Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2016
Mammoth Lakes Recreation
· recording 4 hr 30 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
548 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
19:20 You said without governance we can't provide these deliverables, so maybe governance is, you know, engines allows us to advance these strategies. I think as written, unless we were trying to make the claim that MLR was going to somehow project some new epoch of governance on the town, you know, that that was really a deliverable, that we were really going to, like, you know, raise the bar in terms of the way.
19:53 Maybe that's a strategic claim. But I think just being good at operating our entity probably isn't strategic as such. It has a place in this plan, I'd imagine, but maybe not as one of the strategic pillars. I would still support leaving it there as governance because it does take a certain extent of our time to ensure compliance with state mandates, Brown Acts, meetings, all that coordination.
20:27 Maybe it's weighted less in terms of how much time and effort we put into it. But aren't we overlapping operations versus strategy when we do that? Because now we're really saying that's part of strategy. That's really just your operation. I don't disagree with the timing. You're probably going to have more time spent on this as an operational entity as it grows. But I don't think as a strategy it really...
20:49 You know, because to me, the strategy in there to see, you know, develop and sustain organizational resources and capacity necessary to achieve mission. Okay, that's the only one in there that really kind of, like, all right, where do I fit that? That should stay somewhere within there, but. Well, we could take strategy five. I mean, I'm looking at it, it's, we're really close to the governance, right? I mean, you are because it takes so much of your time. And, but I'm looking at this document as somebody, you know, the proverbial Martian coming in and saying, what's MLR, you know? And what's their strategy?
21:20 I don't know that I care so much. Okay. If I'm really trying to see what are you going to do for the town. So perhaps we take strategy five governance and put it on page nine under the scope of work. That could work. Because I will say this. I think acknowledging our intent to comply.
21:49 And to be governed in a way that is efficient and effective and lines up with everything is important to state. That people understand that we are following a governance structure. This is a highly public entity. It's not a backroom channel for decisions to be made. It's a public trust. Exactly. Well said. I think that should be, that language should probably make its way into this document.
22:16 So I think if going to that organizational overview, is that the section you were looking to insert this in? Could be overview, could be scope of work. Oh yeah, sorry. Yeah, it was either that or scope. Or maybe it's a third heading that is governance, just specific to governance. And then it says, you know, this is how we're organized, this is how we govern ourselves, this is how we...
22:44 We comply with our regulations. Maybe that just is, it's just taking it from that and moving it over into giving it a governance section. And then I think the remaining four reasonably articulate what our kind of strategic objectives are. I think those are, I like those thoughts. I'm trying to think of anything that we've, you know, we've committed to that doesn't fit in one. I was going to say.
23:25 I think, I don't think that there is actually. I think these are broad enough that we can fit something that comes up. But also gives clear sideboards that says, I'm sorry, it doesn't fit into this. You know, when somebody does come forward and say, hey, why aren't you doing this? Well, it doesn't fit into these four strategies that we're following. I mean, I look at these broad enough and say, you know, this is a business plan. This is a living, breathing document. If someone comes up, I want to make a change down the road, but it works well enough for me to move forward and not have to.
23:55 Kind of repositioning. I am looking, though, in terms of what is fitting in these buckets, and, you know, one of the things that we're really, where we've made some very significant progresses in trails, and I don't even see it, I would assume it would fall under strategy two, experience development, new product development, I don't even see it mentioned there. It's under strategy two, it's Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
24:32 I think this is good to take to the board after this meeting. I think just see what they say on the strategy piece. I think we could very easily spend almost two weeks to put this together, trying to take all the pieces, try to make it fit, strategy, operating plan, milestone, try to make that fit one, two, and three so it would float.
25:01 You could very easily spend, you know, a half-day seminar going through something like this. You could just be placing a working document based on the direction of the board on January 5th. You know, in the best of all the worlds, it would be nice if the recommendation of the board was, you know, at your convenience, your nightstand reading, you know, read it and send rich comments so you can kind of flush stuff out. That's why I send those board packets out a week in advance. I know people are busy, at least gives people the opportunity to, you know.
25:30 Well, is the, so you feel like the document's ready for kind of a deep dive of kind of idea level scrutiny, not just structure? I mean, I feel like our exercise so far has been trying to structure the document, not so much wordsmithing and kind of, are you ready for a content scrub? First is the framework, right? So there's the framework. I look at the table of contents, do I have to write things in here at this point in time? You know, just in general.
26:01 There was limited feedback in terms of pros and cons on this prior to this afternoon's conversation. It's always helpful to me to get some feedback prior to a meeting so I can go a little more direction and say, by the way, I got some input and these were some of the comments or questions that came up so I can guide a conversation. Yeah, but part of that stuff a little bit until we get together as a board.
26:24 You know, I'm trying to bounce off and think, okay, am I heading the right way? I don't want to just shotgun you with, hey, can you change these 26 words? Well, and I think that's important, too, that I appreciate the we're all going to submit comments. At the same time, you're going to be inundated with comments and how do you balance? Does his comment resonate? Does my comment resonate? So I think collectively we want to try and give some direction that...
26:48 Resonates with all of us. And that by consensus we can all say, yeah, yeah, please do that. So that you're not off doing something that I tell you to do that doesn't line up with what everybody else does too. So I appreciate that we want to have that feedback, but also by bringing those comments into the board, these are the comments I've had so I can at least structure a conversation so we're a little more efficient in our time. Yeah. Well. It's a balance. It's a balance. Thank you. It's a balance.
27:19 So I think, back to Tom's point, I think we're good with the structure. I think we're good with the layout, a couple of tweaks to it. And I think what's represented in here is what we need to have represented. So now, not for us to do today, but I think what we say to our board this afternoon is...
27:42 We're good with the structure. We're recommending that we continue with the structure. There's a couple of tweaks to it, but now we're going to dive into the substance of it. Everybody has a copy of it, and the expectation is that when you come back to our February or March meeting, we're going to approve it. And so between now and then, you will be going through the substance. They will be going through...
28:05 You know, substance. And I think what we want to do is where you get comments, let's track those changes. So we're going to track them because we will come back and have the board by approval jointly say yes, we're good with those substantive changes. Does that make sense? Yep. I had a few more. Keep going. A few more generic comments. Go ahead. So one of the things just in the same thing with structures, like we get to the point of page 13 here, you know, we talk about where we have funded. It's not.
28:35 It's kind of a history to it, but, you know, I've kind of said, okay, where are we going a little bit, and also town budget from the standpoint of saying, okay, this is what we've got, 15-16, the fact that TOT will be a record this year, we hope Dan, but it looks, it's a little bit, I don't mind the history, but it's kind of said, I'm trying to look, where's the next step, where are we going after this? We've got today, got it, what about next year? So just generically, it's just saying it's a little bit.
29:04 Here and now versus forward looking because if it's a business plan we're supposed to build to that and if the town's goal is to make pay off the debt service in 2025, okay is there anything that we're doing? But there's certain things we've related into our plan for future dates that I'm not saying we're trying to outline them all in this one document but just more looking a little bit more forward as we combine with that.
29:30 Or we say the town's expenditures are looking to be the same in the next three years because without predictability of weather, we don't know if next year will be a good weather and we're building up reserves so the town can function, but we really don't see a significant change within where the town will be or Measure U, measure our funds. I think we just need to look at it as an added to portion of our plan here. Well, I was just going to ask, do we need this? Do we need the town's budget to be in here? Is that...
29:57 Is the town's general fund budget and their annual appropriations, is that important to our business plan? So they've got their general fund and their projects and everything that they're focused on, and that's going to fluctuate based on the revenue. What gets allocated to us is going to fluctuate based on the revenue. But does this need to be in here? That was the same question Matt asked.
30:27 The response was, if this document's going to go out to secure sponsorships down the road, they want to see the fiscal solvency of a larger organization. We're a startup non-profit. So if we're going to go to the King's example and have a conversation, who's your backing? Who are you working with? The town of Mammoth Lakes. Here's their financials. They didn't hear their financials at this point. And I'd ask the second part, does it become part of the interior to our document or does it become an appendix to the...
30:52 To the information saying the town plan is attached. I think that's the thing. And so the town budget is attached versus being within the document. I would line up with that because it is going to change annually. And so the reference, the point is the town's solvency informs our efforts too. And so we will have an example annually of the town's financial situation and it'll be included as an appendix.
31:22 I don't know if you need to make the connection of why we need it. My suggestion would be that you don't need it in this run of the business plan, that it's a supplemental that you could, if you get into a negotiation with somebody and they ask about the solvency of the town, you have a supplemental that you can hand them. For the most part, the kings or whomever, that might be an issue, but they're more interested in markets and in psychographics and demographics and who are they reaching.
31:51 What's their brand going to, how's their brand going to interact with our brand? If this becomes an important, I don't think we have to lead with it. Yeah, so I would support that. It's either supplemental or it's an appendix, however you want to call it, but it lives outside of the document itself. The point, though, the reference is, you know, that there is a town financial, the town's finances inform some of our decisions down the road and we'll track those or we will, you know,
32:21 and follow this closely. This is an instructive little exercise here. Is this the whole toolkit? Is this a piece of the toolkit? How big a piece of it is the toolkit? What other supplemental pieces belong to that toolkit as we reach out and form partnerships, go out and look for sponsors and partners down the road?
32:52 Did you have some more? Nope, that was mine. So that kind of carries back to also like appropriations and, you know, measure you, the same type of thing. It's just looking forward versus where we're going. You know, we can all document what's been and it's more of a dialogue to me and saying, okay, we support these things and we'll continue to be part of where we're going, but we're looking to be more capital-based, more structural-based of where we're going to be tactful in our resources and the implementation of those resources in the future. Okay.
33:20 One other comment I'd have, maybe more of a question about the framework, is it seems like most of the supporting material, and we have the section with our strategies and then some operational material, and then we go into fundraising, we go into advocacy, we have stuff on capital projects and partnerships, but the headers aren't.
33:47 Tied back to those four strategic buckets. I'm wondering if maybe throughout the rest of the document we really align that material so we're seeing how each kind of part of this document rolls back up to that strategy in a definitive way. I mean, it already almost is this way. The headers instead of, I don't know what you call it, you have a section on advocacy but you don't call it... Strategy for... Yeah, leadership and advocacy. You have a...
34:16 You have a section on Measure U and Measure R and then fundraising, but you don't call it leveraged funding. Maybe it'll clean up the flow of the document. Yeah, that makes sense. So it tracks back. The narrative tracks back to the upfront strategies that were stated. Makes sense. Yeah, that makes good sense. I'm good with that. That's my last comment. I think everything else is starting to look good.
34:47 This represents a lot of work. My goal would be to clean this up, leave the map tomorrow, rework it based on what I've heard, and send it back out as part of the Sunday communique. So that gives people two weeks then to kind of play with it, and I can track changes, and we can bring that back on March 1st. Oh, so March, so we're not, so the rest of the board didn't see this tonight.
35:08 Not to the review. I can say they've seen it. It's in the packet. The structure that we wanted to go through was executive committee to review it and provide some feedback. Give the directions to the rest of the board at 5 o'clock. We've given it some structure changes. It's going to come back to you. You'll have a couple weeks to review it, and then we'll approve it in March. And I think you should solicit commentary. Say, look, we've made some...
35:37 Framework changes based on recommendations from the executive committee. Please scrutinize this. This is coming back to you for approval on the next board meeting. Yeah, and that we're looking for substantive, you know, substance changes in here. We want if there's something that doesn't align or something that seems counter to the work that we are doing or we intend to do, let's pull it out or, you know, let's highlight it and make sure we address it. Okay.
36:07 Anything else on that? No. All right. Thanks, guys. Good feedback. Yeah, thank you. Dan is here. Are you staying for our five o'clock? Are you leaving again? I don't mean to put you on the spot. I was just going to say, if you're here, we'll keep the flow, but we want to let you go also. So if you're here, let's go ahead. Let's go do that. So then let's move to number seven, town manager.
36:35 That's you. Yes. It's your turn. I kicked around just coming back in and some of the budget work being done, and I want to provide some background information, some discussions we've had as we go forward. And a lot of it deals with kind of a rough discussion I had with the auditor when he was in town and also just in terms of some of the review of work as we go forward.
37:06 The two documents we've got is, let me take one step back. We set up MLR with the funding coming out of Measure R. And so that has legal restrictions on how that money can be spent. And secondly, we did provide, I think it was $15,000 for general fund dollars to help us to set up an organization getting better with MLR. The question that came out of the discussions and the review on things was,
37:34 What's in place to show that the Measure R money is being spent in line with what the voter initiative says? And I think we have some things that are already outside of those boundaries to come back and look at. So I'll kind of walk through some of that and then come back to the other handout there. But we're not reading all this through here, but when we get the
38:03 Voter Initiative is definitely very clear on what Measure R can be used for. Can we clarify this? This isn't the voter initiative. This language we're looking at is the language of the ordinance that the voters approved. So this is the ordinance. This is the ordinance language. This is what was put in place by the voters. Technically, we cannot change anything up here than an expenditure plan. The expenditure plan can change. Right, if it's in line with the voter approved ordinance. The ordinance calls out the expenditures, you know.
38:31 It can be done these things. It's, you know, it's trails, parks, etc. And calls that out very specifically in terms of what the money can be used for. Measure R has this expenditure plan element in it that we can amend the expenditure plan so long as the funds are still utilized for recreation, trails, parks, funding. So it's not a matter if we can take that expenditure plan we want to go do.
38:58 Something completely different. We want to go, you know, hire a police officer to promote safety in the community. You know, it still has to fall in line of what the uses were for there. The other element is it does call out, and this is part of the language where it uses the term city in here because it ties back to the TUT tax for issuing debt and those types of issues.
39:24 What happens down below in the expenditure plan, we did two things the last time this was amended, or one thing in particular, was I'm sorry, Dan, amended. We amended the expenditure plan. When did that happen? What was it? When we did the, was it, you're going to have to go down two years ago with MLR was created. It's the last paragraph that basically says that we can designate by a resolution of order of commission or committee to provide recommendations.
39:53 Before that said, it was the Park and Tourism or Rec and Tourism Commission. We took that language out, made it open to the council, designated a body. And then also, it continued the language that the town council, you know, to provide input regarding the use of funds. Once the requirements is to go out, have another body take public input, public comment that way so I can bring it back. The difference between R and U on this one is set up for public input.
40:23 Measure U requires a public hearing. Two separate legal processes when we do those things. And then what we added to the expenditure plan that the town may authorize direct funding for such a board or commission to offset the cost of providing the recommendations, including the operation administrative expenses. That was the whole debate over the overhead that would go to MLR, frankly, and it could go to any commission that's appointed that way to do that.
40:51 I think that's, you know, we had a temporary budget at the time or a proposed budget. It was $300,000. That was the whole process went through that. The first year we had it was $200 because of the hiring, et cetera. And those issues are there. So the concern that was raised is the question is how are we managing or tracking expenditures by MLR to show that they still fall within the framework of the ordinance where the money is utilized for the purposes called out to be
41:22 The planning, construction, operation, maintenance program, the administration, trails, parks, and recreation field managed by the town without supplanting the other elements, those types of elements within that expenditure plan statement. And that comes back to that owned and managed type issues that come into play from the language beforehand. And so part of that gets into the issue, for example, we spent a lot of time and effort on the Measure U allocation process.
41:51 That's not eligible funding under Measure R. So it's a going back and saying, so we've got dollars sitting over here that we did on purpose in one deal to get set up, but also we knew there would be work that's not Measure R eligible. And so it's up in the accounting side to kind of track that back and say, yes, we did spend $2,000 on the Measure U allocation process, and we're going to charge that against the unrestricted money, not against Measure R.
42:20 Otherwise, Measure R funding is directly supporting the Measure U process, which isn't, you know, they're two legally different things. Right now, it's mostly staff. It is. It's primary staff. It's also like contract work that I have to go back and say we did some contract work to develop a logo and stuff. Okay, is that the administration of the organization to meet these purposes? And at which point do we step over that line and we're supporting a non-profit to go do whatever it wants to do?
42:50 But the dollars we put into it really should need to have a link back to these recreational elements. Did we use the general fund dollars for the graphic design work? There's been a little bit of that extended. Yeah, so we've expended into that general fund. So we didn't use measure our funds for that. We used general funds. So let me ask this. So we're trying to track that out to say
43:16 And there's some gray area in here. We talked a little bit about it. We talked about the operating administrative expenses. On the front-end discussion, we knew that you're going to have, potentially at the time, we're assuming rent. I haven't picked that issue out, so it's pretty much free. You're going to have funds. You've got copiers. You've got that general administrative stuff you're going to have to go do. Some of the organizational work that needs to happen, you've got personnel stuff you put together. To some degree, the strategy document falls into that. It goes beyond Measure R, but it's part of that.
43:45 Operating sides of this. Those are things that have some sideboards and how we look at those elements. The way this was drafted and part of that, the idea would be a lot of the effort would be dealing with the public input in this process and so it's kind of tied back to that element of it. And so one is tying it back to as tied as we can to the ordinance because you don't want to have somebody come back and going, hey, we think there's been a mouthpiece expenditure for us.
44:13 You know, what happens with that either, generally what happens with that is the town of general fund will be on the hook to go back and backfill the new Girard. Right. I mean, end of the day. And so, the other piece that kind of helped with that was the first shot, this was the other handout on the exhibit seat from the contract, would be that in each, this is item D there, would be that each year we need to get information from the MLR showing specifically how the funds were spent.
44:42 And that relationship to the restrictions on the use of those funds. And we call that an example of RU. At one point, I think U was looked at for administrative dollars, potentially, because of the number of board members that had direct relationships to the major U.
44:57 Funding of events, et cetera. No major few dollars were allocated for overhead. I don't even remember that conversation. I do. Okay. Where was that? Was that before the board was seated? Yeah. Where was that? Well, there was people who were coming in, and Rick and Joe were involved, et cetera, in that dialogue. Part of that issue was, well, if you have a number of people in there that potentially have a direct conflict.
45:19 Not just on making the award because they can recuse on that, but now you can actually do any of the operational use of those funds administratively because you could benefit from that work. So then let me ask this. So when the town said to MLR,
45:33 Go do a Measure U allocation process. Should the town at the same time also have said, and oh, by the way, here is $5,000 from the general fund. We provided $15,000. The $15,000. And then the idea would be, okay, MLR needs to raise some other non-restricted dollars ultimately for a lot of the other work that's going on. And that's been that whole push me, pull you on the overhead discussion that went on. And those things that turn around and say, how do we do this?
46:03 It's like the prohibition on fundraising with our new money. It's been a legal finding from a few years back. So how do we raise money if we can't use the money to raise the money? That's the kind of discussion we had. And so that was one reason, okay, here's least some startup dollars that are unrestricted. They help to get the organization going. I think some stuff I forget. It was a 100 for 100 campaign or whatever that mission kickoff was. There's a good dollars coming in from that. And that's unrestricted dollar juice, however you want, type of issues there.
46:32 But ultimately, as we get into the next year, the request will be is to really show this, the accounting side, so I can show that to an outside auditor who comes in compliance with the ordinance. I'll need to show, well, here's how $200,000 was spent to measure our money, and yes, it is linked to the purposes that are in the ordinance. And so, you know, I can mention some of the operation stuff is a little, it'll be a little loose, and we'll deal with that as we have to.
47:01 A lot of the work initially stuff coming in, we're spending a whole lot of time, for example, on the outdoor performing arts facility. Is that a Measure R item that's going to be tied to one of these things, or is that more of a Measure U slash community item? To the extent it's performing arts, and we can truly make that connection to arts and culture, it's probably Measure U eligible for some stuff. But is that a Measure R funded work? You know, Rich is putting several hours into that, we're putting time.
47:32 Now, see, should that be coming out of a different funding mechanism? Because right now, that's not a project owner managed by the town necessarily, although it may end up there, but is it for these purposes? Now, some people consider concert and drinking recreational activities, so... But we define recreation to include the arts and culture piece to it also. Yeah, that was back to... That's defined all the way.
47:57 It's all the way back to just the definition of recreation, back to rec straps and the whole bit, so it does include an arts and culture element. This here talks about, in the ordinance, it goes back into defining it very clearly to be its trails, programs, facilities, for recreational purposes. If we define it too broad, my other concern is, frankly, we can go spend the money on anything we want.
48:22 That's the other concern. It's going to be, I'm going to be very narrow when this request comes forward, but in our use of it, I'm going to be very broad in terms of definitional issues. So, and the concern there will be, as we look at a compliance audit, I want to be able to have a record that says, no, we have the dollars here, here's the input we got back, here's their records coming back and showing how they...
48:44 So have you shared with us, MLR, the form or process that you use at the town
49:14 for how you track Measure R expenditures and so that we're in compliance with how you're doing it also so that there's not two different tracking mechanisms in place. What we're doing for Measure R, one is it says we put it into a separate fund to start with all goes into that fund and then those expenditures are allocated out and they're all auditable by an honor. The piece of isn't is here's $25,000 to MLR for this contract. How did MLR spend that?
49:42 I'm not auditing your books. But are tracking it, but we can respond. Yeah. When the request comes in, we have the ability to respond with where the expenditures are. So I guess what I'm asking for is, are we tracking the same? I don't have a set format. Okay. Is there something that we should? Yeah, payroll. Well, yeah. And so we get each month something comes in. We've had some discussions on that. And you break out.
50:09 On the timesheet, the timesheet has... In our conversation on December 16th, we started doing that at this point. Yeah, start breaking. We began to talk about what doesn't fit, what is a U. So you go back and look at the allocation process, look at the graphic design, some of the communication stuff, that's all general fund. So we believe right now, if it's pretty clean, I just want to get to the board, next November we'll be requesting documentation for the year of the show. Right.
50:39 That I can show up to an auditor and say, yeah, hey, we're in compliance with the ordinance. Here's the backup from MLR. Now they spent $200,000. We have that detail on the trail side and turn all that. Here's how we spent $500,000 in trails, money on trails. So let me ask a few questions. Yeah. And just make sure I understand kind of the ins and outs of the situation. It seems like you is,
51:09 a problem. Anytime, as long as we're whatever, anything that includes a U component, you could make an argument that we're spending some resource against something that doesn't directly go to the ordinance, to the art ordinance. It sounds like the work we did, the graphic design and everything, is okay for now because we used a different funding source for now, but as we're
51:39 Emerging into a fundraising entity, we know, it sounds like there's a very, very small basic level of expectation that you're going to have some administrative costs right to do this, but not the kind of expectation we're talking about in terms of really trying to go out and raise funds. If there's travel costs, if there's, you know, to build the prospectuses that we need to build to try and attract money into.
52:08 The fundraising machine that we're trying to build. So we have to solve that problem. And we deny that to other applicants. Even though it's in the service of R, that violates that very small, basic administrative expectation. Or at least that's his interpretation of it. Well, I think maybe we get the same.
52:35 I'm not sure about that. Yeah, I'm not looking at challenges, but there's, I mean, but it's kind of broad in terms of planning, construction, operation, maintenance, programming, administration. But here's the key right here. If we showed a dollar match. Oh, that's it. That's it. But I'm really asking that question. But, so that's, understood. So, so that's one issue. Is there, is there any,
53:04 Well, how does that work, though? Because we had board members who recused themselves from any recommendations of
53:33 for projects that they may have a conflict with. I think that's what you were saying. It's not just in the allocation. You can manipulate strategies and such. I want the strategy to really come back to focus on Shakespeare in the park.
53:47 I think that's just a really cool thing and you really should work on that. And even though it goes through a public process and all of that. That doesn't matter. In fact, that even makes it worse. It's, oh, now you're here debating and I can bring forward and you have an interest in that. It makes it really hard to populate your boards with people with expertise. So the decision at the time of one way to not have that conflict on you was not to fund it, admit of it on that directly.
54:16 You know, is there a U-dollar that could be allocated out? Let's say we do the, you know, the allocation process and we're putting ads in the newspaper and we're putting a call for stuff and it's a direct hard-of-dollar expenditure. Is there something like that to offset some costs that would be potential? And then to use of it differently because it requires a formal public hearing, not just public input. Right. So that has a different noticing requirement, et cetera.
54:44 And you could argue that under an admin expense. But again, that's probably a Measure U expense. It's not a big one. But those are the types of issues. And again, I don't want an outside auditor asking those questions and saying, yeah, I don't know. I think that would be good. And you're right. The language of the R ordinance is much more specific in terms of how you define recreation. U is much broader, which also gives more potential for
55:13 Come benefit me. Well, you still use the word recreation the same way R does, and it also includes arts and culture, and it includes mobility. But it's broader than that in the recreational level. It doesn't have to be town owner managed. Right. There is no expenditure plan for Measure U. It's just pure what we say. Yeah. Yeah. So just to confirm, we are...
55:36 tracking right now using our timesheets in a manner that you've seen as a town manager that you've given a, you've looked at it and you're okay with how we're tracking it. So can we get that back and make sure that Dan sees it and he's okay with how we're tracking it on those timesheets? Yeah. So that when, you know, to his point that if there is a question asked, we can show the records and you can see through that timesheet.
56:05 What we're doing, they provide a summary, actually, that gets attached with our payment request, whether it's for $25,000 or zero. That goes into our file. So that would be what an auditor would go and look at and say, what backup information do I have on a payment? Or on, you know, the background for that. Okay, here it is. Since we had this conversation on December 16th, we've cleaned this stuff up. So it's safe to say that...
56:28 Right now, we're okay, but we have ourselves a persistent issue that we're going to have to deal with in perpetuity until we find unrestricted funds that can finance some of these more administrative and kind of grounding. We're out to do things, but it's not tied to a particular planning administration of a project. It's much broader than that.
56:55 And you can volunteer all the time you want from a board member standpoint, several you can put hours in doing some of this stuff. But it's like some of the other work, you know, it falls into a lot of the communication strategy. Well, that's broader in nature versus, yes, we're working on this project that you can link it to the facility.
57:15 Are you skeptical of that interpretation? Do you have grants to be skeptical? No, I'm just pushing the envelope from the standpoint of just understanding because it has a very defined managed by the town. I'm thinking to myself here, what does that mean owned by a town? What if somebody's leasing property for the town that's not managed by a town? Did that prohibit us from being involved in it? And the reason that two different languages in R was set up, one is town, there's an element of town owned and town managed, and the managed came back into like the lease with LA.
57:45 And use permits with the Forest Service. The Forest Service elements. One of our challenges in some of those, we do some projects out there that are really pushing the envelope there a long ways of, I'll say, one of the elements we've tried to work through the Trails Program is how we do the Stewardship Days. If there's a program that initially we didn't set the Trails, we didn't...
58:11 Manage it. We weren't overseeing it. It was truly just, here's a dollar amount to somebody else to go do that. We brought that back in as analysis going, okay, we need to have more of a management of a program. The problem is it doesn't, the facilities, we're working with the Forest Service to have more relationship there too. So we're strengthening those types of programs and projects.
58:35 to make it much stronger in terms of, so if you get a question on, now, hey, here's how we're using money, here's what we're going forward, here's the Lincoln Act, and then on the ground, obviously, results are the other thinking. Okay. So that was a heads up. Rich and I had the discussion. We wanted some of that explanation to come in. And again, next year, I'm sure there'll be a request in the auditing standpoint. Okay, where's the documentation that shows, from MLR, showing the detail, how we spend additional discussions for that.
59:09 Rich, I think this goes back to this plan under time consumed for administration. Yes. Right. Your plan is truly, you know, it's restricted dollars. Yep. Right. And that was, you know, a significant part of the setup. And the town attorney was a part of those conversations early on. He provided his interpretation of it and how it was, that's how it was formed and how it was set up.
59:38 Okay, Dan, anything else you want to share with us on that one? Any other questions I can answer those or not? I recommend Dan comes down back next month and talks to the whole board, financing, cost, let's get a better plan for that in March as we begin to look at these capital projects, what cost will be as we begin to set our budget for $16, $17, and beyond. So is that specific to projects or to NMR or R&U as a whole?
1:00:08 Combination of all, I think. I think it's the RGC. We've got to put a number, for example, for the RR projection. Okay. Stuff like that. We can walk through some of that there with some of the same information and also some of the financing elements. Okay. I'm beginning to do some guesstimates of the cost, some of the preliminary numbers you can share with us, and whether it's the cost, X, Y, or Z for project-specific. How are we going to map these things out? How do we want to make this work? What's our recommendation?
1:00:39 Okay. Okay, so we'll put you on for March meeting also. All right, thank you. Thank you, Dan. Thank you for that. To my fellow, we have two other items plus an action that we needed to take. Are you guys...
1:01:10 The prospectus and the Winter Recreation Summit. Are you okay with putting that? We can kick that to our regular meeting. We can discuss it completely as a board. Is that all right? I'm totally okay. Okay, but we do need to look at 7B. Rich, funding? 7B. Page 37 in your packet, agenda bill. Looking to continue to work on our prospectus and business plans.
1:01:40 an allocation from its general fund expenditure to work with a graphic designer to continue to do some work with us to clean up some of our documents so when we do get to the point we're doing fundraising, sponsorship, et cetera, we have some materials to share. Page 38 summarizes the breakdown of the projects in our business plan, Park West Center, Parks and Culture, trail system, outdoor events venue.
1:02:08 Move these things along not to exceed $1,000 is a general fund expenditure. Based on going back and doing some adjustments in the allocation process based on funding, we believe out of the $15,000 we spend about $1,200 at this point in time. So it leaves us about $3,800 give and take a little bit of general fund money to allocate for project specific because we need to begin to set the table for funding, sponsorships, et cetera. So the recommendation is to
1:02:37 Allocate $1,000 from the general fund to support work with our graphic artists to continue to put a polish on our project's prospectus and our business plans. We may not spend all that this year based on how far along we get in the process. Okay. And that's in addition to the 2, 3, 35. It's already been done, right? Correct. Okay. And these are the graphic designer's estimate hours? Correct. Okay.
1:03:08 All right, so do we have a recommendation? Yeah, and wasn't this a follow-up of what we asked before to come back because we said we're going to need some additional hours to do some of this stuff? Well, she had some additional hours. That she gave us all. Yeah, and then we expended those, right? Yeah. So this is on top of that. To add to that. Yes, this is on top of that. This is to get her to start helping with some of our design work for our documents.
1:03:32 The conversation we just had, notwithstanding. It's clear to me, it's clear as day to me that for us to really build an effective fundraising machine, we have to have these documents. They have to be on point. They have to be pro.
1:04:00 I fully support this expenditure. And if she can set it up for us that way, that staff can plug into it. But to your point, this is our representation out to potential partners and funders and contributors. And so it has to have a style. Is there a motion to, I would entertain a motion to recommend.
1:04:24 He has a question. Oh, was that a question? I thought you were making a motion. I will make a motion. I moved. Yeah, he supported it. I know. So you make a motion to approve the recommendation? To approve the recommendation. A thousand dollars. Yes. Is there a second? Yeah, I'll second that. And I just, from my standpoint, there may be some tweak in where it goes, but I agree that use of time and energy and where they need to be in professional is where we need to be. It does raise, well, I'll stop there because.
1:04:51 I got Dan's stuff in my head about that website. And we'll talk about it when we make that recommendation to the board. All right. Any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 3-0. Dan, thank you very much. We are at the end of ours, so we will adjourn and we'll move into our board meeting. Thank you. You guys, the exec committee is finished. Come on up and join us. Thank you. Thanks, Dan. Yes.
1:05:25 That's where we start to get into this word right there. That's what that was intended. And then there's this. What does that mean?
1:05:40 I can tell you what it was intended when we drafted it back in 2008. I can tell you. I have the original.
1:06:18 Are we ready? All right. Rich, we're going to go ahead and get started. We'll call the board meeting of the MLR board to order at 515. Apologies, you guys. Thank you for bearing with us. Obviously, you heard the discussion as you were coming in.
1:06:46 We'll have Dan come back and talk to us some more in March. We have some housekeeping issues that we'll be working through. Let's go ahead. Roll call, please. Liz Leanne. Okay. Colin Frank. Tom Johnson. Here. Gary Morgan. Here. David Page. Here. Here. Dennis Drow. Present. Terry Costello. Yes.
1:07:11 Here. Okay. I'll open it up for public comments on any item not appearing on our agenda. Is there any public comment tonight? All I'm going to say is thank goodness. Go ahead. Thank goodness for snow. Snow, snow, snow. Lots of it. Glad to see for water, for fire, for business, for everything. It's just a very nice thing. Did you guys all see the photographs?
1:07:36 From the top of the mountain that we posted. Yes. Oh, yeah. Signs almost buried. There's no stairs coming out of the ground below the station anymore. That was crazy. We also had to take a step up to get out, right?
1:07:49 Go up, go over to, to go down, kind of thing. It's also Groundhog Day today. Hello, happy, and we're going to get an early spring, based on what Punxsutawney Phil did. Yeah, I don't know what it means, early spring, but that's... I relate that to the East Coast. Yeah, that's true. I know, but, you know, it happened, so there you have it. And everybody survived Iowa, and we'll see what that means down the road also.
1:08:14 That's a whole other conversation. No other public comments. I'm moving to our administrative items. Approval of our agenda. Everybody's okay with what we've got? I will note two items that our Executive Committee didn't get a chance to review. That's the Mammoth Creek Park West Prospectus and the Winter Recreation Summit, and we'll just collectively as a group talk about it when we get to it. Any questions about the agenda? Okay, then we have minutes of the January 5th meeting to approve.
1:08:43 I would move that we approve them. I had one thing that I thought we might do well to add and find it here. It was where it was a comment by Steve Brown. I thought it was worth noting that he mentioned the town's perception of MLR as the fundraising arm of these efforts. Is that under the taking action on the $145,000?
1:09:17 Do you know what page in this packet it is? 46 is where we start our minutes. There was a reference made under the five-year strategic plan. That was on page 48, top of page 48. We start to move into that.
1:10:13 Working together with partners and establishing roles. Public comment, yes, on number four, Roman numeral four on page 48. Beginning public comment was also made by Stu Brown and Dream Oak, Betsy, about working together as partners, establishing roles, working as a true partner. And I think he had a specific comment about expecting MLR to be a fundraising partner in the partnership. Yeah, that was, I think that was in our notes. Leslie, and we can go back. Not a big deal, but it seemed working.
1:10:45 Yeah, we can go back and review it. We have Granicus. We can go back and just take a look at it real quick. And if you want to approve, if you want to move to approve with the amendments. Yeah, I'd like to move to approve with that one minor, minor, very minor amendment. Okay. Is there a second? For a second. I see I'm in the minutes, but I'm not present. So, even though I wasn't at the beginning. You were at the, you were here a couple of times. Yeah, nobody came in.
1:11:15 But I have comments, but I just, we can change what time I did actually come in, but I was late coming in, but I was, I was here because I've been into minutes. Yeah, you are into minutes. Okay. Yeah. Thanks for that clarification. So up on top. Yes. Under roll call, Lesley-Ann, we add Brent to the present. Okay. And I think we know at what time he arrived. Oh, yeah, it does say what time he arrived. Yeah.
1:11:40 So put him up on presence. It does say Brent Truex joined at down below. Yeah, down below. So he just wants for the record to show that he was present. So with that change, so two changes, Brent and David's comment. So there's a motion. You want to amend your motion to include Brent? Sure. All right, is there a second to the amended motion? I'll second. Terry?
1:12:04 Move and second to approve the minutes with two changes as recommended. Any further discussion? All those in favor indicate by aye. Aye. And any opposed? Okay, that motion passes. All right. We're going to move on. Where did John Mammoth go? So, we have on your agenda, if you remember last month, we were going to have this presentation provided to you, kind of as...
1:12:32 For a couple of reasons. In thinking about Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the broader landscape that it has relative to the outdoor recreation industry and what goes on here in Mammoth Lakes, but also to start to understand what's going on around the country with this outdoor recreation movement. The Forest Service started, or actually the document that was included in your packet was distributed and published by the Forest Service back in 2010.
1:13:00 And it was really an internal document. Unfortunately, they haven't implemented as much out of there as they would like, but it provided a framework by which they were going to pursue this discussion about sustainable recreation. And here in the Eastern Sierra, you guys are all familiar with the forest plan revision process that we've had undergoing since 2014 now. And as a part of that, there was a group formed, Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative, that brought together several
1:13:30 Gateway community stakeholders to help provide comments to the forest plan revision process through a recreation lens. And in addition to that, there's some forward-looking efforts around ESRC and MLR and our entire recreation product. So John Wentworth, who is on that leadership team for the ESRC, asked him to come and give a presentation about the sustainable recreation and what
1:13:59 Where things are going in that regard. And so John's got a presentation for us today. Dana, thank you very much. Does this need to be on? It's got a red light on. Does that matter? Okay, good. Good afternoon. I just returned from Washington, D.C. I was back there with some family business, but when I'm back there, I try to take advantage of those trips to check in with folks.
1:14:26 And I was thinking about giving this presentation to you guys this afternoon, and over the course of my trip, so many things happened that go right back to this, the value of this effort, what we're all doing in the Eastern Sierra. The eyes of the folks that are interested in public lands in the nation, they're focused right in on the Inyo National Forest as an early adopter forest with forest planter vision. So this is just increasingly germane as we go forward.
1:14:56 So let's just get right to it. So the management plan for the Inyo National Forest is being upgraded using a set of rules that are called the 2012 planning rules. A lot of strum and drawing, a lot of effort went into putting this set of rules together, and these are the rules that guide what's going to happen with these updates to these forest plans.
1:15:15 It was done. They were completed back in 2012. These things get published in something called the Federal Register, which is the official national notification of all things having to do with federal efforts. And, you know, it's 115 pages long. There's a lot of...
1:15:30 Typing that went into all this. There are three fundamental parts to it. There's an assessment of the existing conditions of the forests on the ground, the plan or vision or the amendment to the forest plans of the individual forests, and then the monitoring once the forest plans are in place. And these rules are going to apply to every national forest across the country, every single one of them.
1:15:50 So the same way we hear about the travel management program. Congress said every forest in the country, you will take an inventory of your roads, you will clean up your road system and provide a sustainable, maintained system of roads. This same process is happening for every single forest across the country. And the three phases they've put together in this rule are designed to complement each other and work together. The Forest Service is trying to get to be more flexible, more adaptable.
1:16:17 They don't want to write a 500-page plan that's going to sit on a shelf or get implemented in pieces over 15, 20 years. They want to be able to be more flexible, more facile with how they do these things. And they want to make sure that the public is involved in this thing. They really want to get public outreach. And they want to have the public involved. These are the public's lands. They want to do what they can to get the public involved in this process. And it requires...
1:16:45 To their own internal staff folks, you've got to work with the public, with the landowners, with the partners, with tribes, with gateway communities like ours and folks in the Eastern Sierra. These folks need to be a part of this process. Which brings us to the word of the day, which is collaboration. Collaboration is not required by the 2012 planning rule. They don't legally mandate that you have to do it. But they acknowledge and recognize that if you're going to get a good plan, you're going to have your stakeholders and your partners involved.
1:17:13 And they encourage their staff to do this. On the Eastern Sierra, we have a very proud history of collaboration. And I don't say this lightly. Dana was part of something called the Collaborative Alternative Team. This had to do with the travel management process. Now imagine you're Jim Upchurch, who's the forest supervisor at the time. And you're completing your NEPA process. And there are seven or eight alternatives that are coming at you through the NEPA process. And you know that if you pick any single one of those, you're going to get sued by somebody.
1:17:42 Some national organization is going to sue you and say, I don't like that one. I'm going to sue you. Jim Upturch made a very interesting move. He went out to the stakeholders and said, look, if you guys come up with an alternative that you guys will agree on, I'll sign it. You guys do it. You figure it out. I'll sign it. And that's what that team did. Dana was part of that. He signed it. Didn't get litigated. Didn't get sued. Nothing happened. It went in as law. Every other one of these travel management processes, litigation, lawsuits, blah, blah, blah.
1:18:12 That's a prime example in the region of what we've done with collaboration. Here in Mammoth Lakes, we've done two much smaller efforts, but the same set of values, the same approach to addressing conflicts and issues on the public landscape. This is not a community-based process. These are all public lands that we're dealing with. So anybody...
1:18:31 And the nation theoretically wanted to participate can't participate. But the Sherwin's Area Recreation Plan, the SHARP document, the Lakes Basin Special Study, these were done at these types of collaborations. And the recreation plan even won a little award from the Far West Ski Association, which we should all be very proud of. The increasing use of collaboration
1:18:52 Just from a management perspective, the analysis time gets shortened. You cut down your risk for litigation. You've got buy-in from the public of how their lands are going to get managed, so why would you have any problems? It's just common sense. Get them involved. Get it all done up front so you don't get end runs. You don't get powerful interest groups with unknown existential resources that can distort the process. Get everybody involved.
1:19:17 Work together. So Inyo National Forest has a management plan from 1988. Nice, big, thick, good, rich, classic, late 20th century Forest Service Management Plan document. This is now the subject for the update that's happening with this new set of planning rules. And of all these national forests, eight forests have been selected to be early adopters. What this means is, in this case, the Inyo, the Sierra, and the Sequoia, you guys are going to go first.
1:19:47 And we're all going to watch how you do. We're going to see how this works with this new set of rules. And the lessons learned on these forests are going to inform, I don't know how many forests are on the country, there are hundreds of them, but the lessons learned of these eight little forests, this is what's going to happen. And overseeing this whole effort is something called the National FACA Committee, which we'll get to in a second. But they're charged with how well these rules are working. How is this, what's happening on the ground?
1:20:14 They're looking at all this stuff, and they're looking at the Indian National Forest and saying, what the hell's going on out there? Is this thing working? And I think, I guess it's in your packet, the Framework for Sustainable Recreation. Nice, concise, specific, aspirational document. One of the key aspects of sustainable recreation is your documents have to be short. You cannot write a 150-page document. It's got to be 10 pages or less. Concise, focused, digestible. That's one of the homeworks of this thing.
1:20:44 It points to providing, protecting, partnering, performing, and planning with stakeholders. And one of the specific components of this is something called gateway communities, of which Mammoth Lakes and all the little communities here in the Eastern Sierra, we are textbook examples of what gateway communities are. When people come for a public lands experience, they're coming through our communities. We're the first people that they, hey, where's the trailhead? What are the conditions like? Where do I stay for a night? Where do I get food? All this kind of stuff. We are the
1:21:13 primary point of interface to the public lands experience. And the Forest Service has done some things to implement the sustainable recreation philosophy. In the southwest region, in Arizona, the entire region went through internally a sustainable recreation program to get their documents in line with this. The Deschutes National Forest up in Oregon has done some of these similar kinds of things. It's a hit or miss thing. It's happening on some forests. It's mentioned in the planning rule. Entire regions are doing it.
1:21:42 A top-down directive from Washington, D.C. down to the ground to implement this stuff, it frankly doesn't work very well. And any of you guys who study political science, you know that you can't just tell a bureaucracy, you know, it's not that simple. It takes real will internally and externally to make these things happen. But they're trying. This is what it looks like in the Southwest region. And again, this is their plan, which is not very many pages long. Simple, specific, direct, accountable. This is how our programs and systems work.
1:22:11 As opposed to unending, unaccountable, who knows what's doing what. You know, get simple and focused with the things that you're trying to do. So here in the Eastern Sierra, we have this Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative, which was put together by Michael Ward, Dan, and myself to work specifically with this Inyo National Forest Management Plan update to provide a collaborative capacity to work with the Inyo to get these kinds of things done. And if you take a look, this is just Mono County.
1:22:40 All these little red dots are the points of recreation access. It gives you, I mean, this whole county, we're all about recreation. That's what we do up here. And if you look then across from Lee Vining all the way down, this is the specific granular types of recreation infrastructure activities that people are coming from all over the world to enjoy here. We need to work effectively with our forest to do things we can to enhance these things. If we leave it all to them,
1:23:10 They've acknowledged in this document it won't happen. They cannot get it done by themselves. They don't have the resources. And there are serious political forces back in Washington that are trying to underman the whole idea of public lands. This is not settled business. Teddy Roosevelt got in some trouble a hundred and some odd years ago when he got this thing going. That trouble has not gone away. And the state of Utah is putting a lot of effort and resources into to change all this stuff. But this just gives you an overview.
1:23:37 From the collaborative perspective, which was not, again, not a Mammoth Lake-centric thing, but a region-wide look at all these opportunities, look at all the opportunities that we have. Here's Bishop, Lone Pine, even down to Alantia. Across the entire forest, the opportunities are really endless. And this is the bread and butter. It's the essence of our culture, our economy, why we're here, and why we do the things that we do.
1:24:01 About a year ago, this was the kickoff meeting that happened in Bishop. This is giving you a little background on the collaborative itself and how it functioned and what it did. Established values from the public. I mean, this is not me and Dan or Michael running around setting up.
1:24:16 Sharpies and getting chairs and doing that kind of stuff. This is the voices of the people who show up to participate in this stuff. These are the values that they define for the public lands experience and what they wanted to carry forward. So stewardship, resource protection, access for all healthy and sustainable communication infrastructure. These are the things that the public is saying this needs to be part of the public lands experience. It needs to be enhanced. The management plan needs to point us in this direction to make these kinds of things happen.
1:24:44 Sticky notes, dots, lots of people. Input, input, input. Happy faces. The draft recreation strategy, right? Took all that stuff, combined it into creating a document, took all these different ideas, summed them together, do what you do in these kinds of efforts. And all of these things are written to, in the language that the Forest Service uses.
1:25:08 for their management plans. So desired conditions, objectives, standards, and guidelines. These are terms of art that will be in the final plan itself. Michael Ward did an excellent job of facilitating these conversations with all the comments coming from the public speak directly in the language of the Forest Service itself. No one has to do any translating. It's right there. And then a final document was produced. And this is back in January, about a little less than over a year ago, January of 2015.
1:25:35 And so there is a proposed recreation strategy to share with the planners of the Inyo National Forest, to share with Region 5, to say, look, this is what a collaborative of variety of users and stakeholders would like to see reflected in your management plan. Let's see if we can get that integrated into the document. 52 different desired conditions spread over the six values, principles, and guidelines that were established by the collaborative.
1:26:00 This is what the document looks like. Desire conditions, objectives, standards, and guidelines. Again, written like a Forest Service document, but written by about 50 or 60 different people. And it marries this framework for sustainable recreation with the management program for the forest. And again, here are the values that are there. And about a year ago, the Forest Service was on a very aggressive
1:26:27 Time frame to get to the next phase of their management planning process, which is the draft environmental impact statement, the draft of their plan. And the leadership team worked with Inyo County, Mono County, Mammoth, and Bishop to send letters to the Forest Region 5 leadership to say, look, let's allow a little bit more time so you can integrate these things into the planning process. We were concerned that they'd be coming out with their draft document in two months. Well, it's about a year later. It still hasn't come out.
1:26:57 But that's good because lots of things have happened between now and then. And the request from all the local governments in our region was to let's have a reasonable extension of the deadline so we can incorporate this into the document. And this was the rationale for doing all that stuff. In the meantime, some things happened. Something called SHIFT, where conservation meets adventure. This is a national level conference.
1:27:26 Where the values of the conservation community and the values of the recreation community, folks are saying, let's bring these things together. Exactly the same kind of thing that we're doing with this little collaborative here on the east side. Let's bring these things together from a national perspective, because a lot of people have interest in this stuff. Because outdoor recreation and natural settings is always and has been an indispensable part of conservation. These two cultures are not...
1:27:52 We fight together sometimes, but we shouldn't be. We should be working together to enhance the public lands experience. Outdoor recreation has economic stability, diversity, resilience, and prosperity to communities across the country, gateway communities like ours. Public lands experience is critical to our economy and our way of life. When you don't manage it and do it properly, you damage the resource. You're not conserving anything. You're delivering bad recreation experiences to people. It's in everybody's interest to work together to manage this stuff properly.
1:28:22 Look at all these people. This is all I could fit on this slide. There's about 10 or 15 more that had a presence at this conference. So you've got the Wilderness Society. IMBA was there. The Outdoor Alliance, which represents snowlands, winter wildlands, IMBA, a whole bunch of different folks. The Access Fund, Forest Service had a huge presence there. This was really literally all the hitters involved in the Conservation Committee and the Recreation Committee gathered at this conference. I just want to point out that Theodore Roosevelt
1:28:49 Conservation Partnership. This organization has been around since 1912 or something. They have their own internal ethics about what they do in the public lands landscape, how they do all this kind of stuff. This goes back to the very roots of the public lands experience. All these people are gathered. A great conference, the dawning of a national movement around outdoor recreation, which is a $650 billion industry, as I'm sure you've heard that.
1:29:18 Repeated many times. It is a huge part of the U.S. economy. That example is getting translated all over the country. This is a, I can't pronounce the name, this is a Nantahila Pishkash National Forest in North Carolina. Look at all these folks. Same thing that we're doing here in the Eastern Sierra, same thing we've done in the Sherwins. Wilderness societies, IMBAs, access funds, all these.
1:29:46 The conservation and recreation committee coming together to make a recommendation to the forest supervisor of what his forest plan, of what the final alternative should look like for that forest plan revision. It's happening in North Carolina. And as I mentioned earlier, it's happening right here in Mammoth. This stuff is happening all across the country because everybody recognizes the value of doing this stuff. Here's the Sherwin's thing with all the nice signatures on that page right there. And this kind of caught my attention.
1:30:16 We all know what was happening up in Oregon with the standoff with the folks who had some government land issues. This community had done a collaborative plan, blessed by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, to manage this national wildlife refuge. They'd gotten their plan together, it was being implemented, it was being used.
1:30:37 And yet you still, I mean, I'm sure the folks who went up to occupy this place had no idea about this. But the public lands experience is susceptible and vulnerable to outside forces running in runs wanting to impose their will on what their vision is of the public lands experience. It's very serious. And what I was hearing when I was back in D.C., there are committed
1:31:00 Forces that want to undo the public lands experience, give it back to the states, give it back to resource extraction, all the rest of that kind of stuff. It's a very real and living thing that's going on in the national conversation. So the degree to which the recreation community and the conservation community is fighting with each other and arguing about stuff, it's giving an opportunity for those who would just say, look, this is ridiculous. Let's get rid of the whole thing. Let's start mining and drilling and we'll do something else with it.
1:31:28 It's a $650 billion industry. And this is in large part why you guys exist, to be lined up with this. Imagine MLR at the shift conference next year with the president saying, our communities, we get this, we're dependent on this, we want to be part of this larger national conversation. So what are the next opportunities for us to engage with these things? And I think Dana mentioned the Winter Recreation Summit, which is getting pulled together right now. It's going to happen in the middle of March.
1:31:58 And the forest plan revision process is going to get started probably in April, it sounds like. So the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative will get revved up again and start getting noticing out for folks to participate in those efforts. So I don't know if you could be talking about the Winter Recreation Summit and your keynote speakers and stuff. Yeah, we're going to talk about that a little bit later in the agenda. I wanted to add on to that.
1:32:22 MLR was at the SHIFT conference this year. Yeah. Didn't have a logo, though, I don't think. Didn't have a logo, John. Didn't have the hat on. However, John was there, I was there, Mike Schlaffman, those of you who remember Mike, he was there making actually a significant presentation on the work that the Forest Service is doing up in Washington to collaborate and to look at their procedures and how to improve upon those.
1:32:51 The point here is that MLR at that SHIFT conference, we were talking to all of these conservation groups and we were talking to these recreation industry manufacturers and leaders in the industry.
1:33:07 And talking to them about MLR and talking to them about our collaborative out here. And the attention that they were paying was significant. They were very, they want to know more. They, you know, it's happening here on the ground. And what we're doing is a potential model for some of the work that they're trying to pursue in other parts of the country. And even looking to, you know, how to align with it. And so I say that because we got attention.
1:33:34 And we're living it. We're doing what a lot of those groups want to be doing, and we're actually doing it. I don't think we knew it, but that's where we are. So at your stations, there are two documents there that have been printed out for your consideration and for you to read. The first one is a list of the partners that helped fund the SHIFT conference itself.
1:34:02 And then the second one is the principles for advancing what they call principles for advancing outdoor recreation and conservation. And these principles, if you look at the list of people that helped put these principles together, these are the leaders of the industry. This is a living document that they're going to continue to update as they go along. But it establishes some principles. And as we start to look at
1:34:28 The values and principles that were established by ESRC, as we look at the values that were established when MLR was formed, all of these start to line up and they start to point to this goal of recreation, conservation, economic sustainability, natural resource support, and really building some capacity around these issues and around these items.
1:34:57 I'm sharing all this because it's not a one-off. We're not a one-off. We're not out there doing something that nobody else knows about. We're in the middle of what's going on around the country. And I think it's important to note, I was looking at the principles here and how many of these folks that are on here we are interfacing with. We're actually having dialogues with.
1:35:22 You know, people who are interested in wanting to be a part of what we're doing here. So it is a significant movement. We know what's going on back in Washington as it relates to the funding of our natural resources. You know, although this budget was just passed, there was a little bump in the budget for our Forest Service folks, but not nearly enough to cover all the recreation facilities and programs that they've been charged with.
1:35:51 We're going to be looking at partnership development where we have opportunities to help inform these decisions that are being pursued by the Forest Service. We'll talk a little bit later specifically about some winter recreation efforts.
1:36:07 But I think for us, because we are so connected and dependent upon the federal lands that surround us, we need to be knowing what's going on, and we need to be involved in paying attention and not being afraid to reach out and communicate with these folks. We are not to be intimidated by it. And when I say intimidated, Dan Nordstrom, Outdoor Research.
1:36:30 We're talking to him. We're having a dialogue with him. We should not be afraid of that. And they want to pay attention to what's going on here. So I'm wanting us as MLR to understand that we have a focus certainly on supporting our community infrastructure. But when we also look around at what the product is, it helps drive our visitation.
1:36:57 The quality of life that people move here for, it's that out there. And what our interface is with that is just as, if not more important sometimes than what we look at internally in the four square miles of town. And being actively engaged in that is something that's very important for us to track. So this is why we asked John to make this presentation, but also to remind us we're not alone in this. There's a big movement out there. David, you were just at the
1:37:26 Retailers show and you experienced it and you saw it firsthand. Those of you who are out and you're seeing it happen as well. It's rather exciting actually to think about what's going on out there that MLR is potentially a part of and even helping to inform as it continues to move. I wanted to share those extra points. You guys have any questions for John about ESRC or forest planning or shift or anything else?
1:37:55 Quick question. It may be hard to pull it out of memory, but just as we go forward and start talking about our own strategy documents, I'm curious, you referenced that that document was written by 60 people, but I'm assuming that Michael Ward kind of wrote it, packaged it at the end, and I'm wondering if so, what that cost, and kind of what was the cost to achieve that, just specifically the ESRC strategy document? Yeah.
1:38:23 The language and the words in the document are literally translated from the notes. Not even translated. They are literally transcribed. They're copied, transcribed. The spelling was fixed in a couple places, but it is literally what was said. And it's an excellent point because...
1:38:41 The agency, while they talk about collaboration and wanting to do it, they do not have the tools, the skills, and the bodies to do something like this. And that's one of the messages that's going back. I met with some staff folks from the FACA committee that Dan introduced me to, and they're understanding this, that in order to do these things effectively, you have to have...
1:39:01 A capacity outside of the Forest Service to do it. And this is one of the communications of the Outdoor Alliance is to say a great service that they could start providing is a how-to guide to put together something like this for all of the other hundreds of national forests they're going to be following after this. And they're kind of going, yeah, gee, that makes a lot of sense. I guess we better do that. Michael's a very, I don't have the numbers off the top of my head, but it costs, it definitely costs some money. But when we're hiring Michael, you're getting an extremely
1:39:30 Yeah, I'm just trying to, you know, again, just as an open conversation about how we figure out, you know, do we consistently have to bring some packages, things, or do we?
1:40:07 You can build it locally. I would jump in here too because it's not just capacity, it's also culture and how we choose to conduct our business that way. And I think that was the lesson learned out of the collaborative alternative team, the picture that John showed back there from 2009 of the travel management plan decision. It was a culture of we will work together collaboratively to do this. And that meant a lot of...
1:40:37 Late nights down in the Forest Service Supervisor's Office going over maps, you know, if you will, arm wrestling over what stays, what goes. It was the culture more so than even the capacity that really helps inform this because if we are, as a culture, we say yes, we will always collaborate and we will bring in. You don't like it, but you do like it. Well, we're going to come in together and figure out how we can reach some consensus on moving this forward.
1:41:06 It's not just capacity, but there's a culture and a willingness, and even, you know, this is how we choose to do our business. You know, I get that, and it's inspiring, and I think it's great, and I've seen, we've done big things that way, but I think that the culture we have and the capacity I'm not sure about, and part of what makes that culture of collaboration work is that ability to, at the end, crystallize a message to then present and take and
1:41:35 And have, you know, a unified vision that comes out of a collaborative process. And so far, I think for the most part, we're doing that with facilitated, with consultants. They're very good at it. How do we transition to a place where our, you know, the staff, we're putting tax money into these sorts of things. How do we get to that same, you know, be able to say, and maybe...
1:41:58 Having the Outdoor Alliance help to do training, that kind of thing, where we're going to build that capacity, I think it's going to be fundamental to our success. I will add to that that the CAT, the Collaborative Alternative Team, there was a little bit of funding for a facilitator to come in, but he ended up training a couple of us to actually do the facilitation because he wasn't going to be able to make the trek over for all of these meetings, and so it was just that point.
1:42:27 Getting some training in place that now we've got resources locally that we can tap into. So that's a really good point. Thanks for bringing that up. And I think we can. I think if we look at that as our culture, then don't we, as a community, want to have that capacity? Yeah, I mean, we had a collaborative meeting in here last week. And the question gets raised, what is that driving to and does it ultimately...
1:42:55 Pull together a strategic plan that everybody buys into in the same way that ESRC managed to pull off. That's a great point. Yeah, the critical things in all these things is a need. You can sense when something is starting to head towards something, it's like, okay, this is going to turn into something. The Sherwins is a great example of that. Mike Schloffman, we had a huge real estate development project going on out there. We had conflicts going on with public access.
1:43:25 Propane tank thing going on. And, you know, you start to, your antenna kind of goes out and you go, okay, this thing is headed towards something. We got to, you know, get the resources, figure out how we're going to do, we need to go get into a process. And the CAT thing was the same kind of way. It was like, okay, this thing is at a certain point, we got to bring in some capacity to make it happen. So it's always usually tied to something like that. Some investment. I like the point you're making. To some degree, the facilitating continuing to
1:43:57 Produce facilitated events, and this town is a level of training, but very specifically when we have these gatherings, these public gatherings with staff and the public, and there's a kind of continual blockage that results. Do we have...
1:44:13 Do we have a need for, you know, like in-house facilitation? Well, we just, you guys just went through, you know, what kind of unrestricted funds do we have to work with and can we afford a thousand dollars for graphic design? And that's, I mean, that's why I ask, it'd be nice to start seeing some specific line items for our educational background and be able to say, well, here's what it costs to get to ESRC. Here's what it costs to get to the Sharp.
1:44:42 And those costs, can we reduce them by doing it in-house? Do we have that capacity? Or do we need to begin to budget for those costs so that we know that we're paying somebody to write up these documents and to design them and to present them in a way that are, as John put it very well, concise, focused, and digestible? The next phase at the ESRC, we have a grant from the National Forest Foundation for $24,000 that will cover, I think, six or eight public meetings.
1:45:13 With, I mean, you know, with region-wide advertising, promotion, all that kind of stuff, facilitation service, document creation, all the rest of it. There'll be a lot of in-kind stuff that goes with it, but it's usually numbers. It's those kinds of numbers for a big process like that. Yeah, and I think Sharp was maybe like 35. Yeah. And the Forest Service, actually, in that one, the Forest Service paid for the facilitator. That was paid through? Well, it was combination, but yeah. There's some in-kind. If you get the parties together and everybody goes, look, we've got to figure this out.
1:45:43 Agencies might have some resources, someone else is going to have some resources, and you can kind of pull it together. That's a good point. Any other questions for John, ESRC? If you guys remember, we did provide comments to the early alternatives that were proposed for the forest plan revision. So MLR did submit comments.
1:46:11 And when the DEIS comes back out in April, April or May, somewhere around there, we'll look to come back and have some comments. Because that will be, when that document comes out, there will be an official public comment period based on the NEPA process. And so there will be an opportunity and we will, I would encourage us to look at how we can submit those comments within that period to be on record. And just as a reminder, Forest Service still is.
1:46:41 Taking some comments on their wilderness evaluations that they put out, their wild and scenic river evaluation, and their species of conservation concern that they released. The deadline closed on the 1st, but it's not a hard close, and so if you have an interest and you want to provide a comment, you can certainly do that in those three areas. John, anything else you want to share? No. Thank you very much, John. Thank you. Thank you. All right.
1:47:10 Let's move on to the next item, number four, sorry, our executive committee report on the first draft of the MLR business plan. So the executive committee met prior to this meeting and you all had a copy of that draft business plan in your packet and we came up with, we want to let you know, we gave some additional direction to Rich on a couple of things. Number one, we think the structure of the document, good, makes,
1:47:40 Makes sense, the way it's laid out and structured. We had some suggestions. First of all, strategy number five, governance, and not using that as a strategy, but rather inserting it into the narrative within the document back under the advocacy section and the, what was the other, there was
1:48:03 Scope of work. Scope of work, thank you. So right underneath scope of work, we will take that governance and put it back in there. So we will be down to four strategies looking at that. That's one change. The second change that we looked at was related to, sorry, let me get to my notes, governance. Oh, up front under the executive summary, we've got the vision, we've got the mission, but we're looking to insert.
1:48:32 The why MLR was formed, the narrative of, you know, why, why is, why are we in place? And if we go back to 5.0, that document, there's an opportunity to put some of that in here to establish the why. That, you know, gives us the vision and mission. And then we were looking to, I think, you guys remind me of
1:49:00 Additional, we had a couple additional, oh, in the back, we had inserted the town's budget as a part of this document. We're removing that as a, it's more of an information piece or an appendix or to the document itself. And the reference is that, you know, there's the town's budget does inform our budget a little bit, but we were taking it out of the body of the document and putting it in as an appendix.
1:49:28 So we have that in place. And what else? Also just the general structure mapping back to this strategy. Go ahead. It's already kind of like that. We have the four strategic categories. And then the following supporting material loosely aligns back to those strategies. One of the strategies is called leverage funding.
1:49:57 We have a section on Measure R and Measure U, and we have a section on fundraising, but they don't map back to leverage funding precisely in a structured way. So just taking all that content and aligning it with those four strategic categories. And also, part of it is...
1:50:17 Looking more forward, we talked about taking these things out that are part of the structure, but not just say where we have been, but really the business plan is to develop where are we going. We've kind of boxed in some things, examples, but we should be open-ended on how we are working with other things that we don't even know what will be tomorrow. So it's an open forum of bringing in more things into that discussion points, but not just say these are the only things that we're only looking at events, we're only looking at one thing, but how do we open up that whole door to look forward in our discussion and as a business plan.
1:50:45 So the way we structured this is that we had the exec committee give its review and comments back to Rich. And what he's going to do is take what we provided him and edit it and reformat it and then send it back out to us as a board, the entire board. You will have a couple of weeks to review it and track your changes back to Rich.
1:51:13 And at our March meeting, we will look to review it and approve it at that point. So you will have homework that you will have to do, and you will be hoping that you want to take a look at the substance that's in here. We're asking you to track your changes on that so that Rich will be able to keep a handle on the master document. But your focus is going to be on the substance. Unless you have a real heartburn about the structure,
1:51:43 But we think the structure is good. And you'll see the little revisions when they come out. We'd like you to focus on the substance and thinking about the business plan. Rich, anything else you want to add on this before I ask questions? Okay. Are there any public comments about what we're asking to do about the business plan? Okay. Any comments from the board about...
1:52:09 Where we're headed on this and the direction that we're taking on this. I just had one comment that came up when we were talking that this is a living document. I mean, I, and this is to your point, Brett, that this doesn't exactly, it's not a five-year plan. It's very kind of narrowly focused to the here and now. There are some milestones that you start to see creep into this document. I expect over time that once fundraising has a kind of
1:52:35 of a substantiated set of goals and milestones. That would make its way into the business plan. And kind of in every affected area of our work, we would start to see things that would represent our vision a year out, two years out. But, you know, we don't, we haven't looked that far ahead in some of those areas yet. My new question, what would be on Measure R and U? Are we going to know by the time this is due to be finalized whether we're actually going to be allocating that money or whether we'll be doing it?
1:53:08 Additional on our strategy. Or how are we going to, are we just going to keep this living while we try and work that out? Because it's quite a big part of this plan. Our allocations, the allocation process. We should have, at our March, an allocation meeting to get an idea of what allocation is going to look like for 16. Dan and I have been speaking about that over the last couple of days.
1:53:36 We shared a couple documents with David today. Had some good conversation with the folks in Vail. Tell you why they got some good foundational stuff. I've got a few folks I'm being with on Friday to be able to just think this through and bring something to our town manager to say, this is where we think this could go. What's your vision for it? We've talked about having the chamber involved as part of an economic development strategy. The positive with that.
1:54:04 Is that if an event makes money, if it's an economic development strategy of the chamber, there's not a concern about giving public funds that allows events to grow. But I still need to get a better flavor from our town manager of what he's thinking in terms of structure. So I'm trying to put a frame together to bring it to him. Gary, there's no way we're going to have that done before we get to March. I think that's going to take us a couple of months because it's got to go through the town council through a process also. And as we've said to the town council on a number of occasions,
1:54:31 There will be no further allocations until we have a strategy in place. And that's specific to events that you're speaking of? I'm looking at allocation. In general, okay. There will be a wide range of allocation. As one of our board members said, what happens if somebody walks in and says, oh, I want an X dollar shirt for something? You know, you look at, a lot of these folks have set up separate commissions or foundations or non-profits to look at an allocation of funds. Telluride Foundation was set up and they allocate $865,000 a year.
1:55:01 It's from athletics, to special events, to programs, to projects, to capital, to education, to athletics. Along and longer, there's almost a dozen different things they'll fund. There's an application process based on a strategy and you can go through a process. So we better figure out, you know, based on those models out there, what this fits for us and what is our town manager thinking about in terms of how this fits in with economic development and our issue with the gift of public funds. It's a big conversation.
1:55:30 Should the allocations committee be involved in that discussion? I would think so, but... I would think down the road. Okay. Who are you meeting with on Friday? Just a few people in the town that have an interest in this. Town government, community members. Okay, what time is that meeting? Okay, well, we'll follow up on that, because before anything gets way out ahead, I think we want to keep catching up. I guess that was my concern, so these things are taking place, but, you know, we're not involved in that conversation, so...
1:56:03 So to answer your question, Gary, no, but, you know, that is, the R&U allocation is a role that we're playing, and how we're doing that is still to be developed, but it's not our sole, it's not our sole purpose, you know, there's a lot of other purposes in here. So based on Terry's comment, I will send you the links, because I'm spending a lot of time doing research now.
1:56:28 I can spend into the links to the research here and I stand reading to look at stuff because there's a lot of stuff out there. The question is what works for us. That would be great. I'm not here Friday, so I don't know if you can attend or Drea can attend. That would be the people on our allocations committee. We'll circle back, see when it is. Yeah, just sort of stuff. What do we think, guys? What do we think? What do we think? Did you ever get clarification from the town manager about
1:56:57 And this is specific to special events, but those funding buckets that were available for any of that? Okay. We have not. Okay. Because that's an important piece also. So just can I piggyback off that real quick? There's other things to say, but are you guys envisioning that a part of this document eventually, maybe not by March, but eventually would have kind of a five-year budget strategic where we say, all right, there are one point.
1:57:26 Let's say $1.8 million per year coming in in revenue and measures R and U and what does that look like over five years and what percent goes to this, what percent goes to that? In this business plan? By March. Not by March. This is what I'm saying, not by March, but is that, would the theory be that at some point this year we have that as part of, as kind of a brass tax operations budget for, I mean, as strategic planning goes?
1:57:55 That was, I think I called it the next missing piece, tooth for our entire organization, in my opinion. I think that's what Dan's going to come to the next board meeting and start to share kind of his take on our, on how to, where the fund sits. He's got some projections on what it's going to look like next year. We've got to make that determination, how to responsibly manage.
1:58:24 Should we get advice from other sources too? I would absolutely think we need to. What do you mean? Because let's remember that through the ordinance there's processes that call for public involvement. And so even...
1:58:45 Outside of this, there's a process that you have to go through for that allocation also. Oh, I get that. Is that what you were referring to? No, I'm referring to some kind of outside, somebody who knows about strategic financial planning, somebody who understands how to, you know, various ways to build big capital projects, various ways to, I mean, so that we're not just getting one piece of advice and then seven of us are saying yes or no based on...
1:59:14 One perception. I think the people on this board, the expertise on this board, we have the expertise to review a recommendation like that, not to make one. That's my opinion. Every time I've engaged in this conversation about how do we leverage R&U long term, we talk about floating a bond, and that's about as far as the conversation goes, and there really isn't...
1:59:41 There is no expertise in the conversation. No one brings it to the table. In terms of allocation, how do you manage a long-term allocation of the scope we're talking about? Someone can point out someone in the town, you know, in our government that has that skill set, but I haven't had a conversation with them yet. And I agree with that, and I think that we need to look at what the other options are out there, you know, because, you know, if you just...
2:00:10 Go straight to a bond. You really don't have any other opportunities that you can bring forward. So how can we leverage those funds so that we can create a bigger... And perhaps there's a matrix that we look at how you do have a bonded allocation that's asserted, but what percentage and to what end? And is that part of strategically, how does that fit into your overall capital plan?
2:00:39 I don't think that I have heard anything that makes me feel like we are going to be great stewards of these two funds moving forward unless we bring that in and have a conversation. Well, we haven't done it. It just has not been done. But I think this to me shows that we are getting close to a place where we've sketched out a broader vision. I think there's a lot of work still to do in terms of making it polished.
2:01:09 But, you know, we've got a scope of work before us, and now I think getting some outside real expertise as to how we get from here to there is, I think it's coming up on due. Any outside source is going to require some funding, you know, to do that, and I appreciate the point about not having just one perspective, but there are
2:01:39 Around the country, there are triple P, P3s, public-private partnerships happening, and there are firms, actually, that are specializing in pulling together those P3 projects, and we probably have access to a few of those. We know a few. So I think if I'm hearing, we want to make sure that we use resources to help inform our decision, use additional outside resources. How have other successful models done it?
2:02:09 I don't mean to demean the board in such a large way. We can be responsible with money. We can budget public funds or recommend the budgeting of public funds in a responsible way. There's no question. It's that next step.
2:02:34 That next level understanding of finance that we don't have. Well, but just to do part of it, I would disagree with the standpoint of responsibility because I think we are responsible, but it's all in a good prudent process. We may need more information, but going to your point, David, to me, that's all we're building to is how much money do we have and how much we're going to allocate for certain type of things and long-term things, and then what is the best way to manage that dollar? Do we save it for five years and do one project, or do we bond it and do $15 million and say we aren't going to build another project for...
2:03:00 20 years. I don't know. To me, that's all comes back to that last dollar. How much money do we have? I started the conversation when we first started. I said, let's start figuring out how much money we're going to put into certain buckets, and that will define where our direction is going to go. We're kind of getting back to that, but at the end, we're going to be saying, okay, do we take half a million dollars a year? Great. Well, and this gets raised when Mammoth Lakes Foundation is saying, you know, we would like $300,000 a year for operations budget on a new MAC facility.
2:03:30 Can we afford that? I mean, we've got to really plug that in. What does that mean in the context? What does that mean in the larger context? And I don't think we really have that. We don't have that experience and or expertise that goes with that. So I'm just saying I'd like to, that seems to me a milestone for this year would be to get to the place where we are considering some hard options with some real expertise and coming up with a strategic budget.
2:03:59 For the funds that we are charged with. I think a lot of this is going to be down to the stakeholders doing all of that work for us. We should be overseeing rather than doing the due diligence ourselves. It could be as simple as having a CPA or a business advisor look over the stakeholders' information themselves and see if they have viable business plans. Does what the MLF give us mean that we should get them to $300,000 or does more need to be done?
2:04:25 So, I mean, a lot of it is out of our hands until we get that kind of information. Well, I think that's right at the core of the conversation. Where does our research really lie? And it's one thing if it's an outside stakeholder that's got the money and the funds and they're developing a project and then they're coming to us. It's another when we're working with rec commission in town and developing a project as a municipal octopus. I mean, it's like three things, right? There's scope of work, there's fundraising.
2:04:56 And then there's financing. And I think we've nailed, or we're starting to, two of those three pieces. Financing is the missing piece. That's new for us. And let's readily admit that, you guys. This is, you know, it's taken a while to get there where we're actually talking about finance. And this is one of the reasons MLR is in place. And we're about to, you know, at the next board meeting, we're going to have a presentation from our town manager and we're going to download.
2:05:25 our town's expertise in that regard, and it's our job to assess what we are and take the next step. Okay, I interrupted you. You were going to say something, MLF finance? Sorry, my bad. David, you had other comments or questions? Well, I'm glad, I like the idea that we, in a couple of weeks or whatever, with a couple of weeks lead time, we can...
2:05:54 Go through and do, because I have a lot of online level edit stuff, of course. No. But I also, but I, on a more general note, I just, I wanted, you know, we're about to have a discussion about the, I assume, or maybe it's already done, the $1,000 for graphic design. This has made me realize that I think we need some of that budget for copy editing and maybe even for some writing.
2:06:21 In order to get to that place that's concise, focused, digestible. A lot of the sections here, I think the structure's great, I can tell a ton of work has gone into this. But a lot of these sections are just pasted wholesale from other documents, and there's no source referenced, and it's not a unified voice. There are a lot of things, like the whole section on Mammoth Lakes comes straight out of Wikipedia.
2:06:49 You know, isn't on point for what this document needs to be focused on. So I just raised that. I don't necessarily have answers for how we get there, but I just want it to be, you know, when we do go to approve this final document, I want it to have a unified voice and for it to be polished and for every sentence to make sense. Okay. So copy editing? Copy editing, but I think it's more than that. I think it's, you know, I think it really requires...
2:07:23 I mean, it requires somebody to really sit down and say, you know, make sure that it reads for somebody who's not, you know, who's not just us. It needs to, this should be a document that I could send to somebody in New York City and say, here's what MLR's up to. And there's, as yet, no real description of Mammoth Lakes. I mean, this, a lot of this stuff is things we talk about, these guiding principles, but it's not put in a context of
2:07:50 What are four square miles? What's at stake? What kind of recreation are we talking about? That's not ever defined in here. There are no specific user groups pointed to. I've said this before, but I think it's awesome stuff, but it could apply to a recreation department in Detroit or getting people outside and the healthiness of that is fundamental. But what about our public lands issues? What about the kinds of things that
2:08:20 We're referenced in John's. They're not in here yet, and I think that's what lifts the stakes of this, and raises it to a place where, okay, Amara's doing something different for a very unique place. Sounds like you're talking about two things, one's copy editing flow, and then the other is content. And I just don't know, you know, because...
2:08:44 Because this is a tough process. I mean, trying to write something with nine of us, and that's kind of why I brought that in. It's like, at some point, somebody's got to take ownership of this document and make it case. This is a selling document for our organization. And it should set us on a course for 10 years that says, this is who we are, this is what we're doing, this is our mission, these are our guiding principles. We look at everything this way. It informs our allocations, it informs...
2:09:13 Our involvement in capital, you know, these are cool infographics where private sector, NGOs, public sector, and I know a lot of this is just bookmarked, so I don't mean this to be critical, but I'm just saying, you know, I would like to be able to finish reading this 12-page document and go, ah, I see where MLR fits. Whether I'm a stakeholder or I'm a voter or I'm a taxpayer or I'm somebody who's never been in Mammoth Lakes, I see this is what this organization does, this is where it fits, this is what it does.
2:09:43 This is where it's trying to go. That's kind of, I mean, you brought up why MLR, so kind of an aligned comment. I look at this, why MLR, why wouldn't, why don't we already have this from all the other organizations that are out there, from our government directly, why is MLR specifically constructed to do this? Yeah, and we know the answers to that, and we have specific
2:10:10 context put in. I mean, there were previous bodies that couldn't do these things, and why should be articulated here. So, I guess the next question is who and how. I think one, just listening, David, to you kind of going through some of those issues, one, I'd love to see something put together where it's just what's missing, right?
2:10:40 First and foremost, instead of, because you're going to receive just a lot of edits. Right. And they're just going to come at you from all the different board members and how are you going to prioritize them, group them, etc. I'm wondering if we could maybe do an exercise or two ahead of that kind of really detailed line level editing that would be helpful to you. And maybe one is just a basic what's missing. You just rattled off a bunch of things that you don't find in that document.
2:11:09 Right now. Maybe that's the first thing we do. Maybe we take a week and everybody's like, what is not in here? And you compile a list like that. But I think your point is really good and I think I have to put it back to Rich. What is the best way? And I mean, have we provided the right direction? Do we need to...
2:11:33 I mean, what is our process here? Like, the ESRC was a clearly defined process. It had a facilitator. That facilitator was going to compile a nice polished document. It had a background in that. That's what that person does. So we can talk about this, but then we give it to Rich, who maybe doesn't have that background. And also, this is pioneering. I mean, we're doing this for the first time. The problem is, what you're talking about, a basic just hired hand copy editor out of the blue.
2:12:02 That can polish language, but can't cull vision out of all of these pieces. A coherent vision. That's an extra level. I agree there are two parts to that.
2:12:19 You know, ideally, and we have to look at our budgets and what we're already spending on admin and what we're spending on staff, and we can't afford to spend $30,000 on an outside consultant to write our non-profit business plan. I can't sell that idea. Yeah, but do we go to the next process and get board member comments back, get at least the content going, then how do we finalize this document? Maybe we come to a consensus saying we need somebody to go through this and...
2:12:46 And smooth it out and get the portion and reduce that cost to... Of having somebody write it versus somebody review it. Exactly. And just kind of clean up that last portion. To me, that seems like the best option. If we can pull it off and if we were to agree that's the goal, I mean, I think there are people who can come in and do a little more than a copy edit, but they're not writing it. But I just want to, you know, when I saw that, okay, let's...
2:13:13 Put money into graphic design, and I see, you know, we already did put some hours into graphic design on a rough draft of something, and I think we should watch that. You know, let's get the copy down before we go to graphic design. I agree. So, that begs the question, you know, is this a, did we just, are we looking for a new resource? Well, what's your initial reaction? Does it feel like, I mean, because you guys have, there's so much on your plate. Well, that's the biggest challenge. First,
2:13:45 I really need you guys to clearly define what you want us to do first, second, and third, right? And then we've heard of the budget conversation with our town manager before, what fits and doesn't fit. You know, we talk about later on getting into fundraising. I really think we need to do a crowd rise campaign just to support MLR. We talked a little bit this afternoon. Well, there's $2.50, no matter what we call the darn thing, but mainly for family and friends. I got people that will give me money, unrestricting funds, to do stuff, to clean up documents.
2:14:12 We didn't have a business plan walking in the door a month ago. So in this last month, we got a lot done. So we got a frame in place. It still has a lot of work that needs to be done. I would encourage, I would be very comfortable, I feel comfortable where we are starting at this point, for you all to give me some feedback on structure, what's missing, etc. I'm working with the Small Business Coalition at Bakersfield. It's a change of peak performance, 3D consulting work on creating business plans.
2:14:42 Based on your feedback and my work with Matt Hightower tomorrow at 11 o'clock in the morning, kind of share some of these pieces. Feedback from you guys, cleaning up a little bit more, look at a second rendition when we come back in March. Obviously, we're not going to finalize this because it's a ways to go. But you begin to look at some of the milestones in there and think about the budget stuff. We can begin to look five to ten years about what are some of those projects we want to do. We have a phone conference tomorrow morning at 10 o'clock with some King's representatives.
2:15:11 Just to begin to talk about what does that support look like, what does it taste like, and just initial conversations. And this is not going to happen overnight, but by, we've got a good first draft going, I think, I'm comfortable with that. I've learned a lot about, you know, a lot of different things, putting these together. It's taken the majority of my time at this point, but by giving me feedback, I'll try to compile all that feedback, bring a second draft back in March, and based on that, we can say, okay, how much progress have we made?
2:15:38 I'm sure, based on the work we've done and the focus we've got right now, there are a lot of things we're trying to balance, you know, many of those entities right now. But I think if you see what we've crafted in two weeks, I'm sure we can double the quality of that in two more weeks. You know, so I think it's just being real clear, Rich, this is the first thing we want you to do. This is the second thing we want you to do. So Leslie and I, when we sit down in our morning briefings, you know, okay, this is the work for the day, for the weeks, we can be in the plan. It's just the allocation process that came up.
2:16:08 I probably spent, sorry Dan, probably 10 hours just researching, you know, talking to people, email, texting, what documents do you have, what can we replicate, what does it look like, because we're going to be in a position where people are waiting for something to happen, we've got to push the envelope, but it's got to be the quality of the work that's really going to narrow that. So, to come back a little bit, because we've had the budget conversation, how much general funds do we have left?
2:16:34 About $2,500. About $2,000 to $3,000. Because we're having another request coming up that we're going to have to... Well, that's $1,000. We had $3,800 in there, so we take $1,000 out. But I'm based on the hearing right now. I would say let's poll that. Let's redirect where we're going at this point based on this conversation. Let's start there first. Let's get the content and the copy clean to the level we're comfortable with and send it out to somebody.
2:17:01 You know, you communicated with somebody today that we're both familiar with. It does grant writing. It does power stuff up. You know, there'll be a conversation next week to say, what would it take for you to come in and spend a little good time working with us? You know, so I think we have a lot of resources that if we're really focused and targeted and really crisp on what we need, it's a little package. It's a little package. So what's the process getting this, pounding this into enough shape to turn it over to an outside resource?
2:17:29 Well, it sounds like we're on that. Is it we're just going to send you stuff? So you're going to do another buffing. You're going to send it to us. I'm going to buff it first based on what I've heard, based on my conversation, Matt, tomorrow. Clean it up. Part of the Sunday communique. Give me a couple days. Clean that up. Get it out to you guys on Sunday. And then give it two weeks. Less than two weeks because February is a short month. And get it in the board packet as a second draft.
2:17:56 I think we're going to be doing this for March, and based on that, we can sit there and say, okay, what's our next step? Right. That makes sense. The only other, I just want to say one thing, is that one of the things that I miss in here is you are so convincing when you're standing at the dais talking about MLR, and to get your voice into here as a, you know, as the...
2:18:19 The guy who's steering the ship. As the Executive Director. As the Executive Director. Saying, you know, and on some levels informing us what you think is possible with this organization. Because we can only, you know, we're looking at it from different committee levels and once a month we're doing this. But you're the guy on the ground. You're the guy who can see, you know, can begin to see. Here's where we're going and here's what we can do and here's the capacity we have. And so that instead of us just...
2:18:44 Imagining it, you come back to us and say, you know what, here's what we can accomplish this year. Well, you're living it and breathing it every single day, and that's the, you know, that's the voice, I think, that we're looking, because everybody is doing a lot of other things, too, so your direction in that regard is important for us to be able to line up with. My first step was, what's the frame that we're comfortable with? Let me get to put some meat on the bones. If we're comfortable going in that direction, you know, it's going to take me a couple more weeks and a couple more weeks because you're a writer.
2:19:12 A hell of a lot better than anybody in this room. It takes time and effort just sitting down and writing. This is hard writing, too. It's a technical document, but it's also got to be aspirational and tell a story. It's got to capture you. It's got to touch your heart. So we're clear on what you'll do. You'll get it back to us on Sunday. We'll have 10 days or so to respond back to you, and then we'll have a look at it in March and we'll determine.
2:19:40 How clean it is, how not, and if we have copy editor opportunities or some professional review. Anything else? Any other comments? I have one quick thing. It may be off topic, but there's this chart, and I know we all approve this with different buckets, which projects are in implementation phase and priority phase. And when I see it in this context, I just realize that things like the
2:20:09 The MAC are not by any means in implementation phase. They're still in development phase. And the same is true with the Mammoth Creek Park project. So let's remember the implementation, our interpretation of that was this is where our emphasis was being placed. This is the, this is, this is the, isn't that a priority? No, we, I don't want to go, I don't want to go down that. Don't, we already beat it up. We came up with the word implementation. If this was going to be our focus. I hear you.
2:20:38 But I think public perception is correct. So, yeah. Yeah, and I think there's room to revisit that with the, I mean, if you came to us and say, hey, let's include this, and we could all just go, yes. Anything else? Madam Chair, I would recommend, let's combine four and six, because I think four and six conversations probably weren't the same, based on the perspectives. Okay. People looked at it. Once again, I'll send it back out. Give me your feedback on that. I'll clean it up and take it back in the bucket again.
2:21:13 Because we're not in a position of taking stuff out just yet. So I would say let's combine the same process on those two projects right now. Does anybody have anything specific about the prospectus that you want to share at this time? Since you have it in front of you, and as he's going to go do some cleanup on it, is there anything you want to add to it in this first round of cleanup? I'm looking at you. I do, but I also think that I'd better serve to sit down with Rich and talk about that versus the...
2:21:39 I was thinking more in detail. We're trying to go a little bit and have a longer conversation. I've got a lot of questions around it and just don't need to take time tonight about it, but just education to me a little bit and what are we trying to achieve here and I have some thoughts, but I just... Sorry, we're talking about the mandatory park west center? The document, the prospectus, yes. It's really long. So that would be my...
2:22:10 Initial. It's not inspiring or exciting. Can I ask a Brown Act question? Is it possible for us, you may not have an answer for this, but is it possible for us in a process like this, Rich gives us a document? Is it possible? Because I would love to hear Brent's feedback. Is there any way for Brent to give written feedback to Rich where we can all listen but not say anything on it? Is that...
2:22:45 That starts to get into serial. He said to you, and then he says to you, that's serial. So the only way for that to work is if that goes into public record. Now you can talk to Brent, but then you cannot talk to a quorum. Then you can't come talk to Tom about it. I'm just thinking digitally by email. If somebody's feeding comments back, it's useful if we all see those comments.
2:23:16 And we can see those comments, but it would have to be in a public meeting. Yeah. Yeah. I was going to say, his comments will be reflected in any document that comes back out, but... That's fine. Yeah. Just curious. Let me explore the options. You know, it would make sense that the digital box, sometimes we all enter it at the same time. Can we answer the question, though, for Brent, the purpose of the prospectus? This came out of the communications and fundraising discussions, having a document.
2:23:47 of this kind for each project that we're out there looking to generate some revenue on and having a description of the project, having goals and objectives of the project, what it's going to be, what it's going to look like. This is intended to, if somebody says, I want to donate, and you say, okay, great, well, here's what is going on with Mammoth Creek Park West project, and here's what's going on with the map, and here's what's going on with
2:24:16 However many other perspectives on this. We've got environmental review going on, which is looking at alternative sites, and they haven't given a final version on that, so we're doing a project on a perspective so that we don't have a final on, so there's a lot of little things that don't quite tie together to me, and just trying to make sure we're spending richest time in a productive way. The purpose of the process was to begin to create a template and say, this is the proper template we want to use.
2:24:42 We've got a frame we can begin to put some meat on the bones off. We're not ready to go to sale yet, but at least we've got some things in the shoe ready to roll. Yeah, and for me, just to make a general comment, I'm looking for a sales pitch. I'm looking for, I love you. That's why I'm looking to change. This is why I want to be there. I think the voice and the portion is there, but I just don't know if we're...
2:25:06 We're kind of like, we're getting there, but we're kind of getting a template. I may be jumping ahead because until we have stuff, it may not be fair to jump into that. So I'm just trying to be cautious. Am I getting too much into it before we're there? Well, I think they're parallel right now. And this was the furthest one, farthest one down the road, or Mammoth Creek Park West is the farthest project.
2:25:29 For potential implementation down the road that a prospectus will be used for. So that's why it's the demonstration. It's the one that we're being focused on. But it is parallel. And I want $5,000 to make a nice video because I already have a video in my head of how to promote this. I was just saying, donate it and you can make whatever video you'd like to. I think the whole thing is highest something. We can have a whole lot of fun with this. All right, so you're going to... Any other comments you got on the prospectus? I'd make one comment just that...
2:25:59 Kind of marries your two comments about it being kind of wordy and long and words about wanting a sales piece and be kind of moved is perhaps we need kind of two pieces and understand a cycle, right? A kind of funnel, if you will, in my language, in marketing, right? How you pull someone in at the top of the funnel and they just get what they need to get to the next step. They get inspired, they get...
2:26:27 They're interested. They get the basics of the plan. They get kind of the aspirational, what's this going to do for the community? How can you be a part of it? What will your money bring? And then you drive them as they are interested to the more mundane pieces of the larger business plan. That's why you have a website, too. I'm not necessarily saying we need two print kind of assets. Maybe we do. It depends on how we're going to, what kind of outreach we're looking at.
2:26:56 Just putting it out there that maybe we don't need an all-size, you know, a one-size-fits-all kind of print solution that we just dump everything we've got into and that that's our outbound piece. But until we just pull this option, we're not going to do that. Yeah. But it was, I mean, it was clear the other night that, and there's reference in this prospectus, because I recognize this language from the town website.
2:27:27 There's reference to due diligence on three or four different occasions, but there's no due diligence presented. And I know that shouldn't go in the sales pitch, but at some point, it would be so great to be able to say to a contingent of people who were dead set against the project, hey, here's the due diligence. Like, here are the alternatives that have been, and then, you know, maybe they aren't going to read it. I mean, that's been the answer that the town has given me.
2:27:52 But at least to know that it's there, it's well presented, it's accessible, the work's been done. So that whether you're a stakeholder or you're a neighbor concerned about it or you're a potential investor, wherever you are, you can go through the bones of the project right as it is, where it stands. Some of those decisions have been made or mandated by town council because there still seems to be quite a bit of confusion on that. And I see that to be referenced in a document like this.
2:28:23 But I see, you know, why am I, the LA Kings, even talking to you? No, I totally agree. It is two different things. I mean, trying to bring stakeholders or people who are resistant to a project over and you're already, they're already informed or misinformed, whatever the case may be. That's one thing, but talking to somebody
2:28:49 Like the LA Kings, you know, who has a very different investment in the project or not about giving money. Do you really have one document that does all of these different things? No, and I'm concerned about already going down the road too far with the, you know, the idea of coming up with a, you know, you can buy the seats for this amount and that before we even have a budget for the project and before you've offered it to the big ticket.
2:29:17 I mean, if you've got some NHL team or some, you know, Annenberg Foundation or some massive investor who's like, yeah, I love the vision of the high altitude training thing and I'm going to pay for that. And you've already outlined this like nickel and dime, you know, and you've already sold the board for $250, you've kind of lost.
2:29:38 So maybe the prospectus is a due diligence document that we're talking about, and then there's that, as you said, there's that sales document. And I think the one, the larger one has to go first. I think we're on the right track. I think that full fleshed out kind of articulation of the project and why it's worthwhile is the first piece. And then you scale down to that. For your other uses. Our first priority is the business plan.
2:30:08 For MLR's business plan. Well, and then I think that that informs the way we would want to approach the Mammoth Creek project is that you say, look, we need those same elements in the Mammoth Creek project. We need to see a full business plan. What is a multi-use facility? All these questions that are getting raised and not necessarily answered should be answered.
2:30:32 Whether it's a print document or it's an online thing. But the thing I see now is our challenge is going to be having certain dollars to allocate for certain things and how to regenerate some of that money so we can get that next step. And we're going to have to, I think, do some fundamental fundraising to have some dollars to say, Rich, you need to go down and do this. Because otherwise we put him in a box and I don't know how he's getting out of that box. No, it's, this is the, these are the hard won steps right now. I mean, we're trying to, this is template stuff. I mean, once we,
2:30:59 Once we get through to the other side of one of these exercises, then you have a template for every other one that comes down the road. If we were raising funds right now, unrestricted funds, and could put some of that to get you resources, we could expedite this process without question, but it's not where we are right now. So I think we're marching along as best we can. But I think that's an excellent point, and maybe that's the part of the business plan, of our business plan, that needs to be worked on first in order to justify
2:31:29 This idea that, I mean, you've got people who put $250 into it. I can't think of one person who's going to put $250 into MLR as it stands. But if you can articulate why that $250 is going to lead to these great things for the community, then you're on the right track, I think, with the business plan. Does that make sense? Makes sense. I mean, so that we can raise those unrestricted funds. But as it is right now, we haven't yet done that sales pitch to make it make sense to...
2:31:58 There's a car course thing going on right now that's difficult, and it's just, those are the problems of founding an organization. Or we need to look at how we dedicate things so we can classify it in a certain way so we can spend certain ways. Yeah, and that's one of the things I brought up at Rec Commission today is, you know, at this meeting, it was stated that here's, we have the money to build this basic building, but if we want it to be something more than that basic building, MLR, you know, where are you going to bring, what are you going to bring forward? Well, how are we,
2:32:28 Going to, you know, sell that embellishment to, you know, make that a better project. And, um, I also asked at the rec commission meeting to bring back what the policies are and what the process is for naming rights and things like that. And have you, because this is still a town facility, so that becomes an issue as well. There's no policy. So. It's on my list. You look at that picture I sent you guys when I'm doing that.
2:32:56 My Sunday communicated the picture of all the projects we're working on right now. You know, what's the priority? One is town policy and naming rights. Working with Scott Morgan. He's got something in Douglas County that he's sending down to me. We'll modify that to look at what it looks like, bringing that to you guys, but it's one of the many projects we're working on. Is the town working on their naming policy? I asked it to come back to our next rec commission meeting. So isn't the town doing that? The town does not have a naming rights policy. No, they don't.
2:33:26 Let's go and look at, well, I don't want to debate it because there was a discussion about names of humans. Many years ago there was, yeah. People. But it never got any, never got traction on it. You know, the whole concept of town policy on intellectual property. You know, we're working right now with a small group just on photos. Who's got the photo library? Who's got the rights for photos? What do they live so we can access them? MLT, MLTPA? Where's the library for that stuff?
2:33:54 How do we access, that's all town property, it's public money's been spent on those. How do we access that stuff? The whole concept of intellectual property, naming rights, sponsorships, we don't have that package. Is the town attorney working with you on that? Relative to naming rights down the road? Because that's a... And so just to, I did ask for it to come back to our recognition meeting, so we'll see what comes back as far as those policies go on that.
2:34:22 But so as we're developing this brand new strategy with a fast track, you know, 18 months to build in an ice rink. Well, that was my concern today. But so just, again, imagining the Trails End Park scenario happening again. If we had sort of three options, you know, here's what we can do for $2.1 million with what we have. Here's what we can do for $4.5 million. Here's what we can do for $7.
2:34:48 Then we can begin to build a sales package that says, hey, wouldn't we rather do it at 4.5? And in order to do that, we're going to have to, here's the gap we've got to raise. Yeah. And I asked that today, and I was pretty much told that it's going to be March or, no, probably. When was, did you recall what it was said? Because it's basically, it needs to go down the road until next.
2:35:09 It's way down the road before we're going to have something. Because I said, well, we're going to need to have a rendition that says, this is what it's going to be if we just go with what the town has right now. This is what it's going to look like if we have and we raise this amount of money. When are we going to have that information? When can we do that? And really, what I got is we're going to have two or three months, maybe, to bring that forward and out. Because there aren't any other comparable ice rinks in the country.
2:35:37 Yeah, yeah, I don't know, but that was the information that I got today because it was a real huge concern of mine is, you know, how can we be moving down this rapid speed and you're putting MLR out there and saying, well, this is what we're going to have unless MLR comes up with something else, but we don't have anything for MLR to go out and sell to make this embellished project. All right.
2:36:03 Can I back up one more? Yeah, please. Go back to Richardson and where we want certain things because we all followed with the Yosemite Valley and the former Awani. Are we trademarking our logo? We will now. I mean, it is trademarked. All right. I want to go, sorry, because we're, yeah, come back to this because we had, so the prospectus, but there's also,
2:36:35 I guess we're presuming that the Recreation Commission is taking on some of these issues related to the process that we're in the middle of as far as getting alternatives back out and all of that because we're not driving that. We're not driving alternatives. We're not in that seat to drive alternatives. So the town staff who's got the project management of this, they're the ones developing alternatives. They are met at this point in time based on public input.
2:37:04 They'll bring something back on March 18th based on the feedback they heard last Friday night. At that point in time, we'll make a recommendation in early April to town council about a preferred alternative site that they will be... A site, but not a project itself. To the point that was made, here's the $2 million project, here's the $5 million, here's the $10 million project. Conceptual designs have not been done just yet. That's not going to be probably until later on in the spring, early summer. I heard as late as October, and that was Terry's comment.
2:37:33 Now you're backing us into the corner, MLR, as the fundraising agent to support these projects. We have very limited time. So how do we begin to put pieces in place that are so rough around the edges, begin those conversations so when things do come down the road, we've got some things in place that we can execute fairly quickly. We're not hustling at the last minute. Well, I think that's great to that effect that you are working on this prospectus.
2:38:00 Are speaking with the Kings. We're trying to be ahead of it as much as possible. As we should be, because we're not going to be able to do it in one year. And that's the conversation that Stu, Betsy, and I had lunch today. What do I got to do? What are we doing? Who's working where? What do we do well? Who's talking? We've got to be in firmness. We have a lot of work to do, and it's going to sneak up on us real quick. And we're unfortunately in the position where, as we talk about kind of idealizing,
2:38:30 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:39:00 You've got to have a prospectus that you can hand off next week. Something that's iterative and that will work for now that's better a month later, that's better a month later, that's better a month later. Exactly. And has Stu been able to help you on the demand analysis and locally and outside of the region? Who's likely to use this? The number of visitors? Because I see that a lot of partners we're putting down, but it'll be useful if those partners, like Mammoth Hockey Club...
2:39:28 You can actually help us put detail in here about how many competitions they'd expect to be holding, how many people they could bring, and put some bit more meat around the future of the ice rink. We've got in here that it's pretty much flat at 7,000 people, but how are we going to grow it? How are we going to make it into an attraction that serves the community, and that's where the public funds come from, but also how are we going to grow the ice rink into a visitor destination to make it enticing for people to come and use it, for the 1.5 million people that come here every year?
2:39:57 How many of those are going to go to the rink? How are we going to make money out of the rink, the concessions? And that's the excitement that the expertise that this board brings to the table. A group of people in this room can see the future. We can pull people into the future. A lot of people can't do that. You ask them what's going on. They're good here and now. Help me write a business plan. Project what you're going to do with tournaments. What does that look like?
2:40:19 That's tough for a lot of people, guys. Especially because, I mean, so many of these paragraphs in this why this project needs to happen end with escalating costs, right? But there's no projection of what, I mean, how are we not going down the same road the third time around? We're focusing on the community aspect, and I think the town is focusing on, we need one of these ice rinks because everyone here wants one. That's not going to make the ice rink work. Right, right. And then, so, go on. Go ahead.
2:40:47 I was just going to say we had that conversation at the rec commission today because we're going over programming and, you know, the subsidy and, you know, how that's being discussed and, you know, at the municipal level it is a matter of we're providing community benefit and that community benefit needs to be heavily subsidized. And I said, okay, well that's fine and I think that's great if we're bringing a community benefit but we can't keep building things.
2:41:16 At this huge subsidy, because you're never going to be able to move any further than this one facility. So we need to look at these facilities and how, and not just programming for a community, but how are we going to program this so that it actually can bring some other monies in so we can subsidize it and we can have a quality experience for our community at a low cost. And we can, you know, build on that benefit by having tournaments, by having what do we need to do.
2:41:45 To drive that facility to be successful beyond just being a community. Because otherwise we can't do that. You know, because that, you know, basically that's what we were looking at there is just looking at that community benefit and that's the programming. And so they're looking at putting a group together for that programming and, you know, who's sitting in that group.
2:42:13 You know, I threw Mammoth Lakes Tourism into that, too. So, you know, we need to look at what the full potential is of the programming and what the needs are. Especially as we're very difficult for Rich or any of us to go out to get sponsorship for money based on a $250,000 package. What are they going to get back? Just putting a name on an ice ring that stays flat at 7,000 people, they're going to withdraw that money pretty quickly. They need to see that they're getting a benefit from it.
2:42:41 So we have to show them there's a clear plan of how we're going to enhance the facility. Yeah, but the only thing I say with all that is I devil is with Teddy for a long time on a sign that's out front and no one has complained about putting money into that sign.
2:42:54 Did you complain about it? I didn't. I didn't support it. It was a lot of money. Mr. Chair, let's close number six. Thank you. Thank you. I meant to be able to put money that paid for a block of air. Yeah, but I think the point is that what MLR is trying to do, I think, is what we're attempting to do, is I use this term a lot. We're trying to challenge this assumption.
2:43:16 This isn't just about a community benefit or a community amenity. There is growth potential with this facility that we're talking about here. What does that look like? And getting out of our rut of just looking at here, but looking at it this way. Community investment. Yes. There it is. Community investment, but also a growth opportunity beyond just... A true investment. A true investment.
2:43:45 This is a learning curve for a lot of people who have not been used to doing business this way. And MLR is trying to, I think, push it a little bit. We're going to run into resistance. We're going to run into nobody having the information. Gary, your point, where is the market demand analysis? It has never been done.
2:44:04 We're going to be running into those types of situations. But if we're not asking the questions, we're going to find ourselves five years from now with a facility that is accommodating 3,500 people a year, and we're all satisfied with it. I don't think that's where we want to be. I don't think that's what we're continuing to do here. So I'm saying that because this is new territory for this community, and MLR is in the middle of this, and we're going to have to help guide everybody through this and be a part of it. Does that make sense?
2:44:34 So, Rich, on the prospectus, you're going to come back to us and route it to us and we'll take a look at it. Business plan is number one. I appreciate that you can add that these prospectus literally are iterative. Today it works. Tomorrow there'll be new information that'll change it and it'll change accordingly and it will continue to change as the information comes along. But let's get our business plan first and then prospectus comes along as well. It's still a couple months out, but let's get some new stuff. But it is one of the reasons that, at least in conceptual terms, we're thinking of
2:45:05 The website as this iterative space where we can post it on a weekly basis. And the caveat there is that we can't do rough drafts online because it's published and it's public. So, you know, let's, you know, we just need to keep it to what's actually, you know, we can't be putting up rough draft, you know, funding plans or anything like that. But we can do, you know, here's what happened last week and here's what we know so far and here's the timeline.
2:45:34 And as it changes, check back in. Yeah, and here's the one page. Sign up, get excited, hand out, and the rest gets updated online. Yeah. All right. All right. Moving on back to item number five, consider approving engagement with the Winter Recreation Summit and taking a leading role in producing the event. At your workstation, there is a brief outline of what the Winter Recreation Summit is.
2:46:05 When the trail system master plan was approved and put in place, there was a recommendation in there to conduct these winter and summer summits around pertinent topics related to our trail system. And we are now at a point where this is of a need for a couple of reasons. So I want to just take you through this really quick. What we're asking for is MLR's, you're okay.
2:46:35 for MLR's participation in a leading role in this. There's a steering committee that has already been put together that includes representatives from the town. MLR is at the table and MLTPA is at the table. We've got feedback from the Forest Service on this. General public is going to be invited to participate as well as
2:46:58 Enthusiasts from around the country and around the region who would like to participate. If you remember the comment that was made up here about our public lands are just that, public lands, and so my Aunt Ethel in Maine has every interest in what's going on out here, and she can come out and participate in this. So this is open to anybody who's interested in what's going on regarding to our public lands. We've got four clear focuses on this. First of all,
2:47:25 Looking at implementation of our trail system master plan, creating a public awareness for the Forest Service OSV, over snow vehicle, subpart C planning process at their beginning. There's been dialogue about how this summit could help them receive some information back from participants on their planning process.
2:47:48 We want to look at a community dialogue that is focused on our winter recreation use and the opportunities that we have for enhancing that. And then looking at using these different tracks to identify some potential policy and or budget recommendations that could be used by decision makers in the future. So for instance, down here under these list of tracks, there's one in here that is
2:48:17 Winter Transit. And if you imagine the track is going to talk about how do we move around in this community. And there's the potential for input to be received that may go back to ESTA and say, we think you should expand your winter service to this particular area. And that's information that could be taken back to ESTA for them to use for making a budget and or scheduling decision. So that's what I mean by
2:48:42 Budget and policy decisions up here that there's information to be gathered that could go back and help inform some future decisions. There are these nine tracks that have been put together for this session or for this week summit or weekend summit. We're talking about winter recreation up in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. This really has to do with the Tamarack accessibility, the public accessibility and kind of the
2:49:09 Issues that are being raised up there with who's using what and when and how and the opportunities for helping to address some of those issues through a collaborative process between the town, the Forest Service and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Number two is winter recreation and shady rest and this has to do with the staging.
2:49:29 OSB staging area process that the agency began a few years ago, agency being the Forest Service, and what's going on out there with our winter recreation, grooming, etc. Forest Service, OSB, we just talked about snow play opportunities in Mammoth Lakes. This is something that shows up on MLR's list of responsibilities, but identifying and...
2:49:52 Considering what type of infrastructure might be needed in some of these snow play areas and how can we achieve these and what's the public feedback on that. Looking at our snow culture in Mammoth Lakes, when you're walking your dog, are you picking up after yourself? And if you are on a pair of Nordic skis and you encounter a snowmobile, how do you get, you know, what are we doing? So what does our etiquette look like here in this community?
2:50:17 Thinking about number six, reliable information and where people are getting their information about our winter recreation in this community. What are all the resources? Is it efficient? Is it effective? Are we missing something? We're looking also at winter fat biking in Mammoth Lakes. And in fact, tonight, right now, they're out at Sierra Star riding out there through an agreement that Sierra Star provided them. But are there opportunities to integrate fat biking into our winter recreation in Mammoth?
2:50:45 Number eight is winter transit, very specific to how we get around in this community. And then number nine is very specific to the town and their needs for mobility. So for instance, you guys are seeing that they are removing snow off of the Lake Mary bike path from Canyon up to Kelly Road. So the question is going to be to the public, do you want to see it removed down to the asphalt? Do you want to see it packed?
2:51:12 Do you want to see it not removed at all? Let's start having a dialogue for how we use our existing infrastructure for getting people to move around, whether it's for recreation purposes or literally getting from the grocery store back to your home. How are we looking at our mobility and how we're moving around? So if you imagine these tracks, we're going to have presentations by those interested parties for each of these areas as soliciting feedback and input from the public.
2:51:40 establishing some notes and formatting some recommendations to move forward. We've got already confirmed a keynote. Luis Benitez from the Colorado Office of Outdoor Recreation has agreed to come out and be one of our keynote speakers. His office was the second one formed in the country after the state of Utah formed theirs. And we've got Luis coming out to give us a
2:52:08 An overview of our sustainable recreation movement, kind of along the lines of this, but on a much broader scale. He was just over in Europe a week ago at the Europe, it's in Germany, it's their version of the SIA show, the SIA show, and he's over there talking sustainable recreation and promoting Colorado as a destination for winter recreation.
2:52:35 Recreation as a whole, but promoting Colorado as a destination for recreation, not just users, but manufacturers, researchers, all kinds of stuff. So he's on the road promoting it. He's got a worldview, and he's willing to come here and share that with us. We've also extended an invitation to the POW folks to see if they would want to come here and talk about climate change and weatherproofing.
2:52:57 Our efforts in Mammoth Lakes and getting to learn what they're doing out there as a big movement. Building an ice track in case it doesn't snow. There you go. With the roof on it so that if it does snow, you can still use it. So there you have it. We're looking here at MLR's role in this effort. Participate and provide support for the steering committee.
2:53:22 We've been assigned through the steering committee three presentations or three tracks that fall into MLR's scope, the snow play, the snow culture, and the reliable information sharing. Also looking at MLR's role in helping to promote the summit to various stakeholders outside and in the industry outside who want to be a part of this, potentially secure sponsorship support, and also provide logistical support, meaning you might be asked to come and
2:53:52 Be the note taker for one of the sessions or be the greeter at the door for one of the sessions or be out and help provide one of the demonstrations that will be happening out at Shady Rest or out on the MUPS or out somewhere up in the Lakes Basin. So there'll be some volunteer opportunities as well as support for helping to produce the event. The budget for this is coming from, if you remember,
2:54:21 Coming from the trail system budget, there was $20,000 that had been allocated for the NEPA process for the OSB effort. That was originally put in there before the Inyo decided or moved into this OSB planning process. So the Inyo is not going to be using that $20,000 for NEPA because they're moving into
2:54:47 This very broader OSV planning process. So we have this $20,000 that we are able to reallocate to go towards helping to produce this event. And when we produce it, we've got
2:55:00 Helping to cover staff time for project management, helping to secure some promotional opportunities, helping to bring in some equipment for potential demonstrations. So that's where the funding, some initial funding is coming from to help support this winter summit. Is there a reason why this is just focused on winter and it's not... Because it's winter? Well, yes. And because we have a summer...
2:55:28 For OSB. It was for OSB. And that's over snow winter. Okay. Yeah. So it's very specific to coming back to the OSB. Yeah. And also note that the Trail System Master Plan does recommend a summer recreation summit also. And there's the opportunity to do that as well. And you can imagine that the focus on that would be things like SHARP.
2:55:50 And Sherwin Implementation up there. There would be trails development up in the Lakes Basin. There would be also mobility. How do we get around? How often are we clearing out the pine needles off of our trails? So there's that opportunity for a summer summit along the same way. Okay. I guess I was looking that if we're spending $20,000, maybe you could combine something. Yeah. Anyhow, it might be too much. Yeah.
2:56:19 Variety of places. We're looking at Suite Z to hold some of the sessions. We're looking at the Edison Theater to hold some of the sessions. We're looking at Chalkin and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area about some of the sessions. Tamarack potentially as a location, the little restaurant in there for a session. So we're looking at kind of placing it at various spots, the Forest Service Auditorium as a session also. How many people do you think?
2:56:48 What are you going to get, hopefully? Well, hundreds. So have you got an outreach plan ready to get them? Outreach plan is being developed to go out as well. Who's the lead on this? It's a combination of the town, first of all, because a lot of these fall into their needs in that. So the town, and we're working with the public works department in that.
2:57:13 As well as the Town Manager's Office is providing support for that. MLTPA as the contractor for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and the role that they play. And MLR right now are the three that are the leads on that. And we're talking to MLT about some assistance for marketing efforts and some outreach, looking at tapping into their PR firm to see about helping to get some placements out there on
2:57:42 You know, some coverage for it. So we're soliciting MLT support as well. And Joel is really the project lead on this. Joel, as the trails coordinator, is he and I would put he and Hayes and MLTPA, the three of them. They're really producing them. They're really the, they're, they are serving as points, you know, points of contact. So yes, they have that responsibility. Well, who would you say is producing them? The three.
2:58:11 The town, MLTPA, MLR. Grady's chair of the steering committee at this point in time. I would say the chief sponsor on this really is the town of Mammoth. The town. So they are the, like I said, a lot of these are directly related to their efforts and to their needs and things like demonstrations on our MUPS and Lakes Basin and Shady Rest. Those are all town.
2:58:45 This group's convening consistently Mondays at 4 o'clock for about 90 minutes, kind of sort stuff out. The goal is to have the final draft by Monday, next Monday. You get a press release out and begin the marketing piece on this, so things are tight. So, a couple of things. The target is obviously community members, you know, locally because, you know, you're living in it every day.
2:59:07 But number two, our visitors who are coming up here. How are they interfacing with our recreation product? What's their experience like when they hop on the trolley? What's their experience like when they want to go out and ride their snowmobile out at Shady Rest? What does that look like? What's their experience when they're trying to find a snow play area for their kids? And so we're looking to tap into the visitors. We've also got interest from national groups who are very...
2:59:31 Interested in the whole OSB planning process, and so they're looking to be here and participate in that as well. So, you know, we say hundreds, that's kind of the focus. And we want a good, we were hoping to get a good community turnout because this really is about, you know, how we recreate, but also getting that visitor input is equally, if not more important as well. It should be great for the future to have somewhere around Christmas time when there's just tons of service here who, the number of...
3:00:00 People who come up to you is asking for advice on where's the sledding, what do I do, how do I get chains. It'll be really good towards next time, beginning, towards the beginning of the season. Well, hopefully this, this, this session right here, reliable information and winter recreation, getting a feedback from where is that type of information being shared so that at Christmas time when those questions are being asked, there's...
3:00:23 The source put in place to help answer them. Is your parents just volunteer to help you with that session? Gary's going to do that. I was going to stand at the bottom of two or three, actually. Take one less thing off my plate. Point here. Just like a snowboard and all. $30, I'll put them on, fundraise for MLR. Maybe there's something that, there's some type of survey that can be sent out to our guests.
3:00:49 Well, that's talking to MLT. We've talked about using – and that's – Terry, thanks. It's a good point. That's what I'm watching. I have an email list that I emailed last to. And that's a really – thanks for bringing that up because that's – there's a lot of pieces to this, but one piece is to prepare the public for their participation and to actually garner information up front to help shape the presentations also using some surveys to –
3:01:16 Solicit that feedback for things like getting around in snow, getting some feedback. How do you do this? Where do you go? What do you do? How do you access it? So that as Hayes and his team are putting this together, they're receiving information up front. There's a lot of tapping into databases that we're going to be looking at. The Lodging Association, the Chamber of Commerce playing a role in this, MLT playing a role also. The Lodging Association is going to have a meeting.
3:01:49 The end of the month. Good. We're going to tap into that soon. Soon. Yeah. The next two weeks we need to do a couple of stakeholder meetings to prep for this recreation center. Yeah. So what we wanted to put in front of you, a couple of things. Work's already begun, so before getting too far ahead on this, we want to bring it back to you to make sure that, get your feedback. Are you okay with this? Are you willing to participate in this? And are you okay with MLR playing a role in this?
3:02:19 I will say that it is the weekend of the biathlon. It was a conscious decision to put it on this weekend and realizing that biathlon is kind of a morning activity and those who are here in town can participate in the summit activities in the afternoon if they're not competing. And so we don't think that it's going to deter one over the other. There's not going to be a negative impact. I wonder just as a comment.
3:02:49 What might be, I think it's super exciting with a general note. It seems like a lot of these things on this track list are kind of very local, very kind of policy wonkish stuff that's interesting to me, but not necessarily the general user. But if it builds up, I mean, a lot of these things work is you do that stuff during the day, the heavy sessions with the town gathering information, and then have sort of
3:03:14 You know, you've got the keynote ideas, which are great, and I think the sort of Winter Without Snow is one of the main, you know, big sort of keynote panels that will bring the public in. Another one is, I mean, as John brought up, I think another panel possibility for an evening attractive session, general public, would be just a conversation about the state of public lands, you know, what's it saying?
3:03:38 What's going down in the context of what's been happening over the last couple months. Yeah. I think that's a really one, because we've extended this to POW, and if they're not even making it, we have an opportunity to, you know, change that. Somebody from POW will be here. You can help on that, because we're having that dialogue with them right now. And I think this is, it's not covered in here, but one of the original...
3:04:05 Premise for this, well, I guess it does, it's a community dialogue, but it really, it's intended to kind of expand our awareness of our recreation product and how our public lands are a big part of our recreation experience here and how are we as a community and how are we as visitors, you know, connecting with these public lands and interfacing with it and what are the issues that are impacting it? So that's a good topic.
3:04:34 For that. And if you guys remember 2007, Jeff Olson, those of you who were here in 07, Little Eagle, Jeff Olson talking about trails. Room full of people. Big room full of people. And the inspiration for that was doing a trail system master plan update. That's kind of what I'm envisioning. Is that type for some of these sessions and some of those keynotes that it's bringing people in to
3:05:03 You know, talk about things that we don't always talk about and what's going on in the real world. Questions? More questions? Yeah, so a couple different ones. So it looks like when I say it's a Winter Recreation Summit, so it's really a Mammoth Winter Recreation Summit. Yeah, it says Mammoth Winter Recreation Summit. Yeah. Yeah. No, but the goal is local because you start off with the premise that it's really a local focus though for this summit that's coming in.
3:05:31 Yeah. I think that's the same point John was making, that even the local conversations, because they're not public lands, have a national interest. Yeah, can have a resonance for people from elsewhere. Yeah, it's not really a pertinent conversation partially, but is, you know, I don't know if you've done it, Tom, is Mammoth fully involved in this? I'm assuming so, but... Mammoth's been involved at various stages of this, and they're being...
3:05:55 Being integrated into more of these. So for instance, the Lakes Basin, that's stemming off of conversations that have already been occurring between the mountain and the town and the Forest Service and MLR and others. And that was really related back to the steering committee because they weren't mentioned in part of the steering committee so I didn't know where the role might or might not be there. And just pursuant to our conversation earlier with Dan, I was looking at our cost and saying, is this an appropriate cost?
3:06:25 I don't mean total, but are we spending this money correctly? Got it. But we're also got on this task list things that aren't there. Are those really all in there? Is it town owned and managed? Sorry, I'll just come back to what we discussed before. And it would seem appropriate that this would be general funds supported as well. And the town is putting in their...
3:06:55 I would call it in-kind at this time. In-kind, yeah. They haven't, they have not put any additional cash into it, but it's definitely in-kind. And it was in the Matt McClain's committee, approved by the committee at that point in time. Grady Dutton is the acting town manager. Right. He was fully supported by the public. So, other questions? Comments? Kind of exciting to think about the summit.
3:07:21 And Mammoth. And we're getting, we're getting in, like I said, we're getting interest from outside of the area who, you know, want to come in and be a part of those conversations. So, did I answer your question? I don't know if I understood. Did I understand what you were asking about Mammoth, why this is a Mammoth Winter Recreation Summit? Did I? Well, you kind of addressed that before. I was, I would just make a point going reverse-wise in terms of, my point really is come back to the dollars there and what was being the dollars spent for from that standpoint. But, last thing, and just, I don't want to get sidetracked, but.
3:07:52 This kind of goes back to our business plan and saying, okay, now we've got a winter summit coming up that I've heard about in the last two weeks, but that's it. And also I've got something new that's on there that we didn't put as a priority within our documentation. So all of a sudden now we're doing a winter recreation summit, which I think is great. It's in our business plan. Sorry? It's in our business plan. Advocacy. Advocacy, it is. I know, but it just wasn't my forefront. And I appreciate that it might bring business to town. So I think it's a good potential business. I'm just going back to...
3:08:21 Okay, if we're supposed to be kind of highlighting where we want to be, we've got to control the direction versus responding to the direction. Well, that's how we're coming to you. You have every ability to say no, and MLR can stop its engagement with this process right now and let the town and MLTPA handle it. Well, I think it also makes more to what I take to be Brent's point. I think this also helps inform, as we're writing up this business plan.
3:08:49 It is in the business plan. It needs to be clearer. It needs to be more precise. And this is a great example of what we can do as advocates as part of our business plan.
3:08:59 So I would just say, I would say the business plan. So your point is that there's something else now on his plate to have to engage with. That's the only point. It's not necessarily a bad thing. No, no, no. That's not my point. But that's why it's coming back. It's just that it's now we're saying, Rich, go jump over this bridge. It's coming back. That's why we brought it here to you guys to see, you know, are you okay with this? Because this is going to take up some time, both Rich and Leslie Ann.
3:09:29 To engage with this and take on some of these responsibilities. Are you okay with that? I mean, it's one thing for the... I've been asking that question on the trails committee, and the answer that I've heard is that MLTPA, the town, and Joel Rathji are doing the bulk of that, and that Rich is in a secondary support role, and that we are in a secondary support role. And that, to me personally, I think we can support that as long as it's something rich. We're leaving three workshops. We met on Monday for the define these for me, so I'm going to be with the group in the next couple days.
3:10:00 You know, for us to do this, if you look at an hour workshop, 15 minutes kickoff and then engagement, and I've got to meet with a group of stakeholders once or twice prior to that, I'm going to need a little more support, guys, because I've got some other projects on my plate now. But it's doable. We'll make it work. Yeah, Joel and the town are pretty much the leads on it. And Hayes very specifically with the town. And Pam Kobylarz is also providing support. And what does the $20,000 do? All the...
3:10:29 Supplies that are going to be needed, the outreach and communication, the promotional materials that go with that. And like I said, the $20,000 has been reallocated. How much of it gets used, the budget is still being finalized also for that as well. That's our major. Out of the Mammoth Trails budget. You'd like to see us helping by being at some of these. Yeah.
3:11:02 Yeah, and helping to, you know, like you said, be the person to get people to register. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, you know, sell the MLR hats, you know, at the summit and all that kind of thing. And thanks, Rich. There are some social elements to this as well throughout the weekend. There will definitely be some social, you know, parts that go with it. So looking for any, you know, your feedback and or are you okay with this and, you know,
3:11:31 To continue moving forward and playing the role that MLR is playing at this time. And I do think it's a great opportunity for us to continue to make an appearance with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and maybe making some new connections or partnerships. And talking about Green Park West and just other opportunities on the side. I will say that the list...
3:11:59 for the potential tracks was longer. It did include things like the ice rink and a few others and it got whittled down because ice rink is doing its own thing right now and there's a couple other processes that were on here that have lives of their own right now. So this did get whittled down to what was most manageable and most pertinent and in front of us right now.
3:12:28 It does seem like, as a trick, I'm in winter without snow. I have that discussion. Alternatives to... I know it's down as a...
3:12:41 It's down as a keynote, and we did actually have it up above as a trap, so something changed a little bit. There's a conversation that occurred that I wasn't privy to, but something changed, which is fine. So when this is all done, what will be produced? So Brent asked a really good question, and I think this is the nexus, or the...
3:13:05 The whole point. So let's take a look at winter recreation in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. As an example, what will be produced out of that is the potential solution for taking to the Forest Service. Here is, through a collaborative process that included all of the stakeholders and public input, here are some recommended solutions for addressing the issues that are being faced up in the lakes basin. Literally a document that would be generated.
3:13:31 To be submitted. When we look at winter recreation and shady rest, the same thing. Here are some issues that are being faced out there. Here are some recommendations and solutions. There are some of these that, like for instance, the OSV, that's not going to be us. That's going to be public feedback provided to the Forest Service to help inform their planning process. Who's going to write up those recommendations and deliver at the end?
3:13:54 The staff that's participating, mostly the town, Joel and Hayes. Joel and Hayes will put the information. Exactly. And so if you think about the snow culture, we called this, at one time we called it snow etiquette, but coming up with, here, town of Mammoth Lakes, here's how we play in the wintertime. Here's how you interface with...
3:14:16 A dog walker, and a Nordic skier. Here's where you pick up. So it's intended that for those that have specific recommendations, that will be captured and put written up and submitted accordingly to the entities that are responsible for it. See, I want to put in there how to drive up Davidson for a town. Getting around the snow. Getting around the snow. All right. Any other comments or questions?
3:14:46 Public comments? Casey, did you want to say anything for that? Okay, great. Anything else? Are you guys, by consensus, are you okay with this? Yes. Just on sponsorship support, I don't know if I missed that one out there, that's presumably going to local businesses and hotels and stuff I'm trying to get. Yep, I'm going to try and get some local support, somebody to help, like with the reception, if we have a reception, somebody to help underwrite that.
3:15:11 So I would say it would be helpful once those materials are produced in draft form before posters are printed. If we have a little lead time and you send that out to us and kind of give us some ballpark sponsorship levels, I might be able to help with that. Awesome. Then we'll follow up with you immediately. We'll be going to papers, radio, our website, et cetera, et cetera, social. Yeah, so all those communication channels to get that access. And like I said, you guys, there's been two meetings.
3:15:42 We've had one, two, and so it's, you know, all still being, yeah, it is. Yep, so, and my, my portion is, I agree, go forward, I do, do have a little bit of concern just in terms of what we have available for staff and where we're trying to spread ourselves. That's just my caution. Again, we're secondary. Yep, but I just know how, I know how it gets. But it's a good point. Yep, no, no, it's a very good point. It's, it's a very good point. All right, anything else on this one?
3:16:07 Okay, then let's move on to the outdoor events venue. Oh, excuse me. Let's phone number seven based on the previous conversation. Recommend we move on. So we're going to, so just so you guys know, we did at the Executive Committee approve that recommendation, but based on the conversation that we had, we'll come back to you with a different recommendation. So we will table that, number seven. Outdoor events venue. Okay. Okay, so first of all, I'd say that
3:16:38 Great job Rich and Leslie did because it's only started about four weeks ago and within that time frame we've managed to get from 38 possible sites down to top three really in both short and long term. To do so we rely quite heavily on a study that was done before 2013. This was an outdoor, it's called HVS, it's a consulting group that specialised in outdoor event centres.
3:17:06 And a lot of money was spent by the town council at the time, and I'm sure you remember David. And it was largely sort of put on the back burner. But we brought it back out because it was very objective. It was 97 pages long, not a ranking criteria that went into that. We sort of mimicked in the matrix that you have in front of you here. And then we also did our own grading as well. So we compare how we were grading it against how they graded it as one of the objective qualifications. It was a very transparent.
3:17:33 Process. We had a steering committee meeting on the Wednesdays followed by all the stakeholders on Thursday morning and that started off at like 42 people came to the first meeting I think. So transparency was not an issue. I think everyone had a great chance to give their point which was keeping everyone informed with emails and with the matrix as it was being updated each week. A lot of time is spent actually with public comment during the process.
3:18:02 I don't know if you guys have all had a chance to look at it, but basically we narrowed it down really by the sort of third week to the top of one, two, three, four, five, six, eight, nine, ten. And then we looked at the ratings and the qualifications to see as objective as we could because there was a hell of a lot of subjective comment in this. For example, Bluza Palooza, Sean.
3:18:25 He was adamant about only one or two sites could work, other people wanted other sites, and we had to be careful not to sort of listen to Blues of Blues above everyone else, because it's a big festival, but at the same time it's one festival. So we had basically all criteria site considerations. The first thing was, was the site that we were looking at big enough to hold five to seven and a half thousand? If it wasn't, then it really had to be scrubbed up immediately, because the idea was...
3:18:54 Five to seven and a half thousand, three events a year at the time that it's going to be built. And if it didn't meet that criteria, we had to get rid of it. A couple of other things that... I'm sorry, I'm just kind of confused. Where did we come up with that number based on Looza Palooza? Actually, a lot of looking at the other sites around the country, Aspen, we looked at Idaho, we looked at a couple of the names of all these places now, we looked at a place in Colorado, and they all seem to be around that level, the outdoor amphitheater style.
3:19:22 Some of them also had the ability to turn it into an indoor stage during the winter, but we felt that at this point we had to look at three minimum events a year, big events around those size so we could actually pay for itself. I was going to say, to actually bring a name in that somebody's going to pay for to actually make something like this happen, you'd have to have some numbers like that. Yeah, yeah, and that's a minimum really. We'd like that to expand to over 10,000.
3:19:50 And so scalability was another key criteria. So down the side you have four criteria. Psych considerations and then some subcategories there. Urban impact, so obviously the effect it was going to have on neighbourhood relationships. Access, the place had to be accessible. And then financial considerations, cost, whether USFS will actually allow us to do it, that kind of thing. And then each one of these...
3:20:18 Categories and subcategories had a weighting of one to five. The weighting showed how important the ranking would be. So, for example, wind protection was a big issue with Mammoth Lakes Foundation. That could have wiped it out of consideration. It didn't in the end, but we had to look at it. If we couldn't abate wind, we couldn't have it there. Then we looked at each of the sites and we ranked them one to three in line with the HVS report.
3:20:44 And the first thing you see under each look at the BSP, which is, what was the BSP? I've forgotten. Belsier parcel. Belsier parcel. So the first capacity for recommended program building, three, which meant it could take five to seven and a half thousand. That was the, that was our grading. Then, sorry, that was the HVS grading. And the second grading was, was our own grading amongst the stakeholders. So we could see the disparity, which is the third number.
3:21:12 Just so we could see if we were following a very objective report against the local stakeholders and seeing how objective we could be. So, to cut to the chase really, if we can go through any of these categories you want to look at, I don't know if you had a chance to look at them yourself yet, but essentially what we ended up with was Mammoth Creek Park East as one of the viable long-term recommended sites, the snow pit,
3:21:44 which was also recommended as a short-term site, and we can get into that in a minute, and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. We ruled out places like Kennen Lodge for anything but short-term just because it's mountain-owned, and who knows what's going to happen with the mountain in three to five years, and plus they could pull the rights to do anything with it at any time, but we didn't have really any control on it long-term. The wood site for the same reason, short-term, but we're probably not going to buy it. Can we afford to buy it?
3:22:11 So it's short-term. But it's important that we had two short-term sites in there at least because we may have to really look at using short-term sites and doing a deal with Canyon until we can actually build this thing ourselves anyway. We ran into all kinds of problems with the USFS wanting to give us the change of permit, et cetera, et cetera, whether they want to do a land swap, how long that would take. So a whole number of derivatives came into this. So that was Mammoth Creek Park East? And so there were discussions that occurred with them?
3:22:40 Like the Forest Service? Well, they've intimated. One of the reasons why we didn't put the RV park east, for example, is USFS said they'd rather give us the rights to use something north of the 203 than south of the 203 on that one on that corridor. And they were at the table on all of this, or this was just other conversations, sidebar conversations? Yeah, conversations. So Mammoth Creek Park east, they have indicated that they would be willing to look at allowing us to use that.
3:23:07 Remember, these are recommendations for further study. They're not the sites. So things could change. But this at the moment is where we've got to. So I can go through individually each one and explain why we cut them out or not. But we can just start asking questions. So do you guys want to go through each one? Or do you have just some general questions? I have more started with general ones. Sorry. Go ahead.
3:23:36 HVS has done hospitality value systems, one of the top value systems people in the country, and they evaluate based on a number of different criteria. I'm sorry to say good or bad, but now we've got stakeholders that have come back and have a different list of criteria, some very, very similar, but some different. And things were ruled out, as I read through criteria, based on opposition, based on what I thought. What makes this a better document starting standpoint than what HVS did in the first place?
3:24:06 Basically, the HBS could only look, they looked at 13 sites, there were 38 sites we had to look at. So, the feeling after the HBS study was done and presented to the council, the council at the time, was apparently, well, they don't really understand Mammoth, we do, so we don't really want to use the report at that time. Disagree. HBS was focused on town-owned only? Was that clear? They were given 13 sites to look at, and there were 38 sites that the stakeholders wanted to talk about.
3:24:36 So, for whatever reasons, and you probably know more about it than I do from what happened in 2013, but we felt that there were certain criteria that they may not have looked at. I think they did a very good job, actually, very comprehensive, but the stakeholders felt there were certain things that they wanted to bring into the equation as well. In the criteria, Brian, there are already three modifications. From the HES? From the HES criteria, when you look at the four main areas, those are already three modifications.
3:25:06 Very little variance in those indicators that were used. The weighting changed a little bit, but not much for the most part. It was just an in-house group of people looking at the property from a mammoth-centric vision versus an external group. Yep. No, and Mark, one of my conversations is almost what was brought up earlier in regards to financing. We've got a group of stakeholders together, and we're looking at an event venue. You've got one of the premier...
3:25:33 Value people in the country looking at venues, size, location, and I'm just trying to make sure that we're heading down a road that qualifies as a way to look at sites and we're not just jumping into something because somebody has an emotional attachment to something over something else. There's actually reason behind it and there's actually something that programs that because I'm trying to make sure, you know.
3:25:52 If somebody said that I need wood, well, is that really what the site needs? Because there was a lot of discussion, Mark LeWard a lot of the original discussion on this, and there's a lot more, there's a group together of stakeholders originally on that first study that was done. There's other parameters, limited part of what they're looking at, but they're also looking at short-term, what can be done relatively soon, not a necessarily permanent.
3:26:14 site as well. There was a lot of discussion about how do we go forward, power, wind, sun shading, where those things would exist within any long-term facility. There was probably not one site that didn't need something to be done to it, which was one of the big problems. I agree that was with every study. I was going to say, I think there were some sideboards that were given to HVS when they did this, that there were some people that disagreed with.
3:26:39 You know, what those sideboards were, so that it kind of tied their hands as to what outcome they were going to come out with. That's just my perception and why, because council, they accepted the report, but they didn't, you know, it was never made official and saying, you know, with the rec commission. And so there was just some concern out there in the public that, you know, with the sideboards that these people were given, that it was kind of...
3:27:05 a foregone conclusion as to what the outcome is going to be. And so I think that looking at it in this manner, I think they're using it. I don't see a problem with it. And I agree to a certain aspect that HBS, I think, did have some limitations as to what they were brought in for. But they're also the ones that suggested a certain size and what the scale was. We're guessing at the size.
3:27:31 From my own education saying, okay, I know Lake Tahoe's got a 7,000 seat arena in a parking lot, so 7,000 seats seem to work for them, but I don't know if math is for the right size for Mammoth or is it 10,000 people because you can't charge as much. I'm just looking at saying, one, criteria, two, when we come back down to how much did the, just to jump a little bit, how much did the actual
3:27:54 Potential of opposition weigh into the factory. And I don't know what the scale of one of these were, because that seems to be a comment through a lot of these is, we don't want to do this because somebody's going to be opposing that. It was. It did come quite heavily, actually. Impact on neighborhood and residents was quite heavily weighted. It was felt that, I think Dan spoke about this at one point, that there was really no appetite for litigation. And that became very heavily weighted.
3:28:22 The flip side, at least in the initial meeting, was that, you know, why would you invest any money in an event site that has to close at 10 p.m.? Yeah, that's a good point, yeah. And you have to go outside the town boundaries. Well, I commend you guys for the work. Yeah. I think you've had a conversation part of it. I was going to comment that how you guys did this is very similar to how we did the biathlon feasibility study, where we started off with about 14 different locations and through
3:28:54 The local expertise, the consultants were there, but there was the local expertise who narrowed it down to the four or five sites that the consultants then went and did their work and said, yeah, of those four or five, these are the two that work the best. And so I think having the stakeholders provide local knowledge to this and some real on-the-ground perspective, I think, has been very helpful.
3:29:23 It's based on reality with what we have. It's a difficult process because there's so many people wanting their perfect site and it's almost impossible to meet all those criteria. It is impossible to meet all those criteria. It is impossible. Well, but at some point, the most interested stakeholders will or should come together and use this and use the previous study and come up with...
3:29:52 Dare I say a business plan that says here's why 7,000 people and here's where they're going to stay and here's how much, the question I keep putting back to Sean is how much is Beluza Beluza willing to rent a municipal facility for? If we do three of these events, how much money does it make? Can we afford a land swap or can we afford X million dollars in order to build that? I think that was one of the points that was made, wasn't it? Which site available and the site next to it?
3:30:21 What, six and a half million? That's six and a half million taken away from actually building infrastructure. Which brings us back to the financial planning thing. Yeah. Because nobody has ever really, I mean, let's think seriously about it. Do we have, let's say, $20 million that we're thinking about over the next 10 years?
3:30:45 Should we be investing in raw land? Or should we be building infrastructure? Or, you know, what's the best outcome for the community in the end? And you have seven different opinions right off the bat. And then you go out and ask ten people and you'll get ten opinions out there. So finding that expertise. One of the problems was, you know, look at the wood site. That's zoned already for hotel or resort. And so that use would probably suit the town better being used for that rather than being used for this. Although the wood site, a lot of people love the wood site.
3:31:16 You know, and I guess, you know, we're looking at a site, and I think it goes to, you know, David's comments, is it's the financial plan and the operations. And is our municipality really the person that would be looking at running something like this? If you look at, you know, the Tahoe site, or if you look at, you know, I bring up the event site that they put together in...
3:31:41 Arizona, Laughlin. They have a 9,000 seat thing and a parking lot too. So that's not really the experience that we're looking at as necessarily happening as maybe a parking lot. We want to make it a little bit more of an experience. But, you know, to bring and to operate something that's going to be like that, really, do we have the capacity to operate something like that? Or are we relying on each of these individual...
3:32:06 events to be able to do this. Or if we're going to look at a site that's going to have 5,000, 7,000, can possibly expand to 10,000, who's going to operate? What do we need to have to make that happen and be successful? And I don't think it's within us. I think it would be looking at an outside company that's going to come in, it's going to program this thing, they're going to operate it, and you're going to expect them to bring in.
3:32:32 And make it a profitable or at least a break-even site. So where are they in all of this? We've had this conversation with an event management group at Salt Lake City. They came in to meet with a few of us a few days ago. I gave them all our homework, what we've done. They've walked all the sites and gave us some input. They're going to work with us to say why this site might be best used for this type of program. There's one site specifically that they...
3:33:01 Fell in love with the snow pit up on the hill because they can see the potential for growing the MUF system out to that neck of the woods. They can see expanded camping opportunities with the Forest Service down the road. That's looking 10 years out. They're going to help us craft some of this stuff as an information item to the Town Council on March 2nd if you all say we should continue this conversation. So I'm just looking at you guys right now to say this looks like a good start. Please continue this process.
3:33:31 And we go from there. They're doing that for free? But you're talking about who's going to run with that. I'm not asking too much about just site selection. Well, we can look at site selection, but why are we even looking at site selection if there's not an opportunity to make this successful? And so I think as we're looking at site selection, those things need to be taken into consideration. If we're looking at something that's going to do 5,000 to 7,000, then we need to be...
3:33:57 Working with, you know, somebody like this, you know, that is going to be... I think it's great that we're engaged in that conversation. To me, it fulfills a lot of our, I mean, as we look at a long-term strategy, you know, we're still in this reactive mode of giving money to...
3:34:25 A bunch of different groups, and some of that is basically renting facilities, and so we've articulated a need to at some point find better venues for some of these events, and that might save us money long term. I mean, I think we have to engage the conversation. We have to engage the conversation, but we have to have a business plan. I was just going to say, so we're not, so that we're clear, so Gary, so that we're clear, when you take this to the council on March 2nd, it's not going to them as
3:34:54 Here is our top three, and we're going to go build event centers on these three. That's not what's happening. There's a recommendation to investigate. We're going to ask for direction from them. That direction may look like once we start this. Halloween 2019. What do we need to do to process some of this stuff? There will be private conversations with Forest Service staff, District Rangers specifically about some of the land uses right now.
3:35:20 About perhaps phasing this in with a special use permit over time, so it's going to cost us an X factor, that maybe over time we would purchase that, but not a flat out purchase up front. We talked about land exchanges and some of the property pieces, so we're engaging in those conversations right now. And it's got to be authoritative structure of government to government that we're going to have those conversations with the district ranger, which is town, support staff to the ranger. So we're asking direction to continue some of those.
3:35:49 On those top three at this point in time. And they're asking for, you look at a My Arms Bandit, asking for, can we engage conversations for short-term solutions with SAM and with the Canyon Lodge. You know, is the mountain willing to say, you know, we have a contract for support services with X vendors, but are they willing to waive those requirements for me to come in and say, I want to do an event X.
3:36:17 I'll give you a certain percent of my profit, but I want to control the venue, the food, and the beverage. You know, Bill Cockcroft specifically says we're open for those conversations, and if the town says you may do that, then we're going to sit down and say, okay, this is what we need. Are you willing to do that? You can begin to plant those seeds for us. You know, what are you willing to waive? I would have to think in those contracts that there's probably an agreement with the next vendor that says they have full right for food and beverage regardless of the event. We don't know.
3:36:45 And that hasn't gotten answered yet, and it was, well, how'd that conversation when the time comes? What's kind of interesting about it, there are like 40 odd events that happened in Mammoth throughout the year, mainly in the, not in the winter. That's quite a powerful strategy to go to someone and say, look, we could put these on your site.
3:37:06 We've got to work out the business planning, we've got to work out who's showing the money, where's the profit going, we've got to work out the cost infrastructure. We also said to the stakeholders that you're going to also be responsible for working together to make sure the infrastructure is kept at a collaborative price. So if it's semi-permanent, the cost of storing it, building it, it's all got to come out of everyone's budget eventually. So there was no sort of, look, we're doing this for Sean, so Sean, you leave charge. It was like, no, we're not doing it just for one event.
3:37:33 It's a very big event here. Everybody has to invest. And like you said, we talked about this with allocation. There has to be business plan. There has to be profit. You don't have to show the P&Ls. We have to be part of that conversation. And then, you know, really, this is a recommendation at this point because then we have to look at who is going to come and perform. Is it really, are we really going to meet that five to seven and a half thousand criteria or is it going to go above that? Can we get the likes of people like Nero here, the DJ? Can you, you know, it's possible and you can piggyback off Bishop.
3:38:01 They're getting pretty good acts down there. And begin to set ourselves up as producers of these events so we get a certain percentage to produce them that becomes general fund unrestricted dollars for us. So the other part of that is the short-term portion. Has any further investigation been done with any temporary, well, this is going on, with any temporary usage of an existing site that might be available?
3:38:28 The next two, three, four years? That was a very important part of it because realistically how long is it going to take to build something anyway? It's not going to happen by next year. So we have to look at temporary solutions. And Canyon's an obvious choice for that if, you know, as Bill said, he's open to sharing in the profits equally or letting the vendors come in, letting the town. But that hasn't been the focus with this conversation. I mean, have you talked to Sam Walker and all the other people that...
3:38:54 I haven't spoken to, have we talked to Sam? I've had one-on-one conversations just beginning to do. Sam is just an example, but just saying, you know, what's that short-term potential site look like? What do you mean? What's it look like? What are you looking for in the short-term? I mean, I'll go back to Sean's comment. He's looking for a place for next year. Yeah, well, Sean would be happy. It could be anybody. Sean just basically said, I didn't want to move once. So if we can secure the wood site for the next three years, then he's happy with that.
3:39:24 Yeah, but it carries back to our conversation about what are we going to invest in infrastructure from this group and recommending going forward. You know, if there's one site or a site that can be utilized over the next two, three years as long term, it kind of focuses our direction in terms of we may need some tables and chairs and whatever else versus doing it in other ways. Yeah, I think that's why we looked at Canyon and Woodside. The Woodside is already being used.
3:39:49 Setting up the infrastructure there, it's a lot of experience in doing that. We know how to run that site, or at least Bluza Bluza and the others do. So a clever question, do you have a short grid for any temporary sites? Yeah, we have Canyon Lodge, Wood Site, and the snow pits down as well just because we felt that if we're going to move once, that could, if we had the money. But those also classify as your temporary sites? Canyon Lodge and Wood Site are classified as short term. Two or five minutes. That's right.
3:40:17 I kind of saw that that's where you've seen as the biggest potential. Yeah, because Canyon's got the infrastructure already and they're used to throwing events. Woodside's used to throwing events. So we felt like I had an extra experience. Yeah, I'm not disagreeing. I'm just trying to make sure. Yeah, there's one slight difference is a snow pit, which doesn't have any infrastructure or anything set up yet. But we felt if we could move once, it's worth looking at. So from this perspective, you're looking for, what are you looking for? Are you supporting the cause at this point in time? Do you feel like we've got enough background?
3:40:47 to bring this forward. You support the work that's been done so far. What is the next step, exactly? Bring it to Town Council with these recommendations to engage and to explore long-term solutions with East Park, Snow Pit, and Mammoth Lakes Foundation to explore long-term solutions with them, explore short-term solutions with SAM and Canyon at this point in time.
3:41:14 That's the request. And if so, we'll give us permission to do that. We'll continue to be forwarded. Does the snow pit have the same restriction on it from the mountain that the canyon does? Are you looking at borrow pit? Oh, over here. It's over here on that side. Okay, there. Go for the walk. It's already pretty torn up based on snow storage in the summer.
3:41:42 Summer storage and stuff. It's got the helipad up there. It's got access issues, but the views, the trees, the potential. And I went out there with Robert Richards probably back in August, and I was like, this is a gorgeous site. It's got, I mean, I could see 20 years down the road. That becomes quite the venue to do some stuff. I mean, that's a legacy project. Yeah, there's, I think there's a lot of good value in that site.
3:42:07 I got to see the close-up version, so I can read that, but it would be great if we could get an email copy of the updated one. That I sent to you guys on Sunday communication. Oh, did you? Yeah, I did. So I was going to say, I didn't get this. Sorry, so I'm looking at the one from the board packet. Yeah, so the board packet has, yeah. Tuesday, we finished this on Thursday with the team, cleaned it up, sent it out to review, but I missed something.
3:42:31 So I just wanted, in thinking about anything being missed, that avoiding going down a path that says, yeah, we're going to invest short term here, and we're going to look long term here, and that there's not any...
3:42:51 Additional discussion and strategy or plan for how we're going to operate this thing and how we're going to maintain this thing and how we're going to program this thing that we don't get into a situation where we build something and then try and figure out how we're going to program it and function it. So just where we're very clear on where the programming and operation and management and maintenance of a facility of the kind that we're talking about factors into
3:43:17 A future decision on whether to build or not build. I think that's why at the moment we're just asking to say to the council, look, we've identified what we think of the sites, but we need a lot more study because we don't even know if Snowbit's going to be available. We have to engage the USFS into that. So this is like a recommendation to look at if the sites that we think are the top rated sites, are they viable as sites?
3:43:43 I think it's really exciting. I really, again, I commend the way you guys are going about it, and I think this shows the beginnings of a model for how we do due diligence as a community. It's a matrix that you put together, it's great. It's a group process, you know, it's a good recommendation, you know, as we do, you know, talk about due diligence, you know, I keep going back to the opportunities and matrix we did with that, I hate that name, Muff committee. Yeah. We can very easily take that matrix and do a verbal outline.
3:44:13 You know, the pros and cons in written form of why we find ourselves at Park West making a recommendation for this project, which is the lesson we learned I've got right now as we move this project forward to take all these things out and give the rationale of why we do what it is, like more of a narrative. No, and I think the way you've presented it here is really convincing. It took a lot of the subjectivity out of it. It took a lot of the stakeholders' power to say, look, I want this, because we listened to everyone but then put down everything objectively.
3:44:42 And then to not be able to say, oh, well, the consulting firm didn't understand and then shelled it. It's like we all did it together. It's quite interesting how close the stakeholders and HVS were, actually. So I said to the town manager, so how much money did MLR save you guys for not being a consultant to do this? Like unrestricted general fund money? No, seriously. I mean, you know what? Somebody else is going to get paid for it, so...
3:45:08 If we're doing the work, where do we get paid for it? No, and that's where we need to be tracking our time, too. We are an enterprise. At the end of the day, we need to be able to show the work that's been done. And the savings. And what that would have cost otherwise. We're an enterprise fund. We are in it to make money. So nothing wrong with charging them for our services. So do we have consensus? Do you have, I think we all say yes. That's all you need is consensus. Just make sure you guys come until I present this recognition today.
3:45:36 You know, I just want to make sure you guys are good with this. We're missing something. You know, you may wake up in the middle of the night at 1.42 as I do. You missed something, Rich. Send it to me. Yeah, okay. Moving on to our financial reports. They were in your packet. Our executive committee did not review those. Do you have any questions or issues about what's in front of you from a financial perspective? I'll just direct you to page 39. Quick summary.
3:46:03 Balanced forward as, remember we're a month behind, so we're at December. So page 39, balanced forward, tune, change. We need to do a billing invoice to the town for 25. We've invoiced them twice, our total of 50 in the first six months. Remind ourselves, we had $112,000 carryover moving into the season, so really our deficit spending. Our total revenues right now are 107. Our total expenditures are 129. Graphic design cost is 16.
3:46:32 And organizational growth. We brought annual membership to the outdoor industry. So our balance at this point in time is 94 and change. Bottom of 39, you begin to see the breakdown. Allocation, leverage, MLTS, organization, strategy, support, contracts are total. That's how these are broken down. This is the monthly report to the town manager by the 10th of each month that he is using for his audit purposes so he sees how we're spending our money at this point. And you see the general fund.
3:47:02 Board, so our total expenditure is 12. So our balance at this point in time is 94. On page 41, it breaks it down by line item for the first six months, the budget percent over and under, and that would answer any questions you'd have on any of those line items. Does the town have a line item for due diligence or research or something that can begin to become a line item? We need to, yeah, we need to.
3:47:27 Because it's really, we're not really doing organizational admin when we're doing research on research facilities. For town facilities. And so if that's really going to be our responsibility, then we have to be able to track that out of another source. Is that something that in your conversations with him, the town manager, you can...
3:47:53 And is that something you want to put, having a discussion with him about when he's here in March? We keep planting seeds, but I think we can probably put some stuff together, talking points in March. Okay, because the town manager's going to be here, yeah. It's like, for example, the report was made before. Well, you know, I was charged with allocation, but there was no funding for it. His response was, well, it was general fund. But it ate up $5,000 or $6,000. Exactly. And you hear the conversation about outdoor menu stuff. You know, is that really an hard expenditure? Will we spend time on that?
3:48:23 We're doing all this research and due diligence. It's like, okay, who's going to do it? And if not, then this stuff's not going to happen. Right. I have to agree, but in his comment there where he said that Measure R put money into that HBS study, so. Anyhow. So that's exactly why we should be able to put some of that money into contemporizing. They were told earlier that that wasn't the appropriate funding. So anyhow, but Measure R did fund.
3:48:50 A portion of that, and measure you funded a portion of that. Right? Already out the door. Well, that's why it's interesting. Based on town staff comment, if we're responsible for fundraising, then there needs to be money in the budget. What do you... Well, except for their... I'm sorry. Their comment is going to be, well, you're supposed to be going out and getting money to do these additional items. Yeah. Sorry.
3:49:24 No, you're right. You raise money to help you raise money, I guess. Yeah, right. You had a question? Yeah, the support line item. What all is going into that? All the stuff that you've heard me talk about the last 30 seconds. Okay, so that's all. That's the kind of grab-all. Yeah. Okay. And so it sounds like you guys are going to have to break down that support category, correct? Because we do, I mean, not just for...
3:49:53 I mean, our goes to planning very frequently, does it not? We're asked for $10,000, $20,000 a year for planning, so maybe we need a planning plan. I think these are helpful not just for the town manager and his audit report, but for us also. Yeah, absolutely. Okay, any other questions on that? Rich, thank you. Moving on, I'm going to go through committees.
3:50:25 Do we have any update from development fundraising? Any additional work you had? Well, I mean, we're kind of on hold, really, until we have the packages to send out. Rich is also talking to the Kings. One comment did come up when I was reaching out to people who aren't necessarily the brands, or the people who would normally go out and find the brands or the sponsors. They were asking what the recompense would be if they bought money in.
3:50:55 Which I assume would be a percentage of directly from the other side, rather from us, because obviously we do have certain legal issues in paying people directly from here. But that's something we're going to have to look at, because obviously they're not voluntary. If they're not the brand, if it's not one of us going to a brand directly, then the middle person's going to say, well, why should I bother? We pulled up some IRS information, research on that in terms of the do's and don'ts of fundraising, what you can and can't do.
3:51:25 You know, DSCS pays that person a flat salary. Now they get a certain salary fundraiser. You can't do a percent off the top anymore. So we've got to be careful for that. My recommendation, look at the agenda, I would like to move forward to crowd-wise platforms. I would like to move forward with making sure the Raise the Roof campaign continues. We have the batter at the ice hockey rink at this point in time. Even if it raises nickels and dimes, it keeps us out on the forefront. You know, it's an active page. And I'd like to sort an MLR page for family and friends.
3:51:55 Because they do have a fair share of people that are willing to give me some money. We talked to Mallory that Friday morning, went Friday, a week ago Friday. You know, she's willing to give us, it's a free service. But for $50 a month, you get the first three months for free. $50 a month, they'll help you create the page. They'll help you hone the message. They'll help you look at what the target should look like for no cost whatsoever. The no cost crowd rise right now, they take 5% of what comes in.
3:52:22 If you do the $50 a month, then it's only 3% off the top. Based on how much work we're doing right now and the capacity conversation we're having with two people in the building, if we can do this crowd rise gig for three months for free, do these two platforms, do the $50 thing that they're going to wait for three months to get a better flavor for it, it gives us another set of hands. It's an expert in that house of creating these documents.
3:52:49 The pages, the message, helping shape that stuff for us. I think it's a well worthwhile expenditure at this point in time. There's no money up front at this point in time. We'd go through March, April, and May. We'd have a good idea of kind of what we've done in these next couple of months kind of as a pilot. We can come back in May and say, okay, what are we thinking? Where's it going? What are we going to do? And the two platforms are the Raise the Roof and the Friends and Family? Those are the two. Yeah, MLR, Family and Friends. I said a 250 thing.
3:53:17 You know, it's like, it's a $2.50, and I talk to my brother, he goes, send me an invoice. You know, the nice thing about, if I get that link out, you know, he'll do his donation.
3:53:27 And then it goes into the donation base. He fills the deck, goes into a database for donors, as any other sales management program does, which we need down the road. But then it also sends him a letter that we can frame saying, thank you very much for your tax deductible donation. It keeps track of all that stuff for us. And also it tells us, Tom's already donated once, don't ask him again. So it really helps us manage our donors at that point in time. And I think we're at the point right now, we're not real clean and crisp on stuff.
3:53:54 But I think we need to start taking those steps. A few thousand dollars. Well, look, as we're talking about copywriters and graphic designers, a few thousand dollars is meaningful. At this point, yeah. I mean, when my brother's the national sales chair for Yankee Candles, he's saying, Rich, you know, send me something. Let me get this going, you know. My cousin, you know, he bought a shipbuilding company the other day. My sister's husband, his father's one of the many vice president of U.S. Steel.
3:54:22 You know, I want to be able to get stuff out to them, family and friends, you know, give me a couple hundred bucks, give me five, give me a thousand dollars. Maybe we can raise a few thousand dollars like that in the next couple of months, but that'll pick up the nickel and dime stuff we've got to deal with at this point. And we need that boost in kind of exponential efficiency. It would be nice to have...
3:54:41 A little more resource for you guys to do a few targeted things in the short term. In the short term. That would help us, and then it also helps public perception. Absolutely, and I think there may be members out in the public watching us right now who would like to support us and see what we're doing. I think it's a great idea. And so the first three months, and then we go to $50 a month for the, and so with that $50, are we able to expand and add platforms based on campaigns that
3:55:11 We can have as many platforms as we want. Okay. And does that, does the $50 increase based on any of those platforms, or is it? The theater house, 3%. Plus the 3%. Okay. Yeah. Plus they give us access to legal counsel, just in case we have any legal questions about promotions we're trying to run. I mean, you guys have a lot more expertise in that area than I do, but I was just, first time looking at the website, talking to Mallory, and then going back to Classy, Classy coming at us. You know, come on, Rich, for $199.
3:55:41 I'm like, we're not there. I'm like, $199? Free. $199? $50. I'll pay the $50 a month. Where does the database live? Is that? Web-based. Okay. We have access to the administration. Is it hours? Or is it? Are they on it? Is it hours? Okay. And then once it gets to a place where it's unmanageable, that's when you go into Salesforce. Yeah. I mean, for now, what you're going to get is an Excel spreadsheet.
3:56:08 And they're hosting that. One thing that I would say is just, I think it's time to pull trigger on some of this stuff. I just think that once you do, there's a level of management that you have to, I mean, that Raise the Root campaign.
3:56:31 was more than a year ago now, and we haven't followed through with those people, we haven't shown what we're doing with it, and so I think if we're going to get back on that horse, let's be sure that, because it takes a level of, you know, you have to update every so often, you say, this is what we're doing, here's the money, thanks for giving us money, here's what we're doing. So I'm still a little reluctant, I'm game for the 250 friends and family thing, but it seems really abstract to me, I think that's going to be it.
3:56:59 Tough sell. Raise the roof is a tough sell just because of where we are, but I think maybe that puts fire under our, you know, to be able to show the updates, here's what's going on, here's the timeline, raise money, but we're still not able to say where that money's going, really, or answer those questions. I would just say take another look, move with Joel, see if there's a way to strategize a crowd rise fundraiser around the stuff we're doing on trails. Well, we talked about that whole adopted trail. Because it's very active and we're really doing stuff. Yeah.
3:57:29 And that's, you know, we have more, and we've got Joel, we've got other staff, we have more capacity. There's, it seems like to come up with a nice, dedicated, crowd-wise, trails thing, gearing up for work this summer is another place. I think we do this group. Equipment purchase, yeah. Raise the roof for it, there's already. Yeah, there's a roof already there. I think the friends and family thing is more than anything at this point.
3:57:56 It's a vehicle for you to go out and make 10 sales and double our unrestricted fund balance. And then I totally agree with your comments about leveraging trails, our most developed interests. And that's what we're using. This is now billable hours under time feces leveraging dollars. I have a question on the class. You said it's $1.99 a month. Is there any percentage that's off the top?
3:58:23 Beyond that? Or is it just the $199 a month? It started at $4.99 a month. Oh. It came down to $1.99 a month. Oh. You know, and then we got into crowd rise, and Mallory, it's on the origin, zero and 50. I'm like, you know what? Classy, thank you, but we're not there right now. Same parameters. Yeah, so at some point in time, we can... Well, I asked Jessica, give me a problem. Why would I go with inverse and classic? She goes, well, because we're going to give you the same services, and we're not going to charge as much. Well, yeah, when you start talking 3%, that can start adding up, so...
3:58:52 But any, that's, you know. You're going to get that at any of us? Paypal is for something. Okay. We probably haven't even gone through the non-profit stuff. And we have the swap and change platforms whenever we want anyway, right? Yeah. We need something to get off the ground. Yeah. Just get wrong. Totally agree. No, that sounds good. You've got three months that gives us the idea. And again, it feeds back to what we put in the business plans, part of our strategy. It puts fire on your, you know, you've got to sell this thing to your uncle and try to.
3:59:22 You know, you're going to have to tell them what you're doing. So that's what, that's the view. What it's all about? Yeah. Anything else? So, I'm good. I just wonder, has anyone heard of Sierra Lifestyles? Yes. Do you know much about them? Yes. Because I just, I just came across them the other day, and they're acquiring local outdoor sports stores, including six in Mammoth and Big Bear in Tahoe. They seem to be growing quite fast, but I'll, I'll, I'll. We can talk offline. Okay.
3:59:50 Right. Anything else? Right. Anything else on development fundraising? Okay. Allocation? We need to set a meeting up. Okay. Do that. Communications? Yeah. We had a pretty wide-ranging meeting, I think. We brought the fundraising committee and the communications committee together. Kind of the takeaways from that was...
4:00:19 What you've heard here about business plans, that was kind of the point of insistence, that all of these projects must have a comprehensive business plan to move forward as a viable project in the town, but also for us to fundraise against. That, you know, maybe the person who's going to give Rich 200 bucks isn't going to demand that necessarily, but the guy who is going to give us $200,000 sure as hell is going to demand that. Conversation with the Kings tomorrow, they're going to say, what do you get, send me something. Exactly. So that was
4:00:49 One takeaway. We also define kind of social media as our primary at this point engagement tool with our own community and that we really need to start trying to grow the engagement on those channels. We also talked a little bit about our webpage being and comparing it to the page that
4:01:17 The town set up for the Mammoth Project. If you haven't seen it, it's, you know, it's got all the information there. It does, it serves the purpose that the town created it for, right? To get the information just in its kind of unvarnished, yeah, it's, yeah, right? And it's, and it's not, it's not built for that. And we had a little, I was in a committee meeting that kind of,
4:01:45 Pre-stage the meeting you attended about the public meeting, just where they brought a few of us from the old committee together just to show us the communication plan. And I mentioned that, and Stuart said, well, our site's not sexy. We know that. And my point was, we need sexy. We have to have some channel.
4:02:08 That is comprehensive, but that is also kind of in the modern vernacular, right? Where people come and they are used to engaging in websites in a particular way. People who have no interest, they see all that text and they just, their eyes glaze over. In our community, the hope is that our website is a place where you can go and kind of flip around and be inspired and engaged and still get your full diet of real information about the project.
4:02:37 So we talked at length about that. And also just that our website should be the end point of every call to action, no matter what it is, for fundraising, for community outreach, if it's a print thing that you get in the mail, if it's an email that is sent to you, whatever, it drives you to that specific page that represents the project. And that it's kind of a critical channel at the end of the day for us. We also kind of next steps.
4:03:06 We need to develop, and our conversation about the prospectus here is evidence to this fact that we need a channel and a market segment strategy, just your basic tight marketing strategy, and I think some of that's on me to provide the first framework.
4:03:27 I kind of shared a list at the very end of our meeting. I ran down a bunch of things. I'm like, look, these are the elements that we need, and everybody's like, build it, send it to us. So we need to have another communications meeting where I come and I provide that, where we review it. I'll give kind of the bones of a basic strategy. It'll have kind of, you'll go channel to channel. Here's what we do on Facebook. Here's what we do on Twitter. Here's what we do.
4:03:54 Here's what we do with direct mail if we ever do. Here's what we do with email. And then it'll go to market segments. Here's how we talk to these guys. Here's how we talk to these guys. And then kind of just an implementation section. It's like here are the first 10 things we need to do to get ourselves off the ground. So I think that's a deliverable that I owe the committee just to get us started and then we'll kind of flesh it out from there. I would also add, you know, there was the fundraising part of that meeting too, I think.
4:04:22 We need something like that on the fundraising side, too. Gary's gotten us off the ground, gave a presentation at that meeting, kind of a work-to-date. I think we need some kind of prospecting strategy. I'd like some visibility into who you're talking to and what. Are you going to make 10 calls a week? Are you going to make five? Or who's going to do that? In what categories? How are we going to get leads on? How are we going to manage prospecting for fundraising?
4:04:52 And then I think we also need, and this will be part of my social strategy, I think we really need to build our email lists and our engagement in social. We've got to have more eyeballs on what we're doing, more people engaged. So we need to work on that. And I call those engagements channels. I mean, I could see us, right now it's just social for us and it's a mailing list.
4:05:23 This, you know, the summit we're talking about kind of inspired some other things for me. I mean, an engagement channel could be that MLR, two years from now, sponsors a monthly talk, you know, where we bring in some expertise. We are in that advocacy vein, right, of taking on some issues that our town maybe doesn't deal with that well or some, you know, and that's an engagement channel. So we've got to have an eye to that to really get our work out there and start communicating.
4:05:52 I think that's kind of the broad strokes of what we did. It's also, again, on the low-hanging fruit front, that's a tool that we can build, that we can leverage. We just got an email from Eastern Sierra Nordic, and they're trying to pull the biathlon together, and what are we going to be able to do for biathlon? Not very much, but if we have a bigger social channel than they do, we can help them promote.
4:06:21 Get people there. Exactly. Without a lot of heavy lifting. Without a lot of heavy lifting. Yeah. Yeah, it's like a pushy button. Yep. I like that. Anything else? Any questions? Yeah, anybody from who else? Anyone else in that meeting want to add in? Just along the lines of the Planned Mammoth Creek Park West, do you think it'd be helpful to have our website link on there? I mean, like you said, it's not very sexy.
4:06:50 You mean in the outgoing, the things that Stuart's putting out? Yeah, because I just checked on it quickly. I didn't see Mammoth Lakes Recreation buttoned on there. I mean, he did mention, has anyone heard of Mammoth Lakes Recreation? So, you know, maybe it would be good to have that. I think that's one mention. I mean, when we're ready for that, I think that there will come a time when we should say.
4:07:19 Please put us in the materials because we're this portion of that project. Actually, to that end, we also talked in the committee a little bit about an MOA between us and what the rec commission was. I guess it was, not rec commission, but recreation department, Stuart and those guys, and trying to define some of those lines. I mean, because we're, he's got a communication plan. He's got channels that he's leveraging right now.
4:07:49 For this project. And that's, he's doing the heavy lifting. He's getting the people to the meetings. You know, he's facilitating the meetings, talking about it. So where do we fit in that communication plan exactly when there's already a website? It's a very good question. The easy answer is, well, fundraising, of course, and that's in no brain, right? But in terms of...
4:08:14 Just public engagement and trying to get people really excited about this thing. I think that is a broad goal in that advocacy bucket that I see. I think our website would be, and our social channels would be a huge piece of that. So to answer your question in the short term, I mean, yeah, I'd love to see a button. I'd love to see us. Maybe down the road, though? Maybe when the...
4:08:43 The designs are in, and there's a budget, and now they can put that... But pretty quickly, if we're going to start building a Raise the Roof campaign, let's get that Raise the Roof thing on every single piece of communication that goes out. I agree. And the cool thing about an online fundraiser is you can change the formatting of it, you can change the frame on it, you can say, here's how...
4:09:06 How much we have now? We've got a lot of this to go. The budget's different. Here's what it is. Here's the timeline. And, you know, as we're moving along, when all these things are going on, because you've talked to the kings, well, what do they need in this facility for them to be able to invest in it? You know, as opposed to just looking at it at a community standpoint, what is it that, you know, if you're going to invest in it, so this is what you need, but we're going to need you to put that money in so that we can have these things, and then you can...
4:09:34 We can make more money by bringing in here. Well, tomorrow's the opening conversation, so we're beginning to date. Yeah. I mean, they're going to say we need a larger place to change, so, you know, we can bring our camps up here, or we can use my office training. Thank you for that conversation. All right. Anything else? Okay. Unless there's a question. Do we want to think about scheduling a joint meeting again to talk fundraising? Joint. Joint. I think so. Joint.
4:10:07 Okay. Mammoth Trails, nothing. I mean, we had our meeting. Yeah, we've covered it. And Joel's on a mission. He is. And doing good work. So we're getting ready for summer. Performing arts. There's really nothing to report. Developing close to the chest. It's the same conversations.
4:10:40 Okay. Reconciliation. Nothing to report. Dan's been out of town. I would like to get our committee, Brent and Rich, together. And as opposed to going into these meetings being handed documentation that we then have to go back and try to, you know, match to something, I want to...
4:11:09 Drive that as opposed to going in and sitting there. So I want to sit down with us and kind of put that together. What are we asking for? This is just setting a meeting. Let's put this together and this is what we would like to have at this next meeting. This is how we would like to see it.
4:11:26 This is, you know, so that we can drive that next meeting instead of, because I think we're wasting meetings right now. I think it's kind of wasted time. We get stuck, but we have to go back and look at it and try to match it up. So I want to try to drive that as opposed to just do that. So I've been trying to get Rich and Brent and I together, but that has only been this last week because I've been tied up. So anyhow, so that would be my next step that I would like to do and then have that meeting with Dan so that we're driving what that, what.
4:11:53 What comes to the table at that next meeting. My member is Jennifer, the town staff person that's running the new finance system for sale. She's helped me. We have a better understanding of our funds 216R, 217U. We've got account code for all our trail stuff, for all our projects, our special events. She's got a much better understanding of what our needs, wants, and desires are. So we're going to meet sometime next week, and she's going to start getting monthly printouts that will be in your packets.
4:12:22 Based on the town finances, it shows roll over balances. Right now, based on the numbers that I'm looking at, if you take all the stuff out that we've allocated that really projects aren't happening, I'll bet you probably get about $4.6 million. Yeah. So that's why it's important for us to get a better handle on this. By the time we get to June, or following June, before we actually do anything, you know, we could have $6.5 million.
4:12:51 And, you know, with fundraising, once we have that number and we say, okay, this is what we have to put into this project, this is what we're doing, it's easier to bring other money into. Trails End Park's another great crowd rise. I mean, this is what we're doing, but if you guys want X, Y, and Z, if we raise another $50,000, we could do X. That's a really straightforward fundraising campaign.
4:13:22 The two people I had lunch with today, one of them wasn't very responsive to it. Really? Even though the town council shared some... But they cut half of the project, right? So can't we just bring in one of the most interesting element and try and raise money for it? Was that because this person thought it would delay implementation? I don't know. I don't know. I mean, I brought it up. I said, I want to... What do you think? Because Shields challenge us... I was saying town council... Do it. So if you want to go...
4:13:53 Go sell a rock. I'll go sell a rock. Yeah, I'll go sell something. He said sell the rocks. Right. Yeah. And then Mr. Wentworth, Councilman Wentworth at that point, let's make sure we've got our policies in place about sponsorship. But it doesn't have to be, but see now, I mean, I want us to go down a road where we're just, we're only raising funds for vanity purposes. This is a community project. Yeah. People are going to give 25, 30, 50, 100 bucks because they want a gazebo.
4:14:22 Not because they want their name on the gazebo. Yeah. Community pride. And the community will do things like that. Yeah, and especially if we're saying, look, we're already putting, it's not that we're asking you to do, to bear the whole front of it. We're putting $145,000 into it already. We just, there's some icing on the cake that we could do if we got together and raised a little money. Frankly, I love that strategy in general where you don't just say, hey, give money to this big amorphous thing, you know, give money to a gazebo.
4:14:51 We want a gazebo. We want a gazebo. You can walk by and say, community garden is something there's a lot of support for a community garden. There's room there. So maybe we can revisit that discussion at lunch. Why don't we revisit that discussion? You're good with that? Yeah, because I think that's the point. I'm ready to go to the fourth, so. Yeah, I'm ready to go to the fourth because the council did challenge us that night, you know, go raise some additional.
4:15:20 And you guys, this is leverage. If it's 145 already and you bring in 20 more, now we've taken that 145 and turned it into 165. That's what leverage means. I would like you to talk to them about the snack shack out of Shady Rest Park because we keep being told that we need all this money to go to fix this thing. And I'm like, why aren't we asking for that as a community project? That's a huge community project that people will fund and it's still not coming up on the radar as far as...
4:15:49 On the donation list. I think there are challenges, though, with who matters with that and where that money goes. Yeah, it's town-owned, though. The thing is, it's a town facility. You know what? That's... It's a town facility, so... I know there's something. He brought up a point that... But anyways... But those are the things. Once we have our... I know what he's talking about. ...where we begin to drive these things. And we're not waiting for somebody to come back and say, we want to do this. We say, these are the things we see that need to be done.
4:16:19 All right. Sorry, we beat that one up. All right. So that's awesome to hear that there's a finance system in place that's working. We're going to get reports. I'm starting to get reports. I mean, reports. Rich just went and got some reports because he went and actually taught firsthand.
4:16:46 And I shared something with Terry. Yeah, he did. Because we had an allocation last, I'm going to go sideways for a second. If we allocate an X factor for a project, who's signing off on that project's done? If it's funded by MLR, MLR should fund off, sign off on it. Because there are you. One of the projects specific, there was an allocation of 35, and it came back in as 43.50.
4:17:10 But it was only 35. So who signed off? So she said, well, that's going to come out of your allocation. This is not coming out of my allocation. We allocated an X factor. You're beyond that by Y. Where's the project management? That's project management. That's a general fund expenditure. So we'll see. Okay. All right. Good. Thank you. All right. Thank you. Strategy, we have direction on that. We know where we're going, right? Nominating committee. Brent had to leave.
4:17:40 He's not aware of any applications that we've received to date? What applications come in thus far? Is that right? Yeah. A couple people have reached out to me individually just fishing around on it. One of the people that I talk to would be an amazing asset, but I think, again, what sort of chicken and egg is like to be able to show, here's what we're planning for the next 10 years, here's where you fit. It's still kind of, is this like, oh my God, that sounds like a lot of work.
4:18:05 Well, I was just going to say, it's not for the faint of heart, maybe, actually. It's only 830. But we do have some ads. We have ads. Kudos to Leslie. It's on Facebook. It looks beautiful. I think that's really going to help when we get down the road to be not doing, like, digital scans and handwritten forms for allocations. I think our original application was electronic also, maybe, but hers looks much nicer. Hers is much, much nicer.
4:18:34 Meaning like a PDF that you download and fill out versus being able to populate. Two things. Gary has three potential candidates also that you're talking to. And the second thing is if you're on Facebook, go like our posting because there's a posting on there for board recruitment. So go like and share. Outdoor event venue, anything else you want to add on that? Okay.
4:19:03 Board member reports. Drea? Okay. Enjoying the snow? Love it. Thank you. David, anything to add? No. Tom? No. Mountain's doing good? Mountain's crushing. Always. I mean, literally, I mean, seriously, like, we want to know that, but that's really happening. And, and what's his name? Sean White is the next saving grace. Yeah, right. If you need.
4:19:30 Apparently if you need anything, go to Sean White now. Right, is that how that works? All right. No, that's exciting. That's an exciting development. Okay, that's good to know. Terry? Well, I kind of went through some of the stuff with the rec commission. I think it's important for us to, you know, attend as many of these plan year park programming meetings as we can. Because I think that that is going to be important in us staying involved and informed.
4:20:00 We have the graphics of this. We're going to start posting some of that stuff. Okay, so you guys, there are upcoming dates on this that a bunch of, you guys are talking about programming. So this is a bunch of meetings that the town is having on programming? Programming and their thought of this as programming is going to speak to what the facility is going to look like.
4:20:24 This is why we're not going to see anything until October. And, yeah, and so anyways, I think that it's important for us to, you know, hear that and, you know, continue looking at what are those other options, what are those other needs that need to be in there. You know, we need that community benefit, but we also need to pay for these facilities. Yeah, I definitely plan attending all the meetings. How many were able to go to Friday night's meeting? Were you there? Those were there? Sorry, I hadn't.
4:20:51 Previous commitment. And how was that? Was that well attended? Was it good feedback? Especially by the neighbors. Mostly. And dialogue? It's on granted because I guess we can go over there. All of these comments came out of that meeting. These comments that are written up here on the board, that's the town's takeaway from that. So they're going to take all those comments, take the three site placements that they have now and create one that...
4:21:19 they're doing from the takeaway. Kind of my one comment today was it was kind of Grady, you know, truly I think he did a good job and he was trying to pull this information out from people but you know it was really taking each and saying you know what you like and what you don't like and what what could be tweaked or it you know putting this one here and
4:21:39 I think general comments were made, and they feel that they've got enough general comments to make that happen. I was hoping there was more comments on each specific site, but there were more general comments. Well, I want it to be over here instead of there, but that generally kind of moved it a little bit. So are they coming back with the site? They're coming back with an alternate plan.
4:22:05 Taken from everybody's comments. So they're going to take all three of those and come up with one. March 18th is that meeting time. The primary purpose of the meeting this past Friday night was to engage the homeowners, look at the footprint where they wanted to be. Most of the recruitment sites are over there. Those three right there. That's the place. Which one was the favorite?
4:22:27 They didn't like any of them. They didn't like any of them, yeah. They put it up against the road, you know, where the grass and those big rocks are. Yeah, they want, some people wanted to. They want it furthest away from there. Yeah. Great. So essentially, it was more of a re-litigation of the whole idea of putting it there. Yeah. But if you wanted to take a look, these were the three presentations that were given. So what's March 18th? Is another site?
4:22:53 Because then March 14th and 15th, there's programming. March 18th is to come back and make an education based on the input from the initial Friday pass and email exchange that they had to present the preferred footprint for the facility. That preferred footprint, and that will be the one that the environment with your team. Okay. You know, if I can just go off of your comments, there were a number of people that said, but I went to all the Planned Parenthood Parks meetings, you know, a year, year and a half ago.
4:23:24 I said I really wanted a pool. So there were definitely a few people with this information I have that I plan on contacting. And I said, great, you want to get a pool? Come join me. Come join me. There was a little frustration that, you know, well, wait a minute, because I went to this and not a single facility that you said we're going to go here is going here. Yeah, the whole plan, your park's thing. The ice rink was never. Yeah.
4:23:53 And the answer was is that, you know, council mandated that this was happening, so this changed the game. So on that note, we talked about how these meetings were set up to not replicate what happened with Planned New Parks. If you're coming to these, six months from now, what you've said here will show up somewhere and not disappear. Correct. Correct. All right. Anything else, Terry, you want to add? Gary.
4:24:23 Paul came up, a friend of a friend of mine, no, wait a minute, the Chief Marketing Officer of USA Swimming is a friend of a friend of mine. Oh, there you go. Well, there you have it. He's basically, he said that when we're ready to have a chat with him, he will, so I don't know when you want to make that happen. I've got plenty of time, Sunday morning. 1.42. Maybe it starts with Drea. Drea, do you have Drea? Do you have an initial conversation? Just a chat. Is it worth setting something up?
4:24:50 Or March? I mean, I don't know. Yeah, go have a conversation. See what they have, what they're, you know. Because as soon as you get stuff on the topic, as soon as you can realize which way you need to go. Right. Right? Yeah. Okay. I think that's good. Then there was a question from one of the event, on the allocation committee, one of the event, people who received money from us asking if it was possible to roll the money over to the next year rather than use it this year. No.
4:25:16 That's what I thought. It comes back. If they're not using it, it comes back. Yeah. Yeah. I just wanted to double check. Wow. Isn't that interesting? It's public funds, so no. It's for a specific... Grand fund who had an allocation of $28,000 this past fiscal year. They didn't use it and they returned it. That's not good, I guess. I mean, it's too bad that they didn't use it. And they didn't ask for anything this next year. Yeah. Another quick question is, I hear the kindergarten is going to probably abolish ski PE for...
4:25:45 As of next year, as of this coming year. Kindergarten. Oh, kindergarten. Is that something that would qualify for R&U? Well, what? I mean, I mean, the Community Foundation supports a lot of that. Yeah, I thought they did. Community Foundation. They're citing safety issues. The Community Foundation or the Mammoth Lakes Foundation? No, Community Foundation. They need volunteers to go on support some of the kids. Through the Chamber of Commerce? So that's...
4:26:08 I thought they supported some of that programming, the SCPE. Through the Chamber of Commerce, because the Community Foundation lives in the Chamber of Commerce. Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation. Okay, sorry. There's the Mammoth Lakes Community Foundation, then there's the Mammoth Mountain. Sorry. But that's, again, we don't have a strategy for these sorts of things. There are a bunch of those that people aren't coming to us, but...
4:26:35 They're good use. I mean, ESAC's another one that I keep pushing. And until we have some kind of strategy for how we deal with those sorts of things, there are 100 programs we could invent. What was the explanation? Safety issue. It seems a bit of, they're saying safety issues, but I think it's about, they don't have the money for the people to shepherd the kids around. So I said other volunteers. And it's the cost of bus transportation, I can tell you.
4:27:03 It just seems a bit silly, though, to have a kindergarten and abolishing that in a ski town. Yes. Yeah. Especially with rangers and everything else going on. So it's essentially an extra session that they pay for, an extra bus. Well, it's like a Wednesday afternoon or something when the kids... Well, because the older kids take buses up on Wednesday and Thursday. I mean, my daughter's on a bus every Wednesday and Thursday training. There's Lois Klein told some parents today that we're going to go into kindergarten next year.
4:27:32 Maybe we talk to ESTA and see what the cost would be to run it up there. Something like that. I don't know. If they don't have the school, doesn't have the bus. I don't know. So we have to think about allocation. It's our allocation strategy. It's our allocation strategy. So if we want to do that, we have to do allocation strategy. Anything else? No. Okay, good. I don't have anything else either. Rich, do you have? Oh, that's right. It's Colorado. To be back tomorrow.
4:28:02 What are the three big ideas you want us to share with him? Of what we've decided to make? Yeah, three big ideas. Legacy outdoor event recommendation. Progress on that. But that's going to be, yeah. Significant progress on that. Okay, OEV. And maybe, well, the Winter Recreation Summit. Winter Recreation Summit, yeah. Yeah, we're fired up to fundraise. Long-term planning. A crowd rise?
4:28:34 Our crowd rise? That's all we got. Long-term planning, inclusive of business plans and prospectus. How about reiterating the allocation strategy necessity? I want to keep putting business plans out there all the time so they can hear that. Yeah, that needs to be there because we haven't had one for anything that's ever gone forward. So, anything. Okay. Anything else? Okay, one more thing. Do you have? Oh, yeah. Didn't buy you guys any food.
4:29:00 I got you guys a nice little meeting to keep your heads up. Very useful tonight. Very useful. So this is a gift from my heart to you. Oh, no. So when friends and family crowd rides get rolling, feel free to make a donation. Thank you, Rich. This is cool. I got the longer ones because they tuck down a little bit more. Because Rich's neck gets cold. And it didn't cover her ears.
4:29:28 Thank you. Thank you very much. Good job I see you've got a new piece of clothing. I know, look at his clothing. So we're adjourned. We're adjourned. We're at the end of the agenda. We can adjourn. So that's good. Thank you.