Town Council
· recording 3 hr 28 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
211 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:01:36 All right, welcome, everyone. Thank you for joining us. I'm going to call to order the regular meeting of the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, April 20th, 2016, 6.02 p.m. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bacon, here. Councilmember Fernie, here. Councilmember Wentworth, here. Mayor Pro Tem Richardson, here. Mayor Raimondo, here. I've asked Councilmember Fernie to lead us in the pledge this evening. If everybody could just stand and join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.
2:02:08 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Colin. I'm going to open the floor for any public comments that are not on tonight's agenda. Please come forward. It's a race. Good evening, Mayor Raimondo, Councilmembers. John Morris speaking to you tonight as the chairman of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board of Directors. I just want to update the public on...
2:02:41 Some opportunities with the board. I'll just read this real quick. It's a press release. The board of directors for Mammoth Lakes Tourism has three seats whose terms expire as of June 30th, 2016, and are available for candidacy, restaurant, retail, and at large. These seats are a two-year term. To qualify, applicants must hold a current Town of Mammoth Lakes business license, be in good standing with current business licenses, taxes, and assessments, reside within Mammoth Lakes, and have a substantial business.
2:03:10 Interest in the town. The restaurant and retail seats must also be business owners or managers from those business types. Those are the positions that are currently will be available for candidacy. I want to make it clear that they are currently filled.
2:03:28 Not sure whether all three of the incumbents plan on rerunning for those seats, but I believe at least two out of the three will. The way that the procedure basically works is the interested party should simply send a letter of interest to, let's see, it is, here somewhere, sorry, info at
2:03:50 Visit Mammoth.com, or they can drop off that letter of interest at the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Office on Main Street next to the Welcome Center. The nominating committee, which is made up of three of the current board members, will conduct interviews at the end of May. So we'd like to have all those applications in no later than the 15th of May, so we have a chance to look them all over. But that ad hoc committee will conduct interviews at the end of May. They then give their recommendations.
2:04:19 We have a great board, very dynamic. We have a lot of lively discussion, as Raimondo knows. It's a lot of fun.
2:04:48 The positions, again, restaurant, retail, or at large. At large can be anything as long as you meet the qualifications. And again, for restaurant and retail, we are looking for people within those industries that meet the qualifications as well. So that's about it. Any questions? Thanks, John. All right. Thank you very much. Appreciate it. Ms. Mayor, Town Council. I have a daughter at home, so I figured I'd beat Rich to the podium.
2:05:20 First of all, I'm going to steal a little bit of Stacy's thunder because I just want to say I'm very excited that Tiger Pass, to the extent, will be open and out of the way, but to the point of getting partially open so we start on, we're going in the Board of Supervisors, spending the dollars necessary to start getting us ready to hopefully pass open sometime early.
2:05:40 Clarify. Clarify. But also, just very excited to looking forward to a great summer. And to clarify as well, yes, I am running for Town Council as a writing candidate for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. So I appreciate it, and have a great evening. Thanks, Brent.
2:05:57 Yes, Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors. A couple items of interest. As Brent mentioned yesterday at our regular meeting, we authorized our county road crews to begin assisting Yosemite Park crews with clearing the Tioga Pass Road east of the gate. So Mono crews will work west into Tuolumne, and the park crews have started on the Crane Flat side, so no official opening date yet.
2:06:23 I heard it from Park Superintendent Don Neubacher himself last week. He said it will be sooner than you think. So that's a tantalizing bit. And also, as Brent mentioned, Caltrans told us yesterday that they are working to open the lower gate on 120 West heading up to the park, you know, weather and conditions permitting. That lower gate will be open in time for a fishing opener next weekend.
2:06:47 Great. Yeah, so very good news, and thanks to Caltrans for that. On a less cheery note, I was over in Yosemite Valley on the west side touring some of the tree mortality affected areas in Madera and Tuolumne and Mariposa counties, and as we all know, it's terrible, and participated in a panel discussion about how they're trying to...
2:07:11 Cope with that situation. So over here, next week at our collaborative planning team meeting, which of course the town is a member of that team, Thursday, April 28th, starting at 10 a.m., we are going to do a fire tree mortality fuels management roundtable discussion with all our agency partners, and I really hope the town can also participate in that. I know I'm hearing from my constituents out in Old Mammoth about
2:07:38 Dead tree removal. What are we going to do? How are we going to help them? So I hope we can participate, and members of the public, of course, are invited to listen in to that as well. Thanks. Thank you, Stacey. Stacey Keshe, just one question to clarify. Shields and I both sit in the LTC, and there was discussion. Shields will talk about this. There was a presentation from Caltrans about all the work they do up over Tauga Pass. Yes, a great presentation. We heard that yesterday as well. But just to be clear, so Mono County...
2:08:07 Takes on the responsibility of clearing Highway 120 on a regular basis from the gate closure of the park into the park itself to meet the crews coming up from you? Correct. Correct. That has happened, I think, in the past few drought years. That hasn't occurred. The park hasn't needed assistance. But we do have an MOU.
2:08:32 With Yosemite to provide snow removal assistance. And our public works director was very clear. We're really just doing snow removal, which the non-incorporated parts of the county didn't get much snow this year. Apparently, the crews are very excited to dust off the snow blowers and get up there and do this. So if there are big issues somewhere along the way, of course, that could affect it. But our crews are starting from on the east side.
2:09:01 Working West. Again, though, there's no set opening date yet for the pass. But it's Caltrans goes from the closed gate down the bottom up to the park gate. That's Caltrans. That's Caltrans. And apparently they do have it snow-free up to the park entrance, but of course that doesn't mean the road's ready to be opened. And Caltrans really, it is an excellent presentation they have about all the work they do to clear the road. So we thank them for that and look forward to open passes. Thank you. Thank you very much.
2:09:35 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Council, staff, members of the community. Celebrations are a part of life. U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell announced yesterday the federal government is going to initiate a measure to measure the impact of outdoor recreation on the economy. That's exciting stuff. We know that the outdoor recreation economy in California alone last year generated $85 billion in consumer spending, generated $6.7 million.
2:10:03 Billion dollars in state and local tax revenue. Pretty exciting stuff. We know Mammoth is a recreation-based economy as part of our Mammoth 2025 plan. How do we maximize recreation in our great community? We bring it home. Talk about celebrations. The California Trails and Greenways Conference. Brother Joel, come on up.
2:10:23 Celebrated the great work that Mammoth Lakes Trail System, MLTPA, has done over the last few years in partnership with the U.S. Forest Service, our project manager, Nicole Montano, for the work they've done in creating a social web-based media program to celebrate our trails and announce some of the great things we do. So, Jules, enjoy the closest thing to the Forest Service I've got in the room at this point. On behalf of the California Trails and Greenways Conference, we're proud to award you this Merit Award for Social Media Websites and Technology.
2:10:52 Congratulations. We appreciated the work the whole team is doing. Thank you very much. Celebrations are a part of life. Let's make it happen, people. Joel? Thank you, Rich. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Town Council members. I just wanted to add regarding this website, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website. So it's a terrific tool for visitors and residents to become familiar with our trail system.
2:11:22 But I really wanted to emphasize how we use it as a tool for projects. It is based on some foundational data sets and vetted information that we use for just about every project that we start and throughout each project. So it is not just a static website for information. The GIS data that was created for this project I use on a daily basis.
2:11:52 You know, the photographs that are embedded, we can use those for different things. The information in the website, so well written, vetted with the federal agency, our partner with an MOU for the website. So we use this as a very fluid and dynamic product for many other things other than just a website for people to get information from. So I really wanted to add that to this part of Rich's presentation.
2:12:21 And express how valuable it is for me as a trails coordinator as we endeavor on projects both current and future. Great. Thank you. Thank you, Joe. Anybody else? Okay, seeing none, I'm going to move on to Councilman Reports. And any additions to tonight's agenda? Okay. Seeing none. Colin? Thank you. Not much to add this evening. I did attend the...
2:12:54 Most recent Sierra Classic Theater presentation on Thursday, April 14th, so I attended at Black Velvet. A couple people in the audience were there as well, and that was a fantastic show. So they did it again. Another great show. It was hilarious. That's it for me. Thanks. Jill? Last Friday, I attended the ESTA.
2:13:17 A monthly meeting, and first want to report that the board did approve the commitments that were identified in the strategic planning document for us. And then some of you will remember, and it's near and dear to Stacey's heart as well, that there's been one person short on there because of the conflict, and Mono County has appointed Kirk Stapp as the other representative for the county on Estes board. Okay. Is that it? Mm-hmm. Thank you.
2:13:46 John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. A couple things. Shields and I attended the LTC meeting. I'll defer to Shields as the president of the LTC to provide some public insights into that. Mr. Chairman. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, I'm sorry. The chairman of the LTC. I attended the Mammoth Creek Park workshop here on Sweet Z on the 12th.
2:14:11 Wednesday, the 13th, I had a very interesting meeting with Deb Schweizer, who's the Public Affairs Officer for the Indian National Forest. You're going to hear a lot about fire. I'm not repeating what Stacey's talking about just for giggles. This is a very, very, very serious situation that we're all looking at. And Deb and I talked about and included Dan in this conversation about getting regular updates from the Indian National Forest about our fire season for the summer.
2:14:40 To be working to arrange some tours to the west side, the tour that Dan and I and John Regalberger went to, the rough fire was enormously illuminating, not just to see the fire site, but to see the things that Stacey's talking about, the tree mortality issues. The governor of the state has issued a proclamation of the dire emergency type nature of this tree mortality thing. He's, you know, all agencies across the state are now rallying and focusing around this issue.
2:15:06 And as we get into things that will happen this summer, inevitably, I think we need to be informed, wise advocates for the interests of our community in the eastern Sierra. I don't think we want to be shooting from the hip and saying a lot of things that we go charging into these situations. We don't know. We act like we don't know what we're talking about. I think it's important to really get involved in a good public effort to deal with this stuff. Then I attended the Mammoth Trails Committee that Joel was mentioning.
2:15:36 A lot of the successes of the program going forward have to do with the fact that the district rangers request that he have an agency-to-agency and peer-to-peer relationship with our town manager so that the line of communication is very clear and very straightforward. Opportunities for misinterpretation or noise or whatever.
2:15:55 And I think it's very important to Dan to commend the District Ranger for setting that system of communication up, but for us to continue to invest in it so we're not dealing with end runs, we're not dealing with distortions of what's going on in the process, but that you guys really work very closely and clearly together to deliver this program. It's an important program, as we all know. Then I attended the Mammoth Lakes Winter Recreation Summit meeting, preparing for a workshop we'll have for the Council on the 4th of May.
2:16:24 There's exciting things coming out of that. I attended that on Monday. I will not be at the Mono County Collaborative Planning Team next week. I'm going to be back east. I believe that Sandra Moberly is going to be filling in, I think. So Sandra will be there. And Monday of next week, I'm attending with the Sierra Business Council, the Sierra Camp effort that we've talked about, which is the Sierra Climate Adaption Mitigation Partnership for the Sierra Business Council. This is about...
2:16:53 How we as a rural community can access the billions of dollars that are coming out of the California cap and trade program for climate change mitigation. It's a very important tool that we need to be accessing. Then I'll be traveling to Washington, D.C. next week representing Mammoth Lakes at the Outdoor Industry Association Capital Summit. As Rich mentioned, the federal government will now be analyzing the outdoor recreation economy as a sector of the United States economy. It's a $650 billion industry.
2:17:20 There may be some hope to bring back something of value for all of us and for our community, for the Sierra, as we look to really invest in our recreation economy across the region. And hopefully I have a meeting set up with Congressman Cook's staff and some folks to do some checking in with that. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Shields? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I attended the LTC meeting on April 11th with Councilman Wentworth.
2:17:50 Takeaway there was what Supervisor Corliss talked about. The Mountain Pass opening, Caltrans did a really nice presentation on that. If you have a chance to see it, it kind of gives you an idea of what they have to go through to open that pass. But that's all I got. I have nothing actually additional to add this week. Appreciate everything from Council. Can I add something else on the opening of the road? Sure. I was checking out their website.
2:18:17 Yesterday, the park website, and they've added videos showing how they work on it and everything, so if anyone didn't get a chance to see those presentations, there's much more information on the Yosemite National Park website than there ever has been before about it. Great. Thanks, Joe. Okay, we're going to move on to reports on commissions out of departments, please.
2:18:38 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just to report that the Planning and Economic Development Commission had a meeting last Wednesday. They had a couple of items on the agenda. One item to note is they discussed the existing nonconforming uses and structures section of the zoning code. We've had a number of different projects that have run into issues with the way...
2:19:02 The non-conforming structures requirements are applied. So they took a look at that and discussed that. If we do move forward with the zoning code amendment to clarify that, it would ultimately come to the council for consideration. And also a report that Ms. English, D. English, filed an appeal which will be going to the Planning and Economic Development Commission on May 11th. So that's the item that you heard last time. And that's all I have.
2:19:28 Thank you, Senator. Senator, does that existing non-conforming cover the loft issue? Is that part of that or no? No. That's out there somewhere, right? I'm assuming that's working on that? We've met with the Lodging Association to discuss it. We're meeting with the Contractors Association and the Realtors on May 5th.
2:19:46 To talk about just to question and answer. And right now our plan is to take a look at that loft section and incorporate that into the building code updates that have to be done this year. So we have to update the municipal code to adopt all the new building codes. And so that's something that we're going to be looking at. Tom Perry, our new building official, will be digging into that. When is that due by? We usually do it in December. December, okay. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:20:19 Grady Dutton Public Works. Just two things real quick. One on FAA, actually two items. We did discuss our forecast with FAA in the last few days. They have a final letter that's in Washington for final review. They've received comments back, and we hope to hear a final letter by next Friday. That's what their expectation is, whether it happens or not within a couple of days, but we do hope to see that. What that does for us is that allows us to write our letter to FAAs.
2:20:46 Letting them know what our process is going to be for requests for qualifications for consultants and possibly with their agreement getting that process started. So we're excited about that again.
2:20:56 When we get the letter, then we'll take some action before that. We can't do it. The other thing on FAA is at the last SCOG meeting, I'm committed to providing a draft letter to the chairperson to send to FAA. That letter has been written. In fact, you'll probably get it tomorrow or the next day. Basically, what it says is we're excited that FAA is interested in visiting the region and we want to get both the...
2:21:17 The ADO manager from San Francisco and Los Angeles to come to the area and visit both Bishop Airport and Mammoth Airport. So we'll provide that letter in just the next couple of days. The other thing I had is relating to openings. We've met with the Forest Service on a couple of occasions now to talk about Lakes Basin. We'll actually be out there on Monday helping them get going with some snow removal and getting that open. We hope by the end of the week, not hope, but we expect by the end of the week, unless we get a lot more snow, that we'll be there by Wednesday.
2:21:46 So we'll get an update as soon as we have that. But that will include, of course, our now usual efforts to help them with porta-potties and other things to make sure that the facilities are there when the fishermen show up for opening day. One thought on the lake space and opening. I know in the Winter Recreation Summit, we'll be talking about snow management and those kinds of things. If you drive up Lake Murray Road across from the bridges, there's a significant pile of snow.
2:22:14 It's probably snow storage related. I'm not sure. But I know you guys have been trying to plow and get the lake space and path open, but there's a, looks like a snow storage situation there. And I'm hoping that we can get into doing a little bit of an inventory of where people are storing snow on mops and other facilities that are critical to visitation and start kind of figuring that out a little bit so we can get these things open.
2:22:38 Without having to plow through Mount Everest on the way to get into the lakes basin. And if I could, specific to that, that snow actually comes from bridges across the street. Right. And this is something they've done historically, which means...
2:22:48 15, 20 years. I have no idea how long they've been doing that. I actually corresponded with them this morning, and we've asked them to get that cleared off and in good shape by Tuesday. So they're in line with the same thing. They understand that it has to be open, and they've gotten that message. But I also invited them to come and talk to us about future years to make sure that we have a more formal arrangement for that because, again, that's just something they've done historically.
2:23:11 We need some stuff to clean up there, but they'll be out there, and they said they'd be done by Tuesday. Good. Great. Thank you. Great. Can you just include the air group on your e-mail that's going to go out to ESCOG? Absolutely. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Council, Councilmembers, Mayor, and a member of our public, Stuart from Parks and Recreation. Just a few items for the benefit of the community. Recreation open houses next Tuesday. I think we talked about this two weeks ago. It's still next Tuesday.
2:23:46 April 26th, 3 to 6 p.m. at the Mammoth Elementary School. And that's essentially a one-stop shop for everything recreation this summer. So come along if you need to have your kids taken care of and enjoy the great outdoors. All parks are open at this time. All the water is on. If not on, it's on momentarily in probably a day or so. So they're all ramping up. Whitmore Pool opens May 9th for lap swim. So that's Monday, May 9th for lap swim. Next meeting of the Recreation Commission is May 3rd.
2:24:16 And also on May 4th, Recreation Commission will be bringing forward the recommendations for the youth sports funding recommendations as well. And just quickly on the public information front, Town Cleanup Day is May 21st. Orange bags, maximum of five per person are now available from the transfer station and also the town offices. So if you want to get a jump.
2:24:39 On cleaning up your town, you can start any time. You can also take those items to the Mammoth Transfer Station any time for regular fees. You don't have to wait until May 21st. So if you do have something you need to take care of, get it together and get it down to the transfer station, normal fees apply. But May 21st, Town Cleanup Day, 8 a.m. Great. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Stuart. Okay, I'm going to move on to introductions. Item number two, introduce new building official Tom Perry. Sandra?
2:25:13 Thank you. We are very happy to introduce you all to Tom Perry, our new building official. Tom has been the building official for Mono County for the past five years, so he brings with him a lot of experience as well as a lot of knowledge of the town and our local contractors.
2:25:31 Also, Tom has worked for the town from 2000 to 2005, so it's great to have him back in the town offices. He has a number of professional certifications that he brings to us, including certified building officials, certified access specialists, a number of plans examiner certifications, as well as inspector certifications. We're really, really pleased to have Tom here with us, and we think he'll be a great addition to our team. Welcome. Thank you.
2:26:10 Okay, I'm going to move on to consent agenda. Are there any items that council, staff, or the public would like to pull this evening? Yes, I've got a couple, Mr. Mayor. Okay. I'd like to pull number five. Okay. And number six. All right. Are there any others? Okay. We'll pull items five and six. I'll look for a motion to approve. Item three, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 6, 2016. Item four, receive and file the Interwest Development Agreement Annual Review Report.
2:26:40 And item 7 to accept payment approval report 15-29 in the amount of $914,019.52. So moved. Okay. Second. All right, first second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Fernie? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Richardson? Yes. Mayor Raimondo? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. John, you wanted to pull item 5 and 6. We'll start with 5. If you could read that item, please, for the viewing public, too, it would be great.
2:27:11 What would you like me to read? Just read the item. I'll read it. Award the contract for construction of the Old Mammoth Road Rehabilitation Project. From the agenda, okay. Yeah, that's the item. I was wondering if, Grady, if you could give us a little bit of an update about the conduit, the broadband conduit situation, given the realities of what's happening with this project. Yes. There's actually one of the separate...
2:27:36 Broadband Conduit Project, if you will, that's happening in the next few days, frankly, Praxis is out there doing the conduit up Tavern Road into Eastern Sierra Bank. We talked to them on site and we looked at our plans and to do a conduit for...
2:27:49 Basically for digital 395 would be a larger conduit than we would do for typical street crossings. It would have to be deeper. One of the reasons that they're not doing it open trench, they're actually going to bore it, is so they don't have to deal with water laterals, sewer laterals, and the like. We will still talk to our contractor about extending the conduit across Old Mammoth Road, but our concern is twofold. One is it might be very expensive, and it would be a cost that we would bear versus...
2:28:16 Whoever the end user would be to do it at a later date. And second, we are concerned that we would not pick the right location. In other words, it's very site-specific for each intersection, and a future user might want it to go diagonal as an example as opposed to straight across.
2:28:32 If it was a $2,000 job, we would be happy to guess, if you would, but for a more expensive one, we'd be concerned about that. What we will be doing is wherever we tear up that intersection, any of those intersections, we'll at least lay some conduit in for crossings for future streetlights, future other things, because, you know, when we have the street open, we want to do it. We don't want to have to dig it up at a later point. Along those same lines, just your information, SC has actually come in and said they need to do something down near the police station, and we've told them they have about...
2:29:02 Thank you very much. I think I attended a meeting. It's an informal group, the Broadband Task Force, which has been identified in our alignment process. Pam was there playing a very important role in that. And I think we've already, there's a five-point sort of scope of work.
2:29:24 You know, things that need to get done for this broadband stuff. And I'm looking forward as we move forward to be able to produce the kinds of opportunities and alignments of where conduit is needed, where the infrastructure is needed, and to formalize how that task force is going to work with this body, provide advice to this body, but also be working with Public Works to make sure that whenever we get an opportunity to do something like this, we can get the conduits in the right places, aggregate the opportunities and all the rest of it. So thank you for the update.
2:29:54 The second item has to do with the letter. Sorry. If I could, the estimate that we provided previously was about $650,000, and that was really for the paving. What we found when we got into it is we also needed to replace all the pedestrian crossings, the ramps themselves, to bring them up to code.
2:30:22 We found, however, that the old Mammoth Road Assessment District is eligible and appropriate to do that, so the cost that you see in your agenda sheet of 723 for the road rehab is pretty close to the 650. It also includes 30,000 square feet of full depth removal, so that's in that number. If it goes over that, we might have more, but it looks like it's the right number. I've already talked to Stu about getting some information out to the public as soon as possible. Our contractors contacted us and said, look,
2:30:52 You want it done in May, I think I can do it in May. They've already contacted the batch plant. We've sent them a letter of intent to award, which is, again, not a legally binding thing, but allows them to get their bonds together and at least start on their mixed design. Because I think we've told everybody here and everyone else in town that we've talked to that this is very critical to...
2:31:12 You know, the town, because it's one of our major thoroughfares, but also the timing is very critical. And the contractor, West Coast Paving, is convinced that, yes, they'll get it done in May. I mean, certainly weather permitting, you never know what's going to happen, but they're confident they can do that. And it's their responsibility to notify individual businesses and things, but we'll be helping in that effort to make sure it gets done. Great. Grady, how soon do they think they'll start? They're suggesting they might be out there as early as May 2nd. Okay, so before our next council meeting.
2:31:42 That's correct. At latest, it would be late that week, but they've said, look, we're going to do everything we can to get our mix design approved. They've already talked to the batch plant and get out there and get started. Grady, can you speak a little bit about the rationale behind the breakdown of the costs, the 723, 33, and 110? Where did that come from?
2:32:02 Yes, we actually talked, and the town manager can help you on the 723, but we had road rehab money from this year, and we had some other savings that we've applied to this to cover that, so it's really all road rehab money for the 723. On the 110, that is Old Mammoth Road Assessment District, which is there specifically for this reason, for landscaping, sidewalks, curb ramps, those types of things, so we're taking advantage of those funds.
2:32:28 to do that portion of the work. The other 33,000 is with the franchise agreements with and whatever else agreements with SCE and with the water district.
2:32:37 They're in that road at our pleasure, if you will. So if we do a project to maintain or update a road, they're required to raise and lower their manhole covers to match. We actually have sent a reimbursement agreement to Pat Hayes at the Water District to give them the opportunity, if they'd like to do the work themselves, they can. Our expectation is that they'll say, no, that's a good price and get it done. But that's why the breakdown of the three, I just wanted to show the source of funds for that total project.
2:33:03 In the 723, Dan, is that what's currently in the road rehab budget? We just maxed that out? Yeah, we have 580,000, I think, is in rehab, and then we had 274 and a contingency item within public works. So between the two of those, we can fully fund the project. We will be coming back at midyear asking for some additional dollars to go back into that road rehab because this wasn't really the road we'd planned on doing this year. Initially, we looked at the kill side.
2:33:32 To take all of those dollars, including what we had in there for future contingency items that tend to happen throughout the year, to the one project that would leave us really bare until July 1, we would have another 580 going in from the budget standpoint. But again, that would be scheduled out either this late summer and or for this time next year. And so to not have additional dollars in the road budget.
2:33:56 It basically puts us a year behind of what we had planned to do. And as Council's aware, we're short on an annualized basis for what we'd like to do in terms of road maintenance. So we do have enough money in there to award the bid against, so I'm confident with that. Again, as part of a mid-year review or end-of-the-year review, I should say, we will be looking for some additional dollars to go back into the road budget.
2:34:17 And if I could add, in May, we'll also be returning to council with the village area parking situation where we're going to describe the project that we'd like to do with the CFD funds in Minaret Road, the additional parking on Hillside, the parking where the four 30-minute spaces are on Canyon Boulevard, some other work over on Forest Trail. And when we do that, we'll come back with a recommendation for that, the Hillside parking lot, and further our budget discussion. So that'll kind of wrap up the whole thing. Great.
2:34:47 Okay, just three quick things. So the crossings that are in old mammoth road, those are going to go away, those paver crossings? Yes, we've found over the years that they're...
2:34:57 They kind of look nice sometimes, but mostly they're kind of an annoyance to snow removal and other things. And also just for this project, it does save some money to just take them out and put it back in asphalt. But mostly it's just better overall. So is it fair to say that that was maybe an experiment? It was interesting, but I hope we've got some lessons learned out of that. Maybe that's not the best way to be dealing with these kinds of structures. In our climate, when you mix materials and have cracks, you have problems. No more pink concrete. Right.
2:35:25 The landscaping strip on the side, is there going to be a change to the width of the road? I know there's been challenges along with that little landscaping strip that's along the side. Any thoughts on the fate of all that? Yes, in fact, we've looked at that again, and when they're two feet wide, they're just...
2:35:45 Not reasonable to keep landscaping growing there. We actually have a project we're designing right now that we'll bring back before you with a presentation for what we'd like to do to get rid of probably two-thirds of those. Some of the wider ones can stay, but the narrow ones would go away. What we're dealing with is we'd like to come back with a good recommendation for what it should look like. We don't think we just want to put down...
2:36:07 Pink or rose-colored, you know, concrete to fill it. We think we have an opportunity there to do something a little bit better, whether it's stamped concrete, whether it's colored, whether it's regular concrete with paw prints in it. I mean, there's a lot of ideas around, but we'd like to come back with some options. And that'll be something that could, you know, move into what's happening in 203 with our, you know, the water issues we've got. Correct. All that. It's a part of a holistic landscaping plan, I would hope.
2:36:31 And that project is, again, also in the assessment district budget because we haven't spent money on landscaping and landscape maintenance. It's appropriate to do so. We've made sure with those guidelines. So that won't be general fund dollars or road rehab. That's, again, the assessment district. That's what it was created to do. Okay. Finally, is there any thought on the grindings, what, you know, all the grindings that are happening out there? Is there any opportunity to do any interesting stuff? I know you guys love grindings. You do good things. Yeah, we love them. Yeah, it's right.
2:36:56 Every time we get them, we spend them two or three times over. We've had discussions, preliminary discussions with the Forest Service about utilizing over by the tank farm again, extending out some of that roadway out to the actual trailhead. We've also looked at some work on Sherwin Creek Road, extending that out a little further in terms of some of that grinding type paving. We've also initially, because of the timeline to get actually a use permit in place, we basically gave them, you know, less than a month, and that's a little tough.
2:37:23 We've also just asked the question is can we store them there then work on a project going through the use permit process. If that doesn't, we like that location. It's very close. The haul is very short. It makes for a little more efficient project. We've also continued to look at some enhancement at Whitmore Park if we need to haul them. I think the contract has they can haul up to 10 miles. So we can put them at Whitmore Park in terms of some improvements to the current.
2:37:49 Parking area there plus some of the existing dirt roads that still extend like around the ball fields and stuff like that. So we have use there. We've also had some plenary discussions with the county on some use for some of the grinding material as well. So it will definitely be utilized. We've also looked at the little turnaround parking area out by Shady Rest area as a potential use. That would, again, work through our use permit with the Forest Service. That would be pretty simple, I think. And, Grady, you kind of alluded to the fact that, you know, the old Mammoth Road district.
2:38:17 Assessment District has, you know, monies that you'll be looking for for other projects. What was the rationale for the 110 ask on this one particularly? Basically, the money is set aside for landscaping and for sidewalks, maintenance and improvements, and the concrete, the pedestrian ramps themselves are part of that pedestrian access thing with mobility, so we felt it was very appropriate for that use. The other side of that, if not...
2:38:42 We don't have a choice but to replace the ramps. It's a requirement. And so if we did it, that 110 would mean coming out of your road budget, which would put greater stress on the funding for the total project. I'm just wondering why the ask was 110 versus 100 or 150. That's the estimated budget for that work. We actually, when we bid it, the curb ramps were bid separately.
2:39:04 Okay. So we know that is the number. When we talked about using that source of funding, I wanted to make sure it was well documented that that was the number for that. So when we went to the assessment district, it wasn't a question of we just guessed. Okay. That was the actual bid number. Got it. And so that all of them would look like what was done on Meridian with that project, because I presume that's the new code. The truncated domes and the whole thing. That's correct, yes. And I'm sorry, it's kind of related to the sidewalks. Are the flashy lights at...
2:39:34 Oh, for Barberto's going to go away? Oh, they're staying. We have two of them. We have Tavern and then one down the road. They're absolutely staying. Crosswalk. Yeah. Yes. Okay. They've been very, we've heard great comments about things. Well, no, and I wanted to make sure they didn't just accidentally get turned up. No, no, they're pushed out of the way. That's a technical term. Quick question on bike lanes. The curb-to-curb width is 39 feet. I actually took advantage of an old friend of mine who's been doing traffic and engineering for
2:40:03 Unbelievably 55 years, and I confirmed with him that we can't do bike lanes on there with the 39-foot width and maintain the center left turn lane. It's just not reasonable to narrow them down to 10 feet each, okay, and then have a true bike lane. We did look at various options. We actually looked at getting rid of the dual left turn pocket.
2:40:25 We just don't think that's reasonable either. So what we will likely do is at least paint charrows, known as the bicycle and the arrows on Old Mammoth Road. But if we do a bike lane, it has to be to a certain standard. It can't be three feet wide, as an example. It could cause more problems than it would help. Thank you. Needed a couple more feet. John, item eight? Thank you. Item six. I can take them together. Oh, okay. Yeah, we'll take them together. Item six, I meant on eight.
2:40:53 Yes, item six. I just wanted to commend staff for the work in getting these letters out on the Recreation Not Red Tape Act from Senator Wyden up in Oregon to start, you know, get things moving for recreation interests of public lands and also supporting the legislation in the Senate to
2:41:17 Have the outdoor recreation economy analyzed as part of the federal budget. I just wanted to appreciate the work that was put into that and what's in the staff report. And I think that when 50% of our municipal landscape is federal land, they're a significant partner in everything we do. And it's good to be chiming in on these things. Absolutely. OK.
2:41:36 I'll entertain a motion on Item 5 and 6 unless there are any further comments. I'll make a quick comment on that red tape deal. One of the parts I thought was very interesting where it says directs revenue from ski area permits on federal lands to fund recreation projects on the same lands where the ski area is located. So I thought that was a very important part. Keep it at home. Mr. Gregory will talk about the role that...
2:42:00 He was involved in advocating for that legislation that allowed ski area permits to be used for summer recreation stuff, but this is building on these kinds of things. Right. Great. Okay. Do you want any public comment? I don't know if you took it or not. Sorry, if you want any public comment. Any public comment on the items we discussed? No? Okay. I'll entertain a motion on items five and six, please. I'll move that the council approve items five and six of the consent agenda.
2:42:30 Is that sufficient? Do you want me to re-recommend? That's fine. Thank you. Second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Fernie? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Richardson? Yes. Mayor Raimondo? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I'm going to move on to policy matters, item 8, status report on planning and environmental documentation efforts for community and multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. Grady? Thank you.
2:42:59 In your packet, of course, we have the regular agenda sheet and staff report. Since we've prepared the agenda sheet, Stu and I got together and thought, you know, to kind of wrap up the public outreach effort to this point, and there will be more, we went ahead and prepared a PowerPoint. We've actually posted it on the website already today, so that's available for the public, and we'll use that as kind of a guide for our presentation. And again, one of the main components of this from the beginning was public outreach. Get it out there.
2:43:27 Tell that message and make sure everybody hears it. So with that, we'll go ahead and walk through that PowerPoint. First, just a very tiny bit of history because we could talk about this project for a long time. It's been around for quite a while. But the Town Council did make a site selection last year and they directed staff to work on a multi-use facility with complementary community facilities. That happened last year. The first...
2:43:54 Formal action on that was in January of this year where the Town Council authorized the two consulting agreements between HMC Architects and Michael Baker International, the environmental consultant. Public outreach efforts. I want to hit on this because just about every meeting we go to, somebody comments that we haven't done enough.
2:44:13 Since January 6th, okay, prior to 2016, of course, there were a number of opportunities for the public to comment on the project. After January 6th, we've created a dedicated website, planmcp.com. I think we've gotten a lot of comments through that and a lot of good interaction. We've held two specific site planning workshops, which I'll address in a few minutes, which talked about
2:44:36 Where the buildings would be on site, the size of them, a little bit of what their massing size and shape would be. We've had eight programming sessions, which, again, we'll get into a little more detail later. It's been on a monthly basis at Recreation Commission. It's been discussed at Mammoth Lakes Recreation. We've done a couple of updates to PEDC, and it's been before Town Council, if not as a formal item, but in my regular staff reports.
2:45:00 So I didn't add those up, but it's something like 15 opportunities for the public to participate since January 6th, which is like once a week. So it's out there. There's plenty of information. It's online. It's every place. These are some of the advertising that Stu's group did on Plan Your Park, which was the programming effort. On the site planning effort, we actually sent letters, again, to, I don't know if it was a 500-foot radius, but probably a little bit greater than that to include.
2:45:28 Most of the condominium developments in the area and most of the neighbors, one letter for each of the two workshops as well. So again, the information is certainly out there.
2:45:39 The site planning effort, we hit a kickoff on January 11th, just five days after the Town Council authorized those agreements. We had the architect in town. We had the environmental consultant in town. We met together. We toured all the existing facilities in town, including all the parks, the community center, the ice rink rec zone.
2:45:59 All those things, we toured Mammoth Creek Park east and west just so they got a good sense of the lay of the land. We met with staff. The environmental consultant and the architect got together and talked about what's important, how we can begin to start mitigating any potential environmental impact. So I thought it was a great kickoff. The environmental consultant even went out.
2:46:18 During some of the hockey games that were going on and started their noise studies for ambient noise levels and to see what it was like during an actual game with people in the stands. So we have some good data from this last winter on that. March 18th was our first workshop. Again, we planned that for the Friday late afternoon of a non-holiday weekend. The idea there was...
2:46:42 Anybody from out of town could give ample opportunity to get there. They weren't going to necessarily rent their condo out. They had plenty of advance notice. We talked about March 18th as early as January and got notices out. So that's why we picked that date. It was not quite standing new room only, but we did have 40 or 50 people here.
2:47:01 That workshop very frankly focused more on the negative, if you would, or why we shouldn't put it there, but we got a lot of good comments to that. We also got a lot of positive ones about what could be on the site. We posted those comments and our responses to those on the website within just a few days, and then we got to work on refining it. During that meeting, we presented three.
2:47:22 Side alternates. And again, I'm not going to go into detail because you've seen some of these before. They're on the website. The first two showed a north-south configuration for the rink slash rec zone. This one did not have an enclosed area on the west. It relied on some mounding. And the third one, which from all the comments we received from an environmental standpoint, was referred at an east-west arrangement for those things. After that, we went to work.
2:47:49 On refining those things, we took alternative three, which we thought was the best, and again, with the input we received, it was not quite unanimous, but fairly so. These are the things that we did to change that. We moved the buildings to the south and to the east to give better separation from...
2:48:08 The residential neighborhoods, the west and north sides of the facility would then be enclosed with support facilities. So that did two things. One is it certainly helped from noise attenuation to the west and to the north, but also it kind of focused the sound to the south and to the east and gave better opportunities, we thought, for events or other things we'd hold in the facility to take advantage of the Forest Service land. We actually moved the north parking area to the south a few feet for a bigger setback.
2:48:36 Our environmental consultant actually said that was a nice gesture. It didn't do a lot from an environmental standpoint, but it shows that you're interested in listening to the concerns of the neighborhood. The other thing we did was reconfigured the playground and moved it sort of north into the east a little bit, again, to get a little bit further from the multi-use facility. This is a site plan that we ended up with sometime in...
2:49:02 After the January meeting and before March, as you can see, if you compared alternate three with this A, as we called it, it's further to the east, it's further to the south, and the playground has been reconfigured. Thank you.
2:49:17 This is sort of a 3D image of that. We're going to develop these further, but this kind of gives you a sense of massing, if you would, for the entire project. You can see the condominiums and other residential structures surrounding. One thing I want to point out is you can see how close the facility is to the existing playground, and that's why we've reconfigured that. We actually had a separate session in programming, and Sue can address that in a minute about the playground and the inclusive nature of what we'd like to do there. But there was good reason.
2:49:46 And just again, give a little bit of breadth of space, if you would, between the larger building and the playground. After we finish Alternate Day and we went to the March 18th workshop, and just before that, we actually got some great comments. Councilmember Fernie and Rich Bochy and some others went down to LA and got some great comments about ice rinks in particular and some of the uses. And we, again, one of our...
2:50:12 Things we've looked for this facility is flexibility and make sure we're doing everything we can for the future. I've mentioned in other conversations and presentations about CEQA and the fact that we don't want to put something on the site plan and then come back in three years and say, yeah, we'd kind of like to add a couple thousand square feet because we'd have to start over. So one of the things that we heard was that
2:50:32 Should there be an interest in the future for, as an example, professional ice skating, they would really prefer an Olympic-sized rink. What that means is 15 feet wider. It doesn't mean any longer. It's 100 by 200 versus 85 by 200, if I have those numbers correct. But they said Olympic-sized ice would help. It doesn't hurt hockey at all. In fact, it helps in terms of programming because you can play.
2:50:56 Crosswise with smaller kids and have a little bit more space. And it certainly opens it up to ice skating. If we do that, the suggestion was that we might need additional support area. As an example, and there's no suggestion this is going to happen, but if women's USA hockey wanted to come here, they're going to want a media room, they're going to want a training room, those kind of things. Now, again, there's no funding for that. That's far off in the future. But if that should happen, we want to plan for that. So from a CEQA perspective,
2:51:25 We wanted to add a little bit more square footage. So actually, if you go to the next one, you'll see that in the upper left-hand corner, we've squared that off. Before, that was a brown area for a hardscape plaza. We squared that off. It probably adds to about 2,800 or 3,000 from a planning perspective. And we've also reduced the setback to the south.
2:51:48 To 20 feet instead of 30 feet. Just a couple of tweaks on that. This is by no means final. In fact, what we'd like to do after this, we'll work with the architect. There are other tweaks we've made. If you see the blue oval as an example, that might move slightly to the east. That's the entry area. And there have been some comment that we'd like to have. When you enter into the building, you can still look out. You can still see the trees. You can still see the mountains. And if we push it to the east a little bit, we can do that. But those are relatively minor we can do over the next few weeks.
2:52:17 Thanks. I'm going to turn over to Stu now for a second on the Recreation Commission Programming Committee. I'm sorry. Before you get to the programming, that last slide that came up that had a couple of tweaks to it, a little bit different to one in your pack. I just want to make sure that you're all understanding what we're looking at. So just unless you have questions on this, we'll move into the programming. You just squared off. Yeah, squared off and dropped a little bit to get the Olympic-sized ice.
2:52:46 Unless you have questions on this before we get into the program. Correct. Correct. So I just want to make sure that you're comfortable with that. Right. So this thing we have in our packet is not current. That's current. Correct. That's what I want to. And that came kind of after the timing of getting everything put together based on the discussions that came out. Sure.
2:53:04 Just so you understand what you're looking at. And again, to talk about the process real briefly, and I'll get to it in a minute, but there are still opportunities for the public through the CEQA process, through the notice of preparation, all those things, but I'll hit it on in a minute so everybody will see this again. But to get to programming, I want to do one thing before Stu starts is that...
2:53:24 Everybody's familiar with the Plan Your Parks effort and the amount of time and effort that went into that and the consultant cost for that. This Plan Your Park effort, if you would, with those eight different workshops was, frankly, it was Stu and Betsy Truax, the Chair of the Rec Commission. I want to thank them personally.
2:53:40 And a lot of the number of hours, you know, Stu got paid for it, Betsy didn't, probably 50 hours of her personal time. And that was quite an investment. And, I mean, she was there at every workshop, met with Stu and I before everyone and after everyone, helped compile the data. So thanks for that. And then I'll turn to Stu. Thanks, Grady. Thank you, Council. You know, we made this brief presentation on April 12th.
2:54:05 And it wasn't brief at all. But we spent about 30 minutes summarizing the public input collected and where we're going with it and what we're going to do with it. And since I don't have 30 minutes, I'll direct you to a page. It's on planmcp.com, and it's titled Programming Input. You don't have it in your packet, but I can kind of speak to it and we can kind of get to it at a later time. But it really summarizes all the community input that we've...
2:54:31 Collected and collated into kind of what we're calling the playbooks. So the playbook has been created for each of the facilities, and this is what we presented to the community on April 12th, which really gives you kind of a day in the life of the facility. So if you can go in and look at kind of the ice rink, you can kind of see how the ice rink would be programmed over that period of time, the summer rec zone activity, how that would be programmed, how the court sports, how the facility would be...
2:54:57 You know, a real complementary multi-use facility, which is really important to this discussion. So it's not just a sports arena, an ice arena, it's a multi-use facility, you know, with many users. And what the community did through the Recreation Programming Committee...
2:55:11 Was to kind, to prioritize it into three tiers or, you know, daily activities, weekly activities, monthly or special events. So, you know, when you see those playbooks, it'll really help us moving forward to build an operating plan, you know, the day in the life, how that facility really looks. Then we can start to put some numbers against it, start to put some revenue expenses and, you know, really get into the detail of what the facility will provide the community.
2:55:35 So I don't have 30 minutes, but that's essentially it. You'll go through the programming inputs. We had many workshops. We had over 8, 150 people all together provided their input with us. Very interactive. It was a real charrette experience. Everybody was able to come in and provide verbal, descriptive, definitive, and actionable information for the committee to review, and I thought that was very valuable. So I do want to thank everybody that took their time to come out.
2:56:01 Either in the morning or in the evenings to spend some time with the commission and the committee members. I do want to thank the committee members as well. They also helped facilitate. We had over 10 committee members from a very broad section of our community participate as well that supported the recreation commission.
2:56:20 With that, we also have over 25 emails as well, which is on this page. You can go through and click each of the emails that we've received. It's a PDF document. We received over 33 surveys from the online SurveyMonkey tool. That kind of went into the programming.
2:56:33 And as we said, we met four times with the committee as well. And we also went and actually talked to a lot of stakeholders, community members. We toured a lot of facilities, not only down south as well, but we toured facilities up in Tahoe, around that area as well, Southern California, to really get a kind of a feel of really what we're looking at for the programming of this facility. So all that information is attached. So you can kind of just go in and click on each of these links and kind of look at what the committee and the commission have been reviewing.
2:56:59 That would contribute to the programming of these facilities. So again, I do want to also thank my partner, Betsy, for all the time. I actually asked Betsy to kind of track her time, and I think she was probably more horrified when she actually wrote it down. It was a big number. It was a lot of effort, very intensive, very comprehensive. So again, I want to thank our chair, I want to thank our commission. It's not over. You know, we're moving forward. Just this phase of the programming is complete at this time. So if there's any questions on the programming, I can certainly answer them.
2:57:29 It would probably take more than a couple of minutes to explain to you. Any questions for staff before we bring it back for discussions? I've got a little bit more. Sure. One comment on the program is that it will actually help us in the environmental process as well because one of the keys is how many people are going to be in the facility, what's the maximum occupancy, what are the traffic impacts, things like that. So this is also very important, identifying that sort of maximum occupancy, hours of use, things like that. So very valuable from that.
2:57:58 Standpoint as well. Next steps. Environmental documentation. What we expect to do, in fact, we've already set a conference call with Michael Baker International and our design consultant next Wednesday to kick them off and get them going. They need to go ahead and get going on their technical studies and their baseline data. They're going to review, they've already reviewed the preferred alternative and given some comments.
2:58:23 To this point, one thing I want to mention is that, and I said it in the staff report, is that when we talked about the preferred alternative, A, they basically said, look, we haven't assessed each potential impact yet, but you're doing all the right things. Everything you've done has lessened the potential for significant impacts, and then, you know, obviously the analysis is yet to come.
2:58:44 While they're doing that, basically, we're going to go through the cost estimate and funding phase. We already have an extremely rough conceptual estimate based on one of the earlier plans of some of the phases, but we need to get very serious about each and every piece, what materials at the existing facility we might bring over as an example, what can we relocate, what it's going to cost to demolish the existing site, and frankly, we'll have to start discussions with the school district to say,
2:59:11 Look, we're doing this, and in your agreement, it says demolished. Do you really want us to tear this out, or do you have some future use for the parking lot and the concrete slab? We are guessing that they won't want us to tear it out, but we have to have those discussions. We've not formalized that yet. And then we'll also do cost estimates on all the buildings, the phasing, the site preparation.
2:59:32 And very frankly, while we look at that exhibit there, that alternate A, and it shows 10,000 to 15,000 square feet of support facilities, community rooms, community center, we have not yet identified the funding for all of that, of course. So part of our analysis will be, okay.
2:59:50 If we have $3 million, this is what we can do. We can rebuild the existing rink as an example. If we have X number, we can do this and really put a number to it so that when we come back to Council with those cost estimates sometime during the summer, you can start to get your head around what that means and start looking for where that funding might come from. And then when it comes to the addition,
3:00:13 Excuse me. When it comes to a decision point in January with certification of the environmental document by PEDC and coming to Council, you'll have all the information you need for what it's going to take, how much is it going to cost, what phase we can really do through that first phase, operation and maintenance costs, all those things.
3:00:35 When we look at the schedule, I just wanted to point out, and it's just to show that staff has been very committed to this, and so has the recreation committed, been committed. When we went to rec commission on December 1st, we provided this.
3:00:47 Rough schedule on the left there, on the right of the actual dates. So other than a couple of weeks of getting the architect started, we've hit every one within just a very few days, and we anticipate hitting the rest of them as we go through this. So it's been a very high priority for staff and the rec commission, and we expect us to keep going on that schedule. We don't expect to lose any time.
3:01:09 If we're going to open on October 31st at 2017, we need to keep moving. One thing I wanted to mention on this without going through each step is that when we talk about a ribbon cutting, I specifically said the ice rink, because if, as an example, we're building 5,000 square feet of community space,
3:01:28 We cannot commit that that will be open on October 31st. That's a different construction project than doing the slab for the roof and building the roof for the ice rink. That may take longer. If the funds are there, it will certainly be under construction, but it may not be able to be open at that time. So I wanted to be clear that I doubt that can happen, but it certainly can be under construction.
3:01:52 Again, next steps, environmental documentation. We're meeting with HMC and Michael Baker next week. Their process, and I've cut out a few of the steps for the sake of brevity, but first they do an initial study and a notice of preparation. We have a public review process for that. I believe it's 30 days. Then they have a formal scoping meeting. Then they go into the draft EIR stage, and there's really three stages to that. They do an administrative draft that staff sees. They do a...
3:02:20 Rough draft that goes out to the public, and they do a final draft that comes to PEDC for certification later, and that also includes a 45-day public review period, a response to comments, and a certification hearing. Michael Baker's proposal said they could get that done in 10 months. We're going to give them just a couple of weeks short of that, but again, we'll impress upon them Wednesday that we need to get that done, and we believe they're committed to doing so. While they're doing that, again,
3:02:49 Some of the goals of this was, and I will read this part, provide enough design details to appropriately scope the required environmental documentation, design components to provide the desired community benefit, while considering how to best mitigate potential impacts to the environment and neighboring land uses. That's what we've done to this point, and that's what we expect to continue. With that, if you have any questions, be glad to answer them.
3:03:15 One question on the environmental thing. So at this point, when is the next time you come back to Council? You know, I don't think that that's really required for the environmental document to come to Council at all, frankly. PEDC usually does a certification hearing. We will...
3:03:36 In my, you know, bi-weekly reports give you an update all the time. And if you'd like to see something more formal, we can. Well, what I'm thinking is since so many of the initial negative comments had to do with what is analyzed, I'm wondering if you can add something to the Plan Your Park.
3:03:56 Whatever they all are, that just reminds everyone that noise and aesthetics and so on and so forth are all going to be covered since you won't be coming back to us. That's a place where people can go to see what's going to be covered. We may try to do the scoping and the project and look at everything.
3:04:12 We could bring that report back to Council. So, hey, here's everything that's going forward for the EIR work. Either that or posting it to the site so that there's a place that people can go to understand everything that gets covered. Because most people, and I'm sorry, I can't list all 13 of them off the top of my head either, so I won't put you on the spot. But just so that people understand what.
3:04:35 An EIR analyzes. We're going to maintain that website, the planmcp.com, as a dedicated website for this site and for this project, and every time we do something, we'll post it on there. Now, we'll be careful to draw a very hard line between the public outreach process to date and the CEQA process, because that is a very formal, you know, prescribed process, but we will definitely be posting those things on that website. Okay. Grady,
3:05:04 So far with the direction from Council, it's been to really move forward with the design and not site-specific. Obviously, tonight, after our discussions, if this goes forward, it becomes site-specific, correct? That's correct. Okay. Questions?
3:05:25 I guess do you want to do public comment first? Well, we can do questions first and go public comment and we'll come back for discussion. So a couple of questions. In looking at this, this very ambitious public outreach program, does staff wish to characterize any comments or engagement with the neighbors? If you don't feel comfortable doing that, don't, but I'm just wondering, looking at this, I would want to make sure that should there be sort of a
3:05:51 A recognition that there's some opportunities in this project that the ability of the neighbor to connect to the project is not going to be precluded by what we're doing in the environmental work. If people finally say, hey, this thing's kind of interesting. We want to be integrated into this thing. There's nothing we're doing in the environmental work that's going to preclude that. That's correct. In fact, with the lack of...
3:06:14 Comment about, gee, we need additional pedestrian access or things like that. We are going to include those anyway and get comment on those. In other words, we're not going to... The neighborhood comments, if I will, too, is in the first workshop, there were several people, not... It wasn't roomful by any means. There were 40-some people and just a few people were speaking out that they had problems with the project. But over time, those people will still be there. I'm confident they'll still comment. But the last email we got from them...
3:06:43 And again, it's up to them to characterize it and follow up during the CEQA process. But they actually stated, look, we're not objecting to a project here. We just want it done right. Which, again, doesn't mean they won't object to the project sinuously, but at least that softened it a bit where they sound more like they're ready to participate. But again, the overwhelming response from all the other workshops was very positive and a lot of support.
3:07:09 If I could characterize that through the programming and everything. There are still people who will either object. We hope that they do come in early and give us some comments so we can improve the project. Because one of our things from the beginning is tell us what you see, and we will try to mitigate that as best we can. But we expect to do as much connectivity as we can. Okay. Is there any, with the federal land that's right next to this project, is there any, you guys, there's no chance that we're going to get involved in having to do any kind of a NEPA analysis for this, correct?
3:07:37 We are not anticipating that whatsoever, no, because we have a special use permit for the Forest Service already for this land for parks and parking and things like that. Even the land that's between the proposed facility and the creek? That area to the creek is under our permit, the same permit with Mammoth Creek East. We will look at those things, of course, from a CEQA perspective, but we don't anticipate any issues there. And as you go through the environmental process, the relationship of the design work that you have to do to be building this thing,
3:08:05 How are you balancing the work you need to do to be ready to start constructing this thing with keeping things somewhat open given that you may have to mitigate some things through the CEQA process? We are going to continue on the design to a point during the environmental process but not past the point of preliminary design. This is sort of partway between conceptual and preliminary. We think we can do a little bit more work. In fact, we think we have enough money in the...
3:08:31 The design consultant contract at this point to get us close to where we could actually do a design review process. We set it out to CEQA to do basically just for the massing and site planning. In a typical project, we'd also get the architecture far enough for design review.
3:08:48 It gets a little sketchy because as a public agency we can't spend money past preliminary design without having CEQA completed, but we have room in there to do additional preliminary design to get to design review. Okay, so you're balancing those needs as you go forward. And the final question about the website, I mean, Stuart, a lot has been invested in this portal for public information. Is it your idea that this would become the webpage, the website for the facility itself once it's up and running?
3:09:16 Just transition from a planning to a building to it's open. This is the web portal that's going to be used for the actual operations when the facility is operational. I don't know. We've actually discussed the transition of that website yet, Councilor. So I think that's a good question to bring forward to the Commission and certainly staff. Okay. That's it. Thank you. Thanks, John. Any other questions from Council right now? Questions from the public? Comments? None? Okay, I'll bring it back for discussion. Do you want to start, Shields?
3:09:47 You're ready. We'll see if I'm ready. All right. I think you made a very good point when people around the proposed project, and I'll call it proposed right now, said they want it done right. We've had too many times out here that we've started something and it hasn't been done right. I don't want any more mammoth temporary going on. So hopefully that we take the time.
3:10:18 An effort to make it right and make sure the funds are there to make it right. So that's the only comment I have. Thanks, Shields. I just got a quick comment, a couple comments. One, I still have my same concerns. First off, best use of funds with our limited funds is right now the best use of funds. I don't believe it is. I'm supportive of hockey. I'm supportive of the project. I've been supportive. I think, you know, we're doing some visioning.
3:10:50 Planning right now. I think that there's potential other opportunities. Stuart, you mentioned about being a true multi-use facility. I'm really concerned that this becomes an athletic facility and not a true multi-use facility. Again, to Shields' comment about getting it right to make sure if it is going to be a multi-use facility, that is going to be done. Because if it's going to be an athletic facility, I mean...
3:11:16 You know, there's partnerships, there's other opportunities with Snow Creek or others that have infrastructure that could save a lot of money if that's all this becomes. It's going to truly become a multi-use facility and we're going to get a big bang for a buck. That's a different conversation. But, you know, I just, I'm really concerned, again, financially and, you know, what's this going to do economically to drive TOT to the town?
3:11:43 Is this the best use to really try to push that? I'm concerned about that. So, again, I've made the same comments over and over, but to Shields' point, too, make sure it's done right and it's not a start or out of money and part undone and so forth and so on. So those are my comments. Michael, if I can speak to the uses. I attended one of the programming sessions.
3:12:10 There were so many, so you should take a chance to go look and see what they came. I don't know which ones end up at which tiers, but there were art classes and quinceañeras and all kinds of things that are envisioned and that are going to go into the planning. So, no, it's not just going to be an athletic facility. And I also continue to believe that this is the correct location, and it's going to anchor that end of our commercial district. Any comments?
3:12:39 Nothing really to add at this point. I mean, I've made comments in the past. Nothing's really changed for me. I appreciate the outreach efforts. I attended most of the sessions, so I got a good sense for the engagement and just, you know, commend Betsy and Stu and everybody that was involved in that effort to engage with the community.
3:13:01 I still continue to be supportive of this project, but I would definitely echo some of the sentiments mentioned by other council members that I think it's imperative that we do this right. I think we would be doing a disservice to the community if it becomes just a concrete slab with a roof. I think this has to be... An expensive one, too. What's that? An expensive one, too. Roof's a roof.
3:13:30 You know, that doesn't change where it's located. And I think, you know, we need to do the right facility for that location, which I think does need some complement. So as this thing starts to evolve and we look at other funding discussions, I'm looking forward to that. But I view this as needing to be, you know, the right facility based on the location we pick. So, you know, I appreciate...
3:13:58 The status update, I've been pretty well involved in a lot of this stuff, so not a lot of it's new for me, but I think it's great for the community to kind of get the status update. It's encouraging to see that, you know, the rather detailed timeline that you laid out, you know, back in January has been followed, and, you know, I appreciate the information and continue to be supportive of the project. Yeah, I'll just add, I'm kind of thrilled.
3:14:29 Thank you.
3:14:54 I support it. I think it's kind of inspiring. And I think, as you heard from this council, to all of us, getting it right, we're going to have budget issues. We're going to have all these different kinds of things to deal with when we get into this. But I think if we're all on the same page, we're all going in the right direction. I think it's a pretty exciting, inspiring little project. So thank you. And just a couple more comments that I might be remiss if I didn't say. But we have an existing facility that, frankly, does not function the way it is.
3:15:24 And, you know, to me, a lot of the impetus behind this is completing, you know, as you said, Shields, no more Mammoth temporary, completing a facility that has been insufficient since inception. And, you know, we...
3:15:39 We've done some things as far as the approvals with some of the guidance from MLR and the recommendations that council approved as far as what priority facilities we have right now. We know we have a lot of capital infrastructure needs here and limited dollars, and one of the major considerations for me is completing.
3:16:00 Dan.
3:16:19 You're looking for direction. There's not a clear motion in here. Right. What we had on this was an update. Council approved the contracts and move forward. We really wanted to do the check-in at this point, as was raised in some of the discussion, that unless there's something contrary and Council wants to see us to go a different direction, we'll stay on the same timeline.
3:16:41 Go forward, as was mentioned, with the EIR work that would be site-specific for this particular site and the conceptual design, as you're seeing, it'll be tweaked a little bit more through that process. We wanted to make sure that Council is aware of the public outreach that's gone on, the information that's on the website, if you want to go and look at some of the emails and those types of elements that come through that. We did want to highlight a couple of the changes that, based on the last couple of weeks, it's been made there. So, unless we have a different, you know, formalized direction from Council,
3:17:11 We would proceed down the path that's been laid out. We would go forward with the environmental work on the site and finalizing that design and move that forward accordingly. So we didn't, because we'd already gotten that direction to do so, but we wanted to take a pause. There was asked a while back about making sure that we're able to do that. And so we wanted to take a pause here and ask council, unless you're, you know, I'll say majority of you want to say no, hold off and wait to do X, Y, or Z, we would proceed forward. So we wanted to have that opportunity.
3:17:40 Here for that discussion. So that's to check in. We understand there's some concerns that have been expressed and we'll continue to understand those and move forward with the majority of the council's direction. And are we to understand that the next major milestone would be? It'd be the scoping work in terms of really going forward with the formal EIR. Okay. Which at that point?
3:18:03 It's on this site. It's pretty much at that point we'd be moving forward. It would be locking in that work to this particular location. And to be clear from the public outreach perspective, the environmental consultants are managing that process, correct? Correct. It's going to be a different website. It's a whole different bunch of... We'll probably end up utilizing some of our information so people go to the same place, but to the extent that they do any different outreach, we'd want to make sure it's consolidated so people, if they're used to going here, they continue to go here to get information. Right, because that's a whole legal...
3:18:32 After the legal process, we have to follow on that. So we'll make sure that that's clear. Okay. Okay. So unless there's other comments or questions. I think when they did the noise analysis on the current rink, I believe Colin was there and there was a concern raised. I got some time to tone it down, yeah. Yeah. Slap shot was that. Ken will be boxed. It's quite a slap shot. Whatever it's called. Okay. So with.
3:19:00 Clear consensus for the majority of the council to move forward. That's what we will do. We're going to move on to item number nine, approved funding not to exceed $12,000 to measure our funds for delineated wetland study of the bell-shaped parcel as recommended by the MLR Outdoor Performing Arts Steering Committee. Rich? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council, staff, members of the community.
3:19:25 There's such a positive amount of energy in the room right now. We need to stand up and maybe do a couple of jumping jacks. I'm looking forward to the whole design model so MLR can really focus on raising funds for the Park Plus project. That's the next step for us. What does it look like when we sell that dream? So a quick update on the Outdoor Performing Arts Center. Our request tonight is approve funding for the wetland delineation study and provide an update on the other six parcels.
3:19:52 It's consideration as we move this project forward. Brief history. This is one of the MLR priority phase projects approved by council on December 16th. We started out with 37 parcels. We came back on March 2nd for review and recommendations and narrowed the list down to us at this point in time so we've got a quick update. Number one, Sam's Wood Site properties for sale. Number two, we're meeting with the Mammoth Mountain Ski Association team on Friday to discuss options for Canyon Lodge.
3:20:22 Number three, the Mammoth Lake Foundation properties open for consideration. They're willing to engage in the conversation. Heaven's primary focus right now is the MAC, Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. Tenanted a date to open that in December of 2018, but they're open for consideration. Number four, we have three properties that are public lands managed by the Forest Service. We haven't had the opportunity to meet with the District Ranger at this point. We're hoping to have that conversation sooner rather than later. Those parcels are the snow pit.
3:20:52 RV Park East and Mammoth Park East. We're recommending the wetlands delineation study for the bell-shaped parcel really to determine the usable area for future planning purposes. Let's find out what we can and can't do on that parcel at this point in time, at least narrow it down. You know, I talked to Gary in time at Triad, talked to Sandra. Looks like the last time we've done a study was 2004. That was 12 years ago. So let's redo this. Let's figure out what we have over there and go from there.
3:21:20 Wind studies were not quite there just yet, but I've been working with talking to Howard Schechter, Chris Smallcomb out of Reno and NOAA. He turned me on to a place called Mazel West Weather Station at the University of Utah. He collects weather data on the weather stations around the area.
3:21:35 It's got longitudinal data over time that you can really analyze. The recommendation was, yeah, Rich, you can pull that stuff out, but you're a kindergarten teacher by trade. We really need to have a certified meteorologist really certify that for us for liability purposes. So if we look at this, we might consider windsetters in the following areas. Perhaps the bell-shaped parcel.
3:21:55 Perhaps two of the public lands managed by the Forest Service, maybe the snow pit at Mammoth Creek Park East. If we do Park East, we could probably measure the wind studies between Park East and Mammoth Lake Foundation. That's the same wind total, give or take a little bit. And we all agree there's wind, right? But let's really confirm what it is. But to do those, we'd have to have permission or some kind of modification to a special use permit to move that forward. And then a data collection at Canyon Lodge. It looks like the Meso West weather station at Canyon already has data for us.
3:22:24 So we don't need a new weather station. We just need to analyze that data. I've had conversations with some potential vendors about this. They wanted 8-6 for one study, and it looks like it'll do 3-4s or 4-4s or about 11-4, 11-5. But that would be something based on the direction you give us today. Other thoughts and information. I gave a quick update to the Planning Commission last week. They wanted me to weigh in to remind them.
3:22:49 Their thought on this was that this location should be, this outdoor performing arts center should be located in either the North Village Planning or the downtown planning districts, that sense of synergy as we look at, you know, our plans in the future. And then one of our public comment, our buddy Tom Hodges, will want to remind us that traffic is an issue, you know, MMSA plans for 2.0.
3:23:10 2.4, 2.5 people per car, 45 people per bus, and they get 3,000 people per hour on the gondola from the village of the Gantt Canyon Lodge. So, quick update, we're moving forward, so we're seeking your...
3:23:23 Approval to move forward to wetland delineation studies. Give me some input on wind studies, what the recommendation would be. I'll bring something back to MLR on May 4th. Depends on May 3rd. Whatever that decision is, we'd come back here on May 20th if we move in that direction and then do wind studies and try to get all the stuff done over the summer, which gives them time to map this stuff out. So comments, questions? Great. I've got a couple of questions. First of all, Rich, is the timing. Is this wetland study going to be in place to get our...
3:23:51 Real runoff, normal runoff that we're going to have this year as it works its way through that parcel? We're hoping that if you approve this this evening, we can work with staff to get this out and down on the ground to do the data collection we need to do this summer. Okay. And then it's probably semantics, and I understand this came from the Outdoor Performing Arts Center Steering Committee who's been doing a lot of work, but...
3:24:15 The MLR Board is recommending the expenditure of the Measure R dollars. The Board has seen it and recommended to us. Correct. Okay. All right. Any other questions? Public comment, questions? Okay. Okay. I have just one comment that when you look at...
3:24:40 It says page 39, but I don't know if it's actually page 39, where we have the preferred concept for plan your parks. I want to state again that that was just accepted, not approved by council, but I think that finally delineating the wetlands on this site is so important to whatever purpose it has.
3:24:59 Yeah, I agree. I think it's going to be a little more extensive than this little drawing, but in the sense it hasn't been done, whatever happens with that parcel, it needs to happen. I think it's an appropriate time to do it. And I'd also like to see that those wind studies come back to us so that information is available sooner rather than later. And the recommendation, so that would be helpful too, recommendation for wind studies and what parcels?
3:25:22 Correct. That's what I mean. Yes. As to which parcels and all of that. So getting that back sooner rather than later is whatever MLR wants to recommend to us. Very good. Thank you. I just have this kind of work, the story map that's part of what we're doing, that whatever is coming up with is going to be representable. I'm sure it's a GIS thing. You can do it. But we want to be taking all this information and putting into that.
3:25:51 A minor question, but the recommended motion is italicized. Is there a reason for that? Typo. Typo? Okay. It's not something special to sing it out loud or something. Oh, yes, you have to sing. You know I can sing. You know I can dance. All right. But you can't make motions. All right. With no further discussion from Council, I'll entertain a motion. Oh, you have a motion. Yeah, just a couple of comments. You know, Rich, I think.
3:26:20 I understand, you know, sitting down with the Forest Service and, you know, we've got to do a lot of coordination of schedules, but I just want to impress the importance of getting that done. You know, we've got a list of seven sites, four of which are under their jurisdiction. So, to me, I think it wouldn't be prudent for us to make any recommendations on wind studies until we get a determination from the Forest Service about whether those parcels are in or out of play.
3:26:45 So, you know, I think as we start to narrow this list down from seven to whatever it ends up being finally, that wind study will be an important part of, you know, finalizing the site. But I think it wouldn't be prudent to do it prior to that conversation with the Forest Service. And, you know, I think as we've all discussed, I mean, I haven't.
3:27:07 I've been involved in this stuff as long as many people in this room or even on this dais, but I know that any planning effort I've been involved in in the town has inevitably come back to the bell-shaped parcel and said, well...
3:27:20 What do we do with this site? So I think understanding the wetlands delineation, eventually probably understanding a wind study on that site will help us to determine what that ultimately ends up being because it's thrown into every conversation that we have. So it's an asset that we own. For us to not understand what that asset can be utilized with doesn't make any sense to me.
3:27:43 So I support this, and I think I would be happy to support some sort of recommendation on the wind study, pending a conversation with the Forest Service. Agree. Mr. Mayor, I'm ready to make a motion. Okay. To approve the funding not to exceed $12,000 for the delineated wetland city on the bell-shaped parcel as aligned with the Town Council approval of priority phased projects on December 16, 2015. Second. Okay.
3:28:12 I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Fernie? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Richardson? Yes. Mayor Raimondo? Yes. Motion passes 5-0, and that concludes our meeting this evening. We will adjourn to our next regular scheduled meeting Wednesday, May 4th, 2016, 6 p.m., right here. Thank you. Have a good night. Well, that was singing for me. That was learning.