TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2015

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 36 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

336 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 I need to use Google Earth, or I needed to. Now I'm just going to use an alternative here. Google Earth was not loaded onto this computer. That's correct. That's correct. So I have an alternative to what I had hoped to do. Google Maps didn't work for you. Here we go. Here we go.

0:33 This is what I want. Let this populate. This will start to populate with all the photos.

1:07 Okay, here's a story.

1:26 Thank you.

2:23 Oh, Missy.

2:58 Good morning. I'll call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, October 15, 2015. Roll call, please, Jamie.

3:28 Commissioner Svendsen? Here. Commissioner Turner? Hello. Commissioner Svendsen? Yes. Here. We're now open for public comments. This is the time when any member of the public wishing to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do so. Good morning, Madam Chair, Commission, staff, community, Rich Baccia, private citizens. With great pleasure, we cordially invite you to attend the Mono County Veterans Day celebration, which will be held on Wednesday, November 11th.

4:01 Mammoth Lakes Fire Station on Main Street will be hosting a celebration beginning at 9 a.m. Veterans Day is an official United States federal holiday that is observed annually on November 11th, honoring people who have served in the U.S. Armed Forces, also known as veterans. It coincides with other holidays, including Armistice Day and Remembrance Day, which is celebrated in other parts of the world and also marked the anniversary of the end of World War I. The United States also originally observed Armistice Day. It then evolved into the current Veterans Day holiday in 1954.

4:31 Please mark your calendars as we look forward to seeing you there. Thank you and good morning. Good morning. Thank you. Thank you very much. Seeing no other public comments, I will close public comments and we will open for staff reports and we'll start with you, Stu.

5:13 Chair, the adopted town budget. In the back of that packet, there's any budget changes, line items, you know, too much budget, but that's it for you, and I'm sure you do ask at the end. Is that better? Okay, great. Thank you. As you can see, we have still a number of programs operating this fall, which we've listed here in your program. Just the big news as well is that the concession stand, the concession booth at the Whitmore Recreation Area is

5:55 Almost finalised. We'll be by Thursday, Friday. So we're going to start using that on the weekend. Facility use agreement has been executed with the Mammoth Unified School District and the high school. So the high school is essentially going to operate that as part of its sports teams programs and the relevant sport team will program that for whatever season they're operating under. So that's a great arrangement. We're happy with that. We're currently performing upgrades to the...

6:22 Ice rink slash Rec Zone, the concession booth, the concession room, stripping the skate storage section off, which Warren will talk about in a sec. So that's kind of undergoing. And then no special event permits. And then I just listed all the parks and facility upgrades that's happening under Warren's oversight. So I'm going to probably have Warren speak to a lot of those. But if you do have any questions, happy to answer them.

6:52 At this time. Do you have questions? No, I was just wondering, in budget-wise, how are we comparing to last year's budget? Because we have the upcoming budget, but we don't have a comparison at all. Very similar. It was within $2,000 or $3,000 difference. Less. Less? A little bit less. I didn't really have to ask. Yeah, parks maintenance went down a little bit, and recreation went down a little bit. But, you know, both are within kind of realistic numbers. But we'll come back in November, December.

7:26 Go through our COP major maintenance list again. There were a couple of items in here that we'll talk about that we've had to take action on just because of, well, things broke and we have to get them fixed that have to be addressed. But overall, we...

7:46 I think it's an adequate budget for what we're providing right now. We are looking at, as you'll see, the whole analysis, and then we'll kind of look at our programming for next year, and that's when we'll do our budget numbers again. But it's satisfactory, yeah. I think that's all I had on that one. Other questions? Comments? I just had one quick question, well, really more of just a comment when we do talk about our list, because...

8:16 We have a seven-year agreement now with Field Turf for maintenance, so obviously that's something we need to think about beyond the seven years. Warren. Good morning. Good morning. We're going to start down at Whitmore since Stu already brought that up this morning. The Snack Shack is near completion. I'm hoping to be able to use it this weekend. Majority of the stuff, the high school, which was a good program, they actually built the building. We outfitted it on the inside. It's turning out very, very nice.

8:54 Majority of the work's been done in-house, so it's saved us on contract expenses. Going to your field turf, they actually came in just recently, groomed and steam cleaned the whole track itself. It actually came out really good. Speaking with those guys, they're saying that it's holding up very well. They don't see any problem with us getting 15 years out of the track itself. Everything down there, they say,

9:21 Looks very well. They were very impressed with the crew that we have down there and keeping it groomed and maintained. Coming into town here, into the ice rink section, Stu mentioned that we are doing some improvements in there. We are replacing the racks that the ice skates and the rollerblades hang on, which will work out for future for people going in there and actually saving on manpower. It's going to be a new rack. They won't have to tear stuff down.

9:51 To switch out to skates, to ice skates. So that's going to save us from having to go in there every year and do that. We got a new countertop, some sinks. I think it's going to turn out really nice. And once again, that's all going to be done in-house. We got a couple of seasonal guys this year that are extremely qualified in what they're doing and saving the town quite a bit of money by us not having to contract out. Going into our parks, as you guys all know, it's starting to cool down. Things are starting to shut down. We actually have winterized a few things around town.

10:20 We're looking at the end of October to probably start shutting down and start winterizing shady rust out there. We're actually still getting quite a few people with the soccer and people using the park. Other than that, I think we're going to start preparing for winter, start getting our snow equipment ready, maintaining some of the sidewalks, getting that stuff marked out for snow removal. Do you guys have any questions? Thank you.

10:57 Warren, forgot about it. It's a good project. The high jump cover is at the facility down at Whitlong. So if you've been down there, it's all very colour matched. Blends in. It's almost camouflaged. Kids are accidentally running into it. No, just kidding. It's pretty big. So it's big. I mean, the ski area, we contracted the ski area to do that work. We are going to affix that to the surface of the track. We don't anticipate that blowing away, but we really want to make sure, so we're going to tie that down.

11:26 So that was the only other thing I think that we're wrapping up. And then we are replacing a pump down at the pump house. And that was one of those projects that we identified on our major maintenance list. And this is the main, we have two pumps. This is one of the smaller pumps. Well, this was a large pump that provided smaller areas of water for the fields, the animal shelter, the restrooms and so forth. That finally did break. So we've gone ahead and replaced that whole pump.

11:56 In excess of about $7,000, $8,000. We're just trying to get the cost on that. So that's kind of our budget with that. And then we're looking at trying to work with the school and the softball team and the junior huskies on the softball fields down there. They're also erecting a little shack that we'll place down at that field for storage of equipment and so forth. So we're just working out the best way to kind of mount and affix that down at those fields. So, you know, adding value to those facilities without a lot of, you know, upfront costs from us.

12:27 So I think it's good for everybody. So looking forward to those. So a lot happening a bit more. So we're happy with that area. And I think that was it. And the community courts, we wrap up programming on Sunday. So it's the last day for the Sunday socials. And then we'll just strip all but two tennis nets. So we'll have two tennis courts operation until it snows. That's kind of our typical policy. And then at the community centre right now, we do have Mammoth Cheer are in there as well. We also have Sierra Classic Theatre.

12:57 They have their Mammoth Children's Theatre programming that as well, so that's heavily utilised and we are getting a lot of interest this time of the year because people need to come inside and program, so that's well utilised in addition to the regular programs, so happy with that use and we're also talking with, Stephanie's got some folks on the hop regarding programming at that facility as well for some kind of senior slash just adult.

13:25 Fitness Program. So we'll see how that goes. There we go. That's all I had. Stu, I've got a question for you. You do. Well, for any of you, actually. It could fall into any of your bailiaries. Okay, there you go. In the budget, we have the maintenance breakout, which I'm assuming includes the day-to-day operational maintenance, which is the landscaping and that kind of stuff, and the pump replacement and that sort of thing, which is the long-term maintenance of the facilities. Do we break those out? Is there a way to see those differently so we can see how much we're allocating? Yeah.

13:55 to actual, not operational maintenance, which is just day-to-day operations, in my mind, but actual, are we keeping up with our needs in terms of overall maintenance so that we don't lose facilities due to lack of? Yeah, I think we can provide that information. We can keep drilling down and drilling down as much as we can do. I think it probably ties into the upcoming discussion we'll have with the Commission on the annual CIP slash major maintenance work plan items.

14:24 I was just chatting with Warren, we're trying to break it down by area, by facility like we normally do, we can bring in our, you know, relevant budgets. The budgets don't speak specifically to an area, I mean, Whitmore is quite unique, only because of the reimbursement of the county, but a lot of our other parks just fall under, you know, a lump sum budget. But fortunately with a new accounting system, with Cassell, we can assign accounting codes to each of those facilities, so now we're actually tracking each and every expenditure and the staff time that's required to maintain those facilities.

14:53 To a specific area. So we can break it down by overall parks or specific parks and whatever. So the answer is yes, we can get a lot more detail. But for that long-term maintenance, even when it falls into CIP, it still has to come out of the parks maintenance budget, right? Or does it go into a separate building budget? Well, I think we're trying to keep everything together. I think the discussion moving forward with public works on hand is really...

15:20 Parks Maintenance Staff are just trying to at this time, and that's where our budget resides, is to maintain projects. Capital Improvement Projects is really where we look at Grady and his team, and where are those funds within the town budget that can be utilized, acquired, or? Yeah, so not necessarily out of the parks budget, but out of a capital improvement budget. Correct. And that's kind of the role and what we've tried to do with a little shift in the reorg. So we're just trying to keep our maintenance crew maintaining.

15:50 Our amenities, our facilities, and if there's major capital projects, you know, that's where Grady's and his public works are. Really, with the new financial system, we're going to learn a lot this year about what it's really costing in each facility, exactly on point with your questions, because in the past, we just kind of had big numbers, but now we're going to be able to identify day-to-day maintenance versus, you know, major maintenance and those other things. So, yeah, we're looking forward to having that information, and next year's budget will be even more spot on.

16:19 I've just been absent so long I wanted people to know I was paying attention. Yeah. Thanks. Yeah, it's a little bit difficult too because of the water restrictions. You know, we're not, say for instance, the Main Street Promenade. I mean, we're not spending those mons, those monies, you know, with that contract service and dialing down the water use, I mean, everything's down about 30%, but we still have expenditures, you know, for pipes and sprinklers and those type of things. Well, I'm assuming next year.

16:45 After El Nino, those expenses need to be back in our budget at any rate because we're going to have them and more to replace whatever is dead. Even if we don't replace it with grass, which probably we shouldn't, that's going to mean a larger desired budget than a smaller one. And if I could offer also...

17:05 Working with the assessment districts that we have, both up at the village and on Old Mammoth Road, we're going to do a little bit more this month, frankly. And the next year we have other capital projects to start getting rid of some of those two-foot wide strips, repairing some sidewalks. There are some pretty good size funds in those assessment districts, and our goal is to start spinning it to the benefit.

17:27 Can I ask when we bring forward the CIP and we start working through that, I know there's been some community effort to earn some money to help maybe put clay in our ball fields and some different things like that. If we can look at each of our facilities and see what items can make this an optimal facility, like a clay field. And we talked a long time ago about a book, putting together a book of items.

17:57 that community members can contribute to and that we look at that and put that together and then work with our user groups and our youth groups and everybody to see if they have anything that they want to add to that and then hopefully bring some money in to improve some of those facilities to make them the best that they can be. You read my mind, actually.

18:21 Pulled that out two days ago. Oh, there you go. Really good, and I'm trying to tie that in too as well, and I was at, I'm on the boosters board, so I did bring that up with the boosters last night as well about, you know, hey, here's a joint use facility that predominantly the school uses, you know, quite heavily. What are the opportunities that we can kind of acquire some funding, you know, through these other sources? So that's a great idea, so absolutely. Yeah, I actually just got an example of a community that did, you know.

18:49 Here are your options for things that we need and that you could donate to, which I'm happy to share. And I think it's just really important as we start our CIP process that we engage our stakeholders. Because some of these things weren't even on our list. So I think it's just good to know what our partners are looking for. And also they make them aware of the rest of the things on our list. The thing, of course, you have to be careful of there is that if we accept funds for specific projects and then can't complete that project, how do we?

19:20 Deal with that. We give that money back to the people who donated it because we can't build a Olympic swimming pool, you know, in the village or whatever. And if it's airmarked as such, we didn't know that. Because we got in trouble with that with developer impact fees and putting them in too many, too specific buckets years ago. So we need to devise a program that will allow the optimum use of that donated funds and still encourage people to give.

19:45 And I think it can be earmarked for that. And if it ever becomes something that you can't do, then the money can either be returned or you can say, would you be willing to donate those funds to XYZ Project? Well, we can hold things in trust like we have the group contributions. Greedy, Public Works. I have five things for you this morning. First is...

20:11 We are going to be advertising the multi-use path that goes from Lake Mary Road up to Lake George Road this Friday, actually. We don't intend to start it, obviously, until late May, early June after next season begins, but that's one that's been fully vetted. The Sarbanes Grant is paying for that about a million dollars' worth of work there. So we are going to go ahead and advertise that so that next spring we'll be ready to go.

20:35 We've had the trails coordinator look at that as well. He'd given us some good input on some additional signage and things like that, so I think we're in good shape. The second part of that path goes from Lake George Road up to Lake George, and that's been a topic of some discussion. We did submit for an RTP grant for that work as well. Again, it's some $800,000. We do have some suggestions on how to refine the alignment of that to make it better up at the top and some more amenities down at the bottom, which we'll be working on in the meantime, but hopefully we'll get that grant as well.

21:04 And we might be able to do that one next summer. Again, we don't know that. Third and fourth, and I combined them because they both have to do with the town loop. One is we did receive a grant for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure, which is a multi-use path from the intersection of Minaret and Old Mammoth Road along the...

21:24 North side of the road, south edge of the creek, up to Mammoth Creek Park West. That was very exciting, $847,000. It includes right-of-way acquisition and some other things. That might not happen next summer, more likely the summer after that, but that was very exciting. Second part is the council authorized our agreement with the consultant team to do the environmental and civil work for our STIP projects on Main Street, which is really the sidewalks. On the south side, it would be from Laurel up to Manzanita.

21:52 Through that whole area and on the north side it would fill the gap down near Forest Trail and additionally from Sierra up to Minaret. The third part of that is actually from Minaret at the corner there up to the 8050 sidewalk. We are going to do at least one of those phases next summer, most likely the one from Sierra to Minaret where SCE has been...

22:14 Putting some conduit underground. And we hope to actually do more than that, but we don't know yet. We have to take a look at the funding. But that is STIP funding that's in the program today. If you're familiar with that, the state of California has said that there won't be any STIP funding to be able to reprogram after the next three or four years until the budget changes. But these monies are here. They are programmed, so we're confident this will happen. The reason I mention them together is if we...

22:41 When we get these two things done over the next two summers, that will complete the town loop that's been in process since the late 80s. I mean, I said on the first trail system master plan in 1991, but I imagine it was before that. But that will actually complete that loop. So that'll be a fun ribbon cutting when we get that done in the next couple of summers. Last thing I have is we're able to create a parking lot out by the propane tanks.

23:10 It's sort of part of the Sharps program because that's one of the staging areas that's identified in that program. Working with the Forest Service and our contractor who is doing work right there on Sherwin Creek Road, we actually paved an area that's large enough for a little bit over 40 parking spaces. We're not going to stride them this winter, but it will be an area that we will plow and it will be available. And I'd like to invite you to a ribbon cutting that the council will be having on October 21st at 5 o'clock out there at the probane tanks.

23:40 When is that? The 21st at 5 o'clock. On the Laurel to Manzanita portion, how does that alignment fit with the proposed changes in that downtown, whatever we called that plan that we worked on, the Main Street plan? Because it seems to me in the outcome of that, it would fall under where some of the current buildings exist.

24:09 It wouldn't be there. It would be closer to Main Street. But we are balancing that, our new FAR study and how that changes, how people might be able to actually acquire part of the frontage road, things like that. That's phase three in our three phases, if you will. So that will be the last one. We're starting environmental work and preliminary engineering design. I don't have a lot more information than that for you today, but we do understand all those different players and different pieces, if you will, and we'll make sure that they work together. Any questions for Haley?

24:40 Just one quick one. You know, the propane tanks, the parking lot out there. It's not paved getting out there, correct? Have you ever? It is. It actually is paved. The pavement ends just past the propane tanks, probably 100 feet past that. Okay. We repaved the section from Old Mammoth Road up about, let's say, halfway, two-thirds of the way, which was our responsibility. It's a four-service road, but that was our responsibility. And it's paved just past the propane tanks, about 100 feet or so, and then it stops there. Okay.

25:08 Then I need to spend more time out there. I mean, that's one area, you know, I go this direction, but I haven't really gone this direction much. So, okay. Thank you. And obviously every time we build sidewalks, we need to account for snow removal.

25:24 We are looking at that. We had a discussion even earlier this week about exactly what we think we can do this year. Obviously, Meridian was added to this late last year. We did part of Lake Mary up to Kelly Road. It all depends on the snow, of course. Main Street will be even more difficult, however, because it's a Caltrans road. In our maintenance agreement with Caltrans, their first priority. So they're going to clear the road, probably dump snow on our sidewalks.

25:51 And they actually require us to then remove that within 72 hours, which is kind of tricky. Really? We did as well as we could negotiating that, yeah, for now. Wow. Okay. Because the main point of Caltrans is get the cars through. That's it. And even, yes, it's a bit perplexing, but it'll work.

26:15 Well, you're correct. We do need to look in the future at our budget and power for doing that because when you build a new sidewalk, as we did with Meridian, the expectation is, okay, it's going to be clear. Main Street will be tougher. Wow. That's just challenging with our feet-first community and all of our safe routes to school sidewalks. Obviously, pedestrian safety is also key, but since it's a Kaltrans road, we don't have a lot of time. Okay. Any other questions for Grady?

26:46 All right. Well, I asked Joel if he would come and just give us a trails update just so we kind of know what was going on in the world of trails. So thank you. Thank you for the invitation. All right. Thank you. Thanks for being here. First, I'd like to express some gratitude for a really great orientation over the last month and a half or so. Thanks to town staff, really strong orientation from MLTPA, MLR folks.

27:14 and the community at large, making a lot of friends and good neighbors, so thank you. I just wanted to share a few projects that I'm working on briefly. Had a couple of field trips with the Trails Committee out in the Sherwins area and also the Lakes Basin. In the Lakes Basin, we were focusing on the project that Grady touched on mostly.

27:43 The pathway that will go up to Lake George from Lake Mary. We were looking at the proposed alignment, looking at some alternatives, and specifically how that will tie into existing recreation infrastructure at the top. So where existing soft surface system trails will tie in so that when people get up to Lake George, they'll have a nice...

28:09 We hope that they'll have a nice soft surface trail experience from there, fishing and all the other activities that take place there. In the Sherwins area, we're focused on a short list of seven proposed trail projects that we hope to move on sooner than later. I've also been working with committee member Alan Jacoby on one specific trail alignment, a trail alignment study.

28:39 And so that's been going very well. And then also I've used a contract with Friends of the Inyo this fall to do an inventory of problems in our trail system within the municipal boundary. It's about 30 miles of trails in the system. And I had them go around with GPS gear and a camera and log problems as they went.

29:07 And so far we've logged 796 problems. And I just wanted to show a brief overview of what that kind of looks like. If you can see this map here, these are geo-reference photos of the trail system on a handy Google map. And there's data associated with all of these in a GIS. And you can just kind of click through these.

29:42 And I had them logging all kinds of problems like channeling where a bench would need to be reestablished, where we have, well, almost a non-existent trail in this case. And they did a really thorough job. I was able to take that data, correct some of it, put it in the right place. And I think this will be a very valuable, useful tool if we work with contractors for trail maintenance.

30:12 Or I kind of see an all-of-the-above approach for next season with maintenance. We're going to need to use honest-to-goodness trail contractors. We're going to need to use probably fire crews, volunteers, really whoever I can get. 796 problems is a big problem. And I've been doing trail work for a long time. And from what I'm looking at,

30:39 Both on the ground myself and in these photos. This trail system needs some love. And so we're going to propose to the Forest Service an agreement, probably a challenge cost share, not exactly sure quite yet, it's in the works, but whereby we would have an agreement with the Forest Service to be able to do work. And we'll propose to spend money on that work using Measure R funds. And this is in the works.

31:08 I'll be bringing this to the Trails Committee tomorrow and then as an informational item to the MLR Board and to Town Council. So we hope to be doing about 30 miles of work next summer. And I can send this link to anyone who's interested. It's basically just a nice handy interactive map where you can see all 796 issues. That would be great. Yeah, I'm sure I'd like to see that if you want to send it to Stu so he can pass it along.

31:42 Everyone on the commission, I think, would probably like that. Very much. To be on that. Thank you. Yeah, you know, at your leisure, it's nice to kind of scroll through and see the different issues. So it's a handy tool for everybody. You don't have to go hike 30 miles to go see what we're dealing with. Do you have any questions for me? Yes. How is the trails committee, and you're as the coordinator, whatever your position is being called, dealing with,

32:16 things other than just non-motorized in the boundary. When we first created MLTSCC, the hope was that it would expand and not be just one-dimensional to include all of the other users and the uses such as cross-country skiing and snowshoeing and dog walking that occur outside of the municipal boundary. And have you looked at that? And snow management for

32:41 Motorized and non-motorized alike, for instance, for grooming back here for snow play, for cross-country ski, for anything that might be happening out there. Great that we're looking within municipal boundary, but I've been fighting for more than two decades to get the town to look at recreation that supports us that's outside of that as well. So hopefully that hasn't been ignored in your orientation.

33:10 Thank you for the question. It comes up every day. This particular project, we're proposing just within the municipal boundary to engage with the Forest Service with an agreement to do maintenance on those existing trails. Having said that, I have a list of 36 initiated projects and motorized, non-motorized alike. Shady Rest Winter Grooming is among that project list.

33:40 And then other historic projects, as you're aware, you know, there's a project for access through the tunnel that's proposed. So we'll have to engage with the Forest Service on that project. I certainly understand completely your logic about let's get outside the municipal boundary. With the Forest Service, as a baby step, we'll take on this 30-mile project.

34:10 Town manager is looking at it as a pilot project, and so based on our success, maybe we'll be invited to work outside that boundary some more. Having said that, I know that I need to be careful, as does the town manager, as to how Measure R funding is spent. And so far, it looks like we have to be careful about spending it outside of the municipal boundary. That's information that's come to me as a new employee.

34:40 But I know that these trails and access points go far beyond that municipal boundary. Of course, there is more than Measure R available that has traditionally been used for trails. Measure U doesn't have those same restrictions, and it was passed for recreation and trails as well as other issues. So I would suggest that we look a bit beyond and since Rich's group is handling both of those funds, we don't have to lay it all on R. We can go outside of that.

35:09 to meet the necessary needs for the recreating public in its entirety. Yeah, one interesting thing about my position, so I'm about 80% funded by Measure R, but then 20% general fund, so that 20% is not restricted to that municipal boundary, and so there's certainly, I think, a little freedom there. Excuse me, if I could add one thing. Joel mentioned the Forest Service, and I just want to...

35:38 I want to emphasize, I guess, how well that's frankly going. We've improved our relationship with them over the last year. I think there's a great deal of trust now back and forth. I mean, even the parking lot at the propane tanks, they gave us authorization to do that in three weeks, which is moving very quickly. We had a meeting with the Forest Service just recently where Joel started to lay out some of this work in the sharps area and the soft service trails. And rather than...

36:03 Forest Service showing up to the meeting telling us why something doesn't work. They were very interested. They thought it was great news, great that we had some resources now to put towards these soft surface trails, and they were, frankly, John Ruggerberger was even excited about, okay, let's do this. Let's figure out how to make this happen, and that's...

36:20 Sort of an overarching thing, but it means a lot to our relationship with the Forest Service and how we get things done. We'll be out there again trying to keep the Lake's Basin open as long as we can with porta-potties and dumpsters and things like that, and I think we're working even better than ever on a day-to-day basis. That's great. It's nice to hear. I think one detail that really spoke to the ranger was, so, you know, I'm proposing to use Forest Service standards for trail maintenance, their manual, you know, their construction.

36:51 specifications and things like that. I think he was refreshed by that message. I've worked with federal agencies in the past on trail projects, and I'd like to think that I can speak the same language. My problem is their language seems to change as their managers change. I've dealt with them for years and years on projects and been very successful at one point with one manager and very less than successful at another point with a different manager. So I wish you all the luck in the world there. Thank you.

37:23 Sounds like a challenge. All right, other questions for Joel? No, I appreciate the work you've done and the relationships you're making, so I think that you're doing a great job. Yeah, it's great to have you here, Joel. I just have a couple questions. One, so with this 30 miles of work, do you have any idea of just kind of a breakdown between problems on the soft surface trails within the boundary versus the hard surface trails?

37:52 Hard surface trails are like road projects, you know, crack ceiling, things like that, quite different. Each trail I will have in a spreadsheet, in a category, all its own, because, you know, each area has its own set of challenges. The Lakes Basin has the most problems. Trails closer to the urban growth boundary, like Mountain View, Uptown, Downtown, Mammoth Rock Trail.

38:21 Need some work, but not as much work, so I'll likely engage with volunteer groups on those projects. Lakes Basin will need really serious, serious work. Some of it, quite frankly, just can't be fixed. I'll have to think about rerouting some of it. The ranger was encouraged by that statement. You know, and so really, it's on a case-by-case basis.

38:50 Some areas will need things like bridges, so those cost money. Other areas, there are some trails that are very damaged or eroded, but we're not going to put in a bridge. And so right now I'm really trying to wrap my head around those sort of details, what it might cost, and I'll bring forward a solid proposal.

39:18 to the Trails Committee and to the MLR Board as an information item to really spend some real dollars on fixing these issues. Joel, all 30 miles are soft surface, correct? That's correct. The specific inventory that I showed you, that specific inventory is all soft surface. That's a separate, on its own kind of project. Thanks for clarifying that.

39:47 Our hard surface trails are included in our regular yearly maintenance, isn't it? Yes. We get out there and sweep and maintain what's out there. Any crack sealing that you need to do and all of that? Okay. I wasn't sure because you mentioned benches that needed to be replaced. And then, so the shady rest agreement for trail grooming this winter, that's in process? We need an agreement with the Forest Service. The permit that's been used in the past is expired.

40:19 Okay. And so that's really the one thing right now that has me, you know, I've got butterflies on that project because we don't have an agreement yet and the town will need that. Yes. I think that's a really important amenity so if you can just keep us surprised and anything we can do to advocate for that, I think. Do you know in talking with the Forest Service on that project, the Forest Service using the groomer that it has access to, the OHVMR groomer,

40:51 Has pre-groomed those trails before tracks have been set because the track setting machine that we have access to can't do the deep snow. Do they still plan on going over those forests with that asset? So the trail would be available regardless. It just wouldn't have the track set. Yeah, thank you. I have that question into the Forest Service right now. Do you plan to do that first, the first groom?

41:23 And so I do understand that dynamic. And this is a very pertinent subject right now. Because I realize the last two years it hasn't really been necessary. However, if we do have an El Nino, everybody's talking, I'm very reserved about that still. If that should happen, we cannot groom without their help. So that needs to be an integral part of that decision making. Or we would have to hire somebody else for the SNOCAT.

41:53 My snow grooming question to you earlier, a snow management question. The town owning its own groomer becomes so critical for these very important trails. This is another project where first step in agreement with the Forest Service is necessary before we can do any work. So similar to the maintenance that I hope to do, we need an active permit for the grooming as well.

42:22 And I think that's something that as this is moving along, we need to look to see what our needs are as far as a groomer goes and what other areas that we can look at in grooming. But I think the first step is let's get this going. Shady rest, absolutely. But I think in those conversations, I would encourage him to start conversations now with the Forest Service. If we get the tunnel, the groom trail going back to the tank farm.

42:51 Pitt and that sort of thing which expands the system is all very important. So we want to look outside of just shading so that we aren't starting brand new when we look at expansion to that and potential cross-country and snowshoe trails in the Sherwin area as we build those trails because that is hugely to that plan as well. Thank you for the information. I'll bring that. I hope to meet with the Forest Service very soon on this specific topic. I do have messages into them.

43:23 You know, very compelling messages. Good job. Thank you. Sounds great. No. You're just getting your feet grounded. I think you're hitting it running. So I think that you're on the right track. Absolutely. Thank you for your support. I appreciate it very much. It's great to have you here. Thank you, Joel. All right. I've asked Rich to come and just give us an executive report from MLR. So we know.

43:54 All the work they are engaged in. Joel and I and staff meet every Monday morning for about two hours and go over many of the elements you talked about right now. I think our biggest challenge and grading staff would concur is to continue to establish that positive work in relationship with the Forest Service, whether it's special use permits, whether it's cost share agreements, but without some of those pieces in place, we can't move forward. You know, we talked Thursday morning, but now I have just focused on the Sheeter S. grooming project specifically.

44:27 Joel's been here for nine weeks now, I think, Joel. He's an expert in his area. We're blessed to have him, and he's getting his hands wrapped around this. He's got a lot of support. There's a ton of work to do. You talk about the history, there's a ton of work to do. So that's just one of the projects MLR is working on. What I wanted to do is kind of, I've got five different things to share, kind of bring you up to speed. Number one, we're in the final phase is completing our branding strategy, logo, web banners, general marketing materials.

44:57 And number two, in the process of identifying the readiness of top-tier projects. One of our deliverables in R&U is by December of 2015 to bring a list of recommended R&U projects amenities to Town Council. And we're working through a simple filter. Filter's got three elements. That's the public benefit of the project, planning and development. And number three, the operations and sustainability.

45:23 You know, we talk too often that if we build it, we've got to be able to put a life cycle in for maintenance down the road. And the worst we can do is build something and it falls apart. You know, we need to have money allocated for that. We're working with the project managers and the user group. So, for example, one of our favorite projects right now, the Multi-Use Facility, working on a simple executive summary, which will be expanded into a business plan as this grows legs and will become a little more.

45:51 If it becomes a project that moves forward. Our timeline for the completion of this readiness determination and recommendations of the Town Council, October 27th, we'll do a special board meeting here in Suite Z, and we'll engage with user groups if we miss something, and we're working on a top-tier matrix right now that goes through opportunities, constraints, external influences, missing information, budget allocation, stuff like that. So we're really trying to come to you. What are the tiers?

46:20 What do we think is ready to roll? What's it going to cost? And begin to look 10 years out on a financial plan. If you've got almost $2 million a year and just restricted R&U money, what does that look like, $20 million over the next 10 years? How do we maximize that? How do we leverage it? Do we bond something? What goes into programming? What goes for maintenance and operations? What goes for seed money for special projects? We want to grow something. November 3rd, MLR will have their board meeting to confirm what we've heard and recommendations.

46:49 And we'll take our first recommendation to the Town Council November 18th, saying these are what we believe to be our top tier. What are we missing? Give us some information. We're trying to get under the habit of making sure everything's an information item and then an action item. Bring an information item. What are we missing? Give us the opportunity to do some more due diligence. And I'll fill in some of the gaps and bring it back. Number three, my favorite, one of my favorite activities is the 2016 allocation application.

47:16 We're going to open that for special events and events programming. That's going to start on Monday, everybody, Monday, November 19th. I appreciate the support of a press release. We'll get that out to the group today. I think that's October 19th. Excuse me, October 19th. Thank you, thank you. October 19th and closes on November 6th. It's a quick window. It's about three weeks. Our timeline for the completion of this process will open on October 19th. We'll close on November 6th.

47:42 The Allocation Committee will meet on November 9th at 5 p.m. to review allocations. We'll do a special board meeting on November 16th, the public hearing process. Hopefully lessons learned from last year and the process we went through. And then December 2nd, we'll make a recommendation for town council for allocating funds. We're trying to tackle those projects prior to. And this is just special events and special programming. It's very isolated. Our goal is to put an X factor in there.

48:11 So when we come back with a top-tier recommendation that the Council has given us direction on, then we can come back in January and say, okay, we need an allocation process to move forward, whether it's environmental reviews, whether it's conceptual designs, things like that. And we want to remind everybody that all previous funding recipients...

48:29 Are required to submit an annual performance report prior to requesting future funding. There are some folks that still have not done that some as many as two years ago. So there's got to be an accountability piece on the allocation of these funds. Number four, we understand the importance of engaging the community in our work. We can always do a better job at that. Communication is always a critical concern. We're establishing some ad hoc committees.

48:54 And we want to be able to build capacity and ownership from the ground up before things get too far off the ground. Let's circle the wagons, get everybody involved in this conversation so we all have a part of this. I've got six things kind of outlines. A, we really need to have a strategy for special events and special event funding. We don't have a strategy right now.

49:16 Without a strategy, we don't have a foundation to stand up. I know that Mammoth Lakes Tourism, John Urdi and myself have been talking about that with our town manager. What does that look like in the upcoming months? And then what does it look like when we get to February and begin to look at, since we're past Q1, quarter one of this fiscal year, it's too late really to regroup. And let's begin to look at February as we begin to plan the 16-17 budget.

49:39 In the best of all worlds, begin to look at allocations in three to five year windows. Instead of a year at a time, it's tough to plan a year at a time. Let's plan three to five years out there. What's it going to look like? What's it going to taste like? What are we willing to commit to? What are the priorities? And go from there. We need to do a better job at engaging the folks in the Mammoth Creek Park West project, looking at a

50:02 Development of a community center of complementary facilities, including a multi-use facility, maybe a developmental playground, and perhaps frisbee golf, disc golf. What does that look like? How do we engage the partners in that neighborhood to work with us for conceptual design? Because we hear concerns, we hear challenges, but if we're willing to sit down at the table and have a dialogue, I think we can get through some of this stuff. Excuse me.

50:27 I just started to work with the Arts Council, bringing those players together. One of the top tier projects is probably going to be the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. How do we make sure all the Arts Council is working together to maximize the facility and the programming of that facility, which will continue to work with the Recreation Department in terms of what does that look like, what does it taste like with those partners. We know we need to identify an outside events venue. We need a venue. So we need to get a group together to begin to have those conversations, begin to look at Janelle.

50:55 What land is the town owned and managed by the town? What forest land is out there? That may be a cost share agreement or perhaps a special use permit, but we need to get on that sooner rather than later. We started a conversation with Rob Lockhart at the Snow Creek Athletic Club about the possible public-private partnership for an aquatic center. What does that look like? How do we maximize part of our shattered MLRs to ensure we're not duplicating venues or programs?

51:24 We've had some good conversations, Betsy, Stuart, and I with Ralph about ensuring, clearly defining the work each one of these groups is going to be doing. And then we're starting, there's a small group beginning the conversation about the application process, United States Olympic Center, I have a two training center. What does that look like? What does it taste like? What's that timeline? I talked to Andrew Castor three weeks ago at lunch. You've got the Olympic trials here in February. What does the Mammoth Track Club look like?

51:51 You know, we're going down to Rio. What does it look like in Japan in 2020? You know, you're going to have, he wants five competitive men and women to be competitive for that team. You know, his dream is that the Mammoth Track Club is the United States Olympic team. And you go out eight years, you know, 2024, we could come back to LA. You know, what are we doing to prepare our community?

52:12 to host athletes, to train national governing organizations, to bring athletes in for high altitude training. You know, Gary Myers and I are going to continue that conversation tomorrow in terms of the hospital fits in that conversation. And then after the, once we begin the new year, after the Tournament of Roses parade, the 125th parade where we're celebrating the National Forest Service.

52:30 When Mr. Bocci gets out of his white suit and comes back to Mammoth, we'll step back and begin to look at a five-year strategic plan based on using the MLR 5.0 document. We're looking at those six essential strategies. What does it look like as we look five to ten years out? What do we want this to be? Which is aligned with the town, the NGO, staff conversation we've had on our larger strategic planning sessions. So that's kind of what we're up to right now.

52:58 You know, we've got a lot of moving parts. I'm thankful to our Board of Directors in Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I appreciate the partnerships we've built. The staff's been very supportive. Joel does a great job, and he's getting his fingers wet on stuff. Leslie, my Executive Director, for keeping me organized. I feel like we're making progress. We have a lot of work to do. We're trying to stay focused. We're doing the right stuff over at the right time. So with that, I'm open for any questions or comments you may have for me. Okay. Questions?

53:26 Where would you like to start? Do you want me to go again? Sure. Go for it. Hello, Bill. How are we today? I am glad you are feeling better. It is great to see you back in that show. It is good to be sitting back in this chair, believe me. The alternative isn't so pleasant, I think. Bingo. So I've heard a lot of things about where MLR is going and where you want to be. What I haven't heard, which is in my mind one of the only good arguments for MLR in the first place, was the entrepreneurial spirit.

53:53 that the town rec department didn't seem to be able to have. So what I'd like to hear out of the organization is how are we going to bring those dollars to the table that the municipal government hasn't been able to bring? And what are we doing that we're doing differently? Because a lot of the things that you're saying you're going to get started on, we got started on and may not have brought to fruition, but by God, we've done a lot of work on them. How is it you're going to be different?

54:22 From what we could have handled on the municipal side, not to be negative, but then to justify the extra money for the extra management side for MLR, I'd really like to hear more about that. Where are we bringing the dollars from? How are we spending R&U? Because I think we did a damn good job of that. But how are we going to get others to match that money so that it will go farther than was the capacity of it underneath the town's watch?

54:50 Does that make sense? Makes sense, yes. So let's look at, there are about 20 deliverables that MLR has at this point. You're speaking to deliverable number three that indicates bringing to town council a recommended list of top tier priorities that leverages measure R and U. Part of that conversation, until we find out what those top tier amenities are going to be, until the town council says this is one, this is two, this is three, we're not able to go out and say,

55:19 Let's support a multi-use facility or a community center because those are going to become facilities. But an example of what Evan Russell's done right now, and this would be a good way to look at, you know, one indicator, one example of where this could go. You know, Evan right now, his total package for the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center is about $7.5 million. He has an agreement from Kern County Community College for $4.8 million. He's got a grant from the Tambor Foundation for $2 million.

55:49 He's got a million dollar matching grant, and he's probably going to come to MLR for some ongoing maintenance and operations programming funds, probably between a tune of three to five hundred thousand dollars a year for an extended amount of time. We believe that's one example of how we leverage those funds to accomplish the completion of that project. One of the reasons I'm working, trying to pull the Arts Council together right now is...

56:11 How do we maximize program in that facility so we can generate the funding to support ongoing operations and maintenance all the time so we can begin to decrease the amount of money MLR or R&U using to support that after we've leveraged other dollars? That would be one example. But I've got to get the town to give us direction. This is priority one, two, and three before I go out. Let's say it's, you know, Joel and I have talked about adopting trails, you know. We get to the point, who wants to adopt a part of a trail?

56:40 You look at, let's say we move forward with a multi-use facility, you know, who wants to buy a piece of ice? Once we find out what it is, what those priorities are, then we can begin to market that, begin to develop partnerships, look at further granting opportunities, naming rights, corporate sponsorships, and things like that. And to that end, I think it would be really great if any of us who can could participate in the public hearing on the 27th of October, just when you kind of present this talk to your projects to the public.

57:11 So part of my question was, how are we thinking outside of the box that we were thinking in municipally, this group versus that group? Evan has done a great job going outside and getting funded. The arts was put into Measure U specifically at Evan's request so he could cover the O&M on the facility that he was going to find the funding for. How are we going to duplicate Evan's work on other works, not just the ones that we've already outlined perhaps in

57:40 RecStrats and Plan Your Parks. But how are we going to go outside of that? And the best example, to my mind, would be the high-altitude training you talked about. How are we going to get beyond where the town could have ever gotten? Because we cannot afford to operate that facility with what our budget is going to be in the near or long future, in my mind. And I believe the potential for the USOC high-altitude certification National Training Center status brings the opportunity for branding and marketing.

58:09 You know, you look at the track facility, and I don't look at it as a center, as a place. I look at this as a regional conversation. You know, you look at different entities. You look at, you know, you train high, you live high, you train higher. You know, you're looking at the track. Do we go back to ASICS and say, you guys want to do some naming rights? I know we need to deal with some of the Department of Water and Power, LADWP, has got some certain constraints on marketing and advertising, but we need to engage them in those conversations. What does that look like?

58:38 Is it going to another outdoor industry that wants to support one of our projects? Is it maybe some naming rights or working with an aquatic center at Snow Creek Athletic Club, beginning to look at putting some names to things? I think we need to be a little more creative in seeking members of the outdoor industry that are willing to come to town, high altitude, see the strength, and want to put their names on things and support things financially.

59:07 I think we're just in the process right now, three months in, to begin to think about what the projects look like, who could those partners be, and begin to have some of those conversations. I know that my partner, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, has a number of partners that are willing to step up and talk about these things, but we need to refine what that project's going to be. So when I go to partner, I say, this is what the project is, this is how we think you can help us, how would you like to come on board?

59:37 I really love the fact that for once someone said regional rather than just mammoth specific because it is important to include. It is not just us. Half the kids in our facilities come out of Crowley Lake, which we do not receive any direct tax benefit from. So hopefully you're thinking along those lines of a perhaps regional recreation group or some other such county tax. Absolutely. Well, those are larger conversations down the road in terms of...

1:00:07 You know, recreation districts, I understand those conversations we've had in the past, you know, but we're trying to take one piece at a time looking at where are we going to go. There's a lot of work to do. Good questions. You know, you keep us thinking about, you know, how do we keep going forward on some of this stuff. Okay? Exciting set. Any other questions or comments about it? Sure. Nothing I haven't already said before. Thank you for your efforts on getting us a special event venue. Can't stress that enough. Absolutely.

1:00:43 And, you know, what I'm realizing more and more is that 2017, Summer of, you know, we're fairly certain we've got Sam's Wood site for in 2016, but 2017 is only 18, 20 months away. Well, that gives me, that's nice here, it gives us some breathing room, because I'm sure that Vent Center is going to be one of our top tier, top tier pieces, but we need to look through. Grady and I have done a number of property walks right now.

1:01:12 Looking at what's town owned and managed. Let's say these top tiers roll out. Town gives us direction in December. Okay, this is our first priority, second priority. Who out there wants to work with a community center, a multi-use facility? Is it the LA Kings that want to get involved, some seed money on stuff? But then you've got to look at, do we do the next allocation process? It begins to look at environmental reviews. What do we look in conceptual designs?

1:01:41 You know, we looked at the bell-shaped parcel. Not that we're going to put an event venue out there, folks, so don't get carried away. You know, Bachi didn't say. But we've never done a stutter to see what that land really is, the wetlands and what it is. We really need to do a better job at really looking at what we have and then working with the community to say what fits best. You look at the map over my shoulder here, over my left shoulder, it's a story map of Mammoth. You know, who are we? Where are we going? What do we want to be when we grow up? Where are we going to strategically place these pieces?

1:02:10 You know, there's a lot of moving parts. And we, you know, John and I were talking about this. Even in the conversation yesterday, you know, Dan Holler made some good opening comments. You know, this is mammoth. Let's not be afraid to be great. But we need to have the collective genius of this community that says this is who we are and this is where we're going. A shared vision based on the common good. And what is that shared vision on the common good? You've got to realize it's got to be a collective. It can't be my project, your project. You've got to work together.

1:02:39 And I'm hoping that we can circle this community and say, we need to do a better job engaging people in dialogue and make some tough decisions about what we want to do. And with that, my three minutes is up. Thank you very much. Thank you, Rich. And I think, you know, from our standpoint, it's not just the vision but the execution that we're all hoping to move forward on. So, thank you. Chair, if I may, the town is investigating

1:03:08 Applications to that funding cycle. It's a bit tricky because we meet on November 3rd. So I think what we're going to do is investigate kind of some event tournament software and some special event equipment. I know we've obviously been funded about two, three years ago, but there probably is a need for additional equipment. So we're going to look at that. We'll probably put the application together and bring it to commission on November 3rd.

1:03:35 And then have you consider those for submittal. And that gets us to the November 6th deadline for the MLR application process. And those applications will fall within the parameters of the limited? We believe, talking with what Rich is putting forward, we believe they're consistent with the process. That sounds minimal. Great. Perfect. Thank you. All right. Then we'll move on to the consent agenda.

1:04:06 Anyone wishes to poll? If not, I would entertain a motion. I approve to accept the consent agenda. Any other motion? Is there a second? None are here. Okay. Well, I wasn't here either. I'll second. Thank you. I mean, I know we can, but it's best if you two do. Okay. Well, we still need someone. Well, anyway, all in favor of approving the consent agenda? Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. 4-0.

1:04:40 Alright, and that brings us into our discussion items. And we will start off with our multi-use facility task force planning update and recommendation. This is something that we've seen a couple of times, but this is going, this was an information item to council at their last meeting and will go to council for action on the 21st. So we'll have a staff report and then hopefully the commission can

1:05:10 Give our recommendation to council on the work of the task force. I'd like to separate this into two pieces, if I might. Even though the temporary shade idea that the council has asked staff and the task force to look at is certainly related to where the permanent facility will be, if we can separate them today and talk about them separately, we can then answer questions how they are related to each other. So first on the...

1:05:41 The ultimate sighting, again, council has given clear direction that the facility will not remain on the school site, period, and that was a very clear vote by council and clear direction. What they did ask staff to do is to convene a task force and look at other town-owned and managed sites and, frankly, just about anything for the best location for that multi-use facility.

1:06:05 In your packet is some of that due diligence from that task force, and I want to emphasize that this was a task force effort. This was not staff-driven. As much as I'd like to either take credit or get hit for some of the stuff in here, that's not the point. The point is it was a task force. There was MLR staff was there at every meeting. MLR members were there at every meeting. One or two council members were there at every meeting. Rec Commission was represented and town staff. So we think it was a really good cross-section. They took a look at...

1:06:34 An awful lot of previous information, let's say, that goes back to the 90s, frankly, and to the 80s about ice rinks and locations and preferred and all sorts of different things and multi-use facilities. I think that one thing I noted at the last council meeting when I heard some of the public comment is that since this has been around so long, it's very easy to reach back 15 and 20 years and pull, kind of cherry-pick an item and say, well, what about this?

1:07:00 That's nice. What the task force did was they took a fresh look at it. They did review all that. They were informed by those previous studies, but they recognized that 2015 is a different year. This is not 1989 or 98 or any of the other years when this subject was brought up. This is today. I think they took a really good fresh look at it. The facilities they looked at were the community center parcel, the bell-shaped parcel, Mammoth Creek Park West.

1:07:27 Whitmore Park, Trails Inn Park, and even the Civic Center site over near the hospital and the courthouse. Mammoth Creek East was looked at also briefly, but recognized that since it's for service and acquisition would be a long and difficult road, it didn't even make the list, even though, again, it was discussed at those task force meetings. What came out of it was not just a consensus, which...

1:07:53 which is sort of the thoughts of the group, but it was unanimous that Mammoth Creek Park West was the appropriate location long term for a multi-use facility for a number of reasons. And again, there's a lot of detail in your packet and we have a lot more that we could talk about. Rich is here as well who can describe some of the task force doings and MLR's action that they took last week as well. One of the things that was focused on after

1:08:19 Mammoth Creek Park West was kind of selected or recommended, let's say, by this task force, is what else should go there? What is the complementary facility? What is the highest and best use? What is the most intense need that the community has right now?

1:08:35 And again, it was fairly unanimous that a new community center was the top of that list. The current one of 2,500 square feet, we've managed to keep it together between Public Works staff and Warren, mostly by paint, frankly. I mean, you go in there, it does look very nice inside. It works, but I mean, it's awesome.

1:08:55 Exactly. It's not in great shape, clearly. And that's the one facility that the task force thought was the highest on the list. And what does that mean? A community said, let me talk about that a little bit. We're not sure yet, frankly. The existing one is 2,500 square feet. We've talked about a 5,000 square foot community center. It'll be up to this group working with Rec staff to program that and get back to MLR and others about what should go in that facility. What we're suggesting...

1:09:24 The task force is, and town staff agrees with this, is that we recommend to council that they include a 10,000 square foot facility in any environmental documentation we do because it's very easy to program for 10,000 square feet, look at the impacts of 10,000 square feet, and then if the first phase is only 5,000 or if long term it's even 5,000 to back off, that's very simple. If we go in there with a 5,000 square foot community center and we say, well,

1:09:53 1,000 more square feet, look what we could get, then we have an environmental issue. So we want to suggest we look at a 10,000 square foot issue, do some preliminary programming, and do that. The recommendation from the task force, from town staff, and from MLR that Rich can speak to is, in fact, MLR took action to approve that recommendation that the multi-use facility be located at Pammoth Creek Park West in conjunction with the community center.

1:10:19 And in fact, the community center, if anything, is sort of the lead attractant there. And the multi-use facility is a complementary facility. And they're recommending we do that, and that's the recommendation we expect to take to town council on the 21st. When we go on the 21st, we actually have some rough estimates for what it would cost to do some real preliminary design that would lead to the environmental process.

1:10:42 And we've heard a lot of talk about what should be studied in that environmental process. Again, you've heard me many times say I'm not going to presuppose what CEQA requires us to do, but I can assure you that staff will make every effort to make sure this is very defendable, defensible, and it's a good, solid document. Some of the things we'll certainly look at would be traffic, would be noise, would be parking situation itself, which is...

1:11:07 Sort of a related issue, light, all those types of things, things that have been studied in the past as well back in the EIR that was begun back in 1998. Which one was it? The years go back. Anyway, we're going to look at all those things. So based on that, that's my comments on the location for the multi-use facility. And if Rich would like to, I'd like to focus on that.

1:11:33 Part of it first, if you have any comments to add from M.O.R., and then I'll come back for the interim shade structure, and we can address that and combine them at the end. I'll present just a quick summary of the work we started starting back on July 15th. We know the Town Council considered the school district's offer for a long-term lease agreement, but respectfully decided to look for another long-term permanent location. Additional action by Town Council.

1:12:07 Directed representatives of MLR, Rec Commission, Town Staff to complete the due diligence to find a new location for facility and options for a temporary shade structure. Our task force began its work on July 28th, about, what, two months in now? Our goal is to find a location for the multi-use facility and a quick win for a temporary shade structure. We really thought we could find something that was affordable, that was doable. We were enthusiastic.

1:12:33 Task Force created and completed a due diligence, opportunities, and constraints matrix. And that matrix looked at all the town-owned and managed properties. You know, what, how do we maximize the use of those properties, knowing that green space is of vital importance to this community? And we expanded our thinking to include potential complementary facilities. We reached consensus that Mammoth Creek Park West's town-owned properties is a recommended location for a permanent multi-use facility.

1:13:00 Permitting Community Center with complementary facilities. We support that recommendation to go to Mammoth Creek Park, which is the action MLR took on Monday, October 5th. The task force continued with their due diligence and created a temporary shade struck matrix that allowed us to compare a number of other venues in cities such as Breckenridge, Sun Valley, Salmon, Idaho, Lake Tahoe, and Jackson Hole. There are a number of people here and others that assist with research.

1:13:27 Breckenridge was identified as the best comparable model for further financial research. And, Rich, I'm just going to have you just hold on the sheet structure comments because I think we're going to take these, we're going to break these into two. We're going to start with the location. Okay. So the action taken by the ML Board on Monday, October 5th, was to include the construction of a new multi-use facility on the town on Mammoth Creek Park property west as part of a complementary facility with

1:13:56 Community Center. All right. So are there any questions for staff or Rich and I both sat on the task force about just the location and the potential complementary facility? My only comment is that we need, of course, to look at the rink and its needs first. The fact that the other is a complementary facility is a great thing, but placement...

1:14:26 And all of that work needs to be done after we've dealt with what we're doing with this facility so that we can get it in place in time. So as long as I have that assurance and we're not trying to move these together at the same time, I'm good to go. No, that's correct. We are looking at siting for both those facilities, but the multi-use facility, we absolutely expect to have a groundbreaking on Halloween of 2017. And that's the focus. Right.

1:14:53 Groundbreaking or opening? Sorry, opening. Thank you. Ribbon cutting. Ribbon cutting. Thank you. Ribbon cutting. Again, thank you. I'm scared. I know. Thank you, Sean. Also, after we know that we're going to move forward with environmental work that's going to include a complementary facility, that's when we can actually start having the discussions about what that facility might look like, but we can't really do that until we have that direction. Correct? Okay. And we're going to deal with the shade structure separately.

1:15:24 We're going to be able to see the instructor in just a moment. So you're looking for a motion from us to? I can wait until the end, but I think we'll maybe, MLR separated it into two. Can I just say that, you know, we need to publicly state, because I know there's been some questions from the public as to why we haven't even put Shady Rest in this discussion and why we didn't look at that, and just...

1:15:49 I think we need to do better at explaining to the public that Shady Rest and Mammoth Creek East are under the special use permit, and with that we cannot build a permanent facility on those parcels, which is why it was not included in this whole research.

1:16:07 Development that we're doing. I appreciate that. We'll add that to the staff report that goes to Town Council next week. In fact, this morning, Jamie came in to check on that action sheet. My point was I wanted to wait until after this meeting that we can finalize that for comments just like that. So we will definitely comment on Shady Rest and the fact that it's under.

1:16:26 Special Use Permit and what's allowed there. So appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for bringing that up because when I was at the last council meeting that came up several times, obviously that's not really an option or we would have pursued it. Okay. Okay. So should we move on to the state structure conversation and then we can do a motion at the end? Thank you. As Rich described, and I did not warn him that I was going to suggest separating these two items, but I know he's quick on his feet, so not too worried about it.

1:16:55 The task force did look at a variety of facilities all over the west, frankly, and by photographs, some places in the east as well. What works, what doesn't work. We had council people on a road trip that went by several facilities as well. Initially, the task force said, this is great. We're not going to do ABC. Let's do a cost estimate and focus on what Breckenridge has done, which is, while it is interim, it's certainly more substantial than some of the others.

1:17:22 Staff did do a detailed cost estimate. As Rich said, we got copies of some of the construction plans from Breckenridge, basically 30-foot tall steel poles with some netting across that from end to end along the long way where that netting can be pulled in under certain storm events and things to protect it as best we can. It was also manageable where you could turn that netting.

1:17:47 The other direction increased the shade level by rotating it so there were more poles on the other side. And again, some of those drawings are in your packet if you want more information. The task force initially said, you know, we want something like this. We don't want something more flimsy, if you will, something less than that. If we're going to do it, it's got to look good. We know that the school district is going to have an approval process for that. And that's where we ended up. The second part, though, was really

1:18:16 The interest of the hockey community, among others, and we more than appreciate their enthusiasm, their passion for this, believe me, and staff has tried to let them know for some time we would like nothing better than to be able to build something temporary for $50,000 or under $100,000.

1:18:34 We did have a very good meeting with that group and the task force last Friday. They were able to bring in a few days before that some more detailed cost information and even a brief schematic design of what a facility might look like. It basically had 25-foot poles with shade netting going the short way, if you will, from east to west.

1:18:56 25-foot-high poles, 10-foot-high hanging down, and they provided a cost estimate that showed that for the poles and the netting material would be about $58,000, $59,000. And they did fully admit that they did not have a complete estimate. That did not include most of the labor. It didn't include foundation. It didn't include tearing and grubbing, demolition. And there are a lot of things that weren't there. But, again, we really appreciated that information. Staff has taken a look at that. And, unfortunately, very unfortunately,

1:19:24 It's our opinion that to even build what they're suggesting is closer to the $150,000 range. And on top of that, staff's look at it, and again, Rich can fill in with other comments from the task force, we didn't see that that specific design really afforded a lot of good use for the summer. In other words, it didn't provide a lot of shade, a netting that hangs down to within 13 feet of the surface.

1:19:50 Really just doesn't work if you're going to play basketball, if you're going to play volleyball, those types of things. And one of the concerns was provide shade and cool that surface off for some of the summer programming as well. With that, the task force is going to meet again on Friday. Look at that detailed information one last time before we go to council next week and hopefully have a final recommendation on that. And again, let's ask Rich to please speak to MLR's action regarding the temporary shade structure.

1:20:25 So we began, we continued our research, and we realized that the costs would come in at about $200,000, give or take a little bit. We also began to look at some other incomplete projects based on your list of projects. One example would be to complete Trails End Park is $145,000. It would be nice to go through the check sheet and say, check, check that off, move forward. As Grady was saying, we continue to refine some costs. We at that point agreed that we're not going to move this forward.

1:20:53 So MLR took action on October 5th, and the language of that motion was that the MLR Board of Directors not pursue a temporary shade structure unless there's a low-cost bid that meets all the compliance and requirement codes for the town and the school district. And that was passed 4-1. And based on Grady's comments we met this past Friday, we'll meet again this Friday, we'll begin to look at some other options and continue to prepare for recommendation to town council on

1:21:24 October 21st. Thank you. Okay. Okay, so do questions and then take public comment before we deliberate. So questions of staff or which regarding the shade structure? If I'm right looking at the breakout here, if for whatever reason the council decided to do the shade structure as it is in Breckenridge, the loss in putting it

1:21:56 Temporarily for one season, although we wouldn't have time to put it in now anyway, but just for looking at numbers, it would be about $140,000 because that's the cost of the foundations to put the thing on. So we would throw that much money in the toilet, as it were, if we chose to do that at that location, as I suggested some time ago. That would be right. I'm just saying that so anybody looking at this on the TV understands why the choice was made. Those Friday meetings aren't telecast.

1:22:28 Not to go forward with putting it in and then potentially moving it to the other side. You know, I think that maybe if I could just ask you to clarify your comments, I don't think that it's necessarily putting money in the toilet as much as it's spending money for only one season. For only one season, right. And that's a very expensive season. And I think the Breckenridge option was even more than the $140,000. Well, the total option is a half a million dollars.

1:22:55 But if we chose to move it to the other location afterwards, everything could be moved except for the 28 pillars, the foundations for those pillars, because the poles bolt to them, as I'm understanding here.

1:23:12 The way we would do this is, again, if we got direction to proceed with something like that, the footings themselves are, again, about $140,000. There's other costs associated with that, clearing and grubbing and everything. I think what Commissioner's referring to is the cost of the poles themselves, which we estimated at between $12,000 and $15,000. And certainly, if it was the council's direction to do so, if it was constructed over at the school site,

1:23:40 and we wanted to create that same type of shade structure at the new site, we could reuse those poles because they would be bolted to a foundation. Now, just to be clear, though, Council has directed us to look at a metal building.

1:23:54 on the Mammoth Creek Park West site. So that really isn't something that staff has been asked to look at. But certainly those poles could be relocated over there if we wanted to do a shade structure versus a metal building. Right. It doesn't mean that the metal building might not take 10 years to erect. The shade structure could be our interim over a much longer period of time and therefore be more palatable.

1:24:14 But we also have to take into consideration the demolition costs, right, to restore the site. Yes. Yeah, to take the foundations out and things. We would assume that the school district would like us to do that. It's a lot more complicated than that, but I think I wanted to help clarify what we started. And just a question for my own edification in the column footing detail that you have here. The only thing I don't see is the shade cloth itself. You've got the cost for the 26 poles.

1:24:43 At $275,600, but the shade cloth, as I see it, would probably be about another $6,000 on top of that. Again, what we found, of course, is the poles themselves and the foundations, all that work is far more expensive than the shade cloth, so we weren't too concerned with that cost, but correct. Thank you. Any other questions? I guess I want to ask a question that, you know, I've had the chance to ask you in private meetings, but I think I want to just ask it here is, and actually just a little bit of background.

1:25:14 One of my biggest concerns about what we are proposing here is that we talk publicly about a ribbon cutting for Halloween 2017 and we don't make that date. You know, that's just a concern that I think we all share. Grady, can you speak to if we are committed and we have some kind of

1:25:38 Consolidation, you know, that there is consensus here that we are going forward both at this level, Town Council, and we get the public behind us. Can you speak a little bit, and I know you can't give any guarantees, what could hold us back? What do we need to be forthcoming to the public on could prevent that October 2017 ribbon cutting? Let me address some of the...

1:26:05 I'll call them assumptions, even though I hate that word, but expectations of staff. In other words, we were saying ribbon cutting again on Halloween of 2017 with the expectation that on October 21st the council will say go. If they say something else, then we look at it again. Having said that, if we start at that point in time, and I will get to...

1:26:27 What could hold us up, but I want to walk through the process again very quickly. If we get it going October 21st, we already have a stable, if you will, of environmental consultants under contract with planning and economic development who can start on this right away. We would go out with an RFQ very quickly again for a design firm to help us finish the design for the facility. We think that could all be complete within 60 days or so in terms of a preliminary design, a little bit better site plan, a little bit more information.

1:26:56 The environmental process, even if we are required to do an environmental impact report, and while a project of this type or this size may not always require that, it might require a focused negative deck as an example, it's staff recommendation right now that it be an EIR.

1:27:15 Because we can ensure that we flush out everything. It's more defensible. We think it's worth the investment, very frankly, to answer the questions of the neighborhood and everybody else and really do our due diligence. We really expect that process to take nine months. We expect by next October to be certifying an EIR in front of town council. What that means is our only drawback is the construction season. We can't start until the next May.

1:27:40 We could theoretically start during next winter, but we certainly wouldn't go out there and tear up the site then. It's also...

1:27:47 Entirely likely we could open the facility in June or July, let's say, more likely July. The only reason we've even mentioned Halloween is because we thought that with the summer programming at the existing facility, we could actually do both. We could be reconstructing the multi-use facility during the summer. Once the summer programming is done, we switch over to that point. Having thought about that and talking to Stu about that summer programming, which ones really need the boards?

1:28:14 There aren't that many. We may go ahead and recommend let's get it done and let's open in July at the new location. So we think there's some, I hate to use the word float, but there is some float in there. If the environmental process takes a year instead of nine months, we're still in good shape. Now, to your question, what could hold us up? Not getting a go, not getting started. Certainly that holds you up. We're not going to get any place unless we get started.

1:28:43 The second thing is just the concerns of the neighborhood. We think there are valid concerns. They want to hear more about noise. They want to hear more about light, traffic, parking. It's our opinion so far that the number of vehicles on the road is not going to be a huge issue, but that will be something we'll need to look at. Parking, we'll have to look at the maximum seating capacity of the facility. How many stands are we going to put in? Is the 44 spaces that are already there enough or not?

1:29:10 So some as it will study. What really holds us up is if we do get a lawsuit filed or some kind of an action by the neighborhood or others that want to slow the facility down, they can do that. They need to meet certain standards even to do that, though. You can't, in the environmental world, if you file that type of thing, if it's going to negatively impact the town in terms of funds and things, they actually need to step up.

1:29:34 Certain times and make sure that it doesn't cost us money. In other words, it can't be just a frivolous lawsuit. That's one of the reasons we want to do an environmental impact report, we believe, to make it more bulletproof, to answer all the questions, to lay out any necessary mitigations to reduce any impacts to less than significant and really handle that. I don't know of anything else other than funding.

1:29:57 I think the town manager has laid out a funding program that covers most of this facility so far. He's admitted we don't have all the dollars yet. That's something we certainly have to look at. So to me it's funding. Well, go. We need to get started. We need everybody behind it. The funding issue is one that's out there, but we think we have a way to handle that and then managing and answering the concerns of the neighbors in an inappropriate fashion. We will not...

1:30:24 Ever please everybody. It doesn't matter. Where it is now doesn't please everybody. So that's not going to happen. We just need to do a really good job of that due diligence. Okay. Well, and I know we're about to go to public comments, but, you know, I just want to encourage us to embrace this and go forward with consensus as a community.

1:30:43 and really keep our eyes on the prize of cutting this ribbon in October of 2017 for the benefit of everyone. At the same time, I want to challenge town staff to be prepared for the worst, you know, and make sure that if there are challenges that come up, that that's communicated as quickly as possible and that we're anticipating challenges.

1:31:08 So, Commissioner, it sounds like your concern, if the town was directed to pursue also a temporary sage structure and try and commit to opening a facility in 2017, we'd be jeopardising both those projects? Is that kind of what we're kind of hearing? I'm just concerned that if we get sidetracked and have to focus a lot of our energies on other projects without really staying focused on delivering a multi-use facility by 2017, that would jeopardise that date.

1:31:33 I didn't specifically say that, but I will say that. Because, well, you know, my concern is that, yeah, we can get sidetracked and that there are, and, you know, something that I've learned about the public process is that there are always going to be questions. There are always, and fair enough, you know, fair concerns. There comes a point when we just need to embrace and go, let the ship leave the dock. And I think that we're, from what I'm understanding, we're at that point. I just want to make sure that we're,

1:32:03 Fully prepared to really make sure that if we go forward that we are going to complete this process with all the challenges known in advance. But Stu, to your point, yes, I think that I know that there's a lot of people who want this season at this existing location. A lot of people that are asking, should we be moving? Town Council has already directed us to definitely move. And I think that that's a good choice. I just want to make sure that

1:32:32 Since we are embracing this decision, hopefully on the 21st, that we rally together and go forward with the eyes on the prize of having a grand party on Halloween in 2017, if not sooner. We're starting to get into deliberations. Thanks for that clarification. Are there any further questions before we go to public comment? Any comments from the public on this item? Sandy Hogan, longtime supporter of recreation. Don't miss too many meetings, but I'm sorry I missed your last couple.

1:33:09 Sean and Bill have brought up some excellent questions, especially about the past history, I think, and the commitment issues, and those are those important ones to really go back and look at, and I'm sure it sounded like you looked at, I think it was the 1998 EIR, and you saw, I mean, that one was...

1:33:31 That was a problem, obviously, and shot down, and you hate to initiate a process like this without looking at all of those. So I think that's really important to anticipate everything that came up, and especially the neighboring issue and whatever, the noise, the lighting, whatever. The funding is one that I think also would be good. As I understand, and you could probably clarify for me, this is going to come through an internal loan.

1:34:00 Is that how the funding will come forward? I'd rather not get into a lot of detail on that because it's still in the works and that's something the town manager is working on. I know that one has to do with the current lease payments we make now to the school district and ice removal, which adds up between the lease payment and snow removal. It's about $60,000 a year. So that is one of the things he's looking at as an internal loan based on that.

1:34:26 Already committed $60,000 a year. Right. And there are some diff funds that are available as well, and there are some Measure R things we can look at as well. Okay. Just in the sense that these guys brought up a little history you might want to look at, and I know there are some...

1:34:42 Folks in the past that are still burning about an internal loan taken from DIF. I'm sure you guys remember for the parking garage up there by the parking structure, I should say, up by the village. And I think it was someplace around $3.5 million, a loan that's never been repaid as far as most people think. I'm not sure, but you might want to look at that. I know I've heard from John Vanuc on that and Ward Jones and folks like that, and they still are really, because those were people that paid into that DIF.

1:35:11 And all of a sudden there was an internal loan. I can't even remember what it was for. You guys probably, or Bill probably could. I can't remember. But those are the things that if you borrow from Diff again, you realize that's going to bring up. So those are the little things to alert because none of you guys, nor Dan, was here during that time. So I understand the repayment part. That's no problem. It's the loan part. That's all I'm looking at. Where does the money come from, you know, to finish it on 2017?

1:35:40 So just little things like that, the payment, nothing wrong with that, but maybe follow up on that so you can answer that question, because I'll bet you somebody will bring it up. Best to know those things. A little institutional memory again. Any questions? No. Thank you, Sandy. Any other comments from the public? Okay. So seeing none, I will bring it back. Who'd like to start? I think I said my piece, so. Okay.

1:36:15 I would just reiterate what he said. Let's start the motor of the ship and get it the heck out of dock. All right. Teri, if you have anything you'd like to add, you made the most of it at MLR? Yeah. No, it's just kind of the same thing that I said at MLR. You know, the decision to move was made. So let's move this forward in the most efficient and expedient way we can. I think that if we're moving down the line,

1:36:46 We see that this is going to be a longer term thing than maybe go back to looking at the shade structure and maybe a little bit more money into that makes a little more sense if for some reason it's going to be delayed for a few years. But that's why MLR left just if there was a low cost option that came forward that met the school's requirements and the town's requirements that there was still that you could leave that door open without it having to come back again.

1:37:16 Anyways, that's the reason that that was left. But to spend, you know, the $140,000, $200,000 and up for a one-year purpose, well, we would all love to do it. I would absolutely love to. And I will tell you that I know Tom from MLR was going in with the exact thought that, you know, this is going to be done and we're going to make this happen. He was totally gung-ho. And unfortunately, with everything that's came forward, it wasn't.

1:37:45 possible. So I would say absolutely. As I said, the decision has been made to move it for us, so let's move forward as expediently as possible. Okay. Just a couple of comments. One, to Sandy's point, I think it's really important that as we move forward that we make sure that the public understands that this isn't...

1:38:06 This isn't new money. This isn't money that the town suddenly just decided to spend. These are funds that we're already spending on the lease, and we have a little gap to close to complete the facility, but I know there have been a lot of questions in the community about, well, why are we doing this and not an events center or a pool or something else? And so I just think it's going to be important going forward that that information is well presented to the public. In terms of the shade structure, I just...

1:38:33 I know that this is disappointing to a lot of people. And I think that all of us as advocates for recreation

1:38:40 We've all been out there. We've seen the rope across the ice where it's really soft and you can't skate on it when the sun is melting it. And it's a problem and it's something that I really, really wish that we could address. But this is something that the commission looked at three years ago. And even when we weren't talking about moving the facility, we found it to be cost prohibitive then. And I haven't seen anything to indicate that those numbers have changed. And when you look at our giant spreadsheet of

1:39:09 Other priorities, you know, deferred maintenance, the funds to complete Trails End Park. I just, I don't think that it makes sense to spend these kinds of funds on something interim and temporary. I think I'd rather, you know, use that money to deliver something really spectacular for our community and something that's going to really be viable year-round that we can do really great programming with. And those are my comments. And then just one question to Terry and Rich in terms of the shade structure.

1:39:38 Because I think the commission, I think I've heard that we are all ready to move on with this. And so, you know, is MLR interested in continuing to, you know, pursue any of those low-cost options and, you know, funding for that? I think that the Friday group is still bringing those ideas forward. And, you know, I know there's some more information that just came forward for sprung structure, which I know when we looked at

1:40:07 You know, this was something that we looked at a few years ago on a permanent sprung structure and it was going to be too high because of the width that it had to be. It had to go too high. I know that Rich got some numbers on leasing something in the short-term option and it's just the cost is just...

1:40:26 And it was funny because I actually went back and watched some old commission meetings and I think there was one where you actually talked about going to sprung.com and doing some of that research. Yeah, we had a whole documentation from sprung and gave us the specs and gave us all of that information and it just wasn't going to happen because it was going to end up being too tall.

1:40:47 For the facility that we could build over there. And so, you know, it has been looked at, but they were actually looking at just doing a temporary and doing a lease. We're collecting more information. The task force will meet again on Friday, continue with our due diligence, trying to refine numbers. Let's remind ourselves, there's no money available. There's no funding line item for this temporary shade structure. We'd have to go through an allocation process for the review, the design.

1:41:17 The public bid process. So even if we went through that process, we're going to miss a season at this point in time. And let's remind ourselves that the task force on Friday realized that this temporary shade structure, if it were designed like the Breckenridge, it's just going to be vertical with the ground.

1:41:36 It's not going to shade like a shade structure. It's not going to help us in the summer. And we realize at that point, if we're going to start looking at your blinds on the window, you can address with that wand to change the shade for summer and winter. You know, we're going to double the costs on this project. So just remind ourselves there is no funding. We'd have to go through an allocation process. But we will continue to do our due diligence. And if there's something that's there, you know, we'll present that. Thank you. All right.

1:42:03 Well, I would certainly entertain a motion if someone is prepared to make one. I'm assuming you'd like two motions. I'll make the motion that we accept the recommendation and send the strongest message possible to the council to proceed with the moving of the rink from the school site to Mammoth Creek West. I'll second that. Okay. I have a motion and a second.

1:42:36 For further discussion, do we want to add the language in the recommended motion includes the complimentary facility? Do we want to add that at this time? I don't know that it's necessary to include that in this or whether that's just a given that we move forward. If everyone's more comfortable, I will go back to the language. Do you have the language here that they used? Well, it's just not pursue a temporary structure at this time, right? Just the number one. Recommended multiple-use facility be located at Mammoth Creek Park West with the plan to include.

1:43:08 Potentially a community center as a complementary use with an opening date, not targeted, but opening date of October 2017 for multi-use facility. That would be my motion. And I will amend my second. Okay. I have an amended motion and a second. Any further discussion? Okay. All in favor of accepting? The motion is presented. Aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes. 4-0. We'll take that to council. And

1:43:42 On the shade structure portion, I would entertain a motion. You know, I think, Chair, that we don't need a motion. If we don't pass a motion, the shade structure doesn't move forward from our perspective. Just consensus that we're not moving forward on a shade structure at this point, I think, would be adequate. Correct me if I'm wrong. Staff? I guess I would say that, you know, that kind of as a...

1:44:11 note of consensus is that we understand that the task force is still meeting each Friday and that there's still a potential of something to come forward if there's a low cost structure that they feel is viable and at that point because it would have to have financing it would come back anyways so it's not something that's just going to happen because so I don't know is that yeah I think not doing anything today allows us to act on anything that comes up in the future

1:44:41 And as you said, anything new would have to come forward in the future anyway. Yeah, and it would go through MLR in terms of funding. I don't think I might suggest in order to send the strongest message possible to town council, what MLR did was a little different, but I ended up really appreciating the motion. In other words, what you did was say.

1:45:00 We're not going forward unless a low-cost alternative can be identified. And I don't necessarily think we need that in terms of a motion, but if that's your consensus, that's the message that we will pass along. I guess that's kind of what I was thinking. It's still the same thing. Yeah, I would agree with that statement, which would make it consensus. Okay. I'm fine either way. I'm fine with consensus or a motion. I think from the Commission's standpoint, I think, you know, unless something...

1:45:25 New and exciting comes out of, you know, what the task force is looking at. I don't anticipate that we'll be talking about a shade structure again here. So. Thank you. All right. So we have consensus on that? Sure. So. Okay. Perfect. Thank you. That can go. All right. Would anybody like a break? You guys doing okay? It'll be fine. You good? Taking the break? We're taking a break. We're taking a break. We'll take a five-minute recess. We're going to work this diuretic tells me I need to get rid of it. Get your blood on a little.

1:46:07 Thanks, guys. Okay. Yep, let's do it. Okay. We'll reconvene and move on to item number eight, the 2015-16

1:47:06 This winter, Mammoth ice rink operating plan review. Thank you, Chair. Yes, I'm just going to walk you through the operating plan, our budget, which we've attached, the new revised winter schedule, an overview of our youth hockey programs, and attached to this packet is also the 2014-15 ice rink presentation we presented last year, just in case you wanted to see, you know, some new metrics or different numbers that I don't think we were able to provide you last year with.

1:47:36 See, we closed last season as scheduled on February 22. This year we've actually tried to get another week out of the ice rink, so we're going to extend that for a week. We're trying to get to the end of February. So it's going to push that season a little bit longer as best we can. And then we had just over 7,000 people, 7,321 skated that facility. We reached 98% of our revenue and we're approximately, you know, about 10 to 15% under budget for that season.

1:48:04 We're scheduling to open the ice rink February 27th and close, as we said, on February 28th, which is a week later than last year, weather permitting. So we've completely revised the operating schedule that I'll walk you through, and that schedule provides for additional public skating sessions. We have a new lunchtime skate session for $6, and we've really kind of looked at the configuration of our schedule to really focus on community programs at that facility. So I'll kind of walk you through that when we get there as well.

1:48:33 No fee changes have been incorporated into the upcoming season. We'll reevaluate after the season to look at those fee schedule numbers. But last year ran on new fee schedules. So we want to kind of look at a two-year window, kind of see what was going on, before we kind of consider changing those fees. So I'm just going to walk you through the operating plan, just to kind of point out what's new, what's changed, what's different. The brochure is being produced.

1:49:01 As we speak in a draft format, we'll be able to get it to the Commission, I would say, by Wednesday, Thursday this week, if you want to have a look at that. That'll incorporate, essentially, a lot of this information, a little bit more condensed. And again, the website's being updated as well. So the first page of the document just runs through basic information that we have. We've talked about dates of operations. We've plugged in the winter holiday dates. And we've said, you know, no changes for this season are in effect.

1:49:30 The addition to this season will be helmet rental. We had a lot of requests last year for helmets, so we've gone ahead and purchased about 20 helmets, youth and adult. If you do participate in one of our lesson programs or hockey lesson or hockey programs, that'll be complimentary. Otherwise, it's a $5 use per session.

1:49:48 We still continue with the very popular five skate pass. That's really our main promotional piece and main product that people buy if they want to come back time and time again, not only for locals but also for our out-of-towners. We still have our $2 school special. That's obviously part of the existing agreement that we have with the school district. That's not really up for negotiation at this time. You can see we've moved lunchtime skate.

1:50:13 Into kind of a lunchtime period from 12 to 1.30. So really going after kind of our locals. So this is going to be our kind of locals promotion. Come down, skate. We'll try and have some concession lunch specials as well. But for $6, we've moved that from like a 2 to 4 p.m. period up to kind of our lunchtime. So we want to kind of see if we can get some folks out there at lunch. The ice is probably in the best shape. We've just opened. I mean, it's clean ice. It's great before it gets too warm. Those type of things. The ice rink board program will continue on as well.

1:50:41 And then right at the bottom of page two there you can see a lot of our special events. We're plugged in, we're looking at hosting three tournaments this season already. The first one is really our local Youth Hockey Classic, so that's looking at our local kids, kind of putting on a little tournament just for them. We might have some out-of-town teams come in and participate in that as well, but that's kind of early December. You can see there that we have the Haunted Roller Rink on Friday, October 30th.

1:51:07 So that kind of precedes Halloween on the Saturday. And that essentially is like last year of 5 to 7.30 p.m., really focused on kind of our elementary slash middle school children. The next one, you can see the one we hosted last year for the first time, the colder winter youth hockey classic that's back. It's really that same schedule. That's that Thursday through Sunday. That's all early morning. That's, you know, 7 o'clock to about noon. We'll kind of manage that parking situation and so forth as we need based on demand of that facility.

1:51:38 January is National Skating Month, so we'll run those promotions we did last year, which was really quite successful on our free Friday night lessons. And then we've looked at doing a couple of events here on the Hockey Weekend again. These are just early morning programs. We have an MLK Hockey Weekend and a President's Week Hockey Tournament. So that's looking at just inviting kind of different regional teams to come in and participate in mini tournaments that we have at the rink.

1:52:03 And then Patrick's done a great job here. We're bringing up the Valencia Flyers. It's a DSCS event. We're partnering with that group to bring that group in just for a day on February 21st. So more information to follow on that. So that'll be really exciting. But again, that's for a lot of our, you know, skaters with disabilities. Get them on the rink and get them out there and enjoy the experience. So that's great.

1:52:28 We have two lesson instructors. If we talk about our lesson programs quickly, we have Steph and we have Julianne. So they've put together this new program. And we've really much scheduled specific and exclusive ice time for this program. So there's three hours of exclusive ice time just for our lesson program. So it's not shared ice, it's exclusive ice. So I think they have a great opportunity to provide a really good experience and really good lesson product for not only our kind of locals, but if we have any visitors coming in, which I'll talk about coming up in a little bit as well.

1:52:57 But these programs here are really just for kind of our locals looking at a program. So it's not a one-off. It's kind of a program. So they'll come in and purchase a $41 product. They'll give them five lessons. We really want to walk them through a program, graduating them from kind of a snowplow Sam up to a level one product and then up to a level two product.

1:53:16 Which kind of moves them up into the advanced skills skating class as well. And we have two of those sessions. So we run kind of an early session in the season and then a session two starting just after the holiday season. So again, if we have folks that start early, we can graduate them up into the new programs or vice versa. If they miss that first one, they can still get the session session. So that's kind of how we put that together.

1:53:41 The other one in there as well, I don't think it's listed here, but it's in the schedule. What I'll talk about is what we call the first-time skater assist program. So on Friday afternoon from 4 to 6.30, what we're really going to provide is some lesson times that folks can come in, register at the rink for, and then we'll give them kind of lesson tips, instructions if they're just first-timers. So it'll be kind of like a 20, 25-minute lesson product. There'll be public skating going on. It's kind of like a flex time is what they call it on a rink.

1:54:11 So really that's just giving an opportunity for folks that never skated before. This is your day to come in. So again, it's on a Friday. If people locally want to come and learn how to skate, we'll direct them to that time on Friday. But again, if we have folks from out of town looking to gain experience on the ice rink, that's what that product is for. So it's a first-time skater assist program on that Friday afternoon. A hockey program.

1:54:36 So the way it's set up this season is similar to last season with our youth hockey program. As you know, Patrick Bernard runs that program. He's also employed at the facility as our site coordinator in summer at the Rec Zone and also our assistant site coordinator at the ice rink in wintertime. He's ultimately in charge of programming the facility and our concessions. So Dan Storrs is coming back. He'll be the operations manager for the facility. He'll maintain that facility, run the facility.

1:55:03 Patrick's in charge of programming facility. That's how that works with oversight from Stephanie, our recreation supervisor. So he's put together a great program. It's based on really how much the hockey the kids want to play, if you read this. So it goes from a $100 program up to a $200 program based on the kids' appetite for how much hockey they want to play and what they're into. So that's a great program. We just sell them a discounted season pass. So we just basically say, if you join this hockey program, you commit to the season.

1:55:32 We'll sell you a youth season pass for this program. So that's how the rink benefits from that program. We don't charge them a per hour time for that ice program. It'd just be way obviously too expensive for the community kids to participate in. But that's how we gain our revenue from that program. There's a new program that they've introduced called the New Future Stars Hockey Program. So these are kids from four to eight years old that probably haven't been introduced to hockey or they have siblings that play hockey.

1:56:00 So it's a program just for them right after school on Mondays. You can see they come in just after school time, 3 o'clock, get them on the ice, and they can pay that program for the season. That's a youth hockey program. Power skate session is what the rink's going to operate. So these are just ways for hockey players, skiers, you know, that want to come down. Again, we've tried to put these programs on kind of a Monday, Tuesday.

1:56:25 Based on the schedule that the ski team operates, which is kind of a Wednesday, Thursday, Friday. So we're trying to put these in a time slot that we can still get those kids participating in our programs in addition to and not competing with the ski team. So that's the new power skate session and we think that's going to be a great and a big hit to the lesson product menu. Women's hockey, we're introducing women's hockey. I know it's always been on the schedule but we're going to give them a specific time. Women can also participate in the adult.

1:56:50 Hockey League as well. It's not just gender specific. So they can come and join the 3v3 league. They can join the men's league and the co-ed league on Wednesday night as well. So again, not gender specific. They can join at any time. And you can see adult hockey is programmed 3v3, pond style. Patrick's going to start to get a league going, which I think is great finally. See how we kind of go with that program there. But there's plenty of session times for the hockey program. And looking at just generally the schedule,

1:57:19 I did a quick analysis of the time. It's programmed about 70, probably 75% of the time is for public recreational skate time, tournament time, open rental time, lesson time, you know, kind of our time that we program the rink for and about 25, less than probably 25% for hockey programs in general. So that's youth, adult and so forth. So we think that's a pretty good mix.

1:57:44 So also in the packet here you can see attachment B is the budget. This budget includes both the winter ice rink operations and the summer rec zone operations. If you have any questions on that we can kind of double back. But this schedule here, attachment C, just gives you an idea of kind of what we talked about with our programming. So we really tried to break down going from kind of a two and a half hour session time, which is what it historically was before. That's kind of really what we looked at.

1:58:13 Down to a two-hour session or really for a lot of these individual programs going back to an hour time slot. So if you look at kind of Monday, we go a midweek lunch special for an hour and a half, then we go into the Future Stars, then we go into an ice skating program, then we go into the youth hockey program and then we go to adult hockey. So I mean it's really programmed aggressively for the community and conversely on Friday or Saturday, really it's predominantly all public skate with a little bit of first-time skate assist and a little bit of youth hockey early Saturday morning.

1:58:41 But again, you can see we're really trying to periodize the program based on the use of the facility. So that's kind of how that programming works. So again, just want to thank our staff for putting this together. I think it's going to be really exciting. And as best we can, the winter holiday schedule is just really a three-hour block. So once we get into the holidays, Christmas, MLK and Presidents, all that really means is you can see it down here right after holiday schedule.

1:59:10 We'll open at 12 till 3. We close half an hour to groom. We'll open from 3.30 to 6.30. We'll groom and open from 7 to 10. So super simple, right? Just a really easy program for our holiday skaters. Hopefully reduce any confusion anybody had in their program. And we'll also try and create kind of a weekly or dynamic schedule based on weather. Things will change, as we know. We'll try and post on the website. It might be kind of a Google dynamic calendar that you can kind of go into as well. So it's not just a static calendar.

1:59:39 That you'll see in the brochure. It'll actually be a dynamic calendar on the website. So if things do change, we can obviously make those changes and communicate to the public. That was an issue in previous years, right? So we're pretty excited about that. So that's the winter schedule. I've just provided additional information here in attachment D to the hockey program. So this is everything that Patrick and Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey are really expanding. We have, like I said, a facility use agreement with that group as well.

2:00:05 But doing great things to expand and really encourage our local kids to get involved in hockey. This is a really good, viable sport. They also receive youth sports funding from the town and recommend from the commission as well. I think they're doing great things in our community to provide that experience for our kids. And then the last one was just the presentation from last season. And again, we'll provide you the same information as we track throughout the season on that information as well.

2:00:35 So with that, really what we're looking for is any kind of consensus, comments, any directions from the Recreation Commission at this time. We'll also provide this time as per our agreement with the school district so they'll be able to see this program and schedule as well. We want to really keep them as a partner engaged in the operations of that facility and they really help us promote this facility through the school district. They're a great partner. I mean, that's really kind of our kid base is.

2:01:02 So we really think that's a great partnership to continue to engage with. So there you go. That's a really quick overview. But we're really excited about the season. Just quickly, we have Billy, who is...

2:01:23 Our parks manager just left, Warren, but Billy, who was with Train, is now on his own. He has his new business, so we're actually able to get someone more dedicated, more affordably, to our facility more frequently. So he's coming over mid-October, actually next week, to do a service on the chiller. They'll actually turn it on. We'll run it for a couple of days, see how it operates. We had a few kind of issues last year we're trying to get ahead of, and our plan at this time is to begin making ice on November 16th for the opening on the 27th.

2:01:53 And as we mentioned before, we're upgrading the concession room, all that kind of main building. The challenges we had before was with the skates, we had kind of a different way to kind of store and hang those skates versus the roller and inline skate. So we've come up with a hybrid that we think will work for both. So the staff right now have just pulled everything off the wall, painted it, and we're going to do it properly. That will kind of suffice for winter and summer. So if that facility gets moved over to the new location, we're ready to go.

2:02:19 We're also upgrading the concession booth area for food and beverage. We're just putting in kind of countertops, a bit more storage. As I said, we're kind of using US foods. We'll provide a little bit more of it, we think, a more winterized menu. Have some soups and things like that, warm goods, chicken nuggets, you know, for kids. At that facility, which we think would really help. And then the second point of sale will come up from Whitmore as well. We'll run, we'll have new display cases, new sandwich boards.

2:02:48 Just trying to think of all the things we're going there, fixing the heaters, things like that. But anyway, so we're ready hopefully for opening on November 27th if we get some culminating weather. So there we go. That concludes my presentation. Any questions? Thank you, Steve. Welcome. Questions? Come on. I have one question. I'll go up real quick. So you mentioned the...

2:03:15 The holidays schedule. Yep. I see we have some tournaments that are also occurring over the holidays. Yep. And those will occur prior to opening. Correct. Yeah, so as we've done in the past, you know, tournaments get going about 7. We don't operate at 6. So 7 o'clock is our first start time. It's just not light enough. It's too cold. We need that hour to kind of get the facility ready. So we'll get going at 7. We might push back some of the opening until about 1.

2:03:43 Just depending on how the games have gone, you know, you're always going to get overages with time and so forth with teams. But that's our plan at this time. So it's kind of like a six-hour schedule from seven to one on those days. Fingers crossed for some, I don't know. It'd be nice eventually if we could get some of these tournaments onto non-peak weekends as well. It'd be really great. I know we don't have a lot of control over it when kids are out of school.

2:04:09 And it's difficult for us just because we don't have a roof and, you know, we're really at the whim of the weather and I think we had a roof, a longer season, we can kind of put these in, these kind of off-peak times, which is really where they should go. But I'm also following up on a conversation with LA Kings and Megan, she's kind of the programming lead at that facility and we'll obviously be looking at, as I mentioned last year, scheduling kind of an adult and a youth LA Kings hosted camp at the facility as well. We're just trying to put that in too.

2:04:38 As you can see, there's not a lot of time. We're already filling it up. I mean, that's really the goal of the facility. So, I mean, you can see if we extend this into a five-month operation, I mean, that's all we're really doing. We're just going to fill these spots with the tournaments. We'll push them out of the holidays, keep them available just for the holiday use, you know, and those type of things. And you can see we're filling it up pretty quickly already. But really good team. We're really excited. We're posting a couple of positions right now on the website. We had a couple of employees that chose not to come back.

2:05:07 So we're seeking additional employees for the ice rink. So we'll have our kind of template locked down by the end of October is our plan at this time. So here we go. Any other comments or questions? No, I think you guys are doing a great job taking, you know, every year and with your opportunities with the experience and including it. So I think that's great. On the budget, is there any way you guys can break out summer and winter with your new system that we can break out even if it's best? We can give you that. Yeah, absolutely. As you know, the summer budget, $20,000.

2:05:39 When a budget's $229,000. So you can see it's a $249,000 budget. Really the blending, honestly, Commissioner, is in temporary wages, a little bit in salaries, recreation services, recreation supplies, and other things as well. But we can get to that detail for sure. I guess as I'm looking at that, I'm looking from a MLR reconciliation perspective, and that even though it's $20,000, it should be split out so that we can see where those measure are, dollars are, and new dollars are being used.

2:06:09 This is early for summer. Yeah, but we can do that. So with the new financial system, I'm hoping you can do that. We can do that. Yeah, absolutely. Thanks. We can do that. Excellent. Welcome. Very excited. You just need a consensus on that, right? Just if there's any consensus, directional comments from the Commission. Otherwise, we're just charging on and... Atta boy. Yeah. We've got to open as soon as we can. Yeah.

2:06:37 And like last year, if the facility's ready to go Thanksgiving or earlier on Wednesday, I mean, we'll get open, right? I mean, we're not going to just wait for Friday, so if it's there and the ice is good. We did have problems last year, as you know. We kind of painted it and Dennis got out there and then we got the wind and the leaves in it and kind of affected the integrity of the paint and the ice itself so they had to keep cutting it back and then anyway. It's warm. Fingers crossed. And it can't be snowing while you're doing it either, right? It's a little bit.

2:07:05 It's a little tricky. It's a little bit tricky. All right, cool. I think we should plan a lunch over there or something. Yeah. Yeah, lunch would be nice. All right. Great. Then let's move on to item number nine, our 2015 summer programming review. Yeah, thank you, Chair. So this was a great season. Probably, I would think, our best summer ever for the community parks and recreation department.

2:07:36 Staff did a phenomenal job. We had a lot of challenges. I pushed them on adding programs. I pushed them on adding different camps. Across the board, I believe we did really well. So I'm really excited. You can see really what we're looking for here as a recommendation is really just the same, just to provide any consensus recommendations, but also to convene our ad hoc committee.

2:08:01 As we move forward as we've done in the past. But just really quickly, I mean the background information here, so our overall participation grew by 32% as compared to last year and that corresponds to kind of our revenue number as well. We grew just participants in our summer camps by 39% and we've grown our camp business since 2010 by 117%. So really our...

2:08:27 Our mandate and our mission is to really connect with each and every community member. So again, you can see we're really being centrally focused on our youth, but you can see we're expanding into kind of infant programming, our three- to six-year-old programming. We're going to further expand into adults and our active adult demographic as well. I'll just run you through some of these numbers as well as we get through the presentation, but in this packet you can see we've got just the brochure. If you didn't get to see it this season, it went really well.

2:08:58 Feedback on comments and how we can kind of continue to improve that as well. We provided the new ActiveNet dashboard that we provided last year, so we'll kind of walk through that with you as well. We've got some just attendance financial numbers, comparisons, satisfaction surveys, and what we did this year was actually collated all the comments. So we went through each and every survey. We got 87 this year, about 59 last year, so the team's doing a better job of collating.

2:09:22 Collecting those. But we've included every survey comment as well and recommendation for next year. So that really kind of leads to a lot of our programming development. And then we break it down by facility. We'll quickly look at Whitmore Pool, Mammoth Rec Zone. Mammoth Rec Zone is still operating just on a limited capacity. We'll kind of shut that down on October 30 and transition fully to winter. And then just a few advertising examples.

2:09:49 Just roll to attachment B, which is the ActiveNet dashboard. So this provides real quantitative data on what our customers are buying and where they're buying it and how they're buying it. So you can see just quickly those top line numbers, online revenues 50%, offline is 50%. So really the goal there is to obviously increase the online revenue portion of that number. Growth was 2% up. Total revenue growth was negative 4%.

2:10:21 Yeah, I'm looking into that. So online went up. So that just means that more of our programs really went through offline sales. So a lot of the adults. So this is only what was sold online. Right. Exactly. So if we grow adult business, they really, you know, you'd think they would really embrace technology. You would think. They sometimes struggle. And I'll talk about a program that we want to investigate moving forward. We think it will help that.

2:10:50 But you can see just general kind of numbers that talk about activity registration. The difference with facility hours, we're still booking the same number of facility hours, if not more, that we just weren't able to, when this report was generated, we weren't able to get all the facility use hours that we booked for our youth sports team in the system. So we're doing that kind of back-ending as we go now as we kind of commit to those facilities. But that's really the difference there.

2:11:17 You can see the mix with business online versus total, point of sale as well. You can see kind of point of sale grew dramatically as you can see so point of sale has really worked out more at the pool and summer at the rec zone. Customer demographics, this just gives you an idea of our customers, how often they log in and we break them down by age that you can see as well. The repeat customer information is really important for us because it really tells us who our kind of

2:11:47 Top customers are, who are really key VIP customers are, who's really using the system a lot and who do we really want to kind of encourage and develop kind of loyalty programs with. And you can see two to three times, you know, 48 people kind of logged in and booked their programs online, six, you know, did it four to five times. And interesting, last year we didn't really have any or only had one, but, you know, three people booking, you know, six to ten times online. So there's really some great customers that are embracing technology.

2:12:17 That we really want to kind of encourage. The next slide over there on the next page just talks about, which is a really good number for us. So this really tracks utilization of our programs, really gives you an idea of how those programs are being utilized and filled, which is what they call fill rate. So these programs have a maximum number of enrollments. So this gives you an idea of, say, for instance, aquatics. We filled, you know, those camps, you know, 36%.

2:12:45 So there were still 60% of those swim lessons that were unfilled. As opposed to camps, our summer camps, you can see, were 80%, almost up to 80% were utilised. As you know, some in our most popular signature camps are over-utilised. You know, wilderness skate camps, they're all over the utilisation number. So we have a waiting list and we do our best to get them on. So if the maximum number for wilderness camp is 20, we'll end up probably taking 25.

2:13:12 Conversely, if we look at our smaller programs like tennis, basketball, youth theatre, they're underutilised. So that kind of gives you an average of 80%. And then as we move towards membership data and demographics, so if we had a membership program, and this is just another module with ActiveNet, so if we did look at moving towards creating a year-round multi-use facility, we could actually create a membership program.

2:13:41 And this is how you would run that program through them. So this would be able to tell you really who your members are. So like Snow Creek would run a module like this. So we would kind of look at this as we move forward for kind of a year-round facility management and certainly our community centre if you had year-round programs and facilities that folks were utilising. The next one is, again, you've seen this before. We try not to change too many of the forms for you, but attachment C is essentially just an overview of each and every camp that we've offered.

2:14:11 With the corresponding dates, the number of participants, the revenue that we collect, our labour expenses, operating expenses. Again, these are just direct costs. It doesn't incorporate the admin or the overhead to these programs. We can certainly go and run those numbers, but again, from a benchmark, from year after year, it just gives us enough analysis and understanding of how these programs are running right now. And again, just want to thank Liz did a lot of work on this. Liz was our staff assistant. Missy kind of built this program last year.

2:14:41 So all the templates were built and then with the new, actually the finance system was a lot easier to kind of go in and pull these numbers already. So it took probably half the time to complete this work than it did the previous year when we really had no system, really very limited financial support. So new accounting software has certainly helped us put this together for you. But again, it gives us a good idea of what successful camps, what are really overutilised camps, where we can kind of increase our efforts in our marketing and promotions.

2:15:09 You can see the big change here was our mini summer camps, so that generated 109 more visits, just with a 3- to 6-year-old market, and generated another almost $8,000 in revenue for the department. And you can see our summer camps run pretty well. If you just look at that category alone, we're generating $46,000 of revenue just from that business, and we're tracking and controlling expenses, so we're still netting, just on direct costs only, about $10,000.

2:15:40 Youth and Team Programs is just below that. Little Sluggers, we ran that program. You can see that's just a small program. It's run by just John and the volunteer base. Gymnastics, we ran during the spring session. Again, we're still trying to find a year-round gymnast. You can see that program, you know, still very successful. So once that program gets going again, and hopefully we can look at a newer expanded facility at some point, that'll really help. And then Kyle really got going with drop-in tennis sessions now.

2:16:10 Predominantly adult was really where the attention was on the drop-in tennis sessions. Pretty small for youth tennis sessions, but we still had Kyle out there. He still made himself available for the kids. What we're looking at next year is can we incorporate tennis into kind of an adventure camp or into kind of a wilderness camp into those programs so we can introduce these kids to just more than what we're really currently doing. We can really utilise our staff and our professional base to give them more opportunities and experiences.

2:16:39 In the Eastern Sierra. Adult programs, so again, the biggest change here, drop-in tennis is really expanding. Kyle did a great job. So this includes Tuesday and Thursday afternoons, and it doesn't include the Sunday socials, but Kyle also makes himself available, and he heads over to community courts on Sunday and plays with Sandy and the group, which I think is great, and we really encourage Kyle to do that, and it's really kind of creating, I believe, or re-energizing a program that's...

2:17:07 We're really focused on and really important to us to continue with. I don't know if Sandy did the doubles tennis camp and socials. She probably had your knee operation. Yeah, Sandy's back next year. But that was a really exciting program. We put this one on the schedule, didn't know how it was going to go, but we really wanted to kind of expand into kind of more, you know, adult, active adult programs. So a doubles tennis camp and social.

2:17:34 Kyle said we had about eight people that were there, but we had a lot of people kind of coming and going. So who really thinks we can kind of look at expanding that next year as well and maybe offering a couple more programs for adult tennis players. So that's great. We're currently running our drop-in women's program, drop-in street hockey. It's kind of off and on with the adults. The kids has really kind of taken off. I don't know why. Adult Softball League ran the same number as previously operated from last year.

2:18:02 We didn't run an adult soccer league and we didn't run the dodgeball league this year and that was really just due to kind of resource issues that we experienced so we're looking at better ways to kind of structure the department to better kind of deliver those programs. Adult softball tournament, that still went on so we contract that tournament so we just receive a dollar figure per player is how that kind of works but we do have kind of expenses associated with it so we want to kind of look at that program and how we can best provide

2:18:33 Services of that group in the future. And adult indoor soccer, so we grew that indoor soccer league. We had last year an indoor soccer and outdoor, and we hope to run the indoor soccer league on the new gym floor this winter, so we're really looking forward to that. But adult programming did expand as well, so we're pretty excited about that. And you can see the numbers at the bottom, total program participants over just summer. This was kind of just during that period of time.

2:18:59 You know, it's just over 1,652 people. And you can kind of see the corresponding, you know, revenue numbers across the bottom there as well. And then we kind of track town cost participant, and that gives you that little number below that town cost participant, gives you what, that's the revenue number that we take in per participant. So it gives you an idea of what we take and what it costs us to operate as well. So there are those metrics, so they really help as we move forward.

2:19:30 The next one, hopefully this makes sense to you. I put the graph on the bottom just to kind of help validate some numbers. But this is really just looking at 2015 versus 2014. You can see we grew youth summer camps by almost 40% there. Youth programs went down just from really our gymnastics program. That's kind of the bulk of those numbers. And adult programming went up correspondingly as well. So that gives you kind of just a one-page snapshot of how the summer went, which was great.

2:19:59 I don't know if you had a chance to look at the customer survey and a lot of the comments, but we love reading these comments. We really take them to heart. We broke them down by comments and recommendations. But just this first page here just gives you an understanding of one. 87 surveys were collected, which is a 47% increase from last year. We obviously want to get more than just 87, but that's a pretty good sample size. 79% of those surveyed were residents.

2:20:27 Which was up from last year. One in five are from outside Mono County, right, 20%, which is still pretty consistent with numbers from years past, went down a little bit. First time users and increasing satisfaction. So the numbers you can see here compared to last year on those benchmark questions that we ask our participants. As you can see, availability information, customer service, registration process.

2:20:56 Cost value for money is obviously really high. They value the pricing structure that we're able to provide these camps and programs very affordably, but still provide quality of instruction. I think that's really important to note that not only we can provide very affordable programs, but the quality of instruction is still high. So we're still delivering great programs through our great people. Condition of fields, we're always improving on that. It's always kind of a detriment of the weather and how much water we have to actually keep the grass growing.

2:21:24 But you can see the overall number there, a 4.59 is certainly higher than a 4.32 from overall satisfaction, so we're really happy with that. So that's really good to see when you, I mean these are hard numbers to really kind of excel, but when you see more programs delivered but increasing satisfaction. So I mean it's just a great overall pat on the back for our team and our staff. The numbers on the back side of the customer survey just really talk about how people find us and what

2:21:54 Marketing Communication Vehicles are important to them. So you can kind of see some changes there. Again, town website referral, always the highest numbers and always will be. But interestingly to see radio was a big jump from last year. You know, that's a pretty big increase from, you know, two to almost 10%. Recreation Guide went down a little bit. And social media, I was kind of surprised. It's really bizarre, isn't it, in the age of social media.

2:22:22 People use that less than what they've done before. So whether that means that we have to do a better job with it, I'm not too sure. So we'll have to dig in a little bit more as well. And everybody that wanted to be heard or had a strong interest in staying involved, we did communicate with. I've reached out to a lot of those folks that had some comments on the programs. We've been engaging those folks as well. So really encourage folks to, you know, write in and we will respond. Absolutely. And then we add them to our mailing list so they can stay connected.

2:22:50 I don't really want to get too much into the facility, the comments. This is kind of the role of, if you want to ask some questions at the end, but the ad hoc committee can kind of look at as well in more detail. But I just broke them down into just general comments and recommendations. For each facility, you can see the Whitmore Pool, general comments for our youth camps, recommendations for our youth camps. And again, all these recommendations, you know, last year was all about kind of the youth and the mini camps and those type of things and tennis.

2:23:17 And you can see we're able to take those recommendations, actually put them into programs and make them successful. So we really kind of value all of the comments and recommendations we receive because we do act upon them and we do able to, if they make sense, implement them as well. So that's all the comments there. So really good comments. We really value those. We'll just quickly move on to the pool.

2:23:42 Just overall, so you can see I just provide just a kind of a summary of the pool visits. You can see it was very similar to last year actually. It was almost the same. A little bit more on visits, a little bit more on revenue. We did increase our pool pass programs. That's probably the change with the revenue. But everything's pretty consistent across the board. Good to see those numbers not go down. But you can see the changes. We bring more of our kids to the programs.

2:24:10 Certainly a lot more groups to that program. We grew our swim lesson business. Probably what decreased from years past and is always a fluctuating number and a big user and a big impact to this is really the swim team. How many kids can they get on their program? So we're going to sit down with the swim team again and hopefully this week and really kind of debrief for them as well on the season and how they saw their operations and their programming and their support and their schedule and how we can kind of improve that next year as well.

2:24:39 Because we did open a week earlier for that swim team this year. You can see the average daily attendance. You know, it's pretty consistent. From last year, it went up a little bit. And these are just based on the number of operating days divided by the number of attendees. Gives you that number there. You can see pool visits by month. You can see everything was an increase apart from July. July last year was a considerable month for the pool.

2:25:08 2,272 visits in 2014, just under 1,800 this year, but you can see we grew visits in May because we opened earlier, grew visits in June, and grew visits in August, and then September's about average. It's always pretty slow. We only have that one week in September and our lap swim is pretty much done, which is kind of a shame. It gets too dark and kids are back in school.

2:25:34 Just a quick look at our product mix and this is not a lot of changes when I was looking from last year. You can see predominantly our rec swim business, lap swim business and swim lessons. So kind of on the right hand side is kind of really what we really control from a programming point of view and then on the left side is our swim team, day camps and groups. So that gives you an idea of 60 to 66% is kind of what we really control, swim team, day camps, groups.

2:26:03 Showers, Non-Swimmers is about the other third of the business. Again, we didn't really change any of the main pricing this year. Really, the only thing that went up was just our Season Pass program. But all the drop-in, walk-in business stayed the same. The next page, quickly, this is the financial summary that we provide the county. So this basically gives you a look at what it costs to operate the Whitmore Pool and the Whitmore Recreation over a one-year, fiscal year period from June 30.

2:26:35 through to July 1, or July 1 through June 30. You can see it cost us last year, last fiscal year, just over $108,000 to operate and $111,000 to provide maintenance of the Whitmore Recreation Area, which kind of excludes the track. So the track really is not part of this budget. And then you see we receive a subsidy from the county of just over $100,000, and that's split on those percentages back into

2:27:05 Those departments. So the pool would receive 49% of the 100,000 and Whitmore would receive the 51% of the reimbursement from the county. So that's how that works. Just moving on to the rec zone. So we really stepped up the rec zone. We want to try and provide a real broad array of activities at the rec zone considering its challenges. Again, Patrick started as our rec zone site coordinator this year, really kind of enhanced the

2:27:37 Hockey Community, really got them engaged and used as well and I think he did a really, really good job at that. Not only providing, you know, the other amenities, we had basketball set up, the volleyball, the badminton, we had the beanbag toss and all those type of things, but it's a tough facility when it gets pretty hot out there and certainly we suffered earlier on when we opened up in June and July when it gets wet and rains. Yeah, I mean it's just really kind of unusable.

2:28:03 And our camps. But a big use for camps. So if you look at our numbers, just this one-page financial, you can see camps is a big user of that facility. So, you know, 600 camps. Predominantly, most of our camps start there, and they certainly end there. So that's really where we kind of meet. We get everybody coordinated. They can play. They can get on the equipment. They can get on the skate ramps. We can give them food. They can get to the toilet. It's more convenient for the parents to drop off and pick up. So it's a really good location for that.

2:28:32 And you can see that facility, we're still going, but right now just kind of the operations, 959 visits, a little bit more than last year of 741, and a little bit down last year, the year before in 2013 was our first year when we opened. Pre the bowling alley was about over 1,000, 1,100 on that first year. So we got it back, we climbed up to some good numbers, really kind of focusing on who our users are.

2:28:57 And you can see we rented the facility more to groups. These were to the Bishop hockey teams came up. We still had a couple of families that actually come and host their event there. They bring 30, 40 of their family there and take over the rink for the afternoon, which is great. So the facility rental certainly increased from years past as well. We just break down the visits by month. Just on that next little kind of graph there you can see as well. Orange is the new year if you've got...

2:29:26 Colour Graph, 2015. So you can see we're driving visitation higher than certainly last year, month by month. So that was good. And just really simple pie chart just shows that emissions in Brental is 43%, our food's 12%, and we generated 45% of the revenue from, gives you that idea. And that's really it. That just really shows you just a few of advertising examples that I printed off. Couldn't get some in colour, the printer wouldn't work properly, but.

2:29:57 Really great summer, really thrilled with staff. It was probably our biggest summer of staffing ever. We had a few challenges, weather-wise, staff-wise, but just want to thank Beth and John for a great effort. We had really some, probably the best crew at the pool we've had, the best group at the rec zone, all two of them. And our slew of...

2:30:19 And our slew of counsellors, and a lot of our counsellors, you know, come back year after year, which we're really thankful for, and our summer intern program, we started this last year, and our summer interns grew from two last year to probably six this year, and summer interns are our school kids, they're our high school kids that we recruit from the school, we get ages from sophomore, I think it was our youngest, up to, maybe freshman, yeah, so freshman up to seniors that help and assist with our counsellors, so it really helps us keep the number, you know, the participant,

2:30:48 Can't Council a Ratio Down, give some more oversight of our programs and looking ahead for next year, really want to kind of drill into that more as well. But just overall, great program. Moving forward, we're really looking to now take a lot of this information, meet with the ad hoc committee, if we can kind of look at some dates, come back to the commission, potentially in November, but probably December, with kind of an overview of our 216 menu.

2:31:13 And how that kind of looks. And then we can, once we kind of formalize that menu of offerings, then we kind of look at the structure of the department, the ratio of our counselors versus interns, what type of staffing we need, and then we can kind of start to build the budgets and so forth. So with that, any questions? Atta boy. It's a lot. Sorry, it's a lot, but there you go. And to Stephanie and John and everyone as well. I'll just put the numbers together.

2:31:46 I heard so much really great feedback this summer. Thank you. It was just really successful, so I really can't commend you guys enough. It's fantastic. Yeah, really exciting. So with that, if you can maybe look at the calendar or send me some information if we want to convene that little ad hoc subcommittee group. Ad hoc consisted of Betsy and Sean. Sean, and if that's... I'm okay with that same ad hoc committee. I'm fine with it. If you guys are okay with still doing that.

2:32:17 Yeah, we're good. I did talk to Clayton. I think he was happy to have us continue as well. So I'm good if you are. Yep. I really enjoy that. I think that's a really great process. I really enjoy talking to staff. I think we had some really good ideas come out of it last year. I think for next year we might want to include, I think we had a lot of people sign up for camps because of our open house. So that's another one we could track. Great. But yeah, I'm sure we could put together some meetings. Any other questions or comments?

2:32:47 Great, thank you. So what staff will do is just put together some dates, send it to the committee and see if we can kind of sit down and maybe schedule a couple of meetings and keep them to an hour, an hour and a half and value your time and keep this moving forward. But thank you. Sounds great. You're welcome. Thank you. All right, move on to Commissioner Reports. Sean? I don't have anything this week, this month. All right, Bill, welcome back. Thank you. My report is just in a way of thank yous.

2:33:16 I have been unable to attend for two months for health reasons. And Betsy has been great with her time and coming over and keeping me on top of what everyone's been doing and keeping me apprised of the situation. And I want to thank her. That is absolutely great. I had my first outing last weekend. I went and camped at McGee Creek. And if you guys haven't gone out and taken in the fall colors yet, Upper McGee is spectacular and all over the county. So, you know, we live here for these times. Get out there and enjoy them.

2:33:48 My report would have been on MLR, but Rich pretty much covered all of that, so I am on the board again for another two years. Congratulations. Yeah, I've just been attending a lot of meetings, MLR, Multi-Use Facility Task Force, I was at the last council meeting, just starting to talk about the Christmas tree lighting with staff and partners, and finally...

2:34:19 Have we said it tonight? We'll have a report next month on that. And also just wanted to say the Husky Pup Bun Run at the elementary school last Friday, very successful. So thank you to everyone for it's a great community event. And it's so cool because knowing that Terry was, you know, started it basically and just seeing how that's grown is really, really cool. So thank you to everyone for that.

2:34:46 All right. Do we have any requests for agenda items? I know, Stu, do you want to go through? We'll have the CIP and major maintenance in November. Yeah, we'll start talking about that as well. Multi-Use Facility, that's kind of a standing item. We'll just keep that on the agenda. We'll bring back those kind of applications to the MLR special event and event programming process coming up. And then if we have any updates on the summer programming, we'll bring that forward as well. Yep.

2:35:21 Yeah, I think that would be great. to have that come back because that should be the top tier recommendation that's going to go to Kinske. I'm planning to attend. Yeah. Commissioner, we, just Vice Chair, so we keep the executive report on the agenda now moving forward. Are you okay? If that's, that was kind of the direction we got from the Chair and I think that provides the Commission. Absolutely. I think it's really helpful. Just really want to make sure that we're staying connected. There's good communication. Right.

2:35:57 So that was kind of a go there. Thank you. So any requests for anything else? That sounds like a pretty full meeting. Yeah. All right. I would entertain a motion to adjourn if we have nothing further. I'll second that. In favor? I'll vote for it. We're adjourned. Thank you very much, everyone. Thank you.