TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2015

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 7 hr 49 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

1052 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 I was just going to say, yeah, the change to each square. Yeah, yeah. And this one has a number of changes. I just came back. On which one? Oh, right? Yeah. Oh, we can write those notes. Yeah. And this one has a number of changes. Well, and also, one of the kids' control. Oh, change since you guys make a set.

0:27 Yeah. No, it's changed since these are the original request. These are the original request. Oh, okay. But that's a change, too. If this is, if this is, if this is mine, whatever we're going to be suggesting what's voted on or whatever, we'll put, we'll write it in. That way we know what's. I have a red pen. I have a red pen. We're not judging. I know that. I think you might, that we can use to write on that. Oh, that's not great.

0:52 You'll know the difference, huh? Yeah. Janet, can we have a break kind of built in similar to last time? Well, I was going to follow this one. Use the same thing to take a break after number, after Bucky 16. Where we had the break. Yeah. This one.

1:18 I think it was Lucky 16. Is there a Wi-Fi right here? Yeah. Yes. Mammoth 1, right? Yeah, the Arabic 1. It's called Town Suite Z? Yeah. And Mammoth 1? Mammoth 1.

1:41 Right? Yes, sir. I tried that way. I don't think it's case. So did you want it? You're going to be able to tell the writing. I have.

1:59 I don't think that's the other thing is can be spelled correctly. And what we can do is I can even while we're deliberating if there's different announcements and then we'll put the final number forward once it's voted for them. Okay. Joe, we'll call for a joint or I, nay.

2:27 It's not like it's a consensus vote, so I think you take hands, you know, you have eyes and nose. Yeah, I don't think we have to do roll call. I was asking if we were taking a roll call vote or if it's an eye and a... I think it's an eye and a no. And it's a majority vote. Do you want to do this? Oh, no, thank you. And I have a commentifier. You guys let me know when you want me to start listening. You have to push it.

2:58 Thank you. So Mammoth 1 for Town Suite Z.

3:26 Yeah, he went to make copies for the audience.

3:53 Thank you. How are you, Michael?

4:14 I did. I did get it. I got it from Michelle. How are you? Good. It's very pleasant to see you. I made coffee. Thank you for that. Absolutely. I did get it. Thank you. Now, we're going to go in the order, Michael, we're going to go in the order, so 30s last, so it might be late in the day.

4:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

5:11 Thank you.

5:41 I have to get them all in the right place.

6:04 Yeah, let's go ahead, Brent, I'm sure he's on his way, so we can go ahead and get started.

6:38 We're going to wait for a few more minutes for one of our board members to arrive. So we're going to give him a couple more minutes to get here. And then we'll go ahead and get started. There were some copies made of the filter.

7:32 Document that has been put into the back of the room? It's right there. Oh, right there in the corner? So if you didn't receive that and you want to have a copy of it, it's right here on the corner of the table. And just as a reminder that we will be going through the order that we went through the initial request review schedule.

7:55 We'll be following that schedule and reviewing as such.

8:19 That's new not to put you on the spot, but did any communication?

8:59 Everybody is curious. Getting lunch. Well, was he bringing lunch for all of us is the key. That would be the key. He didn't even bring lunch for Betsy. That would be the key question if he brought it for all of us. If everyone wants to know the drinker machine, I work with the program. I'm sure that's not. Well, I'm sure a lot of things are not. Latest is late this afternoon.

9:22 Verizon will be back up. Really? Yeah. They're patching it into digital 395. Wow. Yeah. I don't know. You know, they didn't want to be part of digital 395, and now they're finding out they should have been. All right. Let's go ahead and call this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation to order at 110.

9:52 PM, and we'll go ahead and have roll call. Drea? Here. Terry? Yes. Joe? Yes. Brent? Here. Dana? Here. Thomas? Here. David? Here. And is Rich? Not joining us. So I'm going to open it up for public comments in just a second, but I do want to take this moment to acknowledge

10:18 Just the horrific events of the weekend and the fact that many of our good friends and neighbors lost a lot of everything over the weekend. And word that we have from emergency services from Mono County is that they are still accepting donations, you know, clothing, bedding, supplies, and I just hope that we, as

10:46 We always seem to do in these situations that we're able to rally to support our friends and neighbors who did lose everything and encourage us to continue to just be in touch with emergency services and with Mono County and being able to show our support as much as we possibly can and appreciate those who have responded and were able to help out as they could while the situation was actually occurring.

11:14 It's just a tragedy, and it's kind of a reminder that we do live in this awesome natural environment that sometimes we just don't have any control over, and where we can support one another as best as we can is where we come forward as humans and where we achieve as humans. So I just hope that we just pay attention to the needs that our neighbors are going to have and that we can help out as best we can.

11:40 So with that, I'm going to open it up for any public comments on items that don't appear on today's agenda. Okay, we will move on to administrative items. The first one that we have today is the review, deliberate, and consider approving funding recommendations for the project request forms that were received for the Measure R&U interim funding cycle.

12:09 and before we get started a couple of things that we want to go through and just set the set the schedule for today the you all received the what we called the evaluation criteria those who submitted request forms received the evaluation criteria and I just want to go over that with everyone so that during today's deliberation you are all aware of what we are we this board are

12:39 speaking from. First of all, this was called the interim funding cycle, and as such, it was designed to be limited in scope and in amount. This was approved by the Town Council as we went to them with our proposed interim funding cycle process.

12:58 It's intended to serve as a temporary stopgap until a new comprehensive process is approved by the Council and put into place hopefully by the fall of 2015. As we deliberate and evaluate today, we're going to be guided by some priorities that have been outlined and defined not only on this document but previously, and I just want to remind us of what those are as well.

13:28 Consider those projects that, if they're complex and they're outside of the realm of what this interim funding cycle was intended to pursue, we're going to potentially set those aside. If we set those aside, we might look at setting aside what we call a reserve funding amount to go towards those projects that are set aside. If that funding, as we're calling it, reserved, is approved,

13:58 Then the applicant may come back outside of the funding cycle for additional funding as their complexity of the project is addressed and we move into finalization process. I will note that there aren't any additions to be made to the original funding amount that is going to be held in reserve once that's set aside that is in place and any additional requests outside of that reserve that is set aside for the complex projects.

14:27 comes back during the funding cycle that would be established for this fall of 2015. That is specific to what we're considering complex or early stage projects. Additionally, I just want to remind us that we are looking at the leveraged funding opportunities that we have with this. As was noted in our scope and instructions and as was noted on our evaluation criteria,

14:53 This core component of MLR's emerging strategic vision is that facilitation of better partnerships and coordination among the town organizations and supporting projects that add long-term value to the community and develop shared resources for other groups, events, or projects. This priority, as we've just advised, this leveraged funding priority is going to figure prominently in our deliberation during this interim funding cycle.

15:22 I also want to note that MLR has begun a strategic planning process. And as such, MLR is looking to, those of you who have played basketball will understand this, we're looking to make a pivot. We're looking to pivot. And we're pivoting away from some previous processes that may have been not lined up with the Measure R and Measure U ordinances, the language of the ordinances.

15:51 We're pivoting towards a more strategic use of the limited resources that we have in front of us. Measure R and Measure U is not limitless. It does have dollar amounts attached to it, and it's not an ending amount. And as such, in this pivot away from an ad hoc to a more strategic use, we're going to find ourselves really diving into some of these request forms.

16:19 and asking a lot of questions of ourselves and seeing if it lines up with the direction that has been provided us by legal counsel of the town as well as what we identified as our evaluation criteria here today. So this strategic use of the dollars and lining up with the language of the Measure R&U ordinance is going to play heavily into

16:46 our deliberations today and the direction that we're going to take. So this was intended to be interim. It was intended to be a stopgap until we were able to get the strategic direction out there. I'm going to acknowledge again the work of this MLR board who has taken this all very, very seriously and has taken it to heart as to what has gone on previously and this desire to go towards a more strategic direction. And I want to thank

17:16 My fellow board members for the work that has gone into this. And with that, I think we're ready to go. And unless you guys have anything else you'd like to add? All right.

17:28 So we're going to dive in. And for number one is the town's special event trolley. What we will ask is the applicant to come on up to the podium. We may have questions of the applicant that you might want to answer. We may not have questions, but we want to give the applicant the opportunity to be at the podium in case we do have questions. Again, as a reminder, this isn't a...

17:55 Presentation by the applicants, we've already had that through the request forms, this is where we get into our deliberation. And so, Special Event Trolley form number one. Dana, can we just say, there is another opportunity, correct, for applicants to make a statement of some kind in front of the council when this recommendation is made? Thank you for reminding me. We may...

18:22 the funding recommendations to the Town Council. On February 18th, the Town Council is scheduled to receive our funding recommendations and they will have their own deliberation.

18:32 and vote to approve whether to accept our funding recommendations or not. As such, during that time, and I'm turning to our council member because the structure of that meeting may not have been yet established, but there will be an opportunity for the applicants to make a comment or some type of provide feedback to the council as needed. Yes, we have not really worked out exactly what we're sending forward, but presuming that we're sending forward.

19:02 lists in categories that we might have and with our justification for the decisions. But yes, there's still public comment within that. On the 18th. Any further questions? So let's go again, sorry, number one, special event trolley. And we'll start with...

19:22 Our filter worksheet where we basically have asked three questions. First of all, does it fall within the measure RNU ordinance? Number two, let's describe a public benefit. And number three, let's answer some of the public project filters that we've identified. Whose project was this? This is mine. Yours. You want to go ahead and... Are we, just a kind of point of clarification for our process, are we going to work through the filter for each one, kind of one by one, or can someone move to approve at any time?

19:52 Someone can move to approve at any time, but I think we want to start with Filter 1, Filter 2, Filter 3, and make any recommendations at the CPIT. Okay. And am I declaring my answers to the question to start? Tom, do you want me to try the first one just to? Because we haven't tried it, but let's start with Measure 1.

20:17 Does it fit the Measure R&U ordinance? It fits you. You. Now that's what we have is you. Are we in agreement on you? Are we going to go, it seems like maybe one person should just make a case for the whole thing and then we can have a deliberation one by one on rather than, because most of these are pretty amorphous on a lot of fronts. That works for me too. So then public benefit? Public benefit is enhancing public transit. Down below. Yeah.

20:45 What about under A2A and 2B? You know, because it was so straightforward, I didn't fill them in on my form. I answered yes on mine. The only thing that I think we need to confirm is what the committee had recommended of one year funding, not three. Right. And that was just because of, you know, not wanting to get into long-term commitment without knowing future needs.

21:11 So with that. My only other remaining question, and this may have already been answered, but what was the mechanism for, I mean, there's like a $7,000 contingency, right? So what if there's unspent funding at the end of the year? Where does that go? Well, Teri or I can answer that one. It's only spent if it's used. So if somebody applies for funding that wasn't identified, then they would be funded. If there's anything left over, it just stays within the measure you.

21:40 Got it. So it doesn't go anywhere unless it's actually applied for and approved. Got it. Yeah, because it's all on a reimbursement basis. So essentially we're saying up to, but we're saying $24,000. Just for point of clarification also for the public, we will be voting on these individually, one at a time, because later on we're going to have some recusals, and so we will be voting on these one at a time. So I would entertain a motion to...

22:10 Take any action as such. I don't know that we need motions. I think, well, you want a motion for each one? Okay. We're going to have language in there. Okay. So I move that we approve for just one year at $24,000. I'll second that motion. Move the second to approve the town's special event trolley for one year at $24,000. Any further discussion?

22:40 All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, motion passes. 7-0. Yep, one year. Okay, number two is the town's annual maintenance for facilities and initial, again, does it fall under Measure R and Measure U ordinance? I said yes. It's actually these...

23:13 The way it's presented is that these are requirements. Right. Almost by definition. It pretty much falls into yes. If you'd like. Now, do we need to identify how much is coming out of R and how much is coming out of U? And on my notes, did anybody else categorize them? Do you have them categorized how much you want out of each?

23:47 I didn't find that. It says right here, so we have... That's previous. I didn't see the breakdown. It is not broken out from what I can see. Right. So Stuart, do you have an idea of which one you like out of which one? Number two is split. So the way it worked before is if you look at maintenance, maintenance,

24:20 The rationale applied previously was when the track was funded, which is Whitmore, two-thirds of the funding came from Measure R and one-third came from Measure U, so we applied that same percentage. So we could say, if you want, for the 25,000, we can divide that into thirds. Two-thirds would be Measure R and one-third would be Measure U. Trails End Park is all Measure R. Oh, wait a minute, wait a minute. Oh, okay.

24:47 Trail Sand Park, okay, got it. Yep, is that right? Yeah. Yeah. And then maintenance items is all Measure R. I'll be looking at it. There we go. So the 2,000 for maintenance items is solved. That's 2,700 from, because there's too many sets to say, from Measure R. Yeah, we rounded it up and rounded it down. Actually, it's pretty bad, but we, so 8,300 for you.

25:19 And the $2,000 is R. Yep. And then the $12,000 is R. And I'm assuming the administration would be from the source of the funds. Yeah. That's how it would go, right? Yeah. And the audits are split in half. Correct. One's R, one you. Right. So would you say $16,000? I don't see the audit cost on here. $7,000 under administration.

25:49 3,500 each, right? Question 6, and it's in the full title. I get 335, something like that, out of R, and the rest out of you? Well, not counting the admin, because we don't know the number. So, I got 34, too.

26:21 Now on top of that, there was a question that came out of the Allocations Committee about process, about invoicing and reconciliation. And the town came back with specific language about their recommended process and their written answers. I'm wondering if we want to...

26:37 Deliberate on the language of this process now. My suggestion is we defer that to the Reconciliation Committee because the Reconciliation Committee has already agreed to come forward with a process that applies to all awards. Okay. Sounds good. So the caveat then is that the process by which the town is reporting on this needs to complete the law. With whatever reconciliation. Yes, whatever reconciliation.

27:06 Recommends to hear that Council approves, but yeah. Right? Same thing? So we just need to make sure they line up with it. Right. So Teri, you have 34? So I move to approve the $46,380 for maintenance and administration of Measure R and Lee funds for the Whitmore track maintenance for R to be two-thirds of that cost at this to be approximately

27:37 Teri, Teri, before you go any further, I don't think the 380 goes in there. I think the 380 is per application and it's separate. Isn't it? I was going to specify that it's admin, but it's all in the same application. I know, but isn't it 380 per awarded application, which we don't know the number yet, so we can't include it. Per application. I thought it was a pretty odd number. Yeah, we'll know that. We'll have to come circle back at the end. Right, okay. Sounds good.

28:07 Okay, so I will go ahead and move to approve the $46,000 for approximately, for $34,200 coming from Measure R covering two-thirds of the Whitmore Sports track cost and the $12,000 for the trails and park and the $2,000 for maintenance items and $11,800 from Measure U with

28:34 $380 in administrative to be funded for each application that's been approved. Second. That's right. Moved and seconded. 34-2 comes out of Measure R. 34-2 was right. And 11-8 is you. Okay. Is there any further discussion? Moved and seconded. All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, that passes. 7-0.

29:12 All right. Let's move on to item number three. And this is the Whitmore concession booth. Concession stand, concession booth. All right. Does it fall under Measure R or U? I said yes. It was Measure R. Public benefit, serving the attendees who are participating in activities out there at Whitmore.

29:39 There was a question about the incidental value of this because there is going to be that benefit to those groups who are getting to use the facility, but the fact that the facility is being built is money is not going directly to those groups, but those groups do get to use the facility for their fundraising elements. So that to me was a secondary or incidental value. Project filters all the way down.

30:06 I'd like to make a note on this. I thought this was really ingenious that they had the school engaged in the designing. That was a great use of their skill sets and their equipment over there. And I also thought it was great that the groups are going to get to use the concession stand when their events are at them. I thought that was a nice idea also.

30:28 Question, yeah. I think we need to include the discussion that maintenance of this facility comes from the proceeds of the nonprofits using it, that it is not something that's going to come back to us as a separate maintenance request because it is stated that way. Right. And then I'm also a little bit concerned in the last step of the policy that is stated in the Q&A is that if nobody comes up with it, staff is going to operate it. I don't think we can commit town staff.

30:58 To operate the concession booth. If there are not non-profits who want to use it connected with their events, then I don't think it's open. It doesn't operate? Yeah. So one of the discussions that we had is that funding from revenue generated by some of the sales of the product at the concession stand, some percentage of that gets set aside for maintenance and upkeep of that facility. Correct, but I think that needs to be clearly stated because it was...

31:31 Yeah, I think that needs to be clearly stated. Because the question about coming back for additional funds to maintain it. Because it's now been built with R or U. Did we talk about whether it was R or U? R. Yeah, okay, we didn't say that for sure, though. Okay. Thoughts on that? I think my other question is just so we were to correctly, because I'm not sure if we can dictate whether or not the town usually staffed or not, but we can recommend.

32:07 You know, that portion that did proceeds from. So that actually funds this project and it's going to really come back to Town Council to vote on budgets. Correct. On their budget. Yes, that's what I'm saying. But I don't want anybody to go into it who is saying that if the nonprofits don't show up, we're still going to build it. You know, that kind of a thing. And then to have it sit there. Has this been an issue at the Shady Rest? No, but it's the same groups.

32:37 And as we know, my concern is we have a limit to the number of volunteers we have in town. But I do think we have a very strong interest from those groups that are going to be down playing at the field and being able to accommodate the players as well as the spectators. Just let me know if you want me to comment. I guess I would say that, you know, if the...

33:01 If the town, I don't think the town is going to go down there and run this, but if the town has the funds within their regular budget and that's what they so choose is to run that concession loop, then I think that's in their purview. It's not for us to say yes or no, but I would say that measure R should not be impacted for the operation of that concession loop. That's a good thing. Well, for the operation or maintenance, right? Or maintenance.

33:37 Kind of looking at this as a one-time funding opportunity from Measure R for the construction of this facility. Right. Do you have a question? I'm trying to find the name. It's a one-time. It's in the Q&A. Oh, it's the Q&A. Yeah, it's in the Q&A. Got it. It's 3B1 and actually 3A1 as well.

34:19 And, you know, I will say that I did ask, I spoke to Grady, and Stu may want to, you may want to. I'm just reading the notes. But Grady said that in previous areas where he has worked, they have had something where they've asked for 10% back, and typically towns kind of always end up waiting that when it comes, they're asking 10% for maintenance, but it becomes, you know, we're working on our.

34:49 That does not mean that that's what we have to suggest. I'm just saying that you said that it has not worked previously because most of those groups come back and ask for it to be forgiven and pretty much always be forgiven. Not here, but in other cases. Well, and that's why I like your comment that we say that Measure U is not impacted for either operations or maintenance and then it's up to those groups and the town to work out if there's some other, yeah. Measure R.

35:17 Sorry. I've got one question for Stuart first. Phase two, the permanent potential of the permanent structure, what's the timeline? The timeline's really, I think, up to the MLR board and the Recreation Commission to come together and talk about that project, much like Charles Ann Park and those kind of larger projects that, you know, we've been working on for several years and so it's...

35:43 Probably a question for all of us, right. Yeah, it's really the kind of next phase, I guess, after this interim phase. When would the high school be ready to build it? They've been calling. They've been ready. So what we're doing, since you've asked the question at once, there's actually formatted plans for 10 by 10, 10 by 12 structure. It's already set. So we're going to print those off. We kind of buy them. We'll take them over to the school, sit down with them, and go through them with them.

36:13 Our engineers and Hayes and Grady and the crew. And then we can get an equipment list, a material list, work on a timeline, see if we can get this done. Really, our goal is up by summer. Yeah, that would be great. Absolutely. And this project, you know, because it sits in Whitmore, is still part of that Mono County maintenance agreement too, right? So it's actually part of that whole package that we're in that 50-50 cost share split with the county for the maintenance of those fields and facilities. So we're confident we'll be able to...

36:41 Maintain this facility without really, you know, impacting out user groups. Right. It's an incredibly low price tag. Yeah. And it is a one-time funding request. Yeah, and I thought the leveraging of funds and going into the community was an awesome idea, and I hope we see more of these projects in the future. So is there a motion? Sure. I'll go ahead and make a motion to approve the $16,000 for the Whitmore concession booth with a caveat that Measure R would not be impacted.

37:12 By operation or maintenance costs, this is a one-time funding. I will second. Tom? Moved and seconded to approve the $16,000 for the construction of the booth. Any further discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0. All right, let's move on to item number four. This is Vulcan Brothers Skate Park.

37:40 So the first filter on this was does the project fall within the requirements of Measure R or Measure U ordinance? Yes, I feel it does. It's part of the town-owned facility that's currently managing. Is there any debate about that? Well, I want to ask you a question. I wanted to discuss whether or not this one is a complex item that would be deferred.

38:06 And I don't know if that comes before we go through the filter worksheet or not. We said complex would float to the top, so thanks for being able to. For a couple of reasons. This has, whatever happens here has to fit in with Trails End Park, which has been delegated to the Recreation Commission to work with MLR to come up with a plan. And I...

38:34 looked online and tried to find copies of these plans and things so we could at least look at them and I'm afraid that without looking at the whole area as one, we've got a pathway going somewhere and I don't know that we want to make a decision in absentia of knowing what's going to happen with the other half.

38:52 Putting it into complex allows us the opportunity to do that. And you'll remember when we had the Q&A, there were two things we questioned, is whether or not it was prudent to be putting in landscaping in a drought. And also, I think there is the question to be answered is whether or not the landscaping can be done without a pathway and be a much lower cost. So those are my reasons that I would put this into complex, which would give us the opportunity to work some of that out.

39:22 in the next couple of months. Any additional thoughts about the complexity of this project and putting it into the complex bucket? You know, the challenge is, and we're going to face this with several of the things we're going to talk about here, what's complex and what's not complex, and also trying to derive some end-use results and some things like completion that come before us. And my concern is, in this one, do we have the funding that we do? If we stall on this right now.

39:51 If we defer ourselves, is there dollars down the road, or is it something that will come to a park conclusion and move this project on is my concern. It's going to come up with several things that we discuss here from that standpoint. It's, you know, what's complex and what's not complex. You know, I go a little both of it. There's things there, but is the vegetation my hesitation? No. What trails on park? Yeah, what's going to happen at the very inside of trails on park? But at the other time, we've got a project that could be done and gone where we're looking at the client for saying, okay,

40:21 It's interim, what falls later, what falls now. So I kind of mixed in between. I kind of lean towards this non-complex at this moment. I recognize that there's different items around it that could be, but to me vegetation is not a big issue from that standpoint because the water district may not allow anybody to have any water for anything. There may be no vegetation. It's great that we're going this winter.

40:41 But does it complete that far end of the park or does it complete the project is where I'm trying to look at? Is this a completed project by that time or is it still an ongoing project? Go ahead. I was just going to say I share your concern and I would like to see this move forward from this board. However, I would put it under complex project and maybe use the reserve clause we developed.

41:07 Consider reserving some funds here to follow up on some of the concerns that Joe has and others might have, but just don't get in the way of completion, because I was satisfied by your guys' answer that this is pretty close to shovel ready in a lot of ways. These are just at the detail level, not at the kind of fundamental level to resolve. Yeah, well, no, I mean, it's the same one. I agree. I'd like to see this move forward. I worry about the timeline. At the same time, I think...

41:36 It would be great to be able to say, okay, we're committed to it, let's reserve some funds, let's look at those plans, make sure everything's fitting together, and then circle back and let it, you know, recommend that we take it out of reserve with certain contingencies. Can I ask this clarification? If we recommend to put something to reserve, we go to town council and make a recommendation, and we're saying those funds are...

42:01 Can pull out any time at that point, time that the project is done? Yes. We're saying that as, so if the questions are answered the next two and a half months, you're still going to hit this construction season, but you found out what level of water restrictions we're at, and we found out these other things, because I know the water board's going to be discussing that on the 19th. So it does not preclude anything from moving forward. It just sets it aside until those answers.

42:25 are coming forward, or the plans are complete, the strategy is in place. And just to go to the next step, at that point in time, let's say the plan's complete, are we going to make a recommendation that's satisfied our recommendations to go back town council, or are we going to hurry back town council to spend money? We would be going back then, we say this project is now ready to go. So it comes back here. Yeah, it comes back here before council. That's in our criteria language. Yeah. Right. And I guess I would just like to add that I'm...

42:52 Concerned that the leveraged funding might not be there if we don't go ahead and move with this, forward with this. I guess I'm a little confused why we would wait for the reserve fund and then possibly delay the plans. Teri? Okay. I would say that I would feel more comfortable putting this in as a complex and reserve. You know, it is one piece of this part, and so one of the conversations that you were having is,

43:23 What do we need to do for the entire park? That's Trails End Park and the Volcom Park. And I realize the funding is here for this. And so I, you know, I guess I'm looking at this and saying, do we need more than just the one picnic pavilion? So is it more cost effective to build just the one picnic pavilion instead of three other picnic areas? Is it more cost effective if we're going to do this to put some more money into doing the entire?

43:48 Caving area instead of the one section. Okay. You know, I guess these are some of the questions that I would really like to answer. If we can answer those pretty quickly, and the answer is no, we want to go with this, then it would be able to move forward because it would still be in reserve. So I'm not looking at holding it up, but I think that I would really like to sit down with Rec Commission, with staff, with NLR, and look at the whole picture and see where we're at. And if it's a matter of it's going to be more cost-effective to wait.

44:18 Put everything in all at once, then it comes back in the fall. And so then it would delay that. But, you know, I don't know. I just think those are questions that I would love to have answered, but I don't know that we've gotten those answered. That's just my concern. Stu. And then the plants. I was just curious if there had been any more information from the Water District or...

44:42 We haven't received anything. As I said, they've announced it publicly that they'll be deciding on the water restriction level on the 19th of this month. So it's probably more of a general discussion than what we're looking at. But I think I would just offer up that we started off this discussion at the beginning of this meeting about the strategic use of the limited resources that we have and where we have the ability to set aside on a reserve.

45:07 funding for this project should it be determined that holistically the entire Trails End Park, Volcom Brothers Skate Park, Little Brothers Skate Park, Water District, Town, everybody has looked at that and agrees this is the next phase it needs to go, this is what it's going to look like, this is how we're going to deal with the landscaping issue of it, or not, or it's determined that

45:29 Holistically, something in this doesn't line up first, and maybe it's second or third. I think that there's value to having this strategic discussion about the park, and not, it doesn't preclude from moving forward, it just says, let's get some more answers before we say, yes, go spend this money on this little piece of a much larger park.

45:53 So I'm leaning towards the complex nature of it, the set aside and the reserve and getting the questions answered, coming back to MLR to then go to the town council for approval down the road when it's all in place and ready to go. And that we would help facilitate it so that it moves along in a quick fashion so that it's not delayed through the summer, through the fall. Yes.

46:18 Because I also think that there's some additional opportunities to talk with JLA and Volcom and others about the long-term support of that facility and how that agreement looks between the town and all the other parties involved. I think there's some even more strategic opportunities that lay out there with this as well that can be explored. And just out of curiosity, what kind of a timeline do you think that would...

46:43 For the town to look at this holistically, and for the Parks Commission, and the Recreation Commission, it's on their priority list, it's on their list, and in fact, we have a directive to be talking, we, MLR, has a directive to be talking with the Recreation Commission about trails in the park.

47:03 Betsy, would you like to add something? Just Betsy Truex from the Recreation Commission. This discussion will be on our March agenda in terms of looking at the larger vision for Trails End Park. But I also do want to mention that the commission did direct staff to go ahead and apply for these funds for now because we are just anxious to, you know, continue to move forward and we've had a good partnership in the past with JLA and we just want to continue that. Thanks. Well, Betsy, before you leave, do you think that there's anything within our...

47:32 The concept of putting things in complex when there's more details to be worked out but the money can be released would hinder that discussion in any way? I think it's fine as long as we're all just cognizant that we want to move forward with this project this summer and this upcoming construction season. So I think as long as we're all just working on that timeline, I think it would be okay.

47:56 Yeah, I would say we could even build in the language that as soon as possible we should hold a community-wide workshop of the various, you know, rec commission, town, all the various contractors, look at the plans and establish a timeline. Well, they're going to be addressing it at their March meetings. That's an opportunity to put a timeline together. Perfect opportunity. Yep. Betsy, when do you think you would have more of an idea? Well, our March meeting is on the 3rd, so I'd say March.

48:26 The afternoon of March 3rd. Oh, I thought you guys moved to the morning. We did. We did. We moved to 9 o'clock. 9 o'clock. But it is already on our agenda for the March meeting. Perfect. So I think it behooves us, based on whatever it is that the council does on the 18th, is that our meeting on the 26th is we essentially assign people to getting anything that we've put in reserve to kind of lead it to completion.

48:54 Like attend the March 3rd Recreation Commission meeting where they're going to discuss this, etc. I think that timeline works for us to move things quickly and to let Council know that we're not, Reserve is not a black hole. It's a, there's more questions to answer. Please. I really like that idea. I think part of what scares me of the Reserve is that it could just...

49:18 No, no, that was one of the things that we don't want to do anymore. Well, and I guess I'm wondering how that would be different if we just said, okay, we're funding it with these contingencies. I think it's because it's cleaner and the...

49:33 We don't really have that list of contingencies. Speaking with my council hat is we don't really know what all the contingencies are at this point, but if it's cleared up between by the April Recreation Commission meeting, then it can be on the second meeting in April for council when it's on its way. Well, actually, I think it's a good point, Jerry, and I think we're going to cross this bridge on a couple other projects. And the idea that we would begin to establish that if we're going to put something in reserve, it comes with the contingency that all the ducks be in order.

50:03 by summer construction or, you know, that we would get to a place and obviously there's so many contingencies on this one it's hard to say but that if we don't reach a place where we're letting these funds go by June 1st or that it would then get deferred to the fall cycle. I mean I don't have an answer for that but just to build in some kind of

50:29 I think we're putting our personal integrity on the line when we say we will get them accomplished, but if you put a date, then we'll have something like last weekend happen when nobody could email anybody else or call. But we can't hold things in reserve indefinitely, that's my point. So we would say, you know, this is for six months, and then if for whatever reason, you know, those documents don't come forward, or we can't agree, or the contingencies just get...

50:56 Crazier, then we have to revisit it in the next cycle. Correct. Correct. Yeah, because I almost, I go along with it, I'll say that all it goes right to the next cycle and say, in our fall cycle, we, more permanent measure, we look at that and say, is this reserve appropriate at that point in time? Right. Are we making the right choice? Yeah. What's the construction window look like, exactly? Nine snow months. Summer, as soon as possible. You know Jane, she'll want to get this thing done, you know, by May. Yeah.

51:27 Just so everybody can use it too. There's some really good project items in there. I think they all tied really well together. We met with that group last week, actually two weeks ago. So all the contractors came out. We did a walk around. Everybody's engaged. Everybody's got the timeline. We also indicated from Volcom they want to renew their contract on a more permanent basis. They want to look at building kind of a monument sign on Meridian 2. So they're really into getting this thing moving in kind of lockdown. So it's a great project. It's another good community project.

51:56 The pieces that go into this holistic view. We have the piece executive. Right. What's the timeline for that negotiation? Okay. It's just moving onwards as soon as I want to kind of get more engaged in the process. You know, Jane kind of holds the key to a lot of that, right? Understood. Yeah. But we'd appreciate that. So I think if there's any items that, you know, do want to come forward, we have that March 3rd commission meeting. These are all Recreation Commission, you know, approved projects. So, like I said, if you're going to talk about the next item too.

52:25 Might be fine, you know, coming back and getting this on the agenda and we can get this thing wrapped up. So I'm hearing that I would move that we identify this as a complex project, reserve the $60,300 and commit to working with the Recreation Commission and other parties to release those funds as soon as possible.

52:57 Is there a second? I'll second that. I'll second. Wait, wait, wait, wait. David, Paige, second. And may I suggest that we also assign or somebody volunteer to take this project on? Well, my thought was that we assign it at the 126 meeting because it will probably not be the only one that falls into the complex bucket. That's not an oxymoron. And that we would then...

53:25 Okay. We've committed that when we have that meeting based on whatever it is council does. Because I don't know that we need to do this before council has actually made the determination of if they like that. Or if there's, I guess I'm just wondering if there's any follow-up between now and then as well. Probably more after that. Between now and March 3rd? No, we mean between now and the 26th. Between now and our next board meeting. On the 23rd? Is it our board meeting on Monday? On the 23rd. 23rd, sorry. I'm in the wrong month. Yeah. That's all right.

53:54 That's not coming to the Reclamation until the first meeting in March. In March anyway. No, but it's not going to Council until the 18th either. Yeah. Okay. Can I just, since this is the first one that we have not holding, we're putting in a reserve as opposed to maybe reducing if there's any other common on this? Are we just doing straight deliberation and voting? Deliberation and voting, unless, I mean, I don't, we haven't set it up for that type of...

54:20 You know, public feedback at that point. Okay. So, deliberation. So, we have a motion and a second on the table to Who is the second? I'm sorry, David. Thank you, David. To set aside the $60,300 for the Bolton Brothers Skate Park and commit to working with the Recreation Commission to identify the holistic plan of the park and keep it moving forward. Is there any further discussion?

54:50 Just from my standpoint, I'm still kind of delivering it in my head from that standpoint, because this is something that's deliverable that we can have. I just want to make sure it doesn't get, I think that's where a number of board members I'm hearing is, will it come to fruition fast enough and what's the best move forward? I don't have an answer for that, but I think it's a project that could be very useful to the community if it comes together. That's why I think that language is good, that we're committed to work with the various parties.

55:17 Ensure that those funds are released as soon as possible. I think that's the best, kind of the best way forward, unless we wanted to take one stronger step, and that would be to sign a date of some kind. But that would be arbitrary. Yeah. I was just saying, because first of all, this is a recommendation to council. Council could say yes or no. Council could say fund it. We don't care. Right.

55:40 But I think, I think we are stating we have a commitment that at our next board meeting any that fall into the complex bucket have someone assigned to shepherd them through, expedite them. We can have a discussion at the next board meeting. Yeah. How we can handle it. Yeah. That's on us. Yeah. So that really, the commitment was not part of the motion, it was just discussion. Okay.

56:06 As an organization, MLR is committed to working with the Recreation Commission. We have not assigned an individual on that yet. We can do that on the 23rd. We have a motion to second. We have a motion to second. No, we have not taken a vote yet. Is there any further discussion? All right. All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0. Moving on to item number 5, this is the Multi-Use Facility Group.

56:35 So I'm going to ask the first question. And I'm going to make the case that this one is also complex. Right. It has a lot of moving parts, and I realize that the previous allocations committee had talked about approving it with a lot of contingencies, but I think that this idea of working through the complex ones is a better way to go about it. The first issue that makes it complex is the lease. As you all know, Dan Holler managed to

57:05 Take a spill, and we did not have the closed session at the last council meeting. It is scheduled for next week, for the 18th, for the council to discuss options on the lease. It then goes to the school board later in the month, but since that's property negotiations, I do not know whether or not that's a quick solve. You know, there are many, many pieces of that, which of course I can't discuss, but I see that that's an issue. I think the shortfall...

57:35 of the fundraising money. I believe it will happen, but I would not want this board to be recommending to council that they fund pieces where they don't have all the money because this town has a huge history of doing that, coming up with false money and then falling short and having all kinds of problems down the line. I see that it's also one that can fall into a

58:03 Quick turnaround, but I just don't believe that we have enough of the answers at this point. And I think that another issue that was brought up by the Allocation Committee was maintenance, long-term maintenance, and whether or not we were going to, because it's part of the proposal, whether we're going to commit to that without any kind of plan, maintenance plan put in place.

58:34 Any other thoughts about the complexity of this one, put it into the complex bucket? I just disagree with Joe in terms of the fundraising portion, because I think I just saw they raised about eight grand this weekend, even though they didn't have a tournament. I know, but there's 85 to... Yeah, there's always a challenge portion, but there's a lot of things. I'm concerned about the school's portion, and what might or might not happen in that, I just don't know how we, if it was all our property, would we want to go without our property?

59:03 And that's part of the part I can't discuss. Is there any update on the lease situation? There will be a closed session next Wednesday the 18th for the council to look at options of an offer or to begin negotiations with the school district. Then their board will have a closed session later in the month. I can't remember the exact date. So what we do to look at is long-term impact.

59:33 To Measure R, we're putting this through. So I agree that it's complex. So the lease is an issue. Maintenance, if we're putting a roof on, it extends the season. So what does the operation look like, usage look like, and what's the impact to Measure R? Is there going to be one on operating at extended hours and extended time period? So those are all the things that we need to look at as we're looking through the...

1:00:01 answering all those questions for a complex project. When the town decides to construct something, they go through an approval process that says, we have the plans, we have the design, we have the engineering, we have the maintenance, we know where the money's coming from. Isn't there an opportunity to come forward with the plan that says,

1:00:33 Council, will you approve this plan as we've put it together? Because it seems to me that the same thing that happened the first time around with the ice rink is that that didn't happen, that the complete picture did not come in the door, and so pieces of the project were funded along the way, and then more costs came in, and then more costs came in, and there was an incremental spending of dollars to

1:01:01 To get that bill. Instead of having the holistic view of it. So it was long enough ago that I was on Planning Commission, and I don't know if it went to Council. It may have only gone to Planning Commission for a roof style. The changes to it, I don't know whether they're being considered as being within that same approval from what had to be before 2008. Specialties permit? Yeah.

1:01:25 So I think that's another piece of the complexity of it because it may or may not be everything that's envisioned. We got in this habit of doing things, we as a community, we as a council got in the habit of doing things in phases, and no, I don't know that the full thing is. Well, the reason I ask the question is because if we're headed down this path of setting this aside as a complex project, there are a lot of pieces.

1:01:56 that need to be put in place. And I guess I'm looking for when the trigger occurs that says we have all the pieces in place, we know the answers to all of these questions, and somebody is making the final decision to move forward on this. And the scenario that I'm concerned about is that the council's going to go and negotiate a lease, and so that's going to end up being done somewhere.

1:02:23 There's going to continue to be some ongoing outside fundraising, and that's going to live over there somewhere. There's a debate or discussion about should Measure R funds be used to enhance the programming of the facility, and I'm not sure where that discussion is going to occur. I'm assuming it's going to occur here. So there seems to be a lot of this that goes on. I'm just curious, where does it all come together to say it's ready to go now and we move forward?

1:02:52 I believe that's what the NLR board's been given if you read our contract, is that we're the one who pulls all those pieces together. I think that the advantage to proceeding, I think as we're discussing, the idea of setting aside a reserve that's tagged for this project in particular that comes also with a commitment by this board.

1:03:14 to arrive at a holistic plan to work with the various parties so that it then comes back at that moment where we are ready to recommend releasing those funds. We're looking at all those contingencies. Because I agree there, I mean, we're going to still have to determine, okay, call this phase two of ice rink. You know, does that include stadium bleachers? Does it include audiovisual?

1:03:43 and a screen for the summertime stuff. And those are still kind of abstract questions, but I feel like I would like to commit to having a couple of our members work with Rec Commission, town, interested user groups on as short a timeline as possible, answer all of those questions, come up with a holistic plan, present them to the MLR board to say, okay, now here's where this

1:04:11 $200,000, $300,000 that you guys have put in reserve fits and here's our plan for the gap and here's our timeline. Yeah, because take it one step further, what if it goes to town council and town council overrides and says they've allocated $300,000, what do we do next?

1:04:27 Well, that's our prerogative. But I think we're offering the beginnings of a plan to completion. And I think that whatever those funds we set aside are a carrot to say, you know what, let's move, and this money's here, as soon as the plan makes sense to us, we'll recommend that those funds be released.

1:04:53 And it's not just a carrot. It's also a declaration from this board that this is one of our priorities to get it rolling. And from what I've seen, it's not just are we going to have bleachers or whatnot. It's even just the basic engineered project. I mean, it's still a lot of ballparking has been done. So there's a whole kind of path that still has to take place for kind of the basic constructed roof. But I think my point of view is I'd like to get the ball rolling. And I think the reserve.

1:05:23 Kind of procedure here is the way to go to do that. Now, David, I don't know if you intended to say it, but you said 200 or 300,000. I just was saying, like, whatever that number is that we agree on. I'm just going to ask, is there any reason why we wouldn't reserve the full amount at this point? No, I mean, the only thing that I've been thinking about on some of these projects that I think we should consider at some point, and it probably doesn't fit in this complex reserve strategy, but...

1:05:51 The idea that we would say, instead of just a $300 straight allocation, that we would do, say, $250,000 and then $50,000 in sort of a sub-reserve that would go as matching so that whoever's doing the fundraising on this can use that 50 to parlay that into 100 to bridge that gap. But again, that's not something we determine now. We just set aside a reserve and then figure out how that allocation would look once we know the whole project.

1:06:20 We could always build that in. Right, because I think that allocation within that $300,000 might look very different with a lot of the answers to the questions that are being posed, and it might not be all $300,000 that way. It might be used very differently. Yeah, because I do like, Dave and I had a chance to discuss the idea of matching funds. Yeah, absolutely. As long as our town attorney says we can do that.

1:06:42 Well, I hope so, because that's our premise. I just got to say, we're leveraging it, yes, so we should be able to, but I like the idea of doing that, and if we're setting aside reserve, we're not saying that we would agree whatever the current breakout of the funding is, but that we're saying, yeah, we see that it's going to need this much, or at least this much. I was going to say at least this much, and there's a commitment to set that aside so that we can keep moving down this path of getting it finalized, because...

1:07:10 That gap may be greater than $85,000 down the road. $300,000 may not be the right price tag down the road, but at least this is the commitment to getting it moving and getting it going. I was just going to ask Stu, if the building were to happen this summer, when would you need the $300,000?

1:07:33 So, I mean, Dan was pointing out, so we have to publicly bid the project, right? Yes. You can't publicly bid it till we have the money, so it's kind of a little bit of a catch-22, so you have the commitment that we can go and publicly bid it, and the bids might actually come in less than what we think, and, you know, we might be fine with the money, and then that would give us that timeline in construction. So, the structure itself is prefabbed, it's very consistent when we presented the plans to the school two weeks ago.

1:07:59 It's really the same structure we set before. It's still a steel roof. It's still a 16-foot span. It's still the same height. You know, it's 99% the same project. So I think that's consistent. So I think until we get publicly bid, then we get the timeline back, and then we can kind of get this thing going in the ground. But I agree. It's a very complex project. I mean, I absolutely got a lot of moving parts to this lease. That could be a couple of months, you know, to get this thing sorted out. And then we can kind of get closer towards, you know, the other questions in regards to the operating plan and the maintenance.

1:08:28 Until we really know what we're building, it's hard to obviously build a maintenance plan for it. I think the programming discussion's great. You know, that's going to go along with the operating plan, so I'd love to work with, you know, MLR and some board representatives to talk about that and what we see. We've already engaged some community members in that facility and what they see it and how they can best utilise it. So I think it's a great, great community project we just want to get behind, and I encourage and thank MLR for, you know, keeping it moving forward.

1:08:53 And so as long as the money's in the reserve, then you can start asking for the bids. Absolutely. We're going to keep moving along. Well, we can't publicly bid it until we have all the funding. Right. So if it's in reserve, you can't... Well, there's still that gap we have to deal with. There's still the 80-something... Yeah, but it can't be bid until all the funds are identified. But it is possible to get informal bids and know at least what the baseline costs... Which is what we have right now. Right, exactly. So we can... We have two steel structures and we have one fabric structure.

1:09:26 Not even a proposal, but you've just got some information. Because it's not quite the process that you want to go out and actually front load it. So we know pretty much where we're at. Just a technical process to follow. Did that answer your question? Yeah. I mean, I guess I just don't want things to get held up for another year. Yeah. I agree. But if we can all work on it together, I think that's great. So we're all for it. Thank you. Any further questions?

1:10:00 Comments? Is there a motion? I move to fund this project in reserve for the full amount of $300,000. I'll second that. And do we add the same language? With the same provisions that we mentioned above? With the same provisions? Timeliness. Exactly. You did? Okay. Any further? Move to second. Is there any further discussion? All those in favor, indicate by an aye. Aye. Any opposed?

1:10:35 Motion passes 7-0. Let's move on to item number 6. This is the town summer programming for the multi-use facility. Make note of that, Teri, over marking that, the ice rink was Measure R. This is item number 6. This is the town summer programming for the multi-use facility.

1:11:07 Does it fall within the Measure R and U ordinance? Yes. Yes. It's been done. Well, no, no, no. Yes, because it's been done isn't always going to be the way. I think it is Measure R. Technically, it could be either, but I think that when Measure U was used in past years, it was a little bit more of a stretch, so I would say maybe we should identify it as R.

1:11:38 Yeah, I had you guys, because I had it as R. Where do you guys put it? I had it as R as well, but that does bring up a good question as to when do you use the Recreation Clause in U and when not. I think in the past, if I remember correctly, like winter came from U and summer came from R. Yeah, well, there were various, there were various, I'm sorry.

1:12:02 Didn't it sometimes come apart, Stuart, just based on which money was available at the time? Because that's how the track has both are in U in it? It was half and half. Oh, it was half and half? Oh, okay. Split down the middle. Split down the middle. The commission and the U committee, yeah, made that determination that they'd partially fund it from both those sources of funding because they both had that recreation. One specifically speaks to town facilities and one doesn't specifically speak, but it was still a recreation programming use. So, they just saw it as a... Yeah.

1:12:31 Could we possibly table that kind of a discussion to the strategy? Because in the long run, there's likely to be more funding out of Measure R than there is out of Measure U, just as far as total dollars and things like that. Don't we have to, are we providing? No, no, no, I meant over the next 10 years. Because TOT should grow faster than utility users tax does. Just to have a set of info,

1:12:59 $10,000 is already coming out of Measure R right now for this next season. And so the Measure U Committee at the last go-around only did one year where the Measure R did two years. And so you can say that the $10,000 would be the portion of the Measure U or we can say it's all coming out of R.

1:13:23 Who would like to do that? One of the things that we did talk about in the allocations committee is the fact that within the budget, there's $3,000 in there for marketing, so of the $20,000 budget that you had, you were going to take that out of the previously awarded $10,000 and not out of this new, potential new award. Well, in the Q&A, you said that the $10,000 you were going to ask for now would all go to wages and salaries? Correct, which I think is the same. There's $3,000 in the budget for marketing.

1:13:53 Yep, and we're using wages and salaries. Yeah, that was, so that budget you're looking at is kind of like a $20,000 annual budget. As we said, the $10,000 is already allocated from Measure R, which is part of that marketing function. So the $10,000 we're asking for is just to fund the wages. The difference, the difference, Dana, being that that was awarded a year ago. Right. And so it was under different rules.

1:14:18 So are you suggesting that we go backwards in time? No, that that's out of the last year. I'm presuming that there was a budget that they used for the last award that might have looked like this.

1:14:31 I don't think so because it was, I don't think there was an application, right? It was just in the budget. There was an application. There was an application. Okay. This isn't a Measure R where Measure R is required to do this. This is something that's coming forward because there's no other. Okay. Yeah. So to clarify, none of the 3,000 that was set aside for marking was coming out of what you were asking of this. Correct. I just want to clarify. And that the original award was awarded.

1:15:01 for that specific purpose. Correct. Yes. I think you're all saying the same thing. Yes. The caveat, right, look, we had said no marketing and then we went for the town also. We just clarified that, yeah. Is there any other questions about this? I just have a general comment because it's going to lead into other things as we move forward and that is that we're looking at all of the applications. We've got

1:15:30 About 150, almost $160,000 worth of ask for venue and facilities. And so, and I don't know exactly where this fits in, but I would just say that as we move forward, let's try and figure out a way to incorporate some programming in this facility that will overlap with some of these other applications that are, where they're paying for facilities elsewhere.

1:16:00 Here we've got a facility. Let's just think of it in longer term. It doesn't really have anything to do with this particular allocation, but the programming that we're talking about here is specifically recreation, but I think that facility has potential for other types of events that we're seeing other people asking for in other areas. So just to begin to figure out a way to...

1:16:26 Consolidate these things. Well, I appreciate you asking that, because a note that I made on this was I'd like to see the program plan developed and then the report that comes out that shows the outcomes of those programming efforts. And so if there is that program plan that is developed that perhaps is in place, we just haven't seen it, that that starts to integrate some of those other activities that are using other facilities that could very well be in this facility as well. Yep.

1:16:55 And that will feed into our complex discussion about the facility as well. You know, is there a stage? Is there audiovisual? Is there speakers? Is there a sound system? And it also sets us up for the strategy. Yeah. Teri, you have a question? Yeah, I have a question. So if the roof moves forward and they're doing construction, potentially, let's say everything falls in place.

1:17:18 All the stars align that you're doing construction this summer. Are you actually going to operate this facility still? It's a good question. I don't know how we determine it right now. I'd probably say no, right? So for the period of time for probably that month, you know, there would be a savings, right? So you wouldn't be using those programming funds. And then, yeah. So once again, money would only come out of this if...

1:17:42 Absolutely. As it's been done in the past. Absolutely. And then we've had those discussions, as you know, with some event producers have already come forward and asked to talk to us and say, what can we really do? Because if you look at it, it's a closed gate, right? You can track the number of people, you can control the venue, you've got parking, you know, just some issues that we have to work around with our partners. But you have lights, you have concessions, you have toilets. I mean, it's a great, great multi-use facility.

1:18:09 Such a big upside. What we're struggling with right now, I have an operating plan that we've had in place for a couple of years without a roof. If we get a roof, then we're redoing the operating plan, and it's a great discussion, and we can kind of work on that together. Anyway, that's kind of where we're at. Sounds good. And I guess I would suggest that there's not, and it's going to determine how we look at some of these other projects, but since Measure R. does encompass recreation as well, and it's been coming out of

1:18:39 Measure U, when there's already 10,000 coming out of Iowa, I guess I would say that, you know, this 10,000 would be consistent and come out of U. Was that a motion? Sure. That sounded like it. And your recommendation is included in that motion is to come out of Measure U? Measure U. Okay. Is there a second? A second. Joe. We've been seconded to allocate 10,000 out of Measure U for the town summer programming multi-use facility.

1:19:08 Any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. And any opposed? Motion passes. Sorry, any notes? Measure U, Teri. All right, number seven, this is Mammoth Rocks and Sierra Boo. That's right. So I'm going to ask the complexity question. Does it fall into the complexity issue?

1:19:43 I don't think it does, so no. So moving to item number one, Measure R and U Ordinance. Does it fall within requirements of Measure R or Measure U Ordinance? Well, can we do, can we look at the whole picture rather than going item by item? Sure. I mean, I'm willing to jump right in. I have some concerns about this project. I think I'm not.

1:20:07 Clear on public benefit and I think this is a discussion that's going to feed into several of the other events that have come up and I'm not, you know, I think there's been an assumption or practice that has assumed that because a certain amount of, because certain programming is free and available to the public, it is necessarily a public benefit and I'm not

1:20:32 I feel like it's time for us to begin to raise the bar a little bit and discuss what that is and sort of the abstract notion of music programming can either be a true cultural benefit or it could be just animation for a facility and I think we have to begin to articulate the difference. And this is one of the several projects here where

1:20:56 Personally, it feels more like an animation of a facility that's not a municipal facility where there's benefit to business owners. And there may be an incidental benefit to the public depending on, you know, if you like those kinds of bands or if whatever that is. But it doesn't seem to me the primary reason for the event. I also am concerned about the sustainability and the fact that this is a fourth year request on this one.

1:21:27 That's 2019. So four more years. Three more years. Actually, David, you very eloquently stated all of my concerns on this one. I think that there is language from the town attorney that suggests that driving visitation is a public benefit. I think that's another separate question as to how much incremental

1:21:58 Visitation to these, does this kind of class of animated events drive? And I break it down a little differently. If you look at the studies that MLT did in terms of activities and animation, they have a big impact on the economic diversity within particularly summertime and in this community. I think I have really two portions. One is, and we're addressing, as David brought up, I'm addressing a larger portion, is events part following the funding. I adamantly believe they do.

1:22:26 But what I have a question is, at what point in time does the source of those dollars need to be diminished? And say, you typically say, an event starts, you get more dollars to start with, and then it should be weighing off. And if an event can't sustain itself over a period of time, at what point in time we say, you know, we've had enough? If an event's been going on for 20 years and we're still funding it, unless it's a public good that is something that we all agree that benefits the town, we're, you know, is that the best usage of these dollars going forward? Because I look at this being strategic, saying,

1:22:55 What do we need to be to have a certain amount of money moving forward to do the larger projects and do the things we have? But I think, you know, we just approved trolley funding for special events. I think we're, to me, that says special events falls within the purview of what this criteria describes. Separate mobility. I think that's what it is. It is very, very specific. No.

1:23:18 But my point is, I've got that portion, but if we're not going to do events, then we don't need the trolleys. I think events do fall within our purview. It's just a matter of what is the right portion of what is events funding. And, you know, I think, you know, we're picking on Mammoth Rocks because that's the one out here, but that's 2009, I think, was the first year. So I think there's been assistance going from day one to that venue.

1:23:43 And there was an initial portion that was done with MLECC, saying that events after their, you know, let's call it, I think it was seven years, would be received no more than 10% of their funding maximum, even. And I'm a firm believer that there should be a point in time where, it's not a maximum, there should be a point in time where you move forward. Either events survives or it doesn't survive. Yeah, let me just clarify really quickly that I'm, I'm, I completely agree. I don't, I'm not saying that all.

1:24:07 Special events should be off the table. I think I see the value in special events absolutely as part of our cultural programming. But I think that we've established that we have to look at that cultural benefit or the public benefit. You know, I'll go. I've been struggling with this one, too, because somewhere things kind of turned, but if we really look at the language of Measure U and Measure R, being just being a special event, I don't think...

1:24:45 Holistically fits into that language. If we're looking at the legal language and the legal meaning of what this is, what Measure U is looking at potentially helping these folks out with is capital infrastructure. So, you know, this year we were looking at that pivot. I mean, I don't know. Are we saying right at this point if it doesn't fit that we're stopping this or was there that stop gap?

1:25:14 That we're moving forward with some help. But I think that we have to answer that question because we're going to have the next, there's going to be a few applications that are going to fall within this. It's not just Mammoth Rocks. It's going to, this is impacting. I think David, you know, kind of hit it on the head. I think that there is, there's, I, you know, my, my wording that kept coming up is, is animation and amenity isn't visitor driving. It's, it's animating an area.

1:25:42 But is it truly visitor driving? That's, you know, a big question. So the visitor driving is where it is going to become the public benefit. You know, where Measure U specifically does talk about infrastructure and things that can be used by the town and the community. And that's, I think, the direction we need to look at going so that we're helping events in another manner as opposed to just handing over monies.

1:26:12 And we're helping already in the trolley costs. And so anyways, I have a hard time. I think there's a few of these that don't necessarily fit into that category. So it's a matter of are we saying no to everything? I actually kind of went down through and went, okay, this is that pivot year and potentially we look at doing a small portion of funding.

1:26:39 Tickets for this year until we get thrown strategic. But legally, is that the proper thing to do? I feel like we have kind of two separate questions in front of us. One is the value, the inherent value of animation of this type, one. But then there's kind of a separate question as to whether that falls under R&U. My take right now is that I think Brent's point of view has merit.

1:27:09 I agree with the sustainability idea first and foremost, but in terms of animation being important to this town, I think that's an argument that can be made forcefully. And I also agree with your point of view too, that this has to be kind of understood at a strategic level in terms of what is the actual cultural value. I think I come down to where we're not quite ready to make a strong, a super strong pivot. I think these are big questions.

1:27:39 And I think there's a lot of interest in the town, you know, which way this board's going to pivot on this very issue. It's kind of one of the fundamental questions that we keep returning to in all of our conversations. So I almost feel like we have three opportunities here. One is to business as usual, one is to have a interim solution, and one is to make a hard pivot.

1:28:07 When you make a pivot, that's a motion, and it involves transition from one spot to another. And so that transition allows that interim to occur. So there is that movement allows that. I wanted to offer a couple of things. We've had quite a bit of dialogue and back-and-forth discussion with the town attorney on the use of Measure R and Measure U funds.

1:28:35 It dawned on me last night, as I was filling out my little notes here, did we ever, we never asked the town attorney this question, and so I sent this message to him this morning. I asked him this question. How is it that previous Measure U funding went to special events without any questions that we're dealing with right now? Like, how is it that right away,

1:29:05 Measure U went to special events, and yet we're struggling with this issue, should Measure U funding go to special events? And I was struggling, how is it that there wasn't a debate anywhere? Where did that all occur? And here, the town attorney responded, you know, there was, Measure R was cranking along, it had been in place for a few years, Measure U came along, and because of Measure R precedent, it was just in people's minds that

1:29:32 Nobody asked whether the awards were consistent with the use of Measure U or not, and nobody really raised a question. We're raising that question, and he points out the formation of Measure R, or excuse me, the formation of MLR has prompted an overdue fresh look at how R and U funds are spent. And so we've triggered this question, we've triggered this debate.

1:29:57 And where we have the opportunity to provide the community with an answer as we go through our strategy and the formation of our strategy and the development of our strategy is where we're going to land down the road. That doesn't help us with summer of 2015, the activities and animation and events, you know, that have come to rely upon.

1:30:20 the previous funding that was never questioned before. So I'm sorry to interrupt, but it actually was questioned before. If you look at the Measure U funding requests that were happening in the Measure U board from 12-13 and their agendas which are online for the town website and the joint workshop that was held with the town council to discuss these very items are all part of the agenda and minutes if you want to go back. Special events continue to be funded. No, but I'm just saying, but there has been discussion on it. They're just, this is a difficult question because we had the same issue. So I'm just saying.

1:30:47 The school attorney today points out that the formation of MLR is now offering up this look at the measure of our new language, and we're going to have to be in a situation through our strategic development that we're going to get that question answered. And the piece that was never discussed before was the gift of public funds.

1:31:06 That's the piece that was not brought up in any of those previous lines. They actually were brought up in previous meetings with them, Measure U committees and... Well, they were not brought up in Council. But that was also something that was brought up as a and why a recommendation from Town Council is given on certain profits was part of that. So then the other communication from the Town Attorney is that we struggle with, and we've been struggling with this, and we started talking about it at the meeting on Friday. Facilities or projects?

1:31:35 Are those special events? Under Measure U language, it talks about facilities or projects. Do special events fall under that? And we're not going to be able to answer that question today, I don't believe, but it is going to have to be part of our discussion about our long-term strategy as to whether those special events fall under facilities or projects. And I will advise that the town attorney

1:32:04 In a preliminary opinion says he doesn't think that special events fall under facilities or projects. Now, with that said, you know, there's a long-term discussion or debate that would have to occur with the town attorney and everybody else about this level of funding. I don't think that there's been any precedent that has been established that prevents us from doing any type of interim funding.

1:32:31 But I do believe that the town is looking at MLR to create the strategy down the road that finalizes and answers this question. And so I've just made it muddier than you need to. But I think, again, we have to look at the direction and information that the town is providing us from the use of these funds. And we realize that people are...

1:32:57 Outside of this area, look at how special tax measures are used and implemented down the road. And if they don't line up with what the tax measure ordinance says, sometimes problems occur. And I think we want to avoid those problems as much as possible. So with that said, we have Mammoth Rocks in front of us. I would just add one thing that kind of just to summarize the...

1:33:26 The information we've been getting from the town attorney, I think it's basically that special events likely do not fall under Measure U, but not impossible. That's the language. It is not a, we have not gotten a strong position from them, but we have been given some guidance. And my feeling is that with that in mind,

1:33:53 I would prefer to take an interim step here. I wouldn't want to go further down the road of special events, funding special events, but I don't want to do damage to things that have been funded in the past. So with that, I looked at the budget of Mammoth Lakes and what the request was for, and $11,000 is for the programming of this.

1:34:22 But there's also funding in their budget for the co-director and the event director that goes in there. And it's the event budget, and every event does need a director and a co-director, et cetera. And it's indicated in here that programming is their largest expense, that they need the funding to pay for the entertainment that is going to be performing as part of this.

1:34:52 I'm just wondering in this interim are we able to or does it make any sense to take the $11,000 that has been requested and do we change that or adjust that in any way to focus on entertainment or to change any level? And I don't know. Actually, Dana, I was thinking along the same way looking at maybe there are some other things that we might fund at a lower level.

1:35:20 But to tell you the truth, I will have a lot of problem, you know, this was last year's budget, but let's say giving them most of the money for an event director and a co-director when we've got all these small non-profits that are asking us for like $2,000 for staffing costs. But I think that you might be right that if we set a lower amount that went like for AV and equipment rental or something like that. I just, I have a real problem with

1:35:49 Bringing, you know, bringing the talent in from outside. The benefit is going to the businesses there. It's on a private stage. It's certainly not Measure R. It can only be Measure U if we find things that are appropriate to fund. But I can't see that $11,000 is an appropriate amount. Maybe something less and maybe it's in some other areas that we specifically identify.

1:36:17 That we feel fall within you. I will also mention just as a general observation that most of the events of this nature that are happening in the village and are what we've kind of called animation, I don't know that that's a fair thing to say exactly in comparison to other kinds of events and programming, but nonetheless are under-sponsored. And I think a lot of it is because there has been money coming from the town.

1:36:46 There are no, you know, to not pick on Mammoth Rocks, but to mention another one, there's a reggae festival we're going to look at, right? Village Fest, and there's all kinds of things to look at. Yeah, right, and none of them have title sponsors. You go to Sugarloaf, their reggae fest is sponsored by Bud Light. I mean, there's just an opportunity here in general.

1:37:05 for these kinds of events. So I'll just put that out there. Well, and I think that's an excellent point. And again, to get back to the matching idea, and I think this is something that can come up in other, I've got some proposals on some of these other ones where perhaps, you know, instead of saying, okay, we'll just give you $11,000, we say, we'll give you X amount if you can bring another sponsor in and have us match that. So that that then is covering, you know, it's sending them down a track where

1:37:34 where they're having to go and look for these sponsors to cover these events to guarantee their sustainability long term. I mean, we have examples of events that have grown over the years that are sustainable, that haven't used Measure R or U funds, that are extremely successful, where people are getting paid, where they're demonstrably bringing a lot of people to town. And, you know, obviously we haven't yet set

1:38:02 Our standards for that, but I think we need to begin to really push for that. You know, that they're going to, you know, an event, I mean, one of the things in our project filters is does project require funding? And I look at this and I say, you know, I bet they could pull it off without us. Which is kind of a harsh thing to say, but there are other events very much like this that can do that. And to, you know, another point of discussion that's another, for longer term, is $10,000 in marketing on this thing.

1:38:31 You know, if, on the one hand, a producer is going to make the argument that this has benefit to the whole community, well, why then wouldn't it have benefit from a marketing standpoint for our marketing organization? You know, this is, it's a longer discussion and complex, but I'm just, you know, I want to have everything on the table so that we're not just subsidizing. And I would like to say that I, you know, I have folks contact me because

1:39:01 You know, it is that whole thing. Are we subsidizing an area where these are taking place? Now, granted, the village was built and it's kind of perfect for something like that. For it to be healthy, you want that animation to be there. But I've heard from other restaurants in town that when something is going on there, they have no business in their restaurant. I've heard from other folks that, you know, why are we putting all of this as public money into one?

1:39:29 Area. Granted, somebody could bring a, you know, program event together for another area, and that would be considered in the same manner. But, you know, it is public funds that we are using, and there are a great many of these that are going on in the village. And so, you know, I like that, David, where you're looking at saying, you know, we can do this, but we need to bring in somebody else. You know, I was even looking at, because I, you know, I...

1:39:58 To be perfectly honest, I struggle with the fact that this doesn't fit, period. If you're subsidizing for somebody to bring something else in, otherwise, how do you go across the board to be fair to everybody else? Do you just look at a percentage this year and say, this is our stock gap? We're going to look at a percentage that we're going to fund these folks on their expenses and look at that. That's why I'm approaching it a little bit. I agree, because as we go forward, I'm not saying...

1:40:26 We should be the sole source of events or other activities. I mean, this is part of what was supposed to happen two years ago. It just kind of got dropped. There's supposed to be a discussion about this and what do we do with special events. Because I know with MLECC they're talking about different ways of funding. There's many different ways of doing this. And I look at us being more strategic down the road. But I am concerned about stopping everything this year.

1:40:49 I'll tell you why I would like Mammoth Rocks. My suggestion was going to be saying take five grand from that portion. I took the 4,800, took basically 10% of that. I think the supplies portion, they're going to make money on selling stuff, so I took that out of that portion and said, to me it's more like a five grand application from that standpoint. And that's where I was approaching this one. And I'm sorry, which categories were you identifying? I just took the bottom and just started with, I just took it as a total event funding and took approximately 10% of that. Okay. And I didn't.

1:41:18 Try to deal with marketing, not marketing. Reduce that down, but not utilize the retail concession because there will be sales that they'll make off those. That's where I start from. So my initial recommendation is going to be starting at 4,800 was where I was starting from this project. Just 10% of the... Just 10%. And that's kind of what I'm doing too, is if the first decision needs to be, is that we're moving, are we moving forward to the stock gap? And if the answer was yes, that we kind of need to be consistent.

1:41:47 Throughout, and that's kind of where I did too, Brin, I took 10%. I said, well, either, I either looked at 20% of what they were asking or 10% of the actual expenses that they were proposing. Dana, to get back to what you were saying earlier, Measure U Committee, we did start to struggle with events last year, and we did start to question that, and I believe it was the first time where we didn't fund events fully, and so we made that decision to

1:42:18 to come down in amounts. And, you know, looking at this event, and I know some events, you know, can be on their own and be successful, but this is a free event. It is an event that takes place sort of at that time of year when people go back to school. Whether people come specifically for this event, I don't know, or if they've come in the past and they like this event, it is in the village. I mean, there's all sorts of different things.

1:42:49 Feel like it would be tragic to just completely stop funding events at this point, given that we're so close out to the summer. But, you know, being able to give a heads up to other event producers and saying, you know, strategy is looking more closely at this and we would like to help out to some degree and in the future this money may not be available.

1:43:15 There is a year and a half of planning and greater sponsorships and that MLR will be here to provide support and direction in finding future funding and leveraging funding. I think that pretty much articulates my point of view as well. And just one extra comment, I think moving forward, I think events needs

1:43:39 Needs a way forward itself. And whether it's MLR partnered with Chamber of Commerce and MLT, there's a solution out there, a better solution out there, but we're just, we're not there today. Well, and you know, Andy pointed that out at one point is, you know, it may be that there has to be a different funding source for them. Yeah. Well, there's another way to conceive a view as well when we look at, you know, down...

1:44:02 Down the pile here, when we get a proposal for a year's worth of programming in a certain facility, it may be easier to look at Measure U funding for a bigger picture than just for these one-off events that may not fit in the whole scheme. Well, and that was part of the conversation on Friday also, that we talked about those...

1:44:23 Opportunities to bring more people under the umbrella of organizing and planning and programming so that it's not just the incremental ad hoc but rather there is an end game in mind and that you start to feed all of those into that long term programming opportunity and or organizing opportunity. Because they've also got $1,500 in equipment rental and those are things that down the road we need to all figure out.

1:44:53 There's one pot, you know, we're paying the town to rent that stuff, or there's some way so that it's all, so that we're cutting down this, you know, $150,000 in venue asks. And allocations did talk about, I think we started to start a list that had, you know, this one needed to stage, this one also needed to stage, oh, this one needs to stage, and we started to put together that list of the equipment that was

1:45:21 You know, floating around among all of these event-type applications. And so that's the role in thinking about strategy. MLR has that list in mind and can commit to getting those things purchased that then don't have to be rented by organizers down the road. And making the price of entry cheaper. Right. You know, for everybody. Right. So there is a concept on the table that we look at the

1:45:51 Going from $11,000 to $4,800 and based on a 10% of the budget not including the revenue set in their budget. Yeah, and I'm making this recommendation based on the length longevity of the program, et cetera, because each one I think we've got to look at individually. Absolutely. So this is just, I'm not, I'm just saying in general, I'm sorry, I said the mode that events may not get full funding for what they're looking for. They recognize that we need to fund events to a certain degree as we move, and to give a definitive word down the road of what we will recommend as we do our full cycle.

1:46:20 I think stopping completely will be harsh to what we need to be this summer, but on the other hand, realistic that if we spend all the money now, we have nothing to spend for the future. And what about to add in also the possibility of saying $4,800 or $5,000 contingent on that you find in your, because you need that other $5,000, you've asked for it, contingent on that you bring in a sponsor for $5,000 will match it. For another $5,000? Yeah, or another $4,800.

1:46:47 I'm actually... No, no, I mean that we said $4,800 would be our allocation, but that $4,800 would be contingent on them finding $4,800 from another source. I think in the future I think I would agree with that. With this one I would say that you need to have something so there are certain expenses that small projects need to get started. And I think that's where I'm looking at saying there's got to be a certain level of portion funding. I think there's opportunities down the road.

1:47:13 And even with bigger sponsors, maybe you could talk about that for the whole town. Now if that becomes, you know, really that's what I thought we would be having that conversation down the road. If Coca-Cola or somebody comes in and says, okay, we're going to have 12 events, this is, we'll contribute, you know, 10 grand each event or whatever it is. And it's having those events identified and this is, if you come in, Coca-Cola, here's who we can align you with. Exactly. And that's a strategic conversation. Right. I mean, I think in some ways,

1:47:42 Cutting the award, we're doing what you're asking without mandating. You're right. I think down the road is the leverage. That's the leverage idea and that match idea. Okay. So is there a motion? I consolidated what you said to say 4,800 for appropriate Measure U expenses. Is that essentially what you were saying? Yes. Was that your motion? I'll make a motion. Is there a second? I'll second that.

1:48:12 Just a quick comment before we vote. You know, another thing, when we, when events did apply to the Measure U Committee, one thing that was, you know, thought about is it's not just arts and culture, but it is a form of recreation, and it may not be hiking in the woods, but it's something that people can do when they come to Mammoth, and it's...

1:48:36 Well, and in that case, I agree with you, Treya, but I think that's the recreation part of Measure U. Absolutely. Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. So there's that fine line, you know, within Measure U of recreation. Right. And arts. There's a motion on the table and a second to allocate $4,800 for expenditures that are appropriate for Measure U language. Is there any further discussion? Just one comment that I appreciate.

1:49:04 that this application had a trajectory towards sustainability and that each year was incrementally going down in the level of its task as well. So I just wanted to make that comment. And I think that rolls into the strategy because that's still...

1:49:22 Four years away. That's still five years worth of funding away. And that would make it, you know, that we have to discuss this strategy. I'd just like to add a bit of a disclaimer. The first year of Mammoth Rock's funding came out of Measure A. There was no Measure U and there was no Measure R. So it aligned a lot easier with the Measure A funding because that was intended for recreation, tourism.

1:49:48 Marketing opportunities. And it was a lot easier at that point to consider a sponsorship, if you will, of Mammoth Rocks using Measure A money because it lined right up with it. When we start to get into Measure U and Measure R, that language is a little tighter than what Measure A was. And I just want to point that out as well. But the initial wasn't Measure R or Measure U. It came out of Measure A.

1:50:17 And it was at that time it lined right up. I just want to share that. There's still a motion on the table. Any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, motion passes 7-0.

1:50:38 You did. What we had said is if we had questions for the applicant, we would be able to turn to the applicant and ask for those questions. We didn't have questions for the applicant. And so this wasn't a, if you will, opportunity for any presentation or anything by the applicant. But if we had questions, we certainly had the opportunity to ask you, Mark. Questions that you asked each other should have been asked directly to me as being one of them.

1:51:08 We'd best be able to answer some of those questions rather than some speculation and some guesses as to what's happened over the last five years of this process. Thanks. I appreciate that. And I think we just set it up because we have so many to get through, but also because we have done the work in advance of asking all the questions up front as well as the applications that had answers to the questions that were asked in the request form. So I think we...

1:51:38 Felt pretty strongly about having those, but I appreciate you being here and sharing your thoughts with us. Thank you. Item number eight, this is the Mammoth Kids Jazz Camp, and this, also I'll ask the question, does it fall into the complexity bucket? No, no. All right, so then we'll go, we can look at this one holistically also as it relates to the Mammoth Kids Jazz Camp.

1:52:06 They are requesting funding, and this, as a note, we discussed this. This previously was all a part of Mammoth Jazz Jubilee, but it's been broken out separately this year. And so this is a separate activity from Mammoth Lakes Jazz Jubilee, or what is now called Mammoth Jazz Festival. Well, it's a separate application, but it's the same 501 CC. Same organizers.

1:52:30 Or the new organizers, but it's separate from the event itself. Can I ask just a quick question? Do we know yet, I mean, as of our last meeting, it was unclear whether the 501c3 was actually involved in these events? We don't know that, and actually I checked, and that 501c3 is in a delinquent status with a registry of charitable trusts.

1:52:54 So I'm not sure that I'm ready to answer that it doesn't fall into a complexity bucket because I'm seeing on this and the next one a lot of unanswered questions about whose event it is and what the actual budget is. Right. And I'd add to that that the request has marketing in it even though we said no marketing. Yeah. And we asked that twice. Yeah.

1:53:22 Well, in that case, yeah. I mean, I wholeheartedly support the idea of a jazz festival and a jazz camp, and I too hate to see the thing die, and I see the need for damage control. All of the components of this application that address those, I support, but I'm not sure that we're...

1:53:41 in a position, given the information we have, to finance this and know that it's going to be successfully brought off. Well, my challenge goes one further. It's been around for 20-plus years. And why is it? This is a different portion. We're going to be faced with a couple other projects that we've got coming forward. At what point in time do we continue that funding? So I'm not against it complex, but my concern would be is reserving full amounts for this project, even if we did go with a complex project.

1:54:11 Because it's been around a long time. Is it beneficial? Is the kids camp different than the others and it's educational is one component to me. But the other part's been still a long time. Is that really something we still should be funding at that amount at this time? And if you remember, I asked the question of, well, was this independent of the full festival? And I don't know that we really got an answer to that either. Potentially it could stand on. It could. Okay. And they have, yeah. So I think

1:54:44 You know, a lot of this goes to the transition that the events is under. And whether we call it complex and put it into the complex bucket and get the answers to the questions that we're asking, we can certainly do that. I think it still begs the question a level of funding that would go towards this because of the fact that it's been around for 20-plus years.

1:55:15 There are a lot of factors that go into this one. Yeah, I mean, I think they're talking about, you know, doing a whole rebranding. There's a lot of timeline issues that, I mean, super tight. You know, while I appreciate the desire to keep the thing rolling, I also don't see any, I mean, really, to take a year off, do a rebranding, start with all the ducks in order, come back to us with more.

1:55:43 Sounds like a reasonable approach to me. I don't think you lose much by that. And the risk would be a lot less. When I look at this, you know, I like that this year the kids camp has been separated from the jazz festival as it was formerly known. I guess I feel like if we're committing, if we were to commit $5,000 to this, it's not such a huge risk because if it doesn't happen, they're not going to get the money for it.

1:56:13 And what I really like about the Kids Jazz Camp is the educational parts of it. Well, my notes asked, as I was looking at this, my notes, I was asking, could we, if we were to go down a funding level for this, could we specify that they were to be used as scholarships to get the Mammoth Lakes kids into the camp? Because it was referred to as

1:56:41 What, 35% mammoth? 30 to 40% mammoth. Yeah, and 65% out of area. And is there, you know, a way to...

1:56:51 Incentivize the local kids. Incentivize, and also to, you know, encourage the local kids to be able to participate in this because of a level of funding that is coming through this. But I don't know. Or maybe it's not just Mammoth Lakes kit. I mean, it's $650 each for 42 people, so the, you know, the actual impact of that on the community is smaller than some of the other less expensive events. Per attendee, I mean, per...

1:57:19 Public Benefitter. Yeah, on the chart. That was really helpful. It's one of the, maybe the most expensive one on the entire life. $5,000, the dates are July 14th to the 19th at Mammoth High School, six days down, 38 to 40 attendees. I think her 2014 was actually, or 15 was, 42. So it's $125 to $132, depending on how many people, for per person, that it would be subsidizing.

1:57:49 It's always been funded with the Jazz Festival. This $5,000 is 14% of the budget. There were no town plans that were identified that it fell within. Not a fundraiser. For-profit. You know, that's questioned depending on where it lies in the 501s and 30s. And then the questions we still had are where are they in their planning, which would possibly put it into that complex because that's still a question. And then 30 to 40%.

1:58:18 Our local kids. So if you put it into the complex bucket, are we putting it in there with the caveat that the answers to the questions that have been posed, such as the non-profit status, the use of the funds, how it's intended to be used, get answered. That's an initial suggestion. That's an initial suggestion. I mean, it feels like it's that or

1:58:49 We have to say no because we can't show that. The benefit is there. Right. I think you're right. We can't show the benefit. And that's one of our most expensive per person. So how do we feel about putting this into the complex bucket? And if there's a motion on the table to do that, then we would go and our meeting on the 23rd, we'd assign somebody to do the follow-up on this to bring it back. What do you think? I don't know if it's...

1:59:19 I kind of feel like we're putting a complex project because we don't want it to go away, but at the same time we don't have another choice what to do with it. I'm just concerned if we put this in a complex project, you know, there could be other things that come down that we put in complex too because a lot of events, activities may not have locations, et cetera, put into place. I'm torn between two. Yeah, I am too. I mean, there's, yeah, there's a big part of me that kind of has to turn the onus back on the producers to be ready.

1:59:49 At this stage of the, I mean, if you want to produce this event this summer, now a lot of these questions need to have been answered already. Yeah. So yeah, so to kick it down the road a month doesn't... It doesn't hurt. Right. Well, no, it doesn't, but it doesn't... Well, it does put the onus, though, on the event producer to look at these questions and get them answered.

2:00:19 Because I think it's going to help them determine whether they're going to actually have this jazz camp or not. Right. Help them with their business plan. Well, I think that there are a lot of questions in here that we asked that kind of had vague answers to it, which leads us to believe that they don't know, that they just don't know at this time because of the transition that they're in.

2:00:42 Because of the, you know, how things were handed off to them or not, and they're having to really recreate something that they're quickly scrambling and trying to do. And maybe we put a date to that. So, you know, these answers, these things need to be answered by markers, by whatever date that is. What was the percentage of local kids?

2:01:05 And I'm assuming that cost would be the same for subsidizing the local kids because they wouldn't have to pay for housing and food, which is a significant cost. I'm struggling with the public benefit. We're talking $5,000 for 10 kids, local kids, and then subsidizing other kids, potentially not from our region, to come here.

2:01:34 This starts to sound like a private business to me of doing, you know, jazz camps and classes, and we're subsidizing them for 10 local kids. Yeah, if there were a concert, a free concert that came at the end of it, if that were part of the plan, I mean, I think there's a way to bill this as something that has community benefit, but it's not yet being billed that way.

2:02:00 I mean, in the abstract, don't get me wrong, I love the idea of a jazz camp and having something like this for kids in our town and building them. And actually, David, that's why I asked the question of was it dependent on the other one because, you know, the kids were part of it all week and they performed several times and all that kind of stuff. And if you're trying to pull that out separately, I don't think they'd have... No, no, we'll depend on that same one. My question was, is it really, we're looking at these both together even though there's two separate locations because I have...

2:02:35 Pretty hard time on, after all these years with Mammoth Jazz, I love Mammoth Jazz, but I'm having problems with, they've reached a point where, do we even fund them? And they've sold all their infrastructure. They've sold all their infrastructure, there's nothing there. I'm struggling with, you know, at this point in time, if they've reached a point where they've got to come up another strategy to make this successful. I'm torn on the jazz camp. For Mammoth Jazz, I could see a much lower award just not to kill the event.

2:03:09 and trying to help the producers sustain, but that 25,000, I mean, I know we're not on that one. Yeah, well, okay. It has been a function for many years, but you're right. So the previous producers are no longer involved. So, which she did put it on last year with somebody else, but with a lot of strings that were attached. So I'm not saying enough here to say that I would be willing to absolutely go forward.

2:03:38 Because there's a lot of questions that still need to be answered. And so, but I have a hard time, as you said, you know, can she move forward with this without having some funding of some sort? And do we want to provide 50% of the budget for something that's brand new? You know, one of the Measure U questions, I believe, Drea, was not funding first-year events.

2:04:05 Yeah, that's... You know, because... But then we looked at certain things, it's like, well, is this really a first year? Because it's kind of been around, you know. Right. It's... Look, I'm hearing that we're struggling with this one, and I'm hearing that perhaps, even if we put it into the complex bucket, it doesn't solve the question, and it doesn't answer the question about the subsidy of kids, you know, out of town coming in to learn to play music. Right. I hear that we're struggling with that public benefit question.

2:04:35 And I don't know that putting it in the complex bucket gets us any further. And I am also hearing that perhaps the public benefit just doesn't line up with the use of Measure U for this one. And perhaps this isn't one that does get funded by Measure U as this move forward. So I'm going to make...

2:05:03 Suggestion that we take the treatment separate, that we take the myth, kids jazz can't treat that as complex. I have concerns about doing it, but I think that that's a question mark because I look at public benefit. Is teaching kids to play and learning something with arts and culture, I think it falls within public benefit, but is it worth it? Can I pull it off? I have no idea. So my suggestion is we take a portion of that and put dollars into there because I think I'm pretty adamant on the next one about the

2:05:32 where we should and should not fund certain things, and I don't think they can achieve that without the other funding. And we can at least put that there, but at the same time have a way for us to come back and say if this is not going to happen, we just kick that out of the reserve altogether. Are you reducing? Yes, I'm suggesting it's $2,500. And that's what I'm suggesting as a discussion here. I'm not making a motion, just throwing that out there as a discussion point. Well, and if we use Dana's approach and say if we incentivize

2:06:02 That $2,500, just for discussion purposes, for scholarships to local kids, then we do have a public benefit. Well, I think that's the struggle that we're having is that the public benefit is to some kids coming from outside of the area. There's also some local kids that benefit from this as well. So by reducing the subsidy, then we focus on funding for the local kids, framing it that way.

2:06:29 Might go further. Was that a form of a motion? Did you? I was hesitating to that point, just seeing that there's consensus before making a motion. Okay, I wasn't sure if I had missed anything. Because I'd actually, I'd actually, just, if we do point of order, I know we start with one, could we go, put table lists and come back in just a moment and discuss Jazz Jubilee as a portion first? Because that may frame our opinion on what to do here. Yeah, I think we can, because they, while having come forward as two separate

2:06:57 Items, they are connected and they do reference each other. And because one does occur at the same time as the other one and is a part of the other one. So are we tabling without a motion? We can table without a motion. I think at this time let's table without a motion. We will come right back to it, but we can talk about number nine, Mammoth Jazz Festival. So since I started part of that conversation, I, you know, the jazz festival I've enjoyed greatly over the years. I think having jazz in the community and having something else is a great benefit.

2:07:26 I've reached the point where it's 20 years, and I think that I'm having a hard time putting $90 towards this as a recommendation. There's no equipment. There's no infrastructure that exists with this. They're putting it together. God bless them. I hope they're very successful. But without a different plan than what I've seen, I find it very difficult to recommend any dollars be put to this at all.

2:07:47 Brent, there's a couple more pieces to it. Again, we're not funding marketing, and that was a big part of the ask. And also, we have to be realistic that the Jazz Festival had been losing money for several years, which is how they, it's essentially, it's a dwindling. I realize they're talking about a different format and all that, but...

2:08:13 I think they got $35,000 from the county a couple years ago. It's just a lot of resources. This goes back to strategic in terms of what's the best usage of our dollars here going forward. I'd rather be for capital projects. Other projects are strategic to what this town envisions. Or for the infrastructure to support. I would just add to the conversation that you took the voice of the producer here. They say that

2:08:42 in writing that they think they'll be self-sustaining by 2017 in their answers to our questions. Just throwing that out there whether that's whether we think that's the case or not. The other piece to this is that they are reformatting, so it's going beyond what was historically kind of Dixieland, so they are in the process of reforming or reformatting their event.

2:09:07 I went to their budget and looked at the fact that they were having to rent stages and tents at a $10,000 level. And perhaps that's an amount that I was looking at in thinking about the event continuing and utilizing Measure U for an infrastructure expense within their budget. With the caveat, though, that if this doesn't get formatted and it doesn't get up off the ground,

2:09:36 It may not happen. I think much worse is that it happens in a really shoddy fashion and just puts the nail in the coffin. From everything I've seen so far, that would be my biggest concern is that if we gave money, they'd feel like they want to spend it, but that it falls flat. I'm with Brent. I don't think that this is ready for funding. The only thing that I would say...

2:10:05 as part of a larger discussion is that I see there are about $25,000 here for facilities, rentals, and infrastructure, and that without being able to do anything specific about it, I would put a plea out to, for example, the town and the ice rink summer programming budget and also Mammoth Lakes Foundation that has a venue that could accommodate jazz.

2:10:34 to begin to work together with potential producers on this to start a new pilot jazz idea to feel out what that might look like for 2016. Yeah. And I really felt that this one's also not ready because, you know, the last thing she puts in on our Q&A was that if we use the iSync, then we need trolley services. And, well, yeah, but we told you trolley services are done through the coordinated one. So, yeah.

2:11:03 You know, I guess, I know there's a lot of people that would like to see this event still happen, including folks from out there, because I've got owners and stuff that are asking. I would like to see that we put something in a contingency with a date that says you have to come back with a formulated event that you have, you know,

2:11:29 You know what your cost of your bands are going to be. You know where you're going to have your events. One of my concerns is you're going to sell tickets. You have one of the events of places that she's looking at to the village at Mammoth. And so, you know, okay, you're going to sell tickets to this thing. How are you going to have that village at Mammoth? So there's some different things. I guess if we're going to be funding events at all, I would like to give the benefit of the doubt that says that we put some money in the contingency to say, come back.

2:11:59 for the formula to play. That would be me. All right, so we've got some ideas, some options out here to look at. It's also interesting that she says in the questions that besides Measure U that all the other funding is in place when we asked how secure your funding source is, but then there's a kind of a private donations TVD line in the actual application.

2:12:29 I'm not quite sure what to make of that. And that SCE grant shows up in a lot of different places. It's also a fishing festival or some... Dan, as you mentioned earlier, there are some upcoming events and festivals that we'll be discussing that have talked about stage

2:12:59 That could be a shared use. You know, I could see that if MLR did purchase a portable stage, this would be something that we could offer to the Jazz Festival. Obviously it would be for a smaller concert, a smaller venue. But David, I do really like the idea of saying, yes, the ice rink or the multi-use summer facility may have a roof. That would also be an excellent venue. And in trying to work...

2:13:29 with the town that there would be maybe no fees necessary for that venue for that day. So you're suggesting that would be... Well, who knows? Maybe we will have that venue by the summer. But, you know, but... Well, I think it brings it back to, you know, another one of our criteria here is this partnerships, coordination, shared resources. And, you know, we'll get down a little bit later to...

2:13:55 You know, these questions about John Verruck's facility. I mean, I think there are these facilities in town, and I'm seeing this, you know, this lack of collaboration between event producers and event venues. And, you know, for us to just keep paying to pay into those venues rather than kind of forcing and asking everybody to come to the table and figure out in the interim, before we have an arts facility, how are we going to do this together?

2:14:22 So that it isn't just for X organization or X individual's profit, but that we're getting the programming that we want and at the same time we're building toward a community facility.

2:14:34 I agree wholeheartedly. I think that the multi-use facility is a little premature this summer. I agree. So I think that's an absolute strategic discussion. So I'm going to go back to, we've got a few that don't believe that the Mammoth Jazz Festival should be funded at all.

2:14:56 There's the potential for putting it into the complex bucket with a contingency on it that says you've got to come back with your plan and basically your plan for this summer that clearly identifies your other funding sources and your program for this event. And if it doesn't come forward by this certain date, that contingency or the reserve that is set aside doesn't move forward.

2:15:22 I think my only other question would be if, I mean, because I'm certainly willing to look at this again in a month, but does that open up, you know, what does that say to other producers who did have their ducks in order for this funding cycle? You know, can we really do kind of this ongoing open-ended conversation with every application? Yeah. And does it really help them in the long run? It does. And if they're in a transition,

2:15:51 If they are in their transition year and they're still trying to figure out what the event is going to be, does this... Is it ready? If the event is going to be ready. Is it ready to go? Right. Is it ready to go? All right, so I'm hearing one thing come forward a little louder than the rest, and that is on this particular one that we don't fund Mammoth Jazz, the request that they've submitted. One more thing I just put out on the table.

2:16:20 Is that they've gotten $25,000 for the last two years. So there's a little bit of a precedence here. Even before that, they've gotten this. Right, exactly. About Measure A. So, you know, I want to make sure that we're making the decision because of the state of the event application, not kind of just... Correct. Okay.

2:16:46 Dana, was that a motion you made? No, I was trying to just kind of coordinate the thought that it seems that we are leaning towards, again, there's the uncertainty with the event itself, there's lack of information in the application itself, there seems to be some confusion as to the staff of the event and the organization as a whole.

2:17:15 Those are the factors that lead into not funding this event. Well, I've added back into my first call in terms of, it's also been 20 years of funding, and I've just, at what point in time do we say that we're done? You're, you're, yes, it's been 20 years, but there is somebody else that's taking this on because the other one has called it first. Right. No, and if they brought, and to me, if they brought that as a new JAS application under a different 5-1-C-3 and started anew would be a different application, but that's not what they brought with us.

2:17:45 No, they brought, they're trying to transition and trying to, I think, balance the previous with what they want to do with the new and they pay a lot of uncertainty. But they pay a lot of uncertainty. Without a 501c3. True. Yeah. We have made rocks that we've just passed that does not have a 501c3. Right. And there's a private in here as well. Yeah. And I guess so that's the only reason I, you know, I just want to be consistent. And I realize that this is not an estate because that's why, you know, we're, there's a lot of planning that still needs to go forward.

2:18:14 and can't move in a manner that it's going to be successful in summer. I guess I'm looking at the carrots still laying out there, just not solidified until it comes back. So you're suggesting the complex bucket? And are you suggesting a timeline by which they come back with the answers? And do we have what those answers need to be in order for it to?

2:18:43 Qualify for the funding? We would need a fully better program, you know, where you're having your venues, you have bands that are at least potentially coming, and you talk to and giving you a heads up if it's a move forward, and so that you know that this thing has the potential to be successful and move forward in a smaller manner.

2:19:09 Well, so we're sitting with one or the other, and I don't know that we have consensus, and so I would entertain a motion and see where we vote on this. Because something that you said, David, that sticks with me is that I'm going to go back to my 10,000 that I had in here for their stage. So there's 10,000 for the stage.

2:19:39 Does that mean that it's one activity or one concert that they end up being able to put together? I don't know that our investment, or not our investment, but the use of this funding gets the event that we've all become accustomed to. And I don't... Well, I think it comes back to that. Even though it has a long history, I think we have to look at this as a pilot program for a way forward. And so I would suggest...

2:20:08 I mean, if I were the event producer, I would want to go and say, all right, I'm going to do a very scaled back, I'm going to do a weekend, a couple nights of programming, I'm going to work with a venue, I'm going to do this, I'm going to get a sponsor, and then I'm going to come back for, you know, for bigger ticket Measure U money next year with a plan, and I'm going to show that there's still community buy-in at this level, and here's how I'm going to scale it. Teri, the percentage of the Measure U funding for this budget is about...

2:20:36 And I think that we also have to step back to the strategy. And so when you mentioned $10,000 for renting the stage, how much stage could we buy for $10,000?

2:20:58 Yeah. We've seen it. And it has been declining over the years. And it's been up to $10,000. All right. So it's a pretty significant decline. So I don't know. I'd like to make a motion that we don't recommend funding this at this stage and that we'd like to see it come back to us next year or in the fall cycle with a plant. Is there a second? I'll second that.

2:21:24 Movement seconded to not fund Mammoth Jazz in this interim funding cycle and to recommend coming back in the fall as part of the strategic funding discussion. Okay, and you want the coming back part as part of the motion? No, I mean, it doesn't have to be, but that's... Okay, right. Yeah, I guess I'm wondering the same thing, Joe. Do we need to have that be part of the motion? No.

2:21:54 No, so I'm just having to use it that would not fund Jazz Jubilee for summer 15, yeah. Due to the being that it's not fully that event? Yeah. Is there any additional discussion? All those in favor? Go ahead. I'm struggling because I'm looking at an event that I understand it's retreated and it's in a little bit of a shambles in terms of its organization, but it's also an event that...

2:22:25 Kind of just out of the gate can make $25,000 in beer garden sales, and it's got a foothold, it's got a history, it's got a lot of advantages that some of these other ones don't. I understand that we're not satisfied with the kind of composition of this application and the organization here, but I hate foreclosing on kind of those built-in advantages of legacy and opportunity here.

2:22:55 But at the same time, if they have those advantages and legacy and opportunity, do they need us necessarily to do the next step? And if they can make that much in beer sales, then maybe that's the size of the event that they start with. That they scale to what they actually think they can have with the numbers they're getting. That's a fair question. As stewards of the public dollar, we have to make a wise investment.

2:23:21 And I think there's venues out there that if someone approached them at the size of the space, they would be very interested in having that conversation. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, I would love to see us facilitate that with them to try to make venues a possibility and a shared stage. And I guess that's why I would be looking at saying that it falls into that category, but anyhow.

2:23:49 We have a motion on the table to not fund the $25,000 that's been requested for 2015. Is there any further discussion? So I'm going to ask all those in favor to indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay. I'm going to vote no also. Okay, so wait a minute, then let's do it by hands. So we're going to start over with Drea. Yes or no? Yes. No. Yes.

2:24:20 Yes. No. Yes. Yes. Okay, so I think that makes it 5-2. Okay. The motion passes to not fund for 2015. All right. That takes us back to Mammoth Jazz Kids Camp and a decision on whether to fund that or not. And oddly enough, I'm going back the other way with this one in terms of saying and taking a little bit of partial from David saying,

2:24:53 If we did a partial funding, partial, if they can show support, it would increase that. So my recommendation is going to be is we take $4,000, but $2,000 we're committing to, and $2,000 if they can generate another $2,000 in support. So your motion is $4,000 with $4,000, but $2,000 is dedicated to them, matching $2,000 of contribution. So then that turns it into $6,000.

2:25:18 No, no, so our portion is 4,000. Our portion is 4. No, we do 2 as our base. Okay, our portion is 2. The 2 is another base. And then matching? Because they match it together 4. Okay. I do see, I look at our kids as our next generation, and I see that that's an educational, it's a public benefit for, you know, if it's our kids or other kids within the community, I believe there's a benefit there for us within the community.

2:25:40 Can we put a contingency in there that there has to be a recital or something at the end that has community benefit? Well, that's getting a bit too much in the programming, but can we say that funding for Mammoth Kids? Right. Funding for Mammoth Kids? That would be a contingency I would be keen to require, that it would go to Mammoth Kids. Yeah, unfortunately, you know, we're saying two different things. We're not going to help with the JASC.

2:26:05 Festival. Festival. Yet we're going to help with jazz camp. Part of the portion of that jazz camp is they get to perform on the stage in front of other people. It's not just a recital. It's actually performing for, you know, other folks and other people in there. So I think you've kind of just said, you know.

2:26:26 We've spoken out of both sides of our mouth as far as what we're proposing. I don't think it's been two sides. I think there's a discussion about the public benefit of the Mammoth Jazz Festival and what has been funded for that event. I think this one, taken on its own as a kids' jazz camp, has its own public benefit. And I don't think the two...

2:26:50 are necessarily tied to one another, and I don't think that we're sending two different messages here. We're saying that education of jazz for kids is important, and where we have the opportunity to fund so that there are some local kids that can participate in this that receive that benefit is of value to this effort. And I think we've also said that anything we could do to facilitate a version of Mammoth Jazz I think we should do, but that we're not ready to fund it at the

2:27:19 level that the proposal has come in. Then I guess if we were going to move this forward, I would suggest that we're actually just doing this as scholarships for whatever number of kids. If we're taking a percentage, they have about seven mammoth kids. So that in itself would be 4,375. So if you want to say we're going to sponsor four children or three children or two children to...

2:27:45 Attend this camp, that I would put it forward as a scholarship as opposed to? Yeah, just specifically, yeah. So then it's directly tied to a community? So what did we say, 30 to 40 percent of 40, what did we say, that's 10 kids? Yeah. And one in the 100, what is it, 135 times a kid? 625 per person. That's right, 625. But do the local, will the local kids?

2:28:15 Pay that. Yeah. I think it was $125 out of that. They don't have the housing. That they were subsidizing. Right. So that's, what, $1,125? Well, are we saying, though, that up to a certain point? Because there are some kids in town who can afford because they've gone in other years. Well, going back to Brent's initial idea of $2,000, partial funding of $2,000.

2:28:45 To cover local children's sponsorship to be able to attend the camp. I guess I'm wondering why we're just going to do local kids, though. Why there wouldn't be a benefit for kids that are, you know, in this greater area to come here and to perform and to learn. I guess I would be saying local is, you know, like, it's in the whole area. Regionally, regionally local, but not Crossbad or Eastern Sierra. It wouldn't just be Mammoth Lakes. Yeah.

2:29:14 No, I guess, I mean, I'm sorry, I don't remember. Where do all the kids come from? All over California, out of state. I mean, I can see Drea's point. I mean, I think why not subsidize a certain number of scholarships independent of where they come from, and that way a certain number of Mammoth kids would have an option for that, a certain number of LA kids would have an option. If it's kids from down south.

2:29:43 There's the ancillary benefit that they're bringing their families. That has impact on the economy. It's an expensive acquisition. Yeah, it's public benefit. How does that fit in with the town's public benefit? Yeah, it goes back to the town. Got it. But I think that the regional approach, because we know part of our community is down there in Paradise and Swallow.

2:30:05 Well, Crowley. Crowley, yeah. The kids come from all over. The school district. It's the, you know, it's where the kids come from. It's the county. The school district. So, we still don't have a motion. No. There's discussion, but it's, does somebody want to bring forward a motion on an amount that, to fund for the Mammoth Creek's Jasper? There was an idea of 2,000. There was an idea of a number of kids.

2:30:38 And then I guess I looked at scholarships, and we're sitting and talking to scholarships for a camp. It is a musical camp, so I don't know if that then falls into arts and culture, but what about other camps? I mean, why, you know, are we setting precedent for scholarships for camps in general? I mean, should we be doing that? You know, I don't know. Well, I think that's going to come up later on, too. I mean, we're going to have that conversation because there's other kids' activities that...

2:31:08 Following their arts and culture that we're going to have a discussion about it also. Yeah, for me this is arts and culture, not camp, I guess is the way I look at it. That's the way I look at it too. This is arts and culture. We just keep talking about it as a camp. Well, because that's what it is. It's called the Mammoth Jazz Camp. And so for the discussion, it's easier to say camp than to say Mammoth Jazz Camp.

2:31:34 That's fine. It's a semantics thing. No, but it's a different model, though. I mean, you know, the one that we're going to be talking about later is X amount of kids for free. This is X amount of kids for... For a cost. It's a much smaller percentage of kids. So if I'm reading this right, I'm sensing that we're perhaps not leaning towards funding any of the jazz camp.

2:32:05 If I'm reading what's not being said by this board. I'd like to fund. I don't exactly have it formulated yet, but I do think there's a benefit. And I guess I'm clearer on this as an arts and cultural benefit to our community than a jazz event. And one that, you know, is...

2:32:35 Whose application is a little bit in disarray and not as organized. And I guess I come back to if this doesn't happen, the money doesn't go anywhere. Right. Right. And there's a, in our project filter, there's a line item called long-term benefit. And I think any time you're culturally enriching your children, your community's children, there's some aspect of long-term benefit there that's not.

2:33:04 I just don't feel like, yeah, our kids don't have that many opportunities. Okay, so I'm going to go back to the original. There was an idea of funding at a $2,000 level with the idea that there is some match that comes in.

2:33:26 I think it's a great idea and then just add in the language about... No marketing. Okay, no marketing and somehow subsidizing a certain number of local kids. Should it be a certain number or should this funding, whether it's $5,000 or whatever, be applied to opening it up to more male kids? I mean, are we saying we're only going to fund 10 kids from the community? Or are we saying that...

2:33:55 Well, we may have 10 kids that are interested in that. I don't know. I don't know whether that's due to interest or cost. Well, so is it $2,000 with the intent of funding Mammoth area kids for the kids' jazz count? Is kids 13 to 17? Yeah, we then carry the other $2,000 to say the same thing. It's actually four at the end of the day. If the match comes in.

2:34:24 You know, I don't know. If you're doing this, then they're not getting any money for their registration, which then affects their bottom line. Yeah, I guess I'm a little wary of having too many stipulations on it. I understand the desire to do so as well. If we're going to go down that path, then I would say that we don't put restrictions on it. It's a $2,000 fund contingency. They come back with the...

2:34:56 Some local... Well, that's the same. That's contingent. That's a contingency. So, are you going to measure that or are you going to attach something to it? You can't go down that. And what is the public benefit for the camp in itself of our community if we're not going to say... Local kids being able to go learn music. That's not a contingency. That's the public benefit. Yeah. What if they can't play at the end?

2:35:24 Well, do we get to pick that? Do we get to pick that, please? All right, so I'll try to finish this. Yes, they have to be able to perform something at the end, right? A free concert at the ice rink. I'll make a motion that we fund the, make sure I get the right word here, the Mammoth Kids Jazz Camp up to $4,000 with $2,000 of that being direct funding.

2:35:55 and $2,000 for matching funds that they, as long as they provide, that they've secured $2,000 of funding, that can be released as another $2,000. Above what they've got in their budget? No, so they've only got, so they're doing $5,000 is only 14% of their budget? No, no, no, what I mean is within their budget they're talking about getting

2:36:19 They have Jazz Camp donations in there already. Yes, in addition to what they've already had. New sponsorship. Yes, sorry. So, it's been moved by Grant to recommend $2,000 direct, set aside an additional $2,000 for matching. Should they come in up to $2,000 that they bring forward. With new matching. New matching. Okay. And nothing about...

2:36:49 Regional Kids. I'm keeping that out of the motion. I just want to make sure. In the end, if that second part comes forward, our commitment is $4,000. Mm-hmm. And it would be nice if that went to the Regional Kids, but I'm not making that part of the motion. No, you're not. You didn't. So that's Brent's motion. Is there a second? I'll second that. Seconded by Drea to recommend...

2:37:10 $2,000 direct funding, an additional $2,000 as a match should the applicant come forward with their $2,000 match. So it would be a total commitment of $4,000 from Measure U. Moved and seconded. Is there any further discussion?

2:37:30 Yeah, I'm just thinking through the match. I mean, I love the idea, in general, of matching, and I think it should be part of our strategy moving forward. Well, this can be our pilot for it. Well, I'm thinking through whether it's kind of arbitrary on our part or if it is kind of, if I like it, as a little bit of a pilot maneuver. Well, here, so I would just add that they identified that they, or they've listed other funding sources, and

2:37:58 I think the response back was that some are in place, some aren't. I'm not certain that I would look beyond, that I would put in the constraint that says it's got to be new. I would like to get them committed to the other funding that they've identified in here. Well, but if they don't find the other funding, then it doesn't go. If they don't meet what they said they're going to meet.

2:38:27 Essentially unrestricted donations. All right, so we still have a motion on the table. It's $2,000 direct, $2,000 additional for matching of $2,000 new that the applicant would be required to bring in. With no local contingency. There's no contingency like that attached to it. And why did we drop that? Can't we just put $2,000 with the understanding that that's to offset the cost of local participants? For me, that's...

2:38:56 That's kind of the main piece for me, is that go to local kids. So do you want to add that to the motion? Do you want to ask the director? I would like to add that to the motion. You can ask Grant if you're willing to add that to your motion. I don't look at for it and say, are you willing to accept it as an amendment to the motion? Yes. I will amend that. Are you willing to amend it? Yes. So the direct is for regionally, regional kids? Yeah. Local area. Local area. It's called local area. Yeah.

2:39:26 Local area. Okay. Okay, move and seconded. 2,000 direct, 2,000 matching, 2,000 with a caveat of additional, 2,000 from new source to used for local area kids funding. Any further discussion? All right, all those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes, 7. All right, 8, 9, 10.

2:39:59 We are on, this is Village Fest. Alrighty. To number 10, Village Fest. Is there any complexity to this one? Nope. I'm looking around, I didn't have any, unless you guys did, so I didn't have any complexity. So let's move on. Does it involve within the requirements of Measure R&D ordinance? I'm not sure.

2:40:32 Oh, I wrote that too. Not sure. Not sure. So, some initial thoughts on this one that anybody had. This request is $15,000 for an event that has occurred over some time since 2003.

2:40:55 And so they're requesting $15,000 for this year. I mean, this falls to my same portion with Jazz Jubilee a little bit in terms of, I think it still falls under, but it's been test 2003. Yeah. I'm just challenged at how long do we keep funding it, and I just, it's a great event. I've been several times, I enjoy the food, but I just, you know, they say that they're going to be sustained after a while, but we've been.

2:41:20 We've been a while now. Teri, is this one of the ones that was getting Measure A dollars back before? A long time ago. A long time ago? I think there was maybe $2,000. When we did what was called... Heads in Beds funding. Yeah, and it was marketing. It was specifically used for marketing. Yeah, there was no... There were never any money to these.

2:41:45 They came right out, Brent, to your point, and said, in answer to one of our questions about self-sustainability,

2:42:13 They said, no, this is not a sustainable event. So Village Fest has never been a self-sustained event, as this is not a ticketed event. So Village Fest, correct me on the guess, it's been an event since 2003. They're asking for $15,000, a three-day event at the Village of Mammoth. They're estimating that they will bring in about 11,000 people. They were estimated at 9,500 people last year.

2:42:43 And that's one of the things that we really need to look at is that, you know, when it's not a paid event, there's really, what's that new way? And as a meeting, figure out how many people are there and how many unique attendees. So at the $11,000, you're looking at $1.36 per person. They received $12,000 last year, $15,000 a year prior, zero in 2012. It's 21% of their budget. It was not identified that it's in any of the town plans.

2:43:11 It's not a fundraiser. It is a private for-profit organization. And there was comments that they were receiving reduced funding from that. Is that? No, this might have been me just.

2:43:26 Transposing numbers. Is that zero for sure that they didn't get any funding? No. Three years ago? There was no funding then from you. Oh, of course. There was no Measure U. Yeah. So, but they were Measure A. They had gotten funding before, yeah. They did not in 2012 receive any funding from Measure A after. Okay. And is it also, am I missing, we have $9,000 as I read it in planning and marketing. Yeah. Yeah. And

2:43:56 Of the 15th. There's 10,000 in production. Well, there's 21,000 in performance. And then there's another 3,000 in equipment. There's $7,400 in sites down. And then I also have some concern with, well, what's the public benefit? Yeah.

2:44:25 Yeah, I think it falls in the same category as what we were talking about with Mammoth Rocks in terms of animating a space that's benefiting some vendors over others. And the majority of what she requested was $8,000 for marketing. Well, she has a response that she would change it to get higher caliber entertainment this year would be the transfer from marketing to better entertainment.

2:44:57 Any initial thoughts? Yes, Brent, I can't remember, how was it that you came up with the numbers for the Mammoth Rocks Festival? I took 10%. Which in this case... There's one kind of... 10% of the whole budget? But I think, didn't she change it?

2:45:27 And to $6,700, I remember. If you look on the monies that she had coming in, she changed it to $70,000. Which one is her budget and which one was, okay, here we go. She included a 2015 budget and then an actual from 14. But there's a big discrepancy between decor, stage, and booths. Yeah.

2:45:57 At $13,000 cost, and then she only brings in $5,000 for the exhibitor and vendor cost. Uh-huh. So she's not charging them anything. Yeah, or at least it's outsized expense to revenue. It's not cutting the cost. Yeah, I said that to the VIP, too, that the cost of putting on VIP and the cost of actually being, you know, what you're selling for a minute. Right. It's pretty huge, but...

2:46:21 I don't think we can find a public benefit for funding booze. I kind of agree. And so we're struggling with this. We're struggling with the fact of the public benefit. We're struggling with this as animation, if you will, at the village. We're struggling with kind of the inconsistent funding that has occurred that this event has taken place before.

2:46:52 There was Measure U funding, and it has received some Measure U funding since it's been in place. So obviously it has the ability to sustain itself because it hasn't always received funding to the level that it has here. So I hear Teri's point about the consistency of this. We can go back and look at what you did for Jazz Festival or for Mammoth Rocks.

2:47:20 as the model to look at. I think Mammoth Rocks is the model to look at because this is a pretty well-oiled machine for the most part in terms of its ability to produce. It's not really in question like it was with Jags. In terms of public benefit, is it because it's food and not music? Is it because it's rock and not

2:47:49 Orchestral. I mean, those are things I don't think we're prepared to address. No, you know, arts is music as well. Exactly. So I'm inclined to do something similar to what we did from here. So the budget shows $72,000. So 10% of that would be $7,200 versus the $15,000 that's being requested. But did that budget include

2:48:30 The sales and things that Grant took out of the other one. No, I don't think so. I was trying to look to see if there's any retail. It does have $14,550 in marketing, though. Yeah, and that's like you have to take that off the top, I think. We didn't take it off the top. We didn't take it off the top. We just said don't spend it on that? Okay. They do have beer garden sale, $31,000.

2:49:00 And then additional T-shirts of $2,000 and additional VIP area of $2,000. So out of that $72,000, $35,000 is revenue from sale of beer and some retail. Yeah, and I was going back to, if we take the $72,000, we have the beer garden, which I'm assuming is the cost of the beer, which is $9,800, and the supplies for beer garden of $1,850, which all goes back to revenue.

2:49:25 I could go without the lights in its core, but taking that 72 down by about, what was that, 10.6? So that becomes 61.4? And I think we want to be specific when we get that far, because there's all kinds of things like here in, like, VIP food, I don't think we can call, you know, there's a whole bunch of things that can't be covered, so I think when we get down to it, we have to say it can go specifically for these things. Yeah, which will have enough expense to do that. Once we get that far, yeah.

2:49:57 That, for me, was tables and chairs at $3,000 and room and fees at $1,600. So wouldn't we have $640? But that's what we need to do for each of these. Was that $640? $6140? $6140, I didn't write it down. Just a second. Sorry. That would be $60,290.

2:50:26 For the whole thing, which would be 60, when you took out, which is, yes, 6-0-2-9, 6-0-2-9-0, you know, take out Beer Garden and Supplies Beer Garden. Okay. Oh, that's a nice big number, 62, 60,000, 2-9-0. Thank you. So we go 6-0-2. Because I heard Tom was recommending me about 10% of that. Yeah. Is that motion? Or do you want to leave it at the 29?

2:50:56 6029 or six, what do you want to do? Six, so what are our, we have 6029. So when we take out the cost for the beer garden, their budget of 72,000 drops down to $60,290. If we go 10%, which is what we did with them with rocks, that would take us to 6029. Let's follow suit. Okay, is that a motion? So I make a motion to fund at the level of $6,029.

2:51:21 Can I ask you before I second it if you would include for appropriate Measure U expenses? Yes. Is that adequate language? Yeah, because when they work it out in the contract. Okay. Yeah. Yes. Okay, then I'll second it. Okay, it's been moved and seconded to fund the Village Fest at $6,029 for appropriate Measure U expenses.

2:51:52 Is there any additional discussion? No, I mean, I think there's another component which I think is good is that we're showing a diminishment of funding over the years. This would be the third year. So this would be the only thing that I would say is that if you weren't going to fund this one, you aren't funding it because it's been going on for 13 years. And at what point do you say that, like I said, that should be...

2:52:21 Standing on its own, but then the argument to that is because it's a free event other than the beer garden, then it will not be self-sustaining completely. And I agree with you, Teri, and I think that goes into the strategy and part of the question is, well, should we be funding free events?

2:52:39 Or is it not that we're funding, is it that we're purchasing equipment that the events can use? And that will be the strategy, that will be the question. It's not are we funding events, it's what equipment is being purchased that are going to help events, whether they're free or for charge, right? So we're back at the stopgap. Right, this is definitely a stopgap. So there's a motion on the table for $6,029 for appropriate Measure U funds. Is there any further discussion?

2:53:09 I guess I'm looking at it, kind of comparing it financially, from a dollar perspective to the Mammoth Rocks Festival. And yes, we're going off of a budget, but how a budget can be padded or can be accurate, it cannot be accurate. So I guess that's where I'm struggling. With the dollar amount? With the dollar amount. When you look at Mammoth Rocks, it's been an event that has been around...

2:53:39 Fewer years that we're giving less and we're giving more money to this. Just to remind everybody it was $4,800 to Mammoth Rocks. Actually that's a very valid point. Yeah. So then we're going to start to get into the questioning of how somebody builds their budget. Well, I don't think we don't have that ability to question or to challenge the fact that somebody has either padded their budget or they haven't padded their budget.

2:54:09 And I'm presuming that people who come forward with their applications are being forthright with their information because they are receiving public funds for an activity. So I don't know that we have the ability to question how somebody built their budget and compare one's budget to the other one that way. We actually have that precisely because we have an actual budget from P&L. So we can see that.

2:54:35 So yeah, I'm just looking at 20, yeah, 24. We do have their 2014. Or if you're looking at something, if this is a straight event, you know, I know we already did something for, you know, adults, and we were looking at, here's what a two-day event would be funded at, here's what a three-day event would be funded at. And, uh... This is two days. They've got their, um, and Caudade Festival that's attached to this also. And so I, um...

2:55:02 But that's another way to look at it as opposed to a percentage. So we're seeing their budget being $6,000 greater than their actual for 2014. Yeah. And that actual included, wait a minute. I don't know, she says it's three days. Crawdad has three. Crawdad adds a day to it. Well, the categories are different, so it's really hard. Yeah.

2:55:32 Well, and I think the difference here and Mammoth Rocks is there is funding in here for prizes and things, which I didn't see with Mammoth Rocks. No, because they don't have a competition. Correct, they don't have a competition, so maybe that's the difference. Well, there could also be a question as to the level of performers that are secured for Mammoth Rocks versus what...

2:56:01 These performers are. There's a lot of subjectiveness on this. The level of entertainment that goes with Village Fest versus the level of entertainment that's Mammoth Rocks. Well, you know, I'm thinking that if we have in the motion that is for appropriate measure U expenses, that that in a way, and it is on a reimbursement basis, we're saying essentially not to exceed the 6029 and don't know what the actual might be.

2:56:35 Is that close enough? Yeah. It could come in less. Because of Measure U, Appropriate Measure U funds. Why would it come in less? Just because there were so many things in the budget that weren't going to be applicable to Measure U. That's true. Yeah, and that's the bulk of what...

2:57:01 No, it's not. Marketing was the bulk of what they were asking. The second largest was for bands. Yeah, and then ultimately, I think the last thing we want to do is get into the business where we've got to go line by line on people's. Correct. Or people start padding their budgets just to get more. Essentially, we've devised an interim.

2:57:31 Correct. This is an interim solution that we can look at. Performers? The number of performers may differ. I'm just comparing now $21,000 for Village Fest for performers and then talent for Mammoth Rocks at $13,625. Again, we can't. I don't think we can because we don't know all of the schedule.

2:58:04 We don't know the level of the bands that are coming in. We don't have that. Now, if we want to get that information in order to make that kind of a decision, we can certainly ask for that, and we can certainly ask for the quality of the bands, but I'm not certain that that, me personally, I'm not certain that that's a degree of specificity that MLR is looking to get into, but I could be convinced otherwise. I would suggest that on Fridays,

2:58:34 Board meeting. We kind of discussed whether we wanted to evaluate these comprehensively or just one at a time on their own merits. And we decided very distinctly to do them one at a time on their own merits. And I think part of that is just because we, you know, for the next funding cycle, the strategy is what is going to dictate these decisions that we're talking about. And one of the things, since we did say we're not covering marketing, and I know we didn't make marketing on the other, but I'm...

2:59:04 Looking at graphics work and marketing at $11,500 for an event that brings in 11,000 people. I mean, but again, that's not our business. I mean, if somebody wants to spend $11,000 on a logo, so be it. That's not our funding. I guess I'm looking at if we're saying we are not funding marketing, we're funding marketing in a roundabout way.

2:59:35 Well, no, we have to begin with the premise that any kind of special event like this is going to require marketing, and that will be up to the discretion of those. We're not funding it. Do you take that out of the budget? Is that what I'm saying? No, we're saying that... To take that 10%. Oh, she's taking that. To take that out. To take that out. We didn't take it out. No, we didn't take it out. No, we didn't take it out. So we can, if you want to go back and do that. I don't...

3:00:03 And it gives them the opportunity to, I mean, we're not asking them to prove that they spent 90% more than what we funded either.

3:00:29 No, correct. So we're setting a number based on their original budget, and now they can shave off wherever they want to make up those costs. And let's make a motion. There is a motion on the table. You have a motion on the table that is $6,029 for appropriate Measure U funds. Expenses. That's the motion. Appropriate Measure U expenses. Thanks. Is there any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye.

3:01:00 Aye. Any opposed? No. Okay, motion passes 6-1. Who seconded? Joe seconded. Tom, you made a motion. Joe seconded and it passes 6-1. Okay, on to 9-11. This is Eastern Sierra Symphony. First question, is it complex? Can I ask a...

3:01:23 Procedural question. Do we have a plan for a break? After 16. After 16. That's the target. What number are we? We're on 11. And we've been at this three hours. Okay. That was the initial... That was my question. We've been at it for three hours. Yes. We can change from the schedule and do it as we see fit. Well, I think that...

3:01:54 I think that we're going to start speeding up a little bit as we're setting precedents. We'll see. We'll see. May I make the motion that we move the break up? The break up or the break up? If you would like to. Where would you like to take a look at? I would love to. Because we've been at it for three hours. I move to take a break. I second that. We'll take a 10 minute.

3:02:22 We'll come back here at 4.13. Turn yourself on. You just turned yourself on. I didn't touch it. Oh, you didn't? No. So you've been on. Were you on? Did you push it? I've been on the whole time. Somebody pushed it. Oh, Brent might have pushed his bench. So with regard to what we were talking about before, if we were to...

3:02:58 Continue in this case. I know, we'll be here until 10 o'clock.

3:04:54 No, but we have that, right? It's very straightforward.

3:05:23 Thank you.

3:05:58 Oh, thank you. Now I've got this.

3:06:23 Thank you.

3:06:51 Did you say that we went yet? Verizon is supposed to be up by late afternoon. Well, it's going to be late afternoon. Oh, mine just kept reading no service. Yeah. Yeah. Actually, my phone finally died today. Well.

3:07:18 Oh. As it continues to search for terms. It's funny. All you have to do is just ride right out there to the junction. I know. There's a bunch of people parked out there. Uh-huh. People parked all over by the geothermal and all that. There's still sort of down there. Yeah, right? This is you get on, so you do 335 stop. Yeah, so you just go down. Isn't that weird? And then it goes dark again as you kind of drive down past the valley and then it comes back up once you get the times. Mm.

3:07:46 Well, back when I had AT&T, I was down in Bishop one day for a meeting, and I'd just pick up the phone to check the time, and it was actually getting the time off some tower in Kansas. It was the wrong time, so I'm going, no, that can't be the right time. Well, because, you know, in line of sight, well...

3:08:06 When I was a kid, we used to pick up K-O-N-A, Oklahoma City, on our AM radio. You know, if the weather was right in Southern California.

3:08:25 That's what comes in from the desert. That's right. I had a message coming in my phone. Really? So if I moved anywhere, but if I sat right in that spot, I had one bar. She couldn't, right there. I had right there. Couldn't mean one way or the other, but yeah. That was crazy.

3:08:46 Yeah, it's like people were parked down there. Wait, everybody's hanging out there? Yeah, because there's like six cars down there. Well, then a lot of people also figured out Saturday they go to the library because they've got a drive. Well, that's yeah, we went to the library yesterday. Uh-huh, uh-huh, all right, because they don't turn wireless off on Sunday. Yeah, no. Yeah, it's just knowing our other options. Yeah, that was good. Well, that was good. That was good.

3:09:13 So, but I still can't remember this office. I can't remember that. Mm-hmm. So. There's a problem with businesses. You can get the water. Yeah. And you can get the water. Yeah. And you can get the water. Yeah. And you can get the water. Yeah. I don't know.

3:09:35 Well, you know, yeah. It's funny, because my dad always said that, but I do that. It's exactly for those reasons. I say the rule. I can't agree. I know. I'm starving by the time it's the night. That's one night. I should probably put something to eat. I've had my...

3:10:03 Pretzels to eat today. That's all I've had to eat today. That was it. That was it. There's this great plate. Oh, yeah? I heard there's this actress who has the best wardrobe I have ever seen. It's fun. It plays fun, isn't it? It is a lot of fun.

3:10:33 What was amazing, Thursday night I went to the opening show, and Maya went with me, and some friends came, one of the three other kids who have never really sat and watched a play before, especially, you know, and so they all sat in front row, and at first I was like, oh, it's a disaster, so I tried to get them in the back row, and

3:10:59 Oh, yeah. Great. They got it. Oh, yeah. This direction and everything they understood. Great. I just love the way that it's written so that

3:11:19 I'm not talking to you, but all of the dialogue fits so well. It's masterful. I'm glad it came up as well. I know, that's an ambitious play to take on. It is. It is. Did you go to the keynote? Yeah.

3:11:36 Yes.

3:11:37 Yeah, you need to make sure you get a chance to see it, right?

3:11:40 I got the little flag from my ex-pandemic.

3:11:42 Yeah, that's right.

3:11:44 Yeah.

3:11:44 You have no choice.

3:11:45 Let's go.

3:11:46 Let's go.

3:11:46 Let's go.

3:11:46 Let's go.

3:11:47 Let's go.

3:11:47 Yeah.

3:11:51 Was it well attended?

3:11:53 Yeah.

3:11:54 It was quite good.

3:11:56 They did have an really good animation audiences every night.

3:12:00 Which, with play like that, it is essential for people to be following.

3:12:05 Thank you.

3:12:05 Thank you. Thank you.

3:12:35 Which makes total sense as soon as you realize.

3:13:06 Yeah, you know, there's just a bunch of fun in this direction, and that's pure stagecraft. Yeah.

3:13:33 You know, yeah. She should be. She, you know, they, they, they, it was dadly enough kind of hope in terms of whether they were all going to be queues and lines and like, just so much. That's right. And, you know, I think each their performance is there too.

3:13:51 Some patches that have not happened because somebody's missed the line of the camera, they're thinking about perfectly, and the audience has a little bit of it. This is a part of this because of that. Here, would you like me to press?

3:14:07 A lot of their expressions are the same, are very similar to something they say, you know, 25 minutes a week. How strong are you? Look, look, look, look. Thank you. Thank you. That's a great person. I like some nuts. So do you guys want to do a system or cut all of the Shakespeare? Right? That's great.

3:14:35 So we're going to start to move in towards reconvening here in seconds. Oh, thank you. Oh, those are those. Those are those. Sweet. Sweet, sweet, sweet.

3:14:58 We're going to call Drea our, what do they call the Cub Scouts, the Den Mother, in case you make sure we've all got food. We're going to start with number 11, this is Eastern Sierra Symphony.

3:15:31 Andrea, thank you for providing us with some sustenance if we go forward. So I'll ask the question, is this a complex project? Okay, then let's move on. The request is for $10,000 for some increased programming opportunities. And I'll open it up for observations, thoughts. I have one initial thought. I mean...

3:16:00 One observation would be this is kind of a model in many ways for being a relevant and very leveraged project. All the other contributing funding sources stack up quite well against the contribution that's being asked for. The one thing I would say is it's a $10,000 ask. They're expanding the offering.

3:16:28 I'm just asking the board kind of an open question. In an interim funding cycle with limited scope and amount, is that something we're looking to do? They asked $6,000 last year, $4,000 the year before, and this is kind of the combined total of both the previous two years is the ask. So just wondering if it fits under the idea of limited scope.

3:16:54 That in a year when we're kind of transitioning there. That's right. It's not that I don't value the expansion, the idea. It's just in terms of... I guess, Tom, the way that I would answer that, I have been working with Amy, and I'm a little bit familiar. What they really have done is broadened the season. It used to be called the Sierra Summer Festival. A couple things that I do appreciate what they have done with their dates is move into...

3:17:22 The off-season, March 7th, April 25th, November 27th, 28th, you know, our Thanksgiving time period, shoulder season. And then back to the idea, too, of creating the MAC and continuing to have programming here in the area that comes up a lot that is, you know, this is programming that is very invested in the community and

3:17:52 We're going to need to rely on that in the future. And, you know, I think just tapping into the whole idea that starting to draw not just from Los Angeles but starting to draw visitors from the Reno, Tahoe area to come down and to see that we're really trying to create an arts and cultural society to go with our center.

3:18:20 So perhaps the point is that by the expansion we're now starting to get into this idea of almost year-round type programming that starts to get built now in anticipation of future facilities being available. Yeah, thank you. Additional thoughts? Yeah, totally in agreement with what Drea is saying. I did have a little concern about how much they should try and expand in the first year.

3:18:49 And it was the question I had sent to Teri and Tom that didn't get asked of them is that March 7 is going to conflict with a Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater event. And so I don't know if we go for all that. I don't know if they could even pull one off two weeks after getting their allocation.

3:19:12 So that was, and then I think we also would need to, whatever amount we decide on, we have to make it clear about for Measure U applicable expenses. And I think if you look at it, there's a lot of money here going into venues and facilities and equipment rental that we definitely want to deal with differently in the future.

3:19:35 My final thing was that this past summer their attendance was very, very, very low and we didn't really get to, didn't even realize that, you know, it dropped quite a bit and to ask the question of, well, how are you going to deal with that? You're asking for more money, more events. How does that relate to having lower attendance? I think on the first couple of points that you bring up, Joe, I think just to reiterate a point I tried to make earlier and I'm not sure that we have an answer for it, but I see here

3:20:07 The way I'm counting it, and it comes up in a couple different ways, but I think they're, I'm seeing $5,600 roughly in facilities costs, and I think it's interesting that you bring up that conflict with Mammoth Lakes Rep, and this is one of those where I feel like however we do it, we need to begin to incentivize collaboration between these organizations, you know, to have

3:20:37 The Summer Symphony Series operating completely independently of Mammoth Lakes Foundation's programming, where I think we've all agreed or begun the discussion that we're down the road, we're going to talk about having one facility with community governance. When do we begin to require that Summer Symphony sit down with Mammoth Lakes Foundation and plan their year together and work out sharing their facility's costs?

3:21:06 You know, that may not, that's obviously not going to happen in this one. But I think it's something we have to consider. I don't have the actual numbers, but I did have a discussion with one of their board members asking me for ideas on how they could increase because last summer's attendance was very low. But I don't have specifics. Yeah, and I'm sorry, I realized over the weekend that I did not have those numbers to plug in, and I sent out an email, but it was kind of...

3:21:37 in the 11th hour, so I just checked and I have not heard back. Okay. Terry? You know, I realize this falls into the arts and culture and everything else, and it can go swimming up with recreation, but to me, I kind of took it as the same thing. It's still events that they're putting on, and I looked at 10% of their expenses, which would be in the 19th century. Still keeping it consistent.

3:22:03 Which budget did you use? The one in the Q&A. The one that's added in the Q&A. Yeah. Where they have a total of $89,300. And then again. I think their asking budget is 11%. So that would be 10%. Yeah. It could be a little bit less. And again, they're only measure you acceptable because they've got food in there again. You know, and I guess I know we...

3:22:34 You can refer to it as an event. When we discussed it, what was that, about a week ago, we thought, well, is this more of a programming because it happens over multiple days, over a true season.

3:22:53 And I guess the definition of event versus programming also. So the only thing I would add, though, is that they've got $26,000 in housing, $21,000 in-kind donations housing. So my question is, is that really a budget for, is that really a $5,000 budget versus a $21,000 budget, a $26,000 budget? We asked

3:23:21 in other budgets to show in-kind support. Yeah, but then it's not, is it really $89,300 or is it $89,300 minus the $21,000? Yeah. So that takes me back to the other budget, this one that showed it at a $63,000. Well, I thought that they had $19,000 in-kind housing.

3:23:51 Yeah, because there isn't the educational component here. No, it's all. So I think it is. I think it's. It makes sense to handle it in the other way. So Britt's got out his calculator with the really big numbers on it. So did you take. But I guess I look at this. I guess I don't really compare this to an event personally. No? Because I see it, you know, throughout the whole year. I do also think of it as.

3:24:20 Education in the sense of being able to take our children and give people the opportunity to hear this type of music that you don't get to hear anywhere else in town in a very limited scope versus going to an event in the village that has more mainstream type of music. For the sake of the discussion,

3:24:53 We provided or identified a definition of an event versus programming. In the previous activities that we've been looking at were events. They've been those one or two day, you know, events where we look at something as a program that is over that extended period of time offering a different diversity of those activities. And I'm just wondering, for the sake of this discussion, do we start to now look at programs?

3:25:22 Because we're going to start to come up against a few of these that are considered programs versus looking at them as special events. And I think we have the discretion to do that, to look at this programming differently than how we are handling event funding. Well, I think it brings it back to the discussion about infrastructure. And if we're talking about starting to strategize how to build a community arts center, we have to...

3:25:50 Be willing and able to explore different programming options. And here's one programming option that's set before us for something that once we have a facility, we'd be able to say, oh, well, we already have these programming strategies that we'll be able to put in there. And I think that does really contrast the one-off events in other facilities that wouldn't really transfer over. All right. Just one.

3:26:23 Just kind of statement, I think, in terms of while we're trying to struggle how struggling with how to differentiate some of these. It's my personal feeling that music like this is less likely to be able to make money on its own than other kinds of music. And we can debate the cultural value of rock and roll versus

3:26:51 orchestral music, and I have a personal opinion about it, but I'm not prepared to kind of make judgments on that here today. On the event versus programming kind of issue, perfectly fine drawing some distinctions one to the other, but I think we need more of a kind of strategic foothold before we start valuing one kind of cultural

3:27:18 Representation over another. Well, I don't think that we started to go down that path. I think we came back to event versus programming and the fact that we have the discretion to deal with programming differently than we do events. When we look at our definition of programming versus events, this falls under programming. So we do have the ability to not have to look at the 10% precedent that we've already established with the events. So with that,

3:27:44 Kind of caveat out there that we can discuss. They're requesting $10,000. They are expanding at a time when we're doing interim. They are building, though, for future programming opportunities with facilities that are going to be developed. So we give them a head start to get those programs going so that when the facility's in place, this gets locked right in. So I'm looking for an idea from you guys.

3:28:13 I have one, but I would make a motion to fund them in full for their $10,000. For appropriate measure U funds? Yes. Is there a second? I'll second it. Movement seconded to fund $10,000 appropriate measure U expenditures. Is there any additional discussion?

3:28:45 No, I just did the math on it. If we did 15% it's 10,245. It would be 15% of it. Appropriate budget. Appropriate budget. I reduce the 15. I reduce the housing down off it and put back in the housing cost at the bottom. Okay. So it would be? Right about $10,000. Any further discussion? Any additional thoughts on this? Because I'm going to call for the vote.

3:29:16 Okay, we have a motion on the table. Teri, did you have some, Teri? I don't know. I guess I have a concern we didn't have what their numbers were. You know, that is a concern of mine. I understand this is an arts and culture, so there's the ability to draw as large a crowd is an issue. You know, I guess I'm having a hard time with the, you know, one type versus another.

3:29:43 You know, if this was programming and we had an agreement with Nathwaite Foundation and we knew what that programming was, there's going to be a whole, you know, contract as to what that looks like and everything else. So I understand where we want to keep this going. Sierra Summer Festival has been going on for a long time as well. I appreciate that they wanted to make that larger, but I'm having a hard time that we're...

3:30:11 Judging the two so diversely. Judging the two, which ones are you referring to? An event versus a programming, versus a programming. So their programming, they provide the list of performances that are coming up for the coming year. As Drea pointed out, March it starts and it runs all the way through November. That's just my concern. I'll just let you know my concern. Sure. No, I mean, I think that to my, I mean,

3:30:45 To my view, I think this is much more specific than some of the other events that we've seen, than the event applications that we've seen, where here we actually are seeing this programming in place, these bands are in place. To Tom's point, initially, there's an extraordinary amount of leveraging that's going on here that we weren't necessarily seeing with some of these other events. I think there's a lot that speaks positively to this one.

3:31:13 My review has also indicated a very significant leveraged opportunity, yes. And then there was also the benefit, Drea, you touched upon this, the exposure that they have with the students to the musicians that are coming through as part of their programming, providing a kind of a unique benefit, if you will. It's more, it's a...

3:31:40 I didn't mean to pass judgment on the different types of music, but I guess this is a more unique musical opportunity for our community than other types of music, I guess I would say, that we have. And as you mentioned, it's just something that is really, I don't know if it's ever self-sustaining due to the costs of moving around bigger orchestras.

3:32:11 The other thing, you know, I believe most of these are paid ticketed events. Yeah. But they do offer student rates and then also volunteer rates, you know, discounts for volunteers to come in. So I feel like it...

3:32:42 We have a motion on the table for $10,000. Is there any further discussion? Because I'm going to call for the vote. I'm just going to add one little comment, and it's about the idea that we would be financing the first step of the Arts and Culture Center. That starts to become compelling to me just because of the language of Measure U that we have a responsibility to programming for the facilities.

3:33:13 If I'm reading it correctly, come out of that measure. I'm just kind of wrestling with whether it's appropriate. Yeah, exactly. Well, I think, I mean, again, this is definitely for strategy discussion, but as you're saying, the idea that events needs a home and a champion and that we would start to lean strategically toward looking at annual programming so that events would fall under a broader rubric.

3:33:43 Which I think will save these one-off events from having to deal with the same kind of scrutiny that they're seeing right now or the same kind of arbitrariness of funding. We're not ready to do that yet. Agree. And so the only question I think I'm with Terry here is that I'm just, we've given a haircut to a bunch of other events in a limited scope and amount funding cycle and I'm just...

3:34:13 Struggle. I mean, I'm at a margin of $1,100 here. It's either $8,900 or $10,000, so it's not big. In my notes, under sustainability, I made a note that this becomes reduced without measure U.

3:34:33 I was trying to find the language in there. Oh, it's in the Q&A. It's in the Q&A. Yeah, essentially, yeah, it's in the Q&A. They would continue with a reduced season. A reduced season. Without Measure U funds, they will need to scale back. Hire less guest artists.

3:34:50 and will not be able to produce five different concerts this year. So that's kind of the other option is to say, well, we'll fund you for what, you know, for X amount to do your regular Sierra Summer Festival, prove to us that it is sustainable, and come back to us with money for the other. That's what I was wondering. And I'm comfortable with that because the $8,900, if that's what the math works out. Well, I think it was less than that, right. Okay. $6,800. $6,800, okay.

3:35:18 But if it was only for the three days, yeah, that was kind of my thought too and really the feasibility of whether or not they'd actually get a March 7th event off the ground. Well, if you're talking about we would look at this funding to go towards what they already programmed and that any expansion that they're starting, they have to find the funding for the expansion. We could go that route. We could look at it that way. Yeah.

3:35:49 And again, as much as possible, if in the interim we can help them alleviate some of their facilities costs by brokering a deal with one of these other facilities that are asking for our money, maybe that's a... I think in this case the facilities are the college and St. Joseph's Church, so I don't know that we have much leverage with the church. No, but they could shift venues to something that costs them less. Potentially. Potentially.

3:36:19 I don't, yeah. I'm not sure what the sound requirements are. Right, right. But I agree eventually. You're looking at those. All right, so there's a motion on the table. So there's a motion on the table for $10,000, and I'm going to go ahead and call for the vote on that. And if that motion doesn't pass, we have the opportunity to come back if there's another motion on this regarding a dollar amount. So the current motion is for $10,000.

3:36:48 I'm going to ask all those in favor and indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. No. All right. Wait a minute. What was the count? So? That was 6-1. 6-1? Okay. Thank you. Well, 1-6. You didn't. Did you say the same? No. I'll vote no. Vote no. So let's kill this. Okay. So that gives us. It fails at 6-1. So now I would entertain a motion if.

3:37:14 We so desire to come back with a different dollar amount relative to the discussion we just had about funding existing and with the, if you will, invitation for them to generate their income, additional revenue to cover the expansion that they're looking for. And we think that that might be $6,800. If you use 10%, that becomes about $6,800. Yeah.

3:37:36 Okay, then. Which is still an increase over last year. Yes, so I'll move that we fund them at $6,800 for appropriate Measure U expenditures to continue their current program and that expansion would be on their own. For this year. For this year. Okay. Is there a second? I'll second that. David?

3:38:04 Recommend funding at $6,800 for appropriate measure U-Funds covering current programming opportunities, period. I'm sorry, David, were you the second? Yes, David was the second. Is there any further discussion? All right, all those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, that one passes 7-0. Okay, let's go on to number 12. This is Chamber Music Unbound, and this is a...

3:38:34 Request of $9,500, which does less than what they've had in the past. There are three very specific things. So I'm going to ask the question, do we think this is complex? No. Okay. So then let's move forward. They are asking for three very specific things. One has to do with some artist programming, one has to do with repair on the piano, and one has to do with the purchase of new violins.

3:39:02 And again, this is a programming opportunity, not on our definition, this is programming, not as an event, because it does go across time. This is taking care of a piano that would be utilized by not just Chamber of Music and BAM, but the college, it's going to be stored at the college. There's an opportunity for the violins to be purchased for the school kids program.

3:39:31 And so, any thoughts on this one? I just, go ahead, this one I've been struggling with is the purchase of the violence in terms of, I don't know what Brian does, I know they've done community, but we're basically buying the equipment for them, which will then lease back to students and other people that are available. And that was the only thing I was struggling with a little bit. They're saying, you know, where... Yeah, they're the student violence that the kids learn on, or the originals.

3:39:59 But they own the violence. Well, so we can put a Measure U sticker on them. No, that's the only thing I was trying to figure out. Measure U doesn't have that constraint. Measure U doesn't have that constraint. Yeah, that constraint. I recognize. But that's the only thing I was struggling a little bit. I personally think it's been a great program. I'm just trying to figure out how to go around that portion that says how do you make that happen in a way. But I'm not sure is there any way that we can...

3:40:24 I think it's a good call out, but I think I'm inclined to think of them as good caretakers of that property. I don't think I have a problem. Well, they're going to know better than I do. I believe they at least does have to...

3:40:38 Local. To the kids. To the kids. Yeah, yeah. A very small pile. Oh, yeah, it's hard to do anything. It's not even enough to pay for those. Yeah, it does. And that's what I was thinking was that just if you had to actually lease a violin. And I can, yeah, I can make sure they take care of it. I think it's actually a really good model for how we can approach certain infrastructure needs where without us having to incur, without the town having to incur storage and maintenance fees, and yet we're not having to rent them every year for this purpose.

3:41:08 No, I just, and I'm not trying to be negative, I just left three years from now, so the violence are gone, and that's the only thing I was thinking of. Well, and does that go into the language of the agreement that talks about the checks and balances and reporting on it and things like that, so that everybody's fully aware of where the equipment is, how it's being used, that goes into that agreement. We could put language in this that would say, if for any reason,

3:41:35 The program disappeared that the violins were remitted back to the town. For the next program? Yeah, for some other group to do. Instead of that group, you know, taking them off. We'll store them next to the Zamboni. Right? So have the kids up there play. And in the concession booth. Yeah. All right. I will entertain a motion, and perhaps that is part of the motion, is that the language includes that the...

3:42:06 Equipment stays. If the event, if the program unfolds, the equipment stays with the town. That could be a program motion. So I'll make a motion to fund at $9,500 with that language. Wait a minute. If the program ends, the equipment is returned to the town. No, it has to go back to the town. I'll second that.

3:42:40 Drea is a second. Moved a second to fund $9,500 for the three items on here with the caveat that if the program disappears, the equipment, specifically violence, comes back to the town. Any further discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0.

3:43:07 DAP. You've got to write DAP. You're in trouble. You've got to write DAP or DAP. It's all right. And we confirmed that one's Measure U. Yes, Measure U. That one is Measure U. Okay, number 13. This is Mammoth Musicians Guild. And my first question I'm going to ask is the complexity on this one. Is there any complexity to it? No. I think it's quite complex. You know, I've got to say, I...

3:43:39 In the abstract, I love the idea of supporting the development of some of these things here. I just, it's complex and I think there's a lot of, I mean, I circled a bunch of different lines in the executive summary where it's like, we hope this will happen, we will try and prove this will happen, and there's just a lot of, we intend to do X and Y and there's...

3:44:05 Yeah. I think there's just a lack of concrete planning here, and I find it complex but not worthy of a reserve. I want to support this very much, and I want to work with these guys, but I just can't in good conscience.

3:44:26 Fund, yes. Yeah, well, and following on that is it, you know, I didn't look at it as complex, but I looked at it as there were a lot of questions to be answered, and I really have some concern about whether or not it's appropriate for us to be recommending that public funds be used to improve a private facility. Right.

3:44:47 There hasn't been a partnership developed. Correct. No partnerships developed or anything. Do you have a question? No, just a comment on that. I think that we can begin to make a distinction between complexity and vagueness. Correct. And that's kind of where this lies now. And again, I think it's a laudable idea. I think for sure it's something that's worth developing and fostering and encouraging. And I'll just bring back in, once again, I think we have potential partners for this.

3:45:15 that could begin to help them show viability, you know, if they partnered with a venue that is better funded or can get up and running without, you know, or, you know, yeah, show us some examples of this on the ground and let's talk about it. Yeah, and Tom, to me, that's why we just say, well, work your stuff out and come back in the fall.

3:45:40 Well, I would take it a step further, though, because I think that there's an opportunity, if there's no funding that goes with this, because I'm kind of hearing, that there's an opportunity to sit with these guys and start to identify who those potential partners might be, who they might be able to reach out to and connect with, who they might use to help build their program. Correct. So then it does become something that's a bit more viable down the road, questions answered, and starts to move into place. The vagueness goes away. I think that is a role that MLR...

3:46:09 Plays by helping point them in the direction of some additional resources that they could tap into to help them get their program going. Yeah, so I would really like to say it's not ready to be funded at this point. I think that's exactly what I wrote down. Is there a motion? Anybody want to entertain a motion on this? I'll move that we not funded at this time. I'll second that. Second.

3:46:38 Movement seconded to not fund Mammoth Musicians Guild at this time. Any additional discussion? I'll just add to that, because I agree that the great concept, and I think there's an option for something to happen down their road, but this may not be the most complete time frame and location to do that. It's not ready for funding. What is it? Not ready for prime time? Yes. You're dating yourself, Dan? Movement seconded.

3:47:07 Further discussion? No, I mean, I will just say one last thing. I do laud the, I mean, I think it's a great step toward what we're talking about in terms of programming and distinguishing between programming and one-off events. So I think, you know, I think we should encourage more of this kind of thinking and developing these kinds of strategies I think will be really great long-term. I think long-term this is a community worth supporting these musicians and identifying too. They call them...

3:47:36 You know, the Musicians Guild, I'd actually like to see some more story maybe around that grouping too. So is that a commitment to have some MLRs, you know, help answer some questions on the road? Any further discussion? All those in favor, again, the motion on the table is to not fund at this time, it's not ready to fund. All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay, that motion passes 7-0.

3:48:05 On to number 14. This is the Eastern Sierra Advance and Community Outreach portion of this. And I will ask the initial question, the complexity question. Do you feel that it's complex? I think it's the same thing as what we just last said. It's not fleshed out enough yet.

3:48:31 And this, I think, really skews even further in the direction that you were mentioning, Joe, where we're being asked to recommend town funds for the development of a private facility without any guarantees that that private facility will be open to other organizations or that somehow this advances the general municipal cultural cause. So with that said, though, that

3:48:58 My notes said that's the opportunity to reach out to an underutilized facility to identify what those needs might be and where those partnership opportunities are going to exist and how does that facility fit into the bigger tent of arts and culture in the community of Mammoth Lakes. I would very much like to do that, especially as we look at some of the remaining pieces here when we start talking about having the town subsidize or finance part of a film festival.

3:49:28 How can we neglect one theater and be spending lots of money on audiovisual for a non-existent theater? I think I would very much like to make that a priority to figure out where this fits. And kind of across all the deliverables here, kind of same thing, they're suggesting they want to do certification programs.

3:49:52 By whom? And what is that? An educated, structured music program, seminars, presentations, anything. We would need to kind of have a look at the content that we were investing in. Yeah. And I do think that there is that opportunity for MLR to engage with this idea. Absolutely.

3:50:13 How to utilize that facility and what are the additional partners that can be brought into that facility and the resources that these guys can bring to the table that we haven't tapped into. Any further discussion on this? I will entertain a motion. I move that at this time we recommend to not fund the Eastern Sierra Entertainment Services Community Outreach Project as proposed. I will second the motion.

3:50:42 Moved and seconded to not fund community outreach for the Eastern Sierra Entertainment Services application at this time. Is there any additional discussion? Okay. All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. And any opposed? Motion passes 7-0. Yeah. So I'm going to need to recuse myself. I think of the next two. Yes. Yes. For 15 and 16, you are going to have to recuse yourself. So we'll let you, and you can go into the little special air moments.

3:51:13 So for the public's benefit, Tom is recusing himself of discussion on the next two items because of his employment with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and any perceived conflict with that. So Tom will recuse himself. So we'll move on to item number 15. This is Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation Kamikaze Games. I'm going to ask the question about complexity.

3:51:42 Does anybody feel complexity? All right, then let's move on. Come on. You got it. Thoughts? This is a tough one. Is it really hard? You know, well, it's providing an event on an off-season. There's also an absolute fundraiser that is making money and has the potential to continue to do so and grow those funds.

3:52:09 So that becomes that question, what is the primary purpose or the incidental purpose versus community benefit? Right, right, right. Well, I think the fact that they've proven it to be sustainable and profitable to the organization doesn't necessarily make the community benefit any less. From a personal standpoint, I think this is, I mean, I think it's a fantastic event and I think it really...

3:52:41 is something that I hope continues. And I'm not saying that it doesn't continue, but they're asking us for $25,000 and then they're estimating that $37,000 or $38,000 goes to a foundation that has assets over half a million dollars. And I think that

3:53:05 If this timing equipment is so important for the class of the event, that to ask us to spend $25,000 for a special timing system just doesn't fly with me. Any other thoughts? Well, it's also a third time request, so, you know, do we...

3:53:30 It feels like according to some of the precedents that we're establishing for the criteria, we're establishing that we would talk about, assuming we're interested in entertaining funding it at all, that we would entertain funding it at a rate that's diminished from the previous couple years. And it's rendered a little more complex because of the fact that it's been separated out into two events. Right. Which is...

3:53:57 Probably makes sense as far as the events go. It's also shrewd from a producer standpoint. Yeah. But I think we kind of have to look at them together to a degree. And I'm having a little bit of problem with the public benefit from the standpoint of their purpose of the nonprofit is to provide scholarships and training for athletes. It's narrow.

3:54:27 But again, if we start, it's my understanding of the town attorney's memos to us is that the first question is does the event provide a public benefit? And if we decide that that's a primary function of the event, then how its proceeds are allocated are no longer as relevant. They're definitely relevant if we decide that it doesn't have a public benefit.

3:54:55 Or that the primary purpose is the fundraiser. Or that the primary purpose is the fundraiser. And I think that's the... That's where I'm having the problem, is the primary purpose of fundraiser. But again, I mean, is that... So if an event is... If it's a for-profit event and it's showing profitability, does that mean that its primary purpose is profitability? If we also agree that it's an event that serves the community in certain ways?

3:55:24 Well, I think we've had some conversations about how it serves the community. And we have talked and we have gotten communication from the town attorney about, if you will, visitor driving events. And we've talked about that in the allocations committee. That can certainly be looked at as a benefit because it does have that impact to the entity, i.e. the town.

3:55:52 Because of it driving visitation here. But the other component here, and it comes up in one later down in our stack, is that the primary benefit of visitor driving goes to MMSA. Now there may be some ancillary benefit to the town, but the primary lodging base, the primary food and beverage service is all going to go through MMSA.

3:56:19 So I would just, to move it forward, I'm wondering if there isn't a way that we can craft a recommendation that, again, I'm going to come back to my little pet matching idea, but that, you know, I look at this budget and I'm seeing MMSA benefiting but only giving in kind, and I wonder if there isn't a way, and maybe this goes strays beyond what we can actually do, but if we were to say, you know, look, we'll fund this event at a reduced rate.

3:56:49 Whatever we decide that is, contingent upon MMSA stepping in with the same amount. As gift and kind or actual dollars? As actual dollars. Because I think that there's a lot of built-in benefit from a marketing standpoint, from a lodging standpoint. I think there's a big part of this event that benefits that mountain or that corporation.

3:57:18 I agree with part of that. It's also we get TOT, we get tax revenues, so the town does benefit from a total... I agree. But it's also I struggle with the same thing in terms of we're giving the dollars back to a different organization we've done, and does that violate our gift in kind from what happens at the end is my concern. I think it's an event, but the question is at the end of the day you've got $25,000.

3:57:42 Are we really just funneling $25,000 to the event? To the foundation? No, I'm asking a straightforward question. That's my concern. That's exactly the question. It is exactly the question. It's a question that the town attorney has posed to us, and that's the differentiation of it. Again, that in the end, where does that money go is viewed as a gift of the funds.

3:58:10 And another of our project filters that we haven't necessarily brought into play too many times, but does it actually require funding? Is it something that can't operate without? Well, it would appear not to because there's a net income of $37,000 and $25,000 taken away from that still shows that there's 12 remaining. It just is a lesser amount that is netted out.

3:58:37 And to go back to your, you know, matching and all those kinds of things, they're talking about USA Cycling and California Enduro Series and, you know, can't they cover some of this timing cost or something? And I have to go, if you look at the question and answer, look at number one, the very last sentence, is that they need to show solid and sustainable net revenue in order for the event to be determined as a successful fundraiser for NMCA. Yeah, and I think that's our...

3:59:07 Public benefit question. So will you articulate that and just finish this up? Yeah, that if we have to give them 25 for them to make 32, then that doesn't make sense to me. Right. It doesn't seem to leverage very much. Yeah. So I'm just wondering, we're struggling with this question of the gift of public funds that

3:59:39 Net income is going back to the Community Foundation. It's a fundraiser. It appears to be the primary purpose. Yeah. I'm just wondering if there is a way to take upon your idea about asking for Mountain's cash match of any measure R or U match that offsets that.

4:00:11 Gift, or, you know, that answers the question that because there's a cash match, the gift is not perceived. I don't know. I'm just asking the question because on the flip side, what I'm struggling with is the fact that this is one of those signature events.

4:00:34 That when we start to talk about recreation and outdoor recreation activities in this community and the awareness that this is creating for coming to a place like Mammoth for this type of an activity, that there is where we're trying to go is to establish Mammoth as this outdoor recreation place. So now we have an opportunity for an event.

4:01:00 That is also happens to be a fundraiser. Right. Well, and see, that's my feeling is that if they're... I would have no problem giving them some funding if it ended up with a net amount and nothing went to the foundation. Yeah, but then why would they do the event? That's what motivates them to do it. And in the beginning, it was the mountain doing it. I was going to say that the mountain issue... The mountain is, yeah. The mountain stepped out of it and put the community foundation in there, but...

4:01:28 But in reality, is it a mountain event? I mean, it's plastered all over the mountain vehicles. Oh, yeah, no, I mean, it's a big marketing point. But I think it is also for the town, so I guess that that's sort of the question, and maybe that's too broad a question at this point. And, you know, I think this is where we facilitate that conversation with the rest of the business community as to, you know, what is the value, and is there some type of funding mechanism that the money can be put together from folks? If there's a benefit,

4:01:58 to these folks, for the folks in the community that this is going to bring people in, it's going to improve their business in some manner. Is there some money that can be brought forward as opposed to taking public funds that are meant for another reason?

4:02:13 You know, I don't know. And that could be something that we could facilitate that conversation when we get an LTV and Chamber and an MLR. Right. And it's also, as part of a bigger strategy question, here's an opportunity, sort of a cornerstone for cycling programming over the course of the year. This, that.

4:02:35 Three other events, you know, and that's, I mean, obviously we're not there yet, but do we just simply cut this off in the meantime or do we say, you know what, this is where we are and this is where we're headed and we're going to do like we've done with these other events where we say, you know what, we'll give 10% and know that next year this needs to be part of a much bigger package and needs to involve more leverage from different sources.

4:03:03 Sure, that's... A village? Yeah. Kind of like the state of the sea? Well, and we have, you know, I think part of our strategy long term is to develop more of the mountain biking off the mountain and where does this play into that? Yeah. Because we know it's going to happen. If they're showing up for guests, they're going to go out.

4:03:22 Yeah. No, I mean, I don't think there's any, to me, there's no question, I wouldn't hide behind the idea that this doesn't have community benefit, because I think that's really foremost. I agree, I agree. I think the event's on off-season, it's definitely. It's off-season, it's targeting mountain biking, which, yes, a great percentage of that does happen on the mountain, but we do have other trails in our town that are not part of the mountain.

4:03:50 So we're struggling with the fact that $37,000 goes to Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. Yes, and they are asking also for 17,000, I'm sorry, 17% of their budget. I believe last year the request, I think if I remember correctly the request was for

4:04:13 50,000? 30,000 for the two combined events. Was what we awarded, but I believe the request was 50. Yeah. So, you know, that would have been the 13-8 that they got last year for the event. Lindsay's here. I'm going to take advantage of her being here. I have a question. Lindsay, the timing system that you used last year is different than the timing system this year? Same timing company. Same timing company. Is it a...

4:04:43 Different System. Is it more complex than what you had last time? It would be a bit more complex in that the Enduro race, which happens on the last day, we're going to run that differently than we did this year. Okay. All right, guys. So we asked the question if this was complex and we said no. Well, and then it turns out. The discussion is complex. Yes. The project is straightforward. It's just how to deal with it.

4:05:17 It is. I mean, it is. It's one of those. We want to have this. And there is an option that I read within Andy's letter is that since it's a case-by-case basis, if there's a recommendation, it goes forward. And even if counsel says that the town attorney can still say, no, it's not. Right. You know, on a case-by-case basis, it's not appropriate because of the carry-through. Yeah.

4:05:42 So that's why I would really like to understand if there is that cash that comes in from the mountain, whoever should recommend it. Does that offset? Or another partner, I mean, just somehow if it came from. Yeah, well, they've already got, there's 40,000 in sponsorships listed here, so I don't know how many more. I have over and above that.

4:06:06 Maybe. I mean, I just know from a fundraising standpoint, it's a heck of a lot easier to go to somebody and say, hey, I've got $10,000 coming from the town if you'll give $10,000. But I just, yeah, I like the idea of asking the mountain to do it. I just, you know, wonder with a low snow season if the mountain would have that kind of money to give, you know, in their budget. Well, that's why I would... Because they are, I mean, obviously they're donating a ton of in-kind services. Well, I would say that, I mean, we'd want to leave it at, that it could be anybody, you know, it could be Trek, it could be...

4:06:37 Who knows who, or maybe that's too ambitious for the moment. Let me just ask one other question without opening, I mean, maybe it's opening another can of worms, but would we feel differently about this event if a portion of it were, say, running on town trails? Like if, or, you know, if the Enduro was going through Shady Rest and, or does that, it doesn't matter? No, in fact, if the Mountain were asking for it.

4:07:04 It would probably be even different because this whole idea of the gift, if you will, the pass-through is for me where I'm struggling. Totally struggling on the pass-through. And I can understand having successful fundraisers and I understand the work that goes behind them. We've all done it. We've all killed ourselves over them. So what about that other discussion that has been brought up?

4:07:32 Again, in the abstract, where we say if there are proceeds, 10% of the proceeds come back to reimburse or whatever it is up to a certain point. Comes back to the Measure U. Comes back into a Measure U fund. So it really is kind of a loan that helps to get the event to where it's supposed to go that they can then leverage in their own way. That's an interesting idea. A loan? Hmm.

4:08:01 Percentage or the whole thing? I don't know. I mean, I'm just suggesting. Because if it's a percentage, then we just say today, well, let's just change the percentage and not worry about the pass-through. I mean, just as an example, if we began to set a strategy whereby any event that has proceeds, 10% that we've invested in, 10% comes back to, you know, we're investing 10% in the event.

4:08:30 And 10% of the proceeds comes back to MLR. Then we're interested in that they benefit. Right. And that they do well. And that they do well. And, you know, ideally we've created a bit of a sustainability model. So is that a motion that you'd like to make? And, well, with the idea that, you know, we have to explore it. And we have to see. And we haven't asked that in even our...

4:09:01 I think that may be something we're not yet prepared to do. Yeah, I don't know if we're ready to do that in a strategy. Because it still, I don't know that it still answers that question. No, it doesn't. Because money is still going through. Yeah. Yeah. Well, you guys, we have to... We're thinking, yes, thinking. Because here's the deal. What if, okay, this is not a motion yet, but what if we say 10% of the cost, but that...

4:09:36 We'd, um, they would have to return the funds if, all of the funds if they make a profit. I don't know. Because I'm really concerned about, it's going to get to a point where Andy's going to say you can't do this one anyway because, yeah. Well, and Andy has said, you know, we're in this because, uh, previous funding had been questionable. Right. And I would imagine that this is one of those that, um, Andy would say.

4:10:07 If it's questionable, we're supposed to err on the side of caution. Caution, yeah. Well, I mean, I think that seems like a reasonable middle ground to say, okay, well, I mean, we're saying $15,000. So we're coaching that alone. $15,000, and at the end of the event in reconciliation, if you've made over that amount, you need to return the $15,000. The $15,000, yeah.

4:10:31 Because I don't think we can do it on a percentage basis because you can't. It's either an all or nothing. It is. I think it is all or nothing. So their goal is to parlay that $15,000 into $45,000 and then they get to keep the $35,000 and the $10,000 comes back to Measure U. Yeah. I think that's the way, I think that meets Katie's requirement. But it establishes a certain precedent that we would probably have to apply across the board going forward whether it's for-profit or non-profit.

4:11:02 And how did you come up with $15,000? That's roughly 10% of the budget. I thought there were awards before for Measure U, there was that language before that was in the agreement that if that made money, they were supposed to contribute back their dollars on those awards. And the very first award is... I don't know that we ever saw that get into contracts. It was supposed to be that if there was money that was made, that that would come back. That was the first time, I think.

4:11:32 So let's take this for a second. We've got a $147,000 budget around there, so we're looking at about 10% of that is $15,000, because this is an event. We're talking about this as an event. This qualifies as an event. I guess I took meals and entertainment out, and if you do that, it comes down $14,000 to $35,000. Yeah, so thanks for that, because meals are on the next one also. So if we take that down to that.

4:12:02 15,000 or 14,000. And the caveat is if there's revenue that is generated and net income that comes in off of this event, that before it goes to Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, that 14,000 comes back to Measure R. And anything else but that is gravy for them and it goes forward. So this is part of the discussion three years ago with the same thing. And part of it was the question is Mammoth Mountain could easily say, I'm not giving this in kind now. I'm going to give.

4:12:32 We want some money out of this because we're now giving a lot back and therefore the penal makes it look like it's a certain amount of dollars and that's for any event. There's a lot of in-kind donations by a lot of people and what if they start including that cost in? That was something that was brought up in previous discussions on this. It's a good question.

4:12:52 If there's sincerity in the effort, and we're talking about leveraging and the opportunity to, you know, generate additional revenue so that their foundation benefits, we take people at their worth. If that's not how we're getting our business, then that's a whole other conversation. And in reality, on the expenses side, I don't see that there's really any...

4:13:21 thing extra in here, except we need to pull out things like food, meals and entertainment, you know. So what about that? Is that something that... What about... Taking the food out of the budget, drops it down, 10% of that takes it down at 14.2, and the recommendation is to fund the kamikaze at that level, and the caveat is net income comes back to...

4:13:50 Measure U Fund first. Up to the amount of the award. Yeah. Up to the amount of the award. But then from a macro level, how does that not also apply to a for-profit event or any other event where we determine that fundraising is, if not...

4:14:09 Primary at least equal to the public fund. Well, this is our first one. I think, because this is the first one with the pass through. This is the first one with the pass through. With the gift of public funds. Yeah, with the gift of public funds. And it's going to come up again. There's about five more that it's going to come up. Right. So the standard for a for-profit event is you can make as much money as you want because it's just going to into your own pockets. It's not going to another organization. Well, but I don't think that we funded any to the point of where they're going to make.

4:14:39 All that much. But I mean, we've said, okay, we're going to give you 10% of your budget, go ahead, make as much money as you want, and you don't have to give it back to us. But in this case, we're saying to this non-profit. Yeah, but I don't see that we had any of the events that we're going to make money yet. And I think for an interim stock gap, I think this works while we're still figuring out the give to public funds. Okay.

4:15:07 So then what it is is that next year when they come back will say, oh, well, actually you made money, so we're going to have a different structure for you this year. Possibly. If the strategy says we're even, you know, whatever the strategy says. Well, the strategy may say we're going to go buy the timing system that can cover everything else, or we're going to buy...

4:15:27 The stage it's going to cover. Tenants. That could be the strategy. Right. Or we want you guys to buy it and keep it and maintain it and don't come back for us next year. Right. That could all happen that way. Was that a motion, Dana? Well, I was ready to do it. I mean, I'll put it out there because we need to keep the discussion going. We can't because there's more like this that we're going to come against and we've got to get this out a little bit.

4:15:57 We're halfway there. We are. Right? We're supposed to be out here at 6 o'clock, and they're closing in on us. So I will say that was kind of a motion if somebody wants to consider that. Do you want to make a motion? I'll make that motion to... Teri, what's the dollar? $14.25. All right, so we're looking... And you took the food out? All right, so we're looking at a move to fund...

4:16:29 Kamikaze Games, Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, Kamikaze Games at $14,235 with the caveat that any net income comes back to Measure U up to the amount that Measure U is funded. Up to the award. Okay. Up to the award. And did we decide this was our, or this is you? I had it down as you on my evaluation form. Okay, just checking. So that's the motion.

4:17:01 I will second it if you'll add in the part about the appropriate U expenditures. Oh, yes, I will add appropriate measure U expenditures. I will manage to include that. Okay. So there's a motion in a second. Is there any further discussion? No, I just don't say it's probably one of the best ways to go because I was just trying to bait. You've got an event to bring in a lot of people, probably brings in.

4:17:24 $40,000, $50,000 of revenue to the town, but there's expenses occurred with that. Just the pass-through is just the part that I'm just trying to figure out. Yeah. I think these type of events, I hope it grow bigger and bigger and just trying to figure out how we can support that point forward. Right, yeah. I think this maybe helps us address the pass-through and when we take it to the town council, the town attorney will correct us whether this works or not. Right. Any further discussion?

4:17:52 All right. All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Nay. Okay. Did you say nay or you? Any opposed? Nay. Okay. She said nay but not in context. I did but not in context. Thank you. So it passes 6-0 with one refusal. Sorry, I just need to make this note. So let me write this up. Okay. We're going to move on to number 16 then. This is the...

4:18:30 Navigant Community Foundation, Fall Century, and William Fondo. And I'll ask the question, is this complex, any complexity to this? Okay, so let's go ahead and... No, just the same question we just had. So, they're requesting $28,000. I specifically asked, this one also had that, what the funding is being requested for is the...

4:18:59 Event timing and the food stations. The aid stations or whatever. Aid stations, yeah. And the, what was it? Yeah. Event timing and, yeah. Oh, yeah. Entertainment permits. So this is kind of the same thing. They have a net that goes on to Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. Yeah.

4:19:38 Same thing, asking for, now this one, the amount dropped or am I not correct? No, it did not, okay. The event budget, they came back with a revised budget that defined. Correct, okay. It's event timing and CHP supported. Uh-huh. And some permits. And food. Yeah, and I think the food's the.

4:20:05 Is the food the sticking point? The food is for the riders on this one. Yeah. Yeah. The food was the sticking point from the town attorney's perspective. Right. But that wasn't an appropriate use. The timing system was, you know, good. The paying for the CHP services was good. So if we take out the food, which is $12,000. Did we determine whether they could use the town's timing system?

4:20:38 We asked that, but the answer, I believe the answer, I wrote down the answer was no. I did follow up on that if you want a little bit of information. We did look into that actually before applying, and we anticipate that we would need to purchase about a thousand more timing chips as well as

4:20:59 A few more of the actual timing pads. And as far as we understand, there's only one person who knows how to run the timing system, so we would have to make sure that that person is available and willing to work the event for us. Or train somebody else and have somebody else take the time to learn. But that's a purchase of equipment that we could use over multiple years. Yes, if it is, yeah, as long as if our event increases, we just...

4:21:25 Continue to have appropriate supplies. Sir, just to ask one more question, do we know what that price would be? I do not know that. Dana, do you remember how much we paid for the timing system a few years ago? Yeah, when we bought it with Measure R, I read that. Stuart? No, it was mine. Yeah, and we did the research on it and how many chips we ordered.

4:21:55 Do you remember how many the town owns? I mean, we can say it's something that could be covered and those details to be worked out without necessarily saying that this one was too complex to go forward. I was trying to look at it in the way we've done with some of the other ones, is identifying things that were reasonably appropriate based on the expenses and with the same provision about returning.

4:22:23 Funds, but I didn't, I don't have the calculator handy, but I know that things like, I'm sorry, donations to aid station volunteer organizations would not be needed with the, you know, so just looking to try and figure out like web design and stuff like that wouldn't be, but do we want to, is there anything we would want to drop off, because I'm not seeing the food on this, I'm looking at the budget we got with the Q&A.

4:22:51 Am I just not seeing it? Yeah, down here is under food and beverage MLR funding. Oh, thank you. Oh, okay. That's $12,000 down there. And everything else up above where you get into the permits, you get into the event timing, you get into the CHP. Those are services needed. Those fall under. So if we were to take out $12,000 out of food, you would have...

4:23:15 You'd have $8,500. And if we did the percentage with the payback? Yes. Oh, yes. We did take that out. We need to take that one out, too. $18,000. So $18,000 comes off. Was it on the... Well, no. I think we can say... That would be $75,000. If you're just looking at the total budget, I don't know. Yeah. Oh, yeah. Yeah, I was just looking at the total budget. Yeah.

4:23:43 So are we just taking the 12 or are you taking the less than 6? I think we have to take the 6 out of the consideration because that's that same gift to public funds. If we took the 6 and the 12, we're looking at a 72.5. Okay. I believe during our meeting last week we discussed the option as well as having the town provide possible trolley service.

4:24:19 So I don't know if... Well, but that would go into the $24,000 that we already approved on the other side. Why? Do they have... No, it wasn't in the original trolley request, but I remember... No, but they put in contingency. Yep. Yes, yes. But I'm just saying, I think for this event, one other thing that we might be able to provide, which would be true Measure U funds, would be the use of the event trolleys with the bike rack.

4:24:46 For shuttling. For shuttling. Yeah, yeah, but I was just trying to figure out if we were going to do a 10%, what number were we working from? So since it wasn't in the budget, I was presuming it was going to come out of the trolley budget. So if they chose to do that, they could apply through the town for the trolley money. Yes, right. This is what I'm trying to say. Yeah, okay. We're saying the same thing. Teri, I'm struggling with your, where you got $72,000? I've got the, on the budget it's $90,000.

4:25:18 92,500. Expenses is 92,500. Yeah. So take the 12,000 off and the 6,000 off. So minus 18. But that's 18. Doesn't that get you to 74? Yeah. 72, or 92,500, I don't know. It's 74. It's 74. Oh, 74,500, sorry. 74,500. Thank you. Oh, you know what? I think I took the other 2,000 off, too, the original time.

4:25:50 Other Events, Staff Setup, Food Service, et cetera, up there. Oh, okay. Where is that one? Other Events, Setup, Food Service, et cetera. Well, hmm. But I guess I'm struggling with the understanding of the rubric here. We're taking certain things out of the event and then taking and then saying, let's find a 10%.

4:26:15 And then we're adding that 10% is only to be used for certain things. I mean, we're not taking marketing out. We're not taking... What are we taking? And actually, if we looked at the 6,000 and the 2,000, we were taking food costs out before, which were food that they were going to be selling and making revenue off of. So it's the cost of goods as opposed to something like this. And so, you know... What I'm saying is that...

4:26:41 You want to read your... The Dandy, the town attorney, food and beverage of this kind would not be appropriate use of Measure U funds. Which is fine, but... Right, so why would we take it out of our... Why wouldn't we do our 10% of the 92 funds? So we're looking at the $12,000 because that would be what they're doing for their amount. Well, but that's why I also think that the donations to the volunteer organizations, that's a pass-through.

4:27:11 Yeah, it is. And so that would have to come off. Or not be eligible. Not be eligible. Again, if we're saying 10%, we're not funding those other things that aren't eligible. That's true. So it gets a little bit arbitrary where we just say, well, this isn't part of what we're funding and we're taking it out before we do our 10%. Yeah, I think David's right. We start with the 92-500 budget and the 10% and say measure you applicable only.

4:27:40 Well, I don't know, if it was a 12,000 food and beverage, I would assume that's the cost of their supplies to sell, they're selling food and beverage. Yeah, but they can, you know, we can pay for the septic services. Would you be able to clarify for us? I can definitely clarify that. Lindsay, could you clarify for us, please? Yep, so the riders, when they go, there's however many rest stops, this is purely the cost of the food to supply those rest stops.

4:28:12 as well as to supply the food at the village that the riders enjoy after their ride. So we don't sell any of that food. And are those in-kind donations from Mammoth Mountain? We did get $2,000 worth of cost reduction from U.S. Foods for that. But then we pay. So really it's probably a cost of about $14,000. But we only pay $12,000. So 10% is $92.50. Yeah, I'm more deep in that same part. I'm just trying to go with the logic saying, okay,

4:28:42 Gave $13,000.72 last year on this one. Asking $28,000 to do a world-class event. Marketing is $12,000 last year, $11,000 this year. I'm just trying to figure out what's the difference between one year over the other to support a higher number of requests. They split them. We funded them together last year. No, but they split the funding on this, too. They reflected between the two. So I don't think they split it in half. That's why it shows.

4:29:08 I'm just trying to figure out what's the additional funding. Yeah, as I remember, they took the amount last year and just did a 50-50. Just did a 50. Yeah. And this is more event-specific. Yeah. So I don't really have a problem with it. So here's the deal. If we want to pattern after kamikaze, that's 250 is on the table with the... If revenue is generated, the dollars come back to measure you up to amount of award. I think we have to because it's doing the same thing. Yeah.

4:29:39 I would entertain a motion if someone would like to make it. So I'll make a motion to fund $9,250 to go towards this event with any net income that comes back to the Measuring U up to the awarded amount. And my request is for the appropriate Measuring U expenditures. Is there a second? Second. We've been seconded to recommend...

4:30:11 92.50 for the Fall Century Gran Fondo, net income back to Measure U and use for appropriate Measure U expenditures. Is there any additional discussion? All right, all those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 6-0 with 1-2-0. Does somebody want to go get Tom out of the...

4:30:43 Lindsay, thanks for being here. Thanks for your questions. So we'll move on to number 17. This is the building. Did you have cell service? I don't have the zero, so let me get. All right. Mine is showing. It is late afternoon. My cell is showing. I still have no service. I still get no service.

4:31:19 Oh, I'm getting three bars. And I don't have the slash there. Okay, we're on to item number 17. This is the reggae festival. And I'll ask the question, is it complex? No. Okay. So then let's move into discussion about this funding request, which was $15,000 for an event at the village.

4:31:48 And you had some, you provided this with some additional information. So I handed out P&L from last year, the guy sent, and then also I forwarded via email his answers to the questions we posed. And I can look those up if you guys didn't get a chance to read them.

4:32:20 I'm just going to cut to the chase. Is there any reason why we would not treat this event like the other events? Right. You know, when this came in, I was really concerned about it being 50% of the whole budget, but I could deal with giving them 10%. I mean, this is, you know, this is an event, I love the idea of a reggae fest, but it's thoroughly unleveraged. Yeah. And they're...

4:32:48 Kind of under number three on the application. There's even the assumption it says Mammoth Regate is an annual event. We will request similar funding amounts every year. Right. Yeah. So there's no sense of sustainability here. He did respond to a question about it.

4:33:07 God, I'm getting like 100 text messages. You're live. Backlog. You're live. There you go. I got service. All the people that send messages. Right? Obviously, you haven't left him over the weekend. You know, I just, I can't see that we can handle this any differently. Yeah. I think it's the same. Yeah. Yep. Okay, so 10%. I believe the budget was $30,000. $30,000 is the budget?

4:33:37 It wasn't revised. No, nothing was revised. I mean, there is an answer to the sustainability question, and it was just, yes, we are always seeking sponsors, constantly approaching food and beverage partners. Right now we have a partnership with our own business and continue to build the event as a passion. Our other long-term partner is the Village Neighborhood Company. And they hope to partner in the future. Okay.

4:34:03 So $30,000 is the budget. So I will move $3,000. I'm looking back for appropriate Measure U expenditures. And it's been moved by Joe. Is there a second? I'll second that. Seconded by Brent to recommend $3,000 for the Reggae Festival for appropriate Measure U funds. Is there any additional discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0.

4:34:32 Okay, 18, this is the Mammoth Margarita Festival. Any complexity? No, but I think we've got the pass-through issue. Yes, we did. So you guys probably set a precedent that I don't know about. Yes, we did. I will say that this is probably the perfect example of one where the pass-through is the incidental part. I mean, the event is the thing.

4:35:05 I almost feel like the... And actually, he doesn't, he didn't really even have a pass through. He had a... No. He was just... Well, in his... In the Q&A, he said, I'll just write them a check. Yeah. But I think, I think to open it up for the possibility that, so the precedent that we set is... If he did, then... Yeah. Instead of to AYSO, it would come back to Measure U. Yeah. Yeah.

4:35:28 The initial award amount, and anything above that award amount, he could give wherever he felt. But go back to your previous question, do we go back to everyone that we've said yes to that has events, the same thing, like Mammoth Rocks, and do the same thing. No, they didn't have pass through. No, no, but I'm just saying...

4:35:45 We're making a subjective opinion. And this passed through, I'm sure, thinking of it from the producer's standpoint, that he threw that in as a carrot to us. Like, look at how generous I am, and we're actually penalizing him for offering to... But he has made the donation previously, though, too. This isn't the first time that he's made the donation, so he has made it. He did make it previously. And he still shows...

4:36:15 If there are monies that are made, you have a positive net that those monies would come back to measure you first, and then... I think that makes sense across the board, but we didn't start that way. So is that the precedent you guys kind of put together while I was going? The precedent is for those that are passed through. The passed through is that if any net income comes back to measure you first...

4:36:40 And then you can continue with your pass-through on. And that addresses the issue of gift of public funds. Well, and if you remember, this one is a little bit different because I asked the question, you're running an event that's going to lose money. It shows losing $7,600. And he said he was going to make the pass-through anyway, and he didn't actually put it in his budget. Well, he's going to make a separate donation. Yeah. He's going to make a separate donation. Yeah. That's what I meant to say. Yeah.

4:37:08 So essentially what it sounds like is we'd be offering him the option to either make money on the event and forget about the AYSO donation or make a donation to MLR to measure you first and then you can do whatever you want to AYSO and then over and above that you can make a profit. Yeah. Complicated. If we go that second. He's out of pocket unless he...

4:37:38 He nets more than the award from you is what we're saying. Because he's showing a deficit of 76.21 and he's asking for 7,500. But if we went to 5,200. If we went to 5,255, yeah. So just so I understand, with the other ones we did, essentially there's no

4:38:09 All funds are returned to the review. First funds are... First funds are... First funds are... First funds are... First funds are... Okay. Up to the award. Up to the award. Before they can... Before they pass through to the... To the gift of public... To the foundation. Okay. Yeah. So if we were going to handle it as the... Well, I think we could... I mean, can we not recommend to the council that this would be... There would be two possible options here when it comes to contract, and one would be...

4:38:43 That the contract would be that there is no, there's no beneficiary, and therefore there's no reason to give any money back to Measure U, or that if you say there's a beneficiary, which I could see also functions as a marketing thing, you know, you're saying, hey, this is a fundraiser for AYSO, and that brings people out, and therefore adds to the profitability of the event, theoretically.

4:39:08 Well, we've essentially done that up to this point, but this is the first one that's kind of blended. Right. We said 10%, but if there is going to be a disbursement, then it comes back to us first. Right. We could add that. That's the caveat. That's what I'm saying. It's slightly different. But we didn't say that for, like, Mammoth Rocks. No, but they didn't have any pass-through. But I think what we're saying, CrossFit and non-profit pass-through are two different.

4:39:33 Thanks. They didn't show that they would make decisions. I'm speaking hypothetically. Yeah, I would think that it should apply across the board. Yeah, I think we should too. And just to be clear, this isn't necessitated by the town attorney's language. This is a recommendation that this board is making to the town council in terms of how we should...

4:39:56 Approach nonprofits. Do we want to? It's not. Or just pass through. Pass through. It's addressing the pass through. Fundraisers. Fundraisers. Those that are fundraisers. But even if according to the town council's language, it's not a gift of public funds issue. Because remember their whole thing was public benefit first, pass through is okay. Right.

4:40:20 So we're saying that... Unless it's that, unless there's the primary purpose. It's the primary purpose. That's right. Fundraiser. The primary purpose is a fundraiser. Yeah. And that changes that, it doesn't matter. Okay. But what I'm hearing, I'm sorry, I'm hearing that we're trying to establish a precedent regardless of whether it's primary or secondary?

4:40:47 No, because I think the two that we've talked about were primary fundraisers. They said it was primarily a fundraiser. This was a fundraiser. Yeah. Okay. You know, in this case where it still makes the, you know, if we do the 10% and say there wouldn't, you know, and just with no pass-through, because that's essentially what Michael was saying, there wouldn't, you know, there weren't going to be any proceeds to send to AYSO. So we go 52-55?

4:41:16 Yeah. Take 10% of the budget. Yeah, because I think we have to do one or the other. We have to go back through and make everybody the same. Correct. Or keep our same process the same. Or keep our same process, yeah. What is it that we're removing? Which line? Well, what we were saying is. We're going to their budget. On the Q&A budget. From the budget, 10%. We're saying that of the 52, 551, we would say 52, 55, the same 10% that we've done for the other ones.

4:41:46 And maybe we need to say that we do not anticipate that there's any pass-through on this one. Yeah, but I think I've got to care about a single one. Because what if Reggie Fest makes $20,000 and they also give it to the Reggie Fest Foundation of Jamaica? Yeah. Well, I also, frankly, would argue that this is a margarita festival.

4:42:10 Primarily, it's an event. It's not structured. I mean, I guess that's the problem. Thank you for saying that because I don't remember what you said because, you know, AYSO couldn't have their name on a margarita festival. So maybe there really, maybe there isn't any connection between what this event does like the other private events and AYSO. And I'm looking, you know, we're going to come to another one at some point that has like auctions and all the kind of...

4:42:35 Things you would expect to see with a fundraiser. This doesn't. Where that line is of this is expressly a fundraiser, this is an event with a kind of back-end pass-through. Then I would just offer up the way we treated the other events was 10% of the budget. But I would still have to now be concerned that we've established this precedent where it's okay.

4:43:03 to profit privately from an event and you're going to be penalized as a non-profit for doing an event that has public benefit. Because we're saying if it doesn't have public benefit, we're not even going to talk about it. If it does have public benefit but it's also a fundraiser, we're saying, you know, you're going to have to, it's basically a loan that we're providing. And why are we doing that for

4:43:31 Fundraising events versus for-profit events. I agree. For-profit events, you can just budget as you're paying yourself or as an event producer or whatnot. And they do. I mean, we see that in the budgets. How about we deal with this one and then we do an overall motion that amends the previous ones that were for the...

4:43:58 For the events. And the amendment would be, what would we be recommending at that point, though, is that if somebody makes money, that it comes back to, no matter whatever it is, if it makes money, it comes back to. I mean, I like that concept a lot. I mean, to me, that makes a lot of sense. It's like, we're helping to see this event. And it's a no-cost loan. You get it for, I mean, it's...

4:44:25 That's pretty sweet. That's not a bad deal. Yeah, it's just... But will the events want to... No, it's just tough for good... Yeah. Well, because a lot of people are doing events, I mean, they put a lot of blood, sweat, and tears into it, and there's a lot more than, you know, they'll come back and say, well, you know, in reality, it cost me $6,000 worth of $4,000 on my budget, so therefore I've made no money, because there's a lot of work and kind that everybody does. They can put fees in there, but I know this town. Yeah, but that applies to nonprofits, too. Yeah, I agree. We overwork our volunteers. Yeah.

4:44:56 Before we do the overarching one, let's keep going through, and then as we get to the end, we can come back to the overarching, as we start to see what else continues to materialize. I'm not saying we're not going to do it. I'm saying before we go back and redo it or add to it. So what are we doing with this one?

4:45:19 I almost think we have to come up with an overarching... Okay, so let's ask the question. If AYSO weren't a part of this picture, what would you do with it? We would treat it just like Village Fest and everything else. We'd do 10% just like we did before. However, given what just came up and there's a potential of showing profit, then the question still stands. Do we have them remit the loan, essentially?

4:45:46 Or do you go back to the question, though, is this primarily a fundraiser? A fundraiser. And you... Well, you were saying if there was no fundraiser. Yeah, if there was no pass-through. If there was no pass-through. I just think we're, I mean... I hear you. I hear you. Tom should really still be recused if we're still having that conversation, but I don't think we ever really fell down. I mean, there's no real way to quantify whether it's an incidental...

4:46:16 Public Benefit or Prime. I mean, yes, it's a fundraiser, but yes, I think we all agree there's public benefit. Other than we see the net income. For an event also? And so for all the previous ones and the future ones that we're looking at from an event perspective and from a fundraiser perspective.

4:46:44 And I think that if we do this at the 10 minutes, I will make a motion, and then we can discuss it. I'm going to make a motion that we fund this at the 10% as we pass out at $5,255 to be used on appropriate measure, or measure you expenditures. Is there a second? Second. Okay. Discussion?

4:47:09 And I think that what we want to do later is do that overarching for everything because that's going to go to council separately. Correct. We discuss with legal council separately and then we can bring that forward. So when we say everything, we're talking about all the events. Okay. Because somebody could argue the programming side of things too if we really want to start splitting hairs in that regard. Well, yeah, and obviously, yeah, that's complicated. Okay.

4:47:39 I mean, we do need to actually, you know, I think there's room to actually award these funds. I mean, that's what they're for. So we can't, to every single thing that comes across the table, say, well, we'll lend you these funds. We have a motion on the table to recommend Mammoth Margarita Festival be funded at $52.55, which it ends up being 10% of the budget for appropriate Measure U expenditures. Is there any additional discussion? Well, don't we have to put...

4:48:11 No, we're not going to put a contingency that they can't give that money to AYSO. Well, that's not in this motion. We're just going to come back to that. Dangerous. Okay. Not until we adjourn, we can still do additional motions. Got it. So on the table is 5255. Is there any additional discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. And any opposed? Okay, motion passes 7-0.

4:48:39 on the Mammoth Margarita Festival. Before we move forward, we want to go and create the motion for all of the special event funding that says any income, net income off of the event comes back to measure you first up to the award.

4:49:02 Anything that they make beyond that? Is there net? I think in the case of events that we determined to be either for-profit or a fundraiser, that works. For events that are primarily outreach or free services to the community or things where there isn't a...

4:49:23 where there aren't proceeds to the organization. I think that's a separate issue. We have programming and we have events. I think what you're talking about is still looking at over a multiple time period that that would fall into the programming. And it's the single, you know, something that occurs in a particular place and one type of function is event. But the question would still arise for an organization

4:49:49 That's providing a year's worth of programming and they are profiting as an organization over the course of that. You know, that allocation is still benefiting that organization. Programming can't maybe be treated differently just because it's multiple events. I mean, maybe we need to go all the way through them and then come back to that. Yeah, because I know there's going to be some here that make a, that have a pass-through that's much larger than the award they're asking. So, I mean, essentially we'd be...

4:50:22 saying no funding, kind of de facto. Now, there is one other kind of route. We could institute something like this, but as a...

4:50:34 Interim. Absolutely interim. Because each one that we've talked about has been a discussion about the strategic nature of the event or programming down the road and where does that fall into the bigger, you know, the larger tent that we're talking about. So this is absolutely an interim decision or recommendation, I should say, with the idea that there will be these various strategies to be developed.

4:51:01 for where these events can get funding, where these fundraisers can turn for funding. No, and I think, I mean, it's potentially a good way for us to not say no across the board, but also to limit scope and amount in the way that you suggested you were going to. Exactly, and to address the legal concerns about gift of public funds.

4:51:29 So let's move on to 19 with the note that we will circle back at the end. I have that. 19 is kids' adventure. So I'm going to recuse myself for this. And go answer all your text messages. I'm catching up on you. So the recusal, Tom is recusing himself because this event is also occurring up on the mountain ski area, and so he will step aside for this one.

4:52:00 Complexity? Not complex. I think to me the fundamental question here is what is the public benefit, what is the community benefit? It's an event. Right, it's an event but the impact may be less than some of these other events, right? In terms of its cost per, I mean I just remember this year my kids

4:52:30 It was expensive. It was too expensive to do it. And we talked about that in the allocations committee, that the event itself and the opportunity for kids in Mammoth to participate in this feels like a good one. It's really exciting. It's a great challenge. And I think one of the conversations that we had in the allocations committee was, again, scholarships or having a certain amount.

4:52:54 set aside to allow kids from Mammoth to participate in this. And I think what happened last time, it was a little late that they had some openings and some kids did get to participate, but maybe with some advance notice they might have been more prepared and proper clothing and all of that. So we discussed that this has that.

4:53:21 There's an opportunity to engage more kids by asking that the producer to allow more kids to participate from here and scholarship opportunities. And Teri, if I could make a correction to the chart, cost per attendee, for some reason I ended up writing what it actually cost people to do the event, so it was $75 per person or $150 for a team of two.

4:53:49 But the funding of $5,000, assuming there would again be 110 people this year, which they of course would like it to be greater, that funding would be $45 per person that we would be giving the value. And yeah, that's based off of the actual number of last year, not the projected number.

4:54:18 Okay. Okay. So. So they're essentially asking. This is an event. They're asking for $5,000. Right. For their event. Percentage of their budget, Daria, on that one? Well, they have their budget is $28,800. I was kidding. 15%. Thank you. All right. And if we go across the board. Yeah. That would make it $2,880. So that's. Our precedent is $28,800.

4:54:51 With the other provisions? Well, it's going to be difficult to mandate that we're giving less than the ask, and also it's to subsidize. No, I meant the measure you appropriate part. Oh, right, right, of course. Yes.

4:55:10 Because we're not going to cover some of the stuff. They didn't receive any funding last year. No. No, but they had a... They didn't know about Measure U funding. They didn't know about Measure U funding. They ran the event last year. Right. They made that Measure U funding. Right. A lot of people ran that, so Measure U came to campus. Yeah. Yeah, you know, I'm sorry, I looked at this one and I didn't see the public benefit other than, yeah, it would be fun.

4:55:36 If you had kids who could be adopting it, but I didn't really see it. It was, what does it give us? If you take it back to something like the Kamikaze Games, this is driving visitation. Right, no, so that's why I'm okay with the event and an X percentage in our stopgap. And I think it is to kind of create a big event. Right now it's in the very early phases of it.

4:56:01 In Vail, they've made it very successful. Adventure racing is something that's becoming increasingly popular worldwide. Mammoth could be one of those destinations. And again, strategically, if we start thinking, you know, let's have an annual program for adventure races and bike races and these kinds of activities, and each of these individual events falls into the overall program, this seems like a good step in that direction.

4:56:29 And changing the date is a good thing. And it's kids. Changing the date. Last year it was during Bluza Bluza. Oh, yeah. And so that was very problematic. Yeah. But anyhow, so I think changing that date is actually a good thing. What else did this call in for this year? August 21 and 22. What else is going on? I think that's the math rocks.

4:56:53 Is that the same? It's the same. Yes. Well, I would argue that's not the same idea. So there's village activities going on. Yeah, it's the kids. Yeah. The parents who are going to Mammoth Rocks. Okay. Just as a reminder, you did ask some additional questions last time, and then here are the answers that I received via email from Kids Adventure Games with showing what their direct requests are for their $5,000 budget.

4:57:24 And it does say that $1,500 of it is for advertising and marketing. But if we say the 10% for Measure U Appropriate, then that gets... That would be removing that. So I'll make that motion. To fund the 2880... 2880 Measure U Appropriate expenditures. Is there a second? Drea? Terry. Terry? Oh, sorry. You know, just to note, I'm not sure if they...

4:57:53 They probably bring in their own timing chips and things like that. But again, something for us to be thinking about is what equipment do we have that they could be using. So we're going to let these folks know what they can use their funding on, or that this is not appropriate funding.

4:58:17 I think probably across the board we should just come up with a statement as part of our recommendation. Correct. The items we considered not appropriate. So it's moved and seconded to recommend 2,880 Measure U expenditures appropriate for the Kids Adventure Games. Is there any additional discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. 6-0-1, recuse it. Okay.

4:58:46 Tom, can you hear us? We're going to move on to number 20. This is the Kids Fishing Festival. I'm going to ask if there's a complexity to this one? No. Okay. Questions? Yes. All right. Yeah, lots of questions. So, Jo, why don't you get started? Well,

4:59:18 It's really kind of funny because it's called the Kids Fishing Festival and you go, well, how does that get into art and culture? But it does because, you know, they get to paint the fish and then put it on a t-shirt and take it home. So I don't know if everybody knew that. But on the other hand, I was a little concerned about whether or not this was really ready for prime time, especially since Fish and Game has just told us they're dropping.

4:59:46 Trout stocking significantly, as they are. So that I don't know whether or not the, um, where, you know, these other, um, fish and things are, yeah, the DFW fish and programming, I don't know if those are going to show up. I have a note from Gay from this morning. She says, uh, Tom, I'm still in L.A., wanted to update you.

5:00:15 That Mammoth Chamber is having their board meeting today at 3 p.m., and they are going to discuss being the sponsors of the Kids Fishing Festival. Greg and I feel pretty positive about it. If they decide not to, I can get an outside nonprofit to take it over from Southern California. I'd really like to see the sponsors stay in Mammoth, but there are very many people who care passionately about the event throughout the state. The chamber has the nonprofit Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation.

5:00:43 to be the administrator of the MLR funds as well as the Mono County Fisheries Commission's funds. Thanks. Okay. So is she withdrawing her request? No. No, no, no. I think she's saying because MCA stopped being the sponsor or maybe the administrator. Maybe it's not sponsor is the right language. That's right.

5:01:10 Council for the Arts is not the fiscal sponsor. Right. They decided that it was no longer kind of in line with their mission. Right. No. So she now has a, I guess she's calling it a sponsorship group, a group to administer the kind of headline. She said the chamber, the Mammoth Chamber. It's going to be the fiscal sponsor board? Yes. They were going to debate it today at 3 p.m.

5:01:34 And while we're talking, we're checking to see if they had a decision today. Okay. However, within the Q&A, she talks about all these fish she's going to get from the town and every place else. That's my concern. She says this year we will have fish donated by Desert Springs Hatchery and DFW. This will save the town of Mammoth Lakes between $5,000 and $5,500. Yeah. Yeah. But DFW just told everybody.

5:02:03 They're reducing fish. The question that I had about this is that the request was for $3,000 of which $3,000 of that is for the court year. Yeah. And this is the one that we talked about, you know, T-shirts. I mean, the rec department is coming up for their camps is to look for businesses to sponsor T-shirts for those things.

5:02:29 And, you know, wouldn't you want to have your business name on something like this that could go out at the Kids Fishing Festival? So, I mean, she's asking for T-shirts. T-shirts could be a sponsored item. And then the other one was coordinator fees. And the other is lodging. And so Snow Creek is providing some of the lodging. And, you know, I'm not sure how much lodging you need for something like this, but I assume she could go out to the community.

5:03:01 Potentially find additional lodging. So, I mean, one question, I'm looking here, it looks like it's, if these are right, 52% of the total value. Yeah, yeah, that's pretty hard. So, on the one hand, that's a big chunk that these funds would cover, but also it may be the kind of life of the event at stake.

5:03:33 It is an event that people look forward to each year with their kids, and fishing is, you know, a very large part of their economy, so it's kind of nice to get the kids out there and enjoy that fishing, but I'm not sure that it's being presented as appropriate funding for Measure U. Literally, our town council events are not to be funded by Measure U.

5:04:03 So, all right, what we've done previously with events is 10% and... Well, or does it, I mean, maybe it falls in the camp of Mammoth Jazz where it's just not got enough yet hammered out for us to participate. That's kind of my feeling. And if it is as popular, then it wouldn't take very many donations to make up the difference that we're not comfortable with. Yeah.

5:04:30 I've been to it two years in a row. Uh-huh. It's quite crowded. Oh, it's jammed. Oh, yeah. It's jammed and it's well attended. There's no doubt about that. Oh, yeah. It's popular. Yeah. All the grandparents. Sure. But those, yeah, those grandparents might be able to cough up a little bit for it. No, I was just going to say, if we're talking about 10%, that's $572. Mm-hmm.

5:04:55 But go to complexity, though, if they're basically fish, just like all these music fans, they're all still booking entertainment, they don't know what they've booked. Well, that's true. Well, my guess, though, is that fish are going to cost so much that it's not going to be able to fly. They may be smaller fish. Oh, they've already talked about we're getting smaller. Or it'll be really about fishing, which is not catching fish. Exactly. It's a casting festival. Fishery, they're the ones providing fish.

5:05:23 Yeah. So the question is, will they continue to provide the fish after they've reduced all the stocking? And you know what? DFW has a pretty, what I would call robust, like a passport program where they try to get the kids out there. So these types of programs. So I would imagine DFW is going to continue with the fish that they come into to keep it going because they like to keep teaching people how to fish. Well, sure.

5:05:50 I suppose we should proceed as if. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So we have two options. I'm hearing two options. We proceed with 10% as we've done with the other events, or we look at it as we did with Mammoth Jazz, or the Mammoth Jazz, and that we just, there's too much not known yet.

5:06:17 And, you know, I just realized there's another little wrinkle. If she's asking for money to purchase the T-shirts that she's going to then sell, is that a give to public funds issue? I don't think she was asking from us. Because she's asking us to purchase the T-shirts, but then she has proceeds from T-shirts. Well, but again, if we say 10% and measure your appropriate funds, then that's... I'm going to take that out. I would move that...

5:06:48 I mean, I think where this is different than Mammoth Jazz, I think, is the scope of it. And I don't know, it seems like a better bet at $500. Especially if the chamber, if we find out, should we make it contingent? Yes. That the chamber is, somebody is confirmed as a fiscal agent. No, that makes great sense. Okay, so what was that, David? So I would move that we recommend funding the fishing, the Kids Fishing Festival.

5:07:19 at 10% of its overall budget, which we decided is 572. It's 5718, so 572. Contingent upon. Chamber is not going to take it. Chamber is not? Okay. So it's still contingent. So it would be contingent upon having a fiscal agent confirmed. That we would have to approve. That we'd have to approve.

5:07:47 Yeah. For the funding. Yeah, right. I don't know. I mean, if the Chamber says no, does that shift it? No, I think the Chamber, what they said is the Chamber said that they're concerned about pass-through for the nonprofit where that exists, plus just the time frame right now to jump into it, the direction of the Chamber's going on educational and business to business versus doing events. Mm-hmm. Got it. So, you know what? So there's a fiscal, so there's a couple of other fiscal agents that she...

5:08:19 We might be able to find out there that our Mammoth, she was going through the Mammoth, the Community Foundation, Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation. Well, there's a fiscal agent called MLR that's already working on a Raise the Roof campaign. True to? True to. That's a good point. So we probably aren't able to, I don't know, that puts it in a complex bucket.

5:08:46 Yeah, it did kind of move to the complex bucket. We haven't approved that yet. I know. So here's the deal. If she still has a fiscal agent out there to find, if she comes forward with that fiscal agent, and that we do approve it, and if it doesn't, then MLR might be the potential default fiscal agent. I guess we can talk about that. Is there a timeline on that? Does she need to have that before the recommendation goes to council, for example? No, before it.

5:09:16 Before she gets a contract. So we have some time to develop that. Okay. Okay, so David, did you make that as a motion? I did. 572 measure U, appropriate and contingent unconfirmed fiscal agent? Yep. And appropriate measure U fund? Yeah. Is there a second? I'll second. Drann? Moved and seconded to fund 572. We round it up.

5:09:57 With contingency of having a fiscal agent in place and appropriate measure U expenditures. Any additional discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0. Okay. We're on to number 21. This is the Labor Day Festival of Arts, Mono Council for the Arts. I've got a...

5:10:34 Couple of additions for the chart. Labor Day Festival originally requested $9,000. They've come back when we did the round of questions and reduced their funding to $4,500. They are interested in using an MLR purchase stage to share with other events, and they did a little bit of research on that. And the event is free.

5:11:05 But if we were to pay, let's say, if we were to fund the $4,500 for the estimated 1,500 participants, it would be about $3 per person that we would be funding. Again, the event is free. And so I think $9,000 was 8%.

5:11:36 The total budget. Yeah, but that was for the overall budget, not just for the kids' festival budget. And, Andrea, in their answer to number one, I thought they were asking for $2,500 for rental of the stage, even though they said, well, if you guys buy one, great. But at this point, didn't their Q&A number one say, we're asking for rental fees to include a stage in several tenths in the amount of $2,500? Correct, correct. But I think, I'm just saying, I think they would be amenable, you know, if we could...

5:12:05 Fund on the condition that we may be purchasing a stage and that might be of use to them rather than having them pay for somebody else to use the stage. Right. Do we really think we'll get through the strategy and have that kind of stuff worked out before the summer? No. And they do say that in their initial answer, too, is that if it's ever to be used, here's the stage to look at. So I think the rental of the stage is appropriate. So they minimized or they reduced it.

5:12:34 their request because presuming that there was going to be a stage purchased. No, no, no, no. They reduced their request because they decided not to because there was during the transition period of when it was of when the funding request was submitted and then the organization has switched around with Kristen now in charge of this and they've decided not to

5:12:59 Have, I think, a puppet show and another entertainer. And so they realized they were able to reduce the funding request. So it's down to $4,000 something? I thought she said it was down to $7,000. That was the first. Because the $2,500 and the $4,500. Kristen, could you come up so we could ask you some questions, please? Yes, please. Because we did move it. Did I write that wrong? We did go from $9,000 to $7,000. Yeah. Early. Kristen? Did you have a list of my proposal?

5:13:28 Yes. Can you go to the podium, please? Thank you. So are we correct? I wrote down when we had the Q&A that you said you're reducing the budget by taking out the puppets, and it would be $7,000 total, which was $2,500 and $4,500. $7,000 is what we reduced it to. Okay. So $7,000 is the still to house. Yes. Okay.

5:13:58 All right. From the nine. Okay. Sorry. Sorry about that. So I guess it's the $2,500 is still for the stage. Sorry. So that $7,000 would cover potential rental of the stage. Yes. But you did not provide us with a kids' tent budget only. The budget that was attached on the Q&A is for the entire event? Yes. Yes. The $38 and... Yeah. Yeah, that's the entire event.

5:14:28 So if we were to look at that 10%, that would be less than the $7,000 that we were looking at, and they had profit there, so that would fall under the same pass-through that we were looking at. Or fundraiser, I mean. So on their original budget, they didn't break out the kids' art booth. Okay.

5:15:01 Taken out is the puppets. I'm just wondering to go back to the question about specific the kids' art booth. Yeah. I was looking for that page, but the one I'm finding that's for 61,000 or whatever, that's for the whole festival. But again, I mean, I wonder if, I mean, it seems to me that the producer in this case...

5:15:34 has tried to give us a they've suggested to us why don't you finance this portion of our budget but for us to go to go from the overall 61 down to the just the kids art booth and then take 10% of that obviously is

5:15:54 Kind of a radical. So we do 10% of the whole, right? Right. 21 is the income, 45 is the expense budget. Got it. And 15 is a fundraiser, almost 16 is a fundraiser to Rural Council of the Arts. So I think we handle it like the other fundraisers. Right. Events, fundraiser events. Okay. Yep. Yeah. Which? Makes sense to me. The only other thing that I would add is as we were discussing

5:16:23 Is there an update? Do you have an MOU with Sam Walker? Do we know that the wood sites are feasible? I don't know. I don't have the latest information on that. So the only thing I would say is that we should consider, I mean, we're talking about programming for the summer multi-use facility, and I think that could be a perfect facility as a backup for this Labor Day Arts Festival.

5:16:53 Could potentially, that could potentially be that place where we say $2,500 and we're going to buy a stage for the multi-use facility that would be used. I mean, I know that's thrown in a lot of things, but. Well, unfortunately, though, that also gets in the question of how much, if it's under construction this summer. Absolutely. So, yeah. So, maybe let's take a step back, if we go back to our original. Yeah. 10%. Yeah. And.

5:17:22 With the caveat that the Sam's Woods is available. Well, they're going to. You're going to have to. We're going to have to find it. We're going to have to find it. We have Shady Rest as backup. Yeah. So then let's go to, if you want to go to how we've been doing events like this. 1040, 730.

5:17:42 So I took off the puppets, which ones did you cancel, isn't that the

5:18:13 $4,224, Measure U Appropriate Expenditures with the caveat we have done before about returning the funds up to the amount of the award since it is a fundraiser. Hold on. There. She just said it. Yeah. Did I get the whole? I think part of that motion, I'm going, did I forget something, but I think I got it all. There's a fundraising element to it. There's a percentage that comes back.

5:18:44 Yep. Up to the amount awarded as part of the debt income. Yes. And appropriate measure U expenditures. Right. So that's a move by Joe. I'll second it. Seconded by Dave. So I just have some question about this. So it's a fundraiser for the Mono Council for the Arts, which is for the arts. Right.

5:19:15 Which we are, is a big portion of Measure U. So I'm just wondering if that isn't different than a fundraiser that goes to help skiers pay their education and tuition and travel housing expenses. Well, I kind of agree with you, Drea, and I even went and pulled their stated purpose.

5:19:43 which is to promote the growth and appreciation of art in the Mammoth Lakes region. But I think we still have to ask that question of how closely does our purpose fit with the town's purpose? And we're going to get into it shortly about another organization whose mission is to promote cultural enrichment in Mammoth. I think in this interim part of it,

5:20:18 I don't know that we can differentiate that way. I think in a larger strategic discussion where there's the opportunity to grow the organizations that have the arts and culture elements to them and where they are all pulled together to help grow each other, I think we have the ability to do it that way. I don't know that we can differentiate at this one because I would kind of offer up that

5:20:45 Making money for education for kids to ski, that's recreation. And that's a competitive outdoor recreation element, and that lines right up with this also. And so I don't know that we can differentiate, but I will... I agree because I think there are two components, and one is the mission of the organization, the purported mission of the organization, and the other is where does their programming align with ours and with the interests of the town.

5:21:11 And so, again, strategically, hopefully we'll get to a place by the fall funding cycle where we're looking at everything in a bigger picture and each organization is bringing in part of a larger programming puzzle instead of, as this has been in the past and continues to be for this interim phase, a kind of reactive based on here's what we're doing and can you help? Down the road it's going to be more of here's where we think your thing fits and...

5:21:40 This is how we'll help. This is how we'll help. Exactly. So we have a motion on the table. And it's been seconded. It has been seconded. Is there any additional discussion? Good points. I don't know that we can differentiate. Any additional discussion? All right. All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0. Kristen, thanks for answering our questions.

5:22:10 Item number 22, this is the Kids' Summer Art Camp, also a mortal council for the arts. Complexity? Nope. Nope. Okay. Discussion? Can you tell me off of that, Teri, because I can't read it from this angle, what was the cost per kid on this one? Let me correct it. So it's free for kids ages four and up.

5:22:36 If we would fund at $7,625, it would be $25 per kid. Okay, so, but did you start that by saying it was free for kids 4 and up? It's free.

5:22:57 Up to four. Up to four. Thank you. Okay. Up to four years old and then from five to four. No, no, it's free for kids four and up. So you have to be four years of age to participate in this program. Okay. But if it's free for them, then how does it get? Oh, okay. It's free cost to them. If it's $7,000, it would be funding them at $25. Okay. All right. And I did make a note.

5:23:25 with the budget where we had asked about the in-kind value of the facility at the Sierra Center Mall and so that was $4,000 but that was not added to the total value to the total budget so the budget if you were going to continue with the other models that had in-kind

5:23:55 As part of the budget, so it would make the budget $12,485, so at that point the request is 61% of the budget. And the request is all within the administrative and supplies, not the marketing and advertising. Correct. On something like this, you know, I see us, you know, do we provide these art supplies for something like this?

5:24:30 Supply that, you know, that type of contribution to a program that is putting on something like this as opposed to, you know, it's not an event, it's, you know, are we completely funded on the thing? And I don't know if they ended up getting any money from Mono County either. They'll find that out on the 17th. Okay. But it will, if funding is received, it will probably be minimal this year.

5:24:59 One thing that distinguishes this, I think, in my mind from other events that we've looked at or other programming that we've looked at is that it's really, there's no financial benefit to any organization, right? There are no proceeds. So this is strictly, this is just a service being provided to the community. Correct. Right. And without it, these five weeks of programming don't occur. Right.

5:25:33 I mean, there's no revenue stream. There's no revenue stream? No. So without it, kids don't know. It says that they will continue with the Kids' Arts Campus. We'll have to charge a fee. So it won't be free. And so that probably impacts who gets to participate? Because right now, as being free, it's open to a variety of participants. It's programming. What did we do for previous programming? It's been a while. For Chamber of Music, we did 62%.

5:26:10 Chamber of Music, we did... We did $9,500. We did $9,500 for the program. For the program. We did ask the question also about the role of the Recreation Department integrating into some of their... Right. Yeah, and I guess that would be one of my concerns. You know, I'm, you know, once again, I think in strategy we're going to figure out, you know, what we're supporting, but...

5:26:44 You know, there's a lot of support that already goes into different camps and, you know, they aren't coming to Measure R or Measure U. But there aren't a lot of free camps. I mean, this one to me seems like 100% public benefit. There's no real way to, you know, they're not charging an admission. They're not, you know, obviously there are minimal administrative costs that make something like this possible.

5:27:18 The only way, we have to, I think, fundamentally decide if we treat this the same way as we do some of the other things that come before us. And, you know, the only way that this becomes sustainable is through other sources of funding or some kind of pay for the service, whether it's a donation-based, an aggressive donation-based kind of.

5:27:43 And there's some in their answers, there's kind of a hint that, yeah, well, they think they could find some of it. Maybe this is one of those times to go back to a certain amount and then a match for other sponsorships or contributions. The leverage side of it? Yeah. Figure out what that percentage is and then use that as a match for additional revenue to come in.

5:28:09 Yeah, and Joe, you mentioned the CrowdRise thing. This is definitely one where we could set up a fundraiser and say, let's raise X, you know, here's our goal, everybody, let's get on board with this. It's free art for the community. Yeah, and it's my understanding if we say, I don't know, I'll just use two and two because it's easier to add. So that really means that they raised two so they end up with six, right? So maybe this is the time to apply that as well.

5:28:37 I'll entertain a motion if someone would like to frame it. So what we're saying is, let me see if I can understand this. We're not saying to fund the whole thing at 76, sorry, turn to that page. We're not saying to fund 76.25. We are looking at a percentage of that or some dollar amount to fund with the opportunity to

5:29:05 Match with some outside fundraising efforts that MLR could assist with? So I would move 3,500 direct, which is about half of what they asked for, 3,500 held for matching, measure you appropriate, etc. Yes.

5:29:28 But then we're boosting their budget.

5:29:32 Oh, sorry.

5:29:32 Oh, okay.

5:29:33 Somebody who's got a calculator who can do the math.

5:29:35 I'm sorry.

5:29:36 What's half?

5:29:37 So do, if you're going to do 35 direct and then do 20.

5:29:41 Whatever half of it.

5:29:43 Well, I was.

5:29:44 1750.

5:29:45 Yeah.

5:29:45 And matching.

5:29:49 Okay.

5:29:50 Somebody who's got a, what are the numbers?

5:29:53 And then I'll.

5:29:54 I was thinking.

5:29:55 So they asked for 7,625.

5:29:58 Half of that would be...

5:29:59 $3,813. But they've got a total budget of $12,485, right? Mm-hmm. And if we do... Okay, so then how about... So that's what I explained of the $4,000 for this... In kind, which was in the additional questions. But this one, they're asking for a much higher percentage of... So, let's go... Okay, what if we said...

5:30:34 What? But, I mean, they've already got the four. Oh, oh, I'm sorry. Oh, okay. Wait a minute. I think we have one. 3,000 direct, 2,000 held in reserve for matching of new sponsors, which would give them a total of seven. And we can assist in setting up a fundraiser that would have that matching as part of the incentive.

5:31:02 3,000 direct, 2,000 matching for Measure U Appropriate. I second that. So that's Joe. And Joe's going to explain all this to Tom Counsel, right? Yeah.

5:31:17 So let's get this right, so 3,000 direct, 2,000 held in reserve for matching, for measuring your appropriate expenditures. And with the MLR, with the MLR. Well, I don't think that's part of the motion. Do you want it part of the motion? Okay, okay, with MLR, okay. Okay. Do you want to put that motion?

5:31:39 I'd say leave that out. No, yeah, I mean, I think it's just like all the other ones, like that's part of our commitment. Because they may find that it makes more sense for them to set it up. Right. And that match can come from various sources. And then, incidentally, in the discussion, if we help them set up a progress for it, then... So that gets them, if they come up with that other $2,000 to match this $2,000, that gets them to $7,000. Yeah.

5:32:09 Eight, no, three and two and two.

5:32:12 Two and two is four and three is seven.

5:32:14 All right, is there any additional discussion?

5:32:19 All those in favor indicate by aye?

5:32:21 Aye.

5:32:22 Any opposed?

5:32:24 No.

5:32:24 All right.

5:32:28 Okay.

5:32:32 Okay, now we're on to

5:32:33 number 23, the art club.

5:32:37 also council for the arts

5:32:42 Yeah, complexity? No. Just to jump to the end is that I see this should be treated just like we did the Eastern Sierra Symphony because it's a year-round programming and that if I remember correctly, the revised budget is $48.60 because they took out the $100 on the flyers.

5:33:12 Yeah, it's 4860. So if we did it the same as that, it would be full amount, Measure U appropriate expenditures. 4860. 4860. And they did just secure funding from the MESPTO for $1,000?

5:33:36 And I think that showed a great initiative on leveraging. That was per a suggestion of our group, the allocations committee. And if they were able to say to the PTO that they're leveraging PTO's investment with Measure U investment, and now we can leverage each other's funding. That worked. Yeah, so it worked.

5:34:01 So Joe, I think I just made a motion. Yes. To approve it at 4860. Yeah. 4860, measure you appropriate. Art camp? Yes. Art club. Art club? Program. Yeah, because the town also funds like the Husky Club, you know, $26,000.

5:34:21 So I, you know, I appreciate you did that. So are we going to reduce it by $1,000 since they discussed $1,000 from BTO? Um, no, because that's, I think that's one of the areas. Oh, were we? Oh, I'm sorry. Okay. Um, total.

5:34:50 I was just looking at... Program expenses is listed as $48.60. Yeah. Oh, okay. And they've just secured $1,000 from the MESPTO. All right, so then I'll amend my own motion to say $38.60. Although they are saying that they've got a $400 loss. Oh. So maybe we just take $600 off. All right, so that would be $42.60.

5:35:23 We're taking $600. I just want to make sure that we're going to look at these things in a strategic manner at a later time, because I just think that we're kind of all on the board. This is programming, and it lines up with the Sierra, Eastern Sierra Symphony that we spent. Which was funded in full. Was programming, and it was funded in full, and it established. Because they were purchasing items for them to do their program. For the Sierra, not for, no, that was for. Wasn't that the violence? No, that was Chamber of the Musical Band.

5:35:51 But we didn't fund them in full, did we? We funded Chamber of Music and Brown in full. In full, yes. Yeah, we did. Symphony was in full. Symphony, we gave them $6,800 out of $10,000. Oh, that's right. Okay. It was CMU that got the full amount because it was the school-related. The violins and the piano and it was the school after-school program. So, yeah, it was the expansion. That's right.

5:36:14 Okay, now I'm totally confused of what number we're all discussing. So you had a motion that started off at 48 and 60. So you had an initial motion and there hasn't been a second to that. There wasn't a second to that. So it can, we can, it can die. It died. So that initial motion is no longer. But I got confused when somebody said, well, we're going to reduce something else. That got me confused. So the question was asked, the budget was at

5:36:42 Went from $49.60 to $48.60 because we removed the flyers. Right. And then the PTO has donated $1,000, which if you were to subtract that would take it to $38.60. And why do we remove the flyers? Because that's marketing. Well, yeah, but we've been allowing marketing and all these other budgets. We're just not allowing them to spend their time. But they were asking for 100% funding. I see. Yeah.

5:37:06 There was no, there was, now there's a donation, so then $38.60, I think, makes sense. Well, and one thing I do want to point out at this, they don't have the value of the in-kind donation of the school facilities listed in their budget. Well, that's true. That's true. And I think you have to take into account this $366 loss that they're... So, I mean, what...

5:37:34 If we fund them and they don't spend it, we're going to get it back. Exactly. Where are you seeing the $366,000? Am I wrong on that? On the addendum. On the Q&A? Yeah. Oh, okay. Because I'm like, no, their expenses are $49.60. Yeah. That was their losses for 2014. That was last year. That was last year. Yeah. Fair enough. Okay. So I'm just looking at what their expenses are being proposed for this year, $49.60.

5:38:03 So if you take off the $1,000. And the $100. Then we're at $38.60. Well, yeah, but we don't have to take the $100 off, then. If we're already taking... The PTO's paying for it. But we're not 100% funding anymore. $1,000 can come out of the PTO. Okay, 100%. So we're at $39.60? $39.60. Wow.

5:38:27 The group, the group, 3960, measure your appropriate expenditures, yeah. So Joe, that's your motion, 3960, is there a second? I'll second that. David, second, 3960, is there any additional discussion? All those in favor, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes at 3960.

5:39:00 Yes, you do need to recuse yourself. David is going to recuse himself because of the next two items. Okay, this is number 24. Yeah. This is number 24. This is Mammoth Children's Theater, Sierra Classic Theater. And the request is 5625. And that is 100%, right?

5:39:36 No. Okay. Wait a minute. I've got to pull the other piece up. Hold on a second. So it's about half. Not quite. Just about half. It's like 40-something percent? 51 percent. Oh, okay. Oh, yeah, that's right. So you'd be subsidizing $193 per person. Ooh. Yeah. And they are growing.

5:40:17 They're looking to increase the amount of participants. So they are looking to grow those. On something like this, you know, I guess I kind of go, I'm going back to where I was before, because I thought we could, you know, offer the supplies. So I'm going to go back to the same thing here. If we're looking at costumes and props, sets, and theater rental, that's helping them with their base expenses.

5:40:48 to move the program forward. I would also offer that they do need the supervision, because this is the kids' side of it, and so you do need the, how do I say this, someone to teach it, or to instruct it, or to stage it. The director and assistants? Yes. I would argue that we do not pay for a cast party.

5:41:16 You know, I guess I go back to this one, and I'm still struggling with this as far as, you know, what we do with where we work with the town. And she answered that. Well, she sort of answered it. Because the town does not offer a free program. The town charges a fee to show up your theater. There's not a free program there. And so I think that's fine, and I understand that, you know, they're looking at possibly doing two different things, but I think the opportunity is there.

5:41:46 to possibly work with the town's recreation department and move something like this forward where they could help with facilities, they could help with some different things. Because she stated that the youth showboat youth theater is free and it's not. The kids have to pay you.

5:42:07 A fee to get into that. And I just see that, you know, I see us kind of going against what the town's doing if we're trying to do programs that are kind of consistent to the two, but it's not a benefit to the town that's kind of going against their own department. And I'm struggling with that one. Yeah, but I think there was an issue with the showboat theater.

5:42:34 And I'm thinking that the initial communication that came in from the town didn't express that interest in replacing showboat theater or adding SCT theater to the town program. I was going to say, is it showboat in the summer? It is, it is. It is in the fall, yeah.

5:43:02 This is definitely more directed, I mean, towards local kids that are in the community year-round. Yes. I want to point out as well that that 193 figure per kid is, I think that's inaccurate, I think it's 112. Yeah, I think that's exactly for the 29 students instead of the 50. At the projection for 2015. Because I don't think we have 15. Yeah, it's 15. We did 27, what was it, 29. Okay.

5:43:32 So, has this been done before at the same time of year? What's the question? I was just, I'm just, I'm trying to figure out, I'm actually now trying to figure out the difference between this children's theater and the theater for young adults that MLRT does at the same time. So this, but this is our kids, this is local kids doing the production.

5:43:56 This is our kids. This is after school for students second through eighth grade. And it's been traditionally, for the last two years, it's been done in the fall, October, November, with an early December show. Did you calculate using 50? Yeah. Okay. So, yeah, so they've had 17 the last, or in 12, and in 13, 14, they had 29. They're looking to expand it to 50. And it is in the fall.

5:44:25 Yeah. There is no, this is not a summer activity. And for me, the compelling thing was that we didn't have any drama programs offered. This kind of filled that gap. But if David were sitting here, I could hear him saying, all right, well, how are we in this strategy discussion? Right.

5:44:50 Linking Show Boat to SCT to MRT and all those programs that aren't operating independently of each other but rather get merged and shared resources and even collaborated curriculum.

5:45:10 That you're doing one thing here and then you move to the next thing and then you move to the next thing and then it's collaborated together. That's long term. So are we just saying this one might be complex? No, I don't think it is because I think it's programming that has a request for funding. I think there's the opportunity to grow it strategically.

5:45:33 I will say with the showbook here, if we recall when we had our Q&As that Allison stood up here and kind of gave a pretty robust rebuttal to that possibility that it was kind of wrong for her organization and she gave a number of different reasons why. I guess that's where the collaboration needs to come in. I'm having them struggling with what we're trying to supply with the town's recreation programs and then what we're funding here for the town's struggling for their funding and making that program work.

5:46:02 But the town is doing it as a summer program opportunity. They have historically done it as a summer opportunity. And this ends up being school kids program, not second homeowners that participate in the showboat side of it. I think that showboat is mostly, and there's a good majority of it that's all for kids. Yeah. I think this is the programming side of things.

5:46:30 You know, I will suggest that my daughter was not in this, so I can kind of speak a little more impartially. But from all the parents that had children in this, it was a wonderfully successful program and something that I think we should look to at supporting at some level in our town. And I think we're all talking supporting it. It's just a question of what's the level.

5:46:57 At what level do we support it? And I mean, that has to become part of the strategic later, is that we have to get all sorts of stuff. And we're not there yet, so this is interim, so is there a funding level? That's where I'm truly struggling with this. Yeah. Well, and so I think traditionally, my children have been in it the last two years. I can't remember the exact cost per child, but it was about $175, maybe $200.

5:47:26 Incredibly reasonable for the amount of time. And I think, you know, she's looking to be able to provide it for free to kids. I don't know that it needs to be free for every kid. Personally, I can pay for my children, but I do think it would be really neat to have that opportunity for other people to be able to have either reduced tuition or no tuition.

5:47:53 The other thing that I see here, you know, again, the theater rental, 2014, there were a couple of dates that were at Edison, and it was wonderful. There were a couple of days that were at the school, and the venue was just not the same, but to be able to go to Edison is, you know, the future outlook. It would be wonderful. And that's what increases the cost. It's what increases the cost, but it would also just be so wonderful to be able to

5:48:25 Have an agreement where we're not paying for someone to then pay Edison, you know, or we're not, you know, so. Yeah. Oh, yeah. And, you know, she's a baby reference that Edison doesn't have that flexibility right now to waive fees because they have costs too. So I'm going to take us back to number 22, the Kids' Summer Art Camp, where we had.

5:48:54 An amount that was direct, and then there was a match set aside. Right. And that that was a potential way to address programming opportunities on this. And I agree with you there. I think that there's just one thing in this budget that doesn't make sense under as Measure U applicable, and that's the cast party. So if we take that out, we're looking at like $3,300.

5:49:22 But I think there's also needs to be an incentive to go out and leverage some funding. So Joe, if the task is 5625, the task party is 5325. Thank you. So again, taking a percentage of that. Rhetorically, would anybody have problems with doing 3,000 direct, 2,000 matching like we did on the other one?

5:49:54 Yeah, except for you to go down because it'll be given over their budget. Oh, excuse me. Yes. Thank you. Yes. So add it all up for me. It'll be interesting to see if she can get, if she hits these numbers because looking at her description of how she gets to 50, I'm not entirely sure if I'm understanding this correctly, but she says

5:50:19 50 is just a guesstimate as how many kids will want to do it. I imagine that in the three years I have tapped into most of the kids who can afford $200. And then she says I could probably get a few more, but I imagine that most people will want scholarships of some kind. I could probably reduce to $150 per person if I got enough, but I'd have to balance this out with the cost of assistance. So I don't know that I see a clear path to $50 here exactly. So it might be the higher cost.

5:50:48 If the funding is there, then that minimizes and reduces the cost and turns it into a fee that expands to participants who can participate. If we covered half of the budget, then that means that she could make some reduction or go out and raise money other places to make it free. So if you cover half of the cost of the entire budget, the 11.125,

5:51:18 So her whole budget is $11,425 minus the $300 cash card and you take it to $11,125 and then half of that. If you're saying you spend it in half and then... And that's basically what she's asking for, but you make it a little bit less than that so there's the incentive in there. So if you were to do $3,500 direct with...

5:51:51 $1,000. $1,000 matching? Did you just make a measure you appropriate and you just made a motion, right? What was it? $35? $35 direct? $1,000 matching.

5:52:11 and measure you appropriate. I don't know that I'm really the person to do this because I'm not sure that I truly do agree with that. I'm just trying to come up with a mathematical. What you're not agreeing with. With whether she was making a motion. Yeah, she wants to introduce them. I think that it needs to work together, but anyhow. Well, I think everything, every application that we received has the opportunity to work together with a lot of other programs.

5:52:35 Unfortunately, that emphasis hasn't been made in some previous awards or not as effectively. So where we have the opportunity to do the interim funding to then focus everybody on the strategy moving forward is where we're sitting tonight. We would love to be able to say everybody should be collaborating, but it just hasn't happened previously. So this is where we are. Okay, so we have an unsponsored motion yet.

5:53:04 Of 3,500 direct, 1,000 matching. I'm making that motion. Okay. I think I can work with that. I will second the motion. All right. So it's 3,500 direct, 1,000 match, appropriate measure, U-Funds. Is there any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. I'm saying no. Okay. Motion passes. 5-1. 5-1. With one recursal. Thank you.

5:53:31 Okay. I have to recuse this one. That's right. You have to do this one, too. So this is number 25, Shakespeare in the Woods, and this is also Sierra Classic Theater. Complexity issue? No, I don't think so. Discussion. This is more than last year.

5:54:11 And I had some difficulty figuring out exactly what was being requested in the budget. So, Teri, what are the numbers up there, please? Because there were certain things with, you know. So, 59.50 is an eight-day program. 59 or 56? 59. 59. Okay, because on the attachment it says 56.50. Yeah, because it's 59.50. Asking, asking 50. 59.50 is the request.

5:54:40 5950. Yeah, but on the Q&A it says 5650. Asking. Oh, on the revised? Yeah. Their funding request says 5950. Yeah, I know, but that was attached to the Q&A when she redid her budget. And I think there was a comment in here about taking some stuff out. They took out under red. So I think we're, yeah.

5:55:07 Yeah, she changed it to $5,650, I think, after taking out $300 in marketing. Right, okay. That's what it was. That's it, okay. Okay. So, that's $5,650. And then, eight days, approximately 2,400 people attended. Cost per attendee brings it to $2.50 subsidy per person. They received $4,500 last year. This is 40% of the budget.

5:55:38 A little less since it's a little less. They have, otherwise they receive donations, they don't have a ticket fee, it's a donate fee. It's not, this says no as being a fundraiser. It covers the cost. It's a non-profit. And funding to cover production equipment. Yep. Okay, and so it's for stage instead, tat, costumes, house, what is house?

5:56:20 Oh, back of house. Okay, got it. Yes. Director, et cetera. Now, even within the 3,500 on the director, they've got graphic design. I don't know. Professional fees. Yeah. Professional fees, including. Including photos. Director, producer, stage management, photos, graphic design. Right, so that's that 3,500 that you say is not appropriate.

5:56:54 Liquor license? What's that? Liquor license? Under which one? The insurance and fees. Just, I think. Did they start selling this last year? I think they take it as donations. I don't know if they would sell it, but I think they have it as a donation. I don't know, I've always brought my own picnic. Okay. Okay.

5:57:21 Yeah, they have your mind sale, so they do need a local license. And they're, so they're asking for, what was the percentage around 40? 40%, yes, I just wonder. Okay, so I think that there might be some, not measure you, acceptable things within here, but I'd also like to do the bit of the challenge to this one. They do have other income.

5:58:00 Sales donations, refreshments, so. And again, this is one that I don't think is showing the in-kind donation of the site. No, of the site. Yeah. Of Samus Woods. And no, it doesn't. And there's also additional equipment, chairs that are provided as well as income. Yeah. So there is additional. They have $1,600 for chairs, porta-potty rentals, and drinks. They're having to, they're.

5:58:32 Sean, it apparently is going to donate some, but they have to get more also to accommodate them. Yeah. That's something we can consider down the line, yeah. And again, this would be, if we had a MLR shared stage, this would be another event that could use it. Definitely. Yeah, because the stage is $4,000, $4,900.

5:59:08 This is an event. It's two weekends of Shakespeare. Two or three.

5:59:14 Two. Two. Four. I thought it went all of August. No. Wait a minute. It doesn't go all of August. It doesn't. It goes August 15th to, sorry, it goes on the next page. I think it's doing, I'm going back to. April. April is starting on the 6th and close on the 16th. Right. Yeah. Two weekends. Two Thursdays through Sundays. Two Thursdays through Sundays.

5:59:43 From a non-profit mix that has so little in the bank they only have to do a 990N. All right. Entertain any discussions about this? Three weekends. Two weekends. All right. So we'll float up there and see if we get traction. I'm looking at this as the same as the last one. Yeah. Sam, we split up as $3,500 as set fee and $1,325 as the matching amount.

6:00:15 3500, 1325 matching. Yeah, 3500 matching. And measure U appropriate. And measure U appropriate. I'll second that. Moved and seconded to award 3500 direct, 1325 match, measure U appropriate expenses. Any additional discussion? All those in? Aye. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. Aye. 5-0. 5-0 to abstention, or to re-cancel.

6:00:50 That'd be great. Thanks, Stuart. We're on to number 26. This is the Bandenberger Battle of Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Complexity? Nope. Discussion? I'm trying to get all the right papers.

6:01:29 It was stated in our Q&A that $3,500 was going to be income to Mammoth Lakes Foundation off of their budget. Yes. So is that an event that's a fundraiser? Yes. This is the one that I had a difficult time with $5,000 to net income, $3,500 to the foundation. I think this is the first one as well where it's...

6:02:04 Admitting it's a fundraiser and it's also not got, I just, I question the primariness of the public benefit. Yeah. And I think it adds, there's another component of it which I think is exciting but may not fall under our mandate which is that I think it's a potentially very strong event in terms of marketing for the town and so again I would

6:02:34 I would love to engage our marketing organization with the potential for is there a way that they could participate in this thing because it has all these, I think, interesting ancillary marketing benefits. I have the same reaction on the marketing side, too. Well, because the whole idea is that somebody is getting to be qualified for the World Food Championship, and therein lies the broader...

6:03:04 Somebody from Mammoth is in that, and there's a leverage opportunity for MLT or somebody to utilize that positioning. Yeah. Didn't I see an attendee? No, when I asked that question, Tom, and it was, there was no way to estimate because it's a free event at the village. Oh, I'm sorry, it was for the food and wine that I saw. Yeah, that's later. This event was part of food and wine. Previously. But not without the...

6:03:37 Competition portion. Yeah, it had competition. It had a competition portion. It didn't have the band competition. Thank you. It didn't have the entertainment. It had food. And they did sell tickets, and now it's a free event, so that eliminates that. And it's also the same week as the bike championship that the mountain's doing, right? And it's actually Jazz Jubilee if Jazz Jubilee happens.

6:04:08 Which was also kind of interesting because she was talking about using a village at Mammoth and this is a village at Mammoth. Yeah. That's right. Yeah. Discussion. You know, I guess I would have no problem going with the same other fundraisers in the net that we did. Well. We're looking at $2015 and it comes back, you know, the net incomes.

6:04:39 I do think at some point we're going to have to engage, and maybe we're not ready, to what public benefit means. And I think there are beginning to be, at least in my mind, some delineations about that. I'm still concerned that in that case, I'm sorry, I have to pull up my other document that had the

6:05:11 The budget on it. Because my understanding is that, okay, we can subsidize a fundraiser if it has public benefit, and we've devised a mechanism by which we would get away from the public pass-through and the gift of public funds. But if in discussion, if we don't see a public benefit, and maybe others see one where I don't,

6:05:41 And if there's not that public benefit, then we wouldn't, even with that mechanism, get involved in subsidizing it. Yeah, and I agree with you. Spend $5,000 to have a net income of $3,500, there's something upside down about that. So just to quote the town attorney on this, there is a way that we can actually get in the game of funding.

6:06:12 Nonprofits for the eventual benefit of their mission. But I think that's a very strategic decision. I mean, I could see in the future in one of the next applications that talks about an event that would become a seed event for funding the Arts and Cultural Center or something like that. There's some circumstances where I could see that, but here's the language.

6:06:39 The arts and culture statement in Measure U would support these types of events to enrich community life and add to the economic vibrancy if the events meet the language of the Measure U ordinance. And here's the key part. But if MLR is considering funding an event that is mainly intended as a fundraiser for a private organization, the specific details would need to be provided and reviewed to see if there is a clear understanding of how the event itself is going to serve the town's purpose.

6:07:07 We'd have to understand the nature of the private organization and how a donation, so it would be understood as a donation, how a donation to that organization is going to serve the town's purposes. So it's a little bit more complicated to get into that business of just kind of directly funding fundraisers. Which is why I think the next one is that future...

6:07:31 Big fundraiser for the big event that's very clearly identified falls into that. This one may not be falling into that. Although you can argue that MLF, everything goes to that. And their mission is broad enough that, I mean, support higher education and cultural enrichment.

6:07:53 So broad. No, again, we have to agree to the programming components of it, not just the mission. Right. The detail, as they say, the details of the fundraising purpose. My inclination is, in an interim way, is to not get in the business of funding the eventual outcome of the pass-through. I just don't think we have enough strategy kind of put together.

6:08:21 I would advise that we stick with the kind of deliberation on the public benefit as such from the event. Right. Because I think you're right, Tom. I think if we were further along, and hopefully we will be soon, there would be a possibility to say, okay, this looks like a viable fundraiser, but we need to be assured that the beneficiary of that fundraiser aligns exactly with the...

6:08:47 with the goals of the town and of MLR. And so if you said, oh, let's do Battle of the Bands and Burgers to benefit, you know, to benefit, to fund, to raise money specifically for an art center that MLR is also specifically raising money for.

6:09:06 Then we can kind of let go a little bit of the public benefit and we can let go of the pass-through part and we can work together on it. Because it aligns with a specific strategic priority. Exactly. It's clearly defined. But at this point it doesn't because we don't know where those proceeds would go and I think it's questionable public benefit on the front end. Yeah, and I'm still struggling with the public benefit.

6:09:34 Overall on this one of whether it should be funded at all. Brad, you had a question? No, I'm just calling it a public benefit. I think it's actually, if we look at the marketing standpoint, there's a great little marketing niche, there's a great little marketing portion for relatively small costs for some of these larger events, certain things. I think there's a public benefit given what we've had in discussion today. But we can say we're not funding marketing. But that's not our, yeah, it has a public benefit from a marketing standpoint. Yeah, from an overall...

6:10:02 Town standpoint, because I see this as really no different than what we've talked about before, saying, okay, we've talked about a certain percentage and a clause for any profits, and I think to make over that is theirs, is kind of the way I'm looking at this one. Well, except if they've made the statement, though, that they're going to give that money to the, it's a fundraiser, as they're saying, the $3,500 goes to MLM. Yeah, we did the same thing. We did the same thing. We did the same thing. We did the same thing. We did the same thing. We did the other thing that came forward earlier. Right. They said we would, on those, these ones.

6:10:30 Anything that would be revenue up to the amount of whatever we put them back to us directly. Then they could take whatever they make out of that. Seed money? So would you do that at the $5,000 or would you just say the difference between the $5,000 and the $3,500 or something?

6:10:50 No, we were taking a percentage before. Okay, all right. And so that's basically, we're making an admission that we're not prepared to make a judgment about public benefit at this point. Because to look at the relative public benefit of a Labor Day Arts Festival versus a battle of the bands of burgers, we're saying we can't determine that.

6:11:14 Just to say that. I mean, we have to recognize that we're saying that. We're saying that our stopgap is to approach it this way while we work out the strategy and those definitions. Okay. So we are, however, essentially saying that we don't want to see Measure RU funds passing through. I've got too many things open in here. Okay. Okay. Okay. No, no, that's a couple. I'm doing 20,150. So 2015.

6:11:44 2015. With return? With return, up to an awarded and appropriate measure UF expenditures. Is that your motion? Yes. 2015? Was that Teri's motion? Teri made the motion, Brent seconded to 2015. Yeah. Where is that? We're in the year 2015. Oh.

6:12:20 Is there any further discussion? So the motion is to recommend $2015 for the Vandenbergue with 2015 coming back to Measure U out of any net income. Yes. Any further discussion? All those in favor to take by aye? Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 7-0.

6:12:49 Okay, we're on to number 27. This is Mammoth Food and Wine Festival, also Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Complexity? Nope. Nope. Also a fundraiser. Yes. We've just established we don't have to discuss public benefit. Right? Well...

6:13:12 No, but what does the cost per attendee come out to on this one? Oh, that's true. The other one is free. That's a difference. This one I have. This is a higher one. What does that say, Teri? $31. The cost per attendee is $31.40. This was for $70. You mean the value of attendees? Value, yeah. Subsidizing each attendee if we had 700 attendees. Yes. And what was there last year? Attendance? They had 700 and...

6:13:40 2014, if you added all of their different activities together. Tickets sold. Okay, but was there any way to... So it's a smaller event because there's no... Burger battle. No burger battle and not as many of the classes, and yet they still expect to get the same number. And that 700 is... But that's not 700 individual people, I don't believe. 700 tickets sold.

6:14:09 May I ask Dion? Dion? Yeah. Is it the 700 tickets sold could be 400 people because some of the people bought several tickets? You could get somebody who goes to the Wine Walk and then also goes to the Grand Tasting.

6:14:29 So it does not mean it's... May not be 700 individuals. Thank you. We're only forecasting 600 individuals this year, I think. So the calculation is still $30 and something subsidy of each ticket sold. But the actual cost to the participant is at least $99. Yeah, based on what they're... What are the different costs this year, Dionne? The wine walk is $45.

6:14:58 A person, the grand tasting is going to be $99. Thank you. And the net income is $72,000. Wishful thinking. Yes, that's a proposed budget. I'm going to do my best to turn this into a profitable event. Leveraged funds. Notice the leveraged funds. So this is the clearest example of a...

6:15:34 I think there's no question that this is fundraiser first. Right. And the event's kind of incidental. I look down all the light items, the raffles, the table sponsors, silent auctions, live auctions, the dinners at private homes. I think that's clearly the emphasis. Even the goal is stated as a fundraiser. Our goal is for it to become a stable funding source in support of Mammoth. The excellent example they use of Sun Valley.

6:16:03 Is of their food and wine event, the purpose of it, it brings in 60% of that center's operating budget every year. So I think there's no question that it's a fundraiser first and an event second. The question is, for interim purposes, do we treat it the same as the others? Or is there an appetite to...

6:16:29 to talk public benefit more specifically. So, well, so we're saying is they're requesting $22,000 to end up with $72,000. So if they didn't get funded at all, they still make $50,000. Okay. We've never made money on the event, just FYI. It would still be a $50,000 net projection if these all pan.

6:16:59 Yeah, didn't include a lot of line items that a lot of the other events have been brought up, not including 700 hours of in-kind labor that goes into this event, some other things that weren't included. Well, agreed, but what was your total donations for last year? Wasn't it, you know, your assets not counting the land are pretty significant. You had, you've been getting...

6:17:23 A lot of money from somewhere. So if you're saying this is a fundraiser and you're purporting that it's in the budget you gave us, that it's going to make $72,000. And again, I would want to encourage that this be a profitable fundraiser for the organization. But the question before us is if we're going to finance any portion of that, does it match up with our mission and does it also have

6:17:51 Public Benefit that's not merely incidental or doesn't have public benefit at all. And just to say again, I mean, I think when we, I mean, I would like to, I would love it if they can show that this is a, this is a viable fundraiser and then to be able to, when we're on board with our strategy and when, when we've gotten down to the, to the Mammoth Lakes Performing Arts Center,

6:18:25 and we have a budget and we're on track, then a fundraiser like this specifically for that purpose would seem to me something we would want to participate in. But since we don't really know where that benefit is going, I don't see our participation as being relevant. The benefit is going to

6:18:50 Subsidize a community arts center that is currently being asked to support a lot of the events in the community. So we are specifically funding a community building, public benefit building. I don't know if you want to, I mean, I don't think we want to get into deliberation with Dion. But I do have a question, Dion, wait, I had a question, sorry. You indicated that last year you didn't make any money on the event? Correct. I didn't hear you say that? Correct. When we factor in our labor costs.

6:19:19 Into this, not factoring in the volunteer costs. When we factor in our labor costs, it's just like most of these events that you guys are delivering on today. We do not make a profit. That's why I've revamped this and put forth a budget to show that it makes money. So we're going to switch direction and revamp it. Whether I can meet that strategic change and that value on that budget.

6:19:49 is yet to be determined. Okay. I mean, in terms of net dollars. So you're saying you have costs you didn't include in your budget? Say again? You're saying you have costs you didn't include in the budget for the project? Correct. But they're income costs, right? They're not. Our labor, I didn't include our staff labor. Well, we have an admin of 8,000 and contract services and vendors.

6:20:13 Those are portions of components. Yeah, again, the details, we wouldn't supply the details that break up those lines, like nobody else supply the details that make up their lines, so there's details on them, yeah.

6:20:28 So let's try and limit it to where we just ask a question and get an answer. But I would like to, I mean, since Dion brings it up, this idea that this is funding a community art center I think is disingenuous because even though we all benefit from that art center and I want it to survive and thrive, we're also being asked to pay for the programming of that art center separately.

6:20:55 So I think we need to address each of those things separately and consider where is the community benefit. And just to add to that, as much as I say we all benefit from that arts center, it's not community governed and it's not necessarily open or viable to other arts organizations, which to me is a measure of a community arts center, which is something we're striving for but we don't necessarily have. So we have to look at this as

6:21:25 What are we doing in the interim? We haven't gotten there yet, so it is about interim. So I'm going to go back to something that you said. We did not define public benefit early on. And so if we look at this as the same way that we've looked at the other fundraisers, we would go back to the 10% of the budget of the $81,000.

6:21:45 And look at that as the recommendation. Because, you know, again, money would come back. And as Dion has indicated, they're going to hustle, they're going to work hard to, you know, make that money. And we want them to make that money in order to keep that facility going.

6:22:08 But, you know, to be consistent with the previous discussions that we've had, we did not define that public benefit, so that is an option that we have on the table, look at that $81,000. So that would be $8,100? $8,100. So does somebody want to make that motion? I'm trying to make sure I'm getting, okay.

6:22:34 Yeah, I'll move. We funded $8,100, Measure U-appropriate expenditures with that money being returned up to the amount of the award if there are net proceeds. Okay. I'll second that. Seconded by David. Okay. Any further discussion? Any further discussion? All right. All those in favor. Wait a minute. Wait a minute. Okay. All right. Measure U-appropriate funding. So, the motion on the table is $8,100.

6:23:07 Measure U appropriate expenditures with a net income funding back to measure U up to that $8,100 award. All those in favor and indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. Dion, thanks for your answers. All right. On to number 28. And I'm going to recuse myself on this one. So, Brent, would you do me a favor and scribble down what the actual motion is on the back of this one for me?

6:23:37 Since I'm trying to do minutes here. So this is Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. Jo is recusing herself because she sits on the advisory committee for the programming of the Repertory Theater. So she'll recuse herself. And this is for $75,000, of which most of this is for a film festival.

6:24:03 that is being proposed for this coming year. So I'm going to ask about the complexity of the project. No, I don't think it meets the complexity criteria. All right. Okay. So $75,000. As we said, the bulk of this is for the Mammoth Film Festival that is looking to be brought to town.

6:24:38 At our question and answer period, we did talk about... I'm sorry, Dan, where are you getting that $70,000 is for the film festival? During our question and answer, we were looking at $11,000 for the specific for the film festival, $42,50 for the permanent installation relative to the film festival, temporary installation for the film festival,

6:25:07 And in the narrative, the reference is welcome this to the film festival. Okay. Do you want to clarify? You want to see it? Yeah. That comes out to $15,000. Yeah. And how is that the majority of $75? I don't understand that. Oh, on your film festival.

6:25:27 Yeah. Oh, those pieces, okay. Because you're saying that the bulk of it, the bulk of it is not for just the film festival, it's for doing a year-round program. I was wondering what your narrative indicated, that you were looking for the significant funding for your film festival.

6:25:47 No, you guys were asking me questions about the film festival, but I never said that the bulk of the funding goes towards the film festival. And then it has all the different programs. It does have your schedule attached. Right. So there's like 15 programs on there. Right. Of which most of them were in 2014, and we've got one...

6:26:09 Two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight that are in 2015. I guess that was one of my concerns for this one is that we're funding in arrears. So it's, you know, I don't know. Maybe that's what these usually do, but that seems always worth it. Okay, guys, you've got to let us deliberate or we're going to go. I'm just standing.

6:26:32 Yep, so we'll ask questions. Yeah, please do. But yeah, half of it has been 2014, half of it's 2015. So I guess that's where I would love to see PL on some things like this. It was never asked. We didn't ask. We didn't ask. Just a comment. In previous years, I think funding was for similar

6:27:02 Say 85,000, 67,000 in 2014, and it has always been previous, sort of for the season, if you will. Yes. Yeah, I think we can, from my mind, we can be pretty lenient about that because these funding cycles have been shifting and moving targets. Right. When was the last MEGIE funding cycle?

6:27:31 So it happened in February of last year. But the process started in November of 2013. So the request is for $75,000. Programming is what is being asked of. And on the budget that was provided, it outlined what all that programming entailed.

6:28:10 We did ask the question about can ticket sales grow beyond the projected $73,000? Is there an opportunity for more income from ticket sales? And she did respond that that's based on that 70% to 75% capacity, which is a pretty good occupancy over the course of time. It'd be great if that's 100%. We're striving for 100%, right? Yes.

6:28:40 So it's there. I'm assuming it's increasing. What is your increased attendance from year over year? We went up about 5%, so we went from 70% to 75%. This year I don't know what the final increase will be because we don't have to wait until the end of the year. Some things do better than others. Obviously this weekend was a horrible weekend and our numbers went down considerably.

6:29:09 Yeah. We've got more events this year. Yes, but I'm going on an average, so it's, you know. So, Teri, in the Q&A, it says increasing our average attendance numbers from 65 to 70 percent and then to 75 percent over the last three years. So, you know, I was just looking at what is highlighted here. We have artists at 42,000 and we have contract services 11,000.

6:29:37 Choreography, 300, costumes, sound lighting, 80 equipment sets, and we have room and meals for talent, and I think that we have to eliminate that piece according to the fundamentals earlier. Well, yeah, unless we're only if we were going to fund the whole thing. Yeah. Which we're not. Music and orchestra, props, royalties, and then there's another $8,000 per travel for talent.

6:30:08 The room of meals is for imported people. It's usually for their housing. Can I add a point of clarification on that? We highlighted all of the components of programming, but we didn't ask for funding for all the programs. We're trying to illustrate the difference between all of programming and what we asked for funding for. So we're not asking for funding for all those lines. You indicate 65%. That's right. Right.

6:30:34 Of your overall program is what your 75,000 is requested. I think it is all that. No, it's 65% of that. I did the math. It's not 100%. All right. What are your questions, thoughts on this? This is programming. Yeah, in a general sense, I think it's obviously something that's very important that we subsidize and support.

6:31:05 I think this programming is important in what I'll consider an interim period not just for us but for the town of Mammoth Lakes as we move forward toward the idea of a community arts center. I think the work that Mammoth Lakes Foundation has done to prove the viability of programming is important work. I hope that, as I've said before, the next step is to begin to work together with other producers. I would like to have...

6:31:34 The programming in these venues be not just one specific program but also include different musical events that are produced by other entities. But I don't know that we're at a stage now where we can dictate that or make any kind of real strategic recommendations. I do think that they've got...

6:31:58 Some considerable leveraging going on in terms of the money that they're putting into it, the facilities they're putting into it, and that needs to be acknowledged. I think this is one of the soundest applications and uses of asks for funding that we have in front of us. I think there's no question that it falls into the mandate of Measure U. I'm inclined.

6:32:29 I'm inclined to consider funding the entire amount. Is that a motion? It is a motion. It is a motion. I'll second the motion. To fund $75,000. Moved and seconded, is there any additional discussion? Just to make sure I understand, so all the highlighted ones in the expense sheets represents the programming and this represents 65% of the cost then?

6:33:02 Is what we're saying? We're saying that the $75,000 that they're asking for here is 65% of all the highlighted costs of photogramming. So just a little over 50. We have a motion on the tables entering further discussion. All right. All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Aye. Sorry, I just paused. You had an aye. Yep. No. All right. I'm going to go. I'm going to go. I'm going to go.

6:33:35 Aye. Terry? I'm going to say no. I don't think we should be defining the 65 percent. Grant? No. David? I'm going to stick with the aye. Tom? Aye. And I'm aye. It's okay. I'm recording for Jill here. Can you just please restate the motion? The motion is to fund $75,000 at the requested level.

6:34:07 I do wish that we could put in some kind of language that says it's not going to go on like this forever. That's going to be in the Articultural Center. Out of 4-2, if motion passes. Thank you. Thanks, Shira, for answering questions. Shira, obviously we need to get Joe back out. I got it. Thank you. Two more.

6:34:44 Right, so it takes us down to six. Okay. Thank you. We are on to number 29. This is the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. Mammoth Lakes Foundation is the applicant. And let's talk about the complexity question.

6:35:16 Yes. Yes. And the request is in for the $100,000 to be held in that reserve, as we've discussed, so that as questions are answered and plans come forward, negotiations are occurring, the college gives their approval, the state allows the project to be...

6:35:42 Designed and built and they approve what's being designed and built. There's a lot of factors that go into this. There's also our stated contract deliverable of coming up with a financing plan, feasibility, etc. in May? June. So that means that it doesn't sit for long. And that's where the foundation committee, MAC committee that's been working on this.

6:36:10 Keeps that discussion going with a lot of, again, there's contingencies because of the college and because of the state requirements and where they have their sales. And we still have to work on that operating. Right. And business. And what those. And governance. And governance and all that. So that's all, yeah. There's a whole list that goes with it. This shows the, this shows the, you know, again,

6:36:36 Commitment, that as all those are answered, there's funding set aside to keep the project going. I move to approve the $100,000 to be moved to into a reserve, considering it's a complex. I second that. Drea is seconded. Move and seconded to recommend the $100,000 to be put into reserve for the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center as the project continues to move forward.

6:37:09 Is there any discussion? I have just a larger question. We went through all this. I forgot to ask you to do this part. How much money do we have? Enough that what I said, and you may not have heard it too well, because I was way over here when you're on the phone, is there is enough money there that if all of them...

6:37:27 Were viable and funded at the full level, there would have been enough to cover it. But since our philosophy, yes, yes, no. We don't actually have a final number, but it's bigger than that. The folks who are working on the reconciliation have advised that as they are...

6:37:45 Going through reconciliation, they are identifying the funds are. Okay, I'm just trying to make sure. Good question. So we still have a motion on the table. Is there any further discussion? No. So all those in favor of the $100,000 for reserve, indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. We're on to number 30. And this is the Shane's inspiration part.

6:38:13 You did receive an updated budget that we put at your table. Because David wanted to be home 40 minutes ago.

6:38:38 Can I suggest that we consider this one complex because there are a whole bunch of decisions to be made. It talks about the site. There is no site yet. I could go on and on, but that we reserve the $500,000 at this point and call it a complex project. We're reserving $500,000 or just the $25,000? Oh, excuse me. Actually, the revised budget is $15,000. Sorry, $15,000. Excuse me. All I'm in that to say for the $15,000.

6:39:08 Yeah. So Joe, is that a motion? Yeah. Okay, so wait a minute. So what's your motion? The motion was considered a complex project, put the $15,000 that's the top grade items into a reserve for discussion. Okay, so we're not looking at putting the whole $500,000 into it? No. Not at this time because...

6:39:31 This is, from my perspective, this is so preliminary, and it doesn't show the partnerships, the other funding sources, etc., that to reserve the first part, even though we recognize that we want to look at it holistically and not phases. And if this is set aside as a reserve, then as the project continues, it does come back. And we can always... Actually, we said it has to wait until fall.

6:40:00 Oh, yeah. No, so, yeah, so I think I was right. So it should be the full $500,000 that is held for reserve with the $15,000 being ready to move forward to identify projects. But, yeah, we're not releasing anything, but in that process, you're right, we could release it in pieces if we need to, but if we didn't put aside the full amount, it would have to wait for...

6:40:23 June, or fall, but it might end up waiting for fall anyway. I would like to make a move that we release the $15,000 now so that they can go forward with this planning. Well, I'm going to disagree with that because they don't know where they're planning. Well, but that's what it's for. No, when you start getting into TOPO and environmental, that's, that's, you mean, you don't do environmental until you have a site. And so there's, there are a few additional steps that have to be taken in this.

6:40:53 But setting out that 15,000 allows those steps to, when those decisions get made, like a site location, then allows this to quickly move into doing that. Correct. So if we reserve the full amount, then we can release as needed, or we get the whole thing finished and work from there. Or we can release the 15 and reserve the balance. Yeah.

6:41:22 So what would be the specific requirements to release the 15 at this point? Or do we not even know that? I don't think we know that. They would have to, if we put it in reserve, the way we wrote this is they would then come back to MLR and say, here's, you know, we've resolved whatever we're doing. Or we'd be working with them, yeah. And this is what we want to report, right.

6:41:42 I think that makes sense, and it comes with like these others where we're committing to delegate our time and some committee members to work with them to get us to where we want to, I mean, with the goal being to allocate or to recommend allocating that $15,000 as soon as possible. Correct, but that would come after Morris now. So through the plan, your parks, it was identified to be at Mammoth Creek. Is there a potential that it was somewhere else? Yes.

6:42:12 Yes. No. Yes. Plan your parks was only accepted as a study. It was not, yeah. There's opportunities. Yeah, there's opportunities for other places. So, Stu, is there a determination of site that's already been made? So, the $15,000, thank you for the question, $15,000 is to conduct a topographic analysis of Mammoth Creek Park West and then to gauge environmental impacts on that site and then funds to work with.

6:42:41 Shane's inspiration in that group to basically match their in-kind so staff will be able to engage with them with that process to lay a conceptual diagram, design, everything on that site. So that's what we're proposing. So you're saying that essentially there would be nothing else that you would be able to bring back to us? You're bringing us, we need the 15,000 to get started. No, I don't think that's necessarily true. Okay.

6:43:08 Because that site has not been fully vetted. It was not accepted. It was only accepted in concept by council, not as the specific site. But is this study required to fully vet that site? Is that... Yeah, yeah. So there's a first decision that needs to be made before... That's the complex part. So here's my question, though.

6:43:37 I'm just thinking that 15 at this stage, don't we want to also think about potentially Shady Rest and Community Center and have the funding to be able to take a look at those also because if Mammoth Creek is not the right spot and it turns out not to be approved or whatever, that you have the backup for the other sites that have gone through the study also and you can point directly to

6:44:05 This site, that site, or that site that are all can accommodate this. Yeah, so it's about just under 5,000 for a topographic analysis of a site. So, you know, if we're including more sites, then, you know, it's more money for that site. I think where Joe's coming from, you know, is fair. I mean, I think we're happy to just keep this project moving, so whatever we need to do to publicly vet a site.

6:44:31 and get it back to town council for their approval to move ahead with the site. Great. But the planning parks process was that process. It was a conceptually designed plan and that was that public process that we went through. So again, we're just trying to make sure we can kind of keep moving along.

6:44:51 But again, so if you wanted to evaluate additional sites, it's going to be more than the $15,000. Which was why when I started the motion, I said let's reserve the $500,000 and work through a very complex issue. And not release anything at this point. And not the $15,000. You're saying you're ready to spend $5,000 tomorrow. To go look at Mammoth Creek Park. Right. And that's, and Joe, are you saying that's not the case? I'm saying that's not, that's...

6:45:17 So what, what, I'm just curious, I mean, it sounds like there are some steps that need to, we need to go through, and I'm wondering if we, what those are. And I'm sorry, but I can't speak to them because they're closed session items. Oh. So that's all I can say? Well, the final site has, the final site came through Plannier, or a recommended site came through Plannier Parks. Okay.

6:45:40 That was conceptual in nature. The study itself didn't go through a formal, what I would consider a CEQA process, or for it to be adopted at that stage. So the opportunity is to come back around, pick this up, identify the spot that it should go into, and then be able to go do those topo studies. But so without revealing any details, what we would be waiting for is the council to recommend that site as well, or to approve study of that site.

6:46:09 Prove a site for Shane's inspiration. Yeah, for an inclusive park. Okay. So it's on your desk. Plus a bunch of other questions that have to be worked out. Yeah, I guess, well, I'm sure that's why it's in that complex, but, you know, if we're just looking at sites, I can't see that Community Center fits that bill at all. So we would be looking at potentially, you know, Shady Rest or... Well, but also to realize that don't just presume, it goes on.

6:46:40 What's currently town-owned property? Well, okay. I realize that. See, that was the sideboards of Plannier Park that don't allow necessarily other strategic moves. It is only a town-owned managed property. Okay. Without being more specific. And has the folks from Shane's Inspiration looked at the different parks and potential areas?

6:47:05 Potentially other buildings or private areas that we might be able to work with? No, I mean, they can't really work until we get the green light from town, but they sort of gave recommendations as to what we're looking for in the park, the size and everything else. The footprint that it would fit in. Yeah, the footprint, ADA bathrooms and all those type of things. But the fact that it's that Mammoth Creek Park...

6:47:32 Went through the public process, and that was where, you know, all the townspeople in all those meetings, and everyone came to the conclusion that that was the best spot for it, but it's right in the center of town. It's close to where a lot of people live. It's on, it's already connected to trails that are connected to the schools. Husky Club takes field trips there, and that's where a lot of the, a lot of those community events during the summer are already taking place. So, that was sort of why.

6:48:00 It went through that process and ended up as that being the best spot for it. So here's one suggestion. We could recommend to council that funds be released for this and then we would officially leave it on their desk because they're obviously not going to release the funds until they've sorted out whatever they need to sort out. And that way we're not on the hook for having to go back and forth with council. But if you do that,

6:48:31 Because one of the things we haven't really discussed is how all of this is presented to Council. And whether or not you want to continue to do things in a phased approach or if our strategy is to turn things around, and I don't think it slows it down that much to get some of those other questions answered first. Okay. Because in the past, allocations were either voted up or down in total, even though

6:48:59 There was an ability to change them, and I don't know that it's an appropriate time to, this one's just not quite ready. I'm not saying it's far off, but I don't think it's quite ready at this point. Again, because of those sideboards. If I was going to make a motion, I'll make a motion to accept, to place the $500,000 into a reserve due to this being a complex project, and that we

6:49:29 verify or we clarify or we place the final resting stop for the inclusive park and upon that clarification from council that then the $15,000 get released to start the TOCO survey and environmental. Does that make sense? Yes, but that's not really what we said in our

6:49:56 Project, our thing up front. I was going to say, do you have to say the second part? No. If we set aside the reserve, that allows the opportunity to come back and tap into it all throughout the process. So I would make a commission to set the, to place the $500,000 into a reserve for the inclusive part, considering it a complex project. And I would just suggest to the stakeholders that

6:50:21 Being held in reserve, I mean, a decision is only a board meeting away. And we have one every two weeks. So, you know, I don't know that holding the 15 in reserve is going to be that big of a delay. Well, and what it is is the commitment. That's right. The commitment is there. But we were saying that, you know, if you had something complex, we were going to look at it holistically.

6:50:45 But as soon as we're ready, you know. Then you tap into it. So there's a motion on the table to reserve the $500,000 for the Shane's Inspiration. Did we get a second on it? No, there has not been a second. Okay. So I'm looking for a second. I'll second that. Seconded by David. Is there any further discussion? So it goes back to my third question. So you say we have enough money. Yeah. Have we tied ourselves up? No.

6:51:13 No, and we were trying to do this strategically so that there would be money left for the fall cycle. So no, we haven't tapped ourselves out. And I think also what's not referenced in here is the need and desire for some additional partnership development, for some additional funding that goes with this. So while the $500,000 is asked, I think as this gets developed and fine-tuned,

6:51:43 That changes also. Correct. And this is so preliminary. I mean, like on grading, you've got anywhere from zero to $149,000 depending on where it ends up. Or who donates. Or who donates. Who we rook into it. And then you have your long-term costs. Yeah, and long-term costs are a question too. So we have a motion on the table to set aside $500,000 for the reserve of the change inspiration accessible.

6:52:13 Park. Is there any further discussion? I guess I would just ask what are the next steps then for... So the first step would be to hear from Council their determination. Okay. And then we would immediately go back to... Well, and it's the same thing, you know, you can't go to, you know, Council will not send anything to bid until all the funding's been identified. All the things we talked about hours ago. Yes.

6:52:40 So again, this would go into the next meeting on who will be the person that will follow up on this. Is there any further discussion? All right. All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? All right. And that motion passes 7-0. Okay. I will remind us that we still had the discussion about an overarching that we finished up. And we also... And then we also need to...

6:53:08 I don't think we need to do it here, but when we're working this up, we have to count the number of applications that are going forward to figure out the 380 times how many. So is that the allocations committee that needs to take this back and go through that? I don't know. Well, we only have, you know, the final piece has to be together Thursday evening.

6:53:35 And putting my council hat on for a second, I was going to suggest that when we take this forward, we should group it by the different kinds of things so we can say, here's the justification for why this group was given and then what their funding was recommended. And then here's the next kind, you know, so not doing it in number, doing it in history order. We are also going to have to do

6:54:01 Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater separately so I can recuse myself on that and not have to recuse myself on the entire vote. Right. Yeah. So... Can you vote from... If you voted here, can you vote as the town council? Yes. No. Yes, that's... Yes, that's what Andy... We went to Jack this last summer. Yeah. Okay. No, I will still have to recuse myself on that, but no, I can vote on the whole package. Okay. Minus that.

6:54:29 So, Jo, they will probably all go as one motion or as one? Well, as I'm saying, everything except that one. So we did that with MLTSCC's last ones because I'm on the Frenzy Inyo board, so we had to pull that out separately. So, Jo, you bring up a question that I don't think we've had answered. I know Measure R funding, I can't speak to Measure U, but Measure R had, you know, the whole thing had to pass.

6:54:58 Yes, but, and in fact, the last time around, things were changed, and because the legal opinion from Andy was that, no, that was just a guideline that council can cherry pick if they wish to. And that's how in the MLTSCC there was the money for the tunnel was taken out of reserve and, you know, for the snow. So do we anticipate then that...

6:55:28 Do we, in thinking about how the council's going to vote on this, is it better to have them vote on clusters of programming, clusters of events, clusters of fundraisers, to go that route, and then can cherry pick out those clusters instead of cherry picking out the whole thing, does it matter? No, I think we want to cluster it just for an understanding. Right.

6:55:56 No, I'm sorry, after seven hours of marine inspectors, we talked about overarching principle as our next item. Yeah, no, but we have those two things. We have how we, who's going to pull this together? Who's putting together the report? So I'm looking back at the allocations committee. Is that something that allocations committee needs to be working on? This looks to be out, yeah. We have to have it in Thursday. Done by Thursday.

6:56:19 Is that something you guys want to do, or who wants to? I don't think the Allocations Committee needs to do it. I don't necessarily. I think that if we, if two or three of the board members can pull that together with the time that's available. I don't know, Tom, you have this in your system. But we don't want to give that kind of detail to council. I'm sorry. No, you can just pull out the. What I'm saying is, yeah, is if we group them like,

6:56:47 Events were handled in this. Here's the justification for how events were funded, and here's what it looks like. Here's the justification for those that were fundraisers. Here's the justification for what we're putting in reserve and why. Joe, would you like to put that list together? I can help, but I think that it also takes Dana, maybe? I've written most of the other agenda bills that came out of MLR from formation on. So how about Tom, myself?

6:57:17 Joe, you'll take a look at it from a council perspective and make sure that it kind of lines up with council. We'll work on it and get it routed for everybody to take a look at. And what I'll do tomorrow morning is get the minutes and the motions to you so you can start pushing. We have those notes too. So we've got that taken care of. Tom and Dana will work on the report for the council. Do we anticipate also the...

6:57:41 What's it called? The agenda bill? The agenda action? I talked to Dan about that today. He will do a quick agenda action sheet that covers it, that talks about whatever's in it, and also releases whatever this total amount turns out to be from suspension. Okay. So the RU stuff has to be worked out, too. Okay. So Dan handed that. All right.

6:58:07 So then the second piece to that is we did talk about in the middle of our deliberation coming back and creating this overarching, if you will, guideline or framework for the event funding for profit? Event funding for profit. And so there's a support the rationale for how we took percentages of those events.

6:58:35 So we're going to go back and ask those that were for profit. It was the events and fundraisers. Well, the fundraisers, we put the give us the money back. On the events, we didn't. So it was a question of on the events, do we need to go back? And as we went through it, I think we later started doing that with events. No, we actually didn't. We said we were going to do one. We said we were going to do one. Oh, okay. Yes, we just did it with the fundraisers. So discussion about overarching.

6:59:05 For an event that has a, in their budget, if we have approved a funding level, that they repay that back to Measure U before they have any additional net income. My inclination is to do it equally across the board as an interim measure. Okay. For every funding request? For it.

6:59:33 Every funding request on the list. If there's a profit shown, if money goes up to the amount of the award comes back to MLR. I think it's just fair and consistent, and then we'll reevaluate strategically moving forward. That's my initial thought. So you're recommending all funding comes back to measure you?

7:00:04 To that effect. Okay. Is that for programming as well? I mean, should we go through and just double? He's talking for everything. Everything. Everything. Everything. So if the free kids art camp that we funded doesn't have a net income,

7:00:32 There's no net to it, they throw out, then nothing comes back. Because if they pencil out $10, that $10 is coming back to measure you. For the programming, for the events. It's a little sloppy, it's a little messier, right? If you're talking in $10 increments. I know, I'm sorry, that was a bad example. No, but I think the effort of being fair across the board for, you know, an interim measure like that, yeah.

7:00:59 Sorry, I'm just waiting. I'm just holding the delivery still. There's a second on the motion. Did you make that in front of the motion? I'll move. Okay, is there a second? Is there a second? Because if there isn't... I think we need to talk more about it. Yeah, I think we're not quite so it dies without a second. So let's keep the discussion. Brent, you had a question. Well, because I think there is certain levels. You know, town's asking for certain funding on certain things. So if the town has a profit in here, does it mean we go back to town and ask them to give us more money? It's already the case with all the town ones.

7:01:30 That anything that they don't spend comes back to them. Yeah. But they make a profit. Does that mean the town make a profit? Would they give us money back? So event or programming, is that what you mean? Right, okay. Yeah, so let's refine then. And it's really for Measure U, not Measure R programming either, right? Yeah, I think it is. Because things like the summer ice rink programming, we would obviously want them to.

7:02:00 Well, but we put that to Measure U, didn't we? Did we? Yes, we did. The summer event program was Measure U on anything other than town owned or managed properties. I mean, I think the distinction with the town is fairly clear because that's going back into town coffers to be spent. I mean, that's... Well, and it doesn't actually go in there. It's still an invoice.

7:02:35 So I guess, I mean, you know, another one that I see potentially being very complicated is the Mammoth Lakes repertory where you've got a whole year's worth of, you know, I mean, that's a big budget and a percentage of it we're financing and obviously their goal has to be

7:03:05 I mean, they're building in a certain profit to keep their facilities running, to pay their administration, to... Right, then you're making us a special exemption, which is fine. We can debate that, but I think we'd have to develop some logic for the exception. I still think it's tough in many ways, just from... Everyone's going to change their budget around a little bit, but I agree that we should be uniform across the board.

7:03:36 This is interim, we should be, until we have a larger discussion, we should hold everybody, but I think there's ones that, the town or some of the other ones here that might not fall, because my suggestion is going to be, it's going to be the Mammoth Rocks, the Mammoth Kids Jazz, the Village Fest, Eastern Sierra Symphony, the Chamber Music Unbound, the Mammoth Reggae Fest, the Margarita Fest, the Kids Adventure Games,

7:04:07 the Kids Fishing Festival, the Labor Day Festival, the Free Kids Summer Art Camp, Free After School Art Club, the Mammoth Children's Theater, Shakespeare in the Woods, oh, we fall into that.

7:04:26 Do you guys want me to put a circle around which ones you want to include? I'm just suggesting. So which ones did you exclude? I excluded the all-towns, all-towns, and then I excluded the ones we've already discussed with that were fundraising for. So they're already included. Because they're already included. The one I didn't put down, the very last one was the Shane's Inspiration, because of the expense, there's not, I don't know where we're getting revenue from that one, so I didn't include it. So maybe we exclude capital projects? No, I think maybe.

7:04:55 doing it this way by doing the specifics, but I would also argue that Chamber Music Unbound was a programming one, not an event. But he's saying, we're saying that. Oh, okay. It doesn't matter. I'm suggesting that. Okay. All right. That included Eastern Sierra Symphony, which was programming. Okay. The kids, all the art camps, those are programming.

7:05:15 But the one concern about that is that on the one hand we're saying make your event sustainable, on the other hand we're saying we're going to take the money back at the end, which means it's not going to be sustainable that way. Well, it's break-even, essentially. I mean, that's kind of what we're saying. And as you pointed out earlier, basically Measure U and Measure R becomes

7:05:43 A free loan. Right. So, but are we really helping them along? Yeah. Oh, okay. Hold on a second. I'm trying to... These are the same things that we've told these other... So, right. So, are the non-profits then materially different?

7:06:09 Well, I think there's a legal distinction, but is there, but yeah, are they materially different? Well, I'll go back to the discussion two years ago when this was looked at and it was as part of the Measure U award saying profit, non-profit, we're going to treat the same. So, that's what we were talking about at that point in time because it's hard to differentiate what you're going to do with someone's profit, non-profit. Did you hear that from Andy? Yeah, there's a, I don't think he distinguishes between.

7:06:36 He does make a distinction. A for-profit organization, it's very hard to distinguish what they may do with the monies that they make because they can do anything they'd like. Where a non-profit has to live within their... Here's what he says. Funding for non-profit versus non-profit is a distinction that does make a difference. A non-profit is inherently limited in how it can spend funds, but if those funds are coming from the town, we still need to make sure that the purposes of those expenditures line up with the town's public purposes.

7:07:05 A for-profit entity has no obligations to spend funds to benefit anyone other than itself. So spending town funds primarily to benefit a for-profit entity with no real public purpose is going to be difficult to justify. So this is where, you know, we've walked ourselves down a plank where we've invented this mechanism to get away from having to discuss in any serious fashion the public benefit.

7:07:34 I mean, we haven't made any radical decisions here based on public benefit. And really, we're being asked to do that. I think we have to, I mean, we're not obviously going to do it at 8 o'clock at night right now, but, you know, we've opted not to make any decisions about public benefit. Or definition. We made no definition of public benefit. Right. And frankly, I think that's the right decision. Yeah. Because that's a...

7:08:04 Big question with the special events and there's a lot of invested people in the town in that conversation. Okay, so the ones that we might want to consider a motion or an amended motion on were the ones after we started with the town and before we got to Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. So that's Mammoth Rocks, Mammoth Kids Camps, Village Fest, Eastern Sierra Symphony, Chamber Music Unbound.

7:08:33 Those are the ones that we need. I can read them. Mammoth Rocks. Sorry, sorry. Mammoth Rocks, Marguerite. No, no, we made. Yeah, you're right. No. Yeah. Walk ourselves back. Yeah, we can. Let me walk down through these inlets. Okay. So we've got Mammoth Rocks. Yes? Yes, what? Yes, that we need to reconsider. That we need to have that overarching. Yes. Okay. Okay. Okay. Mammoth Kids Jazz Camp.

7:09:04 Yes, because we weren't sure if it was a non-profit or not. Right. Now, let's remember on Kids Jazz Camp, we did have the 2000 direct and then the 2000... Yes, and the matching. We had direct and matching. Yeah. So there was that piece to it as well. But I guess, like, what's their incentive to find matching funding if they're just going to have to give it back? Yeah. Right? Right?

7:09:37 Keep going, Teri. Village Rest. Yes. Yes. Eastern Sierra Symphony. I don't know. We fully funded them. No, we did not. Sorry. Current program expansion on the road. Monies to be used for appropriate energy. I mean, I have to say, I would like to consider, if it's feasible at this late stage, that...

7:10:08 That funding mechanism that we invented exists if there is not a demonstrable public benefit to the event or programming. If there is, then we should be awarding funds because we should just be awarding unencumbered funds. Because the concern was the pass-through, and the pass-through exists.

7:10:34 That pass-through is only a concern if there's not a public benefit. Well, let's just take the private ones to start with. So you've got Mammoth Rocks, you've got Village Fest, potentially the Jazz Camp, you have Mammoth Reggae, you have Margarita Festival, you have the Kids Adventure Camp, Kids Fishing Festival, we're not sure where that is.

7:11:06 I would go back to, I would say that every one of those that you've just listed, we've agreed there's enough of a public benefit that we are willing to fund to the tune of 10% for now.

7:11:30 The only issue to me is when we get into a place where we're saying that the public benefit is incidental, then we have to defer to looking at the pass-through concern, and that would be the place where that mechanism of paying back that money would come into play. And the only one of those that we handle... I'm inclined to walk back, I think, to the old...

7:12:01 Here's kind of what we did. After, and I wasn't, I don't quite know when, the pivot happened right after Kamikaze and Fall Center came back in and we had developed this. What we ended up doing was not following the kind of prescription of A, is there a public benefit, and then B, you know, the second step to that is do we want to fund the

7:12:28 The actual fundraising mission of the fundraiser. Right. I mean, the problem that we ran into there was that we were on the fence about which came first, primary public benefit or primary fundraising. And we decided that we... It was a fundraiser. Okay. But I'm not sure that we actually did have that discussion fully about whether or not it was... I mean, it was definitely a fundraiser, and that's okay, but it also, I think, has a primary public benefit.

7:12:56 I agree. I don't remember having that conversation. I did not agree that that was primarily a fundraiser. Right. So let's go back to the notes here. I thought we did because it was right there in their statement. Well, no, I don't think anybody disagrees that it's a fundraiser. The question was whether the public benefit outfaces the fact that it's a fundraiser. I mean, because as we've said all the way through this, that we, I mean, if

7:13:24 If an organization's motivation to create something for public benefit is that it's a fundraiser, we should encourage that. Yeah, but I think that might be the part where... So this is what I'm saying. But they're showing a profit to their organization that's significantly larger than the amount they're asking for. So that was where we decided in that instance... So we said how much of a community, total community benefit is now the community foundation.

7:13:52 Which is the pass-through amount that we're doing gift of public funds. Exactly. So in those instances where there was a question about gift of public funds for now, we created the mechanism whereby we would subsidize and then it was at this loan idea. And that came out of the legal question of public benefit or pass-through. Well, because the question is, are we going to...

7:14:20 Are we going to put $28,000 towards an event that's generating $73,000 that is going to cover some education for some, you know, athletes? Well, I think we said we can't consider what the overall mission of the organization is at this point because we don't know. Well, actually, that's what we were supposed to do. The overall mission of the organization that the money is going to is also of the benefit and benefit, you know, the town as a whole.

7:14:47 But I think what we realized is that it's more than just the mission, it's the mission and where they're spending the money, where the programming is, because if the mission is broad enough that they could be using it for something that doesn't necessarily benefit. Right. Which is why we essentially said those are loans. Would it be accurate to actually say that our problem here is one of scale more than anything?

7:15:12 What I'm hearing is that we don't have a problem with a kind of smaller project eking out profit after hard work and some help from MLR, but what we actually have a problem with is events that have gotten to a stage where they are making a significant profit, and we have a hard time contributing to that.

7:15:37 Is that a fair statement? Yes, yes. Well, I would just also add that there are some that have been in there for a lot of years on their own who have come back and asked for funding also that play into this as well. But, yes, that is a, I would support that as a primary or a concern. Right. There's a lot of money being asked to generate money.

7:16:06 So could they ask for less and not generate as much? Or could they ask for less and generate as much? Well, I disagree a little bit from the standpoint of size. This project doesn't bother me. The question was, what are we giving money for? And we started this question. Right now, we're in interim funding process. We could spend all night delivering this one issue right now. And I'm going to push us to kind of bring to a close on that conversation.

7:16:33 You know, we make our choices. We're going to make good decisions, bad decisions. I remind myself that we've got a whole community down the road that's without homes, without everything else, and we're not really, you know, at the end of the day, we're making a recommendation to town council. We'll end up making the actual funding, but I want to feel good about what we left here with and saying, okay, did I feel we did a good job? Did I feel we made the right recommendation? You know, I'm torn here with that.

7:16:54 I've done events in town. I know how hard people work. There's never enough money put into events for what you put into it. I don't care what the numbers show. No one really makes events. Just money on events. Even Kamikaze at the end of the day, there's, you know, the mountain puts a ton of money into it. And they're not really making any money on that. But is it helping us promote the town? Yes. And is it a good starting for them from an interim funding portion right now? I think we've come a long ways in the last seven and a half hours.

7:17:22 You know, going through items. And I don't think we've made, I think we've made intelligent choices on where we were at and where we need to go. And are all those right? I don't know. I mean, I'm trying to make from the heart saying are these good decisions that make the community better? I feel like we're close to an intelligent interim presentation right now. I just feel like there's a one, this one thing is an inconsistency.

7:17:51 I don't have a hard time walking away. But from the standpoint of that you believe everybody should be giving back? No, I'm not saying that. I'm just saying that I want some standard. It doesn't have to be that one, that everybody kind of pays back. I'm just saying that we kind of use that as a solution, and I just don't want it to be arbitrarily applied. I want there to be some logic behind the application of that solution.

7:18:21 Well, in looking at the ones we had before that, they weren't showing a profit. Right. So that didn't really come into consideration. It didn't come into consideration at the time, but they couldn't show a profit. So David's point was, so we're asking fundraisers, if they make a profit, they have to get the money back, but if a private organization is making a profit, we're not asking for that money back. So that's the inconsistency. Exactly. So, and we were specifically speaking to events, not necessarily. Right.

7:18:51 And I think the distinction's important. I think, I mean, I guess my feeling at this stage in the game is to say let's be, let's say, let's come down equally on one-off events that are for profit and not for profit and use the same mechanism for both. So if they don't make a profit, then so be it, we're awarding them.

7:19:14 We're helping them to finance an event. If they do, then that money comes back. But programming, I think, has to be, that's a much more complex kettle of fish that I think we're going to be, you know, it doesn't really make a whole lot of sense to ask them to pay back. What about this, perhaps? What if we, instead of asking that money to come back to MLR, we ask that it's reinvested in the next year's program?

7:19:43 or Project. That way we're still incentivizing, you know, we're not, we're not, there's not like a little bait and switch going on, you know, they can still use those funds, and it's helping them to grow their, their event. But that we say it should specifically be applied to that event or that programming the next year.

7:20:07 I mean, that at least helps encouraging them to leverage funds, because otherwise, what's the point? Exactly. Why ask for more money when you're just going to have to give it back from other people? What if there is no event?

7:20:23 Well, then it would come back. Well, then it would come back. Then the census on a reimbursement basis, no event, no money. Yeah. I think that's a really, I think that's a very graceful solution. I like that a lot. I think we could apply that across the board. We would apply that to the other fundraisers that we did, too, and take off the... To me, that can apply to every single one of those.

7:20:44 That's the... I couldn't vote with that. Not for nonprofits in certain ways because it's a pass-through. And I go where it's going, but it would be a pass-through for me. I couldn't vote on that. I think that where the issue comes is we dealt with private...

7:21:01 Events first without thinking about it. And so I think that if we can focus on some way to craft something that covers them because the other ones we followed the logic once we arrived at it. For the fundraisers we followed that logic. So can it be as simple as walking back up the plank a little bit and saying for those events that were funded. Private entities.

7:21:26 Not identified as fundraisers that we did not ask them to bring back funding back. We just go and ask for that money to come back. If they do net... Over and above that amount. Over and above. If they net, then the first payment back or the first repay is back to Measure U of any of their net up to the amount awarded. And that would be Mammoth Rocks. That would be Kids Jazz.

7:21:58 That would be Village Fest. That would be... Reggae. Reggae. Margarita. Margarita. Yeah. And kids' adventure games. Yeah. And I think as Brent pointed out, it'll be fairly easy for some of those events just to do their books in such a way that they show that they didn't make any money.

7:22:26 No, but they may want to allocate certain costs that we didn't initially see. I'm not prohibiting that. I'm just saying that's available to them to... That's their reporting. That's their reporting at the end? Yep. The sincerity of it is that they follow the spirit of by which everybody else is... Yeah, it's going to be a challenge because they all have more expensive than what they're reporting. Right. Every one of them do. Yeah. Sure.

7:22:50 No, and I think that's something to encourage as well, that in these applications people come forward with all the expenses rather than trying to make it look a certain way. And then to report all your revenues because if you've made X amount over and above, oh, that's great. So let's just test this really quick. Yeah, can you look, but I just have a question. So the money that we...

7:23:19 Funded, say, the Kamikaze Games of the False Entry. No, we were excluding them. Well, no, I understand that, but you said the question was asked, could we apply that, that same idea that. We did apply that. We did apply. Within their motion, so like for Kamikaze, it says if revenue is generated, dollars come back up to the amount of the $14,235 that was. Okay, sorry, I'm not, I'm tired. I know, right?

7:23:49 I guess what I'm trying to say is that why would it be, why would it be pass-through if we would give an event that's also a fundraiser money and instead of asking them to give it back that they wouldn't just hold it on to the next year. I'd like to explore that a little more too just because. That's a reconciliation nightmare.

7:24:19 Haven't we gone to great strides to clarify with the town very specifically that if they have not expended money, it comes back. There is not a carryover because you start to lose the accounting side of it. You start to lose that piece of it. So early on, there's been very clear that there is not a carryover. If it doesn't get expended, it comes back. And actually, council has already proved that in concept. We haven't written up the final reconciliation statement.

7:24:49 I don't know if that was your reason why, but I think that's one of my reasons is that we've said we would not carry over. Yeah, but aren't we carrying it over if an event is making money? I mean, are we even carrying it over? They just, yeah, they just pocket it, put it in there. And that's why we're saying that we need to. But that's why there's a P&L. Make check the same thing. So, let's go back. There are these, these that we.

7:25:19 Did not use the same rationale. So Mammoth Rocks, Mammoth Jazz, Kids Jazz, Village Fest, Reggae, Margarita, Kids Adventure. And I'm going to go, I'm looking at what we did for Mammoth Rocks. They had a budget of $48,000 was their operating budget. We took 10% of that. We rewarded $4,800 to them. I'm going to make a motion.

7:25:52 The identified events, Mammoth Rocks, Kids Jazz Camp, Village Fest, Mammoth Reggae Festival, Marguerite Festival, and Kids Adventure Games, that any net income comes back to Measure U up to the amount they've been appointed. Is there a second? Second. Now, does that bring, I mean, remember, I'm sorry, for which ones? For

7:26:23 Mammoth Rocks, Mammoth Kids Jazz, Village Fest, Mammoth Reggae, Margarita Festival, and Kids Adventure Games. Okay, for the Jazz one, didn't we, we did a matching? Kids Jazz had a matching. Kids Jazz. So that, right, so that one is problematic. Kids Jazz was 2000 direct and 2000 matching.

7:26:54 I would have no problem excluding the kids' jazz camp. Well, and we did that under the assumption that that was also, that it is a non-profit? We weren't sure. We're not sure. Just as a reminder for Village Fest, it was $6,029 for appropriate measure expenses. That was off of their 10% of their budget. Reggae Festival.

7:27:25 was $3,000. $3,000 was Reggae, that was 10% of their budget. Mammoth Margarita was $52.55, which was 10% of their budget. So the other one that we have here, we didn't say that money had to come back as the kids, the Labor Day Festival. We did the 42, 24, 10% kids area measure you appropriate.

7:27:54 No, I have returned. Yeah, I have returned. That's for the kids. What do you guys want to do? I think Terry's. There's a motion on the table. I think Terry's motion makes sense. There's a motion on the table and a second. So, is there any further discussion? So, we excluded, did we? You just excluded. I excluded it. Was it the second?

7:28:25 Accepted that and excluded? Yes. So we've got Mammoth Rocks, Village Fest, Reggae Festival, Margaritas, and Kids Adventure are the ones that are in this motion. I'm sorry, is the motion right now that it gets returned or that it gets put into a fund for future events? No, that it gets returned. It gets returned. Thank you. Because no carryover. If there's no further discussion, I'm going to call for the vote. All those in favor, indicate my aye.

7:28:57 Aye. Aye. Any opposed? No. No. Two, no, five, yes? Mm-hmm. That means the motion passes. Right. All right. So just to confirm, the Mammoth Rocks, Village Fest, Mammoth Ray Game, Margarita, Kids Adventure Games, any net income comes back to measuring you. Up to the amount. Up to the amount.

7:29:32 And I hope that way as we move forward we do find public benefit because there may be larger entities which we may say, you know, anything going to this entity may be falling where we need it to fall. Yep. That's definitely a very important next step. Yeah, and I'm just going to go back to the conversation last Friday. It kind of occurred when there was a discussion with the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation about this larger role of activities and events.

7:30:01 How those are all working together and leveraging each other's sources, that they all fall under a bigger plan, if you will, or strategy for where these events are occurring, when they're occurring, what project or what equipment they're using, that it's a much bigger effort and not these incremental ad hoc.

7:30:25 Side of things. But, I mean, I still push in. We're interim funding cycle. I'm trying to, we got to get a smooth direction, move forward. We had a lot of discussion. There's a summary left. There's a lot. Right. But this is interim, and we did talk about it. So. Good. So that's the overarching one that addresses that. The other ones were already addressed. Right. We'll work on the presentation, and we'll move forward to get it over to the council by. So what I did put down, we have.

7:30:54 Suggested funding for 27 projects at $380. It's an additional $10,260. Okay. Yeah, it's down here, too. So if it's in reserve, does that count? No, because when they come forward out of reserve, then you would apply the amount at the same time. Well, I did count. Oh, no, I would think you don't. I think you don't because you don't know, you don't really know if and when they're going to come forward. So I would say we only count the ones that we're actually saying allocate money now.

7:31:24 For the towns? Yeah, for that, for the admin fee of the contract, because there isn't a contract on those other ones. But if one comes forward in the beginning of March, then we just say it's so much for the project and X amount for the admin of the contract. So how many are you at four? Four. So which four? The roof, the Volcom, Shane's, and the Cultural Center?

7:31:53 It would exclude Bolton Brothers, Maltese, Roof, Arts and Cultural Center, and Shenzhen. Sorry, my head's a little slow. Why would we, I don't understand why we're just, I recognize we're reserve funds, I'm not spending, we're saying that the 300 were. No, what I'm saying is that the amount that we're putting into number two, which was,

7:32:17 X amount per each contract that they're going to have to, you know, create and manage would only be for the ones where we're actually allocating money. If it's in reserve, then what, yeah, then you allocate it at that time. Okay, we just went through the whole portion saying we weren't going to go above what was already allocated, which we're saying now contradicting and we're. No, no, because number two, number two at 46 plus a fee per award.

7:32:45 No, I got it. Yeah. But I just, we said we're going to set a limit, and then you can't go above, and now we're saying you can over inwards. It's $1,000. All right. So it may end up being in the amount. Yep. All right. Yeah, I was just going to say moving forward, I'm happy to write the kind of treatment of this, but I would like it if somebody else would summarize the decisions for me.

7:33:13 I can do that from what I've got here electronically and get that to you and Dana tomorrow morning. And then I think grouping will really help. May we take five minutes before administrative item number two, please? Yeah, we can do that very quickly. We made it to number two.

7:33:37 What is number two? We have minutes. We have minutes. There's a number two? And we have, we also have a closed session, you guys, and we need to make a decision on something. Keep looking forward on some things. So, you know, you have three minutes. Yeah, three minutes. Yeah, because there's, I gotta go back to work, so we gotta, you know. Or, you know, David, we need approval on a couple of these things, and we need to talk about this next step and when we can bring whatever we need to do. Okay. Yeah.

7:34:07 Tom, you want that? Who's summarizing it? I am. Yeah, I'm just going to summarize off of the notes I took. I'm going to summarize off of my notes. Let's say that. Okay. Well, hopefully we can do the minutes in the other one really quickly.

7:34:57 Do we have any kind of a cost associated with it? We have registration is $90 up until February 16th, it's $115 after that, and then we have a flight and two nights accommodation, so upwards of three, yeah, three.

7:35:22 2, 2, 4, 7, not over $1,000. We should be able to do it. There's some food in there. So we should be able to do it. I'm going to nominate St. David, but that's who I was going to nominate. Okay, then I'm going to ask the question, is it going to come out of unrestricted funds, or is it going to come out of the general fund, or is it going to come out of the...

7:35:52 I think it's coming out of our general. It's out of the general fund. How much do we have in the general fund? Fifteen. I think it comes out of that. Because here's the whole thing. Because I don't think you can say it's R or U related. No, it's not. You could connect it to R. Yeah. Notice down the bottom right-hand corner who's speaking. Sorry, I can't read. Oh, sorry. You mean the Chris Warner? No, this one right here. Oh. Well.

7:36:21 This one right here, and that's EMBA, and that's in academia, and she's like, you know, a genius on that kind of stuff, so. Yeah, there could be rationale for Measure R. Well, if we were sending the Executive Director, I could see it being Measure R. Yeah. But, we don't have that yet. Yeah. Okay, surveyed back yet? Not quite. Almost.

7:36:50 This time I'll take a step. Dinner? Dinner? I'm with my kids. So sweet. I don't want any more of these. I haven't had lunch, I haven't had dinner. I want food. Oh, did you? What do you have? Ooh, from? Ooh.

7:37:21 Oh, I had an apple. I started an apple. It was a honey crisp, you know, the really good ones. And it was rotten. Did you buy it downstairs? No, I bought it. Oh, wait. Where did I buy this one? This one might have been here. Because usually I shopped here in Bishop. Well, I shopped at a market for produce. Oh, good idea. All right. So we're going to...

7:37:53 Be convening in a second. We've got a couple of items to address here real quick. We all are. All right. Tom, come back? No, he's not back again. This is nothing. After the settlement, yeah. Let's go ahead. Let's convene, and we can get started on considering the minutes of January 26th. So we convene. Uh-huh.

7:38:28 35. We don't have to put any of that in. Okay. All right. Item number two on the agenda is to review and consider approving the minutes of the January 26th meeting. I'll make motion to approve the minutes as distributed. It's been moved. Is there a second? Is there a second to approving the minutes? Yes, there's a second. I don't want to make the motion to interrupt them. Right? Move the second to approve the January 26th minutes. Any further discussion?

7:39:01 All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. This item number three, this came before us a couple of times as an emergency item at a previous meeting, but it's back in front of us now as an action item. The Utah Outdoor Recreation Summit is coming up here in March of 2015. It is Tuesday, March 3rd.

7:39:26 And we did talk about being able to send a board member to this outdoor summit. I just want to point out who the featured speakers are. President and CEO of REI is going to be there. The senior director of what's called Outdoor Nation for the Outdoor Foundation. Outdoor Foundation is the nonprofit for the Outdoor Industry Association. So he's the head of that. We've got...

7:39:53 Kelly Bricker is there from University of Utah. She's in her own field relative to outdoor recreation. And here is her topic, why is sustainable destination planning and tourism important to your community? There is someone there from IMBA talking about guides to new trails and rural cycling adventures. So we have folks from Black Diamond that are going to be there.

7:40:23 This is a convening in Utah of their outdoor industry summit. Brad Peterson, who's their head guy, sent this over to us. We might be interested in attending it. There's a registration deadline coming up. By February 16th, it's $90. After February 16th, it's $115. We would look to incur the cost of air and lodging back there for a couple of days.

7:40:51 I think that we should be sending somebody to this. I've spoken to David about it. He's expressed an interest and an ability to go there, to be able to network with a lot of the sponsors. There's over 400 folks who attend this that are from that outdoor industry association in the outdoor recreation world. And I think it's a good start for us for some networking opportunities. So I wanted to entertain a motion, if you are considering this, that we would send David, that we would cover

7:41:21 His registration, lodging, air, and meals to get back there. It's one day. It's a one-day event. March 3rd. It's a Tuesday. And you made a quick calculation of about $1,000? I would say up to $1,200, air, lodging, middle of the week, a couple nights. I guess before, have you already made a motion? No.

7:41:52 As late as it is, I'm not sure I'm really ready to visit this thing very specifically, but I would think that if we were going to move forward on a motion like that, we'd want to attach some deliverables, because I'd like to know what would be the... I mean, obviously, as a general networking and just being out there thing, that seems great, but is, you know...

7:42:18 And that's a great point. How do we make it valuable to the organization? Right. A couple points on that. We have a couple of deliverables in our contract that speak to grant opportunities and grant requirements. And in understanding who is attending this, the opportunity to identify potential grant rounds that some of these organizations either offer through their own foundation or through their corporation as a whole. And so I think that that would be an expectation that I would have coming back is that those...

7:42:47 Opportunities are identified and leads generated to bring back with you on that would be one of mine. And because those are the subjects I think we also need include the fact that we would take it out of that general fund allocation we received for things that cannot be directly tied to R or U because it really isn't a direct tie.

7:43:13 And I think the sustainable tourism recreation to sustain community, that's a key component, I think that would be. Now, I'm waiting for case motion, but, you know, I'm going to be very adamantly against this from the standpoint of I believe we've stretched a bore too thin. I believe we need to get an ED in place, and I think we have to make that our biggest priority in falling after our U-funding. And I think that we're moving to the point of a...

7:43:40 Too far stretching for what you get for board members and what they can deliver and time for that they can dedicate to one individual project. I would agree with you wholeheartedly. The fact that this comes up on an annual basis kind of puts it at a... And if an ED goes, it's probably closer related to... I would have no problem with ED going to this or, you know, because I can give you 20 other outdoor recreation...

7:44:08 Conference is taking place all within the West Coast. It's, there's a, that'd be a different, there's, there are quite a few. I'm involved with a number of those in different ways, so, yeah, but they're, each represents a different ability. I just think we need to be very focused moving forward, and I think, you know, just like our deliberations today, there's ways we can make ourselves more efficient, and the DED is a way that we really need to move in. I would, I would also add that.

7:44:35 After today's deliberation, you know, making decisions at, I mean, we're talking $1,200, and we were making decisions for other groups in this town. At those kinds of levels, I think I would be much more comfortable not sending someone at this time. I agree. No action.

7:44:59 We do have March and April MLR board meeting dates. Our next meeting is scheduled for the 23rd of February, so we do need to set dates. A rhetorical question. At this late point, since I heard a side discussion a couple of days ago about we're going down to one a month, right? I wonder if

7:45:29 We wait until the 23rd to set the other two meetings. You know what? I don't know about your calendar, but I have to fill that tomorrow, and if you do fill it up on the 23rd, it's probably already filled anyway, so it doesn't have to. Then do we want to set just one for March at this point? I would propose that, that we get March on the calendar. Okay. We also, a couple board meetings go.

7:45:58 had proposed the idea of doing a 5 p.m.? Correct. But we didn't make a decision. No, we did. I would only ask if we go to one a month that we make it later in the month so that it can include the financial reports and things like that. For example, I just got those yesterday from Sarah.

7:46:26 I'll still put them on the 23rd, but if we meet, I would rather say, let's meet towards the middle or end of the month instead of at the beginning of the month. Well, we might have special meetings or closed sessions. Yeah. So if I'm looking at the March calendar, there's five Mondays in March.

7:46:52 So the 16th or the 23rd? The 16th would be right before the council meeting. I think in thinking about how MLR reviews things that are on the council agenda, perhaps that makes more sense. I can do the 16th. I can too. Yeah. All right. So then the next question is time. Can you do 5 o'clock? I can do 5 o'clock. Yeah.

7:47:23 I can too. Drea, I'm looking over at you. Yes. Brent, I'm looking at you also. If we're trying to five, will we be done by eight? Yes. Yes. Yes. Because there's not. We're going to be tight and organized. We don't have to. Well, we have other things coming back like that. We will have other things, but not as much as all this. And will it be here in the suite? No, we would most likely use the college room at the library.

7:47:51 We would request it. I'm good for 5 o'clock. On the 16th. So then let's go ahead and set March 16th at 5 p.m. What about? Is location TBD? Location TBD, but most likely it'll be the college room. We don't need to be. All right. And we'll set that for now. What about April? It would be great if we could do it now. So again, same thing in April. There's four Mondays.

7:48:21 Joe, are you guys, your council meets on the 1st? The 1st and the 15th. Okay, so then what about Monday the 13th? Well, apparently it's Thomas Jefferson's birthday. What does your Monday the 13th look like? It is Thomas Jefferson's birthday, so yeah. When's school break here? When is school break? The following week. The following week, yeah.

7:48:42 So this would be good to do the 13th at least so we do it before school break. As long as we're 5 o'clock, I've got a meeting that ends at 5. Okay, great. You can join us. So 5 p.m. would work there too? So let's go April 13th at 5 p.m. Okay. All right. Set. Okay. Anything else on the board meetings? Okay.

7:49:08 We do have a closed session item that we wanted to go into. Right. And I would, I would suggest that we turn off the Granicus and we actually go use the closed session. So we, Teri, you'll shut that off. Well, no, we're not, yeah, we're going to close. Yeah.