Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 3 hr 2 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- The Town Council voted 4 to 1 on April 7, 2010 to start the Open Space rezoning; a speaker said at the June 2, 2010 meeting that the Tourism and Recreation Commission had twice opposed it Bell Shaped Parcel (Meridian Boulevard / Minaret Road)
Transcript
405 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you. Thank you.
0:19 Thank you.
0:43 She lives next to Bill Taylor, Bill and Sherry, yeah. Bill had to go in. The housekeeper saw her but ran out.
1:12 Yeah. Was it illness, sudden? Well, he said it looked like she had been sitting at her desk and collapsed. Yeah. So they don't know that. Okay. Wow. What a good life she has. Yeah, absolutely. That's wonderful. Yeah, that's nice to do that.
1:45 Thank you.
2:18 So I knew exactly when I was getting a grandson.
2:47 How many is that? How many is that? That's a good one. This is our first. Where? We're here. We're here. We're here. We're here. We're here.
3:16 Thank you. Thank you.
3:38 Karen, if we could get started at this point to call the meeting to order. And Sharon, can I ask you to lead us in the pledge? Sure. Would you stand and join us, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Karen, can you call the roll as well?
4:11 Here. Here. Here. This time we will have reports from the commission and I believe that Vice Chair Barrett has something you would like to open with. Sure. For those of you that don't know and for our TV audience, a long time resident, wonderful woman, Edith Buchanan, passed away this morning.
4:39 And so we would like to do a moment of silence for her from the commission and for the community. Edith, you know, her and Walter, those, I mean, family that lived here for 50 years, had celebrations, her business, and it's a sad day for us, a big loss to the community, but if we could have a moment of silence in her remembrance. Thank you. Thank you.
5:14 Yes. Anyone else would like to share reports from the commissioners today? Elizabeth, do you have anything? Nothing today. Yep. Tony, anything else? No? And Sharon. Moving right on. At this time, this is our public comments section for any matters that are not on the agenda. This gives us an opportunity for the public to address this. And we'd like to hold your comments to five minutes, but please, there's a...
5:42 There's information at the back when the information forms. Otherwise, come to the podium and state your name as well for the record because we are trying to stream here this morning, this afternoon. Good afternoon, commissioners. My name is Terry Plum. My family has had a residence here in Mammoth Lakes since the late 1980s. We're just humbled to be part of the Mammoth community.
6:11 I have given you attachments today. We own five and a half acres out on, in Old Mammoth, immediately west of the Snow Creek Golf Course, and extending up into the Bluffs subdivision off of Laverne Street. We have submitted a tentative parcel map to the town. I'm working with staff, Jessica Morris, Steve Spidell,
6:40 And Peter Berners-Corny very closely in addition to John Wentworth of MLTPA and Tom Heller of the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. And we think we're going to be coming to the Planning Commission probably on September the 8th as agenda item to begin the public comment process. And I would ask you to take a look at these three pages that I've given you over the next few days.
7:08 Please, I welcome any opportunity to visit with you. More on it. I had a public informal meeting last Saturday out of the site. There was probably about 20 people in attendance. Most of them were neighbors. And I said, overall, I thought it was a very good meeting. So I just want to bring this to your notice now and expect to see me back in early September. Thank you. Madam Chair, if I may. Yes. Mark.
7:35 Would it be possible for Mr. Plum's project that he has, you know, it's a fairly extensive project and a lot that we'll be going through on it. September it starts. We can end up having snow on the ground shortly thereafter. Is it possible for us to have an adjourned meeting out at the site and maybe at our next meeting, go out there and start the meeting there so the commissioners, we have a chance to see the site without snow on it and get a good idea of what we're going to be working with? The answer is yes.
8:05 If you, you could actually just, as part of your next regular meeting, convene the meeting at the site, if it's convenient, also with Mr. Plum, and so that portion of your agenda would be a site tour. Are you in town the rest of the month, Terry? I'm in the backcountry, some of it. When is the next meeting? 28th. 28th. I will be in town, I think, on the Wednesday, the 28th, I think. Yes. Okay. Okay. Yes. Thank you.
8:32 We know that too. It's consensus to add that too in the agenda. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you for the information. You bet. Thank you, commissioners. Thank you. Public comment session is still open. Is there anyone else that would like to address this at this time? There is another public comment section at the end of our meeting today. Moving on, we have no presentations, but we do have consent agenda, and there's three items on that. We can either approve those in total or anyone would like to pull items.
9:05 And Madam Chair, I'd like to pull item one. Okay. I'd like to pull item three. So it looks like we're going to go one at a time. Let's go into item one first. Do I need to approve item two first? If we can. I'll make a motion to approve the minutes of May 12, 2010, as presented. I'll second. You have a louder second from Elizabeth Fields, and she seconds that. Any other discussion? All in favor? Aye. Approved. Minutes of May 12, approved.
9:36 Let's go to item number one, which is the minutes of April 28th. There was an omission in paragraph one, let's see, yes, in paragraph one under reports from the commission, line four, the word candidates is omitted, it says town council forum, and it should say town council candidates forum. That was my only correction. And that was mine as well, so. No, go ahead.
10:06 All on the same page. I mean, same item. Any other issues? If not, I'll entertain a motion of approval. Move. We approve minutes of April 28th as amended. I'll second. Any further discussion? All in favor? Aye. Item 3, the minutes of June 9, 2010 meeting. And, Chair, you had an item on that. It's so tiny, but I think we need to.
10:34 Do it. It's on page 11 of our packet, page 4 of the minutes, and apparently I have lost page 4. We have left. We left out a word. Well, I'm not finding it. Nope. I don't remember. The word was list. That's all I have. Apparently we had a list.
11:23 Mark, I think, provided a list of something. Under Director's Report, it says Priority List, is that what you mean? On page 4? There it is. It's on page 11. Thank you. That's not, that is it. Thank you, Elizabeth. I did find it. Page 11. Provided an updated list on the Snow Creek development. Thank you. Oh, yeah, it's just a type of update. Yeah. Yeah, it's just an update. It's just an update, right, Mark?
11:58 Well, it's either update or updated list. The line reads where your law provided and updated on the Snow Creek Development Agreement, so it's an update. It's an update period. Update period. There's no list. We obviously understood the intent, but it doesn't read. Well, we were all grabbed. Move approval of June 9th with that little tiny correction. Second.
12:27 Any further discussion? I just would make a comment to the public. These seem like really nitpicking issues, but we often look at minutes that are 20 or 25 years old for reference on an issue that's carried forward, and you have to know what was intended. So that's how we have to be sure we get it right. Thank you. No further discussion? Call for vote? Aye. All in favor? Aye. Thank you.
12:53 Public hearings, we have not at this time, we're moving on to business matters, and it's item number four, which is the draft downtown neighborhood district planning, or a DNDP report, and that will be led by Ellen and Mark. Thank you very much, Chair and members of the Commission.
13:21 This item was presented to you in an introduction, not a staff introduction, but we just spoke briefly about the overall process and provided to you the outline summary of the overall draft downtown neighborhood district planning report, which is a study. So today I'd like to do a brief recap of the staff report so that the members of the audience and those watching TV can follow along.
13:49 And in response to some of the questions that the Commission raised at that meeting and comments and questions that we've heard since that time, we have a slightly modified PowerPoint presentation to cover some points that aren't well discussed but are part of any process like this that you would see implemented in a community.
14:13 So, first, by way of background, the purpose of this staff report is to bring this downtown neighborhood district plan report, this study document, to the Planning Commission for your review, consideration, and recommendation to the Town Council. As a study, you're not adopting, you're accepting, and your recommendations and comments will be forwarded to the Town Council. We have now presented this and received comments.
14:39 from the Tourism and Recreation Commission. Next week we'll be presenting to the Mobility Commission and also to the Public Arts Commission. And overall we will capture those comments and include them in our typical addendum format so that you can see the comment and understand how it's addressed and ultimately the Town Council can direct if it should be included and modified in the study or some other action should be taken.
15:09 This report, as I've mentioned, has been distributed since two weeks ago or so to all of the town bodies that relate to this effort, Planning Commission, Tourism and Recreation, Public Arts, the Town Council. We've also posted it on our website. It's been available since June 18th, and we continue to receive comments. We received a comment letter from the Water District, which we'll respond to separately in our presentation to you.
15:38 Our overall scope of work, this is a pretty important concept. We came to you and the Town Council with a scope of work which identified the framework purposes, the principles of this study, the method and the timeline, and you made...
15:54 recommendations to the council and the council adopted that scope of work. In this effort, our overall process and the report document substantially follows that scope. So that's, in a sense, our contract as if we're consultants and you should opine whether we met that contract and also that we addressed thoroughly the principles that were established in the framework analysis itself. Overall, the downtown and main street area
16:23 In particular, have long been an issue in the town. It was probably an issue when Main Street was redeveloped in this configuration. And through the general plan process, Main Street, the environment, the transportation, the snow conditions, winter conditions, the success of businesses, parking, all of those issues were forefront in the general plan. And this was one of the key reasons that we set up.
16:50 The entire neighborhood district character section of that general plan and established also the district planning process as a policy and action of the general plan. So this effort stems substantially from the general plan. Unlike some of the other district studies, this is a freestanding community planning effort. It is not driven by an applicant nor any one particular interest or entity.
17:18 The community has long recognized a need for change in this area. Building on the successful components of this downtown area, there are many successful businesses, there are many well-designed buildings. The streetscape sometimes is very attractive. Now in full bloom, the grass and the flowers are attractive. In the snow condition, the mounds of snow block view and access and can start to look
17:45 Unsightly as they get higher and higher and covered with cinders. So there's a lot of positive to build from and there are a lot of issues to address. And so we hope that many of these issues are captured and reflected in this district study. This DNDP is far more complicated than any of the others. The area is about 210 acres, so it's...
18:08 Five times the size of North Old Mammoth Road. And it also has different subject areas that are individually far more complex. The operation, the maintenance, the ownership, and the design of 203 is its own unique subject. In this effort, we've been assisted first by the initiation of the Hart-Howerton plan, the concept plan, the catalyst and call to action of this effort.
18:34 It was funded by the Mountain and by Chadmar, and they have maintained their participation and they helped organize and facilitate and conduct public outreach in these efforts. They've also, Mr. Landy served on the focus group, and the focus group itself, the 15-member group, was identified and requested to participate in this by staff and by the Mountain as well, and that group has provided
19:03 Provided to us very, very useful and important information and feedback in crafting this community plan. So this is the community's plan, the community's vision to date, and it's certainly not a staff-driven project. This study report is not meant to be the final plan. This is the starting point of a concept or a vision for the community, and there's a tremendous amount of work that would proceed from this effort.
19:31 Once directed by the Town Council. We have traffic studies to conduct and to work with Caltrans on to see how the traffic system actually would operate with these types of changes that are discussed in this report. We have population at one time analyses that we would conduct when we have a frame of the development concept and the development intensities. The project impact evaluation criteria
20:00 would be a subsequent analysis, and that analysis will draw on some of the traffic studies to provide detailed information. So looking ahead, there's a lot more work to do, and it will be important for us as we go forward to set up milestones so that the community, the Planning Commission, other commissions, and the Town Council can weigh in on those milestone reports so that staff is not...
20:27 Just continuing to proceed through some programmatic creep and study effort. So this program will result in an implementation program where we'll come back, report the traffic studies, our population at one time studies, et cetera, and receive the appropriate feedback and direction from commissions and town council. With that, this concept plan is really perceived to be a bold, long-range vision for the community.
20:56 The community's plan that's connected to businesses and it can be implemented by businesses with their own development plans, whether a business chooses to stay or a business chooses to move or new development comes forward. The overall concept needs to work in all of those conditions.
21:16 Many of the public facilities that would be implemented through this type of a plan, they also need to be able to be incremental and lead to the successful completion of this long-term vision. The report itself includes a discussion of our process and the principles and the approach. I'm not going to read those key ideas from the staff report. You all have that.
21:43 It includes key components and recommendations. One of them is a physical development concept that outlines the land use characteristics, the features in the program that we would use then to guide the codification and the establishment of development standards for these areas. It includes significant aesthetic improvements, streetscape, changing the right-of-way, having appropriate landscape plans.
22:12 And repositioning buildings so that they're moving up to the street and creating a charming and pleasant public space or public room. A significant issue, as you can imagine with 203, is how we handle the long-term transportation system. We must carry traffic. This plan, as you saw in your last presentation, includes four traveled lanes.
22:38 A center median. It also is designed around the complete street concept so that there's not only traffic and transit capacity but pedestrians, trail access and bicyclists are safe and fit within to that program and that the overall transportation program is designed to support the uses that they're in. So in that district, if it's a commercial Main Street district, it has a different configuration.
23:07 Then there's Western and Eastern ends that are not Main Street districts. The next steps and implementation actions that would come out of this I've already touched on. They would include certainly additional outreach to the local businesses in this area as we develop more progressive and detailed plans.
23:30 A gondola feasibility analysis. The gondola is very important, and as I mentioned last time, many people think there are positives to the gondola. Many people think there are negatives to the gondola. And at this point, I don't think we, the staff, have enough information to give commissions and council enough information to discard it or to support it. So I think it's certainly a critical path item.
23:57 And figuring out how it fits within the placeholder center median will be key because that median dimension will ultimately set the curb-to-curb lines, which will be key to our successful incremental implementation. Traffic modeling of our networks and land use assumptions, a district-wide parking study, pedestrian and bicycle facilities and needs analysis, transit studies, cost and feasibility analysis, among other studies.
24:26 Are necessary to implement this. So that concludes a review of this staff report. What I wanted to do is respond a little bit to some of the questions and comments we received at the last commission meeting. And partly this sizzle, if you will. What is the message that this 100-plus page document is sending to the community? And we did not try to craft it at this point in time. And we'd certainly like...
24:57 Commission input on this because I think some of the core components are from the community, which includes the commission. So first, this is a long-term community vision. It has to be for the community and by the community. Without that, it won't be successful. It'll just be some other idea that becomes shelved.
25:16 This must be connected with the businesses and property owners in that area. It has to fit their long-term plans, whether they stay and operate forever, change or sell or redevelop. And so it has to be a dynamic plan, one that can accommodate those who wish to stay for the long term and those who wish to change in the long term. It needs to be built about momentum through small successes.
25:41 It's very difficult to, in your mind, conjure wholesale change to a system such as 203 or to the streetscape. So how the community and how the town council directs its resources are important to this kind of a plant. That strategic focus that achieves impact and the biggest bang for the buck will be important.
26:03 Can we look at our capital infrastructure, whether it's mobility, streets, sidewalks, and public arts, and economic development activities, and focus those to achieve that momentum that will drive forward any successful plan? And that finally is all contrary to, I think, what has been the approach, which has been an ad hoc and disjointed effort. So you see certain improvements.
26:30 That are scattered throughout an area, but they haven't combined to create the critical mass of positive change that appears to be still desired. So one concept, obviously, from this starting point is working with business and property to enhance their programs. And how would we do that? Typically, that is through facade, sign, and...
26:56 Property upgrades. So how does the community, how do local businesses and how does the town interact and support to achieve those kinds of changes? How do we encourage versus become a barrier to increased and incremental reinvestment in the community? Many of the techniques you'll see in other communities include, in addition to facade assistance and technical architectural design assistance, murals on blank walls. Very common to see that in Bishop.
27:26 Business assistance programs, low interest loans, and support to technical assistance, very common throughout California. Developing business directory and map. You'll recall in our economic development work that the community has asked for help in assembling the interesting illustrations of the community, where businesses are, and how people get around.
27:54 And then finally, programming more events. There are other tools, but this is the look at how we can engage directly with businesses now and begin some of the momentum and improvement that's necessary to complement any physical change. Streetscape enhancements. You're all very aware of other communities, Reno, Santa Barbara, the list goes on and on, where we've
28:23 Where communities have targeted their resources to create change in the environment, the town's entrance marker that is located on the eastern end of 203, which is now underway, can be part of an integrated program. Perhaps it leads to the gateway marker to Main Street, complementing the existing stone and sign pilaster that is on the north side of the street. Event messaging and an information marker. We continually are requested.
28:52 To include some kind of signed program or banner across the street or information that says an event is coming. These are all plausible and possible investments and facilities that should be assembled into our incremental pilot projects, if you will, that implement this overall vision. The appurtenances to the streetscape, benches, drinking fountains.
29:19 Trash containers with dog bags, bicycle racks. This is the standard list, and this is the now that can be implemented, regardless, again, of what that plan results in. Mobility improvements, incremental feet-first improvements can and should be continued. Build on the wayfinding and directional signage system.
29:43 Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access has participated with the town and some of the grant funded projects are moving forward with a consistent palette and messaging system. It's probably now time to build on this in our own streetscape and manage our own transportation and traffic flow. So we're not starting something new, we're building on momentum. Traffic safety items, crosswalks, more crosswalks are probably required. Traffic signals.
30:13 Caltrans is working on a traffic signal right now to understand how the speed and flow of traffic is safe or unsafe on Main Street. Upgrading our transit stops and shelters. The transit stop that's on the north side of the street on the westerly end is in poor repair. So these are things that we can program now and start to put together and assemble. Working on snow management. It's either going to stay berms or not.
30:41 And the snow management program moving to implement that is not dependent on the ultimate configuration of the right-of-way. It's something that can now be addressed. Visualizing change, this is what we have now. Many communities do this, and we didn't try to animate this through our studies, but we thought we'd show you examples of what other communities think about it. And this, in your minds, ILO, we haven't done it for Main Street.
31:11 I think you can certainly apply this imagery. That's what the list looks like when it's installed in the streetscape. Sidewalks, appropriate landscaping that's breaking up that total sense of asphalt, landscaping and curb bulb outs that provide a shorter distance to cross the road, appropriate tree species to Mammoth, probably not those for us, on-street parking, the street benches.
31:43 And the trash containers and lighting put into a place that supports the retail Main Street that this document supports. Next. Here's another lovely patch of pavement. No palm trees here, but this is what this looks like when you assemble the list of improvements. More and more people. And, you know, I think it's important to note that although they're pasted up,
32:16 People are drawn to these environments. You all know that and you've experienced that through your own work and applied through your principles of design and the projects you've looked at. Attractive facades, rehab of existing facilities and allowing phase development to occur while still supporting existing businesses. Bike racks, so people see that it's a district where people are intended to come frequent, be safe and protected. Go back.
32:55 When we see streetscapes, what our eye tends to see is the flat plane, and it's the vertical projections that break up the streetscape. And in many of these case studies, you see the application of a center medium with, they don't need to be forests of landscaping, and too much landscaping tends to divide the commercial area. But just subtle change with an integrated plan and well-thought-out public art, landscaping, and accoutrements significantly changes.
33:24 The way that we perceive these streetscapes. And this is all what is intended, again, not the plant species, but these are the principles and ideas that are suggested through this particular document. Once again, it is incredibly important to not only make them attractive and functional, but safe. Time and time again, we're reminded of Old Mammoth Road, although it's functioning.
33:51 It moves traffic. It's not safe for bicyclists. And so complete streets and where we have limitations to integrate bicycle access, we need to think of those other alternatives. And when it comes to bicycles, there are road bicyclists, those people who are generally going faster and are intended to be in the street. And then we have recreational users, moms, dads, and children.
34:15 And they might not be suited to be in this kind of a configuration. The Tourism and Recreation Commission emphasized our look as we advance. How do we provide safe bicycle access for those other users? Infill development is very important to us. And it's the repositioning of those buildings over time through reinvestment that will support the implementation of whatever plan is implemented.
34:49 It's the buildings and then these taller elements of landscaping that frame that public room and that street. So getting them right, putting in the details and the finish that invite the shoppers, the retailers to these areas is really important. So all in all, downtown is intended to be a place where people play, shop, work, and live. That's it.
35:20 What we hope to hear from you in addition to your detailed comments, those ideas that you think are the important aspects of this concept that should be included in the summary page. It's not just an executive summary. It is the message, the compelling message that you want to use for the community to understand and for others to understand where the town intends to go for this particular project.
35:51 Thank you. Thank you. This is a study right now, so what we were really looking at is inclusive enough of all the information. And if we have questions of Mark or staff, I'd like to open that up at this time. Tony, you'd have one, and then I'll go to Elizabeth. Okay. Mark, the conceptual photos we saw there showing, are there any that have any kind of
36:22 Areas where they have the climate that we live in? Because a lot of what I've heard from Main Street folks is that we're looking at beach cities and other areas and trying to compare those of what our town could look like. So I'm speaking more to, you know, the snow removal, the trash, the benches, placement. I mean, we saw those nice conceptuals, which is great, but are we going to see something comparing it to another resort, another ski area?
36:48 Another area that gets 300 to 400 inches of snow. We have a huge photo inventory of Aspen, of Whistler, of areas of South Lake Tahoe. And all of these places employ these tools. These are the tools of urban design. And you have to acknowledge that if you have a bench and it snows on the bench, you either have to remove this snow or...
37:14 You know, it could be that some of the facilities are temporary, and when it becomes snow season, you remove them. But yes, we have those, and you know, there's nothing unique to these images and concepts that you wouldn't find in Vail, Aspen, Boulder, Breckenridge, Whistler, need I go on? Just a hurdle, I think you're going to have to go through with some business owners, so it might be good to have those to compare it, so it's not comparing it to a beach city.
37:43 I noticed you had the gateway entrance markers and you showed an example on slide five. And on that slide it has amongst things the community center park, but it also says North Village. And speaking to some of the business owners in the village, there is concern and I also have concern that North Village encompasses a large area. It's not just the village. It encompasses down the stone gate.
38:11 All the way up and around the golf course. So is there going to be any kind of marker saying Village at Mammoth, something that directs people to where lodging and the businesses really are, instead of just saying North Village? Yes. So yes in this effort and in a more detailed application right now, MLTPA, John Wentworth, is working with Public Works on the nomenclature of signs that are rolling out.
38:40 And it's important that the demonstration project that's coming, which, so now I won't do this in director's report, a demonstration prototype will be installed at the visitor's center in early August with the intent of everybody looking at it so that we can make sure that the overall signage program is perfected. And then the naming nomenclature, John and Public Works staff are going through that to make sure that the shop drawings
39:09 are going to be correct with names. And so if, for example, it shouldn't be called North Village and it should be called the Village in Mountain, they're working to get that right right now. Okay. So then I can let them know that you are looking at Village at Mammoth as the nomenclature instead of North Village? Yes. Okay, thank you. That's all I had. Elizabeth? I have a process question. This was a private...
39:37 Effort to instigate this planning. That was when Rusty and Chuck Landy contributed money to get, you know, a plan out there just so we could look at it and react to it. And then it was decided that it would be a community-driven project planning effort. And that's when the focus group was formed with each member of the focus group representing a demographic in Mammoth. And we had, I think, four or five meetings and with a lot of support from staff.
40:04 And then this was the result of that and it was handed to us at the last meeting and everybody's had a chance to study it. And today we're looking at this and I thought it was our job as Planning Commission to be making a recommendation to Town Council with mobility, public art, tourism and rec being advisory to us with their comments. And yet you said Town Council already has this.
40:28 And we haven't even had a chance to chew it over, to digest it, to make suggestions, and town council already has it. What happened to our process? I don't think it's a process problem. What we have done through this effort and through all the neighborhood district plans, council and commissions have asked that the information be posted and made public well in advance of the meetings. And so it is not uncommon. In fact, it's a good thing.
40:58 To take the report, and when it's available, make it publicly available. It would be unusual to post it on the web and not distribute it to the council as well. Okay. So, let's see, it was posted on the web on the 18th. It was made part of your Planning Commission packet a week in advance of when you received it, a week in advance of your meeting. And so this is your opportunity to make a recommendation.
41:27 to the Council and provide any modifications or changes. And that's what you're expecting today is a recommendation from us for Council? Yes, I think your staff report asks for your recommendation. In fact, the recommendation is the Planning Commission should review and discuss the draft downtown NDP report and then determine whether option one or two is appropriate. Option one is to
41:52 Modify and make a recommendation. Option two is that you determine you want to have additional meeting time to discuss. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions of staff? Sharon? Yeah. I guess it would be appropriate to follow Elizabeth because I, too, am very concerned about the process. First of all, I think this is a great jumping-off place. I think this report is really great.
42:19 Gives us lots of information. And I also want to thank Jen and Ellen for spending an hour with me this morning since I've been out of town for a while. Thank you so much. Are we ever going to have public hearing on the draft? I mean, I feel very uncomfortable not knowing what the general public thinks. It's on the agenda. It's been advertised. This is one of the opportunities for the public to weigh in. And remember also that
42:48 In this kind of a community planning effort, the public meetings that we held, the workshops, a number of them, as well as the focus group meetings, that is giving us extensive information that we've captured and rolled into this report. With every commission meeting, those agendas are posted as well. We've communicated through the newspaper, describe our outreach efforts.
43:16 We publicly notice in the paper ahead of every meeting, so two weeks before each meeting there is an ad in the paper identifying the time and place and content of the meeting for the neighborhood district plan. I also have an email list of over 170 interested peoples, council members, commissioners who are interested in getting updates on the DNDP report and process, so they're also notified of the meetings.
43:43 And we also have the meetings in our Friday update as well. I guess I'm not asking specifically about our meetings, but it seems to me the public ear would pick up more specifically if they understand that this is something that we are recommending to town council. And they would know specifically that this is it. And they might want to respond specifically to things in the report.
44:13 I understand that they can come to any meeting, but it just seems to me if a public hearing were advertised that we might get more information from the public. Are you saying we should have public hearings on this first? Is that what? I think so, if this is going to be something that is going to guide us for Main Street development. Well, I think the public hearings would come at a time when you have something that's more of substance.
44:43 That you want to make decisions on, like is the street going to be two lanes or four lanes? Is it going to be, you know, one way or not one way? That's not what this is. This is the simple, the beginning so that Paul Rudder, so that people that are here today have the opportunity to move on as it goes through the process with town council to respond and be a part of the process. But we have to start at somewhere. And it's a concept. And it's a concept. It's a concept. But very often,
45:12 Concepts get turned into concrete proposals. And I'm not in agreement with everything, which I will obviously state today, but I'm just fearful that concept is going to become concrete. We spent a lot of time in the report and in the study document emphasizing that this is the initial phase and there's a lot more work to do.
45:39 So you could add language to that effect if you want. And I do want to point out that you have members of the focus group and members of the public who participated in some of the workshops here as well. Maybe I should ask, when do you perceive a public hearing on this? There will not be a public hearing on this. Not on this, but the downtown neighborhood district plan. That's a great question. So, first, here's a study, the starting point.
46:08 And we've identified a conceptual approach to the road, to land use, to concepts. And we've identified the fact, for example, we need to work closely with Caltrans on the traffic studies so that we can all make sure that it's going to work. So as we conduct some of this analysis, we're going to be going back and reporting that information to the town council and say, look, it works.
46:34 It only works if we do this, this, and this, or it doesn't work. And so with those milestones, these reports that are going to come in, they're going to inform our direction and our ability to make changes, for example, on 203. And then the council's going to have to say, yes, proceed, or do not proceed, or proceed but do this differently. And so those milestones...
47:03 of action and approval by review by commissions and then action by council will be those incremental steps. Did that answer your question? I'm not sure. It sounds like town council is going to be doing some of the work that we should be doing. Well, we'll certainly bring the appropriate work through commissions. Another good example will be the zoning code.
47:32 So there's a concept disclosed in this, and it's not quite enough information just to go off and write a zoning code section that might update the commercial general zones. And so if directed to this approach, we'll prepare more detailed work based on your Appendix C. So turn to Appendix C of your report, which is well in the back.
48:03 It's the typologies of uses and places. So building on this information, developing some more information that describes land uses and building some more substantial information on building the envelopes and unit counts, et cetera, we would host probably neighborhood meetings, come back to the Planning Commission, and then go to the Town Council to check if
48:32 Those options in that direction implemented the Council's direction on the neighborhood district plan and then would segue to the zoning code. You're not saying we're doing the update for our zoning code before we approve the district plan? No. Thank you. Any further questions at this time? I have a whole list. Do you want them now? Yes. I mean, I thought we were doing general stuff. Okay.
49:03 I have already voiced my concern about the executive summary going to town council before we see it, and apparently it is in process. We have not seen that executive summary. I think Elizabeth said something about that at our last meeting. I have that same concern I was going to bring up today. You want me to go ahead? Sure. Okay. Okay, I've already said that are we wedded to the content of this, and you're telling me we are not.
49:32 No, you as the Planning Commission should identify consensus points and if you have minority non-consensus points and we'll take that forward. Okay. Then we can get specific, page 32. And our general plan, excuse me, not in here, requires the development of a formula-based method and standard.
49:59 And we started this in 07 and it's to be completed in 12, 2012. Do we have an update on our formula-based? What page are you on? 32 of the general plan. Oh. I'm just asking about our several places in here. Page 104, for instance, talks about a formula-based method and standard being developed and we don't have it yet. Direction from the town council.
50:29 As resulting from your last workshop and the meeting beforehand was the community benefits incentive zoning process that's generally written and with the comments from council to be changed. It is implementing that action from the general plan. Our formula-based method is in the CPIS policy? Yes. In fact, if you remember, if you watch the tape, council member Sigamora
50:59 framed a, it's an evaluative formula. I'm trying to quote what she said. So that discussion from town council was held and they gave us work direction that would be part of the zoning code update. On page 35 of our district study, we have had discussions with Caltrans and you said that's ongoing. Is
51:33 Where is, what is the status and is the Mammoth Mountain ski area involved in those discussions? No, they're not. We have a project team in working with Caltrans. Ray Jarvis and the Public Works staff is leading the transportation and the mobility analysis. We've had a series of meetings with them. We also...
51:57 As you may recall, we were awarded a community-based transportation planning grant that supports this work and also some of the traffic analyses that will evaluate this study and the mobility plan. So in that contract, we work very closely with Caltrans in setting up the model formulation, the methods, the analysis, and as the grant or...
52:26 We have contractual relationships that we have to meet with them frequently and we have to provide reports to them. So we've had an ongoing process to date and we'll have an ongoing process subsequent to this effort. I guess in that same context would be my concern or interest in a redevelopment agency and I guess that's why I was asking about Mammoth Mountain Ski Area being involved because I would like to see
52:56 Main Street become a, you know, area, but it wouldn't include from, say, just north of the village, what trails, forest trails up would be, you know, that would be Mammoth Mountain ski area's responsibility, whereas the rest of Main Street to Minaret would be a redevelopment area. By California state law, communities are allowed to
53:27 Consider establishing redevelopment agencies and redevelopment project areas. And state law requires extensive findings of blight, physical, economic, and social characteristics of blight. It is the basis of establishing a redevelopment project area. So it's state-enabled. The town, it is actually on our future work program, not this year, but in a pending year.
53:56 It's part of the Dr. Sed's program to establish a redevelopment project area. And essentially, once a project area is identified, the intent is that future property tax growth, the tax increment, be used to fund those projects and activities that will correct the blight. So there's a process to go about. It's generally not legal to include non-blighted areas.
54:24 In a redevelopment project area, although some funds can be spent outside of a redevelopment project area. So if we were to proceed with one, that would be an extensive effort documenting physical, economic, infrastructure, building, parking, all of the conditions that lead to light. So it's in 2012-13, something like that, is your projected item? If I may, Mark, aren't you not, are you not reintroducing the redevelopment?
54:53 District Agency to the town? Because we already did have one. And it failed in the courts and the appellate court on Main Street. But then also, it must be a contiguous area, correct? It can't be Main Street here and then you skip over the golf course and go to another area of town. It has to be one district. So there's a lot involved in that. And it would be reintroducing.
55:19 Right. The redevelopment agency is probably still existing, but it's the characteristics of blight and setting the project area that's tricky, and it's also very controversial. There are a lot of entities that follow that and try to challenge it legally. So it's going to be a big effort, but it's a very, very efficient tool to cause, to implement these types of plans.
55:46 Well, I guess I was interested only in Main Street, up to Village and Batman. Okay. And then, of course, on 68, I guess all the red, page 68, these red streets, they're not all involved in the district, but certainly the areas north of Main Street, those new roads would be the sort of thing that we might be able to fund with the...
56:14 Financial. Right. Deferent. Okay. Page 91, I'm very concerned about recommendations. These are questions, right, Sharon? This is questions of staff because we're not going into deliberation right now, but that's okay. Because you said you'd have a list of questions. Okay. Well, those, I guess, would finish the questions. Because we have, we're listening to the public as well today. Sure.
56:52 May I interrupt just for a moment? Sure. Ray Jarvis is with us for a very short time. He has another conflicting meeting. If you have, you the commission, if you have questions for Ray, you might want to ask them now. Okay. Like traffic, snow management, those kinds of issues. Is anything specific in this?
57:16 I've got questions about 203. Is now the time, Ray? Okay, good. One thing that was identified in the copy of the PowerPoint that we haven't seen yet that was in our packet were catalyst opportunities. And the one that was sort of buried in this report, which I've said on three other occasions, gets in the way of itself, and I'll talk about that later. On page 106 and then recommendation 3.7, they talk about
57:46 Reconfiguring 203 and offering the frontage roads, you know, is that real estate opportunity that it is. I think personally and business leaders I've talked to say that's absolutely the first thing we have to do. There's a lot of concern on Main Street about they see this as a burden more than an opportunity and until government does what needs to be done with, you know, a road, this other stuff may not happen.
58:13 And so, where are we with Caltrans? I know they're positive about our concept, our ideas, as long as we can manage the snow, but planners talk about it from a planning point of view, and you start at the zoning and this kind of stuff, but practically, the road really has to come first. There's no discussion in here of incentives.
58:37 for people to develop their property so it's next to the street, taking back part of the frontage road, there's no discussion of how that could be a community benefit, the kinds of, like, discounts, you know, the town owns frontage road, so we've got this asset and we can use it. Correct. But that discussion isn't in here, so I'd like to know what is the status, that really, that's, otherwise it's a cart before the horse as far as I'm concerned. So tell me where we are.
59:03 Well, I think the largest piece of real estate left in town. Oh, yeah. So just tell us where we are. I'm sure that Mark and planning staff have discussed the fact that Caltrans has been at the table. We've been down there talking to them. They've been here. So they're in the loop in terms of what our thoughts are and what we'd like to consider going forward. Clearly, as it relates to the frontage roads and that land,
59:30 There are details that are going to need to be worked out. But we believe we can get there because as long as we maintain at this point a four-lane facility, the main road, we think we can make it work from a traffic standpoint. Now, Caltrans has said all along that as long as the traffic portion or the traffic flow continues to work, you know, they're supportive of what we want to do.
59:59 You know, the answer to your question right now is they're at the table, we're all talking, we're communicating, we're working through these ideas, but there are some details that need to be considered. Obviously, you know, how we use the frontage roads in the future, that's all part of this, but I think we can get to a point where we can use that frontage road as an incentive, and that's definitely something we've been talking about. Because that's a catalyst that's completely overlooked. Absolutely, yeah.
1:00:25 I think, you know, we also believe that improvements to the road itself or the geometry that we want, that's really the first thing that needs to be done. You know, we need to obviously figure out how to phase it so that once you start getting rid of the frontage road that it all still works. We haven't done that yet, but we can figure that part of it out. And then the snow management part, obviously that's a big piece of this. And at some point in the future,
1:00:54 You know, we may treat Main Street just like we do the North Village or Old Mammoth Road. In order to maintain sidewalks or promenades that people can use to walk on during the wintertime, we can't blow snow from the road onto those surfaces, otherwise you just, you know, you're done for the winter once you've done that. So, you know, we need to figure out how to burn the snow, come in, load it, and truck it off so that we can keep those sidewalk facilities open and useful in the wintertime.
1:01:24 So, you know, yes, there are some details to be worked out, but I think at the point we are now, we can, I think we can see how to make this work, but there's obviously stuff we need to do with Calrans. So you said the first priority is reconfiguring the road and getting that with Calrans? I think, you know, that's really the first thing that needs to be done. Okay, so that's a commonly held opinion out there. Now, where would you rank incentives for developing adjacent property owners developing onto the property?
1:01:54 onto the frontage road, real estate, that could provide for community benefits. You know, how, working out some kind of incentive program for people to do that that would result in community benefits. How to rank that? Yeah, where do you put that as a priority? Because I put it number two. Where do you put it? Well, yeah, I mean, it's certainly number two, or it's definitely near the top. I mean, if the idea is to try to move buildings closer to the roadway, then...
1:02:21 You need to provide some incentive for that to occur. Depending upon where we end up with geometry, some of those buildings may already be at or near the right location. If you want to put a promenade or a sidewalk adjacent to the roadway in front of a business, they're not that far off right now, some of them. But certainly, yeah, we need to provide that incentive to...
1:02:46 To implement this plan and have it come out the way I think people are looking to have it come out. Good. That was helpful. Thank you. Cost analysis of any been done so that the folks know what that cost is going to be in the future. I would assume that we're going to be looking at BADs and other things to compensate, not just the sale of the real estate. And I know from the past that we've had very high figures coming in on the cost of maintaining 203 and then snow removal.
1:03:15 Tens of millions to be, Frank, two-thirds of what our annual budget in the town is. So have you done any analysis to show the folks what it's going to be? At this point, we haven't done a detailed analysis of that. We have some idea because we can compare it to Old Mammoth, which is obviously a much narrower roadway. We can compare it to the North Village, which...
1:03:35 You know, it's not the same facility through the village as it is on Main Street, but we can, you know, we can come up with and give folks an idea of what that might look like. And an important thing to remember is that not 100% of that cost is going to be included in a potential benefit assessment district because there's a general benefit that the town would participate in. Is it also... It's roughly about half of the cost.
1:04:01 And are we still looking at with Caltrans from 395 taking over 203, or is there just a section? Has that been modified? Well, you know, we haven't had any serious conversations with Caltrans in the last couple of years about that, although I will say every time we meet with them, that's one of the first things they offer up is that facility. So we all know that they want to get rid of it. We all know we can't afford it. But we continue to. It's always on the radar screen. They would like to.
1:04:31 Just get rid of the whole facility and relinquish it to the town. You know, we have in the past talked to them about the idea of a segment in the middle, which could include Main Street and the North Village. Generally speaking, they're not thrilled with that idea. They don't want a discontinuous highway. But they have said that if there was some plan to continue that relinquishment, you know, say from North Village on up,
1:04:59 To the county line, then, you know, they might think about that. But, again, you know, we haven't had serious discussions about that in the last couple of years. When you say up to the county line, you mean up to Main Lodge? Yeah, up to Minaret Summit, essentially. Yeah, okay. And to their end of theirs. Yeah. Their responsibility. Yeah. I guess that's why I was asking about the mountain being involved in the discussions.
1:05:24 Yeah, well, we're definitely, we're always talking with Caltrans. We have a good relationship with them. You know, so I think as we move forward with these ideas, again, they're going to be involved in the conversation. We've discussed these ideas with Tom Hallenbeck, who's the District 9 director. So, you know, I think we're doing what we need to do in terms of that relationship. So I think it'll be helpful in the future.
1:05:53 When you talked about the elimination of the frontage roads being a workable possibility, is that true regardless of who ends up having ownership of and responsibility for 203 or the road through that along Main Street? Will that work either way? I mean, assuming I think so. I mean, and right now, we're not, we are looking to implement a plan.
1:06:21 Without owning the facility. Now, if we get to a point where, you know, Caltrans says, hey, we've got all this money to bring to the table in addition, you know, then it's a different conversation. But we understand that right now we're not in a position of taking over that facility from a maintenance standpoint. So, you know, we want to move forward with the idea that it's a Caltrans owned facility. So that's the context of our conversations.
1:06:47 That's why we always chuckle when they bring up the idea of giving it to us. One follow-up for you, just for clarification purposes. When you talk about County Line and Main Lodge, Mammoth Mountain now maintains Minaret from the corner of Whiskey Creek up to Main Lodge. No. In the wintertime, they do snow removal. Well, I shouldn't say flat out no, but from the winter closure...
1:07:15 Up to Main Lodge, they take care of snow removal. And that's what they meant, I'm sorry, excuse me, I meant snow removal. Oftentimes they'll come down farther. Right, and they have done that. Absolutely. So they'll continue to do that through this process? As far as I know, yeah. And so when you're talking about county line, you're talking about from Main Lodge down into post pile and that's winter closure though, so there's no Main Lodge. Well, I was thinking of summertime usage. Just the facility itself, yeah.
1:07:45 But, you know, if we ever get to a point where it's relinquished, it would be the whole facility, which would go all the way to the county line. So there was a comment you were making earlier. I think it probably brings into context what we saw as the overlay drawings of saying that a lot of the buildings may actually be in the right place because in a lot of what was demonstrated in this.
1:08:07 Very few of those buildings actually moved. It was road enhancements and landscaping enhancements and they then were the beneficiaries of better visibility and more mobility and that's where once it's decided who does that, that may be the options that we're looking at as well. Is that, trying to bring that into context because not seeing this, not seeing our own.
1:08:35 Streetscape enhanced the way we saw the others. It makes a huge difference, but I was watching those as those overlays came on and realizing they were very, with the exception of the parking building, none of those buildings really moved per se. And so those particular business owners could stay there but have much more enhanced streetscapes and accessibility through a plant like this. Yeah, I would say it's definitely a potential, yeah.
1:09:04 If we were able to bring some of the buildings to the edge of 203, would Caltrans truck the snow? Doubtful, just because of the cost. So they wouldn't have any place for snow storage? Yeah, certainly if you bring the buildings right up to the roadway.
1:09:32 Well, aside with pedestrian ways and bike trails. Right. Yeah, precisely. And the thing is, is we want to maintain those sidewalks year-round so that they're accessible. And in order to do that, you just can't blow snow on. So it has to be trucked off. And, you know, we've had this conversation with Caltrans in the past, and, you know, they're going to tell us that, hey, if you want to do that, you can do it, but it's up to you to finance that. Ray, do you have the report from?
1:10:02 I want to say maybe eight years ago now of the study that was done that we did on 203 with putting snow up the median of the road and coming out and tracking it back out. I had volumes of information. We had many of those that we've done in the past. I think the last one was 2006, but yeah, there was work done prior to that. I think one of the key concepts in this is the snow now is burned on the landscape areas.
1:10:33 And the businesses don't like it. However, the change condition is how do we finance for trucking incrementally? And ultimately this configuration is the idea that in the on-street parking, that becomes the temporary location for snow, gets pushed to the on-street spot when the storm occurs, and then trucking would occur. And then without that, it's unlikely that we'll find financial angels.
1:11:00 from Caltrans or anybody else who will just give us more money, truck it away. And so this forms a fundamental partnership in how can the town and Caltrans work together to implement a long-term plan that enhances businesses, that allows businesses through either business improvement districts or just through other funding sources from the town to solve that snow management issue.
1:11:29 And as long as we just talk in a circle, nothing will happen, and it will just stay mounds. Whether it's all in the middle or all on the side, there'll still be a mound. And so I think finding those right solutions to incrementally improve the business environment, that's a significant objective of this overall effort. Thank you. Any other questions that are waiting at this time? Madam Chair, would you allow me to ask a great question just to clarify? Probably.
1:12:00 Thank you. Great. This, for the record, is Paul Rudder since the public can't see him. And also, could you speak to the microphone? Yeah, you should be on the microphone. Yeah, you can jump back and forth. Thank you. I just wanted to clarify, Commissioner Tenney and Commissioner Dinkin raised a good point, and I thought it was important to have it clarified. If we wanted to change the use of the frontage roads now, can we do that?
1:12:29 Assuming we left 203 alone, can we change the use of the frontage roads without receiving permission from Caltrans? And the way I would answer that question is, yes, but. So we do own the frontage roads. To a certain extent, right? Yeah. But because traffic accesses State Route 203 to and from the frontage roads, you know, Caltrans is certainly a partner in that discussion.
1:12:56 So we want to make sure that from a traffic standpoint, it all works. So that's kind of a qualified yes. So you have to keep them happy, but there isn't an ironclad process of getting their approval to some million dollar plan to put them down to the base. Well, yeah, that's basically the gist of it, yeah.
1:13:22 You know, if there's, I don't know if there may be any legal issues related to, if the town just went out and closed the frontage roads that has an impact on their facility, you know, they may be able to make an issue out of that. But like I said, I think our relationship is at a point where we can work with them to make these kinds of ideas work to everybody's benefit. Thank you. Sure. And Ray, there's already been precedent set also with the Swiss Chalet project, which is now Mammoth View.
1:13:51 of Caltrans giving up some of the right-of-way that they had? They did. I think they had some excess right-of-way there that they gave up. I see Mary. They're shaking her head, though. I know there was something. They sold it. They sold it. Right, right, right. I didn't mean to give it up. I meant to give it up. Give it away. Right, right, right. Yeah, right. They don't normally give right-of-way for nothing because it is a real estate asset for them, too.
1:14:18 Okay. So I guess the question, and this is a very important question, and thank you, Paul, is that there's some places you can't touch.
1:14:25 Without talking to them or at least getting them involved. And this is one of the areas that they'll be interested in the outcome, how it affects flow of traffic there. But we do have the ability to plan and make those changes within our frontage roads as long as we're still keeping the flow of traffic into their area the same. And then if it's not, it becomes a discussion of us accepting the responsibility for 203.
1:14:53 That's right. And I guess, could I follow up again? We then determine the road cuts? The curb cuts? Road, right now, we have cuts, you know, so we can get into Manzanita and so forth. Can we close those? No, that's exactly what we're talking about. That's the issue. That's the discussion we would want to have. If we're going to redesign the road and get rid of the frontage road, then obviously you need to have parking in strategic locations.
1:15:22 And you want to be able to access it from the highway. So the curb cuts or the entrances to and from those parking areas may change. And Caltrans would certainly have an interest in access to and from the highway still. But it could be a cooperative effort. I mean, those particular road cuts that are there now are not set in stone forever. No. Thank you.
1:15:49 It's how it affects the flow of traffic onto there. If there's an improved flow, that's fine. But that's when they would want to be involved. Right. Particularly involved. Yep. Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. That was helpful. Thank you. I'm glad you were here. Thank you. Now I'll let you go.
1:16:08 Any other questions of staff at this time? And keeping in mind these with a study that we want to make sure that these are the important factors that you take to develop a plan and make sure that we're working on the right things like the long term.
1:16:24 This is long-term versus short-term. And the example of that, what's best to keep the traffic flow over the community, not on a busy Saturday next week. What are the changes we're doing right now? So it's looking much beyond that as well. And we will, at this time, there's not a per se public hearing, but there's a lot of people in the audience who have participated that we will be talking, allow them to
1:16:51 Continue to give some input on this to make sure to stay in focus. After Jay. I just had one more question of staff. Page 4 of the staff report, which is page 16 in the packet, the major catalyst sites were discussed. And the second one is the town and county property at Sierra Park Road and Main Street. It says that in the concept, this is an active sports park and event venue conveniently located.
1:17:20 Near to the downtown core, et cetera. Can you give us a, relate that to what's there currently? How does that change? We've got the county courthouse being built right now. How does it relate, how does the sports concept relate to that? How does it relate to the RV park? Yes. The civic center site was assembled through a forest service land exchange and it was intended to host a government complex, county,
1:17:51 Hospital expansion, Civic Center expansion, and also the State Office of Superior Courts. And the State Office of Superior Courts is located in approximately the northwest corner, and it's under construction. And then of that site, which is also shown on page 31 of your report, the generally northeast corner is county-owned, and that's a surface parking lot.
1:18:20 After the idea of the sports events park was framed and all parties started moving forward with that implementation, we met with the Forest Service and parties felt that it was certainly a useful idea. It added character aesthetics and programming to the environment to maintain the sports park and we had a conversation about
1:18:47 Shifting the RV, not displacing RV, but just sliding it over. And so the idea of the sports park, if it would proceed, it would have to be shaped around whatever remaining land might be on the Civic Center site or is located on the RV. RV pushes over a little bit, which would have even more direct, I think, connection to the school district properties to the south. Thank you.
1:19:17 So no other questions at this time. If anybody from the public would like to help contribute along this there, we're talking about the study, we will be recommending or making changes to additions to the study at this time. And it looks like Paul, you're first. My name is Paul Rudder and I'm a member of the public. A couple of things from the last planning commission I'd just like to bring you up to date on.
1:19:48 There was the issue raised about, you know, I was concerned about the gondola. And I was told at that meeting for the first time that it was Skip Harvey's idea. So I took the step of going to Skip and asking him about that. And Skip corrected me. He said, no, that's not the case. Actually, the idea was Rusty Gregory's. But there was a feeling among Rusty's aides and supporters that it would be politically more expedient to attribute it to Skip.
1:20:18 So that's the ideology of the gondola, which is what caused me some concern. Also with regards to the focus group, Tom Cage told you very confidently that if I check my emails, I find an email in there inviting me to be part of it. I was concerned about the focus group because although it does represent different demographics, less than half of the focus group actually has an investment on Main Street.
1:20:48 And I have, you know, a fairly substantial investment on Main Street and checking my emails, I was not invited to be part of it. And I talked to Mark Wardlow at the time. I said, you know, can I get on the focus group? And Mark said, that wasn't created by the town and I don't have the authority to appoint people to it. It was created by the mountain. And who's on it is the mountain's decision. It's another thing that created this feeling of unease in me that the plan that was created by the mountain and paid for by the mountain.
1:21:17 The gondola plan that was in fact created by Rusty, the focus group that was created by the mountain. I got the impression that this wasn't as community connected as the marketing was. In fact, if you look, I think it's in the report, it says that originally the town was supposed to be responsible for the planning and the mountain was responsible for the marketing.
1:21:42 Which I thought was kind of interesting because usually plans, you know, plans like this don't have a marketing element. But in any case, that was the source of concern that I had. On the other hand, I have, you know, having an opportunity to get this report and reviewing it, I think this is a really, really good piece of work by the town staff. Not to say that I or
1:22:09 You know, members of the public at large necessarily agree with everything in it. That's not the point. The point is that it's very good planning work. And as I think Tony, you were saying earlier, you have to start somewhere. You have to have a planning beginning. And this really is a good, solid beginning, a place for us to work. But I think Sharon brought out a really good point.
1:22:33 With all these meetings, and this is one of many meetings before the Planning Commission, it's hard for the public to know when they should get involved and where their input would be welcome as opposed to not. So in an effort, and town staff has made a really strong effort to get the public involved, I think that's critical to this thing being a success.
1:23:00 What town staff did, taking this from the original Hart-Howardton plan and turning it into what they've given you today, they have made tremendous progress not only on creating a good planning document, but they've also created something that has community input. So I think they're to be congratulated. Conversely, one of the things that's concerning, I think, the public out there is this is a planning document
1:23:26 But it doesn't have in it, and that's because of the kind of document it is, you can't read this and mentally in your mind see what Main Street's going to look like when we're all done. It's hard for people to get on board when you really don't have any idea what the final product is going to be or what the vision is or the goal. Mark showed us some photographs earlier of street scenes where people did changes.
1:23:56 And to a certain extent, understanding the process, it's a lot easier to look at those pictures and understand the process than if you read this with all the maps and things, it's still hard to get a vision in your mind of what it's going to look like. Those pictures really did a good job. But I want to refer to some of the pictures in the report. If you look at page 36 in this, you've got a photograph of Main Street. And this is really a great photograph. It tells you what we have today.
1:24:26 And I think it's fair to say that what we have today isn't going to cut it. It's just not consistent with a destination resort. Conversely, if you look at page 80, there's another photograph there that really jumped out at me. And I think it's important to consider this photograph. It's a photograph of a street scene. Interestingly, it's not a street scene of buildings right on the edge of the roadway.
1:24:59 To a certain extent, we've been talking about kind of a Park City model where you have buildings right on the edge of the sidewalk and then the road is right on the other side of the sidewalk. That works for Park City because it was built that way many, many, many years ago. But this kind of environment you're looking at here where there's a lot more space to walk might be more consistent with what the possibilities that we have on Main Street today in that the buildings are not.
1:25:28 On the front, right up against the road. And, Elizabeth, you had mentioned that, you know, in your mind there's a powerful priority about that. And I know that you've spoken to people. I just want to say, for the immediate future, moving buildings or building new buildings, it's not economically feasible. That wasn't what I said, though. Pardon me? I didn't say that. Okay. I didn't say that. Well, you had mentioned it as a high priority.
1:25:57 No, that wasn't exactly what I said, but go ahead and I'll say it. Okay, and I don't want to misquote you. I just want to say that it may be with our present configuration, we have opportunities to do things that we might not have if all the buildings were right on the street. And that's something I know town staff is sensitive to. And I think if we had computer-generated pictures of what Main Street could look like using the building configuration that we have now,
1:26:26 It could be fabulous. But at a minimum, if we had a walking around area, people who go to ski areas and get through skiing love to walk. If you go to Aspen or Vail or Whistler, any of those places, you'll see a lot of walking going around in the commercial districts. We can do that on Main Street without huge changes to 203. Changes would be great. 203 is not a thing of beauty right now.
1:26:55 But we can do things with the frontage road in creating walking around districts. And I asked Ray to clarify because I think we can do those things without huge planning issues with Caltrans, without huge amounts of money spent. And the town doesn't have the money. And individual business people like myself don't have the money. To a certain extent, and I asked Jen to put this up, it says build momentum through small successes.
1:27:22 To the extent that we can create at very low cost a walking around district and fill that people with happy shoppers who say nice things about Main Street instead of bad things, I think we can get a lot of momentum for this district plan without a great deal of investment. So to that extent, I would want to mention that because the people on Main Street with big investments,
1:27:53 Those are the kinds of things that we can get behind. Mark had mentioned to me that he didn't want
1:28:20 Opposition to these plans to result in churning where all the staff does is work at getting everybody to line up and support. To that extent, your fear factor will go down enormously when we talk about making small steps that will work and making changes if we find the steps don't work. Business people are afraid of revolutionary change because if it doesn't work, you're dead. With evolutionary change, you make adjustments as you go along.
1:28:50 So to the extent that evolutionary change can be embodied in what the Planning Commission talks to the Town Council about, I would certainly advocate that approach. Excuse me, Paul. I'm sorry. Question? Specifically, let me just make mention one thing, specifically with regards to snow removal, because you were mentioning it substantially earlier. And, of course, a big issue is cost. I know all about that because I provide snow removal on Main Street right now.
1:29:19 When the snow gets piled six feet high, the merchants that I represent scream like crazy, and we have the plows come out, and they pick up the snow, they take it to the trucks, and they take it away. It is, it's pricey. But let me tell you why it's really pricey. We create kind of a hole in the snow wall.
1:29:37 One day, my wife looked out the window and saw the Caltrans trucks coming and filling up the hole. So she ran out there, and you know when Kathleen's upset, she's the force to be reckoned with, she ran out there, ran into the street and threw herself in front of the Caltrans truck and talked to the driver and she said, you know, what are you doing? We just had to send it out. At a cost of thousands, I might add. And he said, we have orders to fill these holes. That's where we put the snow first.
1:30:06 So, to the extent that the town wants to create a district, I can't speak for all the business people, and I'm sure some of the people on Main Street will tell me I'm nuts, but if you want to create a district and have us owners pay into the district to help with the cost of snow removal so that we can have the whole thing clear from one end to the other, as long as you have this picture on page 36, Main Street is caca.
1:30:30 It's basically nothing more than a huge thoroughfare with giant walls on either side funneling cars up to wherever they're going. It's not a real main street with attraction to tourists or visitors. That's something that we could fix without huge change. We could create a stone removal district, and if everybody on the street paid in, I think the cost would probably be pretty reasonable. Frankly, it'd be less than I'm paying right now. So, you know, I have a personal...
1:30:59 But, you know, those are the thoughts that I had. And I think your discussion is great. You know, you guys have a handle on this thing, and that's really a credit to Mammoth and people like myself. The town staff has done dynamite work. My only caution, of course, is with respect to the gondola, someday that'll be a critical element to this whole plan. When we have enough destination visitors,
1:31:28 To use that facility seven days a week to make sense out of it. To the extent that the bulk of our visitors are still weekend visitors, if you use the gondola very well two days a week and not at all five days a week, that's a failure. The thing would be a giant eyesore. So I think that the gondola, for instance, if we can have a median strip in the middle of 203 where you can put it eventually, terrific. To put it there today, it's a disaster that would color this whole project.
1:31:57 And as far as redevelopment is concerned, Tony, I did note your points. I think that Main Street does have blight, Kentucky Fried Blight. And I think that it would qualify if you had a small enough district. And if your plan was to have, through redevelopment, a green orientation, a lot of the opposition that existed to the past redevelopment would not, it wouldn't.
1:32:27 Now it would be greeted with, you know, cheers. Excellent. So I think it's something we could do, and that money doesn't have to go to benefit individual business people, myself. Have it benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes by making Main Street something that everybody's proud of. And if redevelopment's where the money needs to come from, I think we can make that work. Yeah, redevelopment with a small R. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Don't go away. I got a couple points, too. No place to go.
1:32:55 You mentioned evolutionary steps in conjunction, and when you did, you were talking about pedestrians, pedestrian traffic. Yes. It sounded like one of your evolutionary steps was your snow removal plan.
1:33:12 Specifically to winter, but do you have any other, I'm trying to form in my mind other evolutionary steps as examples of what would give you the pedestrian movement you're talking about. Do you have any ideas? Yes, yes. We have this frontage road. We have four lanes of traffic, and then we have another four lanes, you know, on the frontage roads. I mean, you know, there are freeways that aren't that big. We could use those frontage roads as space to create the walking around district.
1:33:38 Also, the combination of our lousy-looking apron-style parking lots and the frontage roads now create event locations. And as you might have gotten from Flossie and Ken when they were here, the places for event locations are diminishing in Mammoth. Every time there's a new project, there's one less place for an event. Maybe we can have not jazz jubilees, but smaller events in our combination frontage roads and parking lots where we can have some real interest and excitement on Main Street.
1:34:07 And people would say, man, what a great community. This is a lot of fun. Not only in the summertime, but in the wintertime, too. But we have a place for those things to happen instead of just two more lanes of traffic on either side of that giant highway. And that's, once again, why I asked Ray about that. Something you guys can do without great expense. You can change the frontage roads, the use of the frontage roads, without changing the asphalt too much.
1:34:36 Sharon's right about the curb cuts, that's eventually got to be part of the plan, but maybe not right away. Two points of clarification, what I said about the real estate, oh that's okay, because I wanted to clarify their last meeting, and this time I'm going to be sure I do it.
1:34:55 What I was talking about with the frontage roads is a business that's set back, well back from Main Street, and we're talking about turning it into a boulevard, a complete street, you know, with sidewalks and parking and bike lanes and, you know, median and landscaping and beautiful. If it's an older business, they want to do a remodel, maybe even build a new one and bring it closer to that boulevard rather than having a sea of cars in front, I personally think there should be incentives for them to do that because that will encourage
1:35:24 What we're aiming for, which is a feet first community, you know, get people out of their cars and patronizing retail. I completely understand your point about these pockets for people to move about and events and that sort of thing, but that's what I was talking about when I said incentives for the frontage road real estate for businesses to move closer to what would truly be a Main Street. Then the other point of clarification, it's important that everybody understand your statement that town staff
1:35:53 Turned the Hart-Howerton into this plan. Town staff has done a terrific job. They were wonderful. But they didn't do that. It was this focus group, which was a broad representation, but not the complete representation of Mammoth. It was only 15 people, but a really good portion of the business community.
1:36:11 It was staff taking all the input from that group, which started out with a Hart-Howerton plan on the wall, and we went around this big table, what do you like, what don't you like, what would work, what wouldn't work, and people were very blunt. And so staff took that, and then they came up with ideas, you know, to frame the next discussion at the next meeting we had. So they were strictly support staff for the focus group, but because they're professional planners and know how all this stuff works, and because they are so familiar with the goals and the general plan,
1:36:41 That's when they came up with this book, which is, you know, a result of that. But it wasn't a matter of staff taking Hart-Howerton and turning it into, you know, the Mammoth Plan. No, there was a big process involving the community, and I think it's important that everybody understand this is a community process as it is now talking to you. And, of course, public input at Planning Commission is always welcome. Well, Elizabeth, I apologize for that. Yeah, I just wanted to be sure that was clear.
1:37:06 I wish I had been at the focus group so I would have a first-hand knowledge of what you're talking about. I would have said it better had I been there. I'm sorry. No problem. No problem. But that's how it worked. It was good. It was a good discussion with a manageable group, but I didn't see, as a representative for the Planning Commission, I sat in on all the meetings, and I didn't see it as a group that was biased in its selection or that the selection was biased.
1:37:35 It was just a broad representation. Well, Elizabeth, we all have our perspectives. Yeah, and that was my perspective from sitting in on it, but I can appreciate your perspective. Thank you. I appreciate it. I'm just curious, when you were interested in the focus group and the members, could you or did anyone suggest that you audit the focus groups, that you could at least come? Did anybody suggest that? I got the, no, they did not, and I got the impression that it was a private group.
1:38:05 created by a private entity, Mammoth Mountain, and that if they, they obviously know that I own some property on Main Street and have an investment there, and if they chose not to invite me, I assume that that wasn't accidental. I guess I thought all these kinds of meetings were public, maybe not publicly noticed, maybe not, I don't know. No, they're not, and as you recall in the scope of work and all of our district plans, we face, there's a,
1:38:32 There is a real challenge in how we effectively meet and listen and engage with groups. And, you know, it is never our intent, I'm sure it's not the Mountain's intent, to exclude people for particular reasons. And so the idea of the focus group for North Old Mammoth Road, for the East OSSC, for the Sierra Star Master Plan, has always been to have a smallish group of people where there can be dialogue and discussion.
1:39:00 And this group actually became quite large. And it's very difficult in a short period of time to go through a host of issues, understand them, discuss them, and then move on. And as Mary Handel might remark to you, because the group was so large, sometimes the group in a two-hour or even three-hour session wasn't able to cover enough ground. And so that's why we have a smallish group.
1:39:30 And that's why we also have our public presentations, our updates through Planning Commission and other commissions, and the community meetings. The last October, you know, we held the first community. In fact, Mr. Rudder was there. That was when we had the horrible snowstorm that snapped all my asphalt trees. And then we did a redo for this first meeting. And then we held a second workshop.
1:39:54 That was preceded by two days of walk-arounds where everything was posted up on the wall. So effective meeting management and public engagement is an ongoing mission for us. We have a web-based survey where we gather information. So we've done a lot. And we've been pretty proactive in advanced advertising of all of these meetings. So there's no intent to exclude anybody.
1:40:24 Apologize if you feel like you were excluded. We always remain open. And we're very, we actually met with Mr. Rudder yesterday, day before yesterday, and he gave us some very, very useful insight. And so it's an ongoing process, and we wish we could do more, but we do have time schedules, and we have only so much we can do.
1:40:52 But, you know, we try to make ourselves and the process as open and as engaging as possible. Sean, if I can point out, I think we're beyond the issue anymore. We've got the report that the focus group and the town staff worked very hard to create, and we're going to move on from there. So our focus really should be on moving forward. I didn't mean to.
1:41:17 Have us look backward. I just wanted to report to you what happened after the last meeting. I don't want to look backward. I want to look forward. I think everyone would agree that Main Street needs your time and attention. It's got staff time and attention. Everyone's time and attention. We appreciate, you know, we of Main Street appreciate the hell out of it because this needs to be planning commission, town staff.
1:41:39 Town Council, it needs to be everybody. It's everybody's town. Main Street is what you see first when you roll into town. It would be, you know, it could be so much better. I think with just walking around areas, we could have so much activity. The tourists and, you know, skiers and all would say so much nicer things about us. It would give people a feeling that there's a there there. Paul, I have a question for you, Paul, before you leave.
1:42:10 When we talk about a benefit assessment district, you know, you having the greatest amount of per square footage on that frontage means that you are the largest vote. You are the intrawest of Main Street, basically. I don't think I've ever aspired here, Tony. I had to say that, too. But so, and I think maybe the sheet will get a big quote for you. I don't want to go bankrupt in a couple of years. You just keep doing it over and over again. And so, you know,
1:42:39 To have that passed, you're going to need more of the property owners in favor of it. I'm hearing from you that you're in favor of that for a small area, walk-around area, that's no removal. What is your feeling on the rest of the property owners? I know two of them that have told me they would not be in favor and two that have told me they would be. I'll tell you what. What I would do is, first off, you can't ask somebody to be in favor of something until they know it's going to cost them. Well, I'm not asking you that. I'm just saying. No, no, I'm just saying. First, I did.
1:43:07 Do whatever I could to find out what it was going to cost. And then I would look at cost-benefit analysis and say, is this something we can reasonably afford? What would the cost, once we establish what the cost is, then I'd ask people like Ray, what's the cost going to be to the property owners? And then looking at that, I would go hat in hand to each property owner and say, this is what we're looking at. This is what it's going to cost. This is what it's going to cost you. Okay?
1:43:37 Can you live with this? How can we make this work for you? What benefits do you see? What dis-benefits do you see? Everybody who has a stake... Okay, I'm going to be a smart ass. I wouldn't have a focus group tone. I go to each and every person with something to gain or lose on Main Street and talk to them about how they felt about it. No, I understand. That doesn't mean we'd have everybody...
1:44:04 Not in favor, but I'd like to think we'd have a majority. I only ask that because, you know, a number of years ago, we had a benefit assessment district that failed. When we did Old Mammoth Road, the owners on 203 voted it down. So it didn't happen. Let me tell you something. I was an owner on Old Mammoth Road, and I worked hard to make sure that it got passed on Old Mammoth Road. I know what happened on 203. I thought that was a disaster.
1:44:30 Exactly. But at the time, that wasn't my focus. Right. But I think that that was a bad decision then, and I think it's reverberating through the years. And I'm going to defend Rebecca Peronick or Rebecca Landy here a little bit. After the last meeting, I did go back and look at the emails I received and details, and you were on it, but it was a four-year law office. It was one of your addresses, so I don't know if it's the one you still have. You might check in. You might check with Jim Smith and find out what you have.
1:44:58 It was listed there with your name on it. Moving forward, I appreciate your comments about moving forward because what you've brought is some great insight and I think seeing the evolution of a lot of those properties where the buildings didn't move gave us the start of the vision that we're looking at the very same thing because looking at this particular project, it's
1:45:26 It is a huge long-term project, but there's a lot we can do today to just improve what we have there, and the insight that you've given us today is looking towards what can we do today to make it look better. Rhonda, I really appreciate that you're with me on this, because I really wanted to, I mean, this is the Planning Commission we have now. Who is that guy who said, you know, let's work with the Army we have now. Let's work with what we've got now. Because that's what you have.
1:45:55 That's all you really have. Yeah, we want vision from the vision guys for the future. But we need stuff now. We need to make Mammoth better today, not somewhere down the road. And the millions to make huge improvements might be there. I'm sure they will. If we make small improvements now, the big bucks will follow. But have the big bucks arrive without those small improvements, I don't see that happening. It's an awful lot of vision to have. And if you don't have a plan, how do you know where you're going and when you get there? No, we have to have the vision thing.
1:46:25 As George H.W. Bush once said, we have to have that. But we have to have boots on the ground today. We have to have progress now. And if we can do it without spending a bunch of money, we're golden. We're looking good. Appreciate that. Thank you so much. Thank you. Anyone else? Lee? My name's Lee Gosh. There's one thing you haven't talked about on this is the sphere of influence. Sierra Valley Sites is within the sphere of influence. And it does...
1:46:59 Make me wonder how is it going to affect the sphere of influence. I know the businesses don't have enough parking on their properties and it could become Sierra Valley Sites problem because they already park on our streets all the time. Fourth of July, I have them parked in my driveway. I mean, they're just parked everywhere in Sierra Valley Sites. They cut through our streets. We don't want to be a thorough way to get to Old Mammoth. I know we have Meridian, but they still use our street and the police know they do it too. So how are we going to...
1:47:26 Get the people involved in Sierra Valley sites and the sphere of influence because we're the residential area. We're butted right up to the main street and all that stuff. So how do we, what happens with us? How is that going to affect us when all this stuff happens? I'm always looking into the future. We've got a lot of kids in this area. How do we protect Sierra Valley sites? We do need this to happen, but it can impact us a big time. How do we work with that, the sphere of influence?
1:47:58 Yeah, I mean, that's true to at least part of your question. One of the near-term efforts that we have coming up is actually the district plan for the Sierra Valley sites, and that will give us the opportunity to look much more closely at the specific traffic parking. I mean, I think we all recognize there are those issues in the Sierra Valley sites, and the downtown
1:48:21 NDP is looking much more closely really at the Main Street corridor, but it's really through the Sierra Valley Sites District Plan that we'll be able to look at those details, those issues in depth, along with other issues for that neighborhood. So you can have the Main Street District Plan and Sierra Valley Sites in one because we're within 500 feet of a frontage road, so I mean, that's two and one right there. The Sierra Valley Sites NDP will obviously look at the outcomes of this planning process for Main Street.
1:48:50 In a connected way, although they aren't going to be the same combined into one plan. Let me speak to parking travel. So in all of our commercial districts, we always want to make sure that there's adequate parking, that it's effectively managed and that there are shared parking resources. But we're always concerned about spillover traffic to residential areas. And I don't think at this point in time we haven't developed.
1:49:19 The detailed look of what those parking shortages and what those parking requirements are. So that would be one of our next steps. And in terms of traffic, we have two issues. One, we're fairly aware of the traffic calming concerns that Sierra Valley has. And that will be one of the key points of that particular district planning effort. And our traffic model, we can't run
1:49:46 Unlimited numbers of bottle rugs. We have to have a starting point. And so this is a really timely starting point for us. So we have land use assumptions. We'll have eventually level of service and intersection analyses coming forward through this study. So this represents the starting point of ideas in place of departure versus five alternatives all at once, which we just can't handle.
1:50:13 And then we'll be rolling out this information and we'll be sharing it with the neighborhood groups and Planning Commission, Mobility Commission, et cetera, et cetera, as we go forward. So we're not done at all and we're very conscious of that. And the same issues applied to the north of Old Mammoth Road. Cut through traffic, traffic management, those are all very important issues. And I don't think it's the intent of this effort or anybody who's participated in this to have
1:50:42 Significant negative spillover from this to the surroundings. It will be in conjunction with this, so since we don't have it lined out yet, but these are the issues that we're looking at, your issues are forefront there, that it would be how redirection of traffic, how it does flow through the whole town, particularly the adjacent sites. That's what the revenue is.
1:51:08 Why the residential sites, you know, there's always going to be days where, you know, one day, one particular day of the season that some things are going to be adversely affected. But that's not what you want to have every day. And that's where we're looking to have those alternatives. And your particular area, in conjunction with this, is forefront.
1:51:30 Well, I, we all live, you know, someplace, and we all, all of us work all the time, and so, and, I'm protecting them. Absolutely, and we're very well aware that this is part of what happens here. There's not a wall. And so, and not worrying about what happens on the other side of the virtual wall there. So all of this has to flow together. That's what the next steps are.
1:51:54 And then like on the frontage road, those places were built a long, long time ago and their parking spaces are very little. When you look into the future, you're going to be having more people here. What are you going to do? I mean, how are you going to eliminate these cars so that people go to these things? Because some of them could only hold maybe 20 cars at that, maybe 30. And you know they're going to be getting more and more people. So, you know, this is the obvious challenge of how do we progress through change incrementally and in part shift?
1:52:24 Where parking is. Do we have the most efficient use of our existing resource? I don't know. Mr. Rudder's comments are certainly we need to have a vision plan and work towards that, but what do we do now? And I think the image on page 80 is one of those very important images. Absolutely. It shows the elements of streetscape that you mentioned. And so if we're going to...
1:52:50 You can expect everybody to be concerned if parking is eliminated and not replaced. I mean, that just doesn't make sense. Madam Chair, I've got a question. Yes. In our packet, this is, I guess, for Ellen, there was a PowerPoint, which I thought we were going to be seeing today, and then we saw a different PowerPoint, but I just noticed on the front frame of it, it's dated July 8th. Who did this PowerPoint, to whom was this PowerPoint shown? I have some issues with the
1:53:20 Information in it, and I just wondered, this date of July 8th, whose PowerPoint is that? It's not referenced in the staff report. But Jen, do you know? That PowerPoint was presented to the Tourism and Recreation Commission on July 8th. And with most of the commissions, they haven't been as involved as you have in this effort. And so the reason we chose not to give you this PowerPoint is because we know that you've read this report.
1:53:49 It's the synopsis of the report, is what you were, that's how I understood it. This is the same one Mobility saw, and did all the commissions get the same one? They will, yeah. And so we, in fact, we walk through in detail with tourism and recreation, more of the panel boards, the process, the background, the history, because they just haven't been as involved as you all.
1:54:16 Well, since we, will this presentation be made to council, this PowerPoint? Some form of it. Okay, so would it be appropriate for us to comment on it today if we had disagreement with parts that. Okay. Okay, I'll wait until we get to discussion. Lee, did you have a question? This is for Mark. When there's usually a business within 500 feet of your house, you get a letter. Do you guys let people know within 500 feet of Main Street that this is happening so they can get involved?
1:54:45 No, we don't do that. One, because, and this is very much like rezoning a general plan amendment. If, by law and by tradition, we rely on noticing in the newspaper, either it's a public notice or an advertisement, and our weekly updates and our other forms, we typically
1:55:07 More often, you know, we don't notice for large properties or, you know, something like rezoning of the entire commercial district. We might not send out a letter for a notice to every address. But you'll do it for a business, but you don't do it for the district one? It's done for development of a new business. So a new construction is what you're talking about, or an event with noise.
1:55:32 No, I've got some within 500 feet of my house in their existing buildings, but somebody bought it and changing it, so I've got notices, so why do you do this? The noticing requirements are that, I mean, generally speaking, if it's a single property, you have a fairly limited number of affected surrounding property owners. In a case where there's more than 1,000 individuals that would be affected by a project or whatnot, the state law allows for that noticing to occur.
1:56:00 Through the newspapers, just because it's not practical to send out thousands of letters to people when you have a very large project area like this. Because it has a broader reach. The noticing requirements are different for a large-scale project. Because it does concern me. There's eight, nine people here, if that, and a lot of people don't read the papers anymore. They don't listen to the radio or the television. It's depressing to them. I know it's our responsibility to learn about this stuff, but there's not enough people involved.
1:56:30 We need to get more people involved, and I don't know how to reach them. I just want to say that in our last series of workshops, about each day we had about 45 people who attended the walk-arounds, and we had about 45 people who attended the community workshop. And in the world of public engagement, we do what we can do, and we...
1:56:53 About a 7,000 people, though. That's not... I think, Lee, what it comes down to, too, is passion. It's like you're passionate about where you live and what's going on, and it's you, I think, and your neighbors having to become passionate. And I'll use the marijuana cooperative issue. When it went before council, this room was packed. It was standing room only all the way to the back of the room, people there that were in favor. So they had a passion about it.
1:57:19 I think with Main Street, the business owners have a passion, but the surrounding property owners, a few of you do, which is good. Well, they don't know about it. I keep telling everybody, and they said they haven't heard. Well, that's, yeah. And the outreach is very strong, so continue to talk to them. We'd appreciate it. Eric. Hello. Commissioner, staff. Eric Seidmerer from the Mammoth Times, but I'd kind of like to speak as a citizen. I was very excited about Paul Rudder's comment, what could be done sort of in the short term.
1:57:50 Way on Main Street to create a walking district, and it just occurred to me very simply, yeah, the frontage roads as they exist now, just to convert them into sidewalks, essentially, that doesn't, as long as it doesn't affect, I know, the Caltrans easements, I don't understand where the lines are or private property lines, but in an uninformed way, the frontage roads could be made into sidewalks quite easily. You change the cuts where people can access the larger parking lots and center streets.
1:58:19 And then it seems like a relatively small investment to make it, without changing the ownership of 203, without affecting the snow storage areas as they currently exist, to make it an easy blocking district. Another point I would like to make was maybe addressing Lee's issue.
1:58:36 With the traffic affecting the Sierra Valley sites, I used to live there and I understand what she means, but it seems like that's part of the larger picture as well that I don't think anyone mentions, which is the mobility and the transit, you know, taking people out of their cars so that they're not having to park at that location. That would be key to solving part of this puzzle. And my final comment would just be a request for Mark, if you could try to
1:59:02 Speak a little clearer into the microphone. I don't know if you've heard this before. It's a little difficult to hear you even. Thank you. Eric, if I may suggest to you, get hold of Ray Jarvis and go back to the plans from six, eight years ago up the promenade, and I think you'll see what you're talking about and what Paul was talking about. Yeah, it sounded great. I wasn't aware of it. Let's get you a longer neck. Daddy's longer neck. That's what you need is a longer gooseneck. Yeah.
1:59:34 Or, or, or, or, you know, you know.
1:59:38 It's working, at least it's working today. Usually it feeds us.
1:59:40 At least we have consistent comments about that.
1:59:44 I have to do with that.
1:59:45 It's, it's continuing.
1:59:46 The, the, the, it's here.
1:59:47 Okay.
1:59:48 The voice. There you go. The voice.
1:59:50 Hey, you can turn yours on and off. We can't.
1:59:55 Thank you. Thank you. Um.
1:59:58 As again, oh, Mary, please come forward.
2:00:03 I'm Mary Handel with Mammoth View or Britannia Pacific Properties. I had the great pleasure of being able to serve on that. I wasn't so sure it was going to be pleasurable, but it ended up being a wonderful experience and I do want to thank the staff because you did put in an incredible amount of time working on that and it was hard to try to get everybody's input and you did have to keep the group.
2:00:27 Somewhat limited, although I do appreciate any comments that come in. I think everyone has some great ideas, so they need to be put into the mix, definitely. One of the concerns that was raised today, and Elizabeth, you started raising it, and I know it was because of our last meeting, one of the questions that came up was, okay, so we have this great vision, how are we going to make it happen?
2:00:51 And I think that's going to be always the question that we're going to come back to. How do we make something like this happen? Mark has mentioned over and over, no eminent domain. We're not going to go in and say, okay, we're tearing down this building and making you build. So what can we do to provide some sort of incentive? We do need to reposition some buildings. We do need to have some buildings redone. There's no doubt about it. And that's a very difficult thing for a person who owns a building now, even if it's somewhat
2:01:21 Not the best building. It's expensive to tear it down if they've already had the ability to have an existing business in it, to go and tear it down and then rebuild something. So what I guess I would love to see come out of the Planning Commission is encouragement when we're rewriting the zoning code, and that's why I'm here today because that's the next item on your agenda is talking about that. We need to put in place some incentives.
2:01:50 We certainly need to make sure that there are not barriers to people who want to tear down and rebuild. And right now, some of the codes that are out there that, well, I won't say codes because they haven't been codified, some of the policies out there right now, actually when you start crunching numbers to
2:02:13 Tear down and redevelop. They work counter to what you really want to accomplish, which is to have that carrot out there for them to rebuild and redevelop. And that's really better overall anyway because we want to make what we have work as opposed to going to just something that's undeveloped and keep working that way. So I really think we need to look at Main Street as maybe different in the zoning code with some redevelopment incentives.
2:02:42 to be there. The idea of a redevelopment district, state law is pretty harsh, and it is tough. And living at the state capitol and hearing ad infinitum about how the state has no money, I worry about timing. I think, you know, we'll
2:03:02 I'll be gone by the time we would get something done with redevelopment. I'm not necessarily saying we shouldn't be looking to it and maybe all our economies will turn around and everything will be wonderful, but I think we need to start now and particularly if we're rewriting the zoning code anyway or looking to update it, we really need to look at that right now. So that's what I would love to see come out of maybe this meeting and I just wanted to put that in because it really surfaced in our last district plan focus group meeting.
2:03:32 That we need to have some incentives for redevelopment. And, Mary, you're a land use attorney. Yeah. Maybe it's good for the public to know that. Yeah. I know that, and I think some of the commissioners do, but. Yes, I'm currently in house counsel, but I was, I did practice land use law, so I do know about the redevelopment issues and how difficult, I mean, they really, because there was some misuse of that law, so that's why they crunched down on it a little bit. Thank you. Thank you.
2:04:11 Madam Chair, Council, Planning Commission, John Verruck, I also was on the commission, or on the committee, whatever this was. Elizabeth says five meetings, it seemed a lot more than that. What did I say? You said it was only five meetings? It seemed like we had more than five meetings, but.
2:04:28 I think it was five, but you were five. We kept having meetings before the grill meetings. And maybe that's what it was, yeah. We didn't have a lot of these, but they were very productive. But we did spend a lot of time on this, and you guys are getting this thing for the first time, or just about the first time, and I just want to set some light on why we did some of these things. And number one, I'd like to say that at the very last meeting we had, it was unanimous to bring this forward. And it's not a plan. I think it's very important. This is the concept. It's not just a plan. It was just really easy.
2:04:58 In a way, it's a shame there's been a lot of time on a concept, but that's the best we can do at this point. And why, I think we all voted for it, I know I voted for it, for one main reason is that in five or six other concepts that we had, there was everything, pretty much except for this concept, you had to relocate a building. There was a back road, if you remember.
2:05:22 There was a back road, a frontage road behind some of the buildings. For instance, John's Pizza would have had to go because that's where the frontage road would have gone. So the one thing you need about this concept is that we in fact can, which is what I think has to be done, you build the road first. And it's going to be extremely expensive, I understand that. But for whatever reason, even if we're broke, there almost needs to be grants out there. I don't understand where these grants come from, but we seem to have millions of dollars in grant money.
2:05:49 I wish Paul was here, but I kind of disagree with the idea of a little bit at a time. We've seen that already in the grants that we've got. We've got sidewalks that may be going nowhere. So, to me, the very first thing that has to be done, and hopefully you'll put this in your agenda or in your recommendations to town, is that we build that road someway, somehow, and the road would be the redevelopment of the road as well as the side roads, the...
2:06:16 Parking, etc. In my opinion, and I think the majority of us on the committee felt that that road has to be done first. You don't have to move one building to do that road. After that road is in, again, with the side structures, the main road, everything, now you can do whatever you want. You can do the incentivized zoning for the, or incentivization for the owners, etc. Excuse me, John. Excuse me. 203 are the...
2:06:41 203. Well, 203 is also part of the... Is that the road? I mean, we've got the access roads and two, but you're talking 203. Yeah, if you look at that one picture where you see everything on there, when you see the cut, it's everything. You're talking 203, right off the top. 203, everything to the full 400, 200 feet, whatever the way this is. He's talking about the frontage roads also. Yes. He's talking about the frontage roads. You have to do everything. All 200 feet. All 200 feet of it, yes.
2:07:07 In my opinion, I think that was the majority of the, I think that's a complete, a complete redo. Very expensive. I think that's great. And you're going to give us the funding, right? Well, like I said, I mean, I can't believe the amount of money out there in grant money. It's not going to, it's not going to happen from this town. We're not going to do it. It's not going to happen with the mountain. It's going to be, it's going to be grant money some way, somehow. How you get it, I have no idea. I'm just saying that's what needs to be done.
2:07:31 You know, in our opinion first. And if you don't do that, we're going to have another hodgepodge that we have for the last 30 years. And, you know, none of the sidewalks we have aren't great, but they don't go anywhere. Take the one on the north side for the other post office. But that's the grant money that was available. And so all that sidewalks have been done by grant money, as Tony knows. So anyway, so, you know, redevelopment area, to me, the redevelopment area, yes, we need it. I don't know how long it's going to take to get it, but it should be this whole redevelopment area that we're talking about. That should be redevelopment.
2:07:59 And that would preclude anything else like you're saying about the mountain. It's just the area on Main Street and the L-shape in Obama. And again, I'll talk about the grants. The gondola, I think, is probably, in my opinion, probably the most controversial. And we had, one of our discussions was about the gondola and why to do it, etc. It probably was something maybe the mountain thought of.
2:08:21 But basically, the gondola, the way that I remember this two-hour conversation was that a bus will move, say, 400 people an hour, a gondola will move 4,000 people an hour. So, you know, that's the neat thing about it. And there were like two or three stops planted on Main Street. So if there's a hotel, it'd be great to have a stop there. And I think that when you get past the concept, what happens to staff is then you start looking at the cost. And my opinion is the cost of a gondola is going to be...
2:08:49 Extremely expensive, but then what about the operational cost? I know if the mountain does not run the gandola during the summer in the village because of operational cost. This gandola would not go down just Main Street. The master plan would be Main Street, Mammoth Road, and go up Meridian. So it's a very large complex. But it's something I think we should study, but that would be something that would be really tough to pencil in my opinion. The mountain influence that was mentioned.
2:09:13 You know, I was on the committee. I didn't see any mountain influence to speak of. This was the first part. I know that Rusty and Chuck put over $100,000 each into the original plan, and that was, yes, to help the town as a town. But as far as this committee, I think it was very, very independent. I didn't see any influence at all from the mountain. I agree. None whatsoever. The other reason that I think one of the...
2:09:38 The key reasons for getting this concept off the ground is that for once in the history of Mammoth we could actually have planning and we could actually establish a land value. Everything we've done, Planning Commission, you guys would know this, everybody who buys a piece of property in the past wants double density, they don't care what they pay for it, they pay too much for it, so they want something different. If this goes through like we envision it would go through, you know what the piece of property is worth.
2:10:04 You know, John's Pizza, you can build X amount of dollars on it. That's what that property is worth. You don't come before UNS for double density. It's already in the zoning code that's going to be established in the future. And also, you know, the parking lots, you're going to have public parking lots, things of that nature. So that's all part of the assessment district. I'm all in favor of assessment districts. It works, so I don't mind my throat. Between myself and Paul Rudder, I think we have the votes to pass the assessment district and he moved.
2:10:31 Basically, I personally think that the assessment degree at Mammoth Road is a very good example. One of the few things I've said before that I really think does a good job on, but they have kept this 50% less than what they would project the cost would be, and in my opinion, I think they do an excellent job with that. So those are just comments, you know, for...
2:10:49 You know, a year's worth of experience to help you guys when you make a recommendation. And the other thing is, too, is there were, and I don't know, about public comment, we had a couple, we had two or three public workshops, so it's not like the public doesn't know this. You had a number of workshops, I believe, that helped to frame this plan or this concept. And there was a number of people that showed up for me and that really get input. So anyway, those are my comments. They were well attended. Even in the snowstorm, they were well attended.
2:11:18 Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? It's time. So our options today are that we discuss and provide comments and forward recommendations to the council and determine if there's additional level of information that is needed before we make recommendations about the study. So once again, this is to
2:11:48 Do we have enough information here to provide or to start to proceed with the actual plan? And are we hitting the highlights and the points there that we've discussed? And is there something missing that we need to add for consideration? Correct. Are we going through the six questions? We can go through the six questions, absolutely, and see if those have we met or satisfied
2:12:18 Is there enough information for planners to consider things going forward? I'm going to start. Who wants to start? Elizabeth, would you like to start? Okay. Questions, deliberations, things that we would need to add to them. Where are you going to go through each question? Mm-hmm. Okay, so we're going to start with the first question. With the key components and recommendations, is that what you're talking about there? Yeah, right. There's a discussion.
2:12:48 Well, I've got six. Which page are you on? I meant this has been six questions from the last meeting. How many are in the packet? So the discussion questions was number one, the five? Yeah. Is it six right there? So if we look at that, if we go to number one, does the DNDP report adequately describe the key programming character components for the study area as a basis of development or future zoning development standards?
2:13:19 Okay, well, I have a problem with that one, which is also a problem with number two and number three. So number one right now. Yeah, but no, it's the same problem. And it's this issue of the way, well, let me do a little intro here. As I've said three times, the way the report was put together as a sequential documentation of the process, I think, defeats some of our purpose. I'm really concerned about that.
2:13:45 This is more important than the village. This is the most important planning effort we've ever done. For us to compete economically, we have to have a sense of there, there. We have to have a town that looks like a town, you know, instead of just sort of strip development along a highway. And our economy absolutely depends on it. I heard an expression, oh, in the last month, somebody was talking about paradise communities.
2:14:13 And I thought, that's what Mammoth is. It's a paradise community because we live in paradise. We're lucky enough to live here and we have to have a community that's worthy of where we live. Just like when we talked to the general plan about the development, the man-made has to complement, not detract from the natural because our spectacular natural surroundings. And I'm concerned because of the way all this support information has been presented.
2:14:40 that what exactly the focus group had consensus on and thought was the key priority is sort of buried. I'm very concerned about that. I would like to see, and I was surprised to have gone to Council, but I completely understand why, Chapter 5, the recommendations put first, and I would like to see a lot more discussion of the next steps on page 106.
2:15:05 And that's why I think that the study doesn't adequately describe, because it's buried on page 106, the next steps. There's no discussion, just a reference to incentives for the frontage road real estate, which may or may not become available, depending on where, for an adjacent property owner or someone else to purchase, depending on where the current building is located. The priority of doing, getting the road back first.
2:15:34 Isn't emphasized as mentioned as the next step under traffic studies and it's sort of a it's it's just it has to be more accessible I'm disappointed today that we don't have the executive the summary that we asked for I don't want to have this go to council until we see the executive summary I agree with Sharon on that the way that is presented with issues opportunities constraints can be weighted it can have value to it
2:16:03 And I think it's very important that we as the Planning Commission agree on what the gist of this is, what really, really matters. So I don't think it's adequate yet because it doesn't include incentives for development on the frontage road, it doesn't include the importance of getting the road done first, and the way the report is put together, sequential documentation of the process as opposed to
2:16:32 What was decided, you know, should be the intro, the executive summary, and then... So is it more formatting that you're concerned with? Oh yeah, it doesn't involve doing a new report at all. It's just taking all these different documents and reorganizing them. That's what it takes. Just putting Chapter 5 first would make a big difference. And then the executive summary with the issues, opportunities, and constraints and the consensus of the focus group would be the first thing after an intro.
2:17:00 And I think that the Planning Commission should see that before it goes to council. So that's where I stand. Would you list the three things again, Liz, but you said it's centers for frontage road. Number two, I think you said was 203. What is on page 106, which is next steps, should be have more discussion. It's not, the importance of it isn't, it just isn't significant. It's not enough. It really isn't. It needs to be emphasized more.
2:17:30 Chapter 5 is the chapter that talks about the preferred concept. You know, what was synthesized from all the information that came out and what staff worked so hard to do, it comes at the end of the document and it should be, in my opinion, and this may be a minority opinion, it should be at the beginning. This is what we agreed and then here's all the support information and here's how we got there. And it's very good documentation of the process.
2:17:57 With all the additional critical planning stuff to go with it. But I'm just very, very concerned at this critical planning effort. I mean, really, it's the future of Mammoth. Are we going to make it or not? All we've got to do is travel, go to other paradise communities and say, boy, they're doing a lot better than we are. And I'm very troubled by, I just don't want this effort.
2:18:21 The report on this effort to get in the way of this effort succeeding and people buying into it. I'm real concerned about that. Do you feel, if I may ask you, so when I read through this, the formatting didn't bother me, I thought it was fine. Okay. So my question for you though is, is it perhaps, and I'll just throw this out there, perhaps since you were part of the group and you're so connected to it, that you're seeing things that maybe the rest, that the person picking the report up may not see it the same way you do.
2:18:50 Because you're so close to it, but yet they still understand the report? Oh, no, I'm not implying, that's a good point, Tony. I'm not implying that people wouldn't understand the report. It's just, it was a big deal that we met and came to this consensus. And we had representatives from the advocates, we had business owners, we had, you know, all kinds of people, developers, architects, everybody on this group. And that we came to this consensus was really significant. And I think that consensus...
2:19:18 The significance of that consensus is not fully conveyed by this report. I think a well-written executive summary could do that. But the significance, it's buried in here. So if the formatting is left alone as it is and the summary is completed, that answers your questions and that would... My personal preference would be to have Chapter 5, the preferred concept first. But the summary has to be the very first thing. It has to be boom, boom, boom. You know, this is...
2:19:46 This is what we were faced with, this is what we discussed, and this is what we decided was going to work. I'm trying to think of a way that we could do this to keep the momentum going. Oh, no, I'm not trying to stop anything, but I don't want the executive summary to go to council until we've had a chance to review it and make sure that this is our recommendation. And I'm not talking about new work, not that sort of thing. And maybe nobody else thinks it's important to put Chapter 5 first. Well, I kind of do, but I think what I want you to say...
2:20:15 Well, I heard you say in response to Tony that no, that people can read it and understand it, but then what you said after that told me that people can't read it and understand the real points. They can't fully grasp the significance of these 15 diverse people coming together. But that's part of understanding the report. That's part of what? That's part of understanding the report.
2:20:40 Is understanding the significance of those points. The report makes it difficult to understand. Okay. That's my point. Can you sum up for us the recommendations you would have that would cure that? The one I hear you saying is that the preferred Chapter 5, the preferred planned concept be moved up. And the other thing I heard you mention was the... Was page 106, next steps. And the first one is a traffic study, but it doesn't convey that we've got to do the road first.
2:21:07 Okay, so I hear two things there. One is moving Chapter 5 up, but another is changing some emphasis in Chapter 5 itself. Rewriting page 106 with next steps. Just rewriting one page. We need more discussion on that page. Okay, would you move Chapter 5 ahead of the foreword and the introduction? Where would Chapter 5 go? No, I would do the foreword can be there or not. That was just my giving a little history. An intro is fine, and then the executive summary.
2:21:35 That's what I would put next. And then where does Chapter 5 go? After that. Right after that. That's where I would put it if I were reorganizing the document. Would you work with the staff to get that done? Well, I'm not sure you all agree with that, and I'm not sure staff agrees with that. If you did, though, was that something you could... Because I've expressed this three times. Well, the next question I would have before we discuss that is a question for staff. How... That sounds pretty easy to me for an electronic document. Is moving...
2:22:04 Chapter 5 up after Chapter 2, or putting an executive summary in after Chapter 2, and then putting Chapter 5 in after that, and adding to Page 106 of Chapter 5. I think I would answer it this way. The report is written is a sequential document. Right. Because it's a study. And I think, you know, discard the notion of an executive summary for a moment. I think what Commissioner Tenney is suggesting
2:22:32 is you need to have the, you want the powerful reader's digested document. Perhaps the study is fine, and perhaps what you really want is this, I'm just holding it up because it's skinny, so you want to be able to read this and understand the power, the punch, the importance of this vision plan to the community. This is not, and I think you're seeing
2:22:59 So I'll surmise that you think that this is in the right direction, and you want it to be a compelling story that generates community, political will, influence, and maintains direction with the concept. And so to that end, I might just leave the study as the study and produce this, whatever you call it, it truly is the summary, but it's the Reader's Digest, and you can understand, you know, the background.
2:23:29 All of that stuff is really background. So if you think of this as the study, you want a power punch document. Power punch. Well, now that Reader's Digest is out of business, or I think they're out of business, we have to remind people that Reader's Digest is not, you know, PowerPoints for dummies or anything like that. Reader's Digest was condensed. It's a succinct, compelling story that people can understand. Here's what we were faced with. Here's what we're trying to accomplish.
2:23:57 These are the constraints, but this is how this group of 15 people said this could work. And then here's all the support material from staff showing this is how it could work. A succinct, compelling document representing the synthesis of the focus group's efforts. And if there was consensus for that notion, we'd prefer to keep that as a separate document because, you know, we're already into the fiscal year and we really want to move all of our other work programs.
2:24:25 forward as well. Is that something you could get done in a timely manner to coincide with the progress we're making? Yeah, I think if you also have some consensus that you want to see that again, you know, we can take down your notes and come back to you at your next Planning Commission meeting and have you, you know, make sure that you've conformed all your stuff, we'll capture the things that you want to change and not, we're not going to redo the document though, right? We're going to bring it forward like we did the general plan with the
2:24:53 The comments and the responses so that we don't have a creeping incremental revision. And out of courtesy to all of those who have the document, including the town council, you can expect some members have written notes in the margins and we want them to be able to keep those and then see the progress as it goes forward. Okay, what was the phrase you used for what I'm talking about, Mark? A power punch document that compiles a succinct story. And that's not PowerPoint. No, PowerPoint. Okay.
2:25:23 Okay. But I need to hear from the other commissioners. Maybe I'm the only one who thinks this. Well, I mean, myself, I look to you. You were part of the focus groups. You were talking meetings. You reported to us. So I'm looking to you, really, for your input as you're giving. So I would be in agreement with you if staff could get it done and move it along. Yeah. I'm trying to resolve two conflicting things. I hear what you're saying, and in an ideal world where we had unlimited time and unlimited resources, I would agree. But...
2:25:50 We've got constraints. You mean reordering the report. Yeah. And I understand that. And maybe we need to elicit a promise from staff that they won't give this document to anybody and won't let them read it unless that other one's on top of it. I think very much. Unless your arm is twisted. But aren't you also looking at that document as being the, you know, you won't use the dummy thing that you talked about.
2:26:18 No, no, it's not that kind of thing. But to where the person coming off the street can come in and pick it up from the counter and not have to go through the study but can go through the report. So I have a completely different topic to take on this one. Okay. I would not leave the Chapter 5. Absolutely. You're telling them you've come to the conclusion. I think your format is fine because what you're doing is you're building the credibility of your conclusion here by
2:26:48 Introducing what this is about, what you considered, all the alternatives to whereby you have guided them to the preferred plan concept. So that's why this is working, because you're guiding them there. Because if you put it out front, it's presumptuous. And now all the time you're challenging
2:27:11 The reader is challenging the credibility of this and they're taking this preferred concept and looking backwards and forwards. So that's why this document worked for me because by the time I got to five, I bought it because I knew the work had been done, there was a credibility of everyone else. Now, do you need something that tells them in a shortened, condensed version at the executive summary that we went
2:27:39 Through all this, and this is what all of this resulted into, sure, you do need to do that because there's a lot of nuances in here that people may, you want those to be the highlights and the things that they do look for, but I still think that you're going to have to show you're going five days up front, and I think that's what you did. Okay.
2:27:57 That's the way I see it. Yeah, clarify that. I was saying also leave this alone. Leave this alone. Leave it alone and just do the other second. I think that that's the comment because this is out there for the council's review. They haven't discussed yet. They're going to be interested to see how we address points that individually they have written in the margins as well. And that's where...
2:28:21 And so those particular things, I do think that there's a few more things that we'll want to look for emphasis in the plan as we go forward, because that's what this was designed to do, is to draw those, yes, these are important, about defining the road configuration, and I see the frontage road as different. I see it as not a transportation alternative, but it's the actual destination.
2:28:45 You're trying to get all these people here. And so what we've seen today makes those frontage roads area as a place they want to be at, not an alternative to avoid the downtown, to avoid the main street destination. The transportation corridor, that's where I would like to see a lot of this guiding in there. And if that's a combination of blocked off streets for pedestrian and...
2:29:11 Places for parking as well as places for pass-through. I think you will, this can feel a destination because you showed us how to take, you know, a street that left a lot to be desired and to make it a destination and that's what I think we're going to look for here. Rhonda, you make a very good point. I think it was in my frustration that I wanted to rearrange the documents of the important stuff which was out there in the absence of.
2:29:37 The power punch, you know, in the essence of that. How are we going to do it? How are we going to get this important thing out there where people can see it? But I agree with you and I agree with Mark and people have it and they've made notations and if we can just get something out there that says we will, if you have consensus with that approach, we can commit and we can bring that back to you. And Sharon, I haven't heard anything in addition to you, but are we building a consensus?
2:30:03 I think what Elizabeth said is on target. I had a few other things that are very specific that I wrote in the margins. When do we do that? If you want additions of things that you think that should be part of the study that the study opens that up to where those could be in the plan, I think that's probably the time right now if there's anything that we missed because I have a couple more as well. Okay. Go ahead.
2:30:32 Me, in my personal concern. By the way, I guess before we even get to that, is there any way that we could take page 63 or 64, either one, and do an enhanced video like you did with the ones you put on the screen today? Overlays. Thank you. I expect you're going to have a yes to do that one. It was so visionary. I don't know that we can because there's some...
2:31:04 Photographic, it's photographic montage work, and I don't think we have the facilities to do that. Okay, so the ones you had on the screen today were pulled from somewhere else? So the techno experts are saying, no, they don't have the stuff. Because that would help, I just think, immensely. No, we're smart enough, we just don't have the software equipment. Yeah. Because that, a picture of these thousand words. Well, and at least we can now envision what.
2:31:32 You know, different paint and different sides can look like, but we'd sure like to see that eventually. Yeah, it's pretty specialized. Yeah, I know that. I'm concerned with page 91, excuse me, 92. Recommendation 111, it says 1.11 on that page, 92, where it says
2:32:02 Protect public views to the extent possible. I think that is in conflict with our general plan. Protecting public views is not negotiable. So those are just four words that I think are out of place. Page 96. What page? 92. I think I need a little bit more clarity on it. You're talking about protecting public views.
2:32:33 Over private views? No, I'm talking about those four words, protect public views to the extent possible. Well, that's pretty standard. I think that's how the general plan says. That's how the general plan says. General plan says protect public views, period. That's a concern that I have. General plan C2V and C2W. Maintain scenic views.
2:33:10 Preserve views. That was one concern I had. 96. Is there any structure now currently on Main Street that's 55 feet high? I just, for example. Yes, these. Shiloh and. Shiloh is approximately. What is it? It's 106. Yeah, Shiloh. Shiloh. Shiloh. Shiloh and next to McDonald's. Thank you. Oh, okay.
2:33:47 That way. It's actually taller than 55 feet. Right. It has that. But that's just the tower. The tower is too, but the building itself is 55 feet. The building is 55. Thank you. And then the pertinences go up to whatever. 102 or something. 100 feet, 106 feet or something. Page 97. Do our codes require complete streets today, Mark, from what you said? I don't think so. No, they do not. Thank you.
2:34:16 And then the other thing was just was there some way. Oh, I have a real interest in the roundabout at Sierra Park Road. I noticed that that is the second alternative. I'm just concerned, and I guess that won't show up until we do the actual traffic modeling. Right. It's in the preferred alternative. So we would place that and then see where the traffic flows. You'll try it first because
2:34:44 With that roundabout that close to a traffic signal, I don't see how it can work. But we won't know that until you do the modeling? Correct. So if that is a preferred alternative, the traffic signal may be relocated or something, that may be one of the options. It's not leaving it exactly the way it is. And that goes back to what Sharon brought up about the public view is that if two or three is changed, diverted, it meanders,
2:35:13 The public view you have today is going to change. And that's what I think that's referring to. So it's not in conflict with the general plan. I don't see 203 meandering. I'd say I'd use that as an example if it was to in the final plan. Right now it's not, but what if the final plan has it meander, right, curve as it goes up, you know, by Gomez's. We've talked about that in the past. So that could happen. So I think that's what the public view discussion's about.
2:35:42 The reason we typically will use to the extent possible is we're not trying to create some trick or mechanism to exceed building height, nor are we trying to have a word, you know, a phrase that's so complete that says protect public views, and then some people will say, well, any building blocks my public view. Exactly. That's the only reason that kind of qualifier is in there. Sharon, can you cite in the general plan? Because I know this pretty well. The only thing I can find is on page 17.
2:36:12 Maintain scenic public views and view corridors to visually connect community to surroundings as a policy, but I can't find the phrase preserve public views. Do you know exactly where it is? And I don't recall it. And it wasn't in here to protect public views just to be absolutely specific what it says. And the plan. Protect. Protect. Protect public views.
2:36:47 To the extent possible, and those were my concerns. Yeah. C2B, I don't know what page. Page 17, C2W. Okay. That's the only reference I can find according, or, you know, in the general plan. But maybe it's someplace that I've forgotten about. I guess page 17 is correct, and see, they're both right there. Yes. Maintain scenic public views and view corridors. And the one above that is preserved views.
2:37:25 I think that's the other one you referenced, Sharon. C2V and C2W. Yeah. Okay. They're both of them. Okay. Yeah, I don't see a conflict, but yeah, I don't see that. You don't see a conflict? No. No. Sharon, were the other things that she wanted to make sure that we... I had a concern about the roundabout and the traffic signal, but apparently that's not going to happen until we get a traffic modeling. And, of course, I wish there was some way to actually do the enhanced...
2:38:03 Matt, but we don't have any way to do that. Not in this time, but I think... We think eventually we'll have that? I think that whenever comes forward we're going to have a better vision of what things could look like at least in conceptual drawings. Would that be part of the plan we'd look at as we have with others? Yes. And eventually we're going to get to what we hope...
2:38:27 Can be some immediate steps. Are we going to talk about that today? Well, I think that's part of the study that helps you guide to those steps. Because those things are the actual actions that we have to take. And today we're providing, here's the information, now come up with the actions. Okay. Well, the only other concern I have is the letter from the Water District and how that impacts what we're doing today with this study. And I don't know when you want to discuss that. It might be helpful.
2:38:57 You know, if you could go through your sections, you know, page by page. Let's do that. And then when you're done with that, we'll respond to the water district comments. Thank you. Appreciate that. Okay, Jake, I think we're still on the issue of number one. We're still on number one. Yes. And I don't have any further concerns with respect to number one. Okay. I think I expressed mine as well. Johnny. Okay.
2:39:29 Thank you, and Elizabeth, thank you for your input there. Did I accept? I wrote on it, sorry. I appreciate that. Doesn't the report include an appropriate list of project requirements and community benefits that can guide future decision-making and CPIS proposals within the study area? There's a list, but I don't think it's the mechanism for how
2:40:00 You know, the frontage road, real estate, and just all that, it's all intertwined, and how that can result in community benefits, I think needs to be explored more fully. Maybe this is premature, but I don't, it includes a list, yes, but I don't think it's the comprehensive. We don't have it defined yet, but this is the list, we don't know how it's going to work. Yeah, exactly. And that's not what we would know at this point. Okay. But here is the list, now figure out how this works. Is that being satisfied? Yes, that is. Is that list appropriate to the study right now?
2:40:28 Appropriate to what we'll be doing in the future. Probably. Yeah. Okay. Sharon, do you think that the list covers the things that we will be looking for? Well, and it's not, it says it's non-inclusive, and so I, it's, it's a concept. It's a good start. Conceptually? Okay, thank you. Appreciate it. But the reports program's elements describe adequately to guide future implementations and financial, financing plans.
2:40:58 I think we heard from Ray today what, you know, looking at the areas now, which are the priorities as far as Caltrans and what those costs, how we need to come up with, if this is what you're going to do, this is what those things will cost. Do you think that they have the information from the study that those are the priorities? No, this is the one I had the issue with about next steps on page 106. I didn't think the discussion was thorough. Not long-winded, but just, it just wasn't adequate.
2:41:26 You should tell us that you... Where? What else? Page 106, the first step. What needs to be added in? I don't know. Just sit and think about that. Well, I... Can I... Yeah, Jay. As background for the... I agree. The only thing I'm not sure about, since this is a concept, is how much detail do we need here versus just emphasizing what we need to do next. What we expect to do next.
2:41:57 I like what Ray said to be in here, you know, the summary of what he said today. Well, as background for why I think this is a concern, in our discussion today, first of all, it was mentioned at one point that on page three of the staff report, which is page 15 in our packet, the need for incremental changes is mentioned. Then, in Mark's slides, he mentioned
2:42:24 at one point that we need to build momentum through small successes. Then when Mr. Rudder was commenting, he referred to, I think, the same thing as evolutionary steps. And I see all this as a snowball that's building momentum and telling me that all these are ad hoc indications that we need a look at the next steps overall from the point of view of...
2:42:52 How do we parcel this up into things that we do in a sequence that builds winds as soon as possible and as much as possible? And some of those were alluded to. For example, Mr. Rudder said, all you need to do with respect to the street at the start is get those frontage roads turned into pedestrian area and maybe area for events and such. That was an example of one of those small steps.
2:43:22 How specific does this need to be at the concept stage? I don't know. But I do think that as a minimum in the executive summary to be added, there needs to be something that very emphatically states how important this next step is, how important it is to get the phasing right so that we get as big a success as possible as soon as possible and build on it with each increment that is implemented.
2:43:51 Is that something we could have, like, you and Elizabeth work with staff on, on that summary? You're volunteering me? Yes. And Elizabeth? Okay, that's good. I agree because it's, you have to have the entire concept, but then it gets into phases. But what we do want to avoid is taking care of just a portion at a time that doesn't have any relationship. We want to avoid, you know, we've heard people today say, okay, the first thing you need to do. They may be right.
2:44:21 But my point is, somebody needs to look at that overall and say, is that the right first step when we consider the whole thing and how best to do this all properly phased. May I recommend that each of us send to you some of the things that we would like to see on that list? Yes, and not just some of the things you'd like to see, but...
2:44:42 What sequence you'd like to see them and why that sequence is important. But you can't send it to us. You can't send it directly, though. Because it's a brownish thing. You need to send it to staff. Well, maybe we can quickly do it here, then. If you know if there's some sort of things. Well, I just like what Mr. Rudder said about the snow assessment district, and we all hate that, those walls of snow. I mean, to me, a necessity. I think we're in consensus about that one is a major priority. I mean, it's snow management.
2:45:09 Is that is something that we have not experienced before in order to make this work. And our current methods will have, it's not within our current scope of how we do this, so that is a major consideration there. Now the only other question I have is how does this fit into the sequence of what we recommend going forward, what goes to council when, and so on. So I think consensus-wise what you've done, vision plan, summary, the power.
2:45:40 Punch document. You'd like to have before and after. If we can do it, we will. If we can, we can. Develop first steps, phasing planning, as well as emphasize the importance of that phasing plan to continue momentum. You'll meet with us and work this out. And then if we bring this to you at your next meeting, we will have concluded also the
2:46:02 Mobility and Public Arts Commission comments, so you'll be able to read those comments as well, and then if you wish you could take your action and recommendation to the council. So this subcommittee that Elizabeth and I have been suggested to make up, we'll try and get that done ready for our next meeting. Is that right? Yeah, like this week. Would that not be in the report?
2:46:25 So what we'll give back to you in your meeting, we won't make changes to this, we'll give you a brief cover agenda, and then you'll have a RATA text, and we'll map what it is, what you think should be inserted, and we'll suggest where it should go in the document, and then you'll be able to look at that, look at the document, and say yes or no, recommend, don't recommend. So it won't be a final what we get next week, I mean next meeting. No, and so... We'll still be...
2:46:54 Playing with it? I hope you're not playing with it. Well, you said we would then make some changes. No, so what I'm saying is you will meet probably this week with the committee group that you just appointed. We've noted what you want. Your agenda packet for your next meeting goes out next week. And, of course, you'll be meeting at the plum parcel. So we would like you to consider and act on.
2:47:22 These modifications and send this thing on to town council if you're ready to. And so our hope is that we've got this nailed down, your ideas, we're getting snow management, and you have reasonable consensus at this point. And I think your point on the implementation is it's as important as the image itself. What's our quote? A vision without implementation. It's a hallucination. Yeah.
2:47:52 Okay. Does that sound like it meets your expectations? Okay, and then the power punch goes to council as well. Yes, so you'll look at that and you'll make your recommendations summary, power punch. Great. Yeah, but we'll give it a different name. Thank you. Okay, that's great.
2:48:14 Number four, did the concepts and recommendations adequately relate back to the framework of guiding principles and issues? Yes. I think that we are making sure that that's the priority here. I think it does. Okay, was the process adequate to ensure the report recommendations a reasonable degree of the community and consensus, stakeholder consensus? Other...
2:48:37 Other than the fact that you can never have enough outreach, I think the whole U.S. Census is a perfect example of that. Knock on doors, you can tell everything there. You can't reach everybody no matter how much you try. Sharon and I and others attended the infamous meeting of the snowstorm at the Eagle Lodge and what was good to see the cross-section of community that was participating in that.
2:49:07 This, there is, and the other thing, I think, bear with, you know, bear with staff that we are taking input every time. It may not be part of, you know, the actual process and decision-making process, but we're hearing from the public at every opportunity they're here, and I want to continue to do that, and I appreciate everyone's time and the public's time as well, because this may be a schedule, but.
2:49:34 Your ability to come may always be according to our schedule, so I appreciate everyone in the public that participates. Other thoughts on that? Yeah, I mean, people can disagree about what percentage of the public is necessary for it to be good participation, but I was at least two, maybe three of the workshops, and my qualitative sense, not quantitative, was that there was a lot of public participation. I think it was adequate. I think it was adequate as well. Discerning from folks around town.
2:50:06 I certainly received a lot of input afterwards from people I had not heard before, so that was encouraging to make sure that you remember this particular issue. Are the next steps in additional analysis tasks described and appropriate? Does the information need to be refined?
2:50:24 I think that we are answering that question. I think the answer would be no, but we're taking steps to ensure that it's yes. And making sure that we give you a clear direction on that. I really appreciate that. So the options that we've considered and discussed here, the option one is we would not require additional Planning Commission meetings and would allow the draft report to be reviewed by the council, and option two would require additional Planning Commission meetings to discuss.
2:50:58 The downtown draft report. And we've kind of come up with an option three. Well, I don't think we have to take action on this, right? Because we're just continuing it. So we'll come back at your next meeting with the following in the update. Okay. Thank you. It's been quite a long single item session. We do have one more.
2:51:23 Item, but I would like to take a 500 break for those of us that can still stand. And we'll come back. Thank you. And then we will resume with our final item there. Thank you. The zoning code update. Thank you. This is in response to a request from the Planning Commission on a report on our work sequence of the zoning code update.
2:51:48 And so the purpose of this report is for us to obtain your input on our sequence and process for the zoning code update. This is similar information that was provided to you in December, and additionally we have provided you with attachment A, which is an outline of the phases of the code update, the adoption sequence, as well as the planner
2:52:15 Thank you. Thank you.
2:52:42 Do you feel, I guess, are these the, is this the right order to be working on these particular issues or is it, Jay? Yeah, I think we have no, we have no issues with it. We feel it's the same for what we need to get accomplished. Okay. It's not necessarily. For our committee to move forward. It's not necessarily linear. Some of these aren't dependent on each other, but these are the scope that makes the vote. Right. Thank you. Just one quick question on page 31.
2:53:09 Phase 3 is the general plan, zoning map, and zoning code amendments, and that's the one that's been such a sticking point for us because, you know, the zoning code isn't consistent with the updated general plan and that just makes all kinds of problems. Why was that put in phase 3? This is just the section that discusses how to amend the general plan, zoning map, and zoning code. So it's not, the general plan is going to be
2:53:36 Weave through the entire zoning code update, so this is just simply how you can... That's what I would have figured, but that word just jumped out at me. I think a good way to look at it, too, is, I mean, we're rewriting a code. We're not just taking, you know, words out. Oh, I know, yeah. We're writing a brand new code for us. Right. Okay. So the code's going to match the general plan. Okay. So Tony and Jay, are you happy with this format? Good.
2:54:05 So now the question's ready to turn you loose. Well, Chair, do you have anything to add? Yeah, I have a question, I guess, on page 27, page 4 of this part of our packet. You will bring each completed chapter to the user group. Does that then come to us at the Planning Commission? Not chapter by chapter, probably in larger groups, we'll bring that to the Planning Commission, yes.
2:54:36 Each phase, so you're talking like these phases? Well, that's our intent. We haven't fully decided how we're going to put everything together to bring it. Yeah, because we don't want to bring it chapter by chapter. That's probably too small, too detailed. But then if we bring it by article of the zoning code, there are issues because some portions of each article are done at the end. So we're still working through how we're going to present that to the committee. So if I could add to that.
2:55:05 There's a couple of different things going on. Some work, like some of the district planning work, will feed into the land use districts and building envelopes, the general development standards. And so we have a 12-page master sequence of all of our work program items that all link up together. And the purpose, so when we have a block that you can understand and it's intelligible.
2:55:33 We bring it to the zoning code users group as a litmus test. As users of the code, architects, planners, property owners, can you understand that? And then from there, we come to the Planning Commission and hold a workshop with you and a litmus test to see if you can understand it and also to talk about policy. And so that will be an early draft peek at that section. And then when we've completed and followed up with your comments,
2:56:02 We draft it, we set it aside, and then we move on to the next section. And then some sections, like the sign code, will process completely independently. So for us, this is going to be kind of fast and furious because some sections will be proceeding and they'll go to user group and planning commission. And then as another staff member is bringing forward their section, that might be shortly on the heels of that.
2:56:31 Sandra has prepared her overall scope of work as a consultant would for the zoning code and then each member who has a section, they've prepared scopes of work that Sandra and I both review them and integrate them into the program. So we're operating as if we're consultants in this effort and it being very businesslike but also meeting the time standards that you all have asked us to meet.
2:56:59 And then as we meet through the user group sharing, it comes back to public workshops at Planning Commission. So each of the chapters, you will have public input at every step of the way, with every chapter as it comes forward. Well, no, I thought you said phases. They're really kind of, they're phases and some will be multiple chapters and some will be four. Okay, because I mean, you've got it nicely laid out here and that's what I was...
2:57:29 Helping you the day to day. Right, so we can expect updates, you know, timely updates, because there might be some times that you may want to be coming to us, much anticipating the things that is moving ahead of the work that may not be a completed phase, but it's important enough to bring it forward and say this is what we accomplish. So timely, timely updates to the Planning Commission and user group. So we might.
2:57:57 You know, might be practical for us to prepare a monthly update on the really hot work program items for you. So zoning code would be a standard. The district plans as we move. So we could do that if it's useful. That'd be great. That sounds good. Good. Thank you. Moving on then to briefing matters. We have none. And then the director's report. I have...
2:58:22 None. I was only going to mention that the signage work from the MLTPA and Public Works is moving forward. And so, again, early August, you'll see the prototype and John and Ray are working fast to make sure that the nomenclature of these places is going to come forward correctly. And then occasionally we should expect mistakes and we'll have to find a way to update our signage if there is a mistake.
2:58:49 Thank you. And you're going to take care of that one issue I brought forward about the village of Mammoth and North Village. Yes. Thank you. Announcements of future special meetings. We have nothing special scheduled at this time. Is that correct? Correct. Okay. Excuse me, but I thought you were going to address the water district letter. Oh, we should have done that through that item. If you would like, I can either do it orally now, or we can just...
2:59:18 Give you responses in your written package. Yeah, I thought you were going to give us a written response, you had said earlier. Yeah, we'd prefer to do that. We really don't have any issues with them. I think they're just a little confused about when CEQA is conducted on a project versus the role of a study. And we've been very, very, I can tell you this, we're
2:59:40 Including the Water District and our Design Review Committee, that's the group, the internal staff at Fire District where we review projects. And we just received an application for Mammoth View and a concept plan, which is Mountain Boulevard and the Swiss LA site. So we're getting them in very early in the review process so they can understand and track and be part of it. And I met with Mr. Norby on Monday.
3:00:08 Did we get a copy of the September 21st?
3:00:39 24th, 09 letter? I'd have to check our records. It doesn't say to copy us, so I don't know if you gave it to us or not. I'm sorry. Whereas this one that we got today does have us and Town Council CC'd. Oh, did the Planning Commission receive the September 24th? I don't know. If you'd like to see it, we can... No, we have it. They sent it to us. But at the time, I don't think we were given it September of 09.
3:01:11 They didn't give it to you. It doesn't say CC, but when it comes to you, you don't automatically send it to us. Thank you. For our committee, our user group that we have for code updating. Your first meeting should be signed code related. Yeah. Are we able to add one more person from the public onto that committee? Would you have an issue with that? No. I should check to make sure that.
3:01:42 I need to see if it should be... Because we have four people, there's four individuals and then Jay and myself, so if we had one more that would make seven total. Two of us... That's not unreasonable. Okay. And we can just do that between you and I or Jay or we can... Sure, if you don't have any issues with it. Okay. Public comment is still open. If there's any further comment that we have not discussed today or on our agenda, entertain that. If not...
3:02:10 Public comment is closed and we will adjourn to our regular meeting of the 28th at 2 p.m. at the Plum. Yes. At Tamarach Street. The Plum. Is it possible to have that meeting start at 1.30? We can do that and get over here at 2. Yeah, is that possible? Does that work for you, Rhonda? Or not? Of course. Of course.
3:02:36 1.30 is fine. We need to public notice that in addition that we will be meeting there and we will start at 2 o'clock here. That sounds good. Okay. Did we get that change that we got?