TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2015

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

· recording 3 hr 9 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

385 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:57 Okay, I'm going to go ahead and call this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board to order. I think we'll start with the Pledge of Allegiance. Colin, you want to lead us, please? Yep, so everybody can stand. Okay, we'll start off. I'll call roll. Colin is here. Here. Tom is here. It's my pleasure to welcome Gary Morgan to the board. David Page. Here. Andrea Perry. Here. Terry Stellick. Yes.

4:49 Dana Stroud is not with us this evening. And Brent Truax is running late and will be with us shortly. Okay. Next we'll open up the mic to any public comment that doesn't touch on agenda items this evening. Nothing. Actually, Tom, so Tom wants to present a project for consideration. That should be in the latter part of our session tonight.

5:25 So it's scheduled, Tom, roughly 6.50-ish? Okay. You know what? Tom, how much time do you need? I'm okay giving Tom five minutes off the top to give a little presentation to us? Okay. Any other public comments? All right, Tom, you can go ahead. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Tom Hodges. I'm VP of Mountain Development for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. And I'm here tonight to...

6:23 Proposed for your consideration to make signage and wayfinding a priority consideration for your funding cycle that you're currently considering. And I realize I don't know that a formal application has been submitted. It would be from the town. So I provided you a copy of the last application that had been made, I believe, in the funding cycle from last year for the first phase of signage and wayfinding.

6:52 And I just wanted to show you guys a couple things here real quick from the master plan that's been approved by the town previously. And the paperwork I gave you here just sort of summarizes the status of the project and where all the approvals are. So what's being requested is a funding request of $334,000 to fund the completion of Phase 1B.

7:33 for pedestrian signage in vehicular signage per the approved master plan that's been approved and vetted through planning commission and town council actually a couple years ago. So real quick here, so what the background of the project is, it's a comprehensive community signage and wayfinding program.

8:00 Which is needed to reflect in the town's 2007 general plan as well as recently accepted neighborhood district plans and destination resort community and economic development strategy and the draft mobility element. So just by way of history here in September of 2011, staff developed a draft scope of work that detailed requests for proposals for the municipal wayfinding community message program. Draft scope of work was reviewed and approved by Planning Commission in September of 2011, town council.

8:28 In October of 2011, and then the final RFP was approved by the Planning Commission in later October 2011. It was issued in the end of 2011, and a firm by the name of Merge, M-E-R-J-E Design, was selected in January of 2012 to prepare the master plan. In April of 2012, Merge Design made an initial visit and visited the community and toured

8:57 The whole community and all of our resort developments and all of our assets. And I was part of a focus group that was part of the wayfinding committee that included Commissioner Tenney at the time and other stakeholders in the community, including the Inyo National Forest in the ski area, Caltrans, Mammoth Hospital, Mammoth Unified School District, Mono County, Syracuse Community College, as well as some other town commissioners. And as a result of that visit,

9:27 Emerge came back in June of 2012 to present their initial findings that included three concept signage designs that were reviewed and commented on by the focus group as well as the planning commission. And as a result of that effort, they came up with a preferred alternative. And in October of 2012, the planning commission reviewed and approved the final draft master plan and wayfinding signage design, which I'm going to show you guys real quick.

9:56 And then in spring of 2013, the town had prepared a Measure U application that was submitted for $77,000 to cover engineering services and to construct the first district monument, which was approved. And so as a result of that, the town did enlist a consultant who prepared actual working.

10:22 Construction documents for the whole signage and wayfinding program. And so there's standard details for every single sign that's in the program that's ready actually as a bid package to go out to bid to build it. So this project literally is on the shelf. It's shovel ready. And it's just lacking funding. And the whole program is estimated to be a little over $800,000.

10:51 But this first request is just for this initial phase, which would be all the primary vehicular signage on the main streets in Mammoth, as well as pedestrian signage. So it's very much, and I'll see if I can pull it real quick and show you guys here, along the lines of showing people how to get around town. I can't tell you guys anecdotally how many times at the ski area we've had trouble getting people directed to Canyon Lodge and Eagle Lodge, for example.

11:18 We've had people who've had tee times at Sierra Star Golf Course that end up down at Snow Creek and say, hey, we're here for our 10 o'clock tee time, and they're like, we don't even know who we are. And so it's one of these things that I think it's not necessarily evident to us as locals, but to a first-time visitor to our community, it's very confusing. The town's not logical. There's not a grid to our downtown area, our commercial areas, the connectivity between the village and the downtown. You know, where's downtown?

11:47 And there's the notion of where's downtown in Mammoth. It's, you know, we consider it kind of Maine and old Mammoth, but a lot of people don't understand that that's what we consider downtown. So, again, I'm just trying to point out to you guys the fact that it's something that's very, very necessary. We feel that it's a very, the ski area, we feel it's very critical to the overall experience for our resort guests. And yet it's a community initiative because it's all areas of the resort. It's not just.

12:14 Mammoth Mammoth Ski Area. It's not just Snow Creek. It's, you know, it's every, it's all the interests in our community combined that we need to have a comprehensive system for our guests to find their way around the, you know, sensible manner around our town with attractive signage. And, you know, you look at our peer resorts, it's, you know, all the better peer resorts have this and we don't. And so, so again, it's just, you know, we feel like it's something that really should happen. Can I? You can take a minute to wrap up.

12:45 Okay, so real quick, where's the page down here? If you guys look on the screen, I just wanted to show you the content of the context of the signage. So these are samples of what the signage looks like. They include sort of the district areas as well as major wayfinding on the thoroughfares in town. And again, all this stuff is completely designed and detailed and ready to bid and go out for, you know, to get somebody, a contractor online to do the work. The main thing I wanted to show you was this.

13:16 Just sort of context pictures rendered of what this stuff would look like. So that's an example of what the signage would look like on the streets that are going to direct people. So you can see that it reads really well. It's very attractive. It's very substantial signage. It's not cheap, but it's going to last a long, long time. There's a little downtown monument at the corner of Footloose.

13:36 And there's a close-up of what that would look like. You know, very attractive. It plays right into the whole design vernacular that's already in place with the town entry sign, as well as, you know, some of the other elements of, for example, the trail signage in town. So I think it would get people to their destinations, as well as trailheads and our resort amenities. There's an example of the sign on Old Mammoth showing where the public parking is that people don't know that exists.

13:59 Again, just directionals, showing people, if you're on Old Mammoth, hey, turn here to go to Sierra Star, turn here to go to Mammoth Creek Park, et cetera. So anyway, it's a great system. It's on the shelf, ready to go, needs the funding. It's been funded through Measure U before. I think it's worthy of you guys considering it as a priority, and it would have a huge impact on the community. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you, Tom. Can I ask one question?

14:27 So the $77,000 that was given before, wasn't that for the monument sign out front, the entrance to town? I think it was that, it was engineering, and as well as, you know, some portion of that went towards that. I mean, that sign I think was, that whole project was several hundred thousand dollars, if I recall, with a lot of donated. Yeah, so it was a piece of that, is that correct? Yeah, it was probably a piece of that, I believe, yeah. Okay. But the big chunk of it went to making the actual engineering construction documents design package that, like I say, it's...

14:55 Ready to be implemented. They could send it out for bid tomorrow. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. One quick comment from me just in terms of the mountains investment in this particular kind of design vernacular, as Tom pointed out. We're already starting to kind of use it in some of the signage up on the mountain, and I think MMSA is very interested in kind of matching our signage to the town signage over time. Okay.

15:25 Moving on. Any other public comment? Okay. So on to administrative items. First, I'm looking for a motion to approve this agenda. I have one modification on the agenda or the minutes? I'm sorry. I'm on the minutes. Okay. Thank you. Any discussion? All in favor? Aye. Minutes approved. Now on to the minutes of our October 5th board meeting.

16:07 I'm sorry. Although the minutes that we have here say the September 14th board meeting. That should be October 5th, correct? Okay. So in, Drea, you said you had an amendment? On 11A, the final sentence, the board was reminded by the committee that if an applicant did not submit a summary performance report, I believe the, continue to say no funding would be awarded. Okay. Yes. That's right.

16:40 They would not be able to apply for the next cycle. Right, without those materials submitted. Okay. And then I have one just since Evan Russell's here. There's a mention from his presentation about two kind of comp theaters that ours is being modeled on, but the names of those theaters aren't in the record. It would be kind of nice to get them in the record here. So Evan, I don't know if you know the two theaters you talked about.

17:10 Off the top of your head? I think one of them was. Okay. Okay. Okay. Leslie, can we maybe track that down? Cool. Okay. Any other amendments? Okay. Motion to approve the minutes as amended? I'll make the motion to approve the minutes as amended. Okay. Do I have a second? Okay. Gary. Any discussion? All in favor? Aye.

17:53 I will abstain. Yeah, I'm going to abstain as well. Two abstentions. Minutes are approved. Okay, moving on. So our first kind of heavyweight agenda item. So this one is to finalize the top-tier project matrix. And this is a matrix that we started to work on at our last board meeting and realized that it was

18:28 Going to be a very involved process and required a good deal of public input, particularly from the people managing those specific projects. So we, tonight, are going to go through the matrix that was published with the board packet, project by project, and try to go through, there are, I believe, how many total sections? Seven total sections.

18:56 And we're going to walk through each project and try to address each section. We're going to begin each attention to each project with a presentation from that particular project's manager. So without further ado, I'd like to get started. And the first one on our list is the multi-use facility. So are we finalizing the matrix first, or are we going to do a hearing?

19:26 Okay, so yeah, maybe a little more detail on what we're doing. So the idea is here just to compile information and to make sure that the information that we have compiled is accurate and to have any input on things we're missing, documents that have been written up in the past on that particular project that perhaps we haven't brought to our attention and daylighted as a board.

19:55 We are not going to deliberate on each individual project in this period of our meeting tonight. We're going to hear from the project manager or the team that's putting forth the project, and we'll fill this out, and then we'll move on to the next one, and we'll do that for all of the listed projects. Then we'll move on to a second phase of the meeting tonight where we'll open it up again for public comment.

20:22 On these top-tier projects, and basically we're asking the question, have we missed anything? Is there a project that's not listed? Tom Hodges would have spoken during that section had he not had to leave. We'll hear from the public on omissions, anything that they'd like to add based on the conversation they've heard here, and then the board will possibly deliberate or postpone our deliberation to the next board meeting.

20:51 Pending what we find in this kind of matrix informational session. Does that make sense to everyone? Any questions on process? And just to be clear, basically we're trying to look at this to make sure that we've got all the information that we need in order to be able to recommend projects. That's correct. Essentially, I should have continued to read the actual agenda item. This is to address...

21:21 What's really one of our prime deliverables right now. To prepare and provide the town an MLR strategy, the town and MLR strategy and prioritize list of primary amenities recommended to be supported with Measure R and U funds by December 2015. So our work here is basic fact finding and information organization to that end. To basically set up.

21:47 A sound deliberation so that we can go through these projects and produce the prioritized list. Any other comments, questions before we begin? I think we're going to, Rich, correct me if I'm wrong, we're going to try and keep to 10 minutes per project if possible. Is that correct? Correct. Okay. The folks in the audience that will be presenting tonight already have a copy of this project design phases to determine readiness. It's a little tighter frame.

22:19 For the folks in the audience who didn't get this, this document is sitting on the table in the back. Stu is going to start it out with multi-use facility and kind of walk us through these seven elements, kind of give us some information, or Grady is going to walk us through, give us some information as we walk through each project that will allow us then to take some notes to capture what other information do we need to move forward. Okay. So if we're ready to begin, the multi-use facility is the first item on the agenda and town staff that will be

22:49 Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works with Town Staff, and Stu will jump in with anything that I missed. Real quick update, and again, a lot of people here have heard a lot of this and heard a lot of it last week as well. Last Wednesday on October 21st, the Town Council voted to approve a recommendation from staff that the multi-use facility be reconstructed, if you will, at Mammoth Creek Park West.

23:13 And that it be reconstructed with a complementary facility of a 5,000 to 10,000 square foot community center to eventually replace the community center that's now up near the village. It has, again, it's already had a great deal of public scrutiny. It will get much more in the future. I want to give you a quick update on the process, and then I will go through items one through seven. This afternoon, in fact, we had a conversation, a telephone conference with the...

23:40 Environmental consultant that we will look to hire to do the environmental documentation for the project. They happen to be the ones that actually did the EIR back in 1999. There are staff there that we are very comfortable with that have done some very good projects and worked for the town in the past. It's RBF out of Irvine, I believe. We had a great conversation. The next we owe them is a preliminary project description. They'll work up a preliminary estimate.

24:07 On Friday of this week, you'll see in the newspaper an advertisement for a request for qualifications for a design team, an architectural and engineering team. What they'll be tasked with is coming up with preliminary designs appropriate to allow the scoping of the environmental document. We're not looking for final design. We wouldn't do that. We want to work with them as part of that team to try to mitigate any potential impacts on the site to give us input as we're actually doing the preliminary design.

24:36 Subsequent to that, the environmental document will be completed. That design team, we do have to go through a public process to select that team. It will be advertised on Friday. It happens at four weeks from Friday as about Thanksgiving, so we're not getting proposals Thanksgiving week. That's not going to happen, so it will be the week after that. We anticipate coming back to town council for a request for an authorization at the December 16th meeting, if I have that date correct.

25:04 For authorization to proceed with that work. Before that time, the town manager will come back to town council with a recommendation on the funding for that initial effort, which we have estimated to be $150,000. He's looking at some of the funding components, whether it's, as you may have heard the other night, whether it's Melrose, whether it's some other set-aside funding, some refunding that's already there, some things that Measure R has already funded. But he'll come back to town council before that date with a recommendation.

25:32 So in terms of the number one, the approved concept, we do have direction from town council to proceed with the environmental document and the preliminary design. We do have a general description. We have made that side selection, we being the town. Site control, it is a town-owned parcel, Mammoth Creek Park West. The preliminary design, again, we have a rough project description. We'll go through that preliminary design, work with a consultant in that over the coming months.

25:59 Some of the funding has already been identified for the project, but not all of it for design and construction. Entitlement approval number four, I just described the CEQA process we're going to. First, a consultant, then the process we estimate nine to 12 months from today to have that process completed. We will not start that final design until the CEQA process is complete and whatever document we have is certified. At that point, we'd go through the final funding for the design work itself.

26:29 And then subsequent to that construction and operational funding. Really, the bottom line is we're looking for a ribbon cutting on the facility of October of 2017 to have the project complete and in place, again, depending on all the rest of it. One thing I do want to mention, during the preliminary design process and the environmental process, there will be public outreach. We'll have specific public meetings.

26:53 What we'll likely do is have our consultant work with us on a design based on all the comments we've already gotten. Then we'll have public meetings to invite everyone in to comment as well and give us more of their concerns. That's it. Any questions from the board for Grady? Any general comments? Again, just one note, commentary and questions should be to flesh out the project, and then we can kind of deliberate about merit down the road.

27:25 I just had one question. Just to clarify, Grady, the $150,000 was just for the EIR, right? It's for that and the preliminary design. And preliminary design. Now, I did mention the other night that since we don't have those proposals yet, we are expecting that that will be in the right ballpark. We talked to the environment consultant. They confirmed that. But if it comes in at $160,000, we'll be back to council to make sure they know that before we go over that amount. And I guess...

27:57 Do you want to speak any more about the community center? I mean, we kind of have it as two line items here, I guess. Sure, I can do that. Okay. I think the estimate in your packet is for the eventually 10,000 square foot community center, which we want to use in the scoping for the environmental document. What's proposed is to start out with a 5,000 square foot community center.

28:21 complimentary to the multi-use facility that would later possibly be expanded to 10. But again, when you're doing an environmental document, you want to assess as much of the impact potential as possible. So in your packet, I think it says 5.3 to 5.5 million dollars for the community center. I believe that's for the 10,000 square foot community center. It just happens to line up with the overall estimate for multi-use facility.

28:42 Plus community center. In terms of the programming for that, I think Stu could speak to that more if you need any more detail, but it's basically you have a 2,500 square foot center now that's underutilized partly because it's so small and it's not in the best shape. I mean, there are a lot of things that go wrong there, but I think the rec commission has identified a number of more activities that could be in that facility if it was larger. And also it would make a lot better difference if it was in

29:08 Mammoth Creek Park West with the multi-use facility adjacent to it and a lot of things that go back and forth between the two make better use for it. We haven't got into the specific programming for every square foot there. That's what we'll get into during the preliminary design process. I guess kind of to that point, I'm hoping and I know that this is something that we'll get into in the coming weeks, but in terms of our role communicating some of this to the public and trying to put together a package that everyone can get their heads around,

29:39 I'm wondering at what point we'll be able to latch on to some more specific descriptions of these facilities and or comparative facilities, for example, so that we can say, you know, this is what we mean by community center. This is what we mean by multi-use facility. Agreed. And again, we were intentionally, I wouldn't say vague, but we were intentionally didn't have a lot of detail the other night because the idea is that we want this to be participatory.

30:08 If we're able to select a consultant on December 16th, which we expect to do, we'll start work right away. I would suggest sometime in January we'll have the first meeting of some concepts from that consultant. We don't want to start talking about a long time before that because we really don't have that base data. We don't have the consultant on board. Today all I can say is it's a multi-use facility.

30:30 115 feet by 240 roughly with a roof on it and 10,000 square foot of community center. No more detail than that. But I'd suggest that sometime in January we'll really start getting into those conversations. We'll have the consultant on board. We'll have updated topography for the site. We'll know precisely where all the utilities are and we can have a much more intelligent conversation. So I'd look sometime in January. And will that consultant also be getting into the issues of public benefit?

30:55 Community needs? Absolutely. We'll do everything we can. In fact, what we'll rely on this group as well as a rec commission on is to help us with that outreach as well, identifying not just adjacent homeowners. We know a lot of them, but we're already talking to the presidents of the boards themselves. We'll talk to other neighbors. We'll have things in the newspaper. We'll make sure we put together a full program so that there are no surprises. Once we get to a public hearing, no surprises at that point in time. It'll be well known. Thank you. Thanks, Grady.

31:27 Anything else? Okay. Thanks, Grady. Okay. Moving along. Next up is the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. Evan Russell. Good evening, Evan Russell. I think you guys have – we've done a couple of presentations. We've been working with a couple of your board members, and you have a lot more detail than probably comes from this document here.

32:13 But walking through, our project has been part of an EIR that was approved by the Kern Community College District some time ago, and we've been operating or planning facilities that are in the South Gateway under that particular EIR, so it's already gone through environmental review. To note that there is school bond money involved with this project.

32:41 So the project would go through Department of State Architecture, DSA, and not necessarily town planning. Town would have some review, but when it becomes a school project, it's done through Department of State Architecture. We own the property, and we're willing in our proposal to commit a large chunk, eight to nine acres, to a comprehensive

33:13 Arch and Cultural Center project. The project at Build Out, we believe, would have three facilities, the existing 100-seat theater, a new 300-seat state-of-the-art performing arts center slash events center, and approximately a 500-seat outdoor amphitheater. It would include a space holder for a fine arts center.

33:39 That would be operated by another party, quite possibly the Mono Arts Council. There would be additional parking on the site. There would be a storage building that would house equipment that were in or being used by any of the facilities out there. There would be a design shop, construction shop for set design and construction.

34:09 A place for storage for costumes and the equipment that goes in and about and is used by the facilities, which is all part of the MAC Center. And I believe I sent Rich a response to the last meeting where you guys asked some questions and I tried to, the questions I can remember, I tried to answer those and I think part of this.

34:37 is in more detail in that response. Preliminary design, we have done schematic design, which was necessary to get us to where we could come up with the first rough costing. We've used $500 a square foot as kind of the basis. It would be nice if it comes in less than that when we get to the second.

35:06 And third phase of costing. But I think it's a good number based on people in the trades that we've talked to outside the area and inside the area. The next phase of our project is to put funding agreements in place. And there are three key agreements, one with the college for bond funds, one with a private

35:38 We have a donor and a private foundation for a significant part, a little over $2 million. We have other private donors that we're in discussion with, and we've got at least one other verbal commitment for a couple hundred thousand dollars. And then a governance agreement with the college as to how this would be operated long term.

36:01 And then skipping down to operations, an agreement with the town for operational funding that would be a product of the business plan when we get to the business plan stage. And we're close to it. We're just waiting for some other pieces to fall in place so we're guessing as little as possible with it. The entitlements are part of the EIR. There's no additional...

36:33 Environmental review necessary. Final design. We'll use the schematic design. We'll send out an RFQ. I think we've identified about 20 architectural firms in California or the West that have both theater experience and school facilities experience. And one of the conditions of the college is that we

37:04 Select an architectural firm that's gone through the DSA process because that can be a giant hang-up if they haven't gone through that process. And we know that we have many options. The RFQ will come in. We'll go through a similar timeline that the town presented from RFQ. We'll have an internal committee that we'll review and select

37:33 Probably two or three of the firms we think are best suited to do the project that we'd like to have done. And then from there, we'll go to an RFP. We'll have qualifications for a proposal that has funding in it from the architect. And then from there, we'll sit down with the community group, a working group, that will select the architect that moves it forward.

38:01 Once that's done and we believe at the same time, we can, depending on the delivery system, how we choose to build the facility, and there's probably two or three different ways to do that, but we'll most likely bring a construction manager or construction management firm on board, and we'd like to have them working with the architect as we go through the second phase of bidding, which will be to take, refine the schematic designs,

38:31 Look at the elevations. Talk about the interior and exterior levels of finish that we'd like to see in it. Bring in sound and lighting expert at the time that can help identify the cost of some of the ancillary things that go with it. Look at the FF&E that goes with it and then try to put a more realistic bid number together. We'll find out if that's...

39:00 Below or over 500. And depending on how close that is, then we either decide that we're going forward with the project as is, or we have to go back and value engineer in some fashion. But that'll be determined if we're way out of base, or we decide that we try to raise some more money to make that happen. At that point, then we'll go to...

39:27 And assuming everything is moving forward, we'll go to working drawings. And working drawings are probably a six- to seven-month process from working drawings. When those are complete, we will go back to bid. When the working drawings are complete, we'll go back to bid one more time to see if what we actually envisioned comes back close to the numbers that we projected the first two times.

39:59 So it's kind of a three-stage process to make sure we get the numbers in something that's both affordable from a capital standpoint and operationally fits into the business plan budget. So we have a sliding scale from when we can start with the – really it all starts when the three key agreements are in place, at least in final draft form. The numbers –

40:30 We know we have a number from the college of four and a half million. We have then close to just about two and a half million from private donors that are committed, and we're in the middle of tying those things up. Then once we start the planning or the architectural process, it's probably a two to two and a half year process from start to finish. And if it's an ideal world, we would have this.

40:59 Ready to go in summer to fall of 2018. Questions? I have one question. So as we're kind of working through this process, one of the things that I'm really focusing on is as we plan out our community and our assets is not being duplicative in our efforts and making sure with limited land and limited financial resources,

41:35 That we're not duplicating efforts. I know you had responded back to the questions at the last MLR meeting with some more detailed questions. And one of the things you had mentioned in there is that the existing 100-seat Edison Theater would exist as a complement to this facility that is now going to be a 300-seat arts and cultural center. Can you just elaborate a little bit on the difference between the two?

42:01 Facilities where there might be some overlap, where the differences are, that would be helpful. Yeah, I think every facility, when you get into live productions, there's a lot of rehearsal time that goes into it. Rehearsal time, number one, can be done in the smaller theater.

42:21 There will be productions that don't fit in the bigger theater that you don't need to open that up that you can do in the smaller theater. And I think one of the key things, as we've looked at other complex operations, even the Egyptian theater that we talked about the last time in Park City, which is about 270 seats, they have 11 employees that operate that from sales, marketing, fundraising.

42:51 Number of functions that it takes to bring on a year-round entertainment facility. Part of the space in the Edison building would become the administrative complex for this facility. The way the facility is planned right now, there is one small office that's more like a ticket manager's office that goes into that building. But, you know, we talked a little bit about some months ago,

43:21 About the Crested Butte model. And in the town of Crested Butte, they have a 270 or 80 seat theater. Mount Crested Butte, which is five or six miles up the road and is similar to like the town of Mammoth and the Main Lodge, is in the process of trying to develop a 500 seat theater. And then the city of Crested Butte wants to bring in, in a timeline, another 300 seat theater.

43:50 And it's once you start growing these things and we create demand and we hopefully turn Mammoth into an arts and cultural community and that becomes part of why people come here, there'll be demand for all these things down the line. So presumably, you know, I was just at Of Mice and Men this week and it was sold out on a Thursday, which is awesome. Good for you.

44:18 Good for you, Leslie. But so presumably as we kind of program out a more robust and kind of diverse arts and cultural programming, there will be some stuff that maybe fits better at us in theater, some that would fit at the new facility and kind of use the two as complements. Yeah, we absolutely believe that. In the back of the new facility, we have kind of a natural bowl that we think we'll support about.

44:42 500 people and the way the new facility would lay in, it would be wind protected in the back. And, you know, one example or a couple of things we've looked at is you do a free Wednesday night concert where a family can come with a sack lunch and listen to somebody that we sponsor for a couple hundred bucks to play entertainment. Or we start with a getting a Shakespeare festival off the ground that's an outdoor summer kind of an activity the way Sand Harbor is.

45:12 up in Lake Tahoe right now. But I think there's just, there's so many opportunities that we haven't really dived into yet. And we should be looking at outcomes and not necessarily facilities. You need the facilities to get to the outcomes, but it's quality programming that brings people back and it's more diversity, more good stuff that we can add to the community long term. And it supports the visitor and it supports the

45:42 The students, the school kids in the area a lot too. Perfect. Thank you. Any other questions, comments? Did you originally think possibly fall 2017? Yeah, I did. I did. But each, I also thought all these agreements, like the agreement with the college, you know, we started it in September of 2014 and we just got a final working draft a couple of months ago.

46:11 And our board hasn't met yet to review that. They meet first week of November. So I have to present all this stuff to the Mammoth Lakes Foundation board. And it really kind of, there's legal stuff. There's a lot of money involved. It's the biggest thing we've ever done. I'm asking them to give up, you know, 8 to 10 acres of land for this project, which this thing then becomes really a community project down the line. In backdating.

46:40 Backdating two and a half years, you said, from architectural in 2018, I mean, that's about six months, really, right, to get there, to that stage. Yeah, if we get the agreements in place. The key agreements in the business plan. Yeah. Business plan's pretty close. As soon as we, I could give you guys something right now, but I know the numbers are going to change, and if I come in and give you something, and you say, well, this is what you said tonight, and next week it's.

47:08 $150,000 out of whack. I just like to be as accurate about that as possible. Anything else? I'm still not convinced that the $300,000 is where we want to go, and especially after listening to what you just said tonight, is that there's these other communities that are now looking at building a $500,000. We have one shot to do this right, and I guess that's where my concern about that $300,000 to $500,000 seat theater comes from.

47:38 Yes, I know it may not be full to start with, but I don't see us building another 500-seat theater down the road. And so, anyways, I think this is our one shot to get it right. Terry, can I just say, in that response in that email I sent you guys, there's probably four or five other key resorts like us that have theaters in the 200- to 300-seat range.

48:07 I think for the really, when you get into the really big groups, you've got to have full-on food and beverage, which is a very expensive proposition. When you get to that point, I mean, the mountain is really the best suited to deal with groups of that number that are going to come here. That's my two cents. Except for they don't have the acoustics in the facilities that this is going to have. So, anyways, but...

48:29 And then the 10-plus employees that you were talking about, does that include the current staff that are Mammoth Lakes Foundation? What are those 10-plus employees? Yeah, well, I think what we do is we create an organizational structure, a governance plan, which is going to be part of the business plan. Certainly, we have people with experience that will fit into some of those jobs, but overall, that's the kind of thing that most theaters.

48:59 End up having some more, some a few less, but we'll, I don't know, probably start with six or seven positions. And if we've got people that fit into those positions that have the experience, there's no reason why they shouldn't be doing those jobs. And I'll just say, you know, and I'm not going to point out Cher or anybody else in here, but we've got two and a half million dollars that's come to us because there are people that have been going to her shows.

49:26 That wouldn't be talking to us if it wasn't because of the content that has been produced. And you build, a lot of times you build things on relationships. And that's kind of the way the fundraising world works. If you're going to sell something to somebody, if you're going to go to Ford and get them to sponsor something, they want to know what they're going to get out of it. They're going to get a zillion impressions that are going to help them sell cars.

49:56 Where they're going to get some things that they can use that make them more attractive to folks. And I think, you know, as Rich goes down the line with helping you guys leverage the R&U money, it's, we don't really, there's no place in town you can put a sign on and say, give me $100,000 for it.

50:19 Richard's going to have to build relationships. I think a lot of those relationships are going to come from people that come to Mammoth already that are second homeowners that have a relationship with us that we're going to bring out of the woodwork as we do good things, not just this project but other projects. And then he's got to go out, spend some money. I hope he got some money for entertaining in his budget because he's going to have to do a fair amount of that.

50:46 Be able to sit down with a guy that can write a $100,000 check. And then just last question is, you know, I know that you're putting the business plan together, which includes partners. Right now, is the town of Mammoth Lakes the only partner in the O&M? Or are there other partners that are potential partners in the O&M? We haven't identified anybody right now as other partners in O&M. But so there's eight or ten people.

51:15 That will come on. There will be a grant writer. There will be a sponsorship person or a combination that will be out looking for funding. Part of the revenue will come from ticketed events. Part of it will come from rentals. We tried to set this up so that it can be a wedding venue. And I know when I went back to Keystone and talked to the folks back there about their facility in the village, they got about 15 or 18 nights.

51:44 A year of pretty good rentals from just private events that took place. And it's going to be a combination of a lot of things. We will project that in the business plan as part of the operating revenue that comes from it. But certainly everybody deals with some kind of grant revenue. We're in a unique situation because we were able to pass Measure U, and Measure U, I don't...

52:12 believe would have passed if we hadn't thrown the idea of the arts and cultural stuff into the mix. Okay. Anyone else? Just one quick follow-up. You had mentioned kind of in the past that as of tonight you're a little bit reticent to throw out numbers, but I know that we've talked about this 300,000 figure for O&M. Is that a number you're pretty comfortable with at least starting out that you think will cover it? Yeah.

52:42 The long-term goal would be to reduce that, obviously, but that's really to get things going. Yeah, and it's up to all of us. Yeah. If we have a product and you can say, Rich, go help them sell that product, and you can say that to John Urdi in some fashion, you know, from a marketing standpoint, I think there's a lot of opportunity. Okay. Thanks. I'd just add in terms of numbers, it's just an observation. It's kind of interesting, the last two projects that have been before us.

53:13 And I know this is preliminary before architecture, before designs, but they're both kind of right now pegged to a $500 per square foot cost. And they're two very different facilities. So it's going to be interesting when we get closer to design and into some real numbers to see kind of what the numbers for each one ends up being based on the aesthetic criteria that we're trying to achieve with these facilities. Just a quick note. And you have to understand they're both government projects to some degree.

53:42 So we have to meet a different standard than, say, I know the bowling alley, which is kind of similar to what we're envisioning right now, came in a lot less than $500 a foot, but they didn't have to build to the same standard and use prevailing wage in the things that we'll have to build to. Duly noted. Okay, thank you, Evan. Appreciate it. Thank you. So the next item on our list, at least on my list, has a pending.

54:09 Presenter. Do we have someone to talk about an outdoor event center, Rich? At this point, we don't. Okay. It's interesting to me that we heard about an outdoor amphitheater in this presentation, too, and I think that's a conversation that has to happen at some point. You were talking about competing facilities, and we know that we have a need, right? We hear it from the dais at Town Council. Shields has been talking about it at length.

54:37 I haven't heard that need articulated exactly in facility terms. So I don't know how this board will handle it moving forward into our deliberation. It is my hope on some of the preliminary work I've done over the last couple weeks to begin to put some options together, begin to flesh out constraints and opportunities, and look at whether it's private, public, forest land, what do we need to do. And I'll have something probably for our board meeting next week, at least a template to begin to work from.

55:07 Great. Any comments from the board on this particular topic, event, outdoor event? How did we get from outdoor event venue to bell-shaped parcel outdoor event venue? On the list? On this draft filter, it's now called the bell-shaped parcel outdoor event venue. Is that just from? Which one are you looking at? The one in the big packet.

55:35 And in the packet it was attached with something from Planner Parks? That was an item that people requested information, but we haven't gone down that road at all to look at any parcels whatsoever. You know, we began to look at a bell-shaped parcel as probably the opportunities and constraints matrix we crafted as one of the elements of exploring options for the multi-use facility and the complementary community center.

56:00 But there has been no further discussion at that. And based on Grady's presentation tonight, you are moving west for the complementary facilities. Okay. Anything else? No, sir. We just saved a little time, which is great. Okay, next up on the list is the Aquatic Center. Ralph Lockhart will be speaking to us. Hello, board members. Presentation I'll try to call up here.

56:53 If it works out okay with you, there's kind of two areas that I would present on. I can handle them both at the same time if that sounds good. And I'm not sure what the high-altitude training element really is, whether that encompasses what I'm doing or not, but it may be three that we're talking about. First of all, we've been at Snow Creek for a number of years talking about how to expand and get

57:27 Better usage of almost two acres of preliminary design. Some of these I can pass around. You can take a look at work that we've done to better utilize those two acres. We have five tennis courts outdoors. Those four to five months of the year maximum. So we're not getting very good coverage. It's nice flat land. It's already purpose for education, and we're trying to look for ways to leverage that into.

58:27 If you were driving to Snow Creek, you're driving in the parking lots, parking going inside the facility, this tennis court area, this pool area, and if you were to draw roughly a line here, we have about two acres. And I'll stop around and hold it in there. I can send both of them around, but here's the existing facility. It's about 39,000 square feet here, but this area of the property.

59:13 Okay. And Ralph, that's bordered to the west by the Aspen Creek complex, right? Or is it Aspen Village? Excuse me. Aspen Village. Thank you. And then bordered to the north by Snow Creek Phase 4? Okay. And then bordered to the south by Old Mammoth Road and then to the east by your...

59:48 Yeah, Creek House. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. One of these is, if we were trying to put a running track, size of an oval track, in order to have indoor running every month of the year. So these were some layouts on how that might be structured. And like a field house? Field house type concept. That's that page. This page, as part of the presentation, you could roughly see,

1:00:49 Is that 50 or 25 on the diagram? That's 50. Okay.

1:01:46 If you're trying to put a running track, some of the challenges you might face to get a perfectly oval one that you might use for an indoor track meet or something like that. So some of the designs were there. If you decided, hey, I really need this oval running track, then it might encroach upon your potential aquatic facility. So it would be not like a typical university that might have 50 acres to spread all of their field houses out on.

1:02:18 So what I'll do is just quickly go through the presentation and try to address the seven elements as best as I can. The goal here would be indoor and outdoor, recreational opportunities. We think a lot of economic drivers

1:02:56 that would be available to us, improving our position against other areas, Park City, Aspen, Vail, et cetera, and give us some additional shoulder season type things that could be done. I'm going to skip so we can go more quickly, but here's some of the advantages we have about this particular area. I can make the presentation available to you guys as well.

1:03:26 This gives us other elements necessary to become a real high altitude training center. We have an indoor facility that I think I would consider state of the art at this time, but having field house, the running capabilities to complement those that are at Whitmore would be great. We've added on our own trampoline facilities and other things.

1:03:54 that make training here pretty favorable. Some of the kinds of things that are done in other areas, Park City has a field house project. They have indoor soccer leagues for kids. So I think not only do you bring people to town, but you have, with the field house concept, and we'll see some pictures here in a minute, you can simultaneously have a basketball game going on in one court.

1:04:21 Volleyball on another court, indoor soccer on a third, and tennis, somebody playing tennis on a fourth at the same time. You can have soccer leagues, basketball leagues. You can have so many things that are available that I would think would affect thousands of people throughout the year. If we want to get closer to being a USOC site, having 50-meter pool, having the running track.

1:04:51 Those kinds of things really help put us on the map. So I'm kind of mixing the two things, but the high altitude training facility or field house would have possibly a running track, areas that teams could train in, whether that's one of the courts, and you could focus easily on soccer, tennis, volleyball, basketball. Pickleball has become a hot

1:05:22 New thing as well. And leagues and events would be great. The aquatic center would not only be for training but also for recreation and would be complemented by the indoor pools and jacuzzis and things that Snow Creek already has and be available 12 months of the year. Here are some pictures of a variety of various venues.

1:05:52 Perhaps an idea of how they would be constructed indoors. You could have the running track, sport court. You, in these locations, we'll get past all of that. One of the advantages of locating it there is it's in the middle of the town and we get to leverage level ground, probably a minimal CEQA type process because that

1:06:24 Two acres is already purpose for tennis courts and pools and is not environmentally sensitive like other places that you might consider. We already have whirlpools. We have steam rooms. We have 250 lockers on the men's side and 220-something, I think, on the women's side. So we already have a lot of the plumbing, the administrative, the check-in facilities and other things that are needed to...

1:06:52 Really leverage this particular project. Parking, we have about 88 spaces now. We'll skip some of that stuff. We talked about potential uses. Running track, I think there's a great opportunity for expos, trade shows, and I'll show you a couple pictures, conferences, meetings, possibly concerts, other things, in a 33,000 square foot building. This can be done

1:07:28 In a variety of ways. Here is Park City's ski swap in their field house facility. So big trade show, tons of people attending, configurable, large floor space, drop-down nets, partitioning the space so that you can have your basketball game or your tennis match and that your ball isn't necessarily flying the whole 275 feet to the other side.

1:08:00 We'll look at some pictures of courts and how here's a potential type of surface that you would use in a facility like this that is a sport court slash running track. Here are some examples of other facilities, indoor facilities. These are set up for tennis. This one has kind of a circular running track around and all of the sport courts are divided with a kind of an oval.

1:08:32 Section in the middle. Here's another example of how that particular design can work to allow multiple sports to go on at the same time, but also be configurable for big events or meetings. Construction design can be with a high-quality steel building, much lower than the $500 cost per square foot that you would see most of the time in other areas.

1:09:03 Steel buildings can be built at $100, $125 a square foot. If you're going to dig a pool and other things, you certainly have to add those. And you will have some costs for courts and basketball standards and other rigging and scaffolding. This was the Park City. They have fields for indoor soccer. There's another location that's been configured.

1:09:34 Differently for football practice stadium. Construction can be also concrete cinder block sides with girders and ceilings as well at reasonable cost. There's your future multi-use facility. And again, some other ideas. This is an aquatic center. I thought what's wonderful about our summertime is it's beautiful and you want to be outside.

1:10:06 Put an indoor aquatic facility, you lose a little bit of that. San Jose had this kind of glass enclosure. I haven't investigated all the costs there, but I think that's one option to consider as to how you might put your indoor facility together. And again, views from the outside of one concept for the indoor facility. That's the end of that part of the show.

1:10:36 Let me just go over the advantages and hopefully I'm covering the various elements. Certainly would need to be an approved concept. We would have to talk and design the facility to your specification, to the town's specification so that it got the most bang for the buck, so to speak. The own lease or permit.

1:11:07 I think one interesting idea is that Snow Creek could consider building the entire facility with private funds, and then the town leases it for a number of years with an option to purchase. So you don't have huge capital costs and $500 a square foot type of situation to look at for many years. So you get a high-quality facility very soon. Construction costs are 30 or 40 percent lower.

1:11:38 Thank you. Thank you.

1:12:08 It can be owned. Snow Creek could look at selling that land to the town and having that whole process be a town-built facility in some kind of shared use with all of the other infrastructure that we have, but we think perhaps leasing a facility like that might be a good option to consider. We have done some preliminary design work, but a lot more would be needed, and perhaps first round might be to do some funding of exactly what

1:12:38 architectural designs would be needed. Entitlement I touched on briefly. I think it would be much easier than every project you've talked about so far to entitle this one because it would be a very similar use building a structure on top of it. And CEQA would be much faster and easier. Design costs and funding. I think

1:13:09 We've already talked about the cost of this type of building. We have infrastructure in terms of boilers that we already use for the outdoor pools and piping enclosures for all of those. So I think a lot of that could be leveraged. It's in a central location. It's two additional acres in the town that the town doesn't have access to yet. So it expands your

1:13:39 ability to control your destiny. Time savings we talked about, leveraging our new funds, USOC designation. It's not necessarily a project that we would hold forever if we're in second, third, fourth tier because I've got partners who would like to make better use of that land. So we would kind of say it's not a...

1:14:10 Standing offer for 25 years kind of an arrangement. Not $500 a square foot. Not a government project. Questions? Thanks, Ralph. Go ahead, guys. Hi. I'm kind of new to the board here, so I haven't seen a lot of the plans tonight. I've just seen tonight. But first question really I have is two acres. It looks like there's a lot you want to do with that two acres, and it sounds very cramped.

1:14:41 Would there be things that would naturally have to give way to other priorities? For example, if you had the running track, would that impact the pool? Do you have a sort of deeper idea of how we'd be able to fit all that stuff in? You know, that's a really good question. It really depends on what the town would like to see leveraged. I do think you could put both facilities on the property.

1:15:09 You might end up with some variances, zoning variances and things to consider. Putting a 50 meter pool and associated bleachers and things might make that building larger and you might have to make some compromises on the second building. If there was a lot of available land in the town to say, okay, we'll put the aquatic center here and the field house at some other location, that's a possibility.

1:15:40 For the size of the town that we have and what we'd like to buy it off, I think that you could probably do both of them and leverage some parking in locker rooms, showers, steam rooms, pool pools, et cetera, that would serve both facilities. So you may end up with a little bit less than what your ideal dream would be, but working within some constraints and the final design hasn't been put together yet.

1:16:12 And along that line, what about with your recognizability in this area, is there a possibility of you managing an off-site facility that's not on Snow Creek, for example? Has that been looked at at all? Managing an off-site? Well, I'm just throwing this off the top of my head, but you look at the Whitmore's got a track already. Why would you want to build another track at Snow Creek if we could utilize your skills there, perhaps?

1:16:43 That sounds like a compliment, and thank you. I think the Whitmore Track is amazing, and it's wonderful. The problem is its location is a 15-minute drive, and, you know, both ways. And just like our outdoor tennis facilities, it can only be used at certain times of the year. So when the wind is high or the temperatures are cold, it's going to get underutilized.

1:17:13 If there was a structure on top of that track, it might help it. So it's a little lower elevation. It may be good. And certainly we'd look at whatever we could do to leverage our management capabilities if that made sense for all parties. Well, I think the idea of a 15-minute drive to LA having the Olympics is going to be a big plus. And how important do you think a 50-meter pool is compared to a 25?

1:17:41 If USOC designation, do you have any, if you want USOC designation, that's a pretty big deal. My limited understanding is that 50 threshold is pretty important. Yeah. Yeah. Not everything revolves around the triathletes, but certainly I think that's the direction, having been on the rec strats committee, the direction that the town and recreation in the town would like to go is be known.

1:18:42 Even better for all the high altitude things that we can do. We have an amazing Mammoth Track Club and other endurance athletes up here. We don't get the swimmers that we should because of the pool issue. Is it feasible at all to have an elevated running track to make more room for use of ground floor? A lot of the facilities do that. It adds a little bit of cost, but it's certainly a consideration.

1:19:11 You could, in the field house, put easily four courts side by side down that 275 feet and have plenty of room for basketball. You know, each court, I've looked at the dimensions and things, and each of the court sizes would work well, and you could probably fit a running track around the outside. It probably wouldn't be a competition track, but I don't think that's what we're really looking for, is you want to be able to just run and not have to do it all the time on a treadmill.

1:19:40 I think that's a big question, actually. You kind of mentioned it earlier, Terry, is this, you know, competition requires a lot more space. Just being, having a kid on a swim team, you know, even going to those meets, a lot more kind of facility around. And you have to, if you're inviting people there for a day-long swim meet, you also have to have concessions and some of that stuff. And so that competition versus training facility.

1:20:09 Question is a big question, I think. And the training facility is really a no-brainer at altitude, as you've mentioned. And the merits of having, pardon me, as you mentioned, the merits of having a 50-meter pool is that you can divide it into different directions, and you can have diving on one end and swimming on one end, and then you can turn it. Swimming has seasonality where you swim 50 meters in the...

1:20:35 In the summer and then 25 yards in the winter. So there's different competitions, you know, at different times of the year. But from a training standpoint, you can do it either way. And you really open up the door to possibilities by having it 50 meters. I think, you know, I think the bottom line, and you alluded to this, a lot of this would come down to the design and to further discussions on this.

1:21:05 Track and running and those type of things. The limited conversations I've had, it seems pretty critical to hit that 50 meter on the pool. I think we could consult Dina and Andrew and talk to them about the needs of, do we need to have an indoor track facility? Should it be elevated? Should it be on the ground? I think we can figure out how we configure that space and what's the best utilization of the space. Two questions I had.

1:21:33 You're kind of talking about two facilities here. One would be an aquatic facility. The second would be the kind of field house and whatever ancillary stuff goes in there. Do you envision those two being conjoined facilities or two separate buildings? I was unclear on that. I believe that likely you'll get some economies of scale if you plan the project all at one time, though you could organize it in such a way that you build one and then you build the other and they have.

1:22:03 You know, connecting doorways or passageways. You wouldn't have a lot of space between them, and I think there's some advantage to heating and that kind of thing when you've got them designed to be connected. Okay. Second question I have, and maybe this is more for you, Tom. I'm not sure between the two of you, certainly not my area of expertise, but just rough costs. I know you alluded to, you know, the significant savings if you go steel versus, you know,

1:22:33 Post and beam, rock construction, that type of thing. How does glass factor in? I mean, is doing something that's, you know, significant glass, windows type facility, is that significantly less expensive, significantly more expensive? No, and I'm, we should have a great answer to that, but it's going to be a little bit more expensive. With glass. Because you've got to have snow loads and everything else for glass. I think it totally depends on the structure.

1:22:59 Okay. But what you need to support the glass elements. My question to me is going to the same portion. Ralph, do you have a guesstimate of what we're talking about here? I'm always not looking at range, but are we talking $350 a foot? Because I just want to clarify if we're talking 30,000 square feet total or 30,000 square feet for one building and then additional square footage in the other building. Let me go over those. The ones that are on the paperwork that's gone around was a 275 foot by 120 foot.

1:23:29 33,000 square foot facility. That's the field house, 30,000 square feet? That's the field house. Okay. The aquatic center was roughly 94 by 200, and that was 18,800 square feet. Okay. So roughly, you know, 50,000 square feet total. I'm not as up to speed on current pool construction. A lot depends on what, you know, we've got a pool there now.

1:24:01 And what we would be doing is extending it and widening it. Who knows what lies beneath the earth in that area. Did you guys pencil it out when you were considering doing it on your own? We spent more time on the field house just because it's an easier economic model because of the many uses for city leagues and trade shows and expos and conferences and things.

1:24:31 So we spent more time on that. Certainly we could get back in that. I'd have a hard time venturing the guess right now. Most of the time, if you applied something on a field house, about $125 a square foot is a good starting place. In some areas of the country that don't have the snow load and roofing requirements, you can sometimes do those for $7,500 a square foot for pretty good quality steel building.

1:24:59 What we would be eliminating is lots of plumbing, lots of locker rooms, lots of administrative space, wasted space. It could be your exercise field house and not a lot more in theory. Do you envision having to upgrade any of the existing facilities in the 39,000 square foot structure you have today if you're going to accommodate just exercise, just field?

1:25:31 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:26:01 Almost any facility in California from a health club standpoint. And I just had one more question. Just to clarify, you made a mention earlier about you didn't want to get to a long, long-term agreement. You talked about potential of public-private partnership but also lease back or something of that nature. But I heard in between there that you weren't looking at a very long, long-term lease if that was the case. I'm kind of referring in between. You're kind of saying you'd prefer either something where the town took it over.

1:26:30 Some sort of exit strategy so it's ongoing ownership by yourself and your group. Am I reading between? I don't think we mind a long – in fact, the way to finance something like this is to have a lease agreement with the town that's as long as possible, and it's easy to go to the bank and get a construction loan for that. If it's a very short-term lease, that becomes a more difficult prospect.

1:26:58 To us, it doesn't really matter that much if the town wants to do something else or wants to build its nice, acquires land from the Forest Service and builds a $100 million facility 20 years from now. I think that the whole complex is complementary.

1:27:18 Yeah, so I think what Ralph was when you were saying the window was you didn't have a long, long window. It was actually to form the partnership and do this, right? Okay, great. It would be difficult to wait around 10 years when it's time to make a decision. Yes, okay. I misunderstood that. Sorry. Because you don't envision that being there 10 years from now. Is that what you're saying? Same opportunity.

1:27:39 You're looking for an opportunity to make a change there. You would love to do that in conjunction with the town. If that's not the case, you may look at other avenues for utilization of that land. And frankly, one of the reasons we bought Snow Creek in the beginning, it was threatened, and we thought, what a great venue. And it's always been my dream to continue the dream of expanding that venue and someday achieving the

1:28:09 The recognition we as a town deserve and this beautiful location deserves as perhaps an Olympic training site. And I think that would be a nice, would be a tough piece to lose for some other. Any other questions? Thank you. Thanks, Ralph. I think that was really helpful to the board. I think whether you know it or not, you spoke to a couple of our kind of core organizing principles, which are leveraging existing facilities, leveraging public-private partnerships,

1:28:42 Duplicating facilities in the town. So a lot for us to think about. Thank you. Okay, moving on. Let's take up high altitude training. You know, I think we should have a conversation about what that category includes. We've heard, spoke a lot about high altitude training in the last presentation. I've got here that there's no speaker.

1:29:10 For this category? Yeah, the next step in this process is to pull together a group of folks, Ralph being included, he made mention to multiple partners, to talk about what would it take to complete a USOC application, what are the required amenities, what's phase one, what's phase two, we're just beginning those conversations. You know, my own eyes, I don't look at it as a venue specific, but I look at it as a regional conversation. You know, how do we maximize amenities from the mountain down to Bishop? You know, live high, train higher.

1:29:39 What does that look like as we begin to engage more partners in these conversations? So as we go further down that road, I'll bring more information back to this board. Rich, what kind of timeline are you looking at in terms of just informing our deliberations, moving forward to our deliverable for town council? In terms of talking about the high-altitude training and forming that group, is this kind of ongoing beyond?

1:30:03 That deliverable? That would be ongoing beyond that deliverable. Realistically, based on the number of items on our plate at this point, those deliverables, this is probably not a group I'm not going to get together formally until January. Okay. Excellent. Once we get that going, it's probably three or four months to begin to flush it out. Responsibilities, timelines, applications, who wants to be involved in that partnership. Talking to Brownlee the other day, Mark Brownlee of the Mountain, he's telling me they're about three years in.

1:30:27 And they're just finalizing their application for the mountain to become USOC certified. We've got a good relationship with that group of folks. We are engaged in those conversations with them to find out what lessons were learned and how do we move that process along a little bit quicker. Thank you. Any other comments from the board on that category? High altitude training? Rich, just a quick question. Is that designation typically 100% facilities driven?

1:30:55 Or are we looking at some scenario where we may need some facilities to complement, but also we have some natural assets here that may go into that conversation? We had a group engage in that conversation a couple years ago. I looked at phase one. You've got the natural amenities that you can very easily fit the mountain, which kept running with that conversation. You've got biking.

1:31:16 You look at EMBA that we've engaged in right now. You look at the track club. So those are three natural settings right now that we can do not needing facilities whatsoever. That would be phase one. You hear Ralph begin to allude to phase two. And we bring together the amenities, 50-meter pool.

1:31:32 What does it look like with the relationship with the Mammoth Track Club and the track down at Whitmore? What do those pieces look like as we build those for Phase 2? And right now we're just looking at training. We're not looking at competition sites, and we're just looking at training. I think the Mountain's done some competitive events in the past, which further supports their application. And one of the ingredients is what does youth development look like as you're training young athletes to move into those tiers?

1:32:00 And if we begin to create these amenities that are good for elite athletes, probably good for the rest of the community, you know, as an educator for life. You know, we said to my staff, teach the highest, the brightest kid in that class. If we can push that ceiling, we're going to raise the foundation. And I think that's the concept. I'm looking at this as we begin this process with the application. Okay. Any further comment? Okay. Let's move on then. Shane's inspiration is up next. Michael Ramirez. Are we getting a presentation? It is not Michael.

1:32:34 We have Ms. Patty and Ms. Diane. Excellent. This is unable to be here, so I was not involved in the total process, but I'm here to answer a few questions.

1:32:54 Shane's inspiration was a result of the Plan Your Parks meetings, which took place last year over a long period of time. And it was approved at that point in time by the Plan Your Parks committee and attendees that it would be at Mammoth Creek Park West. And what Shane's inspiration actually is

1:33:21 is an organization that was begun in 1998, and they have 48 inclusion, inclusive playgrounds throughout the United States, mostly in the western United States, some in Mexico, and they had one in Sochi, Russia, as a result of the Paralympic Games.

1:33:46 And they provide a lot of services for those who are interested and who commit to wanting an inclusive playground in that area. And I am a public health nurse, so I'm involved with the special needs children in the area. And I do know that I have in Mono County

1:34:11 A certain amount of there are over 60 special needs children and a lot more qualify for other services that are also special needs. And what Chains Inspiration does is they offer seven different services, site plan review, a bubble diagram.

1:34:37 They identify ADA access points. They prepare electronic base plan, conceptual design layout, design development plans, and they coordinate with landscape architects for the area so that we can utilize some of our beautiful area. And there was an initial proposed budget

1:35:07 That was set and you may have that copy. But our next steps for the committee that are really interested is to meet with the project director from Shane's Inspiration so that we can get some more concrete ideas. And some of the...

1:35:33 Some of the organizations that do support Shane's inspiration for the inclusive playground are from the area, Disabled Sports and First Five, Early Start.

1:35:52 CCS, Great Steps Ahead, Kern Regional Center, AMACA and Heart to Hand Family Resource Center, as well as some of the physicians in the area. I may not have all the answers, but I'll try. Do you have anything additional to add? Anyone else who has been on the committee?

1:36:32 Excuse me. Could you come up and speak to the microphone, please? Thank you. It's that there are people watching on TV. It's for the public. Yeah, you're on TV. Oh, I'm on. Hi. Thank you. My name's Patty Stump. I've worked with special needs kids in this community for 30 years, birth to 21 years old.

1:36:59 I kind of went over that last time. And one of the questions that had come up was about where the location could possibly be other than Mammoth Creek Park, and I think that was some of the conversation we've had tonight in the presentations, that there might be some other locations. It does need to be where families are going to come.

1:37:20 and visit. And so if a mother or a father is doing track and another teenage child is in a swimming pool, it's nice for the child or the grandparent to be able to have access to something that will entertain them as well and occupy them. And it's just a really, really important feature that we don't have in this town and it's available and accessible to all children.

1:37:45 And all adults and many children and many adults can't access our playgrounds as it is because, I know, I take children there and I carry them. And I'm getting too old to do that. Just wagons. Just wagons. Yeah, they're wagons. Well, the wagons don't go over the surfaces that are in our parks right now. So actually, that's a good point to bring up. The other point that we haven't been able to access is because we do need to have the project manager discuss with us

1:38:14 What the cost is. We have kind of an estimate of the size, and it's been on the plans that we've provided for you. For placement of equipment, we have a team of people who can help make those decisions about what equipment is most appropriate for all children. And, I mean, I don't know.

1:38:37 So financially, we're not absolutely positive that $500,000 was a good estimate provided by Shane's Inspiration, much of which we're going to be able to raise. I don't think we're going to have problems with that. And we have a lot of people on board to try to help us with that. Those organizations that are partners are also organizations that you probably recognize do not have a lot of money available either. So money wouldn't necessarily come from them other than small.

1:39:04 But there are quite a few grants available. And Shane's inspiration is very, very diligent and successful with fundraising. So they would be giving us a plan. Patty, tell us about the agreement. When I talked to Brad about two weeks ago, I said there was an agreement that we need to enter with to move this down. Tell the board a little more about that. Well, actually, I don't know very much about it.

1:39:32 Diane might be able to fill in. However, my understanding is that they will do a buy-in once the town has said, okay, we're willing to go into an agreement. I think it's a contractual agreement that we will pursue this playground in our area. I don't think it necessarily holds us to size or location or any of those particular details. I can't speak to that intelligently. I'm just giving you my best guess.

1:40:00 He would be much more forthcoming in sharing information and giving of themselves if we make that agreement with them. Do you know if it's binding around finances? I don't. Okay. I can find that out, though. That would be helpful. Thank you. I'm sure it would be. It helped me, too. It wouldn't feel quite so foolish. Yeah. Any other questions, comments? I'm reminded that at our last meeting we...

1:40:31 Took up Shane's inspiration a little bit. And you'll forgive me if my memory is a little hazy. That was a five-hour slugfest, as I recall. But one of the things that came up was we talked about the need to have a dedicated park versus spreading some of the equipment throughout our...

1:40:52 Parks, existing parks. I'm trying to remember back. I don't think we ever came to a consensus. No, Terry had brought that up, and I think that was a good point. But I think, to my way of thinking, which I tried to address a few minutes ago, was you'd like to have that dedicated park where families are all going to come. Now, families do go out and do a couple of things out at Shady Rest.

1:41:19 So that park would be accessible for special needs children and maybe kids who are going to play soccer or volleyball or badminton or during baseball season maybe playing baseball, but that's quite a distance from the baseball fields actually. And what other park do we have? Oh, we have the one of the community center, which is very isolated. It doesn't really attract families for family opportunities. There's one picnic table.

1:41:48 And the equipment there is nice. And we have been housed with Mono County Office of Education. Their special ed program, birth through three years old, has been there in the past. And so we've gone out there and used it, but believe me, we've done a lot of lifting and pushing and catching. So I think the idea of dedication would be you want to locate it where other families are going to gather for other reasons, which is why it kind of comes down to maybe a dedicated.

1:42:16 I was going to say, I think the general consensus was that it needed to be a dedicated park, and if we could put other items within our other parks, then that would be great, but it needed to be the one dedicated park. Yeah, that was actually one of my questions, too, and I don't want to put words in Mike's mouth, but I actually specifically spoke to him about that kind of, do you...

1:42:38 Add features to all of our existing parks so that people can utilize any of our parks that have those needs? Or do you just kind of concentrate it to one area to say, hey, if you want one inclusive park, one area where kind of children with special needs know that they can go? And it's been a long time since I talked to him about it, but it seemed to be that his thought was that it would be better in one location.

1:43:05 He didn't seem to be too concerned about where that is. You know, pretty flexible with what the town can come up with, with where that might fit best. But that seemed to be his kind of general thought, that if we can identify a spot in town that could potentially have some other complementary uses, but... I think you'd find he's matured in his... I mean, I think we'd all be extremely gracious and have so much gratitude to have a park at all.

1:43:32 Sure. And if we can put some in each other, each of the other parks as well as a dedicated park, we'd love that too. Sure. But I think that, you know, Mike is just so intent on making sure there is a park. Sure. That he doesn't want to shut anybody down by insisting that it be a certain way. Right. So maybe to start, it might make sense to identify one location where we can do a true inclusive park. And, you know, if that phases out from there, fantastic. But that might be what we want to identify as.

1:44:02 One location where we can have an inclusive park. Great. Thanks for the feedback. Sorry, a second question I had. I know you talked about kind of the seven things that Shane's inspiration brings to the table as far as implementation. Funding's not one of them outside of maybe going and raising some funds, but they don't bring like matching funds or anything like that to the two.

1:44:27 They bring those seven services. Right. And they do assist with grants. Okay. And they don't actually contribute money. Financially, okay. Other than the services, which. Which are significant, sure. Which are significant services that would save money. Yeah, and I think, you know, one of the things maybe if you could circle back to us on that I've struggled with a little bit throughout, you know, my process with this is it seems like funding specifically,

1:44:59 has become a little bit of this like chicken and egg scenario. It's like do we know how much the funding needs to be or do we have to commit funding to then turn around and figure out what the final wrap-up is? And so I think in looking at a potential allocation, that would be really helpful to kind of understand. There was an initial estimate made, and I don't know if you got a copy of that.

1:45:26 I'm not sure that I did. From the spring allocations. Yeah. Application. On the application. And so that's the 500, is that the number we're talking about, is the estimate? The estimate is the total. Okay. And that's inclusive. Initially made by Mike when he was dealing with Shane's inspiration project manager. Okay. And that's not to be matched, right?

1:45:55 That's 500,000 inclusive of everything. That's not to be clear. That's based on the square footage that is identified on the. And you had talked a little bit about being close to a refinement of the estimate. Is there something that's coming down the pipeline soon as far as honing in on that number? As we hope to be able to talk with more formal. Okay.

1:46:28 Thank you.

1:46:59 So just one more question. Is there a preferred location that, again, I'm first into this tonight, but is there a location that you guys have been looking at or you prefer? Actually, Mammoth Creek Park West was the location that was looked at because there is already a small amount of playground equipment there that could be added to and upgraded.

1:47:30 And obviously a lot of families have... Sorry, carry on. I didn't mean to interrupt. The whole idea really is to... of an inclusive playground is to have both those children that may be special needs children be able to also play with all children so that it is... it has sensory equipment and it also has...

1:48:00 Equipment that anyone can use. Presumably it's important. A lot of families have a special needs child and probably another child. So it's twice as much work to play unless they're included. That they can enjoy everything together. And Gary, that came out of the Plan Your Parks process. When there was a preferred design for Mammoth Creek Park West, it included Shane's Inspiration. So that's where kind of that comes from.

1:48:30 And was Trails End considered? Is there room at Trails End? Trails End was not really considered in that process, if I recall correctly. I don't know who the best person to answer this call in or Stu. Rich, do you think there's room for the multi-use facility, additional parking, the existing playground, a community center, and a chance? Stu, do you want to take that or I can? I'll jump all over.

1:49:05 Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Yeah, so we've been through a planning parks process, and Betsy and I were just chatting. I mean, the identification in the planning parks process was 20,000 to 25,000 square feet in a corner of Mammoth Creek Park West, surrounded by kind of community gardens. It was the back right-hand corner. That way. But, you know, the option here is to really think about enhancing the existing playground. You know, I think I like the all-inclusive element of it.

1:49:34 The option is to actually relocate that existing playground to another park that we haven't probably considered. And I think it's really important because it's already seeing that type of use. And if you're thinking about bringing in complementary uses such as a community centre, which I think would be a great asset for a lot of our entire community, from able to disabled folks, plus you've got the multi-use facility, you've already got amenities parking. I mean, it's already a...

1:49:58 A heavily utilised park for that purpose with greenbelt, right? So anywhere there's some grass, we really should kind of, you know, be very aware of that. So the option, you know, I think is either to designate additional area in that park or really to look at maximising the existing playground and use that space and then consider relocating the existing playground to other areas or just add on to that park and create like an all-inclusive element.

1:50:25 At Mammoth Creek Park West. So it's interesting right now the timing is key because of the proposed EIR that we're working through. So if these are the things that programmatically we're looking at considering for Mammoth Creek Park West, it's probably better talking about it now than having that considered as part of that analysis than not. Yeah, I think, you know, to further just expand on that.

1:50:49 We actually did speak about that in the multi-use facility task force a little bit. It didn't elevate to the level of a formal recommendation, but that did come up a number of times to say, hey, if we think about putting a community center multi-use facility, could we also maybe include Shane's inspiration over there? As far as raw numbers, the existing ice rink facility now, the actual ice rink is about 0.8 acres.

1:51:18 And if you look at the existing footprint of what we have now, so you're talking parking, ice rink, and all of the ancillary support buildings, that's about two acres. The parcel of land that is available at Mammoth Creek Park West is about three acres. So if you could kind of just envision taking two acres, moving it over there, you would gain some space with parking.

1:51:45 You would gain some space with some ancillary buildings because those might be put into the community center that would be in conjunction with the multi-use facility. And that still leaves potentially an acre for some other green space or Shane's Inspiration Park. So I think the short answer is yes, I think there's room at that park. You know, of course we can't put 12 different facilities over there, but if we're looking at community center, multi-use facility.

1:52:13 And a Shane's Inspiration Park kind of tiered off of the existing playground. I think there would be room for that. But we'd have to go a little farther into the design of that. But I don't think we should preclude it as an option. And with the property that the Forest Service owns, there is the potential for placing playground equipment on it as it is not a building.

1:52:37 Yeah, I think, you know, we'd obviously have to run that through the Forest Service in a more formal capacity, but the conversations I've had with them is, you know, if we want to talk about major infrastructure, the answer is going to be a no. If we want to talk about more passive uses like a playground or a green space or those type of things, I think they would be agreeable to that. So, you know, that's another five acres on the southwestern side of that park that the Forest Service has.

1:53:06 That might be a decent option for this as well. So I think there's room on that park, and I don't think this would be something that the Forest Service would have a huge problem with, but of course we'd have to run that by them. Yeah, my just closing comment would be, I don't know, I think it's worthy of considering two playground areas on there, but I just think there's an opportunity here to really kind of, you know, maximize the existing playground. And do you look at moving that and relocating that playground down to something like Whitmore?

1:53:33 Which, as you know, there's plenty of families down there going down for a lot of activities. So there would an opportunity to be able to kind of enhance that existing park and, you know, create more of a, you know, three to 99 year kind of concept at the moment. It's just kind of a sports park. So, and that master plan for that facility does kind of speak to kind of the pavilion, playground and those type of areas too. So that'll be my closing comments, I think. Betsy might have a few words on that.

1:53:58 So I just wanted to add just very quickly for all of you. So first of all, this is a really huge trend in recreation. I think that if we are looking at building any new playground in the future.

1:54:09 This is a really huge thing, this idea of having an inclusive playground that all kids can play on. You know, abled kids aren't necessarily going to recognize that it's, you know, an adaptive playground. It's just they all get to play together, which is great. And then I also just wanted to just quickly touch on there was a little bit of a conversation about adding equipment to the parks versus creating a Shane's Inspiration Park, and I don't think that conversation was ever intended as an either-or. I think that the idea was that as we looked to upgrade.

1:54:37 Our current playground equipment, is it, you know, ages and so forth that, you know, maybe in the shorter term we'd look at adding these elements to our existing playgrounds, but that wouldn't necessarily preclude moving forward with a larger project. Great. Thanks. I mean, my sense of the Shane's inspiration, I've seen the one, you've seen the one in Griffith Park, right? We've played there a lot. I mean, it's, it's, it's.

1:54:58 A, pretty neat, and B, to me it doesn't necessarily jibe with the kind of stuff that we've got right now. So it seems like if we're looking at doing it, we should look at doing it, not having half old stuff and half new stuff. That's a fair point. And it is the case, from spending a good bit of time with my daughter at the Griffith Park one, we would have never known that it was an adaptive playground without actually reading the signage around there.

1:55:26 Actually become inspired by the story around it too. I think one thing that might be helpful to this board though is when we're talking about financing and I appreciate the comments about Shane's Inspiration being good at fundraising and supporting that is to learn a little bit more about how other communities have financed their Shane's Inspiration Park and maybe seeing some detail.

1:55:50 If we could kind of get in touch with some other communities and really break down what their process looked like, I think we could learn a lot. I've gone back and forth to Brad Thornton a few times. As late as 4.47 this afternoon when he texted in, I've got a Tournament of Roses event down in Pasadena this weekend, so you and I are going to have a cup of coffee. I can bring him up to speed to where we are and what we need and try to bring him up here to do a presentation to the board in the next month or so. All right. That'd be great.

1:56:15 But, Tom, I think that's a great point. I'm hoping that for every one of these projects, and obviously I'm jonesing to get to a place where we've got some digital formats that we can work with that are better for presenting these kinds of ideas and backlogging, you know, what's the heritage of each project so that we have easy access to it. But I think one of the elements that I'd like to begin to see in planning any of these things is to see some case studies for each one. Without question. Yeah.

1:56:45 Having robust digital versions, not just for presentation, but for just sharing with the community and kind of really being open about the planning and the vetting of these projects, for sure. Okay, ready to move on? Any further comments about Shane's inspiration? Okay. We're getting near the end here. A little over our estimate, but we're close. Next on the list is Biathlon Training Center.

1:57:15 It looks like we are still pending. Still pending. Talk to Roy Moyer. He's not quite ready to jump in the pool. We've had conversations. We're probably still a month or two away. Okay. Any comments from the board on this category? No. My only comment is I'm just concerned that it doesn't seem to be anybody jumping on board to lead this, and I'm just concerned it may not happen without somebody taking ownership of it. That's a fair point. Okay. Do you expect?

1:57:45 Any kind of presentation to the board or comment in our scheduled board meetings coming up? Roy and I spoke about three weeks ago. He was going to take the conversation we had, the templates, the filter, the executive summaries. He was going to meet with his direct support provider at the mountain since it's part of the mountain property, mountain project, and come back to me. I reached back out last week. Where are we in the process? He says he's still not quite there. He needs a little more time. Okay.

1:58:16 We've already covered the field house, so we get to leapfrog one. And that takes us to our last item on the list of top tier projects to discuss here. It's a niche project category. Do we have anything to add to this category, Rich? Terry just asked me to bring up the Hayden Museum.

1:58:38 And she talked about the presentation of the council recently and thinks that the board should look at the Hayden Museum as part of one of the facilities that we could utilize, maybe a small event center, some kind of outdoor center, but we should start thinking about that from her point of view. And I'll piggyback on that and say that Dana Stroud, who's not with us this evening, sent Rich and I an email talking about Hayden and the idea of kind of a historic...

1:59:06 Center in town should be considered on this list as well in conjunction with Hayden Cabin. I got asked to go speak out there last year for, I'm going to butcher the name, but it was a coalition of writers that came into town. I mean, it's a really cool venue. You know, set up a tent and had some tables and some dinner with some music and, you know, it's on the creek.

1:59:31 You've got historic cabins that you can poke in and out of. I mean, it's a pretty cool spot for some outdoor stuff. So I appreciate that being brought up. I was impressed. I hadn't spent much time out there prior to that. Okay. And then I suppose in terms of deliberation, when we get to it and finalizing the matrix, we'll determine whether that's its own category, if that fits under outdoor venue, how it kind of fits into the puzzle. Do we need to discuss at all the wayfinding that?

2:00:00 That Tom brought up as a board? Yeah, if anybody has comments or questions about that. I mentioned just a quick comment after Tom spoke that the mountain is kind of embracing. The mountain is, and this is just for context in terms of kind of partnership down the road, the mountain's at a little bit of a crossroads in terms of signage and wayfinding. We're, and Rich, you've probably spoken to Mark Brownlee about this in terms of our hiking trails and starting to make.

2:00:29 Pay a little bit more attention to those. We need portal signs. We need a really organized wayfinding system. And it looks like there might be a kind of an opportunity to bring these two together, the design language that Tom presented and our need up on the mountain, just to inform the discussion. Any other comments, questions? And I'll just present.

2:00:59 My history with it, I was on the Measure U committee at the time when that application was submitted from the town and there were five of us on the committee at the time and we did vote to not fund it at a time when funding is critical and also feeling that people tend to find directions with their phone and also feeling like $300,000

2:01:31 Further on down the line, $800,000 could be used to build a facility or part of a facility. So I think at that time we chose, we had roughly $300,000 left where we chose to save that for capital, future capital funding. But anyways, that's just to give you the history and the background of that. Is maybe our decision here just to include it in the matrix for?

2:01:58 For consideration, right? I would agree. We'll add it to the matrix. Has anything else that comes up to see, even from the public? Okay. I think, you know, every single project on here has merit and worth, including that. Absolutely. You know, I think it, you know, I agree with the statement to just include it, and it's all going to come down to dollars and cents eventually. And so I think, yeah, it's worthy of consideration, but ultimately what we determine will come down to we don't have enough money to fund all this stuff, so.

2:02:28 Well, which brings, I think, one of the points that we might want to deliberate on. One of the elements that isn't really in this matrix is the concept of partnerships and leverage. And so on a project like that, you know, would we need to put measures R&U on the hook for $800,000, or is there a matching scheme, or are there other entities that would come in and help fund something like that?

2:02:54 You know, is there a way that we can structure it so that some of it's sponsored? I think that's a critical piece in the filter in general. I think that's maybe one of the most important criterion that we consider throughout all these projects. I know it's in the actual detail filter, right, Rich? Correct. Just not on our summary.

2:03:18 Correct. Matrix that we're using. We're trying to drill down a little bit deeper. You look at the original filter to those three major elements, A, public benefit, B, planning and development, and C was operations to sustainability. Within that B, planning and development, you know, talked about partnerships, source of funds, present partners, funding allocation, potential future partners, so that was in the previous filter. We're trying to drill down a little bit deeper right now.

2:03:46 The conglomeration of putting all these documents together to help us really determine, you know, we're investors right now. What project do we believe is the best investment at this point in time? And what's that recommendation going to be to town council? I would agree with Dave. It's one of those top ones. It's shovel-ready is one, you know, in terms of managing the priorities of these projects. But, you know, leverage is there too. Okay. Any other comments about the

2:04:15 The primary tier projects that we've run through here from the board. Okay. So I think we're ready to move on to item four on our agenda now. This is the public hearing, the official public hearing portion of the meeting. I'm going to start out by reading from the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code.

2:04:42 A yearly requirement that we're fulfilling with this public hearing. And this is code 3.44210. Recommendation for expenditure of funds. The Tourism and Recreation Committee or such other commission or committee as is hereafter designated by the town council shall annually conduct at least one public hearing.

2:05:07 Where it takes public testimony as to how tax revenues collected under the Mammoth Lakes Mobility, Recreation, and Arts and Culture Utility Users Tax Ordinance should be expended. After accepting such public input, such commission or committee shall make written recommendations to the Town Council as to how such tax revenues should be expended. Prior to expending such tax revenues,

2:05:34 As have not been earlier committed, the town council shall consider the recommendations of such commission or committee report. And I think what we want to try and accomplish here is basically open up the floor for the public to come in. A, comment on what they've heard. Give their appraisals, affirmations for the projects, support. Tell us if we've missed something on our list.

2:06:02 Support other projects that you think are important to the town and are worthy of financing with taxpayer dollars. And just general comments on these top tier projects. So with that, I'd like to open up the microphone to members of the public. Rich, did we talk about a time goal?

2:06:30 For commentary? It depends on the number of speakers. Since we have a bevy of people running to the microphone right now, I don't think we're so constricted on time. So I would, in my recommendation, Mr. Chair, probably be three minutes at this point, or based on the public input, be flexible. Okay. Any takers? Stuart. Thank you, Chair. I think my only comment here is probably the timing of the public hearing. I know it's always traditionally being geared towards actually

2:07:00 The public reviewing or understanding what the recommendation of the expenditure of funds are. So that's probably why there's a little bit of cricket noise in the back there. So that's just our expectation of probably what we were probably understanding the meeting was going to be. Does that make sense? So I just don't know if it's a bit premature for the public or the funding recipients to really understand how they should engage in the process and maybe some guidance would be appreciative if that's helpful.

2:07:28 I think that's a great comment. I think the way I'm understanding the formation of this agenda, it was basically to arrange the kind of projects that this board was taking a look at that were kind of in play and then getting public comment on that. What I'm hearing from you, Stuart, is perhaps we need to extend the public hearing in such a way where once we have kind of more of a

2:07:56 A prioritized list. And once we're closer to that delivery to town council that we'd open up to the public again, is that what I'm hearing? Yeah, you could probably keep the public hearing open, right? I don't know if you really need to technically close it. But I think that's probably a good thought to probably make it a more valuable discussion for the board to weigh in on the thoughts.

2:08:20 Because they're not really responding to anything right now, right? Yeah, but I actually see this is what the process is designed to do, is to say, are we headed in the right direction? If someone believes from the ordinance that we shouldn't be putting money towards a pool or to a track or to a high altitude training center or a multi-use facility, this is the time to divert from that versus all of a sudden get to the end and say, here's what we're recommending, and then why would we spend money in that direction? I mean, I look at this as saying it's a very wide interpreted ordinance.

2:08:49 Where many people feel they are deserved some sort of portion of that funds that exist within those funds that are collected. And I look at my role as being, okay, are we doing the right job? Are we putting the monies into the areas? Because you get a lot of pressure in different ways from whether or not it's going to drive economic stability or whether or not it's going to meet community needs or those types of situations. But are we doing the right justice in meeting all the different things that the ordinance was intended to do? That's the way I look at it as a more general higher altitude portion and saying are we headed in the right direction at the end of the day?

2:09:18 We have a list before we decide what is our top-tier project based on public input. The way this framework is phrased that we're kind of working off of, I think this is an internal document, right, the framework document? Correct. Okay. I mean, the way we kind of laid it out before the meeting was to basically support, to have the public come up and help support our recommendation to town council. And the direction I got from?

2:09:48 Town staff was go through this process. We'll bring it back to town council as an information item, which then they would engage the community saying this is the recommendation. Based on that information input from the public at that point, council will give direction back to MLR board, go back and reshape, redirect, or bring back a final recommendation based on your first public hearing, what we've heard in the information item at town council meeting, and they make a final recommendation in December.

2:10:18 From my vantage point, I think both statements are right. I think, Stu, you're right. That's probably not the way it's gone traditionally, but I would tend to agree with Brent that, you know, some of the feedback we hear sometimes is that public feedback is often considered to be too late in the game. So I think we should welcome this as another opportunity to just earlier on in the stage, you know, get some direction from people and make sure the board is heading in the right direction.

2:10:48 Exactly. There was the advertisement in the newspaper. If you're a taxpayer, how would you like to see your tax dollars spent? And I'd also, just for the record, mention that we had a workshop with Town Council earlier on in this process that was public and actually in this room televised where we kind of

2:11:11 Built out and described the process that we're following right now and took town council feedback and opened up to the public for feedback there too. So we've kind of had one early on in the formation of our process, one here where we're kind of getting serious and deliberating about which projects are really in front of us. And, you know, I guess it's an open question, is there another to follow once we get a little bit, once we actually prioritize this matrix.

2:11:39 I think that's helpful. That was my question. Okay. I'm just glad that we've actually got some dialogue and hopefully we can keep moving on. But I just probably encourage, you know, a lot more public hearings because it was a very active public process before and I encourage you to keep doing the same. Excellent. Thank you, Stuart. Hello, MLR Board, Juliana Olenka, member of the community. I'm also working at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I also represent the Eastern Sierra Symphony, New in the Ring,

2:12:10 Renamed from the Sierra Summer Festival. And I just actually want to second a bit of what Stu said. I think this is really great that you're having an open meeting and you're asking for input. The problem is we don't have really any idea. I mean, I know about a couple of the projects, but I don't know about all the projects. And so it's really hard to comment about how you should spend your money when we don't know what the budget...

2:12:36 What the potential is, what the financing is on some of the projects. So you're going to have a discussion after this and then make a recommendation. So it would be nice if the public were part of that process. I have to applaud the town on the Plan Your Parks process. I was involved in all of those meetings. Colin, you were in all of those as well. So it's Betsy and a few other people who are here.

2:12:56 And the input that we got from the community was very broad. And there was consensus reached at those meetings. And some of those issues that were brought up at the Plannier Parks have been addressed here. And some of them have been totally ignored here. And I think the process that went through with Plannier Parks was very, very, very public. And people did embrace and have input into it. And I think the more information people have, the better capable they are of responding.

2:13:22 Thank you. I think that's a really sound comment, and I think it gets back to what David was saying about making available kind of the material of our due diligence, because Plan Your Parks is kind of at the center of this matrix. It is in the deeper filters that we've built for each one, and it's recognized, and our staff, MLR staff, has pulled from Plan Your Parks virtually for every single one of these that was relevant projects. So I think it's...

2:13:50 Excellent comment. I think it's on our roadmap to have digital access to all of the planning documents that we're working through, and there are a lot, but to your point, it is difficult for the public to just show up at a meeting without all that background material and without that ability to deep dive into what we've been kind of swimming in for the last year and make good commentary. Thank you.

2:14:20 Hi, Betsy Turex, and I chair the Recreation Commission, but we haven't had a specific discussion on this, although we have been following your process of, you know.

2:14:30 Delineating the top tier projects and project readiness. And I'm just wondering because it sounds like you're looking for feedback because this will inform your future funding recommendations and how those are structured to town council. One thing that when the commission made the Measure R recommendations, one of the priorities that we had in the past that I don't see on here but we've talked about in other meetings like the task force meeting is completing incomplete projects. For example, Trails End Park.

2:14:59 You know, the Whitmore Track, there's sort of a preliminary phase two design, and so I'm just kind of wondering where that, how that falls into this matrix. Anyone else want to? I guess just to kind of just bring that to your attention. I mean, just, you know, kind of speaking from the conversations that we've had and that you've been a part of at the MLR boards where we've kind of walked through a lot of this, it's one of our guiding principles, leverage, complementary facilities, shovel readiness.

2:15:28 And shovel readiness is, I think, on this framework that I'm kind of working off of right now. I think in large measure, this process is trying to vet where we are from project to project, which reports are complete, how deeply have we gone into environmental studies, is the funding there or not, how close are we to business plans and to design.

2:15:52 You know, to design phases. And these are all great projects, and it's great to see a lot of these projects coming forward because so many of them are in existing town plans, and now, you know, it's exciting to start moving toward the implementation. I just wondered how, you know, moving forward, doing, you know, the smaller things like completing a project like Trails End Park, how that will, you know, just want to kind of keep that on your radar as certainly the town may want to bring things like that forward. So, thank you. Thank you, Betsy. Hi, I'm Anita Westfall.

2:16:29 Community member. And I have to apologize. I missed the meeting. Had to work. But wanted to come and support something for a pool in town. I have two boys, 10 and 12, serious swimmers. One of them has got a goal of going to the Far West meet, and he's a second and a half away. And with our Whitmore facility and the Snow Creek pool,

2:16:59 It doesn't give an option for a serious swimmer to maintain their training year-round. We have other, you know, the track, we have all kinds of high-altitude training up here. Samantha, she's our swim team coach. This summer was our first year that we had a team from down south do high-altitude training up here, and there's even more teams that would be willing to come up. It's just our facility is not what they're looking for.

2:17:30 So I wanted to just come give two cents for some sort of swim facility year-round covered pool in a standard length for teams to really be able to train year-round. Thank you. Hi, I'm Coach Sam. I'm the new coach. I'm really nervous about speaking on this.

2:17:58 I just wonder if we're going to, I don't know if you guys have talked about a pool or if there's plans and work for a pool, but like Anita said, we had a team come up and visit us this past summer, and they were happy. They thought that it was the most beautiful place they'd ever seen, and the coach was going to bring them back up, and she'd like to recommend us to other teams so that they could come up and visit, but we just don't really have anywhere to put them down at the Whitmore pool.

2:18:27 pool here in town that had like a housing structure and then our kids could train year round. I mean ever since Snow Creek let us train there year round our kids have gone from this to just leaps and bounds and I think there's even more there if we had a top of the line facility and maybe a place to house teams that come up just like when the track teams come up. I think we could do the same and I don't know.

2:18:54 My vote's for the poll. I get really emotional when I talk about it because I just worry that something will happen down at that Whitmore poll and then the kids won't be able to swim. Thank you. Sam, can I ask you a question while you're up there? I'm sorry to... But you and I talked at some point this summer about, I mean, look, we were in Tahoe and looking at those invitational meets and you kind of laid out for me a little bit about the...

2:19:21 The way that works financially and how much money South Lake Tahoe makes at that event, for example. Can you just talk a little bit, just vaguely about, because as we get into planning these things, you know, how these things pay for themselves is pretty key, so. Oh, absolutely. I understand that there's a lot of overhead with the pool, you know, the chlorine and the maintenance and the water alone, but when we go to like those big meets like in Tahoe or even when we go down to the Junior Olympics down in the Bay, they have over 500 kids come.

2:19:51 Tahoe had at least 500 kids there this past summer. They had more kids than they could deal with. And you figure each one of those kids is paying at least $75 to be there, maybe even more. If the kids are swimming in more events, then they pay more than that. And then also you think that their parents put money into the town because they have to stay somewhere, and then they also have to eat.

2:20:17 And so I can imagine it would bring a lot of money and business, just general business into the town. And I think if we had a top of the line, maybe even middle of the line, if I could be modest facility, I believe that they would come up here and we'd be able to hold a meet the same way and maybe generate quite a bit of money out of it. I mean, we go to Minden at least once a year and they do the same thing. They have about 500 kids show up and they charge even more.

2:20:47 That money comes all back to the pool and back to the town. So I think it would help us all out, I think, if we had a pool. One thing, Will, we've got you up here, because I can barely swim. Pretty much a doggy paddler. But one of, I know you guys snuck in a little bit late. We did have a pretty lengthy discussion.

2:21:13 You know, in Ralph's presentation about an aquatic center and whether that might fit over at the existing Snow Creek. So it's definitely on the matrix as far as what we're looking at. And we recognize that, you know, Whitmore is a facility that doesn't have an endless life. One of the things that we were trying to discuss, a bunch of us that maybe don't have the level of knowledge that you do, we talked about

2:21:39 25 meter, 50 meter, that type of thing. Is our assumption correct that in order to have those type of events and in order to have people come here for swim meets that 50 meters is really the key? Absolutely. The 50 meter is a big deal because, you know, like an Olympic athlete, if they were to come up to Mammoth to train because of the high altitude, ideally they wouldn't want to train in anything less. They would want a 50 meter indoor pool.

2:22:09 Usually those 50-meter pulls, too, that you can slide them over. I mean, if it's a good setup, you can slide them over into a 25-yard this way so you can maximize, like, group swim or something like that. But if you wanted to have, like, those big teams come that are willing to house their athletes and pay, I think a 50-meter would be definitely where you'd want to go with that. Okay. Thanks for clarifying that.

2:22:37 Hello. My name is Trinity McKee, and I am a student at Mammoth High School, as well as a swimmer on Mammoth Lakes Swim Team. And I want to give you a point of view from the youth, because I'm obviously the youngest one here. A pool is extremely needed, and I don't drive personally. I don't have a license.

2:23:06 And my sister is a business owner, and she's as well my guardian. And during the weekdays, it is extremely hard for me to get 20 minutes. Sorry. To get 20 minutes out of town to be able to swim and do something that I really love. And I really want a pool that is able to have competitions at because it's an extremely expensive sport. And it's really fun. It's really good for the youth.

2:23:37 And I see that

2:24:10 There's kids. These little kids want a future in swim. These little kids that are terrified to go in the water, I see them develop and want to become really good swimmers because they see the Westfall boys and even sons. They see them swimming and they're doing so good and they go so fast. And the little kids look at us and they're like, I want to be like that. I want to do that. I remember when I was little, I...

2:24:40 Would watch the Summer Olympics and just be amazed with how fast people can go. And without a proper training facility, the kids aren't going to get anywhere. They'll get very far, but they're not going to be able to change swim history like Michael Phelps or anything like that. It's going to be extremely hard for them because we don't have a proper training facility so far away. And I sit on a bus.

2:25:10 At 8 o'clock in the morning, barely making it to swim on time. With some other kids that are, that their parents asked me to watch them on the bus because they have to go to work. And it's very important that something's in town and easy to reach for the kids and for the future members of our society. Thank you. Thank you. Sure. Absolutely. The swim facility up in Minden.

2:25:41 It's indoor. It's got an indoor pool and an outdoor pool. That facility, I've been to it different times of the year. It always has people in that facility. It's having a facility like that here in town during the winter, stormy days, the visitors would all of a sudden have another option of something to do rather than now the bowling alley and the movie theater.

2:26:10 There's a little bit of lack of things to do indoors during the winter for visitors. And a swim facility would be, you know, in charge admission. You know, you'd get a fair price from these people down south for a day of swimming indoors with, you know, a jacuzzi. And, you know, Minden has a little water slide and then other little things that dump water on kids' heads, you know, on the play pools. But it's something that would be used by more than just a swim team.

2:26:41 It's something for the town, the community, and the visitors that come to enjoy this town. Thank you. Any other commentary? I think so. My name is Sharon Clark, Sharon Raven Clark. You read a code, and I hope this isn't the only public hearing. Now, you said we had to have one.

2:27:16 Well, it's all public every time we get together. I'm sorry. Every time we get together, it's publicly noticed three days in advance. All of our board meetings are public. As you go forward making these decisions and looking at the matrix, will people have opportunity for input? Absolutely. Okay. Well, you said one, the code.

2:27:40 Right. We were talking about a specific meeting organized around the matrix. We have a board meeting on November 3rd. Every one of our board meetings is public, and we post the agenda three days beforehand. So the public can come in and make comments at numerous different opportunities. Right, but when you get the information, as Juliana said, that enables us to know what is really happening, we will have input at that time.

2:28:09 And also when we bring it before town council. Right. But by the time you get to town council, oftentimes it's kind of all fait accompli. And that's what I really liked about planning your parks. The community had real input. And that's critical at this point with what you're doing. And I appreciate what you're doing. So I just, I think what we just heard from the swimmers is the kind of thing.

2:28:39 That I want to hear more about for each of these items on the matrix. So that was my concern. What sort of timeline do you have as we go forward? Rich, you want to speak to our timeline? This deliverable is due by December of 2015 to town council. Your decision is ready by? Our recommendation is deliverable.

2:29:09 Based on the deliverables the Town Council has given us is due by December of 2015, which is two months away. So we're engaging people in this process to give us feedback about project specific. Now the purpose of this public hearing was these are the things we're thinking about at this point in time. Give us some input. Are we moving in the right direction? Are we missing something? Do we support this? What further information do we need? We will then deliberate.

2:29:36 We'll go back on November 3rd at our next board meeting. We'll begin to bring information items to town council. There'll be more public input. We'll take it back as a board and make a final recommendation. We'll probably have three or four more conversations before we make that final draft recommendation to town council. So at your next board meeting, you're going to have some real data available to the public? I mean, what we heard tonight was off and on real.

2:30:05 So I want something in front of me that shows me really information. That's essentially what this matrix, what we're trying to build. Right. But we're not there yet. No, that's right. The purpose of this meeting was to start filling this out. Right. And we did that with the MUF. But that was, and perhaps a couple of them. But we don't really have that for all of them. Well, we have. Well, and again, isn't the, I mean, maybe.

2:30:34 It would be good to describe what you mean by deliverable, what deliverable is, because we're not talking about, in December, recommending six go projects. We're talking about a long-term strategy with some priorities. Okay. So we're not talking about, okay, we're going to fund all these things starting in December. Am I right? Correct. And we know there are limited funds. We've got to identify some top-tier projects, things that we believe to be.

2:31:03 Shovel ready at this point in time to move forward. We've got to look at long-term funding. How do we support some of these projects? How do we maximize R&U? What will leverage funding look like? Grants, corporate sponsorships. And I would recommend as these board packets come out, the initial filters, the one-page executive summaries, that stuff has been in process for about two months right now. So those documents aren't crafted this evening for the first time.

2:31:33 One-page executive summaries based on all these projects. There's been the filter that goes through those three priority elements we spoke about. Those have been out. The readiness project that was included in this conversation was published, and this filter we began to work through tonight. We'll clean this up. We'll get that in the board packet, which will be published on Thursday afternoon. What we'll make sure we do, Ms. Leslie, is all the filters and the executive summaries.

2:31:58 And the readiness matrix we already published along with this, we'll make sure all that gets into the next packet again. So this way, if we haven't seen some of that stuff in the past, you can see the sequence and order of things we've done so far as we build up. But on December 1, you'll be ready to make your recommendation, or December, make a recommendation for the one you want to move forward with at this point in time? Not one. No, we'll just go through an entire roster. These are the top tier projects. This is what we believe they are.

2:32:27 The council then will say, okay, get some more information. We agree. We disagree. There will be more public input. We'll begin to finalize some of those projects. And we can find this information online or not? Correct. Okay. Okay.

2:32:41 Correct. I guess that's kind of where I'm coming from. Sharon, we will make sure you get this information and the rest of the world. And the rest of the world. Absolutely. She already did. She gave me everything I needed. Thank you so much. But, Sharon, I appreciate your comment because this is – it's over here. Because this is something that, you know, we've been working really hard kind of behind the scenes trying to build a website, and it's something that I think that we're –

2:33:07 Desperate for as a community is a place where we can all go and look at all the information that's been back 20 years, planning documents, kind of the heritage of every project, how it got to where it is, so that we can very quickly reference these things and you can spend a couple days referencing it and reading about it and really getting up to speed without having to, because our website right now and the town's website,

2:33:37 All the various websites are not really very functional. If you're trying to find the Plan Your Parks documents, it takes some digging. So I think one of our main goals, one of my main goals, is to try and get all of this stuff in a way that we can all begin to talk about things on the same page. Great. Great. That's all I want is to be sure the community has an opportunity. Absolutely. And thank you.

2:34:05 Sharon, just for the rest of the community that is in here or watching us on TV tonight, you can call MLR or email Leslie Ann and get on our interested mailing list. And that way you'll get an email that gives you the agendas of all of our meetings, and you're welcome to join us any time. We welcome your public input. We need it. And, you know, thank you for being part of the process. Any other public commentary? It's the time, right? Absolutely. Okay, good. Thanks.

2:34:40 I just want to follow up on the Chair's comment regarding the incomplete projects. So I'm just looking for any direction that you could provide as a board to Executive Director that we can work together, get you what information you need for those incomplete projects, being Trails End Park and Whitmore Recreation Area. I mean, they're very shovel-ready. We've vetted the Trails End Park project several times with the Commission. I mean, there's a budget, there's items. I mean, we're there. Whitmore Recreation Area, as you know, and the track is not far behind it as well.

2:35:09 Just want to see what you need from the town, what direction to get this kind of on a consideration for these planning cycles, that's all. I don't know that we have outstanding needs with regard to those projects. We could include that in the next phase of this. From what our recollects do, in the task force we talked about completing Trails End Park, which is $145,000.

2:35:36 But I believe you have a long roster of projects in your office. Why don't you kind of paint a picture to this board about the types of projects and what those total costs are so we get a better flavor of what's out there? Yeah, so just really quickly, the CIP major maintenance project list that the commission has worked on, we started this about a year ago. They're about to start it again. It's a $3.5 million list of really deferred maintenance items.

2:36:05 You know, for our parks and facilities. So we're a little bit under the gun to try and complete those. But the priority, and I think as the chair was kind of reiterating before, is that something that's very cognizant of the commission and a decision-making body in regards to these funds, if they're very limited, is to, before we start cherry-picking everything else out there, is to really finish the work that we've started. You know, really...

2:36:28 Take heed of finishing incomplete projects that the community has before we start moving on because they mightn't be as glossy and, you know, fun to take on, but really we've got to do the due diligence of the town and finish these projects for the community's benefit. So, I mean, that's really what I want to kind of emphasise today, what we need, what you need from the town, what direction you can give your Executive Director to kind of get you the information you need to kind of put this in.

2:36:53 Put these against these other projects that you're kind of bringing forward because these, if you look at a lot of your filters, they're ready to go too. I mean, they're ready to be done. They just get one funding check and they're done. I mean, that's great. And if you're looking at Trails End Park, we're almost pretty much renegotiated the contract with Volcom, right? So for the skate park, we're looking at a 10-year deal, naming rights, its maintenance. I gave the information to Rich. It's not in any kind of format yet, but that's moving forward. That's $100,000 plus.

2:37:24 You know, leverage to that park. I mean, I think there's really opportunity here to kind of look at those and see how we can kind of, you know, finish those before we move on. So that'll be my last comment. Thank you, Stuart. Thank you. Just to respond a little bit, I think the task force that looked at the multi-use facility, to my mind, was kind of a test case for really vetting a single project in depth, right? We had some of the same.

2:37:54 Outreach issues that we've been talking about up here with that, or we would have been benefited with a website where the public would have been more informed coming into that town council meeting, clearly. But in that task force, Trails End Park came up, and it competed with kind of our assessment of the multi-use facility and the community center. So as a test case, I think it kind of naturally rose to the top.

2:38:22 Don't want to speak for everyone on this board, but I think it's one of the, again, one of the top criteria that we're considering when we do do this prioritization work over the next couple months. I just didn't see it on the list. Well, because this isn't the whole strategy. This is just the top tier new capital projects list. This isn't everything. Am I right? I mean, so do we have a section in our major strategy document that has to do with?

2:38:52 Projects that are ready to complete? One of our guiding principles is to complete projects. I think I'd like to hear a clarification of deferred maintenance because I believe that deferred maintenance, I'm not quite sure if that really is an R&U responsibility based on a project that's been built by the town in the past. The direction we were given is to bring leverage capital facilities based on vetting all the

2:39:18 Consultant reports, plan your parks as a driving force, which is a year young, about what to bring forward. So I think we need to probably clarify deferred maintenance generally whose responsibility that is. Well, I think to David's point, though, this is not the full scope of what R&U funds. I mean, we don't have...

2:39:40 You know, events programming in this. We don't have arts and cultural programming in this. We don't have completion of existing projects. You know, R&U is relatively narrow in the sense of deferred maintenance. But this is not the full scope. This is just one piece of that. But I think, you know, Stu and others, we just want to make sure that that gets included in the full scope of what R&U funds.

2:40:07 Because that is a little bit outside of this. This is top tier for new capital infrastructure. And maybe top tier is a little misleading. I mean, maybe we're just talking about large capital projects and how we go about thinking about those projects. And how we prioritize them. Yeah, I mean, that clarification helps. That's good. I appreciate it. Thanks. I wanted to make sure you've got a really tight timeline. So I just want to make sure that whatever you need, we can get you what you need to help your decision. Sounds good. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thanks, Stu. Anyone else?

2:40:38 I already took plenty of time, but just a couple quick comments. The indoor pool that Sam was referring to is a 19-yard indoor pool and three lanes, and Mammoth swimmers have made tremendous inroads in using that over the last year, and that's potentially part of what could be leveraged. That 19-yard indoor pool could be the

2:41:09 A kiddie training pool or something like that if the additional facility is built. Just a couple other small comments. As you're identifying funds and projects to go forward, one suggestion might be identifying and hiring architectural firms for a consultation project that would maybe gauge the suitability of some of the sites.

2:41:38 that we've talked about, Mammoth Creek Park West, Snow Creek Athletic Club, et cetera, and give you some estimates on cost and perhaps work on some design elements and do some of that preliminary design work. That may be a good thing to fund this year, so I'm just putting in a pitch for potentially funding the next level of design work as part of this overall project.

2:42:06 It might even include hiring someone or bringing a USOC official out to consult with us about what else is needed for us to become a real viable Olympic training center. And hopefully there's not necessarily the need to spend all of the money each year and that you can have some reserves for future planning and that kind of thing. So just a couple extra thoughts. Thank you.

2:42:37 I think that's a good comment for us, and it kind of speaks to what the next step of this board is after we kind of prioritize these projects or make our recommendation to town council, and that is, you know, it's not like, well, if you're number one, you've won the blue ribbon, and we're just going to spend money until that's done and move on to the next. All of these projects are in different stages, and so how do you start looking at, you know, funding?

2:43:03 different projects at various stages and really using Measure R and Measure U dollars efficiently across, you know, a number of our needs, not just kind of one project at a time. Rich, do you have any contacts at USOCN? I know you've got contacts everywhere. It was the training site director I was speaking to a couple years ago. Mark Brownlee has engaged her in conversations.

2:43:32 I believe she's online to come visit us in the next couple of months. Okay. Once they do come to visit, Mark's going to pull me in and continue those conversations and talk about what the next steps could be as we expand this process. Yeah, I think that's a very helpful suggestion is, you know, what are the needs? Where are we deficient? So that would be helpful as, you know, that is one of the goals of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So that would be helpful to get some guiding direction on that.

2:44:00 If there's no more public comment, I have one to read that was submitted to us via email. This comes from the Felicia Piano Trio. Dear Rich, we hope to have a representative at the meeting tonight. Rebecca and I are tied up with evening classes. We did want to forward our brief comments on priorities for Measure R&U funding. This is from Brian. Chamber Music Unbound favors the continued support of arts and culture.

2:44:29 through Measure U funding. CMU supports the efforts to build and maintain an arts and cultural center with flexible space and acoustics to maximize use. For arts and culture events and programming, we suggest that there be block grant awards with application eligibility determined by established U filters, including percentage of budget that is leveraged. An example of a block grant award could be

2:44:58 $5,000 grants for events and programs with budgets of $25,000 to $50,000, $7,500 grants with budgets of $50,000 to $100,000, or $10,000 grants for projects with budgets of $100,000 plus. And that's the end of the public comment. Any reaction to that from the board? Sounds like a great idea. Okay.

2:45:30 And I'm going to go ahead and close the public hearing portion of this meeting. On our agenda, there's a line item that suggests whether we deliberate or not further this evening. I think before the meeting, it was decided that we would kind of take the learnings from this meeting and prepare for our next board meeting.

2:45:54 Is that correct, Rich? It would be interesting. I think it would be good for the board to kind of begin to vet some of their thoughts on some of these projects. It would allow me, as I prepare the agenda for next week, of, you know, what my next steps are. You know, I'm hearing a few things, you know, update the matrix that we started working on today, you know, as one first next step.

2:46:16 But I'd be interested in hearing some of your feedback in terms of what you expect from us. This agenda's got to get published on Thursday, so we've got a quick turnaround on this. Is the expectation that, I mean, mine's covered with notes, that this is fleshed out for our meeting, kind of project to project, point to point? What I'm thinking is based on the notes that we heard in the minutes we recorded, we would flesh out this template and we use this as a base.

2:46:45 Allocate time on next Tuesday, then to work through each one of these and add more notes from staff people, from board members about what we heard, priorities, and that would begin to shape the conversation. What about a framework for that meeting? I mean, I think the framework we set here was helpful for us to kind of get through this material. Okay. I would maybe suggest that we think about a framework for our conversation on the 3rd. You guys sound right?

2:47:14 Yeah. Okay. And let's be mindful of the comments we heard tonight about public hearing. And let's really give some thought between now and Thursday or now our next board meeting if we feel like we've done an adequate job of reaching out and if we need to add something to our schedule. Is the meeting room a third intended to be at the MLT office or here? MLT office. Should we change that? We could.

2:47:45 Just limited space there. What's the pleasure of the board? It seems like that is more kind of the meat on the bones that people seem to want to be more engaged with than tonight. I think it's good to get preliminary comments, but it seems like there may be some public interested in being involved in the discussion on the third. But that's up to everyone else. Sounds good to me. Let me work with Jamie.

2:48:15 If there's not a conflict, we'll schedule it in. Okay. I mean, I guess my concern, and I keep sort of circling back to the same thing, but, you know, we've spent a lot of time on these projects, and, you know, some of us more than others because we're on different committees. But, you know, this is tonight's probably the fourth time that I've heard Evan's proposal.

2:48:38 Which is awesome, and I'm psyched for it, and everybody needs to hear it, but I'm wondering how we get to a place where everybody can get that once, or see that on paper, or have it in a binder, or eventually a website. But in the short term, between now and November, and these are useful, these one pages, but they seem so vague to me that it doesn't really help anyone really get into the meat of any of it.

2:49:03 I mean, we really don't have business plans before us. We really don't have any numbers in front of us. I know that those live somewhere, but I'm kind of dying to get into a process where we have that information consolidated in such a way that not only the public but also the board can actually reference it, you know, so that we can go one project at a time and everyone's looked at the information and then we can actually talk about it. And I know that information's all out there.

2:49:32 How do we get it consolidated? Rich? I would reach out to each one of the user groups that spoke tonight and ask them, give us more information. I mean, I'm not quite sure how deep they've gone into building some of these things right now because the project really isn't moving forward. I mean, I would ask Ralph, you know, how much more information could you give us at this point in time in terms of, you know, a business plan, performa? You know, have you even crafted those numbers just yet?

2:50:03 Put you on the spot. Well, I don't, and I don't necessarily mean, I mean, the difference between Evan's project and this idea of an aquatic center is radical. I mean, Evan's put decades into this thing already. And so he's already got all kinds of material and he's got schematic drawings. And to be able to, you know, whether we need to help him or he needs to bring it to us or how do we somehow get to a place where we have a nice, tight...

2:50:27 20-page package that can be distributed at a meeting that everybody can see and say, okay, here's this project. And then you can see the difference because here it looks like Evan's project is exactly the same as Ralph's project because it's just a conceptual idea. But a lot of work has been put into some of these things whereas other things are still highly conceptual.

2:50:50 As it builds the process into this, because some of these things are going to build, we're going to say, okay, these are things that we see as the most recommended, the most five projects. But as we add into these, I'm hoping that we have electronically, as we're talking about, and have a nice book and everything's got the prints, because it's just like we talk about the signs and ways. I was very involved in that whole process. I wonder where the original documentation was and the people that came out and did the study. It's probably on a shelf somewhere. It's probably accessible to many people, but I don't know how to find it.

2:51:21 For me, I think we need some compendium, some way of amassing these kind of comprehensive documents that we all have had kind of various access to. The question for me is, I mean, we haven't, in our budget, we haven't allotted, you know, some kind of printing line item where we could actually do a publication that we could circulate throughout the town. I think we're left with

2:51:49 Doing it online. And I think, to be honest, I think that's our closest avenue to delivery is the website. I mean, we already have a lot of that content on there. It's just, I mean, to be frank, it's you and me, man. It's like it's one of us getting in there and finishing the last push on that site so that we can get that stuff out. And, you know, I'm game for it. I'm just like everybody up here.

2:52:15 I'm struggling to find a little bit of oxygen. Yeah, no, I mean, and I think that's an important piece of the conversation because I don't have bandwidth for that. I can't do that. I can't build a website for this. But I think that's where we've got to move beyond because I look at it as you guys put so much energy into that, but do you really have the time to make those things happen? Here we are worried about spending $500 or $1,000 when it would be best served to get the information out to people and have somebody help you with it.

2:52:41 That's not me. I think it's such an important component, and it's an articulated, it's a very high part of the deliverables that we have for December, and I think we're a long ways off on that. I think so, too. And I think we've understood from the beginning of this process that that deliverable in December, it's not just about giving town council something to look at. It's about...

2:53:09 It's about getting the stakeholders involved. It's about bringing the community involved. It's about that outreach. And I think that's, you know, we've done a lot of really good work as a board here. But I think we're starting to get bitten by that lack in a number of areas. And I think the answer is we have to marshal forces and finish the website. And look, for better or for worse, it's on my shoulders a little bit right now.

2:53:36 Let's maybe set a goal to buy... But let's look at resolution. How can we help? Is there somebody that we can... I mean, it's not an agenda, so I can't make a motion, but how do we get that move forward? We're all on the same board. We've all got time, but how do you have somebody that can actually help you put that into place? I think we're... To be honest, I think we're close. I think it's really a matter of a day's focused work on my part with Brown, sitting down and just nail it, knocking it out. And, you know, I really wanted to try and have...

2:54:06 Have that bit of work done this weekend and just wasn't able to materialize. I'm thinking that by November 3rd might be a decent goal, you know, to maybe even show the website at our board meeting, especially if it's in here and especially if we make kind of a deal about this meeting and really invite the public. It would be great to be able to show them something.

2:54:34 Maybe we take a day to talk about that and see if we can really commit to that, but I almost think we have to put a hard timeline on ourselves. If we really want to kind of come out the other end with that public outreach component that we really want to achieve. And theoretically, it gets off your plate, right? You're just getting that architecture in place in such a way that they can start filling it in.

2:55:02 Because that's, you know, it's work that they're doing anyway, but we're doing it all on paper on a bunch of different, you know, it's so hard to get our heads around it. So you're giving them the form to start putting stuff in. That's right. I'm taking some of the raw material is up. It's just not ready to publish in any meaningful way right now. And it's, again, I think it's maybe a day's hard work, maybe two days' hard work between Brahm and I to get it done. And it's just...

2:55:31 Between now and November 3rd, can we commit to that? And I've got to take a hard look as well. But that would be, I think that would be ideal, right? I mean, I think it's the right time in the process, too. I think so, too. And, I mean, we've already, because we've mapped out a lot of those things that need to be on there, so we kind of have the ingredients for that. Yeah, I think so.

2:55:53 And I think, you know, rather than, I'm just, I'm bringing this up mostly because I don't want to have an, I think we shouldn't have another discussion in the abstract like this. I think we should begin to, you know, say this is everything we know about this project so that everybody's on the same page and then move to the next one rather than keep, we kind of keep circling around things. I think that's right. I mean, I think we're, yeah, I think we're, I think we're building a competent product but around the margins a little bit.

2:56:24 More than we'd like to. To answer Rich's question and maybe to add something for discussion, you're talking about starting to estimate costs, and we've done a little bit of that. We've done some preliminary design work. To Drea's comment, we had, do we do a 25-meter estimate? Do we do a 50-meter estimate? Do we put a diving end of the pool with two, one-meter?

2:56:54 Boards and a three-meter platform. What does the town really need? I think if you say this is a project worth investigating some more, then you find an architectural firm that has experience designing aquatic centers and that kind of thing. And you maybe do the plan your parks type of process and you say it's worth spending money on investigating this further and

2:57:24 Deciding what we can afford to build because we could do something big and put together an elaborate proposal, but it may not be within the town budget given all the other constraints. So we're ready and willing to do what we can do to help in the process. We just need a little bit more direction on what you'd like to see as the end product. And thank you. And if I remember correctly from the Plan Your Parks, what came out, you know, it was all very hypothetical. What is your dream?

2:57:55 There's, you know, money, there's no limit on money. It was a 25-meter, I mean, sorry, a 25-yard by 50-meter swimming pool with either a diving well as part of it, so the pool either being deep enough or a separate diving well. And I don't know if those documents, I mean, they would all be in the Plan Your Parks document. Oh, I have a hard copy of it. Yeah.

2:58:26 So my suggestion might be if this looks like a worthy project to pursue, that maybe there's some portion of funding that would help us hire the architectural firms that would allow us to kind of estimate where we can go with it and then go from there. I think we can help with one thing tonight. It's got to be 50.

2:58:48 I think we sussed that out. I don't think we've seen any due diligence. I mean, we all may have that opinion, but I want to see the studies. Terry's got the studies. Okay. I've seen those. I'm being the thorn tonight. Thank you. Thanks, Rob. Okay. Any other commentary from the board? Are we down the road enough to understand what we're doing on November 3rd?

2:59:19 We're going to have a framework kind of developed in the coming days. We have to publish by Thursday, right? The biggest concern I hear, and we continue to talk about it, is our ability to communicate where we are in the process. That's number one. So we've got to tackle that. Number two.

2:59:37 You know, we need to do a better job at really developing comprehensive documents. You know, what does that look like? How do we put them in a place for people to find so they can engage in the conversation? You know, so how do you dig in a little bit deeper with those executive summaries and those filters right now based on some of the work we've done? And as you know, the well-pointed comments, you know, some of these as we differentiate the progress of some of these projects, you know, obviously some are much further along than others. You know, and if we find ourselves in a position where the town council says, yeah, we agree, this is the top ten bundle.

3:00:06 And we're going to allocate an X factor to go explore those bundles and see what it's going to cost. Which then gives us at least the first phase to say, this is where we're going, give us some directions. We've met that deliverable at that point in time as a phase one. And then we allocate funding to say, okay, now let's explore, let's dig down a little bit deeper so we can really have those comprehensive documents. Because we at this point in time don't have those, don't have the capacity, and we really need to figure out it.

3:00:30 It is the Plan the Park document, the piece we're going to use to drill down into. It's a base document, as many are documents at this point in time. And then we'll build a frame to kind of engage ourselves in that conversation for next Tuesday. Well, and I think, you know, regarding Plan Your Park specifically, I think it's important to note, like, there were some great things about that process. There was very broad community input.

3:00:52 You know, a number of stakeholder meetings, et cetera, et cetera. But really, kind of what came out of that process is these are the town-owned parcels, these are the areas we might like to see infrastructure. That plan your parks process did not take that next step to go in and put a business plan together for an aquatic center. I mean, not even close. And so, you know, we're still at that phase where we said, hey, you know, do we want an aquatic center? Yes.

3:01:22 Near the level of detail that we're talking about here to get to drill down to what it looks like conceptually, where it's placed, how much it costs, all those type of things. It's a good base document, as you said. So, you know, I think we can learn some things from that process. Some things about that were very well done, but we've got to take another step with these things if we want a tight business plan.

3:01:46 Yeah, it was an excellent example of community input. It was well advertised, there were postcards, there were posters, and it was well attended. Yeah, and people felt very well engaged in that process, which was a really cool thing to see. But you're right, it didn't have money and it didn't have business plans or any of that involved. There was nothing to execute. No, it was like, what's your dream? Yep. And that was pretty fun. I think that's why it's one of the principal documents, though, that we've been returning to.

3:02:14 Kind of in every evaluation of these projects. I mean, it was one of the primary sources that consumed the multi-use facility task force. It was kind of the first building block. It was the source of our charrette that we did when we were tasked with understanding Mammoth Park West as kind of maybe the first site for it.

3:02:39 This next phase of development. But I think in terms of the deliverable to council, you know, putting together just a top-tier framework of potential capital projects is a different step than saying how are we going to actually go fund and build these things. That's right. And I think that came out of our workshop with town council, that the prioritization is the first piece. And then it's really looking at R&U and saying, okay, how do we wisely manage this and figure out how to move projects.

3:03:09 Along a development arc that makes sense. And then how do we start to add core competencies, right? From fundraising and leveraging to, Ralph, your point, it's like we need to talk to people who know how to build Olympic pools, not just kind of scratch our heads together and try and figure it out ourselves. We need to start, and David, you've been a champion of this too, is really going out and looking at comps and bringing in some skill sets that we don't.

3:03:38 Natively have here. But I think that's kind of phase two. But just to sort of add into that is because I see our challenges after all these discussions we're still coming back to the same four or five conversation of new projects that have been out there for a long time. How do we move that forward into something real?

3:03:56 That's what I really see us in, whether it's leveraging funding, make a streamlined process, get behind politically, physically, whatever, how to make something actually happen to those projects. Because my concern is in five years from now we're still talking about the fact that we've got to do another study to evaluate whether or not it's a 25-meter pool or it's a 50-meter pool. That's the great fear in the town, for sure. A lot of hot air. There's some substance there, right? Just to go back on our agenda for just a second, I just want to make sure when we do our...

3:04:25 recommendations because as I'm reading there we should incorporate that we held the public hearing and anything common for that public hearing we should be incorporating into our report to town council because I know we're going to make recommendations on top tier and where they're going but to me that reads we should be making you know we're sending the monies in the right area kind of more global assessment when we look at how we're spending our dollars. I think Leslie captured most everything that was said. She captured all the public commentary and

3:04:54 I mean, maybe we have a separate kind of category, line item, something for the inputs that we receive for the rest of the project. I don't know. Just an idea. Or maybe it's incorporated more broadly. Maybe people are saying things that are already captured. I don't know. No, I think that's a good idea. Pardon me. I think that's a good idea to somehow include that into the matrix, what the public input is or what the public demand or need or desire, you know.

3:05:24 It really is. Our money is sales tax. It's that quarter of a percent sales tax, and it's that utility tax for Measure U. So I think everybody, like we have said over and over, it deserves to be part of the process and is invited to be part of it. And the more we can show that they already have, too, I mean, that we can show that this is something that's been discussed for X period of time. Yes, and that we are using Plan Your Parks.

3:05:53 Because that's not on here. When we're researching. No, you're right. It's not in here. That's right. But it needs to be incorporated. That comes back to our communication issue. You know, the fact is that all of that has been taken into consideration and is incorporated into the filter. It's just, where do you see it? And that's something we've got to solve really quickly. Well, and it is in one of those matrices that we have. It shows all the different documents where a project has been mentioned.

3:06:22 And I think, I mean, I feel like to Stu's point, I do feel like we ought to, if we haven't already, try and distill from the CIP list what are the R&U eligible projects so that we can see that and know what's coming down the pipeline so that we're not just suddenly looking at an allocations cycle and the town is coming and saying, hey, we need a million bucks this year. I mean, that's kind of what happened in the spring.

3:06:47 Okay, this is the money that the town needs for its, so we need to get ahead of that and anticipate it and factor that in with the other projects that we're looking at. Is that part of the, that's not part of the deliverable though, is it? I mean, we're in a position right now where we're kind of just waiting for a submission from town, right? We're waiting for our request during the allocation process for these, this other category of projects. Is the deliverable just top tier big projects or is the deliverable more comprehensive than that?

3:07:17 Well, I think it's, I mean, we're delivering a full strategy that we've been working on. I mean, this is, to me, from what I've seen, this is one component of it. But the language of the deliverable, there's a little more, I think it's narrower than that. It says prepare and provide the town an MLR strategy and prioritize list of primary amenities recommended to be supported by our new funds by December of 2015.

3:07:44 So, I mean, theoretically that could include, for example, finishing, you know, the circuit of bike paths in town. I think we'd be smart to do it. Finishing Trails End Park. I mean, we have, we need to, I mean, to responsibly manage R and U, we need to, again, we need to be planning and out front of those projects, not just waiting for applications to come to an allocation committee.

3:08:10 And are we going to have applications? Are we going to have regular allocation cycles? Or is it going to be a completely different process? So, David, I would be in agreement with you that we should probably scramble and get a list from Stuart and really start vetting those two and including them. Rich, what are your thoughts? Loud and clear. Okay. All right. Any other commentary? Okay. So I will adjourn.

3:08:37 Thank you to the public for coming and supporting the process. Yeah, they're all home asleep now. And thanks to the board for your time. Thank you, everybody. Thanks, Tom. Thanks for running it.