Town Council
· recording 5 hr 3 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
647 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
14:43 So we've been sending out emails, and you can vote on that stuff and buy your tickets online and come enjoy our gala dinner at the Westin December 8th. The other thing I wanted to talk about was our chamber host program that we're putting together. If anybody is interested in joining, I have an extra host committee handbook that we put together, and this is going to be kind of our volunteer.
15:10 And we are hoping to...
15:33 You know, usually with Chambers of Commerce, it's called an ambassador program. We wanted to use the word host because the Mountain has a host program and we're hoping to eventually work with them in some sort of capacity. You know, we're still at the initial stages of that, but that's the long-term goal with the program. So if anybody's interested in being involved, contact the chamber, contact Craig Schmidt or myself or any of the other board members and learn how you can get involved. Thank you. Thank you.
16:02 Sorry, Mr. Mayor, I've just got a, I had a note that the Granicus audio is not working, but now I'm told that it's fixed, so. Okay. You guys found that out. Yep. Okay. Good. You found out too. Yep. Okay. We are set up here. Okay. Anybody else from the public wishing to make a comment?
16:30 Hi, good evening. Jennifer Halfordi, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I just want to share a little good news. I've talked to you before about the down payment assistance program and a family, a household did close on a house last week or a condo on their home and that's very exciting. Kudos to you guys for supporting that program and the town staff for doing that. We have another household and escrow should be closing before Christmas. So, good news. Thank you. Thanks, Jennifer. Any other comments from the public?
17:02 Okay, seeing none, we'll move on. Next piece of business is a piece of correspondence. John, I don't know if you want to talk about this. It's a letter from the members of the Mountain Pack to members of Congress, which is dated October 31st. Did you have any input on that? No, I think that the staff has indicated that going forward, as we have pieces of correspondence that are relevant,
17:33 To the community, it may not merit any detailed discussion from the dais, but to get these things as part of the packet so people can see what's going on. Mountain Pact is a group that we talked about a year or so ago, based out of Truckee, looking at a lot of issues specific to climate change and ski destinations, places like ours. It's a lot of western resorts. Right. Right.
17:55 Vail, Alta, City of Bend, et cetera. And these are the kinds of things I think that we need to be speaking as a voice consistently back in D.C. Anyway, that is in your packet. We'll move on to Councilman reports or Councilmember reports in additions to the agenda. I would like to ask that we move item 10 to 11 and 11 to 10. Okay? And that's for Mr. Sauser who will have to recuse himself from item number 10.
18:24 Any other additions to the agenda? None? Any from Council? No. All right. Cleland, can I start with you? No. You're not ready? No. Okay. Then I'll go to Bill. I attended an estimated Bishop, a closed session report out of that. I also attended the ribbon cutting at Trails-In Park.
18:53 I'm glad to see that that thing is off the ground and working well. It was well attended. Nothing could please me more than the work that's been done down there. However, we did keep talking about the park being completed, and I want to caution that no park is ever completed, and no park ever should be completed. As trends change, as things need to grow, so yes, we've done a great job bringing it forward to this stage.
19:17 But I look forward to the changes yet to come on all of our parks and the continued improvement. Thank you, Bill. Cleland, are you ready yet? Yeah, you know what? Actually, the only thing that I really have that I can report on is I, too, attended the ribbon cutting. And it was really neat to see everybody that was out there having to park on the side of the road because the...
19:45 Parking lot was full was awesome, but I do want to say that people are not wearing their helmets out there, and I still have a problem with that, so I just want to put that on the record, Jamie. Helmets not worn. Thank you. Is that it? That's it. Very good. Colin. Thank you. A couple items. Monday, November 7th, I attended Sierra Classic Theater's Murder Mystery.
20:13 Awesome as always. There is a final encore show tonight at Rafters. Arguably maybe more interesting than a council meeting. So it starts in a few minutes actually. So we have to compete with that tonight. So that is going on for the final show. That was awesome. On Thursday, November 10th, with the rest of the council, I did attend.
20:38 The ribbon cutting at Trails End Park, we've been doing a lot of these things, ribbon cuttings that is, and we intend to do a lot more in our time here on council, but it was interesting sometimes those ribbon cuttings involve the five of us and maybe a couple other town staff members. That was pretty cool to see about 300 people show up for that one. So it's a very well utilized park and a great community asset. So that was a really fun event.
21:04 Both yesterday, the 15th, and this morning, the 16th, Bill and I have been meeting with Town Manager Dan Holler to work on updating the MLR contract. We made a lot of progress on that today. We're going to do kind of one final sweep in about a week, and then, Rich, we'll get that out to you and Tom, and we're also going to share that with Betsy Truax and the Recreation Commission to get some feedback before we finalize that. So that will be coming back relatively soon.
21:33 On Tuesday the 15th, the Outdoor Performing Arts Committee met again. That was a spirited discussion as always. You know, we were kind of talking about a bunch of different issues, short-term strategy for events.
21:50 And how that may differ from the long-term strategy, whether we operate out of one site that's kind of all-encompassing, or whether we look at kind of a two-tiered approach of multiple sites depending on the event and event size. So we talked about a lot of those things. Last night, I attended the chamber business after hours, talked about a couple of things that Jeremy mentioned.
22:18 So that was a really good turnout as well. And then lastly, Wednesday the 9th, we had our MLT monthly meeting. So I've got a couple things to report out on that, all of which are good news. Our fiscal 16-17 TOT is currently over a million dollars ahead of budget, which is 33.6%. So we are continuing to break records July, August, September.
22:44 September was by far the best September we've ever had. It came in at $967,000 in TOT. So we are very close to that million-dollar threshold. Again, another month over the million-dollar threshold. And that was quite a bit over the previous record. So that's great news. Actually, 23.7% up over the last record in September.
23:13 Kind of that fits in with the whole outside on the east side campaign, which seemed to be very successful. A lot of people here this fall enjoying fall colors and all the events we have going on. It's looking like October will also be a record-setting TOT month. So that's great news. Specifically with August, we exceeded budget by 17.7%, another record. And just a couple other small things.
23:43 The TBID renewal process has been started. We had a few meetings to go over that. Petitions will be going out to businesses in the next week or so. And as of right now, no changes are proposed. All the same percentages that are existing now would be proposed to carry forward. And then for our winter flight schedule, just a reminder, winter flights begin December 15th.
24:11 San Francisco will be seven days a week. San Diego will be four days a week, Thursday, Friday, Sunday, Monday. LAX will be seven days a week plus a second flight four days a week. And then we've got JetSuiteX that is going to be starting a scheduled charter service. So that's what's kind of going on at the airport. Correct. I think that is everything on the MLT front. That's all I got. Thank you very much. John.
24:41 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Monday, November 7th, I attended the MLH board meeting. These meetings have been getting more and more fun-like, and a lot of very good, interesting, productive conversations have been happening. And I guess it's serendipity, but I think that this announcement from Rusty and Kirk could not have come at a better time. And I think it's very encouraging to see the community come around a very important issue like this.
25:10 I think it's also important to point out that the challenges for housing are coming from a lot of unexpected places.
25:40 The issue of housing rise to the forefront and to look at what we're going to have to do to engage with this in a meaningful way. There can be a lot of unexpected things we're going to be encountering here, and it's going to be a very interesting thing to see what we can do with it. MLH has survived their annual audit with
26:00 No findings of any issues. Interesting discussion about tiny homes and shipping containers, which is kind of interesting. Who knows what we're going to do here to address our housing issues. Wednesday, November 9th, Colin and I met with Mickey Brown, recently retired, resigned from the PEDC. We had a good and heartfelt conversation. One of the things we really identified was how sort of...
26:26 Thank you very much. Thank you very much.
26:50 On Thursday, I attended a day-long meeting of the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District, which was fascinating. I heard from Cal Fire, Sierra Nevada Conservancy, Inu National Forest, folks about the Rainbow Fire. And I think it's, you know, this is a startling thing to say, but in case anybody had any doubt about it, the forests of the Sierra Nevada are dying, and they're going to be dead within, you know,
27:20 Thank you very much.
27:43 The re-articulation of the value of the recreation and tourism economies of these gateway committees in the Sierra has never been stronger and never been in need of more powerful and forceful advocates. We had an interesting conversation with Jim Branham of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy when he's here for that meeting. I'm going to be visiting relatives in D.C. next week, and I've got a little appointment with Congressman Cook's office to kind of reinforce this, to talk with Congressman McClintock also to start saying, look,
28:11 The idea of resource extraction out of the Sierra forests, that's a ship that's sailed. And I think it's going to be very important to get federal reorientation as to what's going to be happening in these public lands in the Sierra going forward. Those are going to be interesting conversations. Veterans Day on Friday, November 11th, I was able to make it with the fire station for a little bit. That was a very moving and interesting event. Attended the LTC meeting with Shields, and I can maybe leave it to you to give the report on that. Go ahead.
28:39 Just the usual sad state of the funding for our roads here in the state of California. There's a special session of the state legislature coming up after Thanksgiving. Hopefully they'll try to address some of that. We heard a very good and thorough presentation from the Forest Service about the Reds Meadow Road. And, you know, you may not think that the Forest Service actually...
29:01 Kind of gets their spurs in and does things, but from time to time they actually kind of do. This effort is very high on their radar. They've spent the money on the preliminary NEPA work, the preliminary design work, and it's very encouraging to know that our staff, very capable and talented staff, will be engaging with an effort that's got real support and momentum coming out of the regional office. It's going to be very interesting to see what this thing turns into. But I think that our interest in this road...
29:28 Lies with all the recreation opportunities down at the bottom of that road. Bill and I have talked about that a fair amount. And also the opportunity to connect this community to national scenic trails such as the PCT and the JMT and a national monument. This will be a topic of discussion with the congressmen to make sure that folks at the federal level understand what local gateway communities are doing to make up for budget shortfalls and perhaps some failure of maintenance obligations coming out of the federal government to keep these things alive. And it's going to be important to make sure that that's on their radar and they know about that.
29:58 And I think that's about it. Just one last sort of comment on the election. Rusty mentioned we've all just survived this thing. It's likely to be a somewhat chaotic environment going forward. Chaos has, you know, there's two sides to a chaotic situation. There are going to be things that are going to be difficult, but there may be some significant opportunities for us as a community.
30:25 And I'm just going to encourage staff and all the rest of us to keep our eyes wide open and to listen and to hear what's going to be happening. Certainly issues of infrastructure investment, issues around immigration, issues around climate change are things that could have significant effects for our community. The housing, a lot of the money coming out of our housing initiative is going to come out of the California Cap and Trade Program. Whatever effect the federal policy may have on what's happening to that very ambitious state program, who knows?
30:54 But I think, again, to reemphasize the timing of Kirk and Rusty's announcement to be able to get an application into those California cap and trade funds by June, I think this is the kind of investment that's going to pay off because there are dollars there that we desperately need to make that project work. So no doubt it's going to be interesting. Thank goodness we all live in this beautiful place and can take solace in this beautiful place. Thank you. John, thank you.
31:23 Well, I'd like to comment how beautiful our fall was. I mean, the colors and everything. But who's ready for winter? Yeah. It's time. I, too, attended the Trails End Park. A lot of people there. That was great. Great to see. I also attended the Veterans Day. I actually spoke at it. I want to thank Mr. Boccia back there for putting on that presentation. Great job. Thank you.
31:52 I also attended the LTC, as you mentioned. I would like to add that the Caltrans kind of gave a pretty exciting, hey, guess what? We found some money in there. We're going to actually enhance $14,395 at Freeman Gulch. So they got the money to do that project or part of that project. It's about six miles or so.
32:22 Information and development had not been on the table, we would have lost the funding because all of a sudden they found the money. They said, okay, what can we fund? Boom. And we happen to be Johnny on the spot. So that's pretty exciting. That's supposed to start relatively soon. Let me see what else I got here. I guess that's about it. I would like to also, these are in the back.
32:56 We have some community involvement coming up. It's very important that you in the community be involved. One is for our walk, bike, and ride community workshops. They are on December 5th and 8th. They're either at the fire station or at Suite Z here. And then the other one is the revitalization of downtown, what that means for the community, and it's a community workshop, and that's on Wednesday, December 7th.
33:25 And we have two times on December 7th, one's in the morning in Sweet C here, and the other one's in the afternoon at the fire station, fire station number one. So it's very important that we be involved as a community in the discussion of these two very important parts. So with that, I will go on to commissions and department reports. But before I do that, Jamie, can you tell us about the changes in how this looks? Yes.
33:56 So one of the milestones identified in the Town Council's strategic planning work was to identify technology and equipment improvements that add benefit while lowering costs. So in an effort to achieve that milestone, town staff are testing out an agenda management system through Granicus for a three-month free trial period.
34:17 The system improves efficiency by controlling the versions of agenda items, implementing an agenda item approval workflow that is done by email, and allowing a one-click agenda packet publishing process. The look and feel of the agenda and the agenda packet have been changed and improved, I think. Town staff anticipates a successful implementation of the system, and if you have any questions about the new process, please let me know. That's one quick question.
34:44 Opportunities for public engagement with this new system that may not have been known about before? It's a back-end system. This piece is a back-end system. There are other pieces that we're working on for engagement in community, but this particular piece is a back-end agenda management system. So all the things that were in place before are still there? Yes. Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions for Jamie? Move on. Sandra.
35:11 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Thank you, Mayor Richardson, for mentioning the walk, bike, ride community workshops and the downtown revitalization community workshops. Just one thing to add on to that announcement is that we have a website specially dedicated to these projects, and it's connectmammothlakes.com.
35:33 If you go to that website, you can take a survey, provide feedback. This is a huge piece of this outreach, is to get out to the public and get some input from people that we don't normally hear from. So we're trying to get it out, get it out to all different members of our community, and that's what we're working on right now. Once the walk, bike, ride workshops are completed,
35:55 Our consultants will be putting that on that website. So it's like an online open house. So if you can't attend any of those walk, bike, ride workshops, you'll be able to go online onto that website and see all of the information that's presented to those workshops and provide input on that as well. So we're really trying hard to get this kind of online out to the public. And it is designed to be used on your phone. So it's a...
36:20 Easy to access on your phone. You can go through the survey and everything, and it's a pretty helpful website. Any questions on either of those, the workshops or the website? Any questions? I've got a question. So I'm on the MLH board, and Jennifer sent out a notification saying there have been two meetings set up with that group of stakeholders. Can you give us an idea of what kind of stakeholder meetings you've arranged for both groups, the Walk, Bike, Ride, and the Dinsmore effort?
36:48 Yeah, so we're trying to meet with the NGOs, and it will just kind of depend on the meeting schedule for the NGOs, whether it's an actual board meeting or just a meeting with one or two of the members and the executive director. It looks like we will be able to make a presentation to the Recreation Commission, which is that Tuesday. We'll be meeting with the Forest Service, with the county, with the Yosemite Transit System group, with ESTA.
37:14 There's a number of different agencies. We're setting up all these meetings, basically staff meetings with our staff and the consultants. I'm sorry, the staffs of those agencies and the consultants to provide feedback. If there are public meetings, like I said, we're trying to get on those agendas, but we won't be able to hit every public meeting. Obviously, they're not all.
37:33 That week. So Mammoth Lakes Housing, the board was able to all meet that day, and so Jennifer wanted it to be a public meeting with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, which is great. We're also going to be able to meet with Mammoth Lakes Recreation because they also meet that day, that Tuesday as well. So it will be a presentation to their board. So it just kind of depends on the agencies, when their meeting dates are, and whether their board members can get together for those meetings.
37:58 I've got two quick things. There's a data set being prepared for the consultants. Do you know if that's been prepared and sent on? Yes. We've sent on a data set to the consultants. Joel Rathje, our trails coordinator, put that together. Okay, good. Thank you.
38:11 You might want to mention, are these facilitated meetings? They are facilitated meetings. Each meeting of the different topics will be facilitated by those consultants. So we have consultants for walk, bike, ride, consultants for downtown revitalization. So staff will be providing support, going to the different meetings, but the consultants will be doing all the heavy lifting that week. Very good. I'm assuming that in your stakeholder meeting for revitalization, we also have a meeting set with all the property owners along. Right.
38:43 Yeah, we have the public meetings that Wednesday, December 7th. So we're gearing one meeting to the chamber members. So that's going to go out to invite chamber members. You know, it's not only chamber members, so any member of the public can come to that meeting. And we also have an evening meeting on Wednesday, December 7th. And we're preparing bookmarks that have the website, that have information. So we'll be getting those out to the community, to all the different property owners in that area. So, yeah, those will be included in the public.
39:13 And then briefly, the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last Wednesday, November 9th. They considered the zoning code amendment and general plan amendment for flora ratio and the mobility element update. They did recommend approval of that project, so the council will be seeing that on your December 7th agenda meeting. And the commission also...
39:39 Had made a consistency determination for the Shadow Street property that you'll be seeing tonight. They determined that dedication of that property to the town is consistent with the general plan. And then finally, they heard a presentation from our consultant, the downtown revitalization consultant, on our public engagement tool, and they provided some comments on that. So their comments were built into the website that's live now. And that's all I have.
40:08 Very good. Thank you very much, Sandra. Thank you. Any other questions for Sandra? No. Okay. So this paperwork is basically the charrette that we've been talking about. Yes. Yes. Just a little more identified. Okay. Yes. Thanks. Haislip Hayes, Engineering Manager of Public Works. Quick update on construction activities. The minaret and forest trail project is substantially complete. All the hardscape is in. We are allowing parking. The bus shelter is nearing completion. We'll be ready.
40:42 For the holidays, we do have some punch list items that we need to get through. Unfortunately, the Hawk and Streetlights are built to order, and we are still waiting for them. Current lead time is sometime mid-December. Contractor is on standby. As soon as they come in, we'll get them up. The Hillside parking lot is open for business, currently signed for two-hour parking.
41:06 The bus shelter and streetlights, again, we're working through a couple punchless items, but they're substantially complete and available for use. The police station is clicking along, currently looks like a giant police pergola. We have a commitment from our contractor to work through winter, power through Mother Nature, get a roof on it, and we are currently on schedule overall with that project. We completed the MUP patching on one of our first sections of MUPs ever built in this town between the high school and Wagon Wheel.
41:35 What you may not know is Mark Walter, who has been a contractor here for decades, recently acquired black gold asphalt. He donated all of the materials and all of the labor to slurry seal that path for us. So I know Mark's watching. So thanks, Mark, for that donation. We really appreciate the extra effort. And finally,
41:54 Mammoth Lakes Recreation effectively contracted with Public Works to prepare a wetland delineation study for the bell-shaped parcel. We delivered our findings in the context of the Special Events Committee at their meeting this week. And if it's the pleasure of this council, we'd be happy to come forth with those findings and the implementations and so forth of that study at a later date. Oh, yeah, absolutely. Okay. As soon as it's ready. Yeah, let's do that. We have consensus. Okay, so we'll...
42:24 We'll schedule that for maybe January or February. Yeah, that'd be great. As soon as you can bring. Okay, thank you. And then the second, just one question for you, Hayes. I know you said Hillside Lot's open. I actually parked in it the other day. And I was there for half an hour. I was well within the limits. You know, first of all, everything looks fantastic. I'm really excited about all the improvements all around town. But I did wonder, you know, are we going to...
42:52 Do you think it's necessary that we have any sort of conversation about how we want to handle that lot from a signage perspective and how we want to handle the utilization, or is that something you guys are pretty comfortable with just moving forward in that manner? Your timing is perfect. Al and I were talking about this earlier. We signed a two-hour parking just to be consistent with the other parking around the village. We're planning to come back to council with some opportunities and options for variations on timing and...
43:18 Fees and just give you kind of lay it all on the table so that you guys can make a decision about the future of that law. Okay. And will that be part of the kind of overall signage program conversation or separate? I think it's a separate conversation related. It's a little bit different than the snow route type signage. Okay. Cool. Well, I think, you know, we look forward to having that conversation and I think, you know, the council and the public would be very interested to go through the findings on bell-shaped parcel because it's a land asset that we own and we need to know what we can do with it. Absolutely. Thanks.
43:48 Sorry. Go ahead. Just one good question. LTC, there was a conversation about lighting on Burner Street. Oh, yeah. We did get a commitment from the LTC to use our TIP dollars to complete the lighting on Burner Street. And as an aside to that, the conversations we've had with the residents in that neighborhood, we have put up all the signage to mitigate the...
44:10 The rearrangement of the parking lot, and we've also ordered a flashing sign for Alpine Circle at their request. So we are moving forward with all those mitigation measures that the community has requested. Very good. Thank you. Is that your thing? Huh? Is that the thing you were going to bring up, the lighting? Oh, okay. Stu, you're going to come up? I'm trying to get you. Recycle objects.
44:36 Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Department. Thank you, Mayor, Council, our public this evening. Just a couple of items for the public benefit and also just some news on the Parks and Recreation Department. Winter is here and with winter comes Spirit of Giving Week. So I know it's a Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce event. We also partner with the village at Mammoth, many community stakeholders. And that kicks off on Friday, November 25th.
45:02 That's the official Town of Mammoth Lakes tree lighting ceremony in the village. Mayor Richardson will be welcoming thousands of visitors, residents and locals up in the area too. Only a thousand? Thousands. Oh, thousands. I didn't hear the S. Thousands. Absolutely. Yes, thousands. Compliments of the fire department, Santa and Woolly will be arriving roughly about 625.
45:26 There you go. Time your day accordingly. Don't want to miss that one. Tuesday, November 29th is National Giving Tuesday. You can kind of donate to a lot of local charities in our community. Thursday, December 1st is Dine Out Mammoth Lakes. You can participate by dining at any one of these restaurants that we have listed in the little flyer at the back, and 10% of your proceeds will be donated to those causes.
45:49 That we've designated there on Friday. December 2nd is the annual Stuff a Bus donation program. So Esther bring up a Lyft bus. Anybody that has any donations of toys, warm clothing, non-perishable food items can bring those to the Footloose Sports parking lot from 12 to 5 p.m. and stuff the bus. So it's a fun program. Thanks to Esther for that one as well. So that's Spirit of Giving Week. Again, I've got some flyers and everything on the back if anybody wants.
46:18 That information on the Parks and Recreation front, immediately following Town Tree Lighting Ceremony on Friday, November 25th at 6.30, will be free ice skating. So you can come along at the ice rink from 7 to 10 p.m., and that includes skate rentals as well. If you have your skates, great. Hopefully we'll be open. We're going to need some cold weather, much like the ski area. We're really relying upon our...
46:41 Weather God's out there. But again, that's November 25th, 7 o'clock. November 30th, we'll schedule a facilitator joint workshop with both the Recreation Commission and Mammoth Lakes Recreation. So that's from 4.30 to 8.30 in the Community Centre. Again, it's a public meeting. That'll be facilitated by John Armstrong, who's also very engaged in the formation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
47:04 So that'll be a very productive workshop, we believe, that follow us on from the first meeting that we had not so long ago. And then Betsy would be telling us that on December 6th...
47:14 At the Recreation Commission meeting, again, we'll receive an update on the multi-use facility planning, the annual CIP major maintenance project list that we've been working on for the last several months, and also we're looking at the 2017 programming menu for essentially all of our parks and programs and camps next year. So there we go. Very good. Not much at all. Any questions for Stu? Thank you very much. Grab your flies. Thank you. All right. Any other questions?
47:45 Reports from commissions or departments? Okay, we'll go on to the next item, public presentations. I got together with Rusty and I asked him if he would come down and make a presentation, kind of state of the mountain presentation. I think the mountain, the town, the county are working very well together. And so, Rusty, with that, if you would kind of kindly give us
48:23 You got your tech guy here, huh? Because I don't know how to work a keyboard. Thanks, Shield. Shields asked slash told me to come. I've never done this before. I've spent a lot of time with this dais but never really come and provided.
48:48 So I'm here to do it for what it's worth.
49:17 So the report that I'm giving you tonight really does come partially right out of our board report, but on a somewhat pared back, less detailed basis. And the perspective that I'm talking to you about this evening is really Mammoth Resorts, because Mammoth the company has morphed a bit in the last few years, taking on, as many of you know, the Big Bear Mountain Resorts, Bear Mountain and Snow Summit. And the company is very different because of that.
49:47 That makes this perspective not just about Mammoth Mountain. So I'll talk in general about the company and how we're doing because that does bear on Mammoth Mountain and then talk about our strategies going forward, mostly from the Mammoth Mountain perspective, but kind of how they fold into the Mammoth Resorts piece. I'll talk, which will be very difficult for me, for about 15 minutes. That's so short.
50:11 And then, you know, I'm happy to answer questions or clarify, you know, from Council Shields or from the audience. No, I appreciate you staying around for questions. Whatever, however you'd like that. Thank you. So this is a report through the, really about where we stand and where we're going from the perspective of the recent completion of fiscal year 2016, which ended October 31st.
50:34 Just a little bit ago. And to really understand where we stand today and where we're going, I think it's worthwhile to provide a little bit of historical concept. So that history, along with a lot of the rest of the stuff here in Mammoth that we've all gone through, really, I think, has a lot to do with collapse, capitulation, and then cooperation.
51:03 If you really look at the metrics of where we stood back in this 10-year or so period, back from 1986 leading up to 1995, that was back in the days where Mammoth coming into that period of time in the early 80s, late 70s, we were by far the most visited ski resort in the country, ski area in the country. Mammoth was number one. Number two was Killington Mountain back in those days. Number three was a distant
51:32 Mammoth was, interestingly enough, doing about the same number of skier visits on a good year that we do today. It's very telling that it's not that much different. It's very volatile, but a big year, with the exception of a couple years, is about the same then as it was now. And so we were doing very well. We were very crowded on the weekends.
51:57 People were waiting 20 to 40 minutes in line, sometimes longer. We bought June Mountain to create an increase in capacity so that we had more uphill capacity, and we put probably $30 to $33 million in June Mountain from about 1986 to 1988.
52:20 And during that period of time, we went through a very significant drought period, not unlike the period we've just gone through. We forget that it's more severe recently, but it's not that much different. And the Sierra, we're certainly suffering from and will continue from global climate change. There's no question about that. And regardless of where your politics are, the science is pretty, except for a few idiots, the science is pretty
52:49 Pretty tough to refute. And whether that's because we don't have enough Priuses or Mother Nature's going up and down, I can't comment on, but whatever the reason is, you know, we're in for some very difficult weather periods. But that's not been unusual in the Sierra, and this was one of those periods. We just about lost the company in 1990 and 91. We had no snowmaking in those days, put a lot of money into June Mountain, but, you know, it snowed so much, we thought.
53:17 Back in those days, we didn't think there was a big reason to put snowmaking in, and by God, we were convinced otherwise very strongly during that period of time. We slipped from our high and skier visits, which is the blue line, from about 1.4 million visits to 420,000 visits in 1990-91 during a severe drought following a few other droughts. We were fairly heavily in debt because of the investment of
53:46 of money into June Mountain, and we also put a lot of money into more yon lifts on Mammoth Mountain.
53:52 At the same time, when others were building detachable lifts, and so the market penalized for that for us and for the fact that we didn't have snow, many of you that may have been around, I know Bill was in those days, was a very difficult time. Led to Black Monday, which was a time when 150 year-round employees lost their job in one day. The average length of time with the company was 21 years of the people that lost those jobs.
54:17 It's a very, very painful time that the company had a lot of trouble recovering from. But recovery we did. We worked to stabilize the company with our banks and with our business plan through 1991 to about 1995 and stabilized in 1995 at a time when we did about 1.2 million skier visits. During this time, it was so incredibly painful in town.
54:40 Our friends were leaving town. Businesses were closing everywhere. Forget about development. There was barely enough money to turn the gas and electricity on in those days. That pain brought us together. Anti-development interest got together with development interest. We put our differences aside, got off of our polls and into the middle of discussions, and agreed on a number of things.
55:03 Plans for the village, plans for transportation, plans for the future, plans to get together more clearly on how we were going to run and operate our community, and some incredibly wonderful relationships were created during that time, and those plans served us well for the next 10 years of taking those plans and building together.
55:26 So in town and on the mountain and the very new fledgling town of Mammoth Lakes through during that period of time and everybody took those plans in earnest and shoulder to shoulder we went on to build our community. During the next 10 years of 1996 to 2006, you know, if you look at the graphs and I probably should have explained it before if you can see it.
55:54 The top line, as I mentioned before, is skier visits and indicates the growth in skier visits from about, what is that, about a million, you know, a little less, maybe a million, a little less than a million, two, up to a peak of 1.6 million skier visits at Mammoth and June Mountain. So that's 1.5 million at Mammoth at the peak, and that's almost 100,000 visits at June at our peak year for that growth cycle.
56:22 During that period of time, 1,300 units were built in town, mostly by InterWest and InterWest affiliates. That was all part of the planning that had been done in the painful period. That's what brought us together around plans for the village, around plans for Sierra Star, around plans for Juniper. That's where the predominant, predominantly that's where the development occurred.
56:45 And the town expanded significantly. Juniper Springs was built. The village was built. The Weston came online. The mountain, along with that development, built, invested heavily in new lifts on the mountain. And we spent on lifts alone during that 10-year period of time, $100 million.
57:04 Actually, a bit more than $100 million on detachable lifts and gondolas that we installed during that time. We spent another $40 million on restaurants and improving McCoy Station, other things on the mountain, and we got snow. And when we didn't have snow, we had snowmaking. The first development we started with during that period of time was the money, what we put into our snowmaking system and the ponds.
57:32 That served us well. So we went through a great 10-year period. That was a lot of fun. I vaguely remember that. And then we went through, amazingly, another period of like 10 years of drought, and this time it was really bad. We had drought, global financial meltdown, two years of recession, and it was a very, very difficult time. So if you think about the peak of...
58:00 of 2006, the very next year, and that's the year that Dave McCoy and Penny sold their interest in the business, and we brought in our current partners, Starwood Capital Group, and a lot of us bought into the company, and immediately we went from our best year in history down from 1.6 million skier visits down to about a million. We lost 600,000 skier visits in a big drought. We weren't too worried.
58:29 We're still flush with money and unused debt capacity from the previous years. But for 10 years, in the next 10 years, we had seven years of drought in that 10 years for a biblical record-setting proportion. But fortunately, we had three good snow years.
58:48 But unfortunately, those snow years coincided with massive global financial meltdown of the mortgage-backed security market and everything else associated with it, not just in California, not just in the United States, but globally. So the world fell apart, and so the three years of great snowfall, you know, it does snow in Mammoth. Most people have forgotten that. Not only did it snow during this 10-year period, we had the two biggest snow years in history.
59:16 And which were 9-10 and 10-11. But unfortunately, it was the massive recession that happened during that time that offset the benefits of those. So we had a pretty good, pretty good years, but we, but it was so much worse than it would have been. So 10 very, very difficult years. So all of us were retrenching on the mountain and in town. You know, I don't need to remind people we're around how difficult those periods of time are or were.
59:44 But a lot got done in that period of time. A lot got done on the mountain. We built some restaurants, put some things in the village. That's when campos were created. That's when 53 came out of that. Air service started with that. In town, key bid, the general plan, neighborhood district plans. There was a lot of progress that was made during that period of time.
1:00:09 A little less consensus and agreement than we had during the previous painful period, but we accomplished things because we did get together on air service, on TBID, on the general plan, on neighborhood district plans, on MLR, on a lot of things that we're sitting on today, the plans that we laid during those painful times. And so we now come to today, 2016. So we have just completed...
1:00:36 Our most successful year in history for the company, not in terms of skier visits, but in terms of revenue, and I should finish the chart. Revenue is the green line, and then I'm telling you what our profitability is, which is our operating income, which is the purple line that's next to that. So this year, and this includes the acquisition of Big Bear Mountain Resorts.
1:01:02 So this year we will do $235 million in revenue, well above $200 million, which is by far the biggest record in the company's history, $2 million skier visits, and $75, almost $76 million in profitability. Actually, it's $78 million in profitability, and we're paying out a $2.5 million bonus to our employees, the first bonus we've paid out in 10 years because of the difficult period of time that we've gone through.
1:01:31 So as we sit here today, relative to our operating income, our debt levels are relatively nominal and very serviceable. We've completely refinanced the company, and we're very excited about the possibilities going forward. Mammoth Resorts is in a very strong position with our guests, with our employees, and financially to go forward. So we have an opportunity to move into a period of recovery, opportunity, and growth.
1:02:01 And our projections going forward are driven by a set of strategies that I've tried to sort of simplify a bit for tonight. And those strategies are to increase financial strength and stability. And remember, this is across all of Mammoth resorts, so all four of our mountains. And certainly the largest asset in our portfolio is Mammoth by far, and we're very focused on it. So increased financial strength and stability.
1:02:30 Grow our markets and know our guests. Improve the guest experience continually. Invest in the professional and personal growth of our team, meaning our employees. Refresh, renovate, redevelop our resorts infrastructure and cooperate and lead when necessary, only when necessary, to strengthen our communities. So a little more detail on that.
1:02:57 One of the things that you'll see us focused on is dynamic pricing. It's not just us. Vale does it. Everyone else does it. And we charge a lot of different prices on a lot of different days. We used to set the price for a ticket at one level, and we'd keep it that way all year long. We're lucky to have one price for an hour or two on a weekend. The prices are changing all the time. If you watch closely, the burrito prices change on the weekends.
1:03:22 During the midweek when there's not a lot of demand for burritos and beans, we charge less. On the weekends when we have a lot of demand, we charge more. We charge what the market bears. And that's dramatically increased the financial success of the business, which gives us the money to now start thinking about reinvesting in the company. So if airlines have been doing this for a long time, they're the ones that invented it. Vegas and gambling areas took this to a fine art.
1:03:49 And a lot of other industries are following it, including Disneyland and Universal Studios. And it's a royal pain in the rear from a consumer standpoint, but it is something that allows us to reward the consumer on the quiet days and attract them to unutilized capacity and not to penalize them, but to charge full boat during a period of time when it's quite crowded.
1:04:12 It's interesting that in the paper already we've had a few good summers and, you know, a lot of people are complaining, oh my God, there's too many people in town, where did my falls go when it was so quiet? And, you know, we're very cognizant of the fact that the success at Mammoth is not about having 30,000 people on the hill on Saturday. What we'd like to do is to get people, some people to come on Wednesday when we only have 5,000 people in town. Our employees, yours and ours, are overworked on the weekends and underutilized during the midweek and so we need to...
1:04:40 We need to sort of match up our capacities as a resort communities with demand so that we don't have peak loads the way we do now. We need to continue to recapitalize the company for growth, both on the debt and the equity side. You'll hear a lot more about that in the months to come. We have some real growth goals, and you'll see some very big changes with us on the capital structure side of the company.
1:05:08 We intend to diversify geographic and weather, our weather risks through continued acquisitions. There's a lot going on behind the scenes. You'll see us working on buying other resorts throughout the country. And you'll also see us focused on summer development in each one of our resorts to define and plan for recreational activities within the developed recreation area within our resorts.
1:05:36 We have plans soon in front of the Forest Service for the world's biggest zip line from the top of the mountain down to the top of chair one, and then from chair one down to the bottom gondola, four right next to each other. It will be a butt-tightening ride that people will never forget. And it costs about $3 million, and it'll put us on the summer map forever in people's minds. We also have a dedicated kids' adventure center where Woolies is now.
1:06:04 The tube park in the summertime and also a much more enhanced tube park on the 50 acres that we have under permit. These are all soon to go to the Forest Service for approval now that the Forest Service is entertaining development of summer activities after a lot of work on the ski areas part to get the Forest Service talked into considering these things. So those are ways that our strategies and there's a tremendous amount of detail.
1:06:32 Tactical and task all the way down to who does the work and the projects that we're bringing on and how we operate those projects once they are brought on to work on some of these projects. So growing our markets and knowing our guests. We want to increase customer intimacy through technology. We're not starting another tender.
1:06:53 Or Bumble account. This is really getting to know our customers well, developing a relationship with them by understanding their consumption habits, what they want, what they don't want. On an individual case-by-case basis, it requires a rather massive investment in technology and IT staff and personnel. We just opened up a new office in Orange County to help support that.
1:07:16 And if we do it right, you actually won't notice it. It'll work. The only time you notice those kind of platforms is when they don't work and we're relying on them. And we've got a great IT staff that is way ahead of the game on this. We also need to expand our data analytics platform, meaning not just collecting the data, but making sure we understand what it means so that we can really understand what our individual guests want, both winter, summer.
1:07:42 The kind of projects they want us to do for fun in the future. We're in the process in a joint venture of designing and eventually we'll install a fully integrated guest touchpoint data collection system.
1:07:57 Big, massive, vertically integrated point of sale system which collects data at each point of sale and actually every time that you go through a gate and a bunch of other times during the day so we can understand the movement of our guests. All of that stuff comes together so we can have a better relationship with our guests and closer communication with them on a customized basis, not just spamming them with emails hoping that they're going to come to Mammoth the next time it snows. So growing our markets and knowing our guests.
1:08:25 Just here at Mammoth Mountain, this is across our whole platform, the resorts we own now, the resorts that we intend to own in the future. So we want to improve the guest experience. I won't go into great detail about this because it looks like just one simple thing, but it's not. We have a systematic approach to guest service. We don't just leave it to managers being in a good mood. We have a very specific system in which we identify all the key touch points.
1:08:53 With our guests where we create a guest impression. We set standards at those areas that are meant to be managed and complied with by the people in those areas, whether it's employees on the front line, people in our rental shop. We set clear standards to find the success activities required to achieve those standards and then train our people to manage to those standards. We don't get it perfectly every time, but we've invested a significant amount of time and effort to refresh this whole system.
1:09:23 Across all of our resorts. And it's by taking each one of those guest impression points, those touch points, and making sure that the standard is correct and driving higher standards on a week-to-week basis based on our net promoter score surveys, we're able to improve on a continuing basis, and we're very committed to that. So invest in the professional and personal growth of our team. We want to innovate industry-leading wage and benefit programs.
1:09:54 This is very important in a town that's very small. One way to do that is to be able to make sure we can attract and retain employees, but I think it's time to step beyond that, and it's a time to not just say, what are we going to do to prepare ourselves for when the state requires us to pay $15 an hour to our entry-level employees? We need to jump beyond that and say, we need to pay our employees $15 an hour.
1:10:21 So how do we develop a business model that will support that need? Because if we really run all this stuff out and we want to create an economically more stable community, a big part of that is the people in town need to make greater wages. So we need to figure out a way to pay higher wages. We can wait for that to happen, hope it happens, fight that happening so that we have greater profit. What we need to do is actually find a way to do that. The community and the company will be healthier because of it.
1:10:48 So Ron Cohen in particularly is working very hard on that now. We best-in-class professional training and career development programs, these are things that we had in the company before, got stripped out as we went through a period of decline. I mean, remember, in 10 years, we went from 1.6 million visits to 800,000 visits. Think of another company that you know that could literally cut half of their business volume, automotive, Apple.
1:11:17 Anybody else, and all of a sudden, you know, over a relatively short period of time, they have half the business they had before, those companies disappeared. We and the community that we're in are still here, and so we now want to put back in the things that allowed us to grow before, and a big piece of that is...
1:11:35 Best-in-Class Professional Training Career Development Programs for our employees that Ron's working on now. We also want to relaunch Mammoth University, which is a management and leadership program that we had before, and that's coming up this next summer. And then we need to refresh, renovate, and redevelop our resorts infrastructure. We have a lot of old stuff everywhere. Everywhere. Bad plumbing, bad lighting, smelly.
1:12:02 Just saying.
1:12:31 We just closed escrow on buying back the land we used to own at Sierra Star around the golf course, and we're working right now with the hotel developer with the idea of bringing plans back for approval to the planning commission, the town council here in the months to come.
1:12:51 So we wrote a big check the other day, and we believe in the upside not just to talk about it, but actually to invest in it. And so we're starting to do that with the good results that we had financially out of this year. Main Lodge redevelopment is moving forward as well. Canyon Lodge remodel, we've got a $12 million remodel of Canyon Lodge on the books, on mountain restaurants. All that adds together to a $100 million capital investment program, and that's at Mammoth only.
1:13:19 So we've got other big capital programs for our other plan, which of course, our other resorts, which of course rely on us continuing to do well. We know we'll have some ups and downs, but the intention is to continue growing and have some strong years ahead. And then we want to cooperate and lead, but only when necessary, to strengthen our communities. Manifestation of that effort was the Hart-Howerton plan. The Hart-Howerton plan...
1:13:47 It started off really as a small plan for us to sort of inventory where we left off 10 years ago back when we were thinking about expanding, and we couldn't do that for 10 years. Brought Howard Howard in to collect all those old plans, inventory them, help us look at that so that we could look at it through today's lens and figure out what we should do at the main lodge, what we should do at Canyon, what we should do at Eagle, what we should do at Sierra Star. That turned into a larger effort so that
1:14:17 Was one that we thought we'd share with the community. That's not for us to try to direct the community to every step that it takes, but I think it's a lot easier to criticize art than it is to create art. So instead of getting all of us together and collaborating over a blank canvas and figuring out what we're going to put on it, it's a lot easier to say that's a lousy idea. Matter of fact, I think that's the action that council took, right? Somebody said take action.
1:14:43 And Bill Sauser said, I'll take some action. I don't want to move the post office. And then I think John, somebody else said, and I don't want to do that outdoor facility. I don't want to move the RV park. Those may be good ideas. And that's a start, I guess, taking action, which is to say what we're not going to do. And what we need to do is to also go beyond that and then say what we will do. But that was exactly why we...
1:15:10 Brought Hart-Howerton and took it out of the private meetings of the company and shared it with the community so that we could use that as a catalyst to have a dialogue about what we should and shouldn't do, and that's exactly what we intended, and those discussions are starting to happen, and it's a big process, Shields, that's being led here in town.
1:15:29 So that's us trying to participate in that in a constructive way, and it's good to see people talking about it. Main Street revitalization, we think that's very important. We own no land in Main Street, but we've got a lot of things that we'd like to improve around town. One of the big obstacles that we run against is that people say, oh my God, how are you going to do that when your downtown area looks like...
1:15:50 I don't want to be pejorative because it's my community too, but nothing new has been built in 30 years downtown on Main Street or on Old Mammoth Road with the exception, I think, of Schatz, which is a beautiful building. There's been a nice remodel of Footloose and a couple of other places, but if you really think about how old the stuff is and the heart of our community, we have a lot of work to do together to revitalize the heart of Mammoth Lakes.
1:16:20 So Old Mammoth Road, downtown revitalization, the tech initiative. You know, we're very reliant on tourism here. That's a business we're in, so it's good that we're focused on tourism. But we need more than tourism in our community, and we think we have a unique opportunity with the 60-gigabyte Internet speed that we have here that's only in 12 other communities in the country.
1:16:43 And the fact that we live in this magic triangle between the entertainment and biotech communities in Southern California, the software tech communities of Silicon Valley in San Francisco, and the hard tech communities where all the big server farms and Tesla's big factory is in Reno, we're within a five-hour drive, an hour or less flight of...
1:17:04 Two and a half, almost three million tech workers, many of whom are already coming here in Mammoth. And if we can get them to come here and stay an extra day, to come up here and stay five weeks and inspire themselves with a great recreational surrounding and activities that they have here and work on the coding for their companies back home, Snapchat, Google, companies we're talking to, we think we can, may sound a little outlandish, but with a little bit of work, I think we could create, we could attract a thousand jobs.
1:17:34 A thousand tech jobs to Mammoth and people staying longer or people actually moving here and flying to their home offices once in a while instead of the other way around. So that's a big effort of ours. We are about ready to finalize a lease in Paul Rudder's, whatever the mall is. Roger Affis Mall. It shows you how far back I go.
1:17:57 Right over here for a WeWorks-type co-working center that will be the center of this. We've got a pillar of this strategy that's about sponsoring coding and tech classes in our local schools, setting up hackathons and starting an accelerator so that people that have tech jobs can talk to capital providers for startups, and it's an exciting thing that we...
1:18:23 I look forward to working with the community on to develop something other than just tourism here in Mammoth. Air service expansion, local and regional transit support, a big part of strengthening our community. We very much need to attract capital, new capital, new developers and operators to the Mammoth Lakes opportunity, not just those of us that have been around forever here, and workforce housing and planning and support. You saw some manifestation of that tonight in our commitment.
1:18:52 to support Mammoth Lakes Housing and its efforts to strategically plan a future for our housing and the big...
1:19:00 Big challenge that that is. And then the whole notion of Mammoth as a destination resort, bringing the kind of development to town that's required that allows people to be interested in staying for more than just a couple of days on the weekend, but they'll come and stay during the midweek when we've got a lot of excess employment capacity and our infrastructure is not so stretched by coming in by air. So kind of working on filling up the midweek business. So that takes us to
1:19:28 The projection of where we think we can grow. So this is Mammoth and Big Bear, Mammoth Resorts in total, not counting new acquisitions that we're working on. And in the next 10 years, we think we'll be somewhere around, as a company with the existing properties that we have now, 3.1 million visits and out about $175 million in EBITDA and a lot of revenue.
1:19:58 That's our plan. We're sticking to it, and that's my story. So I'd be happy to answer questions. Rusty, thank you very much. Very informative. Great look into Mammoth Mountain and how we're working with the community. So any questions for Rusty? Comments? Come on. Somebody's got to have a comment. I'll make one comment. Glad to see that you're doing something to enhance and help spread the summer visitor by creating more options on the mountain. That is huge.
1:20:31 So that's my comment. Thanks, Bill. And I'll test the zip line for you. Good. You go first. I'll be at the bottom. That sounds pretty cool. And if you survive, I'll give it a try. Okay. There you go. Could you expand a little bit on what's going on with the land exchange and where that stands right now?
1:20:55 Yeah, so as you know, we got final approval from the Obama administration and Congress years ago now. And so now we're working through really the ministerial process with the Forest Service of the land trade. So part of that is to identify the properties that we'll trade for.
1:21:17 Determine the trade parcel and the value of the trade parcel, which is the land underneath the Mammoth Mountain Inn, which also now includes the sewer pond that's up there that the Forest Service wants us to trade for, which brings the acreage up to 30 or so acres. The relative value gets created, and there's a tremendous, John, you would love this, there's tremendous, endless process to this, and it goes on and on and on, and there's public input.
1:21:43 You ought to be leading it, as a matter of fact. I think you must have written a book. Tell me who to call. I'll lead your process for you, Rusty. So we're working on it, and we think, you know, we're probably, you know, Araminta may have a different version of how long this is going to take. We think we're a year away from actually owning the land.
1:22:02 And then the way it works is that the land that we own around Mona Lake and other areas that the Forest Service has identified as land that they would like to go into public hands, that gets traded for the private land. And then we own the private land under the Mammoth Mountain Inn. And then we come to the town and start working on the plans for redevelopment of the properties that we have up there now. Thank you. I think my only comment is this.
1:22:30 It's kind of thrilling to see the work you guys are doing and the integration of all the opportunities and how you're bringing all this stuff together. I want to make sure that as we go forward that the town and the ski area are communicating in a way that we're sharing our efforts. Everybody knows what everybody else is doing. I know I talked with Dan about this, the liaison, some sort of informal or formal.
1:22:58 Thank you.
1:23:16 John, I agree, and we really appreciate the open line of communication that really we have with all council members, and particularly with you and Shields, and that's been very helpful. We had very candid conversations, as you guys know, behind the scenes, and it's great to have it continue here, you know, out in the open with public watching. With that, are there any questions for Rusty from the public? Please, Ken. Yeah, the development of the main launch?
1:23:52 Absolutely. There'll be a lot of opportunity. It'll start with NEPA, with the NEPA analysis that has gone on. Then it'll be again with CEQA that we'll go through when we ask for town entitlements. And because that's kind of the way we do business anyway, we'll be laying out various alternatives for development and planning once we actually own the land. And so we view that as a very public collaborative process. Rusty, I do have a question for you.
1:24:20 You mentioned a couple of times throughout the presentation that, you know, the Mountain feels that workforce housing in town is going to be a significant issue moving forward. You guys in the past have reached into your own pocket, put a pretty significant amount of housing into the community. What's your thought currently about what your caring capacity is for employee housing? Is it something you're looking to expand anytime in the short run, or are you feeling pretty comfortable with where you're at housing-wise?
1:24:50 You know, I think we need to figure out how to, I'm not comfortable where we are, either as a company or as a community. The available rentals, we're losing employees already that have agreed to come to work because they can't find housing. We're employing things like trying to take our employees that already have homes and
1:25:13 Making sure that their couches are full and that we've got places for our people to stay. We own about 700 beds in various special purpose housing that we built in Sierra Valley Estates a number of years ago. A lot of condos that we've bought. We've got apartments. We've bought InterWest's shoot project. And so we have a lot of housing.
1:25:38 And I applaud Kirk's...
1:26:04 Focus on an overall overarching plan as cumbersome as that is. We really do need to have a strategy that we're actually trying to move forward because right now what we're doing is arguing about tactics. Should we do shady rest? Shouldn't we do shady rest? Should we only do new homes? Should they be single-family homes? Should they be four-story apartments? Should they go here? Should they go there? All those things are tactics to a larger plan, which is how many units do we make? What's our thing?
1:26:34 What types of units should we do? How do we finance and resource that? And we've got a lot of work to do in housing. And Mammoth has a history of when opportunity knocks that.
1:26:46 We're in such a big argument that we don't see the opportunity, and that's about ready to happen on the housing side. So we're finally getting people that are interested in coming in from the outside of our community to make investments and to start putting money into the economy here through development, but development of the type that we've already approved and in our general plan and neighborhood district plans. And so people are interested, showing interest in that. And if we can just stop.
1:27:13 Businesses from closing, like McDonald's. I was in New York working on a hotel financing the other day, and they're a few weeks ago, and Shields and John know about this, and I said, oh my God, we can't even keep a McDonald's open in town. We lost Chart House, McDonald's, the Polo Store, an awful lot of lists, and I'm trying to present Mammoth as this just about ready to go off great financial opportunity for, you know, the capitalists in New York.
1:27:40 So we've got a long way to go, but I think a lot of opportunities to do that, and we don't want to be in a big argument about housing, stuck, you know, with our opposite views on how to go forward in housing, because if development is knocking to build stuff we've already approved to get built, there's money that's going to be available for housing from that development. It's important to note that the only time we've ever built any affordable housing in Mammoth is when
1:28:07 Market rate development was also happening because that's where the money comes from that gets stripped off that goes into housing. So it's such a big deal that Kirk is willing to support mixed-use development at Shady Rest to get those 172 units going. And I think it's a critical piece of the revitalization of downtown as well, that location.
1:28:32 I think we're heading in the right direction with some of these changes that have been made, but we have a lot of work to do. So to me, Colin, it's one of the most critical things we have to work on as a community. Thanks. All right. Any other questions? I have one. What's the mandatory retirement age for the mountain? As soon as I leave. That'll be it. I was going to say, you know, I have another year and a half here. I might go on a job.
1:28:55 I know this pays well, but it sounds like you have a pretty good number. Not that well. Just one other observation. I think the work you're doing with technology, I'm not sure where that's at or what that's doing, but I think that the ability to be able to maybe share some data resources back and forth could be very helpful for decision makers across the board. I think with the housing thing, one of the things we're looking at is the effects of the shared economy and the Airbnb, not just on the illegal rentals, but in places where it's legal to do it, but people are converting their long-term units.
1:29:25 They're getting into those kinds of markets. And I think the ability to be able to generate good, reliable data that we can all share that can help inform decision-making would be kind of a big opportunity going forward. That may be something to follow up on down the road. John, I completely agree. And on rudimentary levels, we've, as Dan knows, we provide our occupancy.
1:29:45 ADR numbers and things like that to the town and our skier visit numbers and revenue. We'll continue to do that. And I think as our technology advances, the more we pull our data and knowledge base here in the community, the better decisions we're going to be able to make to attract people in town and provide a greater quality of life to the people that live here on a year-end basis. So you'll count us in for participating in that effort. Okay, good. Thank you. All right. Rusty, thank you. Thank you. Yeah, it was great. Appreciate it. Yeah. Thanks for coming down.
1:30:15 Okay, we'll go on to the... Oh, can you ask for a copy of that? Because I couldn't really see it. Rusty? Ron? Is it possible to get a copy of the presentation Cleland was asking? We just can't see it very well from here, so I would like to see the years and the figures just because I like that. So if you could just email that out, that'd be great. Please don't send it to my big-shot partners in New York that freak out every time I tell them
1:30:47 With that, we'll move on to the next. Is there another public presentation? I don't see Gary around. Oh, he canceled. All right. I missed the email. I've been in meetings. Okay, we'll move on to the consent agenda. Items three, approved minutes of the regular.
1:31:19 of the regular meeting of November 2, 2016. Number four, adopt the resolution amending the local conflict of interest code. And number five, accept payment approval report number 16-16 in the amount of $1,220,735.72. Would anybody like to pull anything on this? Nope. If not, I'll entertain a motion.
1:31:43 Mr. Mayor, I'd be happy to make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 3, 4, and 5. I second it. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0 on all consent agendas. We will now go to public hearings. There's two public hearings today. Number six.
1:32:13 Consideration of an ordinance adopting and amending the 2016 California Building Code standards and consideration of a resolution ratifying the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District's ordinance adopting the 2016 California Fire Code with certain local amendments. Yes. Good evening, Town Council. Tom Perry, building official with the Community Economic Development Department. My item with you tonight basically has two.
1:32:41 Principal parts to it. The first part is the adoption of the 2016 California Building Codes with associated local amendments to our local building code and also to set a date for a public hearing as required by state law for that item and that date would be for December 7, 2016. The other part is also the adoption or your consideration of an adoption for a resolution ratifying the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District's
1:33:08 Adoption of the 2016 California Fire Code with their associated amendments to their local fire code. For that item we have Chief Frank Fivolt is here to answer any questions or provide any clarifications they have for their proposed changes to their ordinance. So specific to the first part for the 2016 California Building Codes, a little background on that, the California Building Standards Commission every three years goes through an adoption process.
1:33:36 To adopt state codes, which are kind of the state legal minimums for buildings and construction, happens every three years.
1:33:44 The local adoption process essentially is really kind of a formality just to make current our local building code and align it with the effective dates of the state codes that do become effective on January 1, 2017. And that again would be the 2016 California Building Standard Codes, known also as Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations. Regardless of local adoption or not, the
1:34:09 State Building Codes do become effective statewide, effective on January 1 of 2017. Tonight's agenda item that you have here is a portion of what we have in Chapter 15, which is our local chapter for buildings and construction. That's Section 1504. And in short, the reason we have just that section being moved forward instead of the rest of Chapter 15 is that 1504 is the one that has our...
1:34:34 The reference to the state codes that we enforce. So if anything, we have to update those dates and change it from 2013 to 2016. And we also do have a few certain local amendments associated with that that we have in 1504 as well. Further modifications, even for the council to know that we do have more modifications.
1:34:55 Of a more substantial nature for the balance of Chapter 15, which is our buildings and construction chapter, those changes would be including changes with lofts that we had talked about before, some changes with design criteria and a few other, actually a number of other edits and changes that through my observation and also talking to the public probably would be a good idea.
1:35:18 To address. But those will be coming before Town Council in the first part of 2017. But for tonight, we're just focusing on the adoption of the 2016 codes in 1504. With the changes that are proposed in 1504, not too many, but worth going over what those changes are. Most of the changes are changing the dates from 2013 to 2016. But I point a couple other changes out here in 1504-030.
1:35:48 I added item number, or item N, which is the inclusion of the 2016 California Fire Code. Basically, there's 11 parts total to title 24, and that part was missing for whatever reasons. It wasn't in our local code before, so I included that in our local code. So that's been included in item N under that subsection.
1:36:12 Section 1504-050, you'll notice that there's some struck out language in red and some other language that was added in red. Basically, the language that you're seeing here struck out in red is language that's straight out of the California Business and Professions Code that allows basically non-engineers, non-licensed architects to do structural design for certain building types. And those provisions that are found in both the building and residential codes are known as conventional light framing provisions.
1:36:41 There's four different building types that non-engineer, non-architects can design, single-family dwellings, multiple dwellings, no more than four units, garages, utility structures, and ag buildings, agriculture buildings. However, both the building and the residential code have limitations of when you can use those conventional light framing provisions.
1:37:05 And among other criteria that those two codes have is a kind of a maximum tolerance of snow load or ground snow load criteria. With the building and residential codes, they basically say that the limits to be able to use conventional light framing are 50 pounds a square foot and 70 pounds per square foot maximum for being able to use these provisions here for conventional light framing.
1:37:30 In Mammoth here, we're well over that. We're at 230 pounds a square foot when we're at 8,500 feet. And above that, we're at 300 pounds a square foot. So we're well in excess of what those maximum tolerances are in the building and residential code to be able to do that. So for alignment, to align our local code with what we have in state law, I removed that section and just kind of made a clarification as to why that is and specific to structural design.
1:38:00 Beyond that, if we move to 1504-070, another slight change in Item D for work that's exempted from a building permit. I struck out the term building code and inserted building standards code, Title 24 of the California Code of Regulations. The reason I did that is that there's a number of work types that are exempted from a permit, and not just the building code, but also in the residential code, electrical code, mechanical, plumbing code.
1:38:28 For clarity, I inserted, I obstruct that term out and inserted building standards code. Beyond that, there's not a whole lot of other changes proposed at this point in time for Section 1504. And with that, I'd like to turn that back over to the Town Council for any questions and comments that you may have. Okay, Tom, thank you very much. Any questions for Tom? Cleland? Never mind.
1:39:03 That's what it does. It's just cleaning up and, yeah, it's a clarification and just kind of aligning what we have with state law. And I don't know how, when or how that got in there, but, you know, when I started reviewing our local code, even before I took the job, I started prepping and studying what we have on the books. That definitely jumped out at me as something that just wasn't consistent with state law. So that's what it is. It's an alignment with our local code with state law.
1:39:32 Tom, I apologize. For us lowly council people, I think this language is difficult to follow sometimes. Yeah, it can be, yeah. Yeah. So I just kind of have a simple philosophical question. You know, I understand the safety aspect of things, and I understand the update of the state codes. Beyond what you mentioned on load, which makes absolute sense here in Mammoth,
1:40:01 Are there any changes that you're proposing that kind of go above and beyond the state required minimums? At this point, no. Nothing here in 1504. Right now what we have, you know, it's in the works, but the rest of the chapter are not that. You know, we're aware of the loft issue. And, you know, there's, as we talked about, there's certain hazards that are definitely out there with some of these out there. So it's...
1:40:28 That's kind of a clarification in trying to come up with something that has code basis but also has a basis of flexibility and also trying to address what we have. But short answer, no. Nothing really in the works that's going to really be prescribing something that's above and beyond the code minimums that we have at this point. Minus the load requirements. Yeah, that, again, if we had control over that, which we don't, but if we did, then, yeah, that wouldn't be there. But I would add, though, that
1:40:56 And just kind of giving a glimpse down the road of what I have in mind and what I did when I was with Mono County, which is something that actually worked very well is that we had kind of the same situation there at the county where a lot of the county you couldn't use this prescriptive, you know, light framing provisions. But we were able to get prescriptive, like, pre-engineered designs for certain building types where we had an engineer or actually an architect at the time do pre-engineered.
1:41:20 Structures like garages and decks and that kind of thing, things that would normally require engineering. We have pre-engineered or what we call prescribed designs and so that could be something that could kind of possibly lighten the blow from what we have with state law with that. So that was something that worked quite well at the county and there's been some interest with the public here in town to get that going too. So that's something that I'd like to do, just kind of looking down the road a little bit with that.
1:41:50 Okay. Thank you. John? Cleland? No, we're on freeze frame again on TV, though. Just FYI. Okay. Let the authorities know. All right. Oh, okay. Okay. Dan, as a matter of procedure, are we going to break this up in two? Yeah, I would appreciate if you would take public comment regarding the building code component.
1:42:26 And setting the hearing on the 7th and take that action separate. And then you can have the discussion on the resolution ratifying the fire code because they are two distinct actions that we'd like to have separate motions and actions on. Good. Thank you. So what I'll do is I'll open it up for public questions. Anybody from the public wishing to address this? Yes, Kathy. Please.
1:42:56 Hi, I'm Kathy Cage. I am a local structural engineer. I've been working here in town since 88 in this field. In terms of the specific code provisions, they're basically administrative. I support making the changes. But I thought it would be a great opportunity to advocate for something else because it's related to the building code. And that's our snow load. As you can see in the documents there, any building designed in this town is designed to 230 pounds per square foot snow load in town and 300 at higher elevations.
1:43:25 Most people don't know where that number came from. I know where that number came from because I worked for the guy who put that together. It was done in 1982. The original work was done in 1982. It started with staff work at Mono County when we were under the county.
1:43:40 The guy at the staff didn't do a super great job, so they brought in Bill Jenkins, who is a Caltech, you know, aerospace kind of guy who was doing structural, only guy doing structural work in the town, and he pretty much put together the whole snow load system that we have in Mono County. And so he divided it up into mountain communities and desert communities, and he used Department of Water and Power snow load data from all throughout the county, and he basically did a data analysis of that, and boom, we have that. But in 1982, Mammoth's design snow load was the exact same as June.
1:44:10 It was 135. When we incorporated and we got a new building official in 88, he convened kind of a meeting of the local design officials, and I don't have any of the records of that, but the result of that was they bumped the number up from 135 to 161.
1:44:25 So what I want to advocate for you guys to do, could you please fund an update of our snow load study? And it shouldn't be hugely expensive, but we haven't had any real data since 82, and as Rusty anecdotally mentioned, we had a lot of drought years in there. And here's why it's important. It's because it so drives the cost of construction up here.
1:44:46 So if I can give you an example, it might help with a frame of reference. If you had a four-story building designed for Southern California, and you tried to bring that up here, you'd have to design it as though you had three stories above it that you had to design for but couldn't use. The rest of it has to be designed for all that weight, for the seismic, for the snow, and all that. And that's how much it is. It's like three stories of building on top of a building that you can't use.
1:45:11 But you have the expense of building to. So if we can drop the snow load in this town, it could have a significant effect on the cost of all the construction in town. I mean, you're talking about all these ways to make development more affordable, and I know your big emphasis on big developers, but what happens if that helps the cost of a garage or, you know, anything else in town?
1:45:33 I don't think it would be super expensive. I can read the text out of the code of what it has to have. It says, you have to use an extreme value statistical analysis of data available in the vicinity of the site using, and then it has a whole probability thing. But it's a 50-year time period.
1:45:50 So we haven't, at the time it was 82 and then 50 years back because DWP has that data. We got like half of that time period we have not updated the data for here. I think there's a really good chance our snow load will drop. The other thing is when Bill did the work, all that was available was DWP snow survey data. Now we could potentially introduce the data that the Forest Service keeps over at the business center.
1:46:14 They've got a data log over there. I know the mountain keeps a data log of snow levels up at Chair 11. So I think it's a great opportunity to do it. You know, I just really, my gut feeling is that the number will drop if we do the data analysis. But it can't be done by staff. You basically have to farm that one out. And my request is that you ask the building official to come back with a proposal for us to consider. So thank you. Thank you. I have other questions for you. Yes. Oh, OK.
1:46:44 So in 82, we started at 135. Then we went to 160. And the basis for that was... I don't know, but I bet I could call Bill and he would tell me. And Byron's still around, I think, over in June Lake. We could probably ask Byron, too. And then, because I've always thought that our current snow load is way beyond me.
1:47:01 I live in a house built in the 40s that isn't even close to 100. I do know because I have copies of the notes that Bill had when he did the study and he kept additional notes. There was a sense that they'd had about three or four years of very high snow loads and some failures in town, which is why Byron convened the meeting because they wanted to evaluate, should we change it? The consensus was at the time, let's change it. So 135 to 160 and then from 160 to 230, all sussed out from basically the same day to know.
1:47:30 A little different. 230 is some technical stuff. 230 is the ground snow load. 230 is equivalent to 160 on a roof. So the numbers we're talking about is 160 on the roof versus what if we go back to 135? That'd be excellent. You know, the data could support that. But the building official can't just change it. We're in something called a site-specific case study area in the building code, and it's prescribed, you know, if you get data to support making the change, you can make the change.
1:48:00 But we've got to do the data reduction. I mean, it's not huge. It's only 50 years worth of stuff, and you only have a hand. There's only one DWP site here, and it's up at Mammoth Pass. I don't know what else you use. Maybe you get some other ones, but it can't be a huge effort. Any other questions for Kathy? Thanks, Kathy. Thanks. Tom. Tom Hodges, VP of Development at Mammoth Mountain. I just wanted to strongly support Kathy's request.
1:48:31 And like she said, you know, even a marginal or, you know, a nominal reduction, say, 15% in those snow loads will make a, you know, could have significant savings in construction costs. And it's, you know, we're probably the most expensive location in the country to build in. And, you know, going back to my recollection of my structure engineering class from Cal Poly, the first thing you do to analyze a structure is you figure out what earthquake zone you're in. We're in the highest earthquake zone.
1:49:00 You figure out what all your loading is. We have the highest loads of anybody in California. And then all these things drive the design of the structure that go all the way through the roof structure, the walls, the foundations. And so the costs are enormous up here, quite literally.
1:49:18 Just having a realistic review of what those loads are, like she says, from an impartial third-party professional who can provide us recommendations, it's certainly warranted, I think, at this point. It's been quite a while since it's been done, and we strongly support that you guys would fund that effort. Thank you, Tom. Thanks. One other important thing to mention, I completely forgot to mention this. Because it's got this 50-year time period you've got to take the data in, one of the nice things is if we do the data analysis now and we get a number,
1:49:49 It is what it is. But in 2020, the 1969 storm falls off the data list. And the way statistics work, it looks at your biggest and your lowest. And those really drive what your mean number is.
1:50:04 The minute that 69 storm falls off, it'll have a huge effect on our numbers. And if we get the data reduction done now and basically have that, and then all we've got to do is add like four more years of data to it in 2020, and we can have another update to the snow load. Okay, thank you. Anybody else? Good evening. My name is Jesse Baldwin. I'm the president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. I'm also a member of the Board of Appeals and Building Advisory Committee.
1:50:42 It's been a little while since I've been here to speak, Town Council, and it is a testament to the open flow of communication that I primarily stepped up here tonight to commend with our building official. There's been a huge outreach on behalf of Tom Perry with the construction community, primarily in the forum of our monthly...
1:51:05 Contractors Association meetings to make sure that we've had opportunities to discuss these changes and proposals within an environment where we currently have over 40 paid members of the Contractors Association, both contractors as well as construction-related companies locally here in the community that all have a vested interest in what these changes represent.
1:51:35 One of the things about these particular, you know, adoption of the state codes is it's almost like there's no real choice in it, but at the same time it is an opportunity to open dialogue about exactly what you asked about, Colin, with reference to is there, are there any amendments or changes, you know, outside of the code, and yes, there, you know, there will be, and we...
1:52:00 We'll be discussing them. We had our Board of Appeals Building Advisory Committee today. We had our monthly Contractors Association meeting last week, and today was the first that I had heard from Kathy about the proposal to reevaluate the snow loading, so I cannot speak on behalf of the Contractors Association with reference to that. I would encourage anyone with ideas like that that want to get the buy-in of the local construction community to...
1:52:29 To approach me or any of our other board members so that we can discuss it as a body, we can on short notice have those discussions via email and then I could come here and speak on the association's behalf. But from my personal professional opinion, anything that we can do to reduce the cost of construction would be highly welcome because even the minimum mandatory state requirements consistently
1:52:56 With each code cycle have grown more and more restrictive and expensive in terms of the cost of construction. My primary expertise is in the electrical field, and I can tell you that each three-year revision to the National Electrical Code introduces more and more areas of the home that have to be covered with arcfall and groundfall, and for commercial applications, more and more lighting controls, and all of these do save money.
1:53:22 On operating costs, and they help the environment and stuff like that, but at the same time, they do increase the cost of construction per square foot. So, like I said, from a personal, professional standpoint, based on, you know, Kathy basically presented the same information at the Board of Appeals Building Advisory Committee, and I was in agreement with it myself. So, again, I cannot stress enough, and we've had this discussion over the years, you know, I've been up here.
1:53:51 Year after year, I think we're coming up on six years now on behalf of the Contractors Association, and I'm on my second four-year term with the Bill of Appeals and Building Advisory Committee, that over the last couple of years, starting with Steve and now with Tom Perry, we've consistently improved the communication between the construction community and the town so that
1:54:19 There's a lot less confrontational surprise things going on here where town council used to be a battleground when I first stepped into this role between the construction community and the town. And it's not that we agree about everything all the time, but at the same time, like I said, we do communicate these things and have the opportunity to discuss them.
1:54:41 Outside of Town Council so that by the time that it does get here most of the time we're on the same page at least. And just real quickly with the changes that Tom Perry said that he's putting together, it was obvious he'd been doing his homework. He gave some expected timelines for when he was going to be able to present that information. And currently the goal is by next.
1:55:06 Month's Contractors Association meeting that we're going to be going over that. Is that correct? Or code changes. Right. Or the changes for Chapter 15. For the amendments in 15. That's the goal. That's the goal. And then what we discussed with Kathy and Tom was having a co-sponsored workshop similar to what the Contractors Association just put on with the town for the Contractor State License Board that was here where we can talk about that with other.
1:55:33 Professionals in the local, like the development community, designers, developers, and then come to council with it so that we've got total community buy-in. Anyhow, thank you, and thank you, Tom. We really appreciate all your efforts. My pleasure. Thank you, Jesse. Any other public comments, questions? Tom, do you want to say anything? Thank you, by the way.
1:56:01 Yeah, my pleasure. Absolutely, yes. So I'll close public comment. With that, I'd like to get your input on what your thoughts are about the snow load. Well, I'm in strong agreement, you know, clearly with what Kathy and what Jesse had said. This is something I wanted to do years ago at the county, but there's a clear lack of resources to do it. Just didn't have...
1:56:32 Especially a few years ago, I think times are substantially a little tighter probably then than they are now at the county level. That would be my estimation. So the resources weren't there to do it then, but I always knew that this data was outdated, and there's a good chance that with new studies the snow load criteria would be reduced, and that does have a very substantial effect on cost. So I think it's definitely a worthwhile thing to pursue, and I definitely do support what Jesse and what Kathy said.
1:57:02 As we bring this forward, we can bring that forward for consideration, either as part of our mid-year budget update and or as part of the budget process shortly after the first of the year starts. Do I have consensus from the council? Take a look at that for a cost element. I'd like just to add one thing to this. I think it's very encouraging to hear that the town and the building community, you guys all talk with each other. Good. We've come away even since last year. I think that I'm very interested in looking.
1:57:30 We've got all this existing stock. We've got to turn this stuff over.
1:58:00 Do rebuild, tear down, build new stuff, reinvest in what we've got. And I think it would be very helpful to convene, and this snow thing is a great place to start, and we could take it as a separate item and just move forward on that. But to do a review of all these codes, wherever we have any kind of discretion, figure out what discretion we've got, and I'd be interested in having a conversation with the council about how we can start talking about some targeted, incentivized actions.
1:58:28 To start to promote and incentivize the turning over of the physical plant that we have here in this town. I mean, it's a pretty ambitious thing to talk about. But I just would want to see this as a one-off thing, as one piece. I think we could do this as a one-track thing and get that moving forward. But we need to have a larger discussion about how we're going to revitalize. I think that's a future discussion for sure. Sure. Just to follow up on that, I think it's a very important thing to do. Okay.
1:58:58 With that, if there's no other questions or discussions for Tom, I'd entertain a motion. I suppose I have a couple of additional comments. I think I am acutely aware of the fact that I don't have the technical expertise to kind of wade through this, so I'm a little uncertain on that front. But my comments are...
1:59:25 Kind of similar along the lines of yours, John. I mean, we were recently shown a stat that was kind of alarming to me that, you know, only 10% of the stock in this community was built in 1989 or newer. So we absolutely have a need to turn over our existing stock. You know, we're also working on a lot of initiatives as a council of trying to remove some impediments to
1:59:53 You know, whether that's large scale development or small scale, you know, single family home development. And, you know, we went through an effort to reduce our fees, you know, the ones that the town controls by a pretty significant margin. So, you know, I'm just concerned about overall cost. You know, we certainly hear that a lot, you know, from constituents and from people from the outside that are looking to build in this community that.
2:00:19 The overall costs associated, some of which we have control over and some of which we don't, are impediments to turning over our existing stock and also building new. So those are kind of my general philosophical concerns that the direction that Council's given is to try and remove some of those obstacles. And I want to make sure that I understand very much that we have certain code requirements that we have to follow. They're really kind of beyond our control.
2:00:47 But I want to kind of look at the things that we're doing maybe above and beyond that and kind of specifically the nexus of those decisions, which I know are all grounded in safety, which is important.
2:00:59 But how that actually ties to increased cost. So I think just overall, you know, we've got kind of two items here, which I think need to be bifurcated. And both of them I have the same general concerns of is are we making things overly restrictive, costly and onerous? And I just at this point, you know, I know we have kind of a deadline of January 1st. I just feel a little bit uncomfortable at this stage.
2:01:24 Without that technical expertise to kind of move forward and make those decisions personally. Well, we've definitely bifurcated. Right. No, and I agree with that. Okay. Yes.
2:01:35 So if I may, the first item, I think if you're referencing the building code, you're actually introducing the ordinance tonight and setting a public hearing and second reading for December 7th. Correct. So you will have another chance to look at the building code elements if you have specific questions or if there's other things you want us to review. So I suppose the question that I'm posing for the council, if I can re-articulate that, is how between now and then, the ratification, can I at least personally feel like I'm on a better footing to make that?
2:02:04 Ultimate determination. But I would suggest if you want some more detailed walkthrough with that, I would set an individual one-on-one meeting with Tom and come in and sit down and walk through that, and he can show you where those differences are. This has been going back for a while for discussions, but as you're looking at modifications to the building code and any of our codes, basically the uniform code set the minimum standards, and you can make certain findings to go over those.
2:02:32 You can't make findings to go below those. So am I saying that correctly? I'm looking at Andy. So it's not like we can say we're going to reduce these restrictions in the code because we can't. Understood. I think your question is have we put local conditions on over and above the code and should we review those and whether or not those findings are legitimate? Is that trying to reframe the question? And I know that they may be warranted in certain cases and I'm not, you know.
2:02:59 Suggesting that that's not the case. I just want to really understand those differences. What I would suggest is feel free to contact Tom directly and set a time where you could come in and spend whatever, an hour or whatever it'll take to kind of walk through some of those. I think he can probably articulate some of the local changes in the why. But the codes we're discussing tonight. This is the building codes. Just the building codes that we're talking about right now.
2:03:27 Minimums, right? Yeah, these are, and they're ministerial in nature, so they're, yeah, they're very ministerial. You do get a little discretion here and there, but we're specifically prescribed. They're kind of the opposite of like the general plan. General plan is very discretionary. It can be discretionary. The building codes are very black and white and ministerial, so that, that's where the challenge is. Okay. And a few things I'd add, you know, for one, to your point, Colin, this is a big concern in the county.
2:03:56 Probably this whole cost of construction and locals trying to build things and all that may have been even a bigger issue in the county than it would be here. So for years, since I took the building official position of the county, it was just creative solution finding, and it's never done. We're always looking for solutions and things we can do to try to lighten the blow, so to speak, with the code. So that's an ongoing process that I'm committed to. That's how I was in the county, and I'm definitely...
2:04:25 Committed to that and here with the town as well for sure. That's good to hear. Thanks. If you guys set up a meeting, if you guys maybe take some notes on what those things are that we're doing things that are above and beyond. It's probably not a whole lot of stuff, but it might be nice to know what those things are that we're going above, what the minimums are. Correct, yes. My comment, I'd love to be a part of that meeting if you do it, but I could be just as satisfied with a piece showing where we are above state.
2:04:54 Mandates. Right, of course. I'd be happy to add another meeting to your schedule. Well, no, I'm more than happy to make that meeting with you and bring that back to Council. Well, no, I think that would be something that would be good to have in writing if we could because I would be interested since it's posed and so I guess you get to start writing, Colin. Yeah. So.
2:05:19 Yeah, let's facilitate kind of a follow-up on that. Yeah, absolutely. I think that'd be a super great conversation to have. And just my philosophy on it, you know, I mean, I really would have to see something pretty severe to go, you know, something really severe occurring in town to where I'd have to, for me, warrant something above and beyond the state minimums in our local code. If it's not there, if there's not clear evidence of that, then it's not substantiated. And so I don't go there. But yeah, I think a meeting to kind of go over this stuff would be,
2:05:49 It'd be a great idea. I'd be into that. And you would also support the idea of kind of maybe looking at reevaluating our snow loads? Oh, yes. That's absolutely yes. I'm behind that all the way. And, you know, a lot of the stuff, you know, like we're talking about the snow study and the prescriptive designs I was telling you about where they're pre-engineered designs that really work quite well in the county. I just, you know, I would add that, you know, there's a monetary cost to that.
2:06:15 Some of this stuff may cost some money, but I think in the end, like the prescribed designs with Monaco County, they really proved to be very useful to the public. So, yeah. Yeah, there's going to be a cost for a consultant, and we need to talk about that. But what's before us right now is municipal code chapter 15.04. Okay. I'm prepared to make a motion, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.
2:06:46 If I want to be clear, though, the bifurcation language, if I, if the recommended motion, agenda item number six, is that the appropriate, or is there a bifurcation within this language? Yeah, if you look at the option analysis, option one report, the point would be waiting to read everything, or that's all the way down until it says.
2:07:09 Public hearing for December 7, 2016 to adopt the ordinance period. That will essentially be the first motion. Yeah, because we're not ratifying. Okay, I gotcha. So it's all the way up to the semicolon. Yes. Right, ordinance. Did this need to be read out loud? I was about to say. Okay, would you please? I will. Thank you. Thanks for asking. My spectacle's on, I'm all ready to go.
2:07:33 So I would move that the Town Council waive the full reading and introduce by title only an ordinance amending Municipal Code Chapter 15.04 to reflect adoption of the 2016 edition of the California Building Standards Codes including the California Building, Plumbing, Mechanical, Electrical, Residential, Fire, Energy, Historical Building, and Green Building Standard Codes and the 2015 edition of the International Property Maintenance Code with certain local amendments, additions, and deletions.
2:08:01 Thank you, John. We have a motion. I'll second. We have a second. Thank you. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. Thank you very much, Tom. Thank you very much. Thanks, Tom. Have a great night. Thank you. Okay. We'll go on to the next part of the public hearing, which is the fire.
2:08:34 Ratification of the... You get to sit down, Hayes. Chief. Members of the Council, Chief Revolta, Mammoth Lakes Fire. We were here at your last meeting, letting you know that we would take our local ordinance to our board, which we did last night. It was adopted 5-0, and we're back here to seek ratification for that code. All right. Any questions for the Chief right now?
2:09:09 Bill? Cleland? John? Good. Helen? Okay. With that, I will open up the public hearing if anybody from the public would like to address the chief. Hearing none, I'll close it, the public hearing. Bring it back for discussion or a motion. I'll go Cleland.
2:09:46 As long as Tom Heller is not up here at the podium yelling about anything, then I'm feeling pretty good about this. So I can go ahead and make a motion right now unless if you would like to continue on the conversation. Yeah, what I'd like to do is go through. You would? It's just not on me? Okay. Then you guys can talk about it. No, I'll come back to you for the motion, though. Okay. John. I just think that the comments made earlier about
2:10:14 What we need to do to turn over our physical plant, keeping public safety, obviously at the foremost of all that. But I think we may get into a situation where if we don't start overturning a lot of non-conforming, unsafe structures, we may get into more trouble than we are currently. But that's kind of a larger philosophical discussion. But other than that, no comments. Bill. The same questions that I had last time that Colin raised with the building.
2:10:41 We are doing some things here above the standard codes, and while I don't have full understanding, are they creating expenses for the building community beyond, you know, his board's already approved it, so I still have those concerns, because there are things in here that are above what the standard codes would be, and I don't have full understanding of those, but that's my only concern. All right. Fair enough. Colin.
2:11:11 Yeah, I kind of share the same concern. I mean, my comments, although I understand they're two separate items, were kind of applied to both. You know, again, I don't feel like I have the technical expertise, but I know we looked at, you know, and I appreciate the way it was presented to us last time. We did have a significant list of things that were above and beyond, some reductions, some additions, and I just...
2:11:37 Don't feel comfortable with my technical expertise on this at this point. And I am concerned about some of the fees being onerous. So, you know, that's kind of where I'm at at this point. All right. For me personally, yeah, fees is a big issue. In light of, you know, we've been trying to lower the diff fees.
2:12:07 And I know we didn't have a big bite at the apple, the last one, and it's here to be ratified. And I just don't understand, maybe to your point, where the fees come from. I know it comes from your board, right? Our developer impact fees? The fees, the diff fees that you're imposing? Yes, the ones that we currently have, they come from the last developer impact fee.
2:12:37 That's where our fees come from. I think that's from 2007, if I remember right.
2:13:07 2004. So that was our, so we're on the last part of that report that was put together by a consultant who specializes in diff fees. Uh-huh. And they went up how much? I mean, I can't remember exactly, but there were a couple of substantial ones and you added hotel, right? At the, yes, that's actually Tom's request. It was to recognize an area that would actually have a lower
2:13:39 Recognize a lower fire threat for that unit type, that housing type. Mm-hmm. And so, Tom, I would like to get your input on this. Sure. Tom Hodges again. So, yes, as Chief Freehold mentioned, I did participate in the review of those fees. The one area that I felt there was some confusion was there wasn't a defined hotel room. There was just units.
2:14:09 And oftentimes as developers look at things, they try to understand, you know, what is the definition of the unit. So is it in the case of, say, the village, for example, you have a condo unit, a two-bedroom, that's a unit, but if you have a pure hotel, it's just a hotel room. You know, my argument to them was that it's not the same, a single hotel room is not the same as a two-bedroom condo unit, and therefore the fee should be
2:14:37 Evaluated on the basis of the hotel room's impact. And they did that in limited commensurate reduction in the fee for a hotel room specifically. So there's an actual category, which the town did as well, by the way, in your revised diff fees, you had a category for hotel rooms as well. Prior to you guys making your last reduction in your diffs,
2:15:00 Yeah, I think the fees are adopted, but those are
2:15:29 Those were accurately reflected what was requested. And they did go back and fully vet the basis of their DIF fees. I went through that pretty laboriously with Tom and I was able to validate that the charges, you know, the things they included in their DIF analysis were legitimate and the values seemed reasonable. They were, you know, based largely on what was...
2:15:57 Proposed previously or what was in place previously with adjustments for inflation or certain circumstances, but they seemed to be reasonable. So I think in the end their fees actually did go up slightly with the exception that they did add the category for hotel room in the case of their divs. And I think they did a pretty reasonable job of reviewing it. But I don't have any comments with respect to the fire code. I did review the
2:16:28 The proposed changes, there were a few things in there that were specific to our jurisdiction. You know, I think most of those were in the case of you guys mentioning that were driven by safety concerns based on specific local concerns that they've had based on some issues that have occurred in the community. So again, it felt like they were reasonable.
2:16:54 You know, I have to go back and open it up and look at the chapter and verse to recall all the specifics, but I remember spending a little bit of time, talked to Tom about it, and felt like it made sense. All right, okay. Thank you, Tom. Thanks, Tom. Yeah, I never had any problem with the new proposed changes in the earnings. The only issue I had was on fees and understanding where they came from, and I know you went out to another party to, you know, make that happen.
2:17:24 You know, we sit up here and we go, okay, we want to try and make development happen in this town. Every time I see a fee go up, I go, whoa, stop. So that's the issue I have. And so I just want to make sure that when we are talking about fees that I understand where the increases are coming from. And if I may, to your point, it's in a public safety best interest to turn over old stock too.
2:17:53 The older buildings have, you know, different characteristics. There's a lot more engineered safety in the newer buildings. And so, you know, I prefer to see some newer stuff, too. You know, you mentioned the recalculation of snow load is an excellent example to try to, you know, match risk to what you have. Unfortunately, in our case, it's the opposite of the snow. It's looking at...
2:18:15 Wildland-Urban Interface. And so one of the areas in the code that we have had to really beef up over the years, and it's commensurate with the changes your Rusty and Sierra Nevada Conservancy discusses, just undeniable changes in the state of the forest. The biggest way I would translate it is that the length of the fire season at this altitude, with all the mortality, just continues to get wider. And so our window of opportunity for catastrophic fire just...
2:18:44 Kind of continues to creep open a little bit. We did, I think, as we mentioned last week, in 2013, I upped the square footage before hitting some cost thresholds by about 500 feet. And this last time, looked at it a little bit differently, inexpensive one-hour fire separations, and we were able to add essentially another 800.
2:19:08 Total square feet to the, you know, before you hit some of those thresholds. And that's based on, you know, some newer technology, newer tactics. So we are trying to respond to those as best we can. One of the things we're doing is we're also trying to keep the cost of our fire service down. The people side is the most expensive. And so we can try to engineer in safety. One, it's a whole lot faster than my best response time. It's already in the building. And the safety systems don't need.
2:19:36 Benefits, pensions, and some of those roll-up costs. So it is a fine balance. I'm interested in seeing new stuff come in because that's a net positive for us. I just have to try to make sure I've got an effective response force, first to prevent and mitigate, and then when we can, then we have to respond to improve the outcome. All right. Tom, do you have anything to add? Just to address the fee issue, the developer impact fee issue, just a little history. The 2004...
2:20:06 Report that we used is the town's report. In 2012, the town updated the developer impact fee evaluation. The consultant that was used, and I think Dan was, it may have been before your time. The reality of it is the consultant said that our fees were right in line with what he felt they should be, and the process that was evaluated was... The 2004 fees were in line. The 2012 re-evaluation... ...of your 2004 fees. ...of the town's...
2:20:35 The process with which was used. He validated that process and validated the method with which was used, and that inflation was probably running at about a percent per year. So we did nothing out of the ordinary from what basically your consultants told us was appropriate. And all we did was take the 2007 fees, updated them in 2012.
2:21:03 Then updated them again in 2016. Actually, 2015. All right. Thank you. Okay. With that, I'll entertain a motion, or Leland, I'm looking at you. Did you guys want to have any conversation before I made a motion on that? I think we'll find out. I'm good. Okay. Well, we'll see how this goes then.
2:21:35 I understand why you're talking about the fees. However, I don't see the fees anywhere in any of the paperwork. So it's my understanding that we're not voting about the fees. This is not built into this. This is just for the safety issues. So I would like to make a motion. Let's see.
2:21:57 Where are we? Ratifying the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District's ordinance adopting the 2016 California Fire Code with certain local amendments. Did I get everything on that? I believe you did. Okay. I'll second. Motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
2:22:26 Thank you. Chief, what I'd like to do also is if I could maybe set up a meeting with you guys, you and Tom, next week just to go over some stuff. Absolutely. And I would, you know, put the same offer out that Tom did. If there's any area of our local ordinance or the fire code in general that any of the council would like to have some time on, and we'll use small words because those are my favorite as well, you know, we'll sit down and go over that with you. And specifically if you want to look at our local ordinance because that's, you know, I think that's what you're interested in. Anything, it's incrementally.
2:22:55 Bumping above and beyond. Excuse me. We should be able to justify that to you. So if you want to set any of those up, certainly make ourselves available to do that. I might piggyback on that. Okay. Appreciate it very much. Thank you. Okay, we'll go on to the next public hearing, which is number seven, adopt the Mammoth Creek gap closure mitigated negative declaration. Hayes. Sorry about that, Frank. I was so excited about my presentation. All right.
2:23:34 Asa Pays, Engineering Manager. So I'm here to request that the Town Council adopt with any modifications the initial study, mitigated negative declaration, response to comments, and the mitigation monitoring and reporting program as presented for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. The project proposes the construction of a Class 1 multi-use path that is designed to connect to the existing mop on the west side of Minaret Road.
2:24:00 The MUP will run east-west, approximately paralleling Old Mammoth Road on the south side of Mammoth Creek and the north side of Old Mammoth Road. The project consists of a 10-foot-wide asphalt path, minor drainage improvements, lighting and activated pedestrian crossing, wayfinding signage, and all of these improvements will be consistent with ADA standards. The project exists in the mobility element.
2:24:27 General bikeway plan, current ped plan, and frankly you'll be hard pressed to find this project in any planning document from the beginning of time at the town. It's been something I've been working on almost my entire career here. The project exists on open space and high density residential. The overall project is about just under an acre in size.
2:24:55 And it's about 1,000 feet long. We're also proposing the reconstruction of the Deborah Diamond Memorial Bridge that's at Mammoth Creek Park and improving that old creosote bridge with a more standard, consistent core 10 steel bridge. As described, the project runs east-west, connecting the existing multi-use paths and closing the gap as shown.
2:25:26 What we're asking is really to adopt the CEQA document here, and the findings that you make today will allow us to move forward with this project. The conclusions, there's really three conclusions that go along with the mitigated NECDEC. You can have findings that are, you know, less than significant impacts the environment, less than significant with incorporation of mitigation measures, or significant findings that are unavoidable.
2:25:57 Impacts are less than significant with incorporation of mitigation measures. The scope of our mitigated NECDEC incorporated all of the above, aesthetics, air quality, biological, cultural, greenhouse gases, noises, and so on. The mitigation and monitoring report will address the four areas of concern, aesthetics, air quality, biological resources, and greenhouse gas emissions. The other...
2:26:24 Items looked at in this negative declaration were of no potential significant impacts. Aesthetics, we are going to mitigate and monitor by making sure that new light sources provide the minimum lighting levels or down shielded, pretty much consistent with existing town standards.
2:26:43 Air quality. Most of the air quality issues are related to construction, making sure that we have a Great Basin Unified Air Quality Control District permit, that we use best management practices for dust abatement and so forth, and that we really just use common sense when moving forward with the construction project. But there are no long-term impacts after construction.
2:27:05 Biological resources are really related to nesting birds, making sure that we are working outside of nesting bird surveys, nesting bird seasons, that we do assessments to make sure that there are no birds in the area during certain times of the year, and if they are found, that we mitigate that appropriately. We also...
2:27:26 During construction, we need to make sure that we are in compliance with stormwater pollution prevention plans, best management practices. We are under one acre, so we're not required to get an NPDES stormwater permit. However, it is practice of the town to implement all the stormwater practices that are usually associated with those types of documents. Greenhouse gas emissions.
2:27:51 There will be a temporary increase in greenhouse gases during construction, but since this is a bicycle and pedestrian project over time, it's actually intended to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. We put the MND out to public comment on September 2nd. It was circulated for 30 days. We sent copies directly to the state clearinghouse, Bishu Paiot Tribe, and the Torres Martinez Desert Cahuilla Indians. I probably butchered that. I'm sorry.
2:28:21 And we're here for the public hearing today. We did receive responses from Department of Fish and Wildlife and Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board. We did receive some additional responses from Caltrans with no comments, and we did not receive any direct comments from any of the tribes that were directly solicited. And with that, that closes my presentation, and I'm available for questions. Thank you very much, Hayes. Thank you. Okay, any questions? Yes, John.
2:28:50 Did you receive any comments from the property owner on the far, the westernmost parcel? We did not. Okay. And what is an APE? Area of Potential Effect. Okay. So that's the corridor of the analysis? That's the, yes, the defined area of potential effect. Okay. So the only thing we're doing tonight is environmental discussions. Okay. Okay. Any other questions? Just straight out environmental.
2:29:20 Just straight out environmental has nothing to do with easements or anything like that. You're right. Okay. Okay. With that, I'll open it up for the public. Anybody wishing to approach and discuss this topic, please do so. Going once, going twice. I'll close public comment. Bring it back for discussion or a motion. A couple quick questions. Is this project on the CIP list currently? Yes.
2:29:53 Is there a funding source for it yet? We have actually had multiple funding sources for this project over the years, dating back to about 2011, we had transportation enhancement funding. That was deprogrammed, and shortly after that, we successfully applied for and received ATP funding.
2:30:15 Just a couple years ago. So we do have money on the table that's ready to be allocated for the construction and plans and specifications. Okay, so will this project come back to Council in any form prior to being constructed? Absolutely. It will. Okay. Just concerns about signage and wayfinding, making sure that it's integration in the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, blah, blah, blah. So I look forward to it. And the next time you bring it back, please, a map. Yeah, I know. I was looking for my, when I was reading through, I didn't, I was looking for my map in here. Thank you.
2:30:45 So you're going to make a motion? I'll make a motion, sure, unless there's any further discussion here. No? Okay, I would move that we adopt, the Town Council adopt the initial mitigated negative declaration response to comments in the mitigation monitoring reporting program for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. Second. Motion second. Roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We'll go on to policy matters.
2:31:19 Item number eight, appeal of a transit occupancy tax and tourism business improvement district fees penalty and interest due from Seasons 4 rentals. Rob. Yes. Thank you, Rob Patterson, Finance Director, Town of Mammoth Lakes. On September 28th of 2016, Town of Mammoth Lakes Revenue Department was working on a request to amend an August 2016 return.
2:31:49 Thank you.
2:32:20 A penalty assessment. Based upon the immediate response and the acknowledgement of the initial penalty, Town Staff believes that Season 4 Rentals was acting in good faith to rectify the situation and would have done so if they were notified on a timely basis by Town Staff, Express Bill Pay Online, Portal, or by their own review. The Town of Mammoth Lakes Revenue Department has made some important changes in the wake of this event.
2:32:49 New procedures reports have been created and run on a monthly basis to identify a circumstance when a return is filed but no payment is received. Previous reports were run to identify when a business does not file their returns but no instances where a return was filed and remained unpaid. We've also reached out to Express Bill Pay Online asking them to enhance their...
2:33:14 Reporting functions, making it more evident when a filed return has been processed but not paid. While the Town's Revenue Team does make some effort to review the returns and has added the additional items that I've noted, it's not the Town's required obligation under the Municipal Code to notify the taxpayer if tax is due. This is the responsibility of the taxpayer.
2:33:41 Staff believes that in the current case, there were circumstances that did lead Season 4 rentals to believe in good faith that the taxes owed had been paid. This is based upon their history of their payment and responsiveness. Staff believes that additional due diligence on the town's part or the taxpayer's part should have noted the unpaid balance within the following month. Based upon the changes that I've noted,
2:34:09 I believe that our staff will recognize that going forward but would not have in the past. Given the circumstances in the current case, staff is recommending Council consider the penalty and interest based upon one month's late payment be the sole penalty and interest in this event. Okay, Rob, thank you very much. Any questions for Rob? Yes. Yeah. You said the history that this behavior has not happened in the past?
2:34:38 I did not say that it hadn't been late before that had occurred. This type of circumstances where a file was placed and not paid, that had never happened in the past, no. And it's also partly based upon the management team's engagement with town staff and committees and such to support our processes and help us. They're very dedicated to that process.
2:35:08 Okay, and so what you're saying is this case actually kind of clarified some things in your department as well? That's correct. Okay. John? I don't have any questions. Bill? No. Colin? Just one question of clarification. It says on the options analysis, staff recommendation, just to make a finding of extenuating circumstances and direct the tax collector to forgive.
2:35:39 Penalty and Interest Beyond One Month. So it's rolled back to one month. I just want to clarify that how the interest and the assessment is determined. So if somebody was 26 days late on a payment versus seven days late on a payment versus one day late on a payment, would that incur the same penalty and interest? Yes, it would.
2:36:07 So one day is the same as 31 days? That's correct. Okay. I thought there was a provision. The provision is that after 30 days, then there would be a secondary penalty that is implemented, which is another 15% penalty, and then the interest would continue to grow on a month-by-month basis, and the interest is only against the outstanding tax amount, so that interest amount does not compound, but it just continues to grow month-by-month.
2:36:37 So let me re-clarify my question. The difference between one and 29 days, there is no difference? Correct. Okay. Do we not have a provision in there that allows for a 1% per day if it's paid within a 15-day window, thereby making the difference if it was one day late versus 30 days late substantially different? If the tax payer had never been late in three years, that takes effect and it's 1% per day?
2:37:08 Penalty with or notified within 15 days. Okay. Is that? Yeah. Okay. Okay, with that, I'll open it up to the public. Anybody that wants to approach? Terry Stellick, I'll speak on my behalf. Seasons for condominium rentals. My husband and I are the sole stockholders of the corporation. We purchased the company in 99. In that time period, I've been late two times.
2:37:46 And I've paid those penalties when I was late because there's that difference right there is I didn't file a return. I didn't do that. I was late. It doesn't matter whether you're one second late or whether you're 29 days late. It is the same penalty for that first 30 days. So I've been in that situation. Unfortunately, this time I
2:38:16 Filed my return. I don't think anybody in their right mind would file a return and not pay that tax knowingly with the heavy penalties that we have. I filed by the express bill pay. So when you file your return, you hit the first button that says file your return. Then you have four more times that you have to push that button to get to that final payment. And then you do receive an email.
2:38:45 Unfortunately, obviously life got in the way. Whatever, I did not pay attention to the fact that email did not come through. I assumed my tax was paid. I entered it into my general ledger and moved on with life. It was March, very busy, was still working shorthanded, but you know what? I have never accepted that as an excuse from myself or anybody else.
2:39:13 I accept the fact that it wasn't paid. It was paid on March 15th. The tax is not due until the 20th of the month. The 20th of the month fell on a Sunday, so it would not be due until the 21st. So I guess while it's not the Town of Mammoth Lakes' responsibility in any ordinance that we have to let me know that my taxes weren't paid, but it is their fiscal responsibility to know that that payment wasn't made.
2:39:42 And then we continually talk about customer service. And, you know, as a lodging community person, customer service is my business. But where's the town's responsibility in that customer service? So I guess where I'm going with that is it did give them three days from the time that I filed, because I filed on a Tuesday. I'm not sure where the checks and balances are.
2:40:07 Within the town, my checks and balances, I have a reservation that comes through, I have a batch that comes through, and I'm checking my batch with what my sales were. Well, this tax return is your sales. That is the town's income, that is your sales. You have a paper document right there. You have an electronic document. I don't know what the reporting is from Express Pay, but I can't imagine that it's only checked on a monthly basis.
2:40:33 And obviously in this case it wasn't even checked on a monthly basis. So is this an odd thing that happens? Probably so, but actually you guys don't even know that. Are there others out there? I suppose there could be, but you have no knowledge of that because you didn't have a process in place for any checks and balances. So my checks and balances would be on my reconciliation. Unfortunately at that point in time there's lots going on. There's income coming in. I don't balance my checkbook.
2:41:02 Balance it in about three months, and I balanced three months at a time. I went through QuickBooks, click, click, click, said, yep, everything's there. I have outstanding, I always have outstanding amounts with my rental checks that are coming through, so I did not pay attention to it. I wouldn't have paid attention to it until my year end when
2:41:22 I would have to put my receivables and payables together. And so when I got to that process, my year end was just October 31st. So I probably have a couple months before I get everything put together to do taxes. I would have noticed it at that point in time. But the only reason the town noticed it is because I did file an amended return. I can go through why I filed amended return. I overpaid the town.
2:41:48 By about $237 the month prior, I'm in the process of changing my reservation systems. One system was paying, it shows everything by arrival and I have to change it to departure. I failed to change it to departure. So when I filed, I had put arrival income and it was an increase by $237. So I filed a return that was amended so that upon audit or anything else, we jive.
2:42:18 Only upon my amended return did the town actually do any research and find out that I even had a pass due balance. When you go in to express bill pay, I paid mine today. I filed my return today to kind of confirm what that process was and everything else. If you go in, you have two different boxes. You have one that says taxes. You have one that says...
2:42:43 Filed taxes. One's not filed, one that's filed. So the only way that I would have known that there was anything then is if I went back into my filed tax file. Don't really have any need to go back in there, so it's not something that I click on. My filed taxes, if I had not filed my tax return, would have shown up in that other box, and it would have said, you have two months that are here that are not filed. But because I filed my return,
2:43:11 It didn't give me any indication that there was anything that was due. So as far as I knew, everything was okay. And obviously, I've worked on the TOT committee for quite a lot of years. We have a great process in tracking down things that haven't been filed. And so once again, this is kind of an extenuating circumstance. So could the town have actually gotten a hold of me if there's proper checks and balances?
2:43:37 I can't imagine that it's only done on a 30-day basis, that you're only looking at that information on a 30-day basis. But, you know, it's not private business, it's government, I don't know. But it is still the town's income. You have a financial fiduciary responsibility to this community. And obviously...
2:43:57 I don't have a history of these things happening that
2:44:26 I truly don't feel that there should be any tax or any penalty that would be charged to me. The town had three days after I filed my return, plus that Monday afterwards, so they had four business days to see that there was a tax return received but no income. So on that customer service, you know, it would have been nice to have somebody that said, hey, you have...
2:44:51 You know, you need to pay this. It's not paid. You used to have somebody in the finance department that gave us emails every single month that said, hey, there's no return filed. File your return. This was many years ago. It's kind of a nice customer service at that point. So the other one is the 15-day. So if somebody has not been late in the last three calendar years, there could be 1% charged.
2:45:20 Until that tax was paid. Now, if I had 1% charged for 6 months, because that's how long it took the town to figure this out, and only because I amended a return, that would have been over the $10,000 that I'm being penalized now. But, if I took 10 days, which would have given you through the first of the next month, it would have been $2,544.30. So, there's a lot of issues that have been daylighted, and like I said, unfortunately, they're at my expense.
2:45:49 I have every faith that the town staff is going to be able to fix those things. I think you have a good team in place. I don't have any doubt about that at all. Unfortunately, this is a really embarrassing situation for me to be in. It is very humiliating, and I feel like I'm being put on up here as a tar and feathering, a public tar and feathering. I mean, it's...
2:46:14 It isn't a good situation. But the only situation as a legal business that I have being in this position is to come up here as a public hearing before council. I will say that the public hearing did not have to be at a council meeting on TV. The public hearing has to be public. But it is at, if you look in the ordinance, it is at the town council's discretion as to where that's, when that's set and where it's set.
2:46:41 You know, and it's kind of timely that now I get to be on TV for our Thanksgiving guests and my owners and my guests. I'm sorry. This is my livelihood. So as I understand that it is completely my responsibility and I take full responsibility. I hope I am never in this position. I guess I can never say never because obviously I'm here now and I would have never said I would be here now. So anyways.
2:47:10 There's also an ordinance that states, so it was stated that it's not the town's responsibility to let me know that I have a tax due. However, there's also part of the ordinance that says that after 60 days, I'm supposed to be notified that this
2:47:33 Tax and penalty is due and that if I don't pay within 15 days that they actually suspend my license and they take my license away. Well, once again, the town didn't even know that that was something that was due so there is a portion of the ordinance that says that I should have been notified and that's at a 60 day. So I appreciate the fact that staff is asking to only look at that 30 days. Well, go back to what Rusty said. We've had 10 years.
2:48:02 Of bad economy. We finally had one good year. $4,100 hurts. $10,000 is not something that I can even remotely even commit to. So, anyways. So, kind of, you know, final comments. I appreciate the staff. I've worked with them for a long time. I think they're quite capable. Unfortunately, there's a lot of things that have been daylighted through this whole process.
2:48:31 I have every faith that they're going to be fixed. I'm going to ask kind of as a closing that you go with option one and go, you know what, there was plenty of time in those days that I filed my return that I could have been notified if there were proper checks and balances in place. Number two, if that wasn't the case and it hit that 30 days, I could have did the 15-day and went with the $2,500.
2:49:01 Anyways, you know, this is something that you guys are going to have to determine. I don't feel I'm asking for anything special because truly the difference is I filed my return. And I filed it electronically, which means you get it instantly. It didn't get put in the bank or in the mail and sent in. It's an instant notification that should have jived with a payment that came through.
2:49:30 The other thing, I don't know that I'm going to be on the TOT committee anymore after today. We'll see how things go. But I will say that after looking and knowing what the process is for somebody that illegally rents or is renting under the table, where they can have a first hearing that is behind closed door with one individual, yet I have extenuating circumstances on mine and the only opportunity that I have is coming up and publicly...
2:49:58 Standing here in front of you, there's some major inequity there. And I would like to, for this town, so our community knows what that transparency is, opposed to having just a report come up from John, because he's the representative on that committee, and say, hey, we had 20 cases, we collected $20,000 in revenue, we collected $11,000 in zoning fines. I would like a report to come up that's
2:50:27 That's split out by case. So you know what the initial charge was, you know what it was agreed upon, you know what's been paid, and you know if they're a first, second, or third offender. Thank you, Terry. Anybody else? Good evening. John Morris, Chairman of the Lodging Association. Before you start, I just want to say congratulations to your volleyball team. Oh, thank you. Appreciate that. Yeah, we had a great season. Appreciate that very much. I just wanted to speak in...
2:51:06 In Terry's defense as the chairman of the Lodging Association, both to her character and also to the process, and I appreciate the fact that Rob has been willing to work with her and that staff is looking through some of these things, but a couple things to note. One, I really feel it's kind of a waste of everybody's time for this particular instance to be taking place at a council meeting. You have a finance director. It should be the...
2:51:30 Within the scope of the finance director's job to be able to sit down in these situations and go through initial negotiations and so forth. And if at that time, in Terry's situation, if she's not satisfied with the result and requests a hearing, okay, well then that's a different situation. But this is one of those situations I think that could have been handled.
2:51:53 Much more simply than this. Second point, as far as the revenue goes, we're talking about 70% of the town's revenue is TOT. So knowing where 70% of your revenue is is probably a pretty good idea. So I think that there definitely need to be some more adaptations to this whole process, submission process and the electronic filing and so forth so that there are more checks and balances. We're obviously all concerned as remitters that when we
2:52:22 Pay our 20, 30, 40, 50 thousand dollars a month, whatever it is, back to the town that we've collected on behalf of our guests, that it's going to the right place at the right time and so forth. So that's obviously very important. I really would just, you know, this can happen to any of us. We all, if you go through the records of who remits, most of us are really good. You know, Terry's missed, what, twice in...
2:52:45 30 years, something like that. So obviously she doesn't have a record or history of being late in these sort of situations. And the other thing is, again, for it to be, I mean, the question, the biggest question, when would the town have noticed that this money was missing if Terry hadn't filed an amended return? So there's obviously a breakdown there of where
2:53:10 Of acknowledging where these, you know, where these monies go at certain times and really after to receive, to get a bill eight months later when you've had zero notification that you've done anything wrong, assuming everything was right with all these penalties and so forth is something that in all of our businesses we would never, ever do to a customer or a client. My homeowners every month, they get a statement. It says clearly you either, I either send them a check.
2:53:40 Or it says very clearly at the bottom of their statement, please remit this amount. And if there's an overdue amount, I contact them personally or they get a reminder or whatever. So that to me is really bad customer service to lump all that and to say, well, you know, here's the rules. It's eight months. That's what you owe.
2:53:57 I won't be long-winded. What I would ask the council to consider is waiving all penalties for Terry, given all the circumstances that have taken place. Clearly, there are some issues. We do have a relatively new system, a filing system, which is great that we have it. Obviously, some things need to get tweaked there. There was nothing done maliciously.
2:54:16 I have sat in this room and watched many people stand up here knowingly illegally rent their property, trying to play it off like they didn't know what the rules were, and I've seen their penalties and interest get dropped down way below what they were originally. So in this situation where you have somebody who's been obviously a great part of our community for many years on many committees trying to help the system get better and has obviously made an admitted mistake, you know,
2:54:45 All I can ask is take everything into consideration and do the right thing. Just, you know, let's learn from the mistakes that were made. Let's fix the system as it is and move on from it. But saddling Terry with Seasons 4, the $10,000 penalty for what was obviously just a mistake is kind of ludicrous. So thanks for your time. Thank you, John. Anybody else? With that, I'll bring it back to Council for deliberation or Leland.
2:55:17 I have a question. Are we allowed to choose an option three? I see option one and option two. Is there an option three that we can make it so there is no penalty or, yeah, Andy, I guess this is a you question? Yes. You can. Yes, we can. So we can just add a little option three there that.
2:55:47 And so money would get refunded in the amount that had been paid. I think this has been a one-off. I think that we are going to get more than our... Returning this money is going to mean that we're not going to have to pay $150,000 to a consultant that's going to come in and show us how to collect our money. I think that we've learned a very important lesson here.
2:56:17 For various reasons, I would like to see an option three on there that there is no penalty and that we just use this as a springboard for better practice in the future. John? So have the systems, the system failures, I'm not using that pejoratively, but just the things that went wrong, have those been identified and corrected? Yes.
2:56:48 So if someone went through this same scenario, filing something but the payment wasn't included, how would the town respond to that situation now as opposed to before? So in the running of that, we did identify there are other instances of this. We have taken everything that's within this current fiscal year and are sending out notices on those now. Anything prior to this fiscal year is really a case-by-case scenario we have to review.
2:57:17 But there are more instances, yes. So when this happens in the future, how long would it take the town to catch it? I mean, is it a 24-hour thing? I mean, if you get something that comes in where you've gotten the paperwork but not the money, what should we all be expecting in terms of how long you can catch something like that? So there are instances today where we have people who do file in advance of paying.
2:57:46 They do the filing in order to make sure they get that process done, and they do the payment the very last minute in order to time value of money or money management situation. So it's not unheard of for a return to be filed and not paid at the same time, but the payment come before the due date of the 20th. My current processes were not going to be to identify that.
2:58:11 On a day-by-day basis and be able to call somebody who had that situation where they'd filed and not paid, but it was really within the month we were going to identify. So it's giving folks a chance. There are a significant amount of returns that come in late and penalties and interest apply and they are paid. So for staff to be calling on all of the either non-remitted or non-filed would be a fairly significant amount of effort.
2:58:41 And how do you, is the, this is all going through the Cassell system? Yes. Do you feel that the Cassell system is optimized to the degree that we can optimize it for these kinds of situations? Well, yes, in this particular situation with online Bill Pay Express, it's automated. So it comes in from that, it files the return in the Cassell system and the payment. So that's a little bit, in my opinion, too automated.
2:59:08 Where it doesn't give us good hands-on, eyes-on. So now we are running reports that will identify, you know, the existence of this in addition to not files and just, you know, tracking that part of it. Okay. All right. Thank you. Bill. I think this was a huge mistake. I think there's blame enough to go around.
2:59:37 However, I would concur with Cleland on, in this particular case, a no penalty assessment. I think this was an honest mistake that probably should have been caught, at very least within the 15 days, which would have changed the amount, or 10 days after the due date, yeah. Okay, within 10 days, but the penalty would have been what then?
3:00:06 Well, actually, it would not have qualified for the 15-day reduction because there was a late payment of a day or something before that in the last three years. Three years. So I think to Colin's point, if it's a second late. They pay penalty. The other clarifying thing is to John's question. So we look at that, as Rob mentioned. Some people do file and don't pay until the 20th. So if we were to check something that next day, we'd be harassing them and saying, when are you going to pay? And they'd say, well, we'll pay.
3:00:35 On the 20th now, obviously, the situation here is different. So if we do run a report like that after the 20th, we run it, who's filed and hasn't paid, that would then say, hey, you owe us a payment, you're late, you didn't pay it by the deadline, because we don't know everybody's business practices. So that's in place, again, a little different than what happened here, but that would be the going forward in terms of catching those types of issues.
3:00:59 I want to add one more to that. It has nothing to do with the payment. This has pointed out several issues that we really need to deal with in how we treat our regular paying business people worse than we treat our law-breaking renters. And I think as a council, there's nothing we can do about this tonight.
3:01:19 But this needs to come back forward and whether or not staff should have some leeway in dealing with this kind of thing. I think most people, had this been daylighted, would have just paid the penalty and moved on without the embarrassment or humiliation of having to come up here through the granite system and tell all the online and TV viewers about it. It's just something I'd...
3:01:45 You know, I've been at the podium many times and I'm very comfortable with it now, but I think most of us realize how hard it is for somebody to get up there and speak. So I would like to see something come back in the future as to how we can change this to make it more equitable without giving the staff overreaching authority to, you know, come to their own conclusions. I think that's a very good point. It's a hugely important piece of this. I think that's a good point, Bill. Colin. You know, I would definitely concur with that.
3:02:16 Last statement, I think, you know, typically the way the process I'm familiar with is appeals come to council. And if there's something that we can update in the code to change that, you know, I think, Rob, you work through this in a very reasonable manner yourself. So I think I'm comfortable with a certain degree of discretion through the staff before it comes to the council. You know, I...
3:02:45 I think point blank this was an honest mistake. You know, how we proceed with this, I'm a little bit torn. I'm not at all interested in option two. You know, I think a $10,000 stacking of payment and interest is just egregious and is not warranted based on the situation.
3:03:12 You know, I'm more in the camp of either option one or waiving penalty, and I'm kind of interested in general counsel consensus on that. I'm trying, you know, I think, very, very much appreciate, Terry, all you do for the community. You know, you're without a doubt one of the most significant contributors to the community. I'm trying to attach no name and face to this decision and just make it.
3:03:39 You know, purely on an objective basis, which is tough to do. Yeah, I'd like to just follow up with that. I think that it's important to do this as objectively as possible, and I think to focus on the lessons learned out of this. So I think that I'm supporting your...
3:03:58 Option number three, with your point of adding something here for a staff discretion thing, we get these things on an appeals basis. I think it's important to emphasize that I don't see anything, I don't see staff doing anything that was unreasonable given the kind of way things are structured. So staff did what they were supposed to do, the party involved in this did what they were supposed to do, and this is kind of how it all shook out.
3:04:26 So I would be supportive of your, as I said, your option number three to refund all the fees and penalties and all the rest of it. Have staff come back with something with a correction to the process so you've got a certain level of discretion so that if something needs to get an appeal comes to us rather than this being the only way to kind of resolve these kinds of things.
3:04:51 I would just say no harm, no foul across the board, and let's get resolved and move on. Take our lessons learned out of it, and let's move on. Can you comment on that? Yeah. May I say something? Thank you. Yeah, very difficult situation. And, you know, it is tough, you know, because a face is with this. And I know what Terry's done for our community.
3:05:23 But I know I've paid penalties in the past. I'm a lawbreaker. But I personally would not accept option two. I think based on the situation, it's not warranted at all. I think option one is the preferable option here.
3:05:51 She has paid it. I'd even waive the, leaving the $363.48 due. I'd say, okay, we're done. Let's move on. It's a hard lesson for all of us, but it's still something that, you know, there are rules on the books, and I thought I've paid before. I didn't. I got the bill.
3:06:20 And I paid. Now, it's not nearly the amount that is here. I wish it was, actually. But I think, you know, we have to stay true to what we are here. Yeah. Do we have to do some better work with our outreach to our community? I think we're starting to do that. But, you know, the fact of the matter wasn't paid. So I would recommend option number one.
3:06:49 But I would do away with the additional penalty due. So that would be my recommendation, but I'll entertain a motion. I make a motion that we add option three, which will make a finding of extenuating circumstances in the case of season four's rentals.
3:07:15 And direct the tax collector to forgive penalty and interest and refund the penalty and interest that has been already taken in and then just... Why don't you just say the amount? Okay, so the $4,179.93. It's actually $3,860.
3:07:45 Where we return the $3,816.45 that's been paid leaving, there's no due left. How would I word that? So that's fine. Okay. A refund in that amount. All right. I have a motion. I would like to add to the motion to add an adjustment to the process.
3:08:14 Yeah, I mean, we can look at some options to work with staff.
3:08:38 We started to do some of that previously. Andy can address a couple issues there if we need to. But this was an appeal to the town council because currently we have no authority to waive the penalty and interest at the staff level. So we have no authority to do that today. We staff. We staff, yeah. So staff could not have just chosen to waive these penalties and interest under the current codes.
3:09:01 That's why it was appealed to Town Council, and this did come to you as an appeal from the... Okay, because the original amount was a little bit larger. Right, and we made a recommendation in the findings of circumstances that we felt comfortable with making, and appropriately so, and Council obviously has the policy discretion to do what your motion on the floor is to do. So, but yeah, we can look at some options. I think you want to be careful of the...
3:09:26 Yeah, I would just establish some thresholds, maybe some things like that. I think that the thing that's troubling for me is that my understanding was that when the incident happened and when it was caught was just so, you know, that's. I don't think we're debating that. Yeah, yeah, I understand. I think we're debating the, if there should be a fee or not. Sure, so I would just add to this motion to bring back some recommendations about how, based on staff's experience, if there's an authority you think would be appropriate to help.
3:09:55 Deal with these things a little bit easier in the future. We're saying bring back how to create a better process. Yes. Thank you. I'm the process guy. Are you comfortable amending your motion as such? Yes. Okay. I have a motion and a second. Can I get a roll call? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I'm going to say no. The motion passes 4 to 1. Move on to the next agenda item, which is number 9.
3:10:32 Accept the donation of real property located at 190 Shadow Street. Nolan. All right. Thank you. The purpose of this item is for Council to consider accepting the donation of vacant property located within the Mammoth Creek Corridor at 190 Shadow Street.
3:10:57 The parcel proposed to be donated is approximately 0.45 acres in size and is contiguous with the approximately 28 acres of open space that the town currently owns within the Mammoth Creek Corridor. The subject property is shown here on the screen outlined in red and the property that the town currently owns is outlined in green. 190 Shadow Street along with the town owned properties are all within the open space stream corridor overlay zone.
3:11:26 Which is intended to protect sensitive stream and drainage courses from development to recognize and preserve these environmentally sensitive areas as a community resource and to protect water quality. As required by state law, the Planning Commission considered the donation at their November meeting and found it consistent with the general plan. Based on this determination,
3:11:55 And the benefit of gaining additional property within the Mammoth Creek Corridor is recommended that the council choose option one and accept the donation and authorize the town manager to sign the grant deed. Thank you, Nolan. Any questions? Bill, I'll start with you. No questions. Colin? None for me. Cleland? Just out of curiosity, why are they going to donate their property? Any idea? They don't want to pay tax. They don't want to pay tax? Okay. I would guess.
3:12:25 Yeah, that is one option or one reason they've looked at developing in the past. It is environmentally sensitive area. It was going to require an EIR, and they chose to not develop it and at this time offered to donate it. Well, basically, it's not developable under the current. Pretty much. You're right. John? There is a long history if you want to hear it, but. No, no. No, thanks. I have no questions. Thank you.
3:12:52 I'd rather not, so that's good. I think that has a consensus. Yeah, yeah. Don't look a gift horse in the mail. You're good? Yep. All right, I'll open up the public for any questions. Hearing none, I'll bring it back to discuss or propose a motion. I'd be happy to make a motion unless anybody has anything to say. Okay. Mr. May I make a motion that...
3:13:21 Council accepts the donation of real property located at 190 Shadow Street, APN 022-252-013-000 from the property owners Mike and Carrie Kenney and authorize the town manager to sign the grant deed. Second. Motion second. Jamie, roll call. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you.
3:13:50 Okay, we'll go on to item number actually 11 on your sheet, which is the feasibility city for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Waste Management Options. Can we get a quick break before we do this? Yeah. Just a quick bathroom break. Okay, we're going to take a three-minute break, you guys. Sorry. I know you've been waiting. It's not like this every Wednesday. Thank you for that break. Yeah, yeah.
3:14:35 Okay, we'll reconvene the meeting and go on to item 11, feasibility study for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Waste Management Options. Who's going to start the... I'll kick it off again real quick. We had a presentation as part of the joint meeting earlier today looking at...
3:14:55 Thank you very much. Thank you.
3:15:21 Move us closer to a zero-waste stream long-term here with the Town of Mammoth Lakes and hopefully a number of the communities around us as well in partnership. So I won't walk through as much detail as earlier, so at this point we turn it over to the EDS team. They can introduce themselves again and walk through the presentation, and then we can address the actions accordingly.
3:15:43 Good evening, everyone. Once again, my name is Annie Haller, and I'm one of the partners and founding members of Environmental Diversion Solutions. We're here tonight to discuss the feasibility study. You'll notice next to where you're sitting, there's a little white box and a little potted plant. Inside the white box are just various samples of compostables that we have on our display board right here. And basically what we're trying to convey is that
3:16:11 One of the problems with the contamination in the waste stream with food waste is separating the food waste from the container. So if we can put the food waste in a compostable container and we can throw it away in the same location, then we're going to eliminate a lot of the contamination issues, which will help keep the recycling material as you go through the commingled recycling building here. It will help keep the contamination out, keep the value in the recycling, and again,
3:16:40 Add more to the organics or all this can go through. In the little potted plant, that's actually a soil amendment that was used with some of the food waste. There's some planted seeds in there so you can take it home and water it and see what grows and try out your compostable materials and your dinnerware and see what you think of it and share. Okay?
3:17:07 Haven't gotten that far yet, but we've thought about it. Okay, well, with that, I'll turn it over to Jim, and he'll explain. Hannah, thank you. Atalanto, as they want to become the marijuana capital of California, we can process their marijuana plants, all their waste, into fertilizer. Okay. As we mentioned earlier, I'm going to go through this at a very top line, not get into a lot of details, because you've heard it before.
3:17:36 Quick review. Our approach is to reduce, recycle, and reuse. The key objectives given to us by Dan on the assignment is particularly addressing the organics problems by AB 1826. There's also sewer sludge and ultimately the green transfer station and the dead and dying trees. We identified a number of issues in the feasibility study. The sewer sludge,
3:18:05 Green waste going to the landfill. Green waste is an advantage. It is not really waste. It is valuable. We want to try and capture as much of that as possible. The grease trap ordinance is one that as a council you can probably address. More even enforcement would be probably the fair way of saying it.
3:18:26 We would like to have in an outreach program increasing efforts to increase recycling, and we have a solution for the slash piles and the dead and dying trees within the town. Three phases. Phase one is just basically organizing the waste stream to separate out organics, to take advantage of their value, and to meet the requirements of AB 1826. Phase two, which can run concurrently.
3:18:54 Would be the identification and implementation of a green transfer station. Phase three is the final step towards moving Mammoth Lakes to being near zero waste going to a landfill, particularly considering the closing of Benton landfill. All of our recommendations can be adjusted to meet the timeline of the closing of the landfill. Most of our technology solutions can be implemented much faster than that.
3:19:22 We can move the timeline to be appropriate. Okay? Waste collection, food waste collection will require separate bins and separate waste collection trucks. And Rick is already aware of that and has equipment that can be rededicated, repurposed to do just that. This is probably a bigger problem being the fog, the grease traps, collecting the fat soils and grease.
3:19:52 It causes a problem for the sewer system, clogging up, maintenance problem, very expensive, and it affects their ability to treat the wastewater in their ponds. Fog collection would require specialized equipment, tanks in each generator, restaurant, or whomever is generating grease, and a specialized truck to collect that waste. Now, the solid waste, what do you do with it?
3:20:19 We're recommending you dehydrate the solid food waste, creating essentially clean water and compost. Looks like this. You all had a chance to smell some of it earlier. We don't have to put you through that again. What can you do with the compost? You can treat your green space. There was a comment earlier tonight about expanding or taking care of some of your brown areas. If there's more recyclable water and some composting, that helps reduce.
3:20:49 Some of the demand for water, you might have an opportunity to improve the appearance of Mammoth Lakes. We're recommending vermicomposting because traditional composting takes a lot of space, and it takes time. It's a very slow process. Vermicomposting is basically using worms to convert the food waste into worm castings, which have very high value in composting.
3:21:17 Sewer sludge in Phase 1 can be reduced by about 80%. The solids, well, the water would qualify as recycled water, but Patrick Hayes has indicated he wants it back into the sewer system to help in their processing. The solid output would currently go to the landfill. Ultimately, it can be, in Phase 3, eliminated completely.
3:21:48 Phase two is the transfer station. We talked about that, what the purposes are. The current transfer station does not have the space to accommodate everything that we're recommending to get to that near zero waste. But in phase one, we can address those issues with Rick's help. We went through the description of the transfer station. One of the key changes is commingled recyclables. That will help.
3:22:16 As Rick is putting in a sorting line that can handle that. Hopefully that will increase the compliance with recycling. Phase three is essentially converting the remainder of the waste through a special process called sublimation where it converts it into a version of natural gas and carbon. Carbon can either be sequestered in the ground or if it's a single source such as
3:22:45 Dead and dying trees, it becomes biochar, which is very valuable. I think, Bill, you were talking about the trees, the dying. We were talking about the dying trees. Worse on the western slope, but it is a problem here. Concerns about fire and so on. We can handle that. We tested some of the dead wood. It has high value for sublimation.
3:23:15 Basically, we looked at a C&D sorting line, which would be in Phase 3. It's near zero waste. This is what the plant would look like. This is an operating plant right now in Denmark. We estimate currently, with a real early estimate, about 30 tons a day of waste that would need to be sublimated, municipal solid waste that would have to be processed. This first, this one plant that's running is running 30 tons a day. In this case, it's biomass, which produces a biochar.
3:23:44 On the right, you can see a version of what the plant would look like. Mike? Real quick, Jim, if you back up to the sublimation plant, one of the questions that came up early was on the emission side of that. I believe the standards that the plants are currently under are already operating at the standards equal to or better than the California standards for air. Plants that are operating right now, for example, are under European EPA requirements, and they're as strict as California on most emission.
3:24:15 Elements might have a little difference on some. The only emission comes from burning the gas that comes off that goes through a gas engine that does produce electricity, but there is a potential for some emissions. Now, CRNR in Southern California is using an anaerobic digestion plant, and the gas that comes out of that, they're using the power of their trucks.
3:24:42 In theory, well, once we know what the value of the gas is coming out, that may be an option to run some of the city vehicles off of it instead of, but we still wouldn't address those options, but we do know it's a very clean system. The actual sublimation is done in an airless chamber. There are no emissions. The heat from the engine is recycled back to help dry the waste, so there are a lot of things to eliminate any of the emission problems.
3:25:11 We have some numbers to go through, but let's see if, Mike, if you want to do the basic conclusion, then we can come back. Well, we, as we said earlier, and as I mentioned, I think Mammoth Lakes is in a wonderful position here to really be a model for adopting these types of programs specifically for small rural communities. And these types of programs, this is where it will work. It will work very, very well. Going forward, you know,
3:25:41 Now we need to talk about what would the city, what would the town council like us to do going forward? What would be the next steps? I think we could identify some low-hanging fruit to kind of get started on some of these things. You know, we've identified a couple of areas in the town where just some basic compaction equipment would be very beneficial to start working on the fog issue.
3:26:06 Which would be very beneficial to the wastewater treatment facility. And as well as collecting, again, some of these resources that have value and doing something with that within the town. Additionally, I think just a timeline of how we want to proceed because we know there's some things that need to be considered in terms of the timing of the closure of the landfill and just how we transition into that.
3:26:36 Period of time where we don't want to be putting things in the landfill down the road, but we don't want to stop it today, you know, basically. So we're looking for some guidance from the town council as to how they would like to proceed, and we were, we'll be back up here. We'd love excuses to come back up to Mammoth, so you just tell us when we need to be back up here and we'll be here. And we want to thank you for that.
3:27:05 Jim, did you have some more specific numbers? I have some specific numbers, Dan, if you'd like to get into some of that to show how we came up with some of the paybacks on the equipment. I happen to have, let me get out of this. Okay. I'm using the sewer treatment plan to show you how we arrived at the payback period. In this case, we looked at, well, Patrick felt that we should provide him with a quote without having specific operating numbers.
3:27:52 We didn't feel that was appropriate, only because my background in private business is you don't just throw something out there. There's got to be a return on your investment that justifies any cost of acquisition of that asset. So in this case, if I can use this as a pointer, I use tipping fee projections, trucking cost, I use about $3 a mile to run the truck, two-hour round trip to take a load out, and they do two loads a day.
3:28:21 Going out to the landfill. The landfill does use the sewer sludge as top cover, but they have to dry it out before they use it. So by drying it before it gets there, they can, at least while they're still able to use it for top cover, it can be used immediately rather than having to wait several weeks or months depending on the weather. Okay? Looked at labor costs. How much does it cost them to have a truck driver going out there and back twice a day?
3:28:50 They're basically shipping water out there because 80% of the weight going out there is pretty much water. Then what we looked at is post-implementation costs. What are they and how did we reduce them? And basically the reduction is in instead of two trucks a day, it's one truck every three days. And it's basically taking dry material rather than wet. That saves them time, money, gives them back some additional water.
3:29:18 They use in their plant. And I put in some maintenance dollars. And let me see if I can get this thing to scroll up. Where is that? Sorry. Where is the? There we go. Okay. Summary of the savings. The net difference. I was looking at incremental costs. How do they save? Looking to save them a couple of hundred thousand dollars per year. The increases going forward, I just used a straight 3%.
3:29:53 Inflation rate, we know that tipping fees can go up more than inflation rate. So the five-year savings, about a million one. And we came in with a payback period. Basically, how many years of savings does it take to pay for the investment? Exclusive of financing, okay? Because in private business, that's what we do. One side, the operation side, proposes a solution. The accountants.
3:30:26 Deal with the rest. And then you set a hurdle rate of, okay, any investments we're going to make has to exceed X percent or we don't even look at it, okay? Small investments are very often a two-year payback. Long-term plant investments, long high level of tooling, new product investments usually have a longer term. In this case, 6.8 years, that's about a 16.5 or 17 percent
3:30:56 Return on investment. So then your borrowing rates would affect that return to some degree. Now, since this plan would come from our supplier in Korea, there is export bank financing, Korean export bank financing. They would coordinate with your bank here or any bank that we can choose to finance probably 75 to 80 percent of the plan. That would apply to
3:31:25 The sewer plant, it would apply to the system that would go in to process the food waste. Does that help? What we're looking for, really, as Mike said, is some guidance from the Council on how you would like to proceed, assuming you do want to proceed. I'm making that little leap into the assumptions here. I'm being a very optimistic person. But we are ready, willing, and able to come and help Mammoth in any way that you deem appropriate.
3:31:55 We do have the proprietary equipment we do have is something we can provide. We are the sole distributor for the equipment, and it is exclusive, and it is the only equipment like it in the world. A couple of intangibles that aren't on this ROI are, of course, wear and tear on the roads and the carbon footprint of the trucks going out twice a day and that kind of thing. So we didn't include that in our ROI, but just wanted to be sure.
3:32:24 We're thinking about that. And we have been talking a lot and working with Rick and that's one of our key values as a company is we're not a waste hauler, we're not a recycler, we're here to facilitate how to move forward. I think it was Fred in the earlier meeting talked about how do you make that first step and that's what we're looking for guidance and with Rick's help and we will
3:32:55 Be able to help in any way you would like us to. Okay, Jim, Mike, and Anna, thank you very much. I think what we need to do is, is there any questions of council, of EDS? Before we bring it to public, Rick, I'm sure you're going to say. I would hope so. I did have a question. Mayor, council members, and staff, my friends call me Ricky.
3:33:26 And it's going to take some creativity to get some of this done. But I do want to speak to it. And I'm not going to go into great length. But what I do feel is that we've gotten to where we are right now in the solid waste and recycling programs through collaboration.
3:33:40 And I think of that as the starting point for this new project. It's going to take a lot of collaboration. We've increased programs and volumes. Some of the recent programs that we've introduced at our transfer station and here in the town of Mammoth Lakes is a paint care program where we partnered with the state. We recently signed a contract with them, and it allows for residents to bring in paint at no charge, and it's disposed of safely and recycled. The other is mattress recycling.
3:34:06 We have shipped over eight 52-foot vans down south to be recycled. Once again, another program that the state has funded, and it's working tremendously. I don't know where all these mattresses came from, but they're showing up at the transfer station, and they are pleasantly surprised that we accept them at no charge. We've extended that to commercial businesses as well, and that's not required through this law. We can charge for them, kind of double dip, but we felt it was appropriate in our...
3:34:34 Small town where we live to offer it free to everybody. On the recycling front, we've seen an increase in volume over the years, thanks and due to the partnership with Brian at Sierra Conservation. I think he's our biggest customer. He brings in the best material. He does a lot of outreach. So what we see is the volumes going up so that we can ship loads out. As you guys see occupancy go up through the summer, we also see recycling go up. I think for the first time,
3:35:03 In my history, and I would say almost any history, we sent six loads of recycling down south, and on each load is about 22 tons, and that was multiple months this summer. We haven't seen that kind of hauling out of this town for recycling material before, so we anticipate.
3:35:21 Collecting more through better outreach and collaboration. We know how hard it was with AB 341 and the mandatory recycling program. It took a lot of outreach, a lot of grassroots labor as part of the town staff, Brian, Mammoth Disposal, working together with the community to provide the information so that we could comply with the law. And now with, you know, the project presented here, AB 1826.
3:35:48 Right now, really loose law. But if we were to look at the past in the commercial recycling, we saw how the state started to enforce it. They got more strict. And now we're talking about 50% diversion. Is that the end? Probably not. They're going to expect the zero waste idea. And then so AB 1826, in 2019, if you're a commercial business and you generate four or more cubic yards of waste, you have to have this type of program for organic.
3:36:17 By 2021, if the state does not feel comfortable with the diversion numbers, if you have two cubic yards of trash or more, you have to have an organic composting program. So, I mean, the writing's on the wall, in my opinion, and I think what I'm feeling here is collaboration, and if we invest in Mammoth, we could probably duplicate this anywhere, but we're in a really good position, I think, to make some steps moving forward. With our landfill closure, it's inevitable. It's going to happen.
3:36:47 So 2023, it's gone, so we're planning ahead, and then we're investing in Mammoth and the surrounding community. You know, when I think of collaboration, I kind of run it through my head, my heart, and kind of my hands, because it takes a lot of work, typically. But this just makes a lot of sense. With the landfill closing and investing in Mammoth, logically, some of the ROI numbers that we're looking at, it's going to take time to research, but it makes sense. Recycle, reduce, and reuse.
3:37:17 Feels good. I like that. It's the right thing to do. But like Brian and I know and we live here and we interact with a lot of customers on a daily basis, it's going to take a lot of work. And so if this could be the first step in us walking towards this long-term goal, I'm excited to improve diversion rates and kind of be a model for California on the east side.
3:37:40 If you talk to Cal Recycle, you know, they would love to see more things happen over here because all they really hear about is big city stuff. And you hear small towns file for exemptions and try to kind of say, well, it's not practical. I think with Dan's help, staff's help, EDS, Brian, this collaborative team coming together, I think it could work. So I'm excited for it, and I hope you guys support moving forward, and I look forward to working further with you.
3:38:09 Thanks. Thanks very much. Any questions for Rick? Anybody else? Yay, Brian's going to talk. Good evening. I'm Brian Robinette, owner of Sierra Conservation Project. You guys have probably seen my face up here a few times in the past. So I operate the recycling collection and bottles and cans and cardboard and paper and that kind of thing. And Rick kind of hit the nail on the head, in my opinion, through
3:38:42 It's been a work in progress and a collaboration, not only through
3:38:47 My organization, Mammoth Disposal, Town of Mammoth Lakes, we've had a lot of support from Cal Recycle in the state in order to get funding for containers, for equipment, for processing. And, you know, in our location, it's not an easy proposition. We have a lot of different challenges here. So I just want to stand up and say that I'm excited to see this new technology and some of these. These are new ideas, and I'm learning and kind of reading.
3:39:17 I feel like I definitely want to learn more.
3:39:30 Become more familiar with some of this newer technology and some of these ideas that have been brought forward. But I do think that, yeah, as an effort, as a community, it's a positive thing and something that I think we should definitely take a serious look at and consideration. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions for Brent? Thank you. Yeah, I'll start off on this. This is a...
3:39:58 This is a problem that, you know, if we don't start addressing, it's going to get bigger and bigger and bigger and cost more and more and more. I like the idea of being innovative. Thank you guys for bringing those solutions before us. I like that. I like the collaboration effort. I think that, you know, we should continue that. And I like the idea of keeping it local, you know. I think, you know,
3:40:26 The different solutions that you're offering, you know, from worms and fertilizer to char and, you know, how we can actually use that in our communities in the eastern Sierra and not have to keep shipping stuff away, which costs a lot of money. I think it's very innovative. I think it's important for us to really consider or looking at this very hard and, you know, with the idea of being a leader.
3:40:55 I think this is something that, you know, we should take seriously, and hopefully we'll have consensus to go in the right direction. So with that, I'd like to hear from my other council members. Bill, I'll start with you. You don't. I did, and I faked you out there. So wait a minute. Cold's killing me. You know, I've met the Korean people who...
3:41:26 Make the equipment. This is cutting-edge technology. It's exciting. I would like to move it forward. However, I also like a cautious point in what is the buy-in, what is the next step, and can we afford to go there? Do I want to go there? Absolutely. We would be foolish not to.
3:41:44 We've got laws. I've gone and read the state's laws and what the proposals are, and 50% is only the starting point of where they want to get to. 70% is what they call out in the 75 in the original legislation. So this is going to happen. We have to get there. We're closing the landfill. But for me to make a decision, I can't make any decision. I don't know what the starting point is. I don't have that technical expertise. It's in the audience here.
3:42:14 And I don't know what the initial buy-in, how fast you can pay it back doesn't mean anything if you can't afford the initial down payment, the initial payments. So I need to see that to be able to really move forward. But to continue where we're going to develop this and bring the county in, because this really needs to be a regional discussion. It's not just about Mammoth. Our tax dollars go to support the county as well.
3:42:41 In a very large way. So they need to be complete partners in this. But I would love to see us, you know, start the next step of moving this forward. What we're being asked to do today actually is look at the different sites available and allocate funds coming out of the trash account. So it's not coming out of reserves. I want to make that clear so everybody understands that. I'm not spending reserves again.
3:43:11 To complete the feasibility review of the site locations and get a site to start moving this to, which is going to be necessary regardless, because no matter what sort of sort or MRF we end up with, the current site is not adequate. Correct. So, and I am in favor of taking that and moving those dollars forward. Whatever it takes us to move forward with EDS, I don't see a specific number here, but I would love to continue moving down that road as well.
3:43:41 Okay, Bill, thank you. Colin? Yeah, three general thoughts. You know, the first is to take a step back and look at the strategic priorities that our council laid out. And one of them was to address a regional waste solution. So I think this is very much an important exercise that we're going through. We're continuing to kind of push that ball down the road.
3:44:05 And I think it's an important priority for our community. So I'm excited that we've got some solutions in front of us. I understand as a rural community that we are currently exempt. I'm not particularly interested in exemptions. I think we actually have a larger responsibility as a gateway community. We are at the doorstep of hundreds of millions of acres of national forests.
3:44:35 I understand there's economies of scale that exist in large cities, but I think we actually have a larger environmental responsibility to not skirt those laws and exemptions and to be a leader in this area. You know, I appreciate laying out some financials, some capital costs, some ROIs, some recouping of those costs.
3:45:00 Coming from my seat in the private sector, 17% ROI and a 6.36-year return on investment is a little bit on the light side, but I don't have a very good comp for this scenario. That actually seems to me to be fairly reasonable for what we're talking about. So maybe if I could just get a little...
3:45:22 Frame to reference that against. But out of the gate, I think a 17% ROI seems fairly reasonable for me for this scenario.
3:45:32 And, you know, I have had an opportunity, you know, myself, Bill, and Cleland went down to the League of Cities. We got to see some of this technology in action. And I'm not a trash guru like Rick or Brian, but I was pretty impressed personally. So I think it is cutting-edge technology and something that I'm excited that we're engaging with. So I'd like to continue to push this forward personally. Okay. Thanks, Colin. 17% on waste return versus, you know,
3:46:02 Skis? I don't know. It's a tough reference point for me, yeah. Okay. Cleveland? No, I just had a question for Mike. Trash gas, is that something that seriously could be in our affordable future? You're referring to the gas that comes off that sublimation? Yeah, Mike, if you'd speak to the microphone, please. Thank you.
3:46:32 When we're talking about the sublimation process, we're actually talking about using two, what we call feedstock, two forms of feedstock. One is the MSW, the municipal solid waste that is left after we've pulled everything we can out of it. After we've pulled all the recyclables, we've pulled the organics out. So what are we talking about? We're talking about, you know, some wood and some cloth and some, you know, cardboard and whatever we just, what was left over.
3:47:01 That has a dubious caloric value. It's an unknown, and it's inconsistent. So the main thing we want to do with that is reduce it, and we put it through the sublimator, it zaps it, turns it into charcoal, and we get some sort of gas off of that. We won't know the quality of that gas until we actually have tested the material. On the other hand, on the deadened...
3:47:31 And other green waste, that has a very high caloric value. We've already tested it. We've sent the test results down to the manufacturer. They got back and said, yeah, that's great stuff. And that's where we're getting this value of that, what is not charcoal, but actually biochar. And biochar has significant value in the composting world and soil amendments and even some other uses.
3:47:58 Because that has a much higher caloric value and it's a consistent one, we know what it's going to come out at, then we can rely on that gas actually being able to produce electricity. If our trees keep dying, then we'll have enough gas, but if they don't... The easements, they have to be trimmed and so on and so forth. I mean, it seems like there's a pretty significant supply.
3:48:26 Okay. I just didn't know if that was a pipe dream or not to ever have that. It's not. Now, there, and I was having a conversation with somebody earlier today. I can't remember who. There have been, and I actually got into this business through this technology, and I was told of all these wonderful things that this sublimation process could do, and a lot of it turned out to not be accurate. In other words, we can make, we can put things through.
3:48:54 Trash through this process and make biodiesel. Someday, but it's not here now. So right now what we have is the ability to take organic-based waste, you know, when you pull all the recyclables and the glass, the plastics, the metals, you know, everything out of it. You take what's left, we can turn it into, we can reduce it into a char without burning it, without incineration. But we can take the other green waste.
3:49:22 Where we can identify the caloric value of that, and we can turn it into biochar and a synthetic gas. It's not great stuff. It's not going to run a turbine, but it's going to run an engine that will, you know, a low RPM piston engine that will generate electricity. Okay, and those numbers are included in this? On the? Jim, on the sublimation. On the sublimation, in the report, we use the green waste.
3:49:52 Because until we know what's the content of the MSW, and we can test that, what we'll do is we'll accumulate some of it, a couple palletfuls of it, and we can actually do an analysis of the MSW and get a good idea of what the value of the gas is and how much carbon will come out of it. The analysis in the report was based on the forest waste. Should we...
3:50:14 Collect the dead and dying trees, and that analysis was based on paying $80 a ton for the waste coming out of the forest into the sublimation plant. All we have to do to that basically is grind it up, get it into chunks that are 35 millimeters or less, and run it through the system. Might have to be dried a little bit, but that's all. Yeah, but we did take forest waste from Mammoth. Yes.
3:50:38 Within the last few months and ran it through the test to get the caloric value. So we know what we're dealing with on the forest waste. So the analysis on the forest waste showed a payback period of under five years. And economies of scale. I did one on a small quantity versus a big quantity. The small quantity is still penciled out as I think it was about 14 or 15 years. But if you go up to larger quantities, which 50 to 100 tons per day.
3:51:07 It comes out to be less than five years. Go bigger than that, and there's probably enough dead trees, and when they trim and clear the lines for the power lines and stuff, there's slash waste. We can take care of all of that. The return improves because there's some fixed costs involved in operating the plant. All right, John. Yeah, I want to echo the support of all my fellow council members, I think everybody in this community about.
3:51:37 The importance of going in this direction. But I'm compelled to ask some pretty tough and pretty specific questions. The first thing is that this council has not made a commitment to being a zero-waste community. And I think that's an assumption that you should not take for granted. I think that, well, it's a serious thing. I mean, what were...
3:52:03 You know, you should know this. We're in a community right now that take it to a transfer station, it goes into a landfill. That's how primitive this has been. We've had these folks, Brian and Waste Management, working to try to bring some level of sophistication to what we're doing, but this is a pretty primitive situation up here. So I think that I'm going to look to council, sorry, to staff a little bit. We need to get a process here.
3:52:30 To establish some community buy-in to this because the cost of what we're talking about doing in an extremely expensive community to live in cannot be underestimated. This is the kind of thing that I don't feel comfortable going forward with unless we have real buy-in from the community that this is what we want to do.
3:52:50 This is ambitious. It's very forward-looking, and I applaud it, and I want to be a part of it. But this is not something that I think that we can do without the community saying we're willing to bear the costs and modify the necessary kinds of social behavior that's going to be necessary to make this thing work. And until I'm hearing it from out here, I'm not willing to sit up here and say, oh, yeah, we should just start going down this road. A couple other points.
3:53:19 Biomass. I was at the Great Basin meeting that went on all day. We heard from folks, CAL FIRE, from folks all over the state. Nobody in the state can figure out what to do with these trees. And so the biomass, the viability of biomass and hearing any kind of return on if we get these fuels, personally, I'm not buying that. So that's...
3:53:40 One area that we've got to talk about. There's been research in this region about looking at biomass plants that did not pencil, that did not work. And I sat in on many of those studies, so that's an area I've got concerned about. A lot of the data in the feasibility study is not passing a smell test for me. It's reading a little bit as an advocacy document, which is fine. I'm an advocate. I know what that's like. This data needs to be independently verified by...
3:54:05 Folks with expertise in this region who could look at these numbers and the assumptions, to me, they're feeling optimistic. They're feeling maybe it could work kind of stuff. That's got to be looked at. That's got to be verified. I'm concerned about proprietary technology, and I'm concerned about dealing with folks who say, we have the exclusive path to this stuff. Well, if you build complex, cunning-edge, innovative systems with technologies that are proprietary and owned by other sources, that's concerning.
3:54:34 And I think that before we start making an investment going down a road like that, to all of a sudden say, well, gee, this didn't work and what's plan B and there isn't a plan B, that's of concern. The supply chains, the same kinds of issues. Korean technology, overseas technology, fine, okay, but this is adding to the risk factor of investing in these things.
3:54:59 And I think the issues of the comps, to Colin's point about I would very much want to see peer resort, peer communities that invested in this technology and really understand how this really works. And I think we can't underestimate what it means to work in this area. All of us, I've been here 16 years, I mean, we've come from other places. You cannot have
3:55:24 False expectations of how easy it is to work in a place like this. It's not easy. And when it's not easy, the costs for doing everything are just sitting there, waiting to stack up, and we can't afford to get into a situation like that. And I think it really, you know, the key players in this are going to be the generators of the waste. The businesses, the hotels, the restaurants, we need their buy-in because they're going to be the leaders to make this thing successful.
3:55:53 And until we have heard from them, we've engaged with them, we get a sense of what they're willing to take on. That's all going to get passed on to customers. It's all going to get passed on to people that live here. I have a tough time trying to find a lunch for less than 20 bucks in this town. I think we need to start, you know. I'm going to side doors. Shields has told me where to go. But he's the minority on this one.
3:56:16 This is extremely important, and I'm not saying this to throw any cold water out there, but this is stuff we have to take very seriously, and we cannot screw around with this stuff. So thank you very much. I appreciate all the information, and I'm looking forward to figuring out how to move forward appropriately, not get ahead of ourselves, not get ahead of our constituents, not get ahead of the community, because that will doom this. John, great points.
3:56:45 What I hear is you don't want to be on the bleeding edge. No, I want to be on the right edge. You want to be on the right edge, but, you know, we have to do some studies. There's no question about it. We have to say, okay, does this make sense or doesn't it make sense? Sure. And I don't think we're agreeing to do anything right now except maybe the $60,000, which is something I think we have to do anyway. But, you know, I like the innovation.
3:57:15 I like the methodology of what we're talking about. I like the idea, again, of keeping it local when we're closing this plant. Boy, I think there's some real issues that we've got to get a hold of real quickly, and we're going to have to start making decisions. Yeah, so I would suggest that rather...
3:57:36 Even with the $60,000 with the Forest Service, it makes sense, but I don't know that we know what kind of physical footprint we actually need. And so I would ask staff, what if this thing doesn't work?
3:57:48 What are we spending? You know, we need to, to your point, we need to start very methodically identifying what we've got to, where we're going. I think the question is, does this community want to make a commitment with its dollars to becoming a zero-waste community? That may be a good place to start with, to look at what the costs are involved in doing this, then we can start making some decisions. But I'm going to look to staff a little bit to start figuring out, okay, what is the decision tree we need to start going through to get us to the point to start making the commitments we need to make?
3:58:16 I can address a portion of that. A while back, if you remember, the county actually did a fairly expensive engineering study looking at where do we go with waste. And they came in with a few different alternatives, most of those focused on whether you have a Mammoth-only or a regional transfer station. Basically, you would have a modified clean MRF, you would have a large concrete floor that's enclosed that you would then load all your trash into.
3:58:46 Everything left over that you couldn't pull out of a kind of a MRF component, load it into a truck, if you will, and long haul it, most likely to Lockwood, Nevada, if not south, and I forget the name of the site. And there was kind of like a very limited, and that's a viable option. It's expensive. MRFs are not, or the transfer station of that nature are not inexpensive. To do it regionally, the current sites we have would not.
3:59:14 The original proposal, I think, that was in the franchise agreement sitting there today has us spending about $4 million plus in land costs at the time, plus building out a transfer station. So it's a very expensive program with, I will say, limited opportunities in terms of how to deal with waste. You would be looking at a very traditional system. They're done all over the state. They're not that unique.
3:59:42 South Lake Tahoe runs one. Truckee has a component one. Other places, some of them are open and most of those are now trying to figure out how do they close them and get them inside a building to stop stuff blowing around and odors and those types of elements. Again, very traditional approach. You would be looking somewhere between 8 to 15 acres, assuming if you want to do any recycling of rock and debris of that nature. If you want to have a sorting line for C and D, that's a whole other.
4:00:12 Program you add in. If you want to do true green waste management of that and actually collect it and process it versus hauling it, which you can do, I mean, so those are very traditional type elements. We have a county-funded report that looks at a lot of that already. That was kind of the starting point when we started to look at options for Mammoth.
4:00:34 Let me just interrupt you for one second. So if the question here about the $60,000, if that's going to real estate that's not going to preclude other opportunities, then let's move forward with that.
4:00:49 I think we all agree. Okay, so we can do that. But the question about establishing the buy-in of this community to going, we need to have a community conversation about that. I think it's more than just the community. I think it's the region. Of course. Right. But we need to figure out how to do that. We need to figure out how to do that. However, it would appear that regardless whether the
4:01:12 Town buys into sorting it all at the house or whether we end up with our starting product being a dirty Murph rather than a clean Murph. The state legislature is going to make that decision for us. That's the real issue. So a lot of what you're talking about, if we go with a different system than this, the size and scope, a lot of what those traditional systems have, this system has to have as well. You have to have the sort station.
4:01:41 Because not everybody is going to sort out everything, especially the little individual homeowner or the guest that comes up and stays in a condo. So in terms of the footprint of the land we need, I don't know if it's 15 acres, in my mind it was more 7 to 10 acres, but these guys are the experts. That footprint remains the same, so the Forest Service piece remains the same.
4:02:03 Regardless, there's not enough room for it, even if we buy the wood lot, which the town tried to do years ago. I don't believe to make that happen at the site at the industrial park. I'm just thinking a little bit in the interest of time, because we've got to be at it at 1030. From my perspective, I'm prepared to move forward with the $60,000 with this Forest Service piece, with an addition to the motion to have staff come back to the council with a specific plan to...
4:02:31 Have this conversation with the community, given the state mandates, all that. This is where we're going to start getting, you know, to assess and create community buy-in if it's there to go down a road that looks something like this. John, I agree with you. And I would go further than that. I would ask that we come back with a report showing what the cost of traditional would be for us versus the cost of this.
4:02:57 And what the lifetime of each of those things are. Sure. Because cost is generated long-term by what the expectant life cycle, and we haven't asked those questions yet. So the numbers for that analysis has got to come from staff. Regional staff, it can't come from a consultant providing. No, no. Okay, so let's look at how we're going to motion this. Because what I hear consensus on is accepting the $60,000 report.
4:03:24 Portion. Also, number one, except the feasibility report is prepared by EDS. Except the report, sure. But number two is we have to modify that a little bit. And I would just, let's just bring that back as a separate item based on what you've heard, what staff's heard here this evening. So I think the direction that we want to give, though, is that
4:03:56 You know, we want to do an analysis or have staff, town and county staff, to do an analysis of a traditional waste system versus what's proposed here and then start the community conversation. That would be fun. Mayor Richardson, could I address some of the things that John brought up? And very good points, John. And actually, we've run down some of these paths and run into some of the things that you brought up exactly.
4:04:24 With the proprietary technology, keep in mind this is just simply dehydration equipment. There are two companies out there right now that are operating here that are doing dehydration, and there's more, but I'm just going to give you two examples. There's a company called EcoVim. They deal with food waste. That's what they do. They dehydrate it. Their units are smaller, and they get the dehydration down in about the 20% range. We do the same thing. We just get it down below 10%.
4:04:53 There's another company out there that does food waste called Hungry Giant. They get it down below 10%, but it takes them 18 to 24 hours to do it. We do it in eight. So in terms of our proprietary system here, it's just an enhancement of stuff that's being used daily out there. It's used commonly in the agricultural industry, and it's being used in the food services business. So it's not that.
4:05:21 Newfangled, brand new, like I said earlier, it's practical, it's proven, it's being done every day. These guys just simply came up with an enhancement. On the sublimation technology, which is dealing with the forest waste and creating the biochar, that's been out there for years and years and years. It's being used in Europe. We're talking to a provider that comes out of Denmark, but Lockheed Martin is working on this. So this is...
4:05:48 It's out there, and we can provide that information. Yeah, it's not bleeding-edge technology. Exactly. I agree. Okay. With that, I'd like to make a motion, Mr. Mayor, if I could. I would move that the Council accept the feasibility report prepared by Environmental Diversion Solutions, that town and county staff return to the Town Council with recommendations for next steps and analysis of traditional
4:06:18 I have a motion. Second that. I have a motion. Second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes.
4:06:47 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Guys, thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thanks for your patience. Okay. We'll go on to item number 10. Pardon me. Yeah, 10. And we'll let Mr. Souser recuse himself. Yeah. And if we just make for the record that Bill is recusing himself because he has his primary residence within a limited distance from the Shady Rest site. So he'll be recusing himself on this item.
4:07:21 I can't carry my plant and my trash all at the same time. Are you going to plant that? Because if you're not, I will. No, I'm going to put water on. Well, I'm not. I'm going to give it to my wife and say, here, do this. Okay, there you go. All right. Are we going to make it through this? Item number 10, which will be our last. We have not a lot of time, but the guiding principles for Shady Rest Development Negotiations. Who is going to be presenting this?
4:07:56 Andy, can we get some clarification on that time frame? Jamie and I looked this up. A long time ago, the council adopted it. It was a resolution, I think. Establishing 1030 is a hard cutoff for meetings. So the council could at some point abandon that resolution, but for now, that's what we have. What's the practical consequence if you go past 1030? There isn't one. Let's see how we do. If I can kick it off.
4:08:28 Mr. Mayor, this sentence came before you after following up from previous discussions in the meeting with Mammoth Lakes Housing. It came back up through their last meeting and some discussions, then some other outreach with Councilmember Wentworth and Fernie in terms of with MLH and looking at some alternatives. And also, we've done initial outreach to the property owner, who is very interested, again, in working with the town on...
4:08:55 A project that moves forward meeting their interest and the town's interest. Also, just this evening, kind of new information coming in individually from Kirk Stapp and from Rusty Gregory. What the goal on this one was is we wanted to have a dialogue and discussion with the property owner and look at an option that we could bring forward to the town that would do the things outlined in the staff report. We understand the shady rest parcel was initially through a land exchange.
4:09:22 Designed to create workforce housing. I was looking at 200 units back in 89 or back in the 80s. In 89, the council adopted a overlay that was placed on this property that really restricted it to workforce housing from an affordability standpoint relatively at the lower end of that affordability structure and then also looking at community amenities that would be in there.
4:09:48 That is restated in the general plan, part of the statement, this is a deliverable in-town neighborhood for the workforce. It doesn't necessarily call it out as the percentage of AMI and those elements in the general plan. It also identifies a number of characteristics in the general plan that this neighborhood should encompass. So that's kind of those guiding documents looking at what should go on the property.
4:10:13 The other issue was if we actually want to go forward with an affordable housing project on this site, it is going to require participation from the owner in terms of site control, that they will agree for us going after affordability in terms of grants, whether that cap and trade or CDBG or other types of grants that can be utilized on the project, again, state, federal, et cetera, that we can look at.
4:10:39 Initial discussions with them, leaving everything in place as is with 120% or 80% of median income on the whole property, that's probably a non-starter for the owner. They're looking at, yes, we still want to, and this is the last bullet point here, we want to, at the minimum, we want to meet that 120 units of affordable, I'll say capital A affordable housing, the 52 units of the moderate income housing that's identified in some of the planning work.
4:11:08 But also, how do we extend that out and get a much stronger housing product on the site? Basically, going to the earlier discussion this evening, looking at that to say, here's the affordable minimums we want to meet. How do we get other moderate housing in there? How do you start to work toward, I believe it was John's comment at the last meeting, that missing middle group? Is there a piece of that that goes in here? And there's a range, I think, of housing opportunities that could be created into the site.
4:11:36 And the property owner has indicated their willingness to work with the town in this process to say, yeah, what makes sense for us and what meets those base community needs. So I think we have a general direction out of those discussions that I think makes sense, and obviously that was enhanced this evening with the comments we heard in public comment as we can move through that. So we also attached the report to the action sheet, if you will, that was on the...
4:12:04 19th joint meeting. It outlines a lot of the history in the background. The shady rest also included the cap and trade analysis again that Mammoth Lakes Housing had worked on as an option in terms of development on the site. We believe there's a great opportunity here for a win-win-win process. We end up with affordable housing. We end up with some moderate housing. We end up with more of a workforce, a little more diversification in that housing at different levels.
4:12:34 We believe the overlay still works as a tool to help us incentivize local workforce and to the extent that we can get owner-occupants or local area people. And the rental component is a positive aspect of that and being able to work through those things. So these were kind of the guiding principles, came out of other discussions that we believe we can go back to the property owner with and say, given this and given the other discussion earlier,
4:13:02 How do we start to put a framework together? We'd end up coming back to council. Here's kind of that negotiating framework, whether that's a development agreement, a specific plan process. We'll need to nail what's the best tool is for implementation. But I think we need to come back and say, okay, here's kind of the deal points that we can agree on to move it forward to achieve these various goals. And so this was an attempt to kind of give that structure for that discussion with the property owner. Okay, great.
4:13:31 Dan, thank you very much. Any questions for Dan? Good? John? Don? One question. I know you kind of briefly touched on the fact that if, in fact, some sort of affordable housing overlay was on the property, regardless of what the AMI is, the intent of that would be to kind of steer that more towards local ownership.
4:14:03 Do we have any other tools at our disposal, assuming that we're utilizing public dollars on the site, to actually be more restrictive in that sense? I'll defer to Andy if he has some comments on it. I think it gets hard to say you can only rent or buy this house if you live in the community. That starts to run into some, or if you work in the community, those become difficult. If you own the land, you maybe have some additional controls and releases or something, but...
4:14:32 Telling somebody they must live in town to rent a home and I work in June Lake, but I can't. I think that's where you start to run some challenges. I think there's some things we can do. It would be difficult to impose that unilaterally on the developer, on the landowner, but if it's part of a bargained for agreement, whether it's a development agreement or we give them some other incentives or something, I think we can bargain for that. And there's some pieces. Something I'm actually looking at right now in my other job, about how to structure local only programs.
4:15:02 You have another job? I live in the closed session room. Okay. I'd be interested in a little more development on that conversation. A lot of us want to target how do we get our local workforce in there and then not just people that work in Mammoth Lakes, but if you work for the county, you work in June Lake, you work in Crowley, whatever, how do we really build that community identity here? Yeah, I think if we get to a developer agreement,
4:15:32 Any other questions right now? Any public comments? Yes. Hi, I'm Kathy Cage. I get this sense that I'm coming a little late to the table with this thought, but...
4:15:54 I can't always come to all those meetings. I can't always come to the housing meetings. I couldn't come to the joint workshop before. I know that a lot of the reason you're considering this is because you have a particular property owner right now who's interested in doing things, and they've trial ballooned a lot of ideas out there.
4:16:11 But my input to you as council is I'd like to encourage you to kind of step back and take a bigger picture on the affordable housing, in particular on that max 172 units provision that's in that master plan, the strategic plan. I think it's an incredible missed opportunity to have that as a ceiling.
4:16:30 We've approved all these projects all over town, Demetriatus, right there, super dense and high. We've got the stuff in the village. You know, we just did this downtown plan with that new density calculation thing. Really super dense. I mean, my husband's got property on Main Street. He came back and says, oh my gosh, this property's way more valuable now. We can get super dense there. I think Shady Rest, you should be considering
4:16:57 More on there. More, you know, more units, higher density. I mean, really like a downtown housing thing. I mean, no one thinks anything of that in downtown San Francisco or downtown LA. I know we're not that. We couldn't be that. But InterWest basically proved kind of up here that you can do four-story development in wood framing, and it's reasonably affordable. It really is.
4:17:20 I've got to tell you, I'm profoundly disappointed with this site plan. This is a basic Southern California, low-density, you know, cul-de-sac kind of a plan or like a condo plan. It is incredible wasted opportunity. I feel like once these other big projects happen, and they'll happen at some point, and when they do, they'll go to those high densities, we'll look at this spot and say,
4:17:42 God, what a missed opportunity. Why didn't we go high density there? And, you know, maybe if you use eminent domain, you do pick up some lots on Center Street to do parking so that that can help the downtown and this higher density housing. And I really just want to advocate for those low and very low folks. You know, I think when they were doing the site planning, I asked Jennifer, what percentage of the people that live in our affordable housing are Hispanic? Was it like 75%?
4:18:12 Over 50. Over 50. Okay. So it's a very high percentage. How many of them do you see out here? How many of you typically see at any of our meetings? I'm super active out at the Catholic Church, and we've got a new Spanish priest out there, and he's gotten this, the Spanish community is incredibly active, and I've really gotten to know more intimately the families and the dynamics and how that works. And this development plan you've got here is so, like, not relevant to Hispanic folks, you know, just at all, really.
4:18:39 People that are very low and low income, you know, they're working for 11 bucks an hour. You know, what's that yearly income? They're really not that picky. You know, they just need a place. They need a studio. They're happy with a studio. You can put that kind of development here where you can't put it anywhere else. Where else in this town are you going to place that?
4:18:57 You can't put high-density residential local housing anywhere else except there because it's proximate to that. It's got multifamily on one side. It's going to have this high-density downtown on the other. And you do have this oddity where you've got single families. So maybe you put some border of single-family, moderate income there. But the center part, at the core of it,
4:19:17 So that's my big thing. Please consider
4:19:46 You know, opening your minds a little bit to potentially having higher density on shady rests so the projects were pencil, whether it's done by our housing department or a private developer. So that's it. Thank you. Thank you, Kathy. I think it is being considered. Thank you. Anybody else? Jennifer? Good evening again, Jennifer Halfordy.
4:20:24 I think, you know, to Kathy's point, density is important. I think we have to balance that with livability. The projects that she cited, such as the village and Demetriatus, are not owner-occupied or even renter-occupied.
4:20:45 They're kind of similar to what we're grappling with with our existing housing stock as far as livability and the lack thereof. And so does that pencil and does that work for full-time residents? I think that needs to be looked at prior to jumping with two feet into four-story development.
4:21:06 Some of those units on that site plan that Kathy was referencing do go to three-story with tuck-under parking. But regardless, I didn't want to talk about specifics on the site. I really just wanted to talk about the site and the zoning and the history. So I prepared a little something that I'd like to just share with you. So as you know, Mammoth Lakes Housing is focused on the community's workforce housing and affordable housing for the workforce.
4:21:35 We at Mammoth Lakes Housing want to commend the town for wanting to address the need for workforce housing, but we also want to encourage you to preserve the city rest for affordable workforce housing.
4:21:49 That site is unlike any other site in town. We have no other site in town with that overlay zone. It's unique. And it can't be looked at as a single site without looking at the total town land availability. It has to be looked at within the context of the history and the current policies and future needs.
4:22:17 We know today that we have a need for 264 units. We know that number is growing due to the impact of the nightly rental market and the growing economy as well.
4:22:31 Plus, we know from the EPS study, which was commissioned by the town and used in the Hart-Howerton plan, that there's a projection for future need of up to or even more than 600 units. So we know the need today. We know we have a sense of where the need will be in the future due to these studies commissioned by the town.
4:22:54 You know, at the October 19th meeting, I presented data on and maps on the availability of land and the availability of capital for affordable housing on existing housing stock.
4:23:11 And those were limited opportunities there. So I think that's important to bear in mind as we go forward looking at this site. I also want to just touch upon, and I think you know this from the staff report, but just highlight, you know, that the trails subdivision, that land was traded for affordable housing. The community decided that wasn't the right place. Then they went over to this site, and now it's still vacant.
4:23:38 And the homes haven't been built. Initially they were going to be required, but then the town waived that requirement and just doing the overlay zone was sufficient at that time. And then in 1996 there was a referendum that went out to the community to actually reduce the density and that was not supported. The community supported maintaining the zoning and the master plan densities that we still have in the master plan today.
4:24:12 And we did do a comprehensive analysis of developing the site, and that is including your packet looking at the cap-and-trade funding sources along with tax credits and other affordable housing tools, capital tools available. And the project did pencil at the density of about 19 units per acre. And still, we felt like it was livable. It brought other amenities to the table, such as a bike pump park.
4:24:41 All these multi-use paths throughout the site. So to say that it's not viable as it is, it's just a matter of the land owners cooperating and wanting to see that through. Lastly, I want to talk just a little bit about sacrifices that...
4:25:04 Affordable housing has made in the town. So housing receives 50% of the 2002A political commitment, while all the other political commitments receive 90% of that funding approved by the voters in 2002. Inclusionary housing has helped produce a bulk of the housing, as Rusty mentioned earlier.
4:25:27 But it wasn't done just with the development that triggered inclusionary. It was a partnership. We partnered and we went out and we got cap and trade because those weren't available then, but tax credits, bonds, home funds, CDBG, all of these things to leverage and grow. But we don't have inclusionary now. And mitigation fees have been reduced. So I don't think that we can...
4:25:53 Afford as a community to take any more concessions on affordable housing. I think that's why we're at this place where we are today where we don't have enough for our workforce and people are turning down jobs, leaving the area.
4:26:07 So I appreciate your willingness to negotiate with the investors of the Shady Rust site. I encourage you to preserve the history to ensure the future success of our community. And I want to close with a quote from Winston Churchill. The longer you can look back, the further you can look forward. Thanks. Thank you, Jennifer. It's 1030, but I think we should... We're not going to make it.
4:26:36 We're not going to make 10 things. I'd just like to make, Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a point of order if I could. I think that I would like to continue with this item because there are timing issues having to do with the availability of cap and trade funds with a June application. So if it's okay with the consensus of the council, I'd like to continue this item until I'm done. I mean, right now? Yeah. I agree. Okay. Everybody? Yeah. Absolutely. All right. We have consensus.
4:27:06 Good evening, Council. Bill Taylor, Mammoth Lakes resident. As I think most of you know, I've got a very long history with this property. I worked on the original land exchange for the trails, for the Mammoth Creek Park West property, so I know intimately the history of how we got to where we are. But this isn't about history. It's important to understand how we got here.
4:27:36 This really is about where we're going. And as Jennifer pointed out, we're pretty comfortable from the data that we have. We have a current need, and this is permanent resident households, something in the vicinity of 250 units. And I'd argue it's actually more than that because those projections were made in the depths of the recession. And obviously our workforce demand has gone up since then.
4:28:07 When we look forward, the EPS report that was cited by Hart-Howerton, they show a need going forward, if you assume the same level of development as Hart-Howerton, they show a future need of about 600 units of workforce housing in addition to what we have now. And if you add on some of the other discussions we've had, such as
4:28:37 The discussion that I support fully of exploiting the benefits of digital 395 to expand our economic base. A thousand digital 395 jobs are going to be another 500 workforce units at least. So we're in a hole right now. You look at the available land and how it's zoned. The prior councils have dug you guys a hole. And what I worry about is
4:29:08 We can look forward. We can see we're in a deep hole. And I think we need to be very cautious about digging it deeper, taking part of shady rest, converting it to commercial or other employee generating uses. We'll somewhat do that. To Kathy Cage's point about density, the property is designated as high density residential.
4:29:39 The gross density on the property is 300 units. With density bonuses, arguably you could take that to 600. You don't need to change the general plan. You don't need to change the basic zoning. All you need to do is amend the workforce housing overlay master plan that was adopted for this project. And so I do think it's worth negotiating, or not even negotiating, but it's worth the town understanding what it can do with the property.
4:30:09 I also think it's very important to maintain the current zoning and general plan because right now you have a problem and you don't really have other options. With that, thank you very much. Thank you, Bill. Thanks, Bill. Any questions for Bill or, I'm sorry, or Jennifer? Well, I'm just a little confused why we're talking about this right now. Not at 10.35 at night, but just in general because
4:30:40 It seemed that we had a shift earlier today with Kirk Stapp and with Rusty talking, and some of the concerns that I just personally have about the shady rest parcel is, number one, if we do increase the density, it's like, how is that going to work with homeowner fees? Are these people that move into these places going to also have to pay homeowners, or is this one of the things that we're going to pass off as that?
4:31:05 Oh, if we give them a place to live, they'll keep it clean, kind of like we say if we build them a skateboard, they'll police themselves and wear helmets. I'm looking at the long term. I can see why the density is going to need to be needed, but we're going to need housing forever and ever and ever. That's never going to end because as more we grow, the more employees we need, that's going to be the never-ending until we just cap out and we cannot even squeeze one other person.
4:31:34 The owner or the representative of the property is not here. Why are we talking about things that we really don't have any control over? Well, we'll answer that in a minute. Well, it's just like it's going to go on and on and on, but if the guy's not here saying, okay. Let me just say this. In the discussions with Mammoth Lakes Housing, we encountered a very particular problem.
4:31:56 With housing, which is you get weedy, you get technical really quick, and it doesn't get you to where you want to get to. So this document, which was Colin and I worked on with members of MLH, which was reviewed by the MLH board, is intended to be very high level and to set the framework for these conversations with the town and the developer's representative. So I would encourage us all to look at the individual points, however you would like to do it, Mr. Mayor, and just keep it on this high level. There's been plenty of time to talk about all kinds of technical details as we go forward.
4:32:25 But I would encourage us to take these things, these five points on. Any other direction we want to provide to the town to have these conversations, let's get the conversation started and let's start moving forward. There's going to be plenty of time and opportunity to get into the technical details of what something might look like on the property. Colin, do you have any? I've got a lot, but it seems like Cleland still has something to say. Well, you're acting like we own the land and we don't.
4:32:58 And I can see where you're talking about talking with him, but these are, why are we even spending time talking about it? Staff can just find out the answers to these questions and come back to us. I think what the outreach is is to counsel, okay, based on, wait a minute, based on this document. And to John's point, I think what we need to do is go through this and, number one, reaffirm the honor and spirit of the
4:33:28 The original intent of the land exchange with the United States Forest Service in the 80s. Do we reaffirm that? Do we understand the history of this as a council, where it's coming from? I've read through the paperwork, but it's not my property to say, oh, I mean. I'm not asking if it's your property. What I'm asking is.
4:33:53 I want you to understand, I want our council to understand, do we know the history behind this whole thing? There was a land exchange that was set up for what it was set up for. Well, if they're going to follow the original, then it negates the whole ownership of who owns the land. That's not true. I mean, and again, I would, I would, the point of this is to give direction for the town, its representatives to have the conversation with the property owner. We are in discussions with the property owner.
4:34:21 Okay. No, I realize that. And nothing has been put in concrete, but, you know, we've talked about different ways that this property could be used. And so, but what we want to do right now is affirm, or reaffirm, if you will, our knowledge about where this whole thing began and how it got to where it is right now so that we can
4:34:48 Be informed as we make agreements with the, hopefully developer agreements, with the owners, the current owners, to move this forward. That's kind of where I'm sitting right now. And I think that the owners of the property are willing to move forward on certain aspects. I think, you know, everybody's kind of sitting on either side of the fence here going, okay, there has to be an affordable housing.
4:35:19 It has to be at least 172 units. I think most people agree with that. I don't see an issue with that. I don't think the owner of the property sees an issue with that. He's saying it can't be just that because it should be more than that. And that's what Rusty and Kirk talked about. They want to look at a holistic deal, which is great. They want to look at our whole community. But on this particular property, okay,
4:35:47 There are other elements that fit into it. One is affordable housing. One is the revitalization of downtown and what part that property plays in it. We're talking about amenities, town amenities. We're talking about potential workforce housing. We're talking about potential market rate housing.
4:36:08 What is it supposed to look like and where can it fit into our overall plan where it's a win-win-win to Dan's point for everybody, for the owner of the property, for affordable housing, for the town, for the revitalization of downtown? Okay, can we fit all this in? And, you know, Kathy makes a great point. We need that density to do that.
4:36:32 Okay. If you underpark that area, that will be a travesty. I'm sorry, what did you say if you want to what? If you underpark that area, parking space, that area. No, I'm not saying, again, clearly, but we're not, we don't want to jump ahead to these things about parking and technical details. But you already have because you're taking. No, actually, if you look at this, if you look at what's in here. I have. I've read this thing over and over and over again. I know the history. So, Mr. Mayor, I'm just going to ask if we could just.
4:37:02 Address one question at a time and maybe get a consensus one question at a time and move through it. Okay, why don't we do that? I think that's a very good point, John. One, let's reaffirm and honor the spirit and intent of the original land exchange as executed with the United States Forest Service in the 1980s and the related zoning designations that previous councils have assigned to the parcel to provide affordable workforce housing. I'm willing to reaffirm that.
4:37:28 So a couple comments, and I can address that specifically. So, you know, John is our current representative on housing. I sat on the board prior to that. You know, we've had a chance to talk about some of this, to develop this. We also had an opportunity to sit with members of the housing board, which was very helpful and illuminating. I feel like I have a pretty good understanding at this point of the history.
4:37:54 If you really take a step back and look at intending to honor the spirit and intent of the original land exchange, that spirit and intent was to develop a workforce housing neighborhood on that parcel. The number at the time was 200 units. That certainly can change with bonus densities, et cetera.
4:38:19 But that was the original spirit and intent. I think it's important for us to kind of just walk through kind of the restrictions on the property. First of all, we have general plan. General plan essentially dictates 12 units an acre. We have zoning on the site, which basically just doubles down on that same density, 12 units an acre. We have the third kind of overlay on top of that, which is the affordable housing.
4:38:46 And also you can't forget the district plan. So we've got a lot of things that are kind of in play here, but I think bullet number one is a more high-level bullet saying the
4:39:14 Spirit and intent of the original land exchange was to provide workforce housing for the community on that site. So if the question is, do I reaffirm that, the answer is yes. I believe that we would be doing the community a disservice if we did not address some of our housing needs on that site. I would concur with that. I think, you know, Cleland, do you agree with that?
4:39:44 We're moving the discussion forward with the owner, correct? This is what staff is going to go back and do. So it's not me or it's not as a town council to reaffirm and honor the spirit. That would be something that I would ask. I would ask.
4:40:12 Mark Carney, that question. Is that something that they're willing to reaffirm? Because it doesn't matter if I agree or disagree with this. Well, I think what we're trying to do is put some parameters in place for this discussion. If they want to come to the Council and say, we want to change the spirit and intent of the original land exchange, and therefore we want to put, you know,
4:40:34 A hotel on the site. I'm not, just because I know that there's language in there that people have piecemealed so much that, so I'm just going to say no on number one. I don't want to reaffirm. All right, we don't have consensus on that. Number two, affirm the affordable housing overlay adopted March 22, 1989, a zoning tool to be used to achieve a mix of workforce housing and supportive community amenities.
4:41:05 I'm okay with that. I would say I think that's kind of more headed in the direction that we're trying to do is make it more useful. Except for the child care portion. I'm cognizant of your request, fellow council member, to keep this high level. I'm going to have to jump into a couple of weeds here and there. I think
4:41:31 As a general philosophical point, I am not particularly interested, especially if we are going to be sinking public dollars into this site potentially, to facilitate second home ownership. So I think that an affordable housing overlay on the site is a tool to encourage, maybe not restrict, but to more encourage local ownership and to address some needs that we have.
4:42:01 So in general, yes, I am in support of keeping an affordable housing overlay on the site. However, I'm not sure, you know, the current affordable housing overlay is the entire 25 acres at 120 AMI and below. Is that what we are being asked to reaffirm? That's not what I'm affirming, and that's not what this says. No, I would disagree. I think it's what we're being asked to affirm.
4:42:32 Just what it says. Affirm that the affordable housing overlay adopted March 22, 1999 is the zoning tool to be used to achieve a mix of workforce housing and supportive community amenities. Correct, but the affordable housing overlay that was adopted on March 22, 1989 has a ceiling of 120 AMI. It's a tool. I... No, no, it's... Okay, it says... Is it a tool or the tool? It says the... Well...
4:43:02 Well, it's that specifically that affordable housing overlay that was adopted in 1989 has a ceiling of 120. I want to be careful of what I'm being asked to affirm here. Well, it is what the language says. This, as adopted in 1989, this is the zoning tool that is currently in existence. I think the intent with this is to confirm to the community.
4:43:30 I mean, if council wants to start changing the zoning, we can start doing that. But I think this is what's currently on the books, and I think this is about putting a framework together for the representatives of the town to enter into conversations and dialogue and negotiation with the property owner. I think we need to go into this saying, this is where we're starting from. This is what's on the books, and this is where we're at.
4:44:00 Achieve the goals of the original intent of the land exchange, the affordable housing needs. There's language in here in four and five we get to later that I think, number five especially, is the county's desire to strive to meet or exceed the affordable workforce housing unit, which gets to Kathy's point. But I think this is just really about making sure that we're all on the same page of reaffirming what is currently on the books.
4:44:28 As the baseline for the conversations. If I'm not articulating myself well, I apologize, so I'm going to try again. If I'm being asked to say, do I want to look at an affordable housing overlay of some sort as a tool for this site, I'm comfortable with that. If I'm being asked to say, am I affirming the affordable housing overlay that was adopted in 1989, that is a different question.
4:44:56 Well, then I think that if the council wants to start dismembering what is adopted policy that's been on the books for, I can't even do the math, 16 plus 11, 27 years. Right. Then the council's got to say, okay, we're going to stop this whole thing and we need to go back and we need to start ripping all this stuff apart and reconstructing the zoning we'd like to have. The statement is only intended.
4:45:25 For the benefit of the community to understand that we are affirming past council actions. If we want to change it, we can change it. But that's a whole different deal. And I personally don't see any advantage in reopening those things up at this point. I think it's in the interest of the housing questions to affirm these things as they are in the books.
4:45:53 To go into the conversations, we're having conversations with the landowner with the interest of trying to find a way to make this thing work because we do not own the property. John, you and I have spent a lot of time talking about this. Right now we are talking past each other. If item two is affirmed, you are saying that there will not be a single unit on this site that is more than 1% over 120 AMI.
4:46:22 That's not my interpretation. That is how that reads. Okay, I'm not reading it that way. I'm reading it that this is a tool. That what I'm saying is that we would go into negotiations with the landowner saying that we are affirming that this is in existence, that we don't have any issues with this. I don't know what's going to happen in these negotiations. I don't know what's going to happen in the conversations. But I think I...
4:46:48 This is a, we could change it from the tool to a tool, but I think it's important. That's precisely what I'm saying. I'm saying the wording would be affirm that an affordable housing overlay is a zoning tool that we want to use to achieve a mix of workforce housing and supportive community amenities on this site. That is a very different statement than the way it's worded. So you're just changing it from the to a, correct? Correct. Okay, I'm fine with that. And I'm taking out.
4:47:17 That specific language of March 22, 1989. No, I can't do that. I think because, again, it's like this is what I've heard from the housing board specifically, and we reviewed this with the housing board. Then that's fine. So we have a difference of agreement. I am not in support of item two then. Okay. Okay, we don't have consensus on item two. Well, but I'm only one person, so if we have three to one, that's okay. No, I'm going no as well, so. Okay, we don't have consensus. Okay.
4:47:48 Well, okay, then we can't go forward. Yeah, we can go forward. No, because I think we can't go into the negotiation. If we're saying we can't just look at something that's on the books, that's adopted.
4:48:01 And say, we're not going to, we don't think it has any standing. That's a recipe for chaos. It's a recipe for enormous division in the community. Because what we're saying is, we don't support something that is on the books, and yet we're not willing to come up with the alternative. What we should do is to say, we don't support this thing, we should relitigate it, and we should come up with an alternative to it, and we should tell the community that we want to take this housing overlay off the property.
4:48:30 I'm not saying that there shouldn't be an affordable housing overlay on the property. We can't go into negotiations with someone and be saying that what we have on the books, we're not going to enforce, we're not going to say that it doesn't have any merit. Guys, I think to your point and your point, we're talking around each other. You're throwing out these dates and what have you as, you know, like they're
4:48:59 They're stuck in concrete or something like that. The reality is we've had a lot of different changes on that property. There's been the general plan. There's been the downtown neighborhood district plan. There's all these different plans kind of floating around. They all include affordable housing. And I think what we're saying is, yeah, we go along with...
4:49:24 You know, the history of why that property happened, the exchange. Yes, affordable housing is a key component of this property going forward. Yes, 172 units makes a lot of sense, but does it make sense to have the whole 25 acres be just 172 affordable units? I personally don't think so. I think it can be higher density. I think there's other uses.
4:49:53 The Neighborhood District Plan talks about town amenities and it talks about workforce housing and it talks about possible market rate housing. So I think all those things are in play. I think if somebody wanted to say, hey, look, we want to put at least 172 affordable housing units there.
4:50:19 I'd be all right with that. So can I ask a question to the town attorney? Sure. This, the affordable housing overlay that was passed March 22, 1989, does that have the effect of law at this point? Is this a legally binding situation? Yeah, it's part of your zoning code. Okay. So my point is that we cannot go into negotiation for real property having made a representation that we are not going to
4:50:45 Faithfully seek to implement something that's part of our zoning code. We can't do that. The council always has the ability to legislatively do away with that. Sure, but that's going to be a separate action. So I would say if we don't, you know, if we're not going to say that we're, this has legal effect, then we need to say, okay, let's stop this right now. Let's bring this thing back and let's put to the council the question of changing this affordable housing overlay.
4:51:15 Because you can't have it both ways. You can't go into a negotiation saying, well, we're not really going to take seriously something that's on the books. If we affirm it and we say that we are affirming what is on the books, fine, let's go forward and have the conversations with the private property owner. Let's see what the proposal is at.
4:51:38 Plan the property. No, and I am in total agreement. I want to get to what it is you're talking about. But I do not see how we can go into a negotiation having told the community that things that are legally binding upon us right now, we're not going to take the weight of those policies with us into these negotiations. It's a recipe for disaster.
4:52:05 I think if we don't go into these negotiations having acknowledged the spirit intent of the land exchange, acknowledging and affirming the zoning and the stuff that we currently have on the books right now, if we don't go into those negotiations saying this is where we're starting from, what faith or trust could the community have and what it is where we're starting our negotiations from? And if we want to open up the overlay from 1989, that's fine. That's a separate conversation.
4:52:34 That's a separate item. Okay. I'd say, okay, if we affirm that, then we also have to affirm the 2010 downtown concept for Main Street downtown neighborhood district plan that was accepted by council in 2010. The district plan identified shady arrests as a livable workforce neighborhood with a mix of housing types, affordable levels, including both market rate and below market rate units. The conceptual plan showed a density of 235. And I'm not saying that all these things are not contradictory.
4:53:02 Well, they're very contradictory. Right. But the thing is, they are all in effect. And we should go into the negotiation with the community, understanding that we are honoring all the things that we've... Well, then what we have to do is find another way to say that here, because this is just talking about...
4:53:18 March 22nd, 1989. I'm saying, boy, there's been a lot of stuff that's gone on since then. Well, the only other thing that I know that's gone on since then is this neighborhood district plan thing. Well, there's been the general plan. There's been a whole bunch of different things that's gone on. The general plan is number three. That's number three right now. Okay, but the district plan is not... We could add that. We could add that right now. I'd actually like to pose this question to staff, and that has to do with the legal weight and legal standing of the district plans, because...
4:53:47 We know that the general plan was adopted by resolution as the governing document. We know that the zoning code and the overlay were adopted by ordinance. I believe that the district plan was never adopted. It was only accepted by the council as a reference document. And it, in fact, carries no regulatory weight. Is that correct?
4:54:10 I think that's our understanding, yes. Okay, thank you. That's all I want. Right, and so my point to Bill's comments is that we should go, I believe we should go into these negotiations with all previous actions taken by Council consistent with their current standing.
4:54:28 So that would be the district plan as it was characterized by staff. That would be this overlay as it currently sits on the books. We've had a lot of conversations. We just had somebody come up tonight that says, I think we need additional density on this site. We've had people come up and say things like, I think that 172 units of affordable housing, which means 120 and below, should be a component of the site. That's a different question than is it the entire site.
4:54:55 By this statement right here says it precludes that conversation with the property owner that coming out of the back end, it is not possible for a single unit on 25 acres to be above 128. Well, the point of having discussions with the property owner is to say, look, what kind of a deal can we strike to move this thing forward? And I would hope that if we affirm all the policies that we have on the books, this is where we're starting from. Now, town, go off and start talking to the property owner.
4:55:24 Let's see what you can come up with. Return to council with deal points. These are the proposed deal points. If at that point we need to make a change to anything that's on the books, that becomes a question back to council. That becomes a question that says, look, the landowner is willing to do X, Y, and Z if the town and the community is willing to do A, B, and C. At that point, we've got something to talk about.
4:55:49 That's how I think we should proceed. I think we should just say we are where we're at. Let's affirm all the various things we've got on the books. Let's have the conversations. Let's see what comes out the other side and bring the proposal back to council and the community. So if the words the are changed to a, I'm okay. Okay. Well, let's go for a and let's move forward with that. And then let's include the appropriate legal standing of the district plan.
4:56:17 Right? Which is, whatever it is, it's an advisory document. Let's add that here if that was left out. And let's reaffirm all these things and go through these things. If we get all wrapped up, take that as direction of framework to the council, go off and talk to the property owner, and let's see what comes back out the other side. So, okay, so you feel that we need this to go to the property owner? Yes. I feel like we need to go.
4:56:45 Go into discussions with the property owner, having affirmed all the policies that we have on our books right now and say, this is where we are starting from. This is the legal framework that we're going to have these negotiations with you. We're starting from here. And let's see if in the negotiations and the discussions, it can be arrived at a way forward that says, well, if we can do this,
4:57:13 Then would the council consider making a change? And I think, I haven't talked to these people, I don't know what they're interested in, but let's go in there with our stuff as it sits on the books. One, I think the landowner and the representative of the landowner is very aware, very aware of all this. But our community is not aware of the council's commitment.
4:57:38 To the policies that we have on the books. And we owe it to the community to say to the community, we are affirming our policies. Now if there's a policy that we want to change, okay, that's a separate thing. That needs to come back to us. We need to look at these things and say, we want to change. I don't think it makes any sense to change anything absent knowing what the private property owner may want.
4:58:03 May be interested in doing. So I don't think there's any point in changing anything. I understand the nuance you're articulating. Mr. Mayor, may I offer just a comment that might help quickly and that might help move it forward? My sense is that the point of these is so the town manager could have a sense from the council, are you soft anywhere here? Are you soft on any of these hard lines? As Colin pointed out, or I think you did, Shields,
4:58:32 The property owner knows all these things. They know the current zoning. They know this stuff. That's why they're trying to negotiate, because they either can't or won't or don't want to live within the parameters that currently exist. And the idea is, are you open to anything else in any other way? So that's why I was advocating earlier, gee, if you send the message through the town manager that we're open to higher density, we'll come back, we'll entertain that. And maybe what Colin's getting at is, are we open to a different kind of affordability?
4:58:59 Formula on there, which is a different thing than density. Well, I think if we go through this and you get to number five, when we say strive to meet or exceed the affordable workforce housing unit count as provided by the current zoning and master plan while ensuring livability, standards, and quality of life in shady residents surrounding neighborhoods consistent with the general plan. So I think the direction, if the council affirms that, we're saying
4:59:24 We are affirming all the things that we have in place, but we would like to meet or exceed what is currently on the books. And I think that's the kind of thing we can say to the private property owner, look, we're acknowledging all these things are on the book. This is where we're starting from. We would like to exceed what's currently on our books. We'd like to have a conversation with you about how we could possibly do that.
4:59:47 And I would leave it to the creativity of the negotiating team and the property owner to, okay, this is the parameters we've got to work within. We want to try to exceed the opportunities on this site. It may involve density. It may involve height. It may involve zoning. It may involve all kinds of things. But start from this.
5:00:05 Have the conversation with the private property owner and come back to Council to say, look, we've talked. This is what we think we've come up with. And these are now questions for Council to consider based on those negotiations rather than doing it before we go on. I think we can do it in one comment. I think Council can say, yeah, we know where this started. We know where we stand right now. We've gone through all the different planning. We know the overlay that's on it now.
5:00:32 Okay, great. That's where we start. What's on the books now, okay, I think it can be made in one statement. That's where we start the negotiations. Sure. That's what this is intended to do. Okay. That's what this is intended to do. Okay. Okay. And I don't have a problem with that. I think, you know, we're not trying to usurp anything up here. You know, we're saying, yeah, we know what we got to deal with right now. Right. Okay. We have to go to the...
5:01:00 So I think if we affirm this is where we are starting from and we are advising our community that we are
5:01:29 We're all on the same page where we're starting from. Let's see what the negotiations produce and bring those things back to council and see what we can do with this. I will affirm. I will be happy to affirm the history of the property and where it stands now, okay, with all the different planning that's been done, okay? You know, without any more input, we will start.
5:01:57 With that as the baseline in our discussions with the current owner. Which one? Do you want to just go? We can just go through these. I think there's too much weeds in here, in my opinion. That's just the overall acceptance of we understand the history. We affirm the history. We're not changing anything right now. We know what the general plan says. We know what the district plans say.
5:02:27 And that's where we're starting. We're not changing anything right now. We're entering into negotiations with the landowner knowing what the current zoning is. Okay, so why don't we, if we take out everything, I would only go with number five.
5:02:44 To say that our goal is to meet or exceed the affordable housing work for you as replied by the current zoning and master plan while ensuring livability standards and quality of life associated with the surrounding neighborhoods consistent with the general plan. And that's the only direction we would give to the... I'm very comfortable with item five. I'm very comfortable with number five only. Okay, we have consensus. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Okay, anybody else want to come up and... Is that sufficient direction? Okay, all right.
5:03:19 With that, any comments from staff? I'm getting the direction to work with them and give them the comments and stuff. That gives us context. Great. And we look forward to having a report back from the negotiation effort with deal points or just very basic ideas for further consideration by the council. Very good. Very basic. Adjourn. Thank you. Thank you.
5:03:47 Huh? Oh, yeah.