Town Council
· recording 3 hr 54 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
390 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:01:44 Hold on, it's ejecting right now. Okay, let's see if that works. Here. Good chance.
1:02:39 Thanks. I'd like to call to order the
1:03:21 Town Council meeting for August 3rd. We just came out of closed session where there was no reportable action. So with that, we'll start the meeting. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. I'm going to lead the Pledge of Allegiance tonight. Thanks. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.
1:03:56 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible. Okay, now is the time for public comments, so anything that is not on the agenda, would you please step forward and announce your name? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council members, staff, members of the community, Rich Baccia, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors met last evening. We were honored to have Mr. Tom Hodges present the Reader's Digest version.
1:04:37 The Hart-Howerton Report. The Mammoth Lakes Board of Directors like to go on record as follows. Number one, MLR is very much wanting to consider location of recreation community facilities as catalysts for desired economic growth and sustainability. Number two, MLR is very interested in the downtown vision outlined in the Hart-Howerton presentation and wants to engage in the work to help achieve that vision.
1:05:04 Number three, MLR's strategic plan also aligns with much of the Hart-Howerton vision and believes there's synergy to build on between the two. Number four, MLR is not bashful of asking questions and pausing processes to make sure we get it right. Thank you. Mammoth greatness is the only option. Thank you, Rich. Anyone else? Good evening. My name is Amy Creston. I'm with the Eastern Sierra Symphony, formerly Sierra Summer Festival.
1:05:38 Thank you so much.
1:06:02 String quartets, and we tell you a little bit about each composer, but we don't tell you who the composer is, and you can all guess at the end of the evening. It's big fun. We're featuring a 15-year-old cellist on the Friday night concert, a national award-winning cellist. We have a new artistic director, Edwin Outwater, who's got an international career, and we are just tickled pink that he accepted to join us here in Mammoth Lakes.
1:06:30 We are easternstorosymphony.org, so you can find tickets and information on there. Let's see. Saturday night soloist is Susie Park from the Lincoln Center Chamber Players. We have Nathaniel Stokey, who's a California-based composer, who was the youngest composer ever to be asked to write a piece for the San Francisco Symphony. He was commissioned when he was 17 years old.
1:06:55 And he's doing the second performance ever of his piece entitled YTTE, which stands for Yield to Total Elation. And he will be playing an instrument that he built. So it should be very diverse. Our youngest performer is 10. I will be sharing a music stand with her, last down second violin on the Friday night concert.
1:07:20 I think our oldest are in their 70s. So it's a multi-generational festival with a side-by-side component of super talented kids next to professionals. We've got people coming from St. Louis Symphony, Minnesota Orchestra, San Francisco Symphony, Los Angeles Philharmonic, Los Angeles Opera, Los Angeles Chamber Orchestra. So really top-notch national players sitting right next to the next generation of musicians. So it's a really unique vibe. It's really fun for us to sit next to.
1:07:49 Kids who are 15 instead of people our age. And they learn a lot and they just make tremendous progress in the one week that they're here playing in a professional orchestra. So that's it. Please come. Please tell everybody to come Friday because we want it to be just available. We'd like everybody to be able to hear this. We're real proud of what we're doing. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, Pat Eckert, Mammoth Lakes. I'm kind of a horse.
1:08:22 And I want to mention water. I was on the water board back in the 90s for quite a few years, and I learned a lot about water. And so I saw this article in the paper just today, and it galvanized me. It says, help replenish our groundwater. Follow level three instructions. We are not meeting our conservation goal. Are you doing your part to replenish our groundwater?
1:08:52 Since I sort of know a lot about water, I used to refer to it as what it means to live at the top of a watershed. I used to, when I was on the water board and I'd be riding up the chairlift, I'd keep going into my little spiel about that. And so I think it's a very important issue when it comes to development. And I'm not against development, but there's a cautionary tale here that we could run out of water. We can't. There was a book.
1:09:21 I'm sure there's a new one now, but I have, this one is 1992, a feasibility study for alternative sources of water supply and methods of reducing demand. This is 1992, and it talks about growth, and I learned a lot about water. So it's a cautionary tale. That's basically what it is. And so then when I saw this currently,
1:09:50 Appealing to the community to reduce their water use, I thought maybe this would be a good time to spread the word that we don't have endless amounts of water, and especially in drought years. If we don't have snow for four or five years, where's the water? And we don't get all the water. A lot of it, Duck Lake has to maintain at a certain level, and so we can't drain it. Mammoth Creek.
1:10:17 Thank you. Thank you. Hello. I'm Donna for Gimme Shelter Carnival.
1:10:50 And I wanted to thank you, everyone, for your support on a great event. And I want to thank Stu for all of his help that he did. He guided me in the permits and all that. And we did quite well, and we had a great turnout. And I donated a good portion to Susie with Wild Iris, and now she'll tell you where it goes.
1:11:12 Good evening. For the new council members, I'm Susie with Wild Iris. So we received a donation of $5,000 from the carnival, which is huge for us and huge for the transitional housing program that allows us to continue to keep some single parents and their children.
1:11:34 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Donna. Thank you, Susie.
1:12:00 Good evening, Mayor Richardson, Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth, and esteemed councilmen and councilwomen. My name is Sandra Di Domizio. I'm a local business owner. I employ four people. I'm a neighbor, resident, mom, and very proud member of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Currently, I'm the president of the board of directors of the Chamber of Commerce. And at your last council meeting, I believe my...
1:12:27 Fellow Director Eric Clark came and spoke about some of the very exciting programs that the Chamber's been working on. Our Board of Directors is all volunteer-based. We have one-and-a-half paid administrators. So we all work very, very hard and have been working hard on some of these programs. I'm here to tell you about my favorite one, one that's near and dear to my heart, and that's the Peak Performance Program. We affectionately refer to it as the PPP.
1:12:56 This is a program with a goal of improving the customer service levels in town.
1:13:04 We find that they're fluctuating, and we find that a lot of reviewers online also find them fluctuating and inconsistent. So the Peak Performance Program is our effort to educate employees in town, the frontline staff and their managers, and to increase their levels of customer service. The Peak Performance Program consists of an online training module.
1:13:28 A la Traffic School, in a way. It takes about 35 minutes to complete, and there are two modules. One is a basic level of local information, local education, and then the other is specific to your area of business, whether it's retail, lodging, restaurant, or other. And afterwards, you get a certificate, and you can use that certificate to make you more employable in town, or to boast, or to put in your window, your storefront.
1:13:58 We are very proud of the Peak Performance Program. It's a work in progress, and currently we're working on rewards and treats for those who complete it, and we're going to work with a lot of local partners to provide some great rewards. Along with the online program, we have speakers at our monthly power lunches that are in keeping with the spirit of the Peak Performance Program. So we'll have speakers on customer service, on social media marketing, on online reviews.
1:14:27 In fact, our next speaker is Mammoth Mountain's own Rudy DeFelice, who actually authored a book on exceptional customer service. So we're definitely motivated and proud of this program. We encourage you all to come to our monthly power lunches and after hours to network and learn more about the Peak Performance Program, and we encourage you all to take it.
1:14:52 It's free. It's free for everyone right now. Eventually, we might apply a fee for non-chamber members. And that's it about the Peak Performance Program. Thank you so much. Thank you for those of you who supported our efforts and this program. And we look forward to seeing your names pop up as those who have completed the program because we do run a report. And so we know everyone in town who's completed the program and is worthy of their certificate.
1:15:21 Thank you. Sandra, when's your next Power Lunch? Our next Power Lunch is? The third Tuesday. The third Tuesday of every month. So I believe it's next Tuesday. And our guest speaker is? John Poimeru, who is a marketing specialist, very familiar with this area. I should know all of that by heart, acknowledged. But Craig, our executive director, is here to help.
1:15:56 Thank you. Very good. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay. We'll close public comments and move on to Councilmember reports. But first, are there any additions to the agenda? Yes. Yes, Mr. Mayor, if I may, we do have a request to add an urgency item. It's related to a resolution that allows us to submit applications to the Department of...
1:16:21 Resource Recycling Recovery or Cal Recycle for grants, et cetera. You've had to do one other emergency meeting in the past on this item. Kind of the rules change and or who's authorized changes. So we're hoping this will be a cleanup to allow us to do some stuff going forward, but it does allow us to apply for grants. The deadline for it is this Thursday. And we were working on this the last few days with engineering and myself trying to get it squared away. And the bottom line was, well, change your resolution and then we can actually have you do this stuff.
1:16:51 So we can get our grants and stuff in on time. So the recommendation is to add it to the agenda. You need to take specific action to do that. If so, we'd recommend that it just be added to the consent calendar. It's a pretty straightforward item. Okay, so on this emergency item, we will need to have a motion to actually add it to the agenda. Okay, I'll accept the motion. So moved. Do I have a second? Second.
1:17:21 I have a first and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. So it was moved and seconded, moved by Councilman Fernie and seconded by Councilman Sauser and carried by a 5-0 vote that pursuant to the government code section 5-4-9-5-4.
1:17:50 Point 2B2, the Council hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action and that the need for the action came to the attention of the town subsequent to the agenda being posted as specified in subdivision A, said item being just being, what's the title of this? Yeah, adopt the resolution. Adopt the resolution authorizing submittal of application.
1:18:23 All right. With that, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports.
1:18:57 Councilman Sauser, can I start with you? You can. I have no reports. That was passed. Okay. Councilman Hoff. Yes, I attended things that some of the other fellows did, so I'm just going to tell you where I went. I went to the chamber mixer at Mono.
1:19:16 Arts Council downstairs, and that was wonderful. Got to meet some new business owners there. Of course, the wonderful police department groundbreaking. There was a stakeholders summit series on Mammoth Lakes affordable housing, and I attended that as well as the board meeting of Mammoth Lakes Housing. And I will leave the report parts to the real people who were supposed to be there. Fair enough. Councilman Fernie.
1:19:45 Thank you. It's a couple items for me, some of the same. We just had our changeover, so I attended my last Mammoth Lakes Recreation meeting on Thursday, July 21st. Mayor Richardson is now taking over that seat. We all attended the police department groundbreaking on Wednesday, July 27th. I think that's a very exciting thing for the police department, for the community, and I anticipate that that's one of many.
1:20:14 Coming over the next few years. I also attended the Housing Summit. That's the first of three. So there'll be two more opportunities for people to come out and engage in that issue. I've now joined Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So I attended a couple of meetings regarding that. The first was John Urdi reached out to a number of leaders throughout the community, business owners, et cetera.
1:20:42 To start to discuss the TBID renewal process that is up for renewal in 2018. So we wanted to get out in front of that, discuss, you know, what's been successful, what needs to be adjusted, put together a communications plan. So we are just starting that process. But I did attend that meeting, very well attended and very productive.
1:21:04 On Monday, I attended my first MLT board meeting, so I've got a couple items to report out on that. One major thing that I'm going to continue to discuss over the next couple of months, Mammoth Lakes Tourism has now decided to allocate 25% of their annual marketing spend for a fall push, so I think that's an important thing for the business community to understand.
1:21:30 A lot of dollars and resources are going to be put into driving visitation for the fall colors. So I think it's something at least for the business community to take into consideration as they consider shutting down for a period of time or anything like that. So that's going to be new for this year, and that's something important. A couple other items that we went over at the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Meeting.
1:21:56 We did get a presentation from Michael Vanderhurst, who's in charge of international marketing for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, just to report out on all the international efforts that we're doing currently, and then a couple of new markets that we're looking to jump into, most notably China. So that's something that they're looking at trying to break into. We did have a pretty significant and important discussion on the events funding.
1:22:24 That's something we've given council direction on that over the last couple years, that we believe that should come out of the purview of MLR, and we need to find a new home for that. There were some people that were discussing potentially having that housed under Mammoth Lakes Tourism. The board did vote to not bring that in-house to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. The suggestion is that's going to be a contractual relationship.
1:22:48 Via the town. So that's something that we'll have. We're meeting on that again tomorrow morning, but that's something that I'll kind of report on how that finally works out. But that's a direction as of now is it would not go housed under Mammoth Lakes Tourism. It'd be a similar relationship to Joel and trails. That's a good parallel. So that was an important thing. And I think that's really it.
1:23:13 We've gotten a lot of reports on the fantastic TOT numbers coming through, and those just continue to go up and up. We will be well over $15 million, which is very exciting. I've never been above $12 million before. So that's it for me. Thank you. Thank you very much, Colin. Councilman Wentworth. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Mayor, Mayor, Mayor. So we all attended the...
1:23:40 Because of the timing of it, the July 20th, a very special presentation from Mammoth Mountain Skier in Hart Howerton. I know it was a very interesting presentation for all of us. And I think I just want to commend, I know we all want to commend the skier and their leadership team, which is not just Rusty Gregory. It's Rusty, Ron Cohen, Mark Brownlee, Mark Claussen, Dave Likens, Eric Fursell, and Eric Clark.
1:24:07 For your persistence and your doggedness over four or five very difficult years.
1:24:15 To bring back to the community a level of capital investment that is impressive, it's inspiring, and to bring forward a vision that's going to inspire a lot of folks to get a lot of things done. I think the town, you know, we have been busy as well, and I think it's important to point out that the town, the council has established for a second year in a row priorities and strategic direction, which I guess, which I think is...
1:24:39 Historic in the history of the town as well, and we've got a framework and established some ways forward that we're very eager to engage with the mountain, with other proponents, and that we also have, through the alignment process with the NGOs, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, Mammoth Lakes Housing, and ESTA, that we've got a wide variety of capacity to engage with these kinds of opportunities, and we're very much looking forward to how we're going to do this. I think probably some fact-finding in order, and I think there's some...
1:25:08 Some things that we're going to be doing from the town side to actively engage with the ski area and figure out what this all looks like. We've already heard from Mr. Baccia and the MLR folks. Sounds like there's a little chomping at the bit going on over there. It's very exciting to see. So you've got them riled up, so that's a good thing. And July 25th, I attended the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative meeting in Lone Pine. This is part of our strategic goal for sustainable recreation. That's all part of that process that's coming together.
1:25:37 July 27th, groundbreaking for the new police station, and I echo Colin's sentiments about we're going to be having a lot more of these in the future. I also had a meeting with Dakota Higgins from Congressman Cook's office. We chatted for about an hour just checking in on relationships and communications and how to ensure that we communicate effectively with our representatives in Washington. On July 28th, I had a meeting with Patrick Hayes and John Peterson of the Mammoth Community Water District.
1:26:05 It's been written up in the paper, and a lot of people have talked to me anecdotally about the presentation the Water District made to the Mammoth County Board of Supervisors. There have been some important and very interesting developments. Mr. Mayor, Dan, I would request that we reach out to Pat Hayes and bring some kind of representation of that presentation back to Council and to the community. I think it's worth our time to engage with this, so I look forward to seeing that in the near future.
1:26:31 I attended the ESCOG meeting on July 29th. A couple items there. A gentleman named Randy Short from the State Parks Division of Boating and Waterways Commission. This is a state commission that is representing that they've got some resources. They've got some things that we might want to take advantage of. They're requesting local government participation in a tour of facilities. It's happening on August 9th.
1:26:54 And the Department of Water, Division of Boating and Water Race Commission is going to be meeting August 10th in Bishop. So I don't know if, Dan, we could maybe send someone down there to participate in that. I think it's one of those states there might be some interesting opportunities there. We also had a very interesting conversation about regional air service. Jen Lohman and Robin Hunt from the FAA were here. Inyo County was well represented. Grady was there. Very interesting conversation. There's a request.
1:27:23 By motion from the ESCOG for the town to establish some representatives for a communication channel between Inyo County and the town to further explore options around reliable regional air service. And I would leave it to Dan to maybe follow up on that. I don't know exactly how you want to configure that, but we may need to make an appointment as an elected. It was specific to have some elected representation along with staff. So I'll leave that to Dan to follow up on that. The forest plan.
1:27:51 There was an item on the agenda having to do with the Forest Plan, and all agencies that were represented at the meeting voted to recommend back to the four sister agencies a list of items from the Forest Plan Division specific around recreation and sustainable recreation for consideration for each one of the four agency boards. I believe that Dan has shared that. If it's in the packet, he's got it as a handout for us to take a look at. But, yeah, and this is the SCOG has established four.
1:28:21 Areas of focus, recreation, technology, reliable regional air service, and waste management stuff. And this is one of those four areas. So it's specific to recreation, but it's worth all of us taking a look at. I attended the Mammoth Lakes Board, Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting is my first meeting, taking over from Councilman Fernie, who did a great job over there. And we had some interesting discussions and some things to share with the public and to share with us.
1:28:48 MLH is having a series of stakeholder meetings that Cleland mentioned. I think it's important for people to be attending this to try to get sort of an inventory from the community of what's happening on the public housing front. The next one's going to be on August 17th from 1 to 3 at the Eli Randall room at Mammoth Lakes Library. In this particular summit, stakeholders will share resources, begin working towards consensus on solutions around housing.
1:29:16 New economic chapter is an important thing to probably be paying attention to. MLH has been working to establish a baseline regarding transient rentals with the town in order to better understand the housing stock. And there's been a data issue that I think there's something going on with the data transfer to the new Cassell system.
1:29:36 About 50% of the data regarding TOT business tax certificates and associated APNs is they can't find it. So I think it's an issue we need to follow up with that. It's part of our quality of life ordinance back around the nightly rental issue that the data piece was a very important one. I just wanted to bring that to your attention so we've got to follow up on it and get that kind of squared away. And MLH has been working on some due diligence efforts around the shady rest parcel.
1:30:04 Completed a financial feasibility analysis for one of the phases. They're also talking, they're tracking very closely the cap and trade grants to be able to find money to move forward on that opportunity. I discussed, we discussed with the board, the reality is the fact that the MLH, the town doesn't have any ownership interest in the shady rest parcel, but it's part of a way to have an engaged conversation with the property owners. And I think it's a good thing for them to move forward on this, and we'll see where this goes.
1:30:33 We also talked about trying to bring something back to the council to start talking about taking a sense of the council as to the zoning on that parcel over there, and that may be helpful to all parties to clarify if they pursue some negotiations where we stand with the zoning overlay in that parcel. So I think I talked with Dan about that, maybe bringing something back to council to get some sense of that.
1:30:58 They also reviewed the Hart-Harrington presentation. Tom Hodges was there and gave. It wasn't the same Reader's Digest version. He didn't have the benefit of visual aids. He had to do finger puppets and that kind of stuff. But it's very good to have Tom there and to share with them his thoughts on that and the board.
1:31:15 Just noted that housing didn't seem to be a major theme of the presentation, but they're very happy to get it and receive it. I attended the MLR board meeting August 2nd for a good part of the meeting, heard the discussion about the Recreation Commission and funds, you know, additional funding things. I'm very much looking forward to taking advantage of all the teachable moments that came out of that process, and I think this is coming back to Council on August 17th. I'm looking forward to hearing from staff.
1:31:43 MLR and the rec commission, how to maybe kind of smooth some of that stuff out so that, you know, things can go smoother in the future. Very much looking forward to the hockey rink, how that proposal is going to be forward to make sure that we're all on the same page with regards to numbers and budgets and expectations and all that kind of stuff. Hockey rink slash multi-use facility.
1:32:04 We can talk. The semantic history in that project is interesting. I look forward to having that conversation. And finally, everybody's comments to the Inyo National Forest for the Forest Planned Division are due August 25th. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you. Colin, you wanted to? Yeah, Dan, just one thing I wanted to interject. Kind of in light of this conversation we've had, we've had a shifting around for all of our NGOs, and we just went through that lengthy process of engaging in the, you know.
1:32:31 Council strategic priorities with our NGOs. I'm wondering if we could get some feedback from you, you know, maybe at a later date or a different time. I think me personally, and, you know, I'll look for some direction from the rest of the council, but I'm interested in...
1:32:46 You know, what the status of the contracts with each of those four NGOs is, when they're up for renewal. I think it's important now that we've done the strategic priorities to make sure that that kind of gets infused into contracts moving forward. So if we could maybe just get a report out at a future council meeting or any feedback you have now as far as what's the timeline on that stuff and when the council will have an opportunity to kind of engage in that stuff moving forward. I think a real quick update. We're working with the EDs from the NGOs to kind of an ongoing reporting system back on this.
1:33:15 Thank you. Thank you.
1:33:43 Right. I very much support that, but in terms of us being able to look at what's in scopes of works, how it lines up with, you know, strategic priorities and that kind of stuff. I would support that. Yeah, we plan on having a lot of joint meetings coming forward. Yeah, sounds good. For me, a lot of things have already been said, but the police department groundbreaking, I think, was a...
1:34:10 Something that hopefully we see a lot more groundbreakings going forward here, and I think we will. I also attended the Inyo Forest revision on August 1st, which was at Sierra Cosa College. A lot of great information there. I would suggest those people that are interested, and you all should be interested, attend one of these. It was eye-opening for me. So please attend. And I also attended my first MLR.
1:34:40 Meeting yesterday. Trying to get the feet wet, so to speak. But a lot of heavy lifting has already been done. And Councilman Fernie, you did a lot of that, and I appreciate it. But yesterday they approved their strategic priorities document, pretty much. They approved their allocation strategy, which are huge. I mean, they've been working on it for a while. And they also approved the Trails End Park, finally.
1:35:09 You know, getting it done. And so this is hopefully something that's going to be coming forward for ratification by the council, but the rec commission and MLR both say, let's get it done. So that was an exciting piece. Tom Hodges, it was on his speaking trail, if you will. He was at MLR going over.
1:35:40 We call the Hart-Howerton concept vision presentation. And to that point, I'd like to work with you, John, and go to the mountain, do that fact finding. And I think it's very important that there's transparency in all this.
1:36:03 Everybody knows what's going on because we want to report back to you what's going on. We want to keep this in front of everybody. It is exciting. It's time for this community to begin to share a vision and get together and actually make it happen. So if you'd be my partner on that, I'd appreciate it. All right, good. Other than that, I have nothing else.
1:36:34 Reports from commissions and departments. Room service. Good. I'm glad you can take a beverage break. Let's take me a minute to get over here. Good evening, Mr. Mayor.
1:37:00 Mayor Pro Tem, Councilmembers, staff, public, Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair, just a really brief update on the Parks and Recreation side. The Recreation Commission met yesterday. We had kind of a little summer hiatus, so it was nice to have everyone back and very exciting to have our new commissioners sworn in. So we're very, very excited about our new team. Thank you very much. And I was really...
1:37:23 Quite pleased with their enthusiasm and participation. We tried to keep it kind of a light agenda, and it didn't work out that way. So really terrific to have everyone raring to go. In addition, Sean Turner was elected as our new vice chair, and I obviously remain the chair.
1:37:39 So the commission also received a presentation from the MLR executive director on the MLR strategic plan that they adopted last night, as the mayor mentioned. The commission really appreciated the opportunity to make comments, which I then took to MLR last night, and we're working on scheduling a joint workshop for the two bodies, hopefully in September, maybe October. So really looking forward to just that relationship continuing to evolve.
1:38:04 And then also, as mentioned, we did take the action with a four-to-one vote to recommend additional funding for the completion of Trails End Park and very much appreciated MLR's support for that as well. And that will be on your agenda at your upcoming meeting. Really, really looking forward to cutting the ribbon on that park. So I think we can all be very excited about that. Just to also mention the Parks and Recreation Month in July was just absolutely fantastic. Really great to see so many people enjoying our parks, facilities, and programs.
1:38:34 Next week, the very first junior lifeguard camp commences. So we've got some kids signed up for that, but maybe potential future staff for us at the pool. So that'll be a lot of fun. And finally, just thanks to the community for respecting the changed parking conditions at the community tennis courts. So thank you very much. Thank you, Betsy. Excuse me, just, Betsy, could you, the changed parking conditions at the community park.
1:39:01 I'm in the dark on that one. What is it? Just at the tennis court. So just trying to keep that parking available for the users of that facility specifically. Added in some two-hour signage as opposed to open parking in the past. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, council members. I'd like to take this opportunity to extend a warm invitation to everyone to join the Mammoth Lakes Trail System team.
1:39:36 For a Summer of Stewardship Trail Day, it's a very special event. It's the fourth annual Skip Harvey Memorial Trail Day. It will be held on August 13th, 8.30 a.m. at the Earthquake Fault Trailhead parking area. We'll be doing work on the Mountain View Trail, Uptown and Downtown Trails. We'll be installing...
1:40:03 27 new soft surface trail signs, the exact same design as what we did on the Panorama Dome area for the first Summer Stewardship Trail Day. This event is sponsored by Kittredge Sports and High Sierra Tri Club, so we're very grateful for their help with this. We expect a pretty good showing. We had a great turnout for the first day.
1:40:29 This will be the second of three volunteer trail days, and we look forward to seeing you then. I also want to take this opportunity this week. It's my one-year anniversary as an employee of the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're very proud. My family is very proud to be residents of Mammoth Lakes. It's an amazing place. I've had the privilege of living in a lot of different areas of the United States. This place is the tops.
1:40:59 In particular, I've enjoyed watching my children partake in the most amazing recreation program that I've ever seen. All the camps, the activities, just amazing to see. So great job. We're enjoying it very much. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Just a quick question. Is there any kind of a special...
1:41:24 Prize or anything happening at the Trails Day? And is there perhaps a dollar value on that prize? Cash money. $250. Wow. Raffle. You pick a ticket. At the end, there'll be raffle prizes, giveaways. And that prize is in Skip Harvey's name. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you, Joe, for saying that about Mammoth.
1:41:56 Congratulations on one year. Haisl Pays, Public Works. Just a quick update on some traffic and construction-related activity. Before I jump into that, I want to bring attention to the fact that staff has identified a significant increase in the number of hazard trees within town, within our right-of-way. To date, we've removed over 24 trees from the right-of-way. We were just notified that we'll have to take 40 trees out of the bell-shaped parcel.
1:42:26 This is kind of becoming the new norm as we're recovering from the drought. So we want to encourage the public to contact us if you identify any trees that are an issue within the right-of-way. If it's on private property, we'll work through code enforcement to work to get those trees taken care of. But this is becoming a pretty significant impact to staff and something that we're going to have to work through as time goes on. Speaking of opening and ribbing cuttings,
1:42:52 So far, we've contracted over $5.3 million in construction. We have another $4 million in construction slated to be awarded in the next couple of weeks. That brings our total over $9.5 million for the summer, so it's a pretty big year for us. Specifically, we have a couple of issues we want to bring attention to the public. The Around Lake Mary Loop will be closed until completed. We're doing a road realignment just past the campground.
1:43:21 Pass Poconoby Lodge to Lake George. At the intersection of Lake George on August 10th, we're going to have to close the intersection for the entire morning about 7 to 10 as we set a bridge.
1:43:32 So just want to make the public aware that there are going to be some impacts up there for the next couple of weeks. We began construction on the hillside parking lot just today, just some clearing and grubbing, but we're going to see a lot of activity up there soon. And SCE is going to begin the undergrounding work again on SR203 next week. So we'll see a lane closure for probably at least a month. We'll update as the schedule comes to us, but as of right now, all we know is they're just starting work and they're going to be closing a lane. Thanks.
1:44:02 Hold on. Just a question on the tree, the hazard tree. As we all know, the governor of the state of California has declared kind of a state of emergency associated with the tree kill, mostly on the west side of the Sierra. The Sierra Nevada Conservancy has got a WIP program, the Watershed Improvement Program. Are there any funds that you're aware of coming from the state to help communities like ours deal with these kinds of issues with the hazard trees?
1:44:30 I am not aware of any funding sources, but we are carefully tracking our expenses in case something does become available. We'll be in a position to ask for funding to take care of this. Okay. I think that program's at the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, and the WIP program is. I'd be interested if there's any state money coming this way to help deal with this. But I just wanted to. Yeah. Thank you. We'll look into that. All right. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Okay. We'll close that and move on to introductions. Dan?
1:45:04 Thank you, Mayor, Council. It's my pleasure to introduce you, Robert, or it goes by Rob Patterson, our new Administrative Services Finance Director. As Jill mentioned, he'll be a year tomorrow, and he's eight days today, so stretching the gamut here. But it's great to have Rob on board. He brings with a lot of private sector experience. He's familiar with government, though. Actually, his wife has worked for another county in the finance roles and stuff.
1:45:33 Some familiarity there, but also just brings a new sense of dynamic activity to our finance department, and I think it would be a great fit for the town and for the community and for the leadership role within the town, and I'm excited that he's on board, along with a lot of other folks, frankly, just in terms of workload, and so it's a pleasure to have him here. I'll have him give you a little bit of background on himself and just get you a chance to introduce himself to you and to the community. Thank you. Mayor and Councilmembers,
1:46:04 It's exciting to be here and to be one of the newest members of Town of Mammoth Lakes. I can't believe the level of commitment and excitement that folks have and passion they have for this town. It's very uplifting to see that. And so the town employees, I've been completely embraced by them in the first eight days, and they definitely carry the same passions and support of the town, so a great group of people. A little bit about me.
1:46:33 As Dan said, my wife works for County of Yolo, and we have four children. They're all just graduated from the last two graduated from high school, and so they're off to college. It's a great opportunity for us to find a new place a little bit more distant from the hustle and bustle of Sacramento. We're both country folks, and we like to get away from that busy activity. A little bit further back in my history, I grew up,
1:47:02 Other side of the mountain in Merced on a cattle ranch. Went to school in Sacramento, CSU Sacramento graduate. And in that time, after I left college, I've held two positions, one with Meek Lumber Company. Went there for 12 years, left there as their controller, and then went to work for Raley's grocery store chain and worked with them for just under 15 years.
1:47:31 I do have a tremendous amount of experience in the private sector and I'm looking forward to embracing new knowledge and understanding with the municipal experience. There seems to be a tremendous pent-up need for a finance manager or director within this group. So I've been welcomed by the community, if you will, and I look forward to making a positive contribution to that. So I'm very proud to be here. You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you. Congratulations.
1:48:06 Sometimes you just got to wait for the right person. Well, as was alluded to, this is something we've been working on for a while. It's been a priority, so it's exciting to get that taken care of. Okay, I would like to recognize a few people, and I'd like to have them come down in front so I can shake my own hand. I'm not going to shake your hand. There'll be a photo op out here.
1:48:51 We're going to recognize outgoing Planning and Economic Development Commissioner, Dawn Vruch. I don't think she's here. And then Recreation Commissioners, Terry Stalick and Bill Sauser. Terry's not here, but I believe Betsy Truax is going to accept the Certificate of Appreciation in her behalf. And this is what they say. It's a Certificate of Appreciation. This is Bill's.
1:49:21 In recognition of dedicated service to the citizens of Mammoth Lakes as a recreational commissioner. Dated this 20th day of July. Actually, we're a little bit behind here. We didn't have it on that agenda. We didn't, but we have it on this one. That one was too long as it was. Right. It's a good thing we didn't have it on. So, Bill, you'd come up front here so we can take the photo off and everybody can look at your knees.
1:49:50 Casual Wednesday.
1:51:02 Thank you very much. I know that Terry is quite disappointed not to be here this evening, and so I'm beyond honored, really, to be able to accept the award on her behalf. Just very briefly, as you all know, these two individuals have just contributed immeasurably to our community through their many years of service and leadership on the Recreation Commission. In fact, Bill served on the commission for almost a quarter of a century, we figured out today. So many long years of service, as well as being a very long-standing chair.
1:51:32 Terry also served for over a decade and was the longtime vice chair of the commission. So you can really see their contributions throughout our community, you know, in our parks, our facilities, our trails, and also in a lot of our governing documents that they helped to create. So anyway, I just wanted to say that as the current chair of the commission, I still feel like I'm filling very large shoes. I can only add how much their dedication has really just inspired me personally.
1:51:58 I've just really enjoyed working with them and I'm very grateful that we will all be able to continue to work with them and Councilmember Sauser's new capacity and Terry, of course, remains on the MLR boards and in addition to their other endeavors in the community. So congratulations. Thank you, Betsy. Thank you, Betsy. Is there anyone else that would like to? I'd like just to have one comment. I know that.
1:52:19 I think just to echo and underline Betsy's statements, these really are the lion and the lioness of the Recreation Commission. And under your able stewardship and leadership between Bill and Terry, Measure R came forward and was really well stewarded through that process. Measure U also, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, came to the Recreation Commission.
1:52:44 The hours and hours and hours of service that these two put into this commission on behalf of this community really it's hard to overstate how much work and effort you put into that. So I personally thank you very much for your years of service. All right. Thank you very much. That was very nice. Yes.
1:53:05 I just want to say thank her for her service because the chamber and other things that she's done for the community, people like that who get involved and have been very much involved in this community over the years should be thanked for their service, and I think she's done a fantastic job. Brent, thank you very much for saying that. Okay. We'll move on to public presentation, but before we do, we went through ethics training today, and thank you very much, Andy.
1:53:35 Well, we think. Yeah. And so I will be recusing myself from this presentation based on what I learned today. So I think it's in the best interest that I'm – But the reason why is because you serve on – I serve on the MLF board. I can't remember. I serve on a lot of boards. Yeah, I serve on most of those. Okay. So anyway. Call me when you're done. Okay. Thank you.
1:54:07 Yeah. It's his choice. Can I get a master piece of pizza? Yeah. So thank you. Late until you're out of the room, and then we'll proceed. Yep. So the mayor is now in a secure location. So we can proceed with the public presentation from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation regarding the proposed Mammoth Area Cultural Center project, the MAC facility. Thank you very much. Good evening. My name is Gary Myers.
1:54:47 And I have the privilege of serving as the chairman of the board of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And for the past several years, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation has been working collaboratively with Cerro Coso Community College to plan for the development of the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. And on behalf of the board and as a 35-year resident and great fan of this community, I'm very excited to be here tonight.
1:55:17 To ensure the council that this project has the unqualified and very enthusiastic endorsement of the Mammoth Lakes Foundation as well as the college. So I'd like to turn the podium over to our long-term CEO, Evan Russell. He and I had brown hair, I think, when we started planning this project, so it's very exciting for both of us to have made it. Here we are. This is great.
1:55:45 And he's going to present an overview of the project and next steps to you. Good evening, Evan Russell, Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I think Bill had a brown beard when we started all this stuff also. And I listened to all the stuff going on here, and I wonder, do any of you guys have a personal life? That's an inappropriate question. So we...
1:56:15 We started the Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the McCoy family back in the 80s, shortly after the town incorporated, and the purpose was to support higher education, arts, and cultural enrichment in the community. We had some very passionate people that helped us develop the strategies that we are following today to bring some of our projects forward. We look at our track record.
1:56:42 When we started this, there were no facilities in the South Gateway, and now there's been over $50 million spent on facilities there, and that's all come about after we acquired the land through a Forest Service land exchange. The foundation was deemed the appropriate entity to move the land exchange forward, and we spent about seven years doing that process.
1:57:12 So of those facilities in the South Gateway, land was the first part of it. That took a long time, but it opened the door for a lot of stuff to happen. It opened the door for us to bring the college in, for the college to put funding into the project. We built the Edison Theater, which is where the college started and where we've been developing theater programs for the last six years.
1:57:41 We've built a 24,000 square foot student apartment building that right now is full of kids running camps going on. We've funded more than 650 local scholarships for books and tuition for students that have come out of the area. And we launched two years ago the Mammoth Lakes International Film Festival, which we see growing to be a very big, significant event in the future.
1:58:12 So when we started the college program, we had zero students in the area. And now in the eastern Sierra between Bishop and Mammoth, we have almost 600 kids taking classes. We had 40, 50% of the high school kids this year were taking at least one college class. And we have one student that graduated with an AA degree after going through two years of Syracosa while in the high school.
1:58:43 So the MAC project, which is why we're here, is the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. It's been in the works for a really long time. We've spent about 15 years working on this. In 2010, we had a community working group of 20 to 25 people that was chaired by Bill Taylor, who is working on the committee with us. We identified certain things. It took some time to...
1:59:10 For those things to take shape, we thought this would be built on college property and going through a variety of things that happened at the college level and the state level. It ended up being a project that the Mammoth Lakes Foundation is taking on. The MAC is three things. It's the existing 100-seat Edison Theater. It's a new 300-seat state-of-the-art performing
1:59:40 Art Center. And it's a 500-seat outdoor amphitheater on nine acres of land owned by the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And in the graphic, you can kind of see the rough outline of it, not quite as pretty as the Hart-Howerton report, but gives you an idea where things sit on the property.
2:00:09 We're estimating the MAC project to be $15 million, and we have 90% of that funded, we believe, of the capital outlay of the project. That includes the land in the building that we donate through Shira Dubrovner, who is one of our staff members and artistic director. She's brought a couple of key resources, second homeowners.
2:00:34 Love what she does with the community theater that we have two and a half million dollars committed. We've had some of that funding come into a restricted account.
2:00:45 We're going to go forward with this 90% funded on the capital outlay side, which means we have to raise about a million and a half dollars. And once we get through the next stage of architectural review, then we'll launch a capital campaign. And we already have a list of second homeowners that's just kind of waiting to see where this goes before we go forward. The first phase of the MAC project is the performing.
2:01:13 Art Center, which right now we're estimating based on a square footage number at around $7 million. We believe we have most of that money, if not all of it, lined up. So what do we need to take the next step? We need you guys to release the $100,000. There's $100,000 that was approved last year by the council for this project.
2:01:45 That's money that will go to the next to fund the next architectural review and get us into a hard bid on the project. We want you to release that funding. We would like you to direct the town manager to start working on a long-term agreement for operating the project with part of the measure.
2:02:10 You funding. And that's a to be determined thing after we work with the town manager. And then lastly, something that's kind of a minor thing, but College Parkway is a community road. It's used constantly for all the different events and activities that take place.
2:02:34 Talking to Dena Campbell today, the college director, and they were closed in July, but their parking lot was full almost every day with different organizations and groups that have used College Parkway. College Parkway is about one-third of a mile in length. The town has been funding snow removal and maintenance of the road for over 10 years, and we would like you to accept that into the town road system. So those are the three things that we're asking for.
2:03:05 For us to take the next step with the project. After we get through the next phase of architectural review, we'll have a really good idea of where we go after that, and then we'll hopefully come before you and do a workshop like the Hart-Howerton project was and go through all the details of the project. Have Bill here.
2:03:28 Along with Gary Myers and Kevin Leon, who is our new Associate Director that came to work for us a few months ago. And sure, our Artistic Director, who is absolutely responsible for the $2.5 million that we've brought into the project so far. I'd like to open it up to questions. Oh, we do have a draft business plan that has given us the basis for where we are today. It's a work in progress, but it is posted online at mammothmac.
2:03:58 So you need to go www.mammothmac.com, and it's 40-some pages, but there's a lot of work that went into getting us to where we are today. Great. Thank you very much. I'm just going to ask a procedural question. I'm new to being a mayor of Pro Tem, but in terms of...
2:04:19 I'll turn to Jamie. Is there any opportunity? There's no action. It's a presentation. If you have a couple questions, you can do that, but it's not designed for a lot of dialogue. Okay. So I'll turn to the council first. Any questions from the council members? I've got a couple questions, but Cleland, go ahead. Yeah, no. Could you go over that three-tenth? Where is that three-tenth of the amount? It's College Parkway.
2:04:38 From where you turn on Meridian until where you turn out on Meridian. You know where the new part of the bike trail is down there? There are some parking spaces when they built the bike trail that we allowed the town to go in and put in. So there's a lot of dog walkers and people in the community that use that end of it to access the trail system. Oh, okay. So it's the other end of the... Yeah, as college, if you pull in...
2:05:05 Where the foundation in the theater is and you go down past the apartment building and you come back out right across from the trails. Okay. Thank you. Any other, Bill, any other thoughts? You ask my questions. Okay. I'm good. Any public questions, thoughts?
2:05:30 Good afternoon, Mr. Mayor, Pro Tem, Council, staff, members of the community. MLR took action at their June meeting to reaffirm the $100,000 for the design as the next phase in this project. That will be in your agenda packet on August 17th for action. Thank you. Thank you very much, Rich. Sandy? Something maybe I didn't hear, but I think it's very important to understand the Cerro Coso College participation in this.
2:06:00 I believe it's something like $4.5 million provided out of a bond that we passed, a college bond in the year 2000, and they've already used up, I can't remember, about $6,000 or $8,000 of the bond, and we still have another $6,000 or $8,000 out there that hasn't been advertised yet, whatever, but their contribution here is predicated
2:06:24 In a partnership, a long-term partnership that's undergone an awful lot of twists and turns over all these years, changes in college requirements or whatever, but they are positioned to have this as a part of the college located on the Mammoth Lakes Foundation land. So the town would be the third partner to this. I think that's very important to point out. Thank you. Anybody else?
2:06:54 I was just going to sort of underline what Sandy's statements are. And Evan, I very much appreciate the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, your team, being here today and providing this presentation. I think of the council, the community is very much looking forward to seeing the full team, which is the foundation, which is the college, which is Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and seeing this thing coming forward and start talking about how we start moving forward to getting into construction. I think also that I'm a little...
2:07:23 I'm confused about I'm assuming that there's a recommendation that comes through MLR for the maintenance piece of this. And I'm not quite sure that we have direct negotiations between the town manager and the foundation, but I'm very much looking forward to seeing MLR's recommendation for the disposition of the Measure U funds. I think Sandy's point is an excellent one. This is going to be a
2:07:46 As you pointed out at the beginning of your statement, this is a truly collaborative effort between the foundation, Saracosa Community College, MLR, Measure U Funds, and the town. So I'm looking, I think we're all looking forward to seeing the whole flotilla come forward to see how all the pieces work together and how we move forward. We plan to have an item on your August 17th to follow up. Okay. And part of that, there will need to be a separate.
2:08:08 Discrete negotiation, if you will, private negotiation between the town and the foundation and the college because ultimately it's the town that has to agree to the O&M dollars as the authority to expend those funds. Understood. I know the MLR is in the middle of all this somewhere. I just want to make sure we're all clear about how the whole process goes. We have a number of partners that are involved in this. There will be that negotiation process. Okay, good. Okay, anything else? So I guess we can liberate the mayor. Just a couple of comments real quick. Okay, I'm sorry. Go ahead, Colin. Yeah, sure.
2:08:38 I'll try not to restate exactly what's been said already, but I kind of wanted to dovetail off some of the comments that Sandy made and you just made. I'd like to point out that we are having a fantastic year right now as far as our TOT generation, the most successful we've ever had, but I just want people to remain cognizant of the fact that we do have a very tight general fund budget currently and that
2:09:03 If we are going to get shovels in the ground, which is a huge focus for me, amenity development in this community, partnership is going to be the way that this happens. And to have a presentation come before us with $13.5 million of $15 million raised, that's a very different proposition than coming to the council and saying, we're asking you to build a $15 million facility. That is a non-starter for us.
2:09:28 So I'm really looking forward to how this kind of all works out and susses out. But these are the type of projects that I'm encouraged to see come before us where we can bridge the gap and help to push things over the finish line. So I think that's an important thing for people to understand. The second thing I'd just like to maybe have you address, Dan, I don't want to go too far sideways, but I have heard some comments and...
2:09:54 Concerns and discussion in the community regarding the location of this facility. That was touched on a little bit here. My understanding is one thing, but maybe if you could, for the benefit of the public, just talk a little bit about the location of this facility, what the legal parameters are, what the reality of the situation is, if you can kind of touch on that for us a little bit.
2:10:16 Yeah, we had some preliminary discussions probably a year and a half ago at the college in terms of their commitment to look at it. The question came up on Measure C funds and could they be utilized for facilities elsewhere in the town. I think from a pure legal standpoint, that is a potential. Based on discussions with the college, it's not something they support. And so from the college board, I would doubt that it would go anywhere else with their dollars associated with it.
2:10:40 The other side of that is, as Evan mentioned in the presentation, the property they're looking at doing is being donated through the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, so the dirt is a non-cost issue. It's a donated value, which is huge for the project and what it's going into. The other side of that is keeping some type of educational component and commitment with it. The college has the right to use it. And to put it elsewhere in the community really makes that difficult for the college location and the access to it. And so based on some of those types of discussions and elements,
2:11:09 If we want to build a facility elsewhere in the community, we have the right to go do that, but it will not utilize or not get a recommendation from the college to utilize their funding to do so. So that would be a big setback to the project. So the location we think fits with the current theater. It fits with the current college. It fits in with the program and the discussion that's been ongoing in building the programming through that. It ties in with the high school and, frankly, their whole educational system there.
2:11:38 For a larger facility and those types of activities. So based on our discussions at that point, we would not be looking at any other site for the facility. Partly back to your earlier comment is if so, it's an unfunded project at that point. I just, you know, I appreciate that. I think that's a very succinct description. I just think that's important for the public to understand that.
2:11:59 You know, kind of back to my prior point that the way that we're going to execute these things as a community is with partnerships. And we have a couple of willing partners that are stepping up to the plate, and I don't want to look a gift horse in the mouth around that. So I think, you know, I look forward to more opportunities like this. You know, we have to have private sector involvement for us to get things done. So thank you guys for the time and the presentation, and I'm looking forward to more information on this. Thanks.
2:12:26 Good. Thank you. So with that, we'll conclude. Oh, I'm sorry, Bill. I'm sorry. Dan, I'm assuming as we go into talks with them and as we interact that we're also going to be looking at the transportation piece and everything else to help make this a success. That's correct. And bringing Mammoth's largest undercover seats forward is, thank you, I look forward to continuing to work on them. Good? Good, good. Okay, good.
2:12:56 Please release the mayor. Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Yes, sir. Mayor, you're on your consent agenda. Okay. We'll move on to consent agenda, items 5 through 9A, and I'll read them. Number 5 is approve minutes of a special meeting of July 19, 2016. Number 6, approve the minutes of the regular meeting July 20th.
2:13:54 2016. Number seven, waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance approving District Zoning Amendment 15-002 for the Old Mammoth Place Amendment Project, amending the Clearwater Specific Plan and making findings in support thereof. Number eight, approve the resolution modifying the fiscal year 2016-17 budget to reflect the total cost for the construction of the Hillside Parking Improvements Project and authorize the town manager to make the
2:14:24 The appropriate budget amendments. Number nine, accept payment approvals, reports 15-45, 15-46, and 16-01. And 9A, adopt the resolution authorizing submittal of applications for all department resources recycling and recovery, CalRecycle, grants for which the town of Mammoth Lakes is eligible.
2:14:55 With that, I will ask if any of the consent items need to be pulled. None? Okay. Colin, do you want to? Yeah. I'm happy to make a motion on most of the items. I will need to recuse myself from consent agenda item number seven.
2:15:21 Regarding the Clearwater specific plan, I also recuse myself on that vote. I do have a conflict of interest financial. My company, Black Tie Ski Rentals, operates a shop on the existing property. Okay, and I'd like to recuse myself from item number eight, which is the Hillside Parking Improvements Project. I am a owner of a business and leaseholder in the village at Mammoth, which is...
2:15:50 Close by. So with that, I'd be happy to make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 5, 6, 8, 9, and 9A. I second. We have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Recused on number 8 and yes on.
2:16:21 Five, six, did you mention seven?
2:16:23 Should I skip eight, two, or?
2:16:25 You can accept the note that you're recusing out the items.
2:16:28 Okay.
2:16:29 So you want to amend?
2:16:31 Yeah, sure.
2:16:31 I'll make a motion.
2:16:32 Council approves consent and agenda items five, six, seven, eight, nine, and nine A.
2:16:37 I will be recused on seven.
2:16:40 Okay.
2:16:40 But first, second, can we do the roll call again, please?
2:16:43 Yes.
2:16:44 Does Councilmember Rogers approve the amended second?
2:16:48 Yes.
2:16:48 Okay.
2:16:50 Councilmember Ferney?
2:16:51 Yes.
2:16:52 Councilman McCauley?
2:16:53 Yes.
2:16:53 Councilman of the South?
2:16:54 Yes.
2:16:55 Airports on the road?
2:16:56 Yes.
2:16:56 Airways?
2:16:57 Yes.
2:16:58 Nash, consent agenda passes 5-0. Thank you very much. If we just want to reflect it on item 7, Fernie was recusal on number 8. And the recusal on 7 and recusal on 8, so it's 4-0 on those. Thank you. Okay, that will take us on to policy matters. Number 10, Dan. Good evening, Councilmembers. Mayor Richardson. Pam, excuse me. Pam Kobylarz, Assistant to the Town Manager.
2:17:28 The item before you tonight is approve the recreation development impact fee credit agreement for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.
2:17:35 Back in 2007 when our current ice rink was constructed, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area assisted with some of that development by doing grading work, drainage and utility work on the site. And at that time they were given some development impact fee credits in the recreation category for the value of the work that was done. That was something that our municipal code allowed at that time and the code still allows for that. The initial agreement that gave them the credit
2:18:03 It expired on August 1, 2012, and that agreement did allow for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to request a renewal or extension of that agreement, and they did that in writing. Because the initial agreement was drafted prior to the work being done, a new agreement was drafted that basically reflects the current conditions, the work that was done, and so that's why there's a new agreement rather than just extending the existing or previous agreement.
2:18:30 Basically, the agreement acknowledges the work that was done and acknowledges the value of that work in the amount of $511,713. And it allows Mammoth Mountain Ski Area five additional years from today's date to utilize that credit. If at that time they haven't done so, they could...
2:18:50 Request an additional five-year extension of the agreement. And I just want to reemphasize that the credit is only for the recreation category of DIF. So with that, I would like to recommend that the Town Council approve the Recreation Development Impact Fee Credit Agreement for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Okay, thank you very much, Pam. Are there any questions for Pam on this? My only question, they could use this over a period of the ten years if they ask, until they either use it up or...
2:19:21 Correct. If they ask for an extension after five years, they would have up to ten years to use the total amount. But it's not required that it's all on one project? Correct. Okay. Any other questions for Pam? Okay. We'll take any public comment or questions, if there are any. Seeing none, we'll bring it back. We'll close that and bring it back to Council for deliberation and or a motion. I would make a motion that we...
2:19:54 Approve the development impact fee credit with extension with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area or the new, it's not an extension, new agreement with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for work previously done. I have a motion. Second. We have two seconds. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That'll take us to number 11.
2:20:25 Which is award the contract for construction of improvements on State Route 203 from Forest Trail to 850 feet north of Main Street. I will be recusing myself from this item also as I am a owner and leaseholder in the village. But we've been asked for maybe a short recess of maybe five minutes and then we'll resume. Okay. If you like.
2:21:03 Now's the time. I'm on to the chocolate now. All right, everybody, we're back. We're going to be moving on to the next item. And this item is item 11, award contract for construction of improvements on State Route 203 from Forest Trail to 850 feet north of Main Street. And I'll turn to staff for report. Thank you, Mayor Pro Tem Wentworth.
2:27:21 So this is truly a continuation of the item that was brought before you on July 6th where we gave a presentation on the construction activities in the North Village which included the...
2:27:31 The parking lot, some sidewalk improvements, and the CFD project, as we're calling it before you, which is the construction of improvements on the east side of Minaret from the Burgers property to Forest Trail and from the intersection along Forest Trail to Burner Street includes sidewalk, curb and gutter, parking spaces, street lighting, bus turnout, bus shelter, and pedestrian activated red light signal.
2:27:56 Staff had moved forward with the bidding of the project and we opened bids on July 28th. Spies Construction Company of Santa Maria, California was the apparent low bid at $928,692,000. We are recommending that Town Council approve the plans and specifications, award the contract to the lowest responsive bidder of Spies Construction Company, authorize the Public Works Director to execute the contract and accept the project upon completion.
2:28:25 And authorize the Public Works Director to review and approve minor revisions to complete the project, up to an additional 10% of the award amount. Staff is further recommending that Council provide direction to staff regarding the minimum driveway relocation issue. The information item that was before you on July 6th was truly an information item. We want to provide the opportunity to provide that direction formally to...
2:28:51 Move forward with changing the driveway approach. And for your information, staff has worked from that direction and fully intends to provide a change order to the contractor to remove those pieces. There may be some additional things that have to change related to the Hawk and the Crosswalk and so forth to facilitate not putting those improvements on Burner Street. But we provided some additional information in your staff report that wasn't available at the time.
2:29:18 And we're available to answer questions. And the engineer of record, Tom Blatz, is also here to answer questions. Good. Thank you very much. I wonder if before we get any questions from Council, if you could provide sort of a summary of any additional information or things that are available this evening that maybe we didn't look at when it was just an informational item before. Absolutely. Grady provided a pretty good background in the history of the project. It is part of a
2:29:46 A master plan, a specific plan, all of the improvements shown here which we're proposing to construct are consistent with those documents and with those environmental documents, pedestrian plan, main street plan, bicycle plan, and so forth. These improvements were envisioned as far back as 1994 in the specific plan, EIR, revisited back in 1999.
2:30:12 It is part of the South Hotel entitlements. It was part of their project that was approved, I believe, back in 2006, 2007. So we've also spoken with Caltrans. This project had to go before them for an encroachment permit. That process was parallel with the process of bidding it. We've talked to them about the relocation, and they actually supported the relocation. They provided us a letter of support.
2:30:41 Expressing that they really would like to see the driveway approach move to Burner Street because that is consistent with the highway system. And I can get into more detail if you have additional questions. Okay, thank you. So I think we'll turn to Council for any questions of staff. I think it would be helpful because there's a lot of moving parts in this thing if staff is available to provide whether any thoughts or ideas are consistent or not consistent with any adopted plans, regulations.
2:31:11 Any other kinds of considerations? So I'll turn it to Council. Any questions from Council? No questions. Just so that everybody understands, the Burner Street entrance is what's in the master plan for the area. This doesn't deviate from that plan. Correct. It would have been the release of the parking understructure for the condo, hotel, whatever project that it was there. Right. And I didn't view that any different than the parking lot that's currently there.
2:31:36 Okay. In staff's last report, they said they had hard written, although I haven't seen them, mitigation efforts that take place when traffic counts hit certain numbers and everything else was not to overly affect those neighborhoods. Right. And I was comfortable with that as well. I think this moves forward with that North Village District Master Plan and helps ready us for construction.
2:32:01 of whatever ends up on that piece of property and helps with the congestion on Minaret Road, if you ever do that road on Friday or Saturday or Sundays at 4 o'clock in the afternoon.
2:32:13 I won't use the terms here that I normally use to describe it as I'm trying to drive through it to get to the mountain. Any further questions for staff, though, at this point? No questions for staff. The mitigation is, in effect, have we talked to the mountain about whether they're willing to put on the extra crossing guard, as it were, if traffic levels meet it, for Forest Trail so that people will be able to turn out of Forest Trail and back onto Minaret Road? That was a question I did not ask last time.
2:32:42 Critically important. At that point in time, you wouldn't be able to make the turn from forest to minaret without some sort of intervening. Right. We have not had that conversation with the mountain, but I believe it would actually be more appropriate to have that conversation with our local law enforcement agents because they truly should be the people guiding traffic through an intersection on the state highway system. Right. That's just part of the mitigation is that would have to undoubtedly be done. And I am interested to make sure that if we need to go there, that is.
2:33:13 In place. Okay, good. Any other questions? Yes, Cleland. So I'm just asking questions of staff right now? Okay. So I'm not quite clear because two meetings ago I think is when we voted two to one to keep that. So I just want to clarify. What you're talking about is that the entrance exit for the parking lot will stay on minaret.
2:33:43 At the moment, it's not going to be on Burner Street, and the bid for this project is going to exclude that right now. Yes, as directed, we are going to have to go through a process to move, to redesign the project, to relocate, to close off, to leave it open, modify the crosswalk, modify the hawk.
2:34:10 Good. So, in more succinct terms, you are asking for direction on that tonight? Yes.
2:34:40 Is it left on minaret or moved to burner? You want specific direction from the council? Yeah, we wanted to bring it back on that because the last time it was a discussion and informational item. We did get direction at that point, so as we went out, as Hayes mentioned, they've looked at the process to say, okay, here's what it takes to implement that direction from that previous meeting. We didn't have time to change the bid documents, and again, as an informational item, we wanted to come back for the word of the bid, have this dialogue, be able to make sure you're fully aware of the information that's there.
2:35:10 But we have not taken action to change from that direction unless told differently this evening. We also have followed with the property owner, and basically there's a quote there in your staff report, and they're okay with either option. Okay, for the time being. Yeah, ultimately they know it's going to move long term. That will change with the project, but for this work tonight, they're okay. I understand that. Since I didn't receive really any information.
2:35:37 From my questions or directions beforehand, I just want to clarify that. The current direction you gave us currently stands unless you change that direction this evening. Okay. Any further questions for staff? Okay, so now public, any public comments, questions, thoughts? Please come forward and state your name. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Yvonne Guzman-Rangel, and I actually have something written up.
2:36:11 Dear Councilmembers, the proposal to relocate the entrance to the village parking lot to Burner Street will have a detrimental effect on our neighborhood. I have lived on 30 Burner Street with my family for 20 years. I'm 26, so I've lived there a long time. Therefore, it is safe to say I have witnessed the changes that have taken place around the village. I know that other neighbors have written to you in regards to this proposed item.
2:36:39 However, I would like to give you my personal experience as to how these changes have affected my experience as a child and now as an adult. I grew up playing on Burner Street and walking my dogs on Alpine Circle. As a child, I was constantly woken up by intoxicated individuals walking out of Lakanuki and now in my teenage years also by the village events that they have. On multiple occasions, I had to call the police because an individual was lying outside of my house intoxicated.
2:37:10 As an adult, I watch how cars rarely adhere to the speed limit and how my family cars have been vandalized and stolen. I hope that my personal experience growing up on 30 Burner Street will give you insight on how policies have a lasting effect on neighborhoods. Thank you. Thank you very much. Hello, Council.
2:37:34 Nicole Godoy, homeowner on the Alpen Circle Loop. I'd like to ask the town, do please perform traffic mitigation measures prior to the driveway egress possibly being changed? You are looking at exiting and entering on residential streets. We know there's going to be an impact. That's a no-brainer. But how do we minimize it for homeowners, as well as the frustrations and way findings for the visitors who are going to be using those ways? Moving the...
2:38:03 A driveway from Minaret to Burner Street, Google Maps will actually put you onto Forest Trail. So, thank you. Good to know. Thank you. Tom Platz with Triad Homes Associates. I'm the project engineer. One thing I'd like to state is that, you know, the entrance off of Minaret, people turning right onto Main Street will...
2:38:36 Or on the minaret from the entrance of the parking lot will not be able to see the hawk and oftentimes don't see the pedestrian crossing and people entering it just out willy-nilly. At least the hawk crossing will control the people from entering the crosswalk, you know, and just...
2:39:01 Be continuous. It'll provide a better traffic flow. It'll act more like a traffic signal. But Burner Street, that entrance will reduce the potential for somebody turning out onto Minaret and causing, you know, a conflict, not seeing the Hawk signal working and people entering the crosswalk from the, you know, the east side.
2:39:31 I'm also up here if you have any questions. Any questions from Council? No. Okay. Thank you very much. I'd like to introduce myself to the Council, Mayor Pro Tem. My name is John Lum. I reside at the intersection of Alpine Circle and Berner. I'm also the father of five children. One of my children, Cameron, is right here in the room with me.
2:40:05 And we witnessed a lot of activity in the neighborhood, and I share your frustration about the traffic on busy weekends. I'm here for a couple of reasons. One is represent myself and my family as well as some of our other neighbors, and I was asked by one of our neighbors to read something for the record, if I may. Sure. This is from Chris Ricketts, and he's been to a couple of these sessions already. And it goes, my name's Chris Ricketts.
2:40:33 And I have a home at 863 Forest Trail. I spoke to you regarding the proposed relocation in the East Village parking lot entrance on July 6th and July 20th of this year. I'm traveling today and grateful for the opportunity to address the Council on this issue again. On July 20th, the Council and the public were presented with a renewed vision for Mammoth Lakes incorporating many of the great ideas developed over the years.
2:40:57 I found the presentation inspirational and reassuring since this vision appeared to have been built on a foundation of a solid planning principle. As Mammoth changes, I think we must be cognizant of the fact that we must all be able to enjoy our town, not only in the built-out form, but in the interim stages. One such interim stage is a current use of the East Village parking lot. These parcels are currently entitled as hotels with underground parking for guests and not the public.
2:41:27 In traffic engineering lingo, this is a passively used parking facility. With a passive use, cars are anticipated to park, then move in frequently, particularly in a destination like the village. The NVSP Environmental Impact Report approved a passive use of a garage on Burner Street after the traffic flow was analyzed, but only with required mitigation.
2:41:52 Thank you.
2:42:24 was approved or modeled but seems to work since the guests exit on a minaret turning right or left as they desire. During heavy use periods, left turning traffic is facilitated by pedestrian crosswalks and then dispersed as intended by a signalized traffic intersection. Today we are being asked to award a bid for the 203 improvements which include the relocation of the access to the active use parking lot to Burner Street. Common sense
2:42:51 And in parentheses, not brilliant traffic engineering tells us if cars cannot turn left from Forest Trail on a minaret, they will find another way going right on the Forest Trail and right on the Alpine Circle. This will force traffic through residential neighborhoods on substandard roads that terminate at not signal intersections. I ask the staff for traffic analysis.
2:43:15 Modeling the impacts of parking lot entrance change on the local roads. The staff responded with verbiage in the council addendum saying that the relocation was consistent with the long-term goals of the NVSP. I do not dispute this, but I am very concerned that no analysis was done to ensure that change would not have negative impacts on the community and the interim. In Mammoth, as in other places, interim solutions can last a long time despite...
2:43:45 I encourage you to be cognizant of the existing neighborhoods as you plan interim improvements to do them right. Staff has said the other improvements can go ahead with or without the parking access relocation. So please don't award the contract for the State 203 improvements without a caveat that requires that the parking lot entrance exit remains on Minaret.
2:44:13 I was going to read you a letter that I crafted as well as I was asked by my... I don't mean to interrupt. This will make you aware of the time. A little yellow light there. And how much time do I have left? Okay. I'll just make a passionate plea. Mitigation. This seems like a classic cart before the horse attempt at a long-term solution. Mitigation needs to be put in place first before dumping this traffic issue that you brought up into the neighborhood. I'll tell you what I witnessed.
2:44:43 I witnessed a lot of pedestrian traffic. For primary reasons is the improvements along 203 that consequently the company that I work for, SCE, is about to embark on, but also the fact that it's unsafe. So those folks walk through the neighborhood and bypass all of that. Now you're anticipating the high turnover of parking lot traffic into those neighborhoods, and I'm going to leave you with a simple question to ask yourself. Have you taken the time to either exit out on
2:45:13 Mountain, Sierra, or Lower Forest Trail trying to cross 203. Now imagine a thousand more cars on busy weekends trying to do that. I think you're trading one set of problems for another that are frankly unacceptable and unsafe. And you're exposing a lot of pedestrians and guests and visitors to our community to unnecessary hazards for no other reason other than to push part of this through.
2:45:37 Get your sidewalks and your curbs and your gutters in, get all your traffic mitigation in, and then come back to the residents and revisit this. Good. Okay? Yeah. Thank you very much. Hi, my name's Tabby Manador. I think you guys have read letters I've sent previously. I just want to restate that the residents in that area, I'm on Alpine Circle, they don't know that this is about to happen or that it might happen in the future.
2:46:14 I would really like to request that you guys make a much better job, do a much better job of communicating and getting the input from the residents because this is really going to impact us in a huge way. We're already impacted by the traffic. Thank you very much. Anybody else? No? Okay, so I'll bring it back here for council deliberation. Any thoughts? Anybody want to go first? I will.
2:46:50 I do understand the issue with the hawk. That was explained to me. However, that was a really good point that you just brought up. I didn't catch your name, the gentleman in the blue, that that's one thing that even if you manage to go through Forest Trail and to take some of those little neighborhood roads, you're still ending up having to take a left on 203.
2:47:17 And so I try to just do right-hand turns in this town now and avoid the left. So I think that for the time being, can I say what I'd like to see for the time being? Sure. I would like to see, I think inevitably that will change, but for right now until something is built.
2:47:49 Just keep it the way it is, deal with the issues, and find out a better way to route traffic rather than that because that is going to be an issue that is going to get more difficult down the road, not easier, no matter what we do right now. So I say hold off. Okay. Bill, Colin? I am more than happy to go next. I was the lone wolf last time.
2:48:17 In voting that I thought that it should go in, and for a lot of reasons. I've been in town for a long time. The funding for this, including that, is in place now. I agree with them. We do not know when further construction is going to come through.
2:48:33 I am fairly confident that mitigation issues can solve some of that, not all of it. You know, with every step in growth that Mammoth has taken, traffic has become a bigger and bigger issue. And if we put this off of this now, the approved budget and everything else that's here, in another year, two years, five years, as the problem grows, we may not have it within our power. The community...
2:48:55 Facilities District? Which district are we going here? Sorry, guys. I'm new at all these acronyms. John's very good at these three-letter things. It may not have the money. Part of the money is coming from the refinance of the initial note, and it's a very complex and complicated thing. Is it going to affect some people? Yes. Every time somebody else has moved into town since, you know, 58 when I moved here, it has affected me. But I can't.
2:49:23 Let the fact that it is going to negatively affect some people stop me from doing what I think is best for the public trust and our ability to solve this issue now where we may not be able to later if we say, you know, God, I wish we would have done that. So that's my issue here. It's a tough issue to deal with, but the funding is in place. The contract can be in place, and we can move it forward with guarantees of mitigation.
2:49:50 If traffic increases to that level on those streets. So for those reasons, I'm still comfortable with what my original stance was in moving the project forward as laid out here. Okay. Colin. Oh, boy. I think rarely do I struggle with something to the degree that I've struggled with this. I've spent the last three days just...
2:50:20 Constantly shifting back and forth about what the best direction is. Honestly, I think there's very valid arguments on both sides of this. I think we need to give it its due consideration as a council, so I'm looking forward to some kind of debate and deliberation up here. You know, I'm cognizant of a couple of things. You know, I always try and keep our strategic priorities with us. A couple of our strategic priorities touch on this area specifically.
2:50:50 We have a short-term parking solution for the village implemented. That's really what we're looking at here. I think we need to recognize that regardless of what happens with the direction on this particular CFD refinancing, we have a much larger
2:51:07 Problem that we need to solve in that area. You know, we have traffic flow issues. We have potential park, you know, significant parking issues, transit issues. So we definitely have a lot of work to do as far as putting in place a long-term solution, which is also one of our priorities. I think we have significant traffic flow issues currently, the way it's structured with an entrance on Minaret.
2:51:38 I think if we were to keep the location where it is on Minaret, we have some problems moving forward that we need to address, some of which have been touched on tonight. We do have significant traffic flow issues on Minaret. I also do have some concerns around pedestrian safety. I think moving the location, which is an option, moving it to Berner Street,
2:52:09 There's no doubt would provide a better pedestrian experience on 203. The idea of having a sidewalk that runs all the way from Burgers to the corner with associated parking, significant bus pullout, the hawk setup. I think one of our goals is being a feet-first community. There's a lot of pedestrian traffic in that area. I think there's no doubt to me that it would provide a better pedestrian experience specifically on 203.
2:52:39 If we were to move the entrance to Burner Street, I think we do create a couple of additional problems from a traffic standpoint. I don't have large concerns with adding additional traffic to Hillside. That is intended to be an arterial road in town. It's wider for a reason.
2:53:06 It's got higher speeds. That was always an intent that there would be higher traffic flow on that street specifically. So right now we really have one option, which is Minaret, that would add a couple of options, which are Hillside and Minaret. So from that perspective, it's a positive thing. But I do have some significant concerns about
2:53:28 Dumping significant traffic into Alpine Circle. That is a residential neighborhood that is not intended to handle increased traffic flow. So I'm going to kind of stop here. That's not something that I've kind of seen from our presentation. Is this something that staff has looked at addressing?
2:53:49 Entrance were to be moved to Burner Street. Is there any mitigation measures in place to deter additional traffic flow from entering Alpine Circle in that residential neighborhood? The mitigation measures that were called out were really to direct back to the Main Street and to discourage people from taking cut-through roads. And they were going to do that by...
2:54:16 Putting, I want to say pork chop, by putting a delineator in to effectively eliminate the ability to make a left turn so that the queuing length would never exist and people would never have the opportunity to make a left onto Main Street. It's only right turns. So that was the mitigation that was called out to discourage the cut-through traffic. I'm sorry, can you back that up for me? So if people are coming out of the current lot on Berner Street.
2:54:47 So they would have the option of going right towards Alpine Circle or left back towards Hillside? Are there any mitigation measures in place to deter people from going right towards Alpine Circle and directing them left towards Hillside? No, there's no...
2:55:07 Direction throughout the neighborhood. The mitigation was to discourage people from making left turns onto Main Street. So if you're leaving the area, you have no ability to go where you need to go. So you actually are forced to go back around through the intersection through Forest Trail to Minaret to get to Main Street, unless you're making a right turn. That's what was proposed in the EIR. The second concern I see with moving the location to Berner Street would be if people,
2:55:37 We have, you know, whatever that is, 50, 80, 100 yards that run from burner to 203 that we could be putting a significant amount of traffic flow back out onto in a little bottleneck area. Do we have any mitigation measures in place?
2:56:06 For dealing with that traffic flow and that backup that would occur on that specific section. Sure. We are investigating the option of creating a right turn lane. There's some real estate there that we have available to the north that we could utilize to create a turn pocket to allow people to make a right turn up to the mountain. I'll also note that traffic leaving the parking lot is already making a right or a left onto Minaret. Correct.
2:56:35 So it's the same volume of traffic. We're just concentrating it to free up, like you said, ability for pedestrians to move through the area a little bit more fluidly. So it sounds like we do have some mitigation measures in place that would add a second lane on Lower Hillside. We're investigating that right now. Forest Trail. Forest, sorry. And I'll add that staff has traffic counters at the...
2:57:02 Nor the, excuse me, the westerly portion of Forest Trail near the Community Center, Lower Forest Trail, and Burner Street, and we monitor the traffic annually. So we have an idea of exactly where we are right now. We also monitor cut-through traffic through license plate studies to see how many vehicles are actually moving from the village all the way to Main Street along Forest Trail. So we actually have some benchmarking to monitor. Okay.
2:57:28 So, you know, those are my initial thoughts. I'm having a significant struggle with where to go with this. Like I said, I think there's some very valid arguments on both sides. The reality of the situation is eventually that entrance is going to need to move to Burner Street. The question is, does it happen right now or does it happen in the future? I think it is a valid argument from some people to say that some mitigation measures should take place prior to that movement.
2:57:55 On the other side, I certainly am cognizant of the idea that we want to be financially smart about this. We don't want to have to re-come back at this and spend additional funds. I'm fully aware that they are within their legal rights to make this move today if they wanted to, the property owner. This is what's entitled. This is what's envisioned. There's been a lot of work that went into that, and I'm not trying to reinvent the wheel here.
2:58:25 I see a couple of problems either way. I see significant traffic flow problems on 203 currently with leaving it where it is, and I see that being a negative impact to the pedestrian experience on 203. I see if we move the location, I see a couple of issues which I outlined, you know, cars taking a right on burner and going into Alpine Circle. I think that's not ideal, and I think the potential bottleneck that we could have.
2:58:52 Right there on the end of Forest Trail before you hit 203 could be a potential problem as well, but it sounds like we may have some mitigation for that. So those are my thoughts. I'm looking for some feedback from the council because I'm struggling with this. Okay, so let me see if I could maybe find something in the middle here. And I want to pick up on the distinction between passive and active parking. The EIR and the mitigation is all...
2:59:19 Is it contingent upon it being a passive parking situation? I'm not aware of how that was determined. I know that the lot that was envisioned for the South Hotel had about 60 spaces more than what is currently out there. I don't know how that was interpreted in the traffic modeling as active or passive, but a hotel use, people come and go, no different than a parking lot. So the representation was made that when the structure is built,
2:59:48 There, the entitled project, that would have a certain quality of parking, which is underground parking for a hotel. And that the traffic flow coming out of that kind of a situation is different. I'm asking your opinion and also the legal standing of that differentiation as opposed to being an active parking.
3:00:09 Area that's supporting the village. And I don't know the specifics, so I'm just going to speak anecdotally about this. The project that was envisioned had retail and commercial space, so people would have been visiting the lot to do similar activities as of right now. There would be some people who would park and stay there, so it would be mixed use. I don't know how that trip generation numbers were created for the model. We didn't go back in that much detail. That information is available, though.
3:00:37 Is there any definition, does the EIR make that distinction? The traffic model that, the traffic impact analysis that was done would have that information. Okay. Because I'm thinking that, I'm just, I'm concerned that we're, we know we have to go there. We know we have, it's got to get moved to Burner Street and it's got to get moved over there. I'm inclined to think that we should do it sooner rather than later so that before a project gets built.
3:01:07 And there are problems and things aren't working. We maybe have to make adjustments down the road. We're doing the situation as it will legally be required to be done so we can make changes, make adjustments if things aren't working, all the rest, that that would make sense. But I'm a little concerned that, and I appreciate the statement that, the current parking use is not going to be what the traffic use is going to be once the structure is built.
3:01:35 I don't have a big issue with that. If I thought that the people who come to stay in Mammoth didn't move once they got out of their car, if they were in an underground parking lot, I would agree with that. However, it is my experience that our customers move around a lot. So just because they're staying in a motel and it has amenities like restaurants doesn't mean they don't go down to Footloose for skis and they don't go to John's Pizza for food.
3:02:01 So the car doesn't just sit there for two or three days. I don't see that, and it's just anecdotally, until we move it, we won't know facts. But in my experience, I believe that that active versus passive is a non-issue for me. The issue for me, and I stated it last time, was the Alpine Circle Burner Street. Originally, those streets didn't connect.
3:02:26 Alpine Circle didn't exist when Berner Street was put in, so they didn't connect, obviously. Can we make that a left-hand turn from the parking lot only onto Berner? Can we add that in in the current cost? Because that would be great mitigation. I agree. The transition from Berner to Alpine Circle never should have been built. It is a nightmare for those of us that know how to drive in the snow.
3:02:52 It could still be pedestrian, and it could still be local use, but could we do that as a mitigation for Alpine Circle? Absolutely. Signs are cheap, and we can put those in the project. Yeah. And as Colin was saying, Forest Trail, not Hillside. Thank you. Forest Trail was built as a feeder street. It's an avenue. It is meant to have traffic on it. I know if I owned a house there, I probably wouldn't want to hear that. But I remember when it was built as well, and that's why it is bigger.
3:03:20 Then the other streets. It was part of the traffic flow plan back in the 60s to move people from the mountain to the downtown area. Did you have something to say? Well, the signs, I was listening to a couple of staff members talk during one of the meetings, and within 10 minutes, you said that the signs would be mitigating.
3:03:48 Thank you.
3:04:13 In reality, signs don't really work. The only way that I would even, what I would consider is, okay, if we do it right now, it's going to be on the town's dollar to put, to close Minaret and then to build the other one. If we don't do it right now, then it'll go on the developer whenever he wants to do it, change it to whatever he wants. So that's why I say wait, because it's probably not going to look like that by the time he starts building.
3:04:44 We're going to have the construction going and having the other side of the street look like the village side, and that's going to be more of the cost. And so since we only have, you know, this, what, $700-something thousand dollars to do this, I'd rather have that money right now invested in making that just a really awesome walkway, make that...
3:05:13 Bus transit area, really cool. Increase the walkways for pedestrian traffic, but seriously, to move it, it's not going to solve any traffic problems that I could see, and I would rather wait until maybe a new potential idea comes up for traffic, even if it is the roundabout, I think.
3:05:40 There's enough people that live in that area that it's not something to be taken lightly, and I do want to mention that if you have people and you're diverting them away from Burner and they're not going to take a left on Forest Trail and then take a left on Minaret, they're going to go right down Forest Trail as fast as they can, and at the bottom of that street there is a child care facility that people, they don't slow down by the time they get there. There's like a little speed.
3:06:09 Area right there that people don't realize that they're coming up so fast on an area where kids and parents are crossing the road. Okay, so I'm thinking that I think that we're headed towards conforming with legal obligations that are in place. And I'm thinking that it would be to everybody's interest to start moving into what this circulation plan is going to look like.
3:06:38 Given where we're headed. I think that if we could do a couple things, one is to put, you know, bicycle riders are a slightly different audience than hopefully people in cars that you put a sign that says no right turn. But to do something, to do something, to make it illegal to make a right hand turn going towards Alpine Circle coming out of that lot, coming out of that redirected street.
3:07:01 And also to start looking at the solutions for the 203 Forest Trail intersection because I hear certain ambivalence from staff about what that solution is going to look like. But I very much appreciate the neighbors' and the residents' concerns. But I think that in this situation it's better to be a little proactive on this and let's start looking and seeing what the situation is going to look like. So if we have to make fixes to it, we can do it before.
3:07:30 So the entitled project shows up and says, I'm going to do this and this has to be this way and we're scrambling trying to find solutions for problems that may pop up and we may be even more constrained with what our solutions could be to that. Do we have traffic studies that go back very far at all? Remember where the current driveway comes out on the Minaret Road was the original Burner Street. Burner Street was moved because of the traffic issues that was going to create.
3:08:00 The entrance to the parking lot while it was proposed for Burner Street actually was on Forest Trail. Do we have studies from when it was on Forest Trail to see what that impact was and how much less traffic is there today because it doesn't dump on Forest Trail? That would certainly give us some of the information we need because, indeed, when it was built, it exited on the Forest Trail, not on the Minaret Road. That was changed, and I don't know why it was changed.
3:08:26 We have an inclination as to what that looks like. I don't have those numbers in front of me. We had traffic studies that were done as part of the North Village specific plan both in 1994 and 1999. Staff installed a number of permanent traffic stations around town around 2007-2008 and has been analyzing those on an annual basis since then. So we could compare and contrast those traffic study numbers that were done as part of the EIR, as part of the specific plan,
3:08:56 The numbers we collected. I do know that Forest Trail currently sees an average daily traffic on a Saturday of about 300 to 330 vehicles. That's kind of the benchmark. That's winter Saturday? Winter Saturday. The capacity for that road, the most conservative capacity, there's a couple varying studies, is in the general plan and lists that at 800 vehicles. All right. Well, I'm going to...
3:09:23 In the interest of kind of moving this forward, I'm going to make a motion and let's kind of see where this goes. Okay. So I'm going to move that I would propose to approve the motion as recommended with two additions. One is to add a no right-hand turn sign coming out of the parking lot to Alpine Circle. That's done. Also that the mitigation measures as required
3:09:53 Are available to this new circulation pattern, which I'm assuming they would be. And third, that staff address a long-term solution to the Forest Trail 203 intersection. You know, we need to start figuring out what that's going to look like. And that would be the motion that we propose. I would second that motion. Okay. All right, we have motion to second further discussion. I just have one more comment. I just, you know, I...
3:10:21 Was unfortunately out of town the last time this came before us as an informational item. I just think, you know, the council in general, I think we should take a little bit of a mea culpa that this was not handled as well as it could have been. I think when it first came before us as an information item, you know, things went a little sideways and I can certainly understand and respect the concerns that have been expressed by community members about
3:10:51 How they felt this move forward and the way things were handled. And so I just want to apologize for I don't think this was handled as well as it should have been. Okay. As a town council member, I don't think this was handled well at all. I am very new, but when we made that vote, I thought we were making a decision right there to bring it back.
3:11:22 And as I said, I still haven't received any information. I don't agree with your proposal just with a sign mitigating it. Can I do a counter motion? Let's call for the question on this motion. Well, wait a minute, because I want to talk about it before if we're going to – I mean, so what you're saying is right now – There's a motion out there, so there's no, like, secondary motion. Okay, so right now what you're saying is we're voting if it's going to get moved or not.
3:11:51 But remember... No, no, no. I just asked a question. I said... The motion is... You want to hear the motion?
3:11:57 Read it to me again. So the motion is approve the plans and specifications, award the contract to the lowest responsive bidder, authorize the Public Works Director to execute the construction contract and accept the project upon completion. Authorize the Public Works Director to review and approve minor revisions to complete the project up to an additional 10% of the award amount. Now I'm adding the three things that I added, okay? Okay. That to add a no right hand turn signage coming out of the moved.
3:12:26 Exit out of the parking structure, identify a long-term solution for the intersection at 203 and Forest Trail, and to make sure that, I believe the second part was to have all the mitigation measures in effect for this, as required by, that are available for this process. So that's the motion that's on the table. It's been seconded.
3:12:52 So you're saying that if it votes, it would move? That's correct. And so what's going to happen in two weeks? Are we going to vote again? Well, let's have – I would suggest we have the vote. Let's see how – because we don't know how the vote's going to turn out. So let's have the vote and see what happens. Well, and that's precisely the reason for my comment, you know, that when it was brought before council as an information item, no motion and vote should have occurred.
3:13:21 And that's what happened. And it did not. There was no motion. There was some direction provided but there was no formal vote.
3:13:29 So that's what I'm saying is why this was not handled appropriately. It was not made very clear to staff. It was not made very clear to the public what was going on. And so I think that's where I'm apologizing that this was not handled by the council as well as it should have been. Then we have no business voting on it right now then because we still haven't received that. There's a motion and a second on the table. So I think what we should probably do is go to the vote. Let's just see how this works out. That's what I'm referring? Yes. That's what I'm referring? Nope.
3:13:57 Councilmember Sauser? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Wentworth. Yes. Motion passes 3-1. So, thank you. So, we'll move on if we get the mayor out of his happy little secluded area, and we'll move on. One more thing. Could I ask for reports to come back, whether they're in writing or in emails, as this moves forward so I know what's going on yet and update, because we voted on it, and now it is moving forward.
3:14:30 Okay, welcome back. So we're now on item number 12. Item 12, provide direction regarding the preparation of a comment letter to the proposed draft revised land management plan for the Inua National Forest. Dan. Thank you. We have a couple different things with the comment letter we're working through. One is we wanted to bring it tonight, kind of an overview and discussion. If there's any particular direction, we'll take that. We'll work through that.
3:15:02 And we'll be looking for final comments at your next meeting. So we have a two-step process to give you time to hopefully digest several hundred pages of Forest Service plan work between the plan and the EIS and those things that are out there. We do have hard copies in my office, and we also have a CD copy if you're interested. So it's online. It's the simplest way to look at it. The Forest Service has all the information provided there.
3:15:28 The URL is in various staff reports as well for your reference. Also, the SCOG, the Council of Governments, had put together a kind of a speaking point or informational item of items that they thought were important to be looked at. We're just handing that out this evening. Hopefully it made it around here to highlight a number of areas.
3:15:51 I want to make some general comments on it. In the staff report, we just did some attachments with the part of the EIS work and also the introduction to the proposed alternative or the preferred alternative as prepared by the Forest Service. I also want to note that District Ranger Rugerbergi is here this evening, so if there's particular questions that he could help address, he'd be willing to do so. I think as we took a look at this, we've been engaged for quite a while. I think it's been over two years.
3:16:18 And that's somewhere in that ballpark. We've made comments along with other folks in the scoping and then through this process as well. I think from a general concept in reviewing the proposed alternative and even I think it's reflected in the SCOG work and stuff.
3:16:34 That the revised plan is overall a good plan. There's a lot of elements in it that we find very positive as we work through it. I want to walk through some of those and I think a couple of areas maybe we want to see some beef up or a little clarification with that. The plan itself is a couple of, just the revised draft plan is about 200 pages. So I did not want to make copies for everybody for that.
3:17:00 That element there. I want to walk through some of that. Also then come back if there's questions from the ESCOG reference. We could work through that as well. I think one of the key elements that we see throughout the plan that was picked up and we were very supportive is the concept of sustainable recreation. One of the items there we would ultimately probably make a request is that the original framework for sustainable recreation that was put out, it would be nice to have a reference to that document because that actually helps set up the definitional issues.
3:17:30 Sustainable recreation will mean many things to many people, and so the extent that we can define it a little better may be beneficial from that perspective. It's throughout the document in a lot of different plan areas, but one of the linkages between the two documents is some of the vision statements. The framework speaks to the mission and vision of USDA Forest Service in a broad perspective.
3:17:56 The mission to sustain the health, diversity, and productivity of the nation's forests and grasslands to meet the needs of present and future generations. I think we have that same goal in Mammoth for future generations. The vision, renewing body, spirit, inspiring passion for the land. And then this guiding principle, they come in with connecting people with their natural and cultural heritage. It's a vital thread in the fabric of society. And then it talks about
3:18:23 Recreation is the portal for understanding and caring for national resources and public land. So it links that together. And as you look at the Inyo National Forest kind of drawing from that, you get this idea. It's on page 38 of the plan. It talks about kind of their niche place as inspiring destinations. I think we believe Mammoth Lakes is just that. Especially this summer, we've seen a lot of people inspired to be here.
3:18:49 And then also the same element of this whole idea of connecting people to nature. It's natural. It's cultural heritage. It's that connection point back. And it is definitely woven through the program of being this mixed-use recreational plan. One of the elements that's defined in the plan touches on the variety of recreation from, you know, the solitude in the wilderness to stoma building.
3:19:16 And so it touches on this whole mixed use of recreation element that's in the plan. We find that very beneficial. I think it helps us from a Mammoth Lakes perspective, our elements that are required to have that. Page nine, it gets into the idea of the value and importance of the social and economic elements of the Inyo National Forest, what's that means to the local economies, not just from a recreational base, but also you look at grazing, you look at ranching.
3:19:45 And you look at those different elements, so it blends that in. But that social and economic, again, we've had the discussions with our strategic plan that our economy is currently a tourism-based, visitor-based economy, and to have those experiences of equality in nature are important, and that it continue in that mixed-use frame of mind, whether it's hiking, fishing, backpacking, bike riding, motorcycle riding, four-wheeling, snowmobiling. All those are captured in the plan, and I think it's done a pretty good job that way.
3:20:13 A little better definition of sustainability connection to the national policy through might be helpful. The other key element, I think, in the introduction that they touch on is the whole idea that this is designed to be an adaptive planning process. So as conditions change on the ground, the management tools can put in place to best address those. We've seen some challenges, I think, the 1988 plan. I don't think it was a little more rigid, I think, in some of its perspective.
3:20:43 To have more adaptive measurements in there I think would help, frankly, how we respond, how we partner, how we work with elements, how we begin to work through those pieces of that. Page 35 talks about the involvement with communities and the communication levels. We'd like to see if there would be an addition really to highlight the idea of a gateway community. That's a term of art, I believe, that's in some of the other documents because we really do serve as that front country receiver of people enjoying the forest.
3:21:13 And it's our ability to serve them in a lot of the other areas that make a difference, whether it's hotel beds, whether it's fuel and food and fishing supplies, whether it's maps and everything else that goes on, helping direct people. We have a lot of them directed in the Lakes Basin right now. And if you're up there, it's full contact recreation going on. And with our current project up there, it kind of adds to that a little bit.
3:21:43 Diversification of that recreational experience. How do we keep it healthy? How do we put it in a larger context? And with that, built into that, there's a good dialogue and discussion about volunteers, interpretive work, partnerships and stewardship elements that need to come together in the forest plan. Again, we think that's a very great statement in there. Devil's in the detail. What do those partnerships look like? You know, welcome to the United States. We do have a pecking order. It's federal, it's state, it's local.
3:22:12 And so as we deal with partnerships, as we put those together, how do we become that type of quality partner? I think we have a good on-the-ground example of that right now with our trail maintenance program. We are out improving the quality of the experience on trails, and we're doing so with the support of the Forest Service, and we're doing it utilizing their tools, i.e. all their guidelines and documents. So we're in line with what we're doing and how we're doing it. I'm hoping we're communicating well and when we want to do something.
3:22:42 That process, I think, is a good example for us. So as we look at how we engage, there's some good dialogue in the document. Secondly, there's a lot of discussion about fire, fire management, fire zones, how do we deal with air control, how do we smoke impacts. The one area that one of the fire discussions that we might want to highlight in there would be to incorporate the communication with the regional air districts.
3:23:08 That is done on a fire-by-fire basis by practice. It would be nice to capture that in the document that that is a regular practice as we deal with our air boards, both our local one and obviously smoke doesn't seem to know the boundaries of the forest. Fires in the east side, if you will, tend to have their smoke come over here. We tried to get that written in the plan that that was not allowed, but for some reason that didn't get carried through.
3:23:35 The other side of that is really looking at how we manage fire. I think there will be, and there's a direction to plan for more adaptive fire management strategies to be put in place. That means we are going to see more burning in our forest. I don't think we're going to have a choice. We'd much rather have controlled burning and pile burning than we would catastrophic wildfires. The other side of that, and this might be an addition, is looking at what are the other economic...
3:24:04 There is a discussion, that's page 43 in the plan, dealing with infrastructure support.
3:24:31 And the desire to have a quality infrastructure experiences throughout the forest. We're very supportive of the desired condition there. We've got a long ways to go to get there. And I think that you go back to dealing with the community. You go back to the partnerships. How do we help with that infrastructure, be it our campgrounds, be it our restrooms, be it our water systems? I think there's opportunity there. And there may be even some beefing up in that desire of
3:24:58 It's going to take all of us working together to really have the quality infrastructure experience that comes into play. One of the other areas that we addressed early on was the concern over wilderness at one point. There was potential areas being studied and looked at close into Mammoth Lakes. As a front country resort, that was really concerning. As it encroaches more, that tends to limit the types of recreational uses, the other type of experiences that people come to Mammoth for.
3:25:28 We believe that the Forest Service actually has done a very good job in terms of looking very much to the planning rule, and these are the base requirements for wilderness. As it turns out, the recommended course of action has four wilderness areas. I think it's four additional, about 37,000 acres. Good or bad, they're all in Inyo County, so they're outside of Mammoth Lakes at least.
3:25:54 You know, narrow focus of the town. I think that's a very positive step for us. The other side, we did have some discussion at the workshop, the open house that the force had the other night, just how those were defined and a couple boundaries there. So I think it meets the planning rule. I think there's always concern when we add more wilderness area. Ultimately, Congress has to designate a wilderness, but in the meantime, it will be managed as a wilderness, did not lose those characteristics.
3:26:20 Pro and con on that. If you look at one of the alternatives that was analyzed, there was substantially more wilderness in one of the alternatives that is not the preferred alternative. So I think we're relatively successful in that area in terms of how the rule was planned to look at that. The other one is at page 68. It walks through a number of recreational places by definitions and walks through these. I think that's a good thing to take a look at as you have time to read the plan.
3:26:48 And it calls out different management strategies for those. That is a real key piece to make sure that as we're looking at those in the eastern Sierra but also around Mammoth Lakes that we're comfortable with that work. The ESCOG in the back kind of touches on a number of those areas just to call out and look at each of those. And they're, again, for the region there. And this goes back to this whole idea, this niche idea of this
3:27:15 Destination component that the Inyo Forest is kind of carving out for this inspiring destinations. When you start to look at everything from Mount Whitney to Mono Lake, there is just a phenomenal amount of outdoor experiences people can have here.
3:27:33 Again, we've been focused a lot on that and that recreational element that comes in because that's our bread and butter, frankly. And so how do we do that in the same side of that as the sustainable so it's not a great five, ten-year run, but it's a generational experience. The other element that the plan touches on, I think, fairly well is with the biodiversity issues. The economy comes from that. Again, back to connecting people to nature, there's a specific discussion about
3:28:02 The values of the experience, quality experience of hunting and fishing, and then how that also provides the educational opportunities for people in terms of what that means and how that's managed in the landscape. And so we can kind of get those balances through those areas. It's sprinkled throughout the document, I think, this core idea of the social, economic, and experiential activities. The ESCOG kind of walks through a piece of that.
3:28:32 Is there a way to enhance just the age we're in, sorry, the whole idea of digital 395 connections into our forest? We don't use a paper map. I want to use a phone. It's those types of experiences. There's directed language in terms of not adding new rights-aways in a lot of areas or cell towers, if you will, but working off of existing ones. If we can go to an existing site and expand that capability.
3:28:59 For the communication capability and some of the mapping, you know, it's a whole different attitude, I think, for solitude from what was, I don't know, 5, 10, 20 years ago. You go up hiking, the last thing you wanted to see was somebody with technology because you were out doing other things. Leave it at that. The element there, though, I think there's a way to blend that in there to say, how do we enhance our technology? And the other element that we're dealing with in the plan,
3:29:28 It touches on a little bit of it, but it's just that whole idea of the recreational experience. We're seeing this in Red's Meadow right now where it's almost overwhelming. How do we keep that quality of experience but still be able to handle the guests that are coming to that? We still want to have inspiring destinations and not one that feels like Disneyland with the turnstile and you just walk up and...
3:29:50 Do that. And again, I think technology can help us with that. How do we communicate to people? How do we let them know? How do we help move things out? We're looking at transit systems. We're looking at a lot of other things. I think that comes back to the partnership discussion that's in the plan. Some of that will be on-the-ground tactics, maybe not working itself into the plan, but there's a lot of elements in the plan, I think, that build on the things that, frankly, we've had a lot of discussions on in a very positive way. I think there's a couple of areas to beef up, but there's also some very good areas in the plan.
3:30:19 That we need to stand back and support. I think they've been very conscious and listening to the scoping and the other comments that have come in. ESRC has been very engaged in some of that element. The town's made comments. MLR has provided comments. And so overall, I think as an early adopter for us, what we see coming out, there's probably more things in the plan for support with some tweaks to it than there is about major concerns over
3:30:48 Overreach in wilderness, for example, or, you know, just, you know, let's do a lot of road closures or something of that nature. There's a lot of other things. The plan also then ultimately builds on the other forest policies and procedures and laws that are in place. But again, back to the front end, I think the concept of sustainable recreation, what the annual forest is, is captured well. The idea that we need to be sustainable, the idea we need to engage with our communities, we need to be partners.
3:31:17 And that we need to keep this idea of this connection of people to their land, people to nature, and that the inspiring destination element is retained through this, but it's experiential at all levels. It maintains that multiple-use concept. With that, I'll entertain questions. The ranger can add to this. I know John has been involved in some of the RRC stuff, so if there's additional stuff there, and also I'd defer to Councilmember Wentworth to talk about the SCOG.
3:31:47 Comment a little bit, just as they've come together and say, how do we have a commonality, at least some of our vision across the Eastern Sierra, Mono Inyo counties. Okay, thank you, Dan. Who's going to actually draft this? I'll be working on it, the comments that way. We also have, I think through ERSC, ESRC, actually engaged Joe Bacon to do some work.
3:32:15 In terms of formatting and laying out a system that would kind of help us make sense of the comments. So we'll draft that out. Councilmembers have comments. If they give them to me directly, I'll incorporate as they fit. And then we will have a draft letter to look at at your next meeting and make comments again at the end. You know, John, I'd like to have you kind of weigh in, if you would, a little bit right now. And then we'll have...
3:32:44 Go to Council for questions, which you might be able to answer, Dan or John. I would, Dan gave an excellent summary. I think the plan is a really, is an excellent one, enormously forward-looking on a national stage, which is an early adopter is what this is. I would just, I'd love to hear, John, any comments or thoughts you might have. I think the staff.
3:33:10 Of the Forest Service locally, regionally, has done an excellent job with this plan. And my only question to you would be if there's things that as we prepare to get our final comments together, what kind of comments are going to be useful to the agency? What kinds of things are you looking for? What kind of feedback is going to be valuable to you and your staff? And then I can add anything else if anybody would like. Thank you. John?
3:33:38 Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the Council. John Regalbrugge, District Ranger for Mammoth and Mona Lake Ranger Districts on the Inyo National Forest. Thanks for the opportunity to speak with you. I don't have a lot of prepared remarks. We actually held a public meeting the other evening, and some of you all attended. So I'll start first, as I think what I really came prepared to do was to perhaps answer your questions or give any information that might help you in that regard.
3:34:07 With respect to what kind of comments are most helpful, if you have points of disagreement with us, for example, it's always helpful not only to tell us what they are, but to tell us why and maybe how you disagree or how we could resolve that disagreement.
3:34:26 It's certainly okay to comment on things that you support. It's important to understand the decision on the forest plan that our forest supervisor, Ed Armenta, will make. It's not a vote. He gets to decide what the plan looks like. So, you know, we have lots of people who just want to tell us we support this or we don't support that, similar to maybe what you hear sometimes. In the context of a plan decision,
3:34:52 Much of that is perhaps not particularly germane. So, you know, we're certainly going to consider all the comments we receive. Of course, we want them in writing. Then we have that record, and it makes it a little easier for us to digest. The deadline is August 25th.
3:35:10 But again, if there's things you like, tell us why you like them. Tell us how it's important for the local community and your interests. If there are things that you disagree with or don't like or would like to see changed, again, try to persuade us as to your viewpoint, and we'll consider that. And if you make a good case, it may have some effect on changing the decision or the substance of it.
3:35:40 The public tells us their interest, but we're required by law to, you know, there's a lot of requirements we have to follow. There are things we have to do with respect to how the law tells us to consider the public interest, but the public comments are certainly part of that, and so hopefully that helps a little bit there. Regarding some of the other things John said or asked for, we certainly appreciate the fact that we've heard from a number of folks that they think it's pretty well done.
3:36:07 You know, it's an enormous, it's like two reams of paper in a, you know, modern laser printer to print the complete set of documents. The legal requirements and the policy requirements, it's pretty daunting. The Forest Service, as you know, has a multiple use mission. We have a much broader mission than, say, the National Park Service because we allow more different types of use.
3:36:29 By law. So all of that factors into that complexity in the documents. We know that's hard for people. Quite honestly, a lot of us have spent all of our adult lives working on this, and sometimes it's a little daunting for us to feel like we're adequately treating all the complexity. So we do appreciate folks engaging and, you know, trying to help us with that.
3:36:52 You know, we talked, as I said, we've had a couple public meetings in town, a few public meetings in Bishop, so I don't know that I want to go into anything about the plan specifically unless you all have some specific questions. Fair enough. Let's go to questions for who would like to start.
3:37:11 Go ahead. As you know, I used to be very, very involved with this process at the Forest Service, and recently for a lot of reasons I haven't been able to. So my question is, and I think it was answered at some of the meetings I went to, in terms of the recreational opportunities that we produce maps for, and the Forest Service in the town of Mammoth Lakes produces at least two maps jointly, this forest plan as it sits currently, as I understand it, makes no changes to those. Those recreation bases pretty much stay the same.
3:37:42 I believe in our proposed action or alternative B, and again, our preferred alternative, just throwing some terms out to try to help folks understand. I believe your statement is correct. That would not result in any changes to the opportunities shown on those maps. The winter recreation map is one I'm thinking of, and I'm not sure what the other one you're referring to. The summer recreation map, which shows the mountain bike trails and the motorcycle trails and the single track. Correct.
3:38:11 Preferred alternative would not make any changes to those. The 2012 planning rule, which directs us, that's a regulation that directs us how to do our plan, has pulled the plan to a little more strategic, a little more aspirational level than the old 1982 planning rule. So we really make very...
3:38:36 Thank you.
3:38:59 Designating more wilderness, putting more restrictions in place on public uses to perhaps benefit various wildlife species or plant species, particularly threatened and endangered ones.
3:39:11 I don't know if it would be right around Mammoth, but at the whole forest level, there might be some changes to some of the recreation opportunities because there's significantly more acres of wilderness recommended, so that could affect some roads or some other uses. But in the proposed action, absolutely, I don't believe there's any changes with those maps for winter and summer uses in the Mammoth area.
3:39:38 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
3:40:08 Sustainable recreation piece, there's a thing in looking at global warming and how the recreation affects that and everything else. And we look at smoke and air quality under using fire. But was the effect of using that type of burning and that large burning for prescribed fires and everything looked at as to its effect on global warming? One prescribed fire puts out more carbon than all cars.
3:40:33 California to in a year. So was that looked at as well, and mitigation for that, or other treatments, and this became the preferred? And if you don't have the answer, that's fine, because you're not the forester. As I'm sure you're aware, Bill, being a thoughtful guy, these are pretty complicated questions, so I'm thinking pretty carefully about how I might respond.
3:40:57 With respect to the tree mortality, that's an ongoing issue that's actually increasing in intensity, and we really don't have the opportunity to go back and revisit, you know, some of the planned analysis and say, okay, we weren't necessarily thinking we'd have tree mortality on this scale, so how do we approach that?
3:41:16 What I would say, though, is that the ecological trends that are resulting in that tree mortality have been occurring for a long time, and our planners and analysts who are informing the development of our fire management approach are well aware of them. So to that extent, they're incorporated. As an example, we might expect tree mortality to continue to increase, and that's
3:41:39 That's part of the thinking behind some of the actions that we discuss for the future with respect to fire management. And I think that brings me to the second part of your question. If we analyze the effects of smoke from a prescribed burn or a wildfire that's managed and it may burn more acres, maybe we don't put it out as quickly as possible, but we manage it in a defined area that's maybe bigger.
3:42:07 Because we think there would be some ecological benefit. When we look, if we look at the long term, you know, a 10 to 15 year
3:42:18 Cycle for the forest plan and then some of these things are going to have ecological effects for much longer. Many of us would say it is inevitable that that smoke is going to go into the atmosphere and if you look at the science of we've been pretty effective at putting fires out and our job has gotten more difficult in that respect because the vegetation keeps growing so there's more fuel and it seems that you know whatever may be
3:42:43 Whatever may be driving it, the climate does seem to be changing. We seem to have more drought years. We seem to have more acute drought years. We have earlier spring snow melt. We have later snow in the fall. We've talked about shoulder season recreation and some of these things. So nationally, fires are getting worse. Fires are getting more challenging. They're putting out more smoke.
3:43:08 Additionally, we understand that in a lot of our vegetation types on the forest, fire was a natural part of the environment. So basically, we're coming to grips with the fact that we can't be successful thinking we're going to put out every fire start by 10 a.m. the next morning and we'll have clear air all summer long. We're going to have smoke. It's a question of when, where, how. The extent to which we could mitigate by, say, doing mechanical treatments and, you know, harvesting timber, perhaps dealing with...
3:43:37 And so we'll do some of those things where
3:44:06 And we have been doing this already, but our plan would still have us doing some of these things where it's particularly important, you know, maybe close to the communities. We try to, you know, manage the fuels and the smoke in a slightly different way. But the reality, you know, folks like Councilman Wentworth and...
3:44:22 Town Manager Holler, who, you know, we went over together and looked at the rough fire from last year that smoked us out for a long time, met with those folks. The unfortunate reality is all of the fire scientists are pointing to we are likely to experience more of that in the near future than we have in the recent past. So, kind of a long-winded answer, but it was a complicated question. Hopefully that addressed what you were getting at. It does, to a point, yeah. Okay. Okay.
3:44:51 Yes, John. So I'd just like to thank you for coming out. I think a key takeaway is that the plan is middle to high level. It's not intended to be specific. That's a conscious thing. And I think the values and the principles and the management strategies that are in the plan, Dan did an excellent summary of what they are. And we're very much looking forward to providing you with comments. I want to just commend you for the relationship that you've established with the town, your stewarding.
3:45:21 Of the partnership between the town and our district and the Indian National Forest, in many ways, we're many years ahead of the game. The ideas of sustainable recreation, we're actually implementing and doing these things on this district in this forest, and I think it's something for all of us to be kind of proud of, but I want to thank you for your role in that, and we look forward to getting some good comments together and getting them to you. You're very welcome, and thanks. Was that a question?
3:45:48 No question. Just a wait. Thank you. It's 9.30 at night. Thanks for being here. Thank you. All right. Any other questions from up here? You asked mine. I'm good. All right. Really? Christian? Okay. Any questions from the public? None? Okay. We'll come back and see if we want to...
3:46:12 Direction? Yeah, I would make a motion. There's no motion to be made. Did we have consensus? Yeah, we had just consensus direction. It would be fine this evening. And if you have anything very specifically you want to make sure we look at in the next few days as we put this together, that would be helpful. Dan, I think you did an excellent job summarizing everything and what should be on the letter. Are there any additions? Do I hear a consensus? Yeah, I would encourage. John has kept on top of this. Yes, agreed.
3:46:42 What a great guy at process. Right. So I would encourage him and Dan to continue talking, as they do already, on the letter and how to put that together because he is the one of us that has, I went through this last time in the 80s, but I have not been able to put that much effort into this one. Well, no, I, and you're going to bring it back before Council? I'll come back to Council, but I would like to, if there is consensus to work with John directly, I think he's got a lot of the regional information too. So that would be great if we can do that.
3:47:09 Yeah, I think you have consensus from Council here. And then it has to be submitted by the 25th. Correct. Our goal would have a pretty solid draft on the 17th. You can still modify it based on public comment and Council direction at that point in time. Very good. All right. Let's move on to item number 13, authorize an amendment to the agreement with Michael Baker International for the Community Multi-Use Facility, also known as the MUF.
3:47:38 At Mammoth Creek Park West. Dan. Yes, thank you, Mayor. The item before you is an amendment to the CEQA contractor agreement, Michael Baker. As they've gone through the work, it looks like that they do want to do part of a phase two in the review of some of the archaeology there and work through. There's a write-up that they've provided. I won't walk back through that in detail. Some additional field work. It's expanded out their scope.
3:48:08 Wasn't anticipated that we'd have this much work to do at this point, so the request is to come back and amend the contract accordingly to provide for this recommended work. It's $24,650. It'll primarily come out of our recreational diff fund. There's just over $100,000 within that fund, which is the fund 834. We've noted both. The 858 fund is where we have our fractional Miller-Russ money that has also funded the front end of the work as well.
3:48:37 And so there's adequate funding for the project. It's coming out of town funds, not out of other sources there. We do think that the Phase 2 will need to be conducted, and the idea there is, again, we want to make sure that the EIR is very, very solid and that it's looked at all of the issues. Our commitment to the area residents is that we would do that, that we would be very thorough in our scope. And so this upholds that commitment that we made to the residents there in terms of the level of the EIR work.
3:49:06 Whether it's the full project we've talked about or whether it's a modified or whatever, this level of EIR work really sets us up for Mammoth Creek Park West for this level of development or lesser level depending on final outcomes in terms of that nature. So I think it's very appropriate to move forward and complete this piece of the EIR work. The goal, I'm looking at Hayes to confirm this, I believe, is to have the EIR before the planning commission at the latest would be in January.
3:49:37 All right. From the timing. And does this additional work change that timeline at all? No, that's still the timeline is to have it there by that January time frame. Okay. So I'm just looking at Hayes because he's more intimate in the details than I am. But if you can add, you're just. Okay. Does that include your presentation or Hayes? Do you want to add to that? Unless you have any questions for me, I don't have anything to add. Okay. Any questions? What was it they found that prompted this?
3:50:06 Because we didn't see this in the last EIR we tried to do, the draft EIR for Mammoth Creek Park. I believe it actually. It is all land that has been used in the past. There were foundations dug and put on that land before for affordable housing. And the Forest Service compound itself existed at that area of Mammoth Creek in the 20s, 30s, 40s, and was moved in the 50s to where it currently is. Well, no, it was moved where the housing currently is and then to where it currently is.
3:50:36 So I would like just a better understanding of what we found that is prompting this, and do we have real fears now that this could stop this project after we've gone this far? Well, I'm in no position to argue with a historian such as yourself, but I can reiterate what they found, and I believe this was actually found in the original EIR. Just the processes have changed over the years.
3:51:00 And during the phase one, it's more of a record search. It's just checking the background, any known identified sites. During that phase one, they found site, and this is what it says, P-26-000561, which is a prehistoric site. I don't know what that means. I don't know the extent of it. But that's why we have to do the phase two. They actually have to do an invasive shovel investigation to determine the extent of that site.
3:51:28 Historically, you could do that during the grading process. You could do the phase two while you were doing work. But some court rulings have changed that process, and it's now more responsible to do that phase two cultural work in advance of certifying the EIR. Yeah, you used to have a mitigation measure in the EIR that said if we find anything, we'll deal with it appropriately. Now you have to go do the research before you can certify the EIR. Okay.
3:51:54 And we went through this exact same process with the project right across the creek that we're working on. So that's kind of the standard now. Okay. Colin? Questions? Quick question for me. Hold on. Cleland? So this is something that needs to be done no matter what that property ends up being used for? That is correct. Okay. John? So no effect on the EIR timeline? No.
3:52:23 And I'm going to be interested at some point to start getting some updates because we have to transition from the EIR, environmental analysis, into design and construction, things like that, and looking forward to making sure we're on track and then also start talking about budget and what we've got available for it, but that comes down the road. How long does an EIR last? I mean, how long is it good for?
3:52:45 There's not a specific expiration date. It's not as if it goes bad after a certain amount of time. But what happens is that the longer you go, the older it is, the more likely it is that conditions have changed. And when conditions have changed, then you need to do additional CEQA work. Gotcha. So no specifying like it's good for 10 years or all right. Yeah, that's all the questions. I had any questions from the public? Comments? Tom, you're back there. All right.
3:53:16 Hearing none, I'll bring it back for a deliberation or a motion. I will make a motion to authorize an amendment to the agreement with Michael Baker International for the community multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. I have a motion. Do I hear a second? Second. Second. A motion to second. Okay. Roll call, please. Is that sufficient? Yeah. If you want to mention the dollar amount, that would be fine.
3:53:49 I just turned the page. 26,000. 24,650. 24,650. I'll mention it. Okay. Do you still second that? I do. Okay. Thank you. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. That concludes the meeting of August 3rd. Our next regular meeting is August 17th at 6 p.m. I want everybody to know that
3:54:22 Muff is not only a derogatory term for female anatomy, it also means a bungled attempt. So if you want to keep calling...