TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2010

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 31 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

551 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Yeah, so how do you want to do at this point?

0:22 Thank you.

0:54 You know, I just want to give you a heads up for 15, 20 minutes. I don't want to surprise you. You know, when you were doing that, you know, I thought it was in March. What would be the first thing to do? I wouldn't say anything. Oh, my God. You look at the channel that Ivana has grown up.

1:18 I'll go ahead and call the town council special meeting for Wednesday, July 7th to order.

1:46 Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Bacon? Here. Councilmember Harvey? Here. Councilmember Harvey? Here. Councilmember Kirsten Damara? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Eastman? Here. Mayor McCarrow? Here, but almost gone. Before we get started, I just want to briefly say that Skip missed the last meeting, and I was in the process of moving my offices to, I have a little home office now, and my DSL and my email was down, and

2:15 But Skip actually emailed me and said that he would be unable to make the meeting. So he was not AWOL last week. For the record. Item number one, adopt resolution reciting the fact that the general municipal election law held on June 8, 2010, and declaring the result in such other matters as provided by law. Jamie? Three people won.

2:47 Okay, is there any council discussion? Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion that we adopt the resolution as stated in our agenda packet. A second. A motion and a second. The roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Sugimura? Yes. Mayor Colton Eason? Yes. Mayor McCarroll? Yes. And congratulations, Rick and Matt and John. Thank you.

3:20 Item number two is administration of oath of office to newly elected council members. If you'll step in front of the dais, please. Against all enemies born in domestic. Against all enemies born in domestic. That I will bear true faith and allegiance. True faith and allegiance. To the Constitution of the United States. To the Constitution of the United States. And the Constitution of the State of California. And the Constitution of the State of California. That I take this obligation freely.

4:23 That I take this obligation freely. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. Without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties. And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties. Upon which I am about to enter. Upon which I am about to enter.

5:02 Do they at least get to take their name checks? You know, before we go much further, I would like to ask both Wendy and Neil to come forward for just a moment, please. From the town of Mammoth Lakes, this one's to Wendy Sugimura, Councilmember, Public Servant, and Keeper of the Public Trust, 2006 through 2010. Thank you, Wendy. Thank you.

7:44 Likewise, we have the similar plaque with the same thing on it for Neil. And Neil, I'm not going to give you a hug. Taking advantage, if I may, of running the meeting at this time and also of taking a look at the certification of the countywide

8:29 Clerk and Registrar of Voters results of the election. As most of you know, I've spent some time trying to move up this process and to get the voting in the last election, which was June 8th, certified so that this council that's up here today could get started and move things forward, in particular with our budget for the town of Mammoth Lakes. The certification of the election results, bless her heart, by the Registrar of Voters,

9:02 Linda Roberts in Bridgeport was certified on the 23rd of June. Is that correct? Okay. That's what the paperwork said. Today's the 7th of July. That's two weeks later after the results were certified. This is official. So my frustration is that this new council was duly elected by the community and was not seated until two weeks after the certification of the election results.

9:31 So I would hope that the Town Council could agendize this issue at our next meeting. I would hope also that the two members of the Town Council that are sitting or will participate with the Mona County Board of Supervisors will also agendize this issue at their next meeting, subcommittee meeting, and that this be discussed to see if in the future, each time we have an election every two years,

10:00 That the election results can be moved up at least a week and hopefully two weeks prior to what we went through this time, which was a full month. So if I can have those agendas. John, let me just add something to that, that it had to be approved by the Board of Supervisors as well, and I understand that their meeting was yesterday. I understand that as well, but as a practical matter for those in the public sector, as opposed to the private sector, have...

10:30 Desires to get things done as soon as we can. And there's not a reason in the world that the Board of Supervisors and the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes could not have agendized special meetings as early as two weeks ago to move this process forward a full two weeks. Having said that, we'd like to move the Council reorganization forward. And our next step will be to select both the Mayor and the Mayor Pro Tem for the Town of Mammoth Lakes.

11:04 In the natural process and under current policy of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council, I would be next in line as the Mayor. Skip Harvey would be next in line as the Mayor Pro Tem. I would like to defer if I have support from the Town Council because as the second vote-getter in this last selection, I would come up as the Mayor four years from now in my final year on the Town Council. By myself deferring in

11:33 It will mean a number of things to me personally, but it will also provide the ability for Jo Bacon in her fourth year as a council member to be the mayor and give her the opportunity to run the town council for that year and her fourth and final year on the council. So if I have council support tonight, I would like to move that the next mayor of the town of Mammoth Lakes be Skip Harvey. Second. Discussion? Mr.

12:07 Mayor Pro Tem. I'm honored that you have considered to do this and I am honored to represent our town as mayor. I only ask that we also agendize for an upcoming meeting, a discussion about how the mayor is selected and the process that we use so that we can possibly look and see if it is really configured to best

12:36 serve each of the members and the people might know in advance a little bit more of who will be in the next seat. So if we could just agendize that, review that ordinance and see if it needs to be tweaked a little bit, I accept. I would concur. Under discussion, we need to adopt the ordinance because as it stands right now,

12:59 Four of the next six mayors would be elected after their term was over. So there is something wrong in the calculations. So we have support for agendizing that when appropriate. Thank you, Skip. We'll call for the question. Those in favor? Aye. Against? And we have a 5-0 vote for Skip Harvey as our next mayor for Mammoth Lakes. Can I do it from this seat over here? Can I just sit in the corner and...

13:31 Why don't you stay there for just a second and we'll do the Mayor Pro Tem and then we'll do the seating. Mr. Mayor, I would nominate Joe Bacon as Mayor Pro Tem. Second. All in favor? That's right, I'm Mayor. All in favor? Aye. All opposed? Motion passes 5-0. And we will now begin to move seats. Where am I going? What I would like is, Joe, you can always be there. To the right of you, right? Correct.

14:09 John, would you like to move where Rick is? That seems to be where we're used to seeing you. Okay. And Matt, if you want to... Rick, if you'll be on the end down here, then we'll put Matt between us. Yes, right there. Oh, really? No, before you sit down here. I hope it doesn't find good. Oh, thank you, Joe. The imaginary part. Oh, we did it a little out of order. I'm sorry, Skip. We're done till 530? Yeah, we're done till 530? Yeah, I think we should adjourn.

15:50 Okay. Give us a chance to organize. My first official. Actually, I've got to adjourn this meeting until 5.30. At this time, I would like to call to order the 5.30 study session, the workshop, to discuss the following schedule and steps for review and approval of the budget, public finance framework issues, and the TOT revenue considerations. But, um,

16:30 I know that this has been a topic throughout our community, and there has been a lot of concern from community members about the process that we're going through with this, so I think before we get into the actual study session, I would like to ask if any of the council members would like to make any comments regarding this study session, this issue, and or the direction that we are moving with this. Mr. Mayor, I do, if I may.

17:01 I don't know if it's appropriate at this time, but what I wanted to do at the outset of our discussion tonight, which seems like a scheduling discussion, as well as the substantive discussions to come, is to provide Council with some additional thoughts as to where I'm coming from. And they really fall on the heels of the comments that I made at the last meeting in which I spoke about the anger and resentment in the community.

17:31 Thank you very much. Thank you very much.

18:00 Interestingly enough, a survey was taken of employed workers, and just four highlights are that 28% of those surveyed, and this was done by the Pew Research Center, which is one of the nationally recognized polling or survey companies, 28% of employees reported that they were experiencing work hours reductions.

18:30 23% have experienced, since the recession, pay cuts. 12% have been required to take unpaid leave. 11% have been forced to switch to part-time. It's not my intention to make specific proposals or suggestions with respect to what we do about our staffing levels. Quite frankly, I think that's a level of detail that Council should not become involved in. But I have to tell you,

19:00 It was remarkable in the next morning when I read this that it was so consistent with what has fueled my concern about the manner in which we are spending our money and in particular supports my view that we need to adopt an austerity budget. So that's not exactly process related which is what we're doing today but I wanted the council to know what it is that is fueling the concerns that I'm going to be raising

19:28 In the budget hearings and workshops to come over this next month. Thanks. I was actually going to follow up on something very similar to that. One item I would like to discuss is, you know, that I don't see on our budget schedule really is discussions on staffing levels and salary levels and whatnot. And I understand that that may not be something that council gets directly involved in all the time.

20:01 But I just hope that at some point we can actually add that on there. Maybe it's in there. It's just not incorporating something I saw. If I could just briefly respond to those two comments. When we get to discussing the budget schedule, we're going to propose a couple of changes. One of those changes is to have a closed session in conjunction with our workshop on the 19th on employee relations. So I think those, obviously, those kinds of matters need to be discussed in closed session. And so we recognize that in

20:30 We'll accommodate that in the schedule. Okay. I didn't know when to actually request that, so I was not as close to sending it. That was as good as any time. Yeah, so. John, is there anything, any thought to you? I have nothing, Skip. Thank you. No, thank you. One of the things that has kind of concerned me is that there's a discussion going on, and has been for a while, about the budget format itself. And it seems to me that it's going to be hard for us to have a discussion

21:01 about the budget, about scheduling, about approving a budget, frameworks, even making policy decisions if we don't have a process or a budget format that is clearly understood not only by ourselves but by the community that is looking for some simplicity in this process. And I'm wondering what the other council members might feel about maybe tackling

21:30 I know we have some members of the community that have volunteered to tackle that for us, even presented a contract to us, I think, for a very reasonable rate. We might have other members who are interested in serving on this committee, and would it be more efficient for us to have that committee convene and work on restructuring how our budget is presented before we get into

21:59 too deep of discussion about the budget knowing that we can approve or carry over the current budget to keep our town running until which time this committee brings back information for us about how the budget format will be handled. Skip, I totally agree with you that we're still working towards a better budget format.

22:21 I have two concerns. If we're truly looking at an austerity budget, last year's budget is probably more. And so I'm not comfortable with carrying over a higher amount for any long period of time. I think that, at least in my discussions with Deb, and I will not speak for her, but she has indicated that they're really looking for something that would affect next year's budget with a planning process that started in January. So that, and her most recent

22:50 Letters said that, that they were saying that we understand that, that there's ways to get through and make this one clear verbally without totally stopping and get ourselves moving forward. And I do see, as Rick has said, we're looking at a smaller budget and so just rolling over what we had concerns me. Would it be possible to implement a budget with perhaps a lower revenue base?

23:22 And work off of that. And I just don't know how aggressive, and I would like to maybe hear from some of the public on their thoughts on this, only because if we could implement a new budget, could it be done extremely aggressive where we could in fact get it done in three months or not? That may be optimistic. Well, also I want to remind everybody that this is agendized on the regular meeting as number four. So maybe we can...

23:48 This is such a jam-packed. I didn't think we would get through everything that was on this study session in half an hour anyway. Just suggest that we hold that until we get to number four. Because I think it's going to be a combination of things, and I definitely want to take advantage of the offer. But we just have to figure out how to make that happen. I agree. I think we'll have the opportunity during the regular meeting to do that. But I concur with you, Skip, that we need to

24:18 Focus on format and presentation. I think we – I think Deb Perel has really provided some valuable input and is reflective of what a lot of people in the community are thinking about the way this thing ought to be approached this year, which is different from the past. Okay. I just want to – I just kind of wanted to get everybody's feeling on that before we get too far into this. With that, what I would like to do is, at this point, we're limited in time. You're off. What is your report?

24:49 Is it lengthy? We have three things, and I don't think we have to accomplish them all today. They could be deferred to the budget study session on the 19th. The first thing is deciding on the schedule, and you've been presented with the draft schedule, and as I mentioned earlier, we've suggested some changes to that, which are to add to the session on the 19th a general discussion of things that are in the budget outside of the budget policy decisions,

25:19 And then also to have the closed sessions that I referred to. So one thing we want to do tonight is get your input on that schedule and make sure it's the schedule that you want to follow. Then I have about 10 slides that relate to the longer term financial framework that I think might be helpful as we go forward. And then if we have time, we can also talk about the TOT revenue estimate. Or if we don't, we can continue that to the 19th. So I'd like to start, if we could, with the schedule,

25:50 And everything on that's fine with me. My only comment is if we could try to get some times on the meetings. We've got the dates. We just need the times. Unless otherwise preferred, we'd say 6 o'clock on those days. 6? 6 o'clock, yes. Is there any willingness for council members and staff to change that 6 o'clock to 5 o'clock? That's fine. Sure. John, I'm...

26:16 I'm in trial that week in Bishop and will not be available until 6. Okay. Unless I can settle it. That's fine. And I would recommend that it not be scheduled as like 6 to 8. It just says 6 o'clock so that we don't feel like we're up against the time frame. And also, I would request that we move the Wednesday, July 28th to the 29th for the personal reason that I'm already missing two of the Felici Trio concerts because of council meetings. And I'd really like to get to some of them.

26:47 29th is fine. Thursday the 29th instead of Wednesday the 28th. And that would be a 6 o'clock also? So we are in agreement that all of the meetings the 19th, 21st, 29th, and the 4th will be at 6 o'clock. I just got this handout for this today.

27:26 And I'd like to look at it. Does it make sense for us to move into TO2 revenue considerations and do the third one before the second one? Does that make any difference? Fine. Okay. Thank you. Yes, Mr. Carlton. If we're not talking about specific employees, I'm not sure about why we would have all these personnel discussions in closed session. Shouldn't some of these personnel discussions be open to the public? The town attorney, I think, can probably...

28:03 Answer that question for you. Personnel discussions in closed session. Well, certainly labor negotiations can be done in closed session. I don't think we're talking about labor negotiations. We're talking about staffing levels, and we're not talking about specific people. I don't know the answer to that because I don't know what they're going to talk about. Well, you guys could go into closed session if they got there, but I think that the public would like to know. As we get into those agendas and into those meetings,

28:36 I think the council can make a determination as to how they want to structure that meeting and that discussion so that I do understand that we cannot talk about specific individual employees or specific positions even in our discussions in public because of contract issues. But if the council members have a suggestion and they want to bring some of it into the public in a manner that's acceptable, we can deal with that at that time.

29:09 Comments? No. I don't have a problem with that. I mean, if we, I just think if we went in closed session first, I would like to get at least some feedback from staff before we open up a, you know, potential can of worms. I, you know, I want to get something. Yeah. Actually, Matt, as being the one remaining member of the previous budget subcommittee, Rob and I talked about it. You'll notice there, I believe there were going to be two closed sessions so that the first one could be preliminary and then the second one might actually get into those details.

29:39 Okay. Because it is a pretty big issue. Right. But the first one I believe on the 19th would not be the only one. Well, I imagine not. You know, my comments are we only hire two people. I hope not to micromanage anything in these four years. We'll wind up micromanaging some things, but I hope not right out of the box to micromanage that issue. If the issue is

30:08 A restructuring of government, which is a discussion of positions, and that's something that the council feels it ought to be managing, then it seems to me that needs to be public. But I don't know what's coming. I don't know what's coming in closed session. I think we wait and see. I'm sensitive to the fact that that which ought to be in open session will be in open session, and that which is

30:37 Required by law to be in closed session should be. I just don't know what it is yet. I'm not really interested in going down a list of 102 employees and telling everybody who I think should stay and who should leave. I don't think I would either. I think the only question that arises is, you know, we've gone down a number of policy items where we are shifting a lot of our funds to

31:04 One area, and we have to, in some fashion or another, I think the discussion is ultimately going to come up, how we're going to pay for it. So, Mr. Mayor, in an effort to try to move this forward, and I see at least one person in the audience, maybe a number of people in the audience that would like to speak, I believe, to finance framework issues. Am I correct? We took that number two instead of number three.

31:30 Or took B instead of C. Number three is the TOT projection. And number two is the public finance framework. We can do either one further. Are there people in the audience that would like to speak to public finance framework issues? If not, I won't worry about it. Number four. Number four then. Okay. I just wanted to make sure there wasn't anybody who was here. Yeah. And I'd just like to clarify on the schedule, Rob. I had on my notes that there was also going to be a closed session on the 29th, but I did

32:03 I did not see that on your listing. Yeah, I think we should add that there. You're correct. Okay, time is running. Time is running. So now are we back down to the TOT revenue considering and discuss that? Thank you. At the June 30th budget workshop, the Town Council asked for a variety of different types of information that relate to TOT projections. And so what we've provided is some information about national projections from STS, which is

32:41 One of the paramount experts in the hospitality industry. Information about historical trends and the trend line. A very brief discussion about snow conditions. A discussion about the impact of air service on the success that we had this year and may have next year. A discussion of MMSA marketing efforts which are vastly improved and should have a positive impact on an ongoing basis.

33:11 Information about the projections that Snow Creek and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area are making, which is basically assuming a flat performance next year as we have in our budget, but then hoping for something better. And then a proposal to fully fund the REU. And the reason for that is that if the REU is fully funded,

33:39 One of its main purposes is to provide a backstop in the event of a bad snow year. And so to some degree, having a fully funded REU, if that's the direction the Council goes, would mitigate risk. So we're glad to answer any questions. And otherwise, we would pass the baton back to you, Mayor. Thank you. Comments from Council. John? My input is that

34:10 I'm not interested in national projections where a ski resort in the distance here, I think we're different than that. Historical trends and trendline, snow conditions, don't know what those are going to be. I do think that commercial air service is important, Mammoth Mountain ski area marketing. On the REU, I would like to mention that in addition, the REU, it says here that it was

34:41 It was primarily created to address fluctuation and snowfall. The most recent use of the REU to the tune of about $1.5 million was not for fluctuations and snowfall, but it was for the airport lawsuit, payment of the attorney fees for that. So I'm just saying that it was created for other reasons than just fluctuations and snowfall.

35:10 We've adopted a plan to bring the REU up to 25%. If that plan is adopted, it obviates the need to be overly conservative in revenues. I would submit that if we have an excess, a surplus of revenues this year, which have been identified roughly $800,000 either side, plus the surplus of the $900,000

35:42 That is the surplus on the utility user tax that we're going to see in this next year. That's about $1.8 million. And if we can't increase the reserve for economic uncertainty in those type of conditions when both of those numbers are one-time occurrences, then I would really like to see what this plan is and what the time frame is on the plan.

36:19 So are you asking that we review how we would bring the REU up to the 25%? Absolutely. Okay. So if you turn to page 9 of the packet that we passed out, that page illustrates the proposal that Brad has put together, and I'll ask him to briefly review that for you. So starting with the current REU balance of almost $2.9 million, the

36:54 Addition of surplus revenue from fiscal year 910 of $252,000, allowing the leave liability funding to decrease to 85% is the $307,000, and you might recall that was a, that's a policy decision before you to fund that or to not, and one of the comments was to put it to the REU. Fiscal year 1011 proposed budget, the proposed budget has offered a $288,000,

37:24 And please correct me if I'm wrong, Brad, but at least three of those

37:51 Five areas to fund the REU. At least three of the five are by definition reserve funds in and of themselves, so I would submit that it's likely that we're robbing Peter to pay Paul, robbing three, in this instance, three reserve funds to put money into another reserve fund. The two items to allow the leave liability to decrease, that's a type of reserve. The releasing of the bank held money

38:22 Wasn't a reserve in the town control, so it would be coming to the town fresh and new. How about leave liability? Right, the leave liability. Is a reserve? Is a reserve. Thank you. So two instead of three of the five are taking money, half a million dollars, 600,000 from one reserve fund to another? On the proposed budget increase, is that assuming that we go with the 17-8? Is that...

38:57 Is that what that's assuming there? The proposed budget of the, or let me back up, the bank held release of the trust funds is a total of $577,000. The proposed budget had half of that going to the REU and half of that going to fund services. If that whole amount came to the REU, that's why you see the two turning 885s. I think the question was, does this

39:24 Present a plan to fund 25% of 17.8 million, which is the proposed budget. Yes. Brad, if I may, I don't understand the two references to leave liability, one down to 85 and one to 74, is the additional $299,000, the 11, just the 11% of the difference? Correct. Okay. And then, Rob, I had a question as well. Let me go back to the...

39:51 The agenda bill or the notes and that is when you speak of the projections from Snow Creek and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area specifically you say they recommended that we budget flat with the current year. Can you explain what you mean by that? Both Snow Creek and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area are planning to budget next year to get the same amount of money that they actually received this year. Okay.

40:21 Which is essentially the same thing that's in the proposed budget. Were any other people surveyed or entities? No, I haven't surveyed anybody other than those two. How does that relate to the 90% trendline approach? The proposed budget is 90% of the trendline. So carrying over budgeting next year equal to what we actually received this year is 90% of the trendline. Is that just coincidence?

40:58 Yeah. But 90% and going, I'm sorry, go ahead. Going back to Matthew's question, Matthew asked if the number is, what, 17.8? Right. And last year the number was 16.3. So it's a million and a half increase. Am I correct, Jo? Well, I was just, thank you for opening up the fact that we're throwing all these numbers around. I think the only way we're going to be able to do what ifs as we go through this is

41:31 is see some kind of a live spreadsheet that, well, what if we reduce here and increase expenditures there as we go through the rest of this process because otherwise we start throwing numbers and nobody knew where they came from. We don't even know, as Matt said, 25% of what at this point would be the budget versus the REU. So I think we definitely need to have some kind of a live spreadsheet projected so everybody can see as we make these decisions what impact does it have.

42:01 I agree with John on taking from one savings reserve to another doesn't make any sense, but before I could say yes to any of these other things, we have to talk about what was that expected to fund, is that still a priority, and how else would we fund it? So I hope staff can come up with some kind of a live way to represent the dollar figures as we make decisions in the next few weeks. We do have that.

42:30 And we can bring it to the next, to the budget session on the 19th. From the council. I'd just like to go back to what John said. I mean, it may be 90% of the trend line, but that trend line incorporates some revenues that are non-recurring, I believe. Isn't that correct? The proposed budget was based on actual TOTs received in the most recent 12-month period. So that's what the budget is based on. Taking that number,

43:05 And then saying, if we had used the trend line, what would that have meant? And that would have meant it would have been 90% of the trend line. But no, there is not one-time revenue in the TOT. It's based on actual activity for all the hotels, lodges, everybody over the last 10 years. Okay, thank you. If there are no other comments from Council, is there anyone in the public that wants to speak on the TOT revenue consider? Then are we...

43:42 Going to go back up to A, and we approved our schedule, so we're all good with that. Am I correct? And B, the public finance framework issue. Are we discussing that item number four? There's a ten-slide presentation, which I can either do now or at some other time at your convenience. It depends how much time you want to spend right now. Can you do it in five to ten minutes? I'll do my best. Okay. So this...

44:18 This slide show addresses some longer term financial issues that I think are important to put on the table now because they may impact decisions that you make. When I do the slide show, I'm not presenting a final conclusion. I'm just throwing out ideas and throwing out issues that need to be addressed. So the question that I'm presenting is how can we do a number of things. Number one, how can we build facilities without burdening development? How can we double the marketing budget?

44:48 How can we extend air service to Las Vegas, Phoenix, Orange County, and other places? And how can we effectively invest in new trails and recreation facilities? And the point that we're making is that the general fund doesn't have the resources, even over the long term, to address all of these things. And we're going to provide some examples of how other communities have approached these issues. So first of all, in the last year, the Community Facilities Funding Committee, the CFFC,

45:19 Completely revamped our development impact fees. And part of the recommendation they made is that the town, over time, increase the amount of TOT that goes to capital facilities. And that's a very important piece of the plan. So basically what's happening is that rather than relying as much as we were on private sector developers to fund our capital facilities, they're recommending that we rely more on ourselves. And so this chart's showing

45:49 Right now we dedicate a half of a percent or 500,000 roughly from the TOT to capital facilities. They're recommending that we build that up to 2%. And what that does is it kind of takes all the air out of the room. It doesn't leave a whole lot of room for other investments. I think what will happen is rather than adding back positions that have been taken away, we'll add back capital expenditures. So I think we can do what the CFFC is recommending, but I think it will make it hard to do some of the other things.

46:20 The second issue was how do we double the marketing budget. Marketing in most resorts is a public-private partnership, not just a public effort. A portion of the DMO budget in other resorts comes from the municipality, almost in all cases, but a portion comes from other sources. Based on the council direction at the last meeting, we're starting to survey other communities. The lower portion of those bars shows the amount that the towns or cities are

46:51 Providing to their DMOs and their Chambers of Commerce for marketing purposes. And then the upper portion of the bar shows the portion that is coming from other sources. And so as you'll see, we're actually fairly high compared to the ones that we've surveyed so far. And others still are providing very significant amounts to their DMOs. But you'll see that also at least three of them, four of them actually, have other sources that bring a lot more money to the table.

47:20 In fact, in the case of South Lake Tahoe, the city doesn't provide anything, and all of it's provided from other sources. So I think going forward, that's something we'll have to look at in terms of how we increase our marketing budget. Air service funding is an ongoing expense in a number of different resorts, and Kent Myers, the air service consultant to the mountain, provided information to us about how that's handled. So in Crested Butte,

47:51 Vail spelled incorrectly, Steamboat, and Jackson Hole. It's true that the ski area contributes to the air guarantees, but it's also true that other sources such as sales tax increments, non-profit alliances of the business community come into play. And it's very interesting to me that the amount of money that's invested by these other resorts in keeping air service going and expanding it

48:21 Is, you know, in the 1.5 to 1.8 million dollar range. So it's a lot of money. In talking with the mountain, we have discussed a little bit the need to have some other entity or some other structure in the town of Mammoth Lakes to support air service on an ongoing basis that maybe is modeled after what we've seen in other communities. In the piece that I passed out to you last week that you didn't have a chance to read before you acted on,

48:52 I suggested that there are other ways to look at funding recreation facilities, and in particular the idea of issuing a COP. And in this particular example, which is not a recommendation, just an example of how it could be done, I'm trying to show that we have the resources to issue a fairly significant COP at this point in time, and that we can for sure leverage it with private donations and with Forest Service contributions to get even more.

49:22 This is something that you have asked us to look at further, and I'm working with MLTPA who would lead a process to investigate what is the best way to use the resources we have to invest in our recreation facilities. So in looking at recreation funding, we need to cover planning, we need to cover construction, we need to cover maintenance, and we need to cover programming. In the discussion that MLTPA leads,

49:53 We'll be talking about all of these elements and making sure that we don't put all our money into the COP bucket and not have money for maintenance or programming. And so it's important to cover all those bases. And I've put examples up of places where the money could potentially come from. But again, this is a discussion, not a conclusion or a recommendation. So the conclusion is that we do need to discuss these ideas further, that building our facilities

50:25 Without burdening development, continues to be an issue. We need to come up with a plan to double our marketing budget. We need to extend air service to other destinations on an ongoing basis. And we need to have an aggressive program and have the opportunity to have an aggressive program to advance our recreation programs. So I really just wanted to put those ideas on the table because I think they may help when you discuss some of the current year budget issues. And that concludes my presentation. Thank you, Rob. Questions from council?

50:55 Okay, with about two minutes left, is there anyone in the public that would like to make any further comments regarding our budget discussion in our workshop tonight? I think the answer is that we want to, I think this council intends to discuss employee issues and staffing levels and issues in public as much as we possibly can, given the

51:26 The legalities that we face with contracts and legal issues with staffing. I don't think our intention is to try to hide anything in that nature, but we do have to respect and abide by the laws that we have with our employee groups. So I think we'll do our best to get as much information out in front of the public as we can when it comes to the restructuring and staffing levels. Let's see.

51:54 That's the best we can do in some respects. It's not the private sector, you know, that we can, we have things, we're tied by law, so that's the best we can do. I would like to just make one comment, and I'm not sure as we talk about restructuring, I understand not wanting to micromanage our town, but I do know that a governed law, towns that are considered general law have two methods of operating.

52:25 One is managerial and the other is administrative. And I would like to at least have a discussion about the pros and cons of those two forms of government as we talk about restructuring, if we could include that as one of our topics for our workshops, if no one objects. Thank you. With that, we will close the workshop and we will reconvene at 6.15 for our regularly scheduled meeting. This is...

53:25 A regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, July 7, 2010. We'll call Jamie. Councilmember Eastman. Here. Councilmember Blayman. Here. Councilmember Wood. Here. Mayor Patent Bacon. Here. Mayor Hart. Here. Would everyone please rise and join me in the pledge to our flag? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands

53:55 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Now is the time that we will have public comment. If there is anything that is not on tonight's agenda that someone would like to bring up, this is the moment that you may do it. John? Good evening, members of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council, and to you new faces, congratulations on elections well run. I'm looking forward to work with you on a variety of different subjects and topics.

54:32 I would like to read something and hand you, I'll hand you a document first and read from it. This is following up on something that Rob was talking about a little bit with recreation. So I'll hand this thing out and come back and read it. Oh, you got it. No, thank you. Yes, ma'am. The Mammoth Lakes Trailers and Public Access Foundation, MLTPA, proposes to convene a process to benefit the community of Mammoth Lakes and those agencies, commissions, stakeholders, and user groups with an interest in recreation in the Mammoth Lakes region.

55:25 This facilitated process will work to articulate a vision for recreation in Mammoth Lakes and a strategic plan for its implementation. This process is consistent with the recreation vision and policy development document attached to this as previously submitted to the Town Council. It is anticipated that this process will benefit interagency collaboration, direct the development of recreation infrastructure in the region, and may be used to inform the strategic implementation of both measures R and U. MLTPA appreciates the need for this process to get underway in a timely manner

55:55 And to have work completed expeditiously. With this in mind, MLTPA is setting a project timeline goal of approximately three months. MLTPA has a documented history of convening such efforts, including the Strategic Conference and Public Meeting in 2006, Camp Summer in 2007, Camp Winter in 2008, both camp efforts being part of the update to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Master Plan that MLTPA successfully initiated that is now being prepared for final adoption by the town. Most recently, MLTPA was recognized for its role in convening the Sherman's Working Group

56:24 Group's final deliverable, the Sherman Area Recreation Plan. MLTPA will be contacting representatives of agencies, commissions, stakeholders, private citizens, and user groups over the next several weeks to advise on the structure and timing of the program and to solicit participation. We at MLTPA are very much looking forward to this opportunity, to the benefits it may bring to the community of Mammoth Lakes, and to the unique recreation opportunities of the Mammoth Lakes region. And I will come back this evening at the end of your meeting

56:52 There's an agenda item that has to do with the assignment of Councilmembers to various commissions and committees, and perhaps at that time you guys could consider appointing, make your appointments, the Council representation to this effort, which I think is timely and will address specific needs of the community and stakeholders and others. So thank you very much. Thank you, John. Andrew? Good evening, Councilmembers. Mr. Mayor, Andrew Castor with the High Sierra Striders. The High Sierra Striders are a nonprofit-running

57:24 We are a charter member of the Mammoth Trails. Last fall, I took the lead, the High Sierra Striders took the lead in submitting a Measure R application for funding for equipment for races and events. And this past July 4th, on Sunday, we had our fifth, the High Sierra Striders had their fifth annual Footloose Freedom Mile in which we had 343 registrants.

57:52 70% of which those registrants have an address outside of Mammoth Lakes. 38% of those participants in the race were under the age of 18 years old, so we're kind of catering towards the youth in the community and abroad. And that Measure R application that we submitted last year was for a timing system, 40 barricades, a blow-up start-finish line arch, 20 by 10 pop-up

58:22 Tent, and two generators to run all the equipment. And I have four quick photos I want to show up on the screen. Here's the finish line arch that went up in literally two minutes. And the barricades that we ordered, this is all, of course, measure our funding. All the logos of the Mammoth Trails organizations are on the finish line arch. Here's the starting line of the Freedom Mile. Started at 1010, went before the parade.

59:02 This event was hugely successful this year and very proud of our staff and volunteers that committed their time and efforts to this race. There's the pop-up tent that we got. It's fairly heavy. It's a two-person job, putting that guy up. And there's a picture of a young lad enjoying the day. So I wanted to say thank you for your commitment to the Measure R process.

59:34 This kind of shows that it does work and we have some great results from that process. So thank you very much. Andrew, I just want to say thank you and all of the ICR striders for all the work and effort you put into helping pull off these races and just get the whole running community probably worldwide aware of Mammoth Lakes and what we are and what we can offer. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. We also need to get Meb off the road bike.

1:00:01 I'm working on that. I worked on him yesterday. He's doing really well now. I saw him yesterday, and he's on Lake Mary Road with Gary Ackman. And just, it hurts me to see a gentleman of his talent on a road bike speeding downhill. Did he have a helmet on, though? He did. Good. Yeah, but he was going 30, 35 miles an hour. Thank you. Thank you.

1:00:33 Hello, members of the Council. Welcome to the new members, and congratulations on your win. I came for the High Sierra Track and Field Project, and I just want to make that clear. And I think this can be a worldwide destination running location, so hopefully we do everything that we can on that. Two things I want to talk about. First is the Medical Marijuana Cooperative, and the second is the bikes and the skate park issue. So first I'll talk about the Medical Marijuana Cooperative.

1:01:01 Well, it went ahead and passed with 56% of the vote, so the town of Mammoth has spoken. I'm looking forward to the day pretty soon that legal medical cannabis patients can go ahead and get the medicine that's been agreed to by them and their physician to be the safest and most effective treatment for their ailments. I can say that one thing that I really learned through this whole process

1:01:29 was that I thought that it should be a right as a citizen of our country to be able to have the most effective and safest medicine for your ailments, but what I'm finding out is that it's not necessarily true. It is not a right in our country to have that. And this is undermined specifically by certain organizations such as Partnership for Drug-Free America, California Narcotics Officers Association, who have

1:01:58 So I just want to make it clear that

1:02:25 The place that I come from is that I believe it's my right to be able to treat myself in whatever way my doctor and I agree to as the safest and most effective way. It's my right to be able to do that as a citizen. And for that to be undermined by the profit motives of certain industries of this country is not right. And I would hope that this council would back that up.

1:02:53 Okay, so enough said on that issue. Let's go ahead and move on to the next issue, which is the bikes in the skate park. Now, there is still the issue of bikes in the skate park. Bikes are not allowed in the skate park. That decision was made last summer by Parks and Rec. It has to do with something in the insurance that we have for that skate park. The skate park was built to be used by skateboarders specifically.

1:03:23 The bikes out there are causing numerous problems, the main one being a safety issue, mainly because the way that our park was designed is for skateboards and simply bicycles can go too fast in that skate park and collide with other people, which has happened on numerous occasions, and it is opening the town up for a lawsuit, for sure.

1:03:48 When we're out at the skate park and we call the police to have them dispatch somebody out there, dispatch doesn't want to dispatch officers to the skate park to deal with bikes anymore, even though it's already been voted on. Now, I understand that this issue got tabled sometime last, a couple months ago or something like that, but you need to know as council members that there's a serious insurance issue out at the park.

1:04:16 And that the town is really opening itself up for a big libel case for not enforcing what has already been decided on. Not to mention the fact that skateboarders are their own group of people, their own culture, and to mix bikes with it, it's causing problems because we tell them they have to leave, they won't leave, then we call the police, the police tell them they have to leave, they'll leave for a couple minutes, then come back.

1:04:46 You know, we need enforcement of that issue mainly for safety reasons. And I think Jane Bear will continue on that issue when she gets up here and talks. So thank you. Skip, I had a question of staff. Don't we have an ordinance, a town ordinance prohibiting bikes at the skate park? I'm not sure if it's an ordinance or not. That is our requirement, though.

1:05:13 The only reason I was thinking is if we did have an ordinance that would give the police department, the officers more ability to enforce it. Yeah, we'll be glad to review this whole issue. Okay, thank you. And answer that particular question. Answer that question. The real question is how can we enforce the rules out there. Thank you. My name is Jane Anderson Baer.

1:05:39 And on August the 18th, 2009, the Town Council closed the Brothers Skateboard Park to bicycles. This decision was made after consulting the town's insurance carrier. According to the public service announcement, which is attached to my letter, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department will conduct random patrols to the skate park to enforce the rules and ordinances. This is not happening.

1:06:05 Last week there was an incident at the skateboard park involving a family that had come all the way from Seattle to skate at the Brothers Skateboard Park. They were planning on spending a week's vacation here and they brought their children specifically to skate. The family went to the town offices to file a complaint about an incident involving their young son. The town office personnel sent the family to the police department. The police department stated that it is a rule and that it is posted at the...

1:06:34 That at the park that bikes are not allowed in the park. But since there was no ordinance, they can't do anything about the incidents that involves the bikes in the park. The family was then given my name and phone number to complain to about bikes in the park. My husband and I do not wish to be involved in the continued problems at the skate park park, especially when the town refused to step in and solve the problem permanently.

1:07:01 Please pass an ordinance, no bikes in the skateboard park, so the Mammoth Lakes Police Department can take action and promote the safe use of the skateboard park. And I have been to the Parks and Rec Commission, and I've discussed that problem there, and they tabled it for further discussion. That was in last October, and I don't think that it's ever come back here or come up again, but I'd like you to take action because it's becoming a serious problem. I was down there today. There's kids in the park with bikes.

1:07:30 And actually there was a kid in the bike park riding his bike around very fast without any brakes on his bike. So that's a problem. Who gave your phone number out? I think he said the police department did. So anyway, this family had tried and they'd actually visited, like I said, the town offices and the police department.

1:07:58 The other thing that I'd like to bring up, and I'm bringing it up now here in public comment because I don't know whenever to do it because the Skaper Park did not receive Measure R funds. The Volcom Brothers Skaper Park would like to... I'm sorry. The next agenda item is actually about to measure our funds. I know, but what my point is is this is because I didn't get any funds that I'm asking the town...

1:08:24 Council or the town some way consider another way to fund some improvements at the Skateboard Park without using major R funding. Okay, fair enough. Is that fair? The Volcom Brothers Skateboard Park would like to request the town of Mammoth Lakes complete the paver area in the Skateboard Park. This would entail digging down 10 inches, leveling, and compacting the ground, laying a base and pavers in a 2,000 square foot area. The JLA project would provide the paver, sand, and base.

1:08:53 This can be accomplished by using town labor or contracting Bravo Construction and existing town contractor. The pavers have been waiting for placement for two years. In the past, Eastman Homeowners Association laid the pavers on the volunteer basis. The town of Mammoth Lakes currently does not allow volunteers to work in the skateboard park.

1:09:16 The JLA project would like the town of Mammoth Lakes to install a drip system for landscaping in the skate park. We've been waiting for five years for this. The project would take two town workers three to four days or could be contracted by Bravo Construction. The JLA project would provide the material and the shrubbery for planting. The JLA project further requests the completion of the rock work around the tree well. The JLA project would provide the rock material.

1:09:45 The JLA project would like the work completed for the August 28th Volcom Gene Tour Pro Demo Event and the Wave Raid Skateboard Park Contest. And this project has been waiting for five years to be completed. Thank you. Jane, can I ask a question if I could? In regards to the bicycles at the skate park, I...

1:10:12 I drive by there quite a bit, and I look to see what's going on. I see the bikes out there. I also see, is there not rules about protective gear for the people using the skate park? Are they required? I'm not sure. Are they required? I'm asking. When I went to the Parks and Rec Commission, I addressed with the commission three areas of concern at the skate park. One was bikes in the park. The other was the helmet.

1:10:40 And the third issue was that we have a lot of spectators that are inside the park area. And what we were hoping to do is have the ordinance in place about the bikes and so that the police department would feel comfortable going down to the skateboard park and having some teeth and be able to cite people who did not wear helmets and people that were riding bikes.

1:11:08 We'd also like them at some point to cite people who might be inside the park, but the problem we have right now is, again, we don't have any seating there. And, again, that was part of our request for Measure R as a safety issue to be able to provide seating and shade for the people out there. So, yes, the helmet is an issue, and it's not being enforced. The nice part about it is when I go down there and I ask them to put their helmets on,

1:11:35 What's really interesting is just about everybody already has a helmet, and they go to their car, and they get it, and they put it on, and it's not an issue, but just so you know. I want to be sure, as we're addressing ordinances, I want to just be sure we cover all of the issues, not just the bikes. Yes, and we do have that issue, and I think a year or so ago,

1:11:59 If you didn't have a helmet on, I think you were given one warning, and then after that you got an $80 ticket, and if you were underage that you actually had to appear with your parents to a probation officer. I think that's the policy. Okay. All right. Thank you. Jim? I see you twice in one day. That's right. So I just wanted to say a couple of words. First of all, congratulations to our new members of the council. Thank you. This is an important event, I think, in Mammoth.

1:12:33 And I think you all represent the people of Mammoth and our dreams and our goals here. And I tell you, after five years of effort underway for the Old Mammoth Place Project, I have learned a lot. And now being a business owner that has almost 90 employees here in Mammoth, I've learned even more. And if I might,

1:13:00 Just take some practical business experience that I had running my companies in different places around the world and share that with you. I think you're in a historic moment. Historic in the sense that you are in a position of great opportunity, meaning you can make some big changes here and make them very quickly and easily at a time that not only has this country at a difficult juncture,

1:13:29 Financially. But the town had a difficult juncture financially. And if I might suggest something, there's something, there's a process that we used to go through in our various businesses called best practices. And it's something that's very simple and you can probably figure it out and get the information openly within literally a week. This is not something that would take a month or two or three or six or like my project, 60 meetings.

1:13:58 It is something that you can basically look at like communities, Aspen, other areas that you appreciate, Telluride, what have you, and look at proportional budget allocations for various endeavors. And that's all I would suggest. You will find something very dramatic. You will find, I suspect,

1:14:26 Complete dislocation of various departments within Mammoth and their expenditures versus industry norms. And I suspect, for example, one of those areas will be in the areas of marketing. Now, I believe personally that Mammoth is one of the undiscovered gems of the United States mountain community. And I think that many people here believe that.

1:14:58 And I would encourage you to take a look at these budgets because they're public. They're open. These are public entities. Have one person in staff gather them. Look at the percentages spent in the following 30 or 40 categories or whatever breakdown you desire and take a look and compare and contrast that to your own. I suspect you will find, as I said before, some very interesting numbers there.

1:15:26 And if I might suggest that that will be a simple way of taking a look at some of the regions that have been immensely successful by any standard in terms of growth from a budgetary perspective, a community perspective, revenue perspective, and that will be useful information. So I'm excited that we have some new blood. I think the past

1:15:56 Council Members got a bad rap, in my opinion, sometimes. I think they were fine people. But because of this inflection point that the country is in, because of the inflection point that the business communities are in, because of this inflection point that our community here is in, you have a special opportunity that does not come along often. And I would encourage you not to waste it. Thank you. Thank you, Jim.

1:16:26 Is there anyone else? If not, we will move on to item number one, which is the... You forgot council member reports. We will then go back to council member reports. Let me start with John. Do you have anything? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Two things real quick. I didn't want to leave Jane Bear hanging as far as her second request. Can we incorporate her second request at a future council meeting?

1:16:58 I think if you're referring to the improvements, the pavers and so forth, that we need to move fairly quickly on that. We were aware of the pavers but not the other items, but I think we will bring those back at the next meeting because there's a sensitive time issue involved. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Jane. I just wanted to, now that I'm thanking people, I wanted to personally thank Ray Jarvis who's here this evening and Ray's, your crew.

1:17:27 Our contractor, who's doing the work on the Lake Mary Bike Trail, for all of you guys getting together last week and getting that trail open so that the visitors could come and use it this past weekend. So thank you for your efforts. And that's the only thing I have. Thank you, John. Rick? You know, I want to take the opportunity to just state what I think a lot of people in the community saw over the 4th of July weekend.

1:17:54 As many of you know, I was quite active in the issues at the village with respect to the commercial tenants last year. And it seemed to me that there were a number of legs of a stool that needed to be put in place. And I think in the agreements that we did last year, three of them were put in place. But the fourth one was animation by the town and in cooperation and collaboration with the village merchants themselves.

1:18:23 Anybody who was there, many people were, on July 3rd, all day, but in particular from 5 o'clock to 10 o'clock, would have been pretty proud of this community with the level of activity, the number of things to do, the bands, the extraordinary number of people, and the energy that was produced. I think we've got an opportunity up there at the village that...

1:18:49 is extraordinary and I'm really hoping that the new tourism group that we I guess used to call the DMO will devote the kind of attention and effort and money and time to continuing to develop new events that will take place in the village and also throughout town. That was a pretty fun place to be on Saturday night and Saturday evening and I just wanted to

1:19:16 I point out to the council and the public how appreciative I am to all of those who put those things together. If you couldn't have fun, if you didn't have fun as a visitor over the 4th of July weekend, I don't think you can have fun anywhere. Thank you, Rick. Matt? I just second what John said with Jane. Hopefully we can re-address that later. It's interesting we have this ordinance where we don't have something for not preventing bikes in there.

1:19:46 That was about it. That's all. Thank you. Jill? Just two things. First of all, I would like to thank everyone in this community that volunteered for something over the weekend. That is what made it such a great event. So we're volunteers doing everything. So thank you for taking the time to do that and enjoy the weekend.

1:20:05 I would also ask my fellow members' indulgence that at the July 29th workshop, which we have scheduled, that all of the recreation issues be discussed at that point so we can focus on them and all the different aspects of our budget decisions and going forward with the strategic planning, et cetera, for recreation at one time. Is that the correct time frame?

1:20:36 Well, I'm looking at the other ones in between what's down for the 19th and what's down for the 21st. I think it's the first time we would have to focus on it. I just wanted to make sure. Rob, is that? Yeah, that's fine with us. Okay. Thank you. Anything else? No. Thank you. All right. I, too, just like to thank everybody for a fantastic...

1:20:59 Fourth of July weekend. Everyone had a great time. I mean, Mammoth put on its best weather, especially when you watch on the news and see the 100-degree, hot, 100% humidities back east and think how fortunate we are to be in such a wonderful place. And I did not run across anyone this weekend that was in a bad mood or having a bad time. Things flowed smoothly.

1:21:23 It was great to see everybody out enjoying our community, and the community did a great job of working on a holiday and putting the effort out. So thank you to everyone for what you did. All right. With that, we will move on to item number one, the introduction of our new interim police chief, Chief Daniel Watson. It's my great pleasure to once again introduce Chief Watson, who was sworn in yesterday and actually started work the day before.

1:21:56 When Chief Shinley decided to retire a number of months ago, we decided that it would be a good opportunity to bring in a chief on an interim basis from some other agency that could bring new ideas, new thought processes, and a lot of experience to the table. And we were absolutely blown away by the interest that we had in this position. We had a number of applicants. I think any one of them would make a great interim chief.

1:22:23 But the interview panel was unanimous in selecting Dan Watson as being the one who fit best in our community. Dan comes to us with 29 years' experience with LAPD, which is an organization where he got a very wide breadth of experience in all aspects of police work. But then he also spent eight years as the chief of South Pasadena, which is a very small department.

1:22:52 And gave him the opportunity to see community policing at that scale in action. And I think, you know, the people who he worked with there shared very positive things about the things that he did in South Pasadena. So it's my pleasure to once again introduce Chief Watson. Thank you. It's a pleasure to be here. And once again, I'll thank Town Manager Rob Clark for giving me the great opportunity to become part of this community.

1:23:29 My wife and I relocated up here last weekend. Unfortunately, we were not able to participate in the Fourth of July festivities because we were unloading at our new home that we leased. It's the first time in nine years I haven't participated in a parade. So we are really excited. I've met a lot of people and everybody's been wonderful. I can't remember anybody's name hardly except the council and some of the town staff. But I look forward. When I went to South Pasadena eight and a half years ago,

1:23:59 I said I was looking forward to the opportunity to meet and get to know 25,000 people, and I think I did most of them, and it might take a little less time here because it's a smaller town, but my wife and I both enjoy being involved in the community. I look forward to getting involved in many of the organizations. This is similar to my former town, which had a lot of community participation, which is what made that a great place to live and work, and I know it's the same thing here. I've spent the last couple of days...

1:24:26 Spending a lot of time with the members of the Mammoth Lakes Police Department, and it's been a good experience. My initial impressions are we've got a really fine group of people that are committed to this community and enjoy working here. So I know I'm going to be doing the same thing, and I look forward to meeting and spending time with all of you individually in the next few weeks. So thank you again. Thank you. Policy matters. Item number two, the Major R 2010 Spring Funding. I believe Stuart.

1:25:08 Thank you, Mayor Harvey, members of the Council. Good evening. So I'm here before you regarding the Measure R Spring funding review and award. Just a little background. At the Wednesday, June 23rd meeting of Town Council, the Town Council requested that the Tourism and Recreation Commission provide documentation that would directly relate to the principles and priorities established by the Commission to the 2010 Spring Measure R applications.

1:25:34 On Tuesday, June 29th, the Tourism and Recreation Commission met to reconsider, at the request of Town Council, the Measure R Spring funding review and award. After discussing the Town Council's comments and concerns of the Measure R Spring award process, the Tourism and Recreation Commission unanimously adopted a motion to stand by their original recommendations and to resubmit the Measure R Spring funding recommendations to Council as is.

1:26:04 And to further recommend that the Town Council request a workshop with the Commission to discuss the Measure R process. By consensus, the Commission also agreed to direct staff to reconvene the Measure R Steering Committee prior to any workshop with the Council to review the Measure R award process to address several specific issues listed in the staff report. Some of those issues include defining owned and managed,

1:26:33 Consider a separate process for applications above a certain dollar threshold. Review previous award amounts and accomplishments. Consider placing a time limit on the use of awarded funds. Consider a procedure to determine the economic impact of Measure R funds in Mammoth Lakes. Review a point system for evaluating the value and potential impacts and facilitated objective comparisons. Require applicants to list current and expected users of their projects.

1:27:02 Review public noticing of the Measure R award process. Discuss leveraging of Measure R funds. And discuss how the still to be determined recreation vision of Mammoth Lakes gets integrated with the Measure R award process. Accompanying this memo in the staff report were the 12 Measure R spring applications. The Tourism and Recreation Commission's adopted principles and priorities document. And the Measure R tool application that was adopted by Council. So the recommendation.

1:27:34 is to approve option one of the June 23rd, 2010 agenda bill regarding Measure R funding that approves the Tourism and Recreation Commission's Measure R funding recommendations for the 2010 spring cycle and adopt the resolution directing appropriations for the fiscal year 2009-10 budget from the Measure R Parks, Recreation and Trails Appropriations Fund. We have a number of Tourism and Recreation Commissioners in the audience this evening including the chair of the commission.

1:28:02 If you wish to speak to the Tourism and Recreation Commission directly. And that concludes my presentation. Thank you, Stuart. Questions from Councilman John? My only question is, and I agree with the recommendation, at the bottom of page one it says by consensus the Commission also agreed to direct staff. Does that need to be part of a motion or do we do that as a consensus from the Council if we wish to take that direction? It could be either. Either? Okay. Thank you. Thank you, John.

1:28:34 I have some questions. On our list of items to be funded through Measure R for this year, we have the ice rink slab and the ice rink fence. And I understand some of the reasoning behind it. We need to get some infrastructure in place in order to maintain our lease. But I think the ice rink, the lease, and a number of other items are still up for discussion later as part of our budgeting process.

1:29:03 I don't know if now is the appropriate time to discuss it or not, but I'm not really comfortable with seeing those funded right now. Okay. Let me go back to our chair of TNR, and you can respond to your reasoning for those items. The first time with the chair you're going to make me get up to speak. I think you'll find in our recommendations

1:29:35 That the funding for both of those projects were one of the requirements for them to be funded, they would be brought back later, were things that we asked for as commissioned in the lease. That they weren't funded, they're part of a contingency to be funded if certain criteria are met after that. Okay. And I missed the update that Carrie gave us the other night, but those aren't, I think you'll find we agree with you that there are certain things that need to happen first before those get funded. So they're a contingency.

1:30:04 Okay. And I'm wondering, could another contingency be put in place that in the event that these were not funded, could we perhaps go back and fund something like the Brothers Skate Park, assuming there was enough funding there for it? Usually that's not the way it's set up. Okay. We have to remember that the spring award, we call the oopsertunity award. Yep. So that's for opportunities.

1:30:34 That arise that couldn't be in the fall. Okay. And they have to meet that criteria, not something that, well, we would like it to happen this year. It has to be something that we will lose in the long term otherwise. Okay. Or, as in the case of the timing equipment for the Mammoth Trails, something where we underfunded because something else broke in the interim, so we have to increase that. So that's what the Spring Award is for.

1:31:02 It's done that way. It's not meant to be a funding of major projects. It is meant specifically to handle things mid-year that we have to handle, give us an opportunity so that we don't lose the momentum on the project we've already approved, you know, for overages and things like that. The main award is the fall award, and we push that very hard so that someone doesn't apply for something under the opportunity and doesn't get held up to the same.

1:31:32 Scrutiny that everybody that goes in the fall so they could apply and all the fall applicants aren't going to be there so it's sort of an end run and we did everything we could as a committee outside the commission to try and stop the political end runs from taking place. Okay. Thanks for that clarification. Any other questions? I had a question, Bill. By its very nature, the way it's set up right now, the distribution of these funds,

1:32:02 Has to be somewhat subjective by the commission members? Absolutely. There's no way to allocate these kind of dollars without being subjective with each applicant. What is the good to the community? How many people? Single purpose, multi-purpose. I'm sure that over the course of Measure R, there are going to be some great projects that don't get funded. Because as in this award cycle, certain ones that meet the criteria, remember we put out art.

1:32:31 Our criteria, our priorities each year for the measurable process. So you may have a great project, but if it isn't in that priority set, like finishing a trail or finishing a park, you may well not rise to the top so easily. So a lot of good projects may not get funded because others rise to the top and use up the allocated dollars for that time frame. Or we ask, as we did in the spring awards, we ask staff.

1:33:00 To get us answers that we don't have so that we can bring something back in the fall to meet the needs of that ask in a different fashion for to have questions asked or answered. So I'm rambling from stepping back. Thank you, Bill. Other questions from Bill? Bill, I have a question. I was in the audience when this was originally discussed, and one of the things that I...

1:33:28 What I see in the bill is that you have sent it back to Council as is without any modifications.

1:33:57 I think in response, remember there was an hour and 45 minute discussion about this at the last council meeting or two meetings ago. Do you feel that you've complied with the request of the council over the last time? I think that the questions that council set back were point system, do we have it? Ownership managed, is it necessary? And we're reconvening the original group to take that issue up. I happen to feel personally that they are both.

1:34:26 Hugely important. If we look at other people that grant money for the same sort of things, that's the system that is used, that's the best practice, as we've heard mentioned earlier. And there was a perceived conflict of interest on one of the commissioners, and in fact his employer, and we discussed that as well, his employer has come forward several times and says he endorses the free program, and so we felt there was no actual conflict of interest in it.

1:34:55 And certainly there was no monetary gain sitting on the Tourism and Recreation Commission. Thank you. Bill, I guess that leaves my question, is how did your point system work? Well, I suppose that my vision was different. Originally we talked about a point system, a way for each commissioner to allocate points for certain things. So we came up with a tool, which you probably have in front of you there somewhere. So each one of those questions...

1:35:25 What is related to a specific topic? How many people? Who do you affect? What kind of economic impact? Each one of those questions allows each commissioner to then allocate points, A, B, C, D, 1, 2, 3, 4, that's subjective to the commissioner looking at it. So when you look at the application, which is built on the tool, and you look at the tool, we already have a process whereby in the privacy of their own home, they can allocate points, plus we do two separate meetings. We do one meeting.

1:35:55 To do nothing but get input from the applicants. And then using that tool, each commissioner can assign points for each of those different questions. So to me, the point system already has been established. I don't think you want to take subjectivity out of it altogether. It has to be a personal choice on the good each commissioner thinks the community is going to get from that. After all, the idea behind this is to do the greatest amount of good for the greatest amount of...

1:36:26 People, visitors and locals alike. Okay, so I don't have that. I think I'm a little confused here. Jane, what I saw in the pamphlet you gave us, did you create this or was this the system that was used? If you look at the page before, it said that was the criteria. Okay, but I guess, let me just ask the question. Did you create this or was this the criteria by which the...

1:36:51 Planning Commission evaluated the application. I have no idea. What I'm telling you is this was when I applied for the grant right here. This was the guideline that I was given. Okay. It's the one that I gave you. It says on it, major, it says major funding criteria. This was what I was given when I was told to apply for the grant. What I did was I took this, I put it over here on the next page.

1:37:20 I put those criterias down here. I put the projects across the top, and I said, this is how many times these people met the criteria that I was given. I was told that, you know, how many visitors did you create? Did you bring matching funds? Was it in the Parks and Rec master plan? Completing a semi-completed park?

1:37:49 Do you already have a plan? Again, how many people are you going to bring for recreation and does this complete a segment of the trail? That's the criteria I was given when I applied for the grant and that's the criteria that is on the website. Okay.

1:38:08 The check marks that are in these boxes and the numbers at the bottom of the box is what you did as an example of what you understood the process. Thank you. Thank you. That's what I needed to know. I wasn't clear on the source of that, but I understand now. Okay, thank you. And that's why I'm really concerned because he's talking about a criteria that I don't know anything about.

1:38:32 Because I used the criteria that was on the website. I used the criteria that was told to use. Okay, thank you, Jane. So, Bill, you described the criteria where you each assign a point system to the applications. I don't see that in my package. The tool is built into the application. So the application asks questions based on the tool.

1:39:18 Right. So the application follows the tool. Exactly. So this is the application. So if you look at one of the applications that follows the application, there are several questions. Yes. Each one of those questions corresponds to the same number and the same basic question on the tool. So as you go through the application, you can give points for each of these.

1:39:51 Answers to each of these questions. Excuse me. Such as will there be volunteer hours? Have any public funds been committed? Is Measure R your only funding source? Is it going to have an impact on existing use in the location you've identified? Who's the long-term owner of the project service, which is important because we have a town-owned, town-managed system in place now? And again, there are several. I don't want to read the whole.

1:40:26 It goes through three different sections of questions. Okay, so I'm looking at one of these applications here. If I wanted to find out how many points were awarded to each of these sections on this particular application, where would I find that? You wouldn't find the points given because that's subjective. That's what each commissioner does on their own. Whether they give points, whether they just give pluses or minuses, that is up to each commissioner. Okay.

1:40:56 Come up with the points. It's up to each commissioner on his own to give those points. And again, we're reconvening the committee. And we have been asked to look at that, so we certainly will look at it. The other, as Stuart also brought up, the meeting with you, and one of the things I think I'm considering, because there were several questions asked, this is a very important tool for the town of Mammoth as a whole. And I don't want to see it go sideways with...

1:41:25 Political plays. So perhaps the way this needs to be introduced to Council in the future should be at a workshop where you would each be able to ask us questions on each applicant so that you could be comfortable with how the applicants we brought to the top came to the top. And if you had a difference, then that could be brought up at that time and we could take it back before Council made action. That's just a suggestion that still has to go through both you and the committee.

1:41:56 But I am very confident in the awards we made this spring that they were the right ones with the applications that we received for the opportunity process, the spring funding cycle. Okay. Thank you, Bill. And I think that we are all in agreement on that. All right. Thank you. Any other questions for Bill? Thank you. Thank you.

1:42:21 If there are no other questions from Council Members, is there anyone in the public that would like to speak on this issue? First of all, I brought this along just so you could have the information available. This is the Measure R. I think you gave it. No, this is actually who applied and who received funds. It goes along with what...

1:43:03 These are yours as well. Actually, I want to make sure you didn't grab a few other things there. I think you did. What? You grabbed a few of my other papers as well, I thought. First of all, I produced a packet that I presented to the town council members, and I apologized to Ms. Bacon because she didn't get hers ahead of time.

1:43:35 But in the fall of 2009, the Mammoth Lakes JLA Fund submitted a grant application for major art funding. In my opinion, using the criteria that I was told, I felt that I met all the criteria for grant funding. We proposed to finish a current park facility that was mentioned in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. We had $75,000 worth of matching funds.

1:44:00 And we were the only project that had matching funds, and that was, we were told by Dana Stroud that that was supposed to be a major plus in funding. Using my system, I felt that we were the only ones that met all the criteria, or close to all of it, and we didn't receive any money. I felt if a point system would have been in effect strictly following the published criteria, that there was no way that we wouldn't have been at the top.

1:44:29 In the spring of 2010, we applied again. This time, we lowered our matching funds to $25,000, and again, I felt we met the criteria showing timely need. The skateboard park is in drastic need of shade and seating outside the park to remove dangerous hazards for unprotected spectators. Our application was denied. I strongly feel that this process disregards its own funding guidelines.

1:44:58 When I read the article in the sheet in the Mammoth Times, I was greatly pleased that I felt that the council was doing its job to question what a commission is doing. I think that's really important that you look and see and understand that maybe the council has an opinion, but also some of the citizens might have a different opinion. The voters, when they approved measure our funding,

1:45:23 I think that they really felt that it was supposed to be for parks and recs facilities, trails facilities, and that's not been the case. Over half the money has been distributed for planning projects, and again, I had to readjust what I had said in here. What I found that there was $800,000 worth of money allotted

1:45:53 And 83% of the funding went to planning. Mammoth MLTPA got $466,000 out of the funding. And the track got $167,000 worth of money. And both of those seem to involve planning, not necessarily putting a shovel in the ground and getting a project completed.

1:46:22 I was further surprised when the Mammoth Times stated that John Wentworth created the funding model for Major R. I think that this is a conflict of interest since he is the major recipient of Major R fundings. Mr. Wentworth was further quoted as stating in the paper that the funding tool is solid and has worked for the past two cycles. I think that's because he gets the lion's share of the money.

1:46:47 Also, I really felt that there was a great deal of bias in the interview process. We were told that we were to be limited to 10 minutes. I spent a great deal of time standing in front of the mirror timing my presentation to make sure that it was 10 minutes and I met that criteria. When the process was going on, MLTPA presented a 50-minute program with a PowerPoint.

1:47:17 And the Striders presented a PowerPoint presentation with three presenters that lasted an hour and 20 minutes. The JLA Skateboard Park presentation was clear and concise and honed to the 10 minute limit. The long extended presentations were given an unfair advantage.

1:47:38 The presenters who stuck to the allotted time seemed to be viewed as unprepared and inadequate by the commission instead of being regarded as those who followed the guidelines. I also had further concerns because when the skateboard park was under construction, the water commission wanted to give the JLA fund $50,000 for the bathrooms.

1:48:06 What happened was the town blocked this move arguing that it was illegal for taxpayer funds to go to a non-profit organization. The town won that argument and received the $50,000 instead of it going to the JLA fund. So my question is how can the town of Mammoth Lakes willingly give millions of dollars to non-profit organizations?

1:48:34 How can they use Measure R funds to pay the salaries and employees of non-profit organizations? Who owns the items bought by Measure R funding? Where are they stored? Who are able to use these items? All items purchased with Measure R funding in the Skateboard Park Grant will become part of the park. Park benches, picnic benches, shades, pavers, landscapes, etc. They'll all be used by visitors and locals alike. None of the funds...

1:49:03 has been, will be used for planning or for the non-profit itself. Over the last five years, the JLA Fund has been before the Parks and Rec Commission numerous times and tried to finish the landscaping, seeding, and shading for the skateboard park. We have followed town procedures repeatedly applied through set processes. We are frustrated by the lack of support of the town of Mammoth Lakes to complete the Volcom Brothers Skateboard Park in a timely manner. The JLA Fund,

1:49:32 I am snowboarding, and the Volcom Brothers Skateboard Park, another project that we have is called 4RT, have always presented the Mammoth Lakes town in the most positive light. This is a book that's been published, and it's called Epic Spots, Places You Must Skate Before You Die. And the skateboard park ended up making it number two in this book.

1:50:02 Number one was if you could afford to have a bowl or a swimming pool in your own backyard. And the Town of Mammoth Lakes Skateboard Park was number two in this published book. We have videos. This is one of many videos that features the skateboard park. You can rent it at Take Two Video. We receive tons and tons of publicity in magazines.

1:50:32 You know, tons and tons of publicity. We've worked relentlessly to show you the town in a positive light.

1:50:42 This year, we raised $75,000 with our I Am Snowboarding project, which started out in the town of Mammoth Lakes. It was supposed to be a one-stop project. It finished into 12 cities. It's gone worldwide. It was in Tokyo. This fall, it will be in Innsbruck. It will be in Toronto, and it will be in New York City.

1:51:10 One of the things that I felt was I had all this information to be able to show to the Parks and Rec Commission, but when you're only given 10 minutes of time to do your whole presentation, you don't have that much time. Even though if you look in my grant, it's actually mentioned that these things are things that we do, and I've had people say to me, well, you never told me that. And I did. It just didn't have a chance.

1:51:39 I am amazed that the town of Mammoth Lakes has turned down a project that has offered first $75,000 and then $25,000 in funds that have been generated by the citizens of the town and the action sports industry. I am extremely disappointed in the lack of support that we've received for measure of funding, and I really think the process is extremely unfair. Any questions for Jane? Thank you, Jane.

1:52:14 Is there anyone else that would like to speak? Let me start with Eric. I just had two points I wanted to clarify. Your name, please. Oh, Eric Sugimura from the Mammoth Times. I just had two points I wanted to clarify or confirm. One, it sounds like there's no record of the point system, like what points were given to any particular item, and I don't know if maybe one of the commissioners can answer that. And it also sounds like the spring funding cycle is meant as an opportunity.

1:52:46 For unexpected things that happen to programs that receive funding in the fall, but is it limited strictly to opportunities, or can it open itself to brand new programs? Thank you, Eric. I think we might be able to answer those. Either Tony can help answer those now, or we can also talk about those during council discussion. Tony Colosardo, Parks and Rec Commissioner.

1:53:12 I'm going to take a different tact. I'm going to explain why we did not fund some of these applicants. And we'll start with Mammoth Nordic at $355,000. It was a funding cycle to stop, you know, to fill in the gaps for products that, let me start it over again. Okay. Financial shortcomings. So one example of that is the Mammoth Trails. Okay. They needed...

1:53:42 More money to get a new clock and get some other items. Prior commitments. We had prior commitments to MLTPA to finish those projects, so that's why some of the other ones were funded, as well as opportunities, which would be the biathlon. Those were easily funded, whereas Mammoth Nordic asked for $350,000, $150,000 snow grooming machine, of which we only had $126,000.

1:54:12 To continue with that one, Snow Creek asked for a relationship to build a field house, so we categorized those two applicants as opportunities in the future that needed more research, and that was the reason why we brought up the fact that if there is an application over 100,000, over 150,000, just like Mammoth Track.

1:54:37 That was developed for about a year before it ever came forward in the public. So there's a lot of discussion that was taking place so that when that came forward, we all knew what was going on. The ice rink in relationship to this lab and the fence, I think the fence, according to the closed session meetings, would probably be funded at this time. So I'm not sure whether we're talking about $89,000 tonight.

1:55:07 For $114,000. But I think there's a commitment that was made in closed session to adhere to the agreement with the school district. So whether the fence goes up or not, it either takes it from $89,000 to $114,000. The skate park, we looked at that. And because there is not a Trails End master plan,

1:55:32 And we weren't sure about spending the money on, we haven't seen any drawings of the benches themselves, whether that should go forward, so we recommended that that came forward with a town staff plan on what to do with the park so that we can put the whole thing together. And that's where we are today. So I don't know if anybody has any questions. A picture of the park benches is in part of the plan.

1:56:05 It's actually part of the fall funding grant. It's right here. It's in there so they can see what the park bench looks like. And we have a plan that we worked on and submitted. And I brought it in for the Parks and Rec Commission. And they didn't seem to have any saying about the plan, whether it was unacceptable or not. So we used that plan when we applied for our money.

1:56:34 I don't know what else to say. I went to your commission meeting a month or two months before we applied for the grade. Terry? Terry, Stellick, Recreation Commission. I guess this might be helpful for council and for others to come to our meetings where we actually have these discussions. And I'll add a couple other bits of information to...

1:57:10 Things that Tony said as conversations that have gone on. Trails and Park is not just Volcom Brothers Skate Park. Trails and Park, and one of the reasons that the trail community did not necessarily fight that skateboard park going in is that there's a playground that goes with it as well. And what we're looking at is having a complete

1:57:34 Project. And that not that it's all going to be completed at one time, but we look at it. So what we're doing with Volcom Brothers Skateboard Park is flowing in with what we can do with the playground, which we have playground equipment sitting in storage. I think it's been there for about five years now. And so that still hasn't gone forward. And that's a portion of the park that hasn't

1:57:59 It hasn't came forward, hasn't moved forward. Why? You know what? I'm not sure. We actually did get money to go through the process to move that plan forward to get the CEQA process going. So the benches, there was not only do we want to look at that whole plan, we want the benches to flow from the skateboard park into the trails park. All of that, it's one park. It's not just the skateboard. We have to look at that as a whole.

1:58:28 Say that, I don't know how many times I can say that. As far as the benches go, we did have some questions and spoke to Dennis Rotner concerning the benches. There's some very big concerns. You're putting benches that can be moved at a skateboard park. There's some safety issues as far as that goes. There is seating out there. You have bleachers that are out there right now.

1:58:51 And we do have easy-ups that could actually be put out there. So it isn't as though there's no seating out there. So anyways, these benches can be moved. They have to be removed in the wintertime. Do they meet all the standards that a public park needs to meet as far as the seating and safety? Those are all things that need to be looked at. Dennis said that is not a typical seating that goes at a municipal park.

1:59:21 And so those are some concerns that came up as well. So those were things that I think that Jane, I think that town staff and possibly a commissioner can all sit down and some of these things can be brought forward. It can be discussed. And planning needs to stop happening in a vacuum and that we need to start looking at these things as a whole and that the folks that are bringing projects forward need to seek out.

1:59:49 Staff input and town input when it's affecting municipal parks. And I just think that that is something that can be done between now and the fall process. And I think that would be very important. Thank you, Terry. Is there anyone else from the public that would like to speak? Yeah, I would just like to say as far as the measure our funding goes, it is extremely frustrating when you do raise money. And that was like we have for the JLA Foundation.

2:00:22 And we can't even use that money to do things like get shade for us out at the park that we go to all the time. It's just sitting in the bank account ready to go and we can't go out and buy a shade for ourselves to have out there all the time. So I just really think that it should be at the top of the list if somebody raises funds for their project that that should be the most important criteria to...

2:00:49 Go towards deciding where those funds get allocated. Because it should go to the people who are most passionate. And if those people can raise the funds, then that's where it should go. So that's my comment. Thanks. Thank you, Steve. Any other persons? Sorry, I was going to repeat my question. Is there a record of the points that were given to the individual applicants? And is the spring funding cycle limited strictly to oopsertunity?

2:01:17 Thank you. And I do think that, at least in my notes, during this discussion, we'll answer your questions. I do think we will. If we don't, ask them. No, I'm kidding. If no one else from the public wants to speak, council discussion and...

2:01:38 One of the things I'd like to counsel as we discuss this to look at is that there was a recommendation that this does go back and we reconvene the Major R Steering Committee and they have listed some bullet points here of issues that that committee should be reviewing and questions that they should be asking. So as you make your comments, maybe you would like to also comment on whether or not this list

2:02:03 defines what you think they need to look at, and is there anything additional or anything they may not need to look at based on that list? Presently, I'm satisfied with the level of detail. This is, again, a new process. It's going to be ongoing. We're going to be making corrections periodically. And so, again, I'm comfortable in moving it forward and making the changes as we need to. Rick? I concur. Matt?

2:02:36 I'd agree. I'd just like to ask Bill, when someone's declined, are they given a letter? Is there a way we can incorporate that, or is there a reason we're not? To me, it is more important to explain to the town why the months that came to the top came to the top. I don't know as a commission that we should have to be asked to justify.

2:03:08 Everyone that didn't, I mean, you're expanding the process exponentially. Again, we'd love to have the, you know, work session, we can go over some of this as well. Thank you, Bill. Two comments. I would hope that there is an additional bullet added that

2:03:33 Incorporates the idea of thinking what needs to be brought forward to council because the original recommendation that we saw on June 23rd that led to so many of the questions didn't really incorporate the rationale that they had made and so I'd hope that part of the process is to think about

2:03:53 How it is presented. I think Bill's idea about a workshop first might help, but for the public who sees it at one point, I think that there are probably enough columns that it's a grid-going landscape instead of portrait that we want to look at. The second thing I would like to say is I concur with what's been said so far, but I also believe that our motion should include direction to staff to reconvene the Measure R Steering Committee.

2:04:24 You know, I'll start with Aaron, just to get your questions answered. It sounds to me like, is there any documentation of the point system that was used through ATI's project? I would say the answer is no. It was done subjectively. It was kind of in the minds of each of the committee members, and that is how it was done. So the answer to that question is no.

2:04:51 I think that that should be something that should be put into our bullet points. Is that really, should we do it differently in the spring than we do, and I'm just putting this out as something for the committee, the steering committee to discuss, is should we do it differently in the spring than we do it in the fall, or should it be consistent?

2:05:16 Throughout. I don't know, you know, but I think it should be something that should be discussed. I think they should definitely, as they develop their points system, put in the idea of how do grants play into this. When we've got that additional money, if you want to talk about the importance of grants, just ask the town what they spent a lot of their REU money on this year. Projects that were grant-funded that we wanted to keep going.

2:05:43 So, yes, grants do play a big part in how things are funded and the importance of things. It needs to be clear, the issue of presentation time, you know, we're trying to create a fair playing field here, and that's the whole issue here. There isn't anyone up here that wanted to go back at any time and change the allocations that were made by...

2:06:07 The Tourism and Recreation Commission. But what we wanted to do is to make sure that everyone understood it. And it isn't anybody's fault. We're not pointing any fingers at anybody or saying anyone is to blame. I think what we're trying to do is just tweak the system that we had started to make it better because we know there are more funds and more money coming. And therefore, we want to make sure that we do the best as we possibly can to make sure it's clearly understood, just like our budget, that things are clearly understood.

2:06:37 And accept it. Are there always going to be people who are disappointed or maybe feel they weren't fairly treated in the process? There may be. That's just the way it goes sometimes. We can't fund everybody, give everybody all they want. But we need to make an effort to just put in the little...

2:06:55 Tweaks here to make it work. So if presentation time is put in there for people and people work hard to follow that, then everyone should follow the same pattern. If they're putting in the agenda that they are going to make presentations of awards at a certain time and that that is the time to make your presentation and that the next meeting the awards are going to be given, then at the next meeting they should give the awards.

2:07:25 And people who go just simply to see if they got it or not should not be expected to go up and have to fight their battle a second time. They may not be prepared for that. If there needs to be a third meeting or a middle meeting somewhere in between the first and second for the commission or the people that are giving these awards out to...

2:07:47 Discuss it, then let's look at the process that we're using and see if we need to put a step or two more into that process. But again, this is something that I think needs to go back to the steering committee for discussion and they also need to discuss this defined and define owned and managed because I don't want us to cut ourselves, cut off our own noses.

2:08:12 When we could be maybe benefiting from something that isn't necessarily town-owned or figure out a way that we can work with an organization to bring it into town ownership and still create a successful program. So I would like to add those things to, you know, this discussion of the agenda onto these bullet points and how it's laid out, the number of meetings it takes to make the awards presentation time, is opportunity.

2:08:41 The best should we vary, should we differentiate between spring and fall awards, and I think we should definitely talk about grants and the importance of those as we talk about the points system, and because I think Jane made a great example here in her book of how simple it would be to do it in writing, to show us how these points were awarded and what each project would be given. The council then, when we get...

2:09:11 This recommendation to give this money out, we could probably pretty much look at that chart and see how everything was done. If we have questions, we can go back and review the individual applications. But to avoid the micromanaging, to avoid getting into it, just simply having that chart would probably answer a lot of questions for us. So I definitely support that. So that is John. Yes, Mr. Mayor. I'm sorry, I'm a pretty simple guy. And I think after three hours,

2:09:41 Of public and town council discussion, it's time to move this, stop beating this financial horse and move this issue forward. Therefore, I'll make a motion that the town council approve option number one as stated tonight, adding that the commission agrees to direct staff to reconvene the measure R steering committee prior to any workshop with the council to review the measure R award process.

2:10:11 To address specific issues as listed in tonight's agenda bill, adding Joe's bullet, and correct my wording if it's not correct, Joe, what rationale needs to be brought forward to the town council? Okay? That's my motion. Second. With one clarification is that would you also accept the bullets added by Skip? I wouldn't right now because I didn't really understand.

2:10:43 What he was saying, and I would like the commission and the measure R steering committee to discuss it, and then they can make their recommendation. I'll call for the question. Do we have a second? Yes, then you have a second, because I believe it can be worked out. Okay, Jamie? Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes.

2:11:20 The motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Just very quickly, before we go on from this is that I'm just wondering when we incorporate the information that John Wentworth gave us during the public comments about how to move forward with the strategic plan. It's referenced in these as the still-to-be-determined recreation vision, but I'd like to ask that it be part of that workshop on the 29th.

2:11:49 Because there is an offer here for funding. Yeah. Participation. I concur with that. Any disagree with that? Yes, direction to staff. Thank you. Rob, are we? We were actually planning to bring it forward on the 21st. Oh, okay. Because we want to get the process moving quickly. So just to be clear, on the 21st, you're bringing it forward?

2:12:18 The proposal that you passed out in public comments. And that would be fleshed out in what it looks like in the time frame and how it's all going to work? Uh-huh. Okay. Sounds good. Okay. We will move on to item number three, use of the town vehicle by the town's wildlife contractor. And I guess, Steve, are you starting this off? If I may, you may. Mr. Mayor Harvey. To the councilman that just got elected, well done, guys.

2:12:53 I'm really proud of you, and thank you for stepping up to serve our community. Thanks. Great. Congratulations. At the last City Council meeting, this item came up. Councilman Eastman brought it up about the need for a truck, possibly, for this year's work. I, as most people know, I drive a pretty crummy old truck. I really don't mind, and it's just a beer and a work truck for me.

2:13:24 I got to thinking about it with the national and international attention that we're going to draw from the show. I felt that it didn't adequately represent the community, and I felt that I could do a better job representing the town in possibly a better truck, a better marked truck, and that's where this all got started from.

2:13:53 The first person that found out about the need was Paul Oster at REMAX, the Mammoth. He offered me an immaculate truck for me to do my job free of charge to me. Paul, a lot of people don't know, has supported me for years. He's bought thousands of stickers for me to hand out to our tourists and guests and once again stepped up to offer me a truck free of charge at his expense for me to use.

2:14:22 In my work for the town, when I had gone to the town previous to that and asked to use the animal control truck, I was turned down and I understand the reasons for that. I'm not an employee of the town and as of the last day of June, I'm no longer a contract employee of the town.

2:14:47 And so to not allow me to drive the truck, I understand that. The next person that found out the need was Rusty Gregory and Howard Pickett of Mammoth Mountain. And they, as John alluded to last week,

2:15:04 I'm allowed to speak about it today. The truck was delivered this week, and Rusty and Howard Pickett, Mammoth Mountain, saw fit to buy a brand-new truck for my use during this season, and especially during the filming, and representing our community. I don't have the agenda item in front of me, but you guys do. There's a couple of options there.

2:15:29 About gas money. Thank you for thinking of me, and I could appreciate and use that. Also, in outfitting the new truck, there will be about $3,600 in costs for radios, lighting, bullhorns, that type of thing, safety equipment to go into the truck, and it might be something that you might consider addressing tonight.

2:15:55 As that the truck issue is a moot point at this time. That with your permission, I will continue to serve the community and continue to respond to emergency and non-emergency calls around town, even though I don't have a contract and I'm not actually an employee at this time.

2:16:23 I would look forward to meeting with City Council or your staff in trying to work out an agreement for further employment for the town, and that's certainly what I would like to do is continue to represent the town in the best way I could. Any questions from Council? Questions from Council? Am I understanding correctly that the issue is now that you have been provided a truck through another venue?

2:16:54 It's not another venue. It's Rusty Gregory. It's through the mountain. Mammoth Mountain stepped up and were proud to represent our community in an international forum and get me through the next maybe seven months of filming. And so they jumped at the chance. Okay. And did that agreement include the cost of maintenance and gas?

2:17:16 They're not only going to do the maintenance every 90 days, they won't be doing the gas, but they have been so generous as to agree to fully insure the truck as well. Any other questions for Steve? Questions for staff? Just a clarification is I do believe it is in this budget to have a continuing contract with the wildlife officer, right?

2:17:48 Yes. You know, I think when we put the contract together, we assumed a budget would always be adopted by June 30th, and so the way the contract reads, it's tied to the budget approval. Yes, the budget does propose that it be funded, and we may need to find a way to fill this gap in future years if budget isn't going to be adopted on June 30th.

2:18:12 Well, we adopted, or the council adopted an interim budget, and so is funding going to continue for his work during this period in which we adopt a final budget? Actually, that's a good point, and the dollar amount is the same, so we probably, I think we could use that authority to extend the contract. Thank you. Can I say we have consensus to do that? And that's what I'm, because my concern also is that

2:18:40 It states in here about how the insurance company is fine with this except that he must pass the criteria of part-time and full-time employees, which means he has to be legally technically employed by a town in order to be covered by our insurance. But my understanding... It's in terms of our vehicle, though. Yeah, it's no longer our vehicle. See, most of what we have in front of us, I think, has changed. He's an independent contractor who's worked out a different deal for a vehicle.

2:19:09 But is our insurance still going to? Okay. Update me. Sorry. You have your own insurance, don't you? As per the contract that we went by last year, I have a tremendous amount of insurance I pay for monthly. And again, just to correct Joe, there was no deal with Mammoth Mountain. It was just out of their generosity and no more than that. Okay. Let me get an update from Michael if I could. Just to clarify the insurance issue.

2:19:36 Mr. Searles did provide his own general liability in auto insurance, and the vehicle that Mr. Gregory is going to provide for him, that would be covered under Mr. Searles' insurance. He just needs to notify his insurance company of the change in vehicles, but that would not be covered under the town's insurance policy with the JPIA. What about if we give him our truck? Are we still talking about giving him our truck? No, I don't think so.

2:20:04 What did the bill do I have? I think this wasn't supposed to really be on the agenda. It was a discussion that took place, and I think it got on the agenda. Or maybe it was just misunderstanding. Well, but, yeah, I think you're right. Okay. So we've got Rusty Gregory donating a truck to you, and you plan on using that truck?

2:20:30 Again, not to be argumentative, but the town never insured my vehicle. I provide all of my own insurance, always have. As per the contract, if we move forward and I get a new contract, I will continue to carry those.

2:20:44 Million dollar coverages, but the Mountain and Rusty and Howard have agreed to insure the vehicle. It's not my vehicle, it's their vehicle, and that's through the extent that we'll be filming for Discovery and Animal Planet. Okay, and so you need $3,600 though to make that vehicle that they're giving to you out of the goodness of their heart?

2:21:09 Set up to do the job you need to do. Am I correct with that? Again, they're not giving me a vehicle. It'll just be on a loan basis. If you guys, I glanced at some of the agenda items and gas allowance or a truck coming forward, I could use both, but that the rough numbers for an installation this week on the...

2:21:31 The necessary stuff that would work really well in the truck, not counting and filming, the production company pays for that, but just the bullhorn, modern day radio, those kinds of things, comes to $3,600 bucks, that's correct. Okay, I think I'm up to date now, powerful discussion. Could I suggest that any other compensation or equipment on that vehicle be part of the contract negotiations between the town manager and the independent contractor?

2:22:00 And that they bring it back to us? John, I think you probably have a thought. We have a wildlife subcommittee, and we have committee assignments, changes, or whatever this evening, and I think that the contract that we have with the wildlife specialists, particularly since it's expired on June 30th, that there's probably a number of things that should be discussed at that subcommittee level first, and then brought back to the town council.

2:22:31 The one problem we have, and I need Peter's help if we can, this request for the $3,600, that's probably a pretty immediate need, and I'm wondering if we can schedule that discussion this evening as an urgency item based upon its timeliness and so forth. The need to take action would have

2:23:04 Had to occur within the last 72 hours. Whether that need has occurred within the last 72 hours is a judgment call by the council. You would have to add the item as an urgency item under 54954.2b2. It just came to my attention the last five minutes. Mr. Searles, when did you find out that you needed this equipment on this truck from the mountain?

2:23:35 The truck was delivered yesterday. I got to see it late this afternoon. I had the contractor who does the work on our police car, sheriff, those kinds of things, take a look at the truck and put together a quote. When did he do that? This afternoon. Okay.

2:23:58 As what I'm representing today, it could be a little bit less than that, but it's far less than what you would outfit a police car with, just the basic things that I might need. I'm just trying to get it agendized so that the council can have a discussion, and if the town attorney allows me, I will make that motion. The finding needs to be made by the council, not by me, and so the motion stands. The motion's fine. Okay.

2:24:25 So can I have the motion stated so I can... Jamie, do you have the language over there? No, sure. There is magic language and we probably should have it because I never remember it. The council determines that... We have it right here. We're showing the government code section 54954.2b2. The council hereby determines that this matter has arisen since the posting of the agenda and...

2:24:53 That it be added at this time as an item under that code section because of that later. I will so move. I'll second that motion. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Yes. Yes. Besides the fact that you have some people up there. But my concern is

2:25:21 The question I'm always going to ask, so where's the money coming from, and is it really the $3,600, or was it also the request for gas? That's why we agendize it so we can discuss it. Okay. All right. Okay, so further discussion about agendizing this. If not, call for the question, Jamie. Are we? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay.

2:25:49 We are now discussing the emergency item, as previously stated, regarding the $3,600 to outfit the wildlife manager's truck. At this time, what I will do with this is I will ask for, since I have a row of people waiting to talk, I will go to public comment on it, and then I'll come back to council discussion.

2:26:14 State your name when you come over. Just a quick question. It sounds like the vehicle is a temporary loan from Rusty Gregory to Mr. Searles. Is the town investing in modifications to a loaned vehicle that will at some point be returned to Mr. Gregory? Point of discussion. I just have a comment about the state of affairs. Bill Sauser, private resident at this point, not a commissioner. You know, the amount of goodwill, free publicity, and

2:26:48 General good feelings that Steve has brought to our community. I find it appalling that this year on his television show nationally broadcast, ladies and gentlemen, the truck he's going to be driving in has a private company logo and not the town of Mammoth Lakes logo that we couldn't get out of our own way to get him a town vehicle in some way, shape, or form as an emergency item on your agenda or otherwise speaks

2:27:18 To how well we can step on our own feet, I think. No, that's not the term I would use. Thank you. I think we need to stop debating Mr. Searles. I think his value to the community has been clearly shown. We need to get out of our own ways and somehow make him an employee so that he can drive town cars.

2:27:44 The cars he asked for, if I understand it, are two vehicles that have sat under the snow storage at the town yard for two years, being devalued greatly because of their non-use and the fact that nobody has the will to shovel them out. I just am puzzled beyond belief. I know there are legalities and other things, but the fact that we couldn't get around this and do something for our own town's publicity, incidentally, what we live on is T.O.T.

2:28:09 Created by the publicity that someone like Steve brings to us for free. Sorry, I couldn't just sit there. Thank you. Good point, Bill. Thank you. Deb Perel, community member, and I wanted to say that I concur with Bill Holy, and while the Mountain was very generous to give him a temporary car, it would be great to see the whole town of Mammoth Lakes on all of that filming and to maybe put it in the contract if we can't get him to be an employee if that's an issue in there too. Thank you, Deb.

2:28:43 In answer to the question about are we putting town equipment into a loaned

2:28:50 I ask the same question. And if we move forward and are filming year after year, it's likely we'll keep the equipment in there. But as far as the technical end of it, I ask the installers and the people who own the company if the equipment could be pulled out and put into another vehicle. That's absolutely the case at hand. So to answer that question. The other thing is,

2:29:14 Our new chief of police must be somewhat bewildered by this conversation. As a first responder, working with wildlife, whether it's cougar, deer, bears, traffic collisions, again, it's not only to you guys, if I continue to serve a community, I would love to, but again, out of respect for our new chief, that he is okay with that, I'll continue to respond to dispatched calls.

2:29:43 The last comment I'd make before you guys vote is that if you see Paul Auster around town, thank him for his offer. And if you see Rusty or the Vice President of Marketing, I would really encourage you to thank those gentlemen. Howard Pickett on my behalf for helping out our town. So, you know, I'm still a little confused here. At what point...

2:30:07 Did this agenda bill change? Because for everybody out there, in case you haven't read the agenda bill, I came here tonight expecting to give Steve a town vehicle that we have in our possession. That's what I thought we were here for. And now all of a sudden I'm hearing about this new truck. And I'm confused about who made this change and why it was made. Is this your choice, Steve? Is it something that who made the change? Who decided that we were taking a town's vehicle?

2:30:37 What's going on? Skip, I would just say I was as confused as you. My day's been pretty difficult, and this whole thing, the way it rolled out, I went to my strongest hand first, a truck we already owned. Then I went to a good friend of mine, Paul Oster, I asked him. He offered a truck. As soon as Rusty found out what the need was, he stepped up and pulled the trigger. And so I never saw the agenda item. The first time I even heard of it was this morning. I wasn't invited to tonight's meeting.

2:31:06 I knew nothing about it until this morning, and so the confusion, I agree with you. Okay, so let's do this. We've got an emergency agenda item on for an extra $3,600. It may apply regardless of what vehicle we give Steve. So maybe we should simply take this agenda bill as written, look at the truck, the F-150 truck, discuss the additional monies for gas if need be.

2:31:36 And decide on that first. And then we discuss the emergency item for the additional $3,600 to make a vehicle ready. And I see I've raised...

2:31:50 Another question. Mr. Kaye. Before he speaks, could I get a clarification? Is the vehicle with the big town of Mammoth Lakes, animal control on both sides of it, that's parked right out front, is that the one that belongs to the town? But that's not the one we're talking about. Well, that's what the agenda bill is talking about.

2:32:12 I thought we were talking about the one used by the town animal control officer. That's what it says. It says Mammoth Lakes Animal Control. Okay, thank you. In letters down the hall side. Mr. America, I wonder, I've not heard a staff report. I'm not sure who's in charge here. Can you tell us, can somebody give us a staff report and weave into that what has happened today so that we have a clear picture of what it is that you want or are asking us to do and what it is that Steve would prefer as well?

2:32:41 I'd be happy to, Councilmember Wood. Councilmember Eastman at last week's Wednesday meeting brought this issue up and asked for it to be agendized tonight. For clarification, I actually did not ask for it to be agendized. I was just pointing out what had happened during that time. I look at the tapes. I did not ask for it to be agendized. Certainly, and I stand corrected. What we wanted to do is try and address your concerns.

2:33:12 The next day, on Thursday, we wrote this agenda bill. We had found out from our insurance authority that as a contract employee, he would be eligible to drive a town vehicle provided that we follow the same guidelines that we do for part-time and full-time positions. So on Thursday, we wrote the agenda bill for inclusion in the Friday delivery of the package. At that time,

2:33:40 We had just heard about this possible vehicle that the Mountain had offered Steve. We didn't know very many details about it. We didn't know whether he was going to accept it or not. Given the information that we found out from our insurance authority, we moved forward and produced the agenda bill and gave the council the option of providing the vehicle to Mr. Searles or not. And that's what the agenda bill said.

2:34:10 We wrote the agenda bill since last Thursday. Apparently, Mr. Searles did accept a generous offer from the mountain with the vehicle. The agenda bill had already been published and produced. The town vehicle, which is outside, I had it moved up here this morning. It's been serviced and is ready to go. It's still available for Mr. Searles to use if the council decides that that's where they want to go. Mr. Searles informed me that he did not want to...

2:34:39 Redeg on Mr. Gregory's offer of the vehicle. So that's where we stand right now. Council, just go. Let me. Well, yes. And could I ask one more question of Michael? Is that is outfitted already with cages, radio, those kinds of things? It's outfitted with the cage, and there is a radio inside where it would communicate with the police department. It's a scanner that would provide that ability, yes.

2:35:13 Mr. Cage. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Tom Cage, private citizen. I want to first say, have I told all of you how happy I am to be on the water district? I just had to get that in. I think Councilmember Wood is starting to go in the direction that I was going to comment on, and that is, with our new chief hired and getting his feet on the ground to take care of loose ends,

2:35:44 Maybe you might want to consider setting this aside, letting this all unfold. I'm sure Mr. Gregory in his generosity in the mountain, it's great, but I think Mr. Sauser's point was well taken. We're going to have this truck which will get some visibility and it's going to have the Mammoth Mountain logo on it, which there's nothing wrong with that, but at the same point in time I would think it should have the great logo that's behind you, which I've always loved. I think it's a super logo and maybe at some point in time

2:36:14 Soon, since this is drug on for a long time, truck or no truck, and this really affects me personally because we at Mammoth Chevron service his truck sometimes and it takes a lot of servicing because it has a couple hundred thousand miles on it. So that being set aside for a moment, I'm sure the Chief of Police, the Council, the Subcommittee and everything else maybe finally will get their arms around the serials and wildlife issue and once and for all

2:36:43 Their truck, your truck, this truck, some truck, as well as contract, as well as gas allowance, as well as service agreement can finally be put to rest and solidified and put in a nice little tidy package instead of it being so private, public, you do the service, I'll do the gas, you do the insurance, I'll get the truck. Come on, folks. We've got a new council. Let's get our act together. Let's get this solved right the way it should be.

2:37:09 Whichever way that might be, I'm not here to make that judgment, but I'm sure the bright minds that are up here can make that and get it done correctly to move forward on a long-term basis with the wildlife management program. Thank you. Tom Rupa, if you would. And I agree with what you say. The problem is that we do have time issues here. Realistically, it's going to be three weeks, approximately three weeks before a new chief of police.

2:37:38 We'll be able to get the information that he needs to address this issue. It's going to take a period of time for the Wildlife Subcommittee to meet and to make decisions. We have a situation where this gentleman has been being filmed. I got a phone call today from the producer of this footage. He's in town now. He's going to be starting to work.

2:38:04 With Steve, I think you already have a cameraman, we're already rolling footage, so we're talking about $3,600. You know what, John, and you know what, I agree with you, but at the same point in time, I think council could give direction to the town manager who could give direction to the new chief of police to say, hire him, get this thing done, I don't want to see it come up before council again, make him an employee, do whatever needs to be done, you guys have wasted

2:38:33 We've spent weeks of time on this over the last three years. You know, it's not a question of whether we need them. And I don't know whether he's going to be happy with what I'm saying or not. Steve and I are friends. But at the same point in time, you know, this has gone on long enough. Give direction. Get the man hired. Give him a town truck. Put him on the payroll. Do whatever you have to do. But quit spending all the time on it. Yeah, we can't. I suppose we can't make that decision tonight or anytime soon. I don't know what you can do or can't do. But at some point in time, I hope.

2:39:03 This council gets this solved so that you don't take up so much time. Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you. Good discussion. I think we now know where we're going. We've got an agenda bill on promise regarding the truck, and we've got an emergency agenda item before us regarding the $3,600. Council discussion. Mr. Mayor, if I may, it's my understanding, and correct me if I'm wrong, that our wildlife specialists

2:39:34 Who is not under contract with the town right now, has taken an offer from the mountain for the truck. So he's not going to, are you going to back off on that commitment that you've made? That's what I need to know. If he's committed to the mountain. I wouldn't feel right turning my back on Mammoth and what they did for me.

2:40:03 And how quickly they did it. If you want to approach that with the mountain, you can. But I am not going to break my word with the mountain or rusty. They've been two good friends over the years. So you have an agreement with them? Not a financial agreement. No. They offered the truck. It's sitting there. I pick it up tomorrow morning at 6.30 a.m.

2:40:23 And I think Les Rusty wants it back or something. I plan on fulfilling that agreement. So we move forward with that information that we have. And so the next question, as you stated, is the expenditure of $3,600. Well, I think the next question is, should we take a vote on whether or not we're going to give him the truck? Because that's what the agenda item is for.

2:40:49 Mr. Mayor, I would move approval of option one, amend the current wildlife services contract to allow for the use of the town vehicle by the wildlife contractor. With that not hearing a second, the motion does not move forward. I'm thinking we at the very least have this as a provision. Is that going to cost us anything to have this as a provision? So we'd have to come back and address this again. There's no cost associated with

2:41:24 Letting him use the truck. There is the decision about whether you're also going to provide gas and maintenance, and there is a cost associated with that. So by voting, by taking option one and voting no on it, it just means that we accept the fact that Steve has accepted another deal. If we vote yes on it, then Steve has two trucks.

2:41:47 Well, he has access to it. However, yeah, he has access. He could still use it, I mean, but maybe somebody else could. Well, my concern is if we've got a vehicle that's ready to go that he could be driving tomorrow morning as opposed to spending money to outfit a truck that isn't ready. He's not going to use it, though, because Mammoth Mountain's already bought him a truck. He's going to use the new truck, I'm assuming. He's not going to go renege on a situation where he already got one, so. Mr. Mayor, I think the issue of providing gas or fuel, if you will,

2:42:17 That type of expenditure, I don't want to make that decision tonight. I mean, I think that's an issue of discussion for the Wildlife Subcommittee meeting. My only concern with that, being a member of the Wildlife Subcommittee meeting, is that the subcommittee has focused mainly on creating a policy for which to work with other agencies and to provide the wildlife specialist with the tools he needs to do his job in that respect. We did help

2:42:48 Draw a contract and define the contract. But when it came down to the actual money issues, we believe that it was the council that would make the money issue decision. Absolutely. But there should be a recommendation from the Wildlife Subcommittee is what I'm saying, as there has been in the past. I don't want to sit here tonight and create a contract for a position of the town. We're still under budget discussions.

2:43:18 I think we just keep operating the way we have until we can get this resolved and put it back on and then we can do something, as Tom said, get a package going where we do it right from the beginning. I think we need to probably address that that way in that fashion. It sounds as though, I mean, you're already operating without a contract now. We need to get on that, get that taken care of. And then if there's a vehicle already in place, there's nothing we can do about that. So, except for...

2:43:47 Perhaps incorporate in the contract some use of signage and this, that, the other. I mean, if anything, we take it out of our marketing budget because we're getting it back tenfold, I'm sure, and then some. But we do need to make a decision tonight on the $3,600, one way or the other. I'd personally be in favor of it. It's $3,600. We get back on that for now, even if it's an interim use.

2:44:15 We'll be able to get that back long term. Would you like to make that in the form of motion? Would you like to make that in the form of motion? Yes, I would. You need to deal with... I'll second the motion for discussion. Yeah, which motion? Because we still haven't dealt with the issue that was in the printed agenda bill before we get to the $3,600. We just did. You made a motion. And there was no second. Okay, but then...

2:44:45 So there's no action. So you're not going to want to do a motion to say continue with the current provisions that says that he provides his own? I mean, you know, that's a separate issue. I think there's a motion on the floor. I just need to... Yeah. There was no second. There was no second on the motion. There was no second to my motion. On Joe's motion, but I seconded. But now... There was no second, so the motion died. I believe you declared it. Yes. But Matthew's motion was that the town...

2:45:19 Pay the $3,600 for the necessary improvements on the vehicle that will be picked up tomorrow by the wildlife specialist from the ski area. Yes, it is. Can we clarify where that money is coming from? I said marketing, so it will come out of a marketing budget. I would recommend that the staff look in the budget and find an area where they can

2:45:48 Or two or three areas where you would propose, I mean, and bring that back to us. The measure A money has all been allocated to the DMO, so I don't think we can allocate it twice. So it will come out of the general fund. Okay. Yeah, we take it out of the general fund. It's not coming out, Terry. It's not coming out. Could I ask for a second clarification from the motion maker about the issue of signage on the vehicle being part of the contract negotiations? Yeah, I'd like to see. I mean,

2:46:16 If we're going to be giving the $3,600, perhaps we incorporate that in our contract that some sort of signage from Mammoth Lakes be visible on the vehicle. Are we received in that way, in any way, for putting the town logos on your truck?

2:46:31 I didn't come to address that question. I would hope that that one maybe would be at the subcommittee level, but to your discretion, and I don't mean to be argumentative with Mr. Lehman, but if I take Oster's truck, then I'll have three trucks and two. So...

2:46:47 I'll keep driving my ratty old truck. This was just an idea I came up with to better represent my town. I didn't mean to turn into this. Your truck will be the fourth truck. There you go. Can you teach the bears to drive, Steve? Okay, I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion, Council? I do have a question. Yes. As the motion stands right now, the logo's not part of it. That's correct. So I've taken direction that that's one of the items that we'll bring to the subcommittee. The subcommittee, that is correct.

2:47:17 That's part of the contract. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Jamie? Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Lehman? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tembeke? Yes. Mayor Pro Tembeke? Yes. Mayor Pro Tembeke? Yes. Mayor Pro Tembeke? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We will move on to item number four, the Citizens Budget Committee to address the budget. You know what? I would like to take a five-minute break, if I could. Well, let's see next.

2:48:05 We'll continue on with tonight's meeting. Moving to agenda item number four, Citizens Budget Committee to address the budget format. Staff report, please. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This item was actually requested by Councilmember Lehman to consider whether or not to form a Citizens Budget Committee to address the budget format. And this has come up

2:48:40 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:49:09 Based on our experience in the prior two years working with the Citizens Committee and revising the budget format. So with that, I'd actually turn it over to Councilmember Lehman and he can maybe further address his desire to establish the committee. Yeah, I just really wanted to hear from some members of the public that have been expressing an interest to form a committee so we can basically revamp our existing budget with a new look, a new feel, and some other considerations.

2:49:38 As far as the hours anticipated, I was a little bit hesitant on the 500 hours of staff time that was suggested in here only because I don't think we know exactly what's going to be proposed. So I personally wanted to just hear from Deb Perel and any others out there that were interested on working on this committee and perhaps forming it so we could move forward on a new look and feel for our budget. We've had a, it's been a

2:50:07 Topic of concern, I think, for some time, and I would like to hear from Deb. Thank you. And John Baruch has asked to please... Okay, yeah, any other people that were interested? John Baruch, congratulations, especially to the new mayor. Glad you volunteered. What I'd like to speak to is the proposed budget committee. I think that's what's on...

2:50:40 This may or may not be exactly what you have in mind for item number four, but I'll speak to it and you can be just like the truck and you can do whatever you want to do. But first of all, I'll speak to you in favor, and maybe I will get a truck when I get done, I don't know. I'll speak to you in favor of a budget oversight committee and or a task force, whatever you want to consider it from a legal standpoint. Task force may have more creeds, I don't know.

2:51:07 I wouldn't, you were given one option the way I read it on the internet, and I would not take that option, but I would have another option number two, and I'm going to try and be as politically correct as possible, but I'm not sure. So on option number two, I've got some ideas on possibly how you would want to phrase it. Committee is, committee should be made up of financial or CPA type people.

2:51:34 The last committee we had was public people, and I understand everybody, you know, it was friends, it was ex-mayors, etc. But it needs to be people who have financial knowledge, in my opinion. It should be a small group, three to five at the most. Very critical, it needs to be independent of staff. So forget the $500. It needs to be independent of staff, or else you're going to have the same thing you have today. The interim budget, we should have an interim budget, which I think people already talked about.

2:52:03 Which meets until the committee meets and make the recommendations. The problem, and Joe brought this up the very first 10 minutes of the meeting, is that we ought to make sure that if we use the existing budget, it may be too much money. I would suggest that Town Council requires the Town Manager, who's your only employee, put a freeze on all hires and all expenditures. That the interim town budget, or the interim budget used 2009-2010,

2:52:35 With a 15 to 20 percent decrease until a new budget is approved. This eliminates spending extra money where you guys don't really have control. So that would be kind of frame what I think you should have for the option. Make some notes. In my opinion, I said this the last two or three years, you cannot continue the same we've done in past years. We've got some major issues coming up and we can't continue this.

2:53:03 There was a couple examples in the LA Times, one on Friday, July 2nd on the front paces, job report payrolls shrink, job report cash shadows on recovery, it happens on July, on the curb, which was Saturday, rebound is losing ground, home sales down 30% in one month, it's the lowest in 2001, and odds on a double dip recession in 2011 is now 3 to 1, a few months ago it was 4 to 1. If you remember,

2:53:32 Our town manager, Rob Clark, said that in one of his speeches, based on his national information, is that we were going to have a turnaround in 2010. A number of us disagreed with that, including myself, and I said that in public comment, and I will say tonight that it's not going to be 2010, 11, 12, anytime soon, especially in Mammoth Lakes. Like I said before, we've had major problems for various reasons, and we've stated in previous years,

2:54:00 The budget is not balanced. You've got a new council and you were elected because of a platform that you ran on. And one of the major things all three of you ran on was budget. In my opinion, you need to act tonight to establish some kind of a committee. And there are three people that you know that have volunteered to be on that committee, that being one, which I think is very important. And this is your first night on the job. And I think that this is a milestone.

2:54:30 For Mammoth, and I think that James made that comment earlier this evening. And I think a lot of guts for you to do whatever you have to do tonight. It's going to be something different. There was a comment in the sheet about, you know, any heads? Well, maybe some heads do have to roll. One other comment I saw in the someplace in Nintendo is that you're asked to hire, maybe you already hired this consultant.

2:55:01 To do a review. And again, it's not an audit. You're just going to spend $10,000 or $15,000 on a review of the budget. It's not an accounting review. It's a bookkeeping review. You need to do an audit. I would say the $10,000 or $15,000 and maybe you hire that person, you hire a professional to work with this new, hopefully a new committee. Just a suggestion. And I guess my last comment is a question. Why does this have to be so complicated every year?

2:55:31 Why do you guys get 50 pages, one minute before a meeting, and why do we go through this every year like it's brand new information, and you guys have to make a decision in just a matter of seconds. So those are my comments, and I hope that you use it up at committee, an oversight committee tonight to make it work, and that you don't follow the existing budget that we have. Thank you very much. Questions for Joseph? Thank you, Joseph. Thanks. Welcome new council members and mix.

2:56:05 Deb Perel, community member, and I want to tell you that I really appreciate you taking to heart the seriousness behind this issue for myself and quite a few community members to put it on the agenda, so thank you very much. I want to start with saying that my initial letter, which I think you have, do you all have the line and the agenda bill? So my initial letter outlined that I wanted to very much have us focus on

2:56:33 A budget format. I know John mentioned some policy items and some specifics within it, but for me it's really a format and a restructuring of the budget, how it's presented, how it's readable, and then the information that flows into it. It will certainly include very comprehensive and targeted information and how it should be brought in to how we...

2:56:59 Do our benchmarking, how we foresee the future in forecasting and so on. But it's really a format that I'm going for and that is what's on the agenda bill. My initial letter also outlined that I was proposing that we look at an interim budget to rush this formatting through and to get it done in a few months and then to move forward and put the budget numbers into this new format for this year.

2:57:28 After it got on the agenda and after talking to a few of you council members, I learned that possibly that would take longer through the process than I'm accustomed to in my work and that maybe some of you had suggested that you approve a budget now, temporarily or whenever you can, but that we as a committee, if there is one formed, work to

2:57:56 From now through December on researching other communities, finding the best.

2:58:02 Software format might even be Excel. It doesn't have to be costly. To create a template and then to work with the town council in presenting our milestones, our findings and staff on a consultative basis, not 500 hours like the agenda bill says, to present a document that's easily our information can go into and then move forward on defining the numbers inside of it later.

2:58:28 I sent a second, after the item became agendized, and again, thank you, I sent a second piece of information to you today, and I apologize that it was late, but it was only after reading this agenda bill that made me create this document. Joyce Turner and I have had long discussions about this budget. She has a lot of governmental experience with budget. I have a lot of non-governmental experience with budget, millions of dollars in resort areas.

2:58:58 So I would like to say that when I read the agenda bill, what came to my, what really stood out for me was the first sentence for the past two years. And in the second analysis discussion that we're continuing this process. And on the second page, 500 hours of staff were needed to do this. And I think it really missed the target of what I was talking about in my presentation.

2:59:26 I'd like to then, or now, for those of you who aren't aware of it, today I sent out, Joyce Turner and myself actually sent out, she couldn't be here, she would like to have been here, a contract proposal. The scope of the project, and I'll just read it, it's very simple, is to conduct and oversee the research and finding and or creation of a forward-thinking, clear and appropriate town budget template and software programs.

2:59:51 We will conduct best practice interviews, seek peer and successful resort input, and share the findings with Town Council and staff. Further, we will consult with staff as needed to assure viability and usefulness of these findings as well as information integration capability. This process and the outcome will include a timeline for the budgeting process to include visioning, public comment, adequate staff and Town Council time for work, input and changes,

3:00:19 And public presentation for a timely budget adoption annually. The budget itself will include forms of month-by-month variance accountability and re-forecasting tools, an executive overview, line item amounts under each section, and the ability to understand how numbers were derived, among other components. It's really talking to the format. And then I put with it a timeline that would be done by December. My contract with Joyce proposed that we receive $1 per month.

3:00:49 Through December when we think this will take. My contract also outlined that we receive travel costs as needed because we perceive needing to travel to a couple of other resorts who have offered to work with us. Further, we would like any out-of-pocket costs and we couldn't think of too much except a lot of paper and supplies. And the bottom line is this got written after reading the agenda bill but really to get everybody refocused in our opinion on what we were trying to say.

3:01:18 Which is, I'll step to any beat you think is right. I will donate my time, and I have worked in resorts on budgets for millions of dollars successfully. Joyce has worked in the governmental arena, and I also know that Sandy Hogan is willing to be on this committee with the three of us as well. So whether it's a contract, a committee, what have you, we really are looking to move this swiftly.

3:01:49 Progressively with inclusion but not time and cost for staff and share the milestones to it. And I hope that you will allow us to move forward in a swift and expedient and non-governmental way. Thank you for your time. Questions? Do you know about how many hours, Deb, of staff time you'll require, like gathering data, things of that nature?

3:02:21 We spoke about it and what we honestly feel we both have consulting companies and what we felt was that if we could get past two years in the current year just emailed to us a full documentation of budgets or however they are, we know that they have antiquated systems, we understand that, and that we could do our research to other communities and peer resorts and places that we're aware of and maybe more than we've already presented. We presented fast because tonight

3:02:47 Steve Searle's contract is another example of how this has been a rushed process and is behind the gun and so on. So for us, we would like to really not utilize staff more than consultative to ask questions, to understand some things, whether it be a phone call or a quick meeting, but then to present and get input a couple of three or four times at milestones through this process.

3:03:12 And again, our contract was really to show you that we are committed to this. We really mean it. I received well over 200 calls and emails from my first letter and then the second night together. So this is a big issue in the community. And I believe that bringing the format to a usable way will help define the information inside of it and help create better information in it also. But that's a secondary thing for me. I don't want to analyze the numbers.

3:03:41 I want to create the template to allow the numbers to be easily analyzed. So based on what you said earlier, are you looking to get our numbers from the budget we come up with, create this format, and then next year plug in new figures after a visioning or during a visioning process? Yes, and that's a very valid question because I probably confused you. My first letter wanted to do it fast and get this year's budget in it. Our proposal changes that after input from the council.

3:04:09 Saying we would do our work from now until December so that in January we would come up with a timeline as well as the format so that in January we could start the timeline for having an on-time budget adoption with all of it being done in June. And it would actually take less time from the staff and the council because the time frame would be, you know, you'd have information in advance, you could read through it, the public knows the dates that they could come talk about it, that kind of thing.

3:04:38 Creating the format and the process and the timeline for future budgets. And again, if you guys want to do a temporary one now and get a committee that's quick and we do this, I'll do it that fast for you. If you want to take the proposal and do it through December, I'll do that. I'll step to whatever drumbeat you want. I just want to change this format and I think we need to do it now. Other questions for Dan? If not, is there anyone else that would like to speak to this issue? Thank you.

3:05:10 Can't be dead. Council deliberation. I have some questions of staff. Are we, as a municipality, are we authorized to make this kind of an expenditure, even if it's only a dollar per person a month? So it's no problem.

3:05:38 Okay. The second part of that question is if the amount of money is under $5,000 or $10,000, is that within the prerogative of the town manager to make that expenditure? Well, yeah. It's not a public project as defined in 2161 of the public contract code, and it would fall within the professional contract provisions of the town code, so I think the answer to that is yes. Okay. Thank you.

3:06:09 So the financials wouldn't need to be worked out tonight necessarily. Thank you. Well, I heard two things from the two speakers and I want to address them both. John Brook had some specific recommendations. We've heard them publicly. I've heard them privately before. Many of them, or certainly in some instances,

3:06:40 Some of them came out of last year's Citizens Budget Committee on which he and I served. I don't think that's what's before us, although I think that this council needs to hear from the community as to what individual members think the priorities ought to be, because I don't think we can assume that we just know or have it right.

3:07:09 What I hear from Deb is something much different, which is that she wants to essentially make a recommendation with respect to process, format and timeline. What that suggests to me is what many of us were saying during the campaign, and that is that for one reason or another, or maybe many reasons, the public

3:07:37 has not been satisfied with the level of transparency in the process in the past. I think that if you were to speak with staff members who are involved in the budget, they understand it and they get it and they see it and they're confident that everything that we need to know is in there. Well, I think it probably is. The problem is you can't find it. It's difficult to understand. And

3:08:07 That's distinct from issues that relate to how we spend our money, what we spend it on, what the priorities are. But in the end, what I really want to achieve, and I think that a committee or recommendations to make it more transparent will go a long way toward this, is to have the community think that the staff and council, and for that matter, the committee are actually collaborative.

3:08:36 And not working against one another because what I have sensed in all of the accusations and I've made many of them over the last two years is that there is sort of a circling of the wagons approach, very defensive approach instead of something that's proactive. So if this is a way by which we can begin to be proactive and collaborative,

3:09:02 I understand those are vague words, but I really mean them literally and not defensive, then not only will the staff's job be easier, but the council's job will be easier and the public will be able to understand how it is that we spend our money and why it is the decisions that we make are being made. So I'm very supportive of the committee in terms of how we...

3:09:30 Staff it or how we place people on it. I know all three individuals. I know that they're committed. I know that in their own way they've got budget or financial experience or both or leadership experience. And what I would like to see is something different. I'm not afraid of oversight because I'm not afraid to be critiqued.

3:09:58 But I want to take the politics out of it. And I think that what wasn't achieved last year, and John and I were both on the committee, is that we had a couple of politicians on that committee, or ex-politicians, and it was very difficult to separate the politics from the policy recommendations. I don't want to see a committee that competes either with council or with staff.

3:10:21 And as a result, the limited scope of it, which is to not get into the policy issues, that should come from members of the public, is appropriate, and I'm very supportive. Whether it should be three or five, I don't know. There are lots of people in the community, I'm sure, that could fill that role. On the other hand, I don't think that we need a whole bunch of people. I think it's pretty generous of them to make that proposal.

3:10:52 For better or worse. That is, I don't know what the outcome's going to be. I'm supportive of it. Yeah. Well said. Yeah, I think keeping the politics out of it's important. I'm hearing Sandy, Deb, and Joyce are all three currently interested in working on this committee.

3:11:20 I've heard three to five people. I don't know if, you know, if it's done as a consulting type position. Can they bring their own people on if they choose? Or is it something that has to be appointed by the council or whatnot? And I would, you know, I would assume just basically look at these three right now. And since they seem to be the most active and the most energetic and trying to get this accomplished.

3:11:48 I just think that something needs to be done, certainly, and they seem to be professionals. I know that Sandy's got her experience on the government side of things as well, so she understands budgeting and she understands intricacies of government, as does Joyce, but Joyce seems to work on both sides and Deb seems to have a focus on the private sector.

3:12:12 I'm certainly interested in seeing something happen. It's very difficult for council to try to come up with, as we've seen, you know, in the last several weeks of budget, just because our hands are tied with communication and things of that nature, so it would be nice to have some outside input. John, do you have comments? I'd like to hear from you guys first. Jo? First, I would like to speak to one of the items that you brought up, John.

3:12:39 About having an expenditures freeze. We did put that into the resolution of this interim budget for the month that only required expenditures be made, that nothing discretionary be done. But obviously certain things like paying the phone bills have to happen. So that has already been put in place. Just wanted to clarify that. As far as Deb's proposal, I think it is something we should definitely take advantage of. I think the two important things are going to be figuring out how to be collaborative.

3:13:09 And I know that both Rick and Matt have said that, quote, no politicians be involved, but I think that this group needs to be working with whomever is on the Council's Budget Subcommittee. I think that that needs to be somehow worked into it. So my recommendation would be that those would be the fourth and fifth people based on whomever is assigned that later in tonight's agenda. And I would expect that group then to come back with a discussion of

3:13:41 How and when staff is included. Having done governmental accounting for more than 20 years, there are some idiosyncrasies that will have to come from staff about how funding is handled. Who's currently on the budgets? Is that you? It was Wendy and myself, but when we get to the, it can be, you know, that's open to discussion like any of the other appointments. Skip, I have two things real quick if I could. The time frame,

3:14:15 For the committee to do this work is roughly July to December. Roughly. One of the things that I hear you saying is committee versus the proposal, and I think it does have to be collaborative. We talked about consultative, but we also, Joyce and I, feel have to be effective if we're going to be doing something in any way that we really need to be able to

3:14:40 I don't know if everything has to be done in front of a committee or if we can go off and do our work in the middle. That's one of the reasons we put this proposal together like we did, so that we could do our research and do our work and sit in front of a computer for hours, that kind of thing. Okay, if you would, one more question, and that is for us to be responsible financially tonight, I would think that we would have to establish limits both on travel costs and material costs, whatever that.

3:15:10 And I wondered if you had any suggestions as to what might be a starting point for those two expenditures. I would assume that we would probably visit three or four cities, most, maybe California, maybe a couple of other mountain resorts, if they were willing to work with us. I don't know that we would both go to all of them, and I don't know that, I would think that would be the outside. I'm not sure. We could do a lot of things by the phone. It got put together very fast.

3:15:38 Because of the agenda bill that we saw. We wanted to make sure that we could be effective. And it's not our – the dollar, I think, should prove that we're not out to – I know, but we just – we can't prove something that's open, isn't it? I don't know. I would say there – at the – I don't know, maybe – I don't even know where to grab a number. $5,000. I don't know. Well, the whole thing for both people and everybody in – In reality, Deb, I'm sure as you noticed in your –

3:16:06 Research so far is so much is available on the web and so much can be handled by phone calls. Precisely, which is why I didn't know what to tell you. And that would be an outside number for both of the expenses and the travel. And if we hit it, I'd be surprised. A combined 5,000? We really are committed to this and we don't really usually want to work for free. I think this is important to my community and so does Joyce.

3:16:31 Mr. Mayor, could I kind of respond to the question about what happens in a committee meeting and what happens in research? It's essentially is if the two members of the council subcommittee are on there, it is a public meeting, but as we have done with all the ones with the Mammoth Region, Recreation Council, et cetera, there's a lot of work done beforehand and the meetings are a reporting out discussion. If you do a formal appointment of these three,

3:16:59 To a committee, it's going to be a Brown Act committee. Correct. But it would be a Brown Act committee if there's two council members there as well, right? That's correct. Yeah. But not if there were only two members of the council only unless it's a standing committee. Oh, okay. On the other hand, if... Well, but we already have that as a standing committee. Right. On the other hand, if you enter into a contract, you don't have that issue. Right. Okay.

3:17:27 After hearing that, I would recommend you take our contract, and we will come to Council or wherever you'd like us to openly report to you on a monthly basis. And that is, I think that's the direction I was going, if I understand you correctly, in that, John, in your question to Rob about Rob's spending limits, this might fit within Rob's spending limits, it sounds like. So that is one way to sort of control the cost.

3:17:57 And take care of that part of the issue. The initial proposal was to try to keep the group small so they could be quick, effective, meet when need be, and proceed forward, which I support that idea. I think that's the way to be the most effective for our group and run it as a contract. As far as reporting to the subcommittee, they have a lot of great information they have gathered over time. So at some point, I would think,

3:18:27 The people working the contract would request that a meeting be set up between them and the subcommittee. Then those groups begin to bounce information back and forth and determine how it will then be brought to council after that, if I'm kind of thinking correctly. So I think we got that through.

3:18:49 You know, throughout the process, I would like, I don't want, I would think that it also probably shouldn't go too long without some regular reports. So, at least monthly, maybe we should get something to find out what we're doing. So, let me take one more comment here from Eric. Eric Sugimura. Just another point of clarification. The agenda item looks like it's, the council's going to decide on a budget subcommittee.

3:19:19 And now the discussion seems to have turned to a contract with, it sounds like private contractors, and I don't know if the public is for knowledge or information about this, so if they could speak knowledgeably to advise the council on what they would like to see. It's a point that we're taken. Thank you. The letters have been in the paper, and a lot of the public has heard about it, and I've been at the last three.

3:19:52 Council budget meeting. Yeah, I don't know that this is necessarily timely for tonight decision. I haven't seen the contract, so I couldn't vote tonight anyway, so it might be something that we would bring back at a future council meeting for council consideration. Thank you.

3:20:23 And I would agree. So with that, staff direction is probably in order for this agenda tonight. And I think we need to see it sooner than later. So we probably need to get it onto the agenda, hopefully by the next meeting. Yeah. 21st. Yeah. And I think it's important to lay out the differences of how it would work, whether or not they just report back to the standing committee or whether the stand, you know, how we do that.

3:20:54 The options then. Okay. Mr. Mayor, you know, that brings to mind a comment. It's very important to me that whether we call it a committee or whether it's a group with whom we enter into a contract, that they be independent. There are a lot of people who bring

3:21:17 A body of knowledge to this process, including those of us who read the budget and try to get through it, those who prepare the budget, the support staff that is in the detail. I'm not interested as a council member in the minutia or the detail. I'm very much interested in having somebody who wants to volunteer to make a recommendation that would be supported in a way that we could

3:21:45 Understand the recommendation and either accept it or modify it or reject it. Therefore, I'm not interested in having budget subcommittee members on a committee. I'm also not interested in having or I would recommend that the entity with whom we might enter into a contract report to the council publicly as a whole.

3:22:11 There are two reasons for that. One, because it simply improves the level or degree of transparency as we move through that process, gives the public the opportunity regularly to comment on how this is going forward. This is a very big issue that can, I think, be resolved or we can make great progress on in the next six months and then use it to do it differently in the future. And so what I'm concerned about is that if

3:22:40 If somebody with whom we have a contract reports to a subcommittee and then, you know, that filter is applied for a report to the council that's done publicly, we're in no different shape than we are today. And because I don't know what the recommendation is going to be, except that I suspect that there's going to be a recommendation that the format, at least for the public, be simpler than it is now.

3:23:06 I just want to make sure that the public has the opportunity to be involved and that we're all hearing the same thing at the same time. And our reaction is also stated publicly. So not only does the group know what we're thinking individually, but the public knows as well. Can I just ask a question, Rick? Because, I mean, I heard that we're collaborative and working together and trying to bring all of this in. And so I think as far as, you know, I don't know what we think of when we think of the term reporting, but do you think it would...

3:23:35 Or would you be in favor of allowing them to at least meet with the subcommittee so that they get information that that subcommittee may have had in the past and then not the subcommittee reporting to us but then our contractors reporting to us. That's all. I'm just trying to keep our subcommittee in the loop and so that they can provide whatever information the contractors might find useful. Subcommittee is in the loop because by definition they're two of the five council members. Yeah. Yeah, that's who they would be contacting.

3:24:07 For information, basically, right? But I think you're right, Rick, is that the reporting be done in public session, definitely. To the full panelist. Yeah, yeah. I think what I'm saying is that I don't want to delegate to two members of the council when delegation is not required. You know, whether I'm on that committee or somebody else is on the committee, it doesn't make any difference to me. I think that...

3:24:37 I think that this can be interactive. And by the way, this may be the kind of thing where workshops are useful so that they're less formal and they can occur at 5 o'clock prior to a meeting periodically so that the kinds of questions that would, I think, be generated by whatever we're hearing can be asked and answered because this isn't something

3:25:05 You know, we're trying to change the world here. It's not going to happen in a short period of time. And I just want to make sure that we're all involved because we each, because it's on everyone's mind. Both those who were not up for election this time and those who were, who ran for council and who, including those who were elected. Do you have enough direction at this point? Yes, I can do. Thank you. Yes, thank you. Thank you. Moving on to

3:25:34 Item agenda number five, revision to the Mammoth Lake Tourism Contract, and I do believe to make sure that all the council members are up to date that there was a revised contract sent out this afternoon. That's correct. I did. Yeah, I did get it. I wasn't quite sure where the revisions were. I can explain. Okay. Staff report, please.

3:26:02 Thank you. At the June 30th Budget Workshop, we discussed bringing back a complete discussion of Measure A as part of the agenda on the 21st, which would include several budget policy questions and several other questions that came up at the meeting that are outlined in the agenda bill. The interim agreement with MLT

3:26:29 References a number of contracts in what's known as Attachment B of that. And several of those contracts are the subject of the conversation that we'll have on the 21st. Those include the Chamber of Commerce contract, the Track Club contract, the Fireworks funding, and the Inland Agriculture Group, which is the Fishing Enhancement contract. So what we're trying to do is to take those

3:26:59 Out of the interim funding agreement until the council makes policy decisions. And so I need to apologize. I said that the, well, I guess the change is in Section 3 and I have two Section 3s. At any rate, what we're saying is that items 1 through 8, which are those that are not subject to discussion, will remain the same as provided in fiscal year 9-10. But those listed as items 9 through 12, along with the associated funding,

3:27:28 Will be held in abeyance pending Town Council policy decisions. So, and that's, I believe, agreeable to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We are, you know, well actually you know where we stand on the whole strategic marketing discussion because we've made that clear. But since that is a policy decision that we would like to make it very clear that that is being pulled off the table and I think that the attachment, new attachment B that you have does clarify that.

3:28:12 The other items are items that we have contracts for conducting business. Otherwise, and then the strategic marketing funding is going to be a discussion on the 21st, and so we're agreeable that it's going to be pulled aside and we can move forward. And that the verbiage was changed. Does anyone else in public like to speak? Council discussion.

3:28:50 Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion that the council approve option one, approve the clarified letter of intent and interim funding agreement. As amended or? No, as amended by today's memorandum and agreement. I'll second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Further discussion? Jamie, roll call, please. Council Member Eastman? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Mayor Clarkson-Vaney? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes.

3:29:21 Potion passes 5-0. Item number 7, Local Road Rehabilitation Awarded Bid for Purchase of Essel. 6? 6? I keep these, I'm sorry. I checked it too early. Second, item number 6. Is that why I'm over here? Yeah, second. 6. Second amendment to the joint use and lease agreement for the use of the land and development, maintenance, scheduling, and operation of an ice rink. Staff report, please. Thank you again, Mr. Mayor.

3:29:52 The town signed a lease with the Mammoth Unified School District and the Mono County Office of Education in May 2007 to use school district land for the construction and operation of an ice rink and multi-use facility for a period of 20 years with a 10-year optional extension. The town is currently out of compliance with Section 6.11 of the original lease, which requires completion of construction of the project approved under use permit 0703 and commencement of operation by December 31, 2008.

3:30:20 Although operating, construction is not complete. The school district agreed to a one-year extension of the construction schedule through December 31, 2009. However, the town was unable to complete all phases of the project by the deadline. On May 5, 2010, the town council considered an amendment to the lease agreement between the town and the districts to extend the construction schedule through a lease amendment and phased implementation and completion program.

3:30:46 The Council requested input from the Tourism and Recreation Commission prior to taking action. The Tourism and Recreation Commission met on June 8th to consider the Second Amendment to the lease agreement, and they reviewed the materials that were provided to them and were provided to you as well. Their recommendations are that you only move forward with the Second Amendment to the lease agreement if it includes an option to purchase, resulting in town ownership of the ice rink parcel.

3:31:15 That we have the parcel appraised to determine current value. That we clarify that the language of the current lease agreement allows for a multi-use facility and is not restricted to an ice rink facility. If the town acquires the ice rink parcel, verify the option to obtain a beer and wine license for the facility under a long-term special event permit. Clarify the ability to have a beer and wine license under the terms of the current lease agreement.

3:31:41 Reduce the annual payment of the lease agreement with the portion of the payment allocated to the option to purchase. And finally, that the Tourism and Recreation Commission requests an update on the negotiations before the Town Council executes the Second Amendment, which we did yesterday at their meeting. The modifications to the lease amendment proposed by the Commission are worthy of discussion with the school districts. However, while the Town is currently the party out of compliance with the original lease due to lack of performance to meet a defined construction schedule,

3:32:08 It is important to come into conformance before the town requests further modifications to the lease related to price and terms, lease or ownership, and operational enhancements. Coming into compliance involves signing a lease amendment that extends the construction and completion schedule, continuing construction elements of the project to bring the project closer to completion by erecting fencing and gates prior to October 31, 2010, and keeping the site tidy and orderly.

3:32:35 The staff report includes two options, which are to follow the proposed Second Amendment to the lease agreement, and it also defines the financial considerations within that option. But because the commission also provided you with a recommendation, we evaluated that option in the financial considerations section as well. And to move the ice rink or to stop construction of the ice rink would mean that we have several financial consequences.

3:33:05 I think that it's important to note that there are several grants at stake in the construction of the ice rink at this point in time. If we are to move the ice rink to another location that the town owns, which would simply void all lease payments, it would still cost $1.4 million more to start on a new site.

3:33:28 With those considerations in mind, the staff is recommending that we approve the Second Amendment to the Joint Use and Lease Agreement for the use of land and development, maintenance, scheduling, and operations of an ice rink as proposed by the districts. Questions of staff? We're going to solve our options. There are really options to press forward, options one through three. And I personally would like to have a lengthy discussion with council and staff on

3:34:01 Really some of the realities of us pressing forward with an ice rink. You know, on a personal note, I just think that it's ill-placed. I think that there are a lot of complications with moving forward as there are with moving backward. Looking long term, I'd like to see some better plans in place as far as what we're going to do with multiple facilities and multiple type projects like this. It seems...

3:34:28 You know, we've found a vacant piece of land that we could do something with and we've gotten some funding for it and we've decided that this is the place to put it. And, you know, I would just like to look further into whether or not this is appropriate or not because personally I don't. I'm not excited about spending several million dollars to finish something on leased land. And it just, quite honestly, you know, I envision an ice skating rink as a place where

3:34:57 Families and people go, and there's other animation around it. You know, I recently visited South Lake Tahoe, and you've got an ice skating rink right in the middle of the village, or a village. It doesn't have to be our village, and I wasn't insinuating that, but it's a place where, you know, people are ice skating, they might be able to go grab a bite to eat, they can sit on the sidelines, have an ice cream or coffee or whatever the case may be. And so I just have some concerns about pressing forward with it, and so that doesn't seem to be an option.

3:35:29 I have questions, Karen, several. It just seems to me that option one is not just a $28,000 expenditure, but commits us to $350,000. And I'm looking at page three, hand-lettered three of the agenda bill. $350,000 to match a $500,000 grant, and that $350,000 comes in...

3:35:57 What was required to be expended in 2011-12, but we haven't identified either a funding source or even made a policy decision as to whether we're going to do that. So I need some clarification on that. And also the question in my mind is, what are the consequences of not putting up a fence, of remaining out of compliance with the terms of the lease, at least immediate consequences?

3:36:28 Well, to answer the first part of the question, in option one, it does spell out that there are multiple funding decisions that would occur over the course of several years because that is the way the new lease amendment reads is over several years you will have to commit to funding the project that was originally approved in 2007 by the council and all of the funding sources at that time were not identified either.

3:36:56 The project moved forward and the lease was signed and the construction was initiated. So you are absolutely correct that there are multiple decisions over a series of years that will have to be made to live up to the commitments of this lease amendment. The downside of not funding the fencing this year, I don't know that I could say for sure. The discussions that we've had with the school districts in the past six months have been that there

3:37:26 First of all, very unhappy that we haven't completed the project on the schedule that we originally set forward. They've also been unhappy with the way we've been keeping the site tidy or untidy for that matter. So there is a provision in the current lease, the signed lease, that says that if we don't complete or if we don't fulfill the terms of the lease, we have to turn the property back to them. We would have to basically follow what's listed in option two in terms of the consequences.

3:37:57 So there's a cost to returning the site to its original condition, to voiding the diff agreement that we have with the mountain and all of those other consequences listed in option two. So those are the two choices that I foresee is we move forward on a phased schedule or we have to return the property back to its original state. Well, maybe so, but maybe not without a fight.

3:38:27 In other words, you know, this is a problem that I think Matthew and I can legitimately say we inherited. This is pretty grim. As you know, 12 years ago I was highly supportive of the ice rink and have been a consistent supporter throughout the years, but this is pretty extraordinary. That is the commitments that we've entered into.

3:38:56 I'm not sure what the way out is, except that I don't know whether we really actually have all the options on the table. I mean, I can envision the school district saying, all right, if you don't pay the $28,000, we're going to initiate an action against you to enforce the terms of the lease and evict you and you're going to have to pay lots of money. Well,

3:39:21 Don't we have to figure out before we authorize the expenditure of $28,000 where we're going to get the $350,000 and what level of priority it's going to be in 2011 and 12? As far as I can tell, the Second Amendment commits us to doing that, and I don't see the escape clause, and I'm not ready to make that policy decision given the other priorities that we have. That's what's causing me some anxiety, and that's why I asked the question about what the consequences are.

3:39:50 There are a number of consequences that could require some action to be taken on somebody else's part. But I wonder if time is not needed. And then the related question is, is it possible to put the $28,000 out to put the fence up and clean the place up and not fund the operation for the 2010-2011 year until we figure out whether we're really going to pour more money that we now don't have into a facility?

3:40:18 That many people in the community feel is not placed properly. And the concept of not operating next year is one of your budget policy decisions. I think we all know what the problem is, obviously. And like Rick, I don't have the answer this evening. One thing that I did think of, though, just kind of sitting here, was it might not be properly placed as a facility

3:40:54 As we envision it in Lake Tahoe or any other resort, Beaver Creek. But down the road, long term, it's reasonable to think that we might have two ice rinks. One that is in a village or development format, Old Mammoth Place, Snow Creek.

3:41:22 And then this particular ice rink would be a secondary ice rink that would be mainly for competition and hockey leagues and stuff like that. It's not really relevant today, what I'm saying, but I just wanted to put that out there where it might not just be one ice rink, it might be two. Well, I think it is relevant. Everything that you're saying is because this Second Amendment, as I read it, correct me if I'm wrong,

3:41:48 Essentially commits us to spending $350,000 and therefore having to find the money in order to take advantage of a $500,000 grant and that still doesn't get us a roof. And I think the problem with having the two ice skating rinks are thinking that far forward, it's like having, you know, two or three cars. You know, it's a luxury. I don't know that we can quite honestly afford at this point.

3:42:14 And I'm concerned, too, about the long-term obligations that we're committing ourselves to. And again, as I understand, we don't own the property. We won't own the property. If we do, what's it going to cost for us to buy at that point? And if it is a secondary facility that's only used for, let's say, hockey, things of that nature, do we want to spend whatever it is we've spent $4 million for a hockey team?

3:42:41 Probably not. I'm concerned a little bit about that, so. First of all, I think that one of the problems has been that the multi-use facility has only been used as an ice rink, as envisioned and as planned, and I also inherited it, this Rick, but I still think it's salvageable if we are looking forward to a year-round multi-use facility, not just an ice rink, which is a recreation program that has a big deficit to it.

3:43:11 I think that we need to look at all the items that the Tourism and Recreation Commission has suggested and that we have also all been thinking individually, but I think that's a discussion that happens between now and not coming back to us a week before the season and saying, hey, are we running it? I don't know, and maybe my question of staff is that if we delay this until we have the policy decision on whether or not it works as an ice rink,

3:43:41 This winter, it's kind of like a hiccup that we've had to deal with the last two years is it comes back from the T&R Commission, well, we don't know what to do. I am concerned about being out of compliance because I sit on that school district liaison committee and there have been some serious concerns coming from both the staff and from the school board. I believe it does need more work, but

3:44:10 I also believe that in the measure R we just allocated for the fence earlier this evening? No. No. Okay, we recreated reserve. Okay. Yeah, that was my question was why were we funding it then if maybe there were some other possible consequences for the ring? And it was explaining some contingencies. Okay. I believe the biggest

3:44:38 Issue under all this is working it around to a position where eventually the land that a multi-use facility sits on is town owned, which is a bigger thing that cannot get decided tonight. Right. So then is it possible that the proposed second amendment could, is it possible to not have to sign a second amendment and simply allocate $28,000 to become in compliance with the lease itself?

3:45:06 Why do we need this right now? So the original lease, the signed lease, says we were going to complete the entire facility by end of 2008. That's what we're out of compliance with. What we created was the Second Amendment, which instead of saying we're going to complete the whole thing, the slab, the roof, and all, two years ago, we're now going to complete it over time in phases with certain segments being done by certain time frames.

3:45:36 That's what the Second Amendment says. Could I ask a follow-up question? Karen, I think that there's not only an issue of compliance with the school district, I think there's also a compliance issue with the terms and conditions of the grant because there's a land tenure requirement. Right. Well, we have three grants that we've been using to build what we have today.

3:46:10 Two of them have been spent already. They're about $270,000. And we have to have a lease of 20 years or longer in order to have taken those grants. If we don't continue on, we'll have to return the money from somewhere. There's a third grant that's $500,000, which we have been approved to use for the slab. That's what the $350,000 additional money is required to match.

3:46:36 Returning grant money obviously has consequences. Not only do you just have to return it and find the money to do that, but then when you want to reapply for other grants, often you are looked upon with a black eye because you have failed to perform in accordance with the grant provisions to start with. So there are consequences to that as well. Well, you've laid those out in the agenda bill, and I don't quarrel with those, and those obviously have serious financial.

3:47:06 My question is, alright, it's not just the $28,000. We were supposed to have completed this project by the end of 2008. We're now a year and a half out. And the question is, if we were to fit this into the overall recreation plan for the community,

3:47:35 The strategic plan, the stuff that the Tourism Commission is working on to ultimately make a decision and then live with those consequences, those financial consequences. Are we not better off than signing an amendment that definitively commits us to spending $350,000 in 2011-12? I think I understand what you're asking, which is

3:48:00 To not have to make a decision today on the Second Amendment or the $28,000. Well, $28,000 is pretty easy for me, but the big one is the one that I'm struggling with because I don't want to make that in a vacuum. I want to make that within a larger context of the recreational needs of the community and where things ought to fit. So if you would, if you, I might suggest, if you would like to direct staff to return to the school district to try to

3:48:27 Negotiate something different than what is provided for you in the staff report. You could do that. I don't know where that will go, but if that's what you're concerned about and that you would rather have some time to be able to consider the overall planning approach to recreation facilities and that you need X number of months to do that, I could certainly go back to the district to ask that. And that's essentially option two as presented in the bill.

3:48:57 And in fact, isn't the Park and Recreation Commission, isn't part of their plan to do their, what do you call it, your overall park planning probably within the next year? I believe that will end up being in their work program. They have a couple of different... I mean, they've been frustrated not having done that previously, so I think it's my understanding it's a pretty high priority.

3:49:28 Yes. Okay. So as you say, Rick, you know, if we can buy a year, just trying to keep options open because I don't, because I don't like what I see because of the dollar cost. So Rick, what you're saying is buy a year for all of it or go ahead and do the 28 and make sure we clean it up and look nice and we're in compliance with that part of it, which puts us in a stronger negotiating position.

3:49:59 The 350 we can't commit to at this time even though that's really related to the grant. I mean, that's not even the school district we're dealing with. That 350 is the grant. And as I recall, that has to be expended by when? March. March of 2012. Yeah. I guess what I'm saying is without further thought and public input, I'm having a, even though I'm very supportive and have been of that rink, I'm having a very hard time committing.

3:50:32 Effectively committing today to expend $350,000 in order to get the $500,000 and in order to remain in compliance, recognizing as I do that there are all kinds of consequences if we simply take a bulldozer and return it to its former state. So I would suggest this item is scheduled to be on your closed session this evening if you'd like to not continue with this discussion.

3:51:03 Discussion, discuss price and terms in closed session, we could do that. I mean, Ms. Terry, you have something to say. Yeah. Terry Stout, Parks and Rec Commission. We were told that this was already decided in closed session. I'm going to state that right now. That was what was said to us last night at our council, at our commission meeting. We were told that this was a done deal. And that's why I have no other commissioners here. Who told you that? That's not exactly what I said. Okay.

3:51:37 It is not only $350,000. You have, we were told last night, because there was nothing given to us. We had no paperwork. So we were told that in 2018 that that's when the roof was going to have to be put on. So it's not just $350,000. Then you have, if you looked at some paperwork that was given to you, I wasn't given to the new council members, but the previous council members.

3:52:06 There was, you're looking at about a $2 million expense in the long run. And so it's not just a matter of coming up with $25,000 right now and $350,000 next year. There is much to be considered. And if this is going to go into closed session, I wasn't going to say anything because you guys were debating it and you were doing fine, but I can't let this go into closed session without stating those things. John?

3:52:41 Yeah, you guys are going to go to closed session. So there's one important thing I think that the commission said, and it hasn't really been addressed, is that they wouldn't even consider this if it wasn't purchased. What's the attitude of the school district on the purchase? Are they interested at all? So we have applied for a grant that would allow us to purchase the property. In order to have applied for the grant, we needed a letter from the school district.

3:53:11 That said they were interested in having a discussion about selling the property. There's no commitment there, but they're willing to have a discussion. So my point is the fact that we're going to spend money, and it's more like maybe $2 to $2.4 million. If you go back in history, we spent, we have put two ice rinks in it for roughly $1 million apiece. We shut this one down earlier because we had a problem. We've got another $2.5 million to spend on this ice rink.

3:53:38 We're out of compliance in 2008. Okay, what are they going to do to us? I mean, you know, we're going to spend at least $350,000, but it's not the $350,000, it's the $2.4, the $2.5 million that we're going to spend. I think you need to make a business decision. Do you keep putting money on this thing or do you say, you know, maybe even though Rick said he voted for it, maybe this is what I voted for, I don't know.

3:54:07 You guys are going to go to closed session. I think the purchase option is the thing that's really up in the air. And it sounds to me like, you know, unless you know you're going to purchase something, why would you even continue this? And why you put the fence in for $28,000? Talk to the school district, shut it down for a year, and see where you end up after you guys have a little bit of time to think about it as a new council. Just a thought. Let me add one more thing. Sure.

3:54:34 You know, another consideration is, you know, I think we just approved a project for Mr. Demetriatus where there's an ice skating rink in the middle of it. You know, we've got 8,000 visitors to the one we're going to, and we're anticipating that to increase, but what's the impact going to be when he's got a nice animated one right on the side of the main drag? I think it's going to put us out of business. And, you know, that's just one more thing to consider, you know.

3:55:01 To have a discussion about a purchase, you know, this is doing more of the same thing. Are we obligating ourselves to a grant to open up a discussion that may never even take place, and then we're going to have to give grant money back again? So, you know, I think we need to have a set plan of something we can actually accomplish before we start taking grant money. This is a problem we've been doing for years now, and I just have a little bit of a problem with it, you know, without having a set plan in place.

3:55:28 So if I could clarify, what I told the Recreation Commission yesterday was basically what's on the last paragraph of page 2 in your staff report, which is that the Council had discussed the option agreement and that the issue was that we were currently out of compliance and that before we take up additional lease terms, we should become in compliance. I did not say that the action was done because obviously you would have to make that decision tonight.

3:55:59 So having said that, what the second amendment actually says is that we would have to agree to a $28,000 expense for fencing this year. But it says that phasing for the completion of Phase 2B through Phase 4 is contingent upon future funding by future town councils. The town council agrees to use good faith efforts to fund the completion of the ice rink.

3:56:28 However, this contract cannot bind future funding decisions to future councils. If town has completed at least Phase 2A of the ice rink by October 31, 2010, the town will diligently pursue funding to complete construction of all future phases as described in Attachment A and continue operation of the ice rink pursuant to the joint use and lease agreement.

3:56:49 Should Phase 2B through Phase 4 not be completed by said dates, Town, District, and MCOE shall enter into good faith efforts to revise the progress report and the terms of the completion of each phase of the ice rink consistent with community-wide needs and values of all parties. Failure to complete Phase 2B through Phase 4 by the completion date shall not be caused to automatically terminate the lease agreement due to the investment of over $2 million of local and taxpayer funds in the facility.

3:57:15 If no agreement to revise the progress report can be reached, Town shall restore the property to its original condition in accordance with paragraph 7.1 of the original lease agreement. So in other words, you're not committed to having to spend $350,000 next year. However, there are other things that play into that decision. For instance, the grant expiration of March 2012. And to take one more step, although it may be only $28,000,

3:57:43 It means you've invested just a little bit more if you do end up wanting to pull the plug at some point in the future. This sounds like a $28,000 option to spend more money, and that's what I'm, yeah. I'm thinking we should look at option number two. I would agree. I tend to agree with John at this point. This is definitely, it has turned into just a financial nightmare, but in response to some of the questions that are brought up here, Matt, yes, there's going to be an ice rink built in the middle of town, it appears.

3:58:13 We missed the perfect opportunity for community benefits. We just gave it away. We gave it away on that one. We could have had those community benefits could have helped finish the ice rink that we need. So that's water under the bridge. The location of it, we are a resort community. Just don't forget the community. We've got kids in three schools directly across the street. We've got a college on the same property within a walking distance.

3:58:40 Rob will attest to the amount of trips he makes there, I think, each winter to pick up school kids and drop off school kids because it's what they use. If we had been able financially to finish the project and put the roof on it and program it like we had anticipated, the operating cost would drop dramatically, dramatically, you know, because...

3:59:02 One, the cooling system wouldn't have to work as hard. We could program it to create some kind of income and revenue to help support it. We could use less people to operate it. It wouldn't require as much maintenance. You've got the school kids there that can do school programs, which once you get that...

3:59:19 ...into place than possibly going back, and as they want more programs for their kids, we would have been able to possibly renegotiate the price of the lease or somehow work that into the price to offset it because they want to use it for their kids. They might want to use it for events in the summertime to fundraisers for their different school systems and things to make this multi-use center valuable to them. So you need employees. You've got a college right there that has...

3:59:46 Kids that need part-time work, the workforce is right there, they can walk to it.

3:59:51 The kids at your school can walk to it. Any other place in town, they have to be shuttled. We can program all kinds of hockey leagues and figure skating in the morning. We could do, you know, high altitude training for other type of figure skating stuff. If it were programming, that's the dream. That's our goal for it. But it's turned into a financial nightmare. So we have to figure out how to best handle that financial nightmare. I hate to scrap it, you know, at this point. I hate to scrap it.

4:00:20 Yes, Lake Tahoe has one in their village, but you know where they had it before and where their current one is? It's in the middle of their community. They've got a big indoor ice rink right in the middle of their community. That's what they started with because it was programmable, it was a good place to put it, it was the right place to do it. And likewise, you know, when we look at the tellurides and all that, they're...

4:00:40 Their rinks are just outside of their communities and in their parks. The Whistler one is outside of their town. None of them are in their town. I ride the gondola a lot in the wintertime, to and from work, the village gondola. I frequently see the kids sitting there at the bus stop waiting to go down.

4:00:58 The guests, the visitors, the kids that knew we had a rink, they've got their ice skates on around their necks, and they're excited because their parents can put them on public transportation, zip them down here, and they can walk to the ice rink. So it's in a good location. Yes, the second rink, why that's being built, I don't know. But we should focus on this. I don't think we should give up on it. We need to look at it longer. We can't make a decision tonight, I don't think. We'll talk about it later.

4:01:26 But I don't think it's something that you give up on. Mr. Mayor, first of all, I concur with that which you have said and have a long history hearing those arguments over and over again. We've not been able to pull this off for a variety of reasons. Also, remember that that was placed there in anticipation of it being part of and adjunct to

4:01:55 A recreation facility right next door that's been planned, that's been drawn out. And so I don't – I hate to see it fail as well. My concern is not to consider this in a vacuum. And so I would actually not be supportive of option two. Instead, I'd be supportive of meeting the commitment, the small commitment that we have made in a –

4:02:25 Contractual commitment to, if nothing else, show a measure of faith to the school district who is our landlord and ask the school district to give us a little time to have the T&R Commission, actually the Recreation Commission, help us take this on so that it's fully vetted.

4:02:56 I just think it's because, John, you actually have it right. It's not the $350. It's $4.4 million is what it is to get it done. It's $4.5 million. That's what the agenda bill says. And so that's so big that I think that we need to have it properly vetted before this new council.

4:03:20 And I don't mean to put it off, but I also think that we should probably meet the financial commitment as was recommended by the staff. You're 100% correct. If you're not holding up your commitment in the beginning, why would anyone want to negotiate with your work with you in the future? So you're 100% correct. Motion? Sure.

4:03:49 Just one comment. You mentioned the fact of giving something away, and I think you're referring to possibly the CBiz or whatever. If, what I understand, there will be a nice rink being built this year in Mammoth Lakes, which is on Old Mammoth Road, is there a possibility to maybe possibly do some kind of a joint venture just so they have a nice rink?

4:04:16 And not have this one working just so that you have a nice drink in town. Just a thought. We can look into that. John, you had asked for a motion. My question to staff is, are we not – I'm really reluctant to wordsmith an existing agreement and instead would rather request that staff bring back a proposed –

4:04:50 amendment that is consistent with what this council wants to do and I don't know what the council as a whole wants to do but I've indicated that I'm prepared to meet that small commitment to keep things going and then have a process over the next three months where the commission, council and staff fully vet this so that the public knows what it is that we're actually getting ourselves into.

4:05:18 And by the way, the other thing I'll mention.

4:05:47 I'm not counting on any private developer putting in an ice rink, and that's not part of the – that's not – that won't influence my decision as to whether we have one or whether we don't have one. I heard in the old man with place hearings that nothing's going to be built for five years at least anyway, so this is a now problem, and therefore that's not part of my thinking. So I think that it is direction to staff to possibly bring us back.

4:06:17 A different option that might help us meet our short-term commitment and also give us a way to vet the entire process of costs and the steps and procedures for what might come in the future. Is that pretty much? That's what I'm suggesting. If everybody is in agreement with that, we'll give that direction.

4:06:47 And we will move on to item number seven, local road rehabilitation and award of a bid for purchase of asphalt concrete material. Thank you. Good evening, Council. Ray Jarvis, Public Works. Agenda item number seven on your agenda tonight addresses the town's road rehab program for fiscal year 2010-2011.

4:07:20 Staff is recommending that Council consider awarding a contract to granite construction for asphalt concrete materials. That contract is in the amount of $397,000, $397,698 to be exact. Further, we are recommending that Council consider fully funding this year's road rehab program as anticipated in the proposed budget.

4:07:49 So that we can continue working on the roads throughout the rest of this summer and into next spring. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Questions for Ray? No questions from Ray? Questions from the public? No questions from the public? Council deliberation? Mr. Mayor? Mr. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council approve option number one.

4:08:22 Items 1 through 3. I have a motion. Do I have a second? I'll second the motion. I have a motion and a second. Further debate? With that, Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Aisman? Yes. Councilmember Layton? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Clark Tim Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Agenda item number 8, council appointments to commissions and committees.

4:08:51 I was just going to suggest is that there is one additional one that I'd like to add when we go through this, and I think there may be some that we take off because they haven't met. That was my good thought also. So what do we need to add? Well, my thought is that there needs to be a recreation, reorganization, or strategic planning subcommittee of the council that what

4:09:19 In the last year, Wendy and I kind of morphed into that because the reorganization of restructuring came out of the Budget Committee, but I think it needs to stand on its own. I concur with that. So I guess that's under local issues. And I also wanted to clarify under transportation that on the LTC, the third position has been held by John Armstrong. That was a mid-year.

4:09:45 Change, so there are really, there are two council members who sit on that plus one community member appointed by council. Okay, looking through the list, I see one. There was one other clarification. We found out today that LAFCO, which is under menus, requires two members plus alternate rather than one member. Yeah. Sorry, I'm going to mention that. You say two members plus alternate, Rob? Two, correct.

4:10:30 Joe, can I ask, you had mentioned earlier about a Measure R steering committee. Is that new? No, the Measure R steering committee was actually a group of citizens that were appointed and went through a facilitation process two years ago. It was not, it was formed, they did their process, brought it to us, and then it was abolished, but it did not include council members.

4:10:59 But however, in the future, I think that this Recreation Committee, whatever we're going to call it, is most likely going to be involved in recreation issues. So that would replace or, yeah, take the place of Measure R Steering Committee? That you, reasonably, you had mentioned it earlier. Well, yes, but the Measure R Steering Committee did not have council members on it. Oh, okay. Okay, and so if we look under land use, when was the last time the airport land use

4:11:33 Commission had a meeting of about two years ago, three years ago. It's been a very long time. I will report that from the LAFCO meetings there is discussion about updating the airport land use document that belongs to the county, but I believe it can go through the existing committees. Okay. With that in mind, we had myself and...

4:12:02 Well, sorry, let me go through another one. The OHV under the intergovernmental relationship, OHV, OSV, Coordinating Council, myself and John, never met that I know of. Not in four years. We can scratch that off of our list, I do believe. I'd like to add the Recreation Reorganization, have two council members on the Recreation Reorganization Committee.

4:12:32 Put two on there. Okay. What was that? It's going to be under local issues. It's going to be a recreation reorganization committee. We added it, so you just need to go. Okay, sorry. And, Rob, was there an answer back on whether or not the JPIA was required to have someone on there? I'm sorry, I didn't get that. The Southern California Joint Powers Insurance Authority, the question I had asked you on Monday of whether or not we were...

4:13:02 It could be a staff or it had to be a council member? I don't have an answer for sure. Peter thinks it's a requirement that there be a council member, but we will have to check. Coming back to the land use issues, should we go through and see, just start going down through the list? Now, Rob, we've got two council members and an alternate on the MAFCO commission at this time, do we not? I think you have one council member.

4:13:41 Yeah, so the difference would be that two council members and then also identifying an alternate. And I'd like to not be on that. I could be an alternate, but I'd like to not be a regular. For the information of the new council members, I think we met four times in the last year. Is it on a particular day of the week? Yes. It was on Wednesdays at 3 o'clock.

4:14:16 So it was preceding a council meeting. Locally? Yeah. Yeah, it's run by Scott Burns. Where are the meetings held? Right here, Town County Conference Room. And I'm willing to stay on it, but I guess we need someone else. I typically have a trial calendar or a hearing calendar on Wednesdays that will impact my availability. I'll go on it. Okay. So we're going to put Matt as the second council member.

4:14:48 On to the land use. And John is the alternate? Yes. Okay. I think we are scratching the airport land use commission at this time. Mr. Mayor, you cannot do that because they do meet on a regular basis and they actually do have some upcoming items. Can we just go to one? Do we have to have two people on it? The way this is written indicates to me that it has two members. You do have to have two. So I will stay on that. It never meets.

4:15:19 Go on it. I'll be on it. Okay. Thank you, Matt. The Mono County Collaborative Planning Group, any changes in that or are we good? Unhappy. Okay. The Council Board of Supervisors Subcommittee, we need another member on that. Is that a liaison committee? That's the town-county liaison. I'm interested in that. That's a good committee.

4:15:50 It meets at 1.30 on a Thursday, like right after, what is it? Is it always in the afternoon on Thursday? Yeah. That's the way it's set up right now. Thursday morning is a bad thing. Okay. So, yes, you're good. Yes, I'll do that. Rick is good on that. The League of California Cities, Wendy was on it, and Nia was our alternate. It's a great one for new council members. Mm-hmm.

4:16:22 I think we've all taken our turn on that. Have you, Rick? In my prior life. I think I've had it a couple of years, actually. Good for you. Matthew, if you'll be the original one, I'll be the alternate. Great. And I think the issue that comes in that if John and I have to attend, then there's a good chance we would miss meetings that we have with Eastern Sierra Transit and the same word, not so government.

4:16:51 They meet once a month. They meet once a month. They meet in different cities throughout the desert division. So you could be anywhere from 1,000, 29 homes. California City. No, they live here. It used to be quarterly. I thought it was quarterly when I was. Is it quarterly? Is it monthly? I don't think it's monthly. It's quarterly. I don't think it's monthly. It is quarterly, but it does meet. Actually, you go to some pretty cool places.

4:17:18 Well, they come here once in a while. They come here, but you get tours of air bases. Sewage facilities. I'll jump on that grenade. Steady sails in college. So we got Matt and John on the bait.

4:17:37 Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, I'm happy to stay on there, John, likewise. Transit Authority, I'm sitting as the chair, so I think I should probably stay on that. I'd like to stay. John, it's good to stay on that. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. That is an excellent opportunity. Speaking of sales. Who's the sales over here? Yes. I mean, it's really a good deal, but it's a commitment.

4:18:06 A time commitment, if you will. John, do you recall when they, what day of the week they meet? I want to say Fridays. I want to say Fridays. You think, really? The last meeting I went to was on a Friday. If no one is interested, I just have these trial calendar or hearing calendars that go Tuesday, Wednesday, and Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday. Because I would do it.

4:18:44 Well, why don't you do it and I'll be the alternate. Okay. Thank you. The League of California Cities Legislative Delegate Program. I'll stay on it. Good. Yeah. Mammoth Unified School District Board Liaison Committee. I'm happy to stay on that. As am I. And Joe is too. Southern California Joint Powers Insurance Authority. What did we just decide on that? So Michael did confirm that we have to have a council member. Okay. I'll stay on. All that is is a once-a-month email and a couple surveys.

4:19:19 But there should be an alternate, I guess. Alternate? Going twice? I'll be the alternate. Okay. Council Water District Board Subcommittee, I'll stay on that. I would also like to. County Committee assigned to work with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. Is that for our atomic power plants?

4:19:56 Let's reinstitute it only if it's needed. That sounds good. Okay. Mammoth Lakes Housing Incorporated. I'm interested in that one. Okay. Matt, would you have to be an alternate? Yes. What about me? What about you just took John off of it? You're taking on other things.

4:20:24 Town Inyo, National Forest Liaison Committee, I'm happy to stay on that. Is someone like to join me? Oh, I'd like to volunteer on that one. Transportation, Caltrans, District 9, External Advisory Liaison, John. You've never met that I'm aware of, so I'll stay on it. Stay on it. LTC, John and I cannot sit on that because we are on ESTA. And I'm willing to continue.

4:20:53 That only needs two people. Yeah, we need one more. What days do they normally meet? It meets Monday morning once a month at 9 a.m. Off in the full morning. Yeah, I'll be happy to be an alternate. Well, we don't have an alternate for that. We need a third sitting member.

4:21:12 Do we need three? I think the public member is an alternate, right? No, I think John's fully seated because he replaced Wendy. We can do it with one council member and a public member or do we still need three council? No. Two council and a public member. I guess it's us. Bacon, Lehman, and John Armstrong. Chamber of Commerce. I'll be on that. Can we go back? I want to just be clear. Am I on the...

4:21:43 LTC? Yes. Okay. You and I are both. No, wait, wait, wait, wait, no, because John Armstrong is an appointed member. I thought we should have three. Yeah, but John's one of them, and I'm one of them, so we only need one more. Oh, John's on there too. Okay. John Armstrong. We don't need three council members. No, we switched it. Yeah. Okay, so I'm an alternate? No, you're not even that. No, not even that. Okay. Is it laying around here then? Yeah. When we can't meet Steph,

4:22:11 Is our alternates. Yes, that's right. So we've got Matt on Chamber of Commerce. The town, ski area, liaison, that would be Joe and I. Public Art Commission. Do you still need those? Yes, we do. They are talking about possibly, we're still talking about going to maybe every other month or something.

4:22:41 On that? Quarterly? Quarterly, yeah, every other, I think we, that's still in discussion, but it hasn't really been determined, is that correct, Mark? As needed. As needed, okay, even better. So you need one more for that? So we do need one more. And usually what Neil and I did is we tag teamed it, one of us could go, or sometimes it wasn't split it up, but it was one and or the other. Well, if there aren't any other volunteers, I'll take it. Okay.

4:23:12 Depends on what else I... It depends on what else I'm able to get on. Uh-huh. Because I... Because I got three that I'm interested in. Maybe with Lake Trails and Public Access? I'm interested in that if nobody wants it, but... I'll stay on it. That's fine. That's fine. Okay, Rick. The Ad Hoc Multipurpose Facility Working Group.

4:23:35 Well, since it didn't meet, I'm willing to stay on. I think it's going to be more important. Yeah, I'll stay on there. The budget subcommittee. So, Jo, you would like to stay on that? Unless there's a burning desire from our two new council members, to be honest. I'm interested in being on that committee. Okay. Matt, what do you think?

4:24:05 Yeah. Okay. Okay. Route 2 or 3 Relinquishment Committee. I will stay on that. Don't you want to go through that? I was going to say, I would be on that if no one else is interested. Okay. Recreation and Reorganization Committee. I'm interested in that as well. As am I. Okay. Go on, Rick. Very good. You also need to appoint someone to be the Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

4:24:38 For the Mammoth Lake Tourism seat. Oh, yes. The seat on the board. That would be. Okay. Isn't that one, that's what you, that's what you. Matt would like to be on that. MLT, okay. Who are the two or one? There's only one. Oh, okay. There's one seat for the town. And then we have the wildlife subcommittee. Oh, yeah. We do. John, you want to be on that? I'd love to be on that. Do you think so? I'll stay on it. Give me some balance, Skip.

4:25:11 I'm going to attend those meetings just to watch. What truck? Have you got all that? We just need a, just a, so we've made the, as noted, we have made changes in our council appointment. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All opposed? Motion passes 5-0.

4:25:47 I'll, for the record, I will, I'll make the motion. Is there a second? I'll second. Thank you. Okay. We need a motion. We need a motion. Motion, second. And we get to vote. Okay, we go. Councilmember Eastman. Uh-huh. Councilmember Mulaney. Yes. Councilmember Wood. Yes. Mayor Brooks and Bacon. Yes. Mayor Harvey. Yes, but it wasn't a money item, so I don't think we, did we have to have an individual vote? No, we did a vote. That's not a vote. Okay. Double vote it. Yeah, we covered it for sure.

4:26:22 All righty. Consent agenda item. I didn't ask earlier if anybody wanted to pull anything. I'd like to pull 13 if I could. Okay. Anything else? Mr. Mayor, I'll move for adoption of consent agenda items 9 through 18 with the exclusion of 13. Second. I have a motion and a second. On 13, I wanted to pull that. Don't we have to vote? We need to vote. Sure.

4:26:54 Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Councilmember Lloyd? Yes. Mayor Parton Bacon? Yes. Mayor Hartford? Yes. And number 13, John, you asked us to pull that? Yes, I pulled it because, and we've read the staff report, items 1 through 3, I looked at them as telling us how we can't do something as opposed to how we can do something.

4:27:24 I had a question in the first paragraph. It said we expect the path to be completed from Whiskey Creek to Twin Lakes in the next several weeks. Does that mean two weeks, ten weeks, four to six weeks? End of July. Thank you. So in the next three weeks. End of July. I agree with number four that closures are going to be necessary to complete the work on the tunnel.

4:27:59 And including the slurry seal and the stripe of the path, that's understandable. I don't have any problem with that. I do have a problem with 100% closure of the trail. I think that if you have a chance to view the work that's being done on there, I don't know what the percentage is, I'm guessing, but it seems like we're working on 1% of the trail at any given time. I think what we should do is...

4:28:27 To close the area of the trail, whether it's the undercrossing, the tunnel, or the fencing, we can close those areas that we're working on, but I think we can keep a great majority of the trail open when work is not being done on that section of trail. And we can certainly address that with the contractor. What I was trying to point out is that at this point, the town has not accepted the project, so it's really not the town's.

4:28:54 So we can work with the contractor. And it's not officially open. I mean, obviously we can't do it officially. Well, frankly, when we opened it last weekend, it's tough to close it. It was tough to close it even before that. But we can work with the contractor on that. Their concern, obviously, is their own liability. So we just need to address how we're going to stage those closures.

4:29:21 Extra cost to the contractor for doing that. But we can work through that with them. Okay. Thank you. I just want to make sure we don't do something that delays the completion because they're so busy doing other things. Because, you know, I'd rather see it get done. No, we don't want that either. I have that issue and I have additional costs. We're money crunching down if we're putting, you know.

4:29:44 Any additional money into it over and above what we've done, I have some concerns. So I just want to make sure of those two issues. That if there is a money issue with the contractor, that it would be brought back to the council. And what I was addressing in that memo really related to what we had to do last weekend. And as I say in there, the contractor isn't looking to be paid for that. But if we were getting into a mode of trying to open and close the path.

4:30:10 Every weekend until we have the lower section done, then it's potentially an issue for them, and it's a cost, and we're spending our time opening and closing, and we wouldn't rather be working on it. Yeah, but we're not doing that. We've got the standards up, and again, wherever... We're getting there. The fence is not complete yet, but... Right. I didn't mean fencing, I meant the cones. The cones. Yeah. Thank you. Sure. Further discussion? Is that your motion?

4:30:39 I don't know what we need to make a motion on. No. No motion. Okay. It's just kind of an update. Excellent. All right. Thank you, Ray. Consent agenda item. Does anyone have any or registered demands? I'm sorry. Does anyone have any questions regarding the registered demands? If there are no questions, we will move into closed session and report out any decisions that have been made in closed session afterwards.