TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2017

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 47 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

633 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:44 I have this gavel. You don't have to. I'm going to call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for May 3rd. We have a very special presentation this afternoon that is going to require a slight format change for the presentation. Mayor Richardson has recused from this effort.

3:10 What I'd like to do is have everybody go to the seats that are set up and we can enjoy and experience the presentation. Once the presentation is complete, I'll leave it to the presenters. I'd like to have the council come back up here and the public comment can happen at the microphone there so our friends at home and things being recorded can make sure they can see everything. So thank you very much. And with that, I will turn it over to Mr. Pledge. Should we do the pledge first? Okay. Let's do the Pledge of Allegiance. It's a good day to do a Pledge of Allegiance.

3:39 I'm going to ask the young woman in the red shirt in the back if you could lead us in the pledge, please. Yes, ma'am. You know it. Put your right hand over it. Okay. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

4:09 Thank you very much. And now, Mr. Bacha. Mr. Mayor Pro Tem, Mr. Wentworth, thank you very much. Ladies and gentlemen, greetings and welcome. We are gathered here today to review one of our priority phase projects, which is the Mammoth Arts and Culture project that's been in the pipeline now for some time. I want to introduce Evan Russell, who's been carrying the torch on this for a number of years. We're excited about his work. And Evan has... Where is Evan? He's hiding over there.

4:39 Runner, quit talking to him. I want to publicly acknowledge Evan for all the work he's done on this project. The Town Council gave us direction in December of 2015 to roll this out and bring a recommendation forward. MLR Board had a great conversation last night about funding. We'll bring that to the Council on May 17th. But, Evan, you should be commended for all the work you've done as carrying the torch and moving this into the future. So a nice round of applause is most well-deserved. Thank you, Evan. Thank you, Rich.

5:11 Yeah, for some of you that are here, you know that we've been working on this pretty diligently since 2010 when we hired Bill Taylor to convene a group of about 25 local people to put a kind of vision together for the project, and that's what we've been working on, but it's been tweeted many, tweaked many, many times.

5:39 You know, we started seriously about two and a half years ago. The town helped us fund some of the initial planning through Measure U. And we had a good plan that a lot of people looked at that we used for about a year. And then something kind of significant, at least in my world, happened is my wife and I went to the Shakespeare Festival in Ashland, Oregon.

6:09 And we took the backstage tour there, and I guess what I realized is how much we didn't know about what we were doing. We figured out that we were in the process of designing a really nice auditorium and not necessarily a theater. So we called the Shakespeare Festival people, or Bill did.

6:39 Bill Taylor, and asked if they had anybody on their staff that would like to work with us that we could hire as a consultant, and they said they didn't do that, but they had a consulting group that they used, and they recommended a lady. Her name is Rose Steele, who I'm going to bring up here in just a second, and Rose has worked on a couple hundred theater projects, some

7:05 Really big ones, some really good ones. And Rose, in just a couple of months, has been able to take our project from a $7 million project to a $12 million project. But what we've, I think what we've come up with and what Bruce will present to you later is it's a state-of-the-art facility. You can't do much, much better than go out and build something.

7:34 But this is something that will last the community for a really, really long time. And the other part of this is, you know, I've been in town almost 50 years now, and I've seen a lot of stuff come forward. If this project goes forward, it's truly a public-private partnership with college bond measure C money, town measure U money.

8:03 Private donors. We've got two private donors that have committed in excess of $2.5 million to the project and the foundation's land that it'll go on. And I really don't know any other projects that have happened in the community where we've had that kind of collaboration on things. So let's hear about the project. And, Rose, you want to come up and talk a little?

8:28 Thank you. I'm very honored to be involved in this project. I'm just going to give myself a little introduction, and then I'm going to turn over the mic to Bruce, and I will assist him in describing the project. As Evan said, I have been a theater consultant for 30 years and have worked on several hundred constructed projects and several hundred studies for some that were either constructed later under other...

8:52 And I'm going to let Bruce go through it architecturally and I'll give him any help he needs technically.

9:21 For those who don't know me, I'm Bruce Woodward. I'm an architect here in town. I've been here for 25 years. I've been an architect for 31 years. And I'm learning a lot about theater projects with this project. But I have a lot of experience in this area, in this environment, in this town.

9:49 The theater itself, the basic idea with this is to build a theater project that the theater space inside is state-of-the-art. So when you're in this theater, you're in as good a space as you can be. The rest of the building is then support for that in a number of different ways. The structure of the building, the way the building is finished.

10:16 On the outside, for instance, it's very low maintenance because we don't want to be spending the budget that the building will have on upkeep down the road. So it's almost a 300-seat theater. It's 298 seats. 292 of those seats are fixed seats. And there's six wheelchair access locations.

10:45 It has an oversized lobby which can also be used for other functions. It's also large enough to have a reception for, you can have something going on in the theater and everybody can be out in the lobby, inside the lobby before the concert or play or whatever it is, having a glass of wine, just a social event there. It has a catering kitchen in the building so that it will be able to serve food.

11:14 It's not a full kitchen, so that there's not that expense, and will help support local caterers in this process. It has an outdoor patio area, so in the summer, in the fall, early spring, this time of year, actually down the site's now clear of snow, which is really nice. It's one of the few places in town that's like that. So on the west side of the building, there's an outdoor patio area.

11:44 Glass screen, windscreen walls to protect because it is always a little breezy down there. Anyway, the overall thing is this project and what we're really talking about is the Performing Arts Theater. It's part of the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center which as it develops existing is the Edison Theater which I'm sure many of you have been to. That will stay.

12:12 And continue to operate as the 100-seat theater that it is. So that brings there would be then two theaters. There will ultimately be an outdoor amphitheater for up to 500 locations to put your lawn chair or seat. Not that we were going to build seats, but that's what it would be. So this whole area down here is going to be that Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. She'll talk about the guts. All right.

12:42 We met with a lot of the local arts groups, and for a community situation, you really need a facility that will do a wide variety of events well, from film, for instance, the film festival, which is about to start in two weeks, to spoken word drama, to musicals, to classical music. And so acoustics and the variety of acoustics is one of the key elements. And so to accommodate the needs, the acoustic needs from film to unamplified classical music,

13:11 A room with a great deal of volume, which will provide the reverberation for the music, and then we're going to have a series of curtains and drapes and panels that will close off some of that volume, absorb some of that sound, and provide for speech intelligibility for events that don't have music needs. We have a series of technical catwalks and box booms for lighting and other technical needs over the auditorium.

13:36 In the house itself, we have, as he said, just about 300 seats. There's a cross aisle which provides for excellent circulation as well as excellent wheelchair accessible seating. And should there happen to be a very small event, it would be an easy matter to darken the house lights in the back and push the audience all to the front so that even small events will have a very intimate, full feeling.

13:56 There's a very large stage suitable for orchestras of 50 to 60 pieces as well as dramatic events with a lot of scenery. Because there's a full complement of rigging and drapes, we can close curtains and drapes in order to have small events in front of a curtain on the fourth stage, which is this area here, even when there's an event planned later on in the evening or the week.

14:20 With their equipment on stage. There's also large wings for the movement of scenery as well as for dancers running off stage. Backstage we have performer support spaces. There is a storage building that is part of a future project that will allow for scenery construction. And upstairs in a drawing that we didn't put up, there's a costume attic for storage that could also be used for some small construction.

14:44 Oversized women's room, generous men's room, and a concession space that will serve events that don't necessarily need the catering kitchen. I think that covers most of the technical stuff. Did I leave anything out? Okay. The oversized restrooms, the women's is two and a half times what code requires. And it's really set up that one of the interesting things is one of the...

15:11 One of the patrons of this and one of the donors was very interested in this and had her husband was in a wheelchair for a number of years before he passed away. And she had to deal with him in handicapped or disabled access bathrooms. And we have a family bathroom, which would be a bathroom that she could have taken her husband into. But also in both the men's and the women's, the handicap stall is not a stall. It's an actual room.

15:37 Where there is a sink and the toilet in that room. So somebody who really has that, it really is convenient for them. They have the ability to clean up and everything in private before they go back out into a more public space. So I think this is thought out quite well with a lot of input. So I think we can answer questions about that. Okay.

16:15 The average seat width is 22.5 inches. If you've been to the Edison Theater, those seats are 19, so it's considerably more gracious, more comfortable seat. So if you're large, it gives you room, and if you're small, you can wiggle around in your seat all you want. The sight lines, the seating steps down, and it progressively, as it comes back up, it progressively gets steeper. It could be seen, if you were to come up later and look,

16:45 In the section here, you can see the seats coming up. From the lobby, from the outside here, into the lobby, and through and across to the cross aisle and onto the stage, this is all one floor level. And then these from here, you'll step up and step down into these seats. That gives you a sense of that. There's a control booth here for lighting control, sound control.

17:13 That sort of stuff. This is, I'm trading on her turf. And above that, there are some follow spots, a location for follow spots. So it's lights that follow people on the stage.

17:28 I just wanted to add when you were talking about the sight lines that not only is the lobby and the stage at the same level, but you can get directly from the cross aisle onto the stage on both sides so that there is full circulation all the way around. There are no steps or lifts or ramps to deal with except to get up to the control booth. And also there is full circulation outside of the auditorium for the tech staff so that they can get from the front of house to the back of the house without having to go in the audience chamber.

18:03 The building has primarily a flat roof on the roofs. It's a tall building to put in questions that have come up about this, asked about the flat roofs. And flat roofs work really well if you build them right and you get enough slope in the roof so that they drain. They don't also shed. And when this section of roof above the...

18:29 And we have solar panels on the three roofs on that side of the building. So we're having that as a...

19:00 The building will be putting back into the grid all day long throughout most of the year because of the pitch of the roof and the exposure. So it'll seldom be covered with snow. Dead north. And this is the, the roofs are here. So that's southwest. South, southwest. They'll be staggered. We're working at the sight lines so that you'll be looking between the people in front of you. Open to question. I think what John wants to do based on camera location.

19:57 We'd like people to step up to the podium and ask their questions so we can record this.

21:02 Okay, five seconds, count for zero, no worries, five, four, three, two. Okay, Mr. Mayor Pro Tem, you want to start with questions from the council to staff first, perhaps? How would you like to work this? Okay, guys, settle down. Thank you. I think the council would like to hear just any sort of questions or observations from the public first. Okay. And we'll reserve.

21:31 You know, 15 minutes or 20 minutes towards the end for any specific council questions, but I think it'd be great to hear observations, thoughts, questions from the folks who are here first. If there aren't any, we know how to make air and hot air, so take advantage of this opportunity. Tony Taylor. And I guess the one part that I haven't heard anything about is finances. Evan...

22:07 Made a few comments about it, but it would be interesting to hear a little bit about how it went from $8 million to $12 million or whatever that was and where we are and what the needs are and what the plan is to address all that. And I think what I'd like to do with that, I know a lot of work has gone into the financing and I would, I mean, that's obviously going to be a very important part of this going forward, but I think let's maybe, let's.

22:32 You know, register that as a significant important question, but if there's any other questions about the building, the design, the layout, the use of the building, any of these other kinds of things, maybe let's see if we can kind of go through some of that stuff first. Hello, Juliana Olenka, and I'm actually here representing Eastern Sierra Symphony, and one of the things that I wanted to mention is Amy Creston, who is our Executive Director, is a

23:09 Very experienced professional musician. She's the concert master of the Pasadena Chamber Orchestra. She has played in orchestras around the world.

23:17 And one of the things she was extremely excited about in the process, this latest process of development of the Performing Arts Center, was that Ruth and her company were involved. She said they actually did the acoustics, or no, the acoustics company, excuse me, not Ruth, the company that we are talking to about the acoustics for this particular center did the acoustics for what she considers the best acoustical stage on the West Coast.

23:45 So I thought that was a very positive remark coming from her, and we didn't have any idea that she had that connection when we heard the presentation from Ruth. So I'm looking forward to having this new performing arts facility in Mammoth. Good, thank you. Bill Taylor, Mammoth Lakes. And I don't really have a question as much as some additional comments. As was noted before, I have been working on this project since 2010, off and on. And one of the things that I've really been impressed with

24:20 with the support that Rose has brought to this project is the ability to meet some of the multitude of possibly conflicting uses that this space could be asked to provide. So we've talked about live music, we've talked about theatrical performances, but it will also serve well as a lecture hall.

24:49 As a space for, you know, we always talk about things like TED Talks. It will have the ability to do two-way remote high-definition transmissions. So you can bring in performances from the MAT or London Philharmonic. You can also do conferencing and lectures remotely. And again, you can either produce the content and ship it out or receive content.

25:19 So it'll be a very versatile space if we want to do conferencing. And as was noted, the way it's laid out with the fly loft, you can have the whole set in place for an evening theatrical performance, drop a curtain and screen from the fly loft and do a lecture during the day. And you don't have a lot of time, a lot of effort put into trying to...

25:48 Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, members of the Council.

26:23 My name is Paul Rudder. I'm here as a member of the community. My wife and I have had a continuing involvement with the theater in Mammoth Lakes because we believe in the theater. We also believe that Mammoth is very fortunate to have Shira Dubrovna as a director. She has single-handedly created a tremendous resource for the community, which probably everyone in this room has enjoyed from time to time. The reason I wanted to come up and speak is this.

26:53 We have a very nice community here, which as the Town Council, you members are, you know, have a special responsibility for. We have nice houses, we have nice restaurants, we have nice commercial buildings, we have nice wonderful ski area. Our government buildings maybe could use a little work, but that's a different story. But all of that does not create in itself a community of great quality.

27:23 The infrastructure that we're talking about today is something that will elevate us beyond the norm or the ordinary. It will give this community an opportunity to...

27:36 As Bill was saying, with the TED Talks, not just the theater and dramatic productions, but with all kinds of things. We, for many years, had a place near Santa Barbara, and they have speakers that come to Santa Barbara from all over the world, all the time, to give wonderful talks and bring...

27:54 All kinds of information that you don't see on TV or in other venues. This facility will expose the kids in this community to dance and art and all kinds of things that only a facility like this can do. This is a huge opportunity for the community, and you as council members have an opportunity to make it happen. As I said, we've been very fortunate to have Shira.

28:22 Doing what she does. And the Edison Theater has been a great location, but it is small, it is cramped, and it really doesn't accommodate that many people at one time. This facility will give Mammoth a whole new look at things. And I've heard recently, we have to be open to new influences with the sale of the mountain and all this stuff, and we have to, you know, welcome the outside world. This facility will bring a luster to Mammoth it's never had before.

28:50 It's a huge opportunity for us to show a new face to the world that is one of quality that only the arts can bring. So I feel like you council members are hugely fortunate to be in a position to facilitate something like this. And I just can't overemphasize the huge importance this has to the community to make it something much greater than it has been.

29:18 Denigrating the community. It's a wonderful place. But there is a huge creative element and an artistic element in our community that really has no place for an outlet. And people who want to go to art exhibitions and dance and everything else, this is our opportunity to have that. And I think it's not an opportunity that will arrive again. This is the culmination of work by people like Evan Ford.

29:45 Thank you.

30:11 contributing every single day to the value and the quality of our community. So I appreciate the time and the consideration and the thought that you're putting into this. Thank you. Good, thank you. Shira Dubrovner, Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater and the Mammoth Lakes Film Festival, which is in three weeks. Yeah, I want to ditto everything that Paul said.

30:41 You know, we have the opening night for the film festival, and we're doing it at the Minaret Cinemas, which is great, but it's about, the larger cinema is 200 seats. So we're at a place where everything's growing, and we're kind of busting at the seams with the Felici Trio, with the Eastern Sierra Symphony, Sierra Classic Theater, myself. Our numbers are growing exponentially.

31:08 And we don't have any place to grow. And this is what supports the growth of all our organizations, our community at large. There's no other ski resort that doesn't have a place like this. I'm thinking about the film festival. It would be great to have the opening night.

31:25 Thank you so much.

31:46 I believe that this place is not only needed but will be an asset to bring in a new market to the community to bring a new economy to the community. That's the one thing that the arts and culture does for a community. It brings in a whole new

32:03 Blood into the economy and into the town that possibly have not been before. We have, just for example, for the film festival, we have people coming from Finland, from Sweden, from all over America coming just for that five-day event. And that will, they tell their friends and then their friends. And, you know, with each year, it just brings in new people to bring in.

32:29 More business and help the economy of our community. So I think that's it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Okay. Mr. Rudder is stretching his legs again. Yes, one more thing. I heard Rose speak about the accommodations they've made for people on hearing issues. And as someone who is hearing impaired, I want to thank Rose for that thoughtfulness.

32:59 One of the most frustrating things for me is in many venues I can't hear. And in fact, to be honest, the Edison Theater is one of those. And there's nothing more frustrating to go to a performance and not be able to understand what people are saying. So hearing that Rose has made accommodations for people with disability like me, I can't tell you how much that is appreciated. Interesting.

33:25 It was interesting when Tosh.0 came to Mammoth and I asked him why he was using our small little theater and the reason he said is because there was no other theater in town. Most of these people don't want to come into a space that is a multi-purpose room that is curtained off like in Las Vegas and like a convention type of a center that's made into a performance area. They want a true performance area. Most artists want that and that's another reason to support this. Thank you.

33:55 Thank you. Good evening. Luan Mendel. I'm here as a member of the board for the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, and I just wanted to tell you that this is not just an Evan and staff project. This is very much a project the board has ownership of and are enthusiastic about, and it's probably the public-private...

34:23 Partnership piece that we find most exciting. So I hope as the private, I think we're ready to help build this project, and I hope as the public partner, you will be as well. Good. Thank you very much. Not anything else. What I'd like to do, Dan, is I'd like to have any questions from the council. I've got a couple sort of technical kinds of questions. I want to make sure we leave some time for the town to address the issue of financing. I had a different comment, if I may. Okay, sure. Almost.

34:52 Sorry, somewhat quasi-public. Sure. One, I've been impressed with the work that's been done in a different job. We ended up touring probably 18 to 20 different theaters around the West, and a lot of the questions and issues that were raised and addressed.

35:08 Have been addressed here. So I just want to compliment the work done, especially, you know, the inside of the theater and how it's designed and the different elements. And as you walk through these theaters and say, yeah, if we did it over again, we'd make sure we had a larger ladies' restroom. We heard that numerous times. So thank you. My wife thanks you. We've heard looking at how do you make a single purpose theater work for multiple purposes. And I think they've done a great job. It's not just about.

35:35 A play and a production. There's a lot of other elements to it. So from looking at a number of those and attending different plays around the region as well as here in the Edison Theater, I'm impressed. I like what, you know, when you look at the inside of this theater and what it can do and what it means, it's really exciting to see happen. So just from a personal level, thank you. We'll talk about the financing and funding and the fun stuff. But the other side of that is I think it's right in line with the council's

36:01 Strategic priorities as we look at ways to really enhance our community amenities serving both our residents and our visitors. I think this type of project does both of those things. It provides this venue for those types of activities. We mentioned the film festival, the different productions, et cetera. The other exciting thing for me on this is just the location of it. It's sitting in there next to our college and the other elements there. It builds off of those things that are there.

36:27 The one piece, and it's more to the outside of theater maybe, and I've sat through some of the presentations. Personally, I'd like to see a little stronger connection with the college architecture, but Bruce, that's up to you to take a look at. I mean, those type of things, I think that connection would be nice because I really see this growing as a campus.

36:43 And I think it's exciting to think about the college, about the theater, about the Wounded Warrior Center, about the next element even on the nine acres or so that's there with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I think this is an exciting time for the town to really step up and be proud of what they have and how does it integrate. And it becomes a kind of a there-there when you show up in this campus. You should be somewhat odd about what? Here's this small town in the mountains and you have what? I just think that's a really exciting thing to be looking to.

37:12 Kind of some other comments and discussions. Don't sell ourselves short on it. But I'd love to see a 500-seat theater personally. But this here will take us a long ways in the community and the performing arts. And again, I love the inside, just the capability, what it brings. And it's impressive. So personally, thank you very much. Good. Thank you very much. With that, I'll bring it back here to the dais. And I would encourage us to take advantage of this opportunity to ask any

37:40 Kind of specific questions you have about building capacity, what it can do, what it can't do, that kind of stuff. I guess, Bill, if you have any thoughts or questions, start with you. I don't have any questions. As always with me, financing is still. Someone asked a question earlier about financing. Please donate. That's what the town needs right now for a lot of projects more than anything else is a good, solid donation program to help get this thing off the ground. Okay.

38:16 But other than that, most of my questions have been answered. Okay, good. Thank you. Cleland, any questions? I do have a question because I can't tell the dimensions, but is there a way to get the grand piano easily to the stage? Okay. Okay, awesome. And the acoustics, I'm...

38:40 I think that was Mr. Rutter that brought that up. Thank you so much because that's one thing that's lacking in this town is a place with adequate acoustics. So that is a dream come true in my mind, theater. So thank you. Good. Thank you. Okay. Colin? A couple questions, a couple comments.

39:03 You know, first of all, I appreciate Evan, your team, everybody that's involved in this for all the work that's gone into this. You know, I feel like this is something that I've seen.

39:13 Through a number of iterations, and it's pretty exciting to see it kind of come to this culmination. You know, one of the questions I had kind of throughout the discussion and negotiation process, there were some questions of the town regarding road dedication of College Parkway. Is that something that's been resolved or something that is still kind of hanging out there? I can address that. The issue has been brought up a couple times, so thank you. We're working at the staff level to bring that item back to council. It was addressed.

39:42 By a town council, I think, in 2013. A couple caveats in that discussion at that point in time that we want to readdress. So our goal would be to bring it back to you either May 17th or June 7th, in June, that we'd be bringing that item back to resolve that issue. It's an outstanding item, so thank you for highlighting that. So I would personally bring that to the council as long as it's okay with everyone. Can we have staff come back to us with some direction on that specifically?

40:12 Yeah, I'm assuming that would be. I think when we have the financial. Yeah, it'll be part of the financial. When we have the financial decisions to be made, which aren't tonight, I think all of those things have to be looked at very hard. I just wanted to make sure that that was included in that package. Yeah, I would like to bring that forward in the front end because there's some issues to get that resolved out, especially for this summer and stuff. Okay. Included in that package, I would expect to have the ongoing annual O&M because that's a financial consideration as well. Okay.

40:40 The second question I have is, you know, assuming that the town does invest public dollars in this facility, what is going to be the design review process? Is that going to go before Planning Commission and then to Council, or how are we going to work through that? I believe it's flowing through the town, but I'll let Bruce, I think he's up to speed on that. It's going through the town. It's not, there was talk of it possibly being a project that would be DSA.

41:08 You know, I think...

41:35 Just in general, I'm excited we're kind of bringing this stuff to a head. I know it's been a tremendous effort for everybody that's worked on that. Without getting too concrete as far as financial details, one of the things that I think is so encouraging about this project is the variety of sources that are coming together.

41:56 To hopefully make this happen, including public, private, etc. So, you know, my understanding is we have a significant amount of money that's been donated from the private sector, so that's a huge boost to this project and very much appreciated. There's a very significant ask to the college in the form of Measure C, and then my understanding is there's going to be an ask to the town both for capital infrastructure.

42:23 You know, in the form of Measure U, and also potentially ongoing O and M, which Measure U will contribute to as well. So I think these are the type of projects that as, you know, we have a lot of needs and aspirations as a community, and this is the type of stuff that I think, you know, putting all these different entities together will allow us to push these things across the finish line.

42:45 So, you know, I'm very encouraged and excited. You know, I'm looking forward to a more detailed financial presentation so that we can kind of arrive at a decision point. But a lot of hard work's gone into it. I think, you know, a lot of exciting things to come here. So, thank you. Thank you very much, Colin. Thank you all. We have just a little bit of time left. As some of you know, I have sort of a background in these types of endeavors.

43:17 I'd like to ask, if I could. The first thing has to do with, but before I start, I want to echo Colin's comments. I really want to commend the private sector that's stepping up for this. We are working to create a culture of philanthropy and investment in this community by a very large

43:37 Set of stakeholders, including second homeowners and people who are visitors, people who live here. I really want to commend you guys for stepping up and taking the initiative on this. It's very important. And so that being said, this building, talk to me a little bit about seating and flexibility. I'm thinking about it. To me, it looks like a very much of a theatrical.

44:02 I produced a show at the Brooklyn Academy of Music once many years ago, and I'm interested in how the types of musical performances that this building could accommodate, specifically amplified music, other types of live performance music that may involve some dancing or some space in the front for people to kind of...

44:27 You know, be able to be involved in the music that way. Is that something this kind of space could accommodate, or was it really kind of designed for theatrical and acoustic type performances, or your thoughts on that? It was not designed to be that sort of infinitely flexible space that you're talking about. The stakeholders involved and the decisions were such that it is, for the most part, very much an end stage.

44:53 The idea was that you did not have to build the facility before you could build the production. The design also, however, is not completely fixed. This is a concept design. There are certain changes that could be made to provide somewhat more flexibility. Certainly you can put dancers and musicians on stage. The side stages could maybe grow for other reasons.

45:18 And acoustically in particular, it will accommodate everything from unamplified to amplified music, film and spoken word events and projected events. Okay. And I was just interested in the seating in the floor area. The seating at this point is fixed. It is fixed. It is fixed. Does that, from your professional opinion, does that limit programming in any way or not? Flexibility, as you know, is a two-edged sword.

45:45 Anything, the more flexibility that you build in, you're either paying for it in capital costs, i.e. big movable pieces, or ongoing labor costs, and that is moving those chairs, removing those chairs. I think that there is a need in most communities for a variety of types of space. The Edison Theater is and will remain a flexible space. It's small.

46:08 But it is exactly that sort of black box, build the facility first and then have the event. So that already exists. In order to provide for growth for organizations that are primarily community oriented, we felt that it was very important to limit the...

46:27 Frankly, drudgery labor that goes in with moving platforms, moving chairs, and so on, and to really put the emphasis on the performances. Okay. Good. A couple other questions. In terms of film, in terms of how would the projection of the audio...

46:48 What's the anticipated technology for doing that in this space? We have not begun to design the exact technology. As you know, the technology moves by leaps and bounds. The basic concepts, knowing what's needed in terms of having front projection for presentation of film, the possibility perhaps of rear projection for scenic uses, the remote capabilities, all of those will be provided for. But to choose equipment or even networking capability now,

47:18 Would be to lock in something that may easily be obsolete in a year. When the design is advanced to the stage that we need to choose that, then the expert part of the design team will choose what seems to be the most appropriate specific technology. Okay, so I'm assuming that that, in terms of the financing stuff, that will be, the expectations of what the facility can handle will be reflected in the budget, the anticipated capital costs for doing those kinds, that'll all be in there when we get to that point.

47:47 Okay. As you know, we have something up here called Digital 395. We have more broadband capacity in the eastern Sierra than South Korea does. Just saying. And I think it's...

47:58 It's anticipated that this facility will be very friendly to being able to consume and deliver broadband. I'm assuming that's just... Yeah, we were talking about that last night, as a matter of fact, and how that's going to... There's already a small node there on the site, and of course the college has a node across the street. Again, that'll be part of the ongoing design, and for me to attempt to give you detailed answers now would be probably to pin myself to the floor in a way that we all regret later. I understand. That's something I think will be very interesting, how you...

48:28 And I just have to give another kudos to the acoustical firm that has been engaged so far in this design effort. They also have an AV and IT division, which is extremely sophisticated. So not only will the AV and the IT systems be the state of the art that you need, but they will be designed to make sure that they coordinate with the natural and variable acoustics as well as the theatrical systems. Okay.

48:58 I think the last thing is I saw something on the plans about a residence, sort of a residence room or residence building. Is that great? Thank you. That may actually at this point be a holdover from previous discussions, but that would be, that is down the road. That's a future.

49:20 No, that's a separate building at a different location, so it's not connected to this building in any way.

49:47 Okay. And while I've got you here, Bruce, the state architect issue, is that, can you speak a little bit more about that in terms of, because I know, my understanding was that the measure seemingly, you'd have to have a state architect involved in this and all that stuff. Both the, actually, Evan can speak to this better than I can. However, it's, well, I'll look. Hi, Evan Russell.

50:15 One of the original requirements of the college has been Measure C because this facility will be used for students also was that it go through DSA which is what all school projects have to go through. We've been working with town planning staff and Sandra and Dan did some research on this, had the town attorney give us an opinion and they said since

50:38 The building would not be owned by the college but partially financed by the college that it wouldn't have to be a DSA approved building. So we went back to the college. The college said we agree with the town's attorney's opinion and we'll go forward with you having the building approved through town planning.

50:57 Good. So the Kern folks, they're all on the same page? Yes, sir. Okay, good. Great. So I think my only last two thoughts, I think that the idea of the architectural integration into the campus, I think, is something that will be worth looking at as we start getting to the final steps of this. And I would add the transit piece and how that gets connected. With that being said, you know, the Council commends all of your efforts, MLR's efforts, Evan, your efforts, everybody's efforts. This is a great and very significant opportunity.

51:27 I want to give Dan just a couple minutes to give us some thoughts on how the financial discussion may or may not unfold in the coming weeks, months, whatever. We've been working on this for a while through Mammoth Lakes Recreation as well. Rich can speak to that a little bit as well as I can at this point. We've had some various budget discussions and potential fundings, and some of it is still, you know, predicated on other things happening. Okay. So, Rich, why don't you get started? So, next steps.

51:57 MLR Board had a good conversation last night about a holistic approach to budgeting for 17, 18, 18, and 19 and beyond. So Dan and I work on an agenda bill looking at one-time capital, ongoing cost, holistically as related to R&U and what it means to us. So we'll bring that forward. One of the pieces that the question I think Colin asked was about College Parkway. That's got to be one of the pieces we close. So the two things we need to move back to Kern County.

52:23 The College District is the funding pieces, one-time capital, ongoing cost, College Parkway. Once we wrap that stuff up, the sooner the better, then Evan can go back and work with Tim and Jill at the college to say, okay, guys, we're ready to roll. What do you guys want to do to support, further support financial supports through Measure C at this point? So that's kind of where we are. Evan, I think those are most of the pieces right now? Yeah, just, you know, the funding piece is still...

52:52 A little bit of a moving target, and to answer one of the questions from the audience, you know, our initial cost estimates were done on a square footage basis, which was given to us from an architect who built a nice theater up in the Grass Valley area. When we brought Rose in, there was things that we left out.

53:12 The lobby area wasn't big enough to support. If you have 300 people seated, you want to be able to have 300 people standing for a cocktail reception before you go in. So we increased space there. There was a number of things like with the restrooms. The building went from 14,000 to 18,000 square feet. And then the enhancements that we're making due to all the technical stuff that Rose is helping us with, her company, or she has looked at this as

53:41 A $12 million project. So we don't know if that's the real number or not yet, or an $11 to $12 million project. We know we're going to have to have additional parking that goes into it. We know that we want a storage unit that, you know, when you talked about chairs and things that happen in the building that don't stay there all the time, you have to have a place to store them. We need a place for set construction. There's things like that. We're just trying to make sure we got

54:09 All the details so we don't build something and then come back, as Dan said, you know, I wish we would have done this later on. So we're also taking the Edison building, which is 7,000 square feet, and that'll be the administrative building with conference rooms that help support what happens in the theater. So all these pieces fit.

54:31 Really fit nicely together. You know, one little kind of fun thing we're working on right now is we're in a negotiation with the McCoy family to be the caretakers of all the Dave McCoy history stuff, which is in his office and in his home, anybody that's been there.

54:47 Has seen the stuff in his office, which is incredible to me, treasure trove of our history. We have a room we call the Heritage Room, which would be kind of a private function room that could be used for a number of things. Hopefully that's where the Dave McCoy history lives in this thing in the future. So if right now the piece we have for the theater is $12 million and we take, we're going to dedicate nine acres to this.

55:15 So there's room to do other things on this property down the line, things that we're probably not even thinking about now where people after us are going to come along and think about. The Edison building, which is 7,000 square feet. If we take that stuff and we add it to the cost of the project, so let's just say we have a $20 million project. So we have a value going in and a contribution with it going in too.

55:44 So we know there's going to be some kind of a shortfall, even with town funding, with Measure C funding. We think it's going to be less than 10% of the $20 million. We'll initiate a capital campaign, which we're starting to put the framework together once we know what the exact numbers are going to be to fill that gap. Okay, so why don't we have both you and Dan here?

56:03 Any thoughts on timing? People have been working very hard. I think the iterations as things are progressing is very exciting. I think the council, if you're prepared to speak to this at all, any sense of when you may be ready to start bringing some things forward for this body? Yeah, I mean, it's a building block process. We have an agreement that goes back about two years ago that the college did a joint use

56:32 And development of facilities agreement that they thought they could easily commit $4.5 million of Measure C. Now the building's gone to another level. Dan, I think it's going to bring some numbers to you guys. You know, we're going to ask you to commit. And I think right now this can be done conditionally, $2.5 million of capital. And I know, John, you know, when you and I, I think, were responsible for passing Measure U.

56:58 Back in 2010. And we had a lot of ideas of what it was going to take to get this thing off the ground. You know, seven years later, things change. So we're asking for some capital outlay to go into it. Once we know that you've got your money, we've got at least $2.5 million committed from one donor and a couple hundred thousand from another, that might increase a little bit. Then we'll sit down with the college and say, how much can we increase the Measure C money to meet this project?

57:28 And right now we have about five or six consultants working on the project. We have one really, really good cost consulting firm that we hope will have something in a couple of weeks that will take us to the next stage of how accurate it's our $12 million on the theater project. Okay, good. Well, I think thanks to everybody. Thanks for coming. Do you have any questions for the council or the town on this? Or are we all...

57:55 No, I think, you know, get the road thing off our plates so we don't have to deal with that. The road thing, that's Collins' road thing? Yeah, okay. College Parkway is three-tenths of a mile, and I think you have around 60 or 65 miles of road in town. Three-tenths of a mile, that's all we're talking about. Okay. One other comment. This would be the only state-of-the-art theater in the eastern Sierras. Right. So, it's a big area. We could use it.

58:24 Good. All right. Well, thank you very much. So thanks, everybody, for coming. I think we'll take kind of a quick reset to get everybody ready to go, and we'll see you back here in a couple minutes, and the mayor can lead you through the budget. I love my daughter. I know. We did the pledge. We did the pledge. We're pledged. We're pledged. We're pledged. We're going to pledge again. Let's pledge again. Pledge again. There you go.

59:14 Dan? You know what? It's a totally different group of people, so. Yeah, exactly. We've got to pledge again. I'd like to call to order the Town Council agenda meeting for Wednesday, May 3rd. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Yep. Here. Here. We're all here. I know we did a pledge earlier, but for those people that didn't get to do the pledge, we're going to do it again. So I've asked Mr. Boccia to lead us in the pledge.

59:48 Rich, please. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We got it right that time. Okay. Okay, we'll go on to the next, which is correspondence. We received a letter.

1:00:21 Which hopefully all the council members read. A letter from commercial property owners along Main Street and Old Mammoth Road. Are there any comments from council on that? Yes. Okay, Cleveland. I really liked some of the ideas that they came up with and I was just wondering what presently do we have that we will be doing that addresses that letter and can we get a staff report of some of those things that could be accomplished?

1:00:50 I think Grady's sitting right there. Actually, in my department reports, I have a rundown on some of the things we're beginning to do, so I can do a summary of that at that time, if that's okay. Awesome. Thank you. That was it. All right. Any other comments? Thank you. We'll put that into the agenda for this period. Any public comments? Now's the time. Anybody from the public can address the council, right?

1:01:26 Please state your name. Hello, everybody. My name is Josh Ray. I'm the Digital Marketing Coordinator for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Good evening, Mr. Mayor and members of the council and the public of Mammoth Lakes. I'm here to talk about Fishmas and the successful weekend that we had here in Mammoth Lakes and talk about a little bit of what we did on our end at Mammoth Lakes Tourism. As you guys know, we had beautiful weather. We really can't beat that.

1:01:51 Lots of snow, lots of ice. We were thrilled to have the weather that we did. Lots of happy fishermen. 70, our town occupancy on Friday night was 70%, or 71% was Saturday night and 70%, so great numbers for this time of year. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we actually produced multiple maps, or not maps, but signs, welcome anglers. So we had one welcome anglers sign at the entrance of town, so that was located on Minaret Road, or Old Mammoth and Main Street.

1:02:18 And then we had lots of these little signs at businesses that were interested in putting them up, and we had six three-by-five-foot banners at the local fishing shops and other businesses that were interested. So we really wanted to have a cohesive message to all the anglers that were visiting Mammoth Lakes this weekend, and I think we did a good job at that. On top of that, we produced the Eastern Sierra Fishing Map with Mono County Tourism, Annual County, and Visit Bishop.

1:02:41 This map is incredible in so many ways. It includes a ton of hot spots of where to fish all along the 395 corridor. Great tips for catch and release and other just...

1:02:51 Fantastic tips for people that want to get into fishing for the first time or maybe if they've been fishing for years. So it's definitely a hot spot map and we're thrilled to get that out this summer. We distributed a ton of them at the Fred Hall fishing shows this past winter and we're going to continue to distribute them along with 395. Along with those, we were talking on the radio with KMMT about...

1:03:13 Fishmas and what we were doing, what lakes were open, and where the fishermen should go. And that was a lot of fun. On top of that, newsletters and social media, we have an incredible video that was produced that featured Tim Alpers and a big fish story that I actually want to show you guys. This is on our Facebook channel, Visit Mammoth, so I recommend all you guys like that channel. And it's also on our YouTube channel. And it was right there. Hold, please.

1:04:06 Growing some monster fish from my hatchery. They asked if I would grow four of my legendary Albers trout to be especially monstrous. They wanted to put one to each of the four legs on the competition. So, for 15 months I did. And boy, they sure grew. The night before the competition, I examined the four beasts. They weighed a total of 65 pounds. All of them were huge males with hooked jaws and hanging teeth. They were all perfect.

1:04:39 And believe me, they were big. I planted the fish in the dark so none of these greedy anglers could easily catch them before the competition began. I put one in each lake, one of the biggest, and he was right at 21 pounds. I ended up in Lake Mary. The next day, eager fishermen cast their lines in hopes of catching them. Trophy trout to top all trophy trout. I was pulled out of Lake Mamie, another would reel in out of twin. I was caught at Lake Joy. John went the derby and it finally ended.

1:05:30 So that is one of our most recent videos. It is live on our social channels, going out, like I said, in our newsletters, in all of our key markets. So just want to follow up with a quick wrap up.

1:06:28 I checked in with Trout Fitter. They're up 20% in sales from last year. That was for this past weekend. Comdick Lake was 100% booked over the weekend, and the campground was open as of Friday. So lots of hype about the fishing here in the eastern Sierra. We're going to continue pushing that message, especially with the snow conditions and people not being able to access Yosemite. We're going to go and hammer that fishing message here. So I want to thank you guys all for your time. Thanks for watching the video. And like I said, please follow us on our social channels, and we'll have more content coming out soon.

1:06:57 Thank you. Any questions? No. That's a nice piece. Awesome. Thank you, guys. Thank you. Oh, if you want an Eastern Sierra fishing map, they're in the back. And if you guys would like any of these in your businesses, let me know. Good evening. Brent Truax. I just wanted to extend a thank you to particularly one of the town servants that you have here. But very recently, our fire chief of the town lost a significant person.

1:07:30 And I was unfortunately not able to make the services on Tuesday, but the Celebration Life was a true tribute to someone who's helped out in disabled sports and other areas of the community. And, you know, I think that everybody's given support to Frank in this time of need, but I really want to thank Al Davis for what he's done. I think that people don't know the amount of work that he put behind the scenes to do a very special day for a very special person, and I wanted to just put a shout out and give my personal thanks to him for what he's done. Thank you.

1:07:58 Thank you. I just wanted to stop by and introduce myself. My name is Ken Bringle. I'm the new Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and glad to be here and looking forward to working with you and accomplishing some hopefully very good things. So I will be meeting with Dan later in the week and start meeting hopefully with each of you and have the opportunity to sit down and

1:08:33 And talk about what our goals and aspirations are for this community. So I look forward to it. And I just want to say it's great to be here. Thank you. Welcome. Welcome. Thank you. OK. Any other public comment? Hearing none. Oh, wait. Good evening, counsel, mayor. Michael Baker, resident. Question on the social media that you have cascading. Are you cascading it out?

1:09:09 Or are you just hoping for visitation? How are you getting that message across on the YouTube and your other social media outlets? Well, are you pushing it from YouTube to subscribers? Or do we have a subscriber level at this time with the tourism? 5,000 subscribers? And that is to specifically deal with... And so by pushing a YouTube video on your Facebook channel to all of our fans, it won't be as successful as...

1:09:52 The thousand that you mentioned earlier, what kind of viewership are you experiencing on that today? Not to be critical, Council, but being here a year, being a student of marketing and advertising business in general for years and years, I'm not seeing the messages from the Town of Mammoth Council.

1:10:34 Recreation I do, mostly the agendas, but I'm not really seeing, even though I follow, social media. And I know in discussions it's been identified that the residences aren't really aware here, the community, those that are supporting, as the tourists do, of course, the MAC Center and other facilities that we're looking at proposals. I would urge council to give consideration of finding a way

1:11:03 To better cascade and get out to the community better social media, as most of us are connected by telephone, right, as social media goes also. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Any other public comment? Hearing none, we'll go on to council member reports. Bill, can I start with you? Since the last meeting, I attended the ESTA meeting. We have one of the items from that on our agenda here tonight.

1:11:37 I also attended the Fishmas Day at Crowley Lake. The weather was absolutely phenomenal. While we did catch some beautiful fish, my sister got a 22-inch, 4-pound cut. The number of people complaining about the inability to catch fish, which used to not happen there, is still startling to me, and the number of people choosing not to come.

1:12:03 to the Crowley opener is still startling and while I understand it is out of the three square miles of Mammoth, it drives business for us and I think that between tourism and MLR and the rec department, whoever is going to take up the mantra of recreation outside of municipal, we need to do something to push that forward. I know they have changed some of the rules back to what they were to help enhance that but besides getting people here and I've had this

1:12:30 Discussion with Mr. Erty before, once they are here and we are successful in our marketing, we need to give them that quality experience that brings them back over and over and over again. There used to be multi-generational families that would see me down there and come just to say hello that no longer are coming. It used to be fishermen shoulder to shoulder and you could walk across the boats. It was beautiful and my boat did catch, you know, quite a few fish. But then again, I've been fishing that lake for 58 years, so I may have some experience others lack.

1:13:00 But it's just, as a town, as beautiful as it is, it's something we have to address. Our recreation doesn't just happen within the three square miles of Mammoth. It happens mostly outside of that. So I just wanted us to be aware of that and to push that button a little. I brought it up at MR last night. Yeah. Thank you. Is that it? That's it. Thank you. Bill, if you and Cleland, as ESTA board members, I know,

1:13:29 We had kind of talked in the past about bringing something back regarding additional service on the old Mammoth Corridor and Gray Line piece. Has that been discussed at any of the board meetings? We have discussed it, I think, at almost every board meeting, the fact that we reintroduced some service and that, at least from my end, Cleland both, have pushed hard to see if we can reintroduce the full Gray Line service.

1:13:54 Until the snow is gone and we can actually go back and look at the route and what the timing would be and what our abilities are, we're sort of in a holding pattern. And if you've been up on Redford lately, who knows when we'll be out of that holding pattern. But that's something... Yes, I am not letting that die. Okay. It'll come back in the summer probably. All right. Thanks. Colin. Only one item for me. On Tuesday the 25th, I did go to the chamber business half.

1:14:23 After Hours where Ken was introduced. So it's great to have you here and welcome and look forward to working with you. That was over at Edison and there was a presentation on the Performing Arts Center there and it was very well attended and people are excited. So that's it for me since the last meeting. Are you on vacation? I was, yeah. I was a pure resort tour.

1:14:49 Up in Whistler. You take a lot of those. Somebody's got to do it. So yeah, I was in Whistler for a week, and it was very cool to see. First time up there, and now I'm back. Good. Welcome back. Thanks. Cleveland. Yes, I attended on the 21st, the ESTA meeting, and yes, the gray line is a...

1:15:11 Constantly on the agenda. On April 26th, I celebrated Denim Day with a bunch of the local staff and also I think that same day was the marijuana community workshop which I think was actually well attended and a very productive workshop considering the unknowns that are out there about the whole Prop 64 getting passed.

1:15:40 And that was, I thought, a very productive, and I look forward to the next one. And then on April 27th, I attended the collaborative planning team meeting, and John Wentworth was there as well. And one thing that I'm very excited about, about both the ESTA and the collaborative planning team, is that the Reds Meadow Road seems to really be making some...

1:16:06 It has some momentum going to it, and I'm very excited to keep hearing that come up and moving forward at the meetings. I'm sure you all have something else to say about that meeting. Mr. Mayor, one more thing on the ESTA meeting, if I could. Yes, certainly. It slipped my mind for a minute. One of the decisions we made as an ESTA board was to pay in whole our underfunded liability to the PERS retirement system.

1:16:32 And the reason I bring that up is because I haven't seen that in our own budget discussions yet, but I'm assuming that we have the same issue, the fact that they've been charging not enough and we have a certain underfunded piece there as well. So that's a question for later, but it was one very important piece on that because ESTA had the money to pay that in whole instead of doing the 30-year payout at a fairly substantial interest rate. So it'll save a lot of money over the long haul.

1:17:00 We haven't had that discussion here yet, and I'm sure it is coming. It needs to be a piece of this budget discussion. Thank you, Bill. Were you done, Cleland? Thank you. How many pages do you have, John? A couple. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So, a couple items. First thing is, I think we've all seen the announcement from the Forest Service about Mill City. This is a pretty significant item.

1:17:29 And I will leave it. It's a forest service project. They've got a meeting scheduled for May 15th from 5 to 7 at the auditorium at the Mammoth Lakes Welcome Center. I would encourage everybody who's interested in that to attend that. You can also be in touch with the... Can you expand on that a little bit? Yeah, there's an environmental concern.

1:17:49 That the Forest Service has identified up at Mill City. Around the trail, the old Stant Mill site. There are a number of acronyms in the press release that indicate that this is probably a pretty serious matter. It's going to affect the rec residences up there. I'm not sure how it will affect the town or not. I don't think we really know yet. But it requires people's attention. They've identified.

1:18:17 Yeah, different types of heavy metals that would require a fair amount of probably soil remediation, removal, et cetera, as I guess at this point in time. There is some questions as to how much of that might be naturally occurring. The arsenic we have naturally occurring here, I've been told, was not used in the type of mining that was done there, but it's being blamed on the mining. So there's a lot of questions yet to be answered. Well, anyway, they have to go in there and figure it out.

1:18:43 Okay. Yeah, there's going to be some work. So I would, it's a Forest Service thing, so, but May 15th, 5 to 7 at the Auditorium in Mammoth Lakes, and Deb Schweizer is now at the Forest Service. You can talk with her. She's a public affairs officer. I was also, I took note of an article in the sheet about the plastic bag issue, and I think we're all very concerned about that. I know that Councilmember Ferney was pushing this. We were all pushing to try to get a, some sort of a plastic bag initiative in town that would be

1:19:12 Something effective in terms of our environment. The reporting indicates that it's not doing anything to address the heavier plastic bags are now out in the environment and that the money that's being collected by our supermarket here is not going to any environmental cause and I think it's something I'd like to revisit at some point. I think it's an issue we need to look into this a little bit. Yeah, it was a ballot initiative actually that got voted down.

1:19:37 Yeah. Unfortunately. Yeah. So I think we may want to revisit that. California. California. I mean, we could look at something coming back. You don't have any authority that I know of to regulate on that at this point because we're superseded by state law. Right. Understand all that doesn't do anything to address the frustration of a community living in a place like this. Nope.

1:19:56 Just heavier bags are now being strewn all over the landscape, and the money being collected for that is not going to anything to mitigate any of that. I think that that's a certain point of frustration. I think we may want to come back and try to do something about that. I appreciate that we don't have any authority on it, but it's not working. In terms of fishing, I was out over the weekend. I ran into some fishermen.

1:20:19 I anecdotally want to share reports of frustration of not catching fish. So it's something that was kind of out there. I'm also interested in a little bit in how tourism addressed the fact that the lake's basin was closed. I don't know, Grady, I just got some images about what's actually going on up there. How we're telling the story of, well, gee, you know, these guys are saying, look, I'm going to go to Lake Mary and do my thing. And it's like, well, there's 10 feet. Did you know that there's 10 feet of snow on top of Lake Mary? I don't know if that affects.

1:20:47 The activity, but I just wanted to echo what I've been hearing out there from folks. They aren't closed. The water is just a little solid. Water is a little solid. There's something in between you and the water and the snow and the ice and the fish. Anyway, so a couple of things. So the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, we missed you, Mayor Richardson, at that meeting, but a lot of interesting things happened. The town advised.

1:21:08 Our partners in the region about the letter we've gotten from the FAA and the town further advise that good conversations are happening with Inyo County about reliable regional air service, which is the goal of the ESCOG. I would like to request that part of that conversation with Inyo County involves elected officials from both bodies meeting. It would be good to follow up with that to see what's happening with that.

1:21:30 On the technology front, the Inumano Broadband Consortium convened its advisory council. The first meeting of that advisory council happened before the next Eastern Sierra Council government meetings happened with representation from Mammoth based on council direction on our last meeting for some sort of placeholder type things, but we're looking forward to seating, getting those people there. A provider council, these are the internet service providers. That council will be coming at a later date.

1:21:58 The image you see up here on the screen, the connected Eastern Sierra graphic was approved and accepted by the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. This will be the brand that hopefully we'll be seeing throughout the region telling the story of the great broadband capacity we have here and what opportunities that has for relocation and for business use and all the rest of it. And that's a thanks to the town of Mammoth Lakes for spearheading, helping to fund that effort. The members of the Broadband Task Force.

1:22:21 Stacey Corliss, Todd Johnson, Pam Kobalars, Nate Greenberg, and myself. It's a volunteer group, but we're moving these things forward. That's an exciting little piece. The Eastern Sierra Council of Governments now has a website, scog.ca.gov, so all those folks are trying to figure out what's going on with that body. There's now a single place you can go to get agendas and information and that kind of stuff. There was a motion to...

1:22:46 Endorsed the Respect for State Marijuana Laws Acts of 2017. This is a federal House of Representatives action which is designed to amend the Controlled Substances Act to provide that the act's regulatory controls, administrative, civil, and criminal penalties do not apply to a person who produces, possesses, distributes, dispenses, administers, or delivers marijuana in compliance with state laws. And we'll talk about the marijuana thing in a second.

1:23:12 A significant piece of this. The Attorney General of the United States with a letter and a stroke of the pen could cause a lot of havoc to things happening in a variety of states. So I thought that was interesting. The question of a regional economic development authority was discussed and reviewed. There was a lot of enthusiasm for that. I want to thank Dan for providing some preliminary information on that. A scoping discussion has been put together with representatives from all four agencies to bring that back to the ESCOG to start exploring

1:23:40 The advisability and the value of some sort of regional economic development capacity, which I think would be interesting. And a variety of different upcoming things, but Airbnb discussions, staffing for the ESCOG. I think it's important on the marijuana front that in August, I believe, the ESCOG's going to convene and review the policies coming out of each four of the jurisdictions so we can all look at what marijuana in the eastern Sierra may look like so we're not unintentionally doing something that could

1:24:09 Be unfortunate or crazy. So we'll see how that goes. I attended the TOT committee meeting on April 25th. We had a general review of some very strong TOT numbers. You know, it's strong, no doubt about that. And the question was about how are we dealing with summer? How are we noticing the larger public about what is happening in Mammoth as we transition from a serious winter into a hopefully very active summer season?

1:24:36 Robust. Robust. Robust summer season. And I think it's great to be going to those meetings and really getting the sense of the confidence of the TOT enforcement program we've got going here in Mammoth. We've come a long way, and I think staff needs to be commended. It's really turning out to be kind of a model for the region, and I think there's a lot of lessons to be learned. I think...

1:24:57 Some issues came up about the potential for some of these cases, the more flagrant violators getting into potential felony types of activities, felonious types of activities, and to be thinking in terms of referrals to the district attorney and this kind of stuff. I think that the council certainly appreciates that the opportunities for single-family rentals with using the platforms available to people, people might think that this is just a cost of doing business kind of thing, but we're going to be sticking with this thing as far as it goes, and certainly the issues of

1:25:26 The types of criminal activity that might be happening was coming up. I attended a meeting with Dan Holler and the Forest Supervisor, Ed Armenta, the District Ranger, talking about an idea for the town to start providing some capacity to the Forest Service to help with the kind of challenges that we have here in Mammoth Lakes. I think any of us who've dealt with the Forest Service over the years, the consistent...

1:25:50 The complaint and refrain is no capacity, no capacity, no capacity, and the idea that the town, perhaps a partnership with the county, may be able to do something to help address some of those issues. I saw you there. Yeah, I'm sorry. And Mayor Richardson was there as well. I'm sorry. But it was an interesting meeting, wasn't it? It was a very good meeting. Very good meeting. Excellent. And there'll be some follow-up on that in the days and weeks to come. That's an interesting initiative. Thank you. Thank you for...

1:26:13 Thank you for being there. The marijuana workshop. As Cleland and I both attended, it's a very interesting thing. It's great to hear the community come out and talk about it. This is a very complex challenge, and no one should underestimate how complex and complicated this is going to be, not to mention the fact that it's federally illegal by federal statute, so it's going to be interesting. Mowen County Collaborative Planning Team meeting. I was there with Cleland.

1:26:41 Caltrans has a list going around if you're interested of pass closures with the status of all the various passes are. They're taking this very seriously and letting people know what's happening with the road, so you can sign up for that list. They advise that there will be multiple delays this summer due to Caltrans work, so just be prepared for multiple delays on California roads. The National Park Service advised they have no opening date for the post pile. They spoke a lot about the increasing demands of the visitation on the monument.

1:27:10 The superintendent was very thankful to Town of Mammoth Lakes for providing the Intervalley Shuttle last year, but I think we all need to keep reminding ourselves that was a one-time thing. The challenges the post pile may have down there over time is something that may be something we need to get engaged with with them over time. I was there principally to bring up the issues of shady rest and what happened this winter and requested of Morrow County to convene the Forest Service.

1:27:38 BLM, the county, and the town to get together to really start addressing what's going on out there. It's not funny anymore, and I advise on behalf of the town that the expectations of the town will be providing, you know, $40,000 to $60,000, what we spent plowing sawmill cutoff road, that none of these agencies should be assuming that we're going to be doing that again next year until we get...

1:28:01 Until we know what's going on out there. And I hope they take this seriously. I'm looking forward to following up with Scott Burns and that group to see where that may be going. This will bleed over into LTC discussions. We may hear about that on Monday, how the LTC and the collaborative plan team start working together to start figuring out what we're going to do with all this stuff. I attended the MLH board meeting on Monday evening, where I found out that Tony Dablino is now the assistant CAO for Mono County. Who knew, right? Tony's moving up in the world.

1:28:30 I advised the MLH board and the outreach the town is doing to the NGOs as part of the Measure A discussions that Councilmember Fernie and I are involved with. I'm setting up some dates. It's a meeting for that.

1:28:45 Jennifer, the Executive Director, advised that MLH may be doing some outreach to both landlords and tenants to start getting some good information out to folks about what the various rights are of various parties. I know that people I know in town have had a very difficult time trying to get information about what their rights are as a tenant, what the landlord's responsibilities are. It's led to a lot of complications, but I think it'd be a very good thing for them to host those workshops and get those information out to people.

1:29:13 The Mammoth Lakes Community Housing Action Plan Live, Work, Thrive update was provided. They're in part one, collecting a lot of data, getting all this stuff together. There will be a meeting with the council, I think sometime in July, July 19th, second meeting to review kind of that part one, what all the data looks like, where we're at with all these housing issues. And then immediately after that, they're going to go into part two, which is start coming up with some ideas and policy recommendations.

1:29:42 Assuming coming back to the council what we're going to do about this. There will be workshops open to the public in July, the third week of August, the second week of September, the fourth week of September, the first week of October, the fourth week of October, and the first week of November. They don't have dates yet, but there's going to be a bunch of opportunities for the public to get involved in this process and help to refine these meetings. Upcoming meetings, the Region 5 folks from the Forest Service are coming over here next week.

1:30:11 There's a bunch of different opportunities for us to engage with that. I'll defer to Dan a little bit to help coordinate for Brown Act issues who might be going where. The regional forester, Randy Moore, will be here Tuesday and Wednesday. He will not be here on Thursday. That may be something to help coordinate how we start doing all this stuff.

1:30:29 Just a couple observations. I think that there's a lot of things that we've been working on. While it's been a very crazy and difficult winter, it's been a historic winter, this council and this town has been busy doing a lot of things. And there's a lot of things I think we need to start engaging the public with because I think we're starting to come out of process and coming into some decision-making about some things that are going to be happening.

1:30:50 The multi-use facility, walk, bike, ride, the downtown, all these different kinds of things are happening. I know that Councilmember Fernie and I are working with Supervisor Corliss on a community conversation meeting on May 31st. It might be a good opportunity for these things, but I look forward to figuring out how we can coordinate with members of Council to get out there on things that we take action on to start really engaging the public in these things, because these are important decisions, and we've all put a lot of work into this, staff put a lot of work into this, and this is really going to be dictating the future direction of the community.

1:31:18 And so I'm looking forward to how we can kind of pull those things together. And finally, it's really come apparent to me that this winter, it was a big winter. Boy, it snowed a lot. Boy, all kinds of great things happened. But I think for all the residents and the staff and the folks who are up here dealing with the reality of this thing, it's also a little bit of a kind of a traumatic winter. I mean, there was two months there that were some serious, serious heavy sledding.

1:31:47 And it's something that I think the visitors don't quite understand. They, oh boy, you got lots of snow. Great, you're all making lots of money. Well, yeah, but it was two months there. It was some pretty serious heavy sledding. And I'm thinking that maybe as part of the town cleanup day, we could really start to acknowledge to all the residents, all of us have been through all this stuff, look, this is a real, this is a heavy deal.

1:32:06 And maybe something like a donut for every resident, some T-shirts, some group hugs, some sharing of stories, things like that. I think it would be a good thing to kind of rally around what we've all been through because we all know that it's not over yet. We've got to wait for it to melt so we can find out all the busted stuff. But maybe it's an opportunity for Town Cleanup Day that we could do something like that to really kind of bring folks together. We'll get your coloring book. I like coloring books.

1:32:33 Thank you. Thank you very much. Excuse me. Mr. Mayor, I forgot one thing. Sure. I just want to let everybody know I've been getting some emails from some different agencies and governmental agencies, local, that there is some spam going around. So if you get a Google document and it's from the school district.

1:32:57 Right now, I just wouldn't open any Google, any Word document unless you know that you were expecting that. So that just happened today. So FYI. All right. Thank you. I will not go over what has already been presented for the meetings I attended. I did go to Deb Freevault's celebration. Very well attended. Thank you, Chief. You did a great job up there.

1:33:27 It was a great celebration of life. It really was. Last night I attended the MLR meeting. It was a very long meeting. A lot of good stuff happened. As a matter of fact, the stalwarts that are usually out in the cheap seats, they all left about halfway through. But anyway, we talked a lot about

1:33:57 The different projects, the multi-use facility, the MAC, aquatic center, and how to fund those things. I think we came to a consensus of how to best do that. Bonding is on the table if we have the money to do that, which will include, I'll call it private monies right now for lack of a better term. We are going to go through an aquatic feasibility study.

1:34:27 We didn't okay the amount last night. We wanted to get some more information, so they'll come back to MLR at its next meeting. And I think for the most part, MLR is getting some legs, and hopefully we're going to see some things happen here shortly. So what is it? Our 17th meeting, Rich, that you're presenting? 17th. All right.

1:34:59 Don't mess me up there. All right. So we look forward to that. It should be a very exciting meeting. With that, we'll go on to reports from commissions or departments. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Two quick items. The multi-use facility final environmental impact report is available on the town's website. It was released last Tuesday, April 25th.

1:35:33 That item will be considered by the Planning and Economic Development Commission next Wednesday here in Suite Z. The meeting starts at 1 o'clock. And then will be presented to the Town Council at your next meeting on May 17th. The other item is that the Town Cleanup Day, we have a date for it. It'll be June 3rd. So we pushed it a couple weeks just because of the additional snow. But we'll start having information on that presented in the next couple weeks. That's all I have.

1:36:03 I've got a quick question. Yeah, John. Sandra, I had a chance to look at the draft EIR, and it's an awesome document. How many pages is it? I don't know how many pages. A lot. It's a lot of pages, right? A lot of pages. Can you offer any friendly professional advice to a citizen? How to digest something like that? How do you, I mean, I can offer two cents, but what do you think? What's a good way for someone to just engage with something like that?

1:36:31 Well, I think starting with the, I mean, obviously the executive summary is kind of a high level. If you only have a couple minutes, read the executive summary because that really shows you exactly what the EIR, kind of everything is beyond that. Looking at the mitigation monitoring reporting program to see...

1:36:48 You quickly get to, it's just a table. It shows the mitigation measures. So it ties, it shows what the town is going to be doing as we move forward with the project. I think those are two key items. We do have a document that we give to commissioners. It's entitled How to Read an EIR. I can send that out to the council and I can put that on the website with the multi-use facility EIR. But it's really kind of guides you through, you know, if you're interested in this.

1:37:15 Focus on this section if you know. So every member of the public is interested in different sections of the EIR. Some people are interested in traffic, obviously reading the traffic section. But I can post that on the website and send that out to the council as well. I just find it interesting also to read the letters. The letters of comments that people submitted gives you a sense of where people are kind of coming from. That was pretty interesting. Most EIR work, is there pro or cons?

1:37:44 I mean, it's for people to make comment on what they think about the project, right? It's for the town. It's for the analysis of the impacts of the project. Right. And to provide the decision makers with the ability to see what the impacts are and to show whether or not they can be mitigated. In this instance, they can all be mitigated, and we have that program. So it's really an informational tool to allow the decision makers to make a decision on the project. Great. Thank you for...

1:38:10 The explanation. Sandra, how comfortable are we that this final product, because that's really what it is, is defensible and strong and solid? We're very comfortable. Yeah. To me, that's the bottom line in any EIR, is it defensible? Which is not to say that we're not going to get sued. No, no, I understand that. But I feel much more comfortably knowing that the professionals are telling me that it's... It's the beauty of California. Yeah.

1:38:39 Anything else? All right. Thanks, Andrew. Thank you. It's the play button. Thanks. Oh, I know you made it. Play button. Move it up. The discussion in the letter that you received was absolutely, Grady Dutton Public Works, sorry, was on target because we're actually going to talk about that in my...

1:39:27 Brief thing. And believe me, I don't have a lot of images here and we'll get to them pretty quickly. But when I got the copy of the letter, I thought, you know, I just met with Todd the day before and talked about most of the items on this list. I want to emphasize that the first thing we're doing is safety. That has to come first. Signs, snow stakes, things like that. And we're talking about the Main Street?

1:39:47 That's correct. Main Street, Old Mammoth Road, that letter you received. Really for us, it's town-wide because it's all over the place. As the snow melts, we're finding more and more. You've heard it. You've already seen it. What I'd like to do is come back to you in a couple of weeks. It's more of a defined plan for what we're going to do first and kind of the order of things. And if I could, if I could ask of you to give some thought to

1:40:09 Really the first bullet point here because Old Mammoth Road and Main Street, that is our front doorway. We've had many discussions over the years on what we can do to beautify that. There used to be turf there. I will still not recommend putting turf back in any place. That's just not, you know, water responsible, if you will. But there are other things we can do. We'll come back with some ideas and we'll make it an item in a couple of weeks so we can talk about it in more detail. On the same topic though, Town Cleanup Day, June 3rd, right? Stu?

1:40:39 June 3rd will be Town Cleanup Day, certainly later than most years. Usually does happen in May. We need to wait a couple of weeks so we can find a lot of things. But in advance of that, what I'd like to ask and what I'm starting to do on my walk back and forth to work, and this goes out to every resident, business owner, start now. Start picking stuff up. On my way to work this morning, I didn't have a bag that I found. Let me see. I think there were three pairs of gloves.

1:41:04 Various odd things, socks, plastic bags all over the place. And if everybody really just starts pitching in now in advance of Town Cleanup Day, it'll make a lot of difference before that. Grady, thanks for saying that. Thank you for saying that. Grady, if I leave my rake out front on your walk to work. No worries. I'll take care of it. I will put the rake back in your yard for you. Thank you. Exactly.

1:41:27 Every day should be cleanup day for our community. Sure. Well, absolutely. It's a tough thing. And I want to also warn you, however, that when we come back in a couple of weeks, a lot of this will be based on the resources that we have. We have a certain number of staff. We have a certain number of people working over the summer. I've encouraged Todd to look real hard at where we can contract things. As an example, no decisions yet, but I've told him, I said, look, let's look at the potholes. Is there...

1:41:55 Can we frankly contract that out? Because we have such limited resources. Is that something that takes a lot of our staff time where we can focus on other things, beautification, the signage and safety things, and somebody else can do that? We'll come back to you in a couple of weeks with a little bit more of a program and more information on that. What I have here, and it says Lakes Basin Open Preparations, the only thing we've done so far is

1:42:19 Have pictures taken. Everybody's talking about it. We've talked to the Forest Service. We're getting calls from concessionaires and everybody else already. But I wanted to share with you, most of these photographs were absolutely free, taken by an amateur. I thought that was a photograph of the snow. Yeah, that's Lake Mary right there. Exactly. And then there's three more at the end that were taken by Todd Murphy as well. And, you know, please jump in if you want to add anything, Councilmember, in terms of the locations.

1:42:47 I just want to give everybody a sense. Most of these were taken last week. A lot of it's probably melted a couple of feet, but then in shaded areas, it's going to take a lot longer. This snow is more dense than most years, you know, higher water content. It's just going to take a while, and I'm not going to spend a lot of time on these, but I want to give a sense of everybody. You know, stop if you have a question about a particular one, but there's a lot of snow up there. Those are the signs. In addition to the fact that you can't see them, they're probably broken.

1:43:17 Okay, so don't think that, gee, it's going to melt and the sign's going to be standing there looking great. It's not going to be that way. That's a very large sign down on the right-hand corner that, you know, is indistinguishable. How high is that sign that was poking out right there, do you think? I think that's probably eight feet to the top of the sign, but I don't, you know, there's a lot of signs. I'm not even sure which sign that is, frankly. You might know better than I will. But, again, I just want to give a sense for it. We do have a long meeting tonight. I don't want to spend a lot of time. I'll stop on a couple.

1:43:46 Everybody probably knows what that building usually looks like. A few rooftops. And then I will finish with, I'm not sure which one that is. Bathroom at Lake George. Okay. Those are the bathrooms at Hushu Lake. Again, I wanted to show this just because we are getting a lot of calls. And what I've asked, what I've asked the public and the concessioners, everybody is.

1:44:12 Don't ask again for two or three weeks. We're going up there weekly. The water district's going up. Everybody's going up. Everybody's taking pictures. But we can't really do a good assessment for another two or three weeks, and then we'll see. So there's just no, it's not reasonable. This is farther up, and I believe that's Crystal Crag, that one and that one. And at the very end, the water district is also up there. They have some sewage.

1:44:40 Pump stations up there, and SE actually has had to cut off the power to it. You can't quite see it on here too well, but that's a power line that the guy's almost ducking under, so SE had to cut the power off, so the water district's up there making sure that they have generators and have power so they don't have any issue, but it is serious. It was a two-month, you know, very intense effort, and, well, yes, everybody who came up here had a great time. Everybody else was...

1:45:06 Really working extra hard on that. So I appreciate the images. I really do, because I have not been up there personally. Todd goes up there all the time, so he's provided a few. But again, I just want to give the public a sense of that. Thank you. Thank you, Grady. Any questions for Grady? Well, just one comment. I think at the LTC, we're going to do a debrief of this winter with all the agencies.

1:45:28 The collaborative planning team, we talked also about getting all the agencies on the same page. I appreciate the need to market and the need to fish miss and do these kinds of things, but I think it's going to be incredibly important that all the agencies are singing from the same playbook. And I would be interested in marketing playing a constructive role in this. I know that's important to market and get people up here, but when...

1:45:54 You're driving people up here and the Forest Service and town staff and everybody else, they're going to have to be the bad guys saying not till Memorial Day, not till Fourth of July, not till all the rest of it. I would really encourage the tourism folks to start getting with the Forest Service and the town so that we can all be on the same page of what we're telling people because these are exceptional circumstances. So back in the day, I was on one of the original groups.

1:46:19 And this goes back probably to pre-town that came up with the original criteria for opening the Lakes Basin Road. One of the criteria, there's two spots on the Lakes Basin Road that are opposites. Where Old Mammoth Road hits the Lakes Basin Road is where the least amount of snow is because the wind comes up that valley. So it used to be until the road was halfway, pavement showing over half the road, you couldn't go up and plow it. I'm assuming today there's still probably six to eight feet of snow at that.

1:46:44 There's a picture in there that Grady skipped over at that exact intersection. You can't, there's not even any sign that there's a road. Yeah, and the other doesn't exist anymore. There used to be a very large drift every year right at Lake Mary, which is a high spot, but since it's groomed, that no longer exists. But if it were still there, I'm sure that it would still be at 50 feet. I want to say what John says. First, the Lakes Basin isn't closed. You can self-power a snowmobile up there, and a lot of people are.

1:47:14 But secondly, in terms of the road, until the lakes are obviously free enough so that they don't pose a real danger, I would not be in favor of going there. That criteria, I stop going to the meetings even though I get noticed on them because the criteria keeps getting thrown out the window. I would love to see us reestablish a criteria that makes sense. I know the businesses would like to be open for Memorial Day, but a hard criteria would be a good thing to have.

1:47:43 So that these questions don't occur every year, when are we going to open the road? I don't know if that's something, I mean, is that something we could look at? Well, the only thing I'd add to that, though, and it's, I agree, we'll look at that again and we'll see what happens this year, but one of the things that, I wouldn't say held us up, it was a necessary thing that the Forest Service had to do, was get a lot of trees out of there last year. Right. And that probably took an extra two weeks.

1:48:08 We think there's going to be more this year, and we think that's going to continue for a few years with the tree die off and everything else. So while the snow is a significant issue, even when it's gone, you know, we'll do that. One thing we are paying attention to, though, just so, again, it has to do with tourism as well, is when the half marathon gets here, we're going to do everything we can to make sure we can get runners up to horseshoe, because...

1:48:30 The pictures that we'll see hopefully nationally of a half marathon starting in the snow and finishing in 65 degree weather will be pretty impressive. So we're going to continue to do that. But again, the trees is a part that's a big unknown for us. And we have to take that into consideration. One of my issues has been, and last year was a particularly onerous one for the people who wanted to use it. We plowed the basin road.

1:48:55 And then it stayed closed for so long. We started plowing before opening day, which precluded the snowmobilers from using the road, which is the only thing they're allowed on. So it actually diminished our recreational capacity instead of increasing it, which is the idea behind opening the road. So we just need to take all things into consideration. Thank you. Any other comments, questions? Betsy.

1:49:20 Good evening, Council. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. The Commission met yesterday, so I just wanted to give you a really brief report out of our meeting. We received our standing update on the proposed multi-use facilities at Mammoth Creek Park West. That will be a big topic this month. We had a brief discussion about the EIR and the response to comments, as well as the same presentation on financing options that MLR received. The Commission remains strongly supportive of the project. We're very anxious and eager to move.

1:49:49 Move forward. And our consensus was to support the financing option that the mayor mentioned that MLR also moved forward last evening. Since I unfortunately won't be able to stay for your entire meeting this evening, I do want to provide feedback from the commission on two of your agenda items. We discussed these yesterday.

1:50:09 We had an update on the proposed 17-18 Parks and Rec Department budget. The entire commission is very supportive of the proposed budget, and we're very eager to see that proposed parks maintenance and snow removal position move forward. We think that's very exciting. The commission is also extremely pleased to see the proposal for $300,000 for parks infrastructure repairs included in the possible third quarter budget adjustments. We really cannot tell you just how desperately we really need

1:50:39 Thank you, Betsy. Any questions for Betsy? Nope. Comments? Thanks. Thank you.

1:51:06 Thank you, Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Department. I'll be very quick. I do want to just take a little bit of time to applaud, as Grady's mentioning, we are working extremely hard, I think, the whole town to kind of get everything ready, summer. If you have been down to Whitmore Recreation Area, the community is there.

1:51:23 Just to let you know, Shady Rest is not open. We're a couple of weeks away. We think that's kind of been May. So everybody's at Whitmore. So all our entire staff are pretty much down there. We've got three full-time staff down there pretty much all the time. We've got three, four seasonal staff down there. It's pretty busy. So if you've been down there, that's where the community is if they're not here. But again, they're doing a great job. Whitmore Pool, they fill the pool.

1:51:48 Staying in the pool. We're heating the water. Scheduled to open May 8th, which is Monday, for lap swim. So we're still on schedule for that. How was the swim? What's that? How was your swim? Didn't you take a swim? Not yet. I thought you might have tried it out. I'll be there on opening day. I thought you might have tried it out. I'll be there on opening day. Yeah. But everyone's very excited, obviously, to get the water and get summer going. So, again, just really want to applaud Parks Maintenance staff. They're working exceptionally hard.

1:52:15 And then hopefully once we can get those facilities open and operating, we can move back to Shady and back into town. Town cleanup day, I think we mentioned June 3rd, just want to mention that again, that's Saturday, June 3rd. We talked about the pool, that's May 8th. Fish stocking, we're finalizing that agreement today, tomorrow. Tentatively, we're trying to get up to the lakes basin by June 13th.

1:52:39 To start stocking the Lakes Basin, that program will run through October 5th. This is a joint funded program with Mammoth Lakes Tourism in the town of Mammoth Lakes. This is £19,000, just over $104,000 in those four lakes. That's a really big program.

1:52:54 That'll kick off June 13, fingers crossed. You've all probably heard last day was school is June 9th. The school district received their waiver. That has a big impact for us because our summer camps begin the following Monday on June 12th. So that's all on schedule to carry on. Also I want to just update the council. Our department's currently recruiting for a program facilities coordinator. That current person is leaving the town, which is unfortunate.

1:53:23 Lindsay Lyon did an exceptional job with our many programs, program facility coordinators, manuals. She oversaw the opening day of our summer camp registration, multiple projects. So I just want to recognize Lindsay for all the hard work for the department. That's all I had. Any questions? Any questions? Comments? John? Quick question. Between Andy and Stuart, any update on the Momentum contract? I think Andy Momentum has it. Okay.

1:53:52 So hopefully we'll see something this week or next week. Hopefully. I'll follow up with Jamie tomorrow on a phone call, just to make sure she's got everything, we understand it. Pushing as hard as we can. Yeah, good, thank you. You're very welcome. Real quickly, on the cleanup. We've put together little events and what have you. Are you thinking about doing something like that again?

1:54:17 I think Sandra mentioned briefly we've got our first meeting next week. We're trying to kind of kick this off and just get a good understanding of the scope of the project. We know there's a lot of trash out there. As Grady says, grab a bag, pick it up. Right. But we would like to come back to you on the next meeting. Yeah, that'd be great if you would. A more thorough update. All right. You're welcome. Appreciate it. Thank you. Okay. Seeing no more reports, we'll go on to staff presentations. Grady?

1:54:54 We're going to receive an update from staff and approve maintenance and matching fund scenario and general project description for the Federal Lands Access Program or FLAP grant for the reconstruction of the Reds Meadow Road. Did a little icon, but we'll do fine in this size. Thanks. I can't see it. No problem. Thanks, Joel.

1:55:22 We are working through this week, finalizing all the flat paperwork for the submittal that will happen before May 12th. At the last council meeting, we committed that we would come back to you this meeting with some decision points, frankly. We want you to know precisely what we're going to submit. So I'd like to run through, firstly, just kind of a brief overview of the project again.

1:55:46 I've seen this for quite a while. You know, we had an update many months ago from Forest Service, but we haven't talked about it. I will keep it very brief, again, respecting everybody's time and the long agenda. This is a few slides that I borrowed from the Forest Service presentation that I did a few months ago, and again, it's just a very quick reminder. The project itself starts up at Minaret.

1:56:08 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:56:16 Very interested to see what it looks like in a month or so when the snow gets off of there and what kind of damage, if any, exists. We're hopeful that with the snow melt, it happens in a manner that doesn't take out more of the road or something like that. We don't know. It's still a Forest Service road, not our responsibility, but we will be there helping them get the snow off it, helping it open as quickly as possible. The red area down below is another five and a half miles or so of a road that really just needs to be rehabilitated in place.

1:56:46 And again, I want to commend them because we would not be here today without their efforts. They have spent and are spending approximately $740,000 over the last year and over the next few months doing the

1:57:09 Preliminary Design and the Environmental Studies and I just want to recognize that commitment to really the region to actually take that and happen because this wouldn't happen without that effort. There's no way the town would have been able to front that kind of an effort to get to this point. They went through a great number of alternatives analysis to get to where they are today. One of the key things that I wanted to point out, however, this is a couple of cross sections of what the road's going to look like and while it's not real legible,

1:57:38 What you can see is that on the right-hand side is the hillside going up, and there's very little or no grading work up the slope.

1:57:45 Which means as you're driving down or up the road, what you'll see is just the road itself. You won't see a lot of disturbance. On the left or downhill side, there will be a series of either graded slopes or retaining walls that will really only be visible from down in the forest. There's a couple of trails down there. You might catch some views of it. But this was done both from a construction standpoint, constructability standpoint, and also from an environmental standpoint, it causes much less potential issues with the visibility.

1:58:14 Again, preliminary project design, all these things are available in much larger format. The left-hand side shows the green and smaller areas that show where we're widening the road and the slopes are, and the blue is just a rehabilitation in place, which goes all the way down to Reds Meadow Resort. The overall project estimates, this is what the Forest Service produced.

1:58:38 This includes, these numbers do include, the uphill bike lane, so when I get to the staff report later, I'll explain a little bit more about that, but I just wanted to get a chance for everybody to see the overall. NEPA CEQA, they are launching into that. They've already completed a number of the technical studies, and they're preparing the NEPA and CEQA documents themselves, which will provide that foundation for the permitting.

1:59:04 Next steps. I'm not going to walk through each of these. The bottom line is you go to the bottom, and if all goes well and we are awarded the FLAP grant, construction could begin in 2021. More than likely, it's a two-season effort in discussions with Federal Highways and also their consultant, CH2M, which has done a very, very good job. By the way, they've done this all over the country, so it's a very good firm. We've taken into account just about everything we could think of.

1:59:31 We do anticipate being two seasons, but the road would be open all the time every day. So it's being designed in such a way where we don't have long-term closures. There may be closures in the middle of the day for a couple of hours, but that is not unusual, and if we manage that with bus traffic anyway, which is what we're doing today, it should not be a big impact at all to the visiting public, which is one of the key goals. They understand that. I want to get to one other exhibit.

2:00:02 And I'll try to do it without Joel's help this time. Watch this. Bottom one or top one, Joel, you call. Very nice. Good job. And make it smaller. Now I got it. Got game. And back to bigger. Yep. One other exhibit that we're going to include in the packet, this was provided, MLTPA worked on it and Joel worked on it to try to demonstrate some of the other amenities that are down in that Reds Meadow Valley.

2:00:34 The exhibits that Federal Highways put together, they showed the Inyo National Forest, they showed Devil's Post Pile, but they didn't really show a number of the other amenities that are important to the FLAP application that are down there. John Muir Trail, of course, Pacific Coast Trail, the PAC stations, everything else that are really important to that, all the trailheads, all of our bus...

2:00:56 Transit stops. All those things are important to the analysis, and we're going to include this in there so we can demonstrate some of those. One of the things that happened in our last FLAP application, which was for Lakes Basin, if you'll recall a couple of years ago, was there wasn't enough...

2:01:09 At that time of a concessions at the end of the road, as they called it. I mean, it was good, but it wasn't quite enough to meet their criteria. It's much different in Reds Meadow Valley because there's just about everything you can think of in terms of, you know, gateways to the wilderness and Devil's Postpile itself. So we want to make sure that's included. One thing that is on one of these two exhibits is also, however, the

2:01:32 The broadband, which we certainly hope to be part of the project, we've already started discussions with federal highways about making that part of the project in the future. We think it's a key thing and it's something that nationally and regionally is being discussed at all times. We don't think it belonged necessarily in the flat package because it's a road project, but I wanted to make sure that everybody was aware that that's going to be part of the discussion all the way through this because... I go there because people can't get me.

2:02:00 If you don't take your phone with you, you should be fine, but we want to have that opportunity. So we do have an exhibit that we'll include in the package. It won't have the broadband on it, but we did appreciate the efforts to put this together because it really shows a lot better than just the road project. Some of the amenities that are down in that area. So thank you. To run through some of the things in the staff report and then to ask the specific questions and recommendations that we have in there,

2:02:28 Under analysis and discussion, the first is just an estimate for the project itself. One of the things that Federal Highways and everybody recommended we do is make sure we had a scalable project. What we're looking at as really a preferred project is about $23 million, which would do the upper...

2:02:47 Two-lane, we call it, option. It was just not a matter of just widen it barely, not one lane, but we really think that from a safety standpoint, accessibility standpoint, that upper two and a half miles should be two-laned. That's a cost of about $16.7 million. To rehabilitate the lower 5.8 miles is, again, about $6.3 million. So we think that's what we want to recommend as the project. To make it scalable, because there is only 30, only.

2:03:16 $32.9 million available in this flap cycle. To make it scalable, we would be very interested in the upper 2.5 miles because that's what's going to stop visitors from getting down to the valley floor. The lower, it's not in great shape. It's got a lot of pothills. It's got its problems itself, but without the upper 2.5 miles, it's not going to happen. I want to mention that if we are successful with the full

2:03:44 We'll move forward as quick as we can or federal highways will. If we go with scenario B or if that's what we're lucky enough to be awarded, the town would not, I would not recommend that we accept the entire road. We'd only accept that portion where the road is being rehabilitated. I mean, I couldn't stand before you and recommend that we accept 5.8 miles of road that hasn't been fixed. I mean, that doesn't make any sense. So they know that and that'll be in the application as well.

2:04:13 The thing that will be discussed, I'm sure, on Monday at LTC is that in the project, the Forest Service and Federal Highways did look at an uphill bike lane. That's a cost of about $2 million. It's staff's opinion, and it's our recommendation to you that we not include that in the project. While it is...

2:04:35 We will talk to Federal Highways about our complete

2:04:54 Streets Edict in California and what we have to do. And if they will allow us to do so, we'll make it a, you know, we'll make it a complete street as best we can with sharrows and other signage so that bicyclists can safely get up that road. But we are not recommending that at this time. On maintenance costs, which would be our first discussion and recommendation, we're still, let me back up to the estimate for just one second. When we actually submit the FLAP grant,

2:05:22 Next Friday, the number that's in that might be a million dollars lower or a million dollars higher than this 23 million. The reason for that is they have a very complicated formula that we have to follow. Our estimates are based on what we think it's going to cost. They have a certain contingency of 10% they're required to put in. Forest Service already has 25% contingency in the construction dollars, so we have to kind of balance that and see where we are. They also include the final design costs.

2:05:52 Forest Service has already paid for all the preliminary designs, so there's some juggling there. We're not concerned with that because if we're lucky enough to get past, or fortunate enough, not lucky, to get past the first step, the first thing we do is the town has to write a check.

2:06:06 to the group for $10,000, and then it goes back to central federal lands highways, and we sit down with them over a number of meetings and sort it out. In other words, they go through everything with a fine-tooth comb. They'll make recommendations as to tweaks to the project. We'll look at cost estimates for various things, and at that point, the estimate might then change again by a million dollars, plus or minus. So I don't want anybody to be concerned if the actual application says $24 million instead of $23 or maybe $22.

2:06:34 We're working through their format that's required to put in for the grant. And we'll have that done in just a couple of days and be prepared to submit.

2:06:44 On the maintenance costs, we are still confident that $100,000 per year for 25 years will suffice. And by suffice, I mean, it's a high-level maintenance program. It's not we build it and in 10 years we come back and see how it's doing. That means that in three years we do a slurry seal or a fog seal. In five years we do other things. In 10 years we do other things. So it's a full program. And again, I want to thank ESTA for stepping up and talking about and approving a resolution to increase the fares down to...

2:07:13 Meadow by a dollar a head for adult fare, which should provide about at least $60,000 a year on that. The local match requirement, we are very happy to have been able to identify toll credits for the local match. And what a toll credit is, is the state of California collects tolls all over the place, whether it's bridges, toll roads, everything else, they put it in the bank. If we were a...

2:07:41 MPO, which is a municipal planning organization, we would then compete for some of those toll credit monies in order to use them for grants and use them for other things. Because we're not, because we're rural, basically there are sufficient funds in those coffers at the state that if we ask for $2.7 million match,

2:08:00 The chances are way, way above 90%. I wouldn't say 100% because nothing's ever certain, but it should be 100% that we will receive those and be able to use the toll credits for the full match. So again, no dollars out of the town's pocket. Certainly we're spending a lot of staff time and we'll take a look at that. But we're satisfied that that'll work. Having said that, there are three other sources for possible match funds that I go through in the staff report.

2:08:26 The first is the National Park Service, and I'll return to the decision points after I run through it all. The National Park Service has sent us a letter saying, look, we're willing to put in $500,000 towards the match for this project. Very frankly, when we started discussing this with them a number of months ago, they were really not supportive of the two-lane option for the upper 2.5 miles, not at all. After meeting with us and going through the preliminary design and working with them, what they're saying now is, look,

2:08:56 We'll support it. We'll put in the $500,000, but we really want to work with the town on the Inner Valley Shuttle. What really happens when the bus isn't running? What's happening late season, early season, and what they're really looking forward for in their letter as it was written is a commitment from the town and the Forest Service. We certainly can't speak...

2:09:17 Speak to for any national forest, but a commitment that will at least work with them on a solution for that. And that's something that verbal we've told them we're going to do anyway. We do it every year now. And as we said, that Intervalley Shuttle was a one-year operation, but it's something we need to look at long-term anyway. Second is the Forest Service. The Forest Service has also said, look, we also have $500,000 available for an overmatch.

2:09:41 But they also suggested that they would prefer to use those funds for other projects in the area. They're already developing plans to do some improvements of the Minaret Vista. They'd like to use this $500,000 in the area. So again, our staff's comment and recommendation is that let's work with the Forest Service. Let's use their funds not for an overmatch, but instead for those other projects.

2:10:03 But get a commitment from them in writing that says it will be used in that area of Reds Meadow Road, whether it's trailhead work, whether it's down below Minaret Vista, but really strongly say, look, we'll accept it, not as an overmatch, but...

2:10:16 We just want you to make sure you spend the money here. I have to mention, as in all the federal projects, I'm assuming it applies for park service monies as well, but the forest service funds are contingent on future transportation bills as they always are. I mean, that's the same with FAA funds and everything we're dealing with. So they can state at the local and the regional level that they're committing this, but until the budgets pass in Washington, the money's not there until it's actually allocated. So that's forest service.

2:10:45 The last one for a possible overmatch is local transportation commission. We brought it up to that group before. They seemed very interested in participating. And when staff take a look at that, we thought, you know, an overmatch is great and very important. Having said that, right now the commitment...

2:11:02 of the town to the maintenance dollars of $100,000. Our share is right around $40,000. One of the questions at the last meeting was, what's the town taxpayer, if you will, participating in this project? Right now it's $40,000 a year for 25 years, unless we can find some other sources. So staff is ready to recommend that town council, if you'd like to agree to it, we'll bring it to LTC on Monday and say, look, rather than give us $500,000 an overmatch,

2:11:30 We want a commitment that if we have a pavement management system in place, which we do, we can use some LCC funds to the tone of, say, $25,000 a year over time and work with them for maintenance of that road. So that significantly decreases the taxpayer dollars. Having said that,

2:11:50 Any money you take from LTC one place isn't available for something else. There's always a balance. It doesn't just appear. So if we ask them to do that, they set aside that, or even the $500,000, it's not available for some other project. I mention it specifically because one of the things that...

2:12:07 LTC and Mono County have been very supportive of is our Upper Main Street project and everything else, frankly, and they've put off some of their decisions on Mono County roads and their maintenance needs in order to make this happen, and we'd like to support that as well as a staff. So in discussion with LTC on Monday, we're going to say, look, which is more important, and we're not going to...

2:12:28 I mean, they could come back and say, well, look, we'd like to support it for a million dollars, and that's up to LTC board. We're not suggesting a specific amount, but we do appreciate their participation. So to go back real quickly on the actual recommendations that we'd like to hear, either a consensus or, you know, a vote on whatever you'd like to do on it. The first one is...

2:12:49 We'd like to just acknowledge that you're accepting that $100,000 a year is a commitment we're ready to make with the understanding $60,000 comes from ESTA. The other $40,000 comes from either town funds, general funds, possibly gas tax, although that's something we have to work out because this is in Madeira County. So it's hard to, we're going to add it to our road mileage through a highway easement, but it's not in our county, so I'm not sure how that'll work out.

2:13:17 But the option of either that or going to LTC for some money. So however you'd like to do it, Mr. Mayor, but if you'd like to discuss these one at a time, that's probably the first item is just kind of an acceptance that, yes, we understand it's $100,000 here, $60,000 plus will come from ESTA and the rest from town funds. Okay. Grady, thank you very much. What I'd like to do is that there's any questions for Grady? Sure. Absolutely. Okay. And then, well, just questions.

2:13:47 We're going to go to the public for comment and bring it back for deliberation. Thank you. Motion. So, Bill. So, Grady, I've been very supportive of this project all along. And the Forest Service is saying they want to use $500,000 rather than as an overmatch to do projects in the area. And, you know, I've been talking about us being good partners and not just their agenda, but an overall agenda that helps us all.

2:14:16 There are a couple of very major trails that aren't even listed as trails, I don't believe, on the Forest Service's books. John perhaps could tell us more whether they are or not. One of them is a hiking trail that starts up at the pay shed and basically follows a watershed that goes all the way down and comes out sort of between Starkweather and Upper Soda Springs Campground.

2:14:40 The other is what was the old Starkweather Road that went to the Starkweather Cabin, the Starkweather Mine. In the wintertime, we call it Mr. Toad's Wild Ride. There is an old road base, the Dirt Road. It is the original road going down into Reds Meadows. The road didn't exist where it is today. It existed somewhere else. That is used as a mountain bike trail. It comes out about two-thirds of the way up the two-lane section. John, have you ridden that trail? Yeah. I know currently it is in...

2:15:08 Disrepair, and the Forest Service only allows it for something like four weeks a year, and I'm not sure what all the reasons are, but if we're going to work on some things with their money in that area, I would love to see those be added as system trails, or as Mammoth trails, and we get Joel working on them. Where'd he go? Oh, there he is. Because while we can't afford the two, the bike lane coming back uphill,

2:15:38 Most of that isn't necessary if the old Starkweather Road is rehabilitated because it's a switchback. Its grade really isn't any greater than the road that's there into a single back mountain bike trail or single track with a larger operating season. So fix whatever that issue is. So my other problem is in the design of the road, is it going to cut off access to either of those? Has that been looked at?

2:16:07 We know sometimes Forest Service loves to close things. It's my understanding that the widened road for the upper two and a half miles would not cut off access to any of those existing trails. And in response to your question about other projects the Forest Service might look at, it's our recommendation that we get out in front of them and start suggesting things to them before they have a list.

2:16:29 In other words, look, we're participating in this. We're going to be taking this road. Let's present something to them and then do as much as we can to encourage them to do something that we think benefits the region the best. And to add to that list that we might want to pursue down there would be day-use parking in the existing campgrounds. It used to exist. Mr. Regabruga tells me it didn't, but he hasn't been here as long as I. It did used to exist in every campground, and it is very important.

2:16:57 Access into those campgrounds. Our buses don't go in there. So the fishing access and everything else for families is severely curtailed. So those are the kind of things I would love to see us get into discussion. I'm not trying to push them or say they have to do this. I'm just saying some serious discussions on things that are going to be beneficial to the tourism economy and help us spread the people which lessens the impact on the post pile parking lot.

2:17:23 It is the only major parking lot down there at this point. So everybody that goes parks in that lot. All right. Thank you. Any other questions for Grady? I have a quick question. Yes. How much stronger is the grant if we include the half million overmatch?

2:17:45 I wouldn't say that's impossible to answer, but nearly so, because we don't know what other people are going to submit. We don't know yet what other projects are there, whether they're going to have an overmatch. I would say that the fact that we have several agencies supporting this, LTC specifically, that's really good, Park Service and Forest Service. And even if it's not used as an overmatch, we'll make sure that in the cover letter and the documentation, we point out that, look, even if...

2:18:12 Forest Service land isn't an overmatch. It's a participation in the region. How much stronger? It's just so hard to tell without seeing what else is out there. We do have some indication that there are other projects that are going to be at least $10 million that will be in the running. So it's going to be a points basis. I'm not sure what they're doing. But I think the fact that if it's $500,000 from here and participation in other projects there, that all helps. Again, how much it helps.

2:18:42 Do we have letters from all? We don't have letters from everybody yet. We've made requests. We have letters from the Forest Service, Park Service, ESTA. We're requesting one from LTC on Monday. And even after the package goes in, we're going to hopefully get letters from Mono County, from Madeira, as we've talked about. We just haven't had the opportunity to finish that process yet. We'll continue on that. Very good. Thank you. Any other questions? Grady, in your recommendation, you kind of bifurcate it out upper road and lower road.

2:19:10 And the recommendation coming forward is that the upper portion would be widened to two lanes. Correct. I haven't been down there in a little bit, so my mind's escaping me. The lower portion of the road is already two-lane, correct? That's correct. It's already two lanes, and the project just includes a rehab in place. No widening, no realignments, just rebuild. So the lower 5.8 would just be a rehab of the existing. Correct. The more expensive portion would be the top half based on widening from what it is currently. Correct.

2:19:38 The 10 is $6.3 million. The lower portion is $6.3 million to rehab it in place, correct? Gotcha. Okay, thank you. John? A couple quick questions. Grady, who would be the lead agency for CEQA? Well, the NEPA would certainly be the Forest Service and Federal Highways for CEQA. It would be local, so the discussion has been that that would be the town. Okay. And do we have, I'm assuming we'll have budget allocated for that, for the work we're going to have to do?

2:20:08 So far we haven't set a lot aside because they're doing all the technical studies and they've said that they will cover the CEQA portions, at least the documentation and stuff. We may have to do something at the end to finish it off, but they're taking on the efforts to make sure that the technical studies, the biology and air quality and everything are part of their analysis, which is unusual. Sure, that's all the specialist stuff, but just to be clear, the town would be the lead agency for CEQA? Correct. Okay, I just want to make sure that...

2:20:35 We go round and round on that sometimes, but I think this is not something that we're going to be... I think it's properly us, but we'll be able to tear off of and reuse most of the NEPA documents. Understood. But I think we may have a lot of work going forward with the town. We're going to see a lot of joint CEQA-NEPA efforts, and I just want to make sure that it's clear what our role and responsibility is in this stuff.

2:20:56 There's no sort of vagaries in terms of what the staff understands to be our obligation for those things. And frankly, I absolutely agree. We'll have to take a look at that the next time we talk to them. But we're actually quite pleased that they took on at least the technical studies because there are things that CEQA looks at that NEPA doesn't and they've taken that on. Okay. And in terms of the bike lane thing, would the road be a class three classification, a share the road classification?

2:21:25 That's what we will propose to federal highways. Again, once they take on the design, whether we end up with the road or not, they're going to do what they think is right. We're going to suggest that to them. We want to make sure that we do the share of the road and that we do it as best as we can, yes. Because I think it's one thing just to not build a bike lane, but it's something else to assume they're not precluding bicycles or forbidding bicycles, right? Absolutely. Okay.

2:21:54 I think I have some questions for deliberation about the trail stuff when we get back to that. I think on the National Park Service letter, for purposes of clarification, the only thing that we're committing the town to do is to talk with the partners. We're not committing any funding. We're not committing any outcomes. We're just saying we're willing to talk with you. Is that correct? That's correct. That's why I actually...

2:22:23 Cut and pasted, quoted their letter precisely in here, and I think I included the letter two weeks ago, and if not, I'll get it to you, but it was very clear in quotes that we would commit to working with the Park Service and Forest Service in a collaborative effort to provide solutions and on. That's not a commitment to spend any money or even to do what they suggest. It just means we'll sit down at a table and we'll work with each other. Okay. I have some thoughts on that. We get back to deliberation also. And then, okay,

2:22:55 I think that's it. All right. Thank you. Just clarification. Scenario B on here? Yes. Thank you. Yes, there was a typo when it went from one page to the next. Scenario B is 16.7 at $16,700,000, not a flat $16 million. So thank you. Right. Just a clarification. Okay. I'll go to the public now. Anybody would like to make any comments or questions on this, please come up to the podium. State your name.

2:23:26 What happened to the boot? I'm out of the boot. All right. All right. But shoes hurt me, and I'm in transition. My name is Mark Davis. I'm a very avid cyclist. It is a bit disappointing that we can't afford a bike lane. It would be wonderful. But the trail situation, I was involved with that.

2:23:52 It is one of those very peculiar things. It's parallel to the snowmobiles using the Lakes Basin after the permittee has vacated it. We only get to use that one trail and only after the bus system has been pulled. There have been years that it was open literally three days. And even optimistically, it's only a month and after the tourists are gone.

2:24:22 So the current situation with that trail contributes very little to the solution. I would appreciate perhaps trying to make that more of a year-round thing. There are two non-wilderness trails in that area and well over a dozen wilderness trails. The two non-wilderness trails are the Starkweather Trail, which was the original road.

2:24:47 And there's a trail closely parallel to the section that won't be widened and parallels it from Agnew's Meadows to Red's Meadow. Perhaps we could think a little outside the box and push for a full season use of those two trails for mountain biking opportunities down in Red's Meadow, which will complement the bus system that we've built.

2:25:12 Thank you, Mark. Thanks.

2:25:42 Any questions for Mark? Comments? Thank you. Any other public comment? Seeing none, I'll bring it back for a deliberation or a motion. Mr. Mayor, if I could, just a couple things to add for the deliberation process. The first thing is on to Bill's comments, I think that given the kind of the specific nature of the FLAP application and a lot of this stuff is around the technical parts of it,

2:26:13 I think it's probably not appropriate to get into those kind of specific things with the Forest Service is doing with the half million dollars, whatever that turns into. But I think it's important to make clear to the Forest Service, we have an MOU with the Forest Service now for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And whether we're doing things at the Minaret Vista, if that were to become a Mammoth Lakes Trail System trailhead, that any of these projects going forward, I think it's the expectation of the town with the resources and the capacity that we have.

2:26:41 That these will be Mammoth Lakes Trail System type projects. I think that's, unless there's any thought from the council, I think that's an important thing. Whatever we're going to do with this stuff, it's those kinds of things. The second thing is that my understanding is that the map that's shown here are all the system trails down in the valley. Many of them have been abandoned by the Forest Service. But because they still exist as system trails, the opportunities for rehabilitation and all the rest of it is there.

2:27:08 And the data was developed and shared in this map to make sure that Federal Highways knows where these trails intersect or interface with those roads. So if there's opportunities to do an access point, a pullout, like the work that John Milney did on Lake Space and Path, that all that data and information is there so that that can happen. So I think as we go down the road with this, whatever that half a million dollars given, how the matches and the overmatches work, if the Forest Service does have half a million bucks to do some things.

2:27:35 I think we can, the staff can advise us, we can come back and maybe prioritize some things. Yeah, that's for the future. That'd be the future, yeah. The second thing is, I just want to thank staff for clarifying the National Park Service letter. I'm a little concerned that, and I don't see any need to change the National Park Service language, but I think they have, the devil's post file is a very robust.

2:28:00 Very thorough National Park Service management plan that a lot of people in this community put a lot of work and a lot of effort to. And we're coming into a kind of a partnering opportunity with the post pile. And the only thing that we keep hearing about is the need to do the Intervalley shuttle, which the town paid for.

2:28:17 But there are a lot of projects in that management plan that would connect the post pile to the town and the community that we're frankly not hearing a whole lot about. And I don't see any need to change this language, but I think as staff, as part of your conversations, to say, look, we're eager to hear from the superintendent, from the post pile, how we can start really working on some of these things. And it would be nice to hear some of those.

2:28:42 Those opportunities coming forward that we could recommend to the town to work on. And I think finally on the issue of that map, the National Scenic Trails, the Pacific Crest Trail, the John Muir Trail, these are the things that have standing when we're applying for federal grants and federal monies for a variety of different projects. I really commend and thank staff and Joel for putting this thing together. These have financial opportunities for us. So is there anything else that we should be putting on that map? Is everybody good with it?

2:29:11 Do you think we should have that trail you're talking about? It's on there. It's on there, okay. All that stuff is on there. It's all on there. So what my comment was meant to do is to remind all of us that we need to be in this conversation. Right, no question, no question. I just want to make sure that when we present the grant that we have everything on there that we should have on there.

2:29:31 Yeah, I don't want to commit all these town resources and have them come back later and say, well, we're going to eliminate this parking and we're going to do this to get people gone and I want to make sure we're moving forward as partners. And that, it was created based on conversations we had with the Federal Highways people where they said, oh yeah, bring us the data of where all the system trails, even if they're abandoned, they're not using them anymore, let us know where all that stuff is so they can be mindful as they do the projects. We don't have those kinds of problems. Okay, so as the flap grant.

2:30:00 I only have one comment and it's probably too late to make the change. If it was me personally and I had to reduce it rather than just taking the top two miles, I would have reduced some of that two lane to single lane and continued with the rehab of the lower two lane section.

2:30:20 But I don't think we have the time to go through and rehash all of this now. And I say that for some critical reasons. There are springs that used to come up in the middle of that lower road before they made it Tulane that have not been mitigated or have not had fill put over them or anything else. After a year like this year, we're going to see those things popping back up and see that lower road floating away.

2:30:41 Remember, it hasn't been two lanes all that long, although it is in terrible shape because there's no base under the pavement. There's no, so it is a critical piece. So I don't know if that's something that scenario C can be added. How do we, when we go to the flap folks and we're presenting this, are we presenting two scenarios or are you asking us to just come in with one or? We will present.

2:31:08 Scenario A and Scenario B, one fallback position. And while I agree that the lower road is in pretty bad shape and it's going to get worse, looking at the upper road in its condition and look at the safety issues, and there haven't been a huge number of accidents, but there have been accidents over the years in that area. Engineering staff and talking to Federal Highways, CH2M.

2:31:32 They're all in agreement that completely rehabbing the upper two and a half miles to a full two lane is by far the highest priority. Again, respecting the comments about the lower, that upper just really needs to be two lane for safety, accessibility. Yeah, there's just a couple of areas that are going to be hideously expensive to two lane. They're sheer rock walls, but we're going to be blasting like hard rock miners.

2:31:58 Well, again, actually, if you dive into the document, we have the 15% design drawings, and those two cross-section I showed, most of what we're doing is fill. We are not cutting the upper hillside, we're filling out and really retaining the walls out, and that actually reduced the cost significantly. We had a cost estimate about...

2:32:18 Four months ago, that was $6 million higher than this. So they advanced to 15% design. They looked at this option. It got much cheaper because there wasn't going to be as much blasting. So CHCM has done a great job. So, Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion. I want to make sure that our local newspaper gets the spelling right. I'm so slow on the uptake. I apologize. Ted Carlton.

2:32:44 Does this mean that we maintain the road in perpetuity if we accept this money? That's correct. That's correct? Just like scenic bypass, it's the same situation. That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Okay. So as far as the flap grant, I think we have consensus. I don't think we need a motion to move forward on that. What we do need a motion on is the maintenance contribution.

2:33:15 Well, do we need a motion on the resolution, right? Well, we actually did that last time. There actually was a resolution last time to complete and file the application. This is just some clarifications that we'd like direction on, whether it's a motion or consensus. But the first one, again, is just accept that it's $100,000 at the likely local...

2:33:37 Likely town share of that is about $40,000 a year, and we'd just like to make sure that that's recognized. I'll be happy to entertain a motion if you'd like to present one, John. Okay, so I would move that the council accept and approve the maintenance and matching funding scenarios as presented in the general description for federal lands access flap grant for the reconstruction of Reds Meadow Road and to direct staff to submit the application this week.

2:34:07 Motion is second. Any further discussion? Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

2:34:23 And again, I hate to burden you with several votes, but these are very distinct items that I'd like to make sure we're clear on. The second one is the National Park Service. It's just a matter of accepting their letter, if you will, and saying, okay, we'll accept this $500,000 overmatch with the understanding that the town is committing to working with them and the Forest Service in a collaborative effort as is described. So moved. Second. Motion and second. Further discussion? Roll call.

2:34:54 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes by zero. We'll move on to the United States Forest Service. The third one is just an indication that, and we do have a preference, we could go back to the Forest Service and say, no, we want it for an overmatch, and they would agree to that.

2:35:15 Staff has recommended that instead we very strongly work with the MOU to encourage them to spend that money on other projects in the area, whether it be trailheads, trails improvements, and they work with us on that. But again, whichever you like, we're recommending that other projects, I think, will get more bang for our buck over time. I would make that motion with the wording that we strongly urge them to work with us on the allocation of that $500,000 in the valley. That'll help.

2:35:46 Okay. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Further discussion? Just, it's understood that the MOU between the Town, the Forest Service, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is not something that is going to be ignored or, I mean, that needs to be part of the, I mean, that's an existing MOU. That's where we start.

2:36:09 Right. And that's when we start with these discussions. If it's not going to be a Mammoth Lakes Trail system, we need to know some rationale why it's not. Correct. Okay. Roll call. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. You want to go on the LTC? And the last one with LTC, there's really two parts. One is...

2:36:32 We haven't suggested a precise amount for the overmatch. It's not really covered in here. We were going to let LTC talk about that and come up with a number themselves, if you will, if you'd like to suggest one, we can. But the real question that I have in the staff report is should we use it for an overmatch or should we use it for...

2:36:50 A commitment for future major maintenance. And our recommendation from staff would be option two, which would reduce the long-term commitment of the town, at least for the first 25 years, from approximately $40,000 a year down to maybe $15,000 a year, depending on that amount. So it's really the question, would you prefer to use it as an overmatch or long-term maintenance? Staff would recommend option two. We haven't suggested an amount. We'd like LTC to talk about that Monday. Okay, let's have a discussion on that.

2:37:20 Any issues? I'm comfortable with using it for the maintenance piece. Maintenance piece? Me too. Okay. Everybody is? I'm comfortable with maintenance. Okay. I'll then entertain a motion then. Mr. Mayor, I move that the council direct staff to pursue option two in discussions with the LTC with regards to matching funds for this project. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Further discussion? None. Roll call, please.

2:37:50 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. Thank you very much, Grady. Okay. That'll take us on to consent agenda. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to pull on number 7. Okay. We'll pull number 7. Let me read them first. Sorry. Number 3, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 19th, 2017.

2:38:21 Number four, approve the continuation of the local emergency declarations as declared by the town manager and ratified and declared by the town council by resolutions 17-06 and 17-13. Number five, approve the updated Eastern Sierra Transit Authority joint powers agreement amendment. Number six, approve by resolution the fiscal year 2016-17 Recreation Commission youth sports funding recommendations and the accompanying fiscal year 2016-17 town budget amendment.

2:38:51 Number seven, approve by resolution the Aquatic Facilities Custom USA Swimming Workshop and the accompanying fiscal year 2016-17 budget amendment. Number eight, accept the payment approval reports number 17-14, 17-15, and 17-17. We'll pull number seven for John. Any other thing?

2:39:20 Things that might want to be pulled. My counsel, none. I would make a motion, Mr. Mayor, to approve consent items 3, 4, 5, 6, 8. I have a motion. I will second. A motion and a second on that. And just, I'm not sure point of order on this, but I did notice a typo in the minutes. It's been addressed. It's been addressed. Okay, perfect. Sounds good. I'll give you a motion and a second. Any other?

2:39:51 Further discussion, comment? Okay, roll call please, Jamie. Yes, with an abstention on item three. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0 except for number three. It's four with an abstention. John, number seven. Yeah, just a quick, I've received some communication, I think we've all seen it from the public, about

2:40:21 Thank you, sir. Stu, why don't you start with the USA Swimming Conference?

2:40:43 The town secured USA Swimming Facilities Development Staff to host a custom workshop in Mammoth Lakes. That was 23rd, 24th, I believe, or 23rd of February, it seems like so long ago, during that snowy period. We hosted that workshop very productive. Really, the goal with that workshop is to better understand what an aquatics facility is, what does it mean, and a lot of questions I think we had were well answered, and it gave us some next steps in that process.

2:41:10 The item before you was pretty simple. The town, due to a timing issue with the facilities development staff, had to pay for that workshop up front. And this is just really a budget amendment, you know, rectifying that budget. So that was kind of the presentation. And then last night, at the MLR board meeting, we're beginning to look at our fiscal year 17-18 budget. Holistic approach to budgeting.

2:41:36 We're trying to push over the edge of those priority phase projects that some of these council members approved in December of 2015. The multi-use facility as one complete project. Mammoth Arts and Culture Center, as you saw that presentation today. Enhancement and expansion of the trail system. And the Outdoor Performing Arts Center, remember the 42 folks that joined together for a few months? MLT picked that piece up and is putting funding into that.

2:42:02 We believe we're going to bring something new on the 17th to push that stuff over the edge. The next project coming up that we're hearing most chatter about is an aquatic facility. So MLR, in their budget recommendations, allocated a line item of $50,000 to move that project forward.

2:42:20 We agreed last night that we need more work. We're going to refine the scope of the work. That'll come back to the MLR board in June that we will then refine and move a RFQ folder, whatever we need to do at that point in time. So if we can push the first piece over the edge, we're almost hitting the reset button right now for the new person coming in, and we can move aquatics along, do our feasibility study, and I would compare that to the

2:42:46 Same thing we did with the wetland delineation study. We actually find out what we can and can't do looking at multiple sites, whether it's Whitmore, whether it's Snow Creek, whether it's a shady rest parcel. There may be something else out there that we want to explore. So that's where we are presently, and we'll bring these things forward on May 17th. Yeah. Stu, you might want to kind of enlighten us a little bit why we didn't accept right away the $50,000.

2:43:15 Yeah, I think the Councilman Hunsaker feasibility study was a little premature for us, I think, at this time. We identified two kind of directions. One was kind of developing a better understanding of the site of where the aquatic facility is going to be kind of located. And one of the proposals right now with that feasibility study is to kind of look at Snow Creek Athletic Club. They've expressed an interest of whether it makes sense on their property.

2:43:45 The facility fits. So that was the first step. And then the second phase of the feasibility study is just determining the feasibility, economic impact, cost, so forth of the project. So we really want to kind of tackle step one.

2:44:02 And then we can kind of, I think what we believe is a better approach is to kind of scale and stagger these next studies based on kind of the findings of the previous steps, if that makes sense. So I think there's an understanding that, you know, we want to move this forward. I think there's an approach that Town is bringing forward to help kind of align that with the needs and what's been expressed so far. Kind of a two-step process. We believe so, yes. Which we thought would be better. Sure. So it's fair to say that the Town is actively pursuing an analysis of potential aquatic,

2:44:32 Correct. And that the town is pursuing potentially partnered efforts as well as starting from scratch, but that it seems like this is something that we can do in parallel with other efforts that are being pursued at the time. There's a strategy that MLR is going to be going through of how to keep moving forward with capital projects for the town, not just build and then stop.

2:45:01 Wait. This continued to move it forward. Sure. Good. I think it's just helpful to, what I've been hearing from the public a little bit is, well, it's one or the other or things like that, but I think it's helpful to have a sense that these things are moving forward and parallel and we're pursuing these things. And you return to the December 15 Town Council direction to MLR, priority phase projects, those top four, developmental phase projects. Let's finish these off. Now the next group is ready to roll into the cycle. Good. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you.

2:45:29 So I would make a motion to, sorry, is there any staff comment? No. Approve by resolution the Aquatic Facilities Custom USA Swimming Workshop and the accompanying fiscal year 2016-17 budget amendment. Second. Motion to second. Further discussion. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That will take us on to.

2:46:00 Policy matters. Yes, Dan. I'll just take the first one there if you want to read it. Well, yeah, I'll read it. It's approved the proclamation declaring May 7th through 13th, 2017 as Public Service Recognition Week. Thank you. I'm going to ask all of our employees to come up that are here tonight, and I'm going to ask Mr. Bocci if I can pose on you to take a photo here in just a moment. And then...

2:46:30 Each year we do this, it's a recognition, it's done throughout the nation, frankly, in terms of just the effort and services that public employees provide their communities.

2:46:41 You know, we have a number of very talented men and women that serve the town of Mammoth Lakes with a lot of pride and a lot of effort. We have a number of full-time staff in the 68 range and then a number of volunteers, a number of part-time staff, all that come together to make Mammoth Lakes work and smooth and what have you. So we do want to recognize our employees this evening that are here. But also on the other side of that as well is I'll actually ask the council to join us in the meeting as well. You guys...

2:47:10 You're paid sort of. Cover a little bit of the gas money. But anyway, putting a lot of volunteer time in, and then we'd also want to recognize the others, our planning commission, our rec commission. We have a number of volunteers with the police department, the CERT group, for example, the recreation department, a number of volunteers that work through that. And so when we talk about public service recognition, obviously we look at our employee base.

2:47:36 But it really extends beyond that to the community. You get a lot of different agencies. We're recognizing the city, the town here this evening. But again, you have the fire department, you have the water district, you have a number of other public employees within the community that really put in a lot of hours and time, day in and day out. Some of that's seen, some of it's not seen. This last winter was an opportunity to really highlight, especially our public work side of the house, not to mention, I think, our finance director and a few others that know how to use a shovel.

2:48:04 In terms of clearing out areas and doing that. So as the manager and looking at this, really my hat's off to this group of people who really, really love Mammoth Lakes and they put their heart and soul into it. So with that, I would recommend that the council approve the proclamation. I'm going to read the proclamation and then we can approve it. And then we'll go. Yeah, then we'd like to have you join us in a photo opportunity. Right. Let me just read a couple parts of it.

2:48:31 In honor of the millions of public employees at the federal, state, county, and town levels, whereas Americans are served every single day by public servants in the federal, state, county, and town levels, these unsung heroes do the work that keeps our nation working. And whereas public employees take not only jobs, but oaths. So I think that's very important. And I'm going to skip down.

2:48:57 Whereas talent is a key differentiator and organization in today's world, at the Town of Mammoth Lakes, our talent creates our solutions, our products, and our services. Our talent serves our customers and manages the important work of the organization every day. Whereas locally, town staff provides services to this community, including parks,

2:49:19 And road maintenance, public safety, planning and permitting, community recreation programs, and many other services that contribute to our vibrant community. And whereas the town has many volunteers, including the town council, that's us guys, planning and economic development commissioners, recreation commissioners, police department volunteers, parks and recreational volunteers, and many others whose services to the town is invaluable. Therefore,

2:49:46 The Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes does hereby proclaim to all citizens that May 7th through 13th, 2017 is Public Service Recognition Week. All citizens are encouraged to recognize the accomplishments and contributions of government employees and volunteers at all levels, federal, state, county, and town, proclaimed this third day of May 2017. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I would make a motion.

2:50:12 To approve the proclamation declaring May 7 to 13, 2017 as Public Service Recognition Week. Thank you, Bill. I'll second it. And we have a motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. You guys are... Yay!

2:50:59 I think you should be in the picture. Why don't you even get out of here?

2:51:29 Oh, shush.

2:51:58 There you go. Those are good. Thank you very much. We're going to take a five-minute break. Okay. We're going to be at 810. Do we have the TV up and running? Does anybody know yet? Channel 19, someone put that out on Facebook the other, or yesterday. Do you have anybody? Down?

2:52:34 Forget it. Forget it. Oh. All right. Hold on. Let's sit down. We'll go on to number 10, reserve policy discussion and direction, funding reserve for economic uncertainty, operating reserve, and contingency. Rob and Dan. Aha. Is that better? There we go. That's better. Yes. Thank you. I hate for you guys not to hear me throughout this process. So if you remember, we discussed

2:53:25 Our reserve policy at the mid-year review back in December when we allocated some funds to a new operating reserve that we had identified. And that time I talked about coming back to council with some ideas and thoughts around the policy and firming that up a little bit. Mainly it was around trying to define the policy elements a little bit better.

2:53:50 And maybe even going as far as describing when we know it's raining for these rainy day funds or reserve accounts. So I'd like to jump into there's three components to a recommended reserve strategy. That is a REU, which is a reserve for economic uncertainty, an operating reserve, and then a contingency, which allows us to spend money on an annual basis against

2:54:20 Minor Project. So I'm going to walk through each of these components, and the gist of it is I want you to understand really what the purpose of the reserve is and when it is engaged. So the first one we'll talk about is the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty. And this is a very special set-aside funds really to allow us to

2:54:47 Whether a long-term revenue shortfall, these shortfalls can come from an economic downturn, other localized events that negatively impact the town's revenues and our ability to provide services. The key thing here is that it is a fairly significant event, something that we would have to make a very conscious decision to decide we need to tap those funds in order to provide a minimum level of service.

2:55:17 to our community, and it's after a pretty major event. The engagement of that, it's at council direction, and so they would determine that the qualifying event has occurred and what level of impact it had or level of emergency that warrants the use of the REU. Our target for this number, we've done some adjustments since we talked about this in December, was we've lowered that to 16%.

2:55:44 Our general fund revenue because of how special this particular reserve is. It's really not to be touched unless we encounter those very significant situations. And so the money is truly set aside. So we lowered that down a percentage point. And so $3.4 million, which is the current balance that we have in that account, that is considered fully funded. We use targeting structures as our annual revenue for the general fund.

2:56:13 And for 17-18, where we have that set, this 3.4 million meets the minimum requirement, 16%. So we won't be asking for any more additional contribution to this reserve account today. As we go through the years and our annual budgets perhaps grow, we'll need to raise this up. The engagement of this policy, and talking about the refunding element of this, if we do have to tap in and use this account,

2:56:45 In my opinion, it becomes a very high priority. So it would be in front of the funding of either a contingency or the operating reserve because this is our most critical reserve account. However, if we've had to tap into this, we do believe that a significant emergency would therefore have had to occur and there could be a long recovery period for that. So we would certainly have the immediate needs.

2:57:08 Based upon the fact that this account is not touched and is pretty much held aside,

2:57:35 We'd like to invest it in the Mona County investment pool. We get our most interest from this particular roll-up, and that makes sense for this particular account. Anything that we get from an interest perspective would roll back into the reserve and try to sort of fund it on an annual basis, if you will, or at least minimize the amount we'd have to fund from general fund or any excess we may have. So any questions on the REU?

2:58:06 So switching gears now to the second item I want to talk about, which is the operating reserve. And I'm trying to put a little bit more emphasis on the operating reserve as it's not quite as critical as the reserve for economic uncertainty because it allows us to really take advantage of some other situations and it's not a dire account. It is certainly something that we use when things

2:58:35 And that's what we would use these funds for. We recently did use these funds at Council Direction to fund for the economic, for the

2:59:00 Research for a new Executive Director from MLR. It was really a decision at that point to engage the funds for that. So they're not exactly a critical emergency that they can be engaged, but it's there for opportunity to take advantage of situations. The funding level on this is 9%.

2:59:24 And again, I've raised that up just a little bit because of how these funds could be used for more activity and more events. That would be a total of $1.9 million based upon our general fund revenue for 17-18 or proposed. Right now, we have this account funded at $452,041, which is pretty good for year one. We really started this in December, so that's pretty good, better than I anticipated for year one.

2:59:53 There will be a request for funds of $200,000, which we can talk a little bit about that. We do have some revenue sources identified for this particular fund. We'll talk about those now, I guess. There are a number of TOT enforcement revenue accounts that we don't necessarily put a lot of budget expectation in.

3:00:16 In this particular one, it would be anything that we do from an enforcement perspective. What if we find either a revenue violator or a zoning violator? And we've talked earlier about the amount of activity we're doing in that. So we're going to continue to force that work and continue to try to achieve as much as we possibly can there. But the recommendation is that we use any funds that we receive from that activity that exceeds budget to fund this operating reserve.

3:00:46 So if I look at this year to date so far, we had a budget in there of 79,000, and we're around 258,000 in actual revenue for those accounts. So we would have somewhere around 179,000 of available funds that we could cover the 200,000 that I'm asking for. So the idea here would be that through town activities of enforcement, we'd be able to fund this operating reserve. So right now we'd be asking for around 20,000.

3:01:15 To meet my funding request, if you will. Let me touch on that real quick. Just a year ago or so, we looked at what I wanted for the REU, too. If you remember a while back, we were about one and a half or two million. So to be up at 3.4, I think, is very comforting, frankly. The other side of that was when we looked at the TOT dollars that Rob's talking about, as we do enforcement, especially on zoning, we budget zero dollars for that because we never know

3:01:47 What's going to happen? And so a year ago, we looked at those funds and outside the pieces that get put out from Transitter, MLT, that those would be kind of committed to capital projects. We wouldn't know what the number was, so they could go into capital reserve. Looking at shifting that to really priority-wise, looking at this operating reserve as a higher priority, so taking those excess dollars, if you will, or the unknown dollars.

3:02:13 Any given year could be different. As Rob mentioned, we'll be pushing $180,000 this year already. Likelihood, we will be exceeding the $200,000 number, frankly. So to commit those into this is a way to build this reserve up and have a committed revenue source, although the dollar amount of the revenue source, again, we wouldn't know until we move through the year. But in order to be a...

3:02:38 I guess disciplined in doing that the recommendation almost on a quarterly basis we had moved the funds into the reserve so they're not sitting out there for other purposes if you will in terms of that priority setting and the importance of setting those aside so I think it's a little bit of a shift from a previous policy I frankly support it and like it in terms of putting the dollars into that operating reserve as a priority over

3:03:01 Maybe the unknown capital side of the house, which we often fund out a one-time revenue or savings that we end up seeing into the future. So I think it's a good move that way and allows us to do that, still keeping funding going into the reserve, although we'd have to look at what that actually turns into each year. And just to be clear, and I know this is jumping ahead a little bit, but you have factored some revenue violations into

3:03:26 The budget moving forward. We have on the revenue side, but nothing on the zoning side. Correct. So we have revenue and zoning. There's zero dollars allocated in the budget for zoning violations, but there are dollars for revenue. Your suggestion is anything above zero on zoning would go into this operating reserve and any overages beyond the budgeted revenue would also go in. So there would essentially be two pots, one beyond the 60 and one beyond the zero.

3:03:56 That's correct. Okay. Yeah, we would meet our budgeted obligations first, and then anything in excess we would take. Correct. Okay. So with the $200,000 that we're looking to allocate this year to this operating reserve, that would bring us a total of $652,000. It's roughly 34% funded against our total target of $1.9 million. So, again, this is still, I'm considering this still year one, so it's pretty strong.

3:04:25 Commitment at this point. These funds would be in Town's LAF investment pool. There is some opportunity for interest in that account, just not as significant as we get from the county pool. Any questions about operating? Yeah, the difference in the two investment vehicles, the county pool, if you want a large dollar amount, it's not immediately liquid. The LAF is basically, I think it's about 9 or 10 in the morning, you can...

3:04:52 Okay. Tap into the reserves if you needed them. It's a liquidity issue. And they're both very secure of the principal. That's the other key factor. But the difference in the two funds is the interest rate based on the liquidity. Correct. Yes. Okay. So those two funds together, they're really the critical components of our reserve strategy. Combined, they equate 25% of our annual revenue or expenditures. Those two balance out. It's not different.

3:05:21 That's a pretty healthy position to be in, to have that level of reserve. I think that's what we're recommending at this point when we get them fully funded, maybe an opportunity to address it again. But we've got other opportunities, as earlier was mentioned, unfunded liability for CalPERS. That's other challenges that are coming down the road. But the key is for these guys, I think 25% is a good number to get to right now. When we get there, we can maybe talk more about it.

3:05:47 The third element of this is the contingency fund. So this allows really for flexibility and rapid response to either small projects or unanticipated needs that arise from the budget throughout the year. That occurs every, not all the time, but it occurs frequently every year, yeah. And so it's something that really is nice to be able to have this available to engage.

3:06:12 The fund's generally allocated at town manager's discretion or as needed and authorized by the town council. And last year we funded, because we talked about this mid-year, we funded it at $50,000. This year it's $100,000 because it's an entire year. But the good news about these funds is that we can sort of count on them to be there when we need them, and it's not a huge, significant burden to come back to council with very small requests as they may arise.

3:06:41 This here is a little less than a half percentage point. The examples on that is we've done them, we've had some computers that have blown up or need to replace, so buying those for some examples. We've done some additional, like we run over in a postage or an office supply type thing, utilizing that. We have something else break that needs to be covered. Again, a lot of it's very small dollars and staff to come to council to spend $2,500 is just the timelines gets to be a little challenging.

3:07:10 Other contingency items we have actually come. One was the cow trout contract we did. That came out of contingency. That was a policy question we brought to council to get that direction on. So there is a balancing between those two. But a lot of the operational stuff in the town to be able to do something quickly is relatively important. So I mentioned that combined our reserve components, our target is 25% on the first two, which is the REU and the operating reserve.

3:07:38 Based on next year's anticipated budget, that's about $5.2 million, that 25%. Our current balance is around 18.3%, which is at $3.8 million. And with the request, we'll just breach $4 million, or 19.2%.

3:07:56 So, again, I think we're progressing nicely, and I would recommend we may have opportunity in the fall to fund this even further with fund balance, but there will be other commitments at that time, perhaps. But the way we're going about third quarter, which we'll cover here just shortly, there should be excess funds available at that time, too. So more options to come, if you will. I wanted to try, and throughout these presentations tonight, there's a lot of them, if you will, but I tried to really

3:08:25 Kind of get some key discussion points and call those out for you guys and say here's the area where we really need the policy decisions and the components. So the next slide I have up is the key discussion points. Really talking about that fully funded 25% and how healthy that particular one is. Also, some people may say that's a high percentage. It's really driven based upon the volatility of our revenue stream. We have some

3:08:53 Some peaks and valleys, if you will, as economics go for us. It's a little bit more volatile than most. Optional approach, you could calculate the REU and operating reserve only on the percentage of operating actual expenses. We use the total town budget for our approach, but that would essentially remove long-term debt, airport settlement payments, and some internal transfers, things that are

3:09:22 Important, but not necessarily the running of the day in, day out, keeping the lights on, if you will. The other thing I'd like you guys to discuss and provide feedback on is, is there a desire to have different rates or percentages of annual revenue for either one of the components? We use rates basically to allow it to grow as our budgets grow, our town will grow and our budgets will change. Some reserve...

3:09:48 Systems have been set based upon flat dollar amounts. We say we have a certain value in the bank that we consider that covered. But that requires you to revisit that in a couple of years and confirm that it is still valid. I personally like the percentage approach because it gives it flexibility to grow. And we only go up. We don't necessarily fall back down. So I think in just a caution that, you know, discipline use of the reserves as well as funding.

3:10:16 Solid funding priority are the keys to making these things really work for the town. For policy discussion items, I'd really ask for tonight for you guys to review and approve the structure of the reserve policies that we've got then presented to you, including all three, which are the reserve for economic uncertainty, the operating reserve, and contingencies. And then approve the proposed rates of 16% for REU, 9% for operating reserve, for a total of 25% of general fund operating expenses.

3:10:46 Or make a recommendation as you see fit. Okay. Thank you very much, Rob. We're going to go to questions for Rob. And then we'll go to the public. The question I have, Rob, I'm going to start out, is, and I agree, I think 25% is, you know, right now we're going to go through this every year. Okay. So it's not like we don't get another bite at the apple here.

3:11:15 It's not working really good. But I like the 25% total. You know, how you broke it up, 16, 9, makes sense now. But that's fully funded. So do you expect in future years to just fund the operating reserve at $200,000 a year? If so, that's another six and a half years before we're fully funded.

3:11:45 In the operating reserve. Or I agree there's, you know, what Colin brought up, there's other opportunities for monies going in there, but we don't know what that means right now. That's correct. And if you think about the way we do our financial presentations, so we do a year-end fund balance review in the fall, and likely there will be, you know, some requests that are associated with that time frame. We'll do a mid-year. We'll do a third quarter.

3:12:14 And as you see, you know, my $200,000 is $652,000 in year one. So I think we're going to find our way there faster than what it would appear on a $200,000 per year request rate. Fair enough. There's just opportunity as we go. And really, we've got to look at, you know, available funds and the balance of the needs. And I think, you know, not overburdening one particular area because then we would have to start, you know, subtracting for perhaps for operating needs.

3:12:40 And I'd rather sort of do it in a very cautious way that allows us to build that with very minimal deductions. The goal would be three years to have it fully funded. Okay. That's the goal. Very good. Yes. No, thank you. I go along with the percentage. I think it makes sense based on revenues. So any questions for Rob? No questions. A few comments. One quick question.

3:13:08 I appreciate where we're going with the TOT enforcement thing and, you know, institutionalizing this as a funding source. There's a lot of discussion in years past about you're building a budget using this, and I think it's clear to everybody that this is, with the Internet, with all these things that are happening, single-family rentals, this is just, this is what it is. There's no issue of appropriateness or legality or anything.

3:13:37 To be doing what it is you're proposing to do with those two funding streams. Now, the one element to the TOT side, if there's the percentage allocation, as I mentioned, it goes to MLT or goes to other allocations by the council on a percentage basis. We still do that out of the TOT. We don't do it out of penalty and interest. But the actual TOT revenue that comes in goes there. And we just mentioned TOT. I should say on some of these, we also collect TBID, 100% of that.

3:14:04 Minus admin goes directly to then the TBID allocation. So if we're collecting, and I guess the issue was about taxes on, if we collected penalties on someone who's renting illegally, there's the issue of using those fines and all that kind of stuff. Does that go into this or is that? I don't think there's any restrictions on the use of the revenue at that point. There are no restrictions, although of course you could decide that there are. Okay.

3:14:31 But those, I'm just kind of going back. It's a funding possible source. I mean, we could come back and say, you know, we don't want to do that. Yeah. Okay. I'm good with this. Thank you. You have a question? Oh, no. All right. No further questions. I'll ask for public comment on this. Question? This is your chance. It's a big one. Yeah, it's a big chance. All right. We'll bring it back for comments, deliberation.

3:15:04 Comments? I'll start. Okay, now we go down the line. I like the allocation of the fines and stuff because it's going to go more. I would like to see as however set in a policy that until it's fully funded, if the fines are less than the $200,000, that we fine the $200,000 for somewhere to put in as a minimum. I had another one as well. We're going to try and get it funded within $300,000. Yeah, so it's more like $650,000. No, no, I understand that. To set a minimum. Very good point, right. Yeah.

3:15:33 While it's inappropriate for our current financial position, the other piece of this is I view the operating budget as much more liquid than the REU, and a 9% operating is a great thing. However, I like to live with a three-month cushion, no matter what I'm doing. So eventually I would like to see us find some sort of funding strategy that could get the REU up to that 25%.

3:16:01 And continue the 9% in the operating reserve because I think future counselors are going to look at that as far more liquid and use it for things. So the REU then becomes your three-month cushion, if you will. We don't have any money this year to do that.

3:16:18 But hopefully as we catch up from the last few years, we'll be able to do that. So that's just my comment. Personally, I would love to see the REU itself up at 25. I think what we need to do is fully fund the operating first. Absolutely. It was just a comment. I concur, actually. Any other comments? Got some? Yeah. You know, I just...

3:16:46 I always kind of carry our goals and priorities. That's why it's looking pretty haggard. But, you know, I think it's helpful, especially when we're going through these processes, to kind of look back and take a check in. But, you know, I think it's particularly noteworthy, you know, as we look at one of our four strategic priorities, one of which was effective municipal services. You know, A was financial stability, and it includes hiring a finance director, check, and a good one at that.

3:17:15 You know, growing stable revenue and services, that's occurred, and increasing revenues, or reserves, excuse me, and that's what we're talking about right now. So I think it's a very encouraging thing that we're actually in this position where we're talking about, you know, increasing our reserves, you know, which are already a lot more sizable than they were to the level of, you know, five and a half million. I mean, don't quote me on this, but my recollection is that our RU got

3:17:45 You know, down well below a million. I think it got down to, you know, 300,000 at some point. So the fact that we're, you know, the goal at that point was to restore it to three million. We've been able to achieve that. We've got, you know, the REU at this point fully funded at 3.4 million, which is a much better position than we were in five years ago. I would agree fundamentally with your comments, Bill, that I think, you know, maybe that's a next level goal as we start to achieve these initial targets.

3:18:15 I think it's important for us to be disciplined financially, especially with our volatility.

3:18:40 I'm good with the 25%. I would much prefer to be on a percentage basis as opposed to a flat amount, so I'm good with that. And, you know, I just thought it was noteworthy that, you know, where we've come in the last few years, and it's good to have that kind of next phase, you know, goal in the future. But, you know, I'm pretty good with everything that's been laid out here personally. I think this is, of the three budget items we have, this is the easiest one for me.

3:19:10 Thank you, Colin. Cleland. Ditto with Bill and Colin. I like having the money in the bank. All right. And we have money in the bank. John. Yeah, I share the sentiments of my fellow council members. I'm especially grateful.

3:19:35 Okay.

3:20:05 I concur with everything. I think I already made those comments. There are things that can crop up. The airport is a great example of that. We're spending $2 million for the next 18 years, and we're not going to have anything to show for it. No building, no nothing. So things do happen. It's smart to have reserves. So we're on the right track.

3:20:34 You're talking about the airport settlement. Yes, the settlement. Yeah. The settlement, that's what I meant. Thank you for the clarification. Sure. Okay, with that, I'll... We're really looking for this discussion on this, for funding this. We'll build it into the budget. It comes back for approval, so if we have just a consensus on this... That's all you need? Yeah, we're just asking for the discussion and direction at this point. Okay, so you don't want us to read a recommended motion or anything?

3:21:01 It says to recommend a motion. If you want, I mean, we're trying to build a budget, so either way.

3:21:06 I'll make it easy. You know, I'd recommend that council approve staff-recommended structure and rates for all three components of the reserve policy. This includes establishing funding targets for the Reserve for Economic Incertainty, or REU, funded at 16% of annual general fund revenue, the operating reserve funded at 9% of annual general fund revenue, and contingency funded at 100K annually as part of the normal budget process.

3:21:33 Okay. I have a motion. I have a motion. Second. Second. Two seconds. Any further discussion on this? None. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. That motion passes 5-0. That'll take us on to item number 11.

3:21:56 Which is presentation on budget performance through the third quarter fiscal year 2016-17 and direction on allocation of additional revenues. Rob. Okay, thank you. Yeah, so we've got that teed up to discuss next. And essentially what we're doing here is we like to get through, as I talked about, those different financial events that we bring to council across the year.

3:22:21 This is one we do after third quarter activity is sort of clear to us in budget performance. I'd like to talk about just where we are, things that we need to firm up, either from an expenditure side or, you know, revenues recognizing the excess. In this case, we're lucky to have excess. And so we'd like to talk a little bit about that. And there is quite a bit of heavy lifting in this particular presentation for you folks. So please, I try to...

3:22:47 Interject elements of pause through there so we can talk about them, but it's open dialogue. I'll start off with the revenue side, and really in this particular case, we're focusing on occupancy tax. We do review all of the financial performance through the third quarter.

3:23:07 Some of the timing of some of the other revenue elements, we like to sort of keep those in reserve and just talk about where we are. If there was something that was falling behind, there would be pause or area of concern, then we'd certainly bring those up, but right now I'm very comfortable with where I'm seeing those. Transient occupancy tax, we budgeted last year at $11.65 million, and again, that's very prudent at that point in time, based on only one year of very strong activity. But actual through third quarter,

3:23:37 It's 14 point, just under 15 million, so it's very strong. We've exceeded certainly our annual budget toward just three quarters of the year. We do anticipate some strange sort of performance for fourth quarter. From some dialogue I've had, I believe that April is going to come in very strong.

3:23:57 We'll know that around the 20th or slightly thereafter of May when those returns are due. But I think that April is going to be far stronger than we've sort of budgeted and anticipated. May in itself is sort of anemic, and that's not to say by design, but that's the way it is.

3:24:16 And so we don't have a lot of expectation for May. And then June is sort of a wild card because of, you know, not anticipating really having the pass open. So just a little bit of a challenge. But we think collectively those three months can produce 1.7 million. And I think that's a very conservative number. I think it could be considerably north of that. You're right. And April may come in at that, perhaps. Who knows? But with those,

3:24:45 Conservative expectations. We think that TOT revenues are going to hit $16.67 million by the end of the year, and that would produce a variance to budget of just over $5 million. So that's what I'm comfortable today, saying this is what we have as far as a revenue opportunity, and that's what we're basing this presentation on. So as we approach this, we kind of broke it down into a couple of different areas.

3:25:15 As been noted earlier in this meeting, and we all lived through it, but we had a significant snow event, and so there were impacts to that. When I'm going through this process, I'm looking at all the accounts within our budgets and looking at where we've overspent, if you will, and then perhaps why. So what we decided to do is break out the snow-related impacts. Now, we did declare emergencies.

3:25:41 Pursuing reimbursement for as much as we can possibly get. So know that the things that you see listed here at least are what we have listed on the FEMA requests and such that are out there. But we thought it was prudent to come forward with those as really a priority funding because the expectation is that the FEMA dollars are going to be a challenge.

3:26:05 And we really think that if we do receive some of those back, that would be opportunities to put them into fund balances for their respective areas. And that would probably be even more, you know, financially responsible at that point. But what you see here is really a list of the things that we've identified as impact, again, related to snow, for the most part. Now, this was a kind of a hairy thing to put together. It's pretty large. There are a few adjustments that we've made this week.

3:26:33 So what you received in your packet, we'll have some slight adjustments, but we'll walk through those and kind of give a level of understanding what we have out there. So the first thing I'm showing is general fund. And again, just looking at where we're upside down on a couple of areas, a lot of the things you'll see, you know, either the first item, facility lease, that's for our town on facilities.

3:26:57 Just a snow removal in the parking lot, common area maintenance, if you will. We received a letter in the middle of the winter saying, hey, heads up, it's going to be a bad winter and we're going to have to charge you a bit more. We've also got overtime wages in there. And again, I broke it down by area. We've got the police department and then the contractual services. And that particular one is a little bit of a mix. We certainly have snow removal elements, but we had several internal investigations. And I thought I would sort of include that into one number.

3:27:27 But the $40,000 is really indicative of where we overbudget on that particular line item. Then a couple of other sort of assessment district elements and things that we've pulled together from our engineering team, pulled together the $5,000 and the $80,000 for like the hillside parking lot and park and ride. Those are really facilities that live outside of.

3:27:55 The gas tax funding area, if you will. So they're funded by the general fund. Thanks for that, because I thought that was you, actually, the shoveling professional service. Oh, yes. I like that, actually. Thank you. And so just some incremental, like, public works engineering, temporary wages. Again, these are just where we have some variances that are out there. So just a real quick question. I don't see anything in here about, like, destroyed signs and all that kind of stuff. Where's that? Where are we going to see that?

3:28:25 So we do have some maintenance sort of request elements that you'll see throughout there. This is really, from this particular look, was really more what do we currently have in the budget line items. So it would be already identified elements. There is one in here, and this sort of came in just last minute, which was the railing destroyed by snow on Lake Mary Road. And we sort of identified that component at the last minute. But it's really, you know, where did we overspend on the wages, employee costs, and such.

3:28:54 That are there. So going to the next item, again, I broke them down by funds. This one's gas tax fund 210 in our account. So this is where we house all the snow removal elements and street maintenance that are out there. And what I try to do is really pull together the wages, if you will, all elements of those to get like a net employee cost, if you will.

3:29:29 And, John, here's the answer to yours. I mean, there's some street sign replacement of $10,000. And what we try to do is we'll go through some of the option elements when we go to the budget that we're going to talk about on the third item on the list is we move some items that were currently in the budget as needs from the snow events into these third quarter monies as really identified needs at that point. That's more and more in the project aspect, if you will.

3:29:56 You know, snow removal, we've got the traffic safety supplies, again, that's the 40,000, and then just, you can see the details of what we've got there, 121,000 for snow removal, that's the CCC crew, as well as, you know, some of the other snow removal activity we did on sawmill cutoff and shady rest. Real quick, do you have a breakout of, can you break those? The CCC crew was about 61,000 and about 60,000 for the

3:30:26 $60,000 for sawmill cutoff and shady rust? Yeah. Okay. And, Rob, this is kind of ticky-tacky, but just for a clarification point, as we present these forward, maybe just for public consumption, but, you know, I found budget shortfall due to strong snow years kind of a confusing explanation. You know, it's kind of actually the opposite.

3:30:50 Yeah. So thank you for that.

3:31:21 So gasoline, diesel, you can see that $125,000. So total for the gas tax fund related events about $417,000. And then the only other area we have really for the snow related impacts. Rob, before you go on, is there a reimbursement possible for that? What we're doing with that, working through the county and stuff, we'll actually put a fair amount in. There's some state aid and there's federal dollars potentially. We have that out there.

3:31:50 The biggest question on that's going to be how much they'll actually say, yes, that quantifies. But I was just saying, is it possible? It's possible. The timing, though, could be anywhere from one to three years. Okay. So it could be that far out. Thank you. Wow. Yeah. We've worked on a different disaster, different location. I think it was five years to get some dollars back. Three years from now, somebody will get a quarter million bucks to figure out. You just don't know. Yeah.

3:32:20 Yeah, but we do have a very, you know, comprehensive list of those activities and submitted for sure. Thank you. So airport, again, snow-related impacts really over time. We do have a lot of paving and striping to be done at the facility, so that $62,000 is associated with that. The contractual services in there I have listed at $25,000. That's really probably in the operating element.

3:32:46 That access was associated with an aviation forecast. It's just a lot of our contractual services elements were in excess due to the excessive snow, so that's why I put it in here, but essentially looking a little bit deeper for some questions from council members, it was an aviation forecast. That was around $28,000, and that's not an annual thing. That's something that we do. It was a one-off. And then we had...

3:33:13 I put it in contractual services down here, again, barbed wire fencing, about 80,000 linear feet. We're collapsed by the snow, so we're going to probably have to contract out for that, so it's around 20,000. So the airport fund in there, 122,000. Total snow-related, 733,000. These funds represent monies that are already spent, so when we talk about excess, they definitely have to be taken care of first.

3:33:40 So that's why they're in that position. The snow pool costs $40 per. How much are they to pop? $39 a piece. We usually buy about $300 to $400 a year. Yeah, we're going to exceed $1,000. What does it cost to put them in? What's the staff time? It's a lot of our staff out there running through it.

3:34:12 And we certainly don't do a calculation on a personal pool basis and stuff. It depends on how mangled they are and how many we can straighten out and how many we have to toss and replace and things. There's a lot of variables.

3:34:37 Some take five minutes, some take a half an hour. But the actual process of pull removal is going to be the same year over year. It's just a question of how many we have to purchase to replace. That's correct. As opposed to just pull and store and then put back in. The one thing I'd add to that, though, is that we don't remove all of them throughout town. We remove them on the major thoroughfares and things like that. There's a lot of neighborhoods where they stay up year-round. This year, we're going to have to go into those neighborhoods and pull a lot more of them. All right. Thanks. You bet. Okay.

3:35:11 So the next area I walk into here is the operating expenses. And these are just, again, so same type of a scenario. You're reviewing the budget for the year, but really looking at where either you have an event that wasn't budgeted or an excess where your expenses have exceeded your budgets. In that particular one, we've just got our financial audit. We had a GASB 6B8 requirement that added some elements to that. It was about $9,100.

3:35:40 Incremental. The police advantage care as part of the MOU agreement, we should have had that in our mid-year review process as a request at that time, but it was not. So we're going ahead and pulling that in today. Dispatch services, that's something that is calculated, I think, on an annual basis based upon the volume of calls and split between Mono County Sheriff and the town as based upon those percentages.

3:36:07 So I think we've had some shifting in allocation this year based upon the calls. And so we're over budget at that point, about $15,000. Next year, as you'll see when we talk about budgets, we've addressed that as well. And so we've got those there. We had some AED defibrillators that we were able to purchase. And we do expect the grant revenue to come in, but that'll be perhaps a little bit later.

3:36:34 And then the fireworks display, that one actually can be pulled at $15,000 because essentially we budgeted, it's a $30,000 expense. We have $15,000 in revenue that we come in. For last year's budget, we did not budget the revenue component or the full $30,000. We budgeted just the expense to the town. So when I looked at that and saw, well, we're going to be upside down about $15,000, but in reality,

3:37:00 The $15,000 in revenue should offset that. So in fact, that should come off as a wash. Total of the adjustments that we would make around $20,000 to the bottom line here, which you'll see on my part of the presentation. And then we have tree removal expectations with the trees that are dying and the mortality rate of those. I'm not expected to really go away anytime soon, so we do feel that we're going to have a little bit more to do when...

3:37:25 Snow perhaps melts off a little bit more. So the operating expense listed as $112,000. It's really around $96,000 as we take that $15,000 out. Next item is political commitments is what I call it for lack of a better term. And essentially these are elements that are tied directly to the TOT performance. And so if the

3:37:52 We budget those expense line items associated with the budgeted TOT revenue. Now that we're exceeding that by, in this case, perhaps $5 million, those numbers have to arise as well. And so transit services, which receives 1% of the TOT, one point of the TOT actual percentages, that overage is going to equate to $225,000. And Mammoth Lakes Tourism,

3:38:17 It's 2.5 points, which is 749,000. There are some adjustments that we make to those numbers, so they won't calc out exactly on the 5 million, but total commitments variance is 974,000. We do recommend that on the transit, we have some town-owned trolleys that are not currently in our vehicle replacement fund account, and we would recommend that we probably take some of that and fund

3:38:46 Put aside around $125,000 for the vehicle replacement fund and leaving $100,000 in the account for restricted operations. So just a kind of quick comment on that, I suppose for public benefit, you know, the three NGOs that we currently, you know, fund out of the TOT would be transit.

3:39:10 Through ESTA, MLT, and also housing. The reason that these show up here and housing does not is because that's on a fixed dollar amount and these are on a percentage basis? That's correct. And we have a flat dollar amount reduction from both of these two entities that's already been done for this budgeted year, correct? That's correct. Okay. It's a larger conversation, but that was a change that was made by a prior council. As part of the...

3:39:48 It's part of the settlement agreement. I know that MLT, I mean, they've got a current war chest of about $5 million worth of unspent funds, and you're going to ship them another $750? I mean, at a certain point, how many reserves should an NGO have before the town says, geez, you know, maybe we should keep that? That's not up for...

3:40:24 Discussion on this right now. I mean, it's a further discussion. Well, 750 that you guys are willingly... No, 750 that you want to ship over there. Based on the contract we have, those are the numbers. You've got to rewrite your contract. Well, I would just advise that Council Member Ferdy and I are involved in a process right now to review...

3:40:49 Measure A, allocations and recalibration. We'll be making a presentation in the coming week. That's honestly precisely why we're looking at this. We're talking about current budget as opposed to future budget where that would be more of an applicable conversation. Okay, let's move on. Just a little bit of a recap on those particular items before we go into the project element of that. Sorry, interrupt real quick.

3:41:20 The recommendation in terms of the allocation on the transit piece, some of this we'll remember to come back to, but is there any concern over that just on the front end by council members? We can come back and spend more time on it, but that may save some time. Not personally, no. In reading the rest of the council members, I think we're pretty good with that. The only thing I would add into it would be replacement or rehabilitation.

3:41:44 Yeah, it's, how do we keep them running? Some of the specialty things we have. As we find these things, you're right. Right, yeah, some of the things that we have are less expensive to rebuild than they are to repurchase, so. Sure. It goes into that replacement fund, that does happen at times. Right. So, that's one of the things. Yeah, as long as that's a possibility, then I'm more than good. I think council is okay with that. Okay, I just been presented. Thanks. Yep, thanks.

3:42:08 Okay, so a little bit of a recap, essentially to bring back the $5 million with those that like already spent amounts, if you will, lower that down to $3.197 million available for projects. Now, we're going to trade off a little bit. Dan's going to talk about these. I will say that the projects, you know, have been to

3:42:33 Really identify the needs. We went through a process with our budgeting of talking about service level and town needs. Similar in this case is if we had options that we needed to really invest in, what would we want to do first? So that's kind of how we've sort of teed these up. And I'll let Dan walk you through them. And then this is just third quarter trip, essentially. We will have another crack at this when fourth quarter comes in. Correct. You'll have another crack probably August, September as we wrap up both on expenditures.

3:43:02 On the expenditure side and on the revenue side as we normally do. The driving in this one was twofold. One was the snow impact and just that our budgets are overspent, so we need to amend those to get them up to where they're at. Also looking at the amount of DOT coming in, there's been a number of other items identified as priority through various comments and discussions, so this becomes bringing that back to have that discussion. This next group of items really is to get some clear policy direction on some of these issues.

3:43:31 Try to walk through them somewhat quickly. Hope you've had a chance to read through that. That first section on infrastructure investments, the recommendation there was looking at about one point. Let me take one or a step back. The total list here exceeds the dollars available, so we will be looking to, you can window some of these down. But those infrastructure investments, $270,000 for Upper Main Street, that bid's already been left and stuff, so you really don't have much control on that as we go into that project this next year.

3:44:01 The airport capital count is the ongoing match dollars for the terminal building. We're looking at a significant road project, hopefully this summer on the one and a half. Just real quick, I want to figure out how we're going to do this. I'm not sitting here reading through things. Yeah, let me get it. I'll hit a couple of these, then I'll open it up. So, sorry, I won't try to walk through all these. That's fine. The capital item here on the roads is the last one I want to focus on because this was discussed at the March 22nd meeting.

3:44:27 Design, can we move forward? This would be a policy question there, is actually if this is approved, we'd like to move that quickly starting this year, although it'd be spending current year dollars, one-time money, and a chunk of next year's dollars allocated to the road so we can get a project on the ground this summer. Then the last piece is there, we can, for drainage and concrete work, that can go, there's 500,000 there. That we found out from the storms. Yeah, we're hitting that stuff.

3:44:58 Out of that 1.6 in total, you know, you probably have another 200,000 or so in there. If you wanted to reduce that down, we could do that in terms of helping balance out the overall need. But these were priority elements to move forward and address significant issues in our infrastructure. And, Dan, you budgeted 580 on road maintenance moving forward for 17-18? Correct. So if we use 500 of that, there's 570, 560 left in the current year budget.

3:45:26 So if you put another 500 here, you'd have a $1.5 million plus or minus project pending final design and bids out of engineering. So the council had a workshop with MLT back in the fall, and Councilmember Fernie and I had a follow-up with the board about some priority projects they were recommending, and they made representations that they were going to be putting some money to this airport stuff. I believe they've set aside.

3:45:52 I don't recall the number, $250,000 or $300,000. $300,000, I believe. $300,000 that could match into the board. Has that happened? At their end, I believe so. It hasn't come back to the town as a reserve payment that way. I don't believe it's been given final board approval. I think it's not set aside. So it's not reflected in this? It's not reflected in here. Maybe we should clarify that? This is separate. The $1.1 million here is currently in the bank.

3:46:15 The $250 would be coming out of our additional funding. Right. So it's two different. But I think that's a good point. I think we need to circle back on that. And it may be academic, given how we proceed with that measure, well, those Measure A discussions, but I just wanted to point that out. I don't, they were supposed, they're supposed to have been agendized, but I don't know what happened. Yeah. Okay, let's go on to group two, unless there's any other questions on infrastructure investments.

3:46:41 Well, and Dan, you made the representation that you could find $200,000 out of this? Correct. Do you need any further direction from us, or are we okay? I think, personally, and I'll defer to the mayor on this, but I'd like to take all three of these groups and then kind of come back. Okay. Because we've got to shave. $775,000, basically. Out of the total. Or more.

3:47:03 Right. Well, there might be some additions, too, so let's move forward. So let me just say one thing on the infrastructure side. There was a recommendation from Mammoth Lakes Recreation to provide funding for the updates of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System signage for new trails, new maps, and that kind of stuff. They're now out of sync with what's on the ground. The recommendation came from MLR. I don't see that in here anywhere.

3:47:29 We hit that under the community projects down there. We did not. Community projects? Okay. Would be where you could fit that in if you wanted. Let's go through the whole thing and then. I wasn't sure we wanted to put that in. That's fine. The second item dealt with a couple of town facility issues. One is deferred maintenance in parks and recreation, looking at $300,000 there. And then we also are, we have a number of town projects we're working on. If you want to be able to really either do environmental work or move some of the analysis forward, you'll need funding for that.

3:47:57 Out of that 600,000, we could trim out 150 of it, maybe 175 as need might be there. There are two elements there. The one, the parks and rec stuff, I mean, the types of stuff we're seeing out there in the field is there's a lot of deferred maintenance. This is shot out there at the bleachers, I believe, in the park and some of the shape of some of our stuff at the pool. The other side then would be coming into the...

3:48:24 So I'll come back to that real quick on that one. The Town Commitments Community Project items in here, we had a number of items. This had the funding for the operating reserve, $200,000. We recommend you pull that out. The implementation line items probably got the most flexibility. The issue there is we've done a lot of planning work, both on the books and what we're doing right now. If you wish to actually implement some of those things, you need to start setting money aside to do that.

3:48:53 Again, you could reduce that down in this case. That would be fine as well. We could take $2 to $2.50 out. East Village parking, one of your priorities was look at parking solutions in the village. We've had discussions with the owner of the East Village area, the parking lot, willing to match kind of a dollar-to-dollar match to jointly look at parking. I've had a discussion the other day with the gentleman in charge of that, and we could take this down by $25 to $50.

3:49:19 We don't know the hard cost on that until you actually go out and select a consultant. That would be ran by the town versus the private side as well, and they're fine with that. The footsteps to brilliance, you've had a presentation from the superintendent of schools office on that project. We put some dollars in here related to enforcement on DOT for the internet search. Not sure this will be a one-time cost, this one. We want to push and have a little more discussion, bid it out, or get requests for proposals.

3:49:49 The different companies we've looked at has ranged from 25 to 100 plus, so we don't know what that number will actually be. And then the last one was funding for the Mammoth Lakes Recreation with some dollars that would allow them to do fundraising and other things that the current measure are and new funds don't clearly state that you can use it for that. So this would be a one-time funding that would cover basically a three-year agreement with Mammoth Lakes Recreation for funding their ED.

3:50:18 So out of that group, again, you could reduce that out by 400,000 or so in there. So that would cover the group so that there's any add-in or other specific questions we can address. Okay. So and then the recap real quick, that just shows on the back that we're about 800,000. Yeah. Yeah, it would be down about 777 at this point.

3:50:44 Okay, are there any questions on the infrastructure investments, town facilities updates, town commitments, and community projects from anybody? Question. Well, frankly, I haven't had enough time to go over these numbers and be comfortable and ask the questions that I want to and need to ask to make an informed decision. There are some things here, some lines that perhaps we need to move forward almost tonight because things need to happen.

3:51:15 But the rest of these, I would really like to take this presentation in and have a time to get with staff and be more thoughtful of it before I start hacking at the $787,000. I'm just not prepared to do that. I suppose had I been here on Friday, I would have had these for a couple more days, but still, the amount of time and the amount of meeting time I've had is...

3:51:42 Inadequate for me to go back and say, okay, I want to take $100,000 from the $300,000 we're doing for maintenance for the parks, and I want to take, and even what budget area I want to put the money into while it's sitting is still unclear to me. No, we definitely have some issues on how to move forward. Sure. There's no question about it. I would like to ask the question. Last night during MLR, we talked about the multi-use facility.

3:52:12 I think, uh,

3:52:45 Well, three elements. One, value engineering on the project. So you reduce the cost down accordingly. Okay, that's an option. Without destroying the projects and still having a full project go forward. Secondly, timing-wise, there will be some additional R&U money, probably not adequate to cover that full cost. And then secondly, you would have, if you wanted to tap...

3:53:09 The general fund side, it would be walking through these types of dollars. So if let's say you set $750,000 aside for implementation, if the plan was hold on to that until such time that we knew you could do something that direction, I think the other pressure that's out there both on us and Mammoth Lakes Recreation would be how do we really tap our private sector side and raise dollars?

3:53:33 The other piece would be is if it looks like we're not going to have that funding in place, again, not recommending this, but you can push the project. We would not award the bid, if you would, based on funding. Yeah, because the need for those funds, my understanding, Rob, from last night would be in 12 months if we agreed to move forward. Yes. Okay. So we'd have to raise those funds somehow.

3:54:03 In the next 12 months. So that gets back to my point. The million dollar set aside for implementation could easily go to that because it doesn't say implementation of what. We have studies out there that we would like to implement. So when I say I don't know exactly what fund. I think what I'm trying to address is there's a litany of things that we would like to implement. We'd have to pick and choose. Right. What they are. What they are. Yeah. Because I'm assuming the implementation dollars here would just go into the CIP account.

3:54:32 And be used out appropriately. You're right. Yeah. So what if we went through this list kind of to Bill's point a little bit about which things are things that we don't really have a whole lot of control over options on, maybe get those off the list and then come back. I think that's a good idea. Yeah. Back at a later date with some more information. Very comfortable with that. I definitely view this more as.

3:55:00 You know, there's town staff seeking more policy direction than allocating an actual $3.2 million tonight. So, you know, it's going to be messy and difficult because it's different categories and we're all going to have different opinions, but I at least have some thoughts and things that, you know, maybe we can knock off the list or something. Okay, so if it's the council's desire, I would like to

3:55:30 Thank you. Thank you.

3:55:56 Any funding, real quick, you don't approve, either it just falls into fund balance for later discussion or it can be moved over to the capital fund for future allocations. Right. Okay. So you mentioned the Upper Main Street shortfall, 270, that's... You need to commit that. That's a thumbs up for me. Okay. Yeah, I'm good with that. Everybody's good with that? Sure. All right. Airport capital account, I think that's something we can hold off. It's a policy question, but... I would... Well, I would hold off.

3:56:22 I mean, that's something we need to do. You're not going to have enough even with the MLT payment. You need to get to $3 million. This would put us at 1.35. If they funded some, you're still way short of $3 million. I would suggest that we do this. If there's money from another source that would come in later, we could do that. I'm trying to get the list down as much as possible. Okay. I think that's something that we can work. I mean, we might be only...

3:56:50 Be able to do $200,000 as an example. So that's on a, we're going to do it, it's just how much? So do you want to leave that optional at this point? Optional. Okay. Okay. Enhanced level of road work, that's optional. If you're going to do the work this summer, it's...

3:57:08 You could drop it down to 500. I would propose we drop it to 500. But we need the direction now if you're going to get it done. Otherwise, it doesn't matter. We'll put it out the next summer. I would propose we drop it to 500 and move it forward because I think that's a significant bump in funding to what we've been doing on road maintenance prior to now. I would agree with that. Well, and if we have 100 left over, they will not have consumed all that money yet. They can be added in. I realize there's bidding processes and everything else that go on, but not all of it is. Are you okay with the 500? Yeah, the 500 is fine. Cleland?

3:57:38 I'm fine with the five. Okay. That will go to five then. Infrastructure, concrete projects. If we have a dollar amount there, we'll work on projects again potentially for the summer pending engineering's capability, but they'll spend whatever we allocate. I would recommend you could do that at 400 between the two and we'll bring you projects accordingly. I'm not going to say it's going to be absolute in this.

3:58:04 You say between the two, you're talking about drainage and... Yeah, they're basically coming from $500,000 to $400,000. I'm okay with that. That's fine. That's what I had down, pulling $100,000 out of those two combined. We have consensus on that? You're just talking about instead of $5,000, we'll take it down to $4,000, taking it from... So it'd be a $3,000 and a $2,000 there, but it'd be a $2,000 and a $2,000, but it may come out different based on the projects we bring back to you. Right. I'm okay with that. Yeah, no, I'm...

3:58:33 I'm good with that, but drainage is pretty important to me. Okay, town facilities updates, $600,000. I personally would hold on the $300,000 for deferred maintenance for parks. I think it's very important. The problem is if we keep deferring maintenance, it's just going to cost us a lot more money in the future. Kind of the same thing. I'm saying I would hold it at $3,000. Oh, keep it. Sorry, I wasn't very clear. I'm good with that.

3:59:02 I would hold it at three. The only caveat I would add to that is I would like information from the rec commission, now that we're going to start to dealing with some of this deferred maintenance, to understand if there are any projects or facilities that it's now time to retire. Good point.

3:59:20 You know, and where it's going to be used. I can tell you that the maintenance list that Grady has for Parks and Rec probably is more like a million bucks. Correct. It's $300,000. It's only a drop in the bucket. Understood. But if there are facilities that the Recreation Commission thinks look.

3:59:37 We want to discontinue this or we don't want to keep going. I'd like to, or if they want everything on the list, fine, but I'd like to know that. And Stu, I think that's good direction as you guys come back with a prioritized list of how to spend that money. You know, there could be priority phase number one, get rid of is a third column and then kind of second tier. All right. Yeah, that was kind of the design through the processes that once the funds are allocated that that team would be the one to pull it together.

4:00:06 I'd come back to you then for here's the project we're funding. What was that? I'm glad Al was going to go check. Something just blew up. Something blew up. Yeah. Chief's checking it out. We're good. Okay. How about front-end planning work? I think for me this would be either a reduction or a hold-off for now. I'm comfortable with reducing from 300 to 200. Or do you want to just kind of...

4:00:33 Well, I'm not going to use your vernacular on hold. Come back to that one later. Yeah, come back and let's. You may have some projects coming up. That's fine. Yeah, what facilities are we talking about? This is one of those lines that I'm totally uncomfortable with at this point. Okay, let's go down to town commitments and community projects.

4:00:51 So we are, you're suggesting to pull the 200 out of the fund operating reserve. You believe that can come from TOT Obridge. So that's whacked regardless. Okay. Did we, I'm sorry, did we on the 300 for the facilities, did we hold on that entirely? Yeah. Yeah. I'm not leaving the money in available. We'll come back. It's a few, further discussion. Let's put it that way. So we're allocating the parks maintenance, but not allocating that currently. We will allocate something. We just don't know what yet. Okay, implementation.

4:01:21 Can, if I may, could we jump? You don't want to talk about that one yet? Yeah, I would prefer to kind of come back from the bottom up on this. Okay, let's go from the bottom up. I don't have a problem with that. MLR Executive Director. I'm good with that. Good with that. Yeah, I think we have made that decision already. I was about to say we've already committed to that one, so. Yep. Internet search, I'm good with that.

4:01:50 That's something we've been talking about a long time, and I think we need to put some dollars to it. We'll get a firmer budget. Yeah, so this is going to be, I don't know how much this is going to cost, and this probably will not be a one-time expense. Understood. I think that's the next step we need to take in our TOT enforcement. Okay. Grant leverage project. Good with that. Good with that. I am too. Everybody? Consensus on that? Yeah, yeah, yeah. That's one I definitely am in favor of. Okay. East Village Parking. It's a matching funds program.

4:02:18 What's the status on that? It's still a project that the private sector wants to help move through. We can reduce it down. We had that discussion, so you could cut 50 grand out of that. If we had 200 commitment, they'll commit 200. That allows us to take a hard look at that east village side and looking at the intersection there at Forest Trail and 203. So let's reduce it to 200. Well, do you want to do that, or do you want to say, you know, we need further information on it? What we'd like to do is...

4:02:47 If you have dollars, we'd love to go out and start soliciting information. If we just hold it, then we won't do anything on it. I think it fits within our strategic priorities, and I would also put airport in that category, but I'm comfortable moving some dollars forward there. Yeah, I think we should move forward on this thing. I think there's... But the current match is $200,000? Yeah, that's current.

4:03:10 They would match dollar to dollar. You can leave it at 250. They will match the 250. They'll match 250 or 200, either one. It's dollar for dollar. You want to leave it? I would vote for 200. I'm good with 200. That probably gets us what we need, at least if it's different. You okay with that, Bill? That's fine. I'm fine with that, too. Implementation, I would just, I would come back to this with more, you know.

4:03:40 More information. More information. I would leave it because I think we've got a lot of places for it. Yeah, leave it. But rather than implementation, I would say at this point I'm comfortable with it moving into the CIP because we need money there for a lot of things. Correct. I think that I would hope for the purposes of this discussion we're not going to do anything with this this evening. So the clarification you're looking for will come back when we have a more detailed discussion.

4:04:12 Well, let me... I will tell you, I think the purpose of this, Ted, the purpose for this is we've got a lot of studies and plans and everything else going on out there, and we rarely put money towards implementation of those, so they end up sitting on a shelf. So implementation would be the money would go into the CIP fund.

4:04:31 But then we would be setting aside money to actually do something with walk, bike, ride or downtown beautification or whatever. That's why it's called implementation. In reality, from my perspective, it's CIP, yeah. CIP. Yeah, it's CIP. It's like the wayfinding project with signage. It's the trail system sign-up. Got it? So, yeah. Thanks. That's a good question, though. So, on a quick recap. Start at the top.

4:05:00 We got the upper Main Street shortfall. That's in. $500,000 for enhanced road work. $400,000 for infrastructure and drainage improvements. And can I just circle back again on the airport? Are we certain that we don't want to set money aside? We did set money aside. I just thought we'd need further information. I'd like to find out what MLT is doing. I think we're going to be revisiting this all one more time. What's going to happen on this, though, is you're going to have...

4:05:28 We'll reduce it down. You're still going to have more committed here than you have money for. Understood. This is the first bite. If I understand what we're doing, we are moving things forward that have to move forward. I would like to find out on this particular thing before we commit to what MLT is doing. That's fine. Where are you right now? Just under $2 million. We will not be putting any money into the airport fund at this point in time. Today.

4:05:57 At this point in time, there's no dollars going there. Today, correct. Tonight. Tonight. Yeah. So that's coming out of the $3.2 million to balance out the dollars available at this point. That's my question. Because you have more requests here than you have money, so. Well, so far as the first walkthrough. You're saying we can't, you know, if we don't put it in.

4:06:21 Today we lose the ability to do that? I'm just trying to figure out how much we're going to come down to and how much you actually have left to play with out of these monies. Well, I think Shields is just asking as a matter of sequencing to have a further conversation about any match from MLT. You know, we're not allocating all the 3.2 today. That's the question. And it's going to come back at a further point. And I would like to, from my perspective, I would like it to be at the higher end of the priority list on the second round.

4:06:51 And I will reiterate, the only thing I'm really comfortable with, we're having a discussion about moving things forward, the only thing I'm really comfortable with moving forward tonight are the ones that we have to move forward. Because the others we can deal with. Give me more time to get this puny brain of mine to add and subtract. So 270 is moving forward, 500 on road work, and 400 combined infrastructure drainage out of the first group.

4:07:17 Correct. Correct. Yes. That's what we're having to move forward. Rob, can you keep a running town? Yeah, Marty got it. Yeah. I figured you did. Deferred maintenance, we agreed to the $300,000. We're going to hold off on the front end planning to figure out. Right. Okay. And then town commitments and community projects, we're taking out the operating fund reserve right now. We're holding off on the implementation.

4:07:44 We're going forward with the East Village at $200,000, Footsteps of Brilliance at $50,000, enhanced level of TOT enforcement at $50,000, and an MLR Executive Director at $225,000. Correct. All right. Is everybody in agreement with that? Can we get a total math list? $1,995,000, leaving you 1.2 left. That'll be set aside. All right. So that's two-thirds done today. That's good. Good job.

4:08:15 Okay. Okay. Do we need to make... Yeah, if we could get a motion on that, that would be helpful, because we'll actually be amending the budget based on that, and actually that would push some projects forward in the planning and design work. So it would be an allocation of the 1.9... What was the number? 1,995,000 even. So, Mr. Mayor, I move that the Town Council direct staff to allocate project funds as described

4:08:46 Per the totals as documented by the town finance manager. Second. And to bring back. We'll come back with the other items. With the other items. For further review. For further review. Okay. Second. We have a motion to second. Any further discussion? The only piece I know John had kind of thrown in there in that first section that he wanted to make sure that it was noted on trail signage. Yep. Got it. For me, I would just like to make sure it's noted as we come back again.

4:09:16 Some talk about our wayfinding signage program. Again, MLT has talked about potentially funding that. We've also heard some potential commitments from MMSA. So I would just like to suss through that as we go back through the second round. That, to me, was the only thing that was missing. I think that's a comment. I think that's going to be part of the implementation. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, I just want to make sure that that was noted. Thank you. And that's that generally, if there's something else from the other council members, I think.

4:09:42 That we haven't listed that you want to see listed, we can do that. I could use a new truck. You ain't getting a new truck. Okay. Thank you. Okay, we have motion to second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That takes us on to number 12, doesn't it? Yes. Good. Okay. Budget update.

4:10:13 Go ahead. This one is a budget update for where we are for the fiscal 17-18 budget, so next year's budget. As you remember, we got together on May 22nd and talked about what we call at that point a draft budget. And so what I try to do throughout this process is sort of illustrate where we've come from that particular point in time.

4:10:38 And reconcile those revenues we started with where we are today, the adjustments that were made to that. And then just, you know, talk through that. There is, at the very end, I'll kind of jump to the last page, if you will, a request that we are able to proceed with the positions that we have funded, what we're asking for funding for, so that we can begin the recruitment process in a couple of cases immediately.

4:11:04 So that we don't lose any opportunity. So you'll have that question at the end. But let's walk through this as designed here. So the first thing I'd like to do is point out the major revenue components that we have in this particular budget. The budget is slightly more than last year, both in expenditures, around $1.3 million in each of those categories.

4:11:28 For where we sit today, we do have a little bit more work to do because we're not yet in balance, but this particular display today is leading us towards a tentative budget. So we had a draft, we'll have a tentative, and you guys will have another opportunity to take a look at it, but hopefully some of the direction we'll get through that. Revenue components, we've got TOT teed up at $12.5 million this year, which is around 59.2%.

4:11:57 of the total revenue budget. We arrived at that number. If you look at the bottom there, we have a three-year average. And in the staff report, there's a lot more detailed reports that are there. Our five-year average, including this current year projection of 1.6, takes us to a little over 13 million. If you take 95% of that number, it's around 12.5. We feel pretty confident with that as a solid number because we had some softer years in the five-year average, if you will.

4:12:26 We also have some other elements, the TOT penalty and interest, I call that out separately, mainly for how the staff report flows, but those amounts are not necessarily shared with some of our partners in the political commitments we talked about earlier. And talking about property tax, so the number, I'll combine property taxes around 17%, the general fund over 3.5 million. And we receive, you know, updates from Mornan County.

4:12:56 On what that's going to look like this year, and so those updates have been placed in there. We also have a property tax in lieu of $780,000, which is currently still active, but how would you classify that, Dan? In lieu is tied to state funding formulas, and it ties to the county and how it's basic aid for schools and stuff for that in lieu revenue.

4:13:20 It's still a big chunk for us. It's something we watch. And at some point in time, that's the potential for that to go away, depending on the overall economy of the county and the state legislature. We have sales tax. We contract with HDL to provide us some good projections. They're a consulting firm. We take the numbers that they provide and take a little bit off of those so that we're a little more conservative.

4:13:50 In those numbers, but $2.25 million is a good number we expect for sales tax revenue, which is a growth of $250,000. And then, you know, franchise fees pretty much flat. We just, those are rolled in as well as the other revenue, which is everything other than the big rocks we'd like to call out and say those percentages. I did include the percentages on there, so we kind of all talk in the same language about exactly what it looks like, at least from a budgetary standpoint. That'll certainly change as the actuals go because DOT does climb.

4:14:22 Any questions on the revenues? Go ahead. Any questions? So as I described, I was going to take us from the draft to the current. Some of the changes that we did make to the revenue projections, we originally came in with a TOT of $12.8 million. We shaved that off by $300,000 to the $12.5 of the property taxes that I described. We did receive our updates from Mono County, so that actually increased $94,000.

4:14:54 Building permits, a little bit of additional legwork on that. We believe we can raise those up about $25,000 based upon some events that are potentially going to build out. And now the Whitmore Pool reimbursement, we split the cost 50%. We actually removed a mower because it was actually in the vehicle replacement fund. So we did not need to request funds to support that. And then so 50% of the cost of that comes away from reimbursement.

4:15:24 Increased parking citations of $5,000, and we had a miscellaneous state grant in there that we just thought we needed to remove. And then potentially some more investment interest that we anticipate getting on that. So in all, we adjusted the revenue down about $193,000, but the total revenue is expected at $21,103,000. Expense summary. We did a lot of work of breaking down the expense into what is an employee cost and what is an operational cost.

4:15:58 And I do have detailed reports down to department head on essentially where the increases were realized. And in this particular, I'm talking not necessarily where we came from from the draft budget perspective, but where we were prior to prior year, because we like to compare our adopted budget from prior year to our current budget request. It tells us really how much we're increasing. We do have plans to go through a process of looking at

4:16:26 Adopted to modified over the last couple of years to kind of get a sense of how things climb, and we'll definitely have more information as we go through these budgeting processes, but tonight this is really talking about what elements are there for a cost increase. Our total cost increase from prior year budget is $1.37 million on the expense side. It's $66,000 higher than it is from the revenue side. Employee cost is $583,000 of that.

4:16:55 We do have three new positions, two full-time, one part-time position staffed in those numbers. That collective group is $271,000. And then the other incremental costs, and again, I'm not showing all the detail, but essentially around 87% of the expense side benefit costs in retirement also have some significant increases.

4:17:18 The operational side has increased about $787,000. Again, the political commitments of tourism transit or the $296,000 on that vehicle replacement. We do have some needs for a little bit behind in that. We do sort of a review of that account on an annual basis, and we have updates that are made to that based upon inflation and vehicle costs, but just where we are in our overall funding element.

4:17:48 We have built into next year's budgets $243,000, so that's there. We also have a need of about $370,000 we didn't put into our request for this year, but we may have an opportunity we have to fund in the fall with excess, but that's there. Special events funding of $125,000, that's the decision that Council made mid-year last year, so it was not in the original budget. So for apples and apples comparison, I listed that out.

4:18:16 And then an airport, we had a number of elements associated with the FAA terminal, some studies and other processes that were incremental. This is around 96% of the total increase, but keep in mind that there are some reductions that are made elsewhere, so this is really just the bigger components. And again, as I said, as we sit today, we have a variance of expenditures over our revenue projections of about $66,000.

4:18:46 30 basis points or a third of a percent off. So we pretty much feel we can get there, if you will. But that's that update. Rob, can you go back to that real quick? Yep. So just so I'm clear, when you've separated those out, 583 would be the total new employee cost for the three employees you're suggesting.

4:19:12 No. So if I had a total cost increase of $1,370,000, that was split between employee costs of $583,000. That's all employees, not necessarily the three that we're adding. The three that we're adding are the $271,017. Right. That is associated with those three positions.

4:19:36 But is that 271-017 just new staff salaries, or is that new staff all-in? New staff all-in. Okay. So the additional 117 and 122 are just our existing staff plus those three. Those are the additional costs, and the 271 is all-in on those three employees. That's correct. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions on this? Rob?

4:20:03 No, I'm just, are you finding this on your, oh, you're looking at a paper copy as well. Are you finding this on your? That slide is not in the original. Oh, okay. The presentation, the budgeting as we went through this process, this particular presentation was not in the slide that was given to you, or the deck that was given to you. You had a staff report and a significant number of schedules that had prepared to support this.

4:20:33 But this is really sort of a recap of that. Oh, okay. So you won't find it in your paperwork. Copy that. Does employee benefit cost in retirement, but no salary? That's correct, because those were, again, this is not a full reconciliation of that. This is really just the bigger elements of cost. So the total of those three elements is around 87%. The remainder would be in the salary side. As we went through...

4:21:09 We started off with the expenses that we had identified. Again, this is the reconciliation element, and there is a chart in your paperwork that follows along with this. But this is really designed to talk about some of the adjustments that were made. And the key element here that I want to call to your attention is that these are some, in some cases, they were decisions staff made to

4:21:32 Recommend some of these things go into one-time funds because they're really associated with the storm events and excess needs that we have to repair from that that we had currently built into our budgets because, again, we started with a service-level discussion from the expense side, and that's how we ended up with those costs. So some of those were moved over, but some of them are truly decisions that were made to cut down a certain level of expense. And so if there's a strong desire from any of you to add that back,

4:22:02 That's an option for certain that would certainly change our $66,000 reduction variance. What's that? Yeah, that's what we got it down to right now. Yeah, so these, and so it's really, I don't know if it's prudent to walk through these on an individual basis as we've sort of talked about them.

4:22:34 We did have, I will mention some elements of significance. The one officer that we do have as an employee request, it was originally there as a lieutenant, really for some structure and opportunities within the police department. That's been reduced to a sergeant. And so you'll see in the report as we go through what was a wage reduction and then what was a total reduction from that particular

4:23:03 Sort of change that we made. Do you guys want to go through these in detail? I don't know what I'm looking at. I'm looking at attachment B. But is this in our packet? This is not in our packet, right? Yes, this is. The PowerPoint is not in your packet? Okay, so just for future consideration, if somebody's not going to be in the packet, like, I can't see that from here.

4:23:31 Okay. You know what I mean? I just, I can't, I can't read it. If it's my packet, I can follow along. So attachment, I believe. Your packet. Okay. I've actually got it in my packet. You should have that in your packet as attachment B. So let me, let me clarify. There are a number of schedules which are there. You will not see this particular presentation. Right. But I believe it's schedule B.

4:23:50 Yeah, it's attachment B. Okay. This particular slide. Yes. And that is, that's the full list, and what you have here is the same list compartmentalized, because that couldn't fit on one screen. Okay. Okay. So I'm actually not going to read through them on an individual basis. These are, you know, sort of the heavy lifting that's already been achieved. I think you'll have an opportunity, since this is a budget update, to come back after review of your schedules and say that, you know, if there's something of interest, let's bring it back on.

4:24:25 I wanted to call out the staff updates, and again, talking a little bit about timing. So we have the police sergeant. This is the $271,000 calling you were asking about earlier. This is the breakdown for those three positions. Right. The police sergeant of $176,932, that is salary and wages, that's all in. All in. I'm sorry, benefits and retirement and such. Okay. And we really calculated it at a higher level. The retirement funds have either Classic or PEPRA.

4:24:55 And we calculated this on the classic level, so it's sort of the worst case scenario, if you will, in both cases. So we make sure that we cover that process. And I've broken those two down in the descriptions to say hire immediately, you know, really for the public works combination position.

4:25:16 That's critical. That position is critical for the town because it's really a test process of saying we want to have a dynamic workforce where we can have a full-time annual employee that we can shift assignments to throughout the year from snow removal to parks maintenance in the summer. So it's important for us to prove that process out and be successful with it. But the key for the request here is we really have to start recruitment like tomorrow.

4:25:44 On that position in order to get it. We do have an internal recruitment that we believe will be a fairly quick turnaround, but not losing any productivity during the summer. We really need a decision on that one tonight and the approval to move forward with that. That particular position will have a Class A license, so it'll give not only the ability to do the snow removal by the equipment operator in the wintertime, but we currently don't have that other than the supervisor levels of parks today.

4:26:13 So it actually makes it a little bit easier to work through on that particular position. The Public Works Summer Intern, and that's really required based upon the number of projects, and it's an assistant resident engineer. There's a lot of requirements on these projects, especially if they're town projects that labor.

4:26:36 is tracked for the prevailing wages and they spend a lot of time doing the paperwork and they're on site with the construction projects monitoring and keeping track of that information. We do have a pool of qualified applicants which are essentially people who are working towards an engineering degree or college students and so we want to be able to reach out and hire that position fairly quickly so that we capture the individuals in the pool who are looking for jobs but we also have the needs immediately.

4:27:03 And then I listed the sergeant. Really, that's a very, it's kind of a long-term process to secure a position of that level. We have, you kind of go through a lot of recruitment. There's a lot of training elements that you have to make sure that are in place. We believe that if we begin a higher July, that we probably would have someone around late August would be the time frame for that.

4:27:29 But, yeah, start now, essentially, you would have one for probably fully engaged by late August. And as I mentioned earlier, we did reduce this down to a sergeant, but the critical thing here is it still provides us with supervision at all staff points. Right now, we have, you know, sort of an officer in charge designation where that's a little bit vulnerable for us. But by having a sergeant, a supervisory, and one officer in place,

4:27:57 That's very helpful. So this is an incremental position because this is a sort of a working supervisor. So they are out doing patrols, which will help us reduce fatigue and potential challenges with overtime, if you will. So it's a strong position. It's very costly, but it's needed. And I think the sergeant is sort of the minimum.

4:28:22 Yeah, it was about $38,000 all in that we thought it was going to be. How, when you say summer intern, how long do they work?

4:28:43 If they're coming from college, it's just during their college break? They'd be starting right shortly here, and then they'd be wrapping up end of August versus September, so it's just for that summer break, if you will, from college. Doesn't 15,000 seem a little high for an intern? I forget the hourly rate that we're having them in there, Grady. What's that? 15.50 an hour, and they'll be working full summer, so masks out. Maybe I should do that.

4:29:13 Yeah, I was about to say. Yeah, and that's all in, too, right? Yeah. Okay. And this 271 that is in the budget, I mean, you've... Yes. Okay. Yeah, so that's... So these three positions are currently built into the budget. All right. So sort of just a real quick recap, things that we're looking to confirm tonight is that our $12.5 million TOT...

4:29:47 Is you guys are comfortable with that? And again, I was asked that you go back through the provided sheets and see if there's any expenses that we remove that you'd like to add back, understanding that that will widen our deficit of $66,000. And most crucially, authorization to proceed with those, the recruitments that we have listed out. All right. Any questions on that? I just have a, I just.

4:30:15 I'm concerned about I see the need to hire folks and to bring them in to do it. I'm concerned about the sustainability of it. And I just have a real concern about that. I don't know what we can do about it, but it goes back to coming up with a revenue solution for this organization.

4:30:41 So that we can have the staff that we need and not be worrying about, gee, we'll have a bad year two years down the road. Right, and that's why we've been very conservative with our TOT. I understand. And, you know, 12.5 million is, I think, a very conservative number. 12.8, I think, is actually conservative, too, but I think it's more prudent for us to go to 12.5 and see if we can't live within those means.

4:31:12 Based on, you know, I look at this year as an anomaly, quite honestly. So, you know, I want to take a look at the previous four years and say, okay, you know, there are going to be some add-ons to it, I mean, revenue-wise, but, you know, it's not going to be, I don't think, $5 million a year. I don't want to budget for that. So I'm very comfortable with $12.5 million.

4:31:40 And based on that, within the expenses and the $271,000, what it gets us, and we're only $66,000 off, I don't think we're in a bad position, quite honestly. We have a lot more work to do on trying to figure out individual things, and I think it's going to be an ongoing discussion, but I think we have to make some decisions tonight.

4:32:10 I'm good. I'm good with it. Are you? Go ahead. I was just going to say for me, like I've got questions, comments, concerns, I'll probably hold them all. So if you want to go to public and then come back. Okay. I'll say some things. I don't know if you have any questions. Any public comment? Public's commenting, so. You good, Ted? And I just say we're not done with the process, but we do have some key points here to allow us to build the rest of the budget. Right. That's why we're requesting some of this direction tonight. Right.

4:32:41 Yeah, I'm very comfortable at the 12.5. I think that's very conservative. Looking back at not just the last five, but the last 10 years, if you fix it for inflation, I think the 12.5 is a very good, solid number, even if we have a low snow year. I am actually fairly committed to these three positions because they are all very needed. The Public Works Parks hybrid is something that I was sort of pushing for.

4:33:09 To get out of the need to hire temps for snow removal in the wintertime because you can't find them. So if this works, this hybrid position may be something we want to consider for more of our workforce. So I'm very comfortable personally moving all three of these forward. But that's the only piece I'm comfortable moving forward from the...

4:33:34 12.5 versus 12.8 on down. I am very comfortable moving these three positions forward. Okay. Any other comments? I got some comments. Yeah, go ahead. Please call. So we're good with public, I suppose? Yeah. Okay. You know, first of all, you know, I think the...

4:33:56 The way that this process has been done, I really appreciate. We've had multiple cracks at it. We've had opportunities to speak with staff. And I think it's obviously one of the most important things that we do. So the amount of times we've had to look at this makes me feel comfortable. I think to arrive at this point where we still have another couple of shots at it and only be at a $66,000 deficit puts us in a really good position.

4:34:23 It's going to be easy to figure out. As far as the specific policy directions you're asking for, I think one of the things that this council has done well has been to conservatively budget. It's put us in a position where we've had overages in the last couple of years and we've had good years. That being said, I'm...

4:34:46 Very comfortable with an increase from 11.6 to 12.5. You know, I kind of worked through some numbers on my own and just my rationale for arriving at that number was I think that our summers are going to be relatively stable. I see us as probably achieving our revenues from this past summer, which was our best summer ever.

4:35:07 You know, 15, 16 fiscal year. I think realistically we will probably meet or exceed that. But I think in a conservative manner, I looked at that summer period, which is basically, you know, I put winter is December through March and the summer is the rest of the year. So essentially April through November and took, you know, looking at last year's summer, which was basically six, nine at a 95 percent level.

4:35:36 Which brings us to 6-5. So, you know, I think that's fairly conservative for me personally on the summer side of things to take 95% of what we did last year. Define summer. Again, it's everything that doesn't include December through March. So I did, you know, for my budgeting purposes and wrapping my head around it, I said basically April through November. And looking at that period and saying 95% of what we did last year.

4:36:03 So to me, I'm comfortable and conservative with that. Then, you know, I still think that we have a good bit of volatility in that December to March timeframe, which unfortunately is, you know, above 50% of our revenue. So that's an area where I think we need to be more conservative. And I basically added in our last really terrible snow year, which was a couple years back. And the amount...

4:36:28 That came through during that time frame in fiscal year 14-15 was 5.9. So I took 95% of last summer, which was a good summer and added a bad winter into that because I think that that could happen very likely in the next couple of years. And that comes out at 12.538. So, you know, I think that's where I arrived at that number. I'm pretty comfortable moving forward at 12.5.

4:36:56 So that's my rationale for that. I do think that I'm comfortable with the additional positions. A lot of my talk with staff was really around the difference between wants and needs. I think we have a lot of things that would be an improvement to our staff, but I really wanted...

4:37:16 People to focus on what do we really need. And I think that the three positions identified are our biggest needs right now. And if we're comfortable increasing our budget from 11-6 to 12-5, I'm comfortable with those three positions and the piece that takes from it. What I do need a little bit of your help with, Rob, if you could go back to the slide where we talk about the additional cost, the 1.3 million.

4:37:48 Help me to understand this. In your breakdown of that $1.3 million, those are additional costs year over year. That's correct. That's from... That's correct. That's against the adopted budget that we started with last year. Okay. Oh, adopted. Yeah, if you look at attachment D in your packet in there, it gives a break out of that. But that was an adopted to adopted comparison, so we could see where the budget grew to. Right, right. Okay. So we're saying...

4:38:18 Of that 1.3, the additional cost increase would be $583,000. For employees. For employees only. For employees only. Correct. So that $583,000 includes $271,000 and actual salary and benefit increases to the three new employees. Correct. The $117,000 and the $122,000 are essentially year-over-year increases to our existing staff.

4:38:46 Correct. Right? So that's like retirement and health costs. If you took the 271 out of the 583, that is the true cost of your existing employees year over year? Right, which is basically, what, 312? Yeah. Yeah. So our year over year, if we don't add those three positions and we just say we're going to keep our existing staff and move it forward to next year, our incremental increase is 312,000.

4:39:14 For this current year and will likely be more next year based upon PERS and unfunded liability, yes. But that's kind of the general ballpark that we're looking at right now. And even that 312 number does kind of include the three additional positions. So if you kind of took those out, that's a small increment. It's probably close to like between 3 and 350, right? Just for round numbers? Yes. So we're saying that our increased staff costs are going to be $3,000 to $350,000 annually.

4:39:42 As of right now, and it could go up, it could go down, which it probably won't. Yeah, I just want to, your very intelligent analysis of summer plus winter and a bad year at 12.5. Right. We've sort of got our, bought ourselves a year. Right. Right? But that, again, it goes back to...

4:40:02 We bought ourselves a little bit of time to come up with a revenue solution going forward so that we can sustainably do what we got to do. Yeah, and I think, you know, that was kind of where I'm arriving at that, you know, we talk about this concept of a structural deficit, which I think is a little bit of a misnomer. It's not really a structural deficit that we're dealing with. It's just very significant increased costs on a year-over-year basis that we have to find a way to wrangle.

4:40:25 Because if our TOT doesn't continue to escalate at that rate and our costs just go up to the tune of $350,000 a year, we are going to run into a problem down the road. And that's my point about the sustainability of this. Appreciate it. It's needed.

4:40:43 Right. But I'm just looking at do I think that 12-5 is sustainable moving forward? I do. So that gives us some time. If 12-5 is the number five years out and those $300,000 increases come on an annual basis, then we're in an untenable situation again. The second piece that I'm trying to figure out is total operational cost increase of $787,000. Give me more understanding and elaboration on that.

4:41:12 If you go to your packet on attachment D, it gives the details. Which one? Attachment D. D, okay. Page 134 of the packet. Yeah. It gives the details on that. So there's a lot of ups and downs in this one, different things that drive that. We had an insurance increase from California Joint Powers Insurance Authority. We've had, you know, we added in the special event dollars into this. There's a number of things that,

4:41:42 Move through that. So it's a variety of items that end up hitting that. We had a larger transfer to the airport for supporting operations. There's a number of elements. I mean, you can walk through all of these. Yeah, actually, I mean, in clarity, that's just by department. That doesn't really give you the detail of what it was. So on the slide, which unfortunately you do not have, I went through the...

4:42:05 One of the slides you do have is the actual detailed budget for Fund 100. And so you'll see in there, really, that's truly the line item detail. However, what I tried to call out here was to say that here are the very distinct items that are causing most of that impact. So the tourism and transit effect is $296,000 of that number. We had vehicle replacement effect of $245,000, $43,000.

4:42:35 And there are special events of $125,000. And again, the airport of $95,000. Those four elements is 96%. Those are major components. Yeah. That's 96% of that $783,000. Right. So, but what I'm basically trying to get to the bottom of is I understand that we're having a $583,000 increase in staff this year because a big portion of that $271,000 is increased bodies. Correct. So if we move forward beyond $17,000, $18,000.

4:43:03 18, 19, etc. Presumably, the additional staff cost increases will be in that kind of $350,000 range moving forward-ish. That, to me, is something that we can't control. That's correct. So, what I'm trying to figure out, you know, the bigger number there is that 787.

4:43:26 To what degree can that really be our area of focus? I mean, if we're looking at a $1.4 million increase year over year, we run out of time quick. If we're looking at a $350,000 increase year over year, it's a whole different ballgame. So I'm just trying to really have a better understanding of those total operational cost increases. And so you've broken those out to a pretty good degree, I guess.

4:43:52 So those are very controllable, okay? Because the political commitments of transit and tourism are directly tied to the revenue level. Right. So it essentially climbs with the revenue, but it's just important to call that out because it does increase the expenses when you do increase the revenues. But that one is tied specifically to a revenue availability. The decisions on the vehicle replacement, that's...

4:44:18 We determine that based upon the life cycle of the vehicles and such. We can make some adjustments and we can make some policy decisions on that if we need to. The 125 pure council decision. Sure. So I would say that the operational costs as they're large are mostly completely controllable. Okay. That's what I was trying to get to the bottom. For the most part. Okay. All right.

4:44:42 I understand. Yeah, you know, I think for the policy discussion, I'm good with the 12-5. I'm good with the positions. I'm comfortable with making up a $66,000 shortfall. I just want us as a council to be aware of, you know, we do have some increasing costs, which are significant, but, you know, what's controllable and what's kind of out of our control. Right. And I liked your presentation on how you got to the 12-5. Yeah, because it also helps to target if that certainty,

4:45:12 Summer, the non-winter, whatever that thing is, those are things we may be able to invest in. Yeah, and it's probably winter and non-winter. Yeah, the non-winter, that's something, there's things we could do with some of our partners that maybe enhance that and do some things with that. All right. So, do I have any more questions or comments on this? Good. Okay. What do you need from us? Confirmation on the $12.5 million, that was the request.

4:45:42 And then really the authority to move forward on the personnel. Do you need the motion? That would be very beneficial. Okay. I'll entertain a motion on the 12-5 motion. So moved. We will build a tentative budget on a 12.5 million base. We'll build a budget for 17-18 on a 12-5 budget. So seconded. Okay. We have two motions and a second. Okay. Further discussion on this?

4:46:16 Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. That'll take us on to the three positions. Oh, yes. Yeah, the request would be to move forward with the recruitment of that with the police sergeant to be hired after the fiscal year, the other two to be hired prior to the beginning of the fiscal year. So moved. Second. Two so moves and a second. Roll call.

4:46:47 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. You're good? Okay. With that, we'll adjourn to a closed session immediately. The blue room. Can we have the closed session? Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Pardon me? Can we have it in my living room?

4:47:22 I just wanted to bring something, so I didn't have to borrow you. I know, I appreciate that. I just felt really bad about that.