TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 48 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

383 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:08 Council for Wednesday, December 3rd. A roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Ferney? Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. John, I forgot to ask you in advance. Would you lead us in the pledge? Of course. My pleasure. Thank you. Arise and repeat after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible.

2:40 With liberty and justice for all. All right. We will next go to public comments on items which are not part of this evening's agenda. If you have something to say, please come to the podium and state your name. John. Good evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. A couple things that I wanted to just update on. Obviously, yesterday's snowfall was something that we've been waiting for, and last year we talked about keeping our powder dry.

3:15 Well, yesterday we started spending the powder by the barrel. We have such an opportunity to have momentum going into the holiday season, making sure that the world knows that we have snow, that we put both feet on the gas pedal. So this opportunity doesn't come that often. Last year we didn't get snow until January 30th. Two years ago we had snow before Christmas and it set us up for a year for the full winter. So we want to make sure that the world knows that between us.

3:42 And the amount of money that Mammoth Mountain has additionally put into the marketplace, you know, the phones started ringing. So we let people know that we had snow. We've got another storm coming next week. And frankly, with these storms coming prior to Christmas, we plan on doing the same thing. If it snows another foot or two next week, we'll do the exact same thing, get people making their bookings. With that being said, I wanted to give you a quick update. Just really...

4:05 A couple things that I've been very impressed with. Dan Izzo and his team in the finance department have done a fantastic job not only getting me the numbers but also making sure that they're accurate and in a timely manner. And it's important right now because looking at this past summer, you know, we talked a little bit about it in our open house last month. We also talked about it in our year-end recap. But I just want to go over again. Right now, year-to-date, we're up 11% to last year, which is great. But we're also up 5% to budget.

4:35 So, you know, $143,000, $150,000 ahead of budget right now is nice. We kind of went into the winter last year with that same sort of cushion. Unfortunately, that went away in December. But right now, we have a good pace going on, and we've got a little bit of growth. Again, those are all record TOTs right through October. September was up 14%. October was up 10% year over year, and both new records.

5:04 With the bump in visitation, the bump in occupancy come the bump in the TBID numbers as well. So based on our forecast for the first four months of the season or the fiscal year, we're up about $250,000 on TBID collections as well. That was part of the powder that we put onto the fire yesterday. You know, we had the opportunity, we saw the storm, we saw what we had for potential, and we went back to our agency and said, listen, right now, what can we do if we put another $50,000 into the marketplace?

5:33 What can that get us? And so we beefed up all of our search engine optimization and all of our banner advertising and making sure that we were in front of people, and it seems to be working. So, again, nice to have that cushion. It's outside of the original plan, so it's not necessarily reserved, but it's contingency, and this is exactly why we have contingency. So, go ahead. Thank you. Thank you, John. Anyone else for public comment?

6:03 Seeing none, I'll move on to Councilmember reports. John, would you like to start? Thank you, Madam Mayor. It was a wonderful, busy holiday season, and it started off Thursday, November 20th. I briefly stopped in the Hispanic Town Hall Forum, which is such an impressive thing that's going on. I just wanted to, I think we all would send shout-outs to everybody who's involved in putting that together. It's a great

6:31 Forum for this community to have. I then went down to Bishop to the Forest Service Plan Revision Conceptual Alternatives rollout, which was interesting. I then joined on to the East Coast where I had meetings on November 24th with Forest Service staff talking about Indian National Forest Plan Revision, bringing the Mammoth Lakes perspective to that effort. I also met with Congressman Cook's staff with John Urdi, and we had a nice chat about Forest Plan Revision and airports and things like that. It was always good to be in touch with those guys.

7:00 Then I met with two kind of senior folks on the Forest Service, a guy named Joe Mead, who is the forest identified behind the Framework for Sustainable Recreation, which is a key part of our strategy, what we're trying to work on here. And he had a lot of very insightful things to offer for our efforts here in the eastern Sierra. And I also met with a group called the Outdoor Alliance, which is a group of outdoor recreation folks that have a national interest in what's happening in the Inyo. It's more sort of a coalition we can bring to our forest planning process we're doing here in the Inyo.

7:28 Monday, I attended the Eastern Sierra Connect Regional Broadband Consortium meeting at a pizza parlor in Lone Pine, which is a lot of fun. And I met with a woman named Diana Matson from Mountain Pact, which is an effort to bring mountain communities together who are being affected by climate change, to try to put together a voice for our types of communities that can be part of the conversation when things like Miami and coastal...

7:54 Environments are lobbying and getting a lot of federal dollars for the effects that they're feeling. I have to start getting the mountain communities to give them a voice in those kinds of efforts going forward. And Dan and I have talked about it a little bit, and we'll see if that might be something we can bring forward to council. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Just a couple of things for me. Both Mayor Bacon and I attended about a week ago. The town received a Water Hero Award for some of the changes that have been made. So that was...

8:26 That was exciting. Michael and I attended an ESTA meeting last week as well, and we'll hear a lot more tonight during the presentation. And on Monday night, I had our monthly Mammoth Lakes housing meeting. Most of the discussion was around there is an application in process now for the Shady Rest parcel.

8:56 So I'm sure more will be coming from that. It's in its very preliminary stages right now. But that was most of the discussion, and I'm sure that will be before Council at some point. So that's all I have for this evening. Thanks. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I, too, attended the Hispanic Advisory for a little bit of time, and it was great echoing your thoughts on that. And I just want to echo what John Urdi said. It was a great Thanksgiving. We see the numbers.

9:27 Side door was well. It's packed. Those who weren't there missed it. And it was a great tree lining ceremony. So make sure you do it next year. Thank you, Madam Mayor. As Colin mentioned, I attended a monthly estimating. And as John's going to share with everyone, very good news was summer, especially out of Red's Meadow. Ridership was way up. And got to see our new five Sprinter vans that are very nice addition to the fleet.

9:58 Also attended our monthly MLT meeting. One really interesting piece of great press that we've just received out of Italy, one of the top ski magazines over there did an eight page really great feature story on Mammoth. So this has given us a lot of great press in Italy. Air service pre-bookings, we're looking very good. LAX is up a thousand seats over the last

10:28 Last year at the same time. San Diego is up about 1,500 with three less flights for flying four days versus seven, so it's very impressive. San Francisco is broken down a bit, but we think that will improve with the snowfall. And, of course, Las Vegas and Denver, we don't have that data yet in a comparison, but those are on sale and will start to arrive shortly. We also have an update letter going out regarding TBID, a little update.

10:58 A letter from the tourism. Everyone's going to be getting this. It's participating in town. It's a good little information piece going out in town. So look for that. And also the MLTindustryinsider.com. A lot of good stuff's being updated in there. Also attended our monthly air group meeting regarding our airport.

11:22 And make some progress there. Hopefully in January we'll have some things to report back on the ALP progress. And that's all I have. First I'll follow up on what Collins said about the water he wrote.

11:34 You know, it's one of the times we sit up here and just tell staff to go do something, and so I really want to thank the staff for what they did in recognizing ways to save water, and especially Dennis Rotner and Haislip Hayes for the work they did in getting us that little plaque about Water Hero. It is the staff who did it.

11:53 The other thing I wanted to talk about just really quickly is that Mammoth Lakes Recreation is busy. Coming forward to you shortly will be recommendations on an initial funding cycle to be finished up and recommendations back to Council before February 15th.

12:11 And there are other items that we're working on. Some of the people are starting to really realize what we said when we said we were a working board. We have been very hard at work. So there will be things coming forward over the next few meetings from MLR as well. I see we have no additions to the agenda. Is that correct? All right. Then we'll move on to reports from commissions or departments. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Steve Searles, Wildlife Management. It's been a really busy week.

12:47 A lot of stuff going on. A depredation permit was filled this week. A bear was downed, and we have a depredation permit pending for another bear to be downed. A bear fell through a pond today and is missing and presumed dead and drowned. It's been a really busy week. With all the confusion, misinformation, the stuff going around on the blogs and on the websites,

13:18 I love to argue. That's what we do in this room. I love a good debate, but to go with bad information, that's not healthy. So I just encourage anybody that's having issues, the bears are starting to dent up. They're slowing down a lot. After three years of drought, all that we've been through, incredible successes. I don't back off on thanking the community for the council, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Mammoth Mountain, everybody that's kicked in to make this possible. But again, I'd hate to...

13:46 Have your wrap up this way on a bad note. I just encourage everybody, I think everybody knows, but whoever doesn't, my number is 937-BEAR. You've got a bear on your porch or having issues or a bear is putting on a couple more pounds or you see anything awkward in your community, don't hesitate to call. I'm out there seven days a week and be glad to respond. But 937-BEAR, if you're one of the people that are...

14:09 Promoting misinformation or confusion or white noise, please, I'll buy the coffee. I encourage anybody that has recommendations, questions, suggestions, want clarification, to please call me and I'll buy the coffee. So, again, incredibly proud of our community. I'll never back off of that. But, boy, it's been a heck of a week. Any questions from Council?

14:38 Thank you for your time. Thank you, Steve. Evening, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, community, Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. So it was great news. We were able to open the ice rink ahead of schedule on Thanksgiving Day, which was terrific last week. During the third day period, we welcomed just under 300 visitors, which was great. But the conditions were challenging. Unseasably warm, windy.

15:11 The quality of the skating surface has deteriorated quite badly. So we're in a position to temporarily close the rink tomorrow and Friday so we can kind of recut, repaint, reflood that ice to have it ready for the upcoming holiday period. So just want to let you know that that's the case there, but it has been well received. It's been a challenge, but our crew did a great job of getting it open for the holidays. We're scheduled to reopen that facility at 9 a.m.

15:40 This Saturday for youth hockey. Also I'd like to remind our residents in the community of the community-wide food and clothing drive taking place this Friday, December 5th in the old Bank of America parking lot as well as a toy drive at Mammoth Fun Shop. So between noon and 6pm we just welcome everybody to drop off their unexpired food items, well-loved clothing at the old B of A building. It'll be that easy, you won't have to leave the car.

16:09 And then toy donors are requested to drop off their unwrapped toys at Mammoth Fun Shop. And Camille's also offering a 30% discount for purchases of new toys. And those toys are dedicated to the angel giving tree. So it's a great cause. All the clothing will be gifted to Salvation Army and the food will go to a marker. So a great cause.

16:32 So we do want to recognise and thank Footloose Sports, Mammoth Fun Shop, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, Amarca, Angel Giving Tree Salvation Army, and Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District for their support of this great inaugural event. But wait, there's more. This Friday, 5.30, is the official Town of Mammoth Lakes tree lighting ceremony. So that's going to follow on from the community food drive. So if you've given what you can, come along. We'll get you some hot chocolates and cookies.

17:02 So that takes place from 5.30 to about 6.30, quarter to 7 in the Footloose Sports parking lot. Madam Mayor will be welcoming the festive season. Sandra's obviously coming from the North Pole again. Busy this time of year. And we also have Wooley and his mate Bucky coming along as well. So we hope he can join us. And that's all I have. Any questions? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Stuart. Any other departments or questions? Okay. Seeing none,

17:36 We'll move on. Next, we have a presentation from ESTA. John? Good evening, Mayor Bacon and members of the council. My name is John Helm. I'm the executive director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. I'd like to thank the town for providing this opportunity this evening to provide some information about our organization. Periodically, we'd like to share with the town and with the community a little bit about the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, who we are, what services we provide, and what's new in our world of transit.

18:08 We recently published our annual report, of which each of the council members have a copy, and I'll leave extra copies on the back counter this evening. And I thought maybe this was an opportune time to share a few minutes with the town regarding our world. As a reminder, the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority is a joint powers authority comprised of four member entities, the town of Mammoth Lakes, city of Bishop, and the counties of Inyo and Mono.

18:33 Our mission is to provide excellent public transportation service in an entrepreneurial style within the eastern Sierra region. We operate a fleet of 70 vehicles. We employ upwards of 80 employees during peak seasons. We operate along a 400 linear mile service area. Now, I don't know for a fact, but if we are not the largest, geographically speaking, transit agency in the United States, we've got to be in the top five. That's a crazy long service area.

19:04 We operate about 55,000 service hours a year, drive about 940,000 service miles, providing those services, and have averaged just over a million passenger trips per year the last two years along our services. The transportation service that the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority provides are diverse. We operate dial-a-ride services here in Mammoth Lakes, extensive dial-a-ride services in Bishop.

19:30 And local services, Dial-a-Ride, in the Antelope Valley area, in North Mono County, and in the Lone Pine area. We also operate town-to-town commuter routes, primarily the Mammoth Express, with three round trips between Mammoth and Bishop, and the Lone Pine Express, again, three round trips between Lone Pine and Bishop. We operate inner-city routes, north to Reno and south to Lancaster, providing valuable access throughout the eastern Sierra region.

19:56 And here in the Mammoth area, we operate extensive local fixed route services. These are through arrangements with the Town of Mammoth Lakes, with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, and under a special use permit with the Forest Service for the Reds Meadow Shuttle during the summer months. We also have offered commuter services via van pool.

20:18 We are on a temporary hiatus on that, but working aggressively with Mono County to try to get that reinvigorated and reinstituted with some promotional pricing on that. Hope to have another Van Poole operational here very soon. And our latest offering is a mileage reimbursement program for non-emergency medical transportation trips to trips outside the area for individuals that have that need. We were able to...

20:47 Develop a grant for that and are offering that service currently. We operate with about a $4.5 million annual operating budget. Those funds come from a variety of sources. We cobble together the best we can from a variety of sources. About $400,000 from the federal government in operating funds for various services primarily dedicated for rural transit areas. We get about a million and a quarter from state funding.

21:15 That comes from a percentage of the state sales tax as well as a component of fuel reimbursement tax or fuel tax. We have contract service arrangements with the town, with Mammoth Mountain ski area that provide about $1.7 million of our operating budget. And then passenger fares make up the balance. That's about a little under $900,000 a year. The transit services we operate benefit of a wide variety of folks.

21:42 Our dial ride services greatly benefit seniors and disabled, providing valuable and important trip services to social, medical, and shopping. We provide transportation to employment for workers throughout the region through both dial ride, our town to town services, and the van pool program that I mentioned. We provide services for locals needing services outside of their area.

22:09 For instance, individuals who may need to access medical or shopping in the Reno or Carson area for a unique product or south in Ridgecrest, Lancaster. We also provide an extensive range of services for visitors to our region. First and foremost, we provide access to the region through our inner city routes from Reno and the inner city bus network there with Greyhound and then from Southern California via Metrolink in Lancaster.

22:39 We provide access to local services both for residents and visitors. We frequently will get a call on our dial ride services to transport someone from a mechanic repair shop to a motel and back if they've experienced a mechanical problem with their vehicle en route. We have seen a real increase in the past few years of transportation services for

23:02 People who are through hikers during the summer months in the eastern Sierra area, the John Muir Trail and the PCT are increasingly busy and many of those people, particularly on the John Muir and some of those trails, may park a car at one end, hike all the way down to the other end and need a way to get back and we provide that access in partnership with our neighboring transit agency YARTS in Yosemite. Importantly here in Mammoth Lakes, we provide the opportunity for folks to come visit Mammoth Lakes.

23:32 And park their car once they get here. There is extensive transit service from 7 a.m. until 2 a.m. during the winter months throughout town. And people here can access any variety of recreational opportunities, shopping, whatever they need to do within our community. And that clearly follows suit with the town's feet first model, which supports transit.

23:58 And importantly, we also provide access to our neighboring national forests and national parks, specifically through the Red's Metal Shuttle Service. Some things that are new in our world, we're embracing technology. Technology is really providing some neat benefits to passengers. We have a program called NextBus that provides real-time bus arrival information via smartphone, text message, and regular phone.

24:25 We're employing that three of our routes here in the town of Mammoth Lakes, and I've heard lots of positive comments from the community on that. We're also active with Google Transit. People can trip plan either a local trip in Mammoth or anywhere along our network via Google Transit. We've recently implemented a scheduling and dispatch system for our dial right system in...

24:50 Bishop called Route Match, which shows the vehicle location using AVL system and GPS, which is improving our efficiency there. And as Councilmember Raimondo pointed out, we recently inserviced four sprinter vehicles for dialeride service in Bishop, and we're very excited about that. They hold the promise of triple the fuel economy of the vehicles that they are replacing. So we're very excited about that.

25:16 That's a quick overview of what's happening in our world in transit. I thank you for the opportunity to share this information with the council and with the town, and I'd like to close by saying it's our pleasure to get you where you need to go. Are there any questions or comments? John, real quick, do you have the numbers with you on Red's Meadow, the increase in the ridership for the summer? I didn't have a note on it. I didn't know if you were going to talk about that tonight. I don't have that, but it was an order of 25%.

25:47 And that was an increase over the largest year that we had seen previously. Right. Yeah, that was great news. And also great on that we got to start the basin trolley earlier and end it later and looking forward to be able to continue that. Right. We had really good response to that. Yes. Great. Great job. Thanks, John. Any other questions? To follow up on the lakes basin trolley,

26:16 Can you talk a little bit about how things are working with the new bike racks and kind of where we're at? Because I know you were testing that out a little bit to kind of see how that would work. We were, and I can report positively that it had a positive impact, although it did not solve the problem entirely. Our capacity issue with the Lakes Bay and Trolley in the summer is really an issue of bike transportation more than anything else.

26:43 And we went from 12 bike trailers to 16, so we had a 30% increase there. But the trolleys seat 32 and can accommodate easily 10 or 15 more standees. So it's, again, we're only able to transport a fraction of the numbers. We did on a few days, we did experiment with a third vehicle in service.

27:10 On the very peak days. And I think that's something, well, I know it's something that town staff and I will be discussing further this winter on trying to develop a plan on that. But it helped, but it didn't solve the problem. Sure. So that's kind of the game plan at this point would be to add another.

27:27 Vehicle into the route as opposed to try and get a larger rack because I know you said there's some issues with the turnarounds and stuff. There are issues. The road is very known places and the transit way, particularly at Horseshoe Lake when it's full of cars and when our buses are full, that area is full of cars. We couldn't use a longer trailer and still make that turn. Okay.

27:48 And then the only other question I had is since it is a new service, can you talk a little bit more about the details of the non-emergency medical transportation service? Yes. What that is, it provides reimbursement to an individual who needs medical service outside the area and it's intended for somebody that's not able to drive themselves. They may need somebody to take them. And it's a very cost-effective way to do that as opposed to

28:16 Long distance dial ride or where an employee, for instance, would be paid for the entire time that they were with somebody to take somebody to Loma Linda, for instance, or to Reno. The way it works is that the individual who has the need, fills out an application, submits that to us, they find their own volunteer and the volunteer has their own vehicle.

28:37 And we approve their trip. They send us a reimbursement request for that, and we reimburse that at the IRS medical transportation rate, which is 23 or 23 and a half cents per mile. Right. Okay. John, first, great job. I'm very impressed with Vesta and what you guys are doing. Thank you. Just a real quick question. What is the life expectancy of the buses?

29:08 They vary. I'm sure they do, yeah. In simple terms, the bigger ones last longer. The big white buses that are operating the Red Line and the Reds Metal Shuttle, those are 12-year, 500,000 miles. So they're expected to operate at least 12 years or 500,000 miles. Some of the smaller, I mean, we operate minivans in Dial-Rite Service and Bishop, and those are four-year, 100,000-mile vehicles. So it's somewhere between that. All right, yeah, I was just asking because you say you're driving a million miles, about a million miles a year.

29:37 Right. Yeah. It's a lot of mileage. Yep. But, John, aren't you already setting aside reserves for replacement vehicles? We are, yes. Specifically for the Red's Meadow, Redline, the buses, there is a specific component for that for capital replacement. We're in dialogue with our board as well as the other member agencies about capital replacement planning for the other vehicles.

30:07 John, did you have a question? No, I'm good, thank you. All right, Michael, you got yours all taken care of. Thank you, John. Thank you. Next up, we have another presentation, this one from Grady Dutton. Thank you, Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Grady gave me one copy of this. Were you going to provide more? Yes, I do have a PowerPoint. I was just going to ask if any of the council would like a paper copy. I did bring four more. Yes, please. Thank you. Thanks, Grady. Either way, I guess the tree's already killed.

30:44 Well, thank you. I look forward to this opportunity to describe a little bit about what Public Works has done for the past year. My own experience has been six months, so there's a few things here that they did before my arrival, and I'll run through those. First of all, Public Works Department, I'll just do a quick overview. We have about 26 full-time year-round employees. That swells to anywhere from 30 to 34.

31:19 During the summer and winter, we have winter part-timers, we have summer part-timers, and the average longevity of those employees so far is 10 years, and that includes people like me who have been here six months and a couple of one-year time, so 10 years is a good longevity. It includes, of course, park maintenance, fleet maintenance, roads, engineering department, public works inspection, transit, which John just talked about, and the Mammoth-Gosemite airport, of course.

31:49 Again, I'll touch on each one one at a time. Parks Maintenance has three year-round staff, up to five or more sometimes seasonal staff. Dennis Rotner is the lead there. I think Dennis promised to stick around. He's back there talking to you. Dennis, you've got to come up into the light when I say your name. One of the things I'll show right now is, as everybody has already talked about it, something we're quite proud of.

32:16 And Dennis was instrumental in the local water hero recognition. This is when he accepted the plaque, which he quickly got out of his office and brought into mind. I'm trying to give it back to him, but we'll see because he's the one that earned that and is well recognized. Some of the things that Parks Maintenance was up to, and again, I will not read each item here. This will be a much longer presentation, but some of the highlighted ones. This is available in Granicus, by the way, and I'm happy to email it to anyone else in the audience who'd like to see it.

32:46 Out at Whitmore Park, new storage containers, bleachers, and a fence. The ice rink installed a sun fabric shade in the picnic area. Water efficiency is the one I highlighted the most, and we've already been through that somewhat. Main Street, Old Mammoth Road, Shady Rest, Juniper Ridge, all those areas had improvements. And then, as I said, he got the local Water Hero Award.

33:07 And this is in addition to the day-to-day activities. Those of you, which I think is all of us who use the parks and trails and everything around here, really recognize and appreciate what staff does to that. And just real quickly, when I asked staff for some highlights, some typical activities they do, I got a list of about 150 things. So I paired it down to about 30 because they are busy every day. I did a visit to...

33:32 Dennis' facility earlier in the year. I told him I'd be there by 7.15 and all of his crew but him were gone already because they get there early, they get out there, and they really seem to enjoy what they do. Fleet maintenance, Lon Adams. I don't know if Lon is able to make it tonight or not. Is he hiding back there? No. We just got a few. Lon lives all the way down in Big Pine, so I do not begrudge him the need to get home tonight. Some of the highlights, however, again, five-year-round staff.

34:02 And I want to mention Luis Cepeda because I'm trying to mention all the 5, 10, 15, 25-year anniversaries. There's quite a few of them. Luis has been with the town now for 10 years. Earlier in the year before I got here, they purchased a new Vactor truck. And basically that really expanded the opportunities of what both Lawton and what the road department could do with storm drains, with other things, being able to clean things out. And later I'll talk about what the road department was able to do with that Vactor truck.

34:31 We also purchased a new trolley, as John's well aware, a new police vehicle. And one of the things we brought to you just two or three months ago was a new, basically a gas island and a system for controlling costs there, and that's well underway. It's working very well. We're still working on even better ways to report that information, working with the new finance system next year to make it work even quicker. Also provided contract service for ESTA, the school district.

34:58 Fire Department. We even took care of a piece of equipment for the National Park Service. And one of the reasons I like to think that John's buss are going to last so long is that Londa and his crew do such a good job taking care of him. In road maintenance, Todd Murphy's been with the town for 23 years. Did he stick around even? I didn't catch him. I had him most of the day in the office, but he's got some new people out doing snow removal the last couple of days, and I know that's going well.

35:27 Again, 23 years for him. The anniversaries this year, Warren Bowling, 10 years. Three 15-year employees, Scott Meredith, Lance Miller, and Aaron Willingham. And Jim Haggerty had his 25-year anniversary with the town. A couple of the projects that they did that were related more to paving and road maintenance that I've reported here previously. One is we took an old lot at the airport that had been grown over and no longer very usable.

35:57 We used grindings from the college parkway job that we got from the college and were stored out there and were able to create a basically looked like a new parking lot. Again, it had previously been used for one, but we increased parking there by some 69 spaces. And at Whitmore Park, those of you who have been there, that had always been an issue with dust control and with drainage. And we, again, used grindings off a project to create a new parking area there. Very successful.

36:26 This is just a quick shot of the parking area at the airport under construction. If you're out there today, you'll see it's fully striped. All the signs are in. In Public Works Engineering, there are five year-round staff. I know that some of them are here tonight. Peter Bernasconi and Hazel Hayes at least. Peter's in the back there. Hayes is over on the side. Thank you. I want to mention that in addition to those three, we have two others, Jamie Robertson.

36:55 Who is an assistant engineer, and Sierra Schultz, an intern. And the reason I mention them specifically relates back to some of the things we've heard at Council recently about education in the colleges. Jamie's born and raised in Bishop. Sierra's from right here in Mammoth Lakes. And I just, that just not amazes me, but it's a great credit to the system here in town that you have two local kids, frankly, that grew up, wanted to stay here, went away to college, came back, and they're working from the town. And on top of that,

37:23 They're women civil engineers, and knowing that industry as well as I do, that's just a great compliment to them and to the town as well. There were four major projects that were accomplished this year. Lower Canyon Rehabilitation, which is complete, except we're getting the streetlights turned on. We're working with FCE on that. We've had our applications in for some time, and we're hoping to get their part of that job done very soon so we can get the streetlights on.

37:49 The Bluffs Assessment District Maintenance, that paving project's complete. Meridian, I've heard nothing but great compliments from pedestrians, from bicyclists, dog walkers, and from bus drivers. As I told John, I quizzed a couple of his bus drivers about how successful that's been so far. And it managed through the first snowstorm okay. I think people are figuring out where the lanes are, and I know the buses appreciate being able to get out of the way.

38:15 Waterford Gap, the last section of bridge on the north side, will be delivered on Friday morning and installed on Friday, and that project will be complete, and again, it will be open to the public for snowshoeing, cross-country, whatever, however the conditions entail, and that will also be done. I wanted to mention that of this $6.5 million in work, as we do last pay applications,

38:40 We've been able to, and by we I mean Haislip Hayes and his crew have been able to manage the cost where the total change orders excess in all those jobs put together is going to be about $100,000. So that's 1.6% maybe, and that's excellent. And it wasn't just managing the dollars. About $80,000 of that were ads that we did.

39:03 One was for the crossing signals down on Canyon there at the bottom by the village, and the other one was to add some conduit in so someday when we do get streetlights on a certain area of Meridian, we don't have to tear the streets up again. And that was about $80,000 of that $100,000. So cost management, great credit to, again, to Hayes and his crew for that. One other guy I do want to mention on this, and he's not here because, and I told him I was going to say that, Mark doesn't clean up real well, but Mark from Speeds Construction.

39:33 He was the lead on all four of those projects. They were the low bidder on all of those. I got permission from him to say that, by the way. They were the lead on all four of those. They were the low bidder. And they came through on every occasion. They worked well with the residents for the amount of work that was done, especially on Canyon over a seven-and-a-half-month period. There were very few complaints. There were a lot of things that happened. We got a question just the other day why it took so long. And my comment was, well,

40:01 We could have done it quicker by closing Canyon Boulevard completely for three or four months, but that doesn't really work here in town. That's the main access to that area. So I wanted to give Mark credit in case he's listening or watching as well. Just a couple of quick shots of that for those who haven't taken the opportunity to drive it. But the Lower Canyon Rehabilitation looks great, the sidewalk along the north side. And again, the only thing to finish up there is the street lights, getting them turned on.

40:31 The bluffs overall went very well. We had a few issues with some of the asphalt. It was resolved very quickly and very well by the contractor, and I think we're very happy to accept that project. Meridian, again, I've heard nothing but compliments about that project. And then the Waterford Bridge, again, I encourage everybody to get out there as soon as it's open after the next snow, whenever, and take a good look at it because it'll be a great benefit to the whole trails there. Next is transit and airport.

41:01 Brian Picken is our manager out there. I know Brian's here. Thank you for sticking around. Brian's been with the town for eight years, correct, Brian? Yes. We've got four year-round staff over there and two seasonal staff for snow removal, which got their first test yesterday. They had about a foot of snow out at the airport.

41:23 Unfortunately, we had some issues with fog, so even though we cleared the snow, the plane couldn't get in, but that's not something we had anything to do with it. The fog dropped down on the ground, and that obscured that, but everything else worked very well. Some of the highlights from a transit perspective, we did, as you know, started bus service out to Whitmore Pool for the swim team and others. The bus turnouts on Meridian and other areas in town. At the bottom there, you see ESTA relations.

41:52 I was very impressed with the communication between John's group and Brian's group, basically, because we could call a day before a large event, and Stu's a great testimony to this, too. We could call a day before an event, and boom, something happened, and we were able to change it. They were very flexible. The Lakes Basin, we were able to keep that open several weeks longer, adding trolleys, and the responsiveness was very impressive. We were very happy with that whole relationship. And we did, again,

42:22 Help them implement the next bus system. I wanted to give credit to John on that as well as long as he's here tonight because I used that this morning. I wanted to test it in order if he was coming tonight. From where I live in Snowflower, I could actually sit in my kitchen having a cup of coffee. Five minutes till the bus, I walked out. It was there in two minutes. I got here on time and it worked. That's the best testimony for that. At the airport.

42:51 Finally, we were able to come and report that we got a conditionally approved AOP. We're excited about that. We finished a project to redo all the markings at the airport and crack seal most of the ramp. There's a little bit of work left to do to that next spring to finish it up. As John and everybody's already reported again, we've added flights to Denver and Los Angeles and obtained multi-year contracts with United and Alaska Airlines.

43:18 And that is our ALP, which again, we certainly hope to be back in January to talk more about the airport and what we see for the future there. Overall, for the Public Works Department, there's a long list, and again, this could have been several pages long of smaller items. We're trying to prioritize everything we need to do over the next few years, and it's literally hundreds of items long, small and large. But we really worked hard this year on our Forest Service Partnership. I think that's going very well.

43:48 Just accomplished with them was to redo the winter maps. Forest Service was able to find some funding that, let's just say it had a short fuse. They had to use it within two weeks by last Friday.

44:02 So we were able to respond to that, get a designer to help update those winter maps. There weren't a lot of changes from the last one. We'll do a more comprehensive update for the next review in three years. But we got those maps done. We had a couple of final comments this morning from John before we go to print. But we'll have 20,000 of those available and 3,000 more durable maps that the Forest Service will hand to the distribution of that. But that is done.

44:28 Peter was instrumental in getting the assessment district's annual updates done. Tonight, before you'll see the updated solid waste ordinances, snow removal and pit contracts. With our inspection department, Anne Hayes Group and Ron Fansler, we reviewed literally dozens of private and public permits, grading permits, building permits, all the things that Public Works was involved in. And also we managed the LTC, the Local Transportation Commission.

44:57 Overall work program. Now to talk about next year briefly. In terms of CIP projects, this year $6.5 million was a very big year for this department. The four staff to do $6.5 million, especially in July, August, and September, they were very, very busy. Next year we see two somewhat large projects on the horizon. One is the trail.

45:22 Up in the Lakes Basin from Lake Mary Road to Lake George Road. The other is the middle school project, a connector path there. We actually delayed that slightly so we could get in concert with the middle school's work. Those are the two largest ones for next year. That's about a million and a half dollars between those two in CIP construction, but everything else will be going on. But what I want to mention is that we've really worked hard the last few months on adding structure and streamlining overall department functions.

45:51 At least in my opinion, and hopefully the guys we're working with agree that we're working much better as a team. We have more regular meetings, we have better controls, much more consistency with everything we're doing, and we're working better with outside agencies. We're also working more closely with parks maintenance and with recreation because one thing I noticed in my first few weeks is Dennis spent as much time in Stu's office as he did in mine dealing with events and parks things.

46:20 We're actually, since Dennis is now a short-timer and he says he'll be leaving us next July, we're working on a transition plan for that, and it's pretty well known that we'll probably move parks maintenance into parks and recreation. And again, year-round, we think that works better. We're not so big that we can't make that work very well, so we're working on that transition.

46:42 We're also going to update our overall capital improvement program. As you know, we're going to be looking at the DIF study, and that goes hand in hand. There's a lot of things that are in that. You need to update the whole capital improvement program and major maintenance. We'll do what we can to help Dan with the finance system. We're already giving them input on how we think it can work better for the town as a whole and help us do our job. And, of course, I didn't list all the...

47:08 Various agencies we work with here because there are probably a dozen more we work with. I just gave a short start at it. Another thing which is a change from the past is that we're working even more closely with the Recreation Commission and we hope to support the efforts of MLR as everybody goes through a transition there and everybody learns what their role is. We've been meeting regularly with the Rec Commission as Public Works, talking about their priorities and assisting them in moving forward.

47:36 Of course, the air service group, the last thing on my list here is the airport. I think the air service group is working very well. We have great representation from the Mountain, MLT, and everybody, and we're all very excited that we think the airport work and the new terminal apron are very much going to be a reality. FAA is a great partner in that, and it looks like the funding we need will be there. Not all of it, and we still have a gap, but we're making great progress on that.

48:05 Tried to keep that as short as I could. I could have talked for an hour about these guys. Any questions of me or any of the folks who showed up this evening? They're all yours? Yes. Colin? I just have one quick comment. I'm not exactly sure who is responsible, but really just wanted to call out the tremendous job that you guys did on all the grinding projects. I think that's something that...

48:33 That has made a great improvement to those areas, to the airport, to Whitmore, and I just think that's a fantastic idea and a fantastic use of those grindings to put them in place and make them useful. So thank you for doing that. I just really wanted to call that out because I think that's a really tremendous job that you guys did with us this year.

48:55 Appreciate that. And that was truly a team effort. And we use that as an example of how to work as a team because we had the CIP projects involved. We had Hayes on that, Peter on the other, Ron, Todd, everybody really got involved. We sat down planning it out and it worked. So great credit to them for stepping up. Makes a lot of sense. And it helped us with CalRecycle. Yeah. Reusing everything. So appreciate the comments. Yeah, thank you for that. Just a quick comment, Grady.

49:24 2014 was definitely very busy for you guys. And all the work that you've done, it definitely shows, I mean, you know, a lot was done with small staff, like you said, and you guys working together, and Canyon Boulevard looks great. Meridian looks great, and the airport stuff looks great. So I just want to commend all the staff. You guys did a great job.

49:50 I wanted them to hear that because I agree they did a great job. Yeah. Yeah, the energy coming out of your department, the aspirations for efficiency and streamlining and partnership and working with a lot of, a wide variety of different partners, a lot of different agencies, those are the unique challenges that we have, but it's very encouraging to hear this presentation and to get a sense of leadership in the department. So thank you very much. Ditto to all of that. And thanks to the staff. Thanks, guys. Thank you. All right. Thank you, Grady.

50:23 Next up, we have the consent agenda. Are there any items anyone wishes to poll? Madam Mayor, I was hoping to poll item 5. Okay, I also want to poll 4. Madam Mayor, make a motion to council approve items 3 and 6. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jane.

50:47 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I asked to poll number 4 just because I wanted to make it easier for Jamie to... Madam Mayor. Yes. I have to recuse yourself. Yeah, I do. For financial reasons. Yes. It's just to record the vote separately, so don't go far. I won't. So, number 4, which is the...

51:18 In the Village Project, I only pulled it because I will restate my, instead of restating my objections, just to say that I will be voting no on this one. So we need a motion and a second. Madam Mayor, make a motion that Council approve items A, B, and C. Would you like me to read them? No, you just have to, you just have to say wait for reading and adopt it. Okay. Second.

51:47 We have a motion and a second. Roll cover, please, Jamie. Some discussion ahead. Yes, I'm sorry. Sorry, I didn't see you. Yes, Amy. Hi, I have a question about this particular item. So I know it's going to come off wrong, but I have to ask the question. So the geographic area of the North Village and those who are impacted, is that the edge of the property?

52:16 Regardless of where your business sits within the village or is it within the designated distance? And the reason I bring it up is because, Michael, I love your place. The New York Bagel is inside the village. Correct. So are you impacted by the North Village specific plan and do you need to recuse yourself? I'll refer to Andy. So that is the question.

52:44 I'd like to field that if I may. Last year the FPPC changed the conflict regulations and one of the things they did was they removed the 500 foot rule for leasehold interests. If you own property there's still a 500 foot rule, it's a little bit modified, but if you only lease property there is no 500 foot rule. Instead the analysis is will a governmental decision foreseeably have a financial impact above a certain amount on your

53:13 On your leasehold. And in this case, we concluded that it will not. I mean, the threshold for Councilmember Raimondo's business is it's something like $20,000 a year in additional annual sales. It did not appear likely that this project would do that, and therefore, we concluded that he does not have a conflict. Okay. So I have a follow-up question. So what's the distinction between Shields' business and...

53:41 Michael's business. Councilmember Richardson's conflict is not based on his business ownership. It's based on his wife's relationship with the developer. Ah, okay. So thank you for the clarification. And thank you for keeping us on our toes. Well, there was a lot of question in town about that, and it was a question I had, so please don't take offense, but I wanted to make sure that that was covered. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Amy. Roll call vote, please.

54:11 Yes. Yes. Yes. No, motion passes 3-1. How far did she go? There he is. Sorry about that. Stay up here. So, Colin, you asked the poll 5. I also have some questions, but go ahead. Okay.

54:48 Actually, if you want to lead, that's fine. You know, the main reason I pulled it is I just think that it's something that I wanted to have a little discussion on and just have that be available for the public as opposed to a consent agenda item. And my question, for the benefit of everyone who does not have an agenda in front of them, this is directing the town manager to enter into negotiations for potential sites for temporary public parking.

55:14 At locations that turn out to be near the village. And first I just want to thank Dan for pursuing this. This is one of our goals on our list. But my concern was that I did not see anything that really talked about a recognition of the potential sites having an issue of how we're going to get the pedestrians then to the village. Summertime is easy. Everybody can walk.

55:44 I was a little concerned. So I just polled it for a little more discussion on that. It seems to me that you would almost have to run some kind of a special trolley loop so that you're not. Parking shuttle or something? Shopping shuttle? We've got snowmobiles. Not on town. Just kidding. As Councilman Fernie mentioned too, this was...

56:11 Just from the public standpoint, it was, as the mayor mentioned, one of the town's goals in terms of looking at elimination some of the quote unquote blighted looking facilities and also looking for expanded parking near the village area. As the mayor mentioned too in looking at it, we hadn't gotten to a lot of detail on that, but the question has been raised at the staff level as you get access in and out of those particular parcels.

56:34 And how do you move people? Because it's a tough walk up and across and those types of things. Some folks would probably do it regardless. We've had a brief discussion with ESTA regarding potentially modifying one of the existing trolley loops that could go by there. And we would have further discussions ultimately on peak periods about Village Mountain, the town coordinating to maybe have a...

57:01 More timely looping through there as well. So that would be something we need to come back and look and whether it's a set loop that goes by there consistently or is it more of a consistent one than being able to peak up or ramp up based on holiday weekends or something of that nature. It's not on an existing set route because of the lack of riders on minaret between Meridian and Main on that section.

57:27 There is a loop called the Yellow Loop that we could look at potentially looping through there between Juniper Lodge and the village. The mountain runs part of that element in there. So there's a couple options to look at from the loop structure. And then also, obviously, similar to what we did with the Lakes Basin, do we look at upping some transit services and doing that in partnership with those other entities that would benefit from that ridership.

57:55 I'm assuming also there's a pedestrian component to this. Yeah, there's elements there you look at. Ultimately, there's plans for a sidewalk in there and stuff, and that would come in the future most likely as part of some other development. Our idea here is more short-term. That property is actively being marketed, so we don't know if we would have it for one year or three years or longer. So there's some elements we have to work with on the pedestrian access. Part of it, when you get them across Main Street there, depending where they cross at, there's not a...

58:21 Great place for them to go to. I'm just thinking when we talked about the 8050 project, there was a component in there for pedestrian circulation. True, but the problem is is then that you really don't want more people going up the wall.

58:34 Yeah, until that wall gets removed and you get the full connection point, you're better off going up the bike path to the other signal and then in that direction in the back of the village. Knowing that not everybody would do that, you know, that was my concern is, you know, everybody's going to cross at Main and then if they don't know that they're supposed to go around behind, you know, behind again. Well, I hope it's a good opportunity if we get, if the efforts prevail and we can actually talk about some pedestrian circulations, it's a good idea to start kind of figuring out how are we going to make all this work.

59:03 So there's some good options there, but the first question is can we actually utilize those properties for parking purposes? Right. Yeah, I mean, I just really wanted to pull it for kind of the benefit of the public to have this discussion, but I see this as a very beneficial thing on both levels. I mean, there's been a lot of talk in the community on a desire to have those blighted buildings torn down or beautified in some way.

59:30 And this also could solve what potentially we could have a significant parking problem should the existing parking in the village go away. We do need to have a short-term solution for that as we're building the longer-term solution. So I'm very supportive of moving forward with this and hopeful that we can figure it out. But I think the comments on trying to fit in some pedestrian circulation and bus route circulation are definitely things we need to consider when looking at this.

59:59 Yeah, I think that's a great comment. I think also this is, I think council appreciates the entrepreneurial spirit behind this and that there may be roadblocks and things and things may not work out, but I think, you know, as long as the public will know what's going on, that's the nature of doing these kinds of things. And so I think you go forward with that kind of support in mind. So Dan, does anyone want to make a motion? Sure, I'll go ahead and make a motion.

1:00:30 Just make a motion to direct the town manager to enter into negotiations for potential sites for temporary public parking and related uses. Second the motion. Okay, we have a motion to second roll call vote. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to policy matters. The first one is directions to staff regarding

1:00:59 Procurement of the cover for the multi-use facility. Great. Madam Mayor, if I may, I'm just going to have Grady Dutton and Public Works staff kind of talk to the project that we're talking about in terms of an ice cover for the ice rink. I'll talk into some of the other processes we're going to need to go through to get there and some of the financial pieces. But I thought I'd get an overview, the project would start, and I'll walk through some of the other steps we're going to have to go through.

1:01:29 Move the project forward or not. Regarding the history of this, I think when the ice rake was built in 2009, there had been some discussion for some time about a roof structure. It was actually part of the original planning for that. It hasn't happened yet. There's been more interest in the last six months at least and it seemed to come back very often. What we did was we went out and let's call it pulled

1:01:57 We found that...

1:02:16 Once you calculate the fabrication and delivery and installation of the building itself, all the site worked, the total cost was somewhere in the neighborhood of $900,000. At that point, we stopped, turned it over to Dan and said, okay, let's see where we're going with this because we didn't want to do a lot of work on actual design and procurement until we had to go ahead from the town manager, from the town council about how to proceed.

1:02:39 What we're looking at is a building, if you will, which is open on the bottom, anywhere from 10 to 12 feet up the bottom would be open. Maximum height, we want to keep it to the 35 feet if at all possible. Approximately 122 feet wide by about 220 feet long, fully span the entire ice area and the small bleachers on the west hand side of that.

1:03:05 It would include some electrical modifications. It would include lighting on the inside, make it a true year-round facility. We've talked about the weather. We've talked about keeping the snow off of it, the difficulty of, well, if you want to ask Dennis what happened in the last couple of days, and as Stu said, it's not really operable, and that would have been prevented, frankly, most of that, not all of it, if there was a roof there. What I'd like to describe now is the procurement process.

1:03:32 We consider the building itself to be something that's actually a purchase. It's a fabricate and install. It's not really a construction project because of the type of structure that we're doing. They're not constructed and on site. They would just fabricate it and install. There is, though, quite a bit of groundwork that would have to be done in terms of just cleaning the area, cleaning some area around that, possibly a little bit of asphalt for walkways on the edges, certainly the foundation. It's most likely that when we go forward with this,

1:04:02 We're asked to do so. We would bid that as a single project for all of that site work. In the staff report, it's, I don't want to call it misleading, but the idea tonight was to get an indication whether you want to go ahead or not, but we showed the building itself as a $1 amount. We showed, it said in-house for $80,000. It wouldn't truly be in-house. There would be some work that certainly our staff can and would do to X-Bike project, but some of that would be certainly publicly bid as appropriate.

1:04:31 With that, I'll turn it over to Dan because the bottom line is it's a roof structure. Our budget number is $900,000 for all of it. We'd like to involve the community wherever possible. There may be some volunteer opportunities. There may be some opportunities to contribute. I think Sue's already advertising a board campaign to raise money for that roof as well, and we see what comes out of that. But we're excited about it, and if we get direction to proceed, we'll jump on it.

1:05:01 The element we started to walk through originally on this and looking at some older bids was the million plus dollar type of facility process and so going through what different options we have out there. The other element obviously was looking at where do we have funding that if we wanted to go forward and you have an outline in your staff report of that. I won't walk through all the details on that and that's with particular questions but we identified a little over $500,000 that could be committed to the project.

1:05:30 And then looking at some community money and then the option at least from some of the vendors that would actually finance a piece. And so we began to look at that. The other element obviously ties into the...

1:05:44 The ice rink and the use of that in the summertime is the location which is on school district property. We have a lease agreement for that property and initially looking at it, you know, we had some grant funds that went into it and so we had a 20-year agreement with the 10-year option on it so we had a 30-year agreement, ongoing payments on that and that was a little bit challenging just in terms of looking at the long-term potential cost issues for leases but the element there would be it's from a practical standpoint of

1:06:13 Permanent facility, if you're looking at 30 years going into something. In preparing the work on this and also though was reviewing the other documents and the issue that came up was the memorandum of understanding between the town and the school district regarding the settlement issues related to the town's filing for bankruptcy. The agreement with the school district basically reduced the lease payment and then also reduced the term.

1:06:43 So we are now in a second part of a 10-year term with two five. The five-year term goes from 2012 to 2017. If this was to expire, it wouldn't make a lot of sense to go invest close to a million dollars in the property that in a couple of years you could say, sorry, you can't be here anymore. Well, we don't anticipate that, and the agreement actually calls out that

1:07:10 You know, that we can meet any time before the expiration of the MOU agreement, which somewhat reading between the lines, obviously, of not being here through the mediation process. It looked like the agreement went into place to reduce the town's obligations as part of the whole restructuring. The five-year term kind of ties into the five-year reorganization plan that was brought to the council following the mediation work.

1:07:38 And so in looking at that, it would look like the anticipation was yes, we'd be back and renegotiating the lease agreement prior to 2017. My request for that would be the direction to go and start that negotiation immediately versus waiting for the term to run. There's nothing that prohibits us from coming together sooner than later. But the whole process of that was to take a look and evaluate the town's financial condition.

1:08:07 To look at the other elements impacting that. Then whether to extend the current terms existing, change it, and then the option obviously would be to terminate as well could happen. The anticipation would be to go back and work through that. And looking at the previous lease agreements, the timing, a lot of the phasing of the project was laid out with the

1:08:35 Groomer storage, which has been done, and then it talked about the ice rink cover with sprinkling and lighting to come in by October of 2018. So we're still within those time frames. We'll have some discussion on sprinkling. One of the issues we looked at, we're assuming that wasn't for making ice, but for fire sprinkling. So it's the challenge there in an open structure, if you have no way to capture heat, a lot of times your sprinklers won't turn on, so there's a question of the value of sprinklers in a facility where they won't activate.

1:09:05 We'll need to work through that with the fire district. But little things like that popping up in some of the review work. But the issues for us tonight was to try to get a feel for the structure, the potential roof structure. I think the council is fully aware of the benefits and why the items before you. Secondly would be, we are looking at it, about a total project, about $900,000. I include some contingency funds. Some of that would be staff level, you know, I'll say the prep work.

1:09:34 We'd be doing it almost as a maintenance work, bidding out some pieces to make that happen, which would be a public works bid, and then obviously, depending on the type of structure that we got, to bring in and have that installed. The question tonight would be twofold. One, being able to get direction to move forward to actually develop a project, but no final action on that until we're able to work with the school district on what does the terms of the lease begin to look like.

1:10:02 Because I think we need to have that resolved before we invest dollars, obviously. But also we didn't necessarily want to lose 30 or 45 days of time sitting on our projects. We wouldn't mind spending some staff time into having that project ready to go based on direction from council, assuming that they were able to reach an amicable agreement with the school district and the Mono County Office of Education. We let them know that the item was before you this evening and that we were willing to sit down and meet and they've actually already

1:10:31 Shout out back saying what dates work, and so we'll be working some dates the next few weeks to sit down with the school districts. Questions for Dan? I've got one, Dan. What's the funding shortfall right now? The funding gap, whatever we're calling it? I would say it's about $300,000 based on the current estimates that we've received and give or take. And for that shortfall, they've been looking for a public-private kind of...

1:10:57 Funding mechanism? Yeah, if we could end up, I mean, it'd be great to communicate rates $300,000, but when we just do the project, that'd be really sweet. And then the other element we'd look at, at least one vendor we'd talk to, they actually will finance it. And so we'd looked at that at a very favorable, their own internal financing, so they were looking at like a 2% interest rate. The current cash flow out of the Mela Roots District would cover that. And so we'd looked at that option. The question is, when you bid it, will it other...

1:11:27 If folks do that, that would be up to them at that point in time. But we do have that funding gap that we will need to make sure it's addressed before we award a bid. I would not want to go forward with the project that says, well, we'll go out and bid it and see if we have the money. That's not a good way to do business. What type of top is it? Is it a hard top? I mean, this is for the benefit of the public.

1:11:51 Well, if I could, there are actually a number of options. Again, some is a fabric structure. What do we do in the bid? And I want to work with the town attorney very carefully on the language because it would be more of a best value bid because every...

1:12:05 Building is different. I mean, some of them have a steel roof, some of them have this, and I'd like to look at it more of a best value to the town in terms of the structure itself, the longevity, and the finance opportunities. I mean, we arrange it so that you get points for certain things. The financing opportunity is a certain one that since not everybody offers it, you know, we have to get as much apples to apples as possible, but we take a look at it, and again, based on longevity, maintenance costs, life cycle costs, I'll make a recommendation based on that.

1:12:35 Great. On the $919,000 cost estimate, that would be with a hard lid though, correct? Actually, the rough numbers that we got from talking to some of the vendors, a couple were a little bit lower than that. One was about $10,000 higher than that, so we picked sort of a high middle, if you will, for this estimate. There was a couple that we could...

1:12:58 Potentially be 30 or 4,000 below. But again, we haven't bid it. We haven't issued a performance specification yet. I didn't want to just go high. I mean, that's an easy way to kill something. Just throw out a huge number. We want to be able to develop it and develop that performance spec. So it covers both of those within, say, $10,000 within a very small percentage. And we've talked to both. Someone who would do a metal steel roof building and more of a, it's not a sprung, but a sprung structure type.

1:13:27 So I would think, Madam Mayor, that a fundamental responsibility that we have, if we're going to be talking about public-private partnerships and fundraising,

1:13:59 Is to ensure that we've done the kind of due diligence work that has to happen with the schools and the property owner to make sure that we're on a solid foundation. Very sensitive. That sounds more like deliberation than a question. Okay, sure. So we want to hear from the public first. I have a legal question, Andy. So when the MOU happened during the settlement and bankruptcy and all of that,

1:14:29 Does that essentially change the terms of the lease? Yes. Okay. So that it truly is negotiate now if we want or in 2017? As opposed to the 20 years with the 10-year extension that was originally envisioned? Yes. Okay. Any other questions to staff? I do have a question. Are there any other...

1:14:56 Items like this? I mean, do we have to be thinking about, now that we've come through the bankruptcy process, are there things like this that we need to be looking, keeping our eyes out for? Yes. There are other leases and agreements where we reduce things and reduce costs based on that, and some of those have...

1:15:13 Taking care of themselves by running out and then others are still out there that we will be addressing as they come forward. Okay. And as you will learn, one of the things as a council member is you are always dealing with things that prior councils approved that in the light of a different time, we want to look at them a little differently. We have to do something about that. You'll find out, yes.

1:15:36 Okay, if there are any more questions before we get too far into deliberation or comments up here, ask if there's anyone for the public who'd like to speak on this matter. If you do, please come to the podium and state your name. Good evening, Council. Martin Kleinbart as an ordinary citizen and also as vice president of Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. As the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, we support this project. We even gave an initial donation.

1:16:06 At our last contractors meeting. I do have a question. Was there any thought to a movable structure so it opens so you can take advantage of the views they have on that section? I mean, I know that it's probably just adding to the cost, but... You need more of a donation. We have not looked at a...

1:16:35 On, off, or a retractable type roof at this point. No, we've not. The idea is keeping the sides open so you still get some of that open feel, but you wouldn't be able to look out as you do today, obviously. Okay, so, I mean, you know, support of the project because it's been a long time coming and it's on the list and, you know, we've gone through a lot of stuff and there's a lot of reasons. I mean, energy savings alone, I think, is a big...

1:17:02 Big thing. Just with the cover on top, the cost of operating the facility probably would be beneficial over the short term, not just the long term. And the only thing I want to say in closing is that just caution about the negotiation over this thing with the school district and get it much advantage to us as we can possibly do so. And caution on the...

1:17:30 The bidding process that we do that properly, too. So thank you. Thank you, Martin. Anyone else? You can just form a line. Councilmembers, my name's Jeff Posey. I've been involved with hockey since pretty much the inception in Mammoth, since we originally got the ring back in 99-2000, I believe it was. I know you got, I mean, I appreciate all your help from the public works department.

1:18:03 Stu, all of your help as well. Council members, all of your help. I don't think we're going to get a better deal on the steel roof than what came in as bid. I cashed in a big favor with a friend of mine whose family, that's what they do for a living is steel buildings. And they're basically giving us the steel at cost. So I don't think you can pass that up. I know the fabric covered building is a little cheaper, but it's not much. And I think the steel will last a lot longer.

1:18:32 With the steel, you can install solar, which will eventually end up paying for itself in a few years of running the chiller and just making money all summer long. And I talked to a friend of mine today from U.S. Poland Lighting, and he's going to talk to his boss tomorrow and maybe he'll donate all the lights for the rink. He's the lead engineer, so I'll forward him to you, Pete, and see if you guys can get together, see what you need. And I just think we should go ahead with the steel building. I think that's our best option. And we're going to do our best to have to pay for it.

1:19:02 Thanks, guys. Thanks, Jeff. Hi, I'm Lynn, L. Terry Need, and even though you've been seeing a lot of the same faces, which is just a few of us, we've been networking heavily, and there are a lot of people that are very passionate about having this roof be implemented over the ice rink, and I haven't heard any challenges to that either.

1:19:26 So really what I wanted to come up and just point out is that as we know it's an underperforming asset. It functions two and a half to three months out of the year. I became involved because my kids were passionate about skating and hockey. But really what I learned through a lot of the research I've done is that we have a huge potential of creating not only a covered ice rink but also a cultural center.

1:19:50 An opportunity, a covered roof that can, this particular venue could host 200 plus persons, which the town currently does not own a venue that does such. Only Mammoth Mountain does. We did a space seating type assessment. We estimated probably around 900.

1:20:09 Some of the town council members, I believe, have seen pictures from Crested View, but if you're interested, I can send you those. That's population 1,500, and they were able to put a roof over their rink, and they're holding music festivals and art festivals in the summertime. And as a result of that, too, they used that center, Budweiser sponsored or whatever USA, and actually gave the town $500,000. So I really think that we need to stay focused.

1:20:38 Thank you. Thank you.

1:20:58 To become a multi-use, world-class recreation and cultural events center. And I know that's a big vision for what we have now, but it's very feasible and very possible. If you'd like to see the pictures of the example of Crested Butte, I'd be more than happy to forward those to you so you can take a look at it. But please keep that in mind when we're making the decisions, and we're happy to, as a community, be working alongside with you on this project. Thank you. Thank you, Lynn. Is there anyone else?

1:21:31 Mayor Bacon, Councilmember Patrick Bernard, President, Commissioner of Mammoth Youth Hockey. I just wanted to come up and thank you very much for your work, Dan. I appreciate your work with us. But I just wanted to simply let you guys know that we really have a great opportunity out there. It's a great amenity. It's a great place. And I just wanted to give you guys an invitation to come out and watch our kids play hockey or to go out to the rink on a Friday and Saturday night and look at all the people that come out from out of town, people on vacation.

1:21:59 That just have a great time. And it's a great facility. And it's a compliment to our town. We have the mountain. But ice is, you know, an ice hockey rink is a great outdoor winter facility. So I think it's something that we need to support. I told you before, my backyard rink lasted a little bit longer than yours. That's simply because of the sun. I have shade. Our town rink doesn't. So with the shade, we're going to have better quality ice.

1:22:27 We're going to have a better guest experience. We're not going to have to shut down on a Friday night or Thursday night like we had to recently. And it's a great thing for our town. So I just want to thank you guys. And I wanted to invite you down to hockey and come onto the rink Friday and Saturday night and talk to the public and see what they think. And ask them about the facility. And go skate yourself. Check out the ice. Check out the paint in the corners. And that's simply there because of the shade. We don't have shade. The ice melts. So let's improve the facility.

1:22:55 Let's make it an asset for the town. It creates jobs and it's a great place. So let's support it. We appreciate your support. Thank you. Thank you, Patrick. Good evening, Council. My name is Jay Cole. I'm a parent of a hockey enthusiast and also part of the group to try to research and find viable reasons why we should improve our facility there. One of the things I'd like to address is solar potential.

1:23:24 If we go with a steel structure, we'll be able to mount some solar panels at some point. It doesn't have to be at the beginning, but there is a great example in Durham, New Hampshire, that has a covered rink, and one side of the roof is all solar panels. It's fully self-sufficient. It generates all the electricity it needs for a year-round ice. And we're not going to have year-round ice, but...

1:23:48 We can have year-round power. That power, any excess of power, obviously we can resell. And that is roughly equivalent to, you know, 10 plus percent rate of return on investment there. So we're talking about financing, fabric structures and whatever. Let's also consider that we can make money on money by going with the solar program. We won't be able to do that on a fabric structure. So let's think.

1:24:17 Let's think metal. Metal looks more permanent. Let's think Mammoth and what we can do for our business and such. Thank you. Thank you, Jay. Good evening, Council. I'm Phil Heigert. I'd like to speak in favor of this project in keeping with Mr. Holler's recent expression of the need for us to look at recreational amenities for all ages, not just the young adults and elite athletes and so forth.

1:24:51 I am walking evidence that hockey is a lifetime sport because I've been involved with it since 1980 when I came here and we started with the Mammoth Quakes hockey team and now I'm looking forward to playing this season along with one of my seven grandchildren who's now getting started. So I appreciate your support of the project and thank you very much. Thank you, Phil.

1:25:23 Hello, my name is Rick Voll, and I've heard how this project has evolved since being part of the Contractors Association at council meetings, and I'm in love with it. I think that the idea of having a reliable, multipurpose facility for our community is a tremendous idea, asset. I've lived at Kodiak Island before, and we averaged about 78 inches of rain a year.

1:25:47 And if our ice rink was not covered, we wouldn't have kids and families out there every day. And a year before I had left, we actually invested in the football field. It rains a lot, so we put the AstroTurf in. And it was night and day as far as how many families and kids sporting events could now actually happen that couldn't in the past. So I think that I may have seen the potential.

1:26:14 In a town of this size coming together and building it. I appreciate the ideas of pulling in favors and where can we get things. At Mammoth Disposal, children of my driver's ice skates, so we're going to be sponsoring one of the banners. We're excited to do that and hopefully we can move forward with this. Thank you. Thank you, Rick. Okay, anyone else? Okay, then I will bring it back for discussion and deliberation. Who wants to go first?

1:26:48 Okay, so a couple of questions. The infrastructure to support solar, is that something I'm assuming you can't just, not any building is going to support solar. You're going to have to engineer that from the beginning, is that right? You would have to do that, yes. Right. That would be an additional cost. Okay. The second thing is, what is the status on the health?

1:27:17 of the chillers in the system right now. Is that of concern? I know over the last couple years things have sort of happened and there's been issues with that. We've updated the header pipe recently and also the control system was just updated this year which really added some, I guess, better usage of what the chiller is doing and overall I think it's in good shape. So we just had it maintenance done on the chiller, it actually produces more.

1:27:46 The chiller capacity that it's ready for it produces 207 tons of chiller versus it's actually rated at 200 chiller, which is really good for on elevation. But it is a 20-year-old chiller. The Angus folks that come and look at it with us have told us that we don't ever want to get rid of it. If it needs to have work, we'd send it off to get it refurbished. They do that as part of their program with TRAIN.

1:28:13 So if we wanted to have longer season of ice, we'd probably need another chiller in its plums so that we could put another chiller in its place. But the chiller right now is running well. We had some recent errors that we figured out the problem. But the issue with the pipes, those things that were happening last year, that's all been addressed?

1:28:34 That was addressed with the Missouri Grant. Yeah, okay. I'd like to add to that in talking to Dennis and Peter both about that as well. We do need to look forward, though, in three or four years of possibly taking at least one of the chillers at a time and doing a full rebuild to extend its life another 10 or 15 years. So that's actually something that we put in the...

1:28:54 In the preliminary budget, if you know, the preliminary look for the rec commission to look at it and start thinking about it because, yes, it is 20 years old and, yes, it started up very well this year. Dennis was ecstatic that it, you know, it fired up right away. We had to replace one of the displays, but we don't want to keep that away. Certainly, in three or four years, we may need to do that, but that's, roof or not, that's something we just need to do for long-term maintenance. Understood. I think,

1:29:20 That the, I think an important consideration about is the aesthetic of what, I think Lynn was talking about what this thing can be. And I appreciate that it's, you know, we're going to pull this thing together with rubber bands and all kinds of other stuff. But I think it's going to be important to think about branding this thing as an amenity, giving it a name and a presence, and doing the kinds of things aesthetically to make it a compelling...

1:29:44 Attraction. I mean, that means painting the roof or doing something like that to make it something that's going to be a compelling place to want to go. I think, though, that before we get to all these great and exciting things that need to happen, we need to get this issue resolved with the school district. And I think that's something that should be part of our actions to make sure that if there are enthusiastic folks who want to really give time, effort, money, and all kinds of things, something like this, we have to make sure that we're inviting them into a project that's got a solid foundation underneath it.

1:30:14 Just as a matter of procedure, can you have a motion that would take both the issues into account, the negotiation with the school district and

1:30:39 Okay. And keep going with the... Right. Because direction can be several things. Okay. So we can do that. I have a lot to say. I'll probably choose not to say everything. But, you know, this is something that I'm very passionate about for a lot of reasons.

1:31:06 As a lifelong hockey player myself, you know, I still play in the Mammoth Men's League, and that was a huge part of my childhood. This is something that I would really like to see happen. I think one of my major focuses, I've publicly stated as a council member, is trying to build and enhance our amenity base in town. I don't think I could say it any better than the current facility is an underperforming asset.

1:31:34 And I think I see the value in getting that facility up to snuff and really making it a viable year-round facility that we're talking about. I have been doing a lot of work with a lot of the citizen group, just trying to kind of act as a kind of conduit between the town and the citizen group. And, you know, a lot of the research that we've done

1:32:03 I feel pretty strongly about the fact that I would want to move forward with this in a steel-type capacity. I think going with the sprung structure route, I think aesthetically it's not going to be exactly what we're looking for. Functionally it's not going to be exactly what we're looking for. I think we need to be thinking steps ahead here. The idea of maybe installing solar in the long run.

1:32:32 The possibility 10 years from now, 20 years from now, of making this a fully enclosed structure that would be a year-round rink facility, I don't know if that will ever happen, but I think it's something that if we were to do a steel structure would move us in that potential direction, whereas a sprung structure would not do that. So I would really like to see us be able to move this forward.

1:32:59 But I also echo the concerns around, you know, we need to make sure that we have a firm kind of lease agreement with the school district. So I'm very supportive of moving forward with this in the, you know, roof structure capacity, but with that caveat that we really need to speak to the school district and make sure we're on solid footing there. So this is something that I really think our community could benefit from.

1:33:27 I'd love to see Mammoth kids be able to grow up with the ability to have a great hockey program the way I did. That's probably all I have to say for now. Actually, my comments are going to fall into three areas. It's great to see the passion. This is another one of those projects that's kind of been...

1:33:51 Struggling along for years. Two thousand. And I would like to see that within the options that there also be so come back to us with what does it take to have a structure that's strong enough to put solar on or is there a way to get Edison or someone to front the cost and get the solar on because I'm the one who's purporting every time we do anything that's got a flat roof it should have solar on it.

1:34:18 I'm a little concerned with the financing. $300,000 is a lot short. It's not a little. Having been one of the people who was somewhat involved in raising the funds for the library, it takes an awful lot of work. So I thank the group that started, and you just have to keep plugging away at that. Of course, I can't get too much into the details and negotiations of the lease because we would do that in closed session. But my earlier comment, I just want to...

1:34:47 Come through a little bit more on that. At the time, it might have been the right way to go, but I really have problems looking at a lease where we've already spent over $250,000 on it, which is, gee, just about the amount we would need to finish this project. And yet, we go through this in however many years it is, we still don't own the land.

1:35:10 And to put more money onto something that we don't have a guarantee of having the use of it really concerns me. I'm wondering if in saying we want staff to, so I'm hearing things is proceed, give us the options including solar.

1:35:34 With the community, continue to look at options for the funding gap. But I think that within the lease, we definitely need to say we need to start negotiating on that sooner rather than later. And I'm wondering whether we want to...

1:35:46 Designate a couple of us to meet with school board or let it be at staff level at this point? Yeah, I think if we start at the staff level, then we need to bring in... But then recognizing that it will need to come back to full council in closed session for a discussion of these negotiations. You know, we have some...

1:36:06 I just want to add, Mayor, the

1:36:35 The excitement of the community wanting to get involved and raise money is great. And we've been discussing this since I got on council. And the initial discussion was where are we getting the shortfall. So here we are a couple years later and we still have the shortfall. And we have a lease issue too. But as Colin stated, I think there's no question it's an underperforming asset.

1:37:03 It's an asset that the community needs. It's great for the youth. It's great for our visitors. It has a lot of positive impact. So I'm supportive of us trying to get the lease figured out and trying to figure out how we're going to pay for it moving forward. Dan, if I could, there have been some kind of questions out in the community about the ability to serve alcohol. And, you know, I know the answer to it. But if you could just talk about that a little bit.

1:37:34 You're on school property, so there's restrictions there. You have to go through another. You can get there, but some other hoops and stuff. And so generally, frankly, alcohol in schools don't mix well. Sure. So the goal there is to, if you can do some events there, you've got to go through another process with the school district for those approvals. Special permit for events.

1:37:53 Yeah, I think that's the short answer is it's not a facility that we would be able to serve alcohol on on a daily basis, but it would be a special use permit situation. Yeah. And actually since the lease was originally done, the law about how that alcohol in schools works was changed and it's actually less restrictive than it used to be. So is that adequate direction?

1:38:25 I think a formal action by the council would be appropriate if you can craft kind of that direction to move forward with the lease negotiations and with the project scoping with the preference for metal roof. Yeah, do you need some more direction on, you know, because in the analysis here we've got a partial shade structure, a sprung structure, and a roof structure. Do you need more direction on that? No. Okay.

1:38:47 I would actually still like to see options. I'm not saying, you know, I understand. We can bring that back. You know, but I want to be able to, yeah, come back to us with the different options and what they might be, and obviously I would think that that would also be vetted through the Recreation Commission, I presume. Yeah, we're hearing the preferences, but yeah, we would not preclude something if it makes sense. Sure, that makes sense. Okay. Okay, somebody want to try and craft a motion?

1:39:19 Madam Mayor, I'm wondering if you could perhaps provide a motion on the lease. Okay. All right. You seem pretty eligible. And I would move that we are directing staff to continue with options for the actual construction, including those discussed this evening, to inform us on any changes to the financing gap, to...

1:39:45 Begin immediate negotiations regarding the lease. And I'm sorry, there was a fourth, is there a fourth piece or is that? I think that covers it. Okay. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Ferney? Yes. Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Councilmember Woodway? I have one caveat. I would hope that, Colin, that your liaison with the groups would continue because I think that that

1:40:16 That information is important. They've been keeping me busy. Yeah, because I hate ice skating. I'm happy to do that. Good. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to our next policy matter, which has to do with refuse and solid waste disposal.

1:40:46 And for the benefit of the council members, I have red line copies of, well, you're going to be providing some more to us as you do, right? What I'd like to do is I'll do a brief introduction and turn it over to Pete for some of the detail. Again, these ordinances are in response to ongoing discussions we've had over the years with CalRecycle. They're actually, as Pete will describe in more detail, very happy with the direction we're going.

1:41:13 These amendments to Section 812 and the new Section 14, 14 specifically has to do with recycling. And we'd like to implement these. They really codify what's already in state law and how they turn it down to the local jurisdiction to put this into ordinances. Referencing the red line specifically, when the package went out last Wednesday,

1:41:34 We were still trying to conform what we were doing with state law and getting some of the numbers correct. The town attorney had a few comments, so we've incorporated those into something I'll hand out to you in a second. I have redline copies that if Andy can go through the...

1:41:50 The last few changes, there was just, I think, one significant one on each one, and that was it. The rest are pretty much format issues and stuff. So I'll hand out the new ones. I also have ten copies of these updated ordinances in the back if anybody from the public wants to grab them and follow along with the very few changes that we've made. So there's actually two resolutions. Well, it's two separate ordinances. What I'll do is while I'm handing these out, Pete can start through the rest of the staff report. Okay.

1:42:17 So with that, Mayor, Councilmembers, staff would recommend that after receiving the staff report and public comment, staff recommends Council wave the first reading introduced by title ONI, the attached ordinances amending, Municipal Code, Chapter 8.12.

1:42:45 Changing the name to Solid Waste Management and adding Chapter 8.14, Solid Waste Recycling. The State of California sets targets for monitors for compliance with waste diversion recycling with the goal of progressively reducing the amount of waste in landfills. AB 341 adopted in 2011, took effect in 2012, and the town's really been working with CalRecycle to implement

1:43:14 Thank you.

1:43:38 So one of the aspects of AB 341 is the town becomes responsible on a local level to enforce and facilitate the implementation of the law. Each of these two chapters provide additional tools for the town to use to increase our diversion rates and meet the ongoing best efforts that the town has been working with Cal Recycle for a number of years.

1:44:07 Chapter 8 essentially provides some clarification, additional enforcement tools for nuisance properties and noncompliance of dumpsters, closed lids and other public hazardous and unhelpful accumulations of material. Chapter 814 really codifies the requirement for commercial multifamily units and large events to provide recycling programs.

1:44:38 We did have a revision last in 2013 which really was to implement bear proof containers and codify that it's required that people that have cash dumpsters and enclosures include a bear proof cover. Some of the challenges that we have that other communities in the state don't have include our large resident bear population.

1:45:08 And people not working well with them, as Steve has mentioned a few times at council meetings. We have large fluctuations in population. They're on vacation. And while they are very well trained at home to recycle and, you know, implement that portion of the requirements, when they come on vacation, we haven't been advertising well enough, educating the property managers well enough.

1:45:38 To implement the recycling programs here in town. The state really, they look at it as ongoing. So currently our 50% diversion rate will increase to 75%. And, you know, long term they're talking about, you know, even higher levels of diversion. Cal Recycle has performed a formal review of the town's solid waste programs.

1:46:12 They recommended implementing these changes. They have been on what's called a two-year review cycle, which means really, in fact, they've actually come about twice a year for the last several years looking at our programs, actually going to the dump and looking at trucks that have been dumped to see what we're actually throwing away locally. They meet with community residents, visitors, and

1:46:41 Try to get an understanding of what types of recycling people, recycling is performed in the town. With these ordinance changes, they have indicated that we'll be moving to a four-year formal review program, which is really a good thing. It doesn't necessarily eliminate some of the reporting that we have to do annually, but it certainly puts us on a higher level.

1:47:09 Reduces the threat of having local fines or something else, other enforcement tools that they have to enforce recycling. The town staff, we really, we did provide, get comments, provide these draft ordinances to the two contractors that town works for, Mammoth Disposal and Sear Conservation Project. Both provided some comments that were implemented into the proposed ordinances.

1:47:41 As you know, Mammoth Disposal is our franchise operator of the transfer station and all waste disposal in town. Sierra Conservation Project provides a higher level of service specifically for recycling and on-property recycling for compliance with recycling and just being a better overall citizen.

1:48:10 For the community and the state. So just a little bit of detail about what's in the changes that are proposed in Chapter 12, 812, is it provides some definition, clarifies what's lawful and what are unlawful acts related to solid waste, changes the title to make it more in performance of what the chapter is about, which is solid waste management, not just refuge disposal.

1:48:41 Since we're trying to increase our recycling and not dispose of it. Chapter 814 really implements state law, provides mandatory recycling for commercial businesses, mandatory recycling for multifamily units greater than five, and large events that have more than 2,000 people.

1:49:09 And I'd just like to point out about the large event, large venue thing. That's not something that we've just invented that's actually been state law for 10 years. We just haven't been doing anything about it. So you may get complaints about why am I going to have to do these recycling plants if I'm going to have a big venue in the village or somewhere else or a big event. We should have been enforcing this a decade ago. The other thing about the special event this summer for the larger events,

1:49:36 We did start implementing a recycling program, not quite exactly what this one specifies, but just to start educating those large event holders that there are recycling requirements, and most of them actually contract with Sierra Conservation Project to implement that program. With that, there is a revised ordinance that Andy can go through the details of the changes.

1:50:05 If you'd like. If I could, before I ask Andy to go through, I'd like to mention two other things. We are going to bring back also a new Section 813 that was mentioned in your staff report having to do with construction and demolition. We had...

1:50:20 A draft of it, but we wanted the opportunity, and Peter did meet with some of the contractor's board's people. We'll meet with them again to go through that. There'll be a fee structure. There'll be a deposit to rip some real teeth into that because C&D, construction demolition, is a big part of what happens here in town. So that will be coming back to hopefully December 17th, if not the meeting thereafter. The second thing is that we're also looking at this from a staff perspective.

1:50:44 I, for one, don't want to ask you to implement a new ordinance and have staff not be able to enforce it. It just doesn't make any sense. It certainly won't make CalRecycle happy. We've looked at the staff and for that we think it will take increased staff time. We're not frankly sure exactly how much. We've met between Sandra Moberly and myself and three or four other members of staff. We've taken a look at it. It's not going to be overly cumbersome. In fact, some of it will be easier.

1:51:08 Some of it will just take a little bit more paperwork and more forms. So what we'll probably come back sometime in January is come back with analysis. Look, we may need to hire, let's see, an intern or a part-time staff for that first year until we figure out the program and figure out exactly what we need to do. Because, again, if we're going to suggest and ask you to implement an ordinance, we want to be able to enforce it properly. So that's my last two comments. And then with that hand, if you don't mind.

1:51:32 Point out some of the minor changes. Yeah, and the changes that I'll describe are the changes between the version that was originally in the packet and the version that we're asking you to consider introducing tonight. And I apologize, we just, in trying to meet the agenda deadline, it just wasn't quite ready to go, so that's why we're having to give you a slightly revised version. We cleaned up some of the definitions. We also, there's a thing about covers on receptacles that I think it's somehow, it's been adopted previously, but somehow got left out.

1:52:02 Staff has an idea that it would be nice to be able to collect delinquent trash charges on tax roll, and that was originally in this, but in order to do that, there's a process the council has to go through first. We're going to have to hold a hearing. We're going to do some other stuff. So that one wasn't quite ready. So we took that out of this version. We clarified the process for getting an exemption from service based on some observations the staff has made.

1:52:27 And then finally, we cleaned up what had been some language that wasn't quite right about the town manager and other staff members being able to go on private property to check on violations. There were some Fourth Amendment issues with the original language as it was drafted. So that's 812. And then in 814, it's mostly just minor cleanups here and there, just little formatting things. And then there was a reference originally.

1:52:53 To green building standards, which would have made sense if we had had the construction demolition waste ordinance ready for you tonight, but since it's not being enacted just yet, that reference didn't make any sense on its own. So when we bring the C&D ordinance, we'll probably bring back at the same time the initial steps of being able to collect elinquent charges in the tax roll, and we will add the green building standard reference at the same time we ask you to consider the C&D ordinance. Are there questions to staff? I've got a couple.

1:53:28 I have one too. Go ahead. Oh, okay. These ordinances will conform with state mandates. Yes. These are things that we probably should have done a while ago, and these are things that Cal Recycle has been asking us to do. The AB 341 commercial recycling, they really wanted us to do the construction and demolition waste that we're going to bring to you next time.

1:53:51 Or soon. They've really, really been wanting us to do. And then the rest of the stuff is just kind of updating what is a fairly old ordinance to sort of conform to current best practices. Okay. And then the enforcement question. Great. I appreciate you kind of being proactive about that. But if we adopt something that gets us right with the state on paper, you know, how are we going to enforce this to a level that's going to be credible with the state? People will come over and look at this kind of stuff.

1:54:22 And I don't think it's onerous. It's like maybe adding a half a staff person for the first year, maybe a whole one at a lower level just to make sure that we have the staff to do it. It's not something where it's $100,000 a year. I just want to make sure that you understand that it just doesn't come without a cost. And we will certainly look to ways to recover some of those costs either through negotiations on fees or more likely there will be penalties. And if we have more enforcement, we'll have...

1:54:50 More enforcement dollars coming in. Well, I just think it's going to be important that we can demonstrate to the state that we are not only complying with the letter of the law, but we're also doing the steps necessary moving forward to be in compliance. I guess my third question, does this have any effect on the landfill and discussions with Mono County about flow and all that kind of stuff? Not directly, not really. I mean, this is sort of getting our house in order.

1:55:17 Which I think is part of the process for having discussions with the county and then eventually having negotiations with our franchisee about a new franchise. They're not really related, but we need to sort of get this squared away. Got it. Okay. Thank you. My question is kind of related to Johnson. So presuming these go into effect, will you be coming back to us with a work program that deals with this education enforcement?

1:55:45 Because I see there's this comment under the financial consideration as has provisions allow fees to be collected, but that means we have to go through a process to establish those fees. Am I correct? Fees, penalties, whatever you want to call them. So is that something we would see outside of the budget process? Yeah, you most likely would see it prior to the budget process. Okay. Okay. Good question. Yeah. You mentioned mandate on multi-unit, right?

1:56:14 And commercial, but nothing on single family? Nothing on single family. That's interesting. Yeah. Yeah. They go after multi-family complexes get hit. Yeah. Okay. If we had mandatory pickup, household pickup for all residential, then we would also have mandatory recycling. But since we don't have that locally, it's not required.

1:56:43 Okay. Any other questions to staff? We'll open if there's any public comment. Good evening again. I'm Martin Clambert as a resident in this case. I guess there's multiple red line issues. My question is regarding 8.12340, the fee and all the, is that being changed?

1:57:09 That is not being adopted tonight. That's the one I'm trying to explain, maybe not very well, that in order for the town to be able to collect delinquent charges on the tax roll, there's a process that the council has to go through in order to make that happen. So you're not making any amendments to that section? Not yet. Staff will be bringing that back to the council for consideration, but no amendments tonight. Because I am concerned about item D, discontinuation of services.

1:57:36 I guess it would be a moot point if it's on the tax rolls, but if an account is delinquent for 30 days, basically you're delinquent, you're against the law, service will be discontinued 15 days from the date of notice, payment not made by that time. I mean, what are we trying to do here? I mean, you're still going to charge us for using...

1:58:02 The services, but you're going to disallow us from using it. I mean, that's problematic in a whole litany of things because, you know, when we were going through the real heavy foreclosures and whatnot, there were landlords that were not paying for the services, so therefore the tenants couldn't, unless they lied, they couldn't dispose of their trash so they would get rid of it any way they could. I know that there was a couple in our neighborhood that was...

1:58:31 That we're doing that. Myself, when I broke my foot severely, I was out of work for a severe amount of time, and I could not pay that bill. So I still had trash I had to deal with. And, you know, I can't see 30 days you're cutting us off. I mean, a phone bill, you don't pay your phone like yourself. Well, they cut you off, but they don't let you make calls either. And, you know.

1:58:57 I think that's just a little onerous to go that far after 30 days. A couple observations about that language, which again is not in front of the council tonight. The first is that it's not written so that service would automatically be cut off or mandatorily be cut off. I saw the word main. It's just an option. The second thing is that cities all up and down in the state have wrestled with this exact issue of if you have people who aren't paying their trash bill, cutting off service means they're just going to dispose of it illegally. So it's not something that I think the town or

1:59:27 Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Good evening, Mayor, Town Council.

2:00:04 My name is Jesse Baldwin. I'm a local electrical contractor. I'm the president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. I'm also on the board of the Board of Appeals Building Advisory Committee. I just wanted to speak briefly to what Grady said. I do appreciate the fact that Peter came to our last Board of Appeals Building Advisory Committee meeting.

2:00:28 Martin Kleinbard and Tim Flynn were both currently on the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association Board were present at that meeting. So in effect, we did all get an idea of the construction demolition portion of the ordinance. Peter discussed essentially that there were different fee levels and percentages.

2:00:56 Basically, it could be applied to a project. He asked for input, as you know, probably that Board of Appeals Building Advisory Committee is made up of architects and local contractors, so they were, you know, great people to have speak on that, and I really appreciated the fact that, you know, prior to just bringing it up here and trying to pass it through council, it was brought to our attention.

2:01:19 Asked for our input. And furthermore, Steve Stokes contacted me today as president of the Contractor Association in advance of our next monthly meeting, which would be the second Thursday of this month, asking if we could allow Peter to come and speak at that meeting about this particular issue. So, like I said, you know, I'm just wanting to speak in, you know, in...

2:01:46 In favor of that type of process and seeking feedback from the construction community definitely helps to garner buy-in and also I think from Peter's questions and everything helps to formulate a policy that is going to generate buy-in from the people who are actually having to pay those fees. We talked about kind of a carrot stick thing with deposits that would be made and as long as you complied.

2:02:13 And, you know, we talked about reasonable amounts of time, you know, rather than just a bunch of bureaucratic red tape, we were actually discussing solutions that would work, you know, in practical application. So, appreciate that. Thank you, Jesse. Mayor and Council, my name is Brian Robinette. I'm the owner of the Sierra Conservation Project Recycling Service here in town. I wanted to speak in support of this ordinance.

2:02:40 First off, I'd like to compliment the town staff and say thank you for putting this together. As was stated, it is state law on a lot of these issues that is being brought to the table. I think that this is going to go a long way in giving the town some teeth on enforcing some of these regulations that we're being asked to be the enforcement on as the community.

2:03:10 About 11 years now in growing recycling programs here in the town of Mammoth Lakes with the help of the town and Mammoth Disposal and also working closely with Cal Recycle. So I think this is an awesome opportunity for us to continue to grow our programs that are existing and improve on them both in the commercial and the multifamily side. I think those are both areas where we've made a lot of progress but we've also got a long way to go.

2:03:40 I'm here to say it's got my support. Thank you. Thank you, Brian. Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers. My name's Rick Voll. I'm the manager of Mammoth Disposal, and we operate a seven-day-per-week, 365-day-per-year recycling center in this town. And it is tremendous to see everybody recycle and ask questions.

2:04:06 Trying to isolate different products in different containers because it isn't single stream. We do ask people to sort of separate, so bring each item, number one, plastic, glass, aluminum, and tin. And then we also operate the buyback center, which is seven days a week. It does have different hours because of processing.

2:04:26 And safety reasons. But we do see a great amount of recycling here. I think that there's more opportunity for outreach in the future. Brian works with us. We also do some ad campaigns in the sheet, on the radio, trying to promote recycling. I know that Peter is, the town developed the little tents that are in condo associations. Real helpful. Hopefully we see that grow. Because after setting through some of the CalRecycle meetings,

2:04:52 What they expect us to do, of course, is uphold the law, and they've been talking about this ordinance. I've been here a year, every single time I've sat in a meeting with them, and I think it's really great that we're taking some of that and we're holding our town accountable to what the state's expecting us to do. One piece, I think, is the large events. We have to start really early with those individuals. And, like, this past summer, working with them, gracefully moving them in a direction, this is now...

2:05:20 Really requiring it. So making sure that we know who's going to come to town this summer. How early can we reach out to them? What can we do at Sierra Conservation and Mammoth Disposal to track the recycling progress? Are they making improvements each year? Because that's what CalRecycle wants to see is data. And how are we improving? You have lots of programs. This is our percentage. But if we're having a conversation and working with our large events, it's going to be a huge opportunity for us in the future.

2:05:50 Also, some of the ordinances mentioned about waste and storage of waste. I think that really ties to health and safety. I mean, if you look at what we're dealing with, with our bear population, I think what we have for a dumpster in this town is awesome.

2:06:06 It's great. The lids are real secure if that carabiner gets latched or a padlock is installed. And our drivers are getting out every single time. We're working with Steve. When there are bear issues, to swap out containers, repair them. And that's been an ordinance now for about two years, and I think we've seen a huge reduction in bear trash encounters. So hopefully we'll continue to work on that. And then also, as a company, we really try to provide reliable...

2:06:34 Service. Because we need to be there when the trash needs to be emptied. And as the snow season approaches, what are we doing to be prepared for great snowfall like we're all wishing for? Because if we have more snow, we're going to have more people, we're going to have more recycling and more trash. And so we can't stop picking it up. So I know we're equipping our team and our equipment to make sure that we're safe on the street and we're reliable. So I'm in support of this and thank you, Peter, for all your work on it.

2:07:04 Thank you, Bill. Hi, Amy Cutter, local homeowner. So I just wanted to make a comment about the one section I know that you're not including tonight, but just to consider it, this comment is in your discussions as you formulate or reformulate sections 8.12.340, the fee and civil debt, the part about discontinuing service to consider this, which is in the case where a landlord does

2:07:36 Does not pay their bill and service may, emphasize may, be discontinued, then the tenants are left in a quandary. What do they do with their trash? And so you may end up in a situation where they leave their trash at their neighbor's trash bin that's outside the trash bin and therefore the unintended consequence could be or they put it out in their yard or at their

2:08:02 And the unintended consequence could be that we increase the bear activity, even though we've made huge strides in that area. So that could be an unintended consequence, and so you may want to consider that when you're in your deliberation over that section. That's it. Thank you, Amy. Anyone else? All right. We'll get back to Council. What's our pleasure? Madam Mayor, I make a motion that Council

2:08:30 Waive the first reading and introduced by title only in ordinance amending municipal code chapter 8.12 solid waste management new title from refuse disposal and number two in ordinance adding chapter 8.14 solid waste recycling to the municipal code. Second. Before we take the vote, Andy, do we have to make any mention of the fact that it was as presented this evening as opposed to what was in the packet? I think you just have.

2:09:00 Is that okay with the motion? Make there a second? That's great. Yes. Okay. Yeah. Nice addition. In that case, we all call a vote. Please do. Councilmember Curry? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Councilmember Lover? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to our next policy matter, which is to awarding of a contract for purchase and implementation of financial system software.

2:09:24 Wow. Yeah, Madam Mayor, this is one of those, I think, long-awaited council priorities to see our system updated and upgraded, and so we've gone through a process to get there. I'll have Dan Izzo kind of walk through the details of that. As you know, we've set aside funding to work through some of this so we can actually have it funded when we finalize an agreement and contract. I do want to note that as we're going through this, we didn't want to have to hold off the item in the short week in prep work that...

2:09:53 We hadn't finalized some of the review of the agreement with the town attorney and stuff, and so one of the actions, if you do approve it, is subject to that final review. We're also doing a final last few implementation discussions with the proposed vendor as well, so we'd want to nail that down. But we did want to be able to move forward to keep this on as tight as timeline as we can, which we'll speak to a little bit this evening as well. But with that, I'll turn it over and let Dan is our finance director to walk through some of the details and where we're at, and we'll go from there.

2:10:23 Honorable Mayor, members of council, basically the council made a decision in 2012-13 to set aside some money, $100,000, and in this fiscal year we're in now, they set aside additional monies to ensure that we could move forward. Moving forward, in my view, the most important item that we're looking at here is integration. We don't have integration right now. It doesn't exist. So when we're looking at integration here,

2:10:53 When you look at like the cash receipts, cash receipts, it will automatically talk to accounts receivable. It will automatically talk to project management. So when the cash receipt comes in, you enter only once, and it goes into accounts receivable if a bill was sent out. It goes into project management if a revenue was assigned to that location. When you look at accounts payable, accounts payable,

2:11:18 Because when an invoice comes in and it's against a project, it will have the project number on it. So when the invoice comes in through accounts payable, it's ready to write the check, it automatically interfaces into project management. It also, accounts payable, when you write a purchase order, it will automatically check, and along with invoices, it will automatically check project management or the line item that we're going to expense it to see if money still exists in the budget.

2:11:48 So anyone would get a warning if they tried to spend more money than was budgeted in a project under project management or an account line item. That is what integration is creating here. Payroll is the same way. When you enter your time, when labor is put in electronically, electronically approved instead of by paper, we have five timesheets right now, it will automatically...

2:12:13 Interface back into project management saying that this person is working on this project. So what you get at the end of a month is an integrated information from your reporting that indicates how much money you spent, how much money you are making, and you only have to input it once. We don't have that today. That's what this CASEL product is. It is a completely...

2:12:38 21st Century Application. They have more than 1,200 installs nationwide with their applications. They were the second biggest company applying for this opportunity. They also offer, which we don't have today, is the ability to write reports at will. Any data you input into this computer system, because it is based on a Microsoft SQL database,

2:13:07 You can print a report on it. You can select that field and you can pull it out. On any data that you put in, you can pull it out. We don't have that ability today. We also, inside this purchase, we can export into Excel at the push of a button. That's what this also gives us. But because we have both on-demand report writing and additional reports, we can modify canned reports. We can modify, we can create our own reports.

2:13:36 And we can download all this into Excel. But we – the best part of this whole concept here is all the information that we put in the computer we can get out. As far as implementation, there's no doubt we're replacing every accounting system we have. The due date for financial is basically July 1. That's the date that they have –

2:14:03 Basically said that they agreed to it. It was part of the request and the proposal that they be done with the finances. HR will follow. Community development will follow. We can't do them all at once. It's a little too much. So what it looks like is we will be prepared to turn on the system by July 1, run parallel with our

2:14:26 Current Systems, what we have, until September 30th, and then turn off the old financial systems October 1. Now, we have to keep the old financial system regarding general ledger and everything up until the auditor is completed, and that normally takes until December. So that system will have to be left up in order to write reports or print reports or do inquiries. So the entire financial system being replaced.

2:14:53 And the old system turned off probably December 31st, 2015. But from that point, then the savings that I've talked about inside the memoranda of $33,000 less annually will be basically in place because we will no longer need the old systems by December 31. But again, we're replacing all systems. When you look at

2:15:20 And one of the questions that came up is how much time is it going to take to do it? Are we going to need part-time people? Because we are going to electronically convert the big files, which in this case is business license, 2,000 plus vendors. So business license, COTT bid, that has to be electronic transfer. Anything dealing with community development has to be electronic transfer. When you only have 63 full-time people year-round in payroll, I can enter that in one day.

2:15:49 I don't think this needs electronic conversion for something that small. As far as general ledger is concerned, because that's another big issue, we are in the process, I started Monday, rewriting the chart of accounts, because one of the things that is the problem is the current chart of accounts doesn't work well. It doesn't create good report. So I've been directed by the town manager to, as one of the three major tasks, that would be one of the three.

2:16:19 That I need to be rewriting the chart of accounts. He will approve it. We're hoping to have the budget software available to us by February, March, April, somewhere around there. Because when we get to July 1, we want to press the button and that new accounting structure along with a new budget will be implemented simultaneously at that point in time. But as far as accounts payable, accounts receivable, all these other applications, they're July 1.

2:16:48 But we hope to get the budgeting software up and running so I can implement the chart of accounts that's now being written right now. And we'll be good to go. This is an exciting thing for me to do. I enjoy doing this. I've done it before. And I believe this is what I was hired to do. Any questions?

2:17:10 I liked it. Through the process, we ended up having four different firms come in. We did the elements there. We actually had one firm withdraw, not meeting one of the requirements, and so Cassell was one of the stronger performers in that process. The attachments kind of walked through. You can see all the different elements that we're putting into the bid process. I wanted to highlight just two items real quick. One was

2:17:36 We will have some custom programming done on the TBID and TOT. All the agencies, I think we were unique in our pacing data and stuff we require. They're like, we don't see that anywhere else. So that is an additional one-time cost we'll need to have to be able to meet those requirements. The other piece that we had the most discussion over was the community development suite. That's on page three of the attachment.

2:18:02 Second group of page threes, I should say. Second half of the attachment. We have the timekeeping human resource in the community development suite. That is kind of a lateral move to where we're at today. So there were some concerns with that. Does it take us where we want to be in the future? Follow-up discussions with Cassell as I believe we can get there.

2:18:21 Actually working with them on some development timing this next year for a public portal and some other issues going into the community development side. If we're able to do that, that may have some additional cost in terms of some specialized programming for that public portal to the community development side. It already exists on the other side. So there's some elements there that we're working through to finalize up in the final proposal that may have a cost impact related to that work. We'll need to come back with that once it's finalized.

2:18:51 For that. Otherwise, I think it's overall we had a pretty good process in terms of looking at the different firms out there. They each have strengths and weaknesses. And at the end of the day, I think Castell brought the strongest overall package. None of them were absolutely perfect in everything, just the way the firms develop and the types of resources and requests that we've made. So with that, there's a staff recommendation there to move forward with that.

2:19:15 Pending that final review, and I did want to highlight the community development piece, if we need to come back, we'll come back with some additional funding in that area. And in case anybody's wondering, I have completed my review of these draft contracts. Software contracts are always a little bit complicated. They're always written to favor the vendor. They're never written to favor us or to be fair. So I'll be calling Cassell tomorrow and sending them a red line version. And there's nothing in here that I think is an insurmountable obstacle. We'll be able to get this done.

2:19:41 Just a quick comment. Exciting we're moving into the 21st century. Another thing that we've been working on since I got in council and that's been a priority to fix finance and get our reporting a little more real time than so delayed. I know it sit on MLT board that there's been a lot of improvements. I want to thank you and your reorganized team for working on that.

2:20:10 And just as far as with Cassell, when looking at everyone else, Dan, you've had some experience working with them too, so you kind of know their system a bit? Ten years. Ten years, that's good. Okay, so transition. Yes, I can run the report right or I can do all that. I can train everybody on that if I needed to. Great. Well, again, I just...

2:20:32 For us, knowing where we're at and being proactive instead of reactive, and this is going to help us get there, I think it's a great thing, and it's been a long time coming. Okay, questions of staff. A couple quick questions. What is the relationship of this system to our integration or reliance on the county IT? Is this completely standalone?

2:20:55 It's a standalone system this way where we will have connection points would be with their GIS database that the county maintains in that. We've looked at that connection point there and that goes back to the community development tie-in with the GIS side which they do maintain and comes off of the county databases and that's an ongoing issue on continuing to keep that updated, moving that forward. And will this be hosted on their servers, our servers locally or? It'll be hosted in-house. This is hosted on our server, yes. Okay.

2:21:25 And we have a goal and priority about working towards being a 21st century workforce, and I'm going to assume that this is a platform that's going to work to that end. You guys are confident about that? Yes. Okay. So overall purchase, around $181,000, is that right, cost? So do you have any sort of sense for, in developing this, you know, the community development suite,

2:21:55 It'll be probably $35,000 to $40,000 additional programming work. We'll need to nail that down. All right. You know, we're essentially looking at recouping our costs on this in about five years with the annual savings. Oh, I think it must be on that because of the efficiency. Sure. Yeah. Hard dollars and then soft dollars. Yeah, sure. The labor savings is huge. Yeah, I mean, even hard dollars in five years.

2:22:22 Just to provide some context, my friends at the town of Truckee recently bought similar software to do financing and community development stuff, and the package they went with cost $750,000. So this is a good deal. Are you saying scaled for us? Well, I think this is what the town can afford, but the numbers are a little eye-popping that it could be a couple hundred grand, but in the scheme of things and as compared to what similar cities are paying for this stuff, this is a lot less. And I think staff's been really diligent.

2:22:52 I'm trying to find an inexpensive way to do this. I think this is a long time coming, so I'm excited as well. Yeah, Dan and Dan, congratulations. Good job. We're almost there. Almost. But I guess my question is about the support that Cassell gives. Can you address that? As I said, I've been using them for approximately 10 years. I've never had them fail me.

2:23:20 When I ask a question, they normally respond within two hours. If it's a payroll question, it's within minutes because when you talk about payroll, people get mad. But no, I've never had a support issue with them in any way, shape, or form. Every time they say they're going to deliver, like July 1, they will have the programming change for TBID and TOT, they delivered. I've never had...

2:23:47 An issue with them from a support issue. I mean, it's never happened that I didn't get what I wanted, when I wanted it. And they'll be on site for a while. They'll be back and forth in terms of their project team. We'll be working, they'll be doing some stuff remotely, then they will. And we'll have to go to Provo to get some training and all that. Got it. That was another question that came from me. So what is the training associated with the purchase?

2:24:11 They have a training component here. We will have some cost elements where we're shipping staff back and we've actually kind of held it in the finance department's training budget for this particular project so we actually have some dollars to do that. Like you mentioned, they're out of the Salt Lake area, Provo, so it's not a...

2:24:29 Horrible summertime, right? That's when they're going to summertime. Yeah. It gives me a chance to visit my sister in Murray. She lives next to Love Salt Lake. Yes. Very good. If there are any more questions, I'll ask if there's any public comment on this. Okay, then I'll bring it back in. And I just want to say that...

2:24:57 You know, to actually have a transparent system that's usable, workable is just, yeah, this is huge. The one thing that I presume you will come back to us with is that once you've gotten this all finalized is to kind of timeline and if you are going to need extra staffing and things like that. It sounds like, well,

2:25:21 I've always joked with the old system is there's no reason to convert the data because everything had already been done in Excel spreadsheets anyway. A lot of it. I understand we have to keep the GL running, but to a certain degree there's really not a whole bunch of stuff to convert in that area. Yeah, and the data within BasicGov, we are trying to make that data as perfect as we can based upon the next ordinance change right here. So we intend to convert virtually everything out of BasicGov into the new system.

2:25:48 And that the ability for ad hoc reporting, I hate to tell you, but some of the agencies I worked for, we had that as early as the mid-90s. So we're just getting there. Sounds about right. Sounds about right, yes. So if there's not any other comments, I'll look for a motion. Let a mayor make a motion that counts, authorize the town manager to sign a purchase professional services contract with Cassell to purchase financial system software training setup and conversion for...

2:26:15 $140,645 with a 5% contingency amount of $7,032 and a $34,000 for customization of software for total amount of $181,677, subject to final legal review and authorize the town manager to amend the fiscal 2014-15 budget accordingly. Second.

2:26:37 Okay, we have a motion and a second, and if there's no further comment, roll call vote, please, Jamie.

2:26:43 Councilmember Ferney?

2:26:44 Yes.

2:26:45 Yes.

2:26:45 Councilmember Wood?

2:26:46 Yes.

2:26:47 Councilmember Wood?

2:26:48 Yes.

2:26:48 Councilmember Wood?

2:26:49 Yes.

2:26:49 Yes, motion passes 5-0.

2:26:51 Can't wait for July 1.

2:26:53 Yeah.

2:26:54 Again, great.

2:26:57 Great for bringing that forward.

2:26:59 So, next policy item has to do with urgent...

2:27:04 An urgency ordinance amending portions of our business license. If I may to kick that off, if I could have Andy touch on what the urgency ordinance means and why. I think that's an important element because we don't do them that often. Thank you for that, Dan. So usually if you're going to adopt an ordinance, it just requires a simple majority vote, three of you, and you do a first reading and then later at the following meeting you do the actual adoption and then it takes effect 30 days later.

2:27:31 State law says that there's another way you can adopt an ordinance. You can adopt an urgency ordinance. So if you can make findings indicating there's a need for something to take effect immediately for the immediate preservation of public health and safety, you can adopt it just with one reading. So you can adopt it tonight and it takes effect right away.

2:27:50 In this case, we have written some suggested findings into the ordinance and talking with Susan and with Dan and Dan. We think that the findings for the urgency can be made in this case. I think it's valid and legitimate. Susan can explain this better, but in a nutshell, the finance staff is about to send out a bunch of business license renewals. There are some existing flaws in our ordinances that Susan and Dan brought to my attention after they flagged them.

2:28:16 Our ordinances are internally inconsistent in some ways and don't provide us with some of the tools we need in other ways, which is what the ordinance is all about. So they can explain it better, but that's what an urgency ordinance is. The other little wrinkle about an urgency ordinance is that it does take a four-fifths vote to get it passed. So if two of you are having cold feet about this, then the council will not be adopting this tonight. All right. Thank you, Andy.

2:28:44 The urgency is created by basically on December 1st. We're supposed to send out 2,000 plus renewals for business tax licensing. We can't do it without this ordinance change. That's a significant issue to us. We are prepared to do it tomorrow, assuming that this is passed. That's really the biggest urgency. The second urgency is that we have followed the ordinance and we have canceled 23 TOT certificates.

2:29:12 Well, that still leaves the business license open. And again, that is a hole that we need to, you know, review and make corrections to. And I know that since I've been here, the council has been asking if there's any changes, bring them forward. If the process is wrong, bring them forward. And this is the opportunity to bring these three items. And I'm going to, she's my expert. There's no doubt that she's the accounting manager. She is in charge of all TOT.

2:29:41 Business licenses and TBID, and she can do the detailed explanation of why we're doing it. Good evening. I don't know how many questions you might have, so we're asking for three things. The first being that, as Dan mentioned, we were planning on sending out December 1st all of our renewals for business license certificates, but the inconsistency brought us up short.

2:30:07 We are going to send out something tomorrow. We're just not sure what it's going to be. It's either going to be the same thing and we'll deal with the inconsistency at a different time or if the council chooses to bring the ordinances into consistency this evening, we will be having our forms reflect that. The second item that we are requesting is that we...

2:30:31 Get direction from the council in terms of an ordinance change that allows us to concurrently cancel a business license certificate when we cancel the TOT certificate. We don't have that ability now. It's not too big of a deal right now at the end of the year because they're going to be expiring anyways, but in January we'll be canceling some more and we may have...

2:31:00 And the last item that we're asking for, and the reason why it is also urgent, is that we are

2:31:24 We will be mandated by our municipal code as staff not to renew any business license tax certificates that have delinquent taxes. And we will not be renewing anybody's business license certificate if they have outstanding taxes. But we'd also like to extend that to fees, which gives us the next step in what we can do with TBID collections as well as other fees that are outstanding.

2:31:51 Have sent out three notices on TOT delinquencies, and the fourth notice is we're canceling your certificate. We don't have a fourth notice for TBID. So, well, we do have a fourth notice. I send out another notice that says, this is your fourth notice, and I may be sending fifth notices out soon. But this will allow us to capture those folks that are just ignoring the TBID as well. And the urgency is, again, that

2:32:21 We will be getting their renewals in next month, and we need to know whether we can deny them or not. So if you have any questions, I'll be happy to answer. Questions? I have one, and it's just more or less to make sure everybody understands that the other change in here was an issue that came up over several years about smaller businesses with the revenues under $5,000.

2:32:48 In this piece, we're dealing with whether or not it says they have to have a tax certificate, but it isn't until we get to number 12 that we deal with the question of waiving the tax for those small ones. So we're bifurcating this at the moment. Just want to make sure everybody understood that. Actually, Madam Mayor, this one deals with whether, in this ordinance change, we're not proposing a tax? Correct. But it says to have the certificate. There will still be fees. And the inference is that there's a cost for that fee for the fee.

2:33:16 There are fees. We're talking about a zero tax, but there still will be fees. Your next item will deal with those fees. I meant to say fee, not tax. Well, our lawyer wants us to be very clear on what's fees and what's taxes. Right. Okay. No other questions of staffs? Any comments from the public? Martin. Yes, good evening again. A question about the $5,000 limit. Because I remember that the reason why it was imposed,

2:33:45 I think partially it had something to do with vendors coming into the area for one day or so like that. So if they still have to get a business tax registration because they're doing business here, they're not going to be getting, I mean, there's going to have to be a lot of education again to get, because that's what the whole problem was back then, because the fee for the tax permit, even in under $5,000, was, what, $50? $65. $55. So, I mean, it wasn't...

2:34:13 That major of a hurdle for some of these vendors that are coming here, they're paying for a spot and whatnot. The $50, I don't know if it was making or breaking the situation, but it was putting them out of compliance. So now we still have that potential of putting them out of compliance because they may not know that they have to, especially the return people that haven't been getting it for the last years, that the change was made. So if I can suggest, I think some of...

2:34:43 The other nearby cities, and I think what they do is they just charge a one-time fee for doing business here. So again, the proposal is, there are two things that a new business or any business has to pay, the taxes and the fees. This deals with taxes, and the proposal is that the tax remain at zero.

2:35:06 There would still be fees. The next item that the council will be considering is waiving those fees. So the total cost by the end of the evening hopefully will be zero. Right, but we're not talking about the cost. We're talking about whether, because with the $5,000 exemption, I don't believe that they had to go into the town office to get anything. Yeah, that was the conflict was there's a section of the code that said you have to do that. Another section of the code said you did it.

2:35:28 Okay, so what will be the results? So now we're saying you do have to have one. We'll need to work with them to get it through and to get the certificates out. Okay, so as I'm saying. Yeah, I understand that challenge. There's not a cost in them to do it, but there is an issue for us in terms of those types of short-term itinerant businesses. If you do do it once, you're good for the year. It's not a matter. You've got to come in. If you're in town two or three different times, you're still good for the year in terms of that total dollar amount. We have a lot of other existing small businesses.

2:35:57 Who are in compliant, not in compliance because the code is inconsistent. Right, right. That are here year round and that's one of our issues trying to address that. We understand the issue. There will be some folks that ultimately won't get a certificate. They don't know they have to. They're here for a weekend. They're gone. We'll need to work through that process as well. Okay. And I also, as far as delinquents taxes within the town, which I think I missed the page, but there was a statement in there that says,

2:36:27 You know, town delinquency tax, and then it said something about any tax, I'm assuming we're only talking about delinquency taxes and revoking a license is only for town due taxes. Correct. Yeah, owed to or collected by the town. He's added to the town. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay. What's the Treasury Council?

2:36:54 I'll make a motion. Okay. I would move that the council waive the reading and introduce and adopt by title only an urgency ordinance amending the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Sections 3.12.100, 5.04.360, and 5.08.010. That's my motion. Second.

2:37:16 We have a motion to second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. So now you know what you're writing. Thank you. Okay. Next we move on to our public hearings. The first being about the town's cable ordinance. Sorry, we'll open the public hearing.

2:37:43 And ask for a staff report. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I'll handle this one. Okay. This is sort of a cleanup of the town's existing cable ordinance. As we discussed briefly when the council was having its joint meeting with the Plemming County Development Commission, the state has taken away the town's oversight over cable franchises and cable television. That happened back in 2006.

2:38:06 And now that's all being handled by the state. So almost everything in the town's existing cable ordinance is irrelevant and unenforceable because it was written back in the days when we could do stuff about the cable franchisee, when we could impose service standards, when we could monitor things, we could take customer complaints, we could do a lot of stuff.

2:38:27 Now we can't do most of that, and the things that we can still do, we have to do a little bit differently. So what we're proposing to do tonight is scrapping all the stuff that we can enforce, that's just cluttering up the code, and instead replacing it with stuff that reflects the current state of the law. So one thing is that state law now allows the town to get, in addition to the 5% franchise fees, 5% of Southern Link's revenues, the town can also impose an additional 1% fee just to support the peg channel, public and governmental access channel.

2:38:56 Can't use it to support operations, but you can buy equipment with it. So that's something that we can do if you like. The state law also requires the town to adopt an ordinance to enforce the toothless and feeble customer service standards in the state law. You'll probably never do anything with those. Even if you did manage to impose a penalty on Suddenlink under the law, you'd have to give half of it to the state. I'm not aware of any city ever that's managed to...

2:39:25 Successfully penalize or fine a cable operator under the new law, but you're required to adopt those penalties. And we did also include some language in here about clarifying that the town does reserve the right to maintain control over how the right of way is used. The state law that took away your authority also gave cable companies the same rights as telephone companies, meaning that they have the right to use the right of way all over town.

2:39:53 But you still have the ability, the town still has the ability to kind of regulate that. So for example, when AT&T started rolling out its cable service, they wanted to put really, really big equipment boxes on a lot of street corners, and cities were able to say, no, that's not going to work, that's ugly, or it's blocking line of sight. And that's the kind of control of the right-of-way that the town wants to be able to maintain. So that's a long way of saying that this ordinance is intended to get rid of...

2:40:20 Things that you can't enforce, replace it with things that you can't enforce, and be ready to deal with sudden link as it shifts to a state franchise in January. All right, any questions of Andy? How does that 1% work? Well, it's just 1% of their gross revenues, and in every case that I'm aware of, it just gets passed through the customers. Passed through the customer, okay. So, yeah, there's no such thing as a free lunch. Somebody's going to end up paying, and it's going to be the customers. Right.

2:40:50 Most of them will actually have that on their bill stating that this is a paid pass-through fee and that that's collected by them and then remitted to the town. So does that give us the opportunity since whatever the channel number is these days?

2:41:05 Since most of what it is is a duplicate of what's on Granicus, does it give us an opportunity to update how we're capturing? Yeah, basically you can come in and do a lot of the camera work, the upstairs computer work. It's for capital equipment only. You can't use operations, but we can utilize it to upgrade our systems and have additional facilities for those types of programming to be developed in the community. Who establishes the value of the revenues of Southern Lakes revenues and what do you think the value of this 1%?

2:41:34 I do not know off the top of my head it comes from that. I'd have to look at what we're actually collecting on the 5% and you could make the assumption it's going to be one-fifth of that. And they actually do it. If we don't like it, we actually have provisions. We can go audit that. I think I've only, like, one place where that's happened. It's pretty rare. The cable company will provide us with their numbers. It's pretty solid. In my experience, I have not known those numbers to be inaccurate.

2:42:05 Okay. And so, but for point of reference, the 5% currently annually is about what? I do not recall off the top of my head. I'd have to look it up. Okay. So the 5% will stay in effect and there will be an additional 1%. We can get those numbers for you and provide it out. Okay. Any other questions to staff? I'll ask if there's any testimony anyone wants to make. I'll close the public hearing. I'll bring it back for deliberation or decision by council.

2:42:34 May I like to make a motion that Council waive the reading introduced by title only in ordinance repealing and readopting Chapter 5.32 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code pertaining to regulation of cable television services. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

2:43:00 That takes us to our second public hearing regarding finance and building department fees. So I will open the public hearing and ask for presentation from staff. Thank you, Madam Mayor. This item was generated from a couple of areas, one being the urgency ordinance that was previously discussed by council and the impact on the ongoing finance charging for fees for small businesses.

2:43:28 Building component has a couple of changes. One, dealing with, I'll say, unintended consequence from the building fee update we did and also implementing a state fee for a SIP fee, strong motion improvement program to actually reflect what the state charges. Whether you change the fee or not, that's still what we have to collect and pass through back to the state. But having it in our fee ordinance is important.

2:43:56 The other one was putting language in the building element relating to the public art fee. And this one really came out of questions from the community going, why don't you have that fee in your fee resolution? Well, because it's sitting in a town ordinance, and okay, for transparency and for information, let's put it into the fee schedule so it's there and people can see it. So it's no change to the fee, it's just another location of it so people know what it is.

2:44:25 With that, in the resolution, there's an attachment that deals with the finance fees, and we've kind of highlighted each of those fees, and I'm sorry for the small print, so the elements there would be each of those charges that these small businesses would be required to pay underneath the change in the ordinance, this would exempt them from having to pay that fee, so there's no net cost change to those businesses.

2:44:56 The archival fee in the building program, the changes there was before we had it all submitted items up to 8.5 up to 11 by 17 would be a $25 charge. What we had was we'd have somebody come in with one page of the larger sheet or two pages and have to pay a $300 fee and that was not the intent.

2:45:22 of the change that used to be based on percent of value which also didn't relate back to cost. We believe by allowing up to 10 pages of larger sheets and if you go over that to have the larger fee is more reflective of what we're actually seeing come in and also reflective of the staff costs related to archiving these materials and keeping them within our systems to do that. The Strong Motion Instrument Program, there's some additional information from the state that

2:45:50 Outlines these elements there so you really have frankly no choice on those fees so we may as well make our fee resolution reflective of what's actually charged there. The document fee will actually end up in a reduction of what some folks are paying, legitimately so, and same with the resolution changing the finance fee that's actually a reduction or maintaining a zero fee element.

2:46:18 I can particularly talk to any of the other elements here in questions if you need for those elements. I do want to note we did the public hearing because we're changing fees. If you're actually increasing fees, we would do a 10-day notice. The fact that where you're not increasing fees that we have any control over, it's here as presented, partly driven by the ordinance that came forward recently, very recently, like 10 minutes ago.

2:46:46 To be able to keep ourselves consistent through this process. Okay. Any questions of staff? Just one question. What is a card room application fee? Which one? Card room application fee. We don't have any card rooms in town, but they can come in and they can be allowed within certain ports and so you could have a card room in the... So it's a state... Here you go, John. It's an allowed element. Just fishing around.

2:47:17 Always looking for opportunity. Good. Card rooms. Johnny's card room. That's right. Okay. If there are no questions of staff, I'll ask if there's any testimony. Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing and bring it back to council. May I move the council approve the resolution to amend the town's fee resolution 14-26.

2:47:45 And 14-32 for certain finance and building division fees. Second. All right. We have a motion to be seconded. We'll call those. Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And with that, we will return to our next regular meeting on Wednesday, December 17th. Thank you, Madam Mayor. All right. All right. That's a long one.

2:48:15 They're sleeping. They're sleeping. They're sleeping.