Town Council
· recording 5 hr 21 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
697 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:02 Oh, it'll be much fuller.
0:33 Okay. So, Dan, are we waiting for any more staff? Okay. Since I would love us to make sure that we have a break in here. Are you ready, Jamie? Okay. Then we will start our workshop. Really simple. Go for it, Dan.
1:19 A couple things for the workshop. One is kind of a review and update of the strategies that were adopted about eight months ago when council did some workshops going walking through the project list. And I want to kind of start with that. There's a couple items in there that help us inform to the budget. So if there's some additional modifications or adjustments or things to look at, we'll need to know that.
1:45 It's also a good checkpoint for the council in terms and for staff in terms of walking through those priorities, how they were laid out in that element. And I do want to hand out one thing that kind of helps me talk to that briefly. What I use this for, it's kind of a definition of how and why of achieving various things.
2:23 And when we met with the council before, we didn't spend a lot of time on the bottom portion of the pyramid. We didn't, you know, vision and mission and those elements. A lot of that's, I think, been developed through the other documents that town has worked on, be that the planning side of it with the general plan. There's been other elements, I think, to help inform that. The work that we did touched on strategy in some of those elements, but really didn't lay out what I would call a really defined strategic plan or strategic elements.
2:53 Maybe a better term I'll use is a strategic umbrella where a lot of things fall under for that. Well, that was part of the work program touching on those. And then the real focus came in on working through kind of a list of priorities and goals, and that's kind of reflected by the one sheet that was ultimately worked through and adopted by town council. As we continue to move forward in this, and as the council looks at various ways to move their priorities forward,
3:22 This next year we'd be looking at a similar process, coming in and spending some time, again, whether that's a half day, full day, two days. In terms of strategy development, and again, reconfirming our current goal, which we'd be into it for a 12-month period then, so you're looking at 18th month as we laid those out. And obviously, as we've even seen on some of these, some of them will not be achieved fully in the 18-month most likely. Others are done.
3:49 We'd be walking through that. But as we look at that strategy umbrella element, I think that also helps us to go a little broader in terms of how do we bring, I'll say, more of the organizational levels into that. How do we bring our other partners as we're growing capacity outside of the town? How do those fit in? Some of these elements here rely on that. You have some strategies here that rely on Mammoth Lakes Recreation completing certain tasks.
4:16 And so, again, as we kind of look through
4:45 The process, I wouldn't expect this year or even through this process, the vision and mission probably not a big focus, but in terms of more focus on overall strategy and then continuing the current goals, priorities and setting the next round of those and how they integrate across other partners and those elements kind of under that umbrella of the town.
5:09 The pieces we have. And then ultimately, again, what are the results that we look at in the near term and then ultimately, you know, the actions being taken on a regular basis as we move forward through that. So yeah, it's one of the questions. I don't spend a ton of time on that, but that kind of makes sense in terms as we look at this now and also going forward, spending that time to kind of enhance where we're at. We kind of started with the priorities and goals areas.
5:35 And a lot of that was a brand new council coming together going, okay, are we kind of on the same page for a work plan? I think the answer to that was yes. And then how do we move that on forward for a broader strategy and continuing to develop work programs and tasks to feed into and ultimately going out, how do we achieve those strategies? That means we're completing our mission and ultimately implementing the vision that we've established for the town. So I think all of those elements fall into that category.
6:04 And then at this point we came back and looked at kind of 18th month of strategies, commitments, and start to walk through those, which is kind of the attachment to the budget report. So if you have that before you, it would be some of the discussion. But before we dive into kind of the strategies and those elements, are there any questions just in terms of that, I guess, kind of that pyramid concept? And we're at the goal stage right now.
6:32 It's next year taking, I'll say in that August, September time frame, taking a step into working on our broader strategy, confirming the priorities and shifting those or adding to as some drop off, some come on. Kind of that process makes sense? Yeah. Yeah, I think it's very important that we do that. There are things, as we go through the list, there are things popping up that that's what we're going to need, that strategic umbrella and tying everything together is going to be important.
7:03 Any other comments? If not, we tried to lay out in the staff report detachment there, was really looking at, we had identified kind of these broad areas, A, B, C, D, E through G, the first one enhancing community amenities, and then we began to look at kind of a list of what does that mean. And then we tried to do a little bit of a status update and some of that.
7:31 Maybe not as clean as it could be there, and it's obviously we could have wrote more in some areas, but to give you a feel for where we're at and have this dialogue, and also a chance as we look at those, and I'll mention the first one here, if we talk about, you know, groundbreaking for a new Sherwin Trail and first amenity coming into play, I know we're going to be out probably throughout this time frame completing the NEPA process, so we may not actually get to a trail.
7:57 But what would be a first amenity? And the status kind of gives where we're at on that. We're actually working on NEPA with the U.S. Forest Service. They've actually done a little work this year. We're losing one of their staff people, so that may push us out a little bit again. Those elements that we don't control come into that. Real quick, so anything having to do with the trail system is going through a Mammoth Lakes Trail System committee, which is a subcommittee of MMR, correct? Right. That's where these things are living, and that's where they...
8:25 It's where it's living, but I think that, you know, initially it had come forward, and I think, John, you were the one that suggested we say we wanted the first Sherwin, you know, groundbreaking for the first trail in the Sherwin, but now we know that the NEPA is not likely to be finished to a point, and you're right, so then it's like, well, okay, so we know we've assigned Mammoth Trails Committee of MLR to be in charge of that, and we're...
8:53 Going to have a trails coordination contract, all those things. So things are moving forward. But specifically a Sherwin area trail may not happen by June 2016. No, I understand. My point is back to what Dan was talking about with the strategic stuff at the beginning. Is we've assigned somebody to get it done. Yeah, so we should be able to go through this and be able to say so. Correct. Next question would be the ice rink. Let's call it multi-use facility. Multi-use facility.
9:20 That is a, ostensibly, that's a town facility, and that's between the rec commission and NOR. The rec commission is the leads. That's a town thing. So repudates in that process, that's where you're going to respond to. Right, and we know that both of those areas, work is being done. Oh, sure. I understand. I understand. I think, but...
9:38 But there's another piece of first amenity that my understanding when we had the discussion was that that might be something in town. So in that case, the multi-use facility would count for it. When we said that, that was before the contract was made up with MLR that didn't even ask for the strategic plan or the list of amenities until partway in, you know, about halfway through the 18 months. So I just want to check basis with everybody that we know there will be some amenity and we weren't specific.
10:08 But after we get that information this fall, then we will know what's the priority one that we're going to be working on and will at least be someplace through it by the end of the 18 months. Sure. And I just, again, my, I want to make sure that we know so that not everything's coming to us. Correct. Where these things live and who rolled and accountable and all that kind of stuff. Okay. My question on this, kind of the status on that, we touched on the trail as we look at
10:38 The first new amenity, the one element I put out there was the Lake George Connector Path, the MUP if that comes forward. That's again pending for the Forest Service work, whether it will hit this construction season or not, based on discussions with the fish and wildlife side of the house for them. But also, you know, the multi-use center with that one, it's an existing amenity we're working through, would that qualify?
11:02 Or if we're missing something there. But that's kind of the thought process on each of these. I don't want to necessarily blabber each item to a high level of detail. But getting a feel for are we going the direction Council anticipated? Some things moving quicker, others moving slower. And or if there's something in there you're saying, I really want clarity or move this up in priority in terms of work programming or would love to do this. Is that a budget issue? Those are the items we'll be looking for as well.
11:28 I think for me, the priority has not changed one bit, and I think we are moving in the right direction. We've got a place where those things live, and we're going to continue to have updates on where that progress is, but we at least have someone moving that forward. So I'm comfortable with that. I think we'll know a lot more, as Joe said, in the fall when we really look at that strategic priority list.
11:54 B and D kind of both fall together with the MLR work that's going on. Well, actually, B, D, and E. Well, yeah. Yeah, D actually has an element, or E has an element in there, too. And while we're still on A, I had a couple of meetings ago, and maybe it was the one when you weren't here, Colin, is we were asked to consider additional red line and then opening up the lake space in Memorial Day weekend, and I asked that MLR consider it a strategy of whether or not
12:24 We're really enhancing transit funding through Measure U or just special event funding, you know, because to me, opening it up to get people to a trailhead, as long as they're not snowed in this weekend, is an appropriate use of the mobility part of Measure U. So that kind of asks for that piece to be expanded a little when MLR looks at it as a strategy. Do you have anything on A, enhanced community activities? No. Okay. All right, do you want to move on to B, Dan?
12:54 Yeah, there's nothing under that total A in community amenities. I can, yeah, the improve air service. Just hang on one second. One thing is on B, A, B, is the need to make sure that the MLRs, you know, they're coming up with a strategic plan in the fall, but that we really need, as Dan mentioned at the beginning, the strategy thing, we need to make sure that the MLR strategy is talking up for MLT, might want to start doing some work.
13:24 If that coordinates with the MLT strategy, then all these things are going to be coming together. Yeah. And actually, the date for MLR to be back with the strategy is, I think it's September 1st or something like that. The Performing Arts Center, MLR is ready, but there's some hiccups at the state architect's office, some other things like that, that may get delayed because of that. Didn't we have somewhere in the discussion on...
13:52 Events location of trying to discuss that a little further or someone take the lead on that? I mean, I know the performing arts is on here. Yeah, it's really, it's a little d, the prioritized list of recreational amenities projects. Okay, so it's living under that? Yeah, it's living under that, right. Okay. That's one of the issues they need to bring back going, what is that outdoor? Here's the strategy and then when you implement it, here's what comes, here's what.
14:16 I think that we need to put some focus and concern on that. I mean, we were this close from Bluza Palooza not having an event site. And the likelihood of them having an event site at Sam's next year is probably, you know, less than it was this year, which was almost gone away. We certainly can't afford to lose that event. And I think we need to have that discussion sooner than later.
14:42 Yeah, what are we going to do with that? In reality, MLR is dealing with both of them together because your strategy has criteria to help you decide what are the priorities. Right. Yeah. So it lives there. It lives there. I didn't see it called out anywhere. Okay. Yeah, we need to hear a little detail. I did have a comment on AE regarding transit. Now is an appropriate time.
15:12 We just had our ESTA meeting on Friday, and one of the things the board was asked to do is look at the six-month operating plan as far as the transit schedule. So we do that biannually. And, you know, I know we had discussed enhancing and expanding some service as far as special events, which I think absolutely we saw was needed, especially this summer, and also lakes basin stuff based on the success of that event.
15:41 One other thing that I wanted to discuss that jumped out at me is in the winter, we have a night trolley that runs until 2 a.m. on 20-minute frequency, so there's a trolley seven days. In the summer, we have no trolley service past time. That was the one thing in the operational plan that jumped out at me that I thought was problematic. Reason being, I tried to ask some questions as a new member of the board of whether it's always been that way.
16:16 The answer I got was that that kind of predated most of the board, predated John Helm. I think, you know, as recently, seven to ten years ago, there probably wasn't a need in the summer as the shoulder season, if you will. But we've seen the expansion in summer tourism, especially with all the event stuff going on. A lot of those events are, you know, in and around the village. And I want to encourage people to take mass transit to get there because, you know,
16:50 A bunch of cars trying to go up. And then a lot of times people will choose to stay up in the village afterwards and go out to the bars and those type of things. I find it problematic that we don't have anything to happen. So was the staff of ESTA asked to make an estimate of what cost that would be? So I can get a more accurate number. I had a very brief conversation about that. I think if we were looking to do one trolley, which would mean 30 minutes rather than 20 minutes,
17:22 In that 10 to 2 range, I'm thinking we're looking somewhere in the neighborhood, quick math, if there could be expansion to help. Well, then maybe what we want to do is ask staff to work with us and bring something back to us as budget as to how, you know, what that cost is. Is that something that would live under Measure U as well for mobility? I don't know. I don't know. I think it would. It possibly could. Yeah, we can bring something back both. We can get a cost estimate and then... Of course, I...
17:52 I don't know if it would mean an additional allocation, because I know staff asked for a higher amount for the trolley service related to the special events, knowing that we were trying to expand it, so maybe it's to see whether or not there's an estimate of whether that $24,000 would cover this as well, because I know it was a total guesstimate because it was so early and they didn't even know what all the events were, so maybe we can come back to that.
18:18 If additional is needed, put that into the budget for us to consider. And Dan, we also have some potential savings based on the extension of the mountain that was unanticipated, right? Yeah, correct. When we requested the funding here last week from the council, which was approved, ESSA has since extended that out at least one other week, maybe both weeks. And so there's some dollars there that were allocated transit that we won't spend in the current year. Between part of that and the $24,000 from Measure U, there's probably a way to
18:48 Move it around. Yeah, to make that work. Possibly. And so, and this is the perfect exercise. So if we ask that that be considered, that if we want that and it isn't going to be funded by something, then we have to figure out what we want to drop in order to have that. But yeah, that's perfect time, perfect time to ask. Yeah, so I just wanted to kind of bring that up. That was the one thing at the ESDA meeting that jumped out at me is something that I think is problematic. And so if we can get an estimate on...
19:14 And I think it would be totally reasonable to just look at one trolley on 30-minute frequency, whether it be seven days a week or potentially we could shrink that to maybe four or five days a week. We could use it as a little bit of a test to see kind of what the ridership is. But I think keeping people out of their vehicles and getting them home safe is what we need to be prioritizing there. And that's also how we got the...
19:41 Number one rating is the best ski resort. Least polluted. Some we're getting right. Least polluted. Yeah, we have something right. We want to support that. We could ask Esther whether it would be, do you start at seven days and kind of do a little pilot project? Are there some better hours? Are there reduced days? I think John kind of could probably give us a little overview of what he recommends. Between that and whatever more.
20:09 Definitive information STAT has as far as the actual cost of the special report for all these. Correct. All right, so this will come back to us. Because we did, we just about doubled the amount that they were given in Measure U. Yeah. So it may cover it. Yeah, and I think that would just be the one thing as we're talking about enhancing and expanding transit services, that would be the one thing I want to throw into the bucket. Okay. All right. Okay. Anything else on our community amenities? Okay. Then on to air service. Air.
20:38 So do you want to go ahead? Do you want to get to it first? Yeah, just the air service element there. I'm just going to touch on some of the... Well, why don't you presume we've read it? Yes. I just... One piece in there, just some of the conversations that are ongoing, I just wanted to touch on. Okay. Ongoing work with the FAA in terms of those dialogues and getting into the ACIP for the work at the airport. Secondly, we've initiated some discussions with Inyo County in terms of the Inyo Airport or Bishop Airport.
21:05 Get referred to as both. Probably the Inyo Yosemite once it's up and running. And so looking at that in terms of reliability, is that an option or not? We've had one test run going to Reno in terms of those areas. So we're looking at various options that way and really letting the FAA also keep in touch and we're engaging with them through that process as well ultimately for funding pieces. The other piece ultimately we need to come back with and say what is going to be that match requirement.
21:32 And how much of our annual allocation can we use? How much dollars do we need to get set aside if we're building a $20 million project? Is it basically a 10% match or is it something different? How much of that is the different pieces? And Grady can speak to that in more detail if there's questions to it. He's been on top of that. Trying to move that forward and say what does that begin to look like for capacity, for service, for reliability.
21:56 And working, again, this regional concept of looking how do we best work together for quality commercial air service. Okay, so again, for A, I think that it's important that we start getting out in front of the financial considerations for this investment. So I think when staff has opportunities, I think we need to get the right numbers.
22:21 They will change over time, but we need to have the numbers and the data out in front of the public so that we know what it is we're talking about. And I'm looking at this whole, at A, as being staff, this is staff, this is the staff. And the issues with SCOG, it's a regional opportunity that kind of gets it to be a little bit, but that's staff to SCOG and maybe us. Has the SCOG had an opportunity to discuss?
22:47 Kind of a regional plan. We've talked about it informally, and there is a desire to have more formal conversations with the ESCOG about a variety of regional opportunities. There's some issues. Chairman Michaels ceded the authority over to Jeff Griffith, who's now the head of the ESCOG. He's looking into the issues about committees for ESCOG and how the ESCOG is formed and works, and I'm anticipating the next meeting we'll be getting into that.
23:14 To follow up on the community conversation about Ragtag and Air Service to start looking at these things. There are a couple other things in here that could come up with regional, that could benefit from regional work. But those are all included in things that you intend to address at the Ask Ogla. Absolutely. I sense there's political support from members there to do it within my Brown Act conversation with people moving forward. So I've got BA staff.
23:41 BB is staff, maybe SCOG, and C is MLT for how this is assigned, right? Right. Just for those responsibilities. Yeah. Grady, a quick question. Is there any kind of update that you want to provide to us as far as how we're moving along with FAA and where we're at? Sure, just a little bit more detail about what's in your chart.
24:04 Regarding the regional issue, we did have a very good meeting within Yale County, and we let FAA know we did that, and FAA, frankly, Mark McClardy was very happy that we were talking. He doesn't expect, you know, everything in the world to come out of this, but he wants us to be talking to each other, so that's the only real progress on that side. On the FAA side, I've actually already started writing the RFQ for the consultant process, and Brian just delivered to my desk yesterday the first of our AIP grant applications for this next year.
24:33 One of them will still be the initiation of the design for the terminal on the air side. It will be focused, however, on that preliminary design necessary to do the leave of documentation. FAA has some things they need to clear up internally before they want us to go full bore ahead, if you will, but that process we think we can get started at least due to consultant selection over the summer. So those things are all moving.
24:59 The only other comment I might have, and I'll add it later for Council as well so everybody can hear it, but we did do a SQR through our Part 139 safety inspection at the airport, and that came back, if anything, cleaner than last year, and last year was a page and a half, so very minor things, they're very happy with us. Okay, great. The only other item, and again, it's just dealing with the airport, the things you did ask is we arrived.
25:21 We're looking at the wildlife assessment study. That's completed. Now we have to do a further report on that, and it's very likely that the recommendations and the money might even be there the next couple of years to do a wildlife fence. The inspector even said off the cuff her opinion out there in the field, if you will, was I really think an 8-foot fence in this environment is appropriate versus the 10-foot plus that is another area. A lot of things going on out there.
25:50 Great. Thanks, Randy. I've got another funding question on little A under B. The letter that we approved me signing on to that might change that one fee, that fee, if we get an increase, would go towards the matching funds for the terminal, right? Yes, it would be restricted for capital investment at the airport, so yes.
26:15 If that goes anywhere. Oh, you have an update on that? Okay. Right now Congress is looking at the appropriations bill for FAA and they didn't, in the first couple of rounds they did not include a PFC increase but everybody's still arguing and talking about it. Okay. So right now they did not address that, just so you know, but the industry is out there trying to push it forward. Thanks, Grady. Okay, any other comments on improve air service? Okay.
26:47 If not, item C is on kind of the municipal capacity category there. A couple of those. Is Al still here? Yes. Okay. So that position is still filled. Checking. He keeps wondering if we actually have summer in Mammoth or not.
27:07 Other elements are a lot of different areas are moving forward that the council is aware of. I won't walk through all of those in detail. I can answer particular questions about them. A couple things in there quickly is, actually Jamie probably has more information than I do, is the upgrade coming into the facility in here. That's a multi-phase process that's moving along pretty well, so for some details she can speak to that. She's engaged with it, obviously.
27:34 And then also, I think our financial stability issue, and this goes to the budget, one of the recommendations is that we take all the efforts we need to retain the $3 million as a reserve for economic uncertainty to retain that at a budget level, not to dip into that. We've seen that a little bit from a beneficial side to us in the last review by S&P. We saw one notch increase in our bond ratings that they're looking at. So that was a positive step there.
28:02 We know it's still a challenge for us in looking at the police station when we did debt financing for that. We did a request out to 15 different banks and funders. We had two responses, the low one, after doing additional work on the credit worthiness of the town backed out. The second, or the remaining bidder, is going through that due diligence as we speak. They should be done the first part of June so we'll know whether or not they're willing to finance us or not.
28:32 The bankruptcy weighs heavily under the filing still weighs heavily. The second piece that they look at is the reliance on tourism, just that we only have one real industry, regardless of whether it's snow, no snow, summer, winter, it's just one industry, and so that's a concern they look at. Again, they've also seen the upgrade in the ratings and stuff, and that's a positive step for us, and also our own financial stability that's out there.
28:58 Showing that we're making payments and those types of things have been a plus. But those two elements kind of work together in this category here from those different pieces that we're working through. The finance system is up and in process, and so we're hoping still to go live date on that in July, August. Quick question on that financing with this bank. Have you also went to the private sector at all?
29:22 Not at this point because the banks are really looking at it from an interest rate standpoint. You're down a little over 3%. And usually what you're looking at that is institutional investors who actually like to have some of the government securities in their portfolio and stuff. If this doesn't pan out, we'd come back and say, do you want to do a public offering, which that would be more of a private sector or institutional investors, a different process. The rates are probably up about, you know, maybe a half a point in that process.
29:51 It's still a good deal in terms of what we're paying now. We're paying over 6%, so if we're somewhere around 3.5% to 4%, it makes the deal viable from a financial standpoint. Right. Can we, in terms of the police station, are there regional opportunities that have been talked about with Monroe County? Yeah, what we've talked really about is, because the site we're looking at is the property we own over by the courthouse. The discussions we had on that was, whatever we design, we need to make sure that there's a vision out there so it can be expanded into additional services.
30:21 Whether you do not want to be in the jail business, frankly, but if that's the right site for a county jail, then we ought to design accordingly. We've talked about additional space in the facility, ultimately, if you have a workspace for CHP, if they need a place to stop, or if the Sheriff's Department can stop, those types of interactions and elements. So the idea here is we're really just taking what we have and replacing it, but keeping an eye onto the future of how that might integrate so we don't design something. So we would look to follow up on that. That would be the design phase to make sure that...
30:51 A couple other quick questions. The financial system is obviously very important. I don't need an update on that, but I think we all know how important that is. Very important. I think there's something with the 21st century municipal government. This is a little fuzzy in here, and I think that this is something that we heard from the Digital 395 folks about investment in anchor institutions and the ability of institutions to actually do something with the bandwidth that's being delivered to them.
31:16 And the disruption question is not so much a question of putting the pipe in, it's a question of what the organizations have to do to accommodate and make use of it. So this is something I appreciate what a big lift this is going to be, but something that we may want to be mindful, you know, going down the road, make sure we look at those opportunities. And I think also, you know, as you can tell, I'm at least tracking who's responsible for which things are happening here, the use of partners, the integration, the integration of the town as an organization in with our
31:45 You know, our NGOs, I don't want to call them partners, they fall within our oversight to really start integrating those capacities. And that's a topic for another day, but I think we're going to keep our eyes on. Dan, I had one. I just want to make sure that the financial stability, you are building the budget with leaving the reserve at $3 million. Yeah, right now I think it's $3 million and $22,000. So, yeah, we're not anticipating going below that. That would not be recommended.
32:14 I just want to make sure there's head nodding. Yes. Yes. We'll confirm that in the budget, but yes, that's one of the budget items here that we want to confirm. All these items are staff items of government. Right. It's responsible for all staff. Out of curiosity, could I just get some feedback from Dan, maybe Sarah, just kind of some feedback on the 980 and kind of what staff feedback on that has been? Go ahead, sir. Relates to budget.
32:45 No. Okay. Morale. Just in general? Yeah. Okay. Yeah. It's been great. We have these envelopes in the break room that say keep, stop, start for people to anonymously put feedback in there. Yeah, I read that. What the feedback was. That the 980 schedule has boosted morale and has made just the working environment calmer. People seem more at ease. I think in general we've all kind of noticed it's really quiet. People are getting a lot done on Fridays because it's like switching off. We have half the staff on Fridays.
33:12 So I think overall it's been really great. Everybody's been really happy with the alternative schedule. We're mirroring now what the county and the water district and the other local government agencies are doing. Good stuff. Thanks. Issues in here about donuts. Yes. A lot of stops. That wasn't necessarily universally agreed to. Some of us still eat donuts. I think donuts were the only thing that fell into all three categories. That's right.
33:42 I very much appreciate this kind of stuff and how we interface and interact with staff. I appreciate the question also because in terms of the priorities that we're setting, how we can find common things that are coming from staff that are things that we can start making IT improvements is the first thing we keep listening. Good. Anything else in that grouping? No.
34:14 If not, item D would implement kind of that comprehensive community plan. Really just the two items there, but the first energy summit's been held and we're working on a follow-up from that. The other element in terms of kind of this conceptual plan or bringing life to the town, we've just started that with some large mapping work to kind of lay out what's actually been approved or what is in concept or what's in a planning process.
34:41 I think once we get that pulled together, it'll be a presentation we need to make and kind of say if everything happened that's currently on the books, this is what it looks like. And then the question, do we have it right? Does some of this stuff need to shift, move? How does it fit? What's missing? And I think as you look at the big map, it helps you have that dialogue. So that will be coming forward, hopefully not too distant future. By the end of the summer, we should have that kind of rolled out to look at. Where's Sandra? Kind of working through the Planning Commission and then...
35:09 Up, I think. So, yeah. So, is this, I'm assuming this is a GIS-based product, correct? Yeah, we're actually working with the Mountain on it, with some of their GIS folks. It is a GIS-based product? Yeah. Okay. On the Synergy Summit, real quick, we had, Colin and I are continuing to work on that, but it's basically turning into something where there's a summit, break in work groups, the work groups establish key agreements amongst themselves.
35:38 The work groups are people who have capacity to do things, and then they sort of memorialize that with key agreements, and then you go back and start working on things. And I've got that as a council staff kind of a project, and this next one, the mapping thing is a staff project. Yeah, now on the Synergy Summit, so while you've got the working groups doing the key agreements, are you already scheduling the next?
36:03 Summit for whatever it's going to be. We're looking at probably the October time frame, kind of that. And I think at some point there's going to be need to have, rather than the Synergy Summit around a specific topic, but the council with our contracted NGOs, capacities, and partners to look at it from even from that level, I think probably would be a good kind of strategic thing in the late summer to be a good time to come back and sort of look at that.
36:31 Anything else on that group? If not, the idea of addressing the parking challenges. The two different elements kind of going together there. The short term we are working with I-Star in terms of the buildings they're taking down. Initial discussions, are they interested in leasing that property for short term parking, meaning three year, five year?
37:05 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
37:32 Is there a transit stop that works in there for us? Those types of issues. And so that's under discussion right now as one of the ways to have some public parking available up in that area. Plus it also addresses a different issue with the blight issue of taking those two buildings down, which I think people are excited about. I think there's been several comments I've received on, you know, that people are excited to see those come down. We haven't had as much luck with the other two buildings we identified. We've had some preliminary discussions with one that...
38:00 Got put on hold because they actually had a potential offer on it, so they stopped talking to the town. It would be better if somebody else bought it and developed and took it down. That would be great, but I don't know the same things of that. As close as we've come, I think, for discussions on the town-wide parking issues has really been through the EIFD discussion. A little bit of the Main Street plan has some of those discussions, I believe, in it.
38:21 Looking at Sandra, so she's nodding her head. Yes, that's been one of the dialogues in that area, but I would say there probably hasn't been really an overall strategy developed at this point from a town-wide parking issue, but there's definitely discussions going on what the need is. Is that fair to say, Sandra? Dan, real quick, as far as on the village, on the lots with I-Star, was that...
38:46 For us to do parking and lease it back for parking, that was our agreement to do that, to get them to take the building. They looked at that, and then with the homeless folks in there, they charged their head regardless, so we're re-engaging them on us having an interest in leasing that for parking. But that's not a contingent piece. No, it's coming down regardless. I mean, I think they got a little nervous when they had people camping underneath the buildings.
39:15 Then also we found one of them actually has a basement that we didn't know about until someone kind of walked underneath one of the stairs, I think, or four rooms. And has there been some delays and some permit snags or something there? That all got worked out. So now the contractor is fully ready to go. They're actually doing, it'll go real slow initially because they're doing the detailed asbestos removal works. That's a lot of hand work. So you won't see a lot of stuff happen until that's done. And then you'll see it.
39:44 What's the target date for it to be done? I do not have one that I'm aware of. So I haven't seen it on the demo. It's going to be before crowd show for summer, I hope. Yes, we're hoping before, yeah, for. Saturday. Yeah, so. That's for three days, right? So we're hoping, yeah, that the time frame will get there. Soft opening. Soft opening. This might be the end of winter, so. Yeah, I think it's, hopefully we can work it out so we can utilize that.
40:12 Those lots for parking that we desperately need. Correct. So, you know, it's a good solution that could end up being a longer term solution dependent on what happens with those properties. And what we have built in budget wise, heads up again, tying these back together, one of the contractual service accounts, we put some dollars in there for the potential lease of parking spaces. Okay. So that is covered in the budget.
40:41 As an option for us to do that. So real quick on the EIFD, I wonder if there's an update about, I know there was some private money involved in the EIFD, maybe we can update on that and then understanding EIFDs are just there if we want to use them, but I'm interested in an update on that effort. Yeah, so the private money was donated to fund the consultant's kind of first phase. So that private money, when she comes back for her final
41:13 Presentation in the next couple months or so, that will be expanded, so there is no more private money after she comes back. So do we, does the council or the town have access to that consultant? Yeah. I mean, she works for us. She's contracted to the town. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, we're working with her right now, and we rescheduled. She was supposed to be out here this week, but because of all the other fee updates we're doing and everything, we thought it'd be better to kind of push it to later in the summer, so we're thinking of bringing her back maybe in late July or August.
41:41 Okay, but that can solve the sale available. Well, it's available right now to this dollars here. Ultimately, if we wish to engage or beyond that, we would have to come back and come back with additional dollars. But there's a little bit left before the contract is done. Correct. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else on parking challenges, questions? Okay. All right. The other one in terms of diversify the economic development,
42:13 We have the item there about implementing economic development strategy, and part of that we're working through really an update of the strategy. We went through a lot of the documents that are existing out there. Dr. Seds, a number of other pieces to that to begin to look at that. It's not fully completed yet. There's some updates still going into that. The other side of that has been, I know, the outreach to the community and really focusing on digital 395, looking at ongoing...
42:38 It kind of transcends several of these areas of our amenity base, our recreational base. How do we begin to expand our economic from the recreational side into shoulder seasons? How do we do stuff if we're into a fifth year of a drought? All those discussions are ongoing at this point. Obviously, air service plays a large role, I think, into the midterm economic strategy element in terms of being able to bring people in from that capacity area to work through that.
43:06 The other side of that, we do have people looking at Mammoth for investment, mainly I think from the resort development side. Nobody's pulled the trigger yet in terms of really being the first one out of the box. Some of that ties at this point, just the cost of entry into Mammoth seems to be the most significant barrier. That goes into fee discussions, it goes into land cost, it goes into...
43:31 You know, the cost on the property, not are necessarily related to the town, but debt or other issues that are tied into the property. And then ultimately we will get requests coming forward, I'm sure, to say how can the town help close the gap of whatever's left, whether that's through working with infrastructure that we fund, whether that's working in a shared element of our TOT component. You're going to get into those types of requests coming forward in order to, I think.
43:58 Closed a gap on funding to see a new project come out of the ground. And I'd say that one, two, three, the four, the five of them we've talked to, that's been basically the same concern expressed by the full group looking at Mammoth. The fact that they're here and talking and looking I think is good in terms of the interest level. Ultimately knowing what it takes to
44:25 Kind of have somebody pull the trigger. I think that's kind of where we're still waiting to really nail that down so we know what we're negotiating on. They're also waiting to ultimately figure out their own performance, which will tie to some of our fee structures. And they're negotiating on land prices in some cases. So I know you probably have a couple of things you want to say on this, but a couple of things to get started. In the community forum, one of the interesting things that we heard was kind of a plea from the community to make it easy.
44:53 And I think that we're probably in pretty well positioned and got good documents in place. These are in the DIF and housing and everything else. If a significant developer shows up, I think we're in a good position to engage or something like that. But I think at the lower end, we're talking about local businesses, local things that can really invest in our infrastructure and do stuff. I think that at some point, we may want to kind of start taking a look at that and maybe put together some sort of a program.
45:20 That we can point people to so that we can get the people who are here, who are working on the business retention side of things. And I just, I think it's something that came out from that. I think it's, I don't know if there's a whole lot we can actually do, but I think it's something that we can focus on. I got the feeling from some other conversations, because I did hear that that night, but that the chamber was taking on that claim.
45:44 Some spearheading, gathering business retention ideas. That would be great. I look forward to hearing what they have to say. I think if it does come to things like permitting fees, we've produced diff, we've done things like that for bigger projects, but I think a kind of a lower end of things were to keep people investing in their businesses, their physical structures, their houses, their...
46:08 I just had lunch on Tuesday with Craig Schmidt and they are getting ready to roll out very soon.
46:34 The Business Retention and Expansion Survey. So he asked me and I agreed to join like an ad hoc committee that will work on that so maybe you and I can kind of sit down. And what he basically asked for me is it's a developed program, but he's going to ask the ad hoc to kind of look through the questions, see what's missing, what needs to be dropped, what needs to be added, what needs to be tweaked, so that we're really kind of...
47:00 Yeah, I think he's looking to have the ad hoc
47:30 Together, convened in the next month. And so by that point, the survey will go out, you know, presumably shortly after that. So I think sometime this summer, yeah. For now, we built the budget as is because, of course, if you reduce fees, then you've got staff costs that are no longer covered. So when we talk about cost of entry, it's just that. I mean, you know, there's the way current fee structures are set up.
47:59 Nothing's ever getting built in Mammoth unless this council makes a decision to get aggressive and get realistic and create jobs and put people to work and get some starts because as you look at our other peer resorts, I mean, they're doing things and we're not. And, you know, you're going to see more people packing up their rider and getting on 395 and leaving town.
48:21 I've talked to a lot of people that have been here a long time, and they feel like this is the same era of this pre-intrawest day. It feels the same. It's like deja vu. June 3rd, our next meeting, you know, we're going to be challenged with that decision of what we want to do to either get aggressive and tell all these people that are sitting there on the wings right now that want to make substantial investments in town that we're, you know, we are a new council, we are open for business, and that we...
48:51 We want to get some things started and put some people to work. But to have our fees and costs, and not only that, but the complexity, and you talked about that a little bit. I mean, we are trying to streamline things, and we are going through that, but it comes down to the cost of entry. I mean, people are coming with fees that are more than it costs to buy land. I mean, it's just unrealistic, and it's a fairy tale. I mean, we have to...
49:18 You know, make a decision and get aggressive and say that we're going to move forward and not talk about it for another three years while these guys all leave. Is there an item in the budget you see coming forward that we're going to have an opportunity to weigh in on this? It is. No, it's not the budget. It's not the budget. It's different housing. It's different housing. It's total housing. It's coming on June 3rd. Yeah, it's not with the budget. But, you know, the point being is, you know, I think we're at a critical...
49:46 You know, time. I mean, and I, you know, if you look at, like I said, if you look at these other resorts, I mean, we've got a lot of activity and a lot of job creation, a lot of things happening. And I think we have, you know, John Hooper happening. We have, you know, one thing, one guy building, right? But there's some very strong people that are looking to come to town and put their money here and do some...
50:11 You know, great things, but I think it's going to take some will of the council to move the needle a little bit. Okay. And so we'll see where that goes. But that cost of entry is critical. Yeah, and my other point is the cost of the dues on both ends of the spectrum. Right. And we got, you know, we want to make sure that the people who are here, small businesses, you know, the folks that are the community.
50:34 That we're not just looking that way, but we're looking down at the... Right, but I mean, it goes to say, though, if we don't start creating some jobs, we don't start creating some starts, all these little businesses are not going to be here. I mean, and they're, you know, everyone is kind of, you know, running on a survival mode, including the mountain. I mean, there's few visitors that are way down. Yeah, snow is a big part of it, but it's not 100% of it. So...
51:00 You know, we need to look at the big picture. And, you know, like I said, there's a lot of people that have been here a long time that are, you know, heading under 395. So we've got to create some sustainability, you know, and, you know, get some, like I said, create some jobs and get some things going. I mean, we can't keep waiting for a cycle and keep missing it and keep missing it and keep missing it. Why, you know, other resorts and other people are moving.
51:29 I think we have an opportunity to do that now, and we need to make some tough decisions and some smart decisions that are going to help us down for a long time. Yeah, I think we're more charged with enticement, whereas in my conversations with Craig and the Chamber, they've really decided to hone their focus on existing business, B2B, retention, expansion, helping facilitate.
51:56 Okay, this is probably our broadest category, so just kind of, you know, because DIP is on the next page, and we have something on that later tonight, too.
52:27 On item B there, FB, we talked about the whole idea of how do we enhance, I think, the shoulder seasons, kind of those months, and some of the events, I think, are doing that. We haven't spent a lot of time looking to that, but I think that MLT's been talking to that. Well, and actually, after MLR is already starting to talk to both MLT and the Chamber about how to approach that in a cohesive partnership manner as part of what comes back is the MLR recommendations on
52:56 So those discussions are already starting to happen. Yeah, I'm very much looking forward to it. It was hot there for a little while and some folks had to take some direction. Yeah, even though we didn't, you know, the discussion after the allocations was made was that, you know, we need to look at this as long-term sustainable. So that's what NLR is trying to pull the partners together on to discuss. Again, too, that goes back to, like, conference facilities, right? When you talk, like, with Digital 395 and having some of these summits and growing those.
53:25 We need the space to be able to provide that. I mean, in some of these new projects, there could be some space. And again, I also look at taking our existing stock of buildings and structures and figuring out if Digital 395 is a way to start inhabiting a lot of that stuff. And I've heard stories about folks who tried to put together, you know, sort of tech-based kind of working centers in town using existing structures, and they get into it.
53:53 Permitting and this and then that and all the residents are like, I'm not doing this here, I'm going to go to Bishop. So it's, it's, it's, it's, it's on two fronts. Right. We've got to be looking at these things for Heather. Well, we've got 25 acres out at the airport we can put Texas. Exactly. Exactly. Well, I just, I mean, just say in the conference, I mean, talk about shoulder seasons, I mean.
54:14 You know, there's a lot of people that would like to come here, and we have to be able to have the facility to host them and house them and so forth and so on to put these together. And unfortunately, though, what happened since the Inner West came and left is that as other projects came forward, they were built with asking not to have conference space. So we built things, but we still didn't get the conference space. So even on some of the stuff that's entitled but hasn't been built yet, it's not really...
54:43 Adequate. I'd like to follow the conference guys a little bit on coming out of the, I'm sure if it was the Synergy Summit of the Community Meeting, people, there's some conversation about that. And I don't know, it's not on here anywhere, I don't know whether it lives, it's a private sector thing or how we're going to do that, but I think it's something, it's a...
55:00 You know, the right thing, whether it's part of a development that's going to happen or how we're going to do it, there's also a big need for what, some sort of a wedding facility, people can save rent, something like that. I don't know where these things live. No, and that's part of, part of,
55:13 If it doesn't get into the diff list, it gets into the, what MLR brings back, you know, with this strategy here, you know, strategy includes, we recognize there's a need for more things that we're going to be able to build immediately. Yeah, I think, Jo, you make an excellent point back in the boom when all the big projects were showing up. So, like, you know, if you look at the Westin, because that was not built by the Westin, it was just built essentially on spec, and so they have not enough conference space. They didn't even have a gift shop until they turned a closet into the gift shop. Yeah. You know.
55:42 Can I have a gift shop? Yeah. Right, but I mean, there's been, you know, there's been groups that have been coming and using, for example, Canyon Lodge as a place to have a, you know, and they're just like, we're not coming anymore, we're going somewhere else. So, I mean, that's a, there's a big market for that for Shoulders to help our local economy. And then it's the question of, is it a public-private partnership or is it part of a development or whatever, that's the piece to be done. Whatever we have to do, you know. Combination work. Yeah.
56:11 Okay. Okay. Kind of back page, there's a number of items there, and I'll just, if you have items, we can address those as we walk through it, if you need clarification on some comments. No, but I wanted to talk just for a second about the plastic bag ban implementation. Do you want to come back to see after you're done? Oh, I'm sorry. Well, okay, I thought everybody knew where we were. Sorry, go ahead, do regional waste then. So just regional waste, you know, you've written a letter down that indicates the towns.
56:38 And I think that that's something the county may struggle with that a little bit as we're going forward. We just want to make sure as we go with this that we have good communication with the county that we're committed to helping them with that problem. And if any extra time or conversations necessary, let's make sure we have it so we don't get it.
57:03 Crosswise based on miscommunications. True, but we don't have as much time as most people think. Okay. You know, that bases up. Yeah, that bases up in less than 10 years. So we can't spend five years having these regional conversations. It's got to move faster than that. I'm happy with the direction as documented, so following the letter from Dan, and I'm hoping that we're just going to stick with that. And we've just recently, you know, again, some additional discussions with Inyo County as a regional landfill. That's going to be up to L.A.
57:31 Frankly, whether or not they allow annual county to take out of county waste on their leased property. Which is ironic because it's on other DWP leased land right now. Correct. So we're working through those types of items and how do you best ultimately solve this on a regional basis knowing that either 2020 or 2023 January we'll be here real quick on Benton Crossing and we need to have a solution in place.
57:54 Including, you know, our own franchise agreement, I think, has another 40 years or so on it, so we'll be looking at how do we update that as well. Okay, good. So, all that's moving together, and we are having that kind of a group discussion between Mono, Inyo, and Mammoth. Good. And I still have the concern on sooner rather than later to get out of the current situation, because we're just increasing our liability. Understood. And our cleanup costs. Understood. Right. Okay, so on the plastic bag span.
58:24 If you remember, we were a week away from having our own ordinance when the state passed the statewide ban, which has now been challenged with an initiative, so it's on hold until November of 2016. Right. So that kind of puts us in a limbo. We could, because I asked Andy Morris to do this, we could go forward with what we were going to do before if the initiative passes.
58:51 It would, ours would be in place if the initiative does not pass. The statewide ban, which was less restrictive than ours, would stay in place. But we've got this until November of 2016 holding period, and I didn't know if there was any consensus to try and do something in the interim or not.
59:12 Yeah, I'd be in favor of that. I've been sort of confused about the legal ranking that's going on. I'm not sure exactly what environment we're in, but I'd love to get an update from Andy and see if there's an opportunity. Well, so what happens there, as Joe was mentioning, if we adopt something, with the initiative getting on the ballot, basically, it put on hold the state legislation. So that means we could adopt an ordinance that prohibits plastic bag debt. If the state law stays, you know, if the initiative fails,
59:40 And the state law stays on the books, then our ordinance is preempted and goes away. And the state comes in. The earth would then preempt us at that point in time. So if we wrote a local ordinance that was consistent with the state one that's in limbo, and the state one stays in place, there would be no disruption locally because it would be the same thing.
1:00:01 Right. But we could not. But if you remember, what the state passed was not as broad as what we were considering. It was watered down. So I guess it's just kind of a question of, yeah, you know, we thought we had this priority taken care of, but now it's stuck in limbo. Yeah. I mean, that's actually an interesting strategy to think about, though. I mean, if we were to, I mean.
1:00:27 My frustration is that we're basically sitting idle until November of 2016, which is a significant period of time. But like I said to you earlier, I'm a little bit torn on what's the best way to approach it because we could implement something now, which could stay in perpetuity, or we may have to kind of take it back, depending on what happens at the state. So that's an interesting strategy I didn't think of, is maybe writing something to mirror the state.
1:00:56 In the interim. And then in 2016, you know, when we get a determination there, we can either ratchet ours up or it stays the same. It goes the same. How much staff time in Austin? Well, we had the other... Well, no, if we revised what was going to be our ordinance to match what the state says, which is, like, it's less restrictive, but it's a compromise. And then if we...
1:01:22 You know, so I would assume that would be rewriting it, reintroducing the ordinance. I'm just, I'm supportive of waiting and letting the state take the lead, and I think we have a lot of other more important issues to work on, but that's just my personal opinion on it. And I'm supportive of it, but I think, you know, I'd rather, if the state's taking the lead, if it's a little delayed, it's a little delayed.
1:01:48 I'd like to see the cost, to your point about... Well, it's not going to be zero. It's mainly Andy's time in rewriting and redrafting the orders to match the state legislative structure. So you're actually providing us with a small contingency, smaller than this year, within the 15-16 budget. Yes. Can we deal with it of having it come back in July with what an option might look like and a cost at that point?
1:02:15 Because it was one of our priorities and we thought we had it taken care of. I mean, you know, it's just something personally that's kind of been weighing on me. I mean, I'm a business guy and I get all that, but I have an internal struggle with myself and I think, you know, it's our responsibility to be stewards of our environment. And, you know, this is the first one we tried to take on. I've got some meetings coming up this week.
1:02:38 You know, looking at further things that we can do in the business community to be more green, and I'll definitely have some report back on that once I have some more thoughts and information, but this to me was just step one of multiple that I intend to pursue, and I just think it's our responsibility. So what I'm kind of hearing is we still want to consider something, not within the budget, but...
1:03:05 Then bring it back with a port to us as options and things like that, and maybe we can incorporate some of the other things you're working on in a discussion of how we go forward. And I think doing it in July after the budget process. Having just picked up a whole bunch of plastic bags on Town City Day. Okay. Okay. All right. Okay, so the Gigabit community, a couple things here. One is that
1:03:35 There's certainly discussion going on this at the ESCOG and the regional level. I think the thing that we're going to start really looking at is the adoption and the integration of this opportunity into the community on a very kind of bite, bite, bite kind of basis. And there's going to be a need for, I've talked with Craig a little bit on the chamber about helping out. There's some capacity with the broadband consortium that that can help out.
1:04:04 They're working on some deliverables. So I think we're sort of okay for the moment, but I think we're going to need, we're going to be getting into some stuff. Things are moving well, and there's good conversations going on, but we'll have to see how this kind of plays out. But it's moving in the right direction for the moment, from my perspective. Yeah, I agree. And this is, I'm going to put the chamber in ESC or ABC on this thing. Okay, plate removal, did we talk about that? We kind of touched it.
1:04:37 On the other one, so. They're working on it. I'm just looking at the time. Yeah, we're working on it. So that's in progress? Yeah. So we're going to speed up your dance. So div, we know we've got an update on it tonight, and we've got consideration of it at the next meeting. And customer service. Chamber's working on that. Yeah. And Saracosa is now doing workshops. Yeah. Like, you know, how to fill out an employment application, write a resume, that kind of stuff. Not wear sweatpants to an interview.
1:05:06 Yeah. And they actually have a customer service as one of the modules in their program. Right. You heard that. And then the last one in terms of the single family residential rental issue that's coming to you quickly. Actually, there is one thing I wanted to say on that. I was going to bring it up later tonight, but since we're talking about the budget.
1:05:31 Is, as we've discussed it, and we've seen the list a couple of times, we've said we wanted the quality of life ordinance regardless, and we wanted it sooner rather than later. So is there consensus that that's a high priority to get that piece done, you know, within the work plan that Community and Economic Development has? Quick update, Sandra provided to me today, was ideas if we should have one ready to go to June 10th, the Planning Commission for review.
1:05:59 And then it would come back on the 15th to Council. The question there, do you want to do a workshop through it or just bring it forward as an introduction? Would be kind of the question on, do you want to work it through before you actually introduce it or do you want it?
1:06:15 The first three pieces of this. I am too, but the one, you know, it sounded like, oh yeah, it was going to be easy to do the quality of life when we looked at a sample last fall, and then we've heard nothing, so I was just trying to figure out where it stands. I think bring it through as introduction. Just bring it as introduction. I'd say bring it as introduction, but at the same night as the budget? Well, this notice will be July 15th.
1:06:34 Oh, July 15th. Yeah, June 10th for planning commission, July 15th for council. Well, is it possible based on whatever else is established to do a workshop that evening and then the introduction later, that same agenda? Sure. It works, I think. It might only have to be a half hour workshop. Sure. So in terms of the work plan, the quality of life thing would come first and then data and enforcement tier from that? Well, because they're going to take longer to get accomplished. We were told the ordinance was going to be easy. Right, it's simpler.
1:07:04 Five, six months ago. So I'm saying, let's do that. In terms of bringing the pieces where we're not putting the pieces out. Well, that will discuss when we get to the agenda item tonight. I just wanted to say, is it a priority to say within the budgeted work plan for planning and economic development department that...
1:07:25 It's a high priority. I think, you know, I think the quality of life ordinance should precede the enforcement, because that should kind of tier from that. As far as the reliable data, I mean, I think that can kind of work in conjunction. All those things should be packaged up before we would move on to another step. That's my question. I think the quality of life thing sort of sets a vision for what we're trying to do. Sure, I think that should be first in. But I think regardless of what happened, we wanted that quality of life stuff, so. Correct, yeah.
1:07:53 Yeah, I'm supportive of that. And it's not that they haven't had plenty to do, but just to make it a priority to finish it up. Because I know they have more than enough to do. Sounds like it's coming, though. All right, so then, with all of that, Dan, then we talk numbers and stuff? Yes. We made it back and forth, but we want to go ahead and give you some detail. And if you hold on to this, we may need to use it again as we come into June 3rd.
1:08:20 We'll point to the pieces that I think it helps answer some of the questions in the staff report that I've received, so I think it helps walk through that element of it. I'm going to give you a real brief overview just in terms of the challenge for the town in terms of looking at the financial structure. First part of these, we generally...
1:08:43 Put most of the focus on the general fund, frankly, because that's where the biggest challenge comes in in balancing and services the rest of the departments and even some of the other funds. So bottom line is we've worked through this, and it's been kind of a creative process to get to where we're at, but a $131,000 budget gap or a current deficit. For 15-16. For 15-16, correct. Thank you.
1:09:06 A lot of that came out of we projected a larger one to start with. Cindy's done some additional work and analysis looking at our vehicle replacement program. We've gone back and looked at fuel consumption. Now the last four years with the drought, it's been low, and even one big drought year we looked at. Going through some other elements of that level of detail, going what truly are these numbers. So we really tightened a lot of that up in terms, and that's helped us quite a bit. There was a couple hundred thousand dollars in those areas and a little better.
1:09:35 Some of the staffing elements, as you're aware, each time we have a staff vacancy, we kind of work through that and say, can we do this differently? How do we make it work more effectively for meeting our service demands? So there's been savings from that area. We did a couple of, or one major prepayment this year, about $88,000. We brought that to the council a while back for a workers' comp retrospective payment.
1:10:01 So that reduced our cost next year by making that payment this year. So there's been a few things that way that have really helped us narrow down the budget deficit versus bringing you a much larger number, frankly, to work through. And so there's a lot of different components to that. Obviously, I won't walk through those in detail. But as you hit the staff report, if you go to kind of the page two, we kind of lay out what I would call the core assumptions. There's 11 of them listed here.
1:10:30 Part of that is just a confirmation from Council that all of these are still in place. They are currently reflected in the budget. And so mentioned earlier maintaining the REU at or above the $3 million level. Yeah, I'm sorry to interrupt. Just in terms of following along, is this the same stuff that's in our package? Yeah, this is new stuff. What I just gave you? It's new.
1:10:51 Okay, if you just help us make sure when you're referring to the same page numbers. Yes, I will. Yeah, yeah. No, John, I think, yeah. The summary sheets from the individual department. I think we still want to focus on the staff report. So we're on page two of the staff report. Yeah, this is just further detail. Where we've got the assumptions and, yeah. Because, no, there's no way we're going to, I think we need to focus here and look at the numbers. There's a couple pieces in here just from comparison. Sure. So the, I don't want to spend a ton of time walking through all 11 of these.
1:11:20 I'm assuming you've had a chance to look at it. But these are kind of the core assumptions or political directions that help us put the budget together. We're not going to use reserves. We know we have to pay a $400,000 loan back to our vehicle fund. We have certain things negotiated with employees that we need to fund. You have this grouping in here of our...
1:11:46 Political commitments that have kind of been ongoing and being made with the TOT commitment to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the transit, the housing, and those are left at last year's levels through that process. And then the ongoing commitment with road rehab, and we've left those. So those are kind of key areas there. If there's changes in that or if you want to put more dollars in those areas, again, that impacts the budget overall.
1:12:13 But I guess what I'm literally looking for is kind of that one through four is kind of council policy direction financially. Eight through 11 really are those council political commitments that we work through. And the middle ones really are the negotiated costs that, you know, those are part of our budget process. We need to deal with our employees and keeping them whole in terms of what we've committed to in negotiations.
1:12:38 Kind of that grouping in there. So I guess my question would be just to the council, if there's issues in here you want us to any other detail on, if there's other issues here. These focus on the general fund share. For example, if you look at measures R and U, there's a commitment we have to MLR. There's other places in the budget where there's other commitments. But this really drives the discussion in the general fund, again, where we're looking at that budget gap at this point. My only thought is that
1:13:07 In the documentation, if you could find a way to standardize references that have to do with payments for the settlement. So in other words, less 215.562 for MLT, I'm assuming that's for the settlement. Right, and I was going to say, for both 8 and 9, those were in order to help pay the $2 million a year. So for tracking purposes throughout these documents, if there's...
1:13:31 If it's in there, say what it is, so the public knows what it is. It's also important to note with housing, there was a reduction as well. Right, there was housing, and the road rehab is a reduction as well. So across the board, just as clear with it, so the community can understand. We're writing a check for $2 million. What did road rehab used to be? If I remember correctly, it was around $750. But based on their pavement analysis, it should be a million. Right.
1:14:01 And so we're half of where we should be. Okay. Dan? And we're really working through our whole road management program. That's one of the changes we've made is taking our guys off of a paving crew and putting them into maintenance work. And if we pave, we contract out. And we're really trying to, Grady's got an assignment to kind of work through that program and he's, find some time on the weekend to knock it out. But I think it's valid that ultimately we don't want to have our roads deteriorate because it costs a whole lot more to rebuild and it does to maintain them. Dan,
1:14:31 Just for clarity on this, I'm looking on the page that I was just handed, the $500,000 in TOT enforcement revenue has been taken out of the budget, correct? Yeah, it's part of, well, it's really rolled into that 11.6. In the past where we've had the $500,000 in there, it's really been part of the total number, so we're not counting on additional revenue, some enforcement over and above the 11.6.
1:14:57 The other side of that was some challenge in calculation. We would find somebody who wasn't paying TOT, go out, they start paying it. We would take their calculation-wise, every month they paid, we assumed that was from the enforcement, and the question was, how long do we leave that on the books as enforcement versus they're just part of the base now. What we're doing going forward, we're actually breaking out enforcement from legal activity out there, and we're just getting people to pay correctly or they've missed a payment.
1:15:28 The other one, it will be enforcement from illegal activity. What are those revenues coming in? So we can track that much cleaner to give you a feel for actually what we're doing there. But also I think to say there's a half a million sitting there every year coming in has probably been overstated. I guess my concern is I just don't, you know, I prefer not to see the illegal money counted on and somehow to put that to a different fund and whatever you collect is.
1:15:56 Senator RU, I mean, but to sit there and rely on that to balance our budget, I don't disagree with. And right now the projection that we've built, I would say doesn't necessarily, we haven't identified any illegal type revenue that would go into the budget. To the extent it's in that overall picture, this last year we didn't have a lot of illegal activity collections, I don't think.
1:16:21 But we still had an overall increase in TO2. So in other words, I think if I understand what you're saying is, you know, enforcement will be still tracking what they've accomplished, but we're not necessarily saying there's a half a million a year in illegal that's going to come in. Correct. It's just overall we're going to be at 11-6. Right. So I'm just saying that, you know, whatever illegal money we capture, it should go somewhere else. It shouldn't be.
1:16:47 Count it on to balance the squadron. We will track that. When we have our new financial system, it'll be able to do that, right? We've created it. A little bit more clarification on what you're asking for only because... Oh, sorry. Are you not wanting the illegal activity taken into consideration for the dollars that MLT housing transit gets as far as TOT? I don't want it. Yeah, I mean, I don't think that we should put it in the budget at all.
1:17:17 For illegal monies that we're counting on to collect. Well, not budgetary revenue, but if a dollar comes in and X amount of it goes, those pluses, you're saying they would not get that? No, that's not what I'm saying. I'm saying that I don't want it in the actual to pay our bills. I don't want it in the actual expense side. On the income side, that's going to go to expense. So if you collect...
1:17:40 $100,000, then it should go where it needs to go, but it shouldn't be that we need $100,000. Yeah, so you're wanting it to come in through a different door.
1:17:48 Right. I understand what you're saying. This budget wasn't developed with anticipating the illegal rentals necessarily coming in. Enforcement is part of it. This last year, what our TOT people have really focused on is making sure that the month-to-month remitters are remitting each and every month. They're just finally staffed up to have a normal staff and can actually put somebody on and focusing more on illegal activity.
1:18:16 Getting people that are even legally zoned and not remitting. Right. So they're finally staffed up. She's got a great staff and doing that. But this last year, they didn't focus on that. It was really focusing on making sure that every single remitter remitted every single month. We did a lot of cleanup on the process. So what I hear you're saying is when we started this out, the idea of the way we funded an enforcement unit was saying they're going to bring in this extra money.
1:18:45 The enforcement unit is working on both legal and illegal, the amounts going up, and we're not necessarily counting on illegal to balance our budget. Correct. So then can we have that come back as a report when we're closing out the year for consideration of whether or not Michael says is if we bring in the stuff off of the illegals, do we make the same distribution, but do we as a council put our part into the REU?
1:19:12 Or, you know, if you still want to make the same distribution, we can do that if you want to make that decision at the time. Because I kind of like that idea. Yeah. I appreciate calling it out. Right. Right. Absolutely. And my other just, you know, couple little comments real quick. You know, I mean, I'm just kind of four years of drought. I'm just kind of a little bit like time to pull the fire alarm or we should have probably already pulled it.
1:19:42 I hope that we have an El Nino and we have a ton of snow and all this stuff, but are we, you know, have we really challenged every single department to find, you know, any savings we could possibly find so we don't get ourselves where we're short? And, I mean, I just want to make sure that we're really thinking of this new norm that we've been, you know, going through. And if it turns, then great, we'll have a bunch of money that we can put in RRU.
1:20:12 And I think now is the time to do it. Being proactive and not reactive.
1:20:40 I'm assuming, Dan, in my conversations with you that when we talk about various enterprises we want to do that there is no structural issue out there. It's kind of your point, Michael, that I'm assuming in a naive way perhaps that if this new normal continued
1:21:04 For the next, you know, it's not a good thing, but there's nothing budget-wise that's lurking out there that's going to bite us, and that if there are those things, you're letting us know about it. I want to ask the obvious question. Is there anything out there that's going to come and bite us? Well, one thing, I mean, like the $2 million payment every year doesn't go down. Understood. Right? So snow may be going down. Buy one. Right. I'm counting on that $2 million a year. That's coming off the top. So I just want to make sure that we're... It's a royalty payment. Yeah. I just want to make sure that we are...
1:21:34 You know, getting, you know, really looking at this as, leading it out as tight as we can, I think is really important. Yeah, and I think that's where, I believe that's been happening, and when we actually closed this year, because mid-year adjustments were made, when it didn't snow, obviously, that I think it's our responsibility then when we find out what the 6-30-2015.
1:22:03 Budget amount is, is that we seriously consider that most of that goes into our year. Right. I would agree. It's the only way we're going to get our credit rating anywhere. Right. And we should end up with the savings this year based on the amount that we didn't spend in the snow side, the fuel and work. Is that counting for April and May drop? We'll make sure that the TOT is the other piece of that. We're still down at that 11, 3, 11. So we'll know that in the fall. Well, we know what the closing year.
1:22:33 The figures are in the fall, it gives us an opportunity to do some stuff then. And so we'll walk through that. I think if you're asking the question, if I'm hearing it correctly, is going back and looking at it and going, we've had a lot of discussion, is that 11-6 number for TOT Realistic? And the fact that we should be real close to that this year, I mean, we're going to be under it, maybe 11-3, give or take. But for two snowstorms, we'd probably be over. I don't want to count on that.
1:23:02 That is, I think it's realistic, but it's, you know, we're counting that we will have some good snow. Right, but if we hit year five of this drought, all bets are off, right? Yeah, I mean, I think. So I think we have to make it realistic. I think if you cut too deep right now, we get in, we're laying people off, we're doing, you know, and then nothing happens, I think that's a disingenuous to the organization, to the community, because that's a service level reduction that, well, you didn't have to do that, why did you do that? I'd rather.
1:23:30 Keep things very tight and be realistic as we look forward. But I don't think we need to, you know, diminish our capabilities as an organization today, given everything that we're looking at and seeing. So I want to be careful that we don't overreact early on because the impact of that is very hard to come back from. I just, yeah, and I agree, Dan. I just think on all of our things here, I mean, we need to... Tight.
1:23:56 We need to keep the door open and our options open and not just, you know, keep counting on, you know, that snow coming that hasn't been coming. So I just want to keep all this stuff on the table and I just want to make sure that we are being as lean as we can possibly be. And if we come out, you know, a thousand inches of snow next winter, then great. And we have a town full of people. A thousand, a thousand would help us.
1:24:26 Help us water-wise. You know, I think it's, we just need to be realistic. Yeah, and what we, the departments this year, too, was asking, what do you realistically need without making, you know, everything gone, and so we'll take that other round through that and look at those areas. Right. And it may be some stuff, and I'll pick on road rehab for a minute. We have $5,000 or $90,000 in there. We have, I think we'll end up some savings this year there. If we roll that in there, okay.
1:24:54 We're holding that, and we may not do some of that work until next spring, but if you have a bad snow year, there may be, you know, $50,000, $90,000 in there that, okay, that can offset. The question becomes, ultimately, does that become a $500,000 commitment, not a $590,000 commitment? Does our other, do we go back in our loan repayment to our vehicle fund and say, that's a 10-year payoff?
1:25:19 Does that become a 15-year payoff and do we reduce that down so we can manage it over time? Do we look at our, we look at frankly we do that with our staffing structure already when we have vacancies. We're really trying to look at how do we save and we've done some of that this year. What I would hate to do is get too deep day one here and go we're going to diminish our ability to provide the current level of service that we're providing today.
1:25:44 I think that when we get together this summer and start talking strategies and stuff like that, I think we need to bring this budgeting process within that discussion. Because I think that, you know, we're doing a bunch of things and partnering and figuring out how to expand our capacity.
1:26:03 We're still sitting here talking about betting on snow or not betting on snow, and I think let's bring this into that conversation and figure out more strategically what things we've got to focus on with the budget so we can really do some strategic stuff with it. I think that's the general point. I mean, that was what I was going to say, which seems very similar to what I've already heard, that I think we just need to make sure that we're not moving forward with a structural deficit, that we're trying to fix every year by hoping that we have snow.
1:26:28 So, you know, we need to be able to, I don't have any problem with any of the 11 items there. I think that all makes sense to me. And we're close. You know, we're 100 grand away as far as the gap goes. But, you know, we need to, these last few years have given us a good understanding of what our revenues are going to look like in a light snow year. And I think that's how we need to budget. We need to be able to offer the level of service at $19 million.
1:26:55 And if we have a great year and a bunch of TOT, we'll find a place to spend it. But it's not going to be on a long-term encumbrance. It needs to be, you know, we need to be able to balance our budget and run our organization at this level. Right. From the preliminary discussion we had with the council, that was kind of the direction, too, is how do we tighten that up? And when you see some of the shifts and changes, and that was kind of the detail sheet that Cindy handed out this front page, you know, are we took a look like franchise fees. They're up $30,000 over last year, and that's based on actual collections.
1:27:25 During a down year in managing that out. So we think those are solid numbers. We've seen our property tax bump up based on actual collections again and what we're seeing for valuations happening, those types of things. So we're not over projecting these things on what we hope XYZ happens in a lot of these areas. Again, the logical one, the most difficult one is the TOT number because of that December, January, February.
1:27:54 I think we should know in advance what we're going to do with that.
1:28:24 You know, where are we going to, what are we going to do with those dollars? Are we going to put it towards bonds? Again, it just goes back to. It doesn't do us a lot of good to spend time talking about something until it actually happens. It just goes back to. I think you can be a little proactive about it. It just goes back to, you know, we run businesses in the real world and we need to keep our options open and that includes all this stuff. Sure. And I want the flexibility to not say that yes, yes, yes, fixed, fixed. I mean, we need to keep our options open.
1:28:52 And our flexibility open and just make sure that we are being as lean as we can and being fiscally responsible as we can and being smart about this. Sure. But if we can keep our options open. I think that's why it's important that we plan very conservatively because, you know, in the private sector, we run a low, medium, high. If it doesn't snow in December, we have the ability to be flexible and cut staff hours, cut employees, dump expenses that, frankly, we don't have that ability to be that nimble.
1:29:22 You know, in this case, so, you know, we start with the low, and that's where we're budgeting. And we did that this year. We came in at that midyear and said, hey, we need to cut, you know, four or five hundred thousand dollars out of the budget. We did that, and then we got snow, and so we were able to respond and react, I think, in that. And some of that is doing that early projection in that process, too, and we'll continue to do that if it looks, I mean. And giving credit where credit is due, I think.
1:29:49 You guys did a very good job with that this year. We saw the writing on the wall and we made the adjustments and we're coming towards the end of this year and looking like those adjustments made a big difference. I think we just need to plan for next year on the low level. We don't have a mid and a high. We can't be that nimble where we can see something and make a change in 30 days. I think in here are a couple of the highlights here.
1:30:15 As we walk through some of these, and that was kind of some of the detail, you'll see some of those shifts and changes from the departmental areas where we've had savings and being able to, and a lot of the savings we're having here, for example, in some of the staff positions, those are going to be ongoing. We took the senior engineering position, which was a decently paid position, and rolled that into an engineering assistant position. And a lot of the engineering position,
1:30:42 Engineering Assistant position is sitting over in restricted revenue. So we're able to move stuff around that way. So we end up with a $50,000 to $70,000 savings by moving those staff elements around. And we're doing that so we don't end up in this structural element of going our fixed costs or out running our revenues. And that's where we're back to with, you know, down to $131,000 deficit is, I think, actually, I was very surprised and pleased we're able to move that far down.
1:31:11 I think going through budgets, as Michael mentioned, walk back through those. We can trim stuff back out. We ask staff to be realistic but not already aggressive. There's no new full-time positions in this budget. We've modified a couple part-time hours around to meet workloads. If some of that has to get trimmed back, we'll do that. Maybe we lose one person on a snow removal crew. That's a service impact, but are we willing to do those things?
1:31:40 We come back in on that. The goal would be can we balance $131,000 obviously without using any reserves. One of the options, again, you're playing a little risk with this, but you come back and say we had $25,000 in contingency. Do we cut that out? And if we have money left over at the end of the year, we back to our contingency. Otherwise, we go into a year, truly, you don't have a contingency to play with. You're dealing with whatever your REU is above the $3 million.
1:32:10 But there's those types of things. If we can balance it without doing that, that would be preferred. But again, I also don't want to really go out and cut hardcore services to our community. I don't think we're at that point. Do you feel like we can skim another $100,000 without impacting service levels? I think I'm hearing that, right? The full $131,000 I don't know yet, but we will get very close. Again, I'm waiting.
1:32:40 The departments have gotten that challenge to say cut those budgets back. I've done a review of that again. And that would come back and give you an update, you know, in June 3rd going here's where we're at on a deficit. Here's how we've gotten to it. Here's maybe two or three options depending on how you want to see us. I'd rather not have a deficit budget going into July 1, frankly. I'd like to see it balanced. I think that's a...
1:33:06 That helps us in a financial market. That helps us in operation. We're going to trust the staff to be creative enough to figure out, to give us options on how to balance it, right? Yeah. And, you know, Michael, this is something that you and I have a longer experience with, but, you know, there wasn't just the downsides in the organization, which is actually happening every year I've been on this council, but we're actually getting to the point of we're resizing everything to the appropriate size. Right. And I think that that's one of the things that helped us this year, you know, that when positions have been big.
1:33:36 So I think that Dan's definitely following that direction, and that's part of being the 21st century is we know things are going to be done differently. You don't need to resize your positions and things like that. Yeah, and I want to follow up on that because I think that the transition we're making culturally as an organization with our reliance on NGOs, MLT, MLR housing, to provide services that are critical to the economic success of the community.
1:34:04 That if we get into situations where the town as an organization that if we have to make cuts or do the things that have to get done, we're looking at the larger delivery of this place as a destination and making sure that to the degree that we can that that is going to stay in place. That's going to stay, you know, if we've got to make cuts internally so that the quality of life and the visitor services, we're not going to be compromising that stuff. We can keep our amenities moving forward, our marketing.
1:34:32 You know, all those things that we're doing to make this place compelling, but to look at it, again, from that kind of synergistic, strategic perspective that we can know what we can deliver and what we can do. Again, I mean, I think it just goes back to we need to leave our options open and have flexibility. Oh, sure, yeah, I'm not disagreeing with that at all. And we can do that. I mean, you know, our cost elements are driven somewhat by our staffing structure, you know, which is normal in a government organization. That's not unique.
1:34:57 And also some of those key deliverables in terms of the biggest one, obviously, on the public work side dies in, can we, if we have a good snow year, can we keep the streets open? Those types of elements. There's a lot of other, we don't control, well, yeah, a lot of costs we don't control. I mean, July 1, we pay $2 million for a settlement payment. We will pay $790,000 for insurance, so that's right off the top, day one. There's a couple other things like that that, you know, it's our retirement costs we talk about, that's set by state.
1:35:27 There's certain things that we don't have a lot of control over. We have a control over how we provide services, how we staff for that, how we work in that category. And I think, to Michael's comment on that, if we can stay flexible in terms of our revenue and continue to review it on a more regular basis as we go through this and be quick, if we think we have a problem, find ways to address it, be creative in that process. Staff has done a lot of small things this year. I mean, when we had a revenue specialist hire, we went to the county and said,
1:35:57 Workforce Development Funds to pay this person's salary for part of the year. They said yes. So I think we ended up with $14,000 that will come in to reimburse some of our costs. We asked for the, we hired a new one. We made the same question and then we got the feedback on, well, this really isn't designed for governmental agencies. So then they told us no, but the first one was approved. So we want to be looking for those types of things and looking at how we can be created in that area.
1:36:24 So Dan, when will you have the numbers for April and May so we really know where the TOT is going to be and where are the true short? The cutoff is today for getting everybody turning in for April. Right. For a month away. So when we consider the budget, which is on the second meeting, we will have the numbers. Yeah, you will have the April. We won't have all of May yet. We won't have May yet because it will be the 20th of the fall. Because I have a feeling that 100,000 may be a little bit more.
1:36:51 Or we're hitting this year at. The question is, you know, are we comfortable with that 11-6 number going into next year's budget will be the key element. Do you need direction on that right now? Are we comfortable with the 11-6? That's the question, I guess. I mean, if you're not, yeah, I'm comfortable with it at this point from making that recommendation.
1:37:12 I think we will still have, you know, we build it that way, but then we have the chance on the second meeting in June to say, now that we've also got the additional things, are we still comfortable with it, and then what's our gap? Okay. Yeah, I want to, I mean, I'm not comfortable, I want to see, I want to see the end result here. Yeah. We're pretty close to it of where we go. Yeah, we'll have through April, because May won't be until after late June. Can we get an indicator on, can we get an indicator on May? Bad.
1:37:40 Well, it's, I mean, it's not a big month anyway for us. I mean, it's one of the smallest months of the year in our projections. Yeah, but see, the problem is May isn't even, they don't even have to file until the 20th. Today's the 17th. Today's the final due date. And if they're paying online and they pay it today, we won't actually see the dollars for another four to five days. There's a lag just in that timeline. But what you're saying is understood and we'll have, you know, we'll have to discuss, you know, what level of surety we have with whatever figures we've got.
1:38:09 Yeah, I'm just looking at the time in order to give us a little bit of a break for the other meeting. I do have one other item I do want to. Okay. This really deals with Fund 858, which is our Fractional Miller Reef Fund. This is on page 9 of the staff report. And what we've seen there, this here actually is utilized to fund certain projects.
1:38:33 Based on the timing when the fund was created. The multi-use facility is one of the key elements here, as is some of our other maintenance level for some of the park stuff. Which one are we talking about? It's page nine. Yeah. It's fractional Mela Roost. It's fund 858. Let me explain a little bit about that fund. Okay, I found it. So that fund can only, from the time of the inception of that fund, it can only pay for increased level of
1:39:02 So the general fund loaned this fund money knowing that it would grow over time. So at this point in time we have a
1:39:31 There's a loan amount that's due back to the general fund from this fund of $648,000. And I think that's where Dan's going to try to seek some information. But I wanted to give you a little bit about the history of the fund, how it was developed, and how it's progressed over time. So currently it's paying for the increased level of service for parks and maintenance, not a person, because...
1:39:54 We are not, we don't have an additional person from that time, but they can pay for what they're working on, the new facilities that have been put in place since that time. So that's the parks maintenance side, and then the facility that it is covering is the ice rink roller rink facility. And so with this one, what we've looked at in the past, right now we've actually seen the growth in Melrose funds coming into the town. And so...
1:40:23 In looking at the current year budget based on the revenues received to date for this current year and next year and some of the reductions and shifting some of the costs there, we're within $3,000 basically of having this particular fund balanced. So in the past we have put some of the neighborhood of $30,000 to $40,000. It's been as high as $70,000 and I think as low as $22,000 from the general fund going in here to help make the operational component work.
1:40:52 We have also allocated $20,000 from R&U, $10,000 from each, in terms of the operations for the multi-use facility. This year, for example, because of the increased tax revenue, we can reduce those down, but there's no dollars left to make any type of a debt service payment back to the general fund. If you left operationally and you said we've committed R&U money to operations, we're going to continue to do that,
1:41:22 We want to continue to have a general fund piece go in there. Really what you're doing at that point in one sense is freeing up tax revenue to make a payment on the debt. You can say it's the same dollars back and forth. But that would be a way to start to have dollars, if you will, flow back to the general fund that's owed. And again, if you did that, I would take those dollars and say you should restrict those probably to capital or to one-time expenditures to not rely on those revenues. Your other option on that debt obviously is
1:41:52 You could take this year's budget and fix it and say as that revenue grows, we want to commit that to repay the debt. You could frankly, you could have us do up, it would be a resolution coming back, you could waive the debt and say we're not going to worry about trying to collect it, we just want to fully fund our operations going forward. So there's some options in there. But that affects the bond.
1:42:13 Rating is not a good idea. When you waive debt, it should be not a good thank you. I'm thinking, especially at this point, that's a really complicated question. It's going to be affected by how the multi-use facility...
1:42:25 Where it goes and how it's funded and all of that. I'd rather say let's incorporate it in that discussion rather than try to make an ad hoc quick decision here. Yeah. I don't have to have a final direction. Because most of the time when that general fund went in there was in prior years that have all been balanced out and all of that. And I understand what it's saying, but I think we need to look at it as what we're doing with that whole. Yeah. And I think there's a context thing that's. But the debt has to get paid. I mean, the days of the town being on the hook for.
1:42:53 These debts and... Yeah, but you remember, were you on council when we wrote off the general fund paid to the airport over the years? You know, we wrote off a huge debt. Right, we did that one, some of that recently, too. Well, I think, yeah. But before we start writing off our debts, I think we need to look at it in a greater context. And we're not recommending that you write off the debt that's an option sitting there.
1:43:12 We need to make sure you're aware of, but I frankly probably wouldn't recommend that. But the way I read what you put here is it all relates to what that money is spent on, is spent on in the future, etc., and we don't have those answers yet. Correct. It is restricted to what it can be used for, and you can't, you know, for example, we could use it for police officers once we get back to the same level that we were when the fund started.
1:43:37 You can't use it to backfill back up to where you were at. Understood. Is this debt an internal debt? This is all an internal thing that we're talking about? In the good years, John, a lot of money went from general fund to support all kinds of things. Sure. And most of it, like with the airport, we've ended up having to write out. I'm not saying we have to do that here, but it's a complicated decision. Yeah, understood. I appreciate it. The airport was done. You have no revenue coming off the airport to pay it back? Right.
1:44:05 You have the potential here for a revenue stream to actually. Right. And then what would be nice to have would be let's actually create a debt schedule and a payment schedule versus saying, well, maybe if and win in the future. Right. And I'm assuming, my understanding is a lot of these internal debts have been cleaned up. Yes. So that we're not, you know, the previous way of doing business, we're not doing things like that anymore. Operationally, I think this is the only one that's left. And then we have debt in the diff side of the house. Right. Understood.
1:44:35 Very much appreciate you guys doing the work to get that stuff. It was an interesting way of doing business, but it's good to know we're going on to a different one. And some of the internal stuff, if it makes sense to utilize that as financing, it works very effectively, but you should have...
1:44:47 Thank you. Right now the budget is built using all the money and frankly at this point we'd be drawing down just under $3,000 from Measure R.
1:45:17 Right. To actually balance that budget. So it is balanced. And there's currently no general fund contribution to this fund for next year at this time. Okay. So we're at the point where we have finished a workshop and you're going to take that information and the main focus of the second meeting in June, which is, I can't count on my head fast enough, 20th? Yeah, we will.
1:45:43 17th. We'll come back on the 3rd if there's any changes like on the revenue projections. It'd be a real short agenda item. But the 2nd meeting we would actually have a proposed budget to be adopted. So you will, we confirmed the 11 items. We added some other things that we wanted either in or out of the budget or when to discuss them. And we're expecting to see April figures and if there's anything from March.
1:46:12 May, sorry, I'm going backwards. We'll get March, April, but we'll have it. Yeah, okay. And then our goal would be is to bring you a balanced budget or a set of options to balance it. 4, 15, 16. Yes. Right. And also with the goal of having a budget in place before July 1. Absolutely. Is there anything else on policy direction you needed or break time? I think we, you got the policy direction you needed, right? Yeah, I think that. Okay.
1:46:40 And just before we go, is there a date yet that we've talked about for our getting together to revisit these strategic things and priorities? I'm looking at that, and I'll say the August-September time frame, I haven't tried to work through a calendar yet, but we'll get some information out and actually bring that as an item as a group to set a date that works. Okay. Okay. Some structure to it at that point. Yeah, that's going to be very important. Thank you. Thank you all. All right. Thank you very much.
1:47:11 Excuse me, we're going to call to order the Town Council meeting for May 20th. We will begin with roll call, Jamie. Thank you. Here. We have some quiet, please. Councilmember Whitworth? Here. Here. Here. I forgot to ask anybody to leave the pledge, so why don't we as a group do it? Good. Sounds great.
1:50:07 Yes, get us started, John. One, two, three. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I'll tell you we're the band leader. Okay, we have our official band leader, yeah. Give him a metronome. He's never a drummer.
1:50:36 That will move us into public comments that are on items that are not on this evening's agenda. So if anyone has a public comment, you can come forward to the podium at this point. Okay, since I see no one coming forward, we will just notice that we had a correspondence regarding issues on his property located on Waterford, and I believe staff is working to resolve that. Okay.
1:51:06 That moves us to Councilmember reports. Can we start with you, Joe? Yes, Madam Mayor. There's been some follow-up conversations from the Synergy Summit, and that's going well. A lot of interesting things are coming out of that. I'm working with Councilmember Fernie on that. I attended the – there was a Mammoth Trails meeting where some staff of the Forest Service came up to talk about.
1:51:30 The TAPF process, which has important implications for a road system. I attended the, with the Planning and Economic Development Commission, a workshop on Digital 395 with attendees from the Eastern Sierra Connect Regional Broadband Consortium, Aino County, Mono County, and Praxis. Very interesting meeting. The Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative is having conversations with the Forest Service about the forest plan update, which should be useful going forward.
1:51:59 I attended a meeting with Caltrans to get me indoctrinated into the world of Caltrans. It was very interesting. And then that's about it. There's a Mono County Strategic Planning Effort happening on Friday at 8 o'clock in Lee Vining that should be interesting. And Congressman Cook's going to be in town this weekend on Sunday. And I believe the open house is 4.30 to 6 at the Rockin' Bowl, correct? At the Passerie upstairs at the Rockin' Bowl. So that does it for me.
1:52:31 Thank you. Just a couple things. I also attended the Joint Town Council Planning Commission joint meeting on Digital 395. I thought that was super productive and, you know, looking forward to what could potentially come out of that as far as opportunities. This past Friday the 15th I attended an ESTA board meeting. I already alluded to this earlier, but we were asked to
1:52:57 Take a look at the service schedule for the next six months. We are proposing increases to event funding, trolley service, which I think will be much needed. Also looking at additional funding for expansion of service for the lake space in the summer, which definitely is well deserved as well. The one thing that we are going to come back for budget discussions to discuss is to look at a late night trolley option for the summer. Currently nothing is proposed after 10 p.m.
1:53:26 And I'd like to take a look at some things about at least getting a single trolley 30-minute frequency at later hours during the summer with all the visitation and events. This Tuesday I went to the Chamber Power Lunch at Chart House. Christy Osborne from Mammoth Lakes Tourism is the first approved consultant in town by the SBDC. So anybody that has interest in getting business consulting,
1:53:56 It's free to the business owner. Her services are paid for by the SBDC in a grant program. And there's going to be other people that have put in applications that are going to be coming online so you can get a variety of advice from accounting to legal advice, online marketing, et cetera, et cetera. So I think that's a pretty exciting thing for the community that businesses should take advantage of.
1:54:21 I've got a couple of meetings tomorrow. The first is Airport Land Use Commission. That was continued from before. And then also, one of the things I also alluded to earlier, one of the things that's kind of weighing on me that we're getting close to a year in our first term on council is
1:54:42 You know, really looking at things that we can be doing as a community to be good stewards of our environment and to help get the business community on board with some green business practices. So I'm having some meetings with some people this week to kind of develop a plan for that, and I'll have more information to bring back on that. That's it. Thanks. Just a couple things. I'll be attending our monthly air group meeting tomorrow, also attending the air meeting with Councilmember Ferney.
1:55:11 MLT, just a reminder, we have our open house next Wednesday, 9.30 to noon at the Westin. Going to go over ROI study, the effectiveness of the study, our summer campaign launch. There's free parking at the Westin, so everyone come out. A lot of good information. And that's, again, next Wednesday, 9.30 to noon. That's all I have. Okay.
1:55:38 I think we had a great town cleanup day. I'm sure Stuart will be giving us the exact figures a little bit later, but I wanted to thank Shireen Sanders and all the staff who supported her in doing a great weekend. One of the reasons I could say it was successful is I heard from one of our little Husky Club participants that the earth is very happy because we did this cleanup. Well, good. Good. Good to know. And thanks to...
1:56:08 The Old Mammoth Road Restaurant Association, and I know I got the name wrong, for the little party that they put together and had some great things there at Rafters. We have no additions to the agenda, so we'll move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Don't everybody jump up at once. Perfect. Thank you, Madam Mayor. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Yes, I will provide the...
1:56:44 Council and community with a little update. Madam Mayor kind of provided a little thank you list, which is terrific, and I think, and I certainly want to thank everybody for coming out. It was looking a little bit dubious on Friday. Saturday turned out great, and thankfully it was Saturday, not Sunday. But yeah, so here's some statistics. So we collected 30.36 tonnes of green waste, and a lot of that green waste was actually getting transported up to Lee Vining for a Caltrans project, which was great.
1:57:14 Great recycling effort. Just under 5 tonnes of e-waste was collected. Just under 25 tonnes of bulky trash was collected for a total of 53.3 tonnes, which is approximately about the same as last year. So great effort from the community. In addition, we picked up 120 yards of metal items. So there you go. Mayor Bacon thanked a lot of the folks. We also want to thank the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors, Disabled Support Season Sierra.
1:57:41 The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Four of those guys came along and saved Manzanita Station, so I want to thank those personally. They did a fantastic job. All our Mammoth Neighbourhood groups, Mammoth Disposal, Transfer Station, Sierra Conservation Project. We also want to thank the county for waiving those tipping fees, which is a big deal. That's a very expensive undertaking, so thank you for them.
1:58:04 We also want to thank the Fire District for actually coming down to the transfer station and shipping a lot of the limbs as well. We also want to thank the Mamm Times and the Sheet for helping out. Chamber of Commerce is another thank you. The Ski Area for donating the use of Manzanita and the high school as well, the school district. So as you can see, it's a large undertaking, so great effort. Certainly want to thank everybody for contributing. And yes, kudos to Shireen Sanders for making it a great, successful event for her first one.
1:58:33 Also, I just wanted to advise Council and the community that we started and commenced our fish docking program yesterday in the Lakes Basin. Yes, we were getting snowed on as the fish and trout were coming out, so it was kind of entertaining. So we dropped 1,200 pounds of 3 to 5 pound fish in the Lakes Basin, so there was some beautiful fish up there. And then Whitmore Pool is still open.
1:58:53 We fixed a few little kinks in the system. So we're open right now Monday through Friday for lap swim and swim team. And then we're going to have a free swim day kickoff for summer on June 13th. We're going to move that up a week just to get the community excited about summer. So that's all I have unless there's any questions. Great. Thanks. Thank you very much. Two quick items. I did attend with...
1:59:19 A couple of other staff members, the Contractors Association meeting, the most recent one, we updated them on some of the housing stuff and the diff things that you'll be looking at tonight in terms of the list of projects. The only other thing I wanted to mention, I mentioned earlier during the workshop, is we did have our annual inspection from FAA where they basically looked at the entire airport. They were here for two and a half days. They left very pleased with an extremely short list of just a couple of items we'll probably take care of in the next week. Nothing structurally out at the airport.
1:59:46 When they do that, they actually do look at our ALP. They look at the restrictions. They look at the restrictions. They make sure nothing has changed since the last one, that it's in conformance with what we've reported to them. And again, they left very happy. So we're glad to see that. I've got a couple questions, if I could. On the Lake George Mutt Project.
2:00:05 Two questions on that. Is there an idea or a sense of if construction will happen this summer and if it will when? And secondly, do you have any idea when the District Ranger's NEPA decision may be coming out? On that, the District Ranger has submitted the package to the Fish and Wildlife.
2:00:25 They're having to have a consultation on the toad that's up there in certain areas. We don't think it impacts the first phase. It's more for the second phase up from Lake George Road up to Lake George. However, the NEPA document, as you know, covers the whole thing, so it's going to stay together that way. We're still hopeful that it can happen this year. The plans are ready to go. We're ready to advertise on very short notice, but we're not going to advertise it and get it out to the public unless we know that that process is complete. We hope to hear and find out in the next couple of weeks.
2:00:55 To the Forest Service, if we can help to facilitate that meeting or that consultation, we're happy to do so. And is the NEPA decision tied to the fish and game? Fish and wildlife, yes. Fish and wildlife? Yes, because basically an issue with the biologists in terms of how the toad groans and what the impacts are. We don't believe that especially in phase one there are any, but that consultation needs to happen before we can move forward.
2:01:21 Okay, and then on the Sarbanes Grant, is there supposed to be some sort of a public outreach?
2:01:27 Thing this summer, any thoughts on when that might be happening? I don't have a date for that yet, but all to planning along with the local triad homes is working on that now. They've got a lot of their documentation. They want to get out in the field and do the field work before they set that date. And now is when they're doing that. I don't know if they're this week or next week. So is it maybe a July, August kind of a thing probably? And as soon as we have a date for that, certainly we'll let you know and then we'll get it out there to the public. Good. Okay. Thank you. You bet. Thank you, Grady. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers.
2:01:59 I haven't done an update with you guys in a little while, so I have a few things. On the consent agenda, you'll see some risk management policies. I've been churning out policies. Dan and I have been working through those. And that's part of our risk management evaluation in August. We get that done every few years. And we're doing this in preparation. We have to get policies done. We have tons that are super outdated, 10 to 20 years. So we're working on that.
2:02:25 Doing a ton of recruitment, you'll get to meet our new revenue specialist and engineering assistant. We hired an engineering intern at a ton of seasonals in prep for the parks and camps that Stu was talking about. We had a round of interviews today for the parks manager position, and this is going to be replacing Dennis Rotner, who's retiring this summer after 31 years working for the town.
2:02:46 Along the same vein, the demographics of our workforce, much like many other governments, we have a lot of baby boomers that are retiring, and we're going to be having a slew of people retiring in the next few years, and so recruitment is going to remain a very large part of my job, and succession planning, and planning for this in advance, and we're already doing that with Dennis, that's why we're doing the recruitment right now, he's retiring in late July, and that way we'll get someone on board and trained up with him.
2:03:13 And then the employee opinion survey I already talked about was completed, but now we're in the process of collecting feedback from the employees and really getting the changes that they want to see, the specific changes and things they want to do with the town to make us evolve as an organization. Any questions? Thank you, Sarah. Just one question. Sorry. And you had mentioned when you sent that email out that there's going to be some point where we're going to be able to kind of engage with that in a workshop or something. In the employee opinion survey? Yeah.
2:03:42 Yeah. Dan will be talking to you guys about how you all will be involved in that part of the process. Okay. Great. Thanks. Thank you. Any other council, or excuse me, departments or commissions? Okay. Then we'll move on next to a public presentation by Patrick Hayes on water conservation and water restrictions. So can someone get the lights in the back, please? I'm doing this. Good evening, Mayor Bacon, members of the council, staff, and the public.
2:04:30 Patrick Hayes, I'm the general manager at the Mammoth Community Water District. I'm here today to give you a very brief and quick presentation about the status of our water supply. I don't think there's anyone amongst you that doesn't realize we have some drought conditions underway, so hopefully nothing I'm going to say today is of surprise to you. Certainly I welcome any questions and thank you for the opportunity to talk to you about our local water supply.
2:05:04 I think you've seen this slide before, but in summary, our mission is to provide reliable water, wastewater, and recycled water services to the community. It's a 24-hour a day, 7-day a week, year-round sort of job, and I don't think you've suffered any outages. Our goal is to keep maintaining that that level of service is going on in perpetuity. So a little bit about our background. We're a chartered state agency. It's a special district.
2:05:34 Chartered in 1958, at which time we were also granted water rights by the Department of Water Resources. And our goal, as I said earlier, to provide municipal water, wastewater, and recycling supplies. The service area is not the size of the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's the little area shown in the beige-pink bracketed area. That's the service area for the Mammoth Community Water District.
2:06:02 Some statistics, we have currently almost 3,700 metered connections. All of those meters are brand new. They were installed last fall at a much higher resolution, and they're reporting hourly data. I'll discuss that in a moment. Population, we have a resident population of about 8,200 folks. We have a 16,400 equivalent population. That's from our urban water management plan.
2:06:28 And that bears into another part of the discussion about the State Water Resources Control Board and their mandatory conservation requirements imposed on May 5th of this year are based on your per capita flow. And we ended up in Tier 5, which is a 20% reduction. We have 42 full-time staff and a budget of about $13 million. This drought slide from April 28th of this year,
2:06:58 Finds Mammoth the right debt center in extreme and extended drought. We are in the fourth year of a drought cycle. In the last couple days, I've been reading a report that the University of Arizona did for the Department of Water Resources. It looks at tree ring data for the San Joaquin, Sacramento, Klamath Rivers, and also the Colorado. The record is 1,200 years, and it has good correlation with actual
2:07:27 I can tell you from what I see there that the situation we're in is completely not without precedent. There are plenty of examples of exactly the situation we've been in over the last 1,200 years. In fact, we're probably in the middle third band, and it could be far worse or far wetter. It's so bad right now, though, even Los Angeles has dammed up the aqueduct.
2:07:57 And for the first time since 1913 is no longer exporting water to Los Angeles. So I think from their experience in the last 100 years, that's a pretty big deal. That's Mr. Yonata walking down the banks there. Water supply, if we're supplying water for the community, where does it come from? It comes from these three sources. Surface water, which is Mammoth Creek and really the Lake Mary.
2:08:26 The catchment area, groundwater from wells, and then whatever we can make from recycled water, we can turn into reusable water. Not surprisingly, over the last several years, with conservation and drought, the amount of wastewater being produced has reduced, and commensually with that, the amount of recycled water we can produce is also diminished because there's less wastewater to make it from.
2:08:54 Here's a good aerial shot of where those water sources are. Surface water in the upper left-hand corner. Groundwater basins are generally stretching from Sam's Woodside out to the Snow Creek Golf Course area. We have nine groundwater wells in that area. And then recycled water would be produced at the bottom of the system at our wastewater treatment plant. Potable water source is surface water from Lake Mary.
2:09:23 And we collect water from that basin. Groundwater, there's a total of two wastewater treatment plants, nine production wells, and the aquifer end is really atraditional. It's fractured rock. It's not the typical sediments, gravels, and rocks like you would see in the Central Valley or other groundwater basins. And the other added attraction with groundwater is we have to pump it out of the ground. Surface water is mainly gravity-fed, so there's a heavy energy footprint.
2:09:52 Here's our surface water basin, Lake Mary off to the left. This basin is actually quite small. Recently, Jet Propulsion Laboratory has been doing aerial surveys of snow volumes using LIDAR. The Tuolumne Basin takes them about four hours to do. When they fly our basin, it takes them about six minutes. So it gives you a relative idea of the size of the basin. So where does the water come from into Lake Mary? It's snow melt.
2:10:22 Actually, of a very, very high water quality, we virtually have to do almost no treatment for it. And it's gravity fed. It's starting at the top of the system, and we can put it down through the system without much in the way of energy embedment, and it doesn't cost as much to treat it. So that would be the preferable source. There's some limitations to that. Obviously, the amount of snowpack. There's some regulatory ones, about 2,760 acre feet. The actual diversion has never been close to that.
2:10:50 We have had a settlement for the last few years with cow trout and fish and wildlife that limits our take until after the fish flow requirements are met. And then in 2013, we had a settlement arrangement with Los Angeles Department of Water and Power over disputed water rights that gives us 4,387. We currently, last year, used about 2,600 acre feet, so there's about two-thirds of it being utilized without drought conditions.
2:11:20 Set the tone for the next 100 years, LA won't be back to talk to us in that period of time. Groundwater recharge is another aspect of the amount of snowfall we get, and it's far less costly, as I said earlier about treating it. The two groundwater treatment plants are there to pump water out of the ground, take it through various levels of treatment to remove iron, manganese, and arsenic, and some of our wells show some geothermal influence.
2:11:51 Recycled water, while we have a capacity of about 6 million gallons a day in the average winter months, it might be about 1.4 million gallons coming into it and slightly less during the summer months. We have one connected recycled water customer, Sierra Star Golf Course, and they use about 500,000 gallons a day in the summertime. Snow Creek, the system was built to serve both Snow Creek and Sierra Star. They're supposed to be online July 1 this year.
2:12:24 So what is our water supply situation? Rather than speculate, I can show you some actual details of that. So we have snow surveys that are done throughout the Sierras. Our snow survey course is on Mammoth Pass, and you see there the old traditional method of taking big straws and sticking them into the snowpack and measuring the water content. I mentioned to you the jet propulsion laboratory stuff will revolutionize this whole business because it takes in the whole basin.
2:12:53 And a pretty good squash. So here's where we were on March 30th. There's a lot on this graph, so let's start with the top of the graph. That dash big mountain there is the best year on record. The record goes back, I think, to 1895. The more straight dash curve is the average year. The blue one below that was last year. The dark red line at the bottom is this year.
2:13:22 So the snow survey as of the end of March showed one inch water content, which was a very similar year to the 1977 drought, which is the dash line right behind it. The only significant difference is it was warmer this year than that year, so the precipitation stopped about a month earlier than 1977. And here's another form of that same data. We're the snow pillow side on the left.
2:13:52 Mammoth Pass at 2% of average for the year as the second block over. You can see the precipitation on the right, which includes Long Valley, Bishop, Big Pine, Independence, etc. They actually weren't anywhere near as bad as our situation, but I can say that we were far better than Rock Creek, South Lake, Big Pine, etc., because they had zero. This is the last 50, 60 years' worth of data. You can see where we stand on the far right over here.
2:14:23 But there's been plenty of periods of low rainfall. Our last average year was 9-10. 10-11 was a pretty good year. And then we've been in declining production the last three years. Again, looking at those 1,200 years worth of tree ring data, it's completely random. There's no predictability of these. There's no cyclic patterns to it. Next year could be just like it was this year, or it could be a very banner year. There is no...
2:14:49 So we have to plan accordingly and that we might not have a recovery next year. The other aspect of our storage in Lake Mary is that there are fish flow requirements from the cow trap, fish and wildlife. The hydrograph on the top there shows what the runoff has been over the last 10 years or so. Any time the hydrograph in the blue exceeds the red for fish flow,
2:15:19 We can store that water to the tune of about 700 acre feet. You can see that last year we barely were able to store water. This year we're predicting that the hydrograph will never exceed the fish flow requirements. Therefore, we will have no additional storage in Lake Mary. There's some implications for that. We currently have about 200 acre feet of storage.
2:15:41 Up and down blue line shows we have about 200 feet or about roughly two feet of storage on the top of Lake Mary. We can take up to about five and a quarter feet of storage there. We aren't going to get any more this year. The previous years are shown where it filled up in 13 and 14. And we have essentially 200 acre feet of storage for emergency purposes in Lake Mary. And that's going to be it for this year because we'll never exceed the fish flow requirements and we'll never be able to store this year.
2:16:10 So the status of our nine production wells then gets a little bit more attention. If there's no water in Lake Mary, where is it going to come from? We have nine wells. Two of them are showing signs of stress, which means that they're kind of running dry. They get used regularly to keep them fresh, but there's not much water there. One is in repair, but it's expected back online on May 1st. But it's not all doom and gloom. The remainder of them are all in pretty good shape.
2:16:39 They actually look to be pretty solid. So that's an encouraging sign. This is another way of looking at our water sources in color coding. The takeaway on this, there are two things. That shows April of this year, we're almost totally relying on groundwater, and that will be the situation for the rest of the year. There is a component of recycled water, but it comes from groundwater, so it's kind of double dipping when you count that.
2:17:07 The other thing to take away is look at the summer months and the amount of flow that goes on there. It's easy to pick them out because the flow doubles and triples during the summer months. That's irrigation, and that's the topic of where we're going in terms of water conservation. With limited supplies, we need a conservation plan, and our estimates is that we need to be reducing by about 30% to give us assurance that we'll get through this year and provide some padding for next year.
2:17:36 Currently, we're in mandatory water level three restrictions that went into effect April 10th of 2015 by unanimous vote to board. That is asking for a 30% cutback over the 2013 year. In April, we cut back 26%, so we're almost on that number with only a partial month of that level three requirement. Our level three restrictions...
2:18:03 We have these flyers out. They're available, and Irene's brought some copies of that. Basically, it's telling you the days of the week that you can water and where you can do hand watering. Irrigation is restricted to two days a week per customer, and there are certain days when there's no watering. From this chart, you'll quickly be able to derive Monday, Tuesday, and Friday are no water days. And again, copies of these are available either today or from the water district directly.
2:18:36 Meanwhile, the state government has decided it was important for them to step in and regulate all the water utilities in California through the State Water Resource Control Board. The governor proposed on April 1st what those rules would be. It was adopted on May 5th. It affects all water utilities. It served more than 3,000 customers. And MCWD ended up in Tier 4. We started up in the top tier, which was Tier 9, but we were able to...
2:19:04 Get the board to realize that we have an equivalent population, not a resident population that really rules things. That put us at a 20% reduction. If we had not been able to get that across, we would have been at 36%. So right away you'll notice that our requirements are actually more stringent than the states, and they're based on our local estimations of what our water supplies are, which I think you've just got a pretty good idea of where they stand in terms of surface and groundwater.
2:19:32 And again, the biggest potential to conserve is in irrigation. Here's a lengthy list of the comparisons of the several. This is available online. I won't bore you with all the details, but you can see that the state has put out lots and lots and lots of regulations here. The only real takeaway from the town's point of view is they've prohibited irrigation of median strips. So that means Old Mammoth Road and Main Street.
2:20:01 Median strips, the state will not allow you to irrigate those. And I'm pretty sure that Dennis has been working very hard in compliance on all that. We're sorry to see him go. We are providing a means for the town to keep trees alive. We think that's a really important issue that could be done through a water truck and a fire hydrant, and we're working out the details of that so that we don't lose any more trees than we already have.
2:20:31 Here's a seasonal condo. You can see the summer months are three times the use, and that's all due to irrigation. So that's why we're focusing on irrigation. It uses well over 60% of the water. A winter day might be 1.4 million gallons of demand. Summer, almost 4 million gallons. And that's why we're going after the irrigation component, because that's where you can get the results. And again, focused on that block.
2:21:01 In the May through October time frame. So we're fortunate that last fall we implemented a new metering system, an advanced metering system. All new meters, higher resolution, hourly data being recorded. And how is that useful? I'll give you some examples here. It also provides some analytical tools. It helps us on leak detection. And it helps us on enforcement of the time of day and day of week.
2:21:29 When people are irrigating, it's a far greater number, ten times more than normal domestic consumption. It's very easy to see with a human eye in graphical context when irrigation is going on. Here's an example of hourly data for a month. You've got the hours of the day across the top and the days of the month down below, and this particular customer, that gray block in the middle are all violations.
2:21:58 They were violating the time of day and the day of the week requirements with that. And not only that, it looks like they have a huge leak because there's not an hour of the day that they're not using water. It turned out that there was a 300,000 gallon a month leak at this customer they were completely unaware of. So they did some work and a couple of months later, they did pretty well. There's still a few outliers in the middle there where they're off track.
2:22:26 They eliminated the leak and got on track. Here's some customer use from a typical homeowner. You can see that they got up in the morning and turned on the shower and there's a big blop there and there's another one in the evening when they cleaned up and went to bed. But interestingly enough, there's continuous use around the clock. That's a sign of a leak. Sure enough, this customer had a leak, repaired that leak and there's the comparison.
2:22:54 Several days later after the leak got fixed. Irene and Betty and our staff and Karen Siebert in the last two months have called 120 customers with this data and saved 22 million gallons of water annually just by going after these insidious sort of leaks that are occurring. That's the value of having the sort of interval data we're talking about. I'll let Irene come forth. We have a rebate program to encourage conservation.
2:23:24 But really it's in our hands collectively to solve this problem. Rebates for toilets and the like are available. Irene, did you want to speak to that? Thanks. Before I get to the rebates, I just wanted to mention if you see water waste or you see a violation, you can call our office. We actually have a hotline number set up so it's anonymous. No one ever picks up that phone and answers it. You can get that phone number from our website.
2:23:54 So as Pat's mentioning, we do have a rebate program for toilets, shower heads, clothes washers. And we also have a rebate for pressure reducing valves on your irrigation system. A lot of times the irrigation system has too much pressure in there and your sprinklers are not running efficiently and they're misting and you're losing a lot of water through that. We have had a lot of comments. People are afraid to buy a new toilet. We openly accept.
2:24:22 Toilets that use 1.28 gallons or less. Toilets have been re-engineered. They work really well. If you have a 1.6 gallon per flush toilet and you've never been happy with it, you'll be a lot more satisfied with the 1.28 toilets. So if you have any questions, you can go to our website. You can download the application. I'll leave some here on the back table. Pat also talked about the level 3 water restrictions and the time of day and days of weeks.
2:24:51 I'll have some of those on the back table as well. So please feel free to call our office and pepper us with questions. We're happy to help you. Thank you. So that's it for the presentation. If you have any questions, we'd be happy to try and entertain. Questions? Just one. There's kind of a national debate on fluoride treatment in water. Kind of what is the district's philosophy on that?
2:25:25 As far as I know, we don't add fluoride. You have the option to do that as a water district. There's been a lot of thumbs up and thumbs down in some real lightning rod sort of subject. It's not something we've addressed any time recently. If you'd like, I can look into it and report back to you about that in more detail. I was with a water utility that did implement it, and there was...
2:25:53 Yeah. All right. Thanks.
2:26:24 Thank you. Thank you, Patrick. Thanks, Pat. Okay. Yes. Oh. Ask questions? Oh, sure. Sure. Patrick, would you mind taking? But you'll have to come up and share the podium. Pat, Mayor, Councilmembers, John Eastman. I had a couple of comments for the water district and also a question of Pat and the town as well. I just wanted to commend Pat wasn't here initially for the water district.
2:27:00 So a big improvement there. Kat also showed on the screen.
2:27:27 The water usage. The water district has technology now, and as he said, he's got a couple of employees that call people if they're losing water on a continuous basis. They can tell. So I've experienced that with my homes and actually have one today. Usually it's a toilet, or there might be a water leak. One time had a bad valve on the toilet. So anyway, it's comforting to know that the water district is doing
2:27:57 As much as they are in helping us conserve water. Pat didn't talk about it tonight, but I've talked to people in the community recently, and I don't know that there's a resolution, but I'd like both the council and the water district to look at a possible resolution. When our visitors come into town, one of the first things they say on Main Street is the grass area, the sod area on both sides of Main Street.
2:28:27 I don't think it's a stretch to say that that section of sod is an indicator as to the health, the economic health of our community when our visitors or homeowners come into town. It's a very big presence to the people that come in. As Pat said, as he pointed out, the state of California is requiring municipalities, which we are a municipality, the city of Mammoth, the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're not supposed to be watering the ingredients.
2:28:58 That's the rule. I've been out of town two of the last three weeks in Southern California, and every meridian that I saw in Southern California in the last two to three weeks is continuing to water and is very green and lush. For some reason, they haven't gotten a message. Probably 10 to 12 different municipalities. Anyway, that doesn't affect us. I'm just saying.
2:29:26 That some people aren't abiding by what Governor Brown has asked them to. Getting back to Mammoth Lakes, I realize that it's obvious that we're not going to use good water to water Main Street at this time. There's been some proposals which the town is aware of and as the water district is aware of, of using reclaimed water in water trucks. There's volunteers in the community that have put the reclaimed water in the water trucks and water.
2:29:55 Main Street so that we could get by this summer with grass on Main Street. It's obvious, I think, to all of us that we don't want sod or grass on Main Street for, you know, in the long term. I think that since that's the town's property at some point, the town has to decide what it wants to do with those meridians. I don't have an answer on what it is, but it's not going to be grass.
2:30:25 But I would just like to encourage both the town and the water district to work towards using the replaying water this summer to get us through this summer in that area. Final thing, I also understand from the water district that there's a limited amount of replaying water. They have replaying water committed to the Sierra Stock golf course, they have committed to the snow creek golf course. There's a question if there's even any water availability.
2:30:54 John, thanks for your kind comments and encouragement.
2:31:23 Specifically about recycled water, we can basically sell every gallon we can make. Under contractual obligation, we're to provide it to Snow Creek and Sierra Star, which is to say there's really no more left. There is another aspect of it that I won't go into in detail, but it's a biological process to make Tidal 22 water, and because our system has variable loading in just even a week.
2:31:50 It's very difficult sometimes to make it continuously. And that has to be made up for with raw water, which could have been potable water. So unfortunately, as I said earlier, there's a diminishing supply of wastewater. And through the agreements with the two golf courses, we have both sides have invested a great deal of time and money to build that system. We're contractually obligated to supply it to them. If there were any more, we certainly could entertain those.
2:32:20 I just don't see it being available. Is there a restriction from the state for if the town could acquire some of that water to use it to water our meridians? I don't think that there is. Recycled water is generally gets a pass in terms of irrigation purposes because it's for irrigation. That's the main use for it. If it were available, that would potentially provide that. Thank you.
2:32:48 Pat, are there any, are you guys offering any rebates for synthetic turf, pulling out grass at this time? The question comes up, as you might imagine, Councilman, very often. There are some communities that are really desperate for water, like Las Vegas Valley Water District. They're paying upwards of $3 a square foot to remove turf. I will tell you that the water restrictions that we have in place, that
2:33:15 It's likely that if you are following them that you're not going to be able to maintain a large amount of turf on your property going forward. I kind of liken it to pay people to do the right thing. The restrictions already are setting that standard. So, no, we don't have such a program. And with it comes a lot of administrative burdens. You end up actually putting a restriction on their deed.
2:33:44 So you don't have them coming back every three years to remove the same turf. Thanks. Okay. Any other questions for Patrick? Thank you so much. Thank you. Okay. On a lighter note, next we have introductions of new employees.
2:34:17 Grady Dutton, Public Works. I'm here tonight to introduce our new engineering assistant, Sierra Schultz. She's actually been an intern with us for some time now and started full-time in that new position on May 11th. I'm actually going to put her on the spot and say a couple of words because not only is Sierra a graduate civil engineer, but she's also from here, went away and managed to find her way back. So if you want to just send 15 seconds on your background or whatever you'd like to say, I know she's excited to be here.
2:34:47 Yeah, so I grew up here and I'm really happy that I got a chance to come back and work because I know a lot of kids don't get that opportunity to have a full-time job here. So I'm excited to keep working for the town. I've really enjoyed my time here so far. Yeah, thank you. We're glad to have you here. Welcome. Thank you. Good evening, Madam Mayor, Council. I'm Susan Cash with the Finance Department and I would like to present our new revenue specialist, Eric Berdovich.
2:35:24 Eric was replacing Shireen, who was stolen by code enforcement, and we're happy to have him. Eric was born and raised in Richmond, Virginia. He earned his undergraduate degree in kinesiology from James Madison University and his MBA from Virginia Commonwealth University. First came to Mammoth Lakes in 2010 to work for the mountain in their race department, and he fell in love with the area and knew he wanted to call this home. But he knew that working on the mountain was not a long-term possibility due to three
2:35:54 Major knee surgeries. He only has two knees. He's had three surgeries. So his hobbies include skiing, hiking, scuba diving, cycling, mountain biking, and baseball. So please join me in welcoming Eric to the town family. Welcome. Welcome. And Eric was a good partner at Mammoth Creek Park Saturday morning. That moves us to the consent agenda. I have requests to...
2:36:25 Poll items 9 and 10. Are there any other items, John? Number 5. Anybody else up here? Any community member? Yes. That would not be part of our consent agenda. We will be dealing with that. The consent agenda items are the ones that we can pass as a whole amount. Okay, so then with 5, 9, and 10 polled,
2:36:55 Madam Mayor, I make a motion to Council approve items 6, 7, 8, 11, and 12. Second. And we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Council Member Frey? Yes. Council Member Frey? Yes. Council Member Frey? Yes. Council Member Frey? Yes. Council Member Frey? Yes. Council Member Frey? Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. John, number 5? Yes, I just wanted to commend Jamie's effort on transcribing that very long and lengthy and complicated list of questions associated with the multi-use facility project.
2:37:25 But I just also want to emphasize that those questions are important. And I think that we all appreciate how important this multi-use facility conversation is. And that if anybody has any questions, if things are missing, more than happy to revisit those things. But thank you for your efforts on that. And just to emphasize that this is very important for the conversation going forward. Thank you. So then do you want to make a motion? Yes, I would make a motion that we approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 6th as presented. Second.
2:37:56 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. I'll abstain. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes. 3-0 with one abstain. I asked to poll number 9, which is about coordinating to submit letters of or comments in support or opposition of bills in the legislative process. I just wanted to make sure that all the council members understand that
2:38:27 We will, you know, if they fall within the general policies we've set, myself or the next mayor can respond to them, but there will be occasions when something needs to come back, unless it is based on the priorities that we discussed earlier tonight in our budget workshop session. So I wanted to make that clear. And Madam Mayor, if, is it clear that this applies to state and federal issues as well? Yes. Yes. Okay. It presumes that, it presumes it applies to all. Okay.
2:38:57 Did have one question regarding that one. Dan, Andy, are we at all engaging, tracking, anything going on with the mandatory vaccination bill that's moving through? If I may, I'm not at the town level watching that one. The county may be and the school district may be. When I was at the Lincoln City's annual legislative days,
2:39:24 That was a couple days after when the bill was initially heard in the Assembly, I believe it was, and there was a lot of debate and discussion, a lot of people in town regarding that. The comment that we got back from talking to some of the legislators was that the bill is moving forward, and at least a couple we talked to had no indication that it would not go through the legislature without issue and be signed by the governor.
2:39:48 That was the feedback we got. It was more just out of curiosity. I wouldn't really expect that to be something that we necessarily engage with as our purview, but I was curious. But since we're talking about legislation, I can tell you that the bad TOT bill appears to be dead. It's been stuck in committee for a month. The hearing canceled. The request of the author doesn't appear to be going anywhere. And the good TOT bill is now on its third reading in the Senate committee. It looks like it's going to pass. Great. Great. Thank you. Okay.
2:40:17 Then I will move, we approve, we authorize the mayor to coordinate with the town mayor to submit letters of comments. I'll second. We have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. That takes us to the community indicators report. Jennifer.
2:40:45 Hi, good evening. Jennifer Halperty, Mammoth Lakes Housing. Thank you for pulling this. I just had some questions, and I've talked a little bit with Jen Dorery about this, because I don't, the community indicators report, we worked with, Mammoth Lakes Housing worked with the town staff and their consultant in 2013 when this was first being put together, and so then when I saw this on the agenda, I was curious to see what the update said. And the way I read it,
2:41:15 Housing is on here as it relates to the community and the median home prices, the gauge to indicate to the community if we're meeting the general plan goal L2, which says substantially increased housing supply available to the workforce. So therefore, you would think
2:41:38 If the median home price is going up, then we're moving away from substantially increasing our housing supply available to the workforce because it's, as California overall and Mammoth Lakes knows, our wages don't typically keep in pace with home costs and that's why we are in this situation we're in and we've just approved support for legislation that would
2:42:06 Create some permanent financing for workforce and affordable housing. So when you go on to page 10, it says that the median home price between 13 and 14 increased 8%. But yet back on page 3, it says that housing median home price is neutral, which means it didn't change more or less than 0 to 3%.
2:42:36 Over five years, but they don't give us the five-year figure. I just feel like it's hard for me to understand, and I'm a housing geek. So it tells us 2007 figures, but that's seven years. So I don't know what it is over five years. I only know that every one year it changed 8%, but I don't know what it did over five years, and I'm not sure that it's really neutral. I feel like an 8% gain...
2:43:04 In home values, obviously, it's good for homeowners and it's good for property tax, and I get that, but as far as this goes, this report's supposed to tell us how it relates to the viability of our community members to afford housing, and I would say that 8% is a negative, although I know that's only one year and this is looking at five years, but I wouldn't ask that the report maybe talk about the five-year number instead of the seven-year figure.
2:43:32 Jennifer, real quick. This report has value, I think, going forward as establishing baseline data for a bunch of things. It's not everything, but it's a bunch of things. Was Mammoth Lakes Housing involved? You mentioned you worked with town staff to establish the metrics of how this thing, how these things were calculated. Is that true? In 2013 was the first year this report came forward, and it talks a little bit about the history, because there was a grant the town received.
2:44:00 We worked closely with a consultant then. It was hard to find data that would really represent the affordability of housing in Mammoth because we don't get statistics like big urban areas. We'd get lumped in with Mono County and how do we really determine it? So we worked with them.
2:44:19 Then, but not on this report, no. Okay, so I'm just trying to figure out what the problem is. If the problem is, it sounds like the question you're saying that the comparisons make sense, but your question is about some rationale about the data and how it's being articulated coming at the other end. Well, it doesn't tell us what the five-year figure is. It tells us one year, and then it shows us seven years. But on the front, on page three, they're using a five-year trend category, and I don't know what the five-year trend is. I don't think it's been articulated in this report.
2:44:49 Okay. On page 10, excuse me, the medium home sales price over the past five years has remained fairly flat with an overall decrease of $600 or 1%. Is that what you're looking for? Sorry, I'm reading something. I don't know if I'm reading what you're looking at, Jennifer, so I always wanted to clarify if that's. Then it talks about the overall sales price dropped by 31% since 2007.
2:45:19 And then the 8% from 14, from 13. Right, and 8% seems like a big jump. It's the highest it's been since 2011. But it does say that. But no, but the 5-year trend is 0.1% down. That's what it says, I know. Yeah, so we're still below the 5% that, or the 5 years, we're still below. I mean, on page 12, he goes back to 2005.
2:45:43 Right. I was going to say, so it's got nine years, you've got nine years, seven years, five years. Right. And I would just, maybe it could show, maybe there could be actually numbers next to each of the five years. It just, it just. Is the, is the, is the underlying data for this report available somewhere? Yes.
2:46:03 Okay, so maybe if you could get access to that and do some analysis and figure out if there's something we need to change in this or not. Yeah, just to make it more clear, I think, you know, why we're referencing back to 2007 when we're really only looking at the five-year trend. You know, sometimes it gets more confusing the more data you have if we're really, yeah, and treat them all equal if we're looking at five years. Am I also hearing you that there's a little bit of inherent conflict in, you know, looking at,
2:46:33 An 8% increase in medium home price as being allocated towards community in the sense that that might be a positive economic indicator. Right, but, yeah, and I think that's true. I think it depends on what you're, but they say on that one page that they're looking at it with regards to the general plan goal of substantially increasing workforce housing. So if you look at it with those, you know, blinders on, then that's a negative, but as I said, yeah. So there is.
2:47:03 Okay. I presume that maybe you and the staff in the Planning and Economic Development Commission can work on that because you're right. It's almost like it's an indicator that it's less affordable. Correct. Yeah. Well, it is. But it doesn't say that. We can clarify that. It's a positive economic indicator. Right. But if you reference the general plan more about.
2:47:26 Affordable Housing, it's actually a negative. Yeah, it's important. Getting that clarified would be good. Doesn't show it that way, yeah. Yeah, yes. All right. But it's okay for us to accept this. In your mind, it's okay for us to accept this one and next year's will look different? Yeah, we can do it that way. I just wanted to bring it to your attention. No, I think that's a valid point. Thank you. Yeah, definitely. Thank you. Okay, then I'll entertain a motion. I'll move that we accept the 2014 Community Indicators Report.
2:47:57 Second. With a motion to second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0. And it's still early. That moves us on to lucky item number 13, which is the housing ordinance update and zoning code amendment.
2:48:26 Public hearing, so I will first open the public hearing and ask for a presentation from staff. Thank you, Mayor Bacon. This hearing is for the housing ordinance update. The housing fee portion of this hearing has been continued to the June 3rd regular meeting, so we will not be discussing the fee and specifics about the fee at this hearing. The housing ordinance is a chapter of our zoning code that identifies housing mitigation requirements for new development.
2:48:56 The ordinance update in your packet reflects direction that council has given staff over the past few months. That includes that the ordinance is structured with a menu that provides developers options to be able to select from to determine how they would like to mitigate their housing obligation. That menu includes paying a fee, providing on-site housing, providing off-site housing, and or conveyance of land.
2:49:25 On-site housing, which used to be mandatory for certain large projects, is not mandatory. And then all the options are considered to be equivalent as directed by council, so there would be no penalty for any developer to choose one mitigation option over another. In addition to the ordinance, you also have workforce housing amenity and design standards in your packet.
2:49:51 Those identify livability-type standards for workforce units, including items such as number of bathrooms, storage, outdoor space amenities, and also describes when requests for waivers or modifications to those standards are appropriate. The ordinance and the amenity design standards as a package will supersede the interim housing policy that was adopted by the council in 2009.
2:50:21 The ordinance also includes, or the ordinance work packet includes an amendment to the housing element of the general plan. Some of the text in the housing element had to be revised in order for it to be consistent with direction given by council for the ordinance. So you'll see that in track changes in your packet.
2:50:46 And then to satisfy environmental review requirements, staff has prepared an addendum to the negative declaration that was adopted by council for the housing element itself. With that, there are no mitigation measures that would be required with this work program. On April 29th, the Planning and Economic Development Commission held a hearing for this ordinance.
2:51:11 They discussed a number of policy items during that hearing. Those items are listed in the Planning and Economic Development Commission staff report as attachment seven to your packet. And the policy items where there was clear commission consensus and closure, those items haven't been highlighted in your report for discussion. But, of course, if the council wishes to discuss any of those, you are welcome to.
2:51:41 So based on the commission discussion, we have four policy items that we highlighted in your report for tonight's discussion, and I'll just summarize those four briefly here. The first item is to allow existing rental units to be utilized for off-site housing mitigation.
2:52:04 The only concern that was raised with that item is a potential concern for existing tenants who may no longer be eligible under a new deed restriction for those units, and so we've prepared some language if Council wishes to incorporate that that would require compliance with relocation law. The second policy item is discussing locations where off-site
2:52:34 New construction of mitigation housing would be allowed. The ordinance language as proposed reflects our current requirements which limits the zones in which off-site new construction of housing mitigation can be located. That really restricts that new construction to zones where transient rentals are allowed.
2:52:59 And the background for that exclusion is that the non-transient zones such as residential multifamily one typically serve naturally as workforce housing. And so the intent was to ensure that we have an adequate supply of workforce housing and that workforce housing is also distributed throughout appropriate areas of the town. And this issue has come up specifically related to the shady rust track.
2:53:28 That is zoned RMF 1 and so would not be allowed for new construction of off-site housing on that site. And it would also apply to, for instance, the Sierra Valley sites. And so there has been some concern raised with those two items, concern of whether or not those areas may be developed or redeveloped.
2:53:56 So another point to consider in that discussion is that the town's expenditure of in-lieu fees as described in the ordinance is not proposed to be limited to certain zones. So we do anticipate that the majority of new projects under this ordinance would be paying a fee and then the town would be able to utilize those fees for new construction in any zone. So the way this
2:54:23 Limitation is currently written is that it would apply to, it would be a restriction for developers that wish to construct that off-site housing. So if council decides to eliminate that restriction, we've identified the two provisions in the ordinance that would be deleted. The third item is a regional housing discussion. And so here the concept is whether the town focuses really solely on workforce housing in Mammoth Lakes or if we have a more regional approach.
2:54:54 Currently, the town's resources for workforce housing are spent within the town limits, and the commission's feedback on this item is that this is an appropriate item to continue future discussions on. Nothing in their discussion is recommended to affect the ordinance as proposed on that topic. The last policy item relates to exemptions of new non-transient single-family homes.
2:55:23 So under the proposed ordinance, new single family homes would all be subject to a housing fee. As I mentioned, the housing fees will be discussed on June 3rd, but in terms of that methodology that we're looking at, it does reflect both permanently occupied homes and occupancy rates of second homes as well to determine an appropriate fee for all new homes. So the discussion at Planning Commission,
2:55:52 focused on two questions. One, whether we should exempt non-transient single-family homes as a whole. The other, as to whether we should apply a habitable square footage threshold to those homes that fees should apply.
2:56:10 So if new non-transient single-family homes were exempt from housing mitigation, there is still a need that is generated by those homes, and so just something to consider is that another funding source may be required to fill that need that may arise if those homes would be exempted. So the staff report does identify two options that we can discuss related to that policy item.
2:56:39 And with that, we did notice one small deletion just that we'll need to make for consistency in the ordinance. That's in section 17.136.040G2. So that's in the fee section. The second item there is methodology.
2:57:08 And this is just talking about how housing fees are calculated. And we just erroneously missed to delete the last three words and residential additions. So we noted that correction elsewhere. That's just one place we missed it.
2:57:24 So with that, we do have Matt Hurdle here from AECOM. AECOM is the consultant that we've been working closely with on the ordinance. They prepared the peer resort comparison study that's included in your packet, and we're also working with them on the fees. So with that, that concludes my presentation, and we'd be happy to answer any questions that you have.
2:57:50 Okay, so do we have any questions before we go to testimony? Janet said one quick question on the inclusionary piece of the removal of the mandate of that. It seems like that word was taken out but replaced with on-site housing. So I just want to make sure that we're on the same page that indeed inclusionary on-site, whatever you want to call it, is no longer mandated as it is.
2:58:16 An option in the toolbox that we discussed. Right. We've changed it just to call it on-site housing because on-site housing is just one of the options that developers can choose from. There's no preference for any option, so inclusionary housing, the requirement for on-site housing no longer is included. Great. Thank you. Madam Mayor, oh, sorry, go ahead. No, go ahead. Just as a question, a procedural question, the staff recommendations
2:58:41 I'm looking at these four items that Jen. We're going to come to, after we've taken public comment, we'll go back and focus on each of these before we get to a motion. Okay, because the motion seemed pretty technical. Correct. Yeah. Thank you. Just one question, Jen. You had mentioned kind of on the recommended motion there, D, adopt, or excuse me, adopt the attached resolution approving the workforce housing amenity and design standards.
2:59:11 But you had mentioned something about waivers where appropriate. Can you elaborate on that, where those exemptions would fall into place? Sure. The amenity and design standards are only two pages. And on the second page, there's actually a provision that discusses the appropriate times for waivers or modifications.
2:59:33 Essentially, it's really, we're trying to achieve these livability standards to the extent feasible. So for instance, there's a lot of limitations with acquiring existing units and doing rehab. There's certain maybe square footage limitations that won't be able to be achieved just because of the cost is prohibitive. So we look at certain, we say that requests for waivers shall be reviewed on a case-by-case basis depending on site,
3:00:03 And or project-specific conditions such as undue financial hardship, undesirable environmental effects, or design compatibility issues. Okay. Yeah, I just wanted you to elaborate on that a little bit. And, you know, as long as there's inappropriate avenue where people can come in and say, hey, I'm looking to rehab this existing unit, this particular designer amenity standard is not feasible, and we have a way, a mechanism to look at that. Okay, thanks.
3:00:32 Okay, if there are no other questions to staff, I will now call for testimony if there's anyone who wishes to testify on this issue before we bring it back for deliberation. I see, I was going to say, everybody waits.
3:00:51 Hi, my name is Kathy Cage. I have a question, a clarification from staff. I've never really known how this works. Let's say you're a small developer, you have a housing impact or so forth, and you own another property in town that is not deed restricted, and you say, okay, how about if I deed restrict that property as my mitigation? It sounds like that's on your list as a possibility. How does that work? I mean, I retain ownership. Who controls who stays there? Do I get to say who stays there? Or how does that work? How do you monitor that?
3:01:19 So there are options. I mean, there's options for full conveyance of the land to the town. So it sounds like you're maybe thinking of an option where the owner retains ownership and perhaps apartments would be built or built something to that effect? Well, basically, if it would be market rate right now and you'd say I would deed restrict it to a certain, like, income category, so that basically gets the system some deed restricted housing, I would assume that would
3:01:49 Be of some credit toward the fees, but I'm not clear about, you know, okay, I would retain the property ownership. Who gets to stay who's in there, and how do I make sure if I rent it to someone I wanted to, they're in the right income category? Do I report back to the town or the housing district? I just wonder if you could elaborate on that. So we do have requirements in here in terms of
3:02:13 Private ownership monitoring and maintaining those units and operating those units. And it does require reporting back to the town and or Mammoth Lakes Housing to ensure that the occupants of those units do meet the income levels just to ensure that they're complying with those requirements. And that's pretty much it, just kind of reporting. But then the property owner still can decide who stays in there and who doesn't, you know, themselves. I mean, subject to, you know.
3:02:39 Within the income ranges and still keep the credit and all that. Tenant regulate law and not being discriminatory. Very good. Thank you. Thank you. I have a follow-up question here, or no? I'll make a note. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Councilmembers. Tom Hodges with Madam Mountain Ski Area, VP of Mountain Development. I want to commend staff for the hard work they've put into this initiative. It's been, you know, immense amount of detail, a lot of...
3:03:08 Thank you very much for your help with that. The mountains participate in this process along with the at-large development community and just trying to make sure that we understand where this is going to go and how it's going to help support.
3:03:36 The policy issues that you are
3:04:04 Considering tonight the four policy issues, I just wanted to point out in particular, we had actually brought up the point about utilizing existing rental units. You know, our feeling was that if you're going to de-restrict an existing market rate rental unit, that it should be supported as a viable solution for affordable housing mitigation. Granted, there's an issue of the existing renters in there that may or may not qualify.
3:04:33 Depending on what the AMI levels that would be defined for that property. But I think the suggestion that if the developer who's going to propose that property would find alternate housing or, you know, the replacement housing for those people who might possibly be displaced would satisfy or, you know, take care of that concern. So we're supportive of that particular adding that language to the ordinance, number one in your analysis here.
3:05:03 Number two, the construction of new off-site housing allowed in certain zones, not RMF1 or CD rest. There was actually quite a bit of discussion at the Planning Commission about this particular item, and I would portray that there was consensus amongst the Planning Commission members, unfortunately they're not here tonight, that they did support including those zones as allowable mitigation locations for off-site affordable housing mitigation.
3:05:33 We at the ski area support that. We really just feel like there shouldn't be any restriction, that it should just be defined as within the limits of the town of Mammoth Lakes. So we would recommend that you guys support the suggested language that would basically strike those two subsections and delete the specific language of the areas from the actual language of the ordinance, thereby implying that you can do off-site mitigation anywhere within the town limits.
3:06:02 You know, we certainly think that, you know, RMF1 in particular, the Sierra Valley sites, certainly there's been housing developed there in the past. There's one discussion point, a couple discussion points were at the Planning Commission level where, you know, there's a lot of dilapidated properties in that zone. The ability with the potential to redevelop some of those properties with new workforce housing.
3:06:27 Would be a positive thing. You would be, you know, providing new product in there that may be replacing some very old and tired properties that need some updating. So this would be a vehicle to allow for capital to be reinvested in that neighborhood and it would be a positive thing. The other advantage of workforce housing being developed in the RMF1 zone is it is not transient. So in, you know, one respect, then you're not, if you're not developing it, you know, that developer chose to develop in the RMF1 zone.
3:06:56 And they're not developing what currently is being proposed or in the current language of the ordinance would be transient zone. In theory, you're not taking away from transient product that would be producing transient occupancy tax because it's being occupied full time by year-round resident. So that was our feedback on number two.
3:07:21 The off-site housing, regional housing, I think we're kind of indifferent about that. I think the only point to make to you guys as we start, you know, there's going to be a lot of discussion when we come back, when you have your next council meeting to discuss the fees, the proposed fee structure. It's really what whoever's going to meet the road on a lot of these issues. But the, you know, the discussion, I think it's just a, from our perspective, it's just acknowledging the fact that there are a lot of folks that live out of town that live in Crowley or June Lake or Bishop, you know, down the road. I lived out of town for,
3:07:50 12 years myself. And, you know, there's a lot of reasons why people choose to live out of town and Price Point isn't necessarily the only reason people decide to live. People enjoy living out in Crowley because it's quiet and it's out of the, you know, the tourists in the town and stuff in the middle or the weekends. They like having bigger lots, being out of the snow, a little bit warmer weather. So there's a myriad of reasons why people choose to live in other areas.
3:08:16 So I just want to point that out to you guys. And I think that'll conclude my comments. Thank you very much. Actually, I have one question for you. So on the second one, when we come back to discuss it, the recommendation is have it be in all zones, including the shady rest parcels? Yeah, we feel like you shouldn't, I think you should just say that it's acceptable to have off-site housing mitigation anywhere within the townlands. And that's the way the...
3:08:46 The staff reports written if you choose to adopt their recommendation, that would accomplish that. Right now it's restricted, the language in the ordinance specifies only areas that are transient for off-site housing mitigation. So keep in mind these are all choices for a developer to mitigate. Likely the majority of the mitigation is probably going to be paying the fee. So, you know, but the other thing to understand is economic conditions are going to change over time.
3:09:15 You know, hopefully this ordinance is written strongly that it'll withstand a test time for, you know, five to ten years. You know, and if we get an upswing and we have a development cycle, you know, things, conditions can change and you'll have to reevaluate things. But I think the point of this ordinance is that it would address all conditions and market conditions as they change over time. Okay, thanks. Thank you very much. Good evening, Mayor Bacon and members of the council. My name is Mark Carney.
3:09:47 And I'm here to just make a few comments with respect to the Housing Update Ordinance on behalf of a number of clients within the development community. First and foremost, I want to make you aware that Bob Mayer and Chris Bichet are here tonight. They're from the Mayer Corporation, which is a third-generation hotel developer in Orange County, and I'm pleased to report that they opened escrow just today for a six-acre parcel on Sierra Star at the lakeside with every good intention to develop.
3:10:16 A full-service hotel, our first full-service hotel on the golf course. They were here for meetings, various meetings today and tomorrow, and so they joined us this evening. In addition to the Mayor Corporation, other clients that have interest in the outcome of this ordinance are I-Star Financial at the 8050 in the Three Corners, Will Gustafson, who's an escort to purchase the East Village, John Hooper, who is really the...
3:10:42 Developing right now, he's probably out there right now, before dark, continuing to build houses at the golf course, Mammoth Springs Resort, which is Talus, Jim Naviteratus, which is Old Mammoth Place, and All-California Funding, which owns the Shady West parcel. I want to echo Tom Hodge's comments, in particular with respect to commanding the staff, and in particular Jen Daugherty, for the heavy lift that she's provided the community in the past four months.
3:11:11 You gave direction in early January to try to get this ordinance in place by June, and it looks like we're going to meet that directive. And as a representative of the development community, we felt fully engaged and informed at every step of the way. So it's been a pleasure to work with Jen and the staff on this, and I think the outcome speaks volumes. We're not up here to complain about anything. We're up here to support the direction of the town.
3:11:40 Is moving in. We do have a concern with respect to the policy too and that's the only issue that I'm going to discuss this evening. We don't think that any property should be off limits for off-site mitigation. There's a limited amount of property in town. We have a need and the ordinance is intended to encourage and promote the development and availability of workforce housing throughout the town.
3:12:10 I think Jen has pointed out in her presentation that this doesn't affect where the fees can be spent. So I don't want to put too fine a point in it because it's really not going to happen as often as one might think at first glance. Because in my experience and in my conversation with the development community, they're most likely to go through the fee route.
3:12:37 And those fees can be spent by the town anywhere in town they want, including RMF1 and Shady Rest, and we think that's appropriate. But if you do want to encourage the development community to build something as opposed to just pay the fee so that you can build something or Mammoth Lakes Housing can build something, then I think it's important not to restrict where they can do that because I think they're less likely to build something.
3:13:06 If they're required to build something on more expensive TOT producing property. So for that reason, we think it's in the town's interest to not limit where the affordable housing mitigation can be. And really, that's all I have to say on the topic. I'll be happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mark. Thank you, Mark. Is there anyone else who wishes to provide testimony? Good evening again.
3:13:41 You know, we've worked closely with Jen and the other stakeholders on this process and the Mammoth Lakes Housing feels that following the relocation laws around the existing apartments is good. It's the same laws that we would have to follow if we received grant funds and buy existing apartments and rehabilitate them. We had to do it at the Star Apartments, for example.
3:14:11 It certainly does not add to the existing housing stock, so it doesn't do a substantial increase, but it typically does improve the quality of those units, and so I think that should be noted. I know that there's a focus on rehabilitating and some of the older housing stock in town, and so it would fulfill that and not displace folks.
3:14:38 Who are paying low rents right now, and if we're going to go up to 150, we're possibly going to lose their units. And I think we have to be aware of gentrification and displacing people as we move forward with this policy. With regards to off-site housing in the RMF1 and Shady Rest, I think this gets back to something that I heard.
3:15:08 said from the dais at the last meeting with regards to the multi-use facility is, you know, we can't ignore our limited land base. We can't say we're going to do something today and then 11 years down the road say, oh, we don't have any land for that. Whoops, what do we do now? And I think we have to be aware of that when it comes to this housing policy. I know you've heard that time and time again from Mammoth Lakes Housing, but it is
3:15:35 It's not just the multi-use facility that could potentially have to find a new home someday and there will be no land available. It could be our workforce that...
3:15:46 Could face the same situation. And the RMF1 zone is already serving as the workforce housing. If Lee Gosch was here tonight, she would say, please don't put any more workforce housing in our community. I'm not sure that I agree with her on that. But, you know, those are the sentiments you hear from people. We've heard them time and time again. You know, the Shady Rest site is already dedicated to be affordable housing.
3:16:11 And so it's a matter of thinking long term and how do we ensure that we don't get to a place 11 years or 5 years down the road, you know, where we don't have enough available land to house our workforce. I guess the only other one I would like to talk on, I think that the off-site, I think that, you know, the town...
3:16:35 And Mammoth Lakes Housing certainly has thoughts on off-site housing going regional. We work in the region, so we're certainly sensitive to that. Exemptions from housing mitigation for non-transient single-family homes. Single-family homes typically in the town when they're new construction are built by, more times than not, by second homeowners, and they do add to the need for workforce.
3:17:04 And they're very rarely housing locals the new construction. So at least some percent of, you know, those units should be providing for the work, mitigating for workforce impacts. And I would be supportive of something similar to what we had before where there's a square footage threshold that would trigger it. You know, something above, you know, 2,500 feet or whatever that number is. That's what it was in the existing ordinance that we have.
3:17:34 You know, I know that it's important for the development community to have this work for them so that pencils. But there's another side of that, and that is our locals and the people that we need to operate all those hotels, clean those beds, and cook our meals, and all the way up to, you know, people to plow our streets.
3:17:59 And those are the people on the other side of that coin. So you can't look at it from just the penciling of development community, but also how do locals make it penciled for their monthly budgets. And so that's all I have. Thanks. Thank you, Jennifer. Anyone else? 30 seconds. Sorry. No, it's round turn. I forgot to add my testimony on the aspect of going regionally. I would...
3:18:30 Ask you not to consider that at this time. I think it's premature. Usually when you push out outside your town limits it's because you've got some super big pressure on your housing stock and the prices and all that sort of thing. I don't think we're there yet. It's always something we have in our pocket for when we need it. But I'm guessing you're probably going to open it up, that RMF2 stuff, shady rest, that kind of thing, based on the testimony tonight. My sense is it's too early and premature to open it up regionally at this time. So I just wanted to add that testimony.
3:18:59 Thank you, Captain. Anyone else? Okay. Then I will close the public hearing, and if it's okay with Council, what I'd like to do is work through each of the four questions and ask if we need clarification from staff so we can focus on each one. Okay. Sure. So the first would be utilizing existing rental units for housing mitigation with the idea that we include the
3:19:34 I'm working for my work, the relocation, am I saying this correctly, Steph? Yes. Does anybody have questions or comments on that, Mark? I have a question. Okay. I'd like to follow up on Kathy Cage's question about the deeds and who manages these, and I'm a little concerned that there's ambiguity. There's some ambiguity from you were saying about who, it's not clear where these deed restrictions might live. I wonder if you could speak to that.
3:20:00 Well, I think it could go either way. I mean, the units could actually be deeded over to Mammoth Lakes Housing for management, so it could be managed by Mammoth Lakes Housing on behalf of the town, or they could be privately owned by a developer who, or a property owner, excuse me, who manages those units, ensures that the tenants who come in meet those affordability levels, and then reports to Mammoth Lakes Housing on behalf of the town. Okay, I'm just concerned about
3:20:30 I agree. Right now we have it.
3:20:57 Structured both ways, some that the town monitors, some that Mammoth Lakes Housing monitor, and I agree that having one monitoring entity would be best. So how do we make a decision about that this evening, or when do we address that? Well, John, let me suggest that if we have the flexibility of both, then the staff can work together and work something out, but we're still offering the flexibility of either turning it over or holding it. Well, and I would want to propose that it not be flexible, that it go to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Well, but if you want to do that, then you're going to delay this whole thing.
3:21:26 I think we agree that it needs to be coordinated in such a way, but I don't think that we need, I think we need to leave the flexibility in there at this point, because you may have a situation.
3:21:43 Where someone turns over a few units and they're still managing the rest, why would you have two different people managing within the same? I understand, but I am concerned about not getting staff in a position where we've got two different capacities, one capacity within the town, one within an NGO that we're supporting. I just want to do this as efficiently as possible. Well, and I think you do, but I think leaving the door open and the flexibility is...
3:22:05 Okay, so then if I could come back to the other questions, which is when, at what point are we making a decision about this? Is that in this item tonight or is that coming later? No, what we're saying here is if we leave it as written, there's the flexibility to allow them to either turn it over or not. Okay.
3:22:22 And if I may, we have talked to Mammoth Lakes Housing about this administration, and moving forward, all deed restrictions will be monitored by Mammoth Lakes Housing. At least internally, we have agreed upon that. I don't think that's necessarily appropriate for the ordinance. Okay. Okay. Anyone else with comments, questions on number one? The comment I have is that I'm in support and favor of revising the language as stated under item one. Colin, any comment?
3:22:52 Yeah, just similar comments along that line. I mean, you know, since I've been a planning commissioner, we've talked for a long time about being development ready, you know, really seeing that as an important thing for the future of Mammoth. I think really that discussion comes more on the third, you know, when we get down to the nitty-gritty of the fee, but I think what we're looking at today is something that we've discussed a lot more and more recently, which is we have a need to improve our housing stock here.
3:23:19 And, you know, we've got 9,626 dwelling units of town. Only 2% of those are deed restricted. That's a very high ratio of units to deed restrictions if you look at the comparisons to other resorts and also to our population. We've got a lot of aging product. So I think, you know, I've been...
3:23:46 I've been kind of singing this tune for a while that anything that we can do from a policy standpoint to encourage the rehab of existing units we should be doing, you know, building new units in areas like Sierra Valle sites is a positive thing. So I'm supportive of as proposed here. As am I. So I'm just going to ask John to clarify.
3:24:12 If what we're talking about here is having the flexibility within the process, not the actual administration of it, which is outside of the ordinance, are you in support of number one? Yes, I am. Okay, so then I'm hearing consensus. Is that with the revised language? Yes, with the italicized language that is at the bottom. Okay, great. Yes. Okay, then the second one is about off-site housing allowed in certain zones, not RMF1 or shady rest.
3:24:42 I'd like to start by asking staff a question. You have stated in here the concerns that were stated at the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, but they did not recommend changing the restriction. Is that correct? They had a discussion. It's some concerns, but did they give you a recommendation to say no bigot townwide?
3:25:07 I think there were some commissioners that supported it. I did not get the sense that there was full consensus, but I also did not hear real opposition either from the commissioners. I don't think they really – I mean, I attended the meeting. I don't think they really drove to that point. You know, they more said this is something that we think Town Council should deal with as a policy item.
3:25:32 Okay. I was trying to figure out if there was a recommendation from him other than just concerns. I don't think they got to that point. It was more just discussion. All right. So who wants to start out the discussion on number two? I would support all zones. Yeah, and I would second that, John. I think to restrict just doesn't make a lot of sense and put it where it financially is feasible to make it happen.
3:26:03 To say not to do it in, you know, RMF 1, shoot your rest zone, I mean, I don't agree with that, so I'm for unrestricting. Same for me. I think, you know, our ultimate goal should be to provide affordable housing up to 150 AMI and allowing areas to sit vacant, closing areas off from redevelopment, especially, you know, Sierra Valley sites come to mind, doesn't make sense to me, so I'm supportive of a town line.
3:26:33 I'm not 100% behind it because I think it does result in stacking. I thought when we were talking about off-site housing and talking about renovating of stock, it was some of the older transient rentals, you know, some of the older condo complexes that have been around since the 70s that are in RMF, too. And I am concerned about how much you might want to try and stack on the shady rest tract.
3:27:01 Or parcel, whichever we're calling it these days. Could you just clarify staff? Yeah. Well, if, you know, most of, I will agree that there's some rental property in RMF1 in the Sierra Valley sites that could definitely be upgraded. Right. We know that. But I thought that when we were going towards the idea of trying to renovate it with some of the older condos, which are RMF2.
3:27:28 And there's already mostly employee housing and a lot of the rental properties that we have right now are in the RMF-1. And then on shady rest, I think it's an understanding of you can't put so many units in there that it's no longer going to meet any of the livability standards. Yeah. I'm leery of, I appreciate the conversation earlier about flexibility.
3:27:49 And I'm – it's hard to predict what kind of opportunities are going to come up. And I think that given our limited land base and the discussions we have, I think it's appropriate to be looking at all opportunities. And I think, you know, in regards to Shady Res specifically, I mean, those are going to have to go through, you know, master plans, et cetera, for development there, where there will be an opportunity to mitigate that stacking or over-densification and those type of things. I just think, you know, restrictions of particular areas don't make a ton of sense to me.
3:28:19 Okay, so I'm still seeing there's a consensus, even though I'll call myself a, make that one a 3-1. So that means that as we go through this, we have to remember to say this business about deleting those subsections. So you're going to help us when it comes time to motions? Yep. Okay. Then on to the third piece of regional housing. If you don't mind, I'll start, is I think that what Shields was really asking for here.
3:28:46 At least my understanding of what he said was that you did consider that people are going to be outside of town. But I also understand that the purview of our plan has to be the town limits because that's what we have the jurisdiction and responsibility for.
3:29:02 So I kind of like the answer of saying leaving it as it is that we are dealing with within the town, but recognizing that there are regional solutions and we understand that. And I totally agree with Tom's comment that, you know, not everyone chooses to live in Mammoth. And so that way back in the beginning it was, you know, we're going to have 80% of our workforce in town. Well, what if you only had 60% who wanted to live in town? That kind of a thing.
3:29:28 I would say that I would agree with Tom's characterization, and I would disagree with Kathy's sense of timing, but then I will agree with your kind of how you're framing this. But I would be a little bit stronger in that rather than just looking, you know, keeping our eyes open to beyond the town, that we actively engage and anticipate solutions that
3:29:57 Thank you.
3:30:23 Working with our partners and other jurisdictions to start addressing these issues that exist right now and that need to be part of the solution. I think, John, too, it just goes back to this flexibility that we keep talking about and having our options. I absolutely support, you know, regional solutions and looking down valley for some solutions.
3:30:47 I think we should be looking outside the box, and I think we should leave our options open, and I think we should do it now and not wait, personally. Right. Can you see the way that Joe framed it? Does that, yeah, sure. I think it kind of works. So I'm going to provide it like a slightly different perspective. You know, I don't think that personally I've really wrapped my head around, you know, whether we take this regionally or not. I haven't had enough time. I don't think we've had enough time to really debate that issue.
3:31:15 I would actually probably echo Kathy's sentiments that I don't think we're at a bursting point currently. And I take that opinion, you know, looking at a lot of the comparisons to black tie owners in different resorts. Big Sky, for example, he cannot hire people unless they come to him with a signed lease agreement, letting them know that they've found housing in town.
3:31:40 tremendous issues over the last five years with people that he wanted to hire, but they were unable to find housing. He had a guy that lived in a van in his parking lot this year to solve his housing need. I don't think we're at that point here. I think what I see in town here is if you come to town looking for a place in September, October, November, you're able to do so. If you come looking for a place on December 20th or January 15th, you're going to have trouble, which is how it should be.
3:32:07 So I think eventually we will probably reach a tipping point where it's more exacerbated than it is now when we may need to look at Down Valley options. And that's happened to most communities as they've kind of matured. But I guess the long and the short of it is I'm not really sure where I sit at on that currently. So I kind of broached that subject with Sandra this morning and Dan.
3:32:33 What they had said to me is they were really looking for a policy decision from the council, not necessarily a decision one way or the other today, but simply are we willing to have that be part of the conversation in the future or not? And I'm certainly not close to having that as part of the conversation in the future. I'm not prepared to say that we need to jump that route, but I think it should be on the table for future discussion. When you're talking about going up to the higher median, you know, the mid,
3:33:01 Right, that we've been talking about. I mean, if those folks want to live out of town, I mean, we should support that. I mean, yeah. We can support them wanting to move out there, but I don't know if legally we can help them pay for it. They'd have to go to the Mono County program. Yeah, then that's where I'm saying this, that jurisdictional piece of it. And that's, I think, a valid point, you know, the jurisdictional boundaries. I mean, I've had some discussions with Mono County supervisors on that.
3:33:28 The feedback I got initially was it's not really an issue of land or zoning, it's more an issue of infrastructure and, you know, water and sewage hookup, sewer and hookups and those type of things currently, which may not be the case in the future and maybe we need to invest in that infrastructure down the line. But, you know, I think some people live out of town because they're forced to or because the finances work better. Some people choose to.
3:33:52 And, you know, Steamboats, when they did the comparison, their little kind of mantra statement, and I'm going to butcher the exact terminology, but it basically said all those that want to live in the town limits should be able to do so, essentially, recognizing that some people choose to live out of town because they want to have, you know, a more rural environment or something like that, more land.
3:34:16 So I think I'm comfortable with providing policy direction to staff today to say that it should be on the table for future discussion, and I think that's... Not change the ordinance now and put it out there for future discussion. That's fine with me. Okay. Do we have consensus on that? Yeah. I think so. If that wraps back, Jo, to what your original thought was. Yeah. Right. Right. Since the ordinance would say it has to be mitigated in the town limits. Yeah, that's fine. For now. Exactly. Okay.
3:34:42 That moves us on to the fourth one, exemptions from housing mitigation, non-transient single-family homes. I have a question about this. How would staff, I couldn't discern from the staff report as to how the assessments would be made. You mentioned a square footage threshold. Would it be based on a size basis, square footage basis? How would that look?
3:35:12 Like if it's a 5 or 10,000 square foot house, what kind of numbers are we talking about? Well, for example, currently we have a square footage threshold for housing fees for single family homes. So any single family home, new single family home that is under 2,500 square feet of habitable space is not required to pay a fee. Okay. That's throughout town, not zone specific. So, and that's simple for us to apply because we apply it.
3:35:41 Time of building permit issuance, and so we have very clear calculations of habitable square footage for each home. Right. So there's no assessment or anything that would be applied in that case. What would be calculated if we chose to go that route...
3:36:01 Could be like for instance now we have a fee that's applied on a square footage basis for single family homes over 2,500 square feet. So right now if it's over 2,500 square feet, it's a flat fee? It's a flat fee per square foot. Okay. And so what's proposed, what is being suggested by this is
3:36:21 What is the proposed change here? Is that per, sorry to interrupt, is that per square foot above $2,500 or just if you go above that threshold it's a per square foot fee? It's a per square foot over the $2,500 square. Okay, so if you're $3,000 you pay mitigation on $500. For $500 square feet. Okay. Okay, so again, what is the proposed? So actually, I mean, the proposed language that's in the ordinance is that all single family...
3:36:50 Homes would be subject to a fee. The next study is going to have a fee recommendation per residential unit. Above the $2,500? No, for all. For all. Okay. So the options in the staff report provide your options to consider that would either allow...
3:37:10 Wholesale exemption of new single-family homes and non-transient zones or considering applying a square footage threshold. Right now the work being done on the fee doesn't have a, isn't being calculated on a square foot basis, it's per unit. So that would be some additional work. It just seems to be confusing. Yeah, I think, I don't know who, I don't know where this came from but, and how it was calculated. What is, so, so,
3:37:40 When you say the fee of currently the $500, like a 3,000-foot home over $500, like in Hooper's and John's example of his homes in here, what is that fee, just the ballpark numbers? It's less than $3 per square foot. It's very, very low. And he was actually under for his new Mountain View project. It was like 2,300 square feet, so they were exempt.
3:38:06 And actually, that's one of the things that comes up is people are starting to build smaller. Right. And who knows where the arbitrary 2,500 came from. That's what I'm saying. It's really kind of, I mean, where did it come from? I would, I would support, I think it's important that above a threshold that we could talk about, let's say 2,500 square feet, that there's a fee. I don't know. Well, I was going to suggest that there's a fee based on the, you know,
3:38:35 Without a threshold, but it's a reasonable fee because the use of people in the community to, you know, plow the streets, cook the food in the restaurants, I can't see whether that's difference on a $2,400 or a $2,500. I agree with that. I can go along with that, sure. To me, there should be one that is a reasonable fee, but it applies because we recognize there's a need because any of those homes,
3:39:05 Do have an impact on the available workforce. Sure. But it's different in here because it's saying on transient, non-transient, right? Well, single-family homes in non-transient zones, which is just rural residential, rural single-family and RMF1. Right. So that's really what we're... It's two separate... Correct. There's two pieces to it. It's a fee for every square foot, a fee above a threshold, or none at all.
3:39:35 There's really three pieces if I understood what Jen just said. I'd like to figure out how to make it as simple as possible. I would too. Philosophically, I have an issue with just drawing a line of demarcation at 2,500 square feet. I think you're either in or you're out. Yeah. And that's my opinion. So then we're essentially saying just calculate it for all of them for... Well, and that's what's currently proposed is just drop the square footage language and just apply it per unit. Right. Per unit. The same. Yeah. Over 2,500 feet.
3:40:05 Or this would just be all the same. If you want a threshold, we can do that. If you treat them all the same, if you said you're paying a fee, I'm hearing two different things. Well, I think we're addressing right now the square footage threshold. I think then there's a... Not having a threshold. Yeah, okay. So if you just treated a single family home the same regardless of what zone it is or regardless of how big it is, then we just have a set fee that they would pay. Well, I think there's a secondary discussion on transient versus non-transient, right? Right. Yeah, we didn't get that prior yet.
3:40:33 Transient, I think, is a $2,500 also? Yes, currently. So a transient home under $2,500, yeah, that's right, transient under $2,500 is no fee associated now currently, right? Right, and for our interim policy, whether it's transient or non-transient, single-family homes are treated the same way. Right. Okay, so I think that, so are we saying no threshold and treat them all the same? Yes, I am. That's what I'm saying. Yeah. I think so. Yeah.
3:41:03 Okay. Is there a different burden on our workforce on a transient versus non-transient? Well, you're going to get contributions coming from both directions. I would think there's no difference because the street still has to be plowed, you know, those kinds of things. Okay. Okay, so, and I see a consensus on no threshold between transient and non-transient the same. Yes.
3:41:35 Which means you'd have to bring us a different piece about, because the transient single family homes is not part of this. Actually, with that consensus, we wouldn't have to make any changes in that portion of the requirements. Okay. All right. Okay. So those were our four policy items. Then over here on, well, it easily says page 7 of 9 or page 8.
3:42:05 Are our options. Can you walk us through the pieces of option one, Jen, with what we've essentially, what we might have to change? Yeah. Sure. So for option one, council would take the following actions as recommended by staff with modifications. Item A is considering the addendum to the housing element update negative declaration together with the negative declaration.
3:42:32 So that's just a consideration action. There wouldn't be changes associated with that. Item B is adopting the attached resolution, making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings for the general plan amendment. No changes have been requested there. Item C would be waive the first reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance, making the required CEQA findings, municipal code findings, and approving the amendment with three changes.
3:43:02 That I've noted. One is to correct the typo that I mentioned that talked about residential additions under the fee. The second change would to be to insert the revised language regarding rental housing requiring those to comply with relocation law as included in the staff report. So we take that language verbatim.
3:43:26 And this third change would be to delete the two subsections in the ordinance relating to restricting new off-site housing to certain zones. Okay. And then the D would stand as it is? D and E would stand as written? Yes, they would. Okay. Is everybody clear on what we've changed in the motions? Yeah, and did we capture the no square footage threshold?
3:43:59 So the ordinance right now would subject all new single-family homes to a fee. There would be no differentiation between non-transient, transient, or any thresholds applied. Okay. And that's how the ordinance is currently written. Okay. Okay. Okay. To make it easy, I'll do it. So moved. Okay.
3:44:26 Second. Second. Thank you. With a motion to second, roll call vote, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Before we move on to the next item, do we need a five-minute break? Sure.
3:45:02 Okay, you ready? Hey, we got water. Yes, that's because the dispenser back there right now. Oh. Okay, we will come back.
3:45:32 Into session and deal with policy matter 14. Could I have it quiet, please? Thank you. Please. Regarding the proposed voter initiative report from staff. Yes, Madam Mayor, thank you. It's kind of an iterative process of bringing some information forward on the proposed initiative. As we're pairing the staff report and putting items together, we hadn't, timing-wise, we hadn't gotten the...
3:46:03 Information from the county initially knowing we had enough signatures in that process. So what I do want to note is this evening there is no formal decision before you regarding the status of the initiative in terms of what the council direction wants to be, whether it's adopt it, put it on a ballot, vote on it. There's nothing before you at this point. That will come to you in June when we actually get the information from the county certifying the signature count.
3:46:32 At that point in time, those options would come before you to say, you know, do you want a special election? Do you want to pursue adopting the initiative as presented? Do you want to have the more technical analysis completed? So those options would come back to you. We're anticipating that June 3rd, assuming we get the official certification from the county by that time frame, which we should, we anticipate it. I don't think we received it today. I'm looking at Jamie, so it did not come in today.
3:47:01 So the follow-up report that's in here was really designed, it was building off of your last discussion on kind of the five questions that were discussed. It was looking at some other issues that council members had asked about and some information from that process. Before I step into that, I guess I'll defer to Andy if he wants to kind of the process, if you want to, I touched on it, but if you want to make sure it's clear. Sorry.
3:47:31 Which part? Just the next steps we have to go through and where we're at in the process. Okay. So where we are in the process is the next step is that once we officially receive word from the county of how many signatures there are, and the initial impression is that there are more than enough signatures to qualify this for special election, Jamie will attach a certification to the petition. She will notify the initiative proponents, and then at the next council meeting,
3:47:55 Which I think will be the next council meeting, June 3rd. She will certify the results to the council. At that point, the council can either adopt the ordinance without changes or call an election or ask us for the section 9212 report, which you actually already asked us for back in March. So if the council doesn't want to call the election or adopt the ordinance right away, you probably just reaffirm that you've asked us to prepare this report on the impacts of what the initiative would do.
3:48:24 If you ask us to prepare a report, we have to give you that report within 30 days. It doesn't have to be given to you at a council meeting necessarily. If you'd like to get it somewhat in advance of, say, like the July 1st meeting, we can give it to you in advance and give it to the public. Then you can consider it at the July 1st meeting. At that point, you would then have to...
3:48:43 You have the same choices. You have to either adopt it or call an election. We have been in touch with the county about possible election dates in general. The election, if there's going to be an election, would have to happen between 88 and 103 days from the date that you call for the election. There is an exception where if there's going to be another election occurring in Mammoth within, I think, six months after that 88 to 103 day window.
3:49:06 The election can be delayed so that it can be consolidated with that. The county has told us that the school district may be looking at a November election. If they do decide to have one, then we could consolidate with that, which would save a little bit of money on conducting the election, if the council goes that route. So that's where we are. Okay. So then what we're looking at tonight deals with the report on the five areas. Correct. So are you going to walk us through that, Dan? Yes, I will.
3:49:35 Just kind of walking through those without repeating. I think the elements that came out of the last council meeting, really looking on that, those five questions in those areas that came up, there was consensus on the first three of needing good, reliable, official data for decision-making. And I think that's, these are questions that council has raised almost regardless to be able to move forward. So I will ask for that confirmation of moving our work program forward in these areas, which benefits us.
3:50:01 Outside the initiative or with it, so it's a benefit to us to do those things. The quality of life ordinance, that is anticipated to be before the planning commission on June 10th and back to the council mid-July 15th. And then the enforcement program, as you heard earlier, we're just recently back up to full staff there and beginning to move forward in those areas.
3:50:26 The other areas was not as much the consensus side, but the whole idea of the discussion regarding the need for change and what may or may not would have come out of a council discussion or may come out of a council discussion. And then depending what that was, whether that would be another vote or the process to implement something of that nature. So the side of that, and part of the analysis, and I do need to apologize a little bit, I think some of the language in the analysis
3:50:53 When we talk about if it's permanent or something is absolute, we recognize that if you have another vote, that would be the way to change something. So nothing's absolutely permanent in terms of the discussion. So sorry for that. Some folks had asked me about that question in terms of the impact of the initiative. It makes it to where it's permanent up to in terms of restricting the council from doing something, but it doesn't restrict, obviously, the voters from doing something. But that's an important point to be. Yes.
3:51:23 To be clear, so there's a distinction between a vote of the council versus a vote of the community. Yeah, so if the residents are voting on this item of the registered voters in town, in that sense, nothing's permanent because the voters can always overturn what they put in. Right. But it's overturned by another vote of the community. Community vote, correct. It's not a council vote. So in some of the language in here, the thought process, it really, when sometimes it's permanent in terms of its application to
3:51:53 Town activities, council activities, not to the community activities. So I want to make sure that's clear and sorry for that. And those would both be simple majority votes. Yeah, I think all this is simple majority. I don't think there's any super majority. It's 50 plus one. Okay. And so we started to look about just in terms of reliable data and bringing that forward. We're really working through that in terms of the, you know, decision making out there. What is the data place?
3:52:21 The initiative doesn't give us more data or less data because that doesn't necessarily change. We're looking at, you know, what are the units within those zonings that are allowed to have transient rentals? What are those numbers? There's been different counts being done. We're trying to nail that down. Part of our cleanup and the TOT certificates is to go out and say, here's a certificate, how many units apply to that? So each unit has a number. Looking at the single family as well, multi-family. So this is a town-wide element that we're working through that on.
3:52:50 Also, the illegal units, obviously, we can't go out and count those, or they wouldn't be illegal. We'd be trying to close them down. We have a fluctuation anywhere from estimates below 100 to 150 units out there in the community at some point in time. If you go online and try to look under one of the Airbnb-type operations for Mammoth, you get stuff popping up all over town. Now, whether those are actually
3:53:17 Legitimate, and you could actually rent them for less than 30 days. I haven't tried to do it, so. But trying to do some of that type of enforcement element, and that ties into the other piece to that. So we're really looking at that element to say to do that. What the initiative would definitely do, it clarifies without question, here's the zones where it's currently not allowed, that all continues to not be allowed in those zones. So it really reemphasized the current zoning and puts that in place.
3:53:45 More stringently, so it can't be changed at the council level. So it would not change any zoning. It would just take the zoning that currently exists and say that if you wanted to change anything in this zone, you'd have to require a vote of the people to change it. Right. And to change the transient rental component. Okay. Simply with regard to that. Right. So if we want to put zoning on some existing property and put commercial zoning on an area, we could do that.
3:54:12 But the transient element of that zoning would not be allowed on that property. Okay. Sorry, I'm looking at Andy then. So you could still change the zoning, but you could not put transient zoning on that property, even if it was allowed under the normal commercial zoning. Okay, now I'm going to pull you back because that's not the part under discussion tonight, right? In terms of the enforcement side, if we change that zoning, we have to make sure that very clearly then that this commercial zoning
3:54:40 Doesn't allow transient units because it's an overlay on top of what was approved by the voters. So that does add a uniqueness to the enforcement side and some of our workload that would fall into that. I'm reading the initiative correctly in that area to have that walk through there. The quality of life ordinance, again, we're looking at moving that forward. The initiative doesn't enhance or take away the quality of life stuff. I mean, if there's CC&Rs, they're still enforced. If there's zoning, it's still there.
3:55:09 The challenges, I think, would be from the quality of life are those rental properties that are actually legally allowed to happen. We're trying to go in and work with them. You know, you've got to meet parking. You've got to meet trash. You've got to meet, you know, notification, those types of elements to clean that up. The council's given us a list of items to address within that area. And so if there's illegal use, you really don't have a quality of life component to say here you must comply with these rules. It's just you can't.
3:55:39 Do this activity. It's an enforcement side. We do have some folks who rent creatively in terms of 31 days or multifamilies over time that are legal that the quality of life ordinance would not apply to those legal longer term rentals, if you will. The enforcement program kind of touched on that. We start to work through those elements in terms of, you know,
3:56:08 How do we enforce this? How do we go out? We have two different levels of enforcement. Right now, a lot of it's been cleaning up the legal activity. Those who rent legally but maybe aren't reporting correctly or they don't turn in a monthly report even if they have no activity. We're going through a lot of that process, again, in terms of cleaning up that side of the house. The other piece to that in terms of, excuse me, the illegal side,
3:56:37 We will start gearing up to that again that we have staff, but that hasn't been a priority for the last several months and we're trying to get the other data in place and make sure that those who are legally renting their property are doing so properly. In some cases we're also finding people not reporting and so we're bringing them into compliance in those types of areas. When we talk about again in terms of kind of like making the initiative would make
3:57:04 Permanently lock in the zoning. Again, that permanently statement is based on council voting, not on a community vote. But if you have a property that says you can't do it there, if you were to change the zoning through the town process, again, yet still you couldn't put transient rental in there. So that looks at two different zoning designations. If you have a commercial zone that allows transient, a commercial then that would not if it actually got overlaid on top of the current zoning that doesn't allow transient rentals under the initiative. Hope that's...
3:57:35 It's a little muddy, but I hope it's getting clearer. But again, a permanently change on that property is, again, assuming voters don't overturn it down the road. We're also running, you know, this is a broader issue of our enforcement that I mentioned with the Airbnb stuff. The technology element out there is really challenging in what people are doing and the creativity that's coming into some of that. I mentioned, you know, people renting creatively. We've actually had the example where they're very
3:58:02 Clear on their advertising that they can't rent less than 31 days. However, if you only want to be there for a few days, that's all we'll charge you for, but you have a rental agreement for 31 days. So they're creative, which they're technically legal. But anyway, the challenge there is that they actually have another renter coming and then we can go ding them. So we haven't seen a lot of that, but people are creative in terms of knowing what the rules are and living within the rules.
3:58:33 In that process. And so as we look at that element, as it drops into the whole question on that enforcement program, there's some real uniquenesses to that. And again, I would say the initial doesn't help or hurt in that area, but it doesn't really give us any more tools than we currently have. And if you do end up with some crossover zoning sometime in the future, it makes that process maybe a little more complicated in some cases. Potentially not necessarily. Absolutely.
3:59:03 The community conversation determined if there's a need for a change. This was kind of one of the discussions with the council looking at that. Having that discussion, again, one of the council's goals when we set a while back was to deal with the issue of transient rentals. I think that whole issue was how do we deal with the illegal rentals out there. We know there's a lot of neighborhoods where they're not allowed, period, by CC&Rs. They're not allowed by zoning. But there's also, if somebody is doing something illegally in an area that...
3:59:31 That neighborhood might say, we don't mind this. There's no way for them to become legal without going through a full master plan or a zone change process. I think at one point, do you do an overlay? Do you have other tools you could utilize? Again, where it would be legally acceptable under the current zoning and it would be something I think a neighborhood or residents would come in and say, we would like to do this. This would preclude that discussion from happening.
3:59:59 It changes that discussion. And I think that's part of the goal of the time. We don't want that to happen maybe. And the other area, we've got a lot of correspondence related to areas that are governed by CC&Rs. I don't think the council's ever had an intent to change those, nor legally can they. I'm assuming the owners could all get together at some point and say, hey, we want to change these and vote accordingly and go through a process to change the CC&Rs.
4:00:23 So, but having the question is, is there a real need out there for any modification in the transient program? Obviously, the discussion would be somewhat moot if you restrict the areas to the existing resort where it's allowed. Unless you want to restrict it out of those, I guess, would be the other question, I guess. You could have that type of dialogue. And then the other question, of course, would be is if the council came back with anything.
4:00:49 With or without the initiative in place, would you put that out to a vote? Obviously, if the initiative is in place and you want to change it, that's going to be a voter process, whether you adopt the initiative or whether it's adopted by the voters. That still requires that. Some of the other considerations noted, these were questions or comments that came up from folks. The voter requirement, one of the challenges there is always with initiatives.
4:01:11 Tried to take a look out there at how many initiatives, if we had any with a good count for signatures to say how many have been passed based on that. I really couldn't find a good analogy for that. The other side of that was local initiatives tend to do better than statewide initiatives. I think it was about a 45% success rate based. I think it was a study done between 90 and 2002. Truly initiatives, not those initiated by the council, for example, where they got the signatures required and got placed on the ballot.
4:01:42 And part of that analysis would be, you know, if you have enough signatures, the question is, does it pass? That's not always the case in terms of some of that. But there's not a great database to look at and analyze that from, so I wouldn't read too much into that. But that question comes up, you know, in the initiatives where we want the voters to make it direct to be responsible for this. We want it to be a voter initiative process. One of those questions becomes, and it's a broader question of,
4:02:09 Do you want the voters to vote on it? And then if you do, then council doesn't adopt it. You put it to the voters regardless of the signature count. But then again, Dan, we're not going to consider any of that tonight, right? No, that's not before you tonight. Can we just focus on what we're going to consider tonight? So the other issue on that was the impact in terms of time frame. This does live beyond any of our other planning documents, which again, I think was the intent. But if you updated your general plan, you'd always need to remind yourselves or keep in that this supersedes any of those types of actions.
4:02:39 The questions that we actually had some emails in regarding property rights and can the council zone things out and put this in place. Bottom line is, yes, you have land use authority that you can do and it and you can deal with the detailed legal side of that if you need more detail on that. But the other side of this, there are people that feel like, hey, I'm disenfranchised, I can't do this. Well, if you don't live here, you don't get to vote. So you're kind of out of luck on that side of it.
4:03:08 It does lock in the current planning documents, I think, again, unless you're having a voter initiative, again, to change it. It says, here's what we're doing with transient is locked in. The other zoning is not, but the transient piece would be locked in. And then the impact on rental markets, it can actually go either direction in different, if you want to look at that analysis, that could happen to that. I won't spend a lot of time on that. The other element comes in in terms of the fiscal impact.
4:03:35 You know, we know there's dollars out there related to transient rentals. You take that off the table, that is a potential impact of the town. It's hard to measure because illegal activity shouldn't be part of our revenue stream to start with, but it's there. Similar to speeding tickets or parking tickets, it's not a way to make money, but they're there as we enforce things that comes into that. The question would be is if you really don't, if we take off the table the ability to rent that product,
4:04:03 In a broader sense, does that have a diminishing impact ultimately on long-term revenue to town? It's subjective, but it has the potential there to do that. I won't walk through all the legal framework that's in the staff report, but part of that issue was to lay that out and walk through what it does. If there's questions on that, Andy can address that specifically in terms of the legal framework that goes through those various pieces and how we control land, et cetera, for that issue.
4:04:34 The item not before you is whether or not to take it forward one way or the other because we don't have that item before you at this point. We did walk through in terms of where staffs coordinate the clerk's office as mentioned earlier. We've got some preliminary numbers. If you do a special election, the impact financial is about $50,000, give or take, and standard election would be $12,000 to $15,000. If it's consolidated between two of us, the cost would likely be less. We haven't really asked for that number at this point.
4:05:05 To have that happen. And so the idea in the report tonight, there's no really official action we're asking council to take other than understanding some of the issue that's come out that a lot of the questions raised regarding some of these other key elements, how the initiative does or doesn't impact those. And if there's any additional information in terms of the council wants to see brought forward, we can do that. Or if the community has items they want to see brought forward, we can do that as well.
4:05:34 And to help with the ongoing discussion up to where we have the decision before the council on how you want to actually handle the initiative, which again will be before you and most likely your next meeting. With that, I'll answer any questions. If there's clarifying questions or if there's other legal questions, we can respond to those as well to walk through that. Okay, let me see if I can summarize that. To essentially the new information is that the
4:06:03 Data is expected to be completed by fall of 2015, that the quality of life ordinance will be coming to council in mid-July, that we have a fully staffed enforcement program at this point, so we can carry forward on the third one, and then the other considerations, legal framework and financial considerations are essentially the new pieces that you're bringing to us tonight.
4:06:29 Okay, so before we go to any kind of public comment on those areas, are there any questions of staff before we start? I have a question. Okay. On the legal framework, the staff report reads, the proposed initiative freezes all the current regulations and prohibits transit rentals in certain areas, writes those rules into the general plan, and requires voter approval to change those rules.
4:06:59 If it writes it into the general plan, is there a CEQA component to that or no? No. Voter initiatives are completely exempt from CEQA. Okay. But it is the same type of action that theoretically would require CEQA except because it's a voter initiative. It does not trigger CEQA. It would require some level of environmental review. It probably would not be a fully IR or be relatively small. But as I said, voter initiatives are totally exempt. Really? Okay. Okay. Thank you. Andy, you had alluded
4:07:32 Due to the possibility of a school election in November, do we have any sense for when that might be concrete one way or the other? I don't know exactly. I think that we hope to contact the school district this week and find out when they plan on making a decision. They're going to have to get going because it would probably be the first Tuesday in November. And so they need to call for that within a couple months.
4:08:00 So we just don't know yet. We'll be trying to get that information as soon as we can. Okay. And if that, let's say that does happen and that fits within the time frame of the 88 to 103 days? Well, the school district election will be outside that time frame. Correct. But if it's outside that time frame, we can still follow, we can postpone our election if we have one outside that time frame ourselves so as to consolidate with them. Right. So we would just have to know yay or nay within that 88 to 103 days. Okay.
4:08:29 Madam Mayor, one follow-up question. Related. So, reading, so let's say that the initiative passes and the question then goes back out to the voters to change something on it, is there again no CEQA coming back the other way? There's no CEQA for any voter initiative, whether it's this initiative or any future initiative that might modify or undo this initiative. It's exempt from CEQA the whole way through. It's exempt from CEQA. If the council initiates it.
4:08:56 If the council would initiate something, there would be CEQA. Correct. Yeah. Okay. Right. So if the council decides to submit something to the voters, CEQA is required, but if it's something that's placed on the ballot before the voters because some group in the community collected signatures, then it's exempt. Interesting. Thank you. Okay. Then I will open this up for public comment. If you have comment, please come to the podium, state your name, and you will be limited to five minutes.
4:09:25 Concise statements will be appreciated. Also realizing that you may comment on things that are not part of our discussion tonight and will not respond to them. It's a little odd. I'm Craig Martino. I wrote a letter to the town council that I believe you have. It relates to the staff report. So I assume it's something I can comment on. The real issues, I think, is just to point out what I believe the staff report and Dan corrected some of the things.
4:09:53 But I don't think he corrected all of them that are misleading and incorrect in the staff report. Probably the most important one is that the initiative itself somehow calls for a requirement of a voter approval initiative. It does not. The initiative states that if there are any changes to transient rentals, that's what requires a voter approval. The initiative, and our belief is that the town
4:10:22 And I understand Dan disagrees and others that we've got so many signatures that it would in fact pass and therefore the council should consider adopting it as opposed to incurring the cost of a special election assuming we can't now bring it with the school district. So that's the first issue. I think we need to make it very clear that the initiative does nothing other than take away from the council the power to change transient rentals and single-family rentals.
4:10:50 It's a very limited restriction on the town's council's control or power. They can do anything else they want in town and in the residential areas as far as zoning. They simply will not, if the initiative passes, they will not be able to change transient rental regulations, the prohibition, without getting voter approval of that. So I'm not certain, and I'm not a CEQA expert in any way, but I don't believe that
4:11:18 This initiative is somehow skirting CEQA because this initiative doesn't change the zoning. It maintains the zoning that's currently in the zoning and the general plan. As a result, to try and argue that by putting a voter initiative we somehow skirted CEQA, I think that's incorrect because it's simply not making any kind of changes, therefore I don't think there would be any possible way CEQA could apply. As far as Dan's comments, he made, I think it's a little bit incorrect.
4:11:45 If the property is currently zoned, RRR, RSF1, or RFM1, and the initiative passes, then the town council, you can change the zoning. If you want to pull a property from those three zoned areas and now zone it commercial, then you can do so, but that will still, the restrictions on transient rentals will still stay there. The initiative has nothing to do with the commercial property. If it's currently commercial,
4:12:13 The town can do whatever it wants. This initiative that passes has no restriction on that commercial or RMF2. It was intended to be drafted very limited, very narrow, and the only power, the only thing it does is take away the power to change transient rentals. So I think that's my concern. And again, if you read my letter, I think there are various other issues that are somewhat incorrect. Dan has clarified that it doesn't lock in anything. There can still be the discussion.
4:12:43 About all the whether or not you want to expand transient rentals, whether it should be expanded, where it should be expanded. All of that discussion can still take place even if the initiative passes. It just means that the community then has to vote on it. Town Council can give your opinion and we suggest that you should change it this way. You put it out to the voters and they'll vote on it. So I think that needs to be very clear. And we believe that you shouldn't spend the money and the time and energy of a special election because we don't think it's necessary. Thank you.
4:13:13 Thank you, Greg. Can I just ask a clarifying question? I have a question. The question is, I would like some clarity about the issue as to whether or not this voter initiative will rewrite and affect the general plan. It will affect the general plan because it will add transient rental prohibitions that are not currently in the general plan to the general plan. Okay. I just want to make sure that we're clear about that.
4:13:44 That this initiative, and I see Kathy nodding her head, it will affect the general plan. I just think that's important to be clear about that. Thank you. Is there anyone else who would like to make comments? I'm counting down. Yes, if you want to, please, if you want to, we need to come to the podium. Well, as you probably put, my name is Bernard Altsbach. I'm a resident for over 50 years. And we've been gone for more than 10 years.
4:14:20 To rigorous zoning procedures up to here. They finally came to some agreement. They checked other areas, key areas, from the east, any place, north, wherever you live. They went to all doors and got information, which I don't think has happened yet, here. And now, all of a sudden, if we voted you in,
4:14:47 Just so that for only what happens on the outside or aren't you also committed to the people that live here and live here for a while and they would like to, they choose the outside, they choose the places where they want to live. They choose because they have all the restrictions that you don't have 25 people coming at night, you know.
4:15:14 How do you not? Because they don't care. There's nobody to watch. If you have a condominium or a bed and breakfast, the owner is interested in what happens to his house. Some of the people that have here run down houses are not interested in that. They're interested in the money that comes in. The neighborhood has to put up there. And I hope that you can put something like this.
4:15:45 Thank you. Thank you. Is there anyone else? I'll bite. My name is Kathy Cage. A couple of things. The first is I'd like to just reiterate very simply what the initiative is about. It's just about who decides. It's all it's really about. It locks the current standards in place, and it shifts the decision-making from the town council to the voters.
4:16:20 That's it. That's all it does. So it doesn't restrict any discussions, any information gathering, any establishment of processes. It's just the final decision, if the initiative passes, would shift the decision making in this narrow area from the town council to the voters. That's it. So that's my first thing. The second thing is some input on your section 9212 report that the council had asked for. I can see in your sort of other considerations area, you're sort of roughly
4:16:49 You've got areas that are roughly based on what the Section 9212 report allows you to evaluate. I don't know, Council, did you ever get one of these things that says the Section 9212 report can cover these eight items? Yes, Kathy, we did that on March 18th. Very good. So I would like to give a little community impact on that, if we could. So the first question is, do all the impacts listed have to be negative?
4:17:14 Right now it looks like they're all negative impacts. So it comes off as like a political document. Normally staff documents are not supposed to be political. So I'd like to ask for an evaluation of potential positive impacts, which is why a lot of people want to see this happen. So for instance,
4:17:31 When we talk about disenfranchising a large number of people who might have an interest in Mammoth, on the other hand, people who can't vote, might be actually completely thrilled about this because they may have purchased their home in a residential neighborhood with certain understandings about what that means in a traditional kind of residential neighborhood character and that if it went to transient, it would change that. So you've got a whole bunch of other...
4:17:56 People that can't vote who would appreciate that. So that's a potential positive impact. I mean, I have a number of other things, and so I'm wondering if it's appropriate if I could provide those potentially and that could be considered as part of your staff input on your 92-12 report. So that's one question.
4:18:15 And then there's a whole other area on your 92-12 report that has to do with potential effects on housing and availability and location of housing, regional housing needs. I wonder if it might be appropriate to get input from our housing organization from that as part of the formal and technical input as to what the impact on this might be on that. So that's my testimony. Thank you. Thank you, Kathy. Is there anyone else?
4:18:50 Sandy Hogan, I think Kathy actually covered a lot of the important things about the whole intent of the initiative because the staff report is really more designed towards the 92-12 report and it does have some holes that need to be filled in but basically the one issue that you have to remember it's the only it's not what could be done in an initiative it's who makes the decision.
4:19:18 That's really the bottom line of this. That's why there are no environmental effects. Whatever. It just says, Town Council, you could become the recommender, but you would not be the decider. Only the people. The power would go to the people. A direct democracy. Some people don't like that idea. Well, sometimes there are. And I think you guys know, this is not directed at you guys. You're all new to this. It just has come up so many times. And the people that I see here have been...
4:19:47 Hearing it for years and fearing it for years. And when it came up this last time, you know, for two and a half years, we've had a group, Mammoth Neighborhoods Group, who's been trying to get those facts out to everybody and talk to people. And when this came up as a priority, everybody said no. And Kathy came forward, she said, let's do an initiative. And that's why. That's why. I think she even asked you about an advisory vote, and she felt like she kind of was shined on.
4:20:16 So, you know, it's the listening that has to occur. The people here, and a lot of them are condo owners. Some of the people sitting in here are condo owners that will tell you. And some of them, if they were second home owners, you know, and I think you have a letter from one of them say, you know, we bought, knowing where we bought, that we want to reside with neighbors that we know, not a bunch of bachelor parties going on. Those are the kind of things that matter. So remember, the initiative is who decides.
4:20:46 Not what the issue is, but who decides. Those second homeowners can't vote, but I can tell you, they support, if they live in a residential area, they support what we're doing. They're not investors. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay, seeing none, I will bring it back. So, Council, our decision tonight is whether or not, having reviewed the information provided so far, if there's an...
4:21:18 Any additional information that is needed under Section 92.12? I have a, I'm confused as to whether or not this staff report constitutes a 92.12 or not. I think that was, it's not yet? I don't, I don't think it's intended to be. It's pretty apparent to that, even though it's mentioned right in the top, it's provided report back pursuant to? Yeah, it's, you'll recall that the Section 92.12 says that you can ask for a report on seven specific categories and then a catch-all that's anything else you want.
4:21:50 And this is not really formatted that way. It's not really structured that way. You did ask for a report along those lines in March, but I don't think this is it. Okay. No, because I'm looking at the March agenda bill and there were several things there that were not included, so I guess I'm kind of confused as to...
4:22:08 It's why we're getting this piece when we weren't getting it. It's coming forward based on that last discussion with the questions and that process. The five policy items. Okay, then let me restate it. Is there anything within this report that or additional questions that council thinks needs to be answered knowing that at the next meeting we'll be discussing the actual initiative and not the final 92-12 report?
4:22:38 Very much appreciate the initiative proponents who met with Councilmember Fernie and I, and I appreciate my fellow Councilmembers for taking the time to walk through those five questions. I appreciate the staff's analysis, and I appreciate the understanding and the representation that this, you know, in order to achieve, I think, the goals and the objectives of the proponents,
4:23:07 There are certain legal things that will happen, such as an adjustment to the general plan. I think it's important to understand that. And so I appreciate that analysis. I'm looking forward to further discussion as we get down to the question at hand. Nothing to add. Just one comment for staff, you know, and kind of...
4:23:29 My time doing a bunch of research on this subject in general, one of the things I stumbled across is, you know, Dan, you kind of alluded to Airbnb, VRBO, I mean, the plethora of properties that are on those sites, different neighborhoods, different restrictions, different agreements, etc. It could be pretty cumbersome, but one thing I would suggest as we look to move towards a credible enforcement program, I know that
4:23:57 Vail has employed the use of kind of like an internet trolling bot. It's like a Google bot that seeks through VRBO, Airbnb, et cetera, looking for meta tags that kind of alert it to a potential inconsistency with the zoning. So I think that's something. I don't know the cost of it, but I would anticipate that that would diminish a lot of man hours. It kind of just flags.
4:24:27 The Planning Department and lets them know that something might be amiss and to pay attention to this specifically and sifts through the other, you know, 2,000 homes listed on there. So as you're looking to develop the enforcement program, that would be something I would suggest you look into. And we know somebody's written that. Yes. So just real quick, Annie, just for clarification, because regarding a couple legal things on comments that were made, the initiative would
4:24:58 Locked down the ability to, for the council to change the zoning to single family, not just in homes, but also in condos and so forth and so on. Is that correct or incorrect? You wouldn't be able to change the zoning so as to allow transient rentals for any property that's within three zones affected by the initiative. Right. So, as I mentioned at our last meeting, on a particular condo complex that has split zoning today.
4:25:28 And we've been internally looking at that. That would prohibit us to change the third to be, to go into two thirds. You could change the zoning to make both halves of it consistent. It's just that no matter what you do, you wouldn't be able to allow transient rentals in the part that's within one of the three zones. You could allow transient rentals in the rest of it, ban them in the rest of it, but no matter what you do, whichever direction you shift to make the zoning consistent, you wouldn't be able to allow transient rentals in the part that's within.
4:25:58 One of the three zones. And that is effective as of the filing of the initiative, correct? Well, the initiative was written such that basically anything, Greg can help me out, but no changes can be made after December 31st of last year. Gotcha. So it even predates that. Yeah, it's essentially retroactive. Right. Okay.
4:26:28 Before the initiative passes, it's inconsistent. The initiative passes, it does. Right. Right. Understood. I just had that question specifically, and, you know, they called out that inconsistency at the condo complex you're referring to, and I said, you know, I think at this point it's too late for anything like that. Okay. Then, other than considering the Google bot, I think that's the only change I want to ask for at this point.
4:27:00 I'm good. Again, I appreciate the work by staff and the looking at the priorities that the council is pursuing to tackle and deal with a single-family rental program and the role the initiative may or may not play relative to those goals and priorities. So I thank you for that. Thanks. All right, so you have your direction.
4:27:25 That will take us on to item number 15, which is a status report regarding diff study and preliminary project list. Could I ask you to please take your conversations outside? Thank you. Could I ask you to take the conversations outside, please? We're trying to conduct a meeting here. Item number 15, Dan? Yeah, thank you, Madam. I'll kick it off shortly, then I'll hand it to Grady to work through this.
4:28:00 Without relaying a lot of the information that's in kind of the staff report, you do have kind of the background of how we got to where we're at today. The item that is coming before you is we wanted to kind of bring that elements that impact the development impact fee program, the projects that impact that. And I have a dialogue about that before we actually had the consulting firm spend a whole lot of time putting the fees together and we come back and say, well, we got the project list wrong.
4:28:28 Because it really helps drive the final analysis that comes into play. And so as we took this to the Planning and Economic Development Commission, they make a finding of consistency with the general plan for the projects. They had some other concerns they raised. We can touch on those to work through that. And so we've been trying to work through again with the consultant. We've been meeting with some of the stakeholders as well through the process.
4:28:53 I think the one clarification I'd like to make, and we can get more detail as need be on this, is we have a list of projects that total a little over $88 million. That does not mean that development will pay $88 million. These projects is allocated out. There's a whole section in the report that has to look at other funding sources, be that grants, be they...
4:29:18 The second element is going through that and say how much of any one of these projects can you actually allocate
4:29:48 To the new development piece. I think that's the mitigation that you really have to look at. So if you have a project and there's only 10% of it that you can allocate to new development, your fee is based on that 10% allocation, not on the total project. I think those are key elements. I think at the Planning Commission there was a little concern just over the $88 million, which is substantially, I think the last project list was $300 million plus, so it's been narrowed down.
4:30:16 We'll get into that in detail on that. So I think that the first caveat, just as people look at this and the concern, we're really looking at a project list here and trying to get confirmation that there's really something on here that can't be just reconciled, that it should be on the list. That's great. Let us know that. But also understanding that not everything on here would be paid out of a diff allocation, definitely not 100% of it.
4:30:43 There are a couple in here that are probably 100% developer-driven, but again, that wouldn't be general diff and impacting. It would be tied to that development. I can provide more detail and walk through that and more robust if you wish to do that, and I could give you one example if you want an hour later how that would work. Why don't you go ahead and do that? Okay. For example, let me just take the first one on the list, police department. Right now we're in a lease building. We don't own any facility.
4:31:12 So in looking at the process for that, right now the program here would say we need to replace that current facility with a permanent one that we own and again, future expansion and stuff. So you look at that and say here's a police station, $2.2 million. You do an analysis that says how much of that is current versus new development and it comes out, I think it's about 20% or so would be allocated to new development.
4:31:40 80% of it stays with the current development. So when you lay out a diff fee, there's only a small portion of that, or in this case say that 20%, that would actually be allocated to the diff calculation. And you're doing that because you're looking at the impact of new development versus existing residents and benefits from that project. So you have that type of allocation that has to be made through that.
4:32:08 And then, for example, let's say we got a COPS grant that would pay for a million dollars of this. We could use that, and then the whole project would go down to 1.2 million, and then that would be allocated, say, 20% of new development and 80% back to the existing residents. And so there's offsetting on those types of pieces. If you look just a little ways down in the list, at ST19, there's a Minaret Forest Trail intersection improvements, 1.5 million dollars.
4:32:38 We anticipate that the vast majority of that, if not all of that, would be funded out of the current community facilities district in that area. There's money set aside for this particular project. And that because of the nature of the development, say the east village development, that could be 100% allocated to that particular project. Now you go through it, there may be a small piece that gets into the diff, but ideally there it's being driven by that new development. It's their impact. They would have to mitigate it accordingly.
4:33:08 And so as we walk through these lists, not everything is going to get passed on to all new developers paying $88 million. I think I just want to make that clear, a substantial number smaller as you go through those analysis. If there's any kind of broad questions I can address, otherwise I'll have Grady kind of walk through the process of how we got to the list and some of the key elements of it. Just a question. When it comes back to us, those percentages will show?
4:33:36 Yes. And will it also let us know which ones are mitigation through CEQA documents? Because it might be, we could say, oh no, we don't want to improve any new section, but it's a requirement, right? It's a CEQA requirement, and that's not noted here anywhere. Correct. This is essentially just the initial project list to see if it kind of makes sense to what we're looking for in the future. Let me go through the process of how we're not hearing that question will be answered.
4:34:02 We started with the list that was populated in 2007. It was indeed $388 million. We had things that were likely not to be built for 20, 30, or even 50 years. So our first goal was to try to make it realistic in terms of what might actually be done in the next five years was kind of our first threshold. That was an easy list. The next was 10 years after that. What is actually possible? The reason you can't really just stop at five is that if you only have a five-year outlook,
4:34:29 We're not collecting very much money. You'll probably never get anything done because if you anticipate a project in year six, here it is. You haven't been collecting money for five years. You're never going to get there. So we tried again to put some reason into it. And just so you understand, in the next staff report, when you get the full package with the percentages and everything, we actually took that old spreadsheet. It's about four pages long, if you will. And we kept the same project numbers that are on this list.
4:34:56 And we're actually going to identify why these are no longer on the list. A great number of them actually are complete. One of the questions we had as we began looking at this was, well, gee, you can't do $88 million in 15 years. Since 2007, if you look at the old list, over $23 million worth of work on that list has been completed. The Lakes Basin Path is on there. There's a number of other facilities, some work at the garage, at the shop out here. So in actuality, in the last seven years, there has been $23 million worth of work done.
4:35:25 Most of it was not done with diff funds. Most of it was done with grant monies. Just the work we did last year on Uridium, in fact, the whole program last year, as I reported previously, was $6.5 million. $6.2 million of that was grant monies, and we're going to continue to look for those things. But we wanted to populate the list with something that, again, made some sense. In terms of development projects and mitigation, the planning department has put together, frankly,
4:35:54 Quite extensive spreadsheet which identifies projects that identify these various things, the intersections and things like that. We have not finished that analysis to identify, you know, every single dollar, every single mitigation. Some of those were fair shares. Some of them are listed for projects that haven't happened yet. Some of them have to pay gift fees. We'll be working hard in the next week or so to do that.
4:36:16 In terms of the process, we have a meeting scheduled, a meeting at a telephone conference next Wednesday afternoon with some of the stakeholders, some of the local developers, the construction industry, some of the local attorneys, and I use attorneys, Mr. Carmel is on the last one to be here again, I'm sure, basically to give a comment. Before that meeting, hopefully a couple of days before so they have a chance to digest it, we're going to give them a draft report.
4:36:42 From the consultant, which takes that first shot at those percentages, we're actually looking at a pre-draft right now. Look, this is what I'm thinking. We started looking at it yesterday, yesterday, so we don't have anything to provide to anybody yet, but we hope to do that by early next week so that they can have a chance to look at it and give us comments on the rationale. Do we think the process was sound? Do we think the rationale that the consultant is using?
4:37:07 It's real good. The fees in our estimation without having to be final numbers will go down more than significantly. It's not as much as I can say, many of them as much as 70%, so 30% of the level that was there a few years ago. So we're going to see some significant changes. The biggest difference, I think, is that there's going to be, in our opinion as consultants, a real nexus between what needs to happen out there, what's development driven, and what these percentages mean. The previous report was,
4:37:37 We went to the Planning and the Development Commission. The only thing we asked them to do, in fairness, was to look at each individual project and say, well, do you believe these projects individually are consistent with the general plan? Or is a police station a good idea of the general plan? Is it consistent? Yes. And they voted.
4:38:06 To make that finding. They did have some great comments about quality of life and should we do all these projects at once. And while we, you know, we appreciated those comments, we said, look, we need to pass those on. We'll write those up for you before the next council meeting because those are important, but it didn't weigh on whether the individual projects were consistent with the general plan.
4:38:30 With that, any questions, I suppose? Again, we might go to stakeholders next Wednesday and we're back to council in June. We're targeting June 3rd, but we need to check the noticing requirements for this particular type of report, so it may need to slide on meetings, but we're trying to get this done as quickly as possible. I've got a couple questions. Thank you very much for this effort. So I see Tom Hodges is still here. I'm assuming, is Mark Carney still here? Is he gone?
4:38:57 I'm assuming the development community has been involved in these conversations? Yeah. Yeah, that's fine. My question is just that this, we're going through a very, pretty radical change between the old diff culture and a new diff culture. I just want to make sure there's not going to be any surprises as this moves forward. And I think, no, it's okay. And my question then is, so the representation of the community's interests at this point in these conversations is
4:39:25 Between staff, which is managing this list, and representation back to council, is that correct? Correct. So... Well, but John, it's gone to Planning Commission and the Recreation Board went to Recreation Commission. I understand, but it's living within the town. There's no community stakeholders involved in this process, right? Yeah, not from an organizational standpoint. We've had the contractors involved and we've had some of the stakeholders involved in discussions and looking at some of the initial policy type so we're not spinning our wheels on something that's going to...
4:39:54 Be heavily opposed. Okay. The projects that have been identified in development agreements that are not mitigation for CEQA, but they're written in development agreements, are those projects on this list, or are they separate and live within the terms of those master plans and development agreements? The only one that I'm aware of that's written in development agreement, 100%, or very close to that, is the intersection of Forest Trail and Interact.
4:40:19 The rest of them, some of them are mitigations in environmental impact reports or other secret documents. I don't know if each of those had a development agreement or not. Well, I'm just wondering because I think in the Snow Creek 8 master plan and that development agreement, there are community benefit things in there that I'm assuming would not be on this diff list. That's correct. Okay, so they're separate. In terms of managing and maintaining and updating this list, that's public works. As projects get completed and they come off and they go.
4:40:48 As it gets updated, and then through planning commission or whatever, and then back to us. Is that correct? Yes, and I'd like to add that one of the commitments, I guess, from staff and from council's direction should be, we're coming back in four or five years. We need to do this more regularly to have an update because things change.
4:41:04 Okay, and then a final question is when you're setting these ratios about what's new development versus what's existing, is that based on a quantitative analysis? I mean, is that something you can actually quantify in a way or is it?
4:41:27 Very much so. Again, we stress to the consultant, he's done this all over the country, that there has to be a strong nexus for each of these. As an example, some of the traffic improvements, his initial percentage for some of them is 17.2% based on the traffic growth between now and 2035 over the next 20 years. We're looking at that to see that we agree with those percentages, because again, that's his first shot, but definitely the key is there has to be a nexus. This has to withstand.
4:41:54 Okay, so maybe, Tom, does that all sound right to you? Real quick, John, if I can add that. Sure. What they look at is the trip generation for traffic, they look at land use issues, square footage, they can look at employee generation, they can look at the number of people coming in, so it's like, in a park side, you may look at, you know, acres per thousand residents or something of that nature, so they go through each of those, so each one has a metric.
4:42:22 Sorry, Tom. Sorry, Tom, to impact your legs there.
4:42:51 While we're on that subject, you know, maybe something that isn't as clear to me is like a sidewalk or a street light or storm drain. Can you speak to that kind of nexus on, let's say, for example, recreation center? Yes. Rec centers, the recreation generally ties to a level of service component.
4:43:16 That the community either establishes, you'll see a lot of times in a master plan or even through a general plan that for X number of population, we want X number of tennis courts or we want X amount of square feet of a recreation facility. And so you look at that and say that rec center then for that level of service should come in and say that's going to serve, you know, currently 8,000 people. So the extent that it's serving that 8,000, there's no diff impact.
4:43:44 If it's designed to serve $15,000, then the rest of the people coming in would pay their fair share through a diff program over a defined period of time that you would look at. So it really is what is that level of service you want to set for your community? And then as other people move in, there's that impact coming in. What is their fair share to participate in that cost of the impact versus having the existing residents cover the cost for everybody?
4:44:11 And I just get to come in and enjoy the fruits of somebody else's labor. And so it's a level of service standards that you can set. And that's a good one, too, to look at that and go, well, it's $15 million, but the real question, we'll have a little bit of discussion, how much of that is other funding, private, other town funding, other pieces that go into that, grants. So that might end up being a $2 or $3 million project that gets allocated from a diff standpoint. Okay.
4:44:40 Tom, please, yeah. Thank you. Actually, that was the point I was going to make, Dan. I think Dan and Gray are on a great track here, I think, in terms of really defining that there's a true nexus to, you know, the impacts. So, you know, we're not really to that point yet, at least to the stakeholders' participation. They have involved us, and we're looking forward to getting that list and assisting with, you know, scrubbing that down and understanding it. But I think that, you know, the pertinent part of the discussion that I want to bring up was
4:45:07 Yeah, there are other methods to pay for these things. And as Grady alluded to, you know, there's been grants here that have paid for a lot of these sidewalk improvements, you know, the safe school routes that paid for a lot of the sidewalks over here and the grants you received for the Meridian project that were formerly DIFF projects. So when we look at this list, let's recognize that there's more than one way to skin the cat. This doesn't all have to come from DIFF to pay for it. It can be paid through grants. There may be some of those projects that would be.
4:45:36 Could be fulfilled through Measure R, Measure U Funds, for example. Well, I guess I think my point is that the last DIFF program, things really broke down, I think from the developer's perspective, that the DIFF program was not a credible program. Oh, yeah, it ended up being a fixed list that was enormous. Exactly. All the capital improvements for the town. And I think we all recognize that. I just want to make sure that there's going to be...
4:45:57 A sense in the development community that this is a credible list, this is a credible methodology, and we're not going to get into things where community benefits are needed, we're going to start saying this is not a credible program, we're going to try to re-debate the whole thing. Yeah, I think Dan has kept us in the loop and I feel like we are getting the information we need at this point, so I think we're fine there. One last point I would make, just as another consideration, there's been a lot of discussion about EIFDs, right, paying for programs.
4:46:24 Enhanced infrastructure financing districts. And, you know, this is another example of an area where you could apply that law, that new law that provides funding that could be another method to pay for some of these projects and then take the front end burden off of a development impact fee. So keep in mind our bigger initiatives here of trying to make ourselves development friendly, trying to get the ball rolling again in town. We have a pretty fragile recovery here.
4:46:51 The more that we can take a burden off the front end and put it on the back end, might achieve our goals to a better end. Thanks, Tom. Thank you. Okay, can we go back to any questions of staff before we open it up? Well, wait a minute, we haven't gotten to public comment yet. I'm trying to rein John in over here. Dan, when this comes back, the fee is going to come back as a simple fee.
4:47:21 Per door or whatever you want to call it. It's going to be us. By law we have to break it down so you'll have the same fee categories by transportation or by storm drain or by police, by community facilities. You have to break them down that way. But the goal would be that for a retail development or a hotel lodging development or for this.
4:47:43 This is your fee for that category. It'll be cleaner, I think, than what it was. Clean and simple. But it is pretty, hopefully it'll be straightforward. Where the developers can actually pencil that in to perform it. Yeah, we go through some machinations too. Now, I will say, just a reminder too, we're not going to be changing fees that we don't control, i.e. water sewer district fees or fire district fees or school fees. So when we deal with this, we're just doing those that are in the control of the council for safety.
4:48:14 Okay. Any more questions of staff before we open it? So now, Kathy. So I wanted to share a little bit of history. I was on the council when we first put our first DIS into place, and that was at the start of the Interwest Building boom when that came into place. And at the time, we purposely had them very limited. There were lots of things we could have had on the list. So there's – my recollection is there's two policy-level questions that council can answer. What's on the list? And then how much –
4:48:46 You can charge to new development. Staff will tell you the maximum you can charge to new development. You may or may not choose to charge that much to them in their fees. And so we had a lot of discussion at our council about whether we should do that. At the time, we were trying to, I think probably a lot like you, trying to kind of incentivize and kind of build a sense of, you know, this is a great place to be and let's, you know, let's, you know, come to Mammoth and you'll make a lot of profit, that kind of thing.
4:49:13 So that's where it started. Then the Inner West Building Boone happened. Things were going strong. And then everyone, you know, as I think we've said, kind of got greedy. But it started adding projects. I think at the time we basically took all the percentage that attributed new development. We had very, very limited projects. It's hard to argue about, like, sewers and roads. People don't argue about that too much, even developers.
4:49:36 But the kind of things that got added after the fact were like public art, performing arts center, rec center, town offices, police station, those kinds of things were not in the original package, as I recall. I might be a little bit wrong on that. But because we knew that they would be, you know, that would make the fees go pretty high. So I just wanted to kind of emphasize to you that you have the same choice. And, you know, if you don't take...
4:50:00 If you have a project you take off the list completely, it doesn't mean it goes away. It doesn't mean the project goes away. It just means you're making a policy-level decision for the community on behalf of the community that we still think it's a good project, but we will figure out a different way to accomplish that. But we don't feel like having the impact of the burden of that being on the developer.
4:50:21 So I would encourage you to really look very carefully at all the projects on the list with that kind of lens, depending on the policy perspective you come from and whether it's important to incentivize right now or not. But the second thing that doesn't often get talked about is that policy-level decision about whether you want to charge the full amount. Staff will give you a technical side that says you can charge up to this amount.
4:50:45 So that's a policy-level decision to do that or not. And then, you know, you have that shortfall. Where does it come from? It's okay to say we don't know yet. You know, or you can say we'll take that on as a community burden. We still think it's appropriate and that kind of thing. So I just thought it's a good time to kind of set up that discussion because I think it's a perfectly appropriate one at this particular time. And then I do have a staff question. If there are some...
4:51:12 Projects that are on the list currently that we have in the past collected money for and the current council decides to take them off that list. Where does the money that got collected for those projects go and is there anything that happens with that? I'll address my understanding from past practice but if the fees were there and they were collected for a bona fide project at the time, they can still be utilized for that project. Annually you have to make the finding that says yes, the fees are still necessary, the revenue you have is necessary.
4:51:42 It is still a project that is still viable. And if it's beyond five years and you can't make that finding, then you have to refund the fees back. Okay. So let's say Performing Arts Center and Rec Center. We still love those projects. But let's say they decide to take it off the D.I.F. program because it saves a bunch of money. That's still okay to keep those monies hanging out there ready for when we do build it because we haven't.
4:52:09 Said we're not going to build it. We're just saying maybe today we're not going to put impact fees on it from new developers. Yeah, you may not be collecting more impact fees. You still have to make a finding that the project's necessary. There is a way ultimately to finance it and that those fees can go to that project. But there's a finding you have to make, otherwise you end up returning the fees. And my final comment just has to do with developers. I know a lot of times you think developers big D, you know, and I know that's what the mountains, you know, focused on. There's lots of, you know, big dollar guys.
4:52:38 I work every day in my business with the small D developers. It's somebody that owns a lot, and it's either a house or it's a small commercial thing. And people are really astonished at how high our development impact fees are. So it's across the board. You know, it's not just the big, you know, Winer, you know, InterWest types that are saying the impact fees are high. They're really high. They're really, really high. So you can help, you know, sort of.
4:53:04 Everyday, medium-sized people, you know, be able to help develop in town instead of just making a system that works for the big guys. Thank you. Thank you, Kathy. Anyone else you'd like to provide information? Okay. Back here for discussion, I just want to make sure that everybody realizes that AMLR strategy will address any of those that have a potential to fall underneath that strategy, so they will come back.
4:53:35 When we see that strategy as well, we'll be reviewing the same questions or the same ones. Just a couple observations. I'm encouraged, and I hope this is reliable, of the quantifiable metrics that we're talking about, and I think that that should take a certain amount of subjectivity out of this whole process. I'm concerned by Kathy's comments about...
4:54:02 The high level of our diff fees. I mean, my understanding is we've knocked these fees down for years, at least where I'm coming from. I'm thinking that our fees are low or they've been knocked down for sort of the big development things. I'm very concerned about the small to medium activity and I guess this is going to be coming back to us and I'd like to perhaps, I'd like to have some analysis that gives us some sense of where these fees live in the general scheme of things. I don't have the information myself, but I'd like to know
4:54:31 So we can put together a credible program that's not going to be exposed to the comment of, well, you know, your fees are just crazy or things like that. We're trying to get to a credible program. I think it would be helpful to have some data that can help us figure out where we're at. Can you speak a little to the current moratorium? Yeah, because the current fees, I would say, if you just look at the allocations of what was approved or, as Kathy mentioned, what you could levy. We're not doing that.
4:54:57 Reduce fees. In some cases we've waived them completely. So what people are paying today I would say is not excessive. But that's been this ongoing each year. You have a resolution. Do we continue to waive them? Do you reduce them? Now the downside to that, as a mitigation fee, and you're telling somebody you get to pay this fee in lieu of building the project, and that can go for a large project or a small project. To the extent that you say pay the fee but then we don't collect the fee,
4:55:26 We're on the hook. The town has to make that up. Otherwise, you don't have a credible mitigation program. And that's a place, I think, that given our finances, we cannot be. Right. So you want to make sure that the program is legitimate, that you can be able to do that. The same is true as stated. You can set a lower fee, but you have to define how you're going to make that gap up or you don't have a mitigation program. And that comes really important to the CEQA process when you can say,
4:55:53 You have an impact here. Instead of having you build, say, a signal, your small project, your mitigation is to pay the fee. And so that makes it much simpler for a small project to move forward versus having to build a $900,000 or $300,000 signal. And I think it's very important for the credibility of the program if we choose to incentivize.
4:56:15 Big development, small development, whatever that is, we're making conscious decisions to do that, but through this DIF program, if there are effects that need to be mitigated, we're not negotiating things that we can't afford to give away. And that's my goal, is to get that program to that level of focus. And actually, John, that's why I said that we need to have it identified as which ones are mitigation as well as those percentages. And maybe what I'm hearing you say is
4:56:42 If you then take whatever this fee is that we're going to see the next time and say, okay, so it's a development of this much, the amount of so much. If it's a development of this much, it's, you know. It's an impact. So it's like, what do you generate for traffic? Not just telling us percentages, but give us some examples so that you can see that. Exactly. Correct. Yeah, I mean, if you don't have the fee where it makes sense, I mean, nothing's going to happen, right? Right.
4:57:08 Yeah, we just have to refine it. But I think... But the comment to say our fees are low is not accurate. Yeah, I don't know. We've done adjustments on smaller projects, but we're talking about big hotel projects. I mean, it doesn't pencil. That's why you look outside and you don't see anything happen. Well, that's fine. But I think, again, if we...
4:57:28 Are developing a diff program that's credible, that's designed to specifically mitigate the effects of a project, I think we need to be able to represent to the community that these are things that have to get mitigated and they've got to get done. If we want to incentivize something, we do it as a conscious thing that the community understands what we're doing and we're not, you know, messing around with things that we know we have to have that we're choosing not to get built. Colin, do you have any comments?
4:57:59 You know, I think really where the rubber meets the road is when we can look at a fee recommendation. I think we're all pretty acutely aware of the reputation that Mammoth has for, you know, stifling development, having too high, you know, development impact fees. We're looking to change that. I'll be totally honest. I struggled with this. It's confusing to me. I'm not a diff expert. But, you know, overall,
4:58:26 You know, looking at what used to be a $388 million list down to an $88 million list that's 23%. So, yeah, your comment of basically a 70 or 75 plus percent reduction is encouraging. You know, I think all of these projects on here are certainly things that I think we want to pursue.
4:58:51 And, you know, if I'm being told that, you know, this is going to be a credible program that's put forth, you know, with experts looking at this and that there is a tangible nexus, because we've also heard that in the past that, you know, some of the problem with the DIF program is there was no nexus to what was going on development-wise. But I think, you know, like I said, I'm pretty comfortable, I think, moving this forward, you know, pending the fact that overall I think we want to be cognizant of the fact that we don't want to hammer.
4:59:20 Thank you. Thank you.
4:59:49 That's enough direction? Yeah, I just, we really wanted to get, yeah, so we'll utilize this to complete our analysis to come back to the council on it. Okay, that takes us on to policy item number 16, which is approving resolution exempting the town and businesses from mandatory organic recycling requirements. September of last year, the state passed to 1846, which is built in recycling of organic waste. Thank you very much. Recycling of organic waste.
5:00:22 There was an exception or an allowance for an exemption, let's say, in AB 1826 that rural counties and rural jurisdictions could
5:00:32 Grant themselves basically a waiver, exempt themselves from the organic recycling requirements. The reason that was put in is because the bill itself was really focused on larger communities that had established recycling programs that could really handle this. It was recognized that with the rural counties, especially that a county such as Inyo or Mono County with a population base and an enormous geographic area really can't afford to
5:00:58 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
5:01:15 I very frankly did most of the legwork. He's been leading that committee for some time and long before I got involved in it. So we were happy to see that go forward to the county. When they took it up, they had a couple of comments, one in general on the recycling requirements themselves. People wanted to make sure that the county, and I agree the town should also, still needs to focus on this. It's not that we don't think it's important. It's just that the infrastructure isn't in place.
5:01:40 You really have a program. If you go out to the landfill now, they have plenty of organic waste. If you want some, they really can't even handle that much. There's just not a real use for it right now, and it would be very expensive to deal with it. So at this time, we're recommending that the council exempt themselves, frankly, from the manner of organic recycling requirements of AB 1826. And as staff, I want to say that as we move forward with the bigger picture and the regional issues of solid waste and recycling,
5:02:10 We're not going to forget about this item. And if there's a way we can work it into the program where it's cost effective and it makes sense, we're still very interested. You know, my own personal comment was, you know, as I've said before on other recycling stuff, I came up here and I'm, it's tough because I'm used to having, you know, my own compost bin and recycling everything. And it's tough up here, but we're making progress. We're making progress every year. And we intend to continue to do so. With that, any questions? Any questions for Grady? Any comments from the public?
5:02:41 Thank you, Madam Mayor, Councilmembers. My name is Jeff Gunzik. I own and operate the Banner Springs Ranch on the Benton Crossing Road with my wife, Delinda, who's here this morning. Anyway, I just want to comment on AB 1826 and the county's position on that. And what the real intent of this law is, it's not about diverting organic waste, just about diverting organic waste from landfills.
5:03:16 But the real intent of this law is to help the state of California meet its very ambitious greenhouse gas emission reduction goals. These greenhouse gas emissions can be directly tied to climate change that has led to warmer temperatures, especially in California, and our extended drought. And I guess I believe for a community that's dependent on snow, like Mammoth,
5:03:44 We should be leading state efforts to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions rather than trying to shirk our responsibilities and not have a plan in place for how we can divert our organic waste. And other mountain towns such as Aspen in Pitkin County, rural Pitkin County, has a very successful organics waste diversion recycling program. And I think that that could be a really good model for...
5:04:15 I'd also like to point out that Mono County's decision to apply for the exemption is not really appropriate for Mammoth Lakes. Mono County's long-term solid waste plan includes the closure of the Benton Crossing landfill by 2020 and construction of long-haul trucking facilities at Hummus Valley to haul trash.
5:04:43 Up to 250 miles away. And if there's not a plan in place to at least divert part of this waste locally, you're going to be faced with huge costs for this long haul trucking project to build the facilities and to do the hauling. And not only will you have the fixed costs in place, but assuming energy prices continue to rise, you're going to have this huge component of variable costs. So as time goes on,
5:05:11 Costs are going to continue to rise to manage the waste that's being generated, not only in the town, but in the county. And also I'd like to point out that the town of Mammoth Lakes generates three times more waste in the county than the rest of the county combined, with the Mammoth Mountain accounting for as much of a third of that. So it's going to become, it might be appropriate for the county to divert this waste and long haul trucking.
5:05:37 For its unincorporated areas that are spread out. But it's not an appropriate policy at all for the town, which could easily develop a waste diversion plan because of the density of the businesses and the density of the residencies here that could be very successful. And, in fact, we have developed a plan that could be completely funded in the private sector. It wouldn't take...
5:06:06 Money from the county or the town to do, and we call this the Queen Valley Resource Recovery Project, and this is a comprehensive plan to divert the entire region's organic waste, and it's contrary to the county's claim that this infrastructure, there's no plan for this, we are developing this infrastructure right now on a site that's about 60 miles away from town, just over the border in Nevada.
5:06:34 We're getting our permits in place. We've got our water in place. So it's not something that's impossible to do, and certainly we can be up and running by the end of the year or beginning of January. So our plan would significantly reduce the total waste removal expenses for all of the commercial enterprises in the town from current rates, and the savings would be even greater over the next several years compared to the projected waste removal costs without some kind of organic recovery.
5:07:04 Project in place. But to get this going, it's imperative to begin a pilot organic recycling program in town here. And what it's going to take to include as many commercial enterprises as possible and get this running by the beginning of next year. In this way, by 2019 or so, 2020,
5:07:30 We could take all of the town's residential organic waste. We could take all unincorporated Mono County's waste. We could even take Inyo County's waste as well. That's our plan, to be a regional organic waste recycler. Our plan, I presented our plan to the Mono County Board of Supervisors last week at their meeting, and we got broad support. They want to include it in the county's strategic plan.
5:07:59 We also have support from CalRecycle. Jeff, can I ask you to wrap it up? You're at your... Anyway, our plan can't happen without political will to make it happen, bottom line. Thank you. Thank you, Jeff. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Okay. I have a timing question of staff based on what Jeff's comments is. My understanding is we've got to have this exemption in place by July 1st.
5:08:26 That's correct. But in requesting the exemption, that doesn't mean we have to wait all the way until 2020 to take other action. Absolutely not. That was my comment from staff. We're going to continue to focus on this. So that regional plans and all that can happen, but we do need to get the exemption filed because we have to have an identified alternative now. That's correct. And we don't have that yet. Okay. All right. Thank you. Okay. Is anyone else who wishes to speak? Okay.
5:08:56 Bring it back for comments or a motion. Go ahead. I'm enormously supportive of this idea, and I think it's going to be a very important part of our strategies going forward. As we all know, anything in this town, in this region, takes work to develop a program and a project and look at the costs and how we're going to make these things work.
5:09:23 And I think we would very much look forward to working with you, with your team, with the county, as part of you heard a lot about regional solutions to these things that put it into that kind of a context. And I think we're very much looking forward to working with you. I think this exemption is something we have to kind of do in the short term, but you should not take that as precluding anything that's going to happen down the line. But it's going to take some work to put this together, so we're all aware of that and looking forward to it. And we're working on it, county.
5:09:51 Solutions now. Yeah, exactly. And to fold that in, I'm glad you've been to the county, you're talking with them, and fold that in to all these things we're working on. Yeah, my comments are very much along the same lines. I really appreciate your comments. I'm very sensitive to what you had to say. And I read your email, and it's one of the things that I'd be looking to discuss this week, actually. But this...
5:10:16 This item for me kind of brought out an internal conflict. I'm this, you know, bleeding heart liberal around a lot of issues, especially, you know, environmental issues and a business owner and all these kind of things. But, you know, I appreciate the comments from you, Grady, about the fact that this is something we really want to look to pursue.
5:10:36 You know, I was not going to be supportive of tabling this thing indefinitely, but I do understand the time-sensitive nature of what we're dealing with here. So I think in the short run, I'm comfortable with pursuing this exemption because I think it's what we need to do because we don't have anything in place currently. But I would very much encourage Jeff, if you guys can stay engaged with us and with town staff, to...
5:11:03 To hopefully develop that program down the road. You know, I, for one, as a council member, definitely support it. And I would say due to that is, you know, I would love to recycle everything. But we do have our limitations here. And I think, you know, I take my other kinds of plastic down to my brother's house to recycle it because we can only do one and two here. Madam Mayor, I'll make a motion to the council adopt a resolution to exempt the town of Mammoth Lakes and the business operate.
5:11:31 Operated within its jurisdiction from the mandatory organics recycle requirements of AB 1826. Do we have a second? I would second that. Are you getting sleepy? No, I'm just, I'm just, you know, I think we, I would like to make a demonstration that we...
5:11:51 Support development of these opportunities down the road. I don't want, I want to make sure. I think that's direction. Okay, good. Well, I won't amend the motion. I'll just simply say. Okay, thank you. Yeah, that was my hesitation. Temporarily was going to be the word I was going to use. Okay. Well, you know, this is only three years short of when the Benton Crossing closes anyway, so we have to be dealt with together. Sure. Okay, we have a motion in a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie.
5:12:20 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. That takes us on to another solid waste matter, which would be approving the updated solid waste task force bylaws. Yes. And this solid waste task force has been around actually since before 1999 in another form, but in November of 1999,
5:12:44 The Mono County Board of Supervisors actually established an eight-member board. It's changed over time in terms of numbers of members, the population of that list, how often they meet. Recently, since 2012, again, according to Tony, because I was on the group then, they really started working at the three elements of the countywide integrated waste management plan. So they were meeting very regularly on that thing.
5:13:09 That's come to a close or very nearly to a close. They've taken a lot of that to the county board of supervisors. Once they complete all their actions, I'll make sure that I can get Tony here to report to you exactly what they've come up with. But what's happened in recent times since we were finishing the work, very frankly, is one, they didn't find the need to meet as often, number one. And number two, I found myself coming to the meeting and having to call somebody to get a quorum. So it was a little bit difficult to do that.
5:13:37 Move forward as necessary. Tony led the group. I was vice chair, and they got the work done. But this is really a cleanup to amend those bylaws. The main two items are to change the meetings so that they happen as needed, very frankly, and the other is to change the number of members. When it went to the county board, they also looked at whether or not all these members needed to be voting members, and there was some concern from the county board of supervisors that the representative from those who
5:14:07 I'll put a bloody stand to make a profit, I guess, which would be, you know, DNS waste removal, Mammoth disposal. Should be on this group very definitely to give input, but shouldn't necessarily be voting members. I don't think these two had a problem with that. I don't think they do. They're very participatory. I think they're, you know, they're good partners for the community. So the county voted to take them off to change the voting members from...
5:14:31 What it was to nine voting members and three non-voting members. You'll note on the second page of the bylaws, there's actually a typo. It has the old numbers of ten and one. It should read nine voting members and three non-voting members. The other thing that came up is they did change some of the members and there are still vacancies. We still need a member at large, a member from the public at large. If the council would like to consider that at some point or at least put a call out to say, hey, anybody wants to be on this.
5:15:00 To represent the town as a public at large member, we can recommend that back to the county at some point. That's not urgent by any means, but it's something that's available. So all we're asking for you to do tonight is take a look at these amended bylaws and approve them, and we'll report back to the county that we're in concurrence. Question, Grady, is that on the voting members, they took off the two solid waste disposal type
5:15:30 Businesses, but they left the Sierra Conservation Project on? Yeah. Okay. I mean, I'm not going to just, you know, I think it should be a voting member because it is going to get us farther down the recycling line, but I just thought that was, they took off some of the commercial ones, but not. Yeah. Does the membership affect the quorum, the numbers needed for quorum? I think they actually set it at five, so it's majority for a quorum to be there.
5:15:56 Okay. It's kind of crazy. When it was 10, it was just still also 5. Right. Correct. Yeah. Prime numbers. Yeah. Did you have a question about it? No questions. Well, then, if there are any other questions, if there's anyone who wants to speak on this item. Mayor, Mayor, Councilmembers, I just want to introduce myself.
5:16:26 My name is Delinda Briggs. I just wanted to let you know that I was appointed to the Solid Waste Task Force by Tony Delino last week, and I'm excited to help accelerate the development of a local, reliable, environmentally sound, and economically feasible commercial food waste recovery project.
5:16:48 Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for your service. So when we do our motion, do we have to note those changes in the wrong numbers in the membership section? Yeah, I would request that you adopt it as amended reflecting the nine and the three in that section. And we did put the county on notice. They may actually have to take it back and we adopt it because it has to be identically adopted by both agencies, but they didn't catch that either, so.
5:17:14 Thank you, Madam Mayor, for bringing that to our attention. So then, any other comments? In that case, do we have a motion? Yeah, Madam Mayor, I'd like to make a motion to approve the updated Mono County Solid Waste Task Force bylaws as amended. Second.
5:17:35 Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, the motion passes 4-0, and we go to our final item before closed session, which is a discussion about whether to become a member of the Mountain Pact.
5:17:57 Can we make this speedy? Tell us what the recommendation is and why? The item's coming forward based on a request a while back from Councilmember Whitworth. Staff's done a walk-through and review of this. The recommendation, based on the current review we've done on it, is to actually give us a little more time to take a look at it. We would want to do a little follow-up with some of the actual members to see what the benefit is. Also, we believe there's been some additional agencies.
5:18:25 Sign on to participate, but the website hasn't been updated, so we haven't been able to confirm that yet. And then ultimately really trying to make the analysis of if this is the right organization or that element to represent us at a state or federal level across the West in terms of the goals that they have for that. Then ultimately it is a, it's small, but it is a budget impact and staff impact that we'd want to come back and confirm.
5:18:51 That Council's good with the funding and the commitment up to 20 hours of staff time per year to participate. So we would not recommend at this point joining, but we would recommend that we're given that direction to continue the analysis to make sure that we can make a solid recommendation from the staff perspective, either to join or not to join.
5:19:10 And Madam Mayor, having been sort of complicit in bringing this forward, I'm happy with option one. I think that's reasonable and I'm prepared to make a motion once you... Wait, wait, I have a question then. Sure. When the analysis comes back to us, could you clarify whether or not we are members of Sierra Business Council or if there are other community members like the Chamber or things that are already members of Sierra Business Council? Because it sounds like this is sponsored by them. It's... Or it's funded by them. Sierra Business Council serves as the fiduciary agent as all. Okay.
5:19:39 So we actually asked them if being a member of SBC would actually give us any additional benefit with the Mountain Pack, and they said no. Oh, okay. Well, can that be written up in what we see? Yeah, as we come back, we'll bring that up. Because, you know, if we're already a member here, get into this. Oh, sure. SBC is a nonprofit based in Truckee that does a lot of...
5:19:59 Different things. We know the SBC. Oh, yes. We know them well. But I didn't know whether or not we were members. We currently are not. We've had a paid membership and we've had a granted membership. Okay, so I'd just like to know if there's also anybody else in town who's involved, you know, just to lay the basis out there. So now, John, if you want to make a motion? Yes, I'd love to make a motion, Madam Mayor. Thank you. I'm sorry. Public comment? Okay. No.
5:20:28 Okay, so I would move to direct staff to gather additional information about the Mountain Pact, including getting a list of current members, speaking to the founder of the pact, and speaking to representatives of other member cities, and return to council with that information before making a decision about whether or not to join. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0, and we will now go into...
5:20:58 Close session. Clean about this.