TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2015

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 40 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

490 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Go, Johnny. Go, Johnny, go.

0:57 I'm going to call to order the regular meeting for the town council, town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:56 Wednesday, October 21st, 2015, 6 p.m. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked Councilmember Bacon to lead us in the pledge to see you. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

2:28 Thank you, Joe. We now open the floor for public comments. For any items that are not on the agenda for tonight, please come forward. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Council, staff, citizens. Quick reminder, Veterans Day is Wednesday, November 11th. We're doing our celebration at Mammoth Lakes Fire Department, Station No. 1 on Main Street, starting at 9 o'clock in the morning. Give thanks and celebrate our heroes. You're all invited to attend. Thank you very much. Thank you, Rich. Good evening, Council.

3:13 Shira Dubrovner with the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. As you know, we have a theater company in town that produces year-round programming. Part of that programming is giving back to the community. We have right now of Mice and Men playing, and what we did with this specific production, we contacted the high schools and offered them

3:33 Half price tickets to all high school students. And we've had over 200 students so far book their tickets and also come and attend. Next up, starting November 1st, we have Theater for Young Audience, which is Go Dog Go. It's a production of a show targeted for a young audience. We've also done the same thing where we have contacted all the elementary schools in the area.

3:56 And we offer that program for free. So there is no charge to the students. They come in on a bus. They come see the show. We teach them about theater etiquette. We also send a theater...

4:06 An educator's resource guide to the teachers so they can implement curriculum activities for them to tie into the play that they just saw. We have over 1,200 students coming this year. I'm really proud of that. And that is growing. We're hoping to get Bridgeport, Benton, and Colville next year so we can even up the numbers next year. And those programs are really due to our donors, our sponsors, and the sponsorship from Measure U. So I want to thank the public and thank the town council and the town of Mammoth Lakes.

4:36 Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Bruce Woodward, local architect. I'm here tonight to request of town council a workshop on the building department in the town of Mammoth Lakes and how it's functioning and how it could function in the future.

5:11 Because right now it's not functioning really at all. It's serious problems. I think that it would be really good to get members of the, one, council, staff, and members of the construction community involved to see if we can figure out a way with the limited resources that the town has to have a building department that will function. Because right now it's kind of crawling.

5:39 It's causing a lot of problems out there. So, that's it. Okay. Mr. Mayor, can we see if there's consensus to do that? Sure. I would be in favor of it. Of having some kind of a workshop? Absolutely. There you go. Definitely in favor. Direct staff, too. Dan, can we work on that? Put that together, yeah. We'll work on that. Thanks, Bruce. Anybody else like to come forward? Okay, seeing none, I'll close the public comment and move on to...

6:09 Correspondence, we received a letter from the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District dated September 30, 2015, regarding the Great Basin wildfire smoke impacts. Does any council have any comments?

6:22 If I may, you know, being the representative on this board, it was part of this decision and we've had previous testimony about the impacts, especially the economic impacts of the smoke. So I'd like to, if it's okay with other council members to work with Dan to pull together a letter to send in support and also to have it taken to the next League of Cities, California League of Cities meeting for consideration by other agencies.

6:49 That's fine. Great letter, by the way. I thought the letter was very well done. It's amazing that a letter by committee can actually come out so well. Oh, yeah. Very nice. The only thing I would add is that Representative Berryhill and someone from Congressman Cook's office is going to be on Friday. Right. And Congressman Cook, when he's here before, he advised that issues that can be framed in terms of public safety are things that they've kind of put a priority on.

7:16 As we develop this thing further, getting it on that line, because obviously these are federal issues. Correct. And as you see in the letter, Dr. Johnson has been very interested in the health and safety aspects of it as well. Someone's going to mention this to him on Friday? I'm planning on going. I could unless someone else was going to go. All right. Dan, is this on the radar of the league currently?

7:42 Okay. I mean, I think that's a good logical next step. Yeah. All right. So you'll work with Dan, you'll work with Joe for signature? Okay. Perfect. Great. Well, for your signature. Next agenda, hopefully. Okay, great. Okay, moving on to Councilmember Reports. Are there any additions to the agenda? Okay. All right.

8:11 Colin, you want to go first? Sure. Thank you. I don't have too much to add as far as formal stuff, a lot of informal meetings over the last couple weeks, but all of us here on October 12th, we attended another council strategic session. I feel like that is moving forward really well, and I'm excited to see kind of what comes out as the final output from that effort. But I think as we're starting to change the way that we...

8:39 Do our government and we've got all these strategic partners in our NGOs. I think it's a very worthwhile exercise to to do some visioning and make sure we're all on the same page. So as Shira mentioned already, the play is going to be going on of Mice and Men through the weekend. So I'm going to be attending tomorrow night, which I'm excited about. And then the last thing I had is.

9:05 MLH, and I sit on that board as the council appointee. We are going to be doing our strategic planning session on November 12th. So that's going to be kind of an all-day retreat. It's going to be facilitated by Michael Ward as well. So that will be starting on November 12th at 9 a.m., kind of a full-day deal. So anybody that wants to engage in that process and have some input as far as...

9:33 How MLH develops our strategy moving forward. Feel free to attend. Thanks.

9:41 Yes, last Friday I attended the ESTA board meeting and we actually had several items that I think the other council members in our community would be interested in. We, in concept, agreed to be a partner including a small bit of funding for the North Sierra Highway specific plan. It's Highway 395 from where it turns by the fairgrounds and comes up, which does have an impact on transit through there as well. We also finalized the

10:10 Joint Powers Agreement that had come through our board as well as the other agencies that will allow for any of the entities to appoint an individual from the public at large. If you remember with the Mono County Board of Supervisors, there was a conflict of interest, so they had not been fully represented on the ESTA board for a while, so this will change that.

10:33 And then also approved the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Agreement for this winter, and they're all ready to go. And again, as we discussed in our strategy sessions, STA has been very flexible about recognizing some additional changes to the early winter routes, much like we did at the end of the season last year. So it's constantly evolving, and they're very well equipped to respond to our needs.

11:03 In almost an instant. And that's it. Thanks, Joe. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I journeyed from our dear home off to Jackson Hole at my own expense to attend the SHIFT Conference. This is a conference where conservation meets adventure. And I think everybody in this room can safely say, why, gee, I'm a conservationist, I'm a recreationist. This is about bringing these

11:34 Communities together. It's a very exciting, very interesting thing that's happening nationally at this point, bringing the conservation community, the recreation community together to start addressing public land issues. This also happens to be part of a $650 billion, billing with a B, outdoor recreation industry, which is tied in with a national outdoor recreation movement.

11:59 The Office of Management and Budget is now going to start analyzing this sector as part of the U.S. national economy. I mean, this is the thing that's getting a lot of traction. So a lot of folks from the senior levels of the Forest Service, Wilderness Society, Recreation Community, very interesting session. Also, the strategic session, I'm looking forward to, as we get into the subsequent meetings, how this is going to get implemented, how we get some tangible results out of this. I'm confident we'll see that. I attended the Broadband Task Force.

12:28 And working with the Mayor on that, I think we're looking forward to a presentation maybe back to Council in December, which will be pretty interesting coming into that. How do we really leverage Digital 395? Participate in the Sierra Cascades Dialogue, again, as part of the Forest Planned Revision Process, focusing on the PCT, Wild and Scenic Rivers, Wilderness Identification, Evaluation, and Species of Conservation Concern and Forest Planned Revision as a function of the Forest Planned Revision Process, which is

12:54 Kind of taking its time at this point. Attended the TOT Task Force with Councilmember Richardson. Very interesting group. Really interesting get-together with those folks. Attended the power lunch at the Chamber. Thanks a lot, Craig, in the Chamber for bringing Carl Roboto down here. Really interesting high-level overview of opportunities in the region. I think some of the rest of us were there.

13:16 Today we had a very interesting meeting with Morrow County staff, Craig Schmidt again in the Mountain Lab talking about shared use opportunities in Mammoth Lakes. Again, how we bring technology to start to revitalize and do new things with our existing physical environment. A lot of opportunities I think that will probably tie into the Broadband Task Force at some point. A lot of very interesting opportunities there. And finally I attended a meeting this afternoon with the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative and the leadership team of the International Forest talking about forest plan revision.

13:45 The Framework for Sustainable Recreation ties right back into the SHIFT Conference and the really enormous opportunities we have for outdoor recreation in common here in the eastern Sierra. So that was it. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I, of course, attended the strategic meeting, the TOT Task Force meeting with John, but I'd like to just take a couple of minutes and talk about what's going on with TOT. In light of Measure Z, everybody thinks that...

14:17 Everything stopped. That's not the case. Our DOT enforcement is continuing. As a matter of fact, the Cassell programming, our financial software programming, is almost there for our DOT task force. It's about two weeks out. Letters have gone out to people in the resort area to see if their homes

14:41 Are eligible or they would want to make their homes eligible and get business licenses for rental. We got, as my understanding, seven, if that's the right number, seven new people to sign up and get their business licenses. So I think that's an exciting number. We continue to improve our data collection, which is a very integral part going forward of how to do enforcement.

15:06 Our quality of life ordinance letter has gone out to everybody. We're starting to get responses on that. Some of them pretty exciting, others not so exciting. But it is something that we as a council and as a town and as a community have stepped forward with and it'll help us do our TOT enforcement. And last but not least, we did our outreach to Airbnb and we've contacted them.

15:35 And they are going to try and, you know, figure out how to work with our town so that in the future they might start collecting the tax. So enforcement goes on. So I just want to make sure that, you know, we've been told that we're not doing enforcement. We are doing enforcement. I want people to know that. We're actively out there doing it. So thank you. Thank you.

16:03 I attended our monthly air group meeting Thursday, October 15th. I have nothing to report out on that meeting at this time. I also attended Mono County Supervisors' meeting yesterday, my first one that I've attended. I touched on our record summer TOT. I plan to do a summer recap of the record summer TOT after we have our September numbers in. That should be very shortly. I also touched base on our GA ramp construction out at the airport.

16:30 And we got support from the county to help us do that project. We're going to be starting that next summer and complete that. I'll touch base on that. We're on track for 18-19 for our new terminal to be completed. Went over joint road projects, park and rec joint funding, broadband, talked about broadband, EFID participation. Moving forward with our flow agreement on our solid waste that's going to be coming forward in November, December. Back to council.

16:57 Cooperative work through LTC. It's a model for the state. The processes we see driving cooperative projects in the town, county, such as Main Street, Convict, Rock Creek, Airport Road are all great examples. Also attended our monthly, well not monthly, our special MLT strategic meeting yesterday. We're really starting to focus on looking how the entity drives more visitation.

17:23 Thank you.

17:50 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. I have two items. The first one is to let the council and the public know that the town has been re-designated as an attainment area for air quality, which means we meet the air quality standard that the federal government has set aside or has set out. A lot of thanks to Bill Taylor and Jen Daugherty who prepared the air quality management plan, which allowed this re-designation. We did send out a press release about that last week.

18:16 So that's pretty exciting. And the other item I have is we are working on a floor area ratio update to our zoning code. We are working on the EIR right now, and we expect the draft EIR to be out in December. And that's all I have. Great. Thank you. Thank you.

18:37 Grady Dutton Public Works. Just one quick item. If you've been to the airport lately, you know that in the passenger drop-off and pickup area across the street to the north, there's an area that has been used sometime for that purpose. It was dirt, basically. It's been used like that for years. We took the opportunity just this week, in fact, to go out, grade that out a little bit, get some grindings and put them down. It's a small project. It's just a few hundred square feet, but I think it'll make a big difference, especially during the winter when all the buses and shuttles and...

19:07 And everybody else are dropping off there. So next time you're out there, just take a quick look across the street. Our crews did a very quick job. I think they did it Monday, Tuesday, done and out of there. Great. Thank you. Thanks, Grady. Thank you. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council members. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission. Just wanted to give you a quick report from our last commission meeting on Tuesday, October 13th.

19:36 The Commission did take action on the multi-use facility item that is before you later this evening, but I'll reserve my comments until that portion of the agenda. So the Commission, in other news, we continue to engage with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, particularly on top-tier project readiness and development, and I'd like to thank MLR Executive Director Rich Spatia for his regular reports to the Commission.

19:59 We also reviewed this winter's operating plan for the Mammoth Ice Rink. It looks really great. We have continued to build our program there. And we really appreciate our community partners who are actively engaged in the success of the facility. At your last council meeting, I briefly mentioned the Parks and Recreation Department's successful summer.

20:19 And since the commission quite literally applauded our department staff at our meeting, well deserved, I wanted to share some data with the council tonight to show how the department delivered their best summer ever for our community. So this summer featured the addition of new preschool camps and a new schools out, girl power, and aquatics camps. And we also hosted a new spring recreation open house.

20:47 Our summer camps have grown 117% since 2010. Overall participation in summer programs is up 32% over last year. We had a 39% increase in youth camp participants since 2014 and an 84% increase in summer adult participation compared to last year. We also collected more surveys this year with excellent feedback and overall satisfaction.

21:16 On a five-point scale, those surveys, even with additional surveys, increased from 4.32 to 4.59. So we seem to have some very happy customers. And the commission's ad hoc programming committee, of which I am a member, will be meeting with staff to begin reviewing offerings for 2016. And just a couple other items. Our youth advisory committee of local high school students will reconvene this Friday.

21:44 The Commission is eager to work with that group to develop teen-specific programming along with receiving additional feedback for our programs and facilities. And our next Recreation Commission meeting is on Tuesday, November 3rd at 9 a.m. here in Sweet See. Any questions? Nice work. Thank you. I'll follow Betsy. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. I'm just going to talk about a great Halloween party, a haunted roller rink for our elementary age students. It's Friday, October 30th.

22:18 5 to 8 p.m., so come along, have a spooky good time. It's only $5 for all the elementary age children. It's free for any adults to come along and enjoy the activities. A lot of good fundraisers from our local groups, including Mammoth Lakes Hockey. So we've got flyers at the back if folks just want to grab that. And then the only thing that Betsy forgot to mention was we open the ice rink Friday, Thanksgiving, November 27th. There we go. So the skate's ready. That's all I have. Thank you, sir. Thank you. Thank you, sir.

22:49 Okay, I'm going to move on to introductions, item two, introduction of new police department record supervisor, Crystal Stewart. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Town Council. It's my pleasure tonight, and I brought the wrong thing now, to talk about the person we just hired as the record supervisor. This is Crystal Stewart. She's a local resident here, graduated from Sierra High School, and now I'm testing my memory here. She attended...

23:23 Alan Hancock College and received her dispatch degree there for the California State Post, which is police officer standards and training.

23:31 She also attended Cerro Coso College where she received an associate's degree with honors in administration of criminal justice. We stole her from the mountain. It's our second steal from the mountain. Sorry. They lost our game. But it was an arduous process that she went through and several great applicants. And I have to thank Sarah Vigilante for the effort she put into working with us to get us fully staffed at this point.

23:58 Here's Crystal Stewart. She'll want to say a thing or two, not much, but my staff and I, who are most of them here, really want to welcome her to the town, welcome to our team, and we look forward to it. So, Crystal Stewart.

24:19 Thank you, everybody, for the nice welcome. Today was my first day. I already feel incredibly welcomed to the crew. And I basically just want to say thank you to the Town of Mammoth Lakes, to the Athletics Police Department, and the Town Council for the amazing opportunity. Really looking forward to getting back and helping the citizens, all of them. So thank you very much. Thank you. Welcome.

25:02 Okay, we're going to move on to item number three, a public presentation update for Mono County. Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers. I'm Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors representing District 5 here in Mammoth Lakes, and I'm very pleased to be here to give an update on Mono County activities. One of the first one being that we are in a recruiting process for a new county administrative officer.

25:44 A round of finalist interviews next week. So I hope the next update we give you will actually include a new CAO standing here at the podium and not just me. So I'm always happy to come speak to council. And on the hiring front, we're also recruiting right now for a human resources director and hope to fill that position by the end of the year as well.

26:06 In other news, back in August, we passed our 15-16 fiscal year budget in a record one day of budget hearings, a balanced budget that included, as you know, I already reported to Council a small amount of youth sports funding that will be administered through the town, and also some funding for our local historical societies throughout the county and arts programs. And those funds have not, as far as I know, been distributed, but I'm sure

26:36 It's in the works. Other news, what I just passed out to you on the strategic planning front, the Board of Supervisors at our regular meeting last week approved for 2015-16 a set of focus areas for our strategic planning effort. As you may recall, back in January, we passed a strategic plan framework that included

27:01 Eight strategic directions. Four that really focused out to our communities and four that were inward to the county organization. We then held public meetings, went out to our regional planning advisory committees, came here to council, did a board workshop to gather ideas. Those actually fed into our budget process. We had to glue it together this year. The timing was a bit off. So basically,

27:31 We tried to feed our strategic planning effort into the budget, but really the way it worked is the budget is driving our plan this year. So our priority areas, our focus areas really include projects that were budgeted for, the departments we're already working on. And what we will do for the following year, or as follow up to these focus areas, is at our fiscal mid-year in January, we'll hold board meetings where department heads report on progress in each of the priority areas.

28:01 And then our board will hold a planning workshop where we set priorities for 16-17. So we will finally get that horse in front of the cart and have our priorities driving our budgeting process. And we will certainly be coming back here, engaging council, holding a town hall meeting in Mammoth also to get input on our...

28:21 Next year's plan. But I'm really excited that we took this first step in implementation in adopting priority areas and also this timeline that will now follow from now on in our plan. And for the public, that information is on our website, mono.ca.gov, if you want to look at those priority areas. Project news.

28:41 Mayor mentioned Rock Creek and Convict Lake Road projects. Happy to report that the Rock Creek project is mostly completed. There are no more road delays. So if anybody's looking to catch the last of the fall color up there in the next few days, or cyclists who want to get first tracks on that new bike lane, well, probably too late for first tracks, but get on that new bike lane, no more delays. So that's really exciting news. And the Convict Lake work is continuing, I believe, through the month. And many thanks to this.

29:11 The county was awarded $750,000 in a USDA, or a community, I'm getting my grants mixed up, a community development block grant.

29:28 That will fund projects throughout the county, including ADA improvements at county facilities and preschool facilities and programs in Benton and Bridgeport. So really great news. And our Economic Development Department worked with Craig and the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce on a USDA business support grant that will fund technical assistance programs for our local businesses here in Mammoth Lakes and throughout Mono County. And that will be offered through the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce.

29:58 So businesses throughout the county. So that's very exciting. Here locally and in my district, our fisheries commission approved some funding that came from the Fish and Wildlife Fine Fund. So if someone gets caught without a license or over their limit, they pay a fine. That funding actually can come back here locally to projects and equipment, in this case a project, which was a Mammoth Creek cleanup event that happened on October 10th.

30:27 We worked with Cal Trout and Friends of the Inyo, along with the Fisheries Commission, and volunteers planted over 100 willows along Mammoth Creek and removed some 500 pounds of trash. I personally removed some of the trash and destroyed a fire ring that was too close to the creek, which is a weird hobby that I have. 500 pounds of trash south and east of Mammoth Creek Park. So we hope that that will be an annual event done through the Fisheries Commission using

30:55 Fish and Wildlife Fine funds. And in other news, the Board of Supervisors at our first meeting in October gave direction to staff to move forward into the next phase of planning for Conway Ranch. And this is exciting. This will include a series of public meetings, at least one of which will take place here in Mammoth early in 2016. And that will result in a strategic facilities plan for the property. And that's a plan that's not...

31:24 You know, it's not a specific plan because Conway, of course, the county owns Conway Ranch. We are in a conservation easement on much of the property. So a strategic facilities plan will allow us to really decide and vision what activities, you know, are we going to have fish rearing or aquaculture there, what type of recreation will take place there. So that will be an exciting process starting early in 2016.

31:49 And our Emergency Medical Services Ad Hoc Committee continues to meet. This dedicated group has been meeting monthly since May to develop a set of priorities and program recommendations that will come to the Board of Supervisors sometime in 2016. And the intention here is to make this program cost-efficient, the program being our emergency medical services, cost-efficient service improvements and making EMS more sustainable.

32:19 And they're really putting a lot of time into that and looking forward to seeing what they come up with. Awards and recognitions are Mono County Behavioral Health Department, which of course is based here in Mammoth Lakes across the street at Sierra Center Mall.

32:34 It was awarded a California State Association of Counties Challenge Award for 2015 for some of their outreach programs in rural areas of the county that have been very successful, particularly in Benton. And our finance department received a State Comptroller's Association Award, too. As we look at regional issues, we look forward to continuing to work with the town on solid waste planning and hearing more about that flow agreement that

33:04 Your council gave direction to work on back, I think, in July. And as I mentioned to Dan yesterday when he was talking to our board, the best holiday gift that I could, and our board could hope to receive, would be that flow agreement. I know most people don't want garbage for Christmas, but I take it. So I hope, look forward to continuing, and I know Dan and our staff member, Tony Dublade.

33:29 Don't need to believe we are hard at work at that. But I do hope we can resume our town-county liaison meetings. We had to miss one in September due to scheduled conflicts, but I hope we can pick that back up in December. Also in December, we have our next Eastern Sierra Council of Governments meeting where we're working, really taking a regional focus on not only solid waste, but recreation, air service, technology, digital 395, and looking if we need to.

33:57 Reshape or formalize things actually in the SCOG to get things done. And then finally, on behalf of Lynda Salcido, our interim CAO, I feel I need to remind everyone here in the room and watching to get their flu shot. So thank you very much. Any questions? Thank you, Stacey. Any questions? I just have one on the solid waste agreement. I know we all want garbage for Christmas. Thanks for reminding everybody.

34:24 But, Dan, any thoughts? Is the council's intention to be working together on the staff level? Yeah, we're working through that. We have a draft. In fact, it's right down in the email somewhere between myself and Andy for review. Okay. But I'll get it there. The county has given some initial comments. And as we get that pulled together, end of November, 1st of December, it'll be coming to the policy boards for discussion. Good. Okay, good. Excellent. Yeah.

34:55 I just want to thank you very much. Great report. But I look forward to the town and the county starting to work together in a strategic direction like you have here and how we work together on a lot of different things. You know, we kind of piecemeal it together, but I think a total plan is something we should really consider work together on. Well, I think we absolutely, now that we've gotten our strategic planning process truly lined up and have begun implementation,

35:25 In our priority setting exercise early next year come to you and now that you've done this excellent work with town and town connected NGOs that we can identify some priority areas early in 2016 to work together. Exactly. I look forward to that. Thank you. Thank you, Susie. All right. Thanks. And thanks again, Mayor Raimondo and Dan for coming to Board of Supervisors yesterday. Thank you. Thank you.

35:51 Next item is number four, quarterly report for Mammoth Lakes Recreation presented by Rich Boccia, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Rich? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, staff, members of the community. One of the deliverables for Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to prepare and deliver a quarterly report to the Town Council that will include updates on contract deliverables, Mammoth Lakes Trail System, project implementation, and strategy project status.

36:28 Included in your council packet were the following documents. The simple status report on each of the 20 deliverables that were included in my scope of the work as Executive Director of the MLR Board of Directors. I've created three tiers within each deliverable to include celebrations, challenges, and next steps. There are attached artifacts as evidence the work include. You already received the first draft of the strategic plan, which was presented in a collaborative workshop.

36:54 Between Town Council and the MLR Board of Directors on September 2nd is Deliverable No. 3, prepare and provide to the Town an MLR strategy and prioritized list of primary amenities recommended to be supported with Measure RNU funds by December 2015. You have copies of the simple one-page executive summary and the filter that is guiding our work with user groups to determine the readiness of a top-tier project. Those are Deliverables 3 and 6.

37:21 You have copies of the fundraising matrix. We realize that this is a major goal for MLR once Town Council provides direction for top-tier projects. That's deliverable number seven. You have copies of the communication outreach plan as aligned with deliverable number 14. Our immediate next steps over this next quarter include the following. We're in the final phases of completing our branding strategy, which will include logo, web banners, and general marketing materials. Number two.

37:50 We're in the process of identifying the readiness of top-tier projects. We continue to work with the user groups in the preparation of a filter, which is three simple elements. A, what is the public benefit of the project? B, planning and development. C, operations and sustainability. We're also working with project managers to create a simple one-page executive summary that will be expanded into a more thorough business plan.

38:15 Our timeline is as follows to the completion of this readiness determination and recommendations of the Town Council. October 27th, MLR will have a special board meeting, public hearing process as mandated by municipal code for top-tier projects. November 3rd, MLR board meeting to confirm our top-tier projects. On November 18th, we'll bring back a recommendation as an information item to Town Council about what those projects should be. Number 3.

38:42 The 2016 allocation application period for special events and events programming opened this past Monday, October 19th and closes on Friday, November 6th at noon. Our timeline for the completion of this process is as follows. We met with the events coalition this past Friday, October 16th to review the application and outline the next steps. The MLO allocation committee meets on November 9th at 5 o'clock to review applicants. There will be a public hearing, special board meeting on November 16th.

39:11 On December 2nd, MLR will make a recommendation as an information item for the allocation of those funds. We've reminded all previous recipients that the annual performance report is due prior to requesting future funding. Number four, MLR understands the importance of engaging the community in the work of the organization and establishing ad hoc committees to build ownership from the ground up. Examples of these committees include, A,

39:38 There needs to be development of a special events and event programming strategy. As we all know, without a strategy, we have no foundation to stand on as we allocate funds. Structures follow strategy. B, we all agree we can all do a better job with engaging members of the community in the development of a variety of projects through the public process as we move forward.

40:01 We're just starting to work with the Arts Council to develop strategies that will strengthen the group as we work with the final recommendation for the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, known as the MAC. We're in the process of identifying members to serve on an ad hoc committee to determine the location for an outdoor event venue. We have engaged the ownership in conversations about the possible development of public-private partnerships and aquatic center at Snow Creek Athletic Club.

40:29 There's a small group that is beginning conversations about the processing of the United States Olympic Committee National Training Center regional application. Mammoth Lakes Trails Committee is finalizing a recommendation for a cost-share agreement with the National Forest to focus on trails maintenance for the summer of 2016, which will be a future Town Council agenda. Number five, my last point, our next step as an organization is to step back after the holiday break.

40:58 And begin to develop a five-year strategic plan, which will include a plan for long-term funding as aligned with the direction provided by the Town and Council to Mammoth Lakes Recreation focused on those top-tier projects. Our goal is to continue to build a shared vision based on a greater good of the larger community that we can execute with passion with a focus on excellence. I thank you for the opportunity to provide an update on some of the projects we're working on.

41:27 Any questions? Thank you, Rich. Any questions for Rich? Just one, Rich. You mentioned in here that the new board was seated at your last meeting. Can you tell us who the board members are, or is that putting you on the spot? Absolutely. I'm going to go around the table. Our board president, Dana Stroud, is in the crowd tonight. Dana, thanks for coming out. David Page is sitting on the side of the room. Tom Johnson, Terry Stellick, Dre Perry, our new board members, Gary Morgan, Brent Truax.

41:54 Colin Fernie represents Council on that committee. And Dana, who am I missing? And we have an empty seat waiting for – we have an empty seat. Okay? Anything else? I have just a quick thing. I want to commend you and all the work you're doing and your board. I've been to several of the meetings. You guys are working your tails off, if I can say that publicly. And very much appreciate all the efforts. I'm sorry.

42:24 But especially, Rich, the work that you're doing as a leader for this organization, I think we all appreciate having someone who's talking. Really, your outreach efforts are not going unnoticed, and they're very much appreciated, and thank you for your efforts. Thank you, sir. One quick question, then one point. I'll make the point first. I was at a meeting today with your board chair, Dan Estrada, with the leadership team of the Indian National Forest, talking about how we can continue this momentum of cooperative efforts with that very important local public agency.

42:52 One of the things they identified as a need is to be able to have a source that's identifying emerging recreation trends. They're looking for gateway communities like ours. They're on to the tip of the spears with our client and people coming up here. What is it the things that are people wanting to do? And how can we take that information to feed that back into the Forest Service to help them design their land management plans? I think I noticed that's number 15 on your list, but I just wanted to think that a lot of these things, we may wonder, well, why is that thing on there? What does that mean?

43:22 But there is a reason for all these things being on here. And that's an example today of how these things are coming to fruition. The question I had was on number four. The MLF and the Kern County Community College District has signed off on a long-term financial agreement. What are they agreeing to do? The Mammoth Lakes Foundation, that's a focus on the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. Kern County has signed off on a 99-year agreement to support.

43:47 Based funding, they've got $4.8 million from the Kern County Community College Foundation to support the construction of the facility. Tambor Foundation's given $2 million to support it. There's a million-dollar matching grant. In total on that project, it's about $7.5 million.

44:02 The ask for Measure U is probably going to be down the road maintenance and operations between the $200,000 to $300,000 and $500,000. So the sign-off on that is that the Kern County Community College District wants to enter an agreement with the town of Mammoth Lakes, not a nonprofit organization, to confirm there will be sustainable funds for maintenance operations for the life of the project.

44:22 Okay, good. Thank you. I want to just note that the college district wants to be in agreement with an entity like the town. This is a similar model that the Forest Service has used. The Forest Service has said we want to be partnering with an incorporated municipal entity as opposed to an NGO. So thank you very much for your update. Rich, I would like to second John's point about all the work you guys have done. Duly noted. Thank you.

44:47 That $300,000 to $500,000 you mentioned, that's just a backstop, though, isn't it? Or is that a... It appears that it's going to be an ongoing sustainable funding source, probably measure you funds at this point in time, to support maintenance and operations and programming. You know, one of our options I talked about is how to work with the Arts Council, all the players...

45:11 To gather, build a stronger partnership so we can maximize that facility, program in 365. Right. And I think we can do that. Down the road, those operational costs, those programming costs will probably back down a little bit. But right now we're hearing the tune is between 3 and 5. Oh, yeah, I think in the beginning. But as you program it, as you say, could it get to a point where it might pay for itself?

45:35 I would like to think at the end of the day any project we do is going to be self-sustaining that will generate revenue beyond the base program for program operations and maintenance, but we know it's going to take us a little while to get there to ramp some of that stuff up. That's the end game. Excellent. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. We're going to move on to our consent agenda. Are there any items, council, staff, or public would you like to pull? I'd like to pull item number eight. Okay.

46:04 John pulled number eight. Any others? Entertain a motion on item 5, 6, 7, and 9. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. Council approve consent agenda items 5, 6, 7, and 9. Second. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Item number eight, you pulled a call. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor.

46:36 Add my two cents on the results of the Measure Z election. I was not with you all at the council meeting the day after the election. That was not by design. I pre-booked a trip. But I just wanted to advise the community that I certainly respect the outcome of the election, and I think we all do. And I think we want to thank all the participants, all the energy and hard work that went into that. It's rare that in the middle of a legislative session.

47:01 Council gets a very sort of unambiguous direction from the public of where they feel, and I think we're all grateful to have that. I have concerns about how we got there, but that's a discussion for another day. But I'm also comfortable with it. I think that the work that we've been doing and started to do, I think, fits in with the intent of the community. I think we're on the right track with that. I wanted to follow up a little bit with what you said about the three things that we've laid out, the data, the quality of life, and the enforcement.

47:27 I just wanted to ask in a public setting with the town attorney to make sure that there isn't any confusion as we continue with the data collection effort, the implementation of the quality of life ordinance as an iterative process and coming up with an enforcement program. This is not in any way in violation of the law, the intent of Measure Z.

47:47 I just want to make sure that all the folks involved in all the campaigns, the no side and the yes side, understand that we are moving forward with this program. This is an issue that we have to tackle. You just have to read the headlines of what's going on in San Francisco right now as we all know these things. I just want to make sure that we're all clear that moving forward with this, there's not any problem with us doing these kinds of things. Yeah, everything you've said is correct. None of the town's ongoing efforts conflict in any way with Measure Z. Okay.

48:12 Good. So I just wanted to, if there's any questions from the community, let's keep talking with each other about this. This is a complex, interesting issue, and I think the TOT Committee is doing a really excellent job with moving these things forward, and so that was it, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Okay, great. With that, would you like to make a motion? I would. I would make a motion that, this is a tricky one, as I recall, adopt the resolution reciting the fact of the special municipal election held on October 6, 2015, declaring the result and such other matters as provided by law.

48:43 Okay.

48:44 Second.

48:45 I have a motion to send her.

48:47 Roll call, please.

48:48 Council Member Baty?

48:49 Yes.

48:49 Council Member Curry?

48:50 Yes.

48:51 Council Member Whitmore?

48:52 Yes.

48:52 Mayor Brotson-Mitch?

48:53 Yes.

48:54 Mayor Blondon?

48:54 Yes.

48:55 Motion passes 5-0.

49:00 We're going to move on to a public hearing.

49:02 This is the time and place for the public hearing for the Town Mammoth Lakes Community Facilities District 2013-3, Transient Service, Annexation No. 2.

49:11 Through the hearing is to inquire into annexation of property into the district.

49:17 And levy a special taxes for town-wide transit services within the adjacent to the district. Before I firmly open the hearing, are there any property owners or registered voters in the district of the territory to be annexed who wish to file written protests? If so, must do so now with the town clerk. Okay, seeing none, the hearing is now open. We will first have presentations by staff about the annexation of territory of the district. After that, we will receive comments and questions and oral protests from any interested persons.

49:48 When all comments have been received, the hearing will be closed. Steph? Thank you. This is fairly straightforward. There's a developer in town who is proposing to develop three parcels in the resort zone.

50:04 As part of that project, he's requested that they be annexed into the Transit Services District, which basically provides funding for transit services throughout town in this area. I've heard no objection to this whatsoever. The request has come from the developer. Just so you know, this will be part of our annual assessment district update that we do in June of every year. The current rate for this area is $156 roughly per unit per year.

50:31 We reassess that or review that every year, and we'll be back before you next June to do that. So they wouldn't pay any funds until they actually have a certificate of occupancy. Somebody's living there, they have impact, they pay the $157 per year. That's it. Thank you. And are all units the same? House versus a condo versus a? The only requirement is per unit. Per unit, gotcha. There's no distinction between the type of unit. Okay, thanks, Grady. Thank you. Okay, any questions for staff?

51:00 Any questions from the public staff? Okay, seeing none, the hearing is closed. We may now consider and adopt the resolution authorizing the annexation of territory into community facilities district, authorizing the levy of a special tax and submitting the levy of a special tax to qualified electors. Look for a motion to adopt number one.

51:26 Do you mean you want each resolution adopted individually? Yeah, yeah. Okay, hold on a second here. Okay. I move that we adopt the resolution of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, authorizing the annexation of territory into a community facilities district, authorizing the levy of a special tax and submitting the levy of special tax to qualify electors. Okay. We have a motion. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes.

51:55 Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Will the clerk please announce the results of the property owner votes? Received and yes votes. Okay, great. Thank you. Record shows that at least two-thirds of the property owner's voters are in favor of the annexation of territory and levy of the special tax. We'll now proceed with the final actions of the annexation of territory of the district. We'll entertain a motion on the final two resolution. Somebody else can read.

52:34 We have a resolution and an ordinance. There will be two separate items there, if you would, please. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I will make a motion to adopt a resolution to the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, declaring the results of the special annexation landowner election, determining validity of the prior proceedings, and directing the recording of the Second Amendment to notice a special tax lien. And, do I have to do the end?

53:05 If you want to do that, and then we'll do the ordinance separate. Okay. Thank you. Got you. I have a motion. Second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. And adopt the first reading and ordinance of the Town Council.

53:30 The Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, authorizing the levy of special taxes in a community facilities district, including certain annexation territory. Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay, we're going to move on to policy matters. Item number 11, authorization to proceed with a conceptual design and environmental review.

54:02 For the community multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. Stu, it's already open. A little pee at the bottom, it's already open. Okay. Thank you. There we go. Thanks. Thank you.

55:02 I'm going to start with the recommendation and then go back through some of the background and history. There's a number of people here today to speak on this item, I'm sure, and I want to make sure that everybody has the same information. First of all, the recommendation is to accept the recommendations from the Recreation Commission, the Mammoth Lakes Recreation, MLR, and the Ad Hoc Facility Task Force to approve the use of up to $150,000 in set-assign funding and authorize the town manager to amend the capital budget.

55:30 To include preliminary design and environmental documentation for the location of a community recreation facility within Mammoth Creek Park West. Now, how did we get here? First of all, and I'll be quick, but I do need to go back into some of the history. The rink was first discussed in the town, certainly just after incorporation. But when it first became formal was when the preparation of the parks and recreation element to the general plan was done back in 1989 and 1990.

55:59 At that time, they did a survey of town residents, and the number one priority was an ice rink and a roller hockey rink back in that time, so that was the number one priority. In 1992, the council adopted a master park facilities plan that also included a rink. 1998 and 1999, there was actually a concerted effort. Planning was done, some preliminary design was done, and a preliminary EIR.

56:28 A draft EIR was prepared to put an ice rink, a multipurpose rink, and a 10,000 square foot community center at Mammoth Creek Park West. That's well documented. The next formal step for Mammoth Creek Park West was really when this council directed staff on July 15th to get together with an ad hoc task force, if you will, made up of rec commission, MLR, and town staff, and a council member to study.

56:55 Where a rink should be placed. The council had previously given direction that the rink, the multi-use facility was not to remain on the school site, so that task force took that as a given and moved on to look around town. The exhibit that I have up there is really just an aerial that shows the boundary of the town-owned parcel at the top, and you can see it's 4.9 acres. About two acres is developed or disturbed by the current turf area, the playground, and the parking lot.

57:25 2.9 acres is still open. And just below that, if you will, is the U.S. Forest Service property, about 4.7 acres total. I just want to keep that up throughout the presentation to be able to answer any questions and kind of orient us as we move forward. A brief description of what we would call the environmental setting. What we are recommending is consistent with the general plan. It's consistent with the zoning regulations.

57:52 It does not impact the U.S. Forest Service parcel. That does not mean that we won't propose some minor uses on that parcel. We do have a special use permit there. We can use it for park uses. And if there are uses that complement what we're doing on the town parcel, we would certainly recommend those at the appropriate time. I want to point out just in terms of dimensions, I have a couple on there just to give you, again, a proximity.

58:19 Over to the west or the left-hand side, you'll see the Mammoth Creek Condominium Project. To give you an idea, the south end of their parking is only about 65 feet from the center line of Mammoth Creek. On the west side, that last unit there is about 90 feet.

58:38 The U.S. Forest Service parcel from our property line to the center of Mammoth Creek is 225 feet. And again, I only do that to give you a sense of scale. So when we talk about planning and preliminary design for the multi-use facility, you have an idea of what we're talking about in terms of size. The ad hoc committee, and there are others who will speak to this. I know that Rich from MLR was also on the task force.

59:02 Betsy Truax from the Rec Commission and others will speak to this as well. But just very briefly, I want to emphasize that this ad hoc committee really did take a fresh look at it. I mean, there was an environmental document of 346 pages, I believe, that 345 pages that covered 546. Thank you. You read every page, and that's impressive, believe me.

59:24 But it covered a lot of the potential impacts that that old project had, and it was a very different project. It did have a 10,000-square-foot community center. It did have a multi-use facility, but it had a lot of other uses on site, and it was also oriented much different than what we're now recommending. But the Ad Hoc Committee did. They reviewed the historic and available information, and they really made it considered.

59:50 Concerted effort with a fresh set of eyes to look at a best location. This was not a staff-driven process as much as I'm, you know.

59:58 I agree with the result. It was by no means staff driven. In fact, staff wasn't even there for some of the meetings. It was really driven by people from the community, from MLR, from the rec commission that really did, again, a fresh look at this. And they were unanimous as to that recommendation. The ad hoc committee was. They came back and said, you know, we've looked at all these other sites. We've looked around town. We've read the old EIR. And we still think that Mammoth Creek Park West is the best place for this.

1:00:26 The rec commission took this up. They had several status reports, and then in their last meeting, they voted 4-0 with one member absent to approve the recommendation for Mammoth Creek Park West. MLR also took it up and voted 4-1 to approve that same recommendation. In terms of community input, and that's really what we're looking for to date, we're looking for that tonight, and we're looking for that in the future.

1:00:53 We had one meeting on site. We had a decent amount of attendance there. We brought back to Suite Z and we went through the project there. We've also had several meetings that have been open to the public with MLR, the Rec Commission, our design charrette that we had, town council meetings. This has been a subject several times. So there have been many opportunities already for the public to comment. But I want to emphasize again that we welcome the comments. We got a lot of emails just in the last few days.

1:01:21 They don't bother us. We want to know because one of the difficulties of staff is to not hear from the public until it's decision time, until we get that. So we welcome these questions. We're going to be taking great notes tonight as well to identify everything we can because as we move forward, we're hoping that the public remains engaged in this project every time we have a meeting. We're going to start out with...

1:01:43 With preliminary design, we have to go get a design consultant to help us do that because the recommended project includes a community center that we had not had on this site formally in the last few months. We will engage an environmental consultant. It happens that the planning department has a...

1:02:02 We encourage this because when we should the council

1:02:23 Vote to move this forward. We want that public input as soon as possible. Some of the things staff has talked about on the multi-use facility specifically is enclosing the West End to try to cut down some of the potential noise impacts.

1:02:36 We want the public at the table telling us, yes, that's a good idea, that's not. What we hope to end up with, again, if Council directs us to move forward, is to come back to you sometime next year with an environmental document, a preliminary design that is a collaborative effort. While there may be some in some of the neighboring developments that...

1:02:58 Have objections to various parts of this. We hope that eventually they'll come to the table and say, yes, that's great, but we also want a path connection, or we also want these things to make this part of the community, and we hope that we'll get there. My request tonight would be that if anybody does speak on this, to please be as specific as possible, because the more we're informed, the more we can do with that information. We're not guessing what that means. In other words, if somebody just says, I don't like light.

1:03:24 What does that mean? Is that indoor, outdoor? We're going to put a roof on this thing, be as specific as possible. With that, I'm open to any questions. In terms of the schedule, again, as we go through this process, our stated goal is to have this thing open and running sometime in the late summer of 2017 and have a grand opening celebration on Halloween of 2017 at Mammoth Creek Park West.

1:03:50 With that, I'd be glad to answer any questions, and I know the town manager, as well, is ready to answer any questions regarding any of the financing or other issues. Okay. I have a question. Excuse me. Grady, a question on the timeline. If I remember my CEQA.

1:04:06 Steps correctly. Yes. The design happens first, so then you have an actual project on which to assess environmental impacts. Absolutely correct. So the actual design where there will be all kinds of involvement would happen in the next few months, and then the remainder of the specified timeline is the actual analysis of impacts, a draft EIR, which everyone can then comment upon and then coming back to council.

1:04:33 That's correct, and that's, in fact, one reason I didn't show our first concept for where the multi-use facility would be on this, because we want the community input. If we need to move it 10 feet here and there, we want to do that to...

1:04:45 To mitigate any potential impact. So that's absolutely the case. And can I ask if there's any significance to the little red area that's on that? The red arrow is basically one is from the U.S. Forest Service property line and near the restrooms. Oh, okay. I can't read the numbers from here. Got it. Exactly. Sorry. Okay. Thank you. It's actually 110 feet to the path and 225 to the creek. Thank you. You bet. Any other questions for staff? I just have one. I don't want to put you on the spot.

1:05:15 There will be plenty of opportunities for that going forward, I'm sure. But in terms of setting the expectations of where we're going to be for October 2017, maybe we can just, you know, think about that a little bit and make sure we put out goals that are achievable that are, you know, they are the expectations that we should all have. And as we get into this process a little bit, maybe consider those a little bit before we put out anything that's maybe too grandiose or not achievable. Absolutely. Yeah. Thank you.

1:05:45 Okay, I'm going to go to the public on this. I would like to go Rich first. Yeah, Rich, one second. With public comment, we have a pretty crowded house. So if the comments can be added to and not repeated over and over again, that would be really helpful so we can get through this. Rich? Rich Glaccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Quick synopsis, quick review.

1:06:16 On July 15th, Town Council considered the school district's offer for a long-term lease agreement, but respectfully decided to look for another long-term permanent location. Additional action by the staff created the task force, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, staff, Recreation Commission to do our due diligence for a new facility. The task force began its work on July 28th. Some of the task force and recreation commissioners will speak to that this evening.

1:06:40 The Town of Mammoth Lakes Plan Your Parks Community Design Workshops were conducted sort of the spring of 2014 while attended and adopted by the Town of Council on August 6, 2014. That document's just a year young. The task force created and completed due diligence, opportunities, and constraints based on town-owned and managed properties. That was the direction. Using the Plan Your Parks as a reference document for our work.

1:07:06 We went through the community center parcel. We looked at opportunities and constraints. We looked at the bell shake parcel, opportunities and constraints. Mammoth Creek Park West, Whitmore Park Complex, track, fields, and pool. Trails and Park, the Civic Center. All that stuff's in the packet for the public to read. We expanded our thinking to include potential, potential.

1:07:28 Complementary facilities on town-owned parcel. It was agreed that the greatest need at this time was an updated and enlarged community center that would accommodate current and future community programs. The task force reviewed the 1999 Mammoth Creek Park Facilities Project Environmental Review Impact Report as another reference document and noted the comments on the executive summary.

1:07:51 Chapter 2, page 19, about the parcel being the Mammoth Creek Park West parcel is the redesigned alternative, environmentally superior alternative for this project. We reach consensus that Mammoth Creek Park West, which is 4-plus acres of town-owned property, is a recommended location as it also retains the open, passive park uses on the adjacent 4-plus acres of the U.S. Forest Land Service.

1:08:17 The task force recommendation to town council is to construct a new community center and a complimentary multi-use recreational facility at Mammoth Creek Park West. Mammoth Lakes Board of Directors took action to support that on October 5th. It was a four to one vote. Once again, I'll share the same comment I made before. Our goal is to continue to build a shared vision based on the greater good of the larger community.

1:08:44 That we can execute with passion and a focus on excellence. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. Thank you, Rich. Okay, I'll now open public comment. Tom Johnson, MLR board member, and I was a member of the task force. And I thought it might be helpful if I just shared really my take on the work of the task force and the recommendation that's before you. For my part at the beginning, I was pretty much on the other side of both of these recommendations.

1:09:21 Going on to the task force. Maybe that's a little strong. I was very skeptical of them. I thought the idea of moving to Mammoth Park West was rash, and I didn't quite understand kind of the strategic underpinnings of that decision necessarily. And then the shade structure recommendation as well. This had come up at the MLR board a few times. We had asked staff a little bit about

1:09:46 A potential shade structure, temporary shade structure. And each time we were kind of rebuffed and they suggested it was very expensive, half a million dollars, forget it, too much. And I was skeptical of that too. So I walked onto that task force really wanting to make sure that the decision to move to Mammoth Park West was fully vetted. And I really wanted to deliver that damn shade structure to the hockey community. I mean, I walked onto that task force with that in mind.

1:10:15 To my delight, the entire task force was very professional. There was no inevitable conclusion we were driving to. Every single location we looked at, we kind of looked at it as if it were the only place we could build. And we asked the question, if this were the only place we could build, how would we build the best possible rink there? And so I feel like it was fully vetted at the end of the day that the recommendation to move to Mammoth Park West,

1:10:45 It was unanimous, and not only that, there really wasn't a close second in our deliberations. So I'm very confident in that portion of the recommendation. In terms of the shade structure, the temporary shade structure, we went through, and it's in your packet, we went through a lot of comps. We ended up choosing one comp to base our work on that met a few basic criteria, and also gave us an opportunity to try and make it cheap, too.

1:11:14 And it became pretty clear to me that, and the rest of the task force, that the cost was going to be too much. We had established a baseline, and it was way twice that at the very least. But we kept that door open. There were some really smart people in the community who were still very skeptical that we couldn't put a shade over that thing for cheap, at least for below $100,000. And so we kept that door open.

1:11:40 We kept bringing people in. We kept bringing new bids in, new ideas in. We kept working over the numbers. I think we became very efficient, actually, when Jeff and Lynn joined our group. And I feel like they might have a different opinion, but I feel like we all sat there and really worked over those numbers together and tried to make them pencil, and they just didn't. So I feel very confident in that part of the recommendation as well. The third part of that recommendation before you is what I think is the key one.

1:12:10 That's the idea of complementary facilities. What we're recommending is basically an integrated facility with a community center and a multi-use facility, which is an ice rink. I mean, this would obviously give the multi-use facility a real fighting chance of being a multi-use facility. I mean, at its current location, without the complementary amenities, it kind of has a hard road to hoe for that.

1:12:39 But my original resistance to the Mammoth Park West location was that I didn't quite understand why for a town council that has kind of staked itself to improving amenities and to getting some of these facilities off the ground that had been talked about for decades. Why you would start with an ice rink? It did not make sense to me. We already have an ice rink. Why not a community center first?

1:13:09 This idea of complementary facilities has changed my mind a little bit. I mean, I should say that keeping the rink where it is was never on the task force plate. We were asked not to vet that, so I don't have much insight to that. But seeing that as a complementary facility, as a community, I no longer see them if this recommendation is taken up. I don't see a community center and an ice rink as two separate pieces.

1:13:35 I see it as one integrated facility, and then the question really to you is, what do you do first? And for me, the gap between those two things, between ice rink and community facility has shrunk, if you consider them together. I think you're really asking the question, which half of the same thing are you going to build first? So I think it changes the nature of the question a little bit. So I think that's the end of my comments. I hope that's helpful, and I'm more than happy to make some more comments. Great. Thank you, Tom.

1:14:05 Hello, Sean Turner, Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commissioner. Real quick, because I've got to get someone home from soccer practice. You have quite a decision to make in front of you, and you're going to hear a lot of comments for or against both the location as well as temporary shade structure, wherever the case may be. I think what I want to speak to just a little bit and what I think is most exciting and you have the opportunity to do here is really execute on a timeline.

1:14:35 As Grady pointed out, I think the best thing that we can deliver to this school, the best thing that we can deliver to this community is a multi-use facility in a location where it will be permanent, where we're going to be setting it up.

1:14:52 By Halloween of 2017. And I think that if there is any kind of deliberation, and you're going to hear a lot of comments, I'm sure both for or against that location. But as Tom just pointed out, coming from Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and I will say coming from the Recreation Commission, we did spend a lot of time looking at the different locations. And in my mind, this is the best location.

1:15:17 Timing, the opportunity is here. And I just really want to encourage you to execute, make a decision. It's going to be tough. There's going to be people who are initially against it. I hope at the end of the day that we will all be celebrating opening this. I think the biggest thing that I want to say to you is please stick with this timeline. That's the best thing that we can do. Thank you. Thank you, Sean. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, council members, thank you for giving me time to speak. My name is Bill Raff.

1:15:55 I am the president of the La Vista Blanc Homeowners Association. If you will look at the map up there, which I can't see from here, but you will see that the hockey rink is directly up, well, the hockey rink isn't shown there, but the hockey rink in the planning is directly up against the facility, which is our homeowners association.

1:16:24 The hockey rink is not proposed any place along the street, Old Mammoth Road. It is only up against our condominium association. By putting it there, it is in the middle of a lot of other associations that go from the end of the park all the way over to Minaret Road. I'm sure you've all seen it. You know what I'm talking about.

1:16:56 I want to make the board aware that the associations around there, four of them have gotten together, are against the location, not against the hockey rink, not against the community center. They are against the hockey rink in the location where it is placed. And if that is the location that the board wants to go with,

1:17:25 Here's what's going to happen. First of all, you're going to have to have an EIR, and I think that's, from what I hear being discussed, everybody recognizes that, and there's no question about it. If you want to look at what's going to happen with the EIR, go back to the EIR that was prepared in 1999. It's just a draft. It never was finalized. But if you look at the EIR in 1999,

1:17:57 It has sections on what mitigation needs to be done if you put the hockey rink where you're planning to put it. And there are a large number of mitigation measures that need to be done. So one of the things I want to point out to the board is that if you choose to put the hockey rink where you're planning to locate it right up against our complex,

1:18:27 What we would like to see, and

1:18:52 And I forgot to say, I'm not just speaking for our association. There are four associations that have combined, and we have over 200 residential units that are involved just around the location of this hockey rink. So what we need to do is try and work something out with you, the council, to make this thing work, because it's not in our best interest to fight the city.

1:19:22 That's not what we want to do. But on the other hand, it's really not in your best interest to put the hockey rink where it really doesn't belong. And where it doesn't belong, first of all, in our opinion, it doesn't belong in Mammoth Creek Park West because it's a residential area. A hockey rink belongs in an industrial or commercial area.

1:19:48 If you are going to insist on putting the hockey rink there, you need to move it over to Old Mammoth Road. Then you avoid a lot of the mitigation problems. Now, I don't want to repeat stuff that you're going to hear from other people, but the main environmental issues here are the lighting and the noise and the parking. And those are the items that are going to cost money.

1:20:18 If you look at the old EIR, you will see that because of the lighting problems and especially because of the noise problems, there are some serious mitigation acts that need to be done. So without repeating myself, just in conclusion now, I think you will find if you look at this project carefully, putting it someplace else.

1:20:47 Will probably work best. That is our request. On the other hand, though, if you insist on putting it at Mammoth Creek Park West, I think you will find that if you don't put it up against the residential part of the park, but move it over, either over to Old Mammoth Road or even take the Mammoth Park East.

1:21:12 Parcel, you can get that. Move it over there. The whole thing will work better and everybody will be happy. That's really what should happen here. Thank you, Bill. The Town Manager, Staff, Mr. Mayor, Council. My name is Dieter Feibiger. And after I read in the paper last week, I had to come here. Okay. The reason of being here is tonight.

1:21:50 I hear the same story what I heard 20 years ago or so. I was on the Parks and Rec Commission. I served my 12 years on the Parks and Rec Commission at that time. We were threatened at that time the first time with a lawsuit because of the ice ring going to Mammoth Creek West. I can understand the homeowners there.

1:22:19 But I don't want to touch this. I don't want to touch it right now, really. The reason I'm here is not only to complain for this site, to put the hockey ring there, but what we want is a solution, okay? My solution is we should look into this plan, what Mr. Buccia made out here. It's very good.

1:22:50 Powerful Mammoth Lake Recreation Director. Okay. I read through this whole thing here many, many times, and I nowhere can see Mammoth Creek East. Why West? There's not enough room. What we need in this town is a huge parcel of land to put all of these facilities together in one place.

1:23:20 One location, and the location I say is Mammoth Creek East. I brought this up many years ago, but it came to the then council planning, but then the recreation center was, what I'm talking about is a community event in the recreation center, okay? And that should be a long, long, big...

1:23:49 Also, we should have, in that community event center, a huge gym.

1:24:21 Well, we can play for the kids basketball, volleyball. And I come later to this from what I've seen in Cody, Wyoming. I come to that. Okay. So this is my solution or maybe my recommendation that we should look into Mammoth Creek East. Okay. Mr. O'Connell is here.

1:24:51 And I wouldn't want to have a building put right in front of his bowling alley and restaurant and screw up his view shed there for the sure in the area. The recommendation is to put a huge parking lot right next to Old Mammoth Road past his restaurant and his bowling alley and then start doing those buildings one by one. Aquatic center, gym.

1:25:22 Event Center with a stage where we can have events like, you know, choirs, theater, art. All these people have, we have people in this town here. So what I'm recommending is, again, Mammoth Creek, look into Mammoth Creek East. And what I read in the paper here last week,

1:25:51 That homeowner association is really strong, I'm telling you. And we were not sued in those days, but we were threatened. It never came to a lawsuit, so we just said, okay, goodbye. So the hockey rink went into the RV center at that time. But now it is in the college side. My recommendation is leave it there, put a roof over it, and let those hockey players.

1:26:21 Play this season, okay? All right. I'm looking for you guys. More so, what's wrong with eventually having two ice rings in this town? If you want to be a four-season town, recreation town, my God, I've seen it. Here, Europe, Canada, all over the place.

1:26:52 Let's do it right and let's do it the first time right. Okay? Let's put it maybe over there in Mammoth Creek East and there's only Edison there. I don't think they will have any problems having a rec center there. I'm going to have you wrap it up. My time is up? Time is up. Oh, I'm sorry. I want to make one more final sentence here. I found out that Mr.

1:27:23 Don Holler grew up in Cody, Wyoming. Here's my card. I was there twice. Looked at their recreation centre. That's the way we should have it in Mammoth here. Okay? Beside my last sentences, what I always was in my years in the Parks and Rec Commission, youth in sport is my support. Thank you. Thank you, Nina.

1:27:58 All right, good evening, council members, mayor, members of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Committee, and all in attendance tonight. My name is Damon Frank. I am a board member with the La Vista Blanc Complex, and I have a unique perspective on this because I am a member of the hockey community. Not only do I work with the Los Angeles Kings and Anaheim Ducks organizations, I was personally one of the main people responsible for bringing the Calder Cup

1:28:27 The Mammoth Outdoor Rink last year will become a gap again. We have teams from Vegas, San Diego, the Junior Ducks organizations all coming. I'm part of the coaching staff. I've also been to visit rinks across the United States and Canada, both indoor and outdoor. I support the improvement of hockey operations in Mammoth in a place where it is widely accepted. I strongly oppose the relocation of the rink to Mammoth Creek Park West. In particular,

1:28:58 Nestled right up next to the Le Vista Blanc Complex. Okay? Why? Noise. How many of you have been to an outdoor hockey rink game? And we are talking about an outdoor hockey rink, people. Okay? How many? Show of hands, please. Outdoor hockey rink game. Okay. Have you ever heard a frozen piece of rubber wrist-shotted from a nine-year-old hitting off the glass? What does that sound like?

1:29:32 A gunshot. A gunshot. How about hitting off the boards? Okay, that's just during a hockey game. Okay? To successfully run a hockey rink, you need open skate. You need figure skating time. You need stick times. You need hockey games. You need adult leagues. You have to run that rink at all daylight hours to make it successful. The noise from the pucks hitting the glass, the boards, music from games.

1:30:03 Open skate, figure skating, whistles, coaches, fans, announcers, lights, Zambonis, chillers. Right up next against La Vista Blanca, you are creating a long-term opposition, a long-term noise pollution. The hours are going to be constrained. Are you going to have games at 6 a.m.? Right up next to all those 200-some homeowners? Because that's what time our games were last Christmas, 6 a.m.

1:30:37 Either for all of the community members, all the homeowners, we want to improve hockey here, but not where it's so widely opposed. I think you have a lot of people here who don't want it here. You can move it closer to Old Mammoth Road. You can move it to Mammoth Park East. You can move it to some other facilities. Putting an outdoor hockey rink so close to all the residential is going to be a recipe for disaster.

1:31:05 So I'm not going to restate some of the other comments that I've made here. You're going to hear more. But that is my stance. Thank you. Thank you, David. Hello, I'm Lynn Elteri-Need, advocate, community member. I've been...

1:31:25 I've been extremely involved in the past year with rec commission, MLR, attending those meetings, as well as town council meetings. You've seen me up here many times, so I'm going to try not to be redundant or repeat myself from things I said in the past, but so I'm going to try to be real specific as well. Due diligence has been my biggest concern of what I've experienced in this past year.

1:31:45 I've spoken with each of you town council members recently, either myself or Jeff. In those discussions, I've picked up on distinct differences in each of our conversations. One of you envision a recreation corridor at Mammoth Creek Park West, presumably a swimming, recreation, hockey, community center corridor, while another states that the town cannot afford to implement a swimming pool nor gym.

1:32:06 One member identifies the urgency to begin pursuing the acquisition of Mammoth Creek Park East. Another council member states that it's unrealistic and we don't have the $2 million to invest in Mammoth Creek Park East. One council member envisions an open air at Ice Rink at Mammoth Creek Park West. Another, it is to be enclosed. By the way, just to kind of touch on what Mr. Frank just stated, I own a restaurant and a mixed-use resort.

1:32:32 13 years. I can't tell you how many times. It's countless numbers that I've been threatened to be sued for noise. So heavily consider, you know, their arguments. I think it's realistic, especially if it's an open-air facility. The one common denominator shared by all the council members is, one, you are limited in land, and number two, you are limited in financial resources. Currently, the town has a public

1:32:58 Partnership with another public entity, the school district for the rink's present location. This represents a true coming together of government and community. One or two of the town council members are concerned with the $3,000 to $5,000 per month lease payment to the school district, yet the town offices are currently leased at $29,000 per month. That's $348,000 per year, $7 million in 20 years. $5,000 per month is a drop in the bucket compared to this.

1:33:28 $5,000 for a multi-use facility that just needs shelter will meet the needs for year-round activities and a win for council. If you're concerned about owning assets, buy a building for town offices that you can pay off for the next 20 years and save the community $14 million for 40 years after that. What do you save in 40 years by moving the rink? $2.4 million. Big difference.

1:33:50 Also important to note, one council member states that this town cannot afford to subsidize a swimming facility nor a recreation gym on its own and will need to enter into a private partnership. So the town is willing to enter into a private partnership and lease, potentially, but not a public partnership with the school district. The school district that takes care of our children. Which one is more risky? And I'm still not clear on, I keep hearing that you want more assets.

1:34:19 Only government entities, MLR, Rec Commission, and Town Council approved the relocation of the ice rink, and I've watched this whole process happen. The town manager did an excellent job of baiting us all with a lowball figure of $400,000 to $600,000 to relocate the rink. That number quickly increased to $1.3 to $1.5 million.

1:34:37 This figure remains in place with no consideration of the cost of litigation, the increased expenses as a result of the EIR that will be impacted by noise lights traffic, the Regional Water Quality Control Board Fish and Game and LADWP.

1:34:51 The town and MLR may want to push on, but a simple filing of a lawsuit will take months to years to clear up, as well as we know in this state you can sue for most anything. That would kill our timing, expand our costs. So once again, this comes down to timing. I've sat in the rooms of Rec Commission, MLR, and Task Force where all individuals present feel confident that the EIR will deliver the pot of gold by October of 2017. But yet they...

1:35:16 Represent a very small percentage of the equation. You see another percentage of that equation sitting in this room. Has this due diligence been done? Have there been conversations with the Regional Water Quality Control Board? Because we've spoken with them. And Fish and Game.

1:35:32 Or L-A-D-W-P. And in addition, I'm not going to talk about the shade study, but that's another one of those issues with due diligence I'm gravely concerned about. And Mr. Johnson, I hope you're still in the room because you'll be able to hear the update. But we as a community consulted with a structural engineer and actually have greater results, a very different estimate that can be done for the shade structure versus what was initially quoted of $400,000 to $500,000. I'm going to let Mr. Posey speak on this.

1:36:02 The total community center with an ice rink is a $7 million project. This is the Taj Mahal. We all want it. I totally get that. And Mammoth Creek Park West will be the single largest capital building project the town has ever taken on. So 6% of that total number will need to be spent on architect and planning. Thank you. That is a $420,000 investment. We want to fast track this facility or should we really be taking our time?

1:36:31 Are we a town that has so much money that we can risk forcing this through? I urge you to get clear, Council, on your vision and on your partnerships. Keep the rink in its current location for even five to ten years while MLR has the time to execute true strategic planning. I definitely believe a programmatic EIR should be pursued from Mammoth Creek Park West. Absolutely. Should it be for an open-aired rink? Absolutely not. I urge you to take your time and recognize that there will be barriers to overcome.

1:36:59 In the meantime, let's not kill the growth of the kids program. The multi-use facility needs a shelter. Please give us a shelter. Pursue the EIR, do proper planning, spend wisely, and fit all that in with your visions and meet your fiduciary responsibilities, please. Thank you for your time. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, Council, thank you. My name's John Heaton, and I had...

1:37:32 This wonderful little speech written out, now it's all scribbled on from all the questions that I have, so I'll try and follow it. I'm a catch and release fly fisherman. I'm close to 60. I was born on a river. My dad was a fly fisherman. I believe strongly in fly fishing. I believe in wild trout, not stock trout. I don't believe in bait fishing.

1:37:57 I'm making a whole bunch of enemies from bait fishers and lure fishers here, but I think that's the best vision like Montana has, stream access for the public, things like that. It would be very tempting if I were on a commission with some power to try and impose that on the community, but I think there would be a lot of outcry against it like there is against placing this rink in Mammoth Creek Park. I know there's people on the...

1:38:23 The various commissions and the council who are very much in favor of hockey. I think hockey's great, just like I think fly fishing's great, but I don't think that it's really ethical to try and force something through that the community's against. One of the people who spoke earlier, one of the commissions said, we're looking for the greater good for the larger community. Today's list of letters, there's 18 letters, 17 of them opposed, and only one in favor.

1:38:52 And by the way, the one in favor, Dan O'Connell, who I guess is somebody in the front row here, wrote, it would be unwise rushing to the quickest, most expedient solution we need to think long term about the bigger picture. So even though he's in favor of a rink, I'm in favor of that sentence. One of my favorite TV shows is this old house. And I remember some years back, they were doing a house in Salem, Massachusetts.

1:39:20 And the Salem Historical Society and the City Council got involved. And one of their big goals was getting parking off the street because the streets are crowded. So this old house crew came in and they came up with a plan and everything else. But they were opposed to it. They didn't want to back down. They had taken a stand. No, we're against it. This is what we're doing. This is what we're doing. This is what we're doing. And they wouldn't back down. And so this old house crew went away and the cars were on the street.

1:39:49 I'm hoping that you'll slow down. I know it might seem to you who have been working on it for a while that it's already slow, but slow down, think about it. Mammoth Creek Park West, I don't know why it's the best place other than the city owning it. Everybody keeps saying, well, it's the best place, it's the best place. Why? Just because the city owns it? I don't get that part. And I don't get why you have to have an ice rink to have a multi-use facility.

1:40:19 Item listed in the various newspapers, letters to the editor and everything else have said all kinds of things that could go into that park and all of them I would support except a rink. They're all good. The tennis courts, soccer, whatever it may be, a closed community center, they're all good but not that loud, noisy, view-obstructing rink.

1:40:47 I hope that tonight every time you hear the word ice rink, you think Walmart. Would you vote to put a Walmart in Mammoth Creek Park West? Because that's what an ice rink is going to be like. A Walmart plumped right down in that tiny little park. It's not the place for it. I know it might be the cheapest, but it's not the place for it. Walmart might be great for Mammoth, but it's not great for Mammoth in Mammoth Creek Park West, and neither is the rink.

1:41:22 Thank you. Thank you, John. Got to get in line, Dan. Yeah. Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, Town Manager, Lawyer, Engineer, Stu, Jeff Posey here. I've been up here quite a bit lately talking to you guys. And I have a bunch of notes this time so I don't get off tangibly, you know, going on a rip. But Lynn covered a lot of things I was going to say. And I want everyone to know, besides the kids in this room, there's probably two other people who want a covered rank more than me.

1:42:00 Lynn being one of them, and Fernie being the other. Okay, you know, we sat down, I've told you many times, and brainstormed, during a hockey tournament, let's get a roof on the rink. Let's work on it. So, we started this whole thing back in August of 2014, and we had a little, see, I'm already off, man. We had a little community group, including Lynn, Jay, and Colin Cole.

1:42:23 And Fernie, we looked at a putting roof on the rink. Other people joined as the progress was being made. After the town came back with a $1.4 million bid, a friend of mine contacted me and said, hey, my dad puts up steel buildings. Let's contact him. We spoke to him. He said, I'm going to give it to you at cost. And that total cost was $793,000, $954, whatever, you know what I mean. A little more than half what you guys were originally going to pay. Great deal.

1:42:48 Okay, in January 2015, this was all a go. The town had $500,000 to use from a certain fund. I don't know where it came from. I don't care. MLR agreed to kick in $300,000. Thank you very much. But we were still short $200,000 due to the groundwork that was involved with putting in footings and whatever and whatnot to grade the whole area. And all our fundraisers was launched. And, Stu, you mentioned sitting and having coffee one morning. Let's have a hockey tournament. So within 10 days, we had a hockey tournament raised $7,000 towards the roof, towards that $200,000 that we were short.

1:43:17 And during that time was a huge rainstorm and then Paradise caught on, not Paradise, but that whole zone, Swalmeadows caught on fire. So on the last night, we raised $1,000 for them. The community is willing to help you guys out. That's a lot of money to be raised by a bunch of bum-ass hockey players from Walmart. Okay? A month or two later, the ID of the roof was squashed when the town manager discovered that the 30-year lease with Mammoth Unified School District was, which was a permanent spot if they signed a 30-year lease, canceled.

1:43:46 And set to five years in 2002 when the Town of Mammoth Lakes restructured their debt due to the lawsuit. Lease negotiations took place behind closed doors and an agreement could not be agreed upon. I personally feel the lease was more than fair at one-sixth of the cost than the lease of the town offices. Now that the task force to move the rink began, wait, now the task force to move the rink from the spot was deemed permanent since the town signed a 30-year lease in 2007, located, I'm off now, crap.

1:44:12 All right. According to me, there's a 2007, October, November 2007, Sierra Magazine article that stated that the rink at the new library just off the corner of Sierra Park and Meridian, the new facility, should be very close to completion by the time you pick up this magazine. Excavation and utilities were both in place by the time construction started in October on the rink. Outbuildings, which include ticket booths, concession, restrooms, and a storage for the Olympia grooming machine. Why they said it was a great spot, it's also central to the trails and transit system. There's a stop adjacent to the library.

1:44:42 Seems like a perfect spot. All right, when the rink is finally completed in the winter of 2008, so we're now down a year down the road, the rink will be pretty much state-of-the-art. Actually, the only thing left to do after this winter will be install the metal roof in 2008, concrete floor under the ice, then they'll be put down next summer. The metal roof won't be on this year, but it's expected to be up by the next winter. How is this for cool? The rink's cool coil system is capable of generating ice year-round for summer ice skating. None of this happened. And now we're in 2015.

1:45:11 So I questioned the timeline of moving the rink 2017. I really don't think that's possible. I hope you can do it. I really do. But then our community group tried to get a shade cover on our rink like other places have for a fraction of the cost of the roof while the task force that we were not invited to until the middle of December decided where to put the rink. September, sorry. Other towns said they built theirs for around $50,000. Breckenridge seemed like the most aesthetically pleasing model to pursue.

1:45:40 When the cost came in, not from a structural engineer, by the way, it was between $400,000 and $500,000. Way too much. I get it. You don't want to spend that money. It was suggested we look at, we meaning us, other options. Okay, knowing that the construction season was over. So if there's no chance of getting it this year, why would you bother to put it up for one year? It seems like a waste of money. We're moving the rig, which I still don't think the timeline fits.

1:46:05 Okay, we came back with $58,247 and we're told, no, it can't be done because of this, that, and the other thing. And our design would have to run through a structural engineer to make sure the calcs worked. The same engineer that the town didn't hire when they came up with $400,000 to $500,000. Lynn, she reached out to Kathy Cage, who did work for us on her own time. The polls that I suggested didn't work. Yesterday, using the structural engineer's calcs, got a quote that came back at $6,778. That may seem expensive.

1:46:35 But the poles needed for Breckenridge Project were $15,000 each for a grand total of $270,000. Two more minutes. Here's the kicker. $67,000, $78,000 is for 22 poles. $22,000 for less than half the price of one pole for Breckenridge. You can call Totten Tubes right now and confirm. And I have it right here. I have both quotes from Kathy for a stronger pole and that pole. The shade structure price is now down to roughly $25,000 minus the concrete, which I estimate to cost maybe $25,000.

1:47:04 You can bump it to $50,000. We're still under $100,000. Okay, this brings me to my concern with movement stability, which I'm all for a great concept. I would love to have a covered-ranked community center, aquatic center, a large grassy area across the street for events, park, and just a general place to hang out in town. It'd be awesome. My question is live with the timing. I don't believe this can be achieved in two years. It took more than two years to construct the current facility where it sits.

1:47:28 Everyone's putting a lot of faith in the EIR process, which takes forever, by the way, to mitigate issues, light, sounds, traffic. They'll all have to be addressed. The 99 EIR couldn't do this, so why do you think a new one can? Snow Creek has grown since 99. The bluffs have been built out since 99. Affordable housing and all the condos across the street have been built out since 99. I'm sure the EIR will mitigate a lot of the issues, but like Lynn said, you have to go through all those other people. You know, I'm all for moving the rank.

1:47:57 And I just don't think that it can be pulled off by 2017. So what I'm asking you guys to do is let's take the proper time to build the right facility. Get a home run. You know what? Hit a grand slam. Win the goddamn World Series. You know? But do it right. Let's figure it out and do it right. And in the meantime, leave it where it is. Put a shade on it. Give these kids six months of ice to play. Two and a half months isn't enough. And boom, now I'm flashing. Thanks. Thanks, Jeff. Hi, everybody. Melissa Raff.

1:48:35 I apologize in advance if I'm redundant, but I too wrote something and some of it has been covered. I can address a few comments that came up. One was the comment about, I think you might have said you don't know what it means when people say I don't like light. What that means is we come up from various areas and love to see the Milky Way and that gets drowned out with bright lights and I would hate to not be able to see the night sky.

1:49:01 Another thing I just want to say is I like Costco more than Walmart, so for whatever that's worth. A comment about the location. I've heard people say where it is now, it's too hard to find and you'll get more use someplace else. I have never known a hockey player, an ice skater, or a hockey team to not be able to find the rink. That just doesn't happen.

1:49:29 But after the meeting two weeks ago, I was trying not to have too many sleepless nights, but what I kept coming back to was Mr. Dutton's statement that, quote, we will mitigate what we can and move on. It was disturbing to me in several ways, as was the lack of questioning and no resistance on the part of the council to that statement. First of all, I think it demonstrates a complete lack of regard and concern for the residents in the immediate vicinity.

1:49:58 Who during hockey games would certainly lose peaceful, quiet weekends, evenings, and other times for which so many people leave the city and come to the mountains, whether they're owners, full-time residents, or vacation renters, not to mention the drop in value that this disruption would bring to these residences. You were asked if any of you in your travels saw hockey rinks so close to residential homes, and the examples you gave were either not hockey rinks, enclosed hockey rinks,

1:50:26 Or in the case of Crested Butte, much farther away than this rink would be, which goes back to what was said earlier, move it away from the residents, you'll have less resistance from us. Do you really want Mammoth to have the reputation of not caring about investment properties and their owners? Because many such potential owners can easily buy in Utah or other places. Second, this statement, we will mitigate what we can and move on, shows a complete lack of regard for the environment.

1:50:54 Does the council care about environmental damage? If negative effects cannot be avoided, do you really want to just label them overriding circumstances and move on? Overriding circumstances is not meant as a scapegoat to allow a developer or agency to build whatever they want regardless of the damage to the environment. And a flippant attitude like mitigate what we can and move on will simply lead to litigate before we can move on.

1:51:25 As you've heard, will be time-consuming, expensive, include a comprehensive EIR, and take, I read, 9 to 12 months without legal battles. Instead, why not save years and large expenses and all this strife by putting a shade over the current rink, Jeff said, now and spend the necessary time to evaluate not only the financial feasibility of a full-size hockey rink in Mammoth, but where it could go without creating...

1:51:53 Such opposition among residents, investors, and young families who don't want to lose their serene, beautiful park to a big, noisy, intrusive structure. My family has been going to this park for 30 years. Our kids grew up playing at the park. We've met other families with their young kids at the park. Is it really in everyone's best interest to put a hockey rink at Mammoth Creek Park West, even if it makes it unpleasant to enjoy the park or what's left of the park?

1:52:21 Because of overriding circumstances. Do you really want that to be your position and your legacy? And that's all I have to say. Thank you, Melissa. We just want to play hockey. And Breckenridge's outdoor rink opened on Monday. Breckenridge's outdoor rink opened on Monday. And we just want to play hockey. Thank you.

1:53:16 What are they? They're pictures of when we spoke at the last meeting and they mentioned a couple of facilities that were in residential areas. So I googled map like Breckenridge and Crested View and Sun Valley and then a couple were the master plan from Platinum Parks, that kind of stuff. If you can quickly put them up. Nothing racy, I promise. As long as you can do it within five minutes, it's fine. And then how does this mouse work? Yeah, open to view. Thank you, Jamie.

1:54:14 Thanks very much. Okay, after the last meeting, I kept thinking, you know, and we'd spoken to David Frank, and he was saying his extensive visit to hockey rinks. I'm not a hockey player. I haven't been to him. But that doesn't mean I'm against hockey. But I have been to Sun Valley. I mean, my husband's family's had a place there since the 60s, so we spent a tremendous amount of time there. And I got to thinking, there really isn't next-year residential area. So I went on Google and looked it up.

1:54:49 Can you give us your name for the record? Oh, I'm sorry. Sure. Robin Bell. Thank you. So the Sun Valley Lodge, number one, that's very charming. That's not a hockey rink. There's no sides to it. It's also not town property. The lodge owns it, operates it, manages it. It's a big draw. Hours are 10 to 8. It doesn't have to make money. It just has to be a nice little amenity to their lodge, which makes money.

1:55:19 They do have a hockey rink, which is behind this enclosed. See if I can see the building in the back? That's right there enclosed. Chillers are all enclosed. Earthview. Do this quickly. All the surrounding area, this is all Sun Valley Lodge, so it's not into a residential area. Then I went to Breckenridge. Let me see that one.

1:55:57 Its closest house, 250 feet away. It's got a parking lot in between, a street in between, and also the density of some of these places that were mentioned are not anywhere near what Mammoth Creek West is. They're much further away. There's a lot of open space all the way around that. Crested Butte was the closest. Let me find that one. Still, closest facility, 173, 175 feet away.

1:56:30 Quite a bit of difference from the 40 feet that the town had their map out when they did the show through town. Also, not nearly the density. This is a pizza shop. This is a Nordic center. This looks all industrial. You've got your houses back here and, again, not the density there. So I keep thinking that the three times around we keep trying to do this, it seems to be we keep trying to force

1:56:59 A square peg in a round hole, and we keep pounding it in, but the fit isn't going to be there. There's a couple of things I did look at. When I was looking at some of the staff meetings, there was notes about to build or not to build when you were considering the swimming pool. So I found, or someone emailed to me, Ice Skating Institute to build or not to build. An ice rink. One of the things that keep going over and over again is you really need to have a feasibility study by a firm who specializes

1:57:30 In ice arenas. This is important. It's a huge investment. According to them, a single rink, ice rink, it costs $2 to $4 million to build. This is 2014. Well, between $2 to $4 million is quite a bit different from what the costs we're getting. It also states that a single rink takes between two and a half to five anchors of land for the ice rink.

1:57:59 You're trying to cram in a rec center, a community center, an ice rink into what's left of, what is it, three acres out of, no, because you're already using up two acres. So it's going to be two acres. Well, that's what it takes for just the rink. We're cramming so much in. I get the vision. I get the charm of the multi-use facility. I am all in favor of it because I think this town could use some charm. And I think that what you're trying to do is beautiful.

1:58:29 But you're trying to force the square peg into a round hole. It doesn't belong on that parcel. I'd have to go with the gentleman that spoke earlier. Plan it properly. Take the time. Get a feasibility study that makes sense before you take this investment and then have it not work and have years and years of problems. You keep moving it around and then you keep thinking we've got to move it again because it's not the right proper place. So put it in the proper place to begin with.

1:58:56 A couple of other things that came up according to the Ice Skating Institute. Soil condition and water table effects on the arena. Very important, which is why they recommend to have somebody who specializes, an engineer who specializes in ice cream. Situations as a groundwater table or frost susceptible soils under an ice cream create havoc if not properly addressed. The cost of these corrections must carefully be assessed during the feasibility study so no unforeseen financial surprises greet the owner at the time of construction.

1:59:27 Okay. Now, I realize you guys have put a tremendous amount of work into this, and you're frustrated, but let me just go one more thing. A couple of other things they've said as far as they were talking about a lot of facilities that fail. Their recommendation is it takes about 100,000 people in a five-mile area to actually have it pay for itself.

1:59:49 Owners of facilities that have experienced financial difficulties or have closed have had many, some of the very valid reasons for the location of the ice skating facilities. Among these are, one, land that is already owned, saving one of the future facilities owners, eliminating cost of real estate as a barrier to entry in the ice skating industry. So that's not necessarily going to make this successful. Two, land that is favorably zoned, saving time and expense in site plan.

2:00:17 Three, land is affordability due to its location. These don't guarantee success. So you need to reconsider seriously a better solution. Don't let the time constraint of we're running out of time because the lease is up, so we've got to move it quickly, and this is what we've got, this is what we own, and this is where it fits because it doesn't fit. So please consider carefully so that you have the beautiful plan that I think everybody wants.

2:00:46 A skating rink for the hockey players. They want to skate. Put a roof on it. Thanks very much. Thank you, Rob. Do I just pull this out? Good evening, everybody. Dan O'Connell, local homeowner and business owner. I'm going to begin by digressing just for a moment. As a lawyer, we used to give out a jury instruction that said basically do not just weigh the amount of documents on one side versus the other.

2:01:24 One document can carry more weight than 10. And I guarantee you I'm not going to get the applause that some other people have gotten in here. You're going to have to weigh this in a way that is not just counting votes in this room because we could just as soon have another election, and I don't think anybody wants to do that. This is your decision, and it's a very, very important one. Sean Turner, that's all he wanted to convey. You have a very, very important...

2:01:52 I'm a sports person. I like to see things come sooner rather than later. The hockey community has a legitimate concern. They want something done sooner rather than later. But, and I was taken out of context, rushing to the quickest solution, which is throwing up a temporary, you know, shade cover on it.

2:02:22 Or just committing all of our funds to that site because we're already there is not the answer. And I've been to outdoor rinks. I've been to rinks in Switzerland with hotels nearby. I think the noise concerns are overblown. That's my own opinion. And I don't have a stake in this as a skater. Up in North Star, there's a beautiful rink surrounded by...

2:02:51 They don't play hockey there, but there's a lot of drinking and a lot of noise going on, and we're not even going to have alcohol allowed over there. Now, getting to points. Yeah, can the audience please keep your mouth shut? Thank you. You've had your turn, sir. If you haven't spoken yet, you can get out. A lot of people were saying things, so I appreciate the comment. Thank you, Don. Thanks. Okay, here's the problem. There are only three locations that anybody has identified here, and people that are opposed to this are not identifying a fourth location.

2:03:21 Mammoth Creek Park has been mentioned, and I hope, Dieter, you don't mess with my view over there, but if it came to pass, I'd live with that. The problem with Mammoth Creek Park, we can forget about it. It's owned by the U.S. Forest Service. It's Forest Service land. We don't own it, and if we wanted to buy it, it would take years and years and years to possibly consummate a deal, and it would cost a fortune. It's off the table. Now, the current site...

2:03:48 Is a crummy, lousy, ugly, off-the-beaten-path location. This is not something that we can take pride in as a community. Now, we just ranked 25th out of 50 Western resorts in the latest ski magazine polls. Now, I think the whole thing's bogus. It depends on how much you advertise with ski magazine. You're going to get bumped up. But it doesn't matter.

2:04:10 We know, as somebody said, that we lack charm here. There's a lack of charm and ambiance in our town, and we're trying to do something about that. And it's slowly improving, which is fantastic. But this is our opportunity to create a home run, as somebody said. And by the way, it's been vetted. It's been analyzed. I don't see this as half-baked by the town. There's been all kinds of commissions.

2:04:34 And the town council's been thinking about it, the planning department's been thinking about it, Mammoth Lakes Recreation's been thinking about it. It's been analyzed. Now, besides the lousy location, I mean, I would never open up a business over there on a dead-end street. We cannot invest a million and a half to two million dollars of our public funds into land that we do not own. Okay? There's a beach club in Santa Monica, California named the Sand and Sea Club.

2:05:03 Millions of dollars in improvements. Paddle tennis courts, locker rooms, living rooms, food and beverage facilities. The members had an opportunity to purchase that land. They elected to renew the lease. And some years later, the city of Santa Monica said, we want to open up our beaches for greater public access. They did not renew the lease. Every single improvement was lost. Now, it's the same reason the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area won't build at Main Lodge until they own the land.

2:05:32 If you drive up Old Mammoth Road, you see these funky little cabins on Forest Service land and up at the Lakes Basin? The reason they're funky and they're small is because they don't own the land. Over in Bass Lake, where my father has a house in a resort community, PG&E owned all the land, and there are very modest, funky little cabins and homes. PG&E sold all the land, all the property owners, and there's a huge construction boom with teardowns, remodels, Taj Mahals going up. We cannot...

2:06:01 Put millions of dollars into that property. There's no guarantee that it will be renewed. And 20 years from now, when we're all gone, and they don't renew the lease if that comes to pass, people will be going, what the hell happened? You know? So we can't. That's not a solution. Neither is Mammoth Creek Park East. So where are we going to go? The only spot is over here at Mammoth Creek Park West.

2:06:27 I saw signs go up. I heard about it. Save the park. I don't get that. We're not tearing out the park, the kiddie park. It's sagebrush that needs to be used and put to its highest and best purpose, and you, we, the town, own it. I heard about Sun Valley and how we should do things like Sun Valley, you know, and how dysfunctional Mammoth is, and we're not developing things the proper way. Sun Valley wouldn't put their attraction, their amenity over where that current location is.

2:07:00 I see the lights blinking. Yeah, your time's up. If you can wrap up, it'd be great. Yeah. I understand the concerns of the ice rink, you know, the serious skaters. We want to get it done, but you guys have done the work. Let's do it. The homeowners, there's four units that don't even face. They face north and they face south, not east. It's a big wall with four windows. And, you know, my final point is this.

2:07:29 I don't know if there's a single person in this room that would put a million and a half to two million dollars to build a home on land that is leased from a government entity or anybody else. So I don't understand why the town's being asked to do that. I don't think it's right. I don't think it's wise. I want to see this community rise in its quality for us, the community members, and also the resort guests. We need to step it up. This is the home run that I heard talked about.

2:07:59 And the analysis has been finished. Thank you very much. I went over, but it's an important matter. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Just for everyone coming up, when it beeps, that means the time's up, not to continue because it's flashing. So if you can try to keep your comments within the time, it would be great so we can get through this. Okay. I'm Tom Bell. I'm the coordinator for the over 200 families who oppose this. And, Dan, I'm going to say,

2:08:29 I get your point about a courtroom, but thank God we live in a democracy and not a courtroom. And we do look at votes, not who comes up with the strongest argument, it's who comes up with what's popular, what the community wants. We didn't want to do this, but last week when Grady made his comments about not worrying about the environment, we really felt we were put in a box. So I've got to deliver this to you. We naturally are going to get legal representation.

2:09:00 You can't live with what Grady said. That we'll mitigate some things and then we'll move on. Two weeks ago, I asked the town council to look at the proposal and seriously read it because it wasn't good. It wasn't well done. As Robin pointed out, it wasn't factual. Can we put up a picture of... Pardon me. I shout loud enough so I don't think I need this. Can we put up your picture again of the...

2:09:30 Of your rink? Grady, maybe you can help me out here. Do we have a map? Because, Grady, you asked us to give you specifics. And yet, I see a picture in part with no rink on it. That seems to me an important specific. Where's the rink? Is Jeff still here? I'm sure if we were up against the hockey players, I went, oh no, we're in trouble. They're big and strong. They're going to be a well-organized force. And Jeff comes to me and goes, no, that's not what we want.

2:10:15 The homeowners want it where it is, and then I find out the hawkers want it where it is. Jeff presented more detailed analysis, Dan and Grady, than you did. That's not his job. He's not drawn a salary to do that, and yet he goes through all this work and does, like I said, go back to the proposal. Those numbers have been nonsense in it. Tom, if you could restrain from attacking staff, that would be helpful. Just kind of make your point. It would be great. My point is,

2:10:45 Go to that proposal. It's not accurate. It's not factual. I'm not attacking them. I'm saying read through it. They shouldn't be asking the homeowners to do the analysis. You guys, each of you, should be provided with good analysis. We should be provided with specifics. As I look up on this, I don't have a hockey rink there. I saw a proposal that said Sun Valley has a hockey rink right behind their lodge. I've been there for 50 years. I'm an old guy.

2:11:14 But you can go to Google Earth. It's a phone call to find this stuff out. This is being rushed. And people have said that over and over again. We're rushing into a decision here on bad analysis. And the bad analysis is coming from a false assumption. And that false assumption is that you cannot be happy on leased land. And when I spoke last time, I told you I originally was a finance guy. And I can tell you from the finance world, when you get on an airplane,

2:11:42 Chances are that airline doesn't own that airplane, and yet they run a profitable and successful airline still. And I bet you there's a lot of entrepreneurs in this room who don't own the property they're on and are still successful. I heard, we don't know what you're going to do in 20 years, but every communication I've seen shows that we're not willing to work with the community, we're not willing to work with the school district.

2:12:11 Let's go back to, if there's something in that lease we don't like, let's go back and try. We don't need to own the property. Their own proposal said a 30-year lease is as good as the assets are going to last. So why are we operating, again, on a false assumption? And this assumption is that we have to own it. And that because it's allowed, because it's zoned, that it's a good idea, and we're coming up with...

2:12:40 A Jurassic Park argument that because we can do it, we should do it. And I think we need to step back from that and realize that's not a good argument. I think we need to look back and say, should we work with the community? As several people have gotten up and said, should we work with the school district? And I think we're looking at bad analysis. And I'm going to ask the same thing I asked two weeks ago. I'm going to ask the town council to go back.

2:13:09 To the staff and say, let's analyze this properly. Let's get our facts straight. Let's get our numbers straight. And then let's go to the community and present something. But instead, I have you guys coming to us and saying, could you present the specifics? And again, I think you've got to ask the staff to do their job. And I'm going to close with that. And decent timing. Thank you, Tom. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission. And as someone who spends a lot of time in Suite Z, I have to say it's really exciting to see.

2:13:50 All these people here because we really do care about public engagement and we really are happy to hear your comments. And I think Grady mentioned that and I just want to say on behalf of a staff I'm fortunate to work with, they're very sincere in that. So on the task force side, because I did sit on the task force, I just wanted to just mention quickly that the task force did vet a number of other options which are all outlined in the packet this evening. So those are definitely worth taking a look at.

2:14:20 And I've been on the commission long enough to see processes that are staff-driven, and this is definitely not one of them. So at our Recreation Commission meeting on October 13th, we've had this as a standing item on our commission agendas for quite a while. But on the 13th, with one of our commissioners absent, who's on his wedding trip, the commission voted unanimously 4-0 to support the task force recommendation.

2:14:48 And in fact, Commissioner Sauser made the motion. And the commission's been actively engaged in this for a number of years, which I'm sure Commissioner Sauser could speak to far more eloquently than I. And I appreciated Commissioner Turner's comments earlier, requesting that the council take action. Because the desire of the commission is really to move forward expeditiously with this project.

2:15:13 We really want to proceed with the design and environmental review work because we want to answer the concerns that are being raised in the community. And until we're able to proceed with that work, it won't be possible to deal with those concerns and the potential mitigations. And I just wanted to say another word about

2:15:37 One of the things that the commission is really excited about is the opportunity for us and for the recreation department to have complementary facilities. For us to be able to have a multi-use facility and also a community center that works and the efficiencies of being able to have both of those staffed in one place would be a huge opportunity. It would be a tremendous improvement over what our staff is currently able to do with our existing facilities.

2:16:07 Made a really good statement, which I'm going to share. And that was, our hope is that we can embrace this project as a community. And we challenge the staff to anticipate the challenges and respond to the concerns of the community by moving forward with design and environmental documentation for the work. And I believe that as a commission, we can all really stand behind that statement. We're eager to work with the community on dealing with these concerns and also programming a really fantastic facility. Thank you.

2:16:36 Thank you, Betsy. Betsy said most of it. First, I want to admit the staff have done a good job as the staff before. To say that I have reached my opinions on this and I am pushing for this way too quickly, well, I've wasted 30 years of my life working on this quickly. We've got a lot of information. I want to point out a few things. At the school, we cannot operate. One of the opponents got up and said that for a rink to be successful,

2:17:11 We need to be able to operate it all day long, every day, to recoup. I agree. We can't do that at that site. It's not in our lease. Exclusive use only for the school during daylight hours on school days. They have chosen never to use it. However, in the lease, we can't do that. That goes away. Hockey in Mammoth is never going to be large enough to support this rink on their own. In Mammoth, we have to have facilities that are a draw for the tourists as well as the locals so that we can provide more for our locals.

2:17:41 Than what a town of this size normally can. And that's how we have achieved everything we've achieved. That's how we have a great trail system. That's how we have all of this. Hockey alone cannot do it. This is not a hockey rink. This is a multi-use facility. Where it sits currently, I believe, it can never be successful enough to warrant putting a roof on it or doing anything else. We need to get it into a place where we can create a business plan where it can be successful as a year-round facility.

2:18:11 And draw in those people. Or we just need to close it and take that money and move it for a whole lot and use it for bigger bang for our buck in other areas to draw people in and have better recreation. I'm stumbling. I normally don't do that, guys. Sorry. I agree with the kids who want to play hockey. I really want them to play hockey. So I want us to create a successful rink. And the only place I see for that.

2:18:39 Is at Mammoth Creek Park West. Mitigate the problems that the homeowners have with it. Other than the fact that they just want sagebrush outside their homes, I understand that. It's been planned as an active use park since day one, since we had to trade the land that was in the village that we owned for this when we decided not to have affordable housing there. It has been planned as an active use park. So it's going to have something there that creates noise, that creates kids, that creates parking issues.

2:19:07 Why not the rink? Let's move this thing. Let's get it done. Let's make it a good facility. Thank you. Unless you have questions. Thanks, Bill. Yeah. John Walter, Advocates for Mammoth. I'd like you to think for a minute about some of the history of rushed projects that people got enthusiastic about and climbed on board and took off on in Mammoth over the years.

2:19:45 It resulted in lots of delay, lots of headbanging together. Finally, usually a resolution and things getting resolved, but it took a lot of time, a lot of effort, a lot of working together. Going all the way back to when the town was first incorporated, I wasn't here then, Bill probably remembers it, that the Friends of Mammoth first suit, that whether there was enough water to support all the ambitious plans.

2:20:15 Where Andrea Lawrence put together the group that kind of brought things to a halt for a while and made them go back and do their planning right. Warner was involved in a Heart of Mammoth thing that ended up with a vote of the people that said, no, we don't want to do anything but leave it as affordable housing, which wasn't what the planners were looking at at the time.

2:20:41 It came in with a redevelopment plan. Everybody got excited. It had a piece in it for everybody. It had some schools. It had some fire stations. It added up to $165 million. Of course, it also had all of the infrastructure for the village, which was eventually paid for by the village after the redevelopment was shot down. And it even had the village gondola was part of it. And it declared most of Mammoth a blighted area.

2:21:11 That took about five years before it died at the Supreme Court level. I don't know what it cost the town in studies and engineering and redevelopment planners and all of that, but I know it was a couple million dollars leased in attorney fees. And the general plan update. The town came out with one that...

2:21:39 It was going to have 65,000 PAOT, just about double what we run now. And this had been worked on for a couple of years and kind of just got dumped out there and people gulped at that being that big at that time. A lot of opposition rose up. It took about five years of banging heads together and getting things done.

2:22:05 We really weren't getting anywhere until Rusty came down off the mountain and dragged some old-timers like Tom Cage and myself and Gordon Alper into the same room, and we came out with some compromises that made it into the general plan. And there was some pretty good enthusiasm about following that for a while with an attempt to plan Main Street.

2:22:33 Old Mammoth Place and some things like that. But I get the feeling right now where something comes along, like, oops, here's a way, we need a roof for the ice rink, so let's bring in that multi-use facility that got shot down years ago. Or, oh, we've got to sneak the swimming pool in somewhere.

2:22:58 Back in the planning days of the general plan, there was a master facilities list and people prioritized things and you didn't just grab an ice rink or a swimming pool and slip them in because, boy, there was an excuse to do it. You had a list of things that you'd prioritized and the voters had pretty much said they sort of agreed that was a good way to do the thing.

2:23:26 You know, the airport was sort of the same way. It grew like topsy to get some things moving down there. There was a development agreement that was going to put hotels and trailer courts and lots of things down there. And at the same time, a plan to bring out a big airport with about a quarter of a million visitors, I mean, employments per year. That's not visitors.

2:23:55 And the two ended up conflicting with each other, and you can, you know, guess at whose fault on a lot of that, but it cost the town over $40 million and a bankruptcy. And, you know, grabbing these things in isolation and not going back and doing the hard work of making sure you got people on board.

2:24:20 You know, don't charge ahead where people are still saying, no, that's wrong, that's wrong, you know. Get some people together, lock them in a room or something, but get some consensus before you go out and get committed to this thing. You'll get there faster, cheaper, and be very careful about getting it too big. It's almost a, it's just so tempting.

2:24:46 When you're going to put a facility in, you say, well, okay, let's put the swimming pool here and let's put the executive suite up there for the town council. That'd be nice. It hardly costs any more, you know, to add that in, but things just grow and pretty soon it just topples over like a house of cards. So don't jump into this thing. Go do your planning. You know, I don't think there's...

2:25:14 Any real demand from the citizenry, the voters, for a community center right now, the little one out by the old one, it gets pretty good use, and it's still there. The, you know, the parks, blubbers and things like that.

2:25:37 The noise haters, a lot of people really disagree about Mammoth West as the right place to put it. You've got to figure out a way to mitigate some of that in advance if that's what you're really going to do, not just let people go away mad talking about referendums and lawsuits and things like that. So, you know, do your homework. Figure out a way to, you know, get the kids the cheapest shade they can get right now.

2:26:06 Hockey enthusiasts have just done a terrific job of, you know, I can remember when they, they were the ones that actually put the rink up for the first few years. They may still be doing it. Can you wrap up, John? Yeah, I'm done. Thank you. And so, you know, don't rush into it. You're just opening up Pandora's box. Thank you, John. Mayor, Town Council, ladies and gentlemen.

2:26:39 I'm Sharon Clark, Sharon Raven Clark. There are several Sharon Clarks around. Our community is hurting. People have not been nice to each other lately. Our town is horribly divided. If you pass this item tonight, you will add fuel to this fire. We have said over and over we do not want it at the Mammoth Creek Park West.

2:27:11 Could you find some project that we as a community can get behind, can work together, cooperate? You have talented people. And John and I didn't talk ahead of time, but we're saying virtually the same thing. You've got talented people that can get us together, let us cooperate, let us move together.

2:27:41 Please, haste makes waste. Thank you for your patience. Thank you, Sharon. My name is Cronus Dillard, C-R-O-N-U-S, last name Dillard. So I'll be brief. I guarantee you won't hear a beep before I step away. I don't live in Mammoth, so I don't vote here. But I have a hockey team that I coach out of Bishop. I have about 25 kids on it.

2:28:18 I think this season four of them are from Mammoth. So the other thing is we do spend a lot of money at the rink over the last two seasons. We've spent several thousand dollars and I would like to spend more money there, but the season is so short that that limits how much rink time we can get. So we play in a league down south and they start in September, go through March.

2:28:46 So in order to be competitive, I had to recently spend $12,000 on synthetic ice for the team. I mean, I'm having the team help me with it because I can't afford that. But I would have preferred to give that money to the town of Mammoth. Today I ordered a skate sharpener because synthetic ice stalls their skates quickly. So in order to get the most out of synthetic ice, now there's another $2,500. That could have been money going to the town. So I don't, you know, I found out about this meeting.

2:29:13 24 hours and 26 minutes ago, so I don't have a lot of background on history, and I can't say what the best solution is, but I do know that there's an opportunity for you guys to bring in more revenue, not just to the rink directly, but I'd like to be able to have teams from the league down south come up and do tournaments. So each team has about 15 to 20 players. That's 15 to 20 hotel rooms. So if we get, you know.

2:29:42 Thank you.

2:30:23 Good evening, Town Council. My name is Jay Cole. I'm here to just point out one thing that we haven't really heard from, real statistical numbers from an operating rink in a similar community like our own. South Lake Tahoe operates their rink full-time, but it does not take full-time to actually make that rink run profitably.

2:30:50 They collect 71% of their revenues in 8% of their operating hours. The rest of the time it's open because it's open and the school kids use it and there's other programs and what have you, but 71% of the revenue is collected during 8% of their operating hours and that's due to tournaments essentially. So hockey tournaments come in, they raise a lot of money, pays for the rink, they can operate it in 8% of their operating hours. Thank you. Thanks, Jeff. Is there anybody else?

2:31:24 Okay, seeing none, I'm going to close the public comment period and bring it back to the diocese of the council for discussion. Would you like to go first? I'll go first. Sure. First, I want to thank the task force for the work they did over the last couple of months. They did the due diligence. They looked at the options. I appreciate them for bringing back what I had hoped we would see was not, was...

2:31:49 How complementary facilities would work as opposed to just picking up the current concrete slab and moving it over. So I'm really happy to see that that has been worked through. And I also appreciate the time that the Recreation Commission and Mammoth Lakes Recreation did in working through this. And not to pick on Todd, but he is right. Some of the comments he made, he was against it until he could see.

2:32:14 Actually the works and that the due diligence had been done if I'm not putting words in his mouth. I also thank everybody who spoke at our last meeting and this meeting for your concerns. I'm a little bit puzzled that you've all decided what it's going to look like when a design has not even been started. So the concerns are there. I'm the one who asked staff to write them all down so that you would see that they're being taken seriously. I've got all the notes from the last two meetings also.

2:32:44 Those concerns, we're not saying you're going to design it. It's let us know what your concerns are. I am going to take exception to someone who made the comments about environmental impact reports. Having been on planning commission and council, we have considered things. I have never agreed to anything with statements of a variety of consideration, and I will not. I believe that.

2:33:11 Grady was misstated in saying that the mitigations could be worked on. I heard clearly that there are considerations. I understand how that works. So I went back and picked up our general plan. Not only was I one of the people on the commission when this was approved, I still consider it our Bible.

2:33:32 I first started just putting a blue sticky on every page that talked either about recreation or our protection of the stream and being stewards of our area, et cetera. Well, I got to putting a blue sticky on every page that stated that because the words are in this general plan from the community vision down to the resource management last chapter.

2:33:57 There are some specific things that I would hope people would read along with the complete document we had. In 2007, it was very clear that the Mammoth Creek Corridor and the recreation, as Bill Sauser said, would be active recreation. When we approved as a town an urban growth boundary,

2:34:20 previous to that but have carried it forward that said we would not sprawl. The other side of that decision is that you will develop within your town limits. The reality is that we have everything in place to do this correctly. We have the input. I hope the input keeps coming. I don't know if any of the people who are providing input tonight went to any of those task force group meetings but I know those same issues were discussed at that point as well.

2:34:49 We have the ability to do this. We have the ability to do it well. And although the decision was made last summer to not continue the lease, I guess people cannot just accept that. But from my perspective, we continue on the path we are on. And we move forward with the design and environmental work for the complementary facilities, which is what's being presented to us. Thank you, Jo.

2:35:21 Sure. Yeah, I think, Joe, I think you said a lot of things that I had thought about saying and said them very well, so I won't repeat them. I think from my vantage point, I can't speak on the same level that someone like Bill Sauser can as far as the history of this. All I can do is do my best to inform myself to the degree that I can. I take that very seriously because I understand that this is a serious consideration for this community.

2:35:51 I've spent, you know, months and months, you know, working through this. Jeff alluded to some of that. I appreciate the shout-out as being the top two in the room as far as concerned with the roof. I don't think that's fair necessarily. I think you've certainly done more work than I have. But this is something that I have an interest in, and my interest is mostly on a broader scope for improving the recreation experience for our community.

2:36:20 I've said from the day I decided to run for council that one of my primary goals was improving our amenity base. I think our man-made environment here does not complement our spectacular natural environment. And I'm interested in trying to execute, move things out of the planning phase and into execution and improving the recreation experience for people that live here and people that come and visit.

2:36:45 During that process, I did read the entire 356-page 99 EIR. So it is something that I'm pretty well versed with. As Joe mentioned, that document looked at a somewhat different project, but in a lot of ways very similar. It looked at all of the considerations that have been brought up tonight. Everything in that document was either deemed to be no significance, less than significant.

2:37:14 We're able to be mitigated to a level of less than significance. As Rich alluded to, one of the primary conclusions in the document was the alternate design, which specifically stated that a multi-use facility and community center should be built in conjunction on that location to achieve the goals of the town and also take into consideration the concerns of all the neighboring condo owners.

2:37:44 I don't take that lightly. I'm very, very sensitive to the comments that have been made tonight. I've tried to do my best to talk to everyone that I can. And I do recognize that we probably don't have unanimous agreement here on council and that we don't have unanimous agreement in this room. It is not my intent to just push past concerns. I think a lot of the concerns that have been brought up are very valid, and we should continue to engage with them during the process.

2:38:13 We haven't designed the facility yet. We haven't cited the facility yet. All of that will come should the council decide to make that decision tonight. But as far as the process goes, you know, the way I view it, this community engaged in this back in 99. This community engaged at this particular location again in the Plan Your Parks process, which is a very well-vetted process with a lot of community engagement.

2:38:40 The unanimous consensus of this community was that Mammoth Creek Park West was a location that the community wanted to see recreation facilities built. We then moved on to the decision that the council made to not renew the lease. I don't think it makes sense to go through that decision again. I made that decision. I was part of the 4-1 vote to not renew that lease. All of the rationale that I had then stands today.

2:39:09 I think the council is well within its rights to adjust its thinking in lieu of new information. I haven't seen anything that changes my opinion that that was the right move to not renew that lease. So then we asked our recommending bodies to come back to us and say, on the assumption that we are not renewing that lease, where is the best location for this facility? And we had a unanimous vote from our recreation commission, which is a recommending body for us.

2:39:37 We had a unanimous consensus from the multi-use task force which looked at all these issues and we had a 4-1 vote from MLR. To me, the decision has been made from our community. This is the recommendation to us. I don't see information to the contrary to vote against that recommendation. I really do hear the concerns of the neighbors and I hope that we can continue to keep the lines of communication open.

2:40:07 But I think that is what is in the best interest of the community, and that's where I stand. Thanks, Colin. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'm going to hit on a couple, follow up on a couple things that Colin and Joe said. From my perspective, this started with a discussion about putting a roof over the ice rink, which is a noble and intelligent thing to want to do.

2:40:40 But the very next question is, well, wait a minute, we don't own that property. So money's tight. We've got to be fiscally wise. Why would we, you know, that's kind of a troubling thing. Why would we want to put, invest in infrastructure that we don't own? And I think it's very important to address this question to maybe revisit this a little bit. The school district is not an airport or an airplane leasing company.

2:41:08 They're not a private concern that's in the business of renting property for recreation facilities. That's not what they do. They did this community a favor many years ago when the community was trying to find a place to put this ice rink, and they said, okay, well, you need a place to put it. We'll help you out. We put together a leasing agreement, and it was a temporary situation. They did us a good favor. And I think that they have been generous to us still.

2:41:37 They've extended a lease on the terms that they feel comfortable with. But I think that we are all committed to the success of this community. And there's going to come a day when the school district is going to identify an opportunity for that land. It might be a child care facility. It might be more classrooms. It might be something that's going to really benefit this community. And it would be, I don't know what the right word is, but it would be irresponsible.

2:42:04 It would be bequeathing to a partner of ours a situation, this decision and this course that we're on to dump that back on the school district 10, 15 years from now to say, okay, well, you know what you want to build now, you want to do it, but we've got millions of dollars invested in a facility. We have advocates and proponents for that facility that don't want to see that thing go away.

2:42:30 That's not a situation I want to extend to a partner like the school district. And I think the decision the council made is a responsible one. So I'm comfortable with that and I think we need to move on. I think to Joe's point about the UGB I think is a very, very important one. I think one of the great values of this community is to have constrained our growth. And there's been a lot of capital invested in that boundary.

2:42:54 But with that opportunity comes the recognition that we have to deal with some challenging and difficult problems to make that really work. And this is a classic and a very good example of that kind of a challenge. Folks, we're talking about a park.

2:43:12 We're talking about a park that is designated to be used for the community for developed recreation. And I'm very encouraged to hear tonight all of the representations of folks who want to work together, to want to work together with the community and the staff to come up with the best solution that we can. These are the kinds of things that we're going to have to do living in a very constrained private landmass. And I certainly welcome everybody to the table to figure out how we're going to do this. And I want to just remind everybody that the question before us right now,

2:43:42 is to begin preliminary design and environmental documentation. This is the process whereby we're going to work out a lot of your concerns, and we're going to make this thing work. This is the challenge to this community, to take our limited and constrained space and come up with good, effective solutions we can all get behind. This is a great opportunity. I'm satisfied with the analysis to date. I've sat in many of these multi-use facility meetings.

2:44:09 I've been in the MLR meetings. Tom said it very eloquently. I followed Tom's path through this. I went to some of those first meetings, and Tom's telling me, look, this is crazy. This doesn't make any sense. And this was not a staff-driven process. This was a process of leaders in your community, MLR board members, recreation commission members, council members, beating this problem up and coming with a solution, and I've got to support it. And I do support it.

2:44:40 Again, I think we're on the right path. And I think that the degree to which we all ask hard questions and we work together, we're going to come up with a solution that we're going to be proud of. I'm getting a lot of interesting emails, a lot of interesting comments from folks. I just want to reassure everybody that's the intent of this council to the degree that we agree on it and this community to build the best thing we possibly can. And these are the kinds of challenges and opportunities that we need to face, we need to meet, we need to rise to. And I'm confident that we can. Thank you.

2:45:10 Thanks, John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Okay. I'm going about this in a different way. John, you mentioned money's tight. I agree with you. I also want to go back to our original agreement, because I happened to be around, as Bill was, when we decided to move the ice rink from the RV park to its current location. We signed a 30-year deal. 30-year deal.

2:45:46 The reason we got out of it is because of the airport deal. But we had a 30-year deal there. So somebody was thinking that thing was going to be staying there for a while. Now, I know the financial constraints of our town right now. We are going to be going into some budget meetings shortly where we're going to have to be cutting monies.

2:46:21 Where we spend our money's best. It's not that I don't want the ice rink. I actually do want the ice rink. I just don't know that it's the right thing to do now, to build it now. And I have concerns about Mammoth Creek Park West and the issues that the homeowners brought up. I hope in the future that MLR, MLT, the town gets together and says, okay, we have a constrained

2:46:56 Landmass right now. We need to add to it if we're going to put all these great amenities that we want. We have to look at acquiring, or start the process at least, of acquiring additional lands. Not just for an ice rink, but for an outdoor events area, because I guarantee you, sooner or later, Sam's Wood Site is going to go away. And we better start that process now. So I believe our monies are best spent now.

2:47:28 Starting that process. We just did a ribbon cutting ceremony out by the propane tanks here. Bill brought up a great point to me. He said, Shields, boy, we should have, you know, continued the parking lot because this is the place where people will come and recreate and do snow play. Wow, how expensive is that? I think my comment was,

2:47:59 Would I rather do that, or would I rather spend the money right now on an ice rink? Quite honestly, I think we get more bang for the buck doing that. I think we have to go out and really take a look at how we're spending the money. I think our sequencing is off a little bit about what we want and when we want to do it. We don't have a lot of money right now. I think in the future, we could have a lot more money.

2:48:32 And I think MLR will have the opportunity to go out and find that private partner to actually build an ice rink that is probably enclosed, you know, in four to five years, give them that opportunity to go out and find that public-private partnership. We don't have that right now. I just think that we're doing this a little too quick. But that's my opinion.

2:49:03 I appreciate all the work everybody's done. You know, it's not easy sitting up here and listening to our community bicker back and forth. What I want to do is, you know, have those meetings up front and those task force, and I encourage, you know, all the homeowners to come and be a part of it because that's where you're hurt. By the time you get here, you know,

2:49:36 We kind of go in this back and forth, and it doesn't accomplish much. So, you know, please, when we call for these meetings and call for the times where we're discussing these programs or amenities to town, be a part of it. Thank you. Thanks, Shields. I want to first thank everyone for coming out. A lot of great comments.

2:50:09 I want to acknowledge that. I also want to acknowledge John, falling up with shields. He said two critical things to me. We haven't really talked much about it tonight. Money's tight and fiscally wise. I was one of the four votes to be supportive of the concept to find a long-term permanent solution for this facility. And as I've said, I'm not interested in throwing good money after bad. So that's not changed for me at all.

2:50:41 I'm struggling now, though, you know, to make this move today, consider our financial situation that we have in town. I have less issues with the site itself. I think that a lot of the issues, concerns will be addressed in the document. We are just, as John stated, we're just starting to do that. We're being asked to start that work.

2:51:06 Primary concerns are simply two things with me. One, and some of you mentioned, is the time. We've talked a lot. I've mentioned it. It's 2017, 2019, or 20, or 25, or whatever it may be. More importantly, though, the cost. I mean, we don't have any money. It's pretty simple. Our next council meeting, two weeks away, we're going to be faced again.

2:51:36 As Shields just mentioned, with $300,000 in budget cuts. Again, I've been on this council for almost four years. All we've done is cut and cut and cut and cut and cut. And now we're trying to figure out how to spend $2 million to build a new site. So to me, it really comes back to best use of our funds today. I mean, what is driving as we're...

2:52:07 Dealing with an MLT board, we just had this discussion to drive visitation, drive to take that budget of ours, as we talked at our strategic meetings, $25 million by 2025. What are we going to do to get there? I mean, and if we're not going to get there, if we're not going to have amenity assets that are going to drive revenue to help us get there, I mean, all this stuff is going to continue to be dialogue for the next 20 years.

2:52:40 So I'm struggling with really understanding if this is the best use of funds today to be able to go out and commit this, or is there other projects that may or may not have higher priorities that may give us a better ROI in the community? We're looking to use $150,000 out of the general fund from the public works, utilizing $300,000 out of Measure R. At the very least, $150,000, I think, should be put back into the general fund.

2:53:11 You know, cut our shortfall of $300,000 to $150,000 and utilize the other money out of Measure R if that's what Council wants to do. So, again, I mean, I'm just, I'm supportive of a long-term solution, no doubt about it. I'm supportive of this amenity. I think it's a great amenity. I just don't know if today is the time to commit this money. So, that's my comments.

2:53:39 Michael, do I understand you correctly that you're suggesting that rather than use what's called set-aside funding is to do the next steps with part of the Measure R allocation? I would suggest that you don't use the $150,000 out of the public works money, the general fund money. So that's what you're saying. And taking it out of R. Right. So you could put that $150,000 back if that's a consensus. That's what you meant to say. Okay.

2:54:09 So is there any other further discussion by council? I just had a couple of comments that I'd be remiss if I didn't say. One thing that Jeff had brought up regarding skepticism around the timeline and what that means in the interim, I think, you know, in my thought to elevate the level of amenity quality that we have here, I think those are two facilities, our community center.

2:54:36 And our current ice rink facility that are not up to snuff. They're not befitting of a resort destination. And I can say that as somebody that uses the facility, it's just not where it needs to be without a roof and without some other improvements. So I think where we're at now, we're giving some direction to our staff.

2:54:58 I think we're putting some faith in our staff and in this community to execute. We have not executed very well in the past, and I think we're putting that charge out a little bit, similar to when we had the discussion around the solid waste facility. We said we are putting that charge to our staff to go out and negotiate an agreement with Mono County that works for both partners where we haven't been able to do that in the past.

2:55:28 So I think we are putting that charge out there to the staff. They've given us numbers and figures as far as cost and moving. They've given us timelines, and I understand there's skepticism out there because we haven't executed in the past. I'm hopeful that we can execute in the future, otherwise I wouldn't be up here. And I think we have to get on board with this as a community and try and do that.

2:55:57 I do want to make one mention on the shade structure. I think the task force did quite a bit of due diligence regarding that facility. I don't have the technical expertise of a structural engineer, so I'm kind of at the mercy of the estimates that were given. I will keep the same stance regarding the temporary shade structure at the temporary facility that

2:56:20 If something can be brought before this council that's reasonable cost-wise, I'm very willing to consider doing that in the interim. We've had enough conversations, Jeff, where I understand that your major concern is just extending the season for the kids in the most expedient way possible, and I totally support that. So if we have a shade structure conversation where we cannot arrive at a number that works, and I think that that was the case we were in in the multi-use task force, I understand that.

2:56:49 If there's new information that can be brought before us, I'm willing to consider that. So that's just one thing I wanted to mention. And I do hope that we can get behind this idea of executing this facility and bringing this town into a new era of getting documents off of shelves and actually getting a shovel in the ground. I mean, that's my hope. And I get the skepticism.

2:57:17 I hope that we can just band together as a community and work towards this. Colin, I want just a point of clarification. So you're saying that if this is passed and we meet the timelines, that you would support investing in some type of shade structure for two years? I think that is difficult for me to articulate based on cost and timeline.

2:57:48 And I think those are two unknowns right now. Right. I'm not willing to preclude it. That's what I'm saying. Gotcha. I think if we can get behind this idea and it's realistic that the facility is open in 2017, which I believe maybe that takes some of the impetus to do that off the table. But, you know, as of right now, I'm hearing some skepticism on the timeline and the cost of those type of things.

2:58:10 In lieu of information, I'm just saying I'm not taking it completely off the table. And I say the comments that I say tonight, recognizing that some people are not going to be happy with any decision that's made up here. I have a tremendous amount of respect for this council and everybody up here. I think everybody brought up very valid points. We are very financially constrained, and we have to be cognizant of that. We have to think about ways that we can grow our revenue and drive visitation.

2:58:39 To me, there's two parts when you talk about being a destination resort. One of them is driving visitation to your location to generate revenue. The other part on the back end, which we haven't talked about a ton, is providing the experience that people want when they come up here. And if we provide them a great experience, they're going to want to come back. They're going to want to tell their friends.

2:59:03 And it grows our revenues in the long run based on providing that value experience. So I think in moving towards a destination resort, there's kind of a two-fold goal that we need to be working towards. One is driving more visitation, and number two is providing better amenities and a better experience so that we're providing the value that we're putting out there with our marketing dollars. So that's why I support something like this. I think we have voter initiatives out there like R&U that were put in place.

2:59:32 Specifically to improve the recreation infrastructure in this community when you talk about Measure R. And I understand it gets complicated when we get down to the details, talking about what's restricted, what's general fund, what's not. I've spent enough time working through the finances with Dan that I believe we have some restricted dollars that are specifically tied to this purpose.

2:59:54 That is where we can utilize executing on a better facility. And like I said, I recognize that there's a lot of valid points out there, and this is just the one that I have. Thanks for the clarification. In trying to take into consideration your comments, Michael, I need a little bit of a reminder since I haven't been actively involved in MLR for the last couple of months. Was the roof put into one of the complex?

3:00:22 Capital Projects? It was. Okay. So then my question to you, Dan, is are there sufficient funds in the Mellow Roos district fees to cover this first part, this $150,000, without going into general fund, and then also now that we have a better project asking MLR to reconsider and bring forward an appropriate allocation?

3:00:50 For the ice rink, now that we have a much better defined project than MLR saw last February. Yeah, I'll start on that. Thank you. The MLR site for a moment, sorry. The Mellon Roos District fees, there's some dollars in that fund that could be utilized. In terms of utilizing them just for the study and stuff, you can likely do that. The way the expenditure plan talks about is for, you know, the operations and construction of facilities that add.

3:01:20 Or from where they were at. It doesn't specifically address, as I recall, the planning and environmental work. I'm assuming you'd have to do that to do a facility. So there are dollars sitting there. There's just over $150,000 in that fund.

3:01:37 I think there would be no question in terms of using the major R funding for that work in terms of the park development and those pieces. I can do some additional research on that. Well, my concern is changing the motion that was trying to craft to not use the set-aside funding, to use Mellow Roos until there is time for MLR to reconsider what funding could be provided now that we have a much better defined project than last February.

3:02:02 Yeah, in terms of coming back with the recommendations, the use of HR funds. But to start moving. Okay. Not to hold this off because we do have a tight timeline. When you say a much better defined project, what do you mean by that? When I was on MLR board last February and we had the allocations, it was we need $300,000 for a roof on the ice rink. That was the entire, that was, there was no more detail than that. Now that we've had the task force and they've gone back and they've figured out all of this.

3:02:30 It's more like asking for, saying we're ready for that complex capital project to be considered and brought forward. There were several that we put in kind of a holding facility, and now that we've closed out another year, I think it's reasonable to consider starting with the Mellow Roos funding and then asking for a reconsideration of what might be the recommendation out of our, and potentially, you, funds.

3:02:58 Grady, can you go through the cost of – The project cost? Well, no, no, no. Just what's in front of us now. What's in front of us now. Yeah, the environmental – and planning and architecture.

3:03:13 And there's really two parts to it. And we are estimating $150,000. We don't have any solid proposals yet. In fact, if you direct us to move forward, our first step is to talk to an environmental consultant. We've actually, on a tentative basis, set up a conference call in a week or so to do that. Our estimate in talking to the planning department is that the environmental document would be in the neighborhood of $100,000. We added $50,000 to that because we want to ensure that

3:03:40 The preliminary design that we bring forward for that environmental document is completely vetted that we do have the opportunity to do public outreach, that we do have the opportunity to look at alternatives on the site. And again, that's why there's...

3:03:52 There's no rink there because we don't know precisely where it's going to go and what's best for the neighborhood and everything. So we put $50,000 in there for that effort. My own estimate is that that should be less than that and the environmental might be a little bit more. So we thought $150,000 should cover it. If we get proposals from an A&E team to do the preliminary design and a proposal for the environmental...

3:04:15 The consultant that are different than that, we will certainly be back to you before we take any steps to sign that. I mean, if it comes in at 140 and you've directed us to proceed, we'll proceed. If it comes in at 170 and you've directed us to proceed, we'll be back to say, look, this is the estimate, these are the actual proposals from the consultants. So actually what you're telling me is you're going to come back to us before spending any money.

3:04:39 Again, if you provide the direction to spend up to $150,000, we'll move forward based on that direction. If it comes back at higher than that, we're not going to go spend more than that without coming back and saying, look, it's $156,000. Whatever the number is, we need very specific proposals from these consultants. And you guys have always been good about that. Anytime you need the budget amended. No question. We'll be back. Okay. And so added to that, and Andy, this is for you.

3:05:07 Should we get into a legal issue on this, what would you estimate our cost to increase to? It really depends on how aggressive the law firm representative plaintiffs would be. Typical CEQA suit, my guess is you're probably looking at $100,000. I'd just like to, before we, this is an entirely appropriate question.

3:05:37 It's a good question. It's a question that should be asked. That's why I ask. I understand. It's a very appropriate thing to ask. I just can't imagine how depressing it is for a fleeting moment.

3:05:48 To be looking at an opportunity like this for this community and for out of the box for us having to be considering litigation. It was brought up. I understand. It's an appropriate question to ask. But I just want to speak to everybody in this community of the opportunity that we have in front of us. And you've heard willing from the head of the Recreation Commission, from the head of MLR, this lead staff person who should get to know, should get in touch with these people, of the willingness of this community to consider all of the

3:06:18 Things that we need to with this project. And I would thank all of us who love this place and love this community would say, look, let's participate in the process. Let's be part of the solution. Let's come up with something that works before we get into silliness about civil litigation. Agreed.

3:06:34 And so it's an entirely responsible question, but I think that I can't imagine why we'd have to go down that road. Let's work together. Let's do something good here. And I think to your point and some of what we've heard from the public is it is critically important to work through the design of this facility and the siting of this facility because it makes a difference. So we want to make sure that people are heard in that process.

3:06:57 So that it doesn't feel like decisions are being made that aren't taking into consideration the valid concerns that are being brought up. And I think, just as Joe mentioned, I'm not looking to just override considerations from the EIR. We were asked to make a decision on this months ago, back in April. And I, for one, and this council supported the idea that it was not appropriate to just go into there without a plan.

3:07:26 We recognize we have neighboring homeowners. We recognize that an EIR is the only appropriate thing for this process. And so we're doing that. And through that process, we need input on siting, design of the facility, how much it should be enclosed. We were asked that question at the last meeting. Those are all things that we need to figure out based on the mitigation measures that we need to do and not things that should just be ignored through the process.

3:07:53 Colin, one thing, I just wanted to follow up on a couple of points that you made earlier, because I thought you made some pretty good, valid points. I think going back to what I said earlier, you know, I'm just, is this the best use of the funds today? When we talk about this whole project as a whole, we're going to talk about bonding R&U. Without revenue increasing, right, without our revenues going up, you're not going to be bonding anything else.

3:08:24 Again, what is the best use of aluminum funds today? And that, you know...

3:08:32 Because I thought your points were good, but I just want to keep going back to that. I just want to hammer that home that with our fiscal situation, where we're going to be going forward, this is not just like a one-shot deal that we'll just go back and bond our and you again unless we all of a sudden start raising a lot of revenue and that probably gets bigger. And I think your perspective is very valid. I'm not looking to change that. You know, to my knowledge of the situation,

3:08:58 And this has been, you know, through discussions with a lot of people. We have a significant portion of this that we can internally finance that we do not need to go to R or U to bond against. If we build this facility the way I want to and in conjunction with a community center, we are going to probably need to bond some money to go after it. So I think it's going to be a portion of the funding that we have with R, but not all of it. You know, I think in lieu of us deciding to pull this amenity,

3:09:28 We're looking at significant costs over the next 20 years to leave it in the current situation. So we're looking at lease payments. We're looking at needing to put a roof on the facility, which is long overdue. We're looking at needing to replace the concrete slab in the next five years. So there's going to be costs associated with carrying this facility either way. I'm looking at what makes the most sense in the long term.

3:09:50 And I'm not up here to necessarily change a perspective on what's the most valid use of our funding. I think this is an opportunity for us to improve two of our recreation assets that need improvement in the short run, and that's what I'm looking at it as. Yeah, I mean, I agree. I mean, I don't think doing it, as I stated, doing a 20-year lease and throwing good money after bad is a solution either. I just don't know.

3:10:14 This is the correct solution today. And I hear you, but then I think that puts us in a situation where we make a decision to drop this facility from our amenity package. And I'm not interested in doing that as a council member. I'm looking to enhance our amenities rather than lose them. If I could just add one thought again. I think that this is a very appropriate scale project to put a challenge to us, to our staff, and to the community to work together to address.

3:10:43 The challenges we all know that we have to come up with good, effective solutions for the challenges that we have as a community. I'm convinced we can do it. Let's all get in this together and let's make this thing work. Because to your point about bonding for long-term things, if we can't as a community take on these kinds of things and come out with successful results, why would we want to bond things? Why would we want to start getting into that kind of stuff? We have to engage with these challenges and do them well.

3:11:09 And thank you, Colin, for reminding me that the lease payments actually are a good portion of the internal financing that would help us to build this. But since I proposed it, I would like to ask either Dana or Rich if they have any comments on whether or not MLR could consider and come back with a recommendation sooner rather than later on funding. The MLR board really hasn't had this conversation just yet.

3:11:41 Well, we know there is a set aside of $300,000 to the roof that was done in the last fiscal year. I would not imagine that we'd probably, I would imagine we can engage in that conversation and bring something back in fairly short order. I would put that on our agenda for our November 3rd meeting to have that conversation. We could bring something back in terms of financing, you know, in the bigger picture. As I mentioned before, we're looking at bringing back our first phase of top tier projects on November 18th.

3:12:08 And we're trying to get special events and event programming funding done prior to the holiday break. We're imagining when we come back, once the council gives us direction, the next funding cycle for allocation is going to be funding for environmental reviews, conceptual designs, all the environmental work that has to be done so we can come back and say, this is what it looks like, which project do we want to move forward right now? Because we may find ourselves in a position that it's not going to work. We're not shovel ready at this point. We're just asking at this point.

3:12:36 Give us permission to move forward so we can determine the readiness of this project. And I'll bring this to board on November 3rd. There is a line item allocated there. I could see he's bringing something back to redirect. Okay. All right. Then in my count, I'm hearing that Colin and John and I are all okay with the current setup. I don't know whether either of you wants to consider the idea of not using the general fund at this time.

3:13:05 Is that something that we just need to check the legality of? Yeah, I can review the Melrose District, but at this point, if you want to give us that direction, we can move through that. There's a portion of those funds that, I guess in one sense, you already have a loan out against it. You could pay that back to the general fund and use those funds. So in that sense, you would be not utilizing general fund money. So there is a way to utilize Melrose funds, I guess that's what I'm saying, if you would like to move in that direction. Is there a way to...

3:13:35 Authorize moving forward and have you bring back the financing options at the next meeting? Yes. We could do that in terms of, as Grady mentioned, we're looking at the phone calls with some folks and putting stuff out, so we'd be moving forward on that. Correct. At that point, we'd come back with some of it slows us down a little bit, but not substantially. So you would be essentially asking for a motion that would include up to $150,000. You'll come back with a staff recommendation on where that funding comes from. If you want to say that you want it to come out of non-general fund sources.

3:14:04 Then we'll come back with that recommendation. That's what I was thinking of. I don't know. John, are you? Yeah, I'm a little concerned. I want to make sure that we call for the question and I'm trying to figure out a motion. And you guys are more adept at these things than I am. I just want to make sure that we're not going to get into some financing question that's going to muddy the waters of what it is we're trying to do. Well, let me try a motion. Okay.

3:14:30 Accept the recommendations from the Recreation Commission, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and the Ad Hoc Facility Task Force to move forward with preliminary design and environmental documentation for the location of community recreation facilities within Mammoth Creek Park West and to return to us with financing options for this first phase, including use or not use of general fund.

3:15:01 You say I'd say with a use of John General Fund dollars. Use of John General Fund. Well, I don't know because we may still say general funds appropriate. Okay. So is the motion to direct staff to come back with the options but to not actually spend any money until the council's going to come? No, no. I think it's to start. Well, the intention was to, okay, so I guess I want to also say and to begin to encumber funds out of the mellow roofs. Yes, we can do that. Andy.

3:15:31 You okay with that? Yes. Is that okay? Okay. I mean, subject to checking on the parameters of the Meller-Russ funding and making sure that we can. Right. Okay, the Meller-Russ or, yeah, okay. I think that's what Jo's saying is that would be her preference to go the Meller-Russ route. We just want to check to make sure that that's acceptable. Correct. If we don't think it's acceptable, we won't spend them. Okay. But you can be back to us in two weeks and tell us what you've figured out. Yes. I'm comfortable with that. I'll second that.

3:16:01 Okay. Any other discussion? I have a question for the council just in terms of the setting of expectations for the fall of 2017. You know, I don't want to, you know, if where are we going to be in the fall of 2017? What can the staff deliver by the fall of 2017? In terms of the project and the layout we've worked through on it, again, we believe that's a realistic time frame.

3:16:35 Now, of course, if you end up in a legal issue that could push that out, that could happen. But barring that, that we're moving through a design process, we're moving through a CEQA process, both of those being fairly strong in the public engagement process when we get through those. We believe that there's adequate time to do that, to do it well, and to still be able to move forward with the bid and the construction of the project by that 2017.

3:17:01 So there's a mention of a ribbon cutting. What are we cutting a ribbon on? And don't, you know. That'll be coming out of the design process and be able to lay that out there to you in that process. And we could say at that date, here's what we would be opening. I mean, we're jumping ahead of a lot of the process here. No, I understand. I just want to make sure that we're not setting stupid expectations. So, okay. And for what it's worth, I mean, my estimate, this is just a very rough estimate, is that litigation might stall things by nine months.

3:17:30 And again, I've committed to myself in my life never to get involved in civil litigation. I don't see any value in it at all. And I would, you know, my email address, all of our email addresses are public. If someone's got a real question, let's talk first. Let's figure this out. Let's not go down that road. Anyway, so where are we at, Mr. Mayor? I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. No.

3:18:00 No, motion passes 3 to 2. We're going to take a short recess. We're going to resume at 9.20. Colin and Joe, can you guys join us, please? Where did Colin go? Hey, Colin?

3:19:12 Sorry, Michael. No worries. Okay, we're going to go ahead and resume our regular meeting, 922. We're going to move on to our next item, item 12, waive the reading and introduce by title only ordinance adding section 15.04.170 to the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code.

3:19:45 Change permitting procedures for small residential rooftop solar. Thank you. Systems. Yes, thank you. The item before you tonight is an ordinance enacting expedited permitting for small. You want me to stop? Excuse me. Can you guys take your dialogue outside, please? We can't hear up here. Thank you.

3:20:05 Go ahead. Thank you. The item before you tonight is an ordinance enacting expedited permitting for small residential rooftop solar energy systems. This ordinance is required by Section 65850.5A of the California Government Code.

3:20:20 And the intent of this requirement is that cities and counties streamline these types of installations and do not require them to go through a discretionary review process, like an administrative permit or use permit. The town doesn't currently subject these types of installations to a discretionary permit review, so we are in compliance with the state requirements, but we are required to adopt the ordinance nonetheless. The government code section also requires that the town develop a checklist.

3:20:47 To determine whether small rooftop solar energy systems are eligible for expedited review, we have prepared that checklist and it's included as attachment A to the staff report.

3:20:58 And with that, we're recommending that the Council waive the first reading of the ordinance and introduce by title only the attached ordinance which enacts expedited permitting procedures for small residential rooftop solar energy systems and adding Section 15.04.170 to the municipal code. And that concludes my report. I'm available for any questions that you have.

3:21:18 Thank you. Any questions? Yes, Sandra. So fundamentally this doesn't really change how we operate. No. I mean we don't require them to go through a discretionary permit at this point anyways. Right. So this simply just enacts the fact that we are going to expedite them. In practice also we are going to expedite the plan check as well because that has taken some time for these types of facilities. So that's just a practice and that doesn't need to be codified in the ordinance.

3:21:48 To functional practice. Okay. Thank you. I'm very concerned about what Bruce Woodward is bringing up. I've talked with Dan about this. I had a very interesting meeting today with Mountain Lab, Scott McGuire, Marla County, incubator space, and these kinds of things, and our ability to inhabit our built environment. And this is good, this is important, but we've really got to focus in.

3:22:18 With our building department, our plan check, our plan review so the people that want to work in this community, build businesses and do things in this place, we don't have this monolithic wall in front of people that they can't get projects done. And Scott McGuire, I know it's not related to this project, but I want to make sure that this is one of many things that we've got to be able to, Scott McGuire, you know, to his credit spent six months trying to get just basic things approved for his project over there, for this incubator space.

3:22:47 We've got to get on top of this. So no problem with this at all, but I want to bring this to staff's attention that I think council's serious about this. We really need to focus on this. Well, and I think we've seen some of the success of putting together these task forces. Yes, exactly. And I thought it was a great suggestion that everybody's on board with. I appreciate staff's willingness to do this, but let's get all the, you know, vested partners in the room and figure this thing out. Yeah. Yeah, I don't think we can do that. Yeah. Okay. Well, there's no...

3:23:15 Public comment. There's nobody left. We cleared the room. So I'll bring it back and entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'd be happy to make a motion. Council waived the first reading and introduced by title only the attached ordinance which enacts expedited permitting procedures for small residential rooftop solar systems and adding Section 15.04.170 to the municipal code. Okay. I have a motion. Second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes.

3:23:45 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Moving on to item 13, authorize the town manager to finalize scope and fee negotiations to execute an agreement with top-ranked consultant HMC Architects for architecture and engineering design service for the new police facility. Thank you. I will keep this brief, and I know Chief Davis has a couple of comments. A lot of times these kind of agreements come back and they're just on consent, but...

3:24:13 I specifically asked the town manager and Jamie if we could make sure this was on policy because, I mean, this is a big deal. We've talked about a new police station for a long time. We've had a design in years past that was a bit ambitious, you might say. We have the funding. We have the site. I wanted to mention that we went through a process with a request for qualifications. We got five proposals. That may not seem like a lot, but up here, that's a lot of proposals, so we did well. We got some good input from them.

3:24:42 We picked the right person, no doubt. We've already had a couple of meetings with these people, and they absolutely know what they're doing. They're approaching it the right way. They're sending out surveys of doing it right. And we're just excited to get the project moving with your support. And I know Chief Davis wanted to make a couple of comments, but that's really the reason it's here tonight, just to make sure we take note that this is a big step forward. Grady, before you turn it over to Chief Davis, can you just give Council and the public a quick breakdown of the funding we're doing? You do that. Thanks.

3:25:13 Yeah, the police station, we looked at this a while back in terms of plans that were done. Historically, we took a second look going back and saying, what are we in today and what do we actually need to operate with our current size of a police force with the potential addition of three to four additional officers? Bottom line is what we took a look at was retaining the current space for the most part. It's about 38 or 100 square feet or so, so we're looking at a 4,000 square foot building.

3:25:40 The estimate there within the $400 or so dollars a square foot to be able to do that. So we think the size is adequate. The land mass we're looking at as a site location is the Civic Center site next to the courthouse. And so we already own the land there. There's been some topo work done and those types of things there. The key element for the building then is we went out and said, how do we finance it? We actually ended up refunding or refinancing the debt that was on the bell-shaped parcel.

3:26:09 And then adding some to that tied to the additional cost for the police station. So basically we did a net $2 million bond issue. The overall payment for that from what we had originally been paying between the current debt service on the bonds, the lease on the police station, and there's a last year payment of debt this year on...

3:26:38 Small Caltrans debt for the airport. If you roll those three debt payments into this one, I think we're within $5,000 of the same number. And so it's really not adding anything substantially to our capital debt, if you will. The operational cost of a new facility, frankly, I believe will be less than the current one, just in terms of maintenance and other operating costs to do that. So the bonding is in place so that there's a $2 million budget.

3:27:06 Thank you very much.

3:27:33 So we'll be looking at some options of how do we retain that. The chief has also been directed to go out and look for some grants if you want anything nice and fancy in the building. Some new chairs or something? Yeah, new chairs. Look at that smile. There's money right there. Ask him to go do those things. He can write grants. But we do have that money. And I think one of the key elements, when we did the debt service on this, it was, I think, fairly creative in terms of pulling all the pieces together to move this forward. We looked at refunding the debt on just a bell-shaped parcel about a year and a half ago.

3:28:02 Just as a general fund savings and the fact that coming out of the bankruptcy issues with the town, the reliance on tourism and the fact that we looked at refunding on a piece of property that had little value to it, we actually got zero offers on that debt refunding. A little bit of time passing, tying this debt to, I think, the refinancing, the adding dollars to get the amount.

3:28:28 Basically leveraging our police station and our courtyard as the assets of the town when you do this type of lease financing. We did an offer out to 15 different banks. Two of them put in an initial bid. One of them withdrew. And so we were really down to one player at the end of the day to be able to do that. So the dollars are set aside. The $2 million are basically in the bank, if you will, from the bond issue.

3:28:52 And that right now, that is the scope of the budget. As I mentioned, we'd like to have about $100,000, another contingency in there, but the chief can't spend that. And then being able to move that project forward on dirt that we already own, on a facility that is sized, I think, to meet our current needs more than adequately with some capability for expansion within the building, but also not precluding ourselves on that site from a long-term location of either a town hall and or.

3:29:20 Other county-type facilities, et cetera, on that site that was identified as a government center. And so we'll do the layout not to preclude that ongoing vision for that site. Is it size enough to potentially move town offices there? To the site, not in this building, no. No, no, to the site. Yeah, but the parcel is more than adequately sized for town offices, and that would be long-term when the lease on this would be up seven or eight years out that we could actually look at that site.

3:29:48 As part of the layout on the site, we're actually doing that in conjunction with the courts, the hospital, the county, and the town, because we're all ordering that site together. So we're actually doing some cooperative work on that layout. And Dan, the lease on the current police station is up in? December of 2017. Okay. And the lease on the current town facility is 22? 22 or 3A. I'd have to go back and look. Okay.

3:30:15 It's way out there. Yeah, I think it's 23. It was further out. Okay. And so this would be a spring break ground? Yeah, ideally we'd do all the design work this winter that we're moving into right now and be able to break ground this spring and summer. Ideally you'd get all enclosed before winter and then you'd finish up the interior work through that winter and then the other specialty work the following summer.

3:30:46 Being ready by that December 17 date. Okay, thank you. This may be what Chief Davis is going to talk about, but I was on Planning Commission when the other facility was approved and included an extension of Tavern Road and all kinds of other things. So can you just give us a quick overview of what's included this time? I can give you a lot of stuff that we took out of the other design. Well, maybe that's the way to do it.

3:31:14 In reviewing the, actually, I looked at the floor plans this last week in terms of what was in the original design of 13,000 square feet. There's some elements that we'd want to keep. We may not construct it at this point, but, for example, the use permit included a communications tower on the site. That will be something we'll need to look at down the road. But the number of offices are dramatically reduced. We're not looking at underground parking. We would still be looking at a sally port of some sort for a safety issue.

3:31:41 The number of conference rooms would be reduced. We would not have a large public lobby space, a public meeting slash training room. We would not have a separate section for a whole investigative division to be within the building. We would not have the number of interrogation rooms, private offices or other types of specialty areas within the building.

3:32:10 Meeting those core needs of the department that we have today, improving on those obviously. And also just the overall size of some of the public spaces and even office space were probably a little aggressive. Since this is smaller and its size for where we are now, how does it accommodate future growth? And the other one did envision having CHP and Sheriff and everybody else sharing the space. That was one of the reasons why it.

3:32:38 Got so big. But how do we build this? Well, at least we're downsizing, so John Walter should be happy with this. But, you know, how do we plan not just for the current but for the future? I think there's three things doing that. One is, I believe with the 4,000 square foot space we're looking at, you could add additional, say, four sworn positions in that space and work just fine.

3:33:04 The other side of that is the layout that we're looking at. One potential is can you add a second story right now, but it would be not conditioned for having people there at this point because it's cheap to go up right now when you're doing the initial construction, so we may look at that. Secondly is designing the building so you can expand out, and so that's a key element of how you design the building so you can add on to it. Also, then that drives all your infrastructure so you're not building over top of your water and sewer lines so you can relocate them later.

3:33:34 So a lot of the engineering design and stuff would take a look at how easy to expand the building. One of the questions we've raised, at least to look at if you do a town hall there, is it connected to this building and do we design, for example, if you look at multi-story buildings, do we only do one elevator? Those types of elements down the road. So how do you expand into that in the future? So it would have potentially space inside, you know, for additional officers in the short term. Let's call that two to five years.

3:34:03 You have the capability potentially to go up if that financially works in the current budget. That would have you design the building. You'd have a wall space there, one of the areas it's easy to add to. And you wouldn't do a whole layout looking at the infrastructure and other buildings day one so you're not complicating the problem in the future. The only thing I'd like to add is that when the consultant walked into the existing space of 3,780 feet roughly, they looked at it and said,

3:34:28 It's so inefficient in terms of corridor space, the core factor, if you will. It's over the top. So effectively, they probably have 3,400 or 3,500 square feet. So moving to 4,000 is going to be an upgrade. Definitely. But again, I want to turn over to Chief for a couple of comments. But they recognize right away that even if the existing space was more efficient, you did a few hundred thousand in TIs, it could last for a while. Not that the building would, but the amount of space would.

3:34:56 HNC, when they came up and we met with them, they did walkthroughs of the police department and also the field, and they're totally on board with looking for future expansion, including town hall or other things, but those are things they're going to design into what they're coming up with conceptually for us. But that's definitely something for the future that was really important. And yeah, they said about 800 additional square feet, if we'd been designed correctly, which of course it was never designed, we'd have that much more room. So it's...

3:35:24 Exciting. It's building. It's exciting for me because I've never built anything like this. I'm learning a lot. We've got a great staff, a group within the town that are working together, excited about it. And my staff is getting on board because they've been down, most of them have been down this road a couple of times. So they're starting to see, okay, it's gaining traction and I'm getting them surveys and things to fill out so they can have the input. And there's going to be a lot more input from my staff about the design and ideas and how things should work. So it's exciting stuff. It's fun.

3:35:52 I'm going to shrink your office and create some more space. No, I'm just going to have a little more. Is Marno County, how are we doing with the county? We've reached out to them and essentially at this point there's nothing that they can foresee in the future being able to assist with or add any funding to this to increase the size or scope of what we're doing. And holding cells and booking facilities are...

3:36:17 We don't want to get down into that because it's very expensive. There's a lot of requirements that if we're going to hold somebody past four hours, it changes the game completely and what's required. So we want to leave that for the Sheriff's Department for now. Yeah, because we just need to get out of that building. The communications tower, so that's part of the use permit. But was that connected to us taking over our own dispatch?

3:36:41 I believe that was the idea then, and I don't foresee that happening in the future for quite some time. I think countywide is working great. It actually helps the collaborative effort between all law enforcement and EMS. It's one central place that is. Well, I remember at the time it came up as they were charging an awful lot for the service. Yeah.

3:37:01 If I may, one final comment is that in the first week of November, we'll actually have a lot of activity on this because a consultant will be here in town for four full days. We have a list of about 12 different stakeholders, including certainly the RIT department, Eastern Sierra Energy, everybody getting on board, being SCE, fire department, everybody. So we're moving as soon as we pass this date. Believe me, we're already setting those meetings up. So we do expect to open quickly. And just one last question. Digital 395.

3:37:30 You're going to be plugged into this thing in a big way, right? That's right. That's why we'll have Nate involved early in the first meeting to make sure that we do everything we can. It's already on the fiber network. Okay, good. There's a lot of insight with those meetings with Ingrid getting ready for the public utilities. There's a lot of very interesting, good thinking about how to integrate that into all this stuff. I'm assuming you guys are doing that. Oh, yeah. Yes. Okay. Any other questions, comments? No questions, but just a comment.

3:38:01 Just wanted to say thank you to staff. I appreciate you calling this out specifically. No offense, Chief, but police buildings probably aren't the sexiest thing that we do as a council or municipality. But you're so wrong. But I think it's an exciting thing. We've asked you, Dan, to be creative in putting some things together and implementing and getting into that.

3:38:29 You know, implementation phase, like I alluded to before. And, you know, we were able to do some creative things to bring some buildings down up by the village. That was a long-term goal, and we were able to make that happen. We've had a long-term goal of improving our police facility, getting out of that lease agreement. You know, when you talk about the finances and everything that was pulled together, it's pretty cool the way that we were able to make this happen. So, thank you. And, you know, I like...

3:38:56 I'm very encouraged by all the conversation we're having as far as the long-term visioning of this site. There was a lot of talk on the last item about the lease that we have on Suite Z and all the town offices, and we don't need to get into the details of that, but the long-term plan is to get the police force into somewhere we own and to get the town hall into a place that we own, and it makes sense that all those are going to go over in the civic center, if you will, where we've got a courthouse and a police.

3:39:24 So, thank you.

3:39:54 Sure. I would make the motion. Michael's got somewhere to be. Authorize the town manager to finalize scope and fee negotiations and execute an agreement with the top-ranked consultant for architectural and engineering design services for the new police facility. Second. All right. I have a motion and a quick second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

3:40:23 Yes, motion passes 5-0. We will adjourn to our next regular meeting scheduled on Wednesday, November 4th, 2015 at 6 p.m. right here in Suite Z. Good night. Thank you.