TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2016

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 51 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

368 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:12 Good morning, everyone. Good morning. I will call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, May 3rd, 2016. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here? Yes. Here. Thank you. This time, I will open the floor for public comments. Anyone that has anything to share that is not on today's agenda may do so at this time. Any comments from the commission? I just have a quick public comment.

1:51 This is Public Service Recognition Week, so I just want to thank all of you for your public service as well as our staff. Thank you very much. Thank you in return. Okay. You're welcome. Okay. I will now close public comments and move to the consent agenda. Is there anything anyone wishes to poll? In that case, I would entertain a motion. I move to approve the consent agenda as stated. I will second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All in favor, please say aye.

2:26 Aye. Motion passes, 5-0. And that brings us to introducing our new Staff Assistant, Lindsay. Thank you, Chair. So this time I'd like to welcome and introduce our new Town Staff Assistant, Lindsay Lyon. Welcome, Lindsay. Brief bio of where Lindsay's from. She's originally from East Dorset, Vermont, East Coaster, but also spent 10 years living in Wilmington, North Carolina.

2:50 Lindsay attended UNC Wilmington and received a BA in Parks and Recreation Management with a concentration in public non-profit recreation, a program she said she thoroughly enjoyed. Lindsay came upon the Eastern Sierra after landing an internship with a guiding company outside of Yosemite. Following her internship, like many of us, she headed to Mammoth Mountain for one ski season. Right? But decided after the winter, actually, to pursue her long-term goal of seeing the Tetons. There you go.

3:20 Only after a short summer of the Tetons, she returned to Mammoth and has been here for the past two years working in hospitality. Lindsay's favourite pursuits, like many of us, are rock climbing, travelling, but she really enjoys backpacking, watching live music and cooking. Sounds like a Mammoth summer, right? Fit right in, that's probably why she's here. Lindsay is passionate about recreation, has a strong interest in public lands and is thrilled to join the town of Mammoth Lakes and is excited to get to know all of you as we get through our meetings. So Lindsay sits...

3:49 in our Parks and Recreation section, but she's kind of the face of the town, so anybody that does come into the town offices will be greeted by Lindsay, and she'll be directed to other town departments as needed, but she works for Parks and Recreation, so she reports to me and then is a great assistance to the staff, so here we go. Very good. Welcome, Lindsay. Welcome, Lindsay. Thank you. I told her she didn't have to stay, but she's more than welcome to. Anything he didn't cover that you'd like to tell us? Just happy to be here.

4:20 Meet you guys. Welcome. Yeah, so Lindsay's going to be great. Got some great projects we're working on, and she'll be kind of taking over a lot of the administration functions that we had Liz do previously, which is kind of active, supporting our supervisors in their facilities, working on a kind of master fee schedule slash policies procedures document, trying to bring a lot of our policies and procedures in one location. So we think that'll be really great assistance.

4:52 Integrating all of our communication platforms. So Lindsay oversees our communication plan. We'll be the new face of recreation this week. So Lindsay's putting that together as well. That'll go out every Thursday afternoon. So if you do have items, Lindsay's kind of, you know, in charge of collating all those items, putting it in, you know, that newsletter and then posting it to the community, which is great as well. And then also assimilating our website. So overseeing active, the Civic Plus site, making sure they're all up to date.

5:22 But thrilled to have us. So great project. Thank you, Jen. Thank you very much. It is. Very exciting. All right. That brings us to our presentation this morning, the 2016 Whitmore Pool Operating Plan. You just tab it. Good morning, everybody. Good morning. So I'd like to present to you guys the 2016 Whitmore Pool Operation Plan for this year. You guys have a handout there in your packet.

6:27 Okay, so for the 2016 Whitmore Pool Season, we're going to be opening up next Monday for lap swim and swim team and aquatic training. We're just getting started on our preseason, and I'm pretty excited. Another season under my belt. I'll actually be starting out next week at the pool, helping out until I get some more staff going on.

6:52 Again, we're going to be open all the way up through September 2nd this year. Again, we start our preseason May 9th, and we'll run that for about five or six weeks until school's out, and then that's when we really get going. We have our opening day on the grand opening on June 18th. That'll be our free swim day from 12 to 4, so hopefully you guys want to come down again and come hang out with us and have some barbecue and whatnot.

7:21 Also this year we had to have a slight increase in fees. So you guys can see that in the box underneath rates. Just a slight increase. You know, just kind of help cover the stuff. The only thing that didn't really change was the group rate, which we don't get a whole lot of, but we try to offer that when we get camps that will just show up from like the YMCA and we got like 40 people. So we try to help them out a little bit.

7:48 Some of the other good points this year that we have coming up. We are still going to be offering the five fun pass this year. And again, you can see the rates on page two, or I'm sorry, page one. And we'll be offering that again. And of course, the season pass that will be available starting Monday for purchase down at Whitmore Pool. So you can take care of all that down at the pool. So I hope to see you guys there.

8:19 Again, I said, like, swim team's going to be starting as well on May 10th with us, and they'll be with us through August 10th. They're also going to be hosting on June 5th a, it's the Mammoth Lakes Swim Team Splash Bash Meet and Greet, and they'll be having, it's kind of like their little time trials, like an inner squad meet, and then they're also encouraged to bring a friend to come check it out. And then afterwards, after their little

8:46 Meet, they'll have just open swim and just some fun. So I hope you guys might want to come out for that. We'll get some more information on the time for that as well. Again, the opening day is going to be June 18th. And then the Mammoth Lakes swim team is also going to host a swim-a-thon fundraiser on July 23rd on that Saturday. So you might want to come out and cheer those kids on because they're swimming laps to raise some money for their program.

9:14 Again, this year we're going to be offering our Whitmore Swim School, our Learn to Swim program, and we kind of changed it up a little bit this year. We decided to knock off two weeks at the back end, so we're condensing things down to a six-week session, or sorry, six one-week sessions of swim lessons this year, still offering all the same variety of levels that we have from preschool up to adults.

9:42 We can accommodate pretty much everybody. We also changed up a little bit, too, with our private lessons. We're going to go ahead and book those just in the month of August from the 1st to the 19th. So our swim lessons are going to go from June 20th to July 29th, and that will be our six weeks of group lessons. And then in August, again, we'll start the

10:08 Private lessons. And then also we moved our last summer we started a aquatics camp. We did that one in June. We're moving that one to the first week of August. And then we also we've added a junior lifeguard program as well. It'll be a new junior lifeguard camp that we're going to run for a week.

10:30 And that'll be kind of our wrap-up of the summer kind of programming down at Whitmore Pool. So I'm pretty excited about that camp because, I mean, I've been involved in lifeguarding since I was 15. So I'm pretty excited for that. That'll kind of help us maybe get some more kids interested so when they do reach the appropriate age to become a lifeguard, they can take the full class and maybe come work for us at Whitmore Pool. You never know. Let's see.

11:03 I think that's all I pretty much have to let you guys know. I'm just kind of ready to get started down there and shift my schedule to have to be down there at 6 o'clock in the morning for a couple weeks. Do you guys have any questions or anything? Questions for Steph?

11:32 How do you feel about the swimming pool? Is there anything that you're kind of on guard with regard to infrastructure? On the facility side, you know, it's always when we're down there now, Parks Maintenance is down there now. The pool is actually full already. I haven't gotten the latest update on our circulation pump, but...

11:52 That's like the next thing that we're just trying to get done. Everything else is in pretty good shape. We had, I know you guys remember a couple years ago we bought Max. He is our vacuum that we...

12:03 Can put in overnight because one of the issues that we had was being open for such a stretch, you know, 12 hours a day, essentially, there was no time to really get the pool clean, so we applied for those Measure R funds a couple years ago, and you guys, we were able to get Max, and he just went down south for service, got all fixed up, and he's ready to go, and I know the maintenance guys stuck him in last week to, you know, get him going again, so.

12:31 I haven't spent too much time down there yet, but I will be starting next week, so I'll start getting that place ship shape until my next staff person comes on on the 16th is when my next person is available to come help out with the preseason of lap swim and swim team. Did want to follow up on Commissioner Turner's comments. So Dennis' years of duct tape and epoxy did finally fail, and the circulation pump did fail. So we've ordered a replacement.

13:01 It's on its way. It's getting installed this week. It was a decision we had to make. We didn't want to try and punt running again through the season and then having that fail and then be inoperable for, you know, weeks. So that's being installed this week, hopefully Friday, and then they'll keep us on track for Monday. That was about a $5,000 investment. And actually, I think we've replaced every pump at Whitmore. We replaced the bore field pumps as well, that main circulation pump over there, and now the pool pump.

13:30 There we go. Yeah. Okay, good. Good. So we think we're in pretty good shape. Yeah. Time will tell. We need just to mostly get down there and just get it running and keep it running. So I'm very appreciative for the fact that we were able to earn the money to get a new circulation pump because, you know, my experience down there is, yeah, a lot of gum and, I always say gum and duct tape, but, yeah.

13:52 No, it gets you far when you need it to. Yep. Everything else seems to be pretty good down there, all of our other hard or, you know, durable equipment like lane lines, pool covers. We'll probably be looking at some replacement in another season or two, mostly just the lane lines. I was inspecting those last week when I was down there, and those were actually purchased well over 10 years ago.

14:20 well over 10 years ago because Emily Falkenheim was still the board president and that's what they did that year with their youth sports funding money as they pitched in and they bought us new lane lines. So that might be something either we can repair or may need to replace down the road. But other than that...

14:38 We just need a few more things, maybe another top doc for swim lessons to replace the one that we have that needs to be replaced. But other than that, I'm just waiting to get all my staff back and get them in there and get excited. We've got probably over 25 swim lesson sign-ups.

14:57 In the various sessions and time slots. So things are, you know, we're already way ahead of the game. Last year we opened up the swim lessons on active on about May 17th. I think was the note that I was looking at. So, and we opened all that stuff on May 1st. I'm sorry, April 1st when we opened all the camps. Everything launched at the same time. So I've already got quite a few. I'm pretty impressed that, you know, people are, you know, wanting to book ahead and get ready.

15:26 For summer. Yeah, I think people are appreciative of that. One last question for you is just I don't see hours of operation essentially for the free swim. Am I just not seeing that? Well, I didn't include the entire operating hours. We do have a preseason schedule that we'll be running now. Basically, it's 6 a.m. Well, I'm there 6 to 9. So 6.30 to 8.30 is lap swim. And then I go away. And then I'll come back down for swim team in the afternoon.

15:59 And then on Tuesdays and Thursdays I'll stay after for adult lap swim. So that's kind of our operating schedule for the next six weeks, and then we go into full operation. And I apologize, I was going to give you guys some rec guides to throw in there too, because it has our full schedule. But those hours will be on the website and clear for everyone? Everything's on the website right now, yes.

16:22 Thank you. And, yeah, again, we open June 18th for our free swim day. That'll be 12 to 4, and then pretty much all the rec swims Monday through Friday are 12.30 to 3.30, and Saturdays and Sundays, 12 to 4. We'll just close on Memorial, 4th of July.

16:41 And we have one private rental in August for the town employee picnic that will be closed on. Other than that, it's all weather permitting. Okay. I'm sorry to be following up with so many questions, but Betsy, when's the last day of school? June 7th. Okay. How come we're not opening sooner? Staff. Some of it has to do with how much staff I have. It just depends on year to year. Last year we did kind of a little soft opening a week early on the 13th. Okay.

17:10 But again, like this year, I have mostly, most of my lifeguards are in high school or college. So I only have very limited staff to even open next week. Okay. We do have, I think, there's some weekend rentals scheduled those early weekends besides swim team, right? I think there's... The only rentals that I have scheduled right now is I have June 4th. I have the Mona Lake committees coming for like their, oh my gosh, I can't even remember, 20th year. They come every year and...

17:38 Bring the canoes down for their canoe training for the guides that do the canoe tours out on Mona Lake. So they bring a couple canoes down, they swamp them and do all that training in a more controlled environment. I also have the local Girl Scouts are coming for a pool party on June 11th.

17:56 On that Saturday. And then pretty much after that, we've got a couple days of training the following week. Swim team will already have started their double workouts. And then by the 18th, that's it. We're full operation. Okay. Till August 20th, 29th. Okay. Thank you. Those are all the questions I have. Any other questions for Steph?

18:19 I just have one question. So on the private lessons, so if someone really wants a private lesson earlier in the season, staff will try to accommodate that if possible? We may be able to accommodate them. The hardest thing that I found with trying to book privates during the regular swim lessons is having enough staff. You know, honestly, I could use, like, three more people down there to help accommodate everything, but that's just the way it kind of works, and we don't get a ton of privates.

18:46 One or two. So we're going to see how this schedule works this year, and if not, we can always change it back. But really, it is staff dependent because I need to take care of my group lessons first and make sure I have enough instructors because if you guys notice when you go through, and I don't know how much, you know, it's...

19:03 How much knowledge do you guys have on swim lessons? But we took some of the younger kid classes and shrunk the groups down to make it a more better experience for the tiny tots and the level ones, the lower level classes. We changed the ratios on that just to provide a better experience for the kids. So we need every instructor I can get out there. Well, thank you very much. All right. Is that it? See you Monday morning. Early. I'll see you on Monday.

19:33 6 a.m. Okay, so that brings us into our discussion items. So we'll move on to item 7, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Planning Update and Programming in place. So we're going to do a little tag team. Grady will cover section A, which is just a follow-up from the Town Council meeting on April 20th. And we did for the benefit of the commission, if you weren't at that meeting and you weren't able to receive or review that presentation, we've attached it to your staff report.

20:04 It's also online if you did want to view it. And then we'll kind of wrap up with items B, C, and D after Grady kind of runs through the action from April 20. Thank you. And most of the information we presented to Council on April 20 of this group has seen before because we've been before you on a monthly basis giving you updates. So I don't want to, I don't have to go through every detail. But again, you're welcome to, more than welcome to look at the Council presentation from last week.

20:33 What I really want to focus on is sort of the last couple things we did in the last meeting with the community in March and then how we looked at the final alternatives. So in the PowerPoint, there's actually an alternate, all the way back, it's probably 10 or 12 in, it's called Alternate A Revised. And what we did was, in response to some of the things that we heard just in the last couple of weeks,

20:59 The slide just before that, we actually added some additional support area for the possibility of future winter uses. We increased the size of the ice sheet from an NHL-sized rink to an Olympic-sized sheet of 100 by 200, and we really looked at some of the site planning, too.

21:18 Look at what we could possibly do over on the west side. Thank you, Stu. So this is the final one that we're taking forward for the environmental process. What it did do in terms of actual square footages, we've talked several times about having a multi-use facility and approximately 10,000 square feet of community facilities, which could be community center, community room, you know, it's whatever the community needs at the time we're building it. We've expanded that slightly in the upper left-hand corner, so we're really adding now about 13,000 square feet.

21:48 That does by no means mean that's going to be built in Phase 1 or Phase 2 or Phase 3, but again, since we're going through the environmental process, we wanted to create the maximum footprint we thought we would have there in the next 10 or 20 years so that if we come back later and we've got a lot of interest from hockey folks or figure skaters and we need more locker rooms, we at least have the square footage that we've analyzed and we can do that. Again, we don't know what the first phase is going to be.

22:14 What we've done actually since the council meeting, we actually had a meeting with our environmental consultant, a teleconference with them and our architect, and we got them kicked off on the environmental document. By the end of today, staff is providing back to the environmental document a lot of detail about the uses for the facility, which come out of the programming efforts, square footages, sizes, all those types of things. In fact, when I get back to my office, I'll finish my comments up and send them back to them as well.

22:43 PEDC on June 8th for a scoping meeting for the EIR. Typically that process is a two-step where we go through the initial study checklist first.

22:54 And then, frankly, decide whether an EIR or a mitigated neg deck or a negative declaration or whatever is appropriate. In this case, since we've committed from the beginning to the community that we do an EIR, we're just going right to that step. The environmental consultant and our outside counsel looked at it and said that's more than appropriate. In fact, it's even better because you're already admitting, look, you're going to look at all these things. In that first part of the EIR, if there's something we don't have to look at or if we find it's a...

23:20 Less than significant. It can drop out at that time. That scoping meeting will be June 8th in front of PEDC. What we'll be doing as engineering and rec staff in the meantime while they're starting the environmental process is we'll be coming back and looking at refining the design somewhat. We need to get additional detail for the environmental work in terms of some...

23:45 Some of the materials and things. And again, we can't go too far into preliminary design, but we want to try to identify that. So we'll be coming back to you with regular updates as well, saying, look, this is what we're thinking in terms of the kind of the character of the building and some of the details. We'll also be looking at cost estimates. That's something that we want to wrap up within, say, 45 days, because we want to report back to town council, to this group, and to MLR to say, look, this is what we're recommending as a first phase. Is that first phase the

24:14 The ice rink, basically, rec zone with 3,000 or 5,000 square foot of support facilities, and does that support facility include a 2,000 square foot community center, community room? We're looking at all the data that we got through the program, and we'll come back with a recommendation to this group, and then take it on from there. Because the idea is, by, this is the early May, by sometime in July, to be able to provide to town council, MLR, look, this is what we're suggesting.

24:41 So they know how much money we need to find, frankly, because, again, this is not fully funded for the whole thing. That's our goals on it. Again, I can answer any questions you might have about the process. One thing we did in town council meeting is we emphasized the...

24:56 The open nature of the whole process and most of the meetings, frankly, were programming meetings, but we did have 15 opportunities for the public to attend over a three and a half month period. So there's ample opportunity. There'll be more opportunity during the CEQA process because there's a scoping meeting, a 30-day public review, and a 45-day public review once EIR is out. So everybody's going to have their chance and we welcome that. So any questions? Questions for Grady on this piece?

25:25 I have some, but I always feel like I start, so, okay. And I hope I didn't just miss it. And I had to leave the last programming session just a little bit early. What's the current feeling, and I think we were just starting to talk about that area too, the west of the location. What's the current, what came out of that last programming meeting or thoughts? Yeah, so I was going to jump in on that one too. So at this time,

25:54 The project description is requesting kind of what space or what passive use we want to consider that space for. We came up with some ideas at that programming meeting. I'm just kind of putting them forward to the group to kind of consider. But one was an urban kind of winter snow play area, which is kind of that big mound bank that can be used for sledding and those type of things. And then in summer, one of the ideas was to kind of build a soft surface BMX pump track.

26:23 That was one of the things came out of it as well. We've also talked about dog parks, right, that came up as well. We've talked about community gardens, that came up as well. But, you know, for right now, we're just trying to figure out, again, I don't know if there was really one definitive answer, but that was kind of the recommendations that we're going to put forward, so. And I appreciate that because we...

26:44 And again, it sounds backwards. We want to make it as noisy as possible for the first iteration of the CEQA process. If we do a BMX type track and they come back and say, well, that'll go, you know, X decibels within 100 feet and that might cause a problem. We might have to mitigate that. We'll just, that might just come off the list. But we want to push it out there and analyze it. We analyze sort of the worst case scenario. And then if it needs to back off to winter play instead and something different in the summer, we'll do so. But that's the first.

27:11 Different idea we've heard in a while, so I think we'll include that. Something with if we're going dog park or going that area, maybe it could be dog agility. I know that we've bought dog agility equipment, and maybe that area would be good to be set up for something like that, because if you're looking at all the information that you're getting on dog parks and stuff, that seems to be the way that a lot of them are going now, that they're integrating that dog agility into that whole area.

27:41 That's a good idea. In a minute I want to ask you the question and I want to phrase it in a way that you explain just kind of what's the current feeling in the community with regard to supporting it as well as against it. And I want to actually make sure I hear comments from both sides of kind of the feelings towards it. But before I ask that question, you know, I want to make sure that we're able to utilize this space and at the same time be as...

28:09 Cognizant with regard to our neighbors who are there for sound. I don't want, you know, I want to find some kind of use for this. I don't want to just let it go the way it is if we're going to be building such a great location here just to the east of it. At the same time, you know, we have to be careful that it doesn't hold up the entire process, too. So I understand that you've got a bit of a challenge here with regard to that.

28:32 So anyway, glad we're still looking at that. Don't want that to hold up the process, but it obviously is critical that we use that space. What is the current mood in the community with regard to any kind of resistance you're getting from the neighbors, support from the neighbors, that kind of thing? Well, Stu might address a couple of the emails you've received in the last couple of weeks, but...

28:56 My view of it is overall everybody who attended all the workshops is overwhelmingly positive and overwhelmingly wants it from the community. We're still getting emails and we still will get emails and correspondence from the neighbors who oppose it because they just wanted to remain open space. It was encouraging that one of the emails we received from somebody who, you know, violently, not violently, but vehemently...

29:20 with or against the project in the early days now is saying, well, we don't want to oppose the project. We just want it done right. We want you to take care. We want you to respect our privacy and our issues as well. So that tenor kind of changed. But again, I'm still expecting that we'll get opposition. We just hope they show up early and they bring up issues that we are able to address because if they don't show up and tell us what we're looking at, it's harder to address them.

29:48 We're looking forward to it. If I can jump in real quick before I let Sean go on to the next question. You're doing a great job. Thank you. One of my fears, and I've expressed this over and over, last time we included BMX in the environmental report, and the homeowners used that as we're putting in a BMX track in order to push home that the homeowners aren't going to want this because it's not about the truth, it's about...

30:12 opposing the project. So as we move down this, what are we doing to make sure the homeowners understand this is something we're looking at, not something we're doing, so that those that are opposed to it cannot use that piece, that BMX piece, or anything else that might create noise or action or kids having actual fun to oppose the project. Well, as an example, if our environmental consultant does a noise analysis of a BMX,

30:41 Use back there and says, gee, you can have 40 kids and parents and yelling and screaming and it'll be an issue. We'll just take it off the list. We won't even propose it. It won't make it. It may be in the scoping meeting, but it won't make it to the IR because we are not going to suggest something that that's something that's unmitigable. We're not going to build a 26-foot wall on the West property line, and if that's what it means, it would just come off the list. It's just a use we won't allow.

31:06 We're going to look at it. But even if our consultant comes back and says that's a non-starter, then we'll take it off the list before it gets to the homeowners. But again, in the scoping meeting, we'll explain that we're looking at these things. We want their comments. We'll see what happens. But we're ready to react to that, I guess.

31:23 And just to jump in kind of on this correspondence and public mood, Stu's been putting all the correspondence up on the website. There's a fair amount of it, so it was a lot to go in the packet, but it's definitely worth taking some time to go through. There's a nice letter in there from Elizabeth Tenney. There's some really good written feedback in there, and that's all on the site.

31:43 Well, and the only thing I want to follow up on that, and my question is coming with regard to this, is that I hope that the public and the neighbors and everyone really does get engaged as early as possible, because the goal here is, and I'm glad to hear that the email you referred to is becoming more wanting to make sure it's done right. We want that too. And so I really want to make sure that the public is invited and participates early with the understanding that we all are trying to just get to a solution.

32:12 By Halloween of 2017 that we're able to open this first phase at the least by Halloween 17. And so, you know, are we still on track? Are there any concerns with regard to that timeline? In the PowerPoint as well is an updated schedule. And the way I framed it was when we came to Recreation Commission on December 1st, we had a schedule. And it's in your packet.

32:38 It took us a couple weeks extra to get started, but we had committed at December 1st to come back to Council in April with a preferred alternative. We did that. So we're spot on schedule. The environmental consultants on track. They're confident they can get this done in the time frame that's necessary. The one thing I did explain to Council, I'll mention it again or two, is we are still committed and confident that we can open the ice rink on October 31st.

33:04 There's no commitment to being able to open a 3,000 or a 5,000 square foot community center on that date. The time period for construction is just plain is longer. There's more design issues involved. So it may be under construction. We don't know because, you know, there's funding issues and a lot of other decisions between now and then. But the commitment is still on the rink.

33:23 opening on Halloween. We hope that we'll also be under construction on an added community center for the community in some fashion, whether, again, 3,000 square feet or five, we don't know yet, but we're still on track. So my takeaway from that answer is, yes, we're still on track for the ice rink with a roof.

33:44 B, number two, and I think we've tried to be as clear as possible, is that that is our goal. You know, we've never really promised the community center or anything beyond the ice rink with a roof by Halloween of 2017, but my takeaway is that we're on track with that. If we can do more, great. Great. Okay, thank you. Shoot, there was one more question. Oh, looking at the alternative site plan again,

34:11 Sorry, that blue oval that's in there, and I know we keep talking about moving at least the community center over just a little bit to the east. I'm still not seeing that in the plan. Did you address that? That's something we've already addressed with our architect, and next time we meet with him, we'll be looking at the architecture, and indeed that entry area, that blue area, will more than likely shift to the east to get a better entrance statement. Again, we wanted to get to...

34:39 It's kind of linear, one thing at a time, but we have not forgotten about that by any means, and we do expect to move that further to the east for a variety of reasons. Okay. When will we see that actually in a plan, and how come it hasn't been done yet? I know it's in discussion. You've talked about it. I just want to be clear. When will we see that in a plan, do you think? It should be in mid-July when we come back. You don't have a July meeting, is that correct?

35:03 Right. But we'll distribute that information if you don't have a meeting. We'll make it available. It'll be on the website, and we'll make sure that everybody here gets that so you can take a look at it as we progress. Okay. Thank you. I think that's it for now. Well, we can certainly schedule a meeting as well if we have, you know, if we want to make a recommendation or comments. Any other questions for Grady on this portion? I have, I just have one more comment.

35:29 You know, realizing, understanding that the community center is not moving forward. I'm still having an issue with how the tier one is worded.

35:37 Where it says, Complementary Facility to Support Operations of the Multi-Use Facility with Community Space for Social Interaction, Programming and Community Events. It still seems to me that we're putting emphasis on support for the ice rink as opposed to a community center. And I have a huge concern on that. I realize that it's stated in here that there is with community space. I think that almost needs to be flipped, that it's a community center with support.

36:05 For the ice rink, because I think that that's where the emphasis goes on is the way it's written. So anyhow, it's a concern of mine. And I kind of was blindsided at the last programming meeting, so I want to make sure that we're looking at a community center and understanding that there may be support for the ice rink. Because truly, if we don't have the funding to build the ice rink with the support that it needs to function,

36:35 Then it should be held off until we have that. And we're looking at a community center separately. Are you looking at page two of this document? I'm looking at where it says community center. Okay, all the way up there. So why don't we, because I think Stu is going to present the playbook work, and we can talk a little bit about our discussion on that with our programming committee. So if we could just hold on that for just a minute. So that would be great. And then I'll take public comment when we've gone all the way through the staff presentation. It would be great. So does that sound good?

37:05 Any other questions for Grady on the planning part piece? I'm staying. Yes, I'll just wrap up just the second page of the staff report very quickly. So April 5th was the lunchtime workshop, which was following the workshop, sorry, our meeting here on April 5th. That was with the playologist from Game Time. Actually made a great...

37:32 Very detailed, very informative presentation to the community on inclusive playgrounds and what it means to be inclusive and I think that was a definition that I think solidified for the participants of the workshop and really what it meant.

37:46 Because I think there's varying degrees of inclusivity. And inclusivity is not only kind of a mental or a physical disability, but it's also adults, it's youth, it's everybody with any type of disabled ability. So I think that was a really key point. We also talked about the components. We also talked about the surfacing of that area. And we also did, we were able to actually walk around the site with the consultants as well.

38:15 View of the facility, what we're proposing, and then we're still talking with Miracle and other company as well on that space over there. So that was a very productive workshop. We also got some great feedback from an eight-year-old on what they actually want to see in the playground, so that was really good. So if you do get on the main plan MCP page, you'll actually see that information up there as well. Wrapping up the workshop for our programming was April 12th. I thought it was a great turnout.

38:43 We had over 30 community members that kind of reviewed the playbooks. We spent about 30 minutes going through all the community input received to date and then were able to present them in kind of what we call the playbook, which I think kind of pulls in a day in the life of that facility that people can kind of touch, feel and see a little bit more of what could actually take place.

39:09 in those three separate facilities that we talked about. The work that we're doing now just for the original project description notice of preparation that we did with the workshop participants and also particularly with our committee and I do want to thank the chair and Commissioner Turner for facilitating those workshops.

39:33 They started, I think, a little slowly. I think we were talking more, and then by the end of the workshops, we were talking less, and the committee members were really providing great, insightful feedback to the programming for those facilities. So we wrapped up the last programming committee meeting last Friday, 8 o'clock. Most, if not all, the committee members were in attendance. That was great.

39:57 And then what we did at that time was really kind of look at the estimated number of people, the programs, when they would start, when they would end. And then, as we said, we talked about the open space in the west of that facility. So what we're really doing now is wrapping that information up, getting it back to Grady and his crew to kind of take that next step. So the playbooks have a little bit more detail than what we had before, really kind of identifying.

40:22 When the activities would take place generally, right, they're just kind of approximate times and then just looking at approximate number of people at one time as well. So that was kind of the extent of the committee. What we're doing following up with the committee is we're going to probably work just as our recreation programming committee with Chair Truex and Commissioner Turner again on drilling down and kind of finalising or at least kind of putting together a framework operating plan for those facilities.

40:51 on a year-round perspective. So looking at again taking the playbook information and then applying some assumed revenue and expenditures for that facility to try and give us a year-round budget. So that process is probably about a one, two-month process we think before it gets into July 4th and everybody's gone in summer again. So that's kind of our plan there with that project.

41:16 And then I think as the Chair said, we have a lot of information that's been posted on the website. All the inputs there, all the meetings there, all the playbooks are up there. Again, the outreach for that process has slowed down. At this time, it's becoming a lot more selective with the completion of the playbook. So that's kind of the wrap-up from that staff report. Chair, if you had any other questions on that.

41:37 Thank you. If I could just add a couple of things. One, so that committee, we may get them back together, but at this point we will sort of bring in, you know, we'll bring in the ICE people to talk about timing and numbers of people for the ICE as we build that operating plan. So we'll kind of just bring in, you know, sort of the relevant people into Sean's and my regular programming committee meetings. And then, Stu, could you also just talk a little bit about the discussion we had about the tiering on Friday? Because I think that ties into Terry's comment a little bit as well.

42:07 Yeah, so if you do have a look at the playbooks, we can pull them up, but really the goal of those playbooks was trying to identify, and I know the wording is going to get weird here, but either buckets or tiers or groups. Again, they're not kind of really prioritised. What we've really tried to describe is what happens on a daily basis, what happens on a weekly basis, what would happen on an infrequent monthly basis. So that's kind of how we broke down all the activities that came forth in the programming. So when the committee looked at this on Friday, they really kind of

42:36 Disregarded the tiering, right? They just looked at actually the programming. So what they kind of just determined was, well, what's the programming going to take place? They really said they didn't like the language, so we told them to ignore it. They didn't like the language either, so we said, well, that's fine. It's just a planning document at this point. So what we really were looking into was the detail in regards to what is the activity, when is it going to take place, how many people would be there, right? Is it a morning? Is it an afternoon? Is it a weekend? Is it a weekday?

43:04 That's really the specificity that the planning group really needs to analyze the activities in the facility. So that's kind of where that's at right now. So if that answered your question. It did. Thank you. And I want to thank Stu, too, because we had kind of a fast turnaround in putting these playbooks together. And so I think he spent most of a weekend writing them, collating all the stuff. So still being refined. Yes, a long way to go.

43:33 Okay, so questions? Do you want to add anything to your comment on the community piece? You know, I just have an issue with the way that this is written and that, you know, we've told the community we're looking at a community center, not a support facility for the ice rink. So I think that there is...

44:00 Some support that has always been talked about that is going to be within that building, but it kind of got a turnaround and became more of a support facility as opposed to a community center. And I'm not okay with that because if we're going to build a facility and we need that support to make that facility successful,

44:20 Then that needs to be talked about within that facility for that facility, and that needs to be included in that budgeting, and that needs to be up front. And then we need to have the community center being spoke of and being operated as a community center. So it's just a concern of mine that kind of came up with, we're going to go, well, phase one is going to be more support, and I just have this, you know, will we ever get to phase two? And unfortunately, what...

44:48 I see that our needs are right now as a community center. So anyhow, that's my personal opinion. Yeah, I'll just quickly follow up that and, you know, that came up at the committee meeting too, you know, when we actually had an agenda and the committee just completely went off topic. First we can get them to start talking, then we can get them to stop talking. They didn't do any of the tasks that we wanted them to do, but they did have that discussion about, you know, a lot of those.

45:16 Facilities and Designs. And they did come and spend probably about 45 minutes discussing that facility and how it could work. And I think a lot of their concerns of the committee is if we're going to build a facility, we want to make sure it starts with or it has the opportunity to be successful straight off from day one.

45:34 So they really wanted to make sure that it had the opportunity to do that. So it did have those locker spaces. It did have those rooms that were required to operate a fully functional professional facility as opposed to kind of what we have. So they were really wrestling with that as well. So they wanted to make sure that there was sufficient space for the ice rink to be successful and then understanding really what a community centre would be. So if it's a community centre with complementary space for an ice rink,

46:01 Great. I just don't know if it's really a wording thing, but I think the essence of that conversation was to make sure that... The essence of my point is if we're calling it a community center, that we're building a community center. And if we're calling it support facilities, then you call it support facilities. And that you have the funding, and you have the funding to build a proper facility with the support facilities, and that should be inclusive of that funding and of that space, and that your community center is separate.

46:31 So, anyhow. Yeah, and I think it'll be a good discussion moving forward in regards to how we can kind of piece this together. However, I agree with the concept that while the ice rink needs support, it doesn't, and so does the community center. We don't need to build two full sets of bathrooms and two full sets of locker rooms. So how do we call it out? Maybe we need to say that this is all part of the ice rink, and it will then go to support the community center when the community center is built.

46:58 I mean, that's just pure semantics. Except for the way that it was presented was not semantics. The way it was presented was absolutely not semantics. And so that's why I just want to make sure.

47:10 That what we are doing moving forward is not semantics and that we are looking at a proper, if we're looking at putting a community center, it's a proper community center and that it's proper support facilities, that we are looking at one and the same. No, I'm not looking at building two bathrooms in two of this. No, I'm not looking at that at all. But if we're going to have a community center, I don't want that to be secondary to the support facilities. Right. However, the support, probably if I were doing it, I would make it three complete separate.

47:39 Items, because you have the support facilities, which are going to support both, and you have the multi-use facility on one side, and you have the community center on the other. The support facilities for both are common, but they both need the same thing. So we could, ostensibly, if it made anybody feel better, break it out into three. Well, bathrooms, yes. Locker rooms, no. So, anyways. I think, I just want to jump in, too, because I think what happened was, I think that the committee

48:08 coming out of the workshops because we got so many requests for

48:13 Things, because it was, people could really grasp the multi-use facility. They had a harder time, I think, grasping the community center. And so I think because we got so many requests for so many things in the community center, I think, and Sean and Stu, you guys can jump in, but I think the committee kind of got a little bit worried that we were trying to make the community center all things to all people. And as they kind of tried to narrow it down, I think that was where that language came from. And I don't know that that was the intent, but that was kind of where that came from, I think.

48:41 And again, it just reminds me how important it is that we're being, you know, I think we all do have this shared vision of what the end product will look like. We just need to be very clear with the public and ourselves when things will be completed. If I could add something, and I encourage you to go back and listen to the council comments as well from last week because it was very clear that they said do it right.

49:07 Do it right. Include everything you can. We'll find the budget for it. I mean, they were very strong in that, especially Shields, who had previously not supported the project as much. This time he came out and said, look, if you're going to do this, do it right. Don't back off. So I think you have great support of Council, better than we've had before, to do what needs to be done. And that's fine. It's just that then we need to look at, you know, every time we take another step, the funding is...

49:34 You know, just a bit more off. So we need to look at that. We're still on track for just the ice rink and the roof, and so keep that clear. But for the support facilities or the community center, it is not.

49:47 And so just along that line, I'll go to public comment in a minute. So, Grady, can you just, at the bottom of the first page of the staff report, it talks about the cost estimates will include a range of phasing concepts and funding alternatives. Do you want to, can you just elaborate on that a little bit because I think that ties into this discussion. Basically, what we are tasked with bringing back to council is, as an example, we need to show them a phase that is just...

50:11 Reconstructing the existing ice rink and putting a roof on it because that's what they currently have set aside, you know, earmarked approximately $2.3 million to do. So we're going to show them what that takes, you know, in a good form. We don't expect and hope they don't ask us to do that, but we have to show that as a cost estimate. The next will be, okay, we've committed to getting the ice rink open on October 31st. What does that mean? What does that take? The first phase that staff is supporting that I hear from

50:40 This group and from Town Council, however, is a first phase that includes the ice rink, rec zone, and a true community center of, you know, is it 3,000 feet, is it 5,000 square feet with support? We don't know yet. We're getting into that. But we're going to give them that range, and then we'll give them the full boat. And that, you know, again, we're just trying to give them enough information to be able to make a decision to find the funding for it and move it forward. So, again, our recommendation, absolutely, it has been from the beginning.

51:09 5,000 square feet along with the ice rink, and in that 5,000 feet is support facilities for both, but we will definitely estimate that. The square footage is fine, but it was being talked about paring it down, and then so that kind of changed things if it was pared down. Understood. Okay, so other questions for staff before I take public comment? Clayton? Is there any other questions? Any other questions? No. I'm good. Okay.

51:41 Open for public comment, and then I'll bring it back to the commission to have a little more discussion. Morning, Madam Chair, commissioners, staff, members of the public. I feel like I'm pretty involved in this process. I'm trying to figure out where this thing got turned, the nickel got turned a little bit from support, because we've been talking complimentary facilities since day one. You know, and I feel like I've been involved in this process, but it is a bit of disconcerting to me to hear support, because we've been talking complimentary.

52:11 The PowerPoint presentation, page two, continues to talk about complementary sites. And we've been pushing that since day one. And if it changes, that's great. I appreciate the process. It's going to unfold. It's going to evolve. But if I'm not in that loop about where this came from, I don't know where the rest of the world is. You know, I appreciate your comments, Teri, because we've been talking complementary. And if it changes, that's great. But in my role, in my...

52:37 conversations and my active engagement with you all. You know, it was when I first heard it that first evening and Stu came back and that, I think it was March 18th or no, March 22nd conversation. You know, it was mentioned support, that it was no complimentary. So as this unfolds and evolves, I really think if I'm not in the loop and where this is coming from, I'm concerned about where the rest of the community is. And down the road, you know, we're looking at design.

53:03 Program, and I appreciate the operation plan over the next couple of months, and we're trying to raise funds, we're trying to build relationships right now, so when the ask comes, people know who we are, we can sell that dream, but I think we need to make sure that everybody's in this loop, and as these things do change, you know, maybe there's some subcommittee that maybe invite more people to the table, because I know for myself at the executive MLR, as a board member right now for MLR,

53:29 I'm sure the rest of my other board members are not on this list by that. They're also on the same opinion complimentary, which is what we've been talking about since we started these conversations in late July. So my two cents on a Tuesday morning. Good morning. Thank you. Thank you very much. Any other public comments? Okay. So seeing none, I'll bring it back. There's one thing. You mentioned Community Center several times this morning, and this is unrelated but related.

54:00 If you have an event of the community center in the next week or a couple of weeks or whenever, we're going to have parking issues because officially the parking lot across the street from the village is closed as of today, actually maybe yesterday. We don't know how long it's going to be closed, whether it's a week or it's a month and why this beyond, you know.

54:19 This person to talk about, but the point is, it is closed, so the community center parking lot will be full. We will be policing that more and enforcing that. But if you have an event or something, just warn people. Just something I wanted to mention, because it's community center, we've been talking about that, so that parking lot will be full. Thank you. How long is it closed for? Good question. But it's closed. It's closed. Chained across the...

54:42 I haven't been out there physically, but that's the note I got. We expected that. Now, we are working with the operator of the facility, Mark, can't remember Mark's last name, thanks, who's talking to the owner of the lot and talking about when it can reopen and stuff, but I have no details on it. I just want to let you know that as of today, it's definitely closed, so it'll impact the community center. But the golf course is opening.

55:04 Yeah. Of course, it's definitely opening. We have an email. I can forward you that email if you like. Please do. The town manager. That would be great. And, you know, we've had conversations about, you know, the stress that, you know, parking already is putting on the community center. So I'm sure that if we have scheduled events in the community center, staff will try to.

55:25 Yeah, staff will try to set aside parking for the people using that, our facility. It is difficult. One of the meetings that I went there, I'm like, oh, we're going to have 30, 40 people here. And I walked in and went, who's everybody? There's no parking. It's a different meeting. And we were there early to try and block spaces off. We're parking attendants. It is an issue. And it is posted as two-hour parking, correct? So it's just a matter of we're going to start enforcing that. And if we have an event, we'll try to block it off early so we can keep it for that.

55:55 Probably ought to make sure that we publicize that. So we're going to start enforcing it. This morning we got the official notice. So you'll forward that to all of us. What has changed though also is that we have the prohibition on parking on town streets. That did expire April 30. So we're past that winter restriction. So there's more opportunity for parking.

56:19 Okay, so back to our regular meeting. Back to our facilities. Okay. Brady, just had to bring it up. No more public comment for you. So other comments just from the commission on the process, on the playbooks. I mean, we're still kind of trying to really, I think, nail down the information that's needed to forward to the consultants on timing and number of people. So any other?

56:47 Feedback? No. So it's looking like July where there might be some more solid information that could be taken out to hopefully raise funds and that type of thing? Okay. Correct. And PDEC is June 7th? June 8th. June 8th.

57:04 Right, so that's actually when this document will come forward, so this is kind of the project description. But then with the new drawings and the new, that information, I heard July, am I correct on that one? Correct. June 8th is really the scoping meeting so that the community can have input as to.

57:21 What we're going to look at with EIR. We'll continue to work with the architect on the rest. I just don't anticipate us, because that would actually be three weeks from now to get the staff report ready to go to June 8th, and it's just not going to happen. And that's just the first scoping meeting in June, right? Correct. That's correct. Yeah, because I think...

57:40 I think we're all pretty familiar with the type of information that we've presented to planning and economic development, but I think the commission would probably like to see whatever goes before council before that happens. So I appreciate that. Quick question, just because I can't. Actually, at the back of our agenda, it says the next meeting is May 3rd, which is today. It just missed a one. That's a typo. So we apologize. May 31. May 31.

58:10 Okay. So the next regular scheduled meeting of Recreation Commission is May 31. Correct. We originally moved our June 7th meeting because we thought Election Day would be in here. Got it. Okay. And then June 8th, I'm sorry, the meeting on that? Planning and Economic Development Commission that afternoon. Thank you. Send out some meeting requests. I appreciate it. All right. So any further comments on that?

58:40 And I would say maybe, too, if you have specific comments on programming for the playbooks, maybe send them to Stu. Just be helpful, I think, as we keep refining those. Okay. Awesome. All right. So that brings us to item number eight, the alignment of vision and strategic direction of community recreation in Mammoth Lakes with proposed town council goals and strategies. So this is a follow-up item from your workshop, actually, on...

59:11 April 6th, I believe, with the Council. The discussion item talked about analysing and comparing the current proposed Town Council goal and strategy document with the adopted Vision Strategic Direction of Community Recreation in Mammoth Lakes document, which speaks specifically to how the Recreation Commission and the Parks and Recreation Department is implementing those goals and strategies throughout the community.

59:40 So what I've done to hopefully walk us through a productive conversation here is to, one, just summarize the five key strategies of that vision document, which is kind of listed on page one. You can see items one through five. The draft of the Town Council Goals and Priorities document has four strategic priorities, and I'll just kind of run through them with you. That's enhance our recreation-based economy, comprehensive community plan,

1:00:06 Enhanced Community Amenities Serving Residents and Visitors, and Effective Municipal Services. So the section that has the most relevance to the Recreation Commission is the Enhanced Community Amenities Serving Residents and Visitors. And I've pulled out two of these items. So one is the siting of new trails and community amenities. And then the other topic of discussion is participate in the creation of a sustainable recreation program.

1:00:36 with the International Forest. So what we've done is provided both those documents. The master document that they're currently working off, we attach to this staff report, and I believe it is on page three. So if you haven't seen this document, you know, it kind of goes from left to right. So you start on the left of the document, which is you can kind of see the town of Mammoth Lakes commitments, works through kind of the kickstart, and then we've broken it down into quarters.

1:01:05 And then you give some milestone or victory column at the end of what that really means. So when you look at the left-hand side, go to the right-hand side and kind of tell you kind of what we're really visioning to achieve with that commitment or that goal. So with that, I'm going to turn it back to the Commission. And I think that probably gives you a good place to start with your discussion. Stu, off the top here, maybe I'm just not getting it.

1:01:36 How is it that one and three aren't connected in the same darn thing? Enhance our recreation-based commodity economy and enhanced community amenities serving residents and visitors. An amenity can be anything, but our job here is recreation. So we certainly should be at the forefront of enhancing our economy through enhanced amenities.

1:02:07 Well, I think they all tie together. Yeah, they all do. So not to interrupt Stu, but I mean, effective municipal services, I mean, that's our department too, so. Well, except municipal services to me, that's the greatest department. There's all of the other things that we are not involved in. But those two items were definitely. I think maybe the question really for the commission.

1:02:28 I think the direction that we got from Council was just basically to look at this and just see if the work that the community does based on our strategic direction is aligned with this work. I think that's kind of the question, if that makes sense. I think if we read our, you know, division and strategic direction for the community recreation in Mammoth Lakes, I think it actually does tie pretty well into that.

1:02:55 I was kind of questioning where it says the five strategies for delivery of community recreation, refocus the work program of the Rec Commission. We've already done that. Is there another redirection that we're looking at doing?

1:03:12 We just haven't updated it. This is the same document. Yeah, so we haven't updated this at all. Oh, okay. Because, you know, I think I went through the, you know, our strategy, and I think that it does still play into this. And so when we're looking at our, you know, our goals and our work program for the future that, you know, we would need to kind of keep these items in mind as we're doing that. But I think that our strategic plan that we have here,

1:03:42 Kind of fits into that. At least that's how I read it. So I was pretty comfortable with it. Any other comments, John? Yeah, I'm comfortable with that first page as well. With regard to the strategic alignment, due date September 30th, 2017. Boy, I think this is the first time I'm seeing this document. Okay, it is. Good. 2025 goals. Where did this come from? I mean, I recognize some of them.

1:04:10 I'm just curious, can you give a little background on how these goals were established or are being established because this isn't still a working document, correct? I'll have a first stab at that. So it's a document that council initiated themselves to provide a roadmap through to 2025. The September 30 date is your 12- to 18-month work plan. So that's kind of what that identifies.

1:04:40 You know, quarter one through quarter six. So really this is an 18-month work plan, understanding that, you know, long term this is kind of where the vision is for the community. So, you know, it's almost like, you know, where do we want to be when we grow up? So what's the big vision? And the 18-month plan is how do we kind of work towards, you know, achieving that vision, so to speak. The next step from that is to...

1:05:06 And this is why the NGOs have been involved is to how those NGOs can kind of work synergistically with council all in the same direction, all in the same effort, all in the same pathway to achieve these goals and strategies. So the question that we came up as a commission, as the advisory body is, well, how do we as a commission fit in with the town council goals with 18 months? How do we fit in with the vision of 2025?

1:05:32 So that's kind of what I was just bringing it back to today, which I think was the direction. So where this goes from now, Grady, I think it comes back to, I believe, Council in June? Just to add to part of the question of where it came from, there were eight, was it eight sessions, Stu, or ten? Eight. Jamie could probably tell us definitively, but I think it was a lot.

1:05:55 Between the town council meetings. They were long. Various NGOs, they were focused meetings with each of MLR, MLT, MLH, and actually ESTA was involved in, well, they're not truly an NGO, they're more of a service organization. That's where a lot of this came from. This is actually going to town council tomorrow night.

1:06:12 for discussion. They're taking this. They have a red line copy with comments they got back from MLR, MLT, and MLH and ESTA on some things. So they'll discuss that tomorrow night in open session. Whatever direction they give to staff then, that'll be refined and come back to council for adoption the next meeting. We're expecting May 18th for adoption of these things. Any input you have, we can pass along in writing. We can pass along verbally tomorrow night, whatever your pleasure is.

1:06:42 Yeah, so I think it's really just if we have, you know, comments, if we have, you know, any concerns, if we feel that, you know, yeah, I think it was Council Member Bacon who said, you know, all the, you know, anything, recreation that falls under TOML, that's us. So I think this is, I mean, from my personal perspective, I think this is pretty well aligned, you know, with the work that we're doing on, you know, Mammoth Park West.

1:07:07 I think it lines up fine with our vision and strategic direction, which we probably do need to update moving forward, but I still think it holds up fairly well other than the refocused portion. All right. Let me ask a couple of questions, and I hope I'm not asking dumb questions, but I'll go ahead and ask them. Ten months with over $1 million in TOT revenues, is that per month?

1:07:29 The idea is that out of the 12 months of the year, I think we're at, well, this year we might end up with 10, regardless that it's been such a good year. But the idea is to have a sustainable economy where TOT revenues are more constant. We've had several in a row that were over $2 million a month. But there's still some, like May as an example, which will be under a million. October is under a million typically. The idea is to have 10 of those months.

1:07:53 Over a million. Okay. Just want to be clear, because I'm familiar, you know, tourism with the 10 months of recreation, 10 months of activity, so I just want to be clear that that's per month. Yep. And I'm aware of it. Some months are under, some months are well over, so it's a good thing. Expanded job base for employees that afford the ability to stay in Mammoth. I think that's great, just as far as, you know, for residents who want to live here. Expanded air service to 50,000 employments based on demand and new terminal capacity. I'm going to leave that one alone for right now.

1:08:24 We might want to just focus in on the recreation portion. Yeah, no, I know, and we are, and I get it, with regard to what our, what we're charged with here. We could be here a while, otherwise. Yeah, exactly. With regard to what we're here to talk about. Broadband utilization, I assume that's internet? Digital 395, internet, just make sure that it's expanded. And not just with the availability of gigabyte service, but also the ability of facilities in town, offices for people that are coming in from out of town to visit where they can work. All sorts of things can be involved in that.

1:08:54 Totally agree and support that. Okay. $1 billion in new capital investment. Is that public, private? Where are we coming up with $1 billion by 2025? The idea is it's a combination of that, and it's a total from now through 2025. In other words, in the next nine years, is that $1 billion? If you break it down, it's frankly quite doable.

1:09:17 Okay. If you look at the actual numbers for what it costs to construct and the value of the facility, you know, once it's constructed and over a nine- or ten-year period, that's not by any means out of line. Even, as an example... Private and public. Absolutely. Even just new homes. Anything of investment in the community. Thank you. I just want to be clear, you know, it's not Measure R, Measure U, it's... Yeah, I know. You've got to be careful I say that, but at the same time, I think it's important that that's just acknowledged private and public.

1:09:47 I'm not sure that we don't take a look at the story map idea and kind of as recreation goes, are we touching all the different pieces of recreation that should be going on at the different places within town? And maybe that's something that we can look at as we're looking forward and moving forward with our goals. Yeah, because if you keep going, if you go flip to the next page, goal six, I keep going, there's more than five, because six and eight.

1:10:13 And nine. Nine goals, yeah. Are probably more related to us. So goal six is story map and use and utilize to sell Mammoth Lakes as a place to live, work, recreate, and invest. Seven is expanded housing options meet demand. Eight is integrated sustainable recreation through expanded and enhanced facilities and programs. And nine is enhanced municipal assets, financial resources, and capabilities to deliver effective government with service partners where appropriate.

1:10:48 You want to talk about this during that? No, I just think that that's actually kind of a good place to start when we're looking at, you know, what we have, what we might be missing, that that kind of can give you, can start a roadmap as to, you can start plugging things in and go, well, gee, we really, you know, we have community members here, we have visitors here, you know, what are we doing to...

1:11:13 Service both of those, whether it be program-wise or amenity-wise. But I think the story map might be a place to start as far as that goes to see what might be missing and what we can possibly enhance or add. And what we've accomplished. And what we've accomplished, yeah. Not in our bailiwick, but when I saw that the council was moving forward with storyboards, it kind of excited me because one thing the council hasn't done well in the past is when they give direction, follow through to see that that direction has been served.

1:11:45 And a storyboard does that if it has the proper updates. And to me, that would be advantageous to all of us. So when we make a decision here, and that goes to staff, to see that come back and storyboard, or however it comes back, saying, here's what you said, and here's what we're accomplishing, to make sure we're going in the direction that we had set is huge. And I guess that's where we would see what's been completed, what holes there might be, and what we can enhance, improve, or build.

1:12:15 Yeah, I agree with that because I think, you know, as we are actually moving forward with creating amenities, it kind of ties back into, you know, our Parks and Recreation Master Plan and RecStrats and all of our planning documents and we can tie all of, you know, the things that we are accomplishing back to that and, you know, and continue to look for the gaps. And, you know, MLR has its priority project list and I think, you know, we've, you know, tied pretty strongly into making recommendations for that. So ICS is in pretty good alignment with this document in the direction of council. I did too.

1:12:45 I'm sorry, Dan, if you've already said this and I'm jumping around here a little bit. So what is our next steps? You know, I understand what we're charged with, but when are we going to start diving into this then? So really Council's comments at the workshop was really just to compare the two documents. I think the comments that I've heard is that we are interested in engaging in a discussion regarding goal number six and goal number eight. Goal number six was your story map as it pertains to...

1:13:14 Mammoth Lakes is a place to live, work, recreate, and invest. And then eight was the sustainable recreation discussion, which ties in specifically to, you know, item number D, which is participate in the creation of a sustainable recreation program for Mammoth Lakes, and then parentheses, community plan, winter rec summit, economic fertility, and so forth. So, you know, at this time, I think they're the comments, Chair, I think that we can pass on to the Council. I'll be there.

1:13:43 Applicable alignment, Commission supportive of the goals that they've seen. And then secondly, particularly goal number six and eight is an area that the Recreation feels that they have value in regards to that discussion as it moves forward. Again, I don't really know the next steps. I mean, Council will really try and get this adopted or at least accepted tomorrow night at some point, if not later. And I just don't know where the...

1:14:10 Commission at this point is really going to fit in a lot of this discussion, but I think that's what they were seeking from your workshop, if you can correct me if I'm wrong. And I think important for the commissioners up here to be looking at, if you look at quarter one, page three, goal eight, identify and secure funding for trails, all design and bid awards, yada, yada, yada. TOML, well, TOML is Town of Mammoth Lakes. As the commission, we are part of Town of Mammoth Lakes, not MLR or MCP.

1:14:40 MLT, so you may want to look at that and see, did I get those all out? So you look at those, knowing that when it says CML, it's recreation-based, that would be the commission, and whether we think that the parties aligned with each goal is where it should be, because that was, we haven't actually looked at that.

1:15:00 Nor do we have time today to look at that. But to me, that was an important part of this when I went to. I think that they're trying to say that there's a lot of different people that are involved in making this happen and that it isn't just, you know, the town of Mammoth Lakes that we're working with our NGOs to make these things happen. So anyways, in understanding that, you know, where it says town of Mammoth Lakes, that is where the Recreation Commission would also fit into that and work with.

1:15:28 Staff and NGOs potentially to make things happen. So anyhow. But I know there was talk with some of the heads of some of the NGOs about, well, they've listed me here, and I'm not sure that that's where we should be. We should be so that discussion outside of the council, unless it happened in those workshops, and I didn't go to those workshops, occurred. There's still some thought process that needs to go into that from my standpoint anyway. And if I could add in terms of next steps, the way

1:15:58 At least engineering and public works staff is starting to address this. There used to be an item on our regular agenda sheets that had how this action aligns with town vision and priorities. It became kind of an afterthought, if you will, at least for the last couple of years. People have done their due diligence, done their staff reports, and said, OK, now how does it fit? What I'm challenging our engineering staff to do is to turn that around and say, OK, when we meet and talk about a project,

1:16:26 We're going to have this final document up on the wall and say, OK, how are we forwarding this vision? How are we forwarding all this work and make sure that we don't lose sight of that? And whenever at least Public Works brings something to this group, we'll do that same thing. We'll say, OK, this fits and this is where it came from. So we see the origin. We can see how we're trying to further that vision. That's what we're starting to do at least. And we're hoping the NGOs do the same thing when they bring something forward. How does that fit?

1:16:52 into all this work that was happening. So just that's our next step from a staff perspective. Good point. Any other questions from the commission before we go to public comment? I just have one. Why is the, on the bottom of page two, initial budget for parking highlighted for us as Recreation Commission? Or is that highlighted for us? That's not highlighted for us, no. Okay. Thank you. Anything else? I'll open the floor for public comment. Anything on the town?

1:17:22 Strategic alignment. Good morning, Commissioners and public. I'm Ralph Lockhart from Snow Creek Athletic Club. Just a couple of comments on the identifiable goals and how this might move forward. Perhaps a couple of suggestions as it relates to the key strategies and the documents that, you know, the working documents that kind of left to right timeline. The number three lists deliver innovative.

1:17:54 Expanded and affordable community-centric recreation. When you use terms like expanded and affordable, often there is a tendency to say we need more of something. And when we do that more of, we end up competing with private businesses. And if I could use an example, maybe I'll pick a brewery, for example, and say

1:18:20 The town of Mammoth Lakes has decided that they're going to build a brewery because we need more beer. And we're going to build the facilities. We don't care if we ever make a profit. In fact, our contribution percentage might be 20%. And we're going to sell, because we think it should be really affordable, we're going to sell beer for 25 cents a glass. And we're going to use Measure R and Measure U utility funds in order to

1:18:50 Do that. So the unintended result is a competition with private business and a price war and potentially driving somebody out of business. So that's kind of an odd example, but maybe a concern or some kind of wording that could be added to the strategy in the future is, and I see things like in the community center, we're going to do yoga, we're going to do Zumba,

1:19:21 There's multiple locations in the town that already do yoga and Zumba at affordable prices, and doing it with public funds just, I don't think it enhances anything. It just creates a situation where private enterprise is forced to compete with their own tax dollars against themselves. So if you could say,

1:19:48 In this strategy, we're going to try to avoid duplication of services that are already at affordable rates. Then I think you're starting to get where you need to. Having an ice rink that nobody else is providing is a great, I think, a great amenity. But where we're duplicating services and we're competing against private businesses with tax funds, I think we should move forward very, very, very carefully.

1:20:18 We could actually have an end result where that $1 billion of investment that we want to get over some future time period is limited because private enterprise doesn't want to be in the same space where they may be competing with the town. So I'm hoping that part of that overall workshop and that overall strategy will include those general principles. Avoid duplication and where already services exist that are

1:20:47 affordable and aren't a reason for people to get on a plane and come here, then we should try not to do that. And thank you for your understanding. Thanks, Ralph. Just real quick, could I just ask you a quick question? Because the strategy that you're referencing, the number three, that's our existing strategy for community recreation in the town now. And then the council process is coming forward separately. Do you have concerns about any of our current programming being in competition with private?

1:21:17 In this way, you're thinking toward the future. There's a certain amount of that that happens all the time. For example, summer camps for kids. The town has a very robust program, and a lot of private businesses have decided, including Snow Creek Athletic Club. You know, we used to do all these different kinds of camps that we would make available because we have a lot of activities kids could do, dance, martial arts, trampoline, swim, tennis, et cetera.

1:21:46 The town programs are subsidized and they're super affordable and they're well publicized through all the town's infrastructure that it's not that profitable anymore. It's not worth investing the effort to do that. That's a minor example and almost every town has a recreation department and they do camps and things like that for kids.

1:22:16 Just keeping those things in mind in yoga classes. You have a community center and you have a new room, and now you have this place where you can say to any yoga instructor that makes no investment whatsoever, they can go in and teach a yoga class and actually make money and be in business as using the town's facility, and it's a competition with somebody else who pays.

1:22:43 Property taxes and insurance and all that other thing. So I just say every time we expand, let's say, does this already exist in the community? Is it affordable? And is it in a reasonable environment? Let's try not to duplicate. Let's go for the stuff that everybody needs but we don't currently have as an affordable way. So my follow-up on that is one of the things that we've identified over and over again is being important for us to move forward in recreation.

1:23:14 Or the private-public partnerships. So how do we go about creating that partnership with someone like yourself so that you're coming in and we're looking at the programs on both sides to see what is affordable? Because what's affordable to some of your customers aren't affordable to a lot of Mammoth working class. How do we do this without getting into the competition? Because to me, that's important. A Zumba class may be important for some kids whose parents can't afford to pay anything. And we subsidize that at the town level.

1:23:44 But at the same time, we don't want to be competing with the people that would be coming to you. So how do we create that public-private partnership in programming so that we're not doing that? Because it seems to me that's the next logical step. I appreciate you coming up because this is an important issue for us to deal with. How do we create that and help us create that so that we aren't in competition with you?

1:24:09 But the programs we're doing and the programs you're doing are actually enhancing each other and tied to each other. Because to me, that's the win-win. Not stop doing it because I need the customers, which I understand. I'm a business myself. But how do we work together to enhance the overall programming for everyone in town? Bill, that's a really good question. And there are people that have special needs, and there are programs that are available.

1:24:38 Silver Sneaker Programs for Seniors and others that are federally funded or subsidized. There are associations that do that. And I think sometimes the innovative solution may be if somebody wants to go to a Zumba class or a yoga class and can't afford it at the current market rate, that it may be easier to find programs that subsidize that individual to go to a private enterprise. I'll give you the...

1:25:05 Four extra dollars or we'll reduce your fee and reimburse the business, so to speak, for providing that service to the underprivileged. And I think those kinds of solutions end up being way cheaper to the community rather than building a new facility, paying for all the infrastructure and losing money on an annual basis than figuring out are there low-income people that may need, you know, $60 a month so that their kids can enjoy this, that, or the other.

1:25:35 Ways to actually direct the funding towards those in need rather than facilities. But even that takes a partnership because it takes our staff time and your staff time to create those levels and the paperwork necessary to see to it the people qualified. So that's what I'm saying. We need to create that partnership somehow. Right. And I'm not the only business that provides yoga or dance or martial arts in the town.

1:26:03 And hopefully, speaking for all of them, there's a way to do that in a fair manner where it's not just a public-private partnership between one business and the town, but that there's a good opportunity for all, and it's a fair playing field. Thanks very much. I just want to say thank you very much because your points are well taken. You know, I think there's other analogies there.

1:26:26 Besides beer. But totally get it, you know, that public should not be competing with private, you know, and that can be talked about golf courses, ski areas, private versus public schools, all kinds of different things there, different conversation. I just want to say this, is that, you know, something that we've talked about with regard to this community center, which is beyond the multi-use facility, and something that I think Snow Creek Athletic Club does a very good job of is creating a sense of community.

1:26:55 And that's not necessarily something that we want to compete with as much as develop it into a larger package that we're...

1:27:05 You know, creating. I guess I'm only saying that just because I think that it's difficult to, I think that your points, I just want to say your points were well taken in the sense that as we go forward it is a mindset that we're not looking to compete but more enhance. I thought that your comment about avoid duplication is, I just want to say is a good point. Thank you. And may I also state that we

1:27:31 In our particular case, we provide kind of a Class A type recreation facility, but because of the economics of the area and that kind of thing, we charge a Class B type pricing. We don't take a lot of money. In fact, we've invested millions more than we've ever taken out in profits of the facility. So because it's a very small demographic, the product that we produce is a pretty high level.

1:28:01 It still may be deemed unaffordable for some people. That's an issue that we all have to address and figure out if there are ways to solve those with community programs and that kind of thing. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I'm just going to have one comment on that, Chair. It actually did come up in the committee meetings. And if you look at the playbooks, it talks about youth and adult introductory classes. So if that makes sense. Really, when you look at the...

1:28:29 Playbook, it has adult introductory fitness classes, youth introductory fitness classes, really with the goal of trying to increase the base of the pyramid. So if we can get more people engaged and enjoying those type of activities as they become more familiar with and they enjoy it more, then we really see them moving on.

1:28:44 And I think that was that kind of philosophy, I think, of that discussion that we had. And that's what we heard from our peer communities in Tahoe. We heard that the public facilities kind of were very introductory and got people excited about fitness and this type of programming, and then they really fed into the private organizations there. But I think this is a good ongoing conversation for us all to have. So it's a small community. We all need to work together. All right. Thank you. Good morning again. Good morning.

1:29:12 Mammoth 2025 strategic planning process has been in line now since last August. I think we've had eight meetings. MLR boards looked at that document two or three times and made some recommendations. Most recent, as of April 5th, I think we spent almost 45 minutes on the document. There's a lot of red line in the council pack for tomorrow night.

1:29:32 I would strongly recommend you look at the Town Council packet for tomorrow night. It shows an updated version with some of the comments from the NGOs. I think that will be the base that starts the conversation tomorrow night. Thank you. Before you go away, since I seem to be in a questioning mood this morning, is MLR pretty comfortable with the items that are kind of MLR slash TOML? Do you feel like there are appropriate? I think the good match on this.

1:30:00 As we walked in in August with a blank piece of paper, we were all challenged, what are your projects over the next 18 to 24 months? And I shared this with the MLR board. My uncomfortable level was putting things on paper in August, September, October, thinking where we're going.

1:30:16 But Council and MLR Board didn't take action to approve these priority phase projects until December. So we feel right now things have lined up pretty well. In fact, the last meeting we had that subgroup got together, I stepped away and worked with the MLT group because I wanted to get other eyes on what we thought the works and progress would be. We're feeling pretty good about where it is at this point in time. But look at that red line document. You'll see there's some other requests for modifications. Thank you. Thank you.

1:30:47 Okay. What agenda item is this tomorrow for Town Council? It's after youth sports funding, I think. Yeah. Yeah, that's fine. Actually, that would be even better. Thank you. I'll look at the agenda while we take a break. All right. So, any more public comments on the Town Council strategic goals and priorities? No? Okay. Any other comments from Commission? No. Okay. So, I'll call for a five-minute recess. 13, there you go. Yes.

1:31:33 I'm not going to be here, but I will. I have a babysitter so that Brent and I can both go to town. Okay, I'd like to call us back to order as soon as I have my staff back. Okay, I will call us back to order so that we can move on to item number nine, youth sports funding update. Would you like to just review the staff report for us? Thank you, Chair. Yes.

1:32:14 I'm more than happy to. So again, this is a follow-up item from our discussion with Council on April 6th. As you know, the recommendations that we adopted on April 5th presented to Council tomorrow night. It's early in the agenda. I think it's item number 9 or 10. And that recommendation is based on the approved funding of $34,800 that we currently have. We understand there's...

1:32:42 Concerns amongst the youth sports funding groups. And what we're recommending here is just quite succinctly to, again, if we would like to discuss briefly the youth sports funding program and methodology, but to really look at how the town, the community, and the county can best support youth sports funding groups in our community.

1:33:08 What we're proposing is to schedule a workshop with those groups May 31 and ask these questions here at the bottom that we've just identified in bullets, right? Because it can't only just be about money, right? We can keep funding and funding and funding, but at what point do we get to a level that it becomes unsustainable for us? Of course, they'll keep taking money, but what other areas can we as a community come together to support?

1:33:35 The growth of youth sports funding and certainly the sustainability. So what we're proposing is to, one, direct staff to schedule a meeting with those youth sports funding groups. It's May 31. It would be lunchtime of our next meeting. We just bring them in here. We're facilitated by the chair, the commission, and the recreation manager. We could potentially look at these questions that we have here and then elaborate on those.

1:34:02 For Council tomorrow, there's no indication at this time that Council are considering additional monies. I can't speak on behalf of really any Council, but we have that meeting on May 31. So if Council do say and do allocate additional monies, we can then come back together on May 31 and make a recommendation for that additional allocation. But at this time, I don't know if it's really in our best interest to really get into a lot of that.

1:34:31 I really think I'm looking to the future of how we can, as a community commission, better support these organisations or at least begin to understand the barriers that they face because, you know, we do have limited funding. So that's kind of my recommendation here.

1:34:49 Thanks, Sue. And if I could just add, if this is the desire of the commission to hold this workshop, we also discussed perhaps inviting Supervisor Corliss to come because she's been very supportive on the county side so that it's, you know, kind of a collaborative effort and not just the town side. So questions for staff? Just to be clear on calendar because 31.

1:35:14 So our regular June meeting will be on May 31st, not June 7th from 9 to noon. Correct. And so we're proposing this workshop from noon to 1. Correct. Okay. I'm supportive of this. Me as well. Yeah, I agree because, you know, the first thing council says is, well, why do you need the additional money? And so I think that those are questions that need to be answered. And I think maybe this also gives us the opportunity to look at how we're funding things and how we're, you know,

1:35:47 Can we set a baseline and then move from there? Things like that. I know we've talked about because some sports are more expensive than others, so maybe there's some type of a weighting that you start with a baseline and then there's some type of weighting that you can put together and maybe that can be added in here that can be a discussion.

1:36:13 Trying to figure out a strategic way to handle it, right? So otherwise, I think that the thing, you know, I think this first question is key, the opportunities and constraints of youth sports funding organizations, you know, that kind of seems to be the key to a lot of this. So anyways, I think that's a good idea in a long-winded way. Okay. So any other questions for staff before I take public comment? Clayton, any questions? All right. I'll open the floor for public comment, then I'll just bring it back up to...

1:36:43 Commission for further discussion. Thank you, Commissioner. Tom Cage, on behalf of Youth Sports Funding, I guess, you know, these questions are all pertinent. A workshop on the 31st would be great. But at the same point in time, we have inflationary things. We have...

1:37:03 Participation items that keep going up. And I'm talking Broadview, all sports. I'm not here just advocating for one. And I would hope the Town Council would realize that, not to mention the fact that we have a bumper crop of revenue this year. And on years like that, I would hope there'd be a little loosening up. And then on bad years, you might have to pull the strings back. That happens. It happens with any business. It happens with any individual when you make more or you make less income.

1:37:31 So, you know, at this point in time, you add in the fact that the county put in a few bucks a couple years ago, I think, put in $6,000 two cycles ago. Stuart can correct me if I'm wrong. So, really, we haven't seen an increase in the overall funding for at least three years, and I can't go back any farther than that because I don't recall what it was then. So, I guess my question to the commission is,

1:37:59 Do we wait until the 31st and go back to the council or tomorrow would you like me to get 100 kids here? For the council to get some impact on, you know, and 100 kids from different sports representing probably 10% of the kids that are participating in sports. So, you know, obviously, you know, some of those are duplicate kids, but, you know, we can do it that way too.

1:38:25 to make a little impact. I'm not sure that inflation and increased participation couldn't just be the reasoning to ask for the 10% that was previously taken away due to the restructuring.

1:38:40 Potential lawsuit and just ask for that 10% to come back. So I don't want to mess with your long-range plans. And then have the workshop to move on beyond that. So I just want to ask Stuart a clarifying question, maybe Jamie. So I know Council is looking at budget. They're having a discussion tomorrow night. And then how's that process unfolding? Yeah, so they'll be reviewing the budget tomorrow night. But again, they're not really looking at adopting the budget until June.

1:39:06 So we do have time. So if there's a direction coming out of council to look at additional funding, whether it be for this year or the following year, we have time to analyze that or make a recommendation back to council on that. So I don't know. It's always great to have kids in the chamber supporting recreation. But I think really the benefit would be to really have the commission fully understand and fully

1:39:33 And I know the youth sports funding process has been difficult. It's always just a presentation to commission, commission asking a few questions. So really, I think this workshop would be a great opportunity to be really interactive, really try and ask those questions. And then we can get that information back to council and we can kind of formulate our recommendation of how best we move forward. Absolutely, you know, I've looked at my budget and I'd like to...

1:39:55 Reallocate that money back at least 32. I think this workshop will give us the opportunity to go back to the county and ask for additional funding as well. I mean, I certainly see it growing, but again, I just don't want to keep it one linear discussion just on funding. I think there's many ways that we can all contribute, and that's really the purpose of that meeting. And look, I get the last three years. We've all been under constraints, right? But now it's not so much. We know there's going to be some budget flexibility unless the town...

1:40:24 Government decides to use it all in payroll, and I'm sure there are spots that could be filled, but I can't imagine that there isn't going to be some level of makeup that we could fund. I'm not asking to double it. I'm not saying that, but you have some good requests from some good people in the sports programs, and we're not able to get any increase, and I respect the fact that you guys go to the council and...

1:40:52 You know, you plead your case, but there's nothing like the impact of, you know, a lot of people. But on the flip side of the coin, Stuart's comments about May 31st at noon. I don't want to put the cart before the horse. I don't want to interfere with your long-range planning and how this might dovetail in with other things that are going on that I'm not aware of. So if your direction is we work on it May 31st and with all the groups and possibly can then go back to the town.

1:41:21 County budget, I think, is more constrained. Their income is from property taxes, which are not going to rebound for another year or two. So the realities with the county is they're going to lag behind us a bit, whereas the town gets immediate with TOT and TBID. And I know TBID goes to MLT, but maybe that should be an approach that the sports groups could make. And maybe at this workshop we could include Erty because...

1:41:50 Tourism has some dovetail, like tournaments that I know football kids have done, I know volleyball does, I know hockey does. If soccer could get their act together, soccer should, because it would be huge and be great to do when it's real hot everywhere else, and you can do one up here in August, end of July, whenever the fields are in the right condition. But I do know those other three sports do do.

1:42:19 Tournaments up here, bring in people, bring in TOT. So to me there is some dovetail between MLR and MLT in regards to this. And let's face it, I know from my TBID contributions, you know, his revenue source is going to be hugely increased this year. So there's going to be a big pop there as well. So maybe that's another area on the 31st we could throw into the bucket.

1:42:48 and see if we could get some participation. Yeah, TBID is restrictive in how it can be spent, and so is MLT as far as marketing. They're not actually funding events.

1:43:00 Whether it be sporting events or other events. Or anything that's not really there. But anyway, so I don't know that, I mean, you can certainly say that, but I don't know that that fits within the T-bit. My best guess would be no. Probably, yeah, probably not. But I do think at council it was a well-received comment that, you know, recognizing that, you know, youth sports.

1:43:19 Is bringing people to town, I think. I think one way as an example, Teri, you're absolutely right for the majority. And she's the one who made the comment, so. But here's a suggestion for TBID slash MLT. What if they started paying for uniforms and all the uniforms had the town of Mammoth Lakes logo on it?

1:43:36 And so when these kids go to tournaments, they've got... This isn't the place to do it. I know, but I'm just throwing that out as an example. We don't have any... But I think the conversation as to how we can better improve the funding, the process. So would you rather I wait until the 31st or do you want me to...

1:44:00 Tom, I made a spectacle tomorrow. Tom, to me personally, when we go forward with whatever we come out with on the 31st, you know how I would have liked this whole thing to have gone down in the first place. We didn't choose that path. So on the 31st, we should come forward with something that's going to go to council. When we come forward with that, that would be the time to have 100 kids in the audience saying, let's move forward. That would be my input on it. So can you give me what date it would go back to council after the 31st workshop?

1:44:29 First meeting in June. It's June 1st. It would be June 1st, which would not happen June 1st. Which would not be at that time. When do they actually finalize the budget? Either that first meeting or the second meeting in June. Well, then May 31st probably isn't soon enough. Probably. Well, except that, remember that the budget, if nothing, is an absolutely fluid document. The budget that we end the year with versus the budget that Council sets in June never...

1:44:57 Balance with each other, and it is changed. So change can happen throughout the discretionary funds. I don't think the council is going to add money in their line item for this that cannot be changed during the process. Is June 1st Wednesday, is that your first meeting in June? Yes. So couldn't it be agendized for the sports funding for that evening with the workshop the day prior? No.

1:45:27 No, and we need to bring new sports funding, the recommendation based on the funds we know we have to allocate. We need to take that to account. That's already on the council agenda for tomorrow night. And that's important because you guys all want those monies for, you know, your coming up. I guess the only thing I would say is, you know, from my perspective, I think what the council asked us to do in our workshop, and you guys can feel free to jump in and disagree, but what they really asked us to do is, I mean, they said, they were very clear. They said, well, you know, there are a lot of...

1:45:54 There are a lot of things in the town budget that have not been restored to pre-settlement levels. So they really need, I think, a really strategic recommendation from us, not just a, you know, hey, give us another X or give us some more money. That's really not what they want to hear from us was kind of what I take away from that workshop. But they do want us to, you know, look at other ways we can support these organizations. They want us, you know, I think, you know, Stu's budget for next year, we can, you know, try to get some more funds in that, I think.

1:46:23 I don't know that we can get more money for this year. That's just my take on it. And I think they tell us why you need the extra money for what groups and why specifically that group needs more money. And I think if we came forward with that in our recommendation, we could easily get it. So I was hoping in the workshop that we would be dealing with that as well. That's what I heard. Yes, they want us in the long term to look at strategically how to do the money, and we've commented that.

1:46:51 There's 6,000 in there that shouldn't even be in there every year. That should just be a rollover for that specific group, and those are things we need to discuss. But what I heard was if we came forward with a reason why it needs to be increased this year, that they could possibly look to find that money and fund it. Perhaps with leftovers from last year, perhaps with, you know, they've been conservative in their estimates and there are extra dollars floating around out there. So maybe the workshop on the 31st will give you...

1:47:20 Good reasons to go back to Council after that in June sometime and give you a roadmap that we can arrive at, it sounds like. We could move it up. I mean, it's up to the Commission. I'm looking. You could schedule it in two weeks if you wished. I was just trying to give us time to get all those groups there, but if we believe that U-Sports funding groups are very eager to at least participate in this discussion, then that would give us an opportunity if we scheduled it on May 17 or that week.

1:47:48 to bring back recommendations for the May 31st commission meeting, and then we can actually get something to council by mid-June. That would be kind of the timeline. Yeah, I'm happy to move it up. Is there any more public comment? I just need to finish public comment. Thanks, Tom. Thank you. Sandy Hogan. Actually, you know, I think Tom's offer is a great one to make a pitch last tomorrow night, whether he brings 30 kids or not. It never hurts for the council to be aware that...

1:48:20 You know, people that offer their time like Tom does, you know, they really believe in this. And I know that you want to do a strategy, but at least to plant the seed, that this is something that's really important. I mean, it's up for discussion. It's agendized tomorrow. So, you know, I would always accept a pitch like his to help. Just my thought. Thank you. Any other public comments?

1:48:46 Okay, then I'll close public comment and bring it back up for our discussion about whether we want to move this up. Do we want to make a push tomorrow night? I'd like to hear from everyone. I have no problem with the 17th. I don't have a problem with the 17th. If we were going to be able to bring that back, that it could go to the budget discussion, but I'm not sure since our meeting is on the 31st that either way that's going to help us. I don't know.

1:49:16 If there was a proposal and it could be at least, you know, given to council in a packet that this is what's moving forward to the commission and that can be voted on and then still put into the agenda, I don't know if that's possible, if that would work legally, Jamie, I don't know. It's not a legal issue, it's a council likes to review. Okay, yeah. Yeah, yeah. It sounds like this workshop you would be coming up with a lot of ideas, I don't know how much would be written ahead of time, so.

1:49:45 We can have it written, but the problem is it doesn't go before commission then until 31st. Well, but if our workshop on the 17th is a publicly noticed meeting, though, we can make a separate item. Well, if we call it a meeting, not just a workshop, so we can have an action item on the agenda, then we can make a decision on what to move forward then. I'm thinking we would have the workshop with the groups, and then based on what came out of that, right after that it would be an agenda item for us to make a recommendation.

1:50:13 I would agree with that. I wouldn't have a problem with that. That way we could have something that would be solid to take to. And we can certainly let Council know tomorrow night that that's our plan. So how does that sound to everyone? Does that work for you timing-wise? Sorry, I was reviewing my notes from April 5th. Because, yeah, I remember I went into great detail kind of on, you know, where I would like to see you. Essentially, we're talking about an additional $6,000, right?

1:50:42 Well, we don't know. There was one suggestion that maybe at least we come back up, you know, put that 10% back. And that was one suggestion. And, you know, we got a why. I'm in agreement that, you know, this has been a good year and let's, you know, we kind of need to reward ourselves here a little bit with regard to youth sports funding.

1:51:09 Okay. So my question is, what is the most effective way for us to be able to, you know, I think we had consensus, general consensus, correct me if I'm wrong, that we were for increasing the youth sports funding. I want to be careful how I say that. But at the same time, what is the most effective way that we can communicate this to Town Council? They won't raise any bandits. Yeah. Right. So when's the best time to have a...

1:51:39 Meeting the 17th is booked. Does it have to be on a Tuesday? Can we do it another day? Sometime with enough time to get preparation to Town Council. I think you said that was the goal, right, Jamie? I'm fine on the 16th. 16th available, Jamie? Yeah. 16th is Monday? Monday, 16 noon. We could just schedule as a special meeting. If it's one hour, that would be fine. I really can't dedicate too much more than that.

1:52:11 I have my calendar, so I'm assuming I'm okay. Yeah, we can look at it. We're talking about the 16th in the afternoon. Is that what we're talking now? Yeah, noon. We're talking noon to one. We'll be driving back from Southern California on the 16th, so. Later in the day? Early in the morning. Okay. Unless we do it kind of towards the end of the day. Which might be better for groups anyway. You could do a 5 o'clock meeting. I'm open. I'll make that work. 5 o'clock on the 16th, speeds available. Are you back by then, Bill?

1:52:40 Yeah. I don't have employee issues. Okay. 5 p.m., 7 p.m. probably. Terry, that does or doesn't? It probably would work better for me. Okay. Okay. I'll just schedule a special meeting. Rec Commission meeting. Okay. I won't do it now, folks. It doesn't get done. Well, Stu, will you be sending out a meeting invite? Yep. Okay. Thank you. I think what's important, just a closing comment, just important for council, you know, because there are a lot of obviously funding requests coming forward. Yeah, it's not just us. Right. For them to evaluate those in a, you know, collective.

1:53:10 Agreed. Strategic manner, and I think that would be appreciative. That would probably certainly find that appreciative from the commission coming forward, you know, during the process that's, you know, set aside for that purpose, so. Very good. And so then that would be part of the budget on June 1st? I'll check with the town manager and see if we can make that work. It's not on the 18th. Stu need. Stu need. The other Stu. Yeah, thanks, Tom. All right, great.

1:53:44 Thank you for coming today, Tom. Thank you very much, Tom. Appreciate it. Okay, so we're good on that. All right, let's move on because we have less than half an hour to go. So item number 10, Parks and Recreation Department Donation Program. Thank you, Chair. So the next two items we've carried from the previous meeting. So the goal and purpose of these two items is to at least solicit some feedback.

1:54:10 Some consensus comments regarding these programs with the goal of bringing them forward back on May 31 to accept them. These programs have not been through legal. They haven't been reviewed in any great detail apart from being a draft document and bringing it forward to commission. So there is a little bit of work to be done with getting these out into the marketplace.

1:54:37 For items 10, 11, I can kind of walk you through the outline. I think the donation program is pretty straightforward. So it's a program that we've been running for several years. What we've tried to do is kind of put it in one document. And as I've described in the staff report, you know, this is kind of 1.0. This is kind of the Parks Donation Program 1.0. 2.0 would be, in a greater detail, showing a map of the location, showing a picture of the...

1:55:05 The products that could be purchased, how that would look in situ, right? And version three is kind of the full GPS, kind of what we talk about, the GIS platform that has it on a web-based. It's a full web-based program that you can actually go in. I've seen these programs online. We have this as part of our asset management tool with my parks manager. He's able to go out there and actually take an image, GIS it, bring it back and actually put it on a web-based system that the public can actually then go ahead and view.

1:55:35 determine what location and what product they would like to donate to the town. So the 1.0 program is just really kind of getting this program up on its legs, providing the community, as you can see with the catalog, a broader selection of amenities that will greatly benefit our parks and facilities. So we've taken this from the parks maintenance.

1:56:00 Asset Management Program that we conducted early in the year. We identified a lot of those items that would benefit these parks, as we talked about here. You can see bleachers are pretty much in every park as well. The typical tables, the park benches, you know, the drinking fountains with dog bowl. I mean, they're just those type of things with the bottle fillers. I mean, they're the type of things that come forward that we see a lot in our parks.

1:56:25 I think would greatly benefit from those enhancements. Shady Resh Park has the Snack Shack enhancement. Again, I've just listed 1 to 50,000. Didn't want to scare everybody away, but that really would get us some legs to get the new siding, materials, fixtures completed. Trails End Park, as you know, we're working on right now with that plan. And again, it's an opportunity for someone to come forward, and even so, the facility might be built and paid for.

1:56:52 There could be an opportunity here for a donation of annual maintenance. They could come forward and have a plaque or something that could be provided, put on that amenity. That would enable us moving forward to maintain that amenity in the level of service we're currently providing. So that's really the outline. You can see we've gone through each and every facility. Right at the back there it talks about other projects on page 7.

1:57:16 Even if someone wants to donate money for our Give the Gift of Recreation programs that enable us to get more kids in our programs, that sounds great as well. But really, again, a donation is something as opposed to a sponsorship that doesn't come with any kind of exploitable assets. It's just a gift for a specific purpose to be used really in the best way that we can for the entire community.

1:57:42 That's the program. It's very simple. John Connolly oversees this program. You know, we have a trail bench program currently running right now. It's sold out until we actually can get on our trails and develop an inventory of available locations. But we're going to work with the trails program on that, which I think is great. Joel's already talked about that. We can kind of work together on that. And that's about it. So we're ready to go. It's really just seeking your comments.

1:58:10 Bring that back in May 31 for acceptance and get this in place. Questions on just the donation program? The only comment, and looking over it real quickly, was that the manager gives okay or disapproves, and there just needs to be an appeal process in there. They appeal to council, they appeal to commission, whoever that is, needs to be added so that they don't feel like staff by themselves is the final arbiter. That was one of my comments as well.

1:58:42 Go ahead, Bill. No, that was it. That was just the one thing that stood out as me. I appreciate not having to deal with every little thing as a commission because that would overwhelm us. But if somebody feels like they are being unfairly dealt with, whether they are or not, they need the ability to make that appeal and they should probably come back to us and then move from there. I'm fine with that. In the sponsorship one, we get into the larger amount. One's come to commission.

1:59:12 Which is fine, and I think that's appropriate. And then it's approved by council as opposed to just staff. Yeah, exactly. But I think there needs to be an uphill process. Absolutely. One of the things that it just says, it covers the total cost of the project, including installation. And so when I'm looking at these things, I just think that there might be somebody that might even put $100 in or $20 in. It could go towards something that...

1:59:39 Somebody might want to do that. There should be some type of a program that, you know, and, you know, maybe you're not getting a plaque for something like that, but you can get a thank you. But they're, you know, working on, because otherwise we might not get some of these things that, you know, someone doesn't have $5,000 to plunk down on something, but, you know, they want to put money towards one of those things in this facility and how can they do that? So I guess that instead of having cover the total cost.

2:00:06 of a project including installation. How can we earmark something so that we can build up to that item? I think it says encourage, right? So maybe we can look at that. Well, I don't know. This bullet point says cover the total cost of a project including installation. So I don't know. No, you know, it's an interesting concept. There's a lot of websites out there now, YouFund, where people are going online with their ideas.

2:00:29 All sorts of people donate to that to get it done. So if we had some things like the shade structures that were really big, and we created that on our website and are advertising a you fund kind of thing that helps create community, and you know, you list their names somewhere. Yeah, and we saw that with Raise the Roof, yeah. Yeah, that would work, I think, really well. We can do that, and I don't know whether that's working in concert with MLR, and there can just be items posted there that people can fund different.

2:00:57 Right. I don't know. Anyways, but it's a thought. No, I don't care where it lives, but it is a great idea. I don't know where it lives either. So anyways, but that's a thought. And then I have, you know, what if a donor disagrees with a decision? So anyways, so that needs to be an appeal process. And then I guess I was looking at sold out. It's like, wow, how can we truly be sold out of something?

2:01:24 I know you don't want a bench every two feet, so anyways, but there's also potentially maybe on our sidewalks, is there potentially somewhere on the bike paths and there's seats. I know right now I'll weigh up those, but maybe sidewalks, there's potential. Where are there places in town's community centers? Well, I think we want to drive it to the parks, right? Because I think that's...

2:01:48 But even if there's a community square, there could potentially be one. I guess if someone really wants to give you a bench, you know, there could be other places that it might be good. We could replace the chairs here in Suite Z. I don't want my name on one of those. And then the only other thing is I know that this came up in conversation and I know there was a group that actually started raising some money but failed enhancements down at Whitmore. And so I don't know if...

2:02:18 They were looking for a clay infield, I know, in particular, but anyways, I don't know if things like that are in your other section that, you know, people can bring forward and, you know, how, what's that process and how do they bring that forward to potentially get something on the radar, so. One other thing that I didn't see in there, so somebody

2:02:42 Donates a bench in memory of Stan Smith or whomever. There's really no maintenance on benches. After X number of years, you yank them out, throw them out, and replace them. Do we have a replacement program built in so that donor gets notified so they have the opportunity to continue Stan's seat? There's a different program. I think it's kind of adopt a bench program, I think. And that could be a little...

2:03:10 Segment of this program, because that is very specific to adopt a bench, which means you can actually, you're not really buying and installing the bench, you're just actually adopting it, right, so a different program. So that's another, you know, area we can look at. Right now, we're just talking about a program, you actually come and buy a bench, we install it, the maintenance is really around the bench, you know, it's the trees, the shrubs, those type of things. So I think there's a little adopt a bench program in there, but I think that's kind of an MLR program that's being considered, I think, as part of the trial program.

2:03:40 I don't know if we want to consider it as part of our whole donation program as well. You know, adopt a pavilion or adopt a something. And I don't know where it lives either. I know that a lot of benches out there already have in memory of very specific locations because the people wanted them. Whether that was done through adopt a bench or however, as long as it is in there so that that trust or whatever it is that bought that bench can continue to have the bench in that location.

2:04:06 Even when it needs replacement, you know, to come up with the extra money to do the replacement. It should be an important part of whatever program that fits into. Yeah, if it's in memory of... Right. Yeah. Okay. Any other questions for staff on this program? No, I think that one's fine. I just, you know, how do items get on this list? I guess that would be something that I think needs to be reviewed maybe on...

2:04:33 If it's not yearly, maybe two or three years or whatever. Well, I mean, this list really originated with our spreadsheet. It did, yeah. So I think that is an annual review, I know for sure. I could write that in there. Any public comment? So any other comments on this? I think these are good comments that could be integrated and then brought back for our people, right? Yeah, that's really good. All right.

2:05:06 Super. So along the same lines, but different, I'll move us on to item number 11, Parks and Recreation Sponsorship Program. Right. So again, this item was on our previous agenda. We've been very busy, so thank you for your time. So this item here, we have just included a draft sponsorship policy. The previous item in April, I wasn't able to provide a draft document. We just provided the five kind of recommended policy documents that we found that were

2:05:36 Probably the most applicable for what we're really looking at. So in the staff report, you've probably been through it. It talks about our current policy and how we recognise our current sponsors and really the difference between the donation program and a sponsorship program. Someone for a sponsor is really asking and requesting for value.

2:05:56 We have an exploitable asset. They want to see some type of return. And that's kind of that definition that I provide there. So it is a very different type of program than our donor program. So it's something that we want to really look at formalizing. I think it adds value to, again, our parks and facilities. And as the first sentence in the proposed policy speaks to that, how can we, as a parks and recreation department,

2:06:23 You know, increase the level of service. We have depleted revenue streams, you know, increasing our delivery for our community. And so sponsorship is a really key way and a very strategic way to provide that. So what we've done is I've provided a draft document. Perhaps we can kind of get to that again and just seek some consensus comments and direction.

2:06:47 I can kind of go through the document with you if that makes sense. Again, it was kind of taken from the best two or three that we found. So one, it provides an introduction to why we're really taking, why we're moving forward with an initiative for a policy for sponsorship, what it means as a policy statement, defines sponsorship. So if someone's really looking at giving money to the town, is it a donation or a sponsorship?

2:07:13 What are the guiding principles? And these are really important that I really want to make sure they are highlighted in this document because it's really how we as an advisory body value or evaluate each of the sponsorship opportunities coming forward. And that really talks about the mission, make sure that it doesn't conflict with our mission. Also talks about condition, cannot be made compliant or conditional upon the performance of the department.

2:07:42 They provide a positive desirable image. Offered should be commensurate with the relative value of the sponsorship. Operating costs, so if they're providing a sponsorship to some level that it's not depleting the cost of the operations. That's why it talks about not exceeding 10% of an operating cost, which I think is pretty conservative. And then so forth. As we move on, it talks about the categories. And this is kind of where we spent most of the time in the document to try and identify the

2:08:11 The relevant categories. Each of the different towns take a little different approach, and their approach was really on money. So they really looked at it from a financial contribution, where what I've kind of proposed here is just really broken it down by kind of a category of either events, a program, which is kind of how we really put our activities together in a program, an event, a park and facility, which is really a fixed asset, or the naming rights.

2:08:39 And I think those are the four main categories that we kind of came up with. The only identification of funding here is when we get into a number that I've put in here of $100,000, which is the approximate value of a cash or an in-kind donation. And then it really talks about $100,000 or less for more than several calendar days and typically less than a year if it's above that.

2:09:02 You're really talking about a naming right for a specific facility. So I've tried to make that distinction and that delineation between C and D, so if that makes sense. D also has some specifics in there in regards to what actually is kind of a naming right and kind of what's a threshold. Again, we've kind of looked at best practices from different municipalities. You can see here the three bullet points that were found is either the land was deeded to the town.

2:09:29 A contribution of greater than 50% for the capital construction, which is how Volcom came about. That sponsorship was of that value. And then a provision of a minimum of 10-year agreement for the continued maintenance and or programming of that facility. Each of these different levels, and ABCD has different approval levels. Again, this is just via consideration. Certainly naming rights should be a...

2:09:58 A larger or a more robust approval level than just an event or a program. So that's kind of our recommendation from a council approval with recommendation from commission and staff. That's how that would look. We identify different authority levels, which we've just talked about, and then we really get into the recognition of sponsors, which is number seven. What we haven't done here is list each and every inventory available that we could provide value.

2:10:27 to the sponsor, but that's something we'll certainly get into. It does talk about some specificity in regards to types of recognition, A, B, C level sponsor versus D, how that would kind of be presented. And then the last page on page five is just kind of really the detail. And then we have drafted a, actually I'm working on drafting a sponsorship agreement at this time.

2:10:56 It's very similar to kind of the town's letter of agreement. We want to kind of use a base document. So that letter of agreement really kind of spells out in greater detail the level of sponsorship for the town and then what town will provide in return for that level of sponsorship. And that's very specific to a sponsorship agreement that we want to make sure it's clearly articulated in that agreement.

2:11:21 And then number 14 is really monitoring and reporting the sponsorship performance. So there would be at some point whether it's an annual presentation to commission and council just in regards to the sponsorship they've received and the value and the benefit it's provided for the community. And then the last page is really a definition. So I think I'm pretty happy with it's a good starting point. Again, it hasn't really been reviewed by our town attorney.

2:11:50 Again, this is kind of the first level of review that we're really bringing forward to commission. Again, the plan would be to get this in a draft format. We can get it for review, bring it back May 31, and see if we can get this accepted and in the marketplace. Questions for Steve? This is a pretty big task, I guess bigger than I thought that it was, but you've done a good job in kind of outlining it. Where did you do your research from? Other municipalities? Yep.

2:12:23 Okay. Yeah, we started with about, you know, you just do a search. We've got 20, and then we found the best five. And then, you know, once you look at them and start to dig into them, you can see what makes sense. But anyway, so this was kind of where we've started from. As I said, I mean, it's an aggressive timeline to get this up May 31. If we need a little bit of additional time, that's fine. But I just wanted to get something that we can at least comment on. That's all I'm going to ask right now, but...

2:12:53 I may jump back in depending on other questions. So here's a question. Does everyone feel like this is the right direction for us to take in this policy area? Yeah, I have no issue with it. It is a good start. I need a little more time to digest it.

2:13:11 I agree with that. I have some questions if you want me to go through. Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, go for it. That would be helpful. So anyhow. That's why we're here. On the second page where it says goals and the first thing is not to auction off the community resources to the highest bidder. Right. I guess I'd just like some clarifications of what that means. So anyhow. I found that someplace. I'm trying to remember where. I think it was maybe an article that just talked about.

2:13:38 You know, kind of that you want to make sure when you're doing sponsorship that, you know, particularly for us on the town, on the community resource side, just, you know, that we're not, I mean, I don't think that's a problem for us necessarily right now, but it was just, it was just language that I came across and I thought was, you know, was relevant. I don't know. To me, that kind of is, I don't know that it needs to be there, you know. That's fine. Anyways, I guess I looked at that.

2:14:07 I think it was a little bit of a negative on a goal to me. I think you could state what I think she's trying to say and saying, finding the best possible partners for each project. Yeah, that would probably be a better way to put it. That would be a better way to put it. I understand what she's saying. Yeah. And I stole it from somebody else, so I'm not attached to it. The first person coming in, you don't want to just give the highest bidder if there's other considerations and things as soon as some things fit better than others. Yeah, I don't know. I guess when you're looking at goals, I guess.

2:14:35 That was a little bit of a negative to me. So that was just my first thing. I think it was from a National Parks and Rec publication, because I think it was more on that side, just in talking about best practices. Sounds like the way they pitch it, too. Yeah. But it really is about finding the best partners. It is about finding the best partners. So maybe we can just wordsmith that. Yeah, we could wordsmith that. So anyway, so. And I can go through this again, too. But just don't make some.

2:15:03 Just comments on some of the things on page two when you get into the actual sponsorship policy. The first bullet point, sponsorships cannot be made conditional on the performance of Parks and Recreation Department or Town of Mammoth Lakes. Some sponsorships may be that they, you know, they're going to do this, like Vulcan's holding, you know, an event, I think, once or twice a year. So that is actually makes a condition upon

2:15:34 the performance of that facility. So I guess that, you know, maybe there is some ask, you know, if we're going to put this into it, there might be, you know, maybe some ask of, you know, an event or use or something like that. If somebody is putting a sponsorship sign in the ice rink,

2:16:01 incumbent upon us in their contract would be that the ice rink actually is open. So there are some things that, you know, the towns... Yeah, I think it's a legal question, not a policy question. No, actually, I think that is. I think that's something that we just need to clarify was, you know, but so anyhow. Got it. And then sponsorship benefits offered should be commensurate with the relative value of the sponsorship.

2:16:29 So I'm not sure that those kind of don't kind of go hand in hand or contradict each other a little bit. I don't know. No, I think that's, you know, we're not going to let someone name a building for $5. Well, yeah, okay. Yeah, that's exactly, yeah. Well, yeah, absolutely. Yep. And then, you know, that actually, your threshold of $100,000 or more, I would question that, but that's kind of.

2:16:54 It's an arbitrary number right now, right? Yeah. If you're going to give somebody naming rights, I think it needs to be more significant than $100,000. Unless it's a $50,000 project. Well, this is true. So then it needs to be a percentage over a certain percentage. Maybe it's a percentage, so it's like 50% of the project, like you said. Yeah, and I think that's why it's got those bullet points underneath to put some more parameters on that.

2:17:17 What else we got? An evaluation of the potential sponsor, which shall include, but not limited to, the products and services they offer. So I can see that if it's a product that's going to be offensive or an issue to the community or the facility, that would be fine. Company's record of involvement in environmental stewardship and social responsibility. So what if they never were involved in anything?

2:17:48 Environmental or Stewardship or Social, you know, I guess socially responsible, you know, that might be fine, but I guess I would question that one. You know, principles of the company, it might be an individual, but how are you clarifying the principles? I mean, I guess if they've been indicted for some horrible crime, then you might not want to have it there, but anyways.

2:18:16 And then sponsors rationale for its interest in the town of Mammoth Lakes, Parks and Recreation. I guess that's reasonable. But the other two I was kind of questioning a little bit. I don't know. Maybe it's just wordsmithing some of these things as to what that is. And then down on sponsorship categories, events. Basically the events consist specifically as to what's named here as community events.

2:18:44 Would there be something that somebody could possibly, if there is another events program that's going on or something like that for other events that are going on within the town and somebody wants to donate, could it be outside of a community event, I guess is what I'm looking at. Yeah, I don't think there was any reference to community. I was just kind of, just for example, I just put in...

2:19:10 What we typically do. I mean, we would love to have a sponsor for our community, Easter Egg Hunt and Play Day, Halloween, Skate with Santa, those type of things. And you were saying if there's a separate event. I think that's who knows if somebody wants to come in and say, even sponsor, you know, some other event that's going on in town that's not really a town event. Well, anyhow. Well, would they give us the money then? There you go. Well, you're usually doing in-kind services and you're doing other things too. Got it. Okay. And...

2:19:40 Then when it came to all the naming rights, I have a whole bunch of comments and questions there, but I can't even read my own comments. I've got scribbles everywhere. So if somebody else can go ahead and I'll make sense of what I've got. Do we have questions or do you want to go to public comments?

2:20:04 Yeah, it's good probably, I'm just saying that because, yeah, there's a lot of questions here and some of them are legal, some of them are philosophical. Right. In some ways, you know, Terry, I'm not entirely opposed to principles of a company, but I understand that that's so subjective. Subjective, I guess, that's what I'm trying to. Anyway, I'd like to spend a little bit of time with this. Yeah, you know, I think today maybe we're just taking preliminary comments and, you know, maybe we'll come back with another, you know.

2:20:32 One comment that I came up with as far as naming rights go is that you're talking about a finite time period that somebody would have their name up there. Some of them were a year, some of them maybe longer, but just depending on how much money people are putting into something, I don't know, maybe we look at a useful life of a facility and maybe if the amount is significant enough for that useful life, so then when that

2:21:02 Facility then is going to need to either be rebuilt or, you know, major kind of renovation, that that would be the time that you would notify these people and say, hey, this is, you know, so I don't know if that can be. Although, and I'm not ready to say yes or no to one way or the other, but in there he has, besides your sponsorship, there's going to be a maintenance commitment. Yeah. Which would be a revolving contract. You've got a 10-year period if you.

2:21:29 Continue the maintenance contract after the 10 years, your name should stay on it. But if you don't, then that would terminate your name at the end of that maintenance contract. And so what if it's a facility that the town, like our muff, that the town is already building and they're looking at maintaining, are you looking for somebody to help you with the capital to get that thing built, or are you looking for somebody to help you to support it, or both? So I guess I don't know if you tie that...

2:21:58 Same person that might come up with that capital to do what you want if the town is already looking at being able to support that facility. So I don't know. I think it's case by case. I think in all the research that we did, I mean, one of the reasons this policy was...

2:22:13 took so long to draft is because it is pretty subjective and it is a lot about relationship building. So on that note, I'd like to get a public comment because I think Rich probably has something to go away. And it's a great starting point. No, it's a great starting point. Thank you. So anyhow. Agreed. Great starting points too. Thanks. You know, MLR has talked about this in terms of sponsorships, where this goes, and I'd like to get more involved in this process to make sure we're covering all the bases. But bottom page two.

2:22:37 Organizations that are prohibited. Talks about sex and drugs and rock and roll in there. Tell me I'm having conversations, obviously, with a number of partners at this point in time. Implications for perhaps a Heineken or a Red Bull or a Monster. Give me some direction on how those fit or wouldn't fit, you know, in terms of maybe sponsoring an event, a summer series of something, you know, those types of things. Clarify that for me if you could as I...

2:23:03 Well, remember, these are town-specific things. But if we're using R&U funds to build facilities, right? This is town funds at that point in time. At the end of the day, there'll be some maintenance attached to these for ongoing sustainability. So do we have a conflict of a X, Y, or Z coming in, even though it's private funds, to support now town-owned and managed facilities? Yeah, well, we're talking specifically about, you know, town.

2:23:31 owned and managed, you know, parks, programs, facilities, so I don't know that, you know, we don't necessarily want to have the Heineken adaptive playground kind of thing. How about Heineken supports the Outdoor Performing Arts Center? The Heineken Music Festival. I think that's case by case. Yeah. I mean, Sean's always good about putting root beer on the camp t-shirt, so. But it is a conversation, and it's why this does have to go through legal review. This is just the precedent in other communities, so. Thank you.

2:24:03 It's a good point. It's a good point. We basically say organisations are not eligible. You know, there could be some language in there that broadens it a little bit. It's subjective, I think. So I think there's flexibility. And I think throughout this document, I think the chair made a good point that it is a case-by-case. I think that's what we really found. So I think the goal here is to provide enough context to the discussion, but not limit it in any.

2:24:26 Shape or form, right? So I think when we talk about that's why you see the language typically one year or more. I mean, I'm talking about approximate levels of money and those type of things. That's what I took out of the other documents that really had really specific numbers. And I think that's for us, you know, as general as we can. So you're interested in being a naming right or, you know, purchasing naming rights for one of our facilities? Great. So what language can we really start with would it get them interested in that discussion and how we can kind of formulate the best partnership?

2:24:55 Right for the town and the organization. I think that's the whole goal of this document to kind of, you know, create that starting point and give it some context. So that would just be my comment there. But I think it's a good start. So at this point, I'll just kind of keep working with it, get it to legal. We'll get back kind of a red line document with you on May 31 and just see where it's at at that point. I do think we need to be cognizant of putting down in there so people understand it's a case by case. If Budweiser wanted to sponsor the multi-use facility, my gosh, I'd have no problem with it.

2:25:24 Okay, it's a beer company, but it's, you know, 90% of the people in town drink beer. If they want to come forward with $5 million and $200,000 a year for maintenance of the facility, I would certainly want to consider their bid. So there was a concern about auctioning facilities off to the highest bidder. I've heard Heineken.

2:25:48 I've heard Budweiser. Sean, do you want to weigh in? I'm so staying out of this. You know, I think Stu has proposed a good plan for him. It's a framework. I suggest we move on.

2:25:59 It's a framework. And what I would suggest is maybe if commissioners have really specific comments, maybe just send them to Stu and he can work them into the next draft for us to look at on May 31st. But I think it's a good discussion. I think it's taken us a long time to kind of get to this point. I think what we're trying to do is just establish a framework because we do have Rich going out and talking to companies. So I think we do just want to have some guidelines, obviously flexibility.

2:26:27 And we've even had people ask about, you know, naming streets, and that doesn't go to this point as far as this goes, but it could cover that as well, but I don't know. It's a starting point for sure. What level, just a quick question to the Commission, what level, I know there is engagement with MLR, what level of interaction would the Commission be comfortable at what point that this document was either presented, reviewed, or there was some type of engagement regarding...

2:26:54 Feedback input to the document. I think feedback would be really important because I know that Rich has been actually talking to different people so you might have an idea of kind of what people are looking at. So I think having Rich review that and bring those comments.

2:27:12 As well, I think that would be helpful. I think that would be valuable, and I want to stress, too, I mean, I think, you know, all of us are clear on this, but just for the benefit of the community is that, you know, we're just, we're really just talking about, you know, town facilities, and that's, you know, we are the policy, you know, advisory body, and so that's, I think, why this is an appropriate place to start that discussion, and it's, you know, still, we have a ways to go. I absolutely agree, but with the town facilities, with

2:27:39 MLR being asked to come up with the additional funding to potentially help the other projects along that I think that the information that Rich has in going out there and talking to people is probably pretty beneficial. Yeah, if this were a business, you are our sales force in some ways with regard to this. So I think that review at the very least.

2:28:05 And involvement in development of this is kind of critical. And that's also why we kind of kept it really broad in terms of that $100,000 floor because we didn't want to, you know, limit it. We just, you know, we don't know yet. This is something I was going to cover in request for agenda items, but naming conventions for the town. At one point in time, the Historical Society was asked, well, what are appropriate historical names and where should we be?

2:28:32 You know, for streets, for assets, for things like that. We haven't really addressed that yet. And I would love to see us put that back on somewhere. So which organization is the one that would lead that, MLR, our rep commission, or public works? That might be planning commission. Could be planning on it. Yeah, PDC. Yeah. So I don't know. It's a good question now. We can get into it.

2:28:58 Okay, so does that work for everyone? You can send comments to Stu. I'll bring back another draft. I'll look at my scribbles and make heads and tails of them. Is there a, good question, is there a committee, the MLR? Yeah, would this be appropriate for? Reviews sponsorship? I know you've got several committees. Do you have one specifically? At this point, no. Okay. I would imagine it's working on. Okay. No.

2:29:31 No, that's why I just said, you know, have Rich review it and take any comments that he might to legal as well, because then I think that might be beneficial. Great. And thanks, Stu, for putting it all together. You're welcome. Thank you. That had to be a pretty big task, so starting from scratch. Okay, so I will move us on to Commissioner Reports. Clayton, start with you. I don't really have a report so much as a comment.

2:30:02 Apparently successful fishing opener has come and gone. And we have had issues opening the Lake Basin in the past several years. And apparently somebody was having none of it this weekend and cut the lock up there and opened the gate on Friday. And the Forest Service was livid and actively removing people from the Lake Basin area. So just a heads up, I'm sure town staff is probably aware or if not.

2:30:33 Probably hear of it. And I guess on that note, when, you know, they're advertising that they're opening Tioga, which they didn't end up doing, but when they're advertising opening up Tioga on that Friday, and we're saying that we can't open the Lakes Basin until the 10th of May, that didn't go over well with my customers either. I have to say that they, you know, hopefully they weren't the ones that were getting lost. But anyways, it was a point of contention.

2:31:01 Well, and the wording on Taylor was confusing too because people thought the whole thing was opening. No, it's just to the first gate. Oh, okay. Well, then there would have been a lot of disappointed people anyway. Yeah. So, yeah. So that communication out there and, you know, why and that because people look and they're like, I can walk it. It's clear. So why aren't we opening it? So I think we need to get out there, just publicize, you know.

2:31:25 What the reasoning is behind not opening it, you know, what the state of the road needs to be in, what bathrooms need to be open, what the, you know, what everything is. We make sure that it's in service. I would say this. I was on the committee, and I still get noticed for the meetings every year for the opening and closing of the Lakes Basin and the Reds Meadows Road. You all know how important they both are to me. I stopped going to the meetings because of the frustration of every time we set up new criteria.

2:31:52 Then through political pressure and push, they get open when they shouldn't. The Lakes Basin Road to have it plowed prior to opening day, cut off access for all the snowmobilers who only get it for two or three weeks a year when there was adequate snow, for the snowshoers, for the cross-country skiers, for all of the users who traditionally go up there when there's still snow on the ground, and left it so the people who don't do those pursuits couldn't drive their vehicles up there. So nobody can use it. It was a dumb decision.

2:32:21 To open the road and still have so much snow so that after we've plowed it, we don't open it to the public for three weeks, somehow is wrong. There were criteria set up originally to see to it that didn't happen and they don't get followed. I don't know who's putting pressure where.

2:32:39 As I said, there were meetings that just frustrated me, so I stopped going. Maybe I need to start going to them again. But yes, that is incredibly frustrating. I understand the frustration of whoever cut the lock because we've decided that the best way to manage it is to close it. Yeah, I'm done. Okay. All right. So anything for us? That's it. Okay. All right. Thanks, Clayton. That's good. Terry?

2:33:08 I don't have anything to add. I've just been going to the programming meetings as we've been having those on the month. So anyhow, Sean? Yeah, I actually wanted to follow up with that comment as well. You know, I realized that when we went through the consent agenda that this is a question that might be best in the staff report as far as where are we with Lake Mason and what's the current status up there.

2:33:34 And maybe this is a request for agenda item. I don't think it is. Maybe it's more just making sure that it's included in the staff report.

2:33:41 And maybe it's too late at this point because by May 31st it's going to be open, right? May 10th is what the proposed date is of opening right now. Okay. And May 10th came around because it was pointed out by the businessmen that they wanted to see us start plowing it by May 10th each year so they could be open for Memorial Day. And somehow that is now being interpreted as they wanted to open it by May 10th. So to provide that, they started plowing it last Monday.

2:34:09 But the May 10th originally came about because that's the date you have to start plowing it so that the businesses can have Memorial Day. Those of us in businesses can certainly understand that, and that makes sense. But to have it so that we can open it by May 10th in a big snow year makes no sense. Yeah, got it. Okay. So anyway, as far as commissioner reports actually go, I just want to say that I'm really pleased that we at Manor Burning Company...

2:34:33 I do choose to only advertise the root beer when it comes to various school type, you know, with regard to this discussion of Budweiser and Heineken. Thank you. Thank you. And it looks good on a T-shirt. It was a decent opening of fishing. It was very cold. I was at Crowley as usual. My boat did get fish in. No one limited. And for a lot of the tourists down there,

2:35:04 That don't know the lake really well and everything else. Catching fish was really hard. I keep harping on the fact that we have to do something about how our assets are managed. If you're into big fish and that's all you're going for, Crowley right now is a great asset. I did manage to get, you know, a couple of four-pounders and a couple of three-pounders in the boat for the fishermen I took out. I never put a line in the water.

2:35:25 But just something we need to be cognizant of. The fewest number of people I have ever seen on the lake this opening day. And there are those who would say this is because of the weather. But I've been out there when it's so cold you couldn't reel your reel in because it froze. And that was not the case this year. So it's not just weather related. We are losing customers every year.

2:35:49 And Crowley, while it's out of our bailiwick, which is why I keep saying we can't keep ourselves in the three square miles, it is a huge asset for the town of Mammoth Lakes. We've lost the sailing community, the water ski community, and now the fishing community is going away that used to sustain us, that used to recreate on Crowley Lake. It is an important asset. We need to be more proactive in helping manage. Okay. Thank you.

2:36:18 Okay, so just for me briefly, I was at Youth Advisory Committee on April 8th, Council on April 20th. The Recreation Open House was great, very nice job, guys. It was good, well attended. We talked about maybe mixing it up a little bit for next year, maybe moving it over to the Rec Zone to kind of help publicize that facility, which I think is a good idea, and I'm excited for the pool to open on Monday.

2:36:43 That's it for me. So agenda items, Stuart, do you just want to quickly talk about our field trip for our next meeting? Yeah, so that might be considering what would documentation, MCP update, program back. So we talked about the desire to do a park visit. Do we want to do that, or do we want to just, you know, do that independently? Which park? We talked about going to see the work at Trails End Park, which will be in progress, and also Mammoth Creek Park.

2:37:23 Just especially as we're moving forward on our recommendations for Mammoth Creek Park. So would you all be comfortable going to check out parks on your own? Let's go check them out on our own. I think that would probably be the most efficient use of our time, right? Unless there was something else specific. I think that's a good use of our time. Yeah, because that's a big agenda. Yeah, that is a big agenda. As one of the commissioners whose time is coming up, what is the process of finding new people?

2:37:54 When does that go out? We actually have a great committee, our Recreation Facilities Program Committee, and the Chair and Commissioner Turner took upon themselves to talk a little bit more about the commission and its role in the community. Do a little marketing. A little valuable group that I think has got a little bit more insight into kind of the ongoing happenings and the responsibilities of the commission. So I think there's some interesting people. But in terms of candidates there. Yeah, I think so. I think we pretty much.

2:38:22 When does that go out for them to apply? So in terms of process, I believe that your three terms end on July 31st. I believe that's how it's structured. So I think it's prior to that time. I think it's after the new council. I'll bring it forward. I think I might bring that forward. I'll bring the process forward May 31. I think we just need to put that out there as we're talking to people and let people know what's going on. Yeah, I think that would be great, yeah, because we really would like some good... And as retiring commissioners.

2:38:52 I know there are a couple people I plan on going and asking if they will not put their names in the hat. I plan on that too, but it's nice to know what the timeline is and what we're telling them when they need to have an application in. I'll bring that forward. Yeah, that would be awesome. Good information. Yeah, exactly. Thank you. I just don't like to think about that, but I think that. All right. Okay, so if there's nothing further, then I will adjourn us to May 16th, our special meeting on May 16th. Thank you.

2:39:21 Thanks, everybody. Thanks. Thank you. I thought we went fast, and we still took three hours. Yeah, right. Sean, did you read all of this so you can give me a synopsis so I don't have to spend it down before tomorrow night? I was just looking at our specific stuff. You're the candidate. You've got to know that inside out, right? Eventually, I do. Yes, you do.

2:39:59 Thank you. Push hard. What's happening?

2:40:45 What's going on in this room next? We have a union meeting. Oh, okay. Okay, we're out of here. Your name has come up in our conversations lately regarding those who are really looking to us sincerely. Looking forward to having you involved in some of the discussions. Okay, great.

2:41:17 We're actually driving people up north, up a lot of the church lot, so many people, you know, just 8,000 feet, like one block of office, after you've had a few beers. So anyway, we'll catch up with you. We're trying to finalize our driving presentation for you guys this week. I think he's in 10 out of two weeks, the week of the 16th event.

2:41:45 I'm doing well. Good to see you. Good to see you too. See you guys.

2:42:16 Get in front of the e-sports funding groups. Approach business. Right. And then all we really want to do is if we are recommending some type of funding increase, what's appropriate, that's all. If there's any changes related to your budgets and so forth. That's all.

2:42:47 Good meeting with swim teams. There's no rule changes there. They just want to get in the pool. They want to stay in the pool. After we finish lap swim, before we get into the pool. We do lap swim, they do their swim team, and we shut it up. We always kind of had one or two lines that's transitioning.

2:43:16 Oh, see, we'll do the best we can. I don't know if I can move forward with how much lessons look. You know, I'm sorry. Exactly. So I kind of saved you up. Yeah, they do. Yeah, they do. It's the reality, right? So, I mean, as you know, they really want a lot of time anymore. Yes. We're getting that discussion right there, right? No, not yet. But that might come up on the 16th. But, you know, like, does something cost us so much money? Yep, yep.

2:43:47 Yeah. Yeah.

2:44:34 Yeah, you're super late. You were supposed to be out of here at 1130. Well, we told you 1130 thinking you would get out of here at, you know, 12. Read that back there? Good.

2:45:52 Thank you.