Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2015
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 38 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
335 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:14 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:23 Yeah, just switch the names. Okay. You can meet anybody you want. Are you ready, Kim? Mm-hmm. Are you ready? Mm-hmm. Where's Michael? He's stuck at the Denver.
2:03 Good afternoon. I now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for June the 10th, 2015 at 2 p.m. And before we have roll call, I would like to just make two announcements for our viewing public and our public. Commissioner Harvey, due to a conflict of time interest, was...
2:25 Resigned last week, and we'll, you'll hear more about that later on, we're obviously, we're very fond of Commissioner Harvey, he's in great, great things for the commission, but we certainly understand why he was in a position where he felt it was the best interest for his business interest and for the commission to resign. So the town will be opening that position up, it'll be advertised, the council will interview, and then a new commissioner will be appointed at our
2:55 August, Reg, 12 feet, right. And then Commissioner Vanderhurst, who goes frequently on the road on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes, spent the night last night at the Denver airport, I think literally at the airport because he couldn't find a hotel room, so he will not be joining us either today. So your quorum is the three of us and we're happy to be here, right?
3:21 Stay healthy. Stay healthy, right. So can we have a roll call, please? Commissioner Greya? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please join me for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, and liberty and justice for all. At this time,
4:01 I'll open up the meeting for public comment. Public comments is for anybody that'd like to speak on any subject that is not on today's agenda. Sherry, why don't you let the, yeah, go ahead. And then we'll hear from the town staff. Good afternoon. My name is Annie Ott. I've been 36 years, and I'm a part-time resident. And I,
4:31 Although I am called a second homeowner, I consider Mammoth during the summers especially to be my primary residence. I love this place and I'd like to keep it that way. Thank you for the opportunity of speaking. You guys have a tough job. You're trying to envision a village in the trees philosophy. However, you have to meet with developers on a regular basis and they have a slightly different vision.
5:02 Their vision is trees within a condo complex, and that leads to lots of conflicts. It puts you in a very, very difficult position, and usually not rewarding, as many people stand up here, including myself, and complain about what's going on. Well, this time is different, and I'm very happy to stand up here this time. I have a photograph over there showing Main Street.
5:30 Now, Mammoth View, Mammoth View Project,
6:01 is on the corner of Mountain Boulevard and Main Street, has funded removal of all the poles by their property along Mountain Boulevard as well as Main Street. There was a request made that they continue the undergrounding further up north, further west, rather, towards Minaret. That has led into many, many discussions.
6:32 Since the approval of funding took place in June of 2013. Southern California Edison has a standard policy, like for like. If you remove a pole, you replace a pole. Like for like. They would not entertain the possibility of continuing the undergrounding from Mammoth View Project all the way to Minaret. The town, unfortunately,
7:02 Had kind of a, what I would call, not proper attitude at that point. Okay? They said, Southern California is Southern California Edison. That's the way it is. We have to work within that framework. And I believe, and I believe most people believe that that's unacceptable. And as a result, it requires what I call out-of-the-box thinking on the part of the town, as well as
7:32 The developers, as well as anybody, to figure out a way to do something that really makes common sense. Now to their credit, Mammoth View actually funded within their budget an analysis by SCE to see if it would in fact be less expensive to continue the undergrounding and remove the additional five poles. And if they were to do that, then Main Street would be
8:02 Utility poll free. They paid that analysis. They paid for that analysis. And it turns out that the conclusion was that, yes, it would be less expensive. So the decision was made. And I believe it's absolutely the right decision on the part of SCE and the town to remove all of those polls as part of their existing funding. So no additional funding.
8:32 I think this is a good sample of how the town working together with SCE can get around bureaucratic processes if they're willing to think out of the box. And so I think we have a wonderful success story here. And I commend Mammoth View project. I commend the town for being aggressive.
9:03 And being diligent in making that happen. And so I was hoping, is Jen Daugherty here? Ah, there she is. This is a little nicer picture there. Oh, yeah. I thought you were going to give her a telephone pole. As I understand it, even though I'm very anxious to get things done tomorrow, you've delayed it once again.
9:40 Because of July 4th holidays, I'm all for that. We celebrate July 4th because of the parade, but work will actually start the following weekend. So I'm very, very pleased. Thank you so much, Planning Commission, Town Council. This is really a true success story. Andy, quick question. I'm really happy to hear this news. Like for like is the existing policy when undergrounding is preferred for safety, fire, and aesthetics? That's right.
10:10 Unless you fund them differently. Wow. The standard policy for Southern California Edison is whenever you remove a pole, you replace it. It doesn't have to go into the same location. And that's what they were talking with us. In our case, the Main Street project requires removal of that retaining wall you see there. So they couldn't put it into the same location because it would be right in the middle of the sidewalk. But they said, well,
10:36 Our policy is like for like, so we're going to find some other place to put the poll. Wow. You've got to think out of the box when you hear stuff like that. Well done. And I really want to commend you and the other residents at Viewpoint, and you've been very tenacious about this in a very nice way. You should see what we say, not nice. No, but we really appreciate it, and this is...
11:05 The overall arching goal was to have ultimately all the polls removed. And so thank you and thank the other people for showing up. So I don't know your names, but thank you very much. Thank you very much. That's wonderful news. All right. Good afternoon. Shireen Sanders, Town Code Compliance Officer. I'd like to give you a brief update on code enforcement efforts since your last meeting. We held Town Cleanup Day, which is a great success with the weather cooperating as well.
11:41 We collected a total of 53.3 tons of bulky trash and 120 yards of metal. I felt we had great coordination between Mammoth Disposal, town employees and our wonderful volunteers at the cleanup sites, the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors, Disabled Sports, Eastern Sierra, and we were saved by the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. We had four elders there that just, I don't know what we would have done without them.
12:11 And then we had a wonderful celebration of thanks at Sierra Nevada Resort hosted by the Old Mammoth Restaurant Row Association and Rob Gill from Sierra Wave. So all in all, I think it was a great success. Sierra Valley sites and pretty much all of the town looks a lot nicer now. So I'm working currently on a trash protocol. Sandra and Steve Searles and Chief Davis and I are working.
12:41 To have spelled out protocol for a number that people can call during the week for dumpster spills and then what happens on the weekend and the police department is going to take care of that. So we're working with the police department to solidify that. Since my ride with Mike Braun a few weeks ago, we have seen some significant improvements in the Sierra Valley sites neighborhoods. One property manager actually asked for flyers to distribute to all of his tenants.
13:11 Outlining the Municipal Code and the debris and rubbish requirements that needed to be removed from his property. We've met with success in a number of cases involving waste debris and abandoned furniture and dead trees simply by going through a verbal warning process and then a written warning process. I haven't so far had to cite anybody. I'm sure that will eventually happen.
13:38 We've been able to get compliance through that process. As we head into the summer building season, we've seen a rise in unpermitted building. I think I've issued four stop work orders in just two weeks, and we expect that to continue. I've received some lighting ordinance violations from Commissioner Tenney. Thank you.
14:01 As we have a number of previous lighting complaints that were never addressed fully, I'm working from the oldest to the most recent, notifying the owners in writing, and then following up within a 15-day time frame, addressing each one in order. We are also working on a code enforcement awareness newsletter for the summer, which will address concerns that are specific to the summer months, such as unpermitted building, trash bills, and bear activity.
14:32 And with regard to the bear activity, I'm currently working in conjunction with Steve Searles and will be sending out a letter to all businesses in town and specifically restaurants regarding grease traps and bear resistant containers that need to be brought in at night if they're not secured. So hopefully we'll get some response from those efforts. Does anyone have any questions? Have you considered a hotline for
15:00 Compliance about code violations, trash and light trespass and bedroom windows and stuff like that? Or is it strictly email or people coming to the desk? We have people coming to the desk. There's the code compliance email. There's my extension at the town. With the trash protocol, we're going to have my cell phone listed for during the week.
15:22 So you're the hotline. I am the hotline. Oh, wow. Yeah. Man's brave. I wouldn't take that cell phone on vacation. Yeah. Did you have any other questions? Oh, no, I don't think so. Well, thank you. I think town cleanup day, one, I think it's a wonderful tradition, and you did a great job. Thank you. Thank you. It was a hard way to help start your new career. Yeah. You did a great job. Great. Thank you. So thank you very much, and everybody that helped you. Great. Thank you. Thank you.
15:59 Okay. Grady Dutton, Public Works. I'm here to give a brief update on the diff, but before I do that, I want to also thank Andy for coming in today. We barely get the other side of it. Yes. Recognizing it was a lot of work. I also want to add that both plant engineering participated, and in the overall project, the county actually was involved with some of their 28 funds to get the whole line underground from Mountain Bull all the way to Minervat. So it really was a team effort.
16:26 Everybody in the neighborhood got together, and I think they're going to start construction right after July 4th. Is that pretty fair? So they should be out there right after July 4th weekend, actually getting to work out there. The next year, the next fiscal year, next summer, we should be starting out some of the main street work in that same area. That's where, as Annie said, that wall will be moving, some of the site will be putting in, so it'll move right along. What I have for you today,
16:54 We'll do just a quick handout here. Thank you. I do have additional copies of anybody else that would like a copy of what the commissioners are looking at. Next week at Town Council, we're going to be bringing forward a first of two agenda packages, agenda items on the DIF study. We received on Friday an updated PowerPoint, which is a summary presentation of the DIF study. The key part of that, of course, is that
17:38 One page you have that has the summaries on it. We've distributed that to some of the stakeholders. We're making sure we don't have any final comments, and they'll go into our agenda packet that'll go out this week. That meeting next week will be for the council to review the project list, the methodology, all the different components, and the proposed fees at that time. We will then notice the public hearing that will be on July 1st with town council where they'll consider adoption of these fees. Okay. So as soon as we have that
18:07 PowerPoint vetted fully today or tomorrow. Again, that will be in the council agenda package and we'll be able to take a look at it. As followed to the last time we were here with the diff, one of the things you asked us to do was to take that full project list and go through the general plan and create basically a chart that showed how each of those projects was in compliance with the general plan. We have updated that list. We aren't complete with that yet. As soon as we have that, we'll get it back to you. But to this point, we found no
18:35 Nothing that's inconsistent whatsoever just as we thought, but we will actually produce that document and make sure we get that back to you. Again, we don't have it yet. We've been working on the DIF study itself. On the first page, again, the fee components, methods, and cost allocation, it just sort of goes through a matrix of the six different types of fee on the left-hand side. And again, we are not including the library, we're not including the fire department and those others because that's the fees that we do not have control over.
19:02 As you move to the right, the service area, incremental expansion, plan-based, cost recovery, and cost allocation are the ways that the fees are calculated. Down below is really the bottom line, if you will, and that is the development impact fee summary that we're going to propose. And if you go all the way down to the bottom, you can see that every one of these fees has decreased. A couple of changes from the last diff in terms of the format.
19:30 I believe the diff used to show transient housing versus non-transient. We've eliminated that. Now it's just single family, mobile home, multi-unit. In addition, we've added a lodging category down below under the non-residential per square foot. And lodging is actually on a per room basis on there.
19:50 We are at least convinced that this is a much more straightforward approach. We think we have a very tight nexus between the proposed fees and everything. I realize, again, you don't have that PowerPoint and certainly not the full report in front of you yet. We don't have the whole report ourselves yet, but we wanted to make sure we got it to you before, you know, as soon as this information was available. We have gotten some good feedback from the development community. After we sent this out on Friday, I've only gotten one phone call.
20:17 Asking one question, which I was able to answer, so I think we're headed in the right direction, and what I'd encourage is that you make sure you look at the entire agenda packet that's going to Town Council next week, and then the full report as soon as it's available. That's something, again, we do need to notice. The notice and requirements for the July 1st meeting are two notices five days apart, so that'll be noticed not this Saturday, but next Friday in the newspaper, the one after, and the full report should be available before that first notice.
20:46 The second sheet that I have, there was a question again about all the town fees, if you will. We don't include the sewer and water fees here, but on this summary, they do at least show the residential and the lodging fees for these. We show the housing fee as proposed, the current diff fee as proposed, other agency, which again, that does bring into the library and the fire department.
21:13 And if you see that total there as an example under single family, the total fee is $14,709. The old diff fee by itself was almost $19,000. So you can see we made some considerable reductions. In fact, there was some discussion among staff that we're going too far. We really don't think we are. We're trying to bring it to something that's reasonable, something that's reliable, something we can enforce, something that will be accepted in the community.
21:41 We also want to comment that we'll be back in three or four years. This is something that needs to be updated frequently because things do change. It's an example I think I presented last time in the old list of projects since 2007. There were over $20 million in projects that were completed, almost all of them using non-DIF funds. So we want to come back on a frequent basis, update this list, make sure the projects that need to be there are there, and make sure that everything makes sense.
22:08 With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions that I have. Again, I don't have the full staff report, the full report yet, but I wanted to get to you what we do have today. This is a dramatic difference. Could you tell us in like two sentences how you calculate these numbers and why it is such a dramatic difference? Two things are key. First is the project list used to be $388 million.
22:36 It was unrealistic at best. Now the project list is just over $80 million. Okay. So there were things on there that just didn't belong and weren't really realistic. As an example, a 14,000 square foot police station. Yes, we need a new police station. We're envisioning one closer to 4,500 square feet, so the cost of that went down dramatically. There were $34 million in storm drain improvements.
23:01 While over the next 50 years the town may very well need $34 million in storm drain improvements, it's not realistic to think that we can find the funding through DIFF or any other sources to do that in the next 15 or 20 years. That's one thing is that project list that we presented last time changed dramatically. The other really is the nexus. As an example, if there are road improvements in the DIFF as a project, there was a...
23:25 There was a different method last time of calculating the percent that went to new development. Now we took a close look, the consultant did, at the development increase portion. So we took development traffic 20 years out, compared it to today. What we found was that increase was about 11%. Therefore, any project we had in there that was not a direct impact, it was a cumulative impact, or just a town-wide impact, new development should really only pay for 11% of that.
23:54 So we took a project, calculated the increased cost and the development portion based on that percentage. So that went dramatically down as well. But I think what resulted is something that's very realistic, but also there's a very tight nexus for that. And if we got a room full of 15 people from the development community and others and staff all looking at it and they didn't throw us out, we're getting closer.
24:18 And the fact that we didn't get a lot of complaints, frankly, I'm thinking we didn't go too far. But the idea is we think we want to have something that really was acceptable that made sense, had a good tight nexus to it. Thank you. This is impressive analysis. So just one second. So, Sandra, the PowerPoint that you sent out last week, that's the final one, right? Because it's the same summary.
24:48 That you sent to us? The one that was sent in the email, the email from Grady, that's the most recent one, yes. Okay, all right. And then I just want to clarify, so there's no additional stakeholder meetings between now and the time that council's going to see this, correct? You know, if we had, there aren't, let me answer that, there aren't. If we had interest in this, we would gladly send another phone call, but we didn't get a lot of feedback. All right. And then,
25:15 Well, let me just back up. I think we've made just such incredible progress as far as having a definable project. You know, you can read it, you can understand it, you know what we're talking about. It's just really terrific. I am a very big component, though, that I think we really need to still always show the fees of the other agencies and at some point, so for example, you know, for how long do we collect?
25:42 On the library fee. Just because we want everybody, you know, that's associated with this to really understand, you know, when we talk to the people coming into town, that we all give the consistent same type of answers. So I do think that's an important component of that. And then certainly if...
26:03 We were in a position to move forward with an EIFD then, right, that would also change part of this or would that would just be the part that would be like the 89% that wasn't the 11% attributable to the diff? Both are true. Okay. Basically, in the analysis, if you looked at the entire PowerPoint, one large column is other financing forces. Right. An EIFD would, you know, would certainly be something that's feasible there. We did make...
26:32 Our best estimate, if you will, for those other sources of funds. As I said, we don't know what ATP grants, what other grants we're going to get. But based on history, we took our best shot at it. That's why we need to come back pretty often. And if we get that kind of an enhancement district, then that would certainly be part. All right. Well, thank you very much. We're looking forward to the council meeting. All right. Are there any other public comments? Then at this time, I'm going to close the public comment.
27:04 Period, and I did ask Sandra to include a piece of correspondence. I just thought it was a very interesting article about findings. I personally learned some interesting things about it. I mean, we know that the findings are really important. I do think we can do maybe even a little better job recapping what our findings are when we take our votes. So I wanted to share that article with everybody. Thank you. Do we have any discussion about it? Yes. Okay, I have a...
27:34 I have a question about it. Maybe Sandra can answer this. I know we have some discretion as a commission, as representatives of the community. How does findings of fact jibe with our discretionary abilities? Could you talk about that a little bit? Well, the findings that you make have to be based on the facts. Right. So if the commission, so if we were recommending approval of the project and we had all the findings written out,
28:02 The Commission would have to, and they wanted to deny the project, the Commission would have to come up with facts in order to create those findings to deny the project. Does that help? Okay, so then when do we have discretion? In what instances? You have discretion based on the facts that you hear. Okay. So as you hear, you know, if staff makes a presentation and then you hear information at the meeting from, I guess, bring up other facts.
28:28 You can take that and use that to create findings for denial if that was the case. Okay, so discretion based on the facts. That's a very good way to put it. Okay, thank you. All right, is there any other? Mm-mm, that's all. All right. Then we'll move off of correspondence and we'll move to our first business matter. Thank you. This item is the Environmental Impact Report scoping meeting for our general plan, land use element, and zoning code amendments.
29:01 This is related to the floor area ratio project and the mobility element update project. We have Lucy Heiss-Fisher here from PCR. She's our consultant on the project. She'll be walking us through a PowerPoint presentation and then we will be taking comments from the commission and from the public. And the purpose of the meeting, Lucy will elaborate on it, is really to get comments on what issues are out there, what issues do the commission and the public want to see analyzed in the EIR.
29:26 So this is kind of how we shape our project process. Let me get the PowerPoint set up for you. Good afternoon. I'm Lucy Heist-Fisher. I'm with PCR Services Corporation, the firm that's working with the town on the environmental impact report, and we've also been involved with the flow rate ratio analysis.
30:14 And this slide just gives you the file numbers. It's a town-initiated general plan amendment and zoning code amendment. Today is a scoping meeting. These are the things that we're going to go through in the scoping meeting, what the purpose is, the summary of the project, an overview of the sequel process, the topics that are going to be analyzed in the draft EIR based on the initial study, and then we'll have a time for public input.
30:40 But if people do have questions, if it's okay with the chair, if you have questions, I don't know if you want them at the end. It's your discretion. Okay. If it's, I'm happy to do questions during. I think it makes it for a better flow. Okay. All right. So the whole purpose of a scoping meeting is to inform the public about the project, but also to identify the environmental issues that are going to be analyzed and to get public comment.
31:07 from the public on the issues that are being addressed, any concerns that they might have, and any alternatives that they feel should be evaluated in the document. I wanted to give a little bit of background on how we got, or the town got to where they are with the general plan amendments and the zoning code amendments. During the zoning code update, there was a proposal about changing from a unit and a room cap to a floor area ratio.
31:36 And in order to do that, the town needed to understand what that meant in terms of build-out under the general plan. We, PCR, did the FAR analysis. I was here in October presenting the findings of that, and there was a determination that FAR could increase the intensity of development. And this is only for the commercial districts. So it's the C1, C2 districts, not town-wide.
32:00 Also, in April of 2009, Town Council gave direction to staff to switch from a people at one time, the PAOT approach, to an impact-based approach, or the PISC that the town has been working with. In October of 2014, Town Council eliminated the Community Benefits Incentive Zone policy, and also the town has a draft mobility element that the original draft was in 2011.
32:30 So there's a lot of activity that's happened in planning in the town since the general plan update in 2007. All of this has come together to make a very nice but somewhat complex package of general plan amendments and zoning code amendments. And that's what is the project today and what we're going to run through. So the general plan land use element amendments, there's a series of them that are bulleted out here. One is the FAR.
32:58 Another is, as we talked about, the PAOT change, the change in the CBiz, and a transfer of development rights that's all connected. And then also when we were doing the FAR work, there were some errors essentially in mapping, and those boundaries will get corrected as well. They're technically general plan amendments, and so we're folding that all into one package. There are zoning code amendments that are related to the floor area ratio.
33:28 And then, as I said previously, there's the mobility element update. This slide shows the different project areas. Each one has a little bit of a different one. So the FAR work, again, is just the commercially designated land, so it's about 122 acres. The PAOT change to the impacts is a town-wide, so it's the urban growth boundary.
33:54 And then the mobility element, because of the connections outside of the urban growth boundary, has a slightly larger project area. So the purpose of this slide is just to show the different areas and how they relate. The floor area ratio, as I said, the determination was that it could increase intensity of development within the commercial zones.
34:17 And this is a summary of Table 3 that's in the initial study of the project description showing that the increase compared to current regulations is about 336 residential units, up to 467 rooms, and about 152,500 square feet of commercial development. So the actual text amendments for the
34:45 FAR, it's modifying the C1 and the C2 text, and the project description shows in red line strikeout what the actual changes are, but it's to remove the unit cap and the room cap and to put in place a minimum of .75 FAR and a maximum of 2.0, and then there's the zoning code amendments that are associated with this as well. So in the OMR, the D, and the MLR,
35:14 Zoning districts, the same type of an amendment would occur so that there's consistency between the general plan and the zoning code. Also in the zoning code, and this was based on a comment that was at the October meeting, was to put a preamble in place in the commercial districts that the 2.0 is not a given, that there's other development standards that apply that also need to be met.
35:42 So the text for that is also provided in the package, in the project description. The town has used the community benefits incentive zone to allow modifications to increase the intensity, get changes in heights or density and setbacks historically. Now with the removal of the density cap, a determination has been made that the CBiz is no longer necessary. So there's a policy, policy L5G.
36:12 That will be deleted from the land use element. And that's consistent with what Town Council did in October of 2014. Again, with the FAR approach, there's no need for density limitations to be transferred within the commercial zones. So the general plan talks about transfer development rights, and there was an action item to create a TDR ordinance to allow the transfer of density.
36:43 That's no longer needed for the commercial zones. However, it will still be allowed within the master and specific plan areas. So the action item that relates to the TDRs is being deleted. With regard to the people at one time, as I said earlier, there was direction to shift from this PAOT to the impacts-based approach. And it was based on difficulties that were identified by the town relative to actually
37:13 Monitoring and keeping track of that people at one time, because as you know, the general plan says 52,000 people at one time is the maximum. How do you monitor that on a regular basis, and how do you really keep tabs on it? So the idea is to go to an impacts-based approach, still with the idea of you're not going, the town doesn't want to exceed its carrying capacity, which is really what this is all about.
37:38 So the language that's proposed for the general plan is looking at an impact-based approach, balancing the social and economic needs of the community and the physical environment, and looking at it from that perspective as opposed to counting people. So again, keeping it within the caring capacity, not ignoring that, but just doing it from a different perspective.
38:05 The mobility element update, as I said, there was a draft in 2011. The mobility element is a component of the general plan. It's one of the elements. What the mobility element does is establishes the town's goals, policies, and actions for any type of movement within the community. So it addresses roads, sidewalks, paths, bike lanes, trails, parking, and transit. It's based on two key concepts, which is the triple bottom line.
38:34 And the feet first transportation. And an important component as well is the Main Street Plan. So it's integrating the work that the town did on the Main Street Plan, which was accepted by the town, by town council. So it's integrating that idea into the mobility element so that the town can move forward with it. This figure shows the complete streets.
38:59 That is part of the mobility element. So the idea being thinking holistically of how people move around the community. This is a graphic for the complete streets. So the project has been defined and now we're moving into the environmental process. It is under CEQA considered a project. CEQA's general purpose is to inform decision makers about what the potential impacts could be from a project. It's really a disclosure document.
39:30 And it also provides opportunities for public participation so that the public can understand the environmental review process and have a voice in it. The other purpose is to identify ways to avoid or reduce environmental impacts, either through mitigation measures or alternatives. One important thing with CEQA is that if there's a significant unavoidable finding, CEQA does not say that the project cannot go forward.
39:58 What it requires is a statement of overriding consideration and findings if the community and the decision makers determine that that's the appropriate path. So I just want people to understand that in terms of CEQA. This is a flow chart showing the overall process for CEQA. You can see where we are in the process. We're at the scoping meeting.
40:22 So the town has prepared the initial study and distributed it along with the notice of preparation. We are right now within that 30-day public comment period. So it started May 29th, ends June 29th. After this, the draft EIR will be put together, distributed for public comment. So you can see the red up at the top, another opportunity for public comment. Comments are received. It's a 45-day comment period.
40:50 After the receipt of all the comments, a final EIR is put together, which responds to all of the comments. That's reviewed by the commenting agencies. There's a set of public hearings for the project to move forward and for the document to be certified, which is the formal town decisions, and then there's a notice of determination. So you can see here the different opportunities for public input. Now, in putting together the initial study, there's about... Why don't we just check and ask...
41:21 Questions? Does anybody in the public have any questions at this point? Okay. So in putting together the initial study, there's about 16, 17 issue areas, depending on how you count them, that get evaluated. So the project is defined in that first attachment, and then you go through a checklist to look at whether something needs further study, or is it clear enough that there would not be any impact or no significant impact?
41:52 In which case, no need to study it further, it's complete, and it's what's called scoped out of the EIR. So these issues listed here are ones that will not be evaluated further in the Environmental Impact Report. The next series of slides are the issue areas that will be evaluated in the EIR. And because we have different components to the project,
42:17 There's different things that will be evaluated. So, for example, forestry resources is listed on here, and you might say, what's that got to do with the FAR? It doesn't. In this case, it has to do with the mobility element because there's a connection that would run through forest service land, so we do need to evaluate it. In the case of aesthetics, what's important is that the FAR is not changing the heights or the setbacks or any of the development standards.
42:45 With regard to the placement of the building, but it will result in taller buildings that are currently out there, so it's a change in character for the town, and more importantly, a change along Main Street, because with the implementation of the Main Street plan, that will change that character. And so, because there's potential impacts, potentially significant impacts, that will be studied further. It's not to say that the conclusion will be significant impacts, it just says it warrants further study.
43:15 And so there'll be photos and, you know, different work done around understanding better that issue area. So air quality needs to be considered because that's a big issue for the town. Greenhouse gas emissions, everyone's familiar with the importance of that. Biological resources and cultural resources because there's potentially development on undisturbed lands, both for the roads as well as for vacant lands within the commercial districts. Those issue areas need to be evaluated.
43:45 Obviously traffic is a big one in terms of increase intensity and because it's a mobility element update to make sure that it all works. Noise and vibration are on the list, land use and planning. Population and housing has to do with the FAR because of, again, the potential increase. If you increase the residential units and the rooms in the downtown area, population that could go up. So we need to take a very close look at that.
44:13 Services and utilities are closely linked with population because the factors are generally tied to those. And so if you see an increase in population, you also want to make sure that you look and make sure that the infrastructure is in place in order to serve that increase in growth. And what we're talking about is what the general plan build out is overall. So these are the next steps. Again, we're at the scoping.
44:39 process. We will then move into the preparation of the draft EIR. I have just listed some of the steps that take place within that process just so people have an understanding of it. Then we'll move into public review and we're hoping that a public document will go public at the end of the year followed by the preparation of the final public hearings at both the commission and the council level.
45:04 And then here's just a slide that gives, again, the date. Public comments are to be submitted by June 29th at 5 p.m. and written comments would go to Sandra. Okay, so if there's any questions I can have. Once scoping is done, is six months standard for a draft EIR or something like this? That's a pretty aggressive schedule, but one that we think can be met. That's an aggressive schedule. Yeah, it's not a slow schedule. Okay. Yeah.
45:32 If things go very smoothly in the CEQA world, a year is generally a good rule of thumb, 9 to 12 months. Did you have any other questions? No. Is there anybody in the public have any questions, comments this time? Is there more? That's the end of the presentation. And we do also have a sign-in sheet. If I could ask people to put their name on the sign-in sheet at some point, that would be helpful to me. Thank you.
46:09 Good afternoon, Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. I apologize, I haven't had a chance to fully read this yet, but we will do so and submit comments if we have any before the deadline at the end of June. I did have some questions though for Lucy in terms of the analysis of both sort of the maximum densities that you're analyzing.
46:38 Do you, are you analyzing it based on assuming, the assumption that everything will get developed at the maximum FAR or do you make an assumption that there's going to be, you know, somewhere in between? But, I mean, because we had a discussion and as we added in there the minimum FAR because we had concerns that people might underdevelop and we're certainly seeing evidence of that in other districts within the community, specifically most recently in Sierra Star where there's
47:04 development going on that's less than the master plan designated densities and I don't know whether that would factor in for example when you evaluate kind of the overall intensity of development in the community. So I guess my question is do you analyze everything assuming it's going to get built to the maximum densities allowable even if it's already been developed at lesser densities or because we know there's going to be some
47:32 It's going to be somewhere in between. So I was curious. Because that obviously had a big impact on water demand, wastewater flows, traffic, everything. Yes. And that's a rather complicated question. And the reason I say that is basically it's a theoretical build out if one were to assume that everything develops, redevelops to that new maximum in this case. And then there's what we would call more of a realistic build out.
48:04 And so the town has taken the approach of a more realistic buildout for the 122 acres. So in areas where the idea is that there would be development or redevelopment, the difference being development would be on the vacant lands, redevelopment would be some things really underutilized, likely to change within a time frame that we're thinking about. In those instances, yes, we do use the maximum, the 2.0. Okay.
48:33 Does that it? But I just want to be clear that it's not saying the whole 122 acres now changes to the 2.0. Right, right, I understand. So, and then, is it as much as other areas of the community may develop at lesser densities, is that considered in the overall modeling? For the traffic, that's something that's still being worked out by the town, and Sandra may need to answer some of it, but if there's...
49:00 A master plan that's already been approved, for example, you would want to use that information and feed that into your traffic model. So, yes, there's always a likelihood it develops less than, but you have to go with what's in place already or the best known information at the time. Okay. Okay. Terrific. That's all I have for now. I'd like to say, if we have any comments, we'll submit them in writing before the end of the month. Thank you. Thank you. Tom Heller with the fire department.
49:34 In several locations, the draft document talks about increasing the potential build-out development. I guess the question is what does that mean and how does that refer to the answer you just provided? Could you not go away just to make sure that I understand that? It says potential increase. Increase in potential build-out development. Correct. What it means is that the study was done, currently the town has the caps in place.
50:04 The units per acre and the rooms per acre. Looking at it from an FAR lens doing away with those caps, a study was done to say what does that mean? How much can you get in that essentially white box? You have a white box that can be so high, setbacks this big, this much of a floor plate. How could the insides be worked and what would that look like compared to the room caps?
50:30 And it turns out that for the residential, it's an increase above the 6 or 12 units per acre. Oh. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. So it is an increase in intensity, and that's what that means, a potential increase in the development within the area. So if someone designs using the FAR to the maximum, the 2.0, it could come out to be about 40 units per acre, as opposed to the 6 or 12.
51:00 And the lodging units fell roughly within what's allowable because the town has the 40 units to the 80 rooms, sorry, 40 rooms to 80 rooms. And it's roughly within that. But as it relates to the 52,000 or as it relates to what our current water cap is, I guess the confusing part of this is it doesn't really explain that we're not exceeding what our previous maximum capacities were going to be, using your words.
51:25 Carrying capacity is certainly an important component. Somewhere, and maybe I missed it because likewise I didn't read the thing page by page yet, but somewhere in there if there is no discussion about how converting, and not only the FAR, but almost all aspects of this change, if it's not related to what the previous carrying capacity is, there isn't a, or at least I didn't see that connection as to where we're going to in the future. Right, and it's a connection that
51:54 Will be made in the environmental document. There will be a section population in housing that will grapple with exactly this issue. Because really the 52,000 is supposed to equal the carrying capacity or the maximum build out in the general plan today. So if we're exceeding it slightly, we will see a slight increase or expect to. And then it's a question of given where it would be located and how it would be done, are the infrastructure
52:23 Is the infrastructure sufficient to provide the services? Which ties into Tom's question, because we do have certain areas of town that have under-densified. Are we going to make those numbers up in these commercial areas where we're just going to potentially over-densify or have the ability to over-densify in those areas? And did Tom make sure that you sign Lucy's sheet for... Okay, thank you, so we can document this. Thank you.
52:57 If you don't mind, I had a follow-up question. So when you do the, I think it's most specifically the traffic modeling, and we're emphasizing the feet first, and vehicle miles traveled, right, is the big driver of what you come up with, I guess, out of your model output that would then drive air quality and all the other greenhouse emissions and all these things. Are you, how are you able or how are you going to make assumptions then that because we're,
53:27 You know, it's a stated policy that we want to emphasize feet first and minimize vehicle trips. So in the example of the redevelopment of downtown, even if we're at a higher far or higher density in the end than what we are today, you know, the hope is that if we have centralized parking and great transportation, you know, public transit and so forth, that the people who come will just park the car and leave it while they're visiting and be able to utilize these other, you know.
53:57 Walking because there's enough synergies in the downtown to support, you know, the commercial corridor and everything else and people don't have to get in a car and drive to a restaurant and drive to shop. They can just walk to it. So is that going to be reflected in the modeling? Again, just, you know, because those things will have, you know, the impacts that you'll be analyzing and, you know, probably should be reflected, you know, and reducing in some proportion versus kind of what we've been in the past and maybe today.
54:29 That's actually something we're having discussions on currently. We don't have a scope of work yet for the traffic study. That'll be done by the town's consultant. But it's certainly things that we are talking about, looking at the set of assumptions that have been made previously, but also recognizing there's a need to look at things to some degree as they've been looked at in the past so that you can do an apples to apples.
54:58 But then wanting to move the town forward because of things, as you've just described, where you've got that concentration and hopefully people out. So putting into place things for the future modeling for the town that would acknowledge those things. And that's the kind of discussions that we're having at this point of how to do that, what works, what's a logical set of assumptions. Additional comments?
55:36 Terry Stelick. I don't have a comment on this. I have a question on the process. Do letters go out to all people that own commercial properties so they know this is going on and this change is happening? Yes. We sent letters to everyone. Okay. Perfect. Thanks. Did you have any other questions? No. So I just had a question. When we inserted the minimum FAR of 0.75, did that change any of the...
56:07 Calculations for the land use changes? We did not go back and recalculate because what we need from a CEQA perspective is what that maximum is. Okay. So while we're acknowledging, you know, obviously acknowledging, and we will acknowledge and analyze in certain issue areas. So for example, in the aesthetics, that's important. So there'll be a discussion of what that will mean for the town. But in terms of the actual number crunching analyses, it's the maximum that we'll be looking at. Okay.
56:39 And then I just really had two comments. This was, and I mentioned this to Sandra, this was partially a flaw on my part when I read this, but even though you outlined the whole scope that included, you know, the FAR, the general plan amendments, and the mobility elements, then when I was actually looking at the individual scoping of the CEQA, at first I was kind of caught off guard, so I think it's really important that whenever we make our
57:08 of public presentations that, I mean, you did it very nicely today, that we just really re-emphasized what the scope is including. And the forester was the prime one, because I'm like, how does that impact the farm? And my second comment is, when I read this document, you know, it's like an old friend now, and so I'm just really hopeful that we can stick to the time of one year and have this completed. It would be a...
57:37 Nice thing to be able to do and we're certainly here to help in any way we can to accomplish that. So, but thank you and thank you for working on the mobility part of it. I know it's been huge. All right. Are there any other comments? Then we'll close this business matter and we'll move on to our next one which is to consider the draft quality of life ordinance for transient rentals and provide a recommendation on the ordinance to town council. Thank you everybody and thank you Lucy.
58:10 Thank you. The item before you this afternoon is a draft quality of life ordinance, as you stated. The intent is to address issues that have been raised to the commission, to staff, to the council regarding quality of life issues with transient rentals. Some of the issues that we've heard regarding transient rentals is noise, trash issues, safety issues.
58:37 And so what staff did was try to pull all of those analysis of all of those issues into one single ordinance so it's really kind of a one-stop shop for transient rentals and those regulations. So I'm happy to walk through them point by point as they're addressed in the staff report. We can maybe talk about them each topic or I can go through them all if you'd like and then we can talk about the entire ordinance at the end. I'm not sure what your preference is, Chair Brown. Can I ask a question?
59:05 Yes. Sandra, could you give us a little background on where this came from? Is this a result of the initiative effort? No, uh-uh, this is not a result. This was started before the initiative was filed. The council approved last fall, they approved a single-family transit rental work program. So they approved a work program based on their goal of trying to tackle the single-family transit rental issue this year.
59:30 So they had a number of items on the work program. One of the items was the removal of the use permit requirement in the RMF2 zone, which the commission saw two months ago and I think was approved. And this was another one of the items they wanted us to complete. So we're kind of progressing through these items. The initiative has, the council will be deciding on July 1st.
59:52 Whether they're going to adopt the initiative or have a special election on that. So I would anticipate that there may be some changes to our work program as far as moving beyond this after that decision, but I'm not quite sure at this point. So at this point, the council has told us that there are priorities getting this done. Our plan is to bring it to them on July 15th so that they can, and that would be the public hearing, so that they could have the first reading on July 15th, the second reading on...
1:00:19 August 3rd or whatever the first meeting is in August and get this piece done. So what you're saying is adoption, potential adoption of this ordinance is not related to the decision about the initiative in a special election. Yes, this was considered before the initiative was submitted. Okay, and this is putting all the stuff about transient rentals in one one-stop shop as you're shopping, as you said. Thank you. You're welcome. And to answer your question, I think the issues are fairly straightforward, so why don't we go through the whole endocument and then we can...
1:00:48 Comment on the other individual in this case. Okay. And we do have a request on the dais. Yes. We're a little over air conditioned today. I don't know if you can change that or not, right? Okay. All right. Unfortunately, it's locked up, so we can't do anything about it. That's what happens when the temperature changes out there. Yeah, you might be better off when you move back.
1:01:09 I'll survive. Okay. Thank you. I'm sorry. Go ahead. No problem. So the first item is signage and notification requirements. The ordinance includes both exterior and interior signage requirements. This is in addition to the requirements currently required by the municipal code, which requires the TOT certificate be posted in a visible location with information on the occupancy limit maximum rate.
1:01:34 This ordinance requires that operators also provide information to guests regarding the maximum occupancy, the parking requirements, snow removal, trash, and any other requirements. The exterior notice is really intended to provide information that would allow adjacent property owners to contact the point of contact if there's issues with the unit. And so that's kind of the interior and exterior signage requirements summary.
1:02:01 The noise, really the town, the proposed ordinance refers to our noise ordinance, which does cover both interior and exterior noise sources. There is also a requirement in the noise ordinance that discusses disturbing the peace and quiet of a neighborhood. The noise ordinance is typically enforced by the police department in those types of situations.
1:02:30 Low sound or some sort of a long occurring sound. Sometimes code enforcement would go out with a noise reader, but typically parties, noise ordinances, people outside is all enforced by the police department. So really this ordinance refers to the noise ordinance and requires transient relatives to comply with the noise ordinance. In a similar fashion, the solid waste ordinance has current requirements.
1:02:55 And really what we're asking for property managers and owners to do is to notify their occupants of the solid waste requirements and how to properly dispose of trash. This includes instructions on opening and securing the dumpsters, animal-resistant dumpsters. This seems to be the biggest issue with the trash is that people either don't know how to open it or don't close it all the way and then bears or other wildlife get in.
1:03:20 So this refers to the current noise ordinance and requires that the operator pass on information to the occupants. For parking, there is a current requirement in our transient occupancy requirements for adequate parking. This ordinance does require that the operator provide that information to the tenants so that the
1:03:44 Tenants won't, the parking for the tenants won't exceed the number of parking spaces allocated to the unit. And then finally, the safety, I'm sorry, not finally, the safety components of this ordinance is the intent is to provide some operational standards to reduce the impacts on adjacent properties.
1:04:07 Went through with the fire marshal, the building official, talked about a lot of different requirements that could be included in here, settled on the requirements that are shown in there. However, one of the discussions was, is this information, does it make it too lengthy? Could this information change? And then we would have to change this ordinance. So staff posed a question to the commission as to whether it's better to keep all of this information in the ordinance.
1:04:36 Or to refer generally to the California Building Code and California Residential Code and then have this information in some sort of a handout. So that's a discussion that the Commission can have to determine where it would be more appropriate. And finally, the violations section, we did include information about or a requirement that the violations, if an operator violates these requirements, we could revoke their business tax license certificate.
1:05:05 Sorry, business license tax certificate for noncompliance. That will require some other modifications to Section 3, Chapter 3 of the Municipal Code, which the city attorney is looking at at this point. So that concludes my presentation on the changes that we're proposing. And to facilitate your discussion, we had a number of questions on page 4 regarding the safety requirements.
1:05:33 regarding whether or not we should require an inspection and whether the town should consider implementing a separate process for transient rentals with a nominal fee that could pay for enforcement of the provisions. So that concludes my presentation and I'm available for any questions that you have. Do you have any questions at this time? I don't know I'm going to come up so I'm here.
1:05:58 Do you have any questions at this end? I have many questions and comments. How are you going to do this? We're going to do questions. We're going to take questions from the public, and then we'll make our comments. Oh, because I've got a whole lot of notes here. Do you want me to go through item by item and ask my questions, or how do you want them? Well, yeah, who might you go through and ask your questions then? Okay, good, okay. Under this, on your staff report, page two of six,
1:06:24 Should we specify how these signs should be constructed? The exterior signs? Yes, the exterior signs. I mean, I think we could. I'm assuming that they would be the typical. In terms of weatherproof, sturdy. I think that would be fine, yes. Yeah, I mean, I think that should be, should be indicated. And at the bottom under noise, what are the fines for noise? And the reason I asked that, feeding wildlife.
1:06:52 Was an issue some years ago in our neighborhood where a lady was paying her tenant to feed the bears and the fine was $25 and the bears caused tens of thousands of dollars in damage in the neighborhood. And so what are the fines for? Do the fines have teeth in them or? I think the current fines for the noise ordinance would be the $100, $200, $500 fines. However, the police department does have what they call it like a party house ordinance where if they go to a
1:07:21 State, the same property a number of times, they have different enforcement mechanism, which I think is associated with larger fines, but I don't know what those fines are off the top of my head. Just as long as it was a serious fine to get people's attention. Okay. How do you define a large party? Because there's a little confusion in the, to me, in the wording about maximum occupancy and large parties. Does that mean people under the roof at the same time?
1:07:51 Does it mean after skiing, if everybody goes back to one house, then does that become a large party? Yeah, we discussed that and what we determined was that a large party was anything that would exceed the occupancy requirements of the unit. And let me find that. We did put it into the section here.
1:08:15 Because the occupancy has to do with heads in beds, right? And that's where the lofts, illegal lofts, come in for calculating occupancy. Not that the lofts were illegal, but they're not sleeping spaces. The occupancy is based on the building code calculations. Right. So a large party is only the number of people that can occupy. I mean, if you have a condo that has, you know, a four-pillow condo, and you have 12 people over for dinner.
1:08:44 That's, I think it's, so it's not based on the number of people that can sleep there. It's based on the number of people that can occupy that unit, which is, and I'm not sure what the calculation is, and I'm not sure, Tom, if you know the specifics, but it's based on the square footage of the unit. Okay. And that's how they determine the occupancy. So it doesn't mean the number of people that can sleep there. It's the number of people that can actually occupy it. And so. 200 square feet per person. And so you just take the total square footage of the structure divided by 200.
1:09:13 And that gives you a maximum occupancy for that structure. But the code does a lot. Can you do me a favor? Can you come to, just so that. So that's good information. Yes, so that way it'll be recorded and then we have it. Okay, thank you. So both the building and fire code require 200 square feet per person. So you take whatever the total occupants, or excuse me, total square footage of the unit, divide that by 200, that gives you a total number of people who can occupy that space.
1:09:41 The building code does allow for at any one time, you can exceed that number on a couple of occasions, and a couple of occasions is not really defined, but what it does is allows you to do the party that you're referring to, such that if nobody's staying there and sleeping there, the ability to exceed that calculation is allowed on a temporary basis for a short-term period of time.
1:10:06 Again, all that's undefined, but, you know, that's when other things fall into place, and when we work this up, the noise ordinance comes into play, parking comes into play, you know, all those other things, those peripheral things, then become the other determining factors as to whether you've exceeded not only the occupancy, but the other factors that are taken into consideration. Okay, so it's intentional then that large parties isn't...
1:10:30 Defined. Is that right? Well, what we ended up putting into the actual ordinance is that transient reunions shall not be used for activities that would exceed the maximum number of occupants unless a special event permit is reviewed and approved by the town. So if you wanted to have a large party, you would have to get a special event permit. If you wanted to exceed the maximum occupancy beyond kind of the limitations of the building code, then you would have to get a special event permit. And that's how we process that in the past. We have had these requests we've processed.
1:10:57 Allowing above the maximum occupancy through that special event permit with really the intent is notifying the neighbors, dealing with the parking, dealing with all of those issues that come up with that. Okay. Page three. I was just going to weigh in. Oh, hi, Tom. I'm sorry. Sorry. It just caught my attention that so like a typical two-bedroom condo is a thousand square feet. So that would be five occupants. That seems kind of reasonable that, you know, you have a dinner party and you have 12, you know.
1:11:27 Say there's 12 people in the unit. That wouldn't seem unreasonable. Seems silly to have to get a special permit for a party. No, that's what I was asking. I mean, where the language is scripted, it doesn't sound correct to me. You know, I think there maybe has to be some other metrics that you're applying. And who's going to get a permit to have company for dinner? Exactly. I think, you know, the intent is that it wouldn't exceed the maximum number of permitted occupants, which would take into account the caveat that the building code has, that allows occasional...
1:11:57 Increases. Well, what you want the language to encompass, because I happen to have a neighbor who rents his place out to a men's group, and then they have 30 people that sit in the garage all day long, and they have their meetings. So, and that's really problematic on the parking. Right. 30 people who sit in the garage? Right.
1:12:22 And they have their meetings. And here we're trying to market the great outdoors. It's a very unusual thing, right? But that's what you're trying to prevent. So I just maybe need to tighten that language up a little bit. Okay. Okay. A few more questions, then I'll have comments later. Talking about the exterior notice, would the neighbor who wants to see who to call, whom to call, have to trespass in order to be able to see the sign? I mean, the requirement says it has to be visible from the public.
1:12:51 Way. Okay. So should we specify, is that enough? We don't have to specify how big the numbers have to be or anything like that? You know, we looked at a number of other ordinances and I didn't, none of them specified that. Okay. Just visible from the public? That's what they all had said, but I mean, I think if there's a concern that people would have to, you know, walk up to the front door to see it and would be subject to some trespass requirements, then maybe we can talk about, you know.
1:13:21 Requiring that. I mean, I guess all of them depend on how far the sign is from, it's probably going to be different for every property, right? It's like at a condo complex, it's all a common area, right? So you could probably walk up and be able to see it. But at a single family home, you might not be able to see it from the street. And they don't want to get into an altercation with the people they're complaining about. Right. That could be a problem. Assuming it's a legal transient rental, doesn't the town have contact information available?
1:13:51 Yes, we do. I mean, I think the intent is that this would happen, you know, if they wanted to call to find out, I guess, issues about it or report issues, they could do that. Maybe the water's leaking or something like that. They could call and notify the owner. I mean, the town, if we received a complaint, we would follow up on it so the person wouldn't have to go and contact the owner themselves. But I think that the intent is to provide neighbors with the information so that they can have it quickly at hand, like, hey, you know.
1:14:19 Your water main is broken or something like that or whatever issues they're dealing with. I would assume most people would probably call the town. I mean, if there's a big party, they're probably not going to walk over and call the owner. They're just going to call the police. It seems like there's a possibility that posting that personal form of contact on every single transient rental location is just creating all these different points of contact. And then if a neighbor...
1:14:52 Contacts this neighbor about a large party or the lights are left on or the water is left on, then there's also no, the town doesn't have a record of that problem occurring. It just seems to me like either the town or the police department should be across the board a more standard point person for any problems. Presuming, of course, unless you know your neighbor personally and
1:15:22 It's not an issue, but I don't, I don't know. Am I making any sense? Yeah, no, this is, I think, I want to hear what, there's some people in the audience, I want to hear what they have to say about this, the signs. The signs, I think, is one of the most interesting parts. Right, but let's see what else, and let's go back to that in a second. What else was that? On page two of the draft ordinance, number two at the top, and maybe Tom can answer this, or Sandra, the maximum number of occupants permitted to stay in the unit. How are we defining stay? Is that stay overnight?
1:15:52 Well, I think we should insert overnight, seems like. And then failure to conform, this would be number six under B. Failure to conform to the parking and occupancy requirements is a violation of the town's municipal code. What are the consequences? It's in the violations section in the back on page six. Okay. So there are these fines that we can apply for violations.
1:16:25 There's some different options. I mean, we can do administrative citations, which is the 100, 200, 500. I would assume that if it was someone, so this is a requirement on the notice that the manager notify the occupant that if they don't comply with the parking and occupancy requirements, it's a violation of our code. So if we did have a violation of that, we could either apply the administrative citation requirements.
1:16:53 Or the second item B, the violation that's 1,000 or 2, for the first violation and 2,000 for a second or subsequent violation within three years. So it would kind of depend, the town would have to look at each case and determine that. I would assume that if there's an occupancy violation, unless there's some issue, unless we get a call or a complaint, we probably won't know about that. The parking violations are probably much easier to deal with.
1:17:22 Or to notice. If we notice that they're doing that, we can deal with that. But really the intent is to pass along these requirements to the tenant so that they're aware of them. And that might already be happening. I mean, maybe these owners, property managers are already telling these tenants, here's what you have to do. You can't have more than this number of people staying overnight in the unit. And you can only have two cars and they have to be parked here.
1:17:48 And, you know, if you want to have other cars, maybe they direct them to the park and ride or something like that, some other location in town. But I would assume that, you know, some, that there are property managers who are already telling their tenants a lot of this information and are probably kind of managing that stuff on their own, you know, dealing with that because it's like, you know, there are parking lots, a lot of these condo complexes, they have managers on site who are kind of dealing with this all the time.
1:18:12 So, but the intent is really so that the tenants understand that the tenants comply with the parking and occupancy requirements and that we have a method to deal with it if they don't. I'll skip over some of the next ones, but page four, number G, this is, I just really don't see how this is going to be enforced. I mean, this property manager at a condo complex.
1:18:39 And you can call the police, but they're busy handling the bar issues on the weekends. And I just, I really don't see how this will be enforced. Case in point. In G, the last sentence says, any propane cylinder with a capacity of greater than 2.5 pounds, less than one gallon, shall be not brought inside or passed through the structure to be refilled or stored. So we've talked about having barbecues on decks, and we have restrictions for that. Well, if it's a second or third floor, you can't.
1:19:09 Drop it off. You know, you have to bring it through the condo. How is that going to work? You can't pass it through the structure, but how are you going to enforce that when you take it back to exchange it for another one? There's just a whole... Oh, okay. But practically, how will that work with condos on upper floors?
1:19:35 Whenever we do inspections and we find propane cylinders inside, we tell people they have to be taken outside, give them the rationale behind the education part of it. Okay. And they move them outside. How quickly they move them back in, I can't say, but that's just part. A propane cylinder inside your house is essentially a bomb sitting. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So that's the reason behind the rationale. Huh.
1:20:02 Okay. Well, I've still got lots of concerns about enforcement. But we have to put that in there because it's state code. Yeah, no, no, I understand, but I don't see, but I'm concerned about barbecues on second and third floor decks. Well, you know, do you want to be up above the barbecue? Good old updraft. Okay. Anyways, I've got specific comments, but those are my questions. Okay. Thank you. Do we have any comments from the public? Tom Hodges with Mammoth Mountains here. So, the sign, signage.
1:20:39 Is the interesting issue. So, and I'm thinking specifically the properties that we manage, the condo hotel properties, the large condo hotel properties, Juniper Springs Lodge, the Village. So would the proposed ordinance require every single one of those units that is participating in transient rentals that we administer through our front desk operation to have a
1:21:04 Sign screwed on the hallway outside their door? No, the intent of this ordinance is not to apply to condo hotels, properties that function like a hotel or hotels. So they would require signs? It's really residential units, so condominiums, townhomes, single-family homes, those types of uses. But we are not intending that this ordinance would apply to any of the hotels or condo hotels in town.
1:21:31 And there's other condominiums, like I'm thinking of Summit that has interior hallways. There's a handful of them that have interior hallways. Well, one of the, so Sandra and I had a pre-meeting when we discussed this. So I think in some of the bigger complexes, so for example in Snow Creek 5, which is 296 condominium townhomes, but the thing at Snow Creek 5, there's a minimum of five different reservation companies out there.
1:22:00 So I think there should be an option that would allow some sort of master board because there's no way you can be able to put exterior signs on everything. Right, right. So to answer your question then, so Juniper Springs Lodge, Sunstone, that would be deemed a condo hotel summit, then I think we should need to look at the alternative of having a master board in a public's place. Okay.
1:22:31 That's what I'm thinking, but I'd like to hear more feedback on that. I'm not so concerned about it, because they'd be unsightly, you'd have a bunch of little tin signs in the hallway, you know. Precisely, right? I mean, so we've worked so hard on our sign code, and while I think this is a really good idea, I haven't figured out the practicality, I mean, I mentally can't figure out the practicality of it. No, no. So you're suggesting have a master sign somewhere, you know, either outside the town offices that, at least. Not at the town offices, but like at.
1:22:59 At the summit complex, for example, there would be a master sign outside the reservation office. Because, so some, like take, let's take the summit, I, you know, so there's probably five or six different people that do rentals in there, I would suspect. There are probably VRB rentals, okay, and so if you have a, you know, a problem in 216 or whatever.
1:23:24 How, you know, and how do you know who that is, because you don't know who the rental agency is. Right. So, that would be my thought on that. I don't know. Right. I've seen other resorts, well, Big Bear, for example, where the homes have, I'm trying to remember, they're not the size of a real estate sign, but they're fairly small, they're staked out in front. Obviously, in our community, that'd be challenging because of the snow conditions. I mean, stuff would be buried. And a lot of stuff. Almost time and damaged and destroyed one winter's.
1:23:54 Use, but anyway, there's just observations. No, it's an, yeah, I'm not, an interesting observation. Tom Heller with the fire department. And we hadn't actually talked about combining the interior and the exterior signs together, but there would be that possibility as well. Maybe those four items could be included on the sign that's inside the door, which would look very similar to a sign that we've all seen in hotel rooms.
1:24:28 And then specifies not only what's written here for exterior, but then identifies those nine items that are included under the interior information. But can you hold a point just a second? But wasn't the purpose of hearing the exterior so that if there was a violation that somebody in the public could then?
1:24:50 Know who to contact, right? Right, right. Understand. Okay, all right. It also informs the people inside who all they should be getting a hold of them. Right, okay. So off of that topic, different topic as it relates to single family residential issues. The fire district still identifies this as a change of use. We believe that the building code that the town is required to enforce identifies this as a change of use.
1:25:17 So, in our discussions, we've kind of said that any buildings that pull a business license from January 1, 2010 onward, so from that date going forward, will be required to meet certain fire requirements. And we're still negotiating with the town. We haven't had a lot of discussion recently, but we're still discussing the fact that that might include sprinklers.
1:25:45 So there are still some very significant major issues that need to be resolved before this becomes reality, and we'll be presenting that to the town council, and we'll be presenting that to whoever else needs to hear it. January 1, 2010, prior to that, if you pulled a business license and you rented out your facilities, we're showing that as being basically grandfathered in. But anything from that date going forward, since...
1:26:12 The requirement was that any new construction had to have sprinklers. If you've decided to take your privately owned facility and make a commercial facility out of it or a commercial use out of it, why would you get the advantage of not having to sprinkler and incur the cost that anyone who built from that day on would have had to have incurred? So we're still working through that issue. But as far as the rest of the list that's on here,
1:26:37 Those are all items that we agree with and they may even prove to be some mitigation measures that we can apply if the ultimate outcome is we decide not to require sprinklers from January 1st. There may be some other date in there. We only got involved in the business license process in about 2012, so we may draw a line someplace in 2012 and say any business licenses that were pulled after that because that's when we initially had this.
1:27:06 The original discussion of how is it that we're renting out single family homes and providing or issuing business licenses and that was the point at which we put the stop to any additional licenses being pulled out or at least they're on notice that they may have to do additional mitigation in order to continue to rent their places out. Okay, so while we're on this subject, so I think I know the answer. So explain to us what the fire code says.
1:27:37 Is required of a sleeping loft. Of sleeping? Loft. That's actually a whole different discussion. But if you want to open that can of worms. Well, because I do think it becomes part of this because, you know, one of the things is what's going to be inspected and not be inspected. Well, in order to be a code compliant loft, it has to have a legal set of stairs going up to it.
1:28:04 Can't have a ladder, can't have a vertical set of stairs that don't meet the code requirements, and it has to have secondary egress. And secondary egress is very simple. It has to have a certain size window. If it's a loft, it's on a second or third floor, which means it has to have an openable window that has 5.7 square feet of openable space that you can pass through. And we have hundreds of lofts in town that don't meet that requirement.
1:28:29 And we're in the process, I don't know if you saw the letter, but we're in the process of starting to deal with that issue. But that really is separate from, in a way it's separate from this. I can certainly understand that a lot of lofts are used as part of a unit that is rented out. Well, I mean, the only reason I don't know if it's separate is because when we start talking about should inspections be required or not being required.
1:28:58 The building code, the town's in a different situation than the fire district is. The building code does not allow the town to go in unless there's some egregious violation of the building code. Somebody goes in and starts modifying their building, doing some things that they have not pulled a permit for, the town has the ability to go in. If there's the large party that was discussed earlier, the PD has the ability to go in.
1:29:26 Right. But you can't just go in for any purpose and do an inspection. The fire code actually allows the fire district to do such an inspection. And as we've been talking through this issue, and I don't want to speak for Sandra, I'll just tell you from the fire district side of things, we're going to do inspections of everyone at some undetermined time period, but we're going to do inspections of every business license where somebody pulls.
1:29:53 a request to rent out their facility, because it's a commercial operation, and there's an expectation on the part of whoever's renting that place that it meets the code. Just to clarify, there is a provision in our current business tax certificate, TOT requirements, that allows town staff to inspect. Okay. For this ordinance, we were going to propose that the
1:30:16 The manager of property owner certifies it, really just signs something saying that they have all of, they meet all of these requirements. Right. And we weren't proposing to inspect every single one before we issue their business license tax certificate.
1:30:31 However, we did include a caveat that we could inspect at any time, which is already in the code right now. It already says that we could. But if the fire department subsequently then, I just want to make sure I'm clarified on this, that the fire department subsequently comes and inspects it and finds out that if something says this, you know, this condo can sleep six and you deem that it really, really legally can only sleep four, then they have to change it, right? Well, actually, on the business license application,
1:31:01 The square footage and the number of occupants that can sleep there will be identified right on that. It's currently on the present application. Right. But let's say somebody said that something could, their business license said they slept six because they were including a loft that did not meet the current code and then the fire department came and inspect it, just hypothetically, and then they would be required to change it to four, not six, right? Correct. Okay, I just want to make sure I see how this is all going to fall through.
1:31:30 Now, Sandra, following on what you just said about inspections, why wouldn't part of the permit, not permit fee, but the license fee be an inspection of the property? We would have to really increase the fees in order to cover the inspection for each unit. But when you consider how things could be misrepresented on an application, it seems. And that's one of the questions that we had.
1:31:57 for the commission to discuss is should we require an inspection. The city of Big Bear, they require every single new transient unit to be inspected, but they contract out. They basically certify inspectors and then they have those people doing all the inspections and just kind of shining them off. But we thought that it might be a little bit too onerous to do that.
1:32:22 So that's why we were proposing the certification that the owner would certify and then the fire district conducts, you know, routine inspections over some period of time to follow up on those. Hi, Terry Stelick. My first question was, what's Terry's comments on this? So there you are. You know, and I have to apologize because I have not gone through and thoroughly vetted everything in here. And I would actually like to request that this come to the TOT compliance.
1:32:52 at our next meeting this month, and because I think this is something that should be vetted through that committee, and any comments could be brought back as well. We can do that. So, thank you. You know, as far as the inspection goes, right, on this, you're not requiring inspection, you are requiring somebody just to sign off. Perhaps we could have a one sheet that there are boxes that people are, instead of just signing something that's, you know, half the time you know people aren't reading.
1:33:20 that they physically have to check off that yes I have these things you know or no I don't so then you have that sheet that goes with your license and your all of your information so at least it forces somebody to look at an individual item as opposed to just say yes I read all of this which as we know in agreements most of us just go yeah okay so anyways and
1:33:47 So I'm just going to kind of go through a few different things here. Parking compliance, has anything changed from what was previously in the ordinance on that piece? Or is that pretty much the same language? We didn't make any changes to the parking requirements. Are you talking about the zoning code update? We didn't make any changes to the residential parking requirements as part of the zoning code update.
1:34:08 A lot of these condo complexes were built under the county standards, so they may not meet the current parking requirements. So our intent is not to make, if someone wants to rent out a condo unit, not to make them have to provide additional parking, but simply to keep the tenants of that unit within the parking spaces that are allocated to that unit. So if you only have two spaces allocated to the unit, then the tenant can only have two cars parked in that parking lot.
1:34:35 And I'm assuming that you already do that. Yeah, we monitor that within a condominium complex, but you do have homes that are renting right now, currently. And so, you know, as far as that goes, you know, there are many issues with parking currently. There's houses that were up on Forest Trail that were being rented constantly this last winter that had anywhere from 6 to 12 cars.
1:35:05 Half of them parked out into the street and everything else. So, you know, rules are great, but if they're not upheld and enforced, they're simply words to pacify those that are affected or concerned. And so, you know, the compliance, the fines and the consequences are all something that has to be a piece that is obviously in being on that TOT compliance.
1:35:32 Something that we've been working towards, but we're far from even being average. So, anyways, that's one piece. As far as the signs go, potentially within, I think the signs that you're talking about, most of these signs, if you look at South Lake Tahoe or Big Bear, any of those, their homes that are being rented have those signs on the outside of the buildings or posted outside by the street, however, so that somebody can, if there's a problem,
1:36:01 Call whoever that contact is. As far as a condo goes, maybe there's language that's added that if there is no management for that complex, that maybe they're required to have that sign on the door. But if there is a manager that is a 24-7 contact at that complex, that whoever is pulling that permit has to give the management company their contact information so that
1:36:29 Anybody in that complex, there's only one contact information, and that's the manager, and then the manager's able to contact whoever that person is. Being a manager, I can't say that I'm going to like that a whole lot, but I just can't say having... No, I was going to say, you don't happen to know a manager quite closely. Yeah, I just can't see a sign on each and every door, so... There's a big difference between the reservation companies now and the management companies. I mean, that's...
1:36:55 That was one of my comments later on. We really need to kind of define that. Well, I guess, and that's what I'm saying, if there's a management company for a complex that they, whomever's renting, whether it's a management company or an individual renting their property, they have to give that management company a 24-7 contact that's taking care of their place. And I guess that's another piece that I had a question here. In the TOT license,
1:37:23 There is a 24-7 local contact that's required, that's specified. But on this one, it does not say that it's a 24-7 local. It just basically somebody has to be able to be contacted within 24 hours and respond. But it doesn't basically say that somebody has to be within an area where they can, you know, deal with something here. I guess, you know, if you have somebody down south that's...
1:37:51 You know, you have somebody comes to something and they're locked out. You know, who are they calling? And that's another thing where that comes from. And, you know, unfortunately, I do. We get phone calls in the middle of the night because somebody else is locked out and that homeowner hasn't made very good contact with their guest and made those appropriate recommendations and keys available. So anyways, but I think that it should at least be consistent with your...
1:38:20 TOT licensing as far as the language goes. I had a question on how you were determining occupancy. You guys have talked a bunch about that. There are some other places that actually determine occupancy within, and I don't know, you know, there can be two in a bedroom plus, you know, and then within the whole house they can have one or two extra people or something like that.
1:38:43 That could potentially be on a sleeper sofa or something, but I don't know how that fits within fire code and building code, but I know that's been in some of the, I've done a lot of research on other area, other areas information, and I know that was on some of theirs, so anyhow, and I was just wondering who verifies that the correct number of occupancy or parking, parking, you know, kind of if it's a home.
1:39:10 Is a whole different thing. Who's verifying that? So if you had that one sheet that says, you know, I can do this, then it could at least be verified that I'm saying I can have five cars on this piece of property. And, you know, if we have a system that keeps all properties in one place, that should all be in kind of a one-stop shop thing. So, trash.
1:39:33 It was determined that, you know, the people would be notified as far as where the trash goes. What are the violations for somebody putting trash in a receptacle that they're not supposed to be putting trash in? The Solid Waste Ordinance does have violations, and I don't find specific fines, but I don't know the amount off the top of my head. I think it's the, I think it's 100, 300 and 500 for the first, second, and third violations.
1:40:03 It's difficult though when people are putting trash into a dumpster. The only time we can find someone is if we can catch them doing it. So that's been an issue and that's been something that the Public Works Department has been kind of grappling with as we implement the new solid waste ordinance. So I think, you know, they're going to try to work. We did, Shireen, I'm not sure if you were here when Shireen spoke, but we do have a new kind of
1:40:27 Trash policy, the way we're dealing with spills, so that hopefully we can get them cleaned up quicker, deal with them on the weekends. We've been working closely with Mammoth Disposal to at least get them cleaned up. And then currently what we would do is if the trash came out of whatever dumpster, we would be requiring that that owner pay for the cleanup.
1:40:47 So we would provide them with an opportunity, the tenants, to come out and clean it up, and then if they can't do it or if there's no one there, we would call Mammoth Disposal who has someone dedicated to this, to cleaning those up. And then the property owners with their, if you have a dumpster at your site, you have an agreement with Mammoth Disposal. Apparently in those agreements it does say that you're responsible for the trash in that dumpster and that you agree to paying an additional fee if there is a cleanup necessary. So they just bill the owner.
1:41:15 of that, or the person who pays on that dumpster. So that's kind of the process now. I mean, I think eventually as we move forward, we need to look more into how we can deal with people kind of poaching dumpsters and those issues. And I think really what, personally what I think it needs is a method for people to throw away their trash that's convenient. I think a lot of it happens in Sierra Valley sites. I think there's issues with people.
1:41:41 For taking the trash down to the disposal, maybe they don't have a car, that kind of thing. So there's a lot of issues that we have, particularly in the Sierra Valley sites, with kind of the poaching of dumpsters, and I'm not sure if you have issues up there too. So I think that it's a huge town-wide issue. I mean, I don't think we're trying to solve that through this ordinance, but I think Public Works is looking into what we can do to make it better. I know Big Bear does have public dumpsters that you can...
1:42:09 Throw away your trash for free. There's no charge. So I think that they market that to their guests. So if you're going to leave, you know, you don't have the trash cans, just drive by the fire station or here. It's something like Barroware, something like that dumpster. So, I mean, I don't know if that's something that we could do, but I think it's worth looking into. Yeah, because it is, you guys used to actually have one, I think, on Burger Street, and it was a mess.
1:42:32 Yeah. Yeah, there's trash everywhere. People don't secure them properly. It really was a mess. But we have issues, and really there is no recourse for us. We've turned people in, turned people in because we have a car license. We've been told, oh, well, the person that owns that car and it's registered to as a female, you just said it was a male that dumped. You know, there's just, there's, we continually pay for additional dumps at,
1:42:59 And then, you know, how is it being
1:43:27 dealt with and enforced. So anyways, because it is a huge expense for Seasons 4. We've been threatened with violations because over Christmas all of a sudden we go out there and there's just trash piled on the sides and we've been told to lock the dumpsters. If you lock the dumpsters, they just stick it on the sides or the top. That is not a solution to anything. So anyhow, it is a problem.
1:43:56 Let me see trash. It was the 24-7 local. And so, you know, you're referring to the California Building Code and California Residential Code when you're talking about occupants in as far as how many can be in each unit. Nobody knows the California Building Code. And yes, it would be their responsibility to read that. But this is where I'm saying, you know, what we...
1:44:23 Can put in something to say, oh yes, somebody's going to read it, and to put in something that's very legible and people know right off the bat without having to go do mass amounts of research and read this document that's, you know, ridiculous is another thing. So I think that's where I'm just doing. Those are kind of just some off-the-top comments that I have just when I was glancing over things to get down here to make some comments. But I would like to
1:44:49 Be able to look at it a little bit more thoroughly and actually have it brought to the TOT compliance because I think that would be a great group to get some information from. That's a very nice suggestion. Thank you. Okay. Are there any other comments? All right. Commissioner Tenney, thank you. Let's make comments and then we'll go through our three discussion questions real quickly. I think we're good. Well, I'll start off with, this is called a quality of life ordinance.
1:45:19 And it lists all the things that we need to have to fulfill our community vision. And the very first line talks about we're committed to providing the very highest quality of life for our residents and the highest quality of experience for our visitors. And doing all this is what it's going to take. But I think it's unenforceable. And I'm really concerned about that. You know, we can put all this good language down and say these are the things that are going to happen. But I don't think it's going to happen. And I'm really concerned about that.
1:45:49 And so I think the town has to commit to really beefing up code enforcement. There's just many things. And we have, you know, during the graveyard shift, isn't it just two officers on duty on Saturdays or is it one? There's always two officers on duty, but they don't respond between 3 a.m. and 7. Okay, that's what I'm remembering. But all these things that we outline, you know, who are you going to call? They are on call. Yeah, but still it's...
1:46:17 We just don't have enough to adequately enforce this. I'm very troubled by that because the whole thing with the initiative, and I've heard from a lot of people in the last week, was, you know, the highest quality of life for locals, for the people who live here. So, with that being said, I think under purpose of chapter, if we're going to, I mean, I'll commit to the process here, even though I don't think it's going to work.
1:46:42 I think we were asked by council to do that. Yes, no, I understand. I understand. So I don't think it's good. We have to commit to the process. Yes, okay, so I'm committed to the process. Okay. So under purpose of chapter, I think it's important that you refer back to the vision statement and talk about the highest quality of experience for visitors and the very highest quality of life for residents. I think that should be in the purpose of chapter. I don't know if Amy and Mickey agree with me, but I'm...
1:47:09 What? No, you agree? Okay, good. Yes. Small thing under definitions, under B, rentals, it should be plural. Got it, thank you. Under A, exterior notice, I think it's better to use square inches rather than square feet. It's very, very clear because there's a common confusion trying to calculate square feet. So I would say 288 square inches, not two square feet. I've had a lot of experience.
1:47:40 With people having trouble with that. My question about would a neighbor who wants to complain have to trespass to see the sign, but I already brought that up. I think under, on page two of the draft, under two, and then under interior notice one, I think you need to define to stay. I think under B4 for interior notice, the person responsible for an unlawful large party may be cited and fined, and I think
1:48:08 An amount up to, I think that should be clearly stated in the ordinance. Oh, five. What is this about if you, maybe there's something I don't understand about Mammoth Disposal, our franchise trash people. You have to, you could leave it at the transfer station for a fee. If you're renting a condo, can't you leave your trash? How does that work? You can't.
1:48:38 Condo, complexes, dumpsters. You can leave it there. This is probably more for if you're at a single-family home, you could take it to the transfer station. But the property owner is paying annually, the owner of that home, isn't that, what is this for a fee? Because the property owner, by virtue of being a property owner, has to pay, is paying the fee. So what's this fee? Well, I'll follow up with Mammoth's disposal and find out. Okay, that's confusing to me.
1:49:09 The failure to conform, we talked about consequences. Number seven, I think it should be name of the managing agency agent property manager and or owner of the unit. Emergency contact information posted inside and out, but that's still got to be worked out. Maybe Terry can address this. How do you restrict the parking for transient rental? What do you do? Is it signage? I mean, how do you restrict?
1:49:37 Parking for Trent, say this is where you can park and that's it. Because you're in the trenches, you know about this. In a condo I think you have, it's a lot more defined. So in a condo we have certain, you know, parking areas and each of our condo sizes are allowed so many cars per unit. And so it occupies, you know, our one bedroom can only have one car. So if somebody comes up here with another car,
1:50:04 They either have to, we either have to have, you know, not full occupancy so they're able to park that car there, or they have to find additional parking for that. So, which there really is none in town. So we actually, when we're doing our reservation, we say your unit will park one car, two cars, three cars. But as a management company, we post signs and says if you don't have a permit, you're going to be towed.
1:50:30 And you have the license numbers. Yeah. Yeah, when they check in. Okay, good. Thank you. Under C, on page 3 of the draft ordinance, conditions of operation, failure to respond to calls in a timely appropriate manner on more than 3 occasions. Where did the number 3 come from? Why not 2? Because, you know, fool me once, shame on me. Fool me twice, shame on you.
1:50:53 No, excuse me, the other way around, fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. I think this was consistent with other ordinances that, similar ordinances we looked at, but this is, I mean, all of this is up for discussion to the commission. I would prefer two. I mean, if it's a problem, transient rental. Well, especially if it's more than two, because that automatically implies three.
1:51:16 Oh, yes, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. So, right now, it's implying four. You're right, Amy. I didn't catch that. That's good. Okay. On E, on that page, shouldn't the web advertising include not only the business certificate number, you know, business license tax certificate number, but the number of occupants allowed? I think it's on there already. In the web advertising, any ad?
1:51:44 I'm not sure what they typically advertise. We just want, the requirement, the intent of that is to, that we know when we're doing our enforcement that they actually have a business license tax certificate. So, I mean, I'm not sure if we need to require that they have a number of occupants. I think they usually say that in the advertising, like, you know, two bedrooms or, you know, sleeps up to a certain number. But the requirement, the intent is so that we can enforce our requirements.
1:52:14 So that you can enforce? So we know when we're doing, so we do, you know, web searching, looking for illegal units, we search. Okay, that was going to be my next question, is how in the world are you going to enforce that? Are you going to troll through every single, you know, rental website there is out there to see if they have? That's what we do right now. Okay. Yeah, I mean, so the intent is that as we're going through, we say, oh, business tax, business tax, okay, okay, okay, and then we see one that doesn't have it, then we know, okay, ding, that might be one that might be illegal, so then that helps us.
1:52:43 So yeah, we do have one person dedicated to enforcement again, so that's really good. Page four at the top of telephone services available. Considering that landlines are becoming dinosaurs, how's that going to work? I mean, to have a phone. For instance, if somebody comes up here, I don't know what the coverage is for T-Mobile and Sprint here. I know in different parts of town, AT&T works and Verizon doesn't and vice versa.
1:53:11 Should we say anything about requiring a landline? Because people are getting rid of them right and left. I mean, that's what this does say. It says if telephone service is available, they shall be connected to the local carrier and in working condition. But if they don't have a landline, then I don't know. I mean, the intent of this is if there's a possibility that you could, you are served by Verizon or whatever service, you should, you shall have, you shall be connected.
1:53:42 So you're requiring every, I mean, telephone company here services every property in the town. So you're saying that everyone who is, has a business tax license has to have telephone service. That's what's proposed. Right. It's not served. For some reason it's not served. That's not the way I read it. Yeah, that's not the way I read it. It's not served because the owner chose not to subscribe to telephone service and provide a telephone.
1:54:16 Well, maybe we should strike that last sentence. I mean, I don't know. I kind of question. Why don't they have a home line? I mean, it's kind of like saying you're going to go outside and pump your water. Right. I mean, this was carried forward like several of the other ordinances that we compared had a similar requirement, so we brought it forward. But if the commission thinks it's unreasonable, we can. I think it's just becoming outdated. Right. More than anything. Okay.
1:54:47 On C, it seems one fire extinguisher per 3,000 square feet of building area really seems low to me. I would want one per floor, but that's probably not the code. Tom would know about that. But that seems more realistic. It has to be the code. So it has to be the code. So, okay.
1:55:16 Within 75 feet of the front door. Interior. Okay, that's the code. F, thinking about the Knowles fire, I would like to see that restated, shall be equipped with a clearly labeled minimum 5 gallon metal container, delete which is clearly labeled, and then I would, in the parentheses, IE, I would like to see it say, do not place can on or near any furniture, wood deck,
1:55:45 or other combustible surface, really emphasizing wood decks, because, you know, when it's cold and they put the ashes out on the deck and don't think about it. Tom, would that work for you? Terry's got a question, Nikki. Oh, I'm sorry. Terry, why don't you just sit up here? I was reading that last paragraph. This may seem really silly and I don't know how you want to put the verbiage.
1:56:15 But maybe we want to put something in there that people can't build a fire in anything other than that's a designated fireplace. Something like that. There's been nine people that have a fire pit outside. They'll, you know, oh, I want to have a campfire. And they'll, not necessarily. You mean they just make a fire pit? Not necessarily in condos. Yeah, I came home to lunch with a house next to me one day and they had a fire pit right next to their balcony. And they had a fire going. Wow. Well, there are permits available in town for fire pits.
1:56:45 For residential fire pits. Well, this would be any property, so. Right. But I don't know if there's anywhere that's not designated a campsite or anything else that really actually can have a fire outside. Mm-hmm. I'm so freaked by fire. The definition of a fire pit should be in there. Mm-hmm. There is a code has a legal definition of a fire pit and fire pits are issued under permit and during periods of time when the forest suspends.
1:57:16 Fires in the forest, we suspend fires in town. You can only have a fire pit if you're the owner of the building or the owner has to be present. There's a whole list of criteria, but fire pits are permitted. There's a set of criteria. You have to have a screen over top of it. It has to be 10 feet away from combustibles. There's a whole list of criteria, but they are legit. So how would we word this? It can only be a fire in the fireplace or it has to be a permitted fire, right?
1:57:45 Well, if they're renting the property, then they're not the owners of the building, and they can't have a fire in a fire pit anyway. That's right. Is that right? Yeah. Because they're not permitted. Because they're not the owners of the property. But isn't it just simpler just to say, or permitted? I wouldn't mix our pits with our place. I think the two completely separate issues, and they're really separate from the barbecues that are the next issue. Right. So they just need to be a separate standalone. Okay. All right. Okay.
1:58:18 Continuing with G, do you think someplace we should say that the barbecues need to be kept clean and free of excess grease being a fire hazard? I mean, this is a very specific and detailed ordinance. Do we want to put that in there? Just a thought? Yeah, I know, but that's what I think about the whole thing. But while we're on this point, I thought you couldn't have a hard propane supply. Well, I thought that was illegal in condominiums.
1:59:01 That everybody had to have a propane tank, no? Or was that the individual associations that determined that? Individual associations can make whatever rules they care to. If you have a building that's four stories or greater, you cannot have a barbecue on your deck. If it's less than four stories, so three stories or less, you can have a hard piped, you can have hard pipe going to the exterior and then hook up to that, as long as you have a 90 degree shutoff that serves a barbecue.
1:59:33 And you cannot have wood or charcoal on a deck for any kind of multifamily residential situation, but you can for single family, then it has to be at least 10 feet away from the combustible material. If you have non-combustible siding, then you can have a barbecue and burn wood or charcoal anywhere you care to. The only exception to that is that if you have a sprinkler head on the deck that you're going to have a barbecue, then you can have a barbecue on the deck. Charcoal or wood barbecue.
2:00:04 Right. Charcoal and wood are prohibited except for single family homes. Just think of all the things we're learning. This is amazing. This is amazing. And my last one on page 6, DD, I would say so as not to produce glare, and I would put glare first because our outdoor lighting ordinance is an anti-glare ordinance, and we could even define that as saying excessive light that trespasses on roadway or neighboring property because that's what the outdoor lighting ordinance says.
2:00:33 Light trespassing glare is what it's all about. And those are all my, that was venting and specifics. So there we are. Thank you. Okay. All right. So I would be really interested to hear what the TOT compliance group had to say about signage. I think we just really, as we've talked about, we just need to come up with a little bit of program for signage. That was a good suggestion. I think it's, we,
2:01:03 Discuss this. It's really important in our definitions that it's clearly defined the difference between a reservation company and a property manager. And then regarding parking, I just didn't know if there could be some sort of statement saying, you know, it says, if you say four cars are allowed to park on this premise and there's a two-car garage, are you going to require them to park in the garage?
2:01:29 I mean, I don't think that's the intent to require them to park in the garage. I think the intent is for them not to exceed the amount of allowable parking. So if there's... So the problem is, is like if there's a two-car garage and there's two parking spaces outside the garage and they allow four cars, then you have... They should only be allowing the number of cars, the number of spaces that they actually are allowed to occupy. So I mean, if the owner uses that garage as storage for all their stuff for when they come up...
2:01:55 Then they should be saying that there's only two spaces available. So the number of spaces that they put on there should be the number of spaces that are available. Okay. All right. So let's go through our questions really quick and give you some feedback on this. So the first question, is it appropriate to call key safety requirements for transient rentals in the ordinance or would a general reference? So I think the ordinance should just be
2:02:34 Personally, a general reference, but then really, to me, what would be key is the handout, keeping the handout updated so that people know where they're legally being required to do. I mean, that'd be kind of my preference. Because we don't want to have to go back and change the ordinance every time there's an ordinance. A handout provided by the town to owners that are going to rent. Okay. Do you agree? I think the...
2:03:03 Building code and residential code should be cited that I think the ordinance should be spell it out like we just like is done here in the draft. Okay, but see in the ordinance though if you say for example what the ordinance currently says about propane cylinders and then they change it then we have to go back and change our ordinance.
2:03:27 So we don't want to have to go through the legal process of changing the order. Okay, I understand. What we want to do is keep ourselves legally compliant and then, I think it's just easier, if I'm understanding you right correctly, to keep this handout page that we give updated with the current language on things. Unless you said, or the current California Building Code regulation. Well, but if you're renting something, you're not going to look up. Yeah, okay, yeah, I see what you're saying. Okay. Right? Right. Okay.
2:03:58 And then should a transient rental unit require inspection either by the town or by the approved inspector or is it sufficient to have the applicant sign up form? I think the owner should pay for an inspection and I think there should be inspections of everyone that should be part of the business tax license fee. Realistically, what is involved in the inspection and how much of a time commitment or expense does that entail? Tom, do you want to?
2:04:28 Kind of walk through what you typically do in your inspections. But that's the fire department inspection. This question is a town inspection. It would be a transient rental inspection. But they would be looking at similar. They would be involved. I mean, they walk the property, they look at all these safety. I mean, most of these requirements are safety requirements. We could have been done in 10 minutes, 5 minutes. Depends on the unit, but the size of the unit and what condition it's true. But, no, we can, in our estimation, as far as determining, because we are going to charge for our inspection.
2:04:58 And in determining what that would consist of, we figured that it's a 10 to 15 minute visit to that occupancy. Our list isn't as extensive as what's on here, but 10 to 15 minutes is probably what it's going to take. How much do you charge for inspections? That's yet to be determined. My guess is we're going to charge somewhere in the neighborhood between $30 and $60. So you don't conduct inspections right now of transient rentals? We don't charge right now for inspections. Oh, okay.
2:05:28 Okay. But once we start, if, you know, if this all goes through, it changes the complexion of things. I just don't think a checklist is realistic. I mean, even though... Well, okay, but so the question is, are we going to finish the town required? And my feeling is, is that when they go through the town process, they should self-certify, and then, because subsequently, the fire department's already made the commitment that they're going to go and do inspections.
2:05:56 So you're saying this would be a double inspection, even though the town's list is more comprehensive, fire is more concerned about safety. Or my other thought would be is that a town would be required to do inspection if a building was over a certain age. So anything that was built prior to the town being formed, so if it was... Prior to 1986?
2:06:22 Yeah, are you kidding? There's 40% of our condominiums were built prior to 1986. That's true. I think if you're going to go into the business of renting your property for transient nightly rentals, then I think it should be inspected. I don't think it should be done by private contractors. I think it should be done by...
2:06:41 The town, which would, and the fee would pay for the person who did the inspections. I just think there's like problems like you take like a, and maybe this is the lodging association would have to come in, but like, so a place like the summit, or seasons four, I mean where you have a lot of properties on rentals, but basically have this almost the same standard over and over again. I just think it's a little redundant to ask those kinds of properties. But maybe that's something the lodging association could.
2:07:11 comment back to town staff and the practicality of it. Sandra asked me to have this forwarded to the Lodging Association. We actually just got that to John Morris today to send out to everybody. So we can make sure that they get those comments back. Is there consensus to make a recommendation to council to include that? I mean, or would you like to staff to work with the Lodging Association and then present the question to council when we go in July?
2:07:48 I think it's definitely worth further consideration, and I don't think a small fee in the realm of what Tom was saying, $30 to $60, is unrealistic for a homeowner to pay for an initial inspection upon getting a license. You know, if it gets significantly higher than that, then you might want to think twice about it.
2:08:14 So how are you making it for the... Well, no, I mean, it's fine. I just, I'd be really curious to see what the lodging associates. Okay. So, for example, if you take, just because I'm familiar, the 296 townhomes at Snow Creek 5, the property inspections are different for real estate. I can almost cite you word for word what every single property inspection is going to say because every property is almost the same, one after the other after another. So, in...
2:08:42 There should be some measure of efficiency. I mean, we obviously don't want to have unsafe buildings, but then there really should be some way of if there's something newer quality or there's a number of places in an association, then maybe there should be some sort of exception to it. Well, what's going to happen with this item today? Because we're taking public comment, we're offering our comments, and now we've asked for...
2:09:08 Reporting back from lodging and from the T.O.T. Committee? Sandra's is going to report it all to town council. Okay, they would report back to you and then all of that would go to town council. So we don't need to continue this item or anything like that. Yeah, we can't because they don't have time. Okay. Town council wants this. Okay. Right? Okay. Yes. I guess you should have your wireless mic. I guess when I was listening to this I was assuming that's on a new certificate.
2:09:38 So most of these folks, unless they change rental companies, then it might be required of that. But are we saying that so for all of my current TOT certificates, we'd have to go back and pay for an inspection? Is that what you're saying? I think the intent of the certification is for a new business. So you would certify. So I would assume that the inspection would be in that same case for a new, not for renewals or anything like that. Anytime there's a new transient rental.
2:10:06 So if they're doing anew, you're kind of dealing it on a one-on-one basis as opposed to coming in with 100 properties or more. That's a good point. That's a very good point. All right. The ordinance currently proposes to maintain the current business license tax certificate and transient occupancy tax certificate process. The questions were raised as to whether the town should implement a separate permit process.
2:10:33 for transient rentals, which could include a nominal fee that would pay for enforcement of the provisions. The commission should provide input as to whether staff should consider proposing this type of process to counsel. My question there is why nominal? Well, I mean, there's a significant number of TOT certificates in town, and a nominal fee could generate, I mean, even like a $10 fee could generate enough money to pay for one person to.
2:11:02 Just focus on the enforcement of these provisions. And can you remind me, the TOT certificate has to be renewed every year? And there's one per unit that's rented, whether one owner owns 100 units. So there's a TOT certificate for each unit. Right. And that's that, yeah, the process we're going through right now is to get them all into our computer systems. $10 doesn't even seem nominal to me when you consider what lunch at a fast food place costs. I mean, $10 is just...
2:11:33 Yeah, but you know, I mean, here, let me just put it. Can one person enforce all this? Well, let me play devil advocate to us, right? We are a mountain resort community. Right. We live off of tourism. I mean, and when you add up all the costs, okay, so one, you know, if you were the average person who was renting your townhome now, you've had a drop in your gross rental income, you pay
2:12:01 A fee to your reservation company. You're paying a TOT fee. You're paying a... I mean, it's kind of like how we're talking about other cumulative fees. I mean, I think if there's a very compelling reason, like if the fire department's going out to do something, I can see it. I just hate adding fees for fee's sake, personally. But I go back to the purpose of the ordinance. We're trying to provide the highest quality of experience for the visitor and the highest quality of life for the residents. And if we don't have enforcement, it won't work.
2:12:30 But that's what you have your, that's what you would use your penalties for, I would think, personally. The penalties are just, we just don't end up. We don't end up. Yeah, I just, enforcement is key here, so if nominal is $10, I think that's just doomed to fail. If there's consensus from the commission that you'd like to look into this, we could look into and propose some options for fees to the council. So the council could decide what the fee would be.
2:12:59 I think we have a significant number of TOT certificates, like I said, so even a small fee like that could pay for one person to be enforcing this. So, I mean, I think the intent would be not to place an additional burden on the transient rental.
2:13:21 Managers, but to have some additional fees to pay for the enforcement. But it's really kind of just a question came up. We heard that question and we just wanted to pass it along to the commission. I understand what you're saying. 13% already, remember. Yeah. No, I understand what you're saying. So just enforcement is the only way this will possibly work. All right. So you have enough input from us on all that? I think so. I don't hear consensus that you want. That's right. I would say there's not consensus. Okay. Okay.
2:13:48 You can let council know. They can make their decisions. Yes. Okay. But, you know, I mean, it's a really good exercise. When people say things right in ordinance, you know, I think people think it's a very simple process, and then you get into the details of it, and it's never simple. There's always more elements and unintended consequences, right? So, thank you. Thank you, Terry. I can't quite see you. Okay. All right.
2:14:19 So it's basically just a brochure, and maybe that's something that people could buy some babies. And I don't know whether people would read them or not, but it's basically general information. Here's the ordinance on noise, trash, and this goes in the property so that the guest would read it. And it gives them all the pertinent phone numbers for emergency.
2:14:48 Things like that. But I know, like, I'm sure you do it already, and I think Snow Creek Resort does it, and so, but it's good. We do, but there's an awful lot of people that are renting on their own, as Sandra and everybody knows for TFT, there's more and more individuals that are pulling permits.
2:15:05 And so I think that this is actually information that might be very helpful because they don't always have the same, you know, guest book that I have that has all of my information in it or things like that. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. This is just a piece of information. Okay, good deal. Thank you. All right, are there any other comments? We've moved off of quality of life. Thank you very much for your input. All right.
2:15:30 We'll move on to our next business matter, which is review the current public art fee and consider recommending to town council a temporary reduction in the fee. Thank you. So the town, as you are aware, the town is updating our diff fees and our housing fees. A question of whether or not we should temporarily reduce the public art fee has come up through this process. So I provided a brief summary of the public art requirements and the fees.
2:16:00 And at this point, I think that based on some of the comments we've heard, based on the diff process, we would like to ask the commission to consider supporting a temporary reduction of the current fee to zero. So while the council, while we work through this fee and through other public art items, Chair Brown and I discussed possibly having some
2:16:28 Funding, going towards creating an implementation plan for public art. It's not included in the report discussion, but that's another option to consider asking the council to fund. So rather than kind of going with public art how we have been in the past, as people come, we allocate public art, people put it into their properties, having some sort of a clear implementation plan that shows the locations where the art would be proposed, what type of art we're looking for, so that
2:16:56 As we get money into the public art fund, we can spend it wisely. So that kind of summarizes the report, and I'm available for any questions that you have on it. So this reduction is going to be, because, you know, I know we're talking about saying, okay, diff needs to be reviewed on somewhat of a regular basis, housing needs to be reviewed on somewhat of a, so would the reduction,
2:17:23 Follow the same timelines or are we just saying that this moratorium would only be for a year? I think it would probably end up being for more than a year. I'm assuming the council would have to have an actual timeline for it. So we haven't proposed a timeline. If the commission has comments on how long it should be temporarily reduced, we could take those comments. But I think the intent would be to give us enough time to...
2:17:47 Review the current public art requirements, that current Chapter 15 requirements, and provide updates to those. Look at the maximum fees, look at that ordinance, and probably do some serious rewriting of it so that we could accomplish the things that we really want to accomplish with a public art program. I think that looking at maybe shifting where art is, not having art, you know, maybe inside buildings, those kinds of things. And I think if the fee was at a more reasonable level,
2:18:16 Then developers wouldn't be proposing to, you know, do art in those certain locations. But if the fee was reasonable and it was contributing to something that was clear, concrete, I think that it would be an easier kind of pill to swallow for the developers. So I had two thoughts about this. One, the current fee, I think, is out of line when you look at all the other fees right now. And then I happen to be up in the Carson City, Reno area.
2:18:45 Carson City has some of those really amazing things with their public art, whether you particularly like it or not. It's very well thought out. You know, it's on every intersection. And it just seemed to me that we should really have a master program for public art that a developer would contribute to rather than, you know, defining what they felt as public art. So my recommendation would be something along this
2:19:15 Would be that the PEDC would support, I would say, the temporary reduction of the town's current public arts fee for a minimum of a year. I mean, that would, I think it should be at least a minimum of a year, right? Part of it, I mean, everything else they're talking about four or five years. I don't know why you wouldn't do it four or five years, but. Well, that's for when we would review the diff and the housing fees, is every four or five years.
2:19:44 But I don't know if we want to propose reducing this fee for four or five years. Is that what you're saying? Or looking at the fee every four or five years? Well, so in the developer world, a year is a pretty short time. Right. I think the intent would be that we would come back, you know, at whatever time, you know, if we didn't have enough time in a year, the council could, you know, reduce it for another year. But the intent would be that when we do implement a new fee,
2:20:16 When we do reinstate the fee, it would be a new fee that's more reasonable that has gone through that whole process. So I don't think the intent is that we would come back with this exact fee in a year, but that we would come back with some sort of refined fee in the same manner as we did with DIF and housing. But I do want to establish that for a period of time the fee is going to be, that our recommendation that the fee is basically zero. Right. So do you think it should be a year? I think a year makes sense.
2:20:45 I think you're too short because I very much like the idea of having a plan, you know, for our community for where we want public art and really assess and not just take individual applications, ideas that come forward as a hodgepodge and using the money that remains in the public art fund, which is I think around $50,000 to get a consultant who's, you know, well versed in this and, you know, come up with a good plan.
2:21:11 And that may, that process may take longer than a year. Do we have to define a time period right now? That's a good question. Can we just say until a plan is formulated? I think they have to have it in the, I mean, that's what we've done for Diff and everything else. How about we say a minimum of two years and that additionally the PEDC recommends that prior to the reinstatement of the public art fee, the council considered directing staff to prepare an implementation plan for public art.
2:21:39 Within town, using funds from the current public art fund balance. So we basically take the current balance, hire a consultant, and come up with a master. Come up with a plan for it. Right. Right. I don't know, two years sounds like a lot of time to me, but maybe it's not. But considering how much else is on our workload, I think. I know, I know. We have to get our super work done. Right. Oh, is there any comments from the public on this subject?
2:22:11 Tom Hodges from Mammoth Mountain, last guy standing. So I support all the suggestions that you've made. And, you know, it's funny though because you look at art and then as we've been doing the Nexus studies, you know, working with staff and going through the evaluation of the Nexus studies and for housing and for all the other diff categories.
2:22:35 Where you say there's an impact attributable to new development that would warrant the levy of a fee or of an impact fee, you know, art to me is like a different category. It's like a discretionary thing. It's nice to have, you know, certainly as a community, we aspire to do things like that. It's great. But I just have to question whether the way to raise funding for an art program should be through the general fund or some other method that's not front-loading the burden on development.
2:23:05 And then I made, you know, the other thing I cut into mind was listening to your discussion was, gosh, you know, we went through, came up with a community-wide signage plan, signage and wayfinding plan. Arguably, that might be something that you could say developers don't pay a little bit to create a community-wide signage and wayfinding. We can't find money for that. I know. Which is just sad. And yet, we have this.
2:23:31 And I, we completely support, keep developing, supports, you know, reducing it to zero for now. But, yeah, it's just a sort of hypocrisy there in a way. Something that really would benefit the community. We can't find money for it yet. We have, you know, currently it was, you know, one percent fee, which is completely out of context with where we've gone with the diffs and everything else. So we support your guys' direction to reduce the fee to...
2:24:00 Zero for two years and we would support your notion that it should be studied as a come back to council when there's, you know, in the context of a community-wide program that makes sense. And Mickey, I agree with your comment that your approach that in the future that if it's a fee that is contributed to a comprehensive plan that makes sense to everybody as opposed to individual developers.
2:24:24 Trying to find a solution so they don't have to pay the fee and nobody wins and it's not a successful program. What I was referring to was the current balance that's left in the public. Yeah, correct. I agree that sounds like a great use of that money if everybody's on board with that. So maybe we should say, it's a good point, after all this is our cause, an implementation plan for public art and wayfinding. Or maybe we should.
2:24:54 The press go about, maybe we should implement this after wayfindings pay for. No, but I mean, basically our wayfinding is public. It is. The district monuments are going to be beautiful. Well, there's certainly precedent for that already, right? I think that we already have an implementation plan for wayfinding. I mean, we already have everything designed, everything's done, and all we need is money. Money.
2:25:21 But that's part of the implementation. It's ready to go to bid. Yeah, I mean, so I think that what we would do with a public art plan would be similar to what we did with the wayfinding plan already. Okay. So we would get to this point where we would have a plan like we do with the wayfinding and really we would just be waiting for money to implement. Okay. All right. And then just since I did speak on the fee discussion that a public comment time for everyone, Grady. Would you put the timer on?
2:25:44 Yeah, go ahead. It's only going to take a minute. You know, the thing to keep in mind here, just a general discussion about fees is, you know, even as much as the fees have come down, and we really appreciate the efforts of Dan and Grady and Sandy and everybody working together to figure that out, and Jen. It's been a huge effort, and we've made a ton of progress, and it's great. But we still have, you know, a current economic situation in our community where that alone isn't going to necessarily
2:26:13 Start development. So, you know, everybody should be cognizant of the fact that it may take other efforts to get people in the door and get these, you know, these first few developments out of the ground and get things started again. And so all these fees, you know, it all helps, but the economics still don't work. I know. So, okay, thank you. All right, thank you. All right.
2:26:39 So have you got your direction? Mm-hmm. Okay. Add a minimum of two years and then the additional language regarding implementation. And then we'll move on to our consent agenda. Do we have a motion to approve the consent? I move the minutes of May 13, 2015 be approved. Second. All in favor? Aye. Commissioner reports? Oh, Amy, want to report on what we got to see today? Sure. I don't know. The way you say it's like... Well, go ahead, Elizabeth.
2:27:13 No, no, no. You're so excited about it. You're so good. The Scripps family is building a beautiful home on three lots in Juniper Ridge, next between the ski slope and the water tank, and we saw the plan today that the architect, I'm drawing complete blank, Bruce.
2:27:38 Bruce Woodward, can you believe I drew a blank on Bruce's, I hope you better not be watching this, that Bruce and Larry, yes, Bruce and Larry did, he's the designer, and we just, you know, worked together on the gateway all that time, and how did that go out of my head? Anyway, it's just beautiful, and one thing they brought up, which I thought was such a good idea, because who knows how long this drought's gonna last, I hate to even say that in this chamber, but there's no landscape plan yet.
2:28:07 Because, number one, they want to wait. It's a three-year project to build this home. They want to wait so that the owners can see just where the views are once everything's framed. That will help them decide what they want to put where. They're not talking about turf for sure. And then by the time they're at that point, you know, the whole water situation may have changed. And so they may be able to...
2:28:32 Do some really creative stuff that they can't even anticipate today. So I thought that was a very wise approach. It was very good. And then do you want to talk about the other one? Sure. And then John Hooper presented to us the duplex, I guess, duplex townhomes on the corner of Hillside and Canyon Boulevard. It's that empty lot there across diagonal from the Weston.
2:29:00 Very similar to the projects he's been working on in Grey Bear and Greystone and Mountainside. In fact, it's nearly identical, I believe, to one of the single-family or duplex units in Mountainside. He may come to us proposing a different kind of stone for the base of the building. He's going to send that information to us. But overall, it looked like a good...
2:29:29 Another successful project in the main village area. It was very encouraging, wasn't it, just to see these good projects come forward and with some creative ideas and it was very good. Very good. So if I had my choice in life, I would be an event coordinator because I just love all events that celebrate happy occasions. So we wanted to...
2:30:00 Officially say congratulations on your upcoming wedding. We hope you have a wonderful day and many, many years of happiness. I personally wanted to write a resolution, but Sandra wouldn't want me. Oh gosh. Thank you very much. Yeah, I think I'm planning to. I don't know how long it'll take to actually do that. Well, you'll have to let us know so that we address you appropriately. I will. Thank you. And may the sun shine.
2:30:30 Oh, I hope so. Is it this weekend? Next Saturday. I think because I think we're going to have a sunny period now. I think so. I think we're going to get the rain out of its system here and it can be sunny next week. Okay. Our chair had a resolution going that sounded like wedding vows. You would have been mortified. Would you like to help us write our wedding vows? Because we're so working. I can help you do that too.
2:30:56 All right. And our director report. So just two things. Chair Brown, you already mentioned that at the August 12th meeting, we will appoint a new commissioner to take Commissioner Harvey's place, and we will also be picking the chair, vice chair, and appointing two committees at that meeting. And I sent the group out an email regarding the November meeting dates. November 11th is Veterans Day. So I provided some different options. I think I heard from one or two of you that, you know,
2:31:25 Generally, the options were fine, but I think it would be good to pick a specific date so we can just change the meeting date officially to that. So the options, I provided four options. One is either the Tuesday or Thursday before, the 10th or 11th, the same week, at the same time, or the Wednesday before or the Wednesday after, both of which are council meeting nights, so we might... We don't want to do it on a council meeting.
2:31:49 That wouldn't be your preference, right? No, I mean, it doesn't, I mean, it wouldn't be my preference, but we could do it if that was the best scheduling for the commission. I mean, we can wait, you know, if you'd like to wait a couple more months to set the meeting date, we can do that. I think that Grady was trying to schedule some updates for November and wanted to know what the meeting date would be. Why would you do it the Thursday after? I was going to say Tuesday. I would vote for Tuesday myself. Not me. Not you, okay. But Tuesday is my day off.
2:32:16 Oh, that's right. But there's a Thursday of Caravan. Wait, but this is in the afternoon. Okay. Thursday's fine. Thursday's fine if that's what we've got two out of three here on Thursday. That's good. Okay. So we'll plan on Thursday and once I'll coordinate with Commissioner Vanderhurst to make sure that that works for him and then with a new commissioner and then we'll just go with that date. So Thursday, November 12th. That's all I have. Look, I have a question for Director's Report.
2:32:45 Sandra, wasn't it April 2013, Winter and Associates came back with their final plan? I think it might have been, are you talking about the, for Main Street, a practical, implementable plan for Main Street. It was either February or April, yeah, I think you're right, I think it was. Okay, and then it's going to be 2016, a year from now, before the EIR will even be adopted, and,
2:33:12 Lucy, the consultant, said that was a very aggressive schedule, but why did this take so long? And that's not a criticism of anybody, but can you tell me what held this up? And we talk about being ready when the capital comes back, and, you know, what do we tell developers? All the work the downtown working group did in trying to define the white box and coming up with all that good stuff, and that was before Winter and Associates were finished for their recommendations.
2:33:39 And then it was April 2009 they decided not to use PAOT anymore. 2009 and the general plan hasn't been updated. What got bogged down? What about the process got bogged down? It's very frustrating. For this particular process, once we signed the contract with PCR, we had to determine what does this actually mean? What does it mean when we change the way we calculate density from rooms and units per acre to FAR? So we had to do a whole analysis of the commercial zones.
2:34:09 To determine what that would be. One of the... Beyond what the downtown working group did. Right. Yes. Building on that. Okay. And one of the issues that we found through that is that our land use data is not complete. It's very poor. We had to go out and verify. This is the GIS land use data. We just don't have data for everything. We don't have... It's so spotty that we really can't rely on it. So we had to go out and field verify.
2:34:36 verify all the data that we were using for this process. So that took considerable time. Another issue that came up as we were moving forward was we did a preliminary traffic analysis because we wanted to find out if there were any big issues with traffic because we figured that's going to be the biggest issue for this project and we wanted to make sure we didn't find out the big issues six months into the EIR project.
2:35:00 You know, spending all that money. So we did a preliminary traffic screening, but what we found through that, as well as the GIS land use data, which feeds into the mobility, or sorry, the traffic model, it just, it's just not very reliable. So we really had to go back and hand calculate the inputs to the traffic model, which is, it's just, it's
2:35:22 It took us a lot of time. We ended up having to just go through spreadsheet after spreadsheet revisions. I mean, so it was really, so it's really kind of what we realized as we got into this process is that a key, a key long-term project we need to do is update our land use data and maintain it. It was updated at one time, but it was never maintained. We never updated it as things changed. And so...
2:35:46 We do have an intern right now working on that. So we are working to update our land use data. And the intent is that we will maintain, obviously, once we get it all updated, we're going to continue to maintain it, which I think will be easier with our new software that we're developing, or not developing, that we're implementing. So we're hoping that that connection could be made between the software. So as a building permit is issued, it automatically goes to the GIS information so that then that's all maintained.
2:36:12 So it's been a, it's been, so just the specific process of this EIR has been lengthy because of those. I wasn't aware of any of that. Yeah, so I mean, so really the first step of the process, so we didn't kick off the EIR right away. We had to do all the analysis just to determine what we were going to analyze. And so that's kind of where we've been. And that's why we're kicking off so late. It's just really been, it's been unfortunate and really, really frustrating on our part that we just, you know, we have to kind of recreate this data.
2:36:41 And kind of go through and cross-check. We want to make sure it's all right, too. You know, we don't want wrong inputs going in. So we've been kind of going back and checking everything. So that's really kind of the story. So when somebody comes, a developer comes to town and wants to invest, what do we tell them about, you know, FAR and all that? What do we tell them? Excuse me. I mean, I think we tell them that we're working on that at this point.
2:37:06 We are working to implement that. I mean, I think we have to tell them the fact that it's not going to be done until next year. All the projects that we have coming up right now, none of them are in the commercial zones. None of them would be affected by this change. We have specific plans, we have master plans, but we don't have anything proposed, and I'm not sure, Tom, if you're aware of anything in the commercial zones that would be affected by this. So at this point, I mean, it's...
2:37:32 Good and bad, I guess. I mean, so it's good because we don't have anybody, you know, that wants to use this change right now, but it's bad because we don't have anybody who wants to use it. Exactly. So, but I mean, so I think that, you know, we're working as quickly as we can, but we really wanted to be sure that it was all the inputs were right and that we're really building a case that will stand up to any challenges. Good. I'm glad I asked the question. Thank you. That was a good question.
2:38:02 Okay, then I move that we adjourn to our regular meeting held July 8, 2015 at 2 p.m. in these chambers. Thank you very much.