TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 30 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

65 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Join Commissioner Danken in the Pledge. Please join us in the Pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay, Karen, roll call please. Mr. Clark? Here. Commissioner Foucault? Here. Commissioner Foucault? Here. Commissioner Foucault has an excused absence. Vice Chair Foucault? Here.

0:35 Here. All right, we will move into reports from the commission. Sharon? I attended the community water district meeting on September 16th and had a question. I just talked to Sandra about this. Is anybody going to the Title 24 standards having to do with build the new building? She said probably it was entirely too specific that we...

1:03 Didn't need to go, but I was considering going. Didn't know if anybody else was interested or not, so. I think that's under the new green building. Is that with the governor's green building code and Title 24 standards? Yes. We have a number of our building division staff attending, and it should be very technical, but feel free to attend. That's what Sandra said. It sounds like it may well be over my head, but I just, anyway. I think you should feel free to go. I feel free to go.

1:32 Eight to four, it's kind of a lot, well, okay, just putting it on the table. I'd suggest, too, if you go online to the Title 24 of the Governor's website for the Green Building Code, it's a 64-page document, and go through that, it's going to give you a lot that you'll be going through on this site. That will be, yeah, and that'll kind of give you an idea of what they'll be going through. Thank you. Do you have anything to report from the Water District Board meeting, or?

1:57 Well, I'm assuming that it's in our agenda. They did appropriate the $15,000 to participate in that spearheading future to the next 20 years. Mark will be reporting on that, I'm sure. Very interesting. Thank you. I have a few questions, Mark. I said to take care of now, maybe you can answer back in Director's Report. You know, winter is coming to us and

2:29 Look out at Snow Creek as you drive out, you know, Old Mammoth Road, they've got that very large pile of dirt that they've excavated. Is that going to remain? Are they doing something with that? Out by Solstice, you know, IntraWest, they did that great excavation of a big pit. They stopped construction. What happens with that? I know, and these are questions I've had from some folks in town, specifically people that are riding bikes on the trails and that too.

2:57 They also brought up Talos, but I do know that Talos, the bank, is working on getting the Talos site cleaned up, so I know that's under control, but for those other sites, I'm curious to see if you can give us any information on it. And they had another request about some information on the bike trail coming down off the mountain and the speed of the bikes. I know there's posted speeds and it's becoming a big issue off of Lake Mary Davidson, that whole area in there. So if there's something we could do.

3:28 Find out about that, if there's going to be more enforcement, or I guess there's been some near collisions with cars and bikes. You mean on the Lake Murray? Yeah, right. Well, they're considering possibly putting the bikes on the road, coming down at least, because it's very difficult to go 15 miles an hour on a bike coming downhill. Most of them do have brakes.

3:55 But are they being used? That's a question. And enforcement. So just some questions from the community. All right. We will move on to our consent agenda. I'd like to pull item number two. Does anyone else wish to pull minutes? Oh, I'm sorry. Again, comments from the public. John. Thank you. Good afternoon. I'm here to...

4:26 invite and advise the Planning Commission on the Lakes Basin Special Study effort and the three important public meetings coming up in the next couple weeks. The Lakes Basin Special Study is an effort being funded by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy with a very significant grant and it's an opportunity for the community and interested parties to engage in establishing baseline data for

4:52 What will hopefully be a significant management planning effort in the lakes basin. We all know what a valuable resource that is. We also, all of us who live here know how the stress that that place is under. And so I'd encourage you to either come in person or you can participate via webinar in the privacy of your own home with your own computer. These are coming up on September 30th, October 14th, and October 28th.

5:17 And I'll, if it's okay with you, Chair Barrett, I'll just approach and hand out some cards. Sure, that's fine. I hope to see you guys there. Any questions on the, on the Lakes Station Special Study or? Great. Hope to see you all there. Thank you. Thank you. All right, the podium is open. Anyone else wishing for public comment? Seeing none, we will now move on to the consent agenda. Thanks, John. And I'd like to pull item number two. It says an appointment. Anyone wishing to pull the minutes or do we have a motion? I move approval of the minutes of, uh,

5:52 July 28th. I'll second. Motion I second. All in favor? Aye. Item number two, this is the appointment of a Planning Commission representative to our Development Forecast Steering Committee. Mark, do you want to give a little update on that? Sure. Okay. Thank you, Chair, members of the Commission. The Community Facilities Funding Committee last year went through an extensive effort to

6:20 Review and audit and then recommend revised development impact fees and housing mitigation requirements. And one of their recommendations was that we come up with a far more accurate development forecast, especially as it relates to housing. And the purpose of a development forecast is to, and this one in particular, is to be much more market-based and have factual data that

6:48 looks at long-term vacancy rates, absorption rates, and the different components of land use. So lodging, residential, retail, office space, those core factors, because that is the fundamental information that leads to us being able to have reasonable projections of demand for workforce housing. It also indicates to us what our

7:16 More probable total population will be over time. And it also informs us as to our fiscal revenues, how much money in the form of taxes and development impact fees can we reasonably expect and count on and then plan for. And as you know, some of our studies are a little bit dated in our review of the

7:42 I think it's a 1991 Parks and Recreation element in the general plan. That development forecast estimated a full-time resident population of 10,000 people by the year 2010. And if we're off on these numbers, we're either over or underestimating the people, the total folks here that are demanding services, and our ability to fund those services.

8:12 This is also the key information that will provide input to the water district's five-year urban water management plan update. And we think it's very, very important to work closely and in partnership with the water district so that we all are on the same page about what the long-term forecast is and then are more able to plan.

8:36 Water demand and supply as well as the location of the infrastructure that actually serves new development. We presented this to the Water District and they did approve financial participation and we think we're committed at the staff level of working with the Water District. They are indeed our service providers and it's an important item for us. This actual contract will be presented to the Town Council.

9:06 This evening with EPS, Economic Planning Systems, doing the work that they started through the CFFC work. So that's the synopsis of the issue and why it's perhaps important to have a steering committee as we progress and have periodic reports from our consultant. I think we'd like to, at the right time, have Planning Commission, Water District, and Mammoth Lakes Housing.

9:34 Review and consideration of the reports before we complete it and totally bake that cake and present it to you and decision makers for its use. Any questions? This is a chair appointment and I've kind of gone through thinking about who to appoint here and what I would like to do is appoint Commissioner Clark to the steering committee. Is there any discussion on that? No.

10:04 If you need a motion for this, should we do it by consensus? Just an appointment, so we're... The chair can do it, or you can do it by consensus. Consensus. Consensus. Okay. A lot of work for you. Well, thank you for doing that, Commissioner Clark. All right, we'll move on. Our next item is a public hearing. It happens. I know it does. It's right here in front. So we have a public hearing on zoning code amendment 10-003.

10:53 The town proposes text amendments to portions of Title 17 of the town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code, allowing for time extensions of up to six years for use permits, design reviews and variances. There would be zoning text changes, which would apply retroactively for six months from the effective date of the ordinance, approving ZCA 10-03. I'll open the public hearing, and Jen, you can let you finish off on that for us. Thank you, Chair Barrett.

11:21 This zone code amendment was initiated by the town. This is to address specific permits that have a shorter lifespan and request for extensions than those tied to tentative maps. So this zone code amendment would apply to use permits, design reviews and variances that are not applied for concurrently with a tentative map.

11:44 And it would allow for an applicant to request a longer time extension than is currently allowed. Currently, these permits are valid for two years after the approval date, and then they are allowed to request a one-year time extension. The amendment that we are proposing is to allow for up to a six-year time extension request. That would be consistent with the Subdivision Map Act and the current extension provisions for maps as well.

12:14 And this would also help to streamline staff's review of time extensions, cost savings there, as well as to provide equitable extensions for the variety of permit scopes and scales that we get under use permits, design reviews, and variances. There are two specific permits that this retroactive period would apply to. That would be the police station permit, which you granted a year extension for last December.

12:44 And an apartment project on Manzanita that was approved unanimously in 2007. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer those. I also did get a few questions from Commissioner Duncan, and I can go over those as well if you wish. So one of the questions was why are we applying the retroactive period if we could do an emergency ordinance to

13:17 Have those provisions go into effect immediately. And the reason that we can't do that is the emergency ordinances are for specific conditions and findings, and they're only valid for a certain amount of time. So for a permanent change, we have to go through this process. The other question was that for the two permits I mentioned specifically, they've already received a one-year time extension. So under this provision, they would be

13:47 Allowed to request up to five years for the maximum of six. The other question was about tracking extensions or tracking expiration dates and how the town tracks that or if the applicant tracks that. And technically it's the applicant's responsibility to do that. The town tracks as well through our permitting system, which is our muni system. And so in that we can identify based on the parcel

14:18 When a permit would expire and so we would get an automatic reminder generated to let us know that an expiration date is coming up. So we do our best to contact the applicants too and keep their entitlements valid as well. Thank you, Jen. Sure. Any other questions of staff on the side of sharing? Okay, this is a public hearing so at this time we'll entertain anyone wishing to speak in favor of the amendments.

14:49 All right. Anyone wishing to oppose? General testimony? All right. We will close the public hearing and open it up for discussion. Sharon? I think this saves everybody time, so I'm very much in support. Okay. Yeah. The only question I had that was really substantial was the third one that Jen mentioned. I was concerned that

15:17 Not that, excuse me, that the town be responsible for catching slip-ups, but that if that happened at all frequently, if they could track it and give the applicants one more chance to catch something they might have missed, and that's what they indeed do, so that was my only concern. And I think just in support of this too, with these projects.

15:44 are still the right projects at that time, but it's not right for us to go with them at this time, so I think that the extensions and the retroactivity of it, his question, brought it to light, this takes care of the issue. Great. All right, yeah, and I'm very supportive of this. It's something we've already taken care of, so I'm happy that we're getting here, so I'll entertain a motion. I'll move that.

16:10 We choose option one and adopt the attached resolution recommending to the town council adoption of zone code amendment 10-003, amending title 17 of the town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code and including the findings as listed in the resolution. A second. Okay, we have a motion, a second. Any further discussion? Can we have a roll call, please, Jeremy? Mr. Clark? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. Barrett? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye. Mr. McEvoy? Aye.

16:42 Okay, motion passes 4-0. Thank you. We will now move on to our business matters. And Mark? This next item is Planning Commission discussion to prepare for your next joint study session with the Town Council. As you know, through email, the schedule date has changed. Mayor Harvey has asked that we hold that meeting when he is returned, which will be...

17:11 In early to mid-November. So we still think it would be useful for you at this time to have this discussion, and we can revisit it later at one of your other meetings. The carryover from the last study session with the Town Council was a specific request to have more discussion about the building height and mass evaluation. You, the Commission, discussed that matter in, I believe it was April, thinking that we would discuss it at that time.

17:40 This is also an opportunity for you to identify other subjects that you would like to discuss with the council at that joint session. So with that, this is your open discussion. And we have an hour for that workshop? Yes. All right, so we have an hour, and we'll be building hyper mass, so anything else that anyone wishes to discuss? I have asked Mark, I'll just add in that we have a new events kind of committee that have been meeting, event planners. I'm also on that.

18:10 Committee, along with Matthew Lehman from the Council, and we'd like to see a little discussion of the Commission and the Council for that, so if the Commission is fine with that, by that time we have a meeting come up next week and we'll have some more meetings and we can actually, you know, put out some information for discussions, so if we could have that item added, I'd appreciate. Anything else that someone wishes to discuss with the Council?

18:34 I think that in light of the staff changes and how we're re-addressing our scope of work and the committees and the workload, I think that we need a recap of what that looks like now because we've had a couple of, you know, a few weeks, by that time we will have had, what, about six weeks to see how the impact is, if it's changing any focus on things, have we discovered that

19:02 There are new priorities, or is it raising issues that affect other things, and I think that that may be, there may be taking, you know, a lot of that time is here's what, here's how we've adjusted, and here's what we've learned, and here's how we're addressing these things, and because if we need redirection, that would be the time we would get it. Very good points. I'd be very educated with that. Commissioner Park? Absolutely.

19:31 I do want to make one point with respect to the building height and mass issue. About a week ago I saw an article, read an article entitled 3D Printing Spurs of Manufacturing Revolution. And for those of you that are not familiar with this technology, 3D printing creates an object, a physical object, by stacking on layers.

19:57 The layers can be plastic or metal, something like that, but it builds up the whole structure going from a computer-aided design file. And one of the things they mentioned in this article was that there's an outfit in Colorado that uses one of these three-dimensional printing machines to create models of buildings and resorts for architectural firms. And they point out that, and I thought right away of the Old Mammoth Place model.

20:24 I don't know what that cost them, but it says here that making those models typically took two months to build a $100,000 model. And with one of these machines, they are now building $2,000 models, taking the architect's design directly and using a 3D printer. So the relevance to the building height and mass policy is that in the statement of the policy under methods, under the last paragraph, it says,

20:54 Methods include digital imaging simulations, three-dimensional computer modeling, other on-site and visual techniques, and physical models. And I wonder if we want to say something about that not, I mean, as I read it, literally that's not all inclusive, but would it be a good idea to emphasize that we should be, feel free to adapt new technology as it comes along, and even should.

21:19 Aggressively look for new technology if it's a better way of modeling to help us make these decisions. I agree. I think that's something we should always be doing. Well, isn't that kind of one of the points of dispute? Because we've brought new technology and that's being disputed. And I think that to have some examples of this, more examples of this is evolving that really can serve the purpose. And even serve it better. Serve it better is we need to be able to bring that forward then. Yeah.

21:51 Since Commissioner Tenney was not going to be here for the originally scheduled meeting, is it okay if we leave it open for her to, if she has anything that she'd like to add on that she can with staff? Would you all be fine with that? Sure. Discuss it with the Chair. Yeah. As far as content, you don't want to focus on? Yeah, if there's anything. Because she had relayed to me that she really didn't have anything to add for the October 6th meeting because she wouldn't be there. But now that it's been moved, I'd kind of like to leave, at least give her that opportunity.

22:20 Oh, the meeting itself has been moved. Yes, it will be after November 15th. I thought just the height and mass had been moved. No, no. The whole thing was moved. The study session. The whole study session's moved until after November 15th when Mayor Harvey is back in town. And we have sent you an email asking for your availability. Yeah, so if you have any dates that will be gone that aren't good for you, it's good to get them to staff after November 15th so we can have full commission.

22:50 And I think by our next meeting, we would be able to recap. This is what we talked about as well. So we'll put this as an agenda item. October 13th. Yeah. That's great. All right. We will move on to briefing matters. Director's report. Yes. I can answer some of your questions. Some I'll refer to Ray Jarvis, and he can respond to you in electronic form.

23:21 First, TALIS site cleanup. We've had a series of meetings with the representatives of the banks that own the site, and they are considering and evaluating how they can move forward to complete the first phase of the project. We also have sent our billing inspectors and public works inspectors to the site to help identify those things to clean up the whole site.

23:46 that will make, you know, more compatible with the existing neighborhoods. So we're working on that project and we're focused because the snow will soon start flying. Jen, I'll ask Jen to refer to your question about the status of the stockpile of dirt on Snow Creek 8. The stockpile of dirt on Snow Creek 7 is the concern?

24:10 That dirt pile is required to be removed by the end of August 2011. That date was extended from the original approval based on findings that the Public Works Director was required to make. And we are currently working on a grading permit for Snow Creek 8 that would allow that dirt to be moved to that site. Good. Thank you. Lake Mary Bike Trail, we're aware of speed and collision issues, so I'll forward that to Ray and let him.

24:39 Deal with that specifically. And then with the solstice issue, the excavated pit, that was an early start of construction that occurred some time ago. And since then, we have modified our policies as to what you can do with and without bonding. I don't know what our time frame is off the top of my head, and so I'll have to get back to you with that because

25:05 It's relatively complicated in terms of an enforcement issue. So I'll report back to you. So that wasn't part of the InterWest deal with the exchange of funds that happened through the bond, right? I don't know. I'll have to look at it because we have a transfer of properties, a transfer of rights associated with the development agreement, and then we have other enforcement issues and bond-related issues. That, too, probably will come from Ray. Good. Thank you. Thank you.

25:35 One other thing that I'd like to mention for, this is the only thing I have for your director's report, is we've been working with the property manager for Sierra Nevada Railway Lodge. This isn't a conflict issue, this is just information. And we plan to consider the application for the escape facility as an administrative permit.

26:01 It looks like it's relatively straightforward. It is a permitted use. It's a seasonal facility. And there's adequate on-site parking to satisfy the zoning code, even with the loss of, or the temporary loss of parking, which will be occupied by that state facility.

26:22 Yes. It's not really an ice skating rink because there's no ice. It's a skate rink. I can't wait to see this. The synthetic rink for skating. It's what they use like in Sacramento down on K Street Mall or San Francisco. Well, and they also use these in big arenas like the Stable Center and places where ice capades and ice shows go into areas that they're not.

26:48 Flooding for those particular venues, so I too will be equally interested in seeing how this works, you know, so I obviously won't be as cold when you fall. Well, the great Sacramento, I mean, during the winter months, the Chamber of Commerce puts it up, you know, there's lines of people around them daily, and it's right down on K Street Mall in San Francisco with Union Square, so I think it's a great idea, it's going to be great for animation for Old Man with the Road, so. Let's see.

27:16 So we're hearing from you it's not going to be an issue, it'll just be administrative. Yes. Perfect. If you have any questions about our current status of processing the medical marijuana cooperative use permits, if you have some questions under Director's Report, Sandra can update you. Not at this time. I think you sent that email to us. What did it say again? When?

27:42 It's October 27th is the meeting date. Will that be a 9 a.m.? Yes, it will. And we have three applicants. So for the public's knowledge, the medical marijuana cooperative use permit meeting where we will issue the two use permits for the two businesses will be on October 27th at 9 a.m. We have three applicants with use permits. We did have five. One withdrew.

28:10 And as our process through the ordinance is defined, the police chief or department went through a review process of the applicants through life scan and background checks and three applicants were found to be qualified, one was found not to be qualified. So the three applicants that were qualified have gone forward to the use permit phase. And that's where we will be at number 27. Anything else?

28:41 All right. Excuse me, Chair Barrett, I have a question. Why were we given political invitations attached to our packets? I can answer that for you. As I responded to your email, there were invitations to meet candidates that were distributed from private people throughout a number of venues in town. And it's not political information, and it's...

29:12 Not part of your package. So had you an inbox, you do not have an inbox. You only have the ledge out there where we place stuff. So that information was just passed along as public information that anybody can tend. So there's no political connotation to the form or the way in which we distributed that.

29:32 That's why the paper's green. Right. It's a different color paper. That's what it used to be before is what it looked like it was separate from the packet. But I have great concerns about party politics being in any way tated. So if staff would please see to it that I do not get any more of this kind of information. I'll share that with the administrative office. Thank you. You're welcome.

29:59 Well, perhaps, because you get multiple, like, mail and that too, so perhaps they could put it separate for you on the... I've never in my year and several months on the plan commission gotten anything that was not part of our packet, so... Oh, see, I have numerous times. You get calendars and... Yeah, it comes through... Yeah, from the governor's office you'll get letters and... Not yet. This is the first. Well, perhaps for Karen, if she could just separate it for you... That's fine. That's fine. Just...

30:28 Not with my planned commission information. Thank you. You're welcome. All right, this is now time for our second phase of comments from the public. Anyone wishing to address the commission? Seeing none, we will, any announcement of future meetings? No, the adjournment is correctly stated. Okay, we will adjourn to our October 13th meeting at 2 p.m. Is this kind of record? 30 minutes? I was thinking this. It is, that's got to be some kind of record.