Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2017
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
· recording 2 hr 17 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
283 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:16 Good evening, Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, I'm Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mount Skier, and I just wanted to bring to your attention, and I think you're probably aware that the
1:01 Planning and Economic Development Commission tomorrow is going to be hearing discussion on the subject of minimum floor area ratio in the commercial zones in town. And we, Mammoth Mountain Ski, are going to advocate for a minimum FAR of .75 in the commercial zones. And, you know, we see this as a really big opportunity, truly, for housing.
1:31 In the community as much as commercial uses are going to, if you apply a commercial use to the ground floor of any particular site, typically ground floor commercial with surface parking is going to yield you somewhere in the neighborhood of a 0.3 floor air ratio for the site, something in that range. A couple examples in town, give you an idea of what that is. You understand what a floor air ratio is? It's the square footage.
2:00 of the building in the numerator and the denominator is the square footage of the site. So a 1.0 FAR would be square footage of the building would be equivalent to the square footage of the site. So in that can be, in one story configuration, that would, in just talking theory here, would be the whole site would be covered by a building. If you were a two story building, half the site would be two stories.
2:30 of the site, and that would be a 1.0 FAR. So anyway, you get the idea. Four stories would be a quarter of the site. And so some examples around town, the Mammoth Lofts units that are above the AT&T store in the Mexican market over here, that's a 0.5 FAR as an example. The Salsas Building, I believe, is a 0.6.
2:58 Far on that site. Sierra Center Mall is a 1.4 Far, I believe. The Village is a 2.0 Far, the Village proper, you know, with the shops and the restaurants and then the units above, the parking below. And the proposed development for Old Mammoth Place is a 1.8 Far. So kind of give you a range of what's out there.
3:27 Our understanding, the town's entertaining, or as an application, active application, and currently for the former old Grumpy site next to the Shell Station, it's a one-acre site for a grocery outlet, as I understand, I haven't seen the details, but my understanding that that proposal is yielding out to a .3 FAR, and they're just proposing to build a grocery store with surface parking. So, you know, as much as the, you know, the community's put...
3:52 Putting forth some effort right now and looking at the downtown and so forth. And, you know, a lot of the collateral that Hart-Howerton generated and, in fact, a lot of the prior stuff, work was done by ERA and EPS and so forth as they looked at kind of the downtown zone and, you know, was really contemplating mixed use. So other uses besides just the ground floor commercial. And so the point being is, you know, a great example is this grocery outlet.
4:22 You know, in order to get to, say, a .75 FAR, they would have to entertain second-floor uses or even maybe third-story uses. It's probably going to be a combination of, you know, two- to three-story type buildings with some, probably likely some kind of parking to achieve a .75 FAR. And so, you know, we think that if, or we believe, strongly believe, that if the town would implement this minimum FAR in the downtown zone, it's going to create an opportunity for
4:52 Housing units largely above these commercial areas because what else are you going to put in, you know, you probably likely couldn't build second floor retail, that doesn't make any sense, right? So, you know, maybe you could put some office space in, but largely it's, you know, likely going to be lodging units, you know, whether that's workforce housing, affordable housing, market rate housing.
5:16 Or hospitality type uses. And so we see it as a real opportunity. And as much as I know there's, as you guys often point out, that there's a true lack of land available for housing. So, I mean, this truly creates the acreage of the commercial zone is well over 100 acres. And so if you consider, you know, if they really maximize commercial development within that zone is,
5:41 Say 0.3 of that available acreage, you're talking 0.75 would be more than double that of housing opportunities on 100 acres. So it truly could fulfill the needs of the community in combination with Shady Rest. And aside from that, it's really good urban planning as much as you can build living units in a commercial in our downtown zone so we have a vibrant, active commercial area.
6:11 Where people live and work and also go for their commercial activities and dining, entertaining, shopping and so forth. And I think that's what we truly are envisioning in the general plan as well as some of the more recent work in the downtown commercial zone. So anyway, I just encourage the board to attend tomorrow's plan economic development commission meeting and maybe weigh in on that subject. And it really truly is an opportunity for you guys to find some potential
6:41 You know, location to put housing. It's really, you know, significant housing. You know, so again, let's take the example of the Mammoth Lofts is 0.5. Salis is, I think, 0.6, which I believe is three-story, right, I believe. And I think it's units, you know, two-story kind of condo units above the commercial.
7:17 So 0.75 is sort of getting close to that break point, certainly. It may even, in some cases, require some covered parking, for example, like maybe you would build units, like again, so the easy one to think of because it's such a nice round number is 0.5 is the Mammoth Lofts across the street here. And so if you took another floor, you could add a third floor to that, so to speak, and that would get you to a 0.75 FAR because there's two floors there now with
7:47 But you would probably, might likely require a little bit additional parking. So in that case, then you might be facing some sort of a structured situation possibly. So it's, you know, our feeling is that, you know, we need to set a standard in town or, you know, set what our expectations are and push these developers when they come in that, you know, just a one story.
8:14 Commercial Center is what we've already built for the last 30 years. We don't want more of that. We want to try and get mixed use. We want to try to create units above commercial spaces and force the discussion, force the...
8:27 These, you know, developers, as they come in to seek you guys out, for example, and say, okay, how could we incorporate units into this project, you know, and it's going to force your guys' position, too, that you're going to need to start looking at, okay, how could we get funding for that? Are there grants available out there for us to do that? I mean, obviously, this type of stuff's going to be well-located with respect to transportation, and so, you know, I don't know.
8:53 Obviously, you need bigger sites in order to apply for the cap and trade funds, right? But, you know, there might be other opportunities to seek grant funding for building housing in these type of areas that maybe there's federal, state funds, I don't know. I mean, so it's just, but the point is, if we don't push ourselves to achieve a higher vision or, you know, we won't get there. I think if, and I think ultimately some aspect this is going to require the town to really
9:19 Start to look at hard at implementing district planning in whatever means they can proceed with that. I mean, they have the parking lot currently at Tavern Row. They could already offer that as an opportunity to defer parking needs for commercial in that downtown zone. You know, that site's been looked at in the past. I think, maybe Kirk, you recall, I think it was an RFP that went out at one point in time for structured parking there with street front commercial and units above. And, you know,
9:49 So those are the kind of things I think that we envision that would really make for a vibrant downtown and create some opportunity for housing.
12:02 I was worried that the rental agents were going to have to shrink, and that sounds like...
12:38 They've got some sort of working relationship. It's a tease or something, but they seem to be doing okay. But they have seen, you know, their workers and impact on long-term rentals. Update, it was the first day of the new board. John Peters. John Peters. And, let's see, we like to make sure and stay safe. We're trying to get off. Hello. Your service wasn't committed.
13:38 Anyway, so that did happen.
14:41 So we had 21 visitors to our website. So we created a webpage that was exactly like the flyer, the brochure that was sent out. So we've had 21 visitors there. And then I think we didn't hear that we had one person who listed their property as a result of the mailer on our website, on their efficacy board.
15:12 You know, it certainly raised some awareness about it. The other thing I want to mention is that outside of what's in the report is that the council is meeting tomorrow as well, and I did notice that they are going into closed session to negotiate.
15:54 The public outreach happened, but I think a lot of people felt like they were blindsided by it. I've heard that from various people.
16:38 You know, when...
17:08 The Aspen Village Apartments were built. There was no sidewalk there, the pathway. There was no bus pullout. All of that was a result of a CDBG grant that Mammoth Lakes Housing, Part of 4, through the town to be half a million dollars spending those improvements. With a real understanding that this would benefit the law. So, you know, I haven't heard direct complaints from any of our residents, but it wasn't even. We're getting a lot of that.
17:49 So it's a little more of a pain, too, for the children, as a parent.
18:59 Because the kids have to do a transfer. So you get on the trolley out there at Snow Creek, so now you have to walk in your apartment or your condo at Aspen or wherever in that vicinity, to Snow Creek, get on that bus, get the bonds, then transfer through, is it correct? No. Is that right? To the school. Because there's no school bus out there. So I think that there might be some.
19:32 It talks about it all.
20:42 Right, I mean, I think one of the things that I've heard people say is, and certainly our tenants, that they feel a little isolated out there versus our, our, our, our, um, Doran's, you know, we've been property for Jeffery's, either property, you know, that's a more desirable location because it's more centrally connected, whereas that property, so we're making that work, that, that's potentially really exacerbating that sentiment for our tenants by removing that.
21:12 Wow. So, I'm anticipating going to council and letting me know that how to involve them in the creation of that sidewalk and allow them at that time when we could talk about that being a big deal for our time. I think the ridership members are in the package. They are in the package. Definitely. Obviously, I understand. I think they were getting the ridership at that stop, but I think that they just feel they can serve it.
21:52 Thank you.
22:40 I think it has to do with the way we perhaps our websites and how we communicate to the public, our messaging. But I didn't know anything about it. I found that a little ironic. Anyway.
23:01 We've, you know, I keep saying this every month now for probably the past six months, and it really is true. We just keep helping people buy homes, and I mentioned that in our email the other day. We just closed another loan on Friday. We have another household getting ready to close Monday, and then the county was verbally awarded an extension on their program, which is doing very well. So it's really a great
23:30 A great thing that we have this program in a time when it feels like we have little else, so it's a lot of fun doing that. I think that's by and large it. Jennifer, did you have a goal for those mailers that went out for responses or anything?
23:56 The committee overall didn't put together any kind of expectation of deliverables. There were certain anecdotally people said if we just got one unit that would be something because a lot of the business owners on the committee felt like it's pretty dire right now. So that's great. Yeah. Yeah. Hi, John. Hi, sorry I'm late. I had a logistical issue. Okay, glad you could make it. Yeah.
24:28 I lent my truck out. That's a bad thing to do. Oh, no. Well, it's generous of you. It's a rough day to walk. I walked it. That's it. We move to agenda item number eight, adoption of Mammoth Lake Housing Resolution 17-1, authorizing a Home Investment Partnership Program application. Everybody get a chance to read the agenda bill? Questions? Jennifer, do you have anything you want to add?
25:05 No, I mean, I certainly entertain any questions. It's a unique program. It's certainly something we've never done before. It'll be our first time applying under the Chaudo. I'm not sure the success it will have, but I think it's worth throwing our hat in the ring and seeing if we can't find at least one or two properties to make it work. It's, you know, there's some risk involved because you have to, as an NGO, you are...
25:34 As a Choto, you have to go out and buy the property yourself, and then you have to rehab it with your own funds, and then sell it, and use their money to help that home buyer buy the property, and then you get some money back when you do that, based on how much you spent to rehab it. So you have to make sure you play your cards right, that you can recoup the money you invested at the time of transfer.
25:58 But it certainly achieves one of the goals of the town council of utilizing existing housing stock and improving it in theory. So yeah, I look forward to that. And then I'm also mentioned in here, I believe that that's the programmatic side of home and then there's also a project side of home. And on the project side, I looked around and we only have two multifamily and most people in other jurisdictions wouldn't even call these multifamily. We have a
26:27 Two unit, a duplex, and a fourplex on the market in Mammoth, and that's it, and they've been on the market for a long time, but there is, there's more fish in the sea, so to speak, in Bishop, and so I have a call with Paul from RCAC tomorrow to talk about possibly doing something in Bishop, an AC rehab project where we would own it, buy it, rehabilitate it, and rent it to the workforce in Bishop,
26:57 Ideally, because we can work in Inyo County as a Chodo. That was my question about counties. Alpine County is on there as well. Is that with our Chodo? We included Alpine in there since we've done a little work with them and I feel like it might be an opportunity sometime in the future to work there. So these are federal funds administered through the state? Do you have any sense of the viability of the federal program?
27:27 Is this something that is uniquely exposed to what the new administration might do or not do? Well, these funds are already allocated. This time around, no. Going forward, they're in jeopardy a lot. They were in major jeopardy last year. The year before, they wanted to cut them by 90%. This is Congress wanting to cut them by 90%. Yes. So, you know, under Ben Carson, it's...
27:57 Donald Trump, who knows? It's very uncertain times. But if the Republican Congress wanted to cut him, it's probably fair to say that they're going to take another whack at it. Possibly. It's possible, yeah. Yeah, I'm just wondering, it's probably predictable. I don't know. You know, that program's been around a long time, since I want to say the 70s. Did Jack Kemp have anything to do with it?
28:31 I don't know. He was the author, the instigator of the tax credit allocation process. Right. And because that's still philosophically aligned with Republican strategies, but tax credit projects usually only work when they're partnered with a home financing. It'll be interesting to see how it all plays out. Right. I think that, you know,
29:01 It's at risk. It's been at risk for a while now, and it seems to have survived. The same can be said for the CDBG, the Community Development Block Grant, although people like that, jurisdictions and Republicans included, tend to like that program more because it's a little more moldable and can do different things with it, whereas the home program is pretty specific.
29:25 So, I don't know. I think while it's available, we have to take a stab at, you know, using the funds. We've been very successful in the Eastern Sierra with these monies. You know, they fund that down payment assistance program that we use a lot. They funded 78 low-income apartment new development in Mammoth. So, you know, part of it, along with tax credits, like Bill said. I mean, it's a pretty powerful tool that way. Thank you.
29:56 Yeah. Any other questions? I can have a motion. I move to adopt the Mammoth Lake Housing Resolution 17.1, authorizing a Home Investment Partnership Program application. Second. I've been moved to second. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes 4-0. Review of scope of... 5. What? 1, 2, 3, 4, 5. 5-0, because John's here. Oh, sorry, John.
30:32 Motion passes 5-0. Huh? Four and a half. Four and a half. Four and a later. Thanks, Larry. Oh, it's counting me as a half. Yeah, yeah, sure. The next agenda item is review of scope of, for 2017, Mammoth Lake Housing needs update, inventory, resources, and strategic project. Anybody have a chance to look at this? Jennifer, you have anything to say? Sure. So, I will. I didn't put together a, um,
31:06 Agenda bill, but this, we talked about this a little bit actually at our last meeting. You may recall we talked about how Kirk and Rusty had met and that was on the agenda and talked about allocating $250,000 for housing studies to kind of see where the housing need is and where housing could go. Did we really need all of shady rest as I understood it was kind of a...
31:36 Where that started. And so then since that meeting, John, Kirk, and I got together and talked about, okay, so what does that look like? I think John's had some conversation, and maybe Kirk too, with Rusty to kind of clarify that this offer is for X, Y, or Z. And then we just kind of hashed out, okay, well, what does it need to do? What is the goal of the...
32:02 This study, so to speak, and we know that our, and I've talked with you guys about this before, our needs assessment was done in 2011. It was right after the Great Recession. We didn't have the same impacts of tourism that we have right now from Airbnb. It's been five years, and that was a five-year projection.
32:23 So we need to go back, we know, and look at that and say, okay, are those numbers still right or what are they now and let's forecast forward to, you know, for the next five years from, given what we know, an update to that needs. And then also looking at our existing housing stock and really John, I think, played the biggest role in really saying we need to look at the, use the GIS because, you know, this is your specialty.
32:51 Look at GIS. See how many units we have. What zones are they in? Are they in zones for nightly rental? Are they multifamily? Are they being, you know, really start digging into that data mining, so to speak. And then out of that, come back with the recommendations or suggestions, possibilities of ways to meet the need based on what we know we need and what we have.
33:21 As far as not only built, but underbuilt and vacant land, and then start putting those into some kind of outlining some strategies. And really most of that would come back to, I think, the council for policy direction. So, you know, I looked at the
33:50 assessor's data, GIS, and it looks like most of the data is already in the database, and it's really a matter for built density, vacant properties, so forth, a matter of structuring a few reports and having the county simply run those reports. And they did that back, I don't know, six, seven years ago when the
34:21 When the town was kind of looking at the impacts of the general plan. So are you thinking we need to actually input more data or are we just trying to extract reports based on the data that's already in there? Well, based on our conversations, I think we need to make sure that the data in there is correct, that the uses are correct compared to what's on the ground. Well, yeah, there may need to be some field checking.
34:52 But no, I think the data's there. Is it there by APN? I'm not sure. You'd like it. I mean, if you go to an individual parcel, it'll have the zoning, all that information. You may not know, for instance, you may not tell you what the maximum density on the site is, but it'll tell you how many units are there. And then you could probably extract that. So are you thinking that we'd work with...
35:19 County GIS to structure those reports and then extract that data? Yes. I believe so. And there's some other pieces of the data. It's not, I think we, the first, it's laid out here in some detail, but we can kind of go through it step by step. But the first step is to make sure that all the APN data, which the county currently has in the GIS, is correct and accurate.
35:41 I would assume it probably is, but there have been gaps. In the TOT collection stuff, we've been hearing there are anomalies pop up and there are gaps and things like that, so that needs to be checked to make sure that all the physical stuff is there. The second thing is the opportunity to start cross-referencing the uses that these properties are being exposed to. There are a lot of, you know, there's a lot of opportunities to rent properties now on a single family.
36:08 On a nightly rental basis that we don't know whether that's happening or not. And one of the things we've talked about at the TOT committee is the town is likely to consider using a robotic data mining tool as part of our TOT enforcement program for things that are zoned legally or illegally.
36:27 To start generating real hard data is what's happening with the nightly rental program where it's zoned legally and illegally. But that tool is also something we could use to cross-reference with this effort to start getting a sense of how many homeowners who can legally rent their properties on a single family on a nightly rental program are starting to do that. The first pass of this would be baseline. That'd be establishing some baseline data. This goes back to 2,800, that number you were talking about that we heard about before from the last meeting. Oh, my gosh.
36:56 This number of units is being rented using 21st century technology. Okay, so we have to start establishing a baseline of how much is being rented and then start looking at trends over time to start saying this is how much of the housing stock we have that is now being rented using these 21st century tools. This could start giving us a picture of how much housing is actually available to the community for people to live in. Out of that starts coming
37:23 And I would assume that this data mining thing is going to be an ongoing process that the town's going to do because the only way we can reliably enforce nightly rentals and TOT and that kind of stuff. But I'm thinking that out of this comes policy recommendations that go to the town that could be on a whole wide spectrum of things. I'm not, I'm no expert in zoning, but I'm not convinced that the zoning that the town currently has is the right zoning for a community. And I think if you look at
37:50 What we have on the books as far as zoning goes and how it's actually being used, you know, we may find, oh, we're in great shape. There's no problem. There's enough rental stock here. People can live here. We can have a community. We can have a workforce that supports the industries that happen in this town. We may also find that there's no way in hell we have enough.
38:11 Places for people to rent, to live in this community, to be the workforce, to do the things we want to do. This is a unique 21st century opportunity to give us the tools we need to do the analysis to figure out where we stand with all stuff so we're not guessing. So if the ski area makes a lot of representations, hey, everybody come up here, we got jobs, we got housing. Oh, wait a minute, we don't have any housing for anybody. You know, we can be smarter about this kind of stuff. And I think that...
38:35 It's going to be very interesting to see what kinds of results come out of this. And I think combined with the updating the needs assessment to really get a sense of where we're at, I would think that there may be some interesting policy recommendations that could come to the council. I want to share with the board that Kirk and Jennifer and I met. We had a discussion about this a while ago. I had a meeting with Rusty Gregory and Shields Richardson, and we reviewed
39:01 The components of our conversation, Mr. Gregory being the person who represented that he was willing to put $250,000 into this, these things that are represented in this document, I believe, and Kirk had the initial conversation, he didn't know better than anybody, but I think what we've got in here lines up with their expectations. I mean, I don't know if he's seen this or if this has gone back to him or what, but anecdotally and verbally, this lined up with his expertise that that seems to be a good use for the money.
39:29 And so that's kind of where we're at. That was going to be one of my follow-up questions, so good. And do we have any structure for presenting this to the mountain to make sure that this is something they're willing to fund, or are we not even there yet? This is the first discussion, and there has been, and I think from your discussion with Rusty, this would be acceptable. I would assume, based on what's in here, this seems to make sense.
39:57 So, let me respond. You know, John is very persuasive about what needs to be done. I absolutely agree, you know, that this needs to be done. My issue is that I think the town needs to pay for this. I mean, this is part of what the town's responsibility is.
40:19 And this is a discussion, by the way, and I don't mean to be backing up or blindsided you or anything else, but I thought... No, I'm fine. If this is how you want to bring this forward, that's great, that's fine. But the $250,000, one of the big issues that keeps coming to Mammoth Lake Housing is that we don't have the ability to go above 120%. $250,000 could be 5 to 10 houses, you know, a down payment assistance program.
40:48 You know, for Mammoth employees, mountain employees or anything, those people that are above that don't have the down payment. So this money, I think, has got more than one source. I kind of believe that it needs to go this. Part of my thinking is that, you know, it's going to take time to do the analysis or, you know, to do...
41:17 This and, you know, the town's budget's going to come forward. I have not received anything from the town council or the town manager that says, you know, even though, you know, we get these things in the paper that this is a crisis, yet nothing, that we don't seem to have any ability to move forward. I mean, inclusion area, all the different things that have been happening.
41:45 And now, you know, I'm kind of looking at this, and I'm saying, okay, I'd like to see actually product done, rather than another study. I talked to several people about another study, and John, I appreciate what you've done, but the reaction, the reaction to the people I talked to, they was, you gotta be kidding. You need to know, study, to find out you have a housing problem? You know, it's in the paper, it's everywhere. So, you know, I'm not too sure this is, and I think,
42:15 You know, Jennifer and I, you know, went round and round about it, and she really feels strongly that this needs to be done, but I think we need to approach the town council and say, we totally agree this needs to be done. You know, you haven't funded 2002A, you know, in five years. You can find $150,000 for Dinsmore, you know, but you can't find $20,000 or $30,000 for us.
42:44 To find out, to interface with all the things that you're trying to get done. And so, you know, I have to oppose this because I think we need to at least try to go to the town council, ask them for the funding. I haven't talked to Rusty since we had that discussion. I would like to see what his thoughts are on the $250,000 being used for
43:11 You know, down payment for those people that are in a funding group or in an income group that they can't, you know, we can't service them. We can't provide them with first-time homeowner loans and everything. So I haven't had a discussion with them. I feel that we need to approach the council first. This interlocks, and I really support some of the things that you're trying to put together. I really do.
43:39 And, but I think that they need to, because it's not just housing, you know, this interfaces with a whole bunch of issues. I think they need to step up and fund this. They've funded, they've funded other projects, and all of a sudden, when it comes to housing, it just seems that we're going to be put off, we're being put off. I hate to be critical of the town manager when he's not here, but we met October.
44:08 29th, and we were never able to present the Shady Rest proposal. We weren't given time. And now it's been two months. We've been sent several emails asking when can we meet with the town council. We're talking $100 million worth of development on Shady Rest that our grant can be grant driven. If you look at five different components to it.
44:34 And $25 million for that first. We haven't even been able to present that to them. And now they're in negotiations and I don't think the council has an idea that there's $100 million in cap and trade grants. You know, so I think, you know, asking them to fund this and also finally getting a chance to present what is, what potentially could happen to Shady Rust. So, you know,
45:03 Jonathan, a ton of work, this needs to be done. It's who pays for it. And I think the town council needs to pay for it. It's the time they step up on housing. If they can be in the, you know, from the dais, you know, saying how, you know, it's critical and everything else, then what, where's their commitment? I'm sorry for the rant, but this has been festering and for a while, and I can go down a whole list of
45:33 of history and everything else, it's time the council says, yeah, this is a problem and we'll step up. And if they won't step up for this, which is a small expenditure, what's the point of doing the study? Well, it sort of ties into what Tom was saying earlier, which I think housing on the second and third floors. Well, how do you make sure that's not a hotel type housing?
46:06 Transit Occupant Housing. The town has to say you have to have inclusionary housing. Right. Okay? On that, if you're going to go higher FARs. Right. And if the reason you're going higher FAR is to get this density, then the density has to be preserved some way for affordable housing. And unless that act is taken, you know, then I was, you know, hesitant to say, yeah, let's...
46:37 Up to FARs. Because all that's doing is making it more profitable for the person owning the property because they can rent it out as transient rentals. But I think parts of this are needed. I do. I totally agree. And the housing needs updates. It's been five years. I think that needs to be done. Are we the ones to take part of that $250,000 and use it for that? Maybe that's what we do. Do a portion of it for that part of it? Because I think that's needed.
47:10 The town council has not stepped up once, other than verbally, and John has been a champion, don't get me wrong, John, you know, fighting for housing and that sort of thing, but the council, you know, in the last two, three years, eliminated inclusionary, dropped the fees, hasn't paid 2002A, you know, the discussion has...
47:33 Waivered back and forth about what shady rats should be used for, you know. So, I mean, there's all these different things. And, you know, the budget's coming forward. We haven't had a chance. I think February will be their first cut at looking at next year's budget. And we haven't had a chance to bring forward, you know, the cap and cave grant and what we put together.
48:00 Because that was always a criticism of Shady Rest that, guess what? It doesn't pencil. It does pencil for affordable housing with those grants. So, you know, I think two things have to happen. We need to request that the town council fund this. Find out if they're committed to housing. And the other thing is that we need to be able to present the Shady Rest proposal or what the potential
48:31 Those two things have to happen before we start going. But I feel very uncomfortable to walk up to Rusty Gregory and say, oh, yeah, we're going to use you first. And oh, by the way, the council is going to sit on 500,000 that was publicly committed to measure 2002A, and they're sitting on it, using it for something else. I just can't go to Rusty and say that. I'm not going to.
48:58 So I have a question going back. When you met with Rusty and he made this offer, he must have had something in mind that he thought would be beneficial to the community and to the mountain to come out of this. He left it open. Excuse me. I don't want to be abrupt with this, but we need to deal with some facts. To your point, Mr. Gregory and Mr. Stapp appeared before the council in public comment. Right.
49:24 And Mr. Gregory clearly said, and Mr. Stapp agreed, that's what the council heard, that this money was to be used for some sort of a strategic effort to address strategic needs of housing going forward. That's what was publicly stated. And I look forward to this conversation, but I have some very, very strong feelings about where this conversation is going and where the reality of Mammoth Lakes Housing is.
49:52 Relative to opportunities that are coming before it. One of the things I'll say just out of the box, the expectation from the council is that we fund NGOs because we look forward to their ability to hustle, to be innovative.
50:07 And to take advantage of opportunities that come their way that may not come the way of the government. I have to assume that Mr. Gregory made this proposal to Mr. Stapp and MLH and publicly made this offer because he believed in the entrepreneurial ability of Mammoth Lakes Housing to take $250,000 in the context of a strategic
50:29 Plan for housing and do something with it, make it real and bring something that was going to be, that would be credible. I, what do we, that, that probably leads right into where I was going. Okay, so, you know, if, if that was the intent, and I'm not saying necessarily, I mean, we don't necessarily have to buy into that intent, but I, for the sake of argument, I would say they're offering the money, they have a purpose.
50:55 What is that? Does that match our needs? Is there something, what information, and we keep talking, we put together a housing strategy. Clearly that didn't suffice for whatever the community and or the mountain and or the town government was looking for. What information do we think we need, if any? We may have everything. That's one of the concerns I had, and this gets to maybe to Kirk's point, was we restudy.
51:26 We restudy, and we keep coming up with the same answers. But if we need to update the data, I think it's a very straightforward GIS effort to go back and get the baseline data. What are the parcels? What's the zoning? What's the capacity? What are the unit counts? Theoretically, all of that data has been uploaded from the assessor's files to the GIS. It should all be in one place, and I've seen reports run on parts of it.
51:56 You got the vacant land report out of them. So I don't think that's a hugely complicated effort. But once we get there, then what do we do? We're trying to come up with an answer, a program that says, this is how we're moving forward. And I think that's what the 250,000 from the mountain is seeking. If I could add just to that. I have my notes right here, what I read. And it doesn't say strategic. I met with Mr. Gregory to Bill's point and confirmed.
52:26 What was said publicly, I'm not saying you have to buy what we discussed, but it was affirmed that this was a direction that he thought made sense and was consistent with the public representations. So I just want to make sure we're dealing with facts. We're not living in the past. There's the facts. We're going off on things. This is what I said. I've written it down and I read it into the council. And it was about a strategic plan going forward for housing. It doesn't say strategic plan.
52:54 It said the whole thing was predicated on, Kirk, would you open up discussions on shady rest for more than affordable housing? That's what it was, that was the premise of this. But the money that I heard, and again, Granicus did not work that evening, and this is why I asked to make sure that the minutes were correct with what was said. It had to do with using the money for a strategic plan going forward for housing in the community of Mammoth Lakes. I wouldn't have agreed. I wouldn't have agreed to it.
53:22 Okay, well then we're all, I don't know what we're all smoking here, but we are not getting anywhere. And there's 250,000, if you think that the town council having heard what was said, that we're going to spin around here and say to the council, we think you should pay for this, I don't know what we're doing here. And I don't know why Mammoth Lakes Housing exists.
53:43 I have to tell you honestly. And disband us. Well then, you're pushing that. Put it on the agenda and disband us. You are pushing that. I'm not saying the rest of the board is pushing that, but you are pushing that. You personally are pushing that. I just want to make sure that this board understands that. So if we can get back to the question at hand, which we have $250,000 offered and we're trying to decide what to do. The town council, the two issues. Should the council be paying?
54:11 You know, for this study, which is five years old, and it needs to be done. Yes. I have a question on that before you go forward. Sorry. When you talk about paying for this study in this scope of delivery, how much do we anticipate that this would cost? Which part? Which part? The whole part? That's my question. This is not a study. There are several actions in here. There are studies, there are recommendations, and there are things going to the Council for policy recommendations. John, other people were speaking. I understand.
54:39 So do you anticipate that the parts of this, the inventory, the policy recommendations, does that cost $250,000? I've heard some people say $30,000 in this conversation. I do not believe what's before us is $250,000. Yeah. So we're, I mean, is it, do we have $200,000 left over after planning and strategy is done? I don't think we ever spent that money on any housing study.
55:07 This needs to be done by us. That top housing needs update. The housing needs update, because that needs to be done. It's five years old, right? I think we should do that. And those are the numbers that we look at now, that like at build out we will need a certain number of units. Well, this is a five year. Yeah. It's a five year projection. Okay. Okay. And then some sort of data development on inventory available housing. I think that those are reasonable things for Mammoth Lakes Housing to be doing.
55:37 The 21st century stuff I think is important, but a lot of that has to do with determining T.O.T. No, it doesn't. Because that's kind of what I understood from Holler, is that there's a way, the new technology gives us a way to figure out who's paying T.O.T. and who's not. And for me, that's more of a town kind of,
56:08 It has to do with determining if somebody owns an apartment building that is legally zoned for nightly rentals, that heretofore has been renting those properties out for long-term rentals, six months, nine months for a year. The economics of it today are such that it is enormously advantageous for that fourplex owner to say, I can make a lot more money if I start putting
56:36 These units for a nightly rental program, for weekend rentals and things like that. This is the shared economy that is changing the way we all live. We do not have the information. We've heard all kinds of anecdotal stories. I think I'm agreeing with you. Good. But the question is, I think it benefits more the town because it's a TOT question. They're losing TOT. No, we're getting to TOT. I understand the way you're interpreting it is that it does affect housing.
57:06 It affects housing. Okay, but I think the impetus would be more along the lines of it's a TOT loss that we're affecting and you have a TOT committee set to find as many TOT violators as possible. I mean, that's kind of the way I'm reading that. But I want to make sure that I'm clear about this because the facts matter here. The town could be perfectly happy, I would not be happy, to legally collect the TOT on these units that are being legally rented.
57:32 It's not a TOT question. The question is, are we losing housing units because the people who own these duplexes and triplex and fourplexes are now, rather than renting on a long-term basis, are choosing to rent legally. We're getting the TOT. That's all fine. But we're losing those units to short-term nightly rental propositions, which is significantly orders of magnitude more profitable than long-term rent. So I'm going to get a little wonkish, but
58:01 My understanding is that we need a baseline. Yeah. And we would use the database plus the first run of the data miner to say, here's where we are today. Get that baseline set. And the data miner's already running. The 2800 number or whatever. The town's already buying and already running. No one may aren't. We will be considering it in the next couple months. Well, if the town chooses to do that. Correct. Then it will be tied to the GIS. Correct. Yeah, and all that. So it's not a separate effort.
58:30 It's simply a matter of taking the parts we already have or may soon have and tracking the outputs. Correct. So I'm listening to this argument going, wait a minute, we have the data. I think this piece is relatively straightforward should the town choose to pursue the data mining effort. If they don't...
58:54 I think I'm probably on board with Kirk. I don't see this $250,000 being appropriate to that because that's really a TOT effort. But if the town isn't tracking which properties are collecting transient occupancy tax and which ones are being rented somehow, then I think the town has a huge problem because it has no idea where it is. I think John's point is that there is a spinoff.
59:20 Benefit to knowing what housing is being lost. I have no argument with that. But I guess going back to the primary thing is trying to track how much TOT they can figure out how to gain. So I guess, again, I want to be very clear about this. If the apartment complexes convert to nightly rentals, the town makes more TOT.
59:45 We would not be making, if the units are rented long term, we don't make any TOT on that. Right? We don't make any TOT on that. So it's not a TOT question. It is specifically a housing question. Because if you frame it as a TOT question, the town would be very happy to say, take every unit in town and convert it to nightly rentals. We'll make a lot more TOT, but there's no place for anybody to live anymore.
1:00:08 That's why it's, these wires are crossing. It's very important to be looking at these issues that they are moving across heretofore historic boundaries. They are not the way we're used to looking at these things. And it's not a TOT question. No, no, I don't think anybody said it. I think what Larry would, let me try and paraphrase. What I thought Larry was saying was that the data collection is driven by the town's need for TOT.
1:00:37 The fact that it provides ancillary information to the town about housing and to us about housing is a bonus. But it's not designed, I mean, it should serve that function. But to be clear, to extract that data and to make it useful, you have to tell the thing that's mining the data to do it. Right. That's what I said to begin with. Exactly. So it's very important to understand that there's a benefit to housing.
1:01:05 If the town contracts this data mining thing in this robot from the housing perspective to say to the town, when you contract for those services, we want to make sure that you are generating and providing us data that is useful for the housing analysis. And if this board says, we don't think it's useful, this is a TOT thing, this is the town's problem, fine, we'll just hire a robot and we'll just stick with TOT enforcement and what's happening to housing will be a mystery.
1:01:32 We will have no anecdotal information. All we'll have is anecdotal information. We'll have no facts. We'll just have, well, we think it's happening, but we won't have the information to back up to know what's going on. I think both the town's housing element and our strategic plan, we know there's an impact on housing. There's a shortage of housing. We know it from applications. We know it from waiting lists. We know it from phone calls. We know it from realtors. We know it from
1:02:02 Property managers, we know it from retail owners who can't find people to live here. We know this. Anecdotally, we know it. Anecdotally, but it's like, you know, it's one of these things that's, if you don't believe it, then you're in some other planet. So my point is, with this scope of work, this draft scope of work, let's get facts. Let's get specific numbers.
1:02:32 That are based on using these tools so we know what the hell we're dealing with. And I'm not arguing against that, but I have to kind of agree with what Kurt is saying is that, look, even if we went through this and did all this stuff, the problem is there's no funding.
1:02:53 For Mammoth Lakes Housing or anywhere. I am trying to do everything I can to bring the money back. But if I come in here and I hear things like, we're going to take $250,000 that we've had two meetings on, I feel blindsided, Kirk, to be honest with you. You could have easily picked up the phone and said, look, I don't support this. I want to go into this meeting. That's just basic common courtesy to a board member. I'll just stop with that.
1:03:19 That we need, there is a way to bring this money back, there's a way to fund this. I'm doing everything I can to get us there. But if every time we try to take a step forward, we're going to take nine steps backwards into the past, we're not going to get anywhere. This is going forward. This is not, if every time we sit in this body, it's like, oh my gosh, we lost the 2002A money. Oh my gosh, we lost the inclusionary. We are trying to move forward. And every time I come in here, it's like, no.
1:03:48 There's a silver bunny from 10 years ago with a bankruptcy. That's what needs to get our attention. I'm trying to get us to a place to bring the funding back, but we've got to start moving forward. I think what we need to do is, I think we can work out it.
1:04:04 Compromise or whatever you want to call it here on this because I don't think this is going to cost $250,000. So that's if we're going to talk about numbers. There's no price tag on this. If it's asking a robot to do something, it can't cost that much money. I mean, how much does that cost for you to ask it? The robot thing is separate. That's not the part of this. That's that section. That's that section here. So I mean, if we're getting hung up on that one section. The other question that I do have, though, in talking about the robot and the information that will get spit out in the 21st century challenges, that section there.
1:04:33 Do you anticipate, John, that where we're at now and the information we'll get, will it actually be able to tell us how many units which are now collecting TOT used to be?
1:04:45 Long-term rentals. Is there a way to go back? This goes to Bill's point about setting the baseline. No, we have to start now. You have to get a baseline. You have to start now. And we'll see a trend over time to see where this is going. But don't we anticipate that already now we've lost a lot of them? Yes. So there's no number. It's all anecdotal. It's all anecdotal to this point. But we still have to get a number. We could go back and look. Yeah. There's some things we might be able to.
1:05:10 Fair enough. But it's not going to be the punch of a button. It's not going to be the punch of a button, and it's not going to be accurate. It's not going to be approximate. I have a couple of questions. When the meetings happened with Mr. Gregory, were any other, and maybe I'm going backwards and I apologize, but were any other options given to him for uses of this $250,000? Or was it, hey, you know, I...
1:05:38 Mr. Gregory would like to give $250,000 and we said that's great. We'll use it how you want it or have we approached any other options? So this, my conversation with Mr. Gregory, this is not exclusive. There's no dollar signs assigned to this. But this was to try to find common ground to get started with the money. What is, where are we on the same page?
1:06:01 This thing, I believe, represents common ground between whatever his interests are and the interests of Kirk and Jennifer and Mammoth Lakes Housing, as we articulated. This is not the whole $250,000. But this, it gets us to the key thing here, which is policy recommendations to town council. These policy recommendations could be very broad. They could be very large. But I think if we update the needs assessment and we've got a sense we need this.
1:06:28 We know we're losing this. This is just another opportunity to go to the council with fresh rationale that says you have got to start funding, putting money aside to buy dirt, to buy, because the key thing that underlines all this stuff is, this is the point about federal funding and state funding and all the rest of it. We have to be dealing with this problem with our own resources. There is no cavalry that's coming to the rescue.
1:06:56 And we have to put rationale and very specific policy challenges in front of the policymakers, being the council, to say, this is what you're looking at. If we don't start putting money aside to buy land and to acquire buildings, you are not going to have a community here because our current zoning has got us in a situation where there's no place for anybody to live here anymore because all the landlords are putting their stuff.
1:07:20 On Airbnb and VRBO. And that's a narrative that I think is compelling to a council that says, you're right, we've got to do something about this. And you think that we need that other than the conversations that have already gone on about a housing crisis? Yes, because a housing, we're living in the information age. Yeah. So to say, hey man, there's a problem. Well, everybody knows there's a problem. The degree to which we can use tools and use data to make data
1:07:49 Based decisions to say, look, this is exactly what the problem looks like. That's the unique opportunity that we have now with this general scope of work to put something in front of decision makers that says, this is specific. We all know there's a problem. Now we can describe it very specifically. Well, I guess the part that I'm struggling with in this proposal is this paragraph of the 21st century challenges of who should pay for that.
1:08:17 I think that's more clearly on the town side of things. I'll look forward to a vote of the board. Okay, but I think that's probably something that his data, that they've been presented, they didn't come to the housing board to present this, the company, I think, that he's talking about. They came to the town, said, look, we can help you out here. We can figure out what losses you're doing on TOT side of things, and we can pinpoint those, and we have this new data, this robot, or whatever you want to call it.
1:08:47 Figure that out. Incidentally, it tells you some more information about housing. It won't unless we ask it to tell us that. Yeah, and I don't, I think, as I understand it, the $250,000 was more along the lines of, look, let's inventory of housing, let's get, see what the build-out analysis is, kind of an update of things to see if there is a standard. And I don't know if it takes $250,000 or not, but.
1:09:15 It seems like it wouldn't take that. I just want to be clear to the board. All of these points in here, irregardless of cost, I reviewed, after having talked with Jennifer and Kirk, I reviewed all of these pieces with the individual who represented on behalf of his company, he was willing to invest $250,000. So all of these things, through policy recommendation, the whole thing, he said, that sounds good. That makes sense. That's going to get us to some kind of strategic direction for housing.
1:09:44 The board can do with that whatever it wants. I'm just reporting back that this was consistent with his understanding of an appropriate use.
1:09:51 For the money. And it's not all of it. It's just, this was a place to start. Okay. So I guess my, sorry. Please go ahead. My, my hang up is, and Kirk said it right at the beginning, is that at what point then, what sort of timeline are we looking at that we actually can have more housing, physical housing available in our community? This is one more study in a long line of what feels like a long line of studies that we do. When do we, when do we get something tangible?
1:10:18 And has that come up? Has that, has a timeline process happened? What's the timeline on this? If this is the impetus that we need to get council to vote and move forward? So let me, just one thing on the council side. Yeah, great. I, again, it's frustrating to come to these meetings to hear people make the representation of, hey, shady rest is good to go. We can get the grant money. The fundamental problem is that we do not own the land. And I, every time we can, every time that gets represented, we can do this tomorrow.
1:10:44 No, we cannot because we don't. Shady rest. I'm just looking at. That's what I'm saying. So we don't own the land. The council is in the process of having discussions with the property owners to do everything we can to try to acquire that property. The council is doing what it can with its power, with its authorities, to bring the property to the table and try to get a representation of what's involved in acquiring that land. We're doing what we can. I think, again, from the federal perspective.
1:11:13 I'm very concerned, and I hope we can work on this, is to get a good, reliable timeline in place for the representation of land tenure as part of the application for the cap-and-trade money to know at what date do we need to have to make a representation, and what does that representation have to say? Does it have to say ownership? Whatever it is, but that's something that I would hope...
1:11:40 We need to get that together because that's going to be part of the negotiation. So, John, what I tried to say was, you know, this needs to be done. Everything that you say, I, you know, basically agree with. It's who should pay for it. And I think that the town, you know, should step up for this particular, for what isn't.
1:12:04 What is the housing component? Maybe it's a percentage. I don't know. But the point is that, you know, that's the question before that I that I tried to present to the board. You know, should we at least ask the town council to pay for it? At least that's all I'm saying is that we should at least ask them, you know, are you, you know, would you step up and pay for this? We think it's an important and obviously you think it's important.
1:12:30 So this is what the $250,000 would be used for? No, no, no. The $250,000 is over here. Stepping up and asking that this proposal, this study that needs to be done, they should step up and pay for it. That was the only question. That's what I tried to frame it.
1:12:53 And I'm sorry I went off on other tangents and everything else and history and all that stuff. But, I mean, that's the question I want to pose to the board. Was your understanding that the $250,000 would be paying for this? Yes. And that's why I'm frustrated because I spent... Okay, so we're on two different pages here. Because I spent time and maybe political capital or whatever is representative of the town trying to, you know, working together to bring that $250,000 to contract.
1:13:22 You know, if someone sets up and says, I'm going to give $250,000 for a public benefit to this community, man, we're going to act on that, and we're going to get a scope, we're going to get deliverables, and we're going to nail that down, and we're going to thank that person for doing it. They didn't have to do it, but we're going to bring that to contract, and we're going to put it to work. And that was the time that I spent trying to bring that to y'all so we could say, okay, look, we've got...
1:13:47 An agreement with the person who says they want to do it, it looks basically like this. It's not the whole thing, but we could get started with this. And I'm frustrated because I show up at a public meeting to find out, no, we want to ask the council to pay for this. And that's, I don't understand that to me. It's provocative and I think it's unnecessary. You met with Rusty without ever informing me. You just admonished me. Oh, Kirk, Kirk. You did. No, no.
1:14:18 Kirk, I met with you and Jennifer. No. And I told you, and I said, I'm going to go meet with Rusty. I met with Rusty. I reported back to you at a follow-up meeting, and I said, these are all the things that I discussed with Mr. Gregory. These are the components of things that he thinks make sense, and he's saying, yeah, that's a good place to start with $250,000. I very specifically made those representations, and for you to say that I didn't do that, someone's hallucinating here, because that's exactly what happened.
1:14:46 And the only reason why this is in front of this body with any degree of confidence is to represent to y'all, look, we put this in front of Mr. Greger and he thinks this basically makes sense. It doesn't obfuscate the, I mean, it doesn't avoid the question, should we ask the town council to pay for this? Put it to the board.
1:15:06 Do you guys need to ask more questions? Yes. It's okay. It's okay for me to be voted down. I mean, I hope you guys understand that. I'm not, I mean, you know, to me, when I went back and looked at it, I know it needs to be done, and I think that, I think the onus of it lays at the foot of the town council. Bill? Yeah. So, going back through your, the outline that was in the packet.
1:15:42 And looking at the different tasks. We've got a bunch of different things. The housing needs assessment needs to be done. We should probably get that done. I'm not talking about who should pay or not pay. And I think that what I heard from everybody was, yeah, everybody agreed that a five-year-old housing needs assessment's out of date, particularly given the state of the economy, when it was written in the state of the economy today.
1:16:13 And so that needs to be done. If I just have one point. The housing needs update was not part of my conversation with Mr. Gregory. It came primarily from Jennifer, I'm assuming, and Kirk. I think it's an entirely important thing to do, and I would advocate going back to Mr. Gregory to say this is important and we should add this in there. So I just want to make that clear. I'm not sure how you could actually implement a strategy without doing it. Sure. To me it was implicit. Sure. But that was the other question I had, is do we need to take our work program back to the mountain and say,
1:16:43 You know, here are the items we think. We think they're going to cost $80,000 or whatever it is. And, you know, are you good with that as a starting point? But I don't want to get there yet. So the next question I'm going through is we have the database. And I see no reason not to move forward really promptly with this to put these questions out there. You know, how much I think it's easy to know. I don't think it's changed in
1:17:12 Significantly in about eight years. So I think if you went back to some of the old town work on density, you'd find the answers to all these questions. But have the county GIS write the answer, write down the questions you want to have a report answer and have them run the report. And I think, you know, maybe there's some ground truth thing needed, but I bet it's 95% accurate, which is probably good enough for our purposes.
1:17:41 The data mining becomes an interesting question. And that is, my understanding was that the town was looking at having, was it host compliance? Yes. Do this. I agree that if all host compliance did was look at TOT, we might not get the answers we want. Yes. But I think it's a simple addition to tag onto that to say we need, you know, we need to know a baseline and we need to know how it's changing as things go forward.
1:18:12 And I think it ties back to the units in the GIS. I don't think that's complicated. And whereas I think if we were to pay for a standalone data mining effort, you know, run over multiple years, I think that might get complicated and expensive. I don't know. I don't know. How much is host compliance asking? Does anybody know? It's a six-figure. It's a fixed six-figure proposition. Annually.
1:18:37 Annually. And the return that communities, the idea of this is you will get back from having hard facts and figures, remittles, compliance, all the rest of that kind of stuff. What I'm suggesting, though, is that the $250,000 would not suffice to fund 10 years' worth of host compliance data so that we could really track this. If we don't piggyback with the town, I'm not sure how we make that part work.
1:19:07 And so I'd like to do it. I'd love to have the data. I want to be partners with the town to make sure we get what we need out of it if they go forward. If they don't, then I think we have to revisit the whole question. And I think that feeds into the 21st century challenges because that is what's going to advise that. Then finally, we've had this discussion before about whether or not a build-out analysis
1:19:36 Some people like taking the five-year bites. Some people think it's worth doing some long-range planning to make sure we don't paint ourselves into a corner. And I'm in the latter school, but that hasn't always been the way things have gone. So we have to decide what kind of analysis we want to do. Those are basically the four tasks we have. Some of those we could ask the town to pay for.
1:20:07 I'm not sure what, you know, maybe the mountain keeps their money. But on the other hand, we can also take ownership of the housing needs assessment, make that happen, and make it work in a way that supports the communities and the mountain's objectives. You know, I want to get it done. I don't give a damn who pays for it.
1:20:44 I think we should ask the council first, and if they say no, or if they want to break it down into component parts, then it's fine. But I think we have a responsibility, or at least I think I have a responsibility to, these are things that are normally done under our funding. But if we have a donor who wants to donate their money for it.
1:21:12 Then you have to ask the question, what other things could that money be used for? And Bill just said, though, or there's maybe no money. I mean, if it's money for this and that money with the town gets saved to use for something else. I want to make sure you're using a portion. Yeah, and I guess, again, I come back to the number.
1:21:34 Are you saying, are you feeling, I don't know what the number is, I'm sorry. I don't feel comfortable making any decision until I personally would know what number if we're asking our town to pay $20,000, $100,000, like that to me makes a very big difference. So I, I mean, I, I don't feel like there's even a decision for me to be made tonight for lack, for lack of information. I have some estimate on what a housing assessment would cost, probably. I mean, we know what the last one cost. Yes.
1:22:02 I think this is an update. The last time we did it, we did a full-blown new needs assessment. And we don't need to do that significant because we already have done most of the work. We've talked about we're going to do interviews with lenders. We're going to incorporate some of the work the town's already procured through BBC to do.
1:22:25 Actual surveys using some of that data and other things that I've got here bulleted to do the update. I think the needs assessment is maybe, I'm just going to throw a number out there without having any real sound idea, but 25,000 maybe. Our last one was 60, and it was full-blown, you know, on-the-ground surveys.
1:22:55 Much more in-depth, because now all we're doing is updating that figure. It doesn't need to be as much. I would guess that this is maybe $100,000 based on very preliminary conversations and not understanding all the in-depth intricacies between this and with the consultant that we consider. I think the county would essentially ask us to pay for them running the report.
1:23:26 I don't know. I think that the last time I did those reports, I worked with the town and their planning staff, and there was no fees, so I don't know. I'm not sure. What was the question, Bill? Basically, by the county, if we said, here are a couple of reports we'd like you to run off your existing database, would they charge us for them?
1:23:52 If I could just, to that point, I've asked. I think it would be very much money. Well, I've communicated with the county GIS people. You know, they, if they say, if the question is, can you just run a report for the APN numbers? Fine, that's not the issue. The issue is the changing use of what's happening in these units per the zoning. And they do not have that data. We haven't gotten there. There's a bunch of questions on this list. Right. What's the number of units by APN and zone?
1:24:22 What's the density by zone? All this other stuff. How much capacity do we have? That they can run. That theoretically they could run, yes. Yeah. I mean, it's true. They, you know, the assessor knows what a building was, you know, what the purpose the building was constructed for. They have no idea what it's being used for today unless somebody's come in for a change of use or change of zone. Well, but that, again, that's where we get into all the other subsequent steps. That is a whole different exercise, I agree.
1:24:51 I'm asking about this one. So, and honestly, short of, you know, I don't think you can put somebody out there in the street. Maybe you can. Just go around and knock on every door and see if you can find out what's going on. But unless you have the information either on TOT certificates or other business licenses, business tax certificates, you don't really know. And I think that's been the issue with the town's data to date.
1:25:23 And that is their job to come up with that. But anyway, so the basic land use report, I think the county can run for a nominal fee. So we're relatively low cost right now to get out of the baseline data, and that's probably where we should start. And then we have to figure out if the town's going to go into data mining, and if so, if we can piggyback on that. And if not,
1:25:53 Then what do we do? Well, again, and the point is that you have someone who is willing to put up to pay for this entire integrated effort to cover every single one of the bases in this proposal. This is consistent with their representation to make the money. Let's have Kirk's vote about putting this whole thing to the town and making the town pay for the whole thing. I would want to come back with a motion that says we have someone willing to start writing checks.
1:26:23 Right now to get this entire thing moving tomorrow. You know, and this, again, it goes to the nature of why does this body, why does this organization exist? Are you going to, are you saying the six, it's going to cost six figures to do the data mining for the VRBO, et cetera? And that would be the town's expense. The town would pay for that. That's the town's part. Correct. So the piggybacking part would be the part that we're talking about.
1:26:52 Correct. And it's going to take some work with some consultants, some people that Jennifer knows, who are going to be able to say, okay, we have the opportunity to piggyback on this data mining tool. Okay. What questions do we need to put into the robot that it's going to ask that are going to be specific to how to. So however that happens, that's the part that we're talking about as part of this study. Absolutely.
1:27:18 Not the six-figure parts of the town. No. Exactly. That's right. And they haven't decided on that yet, right? No. But I would anticipate that we're probably going to pursue that because we have no way of enforcing TOT in a reliable way. The representation is that theoretically you'll get all your money back in a little bit more by doing that. Exactly. By getting everybody. That's what they say. And that's what's been happening in Truckee and other places.
1:27:46 And we have no way of doing it either, so we think it's a good thing at this point. But it's not the same scale at all. No. But it's an opportunity. We could say, look, we need you, okay, robot, we need you to ask these eight, nine, ten questions, which feeds into the data that Bill's talked about coming out of the GIS that says this is all the stuff we've got.
1:28:07 How are uses being done? But we need someone who's going to be project managing all this stuff to coordinate all the pieces, to act the right questions across the different platforms, to develop the data, to put it in front of the policymakers that says, hey, you're losing your housing. You're losing the places for people to live in this community. And here are the facts. Here are the numbers that back this up. It's no longer anecdotal. It's being translated into specific facts. And you go to the town council and say,
1:28:35 Does the zoning that you have that was written in 19-whatever, does that currently support a community like this, which is directly in the crosshairs of these multi-billion dollar companies coming out of Silicon Valley? Do you have the tools that you need to house and have a community in the 21st century, given what it is that you're up against?
1:28:56 Interesting. I think those are two separate questions because I think even without the 21st century, you might find you didn't have the zoning you needed. And Bill, that's a great point. And I would love to have that point brought up to take it. That's what the database can tell us that very quickly. Right. And I would love to have those questions in front of council because I'm not convinced that the zoning that was done 20, 30, 40 years ago, because if it was right and it was working, we wouldn't be hearing, man, there's no place for anybody to live around here.
1:29:26 So, is another way to redress those challenges. And that's going to get to Tom's point about, you know, how we're creative going forward with different opportunities. So. Do you guys mind if I just fell a little bit, I mean, to me this is a very, just maybe a relational database with, you got the land use map behind you, properties that are allowed to have transit rentals, everything's got unique APN. Yeah. You run the TOT report with unique APN.
1:30:04 The TOT assumption is if somebody's collecting TOTs in the loud zone, it's not, but it's probably the legal realm, once you have to figure that out. Right. And then you just meld the database with the APNs of the people who are collecting TOTs, and then you can look at the total inventory of the units and say, okay, this percentage of them are on nightly metals that aren't available for long term. You know everything that's in RMH1, where it's referred to now.
1:30:34 The Sierra Valley sites is the other high density zone that's non-transient, right, and that's, and you can assess based on the build, what's built on specific sites, or what's on each site that's underdeveloped, right, that's allowed by 10 units, that's 10. 12. In the Sierra Valley sites. 12 is a high density, the low density is one in the Sierra Valley sites. So I'm going to get a theoretical number of, okay, we have underdeveloped properties that could be developed in there, so let's, let's start implementing a strategy and looking at those.
1:31:05 Properties and where are there opportunities where we can tear down a whole chunk and maximize the densities or, you know, create quality housing. There's a lot of people who don't like that idea. But yeah, to me, it seems like it's not a difficult task and it's largely just going to be created through the existing database. It just needs somebody who knows how to do queries on databases. It's pretty simple. Yeah, I think if we...
1:31:34 If we said what we wanted the outputs to be, somebody could run... I think if we said what we wanted the outputs to be, I think we could get our baseline pretty quickly. And it might not be 100% accurate, but it'd be close. And what matters over time is that this works over time. So you're not worried about whether your baseline is absolutely accurate, but you're looking at trends. You're looking at what's happening year over year, and you're seeing where things are moving.
1:32:06 If you set up the templates, then we have the data updates year to year, you can update your internet. Yeah, sure. Because then we're looking at, and we may find, I don't know what we're going to do, we may find that the current zoning we have in place right now is setting us up for real challenges. And that require policy responses to it. But if we don't have that information, we're just guessing.
1:32:47 Again, just going back to the anecdotal feedback, I've got my daughter's, she has a friend, she invited up from down south to us, she's working at Canyon Lodge Rounds, and Bonnett Beach, there's all kinds of people in it. Yeah, there are. And, yeah, people are, you know, where they can couch earth and everything else.
1:33:27 Some people honestly prefer to be in their cars because they just want to save the money. Which again kind of based on one of the points I brought to you guys back when you were doing your different types of housing product that can be part of the solution. And that was one of the things that we found through, you know, a lot of people care about how it suggested that hospital style is part of the solution, at least for the seasonal type employees who just want cheap and just a warm place to sleep. And again, that takes pressure off, you know, year-round or the month-to-month type.
1:34:13 So it seems that there's three things that are for the board. Either we can ask the town to completely fund this, we can ask them to fund part of it, or we can just go to the mountain and ask them to fund it, the whole thing. So am I correct? Is that the three options?
1:34:48 And I haven't been in any communications with anybody from the mountain, and as I said before, I really don't care who pays for it, I just would like to get it done. I'm pretty agnostic, you know, have you talked to your boss about it? Remember, we're just asking, when it comes to the council, it's just asking them, you know, to fund it. It's not, if they say no, then it drops back into our lot, our laps.
1:35:19 And the other part of it is that fun part of it. I mean, it seems that the town should be funding. I mean, from listening to Bill talk and Larry, I mean, there's some of this needs to be assumed by the council if we're assuming that the mountain, from discussions that have taken place, you know, the mountain agrees to this.
1:35:45 I think that there's a legitimate argument that the town should step up. What would trigger the town to do a new housing needs assessment? Well, they're kind of doing one. They're doing a small one with BBC through the county as part of their housing element update. It's very small. It's a resident and an employer survey. So it's just a needs assessment based on those things. So we're talking about taking...
1:36:14 We're not going to duplicate their effort. No, we're going to use the, incorporate that data. That's what I interpret that. So, I guess then, they're already spending money on part of it. We're picking up part of it with the mountains money, if that's what we do. Anyway. And the part I was concerned about was just, and I think you clarified it, John, about the six-figure part is going to be the town's part anyway.
1:36:44 And we would piggyback whatever amount that was on top of that if we could. That seems to be reasonable. But should the town pay for that too? I'm not sure. I'm kind of leaning toward an expenditure from Rusty to get this done.
1:37:04 But spending the whole $250,000, that seems way overkill. This is not $250,000. I never said this was. And never put a figure on that. Rusty said up to $250,000. It's really just a number. I think we should focus on getting this out. What do we need to get? So if the town and the county are already doing some things, and we want to piggyback on those to...
1:37:33 Get meaningful housing data out of those things. So, basically, it's what we're talking about doing is augmenting the other programs, either existing or proposed, in a way that we get meaningful housing data that we can use to create a workable strategy.
1:38:02 The town's already, I guess, committed their part, they think. Which part? Well, they're paying BBC. What's BBC? There's a small study happening right now. Okay, there's no staff here, so I can't speak to that, so I don't know. Yeah, I can't have been involved in it. Sure, sure. They will or won't be paying for host compliance. Correct. And they've already, the town and the county have already paid to build the database. We just have to go do a little digging.
1:38:32 So I have a question along these lines. The first thing is to staff is whether you guys feel that you have
1:38:43 The capacity to take something like this on or if you need to bring in someone to help you with this. I would hope, I would suggest that you anticipate bringing someone on to do all this, that you guys supervise what they're doing, but bring someone on to do all this coordination and to make sure that you're not spending all your time running around chasing a lot of rabbits all over the place. You've got someone who's
1:39:07 Doing the coordinates to bring all these data resources together. You guys obviously oversee it and you make the presentations to the board, but I would think that you would want some staff to do this. And I think that while I agree with Bill about the nature of the databases, and Tom said the same things, theoretically these things are there, but...
1:39:23 This effort would be querying of these databases types of questions that they may not have been asked before. We're going to be looking at these data resources in ways that maybe they haven't really been exposed that could uncover all kinds of weird problems and things that I would hate you guys to have to get sucked into this stuff. And I think that there's enough money within this to deliver this thing to allow for some taking on some part-time contract work to help you guys get this thing done so you don't get drowning in this thing. But that's a thought.
1:39:52 Well, and I think that's part of the scope. Okay, good. I think that that is something that the contractor will do. Okay, good. They will hire a sub to do some of the guinea pig work. Do we need additional staff support?
1:40:05 I don't believe so. If something happened and I felt like they weren't. Because I would encourage you to make sure that you guys get plenty of other things to do without this. Right. To make sure you look at this and say, look, we need, and if this thing is a scope of work that makes sense to this board, we want to proceed with it, I would recommend coming back to this board with, okay, this is the general area we're looking at in order for us to deliver this.
1:40:29 We've got some additional staffing needs. We might need this. We might need that. And break this down into component parts with a consultant for this or a thing for that and maybe come back with some numbers that start looking at what we think this thing is going to look like and how to deliver it. Yeah. Yeah, for sure. I just didn't get that far into it because I wanted consensus on the scope. Understand, sure. And other things, yeah. I guess the other thing that I don't want to see happen is
1:40:58 I don't want to have this as an excuse to delay an action on Shady Rest. We waited for the Hark-Howerton plan. We're waiting for the downtown plan. We're waiting for now this to do something that's been on the books to do and is feasible to do financially for Shady Rest Parcel. I don't want to have this as another excuse not to do something there or to delay an action because
1:41:29 I don't see any relationship at all between this and shady rise, frankly. If you can see one, let me know. Because we can't do any, it's like we have studies and studies delaying what we should really have done 10 years ago. That's my point. Maybe that's not going to happen. I have the old paper printouts from about 2009 with all the parcel summaries. And I am going to bet you.
1:41:58 But there is no substantial change in land use capacity between 2009 and 2016. It's just utilization. No, it's more nightly rentals. Well, but there may be some more nightly rentals, but in terms of capacity and going forward, the need for shady rest and other vacant sites and the second stories on new commercial, you know, we don't need
1:42:27 A or B or C. We need A and B and C. We already know that, so we'll reaffirm that. I think it's great to have an overall strategy, but we already know a part of it, is what I'm saying. We already know this is the last vacant land of any substantial amount that's available to develop affordable housing on. And I don't want this to be an excuse not to do something like that.
1:42:53 But when I'm looking at what's going on now, I don't know how long it would take to do the housing needs assessment. But I'm guessing if we can define the outputs we want from the database query, that's a week or two's effort. I mean, just when Nate can actually put the staff to it. So a quick turnaround, whatever we do.
1:43:14 Right. Well, the BBC surveys haven't gone out yet. They'll go out this month. We're still finalizing them right now. But they are going out in January, February because they want to hit this winter population, the seasonal population with these surveys. So, yeah, they're going out soon. I think they'll do another round in the spring, but we could start working with the data that they get. I think this is about three months or so out, like the whole, all of this.
1:43:44 Okay. You know, local resources, strategies, presentations. It's not a year-long, it's not like an EMS study, six-month year-long study. Yeah. I'm a bit on the same page as you, Kirk. Excuse me. Sorry, Larry. You're talking there. We look up. Better looking. You are. You are. You are kind of wearing similar shirts. But, yeah, so when we, I don't know if we present things to the public or how that goes, but when
1:44:15 When the public learns, maybe they know already, that a donor wanted to give up to $250,000 and we say, this is what we chose as the best use of our money to do. Is this really what our, I mean, and I'm behind the eight ball because I wasn't involved in original conversations, but is there anything else? I guess my question is, if this isn't going to take the full $250,000, is there anything else at this point that we should be doing?
1:44:43 That needs to get done, that's high on our priority list, that's in our strategy, or is this kind of where we're at? Like you say, we don't, there's no movement currently on Shady Rest, there's not a lot of land or property to purchase or renovate. I mean, is this something that we can feel good about moving on and saying, hey, we've gotten something done in the interim without waiting and sitting on our hands?
1:45:07 If I may, I think that there is potential to do another step after this. These strategies will be just strategies. They will not be prioritized in any fashion per se because that takes community input to do prioritizing strategies. So there could be an actual another step after this.
1:45:31 That would prioritize the strategies in the strategies, not the resources and not the policy recommendations because that's under 21st century. But if you look at this, there's a menu of primary strategies to consider with potential impacts quantified where possible. But there may be 20 of them. And maybe we just, at the end of this, we say we're just going to be opportunistic and we'll just tackle them as they become available. Maybe we don't. Maybe we say, okay, well, that's a lot. Let's go do
1:46:00 you know a month-long strategy have a consultant work on actually prioritizing them just like we're doing with some of the other things right now and we've done in the past to come up with actually
1:46:15 You know, prioritization of them. I would say two things. I would say that and I would say outreach. I would say that if this is generally a direction to go in to have your team that you bring on and say, okay, where are there opportunities to get buy-in into what this happens? I'm looking at this very specifically about getting policy recommendations in front of the council and it would be very useful if these policy directions come with public buy-in that says, hey,
1:46:42 All this anecdotal stuff we've seen, great. There's some stuff behind this. The public knows what this is all about and they're engaged with it and they're helping to bring it forward. Similar to what's been going on with them.
1:46:56 White Walk Bike Ride, maybe. Yeah, even more so to say, look, because if the community, we're all hearing this is of real concern, but I think if Kirk can talk to some people and say, hey, this is all, we don't need another study, we need X, Y, and Z, and I'm talking to people, they're saying something different, we need to start getting some consensus around this, because there's going to be some lifting in here.
1:47:16 And there's going to have to be, you know, there's going to be things, there's a lot of money involved, there's going to be potentially some zoning questions, there's going to be some things that really have to be engaged with, the degree to which we're putting a good, clear strategy, which is what I heard from Mr. Gregory, a strategy for housing in front of the public, let's have some buy-in into this. So those are, those will be my thoughts. And we should have information in the housing needs update for those.
1:47:42 Families or households over 120% AMI that we talk about that missing middle 120 to 150. Sure. So that will be addressed. Exactly. The needs are specific to type and AMI. Yeah, this isn't constrained by any AMI thing. This is about... Right. This is workforce housing. Right. The community. Which is everybody. It's everybody. Exactly. Again, I think the question, and maybe I'm wrong.
1:48:11 How does this get funded? Or should part of it be funded? We should ask the town to fund part of it. Or should we just, as has been proposed, just work with the mountain and ask them to fund it? Those are the three options, I think. I don't know. I guess I would change your third option. It's not asking the mountain to fund it. It's accepting their donation because it's already been put out there, which I do think is a different...
1:48:40 You said you felt uncomfortable asking. John has talked to him, and this is acceptable to the Mountain. Well, the Mountain made a public statement at a public meeting quoted in the press. All I did was try to facilitate getting together a scope of work of what we could start working on. That's all I did. Kirk had the original conversation with Rusty, so he can speak to that. I guess I'm in general agreeing with Bill.
1:49:11 It doesn't really matter where the money comes from. We need the work done. I don't want to see a whole bunch of money spent on this, though. $250,000 doesn't seem... Let's save part of that for something. Implementation-wise, this is really the data collection phase, and a strategy is not going to arise magically out of the data. Once we have the answers to our questions...
1:49:41 Then we're going to have to use that to start building a strategy, and that may take more time and money. Well, and we have a strategic plan. Yeah. That maybe that's part that we integrate here, update that part of it based on this data and so on. And we have a housing strategy. I think a lot of people don't even know we have that. I mean, it's a... But it would be interesting... We have a whole day's workshop on, whole business.
1:50:09 Some of our strategies will need to be refined. The concept of housing above commercial. That's not a strategy until you figure out the hows. How do you make that work? What's it going to take? What's it going to cost? Up until then, it's just an idea. So it's nice to say, okay, we've got a strategy, but unless we know...
1:50:38 Where and how we're going to park the cars and what it's going to cost, what the second story is going to cost, whether we need elevators, I mean, all that stuff. So if we get to the point where we say we don't have enough raw land, we're going to have to look at the airspace, how is it going to develop? But that's got to come after the basic data. So we're talking about spending a few tens of thousands of dollars to establish the baseline.
1:51:09 Which I think is great. Here's what we have. Here's what we need. Then we've got to figure out how to merge what we have with development to get what we need. And that could take the remainder of the $250,000. Because that's, you know, you don't just sit around the table and kind of... Well, Bill, let me ask you a question on that. Because in this draft scope...
1:51:39 In the 21st century challenges and policy recommendations of town council, are you recommending that the strategic parts that you're talking about, does that, should, that sounds like that should happen prior to any policy recommendation of council, is that fair to say? Yeah, because if you recommend a policy with no idea whether it'll work, what's the point? Okay, so I'm thinking that we should add whatever you're thinking needs to go into this before it gets to council, let's add this into that scope.
1:52:07 To make sure before the thing gets to council, it's what it should be. And if you're thinking, I'm not sure exactly what you're thinking, but it sounds like you've got some idea about what it may take to do that, to take the data, to take what we're finding from all this stuff, refine it into some revised strategies that may need to go to council, let's add that to the scope. I mean, if that's what, you know, it's like this is part A, part B is what you're talking about, Bill.
1:52:38 I think it starts hitting on some of the Part B. Maybe it doesn't go through the full flesh out. Well, you know, we talk, it's sort of things get merged. So the last bullet under inventory of available housing, you know, it says include all data, da, da, da, demonstrate what types of zoning produces more local occupancy and which can inform future changes which should be made if more local occupancy is wanted. We jump from data that informs.
1:53:06 To policy recommendations without synthesizing the data into needs, directions, and policies. And so that's what we, you know, that probably is a missing gap there. So let's, what Bill just said, data synthesis into needs, whatever that is, let's add that as the first bullet above all data developed. Just put that, just put that in as the first bullet right there.
1:53:35 Well, yeah. I can work with Bill to add that. Yeah, to refine that. Yeah, because I think he was talking about the bullet up above, not the 21st century. Sure. But they both, yeah. Yeah. But I think that could be refined. I mean, this, I haven't, you know, this is very. No, it's a draft. Yeah. It's very rough. It's very much a draft. My, my, a goal has got to be that put some, let's put something together here that will, that gets in front of council with
1:54:04 Community exposure, buy-in hopefully to it. Get this thing to council. And does council then accept this and take it to Mr. Gregory? What is the next step? No, no, no, no. The scope of work, to Jennifer's point, she can work with various board members, Bill or others, whoever, to refine this thing to get into a scope that really is going to satisfy the things that we think it's going to need to be.
1:54:28 That goes to Mr. Gregory to say, Mr. Gregory, this is what we're going to do with a portion of your money with an estimated budget of this. But there's a timeline associated that says these steps, to your point, it doesn't take two years to do it. We get this thing done in a six-month window, whatever the appropriate window is, that it is driving to getting something to council so that if there need to be policy recommendations, the council is taking the policy recommendations.
1:54:55 And doing things that are necessary. If we go through this whole step and they're not necessary, then we're good the way that we are. But I personally think in this new environment that we're living in where there are challenges out there that were not contemplated when the zoning of the town was put together a long time ago, and we're hearing anecdotally it's affecting everybody's quality of life, I can't imagine there aren't going to be some policy recommendations from the board or from the folks that Jennifer's talking to saying, look, all these other communities, we know what all this
1:55:23 We're all dealing with these similar kinds of things, but we have an opportunity to maybe try to get it right. And I think that would be a good deliverable back to Mr. Gregory to say over a six-month period, this is going to get in front of the council for their consideration and recommendation that is a strategy that, I mean, you could take the strategic plan you've got, the data could just say, look, it's going to move, it could move a couple things around, it might not. And Jennifer, you'll go through this and kind of make sure it's in a chronological order, but a working order of...
1:55:53 I was just thinking that bullet point right underneath 21st century challenges that all data developed through efforts almost feels like it can go above to the inventory. It's maybe a subset of inventory. And then the policy recommendations almost come very last at the end. Yeah. Some of this was last minute. Yeah.
1:56:18 Back and forth between John just trying to get it published. Just get it. Yeah, just want to get something in front of you guys, give you generally what it's like, but I think we're looking for the kinds of gaps that Bill's identified. It's like, okay, we need this piece, we need that piece, and I think Larry, the recommendation, you know, this should not take, we should put this, if we can do it in six months or something like that, it would be great. But again, I go back to getting some money for you guys for staffing so that, you know, you can drive this thing along and you've got the tools and the bodies you need to make it happen.
1:56:46 Typically, we do not focus on seasonal resident seasonal workers. We may focus, we include year-round resident seasonal workers, but in our... What do you mean by we don't focus? Our product or our needs assessment? Well, I would argue maybe both, but I want to make sure the needs assessment catches the seasonal...
1:57:13 Resident. Oh, yeah. No, we've been working hard to make sure it got incorporated in BBC's surveys because it wasn't being captured adequately. Typically, I mean, we would not, actually, we wouldn't be necessarily, we, as Mammoth Lakes Housing, wouldn't be providing housing for those people, but an overall community strategy that's looking at housing needs might at least anticipate what, because back to Tom's point, and this was made in the community conversation.
1:57:42 This point was made by a couple people that, you know, when I first moved here, you know, I was really happy to have a sofa. And, you know, you know, I slept on a floor for a couple months and that was just fine. It wasn't a long-term solution. But, so, understanding, you know, what the needs of the different groups are. I just want to make sure we are really clear about...
1:58:09 Counting as many of those people as we can so that we're really clear about whose needs we're serving and whose we're not. I'll just add to that to make sure that we're talking about summer and winter because we've got a summer workforce that doesn't necessarily stay through. No, definitely.
1:58:28 It's one of the things I've worked with these folks on that I'm talking with about this, but also with BBC to make sure that we're asking about which seasons are you hiring? How many people for this season? What for that season? Yeah, a lot of good questions. Do we ask the employers if they know if their seasonal employees are also seasonal residents? Yeah, we ask if they're commuting in, where do they live, have they lost employees?
1:58:57 Yeah, all kinds of questions. So far, the surveys are looking really good. Jennifer and Patricia, I would ask both of you, is there anything in here that we need to add while we have some funding, while we have some energy, we're moving on things, and the board as well, and trying to think back through our strategies and our various hard numbers that we're trying to hit on things, and is this comprehensive for us right now?
1:59:28 Sort of open it up to everybody just to be sure there's anything else we need. What I would do is I would suggest that we do a motion to give some direction to staff. Bring something back to us that is what you think it's going to take to do this. The whole thing, soup to nuts, all laid out. Put some numbers in it with a contingency. And for an extra staffing opportunity, if you think you need it, let's see what that looks like. Because I think that could determine
1:59:54 If it's a 150 number or a 7, whatever that number is, that could then, Kirk could go back to Mr. Gregory and say, look, we think we could do good work with 125 of this. You know, what do you think? And we have some great ideas for the remaining 100. And we have an idea, too, for some other things that are, but we could deliver this product, and that's done, and then the board may have some other ideas of other things to do. So the consensus I'm reading is Mammoth Mountain. We will ask them to fund this.
2:00:25 Well, I think that's the money source. I'm okay with that. Bill? And John, you're okay with that? Yeah, I'm, again, I'm a little shocked. You've advocated for that, so I just wanted to make sure. I just want to remember when we're talking about this, please everybody remember, the council every year writes a check for $2 million to a group of investors who invested in litigation against this community.
2:00:50 And we turn to our staff and say we cannot provide raises, we cannot build our staff the way we want to do this because we do not have the money to do that. And any, again, I want to reemphasize, we invest in the NGOs because we invest in their entrepreneurial spirit. We invest in their innovative and creative approach to solving problems. That's why we invest in these bodies. And I would just encourage this board to take that seriously. Thank you.
2:01:17 Yeah, I would hope that the council feels that this board is, this NGO is doing that. I'm troubled by the representation of Mr. Stapp, I have to say. I thought it was a legitimate question. Fine. Are we going to have a vote on that question?
2:01:33 No, I think there's a consensus, and there's also a consensus direction as to, Jennifer, if I understand, you're going to bring this back with some numbers on it? Yes, fleshed out with numbers. And the question I have for you, John, and well, actually the whole board, do we want to try to, when you have that ready, do we need to set up a special meeting? Because time is of the essence. Huh? Well...
2:01:59 I'm not sure. I think the February meeting, honestly, will work because that BBC survey hasn't even gone out. I think it'll go out towards the end and it'll probably have a month to circulate. So I think we'll be fine to come back at the February meeting.
2:02:19 That's right. If you're all okay with that. Hopefully it'll have some numbers. Oh yeah, no, it will have numbers. Okay. Yeah. So it'll be like a draft scope of work with project estimates that is something that is theoretically ready to go to this area or whatever to say, this is our proposal. That's right. Okay, there's a couple of things I'd just like to clarify going forward. Okay. The two items are the contracting mechanism. Yes. Is the contract between
2:02:47 The Mammoth Lakes Housing and the Ski Area for these funds, which means all the project management costs associated with that. That means contracts with consultants, cash flow, payments, all this other kind of stuff that you guys would have to do. Or is this something that the board wants the...
2:03:05 Town to do. Would it be better for MLH if the town handles all that stuff? That's a question I'd like to, we need to get that addressed. We talked about that a little bit, but that's a question I think for the group. Yeah, I mean, Mammoth Lakes Housing has worked with contractors before, certainly with the group that's doing this. This is not a, we do AP and AR, we can handle. So, but in terms of the agreement with the mountain, you guys would feel comfortable setting up the agreement with the mountain so the money would flow from the mountain to MLH directly, correct?
2:03:32 Yes, we can do that. Fine. I just want to make sure it's clear to the board. Wouldn't be it the first time. No, I understand. I just want to make sure that that's clear because, again, my expectation is that if that's the way we're going, MLH is responsible for getting it to contract, making sure this whole project happens. There's no one else to point to to say that someone else screwed something up. Fine. The second thing is I want to be clear about who the communication, who's going to be the liaison between this board and the ski area. I feel a little, I don't know, I feel
2:04:02 You understand how I'm feeling. I do not feel comfortable, whereas before this evening I was more than comfortable playing that role, I do not feel comfortable playing that role now. And I want to make sure that the board designates who is the person or the party that is the designated point of communication to the ski area for this contract. And I'd like to have a board discussion and designate that person. Jennifer should be the person, but we give her direction.
2:04:32 I guess the contract, what contract? So for example. The skier has given us money. No, no, no. Larry, for example, when the trail system, when we said to the town in the ski area, hey, if you put in $100,000, will you put in $100,000? And it was agreed. The town put in $100,000 for the planning of the trails plan, and the ski area put in $100,000.
2:05:00 Then once that money was committed, there was an agreement, there was an MOU that said, this is how the invoices will be paid. This is how we will do this. There is work involved in doing this. There needs to be an agreement between, if we're going to go out and spend $125,000 for all these consultants and all the stuff that we're doing, we have to have some kind of an agreement with the ski area that says, okay, in return for these dollars paid in this manner,
2:05:30 Third up front, third in the middle, third at the end, we will deliver you this work product. That agreement's got to be in place. This work product isn't for the skier. No, but there hasn't. This isn't something we're doing for the skier. No, no, but they're providing the money. There's got to be an agreement. That's the funding source. So do you propose not having an agreement with the funding source? Well, it'd be very minimal. Here, we're taking your money. We're going to produce this product.
2:05:54 There has to be an agreement. It's not for you. It's not for the ski area we're doing this. I understand that, but there's got to be an agreement. We can't start hiring contractors and doing these people if we don't have any... If we have the funding, we can hire anyone. I'm not sure that this is... I don't think we're being hired as a contractor, John. Okay, so again, it's a very simple question. How are we going to memorialize the arrangement between MLH and Mammoth Mount Ski Area for the expenditure of this money?
2:06:22 How are we going to do that? Well, let's say it's $100,000. Okay? Here's the agreement. We take your money. We spend it this way. Thank you very much. And here's the product we're going to get. That's the contract. I mean, how is this a... One question I have, though, then, is if we take the $100,000, but we go over and we need to go back. So I think where you're saying about a third now, a third in the middle, a third making sure... Do you think someone's just going to give us a check for $100,000? Well...
2:06:52 Yeah. Larry, come on. You've been in government too long. No, I do. Honestly, you've been in government too long. That's what happens if you're a developer. Before you start any work, here's the check. For the whole thing. For the whole thing. With nothing written down in terms of deliverables and what your expectations is. You could set it up in three payments or something. I don't care. That's all I'm asking for. Very simple. The contract, John. The question really is not what you're asking for. It's what the mountain wants is, you know.
2:07:21 Assurance that they're going to get their money's worth, and honestly the person that should be negotiating that, just like with all the others, is the Executive Director. Yeah.
2:07:30 It's pretty straightforward. I mean, she's done these things before. It's not like this is anything new. No, I understand. I hope it's not $100,000. I hope it's like $20,000 or something. It's a simple question, but I think it's important that it's documented. And Jennifer, I look forward to having bring something to the board. This is what the agreement looks like. And the payment schedule is understood. And the cash flow is going to make sense. And you can be able to get the money you need to hire the people and pay everybody. And the thing's going to work. Well, if I'm a contractor working for...
2:07:59 Mammoth Lakes Housing that's going to do this work, I want to know that you have the money. Sure. Okay, so where is it? In the bank? Because I'm not going to start my work unless I have a payment schedule from you. You know, whatever this contract is, I think the mountain should give us the money for it, so we can begin the work, so we can get the contracts with whoever we're going to do. So a third, so maybe it's a third up front, third and a third and a third, or something like that. It's up to Jennifer and the mountain to work that out.
2:08:27 To us here as the board. As an example, what we did with the Trails thing, it was all on invoice. So what we did, this could be a way to do it. That was a little more laborious, and I can see why, you know, versus these other scenarios. Well, again, I just offer my experience, the way that that was done, it was done on invoice. But you were splitting the cost. And they were splitting the invoice. So the town would pay half of the invoice, the map would pay an invoice. So there's a fair amount of labor involved in doing all that. So I would just encourage you, if you're going to go there.
2:08:56 To get this thing in place, make sure, because they make, again, that's what they said to us. They said, we're not going to, we're going to pay on the invoices. Okay. So, just. Okay. I'll reach out and see what their thoughts are on it. Okay. And I think clarifying the deliverables at the end as well and what that looks like. Yeah. What is the mountain expecting? It'll all be in this document. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So, I will, I just want to say, I'm not going to do.
2:09:22 I will not provide any, I'm not going to get in the middle of anything, I'm not going to have any communication with the mountain, I'm not going to do anything on this project. If I do, I will be sure to run it through you. Okay. So I've done my bit, and I very much appreciate the consensus. I think it's a good direction. I'm looking forward to other board members providing input to get something really solid in place. But if you need me, call me, but I won't do anything. Okay, thank you. Thank you. Thank both of you guys for getting this conversation going.
2:09:50 It's exciting to be able to move on something. So you have a direction and everything? Mm-hmm. Okay, good. All right, let's move to closed session. Do you want to stay for the closed session? No. Tom, can I ask one question before you leave? Yeah. Kind of back to Larry's from your public comment. Is there any chat that if you do go to the .75, what that additional, is it RAF? What's the FAR? FAR. What it looks like, like if it is going to be the...
2:10:19 And so I think that's sort of the idea of the strategy is like, okay, well, you know.
2:11:23 What are the pieces that are going to solve the problem? And knowing what those needs are, then actively outreaching to the developers as they, you know, being out in front of it and say, hey, we want to partner with you. Guess what? We have money. We can do this. We'll cost you anything. We'll fund that part of it. Why don't you work with us and let's solve this problem? I like that part. Where's the money? The money will come, but I want to follow what Tom is saying, to encourage members of this board.
2:12:07 To engage and talk with and offer partnership opportunities to the development community. As a board member, how do we do that? Because I don't know those people. I'm on the MLH board. I understand what this far, you've got an opportunity. I want to follow up with you on that. How do we know who those people are? How do we get that? Go talk to them. But I don't even know who to talk to. I don't know. We'll tell them. The community development department say, hey, if somebody comes in here and is talking to you about commercial properties on...
2:12:37 Please put them in touch with us. Because we want to have a discussion with them about things that we'd like to accomplish and how we can partner with them to solve everybody's needs, you know. So, you know, I think that's the outreach that needs to happen, and I think you guys need to be paying attention to, you know, the Planning Commission agendas and everything else, or hopefully before things get on the agenda, you're aware of, oh, God, this guy's looking to build a market here. He doesn't want to put anything other than a market on that side. You know, let's go.
2:13:07 Well, this is one of the things I brought up to the county council when they were talking about this, is that, you know, in all the other jurisdictions where they have commercial zones and they look for more excuse, they have requirements of affordable housing. It doesn't just happen because they have a non-profit or CHOTO or even a for-profit affordable housing developer coming in and saying, oh, we want to partner with you. Well, they may want to partner with them, but they don't typically get engagement.
2:13:38 They really just don't get engagement unless there is a requirement because there is not the same return on investment. The ROI is different and that is how it happens and until we make it a mandatory requirement we're just hoping.
2:13:55 For those scenarios to happen. And I said that it... Well, you're hoping if you're just sitting on your hands, if you're out there really practically going out there... But also, Jennifer, the point about this minimum far, and that's one of the reasons why when I was leading the council discussion on this, I was personally quite emphatic about bringing back a recommendation because I think that's, even though that requirement may not be there yet, that may be something that we need to start working on to get that language to come forward. But if there's a threshold...
2:14:24 That says, look, you've got to meet this threshold, and it's not perfect, and if you say, well, I don't want to meet the threshold, okay, well, then you can appeal it. Well, what other things could they bring to the table to get them over that threshold or to make it something that can work? The reason I asked Tom when I discuss structured parking, huge, we've talked about parking districts, shared structures, we've talked about that. My concern with the FAR,
2:15:13 The minimum FAR is when that FAR gets, there's a threshold of which it pushes it into commercial parking. And suddenly the cost per usable in that square foot skyrockets. And so I like the idea of requiring the minimum FAR, but there may be an unintended consequence lurking out there in terms of project feasibility.
2:15:50 Sure, but I would encourage also, we have the walk, bike, ride recommendations will be coming forward in the next month or two, and that could be an excellent opportunity to look at, you know, that could be a good place to kind of play that out. And because maybe if the parking districts are in place and we're working with the county, we've got an EIFD together and we're doing some of this public infrastructure, that could be a way that maybe we get to where it is we want to go. It's just one of those unintended consequences that it's witnessed before.
2:16:21 I'm aware of it. I don't want to stop the process. I think we're kind of off the... Sorry to keep you. I just had a... You're going to report out the action taken? The bill moved to option one, which is to buy back the property during one of the two option time periods. The housing director, executive director, was directed to adopt...
2:17:01 Proceed with option one. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Sorry. That's okay. And pass 5-0. And pass 5-0. We are adjourned.