TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2016

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 35 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

311 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Change could result in up to 336 more residential units, up to 467 more rooms, and approximately 152,500 more commercial square feet compared to the current build-out. The table in the EIR has a lot of notes in it, which we've just put up on this slide so that you could see them. What we're doing with these is to document

0:26 The methodology so that it's clear down the road how we arrived at the numbers. So again, a key thing with Table 3 is it's showing the net increase. So it takes out existing because a redeveloped parcel, the demolition would occur of existing units, for example, and it would be redeveloped. So you don't want to keep the existing ones in and double count things. So that's the whole purpose of the netting. So what I wanted to talk about.

0:55 Today, two is the final EIR because that's the phase that we're in. So the purpose of an EIR is to evaluate the project and identify potential physical impacts on the environment that could occur with the project. CEQA ensures that the public and decision makers understand the implications prior to a project being approved. And as you recall, the draft EIR notice of availability were published on June 24th this year.

1:26 And that started at 45-day comment period, which closed on August 8th. As you recall, we had a Planning Commission meeting on July 13th to take public comments on the draft EIR. The final EIR was released on October 27th. The final EIR includes the draft EIR, responses to comments, corrections and additions, and the mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and I'll talk more specifically about those pieces.

1:54 But just a reminder to, you know, run quickly through what's in the draft EIR. This provides a list of the issue areas that are evaluated in the EIR. It's based on the initial study, so there's some issue areas under CEQA that are scoped out but still accounted for. And then there's detailed evaluations in the draft EIR for the project.

2:16 This slide summarizes the conclusions of the draft EIR, and there's three categories of potentially significant impacts identified in the draft EIR. Less than significant, less than significant with the incorporation of mitigation measures, and significant and unavoidable. So this slide is providing an overview by the different categories.

2:38 This slide just summarizes where there are significant and unavoidable impacts, where those could occur, which are air quality, recreation and traffic. Because of the importance of alternatives in the CEQA process and the requirement of a comparative analysis in the EIR, I just wanted to cover again the three alternatives that are evaluated. The first is the no project alternative, which is the continuation of the current general plan.

3:09 designed to reduce significant impacts that were identified. Alternative 2 is a reduced intensity alternative, which would allow a maximum of 1.5 FAR, and that would reduce the overall development by about 114 less residential units, up to about 254 rooms less compared to the project, and about 25,187 square feet of commercial floor area.

3:37 The third alternative is the mobility element update without the reconfiguration of Main Street. The 2.0 would remain, and then just the properties that are identified as intensifying along Main Street would not occur. So again, a slight reduction in development. So the final EIR is Volume 3 of the document, and it's made up of four chapters. There's an introduction, responses to comments, corrections and additions,

4:07 And the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. The response to comments includes five letters that were received by the town, and these are all from agencies. It's the State Clearinghouse, Caltrans, Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board, MCWD, and the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. The final EIR includes the letters which are bracketed, and then responses are provided to each of the comments. This slide summarizes the comments received by issue area.

4:39 Caltrans requested some revisions to the wording of an impact statement and mitigation measures as well as requesting coordination with the town as the mobility element is implemented. Mammoth Fire Lakes Fire Protection District had questions regarding traffic, congestion, and the provision of emergency responses as well as the removal of the frontage road. The Regional Water Quality Control Board provided comments regarding water quality and stormwater runoff.

5:07 MCWD requested that a policy and mitigation measure be strengthened, and they also requested clarification of the analysis, as well as revisions to the language regarding the settlement agreement. The Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District addressed response times and congestion, as well as availability of affordable housing. In addition, the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District addressed the right sizing of infrastructure and the relocation of utilities along Main Street.

5:37 All of the comments that were raised in the letters are addressed in the final EIR. So what's next in the process? This slide again shows the conclusions in the EIR, which is that the project could result in significant and unavoidable impacts in air quality, recreation, and traffic. And these conclusions are similar to the conclusions or the findings in the 2007 General Plan EIR. Some of the conclusions are a result of the nature of it being a program-level EIR.

6:07 And the fact that there are significant unavoidable impacts does not preclude the town from moving forward with the project. So the next steps include making findings that are required under CEQA since there are significant effects identified, and then the town needs to identify the mitigation measures that would be incorporated into the project.

6:29 In addition, if the town decides to approve the project, the town will need to adopt a Statement of Overriding Considerations. The Statement of Overriding Considerations must show that the economic, legal, social, technological, or other benefits that would result from the project outweigh the significant environmental effects. The findings in the Statement of Overriding Considerations are in the resolution that's attached to the staff report.

6:57 In addition, the final EIR includes the Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program, which would be adopted by the town. The MMRP, which is the acronym for it, is a tool to ensure that mitigation measures are incorporated into a project. The MMRP provides the timing of implementation, the method of verification, and the enforcement agency.

7:21 And the MMRP has been set up to include mitigation measures from this project as well as measures from previously certified and associated EIRs. So the general plan EIR from 2007 as well as the trail system master plan. And the reason for doing this is to make it easier for staff to work with these measures and to ensure that the implementation of the measures developed do minimize the environmental impacts. Now I'll turn it back to Sandra.

7:51 Thank you. So staff put together one discussion item for the commission.

7:57 And that was relative to the minimum floor area ratio. The commission and staff had had a discussion at a commission meeting and the commission provided direction to staff to analyze a minimum FAR. So the public provided comments and staff included a minimum of .75 FAR in our analysis. So staff has received in the

8:23 past year received a number of different proposals for projects and none of them have

8:30 come close to meeting that .75 FAR. So staff thought it would be appropriate for the commission to discuss the requirement of a minimum FAR and whether that's appropriate to include still as a recommendation to the council at this time. So we did provide some analysis in the staff report discussing minimum FARs and so that's one of the items that staff would like the commission to discuss and take public comments on.

8:58 And with that, staff recommends that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached resolution and recommend that the Town Council take the following actions. Consider the Environmental Impact Report for the Land Use Element Zoning Code Amendments and Mobility Element Update and adopt the required CEQA findings.

9:18 Adopt the required municipal code findings and approve general plan amendment 15-002 and zoning code amendment 15-002 as proposed or as with any modifications that the commission recommends. And so that concludes our staff presentation. We're all available for questions. So thank you. Thank you very much, Sandra and Lucy.

9:44 At this point, we'll move on to questions from the Commission, and I think to keep things a little bit streamlined, I'd like to sort of address the various topics within this item as listed in the report summary on page two of the packet. If that works for you, Sandra? Yes. Okay. So that being said, let's start with any questions or comments regarding the FAR portion.

10:13 To allow up to a maximum of 2.0 FAR and a minimum of 0.75 FAR. Jennifer, would you like to start? I don't have any questions as far as approving the 2.0 FAR. You mentioned that there's several proposals for building that don't meet the 0.75 FAR, correct?

10:44 We've had some projects that have just kind of come in and asked about it. We have one project that's in the works right now that we anticipate a submittal for, and it's...

10:55 Located on Old Mammoth Road, just south of Main Street in the Shell Station. And that project is just a single building, and it looks like it's going to be around a .3 FAR. So that's a project that I think is real, that is coming forward to us in the near future, and it's somewhere around a .3 FAR. We haven't received a formal submittal yet, so we won't know until it's submitted.

11:19 You know, that's a project that's kind of on the horizon looking to submit. So, you know, we thought it appropriate just to talk about this minimum requirement. So, I don't want to discourage any building or infrastructure in town, especially since our economy has not allowed for really any new infrastructure in the last few years. So, I would...

11:44 be inclined not to make the .7 a hard, fast rule and maybe look at either making an amendment to that or not requiring a minimum. And I don't have really any other comments on the FAR. Okay. Any questions, Paul? It relates to the minimum FAR requirement. My personal feeling is this, and similar to

12:18 To what Jennifer had just mentioned about not to discourage other developers or investors to come in and to take advantage of the properties that we have, the vacant lots that we have here. My concern is that if we don't set a minimum requirement, it would anyone who comes forward

12:51 Anyone comes forward with a project with a smaller size, ultimately that's going to become a permanent structure and that particular structure could be there for the next 15, 20, 30 years and that may not be the

13:23 The best use of that particular asset. And I just think that, you know, given that we're trying to revitalize and trying to upgrade what we are, you know, the Main Street and Old Mammoth and downtown area trying to revitalize this area, I think if we keep something, if we don't have a minimum requirement, it would,

13:53 We kind of lose the purpose of what we're trying to accomplish here. That's my input for minimum FAR. You know, and I don't have any issue with the allowable up to 2.20 FAR. You know, I think this is a, you know, staff and our predecessors have been worked on this for a long time and I think this is something that we, I mean, I'm looking forward to get this going. Okay.

14:30 Any other questions on that issue? Questions for staff or for Lucy at this time? On the FAR issue? No. Well, my question is more probably relates to the tables, specifically some of the mathematical that was indicated on the notes. I think this would be an appropriate time to ask those questions. So table three,

15:06 In your notes, let's just, you know, grab either D, E, or F. You have a net number with projected units minus existing units. However, you also included the additional units that was developed as a result of a developable land. So I wasn't quite sure how that additional number was formulated.

15:41 The additional when it's stated that way, that would be from a parcel or parcels along Main Street that were identified that could intensify in that category of intensify. Once the frontage roads are vacated, that land frees up and the thought is that that would then become available to the property owner to use in their development.

16:07 So with that additional land would come an increase in the intensity or some additional units. Okay. Does that make sense and clarify it? I think that's the question I have. Okay. Sandra, you mentioned in your staff report that you looked at some other communities, some peer communities.

16:46 As to their use of a minimum FAR, can you just describe briefly what you found? So we looked at a number of different peer communities as we analyzed the minimum FAR. We looked at just some of them are City of San Jose, Seattle, Redondo Beach. It seemed to us in looking at these communities that a lot of them are larger communities that use this minimum FAR where land,

17:15 is very, very tight. Like, you know, downtown Seattle has a minimum FAR.

17:20 The city of Redondo Beach does have minimum FAR, but it's very low. It's like a .25. So a little bit different than what we're looking at. But I think that the minimum FAR, what we saw was it's generally larger cities that require that. And if it is a smaller city like Redondo Beach, it was a lower FAR. But that was just a slice of the cities that we looked at. I'm sure there's a broad range of minimum FAR requirements kind of throughout California.

17:48 Okay. In the staff report also, you're proposing that if we do agree to move forward with setting a minimum FAR, that there would be an avenue for applicants to request a reduction in that minimum FAR. Can you explain a little bit about what that might entail?

18:15 Yes, so that would be an adjustment. So right now the town has an adjustment procedure for basically it's kind of like a minor variance. It's for smaller projects that don't meet a certain threshold that requires a variance. And so we did provide, that was one of the

18:31 directions from commission is to have an avenue to allow a minimum FAR of lower than a .75 in certain cases. We did write the language to be very similar to what a variance requirement would be. And basically what it would mean is that economic issues wouldn't be a reason to grant the variance. So if the developer came in and said, you know, it's just, you know,

18:58 0.75 FAR is just not marketable right now. We just don't have the demand for that. That really wouldn't be a rationale to approve that. So it is kind of tied to these site constraints. A good example might be where there was a steep slope where they couldn't build that minimum FAR because of the steep slope or some other site constraints. So I think that would be a good example of that. So that was the language that we prepared.

19:27 for the adjustment language. We could look at other options to, you know, for modifications to the minimum FAR. However, typically, economic reasons aren't usually reasons that you would approve a variance or an adjustment. Okay. So in just trying to weigh our options here with regard to the minimum FAR, we could choose to not set any minimum FAR at all.

19:59 We could choose to set the .75 or some other minimum FAR that we come to some agreement on. What about the possibility of making a statement somewhere in the code that suggests or suggests a desire?

20:25 by the town for applicants and property owners to try to meet a minimum FAR as a goal rather than a requirement. Is that something that would...

20:39 We could modify the language to make it more of a guideline, a recommendation at this time, and then as we move forward in a year or two years, if the commission or council feels like that's just not achieving what we want, we could modify it to make it a requirement. The analysis has all been completed for that. There would be no additional environmental analysis needed. So it's really something that we could change at this point.

21:08 I apologize while I find my...

21:48 Under the report summary, topic number two, revise the boundaries of commercially designated land in the land use element to match current commercial zoning. This one seems to be fairly straightforward from what I can tell. And just so that I make sure that I'm understanding, we're really just very slightly changing a boundary in our land use element.

22:19 To be consistent with the zoning code update that we've already done. Correct. Is that correct? Yes. I have no other questions about that. I don't have any questions either. I don't have any questions either on that. Okay. Great. Number three then. Change land use element policy and text associated with regulating population growth from a people at one time approach to an impact assessment based approach as well as a change in the build out methodology.

22:48 Start with you, Paul. Any questions on the PAOT versus the new impact-based approach to the build-out calculation? No, I think what we're doing currently, this is a great approach. I really don't have any issue with this particular item at all. Okay, Jennifer, any questions for staff? No, I don't have any questions. Okay. Sandra, could you just...

23:21 Tell us a little bit about other cities that you looked at. You mentioned some other cities that you reviewed that use a similar approach. Yes. So we took a look at a variety of cities in California that

23:40 To look at the way build out is handled in other communities, PAOT is somewhat unique. There are other communities that use something along those lines. However, we found that a majority of the other communities use this tabular build out summary that really just shows the acreage, the permitted density, and just kind of goes through that straight mathematical approach with very little assumptions. The PAOT

24:08 process was included a lot of different variety of different assumptions. This process staff tried to remove as many assumptions as we could through through the process. So we assumed basically maximum build out in our residential zones, maximum build out in the resort zones based on what's approved by the master plans. And the only place that we had to make assumptions was in the commercial zones due to the FAR. And that's the analysis that Lucy described during her staff report that's shown in tables one, two, and three. So that's really

24:38 Where the assumptions were added into the build-out methodology. And so some of the other cities we looked at were Santa Monica, Pasadena, City of Los Angeles, Escondido.

24:53 In a handful of other cities throughout California. So this is very consistent with what they do in other cities. And from a staff perspective, I think it provides a very clear snapshot of what we think build out will be at this time. And obviously build out is something that will change over time. Staff did include a policy to require an update of the build out table every five years. So that will give the town an opportunity to kind of keep checking in on this build out.

25:22 these build-out numbers as we grow.

25:26 The build out table that we prepared doesn't include a lot of the reductions that we've seen with some of the single family home projects that have been approved. So those weren't taken into account because that density could be put other places in the master plan. But I think as projects are approved, as we go through this process, we will continue to update that build out table so that we're kind of always keeping track of how our community is growing and how we look at build out. Thank you.

25:57 There's a statement in here where you say the air quality limitations measured in part by vehicle miles traveled are also based on usage on the town's design day, which is the seventh busiest winter Saturday. Can you comment on how that came about and whether you think that given the sort of uptick in summer visitation might have any effect on whether that design day remains appropriate?

26:27 Hayes, could you respond to this one? We've had a pretty healthy conversation about that. For apples to apples comparison across, you know, the history of the plans, we left it as that typical design day, so it's consistent with history. We have seen an uptick in summer, a very large increase in summer visitation. However, that transportation...

26:50 Vehicles are more dispersed through the network at those times. We see higher concentrations on arterioles and collectors in the wintertime than we do in the summertime, so it's still appropriate to use the design day in the wintertime. However, we did look at certain intersections at the summertime that we know have a bigger impact in the summer than they do in the wintertime. So we kind of struck a balance to some degree looking at the transportation network seasonally. Okay.

27:22 So from your evaluation, our winter, seventh busiest winter day is still considered to be our maximum for vehicle miles traveled. Absolutely. We still see the peaks on those design days. Okay. Okay. Interesting. Thank you. Those are all the questions I have on the PIOT and build-out topic. Moving on to number four. Oh, did you have another question? I just have one quick question. I'm sorry.

27:51 One of the additions that you have included was that if the construction significance on the commercial lodging product, residential product, if it has not occurred within the five-year period, you would go back and look at this detailed build-out again. It sounded like to me that what you were saying earlier was you wanted to monitor this.

28:18 So we don't necessarily have to wait five years to look at this.

28:23 That's true. Yeah. We don't necessarily have to wait five years. However, that policy includes a caveat that if basically if very little or no development has occurred in the last five years, it really, you know, we don't want to go through the process of going and looking at all that. But we can update that build out at any time. But I think that that is just a trigger that we would look at it and we would provide a report to council and commission at that five-year mark as to whether or not we're looking at the build out and if not, why. So that at least everyone...

28:52 understands how we're moving forward and the rationale for that. But yeah, we could always, if there was a big boom, I think we would want to look at it in a shorter time period. Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Sorry, that's all I have. Oh, that's okay. Great. Okay, moving on to then point number four in the report summary, deleting the land use element, community benefits, incentive zoning, or CBIS, and modifying transfer of development rights policies.

29:23 I don't really have any questions about this. It's just following on a directive from town council from a couple of years ago, I believe, and I don't have any questions. Jennifer? I don't have any questions on it either. Nope. Okay. Thank you. Number five, zoning code amendment associated with the FAR, which includes amending the zoning code to...

29:50 to allow 75% of the ground floor to be used for units or rooms and other non-active uses, retaining the commercial uses along primary and secondary active frontages. So, Sandra, I just wanted to confirm in the past meetings when we have talked about this issue, we have focused primarily on allowing, changing that land use to allow residential uses, but I just want to make sure that I understand you're talking about

30:20 Changing the note on the allowable use table in the code, which will allow all of those uses, all of the commercial uses to be used with a certain percentage on the ground floor. Right, so non-active uses. And residential was an example, and that has been the topic of discussion.

30:40 In front of the council. So as I stated previously, it would allow basically 75% of the ground floor to be those non-active uses while maintaining that active frontage along the road so that the pedestrian and the visitor would still see that active use, the retail or coffee shop or restaurant, but then other uses that are not active could be behind that. So it would achieve both. It would allow more flexibility for property owners while still maintaining our goal of having that active street frontage.

31:10 Okay. Great. That was my impression that we're adding a great deal degree of flexibility into the code. Back into the code. Okay. Thanks. Any other questions? No. I do have a comment to make on this one. A question or just a comment for deliberation? Okay. I mean, you can do that now. Right now, primarily just want to sort of ask questions. Okay. So one question I have is...

31:37 The figure 75%. Is there a reason why we use that versus, let's say, 50-50, 60-40? Good question.

31:50 During the FAR analysis, and Lucy, you can add if you would like, we looked at how the build-out would occur, and that was one of our assumptions, is that looking at, if we looked at 100% of the ground floor being commercial, when we first ran the numbers, there was just so much, there would be so much commercial in town that we really couldn't support that. So from the analysis, we just said, well, that's just not going.

32:18 to occur, you know, here. There's just not that demand for commercial. So as we went through that analysis, we looked in the split of 75%, you know, non-commercial and 25% commercial on the ground floor looked like what we thought would occur at build-out. So I don't know if that summarizes that. Yeah, that's exactly what it was. The number for commercial was really, really high and not in line with the 2011 economic study for the town.

32:47 And so then we had a lot of discussion about what could occur on the ground floor and would that be reasonable to say some non-commercial goes there and we felt that it was and so we just arrived at a number that made sense to us in doing the work. Is there an average square footage count on that 25% in that frontage area? We have a minimum requirement of 20 foot setback but I don't think we have a minimum square footage requirement. Is that what you're asking?

33:16 No, I was just wondering if doing your modeling, that 25%, are we talking about 1,000 square feet, 500? I don't have a number that I can provide, yeah. And it would be something I need to go back through the spreadsheets. It's going to depend on what the total development is and then the number of floors we assumed. You know, I could back into the number, but I don't have that available. Okay.

33:48 Okay. Yeah. All right. And then moving on to number six, adopting and implementing the mobility element update. I have no questions at the moment. Commissioner Chang. So give me one second. I'm sorry. No problem. I have a question about the LOS standard. Can that be, that kind of relates to this, I'm assuming? The LOS standard for transfer.

34:25 The transportation? Public service under transportation. Sure. Okay. Can you respond? You're asking about the LOS service for town and what LOS service are deemed. How the town has adopted the LOS standard for five acres per 1,000 people. Oh, are you talking about the parks and rec? Yeah. That's the parks and rec. Sorry, I thought you meant level of service for traffic. Oh. That's part of, yeah.

34:55 No? I guess we really just didn't get to, I was going to kind of follow up on this with the significant and unavoidable impacts in the EIR. Okay, got it. So. I'll wait. Just one moment. Yep, of course. Commissioner Burrow's mobility element? No questions on it. Okay. So I think we can move on to just discussing those three significant and unavoidable impacts that we found. And Commissioner Chang, since.

35:27 You were just starting with the recreation space or park space. Would you like to start with that one? Yes. Sorry. Let me just go back to that again. So the standard is that the town has adopted the five-acre park per 1,000 residents. And then currently we are below that threshold, right?

36:00 And given that as a project would come on board, you would have the increase in traffic demand, I mean, not traffic demand, demand for parks and recreational facilities. How will that, is there a mitigation process, I guess?

36:29 We didn't include a mitigation measure for this, and that's why it's a significant and unavoidable impact, because we cannot mitigate that impact. Right, I understand it's unavoidable, but I'm just thinking that, you know, if there's any other alternative measures that would minimize that impact.

36:50 So the analysis is based on our adopted parks and rec master plan, which established that level of service. The parks and rec master plan was completed, I think, in 2012. And there are other parks that...

37:06 So, we're basing this impact on kind of what we have right now and the level of service that was established now.

37:31 While we can't mitigate it at this point, there are projects that the town is looking at that would better the impact in the long run. And I don't know if you want to add on to that or if Stu has, he's not here anymore. That is exactly it. And the mitigation would be, you know, if we were to have developed one, would be to find a place for a new park.

37:56 And because of the difficulty of doing that, we didn't. And just, this is the same conclusion that was reached in the 2007 General Plan EIR, so it's not a change from that. And as you know, the town's working very diligently on parks. In part, it's sort of that, you know, there's a lot of availability around the town, a different type of facility. This is specific to developed facilities.

38:26 Thank you. So and it's specific to develop facilities within the urban growth boundary. Within the town. Within the town. So it does include Whitmore Park. Whitmore and the Lakes Basin. It does or it does not? Whitmore Park is included. The Lakes Basin is not. It's built park land. So like, you know, Trails End Park, Shady Rest. Shady Rest is included. So we have to...

38:54 realize the limitations of that geographic area that we're talking about. Correct. I guess it just seems a little bit not very intuitive for a town to adopt such a rigorous standard and knowing that we can't meet that requirement at all. I mean, I think that's a goal. You know, that's a goal in the Parks and Rec Master Plan of looking at that.

39:26 The town is looking towards achieving that goal. And we will continue to try to achieve that. Is the addition of the proposed ice skating rink included in these numbers in the 3.12? I think the existing rink is included, but I don't think the new rink is included at the multi-use facility. So that would better the situation by some degree. Commissioner Burroughs, do you have any questions about the

40:01 Air quality component? No. Commissioner Chang? No. I just would maybe appreciate a little bit of clarification on the air quality component there. You make a statement that a lot of the significant and unavoidable aspect of the air quality is more of an out-of-town related aspect, something that is really beyond our control. You mentioned

40:33 Your air quality and PM10 from the Central Valley. Can you just explain a little bit about what you mean? That is a component of the situation. And the circumstances has to do with the way the wind moves the pollutants in the air. So some of it is just blown over.

40:56 From other areas, it's one that has been an issue and will continue to be one for the town and certainly something that was identified as well in the 2007 general plan EIR. So it's not a change from the 2007 general plan. It's not necessarily something that's caused by our proposed change to the 2.0 FAR and the change from PAOT to the new build-out calculation.

41:24 It's something that has been there, a significant and unavailable impact that has been there for many, many years. We've recognized it in the past. We just have to continue to recognize it again. Right, and continue making efforts to improve, you know, as can be done. And the change in the transportation system, the increase in other modes of transportation contributes to an improvement of that. Okay. Any questions on that issue? Nope. Okay, and then lastly,

41:56 Significant and unavoidable impact regarding transportation and traffic. Any questions? No questions on me. It's unavoidable. No questions at this time. I don't have any other questions at this time. Let's see. Did I miss anything? Any other questions for staff before we move on to questions and comments from the public? Public, you said? Do you have any other further questions for staff before we move on to questions and comments from the public? No, not at this time.

42:36 Okay, and so at this time we'll open the floor for questions and comments. If you could come up and please state your name for the record, we'd appreciate it. Tom Cage, thank you. It's too bad the other conference room at the other end of the building wasn't available today. Does anyone else hear the music? I'm leaving after I speak just because I can't take the pounding anymore. Thank you.

43:03 I sat on a committee that evaluated FAR. The town did a great job, and we arrived at a great number as far as that goes. And I recognized that that number would exceed units in our commercial zones on Old Mammoth and Main Street above and beyond what they were currently zoned at. And with that, the PAOT could possibly change. So I also served on a committee that looked at PAOT a long time ago.

43:34 I don't know, 15 years? Probably. And it was very contentious and we came up with this 52,000 and change number and it had traffic elements to it and it had carrying capacities and water and it had all sorts of elements and it went back and forth. And it had a range, I think, memory serves me right, it had a range to where we were.

43:57 Thinking of 70,000 people at one time. I mean, big numbers. And then it came down. And so it fluctuated and it floated into that happy median with everything that was put together. So I guess my concern is here and my question is I'd like to get some better feel or have you show some better way of defining how this PAOT could move. And don't get me wrong, I'm not opposed to recognizing that

44:26 A PAOT on, we'll use Main Street as an example. You tear down Kittredge and Chevron and you build a condo complex that has additional people there and that increases the PAOT but there's a transportation hub right in front of it and there's shuttle buses. I get it, makes sense and that could work as a great example of increasing PAOT yet moving people even more efficiently. But in

44:54 The paperwork that I've seen and what you've put together, I haven't seen how we're calculating that or how we're advancing that PAOT number with some semblance of order. And can it just, is it limited to just that part of town that's limited to this FAR increase? Or could the PAOT change in

45:18 residential areas outside of the commercial zones that we've evaluated for FAR. So if you could help me understand that or explain it, I'd appreciate it, and I think the public would appreciate it if anyone's paying attention, but I know you guys have worked on it, so Sandra's probably got the answer.

45:38 Yeah, so we updated, we have a new build-out table that will be included in the general plan. It's in the packet, and I apologize, I don't have it to put it up on the screen, but I can provide you with a hard copy of it. And so basically, like I described in the presentation, we assumed full build-out for

45:58 Everything in the town. And at full build out, looking at the total number of units and using the same number of people per unit that was used in the 2007 general plan update, which is what the POT was based on, the number that we had at total population at build out was 53,980. So, you know, it is expected that that number would go up with the increase in...

46:26 Intensity in the commercial zones. So that's that number we have. And like I said in my staff report, we didn't include any of the reductions that we have seen occur with some of the projects that have recently been built and are under construction now. So in Lodestar Master Plan, we've seen a reduction in density. This doesn't actually capture that. This is worst case maximum build out, assuming 100% build out in all of the residential zones.

46:52 Everything. So it is an assumption. And that's why we included, because of the sensitivity to PEOT, we understand there's been that long history of discussion about it. We included this five-year check-in to take a look at that. You know, there was a concern during the PEOT discussion about, like, the last person in and what happens to that person. And that's the reason for these checks, is that we'll never get to that point where it's the last.

47:17 Person in. I mean, we'll, every five years we'll be looking at this to see, and to see how it's changing. I mean, you know, the economy's changing, different things are selling, and we don't really know how the FIR is going to be used, you know, so.

47:31 We'll have to kind of see as projects get developed or proposed and kind of feed that into that model as we go. And the PEOT was based on assumptions too. Any kind of development build out is based on assumptions. Every city has to make assumptions about how we're going to develop. And so we did our best to reduce the number of assumptions and make it very clear and easy to understand. And this table, like I said, will be in the general plan. So people can kind of flip to it and see how many vacant.

48:00 Areas of vacant land we have and our assumptions and kind of easily walk through and to see how we got to our final number. So I think that's certainly an improvement for the community. I feel it's just a very easy kind of snapshot look at it. But the basic number at build out using the same number of people per units that we did at PUT, like I said, was 53,980. And correct me if I'm wrong, with FAR at...

48:26 Full build-out or projected unit increase, 2,500 people more, give or take. Yeah, I think we said 52,000 in our 2007 general plan, so yeah, up until about 2,000 more. Okay, and then just so we're clear, I recognize the areas of town where we've had a reduction of density, Lodestar, other areas around the golf course. Moving that density to Main Street then,

48:57 Would necessitate some look at our LOS for traffic, which I think we wanted it to, and I can't remember if LOS was the right acronym for it, but I think we wanted to maintain a D, nothing worse than a D, is that correct? And this does. And this does, okay. So whatever chart that I haven't seen, if you could, that would be great. I'll send that to you. All right. Thank you very much, Commissioner. Thank you very much. Good morning. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mount Skier.

49:38 Let's toss out some of the distraction, the noise. I wanted to understand real quick on the issue of the FAR minimum, 0.75. If an applicant comes in with a number lower than that, what's the process for their review as it's currently proposed in the language? An adjustment, which is like a minor variance. Which is handled at staff? Administratively. Administratively? Okay. However, staff can, if, you know, if there's a concern, we can always bump items up to the commission for consideration, administrative items.

50:07 I see. So I think for the commissions, I mean, my opinion on this is it's a big deal. And, you know, I was actually one of the ones that brought this up at the time when we were drafting language and having a minimum. And I use the example of Cuppy's Coffee. I think you guys are aware of it. It's at Laurel Mountain in Main Street, where the old 76 station was. And I think, Paul, you pointed out in your questioning that

50:36 You know, as we're looking at trying to revitalize our downtown area, if an owner comes in with a proposal to underdevelop his property, we're going to live with that for a long time. And in the case of maybe the old Grumpy site there on Main Street, as I think I understood, is being looked at and proposed at a .3 FAR. You know, it's a significant location in our downtown corridor that potentially would be underdeveloped.

51:05 And, you know, if we want to have a robust downtown, we have to have a certain level of intensity to that to create critical mass that's going to make it successful. So, you know, it's concerning. I think it's very concerning. And, you know, the idea of having a .75 was to, you know, bring it to the applicant's attention that we're looking for a certain level of intensity there. I'm trying to recall from the

51:34 from when I was involved with Tom and some of the discussions on the downtown and the initial formulation of the zoning code update. .75, I'm trying to recall, maybe, Sandra, if you recall off the top of your head, equivalent example in our old Mammoth Main Street corridor. I want to say maybe Sierra Center Mall was a .75. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but...

51:57 You know, it was essentially, I think it implied at least like a two-story building on the site is roughly what it was. And, you know, one of the other things, the notions was as we try to increase the flow rate ratio in these areas, there's an opportunity for us to also provide an opportunity to build some housing in these locations. So it's not just commercial, but there's a mix of uses on the site. So that, for example,

52:25 You know, there's maybe loft units above, a commercial space down below, so there's people living in the downtown and creating more vibrancy and authenticity to our downtown. So, you know, maybe by having a minimum in there when people come in with proposals, it's going to force the discussion. Well, how can I get up to that number? Well, we'd really like you to consider adding some housing to that development proposal. Maybe you should talk to Mammoth Lakes Housing or whoever.

52:52 To see maybe there's an opportunity to add some affordable housing or market rate housing or whatever it is, but add more units to the town. I attended a housing board meeting the other night. There's legitimate concern that there's not adequate vacant land to build out housing to meet the needs of the community as it's projected. But I think one of the viable solutions is to try to incorporate

53:21 Housing into the redevelopment of our downtown corridor in these commercial areas, which do allow for residential uses. So it's not something to brush aside at all. And actually, I'm concerned that it's only an administrative review. I really feel like it should come to at least a commission level for a discussion if somebody's asking for less than 0.75 FAR because it's a big deal.

53:47 You know, we need to, this is really an opportunity for our town to take control of our future, what we want. And if we just say, okay, well, we weren't really serious about that, you can put in a cup of coffee on the old Grumpy site and we'll live with that for the next 30 years, even though it'll ruin our downtown core. You know, think about it. So it's a big deal. You guys need to think hard about that. I think you should at least leave them the recommendation. I'd almost say make it more robust and then require it to go to...

54:17 I don't know what the next level of a variance request would be, but that it would have to at least go to commission for consideration. But again, I think it's, if, I'm not saying, you know, that there's, you know, that's the thing, we're going to have swings in the market and it's, right now we're just coming out of a really bad time and so people are saying, well, you know, I only want to build what I can afford and they're not going to, they, you know, understandably don't want to take a lot of risk, but by the same token, you know, maybe they're not.

54:43 They'll know all of the intricacies of our community. And as we start having discussion about the downtown revitalization, we might find there's more opportunities to make these projects more successful and serve the needs of our community at Build Out. So you guys need to think long and hard about that decision. And my recommendation is you stick with at least what's been recommended at the 0.75 and that we can force that discussion. And then with respect to the density intensity that's driving some of these

55:13 Unmitigatable impacts. You know, as Sandra pointed out, and I think Lucy can confirm, is that, you know, everything was analyzed on the highest density of getting the 2.0 FIR.

55:24 In a lot of cases, these sites won't be able to achieve that just because we have a white box. And I just want to remind everybody that we've specified in the zoning code that there's a maximum height in setbacks. And there's a box that in many cases, you won't be able to hit a 2.0 FAR on these sites as they're redeveloped, depending on how things play out. And so what's been analyzed is the worst case that is not likely to ever occur. I'm not sure what the discount might be to what really gets built.

55:52 It might have been nice to have kind of bookends and say, well, a real low intensity of, you know, if people build at 0.3 FAR, for example, you know, what would that be? You know, so I, you know, there is, my feeling is there's no reason to be overly concerned about, you know, that maximum build out. I don't think it's going to occur. So, and also as we progress this discussion about downtown revitalization, start to really

56:18 Progressive discussion about parking districts and having shared parking and certainly there's going to be, you know, a couple of those locations in downtown. You know, the hope, the notion is that people will come park once, park the vehicle at the property they're lodging at and then be able to utilize our transportation and as well as if there's an appropriate intensity of commercial.

56:44 Act, you know, commercial use in the downtown zone, people can just walk to their, to go out to dinner and so forth. They don't have to get in their car and go drive and so forth. So, you know, hopefully those things will be better as time goes on with respect to vehicle miles traveled. So, anyway, then, I just want to thank staff for their hard work and Lucy for their hard work on a, you know, pretty difficult project, a lot of intricacies to it. It's been a long, long time in the works here and glad that we're kind of getting near the end. Thank you.

57:13 Thank you. Thank you. Can I just quickly, we did do an FAR study of our existing community, and just to give you an idea of what an FAR looks like, the AT&T building across the street is a .5 FAR.

57:29 So, and then the Sierra Center Mall is a 1.4 FAR because it's, you know, has three stories. So, that maybe kind of helps kind of picture what, we don't have, I don't have one on my list that's a .75, but a .5 is basically that AT&T building where it's the commercial below, residential above, and then the parking behind. Thank you. That's helpful. Yeah. Any other comments from the public? Okay, then with that, we will close the public comment period and move on to deliberation.

58:13 I think it would be worth us discussing a little bit further this minimum FAR. I agree that along with Tom early on in the process, I was one of the proponents of further discussion on the minimum FAR. I think it's a really interesting idea. I agree that we're at a stage where

58:57 We really have to weigh these options carefully and in a way can't afford as a town to sort of undercut our development goals. But I also am aware that

59:17 What we're trying to do overall with this entire agenda item is to sort of clean up and sort of create more flexibility within the code, make clean up the barriers to development rather than creating more barriers to development. So I'm really torn and want to be really wary about what we do regarding this minimum FAR issue.

59:49 I can't quite remember where the .75 number came from. Sandra, do you...

59:56 Remember? The original staff recommendation was a .5, and then through the discussion that occurred at that Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting, there was public input, and there was a recommendation for a .75, and so basically the commission asks staff to analyze that and just bring that back for further discussion. So originally we had talked about a .5, and then I think there was maybe some discussion that maybe a .5 wasn't enough, and so that's where the .75 came from.

1:00:26 What strikes me as that isn't quite taken into consideration with just a straight FAR is that there's no differentiation between development on lot sizes and how the other development requirements affect the maximum buildout on a small lot versus a large lot. I think that

1:00:55 You know, on a small half acre or so lot with our other development standards such as setbacks and parking and snow storage and building height, I don't want to get ourselves into a position where it's not even possible to meet a .75 FAR if we set that as a minimum. And I think that those small lots could really fall into that category.

1:01:25 I just wonder if there's any way to take lot size into consideration or if that's something that other communities ever do. I don't recall seeing that in my kind of look at minimum FAR. If there's a desire from the commission to take that into account, we could add that as one of the...

1:01:52 Site constraints that are referenced in the adjustment section. Right now, I'll just read the adjustment section. It says, adjustments to minimum floor air ratio requirements that do not meet the variance findings may be approved if the floor air ratio is not feasible due to site constraints. And then we say, for example, existing buildings, parking areas, or trees. So, I mean, we could add, you know, small lot sizes or some other site constraints so that applicants would know kind of.

1:02:20 What we would consider a constraint that would warrant approval of an adjustment. Okay. Right. I just don't want to be put in a position where an applicant comes to us and says, well, you're requiring a minimum FAR of 0.75 and that's not even possible because of the other building standards. Like, I don't want us to ever be in, you know, to be in that position without having an out. But just to clarify, you're saying that that clause, which is allowing an adjustment, creates the...

1:02:55 It creates the flexibility there. We could add that language to create additional flexibility. It still wouldn't respond to the economic argument. There's just no demand for this right now. So we could hear that, and that wouldn't justify approval of an adjustment based on the language that we have currently. If that adjustment language were changed so that either it was not an adjustment per se, but

1:03:29 You know, something that would then come to the commission? Is that a situation where economic factors could be taken into consideration? Well, we could require, I mean, we could change it and require a use permit. You know, so that would just kind of stepping back and looking at a different way to process something that was below the .75. A use permit would be required to come to the commission for consideration.

1:04:00 You know, I mean, a variance is a specific requirement outlined by state. I wouldn't recommend making it a variance requirement. I mean, so if there's some consensus from commission that whatever, in order to go less than 0.75, it needs to be something that comes forward to commission, we can kind of...

1:04:24 Take that back and then make a recommendation to council appropriately. I'm not sure if the use permit is the right tool. It is a tool that brings the item to commission. So we could kind of step back and look at that and provide the appropriate recommendation to council if that's the consensus of the commission. Okay. My fellow commissioners have some other comments for deliberation regarding that issue? I'm in agreement with Mr. Hodges that we need to

1:05:01 to continue to keep an eye on our downtown concept and to build accordance to that. I guess I didn't convey this well enough before, but the idea of the .75, right now it seems very stringent. It has to be .75, and I would like that variance in there so that if someone comes in below that .75 or whatever we decide it's going to be at,

1:05:27 That there is the opportunity for discussion to modify it or to reach out for those resources for housing to build up that lot size to make it a .75. But I don't just want people to be deterred from even considering building because they can't make it there. I want people who are considering it

1:05:53 to work with the town and likewise that we can work with them to get our concepts in place how we want our downtown and I just don't want it to be so stringent that we can't do that. So if there is a builder that comes in and doesn't meet that .75, I would like as a commission to be able to evaluate that and see if it's a project that would fit into our concept.

1:06:27 Commissioner Chang. Well, I agree with Madam Chair and Commissioner Burrell about having this flexibility. I think we still, you know, there's a reason why we have variance process. We have, you know, sit back requirement. We have, you know, height requirement and so forth. And they can use various tools to make those changes.

1:07:00 But I think if we don't have that minimum standard, you know, I think we're going to sell ourselves short as a community because I think ultimately this is not just a pure residential area. This is a commercial corridor, a downtown revitalizing area. And we want developers, we want a specific type of developer to come in here.

1:07:29 To create this product with us. And what I'm afraid of is when we don't set this requirement, somebody's going to come in and build, like you said, one story with something that's not a mixed-use product that people can't just live and enjoy.

1:08:00 The space, enjoy the area. I mean, if you look at our previous projects that we looked at, specifically, you know, Low Star product, I mean, we have such a tremendous potential there, and now we have, you know, the FAR, the density have been reduced tremendously on that particular.

1:08:30 on those particular parcels. And, you know, if I'm not, I'm not, I'm certainly open to, to, you know, further discussions on this, or maybe, maybe staff can come back with some sort of alternative methods that can, that can give us that flexibility.

1:09:01 But to simply say that we're not going to have minimum FAR, I don't think I would agree with that. So, Commissioner Tang, are you asking the staff for more information for some additional time to review this topic? I think that's certainly, I can agree to, you know, maybe just perhaps postpone this on the minimum FAR issue.

1:09:46 And maybe, because I don't know how to resolve this particular problem other than what I believe in, having this, you know, I truly believe in a minimum FAR is, it's important. What additional information do you think? I don't know. I mean, that's based on the couple options that you have, maybe you have provided additional suggestions.

1:10:16 In looking at if there's an, maybe there's a, you know, so maybe you can sit at FAR range, I mean, a minimum FAR, and then we can say, okay, maybe there's a 5%, 20% discretion, you know, on that minimum FAR for review process. I don't think any of us are opposed to a minimum FAR.

1:10:49 Correct me if I'm wrong. No. I am still in support. I am still very much in support of it. But what I want to be careful of is exactly what you were saying, Commissioner Ambrose, is just turning off potential developers right off the bat before giving them an opportunity to come to staff and come to commission to work out some sort of compromise.

1:11:16 Staff and Commission deems it appropriate to move forward. So do you think we're saying that if the process for reducing the minimum FAR were a process that would come to commission, that would we be more comfortable with it that way? I think that we need to have some sort of variance, for lack of better words, in place that allows us to

1:11:50 to work with a builder. I mean, because if they come in with a 0.6 and they want to build housing and we can help provide housing on that just because that's what Tom's example was, I mean. But then that would exceed the minimum. If we're talking about having a partnership of some sort to have them to come in and build housing on top of what their current design, then you're going to exceed your effort.

1:12:19 .75 FAR based on the scenario that you just described. But you would still keep it within the under two. Sure. But that's what I'm saying. I mean, we can't just say, okay, you come in at .6, well, we're just going to veto it automatically because it doesn't reach .75. We need to have, if we can find a way to help them get to that .75, then I think that that's what we need to do.

1:12:47 I think that we need to be open to that. And it sounds to me like you're saying that you would like to see the commission be a part of that process and not just have that process be an administrative decision? Is that what you're suggesting? Yeah. I mean, I'm certainly open to that. Tom, please. Okay. A couple things. So I know that part of the goal of the updated zoning code was to try to streamline the permitting process and the review.

1:13:23 And I'm not having it in front of me here at the moment. I'm just, maybe Sandra, if you know or Ruth off the top of your head, because I mean, if you have uses that are allowed under the Commercial Zoning Code and you meet all the requirements, you don't, doesn't require any review by Planning Commission, right? It's just administrative approval. Correct. Is there a scenario where if somebody came in with a FAR below 0.75 in his proposed languages currently, that that would

1:13:53 only be reviewed at staff level and not be brought to commission? That's what staff has proposed as part of is this. So I read that adjustment language. So staff would, we would review the, you know, project that's below 0.75 and if we felt it met the findings necessary for the adjustment, we would approve it at the staff level. And then... Which was about sort of the metrics of the site.

1:14:21 Requirements like setbacks and heights and so forth. So if there were sort of really issues with the site that couldn't be overcome, like you said, like we don't want to take this nice beautiful tree down and therefore we can't meet, you know, these requirements, you could make that administrative approval. Right on that, right. Right, but not for an economic concern. Correct. Right. So, I mean, I think the point is you guys, again, I think

1:14:51 The .75 threshold, you know, it was brought up and I think it would start out at .5 and everybody was like, well, that might not, that might be kind of low, maybe go to .75 and then if somebody wants to change it, they would be some kind of a review process. It wasn't to say that they could never do it. Right. So this becomes that question of how you guys manage that and, you know, there's a balance between trying to

1:15:16 Again, one of the goals of the whole update to the zoning code was to streamline the approval process and make it, if somebody came in, they complied with everything, they could just go through real quickly for the plan review and they wouldn't have to come to commission for a use permit and so forth. So I don't know, maybe, as Sandra said, maybe if there's a way for you guys to have some interface with the applicant to have that discussion. I mean, that was kind of the point. The point 75 was to force a discussion.

1:15:45 So that the applicant understood what our goals of our community were, particularly in the commercial corridor. So whether that remains at a staff level or it would elevate to a Planning Commission review by virtue of a use permit at that point, that that would be their alternative, you know, what they would have to do. If they know they're going to ask for .3 or .25, okay, well now you have to go through a use permit. That just essentially brings it to the Planning Commission for review.

1:16:14 And everybody has a chance to weigh in on the merits of the project for the particulars that the applicants asking for. And we could tie it in with the...

1:16:26 Design review. So design review still does require, it is a major design review for like a brand new building on, you know, Old Mammoth Road or Main Street. So there would be some level of review needed by the commission. And the idea was to streamline it. However, that component still remains as an item that would have to come forward to commission.

1:16:47 So if the applicant had to request the minimum FAR and had to go through some sort of a process to come to commission, it would be tied, it could be tied with that design review as well. But could they say, well, there's no purview of the commission to comment on the lower FAR because it's not relative to the design? No, I mean, if it was an adjustment in a major design review, the commission would consider both. That's typically what we do. If there's two, if there's an administrative review and a commission level review, we bring both of those items for consideration by commission.

1:17:17 Which is something that staff can do. If there's an administrative decision that needs to be made and staff doesn't feel comfortable making that decision, we can bring things up to the commission level to get that input. Sandra, I just want clarification on this. So you're saying that the proposed language or the current process is that, so let's say they come in 5% short, 3% short.

1:17:46 of .75 FAR. Staff will review this on their own and perhaps approve this without going through commissions. That's what's proposed, right? And administrative, and that's typical for adjustments. So minor variances, those are always a staff level of review and approval. So did staff have that flexibility of approving that project?

1:18:16 At a below 7.75 FAR. But there's, correct me if I'm wrong, but there's the caveat in there that that reduction in FAR has to be related to site constraints. Not financial constraint. Right, right. So you take a half acre lot and you cut down your box due to setback, height, parking, snow storage. And if what you're left with is less than

1:18:45 .75 FAR, you're proposing to be able to approve the adjustment. So what if that box that you're left with is a .6, for example, and your applicant is proposing a .3, which is much less than the reduction that is caused just by the site constraints. That's a little bit of a gray area. It seems to me that that then should

1:19:16 Trigger the, you know, the, you know, coming before commission? I'm just curious, maybe you could have a, you know, a range that would have staff's discretion and then if it went below, say, a .5, that it had to come to commission in the form of use permit at that point? You know, I just, I'm just concerned there's going to be, you know, it's hard to sit here and play out all the possible scenarios of how this might.

1:19:45 Go. And I think all of us share the same concern is we just don't want to see another Cuppy's Coffee get built in the heart of our commercial revitalized downtown. Yeah. It's just going to underserve our community forever. And there's nothing we can do about it. So that's the concern. So it's, again, it's the, it's trying to create some kind of a catch. So it forces a discussion. And there's a chance for, you know, people who are informed in the community, the commissioners and so forth to weigh in on.

1:20:14 Wow, you know, let's figure this out and do it right. Or, you know, bring the applicant together with other people of the community like the housing board and so forth to figure out a way to incorporate other uses into the site that better serve our community. So, you know, it's a fairly philosophical question, but the question is do we really want to, what kind of town do we want to finish, you know, build out here? What do we create? You know, if we just give it up here,

1:20:44 With the substantial process that we've gone through with amending our general plan and everything else and we give up at the last yard and all of a sudden there will be unintended consequences and we're not getting the real solid commercial corridor we're at where we think we need and we want. Right. So, I don't know, maybe we can't answer the question here exactly, but if maybe you guys can recommend, like I say, maybe

1:21:15 Say, okay, well, staff can have up to a discretion of 25% reduction in that at their, per the adjustments allowances, anything below that would need to come to commission, and however that's manifested in the code. So, I don't know, that's just my thoughts. So if there's a desire from the commission to further discuss, it sounds like really the minimum FAR is the only piece where there's further discussion possibly needed.

1:21:42 You know, the commission can choose to pull that piece out at this time, make a recommendation to council on the remainder of the project, absent the minimum FAR. We can bring that back to the commission at your December meeting. We could discuss that further and have a subsequent amendment.

1:22:00 to implement the minimum FAR that would allow us to walk through all of these different scenarios, provide language for consideration that could talk about possibly, you know, these different percentages at which it would come to commission or just a straight, anything under a certain, anything under .75 comes to commission. So we can provide that analysis for you at your December meeting if you would like.

1:22:23 So you have some options. You can continue the entire process, the entire project today, and we can come back with the entire project in December or pull this piece out since it sounds like this piece is likely the piece that needs more discussion in the remainder of the project. Seems like there's not a lot of discussion needed for the remainder of the project and at least keep that part moving forward. So it's really at the pleasure of the commission how you would like to move forward today. Okay.

1:22:51 So we can simply just call it out, say, you know, we would like to proceed. You would make that recommendation. Through a public hearing to proceed with the town councils minus this specific minimum FAR item. Right. So it would be with modifications. So you would make finding option one just with modifications to remove the minimum FAR requirement to allow the commission to have further discussions on it. In an effort to try not to take too much more.

1:23:20 Work from staff and move things on as smoothly as possible. Would you say that the best way forward would be to pull the minimum FAR language and continue with the rest of the item? I think that would be staff's recommendation. That would give us an opportunity to talk about this item specifically and to get more feedback from maybe potential developers looking at land and town to really provide some

1:23:48 kind of broader feedback on it and also would allow staff to have the time to draft some different options for code language. Okay. I like that idea. I agree that I don't think there are any other major concerns. You know, I do want to just make sure that we discuss very briefly the findings so that we can cover all the bases, but I agree that it sounds like our general

1:24:21 We have a general consensus about the rest of the issue, the rest of the item? Yeah. Does that sound right? Yes. Would you like me to make a motion? So before we make a motion, I would just like to one by one review the findings. Do we all agree that this change is consistent with the goals, objectives, and policies of the general plan? Any applicable...

1:25:05 Pacific plan or adopted master plan of development because the land use element zoning code amendment and mobility element update will allow flexibility in density, intensity of development in the commercial land use designations while ensuring that impacts to the public are mitigated through the use of BIEC during project evaluations.

1:25:30 Finding number two, the changes in the interest of or will further the public health, safety, comfort, convenience, and welfare because the project will maintain the existing urban growth boundary, will provide more flexibility in regards to density calculations in the commercial land use designation zones, and will emphasize feet first and greater use of alternate transportation in the town which will reduce vehicle miles traveled. Yes.

1:25:59 The proposed amendment, are we all in agreement that the proposed amendment is in compliance with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act or CEQA? Yes. Yes. And are we all in agreement that the amendment is internally consistent with the other applicable provisions of the zoning code and that the proposed amendment does not result in a mandatory element of the general plan being amended more than four times during any calendar year? Mm-hmm. Yes. Fantastic.

1:26:37 So I think at this point we could move on to a motion. I would like to make a motion to proceed with the, to pass the Environmental Impact Report for the Lane Use Element Zoning Code Amendments and Mobility Element Update and adopt that require CEQA findings, adopt that require municipal code findings and approve general plan amendments 15.002 and zoning code amendment 15.002 as proposed.

1:27:11 With a modification of removing the minimum FAR items at this moment. Just to clarify, that's option one, and that's a recommendation of town council. Yes. I'll second that motion. Roll call vote, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you.

1:27:47 Thank you. I just wanted to take a minute to thank our consultant, Lucy, for all of her hard work on this project. She has spent countless hours analyzing the impacts of fluoride ratio, putting together the EIR, the final EIR, and providing clear and concise public presentations like the one you saw today. I'm really grateful for her input and assistance on this project, and I'm happy we're moving on to the next step of a town council hearing in December.

1:28:12 Thank you, Lucy. I also wanted to thank Ruth for all of her hard work on this project. She has worked with me basically on this project since she started here at the town. And her experience and insight have been extremely valuable in shaping how we moved forward. So thank you, Ruth. And thank you, Hayes, for all of your hard work on the mobility element, putting the pieces together. Hayes has actually been working on the mobility element since 2009, six years.

1:28:40 So this is a really big step for this project, and we're really excited to see it move forward. So thank you all, team. I really appreciate all of your hard work. Thank you. Thank you, everyone. I echo my sentiments exactly. You all have been very, very supportive and helpful. Lucy, thank you for changing your travel plans, because I know we expected to hear this at last month's meeting. But thank you. Thank you very much. And thank you very much, Tom. You've had some very helpful insight as a member of the public.

1:29:08 It's been great working with you on this. Thank you. And I look forward to making a more informed decision about the minimum FAR at next month's meeting. I just feel that that's something that we don't want to get wrong. Absolutely.

1:29:30 At this point, I would just like to point out that agenda item number two, consider recommending to the Town Council approval of the Zoning Code Amendment 16-003 has been continued to next month's meeting. And so with that, we will move on to our first business matter. Agenda item number three, general plan consistency determination for town acceptance of vacant property located within the Mammoth Creek Corridor at 190 Shadow Street.

1:30:00 And our staff contact for this is Nolan Bobroff. All right. Thank you for the introduction. So the purpose of this item is for the commission to consider that if the town's acceptance of vacant property located within Mammoth Creek Corridor at 190 Shadow Street is consistent with the general plan.

1:30:28 The parcel proposed to be donated is approximately 0.45 acres in size and is contiguous with the approximately 28 acres of open space that the town currently owns within the Mammoth Creek corridor. The subject property is shown here on the screen outlined in red and the parcels that the town owns are outlined in green and the white kind of transparent overlay is the open space stream corridor overlay zone.

1:30:59 190 Shadow Street along with the town-owned properties are all within the open space stream corridor overlay zone which is intended to protect sensitive stream and drainage courses from development to recognize and preserve these environmentally sensitive areas as a community resource and to protect water quality and preserve wetland habitat. The donation of this property will accomplish all of the goals

1:31:26 of the open space stream corridor overlay zone. The donation would be consistent with the general plan as required by state law because preserving the property is consistent with the specific goals and properties of the resource management and conservation element of the general plan, specifically those goals and policies that are relevant to Mammoth Creek. Therefore, it is recommended that the commission choose

1:31:52 Option 1, to find that the Town's acceptance of donated vacant property located within the Mammoth Creek Corridor at 190 Shadow Street is consistent with the general plan. With that, that is all I have for my presentation. Any questions from the Commission? Thank you, Nolan. Commissioner Burroughs? I just want to confirm that this line is vacant, that there's no structure there or anything.

1:32:18 That is correct. The property owner previously submitted an application for a variance to construct a single family residence in 2005, but before or through the analysis process and through continuances at the Planning Commission, it was ultimately withdrawn and was never moved forward. Okay. Mr. Chang? By accepting this donation, the staff have any

1:32:54 Answer as to what will the town do? Is the town going to turn around and sell this for profit or simply just keep it as for environmental purpose? Yeah, it would be maintained pretty much as is, as indicated. With the other properties outlined in green here, it represents the entire kind of Mammoth Stream corridor.

1:33:26 With acquiring this, it adds to that property, and with the other acquiring, we're in the process of acquiring the Snow Creek Creek Corridor parcel. Finalizing that, it'll essentially provide that the town owns kind of all the Mammoth Creek Corridor property there to protect it with its current status. Now, of course, the town has a right, in the future, if they ever want to, they can sell this particular parcel. No? I mean, they, I suppose, yeah, ultimately could sell it.

1:33:57 Buyer would have to go through this, or anyone wishing to ever develop it would have to go through the same process, which was determined would require an EIR to do any development. So, I mean, in essence, this property or the other properties within the creek there could be sold.

1:34:16 But our intent is not to sell those properties. We would be moving forward in the near future with a general plan and zoning map amendment to change the designation to open space. Thank you. That's going to be my next question. Yeah, so that that wouldn't occur. I mean, our intent is to maintain these as open space, and that's why we've acquired all the other properties you see there in green and why we're acquiring the Snow Creek land as well. And also just to add to that, as shown in the staff report,

1:34:44 It could be used for future mitigation, which would involve probably putting it within a conservation easement, which would add additional protection and have additional steps to do anything different with the property. This is just for my knowledge. Is there a taxable tax assessment that will occur on this? For the town or for the owner? For the town. No. Thank you. That's all the questions I have.

1:35:20 Okay, I don't have any questions. Okay. Make a motion. Okay. Okay. I make a motion for option number one to adopt the attached planning and economic development commission resolution making the required CEQA findings and government code findings and finding that the town's acceptance of donated vacant property located within the Mammoth Creek corridor at I-90 Shadow Street is consistent with the general plan. I second that. Roll call vote. Yes.

1:35:55 Yes. Motion passes 3-0. At this point, I'd like to take a brief recess so that we can prepare and set up for agenda item number four, which is the review of the downtown revitalization project. About five minutes? Yeah. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Here we go. Are you ready, Commissioner Burroughs? Mm-hmm. Okay. And so we will move on to business matter number...

1:36:40 Four, review and provide comments on the downtown revitalization draft public engagement tools. Our staff contact is Sandra Moberly. Thank you. So I'll just introduce the project and we have our consultant Darren Dinsmore on the phone there. I'll switch over to allow him to control our screen in just a minute. But I just wanted to give the commission kind of a background on what the town is doing right now. So the town has two major

1:37:09 Public projects that are going on right now. One is this downtown revitalization project that we're going to talk about right now. We also have a walk, bike, ride project. It's a mobility, multimodal mobility project. And I will re-talk about that project as part of my department, my director's report, just so you get more information on that project, the public outreach that we're doing for that project. But the purpose of today, of this

1:37:36 portion of the meeting is to kind of walk through this downtown revitalization. So just to be clear, there are two different projects and they are different but have a little bit of overlap. So just a little bit of background, the town has entered into a contract with Dinsmore Sierra LLC and this is really looking at facilitating a community-driven process to refine, update, and reflect a shared community vision of what a revitalized downtown Mammoth Lakes looks like.

1:38:06 Part of the goal of the project is to create a strong public vision and identify a number of realistic placebakes.

1:38:14 The place-based economic strategies that will lead to implementable actions. This process includes interactive workshops. So we'll be having workshops here in the town. And we'll also have a very strong web presence. And that's what Darren's going to kind of walk you through today to show you what the web presence will be like.

1:38:36 You know, one of the components of this is to look at realistic limitations and expectations for actions that we could take and really keep it within the sideboards parameters established by the council in the community. So we have these two workshops that are available for the public to come and provide comments on. They will both be held on Wednesday, December 7th. One will be in the morning here in Suite Z from 9 to 11.

1:39:06 And then the afternoon session will be from 4 to 5.30, and that's going to be at Mammoth Lakes Fire Station No. 1. And just a note to the public that parking is limited there, so to try to carpool to that location. And then it's not on the screen here, but the consultant will be providing

1:39:27 Some feedback to the town council at that. December 7th is also a town council meeting day. So an item will be scheduled on the town council agenda to kind of report back on what the consultant has heard so far and next steps. And so this is the project study area. I apologize. It's a little hard to see on the screen here.

1:39:48 But you can see that it doesn't directly overlap what the Main Street project area was. The Main Street project area went kind of all the way up to the west to the village, and it did kind of capture that core Old Mammoth Main Street area. One difference is this includes Shady Rest and does include the Clearwater Specific Plan area. So those are kind of a little bit different than what we had looked at through the Main Street plan previously.

1:40:17 And so just to give the commission an idea of what the next steps would be after these public meetings, the consultant would put together information that they've learned through the public meetings as well as from the online tool and then look at the strengths, weaknesses, and opportunities in our downtown and kind of really the...

1:40:38 One of the final tasks is to have an action summit where the consultant would come back to town and kind of talk about everything they've heard, everything they heard at the December 7th meetings, what we've gathered online, and talk about actions. What are the kind of the top actions that the community sees that we should look at? And their recommendations would include recommendations for

1:41:04 financing tools and private partnerships that could occur. And so kind of the key, like basically the very end of the process would be a draft agreement or a process agreement on how we can get a catalyst project or program moving forward. So that's just kind of an introduction to what the project is. And I will turn it over to Darren in just one second. Let's see.

1:41:45 Okay, so Darren, I don't know if you can hear me, but we've got your build on the great foundation of work slide up, so you can go ahead and take it over from here. Can you guys hear me okay? Yes. Let me turn it up maybe a little bit. Okay, go ahead, Darren. I want to thank you. That's better. Great. I want to thank you with, you know, their destination economy, 4.5 million tourists a year housing, and we're here launching tiny home,

1:42:37 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:43:21 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:44:03 And how difficult it was to get a violent majority involved. And we launched a program called Crowdbrite. It's an online tool and involves face-to-face meetings combined with online. We run 100 projects in 90 different cities and are using those tools to help build public support. To give you a bit of an overview and then some questions for the commission. We develop tools and approaches to help communities take action. We help them activate their plans, overcome obstacles, and leverage their resources.

1:44:52 And, you know, I've seen from the wonderful amount of work that the town of Mammoth Lakes has done, setting the stage and the foundation for revitalization, the general plan update, the new mobility element that you were just talking about, the downtown Main Street plan, we've been talking about enhanced infrastructure finance districts already, you're laying the groundwork. We want to help ensure that those move forward, bring, build, help to work with you to identify endless projects for change.

1:45:31 We're really struggling to do more with less and that every project going forward in terms of downtown revitalization is probably going to be some kind of public-private parkership where you're implementing your vision for higher densities as you were just talking about in your F.A.R. study. We continue a public-private parkership and we try to work with you to figure out where you all continue and work backwards to design your process. Let me see if we can get forward here. Online identity would be something like connectmammothlakes.com.

1:46:24 I'm going to go through some slides, but I want to have the commissioners start to think about the top three questions you would like to ask the broader community going forward about downtown revitalization, what those questions might be, how we can incorporate them into this process, and then who needs to be engaged that might not normally have been engaged in your processes. An innovative tool in 50 cities are using called infill score, readiness, and then remove obstacles, FAR challenge. We really, we work on both planning, infrastructure, major projects.

1:47:09 Really try to activate plans, help communities implement projects, act and leverage that and build the future. And as an example, the Truckee Rail Yard Project was about sitting on a shelf in the town of Truckee. We worked in a partnership with the Center for Land Recycling and the State Treasurer's Office, funded an engagement process and planning process and then found a developer who would not normally have worked in Truckee to come into town to help build a more walkable, vibrant downtown.

1:47:47 We use face-to-face meetings, but then extend and expand that engagement online, make it very easy for people to engage using their cell phones or whatever device.

1:48:30 Make sense for them. They can access the project at the public library, can engage at a much higher level than normally would participate. Inclusive, interactive, this is the plan. The N. Judah Line Main Street in San Francisco completed a few years ago. The thing that we really focus on is cost-effective engagement. So how do we elevate the pilot majority of those folks that normally don't partner in your planning projects for your downtown, for example. The communities get the same people coming to the meetings over and over again.

1:49:11 Mountain and Resort communities have a lot of second homeowners that find it difficult to participate. How do we make it available? And if you're finding, still coming to the meetings, and it's very critical and important, you have your online tools and your video recording. But in the last couple of years, about 51% of our users are using mobile devices, 30% are going to the website, 10% using tablets, and another 10% might use paper versions. So we build you an engagement suite using all of these tools.

1:49:57 On taking complex land use plans and making them easily understandable on a phone, what we call an online open house, and we'll be working with your consultant planning, they've developed during their charrette and put it online in an online open house accessible to people, help expand and spread the reach of those engaged in Europe. The other tool that are finance tools and collaboration tools, streamline the planning process. One of them is infill score, the readiness of a community.

1:50:39 for implementing their plans and helps remove those barriers that you were talking about in your previous conversations this morning already. We launched this tool a year ago. It won the Open Source App of the Year Award from the EPA. And a lot of the cities and smaller towns across the country are struggling with some of this in actually implementing their plans and moving their communities forward. So we would ask commissioners to actually use the infill score tool for Mammoth. Go to the website.

1:51:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:51:48 We also have a new tool we've been working with California Forward in the state of California.

1:52:27 Enhanced Infrastructure Finance Districts. There's a website. You can go there and learn about this tool as well. Pointed out a little bit about how it came up in your previous conversation. According to develop 50 building typologies for Mountain Town in 2003 and 2004, a lot of it is dealing with in other towns in the Sierra Nevada. We would be able to build these tools into the engagement toolkit and also use this with commissioners and your developers, some examples of this. Working on the data from Intel scores showed us

1:53:15 There are a lot of barriers to build housing units. So we've launched a tiny home demonstration project. This is what we're currently working on in Arizona and with a number of jurisdictions in California. So working on a number of designs for smaller units under 500 square feet that would work in mountain towns as well. In the public buildings, it's really about figuring out what is that capital that's going to help you get over that hump for those tools as well for the public. Thank you very much, Mr. Ninsmore.

1:54:27 I guess we'll start with some questions, Commissioner Chang. Would you like to go first? Sure. You can say no. I briefly looked at the video that you had, the presentation you did with your partnership with Truckee Entity or the Truckee Management. It relates to infill score.

1:55:12 The engagement tool that you are looking to provide, can you explain, maybe just give us just a little more detail with the engagement tools that you have? Realistically, how would that relate to, how would that assist us in the implementation process successfully? You know, and I,

1:55:47 I mean, Truckee is a much larger town than Mammoth here, right? Darren? Yeah, yeah, good question. Might be what we did for South Lake Tahoe. And it's an online that people have been working and staff have been working diligently in there. What we want to do is pull all of that information into an easily understandable digestible information and to build momentum for change. And there's going to be a fine between repeating what you've already done, right, and confirming the level of public support.

1:56:40 So that you can come in, look at the interactive plan, understand.

1:57:20 The shady rest area, the concepts, the ideas, provide a little bit of feedback on what the challenges are, and then stay tuned with the project. In doing this, we've been able to take public meetings and engage 12,000 people in the design of their Highway 50 project going through. Okay. Now, the following step with this implementation is, of course, the financial.

1:57:57 Restraint barriers that we have here in this town. And one of the items that you talked about is the IFD district. But that also requires collaborations between all the other government entities. How would you approach in getting everyone on the same page on this one? The initial phase one public engagement tool launched.

1:58:36 We've been lucky to receive

1:59:22 Were there any crowdfunding avenues that was taken for these small town initiatives that you have worked on and were they successful? So not in Truckee.

2:00:08 In Honolulu, we've completed, I think, six projects. Their transit-oriented development program, train line that's coming through the community, and the redevelopment and revitalization of those areas, and their waterfront. For their waterfront, we are crowdfunding. Public can donate money towards elements of the waterfront plan. Then we're matching that with major donor funds, and then we're going to take both of those and go to the public agencies and ask for a match on that.

2:00:41 So it's a one-third, one-third, one-third. $3 million commitment. And the goal for that project is $3 million. So the crowdfunding that you just described is really more on the donation level. It wasn't for profit, meaning that the people that contributed money, the private individuals who contributed money, really is through a donation. It's not an actual investment. So it wasn't the crowdfunding.

2:01:23 Okay. You know, which is actually still fairly new with the Jobs Act. Sure. It was basically a donation, correct. But we, you know, we would look at all of these types of funding opportunities with your project. Thank you. That's all I have. Okay. Commissioner Burroughs, do you have some questions? So, we are approaching our busy season in town and, oh, thank you. Can you hear me now?

2:01:55 We're approaching our busy season here in town, and we have a lot of people who work two, three jobs and aren't necessarily going to have time or the energy to engage in this, as well as a lot of our stakeholders, their businesses are booming and may not have the time as well to engage. How do you propose that you're going to get those people on board in a relatively short period of time?

2:02:31 Can you repeat what you just said? I'm sorry, you were breaking up. We're going to launch.

2:03:17 The new website linked to the and also use some social media. We're also going to want to launch this by getting on lists and other things that you may know of through certain existing groups in the community. And what I mentioned was the promise of the technology is really that it is available for people 24-7 to engage at their own convenience.

2:03:47 And we are finding that we're getting a lot of people on evenings and weekends taking the time to do so. If it's fun, interactive, easy to use. If it's not, they won't use it. And that it is working. Your other comment was about the sort of seasonality and the busy season. We found that some of our most successful projects were launched during the holiday season. When people were busy, they were spending time with family between Thanksgiving and Christmas or the holidays.

2:04:19 15 minutes and would take time to engage and show their relatives and show their friends as well. Okay. What sort of information are you hoping to get from our community? Yeah, really good question. So I think number one, it's about educating the community and informing them that they don't know what's going on, you know, how all of these projects fit together, right? The general plan update, the mobility element.

2:04:49 The new work that ALT is doing, the downtown revitalization, how do they understand how those things fit together? So making it understandable, I think, is number one. Number two is asking them, you know, general and specific questions and the priorities that they can very quickly respond to. Okay. Have you reviewed our Main Street plan? Years ago. I'm working my way through the policy documents now. In Section 8 of our Main Street plan, we have some quick...

2:05:35 quick fix tools or implement implementations to get started on our town right away. And I was wondering if you had a chance to look at those and if you had considered how you may or may not incorporate that into your idea for our town. Yeah, that's something that we will be doing and also looking at the strategic

2:06:04 Planning work that council and staff went through and their priorities, and I'm going to want to merge those two elements together and then come back and sort of reconfirm those priorities and provide that information to the general public in terms of those elements that do specifically relate to the downtown. Okay. I don't think I have any other questions. Okay. Mr. Dinsmore, this is Commissioner Callanan. What sort of time frame are you looking at for

2:06:37 For your deliverables, or what sort of schedule are we looking at for this project? Yeah, that's a good question. We're hoping to have the new website, some initial engagement work that the public could engage in up in the next two weeks, and then we'll be having a workshop on December 7th, where we'll be meeting in person, face-to-face, laying out plans and drawings, getting specific focused feedback.

2:07:12 We're going to be working with Alta after they've done their meetings with stakeholders and their charrette to take that work and make it understandable, digestible, and build that into an online open house for the public that will be going on probably throughout January. In parallel with that, we'll be meeting with stakeholders coming back to your commission to use tools such as infill score and EIFDs to kind of look at some of the obstacles and barriers.

2:07:42 Okay, so that takes us into January, February or something like that. Do you think this process is going to continue on quite a bit further than that or are we just looking at a few months? Yeah, I think by the time we get this up and running quickly, we're still looking at final reporting and things in March of next year. Okay, okay.

2:08:18 And then I guess just one more question. Can you just comment a little bit on how you can design or structure your outreach to engage our Spanish-speaking community? Yeah, really good question. So we're going to be making our websites auto-translate and Google Chrome into Spanish. We'll be making Spanish versions of the visual surveys as well. And then we'll have paper versions of them that will be distributed

2:08:51 And I'm not sure what the distribution venues may be. In other communities such as Kings Beach and North Lake Tahoe, we had the greatest impact reaching the Latino population by going to the Catholic Church and engaging them that way. So we'll be exploring those opportunities with staff. Okay, great. Thank you. Are there any questions for Mr. Dinsmore from the public or from staff? Tom Hodges again from Mammoth Mountain Skier. Darren, Tom Hodges here. Can you hear him?

2:09:34 Can you hear Tom? I might need to have, yeah, I might need to have the question repeated. I haven't started the question yet, but I just introduced myself. But Darren, if you can hear me, you know, I think what's, I'm trying to get my arms around how this process is going to work. And I think, I'm just trying to get clarity on how it's going to be portrayed to the public. Because, like you mentioned, there's numerous studies and plans that are out there.

2:10:04 Sort of revitalization program presented to the public via the Hart-Howerton plan, which was trying to synthesize all that prior information and sort of provide a vision to the public that they could react to. And I'm just curious how you're going to portray that because you have elements of public investment with this idea of the revitalization of downtown, but by and large, the future of that's going to be determined by

2:10:32 Private investment. And just as we were discussing in the prior agenda item with respect to the final approval of the FAR densities and how we have a perfect example here where there appears to be a property that might be coming in under densified, you know, I think part of this is a sales pitch to the public to say how do you want your downtown to look and how we can provide examples to them. So in the case of the FAR,

2:11:01 Having visuals that show what one level of FAR versus another looks like and maybe posing the question to the public, well, do you want your downtown to look like this or this? Something they can actually understand versus some esoteric number that they have no idea what it means. I'm just curious how you assemble that information and then actually portray that in your different tools.

2:12:17 Okay, and if I could, a quick follow-up on that exact point was kind of getting out in the weeds a little bit, but I don't know whether or not you've received that study that was prepared in conjunction with Nori Winner's work on Main Street. It was Placia and Associates.

2:13:15 It's one of the appendices to the Main Street plan. Yeah, so it did a fairly rigorous analysis, sort of like a development financial analysis, right, of viability of, like you say, you know, all these ideas are well and good until you actually try to build it and it doesn't pencil out. And one of the primary conclusions of that was that, you know, parking is a deal breaker, particularly structured parking for

2:13:43 for individual developments. One of the big notions of the downtown plan was there's going to need to be a parking district created and shared parking to take a significant level of the commercial parking burden off the individual developers. I think particularly as we start really working with the nuts and bolts of the FAR.

2:14:08 In trying to achieve higher densities, the parking is going to be probably the biggest issue that's going to prohibit us from achieving our goals. And so, you know, I think a huge part of this discussion and portrayal to the public is an understanding of, you know, what that means with respect to parking and how can we achieve shared parking solutions and so forth.

2:14:37 California communities, coastal communities that I'm familiar with that have done revitalizations or redevelopments of their downtown and they always involve, you know, shared parking structures for, you know, commercial uses and so forth. So, I'm just curious how you incorporate that into all the collateral you're going to be providing. Yeah, thank you. Right. I think I certainly agree with that and, yeah, it's funny because, you know, there's already

2:16:08 Life happens while you're planning your life, right? And there's already things in the works and so yeah, I think that's where we've always gotten paralyzed is on the implementation side and we've got, like I say, great plans but we can't find our way out of the weeds to ever implement. So I'm just hoping that there's going to be some real kind of practical implementation ideas that people can get their arms around and understand so that when projects do come up and come before the

2:16:37 The Planning Commissioner, the Town Council, that people understand that that can fulfill that vision for us and that we can achieve our end results that we're looking for. That's all I got. Thanks. Thank you, Tom. Thanks, Tom. Sure. If you could just state your name for the record, please. Hi, I'm Greg Rollins, and I have a couple questions, and they probably haven't reached that phase of the

2:17:11 Plan yet, but they were on the agenda, so I just wanted a little clarification. And one of them is the revision of the boundaries for commercial property. I'm not exactly sure what that entails. Does it mean like changing the property boundaries of existing properties there to incorporate some of their property into these programs?

2:17:40 Into this plan or? Are you referring to the topics under our agenda item number one in the public hearing? Yes. On the 4-15-002 rezoning code amendment. Oh, so that was part of our public hearing session earlier this morning. Yes, I missed part of it. Yes. So I'm untimely in my question.

2:18:08 Yes, unfortunately, we have moved on from that item. Sandra, I mean, what do we? Yeah, the commission has made a recommendation to council, so the final decision hasn't been made on that yet. That will be considered by the council on December 7th. I can give you my business card if you want to sit down and talk about some of your questions between now and the council meeting, and you can provide public comment at the council meeting as well. Absolutely, and I would like to agree with what Tom said.

2:18:34 I recently did some work along the coastal areas, the beach and stuff, towards LA. And they have, as you know, anywhere near the beach you have a parking crisis, really. And they have...

2:18:51 designated areas like four to five blocks away from the beach, just not massive parking lots, but just long thin strips like along the green belt and that. And it has been extremely successful, I mean, and cutting, making it where people park like four blocks from the beach and they walk to it. And during their walk to it, they, it has made foot traffic along the commerce area.

2:19:20 You know, really revitalized, revitalized the whole beach area, having this massive amount of tens of thousands of people a day who walk on foot through this area, you know, without having, they also have a very old parking lot from like in the 70s that is just one mass of like 200 car parking area and it is just, just horrible.

2:19:47 Basically, you know what I'm saying? And people just park there and walk 15 feet to the strand, you know? And they actually do not even walk near any business. They walk like through an alleyway. So I was just thinking that that would be something that I'm sure that they have all kinds of layouts and plans, you know, that could be, you know, considered in it too. Instead of just a huge parking lot somewhere, you know, like Vons or something, you know, where everybody parks.

2:20:15 In something where people would actually park in micro areas and then walk through all of the businesses and stuff to wherever they were going, you know. So, okay, thank you for your time. Thank you. Thank you very much. So, I don't think we have any further questions unless anything specific from the staff.

2:20:43 Did the commission want to provide Darren with some questions that you would like to see us to ask to the broader community? I know we kind of popped it on you today. You don't have to answer it now. If you want to provide in the next week or so, if you have some kind of questions that you'd like to include, we're happy to include those. I think the main questions that I have for the public is how in-depth

2:21:14 of awareness they have on everything that we talked about, the downtown plan, the main street plan, mobility update. I think it would be nice to hear that from the public, not just the residents here, but the second homeowners, given that we have over 50% of the property homeowners here are

2:21:44 Second homeowners. And, you know, it'd be great, you know, to get that input from that group of folks. Right. I would like to know, I would like to probably ask them what their top three things that they would like to see improved in our town or what we should build in our town. Because I think, you know, we kind of have an idea of what needs or should be done.

2:22:18 What do the people want? And I think that that really is something that needs to be asked. Are you saying what do the people want with regard to anything specific or you just want to ask them a broad question? Broad question. What would you like to see in our town? Great. I think that, you know, everyone, we've all acknowledged that housing is a

2:22:45 is a problem and I think as part of this work it would be helpful to find out a few specifics from the community what their specific challenges have have been and are so that we can be a little bit better informed about how to best go about solving our housing problem as well as our you know transportation transportation infrastructure ask them specifically about

2:23:14 The challenges that they have faced and what they would like to see improved. Did you get that, Darren, those questions? Yeah, those are good. Okay. All right. Anything further for Darren? No. Okay. Well, thank you, Darren. We appreciate you calling into this meeting. Thank you. Thanks, Darren. Thank you very much. All right. Bye. Okay. Moving on.

2:24:07 To our consent agenda, agenda items number five and six. Just as a review, our consent agenda typically includes items that are routine in nature and they can be considered by the commission with just one single action. Unless any member of the audience or commissioner would like to pull one of those agenda items for discussion, we can do that at this time. If not, we can proceed.

2:24:38 Would anyone like to make a motion? I'll make a motion. Agenda number five to find the final parcel map that is in accordance with the conditionally approved tentative parcel map and that all applicable conditions at approval of tentative parcel map have been satisfied. As well as number six. You can just do both at the same time if we're all in agreement. Sorry, let me go to number six here.

2:25:10 You can make a motion just to approve the consent agenda. Okay. I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Okay. I'll second that. All in favor? Aye. Yes. Aye. Consent agenda is approved. Moving on to Commissioner Reports. Commissioner Chine, do you have anything specific that you'd like to address? No. Nothing publicly. All right.

2:25:48 Commissioner Burroughs, would you like me to discuss the design committee or would you like to? You can go ahead and start. Okay. We had the pleasure of being a part of the design committee this past month and we heard three items, one being a construction of a roof on Commerce Drive in the industrial area and nothing too specific. They are looking to move to a metal roof.

2:26:19 and perhaps put a skylight in. So, and we also heard an alteration in plans for the, is it St. Joseph's? St. Joseph's, yeah. Yeah, they, unfortunately, the cost to renovate exceeded their initial

2:26:44 Or their budget. And so they had to come back to us with other plans to downsize it and fit it within their budget. And I think that it still will look great and it'll be a nice addition. And finally, we had a presentation from Grady from Public Works regarding the ice spring, the multi-use facility. And it looks like the plans that are currently in place are going to provide a nice addition for our community.

2:27:16 And, oh, if anyone's interested in seeing the plans, Grady is willing to talk to anyone about it, so please feel free to contact him. Thank you. I don't really have anything additional other than, well, I do want to thank Hayes and Grady for...

2:27:39 You know, being involved in all, I know they're not, they left, but being involved in all of the construction and infrastructure projects that we've seen going on throughout town, including the resurfacing of Old Mammoth Road and a couple of street signs and parking lots and transit stations, I think things are definitely moving in a great, great direction and I appreciate all of their hard work. And it looks great. It does. I think it really improved the public area.

2:28:09 I agree. And for our director's report. So thank you. So I already provided the commission with information on the downtown revitalization project, the public meetings on December 7th. I just wanted to take a quick minute to talk a little bit about the walk, bike, ride action plan. So that's another project that the town is moving forward with. And this is just kind of just a quick summary.

2:28:39 So our community vision is to be progressive, sustainable community with seamless access to our key destinations.

2:28:51 Obviously, we want to use, you know, multimodal. We want to have people walk. We want to have people bike and ride transit. And so we have entered into a contract with Alta Planning and Design. I think you heard Darren reference Alta. This is what he was talking about. And so they'll be looking at developing a multimodal bike ped transit parking action plan. So this is to help kind of similar to the downtown revitalization to move some of these projects forward.

2:29:19 And we'll have, we have a number, two public workshops. I apologize, it's a little small on the screen there. But two public workshops that week of December 5th. That week of December 5th is the Charette Week for Alta Planning and Design. Also, Darren Dinsmore will be here that week. So we will have kind of two bookend meetings for the walk, bike, ride public outreach. And that, so the first public meeting would be Monday, December 5th.

2:29:47 From 5 to 8 p.m., and that's at the fire station. And so really that's to kind of kick off this walk, bike, ride project, conduct a strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, threats analysis, and kind of talk about what are the issues, some of the things that we kind of talked a little bit about in the revitalization. What are the issues that the community sees with, you know, transportation?

2:30:08 Issues that we'd like to solve. So that's kind of kicking off the project. Then on Tuesday and Wednesday, the consultants will be meeting with all the different agencies, with the county, with the Forest Service, with kind of all of our partner agencies, stakeholder groups, those types of people on Tuesday and Wednesday. And then Thursday, they will provide the community with a summary of what they heard. And so that's really kind of the other bookend meeting, and that's Thursday.

2:30:37 And this is here in Suite Z from 5 p.m. to 7 p.m. And then the consultants would also be available after the meeting just to talk more about it. So that's kind of the charrette week, the charrette that the Ulta Planning and Design will be out here for. And Darren mentioned in his presentation, he's going to take basically what's presented during that charrette week and do an online charrette. So he would take all the information that the Ulta presents during that week.

2:31:05 And get that online. So if someone can't make any of these meetings, someone can't participate in this charrette, they can basically do everything online. So that's kind of a piece that's a little bit of an overlap between the two projects in that Darren's going to help us with the public outreach on this Ulta project. So the...

2:31:25 I'm the project manager for it, so if anyone has any questions, they can contact me. Also, we'll be using that website, connectmammothlakes.com, to gather data on that as well. So are there any questions on that project? Is any of this being shared in the newspaper or radio station so that people...

2:31:46 Come more aware of it. Yeah, so we had it, it will be in the Town E News this week in the newspaper. We have a graphic designer who's been hired and we've given her all of this information. So she's going to create ads that will be in the newspaper next week. So we'll have ads for all of that. We will have all the materials before.

2:32:06 Next weekend when it goes in the paper. So we'll be able to hand out flyers. We're going to do some bookmark-type cards that we can give to the local businesses that have that website on it just to drive that traffic. Also sending emails out to all of the service groups and kind of all of these groups that everybody is a part of some groups. So trying to just get that out as much as we can, drive that traffic to the connectmammothlakes.com website so then we can get that information through there and provide them with information on the public.

2:32:36 So yes. So any other questions on that? Great. So then a couple other quick items I have is that at your next meeting in December, we'll be asking the commission to choose a new chair.

2:32:53 So as you know, Commissioner, or actually Vice Chair Vanderhurst is the Vice Chair. So that will be a discussion that will be on your agenda for December. Jamie Gray, our town clerk, has published the vacancy for the seat that's available. And so we will not have a new commissioner by next month, but it hopefully will be January that you'll have a new commissioner.

2:33:17 And then just kind of internally for our department staffing issues, as you're aware, Kim and Ruth will be out on maternity leave in the beginning of the year, likely January, February, March. So we have entered into... Yes.

2:33:34 We've entered into a contract with a consulting firm that our planner Jen Daugherty works for down in San Luis Obispo. So Jen will be providing some staff support to help us with some projects that we have in the works now or that could come in during that time. Additionally... She was one of the senior planners in the past? Yes, she was. Yeah.

2:33:54 And then additionally, we have a trails coordinator, Joel Rathje, who has some planning experience. He worked as a planner for a number of years before he came here. So he'll be providing some staff support as well. So we have some staff support, but we will be, staffing will be thin for the winter months here. And that's all I have. All right. Thank you. Well, thank you very much again, Sandra, for

2:34:27 All of your hard work on all of these projects. Really very much appreciated. Unless we have any other comments, we will adjourn the meeting to our next regular meeting to be held on December 14, 2016 at 2 p.m. here in Suite Z. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.