TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2017

Mammoth Lakes Recreation

· recording 3 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

359 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

5:39 Thanks, Dan Holler, Town Manager. I think the board's aware of the work the town's doing, the walk, bike, ride program that's out there. We're also working with Alta Consultant right now to try to provide some additional input on specific areas and looking at inviting stakeholders in from different areas and also would invite folks off of MR to be engaged in that.

6:08 If you have an interest in doing so, if you get a hold of Sandra in our planning department, she's kind of setting up that stuff, so it's not a formal appointment of people, but if you have an interest. But we're looking at some of the different key elements in the proposed work program that came out, the proposed document. Kind of looking at our downtown connection points, the trail points, bikeway points, how does that tie into some of the transit hubs within the downtown Main Street, kind of that core area, and then how does that ultimately connect out.

6:37 And then as you go out, there was a lot of discussion there about how does the transit work going out into the Forest Service lands, if you will, in our planning area, how does that reach out, you know, the impact on trailheads like in the Lakes Basin or other places of that nature. And then also looking at some of the key portals that we need to make sure that we get people out to as you look at long-term planning and stuff, you know, the redo of the main lodge, for example.

7:02 What do those key connection points look like out there as we look at how do we take people, if you will, from a key element in the center of downtown and ultimately put them out to an experience in our wilderness around us, if you will. But trying to look at those in a couple key areas and walk through that and getting people's input and involvement in those areas. So if you have an interest on that, we're putting some groups together, property owners and obviously others from different...

7:31 Box of life, if you will, to have them engaged in that process. So I would invite that if you have an interest as a board members or as individual property owners, etc. If you have an interest in that elements, let Sandra know. We'll let you know when the meetings are coming up. They'll probably get set and hopefully at a time that's relatively convenient, but it'll be hurting a fairly large group, so it won't be around everybody's calendar, if I can put it that way nicely. They're challenging.

8:01 Not at this point, these are just kind of a, we've had people in town, business owners, saying, hey, we want to get together and talk about it, and we're trying to bring other people in that conversation, so it's a little more inclusive, but it's, there's no standing meeting about it, it's not on a regular meeting basis, these will be kind of an ad hoc pulled together staff meetings, and then ultimately coming back, and there will be some formal, you know, obviously reporting back out of what goes into the plan, but sit down.

8:26 The offer here is if you have an interest and you want to be engaged in some of that, get a hold of Sandra. If you have a particular area of interest, great. If we can plug you in there, that would be perfect. But I want to get the invite to you formally to have you engaged in that process. So again, there's the kind of core areas we'll be looking at as we walk through that. Does that make sense? We're hoping to get the meeting set up over the next few weeks. So by the end of the month.

8:55 Having a couple, probably a couple meetings as need be with the group and then starting to have that feedback into the document. So relatively quick. I think Alta was originally planning on doing one more document update based on the recent public hearings and it would have been probably done shortly. We told them to slow down. We want to get more input from some community groups to have that discussion. So it would go relatively quick. Is the document as it stands right now? It's online. A couple different places, yeah.

9:26 If you want a hard copy, let me know. I'll provide those. It's online from a PDF copy. If someone wants a hard copy, I can leave this one here for you right now if you want a hard copy. ConnectMammothLakes.com has a bunch on there. That was the first cut, so we're looking at how do we engage people in that process. If you have an interest, definitely let us know.

10:09 I think, informally, if you do have somebody, because it's a part of an interview, mobility, also how to replace, recommend smartly. Yeah, that's the goal there, so if we have that. Thanks. Thank you, Chair. Board, Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation. Just have a few highlights I wanted just to make you aware of. Summer officially started yesterday. I don't know if you're aware of that, but just wanted to let you know. We opened a summer camp registration yesterday, so for us, summer has begun.

10:57 If you were quick enough, strategic enough, you got your child registered in your camp. It was an intense couple of days. Two-thirds of our camps right now are sold out, which is a big number for us, so that's a great couple of days. It is crazy. But everything kind of went well. Anyway, so we're working through that. The summer brochure was also out last week. If you joined us at the Recreation Open House, it was very valuable. Pretty much all these camps are all outdated now anyway, but that's okay.

11:26 A couple of things I want to bring your attention to. Pool opening May 8th. That's still kind of on schedule. Took a little bit of a beating. We are very thankful for our youth sporting groups, community groups, and their patients opening up our facilities. As you know, we had a little bit of snow, so Whitmore track and field is now open. We actually cleared that off, so that's accessible, and also fields one and two.

11:52 Baseball field is still kind of under snow, so it'll be a little bit longer, and then shady rest will be a little bit longer as well. This morning at the commission meeting we made a presentation on the ice rink, so we kind of gave a season update. If you do want to look at that, it's on our Mammoth Ice Rink website under 2016 presentation. Just really quickly highlights from that, it was 400 more visits than last year, believe it or not.

12:18 60, sorry, 70 open days, which is again higher than last year, but 23 of those were partial openings. So we even got it open for like a two-hour hockey session or got it open for, you know, a special event. But anyway, so that's available if you want to look at that. And then commission also made a recommendation for youth supports funding today that we'll take to council on April 19th. So there we go. That's all I have. Any questions? Parks and Rec. Good, thank you.

13:07 Next, let's take a look. Next up is an update on the Executive Director's Search. So there's an Inland Report Packet. Is it included? Schedule. It's a tight schedule. As everyone knows, we're shooting for a geologist. It's self-explanatory. Our first candidate, which the Forest Group calls a calibrator candidate, basically somebody who meets a certain criteria. We go through the interview process.

14:21 The idea is to learn from that, both in terms of our offer, the package, the response we get to that package, and then make some adjustments. That is coming up live. That's a tight timeline. I'm going to have David talk a little bit. He, over the last few days, while I was kind of really swamped, spent some time communicating with the course. They had produced a draft, what they call a draft. We had some notes.

14:58 at the executive committee level for them, just teching it up, wanted to kind of establish a quality bar with David stepped in and had a call yesterday. They also produced their first flash report, which is kind of a bi-weekly account, but they will be producing these ongoing to kind of update us on their progress. The first one also included a first list of candidates, which we also had some notes. Right now, we're going to keep those

15:38 Which is myself, David, Gary Morgan, Brent, and then John Wentworth, and Scott Dwyer, because of the confidentiality required. So David, if you want to kind of update us on it. Sure, yeah. So I sent a blast out. I see Barbara Sponchelen's plan. One of my concerns is when I go on the phone. They say that, in fact, they've kind of weeds out. I still feel like there are some things that we ought to look at in terms of

16:51 The framing of it is probably pretty good. They asked that they would love to hear feedback from anybody on the board. If anybody can email them directly with comments and they'll try. If you want to copy me, that'd be great. Yeah, but don't copy the whole board. I think that's pretty much it. Again, I think look in particular at that opportunity description because I think we want to be suited. They also assuaged my concerns a little bit in that they feel that

17:40 Pretty much everybody they're going out to is going to have really direct experience in an executive position, so they'll know, you know, we don't really need to reiterate what the Executive Director in general does, but where we are. My main concern right now is just the timing of our contract and before we have an established contract, which might be a little tricky, but at this point, I think we march forward. Any other, Rich, do you have anything to add?

18:40 Any questions or comments? My own question is, I think it's aggressive, I think we do as well as stay focused. Oh, and then, I guess the only other thing is that to keep us focused, we've, the other thing, and I know that I saw that a couple of you already, but to try and establish that. And if there, I mean, this is a real, it was eye-opening to me to see the flash, everybody trying to steal the wood. So, do think broadly, if you have specific candidates that you think digital networks may still prove to be

20:00 Okay, moving on. Next in your packet you'll find a letter to

20:54 The Honorable Eduardo Garcia from the California State Assembly that I signed on to along with MLTPA in terms of some of our brothers and sisters in the recreation space. I won't read the whole letter into the record. It's here in the packet. But the idea is it's part of AB 907. One of the provisions is to set up an Office of Outdoor Recreation and Public Land.

21:25 This is a lot like our friend in Colorado, I believe Washington has one in Utah as well, and right now all of the, it seems like all of us, what's that? Oregon. Oregon has a parallel process underway, and it just passed their lower house. So essentially all, it seems like all of the western states are trying to bring, it's a big deal for us, so we are happy to sign on. From an overall standpoint, it hasn't been funded, I didn't go back to the actual work, but I'm also conscious.

22:30 Yeah, I think it's part of the Parks Bond Bill. I can tell you that the state does not know yet. And I think it's, where's my computer? What's important, though, you know, it's getting started. I think a key point to make with this is that

23:11 There's a lot of things going on in the OHV community with funding for green sticker projects. That's getting absorbed into state parks. There's a lot of stuff going on with that that people are concerned that OHV and motorized use is going to get compromised by some of those efforts.

23:25 I think what's really important is that this group, the people who are working to bring this thing forward, are making it very clear that the outdoor recreation community in California is no different than the outdoor recreation communities in all the rest of the states, in which the motorized and the non-motorized, a full spectrum of recreation users are intended to be benefited by this. And this is not an effort to kind of split one group off from another. There's a lot of issues, things like that, to get resolved as it goes forward, but I don't think they know exactly how it's going to get funded.

23:54 In Colorado, it's just Luis and maybe one, I don't know if he's even got an assistant. It's not a huge cost. It's a staff position, and where it would live is all to be determined. Yep.

24:48 I said, God has tied the pass that we're going to open, and he said we're going to start working on it this week, Caltrans, and try to get that pass open by mid-June, and we might have another record-breaking spring to summer. We'll see where it goes, and we'll be forward to it. No, but that's okay. I'm very appreciative of what we've got. I'll just keep it short, but the other thing is, there's a rumor out there that the gentleman who's now receiving somebody who doesn't want to see the park.

25:36 I'll just add to that, quickly. Yeah, the key is, yeah, you don't know until you get into it. It's an amazing picture. It's the gate to Tioga. They showed a picture of it, and they showed it just, you can just see a slim piece of it. It's just a snow field over that building. And all I'd add is...

26:33 Walk, bike, ride, please, if you haven't. For me, we're just up in the mountain, we're in full spring swing, street breaks, and invitational coming up. There's a great black-white party, arcade party on Friday night. On Saturdays, the traditional gala. Will there be actually 80 arcadians? What's that? 80 arcadians? I don't know how many arcadians. Oh, 80s? Yeah, that's right. That's my understanding.

27:11 I just made the poster. That's what it said. And then the only note for the board, we're getting the communications band back together. That committee has kind of not met for a while. And Rich and I were talking that during our executive search, we thought it would be a smart idea to, now that Emily's kind of gotten her footing and is starting to really handle the administrative stuff well, to really...

27:39 Have another focus on communication. Start producing a newsletter and some other, build some other channels. So that group can get back together and come up with kind of a quick strike communication plan in the next few months. So I'm excited about that. I don't have a lot other than work and we've dealt with the allocations and that's going to be coming up later in the agenda. So I'll talk to that at that time. Yeah, I don't have any more. There's been some great

28:14 Cultural productions here in town lately outside Molengar was fantastic if some of you got to see it at the Edison Theater. They also had their March Magic, which is the end of the repertoire season. And then Felicia Trio had an amazing concert last weekend, almost sold out with two guest artists. So it was a strings concert, definitely one of the better ones that I've seen. It was really...

28:42 You know, great response from the crowd members and stuff. So it was great. And then just quickly touching base on the pool. We're still in contact with the couple that came out from USA Swimming. We still need to speak with Ralph a little bit about potentials and, you know, there's the opportunity to have a potential aquatic center in partnership with Snow Creek Athletic Club.

29:11 Obviously a lot of details that need to get worked out. There's also the opportunity that the USA Swimming Group talked about as far as getting a feasibility study. So hopefully in the next board meeting and in the future just to kind of keep you informed about those different options. I think many of you at the last board meeting saw somebody from the public just kind of stand up and be really excited. Wow, I've heard that you're exploring the idea of an aquatics facility.

29:39 have heard that more and more now from community members, that it's, you know, something that is, you know, a great need here for the community from a safety perspective as well as something that people would enjoy using for themselves. So, that's it. Actually, now that you mention that, it does remind me that Winter Adventure Series wrapped up this week. It was a successful event, I think, four nights. People gave good feedback about the speakers. The venue was terrific.

30:09 Hopefully we'll talk a little bit later. There were issues getting the word out. I don't think there were as many people as we could have had. I'm sure there are lots of reasons for that, but I look forward to talking about how we communicate our Powered by You events program. Communications committee. Yes. Executive Director. A couple quick things.

30:34 I continue to do my Sunday communications. It's my way to communicate with you all, you know, the priorities and accomplishments. It gives you an idea of what we're doing day to day. Give the flavor for it. I appreciate the feedback I'm getting. We've also been copying you guys. The MLR milestones is a running record based on the projects we've adopted thus far. Keeps you in the loop in what we're doing.

30:53 And especially as we hand this off to the next E.D. This is kind of where we've been, this is what we've done, those types of things. And we have a full agenda tonight, and it's going to be a little longer than anticipated, as Tom made mention to. I deeply appreciate all the work that's been done by some of the folks in the audience right now to make presentations in your preparation for this. It's so vitally important to read your board package and to be prepped to engage in the conversation.

31:15 There's too much work. We have some heavy lifting to do at this point. Tomorrow night, there's some recommendations to Town Council for funding special events. It'll generate some unrestricted funds for MLR to help with the search process, transportation, you know, those types of things. And we're also, we've got the two special projects that are going forward also to Town Council tomorrow night. They're all part of consent agenda items, which I accept for special events. That's a, that's a.

31:39 Policy matter. But I feel comfortable the fact that they're trusting our judgment enough that they're going to approve some of these things without having to get up and do some kind of formal presentation. Emily continues to make great progress as the transition to MLR. She actually got up at Recreation Commission today, made a couple of reports. So she's filling her oats, which is good. She's feeling comfortable. And as Tom alluded to, she's putting together a 30-day swing package that we'll work through with the communications committee on Friday at 4 o'clock, about an hour.

32:06 Kind of some big chunking things in terms of conceptual strategies, some platforms, some things we looked at trying to chunk that out. So we're feeling pretty good about that. And then we continue to engage our partners, the people working with right now, digging a little bit deeper, and make new friends as things unfold in the spring. So with that, that's my quick report. Thank you very much. Okay, next item. Review and consider appointments of board members to the MLR, Town of Maniflex, Recreation Commission ad hoc committee.

32:35 I'll just remind the board that this is the committee that we discussed creating after the workshop we had between MLR and Rec Commission. The way we were thinking of constructing this committee would be the chair of each group plus one board member. I believe Betsy and Christy Osborne will be the representatives from Rec Commission. And I've talked to Heather Schottweiler.

33:04 about being our representative with me on that committee. If that sounds right to everybody on the board, go ahead and start doing the work. It's not a formal committee. It's not a formal committee. It's not bound by the Brown Act. It's an ad hoc. And so we just reach consensus. We all agree with that. Any concerns? Everybody, do we have a consensus? Thanks for your time.

33:37 Next. Funding option presentation for MLR capital projects. Thank you. Rob Patterson, Finance Director of Town of Mammoth Lakes. Let me pull up my presentation here real quick. Rich, for the record, I love your Sunday communiques. Very informative. We just had a comment from the public TV world when we're speaking on that side of the table. We get that microphone there if we can maybe speak into that a little louder so people hear us when we're...

34:30 One more speaking, please. Thanks, Brent. Okay, so hopefully you had a chance to review some of the presentation that was sent to you in advance. I wanted to make sure we got that in your hands and a chance to look at it. But I was asked to basically come here and talk a little bit about, number one, to kind of validate the starting point of what we have for fund balances for Measure R and Measure U.

34:53 So I'll begin that process. And then to kind of fold into some options of how we would finance and what that would look like on an annual basis for a budget review. So to begin with, we'll take a look at Measure R fund balance as it is currently this year. If you see at the very top there, starting at the end of last year, we had a $2.6 million

35:18 Fund balance. We anticipate projected revenue for this fiscal year to come in around $1.25 million. We've been very strong so far year to date, and it sounds like we're going to continue that. So with our fund balance and our projected revenue, we should have $3.8 million to deal with this year, starting for Measure R. From that, we start to deduct our commitments that we have.

35:45 On an annual basis, the trail system of 300, MLR of 200, that's the administrative costs, Trails End Park, Whitmore Park, and then some of the Town of Mammoth Lakes items. And those total about $545,000. And those are pretty much the ongoing commitments that we've got identified so far, or you guys have identified so far.

36:11 Then looking down below that, we've got some allocation items that were decided on by the board for 16-17, the 25,000, 45,000, 17 for special projects, Trails End Park project, and the bell-shaped wetland study. That's another 87,000. So the total expected fund balance at the end of this current fiscal year is going to be around 3.2 million, 3.22.

36:37 So for Measure R, that's where we should have funds available for use. Any questions so far? Yes, that would be a correct statement because the way we handle this within our internal accounting system, two ways. We have a separate fund for trails, so we'll take $300,000 out of R and put it into trails, but that money, if it's not spent, stays in the fund balance within trails.

37:28 And so that would be a part of it. Yeah. I don't want to take Joel's wording here. Yeah.

38:13 in our other document that we have. So if I'm looking at quarterly and we only have one more quarter that we would be putting onto that, that seems hard to come up to the 1.25, 1.1, yeah. Well, it was dated March, and so, yeah, I don't know. Dated March, but it's not going to be captured, it may or may not have captured even February's TOT numbers because we were capturing those.

38:44 All the way through, you know, a month late, if you will. So it's really slightly more than half the year included in it. So any more questions? Okay. Take a look at you real quick. Fund balance to end last year of $2.185 million. And the $900,000 that we're projecting the revenue to come in, as Terry.

39:19 Pointed out, should have just over $3 million to allocate and spend this year. This year, we, so we have, we kind of worked through our annual commitments a little bit. We've done some refinements of that. We probably will further refine those. We have, you know, $18,000 in transit services, which we didn't even spend close to that last year. But again, anything we don't spend just falls to the bottom line for available funds, as well as same thing with the town agreements of $7220.

39:46 But those are items that we've definitely agreed upon for this fiscal year and expecting those to continue on based on the annual commitments to that with some minor modifications. We had a couple of MLR board allocations that were performed this year, the $25,000 for special projects as well as the MAC design work of $100,000. So total expenses of $271,000 brings our expected fund balance at the end of this year to be $2.8 million for Measure U.

40:16 The combined values for our NU, just over $6 million, $6 million over 34. And again, these numbers kind of anticipate that all the dollars will be spent. I know when we have some of the things that we're doing for Town of Mammoth Lakes, those are the numbers that we can spend too, and we've spent over those in the past. We pick it up from fund balance to replenish those, make sure we don't exceed that.

40:45 Kind of switching gears now and going into what can be done. I wanted to show one scenario here. Basically, with the total combined fund balance that we have, like I said on the previous slide, just about $6 million, we can fund a pretty substantial project, or at least in one project, the first phase of the multi-use, for example. And I want to clarify in here, there are some...

41:12 Items that I put markers on or names on, those are just to illustrate a point. They're not an ask for funds for that particular event, but really just say, hey, if you were going to spend money, half a million on trails or a million dollars on walk, bike, ride, those are just insert name here. It could be whatever it is, but it's roughly the dollars and trying to illustrate that. So in this particular case, I chose to use multi-use facility phase one because we predict that project to come in around 6.5 million.

41:42 And what I'm showing here is a starting point of $6 million. We should have around $800,000 in additional fund balance next year. And what that means essentially is our revenues and our expenses. When you combine those two, considering everything equal, we should have about $800,000 we put in the bank, if you will, after next year and make that available. So within the time frame, we would need it for...

42:10 For phase one of this facility, we would have the funding to complete phase one. Now, that would assume that we kind of maintain the current levels of funding and that we wouldn't have any new projects. So that's a big component to consider when we talk about the one and done. That's kind of why I labeled it as such. For a while, anyway. So what can be done? I wanted to give you the second one. This is sort of where we get into a more broader approach.

42:38 And just kind of just list out projects on there. And when I say that, you know, trails in capital funding of half a million dollars, that's kind of a different approach than what you're going to hear, I think, later on about the $400,000 per year for the next five years. This would essentially take those $100,000 per year increments and add them all right here in this funding approach.

43:03 And so the ongoing commitment to the operations side would remain at 300, but you would still end up in the same place. Hopefully that makes a little bit of sense. I'm sorry, yeah, Trails 215, Joel's work. Potential requests, you know, I kind of put that out as it could be, you know, XYZ, whatever's coming down the pipe. We have a lot of projects that we have either design or phasing that are going on right now.

43:33 We want to get a lot of those across the finish line or at least started across the finish line. So it's going to take some funding in order to achieve that. So the million dollars listing in there as potential projects that could move forward. Now the MAC, I think that's already been previously identified as an ask at $2.5 million. And then the multi-use listed it in two ways. One is the $6.5 million phase one.

44:00 The complete project of an additional three or total of 9.5 million to put that across the finish line as a full project. Any questions on this slide? Yeah, that's the gap, 2.5. So they're going to come back and ask for that gap of 2.5. They're going to the college, they've got a larger gap. They're going to go to the college and ask for an increase in Measure A money. Measure C, excuse me. 2.5. Correct.

44:42 Okay, so the money slide, I apologize for being a little bit small, but essentially on the top, start off saying, okay, my estimated fund balances, as we talked about, and using, you know, the orange side and the green side, you know, no pun intended as far as which one I'm favoring, but the orange side would essentially be funding down to the $10.5 million or phase one of the multi-use facility as well as those other ones that were delineated.

45:11 The complete project of $13.5 million is on the right-hand side in the green. So taking those two, so Measure R, it's got $3.2 million, additional fund balance anticipated for the coming year of $340,000. The debt issuance, there's two of those that would exist, either $1.5 million or $2.7 million. Both of those numbers over on the right-hand side financed for around 4% interest rate.

45:41 And five years on the low side, 10 years on the high side, produce roughly the same numbers, around $330,000, $340,000 a year. Measure U, same scenario, we have the starting balance of 2.8, anticipated excess of next year, $460,000, and then a debt issuance of either $1.2 or $2.2 million. Those two amounts illustrated on the right-hand side.

46:10 Give you a $269,000 to $271,000 per year payment. So based upon trying to hit a targeted annual amount, so returns five years for the lower side and 10 years for the long side, saying essentially if you want to get this done with funding and you want to get it done within a five-year time period, this is what we would have to do on the lighter side. If you want to do it full boat, 10 years, we'd get the same thing with the same amount done.

46:47 So this would be financing? Bond issue. Bond issue. So how much match that in the bank? It's a coverage issue with cash. With the bond being committed to the tax that's out there and sort of doesn't have a sunset. Sorry. Excuse me, Dan Holler on the bond issues. I've talked to the microphone where she's yelling up. Sorry.

47:36 We've actually structured it so you end up with cash flow in there for a coverage issue, and plus the operating dollars would help cover that. That's what they would look at on a bonding element. They will ask, often depending on the bond issue, they'll ask, will you keep one year's payment in the bank in case you have a bad year, then you can make that payment, and then if you do, then you can replace it. But it doesn't require to have a bunch of other dollars in the bank and you do this. This would be a traditional bond deal.

48:06 The issue here is pretty straightforward because you'd commit all the R new money to the debt, but it doesn't, that's the security, if you will. And so it does tie into that, or you can commit up to a portion of it depending on what bond issuers would want. Does that make sense to answer the question? Yeah, the 1.25 in Measure U, that comes out of updated sales tax information from HDL. You figure the Measure R tax

48:40 It runs about 55% of the regular sales tax, and so actually this is a little bit conservative. There's probably a $50,000 reduction. That was my question. You take it very conservative. I think if you look at the sales tax number, I deal more with the town general fund sales tax standpoint.

49:14 It has not seen the swings that TOT is seeing, both positive or negative. It has dipped a little bit back with the 08 recession, but where you've had massive, massive, I don't know if it's a great word, but great TOT increases. Sales tax has bumped up, but not, there's not a direct relationship. It's actually kind of interesting. So, yeah, so this is a conservative one-year estimate based on the last couple years and then.

49:41 We do not increase it going forward at all. So if it did take a little dip down, then yeah, and there's about, I can't remember the hard number there, X dollars that fall out still that would be unexpended each year unless it's allocated out. So there is some balance in that. So very good, great. So anyway, so yeah, there's debt issues on that, but this here is in traditional financing and work through that. It's an estimate on the interest rates to date. So a couple different points. Which one?

50:28 To make all these numbers work. Yeah, you wouldn't have the debt. Yeah, you can carry the cash flow to do that. The issue on the bond issue is that actually guarantees the cash so you can actually bid the project. If, like, for us bidding projects, one of the questions they ask is do you have the money to build it when you bid it? If the answer is no, then technically you can't issue the bid. So let's say we went to bid on the MAC but we don't have the money secured.

51:29 Either we have to commit other funds to it, so you could say yes, you can issue the bid to build the project, or if you wait, yeah, it's still under the public bidding code. It won't matter, still a public bid. So technically you can't issue a bid without having the funding in place. You'd have to say is the cash there. Yeah, yeah, correct. And so we looked at that saying if you did that and the cash was ready again, the timing is the question in all of these.

52:01 And that was back to the chances are current market force interest rates are going up right now too. So that could easily move to a four and a half percent. That's rough in the market today. Yeah. Yeah. The last bond the town did was 3.3. And so it was for the police station a year ago. And so we've bumped it up from that, obviously, accordingly. But yeah, you could cash flow some of that and say we don't want to borrow that much. Okay.

52:32 So those are options in there. Worst case scenario. Yeah, this is if you want to do it and cash in the bank, you're still short on both of these, as Rob mentioned and you asked about, was to build out any of these unless you commit more cash savings, you've got a private slash other funding source to go out and say we need to raise some other capital money, which I don't think that's a bad thing, frankly. I didn't calculate the difference on that, but.

53:12 You know, it would be straightforward. To me, that's the worst case. That might be what they say. Sure. Yeah, absolutely. I just didn't want to show the fully funded without highlighting that component of it for sure. Any other questions? So taking a look at how that would impact our

54:18 Expected annuals. And again, holding some things. This is really on a broad base. Holding some things consistent across the board to try to illustrate what we would have. What would that mean for R and U going forward if we had these bondings in place? Number one is keeping the same commitments that we have. We have the $340,000 payment in R, which I'm looking back at the last one here.

54:45 Either funding mechanism, whether it be the phase one or the full, end up around $3.4 million. And again, I'm trying to use bigger numbers just to make sure we're conservative in covering everything. Under R, both of those are $340,000 roughly per year. And then we have, you know, some call outs in there as far as the ongoing multi-use facility staffing costs.

55:11 $340,000. So that would actually bring our expenses to $985,000 on an annual basis. So pretty tight as far as available for R. And, you know, if we're running at $2.5 million, what Dan quoted from HDL, we are conservative off that number. It was a little over $1.3 is what that came through with. So I think that that $1.25 should be okay. We give us $265,000 in fund balance. So again, remaining within

55:41 Measure R available to spend. And that would kind of save for one to three years. We basically assume that the projects are up and running in order for those staffing to come in and that cost to be there. But the 265 should be funds available. Measure U, same exact scenario, keeping things consistent with our projected revenue as well as the annual commitments. We did add

56:09 The debt payment in there of $270,000, that was that line item. The MAC ongoing support at $300,000, there's some high variability to that number. We went a little bit high just because of expected programming costs and upfront costs to be a little bit higher, so that number could go higher, could go lower, but it's just trying to put an estimate in there for you.

56:33 So total expenses against you would run around $716,000, give you a fund balance of $183,000 on an annual basis. So, go ahead. Any other questions? So combined, just to kind of roll up at the end, because I think this is my last slide, on my handout I had an extra slide, apparently it was one that was really important and we wanted to really talk a lot more about, but it's just a duplicate. But the $448,000 fund balance availability, that's still,

57:27 A considerable amount of money. It's not what we've been used to perhaps in the past, but it's still something that's out there. They could be used for the smaller projects on an annual basis, things that come to you guys or accumulate into a larger fund balance for another future project. But the key about the bond funding here is that you get a lot more off the ground in a shorter period of time while committing the funds, again, for 10 years perhaps, but it's something that's doable within the numbers that I'm looking at.

58:00 That's correct. So measure R is up on top. You've got 336, 332. Measure U is on the bottom of 269 and 271. So I'm using just rounded up numbers for the 340 and then the 270. The other questions? So I was thinking about that, almost that very question when I was sitting in the audience listening to you guys' conversation earlier and thinking about,

59:00 So this is, if you look at the green slide sections, this is a 10-year commitment. And so while I look at this and I don't think that there's a risk of the numbers working, it's just realizing the level of commitment from those two funds for an entire 10 years. You think about that is you are picking these projects and those are the ones that you work on. Some other things may not get to be worked on.

59:28 And some, you know, things that are near and dear to hearts. So that's kind of where I sit in this. It's like, yeah, we'll get a lot done in a short amount of time, but you'll be committed for a period of time. And, you know, and I was thinking 10 years is a long time. Like, where will we all be and what will they say about us, about that commitment? But the cool thing is...

59:50 To be able to have these types of programs out there, the MAC and the multi-use facility up and running, and the trails, we've already got excellent trails, but if we've got those funded capital projects-wise, that should do a lot for our town to bring visitors in and to sort of help solidify this income level. So I think it'll only benefit us and show that it might add a little spark to the town and get things hopping. There's Rob's perspective. Thank you, Rob.

1:00:42 Let me say for these contracts that we have a commitment with them that we say, okay, we're going to guarantee that we're going to give you programming and support X amount of time, or is this a year-by-year kind of thing? I think it's ongoing. We've had a variety of discussions with Mammoth Lakes Foundation. The assumption would be that it's a commitment for ongoing funding, but the idea would be is do you look at it, you know, at points in time or annually going how much...

1:01:15 You know, if you actually brought in a lot of extra revenue in one year, you had a great programming season, you would reduce that at some point. But it really is a backstop for their funding, because the same question would be, is all of a sudden, for whatever reason, they have a really bad year. You know, people can't get here, we have great snow, and people can't drive in. Do we actually, you know, do they have some level of reserve there in those types of issues? So we've had an ongoing back and forth of...

1:01:42 But I think the bottom line is ultimately there probably will be an ongoing level of support at some level. And on that project, we still haven't really seen a final breakdown of the way the business plan would work, structure, the governance. Point of order, sir. Any other questions from board to staff? If not, we'll go to public comment and then come back for deliberations. The other thing we've had discussion with them on is just the ongoing profitability of the...

1:02:14 It goes back and forth because a lot of people that use it today will definitely want to do it on a low-end cost or free. The college gets free access, schools get free, town gets free. And so there's a certain level of it used that won't have a payback, if you will. So I anticipate a level of subsidy. It's not going to be one that funds itself, essentially. Based on other history and working with other theaters I've dealt with, at least, that tends to be a true reality.

1:02:47 Yeah, that's the discussion we've had pushing it through. I can see the first year or two, they may ask a little more as they get stuff established. But I think that's, I really see that ideally would be a backstop going if you don't make your, you know, amounts, boom, here we can help you stay in business. The last thing you want is a dark theater.

1:03:39 My name is Abigail Giles, and I have two questions, and forgive me if they were in the, they answered in the presentation, but I figure if I'm a little bit confused, then maybe some other people are too. So the first one is regarding the bond, could perhaps, Dan, maybe you could elaborate on what that would entail and where it would come from, and would that require a public vote to be approved, or is it already funding that's been approved in the past? Do you have another question to it?

1:04:10 I have another question. Go ahead. Okay. All right. Okay. And again, forgive me if it's delineated in the breakdown of those expenses elsewhere, but I thought that I heard that in order to fund and finance the bond, it would require potentially allocating all of Measure R and U towards debt repayment or demonstrating that it was possible. And if it came to it, we could fund that repayment with Measure R and U.

1:04:39 Was I correct in understanding that? When the voters passed both measures R and U, there's actually language in there that says these funds can be utilized for debt issuance or a bond issuance. And so in a sense it's been voted on already in terms of when the measure was approved if you looked at some of the language there that the money can be committed to debt, it can be used to pay the issuance cost of that debt. And so that's called out on both R and U and the

1:05:11 Ballot measures that approve both of those funding streams. A bond issue is, you know, it'd be analogous. You go out and borrowing money for a home or something and having a mortgage, you go through a process. There's actually usually it's either you negotiate a sale of a bond or it's a competitive bid bond pending on what the markets are and the dollar amounts we're talking about. It's usually through a financial institution where that bond is issued.

1:05:39 And it's basically we're making payments over the next five or ten years to pay it back with principal and interest. And so it's very traditional financing from that perspective. But both of the measures, the way the voters approve those includes the issuance of debt and using those funds to pay that debt back. In issuing the debt, the banks will look at that and go, you know, how do we know we'll get paid back? No different than if you borrow money for a car or a home or...

1:06:08 Usually people don't know how you pay it back. So they'll look at that and they'll look at a coverage test usually and they'll look at a 1.25 or a 1.3 coverage in terms of our debt payments 340,000 do you have, you know, 400 or 500,000 of uncommitted money that could be utilized to pay that debt back. They'll look at that coverage ratio. They will look at a little history in terms of

1:06:31 They'll look at fund balance. They'll look at all those processes and take a look at those elements as they evaluate the bond issue. And as Rob in the last slide there showed, you have that fund balance left over each year. That's a good thing for the debt issuance looking at that. It would have a first call on revenue in front of any of the operational costs that we do annually. Debt gets primary

1:06:58 Place if you own expenditure side. And so that's one reason it was structured that way in terms of the dollar amount not being too excessive in terms of what we think the revenues are and also making sure there's a cash flow every year. Now each year you could take that and as Rob mentioned commit it to something you don't have to hold it in the bank. But each year if they see that cash flow is projected out that's a very positive thing in terms of debt issuance and securing the debt. In terms of securing the debt. Yeah.

1:07:32 Right, and so what we're committing would be, it'd probably be, I'd call it double barrel bond issue, because you'd have a Measure U piece and a Measure R piece, and the bonding company would look at it that way and say, so you're committing 1.25 million, if you will, of Measure R money that they'd look, okay, you have that much there, we need this, and here's your cash flow, here's your projected use, that looks solid, Measure U, same thing, here's your cash flow, here's what you're saying is committed, here's the debt, here's what's left over, okay.

1:08:02 They would do that analysis and say, based on those, here's what we would want to see. Actually, this is pretty basic debt for a bond company. And the security, they love the fact that these are voter-approved tax measures. And once you issue debt, they can't be undone by the town or by a voter repeal, even, once you tie them in with the bond. So they're pretty secure from that perspective.

1:08:34 Yeah, we didn't walk that through in here. Again, look at the financing between R and U. You wouldn't go out and commit another piece of general fund revenue or the

1:09:07 Fractual Melrose Revenue on a bond side. Generally, that would be more confusing than beneficial. Right now, what we have is the two, well, we looked at two different structures. Whether it would be a continuing debt service helping it. Right. Yeah. Yeah, you could have other dollars that flowed in to make debt payment. But the guarantee from a bank issuing money would be tied to RMU. Yeah.

1:09:36 There's, I think, in the operating cost, that full 260 from the Melrose Fund has been plugged into the operations to the ice rink side, where right now it's a little less than that, and there's dollars that go to the lease payment to the district. I think there's 260,000 programmed into the facility, but that would be, so there's other sources you could use, ultimately, if it's illegal use of the money or the general fund dollars you could use to make a payment, but the banks would say,

1:10:03 You've committed this voter-approved funding. We really like that. That's a very secure loan, if you will. But it's not, we can't change it. That also helps with your interest rate, also, with the security side. So hopefully that addresses the question. May I ask a follow-up question? Sure. This is Abigail Giles again. I just have one follow-up question, just to be absolutely clear. In the period for which those funds are committed to the bond,

1:10:41 Does that ever preclude them from being used to fund the things that they're now used to fund? Just demonstrating that we have the cash flow is important, but at that time at which they're technically supposed to indicate security in that investment, does that lock up or place any prohibitions on how those funds can be used during the period for which we're paying back the bond?

1:11:11 Simple answer is no. If you try to go and issue additional debt, that would raise different issues in which one would be in first place, second place. But as far as the operational issues we're proposing and looking at and the things we've been doing with the commitment to trails, one, you would disclose all that on the front end. In the next five years, we've got $2 million committed to trails. We've got X dollars committed to operations of these facilities. We've got X dollars in programming. You'd lay all that out.

1:11:40 The legal uses of the funds would still be in place and you could still utilize the rest of the revenue for any legal purposes which they can be used for. The bonds would put no restrictions on that.

1:12:55 These funds are just automatically allocated without you raised funds. That's something that we've known about. I'm comfortable with that amount, but I guess I just have a, yeah. That risk is, for me, the idea of there's good depth, there's good depth in the depth. If you believe in your strategy, great projects are development projects. If we believe in a town, then doing a bonding maneuver makes some sense, but we're still questioning the position of the projects.

1:14:02 And these numbers are kind of based on high watermark revenue. Well, to be clear, these aren't automatically processed ahead to make sure that this is. I understand that. I guess just looking at this initial layoff, that's a concern that I raised ages ago when the ice cream came up. So we're moving forward in this that, you know, we're basically essentially you're saying that this is floating to the top of our list because it's going to come down to a point that we're only going to be able to do so many projects.

1:14:50 And it's kind of frustrating because it kind of kept getting pushed back. Oh, no, that's not the case. And here we are. And that's exactly what's going on. And it does frustrate me because I think we have an event center that's important. And we have a pool. And it's always been, what is the largest priority? And what is it that we need to move forward? And unfortunately, we looked at that in our scenario, in our projects that we have coming forward. But I think one project was kind of pushed forward.

1:15:19 And now, you know, it's incumbent on us, and it's incumbent on

1:15:54 And I guess that's been the intent all along, but this is going to fire our heads to something. The future cash flow, at our last board, we talked about fund development, what role that plays once, if we were to do something to do and what we've done, whether it is a bonding, once we have a restricted cash flow, how do we continue to grow that outside of what we've come?

1:16:58 As you said, this is assuming that 2.5 gap on the map as an example is all going to come out of measure. I think our goal is to find some significant other sources. And wouldn't it have to come out of you? You. Specifically. I've just got this double barrel.

1:17:28 And I guess, you know, with that comment, though, I agree wholeheartedly, but I don't know that we have the timing that we need to raise that funding for these projects that are in front of us.

1:18:04 about programming. It wouldn't be big capital. It doesn't preclude them. Just remind ourselves that the MAC already has a good little leverage again. And at that workshop we were at, there were a lot of very enthusiastic people in that audience. So I think the opportunity to raise some more money against that project in particular is that, but to your point, Terry, it's, you know, we're looking at a timeline that's continually shrinking before us.

1:18:40 Well, we knew this day would come. Almost two years ago, when we sat down and made a recommendation to Town Council for priority phase projects. Rob framed this based on those projects. We have to make a decision sooner or later. You know, the rubber's going to hit the road at this point in time. And we're going to talk about it today. What more information do you need to make a decision on a recommendation? We'll come back in May and make that recommendation at this point. Solidify that. Take it to Town Council on May 17th.

1:19:10 They may push it back to us, you know, so we're looking at getting ourselves in line with the next fiscal year. So we've got to, we knew this day would come. It's knocking on the door. So we've got to engage in a conversation about where do we want to go next? What further information do you need? What are the conversations you need to have? What challenges? What concerns? You know, the day has come. And I appreciate that, but the numbers have came in much higher than it has been said throughout the years.

1:19:40 And who knows whether these are still real owners. I feel like we're getting closer. We're getting closer. So this is a bridge. You try to frame your mind. You say, where do we want to be? To me personally, and I'm ready to get something done this time. I feel like we've talked a lot about it. We've spent a lot of time on documentation. We've spent a lot of time on foundation. The reality is the same thing happened when we started. We were able to change the projects that we all knew were the top five projects.

1:20:34 Now it comes back to what can we leverage and what can we build. I personally thought at this point in time we might have raised some more dollars to put personal stuff, but the reality is we have faced what we have today. It's a 100% buy-off on one side or the other. I'm ready to move forward. I'm caught with the Town Council's voted and spent a significant amount of dollars on multi-use facility, location, things like that. Okay, they've made it clear from day one that's one of the things that came up. We've got other things that have come up through our discussions overall.

1:21:04 We're not going to be everything to everybody, but I would look at it saying it's time for us to make some hard decisions on moving forward on some of this stuff and make a decision. I think it's time to move forward. Yeah, I would go to some caveats. Me personally, I've always envisioned, again, going back to fundraising, that we would be making some of this stuff happen. I thought this would be a part of our job. And our responsibility in terms of doing due diligence, we've got to make sure we're clear on what those priority-based projects are and how we're committing against them.

1:21:56 What's the question for Rich? Maybe this is also a question for Dan. In terms of bond to bond or not to bond, what's our timeline for the next steps? This was kind of an informational. Information for us to sort through based on our priority phase projects. Those are the ones approved. Now it's the point where are we going to move forward with this? Probably have three options. One, no decision at all. We're going to step back and wait and figure out, okay, let it roll over.

1:22:27 Just continue to fund the ongoing commitments, do the allocation process. That's an option. Option two, one and done. Got 6.1. You're getting phase one of the multi-use facility done. It's a year before they get it off the ground. Cash accumulation, so you got phase one done. Or bonding. We've got to make a decision which way we want to go. What's our recommendation to council? We've got to sort that out as our May meeting and make a decision.

1:22:54 Pull the trigger on some of this stuff. And then based on that, then council would sit with town staff and say, okay, this is the option coming forward. What do we want to do? And at that point, town staff would begin to sort it out, okay? Projects are in line. Do we need to bond? What's the timeline? They go to their process. So at this point, you're looking at us to draw the next step. We have to make a decision. Town council is looking at us. Correct. Thank you. I think everybody wants to see something else. What we're discussing right now is, okay,

1:23:39 How is that going to happen? What's the best way? We're already talking. There's a gap. Funny, in the scenario right here. It's $1.8 million. What we have to do is say, okay, that's a reality that we're going to be dealing with, or to your point, we're going to have a gap. So, all this other stuff, you know, we can put to the side and we're ready to go. I'm not afraid of debt. I don't think anybody here is afraid of debt. It's done. If we have enough money and reserves to move.

1:24:15 What is the gap? How much of that gap on this $13.5 million do we want? Right now it says, and Rob's doing a $1.8 million. 20% guy, you know? 20% money down, financing 80, good number. That puts another $1 million in the bank accounts for other projects. That's where we need to get to because I agree with you, Jerry. There are other projects.

1:24:53 Second tier projects. We don't want to wait 10 years to build up enough reserves to get. So we've got to fund that gap. And that's the, in my opinion, that's what we have to look at. Once we get that gap to the right place, then I don't like putting the debt on things, starting to get things done, and then all of a sudden we can start funding second tier stuff. Other than that, you know, if it's two deals and everybody's going to be yelling and screaming about,

1:25:41 Other things they want to get done. So am I hearing you say that that gap, putting the gap comes first? In my opinion, yeah. I think we've done all the other work on other stuff. I don't think anybody here's afraid of the debt in buying them. I think we've all said, okay, that is something we need to do. Is that the case? Financially for everyone? I agree, yeah. And I actually kind of agree with Shields. And I guess the one piece that I would like to see...

1:26:15 Because I see that we have these things in front of us, but we don't have any information on any of our other tiered projects, the special outdoor event center, the pool, that none of those are going to happen overnight. Potentially we can use Sam's Woods for a little while. So what do those things look like and what does it look like for us to be moving towards these other projects? And what is our timeline looking at for those types of things? I mean, it may be...

1:26:44 Truly, you know, five years out at least to get any of these others, the pool or something else even going, just looking at what it's taken us to do other projects, you know, realistically. And so that's half of your time right there. So what does it look like, you know, to move forward towards some of these other things and with the money that we have here, with what funding, you know, that we need to bring in for...

1:27:15 Like, okay, what is it going to take to get those other things launched? And just to know what the funding requirements are going on over time. Exactly. The point of this, if you're here today, and I agree, I want to raise whatever it is for each of these projects, but we have the reality of if we wait until we fund that, we can get nothing done in the next three years. So that's the only drawback of CSAT portion, is saying how do you find the right balance? That's how does the term balance overall? Where is that right balance for all companies?

1:27:52 Right now in Rob's presentation, he has $1.8 million in there, or one on the house here. Yeah, but I'm just saying, you know, to get it all done, $1 million or $1.8 million, we're not there yet. So we still have work to do, guys. Yeah. Can I, in the complete, that's doing the ice rate and the, and the. Yeah, I believe that's the full answer.

1:28:20 A full ice rink with the community center. Correct. That's what I thought. Correct. I just want to make sure I'm correct in what I'm... And you think about this, guys. These projects have been in town planning documents for a number of years. We're eating this elephant one bite at a time. You guys should be proud of the work you've done strategically to hold this money to find us in a position right now that we've been very, very tight with it because we knew we'd get to this level.

1:28:47 Let's take that first bite first. Get these pieces off the table. We knew six months ago we'd be getting there, which is why Stu did a great job in Betsy of bringing the U.S. swim folks in. Let's begin that process to talk about Aquatic Center. That's why Ralph is in the audience at this point. You know, we're looking at, you know, $30,000 to $50,000 for a feasibility study. We'd still have that kind of money in this to get this rolling. But let's secure that first phase. Get it off the ground.

1:29:12 Got the darn thing done. We know it's not happening tomorrow, but we can get that stuff rolling. Okay, that's done. It's on the table. It's committed to. Let's move on to the next phase. Things begin to move up. We've got to take one piece at a time, and I think we're doing a good job with this. You guys have worked hard to get all this stuff done. We've got to make a decision here, and I think you guys are ready to make it. I think also to echo what Rob said, there's a heck of a lot of value to that forward. We start taking action. We start showing that we're working.

1:29:43 Working together with our partner now can actually implement these things. I think that launches us forward toward addressing the financial concerns for the other projects as we're sitting back. What else do you need from me to bring to you guys? Are we making decisions? No. Okay. This is information. So what I'm hearing are... What else do you need from me? One is just the basic question. And during what duration?

1:30:39 Would there be value to forming, we have so many committees already going on, but to have two or three people really chop into this stuff, look at all of the documents for both the MAC and the ice rink, look at all the budget information we have and come back to the board.

1:31:12 I think Rob is painting a pretty good picture tonight about what somebody's cost might be.

1:31:50 This juncture. Yeah. I think the problem comes in when we don't quite know and we're being asked. We have these big numbers. Here's $2.5 million and here's $300,000 a year. Ask. And we don't know what that's for exactly. And we don't know how solid those numbers are. So that's one thing that we need. It's all project costs. Yeah. One time and ongoing. But are we comfortable with the ice rink and the community center?

1:32:24 I mean, I guess maybe let me maybe frame the question in a way where we can kind of chop into it. The first, maybe two questions. One, we want to get to size, but one is how do we feel about a phased approach to the multi-use facility versus the complete? I mean, are we, I mean, my instinct is I would like to fund completed projects if possible. Is that something that we

1:32:59 Absolutely. I agree. But that comes down to how much of the gap can we fill. That's right. Yeah. That's right. Yeah. And even under the face in honor of the story. There's a department, too, that goes back to saying, if we have to point down the council, where they're going to come, not just here, but where they're going to say, no, I'm almost going to spend $6 million or $1 million, $10 million. Don't have a judge. Try to get a sense. And if I'm looking at...

1:33:32 I'm looking at these gaps. You have a million gap or you have a 1.8. To me, it's like, it's not even a question. It seems like the same gap to me. You go for the complete project for $800,000, you know, you find that $800,000. But, anyhow. I agree. And let me just say, maybe I'll throw this out there for some comment. In terms of the multi-use facility, I think in the public and on this board,

1:34:02 We're nervous about the size of it. Is it the right project out of the gate? But I believe in the work that's been done in terms of design and delivering a project that is the right project. If that's the project to launch, that's the right thing to build. With the community center, with the bells and whistles, that's kind of what we continue to ask for as a board, largely, not everybody was on the board at different junctures. But we kept saying, don't...

1:34:31 Just slap some boards on some mics. Let's make this a project that the community can be crowded. Solves the problem of two deteriorating facilities. Can we agree that if that's the first project to launch, that that's our project? Instead of, there's kind of this lingering out there, oh, the multi-based facilities, the numbers are high, let's chop it up, let's, is it the right composition? For my piece, it is the right composition.

1:35:04 Can we agree to that? And we can still ask the question whether it's the right project to fund or not. Well, we don't have any other projects that are at that level of ready to start looking at in realistic terms. And I would agree. Going through all the programming meetings and looking at what the, you know, the rec commission's going through and what they can do with the facility, with it, you know, the improvements that have been made.

1:35:30 That, you know, I'm comfortable with that too. I think that everybody's done their due diligence as far as that goes. Okay. So that kind of moving forward when we talk about the multi-use facility is we're not going to be kind of hand-pecking, you know, the decisions that have been made and the number of... A more quality functioning facility. I mean, to me, my only real reluctance is that we're in the middle of a big executive search and I don't...

1:36:03 Frightened about saddling the incoming person with, I mean, just, here's your project and now you're charged with raising $1.8 million right now. Rather than over the next couple months as we go through the search, really beginning to work with those candidates and with the next person to make that call as a group. To the extent that that's possible as far as the timing.

1:36:34 I'm wondering, maybe this would be helpful to us in terms of understanding the timeline. The town made a commitment kind of publicly about a ribbon-cutting that slid for a number of reasons. I'm interested in when this kind of financing would need to take effect in order to, if

1:37:05 If that project was streamlined and kind of on its way with no delays, when this would have to be, maybe, yeah, when, what is our kind of hard stop without affecting the timelines of any projects to pull this trigger? Yeah, I'm making a list of the questions you need, right, so we can bring stuff back for you guys in May to make a decision and recommendation.

1:37:35 Dan, did you hear my funny? He did hear. On the timeline element. Yeah, essentially, what's that kind of drop dead date for financing before you start slowing up projects? Yeah, I have to start working backwards right now because if everything goes forward this summer.

1:37:56 April, May in terms of the EIR work and all that, then you'd go out to bid, so you'd have bids out this summer and then go into the project. So you look at that timeline on the debt kind of following that too. I'm going to assume it's going to take us probably 90 to give or take days. It could be as much as 120 days, probably 90 days to issue debt. Some of that I'd have to, you know, get a bond council on board and financial advisor involved in that stuff. That can go relatively quickly, but 90 days is kind of the...

1:38:25 That would be, assume there's no hiccups and everything lines up. So you look at closing debt by end of the summer, if you would, to that time frame. So it would tie into about the same time you're going to bid on the project. And so that funding and the bidding would need to tie together so you have money in the bank to actually award the bid. So you'd tie it to that time frame.

1:38:46 And we can work backwards on a schedule. Public Works has a stronger schedule than I do on that for the project that way, but that'd be easy for something to get back to the board. And then I can... I can firm up the timeline on the debt issuance as well. So do we need to kind of agree to anything else here? I think we have general support for financing. I think we've made kind of a statement about the multi-use facility. If that's green-lighted, then...

1:39:16 The project is the project. I think we've said we prefer to fund full projects than partial projects. Is there anything else we want to get out of this conversation?

1:39:46 I'll tell you, once you pull the trigger on something like this, it's amazing how people sit up straight and start putting money. Pay attention. Park City just bonded $25 million against a $38 million project and they raised it within like a month. Because they're serious. They showed their, you know, we're doing this.

1:40:21 Any other comments? Okay, I've got direction. I'll bring back some responses. We'll take some action on this. It'll be an action item when we get to May. We'll make a recommendation to Council on May 17th. They may push it back for us to sort through in June and then bring it back in June to meet their fiscal deadline of July 1st. Okay? In the meantime, be very prepared for a conversation. Let me know if you need something else. Any other information you need. Okay? Rob, thank you for the numbers. Good job. Thank you, sir. Okay.

1:41:22 Thank you, Tom, board members. Thank you for this precious time. Just want to take a few moments to create some awareness as to why we and other communities invest in trail projects. In the past year or so, we have clear policy direction from both town council and MLR. This slide is an extraction from the town and NGO alignment document where

1:42:04 I highlighted a couple of items, but what I really zero in on is a year-round destination offering the best alpine recreation opportunities in the country. That's pretty meaningful to me, and I can certainly translate that to trails. Here we see that one of the goals is the siting of 100 miles of new trails. This may sound like a big number to a lot of folks. It does not sound like a big number to me.

1:42:34 Here again, another page in the document, citing of 100 miles of new trails as a goal. Here's the MLR vision, and what I really focus here on is it aligns well with the town goal. The last sentence includes best alpine recreation community in the country, a worthy goal for Mammoth Lakes. And, you know, the subject matter is this, ribbons of dirt.

1:43:03 It's quite different infrastructure for recreation than things made of concrete and asphalt. Very different. A lot less costly, a different context. It offers a different type of experience to someone who seeks an outlet for recreation. Trails, I'm kind of a freak when it comes to trails, as you know. I think that it's primeval. I think that we've been using trails since we were squirrels. And through millions of years,

1:43:33 You know, we have become most comfortable in these sort of settings. And if we're not immersed in these sort of settings, we become cranky, we end up with ailments. To me, this is a pharmacy for us, and there's a reason why we live in a place like this. We all feel things when we walk on a trail like this. Not a road, not even an asphalt path. We get a different kind of feedback.

1:44:03 and feeling when we are working in or enjoying a place like this. To me, this is it. This slide, this picture, this is where I like to be. This is where a lot of people I know like to be. And we've heard the word sustainability tossed around a lot in recent times in the context of trails. What that means to me is, you know, it's a soft surface trail product.

1:44:33 It does not crack up over time when it's designed well. Key phrase, designed well. It is not like concrete that it's inevitable after 10 years you've got to do some work on it, invest multi-thousands of dollars in it. So I have some empirical evidence of my own work. This past winter, the community where I used to live in, where we built miles and miles of trails in the past 12 years or so.

1:45:00 They saw a thousand-year flood event. So in my mind, I'm thinking, oh my God, you know, all this snow we're getting here was all rain there at those elevations. People that I know lost homes. They were not even in the hundred-year flood zone. And so I'm thinking, boy, all those miles of trails, what's happened? And this is some of the feedback I've gotten. Everything you've built, including Lazy Lizard, is good. Lazy Lizard was one that was questionable because the bedrock was close to the surface.

1:45:31 And then another one is, Upper Ranch is totally unaffected. That was the first 14-mile project that we built, and all of it is unaffected. And then there's another quote at the bottom talking about how lots of water is flowing through all the little drainages, but the trails are unaffected. You know, the trails west of the roundabout are in superb shape. So to me, that's sustainable. It sustained a thousand-year flood event.

1:45:59 It did not fall apart. It did not crack up. Some trees came down, and a few of my buddies went up with a chainsaw and took care of it in a day. And that cost nothing to the taxpayer. It was a volunteer effort. It took a day. Wise investment. So sustainability, just a few ideas to go with that as it relates to trails. It's a relative modest capital investment. It's also a visitor-driving infrastructure. People will travel.

1:46:29 To have those experiences. Low maintenance costs over time, if designed well. And then there's a quality life component for those of us who live here. To have more of that type of facility expands those opportunities for us and the visitor. I used a great source for information. Headwaters Economics out of Jackson Hole is a nonpartisan nonprofit devoted to

1:46:59 Compiling data on the economics of trails and why they're wise to invest in. And they have a library on their website, Headwaters Economics, where there are hundreds of articles in their library, and I encourage you to check it out. The main point here is that you can increase business for a community, improve public health, and increase property values. Measurable benefits.

1:47:28 from trails in similar communities with similar goals can support investments in new trail projects. So this tells us that we can look to examples, empirical evidence. One of those pieces of evidence that I came across is a study done by the University of Oregon, the Planning and Land Use Department.

1:47:53 Specific to Oak Ridge, Oregon. This was a community about an hour southeast of Eugene whose economy was completely reliant on resource extraction, timber harvesting that came to a standstill in recent times and they had to figure out, you know, what are we going to do? All the businesses closed, everybody left, all our kids left town. What are we going to do here if we have a community? So they decided to go all in on trails, dirt trails.

1:48:23 And these are some numbers that they've come out. And they've done this study really from the time that they made the investment. So it's a modern times investment. So they've been able to track the numbers. So from their investment, they see between $2.3 and $4.9 million in annual spending just from the mountain biking community. That does not include, you know, trail runners and other user groups. This is specific to mountain bikers that come for events.

1:48:52 And weekend warriors from Eugene and Portland. Surprisingly, there aren't that many trail facilities in Eugene, so everybody travels up the hill. This next slide. So we just read, based on a summary from Headwaters Economics, that we can look to other communities for this evidence. I want to be very careful with the language here. In the bottom left legend, you'll see public access, multi-use. So public access means no lift ticket.

1:49:22 Multi-use, non-motorized, so you can run, ride a horse, ride a bike, single track trails, just like in the photograph I showed earlier, a narrow tread width, and miles of trails accessible within 20 miles of communities. So this analysis, in this data, basically think of it as trails like the Mammoth Rock Trail, okay? We have, the Mammoth Rock Trail is 2.5 miles long. If we add up,

1:49:52 All of our multi-use, non-motorized trails in this community, we have 14 miles of it. When compared to Breckenridge, they have 812. Susanville, where I came from, 65. Oak Ridge, Oregon, that I just spoke about, 300 miles. Bend, Oregon, 231. You start to get the picture. We have an amazing wilderness trail network, world class. We have terrific multi-use pathways.

1:50:21 Miles and miles of old roads, OHV network, 100 miles of OSV trails. This is the piece of the puzzle that we're missing. It's the kind of experience where if you live in a condo here, if you're visiting, staying in a hotel, this whole community can be the trailhead if we have more front country opportunities like the Mammoth Rock Trail. This paints a picture to me. Maps are very powerful.

1:50:50 And this really tells the tale. In the Headwaters Economics Summaries, I'm not going to read through all of this, but there are terrific business impacts. I think all of us, I'm kind of preaching to the choir here with business folks that understand recreation in the room, but it's good to highlight the quality of life component. You can read about how communities are affected, populations of people are affected positively, their health, public health.

1:51:21 Property values. They don't go down. When somebody has a trail nearby their home, that adds value to the property. And then lastly, I just wanted to point out, my friend David over here recently shared a beautiful bit of writing, and I've just bulleted some of the things that we've accomplished in just a year.

1:51:48 What an inspiring question at the end. What will we invest in and accomplish together in the next year? And anyway, at first, reading this, I was like, wow, we really did accomplish that. Hard to believe. But day by day, it doesn't feel like it. But when you add it up over a year, it really was powerful. This is the budget sheet in front of you. It's basically to recommend a five-year commitment.

1:52:16 and recommend a one-year budget for the next fiscal year, but we'd like to commit to a five-year program so that we have some predictability, so that we can plan for specific projects and work very strongly with the Forest Service. I'm going to shift gears pretty quickly here. Also, today, we hope that you can recommend to Town Council how we will handle a very specific project.

1:52:45 Where we have a lot of sign infrastructure in place today on multi-use pathways. They're really, really nice signs. All of the maps are outdated. All of them. We have built infrastructure in recent times, and none of that infrastructure is reflected in the maps. There will be some wayfinding language on the signs that needs to be replaced. And the cost is roughly $25,000. And these are the kind of signs we're talking about.

1:53:15 Just for reference, you've seen them around town. The nice type 2 signs that people gather around to get good wayfinding information. All of these maps are outdated. Thankfully, it's kind of a good news thing, right? We've built new infrastructure. But we do not currently today have a means to pay for the replacement of this. It was not paid for with Measure R dollars. And which brings me to this slide. And if you zero in on the...

1:53:41 The right-hand side here, the word supplanting is very important. Measure R did not pay for this infrastructure, and so it's probably, the town council has to decide how this infrastructure needs to be updated. So my recommendations to you today are to approve the Mammoth Lakes Trail System budget as recommended by the Mammoth Trails Committee.

1:54:11 We worked very hard over the past few months to develop a program budget that will work, a budget for success, and the committee has made that recommendation to you. And then also, given the potential for supplanting on the sign infrastructure, my recommendation to the MRR Board is to recommend that the Town Council provide direction with regard to funding the map update effort for existing Mammoth Lakes Trail System signs.

1:54:41 So I'll be taking that to Town Council based on your feedback. That's the end of this presentation. However, I want you to be aware that if you have any specific questions, I have sort of an appendix of that budget sheet where I've cropped out different sections so that you can see them on the slides all the way from the top to the bottom. Yeah, thanks, Joel. Thank you, Joel. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Questions, comments from the board?

1:55:21 I think we'll look back at it.

1:56:00 I think it's a smart work plan and the budget makes sense to me. I'd just ask you the kind of elevator question. I mean, going through the bonding stuff, that budget was still at $300,000 a year, even in the future cash flow projections. And you guys, the new budget ask is $400,000. So maybe just the quick version of what are we getting for the extra budget?

1:56:31 Me. That first budget was formulated before trails coordinator was on staff. Going back to that budget, I think it was allocated as a $500,000 one-time trail use. So what's kind of the difference in us? That's what Rob presented. Yeah, the way Rob presented is keeping it at $300,000 and then doing a one-time $500,000. I don't really understand that.

1:57:05 So I put the $500,000 in there to basically say how can we, that's really capital investment to work on the trails, but it comes to the same number. So if you take the $500,000 as the funded amount out of the five-year commitment of $400,000, you still get the $300,000 on a regular basis. So we're still really asking for the same amount, just approaching it a different way, and it would make the funds available up front for trail construction. And Joel, how do you feel about that?

1:57:37 That is an amazing opportunity. I am not aware of a community in America that has that kind of front-loaded trails program.

1:58:13 Immediately, I think of the word leverage. I think of a federal agency that would come to the table and say, wow, we can partner with these folks. That's a long-term commitment. This is not a small operation of dirt bags that just want to go work with some tools in the dirt. This is a serious, serious potential partner. And it just sets the stage.

1:58:42 For that, I mean, it ensures that if there's a grant opportunity that reveals itself, and they do, as we know, the Lakes Basin Path was built with an ARRA grant. We know that those opportunities present themselves. We will always have a match, is what I immediately think of. And having been a part of trail programs in the past where we didn't always have that match, like, oh, quick, there's a grant due next month. You know, how are we going to get a match? We are not going to have that.

1:59:12 And so it gives me a level of confidence that I wouldn't otherwise have. And just as an aside, another thing that Joel's been working with others, they call the National Trail Stewardship Act. Various Forest Service regions have been tasked with trying to find priority areas to kind of streamline stewardship and volunteer projects. And one of the criteria for doing that is communities that are well organized and have the capital and have the groups ready in.

1:59:57 So there are things. One, Joel, for financial information, I don't know if you're getting access from John's and the overall stage, but you can get much better than that. Your financial impact is probably much higher than my guess here. Typically, when I see the amount in the summertime and what people spend is here in the community, you have some numbers that would better enhance your appreciation. Just as an overall, it's much higher than what you're using there. Second, though, my biggest thing is, as I read this,

2:00:28 We have saying that we're at $450,000 of unspent dollars that we're walking into the next year for trails. And we went from $300,000 to $400,000. We're short, last I saw, we're about $180,000 short of expending $300,000 this year. And I recognize we have projects going up. I'm a little nervous about going to $400,000. Not because it's not needed, but I'm just trying to figure out, is that the right level each year? Because I take it as this year saying, and then Team Claire says $850,000 basically available this year.

2:00:58 Why are we allocating, I guess it needs more time, if we need in two years from now to be $400,000 versus $400,000 today, why are we funding in advance and take a look at what's our need five years from now and why are we structuring accordingly versus just allocating money into reserve to hold on to it?

2:01:17 When would we be better served to say, okay, this is the money we need over five years? It still looks like it's slightly short if we take all these numbers. There's a few things in here that I question in terms of the wayfinding. It's been kicked around in several different areas. I sat on the initial wayfinding map consultants that came to town many years ago. It's been a consideration of how you do wayfinding, not just this science, but other wayfinding for the community because there's many questions of where do you...

2:01:43 Put these signs. And believe me, I see, I live up by some of these trails, I see people hitting these maps all the time for information. I would have said initially everybody was going to pull the cell phone, but when someone's on their bike, they're looking at the signs pretty regularly from an overall standpoint. We're taking a pretty big chunk of change here, and I don't want to be like, okay, sounds good, we're going to be accepting, let's see, 4, 8, 12, you know.

2:02:12 Basically those $2.2 million in expenditures for the next five years that we're committed to right now. I think that's what Rob understood it properly. I think it is. You see, okay, this is a commitment for me. Okay, that $500,000 is just, you can look at it at $400,000 and an increase in $100,000 a year saying, look, you know, we're going to make a $500,000 commitment to, you know, building these 100 miles of trails.

2:02:43 When it's needed. That's not okay. Okay, so I'm, yeah, I'm going to come across that same, because like right now we're saying, well, I'll get $400,000 this year, we're getting $450,000 a bank, we're going to be left with $300,000, even on this scale. Why, why start with that? Why would you say, okay, year two? I think we made a political commitment. This is what we're being asked.

2:03:06 Yeah, but from an overall standpoint of expenditures, I'm not even going to guess that. It's almost you're talking cash flow. Yeah, I'm really talking the timing of what's needed. I'll let Joel and Dan answer that, but one of the things that we dealt with as a committee was this fact that we're working with an agency and we never quite know what the timing's going to be in terms of environmental approvals, and we need to be able to show that we're ready when it's time to pull the trigger. So we don't have the time.

2:03:35 You know, if the agency says, all right, you're good to go on these five trails, and then we have to come back and spend three months raising the money to build those trails, that's where we're in trouble. And don't forget, relating this back to the bonding conversation too, you know, once we move money towards some significant capital projects, you know, our available revenue has shrunk. This is a lane where we can continue.

2:04:07 to make a great deal of progress for the town in a very needed area. And I like the idea of investing in the workflow and the actual projects based on that timeline rather than kind of holding back to cash flow a little differently. I understand your concern completely, but I think there is value in that upfront commitment as opposed to just kind of, you know.

2:04:37 Following the dollars as they are needed year to year. That would be my personal feeling. I agree. I think it's great. I mean, I can tell a lot of time and effort and energy has been put into this and thought. And, you know, I'm familiar with communities like Oak Ridge, and they were dying. And I know over 50 people who would go for this big mountain biking weekend, and they go every year. And if Mammoth had more of those free public access trails.

2:05:07 It could really help us out in so many different ways. You know, quality of life for all of us, as well as just bringing in people who don't want to pay to mountain bike, necessarily, but want to contribute to our, you know, local economy. And I agree if we have, if the trails have, the trails committee and Joel has the money up front to leverage against other possible grants, I think it's going to be incredibly valuable for them.

2:05:35 To be able to go forward and not just wait, ask money. Three months later, yes, I'm in support of this. Whether it's in the $400,000 per year or whether it's staying at $300,000 and doing the $500,000. So that's other thoughts on that. Further comments? I agree with the time crunch here. Is there a seasonal preparation we are discussing also? So if I need to put our money forward so we can manage it.

2:06:06 I do have a question on the $500,000. If the $500,000 is given up front, you've said that, you know, that would be great. It shows a commitment. Potential grants. I don't see anywhere in here where grants are even considered, and I know grants, you know, are looked for, but, you know, where we're being contracted to say that we need to do this, you know, maybe that's also something that we need to look at as we're committing money towards this if it's a larger

2:06:36 Amount of money. If the $500,000 came forward today, does that move any of this up any faster, or is there any trails that kind of are produced any sooner, or are we still kind of on this same track? Thank you. So your first question about the, you know, including some sort of grant calculus into our proposal, it's in there, so you'll see a deficit over time.

2:07:08 That's an acknowledgement. You know, in that budget sheet at the bottom, you'll see that the numbers go into parentheses in the third year and beyond. That's an acknowledgement that, yes, we need to seek other sources. And then on the $500,000, does it speed up timelines? It does not speed up necessarily like environmental review timelines.

2:07:34 But it certainly shows the Forest Service that we have the funding to pay for that analysis. But it does not affect timelines for necessary processes like NEPA and CEQA mandated processes. Will it help speed up construction? Yes. Okay, so adequate funding at, I pick a $5 a foot figure.

2:08:01 For those projections and cost for trail construction, that's based on several sources and experience. But if we have that kind of funding, we can hire multiple trail contractors to build multiple facilities in the same season. So that kind of funding does allow for construction to go much faster.

2:08:25 We are using, say, fire crews, hot shot crews, or inmate fire crews with Cal Fire. The construction will happen more slowly. We'll get it done, but it will take multi-year efforts. And I appreciate that, but I guess when I look at these deficits, I don't necessarily consider that you're looking for grants to fulfill those. I see that you're going to come back to the table in three years and say that you need more money. And so I guess that is where I'm looking at.

2:08:53 Maybe there's some language that could be put in place. Well, I don't think it should be specific to grants. It could be some wild donation. It could be any type of funding, but other funding than Measure R, I guess, is what I would be looking at. Thank you.

2:09:31 The goal here is to get 100 miles of trails for a lot. Any further discussion from the board? Public comments? I want to speak from two perspectives. One is sitting on the trails committee. And I'm fully supportive. Having the $2 million a year going into trails, I think, is great. The other concern was, I think, tying it up now is important in some sense. So as we have the other projects come up.

2:10:02 Oh, we have the new shiny objects. Let's take our trail money and go stick it over here. I just do not have that happen from a practical standpoint. I also did ask Joel after we got into some of this discussion, what does a $300,000 program budget look like if you put the $500,000 up front? So we knew we had, and going to Brent's comment, there will be $900,000 or close to a million dollars in the trail budget that would not be spent if you put $500,000 over.

2:10:30 That's a lot of dollars to go into the design, the planning, the work to actually get trails on the ground. And so you're not hamstrung in that financial process through that. And I think that commits to dollars. It makes the commitment I believe we've made as a community to our trail system, back to the 100-mile trail option. We'd like to see some of that in areas in joint with the county and other stuff, and that will require different funding and all those types of things.

2:10:59 And looking at that to commit the $2 million over the five years I think is a good commitment to trails and it says we're serious about it. We can narrow the program down to that $300,000 a year if the $500,000 goes in. Now some of that obviously is some overlap when you do design and some of the different work element. But the nice part is to walk in and say we have a rough number of a million dollars to go build trails in our community and we actually start seeing them this next summer being built.

2:11:26 I think that also generates the potential to raise the funding gap. Plus, if we do move some of the environmental stuff faster, some other elements to that, all of a sudden, we're ready to go construction. It's not coming back and asking for dollars that may or may not be available. That's the other trade-off on that. So fully support the $2 million over the time frame.

2:11:48 I put a town hat on. I would prefer the half a million up front committed to capital in that work program and then $300 a year for trails going over time. I think that helps with cash flow for other things in the measure R funds down the road. But it also tells Joel for the next five years at least, we are going to build a lot of trails. And if we're not moving dirt out there, we're not successful, frankly. Some of the program elements may get skinnied down a little bit. And frankly,

2:12:17 If I have to choose between the two, I'd rather see the trail built than the right map done, if you will. I hate to put it that way, but I think our visitor experience is more about being on the ground than what we're doing on the program side. I mean, they ultimately go hand in hand. So from that perspective, from the MTC side, I fully support the $2 million ask over time. I would personally lean as a town manager also to

2:12:41 Put the half million up front. Let's tie that into our capital construction, into the capital program. And then we lean on Joel Skinny, your program down to the 300 a year. Let's see if we can't get more miles on the ground versus maybe some of the other work. And that'll be some choices the MTC will have to work through. But committing two million to trails, I think, sends the right message for at least what I've heard since I've been here and what I enjoy doing, frankly, out there hiking around and doing stuff.

2:13:10 Mountain biking, I see too many people with scars, so that's not a high priority for me. I can wreck on the street just easy enough. Anyway, he, but... Busted shoulders, collarbones. Yes. But anyway, so I think that's there. I think that's, you know, the grapple a little bit, and from a recommendation to town council, I think it can go either way, frankly, in terms of the commitment that way. I think the $2 million is the right commitment. I'd rather see some dollars committed up front, because I'll be honest, there will be pressure to spend that money elsewhere if it's not. So...

2:13:39 And there will be some push-me-pull-you through that process. Anyway, thank you. And that would all still come from Measure R? Yeah, that would still be a Measure R-funded project in Trails. I mean, Measure U can fund that. We're not requesting anything of that. So we focus on the Measure R. Thank you. Other public comment? Michael? Good evening. I'll keep it short. I do want to convey, having come to...

2:14:14 Several of these meetings and like that the passion that you all hold in, I know it to be a thankless job when I served in different boards and I want to thank you from the outside. Have an appreciation for Mammoth the last 30 years and traveling back and forth. I bought a home about almost a year ago down near Corali Lakes and Mammoth has always been a home to me. I've got a home with my family up here also. Anyway, I did want to say.

2:14:43 Thank you for looking out after your town, this town. On a conservative basis, working in the automotive franchise business and operating and working with a CFO of hundreds of millions of dollars a year, you're in a good position. I was in it in the recession, as many of you were. And there was no reserves. But on the MLR basis,

2:15:09 Having $1.8 million to keep their own reserve that could feed the entire year in working capital, that's a pretty certain financial bet, as you were saying and you're comfortable with, and I'm just reinforcing on the outside, you're financially secure. Just like the trails, if there's a $500,000 buffer and you got a $400,000 budget, you got a nice buffer there. You know, even in hard times, you'll find a way to either come up with the money.

2:15:35 Or reduce your expenses in association against the revenue generation. And that's one thing that I see the trails having unbiasedly, even though I walked a lot of trails, is the revenue generation opportunities. I don't know how it's tracked, so to speak, from your example or your model in Oregon, showing that incremental dollars that come in in revenue associated with trails. And I think we all know, I don't know how many years it's been that the

2:16:05 Spring, summer, season, relative to winter, exceeds in revenue, and a lot of it can't even be accounted for, right? It's from a visitation standpoint. And when you can draw more people up here in Mammoth Lakes, which will be easy to do with the trailhead system that leads from the town with the community that needs the support of more coming up here, right? There's nothing wrong with 100% sellout. I heard we were 86% less Friday.

2:16:33 That's pretty impressive. Anyway, thank you. Appreciate your comments. Your donations are warmly accepted. That's a good point about dealing with growing summer visitation and dispersion and the ability. And that's not just about dispersing more people. It's also about stewardship and being able to control the impacts across a broader spectrum of activity.

2:17:01 So we're being asked to approve a $400,000 a year budget. Or a modified motion based on what we've heard so far. Yeah. I am open to a motion or more discussion. You know, I like this. I'm okay with this. But we have an allocation that's coming up. And there's some...

2:17:31 Questions that are going to come up on the allocation that could impact the budget, could impact things going forward. Would we want to go and have that conversation and then make this suggestion or this? It's a fair question. I think they're ones you, ones are. No. No? Well, yeah, ones you, ones are. Correct. So that is true. I'd like to tick this off. I would too. And make a commitment. I agree, I didn't look at it like that. You're right. One's coming from R, one's coming from E.

2:18:02 I'll make a motion to modify the request to $500,000 up front and then continue with the yearly $300,000 for the next five years. Second. Could we just add, there was a second piece which was to add just a recommendation to have council give direction on the $25,000 for the hard surface signs.

2:18:27 That's separate motion. We can take action. That's not on the agenda. Okay. But go to page 32 in your board packet. You'll see hard surface map updates and repairs to $25,000 is included in our recommendation to council. Okay. So they're two separate things. So it's not getting lost. Okay. Okay. So let's just tackle the one thing that's on the radar that's been taken care of further. If somebody else wants to second. You got it. Frank? Oh, it's being council. I'll second. Yeah. Thank you. Okay.

2:18:58 Can I ask an out-of-order question of Joel? I'm okay with it. We have a second, so it's discussion. It's discussion about the motion. So, Joel, does that work for you? If we do it this way, we're allocating the 500, I recognize, but I'm just covering my basis, because are you okay with the, rather than allocating the 400, 500 front, and then 300 a year thereafter? We're still saying about money, but are you okay with that?

2:19:27 There are many positive adjectives that I could use. Just trying to make sure, because you're, you know, one thing as an overall discussion, I think we should be shining bright on what we've done trails. I think Joel has done a tremendous job in this town, and the heart and soul trail is usual, and the reason I'm persuaded to do it is because I know what you've done, and I know you're working your butt off to get this stuff done, and you've made this kind of a better place. I appreciate it.

2:19:56 Thank you so much. Absolutely. I do actually have one question on the motion. So you said $500,000 up front. Are we saying $500,000 for capital up front? And then $300,000 for the program for the next five years? Because that's what I heard in the discussion that I had here. And is that contingent upon us taking action in May to recommend bonding? Okay. So let's think about that as we begin to flush out our budget.

2:20:26 And is that correct, that that $500,000 is near market capital? Is that something we want in the language of this motion? Does that... That's the conversation I heard up here, so that's what I... That was in Rob's... Three and five. Yeah, if I can clarify, yeah, it's in that capital category down there. I mean, capital includes your, you know, your design, your planning, your... Site planning, yeah. Site planning, your... It takes a lot of work to get to construction, so some of those dollars will need to be used for that, the environmental work, so...

2:20:57 It leads to that capital, but it's not going into designing the website. It's not going into some of the other. So we want to clarify this being capital. Yeah, so it's capital. Our capital includes those types of categories. I just want to clarify that. I'm fine with that. I just don't want to put an undue restriction. Yeah, no, I think that works for the operational side. So I can clarify my motion that an upfront allocation of $500,000 for capital for trails with a yearly $300,000.

2:21:26 And we have a second. And I'll second that amendment. Okay. Any further discussion? And the other thing is that I'm taking it just like we're recommending it's where it goes to. It goes to council. That's right. At the end of the day, what they have for budget, they're still short money. That's my biggest concern at this point in time. What happens, whether Terry's right or anybody else, you know, in terms of three years from now, I don't want to be short.

2:21:56 Getting halfway down. We talked about getting projects done complete. I'm hoping with that money up front and that commitment that Joel's going to go out there and we're going to... Well, just our adopted trail proposal is huge and will help with that. And this contingent on moving to show the agency our commitment. So I think it's wrapped up. Okay, further discussion? We need a public comment.

2:22:30 As I said earlier, I'm not a CFO, but I would, in the recommendation before it's approved, retain, make sure there's always $300,000 in that fund as working capital. That's secure working capital for a year's time. You need that to be secure and conservative for this town. Also wanted to highly recommend, because it is a first impression when you walk onto a trailhead that you give them that $25,000 or take the $25,000 when you get it.

2:23:00 and use it immediately for signs. That is a fabulous first impression to a trailhead. Thank you. Okay, we have a motion. We have a second. All in favor of the motion? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Mr. Chairman, can we take a five-minute break? No way, man. We're only two and a half hours in. We're halfway home. Yes, let's take a quick five-minute break.

2:23:32 And then we'll resume with allocations. I'm going to look to maybe pull what we'll talk about when we get there, but I want to burn through the rest of the agenda if possible. So let's all try and really be precise and compact with our comments and questions moving forward. Okay. So next up is allocations. We're being asked...

2:24:12 We're given three scenarios for funding recommendations for Measure U funding for fiscal year 17 and 18. It looks like there's one recommendation that's just our $115,000 cap that we've agreed to for the last two years. Keeping that in place, and we have a recommendation against that.

2:24:38 That would be number A. That's A. And then B is actually asking the board to approve a 25% increase in that cap number. And there's a recommendation on what funding that would allow in that scenario, which is B, budget B. And then C is, has to do with the MAC budget. There's a $270,000 annual

2:25:08 proposed commitment to the MAC that includes the repertory theater. So that one's going to take some explaining. So maybe I'll hand it off to whoever wants to take it, either Rich or Terry, to kind of walk us through the scenarios and the recommendations. I'd be happy to. So, anyways. Yeah, or Drea. Drea was on the committee as well, as well as Rachel. And so, you know,

2:25:37 We went through our new process and kind of what Drea just explained to me is we came a long way from the first time that we took on this and sat here for over eight hours deliberating this. The scoring process, I'll have to say, when we kind of went through the whole thing, seemed like it might be a bit of an issue, but it actually worked better. It still needs some tweaks. There were some questions that may or may not pertain to kind of what we're doing here. So we're going to move forward with that.

2:26:05 But what became very clear was that every year we're going to have more and more demand on the monies as far as programming goes. And we've had that conversation as to, you know, we need to go out and raise some more other money for programming. Kind of another piece, I'm just going to throw it out there before I start talking about A, B, and C, is something that Rachel being new on this committee kind of brought up and was...

2:26:33 Actually a really key thing. So we need to look at kind of what we're funding and make sure that it's kind of a mix and that we're not focusing all everything in one basket. And I think that that was really kind of key. I know my concern when we're looking at this $115,000 and $270,000 that it was at about 48% of the budget that was being proposed. If we go up to the $900,000, it's 42%.

2:27:03 In your column A, one of the things that was taken out is the Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center. And I guess my logic with being able to go to an increase of the 25% is that, you know, that's taking out the one recreation component of this whole thing. So I can kind of justify it takes...

2:27:30 It's not adding another layer to our arts and cultural programming, but it increases the budget for the programming and adding a recreational component to that. And so that's kind of one of my thoughts as I was trying to work through this. I'll have to say we did the scoring process. The scoring actually kind of came out a little bit better than I anticipated because just using a zero to three, I thought it was going to be really close.

2:27:59 There's some questions that were, you know, a little off. And then the next question that we had when we came up with the scoring is, so do you just give all the money to the top number or do we need to have it more diverse and it needs to spread out? And so we looked at percentages. Can you just go with a straight percentage and go on that with the numbers? So we used the numbers to kind of look at what we were allocating towards each person here.

2:28:28 And, you know, did the best we could as far as coming up with something that we felt was somewhat fair. But what, like, I'll go back to the one thing, what we, what came painfully clear no matter what we did in percentages and trying to come up with something, we just could not come to that $115,000 without cutting everybody's budgets to the point that it wasn't worth giving them any money. You know, it's, there comes that point which

2:28:57 Is giving them $2,000 really giving them anything that they're going to be able to have anything that's useful that comes out of it? And so that's why we made the cuts in A that we did is that, look, if we're going to have $115,000 for programming, we felt that this was something that these folks would still be able to put on quality programs, but it did eliminate.

2:29:27 Some folks in there. And, you know, we talked about throwing $1,000 in there, throwing $2,000 in there, and we felt that, you know, that's just really still didn't do that program justice to do that. And so we felt that if we had to go with A, and we were sticking with $115,000, that this would give these folks that we did allocate money to, enough money to still put on their program.

2:29:54 And so really what we are recommending is column B. And like I said, that was kind of my justification of being able to go there is that we're adding a recreation component. And that's kind of one of the biggest pieces that we're adding back to that is the avalanche. And with the backcountry recreation growing the way it is, I think that's a key component to what we can move forward with.

2:30:24 Column C is we're really not sure what's going on with MAC. Is there going to be a contract? Is there money that's going to be coming forward this year that we're going to have to allocate? And that if it is, that it is our understanding and we could be wrong because it hasn't been agreed to as to whether the repertory theater is going into that $270,000. We're assuming it is.

2:30:53 You know, we really don't know. So in this column C assumption is that if we are going to have a contract with MAC to the tune of $270,000 to $300,000, whatever that number is, that the repertory theater would be included in that. And so we've removed it from the C component. And if we did the C component, then we can fund all of these programs to the level that you see there.

2:31:23 If the Repertory Theater has been taken out of that. Is that something you've managed to confirm with them or not? We have no confirmation at all, so no. I mean, we could go ahead and make that decision ourselves, you know, and even though we don't have an official ask from the MAC for $270,000, we could earmark.

2:31:42 The repertory theater's money over outside of. The conversations happen that that would be embedded in that allocation once we get to that position. We need to make that. I think that's probably the first question tonight. Do we want to embed that in the MAC allocation, whether it's 273, number one? And if so, when do we want to do that? Based on what we heard with bonding tonight, do we want to be in a position that we're going to give in to earmark that money right now, whether it's going to get spent or not? Or do we want to hold on to it?

2:32:11 I think you get some little things to line up before we get there. It was kind of my impression from the special board meeting we had at the workshop with the MAC, but they weren't quite ready to ask for that money for fiscal year 17-18. I guess the question is do we need their official ask to know that this ask for the repertory theater is still going to be in it regardless of what the number is.

2:32:39 So do we just go ahead and proactively? I mean, it's something we could do if we chose to do. Yes. So from an overall standpoint, it seems a little bit aggressive to do that. I mean, if it comes back and we choose to incorporate that point in time, we can do it. But for me, I don't see C as being an option at this point in time because we have no ask. And it could be higher, lower, whatever, but I'm willing to consider whatever at that point in time. But from doing today, I don't see how I can act on C from the standpoint of saying, oh, if it comes along,

2:33:10 I don't want to guarantee anybody any money either way until I get an ask and then we'll decide where it goes. I totally agree. And I think if an ask were to come in in four or five months for $270, we'd just deduct the amount that had been allocated. Figured out there? Yeah. Come back. And so we could look at this knowing that that money is going to be going elsewhere. Is that if we increase the program funding to the $143,750,

2:33:40 And we can budget that moving forward. It has increased your program funding. But I think we also need to look at if we're going to increase that and have it as a line item moving forward, we need to make sure that we have varied programs and it's not all going in one basket. Sorry. Go ahead. So the portion is, I look at it and say, all right, if we had savings this year of, I mean, whatever dollars difference is there,

2:34:12 Potentially. But we don't have an increase in revenue. So I'm stuck with it. We already talked about $115,000 as our amount. And I know there's some very tough choices to happen here. I mean, we may get down here and agree or disagree on some of these choices. But I have a hard time justifying going up without saying either, I'm not going to spend more than $200,000 that we allocated this year, so therefore it's a net zero. Or we've got more money coming in. We do have more money coming in. To a partial. But is that going to be every year?

2:34:39 No. You don't know. We're only looking at this year. Year over year now. But Terry's going to say, we start to set the trend, saying, okay, we go forward. To me, it's like, okay, we're going to save $20,000 this year of 120. I'll pay more clients. If there's something coming up, yeah. Excuse me. Thank you. Increasing the expense without more revenue. I agree. I mean, for me, on the one hand, it's a test of our fiscal discipline, for sure.

2:35:08 But, on the other hand, it's really looking at the projects, are we right-sized, you know, for what our responsibility is, what we feel our responsibility is in the programming arena. Because next year, we're going to have $500,000. It'll increase every year. It's going to be a challenge. But that's not, I'm going to have some money to be able to get out and work with people who have projects and no money at all. It's not a terrible challenge. And I guess that's where, you know, that would be.

2:35:38 What we need to do is raise outside funds to increase the program. And that's where I think it still comes back to. It's a gap of if we raised another $200,000 a year, great. I think that's what we should be doing. Yeah, I would just say that, I mean, I can appreciate the reluctance to establish precedent to raise that number. But at the same time, it's

2:36:08 It feels really difficult. Look, programming at this point, I mean, it's kind of like the trails. Like, we have programming in the door right now. We can't, I mean, especially looking at the Mac, and we haven't yet seen the feasibility there. We're talking about building a 300-seat theater. If we don't invest in programming now, that 300-seat theater is going to be empty for some years.

2:36:33 So I feel like it's a very important investment right now to keep that programming alive. Yeah, but I'm not sure the two all tie together because programming that 300 seat theater may be completely different than some of the programming we have here. No, but I think keeping that programming alive to keep those audiences happening, to keep, and I think, I mean, there are a couple of, let me just run through, I have a couple of things that one thing I think we still need to address. One is we need to raise money. The other is, I think, I'm curious, which

2:37:00 What portion of these budgets is coming in as a marketing and promotion element? Because that still has yet to be determined. We still are in a situation where we have a lot of taxpayer money going to marketing, but it's not going to promoting this Measure U-funded programming. So is that a place where we can put our attention over the next year to alleviate that cost for these producers to help make that Measure U money?

2:37:29 More seriously leveraged. We're still not allowing marketing out of these particular funds, right? Basically, we looked at the documents that we were looking at were tax returns, P&Ls, current budgets, and previous year's P&Ls. And then we were also, they had a budget to fill out. That was one of the pieces that we had some issues with is the budget.

2:37:57 But in that, marketing was not one of the pieces that was in what was being asked. Usually, typically it supplies an admin cost that we're looking at here. It's a good, no, your point's perfectly made. I mean, we, you know, that's a function of growing programming that's required. And how that becomes, that's funded over time.

2:38:22 The last piece of that is just to say that, look, next year when we're in a place where we've said, look, we are bonding X amount, this is our budget, this is how much is going to these two capital projects, then we can turn around and say, this is really all we have. But to do that in the abstract now seems like we're kind of shooting ourselves in the foot. No, but I still argue that we're just arbitrarily changing. Let me go back to the first question.

2:38:49 If I look at, and I recall from the financials, we're about $16,000 on our budget expenditures so far year-to-date through February. I think we're going to have to eat up some of that. What's our number at the end of the year, is my question. How far are we going to go from our original budget? In terms of operations. Operation expenses. About $20,000. About $20,000. But we can't use that for this. I'm not going to tell that some. I just...

2:39:17 Just trying to see where we are. So if you want to stay with the 115, which is something that last year we said, you know, we can't go above that number. This is what was set and this is what we need to do. Then you do have a column A. And whether you agree with what cuts were made, those were some of the decisions that we ended up making because it's like, okay, look, if this is what we're going to do, we feel that...

2:39:45 These numbers are fair for these people to put on the programs that they had presented. And so there has to be some cuts somewhere. And that's fine. That's the discussion that needs to happen today. But we felt that we really needed to bring forward some other options so we could have that conversation. Yeah, and we obviously spent hours reviewing applications.

2:40:16 You know, looking at the request of allocations, which was, you know, $250,000 with a budget of $115,000, and there are some new asks, and there are some asks that have been larger this year in part to loss of other grants and whatnot, but we really didn't like option A, and it took us a long time to get to here, and part of that was because we were going to have to give everybody, you know, if we wanted to give everybody

2:40:45 If we wanted to fund everybody, it was just going to be so minute that we thought, was Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center even going to be able to do something if they only get $4,000? Well, they're not. So that's why we had to just make some of those tough choices. But certainly I am in favor of funding B. If we had more money, I would find lots of places to give more money. It's obviously lots of difficult decisions to make.

2:41:16 How, just, you may have already explained this, or it may just have to do with the scoring, but how did you decide how much, by how much to reduce each? We actually kind of started with a percentage and said, okay, here's the higher numbers, we maybe can fund those guys at 85%, and then we started with it. Maniflake's rep, it looks like you're at about 97%, and Chamber Unbound, you're at 60%.

2:41:43 And then some of it is just looking at budgets.

2:42:13 Things making more sense, some budgets being a little bit more, or some budgets being very complete, very exact, and things matching with P&Ls. Yeah, it was P&Ls, budgets, tax returns, money in the bank, volunteer hours versus paid admin. So we kind of looked at a lot of those different things as we were moving forward. I mean, there's a lot that...

2:42:36 You know, kind of goes into that decision. And if I can just, sorry, taking it back to, you know, the strategy and how does that particular program align with our broad strategy. So that was something. The broad objective of the strategy. Yeah, so that we looked at a lot. So at the bottom you've got special projects and those are the dollars from above that you're saying that could potentially be special projects because we do have the 25 there. I just want to make sure I'm reading this correctly. Yes.

2:43:04 But is it the recommendation that that come against the special project or could come against? It could. So this is something that, like the historic society, we kind of worked with them. The initial application that came through was pretty broad. It said they were funding these programs, but we didn't have specific programs that they said they were funding. And so we asked them to give us some additional information.

2:43:31 They did. They still broke it down a bit more, but we really felt that, you know, it was still, it was kind of more just putting money into the operations as opposed to any specific project or program. So we felt that it was something that they could come back. We could have that conversation. What is it that you're looking to do? What do you want the money to go towards specifically and then potentially see if it can come back as a...

2:43:56 Special project. There's a balance of $3,600 in that one-time $25,000 capital project to Measure U. I talked to Dave and Marianne the other day. They're going to put together a little proposal and we'll bring a recommendation for a special project at our next board meeting. Yeah, it wasn't complete enough at that point to... And we asked questions and we actually got a lot of information kind of after our first meeting, which, you know, hopefully we can keep fine-tuning that because when you get

2:44:26 You get new budgets and you get new information and then all of a sudden you're coming back and having to make this decision. It was a little, you know, it wasn't ideal. Because when we talked about it before to a certain degree, we said, you know, special projects actually is increasing our dollars to be able to allocate as we go forward. So we actually have increased the budget by $25,000. Yes. Because when we initially started this, we didn't have that.

2:44:49 And something that we have to consider when we're looking at special projects, kind of like with Avalanche last year with your forest island this year, is that when you allocate special project money,

2:45:06 You've got to look at what the forward ask is going to be. What are they going to need next year? Because you're giving them a special project this year. Is it going to be an ongoing programming? Because if it is, and we spent $115,000 already and we only have that next year, you're saying, okay, you know, something has to give somewhere. You can't just continue doing something as a one-off and not expect it to be an issue the next year, which is exactly where we are with the Avalanche for the last year. How long did we pilot things?

2:45:35 I don't feel great about saying, hey, we want to seed this project, and then they get it off the ground, and it's like, no, no funding this year. And so those are issues as we're looking at our special projects. Our special projects really should be a one-time fund where it isn't going to require funding the next year. So, Mr. Chair, just to come back, so are we saying the seeds off the table? Is that...

2:46:01 Yes, no, I'm just trying to narrow it out of the conversation. I think that's the consensus that I'm reading from the board. So let's take C off the table. Where does the additional 29,000 come from? Because we have got reserves in the overall. It's just increasing the budget item. Okay, so I'm looking at here and I'm saying where does it come from? It's just not on here. It's somewhere that we're pulling in. It would be pulled out of Measure U, our...

2:46:26 Funds that we have right now that are just sitting there in the fund balance. Heather, you look at $29,000. Heather, you look at page 32 and 33. Those are all working. Measure 16, 17, R&U, and some projected items. You see our ending balances at this point. The difference is $28,750. We do have money in the budget. So I'm hearing from the two committee members that they're in.

2:46:55 You guys are in favor of B. Is that correct? That's your of the two? If we were to say which one do you recommend? I recommend B. You've already stated B. B plus $50,000. I would recommend B. But I guess the question to the board was is there any appetite to increase over the $115,000? And that's what I'm trying to get to the point so we get to the individual items. Just the consensus of the board.

2:47:25 So we can then say whatever it is. Let's move on. Either way. I think we're holding tight with this kind of physical discipline that we've been demonstrating for the last few years. We've kept that number where it is. In large part also because we didn't know it was coming. Yeah, exactly. We were really trying to be conservative and now we're starting to see where things are coming from. We also are on a path where we feel like fund development is

2:47:55 Positive fund development is in our near future. So the landscape's changing a little bit. Is it changing enough for us to make that decision? And to David's point, David, I feel like I was hearing you say kind of, hey, well, in this particular year that we're looking at. It's year-to-year. Yeah, exactly. The impact of $30,000 to these programs is much greater than the $30,000 we're going to keep in the bank. Absolutely.

2:48:25 I mean, to divulge my point of view, that's where I'm sitting. In this particular year, I favor B. I really, truly believe we have capital gaps and programming gaps in our vision for where we're trying to go. And I think we have a responsibility to both in this particular year. I like just going program to program, but also in general, I prefer option B. And just something I'd like to say too.

2:48:52 Option B, when we first started putting money in it, it was much higher. And, you know, Rachel, our numbers girl, was awesome. She's like, wait, wait, wait, wait, that's 35% increase. We've got to bring this down, the budget, you know, explain, let's just do this as a 25%. I think we were trying for 20%. Actually, she's doing 20%, yeah. And it was still hard. So, you know, in order to fund these different programs. So, you know, she, I think, was able to contribute a lot from a,

2:49:22 Finance background, as well as looking at a lot of these programs with completely new eyes and also especially looking at the budgets and the P&Ls and just seeing a lot of inconsistencies in some of them. And that was, it's challenging to have that. And I think just on Terry's point, something that was challenging on the whole, it was wonderful that we were able to meet with

2:49:51 Applicants, you know, we were, Rich kind of helped us batch out some of these applications, but it was then hard because we'd ask questions and then we'd get more information a week later or at our next meeting and so in some ways we had to kind of go back and in the future we'd love to have, you know, ideally we wanted all the information up front but we recognized that this was a new process, it was confusing.

2:50:17 There were some issues. There were some challenges with some of the budgets and plugging numbers in and stuff. But we can fix that for next time. And I think learning from the process, I think it's a good first step towards a process that could work. And I'm just going from the standpoint, I personally favor an A, but if I could pose where Heather stands, because it's already four in that direction. I just want to move to the next step. And I just, I'm not going to sit here and belabor the point. Are you an A and B? I'm a B. So.

2:50:48 Can I just ask a broader question looking forward in this process? Is there a danger that we, in this across-the-board reduction, that we begin to incentivize people inflating their budgets because they know that they're only going to get X percent? Absolutely, of course. And I think that's where, I want to take a second to commend you guys for continuing to really clarify.

2:51:18 A very difficult, unworldly process, and I think it's, we've come a long way since I sat on that committee our first year, and they're like, what the hell are we doing? And then we sat here for another eight hours. Exactly. I mean, David, to your point, I think that's where kind of the scoring and tying the scoring in a deeper way into the final decision starts to, I mean, I want to make sure that we do a really, and this is on Rich and his team,

2:51:46 More so, I think, than the committee at the end of the day is after the allocations, the feedback to really make sure we get the information we need to tighten the screws even more. It's interesting seeing the different scores, you know, from people and the question is do we need a couple more people in there to balance or not or, you know, all that stuff. But your point's well taken that, you know, the idea of across the board cuts starts to...

2:52:15 Build in a criterion that maybe we don't want in there. I think this point system kind of takes care of that as well because you can see over the years how people are raising or reducing their budgets and that should give you some safety. It does. And in answering questions like how long, what's a pilot look like, what's a long-term endeavor look like, what are our stakes in those different kinds of projects?

2:52:37 And so our next steps are going to be, you know, getting feedback from the folks that have applied and us going back through the application because we found some. And I had to say that when I first started looking at this application, I'm like, oh, the scoring process isn't going to work at all. But we worked through it and we used it and went, actually, it worked better than anticipated, but it still needs some tweaks.

2:52:58 Yeah, and a lot of the questions were really hard to apply, like, really applicable to maybe people in programs here. So, any public comment before we start thinking about a vote here? Yeah, come on. I'm Hannah Danielson, the County Library Director, and I just want to thank you all for the opportunity to have...

2:53:25 this opportunity to apply for funds for the library, especially in the economic situation that our libraries are in and the future of libraries. So thank you all for your time. Other public comments? Okay. We can continue on. There's a lot to talk about, but I'm sensing we might be ready to accept a motion here. Almost just this. Yeah.

2:53:53 Yeah, and I'm kind of going a little bit where Dave was going originally and just trying to decipher. I don't want to go back and revisit all the work that's been done, et cetera. But a couple highlights from the standpoint of, so as I heard before, Southern Illinois County Historical Society sounds like they may be coming back before us with some other stuff. But look at scoring, you know, just trying to interpret. I have my own personal beliefs on certain things here, but just going on scoring, we've got Eastern Sierra, I've led center 139, and then I've got

2:54:22 Eastern Sierra Symphony at 140. I'm trying to figure out delineations here. I recognize the sub is, but I'm just trying more in more general summary how, and I got what Tara was doing before, I'm just trying to get my head around a little bit more. So we looked, you know, and I don't know that scoring had as much of an input maybe for me. I'd say one thing that I really thought about

2:54:53 was the future of building a Mac and really wanting to make sure that we had the programming that was required for a 300-seat theater. And music was something that we felt really strongly about. And we looked at, in Scenario 8A, before we got to this, we looked at greatly reducing it, Eastern Sierra Symphony, and we realized that

2:55:22 They wouldn't be able to do an entire show in the summer, an entire performance of bringing up an entire symphony to Mammoth Lakes. So, you know, something like that is the cost of bringing a symphony to Mammoth Lakes is incredibly high. I'll take the users here, Symphony, who also gets money from the county as well as some other funding sources. Did they put that all in their application? Yes, they did. It's all in there. And they've also just recently lost a large grant, as have...

2:55:50 Chamber Unbound. So, you know, we looked at that. I can say that I know, like, for me, they scored lower in some things because they don't necessarily retain, you know, keep a visit, you know, one of the questions is like, will they keep a visitor here longer? Maybe, you know, not. And, you know, in the same way that an arts after school club, you know, is not going to keep a visitor here longer. And I'm just trying to make sure that as we go forward in our review of it,

2:56:18 We set criteria, but I don't want to become subjective on how I'm making determinations. We scored it. Whether I'm good or bad, I'm just concerned that we deviate from score because we think we want something else. I'm just saying that our score is not a portion of it. I know, but I'm looking at it and I'm thinking the score is not a grade, so I'm kind of, okay, this is the grade I guess.

2:56:39 And I would have to say, you know, if you went straight on the score, then you would start cutting different things. And I will tell you right now that Forest Island, you just gave them $5,000, so how do you not give them the funding to do at least, all we gave them funding is to do one program. If they come through with that, then, you know, they're going to come back and we'll have further funding later. Your point's well taken. I think that's what we were kind of talking about before, that if we have a bulletproof process at some point.

2:57:07 I don't know that I ever will. Well, we never will perfectly. But if it can get to the point, right, where... It's getting tighter. I mean, there's always going to be some level, layer of subjectivity. Absolutely. There's just no way around it. It's human nature. But we just keep tightening those screws each year. I am of the mind, you guys have done such a tremendous amount of work. Like, for every kind of nitpick, you've spent hours on that very question. You know, so I'm not, I'm not interested in really...

2:57:37 Combing over your evaluations. I'm more interested in kind of after the fact, doing the right thing, getting the right feedback, listening to every producer, going back to the process, and just continuing to make it better and better. But your point's perfectly well taken. I agree that the stronger the scoring can be, you know, the more it's fair.

2:58:01 Yeah. The outcome. That's all I'm trying. I'm trying to make it so it matches up at the end of the day. Yeah. But when I see one gets scored as high and no money and one scored low gets money, I'm just trying to get in my head. And I agree with Tom, I do not want to go back into micro management. And we absolutely understand that. And when we were looking at A, you know, it was one of those things. Do you start digging to the point that somebody can't

2:58:26 Put on a quality program. And I think at some point in time I think they'll say no. It doesn't work. And not just reducing dollars to somebody may not be the right course down the road. I'm not making any recommendations today. Which is why we kept A the way it was and zeroed out some of the others. I just think that that's something that we're going to have to refine as we go. Absolutely. And figure out, okay, when does it make sense? When is...

2:58:49 Those type of things. And again, I'm not trying to dig into a subset. I'm just trying to get my head around it so I can make sure we do have a motion here that it makes sense to me. We've got to make it a goal instead of double that money. Yeah, right. And then we don't have... No, you only have $500,000. And that'll be a great problem. And we've got to get to that point where we have that level of programming coming in the door. Tom, just a separate question, and I know Mr. Mayor won't answer the question. You're right.

2:59:19 Do you think that there, from a town council's perspective, changing that allocation percentage creates an issue? Okay. And one thing I'd just like to tell the board about as well, you know, when we went through and we kind of gave out some numbers, like where do we think, you know, we can, this program can go based on past funding, based on what they're adding to their program.

2:59:49 Came up with very similar numbers and, you know, sometimes we were a few thousand dollars apart and then we, you know, we hashed it out, you know, definitely like, okay, well, what about this part, you know, and we'd bring up different points. And another thing, when you're looking at this 2016 funding, please don't forget that for many of the applicants that wasn't a whole year of funding. So for like Eastern Sierra Symphony, it was like the way that they had had their year.

3:00:17 You know, they weren't on the same fiscal year because they had been doing calendar funding, so we were only funding one of their programs versus this year we're funding three programs because they've added, you know, so it's, we're not comparing apples to apples here. But, you know, again, looking at the budgets and what they have been able to accomplish with the money we've given in the past and going towards what kind of new asks there were. Input, information, even how to go through.

3:00:46 to come up with this. You understand what the objective is here. So I'm very comfortable with what you guys are recommending. I would like to make a motion that we recommend option B. I will second. I will second. Comment, Mr. Chair? Yes. Accommodations to Terry, Dre, and Rachel for the work they've done on this. Committee's done a great job. We did two cycles this year. We're now in front of it. We're now aligned with the fiscal year, so we're not going to come back until next spring.

3:01:17 So, ladies, great job. So, we have a motion. We have a second further discussion. No, I'll make my points. I'm good to go. Any further public? Okay. All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Opposed? Motion passes unanimously. Amen. All right. Good job, guys. Thank you. Thank you. All right. As I said, I want to absolutely burn through the rest of this agenda.

3:01:49 Yeah, so I'm looking to remove this from the agenda for the following reason. The executive committee got together and reviewed a contract draft that is currently on the table. This draft has seen revisions from

3:02:18 Council member Fernie and Souser. We were under the impression that that was kind of the last really edit from those two council members until we did an edit of our own and brought it to town council. It looks like they want to see a few more edits. So this draft that's in the packet isn't quite ready, I don't think, for, I don't see any point in us approving it at this point.

3:02:47 So I'd like to just take the discussion off the agenda and move forward and table it. Do I have to do anything? But I do think it would be helpful, now that you've seen it, if you have comments or recommendations that you send them to the executive committee via our executive director. And that's okay with everything. All right. Moving on then. Quick debrief of the March 24th special board meeting focused on the MAC.

3:03:17 I was there, Drea was there, David was there, Rich was there, Terry, you were there as well. I would, the design phase is the kind of, what did they call it exactly? It's not a rough design phase, it's kind of a conceptual phase, is complete. There were some questions about building orientation from a couple of board members and so forth, but it's moving along a good clip, it's starting to look like.

3:03:47 A fantastic amenity in our town. Okay, so that was the basis of the workshop, was to really walk us through that conceptual design phase. My big takeaway really was, and I think I agree with this, the energy, the money is being spent.

3:04:12 Inside, on the theater experience itself, it looks to me. The outside, and the architect even said as much, was like, look, my task is not to spend a lot of money on the kind of finery of the exterior here. We're putting money in what the right, you know, kind of...

3:04:33 amenities and facilities within, the right, all the contraptions you need to move a stage around, the acoustics, making sure that the acoustics work for a symphony orchestra as well as a single speaker, which is very different. And so there's a kind of mobility in terms of the way they can move in and out acoustical elements to, and I was really impressed by the expertise behind the consulting. That was the big takeaway for me.

3:05:02 It looks like we're going to get the next phase then is to really drill down in the budget. $12 million is the number on the table. It's still a soft number. It looks like we're going to have a business plan that matches to that number or amends that number at some point in the next couple months. And I think that was by and large kind of the takeaway. It is not to my...

3:05:30 It's not a facility that's just this marvelous sculpture that is in the architecture its own art piece. It is a functional performing arts theater for 300 people to enjoy a multiplicity of different kinds of programs. And then I'd look for the other participants to add any comments beyond that.

3:05:59 No, I think you guys did. I think you did, yeah. Just one quick thing. Yes. When I was at outside, and I'm forgetting the name of it right now. Mollengar. Outside Mollengar. It was so great because there were so many people standing around in the theater during intermission and whatnot, and I'd just be like, hey, have you seen the designs for the new Mac? So it's, you know, rather than seeing it online, which I think that option exists, but I would just encourage the public to walk over into Edison Theater and go into their library and take a look at it.

3:06:28 And they were going to put it online. That's what they said. That's what they said. But I don't know. For me, I like to see it really big. And my screen is not that big. Evan and I are meeting again tomorrow. We're looking at scheduling over the next month wine walk, so to speak. Inviting the public in, different groups, look at it, begin to build ambassadorial ships so people get a better flavor for it, trying to get it out more in the community. A dog and pony show, so to speak. We should definitely have our fundraising button up on an iPad.

3:06:58 Is that right? Absolutely. So people can just go ahead. There you go. I think in big picture aspects, that's what MLR should do, period, for some fundraising aspects, is inviting the community, come see what we're doing, and by the way, if you'd like to write a check, you know, and I think that's what it's about, big picture. That will be part of the communication. You're exactly right. But I think your point's well made that this is one of our two, you know, we just went through this bonding scenario thing, and those are the two big elephants in our portfolio.

3:07:28 It's time for the community to start focusing on this project because there's something to look at. And these are people who are interested in the arts. I mean, they're there to see a play. It was sold out the first night. And yet a lot of them didn't really know that the MAC was this far along. So I thought that was important.

3:07:47 Look, they're like, ooh, dollar sign, dollar sign, you know, just. In that opening night with the music going on, I could just see us all in a new facility, right? Instead of kind of crammed together. Yeah. I gotta go buy a tux again? Jeez. But a couple things just overall, and I don't worry about my phone, but actually I heard most of it fairly clearly, but two things that came up as additional questions, because I've talked to Evan since then, but.

3:08:13 There's going to be some work like additional supplemental CEQA may have to be filed, but I didn't really get a sense in terms of where they need to go back to the town in terms of what's approved, not approved, and what they might have to get approval for. Is it one thing that I didn't really get to ask that question? I didn't want to think of it at the time.

3:08:29 But that may impact timing because they have to come to the Planning Commission. What's already covered by existing permits for that whole property, 90% of it may be already ready to go. I don't know. That's kind of where I came up with saying, okay, does that affect timing at all? Or maybe it's irrelevant and it's already enough down the road. But I do know if they do have to do something like a secret, it comes six or eight months down the road.

3:08:49 This stuff can happen while that's taking place. The timeline, Evan gave a timeline to the CEQA. He did speak to that about what the CEQA and something as far as the town went. I can't remember what it was that the town's component was, but he didn't seem to think that it was going to be something that would take us a long time and really put it on. I'm not sure if that's one for me going forward is to get mental. Okay. And the bigger question was whether it needs to go through DSA with the college district or not.

3:09:16 That was it. That was it right there. Yeah, exactly. Where does that take your time? I don't know. Well, that's what they're working. They're working on that process right now. Putting a package together. We'll see it tomorrow. Send it off to the College District requesting increased funding for Measure C at this point. Time to close this. So, so.

3:09:34 I'd like, I'm okay with a little more conversation. I'd like to move forward, but asking what's our next step in terms of information back to the board? Are we waiting for the business plan? Is that kind of the next piece for us to? The business and governance plan, it sounds to me. And then that would be, I think, the time where we, those questions. Timelines, cost estimates, funding.

3:10:01 And I just have a generic question, and I know this tale is probably going to be able to answer it again, but on Measure C, did they actually raise the money, or did they have to sell bonds to get that money? They said all the bonds had not been sold. Correct. So they haven't raised all of it yet. So they don't have the money yet. They can still sell the bonds. That's what was said. That's right. Got it. You know, maybe something that can be said. You know, like, I'd love that thermometer.

3:10:24 Up with those pictures, you could put a thermometer and then where the connection is that they could donate money right underneath that. And you know what, it's what we've been saying all along. Once you have something to show. It's a collateral now. It's time to start moving on. It's a visual. I was going to say, you know, the MAC has a very large benefactor. Okay. Roger McFarland. And I think it would be smart. He was there. Yeah. If you haven't met him.

3:10:53 Go meet him and say, hey, really appreciate what you're doing. I'm doing MLR. We're supportive of this. Get his juices going. He can find people, too. And he was at the board workshop, as well. That's right. He wants to be very involved. He spoke in public comments, too. I think he's pretty pleased with the changes. Okay. Any public comment? Everybody good? Okay. Next on the agenda,

3:11:23 Financial reports, they're all in front of you here. They're self-explanatory. We go over the room each month. Does anybody have any specific questions about our financial reports? We're going to be $20,000 short of budget at the end of the year. Cut it. Okay. We should have about $25,000 give it to take a little bit, which doesn't exceed the 15 percent. Carry over 15 percent at $200,000. So we're in good shape. Okay.

3:11:51 So let's, if no one objects, I'd like to move past financial reports. The last item, Town Council liaison request for information. Town Council. You're going to be there. Yeah, I'm going to step up tomorrow night and make public comment about our conversation about bonding. Just kind of begin to share that with the council. This is what we talked about last night.

3:12:14 Talk about that, and I'll talk about the allocation, just two information items real quick, but specifically the bonding, since I started one-on-one conversation with council members about that. And the recommendation, the trails recommendation doesn't hit town council? We're looking at a holistic approach. Okay. Yeah, I don't want to do one of our stuff. I want a holistic approach to where we're going. Okay, I wouldn't say a word.

3:12:36 So in the measure, the allocation... You'll find something to say. ...don't come to you tomorrow either. So no, not... Yeah. I'll just, how would you like me to phrase it? Maybe that MLR is looking, that we went through and looked at the total kind of both funds, and then MLR is starting the conversations about that.

3:13:05 Potentially leveraging those funds against the priority phase. I think we use that language. We keep using the priority phase. Yeah, priority phase. And I think a little bit on the search update, too, would be healthy for the rest of the council. That our search is long or whatever. We're in phase two already of the search. Yeah, and that we're looking to pull a candidate in the next two weeks. Okay. With that, I'll ask for any future agenda items. Future agenda items.

3:13:37 We're making some decisions in May, guys. We're going to pull some triggers. I would also, if anybody wants, I really, the walk-bike ride is a big project in the town. And we, even though mobility has kind of been taking a backseat, I think it's something we need to keep our eyes on and be a part of. So if anybody here wants to dig in. Don't you think it was even more noticeable this winter, though, that we need more ability to get from Denver? You're dangerous.

3:14:05 Walk this winter. I mean, this winter showed you how bad it was. So let's all try to be involved with that project, but if anybody wants to step up and say, I'm raising my hand to kind of be a liaison, and I will be responsible to go to most of these things, let Rich or I know. And we'll kind of have an informal liaison. So I've been quite involved overall, but I just don't want to overlap with what I'm also trying to do public loan stuff. Okay.

3:14:34 To help in that way. And maybe hearing their update during a board member report. And if you haven't been involved, but I'm going to go through this and let me see if I can come up with it. I want to go through this to see what they're talking about. Yeah, I think it's great. Okay. Cool. Okay. With that, folks, thanks for your time. We'll get back to our quick schedules. Next board meeting, this meeting is adjourned. That was pretty good. Yeah. I was looking for hours.