Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2014
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 4 hr 39 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
606 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 I love her.
0:01 Good luck with that, but thank you for doing that. That's a huge commitment.
0:30 Hi, Dawn. Nice to see you. Good to see you. How are you doing? I'm good. I haven't seen you for a while. Yeah. Oh, yeah. We're very focused on development. Sure. I'd love to sit down here and set up questions for some time. No, I don't think. Okay, there you go. Hey, Todd. What's up, Todd? Very well. Everybody's just sitting around the table today.
0:59 Is that okay? Equal responsibility. Equal responsibility. Equal responsibility. And the last person in has to do the snow dance.
1:22 It was horrible.
1:49 I've got a friend up in Larranty, Wyoming, and it was a negative one.
1:52 Oh, negative one.
1:54 They're getting some good ones here.
1:55 It's going in Front Range, Colorado.
1:57 Yeah.
1:58 Okay, so, I called the meeting to order.
2:04 Are you ready?
2:07 Would you like to start?
2:09 Yeah.
2:10 Commissioner Mayer.
2:11 Here.
2:12 Commissioner Penney.
2:13 Here.
2:13 Commissioner Vandehurst.
2:14 Here.
2:15 Vice Chair Harvey.
2:16 Here.
2:16 Chair Brown.
2:17 Here.
2:19 Would you all please stand for the pledge of allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. So anybody that'd like to make public comments? Okay, the public comment period is floating. So, this is really...
2:57 exciting, I think, because when we first started talking about doing this session today, we had an idea of an agenda, and over the last couple of weeks, as people started hearing that we were going to do this economic roundtable, there's just been more and more input from various folks, which to me is just great.
3:23 And so it's really an opportunity today for us just to put our creative hats on. We don't have to make any policy decisions this morning. We don't have to have any rulings, whatever. Would you like to sit and join us? Oh, sure. So the one thing I know
3:50 Clearly what's going to happen after the day is this will not be our last round table because there was just so much input of things that we could possibly talk about that there's no way we're going to get it done in two hours. So the only thing I know for sure is one of my favorite sayings from Yogi Dera and that is the future isn't what it used to be. And so it's like, you know, I mean, it's a great way just to start to open our minds.
4:19 And there's just a couple things that I ask today for the next two hours. Let's just agree every suggestion with positive energy. I mean, I'm often like the mispractical person. Well, how is that going to work? But let's just assume that everything can work. And just for this morning, we're going to assume that everything on tourism side of the agenda is going according to plan and there's nothing for us to talk about on the tourism side. Thank you for it.
4:47 Okay. And we're going to assume just for this morning that everything is great as far as us being developed and prepared. We've finished our whole agenda. Which we will do someday, right? And the only, for me, the only sacred cows are, I mean, obviously our urban limits. I mean, we're nobody, we're never going to change our urban limits if they are what they are. And really then our, we would never want to compromise our.
5:16 Quality of Life Standards. So, what our farm app's going to be, is we're going to do a series of little mini talkettes, which will just be a foundation of, you know, where we are economically as a town. And there's going to just be a couple agenda changes, as some of you know better than others.
5:42 Councilperson John, when he's very passionate, and once he starts talking, I doubt if he'll stop. No, it's great. And I believe that Matthew Lamine will not be able to join us today. He has some personal issues. So now we'll give you 20 minutes.
6:12 After everybody else does their little talks. It is appropriate. Okay. No, it is appropriate. And then after we do these little mini talks, we're going to then have just some open-ended discussions about where we'd like to go in the future. So, and this really is a workshop. If at any time anybody has a great idea or a comment or a suggestion, I ask you just chime in.
6:42 Sounds just like the knees at the mouth, right? Mm-hmm. Everybody? Okay. Very clever. There you go. So, I'm going to start, and I'm just going to do a little introduction on the residential real estate market. If, Sandra, if anybody else asks you later on, I can give you the links to these things.
7:25 I have two handouts for you. California Association of Realtors is very fortunate to have an economist. Her name is Leslie Ableton-Yunn. She's worked for the association for, gosh, probably 20 years. I really always respect her work. Mid-year, she did a 128-page report on the California economy, and then there's this little six-page summary.
7:52 But that's, I, here's the six-page summary, and then I always do my personal business, a cordwood report, and that's the second report on Mammoth Lakes. So, and this is just the residential market, and we'll have to get Mammoth maybe later on to catch us up on the commercial retail. I didn't really address that. But I think the thing that you really need to understand about our residential market is that
8:22 We never have recovered from the high quarter of 2005. That was our highest quarter ever. If you look at high quarter 2005 compared to the number of closed transactions that we just did in Q3 2014,
8:48 Number is 61% lower, and the dollar volume, the total dollar volume is 75% lower. And we were just starting to get this momentum in our marketplace at the end of 2013. And residential sales are very impacted by tourism because the initial contact is usually an emotional one, they're here in town. And once...
9:15 We started getting weather impacted, then our residential sales really slowed down again in 2014. So if you look at that third quarter of 2014, compare that to the previous year, we're off 33% in number of transactions and 38% dollar buy. So it's pretty disappointing because
9:44 You know, I think everybody always thinks of economic cycles as that you're in a dip and that once you start a recovery that you're going to start moving in a steady path upwards and unfortunately we've kind of like dipped again. The really good news about our marketplace is there should be one of these for you, Chad, if you did get one. So the good news in our marketplace is that the median price is continuing to increase, our median sales price.
10:13 I'm always talking about closed transactions. And our number of distressed sales are down. So those are really two very positive indicators. It's always important for us then to look at the California marketplace. And especially at least today, you know, we've always thought of ourselves
10:41 Primarily as a second home market. So people will only come and buy second homes when they're feeling really good and really strong about their primary residence. The thing that I found really interesting when I started pulling the California statistics is that all the California market went through a similar swing in 2014, that their number of transactions dropped. Now, of course, it doesn't have the same
11:10 Variable percentage that we have in Mammoth because we're such a smaller marketplace. So the big question is what is going to happen in 2015? And as you'll see in this report, Leslie Appleton-Young is saying, well, everything is going to be slightly better. And there's certain pockets of the market that are going to be hugely better, and that is really the Bay Area.
11:38 and the beach cities. So we'll see some slight improvements in 2015, but I don't think that there's anything that's on the current forecast that will create a dramatic change where, let's say, we have a 20% increase in number of transactions, a 20% appreciation, unless something happens with
12:06 What I call the wild cards. And the wild cards are the midterm elections. I do not want to talk about politics. You know, some people believe that now that the Republicans are in control that life's going to change. What will be the impact of the ending of quantitative easing and ultimately now of interest rates? Because
12:32 What that policy has done is that it never allowed the market to adjust to truly market-driven. While we didn't go into this huge depression, it's never really allowed us to start our recovery process. It's just kind of kept us in as a stable. It's called the Goldilocks effect. Not too hot, not too cold. A big snow year.
13:01 Could really be a really positive, a drought, could be a big negative, and then, you know, if there's some sort of big breaking news event, either good or negative, could always be really impact. So that's, I just wanted to give you a little quick overview on the mark. Does anybody have any questions? And if you want to read the whole 128 pages? Well, anecdotally, I'll just add that, you know, I'm aware of
13:28 Like you said, in the coastal communities of California, particularly like the prime real estate on the oceanfront, prices there are above the peak prior to the recession at this point. $1,000 square foot prices hit down there in Southern California, coastal communities, you know, particularly like, you know, Manhattan Beach, Venice Beach, even, Santa Monica, Orange County, yeah, all the prime property there is just... Well, Manhattan Beach,
13:57 My understanding is now $900 a square foot. Oh, it's insane. Everybody's sitting at the table except the press, Sheila. So if you want to be part of the press, you don't want to share this with Marla. Hey, I have a quick question. Tom, I'm sorry, are you done? I was just going to add, I mean, you know, as much as we know a bit of our market comes from those areas.
14:24 There is a little bit of a precondition maybe in those folks' mind that, oh, well, you know, their value, their real estate's real high, you know, they are looking at values that are in those, you know, almost to $1,000 a square foot range, $800,000, they come up and look at Mammoth, they probably think it's a bargain. Notwithstanding the other issues that you both have, make you like the weather, right? I mean, you know, if we can have just a normal snow year, it'll be really interesting to see how things play out.
14:55 Is there a lag time where Mammoth recovers a certain amount of time after the Bay Area and the Beach Cities? Well, up until this market cycle, everybody used to say it was like a 6 to 12 month lag time. There was definitely some sort of lag time. But what's really important to understand is this is such an artificially driven market cycle because of our fiscal and monetary policies.
15:25 It's hard to tell. One thing I think is really interesting from my personal experiences, and I've ran into this a number of times, is that people will say to me, I don't know what the Mammoth Market is going to do. So I really don't want to invest into a luxury property. But it all depends on what they're to earn.
15:47 Term of relatives. But you know, I have $500,000 to $700,000 in cash, and if I buy a condominium for that amount, I'm not going to worry if your market goes up and down, I'm just going to come and use it. Which is really kind of an interesting theory, because up prior to 2006, we never heard that. You know, people were always talking about appreciation of other markets. I've got a quick question. How strong is the connection between property values in the Bay Area and random lengths? Because I've always naturally associated
16:17 The Southern California market for Mammoth Lakes. Right, that's right. And so, you take, like, a Mardis Camp area. Right, outside Truckee. Right. Gosh, I should have brought this. I mean, they have, like, 118 sales. I don't remember exactly what it is. I shared it with Elizabeth once. Over a million dollars so far this year. You know, and... 118 sales over a million dollars. Yeah. And, like, 20 summers that were five million dollars. Because...
16:48 It's such a, you know, the Bay Area, because of the dot-com industries, is very strong, and so then that whole Tahoe region up there, because it's such a driving market. Right, and that's their natural feeder market. Right. So I'm just wondering, because you were comparing the Southern California beach communities and the Bay Area. Well, those are the pockets of the markets that are going to do well in 2015, is the Bay Area and the beach communities.
17:16 And I should have been more explicit about that. And then the beach communities will then impact us locally more than the Bay Area. In the Bay Area, Tahoe, obviously. We've already seen that in the Tahoe Area. Yeah. In the Bay Area Impact. If you go look at prices per square foot on properties in the greater Bay Area, I mean, even to Berkeley, Oakland, San Jose, you know, a three-bedroom, 1,500-square-foot tract home sales for, you know.
17:44 Almost a million dollars. Yeah. It's crazy. It is crazy. Yeah. So for the two of you, you know, and I've asked my real estate agent the same question, what do you kind of attribute this pushback to? Because presumably the economy is improving in general. So the fact that we're seeing kind of a pushback in our market here, what he had said to me is he feels like it's people were so scarred from the bottom falling out that they're a little bit more careful with these price inflations.
18:14 And that they're really scrutinizing value for their dollar more so than in the past where they would just take whatever value is associated with them all. Like what do you think this little pushback is coming from? Well, I agree with that. And I also think the pushback, I mean, you know, and it's very interesting. I mean, if you look at weather patterns, I mean, we've always gone through cycles of big snow years and low snow years. But people, you know, have some pretty
18:44 You know, strong emotional field, and it's like, well, it's never going to snow again or something. I mean, so the snow, one, emotionally really hurt us, and two, I think what really hurt us is not having the number of tourism, because if it's 85 degrees in Los Angeles, people aren't thinking, oh, let's come up to Mammoth and buy their winter home. Now, we did start seeing people say, well, I can't want to live up here year-round.
19:11 So it's a combination. And I remember reading somewhere that there was a growing trend where people were buying second homes in Mammoth for summer use primarily as opposed to winter use primarily. And we're starting to see that too. Can I ask Michael a question? Yeah. Okay, I think because you're in the middle of your report. I was interested to read Mike McKenna's op-ed in the sheet last week.
19:39 about other kinds of recreation other than winter recreation, and there's already been a big article based in Aspen about, you know, beyond snow. And I was wondering, what is Mammoth Lakes Tourism doing to encourage, you know, encourage isn't the right word, to advertise year-round recreation opportunities other than specific events and, oh, the weather's great and pictures of people on bicycles. What are you doing to
20:07 Market that sort of change in how we recreate and how we relax and what Mike McKenna wrote was so relevant to where we are. Yeah, unfortunately I didn't get a chance to read the piece so I'll just kind of answer your question blindly. You know, I mean, our big focus is to really hammer in the summer message, the shoulder season message, the spring and the fall and the length of those.
20:32 Those shoulder periods to increase the visitation. You know, we're talking about Mammoth Lakes as a four-season destination, not just where primarily. You're really emphasizing. Heavy. And I think it's been reflected in the T.O.T. that the town records this last summer, if I'm not mistaken, June through September, record T.O.T. collection months, on top of record collection months from last fiscal year.
20:57 So, I mean, we're definitely getting the message out there that Mammoth is not a one-trick pony for skiing. That, you know, it's a destination that you come up here, you've got the close proximity to Yosemite National Park, you've got Odie, you've got Mora Lake, you've got Devil's Postpile, you've got amazing recreational opportunities in the community, in a resort, whether it's golf or hiking or fly fishing or mountain biking, or a chock-full calendar of festivals and events. You're right. Okay, good. Thank you. Thanks. Thank you.
21:27 All right. Mr. Hodges. So I need to use the projector standard. Just to double up on that again. One of the coolest things that I'm talking about is the used bike trail. Whether it's the nice space here or throughout the community. I mean, people want that. They want to come here. They want to go get on a bike. They don't want to be on their car.
21:59 So I'm going to just speak to resort development from the perspective of...
22:29 Ski Area. And we've got a little perspective on how we see the community and just a lot of issues that we think are key right now to our future. And I just preface the presentation by, I said this before, that we don't view the mountain as our, it's the mountain in the town. We view it as Mammoth Lakes, the resort.
22:55 We're all part of this together, and yeah, we've got the ski area, but, you know, the experience starts, you know, literally starts on the internet, right, when they come to our webpage or the town's website and make a decision to make a vacation to Mammoth Lakes. So, you know, we're all in it together from, you know, really from Bishop up, right, I mean, especially from 203M, so it's all part of the resort experience. The people are only going to remember...
23:20 You know, the weak link in their experience when they come to Mammoth. So, it's critical in our minds that the whole resort works at one. So, I'll just do a brief overview and just touch on some of the statistics that we were to kind of discuss a little bit and then talk about community initiatives and then get into just amount of specific stuff. So, you know, these are, this is sort of the standard marketing spiel, right? You guys have seen a lot of this.
23:52 Where's Mammoth, right? In our proximity, we're kind of equal distant from every major metropolitan area. You know, it's a five to six hour drive from just about anywhere in California. And, but, you know, clearly our market is, we really focus in on our market in Southern California. There's 20 million people in Southern California. You know, probably 85% of our visits, you know, the fluency in Southern California is as high as anywhere.
24:20 Rusty Hill always, he'll mention, I think he did, in the last community, Ben, last week, that, you know, the average income of a visitor to Mammoth was higher than, you know, Bale and Aspen, and at least that was, you know, 506. So, we had a great market. People could drive here and all have connectivity with the airport. You know, we have, once we get into the ski season, we have two flights a day from San Francisco, Los Angeles.
24:49 San Diego, I think we're going to come back to like five days a week on San Diego, if I understand if I'm correct, right? And just skipping some of the lower days on that. And then we're adding Las Vegas two days a week, and Denver 10 Saturdays this season. And the strategy there is to try to pick up flights that have a high load factor.
25:17 As you know, we paid subsidies for once the flights were below. You know, they have a great even, their airlines have a great even point. And as much as we can have those planes full, it's going to make it a more viable program. So it's really trying to focus on where there's demand. And also, I think maybe this fall, you guys might have noticed the flights were reduced to four days a week because there's just nobody on the plane on Tuesday. It just doesn't make sense to have a flight.
25:42 So we're really trying to focus on making sure that those flights are full so that it's a successful program. And I think somebody's speaking about town initiatives and this discussion about the need for building the permanent terminal at the airport is a really important issue. Tom, before you leave this slide, how do you mean super regional here? Well, so, you know, how do you define a destination resort? A destination resort typically is going to be someplace you have to almost fly into.
26:12 Think of like Jackson Hole or those kind of places. You know, we are still a drive-to resort. I mean, people can drive from Southern California here. So, you know, there's this sort of, you know, are we true destination, pure destination? I think, you know, we are in a sense that from a lot of markets, people can fly now. They have connectivity with the air, so we can achieve that. But we also have the ability to be a super regional resort for California because
26:40 You know, we've got the best steam out in California by far. So we don't want to lose focus on the fact that Southern California is our core market. And so that was a big part of why we acquired Big Bear and Sun Summit, was just to integrate that whole experience. So this is just some of the statistics about Mammoth. You guys are familiar with most of this stuff. So, you know, the existing inventory of units is, I think, a kind of pertinent discussion because
27:14 If you look at our general plan and build out, you know, the numbers vary, but roughly 15,000 to 16,000 total units for the community. So we've got, we're about two-thirds there, there's about a third more to go. So 5,000 to 6,000 more units to be constructed in town. And then, you see the existing inventory and commercial is 550,000 square feet between retail and restaurants.
27:45 So that future rooms, single family condo units, and then hotel rooms being like a half of a unit, so if you want to do the math, that's roughly 5,000 to 6,000 units in total. Current accommodations, 2,700 condo units and almost 1,800 hotel rooms. Average occupancy is a little meager there at 36%.
28:09 These numbers, I've got to admit, they were probably from about a year or so ago, so they're maybe a little dated. I know we've been improving in the summer, which is helping dramatically, you know, it's helping, but the overall number is still below, well, below 50% on an annual basis. And those are some of the challenges when you start to try to look at, you know, sort of hotel developments and stuff and justifying what the occupancies are going to be and what the average real rates are going to be and so forth. And then the real estate market, just the key points, Mickey touched on it.
28:40 You know, one of the big things is you look at the gross sales volumes from the peak to the worst year and, you know, huge, huge drop in volume, right? And when you're looking at selling a resort property like the village, for example, right? So take the example, I'm going to show you guys a little bit more some specific numbers on the past South Hotel development back from 506.
29:08 But it's a 200-minute development to a couple hundred million dollars in real estate value. So one of the issues you guys need to think about when we start talking about economic development is absorption rates. How quickly can the market absorb a new product in dollar volume? So this year in totality, today through September, we're at $115 million in annual sales.
29:35 You get some sophisticated outside developers and they come to look at Mammoth and go, man, you guys are, you guys are anemic compared to some of the other resorts that are smaller and skeer-resistant than we are as far as the sales volume. So that's an important thing to keep in mind. Land values at the peak were at $7 million an acre in the village. Today, there's a property in the village being traded at around $1 million an acre. It's not closed, it's in escrow, but
30:06 Just to give you an idea of deflation and property value. I'm also going to explain that to you a little bit more when I show you the sort of past pro forma of resort development as you try to look at what land values are. Single family home prices, $336 a square foot. Can I just add what the main adding is? So one thing you need to understand is that interesting enough, new development creates market activity because it...
30:36 So when we were at the height of our marketplace, maybe we were doing like 200 new condominiums a year in transactions between like the Grand Sierra Lodge and various other products, because then people are trading up. So now we're in a situation where our real estate market, where there has been nothing new come on the market since 2007, which was woodwinds, and really nothing significantly new hasn't come on the market.
31:03 Since the west end of 2006, 2007. So our inventory stock is really aging because we've had this lag period of not continuous new. Yeah, you have really nothing new in eight years. So there's a little bit of untested market in the fact that there is no new product out there for people to look at. Except for John Hooper and his homes, his single-backed homes, and he sold all of those. Yeah, yeah.
31:33 And we did the eldest townhomes. And sold those for great prices relative to the market, but we still lost our, you know what. You sold your lots, though. Not a lot, there's a couple left. So, I put this slide up just to remind, especially for the new commissioners, to keep in mind that we approved the general plan in 2007.
31:59 Under the offices of doing the neighborhood district plans. And the neighborhood district plans in conjunction with the already approved specific and master plans, right, comprise our whole community. And so essentially the neighborhood district plans were specific plans for the areas that didn't have a specific plan. And we've now adopted neighborhood district plans for the whole communities. And just in, what, Sandra, 2000, 11 or 12, we kind of finished that.
32:27 And I think with the downtown plan being the last one we adopted. Accepted. Accepted, excuse me. So there's been a lot of discussion about, you know, is the general plan, are we, you know, is it still valid or whatever? I mean, our message to the community is, yes, we just finally finished the general plan, so let's all stand behind it and support it. It was, you know, hours, you know, how many, you know, thousands of hours of brain barrel opening to develop the general plan.
32:55 Going through the neighborhood district planning process and improvement and all that, it's just got completed. So the point that we would make to everyone is that let's stick with it so that there's certainty for outside developers. When people come and they look at it and they understand what our vision is and they're not confused, then they're going to have more confidence in proceeding with the development in this community. So that's why that's the purpose of this slide.
33:24 Remind everybody that, hey, we've done a lot of hard work. We're kind of at the finish line. The last piece of that now was just finishing this floor air ratio analysis for the Main Street plan and going through the CEQO approvals for that to kind of ratify all that approvals of that density. John, can I ask you a question? Yeah. Before Mark Wardlaw left, there was an element that was drafted that would add to the general plan, not change it.
33:54 And it was called Resort Investment. And it was really, really good. It was drafted and then he left and it never went anywhere. I totally understand about not wanting to revisit the general plan in the sense of revising it because, you know, we haven't even implemented it yet. But how do you feel about, have you had a chance to look at that? I haven't seen that specifically. It's 2012, I think it was. And it may have been driven by, and there's a great report that EPS prepared.
34:23 Fall of 2011, the economic forecast, and I actually got some excerpts from that in my presentation. So it was a lot of discussion about, you know, what's the current state of affairs, what is the community need to do to achieve our vision, right? So both in community design as well as, you know, what are the economic aspects of getting outside developers to invest in our community to achieve our goals.
34:49 I don't know the specific names I have. Okay, I hope that sometime we'll have a chance to look at this, because it's good, it's what we want to do, and it'd be good to have it incorporated in general plan. Okay. Oh, I hope so, yeah. Resort investment, yeah. So, Tom, if that's the mountain's position, is it fair to say the mountain would then be opposed to the end of the village project, based on its lack of adherence to the general plan? No.
35:20 No, I don't think so. No. I mean, we support being at the Village as it's proposed. You know, we don't feel like it's outside the context of the North Village specific plan and that it's an acceptable project and it's the right type of, as much as it's hotel rooms, you know, mixed with what exists there in the Village being largely on the hotel units, but there's a demand for that type of event.
35:47 So, we think that would be a successful project and good for the community. So, this is just some snapshots of Main Street. You guys all know, it's been, we're working on the Main Street plan, I'm just going to touch on that. So, this was the excerpt from the DPS report that I think was pretty telling of, you know, where we stand, especially in our corridor, our resort.
36:21 So, common on the fact that Mammoth Lakes built for them means a lot to be desired, right? Semi-rural subdivisions, a lot of condos, strict commercial, belonging up to the main arterials, so Main Street, old Mammoth. You know, a lot of stuff was developed. That whole core of downtown was developed in the 60s and 70s, right? There wasn't a community, there wasn't a town government at that point, so it was just, you know, there wasn't a lot of oversight. Things got built that probably, you know, we're trying to cure now, and it's challenging.
36:50 So, you know, we're lacking what people want, you know, the traffic downtown with commercial synergies for increased commerce and retail activity. I think that was the point of the Main Street downtown plan that we have approved, Sandra, is that right? So, so anyway, that was their assessment. I think it's, I don't think we'd have a hard time, or, you know, we'd have a hard time to argue with that assessment of how we, how we get local, you come into town.
37:21 So we've got work to do. So what are the keys? This is, again, this is from the EPS report. These were kind of the bullet points that they made about, you know, what are the things we can do to change the game for us? You know, we need more high-quality lodging and with a range of dimensions. So, Ted, you know, I think the end of the village works towards achieving that goal as well. I mean, they're looking at a higher-end type of single room accommodation.
37:46 with the spot facility, you know, just improved amenities that the visitors are looking for. Air service, we've talked about that, we're working on that, I think we're making a lot of progress on the air program. We are going to need that terminal facility to be built at the airport to really support the air program and grow it from what it is today. I think, just real quick, you know, we're roughly in the 30,000 passenger plane range on the air service program.
38:16 32, 33,000. With the new air terminal that would have three actual parking places for the planes, three gates, you know, there's expectations we could grow up to 80,000 in claimants, the air program. And if you look at our peer resorts, they're already there on, you know, Sun Valley locations like that. So there's no reason to expect we couldn't do that, especially with the kind of amenities that we have here as a destination.
38:42 And keep in mind, those acclaimants are multiple day stays, right? They're longer stays than our typical drive-up, so they're really higher spending as well. Yeah, higher spending, exactly. Conference facility, you know, we have bits and pieces of conference facilities. You know, if we can find an opportunity to really create sort of the central conference facility for the community, it would probably be a big win. There's been some studies of that in the past and reports that are...
39:08 In the archives, I've discussed that in a lot of details, but it's something that we should look for. Increased and diverse retail shopping, again, if you look and assess us to our peers, there's definitely an opportunity there for more growth in retail. I think our downtown plan is really, in addition to what's already on the books and the specific plans, is really going to achieve that for us if we can start to realize some of that redevelopment work.
39:36 Indoor commercial recreation opportunities and facilities, MLR is going to be looking at a lot of these things, and there's a lot of discussion about how we can add amenities for the community, an indoor ice rink, right? You look at Brookridge, they have an indoor ice rink, they have an indoor ice rink, they have an indoor ice rink center, a swim facility, all these things that we don't have. I think we need, as a community, to consider the fact that that may be some stuff we need to look at down the road and focus on creating the commerce first and bringing in the
40:06 The right development, it made me defer that gratification a little bit, so we're not spending on a credit card to build community facilities right away, but it is something we need to keep our eye on. Obviously, transit, I think, you know, we're making great strides in transit with, you know, all the improvements the town has been doing, with the additional bus stops and connectivity with, you know, a lot of the new sidewalk improvements they've been doing to the community, John's work on trails and public access, I mean.
40:35 I don't think we've ever looked better as far as all the trail system goes, so we're doing really well there. Enhanced arts and entertainment venues, we've all talked about that. It's been a hot topic about having a community event center, outdoor events venue. We're getting by with the Sam's Woods right now, and there's more thought needs to be put into what's the permanent solution for that, because that property may not always be available. Aesthetic appeal, obviously, of the
41:06 The entry, that really goes hand in hand with the downtown plan and improvements on Main Street. It's both the build form as well as, you know, touch on it, you know, science and wayfinding. There's a huge opportunity for us to actually make some improvements now, some low-handed fruit that we should really try to make happen. And, clearly, we've got, you know, pretty unparalleled natural assets that Michael touched on that, you know, can really pitch that.
41:34 You know, the overall field of community supports everything, right? Marketing and branding, we'll talk about that. So real quick, just resort development opportunities. You know, the village is about 40% built out on the specific plan number of resort units. So you still have a whole east village to be developed. You have the former pit parcel. You have the four corners.
42:02 You know, it's, that's a work in progress, and it's, there's a lot of work to be done there still. You know, thank God we got the village built, but, you know, it's not halfway there yet. So, that specific plan is, you know, in place. There's, you know, I think the one developer is looking at these villages, looking along the lines of what the entitlements are of fulfilling that. So, I think we're, we're making a good direction on that. And, you know, we need to, as a community and as a planning commission and town council, we need to support those efforts.
42:33 Private Development to finish the village. Sierra Star, another huge specific plan, master plan that's largely undone. You know, you've got the whole core of the Area 5 where there's the resort hotel properties specified, more commercial, resort commercial. It's, you know, I think the way to think of Sierra Star, for you guys to go back and read the master plan for Sierra Star to refresh your memories a little bit, but it's a little bit of a resort within a resort.
43:01 I think we don't want to lose sight of that, that some of the recent interest in the property under developing it were definitely in the wrong direction in our opinion. We still need more hotbeds and the right public types to support, you know, the destination visitors. So there's a huge opportunity still at CRSR. And then you've got, of course, Snow Creek, same situation. You know, there's still the majority of the density to be constructed out there in the improved master plan and include the hotel property.
43:31 And more higher density, transient type product. So that's one other thing just for the benefit of the new commissioners. We talked about the resort corridor. That's really the connection between Snow Creek and the village, you know, along the internet. Those are all kind of defined by the specific plans. And then, you know, you have the neighborhood district plans in the downtown zone, which is also part of the resort. But so, you know, those are the areas where we want to make sure we really hit the ball out of the park with.
44:00 The downtown plan, I think most everyone is familiar with it, those of you who haven't already should definitely go read it, but very specific language in there about how to redevelop the downtown zone, increase retailing and commercial, and there's very specific language in there about the built form that's already been approved, as well as where we want to have
44:32 Shop store frontages, you know, on the street front, to improve the retail presence, as opposed to having parking lots on the frontage of the roads, and really improve the character and nature of our downtown and our entry, and obviously the resort, the visitor experience. These are just some images I pulled from the downtown plan that Soul provided.
44:59 You know, those are things that other communities have and the nature and character of what we put into that approved plan. So, I think we all need to remind ourselves what our end goal is. That's a cross-section of Main Street, just showing, you know, at one point there was some discussion about a gondola connecting downtown up to the village. You know, probably not a totally viable idea, but who knows, maybe. But in any event, you know, this notion that
45:31 You know, the redevelopment of the whole Main Street is going to have a huge impact on the experience for our visitor and the appearance of our community. And, you know, bringing the, instead of having nine lanes of highway, frontage roads, bringing it up to the, at least to the edge of the highway edges and having a bike lane and a parking area on the street and having a nice interface between the pedestrian and the shop frontages in the street. So that's more inviting.
46:00 Retail environment. Signage and wayfinding. So, for those of you, especially new commissioners, new counselors, there's already an approved master signage and wayfinding program. All the design work's done. It's on the shelf waiting to be implemented. So, I think the implementation costs are estimated to be between $800,000 and $900,000. And this would be a comprehensive signage program for the community in all the public ways.
46:32 I know that there's been past use in finishing the plans to utilize measure view funds, correct, to design. And there's been some application, there was an application this last fall that was denied or passed over to implement it. I think that's unfortunate because, in my opinion, the science of wayfinding is the lowest hanging fruit we have to create a little bit of a
47:00 Pull together the field community, right? We have, you know, you look how successful John was with the signage on the trail system, right? And the cohesiveness of the system, you know, improves the experience for the visitor. It's the same thing, and this design carries off a lot of work, what was done by the TPA with their signage program, you know, I think it complements and enhances that whole system. And so, so it's just, you know,
47:26 You know, how many people get lost starting on Main Street going, well, where's Eagle Lodge? Where? I don't know which way to go. I have to. I have to. The most telling thing for me was we have probably the most reputable resort developer came to town to talk with us about what they saw for our community this last spring, and we had to stay at the village, and they got lost getting into the village. You know, they're like, you know, we drove around, we didn't know which way to turn, and we didn't know where we were.
47:56 They ended up driving around until they finally found the front desk for the village. So, you know, and I've heard that over and over again anecdotally. So I just think it's a huge opportunity if we can find the funding for this. I think it's a natural to be part of Measure U. I know it's all wrapped up in MLR now, but any of that. So just, you know, things we think that are places to focus, communities, the commercial zoning code update, which is completing the FAR analysis for downtown plan. It's in the works. We need to get that done.
48:25 Supporting this infrastructure financing district, there was, you guys all got informed about that a couple weeks ago, we're big proponents of that, we think that's going to be necessary to bring the parking element into these developments to support the, get these things built. There needs to be a discussion about what are appropriate developer impact fees and what's an appropriate level of affordable housing, exactions, you know, these are things that have real impacts on the bottom line for getting these things built right now, they're not going to work.
48:52 The town's also going to need to have serious discussions about what commitments they can make on future TOT revenues in whatever fashion to support some of these larger scale developments. And again, I'll just say, I think sign-away funding could be a big win for the community. If we could just knock that out, I think it would pay back huge dividends to us. So this is, I think this is a really, probably the most important slide I put in this, I think, real quick. So this was the South Hotel from 2006.
49:19 And what I wanted to just explain to you guys so you understand some of the economics of this. So what does it cost to build one of these things? So this is a, you know, these larger scale developments are expensive to construct. They're, you know, concrete superstructures. So the cost of construction is very high. You have a huge amount of underground parking you have to support. And then just all the other elements that go into building something. So just look, I mean, so this is where the cost, these are real numbers from 2006 for the South Hotel.
49:47 $500 a square foot, just the building, that's just the building, that's only 62% of the pro forma cost, okay, you've got all those other elements that add into it, so, you know, you have the FF&E and the warranty, you have the land cost, which I reduced down to, you know, current market value, you have consultants, you know, you've got to pay the architects and engineers to do the plans, then you've got to pay developer impact fees and affordable housing fees, you've got financing expense, you know, people have to take out construction loans and carry.
50:15 Carry the units after they're finished until they're sold, so you have ongoing carrying costs that are significant. You have sales and marketing, right? You pay the commissions to the realtors, you've got to market this thing, so there's 7%, right? That's big numbers. And then, of course, the overhead management, development management of the project and then some amount of contingency, it's putting up at $800 a square foot. I just noted down there a couple things.
50:42 Construction costs, those are costs from 2006. According to the Engineering News Record, California Construction Cost Index, construction costs have increased 20% since 2006. So they haven't gone down. 20% since 2006, which included some years where it actually went down, but it's gone back up again.
51:05 Inflation hasn't abated and it's only gotten more expensive to build. So the point being is even 500 to 20% inflator is $600 a foot. So what you're saying is there's $300 a square foot. On top of the cost of building. Whatever sticks in your house. Right. Right. So I think for the commissioners it's just important to understand the economics. And then you look at the current.
51:35 What are the current sales values? I mean, the best sales comps in the village in the Westin are between $420 and $550 a square foot. So, clearly, that's why nothing's being built. And, you know, we need to narrow a gap by making concessions on some of these other things so we can get these things built and have the annuity for the community that's going to generate, you know, longer-term revenues. So, we've got to figure out how to crack that nut and make it work.
52:03 It's going to take work on everybody's part. It's going to be a partnership. If any developer comes in for a serious development, it's going to be a partnership with the town that's going to require some deferred gratification on our part, I think, you know, to make it happen. But in the end, if we get it built, we're going to have that amenity for, you know, the next hundred years. Good deal. Yes? We didn't see water. Water? It's free, isn't it? Water ferment. Water ferment? Yeah.
52:32 It was built in almost in the, I guess I considered all the fees, but so building permit in development and packing, yeah. So this is the marking pitch, you guys have probably seen that, I don't like to comment. 400 inches of average, James, a little ball. When did we get that this year? You know, we have Great Mountain, everybody kind of links us on the, on the, on the, on the, on the, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Can you go back one slide, sorry. Yeah. These are, these are,
53:04 A year, maybe two-year-old stats, so I apologize, I said yeah. Three of the four last years, two years ago. Okay. So these are our sort of strategic initiatives for Mammoth Real Estate, cause the development of transient pockets-based associated resort amenities. So we're strong supporters of products that are going to create TOT and create a combination for the visitor. That's why we're so vocal and strong and valuable.
53:36 You know, we felt the CRSR was going in the wrong direction, and we didn't support that. I think it's on a better track now. Work with stakeholders to create and implement a sustainable resource for our community. There's all the things we've been talking about, the downtown plan, the infrastructure financing district, science and weight mining, these are all things we support. And create marketer and real estate products, and strive to implement learning. So, you know, bottom line is we're a for-profit business. We've got to make money. We've got to support our investors.
54:04 And, uh, but, you know, we feel like it's, you know, we're all working together to create the resort experience and be the best resort in North America. So our development focuses are, uh, in the near term, uh, is Eagle Lodge, Camp High Sierra, which, I think most of you are aware, we secure the long-term lease of Camp High Sierra, adjacent to Eagle Lodge, and, uh, mainline land exchange. And I'll explain what that is here real quick, so.
54:32 Okay. Okay, by Sarah, it's just adjacent to the table lodge. As far as development there, just looking to expand skier facilities and utilizing that acreage to provide a new lift for beginner ski school and a couple of ski runs. Really no development on the property other than just adding the skier facilities to help support the base lodge area. And you, Tom, you said there is going to be a new chair that you're putting in there? We're working on initial plans. So we're hoping to make a formal submit of the town this coming year and that we go through.
55:01 CEQA and EVA analysis. So, it's going to take a couple years to work through all the approvals, but approval is cheap now. EVA Lodge, you know, this is the prior plan that was approved, that's on the books, that integrated kind of hotel. Probably unviable right now to get that building. So, we're going to be coming back to the town with probably an amended proposal and have to go through and work through those approvals on new use permit and so on and so forth. So, a little bit of back to the drawing boards, but trying to separate the
55:32 The base lodge from the commercial development so that we can get the base lodge built. You know, we feel like that's a priority, but if we integrate it in one complete development, we can't get it done right now. There's just the economics wants to play. How soon will we get to see something? Hopefully this coming year. This coming, like, 2014? 2015. I'm just checking to see. Main Lodge, if you guys know, we're working on land exchange up there.
56:01 Hope you'll look like that shortly. Just a reminder, it's about 21 acres. It's all on the north side of the highway across the main, the main launch proper, but so it's like median property. We're working on, this was a past plan that they had a kind of more conventional condo hotel type product that he was signed and prepared for us. We've been re-looking at it with some other park power tentative downtown plan, other ways to implement it that's more faceable and it's more pieces and maybe, you know,
56:32 Two or three larger hotel properties, but then maybe a smaller level, like three-story flat tight units that would be easier to implement from a phasing standpoint. I'm going to lose along with it, so I'll just finish up here. Meanwhile, the land exchange, I think most of you guys are aware, it's been reported in the papers and so forth, but we're trying to work through Congress for approval for a legislative exchange because we're not...
56:59 We don't meet all the criteria for current approved laws because we're going to have a high legalization value that we're going to have to pay in cash to the Forest Service and then they have some administrative parcels they want to fire down in the valley, Columbus Valley. So we've been approved through Congress. We're in committee in the Senate side. We're up against the wall at the end of the legislative session. We're hoping that Senator Landrieu, who's the...
57:27 Committee Chair, who's going to hold a committee meeting before the end of this Lane Duck session to approve the passage of our legislation. As you know, she's in a runoff election in Louisiana, so there's going to be some challenges there whether that's going to happen or not. If it doesn't happen, then we have to go back and reintroduce legislation in Congress, or we've got to regroup and just try and see if we can come up with a balanced exchange. So it's still to be determined. Once that legislation is approved, then we still go through an exchange process with the Forest Service that involves...
57:57 All the public vetting through NEPA. And then piggybacking on that will be doing the general plan of Mammoth Town and the specific plan for the site. So a lot of public vetting that will happen. Assuming it does be approved. Assuming if it got approved by this December, say, this year, then we're anticipating 12 to 18 months to finish the exchange process. That's just a secure land. And then after that,
58:21 You know, we might, then we have to go through the specific general plan and the specific plan approvals with the town. So, a large project like that, it's going to take a lot of public input. You know, that's probably another 12 to 18 months, maybe two years of effort. So, you know, it's a perfect world. If we shuffle the ground is, you know, three years at a minimum, probably a long run. Any questions? Sorry, I took too long. No, that's good. Thank you.
58:51 So let's kind of get through all the little talks and then we can get to some questions. Thank you very much. Thank you. All right. Next up, councilperson Bernie. Oh, that's me. Okay. So I think it's nice to see that there seems to be a lot of parallel in what we're discussing here.
59:17 Mickey and Sandra and I sat down about a week ago kind of framing this. And what we kind of looked at for this discussion, this one specifically was kind of three legs of a stool. We look at development, which Tom talked a lot about, diversification of our current business model, which I think we're going to get to later, and enhancing the Mammoth experience would kind of be focusing on what is our tourism-driven economy currently.
59:45 And trying to improve that. And so that's kind of the area that I'm looking to focus on. Most of what I'm going to talk about here, and I'll be brief, comes from a conversation actually that Michael and I had right after I got on council and he got on Planning Commission. The question I posed to him was pretty simple. When you are going to the nation and the world and trying to promote Mammoth Lakes as a destination, why should you come to Mammoth versus one of our competitors?
1:00:14 What are you focusing on as our strengths? What are our selling points? And what are kind of the weaknesses that you're looking to hide? So we kind of broke it down into a couple of strengths, a couple of weaknesses, and what I would like to talk about is just as a council and a planning commission, what are the areas that we can influence positively on both sides of that spectrum? So what's better, strengths or weaknesses? Good news, bad news. And positive. And positive.
1:00:43 Okay. And this is certainly by no means a comprehensive list, but there's actually a lot of overlap. So there's a lot of overlap from Tom, what you just discussed. But one of the things was a lack of conference space. That really, I think, inhibits our ability to bring
1:01:08 Groups here drive shoulder season business, those type of things. We have a lack of flagged properties here. Overall, I think our lodging and amenity base is lacking compared to our peer resorts, and that's something that obviously we discussed. A lot of parallel there. Just in general, the kind of off-mountain amenities and experience when we talk about not having a historic downtown.
1:01:35 Not doing a very good job of placemaking, having a variety. When we talk about all of our plans, we talk about being a four-season indoor-outdoor experience. And I think our man-made is not complementing our natural environment. When the weather's great, perfect, there's a million things to do. If the weather's not great, we're very limited. And the last piece would be the overall customer service that we're providing as a community.
1:02:04 Obviously, I think both Planning Commission and Council can drive some of these things. We, I think, are aware that conference space would be a benefit to this community, so we can help to drive that. We do need to kind of facilitate bringing in some of these hotel lodging properties, flag properties. That's definitely something we can influence in the off-mountain amenity-based experience, which is really kind of my focus as a council member.
1:02:28 I think the thing that we can address most quickly would be the customer service in town. Craig and I had a long conversation on that. I know you guys are moving forward with the PEAP program and you have a committee working on that. But I think we really need to focus as a community on providing that seamless, positive customer service experience. So I think we have some businesses that do a great job. I think we have a lot of businesses that may think they do a great job but don't.
1:02:54 And so if a guest is coming to town, our goal is from the time they enter to the time they leave, they have a seamless positive customer service experience. So I've identified that as the area that we can most quickly address. Obviously we can continue to have our eye on the prize room, flag properties and conference space and building amenities, those are all going to be a process, but I think addressing the customer service would be something that we can target more immediately.
1:03:21 On the strength side of things, we have more than weaknesses. You know, what we discussed is in general the on-mountain experience. For those of you that travel and ski and experience other mountains, it's as good as it gets, and that's a very positive thing. Our weather is something that Michael says he really tries to sell, the kind of California vibe.
1:03:47 There is absolutely a difference as someone that used to live in Colorado and now lives here between the weather. It's shocking to me now when it hits, you know, five degrees, an absolute baby, and that was every week for eight months when we live in Colorado. So, you know, our weather here, the consistency is sunshine. I tell people when they call Black Tide, we have two types of weather here. It's either sunny and beautiful or it's dumping snow.
1:04:15 And that's a great thing. So we have a long season. Our snow holds very well. There's a lot of consistency. We don't have much avalanche danger. There's a lot of positives on the kind of California experience, that sunshine, that nice weather, beautiful scenery, et cetera. Our region is a major selling point because that was touched on before. I would say the lion share of the international clients that we get are all doing the exact same circuit.
1:04:42 So, something in that kind of regional circuit between the Bay Area and Southern California with us in between in Vegas seems to be what most people are hitting, and that is a selling point for us. When you're coming from Europe and you're here for three weeks,
1:05:09 Unfortunately, I don't think we're going to get them here for three weeks in skiing for three weeks straight. So they want to take that major trip. They want to do a few things, experience kind of what America has to offer, and we're kind of well positioned in that region. The last thing we kind of talked about is I like to make a distinction between character and charm.
1:05:32 I think Mammoth absolutely has character. I think we are lacking charm. So, you know, the character that I would say that Mammoth has is a very unassuming attitude. You can come here and you can go to the nicest restaurant in town in flip-flops and board shorts. I think that's a good thing. I think that's a positive thing. It's not hoity-toity here. It's not fur coats. So we definitely have that character, this kind of outdoor mountain vibe where it's come as you are.
1:06:00 Those are all things that I think we are hitting on appropriately. We do have a great on-mountain experience. We do have great weather. Give us some snow, please. We are part of that region, which is a major benefit to us, and I think this community does have character that we don't want to lose. A couple of the other things that he mentioned that they sell to the community where I do think we need improvement would be that it's easy to get here. So when you look at our airport,
1:06:29 It is the most convenient airport and ski country when you land. We are eight miles from town. For the most part, you have a free shuttle or a very cheap cab ride. You're not looking at 45 minutes to an hour like most of our competitors. The problem I see with that is we need a default plan. When people cannot land here, our backup plan is horribly deficient. So that is something I think we need to focus on as a council planning commission.
1:06:57 How we can enhance that experience and make it seamless for somebody that can't land if we're in the middle of a whiteout, what do they do so that we can still get them here, they can still get their lodging nights, they can still get their days on the hill, and I'm mostly talking about the winter in this case. The second area is when you're marketing to people that are coming from the rest of the country, you're marketing to international people, no need for a car is a really strong selling point.
1:07:26 If you were to go to Tahoe, for example, it's much more like an East Coast vibe, where you go and you stay in Truckee, you do need to rent a car, and you're going to drive to whatever resort that you're going to do for that day. Whereas Mammoth, I think, we have the potential to be the only true ski town in California, in the sense that we are a contiguous town, you have free transit, you can walk places, that's all a very positive thing.
1:07:52 And I think ESTA's made tremendous strides as far as not needing a car here. But I think there's some areas where we're still coming up short as far as consistency, as far as scaling up for busy time periods, as far as communicating what our guests need to know so that they can get around town without a car. So that's kind of what we talked about. And, you know, those are the things that I'm kind of looking on, focusing on improving.
1:08:20 The air service, improving the experience if you come here without a vehicle, and focusing on improving our customer service. So that's kind of what I've got. Good deal. Can you say that in seven languages now? I think you hit upon all the points that we discussed. I can't emphasize enough how strong it is to have...
1:08:47 California as our main message when we promote Mammoth Lakes Internationally. I mean, it's great that you can fly in Denver and then you go to some of the Front Range Mountains, but Denver, for the most part, is not anywhere near as sexy internationally than San Francisco or Los Angeles or, you know, for that matter, Las Vegas now. People want Las Vegas, so it's a tremendous asset for us to have that connectivity to all those gateway cities. San Diego as well.
1:09:15 Sin and ski is one package we call it, and service ski would be the other. I just interjected, or I mentioned to you that the air service group is working on a backup plant. Not in the water, yeah. So there's a discussion about it sooner rather than later. Yeah, there is stuff that works. Yeah, I agree. And I think, you know, the airport's a work in progress. I think absolutely that's one of the most critical things to our long-term viabilities and community.
1:09:45 I'm still not convinced that we have the buy-in that I would like to see from our community, but I think it is a work in progress. We're starting to move out beyond our Southern California base markets. That's a great thing. I was really pleased to see Las Vegas and Denver out of this year, and I think we just need to continue to move forward with the airport terminal, with a viable backup plan, those type of things that when we put the airport in,
1:10:13 Weren't there, and I think hopefully we'll be there soon. But, you know, just looking at, as you mentioned, some of these other peer resorts, I mean, they've already achieved 80, 100, 150,000 appointments, and what that does to bolster your economy and those type of things is absolutely the goal that I think we need to have. Because as you mentioned, the average length stay is longer, and the average spend is higher.
1:10:38 Because anyway, like, if you look at Jackson Hole in that example, they have the 100 plus is because Yellowstone, right, National Park, we got this semi-equal natural asset, so there's no reason we can't keep those numbers. Yeah, I mean, you've got resorts that are, they're hosting close to a million skier days. Steamboat, for example, is about 900,000, and that's almost predominantly air travel. People don't drive to Steamboat. So, you know, there are resorts that...
1:11:05 Achieve very high numbers of visitations simply off flight travel. So, you know, I think one of the resorts, when you talk about super regional, you know, one of the resorts that's done that very well is Vail. I mean, they really leverage the fact that they do have a Denver Drive market in addition to all of the destination travels they're getting. So, I think we just need to continue to move in that direction. Cool. Dan, do you want to give us a brief overview of where our current sources of revenue come from?
1:11:37 I think it's probably on the town's general fund. We have a lot of other revenues bouncing around. We've got about $4 million in capital projects this year. You know, there's $4 million that passes through the town. We're ready to achieve it. We get...
1:12:08 Million plus, no reimbursement dollars, and gas tax funds. Some of the restricted revenue is not on the list here on purpose, and it starts to really, their footnotes are longer than the list of revenues. But from a general fund standpoint, so I'll start off with the revenue comparison, page one there. As you know, it's kind of looking, it's going to be a couple of years looking at it anyway in terms of,
1:12:38 The dominant one that pops out is the DOT revenue, just over $12 million, $12.13, should be about less than $10.05 last year, and then $11.06 in the budget in this coming year. 63% of our revenue in that general fund category comes out of there. If you put in the property tax and sales tax, you're at 85% of revenue from those three sources. The in-route property tax is going to have to set them out, and there's a bunch of different state issues that go with that.
1:13:06 That's pushing 90% of our revenue in those sources. So it's a very narrow banded revenue source in terms of the general fund element and obviously dominated by TOT. You go to other communities around the state, you'll see some similar banding, not quite as tight, but often it'll either be property tax or sales tax is driving that large number versus TOT. Mammoth competes with Yonville and
1:13:35 But if you take a look at all of these and the ones that we actually have direct control over,
1:14:04 Just extremely limited. Property tax, again, driven by state law, you know, we end up with about, we get about 6%, give or take, of the revenue generated within town limits. The rest of that goes via county, schools, choir district, and water district, part of the primary taxing agencies there. So, the only way we actually grow property taxes really is value. So, in one sense, people love it, and we like it when values go up.
1:14:32 Taxes then go up accordingly. Other folks, we've had discussions with folks who talk about their own value. It's a good thing to go up in value. They say, no, it's not. I just pay more taxes. I plan to leave my house feet first. So I just, you never reassess it. We've had those discussions with folks. I'm not so much here, but in other places. A growing real estate market for value is, we look at it as a positive thing. Not all of our owners or investors or property people who live in the community agree with that.
1:15:01 Hawks in the drive about increasing property value is a good thing. Some folks don't agree with that. But the other side of that is the limit, the Prop 13 limit, so all the existing stuff only goes up 2% per year. So there's a built-in cap. The last few years, some folks, with the ADA reassessments, the things drop in value, they go down based on what has actually gone on in the marketplace. So the extent stuff has dropped.
1:15:28 It can go back up to where it would have been. It can go up quickly. It's not capped to 2%. So if you had a massive resurgence in value here, you could actually gain all that loss in one year. Don't expect to see that to happen. But when you talk to folks, at least my experience has been, most of them don't realize that that makeup of what's been lost can be regained over a shorter period of time. The other element of the impact that object, something is stolen, is reset the sales price, and that's another issue for us in the property tax.
1:15:58 Sales tax obviously driven what's going on in the community in terms of the spend. The interesting thing for last year was with the decline in TOT and the decline in visitors, the sales tax held very well, frankly. The actual point of sale only gets about 2%, but accounting pool in how taxes are collected that aren't site-specific actually had a good uptick in terms of revenue.
1:16:26 So, there's different things driving sales tax sometimes other than just people in town. If that is one that you don't have influence over the rate, the question becomes, but you have influence over how much spend people do in the community and what's on taxable items. A lot of stuff people buy on a normal basis aren't taxable. If you look at the list, it's several pages long of the exempt items from sales tax.
1:16:52 TOT, you're very much aware of, drivers behind that early being, what's the average daily rate in the occupancy loads that we have as well as the collection rates. Everything else that we deal with, we end up dealing with people on, whether it be business license, which is a direct pass through to the tourism side, but all of our fees and charges, we have a lot of makeback and corpus developers, et cetera, in terms of what we're doing from the general fund side is a relatively small piece of our budget.
1:17:19 Fees and Charges are just that. They need to be tied back to what we actually spend in the cost recovery element. To the extent that you exceed your actual cost, it becomes a tax, which on your back, you either have to go to the voters or the property bank, et cetera. So there's a balance in that. Grants can swing wildly year to year. We had several, a couple years ago from the planning department that were very effective in some of the downtown planning and some other grants that we had.
1:17:48 One of our challenges is working through those and the hard part of grants is whether or not you staff up to do them or not. When you grant those away, then you're staffing back down if you will. And that's up and down. The grants in the current year are primarily with $100,000. There is a primarily tied to our police department cost grant, which is an annual allocation out of the state that we use to battle with the legislature over to retain those.
1:18:13 Not this session, the session before, they actually shifted funding around, so they're going to keep your grants funds, but for the COPS program, that's some discretionary dollars that went out to communities, they kept those and used that to fund the COPS grants, so we actually lost capability on flexibility to retain the other grant, it's kind of an interesting shell game. The other category, the primary interest, I mean, reimbursements or charges we have, we use facilities or something of that nature that come back in, again, that can swing up and down, depending.
1:18:43 What's going on in the community? I think the take home there is really, in California, probably done this, some other states have followed the lead, but bottom line is we don't want to have local governments to have a lot of flexibility in how you create revenue. We don't trust you. We don't want our property tax to go up. We don't want our sales tax to go up. All those things are generally, unless we get a vote on it, and unless we get to say where it goes. And that's not unique to me, but that's across the state. So a lot of times people say, well, how do you generate more revenue?
1:19:14 And generally, you get very creative in how you do it. You reallocate existing revenue often. Or you end up saying, how do we really change our economic elements in the community to drive those other key revenue drivers? And that's a lot of discussion I think here today. On that, in terms of the expenditure side of that and the back side, you end up with kind of straight appropriations for the town departments on the top half of the little spreadsheet there.
1:19:45 General government is the highest, that tends to tie into my office, our county department, that actually includes the lawsuit payment we make every year, HR personnel, those types of elements, the court's office that goes through that, town council, et cetera. Operationally, public safety is the largest body of that, even though they've been significantly diminished over time. You see the other ones following through that, on down, federal details on those.
1:20:14 The transfers out is how we handle a lot of the funding within the general funds tied to the various local commitments that have been made as well as supporting the other departmental areas. Tourism transfer out, that's really a commitment to MLT. Airport, there's ongoing subsidy to the airport. Don't see that going away anywhere in the near future. The transit, same thing in terms of the town's commitment to that. Housing is the same. The transfer of the gas tax fund.
1:20:43 It's a larger chunk of general fund that goes into that. That's our road maintenance and other elements. We actually move it all over matching against gas tax. That gets rid of a lot of accounting issues with the state when they come in and say, how did you spend gas tax dollars? Did it only get spent on basically curb-to-curb type roadway work or some sidewalk work? Just showing that we have a large general fund match going into that. We'll take a lot of issues off the table because of general funds covered.
1:21:12 Whatever is not eligible for gas tax. It is relatively strict and the legislature has changed some things. There's four or five different gas tax categories that we actually received. Used to be they were very much restricted. One could be used for like for street rehabilitation but not maintenance. So you could put your asphalt down but you could go in and do crack sealing. Another one you could use like for parking but you couldn't be used for sidewalks and whatever mess.
1:21:37 And so a lot of that's been changed now to make the uses more similar. I think there's still a couple that have really new differences to it. But having the general fund offset on that really takes a lot of that issue off the table when we actually sit down and go to an audit process. The last audit we just had one that goes back, I think, 10 years worth. We came out pretty clean on that, so that was nice.
1:21:58 So that's the other way. Shifting out into that, that's really awesome, actually, the snow cloud dollars and the snow dollars that we get. We get about a million to a million and three state reimbursement for snow removal. Part of that goes back out to our assessment districts as well. And then the others are pretty straightforward. Very limited in terms of any capital funding out of the general fund the last several years. And then debt services are regular payments. And the debt we have, non-limigation related for property purchases primarily.
1:22:28 Walked through that, so, kind of give you a feel for that budget side of the house, again, if you take, you know, mostly, you know, I'll say that, general governmental operations and public safety, you're, like, beating up a large share of our revenues. Where's that there? Settlement, where's that? Settlement, it's actually sitting at general government. In general, okay. Yeah, it's $2 million a year to make a payment. We hold down this million. That's right. Sorry about that. So.
1:22:56 Yeah, our first quarter's always up. We paid a $2 million out on that. We paid a little over $1 million out on insurance payments. So the first quarter, we spent about 60% of that general government line item. So we played catch-up for the rest of the year. And that's for 20 years? Yeah, 23, I think, until 30 years. So I have a question for you. Yes. Going back to your revenue side. Yes. And this is for Council, too.
1:23:25 Because, you know, what I've heard over and over again is we're probably the only city in the United States that 63% of their general revenue comes from TOT. We're not the only, but it's... Close. Yeah, California, at least. There's three of us that compete for that percentage of general fund from TOT. So, if you could design your ideal revenue allocation, what percentage would you like to see that number? Well, I guess it's...
1:23:55 Qualify that. Most agencies you look at, and I'm familiar with, that would be somewhere in the 10 to 15 percent range. Right. But they're not dominated as a single tourism destination resort. Right. So if you're doing that, it'd be closer, I think for here, it'd be better down to 50 to 45 percent if you weren't so reliant on it. Okay. One of our issues on our bond ratings we look at, they look at that here and go, oh, so if you have a bad tourism year, how do you respond to that?
1:24:22 It's similar, other opinions have the same issue where they're a one industrial town. Right. But what do you do with that industrial hazard spot? So it's your contingency planning, what's your reserve levels? What do you do to diversify your economy? And you can diversify the TOT element. One of the arguments we do make is 60% of it still comes in December, January, February, and March. 60% of that comes in those four months.
1:24:49 How do you begin to flatten that out? Say maybe it's only 50 or only 40 maybe more realistic to those months. We'll probably never be there completely because some of our months are unknown in terms of weather. But yeah, if you can get that down below 50%, that would make us a lot healthier financially from a stability standpoint and also from a boundary perspective. And that's consistent with some of the, like I've only seen figures a couple of times where some other tourism-based communities, but it was.
1:25:16 More around the kind of 48, 50, 52% range for them. Kind of to dovetail off of that question, sales tax at roughly 10%. Presumably that may be something we're able to bump up by providing a better retail environment and stability and spending.
1:25:38 What ideally would that number be? What are some of our peer tourism dependent? Probably more than 20% range. 20% on sales tax. And a lot of that is you have much more of a retail base that's supported both from a local resident base as well as your visitor base. And Mammoth really suffers from the, you don't have to raise your hand. My guess is really around the table, do not do 100% of your shopping in Mammoth. Why?
1:26:05 You probably do. Because you never found Carson City. So, I mean, that is a real issue in terms of what do you bring into the community that supplements and augments what you have that doesn't destroy a part of the community level. That's an ongoing debate. A lot of resorts, we don't want a lot of change, we don't want a lot of large stores, we don't want these things because we're x, y, this isn't just resort communities with others. And the questions, that's great, but you understand local government, that's what their primary source of revenue.
1:26:34 And if you don't have it here, people will go spend a lot of dollars elsewhere. So, but yeah, if you're in the 20% range, would be probably going to be more healthy for, we're heavily dependent on bonds, gas stations, and then restaurants. There's a set of tax on gas, so, when the price drops, that hurts our revenue.
1:26:55 Dan, I've always understood that all the property tax goes to the county and we get 6% of that back. Is that correct? Yeah, that was negotiated with the corporation. Is that ever up for negotiation? No. Bottom line. Because we generate property tax. Yeah. Right now I would say given what I know of the financial status of the county, they would have no interest in doing that.
1:27:20 And you look at their general fund services, they'll come back and say, yeah, you generate the most of it, but also when you look at health services, you look at even something you want to share, you look at the courts, you look at the other elements they do, but also they provide support in the town, but that there's no rule outside. I'm sitting in the county administration issues that say, these are direct or indirect services with these levels that we provide back to the town. You know, I make a general observation that, you know,
1:27:50 The opportunities to grow, you know, to grow development, the right development, higher density transient type development is going to boost these numbers dramatically. You know, again, where there's still a third of the density to be built out of Mammoth, obviously it's going to take a long time, but the, you know, higher density type development is going to create greater TOT, probably also generate greater retail sales, and probably not demand incrementally.
1:28:18 A higher number of public services, necessarily. So the increment there is going to go to the bottom line. Property tax as well. Yeah, and the other thing you mentioned about property values, well, we want, you know, oh, everything's stagnant, all we can do is wait for property values to go up. Well, if we replace a vacant lot with a $200 million condo hotel or, you know, hotel property, that increased property value, you know, that's going to have the material effect on those revenues.
1:28:46 After, yeah, you'll never build yourself out generally at deficits type stuff, but for us to have that ongoing investment to see that incremental growth is a key element. The challenge becomes when it gets too exuberant or you see a big upswing on revenue, a lot of folks break, let's go spend it on ongoing operational issues, which should be a mistake. What is that sustainable level that you get into it?
1:29:14 The other element is actually is how you diversify your existing job base that is less required on the seasonal tourism. It's much more difficult in an area to look at. Other communities, we focus on that. You know you have X out here. You could add 100 or 200 jobs in this region that are not dependent on the tourism that may be related, but it's not dependent on people showing up. What does that do to your economic?
1:29:41 So with that, why don't we, if you won't mind, let's give John a chance to talk, and then we'll, that's going to lead to what John has to talk about. Great, thank you very much. Thank you, Madam Chair. Thank you.
1:30:10 Very much appreciate getting everybody to have this conversation. And I think there's some things that we should talk about in order to ensure that this is an efficient process. A lot of things we're talking about are issues that came up in the campaign. There's a new majority of the council right now that ran on a lot of these issues and looking to make sure that we do things efficiently, we take good use of people's time. So I would hope that we're going to
1:30:39 I would like that if what comes out of these discussions, the Council has established a series of priorities, which is kind of a first place community. I would very much like to know that the things we talk about then tier to those priorities. The Council is very much looking forward to being as a body on its own, to be tracking those priorities, how we're moving forward, how we're getting things into being actionable.
1:31:07 One of the big things about the campaign was we've got a lot of plans in place, we've got a lot of things on the books, we need to start implementing. And I think when Rusty made his presentation up at the village last week, he used some very militaristic type of jargon to describe his relationship to his peer competitors across the West. I think this community needs to be taking some use in that playbook. We need to fight and do what we have to do and to do it productively to fight for the survival of this community.
1:31:36 And regionally, using a whole, probably a lot of new ideas to make that happen, but I think one of the best things we can do is we can do these kinds of things efficiently. So we hope that we would look at the council's priorities, look at the things that are coming out of this, things that identify things to do. One of the things that Colin and I have been talking about is putting together a synergy summit, probably sometime in the middle of December, which is one of the priorities you'd want to do, but we're looking at how we can deliver and make these things actionable across things like Maniflex Tourism, Maniflex Recreation.
1:32:05 There's a lot of tools we've got to move things forward. The boards of these organizations are reporting to the council. We want to hold them accountable for things that we're doing and have them move forward. So that being said, I hope that we can time all the similar priorities that are already established. Two things I'd like to talk about really quickly is one is there's a map that I think Sandy did help. It's not over there. You guys can... Okay. So, the...
1:32:34 So I'd like to just use this document as a framing document for how we're talking about how we're developing. And I think there are three, and I'll take these into this presentation if there's times in the program, especially if you guys can follow along, excuse me. But to look at how we started talking about what we want to do right now with development.
1:32:57 If you look at this map, there are three sets of lines here that I think could be to look at. The first thing is the outermost line, which is in orange, which is the town's sphere of influence. This is primarily, these are all public lands. This is the National Forest. This is the Devils Post College National Monument. I was told maybe I was in Moab a week or two ago. A lot of people I work with were in Moab. Moab is the most god-awful built environment to be ever imagined. They're proud of it. They like it that way. But they have a demand.
1:33:26 It's palpable in that community for people going to that place to have outdoor recreation experiences. It's palpable. You feel it. It drives economic activity. You're not going to restaurants in that place and you get a breakfast at 7 o'clock in the morning with a line out the door, it's better than any meal you're getting at a trendy pisto and brokerage. It's contemporary cuisine. People recognize that they can make a business doing this. You also get a sack lunch to go with the things you're going to go outside to have the activities that you want to do.
1:33:54 That's demand. We need to be in the demand business. So one of the tiers of the economic development strategy is to look at what's happening out within that sphere of influence. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System coincidentally is defined by that planning group. But this gets us into our partners with Poirot County, all kinds of regional partners. There's a national forest plan update process going on right now that we can talk about later, but we need to be very happy to engage what's coming out of that plan.
1:34:20 But I would encourage all of you to look at, okay, what happens out in that sphere of influence? What things do we have control over that we can enhance, that we can do to enhance the visitor experience here? The second line is the line of the Towns Municipal boundary, which includes the Lakes Basin, includes the ski area, includes a lot of things. I'll talk about that in a second in terms of digital supply. The third thing is the urban growth boundary. What I've heard today is a lot of discussion, it's kind of a classic frame to talk about economic development, is within this urban growth boundary.
1:34:50 I'm trying to look at that as being the apple. And an apple on a tree, its sweetness, its value, its sheen, its desirability is directly related back to the tree on which it is growing. And I'm going to suggest that these other two areas are the tree. The health of that tree defines the health of that apple. And a lot of projects we're talking about are multi-million dollar development projects. They have a role to play in all of this.
1:35:15 But I need to suggest that maybe in the kind of a, to build a kind of a hunger and where we're at, what we're doing, that those things are not going to be first up. We've got a lot of work to do to invest in the health of our treaty. The thing that's growing that out, what's going to make most of the things possible. So I'm also going to hand out, these are some, this is the marketing, you know, these are things that are coming out of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. This is what the world is seeing when they think about Mammoth.
1:35:40 They're not getting a pitch on retail. They're not getting a pitch on high-end resort amendments. They're getting a pitch on wildness, adventure. These sparking can't make a change. We can say different things, but this is what we're currently telling the world. This is based on a lot of money invested by Mammoth Lakes Tourism in terms of what are we, who should be telling what we are. Monk County says the same thing, wild by nature. That's kind of where we're starting from. I just passed around our visitor guide, too, that can go. Oh, thank you. Yeah, we tie them in with these things.
1:36:09 And you'll forgive me if I've been listening to Thomas Friedman's book, The World is Flat. We are all living in a world where we have to be thinking horizontally. We're not thinking in terms of vertical organizations. The capacities that we have between MLT, MLR, Mono County, our regional partners, we have to be looking to deliver these things on a horizontal basis. So these are just some things to think about.
1:36:32 I'm going to give you a quick presentation on Digital 395, and then I'll give you plenty of time for discussion. Okay. Elizabeth has already seen this, but I'll take you to this real quick. Okay, get your timer out. He did it in six minutes. I'm not going to do it in six minutes now. I'll do it in maybe seven minutes. So this is the presentation on how to deliver, how to leverage Digital 395. Digital 395 is a background.
1:37:15 It is a piece of infrastructure put in by the federal government of the state of California, $120 million worth of infrastructure that delivers a nervous system. This nervous system can then connect to your house, wherever your beautiful house happens to be. But that's a nice thing, nice to have better endurance of service. What's really good about this are the ancillary benefits. It is a redundant system, which means all along this entire digital 395 backbone,
1:37:46 It is tied into the national, you know, infrastructure for delivery of broadband internet across the entire country. Which means that the backhoe down in Neal County, when it cuts the, you know, the classic Verizon line and the internet would go out, the town of Mammoth Lakes for three days, that's not going to happen anymore. If someone cuts the fiber line, it's a redundant system, it will pick up the signal from somewhere else. This is a 21st century piece of infrastructure.
1:38:09 You will be rerouted through San Francisco. It's important if you're gambling online and you're making a bet and something happens. Now you won't lose money because the internet went down. Again, that's a nice thing as well. What exactly is this thing? What kind of capacity do you actually have? Fiber Optical translates digital information at the speed of light. The speed of light looks like this. We all know what the speed of light looks like. So what's the big deal about this thing? Why is this thing... What's so compelling about it? This is the internet...
1:38:38 Capacity we had in this region prior to Digital 395. Yay! Linky hose faucet deal. This is the capacity we have now. This is what we had before. This is what we have now. It is appropriate to look in terms of the differentiation. It is that gargantuan and that fantastic.
1:38:59 The network has 432 strands of multi-mode fiber, which is capable of delivering 200 terabits of data, the theoretical total of 840 petabytes across the entire network. Does anybody know what that means? Good. You're going to learn. We are going to be technologically literate. We are going to know what this means. This is a key economic opportunity for us. It looks like this. If we have that much broadband, I've got to take you pictures of this waterfall as well. It's that big. It's that huge.
1:39:27 We have as much broadband capacity as anywhere in the United States of America. Literally anywhere on the planet. We have that much capacity. How are we going to leverage this? How does anybody leverage an opportunity like this? There's three choices. You can call Google. Google is doing something that they have in their business model. It is important to establish what are called gigabit communities.
1:39:53 So they go out to communities and they say, look, we're willing to come in and be your last mile provider, your internet service provider. If you can tell us what your infrastructure looks like, we will come in and provide them. They'll show up with trucks. They'll show up with a nice little office. They'll show up with big, orange, fiber optic, literally fiber optic lines that go into people's houses, that go right into your businesses. They make the last mile connection. They invest in that and they pay for doing that. They set up things and trucks that do this kind of stuff.
1:40:21 More guys going into your house, you'll get a box like this in your place of business. Instead of a Sunlink modem, you'll have a Google modem. They literally do that. And these are the speeds that you get. And I hope someone knows what this means. If you're looking at the top of Mammoth right now, your download speed is probably 2 megabits and your upload is maybe 30. If you're a gigabit community, you're getting 100, a full gigabit up and a full gigabit down. So when I called Google Fiber and asked, well, look, this is what I'm getting in Mammoth Lakes. And I said, well, that's nice.
1:40:51 We can deliver something that is 200 times faster. And they'll pay for it. Well, that's an option. We're laying on some scenarios here. But they would put in that last mile of connectivity to make that happen. But that's, I mean, literally, the fiber's right out there in the street. If we connect to it, we get these things. They're doing this in Kansas City, Austin, Texas, and Provo, Utah.
1:41:14 They came and said, we're going to make you a gigabit community. The community said, okay, we'll work with you, we'll make this happen. Kansas City, for example, happens to be right next to I-70, where the major east-west fiber optic routes are. So, one fiber optic, one optical fiber, one of these 432 strands, delivers 200 terabytes of data.
1:41:34 200 terabytes of data, 200,000 gigabits. There are 30,000 residents in the Eastern Sierra. Therefore, 30,000 residents can be served with dedicated gigabit internet service from a single optical fiber with enough data left over for 170,000 additional residents. We have 432 of these strands. It's big. So, we can get tech literate. Do we all know what a gigabit community is? And I don't expect you guys to know the answer to this question. Do we know what this means? Do we know what that is? It's a term of art.
1:42:06 How can digital 3 and 5 transform these gateway communities in the Eastern Sierra into gigabit communities? What is a megabyte versus a petabyte? What is responsive design? We should all know what this is. What is symmetrical upload and download? These are very basic technical terms of this stuff. What is a dig once regional policy? Essentially that means that if you're going to open up the street, you're going to open up a multiple teams path, you put in conduit, you put in infrastructure to support your fiber network.
1:42:34 This is a farmer in Vermont doing it with a horse. There's a lot of ways you can do this stuff. Gigabit communities. What is the value of these gigabit communities? To families. To building viable communities. We talked a lot about the resort opportunities in Mammoth Lakes and Eastern Sierra. What are we talking about in terms of the community opportunities? For families, for recreation, for economic development, for growing businesses. Do gigabit communities represent a significant marketing and branding opportunity for the entire Eastern Sierra region? Well, this is where we live.
1:43:04 And imagine if you live in a place like this and you can connect to a broadband network as robust as we could potentially have. That becomes a selling point. That becomes a game changer in terms of what kind of development we can do for our communities. The third option is to do it yourself. This is Chattanooga, Tennessee. A playground for pioneers. Voting one of the best town ever from Outside Magazine. Chattanooga went out with their public utility and put in the infrastructure to become a gigabit community. They did it on their own.
1:43:32 They put up their own internet service provider, they did a lot of stuff, they did it themselves. What they're doing with this is they host incubator businesses, they host think tanks, they do it on an annual basis, big, you know, four to six weeks worth of conferences and investors and people who are investing in the internet economy coming to Chattanooga to do business and economic incubator development. Last year it was 3D printing, healthcare and smart grid. Big, huge, robust, very well attended big conferences.
1:43:59 In the Eastern Sierra, we've got the Eastern Sierra Connect Measal Broadband Consortium. This may be a place from which we can start engaging to make this happen. Is this where we can start? So there's three ways, given this capacity, just kind of an overview look at this thing to maybe leverage this opportunity. You can call in a Google. We can get edumacated, which we obviously need to do. And we can possibly do it ourselves. But these are questions that we all need to start addressing to deliver and to leverage this opportunity. How are we going to do this?
1:44:29 And I would suggest that part of what's coming out of this is one of the priorities that's established in the council's priorities is to do this. And I think we need to start, you know, I'd like to see an outcome coming out of this, okay, how are we going to do this? It's going to be work, it's not going to be easy, it's going to be complicated, it's going to be heavy lift. But this is one of the key opportunities that we have to diversify our economy and diversify our way to live from our work.
1:44:55 And so I would suggest that the council, I'm sure, will talk about this before any other task force doing something like this to start establishing this as a goal to do the work and the effort necessary to pull our resources to make it happen. But this is a key opportunity. I think also in terms of the recreation stuff, if you look at, again, within the areas where we do things and where this tree grows that, you know, bears the best fruit that it can.
1:45:23 We're lagging behind recreation products. We are not a competitive product. And I think that we need to be looking at a 365-day-a-year free recreation product. And we've got a lot of work to do. We've set up MLR. We've got MLT in place to do this. These things are working together. But I think that we need to really start establishing actual goals, timelines, and deliverables so that we can make a credible effort to make this happen.
1:45:49 So I'm looking forward to future meetings. I'm looking forward to getting actual items coming out of this. They're rolling to council priorities. I look forward to council convening, discussing, looking at these things, and starting really laying out kind of a leadership map going forward. So just to kind of tie this back to what Dan was talking about. So a theory is if you become a Gicabag community, what you would do is you would encourage a permanent population.
1:46:18 And currently all our marketing material talks about tourism, second homes, and locals. I'm not quite sure what local is, but, so maybe it's this table. But if you, if you, if you increase your permanent population with people that are not totally dependent upon the snow economy, then the theory would be is that you would increase sales taxes and hopefully ultimately.
1:46:44 Increase property taxes. So that's kind of how it ties, a little bit back to what Dan was talking about, is it could be a way for us to really diversify our economy. Well, I think just a couple quick things. It's like a discussion on the airport. Right now, the airport is, air services subsidized primarily through MLT and amount of partnership going forward. If the council, we're going to be talking about making capital investments internal. We need to know.
1:47:11 That the buy-in is complemented earlier into air service. If the community recognizes that as being valuable, it's going to be wanting to extend things like TVS, to make these things work going forward. Getting into a digital 395 thing gives us the opportunity to look at the airport now maybe a different way. Because maybe it's a question of...
1:47:31 You know, a high net worth individual or people like that wanting to base a business out of here. The air service takes on a different connotation if it's supporting an indigenous economy that's self-supporting that's not sort of a net worth. So getting this thing moving forward and looking at how it starts to reframe all these issues is really important. One other point about the Mardis Camp thing, which is really critical to keep in mind. Mardis Camp is a basic, classic subdivision. There's nothing more than that. The difference is that the developer invested $150 million in amenities.
1:48:00 Before, they sold a lot. We can't be in the pie-in-the-sky business. We have to be doing what we can to develop the amenities that we can, so that we can point to people to say, we are a gigabit community. It's here. It's not going to be here in five years. You should move here now. We have great recreational experiences. We now have a productive, useful relationship with the Forest Service. We're providing the kind of recreational experiences that you want. We have to really be in the amenity business to start driving all the other stuff that gets the apple sweeter on the branch.
1:48:30 John, is there an opportunity to create Wi-Fi hotspots that can take advantage of the bandwidth now? Maybe, kind of, but that's scratching. That's kind of scratching stuff. I think we need to put together a task force. I'm not sure how to convene it or give in the Brown Act, things like that. We need to put together a group of people who are going to look very, very closely and seriously to how we're going to deploy this stuff. And there are a lot of options. There's a lot of complications. There's a lot of constraints.
1:48:57 I mean, the franchise agreement that we have with Sutherland is now going to be with the California Public Utilities Commission, so it's a very, it's going to be a heavy lift, but I think we need to start establishing a goal that actually we can get to, and I think doing anything less than we need gigabit communities is squaring our opportunities. But that's a further discussion. Well, I have an idea about that.
1:49:22 But before we talk about that, so Alicia, I'm really sorry to like cram in, but I know you wanted to share just a few things with us. I didn't. And the other option is that for the next meeting I could lead off. Okay. And maybe then we have a little more time to talk today because I'm really fascinated to hear more about what you say rather than what I have to say. And we really hope that you would participate. Yeah, I'm excited about it. And really I just wanted just quickly to say Mono County has an Economic Development Strategic Plan draft that is pretty much ready to go to the board for
1:49:51 Further direction on priorities. There's three strategic platforms. It's essentially strengthen the current tourism economy, attract new business, and business retention and expansion strategies. And under that, there's nine different strategies. We don't have the resources to do them all, so we're really looking for direction from the communities and from the board on where do we need to focus right now. So we did a survey. We've gone up to the RPACs. And I would love, actually, for you guys to take the survey. If you haven't already, I'll send you the link.
1:50:20 And essentially, we're going to start with business retention and expansion. Work with the existing businesses. How can we support them? Because when they're happy and content, you don't lose them. And therefore, you don't have to spend a lot of energy and money on attracting something new. We have a very solid base of businesses. So how do we grow that? How do we help them? So that's just in a tiny, tiny nutshell. But I'd be happy to share that more at the next meeting. So this is my thought, is that next week, you know, we have a two-hour.
1:50:50 meeting scheduled. Yeah, we do. A joint workshop, right? Yes? Yes? Four o'clock Wednesday. Four o'clock Wednesday. That we've been longing to have. I know. I'm trying to be very eager for this. Well, so, you know, I mean, what I'd like to see us do is, I mean, maybe now take some of the momentum from today and you can tell us what you think about that and then roll that into that joint workshop. I mean, I don't know, I mean,
1:51:20 And we were going to talk about this, we'll talk about this a little later on in our commission meeting today. I mean, the council now has laid out their priorities, and one of the thoughts was then to go to council and say, okay, council, if these are your priorities, what would you like the commission to work on? But do you think it would be appropriate, Colin and John, maybe to take, to start that meeting and really use start as a follow-up step for the day?
1:51:47 Yeah, I would suggest, again, take the priorities that are published, take whatever you glean from this meeting, look at the things that are in there and say, look, we think there are opportunities in these areas that are worthy of the commitment of resources, very limited resources that they all have to see these things through. And, you know, that to me revolves around the importance of the Synergy Summit, which is essentially a sliding exercise. It says,
1:52:14 These are the overarching goals of the council and our community and our planning commission, et cetera. Where do we slot these things? You know, if we want to improve customer service, maybe we focus that to the chamber. If we want to improve economic development as far as attracting new businesses, what's the best avenue to do that? So I think, you know, the broader frame is the council priorities and then saying where do things fit in.
1:52:36 And the idea to follow up on that is then, okay, then we as a community know, okay, Chamber of Commerce is dealing with the hospitality thing. Tourism is doing these things. Tourism is talking to MLR for product development. So we've got, we're really breaking down these silos of our capacity to perform. And that's the thing we want to get to. So the degree to which you guys can look at things in the priority list and say, this is, we think we should be pursuing this. You don't have to worry about how. We'll figure that out.
1:53:03 This is important, this is important, this is important, then we can start delegating out who's got the actual capacity to get things done, and then we can start moving forward. I think that's the idea. So, Dan, I have a question for you. In your opinion,
1:53:15 If Council appoints a gigabyte task force, then it becomes something that falls underneath the umbrella of the Brown Act, which maybe we have to do for all encompassing. Yes, Council appoints if the answer is yes to that. Right. So do you think it's something better that Council appoints, or do you think maybe it's something better than maybe the Eastern Sierra Regional Board?
1:53:36 Whatever it is the point. Yeah, the consortium. Well, I think it's something we have to talk about. I have to walk through the best of the path of that, hopefully, whether it's the whole personalized counsel thing and staff driven with a working group initially to come back up. Right. There's a couple different ways to tackle that process. That becomes a priority of commitment of resources to make that happen. But it doesn't necessarily have to be ground acted if it shouldn't have thought. The council point is.
1:54:01 It's only for the council to fight. We need to look at that a little bit and figure out what capacity we need to have on the task force, given all the kinds of issues we're going to have to deal with. I figured out how to do that, but I think we need to get that in place first to figure out what kinds of opportunities, short-term, long-term, what kind of goals can be reasonably set, and then what capacity do we have to try to implement this. There's definitely other players here that are at the table.
1:54:31 Sure. Right. Okay, so let's just go around the table real quick, and we'll start with you. Any other thoughts, comments? I think, just real quick, I think there's a number of things that the staff that we've worked on are dealing with our visitor-based stuff, dealing with fee structures, dealing with some of the economic strategies, dealing with some of the other talent policies, where we need those in place to be consistent, and we need to take the building.
1:55:01 And talking to people about investment in the community. Those are some of the key issues they're looking at. What is the process? What's the timelines? Do we have that stability that people are looking for? You'll get to see when they come in and find the best 100,000. Yeah, 100,000 or 100,000,000,000. They're looking for the same elements that I'll say, at least in talking to some folks, historically, they would say that has not been one of the hallmarks of the town. Fair stake.
1:55:32 So, I think that's an area for us to work on is we bring that up and there will be some issues. Us as? The town. The town. Yeah, focused on the staff level initially coming up to over-release. But, you know, we're really figuring out a lot of cars. Yes. Yeah. There's a lot of things that are moving in the right direction right now. So, I mean, it's positive what's happening. And so, how do we build off of that and get that momentum going and also have that change of perspective? Because it doesn't matter if I had a bad experience, that and how...
1:56:01 It takes my whole vision of the town. A lot of people have done that. You have a bad little restaurant. It doesn't matter. It's changed management three times. The assumption is, yeah, we'll leave there. So I think that's a challenge that we have. We're getting better at how we tell that story as well. Elizabeth, do you have one? I have a lot to say, but we don't have time to say it. I think John's suggestion is a good one. We really have direction now for our meeting this afternoon to figure out.
1:56:31 Exactly how to focus and mesh with what the Council goals are, what we think is important, so I'll save my comments for that. Dave? Yeah, I'm excited about the whole process here. The idea of telling the story never changes, just the content. And having good content is extremely important at this time in our juncture. Every consultancy we've ever had has told us the same thing.
1:57:01 We need more midweek business. Well, when you start identifying what midweek business really means for our community, one of the elements that doesn't get a lot of attention is a diversified workforce, an independent workforce, not necessarily associated with the recreation business. And this, I'm very excited to be looking at this prospect and being able to now
1:57:30 begin to create a story that can be told as we go forward. Thanks. Two things really quick. I really like the way John was focusing on a strategy towards actionable items. I think that's key. We can all sit up and talk all we want. Historically, I think that's been a little bit of the main formula, so I like that word actionable. Second would be come tonight, 5 o'clock, 8.30, Mammoth Lakes Open House.
1:58:00 You'll hear about what we're doing for the next six months, eight months, 12 months to promote our destination internationally and domestically within California and the USA. Good deal. Five o'clock. Five o'clock at the Forest Service Auditorium. Is this a formal program of speakers? Yes. It'll be a Q&A session at the end, but it'll be about two hours of presentations. Starting at five. Starting at five.
1:58:24 Unlimited bourbon. No, I don't think I have much to add on top of what we already talked about. I think, you know, the key to me is, you know, as we talk about all these different strategies, okay, we need business retention and expansion, we need bringing new businesses to town. You know, what I'm looking at and my focuses are, you know, who's going to champion what? So, you know, if...
1:58:54 If your team is really focusing right now on business retention and expansion, that's great because that's part of the portfolio and we need to do that. Then we need to look at who's going to focus on that, drawing new businesses to town, whether that be the chamber, whether that be the council, whatever that may be. But we've had a lot of conversation throughout the campaign, throughout a lot of the conversations I've had. I think it's critically important that we kind of diversify our economy.
1:59:20 And all of those conversations for me have circled back to the same couple of things is, you know, some, you know, Dan, you've talked about this a lot in your past, it's like if you're up in Reno, Nevada, you know, maybe a way that you diversify your economy is to bring manufacturing, right? So we obviously don't want to be a heavy industrial manufacturing area when we talk about our location, we talk about the cost of things, you know, that's not going to be a focus for us. For me, these things have always circled back to
1:59:48 Trying to attract outdoor brands because we have a unique location here and not the manufacturing part but the R&D, you know, potentially where you can have within 40 minutes between Bishop and Nana if you have these variety of experiences for product testing. And the second area is how, as John kind of spoke about, we've never had the ability before to go out to the tech sector and now we do. So, you know, that to me is our major game changer is if you can have
2:00:18 You know, 100 jobs here where it doesn't matter if it snows, it doesn't matter if people are coming to town, we're running their internet-based business 365 days a year from a pristine natural environment as opposed to the chaos of the city, then I think we have a game-changer. Then it pulls that TOT number down from 63 to 55 for the 50. You know, and then it does bolster the economy. We have more people living here. But again, you know, my focus is more than...
2:00:46 As we're talking about these different focuses, I think each of our council members have different focuses, and we recognize that there's a piece to providing the type of environment that those type of people want to live in that we need to enhance. So that's where my focus is like, is, you know, providing the amenity base, providing the things that those type of people are going to make them want to move their tech business here as opposed to somewhere else. So, that's it.
2:01:13 I would echo Michael's sentiments, and I think going down the right track here is, you know, we can all tell a story forever, but in the end, you've got to have actionable items that you can actually implement and show progress, right? People need to see that we can be what we say we're going to be, and I think we've had a lot of, you know, the past 10 years, or, you know, since the development ended, all we did is talk about what we can become, but now it's time to act, and, you know, we need to create the priorities.
2:01:40 And we've got to distill that down to the tasks. That's where the work gets done. And, you know, we can't get it too spread out. You know, you've got to focus on the real priorities and make those actual items happen and show everybody that, hey, we're making progress on our plan. And I think we've got a great council that hopefully will be able to provide good leadership to the community that this is where we're focusing our efforts because we do have limited resources, right? We can't do everything.
2:02:07 But we need to pick off the low-hanging fruit. We need to get the things that can make a difference now and start picking away. And it's a combination of things, but I think attacking it from both sides of business development, enhancing the resort experience, you know, go hand in hand. So there's this exciting time, I think, ahead of us right now that we can really take off here if things go our way. But we need to take action. We need to quit talking about it.
2:02:37 I think Tom had said everything I was going to say, but much more eloquently than I could have, so thank you. Did you hear any comments? No, I just, I think the energy and the innovative thinking and the focus is very refreshing, and I'm really happy to be part of this in whatever way.
2:02:59 And to our next first speaker. Yeah, that would be great. I have a lot to share and I didn't want to feel rushed or to feel like I was imposing on our time here. I was going to say there's a new couple that has just moved into the Trails. They were long-time visitors here.
2:03:14 They had a small condo, actually, and they're in the software business, and they were just waiting for a digital 395. They bought a home in the trails, and they're now working, for the most part, remotely here. So that is the kind of thing that Colin's talking about. It's a game changer, and I think that we have low-hanging fruit in the folks that love this place already. They're our first target, right? Because they know us. They know why they won't live here. We don't have to sell them. I'm excited to be a part of this. Thank you. Thank you.
2:03:42 I would encourage everybody to go to Lake, look at the Lake Tala Basin Prosperity Plan, just as kind of a model for that. Sandra, you can just send everybody out the link. It's a nice kind of model, and they've got the core, key focus of theirs is broadband and technological integration. So it's an interesting thing to just look at the model of the things that we're doing.
2:04:06 Great, this is great, this is all very good, very much looking forward to hearing your recommendations and ideas coming up to council, getting them to us, getting these things tasked out, and then really the trick is going to be for all this working together and make all this work, and you can see how there's overlap all over the place, but that's going to be the test, as well as a community, Rusty's analogy about cannonballs and firing and all that kind of nonsense, maybe we can stick all that energy into all those cannonballs and direct it.
2:04:35 For betterment, not to our... We can't use like American doll analogies or something. Yeah. But one thing is, you know, we'll talk today at commission meeting and maybe we can have Sandra and Pamela, Tim Pamela, meeting with the two of you between now and Wednesday because I think what's really important is that we have this two-way exchange with council so you can help us frame how that...
2:04:58 That's fine. I think also to get our priority document out so it becomes an iterative, so it's something that we're tracking, we're seeing how we're going to progress, we're making on, I think, something that, you know, how we're going to start. We've got a lot of things that are already in the works. We'll need to be checking and say, this is going to be here. Mickey, can we change our site visit to 1.15 instead of 1? I definitely have a hard stop, though, in the afternoon, so I don't want to post.
2:05:27 I don't want to push the afternoon too late. I hate to wait. Well, no, no, we still will. We have to start a meeting at 2 o'clock. Yeah. Can we change the site visit to 1 o'clock? I think that site visit to 1 o'clock. I don't think we'll need an hour either. Sounds good. So we will adjourn this meeting to 1 o'clock. At 1 o'clock we will meet actually on site at the Mammoth Creek Inn. How are you going to tell all the people that you mentioned 1 o'clock? You can tell them of course. We'll be there. Really?
2:05:56 Thank you for reminding us that. We don't really expect a lot of public. You can't really change times with 45 minutes notice and really be responsive to the public. You know what? We will have somebody there, but I will tell you that we do not really expect any public to be there, but I will certainly be there at 1 o'clock if they are. Thank you for reminding us that. All right. So with that, we are adjourned to our site visit.
2:06:26 I call back to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting of Wednesday, November the 12th, 2014. We are reconvening after a site visit.
2:06:53 Even though we technically had a public comments period at the beginning of our meeting, since we are a little different procedure today, I will open it up for anybody in the audience that like to make public comments. Public comments are for anybody that wish to speak on any item that is not on today's agenda. If there is no public comments, we'll close that public comment period and we'll move to our public hearing.
2:07:26 This is a public hearing which is to consider the approval of tentative tract map 14-004 and design review 14-002, the Mammoth Creek in expansion at 663 Old Mammoth Road, including finding the project to be categorically exempt from CEQA. Just so that everybody knows what we will do today, we will have a statement and presentation by staff.
2:07:55 A statement and presentation by the property owner, questions from Planning and Economic Development Commission, call for testimony for those persons wishing to speak, rebuttal to previous testimony by property owner, we'll close the public hearing part, then commission will deliberate, there will be a motion which we'll discuss and then we'll vote on. So with that, I will turn the meeting over to Nolan, who's our staff representative on this issue. All right, thank you.
2:08:26 The proposed project is an expansion of the Mammoth Creek Inn located at 663 Old Mammoth Road and will add 12 condo hotel rooms within two new buildings. The two new buildings will be built behind the existing hotel. The Planning and Economic Development Commission is being asked to approve a tentative tract map and a design review permit. The tentative tract map is required to subdivide the airspace of the condo hotel rooms.
2:08:52 Within the Old Mammoth Road Zoning District, hotels are permitted outright, and therefore no other approvals are required for the proposed use. The project is proposing the change of circulation on the site from the existing pattern where vehicles enter and exit onto Old Mammoth Road to a one-way pattern where vehicles enter from Old Mammoth Road and exit via 3059 Chateau Road through a 20-foot easement. This change of circulation improves an existing non-conformity on the site.
2:09:21 3059 Chateau Road is currently used for retail and a variety of other uses. The parking and driveline meet all of the town's public work standards for two-way traffic and parking space dimensions. Signage will be installed at the entrance to the MCI site and the exit, alerting motorists that it is one way. The existing parking along the southern edge of the property will be changed to angled spaces in order to meet the minimum emergency access width.
2:09:50 required by the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. The project is proposing a density of seven rooms above the allowable general plan base density of 40 rooms per acre, but is allowed pursuant to general plan policy L5G, which allows projects to exceed the base density if a community benefit is provided. The project is proposing a $6,000 contribution
2:10:15 towards a new transit stop or shelter in the vicinity of the project as a community benefit. Snow storage is being addressed through an off-site hauling plan which allows for snow to be hauled off-site to an approved off-site snow storage area. Condition of approval number 103 in the resolution requires review and approval of their snow storage management plan prior to issuance of the final map. The municipal code allows for this alternative if certain conditions are met
2:10:45 It includes the requirements that the interim snow storage does not interfere with more than one-third of the required minimum parking and that snow is removed within five calendar days following a storm. The design committee of the PEDC review the project and a summary of their comments are available in the staff report. The committee did suggest changing the parapet material to core 10 installed horizontally. This alternative design is included in the staff report as attachment 7.
2:11:13 And here on the displays, both the original design and the alternative are below me here. The project was found to be categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Section 15332, Infill Development Projects. A traffic analysis was done for the project and found that the project would not result in any significant impacts. A cultural resources inventory was done and found no evidence of cultural resources. As of the start of this public hearing, no public comments have been received.
2:11:43 Staff has made the determination that the project meets all the findings required to approve the tentative tract map and design review permit and staff recommends approval of option one, which is adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, adopt the required subdivision map act findings and approve tentative tract map 14004 and design review 14002.
2:12:11 With conditions as recommended by staff. The applicant and the property owner are both here to answer questions that the commission might have. So can you do me a favor just so that the public can see when you point to the different designs? Maybe we can flip that also around. Before here we have the original proposed design. You're going to have to hold it up no longer. And then we have the alternative design here with the core 10 installed at the top on the parapet material.
2:12:47 So there's a better location of these. I think we have it in our hand up. Do you want to just face it out, maybe? Do you have a sample of the Core 10? I would not have a sample of the Core 10 based on that. The commission is noted with Core 10 material. And then the material for, the original one is with the colors for the building and the window material and the side material.
2:13:22 Did you have any other questions at the staff at this time? Several questions, Nolan. It says on the chart on page 7, development standards, that the interior side and rear setback would be 8 feet, and when we were on the site, the applicant, Craig, pointed to the map, and it showed 5.2 feet for the setback. Why is there a discrepancy?
2:13:54 That's a setback from rock and roll. That's to the eaves, so to the building wall, as measured, it was eight feet. Oh, that, 5.2 is to the eaves. That was, yeah, because I measured on the full-size site plan, the 11 by 17s are condensed, been in the staff report, but as measured, yes. Okay, and then on page five, under the, if it's consistent with global policy actions, it talks about the landscape plan.
2:14:20 This says the proposed landscape plan includes a planting of 11 additional trees. What are the size of those trees and are they evergreen or deciduous? So the trees are included on sheet A1.2 and they're proposing white fir trees, lodgepole and aspens. And what size container? So the one that did not specify the size on those, on the trees that are being planted. Okay.
2:14:56 And I had one. Well, the Aspens are proposing 12 to 15 feet, actually. In height, of course. And then on page three of the, in your analysis, it refers to design review nine in 2002. No, excuse me. It was 2009, design review two. That's five years ago with a different proposal. Why do those, why does that still apply? So that was just design review for the existing building.
2:15:25 For the siding and colors of the existing building. And so that was just showing that. I misread that. I'm sorry. I misread that. The colors for the new building basically. Okay. Okay. Those are all my questions. Thank you. I do have a really quick question. This is probably a little bit more of a rookie question from me as one of the new planning commissioners. But in the PIEC portion of the report, I think it's number six, the first bullet point for the negative report says it does not meet the social capacity.
2:15:56 I don't know if I understand what that means. So in the Pisces, really the questions in the analysis, because they're all standard questions for all projects, are really related to what amenities are on site. So whether there's restaurants or spas, like more of a village type setting on site. With this project, it's really only a hotel on site.
2:16:18 Then it meets because it's close to all the other amenities close by. So the neighborhood amenities supplement what is not in existence on the property. Yeah, the policy questions were really more related to if there's, you know, what's on site, if there's a wide mixture of uses there. Got it. Thank you. Commissioner Harvey? Commissioner Gray? Just one question about the materials board there, which I can't see very well from this angle. I remember in our design committee meeting we talked about the
2:16:52 Glass material, no reflectivity of that. And I believe there is a component in the special planning conditions that would require a lower reflectivity of glass. Did I read that correctly? Correct. Condition of approval 37 would allow a different glass. This glass is
2:17:19 Originally required based on the California building standards for light not to come into the end of buildings so they don't want the sun heating up inside of the building. Obviously in snow country that's kind of contrary to what you want, you'd want natural light coming in to warm the building. And so on that one they discussed with the building official and it would be up to approval from the building official on an alternative glass like that. Okay.
2:17:48 So at the moment the glass on that board is the one that would not allow heat to come in. So it's the one that meets, is it Title 24? Yeah, the HP Sun 2, as in the conditions, is one that works in this area and does allow natural heating. Okay. Commissioner Gray Hickman, you can help me. The HP Sun 2 was to not allow
2:18:18 So much light from the interior of the building to come out onto the open space. Isn't that what we discussed at our subcommittee meeting? And then there was also the reflectivity of this glass we were concerned about. Is that your recollection? I'm trying to remember. Yeah, it was some time ago. All right, well, we'll address that one. Okay. So the only thing I'd like
2:18:56 For you to expound on a little bit is the clarification because this is kind of an interesting project. I mean, it was submitted underneath our old guidelines. It was submitted when we still had a CBIS policy which now has been rescinded. And, of course, we have a new zoning code update. So can you please just clarify for the public about how this project is being evaluated? Sure.
2:19:24 Is in a unique kind of transition where the CBiz is out but there is still the L5G policy which projects have to be found consistent with if they're proposing increased density of what the general plan density was of 40 rooms per acre. So they are consistent with that L5G policy and that they're providing a community benefit.
2:19:46 Projects in the new zoning code are being evaluated on a floor area ratio. It's taken out the lot coverage and looking at just the floor area ratio. This project came in at .75 floor area ratio, or FAR, allowed in further zoning code is 2.5. So it's well below that standard for when you look at that density of FAR. So looking at the community benefits still being provided to be consistent with the L5G policy.
2:20:15 Which in the future won't be required. It's just looking at it as a FAR analysis. And then before the owner or the own representative speak, on our site visit, was there any findings from any of the commissioners that you'd like to state publicly that has influenced your decision today? All right. So who's going to speak? Stephen Hakeem, applicant.
2:20:56 I wanted to thank the Planning Commission for all their time and consideration as well as the planning staff. I know they've been very patient with us throughout this whole process, so thank you so much. We're a family-owned business and we take a lot of pride in the hotel and the enhancements that we've already provided in the existing hotel and the amenities that we provide. We're very confident.
2:21:26 with this addition to the hotel and how it will impact the neighborhood and the surrounding businesses. I know that we came before you for non-binding input about a year ago or so, as well as in front of town council, which definitely helped us be able to amend
2:21:55 and transform the project to make it the most viable and vibrant aesthetically as it can be. And I do also remember Commissioner Tenney saying, as long as this doesn't end up as a box with wood, and I'm sure with the design that our architect has come up with, you would be very thrilled.
2:22:20 Also, in speaking with our team as well as our architect and the input that you have provided during the design review, we have decided, excuse me, to go ahead with that alternative design that was suggested and use that core tin for the paired pit section. We're available for any questions or comments that you might need as well as our architect for any clarification. Thank you.
2:22:49 Steve, can you... Go ahead, Mickey, I'm sorry. Go ahead, introduce yourself and then... My name is Craig Tapley. I'm the designer for the project and representing my client as well as Design Dimension Associates. And through all the different variations of how we design the building, I think it complies pretty well with the site trying to find a fit for the project or for the new buildings rather so they fit in between the chalets and...
2:23:26 Bruce's new bowling alley, something that's a lot more modern. One of the things, Amy, I think you were talking about before in regards to the windows, we were talking about the solar heat gain coefficient with the new Title 24 and what we have applied there on our color board. We can find a window that meets the requirements for Title 24 with the 0.35 solar heat gain coefficient.
2:23:55 Getting away from that reflectivity that we can meet those. As well as Elizabeth, we had a quick meeting and everybody's agreed that, you know, if it suits the need or if you think it's a better aspect or better elevation that the horizontal core tent, that fourth floor, all the exterior siding, may be a better fit than the sink.
2:24:22 That we had called out previous. On the elevations, it's shown vertically. Is that just an oversight? Well, we could do it horizontal or vertically. I think it's supposed to be horizontal. That's what we had talked about, but it didn't show that of the elevations that came in our packet. So, any other questions? Did you give me a question? No. A couple more. Craig, in the comments that the design review committee made, the applicant response, it said we would see
2:25:00 Renderings of the proposed buildings in context, something we usually require, computer generated showing the building and then with its neighboring buildings in context and I didn't see that in our packet. Do you have that? I don't. I don't think we submitted anything along those lines. We basically just submitted renderings of the proposed building. Okay, because this is after our meeting. We have a context map. We have a context site plan, but not contextual.
2:25:28 And at that meeting, staff has also reported, and I remember because I was there, that you would consider incorporating either stone or some hardy board siding onto a portion of the elevator shaft to break up the mass, and I didn't see that indicated. Yeah. No, I think that was something that we discussed, but something that wasn't rendered. Okay, so that's not even under consideration. Well, it's possible. Like I just said, we could render it, but we didn't think that it would be necessary at this meeting. That's just from the...
2:26:00 The notes from the meeting and then your response to the notes. Okay. And the core 10 that you're talking about, and this is a belt and suspenders question, because years ago on Planning Commission we were promised a copper roof and we got an orange roof instead, which was called copper colored. We're talking about C-O-R hyphen T-E-N brand name core 10. Okay, that's good. And either hat section, we can provide these samples of that, either
2:26:29 Hat section, which has flat surface, recessed flat to recess, or the wave section, which is a wave corrugated, if you follow me. No, I do follow you. Which was the one that you would choose? We were going to do the wave corrugated. The wave corrugated, okay. Does that answer your questions, Commissioner? No, but I just asked my questions, so. No, it's, I got answers, yeah. All right. Then I just have,
2:27:04 One question for Stephen. I'd just always like to ask this question that there's 104 conditions that are attached with this approval. I just want to make sure that you and your family have read those conditions and are all in agreement to them. Yes, we have. And we've also gone over them with staff. Thank you very much. Does anybody else have any other questions? Okay, thank you very much. So this time we'll open this up for any person in the public that wishes to speak on the project.
2:27:37 Bruce Woodward, Local Architect. One, I think the, I think this is a, just in general, this is a project that will seem to be meeting all of the criteria that's in the zoning code and we're going to wind up with another birdhouses, birdcages style project. I think it's going to be an unfortunate addition to the time, Mammoth Lakes.
2:28:13 Second, I also don't, I read that too, Elizabeth, I don't see this in context, and it said that it would be in context. I think that that would really help really see what's going on, seeing all of the buildings in there related to each other and the lodge itself, the main building, because you don't get that contextual feel at all right now. I think that...
2:28:38 Care really needs to be taken with Corten steel. Corten will etch the glass on the outside of the building. When it rusts, it's a rusting steel, and it runs. And so you need to be very careful where that runs to, and be ready for the standing that it's going to do. And when it runs across glass, it etches the glass. So you'll get streaks on the glass. So that's it. That's it for the moment.
2:29:10 I guess the other thing is, I'm just, this project, it's unfortunate that it's able to use the CBiz, it's buying seven units for $6,000. The art fee for this project is going to be at least $20,000. To me, I mean, it just seems so out of proportion. It's just, everything about it's kind of wacky. And, but it was originally submitted.
2:29:43 There was lot coverage requirements, and now there aren't, so it's at 82% lot coverage, but now that doesn't matter, so it could be 100% to guess. I don't know if that's really what we want to see in this town, but that's what's allowed now. So those are my comments. As a design professional and someone who did the building next door, I find it a shame that this is going to happen next.
2:30:17 In that context, in that neighborhood, next to the park. And next to their building up front, which is a much nicer looking building than these. Thanks. Thank you. Is there anybody else from the public that would like to make any comments on this project? Would you like to rebut all those comments, either Steve or Craig? Thank you, Bruce, for those comments. Of course, BDD is always in the eye of the beholder.
2:31:00 We don't see the project as a series of, you know, problem that was made on Main Street with the birdhouses. Unfortunately, everybody's got something to say, and it's one of those design crits that could probably go on for a long time, but we've made basically all the conditions as per staff reports. I would, you know, basically suggest that the commission follow the staffs.
2:31:30 comments and basically choose one method of approval one way or the other. And it sounds like it could go along the lines of approval with the option of various materials or the substitute material. But with the CBIS, that's all kind of gone away now with floor area ratio. We could actually increase the number of rooms, but we're not doing that. We're trying to get our parking.
2:31:57 Actually at a minimum, our site coverage at a minimum, and still trying to circulate or navigate from Old Mammoth Road through, you know, where the castoff is. So I think it's a challenging site, it's a challenging project, and I think we did a fairly good job meeting all that criteria. So, you know, it's going to be one of those things, Bruce, where we may, through our lifetime, disagree to, or agree to disagree.
2:32:25 So thank you for your comments. I appreciate it. And I hope I addressed most of those. Thank you. Steven? We actually really took into consideration the overall look of the building next door. We confronted the property owner at a very early stage in our design to get an idea of what they were building while we were in the planning stages.
2:32:56 So it isn't without really careful consideration that we came to this finished product, which we're very happy with. And also in regards to, I know that he touched upon the CBiz and we know that that's sort of a moot point. But at the same time, I think from a global perspective, you know, I know that there's a lot of talks going on around the city of Mammoth in respect of allowing
2:33:26 Home rentals to provide additional TOT tax and here we are providing use that is currently zoned for which is within the confines of the code which is suitable for that use in the surrounding area and so I think from a global perspective I think the $6,000 is a pretty moot point.
2:33:55 Considering the amount of TOT tax that it's going to bring to the town. So I just wanted to also bring up that comment. Thank you. So before I close this portion of the hearing, is there any other questions? There's discussion. So I now close the public hearing part of this. Before we start our deliberations, I just, for the benefits of our two newer commission,
2:34:29 We, as a town, used to have a community benefit incentive zoning, CBiz. The CBiz portion of this actually went to town council and it was approved by town council. So we really don't have any input on the CBiz, the $6,000. I mean, that was a decision that has already been made by town council. As you know, subsequent to this, then, now, the CBiz policy for the...
2:34:59 has been rescinded. So, it's just, it is a little awkward, but I just wanted to make sure that you understood that today we're not going to discuss CBiz because it's pretty well been discussed, voted upon, and approved by a council. Okay? Okay? All right? So, with that, who would like to start the discussion? I'm always looking at Commissioner Tenney first. Would you like to start? Well, let's see.
2:35:29 We had our design review committee, our subcommittee meeting, which is two commissioners, you can't have a quorum for a subcommittee, and we raised some issues, and I'm surprised and disappointed that they weren't all addressed in this report to the commission, because this is a pretty important day for the applicant. The fact that there aren't renderings of the proposed buildings in context, that's a basic requirement. We require computer generated.
2:35:57 Graphics showing the building with the trees, all the rest of it, and I'm surprised that you don't have one, and it's really hard to make an intelligent decision without one. Also, we had concern at the subcommittee level about the massiveness of the elevator shaft, and there was a suggestion about using a material like rock or something else to break that up. And that wasn't addressed. We don't see any options showing that.
2:36:27 The core 10, core 10 was in effect. It was a look like the raw steel on the, on the bowling, you know, on rock and bowl. And I've been told, and I know actually from seeing it, core 10 ages like fine wine. It just gets, you know, more and more beautiful. But I didn't know until Bruce, the very experienced local architect, said it will etch glass. That was a surprise to me. And so I wasn't, I was recommending core 10 for the look.
2:36:53 And the fact that it wouldn't be reflective, I'm glad you decided not to go with the zinc siding because that will be very reflective and you have a prime building spot, absolutely prime next to all that open space and with the Sherwin's viewshed. So that would have to be addressed. I have a real issue, not with the project, not with what you're trying to do with this expansion. This is a much better proposal than we got initially, but I really have an issue.
2:37:20 With the design not being integrated, I had that issue at the subcommittee level and I still have it. It's like all the boxes have been checked, you've got everything you need for your occupancy, you know, return on investment, colors, all that kind of stuff, but the building does not hang together for me. And that's, I can't support the building in its current design. And I would even like, if this is appropriate, Chair Brown, to ask the applicant if they would consider as a condition,
2:37:48 If I am to support this project, going through another design review subcommittee meeting or even design review before the planning commission to address some of these issues. I don't know if you're, the fact that it's not shown in context and a suggestion to break up a mass of the elevator shaft wasn't addressed, those are just simple. But it just doesn't hang together. You've substituted the look of rusted metal, Corten or raw steel, but it's only in the
2:38:17 Box on the top of the building's AB. It's just on top and it doesn't connect with anything else. It just, the design just doesn't hang together. It meets all the requirements, but it doesn't hang together for me. And our requirements in the general plan is the very highest architectural standards, the very highest level of design. And this, our job is to make sure whatever comes before us is consistent with the general plan. And this design doesn't meet that standard for me.
2:38:46 That's where I am in the current design, even though I support the concept of the project, I can't support the design, therefore I can't support the project. So that's where I stand right now, unless you're willing to have a condition where you would, you know, refine and revise slightly to make it a more integrated whole instead of just these various elements stuck together, which is how it appears to me. So that's what I have to say. All right. So I just want to make sure.
2:39:17 You're okay with the CEQA findings, the municipal code, the subdivision map, and the tentative tract map as only the design? Right. I can't support it at this current design. Okay. Commissioner Vanderhurst. I think really the only red flag that kind of comes out at me, and I think I would be in support of this project, is the strategy for the traffic flow.
2:39:44 with the cars accessing the building from Old Mammoth Road, but then exiting the building past the castoff. As somebody who has donated many things to the castoff over the last couple of years, I can tell you on a day that that is open, and I'm sure that the family that owns the property knows from having owned it since 03, that corridor, that access point next to the castoff can be a bit of a nightmare. There's a lot of cars coming and going, people double park right in the middle of it.
2:40:13 On any given day, it would aesthetically look nowhere near as clean and tidy as it did today. I can tell you many times I have driven by there and there's been half a dozen couches thrown out there in that parking lot. So I'm just wondering if there was an option other than that strategy to get traffic in and out of there, that easement, using the easement.
2:40:38 Through the back of the castoff is really the only option. But having nobody here from the castoff to address that in public comment, perhaps it's not an issue for the castoff folks. So I'm a little bit surprised by that. But that would be the only really red flag that I have with the project is the way the strategy is laid out to exit the property via the castoff towards Chateau. So I'd like to have staff address that.
2:41:07 Spent a lot of time discussing that very issue. It's a very good question in our pre-meetings and we actually had public works go to the site. So I don't know who would like to address it. I can briefly touch on it and we also have the public works director, Grady Dutton, here as well to elaborate on any public works standards or requirements for that. So as discussed in the stack board, the easement is a 20-foot easement which starts just on the
2:41:36 We can't have some traffic calming such as
2:42:03 Signs at the exit that say slow two-way traffic or caution two-way traffic, but there's nothing the town could require. The town can't enforce the speed limit or anything like that because it's private property. As far as addressing the collection of junk and couches in the back, that would be something that code enforcement could address on a case-by-case basis.
2:42:30 We can write in paper that, you know, they'll keep that site clean and free of debris, but there's nothing physically, yeah. So, Nolan, a traffic calming measure, as maybe the guests were exiting the property onto the cast-off property would be something along the lines of maybe a speed bump? And that would be up to the applicant to put in place, is that? Or is that not an option because of snow removal? Yeah, I actually let Grady address that one.
2:42:59 Talk about traffic calming and how they work with snow. Or they don't work, yeah. Thanks, Nolan. Yeah, Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Nolan covered those subjects very well. Most of the restrictions that we'd want to put on there to make sure it stayed clear would be on cast-off, and that's, we really can't do that. They do have the required width for the drive on the way out. It looks good. In terms of traffic calming, the only thing that we've discussed, which I actually, you know,
2:43:24 We suggested was to put a speed limit sign and an additional warning to people that, you know, you're going into two-way traffic from this point when you leave Mammoth Creek Inn, headed north through the cast-off parking lot. Speed bumps, you don't see a lot around town because they're not fun for snow removal. They just don't work. My own engineering opinion of speed bumps is that I don't care for them either because, as a driver, you end up looking at the speed bump instead of the other instructions and kids on the street and things like that, so I don't like recommending them generally.
2:43:54 Well, I agree that that is not the best circulation. I do agree also, though, that it is improved. It does help Mammoth Fire get in and out of there, being able to go one way. The diagonal parking actually will widen it because two-way parking through there when there are cars parked there is very difficult. I actually walk past there every morning on my way in and took particular attention. It also suggested an improvement, and again, I'm not arguing either side, but an improvement is that exiting that facility onto
2:44:24 Chateau rather than Old Mammoth is also a good thing because there is a speed issue as people come down Old Mammoth Road eastbound and come around that corner. Right. And if you're exiting there, it will be safer to exit out onto Chateau. So I think we're doing all we can in terms of...
2:44:41 The limitations. The traffic calming. Yeah. The real issue is an enforcement one with cast off and we might want to just remind them very nicely that, by the way, since you have granted this easement, you're allowing this, we won't have a problem with it, but we're going to have to take a better look at your parking lot from now and then to make sure that the couches, and I actually have couches going both directions from that store myself, that they do have to be clear and the drive lane and the access has to be clear. Perfect. Thank you. Thank you.
2:45:10 And while we're on this subject, I just want to make one other comment, is that in the past, the castoff has sublet the two spaces upstairs, two businesses that had a fair number of people going in and out. Is my understanding that, well, one lease has been terminated, the other one will be terminated in a couple months, and that the castoff then will be only using it for storage, so you would not expect the...
2:45:40 People exiting out that side door like they currently do. Okay. A couple of things. I'm a little concerned to hear that there's a perceived materials issue at this point. As I see it, the applicant has come forward and worked with town staff and
2:46:20 met all of the legal and code requirements to come forth with this project. I'm just curious as to where in that process did the materials and design feature break down to where after months and months of work, both by the staff and the applicant, we come to a point
2:46:52 Okay.
2:47:29 The showing of the property in context, the, by the way, I appreciate the walk through the woods there to the creek side. That would obviously be the, you know, the most detrimental view one could have is from that direction. But I think that after viewing
2:48:05 The site and the potential buildings from that location, I feel comfortable with that particular aspect. CBiz, you know, as Chair Brown mentioned, you know, the council has looked at this. They've since rescinded the CBiz.
2:48:42 policy or it's in that process. I don't know that we as a commission can hold anybody to a standard of a process that no longer exists. The comment was made by Mr. Woodward that it was basically $6,000 to buy excess density. Unfortunately, that's what happened.
2:49:14 And I don't think we as commissioners can do anything about that, nor should we hold that against the applicant. The materials, I think I'm good with the project. I would like to see possibly some tightening up of materials to get more.
2:49:50 More defined as to exactly what those materials are going to be. I think there were, I was not at the materials or design workshop for this, so I'm at a disadvantage there as to what was said or not said. I've not heard of an etching problem with, I guess it's this core 10.
2:50:25 So I'm just not, I'm not able to make any comment on that. My position would be to support the project. I would support it probably with a condition that we would have to figure out how to craft this, but with a condition to
2:51:05 I would suggest that our design committee work with the applicant's designer and
2:51:38 nail down exactly what these materials are going to be. That's all I have to say. Thank you. Okay. My turn. Overall, from the big picture perspective, I also support the project. I do, as well as Commissioner Tenney, remember, though, that at our design committee meeting, we did discuss the possibility of
2:52:20 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:52:52 you know, include that, include a further refinement of the materials as a condition, I'd be happy in that respect. As far as seeing the building in context, I do think it would be very helpful, although it was very helpful to be out on the site today. I can, you know, I personally can picture what it would look like on site, but I am
2:53:27 Not sure that I can speak for everyone else here. So it might be nice to see at least an elevation or two, including the surrounding buildings and context. Mr. Woodward made a comment earlier about birdhouses on Main Street, and maybe this is just my rookie status here, but I really have no idea what he's talking about. It's a bad slang term we have for a set of condominium.
2:53:57 That's a mammoth, mammoth gateway project. Oh, okay. I think it was after that, Amy, I think it was after that project we started requiring computer generated simulations of what it would look like on the site because we got burned. Okay, thank you. So, so I don't think I have any major comments. I would be in support of the project with the condition of refining the materials palette. So, I just want to double check. So, the only issue we have,
2:54:31 Is basically design material context. It's not just the materials for me, it's also where the materials are. When we talk about an integrated design, you know, to see one material sort of plopped on top of a building and not see it anyplace else. And then what kind of material could be put on the elevator shaft, on the exterior. So it's sort of exterior placement of materials and what kind of materials, you know, just.
2:55:01 to make it hang together. That's my concern. So I have a question for staff. Rather than trying to write a condition to cover this, perhaps it would be easier to just to continue this into our next meeting, and then we wouldn't have any public hearing. All we would do is just hopefully then
2:55:30 The applicant and Craig Tapley could meet with the design review. They could get their answers to their questions, and then they could just come back with the design portion of that. With the pleasure of the commission? Right. I mean, I think that would be easier than trying to write a condition, don't you? I think the condition, if we had a condition, it would be very broad. It would just say that the final design of the building should be subject to review and approval.
2:56:00 of the Community Development Director upon recommendations from the Design Committee. That's what I would propose, just a high level that doesn't call out all the details. I mean, we could include the details, but that would give the Design Committee the ability to take a look at it, suggest changes, and then it could be finally approved by the Community Development Director. And can we also require the computer simulation of how it looks on the site from all sides?
2:56:28 With respect to the surroundings, the context thing is part of that. I mean, that was what the applicant said he would do according to these applicant response to the committee's recommendations, and it didn't happen. Yes, we can include a condition that requires that for that review if you want to add those conditions on. So, Commissioner Craig, would you be comfortable with that condition? Yes. I could support that. So, I'd like to ask Craig Capley or Stephen or somebody,
2:57:00 How would you feel about us adding that commission into our motion? And do you understand what we're asking? Okay. Well, thank you, commission, for your comments. I've been in the area for 25 years, and we've used Corten for the last 15, and I've never in our environment seen Corten run. I've never seen it. I've got it on my house for 12 years. It doesn't run. Once it oxidizes, it stays.
2:57:40 It's never etched a window that I've seen. So Bruce's comments kind of came in sideways. And I think it's peculiar how it kind of swayed the Commission's decision on the material. I apologize for my short-sidedness in producing a computer-generated context map. I thought that day that it brought the photographs and when you discussed the buildings, that was accepted. No, it says right here.
2:58:10 To have the commission tell us what type of materials we're to use on what part of the building, it might be a little bit too, it might just go on and on and on. If we agree today, I'll do the computer generated context, a 3D graphic, we can do that. But Elizabeth and I have never really seen eye to eye on materials or components or building context.
2:58:38 So I feel that... That was a broad statement. What are you referring to? I'm referring to even the SAR building. But I don't want to go there. It's just that I just don't want to get into a predicament where I'm having the commission telling us what type of materials we're supposed to use on what type of the building. So... Okay, well, let me just address it. So the reason we have a design review committee is because...
2:59:10 The Commission as a whole does not want to be involved in every minute detail. But on the other hand, we want to have these overall design guidelines about what we want the town to look like. So that's why there is a design review. And I can appreciate that. And the last meeting we had, it was, you know, we were split on even the Commission. You know, Amy liked it. Elizabeth never did.
2:59:39 I don't know what we can do from this point, but I would like to sit down with the design review group and refine the materials. All right. And exactly where they are and what they are. So basically, as I understand, the way we would write this condition is we would approve the project, then as a condition, you would sit down with the design review committee. And how many people are on the committee?
3:00:10 Two. Well, two commissioners. Two commissioners. Is this the whole committee or just the two commissioners? It's just the two commissioners. That is the design committee. Okay. And then they would make a recommendation to our planning and economic development manager and she would make the final decision. Is that right? That's what I was suggesting. So that could be one possibility.
3:00:40 And I think, you know, from my perspective, if it came to where we couldn't agree, the design committee couldn't agree on something like that, I would probably bring it back to the commission at that point. Well, just another question, too. Is this just in regards to the elevator shaft and trying to break up the vertical monotony of that, Ms. Tinney? Or are we talking about bringing you an actual material sample of the core tent?
3:01:07 Just to get better understanding. The way this works for large projects with the advisory design panel, when you have professional architects and designers and planners, and you talk about issues, opportunities, and constraints, and a constraint would be what Bruce mentioned about the Core 10. I don't know these things, but, you know, he's had experience. And then, you don't design the building, that's not our job at all, but we can make suggestions about things that concern us.
3:01:36 Based on what the general plan requires, and then we can ask you to come back with various options and renderings, which is what we had asked you to do for today. And that's what we would ask you to do. We're not going to say, we'll put this here and put that there. We'll say, there's a problem with this elevation because there's a large mass with no relief. And then we'd say, how could you fix that? And that's how that sort of thing works.
3:02:01 Great. That's what I was assuming. I just didn't know if you were going to put materials here and there. And when I say the building isn't integrated in my eye, it looks like a checklist to me. It's just different elements. They don't, they don't, they're not cohesive. It doesn't come together. But that was, you know, my opinion. That's why I was concerned about, I'm not concerned about the project, but I'm concerned about that aspect of it, especially in such a visible prime location, even though there are trees there.
3:02:31 That's a very important site. Okay. Yeah. And just to clarify, I was suggesting that the design committee of the commission review this, not the ADP, not the advisory committee. No, oh, no, but I was explaining in terms that we don't design, ADP doesn't design the professionals. They raise issues and problems, and then they might make suggestions. Well, could you break that up, or could you do this, or could you do those to the professionals? And we raise issues. This can be accomplished easily, Elizabeth. We raise issues based on our experience where we say,
3:03:01 This just doesn't work and, you know, you considered this and, but no, we don't design the building. And everything I look at up here, I look at in the context of the general plan, that's what I do. So your statement, I take issue with your statement. I just want to confirm that you would be okay with us adding a condition or would you rather to have the hearing continued? No, let's add the condition. I think I'm comfortable with that.
3:03:38 So we would propose two conditions. One condition would say the applicant shall provide a rendering of the buildings in context prior to the consideration of the final design by the planning manager and the design committee. And then the second condition would say the final design of the building shall be subject to the review and approval by the planning manager upon recommendation from the design committee. Are you ready to make a motion? I can go with that. Can I call for the motion? Okay. I'll go ahead with this.
3:04:14 I move that we accept the staff's recommendation and choose option one, and that is, number one, make the required CEQA findings, two, adopt the required municipal code findings, three, adopt the required subdivision act findings, and approve tentative tract map, 14,
3:04:44 and design review 14-002 with conditions as recommended by staff. So before I call for the second that staff have any other comments about this? Chair Brown, could Sandra read that condition back to us? Can you read your... Yes, two additional conditions. The first one, the applicant shall provide a rendering of the buildings in context.
3:05:15 Prior to the consideration of the final design by the planning manager and the design committee, and then the second would be the final design of the building shall be subject to review and approval of the planning manager upon a recommendation from the design committee. I call for a second. I second the motion. Is there any discussion on the motion? Roll call, please. Commissioner Grayack? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Harvey?
3:05:51 Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. The motion passes 5-0. And then I just have one question, procedural question. You know, maybe when we do our reports in the future, we might actually put, if like the full design review has happened, you know, who was on the design panel and what their vote was as far as approval on that, just to give us a little bit of background on the design. Okay. And thank you very much for your work.
3:06:38 And thank you very much for coming. Thank you. We'll now move on to our next agenda item, which is a business matter. It's to recommend that Town Council adopt the attached draft ordinances, updating Municipal Code Chapter 8.12 and adding new Chapter 8.14. And the staff contact person is Peter and Greg. Thank you.
3:07:07 Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Again, I'll make a brief introduction and turn it over to Peter for a little bit more detail. I just want to mention that we did have a conversation with Town Attorney Annie Morris after the preparation of your packet, and as we expected, there were a couple of other tweaks that he wanted to make to the ordinances themselves, specifically regarding the lids on...
3:07:31 Recyclable receptacles, which will actually go in 812 as opposed to 814. And also we wanted to tighten up and add a little bit more information to the Green Building Code references in 814 to add a little bit more meat in there. Right now we just refer to the Green Building Code. We'd like to put a little bit more in there about the plan. What we're asking you to do today is to recommend to Town Council that this process keep moving.
3:07:56 And that we do take these forward. And Peter will explain a little bit about why and how we're satisfying some CalRecycle requirements in doing so. I also want to mention that we have met with Mammoth's Disposal and I know Sierra's here as well. I see Brian in the audience if they have any comments they can add to this. This is really just the first step, if you will, in this part of the plan. There's a larger issue with solid waste in terms of...
3:08:20 More detail in terms of the plan and implementation, but this will allow us to begin implementing some things and actually have some teeth behind enforcement. You do have one handout today, the resolution. I printed a separate one because when I talked to the town attorney, he mentioned that this resolution doesn't actually have to be recorded, so he's taken out some of that language so we don't have to go through that step. This is a recommendation to town council basically to move forward with the ordinances.
3:08:47 With that, I'll turn it over to Peter for a little bit more staff report. Thank you. Thanks, Grady. So I'm not going to go through and read all of the staff report, but just kind of highlight major components, and then if there's questions, I think Elizabeth in the past has had some questions regarding overall waste disposal in town, and if I can answer maybe most of those questions. With this, though, the Commission's asked to review and evaluate the proposed amendments and additions to the Missile Code.
3:09:20 Refuge disposal and we've actually changed the main to solid waste management. So it makes a little more sense of what we're actually doing with our solid waste today. We're not just taking it to the dump. A couple of findings staff is asking commission to make, which is that this is not a project. Approval of these amendments will not have any effect on any properties or management or
3:09:49 impacts on the environmental that will have a negative impact. These are really just implementing programs that are somewhat in place, they're not entirely in place, and this will hopefully further recycling within the community. In addition, finding genes related to the general plan policies, and there's a couple of tables in there that help guide this commission through the recycled.
3:10:15 Clean efforts that are within the general plan for the community to move forward and recycle more, and in the end we'll be complying with state law. And then further, in the interest, and this is really related to enforcement, interest of public health, safety, comfort, convenience, welfare, is really an enforcement aspect of our solid waste program, which is that we don't want debris cumulating on properties, private properties, or public properties.
3:10:44 that might harbor rodents, disease, and mares as well. So, you know, staff has been working with CalRecycle for many years. A number of years ago, they did take some action. This is well before I was involved in salt waste. And then a few years ago, they wanted an action plan.
3:11:14 And so with that, the town really developed an action plan. It really just said we're going to have a MRF and that's going to solve our issues. Well, the MRF has had its own process and hopefully that will be moving forward later this year into the environmental phase where we can actually select a site and move it into a project. Peter, can you define MRF? Oh, MRF is a material recovery facility. And I think Elizabeth might have some questions about different types of it.
3:11:43 That's not the purpose of this report and the staff agenda bill today, really. So what we're asking the commission to do is approve or recommend approval of the amendments in Chapter 812, which really clarify some definitions. It certainly adds tools for enforcement, hopefully for those problem properties that Steve works with and our code enforcement officer works with.
3:12:12 To control the bear problem and keep properties looking tidy. And it clarifies a couple things that our franchisee, our contractor that takes care of the solid waste in town has had to explain to the public related to why they pay a fee and why it's mandatory. And even if they go to the transfer station, they still are required to pay a solid waste fee.
3:12:42 Chapter 14 really codifies state law in the areas that we can implement locally, which makes it mandatory for businesses to recycle if they've got four cubic yards or more. It makes it mandatory for multifamily, which in this case is five or more units, recycle. CalRecycle defines the number of units differently than we do in our municipal code for zoning, which is two or more.
3:13:13 Or for waste collection, which is three or more, or more than three. And then it also includes requirements for major events, which are more than 2,000 people at one event. So really these are requests that CalRecycle has been asking the town to do for a few years. We've been working with them in many areas.
3:13:46 Most recently, they really saw two things that would help us stay in what's called best efforts program and keep us out of the compliance program, which is where they can find the town and have other enforcement tools related to our town government.
3:14:11 One was that we weren't really enforcing the multifamily business recycling. We didn't have the tools to do that, and we weren't really monitoring for the whole community how that's working or not working. Certainly, you know, our contractor provides two routes, really. They pick up garbage, and then they also pick up, what's included in the fee, they'll pick up cardboard. So they have a separate route.
3:14:40 Picks up cardboard from businesses that generate substantial amount of cardboard. And they do it for any business that wants the bin. The issue that they've seen is that the bins take up basically a parking space because most of the properties were not designed around two bins or multiple bins. They were really designed around one bin. And so they don't really have that space for an additional cardboard. And then the other partner that's in the community town also contracts with them is the Sierra Conservation Project.
3:15:08 And they provide that level of service. They'll come onto your property, provide bins, and do the sorting essentially for you, the customer, to be compliance with the recycling requirements. There's really been, we haven't done significant outreach regarding this, although we've done significant outreach in the community regarding recycling. Last year we,
3:15:42 Basically deliver to each one of the business the tent cards that most many of you have seen. And we've had several mailers that go out to try to educate and improve our recycling opportunities and reclaim the benefits of diverting waste from the landfill. And so Sierra Conservation Projects provides that service. And many, they've got, you know, a lot of customers.
3:16:10 And there'll be a press release going out soon where they've got additional bins so that additional people can sign up for that and have, will not have to purchase their own bin but will be able to be provided by CalRecycle through a grant from, from Sierra Conservation Project through a grant from CalRecycle that the town and they received. So I mentioned that we're renaming the chapter of solid waste management and the,
3:16:44 The changes and the new additions that are within the chapter. Essentially, so we have those two contracts that I talked about. Additionally, our franchise agreement with Mammoth Disposal, it's an exclusive agreement, so they are in charge of all waste in town other than the recyclables type of waste. And with that,
3:17:12 They also provide the buyback center, that service, so that residents can go down and get their CRV materials paid for, and they also provide the service that's next to bonds, and they participate heavily in our town cleanup days as part of their contract with the town and the fees that are paid by the residents in town. With that,
3:17:46 There are several tables laid out for the findings and the general plan findings. If there's questions about those, I'd be happy to answer them. If I could add just two quick things. One is on an enforcement side. This is, it's written so that Public Works will be enforcing it instead of the code enforcement officer, which makes Sandra very happy on the other side of that. The difficulty there, of course, is that it takes a lot of staff to do that.
3:18:12 And what I'd ask, and I'm not asking for 100 emails a week, believe me, but anecdotally, if people in the public see something, you know, we get calls all the time about things like this. We don't mind those calls. We don't need 10 calls on the same one. We don't need follow-up because we will take care of that. But if you see things, take a picture, send us an email, anything like that. Once this ordinance goes into effect, that is helpful.
3:18:34 Because then we can direct our code enforcement people, whether it's somebody from Public Works, an inspector out in the field, hey, drive by on this street, things like that. That is helpful. The only other comment I have, and I do see Steve in the audience, is I personally don't consider it a bare problem, no offense. It's more a receptacle problem and a use problem. There's actually a bin in the parking lot 30 feet from my front door, and it's tourists don't know how to work.
3:18:59 The big brown one, and that's why we have a bear problem. It becomes a mess. It's bad for the bears. So we'll be working with Mammoth's Disposal. We hopefully they'll get rid of those older containers so we have it better. And frankly, I talk to my neighbors all the time about how to work the thing. So that's the only other comments I have. And with that, we ask that you consider this and hopefully recommend to council so we can keep this moving. I have two questions. Yes. First question for Sandra and then one for Peter and Grady.
3:19:30 Sandra, does the fact that CalRecycle defines multifamily differently than our zoning code does affect our zoning code in any way? No. We can have two definitions for multifamily depending on what we're talking about? Oh, that's what, yeah. Yes, we can. Okay. And I wish there was another word besides waste because our goal is, you know, reuse. I mean, it's going to get reused somehow and I wish we could call it discards or anything but solid waste. Potential.
3:19:57 Potentially, yeah, something just all, you know, the birds are singing and the clouds are in the sky. Something else that I wish you could consider maybe in your review of the contract with Mammoth Disposal or however it would work out, but very few people in town have pickup trucks and when it's spring cleanup and you're cleaning up for the fire department, you know, cleaning up around your house, getting rid of the pine needles and the pine cones and all that kind of stuff.
3:20:23 It would be great if somebody could come around on a specified time and just pick all that stuff up. It would be a labor charge because it probably would require snow shovels instead of, it's not like chipping with limbs. But it's a fire problem. It's a source of soil amendment. I mean, it could be really valuable for somebody who wants to enrich some soil. But it's a real problem because people don't have pickup trucks and you're just not going to bag that stuff up and put it in your car trunk.
3:20:51 I appreciate that suggestion. Actually, we did our in-house town clean-up day just a few weeks ago, and we sent out a lot of recyclable containers, that's for sure, just out of the town offices. But specific to your point, and I don't know how it works in terms of budget funds, who does it and all that, but I was actually in a community once last year where they had two days a year where they just said, anything you want to get rid of, put it on the curb. And they had special trucks that came by and just, that's what they did. But twice a year, that was your one chance.
3:21:21 To unload the couches that can't go to cast off or DSCS, those kind of things. And it was an amazing street to drive down. I happened to be there that day and there was stuff piled all over the place. So I appreciate that suggestion. I'll look into that. And again, I can't speak for funding or who actually does it, but it's something we should talk about. Just defending cast off, those couches that are left there, they have to pay a dump fee at the landfill to get rid of them because they don't accept couches.
3:21:49 Poor castoff, you know, trying to do a good thing and then look what happens. No, that would be great if we could know that the rakeings were going to be cleaned up too. A couple follow-ups. And people can call for a special pickup at any time, although there would be a fee associated with it based on the weight or the size. And my understanding with the castoff couches, at least most recently, they waived the fee from the castoff for those dumped couches that weren't.
3:22:16 So you're saying you can call them at disposal for a special pickup? Yeah. But you pay for that? You'll end up paying for the extra pickup, but they would be able to pick it up all at once. There are some requirements of it being bundled or in a container, and that's in the current municipal code. Well, everybody's got pine needles and pine cones and all that winter stuff. It would be nice if there were a better way to do that. I actually just have a quick question. It's a little bit more for my own information for either Peter or Grady.
3:22:50 It says here in the February 2011 formal review with the Town Solid Waste Recycling Program that we were meeting at 27%. I'm wondering, since that was dated 2011, is that roughly the same number now? Unfortunately, it is. It does vary. If we do a lot of recycling for asphalt, the number goes up, obviously, because the tonnage of asphalt is quite a bit. And this year, so for next year's numbers, it'll be substantially higher. This year, we did recycle a substantial amount of asphalt.
3:23:20 But the year before, we were at 27% again. You know, like I said, Cal Recycle's been working with us closely, looking at our issues regarding weather and animals and the transient population that we have. And so it's been, you know, refreshing to work with an agency that's actually able to understand some of the problems that we have and work with us to improve our situation. Thank you. Okay.
3:23:53 One question for you here. You say the town has been able to stay under the best efforts classification and can you elaborate a little bit on what the boundaries of that are and what the consequences would be if we were not to stay within the best efforts classification and also what
3:24:24 Essentially, best efforts keeps us in the two-year review cycle, although they've been reviewing us since 2011 about every six months, plus or minus. So about twice a year, looking at what we're doing, and essentially when they come, they meet with staff usually, but not every time, but normally they will meet with staff, go over their issues.
3:24:56 Want some information and permits that we've been issuing and how we're implementing the C&D waste and those kinds of things. And then they actually go out in the community and they talk to people. And so that's why I said this last time, what they heard from the people, the community and visitors, was that the town doesn't do any recycling at events and that we're not doing a very good job at recycling at businesses and multifamily.
3:25:24 With that came, you guys need to implement this section of code, of the state law into your code, because the state law, this regulation actually pushes it down to local level that cities and agencies, counties need to enforce those regulations. Now, if we don't enforce it, then they've got the bigger stick, which is they'll have a public, they'll have a compliance review, and I think Inyo County's going through this right now. And then they'll have a formal public hearing about
3:25:55 So the penalties could be as much as $10,000 a day for noncompliance. Now, I don't know that they've actually implemented a fine as such as that high, but there have been fines in the past for other cities that are noncompliant, particularly ones that are vocal about their noncompliance. And generally they'll put that money into a fund that might go back into implementing programs in the city. So if they've got a $350,000 fine,
3:26:22 Then they need, you know, that money might be allocated to them as a grant, so to speak, to do future programs. So we certainly don't want to be in the noncompliance performance. Most recently they've indicated that we may move into the four-year review, which would be better for the town staff and staff time, those kinds of things. What it means is that we're doing a better job educating the public.
3:26:51 The required programs. Can you just repeat for me what you were saying about where the duty of enforcement lies? It lies at the local level. So the regulations that were passed by the state basically made the local agencies and cities responsible for enforcement. Without having it in the Minosal Code, we really don't have the ability to enforce. So this just gives us the tools, and we didn't try to over...
3:27:25 Make it an overly burden, especially on things that we can't, we have a hard time doing locally. For instance, we don't have a single stream roof where we could do more recycling. But it's really bringing it down to that local level that things that we can enforce locally, things that we can do to try to meet and basically best effort to meet the standard of the law. And if we were to exceed the best effort level,
3:27:57 What's the next level that you would want to shoot for? Is it the 50% level that you were talking about? Just full compliance, yeah. Full compliance, which would be 50%? That would be 50%. If we had a single streamer for something like that, we'd be needing that pretty easily. Okay. Elizabeth, maybe a better term would be resource management rather than waste management. Yeah, resource management, exactly. That's good.
3:28:22 Because waste really bothers me. It's very negative considering what we're trying to do. It's not waste anymore. All right. And then this is pretty well the obvious question. I'm assuming that these municipal codes make us legally compliant with the state. Correct. Okay. All right. Is there anybody in the public that would like to comment? Madam Chair, thank you. Steve Searles, Wildlife Management.
3:28:55 Thank you for your comments, sir. I'm disappointed in Peter calling it a bear problem. It's a people problem. I'm sorry I don't have your agenda packet, but why I'm here, and I'm sure that Peter's trying to save time by paraphrasing what you're recommending or putting forward to the council, but what he has run by me is
3:29:21 Oftentimes, properties that are owned by out-of-town people here in town are the worst offenders for feeding wildlife and not taking care of their business on their properties.
3:29:32 I would say that most all of them are. And so when we tried mailing them a ticket without their signature down south to hold those people accountable, take them to court, and charge them for these constant violations of wildlife feeding on the DA through a flag. And I hope that in this packet is the verbiage allowing us to notify the people on mail citations.
3:29:59 Hold them accountable financially and responsible for their properties that they own here in Mammoth for blatant violations of feeding bears. Would that be accurate, Peter?
3:30:09 Yeah, thank you. So I'm sure you guys saw it in there. If you would allow me, Mickey, the other things I wanted to bring to your attention. We all saw the enormous grease flow that went down Old Mammoth Road, soiled all the streets, the curves and gutters. It's still there staining our roads. It was from those giant grease recyclers.
3:30:33 And it all went flowing down the road and everybody drove through it and caused a huge hazard and a magnet for wildlife. Myself and Johnny Getz a few years back went with the two companies who come and recycle this waste product.
3:30:51 usable product for Elizabeth, which I think is appropriate and a good thing. We worked with them. We went to every single restaurant and hotel that has those storages, and there's a lot more than you would think there is, and had every single one of them retrofitted.
3:31:08 Super good, put a stop to the problem, with a large turnover of management, employees, businesses here in Mammoth, five times this year already, the chart house being the worst of the issues by far, but four other times there was minor problems with bears getting into grease recycling, the chaining them to a ballard, a tree, or the building, securing them, all of them are retrofitted, and now many of them aren't up to code anymore.
3:31:37 Property Owners are being held responsible. When Johnny and I went around and did it, we didn't want to come to you or make a law or anything. We just thought it was good common sense and the right thing to do, and everybody was hip to it. Gosh.
3:31:52 I think just like finding these people in restaurants that are blatant offenders, once I take them to court, it stops immediately when you hit them in the pocketbook or put them on Facebook or in the newspaper. So if I could ask you if you can't get it done today, if you could put that on your radar, if that's something that's with, if I'm not speaking out of turn in the meeting, and that's something within the context of what you're working on, that we could make people be responsible to keep those things.
3:32:19 Lock shut to not attract wildlife and cause the public safety and health concern for any kind of wildlife. I could really use your help. The other thing is that this was kind of chaired by Mayor Bacon and the City Council. I don't know where it went. I was hoping the attorney would be here today. But with our homes, you can't take your trash.
3:32:40 and all your junk out, put it out the street, feed our wildlife, that's been for quite a while, yet every mall around town, restaurant and business has got one out front, not every one, I shouldn't say that, but many, we all know those examples, it's a constant nightmare every night, the mayor gave direction for the town staff to follow up on this, it wasn't followed up on, and so the people that are making, well.
3:33:03 I should almost say the most profit, but businesses that are generating income that have trash cans out in front of their businesses that aren't compliant to the same codes that we hold the residential areas to. It doesn't seem fair, it's not efficient, and driving me nuts at night, picking up, you know, following up on this. And so, again, I appreciate your time. I hope I'm not speaking out of turn to the subject matter that's in the bill. I don't want a copy of it.
3:33:29 The agenda. But if you can do this today or have it added to, I'd much appreciate it. And if you can, maybe we can do it through the winter and recommend it to council or get it moved forward so at least it's done by the spring of next year. It seems like it should have been done a while back. It just never got followed up on. Is that fair enough? Does staff have a comment? Yeah, and the current code does require that
3:33:57 All of the trash containers, including ones in front of businesses, be bear proof. It's rampant. We don't have it happening in the residential areas. We have it all on Main Street, Mammoth Road. So that's a really... Yeah, that's really a code enforcement issue. The grease pits? You did? No, the grease pits. Is that in our code, too? Yeah, but they need to be...
3:34:23 Yes? I apologize. No problem. We just need to get it. It's amazing to me how fast the bears knew about the grease. It was Jurassic Park. It was. It was really bad. Yeah. I'm embarrassed now. I thought it was bringing things. These are really big problems for me because, you know, I have a finite job of what I do. But I'm sorry for taking your time.
3:34:51 Thank you. You know, with that said, could I take and make one more comment? Yes. Thank you, ma'am. You guys, I poked my head in earlier. I hope you're shooting with rubber pallets in her or something. I can do that. I can spray you all, yeah. You hosted a meeting this morning with some of the council members. I got to come in for a few minutes. Economic roundtable discussion. Yes. And I got to hear one of the council members speak eloquently to it.
3:35:20 And about our sphere of influence and how we bring people here and what we can do to drive this community out of the hole that we're in. I hope, I'm not sharing with you something that's already on the books, but to see the Lakes Basin closed this weekend with fishing season open, the most beautiful weekend of the year, with Tioga Pass open. My embarrassment.
3:35:43 That you couldn't go up and walk around the lakes, you ride your bicycle, be with your family. Oh, go friggin' fishing. Because they locked us out. They interviewed those people that were so frustrated that they don't have a place to go to the bathroom, use a trash can. I've come before this committee and from other committees for many, many years. Front page of the newspaper, radio, television, council. I think that they finally beat me down where I don't want to speak to them anymore. But I can't believe we were locked out of the lake spacing this weekend. It's shameful.
3:36:12 We shouldn't spend money bringing people to our town unless we can treat them with respect while they're here, sir. Thank you, and I do know that there's certain council members that are working on that issue. Thank you for your time. Thank you. All right. Chair Brown, can I make one more comment? As long as it's about waste. Oh, yes. Or whatever it is. Right. Grady and Peter, I was quite serious, and then Amy chimed in, and now Steve chimed in. Can we rephrase solid waste? Can we change the name before that's a final document? Yes.
3:36:42 I mean, I think that would be a great idea because it's our goal. I agree, we'll take a look at that. When I read it, I reacted to, was it waste disposal? Refuse. Refuse disposal, and I reacted to that immediately, and I was the one who changed it to solid waste management at least. We'll take another step, we'll look at it. Yeah, I think we can do better. No, you're correct. Thank you. We took it one step, but you added to it, so I'm glad we're all on the same page. Doesn't sound good.
3:37:09 Is there anybody else would like to comment on the ordinances? All right. Can I have a call for a motion, please? And that would be the amended resolution. Yes. This will be a good test. Yes. I got the wrong page. No, you need to have a single sheet on that page. Oh, that new one that came. Yes, right here. Thank you.
3:37:54 Amy, you want to jump on it? Thank you. Oh, I thought so. It is page 8. Okay. I'll make a motion that we follow option 1 to recommend to the town council adoption of the required findings and recommend to the town council adoption of the ordinances amending chapter 8.12 and adding chapter 8.14.
3:38:30 Of the Municipal Code. I didn't hear general plan fundings. With amendments. With the amended resolution. Thank you. I'll second. It will call. Commissioner Greyhuck. Yes. Commissioner Tenney. Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Yes. Vice Chair Harvey. Yes. Chair Brown. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you very much. Or a gamey. All right. We'll move to our next item on the agenda.
3:39:04 which is discussion of potential zoning code amendment to remove the use permit requirement for the transient rental of residential uses in the RMF2 zoning district. And our staff person is rude. Thank you. The transient rental of single family homes has been a topic of discussion at both council and commission meetings over the past few years.
3:39:34 This past summer, Council held a meeting to discuss priorities for the coming year and requested again that a discussion on possible changes to existing regulations related to single family transient rentals be brought forward again. At the subsequent Council meeting on October 1st, staff presented background information on single family transient rentals and framed specific questions for discussion. The focus of that meeting was on the transient rental of single family homes. At the conclusion of the October 1st meeting,
3:40:04 Council took several actions, including what ultimately became the subject of this meeting, a direction for staff to move forward with a discussion at a commission meeting on whether transient rentals should be allowed in the residential multifamily 2 zoning district without a use permit. While the focus of the council meeting was on the larger issues and impacts related to single-family transient rentals, they directed that this discussion
3:40:28 be related to all types of transient rental residential uses, but in the RMF II zoning district only. Transient rentals of residential uses have been permitted by use permit in the RMF II zoning district since adoption of the town's zoning code in 1989. It is one of two zoning districts which require a use permit for transient rentals. Specific areas of the resort zoning district, dependent on the master plan, also require a use permit for rentals.
3:40:55 Transient rentals are prohibited in the other residential zoning districts, but are permitted by right in the commercial zoning districts. Generally, the purpose of a use permit is to allow for public review and input on the location, potential impacts of the proposed use, to evaluate compatibility with the surrounding uses, and the suitability of the use to the site. At this time, the majority of the developed properties in the RMF2 zoning district have already been approved for transient rental. Those approvals were granted either by a use permit issued by the town,
3:41:26 Or by Mono County prior to the Townsend Corporation. There are primarily multifamily developments in this zoning district, but there are also approximately 20 single family homes and 20 vacant parcels in the RMF2 district. The request today is for the commission to discuss the proposal and provide direction to staff on whether to move forward. If there is commission consensus that the use permit requirement should be reviewed in more detail and potentially eliminated, a zoning code amendment would be necessary. Issues for consideration of the amendment
3:41:56 Our municipal code consistency, general plan consistency, environmental analysis. If the Planning and Economic Development Commission directs staff to move forward with a draft amendment to the zoning code, staff will return with a full analysis of the issues for consideration and draft and specific draft amendment language. Questions? Ruth, on your analysis number one where it says council directed staff, can you tell me what funding the TOT committee? I'm not clear what that is.
3:42:29 What does that mean? Oh, on the specific actions that council took on October 1st. And the TOT committee is what? No, I know that, but what's the committee? Is this a group of private citizens or is this staff or what? It's one council member and then members of the lodging association and staff. And so really what they were talking about is continuing that committee.
3:42:58 And does the committee need additional funding? That's what that reference is. Committee members are paid a stipend? No, no, no. What's the funding? Staff funding for that. Staff funding, okay. And then my other question, I'm remembering when John Hooper, you know, long-time contractor here, came before us and said that these transient rentals in single family, you have to be sure that everything's up to the Uniform Building Code, et cetera, et cetera. Are you saying in this proposal,
3:43:28 that that will be part of an administrative permit to be sure that all those requirements are met? I didn't see that listed here. Yeah, it's really it's we see it as a separate issue regardless of whether or not a use permits required in this zoning district or an administrative permits required really in any of the zoning districts. The building and fire code interpretations and applicable permits stand on their own.
3:43:55 So this discussion is really related to the land use entitlements and applicable permits through either the fire district, the building department, just like the TOT certificates that are required, are still applicable regardless of the land use process that we, or the commission would determine as appropriate. Okay, I understand that better now. Thank you. That's all. Thank you. Let's change it up. Commissioner Greig, do you have any questions on this? No, I don't think so. Commissioner Harding?
3:44:35 Commissioner, do you have any questions? I do. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I was taking my breath here. Oh, okay. I think the process, it's long overdue to get started, and I'd like to see this situation analyzed, not from an emotional standpoint, but from a practical standpoint. I think this is what's going to best...
3:45:05 serve the folks of our community. This has been on the table for a long, long time and it seems to come and go as the years pass and it's usually because we have not gotten to at least this particular step and I'm just happy to see it coming forward.
3:45:33 I think what we will see out of this process is reality as to whether this will work for our community or it will not work for our community. And I guess I've got a lot of faith in the process. So I'm very much in favor of this. Just a quick question, and this is just for my own information. This is properties that are in compliance with
3:46:05 This already, and we're reviewing this on a one-on-one basis up to this point, is that correct? Correct, yeah, and this proposal really has a very specific scope, but it's looking at all residential uses in the RMF2 zoning district. Right. And evaluating them as a whole as to whether or not they should all be exempt from that use permit process. Right. If they'd like to rent transiently.
3:46:30 Got it. So, yeah, up until this point, we've been reviewing specific applications. Case by case. Mm-hmm. Thank you. Yeah. Comments, questions? Yeah. Is this an appropriate comment? Yes, it is. Thank you. Madam Chairman, members of the Commission, Frank Freebolt, Mantex Fire Chief. Welcome. In the process, really, we just wanted to ensure two questions were addressed as we go through this. One would be, if there is no permitting process in the future.
3:47:06 What would be the mechanism by which the fire district would be notified that a single family residence had gone to a rental property? That would be one. And then just that when we go through the full analysis, if the commission goes forward, that the fire district would be allowed to be part of that full analysis from a code standpoint. A municipal standpoint? You're only talking about municipal code, right? Because that's what we're looking at at this point, is just the municipal code. The point would be if...
3:47:37 I understand the land use may be one portion, but we're not sure how we would be notified if a property went to a land use because then we have incumbent codes that we would have to enforce or review for enforcement. So I'm not sure if we go out of the permitting process, that's fine. I just need to know how we'd be in the queue. And then if we understood it right under the analysis section, Code 3 and Staff Report, or I'm sorry, Item 3, Zoning Code Amendment.
3:48:06 Last paragraph, staff will return with a full analysis of the issues for consideration. In terms of any code review, we want to make sure that we had a chance to weigh in on that. So do you want to comment? I mean, you know when they'll be notified, right? Sure. Well, you're right that as a part of the use permit application process, we typically involve the fire district as one of our reviewers in the use permit. But that would be something we could bring back at the next meeting.
3:48:36 At what step in this new administrative process would the fire department be notified? Exactly. And it'd be likely at the same time as our building department's notified and allowed a chance to review. That would be great, yes. All right, thank you very much. Thank you. Tom Cage. Just a point of clarity, it says discussion of potential zoning code amendment to remove the use permit requirement.
3:49:10 You buy a house in an RMF2 area and you decide that you want to rent it out. You don't have to do any paperwork or you don't have to have the property reviewed or you still have to bring it into the town offices for other than a business license. It simply means it's a land use permitted by right, but that doesn't exempt it from permits that may be required by
3:49:39 The fire department, building department, and finance department. So the land use is permitted by right and doesn't require review by the commission, but there's still other applications or permits that may still be necessary. So currently, RMF 2, it's allowed already by right, correct? It's allowed with a use permit. With a use permit.
3:50:01 So I'm trying to figure out the difference. If it's allowed with a use permit, that means it comes before? It comes before Planning Commission. For them to review its compatibility, parking, snow storage, things like that? Correct. It's mostly compatibility with surrounding land uses. And at this point, the RMF2 zoning district is primarily made up of properties that already are approved for transient rental. So that compatibility question.
3:50:29 You know, the more use permits we approve becomes more negligible, if that makes sense. It makes sense until you reach a limit of capacity, I guess, for roadways or snow removal or parking. There's only 22 of them. If you look at the map of the RMF2, we're only talking about 22 homes in total. There's got to be more than 22 homes in the RMF2. 22 that aren't already permitted.
3:50:59 That aren't already permitted for TOT-type rentals? Most of the development in the RMF2 zoning district are condos and apartments. There are about 20 or 21 single-family homes in that district, and then 20 vacant parcels. So it's primarily made up of multifamily condo projects, which are already approved for transient rentals, and then one or two single-family homes that have been approved out of that 20 that have been approved.
3:51:27 For transient rental. Thank you for clarifying. Thank you. Any other questions? Comments? All right. Commission, do you have any comments about this? I learned recently that in South Lake Tahoe, single family residential zoning, if transient rentals, they have to post a sign outside saying how many cars can be parked at the rental.
3:52:01 All kinds of requirements very clearly stated. And so if there's a disturbance in the neighborhood, and I don't know if that's something to consider as you develop the language, so if there's a disturbance or loud partying or something, then the neighbors can call because it says clearly on the sign what's permitted and what's not. I don't know if that's part of this discussion or something to hold off until we talk about single-family residential. The reality is if somebody comes forward and asks for a use permit,
3:52:31 Currently, and they're in a multifamily zone, it's pretty hard to deny the use permit because that's a zoning that permits multifamily. So it just eliminates that step of having, you know, come to action before the commission and allows them to do what they administratively need to do.
3:52:51 As far as the building and the fire. The only reason I brought that up, though, if you are developing, are you developing language, it will come back to us? We're developing a work, well, so there's two separate things. So we have this item to consider elimination of a use permit, which is a pretty focused item. The staff is going to bring back a work program.
3:53:13 On the topic of single family rentals, which goes beyond this, to the council, and we would be recommending looking at those types of regulations if the council wants to proceed with the work program. Okay. All right. Can I have a motion, please? It's 4 o'clock. Yeah, make the motion. Staff, the recommendations by staff is that Planning and Economic Development Commission consider and discuss the proposal.
3:53:47 and provide direction to staff on whether to move forward with a draft amendment to the zoning code to remove the use permit requirement for residential uses in the RMF 2 zoning district. Do I have a second? I have a second. Roll call, please. Just to clarify, are you recommending that they move forward? Yes. Yes.
3:54:21 Did not make myself clear. Commissioner Greyhack? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Harvey? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes by, Gerald. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. We'll now move on to our next agenda item. This was an item that I had requested to be put on the agenda, and it's discussed
3:54:52 Planning and Economic Commission stipend center. Our advocate is Sandra. So the commission did receive stipends, as some of you remember, and we eliminated stipends along with a number of things in 2012 in response to the economic downturn and our settlement with the MLLA. So basically the commission used to receive $200 per commission meeting.
3:55:19 Not to exceed two meetings per month. So the stipend was only for formal meetings held by the commission, not for design committee meetings or any other minor meetings like that. So this item is to allow the commission to discuss whether or not they'd like to make a formal request from the council to reinstate those stipends. It's my understanding that the council is considering that at this point in the next fiscal and in our next budget. So the commission could include
3:55:48 A letter, could agree to write a letter, or some other method of communicating to the council on this issue. Yeah, I mean, I don't think that it necessarily needs to be a council item, but, I mean, as we discussed previously, the way they were removed and then the way we were combined with the other commissions was pretty informal at best, and so my only reason for this is I would just like council to formally acknowledge.
3:56:17 That our stipends were removed and that, you know, to make some sort of commitment that in a certain time frame that that issue will be reviewed. I mean, I just don't want them to forget that it happened. And basically, I mean, I don't think we actually want it as a council. We just really just need to draft probably the mayor some type of letter to the whole council. What do you think? Yeah, I think I would be for that.
3:56:49 And I think that needs to point out the lack of a stipend, although I don't believe any of us are standing or sitting here for the money. The fact is that costs are incurred on a regular basis. And whether you order printer ink online or you drive to Carson,
3:57:21 or whatever it takes. It's been my experience that Commission members have gone above and beyond repeatedly to supply themselves with whatever tools that they need at whatever cost to get their job done and perform professionally. And when the reductions came,
3:57:51 I don't believe that there was, or at least I did not hear a whimper from anyone. The commission was more than ready to step up and take its cuts, just like other portions of the town. So I think this is a fair, equitable, and just request.
3:58:20 This is a volunteer position for sure. I mean, we have many, many meetings to go to, and it's a lot of work, but none of us are complaining about it because we love Mammoth and we believe in what we're doing. However, I completely concur with Dave. We incur a lot of costs. You know, pay for gas, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And the stipend was taken away, which we all understood, but then the work of four commissions was assigned to us, and so we're now doing, you know, that work too.
3:58:49 And I think a stipend is in order, so I concur with, who's going to draft the letter? Staff? Staff can draft the letter for review by the chair. Okay, good. All right. And signature by the chair. I concur. And then the only other point, if you don't know, planning commission is the only legally mandated commission. Right. Right. A town and town has to have a planning commission. So they can't just...
3:59:19 Eliminate that commission, like maybe the Mobility Commission or the Air Partners. All right. Thank you. Any other discussion on that? Okay. How are you doing with time? Good. Okay. We've got to get to our meeting. All right. So now, this is part two of our discussion this morning, and next week we have our Joint Town Council Planning and Economic Development meeting.
3:59:49 It's a two-hour meeting. And I really commend council personally for sitting down and putting all of their priorities on paper. And then what Sandra and I did is we went through that whole list with Commissioner Fernie and said, okay, where do you see the crossover with our commission?
4:00:20 And so that's how this list came up here. So we thought maybe that was a really good place. Last week we thought maybe that was a really good place to start. Now, you know, I mean, I felt like this morning we had this terrific conversation. We were just getting to some really good question points. And then our time is up. I know, I wish it had been longer. So I'm not quite sure how best to approach next weekend.
4:00:51 Open to any suggestions or comments for people about that. And you have FYI that we reprinted the work program because for some reason on some of the copies it didn't come out 11 by 17 so there's one on each. And I know for some reason. Oh, probably I know. Because I'm paperless. Can I jump in first? Thank you. All right, go ahead. Can I jump in first? Okay.
4:01:23 I'm all about placemaking. This really matters to me. Placemaking in terms of development and architecture that's worthy of our spectacular surroundings. Placemaking in the sense of how we treat our guests, our visitors, what kind of experience they have, what kind of place this is. That's really, really important to me.
4:01:41 After 21 years of living here and after three years of drought, I'm really getting worried. Just after the Pier Resort Tour in 2007, and I saw what was out there, what our competition is, and then I followed how they have developed since. We're just getting further and further behind. We're just digging that hole deeper and deeper, and we really have to do some things.
4:02:01 to increase that experience and to improve our sense of place. And I'm not focused on down the road. I'm looking at a quick win which is completely consistent with the council's priority of enhanced community amenities. And that goes along with number five on our list about things that have already been done that are ready to go and why can't we talk about them. For instance, the
4:02:29 Thing about wayfinding and community messaging. We got a grant from Caltrans. We spent so much staff time and Planning Commission time. Came up with a really good proposal. And I even got the phone cord back again so everybody can see how good this was. Can TV see this? Can't see me, though. Anyway, just a really good proposal. It follows on the theme that the Gateway started.
4:02:53 And it helps the visitor experience by giving them wayfinding directions so they can find out where they are. And living in Old Mammoth, I see all these people that break when they get to the Catholic Church and then try and pull off because they realize they're lost. So it does that. And it also has the different monument signs for our different neighborhoods, which gives us a sense of place. And people feel like...
4:03:16 First, they can find their way around, so they feel welcome, so that's a good thing. But also, it shows developers, we've got our act together. You know, this is a quick win. Something we could do soon. The whole thing with FAR and the commercial zoning and what's going to happen with Eagle Lodge and the land exchange that we talked about this morning, these are all important things, but these are down the road. And I think we've got to do something quickly. This is shovel-ready, ready to go. And I think we should strongly urge council.
4:03:45 to find the funding to do this because this is an excellent design. We all know how good it is. We all approved it. It's just like what Mammoth would look like. Case in point, I was on vacation the last three weeks and I went to, went through Albany, California, which is this little working town between Berkeley and El Cerrito. And it's donut shops and garages and Chinese restaurants, that kind of stuff. No character at all. For some reason, they decided to put up street signs with a, you know, way find street name signs.
4:04:14 With a distinctive font, and a distinctive color, and a little design, and all of a sudden, this town got pulled together. It just looked, it was amazing the difference that made. And somebody told me about, yeah, it's like when you go from Venice to Santa Monica. The street signs they have in Santa Monica, well, of course, Venice is Venice, but, you know, the street signs they have in Santa Monica pulls the place together. Santa Monica doesn't need that much help with street signs, but. Commissioner Tanney, can I? It really makes a difference.
4:04:43 What? I understand that. I'm sure the rest of the commission understand that. Oh, am I belaboring my point? I'm sorry. Now what I would ask is are you attempting to garner consensus from the commission? Yes, I am. Please. To move the wayfinding signage.
4:05:05 Into our priority, our first priority. Let's make this happen. To finish that program. Absolutely. It's ready to go to bed. Well, let me just. And so can we make that a recommendation to council? Is there consensus for that? Did I hear the number thrown around this morning was about $800,000 for that project? For the pedestrian and vehicular within town, $350,000, plus the gateways within town was $225,000.
4:05:30 And I spoke with Haislip Hayes, and he said that the funding for the gateways was anticipated to come from the private sector. And then there was the additional airport, which was $112,000. So if we just did in the town, and we just did the portion that was not anticipated to come from the private sector, then it would be $350,000. I did understand from Hayes that there was a
4:05:52 Money for a pilot project to do the downtown district sign, but he didn't want to do one sign if we weren't going to follow through and do the rest. Yeah, I'm not aware of the... I'm not... That's possible. That's... I would have to check with him. I can't verify that, but he did say that. Anyway, I just... This is an example of a quick win. We just got to do it now. Okay, so let's... While we wait for all this other stuff. We all agree with you. We all agree with you. Oh, thank you. This is your choir. Bye. Okay.
4:06:19 I think we have to be realistic, and our council does have certain financial restraints, okay, so when, and we will come back with this, I guess, in January, when the working group put together the preliminary budget for the infrastructure financing district, I mean, the way that we're going to assure that that gets done is by putting wayfinding in there and then putting our preliminary main street in there.
4:06:49 So that's our default position because I believe we will have that completed before Council's going to have the money to allocate to wayfinding. So you're going to bundle them. Is that what you're saying? Mm-hmm. So the quick win is January. Well, it won't be quick. I mean, it won't be done in January. I mean, you've got to be realistic. I mean, I don't know where Council's going to come up with $350,000.
4:07:17 But that's always the problem, you know, it's always, we just don't have the money. Right, so if they don't, we can certainly ask for the money, but just know that if they don't come up with the money,
4:07:26 I mean, I agree it should be, I mean, it's something completed, we're all ready for it, but if they don't have the money, then I just think that we should know that we can still get this done by including it in our infrastructure financing. And it isn't just because we're ready for it that I'm advocating it. I'm advocating it because it's going to make such a difference. Well, no, but I personally, I mean, I agree with that, but I also believe that what we really need to do as a discipline is, you know,
4:07:56 Council or whatever gives us direction to work on a project. We work on a project and we should work to that project to completion. It doesn't do any good, we were talking about action items, to have a lot of projects that are, you know, 80% finished or 90% finished or whatever and not, I mean, the completion of a project is really important. Oh, absolutely. If we take it on. So, that's kind of my feeling about it.
4:08:23 What do you find important? And one way or the other, we're going to get it done. Right? Yeah. Okay. It certainly has my support. All right. What else? How are we going to do this? How are we going to present to Council? Well, see, my idea to Council is to say, look, we really respect the fact that you spent this whole day working on your action items. Right. And, you know, tell us what you would like us...
4:08:55 To work up. I mean, that's one way we could do this. My other thought is, we could say to them, well, look at, I mean, here are some things, I mean, obviously solve parking challenges. Well, I mean, I think commissions have already taken the lead with, you know, their whole, our whole, and by the way, now it's called Enhanced Infrastructure Financing Districts.
4:09:20 Vicki, I heard from John Wentworth this morning, though, that he wants to hear from us what our priorities are, what matters to us. I didn't hear that he wants us to ask them what we want, what council wants us to do. Well, no, so I think what we need, okay, if council has this whole agenda that they spent the whole day working out, and it's really, really close, but I think what we should do is, we've got this whole list here, is,
4:09:50 What I heard then Colin say is, look it, we have to develop these strategic working alliances, and this group is going to, you know, work on this, and this group is going to work on, you know, I mean, obviously...
4:10:05 Commission is going to work on solving the parking challenges because we've been working on it and we're, you know, we've hired the consultant and we're moving forward. So that's a, that's a pretty well given. I think the chamber now is going to really work on our whole guest experience would be my, my thought, right? I think that's accurate. Right. So, so then really, and then I think, you know, the question and it comes to all these other things about enhancing community amenities and diversifying economic development.
4:10:35 What can we add? But what we didn't really, I mean, we just scratched kind of the surface today about truly the opportunity we have about being a gigabyte community. I mean, we rushed John kind of through it. And I think it might be interesting to give him another, and we never discussed our open-ended questions today. So the question is, do we want to, do you think we should
4:11:04 You know, check with the mayor and see if she'd like to see the first hour to continue that discussion that we had today and then go to their existing work program. That's a good idea. I like that idea. I can follow up. Okay. So we should probably have, since you're not going to meet again before that meeting, have kind of two alternatives depending on what her preference is.
4:11:30 Right. So if she says, yes, let's continue the economic roundtable for the first hour, then let's have our agenda set for the second hour. Right. If she says, no, let's just focus on the joint meeting, then we'll have an agenda for that, too. Okay. Sound good? Mm-hmm. I certainly would emphasize how useful our meeting today was. It was a good exchange of views and a sense of urgency, and it was a very useful presentation, I thought. But we didn't get to have the discussion because...
4:12:02 You know, there was so much to say. And time constraints. Yeah, and time constraints. So I would, because she wasn't there, but yeah, I would emphasize that to her. What do you think? I can tell you're thinking about something about this. Yeah, I don't want our gigabyte folks to get lost when they get to town. Not be able to find the village. I mean, my point, and I won't belabor this, the wayfinding signage program,
4:12:33 is 100% complete. What else do we have that's 100% complete? Main Street. If in fact we're going to spend the money that we have to develop programs to get them to a point of completion, we're shooting ourselves in the foot if we do not push for that. I am all over John's comments on
4:13:07 This giga community that we can have. It's fantastic. I did not know about the Google connection. I'm very interested in learning more about that. They have a bunny. They have a bunny. And bunnies multiply. Bunnies multiply. The idea of us getting something, my wife always tells me this, complete it, get it done. Don't do half a project.
4:13:36 Get it done. Get it finished and move on. And you'll see success. And I understand Chair Brown's concern with the limited dollars that we have to spend in this town. Oh, I know. And I understand the sensitivity that we will have in dealing with council about these same dollars. But I think the more we can come together as a group.
4:14:07 And get behind whatever the items are that we've worked on for many years now and believe in. I think we have to stay, you know, fairly unified on that and always with keeping mindful of the fact that council spends the dollars. Oh, yeah. We don't. But we would be remiss if we did not try that.
4:14:37 To point them in the right direction. Thanks. No, no, I agree. And, you know, I think the thing that's hard is when you have, you know, we were given direction by council members, Councilman Layman and Councilman Wood, to do something, you know, and then you have an election and things change. I can imagine what this must be like on a congressional level.
4:15:02 But other than asking for it, I mean, what are we going to do? I mean, other than we can all say next week that we really believe that this is important, I don't know what else we can do other than make our feelings known on the subject. And is that something we bring up next week or are we talking about issuing some sort of a...
4:15:27 No, we have to do it. The problem with the Brown Act is that it makes it so difficult to carry on any kind of conversations that you have to do it in a public forum. Right. So, I mean, something definitely that we have to bring up next week that is important to us. It was important when we started the project and it's still important to us. Right, but we're not talking about issuing some sort of formal Planning Commission statement saying there should be Project A on the list, even if we want that to be. Exactly. Precisely.
4:15:55 There are things that we don't want to be overlooked with regards to grants and things of that nature. If staff is spending some time looking for different grants, we certainly want the hat of the wayfinding signage program in there to be considered. I don't know where the funding is going to come from. I can't tell you.
4:16:24 But I do know that staff is constantly on a visual search for funding. And we should allow them to understand our desires and also counsel to understand our desires. Right. One last question. I don't want to belabor this. But I think when Elizabeth was holding up the crud out there,
4:16:54 Something was mentioned about a lot of the funding coming from private sources? There, according to Hayes, $225,000 of the funding was anticipated to come from the private sector. That's all I know. He's not here, so I can't ask him. Possibly an audience member might know. So basically, I believe...
4:17:17 I believe one of those monuments, for example, was that, it said Sierra Star, right, I think, for example, got it. And one said Snow Creek, and got it. Right, so when those developments moved forward, it would be a condition that they would put that monument sign, that monument sign. So, I mean, it was really a, I mean, a great program, you would have loved working on this program, because, I mean, they had all these, and they received a grant, you know, we had all these wonderful different designs, and then they worked.
4:17:44 Elizabeth especially worked really hard on how to make it all tie in in a comprehensive look for the town. That's good. It'll just transform the place. What do you think strategically we should do? Do you think we should have consensus on our top three, our top five? One thing that we think is the most important and really, strategically, what do you think we should do? Well, I feel really strongly that we've had two meetings, three joint workshops, and always in the past.
4:18:14 It has been, okay, this is what we're working on, this is what our priorities are. And I think it's really important for this council, because of the work they put in, to say, okay, you know, I mean, they set the agenda, it's really important to them, you know, what are we going to do then to help them with their agenda? I mean, I just think, I personally think that's what we need to say. So we don't go in and say what our priorities are that coordinate with their priorities. We don't say that.
4:18:44 Well, we can... We certainly make the case that we have a program that's been 100% complete and it's waiting to be funded. No, I mean, okay, so we've made that point. And the question is, what else are we going to say? You know, what else we're going to say is, okay... Well, the digital 395, we agree on that.
4:19:06 Well, let me just kind of, you know what I'm saying, Dave? I mean, we're going to tell them, look, this is really important to us. We've completed it. We think it's a great thing and we should be funded. I think then we say, look, we're all in on your priorities. I mean, they published them, they stated them, and here are some things that we think we can help you with.
4:19:36 We know we can help you with solving the parking challenges because we're well under that program already. The Gigabyte community, we certainly can support it. I don't know if anybody on the commission is going to actually serve on the task force because, quite frankly, I don't know if any of us are young enough because, Ronald, maybe you are digitally savvy enough to serve on this. So, I mean, the question is, you know,
4:20:05 What are we going to do, you know, what parts of this can we really help them with? To just go back to some of our conversations we had pre-to-the-round table is I personally really believe, and it's not quite written this way in their priorities, but, you know, we have a town that's highly dependent upon T.O.T., and I really believe
4:20:35 That, you know, we need to build those other legs to the stools. I mean, just being totally dependent upon TOT, in my opinion, is really a hard way to live. And to, as much as I believe that someday that new development will come to town and have a great impact, I'm not quite sure if we're going to see sticks in the ground.
4:21:04 In the next three years, so it might be five years, so that's pretty out there. So what else can we do to diversify our economy? So, I mean, the Gigabyte community is a very interesting way to diversify our community. I mean, the other thing that we had talked about is if you hire, if we go out and recruit ten businesses,
4:21:31 That hired 10 people that have over the median, earn over the median income, the rippling of impact is huge about how those people spend their money in our town. And, you know, we never really get to address Dan's point. I mean, Dan was talking a little bit about economic development in that sense and about what staff could do. And, you know, maybe that's really a role that commission can take on is about
4:22:00 You know, developing that mission and really going out and trying to recruit outdoor companies and businesses. I mean, so there's a lot of really good ideas. You know, so I think we say, yes, we would like this completed. Yes, we still really believe in our being developed or prepared program.
4:22:21 You know, are we going to, how are we going to do this? Are we going to support the Gigabyte community? Do we take on, you know, do we volunteer to take on the role of really trying to go out and, you know, recruit new businesses? That's kind of like the open-ended. Yeah, what is the role of the Planning and Economic Development Commission to encourage economic development? What is our role? How does Council see it? Right. Yeah. That's why we changed our name, because it encompasses economic development.
4:22:54 So is this a meeting where you run the meeting? Because it's a Planning Commission requested meeting? How's it going to work? It's a joint town council meeting. I believe it's a council. This is a council meeting. A council meeting? Usually it is a council meeting, but usually the chair and the mayor come to talk about it before. Okay, and then we'll have an agenda with these items we've discussed, or are we going to include all our items? Well, and...
4:23:17 And then, let me just bring that thing. So, I mean, we have all the items here. We have our discussion questions we never finished this morning. And then, the other thing that I think is really important is, how does that all tie into the existing work program? Oh, exactly. Yeah. So that, I mean, I think now we're about to a three-day summit. Oh, my. Yeah. Okay, so, with that.
4:23:49 Does everybody just kind of want to, I mean we know what we're going to ask for, but do we want us to just kind of brainstorm and then just give Sandra their feedback about how we think we can coordinate that best? Brainstorm topics, brainstorm procedure, brainstorm what? About what to do with our two hours with council. Well I think it would be useful to look at the projects that are ready and say this is ready and this is what it would, you know, give a rationale for it.
4:24:26 I got my glasses back on because I printed this out and it's 10% size. It's 2% size. Yeah. The Main Street plan, I mean, I think it would be good to very quickly review that and why it's a good thing and why we should proceed with it. Don't you think we need to do that? It is a brand new council. Are they up to speed on everything? I'm not questioning them, but just, you know, when Dave talked about the fire hose of information that would be greeting them when they took office. Yeah, you know, we did, we've done. Would that be useful?
4:24:58 I think they're up to speed. I mean, we've had private meetings with them. Okay. So we don't need to spend any time on that. We've just had that IFD workshop. I mean, what's your opinion? I think they're relatively up to speed on that. Okay, so that would be wasting time to spend time on that. What does the commission feel about the resort investment element? I know we heard from Tom at the Mountain, you know, don't mess with the general plan, but this is a...
4:25:28 Something we would add to it, and it was really good, the draft element that was done in 2011. It's, you know, the draft is done. Is that something we should consider? Have you seen it, Michael? No, I don't think I'm familiar with it. So, well, this goes back to the general plan in general, and that's a little bit of a redundancy of work. So, I mean, Dave and I have talked about this a lot. The general plan is never meant to be...
4:25:57 A static document. Right, right. Chapters of it should be continually updated. And the problem is that when you wait so long, then you end up with this really huge project. Huge. And so, I mean, that was one of the things that we had put down here as a possibility is, you know, updating the general plan. And I think if you were going to update the general plan, then you would certainly add the resort investment element.
4:26:24 But I'm separating those two. I'm not talking about updating. I'm just talking about adding on. Well, no, because it doesn't... It doesn't work that way. I don't think it works. I mean, Sandra had an interesting concept, and you can explain it, Sandra, where instead of, quote, updating elements, you update topics.
4:26:44 And you go, why did you do? Right, so what I was saying is that if there's a need to update the general plan to respond to economic, you know, some sort of economic development, we could amend the entire general plan, but only the pieces that relate to just that specific topic. So if we say we want to include more policies and actions that really strengthen our economic, you know, development focus.
4:27:10 Then we can go through it and do that. But so that would kind of weave through the whole document. Or if we want to say we're going to add or amend just the economic chapter of the general plan, we could. So like for FAR, we're making changes to the land use element and to other different elements for that topic of FAR. But you know, as soon as you say that, and I think about...
4:27:31 The amount of work that would take, and Tom's figure in his presentation this morning, 36% occupancy, we know, you know, we've got these occupancy, I mean, we've got a fire going here, we really need to work on more important stuff, I think, maybe. Because as we said, the general plan that we adopted in 2007 hasn't even been implemented yet because of the recession. Right, but so... We've got more immediate things that we've got to fix. Right, because it's the staff time, but to me...
4:28:04 More important probably than the general plan is the North Village specific plan. Yes. Because if we have to do another amendment to that plan, I mean, we so lost the integrity of that specific plan now because there's been, I think, because there's been so many amendments and it's all, it's become piecemeal. And that is on our future work program item. Right. But that, those are huge staff consuming products. Exactly, yeah. I mean, why don't...
4:28:32 Which, I mean, and then you had a whole concept about perhaps getting a grant right this summer to do design review. There is a, well, there's a, I think it's Cal Poly San Luis Obispo, they have teams of students, like graduate students, who come to different communities and can do those types of things. They work on specific plans. They give you, you know, summaries of projects they've worked on before, and I kind of looked at it. They've done design guidelines.
4:29:02 They've done specific plans, updates. Now, obviously, they can do a portion of it, and then we would have to continue with it or finalize that. But that was an idea I had, is if we needed, you know, some staff time and some funding, it might be a good idea to bring a group like that in here to do a project like that. So I had that idea for, because another item on our list is to update the design guidelines. And I thought, you know, they could help with that. And Nori Winter from Winter & Associates, he's done design guidelines for.
4:29:31 Pretty much every ski town in the United States. He's done design guidelines for a ton of our peer resorts, and so I thought he could maybe participate in that process as well, but obviously that would have to get direction from the council to make that, put that on our work program, so then we could try to find the funding for that. And I think the San Luis Obispo, it's free, but they do choose their projects based on kind of a lot of factors.
4:29:57 We haven't actually applied yet, so they may say it's too far, all the students would have to drive so far, fly, that kind of thing, but at least it's an option. How long would they stay here? Like two weeks or a month or how long would they be here? It depends on which project we pick, how intense it would be, but I would say it's probably a semester or a quarter, you know, so a couple months of their, so they'd probably do it as a class. And it's free, it's not even like an unpaid internship, it's just it's part of their education. Okay.
4:30:28 So this would be my two options for next week. The first option would be that we would spend the first hour of our joint meeting continuing our discussion today, and then part B of the agenda for the second hour would be their priorities and having a conversation about how we could really interface as a commission with their priorities. My second option would be if
4:30:56 They didn't want to continue the economic roundtable discussion is we would start with their priorities and then we would say here are some areas that we feel could really
4:31:22 You know, need to be considered and ask them, well, what are their feelings about updating the North Village specific plan? What's their update, you know, about the general plan, about design guidelines? And, you know, try to see if there's any kind of consensus if they feel those issues are important. And then no matter what, then our very last item would be that we just really want to stress once again how important it is.
4:31:49 about the wayfinding and Main Street to finish those projects as we started them. What do you think? Do you want to switch the orders today? No, that's logical. The thing that we can never lose sight of is the fact that we serve at the pleasure of counsel. And, you know, for good, bad, or indifferent. And it's, you know, it's our charge to...
4:32:20 Provide them with recommendations to move their agendas forward, their collective agenda forward. If things that are near and dear to us fall within that, then there's probably a lot more chance of us having success with some of the things that we see as a body.
4:32:48 That we feel passionate about. But just never to forget, we do serve at the pleasure of the council. Make an alternate suggestion. Rather than saying we want to continue the economic roundtable discussion, why couldn't we say we want to know what our role is as far as economic development goes in Mammoth and this is what came up at the roundtable discussion? Rather than having it be a continuation of a previous meeting.
4:33:19 Have it be the meeting is scheduled, but with that focus based on what we learned. Well, and I think what I say continued is that I know that John got really cut. I mean, John could have a whole hour, and I don't know how much he's shared with counsel about this. I mean, John really has some ideas about how to move forward. I mean, because besides being a Google community, we could become like...
4:33:48 Having an internet utility that's owned by the town, which is, you know, think about, that's a whole different thing. So, and then there's this great link that you have to look at and see what Tahoe has done with their prosperity group. So, it would really be to give John time to finish his, okay, and then maybe that would be then the discussion question for that part. Well, what do you see?
4:34:17 Our role is in the economic development. That makes sense. Yeah, that makes sense. Are you, yes, you need to leave. I've got to go. Okay, we'll see you shortly. Yeah, very shortly. All right. So, is that good? Oh, yeah. Okay. Do we have any commissioner reports? Nope. Michael has one. Show up at 5 o'clock in 15 minutes. Don't throw anything at me when I'm on the stage. We won't. We'll cheer.
4:34:45 Loudly. Thank you, guys. Okay, thank you very much. Thank you, Mike. Is there any other commissioner reports? No, I'm good. Okay, we have a director report? I don't have anything. What's on our agenda for December? So far, we have, the commission had asked for an item to discuss minimum FAR. Right. I don't know if you remember, so that, I was planning on bringing that back in December. Let me look at my list.
4:35:16 Any public hearings? Any public hearings? I don't think so. I think we'll try to bring back the use permit. Well, so that would be a public hearing. The use permit removal. Okay. For that, so we would try to bring that back. And I can't recall the third item. It's just small meeting at this point. Okay. So maybe we can put on the agenda, then certainly we'll have...
4:35:44 I'm sure additional ideas after our joint meeting. Yeah. And then we'll follow up with it in December and try to keep the momentum going. Sounds good? That's good. Okay. Do you know when the Synergy Summit's going to be? No, they have to schedule it still. Would it be on a council night or separate? I don't know. I'll mention mid-December. I'm not sure. I don't think it'd be a council meeting because they're talking about coordinating with all the different organizations. I hope it doesn't get too close to Christmas.
4:36:13 Yeah. And then, so, just real quick, I don't want to belabor the point, but I was a little bit caught off guard today about this design review. I mean, this is the first time we've ever had people from the design review committee feel like when they actually came to commission that their points hadn't been heard. I mean, did you have any comments on that, or do you think it was just a one-off issue?
4:36:44 I mean, I think it was, we had discussed it with the applicant, they were aware of it, and I think we were anticipating that they would, you know, make these changes, and so we can only, those were only recommendations, so I mean, I think the applicant just today might have made some decisions on the design, I think they mentioned that, that they had some ideas about different designs, so I think that they had just kind of taken their time to respond on that item, but...
4:37:07 But what was in the staff report was correct. I mean, we anticipated those items coming back to the commission, so we apologized that it was confusing, and that's not how we want it to be. Right. Having been at both meetings, my judgment is the applicant did not respond to the concerns we had, which is why you go through the process, and he didn't come back with alternatives or different things, with the exception of changing the zinc reflective siding for the top element, but the other ones he didn't.
4:37:37 And I don't know why he didn't have the computer simulation. I thought that was a required, computer-generated simulation, a requirement. And was he not asked to do that? It's not a requirement. That's something that we ask for, I mean, for different projects. So it's not a requirement for every single project to provide the photo sim? The photo sim, because after the birdhouses, you know. Right. But I think that was a substitute for site visits.
4:38:06 So if you do a site visit... No, it isn't the same thing. You really need to see the finished structure as proposed. No, but I think the way it's written, because we were looking at that once before, right? You're talking about the story poll policy, the old, now it's called the building height and mass evaluation policy. It talks about different ways. It's a little bit different, but different ways you can evaluate the building mass and height. You can include those photo sims, like the end of the village did that fly around.
4:38:34 So different... Like we've done at the Bluffs? Right. Some would do story polls for like a single family home. So there's different ways to show the mass. But we haven't typically required the site photo sims for every single project. Some projects just give it to us. Like antennas, cell phone, they just always provide photo sims for those. So we always include those. But it's not a requirement for every project. Hmm. I think it should be. What are we talking about money-wise? Do you know? I don't know how much they cost. Okay.
4:39:04 Depends on how young you are and how good you are with your computers. If you're good with the computers, whip it out. And then the only thing I'd like just to encourage the commission always to send their questions in to staff before the meeting. Just help staff out. Usually I call and I called yesterday forgetting it was a holiday. I got caught. And this is a holiday. All right. Is there anything else? Then I move that we adjourn.
4:39:33 Are we adjourned to the joint or to our next... To your... Okay. I move that we adjourn to our next regular meeting to be held December the 10th, 2014 at 2 p.m. Thank you.