Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 55 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
355 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you.
0:28 Okay, let me do it after.
0:53 Good afternoon. I now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for February 11, 2015. Roll call, please. Commissioner Tenney. Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Here. Vice Chair Harvey. Here. Chair Brown. Here. And Commissioner Greyhuck is absent. Please join me in the Pledge of Readiness.
1:21 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time we'll have public comments. Public comments is our portion of the agenda where anybody in the public can make any comment they'd like if it does not relate to an agenda item. Does anybody like to make any public comments? If there being no public comments, we'll close the public comment.
2:00 And we will now move to our first business matter, which is the Summer Transient Workshop. It's the Summer Transit Workshop, and I'll turn it over to Brian. Are you going to start? I have a handout that I'll present to the Commission. Why do you think it's appropriate? It seems like summer. It certainly feels like it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you.
2:43 Well, thank you. Again, this is our opportunity. We have been doing this for several years on a biannual basis to brief the community and the commission. It was the Mobility Commission prior to the time that mobility was folded under your commission's areas of responsibility. But to brief the community on what's happening in the world of transit, but then also in terms of planning.
3:08 to brief the commission on things that we're looking at about six months. So our winter transit workshop typically focuses on our summer service and vice versa for the workshop that we do in the fall. I have the handout that I've just presented to you and I have a few PowerPoint slides that I'll kind of walk through to keep myself organized a little bit. Again, as a brief overview of the transit services that we have here in Mammoth Lakes, there is extensive
3:49 Particularly for a community the size of ours, very extensive transit service in the area. We have year-round service that is funded through the town primarily in an arrangement between the town and Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. We operate year-round. We also have significant seasonal services in the winter that we contract through with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and in the summer that we operate under a special use permit with the Forest Service for the Reds Meadow Shuttle Service.
4:19 But the purple, gray, and trolleys operate year-round in town here along with the dial ride service. In the winter we have the red, blue, green, and yellow routes that operate to the various portals, Mammoth Mountain, Skiria portals. Dial ride service operates year-round also in town. As I mentioned, the Reds Meadow Shuttle seasonally in the summer months. And for the last several years we have also operated the June Mountain Shuttle seasonally, operating...
4:45 Providing transit service between Mammoth Lakes and June Mountain, primarily servicing employees who reside in the Mammoth area and work at June Mountain. And then there are regional routes that provide service through and to Mammoth, the Reno route and then the Mammoth Express routes. The ridership by route on the graph that you can see here, almost exactly even ridership between year-round town services, the purple, gray and trolley services.
5:17 At 371,000 trips last year, and 372,000 on the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area trips. I will add a caveat to that. Normally the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area ridership is a little bit higher than the town routes, but last winter, and again this was 2014, so it's a little bit of the beginning of this winter, but the majority of that ridership for MMSA was from last winter's season.
5:44 And we had an abbreviated season and discontinued several of the routes early on. So that's one of the reasons that was down. Conversely though, and it's kind of hard to see the colors on here, but the purple 161,000 for Reds Meadow, that was a record by nearly 20%. We had an extremely strong ridership on that service last summer. One of the upsides, unfortunately, to these dry winters is an early start.
6:13 To our summer activities, the Reds Meadow Road has been opened the last two Memorial Day weekends, and we've started service then, and it's just stayed very strong throughout the summer. And then the very small pieces of that pie graph are the dial ride service ridership and the June Mountain Shuttle. Carrying this forward, these graphs show both the service hours, the relative amount of service for each of the route groupings.
6:43 And the funding that's provided basically for each of those. And it's not an exact match in all cases, and there are some reasons behind that, but generally they parallel along lines. But basically what you can see from that, sort of the takeaway is the service hours are roughly 50% for the town routes, town contractor routes of the service hours that we operate.
7:13 here in Mammoth, in the Mammoth area. And again, there was the caveat that the service hours became abbreviated last year for the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. We would have operated 30 to 40 percent more hours than we did had it been a good solid winter with good solid visitation and based on the budget and the plans that we had with the ski area. But one of the things that the addition of
7:38 Both the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Contract and the Reds Meadows Service that we operate again under permit, what that has served to do to benefit our authority and indirectly, no in fact directly, the town, is those services help to pay a portion of our existing overhead costs anyway and that benefit then is passed along to the member entities that form.
8:03 The Eastern Sierra Transit Authority and particularly the town of Mammoth Lakes here in Mammoth with the services that we provide. So that allows these pie charts to have the shapes that they do where in essence the town seems to on this received a lot more service than the amount of funding that's provided there. And that's purely a relationship to the fact that the authority has been able to develop additional funding sources for services that help to cover
8:31 Some of the, particularly the fixed costs that we have. And an important measurement metric in the transit world is efficiency, or it's referred to as productivity, which refers to the number of passenger trips that are operated per service hour. And there, as you can see from this graph, there's a huge disparity. But this does, it's not necessarily a bad thing. It's just in many ways showing that there are apples, difference between apples and oranges and measuring.
9:00 A high productivity fixed route service such as the MMSA routes with productivity in excess of 40 passenger trips per hour. And I will tell you, that is a high, that is a good metric even for a relatively major city urban transit system. 40 passengers per hour on a fixed route is a very, very productive service.
9:23 And many dial-a-ride services are in the one to two passengers per hour range. So it's not that these are totally out of line. But again, it's an important thing to look at just to understand the nature of the various services there. As you divide, and another metric that is looked at, the operating cost per service hour for various routes by this figure, you can then determine what the average cost per passenger trip is.
9:51 And conversely, just as dial right is very low in productivity, dial right is very high in cost per trip. And similarly, it's reversed on the high productivity fixed route services. Again, just a breakdown of some of the details by route. Again, the summer trolley for the town's route services is the most productive. We are busiest in the summer months. I remember when I first came to the Eastern Sierra seven years ago,
10:24 I really hadn't spent much time in the Eastern Sierra in the summer, and I was shocked when I came to learn that it was actually busier here in the summer than it was in the peak part of the summer than it was in the winter. I was just always familiar with Mammoth as a winter resort, but clearly the rest of the world knows about and avails our services, so it just validates that we actually are busier during the summer months.
10:52 And this graph again shows the continued growth in ridership on the purple and gray lines. These are what we refer to as our community circulator lines. They operate seven days a week, 365 days a year, from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. And the service is basically out of this shopping center and provides service throughout the community. And these routes are particularly well used by the residents and service employees within our community.
11:18 And as you can see, has been very well received and continues to be. We've seen nearly 60% growth in the Purple Line over the five-year period represented on this graph. And just again, a quick breakdown on the fleet that we use to operate this service. Our large 35 and 40-foot buses were procured with a federal grant, primarily in relation to the startup of the Reds Meadows service that we operate now under permit.
11:50 But also lent the way and paved the way for the contractual services with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. And in fact, that wintertime service was included in the grant application that those transportation of those passengers to the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area portals are a separate Mammoth Forest Service Special Use Permit Holder, which is Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for their ski area.
12:16 And then obviously we have the trolley routes. That service is growing and in fact the capital needs that we're looking at in discussion with town staff are looking at enhancing and growing that trolley fleet. Again, particularly during the summer months we're seeing increased usage and increased demand for that style of route. And then we have the cutaway style buses that operate the purple and gray routes.
12:39 And then the larger midsize bus, medium duty buses that we operate our regional routes to Reno and to Bishop with. In terms of this transit workshop, we're bringing forward several discussion items to brief the commission and provide some information about things that town staff and ESSA staff have been beginning dialogue about and seeing if there are ways we can implement and make some of these things happen.
13:12 And I'll walk through these quickly. We began a new service last year on fairly short notice, providing several trips a day, round trips a day, between town and Whitmore Pool. This was really a request that came from the Towns, Parks and Recs Department, and we put together a plan utilizing, and the plan really utilized existing dial ride resources, a vehicle and a driver.
13:43 As well as existing Mammoth Express routes that were going by or near Whitmore Pool at any rate. And we really operated this service for about two months, late June to late August, and really added very little in terms of true additional hours and miles and or vehicles to be able to provide this.
14:10 What we did is we took the existing dial ride vehicle and carved out pieces of time when it could make a run down to the pool and back and would respond to any dial ride calls that it might receive during that period of time once it got back. And that did not seem to cause a problem for the dial ride service when it was there. Similarly, we had the Mammoth Express buses that were traveling up and down 395 between Mammoth and Bishop.
14:38 Deviate into Whitmore Pool and either make a pickup or a drop off there depending on which direction they were going. So very nominal additional time and or miles associated with that. We have talked very preliminarily with staff from Parks and Rec about a desire to, we had very low ridership to be honest last summer, but it was launched late and we feel that we may not have had the full opportunity to get the word out to the community that this existed.
15:08 There are, and these are just conceptual, but some ideas of maybe putting together some kind of a package deal that might be a swim pass and some transit passes or something to go along with a swim team membership thing that might include some transit. So it's my understanding there is interest from town park staff to try to continue this this summer and potentially it does provide and can provide a valuable resource to the community.
15:37 Particularly, for example, for parents who have kids who may not have any other way and the parent, it may not be convenient for them to get them down to the pool at a given time and they could use public transit to meet that need. I'll spend a little bit of time talking about the expanded lakes basin service that we did put into place last summer. And again, a lot of things happened on fairly short notice last summer, this being one of them. And in fairness, some of it was
16:09 Quick planning in response to the fact that we really didn't have much winter last winter. And what should we do with that? And we were looking at a strong Memorial Day weekend upcoming and the Lakes Basin Road was open. It also typically isn't open that early in the summer. So we began the service on Memorial Day and operated seven days a week until mid-September and then for a couple of weekends on the latter part of September.
16:38 And the graph here, not being able to read the days, but the left-hand side is the beginning of the summer season, the Saturday Memorial Day weekend, and that's the ridership by day through the period. And really up until about August 10th, somewhere in there, the second half of August typically visitation does reduce. We see the same kind of pattern on the Reds Meadow Shuttle service.
17:05 For that period, really, from mid-June till early-mid-August, it was very strong ridership every day. The few days that it drops, I believe, really were related to a weather event. We may have had rainstorms coming through the area or something that put a damper on some of the ridership, but it was very well utilized for that period. So, as I say, strong for Memorial Day and then from mid-June to near Labor Day had a big spike.
17:37 What I proposed up here is a possible service model and I think actually the way I presented it is probably more confusing. I know it's more confusing than I intended but basically it would be two buses in service which is our normal level of service during the primary summer season from again late June into late August.
18:04 And then supplemented with Memorial Day weekend and Labor Day weekend. And then later in early June and then in September having one bus in service that provides 60 minute frequency. When we have two buses we have 30 minutes frequency so we have a bus departing the village every 30 minutes from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. And when we have two we have one every 30 minutes during that same period of time.
18:31 What this graph shows is the base level of service, basically what we always used to run before a year or two ago, which was July 1 to Labor Day, is about $50,000 in cost. And then the addition of the various pieces there show you how much each of those pieces cost and what the cumulative total would be. So to do everything that's up there would be about $75,000.
19:00 And that would be service from Memorial Day weekend through the last weekend of September. Now, not only did we operate an increased season last year, and again, as you can see from the first slide there, it was very well received and we had very strong ridership on it, but there has been an increasing request for increased frequency as well. Now, as I mentioned, our normal frequency was one bus every 30 minutes.
19:32 But during many periods, that was not sufficient to meet demand. And we would have a line there at the village, and the bus would fill and depart, and the line was still there. And again, the next bus isn't going to come for another 30 minutes, based on our regular schedule. Just to step back a little bit, our capacity constraints on this route are really not the bus. It has to do with the bicycle rack.
20:01 Because almost everybody going up there, and again, the reason this has become so popular and is used so well, and this is a good problem to have, is the completion of the Lake Mary bike path. And it has just become a really great attraction for people in the community to go up and take advantage of. And every year, more and more people are learning about it and taking advantage of it. So the vast majority of the passengers that we're transporting have a bike.
20:27 Well, our max capacity is 18 bikes. We have a 16 bike trailer and two can fit on a rack on the front. But the bus holds 30 and can easily hold another 15 standing if, you know, we need it to. So it's really the challenge of addressing that and putting more on. And unfortunately, due to the...
20:51 Nature of the road, the narrowest of the road, and the turns, and how congested it is with parked vehicles, both through the Tamarack Campground area, Twin Lakes Campground area, and at the turnaround at Horseshoe Lake, we just can't go with a bigger trailer. Mammoth Mountain Securia uses a larger trailer.
21:11 But we have looked at that. In fact, Man with Mountain Ski Area has looked at it, and we've all concurred that we can't make that turn with a trailer that's larger than what we're operating now. So our only other response to try to meet the demand would be to increase frequency. So one thing that could be done.
21:35 And again, this graph just shows you that during that peak season, and it's kind of hard to see on the graph, but that middle area where the lines are highest, and we had our greatest ridership, they're actually colored in kind of red. During that period, the ridership is shown up above by hour of the day. So from 11 o'clock to 4 o'clock, and the red line that goes across there is the seating capacity of the bus. We're at capacity for that full period of time.
22:03 for that whole basically six week period. And so to meet that demand, the only thing that we can do is add additional capacity and it would be in the form of adding an additional bus. An option could be the addition of, for example, a third bus operating, I would suggest roughly 1120 to 420.
22:29 That's five service hours a day, and that is pretty much that peak period where we're needing that frequency. And that would increase the capacity of our service 50%. So rather than having 36 bikes per hour that could be transported, it would be 36 and 18, 54 per hour. And again, for that rough period, roughly late June to early August,
23:00 Would be about $7,800 to give you some kind of picture as to what is involved there. So again, no decisions have been made, but there has been discussion with town staff, and this is something that we're looking at as a possibility. I don't know practically how this works. Is it possible to add a second trailer so you would have a better turning radius? Oh, look at these vigorously shaking heads.
23:26 Okay. I don't believe so. Yeah, I can understand why one long one couldn't make the turn, but I'm thinking of those buses in big cities that are hinged in the middle, you know, so they can make the turns. Right. Okay. Thank you. So, there's been a lot of discussion and consideration of expansion of the lake space and trolley season, both the operating season, which is pretty much what we did last summer.
23:54 But additionally, perhaps expanding the frequency. And so these are some of the things we're looking at and a relative picture of what the costs would be to pursue that. Speaking of the trolleys, and that was the Lakes Basin Trolley, which specifically operates between the village and up around the Lakes Basin area. There also has been a call for expanded service hours on the trolley in the summer, particularly on weekend nights.
24:23 Particularly in relation to the festivals and events that are going on in town. And anymore, really, the last two summers, it seems that from mid to late June through Labor Day, and actually even beyond now, every weekend there is at least one pretty significant festival or activity going on in town. And again, these are good problems to have. But what happened last summer is we ended up
24:51 operating later night service, later than 10 p.m. During the summer, the trolley operates, is scheduled to operate only until 10 p.m. But we were getting requests on a pretty regular basis the week before the weekend upcoming, saying, oh gosh, we've got this big festival and we didn't think about it, but it would really help if the trolleys could run until midnight. And in consultation with town staff, we pretty much made that happen most of the weekends in the summer, last year.
25:20 What I have shared with town staff is operationally it would be far preferable to plan and budget and advertise the service rather than responding sort of at the last minute. And again, the advertisement and notice about it to me would be a big thing because we would respond to these requests and run it, but people didn't necessarily know that we were going to be out there because all of our, all the stops that, the posters of the bus stop still said that we only ran until 10 p.m.
25:49 So that would be an additional advantage. Again, to give the Commission some kind of a picture as to what this might amount to for 12 weekends from June 20th through Labor Day. And as a reminder, June 20th, the weekend of June 20th is the Mammoth Half Marathon, and that has become a pretty big draw the last years. So it seems like we kind of start summer in earnest at that time.
26:16 But were we to operate until midnight on Friday and Saturday nights, that would be a cost of $4,200. And then we also typically share or kind of conclude our workshop by keeping things that we call a wish list on the table. The purpose is just so we and the commissioners don't necessarily forget about this. We're not saying that we have the money or the resources or anything else to do any of these things at this time, but it's something that
26:47 in a more unconstrained environment, resource environment, we might want to do. Again, we have had requests periodically throughout the years to extend the hours for the purple and gray, our community circulator routes. Again, they, as a reminder, they operate 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. Specifically, there have been requests for later service till perhaps 8 p.m. to get workers home who may work beyond 6 p.m. Something that we have been
27:17 look considering a little bit is the trolleys are really well utilized and we get real positive feedback from the riders in the community who use that because it looks like it's fun and it is fun and particularly it's fun in the summer when they're open air and we roll up the, you know, take the windows out and roll up the sides. The gray line operates in many of the
27:42 Roads that it operates are on are pretty major thoroughfares, Old Mammoth Road and Meridian and others where it gets high visibility and the thinking was well we might be able to increase exposure and ridership on that route if we used a trolley on that route as opposed to the cutaway style bus which is an enclosed bus vehicle. Right now we have a stumbling block and right now it's a deal breaker to try to do something like that.
28:09 goes out Old Mammoth Road, and right now, and has for the past several years, it turns around at the base of Red Fur Drive, and, you know, we obviously have to turn around somewhere to come back into town, and there aren't very many good places, and in fact, that's the best alternative that we have found, short of being able to use Red Fur Drive, and, again, many years, several years ago,
28:35 There was an objection filed by residents on Red Fur who did not want the transit bus transiting on their street on a regular basis. So that's been off limits and we don't look at that. But we have taken a trolley out to that intersection and the turning radius in the trolley is too big. It cannot turn around there. So if we were to use a trolley on the Gray Line,
29:01 We'd have to find some route modification that we're not aware of at this time. And then two last things. Again, we reduce service on the town trolley route to one bus in service. Normally there are two buses in service and they provide 20 minute frequency. It's a 40 minute loop, the whole circle. So if we have two, we have a bus every 20 minutes, which is really good frequency.
29:29 Quite honestly, one of the reasons the route's used so well, because people don't have to wait too long for a bus to come by. During the lower ridership stroller seasons, we reduce that to one, and we go to an unscheduled time where it's approximately every 30 minutes, but it can take more than 30 minutes if there are a lot of pickups or there's any kind of a traffic delay. So it's less than optimal, but it does allow us to
29:59 Reduce expense during the shoulder season. So again, in an unconstrained environment, it'd be nice to be able to run two year-round. And then last but not least, there has been a request periodically to see if we could do something to provide service to Shady Rest Park during the summer. And again, there have not been resources to this point identified to make that happen, but again, sort of keeping it on the wish list, mentioning that to the Commission.
30:30 That concludes my presentation this time. Taking questions. You know, we're all about guest service because that's what our economy depends on. And during December, the buses were exceptionally dirty going around town. What is the washing schedule for the buses? Because they were so dirty I didn't even want to be near them, much less get on them. We did have some periods with
31:01 Challenging weather. Even though we didn't have a lot of weather, it was melting just enough that literally a bus can be cleaned the night before and by late afternoon it doesn't at all look like it's been washed in a week. And that was some of what we were dealing with. And we don't have the capacity and staffing to be able to wash the entire fleet every night. So what we do is a portion of the fleet is washed every night. We try to take the worst.
31:28 Obviously, each evening to clean them to prepare for service the next day. But you're right, I don't disagree. I noticed that as well. And we're working to see if there are things that we can do to improve that. I would find that to be a very important budgetary consideration because we're trying to get our visitors on transit and it's got to be attractive. So I would definitely put that in the budget. Thank you. Okay.
31:59 I have a couple of really quick questions, John. First of all, probably the goofy question that you and your staff have thought about is, would it be possible, I know you said the trailer for the Lakes Basin trolley cannot be any longer than the 18-bike trailer you currently have. You have two slots on the front of that trolley for a bike mount. Would it be possible to fix bike mounts along the sides of the trailer? No? Along the sides of the bus or the trailer?
32:29 The trolley itself. So you have two bikes fixed to the front of the trolley. Right. There's the one side that does not have an entrance. I'm just wondering if you could fix six bikes along that, two, two, two, and then maybe on the side that does have the entrance and the exit, maybe another couple of slots.
32:50 Right. The short answer is no in a state regulation on the allowable width of a vehicle and things that are attached to the vehicle and we would far exceed that if we had a bicycle on the side of the bus. Got it. Okay. So while we're on those subjects, so why couldn't we just use some sort of utility truck just to take bicycles up? You could have the trailer, you could have your extra passengers on the trolley.
33:16 And then maybe some sort of flatbed truck to take 10, 12 bikes up for those six weeks. That could be done. Or whether it's a flatbed truck or any other vehicle that towed another trailer. That absolutely could be done. The costs wouldn't, you know.
33:40 My quick analysis of this is the cost wouldn't be dramatically different. You're still paying an employee to drive that vehicle. You still have a vehicle, whether it's a truck or a bus, that's doing that to transport that. But do we have a trolley that could do that? We have equipment, yes. We have vehicles.
34:05 I love the idea of expanding the Lakes Basin Trolley Service during their peak times in the summer. And like you said, John, summer is starting earlier and earlier and ending later and later. I can definitely say as somebody who is out selling this community on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Tourism that the Lakes Basin Trolley Service is an absolute hit and people come away from their stay in Mammoth Lakes.
34:30 With that being one of the high points of their vacation, the fact that they can take that complimentary shuttle up there with their bike, not have to subject themselves to the altitude as they cycle up the bike path, but then come down and enjoy the multi-use path throughout the lakes basin in the process. So I definitely compliment the fact that you're projecting the rise in ridership that you see coming. Definitely saw some families out there this last summer that were
34:57 Flat out dejected by the fact that they didn't get on a trolley or their bike didn't get on a trolley and they had to wait that 30 minutes. So I think anything we can do to alleviate that during our peak times in the summer would be fantastic and would definitely increase the overall experience for our guests and locals alike. The other question I had was about the funding. Maybe you mentioned this and I didn't see it, but how much would you estimate the Whitmore Pool dial-a-ride option was costing you?
35:32 The short answer is basically nothing. Those runs that were operated by the dial ride service, that vehicle was being billed as being in dial ride service anyway during that time. And the Mammoth Express runs that deviated in there, there was no additional charge for that. So it was a pretty low cost amenity to have the connectivity with Whitmore Pool.
35:59 Are you mandated to have a dial-a-ride service subject to your funding? Is that something you have to have? We're mandated by the Americans with Disabilities Act to provide paratransit service to individuals who cannot use fixed drought service. And the dial-a-ride service meets that requirement during those times. And in fact, we're mandated during all hours that we're operating fixed drought service.
36:25 It's just that outside of our normal, or the hours that we operate dial ride service, we would have to make special arrangement to bring somebody in to get the vehicle to accommodate that trip request, as opposed to just having dial ride in service that can respond to that. Got it. Okay. Thank you. There we go. We're connected. The lake space, in my mind, it's
36:59 Really a no-brainer. We have a number of people, I don't know, staff, number of campsites up in the Lakes Basin offhand. Okay. It's substantial, to say the least. And here's a large group of our visitor population that
37:30 have basically set up camp and sometimes are using their vehicles that they came in to as a part of their camp, i.e. fifth wheel or something of that nature. So it becomes a real deterrent for them to unhook everything and get in a vehicle and come back into town for things. But I believe this is a
38:02 You know, potential source of revenue for the town of Mammoth Lakes and sales tax and restaurant and retail and other types of fees, movies, things of this nature. I think it would be a real short sighted not to pursue that solution of creating more available transportation.
38:32 from the lakes basin down to Mammoth. So that follows into the later hours into the evenings. I'm sure it would be well received to be able to take a trolley and come down to a special event, enjoy yourself, have a few adult beverages, and not get back into a vehicle to drive back up the hill. So all of these things are
39:04 I think very exciting, especially when we look at the meager beginnings of our transportation program and our feet first program. It's actually happening, and anything that would give it more momentum, then I'm certainly behind that. Thank you. Very good. So I just had, one, I also concur that our lake basin trolley system is probably our highest priority.
39:35 On the wish list, I just wanted to know, has there been any further discussion about having a backup system from our airport to LAX when the planes don't fly? I mean, I know there was some perfect discussion, I just don't know where we stand on that situation. There has been some limited discussion regarding that, and I can't remember all the...
40:01 The detail that we either went into or didn't. I remember it came up at one of the previous commission meetings. There are a number of very significant hurdles for Eastern Sierra Transit to provide that type of service, not least of which is basically we are precluded from operating any charter service as in related to the funding that we receive, the federal funding we receive.
40:31 That's one big factor. Another big factor is we're just not well positioned to do that. Our vehicles aren't the best vehicles to be making that type of long distance trip with large numbers of people. An over-the-road coach type vehicle, restroom equipped, etc., that charter coach companies operate would be much better suited to that. The problem is there isn't such a company that's based in eastern Sierra at this time.
41:01 So, that's, that in a nutshell is the discussion that has taken place, which is, in a perfect world, it would be great if ESTA or somebody else was here that could do that, but real world today, these are some real world issues that Eastern Sierra Transit would face trying to address that need. So that, so, just to be clear, so it's not even on your wish list then?
41:30 I mean, so, I mean, I'm sure it has to be in somebody else's bucket in the town. I'm just not quite sure. Yes? I can answer something to you. I mean, in terms of just going to Los Angeles, there's a company called Mammoth All-Weather Shuttle. I'm sorry, you're going to have to come to the mic. There are at least two charter companies in the town of Mammoth Lakes. One of them, Mammoth All-Weather Shuttle, used to have a 12-passenger van.
41:55 They've doubled their capacity, and they do work closely with the airlines, so when there is a cancellation and people want to get to Los Angeles or even Reno, depending, passengers are given the opportunity, they can either rebook on another flight, spend another day, and some of them want to leave then, and then the airlines usually direct them to Mammoth, all other shuttle, or one of the other shuttle charter companies, or they have the option of renting a car. Maybe I can...
42:24 You know, continue to work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism and whatnot to make that more available. Most of the people who are leaving are finding out about this from the airline when they're rebooking. So maybe making it a little bit more public what the options are before it's actually an emergency is something we can work on a little bit. But there are actually some alternatives. And I know that Mammoth Lakes Tourism and John Urdi have worked a little bit on the diversion to Reno, which has been, I think, you know, a work in progress, but at least it was an option that we're providing. Right. Okay.
42:54 Thank you. And you probably do want to work with them on making the notification of the alternative public, right? Yeah, I think it's something we're working towards. Yeah, I think just maybe getting out a little bit ahead of time before it's sort of an emergency situation for most of these people. The people that are at the terminal are being pretty well redirected by the airline staff. Right. Thank you. Thank you. And then,
43:23 The next thing that, and this is probably a couple years out, but I attended a meeting the other day of the Sherwin Recreation Area, and you know, they're working on their NEPA for a couple of trails, and there's going to be this significant trail, I don't know if you know or not, through the Mammoth Metal, and ultimately hooking to the Mammoth Creek Park, but the main parking lot for that will be where we call our Propane Tank Farm Now.
43:53 And this is going to be a multi-use trail, so it's going to be hard for bicycles, wheelchair accessible. So when I was sitting in the meeting, one of the thoughts I had is, well, we better plan in a couple years from now, because I can just see this, because it's going to be a beautiful area through that whole back meadow. This is going to become our next...
44:12 Big tourist attractions. So, I mean, this is way down on your wish list, but I just think it's good that we start thinking about that because it will happen, I'm sure, someday. Okay, good for me to know. Nice to know, yeah. And then the last thing is, since we're having another blissful winter, has there been any talk about abbreviating the schedule?
44:37 Well, after this weekend? Actually, one change has already gone into effect, and it's somewhat seamless. Two weeks ago, the yellow line, which operates between the village and Juniper Springs Resort, scheduled to operate on a 20-minute frequency, was merged in with the orange line, which operates between the village and Tamarack, and they operate that now with one bus, and in fact, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area is operating that combined route.
45:07 on a 60-minute or one-hour frequency. That is the only change that has gone into place at this time, and again, that was two weeks ago. At the time of that meeting with Mammoth Mountain Skiria staff, I left the meeting and they said, this is status quo through President's Day weekend and then we'll reassess. President's Day weekend is this coming weekend, so I don't know, we'll see.
45:33 And I think my only concern about that is how we notify the public. And I'm sure we'll work on that. Right. And I don't know that there are any changes, but we'll see. But I appreciate your comment there, and we'll do our best to make sure that the notifications do get out. All right. Thank you. And I just need to see, is there anybody in the audience that would like to make any comments about our mobility plan? If not...
46:02 I might have one more quick question, and I don't know if this is for John or for Sandra, but the issue with the Red Fur turnaround, is that forever sealed, or is that something we can readdress down the road, or? Yeah, go ahead. Regarding Red Fur, I have brought this up with Brady Dutton, the new Public Works Director. He would like to do a couple things.
46:33 One is look at the existing turnaround, which we actually had modified to begin with so that the cutaways could turn around there. That didn't exist as it was. We fixed that so they could do that. To look at that again to see if it's possible to have a trolley turn around there. And I think he's not averse to perhaps bringing up the whole red fir thing again, although I don't know if it was... There was no...
46:58 There was not a lot of support from the community along Redford to have the trolleys run down that street. So we are going to be looking at the two possible alternatives, widening the turnaround and perhaps even going down that road. Thank you, Brian. Thank you.
47:19 I'm sorry, I just reminded myself. I would make a comment on the record or to the public that we are conducting outreach meetings throughout Mono County in the next month as a portion of our unmet needs hearing process and that will culminate in the final unmet needs hearing held by the Mono County LTC Local Transportation Commission at their April meeting. So that's upcoming. Thank you very much. Thank you.
47:49 I just have one more thing as well in terms of evaluating the service or the ridership and what transit brings to our town. And one of the things we would like to do is conduct a survey of passengers who are deplaning. Do they use the shuttles and the trolleys and to what extent? And also to try to figure out if there was a way to do it. Would they be interested in public transportation? Under what circumstances would it make sense to them?
48:19 If you're getting off an aircraft with skis and luggage, you don't want to get dropped off at the McDonald's parking lot. You really need to go point to point, and that's kind of one of the issues with public transportation at the airport. But we are developing a questionnaire, which we hope to get down there to try to, how much are they using public transportation when they get here, once they get off the plane, and under what circumstances might that be made available to them. I don't know what cave I've been living in, but there's no shuttle that goes from the airport to the various...
48:49 Hotels and things? No, those, currently, that's all handled by private shuttles, the ski area. Like the Western has one? Yes. And then it's either that or taxi service or a fair number of people bring, you know. But in most big cities, there's a shuttle that goes from hotel to hotel to hotel and you just. Well, all of our major hotels actually have their own shuttles which they're using. So what we're, what we're missing, if we're missing anything, is the people who are going to remote.
49:18 Condominium units. And, yeah, you can get up to town and then all the transportation in town is free, but if you have luggage, if you have gear, you're not going to want to get dropped off somewhere. You're going to want to go to your destination. So it's something that I just want you to know it's on our radar. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. We'll now close that business matter and we'll move to our next one, which is the draft housing strategy workshop.
49:50 Thank you, Chair Brown. The purpose of this item is to provide the public and the commission an opportunity to provide comment on the draft housing strategy. The strategy will serve as an implementation toolkit to meet the short and long-term needs of Mammoth Lakes workforce. It utilizes data from a 2011 housing needs assessment, the housing element update from 2014,
50:18 and a bilingual housing needs survey that was completed in 2014. As described in the housing element, the strategy includes a broad range of activities and programs and provides for periodic updates based on new data and changing conditions. The strategy identifies five objectives and includes specific strategies, funding sources, responsible agencies, and measures of success for those strategies.
50:47 The five objectives are rent and mortgage reduction, promote home ownership, develop a home repair program, increase housing stock, and reach out and educate. As we get into the discussion, Mammoth Lakes Housing will provide an overview of each of those objectives. Last month, the town council met after this housing strategy was published. They provided staff with direction to update our housing ordinance, and in that ordinance,
51:17 To not mandate inclusionary or on-site housing, but rather include that as an option available to developers for housing mitigation. Therefore, there are some pieces referring to our inclusionary policy in the strategy that may need to be updated to reflect that direction. And then lastly, in your staff report, we do identify a preliminary schedule for public outreach and steps toward approval of the strategy.
51:46 In there we noted that we would come back to the commission in April to recommend approval of the strategy to council. However, we expect that we can probably come back to you next month in March at your next meeting with any edits incorporated from your meeting today and have you make a recommendation to council at that point. So I think with that our intent to structure this discussion is just to receive any
52:14 Maybe general questions from you first and then Mammoth Lakes Housing can walk through each objective and those associated strategies individually so we can talk about them one by one. I would just like to add another objective that I'd like to talk about as a commission and that was expanding the definition of workforce housing which was on page two of the report. So I think it'd be easier if we did all our general questions and then we could use that as one of our objectives.
52:44 So we would just go then to each objective talk about objective and move on to the next. Okay. I have a general. Yeah, we'll do the general questions first. Okay. Okay. Jen, I wasn't clear from reading this what the process is. Who determines the priorities for these strategies? Is it Mammoth Lakes Housing working with staff, Mammoth Lakes Housing working with the Planning Commission? How does that work? I read page two and I just wasn't sure what the process was.
53:13 I think right now the strategy is, the programs and the strategy that are prioritized right now are the ones that have funding. I mean, I think that's kind of our kind of simple steps at this point, but I think when we can get direction from commission and council through this process, we can be able to see which strategies that may not be funded may rise to the top, and then we can search for funding for those strategies. Thank you. Do you have any questions at this time?
53:50 So I want to just discuss a couple points. So is it easier to talk about the page number of the packet or the page number of the report? What would be your preference? I think the page number of the strategy is probably easiest, but you can refer to both. Okay. So the first, this is page 28 of the report, page 28 of your staff report, page 20, all right, page 28 of the
54:21 Staff report page 14 of the strategy. I'm thinking. Is this page intentionally left blank? No, no, no, wait. So, go on. So page 14, 15 of attachment number one, the strategy draft. Is that where we are? We're right here. Future housing debaters. It should be your packet page 28. And your report 14. Got it. 28.
55:19 We're all on the same page. So this question, my first question is for Sandra on this. As you know in our other work, especially on our current work that we're doing in analysis of FAR, we have established a planning period. And I believe the planning period is 20 years.
55:44 It seemed to me that when I was reading through this that we just talked about future housing demand, but we didn't really talk about a planning period. And maybe you can comment on why in the FAR we did a 20-year? So in the FAR we looked a lot at theoretical build-out versus build-out, complete build-out. So I think the 20-year plan is at
56:12 Build out within the planning period, not looking at this theoretical build out where every single site might be built to the fullest capacity. So that's why we were looking at the 20 year planning period. Plus it's kind of a standard among cities to look at a certain, you know, section in time. And the intent is that the general plan is a living document and you, you know, continue to update, continue to look at these numbers because there's no way we can predict.
56:39 What's going to happen in 20 years, you know, for sure. So we would continue to look at that as we move through. Is that, was that what you were looking for? So, and then am I correct that the way this housing strategy is currently written, we didn't do any kind of limitation on it. It was just like all potential future development.
56:57 I think that's what this shows here, but I think the intent of the housing strategy is that it's going to be updated every two years, right? So it'll be also a living document, but much more updated than the general plan. So we would be updating this as we move forward. So once the FAR work is complete, we'll be probably soon after that completing another update to this so it can reflect any changes that occur as part of that process.
57:24 I just feel that it's really important that to use something that came from a 2009 PAOT document where it talks about a potential 15,817 development units.
57:40 It doesn't really fairly represent where we stand today as a community. I really, if my fellow commissioners agree, would really like to ask staff before you come back that we evaluate that number and either put that number, I mean, you know, I don't know if you want to do it. I can tell you what the number would be in a two-year time frame, but I mean, give us a time frame and then tell us what a number is. Realistically, considering that
58:10 Other than for John Hooper's developments, we have no sticks in the ground right now. I personally would say in five years, I don't know, well let's say in three years we stand a zero chance of any development units being built and completed up and running. Five years, you know, maybe you have a couple hundred, and in ten years, I think in a ten year period,
58:38 You know, maybe we're only looking at the total number of additional workforce. If in 10 years, if we had five new projects that each had 250 rooms, I mean, we would be really ecstatic as a community. So I feel that it's really important that we all come to agreement as a commission, as council, with Mammoth Lakes Housing, what is that number going to be?
59:06 I personally think maybe a 10-year frame might be a good time frame because that's basically the next cycle. I mean, by then we'll probably be into a different cycle. So if everybody agrees with that, I would like to ask the staff before you come back, we really evaluate what that number is. Yes. Yeah, I'm comfortable with that. That's good. Okay. And then I would like to go to local challenges.
59:36 Which is page 18 of the report. So underneath local challenges, there's a couple of things that we've discussed before and I really think it would behoove us to put in this report and that is the age of our housing stock. As we've talked about before, in our condominium market, 74% of our condominium market is older than 25 years.
1:00:13 And a lot of those condominiums when they were originally built in the 60s and the 70s were built very substandard even in those times. And so they're even farther out of being in compliance with code today. And so it just has to be here as a local challenge. And so I would really encourage you to add a paragraph.
1:00:39 about the housing stock. I sent you a little summary that you can use, and if you have any questions, we can, you know, talk about that in greater detail. And then, as we discussed, you know, I personally believe our biggest limitation challenge for housing is our land and the fact that we have no down valley. But to me, the
1:01:07 The zoning limitations in themselves wasn't a challenge. It's the combination of the limited land and the zoning limitations. And so perhaps it would make better sense to combine those two paragraphs. Are you following what I'm saying on that? Can I? Yes. Oh, absolutely. Because this is a workshop, so just jump in any time you want. Well, I just want to talk a little bit about the zoning because
1:01:36 You know, I did a little more research on that today, looking at the housing element update that was just updated in June. And they ran some figures on the cost per square foot in the different zones. And that does create challenges because the land in an RMF2 is exorbitantly more expensive than land in RMF1. And that does create challenges.
1:02:04 When you think about developing affordable housing, which doesn't create, or workforce housing doesn't create a lot of income, and so you can't spend a lot of money on the land and still reap the community benefit of having workforce housing. And then there's also, I believe, and I don't know this figure, but there's not as much land in Mammoth zoned RMF1 than there is zoned RMF2.
1:02:32 So I think the zoning does create that land challenge, exacerbates that land challenge a little bit. Well, okay, so this was my problem in reading it. I couldn't quite get the tie. And so maybe it's the way we describe our words. If we were a town of 100 square miles, it wouldn't be the issue as it is because we're in this compressed environment.
1:03:01 But I have a little bit of a problem saying, well, we have a challenge because of the way our zoning is because the zoning was such a well-vetted process in our general plan process. So, I mean, it's not something I feel really strongly about, but it's just something that I just didn't, I couldn't quite get the initial tie when reading it. So we might just want to work on that a little bit. Yes. Okay. Okay. I don't know. Yes. Did you have any other comments about that? Okay.
1:03:30 And then I also believe that the other local challenge that we need to add in here is the monthly association dues or the mobile home space rentals. And a good resource would be Butner and Associate. I mean, I think they would share it with you. I know that they have done compilations in the past of all HOA monthly dues.
1:03:58 And then as Patricia said, you know, there's a direct component between the amount of monthly dues and what somebody's income. And just as a little bit of background for my other commissioners is for years there was this philosophy in Mammoth, okay, we're going to hold our monthly dues down low. And if we do that, then our project will appear attractive.
1:04:22 You know, it will help us sell better. But what happened is, is we severely, in a lot of these complexes, shorted our funds, and the reserve funds. And now, they have to, by statute, those reserve funds have to cash flow. So you have complexes that are one bed rest for their monthly HOA dues now are $1,000 a month. So... Did it also affect their maintenance funds?
1:04:50 By having a low HOA. Right, so they're, yeah, but it's basically the reserve funds to do their ongoing maintenance are shortchanged. It's a pretty universal problem in Mammoth, and I do think that we really need to put that as a challenge. And then on transient rentals, my feeling is that transient rentals is both a challenge and an asset.
1:05:17 It's something that moves on either side of the equation depending upon the type of winter we're having. In a winter of high visitation, obviously transient rentals are very popular. In a winter of lower visitation, like we had last winter, like we may be having this winter, then what happens is that it actually becomes a better
1:05:43 financial situation for the people to do long-term wells. So, and I don't know if anybody has any other feedback. I just don't think it goes one way or the other. I think it can be on both sides of the equation. I guess my thought on that is that I think it's a challenge to
1:06:01 The workforce for housing. And I think the benefit you're describing isn't to the workforce, though. And this is the housing strategy for the workforce. So I'm not sure that it's a benefit to the workforce when that housing stock leaves. Unless, chances are, I think, that in the climate, the economic climate where
1:06:22 Right, but then it needs to say that in certain times, okay, because right now,
1:06:52 And, you know, it's, in this current market, in this current winter, I mean, it would be relatively easy compared to other winters to go out and to rent a place because there's just not the seasonal rentals for the demand. So I think there has to be some sort of caveat. It's not every year transient rentals are a negative to the housing force.
1:07:16 Right. But anybody looking for a long-term rental right now would say that it's a tight market for rentals, for them, for the workforce. Even now, in this non-appealing time for transient rental, it's, you know, we're still hearing from people that it's hard to find rentals for long-term. Well, I think maybe we just need to really, to track that, because what I see is
1:07:41 You know, in my day-to-day business is that more and more people now are renting their places out long term because of the financial advantages to that versus being on a nightly rental program. So. Okay. All right. So that, those were my comments about challenges. Did anybody else have any comments about challenges? Okay. Did any?
1:08:10 Since there's only the two of you out here, did either of you, Tom or Chuck, did either, you want to comment on the challenge section? We'll just go through one section at a time. Or would you like to wait? Okay. And then assets, I have to apologize. I currently, I'm a little like, the internet's a little slow here. Electrically challenged.
1:08:56 And then the point I really just want to make about assets is that I think we should explicitly talk really about what an asset the potential shady rest parcel could be and the fact that those people are really very motivated to sell that land. So because it gives us a wonderful opportunity now if the town wanted to go out
1:09:29 Buy a substantial piece of property to serve for their future housing needs, that we probably would have a good opportunity to do it. And I can't give you any reference because I have nothing, unfortunately, but a blank screen. So I have three Verizon bars. I'm not quite sure what happened here to this. So I may have to. Just expound upon it being an asset, a potential asset to the community. Yes. Absolutely. Okay.
1:10:02 All right. So those were my main points. I know we talked about some minor points about running our current median prices, et cetera, through 1231. I'm sure that that's all perfect. Okay. So that was my comments about the report. Did anybody else have any comments or questions about the report itself? I just, hello? Okay. Just saw a folded down corner. I was fascinated with this survey.
1:10:38 On page 55 of the report, figure 10, what types of housing will be needed in the future as Mammoth grows? And 22% said larger homes. What demographic was that? All survey respondents. 22% said larger homes. Larger than what bedroom? As part of the survey, we didn't collect data on what type of unit the residents currently were residing in.
1:11:13 So it could be somebody who was in a very – It could be a family in a studio. Got it. Okay. Well, if I may. Yes. One of the – a lot of data in the report, and I guess I wasn't real comfortable with a lot of the data across – with the cross-sections using comparables. I don't –
1:11:48 The one area in describing the cost of RMF 1, RMF 2, I don't know exactly where those numbers are coming from as being explained as a high, one being such a high cost over the other. Is that historical data or is that real-time data? Oh, that's from the housing element.
1:12:19 And that was based on that consultant's work, and I believe they got that information, I just read it today, but I'm pretty sure it was from the assessor's office. Oh, that's, I think that needs to be looked at, you know, quite a bit closer. Well, that was just anecdotal, that's not in here, that's, yeah, it wasn't in this document. Yeah. I wanted to answer Commissioner Tenney's question.
1:12:53 There's a history in our country of people coming here to work from other countries and typically how that would happen, and we've seen this in all our major metropolitan areas, if you will, is that they will come and stay with family or friends or others of their nationality.
1:13:23 And when someone gets here, as you can imagine, we've all heard the stories, you know, grandfather showed up with $10 in his pocket at Ellis Island and the first thing he did was ran out and found some relatives, rented a room and went to work and pretty soon he would make enough money to move on to the next level. And there's a...
1:13:52 There's a similarity in Mammoth here, and that is that in our particular case at the Swiss Chalet, we had a wonderful couple that came here from Mexico, and this was 20 years ago, and they came 20 years prior, and they stayed with relatives in a three-bedroom home. There's basically three families in a three-bedroom home.
1:14:22 And the more they worked, they were able to get themselves to a position that they could get a place on their own, which they did. And before you know it, they had cousins that were coming, and they were doing the same thing. So the larger home is an evolution of something that's happened a long, long time here in America.
1:14:51 One of the things that we forget is that many people do come here as families. There are also others that come as individuals, and a studio or a one-bedroom seems to fit them just fine. It's that smaller, inexpensive facility that they're looking for. But the 22% number did not faze me at all.
1:15:23 Point well taken. Yeah. Yeah, back to what we were discussing earlier. The, there just seems to be in this report a tremendous amount of reference to data and I'm not, I had a hard time reading through it comparing where that
1:15:56 Where that data was coming from and what it was actually explaining. And one of the things I had a hard time with was a number of the charts. And I guess this would be page 45 of the packet, 44 and 45. There were some questions.
1:16:44 asked, and we had English responses, we had Spanish responses, and I didn't necessarily see the very same questions, and then I noticed on the Spanish response there was more than one option, and I'm assuming that that was not included in the English response, is that correct?
1:17:22 Which response is it that you're not seeing in English? Oh, I see. Yeah. The footnote on the source. In the English survey, most respondents took the survey online, which would prevent you from choosing more than one option, whereas in the Spanish survey, it was mostly hard copies passed in, in which case a lot of the respondents wrote down three or four of their choices, because they weren't prevented from...
1:17:55 From choosing only one. Okay. And then on the following page in figure five, what types of housing related assistance may be of interest to you? Again, the assumption I'm left with is was this a separate question or was this information gleaned from the other two surveys?
1:18:30 This was a separate question, and both English and Spanish respondents could select all that applied. Okay. Well, I think there may be a better way of translating that information to the reader. Just exactly how to do it, I wouldn't be able to tell you from the dais here. We could provide some clarifying text, do you think? I think that would be good.
1:19:09 a bit better to understand. And then the, and then when you go into figure number six from the 2011 responses, were these the same questions as the 2014 or am I
1:19:36 No. Yeah. Yeah, and the footnote says the source was the 2011 needs assessment, which was a separate needs assessment done in English and Spanish as well, but that was done by a consultant RRC Associates, whereas the 2014 housing element survey was done locally. Okay. So this set of data translates to a conclusion?
1:20:04 It translates to the strategies. And that is to workforce housing strategy continuum? Yes, exactly. Okay. I would just suggest that you take a very strong look at that and see if there may be a simpler way of conveying that information to where it becomes more specific to the results of each one of those surveys. And I may have
1:21:23 Miss this in the reading, but it says here in the 2014 survey, 19 people provided 38 comments. And what was the whole base? This is on page 51. What was the total number of surveyed? We received, I want to say, 100 English surveys total and 44, roughly 44 Spanish, completed Spanish paper surveys.
1:22:09 And what percentage was that out of the whole population that you were surveying? Well, we opened it up to anybody in the community. I mean, we weren't selective. Okay, so the entire population could have gotten online and done that. The Spanish ones, we worked with the Hispanic Advisory Committee through the MLPD and their members to distribute paper surveys to the Hispanic population because that was really our only way. We only received two online Spanish.
1:22:37 Yeah. Surveys. So that was our best way to get some input. The difficulty in a small population area, I understand that. Yeah. So these 19 people provided 38 comments. We'll double check that and make sure that's accurate. Oh, okay. It just, do you see where I'm getting at here? It doesn't really seem like that's enough for the community to really
1:23:08 Take that and say, okay, I understand that you have to work with what you've got. Yeah. But at the same time, sometimes that doesn't really equate to what reality might be. And I don't think we talked about the responses that we've got through our 2011 needs assessment, but that was a much more extensive outreach. That was a, I think it took six months for us to do.
1:23:38 to complete that needs assessment because we hired a consultant, RRC Associates. They did Spanish-English surveys. They talked with members, employers, employees. They rode transit systems and talked with people on site. And we didn't really talk about the number of responses we got there, but we did see
1:24:04 Consistency between that needs assessment in 2011 and then our, even though it's small, but our feedback we got from the survey was, it wasn't as if there was huge variances between 2011. They were very consistent. So we feel like it's still relevant feedback. I don't know if that assures you in any way because the 2011 needs assessment was so comprehensive. Well, I think
1:24:34 Perhaps you can just look at the way the information is presented and maybe you need to write an introductory paragraph of basically what you just said so that as a reader then we can tie it all together. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So for clarification, weatherization seemed to be an important topic for many of those surveyed. And
1:25:10 Was this in the 2011 survey as well? Yeah, low entry for you. Okay, and my question in regards to the weatherization is, I believe I read that you were working with IMACA with the weatherization program? We have been trying to work with IMACA. They're under new director. Okay, and how much?
1:26:08 How much was spent on weatherization between 2011 and this year? I would have to ask IMACA for that information. I don't know. Okay. That would be good to have that cleared up because in reading through this, I was left with the impression that many of your surveyors felt they were living in units that needed weatherization. Right.
1:26:40 If it was addressed in 2011, it would be good to see what had been done in that respect up until now. Okay. The other thing, and I believe Jen alluded to it, and that is that the report has, and the strategy has many references to inclusionary.
1:27:19 and in listening to the council previously it sounded to me as though the council was going the direction of maybe keeping the inclusionary as something in the toolbox but not making that the law, the code.
1:27:51 That's where you start, is that you have to have inclusionary housing. I don't, after having heard this from the council, I would certainly not want to present to them a report that that's not real clear and reflective of what their wishes were with regards to inclusionary housing. Okay.
1:28:37 I think that's about it. And I will finish with sharing with you that, yes, indeed, doing a survey of that nature is very difficult when you have a small population. I get it. I understand that. But it's really difficult as we go through this process when we're using
1:29:10 A lot of data from a lot of different sources and then combining that to come up with a finished product. And I'm always concerned about that because we may in fact have misleading information when we're using so many different sources of information. I'll just leave it with that. Thank you.
1:29:46 My Verizon bars are caught up in my thought process. If we can go back to community assets, which is page 21 of the housing report. So the point I was making about Shady Rest is I think that there needs to be an expanded comment on there that there may be an opportunity to purchase that parcel due to the fact that it's been...
1:30:18 Taking back through foreclosure, there's a large group of a number of investors that are looking for an alternative means to do something with it. So we should just put some sort of comment in there that there's definitely a possibility that we should be looking at right now. Can I ask a quick question on that? Shady Risk Tract, are there development restrictions on the seven acres of wetland that go through that?
1:30:40 The Shady Rest Master Plan talks about there being open space within the master plan. It doesn't specifically delineate the wetland. Okay. But there are state, federal regulations about disturbing wetlands, stream corridors, things like that. So in all likelihood, it would be preserved in some manner of passive park space or open space. Thank you.
1:31:02 And then I think in terms of shady rest, we do have a specific action item related to shady rest, so maybe we can talk about comments there. And then the other item that I think needs to be mentioned or needs community assets, although it depends on how you look at it, certainly a double-edged sword, but our medium price of our product has dropped so substantially. So for example, in 2006, the medium price of a condominium was $550,000.
1:31:31 And now we're looking at a medium price of $290,000. So that certainly changes the entry point for people's workforce housing as far as what they can purchase. And you had not as dramatic of a drop in single family homes, but in 2007 it was $900,000 versus what we're at $600,000 now. So I think we definitely need to say that as a result.
1:31:57 of the recession, that the median prices have dropped, and they've dropped substantially. I mean, you're looking at 40-some percent. Right. We could make a mention of that. While that's not a controlled, something we can control and predict into the future currently, that's the situation. Right. And this is my personal issue. I mean, this is a really key document, and this is a document that I believe that we'll be using to make a lot of future decisions.
1:32:26 And my struggle with it when we read it is that I feel like we've taken a lot of information like from 2005, 2006, which was a totally different marketplace than we have now, and we just kind of keep rolling it forward with the hopes, well, this is where we're going to go back. And the reality is there is no going back to 2005, 2006 in this planning period. So we really need to make sure that all our assumptions
1:32:54 Today, really represent where we stand today in making our decisions. As we all know, workforce housing is hugely important, but it has to be realistic. And that's where I kind of struggle with the report in general, is that you make a lot of statements in the report, there's a lot of interesting information, but as with Commissioner Harvey, I really struggle where you take that information and the conclusions you...
1:33:23 that are reached, and I can't always tie your conclusions to the information. I would concur. Just to touch further on what Chair Brown was referring to with the shady rest parcel, anybody that's paying attention to our real estate market understands very readily
1:33:57 That here is a piece of property that is zoned. It's teed up and ready to go for affordable housing. And I was a bit disappointed that I didn't read more in our document here about how we would pursue that or the possibilities that exist to pursue. That one piece of land
1:34:28 holds a tremendous amount of potential for solving the number, whatever that number may be, of our affordable housing demand. And I can't think of another time in the last 20 years when the real estate cost would be lower. And as you stated earlier, it typically is the real estate cost.
1:35:00 that prohibits the building of affordable housing. We understand that. But we have this incredible, incredible opportunity that is staring us in the face and it was just, it was curious to me as to why we weren't capitalizing on that in some strategy methods called out in the document itself.
1:35:29 Yeah, I think it is listed as one of the goals in the strategy, but not in pros in the table. Yeah, I would definitely make it front and center. We have a council that's looking for solutions. They're looking for ways to solve the different needs in the community, affordable housing certainly being very high on their list.
1:35:58 I would want to give them all of the pertinent information that we could in this report. Thanks. All right. If we had no other comments about the report itself, we'll go down the list of objectives. Thank you, Chair Brown. So the first objective is on page 48 of the commission packet, and it's number 34 of the strategy. And so this one is for rent and mortgage reduction. And I'll hand it over to...
1:36:31 Jennifer? Yeah. So the rent and mortgage reduction, again, these strategies, these came from the 2011 and the 2014 survey needs assessment work that we did in the community. The strategies, all five of them, they rose to the top from those surveys. And they're not in any particular order. They're not prioritized.
1:37:04 I think it's important as we move forward that we stay as a community opportunistic to those options as they come forward, whether it's grant funding being available, whether it's the shady rest parcel becoming available, whether it's in lieu fees, whatever those are.
1:37:25 That we have to stay opportunistic. And so each of those strategies is important. And one may be more viable at one time than another. So they're just listed here but not in priority. So I just want to emphasize that. And I think that's mentioned also in the document. The rent and mortgage reduction, there was an overwhelming response from the community that they needed to reduce. They wanted to reduce the cost of their rents and their mortgages. There's roughly 58 percent.
1:37:55 of Mammoth's residents experience some degree of cost burdenness related to housing. So that's a lot. House cause, that could include utilities, but 56% is a large percentage of our population. And so therefore, we've proposed three different objectives to help curb
1:38:24 The housing costs, rent and mortgage. One of them being tenant-based rental assistance, which is a federal program that we haven't ever used in the town, but is available through the home program. Another one being rental restrictions and regulatory agreements, and so what that does, those we use on properties where we get grant funds through CDBG Home.
1:38:52 Or we could even use local funds if we wanted to target higher incomes than those programs require to restrict the rents that you can charge on properties. And so that creates an affordability right there because if rents are affordable to a certain target income group, then you know they're not cost burdened.
1:39:15 And then the other one is resale restrictions. Those require properties to be priced below market rate and therefore more affordable to the local workforce because they are priced below market rate. I don't know if you have any thoughts on any of those objectives. Is there any comments on objective number one? Yeah, I've got a quick question. What was the reason the first strategy was never explored?
1:39:53 Oh, the 1A, the TPRA? It's, well, I think it had to do with several things. One, being very busy doing development when we first started, because I think, I remember when I started in 2006, it was something we talked about, and we didn't have the capacity to start a new program. It's labor intensive. And then I think we have been, we've been short staffed. We've got two of us, and we haven't gone out and applied for those grants and started that program.
1:40:23 So it was nothing philosophical, it was more of a manpower? Yeah, I think so. I think that's the case. Thank you. Was there any other comments regarding Objective 1? Nope. Okay, can we move to Objective 2, please? Okay. Promote homeownership, 41% of the respondents felt that affordability of the housing stock in Mammoth is out of reach for them. So we've made some, we have some programs that
1:40:59 Through the state and the federal programs that address the low income segment of our house households in Mammoth and then there is one program that we have through the state that does assist folks households in the middle income group but nothing above that and and we're seeing that the state and federal funds are shrinking year over year I think that's happening throughout the country and so as those shrink up I think we need to look for alternative ways to assist
1:41:29 Our workforce in purchasing homes. And so we go through these objectives here under strategy number two, such things as securing local funding to help folks at 81% and above where we have either none or very limited down payment assistance for folks.
1:41:55 Plan to continue seeking out first-time homebuyer funds that we've been very successful at in the town. Seeking out grants to help with the financing of manufactured housing through the Cal Home Program is another objective. And then to continue to ensure that we maintain our deed restricted units in addition. So all of those tools would allow us to...
1:42:30 To create affordable home ownership opportunities. Is there any comment about this objective? My only comment about this is that, once again, the lending market is changing substantially. There's all sorts of variety of different products out there for our borrowers, and I think education of those different products would be really important. If you use the Mammoth Lakes multiple listing as a source,
1:43:01 It reports that only one person out of all the transactions in 2014 did an FHA loan. I mean, you wonder if it's, it could be, maybe the information wasn't reported right, but it just, it could be a really an education thing. So I think it'd be really important just to make sure we educate and stay current on all the different varieties of financing options there are. Yeah, I think FHA lending is hard in Mammoth, but I think...
1:43:27 Because of our condo supply. I think that we could put that perhaps under objective five. Okay. All right. I think that's great. Objective three. Okay. Objective three, develop a home repair program. And so this really gets back to the heart of the issue with our older housing stock. Mammoth has typically very harsh winters, and we have older housing stock.
1:43:58 According to our report, 60% of our housing stock was built prior to 1979, according to the census, and 45% was built between 70 and 1979. And I mentioned earlier, energy costs are a big part of what makes up a household's monthly housing costs, and so if we can do programs, implement programs, offer programs that curb the costs.
1:44:28 of households every month on their energy utility costs, then I think we could be really helping them in the long run. And so we've got owner-occupied rehab programs in our objectives. We've got investor rehabilitation programs, acquisition and rehabilitation, and then weatherization. We, the town has just actually received a grant.
1:44:54 For owner-occupied and investor rehab, we haven't gotten authority to use grant funds, but we're very close and we're hoping that that program's success is for low income, either low income tenants or low income owners, but it's a start and we'll continue seeking programs and funding for that. Acquisition and rehabilitation, again, those are usually grant funded.
1:45:24 And weatherization is typically administered by AMACA. Commissioner Harvey, are we short on some of the potential for weatherization? I mean, I know there's more than just grant money out there. There's all sorts of different funds, tax incentives. Well, there are. The PACE program that was brought to California about seven years ago and wound up in
1:45:59 In litigation with Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae has finally been sorted out and there are a number of financial arms, if you will, to the PACE program. One has been approved here in Mammoth, that's the HERO program. Their interest rates run about 6, 6.5 percent.
1:46:28 There is another that we spoke with here recently at a trade show. Their name is Y Green and they're a group of Citibank, ex-Citibank folks and they're coming out at 3% all in. So it's becoming a competitive market. We hope to bring them into the Mono County area.
1:47:00 The Y Green folks. And this is a program for homeowners that allows them, oh my gosh, it's something upwards of 500 different types of energy efficiency product as well as major energy products such as ground source heat pumps, solar.
1:47:31 Things of that nature. It goes right on into insulation, weatherization, star appliances that runs the gamut. So I think these are something that's well worth mentioning in the report. We've got a number of product out there right now. These folks are both residential and commercial.
1:48:01 So your properties would apply for those. It goes on to the tax bill. It gets paid twice a year. By law, by PACE regulation, the fee cannot be any more per year than what the current utilities are being assessed. So it's a very viable program.
1:48:31 I believe that it at least needs, you know, some research and mention in the report. Thanks. And then why wouldn't we include, like, town-sponsored programs? I mean, maybe you wouldn't want to say specifically the current program we have for replacement of wood-burning stoves, but, I mean, there's always ongoing programs, and I think we should make some sort of mention of those. Okay. Anybody else have any comments on that? Okay. And then...
1:49:03 Increase affordable housing stock. I have a question. I completely agree with Commissioner Harvey about the opportunity the Shady Rest Act represents. And this is a very worthy list of goals and objectives. It's very labor intensive. What is the capacity of Mammoth Lakes Housing to be nimble and take advantage of an opportunity to
1:49:34 Purchase property at, you know, maybe bargain basement prices. I don't know what, what that, what it would sell for, but certainly this might be the time in the market. So what's, what is, what is your capacity to be nimble or are you sort of locked into this and you don't have. Well, specifically on Shady Rest, I think we are nimble and I think we are exploring that opportunity or that option. So I think that we have the capacity.
1:50:03 I think we have the capacity to look into it and research it and evaluate it. Now, if it came to actually building and constructing, we would have to go beyond two people. Are there grants available for that? For purchase, to purchase them? Grants to purchase what? The land? No, not really.
1:50:23 Not of that size. The parcel's quite expensive compared to what grants are willing to do. State of California just released their Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities grant, which is funded through the cap-and-trade, and for example, that program only allows 10% of the funding to go towards the purchase of land, and the maximum grant you could get is $8 million, so not a lot. And how about grants for building the housing?
1:50:53 There are funding sources for that, and I think cap-and-trade funds could work for that. It focuses on mobility, and I think that with the right cooperation in the town to have bike paths and bus stops over there, that site could be very competitive. But it's a matter of securing the land, then going after, I think, the funding to build the product.
1:51:19 Because my personal priority list would put that one at the top on this page. So I would just like a clarification. When I talk about shady rests, I did not put control of shady rests parcel and Mammoth Lake Housing as the builder of the product. I mean, I don't see those necessarily as...
1:51:46 Tied together. I mean, I think there's a lot better ways to build a product than having Mammoth Lakes Housing doing it. But I think that's one thing is to control the land, and then the other thing is then you can determine how the product would ultimately be built out. So I just want to make sure that I had been confusing in those comments. And I think to even more clarify, this report is the guiding document that our council is going to follow in looking
1:52:15 towards solving the affordable housing issue. And although there are some things that it's appropriate that Mammoth Lakes Housing be very much involved in, there are probably other things that they may not be so much involved in, but the town council needs to understand what their opportunities are, being able to
1:52:45 for instance, control the 25 acres of shady rest will give them a seat basically at the table to negotiate with developers and with developers that do that kind of business, affordable housing and workforce housing business. Their set of investors are a totally different set of investors.
1:53:13 than the investors for a hotel, let's say, or a resort product that would be built here in Mammoth. And the importance of the council understanding they do have options is, I think, paramount with a report like this. All right. Was there any other comments? Any strategy four? Strategy five?
1:53:48 So on this one, we'll add lending as one of the topics of discussion. Did you reach out? Okay. All right. And then I'd like to hear some, if the commissioner's had any feedback about expanding our definition of workforce housing, which was at the beginning of the report. Hi. Yes. Yeah.
1:54:33 This particular subject was looked at back in the early 2000s when we were contemplating a Mammoth Lakes housing entity, if you will, and there was a long debate as to who workforce housing and affordable housing was really meant to be for, and
1:55:02 We have a very unique situation here, let's say as opposed to Los Angeles or maybe Fresno or some other metropolitan area. The idea was that, well, the low-hanging fruit for grants and funds and things were all for low and very low income. So that was the path that ultimately was taken.
1:55:34 The conundrum that we have here in Mammoth is that as the resort becomes successful and we have seen this in the ebb and tide of our real estate market, real estate can become unavailable even to middle income and even the lower portion of the upper income folks.
1:56:05 We didn't know it back at that time and no one was contemplating it, but we have a community now where certain employers, the town being one of them, has had to go out and create their own affordable housing programs and these are typically for people in middle to upper management.
1:56:33 Simply because of the cost that we ran into in the mid-2000s, it was just unbearable to get good help to leave wherever they may have been and to relocate here unless they got assistance, housing assistance. The mountain's done it, the town has done it, the water district, all of these entities. So we know that
1:57:03 That that is an issue. There's no question about it. I know that it talks in the report about doing some research about it. I would be so bold to say is that it's a problem and we need to address it and we need to create some kind of program or if there is a program out there we may need to find it. But that won't go away. I think we're in a period of time where
1:57:35 Housing values and land values, yes indeed they did go down, but they're coming back and we're going to be faced with those same issues and same problems. I would hate to see another two or three year study just to tell us what we already know. However we can address that and present it to council as an existing issue.
1:58:05 I think we would be benefiting ourselves to do that. Did you have any comments on that? No, I couldn't agree more heartedly with your points as a member of that demographic. I concur. All right. This is a workshop, so we're open to other comments. Would you like to make any comments? Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mount Skier. I have a question for staff.
1:58:50 I just want to make sure I understand the process that we're following with respect to this strategy as it relates to the housing mitigation ordinance. So as I'm reading the staff report here on page four, it says it's anticipated the final approved housing strategy will inform certain aspects of the housing ordinance and fee update. And I can certainly see why because there's a tremendous amount of data in here in this report and the strategy.
1:59:17 But, and then you set out the time frame of when you anticipate having these meetings. And I know there's been other discussions and other venues that the need to put in place new housing mitigation ordinance as quickly as possible because there are some large development transactions that are just starting getting in the works and these outside developers need certainty on what is going to be their potential burden for the mitigation cost down the road.
1:59:46 So I know I'm looking at this list here, it appears that you're going through a couple rounds of town council, planning commission, with the expectation to get to council in May to adopt this strategy. And then my presumption is that you expect that the housing mitigation ordinance would be approved subsequent to that.
2:00:11 So is that how you anticipate that? Because honestly, we're trying to get something in place by April is our goal for the housing ordinance. The housing ordinance update and fee update wouldn't have to happen subsequent to the strategy. We just see that there's going to be some interrelated data and information that may be used to inform in both ways. We actually anticipate going to council in April. Yeah, in April, is that what you said?
2:00:40 Well, for final approval, each say May. So I think we're actually going to bump that up a month. So the strategy we anticipate hopefully being at council for approval in April. But regardless, the schedule of the strategy won't affect the schedule of the housing ordinance update and fee update. Okay. So there's no mandate that this has to be approved before we can continue with the discussion on the housing ordinance. Okay. All right. Great. Well, a tremendous job.
2:01:10 Significant amount of information in here and as you guys alluded to, it can be a little confusing and overwhelming to try to distill all the numbers down to what's reality or what do we have to do, what are the action items, but I think you guys did a terrific job and I appreciate the effort that went in, Jennifer. That said, I did go through doing this and read it and gave it an honest pass and I want to provide you my feedback and I'll go as quickly as I can because I know it's not supposed to take a half an hour and we're already, you know, in the two hours into the meeting here.
2:01:39 So let's see here, real quick, I think, you know, maybe there should be a section we should add in this, and Mickey's mentioned a couple times, that just sort of mentions the general market conditions, because there's, I think if you take a step back and you look at this in the context of, you know, what is the build out, right, is one big question, and you guys have cited that 15,800 units have build out.
2:02:08 And it's interesting because I was starting to analyze that and say, okay, well, what does that translate into the number of units per year? And, you know, if you assume a 30-year planning time frame for that build out, that's 189 units per year starting today for every year for 30 years to get to that number of units. Probably not realistic, right? Because I've received some data from local realtors about what were the number of new units we brought online in the past building boom.
2:02:38 And for example, 2003, 150, 2004, 82, 2005, 137. These are new units that were sold. 2006, 127, 2007, 132. Those were our best years. That's when we were going fast and furious. And so in those five years, that was 628 new units that were absorbed in the market, 125 units per year average.
2:03:09 Was what that pace was. Since then, obviously with the recession, the numbers have dropped. 08, 58 units. 09, 53 units. 2010, 64 units. 2011, 23 units. Get ready for this. 2012, 3 units. 2013, 1. 2014, 4. So, you know, I guess the point is that, you know,
2:03:35 Right now the market is anemic, right? There's nothing happening. And so I think one of the commissioners pointed out, I was like, hey, we can't have these expectations that our pace of build out is back where we were in 2005, when we're going backwards right now. And I think you guys all recognize the strategy that you mentioned in the report as a two-year, maybe should be reassessed every couple of years, it's maybe a five-year document.
2:04:04 I just want to urge you to really be cautious as we start throwing numbers out there about what's really realistic in terms of build-out and how long it's going to take to get there based on where we've been, right? We know where we've been and we haven't been anywhere close to probably hitting those build-out numbers in a 30-year time frame. And this gets a little bit to when we start looking at mitigation and how we're going to achieve that.
2:04:31 You know, we just don't want to overask for what we need. I mean, we've got to be realistic about what we really need and make sure that the numbers, you know, this is as much an economic and financial exercise as it is about providing the right housing to the right people at the right time. I mean, it really is. You start digging into these numbers and you go, wow, I mean, it takes some serious concentration to filter through all this information and understand what the implications are. But I don't want, I mean, my concern is that we're throwing numbers out. Hey, we're going to be at, you know.
2:05:01 Build out in 20 years and we need about, you know, 1,200 new units and we've got to start collecting money to pay for that. I mean, whoa, whoa, whoa, it's not the case, you know, we're not even more close to that. So, and I think it's, if everybody understands, hey, we're going to revisit this on periodically and we're going to reassess where the market is and then we can always raise numbers later on if we need to. So, but starting out, we need to be thinking like, hey, we're...
2:05:27 We're starting with nothing. We shouldn't be asking for much more than nothing. It's how I see it. So I just wanted to point out that the realities of what build that is and how long a reality of that would take. By the way, so that 12 years from 03 to today through 14, 834 units at average, you know, with the boom years and the bust years were average 70 units per year of new units that came online. So just to give you an idea.
2:05:58 Okay, real quick here. I just, you know, I thought it's interesting. I know you guys included a lot of information from the housing element and, you know, this affordability cost gap summary table I think is extremely informative that I'm just pointing out here that, you know, it really, in purchasing a home, until you get to a three bedroom unit in the moderate income is where you have a gap.
2:06:26 And then, of course, actually, in the modern income range of 80 to 120 AMI for a one-bedroom, two-bedroom, there isn't even a gap right now of affordability. People can buy those homes that are in those income ranges. So, again, the sky isn't falling. People can buy stuff right now. It's not that much of a stretch, especially if they're going to get mortgage assistance. And there's absolutely no gaps in the 120 and above AMI.
2:06:55 And then the other thing, well, let me continue here real quick, because I think there's some misleading statements in here that would make you think that there's maybe a higher level of units that need to be provided when in fact there's not. Okay, so we already touched on this, I think you guys have it on page nine of the strategy that this develop an ongoing strategic approach, not a plan, since housing market is dynamic, we talked about that, it's not possible to create a static five or ten year
2:07:28 Approach, you know, we need to be, we need to be nimble, we need to reassess every couple years or whatever to how the market's going to, and then we, so I think it's, you guys made that point, I think that's an important point that needs to be maybe emphasized. Workforce housing and the definitions, Mickey mentioned this, so workforce housing just means anybody who lives in the community that's a member of the workforce.
2:07:56 That includes people who earn more than 120% AMI. And if you go to the tables of the breakdown, 32% of our workforce housing is owned by people who make more than 120% of AMI who have no need for affordable housing. So later here in the tables on page 14 of the workforce housing strategy, it makes mentions of what was in the housing element projection for the next five years of the number of
2:08:25 Workforce Housing Units is 74. Well, 32% of those are market rate units that aren't even, and arguably actually where we are now with our numbers, they're affordable down to 80%. So if you look at this table, you know, we're talking about maybe 17 affordable units that need to be developed in the next five years according to our housing element. So again, you know, my point is,
2:08:51 In the near term, when we start talking, once we get to the mitigation discussion about what's the appropriate fee amounts, it's, you know, we're talking about current market conditions, we're talking about very small amount that needs to be mitigated, and there's multiple sources for those funds, as you guys have shown in the report, and I'll touch on in a minute. Okay, so, yeah, so then if you go to table, table three on page 15 of your report,
2:09:21 Percentage of all housing units occupied by workforce households is 29%. And again, because if you're next table four on page 16, you do identify the breakdown between the income levels of what those percentages are. So my point was that 68% are in the below 120% AMI levels. So that's
2:09:49 So it's not the fullest. You take 68% of 29% and that would be potentially the number of the four of the units you would want to build up to the 120% AMI spread. And I wanted to just point out on your footnote on the table two on page 14 of the strategy makes a mention here, you know, at the expectation of this build out of 15,817, which is
2:10:17 Incredibly optimistic, right, in any kind of realistic planning time frame, that we'll need approximately 1,250 additional workforce housing units. Well, that's calculated on 29% of the new units, which includes market rate units. So don't be misled. We don't need that many units of affordable units. So I just thought that that was sort of a misleading figure because I think people maybe are going to get confused between the levels of affordability and workforce.
2:10:46 Housing, even though you show the definitions, if you read it, but it's hard to follow, right? It's hard to... Okay, so I just want to make sure that, I mean, are we in agreement, disagreement on that point? Well, if you look at, this is something that's come up from, this is Colin Fernie's real concern. He's brought it up at the dais here and at our board meeting. If you look at table four, you see a real decrease
2:11:15 In moderate and middle income over the course of 2008 and 2013. And you see a shift if you go back and you look at the housing element update, there's a shift between Mammoth and the county. It looks as if from the data that people are leaving the town and they're going to the county when they're in those income groups. And that's a concern that I'm hearing. Right.
2:11:46 And that's why we're proposing a middle income program for those target, those income groups, because you heard this group say, and I've heard it from the council and I've heard it from my board, that those people actually do need housing. And I see what you're saying, I totally see what you're saying from that chart, from the housing element at the beginning where it says there is no gap there. Right, so maybe you need an executive summary and some narrative that really just sort of...
2:12:15 You know, that really kind of says, okay, here's the salient issues and these are the conclusions. Yeah. Would be, because right now you just have to try to crunch through all this data and figure it out. It's very difficult for the average reader to even figure out what's going on. Yeah. So I think it would be helpful to maybe have an executive summary in the strategy that kind of summarizes the, those, those. The real important data points and the conclusions. Yeah.
2:12:45 Okay, so moving on. Yeah, the shady rest is an incredibly great point. I mean, here we have 25 acres in the middle of town. We have a willing seller. You can acquire that at a tremendous value right now. I mean, I don't know where the money is, but it certainly should be a high-priority strategy, I think, to acquire that or facilitate the master plan and subdivision of that property so it can get...
2:13:18 You know, in bite-sized pieces that you could go after or other developers or however it could work out. But it certainly seems like it needs to be a priority. And take one step back real quick. So on the build-out numbers, I think it's important. I really, I love this report, this EPS report that was done in 2011, economic forecast, Mammoth Lakes Economic Forecast Revitalization Strategies. It kind of goes through, hey, there's a status quo scenario, which is nothing's really going to change dramatically fast.
2:13:48 As far as development is concerned, there's a moderate development scenario and there's sort of a widely high expectations development scenario. By the way, the build out that's proposed in the 2009 general plan is between the moderate and the wild expectations build out. But my point is they actually talk about, they do some forecasting about the number of units that are required and what
2:14:17 Based on similar data that was ended up in the housing element anyways. And I think the numbers correlate fairly closely as you start to look at the data. But I think it's helpful because it points out a few things with respect to what that's going to imply to the town in terms of general fund revenues down the road when we just get more TOT base going with new development. That's going to be a huge benefit and another source of revenue for MLH through that measure 2002A or whatever it is.
2:14:47 But I digress. Let me quickly finish up here because everybody wants to finish. Get out of here. So when you talked about current resources, grants, I'll kind of come back to that because you guys have done an amazing job with that. Measure 2002A, you guys get, that was a little unclear on this. You guys get 13%, Jennifer, of the TOT revenue? Say it again, I'm sorry. The measure 2002A, you guys,
2:15:28 Receive how much, what percent of TOT revenue? Mammoth Lakes Housing or the housing overall? The housing overall, I guess. Allocated toward housing for the next five years. So, I think we just did a report to our board on this. Right now, 62% of the 1% that was approved by the voters in 2002 is going to housing. And according to the numbers in here, that's...
2:15:56 That's roughly 540,000 right now is going towards housing of the roughly 892, which is roughly the 1% of 13%. Okay. So my point would be if we get to some of these bigger build-out numbers, something to keep in mind, and this is in this EPS forecast, that I think it's important because it sort of gets to the political debate about how are we going to do this and how are we going to pay for this stuff.
2:16:20 You know, has all the sources of revenue to the town, currently order around 16.7 million. This is based on 2011, I don't think we're a whole lot different right now. And the scenario two build out, which isn't even that, it's like 14,000 units build out. We get to, we raise TOT, let's see, from currently say 10,000, I'm sorry, 10 million round numbers to 24 million round numbers.
2:16:51 So, you know, your increment of that percent you're taking is going to go up close to $2 million a year that you're going to get allocated towards housing efforts. So, and then, you guys, at your own admission here, and I think it's fantastic, and I applaud you tremendously for the grants that you've received on your table six on page 28.
2:17:20 You guys have been able to leverage the $4.4 million that you've obtained in funding to over $43 million in grants, bonds, and tax credits. So it's a 10 to 1 ratio that you guys have been able to leverage funding. So I had no idea. That's amazing. And I think that that needs to be part of the discussion when we talk about what's an appropriate level of mitigation for the development community.
2:17:48 Knowing that you guys can leverage funds tremendously, and I know you have concerns about what the future holds for availability of things, but the history is the history, and we've done tremendous on it. So, you know, I think, and I know this is just a strategy, and we're not talking about the ordinance right now, but I'm trying to set the stage a little bit for the discussion about what the ordinance should be, and we need to really look at where these sources of funds are going to come from, and again, knowing that we have a fragile market right now.
2:18:18 with development that we've got to be very, very careful not to over-ask for mitigation from developers or we're going to tank before we even get out the gate. You know, nothing's going to happen. And as you know, aside as Mickey pointed out, what's happened since the recession? John Hooper's built seven houses. That's it. There's no multi-family housing being built. You know, and we're so far from getting anything built in the village.
2:18:46 Right now with the economics, the numbers that exist. I did a report when we had that economic workshop a couple months ago that, you know, it costs a developer $800 to $900 a square foot to build something like the Westin. That's what it costs to build it. And then you've got to sell it. The prices in the village, the top prices in the villages are, there's a few units selling over $500 a square foot. So, you know, it's upside down. That stuff's still upside down.
2:19:16 The small stuff, the simple wood frame construction that John's doing, homes, nice stuff, it's the cheapest thing you can build in a resort community and he's just able to make that pencil. It makes sense that he's actually able to get it because he's building it, right? He's making a little bit of a profit on that. So we're just barely starting to get a recovery started. So I just want you guys to understand the bigger economic picture that we can't get overzealous in our ask when we start looking at how we're going to do this. And, my God, you guys have...
2:19:45 Generate $43 million in other money that didn't come from developers. So it's something to keep mindful of as we move into the discussions. Well, some of that was built on developer land, which probably couldn't have happened otherwise. A lot of those tax credit bond units were built on developer mitigated land. Understandable. Yeah. Just a point. So that's a partnership. Absolutely. Absolutely.
2:20:11 Then just as we move into the objectives, I think we already touched on this basically, but, you know, I think really, I think they're all very well thought through. The, you know, objective number four, increase the affordable housing starts. And then just, you know, we already talked about the inclusionary housing ordinance. You know, clearly that's not the direction of council at this point. I think what we should do is we should rename that as going to be the housing mitigation ordinance, right?
2:20:43 Whatever that is, it's all the different things that are in the toolbox. But that's essentially where we're asking for, we're not going to ask for a fee in lieu because what we said, it's going to be a mitigation fee. It's just going to be a housing fee and not a fee in lieu because that'll just, that'll be, that in my opinion should be the lead off. It's like, hey, you pay a fee and then, but you have all these other options. If you want to build stuff on your property, you're welcome to do it and here's the inclusionary rates and that's all the stuff we're going to figure out next.
2:21:11 Right? When we get into this whole discussion. So I think maybe as you guys go back and wordsmith the language in the strategy, maybe just refer to it as the housing mitigation ordinance. Does that make sense? As opposed to the inclusionary zoning ordinance? Because I think we're agreed we're not saying it's mandatory exclusionary. I think that's it. Let's see if I forgot anything I wanted to mention. Well, he's looking through his
2:21:48 No. I'm done. Unless you have any questions. No, I know. The reason I was so willing to spend so much time on this is I thought the whole purpose of getting the strategy done was so that it became the foundation for the ordinance. So I'm a little disheartened that, I mean, otherwise, why are we doing the strategy? I mean, what are you going to base the ordinance on if it's not based on some sort of relevant strategy? So I'm a little, you're going to have to clarify this for me.
2:22:12 So the strategy will inform the ordinance, but the strategy isn't a required mandated document, right? The housing element is and the housing element requires that we have an ordinance to allow for a format for developers to mitigate housing. The strategy has always been looked as a tool.
2:22:31 to help us manage and prioritize funding that we get for housing. So should we be spending those funds on weatherization programs? Should we continue to spend those funds on first-time home buyer assistance? Should we look at developing new programs for rental assistance or perhaps a new home buyer assistance program for middle income? So I think it's looking...
2:22:51 More at the strategies of how we prioritize funding, which may come into place very well with a housing fee that developers provide to funnel into those programs. But I think the framework for the housing ordinance itself has been sort of established by council direction. Okay. But I think it's really important, and we can talk about this because we're running out of time.
2:23:21 But we need to have a strategy that really supports our ordinance. Otherwise, the ordinance becomes what I call a PFA number, a pull from air number. And that's not what we're about anymore as a town. I mean, there has to be a direct nexus. This is our strategy. This is our fee. You know, this is our diff. This is the nexus to it. I mean, I feel really strongly about that. And we can talk about that at a later time if you'd like. So I would just, you know, looking at your schedule here, you know, we need to bump it up by a month.
2:23:51 And we can do it concurrently. Right. Right. We want to try to get something in April to the council. And just to be clear, we have to do a nexus study to establish the housing fee. So that will be done. That fee cannot be pulled out of thin air because that would be illegal. So we will do that. And I think the strategy doesn't inform that, but there's just no necessary linkage between the two. Thank you very much. Did you have any other comments on this subject?
2:24:28 I think the staff has done a great job on this. You know, from working in a zillion jurisdictions over the state, the two things I've learned loud and clear, especially through this last recession, is one, no jurisdiction should ever build, period. Development and construction is brutal. And two, the greatest programs that benefit those in need are the mortgage assistance programs at all levels. They're buying at market rate, they're getting appreciation, they're sharing appreciation with their lender.
2:24:57 Those programs really have worked the best and they work all across all levels. You know, we're in Monterey County right now with a thousand unit project and the whole workforce housing component is a disaster. We're not even building that component and the city council doesn't know what to do with their program. Santa Barbara County, we did part in lieu and those monies are going to mortgage assistance and working well. We are required to build some, half of them sold, the other half are just sitting there.
2:25:26 Because why would I go buy a restricted unit when a market rate unit is pennies away in value? My only real issue is my down payment. So if I can get help with the down payment, I'm off to the racetrack. And in California especially, or any coastal zone, getting in the game is the biggest thing. So once you help somebody get in the game with their first house and get some appreciation, they're off to the race. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, Chuck. Are there any other comments?
2:25:55 So thank you everybody very much for your efforts and work on this and we look forward to seeing you at our March meeting. Very short. We're going to take a very short one minute break.
2:26:30 Sandra, while we have our one-minute break, do you think we can continue our flora area ratio discussion until March? Yes, we can continue both of those business matters if you wanted to. Okay. The work program and the flora ratio. Okay, all right, so let's see. Our consultant has said that the minimum really doesn't affect any parallel analysis. Okay, all right. Thank you. I know. We're ships passing. We live parallel lives. No way.
2:27:33 So we're going to push these two to march for RA community.
2:28:05 Excuse me. Excuse me. Hey, ma'am. Did you get one of these? Sarah did. Pause it. Use it with pride.
2:28:38 After a short recess, I call the meeting back to order. Our next item is business matter number three, general plan consistency determination for town acceptance of Mammoth Creek Corridor property from Snow Creek Hilltop Development Company. Thank you, Chair Brown. This item is for the commission to consider general plan consistency to accept for the town to accept a 15 and a half acre property along Mammoth Creek Corridor.
2:29:07 The property is located south of Snow Creek 1 and 2, west of Minaret Road and north of Old Mammoth Road. The owner has proposed to donate this property to the town with an easement, a conservation easement to Department of Fish and Wildlife. This donation would accomplish a few things. It would permanently preserve this property as required in the Snow Creek Development Agreement.
2:29:32 It would achieve or satisfy the deer habitat mitigation that would be required by Fish and Wildlife for the construction of the Snow Creek Gate Hotel. It would place a substantial portion of the Mammoth Creek Corridor in town ownership. And it would also provide an opportunity for the town to utilize some of this property for future wetland or habitat mitigation that may be required for capital projects that the town conducts.
2:30:00 This donation would be consistent with a general plan as required by state law based on staff analysis because of the consistency with the Snow Creek Master Plan and the consistency with the goals and policies in our resource management and conservation element of our general plan. Therefore, staff is recommending that commission choose option one and find that the acceptance of this property is consistent with the general plan.
2:30:27 And just so the commission is aware, the next step for this process after this determination of consistency, if it's made, would be to work with the fish and wildlife on the conservation easement, which town is currently drafting, and then negotiate or work on the grant deed with the current owner and go to council to direct us to accept the property.
2:30:53 And the owner is here, and I'd be happy to answer any questions, or I'm sure he will too. Yes. Jen, on page three, in the second paragraph, the next to the last line, you said additionally the town may be able to utilize this property, and this in that case refers to the conservation easement, right?
2:31:18 Refers to the 15 and a half acre property. Okay, okay. And then the next question is the interpretive area that was part of the development agreement, is that planned to go in this triangle that juts up from the bottom of the outlined area? No. What's the thing about that triangle? The red triangle? That is just the property boundary. But the, if you can see where the paved multi-use path,
2:31:48 connects from Minaret Road, the interpretive area would be south of that paved path and north of Old Mammoth Road, so between, so in that sliver. Okay, I understand, but it says on the, under general plan consistency, fourth line from the bottom, since this area is anticipated to be excluded from the conservation easement, this use would be allowed in the future, so the,
2:32:17 The red outlines the conservation easement, correct? No, that's a great question. So the red outlines the property that would be donated to the town. The conservation easement that staff is drafting for Department of Fish and Wildlife will exclude certain parts of that property. Oh, it's not this entire area inside the red. Right.
2:32:40 Oh, I didn't understand that. So, for instance, if we need to do road improvements along Minaret Road or Old Mammoth Road, we would want to, we'll exclude those areas from the conservation easement to ensure we can make necessary road improvements and things like that. Thank you for explaining. And the multi-use, the multi-use bike path, I think, is also excluded as well, right? Yes. In case there was some sort of interpretive signage that wanted to be put on or an enhancement of the recreational.
2:33:09 Facilities on there. Exactly. Did you have any questions? Does anybody else have any other questions? Okay. All my questions have been answered. We probably should have a motion on this. I move that we find that the town's acceptance of donated property within the Mammoth Creek Corridor from Snow Creek Hilltop Development Company, LP, is consistent with the general plan of the town of Mammoth Lakes. I'll second the motion. Aye.
2:33:53 Thank you very much. Thank you very much, Mr. Lundy. Thank you for the land. So, we're a little short on time, Sandra, so how would you think this should be best? Do you think we can have a fairly quick conversation about FAR, or would you like, would you think we best to continue? I think we could, I mean, we could start the discussion on FAR, and maybe if we think it's going to go more than 10 minutes, we could continue it to the next meeting?
2:34:26 Okay, you'd rather continue it to the... No, no, no, I want to start... This is why I came today, for this item. This is the most important item we've had in some time. We just want to make sure we get through the consent agenda today. Yeah. Okay. Can I make a request of it, respectfully, if I could... This is a hard discussion of the consent agenda. Unless there's a lot of discussion, a lot of could be placed in front of us. Well, um...
2:34:56 Mr. We have to have our meeting over by 5 o'clock, so we need to do the consent agenda, so either we'll have a very short discussion on this, and then we'll move on, but we will, we definitely want to be to the consent agenda, you have to do the consent agenda and the commissioner's reports before 5 o'clock. Okay. Thank you. So the item before you this afternoon is a discussion on a minimum floor area ratio.
2:35:24 which the commission has discussed several times and at the last, at the December 10th Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting there was some direction to bring back some additional information to provide the commission with an opportunity to make a decision on if for sure the minimum FAR should be included and if so what that number should be. So staff provided a report which includes information from the Main Street analysis just kind of showing what
2:35:54 What we have analyzed and what exists in town. The Main Street analysis ranged, the FAR ranged from a .68 to a 1.7. And then within town I provided some analysis we did in 2012 just showing a variety of different projects in town and their FAR. It did show that the lowest FAR that we looked at as part of that project was a .5.
2:36:22 And that's the Mammoth Loves AT&T building across the street. So that provides some information basically on what we have analyzed, what's out in town.
2:36:35 Commission didn't discuss, but I thought it might be pertinent to bring up that there may be a need to include a range of a minimum FAR. The downtown zone is kind of intended to be a higher intensity zone, so the commission may want to consider a possible higher minimum FAR in that area. I just wanted to kind of put it out there for discussion by the commission. And the commission also requested some information regarding a waiver of a minimum FAR.
2:37:03 Staff looked at that and thought that it would be best included as an adjustment. We do minor waivers through adjustment and we can include this language as an adjustment to the code and basically adjustments are approved by staff unless it's part of a bigger project that comes before the commission. So what we would be looking for from the commission is some rationale for at what point would we approve that waiver or
2:37:27 Allow the developer to build lower than the minimum FAR that the commission determined. So I summarized kind of the report and in some questions on page three. Basically three questions. What is an appropriate minimum FAR for our commercial zones? Should the minimum FAR be consistent throughout the commercial zones or should it be higher in one or more of the zones? And what conditions?
2:37:54 Would the commission think should warrant a waiver of the minimum FAR? In regard to the waiver, I did provide some possibilities for conditions, such as the minimum FAR is not feasible due to site constraints, so there's existing buildings or something else constraining it, or if there's a significant public benefit associated with a lower FAR, or a minimum FAR is not feasible to some other constraint that the commission can provide input on.
2:38:21 That concludes my report. I'm available for any questions you have. Commissioner McKinney? Questions? I don't really have questions. I just comments. Does anybody else have any questions? Let's hear your comments. I'm really considering all the excellent planning that we've done and the really top drawer consultants we've had and what our vision is for our future. I was really troubled to read in this report
2:38:55 predicts that lower density developments such as single story commercial retail and for sale residential units are likely to be pursued first due to economic factors. And I can't think of anything worse than people coming to town to make a quick buck by putting up a fast food place. I mean, I think the minimum far is too low. I'm not sure what the optimum one is. And I'm so glad that we're considering a minimum far. It didn't...
2:39:22 Actually, it hadn't even entered my consciousness until I saw this report, and that's why I came today to discuss this, because I'm very concerned about that. Our whole approach for being developer ready is we say to Mr. Developer, we're so glad you're here. This is our plan. How do you fit in? And to have somebody come to town and with the existing requirements, you know, be able to put up a fast, I don't want to mention a specific one, but, you know, we've got four square miles.
2:39:51 And most of us built. And to think that we would let that happen after all the good work we've done just horrifies me. So that's my general comment. I'd be glad to hear what the rest of the commission thinks. Okay. It's very short-sighted. I think the issue is that perhaps what would be best is let's continue this item and then would you come back and just prepare a subsequent addendum of the report because we...
2:40:17 Because of the overlays in our commercial zones, for example, I don't think it's possible to build a fast food restaurant. Oh, are you sure? We were very specific about drive, well, you could build a fast food restaurant, you couldn't build a drive-thru restaurant, for example. So I think what we really need to do is, if everybody's in agreement, is to continue it and then, now that we know what Commissioner Tenney's concern is, that we can come back and you can probably address that. Those reports. Okay. And then we can have a... We have a plan. How do we get there?
2:40:48 And considering it's always up and down with the economy. Right. I mean, if we're going to keep on our path to our objective, we've got to keep that in mind. So. All right. So do we need a motion then to continue? You can. It's just consensus to continue the March meeting. Is it consensus to continue the March meeting? Yeah. Okay. All right. We can get more information. All right. And is there consensus that we'll move the Community and Economic Development Department work program review to the next meeting? Yes. Yes.
2:41:18 And then our next item on the agenda is the consent agenda. I need to pull the approval of the minutes for January 14th. Would you like to talk about those minutes first or do we want to talk about? Do we make a motion to approve the remainder of the consent agenda? Why don't you do that first? Do we have a motion to approve the? I'll move we approve the consent. Just a second. Minus the earth. Let somebody else make the motion. I lost track.
2:41:54 I'll make a motion that we approve the rest of the consent agenda without the item being pulled. The minutes of the January 14th meeting. Okay. Okay, I will second that motion. Okay. Roll call, please. Or you just want to vote? All in favor? Aye. Thank you very much. Thank you. On the minutes of the January 14th meeting, underneath the director's report, we needed to make a correction.
2:42:26 Yes, it referenced that Ms. Licko was the FAR consultant. She's actually the Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District consultant. So we would strike FAR and put EIFD in that spot. I wondered about that. Can I have a motion to approve the minutes? I'll make a motion to approve the minutes from the January 14th. I'll second it. Favor? Aye. Commissioner reports?
2:43:05 Do you have any commissioner reports? No. I don't have anything. So there's just a couple things I'd like to say. I mean, as you know, we had a very tragic and hard weekend. And I really want to commend Mammoth Lakes Tourism for sending out that great email on Monday about what to do with the lack of Wi-Fi services and where the hot spots were.
2:43:35 And the only thing I would wish is that the next time we could do it on a Saturday. Because the hard frustration thing is when we have these issues happen is that our town is full of visitors. Right. Okay. And then you have an emergency and then it seems like we respond a little bit. But it was really a great thing that we were able to do that. And then I have this.
2:44:02 Did you give everybody a copy or do I have all the copies? I set the copies on your at your spot so you could hand them out when you were talking about it. Where did I do it? Just really quickly I prepare a quarterly market report and the residential market for Mammoth Lakes and then I do a very quick summary of that market and I think it's just good for everybody.
2:44:34 Just to really understand, so this first page is a quarterly summary. 2005 fourth quarter was our high quarter, as you can see, for the total number of transactions, which was 282 transactions, and the total dollar volume, the high was 187 million. Our low quarter was
2:44:59 2008 where we did 42 transactions with a total dollar volume of 22. The thing that's a little frustrating here we are now in 2014 and as you can see we're still 57% off the high as far as number of transactions and 76% off the high as far as dollar of transactions. And I think it's
2:45:26 As we talk about economic development going forward, it's just a good idea to really understand where our market is. And then on the back page, what I do is it's just like it's a comparison of so fourth quarter 2014 compared to fourth quarter 2013 and then fourth quarter 2014 to the previous quarter. And the really great thing about our market is that our distressed sales have
2:45:54 significantly changed, which has changed our days on the market. But where 2014 started out pretty strong, we did lose some momentum at the end of 2014, and that caused our medium prices start to drop again. So I just, we can talk about this, and I'm going to give it to you every quarter, so you just kind of have a really quick glance about what's happening in the marketplace.
2:46:21 And my only other commission report is the scheme's pretty nice. You've got to be careful off piece, but other than that, it's really great. How many people are in town? How busy is it? This coming weekend, right now, we're projecting the low 90%, 92%, 93%. And the encouraging thing is that continues into the high 60s, low 70s next week. So shop early at Vaughn's.
2:46:50 And stock up, because it's going to be crowded all week long. Shop at midnight. Good to hear. And then the director's report. So I'll quickly go through. We did hire a code enforcement officer. Great. We conducted interviews on Monday. And we ended up hiring an internal candidate, Shireen Sanders. She's currently TOT enforcement. And so it's a pretty natural change for her. So I think she's going to do really well. And she'll start in two weeks.
2:47:17 So we're excited to have her on board. And are you going to replace her in TOT compliance? I don't know. Okay. Yes, it's a finance and town manager decision. And I did send the group an email about having another economic roundtable.
2:47:35 In April or May. And I was thinking that it might be, in my email I said that maybe have these kind of every six months. I thought it might be good if we were going to have another one to maybe pick some topics that we focus on, you know, maybe two specific topics. So I just wanted to kind of plant the seed and maybe we can talk about it at our, you know, in between now and I guess our next meeting so I can try to schedule that meeting. But we did talk about having it with the Chamber and Monokone Economic Development Department.
2:48:05 Thinking about some topics to talk about. Do you have any dates? I was thinking the April, either the April or May planning and Economic Development Commission meeting date. Oh, okay. Okay, thank you. And so on the Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District, I think you all know our consultant's going to be here at the end of the month. We're working to schedule meetings with the county, the water district, the fire district, as well as the development community. And we're having the joint meeting on Thursday, the 26th, from 10 to 12.
2:48:34 Just to kind of wrap up her meeting. And then the floor area ratio, we are, the consultant is working on the initial study and staff is working, still working on our traffic analysis, so preparing all of the data for the traffic analysis to give to the traffic consultant to really kick that process off. Can I ask a question about that? Yes, please. Since your staff person that was working on that is currently on leave.
2:49:01 We have Haislip Hayes from Public Works helping us with that piece. It has been pretty cumbersome. It's not an easy process. Our traffic model is very complex, and Hayes is not a traffic engineer, so we're kind of working through that. But we hope to have all of that data clear this week. It just seems like every time we kind of get close to finishing it, we find one more piece. I mean, the traffic model is a really big document.
2:49:29 So hopefully we'll have at least the data to send off and can get some preliminary information from the traffic consultant on this in the next couple weeks. And then at the last meeting, there was a number of different questions regarding public works projects. And so I have some responses. If you'd like to go through them now, I can, or I can give them to you at the next meeting. But there were some questions about wayfinding. Oh, I think we probably have time. Yeah, we've got ten minutes.
2:49:57 Okay. So there was a question about the wayfinding signs with status and the plan. So right now we may apply for Measure U funds in the fall of 2015. And really this would be just for our municipal areas, not for the trails that we would apply for. Right now we're working to identify all of the signage in town. And so, but basically what we would apply for is just the vehicular and pedestrian components.
2:50:26 Which is about $350,000. I know that Commissioner Tenney has been meeting with Public Works also to talk about other options and we are going to bring at your next meeting a discussion on public art funds and how we kind of move forward with public art in the future. So the second question was the signage inventory, in particular the sign on 203. So we did complete a signage inventory I think in 2011.
2:50:54 We've completed the inventory, but we never went through and actually prioritized which signs need to be removed. I think there was kind of general consensus that, yeah, this sign needs to go, but we didn't actually go through and do that. So right now we're completing a signage inventory of signs within town.
2:51:10 We'll match that up with the signage inventory of the signs along 203, 395 and conduct a clutter analysis. Public works will go through and so they'll conduct an analysis of regulatory signage as well so it's not just big monument signs, it's everything. And so then they would prioritize the signs that need to be removed and the signs that need to stay or be replaced. But I think everybody agrees that the sign on 203 needs to be removed.
2:51:38 So I don't think that's going to be part of this whole analysis. And basically what Public Works said is we need a permit from Caltrans and a permit from the Forest Service and that the Public Works Director is going to talk to the council about moving forward with that. So before we remove that sign, we would get kind of the go-ahead from council and then go ahead and do that. The other question that came up a couple months ago was a dig-once policy. We don't have a dig-once policy.
2:52:06 However, we work to implement a dig once policy even though we don't have one. So we try to coordinate with Mammoth Community Water District and we try to put in conduit every time we dig. But there's no plans right now to work on a dig once policy, but it is something we try to work on. And I think that was it on the Public Works questions. Sandy, that second Public Works thing about the clutter analysis, are they considering
2:52:34 Clustering signs where appropriate, in other words, two on a post? I think it depends. So for regulatory signs. Because for some signage, I think you don't have to have a separate post. Yeah, and so I think we would try to do that where we could, but most regulatory signs you can't, like speed limit signs, those types of signs you can't put two on a post. So if we could, we would. But that's why you see so many, because there's so many regulations about how often you have to have those signs, how they have to be displayed.
2:53:03 So, but I can talk to Grady about it and just suggest that. Just to be aware of opportunities. Yes. And I think that is all I have. I have one question for you. It's clarity more than anything. The housing element and the housing strategy and the housing
2:53:33 Code that we're looking at. Will there be and when would it be the time that we break these two apart and have singular discussion on the housing ordinance? So we're working to engage a consultant right now in housing ordinance. So we'll be bringing that forward as a separate item to the commission and the council.
2:54:02 The council is having a joint workshop with Mammoth Lakes Housing on March 18th. So that will be another option to talk about not the ordinance itself but kind of the items that the groups agree on or concerns that the community has. I think we really kicked it off last month when we had that housing meeting with the council and we got a lot of input and we basically got some kind of preliminary direction from the council. So I think we've already started on it.
2:54:31 Okay. And I just want a clarification. So the joint meeting is a joint meeting of
2:55:01 Council, so we're not adjourning to that meeting, we're adjourning to our March meeting? Correct. It's, oh no, you're adjourning to the joint, oh you're right, it is a joint meeting of, you mean the 26th, yes. Okay. I have a motion to adjourn. I'll move we adjourn. I'll second. Okay. This meeting's adjourned to March 11th, 2015 at 2 p.m. Thank you very much. March. March. March.