caused us to move forward with CD4.
43:55 A lot of projects I've worked on around the country, we maybe flow test wells for 30 days, and that's the data that we use to support geothermal development. That is very common in the industry. It is very, very rare to have this kind of data to support a project.
44:12 So this is actually the drilling rig that Unical used to drill the M1 project at Casa Diablo that Jean mentioned. This is what a typical drilling rig looks like if you weren't here in 2010-2011. They're about 175 feet tall. We will primarily drill here in the summer because during the winter it's very challenging. Although usually when we plan to drill it seems like we'd get a big snow year so I think we should plan to drill. It's just hard to keep things from freezing and it's just logistically easier to drill in the summer.
44:42 This is an overview of the CD4 project area. So the power plant, so here's the existing project here at Casa Diablo. This is the resurgent dome. Here's Highway 395 and Highway 203 coming into town. So the power plant is proposed here just north of the SCE substation out Antelope Valley Road. There's already an existing pipeline here that goes up to the two existing wells out here just east of Shady Rest Park.
45:12 Bringing about 6,000 gallons per minute to the Casa Diablo power plant. There'll be, that pipeline is full, so there'll be a new brine pipeline out to whatever wells are drilled to bring fluid to the power plant. The two wells that are sitting out there idle now are 1425 and 1225, and then there'll also be a pipeline from the plant out here to take fluids back to injection out in this well field area.
45:38 One of the things that's come up is like, well, you're permitting 16 wells, you're going to drill 16 wells. Well, it takes a long time to permit things in California. So what we do is we permit the wells for the life of the project and to give our geologists and engineers the flexibility to design. The fewer wells we can drill, the better. They cost a lot of money. So if we could drill one big well, we would be done. And that would be great. Everybody would be happy, us and you.
46:03 The two wells that are there now are not enough to support the new power plant, so we will drill only as much to drill as much fluid till we get the fluid we need for the new power plant. This is one of the existing wells out of Basalt Canyon, so once the rig is gone, we actually enclose it in a fence. This is about one acre. All the wells are pumped, so here you can see the pump motor, the shafts down the well, and then the equipment to support the well equipment.
46:35 The pipelines out in Shady West Park, like those existing, will be underground, as directed by the forest. The forest was very detailed in the review of this project in terms of pipeline design for deer, recreation, whole laundry list. I think they had 21 people review the documents. So anyway, this is an existing pipeline crossing, and that's what the new ones would look like, and then the pipelines that go under 395 would be board, as is the existing one, and we'd work with Department of Transportation on that.
47:06 No, just it goes under 395. The environmental analysis of the CD4 project did not identify an impact to groundwater, and so there were no mitigation measures identified in the EIS, EIR for this project. However, Steve Nelson, who is the field manager for the BLM, to address the water district's concerns for this project,
47:31 It added to the BLM record of decision that a groundwater monitoring plan would be required before power plant startup. And we have been working on that plan with the agencies and the water district since August of last year.
47:47 All agreed that the USGS has made recommendations to the BLM as their technical advisory that we should drill a groundwater monitoring well out near the one well pad at Shady Rust Park, as well as a dual completed well just east of the US Forest Service Visitor Center that would be dual completed into cold and warm water.
48:07 We've been upgrading our monitoring equipment, and I understand from today that the Water District also plans to do the same, as well as start sampling their wells for geothermal constituents, since you live in a caldera. There also is a plan, the BLM and the USGS, to do aerial thermography from the resurgent dome all the way to the mountain to be sure we're monitoring for areas where the ground temperatures may be changing over time, either due to the mountain or potentially due to geothermal production.
48:36 We've added the Sherwin Creek wells that are actually south of town, but add good baseline data to the program, and we do plan to flow test the existing well out there for 30 days to do a better analysis of potential impacts. So what do we provide to the area? The projects are all in the county or on federal land, but we do provide economics.
48:59 Economic benefits here, we pay property taxes to Mono County, we have 25 full-time employees at the plant now, we have a current payroll of about $2.2 million. We pay royalties to the Bureau of Land Management on the wells that are located on federal lands, and 40% of that money comes actually back to the county. Last year, our direct purchases were $1 million.
49:24 And we do try and hire locally when we can to help us out at our plant when we do projects down there. Obviously, those of us that travel down here also stay in local housing and support the town in that matter. This power plant, as I mentioned, is air-cooled. A lot of times people see a power plant, and if it's water-cooled, you have a plume. These projects don't have a plume at the power plant, which is why you don't see that visual impact from this plant, as well as painting everything, the pipelines.
49:55 to blend with the background. As I mentioned, everything is closed loop. All of the fluids that we produce are put back into the ground. There is no consumption of water. And there have been no documented effects in the 30 years of operation here in the Long Valley Caldera. Thank you very much for your time, and ORMAT is committed to working with the agencies and the water district on a groundwater monitoring plan to address the concerns of the community. Thank you. Okay.
50:37 I'm going to keep my part fairly brief just to try to keep on schedule. I'm going to be talking about the Long Valley Hydrologic Advisory Committee. This committee was formed about 85, I think. And it was essentially, it came out of my department, which back then was just me. So, thank you. At some point I realized I didn't have the expertise, the history, the...
51:08 The depth of knowledge that is really required to permit a project in a system as complicated as Long Valley Caldera. So I took the easy way out and brought in other people that I thought might have some information. And so I contacted the USGS initially, talked to them about, a couple of the guys there, about an idea of a technical committee that we could use as a scientific forum, a venue to discuss.
51:39 Mainly science, but I was using it for my own self-interest in the sense that back in 84, 85, we were dealing with Mammoth Chance geothermal project that was down in the Chance Meadow. And the only other wells that were drilled here prior to that was the M1 well, it was a deep well.
52:06 And then some wells by Phillips Petroleum and Union Oil. So at the outset of the exploration phase of the Mammoth Chance Project is when I started thinking about how to get more involvement from a larger audience from the scientific community. So when I talked to the USGS guys, they thought it was probably a good idea. So I enlisted or solicited interest from
52:32 Local agencies, Division of Oil and Gas in geothermal, I mean in Sacramento, BLM, Forest Service, the Water District, Town of Mammoth Lakes, California Energy Commission, State Water Resources Control Board. We had a fairly healthy roster back in the mid-80s. And the Board of Supervisors acknowledged the project, I think it was 85, 86, by virtue of a resolution.
53:01 But that resolution basically acknowledged the formation of the committee. It didn't actually create the committee. The committee was already formed. So by virtue of the board acknowledging it, it gave it some sense of legitimacy, I guess, but it didn't constrain us to the sense that we had to, because it wasn't created by the board, it wasn't a Brown Act committee. And so those of you who are familiar with the Brown Act,
53:30 Just as Tom demonstrated today, open meeting rules, so forth and so on. It's not that we were trying to hide anything back there, but we were a group of scientists and regulators discussing possible impacts from development. And it wasn't just geothermal development. I don't know if any of you are around here that remember a name, Jordan Glazoff from the 80s. He had a proposal for development at the airport.
53:57 Our group saw that as a potential impact to hydrologic resources, not just thermal. So our initial kind of focus was, well actually initially it was going to be a technical advisory group where we were going to address a myriad host of issues, but we realized quickly enough that that was too large a job, and so we narrowed it down to just a hydrologic focus. And so the people that were involved in the
54:27 group at the outset and still are mainly the regulators have their focuses on hydrologic resources. So since then the hydrologic advisory committee has been meeting off and on the early years we met like four times a year I think once a quarter now I think it's meeting two or three times a year but the
54:56 Entity itself is being still utilized by the Bureau of Land Management and Mono County as an advisory board in their permitting process. It's actually written into the permit for the plant that was permitted in 1990, the MP2 plant, in the rather lengthy conditional use permit conditions compared to the first plant that was built in 1984, which had, I think, three conditions. The subsequent plant,
55:25 It had about 125 conditions over 22 pages. So back then, probably on a comparative basis, the early development at Casa Diablo, MP2, was, I would say comparatively, one of the more highly regulated geothermal projects in the state. And the reason that it was important to regulate this so heavily because of the environment that we're in.
55:54 We're in a beautiful environment. I think everybody can agree that the last thing we want to do is to spoil our environment that brings the tourism up here for the sake of industry. So anyway, the group is formed. We have tried to, over the years, leave politics and personalities out of the discussion and mainly focus on the scientific data, which hasn't always been agreed upon.
56:23 The Long Valley HACC bylaws provides for a minority opinion if the group decides that this is an opinion that the group collectively has consensus on. If there's an opinion that does not reflect that majority opinion, that is also considered in our bylaws that that should be acknowledged and also presented to the regulators or anybody else who wants to see the information.
56:53 All the Long Valley HAC meetings have been open to the public except for the part of the meeting that discusses proprietary information. That's handled by a thermal subcommittee whose members have signed nondisclosure agreements. And they are mainly comprised of the regulators that normally see that kind of data anyway.
57:18 And because of the proprietary nature of the geothermal data, we've tried to honor that and also discuss the general effects or consequences of some of that proprietary data in the open meeting. So I don't know if anybody here has been to those meetings. Dan Dawson was just a young intern at a time that they started. And yes, John's been there. So we've had members from the Sierra Club.
57:47 Frank Stewart was actually a very stalwart attendee for a long time. And so it's good. It still continues to be an environment in which opinions can be discussed. There is no right or wrong in this interpretation of data in the sense that
58:14 We have many opinions. We have many scientific opinions coming from individuals with PhDs and long histories of geothermal experience in the area. And there's still disagreement. So I don't know if we'll ever be able to agree on all of the issues. But the Long Valley Hack, I think, is a good venue to discuss some of them and try to concentrate on some of the science. And that's what I think has been...
58:44 Tried to have been accomplished in the last year or so in the discussion of the CD4 project. So that's a little history of the Long Valley hack. I'm going to turn it over now to Mark Wildermuth, Principal of Wildermuth Associates. He's a consultant for the Mammoth Community Water District, and he's going to discuss groundwater in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Mark? Pat? Okay.
59:09 Thanks, Dan. I'm not Mark Mildermuth. He has had another commitment today, so I'm standing in his place. My name is Pat Hayes. I'm the general manager at the Mammoth Community Water District, and I'm pleased to have the opportunity to speak with you today. Charlene, thank you for including us in the 10 minutes that we've been allocated, and I appreciate all the speakers that have come so far. An acknowledgement to Dan for having spent 30 years in public service.
59:36 A lot of it concerned with the Long Valley hack and making sure that things were being watched out for. A special shout out, and I might embarrass him, but Bill Evans this week celebrated his 40th anniversary with USGS. And he is the epitome of a USGS scientist. Always curious about things. Irene and I were out in the field with him this Monday.
1:00:03 And he's probably been doing exactly what he's been doing out there in a fashion very repeatable. And we appreciate your public service for the 40 years that you've done so. I have a very limited amount of time. I know most of you are not hydrogeologists or physicists or volcanologists or specialists in geothermal. So I have a very short period of time to try and express to you
1:00:32 What's our deal? What are we concerned about? So I have a brief set of slides here, and I'll try and go through those now. Nope, not mine. So many of you are from the community of Mammoth Lakes. We appreciate that you've come out today to try and find out what are the technical issues with water supply in this area. There are many, and it will be impossible in the brief time I have to describe what they are, but I'll make an attempt.
1:01:41 Our mission is to provide, as it says here, Mammoth Community Water District is committed to carefully and effectively managing and maintaining our local water resources. Said another way, we're here to make sure that you have a reliable and high quality water supply. We have over 40 staff, some of whom are present here, whose everyday endeavor is to make sure that you have a water supply.
1:02:05 Over the last 25 years, this board of directors that's convening here today has really done everything they possibly can to make sure we had the resources, the capital, and the technical expertise to go out and make sure that when the water supply was at risk that we had it available. We've invested in nine wells over the last 25 years for our system. We rely on subsurface water.
1:02:33 is the bulk of what we have available to us. We're at the headwaters of the system and it's our opinion that any endeavor to look at the resource allocation, whether it be geothermal, water supply, or other aspects that would be used for water, a lot of recreational use, that the primary concern of this community should and always will be water supply. Everything else should be secondary. That we need some checks and balances in this program that's being presented to you today.
1:03:02 To make sure that it is protected going forward. As it says here, we were charted in 1958. If you aren't familiar with the special districts in California, we're one of about 3,400 special government agencies. We're a non-profit. We're here to make sure you have a reliable water and wastewater system. We saw some slides earlier about the Long Valley Caldera. This is just a portion of our basin and a portion of the Long Valley Caldera. We don't take up a lot of room.
1:03:33 We have a very small catchment area for Lake Mary for producing surface water. And we have a very small community in general, about 3,660 connections. We serve about 8,200 residents. And we have the capability to meet peak loads of about 35,000 people. We rely on surface water from the Mammoth Creek area. That's specifically Lake Mary. This year, it's a drought year. We're in an extended drought, the third year of that drought.
1:04:02 Typically in June when there's snow melt going on we see 220 to 240 cubic feet per second. You don't need to know what a cubic foot is but we only got about 25 cubic feet per second this year. That tells you you're in a drought and we have very limited supplies there. We have groundwater from Mammoth Creek Basin and we also have a recycled water system which currently provides about half a million gallons a day to the Sierra Star golf course.
1:04:29 You can see delineated here where those sources are, the surface water up in the lakes basin. We have about five and a half feet in the top of that lake that we could store in. That's the maximum amount. It's almost gone for this year. We have groundwater basins that extend in the area that you see here, and the recycled water is produced at our facility wastewater plant down at the bottom of town. Our potable water supply, Lake Mary,
1:04:58 Lake Mary water levels, that's our surface water. Our groundwater comes from a total of nine groundwater wells, one of which was brought online this year. For those not familiar, this is the lake space and Lake Mary is to the left and we have a very small catchment there that provides surface water for us. We have two water treatment plants that remove constituents in the water, typically arsenic, manganese and iron. Several of our wells are
1:05:26 Have higher contents of those. They tend to be ones that are warmer, deeper, and closer to the proposed project. They are experiencing, we feel, some influence from the geothermal systems that are below it. I put this slide in to remind myself to say the Water District is not opposed to this project. We're not opposed to geothermal power, but we want to make sure that we're protected if this project goes forward.
1:05:54 This photovoltaic facility that we put in is a green power project. It provides about 85% of the power we need to run the wastewater treatment plant pretty much day in and day out. This slide is quite telling. Those components show you up to date through the month of July where does our water supply come from. In simple terms, the top little component, that light blue, is our treated surface water. That's Lake Mary water.
1:06:27 That big component of brown, that's groundwater. Bless you. The untreated groundwater is in the yellow. That's largely going to Snow Creek Golf Course. And then there's a small amount in purple of reclaimed water. What you can draw from this slide is about 75% of our water currently, whether it's treated or untreated groundwater, our supply comes from the ground. We are dependent on that groundwater. We need it to be there.
1:06:58 And we need it to be there for the next 30 years that this plant will be playing out. This is what this project looks like. You saw a similar slide earlier. What's shown in yellow there are the two existing wells and the pipeline that feeds them. The proposed project will add, as mentioned earlier, up to 16 new wells, which, if you look to the middle of the screen, they largely encircle the Shady Rest Park area, our main recreation area.
1:07:31 There will be at least one additional pipeline bringing that water to the plant at the far right of the screen, the new plant that will be built. What's of note here is that there was mention made, and I've heard it repeatedly and it needs to be countered, there are no documented impacts to the environment in 30 years. That's patently not true. The area around the plant itself, starting in 1984,
1:08:00 has started to suffer and continues to suffer what's called tree kills. As you suck water out of the ground for geothermal, you depressurize the underground surface. Some of that vaporizes to steam and finds its way to the surface. It brings heat. It brings carbon dioxide. It brings hydrogen sulfide. And in the process, the trees die. There are USGS scientists in this room who have been noting that and documenting that.
1:08:30 For the last 30 years as a result of this project and the continuation of this project. The more important point is that this movement of vaporization and with it tree kills, carbon dioxide emissions, and hydrogen sulfide has been moving steadily westward. And when the two new wells went in in 2006, the problems around Shady Rest Park related to tree kills and in Basalt Canyon adjacent to it.
1:08:59 Have increased. There is an abandoned well that was taken out. You see it there. It's RD08. It's labeled white in the middle. That was also showing vaporization. Now, that was a poorly constructed well. It was not safe, and it was taken out of service. But it was showing even further evidence that this is moving to the west. It's directly caused by the extraction of geothermal fluids.
1:09:24 The hardest thing to do from a geothermal power point of view is to keep equilibrium underground. You do a small extraction, a small pressure reduction with a large extraction. They're talking about a total of 29,000 acre feet being extracted, total for all these projects. It will reduce the pressure underground. When you reduce the pressure, that liquid that's at 350, 360 degrees vaporizes and it finds its way to the surface.
1:09:51 That shady risk tree kill area is a direct result and actually tells you that the idea that there's an impermeable mass of rock, as Gene was pointing out. I'm sure Gene sleeps at night much better than I do knowing these things. This is a big concern. That groundwater that we have is precious, it's finite, and it's very, very small in total volume. This shows where those wells are.
1:10:20 The important thing to note here is the top left. Our hydrologist, Ken Schmidt, produces this report and has done so for the last 25 years. You can note our wells above the dash line. The flow of water out of those wells is directly toward to the north and the northeast, and that's where the Shady Rest Park area is. If you start reducing pressures there, it can have a drawdown effect on our groundwater. It can be catastrophic and instantaneous.
1:10:50 Or it can be insidious over the 30-year life of this proposed project. That's a concern to us. The other is that if you start vaporizing the steam underground, it will find pathways to the surface. We know they exist by Shady Rest Park. There are likely others around the town, but they're all disturbed soils so you can't tell. It'll only be too late when you start discovering those. What does that do to groundwater? Well, if it can get to the surface, it can certainly get to the groundwater between...
1:11:20 their wells and our surface. It will raise the temperature of our wells. We have one well at Sam's Woodside, starts at 70 degrees, we pump it hard, it goes to 80 degrees. We can serve that water, but if it goes to 100 degrees, we're going to have difficulty. The other aspect that comes with that is arsenic, manganese, silicates, and a whole dog's breakfast of chemicals that come from geothermal.
1:11:49 The more of that that comes, the less we'll be able to treat it and serve it. It's a pollution problem. We're a regulated government health association. We have to meet all standards to deliver water. We do our best to remove all those components and deliver that, and we've done so reliably for the last 25 years. But if we start overlaying all these other chemicals, it's going to be very, very challenging. So what are we asking for?
1:12:22 We want a monitoring plan. If ORMAD is so certain that this project will cause no harm, then for a $150 million project, spending a little bit of change of that to put in an adequate monitoring and mitigation plan should be of no concern to the overall project. It reduces their risk. It certainly addresses the risk that we see out there. Four sets of wells. Another statement that was made,
1:12:52 Earlier is that these one or two shallow wells is what USGS recommended. Well, that's part of the story, but it's not the whole story. The recommendation is for putting in deep wells, warm level wells, and cold water wells. We think there's a requirement for four sets. USGS this morning said at least one set.
1:13:22 Those are not in the plans that you saw earlier. That's the only way we can monitor the temperature, the pressure, and the transient gradients that occur when you start pumping these geothermal wells. I mentioned the 29,000 acre feet. That is enough water to supply the town for 10 years. It's a huge number relative to the amount that we use in our system. It will be very difficult to manage the...
1:13:48 Extraction and reinjection to keep the system in balance and not cause these vaporizations I'm talking about. That's a huge concern. We'd like to have ready access to information. Dan mentioned that there's the geothermal subcommittee of the Long Valley Hydrologic Advisory Council. Your price of admission is you have to sign a nondisclosure. The district is a public agency. We will not sign a nondisclosure, find out there's a problem, and not be able to do anything about that.
1:14:17 These are public agencies that have signed on to this. It's not something the district, I don't think you'd be very happy if we were to sign on to that, find a problem and not be able to do something about it. These are public lands that this resource is being extracted from. The information should be front and center, available for everyone to see and evaluate. That's our problem with the environmental document. It did an inadequate analysis of the dangers to the system. Vis-a-vis they did not provide
1:14:48 Any concern for the groundwater. Their modeler put in a permeability of zero between our groundwater and their hot water. And guess what? There's no impact. What would you expect when you put in no permeability? We know from these tree kill areas there's plenty of permeability. Jim Howell from USGS says we can model all day, but this ground is so fractured, so disrupted, and so unknown.
1:15:19 The only way you're going to figure out what's going on is to start drilling holes, start monitoring what's going on, and provide us the assurances we need that this water supply will be maintained. And these are the wells sites we're suggesting. The location is not as important as the concept that you have a hot, a warm and a cold water monitoring point at several locations to make sure that things are in equilibrium. There's a whole lot of details behind these. I won't bore you with them now. Appreciate your attention. Thanks, Pat.
1:15:58 Next up we have Colin Reinhardt. He's with the Bureau of Land Management. He's going to talk about the CD4 expanded groundwater monitoring that was just discussed here. My name is Colin Reinhardt. I'm the geologist for the Bureau of Land Management here in the Bishop Field Office. I've been here about three years, so I kind of came in on the middle of this project, originally from Arkansas. And my wife and I love it out here. I think this is a great place to live.
1:16:34 So I was asked to come and talk to you guys a little bit about the groundwater monitoring for the CD4 project. Oh, it doesn't matter. I don't have a presentation, so I'm just a quick message. So you can turn them on. So I was asked to come and talk about the expanded groundwater monitoring for the project. And everybody here has kind of already touched on
1:17:10 What I'm going to say, and it's a quick message, like I said, but I think that one thing that hasn't really been talked about is that from the environmental analysis that we did, there were no less than 30 monitoring and mitigation plans that are required by ORMAT before they can proceed with implementation of their project. The shallow groundwater monitoring plan wasn't identified in that
1:17:40 Mitigation and Monitoring Plan, but it was separately called out in the BLM decision because we were concerned with ongoing data collection and monitoring related to the municipal water supply for the Mammoth Lakes community, which is why we required the development of this cooperative shallow groundwater monitoring plan as a condition of approval for the project.
1:18:07 So currently, the BLM is facilitating meetings to gather input from both the U.S. Geological Survey, ORMAT, the Water District, the Forest Service, the Air District, and members of the Long Valley Hydrologic Advisory Committee. And all the people that you've heard from today are involved in that. So all the speakers here are involved in that process, and we're taking information from everybody to try and get a good plan in place.
1:18:38 The monitoring plan will significantly expand existing and ongoing monitoring of hydrologic systems in Long Valley Caldera. Some of those points have already been touched on. But the intent of the monitoring plan is to monitor for any additional or any potential direct or indirect effects on the municipal water supply that may occur from geothermal production and injection related to CD4.
1:19:06 The development of this plan, like I said, is still in progress. But in general, the plan will collect data on fluid pressure, temperature, and chemistry from both the cold, warm, and hot hydrologic systems within the Long Valley Caldera. And as mentioned earlier by some other speakers, we're planning to collect baseline aerial thermography data and also diffuse soil gas data.
1:19:34 I'm in the CD4 project area to help track any potential changes in land surface temperature and soil carbon dioxide flux that may relate to geothermal development. All of these data will assist the BLM in managing use of the geothermal reservoir and taking corrective action if needed in order to protect the Mammoth Lakes municipal water supply as well as other resources in the Long Valley Calavera. And that's all I had to say. Thanks.
1:20:11 Thanks, Colin. I'd just like to add just one quick annotation to what I was talking about earlier on the Long Valley Hack. I didn't explain the USGS role in that group's ongoing activities. The USGS has a cooperative agreement with Mono County, and Mono County provides money for that cooperative agreement from the geothermal developer. It's now ORMAT. In the past, it's been Covanta.
1:20:42 Mammoth Pacific, Pacific Energy. So there's been a host of developers down there, starting with Ben Holt. And it's always been our intention to, well, the county's intention, my former intention, to consider geothermal development within the context of our environment. That's why I mentioned all the effort that was put into the visual sighting and the comparatively
1:21:12 Stricter regulations with the second plant versus the first plant. But as you can tell, the agreement on these conditions is not forthcoming. I mean, it's sometimes opinion, sometimes it's justified and substantiated by scientific data. The tree kill area up at Horseshoe has been studied since the mid-80s. I used to work with one of the guys, Chris Farrar from the GS.
1:21:42 Help them sample up there. That was long before the development really expanded at Casa Diablo. So there are reasons for geothermal consequences aside from development. And I was on the board of directors of the water district for 10 years. I know how important our water supply is. So keep an open mind. Let the agencies do their thing that they're charged with. Keep your input coming.
1:22:12 There will be a litigation that starts fairly soon at the IVLA, which is totally independent of anything we can, you know, any input we'll provide. But stay tuned, go to the Long Valley HAC meetings. They're open to the public. There's nothing, you know, and again, the discussion of the proprietary data is discussed in the bylaws, and the creation of the thermal subcommittee was one way to address that.
1:22:41 If there are other ways to do it, bring them to the Long Valley Hack meeting. Since I don't chair anymore, I don't care. Just show up and yell at the – Colin's the current chair, so he's a young guy with thick skin. He can handle it. So it's 3 o'clock. We had said that we would end the meeting here because of the 3 o'clock meeting with the Water District starting now. So we'll officially adjourn.
1:23:09 Thank you very much for coming.