TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015

Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 36 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

287 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Good afternoon. I now call the order, the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for April the 29th, 2015. Roll call, please. Commissioner Grayack? Here. Commissioner Tenney is absent. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Vice Chair Harvey? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand and join us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Michael, would you like to leave it? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

0:31 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, and with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we'll have public comments. Public comments is that portion of the agenda where anybody can speak on any item that is not on today's agenda. Do I have anybody that would like to speak for public comments? Yes. Hi, everyone. My name is John Robertson, and I'm the operations supervisor for Eastern Sierra Transit Authority.

1:10 And the reason I'm here today is to talk really briefly about an award that we received this past month. What we received is we were part of the California Association of Coordinated Transportation. And what that is, it's a nonprofit organization that represents small, large transit agencies, government, planning departments and such. And this past April 14th was their spring conference. And we were awarded

1:40 The 2015 Rural Transit Agency. So that is for everyone, the employees, board of directors, everyone that makes this possible. And what it was for was for our service through a big diversified area spanning 400 linear miles all the way from Lancaster to Reno.

2:07 Follow the expansion of transit service that S has been involved in, in the Mammoth Lakes area and the surrounding area, up to and including the Reds Meadow service, other dealings with Forest Service, different counties, and our involvement with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area and providing transit service through the whole town. Well, I just really want to congratulate everybody that's associated with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority and

2:37 Going back to the days when we used to have these yellow school buses driving around town, we've come a long ways and it's really a lot of credit to everybody that's affiliated with your organization and we're really proud of you guys for doing it. Thank you very much for coming and sharing that with us. Congratulations. Thank you. Are there any other public comments? Sandra, perhaps since we have so many visitors, would you have to comment on why we have an abundance of denim today? I think we have a deep thing.

3:12 Yes, today is Denim Day. It's a day that is sponsored by Wild Iris here in our community. And it's a day where people wear denim to mark, to raise awareness of sexual violence. And so that's why all the staff are wearing denim. And it started in 1999 with a court decision in Italy where

3:40 A woman was assaulted and the judge said because she was wearing jeans she had to have been participating and she wasn't actually assaulted and so it sparked international outrage and so a lot of different organizations started Denim Day to raise awareness of that issue. So that's why all the staff are wearing denim. Annie didn't know about it.

4:09 And to give awareness to Wild Iris, which is a terrific organization in town. All right. Are there any other public comments? Then I'm going to close the public comments. Today we have two public hearings. Public hearings follow a very definitive format. What happens is the chair will open it. Then there will be a prepared statement by the staff. Then there will be a statement by the property owner. There will be questions.

4:40 from the commission, then any person that would like to speak from the public will be given an opportunity to speak, there will be a time for rebuttal, then we'll close the comment period, and then the commission will deliberate on the matter. So that will be our procedure that we're going to follow today, and our first public hearing today is to consider approval of the mountainside project, it's tentative tract map 15-001,

5:09 variance, 15-001, use permit, 15-001, design review, 15-001, and adjustment, 15-001, located at 413 Rainbow Lane, and we will be asked to find that the project categorically is exempt from CEQA pursuant to section 15332 infill development, and our staff person on this is Jen.

5:40 Thank you, Chair Brown. The Mountainside Project is a 16-unit project located at 413 Rainbow Lane. The project includes two standalone units and seven duplex buildings. These units will all be three bedrooms with a two-car garage and the buildings themselves are three stories. A variance is proposed to reduce the setback along Rainbow Lane and to increase the height of certain buildings.

6:06 The Commission held a site visit and workshop for this project on March 25th and did not raise any concerns with the project at that time. The town has received comment letters from both Courchevel and Snowbird owners, which are the properties to the east and north of the project site, and so I'll focus my presentation on the major points raised by those comments. The first item relates to the setback variance. A 25-foot front yard setback is required along Rainbow Lane.

6:37 The project is requesting a nine-foot reduction to propose a 16-foot setback along Rainbow Lane. The reduced setback would result in the preservation of the steeply sloped portion of the site to the south, which ranges from seven, the whole site slope ranges from about seven to 30%. A variance approval requires that the finding

7:06 that there are special circumstances applicable to the property that the strict application of the zoning code deprives the property of privileges enjoyed by other properties in the vicinity and the same zone. In this case, the steep slope of the property would constitute a special circumstance and disturbance of the steep slope on the southern portion of the site would be inconsistent with the general plan and design guidelines of the town that

7:34 that require preservation of steep slopes also nearby properties in the same zone and in the vicinity have buildings that are located approximately 10 to 16 feet away from Rainbow Lane a variance approval also requires that the finding be made that it would not be detrimental to public health safety or welfare or injurious to property improvements in the vicinity since Rainbow Lane has the standard 60 foot right of way

8:03 That would accommodate the required snow storage and snow management activities. This project would not actually reduce that width. The project would reduce paving that is located on the private property of the project site, and so it wouldn't actually narrow the street itself. Although the reduced setback may modify or increase the extent of shading on Rainbow Lane compared to buildings that are located at a 25-foot setback,

8:34 This town's snow management policy, which identifies snow removal and management procedures, would result in this not being a detrimental impact. The reduced setback also allows for the mountainside buildings and the Courchevel buildings to be offset, which would be more beneficial in terms of snow shed and access to light. We've also had comments about a 20-foot setback being required between

9:05 The Mountainside Project and Courchevel. So that would be the east property line. In that case, for a 20-foot setback to be required, the property line to the west adjacent to Canyon Lodge would need to be considered the front yard. The town staff, in consultation with our town attorney, did not consider that to be a front yard.

9:32 because it is not a town street it does not provide access to the property site or to the project site and it is leased by Forest Service for a parking lot not for access the next topic of comments raised relate to building height so variance has been requested for the height of five of nine of the buildings to exceed 35 feet

10:02 The A buildings are the duplex buildings located to the rear of the site and those are proposed to be 38.8 feet tall or 3.8 feet above the maximum allowed. The C buildings are the duplexes along Rainbow Lane and those are proposed to be 43.9 feet tall or 8.9 feet above the maximum allowed.

10:27 The same variance findings for the setback are required for the height variance and in this case the preservation of the steeply sloped portion of the lot is also a consideration here. That preservation would result in more than 12,000 square feet of the lot not being developed which under normal circumstances would be developable.

10:51 Therefore, it is staff's opinion that it would be reasonable to allocate additional building envelope to the project. The proposed 6 and 12 roof pitch affects the height exceedances requested. The commission reviewed an option for a 4 and 12 pitch at the workshop on March 25th, which was considered to be less desirable aesthetically. Also in terms of snow shedding, a 6 and 12 roof would be considered more desirable

11:21 Since it would allow for less accumulation of snow and reduce potential snowshed impacts. The closest point between the proposed mountainside buildings and the adjacent Courchevel buildings would be approximately 27 feet, which exceeds building separation requirements. The nearby Snowbird building is approximately 43 feet tall, and the 1849 building is approximately 60 feet tall.

11:49 Therefore, the building heights proposed would be considered within the context of the heights in the neighborhood. Furthermore, the lots, the A buildings, the duplex buildings to the rear of the lot of the site would be located at an elevation approximately 9 to up to 20 feet below the elevation of the adjacent rear Courchevel building. The next topic is the dumpster.

12:18 The dumpster is proposed to be located in the side yard setback adjacent to the Core Cheval project. This location appeared appropriate to staff because it's readily accessible to both trash and recycled vehicles. Also, it would be enclosed with a standard trash enclosure which would be faced with stone or other compatible materials. The discussion of an alternate dumpster location has been identified in your staff report for discussion.

12:49 Comments have also included concern of the appearance of the building facades along Rainbow Lane. Since a reduced setback is proposed, the pop-outs and variation of that facade are proposed to be limited. And although the design appears to meet town requirements, the commission may have feedback or suggestions for some additional enhancements to that facade.

13:16 And I believe the applicant, Mr. Hooper, might have passed out some elevations where he's thought of some other options as well. We have received comments, concerns about the photo simulation. The photo simulation of the project shows the project from the most prominent public viewpoint. So this is the vantage point from the

13:45 West looking towards the project from the Canyon Lodge property. Since Rainbow Lane is a one-way street with vehicles traveling east, there would be limited public views from that opposite direction. And it's the town's practice to not require story pole plans or the erection of story poles if we have an accurate photo simulation of the project in context.

14:15 And lastly, although no major comments have been provided on the alternate housing mitigation plan, the commission may wish to discuss that. The alternative housing mitigation plan would allow the developer to choose to pay either the $23,222 fee or pay the housing fee that is in effect at the time of building permit issuance.

14:40 So based on staff's analysis, it is staff's opinion that the required CEQA, Municipal Code, Subdivision Map Act, and variance findings for the proposed project can be made and recommends approval of the project with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications as directed by the commission. And Mr. Hooper, the applicant, is here to provide his statement. Before we move on to that, does anybody have any quick questions?

15:09 Would you just do me a favor now so people in our public understand the difference between public view sheds and private view sheds? So public view shed, the town's general plan and land use regulations only protect public views. Public views are those views that are available from public streets or public areas such as public plazas, public parks, things like that. So private views, say from an individual condo owner's window,

15:37 is not protected by the town's regulations. Thank you very much. At this time, would the applicant like to come forward? John Hooper, the developer who brought this project to you today. As you know, we have already had, I'll try to make this brief because it was already had a workshop a few weeks ago and a site visit to the location and also to some, the Gray Fox Project, which are pretty much identical buildings to what

16:22 We proposed to build there. They're a little bit narrower. And there's some aspects of that project that we wanted to change in this project and make it a better project. Just really quickly, some of the positive parts of this project for the community. One is, I think it would be a welcome addition to this neighborhood. It's going to be a newer, more modern project, pretty much luxury townhomes.

16:51 And it's surrounded by older, dated perhaps condominiums and single family dwellings. So I think it would bring an increase in value in everything around it. Another one that I mentioned before, but it's sort of a different form of residence or rental in that area. Everything around it is a single family dwelling or a condominium. These are townhomes.

17:20 A bit different as far as residence and rental in that area. There's some obvious ones, TOT, property tax, that the town would benefit from. Another's jobs, it's going to be probably done in two phases, so it's a couple years work for, if it's anything like the projects we're on now and we're on last year, 50 or 60, 70 jobs for employees and subcontractors for a couple years.

17:50 I'd like to just go ahead and address the variance, just since there's some concern to those in front of you, and I have some other copies if people want it, but some of the reasons, the height variance I'll address first. You've seen it with a, first of all, the building got higher because of the Gray Fox Project. We had 16 foot wide doors, 7 foot height doors, and an 8 foot 6 garage height, and they don't work in Mammoth.

18:18 SUVs, larger vehicles, pickups. So we've increased the garage door width, which increased the building width, to 18 feet because you can't get two cars in a 16 foot door width. And we've increased the height to an 8 foot door instead of 7 plus room for an opener above it. So we're starting with 10 or 11 foot height in the garage area. And one aspect of this project which we wanted to change in the prior project

18:48 was to give people owner's storage. It's right across from the Canyon Lodge, so it would probably be rented quite a bit. And so we've increased the size of the garages and given owners space, owner storage space. So the garages are large, they're tall, so we're starting with a pretty tall garage. I could have decreased the height by pushing it back into the hill, but then we're disturbing property that we didn't want to disturb. There are a lot of really large

19:16 Old-growth trees back there that we didn't want to disturb. The main reason is in front of you. It's that handout I gave you that shows you the difference between the 6th and 12th pitch and 4th and 12th pitch. So these handouts, do you also bring some for that? Yeah, I brought some to the forest. Maybe you might want to just pass them out so that... But anyway, you know, this location is basically a hood ornament. I mean, it's a really...

19:47 It's a lot that's really viewed by a lot of people that are using the Cagney Lodge area. And I think it's very important to have these buildings. They're going to be there a long time if they get built. So I wanted them to be attractive. And I think we all agreed, you all agreed, that the 4-12 pitch was pretty unattractive. We had it designed for the Gray Fox Project and immediately discarded, and those were approved with the 6-12 pitch. To me, that's the major reason.

20:16 To have the height variance. A lot of it has to do with pushing them back into the hill and that being undesirable. That's a major reason. And I know some of the owners of the Cocheville Condominium Project are concerned with the height. But you've got to remember there's 66 feet in between these buildings. 64 feet in between the buildings, a corridor that you still have a view through to the mountain. I know we're not supposed to worry about the effect of view.

20:47 to private property, but there is quite a wide corridor there that you can see through the way it's arranged. The other was the variance, set that variance off of Rainbow. Rainbow is a one-way street downhill. It's a 60-foot wide easement. And again, to reduce that, we would have to push back in the hill and again disturb property that we didn't want to disturb. That's one of the main reasons that we wanted it. Plus, if you

21:20 And Hayes can verify this from Public Works, but we've looked at the pavement configuration on that street. It doesn't really affect the snow starch of that street much. And again, it is a one-way street, accessed from a parking lot one way downhill. So it doesn't much affect it. And the, you know, the effect of pushing it back in the hill would have really removed a lot of unnecessary, larger trees and undisturbed area. So that's about it as far as the variances in what I have to.

21:54 Relay to you today. If you have any questions, I'd be glad to answer them. Do you have any questions? I do. I have a really quick question. One of the handouts that you gave us, Mr. Hooper, I think shows maybe a modification to the facade that faces? Right. There was some criticism that I actually agreed with, that the facade on the rainbow side was just too bland, too plain. So,

22:22 In response to that, I've created the new elevation on the rainbow, at least what we've suggested that we put some architectural variation on that elevation of the building. We can't turn the buildings around and put the architectural front of the building on the street because you'd have 10 driveways. It makes no sense to have to point in. So we've tried to dress up the rear of the building with what I've shown you there. Thank you. You're welcome.

22:54 Commissioner Harvey, did you have any questions at this time? Commissioner Craig. Can you just, what again was the opening height for the garage? So you went to an 18 foot wide door, but you also went to a taller garage door, which affected the story height? Yeah, we went to a wider garage door. When the building gets wider, the roof gets taller because of the gabled from width to width. So when we went to a larger, wider garage,

23:26 You have to have 18 inches for a garage door opener, plus an 8 foot door, plus there's a beam that hangs down 6 inches. So instead of a 7 foot height door with no opener, which would be an 8 foot high garage, these are closer to 10 or 10.6. Then when you put a foot of joists on top of that, you've already started with an 11 foot base on which to build a two story unit. And a 7 foot high garage door opening isn't adequate for an SUV, with ski racks.

23:57 Yeah. You have snow built up in front of garages. Sometimes when you enter a garage, you've got snow in front of them that hasn't been removed. It will compact so your vehicle gets a little... After four years of being here, I can tell you that a seven-foot-eye garage door is virtually worthless in Mammoth Lakes from experience. So that's the reason. And the width of the door makes the building wider. Yes, of course. What's the approximate square footage of...

24:27 The units? 2,000 feet. Three bedroom, three bath. Large two car garages with owner storage. And that's the same for the two standalones? Yes. Okay. I don't think I have any other questions. We don't have any other questions. Thank you. So at this time, we encourage those members of the public that like to come forward to speak. I have to ask you to come to the podium and announce your name. This is being televised.

25:16 So if you speak from your chair, unfortunately, the people that are watching us on TV in the future won't be able to see. And also, we limit public comments to five minutes per person. So if anybody would like to come forward at this time, you're more than welcome to. Hi, my name is Sloane Maletsky, and my husband and I, we own Courchevel Unit 54. Our unit is immediately adjacent to the proposed building site.

25:53 And we have some rather significant concerns about the variance requests that have been – that are being discussed here today as well as the location of the dumpster. When my husband and I were in escrow to buy our condo unit several years ago, we were a little concerned about what could potentially be built next door to us. So I actually made a phone call to the building and planning department. Unfortunately, I don't remember who I spoke to, but I was walked through all the height

26:20 and setback requirements along with the density requirements. And I got a level of comfort that these codes were in place to protect us from any future development. In addition, I was concerned that maybe a hotel would be put up next door, so I asked specifically about utility sites and kind of where deliveries were made and dumpsters and what if, you know, the proposal to develop that area wanted to place that next to the Courcheville units.

26:49 And I was told very explicitly that the city did what it could to ensure that homeowners, existing homeowners, were protected against future development. So it is rather troubling that my husband and I now find ourselves today trying to explain our point of view as existing homeowners and how we feel that the proposed development is potentially damaging to us. And just so we're clear, we're not against a development. We knew that at some point that was a prominent corner lot

27:18 That at some point somebody would want to develop it. And we do believe there's an opportunity that we can meet all of the welcome addition comments that Mr. Hooper raised and that can all still be done. We can still create jobs. We can still put in a nice set of units there. But we think that it can be done also if we work a little harder in a way that is not harmful to the existing homeowners. I'd like to speak just a little bit to some of the comments that Ms. Daugherty raised.

27:48 with regard to why they think the initial planning committee thinks that it's okay that these variances should be granted. I'd like to start though first with the 20-foot setback. We really believe that that was a corner lot. If you look at it from above, from any town maps, if you think about

28:08 There's Rainbow Lane and there's Lakeview Lane at the top. It really is a corner lot. And so to try to say it's not really a corner lot just because the Forest Service owns the land underneath the road, that just seems like kind of ridiculous to us. Everyone in our community believed that we would have 20 feet between our property line and anything that was going to be built there. And I understand that if you measure from where our existing structures are, perhaps the proposal is a 27 feet gap.

28:36 But that's because we have a larger setback from our property line. And we still all believe that we would still have that 20 feet between our property line and any proposed development. And if you look at the plan that the developer submitted, it does show that they're going to be building right up to that 10 foot setback. In addition, if you combine that reduced setback with the height, those two factors joined are what really make it

29:04 Bad for us. And we also believe from the Rainbow Lane perspective. I mean, it's true that, you know, you could argue that there's no nearby property injury by having the reduced setback from Rainbow Lane, but when you combine that with this extra tall structure, it's these two factors combined that make it actually worse. If you had one or the other, maybe it wouldn't be so bad. But we think that we need to look at these two factors in conjunction with one another.

29:31 The folks at Courchevel, we are asking that story pools be erected because we think that it's very complicated to take a photo rendering submitted by the developer and try to understand what that means in terms of the height. The elevation plan submitted say that these buildings are going to be 42 and a half feet tall. So it's very hard for us to understand how now we're claiming that they're only going to be 38 feet tall from the back.

29:59 So clearly there are going to be some issues with regard to how things are grading, being graded, and the slope of the lot. And we think that without those story pulls, people in the nearby communities and nearby homeowners really aren't going to have the full effect of how this development is going to impact their homes. And we think that that's an important consideration. In addition, the point was brought up that from an aesthetic standpoint,

30:25 The Planning Commission thinks that it makes more sense to go from a 412 roof to a 612 roof. Well, if aesthetics matter, shouldn't they also matter from the standpoint of the nearby homeowners who now are going to be confronted just 10 feet off the property line with these really tall, extra-closed buildings, not to mention the dumpster? Is that my time? Let me ask you, are you speaking on behalf of the Courcheville organization, or is it...

30:54 Are various members from your association going to speak today? I know a lot of you from our letters have very similar issues. Right. I think our board, the president of our board did submit a letter on behalf of the board and the community, but unfortunately with the short notice, he could not be here today. I don't know if there are others that plan to speak, but my husband might give me his five minutes.

31:18 Would this be fair, since so many of you have very similar issues, why don't you summarize your issues of the organization, and then if there's somebody else from the Courcheville complex that has some additional information they'd like to add, then they could come forward and add it. Would that be fair? That's fair. I don't want to speak on behalf of any other Courcheville members that may be in the audience, but I guess to try to then sum, to get things summed up,

31:45 What I'm saying, what I was trying to go with on the roof slope is maybe from a drawing it looks better to have a 612 than a 412, but think about it, if you're standing on Rainbow Lane, when you're looking up at a tall building like this, the slope of the roof line is not going to make much of a difference, but it will make a tremendous difference for those of us on Courchevel that are now going to have this on

32:08 The sunlight blocked. And as we all know, with snow, sun is an important factor in making sure that the snow melts in a timely manner. So I think just overall, the folks that I've talked to in Courcheville, we want to encourage a development, but a development that is done in a thoughtful manner. We would like to encourage the folks here today to deny the variance requests.

32:36 To make sure that we call the corner lot what it is, a corner lot, and have a 20-foot setback from Courchevel. And in addition, we would like to request that Mr. Hooper relocate the garbage dumpster away from our buildings and on the other side because there would be just as easy access for folks living in that community to throw their garbage away if they walked to the other end of the community rather than to our end. And it would just save us from the sight, the smell, and the sound.

33:05 And we would also like to propose one potential compromise if the development still needs the length that would be required for us to forego that extra 10 feet in our setback. What if there's a variance on the other side? So it seems to us that there's not really a need for as big, since there's no need for a setback on Rainbow Lane, maybe there shouldn't be a need for a setback on Warming Hut 2. And take that 10 feet, give us

33:35 Our 20 feet setback that the corner lot should guarantee us and just shift the whole project over 10 feet. And at least that would be a compromise solution that would enable us to have a little more space between our buildings. Thank you very much. I know it's not easy to get up and speak and do a nice job. Thank you. Is there anybody else that would like to speak? Hello, everyone. I'm Rob Carson. I would like to speak in favor of this project today, the outside project.

34:14 For a few reasons. First reason is the public benefit that was brought up earlier, which is providing jobs for locals and stimulating the local economy. John's provided quite a few projects like this in the past and over the last couple of years. Myself, quite a few subcontractors in town have benefited. You know, it's quite a few tough years out there with the economy. But he, probably 75 to 100 people I think would affect.

34:44 Providing jobs for the next two years. Also, I think as far as providing a new structure, updating the area there would be a nice addition. Let's see, also, I'd like to speak, as far as the height goes, I think aesthetically it would be much nicer with that 6 and 12 roof. It's also performance, it would be a safer project with less snow accumulation.

35:18 I was involved with the project, the Great Box Project, and it was approved, pretty similar, same heights, same pitch, and I think it looks great, blends in with the community, with that local area, looks really nice, so I think it would be, like I said, a great benefit to that area. Again, the, you know, the heights, there's many tall buildings there already, so I think, you know, he would, I don't see why you should allow him not to have the same

35:47 Same height as some of the neighbors, or even less, you know, the 60-foot height, 48 feet. Anyways, I think it would blend in real well height-wise. That's about it. Thank you. Are there any other comments? Well, commissioners, Matthew Lehman. Good to see you guys. Nice to see you too, Mr. Lehman. It's been a while. Anyway, I'm here today to speak in favor of the project for a couple of reasons, and I'll try to keep it short. But I'll start off by just,

36:29 Saying, you know, I live at Mammoth Fireside, so I appreciate what a lot of the folks are saying here. I had to write a few comments myself because 8050 was building next to us and there was a project that's going to go where Whiskey Creek is now. And my unit in particular was the one most impacted by that. So I had a few comments, certainly won some, lost some, but at the end of the day it was a very similar comparable type of an argument. People got additional height, they got additional density.

36:59 And I think what I got out of it at the end of the day was I bought a property next to two development sites and I tried to look at the bigger picture and that's what was going to happen to complete a lot of the general plan we have here in Mammoth. It was to make a sustainable, viable community that had a lot of the uses that we wanted to see where they were intended to go. And I think what John's proposing up here

37:29 is a product that fills the need for that location. I can certainly appreciate people thinking that the five foot difference, which is this much difference, is going to make a big difference, but I question how much. I personally, as a member of the community, would rather see a product finished properly and in a manner much like they did down at the village. When you look at a lot of what's happened in the village and a lot of the older products,

37:58 The newer ones are more successful. They may cost more for people to stay in. They may cost more to purchase, but people, there's a void for that. There's a demand out there for that. And I think something else that's going to happen with this, you know, we have a lot of discussion about nightly single-family rentals out there. This is filling a void. There's a problem with that because people want that product and we don't have it in Mammoth. And here is somebody bringing that product across the street from a very visible,

38:28 Location, very accessible location. I think if we're going to do it, we need to do it properly. Again, we have a general plan in place and I think by filling a lot of these uses as they're intended to be filled, it keeps us from being a hodgepodge community laden with blight and everything else that we have up here because instead of becoming a community with sprawling growth and just hodgepodge uses.

38:56 I think what he's doing is appropriate and I think that, I hope that you folks will see your way towards approving it as planned. A couple other things, you know, I think your decision today is going to be important, I think, moving forward. We're at a very critical place in our community's life. You go up Main Street, there's a lot of blighted buildings. There's a lot of, you hear of other places, other resort communities are recovering from the recession.

39:26 But Mammoth really hasn't been recovering all that well, at least not with commercial and development standards. We haven't been doing that. And I've seen it firsthand, as I'm sure many of you have. And I think it's because Mammoth has a bit of a black eye, you know, as far as being able to be accommodating to people that are wanting to bring jobs, business, and new projects to town. And I think we need to change the perception, not only in Mammoth, but with the rest of the world.

39:54 You know, I suppose I could go on. It sounds like a lot of it was addressed by staff, the unintended consequences of this variance. You know, if you were to build back, more trees would come down, more dirt would have to be ripped out and moved. And, you know, not everything fits in a box. We've learned that. There's not a project up here that fits in the little box that we want perfectly. It just doesn't. Talking about the parking situation, I used to lay out at Snow Creek 5.

40:24 I had a one-car garage. It was a nice little townhome unit for myself, but I ended up moving because I couldn't fit my truck in there. You literally had a couple of inches on either side to get your car in, and that just didn't work for me because I had a bigger car. I needed it for work, and it was just the way it was. So as much as I loved the project, I just didn't get my car in there. It became a problem over time, and we had the people that manage the project come by about every five minutes, tell me I had to move my car because I had to park on the street part-time when I had guests. But anyway,

40:54 I'll leave it at that. I just wanted to throw a few new thoughts out there, and I appreciate you all listening. Thank you. Thank you. Anybody else that would like to speak? All right. So at this time, we'll close the public comments. I just do want to verify with my fellow commissioners. I believe we received, I kind of lost count, there's somewhere between 15 to 20 letters from the Korsh Bell owners. So everybody received them, had a chance to review them.

41:34 Yes. Okay. Thank you. So, you did receive all your letters. We appreciate your letters. At this time, was there any rebuttal comments from Mr. Hooper? There is one. This has to address the corner lot issue and the 20-foot setback. It's just wrong. Corner lots still have side setbacks of 10 feet. You can't access any project from a parking lot.

42:14 That's leased from Forest Service. The address is Rainbow, 413 Rainbow Lane, and the front of the project is on Rainbow. Even if it were a cornered lot, the side setbacks are still 10 feet. They're not 20 feet. 20 feet from a street, if it were a street, in fact, it isn't. So the setback issue is sort of a moot point. Regardless of a cornered lot, it still has a side setback of 10 feet, unless I'm incorrect.

42:43 Right, the side setback opposite of a street side yard would be 10 feet. All right, thank you. And Mr. Cooper, so just, so everybody is clear, on the townhomes that are adjacent closest to the Courcheville project, so tell us exactly what the height variance is that you're asking for on those. On the front building it would be, that's? It's 8.9 feet.

43:10 For the front buildings, the building C's along Rainbow Lane. That would be the one to the northeast. And the back one? That's built into the... Yeah, the back, actually, the back building adjacent to Courchevel would not need a variance. It would be the one on the other end. But the others, there's two buildings in the middle that would require a variance for 3.8 feet.

43:40 I also don't care where the dumpster is. I'm just thinking if the dumpster were over, we run into this right now. We have projects over on the golf course. We have dumpsters. Everybody in the neighborhood dumps their personal trash in that they're supposed to be for construction. But the closer it is to the parking lot, we're going to have everybody in that parking lot putting their trash, stacking it on top. This is a daily occurrence in Mammoth, and it's a real problem, and I don't even see a solution to it.

44:08 I don't care where the dumpster is. If you want it located on the other end, it doesn't matter to me. That's pretty much up to planning. Any other questions, Mr.? Okay, so we've closed our public hearing, and now it's time for us to deliberate. I think probably the easiest thing for us to do is on page 15 of our staff report, there are five or four issues. I think it's probably just the easiest.

44:42 to go through those four issues. So why don't we start with building growth pitch. We'll start with our architectural guru. Thank you. Thank you, John, for providing these revised elevations as alternatives here. It's a little bit hard to read. It looks as if

45:18 We changed to a 412 roof pitch, the top of the building would be at 37 foot 4. Does that, does that look right? It's about a 4 and a half foot reduction. Okay. For the buildings A and C. Okay. Do you think that from a design standpoint, both aesthetically and functionally as far as shedding snow, that the 612 makes a lot more sense? Um, that's really my only comment regarding that issue. Commissioner Harvey, did you have any comments about the roof roof?

46:05 No, I'm in agreement. The 612 is a much more aesthetic, pleasing roof line. And I think it, the amenities that come along with what that roof allows for, especially in the garage and access and whatnot, I have no problem with that. Bill, I think I'm in agreement with the 612 roof line, but more from a functionality standpoint of

46:46 of the snow load for that building up there. That location's going to receive, hopefully, a lot of snow as we go into subsequent winters. So I'm just wondering about the performance of this more squat roof. So that's my own comment on the roof. I do have a question for staff. What's the roof material? It's a composite asphalt shingle. Okay, so there wouldn't be a glare factor. No. Okay, all right.

47:18 Moving on to the north elevation facade, building C, was there any comments about that? Thank you, John, again, for this revised elevation. This is almost exactly what I was going to suggest or discuss in today's meeting. I don't know if members of the public have seen the little, I don't know what you want to call them, little roof projections over top of the windows.

47:51 I think it's a much more inviting facade, which actually leads me to the question of the north elevation, no, I'm sorry, the west elevation of building D, which is the single family home that is facing Canyon Lodge, also has a very sort of straight, flat, big, bulky profile. I

48:25 Would be interested to see a similar treatment on the facade to make that one a little more appealing to the Canyon Lodge area and the general public that's going to see that. Plus to make the facade uniform from the Raymond Lane perspective. Right. I mean, by comparison, the west facade of building B, I believe, the other single family home, has a bit more articulation than building D. So I think some sort of similar treatment would be...

48:57 It would be really nice. Okay. Excellent suggestions. It does a lot for the whole project. I agree. Any comments regarding the dumpster? May I just think quick? Yes. Would, if the dumpster moved to the other location, Mr. Hooper, would the, I believe it was a four foot retaining wall that went on three of the four sides of the dumpster, would that just get shifted to the other side? Okay. And what is,

49:47 Just off the top of my head, what is the average height of a dumpster in Mammoth Lakes? Any idea? I mean, I hate to put you guys on the spot. I apologize for that. It's probably a bit of a guess. They have two different dumpsters. Yeah. Four liters and six liters, I believe. Got it. I mean, they're like 50 inches? Yeah. Like chest height, you know, and it's like right here. Did you have any comments about the dumpsters? No, I'm...

50:18 Dumpsters will always be an issue. I don't know how you make everybody pleased with that. One of the things that need to be taken into consideration is, of course, access by the machine, by the truck. You need to make sure that it's safe access. Right. So, I might suggest that staff explore that a little bit and see what's realistic.

50:57 With the dumpster location, as far as functionality, there has to be a large truck that comes and dumps it. That can become quite a congested area. And they have to get the dumpster back into the dumpster enclosure, which seems to be somewhat of an issue. It does. Yeah. Grady, do you have any additional comments on the dumpster? Me? I...

51:32 I have also been trying to figure out if it makes any sense to move the dumpster to the other side of the property because I understand the concerns of the neighbors. Dumpsters can be noisy and annoying, but I'm not really sure that that's any better of a solution than what we have. I think what John was saying about its proximity to the Canyon Lodge parking lot makes a lot of sense. I don't know that having a dumpster right out there on the face of

52:07 of Canyon Lodge also is the aesthetic that we're looking for right next to our prime resort area either. So I don't know. I don't have a solution, a different solution than what John's already presented. So I just don't know what else could be done. You've really had your opportunity. But let us finish our discussion then for a second. All right. And then what about the alternative housing mitigation plan?

52:47 I think we, were there, anybody have any, commissioners have any comments about that? No, I don't have that. I'm good with that. I'm good. All right. So, before we continue, I just really want to explain a couple of things. That often our role as planning commissioners is, it's a very small scope and we operate under a certain set of circumstances.

53:16 So one of those circumstances is variances. And what's written about variances is very specific. And it's really generated by the lot itself. And if a particular lot does not offer the same opportunity that all the neighbors have, then we come into a situation where we are really compelled to grant variances. So I just wanted to really

53:44 So to understand that a variance for us is not a subjective thing, it's very objective. And that we just follow this prescribed set that staff has previously outlined. And that's how we answer the question whether or not a variance is appropriate or not appropriate. The other thing is while the property itself appears to be a corner lot, the reality is

54:11 is that Canyon is a parking lot that's leased from the Forest Service. The reality is Rainbow Lane, even though, granted, I go there all the time, so I know it doesn't appear to be this, is really, truly a dead-end street, and there is some engineering that's going to have to be worked on that dead-end street, because you currently have a dead-end street that goes, like, the wrong way. So, legally, we can't suddenly declare a

54:38 Quarter Lot because it does not fit within our legal parameters. So I just wanted to make sure that you understood that. The other thing is, is good, bad, or differently, currently right now, the town and commission does not have a requirement for story pulls. Story pulls started to fall by the wayside in the new digital era of 3D graphics.

55:05 We may change that in the future, but that is our current policy. We do not have a policy for story polls. So I just kind of wanted to address a couple of those concerns so that you could ultimately understand how we make our decision process. Regarding the dumpster, I think that's probably, it seems to be the area we still have like the most issue about, but the reality is, is

55:35 I would really encourage town staff and the developer to work on that particular issue because it really depends on what you're going to have to go work with the company, the pickup company, to see how they're going to pick it up and how it functions and then make it really conducive for the neighborhood. I will allow an additional comment about the dumpsters if you have one on that. Yes, I'm sorry, you have to go to the podium.

56:08 Thank you for the chance to comment on that. On the dumpster, I mean, it sounds like Mr. Hooper is willing to relocate it. If you look at the design of the parking lot and the driveway in between the two buildings, it's the exact same whether they located on our end, near Courcheville, or on the other end, as easy access by the dump company as well as the folks that live there. And then on the other end,

56:34 There's an opportunity to landscape around it. You can't really do it on the Courcheville end because that's our snow removal and storage area, that little section of property that is on our end. And it seems that there's an opportunity to at least give us something, if not the height and setback variances, which we would still like. And I just want to confirm, Mr. Hoopler, that you're willing to work on the dumpster relocation. Yes, I am. Okay. All right.

57:04 The commissioners, did you have any other comments, questions at this time? We don't want to do kindly make a motion. Well, do we need to have any discussion about the setback? Would you like, I mean, we can have some discussion about it. Oh, I mean, my only comment is that I completely understand why

57:36 Mr. Hooper wants to move the buildings closer to the Rainbow Lane side. As the buildings move further and further to the south on the property, the lane gets steeper and steeper, and I think, I mean, looking at the nine feet that he's asking for, moving those buildings nine feet to the south is probably equal to about three or four feet in height more of dirt that he would have to remove. Not three or four, but three or four feet higher all the way down to the building level. It's a huge amount of dirt, it's a huge amount of disturbance to

58:06 The hillside, which is, you know, one of the main things that the town, as part of the general plan, is trying to preserve. So, just, um, I want to say that I'm in agreement with that. Okay, great. Did you have any additional comments? No, I'm good. I'm good. Okay. Would one of you care to make a motion? Amy, you want to jump on it? Who, me? Well, if I can find the, thank you. Chair, Chair Brown? Yes.

58:39 If I may, could I just clarify what I think are two additional conditions? Yes, thank you, please. So I think there would be two additional conditions that the commission would like to add. One would be that the, well actually I think there will be three. One would be that the west facade of building D be provided with additional design detail similar to the revised elevation

59:07 North elevation for building C. The second condition would be that the commission approves the revised north elevation for building C. And then the third would be the first one, wouldn't it? However, whatever order you like. The third condition would be that town staff will work with the developer

59:35 to assess the feasibility of relocating the dumpster to the west portion of the site, and that that relocated, that location would be approved as long as it's approved by Mammoth Disposal as well. Madam Chair. Yes. If I will. In that analysis, I do believe that a very valid point is going to be accessibility by the public to that

1:00:09 trash unit and an accessible trash container is a target in this town and that's a very prominent area so in coming up with an analysis of what works I would think that that would be a key feature that I think everybody in the neighborhood would

1:00:42 Benefit from that analysis. We can add that to the condition as part of the analysis. Okay. So I'd like to make a motion that we choose option one, make the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal findings, municipal code findings, adopt the required subdivision map act findings, adopt the required variance findings, and approve tentative tract map 15-001

1:01:18 Variance 15-001, use permit, 15-001, design review, 15-001, and adjustment, 15-001, with conditions previously discussed. Do you need to register? I'll second. Deliberations, any comments, further deliberations? Roll call, please. Commissioner Grayack?

1:01:51 Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst. Yes. Vice Chair Harvey. Yes. Chair Brown. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. And thank you again very much for coming on. Our next public hearing today is to consider recommending to town council approval of general plan amendment. I just was caught by surprise. It's also 15-01. I'm sorry. General plan amendment 15-001, zoning code amendment 15-001, adopting the housing ordinance, update municipal code chapter 17-1-1.

1:02:44 3-6, and our staff person again is Jen Hollis. Thank you, Chair Brown. I will give an overview for this public hearing. Then our consultant, Jeff Goldman from AECOM, will present the peer resort analysis that was prepared for this hearing. Then we can go through your questions. So the housing ordinance is a chapter of the zoning code that describes housing mitigation requirements for new development.

1:03:16 The ordinance update before you today incorporates direction that we've received from council. That includes that we provide a menu of options from which developers can choose to mitigate housing. So a developer could choose to pay a fee, provide housing onsite, provide housing offsite, donate land, or a combination thereof. Council also directed staff to not mandate

1:03:43 on-site housing or inclusionary housing so that's part of the ordinance as well and then the council directed that all those options that developers can choose from to mitigate be considered equivalent in other words as you see now we have to make findings of greater housing benefit for alternate housing plans this ordinance would not require that the housing fee that would be allowed to be paid through this ordinance is not part of the Commission's materials today

1:04:11 that will be considered by council and we anticipate that will happen on May 20th but since in-loo fees are set by council they're not part of the zoning code they're not before commission as part of this work effort in addition to the ordinance update amenity and design standards have also been prepared for workforce units that's to ensure that certain standards are met for workforce units that are provided through the ordinance and these standards include

1:04:40 parameters for kitchen and dining areas, appliance and fixtures, open space, number of bathrooms, and also describes how requests for waivers or modifications to those standards are processed. The ordinance and the amenity and design standards would supersede our current interim policy from 2009 that we've been using for a few years.

1:05:08 And the ordinance update includes amendments to the housing element of the general plan. Those are specific amendments that are required based on council's direction for the new ordinance. So you'll see those in tract changes in your packet. And to satisfy environmental review requirements, we have prepared an addendum to the negative declaration that was adopted with the housing element last year. That's also included in your packet.

1:05:34 So staff and our consultant, AECOM, have worked with both Mammoth Lakes Housing and stakeholders in the development of this ordinance. And as part of those discussions, there have been different policy issues that have been raised. And those are included in your staff report. And we can walk through those at the pleasure of the commission. We also did receive, before the meeting, an email from Mark Carney. Hard copies have been passed out. And so we can discuss that.

1:06:05 At the pleasure of the Commission. So I think before I hand this off to Jeff Goldman at AECOM, I did just want to mention that Commissioner Grayhack caught a typo that we had in the ordinance. It's actually in subsection 100 I. It's the exemption section. We should have actually deleted I because we incorporated it with A. So little typo to fix. And

1:06:31 I think with that, so Council did direct us to prepare a case study of peer resorts before going through this effort just to kind of see if we're aligned with what other cities are doing. And so that's included in your packet and Jeff from, Jeff Goldman from AECOM will give us a walk through that to help start the discussion and then we can head into any of the policy items. Is that all I have?

1:07:01 Thanks so much, Jeff. Thank you. Since Jen already introduced me, I guess I won't introduce myself since it's on the record. We were asked to identify and then kind of tease out what would be the critical elements, housing ordinances and either design guidelines or livability standards that are like design guidelines comparable to what Mammoth Lakes now has in place. And we started

1:07:39 By looking at 10 or 12 potential mountain resort communities in various places in California, Colorado, where actually the lion's share of our comparative case studies came from, Wyoming and a couple of other places. And after going through those with staff, we narrowed that down to what we thought were the five most relevant case studies based on factors.

1:08:09 Such as geographic location, you know, we know Mammoth Lakes is a bit unique in terms of its somewhat isolated resort community, whereas some other resort communities are not quite as isolated and are closer to urban areas, like Park City, Utah, like Truckee in the Lake Tahoe area. We looked at factors, whether they had comparable array of options that we wanted to look at for how to comply.

1:08:36 with affordable housing requirements, whether they had specific inclusionary requirements and what those are, what their requirements were related to workforce housing obligations from employee generation, residential versus non-residential development requirements and so forth. And these are, these show up in the comparative matrix that hopefully you all have in your packet. And I'll just walk through those

1:09:05 and be happy to answer any questions. Can you just put yourself a page that's on, and I know it's in there, but 157? So I don't know if you provided this in a half by 11 or 11 by seven. It looks like this. It's the great nature. So we landed, as I mentioned a moment ago, we landed on five comparative case studies that we thought had the greatest relevance and comparability. And as it turns out, three of those are in Colorado.

1:09:45 One's in Wyoming and one's in California. You can see there are Aspen, Colorado, Jackson, Wyoming, Mount Crested Butte in Colorado, Telluride in Colorado and Truckee in California. And the major categories of elements that we looked at that were relevant to the affordable housing update and the livability amenity design standards were whether there was a specific inclusionary obligation like

1:10:14 10%, 15%, so forth. What were the housing mitigation options available in these various ordinances? And I'll walk through those briefly in a moment. And what were the approaches to employee mitigation? So how did they look at employee generation and the mitigation options for those? And finally, minimum units, unit size standards, because that was something

1:10:41 That showed up in all of the precedent case studies. So we thought that would be important to highlight in this comparative matrix. So let's start with inclusionary. You can see that a specific inclusionary requirement is not really predominant. And for those that did have them, they varied from none to as much as 25%. But I suspect if you were to look at other mountain resort communities as well, you might find that

1:11:10 It's not necessarily a predominant thing to have a specific percentage inclusionary requirement. Where they do have them, they do tend to be in a range. 25% tends to be kind of at the upper end of the range. And where there is a percentage, 10% does tend to be at the lower end of the range. In terms of mitigation options, we've laid out here on-site, off-site, in lieu fee, ability to have a specific alternative mitigation plan.

1:11:39 plan that provides a development proposal specific option. We also looked at which jurisdictions had market rate deed restrictions, whether dedication of land, including buildable or shuttle ready lots versus raw land were options, whether dormitory or SRO type or other kinds of units like that.

1:12:10 were options, and we were looking at this primarily from, not for the seasonal workforce, but for year round, because we know often dormitory style or SRO style or group housing style is often provided for the seasonal workforce who isn't here year round, and purchase options for affordable housing as well. And so there were quite a large array of options

1:12:39 options, a larger array than is present now in Mammoth Lakes Housing Ordinance, and we looked through those and decided which ones we felt were appropriate to move forward, which you'll see in the draft ordinance, to provide more flexibility, more ways to comply with a workforce housing mitigation requirement, and also we tried to

1:13:07 Look at these options from the lens of comparability. So in other words, whether the proposal, the compliance proposal is on-site provision, off-site provision, and in Luffy, donating land, including building ready lots. How can the requirement be constructed and if there's an alternative housing mitigation plan, what should the contents of that plan be

1:13:37 to try to equalize as closely as possible. We know these aren't 100% comparable ways of complying with an obligation and probably won't guarantee exactly the same result in terms of number and type of workforce housing units. We were looking at it through that lens of trying to get as close as possible to comparability in terms of the result. What would be the result of using the NLU fees? What would be the result of what gets built on land or building ready lots that are donated and et cetera?

1:14:06 Then we also looked at the various formulas which most of the comparative case study jurisdictions did have formulas for based on square footage typically assumed ratio of a place per square footage. Those tended to be in a range also and they tended to be somewhat lower than we

1:14:28 Mammoth Lakes has been using up to this point. And then we also looked again at units, the unit size aspect of livability standards. It was interesting, although those were also in range, generally speaking, there were options for providing smaller units, less square footage for each type of housing option among these five comparable case studies.

1:14:56 than what exists now in the Mammoth Lakes Housing Ordinance. I'll stop there. I don't know what all you might be interested in about this, but I'd be happy to go into more detail based on what questions you have. Commissioner C. So, because we frequently have had case studies in the past, and so I was curious about, in the end, how you chose these five resorts, how you felt they were compatible to Mammoth Lakes.

1:15:34 They were compatible, we felt they were compatible either because in some cases they had a similar kind of geographic characteristic of being somewhat isolated so it wouldn't necessarily be as easy an option to say well we can't provide the workforce housing here that you know you can draw you can 10-15 miles away there is a community where the housing is very affordable so it's not such a big deal as one example we looked at the

1:16:03 The type of community, the resort community, weather resort community, there was also a substantial residential and commercial community as well because not all ski resorts have a substantial resident population and a substantial commercial and employment base. Some are mostly the resort with some seasonal housing for the workers and maybe some permanent housing, maybe some permanent residents. So we looked at that aspect of it well as well.

1:16:33 for comparability and other factors like that. Okay. Any other questions at this point? I have just one small one because I'm just curious. Did any of these other primary resorts have such a restricted urban growth boundary similar to Mammoths that you're aware of? Well, Breckenridge is famous or infamous, depending on how you look at it, for being one of the early adopters of very restrictive growth control.

1:17:05 Their growth management regime, how they implement that's a bit different than Mammoth Lakes, but that's an example of a community that's had longstanding growth control, also longstanding workforce or affordable housing program as well. Okay, but that one didn't end up as one of the five. That one didn't end up as one of the five. That is true. Interestingly enough, that one, we felt that one was not as comparable as these other ones. For the time being, we're good on the questions. Okay.

1:17:40 So just to back up, agreeable with the activity, we'll hear from the public, and then what I thought we would do is we would go down these list of policy discussions, and then ultimately what we're going to do is because you know this is a public hearing on four or five different items, and then we'll, right now we're talking about the ordinance, but ultimately we'll go through each separate item and talk about it. Okay, at this time, if there's anybody in the public who'd like to come forward,

1:18:12 and speak on this issue. Good afternoon. Tom Hodges with Mammoth here. I've reviewed the pre-resort report, and my only observation would be that, you know, keep in mind that every market's unique, and, and so, and they change over time, and we're in an interesting situation where I think Matthew Lehman alluded to it in his comments on the previous matter that, you know, we're probably behind a lot of our pre-resorts in recovering from the recession because of

1:18:46 Some of the continuing drought conditions we've had. So I don't think it's, just to caution people that it's not always an apples for apples comparison and that every community is very unique and when we weigh what are the priorities for our community, we can look to that for some guidance, but we need to recognize that our situation is its own situation and, you know, for example, I think in particular in the current situation, our

1:19:15 Average cost or average cost of housing per square foot, for example, compared to some of these other peer resorts is much lower. And so how we might approach a strategy of fulfilling our affordable housing needs would be quite different. I'm sorry, are you saying ours is lower? Our average cost per square foot for market rate housing is quite a bit lower than some of our peer resorts. Certainly much lower than Aspen, probably much lower than Telluride.

1:19:44 So again, I know we've had past discussions about how do we solve for affordable housing need, and I know there's been a lot of policy discussion that still needs to manifest once we get to the next study about, you know, do we try to acquire existing housing stock, for example, to fulfill some demand of the affordable housing as a way to meet our needs as our own community. So, thanks. Would you like to comment on the ordinance at this time?

1:20:14 Well, I can if it's appropriate, but if we're going to present through the, I need to go grab my notes. Okay. You might wait on this timer. I'm going to need at least five minutes. Okay. So, thanks for opting to comment on the ordinance. I just acknowledge the hard work of staff. They've been, Jen's been doing a tremendous job of a lot of heavy lifting, trying to put all this together, and, you know, it's really a completely re-vetting of the ordinance, so I appreciate your efforts. I think you're doing a great job.

1:20:49 So I'm just going to go through this sequentially from the draft that is currently on the agenda. And my first comment is in section 17.136.030, housing mitigation for incremental and new demands and credits. And then in paragraph B, housing mitigation credits, line item 1,

1:21:16 Credit for existing uses shall be calculated based on the housing impact mitigation fees applicable to the existing uses at the time of demolition. This was brought to my attention and I had a chance to think about it a bit and I think it would be more appropriate to change that to the time of redevelopment of the lot. So capture what the existing demolished, whenever the thing is demolished, you capture what was there that's kept on record by staff and then at the time that the

1:21:44 property is redeveloped whenever that is, which may not necessarily be concurrent, that then you assess the mitigation, what that mitigation equivalency would be at that time of the redevelopment, or maybe at the time of building permits pulled, if you want to be real specific. So I'd recommend that change. Moving on to section 17136050, on-site provisions of, oh, I'm sorry, excuse me, back on section 2,

1:22:19 040, 136040, paragraph G, Housing Fees Established, number 4, Use of Housing Fees. I think this was a point brought up in Mark Carney's letter to the commission as well that I would reiterate it that at the end of the first sentence, fees collected pursuant to this chapter shall be placed in a separate front of the 10 and shall be used only for the purpose of planning for administering

1:22:47 Subsidizing or developing workforce housing, I would add the stipulation within the talent limits. So, and this is very important, so there's some coordination in the document because this is saying that the fees that are collected, how they're going to be used and in other places in the document there's discussions about where they, where other housing medication can be provided. So, and this comment would be consistent with my other comments I'm going to make here further down the document. So, I'm proposing that we add

1:23:17 The use of housing fees that we added at the end of the first sentence within the town limits. And then moving on to section 050, on-site provision of units. I felt like that we needed to provide a formula for how you calculate the value of the units that are provided because basically everything is distilling down now to a mitigation, to a fee. So

1:23:47 You're going to assess a development and say, okay, this is your fee for whatever you're doing. So it's a cost per unit, for example, of a lodging development. If you, for some reason, at some point, and I think it's a great idea to have these other options in because, again, the market's going to change over time and maybe at some point on-site housing is going to make sense. But it's important to, I think, define how you calculate that. What's the value of that?

1:24:16 Housing provided on site. And I think, to me, the way I would do it is that it's going to cost the developers so much to build that unit, and then you would take the differential between the cost to the developer to build the unit, less the cost of the affordable sales price on it, as it's defined, or that would be assessed to that development. And then you get a remainder value, assuming it's going to cost more to build it than what you're going to be able to sell it for, right?

1:24:46 Then that would be the credit you would get in terms of actual dollars. Does that make sense? Can you please give us the section code again? 17-136-050, on-site provision of units, paragraph B, and it needs to be added to the items in that list, one through four, some sort of a calculation piece.

1:25:18 Okay. And then, you know, it says in that also in that same paragraph, paragraph B, number one, says the affordability level of units stated as proportion of the area median income shall comply with those established by council resolution, which shall be pre-reviewed and updated. So, you know, I'm not sure how that's going to be administered in practice when somebody comes in with, say, like John Hooper's development, for example, that you just reviewed.

1:25:55 You know, how, you know, where you, what level of AMI, so the town, or the council I assume is going to say we need, you know, these many units and these are AMI levels, how do you apply that to any particular development, because the delta's going to be greater, right, if you, if it's a low income unit versus a moderate or a, you know, above medium income level, the gap's different, so, so again, I guess maybe it won't matter, but, uh,

1:26:24 Because you're going to eventually just throw it down to a dollar value that you would give credit for against the mitigation. We'd like just to take a quick five-minute break, please. Sure. Order our meeting. Okay, so getting back to Section 17.136.050 on-site provision of units. Again, just encourage that we should have some form of a formula in there that how do you calculate the value of

1:30:07 What the value is of providing the on-site units relative to the fees that you're going to owe on the development. And then number two in there, it does say secretary units shall be for sale units unless the developer chooses a rental alternative. And it just, in my mind, it just raised the question of, well, if a developer wants to propose rental product analysis, they don't see where he would ever want to do it because it would be so much brain damage to maintain rental units.

1:30:38 For affordable housing. But how would you calculate the value of that? If they do provide a rental unit, how do you, you know, do you do the net present value of a stream of income of rental over 20, 30 years? Or how does that work? So, I just think it's very, very unlikely anybody would ever want to even go there. But, let's see. And then my next point, and this actually, I'll point this out in the other subsequent

1:31:11 options for providing affordable housing mitigation was that if somebody chose to build on-site housing units, they have to build a whole unit, right? And in comparison to what that value is equivalent to what they owe in the housing fee equivalency, they may end up with either an excess or a shortage, which in here does point out if there's a shortage, they can just pay the balance in a fee, in the equivalent, the remainder of the fee.

1:31:41 But my point would be too is they overdeveloped the affordable units that they would then be able to obtain a credit for the excess mitigation they provided. And then there is a provision earlier in the ordinance that does allow for the transfer of credits to other properties and so forth. And just my point about how do you go into paragraph C of the same section, maybe that's the appropriate place to have a discussion about. And it does say that

1:32:18 You know, the staff would review the developers' pro forma to determine the cost of the units. You know, just recognizing that cost change over time, you know, the cost to build a unit. So it's probably appropriate that it is negotiated, you know, as time changes. But, you know, there's going to be a back and forth that will have to occur there with respect to the cost of the built unit. Then moving on to paragraph 3, again, still on the on-site mitigation, which...

1:32:47 is the calculation of project density. On-site housing units provided pursuant to this section shall not count towards the calculation of total project density if all of the following conditions apply. And going to number three, it says the applicable floor area ratio limit is not exceeded. Kind of felt like that was contradictory only as much as that's what controls density for all the commercial zones. So essentially you can't

1:33:17 What you're saying is you can't, you can't, your density would count towards your, any affordable mitigation on a, in the commercial zone would count towards your density. Well, let me answer that because if we change this ordinance, then we have to go back and change all our CEQA calculations. Well, but you do have, you do have a number five in here with respect to these exemptions that findings can be made

1:33:44 In conjunction with the project approval of total project density or density concerning all uses, would meet applicable design and development standards for municipal code, and would not result in significant unavoidable environmental impacts, and would be compatible with surrounding uses. So, you kind of put the lever on there that has to, you know, pass muster with the environmental review. So, I don't know. I don't know if it's, because like I said, it really doesn't, at this point, you just sort of shoot yourself in the further name of the commercial zones because you can't exceed the density.

1:34:13 Because the density is the FAR number. Correct. So, I don't know, just like I say, it's a little bit of a contradiction. I think we all kind of agree, it would be very rare to ever achieve a full FAR build out of most of the properties anyway, so maybe it's a moot point. Moving on to the provision for off-site units, section 17136060. So in here, in paragraph 8, it is stipulated that off-site housing units may be proposed within the town limits.

1:34:45 To satisfy the housing mitigation requirement for the development. And then you get down to paragraph B, the off-site unit requirements. Paragraph 1 then further stipulates that there is the off-site units shall be constructed within specific zones within the town. Not all of them. We feel strongly that there should be no restrictions on where affordable housing units can be built. So we would suggest you to strike.

1:35:13 Number one entirely because it's addressed up above in the opening sentence of paragraph A that off-site housing needs may be proposed within the town limits and then those be handled on a case-by-case basis is kind of how we see it. But because the way it's written right now, you're procuring it from single-family residential areas, RMF1 zones, and those all seem like appropriate places for affordable housing.

1:35:40 And it doesn't seem like we should exclude any of those areas. So we'd recommend you strike paragraph, or section, or number one within paragraph B. Number two, I had a question about units acquired, so this is if you were to acquire units offsite to meet your housing mitigation needs, shall not be currently serving as long-term, non-transient rail units.

1:36:09 And my question is, what if you, because there's other language in here later on about rentals and deed restrictions, would you not be able to propose to deed restrict existing market rate rental units to fulfill your mitigation requirements? So this wouldn't allow you to do that. In terms of rental units, market rate units, market rate rental units are considered part of our workforce housing supply, so we wouldn't say that you could

1:36:41 This is saying you couldn't acquire those rental units, deed restrict, and then consider that you provided mitigation because they're already serving as workforce housing. Yeah, my only point is that, you know, you do get the guarantee then that they're deed restricted to whatever those income levels are. And over time, I mean, right now market rate rentals aren't so bad, but, you know, the market's going to change. And this ordinance is supposed to address kind of the next, you know, without having to maybe change the ordinance.

1:37:09 I kind of feel like that we should allow for deed restriction of existing market rate rental units to be accepted as acceptable mitigation if they're deed restricted to affordable rental rates. What's that? Oh, I'm just saying maybe the current rentals wouldn't be eligible for that income level, right? Yeah. I mean, maybe that's not too right. Yeah, I, well, I'm throwing it out there because I think it's something that... So I'd like to break a little bit from our...

1:37:42 And because I'm assuming the bulk of your questions is about on-site, right? So would I like to just address those? Well, I'm into the off-site now, but there's some similar comments. I'm almost done. Okay, well, I mean, I just don't want to get so far the line that we've lost track of the questions. That's, or your point. Oh, okay. So maybe, I think it would just be easier, because I would like to ask staff, perhaps our consultant, Mammoth Lakes,

1:38:15 So how many, there was like one, two, three, how many points did you have? Let's just go down the list and maybe you can give us a little feedback on those. So yeah, on site, there was just like three points. One was the, just the creation of a calculation to how do you calculate the value of provided by the on site units relative to the fee. I'm just clarifying that. And then I had a question of how do you calculate value if the

1:38:48 developer chose to provide you rental units because you have to come up with a value. And then if in the course of providing on-site units you provided excess mitigation that the developer should be credited anything in excess of what is required for his development in that value. So if you would just, would you like to comment on any of that? Sure. I think the first comment I had noted was about

1:39:21 Calculating credits at time of demolition versus building permit, do you mind if I, and so that's, we agree with that, that's no problem to make that change. The comment about use of housing funds, adding to the end of the first sentence within the town limits, that's no problem, that's, we don't see any issues with that. To add a formula for how to calculate

1:39:48 The cost for those units provided, we agree, that would provide additional clarity, we can do that. Maybe a rhetorical question about how do we apply the target AMI to each mitigation unit provided. So we can think about, I imagine the way it's been done in the past, or most recently, we have a range that the AMI levels shall be between 80 and 120 or something like that, and then it's up to the developer to

1:40:16 choose the... Right. I think the developers can defer to staff, say, or MLH, or whoever the authority is, to say, this is the units we want. Because in the end, it'll just become a question of what's that differential in the cost. So delegates distilled down to dollars. So we can think about that one a little bit more. Same kind of thing with calculating the value cost for a rental project provided. We agree that...

1:40:48 If you're providing mitigation above the value that's required, that you would be eligible for credit for that. So we can make a change to clarify that. I was going to go, I think the FAR question, did I miss? No, but the FAR question and the zoning question is part of our discussion questions already, so. And then I think my other notes were policy questions. Did I miss? That was already in there. Okay, okay.

1:41:23 All right. So then moving on from on-site provision of units, I'd recommend striking B1. And just to expand on that a little bit, I mean, you know, I know there's been comments out there that people don't want to have more affordable housing in the Sierra Valley sites, but, you know, I'd argue that there's been a lot of quality development done, even affordable units. I know Robbie Preston did a townhome development in there that looks terrific. And I think, you know, the point is,

1:41:55 That there's probably a lot of existing product within the ghetto that should be torn down and redeveloped, and I think it would be a huge improvement to the neighborhood to have new housing develop on quite a few of the sites within that area. So I just don't buy the logic that it's not an acceptable place for affordable housing. And again, I think we shouldn't discriminate against anywhere within the town boundaries that you can build housing.

1:42:29 And then I had the question on conversion of existing units, whether you could convert market rate rental units to deed restricted rental units and satisfy your housing mitigation requirements. I feel like you should be able to do that. Because, again, recognize the market's going to change over time and there may come a point where market rate units are very unaffordable. So if you were to deed restrict it, it would be a benefit. So we should add that to our policy discussion. Yeah, that's a policy question.

1:43:01 And then the same question applies as far as from the previous section about having a formula for how do you calculate what's the value of that offsite housing that's developed and where does that value end up relative to the fee that you owe for your development. So I recommend there be another reference to a calculation in these line items. And the same comment that if you create excess mitigation that you're credited for any excess mitigation you create,

1:43:31 with providing off-site units. Come back to one general comment in a minute. And then moving on to, again, still in the section 060, off-site provision units, paragraph C. I was just noticing the relative to the prior section for on-site units, paragraph C actually listed five line items of applicable requirements. I just didn't understand why you wouldn't have the same ones there, sort of the same.

1:44:09 It's no different. I think you've got to add those in there. I think it's D, actually, right? I think it's C, the application requirements. If you go to the 50 on-site provision units, paragraph C, there's five line items of requirements listed. That I thought were all, you know, helped explain it a little bit clearer. I just...

1:44:34 In a sense of being redundant there, just add them into the same C paragraph on the offsite units. Okay, then moving on to section 070 conveyance of land. Paragraph A, I would just suggest adding number 8 that any, again, any excess value greater than the applicable housing fee for the market rate development shall be credited to development. So, you know, because again,

1:45:18 And there's never going to be a balance there. The land is either going to be a little bit less or a little bit more. So either you've got to pay some additional fee or you should be acknowledged and get some credit if it's overvalued. And then the same caveat on paragraph C, conveyance of development ready lots. Again, just if there's an excess credit created that it goes to the benefit of the developer. And then I caught that same issue with that typo in section 100.

1:45:51 Had removed the comment about one employer. So those were all my comments on that. And then just from a policy standpoint, I just, one other thing, I know we're going to get into this when we get review in the next study, but I think it's a pretty important point that needs to be acknowledged is that if you look at the census data and information that was in the housing strategy as well as the EPS report from 2011, that, you know, there's a significant portion of our workforce that lives out of town.

1:46:24 And, you know, it's roughly a third. And, you know, either, I know there's been discussions about whether we should be allowed to provide off-site or housing mitigation out of the town limits. So Crowley, June, wherever it is. But I feel that if it's acknowledged in the demand side of the equation for what we need at affordable housing at build-out, that we recognize that, hey, there is...

1:46:50 You know, a third, whatever the number is, I mean, it's going to change over time, but presently it's around, hovering around a third of the workforce that lives out of town, that then we don't solve for that demand in our build-out scenario for affordable housing within the town limits. So if it's, if you're, if you acknowledge that in the Nexus study, then, then our comments about, in the context of our housing ordinance for mitigation, then that, yeah, that mitigation is relative to,

1:47:17 That reduction in the demand because you're saying, okay, yeah, a third of it's going to be solved out of town because that's historically how it's been, then that's going to reduce commensurately the fee. So it's sort of, you handle it that way. So I think that's the appropriate way to do it and that's why I'm suggesting that we just say that the affordable housing in here is within the town limits and that the next study reflect the fact that we are solving for a third of our workforce housing

1:47:46 Product solution is being provided through adjacent communities. Yeah. And that's, you know, whether people, people choose to live in those communities for all different reasons, and I, you know, I think it's, is what it is. So, that's all my comments. Thank you. Thank you. Our public comment period is still open. We're really kind of dividing our public comments between two things, the ordinance itself and policy. So, you're welcome to come forward today for

1:48:20 Hi, Commission. This might be my first time on this side, so. Thank you for showing up. Sure. Name's Colin Thurney. Just wanted to very quickly answer the question that you brought up, Commissioner Daheck. Wondering if there's any of those comparison points in the study that you think are appropriate to compare based on our urban growth boundary. And I just wanted to also highlight, in addition to Breckenridge, that I think Telluride's actually a very

1:48:50 Accurate comparison. Telluride doesn't have an urban growth boundary per se, but they essentially do based on land constraints. So, you know, one edge of the town borders into the canyon in an old mine, so there's no ability to build into that area. And then there's a major parcel of land that kind of separates their mountain village and their downtown. And I'm probably going to butcher the exact designation, but I think it was put into

1:49:17 A wildlife or open space designation where it's unbuildable. So when looking at that as a comparison piece, I just watching that as well. Thank you. Yep. Thanks guys. So you're basically in your role then you're happy with the comparison study when you thought they were good? I did actually. You know, I was one of the ones on council that asked for an appropriate resort comparison. Obviously we want to look at Tahoe because it's our only real

1:49:46 Major competition in the state of California, but I think the comparison study that they pulled from other states, I think, those are probably the most appropriate. So I think it's a good subset for us to look at. Okay, great. Thank you very much. Thanks, guys. All right. Additional public comments? Good afternoon. Bill Taylor. I'm a board member with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And Jennifer Halperty just asked me to attend today to take some notes and answer any questions you might have.

1:50:20 I know that we sent comments on the draft to staff. Those comments have been incorporated into the staff report. So if you have any questions during your deliberations, please let me know. I wanted to make one additional comment personally about the case studies and the peer resorts. And that is that as we've used them in the past, they aren't really – we're not trying to really compare ourselves with –

1:50:49 Any particular resort or set of resorts and saying, well, we'll do what they do. Right. We looked at the peer resorts as a smorgasbord of options that people have been trying, they've been using. We can see what works, what doesn't, get some ideas. But they're not there to tell us what to do. They're there really to help us understand what some ideas are and what might work. So it's not, you know,

1:51:17 It's not keeping up with the Joneses. Right. It's sort of looking over at the yard and seeing what worked for them. Thank you. Thank you very much for being here today. Do we have additional public comments? Okay. Then what I'm going to do is at this time I am going to close the public comment period. And if it's agreeable to my commissioners, my fellow commissioners, I'd like to move into our policy discussions. Moving through my iPad back to the policy discussion page.

1:51:59 I have to get it to it. I think it's page three. Page which? I think, I believe it's three. Almost there. Sorry. Okay. Our first policy discussion was about inclusionary housing no longer being mandated, and I just didn't know if the commission had any other comments they'd like to provide counsel, or we pretty well discussed this, and it's included.

1:52:41 You want to start, Commissioner Harvey, did we have any other comments about that? No, I think it's pretty much explanatory. It's in the toolbox. I tend to agree with Mr. Hodges, and that is it. It, for many reasons, just may not be used by developers. I think going into a more of a fee-based formula gives the town the opportunity

1:53:25 to be creative and work with developers to provide the housing that we're actually looking for. Did you have any comments on that policy, Mr. Green? Just really in agreement that removing the mandated inclusionary housing, I think, is very well along the lines of the work that we've been doing towards making the town's process for developers

1:54:00 Less challenging. And eliminating the number of unknowns at the front end. So I think, yeah, I think it's a good move. No, I think we've vetted it. Okay, I agree. All right. And then what about time limit for housing mitigation credits? Currently there's no time limit has been included in the updated origins. Any discussion on that? I think it's the right direction. I think so. Okay. I believe it's in line with our...

1:54:36 Or the case study of the Peer Resorts, right? Right. Yeah. Okay. Housing fees for administration. Housing fees provided would be for the purpose of planning for administrating, subsidizing, or developing workforce housing. Very nice. I don't. Harvey, do you have comments? You're great. Nope. Okay. Okay. So on the next one, on-site housing excluded from density, not far calculations. Perhaps...

1:55:29 Jenny, would you like to address that a little bit before we start our conversation on that? Sure. We want to encourage the provision of on-site housing, and so we evaluated whether we should exempt on-site housing from density limitations, such as in the RMF 2 zone, as well as from FAR, which will apply and be the intensity limitation in commercial zones.

1:55:56 Because we're underway with the EIR for FAR, because that would, we anticipate that increasing the capacity of sites already in the commercial zone, we thought it would probably be unnecessary and may cause some potential issues if we also excluded affordable housing on site, or excuse me, workforce housing on site in the commercial zones with FAR.

1:56:30 Did anybody else have any questions about that? No. Comments? That's pretty clear. I'm okay with that. I'm good. And just to underline a point that was previously made, you know, when we did all our theoretical calculations of FAR, it's going to be pretty hard to reach those maximum FAR limits already, so I'm very comfortable with it at that time. All right, so the next one then is construction of new off-site housing allowed in certain areas, not RMF-1 or shady rest, and

1:57:02 Perhaps to start this discussion, Jen, would you just want to give us a little background on this? And then we'll go from there. The town's housing regulations, I think, and maybe Mr. Taylor can help, I think since either 2000 or 2006, has not allowed for off-site housing to be located in the RMF1 zone, which includes shady rest. The rationale behind that is that that zone does not allow for transient rental.

1:57:32 Therefore, it sort of naturally serves as workforce housing. The issue is not that affordable housing is considered inappropriate in those zones. We agree that it's appropriate. Really, the concern was to provide sufficient workforce housing stock in town and distributing that workforce in other appropriate zones throughout the town. Anybody else have any questions about that?

1:58:04 I take a little different look at the Sierra Valley sites situation, and that is that it's sort of in need of new product, upgraded product, and affordable housing, in my mind, in that area, starts to provide that.

1:58:40 and starts to give a shot in the arm, if you will, to a very tired and run down area of our town that can in fact use this kind of product. Shady rest, I still believe very firmly that shady rest should in fact be allowed as a buildable area simply because we're

1:59:19 We're not coming up with the solutions to utilize that property in its original situation. We understand that there are those that would like to hold it aside as already previously accounted for. And that can be a legitimate argument. But on the other side of the coin,

1:59:55 Are we getting any affordable housing from a piece of property that is in fact zoned for affordable housing? And we're not. So to exclude that, I don't know that we're doing ourselves a service by not having affordable housing that's usable, that's produced. Exactly how that cat gets skinned at the end of the day

2:00:35 I don't know. I think we've looked at that as an affordable housing property for how long, Bill? Early 2000s? 1996? 97? Yeah. And it's just something has to happen there. And I would be very cautious to put the Close for Business sign

2:01:15 Out on that property to developers or others that would be interested in creating affordable housing. So for those reasons and more, I feel very strong that offsite housing construction, new construction, should be allowed in the Sierra Sites area and also Shady Rest area. The

2:01:57 I'll just sort of finish with this. The amount of construction that could possibly go on in the next five years, ten years, it's a guessing number at this time. We can come up with some estimates. I just don't happen to agree with the MLH numbers that have come forward.

2:02:44 I think at the end of the day, maybe in 75 to 100 years, we might reach some of those numbers. I just don't have a fear that this huge affordable housing demand is looming over us at this point. Obviously there is a need to some degree. Do we all know exactly what that is? I don't know.

2:03:23 I think if we move into this next building cycle with opportunities for developers to provide the product that we're looking for, with opportunities for the town should we move to a fee-based system to collect fees that would in fact amount to enough to be able to have something to negotiate with

2:03:54 With developers, I think would be a good thing. So, those reasons, I just cannot see Sierra sites being excluded, RMF1, or Shady Rest. Right. And just to clarify, though, RMF1 also includes portions of old male throat, so. Correct. We are talking about more than just the Sierra sites. Correct. Follow me on it? Yes. Okay.

2:04:30 Did you have any additional comments? I think that's enough on that for me. Thank you. Commissioner Gray, did you have any? No. No, I'm good. So, you know, this is probably, for me, the, you know, the one part of the ordinance. Well, first of all, let's back up. I really believe that probably going forward that construction of new off-site housing

2:05:04 Might be one of the lower number uses that will be used in our toolbox. So I don't think it will be the priority in the toolbox. But I do think it's really an important consideration. And what concerns me a little bit about this particular part of the ordinance is that our RMF-1 areas are the areas that I believe

2:05:30 We really need the greatest amount of renovation and rehab work. So when we do our ultimate recommendation to council, I mean, I think we should probably put some provision in there to ask staff to evaluate this provision of the ordinance a little further because what we don't want to do is limit our ability to renovate those areas. I understand what the purpose is, but we also at the same time want to encourage the renovation moving forward.

2:06:01 Yes. To that point is why I was asking that you include that within the town limits of the use of the fees collected. Right. Because as you say, I mean, probably the majority of the near-term development in the next five years, you know, are probably going to all pay fees. So then the deployment of those fees and building a housing product.

2:06:32 would, could be within anywhere within the boundaries of the town and would be excluded from those zones. So that was my, that was the point of including that in that, in that particular paragraph. So, and then, unless we had other questions, that kind of gets us to the next part, which is regional housing. And let me just kind of start the discussion on that. I mean, I believe that we, that sometime we need to thoroughly vet this discussion about regional housing versus

2:07:04 In the town of Mammoth Lakes. But if we do it now, we're never going to finish our ordinance or our nexus study and all those things. So, I mean, personally, I mean, I'm fine with leaving our ordinance the way it is with the language about within town and town limits and those kinds of things. But, I mean, we just have, it's just like, we have the, like our expanded zoning code update. I mean, they're very dynamic things in that as

2:07:32 The situation changes over a period of time, then we have to go back and evaluate the situation. So that was kind of my comment about regional housing. I don't know if you had any additional comments, commissioners. I think when the topic of regional housing comes up, it would be wise to also include somebody from Melvin County. Right. And then, so we're ready to move on to the next policy discussion. Exemption from housing mitigation. Was there any comments about that?

2:08:08 I am, I brought this up with Jen the other day. I'm a little curious about the final sentence, the new single family homes and additions would not be exempt. In the current interim policy, houses, single family homes less than 2,500 square feet, I believe, are exempt from the affordable housing requirement. And so I think it would be worth discussing maintaining some kind of assumption, exemption. Some sort of floor.

2:08:40 Yes, I think so. I mean, unless there's something that I'm not getting. So would you like to comment on that and then we'll, did you want to make a comment? I think there may be public comment on that. Okay, I just didn't know if you had additional comments. Thank you. So just as you know, my feeling would be is in our recommendation to council on this particular subject,

2:09:08 that they come up with some sort of tiered fee schedule for single-family homes rather than just maybe exempted. I mean, that would be... Okay. I didn't know how you felt about that. I mean, I think that's one way to look at it that could make a lot of sense. I mean, in my mind, a home less than 2,000 square feet is likely to be fitting that middle-income category to begin with. So it makes me wonder the necessity for...

2:09:41 Requiring affordable housing mitigation. So depending on what that fee schedule would be. Right. So would you rather make a recommendation to have a floor or do you think we should do a tiered recommendation? Well, I think it might not be unreasonable to have a floor at somewhere between 1,500 and 2,000 square feet and then tiers above, a tier above that. Do you have any other comments? No. Do you have any comments on that? No, I think that's worse. Okay.

2:10:17 Examining and seeing, you know, if that single family residence of 2,000 feet or less is generating full-time employee equivalence or is it not? And I don't know that we need to go through a huge study to figure that out. We've got quite a bit of material that's already existing that will guide us. Okay. But it's worth looking into and figuring out. Yeah, I agree.

2:10:58 And do we have a comment? Tom Hodges from Mammoth, yeah, I apologize, I was going to make this comment, I missed my note. So that's in section 17.136.100 exemptions from housing mitigation requirements. In the prior graphs, you did have the residential exclusions, I think you should include all those. However, I would recommend, my recommendation is that you exclude all single family residential uses in

2:11:33 Rural residential, residential multifamily one, and single family residential zones. And the reason is, is that regardless of size, in my opinion, you're not generating employees, demand for employees, I don't believe. Now keep in mind this excludes resort zones, so in the example of John Hooper building the houses on Sierra Star, they're in a resort zone, those are likely going to be nightly rentals, they're going to have property management demands, and they're going to generate a demand for

2:12:02 You're going to create employees. So I think it's appropriate for those homes in those transient areas. So that would specifically be in resort zones. I guess it would be in commercial as well. Resort and IMF2. Oh, and RMF2. RMF2 and commercial, you're right. So I think in those zones it's appropriate to charge a mitigation fee for single family residential because it can be used transient. But I think in any zone where it's non-transient single family, I think it should be exempt regardless of size because

2:12:32 You know, where is it driving employment? I don't see it myself. And so I would, that would be my point on that. And then I think there previously was, in that section, there was a subdivision of property and single family lots is exempt. I think that should be maintained. Because again, when a house, when a home is built, at that point, then you would assess the fee, if it's, again, if it's in a transient location. So I think you ought to include that back in there. And then I felt that the additions,

2:13:02 Remodels to single-family residences, again with the same stipulation that it's in a non-transient zone, should be exempt. I don't think there's an issue with the footages, in my opinion. I think that makes no sense. I don't think there's any nexus to employment. Thank you. Yeah, thank you. Any other comments on that section? All right. And then existing development entitlements, is there any comments about that? So in summary, it wouldn't affect existing entitlements, right? They're going to not. This would not.

2:13:51 Affect any of that? I would say it. I think that's legally we have to do that. Yeah, we've already made the agreement. All right. And then, so then we had one other policy about taking market rate rentals and converting them to deed-restricted rentals. That was what came up in our previous public comments. Was there any comment on that? And what scenario would that, we find ourselves in that, it would take a developer

2:14:42 That has an affordable housing demand, and they would go out and buy a market rate product and then deed restrict it. Correct. For rentals. For rentals. As opposed to for sale. And how would the value be calculated? Are you asking me hypothetically? Yeah, I am. Okay, so I think what we should do is

2:15:28 Because remember, ultimately what we're doing is we're going to make a recommendation here, and then part of our recommendation is that before this goes to town council, there's a couple things that we're going to now ask town staff to kind of look at beforehand, and probably we should just put that onto the list, because I can't answer those questions. Let's put that onto the list, because I can't figure, I can't see it clearly. Okay. And Tom, were you speaking to that earlier? Yeah. Yeah.

2:15:57 It's not crystal clear. Okay. All right. So let's go and so this is what we're being requested to do and we'll go down these four items. So to consider the addendum to the housing element update 2014 to 2019, the negative declaration and adopt the required CEQA findings. So we've discussed the housing element in the past pretty extensively.

2:16:24 There was a couple of mandated changes we needed to make the housing element because of the new ordinance. And then there was the CEQA findings. Does anybody have any questions or comments about that first part of what we're being asked to do? The second thing we're going to do is adopt the required municipal code findings. Anybody have any? Okay. And then we're going to...

2:17:05 approve a general plan amendment and a zoning code amendment. Are we clear on that? What we haven't really talked about then was the design, the approval for the amenity and design standards for workforce units. We didn't really talk about that. It seemed pretty straightforward. Those are on page 65 of your packet. Especially Commissioner Gregg, did you have any questions?

2:17:44 I don't think I did. I think I was, no, I didn't make any notes. I'm okay. So how would you like this motion to be made? Because basically we will, you know, there's some issues we talked about that were changes to the ordinance and some issues were policy decisions. And then we were making the overall recommendations. So what would be your suggestion about how to do this? The commission could make a recommendation that the council adopt the ordinance with certain changes.

2:18:33 Where the council adopt certain policies, that's what you can do. Okay. But what we really want to do is just recommend that staff go back and evaluate the impact. You can do that too. If you want to make specific recommendations, make that part of your motion, and if you want to include that you'd like staff to go back and do some additional work before something goes to council, you can do that too. Okay. Yeah. I like that option. Okay. Thank you very much. I think our silent concern is

2:19:03 We don't want to do something that's going to disturb our CEQA status with this. Well, we'd have to go pretty far afield before this turned into a different project for CEQA purposes. So I think that staff can do additional analysis without needing to change the CEQA documents. Okay. Well, that gives me a level of comfort. So if I'm corrected...

2:19:37 There's at least two areas that we want them to go back and evaluate for policy, correct? Correct. Or did you have additional policy? Well, I think we'll, I believe the recommendation will be to make the changes that we seem to have consensus on from comments from Mr. Hodges. Right. So do we need to detail those out or? I think we went through them item by item orally and I have the notes. So I think we're okay. Okay. Okay.

2:20:08 And then I have three policy notes for follow-up. The first one, I think, is to conduct additional analysis regarding allowing new off-site construction in the RMF-1 zone. The other was to do some more research in incorporating single-family exemptions into the ordinance. Sorry, just going back real quickly, does that first, the first item,

2:20:39 Includes shady rest? Yes. Okay. Yes. And then the third I had was looking into the option of deed restricting existing occupied rental units as an option for mitigation. Correct. So before I actually call for the motion, I mean, since you've been so great in your public comments, has anybody else had any other comments this time? Just on that, the comment about it.

2:21:18 Which zoning should be included in the, which areas of zoning should be included in the areas for off-site mitigation? My recommendation was anywhere within town boundaries. So I wasn't precluding any zone. So why would you preclude single-family residential zones? I mean, you know, I don't know if it's going to build there, but why would you preclude it? It might be nice to have a house built in a single-family residential neighborhood that's affordable unit. So I would just recommend that it's completely broad and not just adding.

2:21:50 Armoth 1 to that list. So we'll put that in the evaluation correctly. Okay. Any other comments? All right. Can I call for the motion, please? Okay. Make a motion that we recommend Town Council take the following actions. Option number one, consider the addendum to the housing element update 2014-2019, negative declaration, and accept

2:22:38 the required CEQA findings, to adopt the required municipal findings, and Sandra, where in this should we insert the additional evaluation of what we've discussed today? I think we would just say at the end with recommendations. Okay. With consensus by the council. Adopt the required municipal.

2:23:13 Code findings, adopt general plan amendment 15001, and zoning code amendment 15001, housing ordinance update, as proposed, or with modifications, and approved the amenity and design standards for workforce units, with additional evaluation by staff of issues discussed at this meeting.

2:23:48 Does that cover us? Second. Roll call, please. Commissioner Grayack? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Vice Chair Harvey? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much, and thank you, Mr. Taylor, Tom Hodges, staff, everybody for working on this. I mean, I really believe that we're starting to move

2:24:18 Get a really great product, great ordinance, and it's going to make our next phase of this whole project even easier. So I appreciate everybody's input. Item on our agenda is to discuss a letter from Planning and Economic Development Commission to the Town Council. I think you've all seen this letter. This, for me, started after our last council meeting. We had some, I think, pretty strong words

2:24:54 about what we didn't like about the Mammoth Lakes housing strategy, but I didn't feel we ever really, as a commission, said, well, what do we believe in, where do we think we're going? I'm sorry, does anyone have a hard copy? You know what, that one. There you go. Thank you very much. Thank you. There you go. You have your copy? Yeah. Okay. You have seen it, right? Yeah, I read it. Okay. So, um...

2:25:27 So, you know, Commissioner Tenney, because she couldn't be here, helped me draft this letter, and then the people of our staff was really nice to review it. So, what we basically said, okay, what do we think as a commission, what's our current economic forecast? And, you know, I really believe for a lot of reasons, you know, we've been through this great recession, we've been through two years of litigation, we've been through

2:26:00 Four years of drought. Unfortunately, I mean, we've gotten hit really hard. And I don't know, when you look at the current economic cycle, if we're going to have this big boom like we had in 2005. So I personally felt that when I dropped this, that we should, from a conservative side, we should do all our planning that our economy for the next 10 years is maybe going to be perhaps like on a flat, slightly upward.

2:26:29 Projections. So that was one assumption, and I'm assuming you're good with that. Then it was really interesting. I said, well, there's always this little confusion about dates because our general plan is dated 2007, but our actual data for that plan came from 2005. So if you look from 2005 to 2015,

2:26:59 And how many market units were built. And as far as we know, it's 445 units that have been built in the last 10 years. So if you're going to say, well, this is what our economic forecast is, this is what happened in the last 10 years, then I think when we start formulating, well, how many, you know, how much affordable housing units are we going to need in the next 5-year, 10-year period, we can really go back to these numbers and use them

2:27:29 as a benchmark, and that was kind of the purpose for that. One of the areas that I've been really vocal about is, I don't know why, but it seems like every time we get a planning document or a strategy, there's this different set, and we're getting much better about this, this different set of planning assumptions. You know, how many units are we really in this town? How many?

2:27:59 Allocated to workforce. What is our breakout between transient occupancy tax properties and none? And we have all these different planning periods. We have a strategy that talks about two years. We're going to have a diff study that talks about five years. And so every time we get a document, you can't start putting these documents side by side by side and saying, okay, what's the cumulative impact on our decisions?

2:28:28 So, I had some thoughts about this, but in the end, I really believe that Sandra's going to have to sit down and really work with the staff and come up with a game plan about how to start doing these strategies and what kind of time set, and we've started a little bit already keeping this master, now source document of, you know, what is our basic fundamental data for the town, and certainly our GIS system as we start impacting it is really a

2:28:58 A great help. The other thing is that we need to start updating the elements of our general plan. And, you know, that general plan now is already 10 years. You know, those elements are made to be updated on a consistent, rotating basis. It's really hard, grueling work, and there's just never really an opportune time to do that. And so we're really hoping that maybe we can come up with a schedule now and say, okay,

2:29:28 When are we going to just do it and just kind of hold our own feet to the fire and say this is the time that we need to do those elements? With the pending floor area ratio, it's a real game changer, I think, for the availability of land. Part of our general plan says that that whole commercial, commercial zones along Old Mammoth Road, Main Street is supposed to be a vibrant mix, and I'm really hoping that

2:29:59 We can someday see, you know, a real combination of workforce housing. I mean, if we're going to keep that area as a four-season area where people are living in all the time and this is what our vision is, then it really has to be a mix of, include housing in it. We've talked a lot about Shady West. And then on the regional planning area,

2:30:30 You know, this area needs a lot of discussion. But one thing that you can't ever say is it's very difficult to look at urban limits of a town versus geographical boundaries. And, you know, we sit in this valley with this very defined geographical boundary. And I think while you want people to feel very connected to the town and there's really strong reasons, there's just

2:31:00 There's just lots of reasons that people are going to live across the valley. Some of it's for climate, some of it's neighborhood. You know, I don't know. I think when you start driving down the Sherwin Grave, then it becomes a little bit of a game changer because it's not always easy to drive up the Sherwin Grave. And then we've talked about, even today, the importance of renovation and conversion.

2:31:25 So these were the thoughts that Commissioner Tenney and I worked on. If you have any changes, we're really welcome to talk about. But we just thought it would be really helpful for Council just to hear kind of what our basic assumptions were going forward and how we were making the decisions on those. Commission had any comments on that? No, I think it was a very thoughtful letter. Yeah, and the points are logical, well thought out. The regional planning, I mean, the geographic,

2:31:59 Boundary of the Sherwin Gray alone, I think, makes sense. No, I'm in agreement with just about every point on here. Was there any comments from the public on this? Bill Taylor again this time. Since the board hasn't reviewed this, I'm going to be speaking for myself rather than for Mammoth Lakes Housing. But I think a lot of these are issues that have been sort of

2:32:33 Stewing below the surface, and I think it is time to bring them forward, do the analysis, get the hard data that backs up some of the assumptions that have been thrown around. And I hope that the council will recognize the value of that, and I hope that Mammoth Lakes Housing can be a partner in reviewing this and helping to come to closure on some of these things, where we're talking sometimes about different ends, different objectives.

2:33:01 One person will have one set of numbers and somebody else will have a different one. So I think it's timely and I hope that we can be part of the process. Thank you. Well, thank you very much. I appreciate that. Appreciate your comments. Thank you. All right. So do we have a motion to move this letter forward to the council? Yeah, I'll make a motion. I don't have it in front of me. I'll make a motion that we, as a Planning and Economic Development Commission, put

2:33:31 Forward this letter to Town Council of Mammoth Lakes. Second. Second. You don't really need a roll call, just. Aye. Okay. Moving on to our consent agenda. Yes, Davis. Yes. I'll make a motion that we approve the minutes of the April 8th, 2015 special meeting, as well as the April 8th, 2015 regular meeting. Second. Commissioner reports. Nothing's come up before design. No, we haven't.

2:34:20 I'm going to pass on mine as I have a Little League practice that started five minutes ago. Okay. We had a great economic round table. We had a great discussion on non-snow recreation. So those were all really good. We'll move to the director report.

2:34:53 Thank you. Just quickly, two items. A note that you will be having a special Town Council Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting on May 13th from 10 a.m. to 12. That'll be on broadband. So we'll have... I'll be here for it. Oh, great. Okay. I think I sent you a maybe. You did, yeah. So, okay, great. So mark your calendars for that. And also a note, I did send an email out to the commission, but we've postponed the consultant's trip for the EIFD.

2:35:22 She was scheduled to be here the week of May 18th. We're going to postpone it and probably bring her back later in the summer. So that's all I have. Thank you for sending the invitation out. That really helps. You're welcome. Anything else? We adjourn to our next meeting May 13th, 2015 at 2 p.m. Thank you very much, everybody. Thank you.