Town Council
· recording 6 hr 20 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
583 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:02:43 You ready? Well, John's in the phone. He's not ready. You ready? Yes, sir. Good evening. Welcome. Thanks for joining us. I'll now call to order the Town Council Town of Mammoth Lakes regular meeting scheduled for Wednesday, May 18, 2016, 6.04 p.m. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I've asked Councilmember Wentworth to lead us in the pledge this evening. Please rise and follow after me. I pledge allegiance to the flag.
2:03:16 So Council has just exited a closed session. We have no reportable action for this evening. I'll move on to public comments. Anyone would like to address Council that's not on our agenda? Come on forward. Hello, Town Council.
2:03:46 Thank you very much. My name is Kathy Copeland, and on behalf of Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra, I would like to inform and invite you all to an accessible pathway that is going in from the beach at June Lake, from the parking lot at June Lake, across the beach, down to the water. And this is going to be great for people in wheelchairs, for people in walkers, for people
2:04:15 And so Dave McCoy, Bob Schott,
2:04:45 John Fredrickson, and Randy Short all chipped in the money for this Dick Knowles Wounded Warrior Pathway. And we are having a general Ted Banta is coming up to be the keynote speaker for that event. So anyone who wants to come is welcome. The more the merrier for that. Also, the more...
2:05:06 The merrier for the Eastern Sierra Music Festival, which is coming up July 22nd and 23rd, featuring Dwight Yoakam and the Gatlin Brothers down at the fairgrounds, and it's a two-day musical festival, and it's being put on by a non-profit down in Bishop, and the proceeds will benefit the National Wounded Warrior Center, so I will leave.
2:05:33 Posters and flyers and things on the desk out there if anyone wants to take anything. Anyone have any questions about it? Nope. Either of them? Okay, thank you. Thank you so much. Thanks, Kevin. Good evening, Council, Mayor. My name is Jennifer Burrows. I'm running for Town Council. I come with a vast amount of experience in government. Some of my experience includes older adults.
2:06:07 And Community Services Commission for the City of Escondido, as well as Personnel Review Board. I served on the San Pasquale School Foundation for three years in which I was an Executive Director. We raised almost $100,000 during that time, which is more than we have ever raised before or since. I also was elected with the most votes to the San Pasquale Union School Board and served for five years.
2:06:36 Two of which I was president of the school board. I have extensive experience with labor negotiations, which is what you guys are going through right now. And I also know all about government budgets and the ins and outs of those, which none of the other candidates have experience in. I would like to provide economic stability to our town as well as improve the community.
2:07:06 I'd like to commend you guys on the joint meeting with the county yesterday. I'd like to continue to do more stuff like that and reach out to various entities around the county, including the county, the forest, and other towns up and down the 395 corridor to see what resources we can bring into our community.
2:07:31 I'd also like to invite you to the candidates' forum tomorrow night at the Edison Theater. It starts at 6 o'clock, and that's the meet and greet until about 7, and 7 to 8 is questions for the candidates. If you have any questions, please let me know. I'm on Facebook. Look up Jennifer Burrows from Mammoth Town Council. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Jennifer.
2:08:03 Good evening, Council. Jennifer Halferty with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I just want to take a few minutes tonight during public comment to let you know that Mammoth Lakes Housing is working on some work at the Shady Rest site. I know Mark Carney was here representing the owners of that site last week.
2:08:22 And gave you some information, but I wanted to just kind of flesh it out a little bit from our side that, yes, indeed, we did reach out to the owners to see about entering some kind of negotiations on acquiring the site. And we were told that they weren't interested at this time. They're waiting for the Hart-Howerton plan that the Mountain is working on.
2:08:47 So with that in mind, in the meantime, Mammoth Lakes Housing is performing due diligence on the site, looking at a feasibility analysis on the development of it within the current master plan, utilizing cap and trade funds. It's a new funding source called the Affordable Housing and Sustainable Communities Program that has a rule set aside. This year it had $33 million available.
2:09:14 In fact, last round, Truckee received $8 million for a program up there. So we're looking at that. That's a new source of funding that could really make this all the more feasible. And as you know, it's been zoned affordable housing for decades, and so we're just trying to see if now isn't the right time to get that underway.
2:09:37 We've hired an architect. We're working with the Rural Community Assistance Corporation. It's a nonprofit based out of Sacramento. And that's where we are right now. We're just beginning work with those two on a feasibility analysis and hope to have a full analysis and a site plan, rough site plan by the end of the summer. And we'd bring that back to you at that time. So that'll be an agenda item at that time?
2:10:08 I would believe so, yes. It would need more than just public comment, yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Anybody else? Okay, seeing none, I'm going to move on to Councilmember Reports. I'm going to start with you, Cohen. Sure. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just a couple items for me, some of which have already been touched on.
2:10:29 I did attend the first Council Candidate Forum, which was held Tuesday, May 10th at the Sierra Events Center, and I was going to give a reminder that we have the next one coming up this Thursday at 6 p.m. at Edison Theater. On Friday, May 13th, I attended an Outdoor Performing Arts Center meeting with a group of interested stakeholders, including Rich Bacia from MLR.
2:10:55 Dan Holler and John Regalbrugge from the U.S. Forest Service came and spoke to us. So that was very helpful as we've talked about that list of potential sites to get some feedback from the Forest Service about essentially what's in play and what's out. So we have another follow-up meeting coming up here shortly, and I'll have more to report out on that as that gets finalized, but a very productive meeting. All five of us attended the
2:11:23 Joint meeting with the county yesterday. Just want to say thank you to the county for their time and for everyone for putting that together. We all kind of discussed how that was long overdue and something that I hope to continue doing on a periodic basis. And then at the last council meeting, I discussed with everyone and got some direction from the council to work with Dan Holler.
2:11:47 on just kind of tightening up our strat document a little bit. We did have a chance to do that today. I will send my thoughts and suggestions out to the council tomorrow so that you have some time to review it and take a look at it at the meeting on Friday. But essentially, we've tried to just consolidate a number of pages down to a front and back document so it's really easy to read and digest, move some things around. Very little as far as...
2:12:16 You know, actual substantial changes. But I want to get that out to everyone tomorrow so you have a chance to look at that. That's it for me. Thank you. Jill? Just remind everybody of the time for the meeting on Friday. That's a good question. I won't be there. One o'clock. Thank you. One o'clock on Friday. To follow on, since obviously there were some things that we had all attended, on Monday I attended the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting.
2:12:44 And I have something extremely significant to announce. The Owens Lake Dust Control Project, this thing that has been worked on for so many years by the district, is going to receive the EPA Clean Air Excellence Award. It is the highest award it is giving out. They won out in the competition over the Paris Greenhouse Gas Accord.
2:13:07 This is a huge thing. So some staff will be going back to Washington at the end of June to receive this award. It is a huge thing. It's the largest dust control project in the world. Wow. Is that it? That's it. Thank you. John? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So a couple things. I attended last Saturday the Tahoe Trail Summit up in Tahoe, which is a gathering a lot of trail organizations.
2:13:36 Trail builders, trail economic development folks. Very interesting gathering, a lot of like-minded folks. Heard, once again, reinforced in a small, dirty little town called Moab, Utah, generating hundreds of millions of dollars of economic activity just from their trail system. So it's a reminder that I think we're on the right path for the things that we're doing.
2:14:02 LTC meeting on May 9th. We miss you, Mr. Chairman. Very interesting meeting, but again, the continued woes of state funding for transportation, continued woes about federal funding for transportation, looking for alternative means to try to close some of those gaps. Yesterday, I attended with all of you the meeting with the Board of Supervisors, and I think it's not just a platitude.
2:14:25 To say that this was a good effort. I think it's really important to keep those lines of communications institutionally going between us so that we avoid miscommunications, chatter about, oh, they're doing this, they're doing that. It's a very important thing to keep doing. And a couple other items. The first thing is the District Ranger mentioned, sort of in passing, an MOU about a new partnership focuses on increased use of fire in California for natural resources and benefits.
2:14:55 I'm wondering, this is a much more significant thing I think he talked about. This is the idea that fire on the west side is going to be used for controlled burns in a much more aggressive way that's been used in the past. I think it's going to be important for folks in our town and this side to understand what the implications of this are. I don't know if, Dan, this is something we could have someone come back. Maybe the S&C can come back and talk about this. But there may be a lot more smoke this summer that's not coming from lightning strike fires, but from actual controlled burns. This is a thing. We're probably going to see something like that.
2:15:25 Yeah. Yeah. I say when we do the tour, we'll get a better feel for that so we can report back about what they're... Yeah, I think this is something that the public really needs to know what's going on with this. The other thing is the California State Bike and Pedestrian Plan, which is a very ambitious, aggressive thing happening across the state, was not going to come to the east side of California, but now they are. So I would encourage folks with an interest in bicycle and pedestrian mobility...
2:15:48 Thursday, June 2nd at the Caltrans office, 10 to noon in the stakeholder form from 1 to 3. And I'll put this in the back, but I would encourage everybody. In Bishop. In Bishop, yeah, at Caltrans office down there. It's a very important thing to go to. And the other thing we talked about again at the LTC is the California Road Charge Pilot Program. And the state is looking for 1,500 volunteers, I believe.
2:16:12 To be participating in this program, this is a very important thing because transportation is changing how we drive, how...
2:16:20 Road maintenance is paid for out of gasoline fuel taxes, these kinds of things. This is all changing radically. It's very important for us in these rural areas to know what to get the data and the information into the state so they can know how to start budgeting to take care of our roads or transportation infrastructure. So this is the California Road Charge Pilot Program. Sign up now. It's a limited opportunity. CaliforniaRoadChargePilot.com. I'll leave this in the back table as well. And I think that's it. Thank you. Thanks, John. Shields.
2:16:49 Nothing extra to report. Okay. I also attended our first ever in town's history county town council liaison meeting yesterday, and I thought it was very productive. I think what's more important is that as we have been working with our strategic partners, our NGO partners on our plan for the last eight months or so,
2:17:17 How important it is that we're all rolling in the same direction, and I believe that county needs to be a big part of that. And I think we kind of discussed that yesterday, and I think it's important for us to... It was a great start. A great start, and more of those meetings to continue. So that's all I had to add. One thing, Jamie, I just received a couple messages that we're having an issue with the meeting not streaming online. Can you check into that while we continue on? Mr. Mayor, real quick, I forgot to mention that May is bike month.
2:17:46 It is. I'm going to get to it, too. Oh, I'm sorry. Good. Okay, I understand we have a couple additions, urgency additions to the agenda this evening. One is adopt a resolution authorizing the submittal of application of payment programs and related authorizations for the Department of Resources, Recycling, and Recovery, which is also listed as item 7A, but we're going to take it now. And also the other item is options for conducting town council elections.
2:18:14 I'm going to entertain a motion from Council that we could add these items, please. So moved. Second. Okay. I have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
2:18:31 Yes, motion passes five. And just to clarify, that's based on a provision of the Brown Act that allows you to add things to the agenda if there's a need to take immediate action and if you've learned the need to take action after the agenda was posted, which I think was the motion you just made, and in this case, both of these do require immediate action. Great. We'll do it. I'll go ahead and read that. Then it was moved by Councilmember Bacon, seconded by Mayor Pro Tem Richardson, and carried a 5-0 vote that pursuant to the Government Code Section 549.
2:19:01 5-4-2B2. The Council hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for action came to the attention of the town subsequent to the agenda being posted as specific Subdivision A said item being. We're going to go ahead and start with the first item, Grady. You want to take that item?
2:19:19 Item 7A has to do with an application we have been filing on an annual basis with CalRecycle since 1999. Basically, the last few years, they provided about $5,000 a year for recyclable containers. You see a lot of the condominium projects and HOAs.
2:19:37 This year they required us to do it by resolution before we could send that application in. Unfortunately, we learned that the deadline for that is June 1st at 5 o'clock. So we were going to do it next time. June 1st at 5 o'clock is before the next council meeting. That's the reason for the urgency item. It's something we've been doing again for 16 years, but this time they would like a resolution. We only have to do that once because in the resolution itself it says it will remain in effect unless rescinded by the party. But I thank you for taking this tonight.
2:20:06 Okay, any questions for staff? Yes, just one is, did the town attorney review this? Not yet. Okay. Any questions from the public? Okay, bring it back to council for further discussion and or a motion, please. Just another kind of question is, it does not look like this commits us to anything? No, not at all. It just allows us to apply and they give us right now $5,000 a year. That's it. I've reviewed the resolution and it looks fine. Thank you.
2:20:41 Would you like to make a motion? Yeah, I'll move. The council adopts a resolution authorizing submittal of application for payment programs and related authorizations for the Department of Resources, Recycling, and Recovery. Seconded. Okay, a motion is seconded. Welcome, please, Jimmy. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. We're going to move on to the second item options for conducting town council elections. Bob? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the town council.
2:21:12 I'm Bob Musil. I'm the Registrar of Voters for Mono County. As you may be aware, last week we mailed out sample ballots to all voters in Mono County. Last Thursday we received the vote-by-mail ballots from our printer, and Monday morning all of those ballots went into the mail. About an hour after that I got an email from Jamie that apparently Mr. Haller had looked at the sample ballot and had caught a mistake in it. Where there are two seats available,
2:21:42 On your council that are up for election this year, the sample ballot, and I subsequently discovered the ballots themselves instructed voters to vote for three people. Let me start by being very clear, that was not a mistake that was made by your staff. That was not a mistake that was made by my staff. That error was mine. It was a proofreading error. It happened. I apologize. I take full responsibility, and I apologize not only to your council, but also to the voters of Mammoth Lakes.
2:22:11 Having said that, I have been working for the last two days with members of the county council's office and today with your town attorney looking at the options that we have to resolve this issue. We have come up with five possible courses of action and if you'd like, I would like to go ahead and outline those possible options along with the pros and cons of each one and then let you know what we have determined is the best course of action. Sure. We don't have any printed material on that, right?
2:22:41 No. No, you do not. Okay. Sure, go ahead. Okay. The first option that we have is to reprint the entire ballot. That would allow voters to just cast one ballot. It would have the town council meeting with the correct instructions. It would have everything. Everybody would go to the polls or vote by mail, just like they always have.
2:23:06 The advantage of this is it's the easiest thing for voters to understand. It's the type of system they've been using for years. The voting machines that we have would tally the votes correctly right out of the box, and there's no additional training of poll workers that's required. Some of the negatives to this proposal are that because of the way that the ballots are put together, we would not have to reprint just the ballots for the town of Mammoth Lakes. We would have to reprint the ballots for the entire county.
2:23:33 May 31st is the last day that we can mail out vote replacement vote by mail ballots to anybody. We have a holiday weekend coming up and it's extremely questionable whether we would be able to get the ballots in time to turn them around and meet those requirements. Because we would be reprogramming the ballots and reprogramming our database to instruct voters and only count as correct ballots that have no more than two voters, we would have to reprogram the database.
2:24:03 We would have to reprogram the voting machines to correctly read the ballots, and the testing of machines that we're required to do would take more than 30 hours. We're, again, logistically, we're getting down to the point where that's pretty difficult to hit. We would have to reissue all of the vote-by-mail ballots, not only for the town, but county-wide.
2:24:25 Since some voters have already received their ballots and have likely already cast them, we feel that this would lead to a fair amount of voter confusion as to why they're getting a second ballot that so closely matches the one they just returned. The final problem with this and really the biggest issue that we face is that there is a federal program called the Uniformed and Overseas Civilian
2:24:53 Assistance with Voting Act. We call it UOCAVA. Under UOCAVA and under California state law, we have to mail or provide a ballot to every uniformed military person or every overseas voter no more than 60 days and no less than 45 days before an election. Obviously, we've already passed that 45-day threshold. However, we feel that...
2:25:20 This is probably allowable because we're not sending out a new ballot. We're correcting an error on an existing ballot. I will be on the phone with the Secretary of State's office tomorrow morning to work with them and make sure that that is allowable. The second option that we have is to use the existing ballots that have already been printed and have already been mailed out to the voters. But when they are tallied, disregard.
2:25:45 The votes that were cast for the Town Council contest. Instead, we will create essentially a special election that will run in parallel with the general primary, with the primary election. The special election would just have one ballot measure on it, that being the contest for the Town Council. It would have, obviously, the correct information on it. It would be much simpler for us to program the database, program the machines, and test the machines.
2:26:16 So that would be a pretty easy option for us. On the other hand, we're going to have to take a spare machine out of storage and make sure that we have the equipment to make that work right. Again, we run into the time frame. We have to get the ballots back from the printer in time to get them out to the voters. It'll be a little bit confusing for the poll workers explaining to people why they are going to cast one ballot and then why they're going to cast a second ballot for just one measure.
2:26:45 That second ballot, the one for the town council, we do not have enough machines to run the ballots through the machines at the polling place. So what we would do is we would collect those ballots at the precinct, and then after the polls close, we would bring them back and feed them through a central machine in Bridgeport to get the count on that. There is the possibility for confusion for people that have already voted their entire ballot.
2:27:12 And now they get a second ballot for just the town council candidates. And we run into the same potential issue with the UOCAVA votes where if the Secretary of State and the Federal Department of Justice don't approve doing it, then we would be in violation of federal law and we would be, both the county and the town would be subject to possible enforcement action. That election, the secondary ballot would occur in June? Either of those options would run on June 7th, yes. Okay.
2:27:42 The third option that we have is to leave the ballot just as is, send out letters to every voter, do a media blitz with possibly TV, radio, newspapers, do everything that we can to inform the voters, despite the instruction on the ballot to vote for three, that they need to vote for no more than two. This obviously is probably the simplest option. We don't have to print anything. We don't have to reprogram anything. We just go with it.
2:28:11 However, if we do that and somebody does vote for three, the machines as they are currently programmed will still go on ahead and count that as a valid ballot, will result in overvotes, and with that possibility, any candidate or any voter that feels that votes were improperly cast has the option to bring legal action against, again, the town and the county to make sure that everything is done properly. Option number four.
2:28:40 We would go ahead and hold the election on June 7th for every contest with the exception of the town council. We would then probably in August or early September hold a special election just for the single ballot measure of the contests for the seats on the town council. This would allow us to go on forward with everything for the primary election with minimal disruption to that election.
2:29:10 It would minimize voter confusion. There would be virtually no extra work on behalf of the poll workers. And with the concurrence of your council, we would be able to hold that as an all-mail ballot election. So we would save a lot on the cost of having the polling machines having to pay the poll workers. That would also allow us to provide the 60- to 45-day ballot period, which would satisfy the UOCAVA requirements.
2:29:40 Cons to that is that it would obviously delay the resolution of the seats that are open on your council. We have questions which we have not had time yet to research whether or not the candidates would have to refile their paperwork, whether additional candidates would be able to file, how that would change the complexion of the race. That also would increase costs for the candidates because they've
2:30:11 Done all of their campaigning, all of their signs, any mailings that they have done have been geared towards the June 7th primary, and obviously that would have to be replicated. The final option would be to consolidate the election for the town council positions with the general election on November 8th. This option is the easiest.
2:30:35 From the standpoint that there's nothing additional for the poll workers, there's no additional design or printing or programming that's required, it would just be put on the ballot as it would for any other contest. On the other hand, we have the same concerns about what would this do as far as the filing requirements for the candidates, and that drags out the election process even further for both the members of your council that
2:31:02 Are leaving at the end of their terms and for the candidates that are running for office. After discussions, again, between your attorney, Jamie Gray, County Counsel's Office and myself, we feel that the best option would be option number two to go on ahead and print just a single ballot, special ballot that contains only the measure for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Council and run that in parallel with the rest of the June 7th election.
2:31:32 That is contingent upon A, our printer being able to deliver the ballots to us in time, and B, getting approval from the Secretary of State's office. Okay. Questions? Well, and Andy, do you concur that that's...
2:31:51 The best option? Yeah, I do. Jamie and I met with Bob and Stacey and Christy from the County Council's Office. We kicked around all the options. We think this is probably the best. As Bob was initially thinking about this option, there was that problem with UOCAVA with the federal voting statute. We think that we might be able to keep those ballots the same and send out updated instructions, which would...
2:32:11 Avoid the UOCAVA issue while maintaining the same election date, which I think lessens some of the potential for confusion. Although none of these options are perfect, it seems to us that this is the least bad of them. But of course, ultimately, we'd like to hear what the council has to say about all these options. If we were to kind of separate out the two different types of voting, so we have people that are actually coming to vote on the 7th, and then we also have the mail-in, can you
2:32:41 Kind of talk about those different tracks and how that option that we're speaking about, number two, would work for both of those scenarios. I'd like to have Bob explain that. Okay. Okay, well, as I mentioned, we have already sent out vote-by-mail ballots. So what we would do is we would get the ballots from our printer as quickly as we can. We would send out to every registered voter that is...
2:33:05 has received a vote-by-mail ballot and every registered voter that requests one because they can still request them up until May 31st. Anybody that requests or has already received a mail ballot would get the ballot that has just the town council election on it along with a letter of explanation that even though they had already received a ballot, they needed to go on ahead and cast this ballot in order to make their choices for the town council known.
2:33:33 We would have separate ballots, obviously, at the Mammoth High School, which is where we're going to have all of the precinct voting for this election, and the poll workers would explain to the voters when they check in that they need to go on ahead and vote the regular ballot. They can ignore the section of the ballot that deals with the town council election. That ballot would be fed through the machine like it always is. They would vote separately.
2:33:59 The ballot that just has the town council contest on it, and they would return that to a poll worker to be sealed and counted after the election, after the polls close. So the larger concern is probably around the mail side of things rather than...
2:34:12 Which, if I remember correctly, at least in the town of Mammoth is about two-thirds of the voters do the mail-in. Yes. Yeah, that's problematic. So they'd get a second one. I mean, some of them may have already mailed it. You know, we've got people who love to vote and vote early. Yes. So that one, some would already do. And then when I'm, because I prefer to go visit our poll workers, when I walk out, I've got one I'm going to stick in a machine and one I have to hand to somebody else. That is. Which means you have to monitor every single one of the.
2:34:39 Yes. Machines. Yes. Okay. And, Bob, that's all predicated on you being able to get this printed. That is correct. My printer has tentatively told me that he can have them to me by the middle to the end of next week until we absolutely nail down whether or not this is the option that your council prefers and whether or not...
2:35:02 This option is acceptable to the Secretary of State's office. Until we get those issues resolved, I can't get a firm commitment. Are there any liability issues pertaining to people, to Joe's point, that have maybe already voted, gone out of the country? Are they disenfranchised by this? I'm going to defer to counsel on this one. All right. Thank you. Good evening. Stacey Simon, Acting County Counsel for Mono County. So our expectation is that...
2:35:31 We're going to be sending the revised ballot out even to someone who's already voted with the same instruction sheet to send in this new ballot. And because we're already disregarding the improper votes, the ballots that come in with a vote for three, basically the situation facing these individuals is the same as facing every other individual. They will have the second ballot. But that's assuming they're still...
2:35:56 They didn't leave. They didn't leave. You know, because a lot of people go, you know, we have people who vote early because they are vacationing. Right. And so our legal obligation is to send the materials to their last address, to the address that they give us. Someone may, if they've chosen to be out of the area, that would have happened if the materials had been mailed later anyway. Right.
2:36:22 No, what I'm saying is they vote, they know they voted, they don't yet know that there's a problem, and they take their vacation. So there's absolutely a perception problem with that. There's a political problem with that. I don't believe there's a legal problem with that. And then, if I understand, so we can go through this process and go up to the state and then it's all invalid.
2:36:42 Well, we'd be asking the Secretary of State to weigh in on this first thing in the morning tomorrow. We wouldn't conduct the election and then ask whether it's okay. We're hoping to get feedback very, very quickly. Are you sure? Because if the Secretary of State says this isn't going to work because of that federal and state statute, then we're going to have to pursue a different option. I mean, my thought is that we do have a big...
2:37:06 Confusion. Confusion, and I'm confused up here, and I mean, I'm really concerned about the voters and people that, as Joe's mentioned, already voted early and thinking they're going to have to vote again, and then we're not going to have an accurate count. So maybe the question is, do you and Joe want to stay on until November? I think it informs the discussion. Well, I think it's an important thing. I think there's a couple things to be...
2:37:36 Well, I mean, ultimately, I think that
2:38:02 The ultimate decision, I think, lies with the county, truthfully. But I think that the county would like to make the decision about how to run this in consultation with the town. So I think that if the council has a strong opinion about this, I would imagine the county would take that into account. Okay, so the other question is, Bob, you made a couple references. There's sort of a joint liability or cost issue with the town and the county. I wonder if you could clarify that a little bit. That comes into play because for a local election,
2:38:30 Town Clerk is considered the elections official for the town. Now, you, through resolution, I believe it was 1602, requested that the county, and by inference, I, take over the running of the election. Whether the fact that I am handling the election, whether that releases you from liability, I am not a lawyer, I can't respond to that. Okay, so I think it would be helpful for us to maybe, I know this is...
2:38:59 The last-minute thing to have some sense of what our liability is, but also what our financial exposure and liability is. I don't know if that's clear, and I'm wondering if you could maybe, Andy, talk to that. Well, I mean, I have to preface this by saying that neither I nor our county council has had any time to research this at all. In terms of who would get sued, probably both of us, county and the town. In terms of what would happen if we did get sued, if somebody were to prevail, I don't think there are monetary damages.
2:39:26 I think it's more likely that they'd be asking for injunctive relief, essentially asking for a court order ordering that the election be redone. Right. I think that's the most likely outcome if someone were to prevail. And I'm not saying that they would. I think that we have a pretty good argument that we'd be doing it correctly. But I think that's how that would go. So I wanted to, before you get, if you could have a representation as to who's bearing the cost of all this.
2:39:49 That's an interesting question. I mean, yesterday, Chairman Stump indicated that he thought that the county should bear the cost of running a special election if there was one. Nobody has yet discussed who would bear the cost of any litigation. Okay, so I'm just going to, for the purpose of our discussion, if we could assume that in these, if we make a recommendation of one of these five options, that we're going to assume that the burden of paying for this is going to be on the county. Is that fair to say?
2:40:16 I don't think you should make that assumption without getting the county to weigh in on that. Okay. So I'm just – we need to kind of figure that out because if – we don't know what – we're dealing with a very tight little budget. I think it would be very helpful to us. If there's some financial component of this that we have to consider along with these options, I think that would be helpful. And is your question –
2:40:33 Specific to the costs of the, whether it's the special election or the revised ballot? Yeah, exactly. Because there was no financial analysis of any of these five options. And if there's a possibility that we maybe have to pay for some of this stuff, it would be helpful for us to maybe have some idea of what are the costs of these options. And I will defer to the elections official on the county. Because this has come together so quickly, I have not had a chance to do.
2:41:02 A financial analysis on what it would cost to reprint the ballots versus what would it cost to hold a special election versus what it would cost to fold it back into the general election. However, Chairman Stump yesterday indicated that he felt that the county should be responsible for the costs. I tend to agree with him and my recommendation to the Board of Supervisors would be that we not bill the town for any of the costs.
2:41:28 If we have to hold this as a follow-up election, my recommendation will also be that any costs for any ballot reprinting for this election be borne by the county and not by the town. Okay. Thank you for that clarification. Appreciate it. While you're up there, a question on the fourth option of a separate special election sometime late August to early September. When you say that would be all mail, does that mean that they come with prepaid postage?
2:41:56 Or are we then asking all of our citizens to pay to mail them back? The law does not require that the ballots be prepaid, but that is something that I would certainly consider. Because I think that's important. If we do a special election for people who do like to go to the polls, all of a sudden there's an additional cost. I think, again, with that option, though, you're going to have less turnout. Oh, you would.
2:42:20 I don't know. It might be a more contentious race when there's more time. Who knows? But I agree with you. The special elections do have very low turnout. Yeah. And I was just asking the question about the way up. Bob or Stacey, could you answer the question, if there was somebody that decided to go a legal route trying to invalidate whatever option we made here, who would bear the cost of that? I don't think we have an answer to that today. I agree with
2:42:50 What the town attorney has said in terms of what's likely to occur, but I cannot commit on behalf of my board that they would bear the town's cost if a challenge were brought against both parties. Again, it is a municipal election which is being run by the county per the request of the town.
2:43:15 For what it's worth, if there were to be a legal challenge, this would not be like a CEQA challenge where there's a huge effort involved and huge expense involved in preparing the record and in taking depositions. This, I think, would be a relatively self-contained piece of litigation. I think that the legal expenses involved would be relatively small. I mean, relative is kind of important. Can you give me the definition of relative? No. Oh, no, no, no. We've heard this before. It's difficult to estimate.
2:43:44 But my sense is that if we had to bear all of our own expenses and the county bore all of their own expenses, I think it would cost us less than $50,000. That's just an estimate. Which, if I remember, is about a cost of the special election on Measure C, $50,000. Right. So, Mr. Mayor, if I could, I would recommend that we consider pursuing option number two as
2:44:05 Put forward here this evening. I would also maybe if we could put a little bit of number three in there so that there is an outreach, a concerted outreach campaign that advises people what's happening. And I think that if we could, you know, if there's consensus this council to do that, you guys pursue that, see what comes out of that. If we need to have further action, we could have a special meeting or something like that to see what we need to do. But those would be my thoughts. I'm actually not supportive of that for my reasons that I mentioned.
2:44:32 And if there is consensus, then that's fine. I'm not sure if I hear that. But I think that we should have continued dialogue on the other options available unless there is consensus on John's recommendation. For what it's worth, it appears that in the event that you decide to hold a special election, whether it's November or sometime in August, it appears that the two outgoing council members would hold office until that election had concluded and your successors have been sworn in. Okay.
2:45:03 Joe? Well, okay, my trip out of the hemisphere isn't until November. There you go. So that's option four, essentially. That's, no, option, no, no, four or five, we would carry on. Right, I understand that five would be the longest delay until November. If we wanted to hold a separate special election, that would be number four. Okay. I mean, I'm inclined to support just for
2:45:28 Just for the candidate's sake and just for clarity is option five and add it to November. I just think that one through four is very confusing and I don't think we're going to give our candidates a fair shake. I don't see any silver lining to any one through four. And I'm so concerned with the confusion that we would have.
2:45:54 I presume if we picked one of one, two, or three, and there was any kind of a litigation coming out of that, at that point, doing a special election, would that get you out of the litigation? Presumably, because, again, I think that if someone were to sue us, they'd be asking a judge to order that the town do a special election. That's to my point.
2:46:20 Of adding it to the November 8th election. So, you know, I certainly do not pretend to be an expert on this. I mean, this is a difficult issue to work through. I kind of went through and wrote down all five and kind of crossed off the items that I think are least desirable. I crossed off item three. Definitely. Because I think that will create a lot of confusion. People might just throw that letter out. I also crossed off item five.
2:46:49 I think delaying the candidates until November is unreasonable. I think having the existing council seats stay until that time frame is also unreasonable. I know we have no clear determination at this point, but it sounds like the indication is given or if we do have to have a special election that that cost would not be on the town. So I'm kind of in between options two and four.
2:47:18 I don't think one works particularly well either. So, you know, for me, uncharted territory, but I'm sitting between items two and four personally at this point. If I'm able to correct me, you're having a lot of dialogue and working toward a consensus. You may want to have public comment before you complete your whole dialogue. Yeah, we're just trying to get now. Yeah, I appreciate the conversation. I'll actually go to the public now and then we'll come back and have further discussion.
2:47:44 Hi, my name is Kathy Cage. I'm a vote-by-mail voter routinely in elections and local Mammoth voter. So I have a question for Bob, if I can direct it that way. I don't know how prescribed the front of those mail-in ballots are, but if you could...
2:48:01 I tend to like option two, and as a mail-in voter, if you could do something or attach a separate sheet on the front of that that has a lot of color, very few words, something that indicates that this is really a second and different one and the one that counts, that would really help the confusion issue, I think. But if something comes in that looks very similar to the other one with just a few words changed on it,
2:48:26 I might not know the difference, and I might think, hey, I already voted, so this is just a second mailing, and I'm going to ignore that. So that's my only input, but as a local voter, I kind of like option two with some other, you know, lights and bells on the front of the mail-in thing that indicates that it's different. Thank you. Thank you. And if I could just make the request to see Cleland coming up, I know we have a couple of our candidates I'd like to hear from our candidates. Yeah. I think they're coming up. Good. Parade up.
2:48:54 Hi, everybody. I am Cleland Hoff, and I am running for town council. I happen to like option two, just putting it out there. November, if you were planning on doing that, and maybe this is an Andy question, but would that mean that we would have to pull our papers again, get signatures, and then would there be the option of other people joining the race if that happens in November?
2:49:24 It's a fair question, Cleland, and to be completely honest, I don't know the answers at this point. It's something that I think both the county and I are going to have to be looking at in short order, and I will have those answers, but I don't have them today. Okay, now that's awesome, but then I did hear you say something about how that you need to know if the printer can get them printed and also from Secretary of State. So this happens to be something I'm pretty concerned with. So how fast are you guys going to hop on this tomorrow morning?
2:49:58 I will be on the phone with the Secretary of State's office at 8 o'clock tomorrow morning. I actually am scheduled to be down here tomorrow doing poll worker training later in the morning, so this is something I'm not going to wait on. I'm going to be on it the very first thing. And just as long as I'm here, just to Councilmember Wentworth's question, regardless of what option we go with, we will be sending out letters to every voter in the town of Mammoth Lakes letting them know.
2:50:24 What happened? Apologizing and letting them know what actions we're taking to correct this. I appreciate that. I think it's kind of along the lines of what Kathy was talking about. I think we want to make sure that whatever the council chooses to do, to make sure that our communication to the public is simple and direct and they're not getting three or four or five different pieces of mail. It's going to be very straightforward. Just clarifications, council suggestion. It's county's decision. Yeah, I'm just responding to what he was saying. Yes. Sorry.
2:50:57 I did want to thank you for taking the heat for that one and owning up to it, by the way. Another question I have, so as soon as that's done, how are you going to let us know? I mean, this is just coming up to me now. Hold on, I'm going to let someone else ask a question and then I'm going to come back to see if they ask the same question. Okay.
2:51:27 You know what? This is kind of rude, but just out of curiosity, when does your strategic planning era end, the 18 months out that you've got the meetings? Doesn't that end about that same time? It goes until 2017, the end of 2017. It's six quarters. Okay, six more quarters? Okay, thanks. Jennifer Burroughs, Town Council candidate.
2:51:56 I'm opposed to a special election. I don't want the county or the town to spend $50,000 on an air. I prefer not to wait until November. Running a campaign is stressful, and I'd like to get back to my life. I'm in favor of option two. I'd like to get this done as soon as possible. Thank you. Bill Sauser, council candidate, you said you wanted to hear. Anything we can do that would end this in June?
2:52:34 And not carry it on, as you're all aware, the emotional toll this takes running on a family and friends and the entire community for that matter. Anything we can do to reasonably end this without skewing what the possible results were in the normal time by June 7th is where I would place my opinion at this point. That's a vote for number two. If that's the...
2:53:01 Consensus for the professionals involved that that's the cleanest way to do it, that would be a vote for number two. I agree with John. We need to do the outreach so the voter understand what's going on. You need to do that regardless which, whether it's legally obligated or not. Whatever we do, we need to do a huge outreach so the voter understands it. But this is going to confuse them and this could cause changes in a lot of things. Besides, I don't want to take the stupid signs I had to put up down and put them back up again. Come on.
2:53:32 Thanks, Bill. Anybody else? Sandy Hogan. Just one practical suggestion, perhaps, if you do go with number two, and it would be maybe a, I don't know, Bob, maybe a hand correction on the official ballot where you would X out the, in other words, the one that's on there already, so you don't, I assume you're not going to reprint that one, but maybe it's just a hand correction, but if you have to X it out so that nobody
2:54:05 Can do that. In other words, can vote for three. That would just be an easy fix. Thank you. Steve Searles. I know somebody who voted last night and is leaving town and won't be here, so I'm sure there's other examples. I don't think it's just hypothetical. And we all know of an election that was won or lost, depending on where you were, by six votes. So I feel sorry for the decision you...
2:54:43 I don't know if you're really making a decision, but if it's that close, maybe there is a combination, not just straight two, but a combination of what we can do. Thanks, Steve. Anybody else? Okay, I'll bring it back to Council for further discussion. You know, I'm just, I hear what folks are saying on number two. I'm just really concerned, and I think Steve just brought up a very good point. I think this is really confusing, and I think that
2:55:13 I'm just concerned with some potential liability. I know November's far away where it seems like it's eternity, but it has the less, the least, I should say, liability, probably a better turnout, less cost, so forth and so on, and that's why I support that. And I'm also inclined to support number four, but I'm really concerned again about the mail, mail only.
2:55:43 It really concerns me. So that's just my two thoughts. Actually, I concur with Colin's viewpoint. I like number two and number four. But I don't think we have enough information. No, we don't. And, you know, we don't know whether the ballots can be done quick enough and the information put out to the public. I, too, share your concern about those people that will be disenfranchised by
2:56:12 Having already mailed in their vote and being out of country. So that's a real problem. Special election, I mean, it does cost money. It's here before November. So August, you're talking maybe two more months. So that would be an option too. And I'm wondering if maybe, because we're dealing with a lot of
2:56:41 A lot of gaps. A lot of guesswork, yeah. But I think if we could provide some direction to staff at this point with the understanding that we need to hear back from staff in meaningful ways. And then if you need us to meet again or do something, we can do it. But to give you some direction now, have that phone call at 8 o'clock in the morning and let's see where we're at.
2:57:05 Bring it back to us in a way that we can officially weigh in with the information that we need to make a decision. The only further suggestion I would make is that we, I want to be careful how I say this, but I do put a little bit of extra weight potentially on the opinion of our existing candidates.
2:57:24 So, you know, I heard pretty emphatically from that group where their preference resides. I just want to make sure that that, if that's not ultimately the decision, I understand that, but I want to put some extra consideration to the candidates that are going through that right now. I think waiting till November seems, you know, unreasonable to me. From my perspective, if two could be worked out to the point where
2:57:50 We can be 99 and 44 100% sure that there's no confusion and there's no disenfranchisement. I think it's preferred. If that's not going to work, I think it's got to be a special election. I would agree with that. Number four. I would agree with that.
2:58:05 There's no way, no reason to take, you know, you're really talking about a total of about 1,200 voters. So doing a special election and getting that word out, if it was a special election, I would say it's got to be prepaid because we have some of our senior citizens who not only do they love to go to the poll, but they go, you know, that stamp or two stamps or whatever it is might be something that would disenfranchise them.
2:58:34 Yeah. But I think we have, you know, with so much out there about potential voter fraud, I don't want us to get in a position where we start getting compared to some of the things that have happened in other states. And I think we have to give some credit to our voters that are going to be able to discern some of this stuff if done correctly. I mean, I would absolutely have some concerns if we're just, you know,
2:59:00 Resending the same thing or something like that. But if there's a secondary ballot that goes out with clear instructions and a big red flag, I'm hopeful that the vast majority of people are going to be able to – I know there's going to be some confusion. There's no perfect way to do it, but I'm hopeful that the vast majority of people would comprehend that. Bob, when do you need to know so you can pull the trigger on number two as an example? If that's the direction your board – that your council chooses to go, I need to know that tonight.
2:59:29 Unfortunately, given the time frame that we're looking at, the election is less than three weeks away. May 31st is the absolute last day that I can legally mail out vote-by-mail ballots. I have to get them from my printer. I have to process them, stuff them, send them out. If we're going to go with option two, I have to get the ball rolling tomorrow morning.
2:59:53 And I think there's another thing is knowing how the Postal Service treats us here is then they still have to get to people and they have to get back. Yeah. So I don't know what kind of action, if you need a motion or just a motion. I think it's consensus, but I don't know if there's still consensus. Okay. Well, again, I'll propose that I'm hearing a sense of start with two.
3:00:18 And if let's see what you run that up the flag and you guys have some work to do, but then do your due diligence, come back to us and we can have add some questions to our consensus. We need to know about this, this and this. I think so. So you're essentially in some way.
3:00:37 Andy will get the right one, but holding this item over for a final decision until we have those answers? Well, I think what Bob is saying is that he needs an answer if you want to pursue two. So does that mean we're meeting at 8.30 tomorrow morning? Well, yeah, that's what I was going to say. This is a procedural thing. Except that we usually need 24 hours to call a special meeting. One approach could be that you direct us to pursue option two if it proves to be feasible, and if it doesn't, to come back to you as soon as we can call a special meeting for further discussion.
3:01:05 That sounds reasonable to me. Then can I add a couple of things to option two? Sure. Is that in consideration, since this is...
3:01:12 I'm just guessing 1,200 ballots because we're talking only about the people that are in the town of Mammoth. Maybe it's 2,000. That we also, you also look at the option of having that be prepaid postage and that at the polling places you make sure that there's adequate staff. I realize we have one polling place now instead of two, but there's adequate staff to have somebody there at each machine. There absolutely, if we go with option two, there absolutely will be adequate staff there.
3:01:42 I will evaluate what we have, and if I determine that we need to bring in more people, I will bring in more people. As far as making the return envelopes prepaid, I'm not prepared to commit to that tonight, but I am prepared to commit that I will definitely consider it and give it strong consideration. You make some very valid points.
3:02:02 Now, Bob, you said you had to get in touch with the Secretary of State tomorrow? That's correct. The Secretary of State's office is the liaison between the Federal Department of Justice and the various county registrars. And they're going to give you the information you need by? I'm expecting that they will give me the information I need on the phone tomorrow morning. All right. Can, okay. We're putting a lot of faith in the Secretary of State really quickly. Yeah, I get it. You know, I'm saying I don't think we can.
3:02:31 I don't think we can choose an option without more information. Yeah, we can't. Unless we have... Well, but we can make a recommendation, please pursue two with your phone call. Do that. And if that's not going to work out, it comes back to us. Other options. Exactly. It comes back for other options. If that means 24 hours notice, we're probably into a special election.
3:02:54 So that's what we would do anyway. So really the only time-sensitive one is option two, right? Correct. Yes. So let's pursue it, and if it's not going to fly, let us know. We'll call a special meeting, and then we'll figure out what we can do with it. Okay. Now, wait a minute. Knowing that we still have some liability for anybody who's already voted and doesn't have an opportunity to cast that second ballot.
3:03:14 Exactly. We have to put that. Yes. You know, that's a concern. Well, that's something that we're going to defer. It has to be part of it. Yeah. So if we're, I'm going to sum up if I'm hearing correctly here would be look at trying to get the election on June 7th, going through the process, which is option two. Should that prove for some reason it can't be done, now, then you're basically saying you want a meeting on Friday morning or Thursday night. Sure. To get it, well.
3:03:41 Friday morning probably would be the earliest that we could hold the meeting to tell you, no, you can't. But the decision is pretty much if we can't do option two, you want to look at the special election. I'm not sure we need to come back and say, do you want us to go do a special election? I guess I'm asking how much value is that additional meeting with the council if we're saying we can't do the...
3:04:02 June 7th election. Well, I think we need to be communicating. No, we can get information out to you, but I know getting a meeting with everybody here is going to be difficult. I think one or two. Okay, let's put it this way. If option two doesn't work out, I think there's consensus that we go to the special election. Item four, right? Option four, yeah. We will get information out to you and let you know what happens as soon as we know. So we'll be, you know, hey, here's what the information we got back and we can put that out.
3:04:30 Getting a special meeting. I know at least one or two of you are gone on Friday, so now you're waiting until... Well, there is an estimate, and we could always meet right before that. I don't know. Are you out of town? I'll be at the candidate forum tomorrow night. I can meet after that. Yeah. And I could meet after I finish teaching tomorrow. But, you know, I think that nobody seems to have much interest in one or three. No.
3:04:51 And the question on the backup is four or five. I feel much stronger about not waiting until November. I agree. So, you know, I would. Consensus would be a special election number four if two doesn't go through. Yeah. Right. I'm not supportive of two, but I am supportive of looking at four. But if there's consensus, then. Well, and I hope that the answer is going to come back to give us that reasonable certainty that we're not disenfranchising. Right. Mailing people who've already mailed.
3:05:21 Yeah, well, right. Yeah, that was, you know, that was the comment I made yesterday is I don't want to see that we're ending up with ballots that are invalidated. You don't want to get the phone call. So do you want to have any further discussion of option four or do you guys just want, is there consensus just to move on now? Well, no, I would think, well, it's difficult because, you know, and it's not, you know, we're depending on our town manager and our town attorney and our county council and our
3:05:51 Whichever title you're under at this moment, to get to have a good solution, but I would say that if that solution is not going to happen anymore, and you know that, as soon as you know that, I think that word needs to get out, and especially to the candidates, as well as the entire community, on which way it ends up going. Yeah, I mean, again, I'm just concerned of a fair shape for the candidates, an option too.
3:06:19 Yeah. Okay. Is that direction for you? That direction works for me. As soon as I have some answers, I will be in contact with your staff so that they can get the word to you. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thanks, Bob. Thank you. Okay, we're going to move on to reports from commissions and or departments, please. Thank you, Mayor. Recreation Manager Stuart Brown, Public Information Officer as well. I just have some public information for the good of the community this evening. Town Cleanup Day, it's a big, big undertaking.
3:07:00 Election, but we have many organizations contributing to Town Cleanup Day, which is Saturday, May 21st. Just want to run through those really quickly. Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Disposal. We have U.S. Forest Service, Marner County, Mammoth Mountain Resorts, sorry, Mammoth Resorts, Fire Department, Chamber of Commerce, Mammoth Times, and the Sheet. So all the information we have on the back of the...
3:07:26 Suite Z right here. It's always in the papers, as you know if you've seen it. We have essentially three town cleanup day stations this year. One is Sierra Valley Sites, 407 Manzanita. One is at the Community Center. That's 1,000 Forest Trail. And the other one is the Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station at 59 Commerce Drive. All the flyers and the information and everything in the newspaper has what you can take to those stations as well. So I encourage everybody to grab a bag and contribute to
3:07:54 beautifying our town. Stuart, before you leave that, can you just verbally state the hours? Yes. Thank you. Yep. It's going to be from 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. So 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. at those town cleanup day stations. At the transfer station, it does stay open longer for those items, but they do really encourage everybody to bring them in. There's also an e-waste section hosted by Disabled Sports East in Sierra.
3:08:17 Adjacent to the transfer station as well. So if you have e-waste, you can take them down there as well. And you can also receive, get, and be directed to areas where Town Cleanup Day would really help in our community at Mammoth Creek Park from 8 to noon. Sorry? E-waste, electronic waste. Yeah, you're welcome. That cube TV that you've still got, John. Yeah, I don't think they're really quite cute. I think they're just, you know, bricks.
3:08:49 Anyway, so again in the flower, it does talk about metal objects, hazardous household waste items, food waste, yard waste, tree limbs, and so forth. So it's our largest community event, so we really encourage everyone opening this as well. So they're both open. That's all I have. Quick question for you, Stuart. Yes. The nature of the trees, what's the problem? I don't remember a big wind event this winter. What's the problem with the trees? I think the Forest Service has just tagged many trees that they feel are dangerous to.
3:09:18 Area in the community and bringing those down. And do you know generally where they are? Are they by the pack station? Just below the pack station. That's the heaviest area right now. Yeah, that was a thinning thing. I think they started in the fall. Yeah, I was up there yesterday. I mean, there's not a lot. Right. But I guess there is some electrical wires with some trees coming down. Right. I don't know if we can be of any assistance, but we've got to try to get this thing open as soon as possible. Yeah. Thank you.
3:09:49 Welcome. Good evening, council members, Mr. Mayor, thank you. I just want to give a brief update on Mammoth Lakes Trail System activities in the upcoming season. First, I'd like to be happy to report that we'll be beginning soft surface trail maintenance on trails within the municipal boundary of Mammoth Lakes on Monday and should go through November or first snow. Also, I'm very pleased to announce
3:10:24 On National Trails Day, June 4th, we'll be having our first Summer of Stewardship Trail Day, Volunteer Day. We plan to meet up at the Panorama Dome Area Trailhead, and another project we'll be tying right into that day is a soft surface wayfinding sign replacement program. So we have planned to replace...
3:10:50 All of the soft surface wayfinding signs with beautiful oak standard National Forest Service directional signage. And on National Trails Day, we'll be replacing all of the signs within the Panorama Dome pod of trails. August 13th, we'll have our second Summer of Stewardship Trail Day. Save the date. And then September 17th will be the third Summer of Stewardship Trail Day.
3:11:18 And that will be the Lakes Basin cleanup synchronizing with the Great Sierra River cleanup event, the statewide event. Also, we look forward to sort of hitting the restart button on the environmental assessment effort for the sharp area with a first phase of trails. We hope to begin construction next season on some trail segments based on that environmental assessment outcome.
3:11:53 I think that's it. And if we need help with tree removal, I will have a crew Monday, and they have chainsaws. Great. Okay, we're not in the wilderness. Divert crews if needed. Thank you, Joel. Joel, I have a question. When you were talking about some signs that were going to be replaced, are those some of the, shall we call them ersatz old signs? They're not some of our new beautiful wayfinding signs, are they?
3:12:19 Well, they're wood, so these are not your metal signs. Okay, it's the really old, falling off of the trees, and pointing the wrong way. Okay. They're not a part of the metal sign program. Yeah. Okay. Just wanted to clarify that. You bet. I'd like to clarify, they are standardized U.S. Forest Service signs, and so they're nice and clean and professionally routed. Great. And Joel, are we to assume that the challenge cost share agreement was reached then?
3:12:49 It has not been signed. It is in the Grants and Agreements Office as we speak. We have a very enthusiastic ranger and staff on board with this maintenance program. We have the crew that is coming Monday is a Cal Fire crew. And today, the Forest Service could give them a call and have them do work. There's an existing agreement with Cal Fire.
3:13:14 Likewise, we have a master challenge cost share agreement with them, the town and the district to work from. And so the ranger is comfortable with us proceeding on Monday. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Two items for you, just to let the council know that staff held a meeting with the Board of Realtors and the Contractors Association.
3:13:43 To take comments and discuss lofts, lofts within town that range from being fully compliant with the building code to lofts that are hazardous. So our building official is working on that issue and is going to bring back some items for the council to consider. Likely we will bring those forward with some minor cleanup to the quality of life ordinance. So we'll package that all together. It'll probably be later in the summer because this is a big issue for
3:14:13 The building official to take on and to provide some recommendations for the council. Another item is that the...
3:14:23 Planning and Economic Development Commission held a meeting last Wednesday, May 11th. They took a number of actions. One of the actions was to deny an appeal from Dee English regarding her property, so that affirms the Community and Economic Development Manager's decision to deny her interpretation request regarding residential on the ground floor of her building on Main Street. Another item they did was they approved a Hillside Highlands project, which is three three-unit apartments.
3:14:52 On three adjacent parcels in the North Village specific plan area, right next to Magnolia Lodge, right behind the village. And then they approved a final parcel map for a project, and they also took a tour of some different master plan areas, specific plan areas. And that's all I have. Thank you. Question? I know that kind of the most substantial issue with the quality of life ordinance is the loft stuff. Is there a lot of other significant issues you're hearing?
3:15:18 Just minor stuff. Just minor cleanup stuff, clarifications. I think there have been some questions on it. So we have kind of a list of items, and what we'll do is try to come up with something in the lofts, go back to the Board of Realtors, Lodging Association, the contractors, and just...
3:15:33 See if there's any additional items they have. So that was the plan. And those are the three major entities that have commented on the loft issue? Mostly the, yeah, the Board of Realtors has had a lot of comments, the Lodging Association, and then the contractors have had some as well, yeah. Okay, thanks. Sandra, I know you gave me some information on the deer fence around the pond in Snow Creek, but now, of course, then comes back the question, well, how soon will that be?
3:15:57 I think we're working with the applicant on timing, but it is a relatively quick process. We're hoping to get that fence up quickly. They have received communications from Fish and Wildlife Service, so there is other agencies are looking at as well. At this point, we're looking at likely a six-foot-high fence with two feet of...
3:16:19 Cored around the top just so the deer can't clear it. That's the requirement from Fish and Wildlife. So we're working with the applicant on trying to get that up as soon as possible. Sandra, real quick, on the applicant for the hillside project you just mentioned, is there a time frame on them starting that project? Because I know they were originally going to start it this summer. I think they want to start quickly. Okay. Just because we have a bunch of illegal parking going on in there. Yeah, so that will go away. Right. Okay, great. Thank you. Quick question.
3:16:48 Do you, is, are you or someone from the commission going to be at the alignment session on Friday? Do you know? I have to attend the ethics training on Friday, and I'm not sure we can see if someone from the commission. If you just encourage someone from the commission to come. I think also we've, I think it's, we've talked about having a joint mission, sorry, a joint meeting with the commission based on the alignment things that have been put together by the council. I'm just hoping that that's on everybody's radar and that we have a good productive workshop on those things. Yeah, I think we adopt it first and then.
3:17:17 Yeah. We need to have that meeting. Great. Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works. Just one quick item related to Old Mammoth Road paving. When the council awarded that project a few weeks ago, the commitment from engineering staff was that we would not do any work that would encumber anything in late June or through the middle of the summer. The contractor provided a schedule about 10 days ago that showed they'd be complete by June 10th.
3:17:46 They got word on Friday from the asphalt supplier that they couldn't provide the asphalt until June 20th. Based on that, what we're going to do is release the contractor to go ahead and do the pedestrian ramps now, get them done, frankly, in the next two to three weeks. I think there's 13 or 17 of them for not remembering the number. They'll complete that work.
3:18:06 By the middle of June at the very latest. Then we're going to put off the paving and we'll do it right after Labor Day. Again, that was the commitment before. We are not going to mess with the summer. So the contract will be out there after labor doing the actual paving. In the meantime, our road crews will take another look at the road, do what we can to clean it up, restripe it so we're in good shape for the summer. Great. Any questions for Grady? Thank you. Thanks.
3:18:30 Okay, we're going to move on to public presentations, item two, presentations of new Mammoth Lakes Tourism website and presentation regarding the MLT budget. John? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. You're fortunate enough to have a doubleheader with us tonight. We're going to have a conversation on the new visitmammoth.com website, and then we'll do a brief presentation on our 2016-17 budgets. So, with that, I would like to introduce Christy Osborne. Christy?
3:18:58 Recently left us after four and a half years. I want to thank her for her time with us. Christy, if you don't know, this is past her bedtime. She gets up at about three o'clock in the morning to work on her other passion, which is Mountainside Bride, which is her wedding blog, and has turned that into a very good career. So she's unfortunately left us, but she's here to walk us through the website. So let me bring that up and we'll get going. Mr. Mayor, council members, thanks for having me tonight. So I have a very...
3:19:47 Short PowerPoint presentation, and the purpose of that is to bring you through some of our ideas about the website, what we wanted the website to do for our community, for our businesses, for our nonprofits, and for our events, show a bit of a side-by-side comparison, and then give you an update on our key performance indicators in month one, and then we'll go to looking at the live site.
3:20:15 The goals of the new Visit Mammoth website was first and foremost to inspire. There's five phases in a travel cycle for our visitors. The first is inspiration. I want to go somewhere. Where do I want to go? The second is active evaluation where you think you want to go to Mammoth Lakes but you want to find out more about the destination before you make that choice. The third is actually booking. I've made the choice. And then the fourth is
3:20:43 They're here enjoying the place. And then the fifth is they're sharing on social media or with their families and whatnot. The visitmammoth.com website really focuses on the first two phases. So that's inspiring people and getting them to start planning their trip. And then a secondary goal for us was to actually drive traffic to local businesses and have some opportunities for people to book online.
3:21:12 But with the emphasis on inspiration and trip planning, we really wanted to emphasize large format photography. Like you walk out into the parking lot and look at the surrounding mountains and it's extraordinary for us every day. So we wanted to bring that to life in pictures on the new website. We also wanted to layer content that was inspirational and keep people on the site.
3:21:34 The longer people stay on the site, the more they're interested in this as a destination, and the more we know that they're seriously planning on coming here. We also wanted to promote year-round events. We want to showcase Mammoth Lakes as a year-round destination, not just as a winter resort with Mammoth Mountain. So how do we measure success on a website?
3:22:00 So we have a couple KPIs. KPIs are key performance indicators, and that is how we know we're doing well on the website. And our key performance indicators for an inspirational website are time on site, right? The more time they spend on the site, the more intent they have to travel here. We wanted to increase the number of page views. The more pages they're looking at, the more serious they are about planning their trip, but then we also know that we're giving them the information that they need.
3:22:29 And then we wanted to lower the overall bounce rate. And bounce rate online, very quickly, is when you're searching for something on Google and a whole list of results come up and you think that the first one or the second one looks good and you click on it and it has none of the information that you wanted. So what do you do? You hit the back button.
3:22:50 And that's called a bounce. So a bounce rate basically says that people hit our site and they didn't want what we were offering. So to lower that bounce rate means that we're attracting the people who want to be there and we're inspiring them. Okay, really quickly, a little side-by-side comparison of the old site and the new site.
3:23:09 The new site emphasizes really big format photography. So every single landing page, every single article, every single blog post has a big hero image that displays something about the destination. On the homepage, we also wanted to have dynamic content, and that's our blog. These blog posts are updated frequently, and they encourage people to come back, even to the homepage, to look and see what's new.
3:23:36 We've gotten rid of a lot of the textual clutter, and we've cleaned up the site significantly. The site is also mobile responsive, so anybody can access it on any kind of device.
3:23:49 For our activities, our summer, winter activities, we have gone to, again, a large landing page format. We start with a huge hero image. And what we've done is we've cleaned up this site. You see a lot of text on the old site, including a sidebar navigation. And on the new site, we have a navigation that goes full bleed across the website. And it is also...
3:24:14 Pictures, right? So if you roll over these little tabs, the picture changes. And these are our core pillars. These are our core activities. Sightseeing, biking, fishing, hiking, snowshoeing, cross-country skiing, snowmobiling, and of course, alpine skiing and snowboarding. We also wanted to take an opportunity to highlight businesses and try to drive traffic to the businesses so that the
3:24:44 They could book the people, right? We know that the modern World Wide Web is visual, right? We have things like Pinterest. Facebook's gone to a more visual look. Twitter's gone to a more visual look. And so in keeping with these modern Internet trends, we're offering more visual opportunities for businesses to tell their stories.
3:25:14 One thing that we've really struggled with as a community is that in the middle of February, when it's dumping, we have got to get the message out about the fact that it's dumping and that there's snow on the ground and that we want people to come here and ski. But over the past four and a half years of looking at our Google Analytics, I've noticed something particular that happens in February, and that is I see a spike in search queries for phishing.
3:25:43 And camping. And mountain biking. So I had a problem with this website. I was...
3:25:50 Sending all of these messages about snow and it's dumping and it's dumping, but more people were coming to my site looking for summer activities. So how do we solve this? Well, on the new website we solved this with what's called dynamic content. And now on the homepage, depending on how you're getting to the site, where you are, what you're looking for, what you have looked at, we will deliver content that you're looking for. So right now it's geo-targeted. So if you're in market,
3:26:20 Thank you. Thank you.
3:26:39 If you are in Europe, I'm going to talk about a California message because people in Europe are looking for a California experience, not just a Mammoth Lakes experience. In Phase 2, we'll start to roll out more specific dynamic content that deals with search terms. So if you're searching for fishing in February, we will deliver you content on the homepage that gives you fishing information in February. Does that make sense?
3:27:10 So in the first month, in terms of being able to inspire and engage visitors, we've increased our time on site by 97% year over year. I thought that was a mistake. I've never actually seen a number like that for a time on site increase. And the way that we're doing that, and you'll see when I do the live review of the website, is we are layering content.
3:27:34 It's kind of like how when you're on Amazon and you're looking at a book and then they say, you might also like, and there's like five other books that you really would also like and all of a sudden you have like $120 in your cart. We've tried to do that with the visitmammoth.com website as well. So we've done it with articles, we've done it with events, we've done it with a variety of information and it's worked.
3:27:57 Because our time on site is up this much. This is also important because Google looks at these engagement metrics on websites
3:28:07 So if Google sees people bouncing out of our site all the time or just looking at one or two pages and then leaving, it will rank us lower for certain things. But if Google sees that visitors are actually engaged in the site, looking at multiple pages, spending minutes on the site, then our ability to rank in search goes up. So these are some really important metrics.
3:28:34 Number of page views has increased 36% year over year, which is another strong number, and our overall bounce rate is down 21%. Organic traffic is up 3%, and although these were not in our KPIs, some other wins that we've had are our email newsletter sign-ups are up 25%. These are people raising their hand and asking, please send us more information regularly.
3:29:00 And we've had 404 visitor guide sign-ups. We are now averaging 200 guides a week up from 25. So some pretty significant wins. Okay, so...
3:29:23 Here's the live site. And you can see right off the bat, because we're in town, we're in market, the message is getting hungry, you've come to the right place, find restaurants. And if you click on this, it brings you right to the restaurants page. I encourage you to play with this website because this will load differently each time. We have a number of different messages loading on the home page, including event messaging. No two fingers scroll. So now we start talking about, oh no.
3:29:59 So this is kind of fun. Because the resolution on my PowerPoint, or because the resolution is low on this screen, we're actually seeing a mobile responsive website, which is fine. I can take you through mobile responsive as well.
3:30:22 But I do encourage you to look on the desktop because the content is layered a little bit differently. I will say something about mobile responsive in the development of this website though as well. And that is when we chose the company, Miles, to develop this site, we went with a mobile first company, which means that this website was actually developed and wireframed on mobile devices first. It's much easier to develop small and then expand out than it is to develop.
3:30:49 So the content is layered. We have the blog first where we try to offer a variety of
3:31:05 Interests and things that people would be interested in. The blog is a little bit different from Trip Ideas on the website in that the Trip Ideas are the official Visitor Bureau message. And the blog are actually local writers that we've hired to talk about trips that they had and bike rides that they've gone on and four perfect vistas for landscape photography, trying to tell the fuller story of Mammoth Lakes.
3:31:30 Mostly with recreation, but also some more off the beaten path things that you might want to do. We have some navigation here. Again, if you roll over these different buttons, you'll see that the picture changes. And we wanted to really visually tell the story of Mammoth Lakes as a destination and all of the things that could be done here.
3:31:56 A primary focus of this website is to deliver a year-round message for activities in as many places as we possibly can. And of course, going down the page, you'll see that we actually have sort of a sales funnel or a travel funnel where we go from inspiration to active evaluation, and now we offer some booking information. So you can actually book a trip, you can request the visitor guide, and you can sign up for our email newsletter.
3:32:29 We have some options for advertising, for local community members to advertise, and then on the homepage we have some social media integration. Again, the real push for this website is to tell the story of this destination visually, because this is one of the most beautiful places I've ever been.
3:32:58 I'm not used to windows. We also have some fly outs on the side here. And so when we have snowfall and runs open and we're in the middle of winter, people can easily access that information that they're looking for. And they can also click to explore winter, which will bring them to a landing page that will talk about additional activities, not just the ski area, right? The ski area is definitely where our bread is buttered, but we have so much more to offer.
3:33:28 And this website is about showcasing that. So what we've tried to do to keep people on site and why people are staying on site so long is we try to layer content, right? So you have your basic winter activities here. Again, if you roll over, the picture is going to change. You can really get a sense of what it's like to be in Mammoth Lakes as a destination. And then we also have high quality content such as multiple videos.
3:33:58 Winter trip ideas where we try to talk about the destination as a whole, including winter fishing, snowmobiling, sightseeing in Mammoth Lakes, cross-country skiing on the Mammoth Lakes Nordic System, family snow play, and then down back into the blog. Let's take a look at some of our local businesses. So with the hotels and lodging,
3:34:29 You will find a pattern throughout this entire website. Everything starts with a big hero image. We want to connect with our user emotionally through photography and high impact visuals. So we hook them with the visuals. We generally have some SEO optimized inspirational content at the top. And now with the new hotels listings, people can sort by categories, including campgrounds.
3:34:58 Hotels, condominiums, houses, cabins, and chalets, and they can also sort by amenities. Two bedrooms, one bedroom, airport shuttle, fireplaces. We've really worked hard with Whitney Lennon to figure out how people are planning their trip and implementing filters in this that would aid them in that.
3:35:20 The listings have changed quite a bit. We don't have logos running on the listings anymore because we found that visitors don't connect with logos, so we're running pictures of the different venues and whatnot. And one more thing I want to point out is you see this sort by random order. One of the issues that we heard from our local business owners when we talked to them was that if your name is starting with, say, I don't know, Mammoth,
3:35:52 Like everybody. You can be on page 7 or 8 or 9 or 10 or 11 or 12. And so what we've done is we have the top five listings as priority. And then after that, they sort randomly. So you'll see that the top four listings here, you have the Village Lodge Sierra Park Villas. Now this gets cached.
3:36:16 For a certain period of time. So you can't just hit refresh and see new listings because that would be a user experience nightmare. So if you do refresh it the next day, you'll see different listings. I just want to click over to the restaurants page really quickly.
3:36:36 Because although this is the same type of landing page as the hotels page, I want to point out that this website is very expandable. We have so much opportunity to continue to put content into this and continue to tell a full story of Mammoth Lakes, all of the activities, all of the events, all of the cool things to do. So for example, restaurants, you think, well, restaurants is pretty straightforward. We start with that big format image. We scroll down.
3:37:05 And now we have videos where we highlight food and wine events. We highlight local businesses. We highlight foodie places. People can watch videos. Scroll down a little bit more. And we have events. And this is one of my favorite parts about this website. Before, when you wanted to go to find out what events were in Mammoth Lakes, where did you go? You went to the events page. Or if you wanted to find deals, you went to the deals page and so on and so forth.
3:37:35 With events, though, because they're such an integral part of the experience of Mammoth Lakes, especially in the summertime, we've taken opportunity to layer events throughout the website. So here you see that we have food and wine events on the restaurant page. We've categorized these out, and this displays
3:37:53 Oh, by the way, on June 25th, there's the Swalle Meadows and Paradise Wine, Beer, and Food Fest. And on June 15th, there's the Mammoth Food and Wine Experience. And so you'll find that we do have a master events calendar, and then we've also segmented out events by category, and we put those events on category pages. Biking events, sightseeing events, arts and culture events, food and wine events.
3:38:19 So no longer do visitors have to go all over the website to find what they're looking for. We layer the content in each page. Then, of course, we have our local bloggers talking about some of the best restaurants or their favorite restaurants, cocktails. And then we have our listings. Again, we've expanded out the filters significantly. So you can search by categories, such as bakeries, casual dining, cuisine, American burgers.
3:38:48 Meals served. So if you're looking for lunch right now, you can find lunch and then also the price range. And again, we have priority listings, but everything sorts in a random order at first. If you want to sort by alpha, you just click sort by alpha and it will resort.
3:39:10 So let's take a look at one of these listings. I'm going to pop back to hotels. I'm going to look at the Westin's listing because currently I think the Westin has done a very fine job with their listing and making sure that it's complete and compelling to the visitor. Roll by it.
3:39:35 So a couple things about the Weston's listing is one, they are telling the story of their product and experience visually. So it's not just about the hotel room and the restaurant, but it's also about those activities. We have Google Map integration under the get directions. We're driving traffic to the website and we have rates starting out, which is one of the things that visitors are looking for. Oftentimes they're looking to what kind of price range.
3:40:04 We also have a Book Now button, and the Book Now button has changed a little bit on the listings. What we heard from businesses is they are using a variety of different ways to book, and they wanted to be able to choose for themselves. And so on the back end, businesses can log into their account, access their particular listing, and then choose a booking engine of their choice by popping in a URL. This is also significant because it now means that the Mammoth Repertory Theater can have a Book Now.
3:40:33 All of the amenities that somebody might be looking for are listed. And then here's my favorite part. We have integrated deals, events, and related businesses right into the listing.
3:40:56 So instead of having to go to the deals page to get the deals and go to the events page to get the events and go to someplace else to get something else, we've layered the content in a way that's convenient for the visitor right on the listings page. So with Sean Turner's Mammoth Lakes Brewing Company listing, he can have the Bluza Palooza as a related event and any kind of deals associated with that. And then finally,
3:41:24 One of our goals was to make sure that the website was fully integrated with our businesses and driving traffic to businesses and... That's interesting. It's not you, it's me. Technology, like, loves me or hates me. Can you pull up the site on the phone and make sure that...
3:42:07 I just went into troubleshooting mode to see if it's an internet connection or if my site's down. So if you have my site on the phone, it might be an internet connection. Let's keep trying. Well, since I clicked on events, I'll do events and then we'll go back to adventures and then we'll wrap it up. So events, again, big landing page. One of the issues that we dealt with in Mammoth Lakes Tourism is in our old events page, it was just a list of events.
3:42:43 And we have key events that are coming up that sometimes get buried that we want to have a shout out. So what we've done is we have created an area where we have don't miss annual events that let people know what's coming up, even if they can't see them immediately in the events calendar. Christy, does that change? It looks like it's different than the last time. And how does something get featured up there? Yeah, we're still working on that.
3:43:12 Right now, we want to draw attention to upcoming summer events, but we also, I wanted to have as much opportunity to list anything we wanted in there, so we also might want to have the Night of Lights in there to call out a year-round message. So the choice is ours.
3:43:37 Okay, so we've cleaned up the events calendar quite a bit to make it scannable. We also have the ability to search by start date or by categories. So if you know you want to do a family-friendly event or you want to go to a community event, you can just...
3:43:55 Browse by the events. But like I said, the events page here is our master calendar. And all of our events are listed on this page by category. But the real magic for telling the story about events in Mammoth Lakes happens throughout the website. So if you're on the mountain biking page and you are interested in mountain biking events, the events are right there on the page. You don't have to go to a different page and sort by. And finally, I'm going to...
3:44:30 Yes, it is taking too long to load. Okay. Okay. So I invite you to explore the website. I was going to take you to the adventures page and bring you down through the hiking landing page. And one of the things that we did was we know that people don't just go hiking in general. They go hiking in specific places.
3:45:05 And so, for example, so we wanted to deliver trip ideas such as hiking to Emerald Lake, hiking to Arrowhead Lake, hiking to Inyo Craters. And what we wanted to do is we wanted to create content that was inspirational.
3:45:21 And then drive traffic out to our partners and businesses. So on every single Trip Idea page, you're going to see two things. If it's a recreational page that has complementary content on mammothtrails.org, you're going to see us linking out to that specific page. So if I'm on Emerald Lake for hiking, we inspire them, and then it says, for more information, visit mammothtrails.org.
3:45:48 We link to mammothtrails.org to the internal page, Emerald Lake, so they don't have to find it on mammothtrails.org. The second thing that I'm very excited about is that we wanted to offer visitors an
3:46:02 An opportunity to make sure that they were outfitted with gear, maps, and were connected to any appropriate or related businesses in the community. So on the sidebar, you'll also see things like related businesses or find outfitters and maps for hiking or fishing. And what we're trying to do is we're trying to say, hey, I know you're interested in hiking. If you want more information, here are all of our businesses that you can link to.
3:46:31 Here is some detailed trail information about our trail system. Are you just about ready to wrap it up? Yeah. Okay. And the same is true on the blog. And when you do explore the website, you're also going to see at the bottom of every trip idea and every blog a you may also like, which drives people deeper into the site and delivers that year-round message. Great. Any questions?
3:47:02 I have some comments. I don't know when the appropriate time is to do it. I have one question. What was the bounce rate on the old site? I want to say if I were to take a yearly average, it was generally between 50% and 60%, which is right around where an average website is. Okay. Thanks. We're 21% better. Yes.
3:47:28 John, comments? Yeah, I want to applaud, first off, the effort of Mammoth Lake Tourism and you, Christy, for the efforts, the work that you did to deliver a very beautiful, very excellent 21st century platform. Thank you very much. In the interest of time, I'm going to just make some comments here. Sure. A lot of them are technical in nature. I don't want to get into a big discussion about what these things are. But I want to make sure that these things are noted. The council spent the last eight months
3:47:59 And I think this is a beautiful and very well engineered platform. And I think the next challenge we have to look at, which is a very serious one, is the integration of this platform into all of our efforts.
3:48:21 So that being said, I want to make sure that I'm going to throw out a couple ideas here, make sure they're noted for the record. We can follow up with this later about things that we have to do now for the next stages of integration for these opportunities. The first thing is with regard to the visual information. It's going to be very important going forward that there's a digital asset management strategy that's associated with an intellectual property program for all the digital assets that are being produced with this website.
3:48:49 It needs to be clear who owns these assets, all these photographs, which are right in line with contemporary best practices. The town needs to establish an intellectual property program and establish expectations for the management of these digital assets so it's clear who owns them, how other partners in the town can access these things. So that's one point. Sorry, Shields, do you need some more tea, man? I'll be right back. It's just me talking, so don't worry.
3:49:17 So that's one thing. The second thing is would you characterize the state of the site now as a soft launch or a hard launch at this point? We are moving into hard launch. We soft launched it about a month ago with the community. I do want to say that with this website we migrated 140...
3:49:37 Trip Idea articles, wrote another 75, migrated more than 400 blog posts, 100 videos, and hundreds of photographs. And so we wanted to do a soft launch with the community to make sure that we could noodle any of the content that we needed to before we did a full court press to our consumers. So when do you anticipate is a hard launch date or do you have that in mind at this point yet or no? A couple months or something? I understand.
3:50:08 I understand. I just want to make sure that we're clear that there's a difference between a soft launch and there's some development going on. At some point, there'll be a hard launch down there. I'm not holding it to anything, but that's kind of where the site is at.
3:50:18 Okay, I think also we need to, across all platforms, start working off a standardized set of naming conventions for all destinations, all places, all physical assets. This is very important for those folks who are interested in municipal signage and wayfinding program that we're using the same sets of standardized naming conventions across the board. That's something we need to focus on. I think also that we need to establish an SEO policy because I think it's not,
3:50:48 It doesn't do the community any good if MLT is protecting its rankings and its SEOs at the expense of better integration with other platforms and sites within our team. And I'm thinking about the Trails website, other partner websites, that we can't be building navigation schemes where we're going to be hesitating to link out.
3:51:11 Other partner sites because it might be compromising the SEO, the Google ranking of any one of the partner sites. I think that's a policy we have to look into. I will say that with our SEO policy, the fact that this is a 20-year domain name and the fact that it has some of the most comprehensive and authoritative content on the...
3:51:30 Region, according to Google, when we link to you from Mammoth Lakes, from visitmammoth.com, whether it's the trails website or whether it's one of your businesses, that...
3:51:42 Affects your SEO in very positive ways. So that was one of the considerations we had, our ability to link out to our local businesses and partners as much as we could so they could benefit from our authority in SEO. Sure. And I think this may be over a lot of people's heads at this point, but I just want to think that we need to look at a strategy as a team between all the platforms we're engaged with that we're not. No site is privileging its SEO rankings at the expense of.
3:52:09 Other sites that are part of the larger program. Can I write you for just a second, John? Can you try and see if you can get the Adventurers to load again while he's talking? Because I had some questions there. For sure. Keep going. Keep going. I'll have to get to the budget, so. I understand. And I think one of the concerns that I saw in looking through the site is that I think that we're duplicating a lot of content and we're duplicating a lot of efforts. And I think as we go forward with this site and all the other sites, as we optimize these platforms, we have to really
3:52:38 Be able to say with confidence that we're not duplicating efforts, that the content is not being produced by two or three different parties that are all producing the same stuff. We've got to get efficient about that. And I think that's something we've talked about and something we can do going forward. And to be clear, who owns this site? The domain, I'm assuming, is owned by MLT. But this is your previous site. You were paying...
3:53:04 You were basically renting another, through SimpleView, you were renting another platform or something like that. This is a site that's owned by MLT, I'm assuming? Yes. We had it developed on an open source platform called Drupal. We own all of the code, and it's hosted on Rackspace. Okay, good. Thank you. That's good for the public to know that. And I think that's it for now. I'm not going to go any further, but just, Jamie, make sure we got those things. These are things that we need to follow up as we align and bring everything together. These things we've got to work on.
3:53:33 Well, whichever council is looking at the deliverables on the next contract, that's a place to put those kinds of things in. But since it wasn't there earlier, Christy, can you go to hiking and show me where Emerald Lake has the switch over to Mammoth Trails? Yes. Yes, I can. Or pick anyone. I don't care. Okay, well, Emerald Lake is there. Yeah, so...
3:54:03 Another thing I want to point out is because we use so many local assets, including photographers, and I've worked so closely with John Wentworth with mammothtrails.org, we do give photo credit, and so there's your first link to the website right there. Now that dumps into the homepage and might not be as useful for the visitor, but with this, we have a lot of inspirational content, a lot of, we, in marketing, we use a lot of adjectives to kind of prime the pump.
3:54:34 Before people are going into detail. So we try to do that in our copy here. And then when we click to mammothtrails.org, it will lead us to the Emerald Skelton Lake Trail, which is an internal page, good for your SEO, and then also good for the user. And John, is that what you mean about naming conventions? Yeah. That it's called one thing on the one side and there's something else over here? Exactly. And I think that we really need to work to integrate this stuff. So the naming conventions are standardized so that
3:55:03 Wherever visitors going, it's not called one thing. It's slightly different over here. This is going to get into our wayfinding programs. It gets into being able, when people come up here, they have a sense of security of where they are and what they're doing. I think also that all of the information on the trails website, for example, is blessed by the Forest Service, so it's all authoritative information. And what you talked about before about the relationship of authoritative information versus the kind of promotional stuff that you guys are going to do, we have to find a better way to more tightly.
3:55:33 I mean, this is all part of development process you do with content to more effectively and efficiently integrate these things. And that's going to take some time to do that, but that's the next step we get. And one of the directives of the writers, whether they were blogging, and the bloggers for years have been linking to mammothtrails.org as a directive, primarily because I've just worked so...
3:55:55 closely with mammothtrails.org in my position. But they also were told to use that as an authority site. And so we actually would research based on the mammothtrails.org website first, and then pack it full of the inspirational language. And so we have tried to make sure that the two sites complement each other where we could. Great. Thank you. Any other questions from Council? No. I think we're going to move on to the budget from John.
3:56:29 All right, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you. We're going to walk you through our proposed 2016 budget breakdown. Whitney's just handing out a copy of the slides from this presentation as well. So very quickly, and we can get some questions here. This first slide just gives you a breakdown of where our Measure A dollars are spent and where the TBID dollars are spent. I think most of you know that Measure A dollars are
3:57:12 Coming through the TOT and the TBID dollars are somewhat restricted as they have to present benefit to the people that pay into it. So they're somewhat restricted as to how those dollars are used. So as you can see here, we've broken out the first column, Measure A, tells you what the Measure A expenses are, expected to be $2.4 million for next year.
3:57:34 Our projected revenues based on the $11.6 million budget, as well as business license tax, and then the other incremental dollars that we bring in will be about $2.5. On the TBID side, almost $4.5 million of that will be directly spent on marketing. And then if you look down through, we don't have any salaries, benefits, or overhead in the TBID. They all live in Measure A.
3:57:58 And then the final column with the total budget just gives you the total amount. So we are looking at just over a $7 million budget for next year. This year was just about 6.2. And this is because of the fact that we had a decent season this year, but we also have a couple of other expectations for next year with the TBID. And I'll get into that in a little bit in a slide. John, what would overhead represent? Overhead is copiers, office supplies, legal.
3:58:25 Post-in machine, accounting services. So general operating expenses outside of salary and benefit. Exactly. Pretty much our business operating. John, did you say the Measure A column also includes the business license? The revenue does, yes. The revenue. Okay. Correct. And does it also include anything you get, promotional types, you know, outside revenue? Yes. So it's not just Measure A. It's everything except TBID.
3:58:50 Correct. Yeah, so all the visitor guide advertising, website advertising, brochure distribution money, all those different pieces of revenue in there. So I think the TOT for next year is 2.1. There's about $235,000 in business license, but we end up giving back the $215,000 every year, so that's actually factored in as well. All right. Okay. So as you can see on the percentage side, we do spend...
3:59:16 77% of our budget goes directly towards our marketing efforts. And that's everything from the design of things to the placement of ads. So research, all the different pieces that are tied into marketing are in that category, as well as the air subsidy does fit into that category as well. On the salary side, we are at between the salary and benefits, we're just under 11%. You'll see that on the next slide. Industry average is typically 25% to 30%.
3:59:43 We have been able to keep that low because we do have quite a bit of funds from the TBID that keep that as a low number. We don't feel that we're overly heavy on staff, but we do have what we need to operate as well as we work with a number of agencies outside as well. Would you have a question? So if you look at the graphical breakdown of this is the total, you can see again 77% of our budget is spent on marketing, and then the others are broken down there. What we'll do is we'll break down into marketing specifically.
4:00:18 As you can see on the right-hand side, their air subsidy is $2,275,000 that summer and winter, and that's both Measure A and TBID dollars. TBID is responsible for about $2 million of that, and then the Measure A comes in at about $215,000 plus. And then on the campaign side, that's all of our marketing expenses with our agency, all of our placement dollars, our banner advertising, all of those different pieces of the puzzle.
4:00:48 There are a number of other categories in here. Trade shows, production of collateral, or excuse me, production for our advertising, the collateral that we put out, the visitor guides, all the event posters, et cetera. Content creation is a big one. You've seen our ads. They're not things that we do in-house. That's something that we work with our agency on.
4:01:09 And then on the research side, it's also a fair amount with our awareness studies, our ROI studies, air quantitative studies, all of those different pieces that give us the data that tell us that either what we're doing has been effective or that we need to tweak it. And feel free to ask questions as we go through these, or you can say them to the end, whatever works. Thank you, because when we get to the next one, I was going to ask that question.
4:01:42 And that is why we broke out the production. That's my fault. Just real quick, the website, $166,000 for next year? What is that for? That would be for hosting and future development of the, in there, like, for a widget? That's the blogs, that's the video creation, it's photography, it's all of them. Does that include content? It's content. It's content. So this is just operations of the website, it's $166,000, and content is something else?
4:02:23 Okay, so we're talking about a soft launch now, and I think I would hope that before you start adding all these things on, some of these things we've talked about now, we have a discussion about the integration of the content before you start
4:02:57 Doing all these more steps. Does that make sense? So that we need to run a parallel path. Yeah, there's not one person doing this. Excuse me, Whitney? Can you come up to the microphone just because people watching can't hear you? Yeah, no, I'm so sorry. I mean, they do run at a parallel time because there's not one person developing all this. We're working with a team, 15 people, plus our internal team and our content creators in town. Okay, so I just, but the comments that I made.
4:03:24 And the things that I think we need to get in sync are based on a soft launch site. So I think we need to have some discussions about alignment prior to starting to build out all the rest of the site. And we have a meeting scheduled for next week, right? Right. I'm not sure if we're going to cover all that in that one meeting, but we can start talking about it.
4:03:46 We need to keep that in mind before you start investing all this money and building everything out. That's the advantage of having a soft launch. That's why you do a soft launch is to kind of test it out a little bit and see where things are at. Let's see what the soft launch teaches us.
4:04:00 Providing any direction as a single Councilmember. I'm just saying best practices would indicate that you see what the soft launch teaches you, and then you would want to fully deploy the thing out to a more developed site. And as I see it, Whitney, it's about $300,000 between content creation and website for this next year. So content creation would be the blogs, video production. That all costs quite a bit of money. Photography.
4:04:25 And again, the role of a photo library, of a digital asset management system, because if you're spending that much money creating digital content over a year, you're producing a lot of content, which is great. That's exactly what you should be doing. But I think we need to have a database-based system that establishes basic intellectual property about who owns all these assets, and it's an unsearchable database so they can be found, they can be managed going into the future, because I hope you're going to be doing this year over year for...
4:04:54 Decades to come, and we need to build a reliable back-end system so we can manage, find, take care of all these assets, and that's, I know we're talking about that, but I want to. Sounds good. Yeah. And as you know, we have that in process. Yeah, exactly. It is something that is in process. Are there other questions on this, or do you want to move on? Move on. Okay. On the sales side, this is really on our international sales and marketing side. Michael Vanderhurst heads up this department on the marketing side.
4:05:22 Spend about $113,000 in market. That's anywhere from Australia to UK, etc. Representation of $108,000. We have representation in Australia, UK, Germany, Italy, France. We've got representation in a number of new countries as well this year. We're looking at having a representation in China, even looking at South Korea with Chloe Kim coming up for the Olympics next time around. So representation is a big piece. That's both on the
4:05:50 Tour and Trade side and the media side. So that's bringing us fam trips that are in town to write about us as well as to book us. What is a fam trip? Familiarization trip. Basically, whether it's a tour operator from Australia, they may bring seven or eight people up. We show them around, get them to know the area, and they know how to sell it. I understand. Sure. Thank you. Okay. Let's keep moving here.
4:06:16 Unless there are other questions. On the communications side, this is Laura Kaler's world. Again, we have a PR agency that helps us with the really more of the national media reach. A lot of that has to do with our high altitude training focus. Our agency out of Napa Valley has been very productive in getting us a tremendous amount of exposure. Press events, that's either press events that we're doing ourselves or tying in with Visit California. Sponsorships include things like the
4:06:41 The Crib, which is our high altitude training crib, which we offer to elite athletes as well as the Mammoth Track Club. We sponsor the Mammoth Track Club as well. Now, one of the questions that I know we've heard around town, I think that there's a little bit of a misunderstanding as to how much money Mammoth Lakes Tourism may have after the end of this year with reserves because we've had a great year. You know, right now, if we end the season where we are, we'll be $3.5 million ahead of budget for TOT. With that, the town keeps about 71% of that, so that's about $2.6 million.
4:07:13 Mammoth Lakes Tourism gets 19.3% of that, so it's about $700,000. With that in mind, our goal is to, from the board level, we have been trying to work on building the reserve for Mammoth Lakes Tourism up to $1.2 million, which would be about 15% of our budget, which we think is a safe number. So right now, we've been able to maintain a $300,000 reserve, obviously far from $1.2 million at this point. So the plan would be to put $300,000 into general reserve.
4:07:41 But then also at the board direction we focused on three different infrastructure projects that we want to consider for moving forward to support and to help the town. One of which is, sorry, we're going to reinvest another $100,000 into marketing as well. But then on the event venue, we have started three new accounts to be able to put money aside to help the town with the building of an event venue potentially. Also with the airport terminal.
4:08:06 And then we have been talking at the board level about exploring the possibility of a convention center to help us get to that 10-month of viability and help to round out the season. And then lastly, Stuart mentioned a little bit earlier, this year we've added, because of the season that we had, we added another $25,000 into fish stocking. That puts us over $100,000 for the year.
4:08:25 Which is, as far as we can tell, the most fish stocking in the state is 10 tons of fish between now and November, along with what the county does and what DFW does. So that's already been something that's been put aside. And then on the TBID, again, the TBID reserves are fairly restricted as to they have to provide benefit to the folks that pay into it. So it's not something that we can utilize for different facilities, et cetera.
4:08:49 And we're projecting right now that there's a potential reserve of $1.25 million, about $750,000 of that. We want to reinvest in the marketing, and we want to set aside $500,000. Right now, our TBID budget, if you look at that main sheet, is about $4.6 million. If we have a bad winter, that could end up being $4 million. So as we've seen in the past four drought years, we need the reserve to be able to survive if we do have another tough year. And that's it. Okay.
4:09:17 Questions? Comments? I've got a couple things, but I'd defer to anybody else. Just one question, John, on the Measure A reserve sheet. Yep. So it sounds like the board went through some discussions, looked at prioritizing a couple of items to say,
4:09:34 You know, essentially, we feel like event venue, airport, convention center, those are critical to kind of the mission of MLT, driving visitation. Absolutely. Those type of things. So those were kind of highlighted as the top three areas you want to continue to fund. Absolutely. And I think that that's what we set aside. We set aside three accounts, $25,000 a piece, probably four months ago to start that discussion.
4:09:58 The way that they're set up is the board has the discretion to say, hey, you know what, we've got the opportunity right now to go into an event venue. Let's take this funding and move it into here and be able to send $200,000 to the town. Okay. And we felt that they are things that drive visitation. Okay. I know there's been discussion of roofs on hockey rinks and police stations. They're not going to drive visitation, and I think that's our purpose for being here. Sure. Thank you. So a couple things. One is I think I want to commend.
4:10:28 Not necessarily commend, but I think as the NGOs as part of the alignment process come forward, the type of budget sheet you provide as a one sheet at the beginning is a very kind of a good template or model to start looking at. I know that we've got the alignment process so that we're not asking, you know, there's a basic sense of what's in the budgets of each of the NGOs and we're not, you know, trying to find out, well, what's in the benefits or what's in the overhead. We're talking about tactical things and strategic things we're doing to get things done.
4:10:56 The second thing is I'm interested, and you don't have an answer to this now, but as the town, we're going to hopefully have our alignment strategies and those things adopted shortly, and I'm going to be very interested to see how we start to, in these presentations, align the things that you're doing with those priorities so that it's clear the role that MOT is playing.
4:11:22 And how we can see how this is complementing other efforts. And that's going to be something going forward and how we need to start getting these things lined up. And I think the third thing, which is sort of a general question, is how the council is going to engage with your board in terms of
4:11:35 Strategies, you know, how are we doing things from a higher level to be integrating these efforts? And there's no answer to that question this evening, but I think that's a process that we have to figure out so that we can figure out how to engage. If you're putting money aside, you've got opportunities to do these things, to have some conversation with the council about how to, you know, what maybe makes the most sense to, you know, where to put things, where to put places. So we're all kind of on the same page. Again, so we're all working as a team, rowing in the same direction and leveraging all of our assets.
4:12:05 Well, and I think there is the answer. I mean, we have a council representative that's on the board that represents your interests and hopefully brings that back to you as well. Right, but he's, yeah, but he's sitting here, I think he's sitting here right now in a different capacity. And I think we're going to, we will look to have, you know, dialogue with the boards of all the NGOs on a board, sort of as a board-to-board kind of basis. We haven't figured out formally how that's going to work, but that's going to be a very important part of all this going forward. John, you touched, you touched about, you know, investment in,
4:12:35 Infrastructure items with extra monies, basically. You're budgeting a little over $2.2 million on revenue guarantees for next year. Can you just talk a little bit about the actual dollars that were spent this year? Sure. The reduction of dollars versus the budget and, you know, the thought of where those funds will go to go towards infrastructure, new markets, new routes, whatever. Yeah, absolutely. So last summer we had a total of $715,000 budgeted.
4:13:04 Including an additional $50,000 from the county. The subsidy came in at $641. So we were roughly about $100,000 positive on subsidy last summer, 2015. And then this past winter, we're anticipating that we're going to come in somewhere maybe around $700,000.
4:13:20 We've got $1.5 million set aside. We'd like to keep that money focused on the air service side and really start looking at some of the programs that can help us fill some of the shoulder seasons. So we might look at folks that are flying in Sunday through Thursday and doing two-for-one deals or fourth flies, stays, and skis free, different promotions with the community. So working with lodging properties, working with different partners. Another piece that we're looking to build is a program called Friends of Flight.
4:13:47 And the Friends of Flight program, which we talked about yesterday at the county supervisors and council meeting, is really geared towards getting all of the businesses in town to help us promote air. You know, whether it's a lodging property that sends out their confirmation that says, hey, great, you booked your vacation, did you consider flying? Or if it's your restaurant and you're handing out a check presenter, it's got something in there that talks about the option for flying. And as a partnership, it may be that we give these businesses $500 or $1,000 worth of air credit.
4:14:16 So not only are they helping us get the word out there, but then they've got air credit that they can utilize to bring their visitors in or they can use themselves. So I think there are a couple of those different pieces which up until now we've been pretty much running a deficit in paying the air subsidy. We've been coming right up against the ceiling on it and with us responsible for the entire summer subsidy.
4:14:35 You know, we ended up the first year well over budget on the summer subsidy. Again, needed the reserves. But in the past couple of years, last year was $1.5 million. The total subsidy was just over $2 million. So the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area picks up anything above the $1.5. This year being under $1.5, we actually have that opportunity to build that war chest to fill the plains moving forward and to potentially look at new routes. We explored some new routes for next winter. Nothing is really popping out that it's going to make a whole lot of sense. But we also recognize that
4:15:04 If we decide that Seattle or Phoenix is a new market in two years, that we're going to need to go in and spend a fair amount of money the year before that to get awareness. So if we go into Seattle, say we're looking to fly Seattle in 2017-18, we go up there in 2016-17 and make sure that they know that they can fly connecting through LA, and then we can go back with a direct flight message. So there's potential that that could be a million bucks to open that market to really get the word out there so that when we do open the market that we fly the planes full.
4:15:34 Great. Any other questions? Any questions for the public? For John, for MLT? Okay. Thank you for the presentation. Great. We are going to move on to our consent agenda. There are two items I'd like to pull, number three and number five. Okay. Joe would like to pull three and five. Is there any other items that would like to be pulled by council, staff, public?
4:16:00 Okay, I'm going to look for a motion after I read item four, award the contract for publication of legal notices for fiscal 2016-17 to the sheet. Item six, adopt the resolution approving the relinquished agreement between Caltrans regarding Viewpoint Road. Item seven, accept payments approval report 15-33 in the amount of $132,972.57 and accept payment approval report 15-34 in the amount of
4:16:28 166,721.05. Joe, you pulled item in three and five. Well, don't we need the motion on the other one? We do. I'm sorry. We need a motion on four, six, and seven. We'll make the motion to approve consent agendas four, six, and seven with the change. Thank you. I was going to say, didn't we have an updated version of number seven? Okay. Thanks for acknowledging that. Yes, number six. I'll second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
4:16:58 Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Joe, item 3. And they're both related, but if we look on the minutes on page 6 of 8, when we were discussing additional money to youth sports funding, I know there was discussion about Husky Club might be a line item at some point in the future, but I don't remember the consensus to say that the 6,000 we were adding was directly going to Husky Club. I thought it was just 6,000.
4:17:26 To use sports funding. To use sports funding. That's correct. That's what I understand as well. Okay. So then I would move so that at the end of that line it would be to take out the two Husky Club. Okay. So then I would move approval of the minutes as amended. Second that. Okay. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
4:17:52 Yes, motion passes 5-0. Your next item is 5. And on number 5, it's the same thing. It's just youth sports funding takeout through the Husky Club. Okay. But I believe there's somebody in the audience who also wanted to speak on number 5. Sure. Hi, my name is Kathy Cage. I was not able to be at the May 4th Council meeting when this agenda item was discussed. I did watch the whole thing afterwards on the website, the view of it.
4:18:27 One of the things I was surprised about, and maybe you could just answer the question for me, but when we looked at having $2.6 million of TOT in excess, you know, of what our budget amount was, there wasn't a discussion about whether we should consider some service level improvements with respect to staffing in some of our departments. Now, I don't know if it's because in some preliminary meetings you might have said, gee, we don't want to consider staffing with one-time only money or something like that, but
4:18:54 But a couple of things I just wanted to tell you I was dismayed at that there wasn't a discussion about that because we're still operating our town offices only four days a week open to the public. I do work all over the state with all kinds of local governments. This is the only local government that isn't open to the public for five days a week. I mean, that just screams broken. You know, when I have second homeowners that come in and want me to do some work and, you know, a lot of times they'll come around weekends and they'll say, well, I'll go to the town offices on Friday. Oh, you can't.
4:19:24 Oh, that's because of the lawsuit. You know, so I don't know if there's a cost associated with having the town offices open for business for the public for five days a week, but if there is, could that be considered a way to spend some of this $2.6 million instead of just the REU and the capital projects and so forth?
4:19:43 There wasn't a discussion about that. I would also contend that there are a number of us in the community that are dismayed that we don't have 24-hour police protection, but there was no discussion about whether we should consider putting some police staff back on for some, you know, guarantee it for a certain number of years for $500,000.
4:20:02 You added a bunch of new administrative duties to the town staff with respect to our quality of life ordinance, but there was no additional allocation for staffing to cover that. And in the days in the finance department when we did the best on recouping a bunch of our TOT monies, there were two full-time people on that effort. We don't have that now. So these are just kind of some possible examples, but there was never a discussion on that agenda item about considering restoring some of the
4:20:32 So I understand that. So that doesn't answer my question, but I would just give you some input that, you know,
4:20:51 Those of us who rely on having to work with the town government are really struggling with being able to do that because the service levels are still low, frankly. They really are. And I would just say with $2.6 million, that's not like, oh, we got an extra $300,000, so of course you don't want a staff. I mean, the fully loaded costs of a person that what makes $50,000 a year is what?
4:21:13 100,000 a year or 80-some thousand. I mean, you could pull out half a million dollars and cover an entry-level staff position for five or six years probably. So then the second half of the answer, Kathy, is if you wait until we get to item number 14, we have a shortfall for 16-17. Okay.
4:21:30 So I just wanted to kind of register my objection that it was not considered to, you know, and I just wanted the record, Jamie, to reflect that. I just am dismayed that with this $2.6 million that, you know, there wasn't better consideration of dealing with just a regular governmental, you know, service provision rather than prioritizing capital projects.
4:21:57 Well, again, to Joe's comment, I mean, we spent a lot of time on this, and this is one-time money, and if you look at the budget next year, as Joe mentioned, that we have a shortfall again. We didn't increase the TOT, and we didn't go, wow, we had a great year this year after coming off four years of drought. Let's raise it all back up and fill a bunch of positions and have long-time funding. So I think this was carefully considered, and we are very aware of it.
4:22:26 Fiscally next year of what we're facing. Plus there's quite a few positions that we are advertising out there that quite frankly we can't fill. Kathy, I would just request, I know you're a leader in this community and you have been for many years. I've been on this council here for two years and I'm looking at, wow, banner year, record TO2, we've talked a lot about that. But a $2 million check that gets written every year puts a pretty
4:22:55 Interesting burden on leadership to try to figure out ways to manage these very tricky waters. And I think if there's anything that we can talk about to help kind of explain the narrative that we're in and start looking at ways to come up with solutions, it's very much a part of the alignment process that Council is doing with the NGOs because we're flirting with the structural deficit and we're doing everything we can to keep the books balanced in a unique revenue stream that's entirely dependent upon
4:23:24 As you well know. I think it would be very helpful going forward to start trying to construct a narrative that...
4:23:30 Points of the strengths of what we can do together as a community to make things work and not to be maybe just beating on drums that, frankly, we don't have a lot of tools to do anything about. That's true. But like I said, I understand, look, when it comes to the point where the resolution is already on the consent agenda, and I wasn't at that last meeting, and I can't attend all these meetings, you guys have a process. When you look at your strategies and goals thing, that thing is so obtuse, it's really very difficult for just a regular member of the public to
4:23:59 And I can see that you disagree with spending one time money, even $2.6 million on staffing positions.
4:24:19 I would just say I'm disappointed in that, and I wish that it was different, because I think, frankly, that that kind of service provision is more important than capital projects. So thank you for your time. Thanks, Kathy. And just a couple of comments from my end. You know, I think absolutely entitled to that opinion. I just want to make sure that there's not some information floating out there that's incorrect.
4:24:43 First of all, there was money set aside to staffing levels in terms of the conversation that we had around building permit issues. So that was a consideration that we are aware of in the community that was funded out of that one-time money. Secondarily, I think it's important to note that it's not like the town offices are closed for business on Friday. You know very well that that's by appointment and that if anything needs to get done, you can do that on Friday. And thirdly, when you talk about
4:25:09 Funding two positions for TOT enforcement and that's not happening anymore. There's actually up to four positions, currently three positions. So to say that that's not happening when we actually have more positions in that department than there were when there were two, I think is information that I want to make sure is clear out there. So I certainly think you're entitled to that opinion.
4:25:29 I agree with the rest of the council that there's a very distinct difference between one-time money. We had a very good year this year. The reason we have this surplus is because we budgeted conservatively. We're going to continue to budget conservatively next year where we're looking at a shortfall, as everybody mentioned. So to tie a bunch of money up in long-term encumbrances, in my opinion, is not prudent. Jo? Yes, then I'll make a motion to...
4:25:55 Adopt the resolution with the amendment to, if it's in there, to take out through the Husky Club. It's at least in the agenda bill as amended. Okay, great. Second. Motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Move on to policy matters. Item 8. Approve the proclamation to declare in May 26 as National Bike Month.
4:26:26 So just a point of order, did we take care of the outstanding items of the consent agenda? Yes, we did. We did? Okay, sorry. Okay, a proclamation of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, designated the month of May 2016 as National Bike Month, whereas Mammoth Lakes host the U.S. Cycling Mountain Bike National Championships, the Mammoth Gran Fondo, the Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games that attract thousands of cross-country and local bicyclists each year. Any questions from Council?
4:26:55 Any questions from staff? I mean, public, I'm sorry. Just a comment for me that in honor of bike month, I did bike to this meeting. Nice. Very nice. I'll entertain a motion, please. I'll be happy to make a motion. Council approves the proclamation declaring May 2016 as National Bike Month. I'll second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
4:27:27 I guess I'm coming down and presenting. Okay. Are you in the online bike challenge? Oh. Is that the talent thing? No, it's actually something great based on. We're going to take a quick 10-minute break. We've been kind of going at this since 4 o'clock, so we'll be back in a few minutes.
4:28:32 Okay, we're going to continue our regular meeting. We're going to move on to item number nine, accept the donation of real property located at 1244. Can you guys keep it down? I can't. I found that thing. Nice. All right. Thank you very much. We're going to move on to item number nine, accept the donation of real property located at 1244, Old Mammoth Road from Snow Creek Hilltop Development Company, LP, and authorize the town manager to sign the grant deed and record it.
4:29:10 Conservation Easement with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. All right, thank you. As indicated, this is for the consideration of accepting property located within the Mammoth Creek Corridor at 1244 Old Mammoth Road. The parcel is located approximately at the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret Road, as shown here on the screen outlined in blue. The parcel proposed to be donated is approximately
4:29:39 Approximately 15 and a half acres in size. The owner has proposed to donate this property to the town with a conservation easement to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. This will preserve the property as natural open space and continue to allow the existing multi-use path and dirt trails on the site. The donation will accomplish a few things. It will permanently preserve the property as required by the Snow Creek Development Agreement.
4:30:07 It will satisfy deer habitat mitigation required for the construction of the Snow Creek 8 Hotel. It will place a significant portion of the Mammoth Creek Corridor under town ownership. This is combined with the existing Mammoth Creek Corridor land as owned by the town.
4:30:26 And it will allow opportunities for the town to utilize some of the property for future wetland and or habitat mitigation subject to the required approvals from DFW. With that, staff's recommendation is to choose option one and accept the donation of the property located at 1244 Old Mammoth Road and record a conservation easement with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. Additionally,
4:30:54 The property owner or representative from Snow Creek is here. Okay. Any questions for staff this time? Yeah, I have one. The financial section doesn't talk about what it's going to cost us to maintain any of these trails and what kind of funding that we have available, seeing as we have that shortfall coming up in.
4:31:17 Probably future years. So is that a question for Dan instead or Nathan for how did you estimate what the cost of either maintaining these trails or enhancing anything would come from? Sure. So the existing multi-use path is already included in all the maintenance of ongoing the dirt path. I might
4:31:41 To Grady as well, because I know he is a little more familiar with that funding, but at this time for any future improvements on that path, there isn't any planning or any programming done for that. It's contingent on kind of some alignments of future ends on either side and then will be programmed for maintenance as well. But Grady, can you elaborate? Yeah, just very briefly, the rest of the paths out there are really user trails if you've been there. Some of them are...
4:32:10 As deep as they are wide. So we're going to look to Joel, who's not in the room at the moment, though, to kind of look at his program in the future and see where we can do that. What we've been able to see, though, in conversations with him is that the cost with the kind of actions he's taken with the crews he's using is very minimal to maintain that type of trail. But let's measure our money. And is this measure our eligible? No, I understand that it's not. But the point is, it could be in the
4:32:39 As an example, hundreds of dollars per year at the most. So we didn't anticipate that would be a great burden compared to the ability to preserve this as open space long term. Okay. Well, the ability to preserve has always been there as part of the agreement. It's just this is a different version that the community originally thought. In addition, we're actually at no obligation to maintain those user trails either. So it's really, we'll take a look at them, do it from year to year, and see what we can do to it too.
4:33:05 To improve them if possible, but we don't need no obligation to do that. It's really the MOP that we are required to. Okay. And then I guess my second question is, if I remember from the early stuff, and some of this even predates me, sorry, you know, it doesn't happen often, but it does, is that I think that the original idea when this was presented through Planning Commission, et cetera, was that it would be Eastern Sierra Land Trust. Why is it now Department of Fish and Wildlife?
4:33:32 It's our understanding that the property owner worked with Department of Fish and Wildlife and there was a recommendation from them to work with the town. So the property owner came through the town and we saw it as a benefit for the town. So that's why we've worked with the property owner to acquire this property and he's available. So the town owns the property but it's still under the authority of Fish and Wildlife. There is a conservation easement. Because of the easement.
4:34:00 One thing that Nola mentioned, though, as well, is we've reserved a future easement of unspecified alignment, such as if we want to do something, we want to do another trail in there, we can do so. So it's not specified precisely. Again, it's called out.
4:34:16 It says future 20-foot wide easement for multi-use path purposes, alignment to be determined. So again, we've reserved our rights such that if we do find a reason to come in there, we can come back in and do that in the future. OK. And this. Oh, sorry. Those acreage for that existing trail and the future one are excluded from the conservation easement. OK. So it's approximately 1.88 acres that are not going to be under the conservation easement.
4:34:43 All right, so we have some that we actually have final authority over. And then the uphill, upstream part of the meadow, that stays, that still belongs to one of the other Snow Creek pieces. Yes, I don't have it on the map here, but that part would not be carved out. This was as part of the Snow Creek 7 project.
4:35:08 Pulled out as a separate parcel on the map. The other ones are still within the Snow Creek 1 and 2 and other developments there. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions for staff? Yeah, a couple questions. Sure. Which of the public's, well, first question is, is the neighbors, and this is a very important thing for all the neighbors and folks who live around there. There's no one here from that.
4:35:32 What should the public expect that that's going to stay the way that it is? Is there any expectation that the trail system might want to put appropriate signage on those trails or maintain any of these things? What should the public be thinking as we
4:36:01 If we, as we consider taking this action going forward. Under the current proposal with Fish and Wildlife, it would really remain kind of as is right now. The ongoing recreation activities would be the low impact activities that are currently allowed there, hiking, bird watching, fishing, those uses, and there wouldn't be really, the purpose of the conservation easement is to protect it kind of as is for the habitat. It's not
4:36:29 Going and really doing any restoration work, it's really leaving it in the status quo as is there. Okay, so in the trail system master plan, there's a recommendation about a meadow trail and a boardwalk and these kinds of things. I'm assuming you guys are aware of that. Yes, and that is part of what that kind of the alignment that's yet unknown, why that's being reserved is for those portions of the project. Right. But again, they're not really programmed at this time because there is some coordination that has to happen with.
4:36:57 The owners then to the west to where those ultimate alignments would end up. And the signage that's out there now, does that need to change for liability purposes or anything? It's all pretty informal and casual. Is that anything that's going to need to change or no? As far as I know it does not need to change it, we might refer to Andy as far as any liability. I don't see a lot of change here. I don't see a lot of liability. Well, okay, not maybe a recreational liability, but
4:37:31 You know, if you've been out there, you know that these trails are very degraded. Are we, is Lahontan all of a sudden going to say, hey, you guys have to do things to remediate this? Or are they okay when it's in a conservation easement if those trails are getting...
4:37:47 Are affecting the creek? I think Lahontan's enforcement activities and directions to us will take into account that there are limitations on what we're allowed to do with the trails. So I think that if Lahontan were to come talk to us about runoff, we'd have to talk to DFW and Lahontan both and see what they feel it's okay for us to do. All right. I just, you know, here we go with multi-agencies and not necessarily agencies that have been working on partnering. Right. Exactly. Okay. Is there any comments from the property owner who's here or the public?
4:38:18 Okay, bring it back for the discussion and we're in motion, please. I will make a motion that the council accept the donation of real property located at 1244 Old Mammoth Road, APN 040-160-002-000 from Snow Creek Hilltop Development Company, LP, and authorize the town manager to sign the grant deed and record conservation easement with the California Department of Fish and Wildlife. I'll second that. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
4:38:52 Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. We're going to move on to item 10, consider a resolution to ratify Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District Ordinance 2016-01 regarding more stringent building standards regarding fire and panic safety. Thank you. The state law requires that the town council ratify the local fire district's ordinance.
4:39:16 The fire district recently adopted an ordinance 2016-01 to amend the 2013 fire code with additional requirements for fire sprinklers. This was something that was inadvertently left out of the 2013 update that the town council did ratify. And so staff has reviewed the ordinance, the building official has reviewed the fire district ordinance in his support of ratification.
4:39:44 We have Tom Heller here from the Fire District who can give a kind of brief summary of what the ordinance does and the changes. And then I'm available for any questions. And Tom is here. Okay. Questions? Just a process question for Sandra. So when we're ratifying their ordinance, we are not having to do with through a first and second reading and all those things. No, because you only need a resolution to ratify their ordinance. Tom? Mr. Mayor, members of council, my name is Tom Heller.
4:40:15 The Fire District, also in attendance, is our chairperson for our board, if you have any questions of what the actions that the board took. This is, as Sandra mentioned, this was an omission that was left out of both the 2010 and 2013 code. This brings back into effect part of the ordinance that's been in our code since 1989. And so this was just an administerial action.
4:40:44 That I inadvertently left out when we upgraded the code in 2010 and again in 2013. It was brought to my attention by a couple of the contractors here in town. And so we went through the process to, and what the code, excuse me, what the ordinance basically talks to is new construction, buildings greater than 5,000 square feet in size would need to be sprinklered regardless of the types of uses. And for existing buildings, should there be a change of use in a building,
4:41:13 Based on the building official's evaluation, those buildings would need to be either brought up to the 5,000 square foot ordinance, or they could come up with methods with which to modify the building with which to separate the building such that it would be components of less than 5,000 square feet. Okay. Tom, did...
4:41:37 What kind of outreach did you do to the construction, especially, you know, like the Contractors Association and things like that? Because every time we change the law, even if the state's telling it to do us, we hear back. Did your Board of Commissioners do some outreach to them? No, we definitely, we had two public meetings. We have actually had conversations at the Contractors Association meetings. So we, you know, we tried to vet.
4:42:04 That portion of our population as best we could. And I think we had 13 members of the construction organization at the first meeting. We had two at the second meeting. Thank you. Tom, just to clarify something you mentioned. So I understand the new build and anything above 5,000 square feet. For change of use on an existing business, does that trigger the sprinkler requirements regardless of size?
4:42:32 As long as it's less than 5,000 square feet, it would not trigger anything as far as sprinklers go. Okay. Greater than 5,000 square feet. I think there's an add-on to that. It's a greater hazard classification, too, if it goes to a greater hazard. And that's part of what the change of use would require. Right. Thank you. But if it's a change of use that moves it to a greater hazard classification, but it's less than 5,000 square feet, does it need sprinkling or no? It would require sprinkling.
4:43:00 If it was a building that was 5,000 square feet or greater. So the answer to your question was, I believe the answer is no. Because you're asking if it's 5,000, it's less than 5,000 square feet, they change something, we look at it and make sure there's safety elements in place, but does it trigger the sprinkling? Right. That's correct. The answer is no. I think that was the answer you got. If you want to rephrase it, we can clarify it.
4:43:30 Confused. Okay, so if you have a... So my question is, okay, I understand if there's a new build, 5,000 square feet or greater, it needs to be sprinklered. Correct. If you have an existing building that changes use and therefore goes into a classification where it's a higher risk, but it's less than 5,000 square feet, it does not trigger sprinkler requirements, correct? Correct, because on here, right here, it says where it has the greater hazard and is...
4:43:59 More than 5,000. Gotcha. I mean, we still review it for safety. That was contrary to my understanding of the way I read it, so I just wanted to clarify that. Thank you. Any other questions? No. Questions from the public? Okay, I'll bring it back. No further questions. I'll entertain a motion, please. I will move that the council choose adoption one, adopt a resolution ratifying the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District Ordinance 2016-01. Second.
4:44:27 Okay, I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I'm going to move on to item number 11, approve a resolution to write-off or restructure specific interfund loans within the town. Staff? Dan? Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is hopefully the last item you'll see relating to setting some cleanup and some of the debt issues and restructuring some of those and doing some write-offs.
4:44:57 This came up through a couple different budget discussions as well as some of the year-end work that we've done. Real quickly, there's basically a diff receivable and two fractional use note receivables. It's recommended to be written off. Basically, on the diff one giving the current building activity and also restructuring the fees and stuff, the long-term ability to pay that off is small. Also, to the extent that if we're collecting
4:45:27 Future diff fees to actually build new projects are in the books. To the extent you're paying the debt off, you won't see anything new built for a number of years out of those diff fees. And most of those projects have been completed with the general fund dollars. So the other element on that, we're still tracking that, that those dollars from the general fund, if you will, were utilized on the diff side. So where we have had a write-off on a diff fee for a while when the town didn't collect any or there's something else coming in.
4:45:55 We actually have this general fund credit over there, if you will, so we're not impeding or requiring any other developer to pay more or to have an unfair share of a payment to any type of related DIF project. For example, when we waive the fees related to the police station, that doesn't put a burden on any other developer to pay for those fees in that element. The other piece on the fractional Miller-Ruths,
4:46:21 There were some startup fees and some operational fees. Giving the timelines and some operational under state law, I don't believe either of those are actually collectible to be repaid at this point in time. Those fees come in, they're still utilized for the purposes underneath the CFD, but it would not include the repayment of those two outstanding notes. The last one is real restructuring, and this was a diff note receivable to the garage replacement fund dealing with our equipment vehicle replacement.
4:46:50 Million 275. The recommendation on that one is to restructure the existing note that we have between the garage and the general fund. This would basically add some additional time onto that note. We're repaying ourselves at a zero percent interest rate at $340,000 per year. The reason to keep that garage replacement fund whole, frankly, is if we don't, that most likely results in a larger annual allocation every year out of the general fund to backfill that.
4:47:19 Depreciation schedule regardless, so we believe this is a general fund obligation either way. The structure is a note, gives us a certainty of repayment, it's part of the general fund obligation going forward, and keeps that fund whole for future replacement of vehicles, and mainly our major road equipment, be it a blower, greater, or the snowplow equipment, etc. Okay.
4:47:46 Questions? Yes. One. Dan, so on page one of the actual staff report, will those, you know, when we deal with these pieces, will we have finally dealt with all the funny paper that we were carrying all these years? Yeah, I believe there's no other. That was one of my goals. Yeah.
4:48:05 I don't think there's any other outstanding inter-fund loans that have elements where we're concerned about the repayment or not. So this will clean all of that up, I believe. It'll take all of these long-term notes basically off the books in a sense. It cleans up our fund balances so we're not looking at either receivables or payables that impact that in our fund balances. And then it does keep the garage fund whole and cleans that up as a debt.
4:48:31 Between the garage fund and the general fund. So then with the garage replacement and the ones listed lower down there and on the top of the next page, that's the complete set of our outstanding long-term debt and interfund loans? Yes. That is everything that's on the book right now. So that was my follow-up question was, Dan, you and staff, you guys have done a lot of
4:49:01 What did you call it? Funny money? Well, funny paper. It was dollars that didn't have money behind them. Yeah, you've had a big task with cleaning this up, a lot of cleanup and a lot of write-offs. I mean, are we kind of getting down to the... We should be done with the writing-off component. We've done some work with the airport, some additional diff, some other pieces in there over the last year, year and a half. Well, I just want to compliment you for getting this done, and it's been kind of an ongoing process, and I really appreciate it.
4:49:31 So the town's independent accountant will be very happy? I think so, yes. It eliminates some of the account. Staff will be very happy just in terms of some of the accounting and tracking of this, and as we're looking at what are actual fund balances, we're not trying to net it out against payables and receivables of this magnitude. I would just commend you for your efforts, the whole team, for doing this, but I would also
4:49:55 For folks who have been around here for a while, I think this, in some small, minor way, represents the end of a certain kind of an era in this town and how this town chose to attempt to finance things and realize its aspirations. And it's a pretty dramatic swing. But I certainly feel confident about how we're doing things these days and the kind of direction this council is taking in terms of
4:50:25 Budgeting, conservatism with these things and transparency. And it's really a new day dawning in many ways. So I want to commend you for your work on that. Thank you. Any comments from the public? OK. See you now. I'll bring it back for further discussion. Just another comment is that, you know, to put it a little more directly than John did, is that
4:50:48 I hope that those future councils, of which I'll be watching at home, realize that some of these note receivables were more hope than any kind of a strategy, and that's what we've been doing in our strategy sessions. It's getting away from hope and clearing up things that General Fund paid for that are never coming back and being realistic about it. Right. With that.
4:51:16 In mind, I would move that we adopt a resolution to write off or restructure the inter-fund loans as noted. Okay. I have a motion. Second. Motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Move on to item 12. Receive an update regarding your storage area parking and provide direction to staff.
4:51:48 To proceed with final design and environmental documents. And for the record, we have been talking about this item for some time. And as a business owner at North Village, as I stated before, I've confirmed with Andy that conflict of interest does not apply. And I will be voting on this matter. I also have that conflict, possibly.
4:52:15 We've looked into this previously and determined that under the rules as they exist now, you don't have a conflict. All right. I'll take your word for it. Okay. Grady? Thank you. Back in January, we were before Council with some ideas about how to...
4:52:33 Squeeze every parking space we could, if you will, out of the village area. We committed to being back at this time to do so. We've completed a 30% design of one of the options on the hillside lot, and I'd like to run through sort of the process we went through. What we're looking for tonight is just basically direction to keep going the direction we are and accept any comments and make any changes to it.
4:52:56 The first area I'd like to focus is over between Hillside Drive and Canyon. You'll see on the far left there's a sliver on the west side of Hillside Drive. There was a previous design to add approximately seven parking spaces in that area. It was actually completely designed. It required a retaining wall back into the hillside. And what we found, as you'll see later, is that those spaces are actually quite expensive.
4:53:18 I'll show you that later on in the presentation. And what we'd like to do with those is not build them out as designed, but we do have another idea on that. The second area is the hillside parcel itself. We were asked to look at a phased parking lot there to see how many spaces we could reasonably put in that space.
4:53:38 Whether it be one phase or two or overall. The third one is on Canyon Boulevard. There are currently four limited time spaces along Canyon Boulevard. And we had a previous design as well when we did Lower Canyon a couple of years ago to change that from four spaces up to as many as 14. This is the area on Hillside Drive. You'll see on the left-hand side that dark line of the future retaining wall.
4:54:03 Again, due to the cost that I'll show you in a minute, we don't recommend this. However, what we would like to do is just using our own crews, we'll get out there, and if we can grade a smaller area, even put down some grindings and create some spaces that might even be seasonal in nature, maybe they're only valuable for the summer, we can't really use them during the winter, but for snow storage, we still want to do that. So we'll come back later with a report that says, look, you know, it's going to cost $10,000 to create additional spaces. But again, the focus of this staff report...
4:54:32 Presentation was on the bigger nut, if you will, of the hillside parking lot. We will still pursue what we can here. So the recommendation for now is that you'll come back with further options on that particular piece? Correct. That's correct, further low-cost options. Okay. And we got blanks. Okay. I was handed a thumb drive with everything on it. I'm glad we have the handout in your packet, so I'll go through it. That's why we don't always rely on the technology.
4:55:06 It was what was on the thumb drive, that's right. And for the benefit of the audience, I'll hand out my copy of this with the exhibits on it later. But again, I think we'll do what we can. Again, the other one showed an area, again, of four parking spaces, limited time on Canyon Boulevard. And again, you have that in your packet. And we've seen it before where we would expand that parking from four spaces to 14 spaces.
4:55:34 Not require retaining wall, but it would require pushing to the north into the adjacent parcel. We do have a pedestrian access easement eight feet wide to be able to do that without disturbing the adjacent ownership. I don't know where it went to. I wouldn't worry. But if it's not on the thumb drive, it's not there. It's just not there. It's okay. Yeah.
4:55:58 The next exhibit shows what we would consider a full build-out of the hillside lot. It shows a total of 49 spots, and I want to draw your attention to the upper right-hand corner of that where it shows, again, another dark line, which would be a retaining wall up to seven feet high through that area. So this would be the full build-out. The next item in your packet is really what we would consider as phase one. It shows 38 parking spaces.
4:56:26 On that lot, it also shows the beginnings of a bus turnout and additional sidewalk on hillside drive itself. This is what we are recommending that we move forward with this 38 spaces. We think it's cost effective. We did have the consultant look at four different alternatives for this. We could present them all, but basically this is the one that yielded the greatest number of spaces with the lowest cost and the best flexibility, these 38 spaces.
4:56:52 The next exhibit shows what would be phase two. In order to meet fire department turnaround requirements, we actually take out three or four of the spaces we created and then add spaces back in for a net gain of only 11 spaces. And again, when we get to the cost information, I think you'll see why we're at least recommending that we not move forward with those other 11 spaces.
4:57:14 Next one is basically just a representation of what a seven-foot high wall looks like. This is actually one that we built along Canyon Boulevard. In phase one of this recommendation, we do show a wall that goes from anywhere from one to seven feet. So seven is the peak. Most of it is down at two and three, four feet. We don't consider that a significant wall. But we did want to show what the maximum could look like with that photograph of what a seven-foot high wall looks like.
4:57:43 An idea there. Next is the cost estimates and analysis, and I'll go through each one of them. First, at the community center, we still believe we can get a three or even four spaces over the community center. That would be our own forces using grindings, maybe even paving it, and we have some areas for that. Again, we didn't focus on that. We took a look at it on site. We recognized we could do it, and we moved on because we really wanted to focus on the larger.
4:58:08 Parking lot on Hillside Drive. We anticipate the cost for that would be about $15,000 or $5,000 a space. The next is the Hillside Parallel Parking, again, where the wall would be. And as you can see, the cost per space could be almost $26,000. And it just didn't make a lot of sense to us. We anticipated $12,000 to $15,000 a space. That's what we find on the rest of them. And $26,000 a space for just seven spaces on street.
4:58:35 Again, that's not our recommendation. The next is Canyon Boulevard Limited Time Parking. We've had this designed before. Our updated estimate is $110,000 for 11 spaces, or excuse me, for a total of 14 or 10 additional spaces, about $11,000 a space. That seems like a good investment. I will mention that on those added 10, if we go from 4 to 14,
4:59:00 There's no reason we can't restrict the timing in a different fashion than we are today. Right now we have four 30-minute spaces. We don't need 14.
4:59:09 30-minute spaces. So as we're going through the final design, we can come back with a discussion of are these two-hour spaces? Are they one-hour spaces? You know, maybe we do four of them at 30 minutes and the rest of them are two hours. We can sign them any way we see appropriate. That's something that's under our jurisdiction. Frankly, I would talk to the police chief and we'd come up with something in concert with the tenants there and see what makes sense. The last one is the hillside parcel. And again, phase one.
4:59:36 We estimate about $13,000 per space for those 38 spaces. That's right in line with our previous estimates. That's not the only reason we like it. We really do think that's a reasonable amount to spend on that lot for those spaces. Phase two almost doubles in cost because we have to take out spaces, we're reconstructing, we're adding a much larger retaining wall, and the incremental cost is up to $25,000 per space. So again, our recommendation is for less than that. Next in the packet,
5:00:06 We also talk about what we call the CFD improvements, if you will. We were approached a few weeks ago by the members, if you will, of the CFD for North Village and said, look, we have a certain amount of money that's available that we need to spend by October of this year.
5:00:25 And our comment from an engineering staff, of course, is if you let them loose, they're very good at that. But, you know, we think we can get it done. In fact, we're confident we are. We have a consultant on board already doing some preliminary design documents. We've got our first look at that this afternoon, in fact. And we really haven't done a cost estimate, so I'm not ready to commit to how many spaces we can do. But the concept there is to start down near Burgers Restaurant on the east side. And this is the photo I'm looking at now.
5:00:55 Start near Burger's Restaurant on the east side of Minaret and improve Minaret Boulevard all the way to the corner of Forest Trail at a minimum. We think we can add a significant number of parking spaces, as many as 15 or 20. We believe we can add a bus turnout. And those of you who take the bus in the winter, that's where they transition. And sometimes there's two buses and 40 people standing there on the side of the road. So we think we can add a bus turnout, add a bus shelter. Grady, would those spaces be parallel on Minaret?
5:01:24 Spaces up further to the north would definitely be parallel. To the south, we actually have an idea that we might be able to do angled parking through that area. Again, that's very conceptual. We got a drawing this afternoon. We need to talk to Caltrans. We can get more spaces if we can do them as angled parking through that area. But definitely quite a few of them would be parallel. So it will be a mix. Again, this is further behind the hillside lot design. We just started this, what, Dan, about three weeks ago, so.
5:01:54 We'll come back to Council at a later date with a precise recommendation and a cost estimate. And while you're on that page, you obviously have to incorporate what the already approved plans are, because I think Burgers is part of the parcel that's already been entitled. In fact, the preliminary sketch was sent to the owner.
5:02:14 That parcel Will Gustafson before I saw it this afternoon. The engineer said, look, we told him, work closely with the owner, make sure it's consistent with his future plans. He emailed it to him at the same time he emailed it to us. So he's probably spent more time on it than I have. We're talking to the owner. We're also talking to the parking operator there and see what we can do to resolve as many issues as we can. The owner also asked us to take a look at the angled parking more than just parallel parking and gave a couple other
5:02:44 Suggestions in terms of that that better meet their long-term plans there for what's approved and also from what they believe will be a better enhancement to the village today in terms of parking capabilities. Correct, but my concern is that the idea they had originally there, which I saw on the Planning Commission, was for retail along there and so I just want to make sure that you guys aren't going to try and come up with something.
5:03:10 That doesn't meet with their plans. And very frankly, we're not looking for direction on this tonight because we, I mean, it's really a sketch and it's dealing with the CFD funds. Since we were talking about village area parking that we included in the agenda sheet so you could get a good view of everything we're looking at. On that drawing, we show it as extending a round forest trail all the way back to Berner Street because that's the area that the CFD...
5:03:31 Allows us to look. So, again, it will depend on funding. If this moves forward and we bid it, it'll be a unit price contract, and frankly, we expect to spend $675,000. To the last paver. Everyone we can squeeze in with the funds available will want to do through that area. Another section, I mentioned the Hillside Drive. The area, you can see it on the photograph now, on the left-hand side near the parking lot.
5:04:00 Which would be on the east side of Hillside Drive. We'd really like to do improvements there, a sidewalk, a bus turnout, and a bus shelter there as well. We've already talked to ESTA about rerouting that area through there. They said that's not an issue. They really think it'd probably provide better service long term if we did that. So we have a design for that started as well. The cost for that is about $110,000. It's actually eligible for CFD reimbursements. It's in that project. So I guess one of the...
5:04:29 Questions we have tonight is we want to pursue it with the CFD funds if we can, if there's not enough money.
5:04:37 At a later date, we'll ask the council, okay, would you like to go ahead and do that as well? It doesn't provide any additional parking spaces, but it does provide a better facility for ESTA. In addition, of course, we've already called John Hill with ESTA and said, okay, do you have any sorts of funds for the shelter itself, for the sidewalk, for anything else to help with that? So, again, these are very preliminary, but we're looking at every sorts of funds, and knowing that we want to get these done this summer, you know, it's going at a pretty fast pace.
5:05:05 When it comes back to the staff report and the recommendation, what we're really looking at is our recommendation is phase one of the hillside parcel, 38 spaces and the cost associated there in your packet, adding 10 spaces on Canyon Boulevard, limited time, and we'll determine at a later date what that means, whether it's a two-hour space or a one-hour space.
5:05:31 Those are the two big ones. The other one is the community center spaces, which we can do with our own forces. The total there is, I believe, $618,000. That's our recommendation tonight.
5:05:44 Make a final decision at a later point after we get the final designs and the 100% cost estimates. What we're looking for tonight is a direction to proceed with the final design of the hillside lot parcel and final cost estimates for the whole thing. In addition, next time we come back, we would have all the environmental documentation requirements met. We think those are very slight, by the way, because there has been...
5:06:08 Parking structure already on this site. It's already slated for parking. But I have talked to community development, and we will come back with that as well. Great. Really quick, just on the CFD piece, when would you anticipate going out for bids on that that's going to not exceed what's in that fund?
5:06:33 Right. We got, like I said, a concept drawing today. We expect 30% drawings after we look at that, talk to the owner, work with the town manager on that sometime in late June. We actually expect we could bid that late June, early July. And before we do that, we'd come back to council with that cost estimate. We have to work through the CFD issues and make sure that we've done the proper process, if you will, to be able to spend that money on these line items. So we do expect to be back.
5:07:01 Again, either the second meeting in June or first one in July with an update on our cost estimate, what we think we can do. Okay. Questions? Yeah, I have a question too. Sure. On the page it says Hillside Parcel Phase 1 because I noticed these don't have page numbers. Right. Explain to me how this connects people. You know, is it timed parking, first of all? What's the idea with the actual spaces? Are they timed so that there's good turnover?
5:07:28 How do people get from there? I understand S could swing by, but it's, you know, do we want another situation like we've got over there at the transfer station where they're standing in the snow? How does all that work? How does that fit into the design you have so far? At the bare minimum, there are 38 spaces. We haven't talked about operationally. Are those two-hour spaces? Because you're correct. There would be employees that could fill those up right away, and they wouldn't really be available.
5:07:55 What we tried to do first was see if they were feasible from a cost and engineering perspective. Operationally, we need to talk about that, and we'll come back with a recommendation. In terms of how they get around, I absolutely agree. We would really like to do the sidewalk and the bus turnout so whoever parks there can easily walk down the canyon and across. You'll see on the right side of that as well, we show a path over towards the stairs coming down from the west end.
5:08:23 That's not included in our estimate right now because we don't think we want to do that as a phase one. The parking spaces, in our view, is more important than that path back to the steps. But we guesstimate that that's probably about $105,000 at the most to do that. We would have to talk to the west and get permission to tie our sidewalk into theirs and the steps. So again, there's still a lot of moving parts, but we wanted to make sure we could come back to you with at least a...
5:08:49 Minimum recommendation for that Phase I parking so that we can get something done this summer. And the timed spaces that we have in the village and around the village, as far as I've noticed, nobody's enforcing the time. Nobody's giving out tickets. Is that correct?
5:09:09 Well, no tickets are being given out in the community center lot. It's been a while, but yes, we have been doing different enforcements in there, as we know, and watching that. Okay, because it does us no good to say we're going to turn them over because we're timing them if we're not. We've actually, I'll just, and Martin, yeah, and reviewing the parking ticket revenue, it's up dramatically the last four or five months, so. Okay. Sorry to hear that. Mr. Mayor, I'm,
5:09:39 I'm conceptually pretty good with all this, but I have a significant public safety concern with the Canyon Boulevard limited time, the way this is designed. The mountain bike traffic that comes down Canyon Boulevard, it's awesome, it's fast, but they are riding in the road. And if we start putting something in there where you've got people pulling in at 90 degrees and backing in and pulling out, I think...
5:10:04 It would, we would be, without some real safety analysis of this issue, I think, I think I get a real problem with that. So I, and I, but I'm interested in your thoughts on the CFD down in that area. That, I think it makes sense to maybe hold off on this piece of it and start thinking about what this, what the CFD piece looks like going, you know, coming forward and maybe focus our resources on that. I just. Well, I, so that was just, if I could, that was going to be my question, Grady.
5:10:32 On page one of the agenda sheet, so we've got one, two, three, four, five, six items that are listed there. Start with community center, go down to CFD. Three of them are highlighted. Those are the recommendations. Is staff asking us to take each of those on a line-by-line basis, understanding that the CFD is not really under consideration tonight? We're looking at the original five. How do we want to take this, Mr. Mayor?
5:10:58 If I may, if we get some consensus on each of those, that would be good, including the CFD work. You know, the folks that are in the CFD want us to proceed with that, but we also want the Council's buy-in to go do that. To Council Member Wentzworth's comment on that, we've had a request already to take a look. Do we look at angled parking on there? That might reduce the spaces. From a safety standpoint, that could be better, so we can hold off on, you know, finally spending money there, but how we could do that.
5:11:27 Real quick, the last thing in walking through the consensus discussion on this, this would be a $620,000 expenditure out of dollars set aside for parking and roads. And is the council comfortable spending that much on the parking component out of the $900,000 we set aside? That would be the primary funding for this outside of the CFD money. So I want to make sure there's a comfort level in that as well as if you want to look at a couple different.
5:11:55 The 90-degree parking was put in because we designed it before. There's been concerns raised exactly to the, is it going to be safe in the wintertime? Is this going to be problematic? So if you want something else looked at that, we can definitely do that. I share the same concern as John. Does angled parking really change 90-degree? I mean, regardless, you have vehicles that are backing up on the Canyon Boulevard. They're doing that anyway in parallel parking.
5:12:19 You can, I mean, you have people coming in and out. The angle parking would have, the 45 degree angle, I think would help a lot because you're not pulling, you know, into maybe the downhill lane and, you know, you're pulling into the uphill lane and that's where you're worried about. I agree with you. Yeah, there's the downhill lane. The downhill lane. Yeah, so when you have the 90 degree, I can see that they'll back all the way probably into the downhill lane.
5:12:46 And we have discussed that as staff already. The reason to come forward with what we had tonight is because we wanted to make sure we had a good cost estimate so we could make a recommendation there. If we go angled, we may or may not lose one space, but we don't have a strong preference either way, so we'll take a look at that. We'll talk to PD about some of the activity there. I mean, don't get me wrong. I think there's a strong need for additional temporary spaces there. I mean, those spaces are filled. Those would be more permanent, actually, on Canyon. Again, we can. I mean, those.
5:13:15 Time-wise, I think. Time-wise. He's talking about the time. You had like a 30-minute or whatever. Oh, yeah, yeah, right now. Well, we had a 15-minute at one time. 15? Yeah. Did you put that in? That wasn't even enough time to go buy a bottle of wine. Exactly. Right. I think also that the CFD stuff, and it'd be nice to maybe hold a little bit of our resources until we get a sense of what that looks like. So I think that's going to help a lot. It's a separate discussion. Well, and I mean, I think.
5:13:43 Again, I mean, we've been talking about this parking in North Village. That's not an issue. It's not a problem. It's a crisis. It's been a crisis for a long time. We're facing a lot now that's closed. If you took today and said that lot was closed down for good, I mean, where are people parking? Staff reported on Hillside three
5:14:06 Units going to be developed there where a lot of people are parking there too, right? And that's illegal parking. We got people parking up and down and around, I mean, illegally. And I mean, I think the chief's got a full-time job. And I mean, the message is we don't want to be ticketing everybody. And for a problem that really the town is just, we have some issue with it, right? I mean, this has been ongoing. There's no parking in that area. So I think, you know, the goal is being.
5:14:33 Let's get as much as we can for financially what makes sense. And if we can get the most bang for our buck, it's a big win. The hillside lot, there's, you know, to say it's a temporary lot, I mean, temporary in this town could be 20 years. We've proven that with a ski lodge, right? So, you know, I think this is a big win. I think the CFD moving the CFD forward, getting that street front parking along Minerac, getting that beautification.
5:15:03 Really, when folks come around to the village to see what the other side, to have some vision there, to have a safe sidewalk, to not have, you know, that's a big deal to have, you know, you've seen people using the bus there. It's pretty bad. We talked about that at ESTA and the importance of getting a shelter there and getting a turnout, yard spools in there. I mean, so that side, if we can go as far as we can go up and around until the money runs out, so to speak, without having to go back to the well, the money's
5:15:33 There for that. I think it's a huge win. So, you know, I'm supportive of this as it is. Safety concerns, John, I think you're right on the money. And I think that could be addressed with an angled type of 45 or not backing out into the downcoming traffic with the bikes and such. I agree. So you want to go through these just one more time? Well, I want to, if there's any other discussion, I want to go to the public. I want to come back. Yeah, okay. Right.
5:16:00 I had a couple of comments. I'm okay with the community center and okay with some kind of a safe zone on Canyon Boulevard. The fiscal conservative over here is saying, I think you're making a mistake if we don't include bus shelter, pathway, sidewalks and everything in this version because how long will it be until phase two gets considered? And if you don't connect to this, what have you done? You've made a little parking island. So I think that if you're not including the costs,
5:16:30 Of actually connecting it to something, you're doing what we've done several times over. We'll build this thing, and then someday we'll come back and do the rest. I think you need to cost out the whole thing and bring that back. And if CFD funds can be used there. And that piece would tie potentially to CFD funds. Right. That's my thought. And I think that both, you know, summertime, a path over to Weston would be fantastic, but wintertime, you just cannot have people trying to figure out, now that I've parked here, how do I get there?
5:17:00 Right. With the topography that you're looking at. To the stairs of death. Yeah. Well, I call it the Chill Creek Trail. People want to stay away from those stairs, that's for sure. Oh, I know. They do. But summertime, they don't. Summertime, people are up and down them. I mean, we have issues, talking about safety issues, with parking along hillside. Correct.
5:17:22 In the summertime, and, you know, people are parking erratically, and, you know, it's the forest trail. I mean, they're all over the place. They're everywhere. And, you know, they're not parked, you know, they're parked on angles, and, you know, people are opening doors and hitting people, so it's a problem. So I think, you know, to have a standardized parking area is probably a smart idea. You know, this is part of the original North Village specific plan. This was a parking area.
5:17:51 This is a nodule parking part of- Right. But when it was a structure, it was really obvious you went down through the structure and you just walked across the street. When it was a structure, it was an ice room, too. Oh, yeah. No, I don't think that version ever got through. But I mean, okay, we'll have further discussion. Yeah, so let's go to the public and then I think it makes sense to go through each one. Sure. Any public comment, please? This is actually the agenda item I came to address this evening. My name is Kathy Cage.
5:18:28 I'm mostly here because of the hillside parcel, because when the town got that land, and you mentioned it in your staff report, that was because we did a
5:18:38 Development Agreement with InterWest. And there was extensive discussion by the council that time, and I went back to two other council members that were with me on that council that did that to refresh my memory. But it was always understood that even though we owned the land, if any parking was developed on that, it would be covered by the commercial interests in the village who didn't have to develop any parking. It's the only place in our town we ever allowed commercial to be developed with no corresponding parking.
5:19:07 So my concern is, and what I'd like to see if there's a discussion, could be a discussion about Council, is at least for the portion that's about Hillside, could we, I don't know if it's we target that money from the CFD from North Village to that development or something, or have a discussion about how if the town fronts the money to develop that parking, we can talk about a chargeback mechanism so that the commercial space in North Village who benefits,
5:19:36 That clear nexus there could be the people who pay for it, even though we're potentially fronting the money. And I don't know how you guys could have a discussion about that without being conflicted out, because it's commercial space and you've got triple net leases, but I don't know how that works. So that's my request, is can there be some discussion about how we do a chargeback for the cost of developing that particular parking so that it honors the commitments that were made when the North Village Development Agreement and the plan was done? Thank you.
5:20:05 Dan, could you address that? Yeah, we can address that. We've actually done a fair amount of review of the North Village Plan and the DA agreement, and we've met with a number of the owners up there, the tenants as well. The DA agreement, as it ended up, I don't know the history, but as it ended up, the language in there speaks to the fact that the dedication of the land meets their requirement for parking. They're not required to pay anything else for parking.
5:20:31 So there's no legal obligation that we could go back to the tenants and say pay for parking. That's absolutely not what the public discussion was. It's the only reason we did that. I've heard the same comment, but that's not the language in the DA. I understand that. So that's the challenge we ran into there. The other thing on that it references that the town may, at its sole discretion, put parking on that.
5:20:57 Or public purposes defined as either affordable housing or parking. So those are the kind of the two specific items called out when it mentions public purpose in general. But it wasn't required that the town put parking on that lot either. We thought perhaps it'd be a great spot for a park or something. So when we went through that, there's not a...
5:21:18 Legal obligation for the town to put parking there. There's no way for us to go back to the tenants and under the DA and say, you will pay for parking there. So it's one of these. Not potentially the DA, but there are other mechanisms we have. You know, we do road improvements like up on. Right, but I mean, to force them to do that underneath that current development agreement would be, at least the initial review we've done is very problematic to have them pay for the parking.
5:21:45 It freezes things in place and does a number of other elements that was hard to go back to the owners and say, chip in for parking.
5:21:53 Well, it's very difficult to see this happen because it's the only place I've ever seen the town council use public funds, general fund monies that so specifically benefit private development in that way and in a way that was never intended. This is kind of a classic like redevelopment type of expenditure which is, you know, as you're saying, we're in such a budget crisis in other areas. It's totally hard to defend that you're not exploring ways to try to charge back to the commercial districts.
5:22:23 Or don't do it. You know, honestly, who is hurt if we don't do this parking? Oh, it's the commercial interests. It's not the residential people saying, gee, we don't have enough spaces for our friends to come to visit us when we stay in Mammoth in those units in the village. It's really the commercial interests that are most concerned with not having adequate parking up there.
5:22:42 And so it just troubles me and troubles lots of people in this town that you're specifically developing this thing to benefit those particular commercial interests who developed at a much lower cost rate. I mean, you can see what a cost of parking space is. That's why they didn't want to do it. And as the staff report indicated, we were trying to see if maybe a transportation system here could work as effectively as it did in Whistler, and I think we all accept it's just not going to happen here.
5:23:11 It seems appalling to use our limited general fund monies in this way to so specifically benefit development that knew it was underdeveloped anyway. And it's just, you know, I just, so it sounds like maybe there's no interest, if there's no interest on council of having a discussion about finding a way to charge back the commercial interest, I think that's a real shame. Kathy, I just got a quick comment. What bothers me was
5:23:40 Poor decisions made by prior council to build that development without building adequate parking. So this council and many other councils since then have been left basically with a serious crisis and problem for guests having nowhere to park. So it's kind of short-sighted, I think, to say that it just benefits the commercial tenants.
5:24:03 There's events. There's all kinds of stuff that happened. There's tons of animation in that village, and it was designed to do that. There's a portal of a gondola going to the ski lodge out of that village. So the parking need is much greater than, I think, what you're stating. And, again, I said it earlier, as Dan's gone through cleanup and financial things, Council's continually left cleaning up things, items that should have been dressed.
5:24:33 A long time ago. And I think that it takes good leadership from this council to finally say, we need to move this forward and fix this problem that was dumped on our hands. We didn't create the problem. This council certainly hasn't created this problem. We're trying to solve the problem. And the problem needs to be solved. And this is not going to solve 100% of the North Village parking by any means. But it will get us much more than what we have today. And I think as we go forward and there's other developments coming forward, I don't think
5:25:02 This council or another council or another council down the road will let that type of development be built without parking. So that's my personal opinion on it. Okay. Thank you. Any other comments? Okay. Bring it back to council for further discussion. So we're going to go through each one? Sure. Community center. Three spaces, 15 grand. We'll take it. I would support that personally. Yeah. I'm good with that. Okay. I'm good with that as well.
5:25:34 The Hillside Drive, West. No, wait. Oh, I was just going to think. I thought we were just going to go to the three that were recommended. No, I think we should go to each one. Oh, each one? Okay. Yeah. I just thought I'd go down this list here. West side, okay. West side, which is adding seven spaces recommended. I'm okay with the staff recommendation to not do that. Me too. And Grady, I'm hearing you correctly to say that you may come back to us with some sort of lower cost option there.
5:26:03 Yeah, that's correct. As of today, seven spaces for $180,000 not recommended. Correct. We may have something in the future that might be different. Correct. Okay. I'm comfortable with not recommending to do that. Okay. Same here. All right. Since on that, Canyon Boulevard, limited time. I'm not comfortable with going for this unless you get some safety analysis and see what's going on. I think you have to do a, yeah, safety analysis is great, but I think you have to look at a 45-degree angle. Come back.
5:26:32 With us, you know, what would that be? How many spaces? We lose a space or two of doing that? Yeah. And we can come back in short order with that because it's really a striping issue. The improvement plans are already done. We'll just look at various striping options and come back with it. I think, you know, I'm up there all the time. Those spaces are always filled. There's certainly a need for additional spaces there, but I think it's a very real concern of people backing out into either minaret.
5:26:56 In the future with the CFD are people backing out into Canyon Boulevard. And I think we hope it's more than just, you know, redrawing the lines. I'd like to see what, you know, what a vehicle is going to do. There's actually quite a bit of room there if you take a look. I mean, we've been out there. But I think a 45 degree would be there. But John wants an automation with the little cars backing out. Yeah, I can do that. But you guys can do it. Is that consensus on that okay?
5:27:22 Yes, come back, come back. Well, I say bring it back. Bring it back, yeah. That we're not approving. Yeah, bring it back. Yeah. Hillside lot, phase one. I'm okay with it. I would support it.
5:27:36 I'm okay with it, but I still think it needs to be expanded to include the connectivity that I discussed previously. Can you bring back how that might happen? How it would actually happen. We started in the earlier discussion some options to make sure we could put at least the rest of the sidewalk and the...
5:27:54 Bus shelter and the turnout in there. So we'll come back with some options looking at that. And then we can also look at the walkway if that's a priority. So that's essentially part of the CFD recommendation as well. Well, a piece of that can go there, but we can look at some other options as well. Well, yeah. I would rather see that we finish that than get sidewalk that goes all the way around to burner. And if you could come back with.
5:28:18 Summer and Winter? Yeah. And anticipated maintenance costs for any plow that's going to go with it. Right.
5:28:24 What I'd suggest on those spaces or the bus shelter, excuse me, and turnout on that side of Hillside Drive is if we could, we'd advance the design to 90% and then take a look at it there. We'll have a better cost estimate. We'll know where the CFD is. And the cost of advancing that part of the design is probably about $3,000 in the mix of all this. So I'd suggest doing that. And working with ASTA, possibly? Yeah, there are some other opportunities.
5:28:50 And this, what you're talking about, is for hillside lot phase one, correct? Right. So I need a slight clarification on if the CFD money gets used there, then that does mean that the commercial properties are helping to support the building of this. That's correct.
5:29:07 Right. That's a good point. And regardless of what intent may have been, what got written down, if I understand how you described it, Dan, in the other pieces, is there is no commitment from them, but we have the possibility of a commitment here that would make this work better, and it'd be a partnership. Correct. And that can do the on-road work. It can't be on-road work. Okay. But like a sidewalk and a pullout and... Correct. Bus shelter. Yeah. So then we could partner it.
5:29:33 We can partner within our legal constraints. We can do what we can do. Okay, so there's consensus on this, on Hillside lot? Is everybody else okay with me expanding the cost? Yes, or looking at- Total cost. I didn't say town cost. Okay, CFD improvements. Hillside lot two. Hillside lot two. Oh, sorry. I thought we, yeah. I don't think there's- I'm fine with that. I think we have to see how Hillside-
5:29:58 Lot one works. Yeah. Before we go to lot two. I'm fine with not recommending that. Yeah. Yeah. Thank you. CFD improvements? It'll be nice to know what they are. Yeah. Yeah, we'll have that. I think we will have a refunding element of CFD coming forward probably in either your first or second meeting in July. At that time, if we're ready, we would have.
5:30:22 Here's where these dollars are going. They've got to be pulled out of the regular one and put into a different improvements account. And so we'll have some budget items that are related to the CFD, and we can bring this back and then say, here's the options for spending those dollars. Okay. So basically, I mean, just a basic snapshot is sidewalk pavers as far as money goes, so to speak, starting at burgers. Yeah. Street lights on street park and bus turnout shelter.
5:30:52 I mean, we'll take a look at that shelter on the other side, too. Well, two bus shelters, right? There on Minaret and then up on the hillside. Well, it's essentially two locations of the same thing. Right. Parking, bus turnout. Right. But from a temporary, permanent kind of perspective, given that that property is an escrow with someone who theoretically is going to build something someday, this would be temporary.
5:31:17 No, we're trying to design it because it's the people that... You're trying to integrate it into what the ultimate build-out's going to be. Right. So what's approved now? And what's approved there now? But in that case, does that free up some of the costs of the things that were required at the developer of that one hotel site, whatever it's going to be called in the future? Would they not have had to... Well, this here was already in the CFD, so they could already say, we want that money to be used 100% for our improvements there.
5:31:45 They actually have authority. Which they have. The developer that owns it has said that. They have. So we're going to have to try to anticipate a little bit what they might be doing. So we'll do the best we can. And we've asked them more than once. We don't want to build this twice. So please sign off on what we're doing now. End of the day, it could change. But that'll be all on their dime. Yeah, OK. Not at town's expense. Correct. Well, I think so. Big place is going to get a minaret. That's good. All right. Mm-hmm. Right. OK. Yeah, the forest trail and the burner side could.
5:32:15 There's not much traffic going that way, except everybody who's parking illegally in the community center lot. Right. So are you looking for a motion or just a direction? I think we have clear direction on each of these items. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you. We're going to move on to item...
5:32:31 13, Consider an Adoption of Urgency Ordinance regarding Marijuana Cultivation. Mr. Mayor, before you do, Councilmember Ferney and Jamie have both pointed out that the Council has previously adopted a 10.30 hard deadline for finishing Council meetings. It doesn't seem to be a way to waive it, so you either are going to need to finish this by 10.30 or put off an item until the next meeting. Okay, we're going to try to get done by 10.30. It's 9.40. We have plenty of time. Okay.
5:33:02 Let's make this one fast. Mayor Water Cultivation. We've been working this as an urgency ordinance. We've had requests come forward for certain activities in the community. We don't have regulations in place. And so the idea was working through the ordinance here so we would actually have some regulatory structure as these various requests come in. We have done some outreach to the current cooperative owners. And I believe they're, I'm going to say,
5:33:34 I think Andy and Sandra talked to them, but I think they're on board with the proposals or understand what we're requesting in terms of the type of restrictions that we would be putting in place and requirements that we would have for any type of commercial grows to come into the Town Mammoth Lakes. We did talk to Mr. Calvert the other day, and as of that conversation, I'm not sure he was entirely on board, but he can speak for himself. What this would do is...
5:33:57 Allow commercial grows only in the industrial zone and only with the CUP. It would exempt from that requirement grows that are conducted by one of the two existing licensed cooperatives either in their premises or immediately adjacent to their premises. Mr. Calvert has expressed concern that if he were to try to open a new grow-only site that is off-premises from his cooperative in the industrial zone that he would have to get a CUP. I think he's okay with the CUP and he can speak for himself, but one of the things in here is
5:34:27 That grow operations in the industrial zone as part of the CUP that have to comply with some of the existing requirements that apply to cooperatives. One of those is that it can't be grown for profit. That reflects existing state law. The state law is changing, but it hasn't changed yet. But the state has adopted some legislation that at some point will allow for a licensing structure.
5:34:51 That's what's been adopted so far. Nothing's going to happen with the licensing until probably 2018. There's a bill pending that would allow licensees to be for profit. That hasn't passed yet. It went to the suspense file. We don't know if it's going to come back from that or not. So in a nutshell, this would allow some things that are not currently permitted. It's not taking away any rights that anybody currently has because nobody currently has the right to grow for profit anyway and won't until
5:35:18 In 2018 at the earliest, and even that assumes that the currently stalled legislation passes. So that's kind of what this would do. It's just intended to give us a way of dealing with people that come in and make the request to have commercial grow operations. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. I don't know if Mr. Calvert or anybody else in the audience has anything to say, but they might. Andy, you have a quick question. So in event someone would, Mr. Calvert,
5:35:44 Would relocate his existing business to a new location and do what he's doing now plus adding the grow? How does that work? If one of the two existing cooperatives moves to a new location, they can continue to grow either in their space or right next to their space without having to get a CUP. This only applies if somebody who's unaffiliated with one of the two cooperatives wants to grow or if a cooperative wants to grow off-site.
5:36:12 What is CUP? Conditional Use Permit. Okay. How many initiatives are on the November ballot associated with marijuana? I'm not sure how many have been circulating. It's looking like the one that's most likely to pass is what's called the Parker Newsom Initiative, which would broadly decriminalize marijuana. It would allow it for recreational use, essentially. That one appears to be the one.
5:36:36 So I think that this ordinance should be seen as something that helps us get through the next several months and then if
5:37:05 If, as is expected, the voters decide to make it recreationally okay statewide, I think the Council is going to want to have some further conversations about what to do at that point. Probably a lot of community dialogue. So I don't think this ends the Council's discussion of marijuana at all. I just want to make sure that, you know, as we're done with the plastic bag thing, we're kind of lining ourselves up with what we know in a way that we're not, you know, getting out of the dock sideways with things. I'm also...
5:37:34 I remember sitting in this chamber as this was all brought forward several years ago. And again, in a previous council, I think there was kind of a missed opportunity about being able to derive some revenue for the community from the appropriate uses of marijuana as defined in the law. And I think we need to, if this whole thing is going to move forward, I think there could be questions. My understanding is what's in the initiative.
5:37:59 That will be in the voters statewide. There's some revenue components to that, and I think we're going to have to look at that when we get to that. And is there only one, you think it's only one of these initiatives that's going to get on the ballot? I think that's what's going to happen, because I think that the people who are backing all the initiatives recognize that if they really do submit multiple ones to the voters, it's going to cause confusion, and it'll be less likely that they pass. So eventually the others are going to fall aside. Probably Parker Newsom is the one that'll make it on. Thank you.
5:38:28 One other quick question. What's the downside or what downside is there to this potential downside? Well, this would prohibit some things that some people would like to do that are not currently specifically allowed or specifically permitted by the code. That's the only real downside that I see. Okay. Any other questions for staff?
5:38:56 Meaning that they'd have to get a use permit and there's a possibility that that might not be approved? Right. And there are some requirements that would go with the use permit. Among them, the for-profit grows, which is, of course, not allowed under state law anyway. And some security and operational criteria that would be imposed as part of the CUP that the chief thinks makes sense that we already apply to the two cooperatives. Chief, curious on your input and thought on this.
5:39:26 We had several people coming forward wanting to start grows. And part of the allowance of that in the current ordinance, it has to be approved by the chief. So that started us looking, myself and Sandra and Andy, at our current ordinance. And nowhere in there does it talk anything about commercial grows. A couple of the locations we were looking at or people were looking at were commercial areas, but they were within 500 feet of the schools. And there was nothing in there that prevented.
5:39:53 So by looking forward with that, we decided we need to make some kind of ordinance here to at least tie it to a certain area, keep it away from the schools, because there was nothing that discussed it directly. So if we move forward and have it just in the industrial area, it's an area we can control and also add on the security things that we do with the current two locations and have a higher level of security than just basic what's normally in the industrial area.
5:40:20 And really, I think the way to think of it is that our current code, because it doesn't specifically allow grows, it implicitly prohibits them, but it's not as clear as it could be. And so by adopting this, you establish a structure and a framework for staff to use and for applicants to look at and understand. So instead of kind of an implicit, complete ban, it's, well, there's a way to do it. And there's some rules that we can follow that everyone will know what they are and staff knows and the applicants know.
5:40:48 It's a way of providing structure where right now there's just kind of nothing. Okay. Public comment? Good evening, Councilor. I'm Robert Calvert. Good evening. So I just want to say thank you to everybody in Town Council, the Planning Commission, the staff, the chief. One thing that I feel very strongly about is that I am really working to be compliant as the chief can stand behind. We work openly. Everything we do is above board.
5:41:24 I think there's a lot of curiosity. There's a lot of confusion about the medical cannabis industry. There's a lot of excitement. The locomotive is moving, and it's a very exciting time in our industry. So in response to what Andy was saying, I've digested what we talked about the other day. I was on the phone with Andy and Sandra, and I'm on board with everything you're talking about. And as you mentioned, this is not the first time we're going to be here. It's not the last time.
5:41:54 Many things are going to be coming, that are going to be passed by state law that are going to require us to meet and really talk about how it impacts our community. I want this to be a positive thing for our community. And the five and a half years that we've been in business, I think when we were initially offering the permits, there was this possible fear that there was this dust storm going to be going down Main Street. And really the only problems that we've had is twice last year, there was a couple knuckleheads that tried to break in, young,
5:42:24 Locals, and we nabbed them. And besides that, there's also been some other things in the luxury outlet mall that our camera system has that we've caught people. So we've been a benefit to the community. And if you come into the collective and just watched one day, you would really get a really good understanding of what it is that we do.
5:42:51 And I'd say a great majority of the patients that come in are truly getting cannabis for the true medical benefits of it. And it goes back to what Chief and I talked about a while back is education. And I think the more education, the more you educate yourself, the more you learn about the cannabis industry. I live it every day. My father grew up with five sons and was anti-cannabis. And now he's in the cannabis industry and he's full bore.
5:43:20 He educated himself. And so I'm living a real experience. So bottom line, I support what you're doing. And that's it. Let's keep it short. Thank you very much. And thank you to all the staff. And I have to say thanks to Robert for having questions and contacting us about him. He gave us a chance to work through things before the meeting. So he's really participated in the process, which we appreciate. Mayor and Council, my name is Don Wright.
5:43:54 I run the other shop in town. Going through all this, it's kind of a lot to take in. You know, the new laws, I got markers and stuff all over the place. But one thing that it points out in there is if you start running a cultivation site under local jurisdiction and your locals are okay with it, when 2018 comes around, then
5:44:20 You're allowed to go get your cultivation license from the Department of Agriculture or Food and Agriculture. And what's going to happen is not only do you get that license, you also get a pick from two licenses out of like 17. Like some, there's a lot. So you can start cultivating and you can start cultivating and manufacturing either solvents or vital solvents or non-vital solvents, which is basically
5:44:48 Making cannabis oil out of butane or CO2 or alcohol or other stuff. It also says in there, as far as manufacturing, you could start making edibles. So there's a lot to take in. If you grant this, you know, was it UAC? Conditional use permit. Yeah, okay. Conditional use permit. Then you're kind of like opening a door for
5:45:18 People to start manufacturing cannabis products in the town. And, you know, that's fine if that's what you want to do. I would like to point out a couple other things here. The smallest grow operation that the state license is going to offer is a type 1A specialty indoor. It goes up, you know, no less or equal to 5,000 square feet. 5,000 square feet is pretty big. I don't even think we have something here in Mammoth that's 5,000 square feet.
5:45:46 But that's the smallest one they have. When I think of 5,000 square feet, I'm going to think of, you know, 50 by 100 feet. And how many trays of, you know, marijuana plants can I put in there? I could do, you know, 4 by 8 trays. That's 32 square feet. You throw 32 square feet, divide it by the 5,000, you got 156 trays of marijuana. Put two lights under each tray. That's 312 lights.
5:46:16 And each light, you could probably yield about two pounds off each light. Now you're looking at, what did I say, 312? You're looking at 624 pounds of marijuana being grown down there. And I just, where does it all go? You know what I sell in three months? 24 pounds. And you're going to start growing 624 pounds of marijuana down in the industrial park? I mean, if we have a space that big.
5:46:45 But I'm just, you know, I grew up here, went to high school, was born and raised, and I'm just, I don't think that we need to be exporting cannabis out of Mammoth because it's not going to be consumed in here. It's just way too much. That's all. Thank you. Anybody else? Okay, seeing none, bring it back to Council. Any other discussion and or motion, please? You know, I think this is an area where I feel, you know,
5:47:17 Not sufficiently educated. I think it's a pretty fast-moving industry right now, especially in light of everything that's happened in Colorado, which most of us are familiar with. So I'm very intrigued to see how things are going to go at the state level. That's obviously going to impact our policy here locally. I guess my only concern is just making sure that we're not making decisions right now that are going to be in conflict with future decisions.
5:47:45 And precluding ourselves from doing anything with that. So, you know, I appreciate that we have the experts in the room that are engaged in this process. That's very helpful for me and for the council. So, you know, if I'm hearing a comfort level from our existing co-ops, if I'm hearing from you, Andy, that this is just kind of essentially a band-aid in the short run until...
5:48:07 You know, further discussion will need to be had once state-level legislation comes through. I suppose I'm comfortable, but it's just an area that I feel is very fast-moving. I want to make sure that we're on top of it. You know, Mr. Wright made a good point, actually a very perceptive point, that the state legislation that passed last year would allow groves that are consistent with local zoning to get state licenses. The thing about that legislation, though, is it's all geared to the current medical marijuana system.
5:48:37 And I think that if the initiative passes that fully recreationally legalizes it, I suspect that the existing legislation will either be amended or that the medical licensing system may end up still being on the books but may not be used as much because people will then be able to grow without calling it medical. So it's a fair point. It's a good point. I think ultimately, though, I don't think there's that much risk that this is going to open the door to a million future licensees in town.
5:49:06 No, I don't think it's going to. And then the Planning Commission will be able, through the use permit process, to control that. Yeah, that's absolutely right, because nobody is entitled to get a CUP. It's discretionary in the part of the Planning Commission. Okay. Do you have something else to add? I've already closed public comment. Oh. If you have something, go ahead. I lost it, but I did have something. What up? Oh, yeah, who's going to regulate it? Like, locally.
5:49:46 I mean, for instance, you start growing a bunch of weed down there, and I mean, how many plants are we growing? Like, you know, because we don't know the size of the place, but like, who's going to go down there and regulate it and make sure that all the plants are there throughout the whole three-month cycle of them flowering? And, you know, who's going to be down there, like, making sure that all of it goes into batches and it's not going on the black market?
5:50:16 I think, yeah, I think it's real easy to say that a plant died and a pound of weed disappeared. So I'm just going to regulate it. Appreciate it. Council, what's the pleasure of Council? I'll make a motion that we introduce, read by title only, and adopt the urgency ordinance attached as attachment one entitled an urgency ordinance of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, amending the Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code regarding marijuana cultivation.
5:50:48 Second. Okay, I have a motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. Dan, we are. Yeah, Mr. Mayor, if I may, if I could take 15 out of order, I think it'll go very quick. Yeah. And then come back. If we could take item 15 first. Sure. And then come back to the budget item. Yeah, let's do that. Okay, we'll move on to item 15, authorize the town manager to sign consultant agreements for up to $125,000 for.
5:51:18 National Environmental Policy Act and California Environmental Equality Act work within the Sherwin's recreational planning area designated area. Thank you. The item here has been some ongoing discussion with the Forest Service and we're looking at how do we move some environmental work forward this summer. One of the elements that came up in terms of whether the town or the Forest Service could hire some consultants in a more expedited manner.
5:51:46 We're asking for here's authority to enter into agreements. Right now we have a limit to $50,000 that the manager can enter into. If the funds are budgeted, we're not asking for any additional funding at this point. These funds are allocated to the trails element.
5:52:01 But it would allow us to sign a larger agreement if we're the ones that actually end up doing the agreement for the consulting work. There would still be a fair amount of coordination with the Forest Service, obviously overseeing, and we'd have a contact person there, et cetera. Ultimately, it's their property, so there is a certain level of authority they'll have over that. The goal here was to try to create some flexibility so that we don't miss a season of some of the NEPA and CEQA work that can be done this summer.
5:52:31 Okay. I would just anticipate that this could be, that this is a, not to exceed, it's not going to be anywhere near about this amount of money. That's a four up to. Yeah, exactly. And what Dan said is that if we don't do this, we're going to miss a season. Right. And this is already six years in the making. And I was going to say, this is the measure, our money, that's been allocated in a holding pattern for quite some time. Yeah, it's sitting in an agreement. Correct. Okay. Questions? No questions for me. Public?
5:53:01 No questions? We're here to make a motion. We're missing a council member. Is there a problem if there's no council? We're missing a council member here? No. Go ahead. No? Okay. So I would move that we authorize the town manager to sign consultant agreements for up to $125,000 for NEPA, single work within the designated area. Second. Motion and a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0.
5:53:33 Mr. Mayor, can I suggest on the next one, since a lot of this we've seen before is, and in the interest of time, is we just go to the budget balancing options? Sure. I was going to suggest I jump down through this pretty quick. Yeah, jump, not even, you know, because somebody had a question, but we've seen it. What page are you on? So this is page two of the staff report, if you will. Is there any questions on the revenue projections? That's my only. Right.
5:53:57 I wasn't going to walk through them at this point. I was going to ask you, so the question between the revenues and the departments here, we have a $204,000 budget gap. If there's a question on the chart on page two, the revenues are up on the screen, and then the... Dan, can I just read this item for the public? Oh, I'm sorry, yes. Item 14 is a presentation of tentative fiscal year 2016-17 budget information and requested council direction for budget balancing. Correct. Okay.
5:54:25 Go ahead. So we provided a summary of the general fund where we're at to date. Page two of the staff report has the revenue and expenditure, and it shows the transfers in detail there. In the interest of time, I'm not going to walk through those, but I did. If there's a particular question on a revenue line item or a departmental budget item, I wanted to be able to answer those questions. The only one I had on the revenue item is property taxed.
5:54:50 We see that going from 3,288 up to 3,429. That's a trend that you feel comfortable with? Yeah, in fact, it was based on the most recent numbers we got from Mono County. Okay. So we actually projected a little lower originally, but they went up about $100,000 based on the information we received. Okay. On page three, there's some just detail and percentages stuff here. We won't spend a lot of time on that, obviously, but it gives you the idea here was a fill for the areas in the budget that you could deal with.
5:55:23 What we wanted to really get direction on is working through for a final budget. It's looking at balancing the budget. One more? Yep. One more. You can see that. We took a look at initially where we're at in our personnel cost, and very traditional, you take a look, first of all, what are your vacancies? If you don't have any or you need to reduce, mainly because personnel is a large piece of the budget, if you're going to cut sizable dollars, it's going to impact that. So we've got the current vacant positions listed there.
5:55:54 There's some of these that I believe would just be my perspective off the table, which would be the finance director and the police officer. They're problematic. The other two that probably have the most significant impact operationally would be the assistant planner and the equipment mechanic. The two areas that we would recommend for consideration is a modification in the HR director. It's not elimination, that position, but it is backfilling with the lower level position and providing additional support for HR.
5:56:21 Ultimately from the finance director, but also from some current staff as well. The other one is the revenue specialist. We currently have three employees that are dedicated to revenue collections, our TOT, TBID, and business licensing. We've downgraded a previous position there and actually have done an internal recruitment to do one promotion up, so kind of give a lead to that team. So that would leave one of the revenue specialists vacant. That's the 71,000 that's noted in the report.
5:56:50 If you take those couple of items that changes there, it's about $152,000 worth of salary savings. And then we've gone through a lot of discussion on how to cut another $50,000 out of the budget. Bottom line is you have $50,000 in there. I put it in there for contingency. You could just say we'll live with zero contingency and anything we want to spend over and above. If it's not in a budget item, be it $500 for a meeting to...
5:57:18 $10,000 for something that breaks, it would need to come back to you, so it becomes a little bit of a cumbersome process at times. Dan, sorry. As far as little trivular expense items, are you talking about a clean enough? Yeah, from a contingency item, like, for example, we redid the information on the windows, town offices, it was like $800. That would come back to council if we don't have a budget item to cover and say, do you want to spend $800 to do that versus maybe a contingency item that we...
5:57:48 Could do a couple of those small things with, we had a refrigerator break down.
5:57:52 Do we not replace it? Do we come back and say, do you want to spend $500 on our refrigerator? I think we're getting into some micromanaging. So I wouldn't suggest it goes to zero, but you could trim a little bit out of contingency. It was 75. We've cut that back. Dan, just to backtrack you a bit, talking about revenue specialists, with the suggested restructuring and changes, that would still leave three people in that department. Yes, three full-time people committed to that. It would be a position we'd want to come back and look at mid-year.
5:58:20 Especially as we move into the business licensing, do we need some part-time help? We're doing a lot of mailing and looking at that. So it's a little bit balancing still that workload. Also, if we can free up their time in how we do collections. We've had discussions. John's still here. We've had some collections with the TOT group. I'm going to do that quarterly for the small folks. Under the town ordinance, we can do the TOT via the town, make that decision.
5:58:49 Bid component of that that would have to come through approval with MLT slash the TBid oversight making that request. It doesn't make sense to collect one piece monthly and one piece quarterly so you'd want to do them together and there's a process we'd have to go through that. We believe that will free up probably at least a third of a position in time because you're not processing all the paper. Otherwise you've got a lot of small
5:59:14 Stuff going through. There are some other challenges. That's something I think we should take a hard look at. Does it make sense? Does it free up staff time? MLT pays about $80,000, $90,000 into the revenue of specialists, right, to help with these collections? Correct. So it's back to the equivalent of a body. Could the T-bid board, whatever it's officially called, a vote to fund another position?
5:59:42 I know they, I know, or do they have a restriction on how much can go to administration? Basically, we're capped at 2% in the management plan, which on a $4 million budget is about $80,000. Okay. We're a little over that, so that's about the cost of a body. Right, so I mean, the thought to cut that, I mean, when you're trying to collect those funds, I mean, well, we can go. Well, I have a question on that, is that with the new system and everything, are we at a point where we're more efficient? We're more efficient, I think, with the,
6:00:12 Possible hire, hopefully, of a finance director. Yeah. I don't think we'll lose anything in the collection effort, frankly, given where we're at and with the team that's in place. The risk you run is if we lose another position, then you're down to two. That will impact it. I think three can continue that. Your other option is you don't have, if you want us to fill a position, we can. I will just, there will be one of these other positions and or a currently filled position. We'd come back and what level of service do we reduce?
6:00:41 And that becomes a challenge. My concern is I just don't want to cut where we're collecting. No, I think it's more efficient, I mean, that's good. You're not eliminating the position. You're just deciding not to fill it at this point in time. This will be still an authorized position, but it will be unfunded. If we wanted to fill it, we'd be back in going, here's an option to fund it. And I think in terms of the comments of
6:01:07 Mrs. Cage, earlier, I mean, one of the, the town is the only body that can collect revenue and do these kinds of things that we're doing. In terms of prioritizing what our staff is doing, the services that we really want to make sure that we do, we provide properly, no one else can do this. We have to be able to do this efficiently and effectively. Right, yeah, and to me, I think it's, well, we're going to talk more about it, but I think it's a focus, and I don't, I want to collect. Yeah, exactly. We have been. And we'll continue those efforts.
6:01:36 If we can leave the position there, if we leave the position there, that's fine, but we'll need to find another $70,000 out of somewhere else in the budget, which most likely would mean another position. For example, if we don't fill the planning position, we will process items that come to the town, but we will have capacity, no additional work. Council has a special project for us to work on. The answer will basically be no, we can't take that on. So I'm good with keeping the position, but...
6:02:05 Probably not funny right now. Right. And we'll come back and look at that. Like I say, the mid-year review of looking at that. If there's an impact on collections, definitely we're going to bring that forward. It doesn't do good to cut dollars and lose dollars. Well, you have to see the impact of the sell and what that's happening. Right. The other elements in there, there's departmental reductions. We can have everybody go back through their budgets. It's back to here's $5,000 here and $3,000 here and $2,500 here. Very normal budget reduction process.
6:02:34 The road rehab element was if you actually dropped that by $80,000, or it would be $50,000 if you wanted to balance the budget out. The commitment to road rehab has been pretty solidly expressed. The idea there, if you did it, either excess dollars would need to come back and repay it, or savings within the department would go back there first. But that's a slippery slope in my mind, because each year you just reduce that amount, assuming that maybe we'll have some savings, and the first year you don't, it's going to be...
6:03:02 How do we add it back in? But then it's a double hit. And then specific program reductions. The staff report walked through some of those as we deal with tennis court maintenance. We deal with trail maintenance. We deal with fixing things in our parks at break. We deal with other things that are kind of nice to have and very key to our community services. But those things can have some reductions and modifications in how they're prioritized and what we
6:03:31 Put limited dollars into. Mr. Mayor, again, I'm looking at the clock. I'm just hoping we can get this done. So the question there would be, there's $152,000 on the table from staffing. There's other dollars. And obviously, you have the option at the end. You could say, use reserves, balance the budget. And I'm not recommending you do that, but that's always an option from that perspective. Dan, one question for you. On page 2.
6:04:01 The transfers out to Public Works, $2.1 million? Correct. That includes snow removal, right? Correct. The total budget in there is a little over $3.5 million for Public Works. About 60% comes from the general fund. And Grady, Dan, whoever, what's our current budget for snow removal? The snow piece, go ahead and pull that up. I can tell you the snow,
6:04:33 The winter road maintenance there, the 1.6 million, that's pretty much everything committed into the winter component of the Public Works Department. So essentially, road rehab's 580, that's summer, 1.6 is snow removal. Yeah, the summer road maintenance above, that's all the other work we do on the roads in the summer. That's our striping program, it's pothole, it's... Taking out stakes, putting stakes back in. Yeah, it's the crack seal.
6:05:01 But the 1-6 is essentially our snow removal budget. Right. So I would, Mr. Mayor, perhaps if we could go through this list at the bottom of page 7 and just go one at a time and see what we can do. Well, I think that we have to start back on page 4 and say which of the staff reductions are we okay with. Excuse me, which of the unfunded positions are we okay with because there's no staff in any of these. Right.
6:05:29 I like the idea of, again, considering a finance admin services director, but we have got to have that position. We have got to have somebody over finance. Say that again? So down in the third paragraph on page four, it talks about actually changing it to finance and administrative services so that that person could take off the top-level HR stuff, and then you have a technician to process paperwork.
6:05:54 In HR. I'm okay. I like that approach. I've done that job. This is a net number. Yeah. Correct. It's a 76 of the net number. I don't think police officer is an option. Right. Personally. I would recommend on the revenue specialist is leaving it vacant, seeing how it's happening. When we first started that unit, it was a challenge. We'll give you the unit if you'll make.
6:06:24 $500,000. And so that can always be considered at some point. I don't know. I don't know. I still, I mean, I know we're trying to get more efficient with the new system and everything, but, you know, I just keep going back to our bread and butter of we're running a town on one thing and one thing only. It's TOT collection. It's, you know, it's, I don't know. I'm just, I got to believe that there's a way that we can
6:06:52 Well, but this is not necessarily collecting it. These are the people that are doing the enforcement that we've been working through, and I think we've... Well, but that's collecting, right? I mean, if they're doing enforcement... Yeah. But, I mean, that's still an extra body than what we used to have. Yeah, it's still... We had four bodies. Correct, but we used to have two. We had four, and now we have three. And the numbers, I mean... You're on that. I'm on the deal. I've been a couple of those meetings. I'm not hearing anything from any... I'm hearing that what we've got going is working. Right.
6:07:21 So that's your assessment when we went from two to four down to three. We lost somebody, but I think the finance director, if we get him on board, will help out. And I think the new system is. Well, the new system, and also we've worked out so many kinks of the processes that weren't correct, and now those are working. Exactly. Well, so I don't hear any support to. Right.
6:07:48 But the position still exists, and if things change, yeah. Well, I mean, look, none of these are good options. So I think what we're saying here is that the HR director position, the revenue specialist position. Are the ones that go away. Okay. Well, that are unfunded. Unfunded, yes. They're still authorized positions that we can come back to. So with that being said, let's maybe go to the public before we continue on and on and on because John wants to say something.
6:08:15 You know, I think the comment from Councilmember Wentworth that the process is being done properly and that it's being, that the feedback is that it's working, that's false. You know, in the meetings, Shields, you hear from Terry and Cheryl and Tom that we aren't doing the compliance effort. We're not going out and bringing in money. We're leaving that money on the table. Well, I'll answer that, John.
6:08:46 I think it's in a lot of people's heads that we went out and made $600,000 or whatever it was one year. And, you know, they're out there doing compliance. I talked to Danny, I talked to Eric, I talked to Jen two, three times a week. And these guys are out there trying to collect money. It's not an easy deal. Our costs to do this and what we're collecting is actually more than what we're bringing in.
6:09:16 Going out and getting those guys. It takes a long, long time for those guys to, if they're going to pay up, you know, and the only way they're going to pay up is, you know, they've gotten very smart. And they go out there and, you know, if they get an attorney involved, you know, we're going to be SOL, quite honestly. I think, though, if you ask the committee if this was being productive, it's not.
6:09:43 I think the feedback has been very clear from the committee, from the lodging association, that the efforts aren't, they're not focused, because we have three people that are focused on collecting TBID, making sure people have business licenses, making sure that they're collecting TOT, and the compliance effort has really taken a back seat, so there are a few things we're missing out on the revenue that may be a long time coming, but we're still missing out on the revenue, and
6:10:07 We're allowing illegal rentals that just continue on. To my knowledge, to my knowledge, John, they follow up on every lead that they get. Okay. And they have sting operations going on. And I think the lodging community could be very helpful. They've offered. They've offered every single meeting. Whatever assistance you need. Well, I know they have.
6:10:32 What they need to offer is bringing forth those people that they know are illegally renting. They are. And they're willing to do more of it. And I think that the challenge is that, you know, you can't cut your way to prosperity and taking out the people that are collecting the funds and making sure that people are, you know, I look at the revenue team, I look at Eric and Jenny and Danny and what they're doing, and, you know, they're finding people that don't have business licenses, haven't had them for years, and they're getting them on board.
6:10:57 But I think the problem is that there's just so much going on there, so much opportunity from a revenue standpoint that we're missing the boat on it. And I think that it's a wrong thing to do to take the revenue side out of it. I think cutting a revenue-generated position is tough. You know, John, this is just my personal opinion. I think the revenue side, the way the collection goes, because it's their word against ours. There's no support. There's no backup.
6:11:25 That we can go after. Quite honestly, it's their word against ours. Well, we've done it successfully. I mean, we've had a number of people that we've gone after for hundreds of thousands of dollars. Sometimes we catch them. But other times, you know, they get off and say, I'm not going to do it again. But I can guarantee you, if we don't have people focused on it, we're not going to catch anything. I know we have a time. I understand. Yeah, so it's still an issue. It's a critical position.
6:11:49 We're not saying that, but when you get down to it, it may not be as critical as everything else we have to consider. And it's still there. It could still be refunded if there's a plan of how it might work better, be more efficient, which is one of the things that a finance admin services director could do. They're used to doing collections. Yeah, I'm also interested in seeing how finance director, Cassell, I mean, look, we're dealing with degrees on all these things.
6:12:19 And I think that let's bring this together. Let's see what we got. And I think I just, again, I've been to a couple of meetings. No one's come to me and said, look, we've got a big crisis with this stuff. I'm sharing what you're hearing. That's what I'm seeing. Grady, can I ask you a follow-up question? On a snow removal budget, what would a $50,000 or $70,000 reduction do to our service levels?
6:12:45 You know, the issue with that is it's so variable depending on the season. We really have no idea. And I just can't give a better answer than that because if it was last year, we were well under the snow management budget. I mean, well under it. And this year we were a lot closer. And a $50,000 difference.
6:13:05 Doesn't make that much difference because it's so variable. In terms of the level of service, it'd be a matter of, as an example, we'd go through it in February or early March, we'd find out, gee, we're close to budget. At that point, we can't lay anybody off.
6:13:18 Because, you know, they're there already. At that point, we can't change equipment and things like that. That's why one of the suggestions that we made in this is really to look at road rehab instead, because we can control a certain amount of that. Now, I absolutely agree with the comments from Council that road rehab should be a million dollars or a million one a year. But this Council showed in the review of the excess revenue or the one-time revenue this year that you were willing.
6:13:43 And knowledgeable that that's where it had to go and put $900,000 back into it. That's one of the reasons we made that suggestion. And on snow removal, don't we have the problem of the 50% reimbursement? So for every dollar you cut, you're really cutting $1.50? Because you're losing the revenue coming back? The reason I bring this up and I suggest this to Council, and this is a conversation we've had in the past, I think we are so far and above our peer resorts in terms of our snow removal that
6:14:08 I could see that we could have a reduction in service of a certain level and still be providing very, very good snow removal. And I think that's just a more global perspective that I've looked at. I mean, when we compare what we're doing on that front to any of our peer resorts, it's so far surpassing them. And is that only, is that really? And I can't say that specifically from a budget standpoint. I don't know what steamboats.
6:14:37 You know, snow removal budget is, but I can just tell you the work on the ground from our snow removal crews is so far superior to any of our peer resorts. I'm just wondering if there's a little wiggle room there. When you bring back the actual budget, can we have some of that comparison information? Well, we can bring back what... They don't have to deal with Southern California drivers who don't know how to drive. We understood, but we actually, we have some issues here sometimes where when you shear snow all the way down to the...
6:15:04 Pavement level, that creates slicker and more problematic icy conditions than actually leaving a little bit of layer of snow, which is the model that most Colorado resorts use as far as their snow removal. They shear it down to a six-inch level where you can actually get some grip on the tires. And I see that that actually creates a problem sometimes. If we're not getting down to clear, dry pavement, but we're shearing snow all the way down to create that icy, when the temperature changes,
6:15:33 Can be problematic. If I may on that, ideally, we could cut one part-time position that's $25,000. However, as we get phone calls that says, when are you going to come get my street? When are we going to go do this sidewalk? When are we going to go the level of service that people are expecting and are used to? The answer is going to, we will see you tomorrow or the following day, or if it's a series of storms, you won't see us.
6:15:58 As long as we're willing to tell. I just don't think that's realistic. Has that ever been the case that we've said we're not going to do any snow removal for 24 hours? Yes. We have many like in a sidewalk area or other areas of that nature. Yeah, we have pushed that out. I mean, that's not my question. I understand that we might not have addressed a sidewalk in a 24-hour period.
6:16:18 I understand what you're saying from the level of standards that we provide are higher than other communities. But I'm just saying you will get calls and complaints. That's a mammoth blinders perspective. That's all I'm saying. Yeah. I'm just saying. Can we get through the last of these? Yeah, we've got five minutes. Snow removal is going to come back. On page seven, I kind of agree with what Shields was heading. We have to have some kind of a reduction in contingency.
6:16:45 Maybe leave $15,000 or $20,000 there so that it's not no contingency at all. I would consider taking these items $50,000, $50,000, $80,000, $25,000, cutting them in half and making the balance of better reserves. Well, what I can do, and if we only need $200,000 there, so if you take the contingency and departmental reduction, there's $100,000 there. We cut that by half. That would balance out the budget along with the staff reductions.
6:17:12 Right, yeah, I'm not sure of taking anything out of reserves. No, I don't want to take it, you don't. Again, that's using one-time money for ongoing operations. Right. Four minutes. I'm sorry, go over that again. So. Staff reduction's up to 152. Right. Contingency up to 25. Up to 25, and then another. Mental up to 25. Okay. Yeah. Or we'll balance it between the two of those, we'll balance out 50. Okay.
6:17:36 And then I mentioned some to you earlier today. We got a bill yesterday for our insurance that will push additional dollars in there, which has additional hit. We'll work through that out of as we come up with the budget coming back to you. We have a little more snow removal dollars and a couple things coming to offset that.
6:17:56 Last analysis is about 100,000 we were looking at again, so there will be some additional adjustments we're going to need to make based on us. But under this current scenario, then it's not cutting road rehab and not cutting those programs? Correct, correct. We would work out of that other 100 to balance out. So the bottom three, the 80, the 25, and the 204 are untouched.
6:18:15 We take the full 152, 350 that's being suggested, and instead of taking 50 out of either line item 2 or 3, you take 50 out of a combination of 2 and 3. Plus dealing with this other bill. Take 30 out of contingency. Right. Between the two, you get 50. You hit it. That's your plug number. Right. Yeah, whatever's the leftover is what we're left for. So you have $4.37 in contingency. No, no, no.
6:18:40 I know. Yeah. Oh, we get that, so. Excuse me, man. If I could mention one thing, and I'll be very quick on the snow removal issue. I'm not as concerned with if we need to lower that budget slightly for this reason. If we lower it and we need more, that means it snowed more. That means it's likely that we're trending up on TOT. Right. I can't relate it to precisely how many hours, but if we go over that budget.
6:19:07 Chances are we got a lot of snow. That means we have more people in town. So that's one way to look at that. I just think, you know, maybe if we could have something brought back on that, just some direction from staff, that's something that I've felt for a while. I've made that comment before. I just think when we're talking these really difficult reductions here, it's something that it should at least be on the table for discussion. Sure. All right. Okay.
6:19:31 Yeah, so given that direction, we'll work to preparing, will hopefully be a final budget for June 1. All right. I need 20 seconds at the last minute. So you will be contacting us all at some point tomorrow with hopefully an outcome on the election. Yes. I'll see an email come through. But highly unlikely that we're going to have a special meeting. A few of us are going to be out of town. Right. Okay. Okay. We made it. It's 10.
6:19:59 29. I got 28. We got two minutes. Oh, you want to stay long? We will adjourn to our next scheduled meeting held on Wednesday, June 1, 2016.