TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 50 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

491 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Well, yeah, let's get together before we take off again. Where are you going this time?

0:10 Alright, let's get to it before you take off. Before you leave.

0:38 I will now call to order the Town Council regular meeting for Wednesday, May 6th.

1:06 We will begin with roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here.

1:16 Seeing as we are in the middle of Public Service Recognition Week, for the pledge, I would like all of the employees of some kind of a public service agency to come up together and lead us in the pledge, if you would, please. In harmony, right? In harmony. I didn't say see. We got a lot. Yeah. Well, that's part to prove the point. That's very good. Yes.

1:45 Ready? Begin. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you so much.

2:18 As Michael said, wow, there's a lot of them. Yes. We will now go into public comments. If anyone wishes to comment on an item that is not on this evening's agenda, please come forward to the podium. Good evening. I'm Shira DeBrokener, and I'm here representing the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival. So three weeks from tonight is our opening of the inaugural event of the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival.

2:48 It's a very exciting time for us. It's been snowballing into quite the festival just from our level of sponsors and the level of involvement with our jurors and the level of films that we're getting. Our opening night film is from Alex Gibney who is an Academy Award winning documentary filmmaker and his new movie is called Steve Jobs, The Man and the Machine. His last documentary was on HBO about a month ago.

3:15 It's called Going Clear, and that was the Scientology documentary that was amazing. So I'm hoping to get a lot of support from the community and from the town council. Thank you, Joe. Thank you, John, for buying your all-movie passes. There's a few other people that still need to buy them from your constituents, but you've got three more weeks. And the really interesting part is the response that we've been getting from the filmmakers. I got an interest when we gave our...

3:44 We have the submissions come in and the people when we do our rejection letters. I got this one email from this one filmmaker that said, gosh, I never really submit to first year film festivals but I did for this one and I've always gotten into every film festival that I have gotten into and it's quite humbling. So I thought that was interesting that people are really excited about this film festival, not only the people in town but filmmakers alike.

4:14 We have about 75% of our submitted films are attending the film festival. So we're bringing in about 100 filmmakers and producers between the jury and the accepted films for the festival, which is amazing. And that's what really creates the energy for a film festival. So I'm hoping that this first year we'll just knock it out of the park, hopefully with all the support of our community members. And let's have it be a long time.

4:41 Thank you for your support. Thank you. Good evening, council members and town staff. My name is Dena Campbell, and I'm the director of the Eastern Sierra College Center for Cerro Coso Community College, and I'm here to brag a little bit about our students locally. I'm pleased to announce that this year, Cerro Coso Community College's Eastern Sierra Center in Bishop and Mammoth will be graduating 63 local students.

5:13 In a ceremony that will be held this Friday evening on the Bishop Campus, 5.30 if anyone is interested. I definitely recommend coming early because it's going to be a packed house. This number, 63, reflects an increase of more than 65% over last year's graduating class. So we are really thrilled at the number of students that are completing degrees and certificates. And I also wanted to mention that although the Eastern Sierra comprises only 10% of Cerro Coso's overall enrollment,

5:42 Our graduates represent 20% of the total graduating class of Cerro Coso this year. So we're really excited about how well our students are doing locally, and we should all be really proud of the support we've been giving them. So our graduates are completing degrees and certificates in 17 different fields this year, including kinesiology, child development, administration of justice, computer information systems, business, paralegal,

6:10 Clinical Medical Assisting, which is our new program. The hospital came to me about a year ago and they said we really need clinical medical assistance and I said okay, let us get started and we're graduating five students this year ready to work starting May 15th. Also vocational nursing, math and sciences as well as arts and humanities. More than half of our graduates this year

6:37 We're supported by a full scholarship from either the Mammoth Lakes Foundation here in Mono County or the Eastern Sierra Foundation in Inyo County. Many of our graduates are planning to continue their education and are transferring or have been accepted to universities including UC Berkeley, UC Davis, Cornell University, Cal Poly Slow, Chico State, CSU Fullerton, San Jose State, and CSU San Diego. And I know I'm missing a lot, but for the sake of time, I'm highlighting just a few.

7:06 In addition, as a result of the Inyo Mono Promise, which was initiated by Dr. Terry McAteer, Inyo County Superintendent of Schools, nearly 20% of our graduates are planning to continue on to the University of Nevada, Reno, and they will be eligible for the Western Undergraduate Exchange Program, which enables them to have a discounted tuition rate. It's not quite a good neighbor, but it's a very affordable tuition for their following two years. 35% of our graduating class is Latino.

7:36 23% of our Bishop class is Native American. We are graduating one veteran student as well. And we hope with Disabled Sports and the Wounded Warriors Project to be graduating more in the future. Two students are graduating with honors programs distinction. Eight are honors students with a 3.75 or higher. And 16 have been inducted into the Phi Theta Kappa Honors Society.

7:59 On behalf of the faculty and staff of Eastern Sierra College Center, I am really, really honored to congratulate all of our local students and share their achievements with the entire Mammoth Lakes community. So thank you for letting me present this opportunity. Thank you, Dana. That's great.

8:19 Good evening, Town Council and staff. Juliana Olenka on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I'm just following up on behalf of what Dina just spoke about. To thank the supporters in the town, our donors and sponsors who have been supportive of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, and we are so incredibly proud of our graduating students who have been able to take advantage of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation scholarship. We have 13 students that are graduating, and we are actually going to have a little celebration.

8:48 Thank you, Juliana. Good evening, council members and staff. My name is Lois Klein, and I'm the superintendent of Mammoth Unified School District, and I would like to share a few highlights happening in Mammoth Unified School District. Last week, we received our cohort graduation rate from the state of California.

9:20 State Superintendent Tom Torlakson sent out a notice that he was proud of the state's improvement of 0.4% to almost an 81% statewide. I am pleased to report the percentage of Mammoth Unified School District students who entered ninth grade and then graduated four years later in June of 2014 increased from 82% the year prior to 90% last year.

9:49 Four years ago, our cohort graduation rate was 71%, so that's a significant increase. We expect that rate to grow and will not be satisfied until it reaches 100%. Also, we recently celebrated the reclassification of 21% of our English learners who are now fluent English speakers.

10:10 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

10:40 Female Athlete of the Year. That's for the entire state of California. There's one male and one female. There are over 700,000 student athletes in the state of California, and she is the one female selected. She will be honored in Sacramento later this month and will be awarded a $5,000 scholarship.

11:05 I also want to use this opportunity to thank the Mammoth High School Boosters Organization and our entire community for the support of the campaign to raise money for the Maple Gymnasium floor. Finally, our students will be able to practice and compete in a gymnasium of the same quality of all other high schools up and down the 395 quarter. The basketball floor will also be enjoyed by those who participate in the Towns Park and Rec.

11:33 And lastly, I want to thank you the Council for approving the cooperative agreement regarding

12:02 This summer's project to redesign and modernize the Mammoth Elementary School parking lot for the improvement of traffic flow, safer student drop-off, and improved integration with the town's bike and walking paths. This is an outstanding example of our two entities working closely together in a manner that is fair and respectful to complete a project that will benefit children and the community. Thank you.

12:30 Thank you, Lois. Thank you. Hello. My name is Fred Stapp. I'm a Mono County Supervisor. I represent District 2. At one of our most recent meetings, Mr. Holler and Mr. Wentworth came. We appreciated that greatly. Thank you for your appearance. So I thought it was appropriate just to come say thank you in front of all of you. Second, with all this educational talk,

13:00 I do want to recognize a former high school graduate. This is going to sound a little self-serving. Class of 1997, Dr. Benjamin Stump is currently a critical care fellow provider at one of the Harvard hospitals in Boston. So you are producing people that can go on. Thirdly, in the vein of celebration, I bring you some news from County Service Area 1. County Service Area 1 represents the Crowley area.

13:27 And talking to Stuart earlier this week, apparently you were unaware with regard to the 4th of July and fireworks that they authorized in the current fiscal year $1,000 to be contributed to the fireworks. They were never billed for that. Stuart has assured me he will take care of that. And starting with the July 1st fiscal year, they have approved $2,000 in that year.

13:52 My name is Greg Jenison. I'm a local contractor here in town.

14:26 And I want to bring some issues as far as the building department to the town council's attention. You did a search last year and you hired a head of the building department, Steve Stokes. I think he's doing a good job, but he's doing his best job inspecting the different jobs where I think

14:46 We need to hire another inspector, whether it's full or part-time, to do the inspections for him so he can take care of some of the other issues, such as the six to eight weeks we are now waiting to get permits. And it's just, even on the small jobs, you know, on some of the bigger jobs I can understand that, but it's taken way too much time. Tom Malloy's working his butt off. Diana's working.

15:09 I have no problem with anybody in the building department, but they need more help because Steve needs to be out talking to different people on how they can make things better, faster, and he's out doing inspections and it's hard to, you know, get him aside and I think he needs some help to do the job that he was hired for. I mean, he's making the big bucks, you know, where you can get an inspector that makes a little bit less money and whether it be full or part-time and take away some of that so he can get out and maybe even help Tom on some

15:39 And so I just wanted to bring it to your attention. Like I say, they're doing a good job, but they're just real limited on

16:09 on what they could do, and we need to get plans and permits out a lot faster than is happening. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else for public comment?

16:24 Good evening. My name is Kathy Cage. I just wanted to let the Town Council and the general public know that our group, Let Mammoth Decide, who has been gathering signatures for an initiative to put the matter on the ballot about making decisions with respect to zoning changes for transient rentals in our low-density residential neighborhoods. We submitted our signatures this morning to Jamie Gray at the town offices. They'll go to the county for counting, but the number

16:53 The number that we submitted was 1,071. That's about four times the minimum needed to get a special election. And I just want to take this opportunity to encourage the town council just to think about that, to really digest the numbers between now and the time when you get the official count from the county clerk.

17:17 And putting it in perspective, the last election that the town council, last three seats got seated to town council, had a total of 1,530 voters vote in that election. And that was one where the governor was on and so forth. We timed the submission of our signatures so that we could get a special election. We've got enough votes and the special election will come at a time when it will be favorable to us when locals are around and so forth. It will be in the fall.

17:45 And did that on purpose. And we've got a very organized group. We have more than 42 volunteers. People have time. We're well-funded. We're funded from second homeowners and locals and all that type of thing. And I wanted to encourage the town council to just look at those numbers, digest those numbers, whatever they are. It's probably going to be over 1,000 or close to 1,000 when you throw out a few ones that go out for technicalities. When you have a special election,

18:15 You know, very typically the voter turnout is much lower. You know, I wanted to tell you basically it's won. You know, the numbers won't lie. Well, certainly if you insist we have an election, we'll have it. But we would want you to encourage you to think about the numbers and the winnability or not winnability of a special election because it costs money to run. So when that comes back on your agenda, when the numbers come back from the county,

18:45 I just hope you will have taken the time to consider that and, you know, try to identify what benefit can come from having that as an election when it's all but a foregone conclusion. So, thank you. Just wanted to share. Thank you. Thank you, Kathy. Any other public comment? Seeing none, we'll move on to councilmember reports or additions to the agenda. Shields, can we start with you? I don't have anything. Okay.

19:17 John. Thank you, Madam Mayor. It's been a month since we've been up here together, so things have been happening. I attended the Recreation Open House on April 14th. Thanks to the Recreation Department. Wonderful event. Great networking opportunity for those who don't know. On April 21st, I attended the United States Forest Service. It's coming out with something they're calling the Draft Travel Analysis Report.

19:41 And this has to do with the ability of the Indian National Forest to maintain the road system that currently exists. There's no NEPA decision involved, but I think for all of us in Mammoth Lakes who recreate on the road system around here, who might think about converting it to trails, these kinds of things, this is an important effort to be tracking, so I encourage you all to be engaged with that. There's going to be a Mammoth Trails meeting on Monday, this coming Monday from 5 to 7 at the library, and I'm hoping some Forest Service staff will come up to provide direction for that discussion.

20:10 Comments are due for this on the 18th of May. On April 27th, Councilmember Fernie and I were very pleased to do our best at hosting and facilitating a Synergy Summit. These Synergy Summits are part of the Town Council's priorities. The focus of this one was non-snow recreation. And a Synergy Summit very simply is...

20:33 Based on the recognition that it takes a lot of folks to get anything done around here. Nobody does anything by themselves, and we all work together all the time, and to start looking to where we can identify some opportunities for synergies, some opportunities for gaps. And the first step was to take inventories from these following participants, including ESTA, the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition, Mammoth Lakes Foundation, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, Mono County.

21:03 Our Planning and Economic Development Commission, the Town's Public Works Department, as well as the Recreation Department. So it was a pretty excellent showing for all this. And we did an inventory of what each of these bodies do to participate and engage with non-snow recreation. The Forest Service, unfortunately, and the National Park Service could not attend. They were busy doing the things that they do. So we went through a process of identifying gaps. And some of these gaps look like, from a high-level gap, communications, collateral integration. You think, well, why is that a gap? Isn't everybody...

21:32 Producing their own collateral. Well, if everybody's producing their own collateral and the collateral isn't talking to itself, you've got a gap because you've got too much stuff in the wrong place. We talked about attractions and amenities, seamless customer service and information resources, opportunities for the Forest Service engagement, a need for maybe the Forest Service permitting process for guiding and that kind of thing to be a little more effective, a little more efficient, looking for Caltrans engagement, ESEA.

22:01 A lot of discussion about communications and how we can all communicate and work better as a common source of communication. A lot of discussion about branding and amenity opportunities. In the mountain, we're very happy to see Greg Dallas down here talking a lot about what attractions look like, what kind of amenities we can add to all the things that we do here. And then talking about infrastructure as well. So we talked about a quality outdoor event facility, a quality indoor event and convention facility, which is some of the follow-up conversations. That seems to be something that is really needed around here.

22:31 And the third step is we all got together and drew this beautiful little hieroglyphic thing on the wall over here, which was to take non-snow recreation, put it in the context of a timeline to figure out when do which parties start working on these things and why. And it's amazing how many months in advance, like Mammoth Lakes Tourism and other folks start working on this stuff. And from this analysis of all this, we can figure out, well, how can we do this more efficiently and deliver a better product, a better thing for our visitors who come up here. And it's a very exciting, really wonderful thing.

23:00 The next steps is being overwhelmed with a lot of great information and data. Dan and I will probably sit down when Colin gets back and start figuring out how to start bringing these partners together and figure out what these next steps look like to really make all this stuff happen. I would encourage everybody to read Thomas Friedman's book because we all know now that the world is flat. So in case you don't know what UPS actually does, I really encourage you to take a look at that book. So it's all about breaking down silos. In this contemporary world, these silos are melting all around us.

23:30 And then on April 28th, I was pleased to participate with the leadership of Supervisor Corliss and myself and Colin Fernie to put together a town hall style meeting where we all do our best to put together Elizabeth Tenney style six minute presentations on recreation technology and air service building this around a theme of what if we get it right and then what if we don't. These three topic areas are very important for our region, very important for all of us.

23:57 It was a fun event. A lot of people showed up. A lot of great conversations came out of that. And I want to thank Mammoth Forward, Elizabeth Tenney, Colin and Stacey, who worked very well as a team and I think put on a pretty good show. Some of Stacey's notes indicate some of the things that we heard out of this, and this wasn't a sort of engaged, sort of person-to-person talking kind of conversation that we had in the Synergy Summit, but again, looking at coordinating messaging and communications out to the wider world.

24:25 Are we making things easier, which Nicole brought with the Mammoth Fun Folks, which is a very interesting, important idea. How do we build cultures of cooperation? How do we focus on the shoulder season? How do we share a vision top to bottom? How do we develop pillars of our regional brand built around recreation, technology, and air service? And some of our really great informed comments from the audience. So it's a very interesting thing. I think a lot of conversations got started out of that, and I think that's probably what we intended to do.

24:53 And we're all looking forward to following up on this as we go forward. I want to thank Supervisor Corliss for participating and keeping us all on task. Colin, Kevin Green in Mammoth Forward, Elizabeth Taney, of course, Lawson Reef and the Forest Service for providing the auditorium. And I want to thank myself for providing the extension cords. On April 29th, Julie Baer retired from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy and I attended the little get-together over Convict Lake. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy has made important investments in Mammoth Lakes for the last couple of years.

25:22 The Mammoth Lakes Trail System for planning and the CEQA work, the Lake Space and Special Study and the Parks Plan, and Julie will be missed. He's got a long career in history in this region. It was great to be participating in that. The Motto County Collaborative Planning Team, a couple highlights from that get-together. Jim Branham, who's the head of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, gave a very good presentation about the dangers of wildfires and the work that the SNC is doing to try to restore the watershed of the Sierra Nevada, which is getting increasingly coming into focus with dying trees and the drought and all the rest of it.

25:52 And there's some updates from the Indian National Forest and the Forest Service. John Regalberger indicated some mechanical fuels thinning in the uptown-downtown ski back trail area. I'm not sure exactly what that means, but there may be some work on those trails this summer. Also talked about this travel analysis report, which I mentioned earlier.

26:10 The Inyo National Forest Plan revision, the draft environmental document, which was supposed to be coming out this spring, is probably not going to come out until the fall. So that gives a good window of opportunity for partners to get together and start working on this project. And the review of potential wilderness recommendations, which I know is of interest to a lot of folks, are probably coming out in June of this year. There's no set date yet, but that's coming forward. The BLM talked about this huge success with the sage grass. I don't know if you've all been following this, but this is something that's drawing national attention.

26:39 Secretary of the Interior, Jewell, and Governor Sandoval in Reno made the announcement. A great example, again, of collaborative efforts and collaborative work. And it's something that the east side, I hope, starts getting the reputation it deserves for being a source for a lot of these things. Caltrans National Bike Month is with us. We'll talk about that this evening. They also mentioned there's road work happening in Lee Vining. North of Lee Vining, there's a rock safety avalanche slide project line up there.

27:03 And next year is the Centennial of the National Park Service. The Devil's Postpile folks are very excited about the opportunities with that. There's been some discussion with the town about grand opportunities and things that could happen over in the Forest Service Auditorium. I attended the ice rink field trip on April 30th, went to the Bode Hills Open House, and this morning I got a message from Suddenlink saying if I just rebooted my modem, I will get almost twice the internet speed, and I did. So I would encourage all of you, don't throw that Suddenlink thing away.

27:30 Go home, reset your modem, and you're going to be twice as fast. You didn't have to do anything except unplug the modem and plug it back in again. And coming up, we've got this Mammoth Trails meeting on Monday. I would encourage anybody in the motorized community or folks who like the road system here in Mammoth Lakes and the Forest Service to attend. Hopefully there will be some Forest Service folks there. And the Planning and Economic Development Commission is putting on a very interesting Digital 395 workshop Wednesday starting at 10 with our regional partners to talk about big-time opportunities at Digital 395.

28:00 That's on Wednesday starting at 10. So I'm sorry to go on so long, but that's it. That's it. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Now you have to follow that, Michael. Yeah. Thank you, Madam Mayor. I just want to take a moment to congratulate John Helm and the ESTA team. Oh, yeah. ESTA was recognized by the California Association of Coordinated Transportation, Cal Act at its spring conference as the 2015 Outstanding Rural Transit Agency.

28:24 CalACT is the largest state transit association of the United States with over 300 members dedicated to promoting professional excellence, stimulating ideas and advocating for effective community transportation. ESTO's award was not only for delivering consistently high quality of service to a broad range of passengers but also for developing and implementing innovative and entrepreneurial partnerships to expand transit such as the Reds Meadows Shuttle.

28:50 Operated under a permit through the U.S. Forest Service and the Mammoth Mountain routes, such as the Red Line and so forth, operated under contract with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. S has also facilitated cost-effective commuter transportation through a van pool program and last year launched a mileage reimbursement program for non-emergency medical transportation. The award recognizes the commitment to high-quality service and to mobility for all residents and visitors to the Eastern Sierra

29:17 Thank you.

29:38 Reds Meadows Shuttle will not operate on Tuesday 526 through Friday 612. It will resume a seven-day-a-week service on June 13th. So it's nice to get those services going early. Also attended the MLT meeting today. Just a reminder, we have in our spring open house.

29:56 That's March 27th at the Westin Conference Room from 9.30 a.m. to 12 p.m. May 27th? May 27th. May 27th. You said March. I don't know what you're wrong. May 27th. So for everyone to come out to that spring open house. And that's all I have. Thank you. Great. Thank you, Michael. I have just a couple of them. I did write March though. Yeah, good. I did attend the Synergy Summit and sat and watched a lot of passion in the room. So it's going to be

30:26 Interesting to look forward to where that goes. I also attended the Mammoth Forward discussion the following night, and I again would ditto John's thanks to everyone, and especially to Tim Fesco for coming down. It's nice to see some of the farther away supervisors who have constituents in Mammoth at meetings. There was a comment made near the end of that by a citizen who was

30:52 Trying to put John and Colin on the spot about the Performing Arts Center.

30:57 And I realized that it wasn't really a complete answer, so I will, they gave the thumbs up, which was fine for that setting. But I wanted to remind the community that this council has supported the idea for Performing Arts Center. We have given Measure U funds to it. We have put aside a Measure U reserve for it. And we have also tasked MLR with working through the process of essentially getting a recommendation to us on either

31:25 Go forward or not go forward. That's a deliverable in our contract for MLR that we won't meet, but it's only because the plans are held up in the state architect's office. So it's not for want of trying, but I wanted to make sure that everyone understood that, yes, council has made a commitment to moving the Performing Arts Center forward. Other than that, today I attended the local agency formation

31:54 Commission, which we all call LAFCO just because the other name is so long. I just wanted to mention that there's been a lot of newspaper press recently about the Mammoth Hospital versus Northern Inyo Hospital issue, and we discussed it from the standpoint of having staff work to see how we could assist in it.

32:17 Back in 2009 and before that actually, Mono County LAFCO had recognized that there needs to be some kind of a regional solution and that has been in our documents and it apparently has been in the Inyo County documents now. So at this point, Mono County LAFCO is not really expecting to do anything other than try to assist coming to some kind of a solution with it.

32:44 But some of the newspaper articles have made it sound like, hey, why aren't you guys doing anything? And that's why. We're trying to work out something that's maybe not on the front page of every newspaper. Next, we will move on to reports from commissions or departments. Thank you, Council of Grady Dutton Public Works. Just two brief items. First, an update. Hopefully before your next council meeting, one of the new police vehicles that you authorized last year will be on the streets. We expect it.

33:18 We'll be out of the shop in about a week and a half to two weeks. They're taking, frankly, a little bit longer to get out this time just because we took the old ones off the street a little bit earlier. Chief has allowed us to do that, and we're reusing more of the equipment and trying to be more efficient there and actually saving us money in the long term. About two weeks after that, the second one will be out. The old police vehicles will be...

33:38 Recycled back to the town pool out here in the front parking lot. Here we consider a vehicle with 140,000 miles one of our new ones, so we're in good shape. I think Lon can keep it working, speaking of public service, for another 10 years, so we're happy to have it. The other item I wanted to mention, and most of the council, I think, got the email, but for the benefit of the audience, John Kazmirsky, who's been with Mammoth Inu National Forest for 15 years, is leaving us. He's accepted a position as a district ranger.

34:06 On the Cumberland Ranger District, on the National Boone National Forest. So he's going to Kentucky mid-June. Thanks. Thank you, Brady. Evening Council, staff, community. It's always good when you've got an audience. I have a lot to say. But really quickly, a couple of items on the recreation front. May 6th today, Little Sluggers is underway. Little Sluggers is a great free program that we offer for our first and second grade instructional t-ball enthusiasts. So if you haven't signed up...

34:42 Please sign up. It's great. It's a good time. It's happening. Well, it did happen, so you missed it. A couple of other things, too. I know it's kind of snowing outside, but the Whitmore Pool opens on Monday, May 11, for lap swim in our swim team. So if you want to get down there, that's a week earlier than we've done in the past. We're getting the lap swimmers and the swim team in the pool earlier. The propane heater is on, so it's warming. Guaranteed 60 degrees on Monday. No, just kidding.

35:09 Is that air temperature or water temperature? Yeah. That'd be nice air temperature, wouldn't it? And then finally, May 16 is Town Cleanup Day. I know I talked about this before. We've got our posters out. We've got our little flyers out. We have our bags available. So if you want to collect your orange-free trash bags, they're at the town offices. We also took some to the visitor centre, the Welcome Centre. We have them at Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station.

35:36 And to better inform our public about this wonderful stewardship event for our community, if you're lucky enough, you'll get one of these golden tickets. Very few. Anyway, less than a thousand. But we'll distribute these around town. So if you do get one, they're in English and Spanish. It's just really encouraging you and informing you of where the town cleanup day stations are located.

36:01 And for the benefit of the community, they will be at 407 Manzanita, where it's been before, Mammoth High School parking lot, thanks to our school district, and the community centre. We'll no longer have a station at Canyon Lodge, so we're trying to centralise those locations. If you do have those large, bulky, metal, e-waste or hazardous items, please drop them off for free at the transfer station, and they open pretty much all day.

36:27 We talked about the bags, so grab those. And then from 2pm, we're going to bring back kind of the barbecue slash what we're calling the celebration of thanks, which is sponsored this year by the Old Mammoth Restaurant Row Association, which will be great. They'll have a great selection of their little food and beverage items. And that's going to take place after 2pm, so from 2 to 4pm at the Sierra Nevada Resort and Spa parking lot, so do come along. And if you want to get all this information and more bags, flyers, hang tags, whatever you need,

36:56 Mammoth Creek Park from 8am, I believe until about noon or later, depending on how busy it is, you can come along, chat with our Mayor, other volunteers as well about where to go to kind of really help the town clean up for the summer. So I think that's it. Shireen Sanders, our code enforcement officer, is taking lead on town clean up days. If you have any information, please get hold of Shireen and she's at the town offices on extension 244. I think that's it.

37:26 Any questions? Thanks. Great, thank you. Thank you. Any other commissions or departments? Next up then is a public presentation by Supervisor Stacey Carlis and Mona County CAO Jim Letty. So I guess this is a tag team presentation here. We even had two supervisors in the house tonight. I know, I know. Good evening, council, staff.

37:58 It's so wonderful that so many people came out to hear our county update. Oh, wait, is there something else on the agenda? Very happy to be here, and I also want to thank Dan and Councilmember Wentworth for giving an update to our board this month. I think this is the beginning of a fine tradition and a great way for us to be informed and work together.

38:22 Do I need I say anything more? Fireworks funding is happening. So what a great example of the collaboration that's already begun. So I'll give you a few updates and then turn the program over to CAO Jim Letty to talk about our very exciting strategic planning effort that's underway. So a few projects that have come before the board that we're working on at the county. Starting this month, we have formed a board.

38:50 Ad hoc emergency services committee to take a look at our paramedics program. As you may have read or recall when we did our mid-year budget update, the paramedics program was over budget and we released contingency funds to fund that program through the remainder of this fiscal year.

39:13 The board agreed that we needed to take a look at the program and find ways to improve it and make it sustainable. So we formed a committee that has, I think, about a dozen members, including members of the board of supervisors, county staff, a representative from our paramedics association, and each board member also appointed someone to be on the committee. Mammoth is very well represented with Frank Freyval from the fire department.

39:42 We have a representative from Mammoth Hospital as well. So the first meeting is on May 21st. And these will be public meetings since it's a formal board committee. They'll be meeting twice monthly for six months. It's got a lot of work. I want to thank the volunteers on that committee. But I think this will ultimately lead to a program to improve...

40:05 Program improvements, if I can speak, that will benefit all of us who rely on emergency medical services that the county provides. We, yesterday at our board meeting, received a round fire update from Tony Dublino, who's been overseeing the debris cleanup effort by the, that was funded through the state's Office of Emergency Services and performed by CalRecycle. Tony told us that debris cleanup is now complete.

40:33 37 of the homes that were lost, the lots have been completely cleaned up, Cal Recycle did their work, that is now complete, and it was something, Jim, maybe you remember the number 600,000 tons of debris or something insane, a massive amount of work, an amazing program.

40:56 That Cal Recycle performed in 30 days. So we hope that the homeowners down there can now begin the rebuilding process. And of course our county staff are ready to facilitate that and to expedite permitting and help people get back into their homes down in Swal. And let's see, what else, what other updates do we have? Oh, I wanted to give just a quick update on road projects.

41:23 This isn't a county project, but the Caltrans project on the Rockfall project on Mono Lake has started. It's very difficult for me. I now have to leave for Bridgeport 20 minutes early. Luckily, Supervisor Johnston, my carpool buddy, is a very prompt person, so I think we'll manage to be on time to our board meetings.

41:45 But additionally, county projects that continue, one that continues in 2015 is the Rock Creek Road Project. So you can still expect delays in Rock Creek and there will be, I think, two days or two weeks, anyway, we'll have the information on our county website where the road is actually closed for a few hours at a time.

42:06 Significant work happening, continuing on Rock Creek Road, and then we will also begin the Convict Lake Road project this summer. So both of those projects funded through the Federal Lands Access Program. Very beneficial for us, but we'll have to be patient accessing those popular recreation areas. And those are really the main...

42:31 Updates other than strategic plan, which I really encourage council members and town staff to talk to us, let us know what ways we continue to collaborate and work together and how we can incorporate town priorities.

42:48 into our plan where things may dovetail and fit together. And speaking of the April 28th event, I also want to thank Councilmember Wentworth and Fernie for their work. I thought it was a great presentation. It's really exciting for me as a county member of the Board of Supervisors representing Mammoth to see the interest in these issues that

43:10 That we really need to take a regional approach on. And I do hope that this can lead to some sort of sustained engagement by Mammoth citizens in county issues and affairs. So I'll certainly be following up on that. And the strategic plan effort is a great way for citizens here in Mammoth to get involved. Jim will explain. It's the plan framework that the board adopted back in January has been presented to all the regional planning advisory and community advisory

43:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

44:08 8 to 11 a.m. at Lee Binding Community Center, and I encourage all to attend that as well, or to talk to me before then, ideally, certainly after that planning session as well. But we're really looking for your feedback here in Mammoth. And with that, I will turn it over to Jim. Thank you, Mayor Bacon. Great, thank you. I've got plenty of paper here.

44:38 And while he's getting this ready, I really, many of you may know, Jim is leaving Mono County, heading west, and I really want to thank him so much for getting, for really starting this effort and seeing it through. So thank you, Jim. And thank you, Supervisor Corliss, since she's come to the board and before she got on the board, she's been someone that has championed the need for strategic planning. So what we've been doing with the RPACs is going through a long,

45:07 A sort of two-step process where we present a long PowerPoint of how it was developed. I'm going to do that in a truncated fashion because first I want to thank Dan for coming to the board meeting and also the partnership that Dan has offered as a counterpart at the town on a number of issues that we've, during my tenure here, I want to thank him for that. I want to thank also members of the staff that we've had a chance to interface with. It's been a real honor. I really hope that as this is one of my last public presentations, I'm not on thin ice.

45:38 That's why Letterman's retiring too. He's not funny anymore. Okay, there we go. All right. Yeah, you know. Anyway, what you're going to see before you and what's also available on our website is in January of 2013, the Board of Supervisors that came in, came in with the understanding that the county was really in a reactive mode and no longer had the ability to focus on the most important things with diminishing resources.

46:05 Strategic planning has been something that has been done in other jurisdictions, has been done in the private sector, but for Mono County, this was a new endeavor. We had looked through our files and realized that the strategic plan effort that happened in 2004 was an empty binder, literally. County Council brought it to me and said, no, we did it, and he opened it, and it was empty. So what we decided to do was to take a process that would also work from the inside out and engage all of our employees.

46:34 So in late 2013, we presented a process that would not only engage our employees, but engage the public in helping develop a plan that not only does the classic more with less, but does the best things possible and focuses resources on making the best mono imaginable with all of our partners, with people in the town, people in the nonprofit sector, people in the private sector, education community, religious institutions.

47:00 Because the reality is there's only certain things that counties can do or should do, and we should focus on those things. So we worked for a year as a staff, and we brought together every single member of our staff, which is roughly 300 bodies, people who had worked together for years but had never been together in the same place, and we got from their experience some core strategic directions on the handout, which is, I pardon the small type, but we tried to make it

47:29 Complex and rich, but at the same time accessible and understandable. Areas that we can focus on to move forward as we continue to refocus county services. By means of need, not only the drought, but the financial recession that hit the private sector also hit the county. About ten years ago, the county had 345 full-time equivalent employees.

47:58 Don't have it all memorized quite yet. Now we're at 265. This is a trend. Employees have a cost to them. Services cost more. Supplies cost more. And the real estate market, which is the primary way in which counties receive their funding beyond funding they get from Washington and Sacramento for specific services, is diminishing. So this year-long process culminated with an all-employee meeting, the first ever we had had where we brought all employees together.

48:28 We then created a draft document, took it back out to every single department. We then refined it through a volunteer steering committee where we had a third of our staff, and it could be anybody from any department. There was no rank. There was no silos. If you showed up and leave Vining every other Thursday at 4 o'clock, I bought you dinner from Ohana 395, and we talked about how to focus what we were doing. Refined it, brought it back.

48:55 Gave it to the board in January. It was their idea to empower the employees to have this conversation, to give something to the public to react to. And what you have before you today is a one-page document that for the first time ever, Mono County has a vision, mission, our values, and our strategic directions, the green hexagons. The idea of the strategic directions is that they transcend and they break through across departments and across communities.

49:21 The idea is that everybody in the town and outside of the town receives county services, and the way that we're going to best serve the community is by crossing our own silos. We can't be public works and social services or economic development. We have to figure out who that is, and we can't just be that within the county. We have to work with the town. We have to work with the Chamber of Commerce. We have to work with MLT, because that's where we marshal the resources to move the needle on these things.

49:50 Have a vision. We have our mission. The values that we have are the things by which we evaluate our employees. So this is something of the legacy of who we've been and how we commit ourselves to making sure that we're providing public service. The first, I will very quickly just go through the first four strategic directions because these are external ones. These are the ones that face from us as an organization out to the community, out to our partners in service. Promoting a strong and diverse economy.

50:19 Protecting Natural Resources, Enhancing Public Access, Understanding and Addressing Community Needs, Supporting Healthy People in Healthy Communities. Those are external ones. Those are the things that we're going to work through with methods, with measurements, so that when the public gives us a dollar, we can say, you gave us a dollar and you got a service, and here's what that service did. So there's accountability. And then we have the next four are internal, so that we're improving. We're constantly becoming an organization that adapts.

50:46 That thinks that not everything is the way it should be because it was that way. It was interesting being the new guy and now a short timer on top of it. There was a great oral tradition within the county culture of like, well, we always did it that way. And I would say, well, where's the board action or where's the written document? There was no written document. Somebody said it once in the parking lot and that's why we do it. We don't think that's the best use of taxpayer resources.

51:12 The board really didn't think that, so we're refining that. We're trying to codify it. So our internal areas where we as a staff and under the board's leadership want to keep going is rewarding innovation, effectively using resources, having workforce, workplace wellness, and strengthening county culture. And by county culture, we mean the county organization, you know, that it's a healthy place to work, that the people are motivated to come to work there because we're asking a lot of folks. We're on furloughs right now. We have less employees.

51:41 You know, the demands are not getting less complex, they're getting more complex, but that's the life of public service. So where we are tonight is we've gone to all of the regional planning advisory committees, we've gone to the collaborative planning team, the planning commission, gone to first five. We're continuing sort of the agency and public commission process, and we're going to have this special board session on the 22nd where we're going to take those methods, those success measurements,

52:11 And we're collecting projects. Now projects don't mean necessarily an ice rink. A project could be a body of policies that helps shape where we direct resources. A project could be something that reshapes how we deliver services. We currently have approximately 123 project ideas on the master list that the board will have to weigh through to focus down into not only a one-year work plan,

52:38 But also into a 2- and 5- and 10-year long-term visioning process. A place where we can focus it, keep track of it, measure to it, and then when the board is given that direction, project charters will start to be created for the top 10, top 15 projects. And those project charters will be asking for help from the community. They'll be asking for partnerships with the town, partnerships with the Forest Service, whomever it may be, to move

53:07 Those projects along. So what you have tonight is the methods, the success measurements, and a blank page. And what's great about the blank page is we're looking for any ideas that a person's individual feedback, the town's individual or collective feedback can put down there in those areas. And what we've asked of the other groups we've met with is think about something that would benefit the county and then would benefit sort of the community from which you come from.

53:36 And so, for example, in Antelope Valley, people wrote down something they thought would help the whole county from their perspective and then something that would really help Antelope Valley. It's all going on there. It's not being assigned to who said it. It's just all ideas are going to have the fairness of being in the marketplace of ideas, and then we're going to narrow it down. We're going to combine where it makes sense, and then we're going to focus on that. And moving forward, when the, you know, we can never predict the next round fire.

54:06 Any kind of unintended disaster we have to respond to, but when it comes to the delivery of services, we can plan ahead. We have to. The reality is that our budget is shrinking, and we have to invest in this community to maintain its world-class destination and quality of life, and that's really what the county wants to do. So tonight, we'll leave you some pretty color photos.

54:31 And photocopies. I was able to spring that out of the budget. It is available on the county's website. If you want to send in comments, if you want to come to the meeting, we encourage people to come to the May 22nd meeting and be a part of this process. I really would like to thank not only the board, we've been checking with other jurisdictions, counties and cities through different associations across the country on this effort. Mono County is the first county

55:01 In the nation that we have found that did it completely from bottom up, that this was driven by the employees. The board empowered the employees to own this, and they've stepped forward and they've owned it, and it's really created, I think, some great buy-in, some reconnection, better working relationships among our employees, and the ability to see longer than the next budget crisis or the next worry, but to see over that horizon. So with that, if there are questions, I know you have a full agenda.

55:30 But we would love to see on the 22nd. And I want to say that Supervisor Corliss is our board champion on this. The entire board champion strategic planning, but Supervisor Corliss has personal experience, professional experience, and will be continuing this effort. And the entire board and the staff is committed to this, regardless of who the CAO is. So it will continue on, and it needs to continue on.

55:56 Sorry for being long-winded. Are there any questions for Jim or for Stacey? I just have a comment. I just, Jim, I want to thank you for your service to Mono County since you've been here. We're going to miss you. But best of luck to wherever you end up. Well, we'll be back to visit. I hope so. Create some T.O.T. There you go. There you go. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Shields, you're going to want to talk to him. He's going to be in the wine country.

56:24 I'll come visit you. You know, it's interesting, the plane that leaves from the Mammoth Airport goes to L.A. and goes right to Sonoma County. Right. Okay. That's looking like – Well, if you see me at your doorstep, you know why. Exactly. Thank you very much. Thank you. Madam Mayor, if I may add to that, Jim and I have talked about this, but from the report there, we'll actually be walking through this with department heads and looking at items to stick into the strategic plan from a town perspective.

56:55 I would invite if council members have items that you want us to run through and put into the process, please let me know. We'll add them in kind of just as a group. I don't know if we'd have time to come back in a formal council process, but if there's individual items that you want on there, as Jim has requested, that we would put them in as comments from the town. And as they mentioned, also we're not ascribing it to any individual. They want to keep it somewhat, I think, anonymous in terms of putting information in. So we'll put together.

57:23 Items quickly here from the town element. Is there an actual deadline for comments? You talked about this workshop, but that seems like that's soon. Yes and no. Good political answer there. There really isn't a deadline for comments. We think that, you know, if there's an idea, we want it to be considered. We do want to take this list and narrow it into a working document for some implementation. But if in two months one of our RPACs or a member of the council, a member of the public goes,

57:53 This is something that needs to be considered. We want to have it iterative and open to that. So we want to continue to track it. What we would ideally like is that by the 22nd or coming to the 22nd, even just a few ideas, what a number of groups have done is they've given us a list of five or they've given us a list of ten. We're just putting that onto the page for the process on the 22nd. But if after the 22nd the council has ideas or the staff has ideas, we would welcome that. Great. Thank you.

58:24 Madam Mayor, just real quick. So Dan, will you let the council know if you can have some sort of a study session, work session with the staff that council may want to participate in? Well, we had it just through our department head level. It wouldn't be a formal council meeting, so. Okay, but if there's an opportunity to participate. And I'll also mention that this was brought up very quickly at the last MLR meeting. I think at the next one, there will be more discussion because I don't believe the word recreation is anywhere on those two pages. Somebody call Supervisor Corliss.

58:53 It's just there'll be more input, so I believe that NLR will have some comments they'll submit, but we don't meet again until June 1st. No, understood, understood. Okay, that will move us on to the consent agenda. Are there any items that anyone would like to pull from the consent agenda? Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. Wait, wait, wait, I was pausing because I'm going to pull number four.

59:20 So make your motion around that. Okay. Make a motion. Council approve item 2, 3, and 5. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. I would like to defer number 4 until after we have finished number 11 because there are policy items.

59:50 That we haven't discussed yet, but they are part of this budget amendment, and I think it's appropriate to put the timing of it after that, so we'll come back to it after number 11, if that's okay with everyone else's. Great, great. All right, that moves us on to a public hearing on a resolution adopting community development block grant program income reuse agreement. So first I'll open the public hearing.

1:00:18 Thank you, Mayor Bacon. The CDBG program has requested that the town adopt the attached standard CDBG program income reuse agreement as required by federal law. The reuse agreement provides requirements for the town's expenditure of program income.

1:00:43 CDBG program income is typically received when we have a sale of a unit that has received assistance with a first-time homebuyer loan through the CDBG program. And the town has expended and expects to continue to spend program income on first-time homebuyer loans and the general administration that goes along with that. CDBG program income, well, the CDBG program itself is limited to assisting

1:01:10 Households that have an area median income of 80% at or below 80%. And so pretty simply this reuse agreement is a standard form required by the state and federal government. It's consistent with how we've spent program income. This is just one of the checkbox items for the state. So I'd be happy to answer any questions for you. Any questions? Yes. In this revised

1:01:39 Version of this document. Is there any additional liability extended to the town that's any different from the previous iteration of this? No. Okay, any other questions? Then I'll open it for testimony from public, if there is any. Good evening, Council. Jennifer Halfordi, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I don't really have anything to add. I just want to just say that it's a great program. It's great to get in sync with the new federal requirements so we can...

1:02:13 Keep continuing to revolve these loan funds as they come back in. When I was here in, I think, January giving my annual update, I mentioned that we had done one of these reusing funds, and so it does work, and I look forward to continuing to work with the town on this program. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any other testimony? Seeing none, I'll close the public hearing, and we will move into deliberation and or diversion.

1:02:45 Any comments? Then I'll look for a motion. Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to have the council adopt the attached resolution adopting the community block grant or CDBG program income reuse agreement. Do I have a second? I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes for zero.

1:03:15 That moves us on to our policy matters, the first of which is to approve a proclamation about Public Service Recognition Week. What I'd like to do is see if Council has any questions or comments. We would then approve it, and then I would ask, we have some designated people to come up and receive the actual proclamation.

1:03:44 If you'd entertain a motion by the mayor, but I would enthusiastically move that we accept and acknowledge the month of May, I believe, as public, oh, sorry, is it just this week or this month? Just this week. Just this week. Only. As public service recognition week, I'd like to make it a month, but it's only a week, so that would be my motion. I'd second that motion. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie.

1:04:13 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0, and I believe we have a couple of people to receive this. Here's the camera.

1:04:49 Thank you.

1:05:35 That moves us to number eight, which is also a proclamation, this time it's got a whole month, for May as National Bike Month. So, do we have anyone who wishes to make a comment or make a motion to approve the proclamation? I'd like to make a comment, if I could. I think we all know how important this is, how valuable this is, and all the rest of it. But I think that we're lagging a little bit here. We've been working on getting a bicycle-friendly

1:06:05 Designation for this committee for many years. And we're going to have some kind of a discussion I think before the next, I think on the 20th we're meeting at 4 in the afternoon to start getting into our budget process. But I think that we need to figure out how to prioritize this a little bit. It's very important to our economy, to our culture, and I think that we can do a little bit more. So I'm happy to make a motion to proclaim that the town of Mammoth Lakes supports National Bicycle Month for the month of May.

1:06:35 Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:07:01 Yes, motion passes 4-0. Now, there are a number of local entities. Is anyone receiving this proclamation this evening? Recreation Department is on here. I consider all these are educational or extended public service. Yes. And we're talking about some of the events, but there you go. Thanks, everybody. Yes. Practice up.

1:07:38 Thank you.

1:08:02 I believe May 15th will be all on the right to try to work that day for those communities to do the same. There is an initiative that we're supporting on behalf of National Lake Hunt, and that is on behalf of the Great Base Unified Air Pollution Control District. They have actually set up a National Lake Challenge. Everybody can come and register to log in and pass them to the miles throughout our month. There's no requirements from the pedagogical emergency line.

1:08:30 But we do encourage you to do log in, register, and then, you know, do the right thing. So, information is available on that website. If you don't want that website, it really needs a better acronym, or whatever you want to start. But basically, it's www.gbuadec.org. Or you can just log on and put it in your browser, nationalwhitechallenge.org.

1:08:58 Okay. That moves us on to policy item number nine on the youth sports funding, which... Thank you, Madam Mayor. Thank you, Madam Mayor. So, yes, thank you. So, Stephanie Daniel is our recreation supervisor who...

1:09:38 Supervises this program, so I'm kind of presenting this on her behalf, but very quickly and in the benefit of the public, I'll just give you a little bit of background and then we'll present the option, present it before you this evening. So the Town of Mammoth Lakes annually awards funds to supplement organized non-profit and self-sustaining youth sports programs that may be in need of additional funding to provide enhanced programming or to foster greater participation from low-income residents in our community.

1:10:05 The application this year in 2015 opened on March 2nd and closed on March 27. A total of nine youth sports funding applications were received by the Recreation Department. Each year the Recreation Commission receives more requests for financial consideration than is available for allocation. This year is no exception with a total of $43,400 requested and only $28,800 available.

1:10:32 2014-15 Recreation Department Budget. Local youth sporting organisations are also experiencing additional stress to their annual budgets and community sports programmes due to the hopefully temporary elimination of the county programme for community funding. Based on direction received by Town Council on April 1st, the Recreation Commission on April 7 made two funding recommendations. Option 1 in your agenda packet includes recommendations for the $34,800

1:11:03 Which requires $6,000 of additional one-time funding. And option two represents funding at the budgeted level of the $28,800. Staff has identified $6,000 in one-time funding for the program from one-time revenues. So this will be only a one-time additional funding for this program. Option one before you recommends the approval of the 2015

1:11:30 Youth Sports Funding Distribution with one-time funding increase of $6,000 as recommended by the Recreation Commission. That concludes my presentation. If you wish, I can certainly present those recommendations in a financial point of view. I would hope we've all read it. You've all read it? Okay. Thank you.

1:11:50 So that concludes my presentation. I and Chair Betsy Truax, Vice-Chair Stelick are in the audience this evening to answer any questions. And we do have a number of our youth sports funding recipients in the audience this evening as well. So with that, I'll hand it back to the Council. So first I'll ask if there's questions to Stuart. And then I'll ask if Betsy wanted to make any comments. I know she's back there somewhere. You don't have to, but if you did have any comments.

1:12:20 Thank you, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. I just want to say just really briefly, you know, this is something that I think the Commission really struggles with every year. And we all know that we all struggle to adequately fund everything in the town. But it's particularly difficult because over the past few years we've had several new sporting organizations come forward and we've also had a lot of growth in our existing organizations.

1:12:46 That is why the commission really strongly supported finding some additional monies, particularly the county funding suspended this year, because so many of these organizations are volunteer-driven. They're really great for the youth in our community. So we just really appreciate the council's consideration. I'd be happy to answer any questions as well. Actually, I do have one, Betsy. Knowing what a struggle this is, I was just wondering if the Recreation Commission has

1:13:15 talked about other ways to leverage the funding to get it up to a level where we could meet the requests instead of always having to say, well, you ask for this, you're going to get less. I don't know if you've had the...

1:13:29 I know that Mammoth Lakes Recreation has started to have that conversation. I was just wondering if the Commission had. You know, I think the Commission is very open to that. I think, you know, one of the ways that these funds are already leveraged is that we have so much volunteer support for our facilities in addition to the, you know, direct support of the programs. I mean, we have AYSO funding, you know, things for our facilities, volunteers out striping the fields, those kinds of things. I know Stuart's had some conversations with the county about ways we can, you know, be better partners on these.

1:13:58 I don't know if you have anything you'd like to add to that. I think the organizations do a great job at leveraging, but it'd be great if there's an opportunity to expand. We agree. And I just have a question, just a general. I know that everybody's volunteering. I know everybody's leveraging money. Is there any documentation going on for that so that...

1:14:23 There is. It's a fairly rigorous application process that we request of all these applicants. And we ask them to outline what kind of volunteer service their volunteers are doing in the community, their recipients are doing. I think it should be good for the community to understand how much of that kind of work goes on and what the value of it is. I know that certainly with MLR in terms of the reporting for those efforts that it's going to be good to get us all on the same page with

1:14:49 Dollars leverage, volunteer hours leverage, and in-kind things leverage and make that sort of a standard reporting part of all these programs. So thank you. Okay. Any other questions? All right. Thanks very much. Thank you. Next would be comments from any member of the public. Good evening, Council. My name is Teresa Desert. I am the local area president for Mammoth Youth Football and Cheerleading League. And I'm just here to...

1:15:22 Voice my support of additional funding for our program. Like it's been mentioned, the amount that we have been able to receive from the town has gone down over the years while our costs have gone up. Mammoth Youth Football is a traveling organization. We travel as far as Big Bear and everywhere in between, and our program is at great risk of

1:15:51 We do have a big population of low income.

1:16:19 Participants and we work hard to make sure that every child is able to play or participate regardless of ability to pay. Thank you very much. Thank you, Teresa. Thank you. Thank you. My name is Michael Walk. It's LACH and I'm a board member on the Mammoth Swim Team. I'd like to thank you guys for your consideration each year and I know that Stu really works with us and we

1:16:53 You guys try and meet that level, but I think that what the mayor said, trying to get to the $43,000 or whatever it is that everyone asks for is pretty important because these organizations are run completely volunteer. I mean, we have to pay coaches, and due to the nature of the swim team, it becomes very expensive, and so a lot of families can't do it by us paying coaches, but last year we weren't able to run.

1:17:21 So we're slowly depleting the little bits that we have available. And if we can't keep up with that, then it won't be a swim team. So I thank you guys to take into consideration what they're trying to do. And I'd also like to now speak on behalf real quickly of the volleyball team that came in there. That started this year new, and that was 100% volunteer. And just so that you're aware,

1:17:49 These girls traveled all around Southern California, and they didn't lose a game. It was really amazing, and the parents that got behind that did an exceptionally good job of doing that. So I'd just like to let you know that was all volunteer. Awesome. Awesome. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Mayor, Town Council. My name is Jesse Baldwin. I'm a...

1:18:26 I'm a local area resident. I'm also a parent, president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. So as a parent, I can tell you I have an eight-year-old son who is in Mono County Little League, and he's also in the Mammoth Youth Football League. Those programs have done wonders for his self-esteem, helping him keep in shape, his social interaction with other children.

1:18:51 They're great programs, and the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association invited Teresa last year, and we made a donation. We also are having her come and speak this month. Our association supports those programs, and like I heard Mayor Bacon ask, I think it's important as well to try and fill that gap. I've seen these coaches go way out of their way for the children on tons of, like,

1:19:20 Teresa and her husband, you know, drive these kids that can't, their parents can't drive them and stuff. And I went to Big Bear with my son and they had a big camping thing where they basically watched all these kids and went camping so they had a cost-effective way to, you know, allow everybody to stay there because it wasn't cheap, you know, to stay and travel there. So I just want to reemphasize.

1:19:45 Like I said, we support it, and Mammoth Lakes Contractor Association has supported Mammoth Youth Football League specifically, and thank you. Thank you, Jesse. Anyone else? My mother said always to pull my socks out when I was in a formal setting.

1:20:08 So here I am. Stuart Knee, Regional Commissioner from Mammoth AYSO. Thank you for your consideration. Just representing the children of Mammoth Lakes, I think they need a fair shake of the budget, and I think it's not a lot to ask, and thank you for considering their needs and the support they're giving. As far as leverage, Jo, I was just out there leveraging anyway, so it was on the field, so it just came running through here. And so we give a lot of our time, and thanks you guys for really looking into this and making it, hopefully, come forward. Appreciate your time. Thanks. Anyone else?

1:20:41 Okay. I'll bring it back for discussion. Anybody have comments to make? Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion that council approve option 1, 2015 youth sports funding distribution is recommended by the Recreation Commission in the amount of 34,800. Second. Can I get some further discussion? Yes. Yeah. I appreciate the motion and the second.

1:21:10 I am a little ashamed of myself because the last time this item came up, I was seduced by my colleagues sitting to my right here to support this thing outside of a strategic context. I deeply support this. I care about this, and I think it's something that we need to invest in. But I think that I would only add to the motion, if it's possible, to have this item. When we start talking about the budget for next year, that we start looking at this.

1:21:36 In a strategic context to increase this funding to wherever we think we can afford so that we're not going through this every year. I think that we need to show some sustained institutional support for this. And so I would just add to the motion that we bring this part of the part of it, if that makes sense. It's just discussion and we'll use it as consensus. Okay. You know, I've had some of the same thoughts, John, and that's why I was asking the question about leveraging and all that kind of things because

1:21:59 I realize that $6,000 is not a lot when we have a budget as big as we do, but that strategic look at it and the very fact that what's stated is, well, we need to give more because the county cut their funding. Well, we need to be having the collaboration. That's why I was saying, you know, recreation and all this needs to be part of the county strategy, since we are also county residents. Right. And that I agree with you, but I also think that it has to be...

1:22:24 Looking at how we can best assist all these organizations because we know how many hours are being put on them. I'm even a volunteer for one of them. So I totally agree with you. I think that's something that we can bring forward. As they said, I think MLR will be looking at and the strategy is really looking at how you get to where you really need to be. But I don't think it's appropriate to make it part of the motion. I think it's just kind of a consensus.

1:22:52 And as long, and I'm going to, I'm going to assume that we, we're going to have a couple hours before a next council meeting, we'll be talking about some sort of strategic types of things, that this, when we get into those discussions, we start looking at it from that perspective, so, thank you. Yes. Okay, so we have a motion and a second, was that going to be a comment? Okay. No, that was going to be, that was going to be a yes. Really? A roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:23:23 Yes, motion passes 4-0. Excellent. Just a quick query to my counterparts. We're about to go into some longer issues. Is everybody okay with continuing? Do we need a break yet? Yeah, that'd be great. It'd be great. I need some water. Thank you.

1:25:40 The second exhibit I wanted to just bring your attention to is one that came out of the Plan Your Parks session. We did not have it out in the field or earlier one. I know that there were some 122 people, I think, in the community participating in the Plan Your Parks over a year and a half.

1:26:15 There were a lot of public meetings both out in the community and here at the Recreation Commission and before Town Council. But it's an exhibit that shows what Plan Your Parks came up with for Mammoth Creek Park East and West. And again, I think the council is very familiar with it, showing a swimming pool, a recreation center, and the Shenzhen Inspiration Park, at least an expanded accessible park on Mammoth Creek Park West. On the east side, additional parking.

1:26:42 And again, I just wanted to remind everybody that the community has been looking at these parks for a long time. This is the most recent effort. And I guess the statement would be that the town at least has been envisioning doing a project and doing construction on Mammoth Creek Park West and East for many, many years. And I'll leave these here if anybody has any questions. Thank you. That's your April 1st town council meeting.

1:27:23 We considered this item and gave direction to staff and to the Recreation Commission basically to do four tasks. First is to the Recreation Commission as the lead advising body on this to review and discuss the proposed relocation. They have done so. They met on April 7th, just a week after the council meeting and discussed it. And they met again just yesterday and discussed the item as well. And Chairman Truax is here. She'll give some comments a little bit later.

1:27:51 As are other members of that commission. The second was to gather broad public comments regarding the proposed relocation. What we did for that is first, Stu was able to send out flyers, or excuse me, notes to 278, how did they do? 277. 237 neighboring residents to get their comments and to invite them to a public meeting. They did so. We also notified some area businesses who participated. After that, we went about...

1:28:21 Doing these exhibits, we distributed them as well. Then on April 30th, we did have a meeting out on site. We had attendance of just under 30. We had a great sign-up sheet for that. We answered what we think was a lot of good questions everybody had about the sites, both west and east. And if you haven't had the opportunity to do so, at least yesterday, there were still four of the six survey states, basically, that we put out there. We constructed about, I would say, a seven or eight foot

1:28:50 Lath with blue tape on the end of it, on either end of where the proposed roof structure might be located. The three on the west side didn't survive as well. I think one of them is still there, a couple of them knocked down, but there's a lot of activity on that end, people coming off the end of Meadow Lane, so that's no surprise. The ones on the east side have done better. They were still there yesterday morning near the restroom. And if you stand in the playground, you can actually see...

1:29:17 Looking to the west, you can see the left-hand corner. You can see one that would be the center or the peak of the roof and look to the right and the right-hand corner. We described the project out there to the community. It was actually very good to do it out on the site. One thing that we noted and pointed out was the post height of that facility would be anywhere from 35 to 42 feet, depending on the final design.

1:29:40 And that was actually the same height as the La Vista Blanc first building right there to the west. So we were able to really show people, you know, that's how tall it would be. Obviously it would be wider, there'd be some other design considerations, but it would be that wide. We stressed while we were out in the field and after we came back to Suite Z that this has not even reached the level of preliminary design and no environmental work has been done. That was some of the pointed questions we had about the engineering and the environmental and planning process.

1:30:09 Because we told people, we said, look, the town council knows this is a serious issue. They know that there will be a lot of interest. And rather than go to preliminary design and design the whole facility and everything and do the environmental documents, they said, look, the first step is go back to the community, let them know what we're doing so they can start having input. And I think that was much appreciated. And we got it back here this week at 6 o'clock. I think about 15 people followed us back. We also had a good session here.

1:30:39 Conceptual design of the facility, again, I don't even want to call it preliminary design because we're not near 30%, we're probably five, but the conceptual design of the facility, what some of the scheduling issues might be, and some of the cost estimates that we were looking at. Item C, and I'll get back to the cost and schedule in a second, but item C was to engage with MLR.

1:31:02 There have been at least two meetings that I've attended and others where MLR was there. Actually, they're board meetings, of course. The Recreation Commission also participated where we answered as many questions as we could about the process and how we got to where we are, why it was cited, where it is, why staff was making the recommendations they offer. The last thing was to work with staff, the Recreation Commission, to work with staff on due diligence. The two things that came out of that is we have a...

1:31:29 A schedule, and again, I also have a handout that I think you have before we end. I believe there was some available in the back. It's also been posted on Granicus. The staff report notes that our current estimates, in big numbers, if you will, because again, this is conceptual, a new roof for the facility is going to be about a million dollars. Now, 937 to a million and 50,000.

1:31:53 Somewhere in there, we have to concern ourselves with the foundation and other things. So just think of it as a million dollars. And that would be true whether it's an existing location or over in Mammoth Creek Park, west or east. That's the same. So our real focus was on relocating the existing facility and what we could save. Stapp did spend quite a bit of time on it over a two or three week period.

1:32:16 We came with an estimate of between $1.1 and $1.3 million. The handout's a little bit more detailed than that, but again, this is conceptual. So we think, again, the roof itself, about $1 million. Relocating and the new facilities, we'd have to add about $1.3 for a total of $2.3 million for a facility at Mammoth Creek Park, west or east.

1:32:40 The schedule, we looked at what it would take to get through the planning and environmental process. We looked at all the detail and what we found was typical to many projects here in town. Those weren't the controlling factors. Really, the controlling factor is our construction period. We're not going to start a project like this until next June regardless because if there's snow on the ground, we're not digging up the ground out in Mammoth Creek Park. We're just not going to recommend that at all. So if we do start in early June,

1:33:07 Which is over a year from now, you know, plenty of time to get the rest of the processing done. We would time it such that we would finish the work at Mammoth Creek Park, we would erect the roof, and as soon as the summer programs are over, we would take the boards and the glass down and relocate them so we wouldn't miss any hockey this winter. We would be going without a roof. We wouldn't miss any next weather. We'd be able to open, we believe, around Halloween, which is almost a full month before what we've been opening.

1:33:35 And we would also not disturb the summer program. So we think that schedule really works. And again, that was a controlling factor for a scheduled discussion. The only thing I'd like to add before I mention it, before I turn it over to Stu for some of the comments that we received and the Recreation Commission comments, the exhibit that you just shows a ice rink on, I'll talk specifically to Mammoth Creek Park West, that was about 30 feet or so from the playground and about 100 feet from

1:34:05 The right-of-way line of La Vista block, so over 100 feet from the first building. Walking through the site every morning, just about every morning as I do on the way to work, frankly, it dawned on me and I came in and talked to staff. What we thought would be better for the community overall is to move it slightly further away from the park because if you're standing 20 feet from a 30 or 40 foot high building, that can be rather imposing. I'm not sure there's any view difference, but it's just a nearness to the park.

1:34:33 If we moved it about 30 or 40 feet to the west, that helps solve that problem. But in addition, if we enclosed the western end of the building, and only the first, say, 30 feet or so, again, conceptually, if we enclosed the first 30 feet or so, it would do a couple of things. One, it would help shield light and sounds and things coming out of that into the building. Plus, it would allow us to put the Olympia machine, the ice preparer, and the chillers.

1:35:02 Inside the building. So again, less noise, less interference, and frankly, we wouldn't have to rebuild the building that houses those now out on site. That's a couple of modifications you don't see on the exhibit, and they're relatively minor, but it's something I want to let you know about. With that, I'll turn over to Stu for a second if you can describe just kind of the general comments that we received on site, and then move on to Recreation Commission. Thank you.

1:35:27 Thanks, Ray. So really briefly, we included the majority of the public comments in the agenda packet, so no council have seen that, and the public can certainly access those, and we also added the additional comments that came after the packet was distributed. Just in summary, so we did send the 237 property-owned letters on mid-April, and I know a lot of those property owners only got those maybe a week or less before as well. Some got them three days after, so again...

1:35:54 We apologise if we didn't get them to in advance of the meeting. And then we also send around about 1,100 emails to our distribution list informing the public of the event as well. So that was the outreach. Characterising the comments, again, I want to thank the public for sending them all over. I did read them all. They all got forwarded to the appropriate bodies. Just characterising the comments, you know, the criteria for the site selection, site alternatives, what other places or...

1:36:23 What sites have we looked at, the environmental analysis and what process would that take, the funding structure for the facility, the operational impacts, obviously parking noise, and then the difference between this project and what has been previously presented and considered by Council in the past. So that was kind of the summary of the comments that we've received, if I can characterize them in those criteria. So that was the summary. I can give you an update from the Recreation Commission. I'm sure our Chair would probably do a...

1:36:52 A more detailed response than I would. And we do have Betsy here, the chair. We have our vice chair here as well. And I'm not too sure if any other commissioners are here. But OK. Thank you. Thank you, Stuart. Hello again, council members. And thank you for your support of youth sports funding. We look forward to working with you all on making that a sustainable effort.

1:37:18 As most of you know, the commission did meet yesterday, and as Grady discussed, we've been working very diligently on the tasks that were assigned to us by council. And I think the consensus that came out of commission yesterday, we did not take a motion either way, the relocation workflow timeline and the preliminary cost estimate.

1:37:41 That are before you tonight, the commission did not have yesterday. So the commission was looking for more time to review that material. And also, as Steph mentioned, we've been engaging with MLR. I've been attending.

1:37:55 Their meetings, staff has been attending their meetings, and we're looking for a little bit more time also to engage with the MLR strategy effort, particularly in the overall context of the Plan Your Parks effort, because obviously relocation of this facility to Mammoth Creek Park West would impact that, or East.

1:38:14 So the commission next meets on Tuesday, June 2nd, which is the day before the Wednesday, June 3rd council meeting. So I think the commission was really looking for us to be able to bring that back in June just to review these efforts and then be able to bring a recommendation to council on June 3rd. I'd be happy to take any questions or if Vice Chair Stelic wants to add anything.

1:38:38 I do have a question, Betsy, is that can you kind of explain what would go on in this next month so that, you know, what, when you say you would review, what is it you're going to be reviewing? Sure. Well, I actually just asked Stuart earlier to send out to the commission the timeline and the preliminary cost estimate so everyone can have a chance to really take a look at that. You know, Grady's kind of alluded to what it looks like. I should also mention that the commission

1:39:06 Before coming to this consensus, also ask staff whether or not this delay could impact the construction timeline, and our understanding is that that would not be impacted, that it would just potentially push the schedule a month, but we'd still be looking at construction in June of 2016.

1:39:23 And I think definitely one of the things the commission was looking for was for us to have a meeting with the MLR strategy group as they're putting that together. So that would definitely happen within the next month as well. As far as staff, would we be able to continue doing the analysis on the roof for the bid and such during the next 30 days?

1:39:48 What we were looking at is going ahead and looking at maybe even starting the specifications for that roof structure, if you so like us to do that, because regardless of the location, that will still go on. If I could mention one thing that I did not specifically to Mammoth Creek Park East before, it's in the staff report, but I didn't mention it when I was up there. We did review the cost for Mammoth Creek Park East as well, really just relatively speaking.

1:40:12 And our estimate at this time is that it would probably be in the neighborhood of 400,000 more. To put it on that side, just because there is no parking there today, the utilities there are not as robust as they are on the west side. There are some other issues. The second thing is that, as everyone knows, we also met with U.S. Forest Service to at least discuss that. We reviewed the special use permit in detail, which is also part of your handout and available online, just to review that. And there are restrictions for what we can do in terms of permanent buildings.

1:40:41 On the U.S. Forest Service land, we couldn't put a permanent building there. So any permanent building we'd have to do would indeed have to have us look at acquisition of those parcels. And again, they usually end up somewhere near market rate. Again, I need to jump around, but I wanted to make sure I got that in. Well, Ashley, then, so what's an estimate of what near market rate means? That's a good question because I don't have an appraisal for land in that area, but we're looking at the end, the Mammoth Creek.

1:41:10 Okay. Well, personally, I believe that, you know, regardless, we should start the process of looking at to put Mammoth Creek Park east in our portfolio and start the process because it is going to be a long process. There's no doubt about it.

1:41:41 MLR Strategy has already said that there has to be an inventory and a discussion about which of the special use permit parcels we maybe want to acquire it. That's already a thought out there. But I do want to make clear that it's not just 400,000 more, it's 400,000 plus land. Right. And Grady, in this next month, are you going to include the

1:42:09 So-called enclosed west end, how that might work, work on that? Yeah, I think based on the feedback we got from some of the property owners and what have you that.

1:42:32 Probably makes sense. And frankly, overall, we also think it may actually be less expensive to do it that way because right now we're looking at rebuilding the building that holds the Olympia. We don't have to do that. That building where it is today cost over $100,000. So we'd look at relocating it rather than rebuilding it. But there may actually be some cost savings by making the buildings slightly bigger to it. So you'll do that in the next 30 days? Yeah. We'd like to do that.

1:42:59 Anything else, Betsy? The only thing I would add is that the commission did have, there were some questions about could you build the roof in one place and move it over later and so we did actually direct staff to continue working on the roof estimates because we do see that as a separate project and we do want them to continue with that momentum.

1:43:18 Okay. So we have a recommendation from Recreation Commission to continue this for more study, but before we consider that, I'd like to ask anyone else who's been here since 6 o'clock and would like to make comment today to go ahead and do so, then we can discuss, because it may also, that might also bring up some other questions that need to get answered that we're not aware of yet. So at this point, I would open it up for just, for public comments.

1:43:53 My name is Ted Metz, and my wife and I own a condo at Sunrise. That's on Meadow Lane and just west of La Vista Blanc. And you have quite a number of letters that have come in from the various homeowners associations. The difficulty with the west location is being...

1:44:23 Right where it's moved into a residential area, and that's a great difficulty for us, as well as the parking, and it's better explained in the letters that you have. I believe you have about five of those from different homeowners associations, so that explains better than I could what the situation is, and we would...

1:44:52 Very strongly feel that this is not a good location for it. We strongly support the tremendous amount of work that has been done and the interest, and of course it dovetails right in with the youth sports funding that you've just voted on. So we definitely support the concept, but not where it's located.

1:45:20 If it were to be in the west part of the park. Thank you. Ted, do you mean in the west part of Mammoth Creek Park West? I wasn't sure what you meant. Well, it's in Mammoth Creek Park West is one of the options and in the western edge of the Mammoth Creek West. Just a quick question. I'm assuming you have an annual meeting with your homeowners association?

1:45:50 Yes, there's one coming up with our association the first of next month. The first of June? Yes, sir. Is that an annual meeting? That is an annual meeting on the 6th of June. And it happens up here in Mammoth, I'm assuming? No. Oh. The majority of the homeowners live down south, so it is in Long Beach. Okay. Is there any opportunity over the course of the next couple months where most of your members might be up here that if you wanted to have a little conversation or something like that, that might be possible or no?

1:46:19 We'll have a conversation at our annual meeting in Long Beach. Well, I'm just wondering if you might want to talk with some folks in the community. There are very good displays on the website. We've seen, my wife and I have seen these in the last two days. I'm just wondering if your homeowner associate would be interested in having a conversation with maybe some elected representatives of the town or with the community, if you guys are going to be up here. I'm just wondering if that might be a possibility. It's a very good possibility.

1:46:48 Yes. Okay, thank you. Yeah, we'll try to do that. Okay, thank you. All right, thank you, Ted. Any other questions? Thank you. Okay, so anyone else who would like to speak? No, Lainey. Hello, I'm Lainey Altarini, and I want to talk about the rink, which I think we're on. So, we want a rink, we don't have a rink, and we need a rink.

1:47:20 This has been going on since 1998 and we still haven't gotten it and I'm 12. Although now you're talking about moving it and you might follow through with that and you're just talking about this this year. I'm just kind of confused on that process. I don't know about anybody here but is anybody psychic? Okay. So we never know how long that rink is going to take to move and that might even shorten our...

1:47:49 Time to play. So I want a roof where it is so that we can play six months instead of two and a half months. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you. Council members, Madam Mayor, and the good people of this amazing town, Mammoth Lakes. I'd like to echo former rec. Your name, please. Oh, I'm sorry. My name is Michael Russo. I'm a resident of this town.

1:48:22 I would like to echo former rec lead Bill Sauser comments from a prior meeting and just say thank you. Thank you very much for all that you've done. It's just amazing to be able to have the facility that we now have, to be able to live in this town and to be able to play the game that we love and have it available for families to use. It's just great to have. And I'd like to thank you for all the work that you've done.

1:48:54 As well as all the workers and the staff. And just the experiences that we've encountered there has just been tremendous. And once again, thank you. I have a few points I'd just like to make very quickly here. In my profession, IT management for the public sector, I deal with resolutions and solutions on a daily basis. What really befuddles me at this time is how the school committee and the town can't come to a resolution or a solution.

1:49:23 With the current situation to where the rink sits now. You know, you look at the years of history that you've all worked together. You know, the development, the trials and tribulations that have gone through. I just, how can this not come to fruition to keep the rink? A finalized, structured, roof rink, where it is today at this time. I find that hard to believe that we can't work together.

1:49:48 When I say we, I mean you and obviously the school committee can't work together to make that happen. Another thing when we're on the lines of resolutions and solutions, why is the school not involved in that rank more? Why is there not a gym period? Why is there not an activity period where the kids could walk and skate and use the facility on a daily basis? I'm from a small northeastern town.

1:50:17 We used to have gym period on the pond, you know, behind our high school, and that's another thing that I kind of scratched my head at. I don't see how the school committee can't take a great advantage of what is available there now, especially when the structure does have a roof on it. And, you know, I'm aware of the financial implications on long-term moving. I mean, from a business standpoint, you don't want to be chasing money. I'm aware of that.

1:50:46 It's just very interesting to me, you know, with this great town that we have, this great community, that we can't figure something out to work to keep the structure, the finalized structure, where it is and where it sits today. And lastly, you know, why? Basically, it's for the youth. You know, when I meet Mammoth natives, you know, when you meet a Mammoth native,

1:51:13 They're so well-rounded individuals. They have such a skill set. And those skill sets transfer to the type of person you're going to be. If you have this roofed structure where it sits today, the youth are going to grow. They're going to be able to continue their progress. And this isn't just hockey either. This is just skating. This is a family facility to have it available to have.

1:51:38 And continued for usage. And I say this because everything looks great that's being proposed. And I'm all for it. It looks fantastic. And once again, I thank everybody for all their efforts. But from myself being informed from previous residents, it just feels like it could stall eventually. And we can't have that at this point. Momentum is building. The word is out amongst the hockey communities, just in general, about the current facility we have in this town today.

1:52:09 And, you know, people are pretty much blown away when they know we have an outdoor rink. I mean, you know, it's been said time and time again, the tournament aspect, you know, skating clinics, youth tournaments, all that stuff. I mean, it's just really a no-brainer to me to try to move forward, keep the structure where it is today, put a roof on it, and work it out with the school committee if possible. And lastly, it's like we've been encountering this climate situation.

1:52:36 It's just another viable option to have available without a downtime, you know, and another family-friendly activity to have on a regular basis. So I'd just like to thank you, and God bless the town of Mammoth Lakes. Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, Jeff Posey. Here once again, after listening to everything that went on today, I really feel like we're back in 2003, trying to figure out a place where we can put our rink.

1:53:11 I'm not, I don't want to get involved with, you know, the school and the town, whatever you guys do, I mean, that's what you're going to do. Okay, but these kids that are playing now, I mean, some of them weren't even born in 2003. And the others, they were in diapers. And we're still sitting here, figuring out where we're going to put the rink, what are we going to do with our rink. You know, Mammoth Lakes, world-class destination resort, you know, we have a world-class skate park, world-class mountain. You know, see? You know, we have, you know, our soccer fields, our baseball fields.

1:53:38 They're sitting in a really awesome forest. We have the world-class track and our rink hacked on. So I want a roof and I want it now, you know, just sound like a roof of salt, but I think we should get this project completed. You guys can all stick a feather in your hat, look at what we did, we completed the project, let's move on to another project. And if it takes three, five, I mean, what, 2003, we were there in 2007, I believe it started, that year.

1:54:05 Glass blew down and said we'd have glass. There was no hockey that year. There was, but no one ever played because you'd lose a puck every two seconds. Then we got the glass back up four years later. It's just a long process that keeps going and going and going and going and going and going. Let's put a roof on it, finish the project, move on. I don't care where you put it after that. You can put it wherever you want. Thanks. Good evening, Council, Mayor Bacon, staff who's been working hard on this project.

1:54:41 As you guys knew from other meetings, Mammoth Lakes Contractors, Martin Kleinbart, also Vice President of Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association, as you guys heard from a meeting several months ago, the Contractors Association donated quite a sizable amount of money. I think it was like $750. And, I mean, considering our budget, you know, it's a pretty sizable. So, I mean, we, just like Mr. Posey said, you know, this

1:55:09 Ike Shrink has been back and forth here or there. We need to probably just stay with the home it has. Many people here thought that that was the final place it was going to be. And whatever the items, the meeting of the minds between the school district and the town of Mammoth Lakes, I mean, I think that somehow, somewhere, there can be some kind of meeting of the minds to make it all work.

1:55:40 I think that the opposition may be too great to overcome. I used to live at the late 90s near that where the facility is scheduled to potentially go. I don't recall the exact reasons how the opposition was leveraged enough to where they put an end to it at that location. Maybe somebody can recall what that was because if that's

1:56:08 The same sort of leverage that's going to come forward again, I think it's a futile attempt to try to put it there, even if it may be a wonderful place. I mean, we have to do what we can do, not fight what we can't. Anyway, so I'm supportive of keeping it where it is. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Hi, my name is Andrew Weber. I'm a Mammoth Lakes resident for 20 years, contractor in town.

1:56:45 And I also have a son who plays hockey, so I'm here supporting youth hockey. I think I speak for almost everybody involved in the hockey program that the rink, for the time being, should really stay where it is. I'm going to echo what everyone else just said. These designs are great. I just think it seems like we're

1:57:16 Doing this stuff, we're throwing so much more money at this issue when the obvious solution is staring us in the face. And just like the previous comment about the school district town, it just seems absurd to me that, you know, instead of continuing to deal with the school district and try to keep the rink where it is,

1:57:47 Put the roof on it where it is now. It's a no-brainer. I mean, I'm in construction. I don't understand the idea of moving it, spending a million and a half dollars to move it. It seems like we don't have a lot of money. You guys are worried about the cost of all this stuff, but you're going down this road, it's going to cost so much more when, in reality, we have the money allocated for the roof, continuing to lease the land.

1:58:16 Put the roof on the rink where it is. In the future, if we have to move it, we can move it. But to me, continuing with this project, it just seems kind of absurd to me. So I'm supporting keeping the rink where it is, put the roof on it, just like Jeff said. Then we can move on. Anyway.

1:58:46 I don't take up any more of your time, but that's my position. Thank you. Thank you, Andrew. Howdy, Dane Plot. Real quickly, just kind of want to echo some of the things some of these other folks have said. It's just frustrating. We've been here a long time. We've seen it. We've been through this conversation before. My question is, what has changed from the last time we made the decision and decided to put it to the school? Why is it a good decision now to do this when it wasn't a good decision back then?

1:59:20 I don't know what has changed. I know there's different people up here that we're talking to. That's probably the only thing that I see any different. Back then, it wasn't a good idea. All of a sudden, it's become a good idea. But I haven't seen any reasons why it's a good idea. Because our lease is up? Well, we knew that lease was going to be up when it was back when we talked about this. We're going in circles. There's no end to this. Everyone sits up here, and we've seen this all over. We've talked about this.

1:59:50 I could bring a recorder up and we could all sit here and place a recorder the last time we spoke about this. Everybody just wants it to be done. If we can find a way, whether it's here, whether it's wherever, just get it done. It's just, it's crazy. It's crazy to think that we've, every year, I bought a $3,000 mountain bike this year to get in shape because we were told that there was going to be a roof and we're going to have six months of, that's the only reason I bought the dirt. I'm being honest here.

2:00:20 And I threw up at the top of Uptown today, so. Please, I'm not getting any younger. These guys ain't getting any younger. I mean, I come out, I try to help with the kids on Saturday, Jeff Posey, all these guys, they donate so much time, and it's all for these guys. I mean, I'm almost 40 years old, I've already done it. But it's for these guys, man, it really is. And, I mean, they're going to be standing up here, and this guy's going to be my age standing up here going, can we get a roof on the rink? Why is it?

2:00:48 Why is it at the village now? I mean, I'm just, I appreciate, I know everybody's trying their best and I hate to be whatever condescending is. I just, we're just so like, we want to just play. And we want to play for longer than three months. And we want people from LA to be able to come up and play. People, I have friends down there, oh, let's get together a team. Well, we don't know if there's going to be ice. It might be sunny that day. There might be puddles in the ice. We can't put together a tournament when we don't know if there's going to be actual ice.

2:01:16 How do we have 10 teams come up if we don't know? So I appreciate your guys' help. Like Mike said earlier, let's get this done. Thank you. Anyone else? I'm Motoshi Honda. I'm from Bishop. But I have a couple of questions, council members. Is there any definitive strategy this time to overcome some of the opposition? I mean, there are going to be a...

2:01:56 The Homeowners Association, Conduers Association. I mean, I don't like to see, like, a 30-feet building all of a sudden left it right next to my house either. And it's going to be really tough to persuade those people to build this, whatever the facility, right behind their, well, in their backyard. And I just want to ask you, like, if...

2:02:23 Do you have anything definitive this time? That you're confident enough to overcome the opposition? I don't see any discussion. EIR, CEQA, that's like a piece of cake. That's no problem. But this, like, to overcome the people who are opposing, I mean, I don't see any clear strategy here.

2:02:54 Proposed by the council. So I, you know, it's a great idea to move to the west, but I don't see it's going to happen. I mean, yeah, we're going to design and get the cost estimate and everything, but at the end of the day, you don't have any strategy. How are you going to convince those people to build this huge facility in their backyard? And on top of that, you know, $1.5 million more?

2:03:25 I don't know. Is there any budget for it for the next fiscal year to come up with that money to start construction? I mean, if we have money right now to build the roof in the current location, I mean, I just can't see why not. And as everyone repeated, it's just going to end up at the same place again. I mean,

2:04:01 And, you know, they're going to be older. They're going to lose the prime time to play hockey. Because then, you know, sooner or later, when they graduate high school, they have to move out if they want to get career. And their hockey days are over. That's only like five years. But if we go take this path to the Mammoth Creek West or the East or wherever, they're not going to have that great time. Thank you.

2:04:38 Mayor of Town Council, Jesse Baldwin, local contractor, and I'm speaking now as president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. I just want to clarify that as an association, we don't have a stance on the location of the ice rink. We do, however, support the roof getting put on the ice rink, and I spoke here previously when Jeff came to our association.

2:05:07 Asking for our help to help support funding for that roof, we voted as an association to do that, and then that process got a bit convoluted and seemed to take a while, and we came back and got some clarification as it appeared that the fundraising methodology was shifting to the town, and Stuart helped us out.

2:05:34 We got, you know, a pass to raffle off to the person at the round fire forum meeting that we had. And we basically, for myself, when I voted to support that roof, I was just under the assumption that we were putting money forward to pay for a roof that was getting put on a facility in a timely manner, you know.

2:06:03 I haven't been following this topic as closely as I have. There's a lot of construction-related things going on right now that my attention is focused on. But it would help me out to get a little bit of clarity of why this change has happened. Like I said, I'm sure it's been said. I'm not clear on it. And like I said, when we voted to put up those funds, we were just under the assumption that, hey,

2:06:27 We're helping to expedite getting this roof put on to help extend the season and the versatility and the usefulness of that facility, both for the children and everybody else who uses it. So that's all I have to say. Like I said, I just want to clarify as an association, though we don't have an opinion on these locations. Thank you, Jesse. Hello again. My name is Teresa Desert, and I am here to voice my...

2:07:00 Support of keeping the rink where it's at and I am no accountant nor am I a mathematician but when I look at the numbers that are preliminary cost estimates that are presented to us tonight and correct me if I'm wrong but it is my understanding that what the town pays to the school district with the cost of snow removal is approximately $60,000 per year to keep the

2:07:30 For the ring in its current place. And looking at just the preliminary estimate of $1,276,500, looking at just that factor alone, that amount of money would pay for the ring to be in its current place for 21 years. Then in addition, if the

2:07:54 The homeowners fight for this to not be on the west side, and we're looking to be more potentially community-wide, except it on the east side, we're looking at this $400,000 additional that you mentioned, plus the price of land, so that price goes up dramatically. Obviously, we don't know how long an ice rink lasts, but I think that in 40 years, something new or different is going to happen anyways.

2:08:19 Why are we going through all this effort? Let's just keep the roof where it's at. We've got support for it. We've got momentum for it. The price is cheaper now. I know that you guys are looking at long term, but I think that the west side is most likely going to be defeated, and the east side is just going to be too expensive. Thank you. Anyone else? Good evening, Council. Everybody else?

2:08:58 My name is Maria Sandoval, Maria Paul. My husband and I own a property here in Mammoth. It's in La Vista Blanc, number 68. The unit overlooks the park. And it's just where the chiller is going to go. The highest point of the roof is going to go. I am not going to throw numbers off, but...

2:09:27 Just a simple question. How would anybody here feel about having the ice rink in their backyard? Would you feel lucky? I was pleasantly surprised to hear everybody here who are the hockey players. If the hockey players in town want the ice rink, where is that? And the residents that are going to be affected.

2:09:57 Don't want the ice rink to be moved. Why move it? If there's not a problem, if it's not broken, why fix it? Negotiate a lease with the school. It doesn't have to be a 20 years lease. And let's don't be sorry 10 years from now from having rushed into this project.

2:10:23 As the town seemingly rushed to do the lease back then when it did. And just please vote, vote no, no, no, no, to the moving of it. Don't fix it, it's not broken. Thank you very much. Thank you. Hi, this is Lynn Altieri-Need, long-term, I guess it has become long-term now, advocate for the roof over the rink.

2:10:56 And I was looking at the background here in the Recreation Commission staff report and the discussion about how there appeared to be consensus between the parties on the following. And the first one was long-term commitment to a multi-use facility.

2:11:10 Managed by the town in the middle of district property may not be in the best interest of the district, and I'm not hearing that from the district, so I'd like more clarification on that point. The second point is may not be in the best interest of the town to continue to invest in a limited term facility. I would agree with that, but I think we really need to pursue a long term discussion with the district. I also see that

2:11:35 Additional improvements in the resulting enhanced use of the facility will likely create some unintended conflicts with other facilities. And it's mentioned in here the library, which may grow in the future. So I'd just like to point out that in case I'm sure you already realize this, but you have very limited land assets right now, right? As a matter of fact, I'm hearing that you would trade out a 2.6-acre property where an existing rink currently sits.

2:12:01 For potentially a new location that the Forest Service owns, and I know that will total probably four times what we'd be looking at now. So I really think that it says it does not appear to be a cost-effective means to provide the improved facility either by lease or purchase of the property. I think given the new budget that's just come forth for the relocation of the rink at 1.3 million, and I think that could climb upwards.

2:12:30 There has to be some restoration of the original land that was not mentioned in that budget. So, you know, we're looking at now something that's far different than what we heard about a month ago, which was a range of about $400,000 to $600,000. So I think you really need to reevaluate what this consensus is as a member. I want the roof on the rink just like everyone else, well, most people in this room. And just really urge you to consider that as much as you may be considering relocation.

2:12:59 Completing this project is of the most importance. Thank you. Thank you, Lynn. Okay. Were you coming forward, Pat, or are you just sitting down? Okay. Okay. At this point, I'd like to bring it back to Council for a little bit of discussion. But let me start, because I've been keeping notes here.

2:13:30 I'm kind of presuming from comments and body language that we feel that there's more questions to be answered. Well, I have 11 of them that I've gotten from the comments tonight and from others. If you don't mind, I'd like to read them off and see if there's consensus to ask for these. And not in any particular order, but essentially, I think we have fallen short in our...

2:13:56 I think that Lynn just brought it up, but when we say not in the best interest, I think we have to be specific about the restrictions of having it on the school property, et cetera, as much as we can.

2:14:18 I think we need to discuss the difference between putting it on land we own versus land that we would have to purchase and go through, exchange on, or something like that. And or some other option, or lease. I know there are a lot of considerations, especially in the written comments, and some...

2:14:41 Tonight about light, noise, traffic, etc. I think those need to be listed and explained how the environmental document helps to find ways to mitigate those, if there are any things that need to be mitigated. I personally am not interested in signing off anything that says we're going to approve it without mitigating to less than significant.

2:15:06 I think that we need to make it clear that it is a multi-use facility, not just an ice rink, and explain what are the pieces that need to be done to make it function as a multi-use facility, and to, I realize that almost everybody tonight said ice rink. Ice rink is one of the things that is, should we say, ideally dreamed of, but we need to be realistic about what it takes to make it be a multi-use facility.

2:15:35 I'm saying that because from my personal opinion, we can't spend any money on something that isn't going to serve many different pieces of our diverse recreation. We obviously are going to have to explain something that I understand from my years as planning commissioner, but the difference between a public and a private view needs to be better explained, which is about which things are considered a protected view and which are not.

2:16:01 I think that financing is a big issue. I will say that in two ways. Obviously, we've just received this, so there's no way we can absorb the financing here. I'd like to see for the other options what a cost is, like coming up with an estimate. I'm sure there's a real estate person somewhere in town who could give you an estimate on the land cost. But there's a separate financing. Several people tonight said all the money is available for the roof. I do not believe that is correct, so I'd like to see that spelled out again.

2:16:31 I'm almost to an end. These differences in the design, like closing the west end, et cetera, need to be not just said, well, we've got an idea. It needs to be something people can visually see. And then finally, I think that we need to wait and see and definitely recommend that the Recreation Commission and the Strategy Committee out of MLR work through some of the options and also have a recommendation back to us.

2:17:02 Did I miss anything? Good start. Those are the questions that I'm seeing that we have at this point. If I could just ask you, Madam Mary, kind of a procedural question. We sort of headed towards some sort of a motion direction to staff. Is that what we're working on? I think we're heading towards the idea of identifying the unanswered questions that if we are giving a, if we are considering extending it.

2:17:29 Is identifying what has to be answered and then asking the rhetorical question, June 1st or June 3rd is only a few weeks away. Is it something that maybe is going to take more time because they do not want us to be in a position which former councils dealt with where you'd go, well, let's, you know.

2:17:51 Instead of saying we really need two months to figure this out, is bringing it back in a month and end up deferring in another dump? Yeah, yeah. Understood. And I, and I. So that's why I said the rhetorical question would be is I think that if we give direction on the kinds of things that we want to have answered in the next time period, then it's a question of how long is that? You know, I understand a desire to have this happen immediately. Unfortunately, the last two times that this item was looked at, it was done.

2:18:19 Before strategy. Right. And it was knee-jerk instead of really looking at a full. Yeah, I'd like to make a comment on that. Because I was around, you know, you guys that have been here 100 years, I've been here like 200 years. It's 300. 300 years. If you remember, the rink originally was at the RV park, you know, put up and down every year. And then that was crazy. And so we finally found a place at the school.

2:18:47 In 2007, I believe it was. And it got built there. Now look, that's only eight years ago. And we're back at it again. We're trying to get to a point where we don't have to continually go back at it. Everybody wants the ice rink. I think pretty much everybody wants the ice rink. Maybe they don't want it at a certain place. So that's what we're trying to figure out, guys.

2:19:12 Where is the best? And also, there is no animosity between town and school. So we are talking. We're trying to work that out, see what's best. So those discussions are going on. And those discussions are going to happen. They're happening. And so everybody wants to put that roof on it, wherever it's going to be. And they want to do it now. But they're going to do it with great information.

2:19:42 And foresight so we don't have to continue to go through this every eight years. So anyway, that's where we are. And those are the issues and problems staff is getting information on so that we can make informed decisions up here. And we support you guys. We support, you know, really support the youth. We wish we had more money for it. So, you know.

2:20:09 To Joe's comment, you know, that's why it should be a multi-use facility. So it can be more sustainable than it is now. And we understand that the roof is an integral part of that. So, guys, you know, understand we're going through the process too, but we want to make it a right process. So in eight years from now, Posey, you're not coming up here and saying, what the hell are you doing, Shields? Yes, you will. Yeah, you will.

2:20:39 It's going to have a roof on it in eight years. Let's put it that way. I just know if we have to move it in eight years. Thank you. Thank you. So essentially, John, to answer your question, we don't necessarily need a motion. We can just defer it to the next meeting with the consensus and things like that. My only concern is, is that really...

2:21:07 Well, I think that's up to staff. I think, are they able to get that information? And recommission. And recommission and NMR. Yeah, exactly. Exactly, the group. So I've got a couple other questions that may be to add to your list. I want to make sure that you guys, that when we're done with this, you understand what's coming out of us. It's clear what we're doing. I am interested, I think we're, this is a very exciting process.

2:21:33 Anybody who builds anything or gets something done, you understand. You go through a process of focusing, figuring out what you're going to do. You've got opportunities. Some things are going to work. Some things aren't. Personally, I see that we're in the middle of this process right now. I think we're all committed to seeing this thing through. Some information that would be helpful to me, I would assume would be of some assistance to the folks involved in making recommendations, is from the Plan Your Parks process, the things that were put in Mammoth Creek Park West,

2:22:02 I would like to start seeing some very preliminary, gritty, as you've used this term, sort of cost dollar numbers associated with recreation centers, aquatic centers, and these kinds of things. I think we need to start squaring what these things kind of cost with the resources that we have to do this stuff. I think that could be helpful and informative in the conversation. I think also, I think we've already mentioned this land use question for Mammoth Creek Park. They're getting a sense of what that's all about. If those numbers, again, they're not...

2:22:30 It's written in stone, but they could be helpful for decision makers to figure out what we're doing. I would also, I don't, you know, I would like to request if it's possible to go back to the school district based on the conversations that we did not have, but our representative, the town manager have, and just see if there's any, based on the kinds of things we're talking about, is there...

2:22:53 Any possibility to establish a permanent home for this rink? And it's important to understand this. We all live in a community with a limited land base. We have a wonderful urban growth boundary that restricts where we exist. In this scenario, we keep the rink where it is, we build a roof.

2:23:14 MLR, Rec Commission, the community moves forward, and we do start doing things in Mammoth Creek Park West, and all the available land that's out there gets committed to other facilities. Eleven years from now, all of a sudden, the school district says, well, at least we're going to put in a child care center, something that we really want to do, and all of a sudden, we're out of land, and there is no place to move the rink to. And so I think it's important to go back to the school district and perhaps say, are we sure we don't have any opportunity for a permanent solution to this?

2:23:43 I don't know what that might look like, but that might be helpful. I think I would encourage all of I've gotten a lot of wonderful letters from homeowners in condominium complex nearby this park. Very concerned about what's happening. I very much appreciate that. And I just offer that I think this council and this community is very interesting having a conversation with you about

2:24:06 What's going to happen here? You all understand that we have a limited land base, and we all understand that we have a community here that has voted twice to invest in these kinds of facilities. These are two-thirds plus one special votes to do this, and I would really encourage to extend our hands to you guys to start looking at how we can be partners with this. A lot of the work I've done in trails work, I've met a lot of people who said, I don't want to trail my neighborhood, it's going to devalue and all the rest of this stuff.

2:24:32 And I've got the evidence to show that these kinds of facilities I think can actually really improve your financial conditions with your investments. And I just really look for if there are willing partners out there to start working on how we can integrate these facilities into your properties. The town and the community do not intend to build nuisance properties, things that are going to compromise your quality of life. And I would just hope that as we go forward we find opportunities to reach out and talk about this.

2:24:58 So that you guys can be involved in the design of these things and so we can, if you can integrate your assets into our assets. Because I think at the end of the day when you start seeing the quality of the things that we're going to do and the things we're going to build, you're going to want to be connected with these things. I'd hate to have to be scrambling around at the last minute trying to make it work. So I will figure out how to reach out to the homeowners. The other question I think a little bit is one of aesthetics, and I think, Joe, you touched on this, is I know that Grady, you know, there's some design instead of engineering and technical things that

2:25:27 You may be pursuing in parallel with this process, which is fine. But I think we want to make sure that whatever road we're going down, we're not going to be precluding aesthetic opportunities. These structures are wonderful things. They can be very beautiful. They can be very interesting without a whole lot of work. But I want to make sure that if we go through this process, we're not all of a sudden backed into a situation where it will look like this when we may have opportunities to make some, you know,

2:25:54 Maybe not dramatic design decisions, but we can actually make something that would be aesthetic, as aesthetically as welcoming and as good as it can possibly be. Those are my comments. And I don't know what you want to do with them, but that's my thinking. Well, we're still collecting a list here. Okay. I just agree with a lot of the dialogue up here. I'm interested in...

2:26:17 The rec commission's recommendation coming back in the next month or so, if they can get that back to us. I mean, we kind of, I think we directed them to take the lead on this. So I'm interested in hearing their comments and feedback. And interested in seeing the revised budget numbers tightened up and the analysis continuing on the roof, you know, and the bids now while we're going through this process. So everything else I agree with.

2:26:47 Thought everyone else was saying. And, you know, I think, again, for the community's sake, you've got a council that's very supportive of the rink and very supportive of a long-term solution, not just another eight years coming back and you leave in town because you don't have your roof. So that's my comments. Okay. Shields, anything to add to the list? No. Okay. So then I just turn to staff first and ask, you know, questions, comments from staff.

2:27:16 Madam Mayor, I'll take the first shot at it. So we've got a pretty good list of questions there and stuff, and I know the rec commission looked at a 30-day extension time frame. One of the challenges a little bit on that would be coming back on the 3rd. They meet the day before, so if there's a lot of dialogue there, there's really not a chance for us to prepare something for the agenda for the...

2:27:39 Council because of the timeline there obviously with the one day process. So we're guessing to some degree in terms of the staff report and then we're doing a verbal response here. So just take that, I guess, under consideration the tightness of that process there. The other element on that is if the council wants we can meet with the school districts again.

2:28:01 Well, I just need to clarify. We would have to have a closed session to discuss that, right? Right. We could maybe have to bring it back. It would be a closed session item at that point. And that could happen maybe at your next meeting in June. Given the questions you're looking for and the interaction between the Rec Commission, MLR, et cetera,

2:28:24 When you actually ask us to work on a 30-day timeframe, it sounds like a long time, but with the agenda process and stuff, that's actually three weeks or a little less in actual time, so it compresses to get good information to you. For like tonight, we've got information ready, but it's a handout that you're looking at tonight, so there isn't time to really work through that. I guess I'm saying that if you want the level of detail that I think I hear you're asking for, I would almost say let us come back July 1st.

2:28:52 I would come back early in June sooner, but your two June meetings, especially your second one, is going to be very heavy with the budget discussion. So trying to just manage time-wise, I think that may be a better timeline to drill down, answer these questions. Some of the detail you're asking for is going to take some research and time. And so I guess I'd rather push it off a little further and come back with better information, better prepared.

2:29:22 Then rushing it, and as I forget who made the comment, you're almost there, come back a month later. Can you give us an update, though? Yeah, we can definitely give you information and provide some update. I want to keep this moving forward. The two elements I think I heard to continue on, we would continue to design work on the roof regardless in terms of location, and we will definitely, we'll work back through the revised budget numbers and those issues as well for those.

2:29:52 Peaces that have come through that way. So I'm trying to consensus build a little bit here, but also I don't want to say, yes, all this will get done by the June 3rd, and then we come in with not the level and quality of information that you would like to see. If there's one, there's been, I think, an artificial sense of rush with this, given where the rec commission meetings falls and where we

2:30:16 And I think we have to do something about that because we're all getting to this point and everybody's got half-baked information. I think we want to do something about that, whether it means we do a workshop or the rec commission maybe has a special meeting, something like that. So we've all got the information we need when we're talking about it. We're not everybody's getting things at the last minute. I think it would be helpful to try to address that.

2:30:39 I agree with John, but are you essentially saying either they hold a special meeting later in June or we take this to the June 15th meeting? Something. I leave it to brighter minds of mine. Okay. I think we have a pretty long or good list of questions to start on. And let's see where they stand on June 3rd. Yeah, we'll definitely have an update.

2:31:04 Could staff provide, I don't know how you're going to do this, but could you provide a summary of what you think of the questions you think you've got from this, unless you need a motion or something like that? I want to make sure we're clear so we're not wasting time with this. I think we're clear. I wrote down everything that, yeah, Joe and Water, do it a couple of your comments. And it's on Granicus, so you can get it from there also. Okay. As long as that suffices and that's good. And so we would be looking at kind of an update on the third, but probably not a full-blown.

2:31:32 Report. Because I'll just be honest, I don't think we'll have it done by then for the level of detail I think you're going to want. Sounds good. Okay. So. Thank you. Do we have to say anything about the school district? We will have to have a full session. Okay. Scheduled. Okay. Property negotiations must be done for the session. I understand that he has to start. Well, no, we have to give direction first. Yeah. That's the difference. Okay. I am 11.

2:32:08 I know, but I was just going to look to see if anybody needed another break or, okay. Okay, quick break real quick. Yeah, three minutes, John. Okay, we have many more items to go through, so we're going to...

2:32:43 Move forward. And no idea. And we will now move on to item number 11, which is approving the Mammoth Lakes Trail System recommended budget for fiscal year 15-16. Yes, Madam Mayor, if I can take this.

2:33:05 Basically, with a couple of items tonight, one earlier, but this one is really just kind of looking for broad policy direction in terms of some stuff we're... Can you hold up just a second, Dan? Can we get those conversations out into the hall, please? Thank you. All right. We can't hear you. We'll give him a minute. Give him a minute. Thank you. All right. Sorry, Dan. That's okay. You may have to start over. Yes, I will.

2:33:35 Again, one other item tonight, too, is some of the items coming for you right now is helping us kind of look at how we're putting the budget together for 2015-16. So we're not looking for, you know, specific debate on items in this one here, but really looking at what has been historically from the Council the last few years is a $300,000 allocation of Measure R funds for the trail system committed to that. The other question here is a carryover use of funds.

2:34:02 Just over $206,000 recommended. In the past as we've looked at carryover dollars and stuff, a lot of that has been concerning because it's use of reserves. In this case it's programmed reserves for this particular use. So the direction we're looking for is that in terms of putting together the Measure R budget for next year that we would be working with this $506,000 plus for the MLTS piece of that budget.

2:34:30 There will be some modifications to that, I'm sure, based on what we're at in the current program of the current year. We haven't spent everything, and those elements are maybe some additional carryover products, projects, and also in terms of doing some reconciliation work, maybe some additional dollars there. But I was looking for something other than just, here's $300,000 for next year, again, knowing that there's other stuff out there. So unless there's objection from the council, we're really looking for kind of that go-ahead to work with them.

2:35:00 I will say that there was a discussion from this from the Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the

2:35:26 MLTS subcommittee of MLR in terms of supporting the use of reserves and new money in terms of putting the budget together. Okay, and I'll just add to that is that another timing issue of, you know, not enough time for things to happen is that after this had been recommended by the MLR board for our action tonight, when the Reconciliation Committee met with

2:35:51 Dan, we discovered that there were some prior year amounts that should also be carried over. And so we're trying to work that. So the budget for the MLTS part is actually going to be a little bit higher than this because, for example, on the

2:36:08 Forest Service doing the NEPA on the Sharp Area. There was money allocated over three years, but only the last year got picked up in this carryover column. So it's actually going to be a higher figure because there are more dollars that we previously awarded that should be carried forward. Yeah, so we'll be picking those up in the budget process. We have a rough estimation on those dollars? No, we're still working on that. We didn't meet until last Thursday.

2:36:36 And so we've already, as the Reconciliation Committee from MLR, we've reached out to the Mammoth Trails Committee and it'll get reconciled. When the budget is presented, it'll be done. Right. But, you know, off the top of my head, no, I can't tell you, it's probably around $80,000, but that's just a real rough figure.

2:36:57 It's still dollars that were committed for those purposes. It's dollars that were awarded in previous cycles and haven't been spent yet. Right. And this is a five-year commitment? Yes. And we still, this is only, this, 15, 16 is year four. Okay. Yeah. Okay. So, and a lot of this, you know, I do want to be able to say, often we'll come and say we're not using any reserve dollars from previous years on purpose and then let the council work through that. This would be an exception to that because we're actually trying to build a budget utilizing reserves knowing what's potentially out there.

2:37:24 And so if that policy direction is fine with the council, that helps us put the budget together as we look into the... Yeah, if it's been a previously approved budget. And I think the wording here is okay because it says a preliminary budget. Well, that means it can change. Right. But I think the important part tonight is recognize that we are allocating the new dollars, the $300,000. Right, right, right. Versus having that as part of your budget discussion and this level of policy discussion. We're trying to take some stuff out of the way on the front end.

2:37:54 So, any questions of Dan? Any public comment? Seeing none, come back. Any comments or... Just regarding the number that Joe is discussing, when will you have that kind of firmed up? We'll have some of that when we go into the budget, probably more for the June meeting than this, but also...

2:38:27 We actually have ongoing stuff right now in the current year, so we won't have everything absolute because some of those expenses will be incurred in June, for example. But it will be much tighter in terms of the dollars from previous years going into the next year budget. Okay. So it's kind of a two, there's two phases to it. It's recognizing the previous awards that just got skipped in the spreadsheet. And then the other thing is

2:38:52 MLR's responsibility starting in July to reconcile the current year, and then that always leads to a budget amendment with whatever hasn't been spent going back to fund balance. So there's actually, yeah. Again, it's all a part of your commitment. Yeah, these are all restricted dollars for that purpose, so we're trying to keep them there. Okay, I'll make a motion to conclude in the physical.

2:39:23 Year 15-16 budget, the allocation of $300,000 in Measure R funds for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and the allocation of the previously committed funds of $206,668 for a preliminary budget of $506,668. And if you could incorporate that as may be amended for carryover money? Is it okay? It says preliminary. Yes. I'll second the motion. Okay, thanks.

2:39:51 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. That moves us on to item number 12, and because of recusals, we're actually going to be splitting this into two pieces. Madam Mayor, I'm going to recuse myself. I have no financial interest in this, but I do serve on the MLTPA board. Okay, John, we'll call you back in a minute.

2:40:21 First half of the staff report. Yeah, first half item here is the summer stewardship program for the trail days. It's a program that extends over two fiscal years. It goes into starting in June of this year, actually sometimes before that with outreach and publications, and then goes into next fiscal year. The way the budget has worked in the past, it's been bifurcated in process, so we're trying to clean that up as we go forward. But for this year, what we're requesting is that the

2:40:52 And then we'll have it, there's other funding going after July 1st that would cover the rest of the season and frankly next June as well so we're not back to doing this bifurcated approval process.

2:41:20 We had some of this last year, too, where we had to jump out in front of it to make the projects work. And this is just where our fiscal year versus the program years don't line up. So we're working to do that. So in order to make sure we have allocated money and be able to go forward in agreement with MLTPA for the work they do related to the summer stewardship trail days, we need dollars out of the current year. And then with the approval of the budget, we would have dollars going next year as well.

2:41:47 But we really need something this year because it wasn't specifically allocated and authority to go into these agreements. And what is it specifically used for? The stewardship, I understand. This here is for the MLT contract. They're in charge of a lot of the outreach, the advertising, the getting volunteers out to the site. They coordinate with the lunch program they have. They actually do some other fundraising and those types of elements as well. Thank you.

2:42:18 Okay, any other questions to staff? Okay, any comments from the public on the MLTPA part? Okay, seeing none, I'd be looking for a motion that reflects the amount for MLTPA and to sign an agreement with MLTPA. Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to authorize the release of Physical Year 1415 Measure R funds for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Program Summer of Stewardship Trail Days 2015.

2:42:49 In the amount of $6,845 for Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access, MLTPA, and to, what was this? Authorize the town. Authorize the town manager to sign agreements with MLTPA. And, yeah. Second the motion. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Jamie's furiously typing. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes.

2:43:16 Yes, motion passes 3-0. So now we will call John back, and I also have no financial interest, but I'm on the board member of Friends of the Inyo, so we're going to switch spots. So do we need to go back over the second part? Yeah, let me quickly review the second part of the item before you would be in agreement with the Friends of the Inyo.

2:43:50 This actually supports two programs. It supports the Summer Stewardship Trail Days 2015 and the Lake Basin Stewards Program. The Lake Basin Stewards Program is actually a mid-May through September program pending weather. This year we probably could have started a week ago. But it's a program where they're in the basin area. They work with our guests in the basin. They also do some trail maintenance work as well as

2:44:20 There's going to be, again,

2:44:47 This would be that June event, and then we'd have additional events through the rest of the summer going in through September and then to, frankly, next June again for the program. So this would be for Friends of Inyo, two different programs, the Trail Days and the Stewardship Program. And the dollar amounts are noted in the staff report. Okay. Any public comment? Hi, my name is Tim Flynn. I'm a resident and a mountain biker.

2:45:20 And recently, I think it was yesterday, I was up on Mammoth Rock Trail and was going down a trail that I had been going down for 20 years and had been living in this town and noticed that there had been some obstacles put in the way of the trail and proceeded to kind of maneuver around the obstacles and then ran over a tree stump and there was sort of like a booby trap that was set.

2:45:48 And ripped my back derailleur off of my bike and, you know, basically totally dismembered my bicycle. And so I had to walk down the end of the trail and, you know, there was like some big, I just noticed that there was just significant damage done to the trail to like, you know, to get people to not go down it. And so I'm just wondering if that money is being allocated for that sort of work that the Friends of the Inyo are doing.

2:46:17 Because I would definitely be opposed to that. And I think that a lot of the members of the public would be. No trail cleanup's been done yet, right? No, I think if you can tell us where you found all that stuff, and, you know, we'll go out on the ground. Those two trails that go right up to the propane tanks, you know, from propane tanks. At the bottom? And they connect with Mammoth Rock Trail. Yeah, they've been totally...

2:46:45 Sabotaged. And I got down to the bottom and I talked to this woman that was walking her dogs and she said, yeah, the Friends of the Indo have been up there, you know, sabotaging the trail. Well, yeah, let's, we need to take a look at that because that's, it's,

2:46:59 There's a lot of travel management stuff in there in terms of what's closed and what's not, but I want to make sure I know exactly what the places are and what you're talking about. I'll take you to it. Yeah, let's do that, take a look at it. Was there anything along the trail that caused problems? This is at the entrance, at the bottom part of it, right? It was at, there's a sandy section that goes up to, you know, the initial, I climbed up that section on my mountain bike and then I dropped down.

2:47:26 The part where I've always been going through, and there's a why in the road, and I just noticed significant tree branches and things that were placed across the trail to block access. There was no signage, there was no any sort of warning or anything. I almost filed the police report. No, I understand. Let's follow up with that and see exactly what's going on. The program's different than that, so that wouldn't be something that...

2:47:49 Yeah, I mean, I'm almost about preservation of the, you know, but I mean, when it comes to public safety, I mean, at least notify people that the trail's closed or, you know, that their mountain bikes aren't allowed on it or, you know, it's just, don't just booby trap it. Thanks. Thank you, Tim. Any other public comment? Any other further discussion? So I'll entertain a motion for basically the second part of this.

2:48:23 I will move for the town to release fiscal year 1450 Measure R funds for $3,500 for Friends of the Inyo and $12,000 for Lake Space and Stewards Program with Friends of the Inyo and authorize the town manager to sign agreements consistent with those funds. Second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.

2:48:53 Motion passes 3-0. Somebody call Joe. Okay. That moves us on to policy item 13, congressional support for consideration of lifting the current limit on passenger facility charges.

2:49:27 Yes, Madam Mayor, we've been requested through the U.S. Travel Association via the airport and Mammoth Lakes Tourism to sign on to a letter that it would just be adding the town of Mammoth Lakes to a letter that's being sent to Congress. We'd have the mayor's name on the letter. That would be part of a much larger outreach to Congress looking at a way to increase funding.

2:49:52 For airports throughout the country, a lot of the focus, I think, has been on the smaller airports. With the PFCs or the facility, passenger facility charges, the proposals to raise it from $4.50 per person to $8.50 per person. We'd look at maybe not quite doubling or doubling of our revenues that we receive from that type of activity at the airport.

2:50:17 We utilize those funds. They're restricted for reinvestment back into the airport, so they're often used to match federal grant funds or other work on the airport that is necessary. I think there's been a fairly wide support from airports in terms of trying to move those fees up. They haven't changed in some time. And so the request before you would be to have the authority for us to basically just be submitting

2:50:46 Our mayor's name and the town as a sign-on to a list of mayors and towns from across the country. It wouldn't be a separate letter from the town, but it would be a sign-on to a letter. We work with the MLT and the U.S. Travel Association in terms of making that happen. So it hasn't been passed yet in Congress, right? No, this would be a lobby to Congress. Yeah, I just want to clarify. Funding mechanism. Dan, is there a time of, estimated time of when this may

2:51:17 Make its way to Congress. I mean, has that been discussed? Not that I'm aware of in detail. I'm not sure if it's before the current Congress or if it would end up getting kicked to the next level. And is this the letter, this is basically the letter that's in the packet here, is a draft of it? Right. Drafts letter that would show a race through straightforward. Okay. Okay, no questions, more questions? No, not for me. Okay, any public comment? Okay, I'll bring back for discussion or motion.

2:51:50 Madam Mayor, make a motion to counsel, authorize the mayor to sign onto a letter from mayors throughout the United States to members of Congress related to lifting the current limit on passenger facility charges for funding airport improvement programs and direct staff to indicate the town's support for raising the limit should other opportunities arise. Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0.

2:52:21 Oh, I'm sorry. I forgot. We need to go back and do number four. Thank you. I've got my note here and then... I didn't know where you put that. Yes, we need to go back to number four. Back to the future. Well, and this was on consent. It was to make various budget adjustments that needed to be made, including the ESTA funding and... Oh, ESTA, we're not on yet. Thank you. We're not on yet.

2:52:50 Never mind. Anyway. Child programs. Child, yes. The youth sports funding. Thank you. And the MLTS. Right. Current year amounts. Right. So. I think we agreed to it. We agreed to it. I know. I just need a motion then. I'll make a motion. We approve the resolution. I'll make a motion. We approve the resolution and amend the budget for fiscal 2014-15. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie.

2:53:21 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Now we're on to number 14, report on proposed voter initiative related to altering transient rental zoning in residential neighborhoods. And actually, John's going to kind of lead this one off for us. Thank you, Madam Mayor, members of council, members of the public.

2:53:44 So the first thing, just as a housekeeping thing, in the background information, there's a typo in the background information where it should be the focus of the discussion represented only the view of two council members and not the view of the council's whole. So I want to make sure that that's clear so there's no confusion about that. This is kind of a follow-up item to a discussion that council member Fernie and I had.

2:54:10 With the participation of Michael Agnich and some other folks involved with the voter initiative. And we met on April 21st. I've got – I could find the dates number, but we met. And there were several representatives of the initiative in attendance with the Councilmember Ferney and myself. And we had a – I think about an hour and a half discussion where we used these same five questions. And we discussed them at length and in depth.

2:54:40 There was no consensus arrived at. There was no sort of agreement about anything, but it was a good and fruitful discussion, and I think everybody came away a little bit the wiser from that. So the idea of this exercise is to take these same questions, because the council hasn't weighed in on all of these yet, and because whatever the council chooses to say about these issues may be helpful as the voters consider the initiative, which was filed today, and it may be helpful going forward with that. So the idea with this is I would like to

2:55:10 I think it would be useful to have the Council vote, you know, consider each one of these motions, make any amendments that may be necessary or not, and just move through these things in a nice, simple kind of direct way, and from that, the community will have the sense of the Council on these issues. And so, Madam Mayor, tell me how I should proceed here. Okay.

2:55:35 Essentially, this is not, there's no vote on anything tonight. This is just confirming and directing or discussing on these five matters. So do you want to deal with them separately? Yeah, if we could. I've written up the basic questions for the council to consider. So for question number one, does the council support the use of reliable and official data for decision-making as part of a single-family residential short-term rental program?

2:56:04 I do. Yes, and we've already said that. Good? Good? Fine. That was easy. Move on to the next one.

2:56:12 Does the council support a quality of life ordinance as part of a single family residential short term rental program? Yeah, I do. I would say we've directed staff to. Good. You guys are doing very well. I'd be the one to turn around. And when are we seeing that? Yep. Okay. Number three, does the council support a credible enforcement program as part of a single family residential short term rental program? Yes. Absolutely. Yes. Okay. Question number four.

2:56:40 Does the Council support a community conversation to determine if there is a, quote, need to change as part of a single-family residential short-term rental program? I think I need a little more information on what you're saying there. Well, I think, and I, it's very broad, and it was used as a broad question for the purpose of discussion. I would add to this, if, to determine if there's a need to change, such as a substantial change to current zoning.

2:57:09 As an example, as part of a single-family residential short-term rental program. Or determining what the need is. Or determining what the need is. It could... But the community should be involved in the conversation. That's what that's... That's what that's about. I mean... Go ahead. No, I'm just saying, and the community hasn't been? I mean, how long is this issue? Well, it's a question of formalizing a little bit. That if... Oh, okay.

2:57:35 So if the council were to identify a need to change, such as a change to zoning. I'd like to comment on that. Okay, sure. I mean, one thing that we're talking about with this initiative and a need for change, the initiative actually creates some more conflict neighborhoods than it does a benefit. And I mean, I'll just give you one little example, because it's not just on an SFR issue. Forest Creek condos.

2:58:05 Here in town, the property is currently split, the zoning, two-thirds RMF2, it's just prohibited for nightly rentals, and one-third RMF1, which is not prohibited. So one-third not prohibited, two-thirds is, it's split. So with the voter initiative, the way it's written, would actually address a need of change where we would no longer be able to address that.

2:58:32 Because the initiative would not allow us to the town or council to work on that specific issue, which we actually have been addressing. So, I mean, I think when we talk about need of change, I think absolutely we need to pay attention to this and we need to look at the broad scope of it, not just on a single family issue. Okay. Because it locks, it really does lock down, you know, it locks down any type of

2:59:02 Zoning change, not just on an SFR issue. So, but outside of the initiative, the question kind of comes back again. If the council, does the council support a community conversation to determine if there is a need to change? Well, I think it goes to the first one. We've got to get the data so that we can have the conversation to see if

2:59:30 There needs to be a change. Okay. Okay. But let's say out of that, let's say the council determines we think there's a, quote, need to change that's substantial or substantive. Would we then support engaging with a community conversation to determine if the community thinks this is a valuable thing to do? Absolutely. Yeah, I think we've been saying that all along. Okay. Yeah, I think we've been saying that all along. I'm just trying to figure out what your, what...

2:59:56 You think number four leads to at this point, especially with the understanding that the initiative signatures have already been turned out. Understood. I just, I think it's, what's a little unfortunate about this is that we didn't, it's a carp off a horse, but it's attempt to get sort of a sense of the council, where the council feels about these things. It may be, I mean, it's great that they had great success getting the signatures and these have been filed. You know, this is a chance for the council to say, yeah, we feel on this question that we think a community conversation is valuable.

3:00:26 Should there be? Absolutely. Okay. So if that's clear... I'm still a little... I'm still not sure where you're going because the community conversation might just be... I'm concerned about the difference between trying to have a conversation or having a conversation that's a run-up to an election. And I see those as two different things. Yeah, but I... So it's... I can't answer that one in the affirmative at this point.

3:00:54 Well, I would. Do you still have consensus? Well, if it's helpful. I mean, this is not intended to be associated with the initiative. This is just a sense of if we were to say to the staff to continue to work on these things, that if we were to identify a need for change, would we then say to the community, we want to have a conversation with the community about any needs for change we may have identified? Again, I looked at those first three that we went through. Those are the ones we've already. Yeah, but I think.

3:01:23 That information has to be brought forward to the community so we can have a discussion. We don't have, to my knowledge, reliable data for decision making right now. We're working on it. We don't have a quality of life ordinance in place. We're working on it. We don't have a credible enforcement program. We're working on it. And until we get those things, I don't think we can have a...

3:01:51 Community conversation that is, you know, you can't have a community conversation about something that you don't know about. So once that information is brought forward by staff, I think the community as a whole can sit down and talk about it, have transparency and say, okay, where do we stand, guys? So let me try this again to see if we can, if, say, the scenario you've just gone through.

3:02:19 Say we go through all that and we identify a need to change. We say we find something in this that we think we need to change something substantially here. Would the council support engaging the community in a conversation around those identified needs to change? Sure. Yeah. I agree. I guess my concern is that the conversation is already happening and so I'm going to say no but you've still got a consensus on that. Okay. All right. So let's move on to the fifth one.

3:02:49 Does the council support a community vote to ratify any identified need to change as part of a single-family residential short-term rental program? So that would mean if in process number four there's a community conversation and there's identified that here's a substantial change that people want to make, would the council say, yeah, we should put that to a vote? I would entertain that. A council vote? No, a community vote, a sense of the community vote so that the need to change is identified, it's framed up, it's presented to the community. I would entertain that.

3:03:20 If we got the information. Sure. Yeah, it's kind of. I'm making those hypothetical assumptions. We need all the data. We need all the stuff. The community says, we go to the community and say, we think there's a need to change here. The community says that we've identified something that we think we need to change. At that point, would the council support taking that question to the voters for a vote? I'm going to answer it a little differently again. There's a yes. I think a community vote is.

3:03:49 I think, you know,

3:04:17 Put our things we wanted to do, priorities, if you will. This is front and center. This is one of the things we said we were going to quote-unquote tackle. And so we have started the process. We don't have the information to make an informed decision and bring it to town, bring it to a community discussion yet. But I think that's the proper way to do it.

3:04:43 Because I think there's varied viewpoints. And I think the initiative goes to part of it. I just, quite honestly, I don't think it answers some of the things. You know, there's a need issue. You know, do we have a need? Don't we have a need? I don't know. And until we have the information in front of us, you know, and we can discuss it, we're just, you know, pulling at straws. It's meaningless. So I think we need

3:05:13 The information, staff is still working on it, correct? So again, I think the directive is to direct staff to continue with, you know, those questions of the items that we need, the data, the quality of life, I mean, all the things that we've been asking for, we need to have it. I think everybody's in agreement that quality of life issues are front and foremost. You know, how do we tackle that? Okay.

3:05:43 I think, you know, a credible enforcement program, front and center. But, again, until we have the information, and I come from a need standpoint, you know, what is our true need, and I look at it, I'm a developer, okay, I look at what's the need, I build to the need, not just the zone, okay, so not saying that's right or wrong, I'm just saying, hey, let's get the information out so that we can have a credible discussion with the community.

3:06:10 Okay, so again, just hypothetically, let's say that we were to have done the things we've talked about, we've had a community conversation, a need has been identified on this issue, what is the council's sense of taking that to some sort of a vote from the public to say whether or not to proceed? I think that kind of will be determined in the community conversation. It's not really a one-size-fits-all, is it? I think that will work itself out in the community conversation.

3:06:40 Okay. And if it doesn't, then you put it to a vote. Okay, so if... I don't have this, you know, big negative of, you know, putting it to a vote, if that's what you mean. I just want to have the information in front of me so we can have the discussion, so we can have an informed vote. Okay. Well, I think, so what I'm hearing is there's consensus on the first three. There's consensus about having a community conversation about it.

3:07:11 Yeah, I think what the council is saying, that it would really depend on the nature of the identified need to change as to whether or not the council would support taking to a vote of the community. That's what I'm hearing. What are your thoughts? Well, I think I, you know, personally I would say that I would support the community conversation if we identified, if out of the research and the work that we do, we identify something that's going to be substantial, this is going to be a substantial change.

3:07:41 I would support taking that to community conversation. I would try to develop what that question is, and then I would say take that question to the community and have them vote on it. I don't have a problem doing that. Yeah. Does that make sense? Yeah, I would be for that, but I think we have to have the information. Well, understood, understood, understood. I mean, and this is, these are questions that are out of the context of the initiative, which I know is kind of hard to do. Right. But these are the same questions we had, the same discussion we had with the groups.

3:08:06 And so it's just a question of figuring out to give the community a sense of where we stand on a process like that. My comments still stand on four and five. Which would be? Which would be, I don't support either of them. Okay. In the way you've written them and described them. I support community conversations, which I think we've been having. And I do not like the word ratify because that makes it sound like we've made a decision that we're just asking to say you agree. Okay. That's not the initiative process, which cannot be separated out.

3:08:37 Okay. Well, I guess, I guess. So then before we finish this up, we need to take some public comment. Okay, sure. Public comment? Well, I just, I really appreciate the conversation you just had because nothing you've said really offended me or I disagreed with. And what I heard you say was that, you know, you were

3:09:08 On the edge of saying that if you made such a big change after a lot of discussion that you would consider it going out to a vote of the public. Well, our initiative would not prohibit you from doing anything that you've talked about because we certainly believe there are plenty of people out there illegally renting and, you know, there are quality of life issues that exist and there's accountability that needs to be taken care of.

3:09:37 You know, our initiative does not prevent you from making a change in single-family rentals or zoning. It just means we've got to vote on it first. And who really can argue with that? So, anyway, I'm very pleased with the discussion you had. I think it's very, in my mind now, it's more likely, see, I think it'd be great if you would just, you know, when the time comes, adopt the initiative.

3:10:03 Because it will not prevent you from doing anything you've just discussed. Well, the problem I have with that, Mike, is that you decided to put the cart before the horse. And you didn't have the public discussion. We didn't get to sit down with the information. That's the problem I have. And I wish you guys would have said, hey, okay. Because you can do the initiative at any time. Sure. You can. And I just think it would have been smart to say, okay, listen, guys.

3:10:32 Get the information. The staff is working on this. And, you know, let's all sit down and talk about it. You know, we're all grown-ups. I hear what you're saying. And that's the issue I have with you. You usurped a process that, you know, I don't think you really guys needed to do. You did it because you thought that council was going to maybe vote a certain way. And we've never intended that.

3:11:02 With the information that we could have adopted stuff a long time ago, but we were waiting for the town staff to give us the information so that we could have the discussion and we could build the ordinance to everybody's benefit and see how it best worked. So I just wish you guys had, you know, done it that way first because you could have always done the initiative. If you didn't like what we did, yeah, hey.

3:11:30 I hear what you're saying, and again, I really enjoyed this conversation. Sure. Thanks, Mike. Hi. Tim Flynn, resident, again. And I just want to mention that I've been a part of this process since you guys were even put in office, and I was part of the discussions, and this whole time I've watched all three members that have been identified as pro-single-family renters and having this discussion the entire time.

3:12:05 Wanting the information, just like you said, Shields. And I have some information that I just found on my smartphone, okay? And I'd like to hand it out to you guys. Directly off your guys' website. Well, that's your Mac. That's the one that you guys have been saying. Right. It's the same group. Thank you.

3:12:36 Yeah, I did take it. I'm fine. You guys share. We'll share. Okay, good. We'll share. Just give me a second here. It says, you know, basically that there's an existing inventory. There are over 180 standalone homes. This is directly off the Mammoth Neighborhoods website, and I know that it's Let Mammoth Decide now, but it's the same Knowles Homeowners Association that's been leading the charge here. And so...

3:13:01 It says, along with dozens more being constructed, similar to Jackson Hole in Park City, Mammoth allows home rentals, but not in specific locations. Traditional family neighborhoods reserved for non-transient use. Low occupancy rates in existing legal rentals shows there is little unmet demand for this product. So recently the town sent out a postcard to all the residents in town that showed you a, it said, can I rent my house legally or can I rent my property legally?

3:13:31 It was a TOT enforcement effort. And they gave you a website to go to. And so I just looked on their map where they have pink and orange areas that they identify as, you know, 180 standalone homes that are in the existing inventory. And I just arbitrarily just put into that website that you guys gave us to search if our homes are legal. I just arbitrarily put in four addresses. And they all came up that we couldn't rent them.

3:14:00 So if I just did that with my smartphone in the meeting right here, then, I mean, obviously there needs to be a lot more. This voter initiative, it's just based on a lot of misinformation. I just think that the signatures were obtained based on a lot of misinformation, and I just can't stand behind it. And I stand behind council and their idea to discuss this and look at it and see if there's a need.

3:14:27 You know, I just really think that the town is just, I mean, if we had 40 million in our coffers and we had roofs on the ice rink and if we had all this infrastructure and police cars and police, you know, and all this stuff, I think that, yeah, I could get behind, hey, you know, let's not even talk about it. There's not even a need, you know, but I just, the town is just really not in a position not to look at it. And I think that you guys are going about it in an absolutely constructive way.

3:14:53 Great way, and that's the way this discussion has been the entire time, and I just really am just disappointed in some of the community members and their way about going this way, you know, standing at Vaughn's, coming door to door, just think it's really, it's just classless, so thank you. Sandy Hogan, and I did quite a bit of the inventory, and of course I could ask Sandra to explain about the addresses. I think the ones you're looking at are probably Fairway Ranch.

3:15:28 And it's true that that is actually not a part of the 180, nor is Starwood, because those are restricted, even though they're in the pink, they are restricted by master plans that the planning commission and past town councils allowed to be exempted. The reason, one reason why some of these in the pink

3:15:55 So in other words, as we did this inventory Tim, we went through

3:16:26 Because the original numbers were over 200. We confirmed them with Sandra and we found that Fairway Ranch is exempt, Starwood is exempt, I believe Greyhawk is exempt, I think Altus is okay. In other words, there were certain ones that were exempted. So the 180 is actually under the number of stand-alone homes, not having a connected wall. If you want to talk about rentals,

3:16:54 With, you know, townhouses and things like that, we have hundreds, if not thousands. So, in other words, we pass the figures to the town, the town checks ours, we check theirs, we found a few places where the TOT tool was not exactly correct, but our figures are pretty close in this. Very close. Sandy, do you happen to know how many of those 180 homes actually rent?

3:17:24 No, that was not a charge. It's only what's zoned. Because anybody can make a decision at any time during Christmas vacation that they want to go off to Hawaii and rent out their place for a couple of weeks. So, in other words, that is a number, that's for the town and business licensing to handle because that's the question we need to have answered. I agree. My suggestion is send them a free business license, everybody in there the first time that isn't registered, and let them.

3:17:54 And suggest that they rent during Christmas. Now, just curious if you happen to know how many truly rent. Of course not. Thank you. I don't think any property manager in town knows that. All right. Thank you. I'm sorry, Tim. This is not debate time. You've made your comments. Good evening. My name is Dana Stroud. I'm a resident of Mammoth Lakes. I'm looking for a couple of clarification points off of item number.

3:18:25 Number five about the community vote to ratify any identified need to change. I want to make sure that I understand what it is that you're considering. I heard Mr. Agnich tonight propose that you as a council accept the initiative that they were able to secure their required signatures for. And as Kathy Cage pointed out earlier, they received more signatures than what was needed.

3:18:53 I heard him propose that you accept that initiative at some point as the consensus of the community to go to a voter-approved zoning amendments as we go through consideration of single-family rentals. I want to understand that if you're supporting number five as it was outlined, are you supporting that proposal to accept the initiative as it's been presented to you?

3:19:22 Whether it's now or in the not too distant future, instead of going to the voters of Mammoth Lakes as they signed the petition to do so and letting them weigh in on the issue of being governed by voter initiatives instead of being governed by the council that we elected to represent us. I'm looking for clarification. My answer is no.

3:19:52 I don't think that we can answer anything about the initiative because we haven't seen it in its final form, but I think, yeah. That action that you're describing, Dan, is not on the agenda in any event. Then I'm making a comment about future discussions of it because I heard Mr. Agnich tonight recommend at some point that you consider accepting that initiative, and I don't know that the voters of Mammoth Lakes

3:20:16 I think it's important to let the voters weigh in on that and actually go to the polls for that because I believe there's a difference between a single-family rental support and the idea of voter initiative approvals. And I think we only have to look at the state of California to understand that voter initiatives sometimes handcuff our elected officials into decisions that may not be in the best interest of a community. Thank you. Any other comments?

3:20:51 Okay. So is the direction to staff to continue their items that we've discussed? Of course. I don't think that's really the question here. I think the question is just if we could just review this in terms of what we establish as being consensus or support for these questions. So for question one, I heard...

3:21:14 Support, consensus for support of number one. Consensus and support for number two. Consensus and support for number three. I heard, Jo, you're dissenting a little bit, but... Right. I'm dissenting on the... Exactly what you're talking about, so just call me a dissent on that, but three is still a consensus. Three, okay, and then for number five... Same thing. It's the same thing, so there's a consensus, but Jo... Well, I mean, I don't think...

3:21:42 I don't think I'm number five. I mean, I don't think I'm prepared to provide consensus on that. I think it depends on how number four goes. Right. I mean, I think, you know. So why don't we say there is no consensus on number five? Let's just leave that as it is. I would say at this time, I mean, we need the data, right? Sure. So there's consensus on the first four, but there's not consensus number five. Is that fair to say? That's fair. Is that fair? Okay. Does that make sense, everybody? Consensus on the first four, not consensus number five. Okay. That's it. Okay.

3:22:13 So that moves us on to, sorry. Number 15. That moves us on to number 15, discussion of town owner builder requirements. Thank you. This item was continued from your April 1st, 2015 meeting. It was a request for direction regarding municipal code requirements regarding owner builder.

3:22:37 Thank you. Thank you.

3:23:06 I don't know if we need that. At some point we want to hear from Jesse if he has any additional.

3:23:34 Congress, does anybody have any questions or need any refreshing on what the discussion was a month ago? No. No, but we'll have some discussion. Yes, we'll have discussion, but I don't know that there's any questions. Thank you at this point. So, Jesse, do you have anything to add? Mayor, Town Council, Jesse Woodwin, local electrical contractor and president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. As Sandra said, I do want to...

3:24:16 Make sure that I clarify that our notes, our minutes were not voted on. They're not approved. In the future, I don't mind providing, you know, some written documentation and stuff, but I need to know if it's going to become a matter of public records so that I can get approval of the rest of the body. I had some members of the board that were concerned. There's some typos in there, and we had not voted on them, so just be aware of it.

3:24:43 The gist of it was I was providing it to Sandra so that we had a written documentation that said yes, we're confirming that after our discussion at the meeting, I think I felt that the body was cognizant of the fact that there is a differentiation for condo owner-builder permit.

3:25:10 They also seem to understand that number one was the

3:25:39 Absolutely. Most restrictive. And number three was the most lenient. And there were, there was some discussion about item number one because there were certain members of our body that felt just like Steve, the building official, and what was put in the last discussion from town staff that we want to make sure that people who are doing the work are

3:26:03 Licensed and knowledgeable about what needs to be done because that work may not just affect the person who lives in that residence. It may affect their neighbors and other people. So there were some voices at the meeting that wanted it to be more restrictive. Overwhelmingly, after our discussion and we took a vote, unanimously, the group voted for option number two. We felt that it was a fair middle ground, that it provided

3:26:30 That knowledge and expertise from the contractors performing the work, but still allowed the owner the flexibility and economic incentive to pull a permit once so that they're paying one permit fee rather than paying the plumber his time plus the town building fee for the plumbing fee for, let's just say $200 and the electrician $200 and the drywaller.

3:26:59 $200, thereby having to spend $600 on permits through three different people that option two allows the owner to pull a owner-builder permit, one permit. The big concession and contingency that that's based on that we discussed with Dan and Steve and Sandra was there is that we need a revision to the form for that permit because right now if you look at like the owner-builder

3:27:30 Permit form or a contractor permit form. It's not set up to allow the electrician to sign off, the plumber to sign off, the drywaller to sign off. So we do need that documentation, and they said that they would provide that. So that was what our vote was contingent on, is that there's a mechanism to allow this to be successful. But as long as that exists, that was what our association voted for. Like I said, unanimously approved.

3:27:58 Supporting option number two. Anything else, Martin? Unanimous except for one. And the other thing I wanted to mention, as well as the Mammoth Lakes Realty Board? Board of Realtors. I knew I was going to mess that up. They sent a couple representatives to the Contractors Association meeting to kind of hear.

3:28:29 What we had to say, and I encourage and am kind of excited that going forward we may have some interaction with that group. Right now, you know, we really haven't. To my knowledge, they've appointed Tim Flynn to be their liaison to the Contractors Association, and they did, and this is not official, but they told me, you know, my impression is that they support item number two as well, but I'll let Tim could speak to that.

3:28:58 Okay. All right. Are there any questions for Jesse? I have one question. In your discussion, was there any discussion about the paucity or lack of inspectors? Did that inform this discussion at all? Did that even come up? That did not come up. That was not the focus of – and it did not even – That's fine. Just asking. Thanks. All right. Thanks, Jesse. I have a question of staff. Is that –

3:29:28 Presuming one of these options is selected tonight, and that means there is a code update which would most likely include revised forms? Yeah, whichever option we select, unless it's option one, if it's option two or three, we would come back with a code amendment, and we're going to be preparing a comprehensive amendment to that section, so this will likely be one item of other items that will be cleaned up in that section. Okay. All right.

3:29:58 Thank you, Jesse. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak? Good evening, Town Council. Martin Kleinbard. I'm a full-time resident of Mammoth Lakes, and I thank staff for working diligently on this. We've spent a lot of time on this. I have to start off by saying that I'm really here right now as a citizen and not as the contractor because I have...

3:30:33 Very strong mixed feelings. I mean, from an economic standpoint, contractor from the rights of a property owner, second or even first. So I'm here tonight as a citizen of Mammoth Lakes and not as a contractor. As a contractor, I'm a businessman and I should embrace a law that would apparently provide more work to licensed professionals. However, we should not pass in law

3:31:04 The current municipal code is silent as to who can obtain permits, which is not the current interpretation being made right today. State law says that the owner

3:31:35 Or authorized agent can obtain a permit. The property can be the owner builder and also says that any owner can do so. Currently, as the town municipal code states, the wording says that work required a licensed contractor. And it only applies to a plumber, an electrician, a mechanical, or a

3:32:07 Contractor doing structural framing. That's section 15.04.150. And once again, that section is silent requiring drywall, cabinetry, glazing, things like that. The whole premise of this discussion tonight really boils down to life safety issues. And I think that there isn't a single person in this room that would say that life safety is not at most important.

3:32:38 However, what was brought up in discussion was penetrations and firewalls, proper patches and firewalls not being addressed properly, and things of that nature. But right now, the current municipal code does not have any restrictions on a person doing drywall on their own property. Because remember, the municipal code, if interpreted the way it's claimed to be interpreted,

3:33:10 It's only electrical, plumbing, mechanical systems, and structural framing. I, as an electrical contractor in this town for over 15 years, in the trades for about 30-something, I don't have four years of expertise in doing drywall, especially the nuances of doing

3:33:42 Fire rated assembly repairs. So we still don't have a code that says that that portion of the work has to be done by a licensed contractor, nor should it be put on the burden by a code that the plumber or the mechanical guy or the electrician doing work in a fire rated assembly that he is responsible for performing the repair work.

3:34:14 In fact, there's been a highly litigated situation of what is considered work that is incidental and supplemental to the specialty contractor's trade. And I'll read you an excerpt that I found on the Internet just doing a simple Google search of incidental and supplemental work. A specialty contractor is a contractor whose operation requires specific skill and knowledge in a particular craft or trade.

3:34:43 A listing of the specialty contractors can be found on the CSLB website. Contractors are prohibited from working in a classification unless they are licensed in that classification or unless that work is incidental and supplemental to the work they are licensed to do. The definition of what is incidental and supplemental work has been an area of much confusion and has been heavily litigated.

3:35:14 This is from a law firm that represents and has been a friend of the CSB. Okay, I only have a little bit more. The board has determined that incidental supplemental means that the work must be essential to the specialty of the contractor's license rather than the specialty of the project itself. It means that...

3:35:36 Let's just take what they wrote. A swimming pool contractor is not allowed to build a fence. Martin, I'm going to have to ask you to wrap it up, please. Just get to your conclusion. So basically what I'm trying to get at is that the incidental supplemental work, no matter what we decide tonight, there's going to have to be some change to the municipal code to reflect the global picture because we need to define what other works can be done by a homeowner. And we also have to justify the reasoning behind it because

3:36:06 All in all, everything that these things happen in construction, it's supposed to be inspected. And just like Greg Jennison said earlier, that he was concerned that division of time, current staff, is being stretched to the limit. And I need to say that almost every single one of the larger projects that have been done. Okay, thank you, Martin. That's enough. Just one second. Nope, nope, nope. Thank you. You know, you give everyone else time.

3:36:34 Not past the time limit, though. Oh, yes. Please, just one. All I want to say is that all those large projects have all been dealt with litigation over the years, and a majority of the problems could have been alleviated due to better inspections. Thank you. Is there anyone else that wishes to speak? Sorry to be redundant, but just there's been a sort of newly

3:37:09 formed a liaison committee between the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors and the Contractors Association so we can have better communication and since I have a real estate license and I'm a member of the board and a general contractor, they decided to appoint me and I'm kind of informed on the issues. But they're going to stand behind option two and so that's what they wanted me to come and say. The Board of Realtors? Board of Realtors supports option two. Okay, thank you.

3:37:38 Thank you. Okay. Good evening, Tom Heller, the fire department. I know at the last meeting that you addressed this issue, you drew kind of a line between single family and multifamily. And from the fire district side of things, what an individual owner does in a single family home is of a consequence, but it's a consequence essentially for their own use. There was some discussion about the fact that

3:38:10 If that individual turns around and sells their building, some of what they do may be a consequence to the next owner, but the reality of it is that individual owner is still the responsible entity. In a multifamily setting, and we have seen numerous examples of this throughout town, in multifamily, you're literally affecting not only yourself, but you're affecting all the other users. From a compromise standpoint,

3:38:38 Item number two seems to be the best fit to try to accommodate what flexibility the town really has. When you look at the building code, there are a long list of items that are exempt from pulling a permit, but those are pretty minor items. Everything else requires a permit. The reality of it is the majority of work that gets done requires a permit to be pulled through the town.

3:39:03 I guess the encouragement is even though I think

3:39:31 Choice one is probably more in line with what state code allows, state code requires. Your second option is at least an opportunity to provide some flexibility. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Anyone else? Okay, so bring it back in. Discussion? Comments? I think that the letters and the communication I got, I don't know if you all got the same thing. Got a lot.

3:40:01 Yeah, and there was, and, but the consistent theme that I found was this problem with inspections. And that's another topic that we, it probably gets into a budget topic or priorities and things like that, but that seemed to be the consistent thing. So I think if, from my perspective, if the consistent theme is you've got problems with inspections,

3:40:22 I think what Tom has said in our discussions about in-condo complex, the nature of common structure, all the rest of it, at least if you've got someone there who's got a license who can, who, when the inspector does show up, they're dealing with someone who theoretically knows what they're doing, as opposed to the owner builder who's thrashing around. I just, I think in our current situation, current circumstances, I'm inclined to support. Well, I come at it maybe from a different direction. You know, the idea is to have people,

3:40:52 Right. And, you know, I think if the cost of an owner-builder saying, hey, you have to use a contractor to go pull permits, he might not do that. So it's never going to get inspected. That's the problem, in my opinion. So I'm more inclined to say, hey, I don't really care who pulls the permit. I think the owner-builder should have the right to do that. But it has to be inspected. Right.

3:41:23 And I want it to be inspected. And I think that's the most important thing. And if the problem is we don't have enough people do inspections, we've got to, you know, maybe answer that question. I think Jenison brought up a really good point. But the more important thing to me is, hey, we've got to have a permit. I don't want guys pirating this stuff and doing it on their own because they're saying, hey, I'm going to save a couple hundred bucks.

3:41:49 I don't want to do that. I want them to pull the permit so it is inspected. So for me, I think it's more important. You know, 99% of the people, quite honestly, are going to hire a contractor. They don't know what they're doing out there. And, you know, they're going to do it right and they're going to have it inspected properly and they're going to do the good work. But the idea is to make sure that...

3:42:18 We have a permit. You know, Shields, I agree with what you said. And I'm just, you know, my concern is to circumvent and, you know, making someone pull that permit. They're going to just, they're not going to do it. And, I mean, that's the opposite of what we're trying to do. We're trying to address safety. I think taking the, you know, giving them the option to do the work and, you know, really relying on our inspectors. And I agree with Jenison as well.

3:42:49 If we need some more support there, we need to address it. But we need to be able to make sure the work's done correctly and that our inspectors are approving it. And I'm supportive of our contractors. Believe me, I want you guys to work. But I also don't want to take the rights of owners away, their rights away, and force them to do something, and then they're going to circumvent it all the way around. We're just going to go backwards.

3:43:18 My thought is I'm supportive of option three. Well, we're going to have a 2-2 vote here because I'm supportive of option two. I think, Michael, that the way you get around the things not being done is the licensed contractors know they have to have permits, and if that's still required, then you're going to have the permit. Owner, there's nothing under number three that's going to enforce that person ever getting a permit in my perspective.

3:43:47 Looks like I'm going to turn to I'm hearing two votes for two and two votes for three, which isn't a vote that will pass. So my question is, do we defer it until we have a full council? Sure. Bring it back. Or we just die, but I don't think that just dying is what we want to do. Is there any value in you guys if we say

3:44:15 If we could go for two but amend this to get into this permit discussion. So just to clarify, option two. Each of the three options requires a permit. Correct. No, I'm sorry, but to get into the inspection question. I think that's a different one we'll be talking about during budget. Okay. I'm sorry, John, this is your first spring. It's an issue we've dealt with every spring that I've been on council. Okay.

3:44:43 Because there's the, you know, it's the increase and not enough staff and all that. So I think that one's really a budget question. Yes, it comes back down to it. And maybe it's just because of my position, but inspectors have shown up the day after it's been requested.

3:45:01 On the stuff I've had done. But I think it's, you know, to Jenison's point, it's the other stuff that gets hung up that, you know, they're trying to work on. Correct. And that's a totally separate issue that's really a budget issue. Right, right. So at this point, I guess we will defer this until such time as we have a full council, and I understand you, lucky duck, will not be here at the next council meeting because you get to go to the Indy 500. Yeah. Woo! But, hey, I'll try and call in.

3:45:29 No, I don't think that'll work. You can't hear me? No. Bad connection. Yeah. So we'll defer it. Continue it. Thank you. We'll continue it to the next one. Okay. We now get to number 16, and we still have 32 minutes, hopefully. We won't need all of them to deal with approving a resolution authorized

3:46:00 Additional transit funding. Yes, Madam Mayor. We have two things came up regarding additional transit funding that are to be addressed here. One was the potential closure or discontinuous of the red line as it runs up to Mammoth Mountain, which then would eliminate the service within the town as well. To make sure that we continue to have red line service or would be the trolley service in town.

3:46:26 We're recommending that we be authorized to fund that accordingly so we don't have a gap in our transit services in the community. And then also the other one was looking at depending on the demand we anticipate for the holiday weekend for the Lakes Basin and if we need to have another trolley and bike rack put on there that we can quickly do that, we're not worrying about a funding issue.

3:46:55 That would really be contingent on wait and see what the workload is in terms of the trolley and the bike rack and then also the element on the additional making sure we don't lose transit service in town if the mountain discontinues the red line and I haven't got a confirmation that may have ended as of yesterday but we need to get that confirmed but we will have at least a week if not longer of a gap in loss of transit service and we don't want to lose that.

3:47:24 In the core of town, even if they're not going up to the main lodge. Hopefully that makes sense. Questions for Dan? So really you're making a distinction between core of town and lakes basin. We actually are funding two different pieces. Correct. There are two different pieces here. One is the trolley system around the core of town. The lakes basin would be for the holiday weekend if we need to put an extra trolley and bike rack into that for demand.

3:47:51 Any other questions to staff? No staff. Any comments from the public? Okay. So bring it back. I do have one comment I want to make that I made that distinction. We're really looking at two things here. And this is the second year that we've, at the last minute, found some general fund contingency money to fund extended service in the lake space. And I'd like us to start thinking, and hopefully it will be part of the NLR strategy, that

3:48:20 Transportation to a trailhead is Measure U eligible because it's mobility through, it's recreational mobility. And I think Measure U might apply also to the in-town, but I'd like to see it more of a strategy than just getting these last minute things that say, oh, well, let's grab some general fund contingency. Well, if I could, I'd just go back to the synergy of some of the stuff. I mean, all the snow, non-snow months. Figuring out how we start having those discussions amongst all partners. Right. Whatever so we can, yeah.

3:48:50 Right. So let's roll up the start of the funding for it. Right. Well, and I would actually ask staff that a sizable amount of Measure U was used or was requested this time because they thought it was going to expand and things like that is to try and figure out whether or not staying open longer in the lay space into the fall or opening up earlier might come out of that funding.

3:49:15 Yeah, and that's, again, to follow up on a lot of these things, you know, shoulder season, I mean, it's, if the trends that we're in now was where we're going to be going, we've got to anticipate this stuff, and we've got to start preparing for that. Knowing that if we then have our big snow year that we're all praying for, any Measure U money that isn't used goes right back to Measure U for now. Yeah, it's like taking, you know, if you don't want it to rain, take an umbrella. Right. It's going to snow next year. That's right. Yeah.

3:49:44 Madam Mayor, I make a motion that Council adopt a resolution to authorize an additional $9,114 for transit funding for early start to the town trolley service, an additional $2,660 to allow for the possibility of an early start services into the Lakes Basin. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0.

3:50:14 So we are adjourning to Wednesday, May 20th, but is there a quick reminder, do we have any workshops or anything before the 6 p.m. meeting? Yes, we'll be starting at 4 o'clock on the 20th. We'll be doing a priorities and budget discussion. Okay. All right. We're adjourned. Thank you. Thank you.