TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2016

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 9 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

302 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:26 And they pick up a lot, so. So do you just keep it off until you want to talk? No, you can just leave it on. Right? Do you not feel like you need to talk into it? No, it's really, it's way better than it used to be. Great! Alright, if you guys are... Alright, are you guys ready? Yes. Okay. Stay warm, are you guys ready? Morning!

4:00 Good morning. I will hereby call to order this regular meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission for Tuesday, August 2, 2016. We will begin with the Town Clerk administering the oath of office to our new Commissioner. I, Christy Osborne, do solemnly swear to support and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California against all enemies.

4:35 And I will well and faithfully

5:05 Faithfully. Discharge the duties. Discharge the duties. Upon which I am about to enter. Upon which I am about to enter. You're welcome. Thank you. You're welcome. Bill Sauser used to say that we should probably make everyone put their hand on the Parks and Rec master plan when they take it. That's awesome. That's great. All right. So now we can have a roll call, please, Jamie. Ms. Chair Moore. Here. Ms. Chair Mayhem. Here. Ms. Chair Oswald. Here. Ms. Chair Turner. Hello. Chair Truitt. Here. Thank you.

5:39 Okay, at this time I will open the floor for public comments. This is the time when anyone wishing to speak on any item not on today's agenda may do so. What? No one's approaching? No? Any public comments from the commission? Yes, I do. Just a question. Fireman's picnic was great, as always. I heard some comments, though. How come our bathrooms were locked? I know there were porta-potties that were there, but the bathrooms for Shady Rest Park were locked for that day.

6:10 Just the lower ones, the two older ones. The two older ones, when they get well used, like the fireman's picnic, they seem to have some issues just because they are older. Okay. And the fireman's actually are the ones that go in there and lock that up, and then they maintain the porta-potties that are there. So it was the fireman themselves who locked it up? Exactly. Interesting. Okay. They say it's, from years past of them being able to do it, they say it's much easier to take care of and maintain instead of people going in there.

6:37 Fair enough. I just would like then that I want to make that in the public comment that you're saying that the fireman requested it to be closed. That's probably not a bad idea, but just good to know that that's the story. Okay. I think I mentioned last time, I can't remember, but I was interested to see that the Inyo Forest is doing surveys right now on part of their five-year plan. And I was riding up in Lakes Basin and, you know, they had the...

7:04 Survey sign out. And then I noticed that they were down here in front of our welcome center. I'd be curious to, and I asked them more questions than he asked me, actually, was just, you know, how often they do the survey for Inyo Forest. And apparently it's every five years and that it's part of, and obviously this is a key time as part as.

7:27 As far as just inquiring about uses and that kind of thing. I'd love for us to be able to see the raw results of those kind of surveys. Is that possible? You can only ask. That's why I've asked here. Thank you very much, Stu. And then finally, I just want to say it's been a great summer so far as far as recreation goes. And that shameless plug, I know that Palooza Palooza is this weekend. Talk about recreation, though. It is going to be a great event this coming weekend.

7:55 Very, very new. We are closing the road of Minaret there between Meridian and...

8:03 Main Street. But a couple things that are new this year, and one specifically that pertains, and we're going to the shameless plug about what is new with the event, but that we are doing shuttles up and down Minaret, you know, from Sam's Woodside up to Main Street. In previous years, everyone has to walk that hill, which, you know, isn't that far, but you are at 8,000 feet, maybe have a beer or two in you. That it is a bit of a walk, but this year we've got a shuttle, which is, I think, going to make it much better for all participants.

8:32 And that's it for my public comments. I have a question for you, Sean. Yes. Is there a bike parking area? There is, yeah, there's two bike parking areas on the north and the south side of the entrance. Cool. Thanks for asking.

8:50 And thanks to our staff and MLR staff who I believe will be also helping out with parking. Thanks to the entire town of Mammoth Lakes and I mean not just town staff but all the vendors, all the volunteers. Thank you very much for letting me say that because, you know, there's 7,500 people in this town and several hundred of us who I think are very active and engaged in various non-profits and community service.

9:15 And those are the ones that I just are really stepping up to the plate to make this. The event could not happen without everyone coming together as a town. So thank you for letting me say that too. Great. Awesome. Any other public comments? Then I will close public comments. We'll move on to the consent agenda. Is there any item anyone wishes to poll? I have the minutes from the last regular meeting and the monthly Parks and Recreation Department report. Anything staff wishes to poll?

9:51 I would entertain a motion. I will move that we accept the consent agenda. I have a motion. Is there a second? I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Okay. All in favor of accepting items number two and three on the consent agenda, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Motion passes 5-0. Okay. And that brings us to item number four, our presentation. This is the presentation of the 2016-2021 Mammoth Lakes Recreation Nonprofit Strategic Plan.

10:22 Thank you very much to Rich Bacha for being here. Hey!

11:09 All right, so I'm going to walk through a few pages. I'm going to make this as fairly painless as possible. Two of 32, there are 32 pages in the future right now. I'll probably roll a bit more by the two pages, et cetera. But two of 32, these are now on the table of contents. Three of 32, I'm not going to reach out to you. But the executive summary really summarizes the purpose of this document. It gives us an idea of what we're doing, where we're going, and what we need to do to get there.

11:37 At the end of the day, Sean Duce that it takes all of us all in the same direction, pulling at it and make the gains that we will attend in a great place called Mammoth. Code of 4 of 32 talks about our mission to train to form Mammoth Lakes into the world-class high altitude training center, premier mountain arts and local destination, and the best alpine recreation community in the country. Our mission, to deliver cutting-edge sustainable recreation, mobility, arts, and culture opportunities and infrastructure for the benefit of the community and natural environment in Mammoth.

12:07 That's who we are. That's who we are. Page 5 is your organizational overview. Page 6 is your organizational background. You start digging on page 7, sustainable recreation. Outdoor recreation is a critical sector of the American economy, contributing $646 billion in annual direct spending nationwide, contributing significantly to other sectors such as manufacturing, retail, trade, tourism, and travel. In California alone, outdoor recreation generates

12:36 $85 billion in consumer spending and creates 732 direct jobs. It's a big industry. How do we even maximize it at this point in time? I go on to page 832. This is our ethical mandate. This is who we are. Following life, following benefits, sustainability, and leadership. That's our ethical mandate in the world of record. I go on to page 932.

13:04 Let's talk about guiding and encouraging, five steps of cooperation, innovation, design, reform, promote, and build valuable opportunity for community stakeholders. I need to build upon it, because recreation is about advocating. How do we encourage, how do we guide, how do we provide support services to this community and beyond, regional state nationwide, to really advocate for recreation? And I know that's music to everybody in this room. I go to Paige.

13:33 Next page. Our strategic pillars usually describe a foundation for decision-making. And when we look at these things on our next page, those five pillars we talked about, strategic investment, stable partnerships, sensible entrepreneurship, and sustainable development. That's how we're going to ground ourselves in making decisions, is it makes sense within those four pillars with the athletes who have overseeing the entire components. Page 12 is our topic of investment.

14:03 Partnership targets, government agencies, non-government agencies, municipal communities, city governments and programs, recreational user groups, private sector. You know, we need to get in a decision, okay, it's been a year of getting foundational documents in place. We need how to focus on raising funds to build these amenities. We need toys in the back door. We need to be competitive with the rest of the West Coast, with the rest of the nation with some of the recreation facilities. Partnership, developing options, funding specific projects.

14:31 Development-focused advocacy, producing, hosting and co-sponsoring local events, developing community capital campaigns, strategic planning project, developmental goals, exploring, researching, expanding, developing, and follow-up on page 13 of the things we need to begin to do. We go to page 14, talk about entrepreneurship, more development. We go on page 15, probably a little bit of a simple course advocacy. How do we advocate for recreation?

14:58 What does that look like in terms of roles and responsibilities? We look at initiatives, we look at publishing, we look at awareness, we look at strategy, we look at outcomes, we look at monitoring, we look at consulting, we look at research. There's a lot of work to be done. We're going to move this organization to the next level, and it's going to take a lot more than just one guy named Rich doing stuff. We're looking to the future. Sixteen, we're going to get a break down a little more of that with advocacy. The stats, you begin to see, we're talking about the $646 billion in summer spending.

15:28 6.1 million direct jobs nationwide begins to outline the impact that recreation has on the economy. 17 continues with that. 18, we're talking about organizational capacity. 19, we're talking about our operations capacity, who we are, how we're making some of this work occur. Page 20, we get into Morris Committee, ad hoc, and volunteers. Page 21, we get into the organizational part.

15:55 So Jennifer, I apologize. We need to make sure we go back in New York and talk to you today. Page 22, our path forward. Sustainability is not just an ancient buzzword. It's important for us to be able to do all the stuff and be able to sustain it over time. You know, I'll go back and remember our conversations when we went down to see our beds down in L.A., the Kings. You know, as Luke said, you know, it's one-time capital is easier, Rich. It's ongoing sustainability.

16:25 You've got to build it. You've got to make sure you can sustain it over time. And let me start looking at 23 to 32. These are our visions of success in 2021. These next five years out, these are the big ideas. Robots, cost-share partnerships, official U.S. SOC designation, fully operational high-up to track and field facility, centralized, streamlined, strategic, robust, robust events, funding, grant system, Olympic-sized ice rink, sustainable community center,

16:56 Community-Inclusive Playground, Grand Opening for the MAC, Outdoor Events Venue, and other investments under the Olympic-sized Community Aquatic Center. Those are the big ideas for the next five years. They have big ideas, they'll be carried out issues, goals, but I think we're all in the same direction. We can go to page 24. 24 is our first dependence. We need to look at our milestones. And now I'm working on July 12th.

17:23 I'm going to show a tenant to engage in conversations to sit down and begin to map these things out in terms of capital projects, timelines, personnel, and what would it take to make these things happen, because we've got to make sure I'm on the same page. You know what they say? A great idea is not a great idea unless you know we're an implementation plan. So we go through Appendix 1, which begins to break down the milestones, and you see organizational development, development and fundraising, Mammoth Creek Park West, Parks and Culture,

17:54 Page 26, Trails End Park, Mammoth Track Project, Aquatic Center, Trails System, Fieldhouse on 27th, January 28th. During the final process, the council took action with the whole special events out of measure U out of MLR. There was a conversation yesterday at MLT, the special events subcommittee going to talk again on Thursday morning.

18:21 Dan's going to put something together so the funding allocation goes through an account contract of some sort. So special events is coming out. So we're looking at allocation. We're going to be looking at a big, bold objective. Allocations will be invested to support the creation of a high-performance environment that includes a thriving arts and culture community. That's what our allocation is all about. We're going to look at funds, where they are. We're going to look at priority-based projects.

18:50 Probably down to three years. It's programming, capital projects, and special projects. And we know that we're going to look at talking about percentages of these. And we know in the earlier years, probably a greater percentage is going into capital because we're building this stuff. As things move on, we'll probably decrease capital, we'll probably spend more money on programming for these things to go on. And we always wanted some kind of fund that's about 3% for special projects, about $15,000, $25,000 in $25,000. So somebody's got this great idea.

19:17 They want to get some seed money. They have the opportunity to come and talk to us about it. And if it gets the light of day, you know, boy, too long, it may move up, and this is a priority-based project. You know, who knows? There's a lot of good ideas out there. And then you go to page 27, 29. These are our 13 things that are milestones for this fiscal year. Number one, we have the Park West Project. Number two, in the back. Number three, I've got to go performing. And before the USDA Rural Community Grant Funding, there's $300 million available out there.

19:47 Number 5, Children Seek Weapon, Number 6, Working with the National Forest Foundation for Funding, Number 7, Work to an Adopt-Adopt-A-Trial Program, Number 8, Strategic Plan for the Trail System, so we can expand going north and east, Number 9, the Challenge to Call Share Agreements as we look at the Summer of 17, Number 10, Begin to Work on the Aquatic Center, Centric City, Number 11, Begin to look at how we can come up with models for safe sustainability, self-sustainability for projects as we move.

20:16 Forward. Number 12, Customer Relations System. You know, we're going to go out and focus on raising funds. We've got to deal with that. Then we've got to think of what kind of system we put in place besides my speaking notes, you know, my text and my Google Docs. You know, some great systems with their sales force or some spot, whatever it might be. And number 13, you know, always remind ourselves we're advocating for recreation. What does that look like in this community? A placeholder for our communication plan at this point in time.

20:47 So that's kind of a summary. That's the blood, sweat, and tears that have gone through this document in nine generations.

21:16 Thank you.

21:47 Thank you very, very much, Rich. We really appreciate you bringing this forward to the Commission. I know it's gone through many, many, many iterations.

22:17 So we really appreciate this opportunity. And I have just a quick housekeeping question for you. So I'm sure that the commission will have some questions and also some comments on this. And then I know you have your board meeting tonight when you'll be looking at this again. Do you want to take those comments forward? Or I will be at your meeting tonight, so I'm also happy to present those comments to your board.

22:46 This is who we are, and this is where we're going. You know, there's some big, hairy, audacious holes out there, and the focus really right now is, okay, this is the five years, these are the projects we're building. Let's work on designs, let's work on perspectives, let's raise some money, get a deal of how that works with R&U, but, you know, there's a way to make this whole thing work. And also, that's what we've got to do. Awesome. Well, we're really excited that you're here. Thank you. Okay, with that. So with that, I'd like to see if the commission has questions for Rich.

23:14 We'll start with questions and then comments. So, Sean, would you like to start? First of all, great document. So glad to see this coming together. Rich, how far away are you from the final? This isn't the final. I think you said that you were pretty close to it. Now, I think it's brilliant, and I just want to comment on a couple things and then ask a question. And love that intro by Dana.

23:44 And, you know, with regard to the mission, I love the part about here where you're talking about cutting-edge sustainable recreation. And the thing that I want to say is that I am amazed at the recreation, the outdoor recreation industry that is exploding in this country. And I remember when I was a Boy Scout in the 70s and 80s that I think I've heard this statistic that just in the last 40 years that our back country are...

24:10 Essentially, and we are a gateway to the backcountry, has increased tenfold in usage. Now, I don't know if that statistic is correct, but just I remember as being as a Boy Scouts searching the heavens, and we'd see a satellite every two hours, and now you look up and you see one just all the time. It's really changing, and that article that I did forward to the commission about how it seems like the new generation is really learning how to camp through festivals.

24:38 And the advent of fat bikes that wasn't even on the radar five years ago, was it? Maybe it was on somebody's radar, but it wasn't on mine. You know, just the new uses that we are seeing here into the future and the key word here being sustainable as well as cutting edge.

24:57 Our culture, our generations are changing that the kids who are in their single digits or teens will be using the wilderness in a different way than we have in the past or even those kids who aren't born yet.

25:13 And so I like that you are building something here, and I'm slowly getting to my question here, I promise, in that I like the roles that we have defined here with MLRs being tasked with creating new opportunities in the eastern Sierra, Mammoth Lakes in particular, making us a destination. As the entire LA basin continues to grow, those people are going to be looking for outdoor experiences, and we are the gateway to the eastern Sierra.

25:43 So you guys build it. Tourism does a good job of promoting it. Chamber of Commerce, and correct me if I'm saying anything here that I don't think is outside the mandates here, but Chamber of Commerce's job is to make sure that when people are here, they do have a good experience, both just in services as well as actually opportunities. Our job here on the Recreation Commission is to do more of the programming of facilities that...

26:10 Already exist. And Rich, I guess my question for you is how do we assist MLR? And if you want to speak a little bit as we go through this, as you do have a very aggressive timeline here, how do we assist you in programming or setting up for sustainable use of these facilities that you are going to go out there and create? How do you view our relationship and what can we do to assist you?

26:40 Stuart, I've had conversations in that vein. The first piece on this really is let's get the designs and let's start with we'll use Park West Project. What's that going to look like? What's the cost going to be? What kind of money do we need to raise? And then what are the operating costs? And we've been talking about operating costs as part of a business plan. What you all can help us with is how do you program that Park West Project based on the work you did this past spring? How many kids?

27:07 How many adults? What are the programs? What's the income? What are the expenses? You know, looking at the business side. We need to look at these as business plans. You know, at the end of the day, if we build it and nobody comes, we have failed. You know, we've engaged the community to a good extent right now to say this is what we're looking for. Hopefully that programming will allow us to bring...

27:26 Bring people in. There'll be an X factor on funding. We realize it's a municipality, so there's always going to be some subsidy of some sort, but we need to realize what this is. You know, as I've looked at all my previous life, looking at high school athletics, you need to come in and see what it costs all the time.

27:42 It's got to be self-sustaining, folks, or as close as we possibly can. So my challenge to you all is how do you program these pieces with a goal of being self-sustainable? I know that's probably unrealistic, but how do we get closer to and begin to look at your numbers? You know, based on the projects you're doing right now.

28:01 What are your operating costs? What percent are you actually picking up on the total cost of any one project? I would challenge you guys to begin to do the math on your projects and your programs and begin to look at the limited dollars we all have because if we have so many dollars in R&U and we're going to start spending that money to subsidize programs, we're not going to have money to build new stuff down the road. So in the best of all worlds, one-time capital, we're building it. We've got some money to keep you going for a couple of years.

28:27 And then we pull out and we go to the next project. So I would challenge you guys to start looking at your numbers. Okay. I think that's a good point to remember because the only way that you can keep doing your growth is if we are able to alleviate some of the things that you already create, some of the challenges of. Yeah. Okay. I think that was all I really wanted to say. But you've got a great plan here.

28:52 Actually, I will just say one other thing, you know, where you talk about the private sector and corporate partners. You know, that's not a bad thing. I understand that we need to keep this sustainable and really look towards growth, but again, I'm very fascinated by the growth of the outdoor recreation industry. Good luck. It's exciting. Yeah. Thanks, Sean. Clayton, I'll get down to you. No comments. No comments? All right. Christy? Yeah, my comment.

29:20 Dovetails a little bit with Sean Turner's comment, and that is, yes, very thoughtful, very inclusive document. It's nice to see so much emphasis on partnership and advocacy and community and bridging the gap between our visitors and people who enjoy this area from out of town and our community members. Rich, I was thrilled to see that you have business planning built in to your strategic plan. I think that that...

29:49 has been sometimes a missing piece in our community and I'm really happy that you're having that vision that we have to build in the programming and the maintenance and the staffing and the admin for all of these new facilities. There's a lot of great discussion and documentation with both MLR and Mammoth Lakes Recreation about not duplicating efforts and during the

30:17 Formation Committee meetings. One of the exciting prospects about Mammoth Lakes Recreation was the fact that it could be nimble in ways that municipal government cannot, and I think that you were talking a little bit about that, you know, being innovative and entrepreneurial. And I see a lot of references to supporting one another and not duplicating efforts, but I'm having a hard time putting my thumb on what that actually means when we're working together for programs.

30:46 or we're working with other governmental partners like the U.S. Forest Service. And I think that although it might be beyond the scope of this particular document, we need to start bringing this...

31:01 idea of not duplicating efforts and supporting each other out of the realm of the theoretical and rhetorical and into some policies and procedures. And I see some opportunity to update some documents both on the municipal code side and also the MLR side. For the point of this particular document, I'm wondering if in your next draft you would find it appropriate to

31:26 Flesh out some of the key partnerships a little bit more thoroughly, in particular partnerships with the U.S. Forest Service, MLT, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, with the Rec Commission, the LADWP, Housing, and maybe take the leadership in starting the conversation about what that looks like for you and starting to have a document in place that people can respond to. Very good. We're looking at those types of...

31:57 I think you're touching on partnerships, and we look at that right now with grants, corporate sponsorships, et cetera. Year one really was just getting foundational documents in place. You know, my goal is now we've got a document. We know where we're going. Let's build these. Let's find funding for it. It's going to take that structure, you know, a structured.

32:21 Partnership Plan of some sort, you know, truly begin to identify who's doing what. And that's part of the milestones, too, at the same time, begin to build in those. Because the milestones, each one of those is going to become a white paper by itself. Each one of those is going to become a business plan. And then those business plans are going to begin to identify the partners, the expectations, you know, roles and responsibilities, et cetera. You know, Stu and I have been talking about the business plan now for the Park West project for a couple of months, beginning to sort some of that stuff out.

32:49 So good recommendation. We'll plant that and get it rolling forward. And just to speak to the non-duplicative efforts, which has been an ongoing conversation, I think, between all of us, when we get to item number six on our agenda today, we'll be updating our calendar for the commission. And we're hoping to maybe have that joint workshop with NLR and hopefully have that discussion in September. So that'll be, I think, really helpful to everyone.

33:21 Anything else? No. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Laurel? Yeah, Rich, great document. I second everything that was said already. Coming from a nonprofit fundraising background, I am curious about what, if anything, you've done so far to secure further funds or found some targeted funding sources that haven't been pursued yet because I know that's a big question mark.

33:49 in the world of fund development is how do you get it? I can't give away too many of my trade secrets here, Kate. Of course, of course. One of our biggest challenges is that restricted R&U funds cannot be used to raise money. Right. That becomes our challenge. So I try to use the back door. You were expected to work so many hours per week, so once I meet that maximum, that outside window is when I'm...

34:15 Making phone calls, shaking hands, calling people. I mean, just the fact we had the connection with the LA Kings, you know, going down to visit with them. It's all about building partnerships. It's about building the relationships. You know, you can do a very easy Google. You've done it yourself. You're in fundraising. Begin to look at the top 50 contributors in the country and begin to look at all the grant applications out there. This past year, we've applied for almost a million dollars plus in grants, you know, in our...

34:41 June board packet, you know, we outlined a number of those things in terms of, you know, is it of interest to us? Are we going to pursue it? How does it align with one of our projects? Because we're not just trying to catch money. We're really trying to catch money for project specific. And there are all sorts of funding sources out there. And you start with a letter of intent.

35:03 You know, the conversations with our local business people, people are willing to buy in, but they want to know what they're buying into to start with. You know, just don't give me money. It's, can I sell, is somebody going to buy MLR? I don't think so. But, with a nice strat plan at this point in time, my brother's a national sales rep for Yankee Candle. He's interested in saying, Rich, you know, we may give you some seed money, $25,000 to help support the organization. So it's just the personal connections.

35:33 People want to get involved in stuff. You know, people that enjoy ice will buy ice. We need to go talk to ice people. With Evan yesterday talking about, and he's raised $13.5 of the $15 million in need for the MAC at this point in time. He's raised that money because people will buy music because they love music. The Lands and Legacy event this past Saturday, we raised $70,000 because people will buy lands. You've got to find out where the interest is. And that's just, it's sales. You know, it's just...

36:00 Having the passion for what you believe in, approaching people, building the relationship. You know, one of our past council members said to me the other day, Rich, have you raised a million dollars yet? I said, well, the first time you go out with somebody, it's a cup of coffee.

36:13 We don't get to know each other. The second time, hey, we'll have a second cup of coffee. Before too long, it's dinner. Before too long, you're holding hands. So you've got to build the relationship. So we've got a pretty good targeted sponsor list right now, about 40 different folks we're looking at. Part of the requirement of being a board member is you're knocking on doors. You've got to begin to make those connections. So I think with this document,

36:36 Building the relationships, beginning to look at the partnerships and flushing it out a little bit more. Now that I've got a prospectus, this is what this looks like. This is this business plan for Park West. This is what it's going to cost. This is what I'm short. Do you want to buy a piece of this or that or something else? Stu and I have had those conversations. I think little by little we'll begin to build some excitement. You look at the Hart-Howerton presentation this past Wednesday. That inspired a lot of people. It's like, wow.

37:03 Once we get this Park West project, you look at it, people are going to say, wow, I want a piece of that. But we need to have those types of tools to motivate and inspire people to say, hey, I want a part of that. So that's kind of where I am. Excellent. Okay? Thank you. Thank you. Anything else?

37:20 Okay. I just have a few comments. And, Rich, I just, I really, I'm sorry I couldn't be at your last meeting, but I did watch some of the discussion online. I thought it was a really, really good discussion. And I've seen this document really evolve from, you know, pretty boring, you know, really not so exciting, you know, just really basic fleshing out things. Text on paper. Exactly. Now it's really a dynamic.

37:45 Beautiful piece, which I think will be really, really useful to you as you try to engage those partners and stakeholders. So it's awesome. So I just had a couple of questions. One, on the org chart, and I think this may come up later at your meeting, I just wanted to kind of clarify because in terms of the commission's role, where you have town staff slash rec commission,

38:09 As much as we love our staff, the commission rolls up to the council, whereas the staff rolls up to the town manager. So I think you may just want to separate that. You can do that. And maybe also, I don't know if you want to have, I mean, town council gets the biggest one, but I don't know if maybe it belongs maybe up at the top. So that was just my main comment there. And then also, during MLR formation, and I don't know if this is.

38:35 If this really matters at this point because you've come so far. But during formation we also talked a lot about MLR having kind of a dotted line relationship to town council. So that's something your board might want to might want to discuss because we spent a lot of time talking about a solid versus a dotted line, believe it or not. You might remember that. And then the other thing I wanted to talk about is

38:55 In terms, you mentioned organizational capacity. I think it's on page 13. You talk about MLR is committed to providing assistance and capacity to its partners for the development of those business plans. And I just wondered kind of how that will happen. Is that at the board level? Is that at the staff level? Is that everybody all in together? Staff level. Staff level, okay.

39:20 Because I know there's going to be a lot of collaboration certainly between our staff with programming facilities. Well, that's the magic. Stu and I spending time together working through some of these things. And it's even part of you take a step back and you look at the Mammoth 2025 plan. You look at Q1. They talk about business plans and project prospectus. Look at Shields, our new mayor right now. Everything's business. It's like it's going to be a business deal we're making at this point in time.

39:46 Which is great, because that brings me to my next point, which is about, I just wanted to talk a little bit about the definition of sustainability, because on the commission and the Parks and Recreation Department side, you know, it's really our mission to deliver, you know, affordable, community-centric recreation. We certainly are cognizant and we recognize the limited resources, but we have slightly different mission in terms of, so when you talk about sustainability, are we talking about, you know,

40:15 For example, it talks about a sustainable playground. Well, I don't think we're going to start charging admission to our playground. So, you know, just kind of, I think, to keep that, you know, cost recovery, you know, issue kind of top of mind. And that's why I would challenge the Rec Commission to begin to look at, as you're doing these projects, we know what it costs to operate them.

40:33 What's the cost recovery? Is it 10 percent? Is it 20 percent? Is it 30 percent? I think we need to be a little more cognizant in what these recovery costs are at this point in time as we look to the future. Because if we're spending, if we're asking for ongoing support of our new money for programming, that means there's less money in the future for the next project down the road. And who knows what it's going to be, but we need to start being cognizant of what those recovery costs are. In the best of all worlds, we're self-sustaining.

41:00 We know that's virtually impossible, but in any business world, and I realize this is a municipality, you know, we've got to begin to look at those differences. And I think there's definitely some awareness of that. I mean, I think if you look at some of our summer camps, we're very good at recovering, you know, costs on those while keeping them affordable. So I think it's something where, you know, we really do strive for. But at the same time, we just, we recognize that, you know, when we're talking about...

41:22 R and U money and general fund money that, you know, that's the public's money and we want to really serve the public, I think, with that. And then finally, the only other comment I had was just you talk a little bit about the economic development piece in order to, you know, qualify for like a rural development grant. And my suggestion to you might be that you might want to engage with the Planning and Economic Development Commission, you know, just in terms of those pieces. I've already had those conversations. Thank you. Of course.

41:50 The county folks here, the California folks, the guys in D.C. The USDA rural community grant process is $300 million available. It's a set-aside on annual basis for rural communities working with the county and the town right now.

42:06 Hayes and I have had this conversation, Frank Rizzo specifically, about a good Italian name, about what that could look like in terms of bigger projects. You know, we'll begin to look at all the projects we have in town at this point in time. What are the priorities? How do we package something? And as Hayes said to me, let's look at taking one little chunk at a time and open that door up and see where it goes in the future. Awesome. Well, thank you. Really appreciate your time. Are there any other comments or questions from the commission? Staff have any questions or comments?

42:35 Thank you, Rich. One quick question as a follow-up. I know we briefly discussed this. Appendix 1, and I know the board at the last meeting talked about whether that is part of the strategic plan or whether that's a separate document that's going to be further developed. Do you have any comment on that, Rich? I think we're looking at it as an appendix at this point in time. You and I and Grady were going to sit down and talk about the realism of...

43:01 Accomplishing these things and what it's going to take over time. So I think, you know, once we can get ourselves together, this will be an appendix and this would probably be modified, you know, as with the budget. You know, I want to start looking five years out on budget. You know, if you look at five years out on R&U, you're looking at $10 million. You know, let's begin to really allocate what that's going to look like for capital, program, and special projects. So I think it's going to be an appendix at this point, which will be modified based on circumstances.

43:28 Because I think that goes back to Commissioner Turner's question in regards to how effective and what is the best way method for the commission to engage and when commission, as we discussed, is responsible through the department and programming and operating these facilities just to make sure there's an opportunity to obviously be part of that discussion in the establishment of certainly these tasks and milestones and the dates. So I really want to make sure that's an opportunity that the commission has to...

43:56 Fully engage and vet these dates and times so we can both commit the expectation of the community to delivering upon these wonderful facilities that we've described here. So, I mean, that was my only caution in regards to I think there's a real opportunity there for us to engage. And I realize this is a BHAG, a big, hairy, audacious goal. But, you know, if you don't shoot for the stars, you're not going to land on the moon.

44:23 I think if we can be focused and targeted and we're all pulling in the same direction, we're going to accomplish some great things. There's a lot of positive energy right now, a lot of good stuff going on, and I think this is just another indicator of some of the great things that are waiting around the corner. So with that...

44:40 If I could just follow up. Sorry, I know you're trying to leave the podium. But, yeah, that actually falls exactly into is making sure that we are communicating expectations with the public and even ourselves. You know, you mentioned some aquatic centers in here. You know, we've discussed that. And let's not go into any of those details. The Hart-Howerton presentation obviously kind of.

45:06 Changes things up. Not necessarily bad, but we just need to be able to talk about them in a way that everyone is on the same page, expectations-wise. So, yes, please, communication is king here. And you look at, there are a lot of moving parts. You look at the Mammoth 2025 plan, you know, rolls out the next 18 months, you know, some of these projects that are line-itemed in there.

45:29 The Hart-Howerton concept that came forward. It would be an interesting conversation with Shields yesterday, our mayor. So where does this fit? And we've got Tom Hodges coming to MLR board tonight to give a little overview, kind of where it is, because three of the five priority phase projects are mentioned as part of that concept plan. So right now, we're moving forward. We're expecting in October of 2017 to have a nice Halloween ice skating party. We want to meet that expectation.

45:58 I mean, if somebody would come along and say, you know, Rich, if you're willing to wait six months, and I'm going to give you some dirt, and I'm going to build it for you, and it's going to be the best thing since motherhood and sliced pie, I may say, guys, let's wait six months. But I don't see that coming down the road just yet. And I don't want to be in a position, you know, you look at all the stuff in this document is from all the planning documents we've pulled together over the last 10 years. We've been talking about this stuff for a long, long time. Let's pull the trigger, right?

46:27 If we wait for the perfect thing to come along, we'll be waiting the rest of our lives, folks. We can shoot and then modify it, but we've got to move forward. So with that, I've talked too much. I appreciate your time today. Good morning, everybody. Thank you. Thank you very much, Rich. We really appreciate you being here. Okay. If it is the pleasure of the Commission, I would like to move on to item number five first, and then I would like to take item number nine out of order while we have Hayes here.

46:51 Sean has a few other things, I think, going on this week. I am going to try and stick around for just a couple things beyond that, but I would like to get the trails in front and done. Do we need a motion? No, no, this is consensus. Is that okay with everyone? Yes. Okay, so with that, we'll move on to item number five, which is the annual selection of the chair and vice chair of the commission and appointments to the ad hoc recreation programming committee. It's pretty self-explanatory. Do you need to give us a staff report at all, Stu?

47:19 Only if you desire me to spend more time talking about the appointment, but I think it was pretty well outlined in the staff report unless commission have any questions. I think so. Are there any questions? Okay, so we start with the selection of the chair and vice chair. We can do the chair first. If anyone would like to make a motion or a nomination. I would like to move that Betsy Truax remain as chair of the Recreation Commission. Thank you. I would be happy to continue serving in that capacity.

47:51 I would second that, won't you?

47:52 Okay.

47:52 I have a motion and a second.

47:54 Is there any further discussion?

47:57 All right.

47:57 Well, thank you very much.

47:59 Jamie, could we do a roll call vote on that, please?

48:01 Sure.

48:02 Commissioner Martin?

48:04 Did I say yes?

48:06 Yes.

48:06 Or no.

48:09 Aye.

48:11 Commissioner Menlo?

48:12 Yes.

48:13 Commissioner Oswald?

48:13 Yes.

48:14 Commissioner Truman?

48:14 Yes.

48:15 Chair Truex?

48:16 I'll abstain, but motion passes with four aye votes and one abstention.

48:19 So thank you all very much.

48:22 Okay, so we'll move on to the Vice Chair, and I would like to nominate Commissioner Turner to serve as Vice Chair. I'll second. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Are you willing to serve in that capacity? Yes, I am. Thank you. I wasn't going to give you a choice. Maybe I should have asked you before the meeting. Is there any further discussion? Okay, then we'll do a roll call vote on that as well, please. Commissioner Martin? Aye. Commissioner Mendel? Yes. Commissioner Osborne? Yes. Commissioner Turner? Abstain.

48:52 Yes. So motion again passes with four aye votes and one abstention.

48:58 Excellent. All right, so I'd like to actually move everyone around now. I'm so comfortable, though. I know, I know. I know you've had that seat for a long time. I know, right? But you have to come move to my left and be in the best chair seat, which means we get to sit together again. I have to take my name tag and everything. You have to take your name tag. And Christy, if you could just move down to Sean's seat, that would be great. At least 60 seconds here. Clayton, if you could come and sit in this seat, and we'll put Laurel in your seat. We're moving everyone. We're moving everyone.

49:27 Mixing it up. I told you all not to get comfortable. Is this your... Yes, I'll come for that. Bring it behind you. Thank you, everyone. The hokey pokey. I didn't want to get presumptuous and do this before the meeting.

50:02 All right. And so once everyone settles into their new seats, we also need to appoint two members of the commission to the ad hoc recreation programming committee. As you can see in the staff report, standing committees are required to meet formal notice requirements, whereas ad hoc committees are not. This is a committee that we reformulate every year.

50:26 I guess Sean and I are the current representatives to that committee. I would ask if anyone else is interested in serving or if you want to continue to serve. You know, I feel like that's the one area that I can really contribute just because I've got a kid going through the program. Super. I don't know if anyone else feels strongly.

50:49 Does anyone else have a strong interest? No? All right. So, and just so that you all know, anything that gets discussed in that committee then comes back to the full commission, so you'll all still have opportunities to comment on that. And we just meet a couple of times with staff to kind of review the previous season and look toward the upcoming season, so we can continue to deliver great programming. All right. So, all we need is consensus on that, so everyone's, that's acceptable to everyone? I just have a question about the...

51:18 The document itself, in the second to last paragraph, it says staff is requesting that the commission by consensus appoint the two members to serve on the ad hoc recreation committee programming committee. And then in the next paragraph, first line, it says staff is recommending that the recreation commission not appoint members to standing committees.

51:40 basically in the interest of efficiency. Can I get some clarification on that? Yes. We used to have a lot of committees, and what would happen was that we would have so many committees that then the committee, it got kind of fragmented, and so we'd have a trails committee, and I can't even remember all of them, and then they would kind of come back, and it was very disjointed because not all of the commissioners had the same information. Sometimes because those were public meetings, we'd have all of the commissioners at the meeting so we could all hear what was going on. So two years ago,

52:09 We decided that we would only keep the programming committee just because that involves some really granular, detailed discussions with staff and reviewing surveys and statistics. And the whole commission still sees the information, but that's currently our only committee. And if we should have the need to form another ad hoc committee in the future, we certainly have that option. Does that answer your question? Absolutely. Okay. Well, I'm happy to continue serving as well. So we're good on that. Okay.

52:40 All right. And I think what we'll do is in a year, we'll review these reports. Great. I think we should. Moving on, we'll come back to talk a little bit about vision and strategic direction when we do the calendar. But if we could go now to item number nine, if we could take that out of order, I think that would be helpful to everyone. So in that way, Rich can also stay for that. And this would definitely be a staff report. Thank you, Chair.

53:13 Thank you for the opportunity to come forward today to provide an update on the Trails End Park project and provide opportunities for the Commission to fully complete the project with a funding recommendation that we'll walk you through. I've provided some additional handouts to you which weren't part of the original packet. One of those is an option document, option one, two, and three, and then also an updated sitemap.

53:40 that we provided in colour. So I'm just going to walk you through a little bit of the background. Here as well is our Parks Manager, Warren. He's going to talk a little bit about the Parks Maintenance obligations and the use of the facility and so forth. And then Hayes from Public Works will kind of walk through the Public Works role in this project.

53:58 Quite clearly, we are a client of Public Works, so once the commission makes a recommendation, the Parks and Recreation Department moves into kind of formulating a program and operations schedule, and then the project is handed over to Public Works to deliver, in a nutshell. So just as a brief update, and then I'll pass it over to Hayes to kind of walk through the details, and we can kind of walk through some options before you.

54:25 The goal today is to provide you with information regarding the status of the project, as we stated, information regarding the additional completion cost of the project, and then we are before the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board this afternoon seeking a recommendation from Mammoth Lakes Recreation regarding your direction today. It is then scheduled, due to the timeline, to be in front of the Town Council on August 17th.

54:55 So the timeline we are trying to complete and conduct our ribbon cutting in October. Might have been bumped a little bit, but we do want to complete the project this summer. So that's kind of why I'm before you today. So I'm just going to briefly walk through the staff report because that's what you have before you. We don't want to provide any additional other documents to confuse you.

55:16 Very briefly, we allocated, Town Council allocated in January $145,000 for the design and construction of the Trails End Park project. You can clearly see what the project amenities were at that time. It kind of describes those. There were three main elements of the bid. That was the pavilion and the shade structures. So we talked about providing a 24 by 24 pavilion.

55:43 And then originally the quote had three shade structures and that came down to two is what we determined would fit in the space required. We have purchased those items so they are in the town yard ready to go so we've paid those items for $68,096. Pavilion and shade structure installation. So again when we looked at this project it was the best interest of the town to publicly bid the installation of the pavilion.

56:12 But we also are looking at town staff to actually install the smaller shade structures. That project was bid, and you can see... Sorry, is it bid right now, Hayes? Is it out for bid, that installation? Yep. So it's currently out for bid. Hayes can talk more about that, but that installation is between $12,000 and $15,000. And you can see the shade structures will be installed by town staff. Concrete. So the concrete was a big one, and Hayes will talk about this. But generally...

56:40 This project started back in 2010 as a bit of a history, about $1.3 million project. That included kind of the Little Brothers Skate Park. We've spent the next six years trying to deliver that project. We've worked with the Recreation Commission quite diligently over that period of time for our new commissioners to provide a very kind of fiscally responsible, environmentally sustainable and park that the community can be proud of.

57:08 So through that six-year process, we're able to complete the installation of the playground. We're able to put the soft-surface material in. You know, we added some basic paths and amenities, and then complementary to that, you can see the expansion of the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park has really provided an amazing facility for the community.

57:28 We came down to a project that was about $490,000 that included grass, it included turf, it included wood fibers, and then in the end we settled on concrete as the kind of most relevant and probably the most sustainable and most maintenance-free obligation.

57:54 Warren and his crew to maintain. So that's kind of why we went with concrete. And then the concrete, like I said, I'll have Hayes talk about that in a little bit as well. But that were kind of the three elements. Combined with those items, we talked about providing just basic amenities in regards to

58:13 Additional benches, the benches down at the Trail Zone Park, if you've been down there, a little old, a little warped, they're not up to the standard that we really expect for the community, so we, in the original design, had those included in the project, and that was two six-foot tables for the two-shade structures adjacent to the playground, three eight-foot tables under the pavilion with an ADA table.

58:40 Which is really what we desire for the entire community, make sure everyone has complete access to that facility. In addition to that, we had an eight foot wide concrete path allowing folks to access the pavilion. We also had a display case so we can manage the facility. If you've been around our facilities now, we have those located at each of our parks and facilities. It's really the best way to communicate with the public and certainly those that has reservations to more effectively operate those.

59:09 We also included concrete stairs with handrails down to that lower path as well. What we didn't include in the original bid was actually a concrete pad for the pavilion. So that's an enhancement that we're bringing forward that we really truly believe is a requirement of that facility to really provide the expectation that we...

59:34 Really desire for the community. And then we've added two trash and recycling receptacles. One at the base of the facility, the pavilion, and one over by the new bridge, where we see a lot more traffic. So that's kind of the project. Where we're at with the project right now is that if I do bring your attention to this document here, it's the little handout. It talks about options one, two, and three. Any questions? Just jump in there at any time. I'll just kind of walk you through. But what we're...

1:00:02 Providing here for the commission is three options. Option one is an additional $8,000 to complete the items that are specified in the table. So that means we would include the pavilion footings and installation and the shade structures footings, concrete slab around the playground. It would eliminate the red dye that we really wanted to put in that to make it a little bit more attractive element than just the concrete.

1:00:27 You know, grey slab. So it's a very trimmed down basic version, not what we really envisioned at all for the completion of that project. But based on the competitive bid environment, that's the option at this time if we don't request additional monies. Option two includes the pavilion concrete slab as an enhancement to the project. It includes the red concrete die for the concrete slab.

1:00:54 And it includes the six foot wide path, the eight foot wide path, the concrete staircase and the railings around the pavilion. So that would be an additional $25,000. To fully complete the park, which is option three, and that's the original 216 plan that we've described for the community, would complete the project and that's an additional $45,000. At this time that includes all the items in option two, but that's in addition to the tables.

1:01:20 For the two small shade structures, the three tables under the pavilion, the ADA table, the display case, the trash cans and recycling and so forth. And it also includes an additional contingency and project management fee to complete that project. So before you were three options to complete the project, we are recommending option three. We truly don't want to shortchange the community in regards to Trails End Park. We believe it's a wonderful asset.

1:01:50 Town staff want to make sure we complete that project as described for $190,000. If you have any questions on that before I hand it to Hayes at this time. Okay. Hayes, maybe you can kind of walk through the public works, the responsibilities of the project. Sure. And let me just say that we're actually really excited. Some of us have been working on this project for a very, very long time. And to be so close to closing this out, we're really excited.

1:02:20 Deliver this product for the community. A couple of things. The difference between option one and option three is really related to two factors. Construction costs have increased since we did some original estimates and some additional changes in the scope and the design of the project that really shook out when we started taking a closer look at this.

1:02:43 As Stu kind of discussed some of the history of the project, it has changed over the years from a $1.3 million project to a $145,000 project. And a lot of things were not really taken into consideration. And if you looked at the January staff report, you'll see that staff noted that there would be deductive alternates in order to keep the project within the budget that was allotted. We were already kind of aware that we were really going to be tight.

1:03:09 to get everything that was proposed. Why does that happen? Well, in a typical public works project, you'll go through a process of doing your engineering up front. You'll do all your design, you'll do all your cost estimates, and you'll spend a lot of time trying to figure out exactly what it's going to cost. The process that was utilized here because things had changed over the years was more just kind of using some institutional knowledge and making some phone calls and getting a rough idea of what things were going to cost.

1:03:38 The pavilion is a great example. When you start calling, asking about, you know, how much a pavilion is going to cost, they're like, oh yeah, it's X, Y, and Z. And then you say, well, we're in Mammoth and we need a 90-mile-an-hour wind loading and 250-pound snow load.

1:03:54 We've never designed anything like that. That's going to be a custom one-off. So you go through a process, and that makes everything larger, more expensive, larger footings, more rebar, and the cost can't escalate. We were able to control that quite well, actually, and keep portions of these things really close to what we had put in our budget. But new things came up. Speaking with Warren and the maintenance of the pavilion, it became...

1:04:21 You know, apparent that we needed to have a concrete slab underneath that pavilion. We also needed to provide an ADA walkway to get to that pavilion and then we realized, well, they're just going to cut down to the skate park so we better put in a set of stairs otherwise they're just going to, you know, spread soil and rocks all over the skate park which is, you know, just not good for the skaters. So that was something that came up through the design process that wasn't originally envisioned. Stu mentioned the red concrete. When Sierra was putting this together she's like, you know, that's going to be

1:04:51 3,400 square feet of just plain gray, you know, monolithic concrete. What do you think about adding some articulation with some color? I was like, you know, that's a great idea. It's a playground. Make it exciting. That wasn't something that was originally in the plans, and that did add an additional $2 per cubic yard to the cost of the concrete. That's in addition to the cost of the concrete has gone up.

1:05:15 A new law requires drivers to be paid prevailing wage. That's adding $10 per cubic yard to our cost of our concrete. That's just state law, and that's impacting all of our projects. But that was not something that was envisioned back in 2010, 2013, when these projects were re-envisioned.

1:05:32 So I won't go back through everything that Stu hashed out, but that's really the big difference between option one and option three. We had to bring it back into the budget to keep it for option one, and that's where we landed. We had to cut certain things out. Option three brings those design features back in, the maintenance aspects and so forth, to really bring a complete project for the community. Thank you.

1:06:01 Okay. As they mentioned, I mean, the maintenance on the whole factor here I think is huge. I mean, if we can add the concrete in there and stick with option three, it's going to knock down the man hours of us having to go in there and clean. It's one thing going in there and weeding around everything. It's another if a guy can show up with a backpack blower, blow for 20 or 30 minutes compared to spending two hours there on the maintenance factor. With the trash cans and everything, the park is getting used much more lately. Having trash cans in designated areas is going to help.

1:06:31 Trash in these areas now that I believe there was a trash can there. We would not have to be picking that up either. As these guys stated, though, the park is getting busier. I think with this new shade structures down there, people that are coming in are going to use it much more often for families and everything else, doing picnics and so on and so forth. Yeah, we've actually scheduled, you'll see in the new fee schedule amendment coming in March, February, I think it is, fees for that.

1:07:01 Pavilion. We actually think it's going to be used quite heavily or really heavily when you look at what happens at Shady Rest Park as well. So we're really ramping up for a very heavily utilised park once we, you know, cut the rubin in October and we're just trying to provide the amenities that we really believe the community needs and the department really is requesting to complete the project. So with that we're going to wrap up our staff presentation if you have any questions.

1:07:28 But again, staff's recommending option three, which is to complete the project as per the original plan for an additional cost of $45,000. Thank you. Welcome. Okay, so for the benefit of our new commissioners, what we do now is we have the opportunity to ask questions of staff, and they should be questions, and then we'll do this on any time we're making a decision on something like this, and then we'll take comments from the public, and then we'll bring it back for deliberation. So, questions.

1:07:56 at this point. Christy, would you like to start? I would. I just have a question about in option three adding back the ADA table and the trash cans recycling and I'm wondering why those two elements weren't preserved in option two or option one since they both seem to meet the mission and directive of municipal recreation. Absolutely.

1:08:23 They're the low-hanging fruit. It's easy to get money to put these things in at a later date. It's very difficult to find money to put in concrete slabs and foundations and so forth. So unfortunately, those are typically the first things to go from a budget in a project like this. We've bid and rebid this project a number of times trying to just tailor things down to get all these amenities back in, and frankly, we're just not in a position to do so with that budget. Thank you. Any other questions? Clean.

1:08:56 Yeah, I'm fully aware how much work has gone into this project. I know the commission for a long time with the rec staff has been pushing to get this, really just to get this park done and not be done with it, but be able to hang our hat on that kind of. I'm given the current fiscal constraints with this budget cycle.

1:09:24 and the reality that there may not be funding for a 30% increase in the cost scope of the project. If you have to fall back to option one, is that something that's going to be able to be called complete? No. So if we go back to the original plan which was presented, and I think it's still on the website, I just looked at it this morning, that was really what the commission approved in December.

1:09:56 For the complete, you know, completing the park. So at this time, and that was an alternative really when we looked at this project. So we can go ahead, complete the project for the additional $8,000 and then we'd be in a position to come back. Yeah. And I just don't know if that's really in the best interest, certainly for the community to see that happen. I think it was a very difficult decision for us, but really it was the easiest decision to say, you know.

1:10:22 It's the intent. Certainly the Commission wants to see this done. Town staff want to see this done. Let's take a pause. Let's bring it back. Let's get the Commission's recommendation again. Let's get it back through a funding cycle. And we'll see where we're at after we get through Council on August 17th. Again, our goal is just to complete this this year. We don't want to see this go any longer than, you know, 2016. Yeah, no, agreed. And option three definitely represents the closest.

1:10:52 match to those original goals. Okay, that's it. Thanks. Thanks, Clayton. Laurel? With the increased use that's going to come from this pavilion, because I know that the one at Shady is impacted quite a bit, so there'll be a lot of overflow. Is there enough parking and bathrooms and all the other stuff that we're not looking at right now to accommodate that?

1:11:16 Or will that be just it'll be back on the table here in a couple year or two once this gets done and we find everybody's using it? It's a great question. You can talk about the restrooms. How heavily utilized are they right now in regards to? The restrooms now currently that are there. The woman's restroom has two toilets in it. The man's has a urinal and a restroom in it. Both of those right now, they are definitely getting used. I mean, we go in there and have to resupply twice a day.

1:11:45 But I believe at the current standard they are keeping up. And I think within now and a year and a half, two years, I think we'll stay that way. The more people find out about the pavilion and the town saying there is another section to use, then there might be times that we may want to just bring some porta-potties or something in there as they did at the fireman's picnic this weekend. But I think that's a very easy thing to do is if we do have big events there, we just bring in extra toilets, which isn't.

1:12:15 Much of a cost. That's my opinion. It could be passed on to those who are renting the facility. Exactly. But do you think the parking lot, do you have any thoughts on that? I know it's not huge there and it's not really a road parking kind of overflow area. You know, a lot of the events down there when we do, you know, the Wave Rafe Skate Comp, you know, there is parking off pavement.

1:12:38 We provide traffic control measures. I think, you know, always one-off events, you know, we can handle pretty well. I'd be interested to kind of study this as it moves forward, and the Commission has the opportunity each and every year we bring back our capital facility plan, we bring up our, you know, maintenance program. So the Commission has the opportunity every year to kind of go through those kind of questions.

1:12:59 Really, that's really pertaining to level of service and what's kind of an acceptable level of service that the department can deliver upon and what the level of service the community expects. So they're great discussions and we'll certainly include them in their ongoing annual review of our items. And I think, again, when you know you're going to have big events like that, you can include in part of your contract that the parking needs to be considered and permits or whatever. Yeah, and that's the special event permit process, yeah.

1:13:26 I would also note that this park is very well served by transit and multi-use paths, so there is opportunity to take alternative modes and really truly be feet first to this facility. Just following up on that too, we're working on a project with Public Works on updating and enhancing the multi-use path.

1:13:48 From, what does it start, from the school, middle school? From the school down to Wagon Wheel. Down to Wagon Wheel. So we're actually looking at investing probably about $25,000, $24,000 on upgrading that path, which we think would be a great enhancement, certainly to keep people off that road, any skateboarders getting down to that park to actually, you know, take the path, because right now it's quite challenging with a set of wheels. But anyway, we think that'll be a great enhancement. That's when we looked at all our parks and as...

1:14:13 19, 20 miles of our, you know, hard surface trails. That was kind of one of the areas that we really focused on because of the usage and because it links with this facility that is seeing higher visitation, so, yeah. Great, thank you. Welcome. Thank you. We've got a couple questions, and actually I'll follow up on that one right there. Yeah, right now the multi-use path doesn't make it down there, does it? All the way? It does make it? It does, yeah. It's going to school. I know, you know, I love how close it is to the neighborhood there.

1:14:43 Trails, thank you very much. Wagon wheel. Yeah. So, but you said as far as improving that, what are you referring to? The surface of the trail itself. Because it's falling apart? The cracks. Yeah, the cracks are pretty bad. Cracks and resurfacing it. Is that something that's going to come before us or is that going to be a public works thing that doesn't come before us as far as fixing the cracks, improving that trail? I think that was in our giant spreadsheet.

1:15:13 Yeah, it's one of our work items that we identified. We're actually, I don't know, maybe Hayes can speak on that project right now where it is, but we're out to bid. We're out to bid. Okay, apologies for forgetting that line item. Yeah, that was one of my items. It was a good opportunity to bring it up, but that's, you know, we have in our budget...

1:15:31 $30,000 contractual services for our parks, trails and facilities and what we determined was to use the money from last year's budget which is about $23,000 left to perform this parks maintenance work effort on the trail system from this area and then looking at the money this year we're looking at providing a better experience at our tennis courts so we're going to go out and look at what level of effort we can provide

1:15:59 Those six tennis courts to make them safer, more playable, and more usable for our community. So that's going to be this budget coming up. So Commission will be engaged in that process as we move forward, and that will be conducted in the spring. Yeah, thank you. And I apologize because I do remember that conversation. It's just a tough time trying to keep up on anything. All right, so just a couple more questions. And actually some of this I think you've already answered in previous meetings, but I'm going to ask them again.

1:16:27 In option one, no, I guess in, yeah, in option one, we are still talking about doing the concrete around the play area, but that it's going to be gray. Correct. In option one, we are talking about not putting anything underneath the pavilion except for, what was that going to be if it's not concrete? What it is right now, which is gravel. Okay.

1:16:58 Compacted gravel essentially, right? If we go with the concrete underneath the pavilion, is it going to be just underneath the pavilion or is it a little bit wider? I mean obviously you've got the paths there in addition, but does it essentially match the 24 by 24? So in the little site map, Sierra's provided a pavilion, it's 24 by 24 and the concrete pad's 27 by 27, so you'll have a three foot little kind of buffer around the outside area of that pavilion.

1:17:27 And then plus the paths? Yep. Okay. Well, you know, I would agree that it looks like if we're going to do this, do it right. I don't know if I'm supposed to be making that statement yet or not, but I want to lead into that's actually part of my question, though. Okay, as long as it's part of your question. Where are we going to find the money to do this? What's the recommendation as far as finding the money for it? We are going back to Mammoth Lakes Recreation to request a funding recommendation of measure our monies to complete the project.

1:17:57 I just want to be clear. Any other questions? That's it. I knew you were getting there. So I have two questions. My first question is, for ADA compliance, do we need to have the concrete slab under the pavilion? If we're going to claim that that's an ADA accessible facility, then yes, we do. Okay, thank you. And then I know the answer to this question, but I'm going to ask it anyway. The existing picnic tables at the park, do they fit under the pavilion?

1:18:28 I don't think they do because it's a square pavilion and they're rectangular picnic tables. They technically would, but again... Not ideal. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Yes, we only have two of them out there. All right. Thank you. Any comments from the public or questions? This is on the MLR agenda today as an update. It is not an action item. I think the essential question is how do we properly vet projects so we're within...

1:19:05 A small percent of what the final cost is going to be. And I think that's something that we have to think about as we do projects in the future. I know I spoke to a council person yesterday, and that's going to be a council conversation, I believe, on Wednesday night. You know, I'm gravely concerned when there is such a differentiation, you know, did we bid it too soon, cost impact, I understand all that stuff. But we're looking at these big projects.

1:19:32 Park West, and all of a sudden we're off by a half a million or a million dollars. We're going to get to the point where we're not going to build this up, people. So we have to figure out how do we better vet these projects. We're closer with our bidding process and what it actually costs at the end of the day. So it's an information item. There's no action on ML board tonight. If anything, it would come back in September as an action item at that point.

1:20:00 Is it possible to change this to an action item, just given the time constraints? I don't see this as an emergency. If there have been previous conversations, the fact that we got an update on, was it Wednesday or Thursday when we're getting ready to put the agenda out, saying that we want to add something to the agenda, we did. We usually post it a week out. We got this on Wednesday or Thursday. There was a request for additional information, which I'm sure will be shared this evening, but it's just an information item. It is not an action item at this point in time.

1:20:30 So perhaps, Chair and Rich, that we can request the board consider this as an emergency action item for consideration tonight. If you want the priority to do that, it's up to the board at this point. And then my question would be, define emergency. Well, we'd really like to complete the park this year. Is that an emergency? I'm going to debate that with you because I've seen projects right now that are...

1:21:05 Not coming in where they need to be, and all of a sudden we're asking for X, Y, and Z. You know, the essential question is how do we better vet projects so we know what it's actually going to be? And when the allocation request and it came in at 145 as a priority phase project, you know, I'm sure that you guys did a more recent vetting to know what that project actually was going to cost. You know, I don't think you base that.

1:21:31 Allocation request based on a bid two or three years ago. So I think the essential question is how do we better vet these things so we're closer in terms of what it's going to cost? I mean, I will alert my board president that there'll be a request as it comes up in his emergency. I will review the Brown Act to see if this really does come up as an emergency and or do they want to make the change of the language to make it an action item at this point in time? And then that's the conversation this evening. Well, let's do this first. First, we think the commission needs to make its recommendation before.

1:22:00 We're kind of jumping ahead of ourselves a little bit. Sorry about that. So first, we'll have the commission deliberate so that we can make our recommendation and then Stuart and I will take this and Hayes will be there as well to the MLR board this evening. So we can figure that out shortly. So, Sean, I'm going to start with you just because I think, yeah, I'm going to start with you because you and I have

1:22:24 I mean, this project predates my time on the commission's. Yeah. So at this point, we're just talking about it. Is that correct? Well, no. Staff is looking for us to make a recommendation based on the options presented. Do you want me to make a motion? I just want you to share some thoughts. Okay. You can make a motion if you wish, or we can have deliberation and then a motion. Rich, your point is very well taken. And to staff, I would say it would have been great to know the true costs on this and, frankly, had this.

1:22:53 Much greater expectations put in place as far as what the cost would be at an earlier date. I hate being hit with over-budget items, to be sure. My feeling is that this is an important park. It actually has been one of our goals that we've had on the Recreation Commission since I've been on the commission.

1:23:24 of completing parks and I do like the idea of this park being completed correctly and completely since it is going to be getting so much use it is so close to the trails. With regard to the definition of emergency I think that our goal is to get it done this year because those are the expectations that we have set with the community. I will say

1:23:55 I will ask, when is the park going to be closed for the winter? November through April is typically our time that we close that park. So if we go forward with a request for an emergency item, it is because we are trying to fulfill our expectations with the community. Having said that, and I hate to be punting to the Recreation Commission, I mean to the MLR, as far as deciding when this gets funded so that it can be completed this year.

1:24:26 You just heard the answer to that question. But at the same time, I'm kind of in favor of, I am in favor at this time anyway, of recommending that we make an emergency request to complete this this year, which is option number three. With the understanding that the points that I said earlier is that your comments about this really should have been presented completely and it's entirely beforehand would have been great.

1:24:55 And that also knowing that the park will be closed November through April. Okay. I'm of the opinion that it's a little late in the game for this season to be coming up, you know, 30% funding short on a project we're trying to get done by the end of the year. We're kind of in the last few months of the year now for getting that complete.

1:25:31 While it would be nice to get the additional funding and finish the project, I feel pretty strongly that we should just do as much as we can with the funding currently allocated, and if it requires additional funding next year to finish, then that's a shortfall of the planning and cost estimation process for this project.

1:26:04 I do not support an emergency action with MLR. Okay, thank you. Laurel? Is it realistic to put the pavilion up and then build a pad underneath it? That's a question for staff. Yes. Does it compromise the integrity of it? We redesigned the footings.

1:26:30 for that, to be able to accommodate that. That's not the preferred design, but we were able to work with the pavilions engineers to come up with a design that could accommodate that process. I like the concrete for the accessibility aspect, but as you said, if we're not saying it's an accessible thing yet, then that isn't necessarily as urgent. This is tricky. I kind of...

1:27:10 Wonder about the red. I mean, I get that we want to make it look nice, but I don't know. What about green? Why not, you know, is there a cheaper color? Actually, I'm actually pleased that someone asked that because when we looked at concrete color, it actually was, I think, one of the least expensive items for the dye. Blue is very expensive for dyeing concrete. Red, much less so. And fade and all of that stuff, I mean, is that...

1:27:41 Is it going to have any longevity? Red was actually selected because it matches the playground structure. Same color roofs and outline and everything. And it's actually more affordable and we looked at the colors and the dyeing and it seemed more suited to the environment. And if you've been up to our 17,000 square foot concrete slab of plain concrete, any color dye makes an immense difference to the usability and the look and the, you know.

1:28:11 And it should hold up pretty well because we wouldn't be removing snow from it. Right, right. You know, if you look at how well the coloring is held up on the sidewalks, which do have snow removal, I think, I don't think longevity is really a concern. So, quick question. Laurel brought up a good point about the pad. Would the, would public works anticipate the cost to be higher if we did it at a later time instead of kind of doing it all at once, Hayes, in regards to the?

1:28:37 Yeah, there is some economy of scale here. I don't know exactly how much it would be, but there is a process where we'd have to re-bid it. There is additional mobilization, cleanup, so forth, that you get some cost savings when you package these projects together. Is it more staff time, too? Oh, absolutely, yeah. That's probably not apples to apples. I'm thinking we'd probably have to re-bid that, and it probably would be higher than what we're probably estimating here, I think is probably the point.

1:29:07 So I think where I fall is somewhere in between what Commissioner Turner and Commissioner Mandel said, because I think that it does, I know that it could snow at any point, but it doesn't seem unfeasible to me for this amount of work, and that could be just me not knowing to get it done if it got approved in the beginning of September, if it was an emergency item tonight.

1:29:37 Bear in mind that MLR would make a recommendation to Town Council and if Town Council would make that. Okay, so it would be then mid-September and then it would have to get locked into working. Okay. But I think that what I would recommend is that going with the Option 3 because I think if you're going to do shade structures, you need to have the slab underneath in order to be able to use it properly and I think it's going to get

1:30:11 the use. But again, I kind of question the emergency part of the language. Thank you. Christy? I have a question that has also come up, and I think this might be directed back to MLR as well as the Commission, just for some background. Are there some opportunity costs in regard to funding other projects or projects that are in the queue right now that this

1:30:39 that option three would affect. Rich can maybe speak to this. There's currently no allocation process. This is obviously an item that's going to come before MLR outside their allocation period, which I think commences in February, Rich. Yep. So at this time there's no items that are being considered for funding by MLR. So, you know, one of the things that I'm looking at, and I have to, again, thank Rich for this.

1:31:08 Awesome Strategic Plan Document and also to Stu for providing the vision and strategic direction for community recreation in Mammoth Lakes because I think that if we go back to some of these strategic documents, we can start establishing a framework for how to think about this. And the mission of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to deliver cutting-edge sustainable recreation, mobility, and arts and culture opportunities.

1:31:36 and Infrastructure for the Benefit of the Community and Natural Environment in Mammoth Lakes. And there's a couple of details in Option 3 that I think are really core to meeting that mission and directive. Also, the mission and directive of Mammoth Lakes Recreation is to maintain the parks to deliver local residents and visitors with high-quality recreation facilities.

1:32:04 Some of the concerns I have include ADA access. We are...

1:32:10 As a municipality, we have to provide access to everybody. That MUP is used by disabled athletes, residents, and visitors alike, and since this is a trail ends park, I think that the accessibility is really important in this calculus, and I'm just not comfortable moving that back and deleting that right now. The other thing has to do with, you know, trash cans and recycling, not just to keep

1:32:39 Clean an area that guests and residents will use alike, because that is used by guests, and we're sending a message to guests when we have trash all over the place. But also in terms of mitigating attracting animals, which can be a sanitary problem, it can be a health problem, and it can also be a safety problem. So with those things in mind, going back to our mission and directive as both agencies and also considering that

1:33:08 putting ADA tables and compliance and trash and things like that on the back burner. I do think that it raises this request up to emergency status because

1:33:26 It's mission critical to both organizations, and there are some health, safety, and accessibility factors that need to be seriously considered. And so with that, I recommend that we go with option three and that it does be considered an emergency for funding. Thank you.

1:33:46 These are all really good comments, and I'm just really appreciative of Emmerin really delving into this and giving it some careful consideration. I have one more question for staff. This is really a question for Hayes, and that is, in option three, is the, I mean, the contingency in there, the status is already partially spent, is $6,000 adequate contingency for the project at this point? Because clearly, we should have had more contingency the last time around. Yeah, at this point in time, we're, we...

1:34:13 Already have the numbers for everything but the pavilion installation, and we've already had a couple conversations with contractors, so we know we're very close on that number. So the contingency is just to cover any small additional items. Now, to your point, had we attacked this in a different way from the get-go, that contingency would probably need to be out ten times that to deal with the uniqueness of Mammoth. And we did. I mean, there are still items that are, I mean, there are.

1:34:43 We didn't order the benches, and so, I mean, we've already exhausted that deductive contingency. Right. Okay, so I have to say, like I think all of you, I am not super thrilled about this, having been the person that had to stand up at MLR and say that we won't be back. So, you know, that's certainly, I think, difficult. And I think for me it's very much a lesson learned in terms of, you know, just...

1:35:10 Consider taking our environment into account, and I certainly understand how we got here because we've been talking about this project the entire time I've been on the commission, and even before that. So it's been six years, and I think that the commission has worked really hard to bring a $1.3 million project down to a scale that...

1:35:32 is more realistic, but also still really serves the community. And when you look at our, you know, the commission's vision and direction, and I alluded to this earlier, you know, one of our, you know, prime directives as a commission and as a department is to support efforts to complete existing park facilities and infrastructure to better serve the needs of the community. That's right there in our vision and strategic direction.

1:35:55 Though less than thrilled about this, I also just recognize, and I've spent a lot of time talking with staff about this. In fact, I was out of town and Rich was out of town and Stu was like, we really need to bring this forward because we really want to complete this park this year. So I do think that the funding consideration, it needs to happen. I think that's really critical. And for me,

1:36:24 I certainly see how we got here. I also think, you know, that's Hayes' point about the concrete is, it's hugely critical. I mean, that's a change we just didn't even think about. And originally when we were planning this park, you know, we were talking about turf and we were trying to, you know, maybe, you know, find some partners with that and then just the drought. I think concrete is, you know, very realistic and very reasonable. And I think even with the increased cost of concrete, it's still...

1:36:51 Probably the most affordable option and the best option for this particular park. I'm a little bit attached to the color of the concrete, mostly because when you look at this park as a whole and you look at the skate park, I mean, that's a lot of concrete in this park across the board. And so I think we just need kind of that contrast. I think it makes it a little more aesthetically pleasing. And I also think when you consider our...

1:37:19 Partnership with Volcom and the fact that we just, you know, renegotiated the naming rights to this park. I think it would be really unfortunate for the community to have delivered, you know, a great product on one half or, you know, a little more than half on the skate park side and then to kind of have our project on, you know, the playground and, you know, our park side fall up short. I think that would be extremely unfortunate and I think it would be...

1:37:42 Not in our best interest to build a pavilion and not have picnic tables under it and not have the concrete pads. So I, you know, very much am leaning toward, you know, toward option number three. And again, you know, it's unfortunate. I understand how we got here, but, you know, Rich, I'm right there with you. I mean, I even said to Stu, I was like, oh my God, this is horrible because now, you know.

1:38:04 What ramifications does this have on this much larger project that we'll soon be bringing forward? So I certainly am very cognizant of that. And, you know, I did. You know, I stood at MLR and I said that we wouldn't be back and perhaps now I'll be back. So it's regrettable, but I do think as a commission that our responsibility is really to the community and to delivering, you know, the best possible product. And I really want to finish this park.

1:38:32 You know, I really don't want to be having this conversation again a few months from now. So, Madam Chair, if I may, I don't think anybody debates the quality of this project. We all want this done. We're all in this together. I think the quandary we're in right now is the process. And I heard you use the word lessons learned. So let's think about this. Think this through. Emergency is a pretty harsh term. We have an emergency.

1:38:58 And I can recall being a school person hanging out at a high school one year, one summer school experience, and it was wild. Sex and drugs and rock and roll, weapons on campus, just crazy stuff. And I was an elementary principal at that time. The first week of school, I went back to my elementary school, and Mrs. Davis, a great first grade teacher, came running to my office. Mr. Baccia, Mr. Baccia, we got an emergency. I'm like, Mrs. Davis, what's the matter? Trevor's chewing gum in my class.

1:39:27 We've got to define emergency. Do we think that there will be other projects that are going to be cost overrun in the future? Absolutely. My recommendation to this group is that we come in this evening to MLR. It's an information item. Give the rationale for where we are. We want these projects to occur. And say we'd like to come back in September as an action item on this. Because if all of a sudden we're coming with an emergency and now something else is a cost overrun, is that going to be another emergency?

1:39:56 So think this through, right? We're working towards the end of the season at this point in time. We want this project done. We've seen option one and option two in the packet. Haven't seen option three in the packet. So this is going to be new information also. That's going to be a handout today. Okay. So in the best of all worlds, let's maybe step back a little bit. We want this done for the greater good. But if we go in with this is the rationale, which I've heard great rationale for. This is where we are.

1:40:24 We'd like to come back in September and go from there. It gives us a few weeks to massage us versus, you know, and you know how sensitive people can be. I do. Hair on the back of the neck is going to be up. Okay. So how do we ease off this? Maybe we have to go slow to go fast, but at the end of the day, we can accomplish this if we're willing to just maybe rethink this a little.

1:40:46 And I'll take that under advisement, but I need the commission to make our recommendation. My two cents on a Tuesday morning. I have one more question. May I ask it of MLR? Rich, I know that there's a lot of concern about costs, especially with the percentage of costs that we have overrun here. And I think that your point is well taken about we need to.

1:41:09 Get a better process for vetting projects so that all of these projects don't balloon and we're not always running around screaming emergency, emergency, emergency. My question is, just in the interest of doing something right the first time or stepping things out, from where you stand in MLR, if the costs

1:41:34 Continue to increase because we're phasing this out or we are delaying it. Are those costs that MLR is willing to consider? I can't speak on the behalf of the board, but personally I'm going to say

1:41:55 Did we not look far enough out and vet this project to know what it was going to cost to start with and backward map? So to me, it's about planning. Oh, I understand that. How well did we plan this? I understand that, but my question is dealing with what we have now where staff is recommending that we could be looking at incurring additional costs later on. I think that's going to be frowned upon. You know, we talked, and this whole thing with Trails End Park came up when we were looking at the temporary shade structure for the ice rink.

1:42:25 And that 145 is on the table at that point in time. So this has been on the table for a while. And you look at all the documents, it's complete, incomplete projects. Trails End Park was one, became one of the top five priority phase projects. 145, you're telling us at 145, this is done. Now you're telling me at 145, it's not done. So it becomes credibility. Now, is it done or not?

1:42:49 And I think if we step back at this and say, okay, it's a priority phase project, we've had some challenges, circle back around again, I would like to think there'd be some serious consideration by the board. So just one more question for staff in terms of, I mean, when do we need to, when does this funding request need to go to council in order to complete the project this year? Does it need to happen this month? I think staff will have to take a step back and have a conversation about that. Okay. All right.

1:43:19 All right. Well, what I'd like us to do as a commission at this point is I'd really like us to consider making a motion just with our recommendation. So is there further deliberation? Well, I actually do have a couple follow-up questions just from after hearing from them. So I think you just answered that if they're not able to take action today, we do just an update. They do action in September. They do approve the money in September.

1:43:49 Am I hearing that that's not enough time to get it to Town Council, get it approved, and get it concrete poured this year? We'd have to step back and take a look at that. That wasn't part of our original schedule. Okay. So I can't say either way. Okay. It would mean that the Council would be making a deliberation on the funding mid-September. Yeah. So it's going to be tight. It may not happen. Right. Yeah. Let's be honest. Yeah. No, I get that.

1:44:15 Just a couple more questions. Again, I would have asked it, but this is kind of follow-up from what we talked about. Can you speak specifically in not too long? I mean, I hope I'm not re-asking a question. What are the drawbacks if we were to go with option one, but at a later date wanted to add the concrete? Obviously, we can't add the red dye around the playground, but as far as taking a step back,

1:44:43 And we did wait until next year. It's a bummer to the public that we're not hitting our expectations, but can you speak a little bit to how much more expensive and how difficult would it be to step back some of these things for 2017? Yeah, staff is fully prepared to move forward as defined in option one. As we articulated in the staff report back in January, we were fully prepared to take out the deductive alternates to get...

1:45:10 What we could get completed within the scope of that project, like I mentioned, we were already kind of aware that this wasn't going to work out for $145,000. That number, I don't want to say it didn't come from us, but the project had changed over the years. Let's just leave it at that. So we'll move forward. We can put the shade structures in. We'll put in the concrete work around the slab without the color. We'll get the project management and everything kind of managed, taken care of, and close it out.

1:45:38 And then if it's the direction to come back and complete the items later next year, we'll reboot. We'll come back and do some new estimates and so forth. And we may or may not provide a number. We'll see how this process shakes out moving forward. And we'll just go from there. But we can make it work where we're at. One more question, I think, and then I'll just have a comment, and then let's go into that.

1:46:05 Okay, so here we are. We're planning the Trails End Park, and this is something that was originally tasked with Recreation Commission. Correct me if I'm wrong, I guess, is where I'm going with this question. Yep, right. MLR gets formed here in the last past couple of years. In the future, is this creating a new park? We want to create a new park. We're starting from the ground up. We're going to make it red dye, blue dye, whatever the case may be in the future.

1:46:32 Is this something we're going to be doing or is it going to be something MLR is going to be doing in the future? I see that if it's related to community asset, then I think we go through a process. I think we currently do in regards to the annual review of our facilities, you know, look at the analysis of the use, the fees, and commission might come forward and say, you know, as a capital investment project, we need to X, Y, Z, you know, I need to look at this park.

1:47:03 Case in point, I think over at Mammoth Creek Park West with the playground, understanding that we need the inclusive elements due to the accessibility and usability of the park. So our recommendation that was to provide that inclusive element to that park. So it came through the commission.

1:47:19 Package is kind of an outline of the framework of the scope of the project and then it kind of just moves through the process as we've been doing. And when you say moves through the process? Into public works, you know, then I think public works would engage in regards to scoping the project, doing the engineering on it. And then typically you would come forward with a request to actually plan and engineer the project, right?

1:47:40 Correct me if I'm wrong, right? And I think that's most of our projects work. So we'd come through with a request for funding to plan and design this park, which is actually what it was back in Trailsland Park in 2010. We applied for $30,000 of Measure Armani in 2010 in the fall. I would like to say that Public Works only used $22,000 of it, right? So, I mean...

1:47:57 This demonstrated fiscal responsibility, and if you look at the project from, I know everyone's talking about, you know, it's a 30% increase. Remember, this started at $490,000 project after it was whittled down from 1.3, then we went to 1.4. So we're 64% under that number of 490, right? So you can see that the commission, you know...

1:48:17 Made an incredible effort to make sure that this was delivering on the expectations but within kind of budget. So I think there's demonstrated fiscal responsibility. So that would be the process. So we would actually, as we move forward with a project, get the planning, get the design, get the engineering, and then off it would go to design. And that's really where Hayes' team comes in. But they become a client of us once we've established the project. So once we've determined the need, outlined the framework, the scope of the project.

1:48:45 Now we're a client of public works. But I guess what I'm asking here is that, and maybe you're answering me, is that the final recommendation on whether to build a project like this, especially in future projects, the final recommendation going to town council is going to come from MLR. Is that correct in the future? Or are you? Or is that inaccurate? So the Recreation Commission is a town council advisory body for...

1:49:16 Recreation. Yes. Recreation. So if you make that assumption, then your recommendation goes through council because of, you know, that reason, MLR is engaged for the strategic use of Measure R, Measure U money. So if there's no Measure R, Measure U money, does MLR even get engaged? You know, I would think so because they're a partner and we're all trying to, you know, get along and, you know, make sure the benefit of it, you know, so forth, so forth as defined in the strategic plan.

1:49:43 But I think, you know, these are great questions and I think as we further delineate our responsibilities, we further define our roles and purposes together, that's why I'm very eager to get in front of the MLR board for certainly our new commissioners and to kind of reiterate and kind of clarify these kind of questions of how we engage and how we best work together as these two organisations with, you know, really the similar vision.

1:50:10 Our missions might be a little bit different, but when you look at that vision statement, our vision statement is to elevate Mammoth to be the best recreation community in the country, and MLR share that vision as well. So we have the same vision. It's just how we get there, I think, is the mechanics of what you're kind of bringing up. Okay. The only comment I want to say then with regard in getting that answered is, and Rich, I said this earlier, is I hate to punt.

1:50:36 To you guys and let you guys make the decision. But if we don't say that it's an emergency, then you don't actually have the ability to take action. And you know what? There's nothing wrong with us saying, hey, we view this as an emergency because we want to fulfill the expectations of this commission that we've passed on. And you guys saying, we don't see it as an emergency. You guys then, as you've said, are already prepared to act, whether it's option one, two, or three.

1:51:05 So I just want to say that as we go into the motions that are about to happen, forgive me for punting. Let's just think about the process. The Brown Act defines emergency when a prompt action is needed due to actual or threatened disruption of public facilities. Let's just think about the process because we're going to go over on things in the future. Let's hold on to an emergency when it really is an emergency. Point taken.

1:51:38 And all that criteria came to the immediate attention and the need for action came to the attention of the town subsequent to the agenda being posted. So this came after we posted. So we don't need to use the actual word emergency. I would stop. One more comment. Okay. Yeah, I would really like us to take a motion on the commission's recommendation based on the staff presentation and our deliberation. If there's no further deliberation, I would entertain a motion.

1:52:09 Okay. I'll go ahead and make a motion, if I may, that we do move this to the MLR recommending option three as an item for action. Okay. I second. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion?

1:52:25 The only thing that would, actually since now is time to make the discussion, I didn't ask you about it, but Warren, you did make mention of that if we go with option three and it's concrete that there is some savings with regard to maintenance on an annual basis. If you could please outline that. I don't think we need to necessarily see it, but if you could outline that for MLR this evening. Can I also add to that in the interest of just costs and funding and stuff like that?

1:52:53 Stu, you also said that there's some opportunity to rent out the pavilion, which could represent some cost recovery. Yep. So if we could get that information as well. We'll have that when, I don't think we can actually put that in until we actually have the facility, is that correct? But every year the commission reviews. Yep. Fee schedule. Fee schedule. So you'll see that in February, yeah. But that was certainly our motivation for keeping the pavilion in this project.

1:53:24 Okay. So if there's no further discussion, we have a motion and a second in favor of option three. So Jamie, I'm actually going to do a roll call vote on this, please. Mr. Martin? Yes. Mr. Mendel? No. Mr. Osborne? Yes. Vice Chair Turner? Yes. Chair Truex? Yes. Motion passes four to one. Thank you, everyone. We'll take that to MLR this evening. Thank you. Thanks, everybody.

1:53:53 Do you want to keep going? Thank you. The only thing I wanted to ask is, yeah, I would like to list a grant for the items six and seven. Okay, do you want to recess or do you want to just keep rolling? No, let's keep going. Okay, does anyone else want to recess or not? I'm good to keep going. Thank you very much. Thanks, Hayes. Thanks, Warren. Okay, so that brings us on to item number six, to review and accept the annual Recreation Commission meeting and work plan calendar.

1:54:25 Stuart, do you want to talk about this a little bit? Just briefly. Yeah, thank you, Chair. So the item before you is to review and accept the annual Recreation Commission meeting and work plan calendar. So the goal here is to provide the Commission with obviously scheduled meeting dates, which is helpful for your planning and calendars, but also provide these major work items that we have and the Commission has responsibility for as part of the duties as described in 2.40.

1:54:53 of the Municipal Code. So before you can see, it just includes our regular meetings, adjustments for public holidays. You can see, for instance, in July, we don't schedule a meeting in July, and actually the meeting was scheduled on July 4th at that time. So if there is a need to schedule a meeting in July, the Commission can make that request in June.

1:55:20 But we typically don't schedule a meeting in July. It also does not include any work plan items related to Mammoth Creek Park, and we'll talk about that in a subsequent item. We've just finished a lengthy process for our programming where we're scheduling several special meetings of the commission, and it doesn't at this time include any town council workshops. We strive to engage the town council at least twice a year.

1:55:49 So at this time we haven't scheduled those workshops. And then there's also an opportunity here to schedule a retreat with the Commission to discuss several items that I think you can see is coming forward that would benefit the ongoing Commissioners and then certainly the new Commission as it pertains to a number of items that we've...

1:56:14 Talked about and also a part of this work plan moving forward. So there's an opportunity there to kind of schedule a retreat. But at this time, all staff is requesting commission review and accept the scheduled meeting calendar, the major work plan items, and any work plan item can be moved.

1:56:35 What staff typically do is provide an outline of upcoming items for discussion and then the commission at each meeting can also request items for the agenda as well. So that's how items make it to the calendar and the discussion items for commission. In highlighted in yellow you can see the action that Town Council would be taking regarding the items before the commission. For example,

1:57:01 We are striving to bring back the sponsorship program in September and then it would go forth to the council on September 21st. You can see we bring forth our summer programming analysis in October. That would go to council again just as a highlight of summer in October. And then the bigger document that we're working on right now is kind of the adoption of our annual policies department procedures and fee schedule to the commission in February and March and then that would go to...

1:57:29 Council mid-March because a lot of those fees are required to sell our products by April. So that's kind of a brief overview. Any questions? I'll turn it back to the Commission. Thank you, Chair. Okay, thank you. Any questions on the calendar? Okay. On September 6th, it says workshop with Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board, 5 p.m. Is that in addition to the meeting?

1:57:54 Nine to noon? Yes, that's correct. So we meet at nine o'clock on the first Tuesday of the month, generally, and they meet at five o'clock on the first Tuesday of the month. So I think in the interest of having their board available as well as ourselves, I think that's the date that we were looking for. And I think the hope was that we would have this discussion with MLR about roles and responsibilities, and then we would maybe schedule our retreat following that.

1:58:24 Regular meeting in the morning and then also meeting with their board in the evening. Correct. And, Stu, have we confirmed that date with them? This is based on their availability. I don't know. Again, we're going to make that request during public comment today at MLR. Okay. The commission has scheduled or made available this time on September 6th. Will that fit within their schedule? Does that work for everyone then, September 6th? Probably some flexibility there.

1:58:53 Again, I don't know if that's actually a meeting date of the MLR board. I know it typically is on a Tuesday. But I was hoping to use that time during their scheduled time to actually have that workshop. So we're not having two boards then making two different kind of meeting dates. But that's the first meeting of September. I believe that's when they meet. And if they're able to carve out an hour of the time, I think that would be very beneficial. Okay. So we'll propose that to them and go from there. Great.

1:59:23 Okay, so is everyone comfortable with the calendar as presented then? Okay, terrific. And then is it the desire of the Commission to schedule a retreat for ourselves to kind of, you know, one of the things that the Vision and Strategic Direction for Community Recreation was adopted in 2014 following MLR's formation.

1:59:46 The retreat would kind of be an opportunity for us to go through that document, kind of see where we are two years on and where we want to go from here. I think we've accomplished a lot of things in that document, but we probably have some future goals. And that would be a good setting, I think, for us. What's the date on that? We don't have a date yet. I wanted to make sure everyone wants it. And then we can look at some dates. I think it would be good. Consensus on yes. Do we need to think about dates today, though?

2:00:13 What I would suggest is maybe Stu can kind of push out some dates to us and go from there. Maybe we can start with a month. Pick a month. I can't get past. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And thank you for being here this morning. I really appreciate it. So I think what we'll do is we'll go to MLR. We'll see if that date will work for them for the retreat, and then we'll go from there. Okay, great. So any further discussion on that or we're good? We have consensus? Consensus is good. Great. So terrific.

2:00:43 That brings us to item number seven. This is a standing item for us, the Community Multi-Use Recreation Facilities Plan MCP Planning Update. So what's the latest? So the latest as described in agenda item seven, you can see the work right now by staff is through the EIR process, and you can see that is scheduled for consideration of certification in January 2017. So as Commissioner Turner would ask, it's still on schedule. Good. You're welcome.

2:01:11 And what we provide below you is kind of a calendar of items that you can see coming forward to get to that point in January. The notice of preparation, as you can see, complete, and I've attached that to the document just for the benefit of the new commissioners who mightn't have seen that. I'm currently working on the draft EIR currently, and you can see that's going to be available for public review in October.

2:01:35 The final EIR is scheduled for December 2016, and then you can see the associated public hearings and the certification in January. You can see we still provide any updates regarding the project to planmcp.com, and any commissioner at any time is welcome to come and at least ask staff or any questions relating to the project. Talking about design, HMC are working on some design concepts right now, so happy to...

2:02:05 Kind of share those with you if you desire to see those, and that's going to be part of the draft EIR as it moves forward. Very preliminary. It's really, again, just a basic layout of the facility, just in a little bit more detail on what was provided before. And then they're responding to our questions through the environmental consultant. I would say that we're looking at adding additional studies relating to the EIR.

2:02:35 And that's part of the process. So there will be additional funding for that. But that's something we want to make sure that the EIR is complete and every study and resource is being analyzed for the benefit of the public. So are you referencing the archaeological additional study that will be at Council this week? Yeah, additional cultural study. So that's an additional, I think it's $20,000 increase in the cost of the EIR.

2:03:05 Council will consider that. And that's not unusual, right? Not unusual. As far as additional study, what we would be looking at is as this moves forward, we are moving forward also with kind of an outline of the kind of programming. The commission completed a great process with the community as part of the programming effort. We created the playbooks and a lot of the commissioners were part of that. The work effort for the...

2:03:33 Staff coming into the fall once we wrap up our summer programming is to get back into that program and start to frame out the kind of an operating schedule and start to assign some revenue and expenditures looking at some proposed fee schedules. Again, you know, it's all just preliminary. It's all just a pro forma, so to speak. But that's a work effort coming forward that certainly the commission will be engaged in and certainly the ad hoc recreation programming committee.

2:04:00 as it moves forward. But that's kind of the outline. So our goal there is to have something in place by the end of the year that would give us an idea of, based on the design of the facility, because we're still finalizing the design, but based on the design and the area that we have to work with, how would programming complement that facility? And we could potentially look at kind of a design review committee as that moves forward, right? Could be as well. Could be part of that.

2:04:26 Similar to what we did with programming. Right. I still think there's a lot of work, but it goes back to Commissioner Turner's question in regards to the role of the commission. So right now the commission is, you know, certainly the town staff is charged with, you know, determining the programming, right, of that facility. Right, so based on what we're seeing right now, how are we planning the programming, you know, what is the cost of that programming and what's the cost of operations and the maintenance and so forth. So that's the charge of the department and the commission. Yeah.

2:04:56 Any other questions? Thank you very much. I'm going to ask the question, how does Hart Howerton presentation play into this? I think it's too early to say. I think there was a comment in the paper, I think if you read that in regards to the town manager was asked that same question, and I think there's some public review that's recommended on that project.

2:05:26 So too early for staff. I mean, staff right now, we have our direction from council to proceed with this project, and we're still proceeding with that project. Until council tells us otherwise, then that's our direction. Okay. Yeah. I guess the only comment I want to make is that, you know, the Howerton plan actually intrigues me. It's interesting. But it sure does affect this work, and I sure do wish we had seen it about two years ago.

2:05:58 Yeah, and I purposely left that off our agenda just because it's, you know, it was a presentation. Nothing has been. I understand. But at the same time, there's this storm surge out there. Yeah. And I would just like us to be aware of it because we have made promises to the public. And you know what? Like I said, the Hart-Howerton plan is not a bad one. Really wish we'd seen it two years ago. I think we'll be talking about it more in the future. Thank you. Any other questions for staff?

2:06:31 Okay. Terrific. And I would encourage all of you, if you have just questions about what's coming in from the architects and the EIR process, the staff is always available to meet with anyone. And Stu's done a great job of keeping the website updated as well. So I encourage everyone to take a look at that. And that brings us to item number eight, the Parks and Recreation Sponsorship Program. Sure. If I may, I apologize, but I really would like to excuse myself at this time. Thank you very much. Thank you, Sean. Looking forward to Looza, Looza. Yep. Thanks.

2:07:04 So just briefly, no actions requested by staff for the Commission today. It's really just an update. Just in the staff report, we've articulated that we brought this forward on May 3rd and again on May 31. The same document is attached to this staff report. You can see we've also taken it to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Development and Fundraising Committee. We've engaged that group as well.

2:07:29 At this time, it's still under review by the town attorney. So until we actually get some comments and some recommendations to the document, really no action can be taken on this document. So my goal, as you can see, is to bring this forward in September, hopefully for review and acceptance, and then off to town council, and then we can move on getting a naming sponsor for the new facility. There we go. Super.

2:07:55 All right. Any questions on it as it currently exists? Okay. I would encourage everyone to obviously just, you know, take a close look at this because hopefully we'll be adopting it soon. All right. Excellent. So that brings us to the end of our policy items. Next up we have commissioner reports. So Clayton, I'll start with you. Nothing to report. Okay. Christy. Nothing to report. Laurel.

2:08:22 Nothing to report. Okay. My only report is I've been out of town for a couple of weeks, and while I was gone, I had the opportunity to look at some recreation facilities where I was, and so I looked at some playgrounds that very much, like what we're discussing with Mammoth Creek Park, are they're not...

2:08:40 Fully inclusive playgrounds, but they're ADA compliant, but they have inclusive elements. I was able to see up close and personal some of those, which is really interesting, and it seems to work pretty well for the communities where I visited. So that's all I have. So thank you. Any requests for agenda items for the next meeting? We have pretty well calendared, I think. Anyone have anything to add to the calendar that we've sort of accepted?

2:09:10 I think we're good on that. Sponsorship will be coming back, Plan MCP. Well, if there is nothing further, then I will adjourn us to our next regular meeting, which is on September 6th at 9 a.m., and I just would remind all of you that we have ethics training tomorrow here in Suite Z. 1 o'clock, Jamie? 1 to 3? 1.30. Okay. So, thank you, everyone. Congratulations to our new commissioners. We are adjourned. Thank you, everyone.