TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 1 hr 57 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

239 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Not here. Commissioner Burroughs? Well, you can't technically do roll call. Oh, right. Okay. Vice Chair Callinan? Here. And Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.

0:34 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice to all. At this time we'll have our oath of office. So that's the hardest part of the job. I was impressed that she has it memorized. I was thinking the same thing. All right. Our first business matter today is the selection of Planning and Economic Development Commission officers and committee appointments.

2:08 So before we take motions on this and have discussions on this, I just want to say that we do have a standing committee for a design committee, design review committee, and I really would like to add an ad hoc committee to work on parking and snow management. So we'll basically then talk about our officers.

2:40 Our appointments to the design committee and our ad hoc committee unless somebody else had any other comments or committees that they'd like to add to that. No. Okay. So, you need to have a motion for chair. I make a motion that we appoint Mickey Brown as chair. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Can I have a motion for vice chair, please? What can I do? Can I decline and...

3:41 And make a motion to appoint Michael Vanderhurst. Commissioner Chang can withdraw his motion, and Commissioner Burroughs can withdraw her second, and you can have another motion. Okay. So just for your information, I did receive an email from Commissioner Vanderhurst. He was unable to make the meeting today. However, he said he is interested in the vice chair position, so he would accept the position if...

4:11 You appointed him. So he just wanted to let you know that you wouldn't be doing it, you know, when he's not here. Out of the blue. Yeah, out of the blue. He's aware of it and he would be supportive of it. In that case, I respectfully decline. Thank you. All right. I will withdraw. No motion. I will withdraw my second. Okay. So can I have a new motion, please? And I'll make a motion to appoint Michael Vanderhurst as vice chair. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Vice Chair Callanan? Yes.

4:43 And Chair Brown. Yes, motion passes 4-0. So before we actually talk about the design committee, maybe you would like to give a little bit of background for that for our newest commissioner. Yes, so the design committee is a committee that reviews basically any project that has a design review application.

5:02 Prior to it coming to the Planning and Economic Development Commission. So they review the design of the project, provide comments on it. Sometimes we have a number of meetings before it comes to the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Additionally, the Design Committee provides reviews, different items that don't come before the Planning and Economic Development Commission, like monument signs, some minor design reviews, and those types of things. So I would say the meetings are maybe

5:32 Once a month, you know, sometimes there's more meetings, sometimes there's less, and the meetings usually, you know, maybe one to two hours for the meetings, depending on the projects that we're reviewing, so. So I make a motion to appoint Commissioner Callan and to the Design and Review Committee. Do I have a second? Second. Do we do both together or do I have separate roll calls?

6:03 You could do them separate. It's fine. Okay. So can I have a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Callanan? Yes. And Chair Brown? Yes. And I'd like to make a second motion that we appoint Jennifer Burroughs to the same design review committee. It's a great way to get started in the whole planning commission process. So I make that motion. Do I have a second? Yes.

6:33 Okay. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Callinan? Yes. And Chair Brown? Yes. The motion passes 4-0. So we have two permanent appointments to that committee. A couple years ago, we had an ad hoc parking committee, and we really like to reestablish that committee. I spent some time talking to Mayor...

7:01 Shields Richardson about this, and we feel that ultimately solving our parking problems is probably one of our biggest issues of going forward as far as our downtown and village. The goal of this committee is to really start where we left off a couple years ago. We had a very in-detail

7:23 Report written by our consultants that worked on Main Street, and we see it a fairly short-lived committee. We hope to come to some conclusions, present them to council, and move forward. So with that, I need a motion for the parking. I'll make a motion to appoint Paul Chang. I second that. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

7:57 So that motion passes 4-0, and then we need a second person on that committee. I'll make a motion to appoint Mickey Brown. Do I need a second? I'll second it. Roll call, please. Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Kellinan? Yes. And Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. All right. That takes care of our business matter. Do we have some changes you'd like to make?

8:35 Yes, staff would like to request to poll items 5 and items 10. Items 5 are the minutes from June 15th. We'd like to review those minutes and present them back to you at your next meeting. And item 10 is the Planning and Economic Development Commission rules of procedure. We'd like to poll those to sit down with the Chair and Vice Chair to go through those before we present them to the Commission. All right. Thank you.

9:03 So then I need a motion to approve the consent agenda. We're just approving items three and four on the consent agenda. Does anybody else want to pull either three or four? Are we good? Okay. I'll make a motion that we approve the consent agenda. Second, please. Okay. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Callanan? Yes. And Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0.

9:37 All right. So then we are moving to the public hearing. Our first public hearing today is to consider recommending approval to Town Council of Zoning Code Amendment 16-001 to amend the water efficiency landscape regulation in order to meet the requirements of the 2015 updated California Model Water Efficiency Landscape Ordinance.

10:01 California Mwello, M-W-E-L-O, and as in all public hearings, we will follow, you know, I'm really sorry, I'm a little off base today because of our oath, but what I did not allow is for public comments. Is there anybody in the audience that would like to make a public comment on any item that's not on our agenda today? And is it regarding

10:39 Okay, let's go ahead and keep to the order and then we'll go to our public hearing. I totally missed that too. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair, members of the commission, Dan Holler, town manager. I wanted to get an update on a couple of things we're working on that ultimately some of them will be coming back to you and it ties to the town strategic plan that was put in place in discussion with the council, et cetera, and the other NGOs.

11:06 Process for that. It deals with one of the goals being to create an economic development strategy. And we've gone through a number of documents, a number of things that are already existing. And so as we begin to walk through there, instead of going back and redrafting a relatively lengthy economic development plan, which would probably take several months and or consulting work, we started to pull out the elements both from the strategic plan and from the past.

11:31 Work that's already been done, Dr. Seds, et cetera, it goes back starting, I think, to 06 or somewhere in that time frame of various pieces. And so we begin to look at in the various strategies was to come back and go, how do we begin to build pillars of an overall plan? We want to have a short, probably a three to five page, here's our economic development strategy plan. But under that, we're actually developing one that will come to council shortly here regarding special events based on previous direction they gave us.

12:01 Looking at one to come in and deal with technology and some of the broadband and 395 and how does that work from an economic component. We will need one ultimately looking at recreation. That might be a little broader in terms of how much of that is partnership, board service, et cetera, and those types of things. But a kind of recreational one. We'll have one tied to the airport. A lot of that's already in the doctor's head's report.

12:25 Looking at one as, you know, what is the partnerships look like for new development? What type of strategies would we begin to lay out in that type of a pillar? So you end up with five or six kind of core areas versus one overall, you know, 40-page document dealing with economic development that we won't be done and we still won't have hard strategies put in place. So it's shortening up the process a little bit, trying to build off a lot of the work that's already completed.

12:53 And then trying to hit it very narrowly focused. So these would be shorter, potentially shorter term strategies in some cases. Some will be longer going. But ultimately, kind of that overarching piece will need to come back to the commission for review, comment, discussion, etc. And then as the different pillars come together, as applicable be coming forward, especially those dealing, you know, what are we looking at to spur development.

13:18 There's impacts that way and what have you. So there'll be a number of pieces coming back into that, you know, kind of building off one may or may not include a specific item related to parking, for example. The commission's already done work on that between parking and snow removal, so we're looking at how does that roll into more of a development strategy, not just kind of a standalone piece out here. So trying to put that together, so heads up, that's being worked on a couple of those. We'll be going, the tech and the special events,

13:48 Are ahead of the game, if you will, just because of previous direction already given to us from Council and working to that. They're not really a land use related element either. It's broader than that. So, but we do want to ultimately get those pieces in the broader one back before the PDC as well. So, heads up, that's coming up and that's something you see a couple things come forward. We'll try to get those in front of you as well, but I know the one on special events will be coming to the Council next meeting. So,

14:18 Wanted to highlight that one in particular. But again, trying to get it through the PDC as well prior to moving those forward. Thank you very much. Questions to that? If not, I will. Questions? I should see you later this afternoon and talk about the Forest Service. All right. Thank you very much. Thank you. All right. Are there any other public comments? Nolan, are you making a public comment or are you just walking out of the room?

14:52 Okay. All right. Then we will close our public comment period. And I apologize for being out of order here. We'll move to our public hearing. Always on our public hearing, we have a statement and presentation by staff. Then we have a statement and presentation by either the applicant or property owner. Questions, call for testimony, rebuttal, close the public hearing, and then the commission will deliberate and arrive at a decision.

15:17 So as I previously state, our first public hearing today is to consider recommending approval to Town Council and Zoning Code Amendment 16-01 to amend the Water Efficiency Landscape Regulation. And our staff contact person is Nolan on this. All right. Thank you, Chair Brown.

15:37 Zoning code amendment 16-001 proposes changes to the town's water efficient landscape regulations in order to comply with the 2015 updated California model water efficient landscape ordinance. The California MWELO was adopted in July 2015 and required local agencies to adopt landscape regulations that are at least as effective as the California MWELO in conserving water. Just a quick note on the screen, we do have

16:07 What's known as the demonstration kind of landscape at the gateway sign here that was done with all water efficient landscaping just to show what can be done with drought tolerant plants. The town's current landscape regulations were adopted in April 2014 as part of the zoning code update and those regulations were based off of the 2010 California M Wheelow.

16:34 Due to the ongoing drought in California, the Governor ordered the M. Wheelow be updated to increase water efficiency. That update was adopted by the California Water Commission in July 2015, and as noted earlier, local agencies must adopt an ordinance that is at least as effective.

16:55 The major revisions to the town's landscape regulations include a lowered size threshold for new landscape projects. The current regulations require compliance with the regulations for new landscapes that are 2,500 square feet or larger, and the revised regulations require compliance for new landscapes that are 500 square feet or larger. The requirements for rehabilitated landscapes did not change.

17:21 Additionally, the revised regulations added a compliance option for landscapes that are between 500 and 2,500 square feet and only require acknowledgement that their landscaping will comply with the requirements and limitations of the water-efficient landscape checklist. Compliance for this is verified prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy. It also increased the stormwater retention.

17:49 By requiring a greater depth of mulch be applied to non-planted areas, it went from 2 inches to 3 inches, and requires compost to be incorporated into the soil in order to break up the soil. This increases water absorption.

18:04 Additionally, the irrigation efficiency was revised to require dedicated water meters for non-residential landscapes that are over 1,000 square feet, whereas it used to be 5,000 square feet, and the minimum width that could be irrigated with overhead spray was increased from 8 feet to 10 feet. The maximum applied water allowance, that's the

18:28 Calculation that determines the total amount of water that can be applied to an individual landscape was lowered for all landscapes and residential and non-residential landscapes were split up. By lowering the evapotranspiration adjustment factor, or ETAF, it effectively reduced the landscapes that could be planted with high water use plants, such as turf. This is one factor that's used in the Mawa calculations.

18:57 Also, the irrigation efficiency was split up between drip and overhead irrigation to encourage drip usage. And the worksheets for calculating the Mawa and the estimated water usage, or the ETWU, were combined into one table to attempt to simplify the calculations. The town is recommending four compliance options.

19:22 Options A and B conserve the most water and require the least amount of documentation but do limit the plant types and areas. Options C and D allow greater flexibility in plant types but utilize a larger amount of water and require extensive documentation. Options C and D are the same as the current regulations and the current regulations are options B through D are the same as the current. They're currently options A through C in the town's ordinance.

19:52 Option A in the revised ordinance is a new compliance option per the California MWLO, but it is limited to landscapes between 500 and 2,500 square feet. I'm on the screen, it's a little hard to see, but it shows what's going to be required for each compliance option. Staff consulted with staff from the Department of Water Resources on the proposed changes, and DWR confirmed that the proposed changes resulted in a landscape ordinance that was at

20:23 At least as effective as the 2015 California M Wheelow. Based on the DWR determination and the state requirements for updating the ordinance, staff recommends that the commission move forward with option one and recommend approval of the zoning code amendment to the town council. The required findings are on the screen for reference purposes. With that, I'm available for questions. Hopefully not too technical because the

20:54 Material is very in-depth and requires pretty much a PhD. I thought that was my line. Sorry, I stole your line. Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions at this time? I do. Yes. In principle, I like the proposal. However, I don't quite understand why.

21:23 We have to have four different options versus just have two or three options. It sounds to me that based on your explanation, option four, option D, really all the procedure that was created, it's almost to discourage landowner to really go through that process. And if the ultimate goal is trying to save water townwide,

21:55 Why can't we just not have the more, I guess, flexible option you have phrased? Sure. So with this option A, I just want to point out that's really limited to landscapes between 500 and 2,500 square feet, so it's fairly limited in what the scope of it. So that's really the state, by lowering that threshold, they came up with this checklist to

22:25 Try to kind of offset the impacts of lowering that. And then the other three options in the development of the town regulations between pretty much 2010 to 2014, it was looked at and options B through C do all comply with all the state requirements for how much landscape there is, how much water irrigation.

22:51 and all the other requirements, but it was found that when you limit the area as an option B and it's only low and very low water use plants and no turf, that you wouldn't even hit or even come close to your maximum applied water allowance. That's why the compliance options for that were really reduced compared to options C and D because they were found not to be necessary and it wanted to encourage people to use those drought tolerant plants.

23:21 With option C, again, it allows a little bit more flexibility. And then option D, really, it's, you can go right up to the maximum applied water allowance. That's what you're permitted to use per the state and the towns, but it does require extensive documentation and design to comply with that. And so is option D, right? That's option D, yes. Where the other ones do all meet those, but it was found that

23:50 With the limitations, you wouldn't hit that maximum amounts. That's why it's less documentation on those. In what development or new construction in this town would have, would a lane owner would want to seek option D, if you have an example?

24:14 I mean, offhand, we don't have one. We haven't had any large landscape projects come in even since the zoning code update was adopted. But, for example, it would be possibly... Let's say if an existing... It would be like a large multifamily development or a large commercial development that really wanted to go do extensive landscaping that was, you know...

24:37 In excess of 2,500 square feet, they wanted to incorporate grass, they wanted trees, they wanted shrubs, they wanted plants, and they wanted plants from all the different plant factors, so very low, low, medium, and high water usage. And so then it requires them to do the design and all the calculations to ensure that they're not exceeding that maximum allowed water usage. And option D will still allow turf.

25:04 It allows turf. It allows other high water use. It just basically says you can't exceed the MAWA, which is based on a number of calculations and factors. I can walk you through separate on them. We have developing Excel worksheets to simplify it so that people can just put in kind of the square footage of each plant type, and then the worksheet will do the rest of the calculations for the user. Thank you.

25:35 Do you have any questions? No, I don't. Thank you. That was very helpful. So am I correct then that every city has to adopt some sort of similar ordinance? Yes. The state provided the option you could just adopt the California MWLO as it's written. You could put in your ordinance that landscape regulations are pursuant to the state's regulations.

26:07 Or you could adopt a revised one, but it had to be at least as effective. So we went previous, ours follows very similar to the states. Really the only change is that we have the four compliance options. But like I previously said, options B and C were found to comply since you couldn't hit those maximum thresholds based on what's limited. All right.

26:33 And what's the ramifications if we don't adopt an ordinance? As of right now, it's unclear. The correspondence from the state said that at some point in the future, there's likely to be penalties if you don't adopt an ordinance or comply with the state requirements. And does this department have any plans to, once this is adopted, I'm assuming it's going to be adopted, what are the plans to go out and educate?

27:03 The contractors, landscapers, average person in the community on this. Sure. I mean, that is still being developed. We are going to talk with the contractors, the association tomorrow, include them in. But as I said earlier, we're still kind of developing the worksheets and what the compliance will look like. And then once we have those, either

27:26 Just through sending it out to the contractors or again going to the contractors association, trying to educate everyone. We'll also have been working with the water district on kind of what their compliance looks like, but that's still being developed. What their compliance looks like on this or the water reduction? Just on the water reduction and how they're going to assist in helping us with enforcement since they're the ones really looking at the water. They can see just from metering how much usage if someone is.

27:56 Not complying. Okay. But as it stands right now, as far as the ultimate permitting of this, it would be underneath the umbrella of the town's jurisdiction, correct? Correct. That's not changing from the current system. All right. So it's just ultimately water usage that would currently be underneath the water district. Okay. All right. Anybody like to speak on this subject?

28:29 Hi, I'm Kathy Cage. I have a project later on in your agenda that I'm assuming this will apply to. Okay, so I have a question about it. Nolan, could you go back a couple of things where you had some provisions in the stormwater retention basin that I wanted to just get some clarification on? Okay. Requires the soil to be broken up, friable. Okay, and compost to be incorporated in a soil? Seriously? I mean, a stormwater retention basin.

28:58 Is something you can't really plant to really... Yeah, it's not for the basin. That's just kind of for the overall planted areas, basically saying, you know, if your planted areas are broken up and you have mulch, as the snow melts, it's going to percolate down rather than run off into your basins. So that's what that's addressing, not your actual, like, basins, ditches, and those pieces. Okay, wait, wait, wait. Try that again. So I've got a stormwater retention basin in my project. Okay, so...

29:27 What do I have to do on that surface? We've got to go down about two feet and we're making an on-site retention basin. Do I have to put compost in it or is it just for soil that's not growable or something? So that's just for your landscaped areas to discourage further runoff off the site. So, you know, you have your planted areas, you can have your plants, you have a layer of mulch.

29:49 Yeah. And compost in those areas, it's not talking about your actual retention basins. So the mulch is something that currently exists anyway as a requirement. Right now it's two inches, you're saying it has to go to three. So you're not saying that like the stormwater retention basin has to be mulched. Oh, so it's not the basin. It's just your landscaped areas. It's just general stormwater retention. Okay. So the idea is to whatever soil's not covered with impervious surface, you're supposed to try to make sure it can, the water can seep through as much as possible. Correct. Thank you.

30:21 I have a suggestion for you. I would make your landscaping 499 feet. Do we have any other comments? Would you like to comment? So we'll close the public comments. Do you have any other comments on this? I don't. All right. So let's discuss this.

30:50 Commissioner Chang, did you have any comments you'd like to make on this? Nothing other than what I just mentioned earlier. Okay. But ultimately, I think the options are all within the maximum allowable usage. Okay. Commissioner Callahan? No, I don't have any additional comments. Commissioner Burroughs? I don't have any additional comments. Okay. So I don't, you know, as far as the actual district zoning code amendment, I don't really have any comments. But I do feel...

31:22 As a commissioner and as a person that loves the community, that water efficiency in the future is not going to go away. I mean, yes, we've had our drought, but in the end, this whole issue of water efficiency is really important.

31:38 And I'm not overly fond of what we had to do here because I think it's very cumbersome and it's not very practical. And so ultimately if we want everybody to really use drought resistant landscaping and to be mindful of their water usage, we're going to have to come up with some really practical solutions that the average gardener can understand. And not only that,

32:05 You know, we're also very limited by what our

32:09 Providers bring us as far as plant selections usually to town. So my comment about this would be that I would just really encourage, Nolan, that you continue to work with the folks at the Water District. And I mean, I know the Water District has done a little bit of this. I believe they just did this workshop for the local gardeners and landscapers. But just continue working with them and trying to really come up with some practical ways to implement this.

32:38 You know, it doesn't do any good to have a code that says, in my opinion, you know, look at the sunset book. I don't know if you ever looked at the sunset book as far as recommendation. I don't think there are any recommendations because we're really like in zero zone code or something like that. So we just really need to be mindful of that. I mean, that would be my only comment on that. Yeah, and that part, again, is from the state. But, again, we have our making the most of every drop user's guide.

33:04 Which does provide some additional recommendation on plant types for the Mammoth Lakes area. So that is a helpful user guide for the person. That will be updated once this goes through with the current requirements. All right. And then are you going to, like, distribute that, like, in your lobby, like how we've done other things, probably? It's there, and it'll be on the website as well as emailed out to interested people. Okay. Interested parties. All right. Can I have a motion, please?

33:34 Make a motion to adopt the resolution, make the required CEQA and municipal code findings and recommend to town council approval of zoning code amendment 16.001 as recommended by staff. Second. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Callinan? Yes. And Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much.

34:05 All right. Our next issue is a business matter. It's to consider approval of design review DR16-008, located at 58 Ranch Road. The unit skipped a public hearing. I'm sorry. I really am like off my course today, right? Thank you. I caught it this time. All right. Consider. All right.

34:25 Agenda 6 and 7. Right. Consider approval of tentative parcel map 16-01 and use permit 16-003 for Canyonside, located at 113 Hillside Drive and 134 Canyon Boulevard, for the subdivision of an existing parcel and duplex structure into two lots as part of a residential plan unit development, otherwise known as a PUD, located within the North Village Pacific Plan area, and our staff contact person is Kim. On the far left. There we go.

35:18 All right. Okay. Okay, so the project before you is a modification to the Hillside Townhomes, which is a two-unit townhome project located on the corner of Hillside Drive and Canyon Boulevard, northwest of the Westin Resort. The Planning and Economic Development Commission previously approved a major design review application for the Hillside Townhomes in July of 2015, and a building permit was issued for construction of a

35:55 of the duplex in August 2015. The construction was recently completed and a certificate of occupancy was issued July of 2016. This slide is just showing the original approved elevation and the constructed building. On June 9, 2016, John Hooper submitted an application for a tentative parcel map to subdivide the duplex into two separate lots as a planned unit development.

36:25 The application included a change to the name from Hillside Townhomes to Canyonside. The project is located within the North Village specific plan area, which requires a minimum parcel size of 15,000 square feet for new subdivisions, located within the specialty lodging district. You can see, let's see if I can get my, I don't have a laser pointer, but the lot is lot 39. It's just on the outskirts of the specific plan area.

36:59 And then you see the more focused site plan there on the side. The North Village specific plan area allows minimum parcel size for planned unit developments and condominiums to be established in accordance with the proposed development subject to approval of a subdivision map and use permit.

37:27 The application is consistent with the North Village specific plan requirements because a tentative parcel map is the appropriate subdivision map for subdivisions of four fewer lots and the project qualifies as a planned unit development because it meets the specific criteria identified within the California Civil Code section 4175 which defines planned developments. The definition requires common area either owned by an HOA

37:55 or in common by the owners of the separate interests. Civil Code Section 4095 states that common area can consist of a reciprocal easement rights instead of a separate common area parcel as long as the project includes an HOA with the power to levy assessments that can become liens on each of the separate lots. These specific changes required to convert the existing duplex into a planned development

38:25 Included identification of common area and creation of a homeowners association. Common area is identified on the tentative parcel map as a reciprocal driveway access maintenance easement. You can see on this site plan, it's all of the shaded area, which is a large portion of the property. Homeowners association has been structured to maintain the shared site improvements, including the driveway roof and siding.

38:55 Staff included the HOA Articles of Association and CCNRs for your review to show that the applicant has met the qualifications for planned development. Since there are no other changes proposed for the development, staff has made the determination that the project meets the findings as required to approve the tentative parcel map and use permit applications. Those findings are as follows. The proposed project is consistent with the vision, goals, and policies of the general plan. The project conforms to the municipal code.

39:28 The project is consistent with the town design guidelines and the North Village Pacific Plan, and the project is consistent with CEQA. Based on those findings, staff recommends the commission choose to move forward with option one, and that includes adoption of the required CEQA findings, adoption of required municipal code and subdivision map findings, and approval of tentative parcel map 16-001.

39:58 And use permit 16-003 with the conditions recommended by staff or with modifications. I'm happy to answer any questions the commission has. And the applicant, John Hooper, is here if you have any questions for him. All right. Commissioner Kahn, do you have any questions? No, I have no questions. Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions? Initially, this was approved as a single family.

40:31 No. No. Initially, this was approved as a duplex in the form of townhomes, so it would be two units, but the property would be under one ownership. So you would most likely have maybe the owner occupying one unit and renting out the other, or having it as two rental units under one ownership. And we simply, okay, I get it. All right. By this subdivision, how would that impact parking?

41:06 Would there be additional increase in parking requirement? No. There's no increase in required parking for the size of those dwelling units. The development standards are not changing as far as the parking required for the size of those units. And the fact that each of the units can be owned separately doesn't increase parking demand. In the CCNR, I read one of the items, it said,

41:37 There is no property management for the duplex, so there's no property managers. So the responsibility then falls on the individual homeowners, is that what it is? I think that would be a good question for our applicant, but my understanding, having lived in a homeowner situation, is that oftentimes with large subdivisions, you have a property management company come in and handle all of the administration. But in this case, because it's

42:07 Only two units, it can be managed by the two owners. That's all I have. Commissioner Pearls, did you have any questions? I don't have any questions. Thank you. Does anybody in the public like to comment on this? Would the applicant like to comment? First of all, I'd like to thank the commission, and I'd like to do that when you pass the consent agenda. That finalized the mountainside map, so thank you. And also, I'd like to thank the staff for...

42:51 Being really efficient at expediting this process to get this map here this quickly. The project, really, I'm just here to answer questions. It was always meant to be two separate units used by two different people and ran it out. Part of RCC and ours always state that you need to register with the town as far as paying TOT. And the other owner is my partner.

43:21 And we would adhere to that. But really, it's just, you've already approved it as far as the design review, the purpose of the project, the location and all that. So really, I'm just here to answer any questions. All right. Does anybody have any questions? No questions. I mean, I drove by the property today again. You know, it's a really nice, nice design. Thank you. Well thought out.

43:47 And they're really, as you know, to serve as models for the mountainside project. There are 16 of those going up by what I call 7-8, but I guess it's Canyon Lodge or Bunker, whichever you can call it. It has to be Bear something. Now, you said that this is between you and your partner, but ultimately this is for sale, right? No. Of course it is in the future, but at this point in time, no. I see.

44:19 All right. Questions? Questions? All right. I have... Thank you. Any other public comments on this? All right. Then I close the public comment. So, Commissioner Rurals, so in, you know, our public hearings, you know, what we are charged to do are to discuss findings in a more extensive...

44:44 Request. What we usually do is go through our findings individually. I don't think we really need to do that today unless you're uncomfortable with that. Otherwise, what I'd just like to do is I'll just ask each commissioner if they have any issues with the findings, and that's what we'll use as the basis of our deliberations. Are you okay with it? All right. So who'd like to find you? So we have our findings up there. Do you have any comments about any of those findings? No, I don't. I think...

45:13 It's pretty straightforward. Right. I agree. I don't have any comments about it. Be clear. Commissioner Chang, did you have any comments about that? Other than what I just talked about. So I believe that we've substantiated our findings for today. So can I have a motion on this issue? I'll make a motion that we adopt.

45:36 The Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA findings, municipal code findings, and subdivision map act findings, and approving tentative parcel map, 16-001, and use permit, 16-003, with conditions as recommended by staff. Second. I'll second it. Okay. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Callanan? Yes. Chair Brown?

46:05 Yes, motion passes 4-0. Thank you very much. And I believe this was your first presentation to us, so thank you very much. It was nice to have you on the staff table. Thank you. Thank you. Yes. Yes. Are you volunteering? Yes. Okay. We're happy to have you. I'll contact you. All right. Thank you very much. So now we will move to our next item, which is a business matter.

47:07 Which is consider approval of design review DR16-008 located at 58 Ranch Road for the St. Joseph Church Parish Hall project. And our staff person is Kim again. Thank you. Okay. The proposed parish hall project is a 4,962 square foot multi-use assembly building located at the St.

47:34 Located on the St. Joseph Church grounds. The parish hall is proposed to function as an extension of the existing church and will host parish associated uses including religious education, wedding receptions and baptism parties, as well as community uses such as catered dinners, cultural events and voter registration. The property is a 3.37 acre triangular shaped parcel located within the residential multifamily 2 zoning district.

48:04 The St. Joseph Church and Rectory buildings are located at the northern portion of the site and the parish hall is proposed to be located within the existing paved parking lot area at the southwest portion of the property. Site improvements associated with this project include reconfiguration of the parking lot and driveway serving the St. Joseph Church and proposed parish hall buildings.

48:30 A drainage retention basin has been provided at the southern end of the property for improved drainage of the parking area and the site. Energy conservation measures, including a geothermal heating and cooling system, have been incorporated into the site design, as well as a roof-mounted solar array. The incorporation of these energy-saving elements will enable the development to approach or exceed a net-zero energy use.

48:58 The preliminary landscape plan for the project proposes that all disturbed areas of the site are going to be revegetated with native drought-tolerant plant species, which will not require permanent irrigation after they've been established. The design of the steel-framed structure incorporates a residential scale with an overall height of 28 feet 9 inches, an incorporation of attractive architectural enhancements, including view windows and rock siding.

49:29 The primary siding material is a hardy board cementious lap siding as well as cementious hardy boards for all of the trim areas. The roof is a medium bronze kynar coated steel and the interior of the assembly building is outfitted with an operable wall system which makes it possible to move the interior walls to create room configurations that are appropriate.

49:58 for the use of this space. A commercial-sized kitchen and pantry are proposed on the east side of the building to facilitate food preparation by caterers and church members. The parish hall is considered an accessory structure and used to the St. Joseph Church and is not proposed to be used concurrent to the church's primary service times. Based on the proposed staggered use of the buildings, the applicant requested staff to consider a shared parking plan for the two structures

50:30 In line with the alternative parking provisions of the town zoning code. The shared parking provisions of the zoning code allows for shared parking areas where two or more uses utilizing the same parking area have distinct and different hours of peak parking demand and that the required minimum number of parking spaces are provided for the most intensive use alone. Staff has included condition of approval number 25 to address the potential

50:59 For the parish hall to be used for an event or meeting concurrent to an event or service at the church. The condition requires the applicant to obtain a special event permit in these circumstances to ensure that parking is coordinated and monitored throughout those events. The design committee has reviewed the project and indicated support for the proposed design elements. It was noted at the meeting that there is a discrepancy between the trim color provided on the color material board and the photo renderings for the product.

51:31 for the project. So we can see in this photo that the materials board has brown trim, and the photo rendering shows darker green trim, so we can expect to see the brown trim incorporated into the final project. Additionally, the applicant indicated the photo renderings illustrate steps and handrails to the southern entrance of the building.

51:58 And because the site is relatively level, those elements will not be incorporated into the design of the structure. Public comment from an adjacent property owner was heard at the design committee meeting in regards to the removal of a Jeffrey Pine tree located at the western perimeter of the property where the grading plan identifies a cut grade area and swale construction. That property owner requested additional information regarding the removal of the tree and the design committee requested a condition of approval

52:31 to be included in the resolution to address the additional analysis requested, and if possible, require the tree to be saved or mitigated. Condition of approval number 22 included in the resolution addresses that request. And this shows on the site plan where the tree is located, and then it just blows up that window to show how it's shown on the plan.

52:57 Staff has made the determination that the project meets the findings as required to approve the major design review. The findings are as follows. The proposed project is consistent with the vision, goals, and policies of the general plan. The project conforms to the municipal code. The project is consistent with the town design guidelines. And the project is consistent with CEQA. Based on those findings, staff recommends the commission move forward with option number one.

53:25 to adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve major design review 16-008 with the conditions recommended by staff or with any modifications requested by the commission. I'm happy to answer any questions from the commission, and Kathy Cage and Robert Creasy, our applicants, are here to answer any additional questions you have. Okay. Now, did you have any comments?

53:56 From the design review committee, additional comments would you like to make? No. The summary in the staff report on the comments and the response to that I think were fairly accurate and sound good to me. I don't have anything additional. Okay. Commissioner Burroughs, did you have any questions? I do not. Okay. Commissioner Chang? I do. Yes. Earlier you mentioned the color on the siding here.

54:27 This is, well, you didn't talk about siding, you talked about the trim. The siding here shows green, but when I saw it right there, it's gray. Am I correct? It's actually, it's green. Well, this is green, yeah. So on this materials board? Yeah. This appears gray to you? No, that's green. Okay. But one of the images that you show was... Okay, so the photo might not have...

54:56 Been the best light to take for the materials board. It's the same materials board as it's displayed right here. Sorry about that. But the trim is going to be this color or that color? It's going to be this color. It's this color. This would be the most accurate representation right here. The landscape itself, will that be a very similar rendering?

55:27 Will it be similar to real life product? Are you asking if the photo rendering of the site shows the landscaping? On the landscapes specifically, yeah. Similarly, I can let the applicant sort of answer to that, but they have proposed to use native vegetation and boulders to sort of replace the existing...

55:56 Natural vegetation that's at the site currently. So that is what's shown here. You're seeing more background trees than I think exist at this time. But I'll let Robert speak to that. Thank you, Chair and the Commission. And actually, I'd really like to thank staff. You guys were great working through this process and very thorough with your report. Thank you. Quite accurate, I thought.

56:24 So the renderings were done fairly early in the process, and the renderer that we hired used a little bit of artistic license. So for example, you're seeing kind of summer wildflowers with autumn trees. So it's not an accurate representation probably of how these two parts of the vegetation will ever exist together. But the idea is basically that there are a lot of aspen trees on the southern end of the lot.

56:51 And we may introduce some more on the northern side of the building, which is the right side. But otherwise, we're planning to reseed with a hydro seed mix that has native wildflowers and sage and bitter brush and that kind of stuff. But like next to the parking lot, the driveway and...

57:12 The porch, that's all going to be fairly similar. Yeah, so it'll be sort of a natural landscape with some boulders. With additional boulders more than what you have showing currently, right? Not much more than that, I don't think. We're trying to keep the landscaping effort as minimal as possible. Got it. I just want to make a comment that I love the fact there's solar panels on this. Well, thanks. If I'm not mistaken, I don't think I've seen that many, or if any.

57:46 solar panels in this town. Well, it is a goal of the, of the, well, there's, so the state does have a goal of all buildings by 2020 being net zero, and they're going to be hard-pressed to, especially in a climate like this, to manage that without doing the combination of low-temperature geothermal and solar. But the parish is very interested in minimizing long-term operating expense and

58:15 Having lower energy costs is a good way to achieve that. So it really was a directive from the church to go that route. Given the amount of winter that we have here, how would that negatively impact those solar panels? So the panels, you want to have them in a steep enough slope that they will shed naturally of their own accord when the sun comes out. So we expect it.

58:43 A couple feet of snow could build up during a storm, but once the sun comes out, it's a pretty solar exposed site. There's not a lot of shading on that end of the building, so as soon as the sun hits it, it'll shed of its own accord and I think do perform pretty well. The panels are facing due east, but again, solar panels, as long as they're anywhere from due east to due west, they tend to do pretty well. Thank you.

59:14 Sure. Any other questions? I had some questions, if you don't mind. Sure. So I have two, I initially had two concerns. I believe my first concern has been pretty well vetted when we did our pre-meeting. My first concern really was about the fact about having sensor motion lights in the parking lot because you have these adjacent homeowners and I can, you know.

59:42 We have a lot of things that run around at night, you know, so rabbits, coyotes, bears, whatever. So, but they felt pretty strongly that between the down shields and the heights and whatever, it would not be an issue, but I would just ask as good neighbors that you really work with the lodge association to make sure, I mean, I realize that was required by the fire department, but I think it could be a little problematic in the future, so.

1:00:12 Well, and the dark sky ordinances do require that there's no light trespass beyond the property line, and I think that can be achieved. Right. We're not lighting the entire lot, it's really just the southern end in front of the building, so that if there is nighttime use or an emergent occasion, then there's lighting available. But I think the thinking is that they would be on a

1:00:38 A photo control until about 10 and then it would switch to the motion sensor through the night if needed, but I suppose wildlife could encroach on that area and trigger it, but it is sort of a parking lot, maybe not the most inviting to wildlife. We'll see. Yes. At one time you knew your sensor emotions when you drove down Ranch Road would like light up the stairs, but I think that was just a sensor emotion, so. But the, go ahead. Yeah, I can address a little bit of that.

1:01:09 Our interests and your interests are very much alike. The truth is I'm a real cheapskate and so I don't want to have to pay for lighting that we aren't going to use much anytime. So there's very few incidents where I can imagine we'd even want the lights on at night. Like if someone pulls in for some reason to drop something off after 10, why do we need parking lot lights on? Honestly, because you have your car lights. So we would probably have some kind of a control system that literally shuts them off at a certain time at night and not really even be motion controlled past a certain...

1:01:37 like evening time, most likely. So I, you know, we haven't really talked about this in detail, but all the details of that. Tom is. Yeah, would you be able to talk to the fire marshal about that? No, I mean, honestly, because I, anyway, we'll work that out, but we are interested in having fairly low-level lighting so that it doesn't, you know, impact the neighborhood. That works for us as well. So I think we only have like four new light fixtures, is it? Three. We only have three new light fixtures.

1:02:05 You could set it so that at a certain time of night, the light level that comes on is a much reduced percentage of its output. Even if it does come on. So if it does come on for the fire department, it's only at 20% or 30% of what it does during the evening hours. And, you know, we're going to work with Tom on that. Because it's hard for me to imagine what need the fire department would have for middle of the night parking lot light thing that they're not going to provide for themselves, honestly.

1:02:32 We will work it out to be an absolute minimum impact as we can into the neighborhood because that works for our interests too. Okay. So while you're both there, my real concern, because I live in the neighborhood, is parking. Ah, yeah. And, I mean, I just happen to know that your prisoners in the past don't like to use the parking lot, they like to use the...

1:02:56 The road. Get away. I know. I'm trying to be diplomatic here. Okay. So, but I will tell you that I know, because I've been in some meetings recently, that, I mean, we're really, as a town, going to start working, especially in the winter, on enforcing our no parking. And so, I think, you know,

1:03:21 Besides having your shared parking arrangements and having some conditions on that, I would really encourage you to start doing an education process. Maybe you have to have a couple of your parking attendants, not parking attendants, but some people like to really, especially on your big weekends, to really assist people how they're going to park in there and to exit and not to block the traffic and those things.

1:03:48 I don't think you can assume that you're going to forever be able to park on Ranch Road, so. Hang on, I'll just, because, you know, it's funny, Mickey, I just noticed, and I don't know if it's been up there all along, but the no parking from November 1st to whatever, and that's, I mean, supposed to be 24 hours, and I guess never been enforced, and I don't know if, is that new? Is that new? Is that always, Ranch Road always been that way?

1:04:13 Okay, because, I mean, that's sort of a really fundamental question. Is it really, you expect that people don't park on the side of a public road during the daytime when it's not, I don't know. So is that just a really big fundamental question about what we're going to do and what we're going to enforce? It's a town-wide issue, and that is actually applied town-wide. There's a sign when you're coming to town that says that, so.

1:04:38 Again, we're not going to get into the details here about the parking and the changes that may be coming. It hasn't come before town council yet. Okay. But, yes. But that is something that's like a real fundamental question, like what and when is it enforced and, you know, are we really serious about this? But I will say that you, in your future, Yeah.

1:04:57 Planning parish activities. Yeah. That you can assume that if it's winter and there's snow on the road, it's going to be enforced. Okay. Okay. So good luck on December 12th, Our Lady of Guadalupe at 5 in the morning. I know. But you know, but the good thing about the way you use the facility is, I mean, it's pretty predictable what your big days are. Right. So, right? Right. Yeah, and I just want to add something, too. The new configuration in the parking lot, I think, will actually provide much more utility of parking.

1:05:27 The way the lot's configured, it's sort of a barbell, and the spaces don't coincide with typical parking spacing layout, and by actually reducing the length but making it wider and well organized and better graded, it will be much more user friendly for everyone to get in and actually use all the spaces rather than, I think right now people kind of come in and they all parallel park and then you lose spaces that could well have been used.

1:05:55 I think it will actually help to improve the existing pressure of parking on the street with the new lot that we're proposing. Okay. All right. And then I just have one last question, and I just want to make sure that you've read the conditions and they're all acceptable. I have a couple questions. And then we can let you... Yes. Yes. Yeah, they all seem quite reasonable. All right. Just a couple questions somewhat related to what we talked about in the design committee meeting, but I was just...

1:06:22 Wanted to ask again on the record that given the energy efficient nature of the building and of the site, if you think there would be any possibility of LEED certification? I don't know actually what that process is except that you have to have like a certified person evaluated. Can you step up to the mic or share the mic? I've seen different projects LEED certified and I know there is a certain kind of a certified individual or, you know, that has to do that.

1:06:53 There's an expense associated with it. Right. And for a project that's so budget challenged. Budget challenged. We're achieving a lot of the things that, as you're identifying it, that would qualify for a lead. It's just going through the process and getting the label. We think, as we talked about, we'll just share for the rest of the commission, we think probably it would end up kind of around a bronze, probably. I think better than that.

1:07:22 Better than the bronze? Okay. Yeah. So it is nice. You're right. So you could say maybe it's a LEED silver equivalent. Yeah. Or equivalent. But maybe not have the go through the process, time-consuming and expensive process of getting an official certification.

1:07:38 And, you know, so, and this is just, since we're public here, I'll just give Robert a lot of credit. Basically, we've taken a super cost-efficient structure for up here in our seismic and snow load area that we've, you know, it's a warehouse building. It's all it really is. And he's done enough, you know, finishes on it to make it look attractive in the neighborhood and for the use. But it's super, you know, cost-efficient for us to do.

1:08:03 You know, it kind of accomplishes a lot of things. And, you know, he's the expert in all these great, you know, energy systems, which is one of the reasons we picked him as an architect. So he's got a lot of experience with these systems. And that's really going to be a great benefit to us.

1:08:17 You know, we're going to be lucky that you're not going to see, if you don't see us back here in six months with a hole reduced, because I'm pretty scared after we saw the price of the police station and the parking lot that the hospital just went in for 90 spaces, $588,000. I mean, I'm really starting to get really scared about prices now. So, trust me. Thank you for mentioning it, but I think spending money for a lease certification is very low on our priority list. I knew what the answer was. I just wanted to...

1:08:44 No, I appreciate that. Have a discussion about it. Since no one will actually be certifying, we'll be able to just say it and who's going to challenge us. So anyway, thank you. So I don't know how about Mickey, you or the rest of the commission fields, but it'd be interesting to know or to have a discussion at a future date on the towns. What can a town do in the future to incentivize or help project applicants, you know,

1:09:14 Down the path towards LEED certification. And I think that along with the low water usage that we're promoting, that low energy usage is something that we should really continue to promote. I agree. And one time, you know, we were pretty verbal about it, but then the Great Recession hit, and we were just happy to see. I just think there's got to be some grants out there available for

1:09:39 You know, to help with the paperwork, the process. But I know searching for grants and writing grants is also a time-consuming and expensive process. If I could speak to that actually a little bit. I'm on the board of the Sierra Energy Foundation, and we have talked about what are ways that we could work with town to provide identification or acknowledgement of projects that are more energy efficient. It could be a retrofit or a new project.

1:10:08 So I think as the town pursues that, please include us in the discussion and I think Rick Phelps and the rest of our group would have a lot to add to the discussion. Great. Thank you. All right. Back to the topic. Ken, did you have any other questions? No. Did you have any questions? All right.

1:10:32 I think we thank you very much. I'm assuming there's no other comments. We didn't receive any email comments, correct? No, we've not received any written comments from the public. All right. So can you go back to the slide with the findings, please? So there's our three sets of findings. I think, once again, we'll just discuss them in bulk. Did you have any comments about the findings, Commissioner Chang? Okay, thank you. Did you have any?

1:11:11 No, I'm happy with everything, I think, as we talked about, the main concern was the lighting and the parking, and the parking is actually a couple of spaces above what the code requires, and the lighting is well within, and in fact below, probably, what the code requires, so I'm happy with everything. Commissioner Burroughs? Additional comments? All right, can I have a motion, please? I'll make a motion to adopt the attached resolution, make it require CEQA findings.

1:11:41 Municipal co-findings and approved major design review 16-008 with commission with a minimum of staff. Second? Second. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Kellenan? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. I'm sure Father Andy is very happy today. Father Andy was a proponent of this project for at least 30 years, right? I know, right?

1:12:11 Oh, my goodness. And thank you very much, Kim. All right. Thank you very much. We'll now move on to our next business matter, which is to discuss and comment on the proposed draft revised land management plan for the Inyo National Forest Plan. And our staff contact person is Sandra. So, actually, the town manager, Dan Holler, is here to speak on this item. Okay. So, you want to hear it? Thank you, Madam Chair, Commissioner.

1:12:54 We're in the process of drafting up comments that will be going to Town Council on the 17th. It's not complete yet. We did submit comments via to the county regarding wilderness areas. They had a hearing on that and wanting input for that. I think a copy of that report or letter was available. I'm not sure if you've all received it yet or not. But I won't spend as much time on that. It basically, in the preliminary discussions and stuff, was looking at a number of the Port of Service

1:13:24 I don't know how much up to speed in this stuff you are, but they had three basic alternatives, A, B, and C. A was kind of a, well, actually they have another one that says no change alternative, but A had no new wilderness, for example. B has about a little over 37,000 acres, and C had substantially more acreage than that. So the town basically is supportive of the recommended alternative, which is alternative B.

1:13:53 Not just for wilderness, but for the overall plan, that's what they're looking at. So in the proposed revised land management plan for the Inyo, we're looking at supporting that alternative. I won't walk through a lot of the wilderness unless there's questions to that end, but basically when you add that 37,000 acres in, you take about 51% of the Inyo National Forest and it'll be included as wilderness.

1:14:19 The other 49% then is really focused on the recreational elements, whether that be for us in those areas, the other elements, grazing or other uses that are in the forest or some other designated areas that aren't wilderness that have restrictions on it, such as Mona Lake. There's those types of elements there. So a large percentage of the forest is committed to either, you know, very low impact or quasi no impact.

1:14:44 in terms of use elements on that. And so there's a write-up to that, and I can speak to more detail on that as need be. The other side, we've focused on the Inyo versus the other two forests, again, as it impacts Mammoth Lakes, but it is a three-forest process they're going through. So the Sierra and Sequoia are also incorporated as one of the early adopter forests for dealing with the new planning rule that allows them to mend their plans.

1:15:12 A number of areas that we've looked at is going through it. One of the elements there is we'll be asking that they actually reference and call out the framework for sustainable recreation that was a report put out by the Forest Service back in June of 2010. One of the key elements, I'll just read this in. I think it's a vital piece. It underpins a lot of our comments. And it's kind of the guiding principles for their mission and vision.

1:15:39 One of the statements is connecting people with their natural and cultural heritage is a vital thread in the fabric of society. It contributes to American identity and reminds people of the resources that sustain life, water, soil, food, and fiber. Moreover, recreation is the portal for understanding and caring for natural resources and public lands. It provides opportunities and motivation to advance from fun and attraction.

1:16:04 Through awareness, education, understanding to a role of citizen stewardship, one of giving back and supporting sustained management of natural resources. One of the other statements here for principals that we'll be touching on is community engagement is essential for creating a sustainable recreation program. Our role, meaning the role of the Forest Service, is to serve as planners, facilitators, conveners, and collaborators.

1:16:29 Tapping the enormous energy and creativity of people and communities that care for and benefit from public lands, including both private and public sectors. So one of our requests will be to incorporate the reference or direct quotes from this document from a national perspective, this overseeing all fours, not just ours, but to be reflected in the modified plan, the proposed plan. The element for that is...

1:16:56 The things mentioned there are exactly what we're trying to do now with our trails program, partnering with the Forest Service, how do we go out and get people engaged, how do we help maintain a partnership, and the idea is getting people, not the fact that we have a trail, but do they understand the trail network, do they understand the connection points, and do they understand the maintenance element and what trails do, and they can be different if you're biking or hiking or

1:17:20 Other uses, off-road vehicles, over snow vehicles, etc. What does that mean in the system? And as you bring people into that, hopefully they get a better understanding of, oh, I shouldn't do this, or maybe I shouldn't do this, or I should do this. You know, you pack it in, you pack it out. You go out and do a cleanup day. You know, you pick up several hundreds of pounds of litter. Okay, folks, this just didn't show up by accident.

1:17:44 Please think about as you're out there. So those types of connections. And the other element, a lot of that is with talking about Mammoth as a gateway community and frankly a number of the communities in the eastern Sierra region. The fact that we actually end up providing that support structure for people to enjoy both their front country and the back country. You're coming in here whether you're spending the night.

1:18:07 Whether you're here visiting, recreating, and eating, and dining, and providing those services, and shopping, something you may not think about much is we have folks coming off of the John Muir or the PCT trail coming to town, all of a sudden they need emergency dental work, and so local dentists are providing those services. It's a portal stop for people in this gateway community to say, you know, I got hurt on the trail, what do I do?

1:18:33 Those type of things. So we're actually providing that support service for folks who are enjoying both our wilderness areas as well as our front country area. We had a discussion today about a dentist. We had three people coming in off the trail that had emergency dental work they needed. So it's, you know, you think about that, you're out in the middle of nowhere. What do you do if, you know, a cap comes off your tooth or you break a tooth or something? And if you're a long ways from nowhere. So the whole idea there is gateway communities provide those resources.

1:19:03 And there's an impact and a benefit from that as we see that come through there. So there's a lot of stuff in the plan that we like and be supporting. It does talk about, you know, that whole recreational element. I'm not sure, you can go online and you can, the actual plan's about 200 pages. The environmental work's another 1,000 plus pages. So if you have some late night insomnia, I'd say it's interesting reading.

1:19:33 pieces of it. But I like the element they were talking about in here. It's although recreation may be what draws the majority of visitors and their associated economic benefits to the area, other uses of the forest, such as livestock grazing, mining, and renewable energy maintain some of the historic uses of this area while also providing local society, culture, and economy.

1:19:56 And it goes into this blending of we're very much focused on the recreation economy. It's estimated $650 billion a year economy across the country. But there's other elements of our forest in our particular area here that is important that we don't want to lose sight of. It's not just all about recreation. There's other economic elements that come to that. And we do have a lot of cultural heritage elements from Paiute tribes and stuff that we're through here from an Indian historical perspective that we need to be conscious of.

1:20:26 Support seeing those things. And as we look at that, it really is a force of multiple uses. Again, they mentioned that it's the social and economic elements really important. It's a four-hour drive of nearly half of the 37 million residents in California. So we're a popular destination. And that gives them some really good challenges, both in how to look at nontraditional methods of providing services. There's over 2 million people a year visiting the Inyo, and that doesn't include the use permit at the mountain.

1:20:54 And so you start to look at that and say, how do we balance that? So part of our comments is we recognize that changing recreational element. And a lot of the focus will go into you're not going to be successful, we believe, unless you really develop meaningful partnerships with local communities to help manage that. The Forest Service isn't set up to do that financially. They're not set up to do that from a staffing standpoint. And we see that happening in a number of areas. And I'll touch on some of those as we go through.

1:21:22 Some of the comment areas. But the other positive elements in the plan is this is trying to make it a more of a high-level plan. It's not as detailed on purpose. It's adaptive planning is the language they're utilizing, understanding that we don't know what for sure is going to be here in the future, so we need to have means to respond to what changes on the ground. Be that climate change, to be that visitor impact change, to be that

1:21:48 You know, natural disaster changes, whatever that might be, is how do they adapt the various things that happen in the planning process and the things that come forward as they do that. So they will be looking at the plan as truly that higher level piece of that that will happen. They make the statement, generally, of course, plans are not tactical and do not specify particular methods that must always be used and do not require resources to be allocated.

1:22:18 Forest plans emphasize strategic decisions, the why and the what, and to the lesser extent when and where. The how decisions is generally made at the tactical or project level and includes a set of specific details of time, place, and circumstances at that level. So you won't see a lot of that level of detail in the plan, which actually we think is probably a good thing because we're trying to do that today and we don't know what it's going to look like 5, 10, 20. The last one was done in 88, so give you a feel for the time frame of these plans.

1:22:47 Are in place. So with that adaptive planning structure we think is a healthy element to get into what the forest plan will be supporting that. One of the other things the plan gets into and talks about is fire. It's a huge issue going throughout not just the Inyo forest here but just in the reintroduction of more fire activity on the national forest throughout the west primarily.

1:23:15 Just in terms of, we've been under a number of years of heavy suppression, and so we're set up for much more catastrophic type fires, and so there's a fair amount of discussion about how can we use fire as it has been more historically allowed to be utilized, be that from lightning strikes and stuff of that nature, even some human caused fires, how do you manage those versus suppress them? Definitely that's a choice each time that gets made, you know, how quickly do we put this out versus

1:23:44 Are there resource advantages to allow it to burn? Just the recent ones, I don't know the end game, finally on the Clark fire, but on one of that, there actually was a big thinning project out there about 15 years ago. Actually, if that fire burned into that, that would actually be a healthy use of fire. It would actually knock down the stuff, the latter fuels that were growing, so it would be a way of natural fire, that was a lightning strike. So that would be a natural way for that fire to go out.

1:24:12 Do what it's supposed to do, frankly, in some of these environments. Rock Creek fire was human caused, most likely. It's still under investigation. Again, much more dangerous there because now you have life and property and things that get in the way. So those types of decisions coming in. We'll probably add a comment requesting that as they look at air quality issues that they do consult with the air districts. They do that as a matter of practice. We'd like to see it actually in the plan that they have that liaison work with that.

1:24:41 The other component the plan talks about is volunteers, interpretation, partnerships, and stewardship. Again, this whole element of how do we begin to put together meaningful partnerships. The language in the statement here is desired conditions and other plan components for interacting and participating to work together on shared interests with people, organizations, agencies, e.g. local, state, and federal, nonprofit businesses.

1:25:09 And communities are included under the heading there. And one of our key elements on that, you'll get a lot of push of just saying the Forest Service has to create this partnership coordinator to go out and create partnerships. And our concern is partnerships for the sake of partnership is probably not the right way to go. You want partnerships that truly bring resources and capacity to the Forest Service and focuses on the success of their programs that it calls out. You know, they make a goal for recreation in 10 years to have

1:25:38 I think it's 600 to 850 miles of trails meeting standards. They will no way that I can see do that on their own resources unless Congress fixes the national deficit and funds them again or we take all the fire funding and put it into trails, let the rest of the forest burn up around them. But the element there I think is what you're looking at on those types of things is that can happen to a much larger degree.

1:26:05 If you have meaningful partnerships, we're coming in and not telling the Forest Service, here's what we will do as a partner, but you're trying to come in and say, here are your goals and things that you're trying to achieve as a Forest Service, how do we come alongside of you under your authorities and help you achieve those things? And the town has really been trying to focus on that, how do we come in with use permits that make sense, how do we come in with programs that says, we're doing that right now in our trail maintenance program is probably a good example, was

1:26:32 We're actually taking their manuals and saying, here's what your own documents say how these trails should look. How can we come in and help you achieve that? Not saying, here's what we think they should be or here's what we think it should look like, but how do we take your designs, if you will, and actually implement them on your behalf and partner with you? Same thing with trail heads. How do we get more of them in place? But right now, they have a whole other section talking about infrastructure and their goal to bring it up to standards.

1:27:00 That's literally millions of dollars in investment just in the Mammoth area. Reds Meadow Road is probably on its own a $20 million plus or minus investment just to bring it up to standards. But how do we partner with them and say we agree that your infrastructure is lacking, we want to bring it up, how do we help you? Same thing going we want a new trailhead, they're going to go great, we have no money to build it and we have no way to maintain it.

1:27:26 So the extent that we want that as a community to come and say, well, right, we will provide the stewardship what's necessary to make this a successful trailhead. We'll come in and enter into agreements for how do we maintain some of these elements, how do we help fund their construction. And I think some of that is missing in some of the detail. I think it's there in concept. So we'll be asking for some harder language in there. I think it says, here are some key elements that probably should be in there that give us the strength we need to walk in with our partners and go.

1:27:55 We want to walk beside you and help you not come in and tell you how to manage the forest. It'll be a key element there. The sustainable recreation is built in throughout the plan and it could say we want the one reference to the original guiding document. But we like their comment that the Inyo's niche, kind of in this whole recreation, what they call it, inspiring destinations. And if you think about it from Whitney to Mona Lake to, you know, the...

1:28:23 Wilderness areas, they have a lot of that element there that is very powerful and we see that in the draw of people. Part of our challenge is how do we work in the front country and expand out dispersion of some of that recreational impact versus the full body contact recreation currently going on in the lakes basin. I don't know if you've been up there on a weekend here recently but a lot of fun but your shoulder to shoulder on trails and maybe some of your experience isn't what you would normally expect in some of those areas.

1:28:53 But it's a forest-wide goal that how do we do that the year-round elements and begin to build that recreational element that brings the social and economic elements in as well as the other things there. We think, again, that partnership and a lot of this really feeds together. We're a gateway community. We can create partnerships. We can come along and help provide stewardship elements in a lot of areas to expand that recreational experience. Again, they have all the authority to do that, so there's a certain level of protections you want under that.

1:29:22 How do we do that together? I mentioned earlier, they talk about energy in a very short statement. They talk about the infrastructure needs and the challenges there. Then they get into the management strategies, and I won't spend as much time walking through all of those. One of the biggest areas there will be ultimately, I think, a change in fire. More activity, more, we were actually in support of a lot of areas, more mechanical treatment. When you start to look at the tree kill,

1:29:48 You know, this side, you see stuff here and you kind of get a little shock. If you go to the west side, it's scary. It looks a lot worse and a lot more invasive and a lot of things of that nature. The last point, the last two points I'll touch on. One is on, there's a definition of a lot of recreational places. There's some of them very, you know, key to Mammoth. The lakes basin area, Mammoth and Scarpment. There's a couple others, you know, the June Lake Loop is defined in those types of areas.

1:30:17 And looking through those and making sure we're comfortable with the way they're defined out is very important. We have one change in the recreational zone issues. I think it's a technical error is how it calls out part of the Sherwin's area as being, you know, almost, they have a list of areas I'm trying to, it's almost like a non-roaded, non-habited, non-developed at all. And yet, that's the Mammoth Rock Trail. That's the road that goes out there, Sherwin Creek Road.

1:30:47 In one map I think it's correct, in another map it's wrong, so we want to make sure that gets corrected in the process there, working through that. And so they deal with Mammoth Place, Mammoth Escarpment, Cune Lake, talks about the lakes basin and different areas of that nature, that works into those iconic places, a lot of them impact us directly, and so we'll be wanting to support some of that, but making sure that those goals are lining up with what we see into the future in some of those areas as well.

1:31:15 And then lastly again is the last item I had marked in here was just the wilderness component which I won't dive into in detail there but we do have a lot of wilderness in the area as we work through that. And so that'll be kind of the flavor of the comments we'll be making. We'll be working through this next week with Council to kind of nail those down. But there's a lot of pieces of moving parts and obviously there's a fair amount of discussion out there by, you know.

1:31:43 Various interested parties, individuals across the forest. You're looking at a little over 2 million acres of land, so a lot of interested parties. A lot of our comments are Mammoth-centric on purpose, but some of them also would lean toward the eastern Sierra region, so trying to balance that out a little bit. With that, I'll try to answer any questions. I should have told you to interrupt me as I was going if something came to mind. It's a lot of information to try and digest. The town's been engaged on the front end.

1:32:12 with comments and the scoping and then now the process is moving through here. So with that. So I, you know, I had the opportunity to go to several informal meetings on this and so at one, and I know we're running short on time, so this is why I'm trying to get a sense about what we're going to do here. So I know at one time the objective was that

1:32:39 We felt that there was some merit in the, at least Mono, maybe hopefully Mono and Inyo counties, the town of Mammoth Lakes, presenting this united front to the Forest Service saying, hey, this is what we really would like to see, you know, in our comments. So I'm assuming that's, except for the wilderness component, basically what we're still on, right? So then, now, you're going to write

1:33:07 In some fashion with Councilperson Wentworth, right, a letter. Right, it'll have this type, all these types of comments. Right, on the comments, right. But we won't have, we as a commission won't have time to see that letter before it's due, correct? Yeah, it's due by the 25th. Okay. So is there any advantage, because one thought was that, you know, maybe what we just make a motion today that once that letter is,

1:33:37 You know, actually presented to council, council approves it, then, you know, somebody on commission could say, yes, you know, we as a commission like this letter and then we could put our also our name on as a commission. I mean, is there a benefit to that, do you think? It probably doesn't hurt just in terms of the public bodies making the comment. You may be able to structure that either at a special meeting.

1:34:00 It'd depend up to the rest of the commissioners that they wanted to give that authority to the chair to review it. Right. And unless there's something that jumps out that says, no, based on past discussions, you wouldn't see the commission supporting that. But if they trust the chair or somebody else in the commission to do that review and say, yeah, we don't mind saying that this generally supports the elements and support that the planning commissioners looked at in Mammoth Lakes and that some, you know.

1:34:27 Intro type paragraph, maybe that way, almost as an attachment, going with it. That would be viable and doable. I mean, there's a lot of information, a lot of things there, so it's more of a comfort level of the commission. You know, you can't pass it around for comments, but you could do it back, either do a special meeting, or you could come back and delegate that to the chair to look at, or if somebody else wants to take that on, that's up to you all, so. Do we have any

1:34:58 Questions? I mean, has everybody seen at least one presentation been done meeting yet on this? Or is this the first time? Meeting by the Forest Service? No, no, like in the last, pardon me? You mean presented by the Forest Service? Well, actually, it's the, you know, Eastern Sierra. Yeah, there's been workshops by the Eastern Sierra Recreation Collaborative, and that's been very focused on the recreation element. The Forest Service has been conducting open houses.

1:35:28 I don't know if anybody's made it to those. I went to the one here the other night at Sierra Coastal College. So they have a couple, one or two more of those coming up prior to the comment period. It's good information whether, you know, just, if you just want to get informed on and get a better understanding of some of the dialogue, they're good meetings. They're an open house structure, so you go to different rooms, if you will, and here's all the maps and pile of documents.

1:35:54 It's some good conversation. But the executive summary, I mean, I think it's 17 pages, so that's doable. Yeah. And, you know, frankly, if you read the first few chapters of the actual plan instead of all 200 pages, you get a pretty good feel pretty quick of what is in the plan. And it's all on their website.

1:36:19 I have it right in front of me, a website address. Also in the packet, we provided the summary document, the overview guide, which looks like it includes a YouTube video as well, so there's that option as well. The actual draft management plan is that you had to read, and then the EISs are what get really entailed. There's two volumes, and there's a whole other one on wilderness, so those elements are there.

1:36:48 But if you went through the first three chapters in here, which is just under 100 pages, it gives you a really good overview of what's in the proposed plan. Now, how it got there, that's the draft environment impact statements and everything else. I think the other comment in here that's important for people to understand, I think they forget it, is actually the land management plans do not require the Forest Service to actually do anything. It does put some constraints on them if they do do things.

1:37:16 It doesn't say thou shalt go do all these things. It doesn't constrain the public because the public processes and things we go through, you know, if you want to do something on forest land, then you have to follow, okay, here's all our guidelines that we will regulate you with. And then there's a lot of other forest orders and other legal obligations they have in protecting the forest and doing different things that aren't in this plan, but it references some of that.

1:37:44 And so then, so it constrains us ultimately when we come in to request to do something. Otherwise, there's really no constraint on the public until you request to use your property in some other way. But it doesn't force them to do anything either. It's truly, it's a planning, big picture document. I think some people look and think, oh, we've got to have language in here so the Forest Service will do what I want. But they're not going to do it anyway. Well, they don't have, it doesn't force them to go do those things.

1:38:11 The wilderness is the biggest one because what happens there is it actually, Congress is the only one that can designate wilderness. So if you call out a plan and says this area has the characteristics of wilderness and in the plan, that what it tells them is okay, we will manage it and the things we do want would be managed as wilderness. If you came in and said I want to put a road across it, the answer would be sorry, you can't do that, it's wilderness. You want to extend a power line here, sorry, you can't do that, it's wilderness. We want to open up a campsite.

1:38:39 You know, a trailhead or something. Sorry, you can't do that in wilderness. But ultimately, Congress has to act at some point in time and say, yes, we reviewed all these potential wilderness areas and we're going to designate one or none or all as wilderness. But it's a congressional delegation that actually makes it wilderness. Some people know that, some don't. So if I'm speaking out of school here.

1:39:02 I mean, and just, you know, my personal opinion about the option C for additional wilderness is that, you know, our problem is we have limited funds anyway, so then if you designate even additional wilderness, okay, you know, and then how are we going to manage it where we could manage that open land other ways than have giving it a wilderness designation?

1:39:24 No, option B has a, it's kind of like the middle of the road as far as the wilderness. Option C, you can correct me, all the way out to the Glass Mountain. There's a lot of it. Right. And I think the claim on that is the Forest Service did the analysis and they looked at a bunch of that and said, from their analysis, you know, it's nice when you agree with it. It's the analysis going, this really doesn't have the wilderness characteristics that we believe qualify it to be wilderness under the plan. It's the difference between

1:39:52 I just want this to be wilderness, but I think it's a good idea, versus, no, here's all the characteristics it has to meet. And, you know, we had some discussions with them at the open house and stuff, and one of the ladies was, one of the, she goes, this has been my life for the last five years or three years in this wilderness, going, well, here's the findings we made on that particular piece of wilderness, here's the findings we made on that one. And it was really interesting to walk through that, because if it...

1:40:18 If it hits that character threshold, it's easy for them to recommend. If it doesn't, it's hard to say, well, it doesn't really, but we'll go ahead and put it in out of a public request, which generally they stay away from, frankly, because of the management challenge. You're right. The other side of that for Forest Service plans is ultimately the Forest Supervisor makes that decision. This is not a public vote. It's not a, you know, we got 52 comments and percent didn't.

1:40:48 Favor and 48 against, that's ultimately the supervisor will make that decision and then the courts will either back it up or not. Only expect that this will be litigated regardless of what we do. But you want to make as strong as you can. So they do appreciate comments and adding in language of why do you want that comment. Any questions? I certainly don't feel I'm knowledgeable enough to provide a feasible

1:41:26 Intellectual feedback or comments such a broad, sophisticated topic and involves essentially these government agencies that ultimately requires quite a bit of bureaucratic process, right? True, I agree on the process. And one of those, yeah, here's a thousand pages, go ahead and skim through this. Between this and the water efficiency, when I was reading my packet, I thought I was reading in a foreign language or something.

1:42:04 It's a nice introduction. We did that just for you, right? Good timing. Did you have any questions? No, not really. I echo your comments about the wilderness and the burden that options see would be. That's it. Did you have any questions? I don't have any questions. I really appreciate trying to build a partnership with the Forest Service and have

1:42:35 You know, a mutual plan is how we're going to go forward and benefit both parties. I do have one question since the partnership. Every time I hear that word, partnership, with a federal entity, given that they, with the lack of fund, and with this partnership, I'm assuming that whenever we approach them, we ask them how we can contribute. Ultimately, if it's not

1:43:07 Ideas, labor, or ultimately it's fun. Do we contribute to China Mammoth Lakes? Actually? I can speak to that, but yeah, go ahead. I'm sorry. That's the question. Financially, how do we contribute to trail maintenance and things? Right. So the agreements we have with the Forest Service deal with a lot of that and how we structure that. You think a partnership with, I'll say any federal agency, but...

1:43:38 In this case, the Forest Service. It's not a partnership of equals necessarily. We actually have, you know, we have a federal government, state, and then we're creators down from the bottom here, counties, cities, et cetera. And so it's built on mutual respect to that and, you know, understanding their authorities and what they can and can't do. So we do a lot of partnerships to do these through formal agreements. For example, the Lake Basin, Lakes Basin Bike Trail.

1:44:05 That was built out of a partnership of everybody kicking in dollars. There was R money involved in different things, federal grant dollars. Use permit for the trail, then the questions come up later, well, who actually has to go maintain that? So we're maintaining the trail, but when you have a hazard dead tree next to it, who takes those out? The Forest Service did a bunch of this this last year, for example. But we do have agreements on those, and so we fund some of that out of town dollars, be it our maintenance budget. With Measure R,

1:44:35 The dedicated half cent tax. I'll call it a sales tax. It's a transaction use tax. Part of that is what's funding the trail program. Trails are actually called out specifically in that. And the uniqueness there requires that money to spend on things that are town owned or managed. And so the management side is that's what we're working with the Forest Service. We want to have this cost share agreement. We want to have a use permit. We want to have these other authorities in place that says, okay, you are responsible to do

1:45:05 X that on this property, so we're managing that effort, be it trail maintenance, be it snow removal, we have an agreement where we, with the town, not part of me as you are, we do some law enforcement work for them, our shady risk park is on a use permit, for example, we have to maintain the park, we have certain requirements we have to do out there for that park on their property, so most of the stuff we end up doing, the more high profile stuff is generally coming out of restricted money.

1:45:32 But each year we have an agreement how we handle the early or late closure opening of the Lakes Basin. We actually go up and we put up trash and we put up portal toilets and we do some of the snow removal and we pay that out of our general fund. But there we have an agreement with them that we will go do that because they're going, that's great, we can't provide those facilities so either we leave it locked or if you want it open earlier, how can you participate?

1:46:00 And then they get the call we give them, you don't want us up there. If there's a major storm coming in, you don't want a crushed outhouse up there, frankly. A little messy to clean up in the spring when it thaws out. And so they have other authorities, they'll call and say, hey, we need to get them out, or no, they're okay. We'll ask them, where do you want them? You know, help us place stuff in the basin. So it's a partnership from that perspective, working through that. And they've been very flexible in some of those areas. It's been very helpful for us in working with our guest experience in town.

1:46:34 All right. So if, as far as a letter, do we need a motion or how would that work? Okay. For, for you to be able to review a letter on behalf of the Planning Commission. Right. And then sign it. I'm comfortable with that. All right. Thank you very much. I really, you should have just like recorded the speech by this time. It's very, it's, I just will say, you know, it is interesting as much as,

1:47:13 We have been involved in planning. You know, that document is like seriously like reading a foreign language because it's just so outside what we normally do. And yet, I mean, it's really our sister document because we're so closely tied together. So I really appreciate all your work and Councilperson Wentworthworth and Supervisor Corliss, I mean, for leading the charge. You know, it's really been great. So thank you very much.

1:47:56 Okay, so we'll close this business matter and we'll move to Commissioner Reports. Design community. I think our last meeting was about the church, or the parish hall, which we don't need to discuss again. Did you have anything else you'd like to add? No. No, I don't. Not before, but I was going to go back and talk about that. That's a very short discussion about leave.

1:48:31 Yeah, so what we really would need to do, if we want to have a discussion about LEED, we really need to put it on. Not specifically. But we need, and we should probably put it on our agenda. I mean, at one time it was, I believe it was part of our Dr. Sed's document that. We can put that on the agenda for a future meeting. I just really have one quick comment or question about it. Is that given the new energy code in Title 24, I thought those codes LEED cert requirements.

1:49:07 That's my understanding that the current California Energy Code and green California Building Code exceeds the minimum LEED standards. Yeah, so that means almost that recognition isn't... Well, except that the LEED actually encompasses a lot more than just the energy. There's a whole lot of other components to it, such as...

1:49:36 You know, landscape use, and site use, and service by public transportation, and there's a whole lot of other components to lead. Energy is a big part of it, but not exclusive. I do think it'd be worthwhile someday when we don't have a really heavy agenda to just put on there. We can have a general discussion about that. I'd just like to report that I did attend the

1:50:07 Long Valley Hydrology Advisory Committee, also known as HAC, meeting today. And I just had a couple of comments. You know, obviously, I think it was well said that our drinking water is really important and renewable energy is really important. It's very complex, and there's a lot of different data. I think the one...

1:50:32 Takeaway is that the BLM right now does not have a geologist, and until they have a geologist, there will be no action coming out of the BLM in the near future. So that's an important takeaway from that. Our water is still safe to drink. So, all right. You want to talk about director's report and joint meetings and stuff?

1:50:59 Yeah, so the town council has suggested a joint council commission meeting on September 21st, which is a Wednesday. That's a normal council meeting day. And I think the time is we're looking at 4.30, so from 4.30 to 6. So this would, you know, the commission and the council, you know, every six months or so have joint meetings to discuss topics usually of interest to the commission or council.

1:51:28 Often we talk about the department's work program, so we'll put together an updated work program for that so we can walk through that at that meeting. And typically what we do is the commission meeting before we talk about any agenda items that the commission would like to talk about. So I guess preliminarily we want to see if there's availability for the commissioners for September 21st. And if you don't know right now, that's fine. I can send an email out just to let you know and to

1:51:57 You know, see if we'll have a majority of the commission here for that meeting. I think I'm okay if it's late afternoon. Yeah. I'm potentially out of town, but I won't know probably for a couple of weeks. Okay. Potentially, okay. And then, and this is very preliminary, but just so that you know, I had a conversation with Mayor Richardson, and we really wanted to do maybe a series of workshops. We haven't figured this out yet.

1:52:26 To really discuss some of the ideas that were presented by Hart Howarden and really do an in-depth study, and we'd probably divide that into two separate meetings. One meeting would be to discuss amenities, and one meeting would be to discuss workforce housing. But we have to figure all that out. But I think the important part is that we were given some, Hart Howarden is an amazing planning firm. They had some really great concepts, and the reality is that some of them we can incorporate.

1:52:56 Thank you.

1:53:20 So, in, when we, the last time we had new commissioners, we had, actually at that time we had three new commissioners, and so as a group we spent time having meetings where how, one meeting which I thought was really good was how to read a CEQA report and the different elements of it, those kinds of things. And, you know, we also have our infamous reading list of our important source documents. So,

1:53:50 Kind of the question is, we can do these things with one-on-one meetings with Commissioner Burroughs, or did anybody feel that you had a need for any other educational component as we start the new commission year? Well, I don't know. Sometimes review is useful. But it depends what you have in mind, I guess. Well, I mean, probably, you know, I just, well, let's ask about the CEQA report. Does anybody want to go through that CEQA training?

1:54:22 Session that Nolan put together again? I'm indifferent. Okay. But you probably have had a little bit more exposure to it. I'm indifferent either way. Okay. So, I mean, I don't know how big our agendas are in the future. It looks at this point like the September agenda is relatively light, so maybe we can put some sort of a kind of a quick refresher course on some of these different items on the September agenda. Okay. Or if there's anything else explicitly.

1:54:57 That you feel would be important to make you comfortable. I mean, because, you know, unfortunately, the bad, you know, we kind of get a little bit of a bad habit because we've done this now for a while and then we have all these little acronyms and, you know, shortcut ways of doing things. But we're willing, anytime, you know, you don't understand what we're talking about because we've done our, especially the acronyms, we're really happy to, like, just say, hey, can you explain that to us? Explain those to you. Asking questions. Yes.

1:55:26 And the staff has been really helpful for me during my first term, in my first year. A lot of documents in relation to different parcels. That's what I'm thinking. To try to maybe, you know, capture everything at once. All right. Do you have anything else? No? Okay. Then I move that we adjourn to our next regular scheduled meeting, September the 14th, 2016 at 2 p.m. Thank you, everybody.