Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2017
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 50 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
243 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:17 Oh, okay. Plug it into the USB, I think. You could have this one. Or maybe not. Oh, yeah, don't plug into the USB. It seems like if it's not plugged in. Mine works. Mine, test, test, test. This one's working. Testing. It's just recalibrating is all. Now it's ready. Ready? I'll call to order the Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors meeting, special meeting on June 13th. Roll call.
1:51 We have a quorum. And Larry Johnson and Lindsay and Giselle should be on her way. Public comments? If there are no public comments, we'll move to the approval of the minutes from May 1. Any corrections, deletions? Are there any changes? I'll move to approve or submitted. I'll second. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye.
2:31 We'll move to agenda item five, approval of minutes from June five, regular board meeting, discussion, corrections. Nothing for me. We'll have to wait for that one. We'll have to wait for that one. Giselle's not here, and so we won't have a quorum to vote on that. Okay. Without Giselle being. We'll hold that, and we'll wait for, we'll take a five-minute break. We can come back to it next meeting.
3:02 Need to do a five minute break. Don't want to jump into the other item. Do you want to go to the closed session? We don't have a closed session. Oh, I'm sorry, that's in the minutes. We already did that. Kirk needs a break. Okay, go ahead. Did do the approval of the minutes and we're on agenda item number six. I'll call the meeting back to order. Agenda item six.
3:45 John, you requested this? I did. Thank you very much. And thanks ever to the board and the staff for making the time to come together. I think we've got some public here interested in these things. This is an important topic. What I wanted to discuss is first to apologize. The council didn't get to this until about 10.15 on Wednesday night. We had an important but perhaps
4:12 lengthy discussion about landscaping and flowers and beautification that went on a little bit too long. And so we didn't get to this, but I could have a sense that people would have a lot of questions about this item. And I thought it was important to bring it back to this board to clearly identify exactly what the question is that's in front of the council.
4:37 And I wanted to do that because I think this is a very important item. And I'm concerned about making sure that the council is going to be able to engage with this specifically and with focus. And I think it would be to the detriment of this item. And, you know, Council Member Ferney, our primary motivation in this is to get more money to housing.
5:04 is to do a recalibration of the Measure A funds coming out of the bankruptcy. Housing is a dire need right now. We have to do everything we can to try to make that happen. And there's a lot of technical stuff in the item. There's a lot of housekeeping. There's a lot of little rabbit holes that people could go down into, which is fine. But I wanted to give the board an opportunity to ask me any questions and maybe kind of talk through a lot of this stuff.
5:31 Because I think it's going to be very important that when the council considers this item next week, that the comments coming from the public, coming from the MLH board and others is clear and is focused. I would point out that at our last council meeting, one of the council members advised that
5:47 She is not supportive of the idea of delivering services through NGOs based on her votes on the MLR contract and these kinds of things. And it should not be assumed that while the town is delivering services using this model, it's not a gimme, for lack of a better way of putting it. So that being said, what I did was, I mean, we can proceed however you want to do this, Kirk. I brought
6:15 I can hand this out to folks. This is how it's proposed that the council address this item. I can get some extra copies if you guys want to see it. So these are the eight kinds of, this is the framework for the discussion of the council and for the basis of how we're going to talk about it and engage with it. And if it would be helpful, we could have any discussion you want to have.
6:38 I'm saying we should do this in any particular way, but it might be helpful at some point to just walk through these eight questions so you understand what the questions are, why they're on the agenda, and what the questions are to the council. I'm going to ask the board, how do you want to proceed? Well, you know, I've been through the agenda bill, looked at the materials. I really only have a question in one area. For the most part,
7:13 Well, not for the most part. I really, you know, commend the work that you and Council Member Fernie did, both in creating the document that will be really useful going forward, and in, quite frankly, expressing the strong support for reestablishing funding for housing. I, you know, to me, that's all good. And there's really no part of this.
7:39 Right now that I disagree with except for the part that I mentioned in the note that I sent related to the reserves. And so that's the discussion item for me. I don't know how the other board members feel. What do you mean by the reserve? Are they the $200,000? Or are you talking about the money that the council is going to hold back when there's excess revenues? Well, you know.
8:07 There's two reserves. Actually, there are two issues. Well, there's three reserves. Well, there are two issues for me. One is our operational reserve. And I understand why the council or the committee may have felt that that was a good idea. But I think that the operational reserves, that number is kind of arbitrary because different organizations have different needs.
8:33 Depending on what your cash flow is, your budget is, you may need a larger reserve or a smaller operational reserve. And then there's a reserve for projects. And I guess my concern, as I expressed it, is that depending on where that reserve is held and who has control over it, you may encourage or discourage the NGO. Just talk to us.
9:02 This may apply to the other ones too, but it makes it more difficult for us to do long-term capital planning and to be responsive if A, we have to go back to the town to ask for the reserves and B, if we actually don't know that those reserves are reliably there because other parties may actually be
9:32 Looking to dip into the same reserves for similar purposes. And since we don't know who those parties might be, it somewhat gets to a role and function discussion. Typically since MLH was formed, we've been the development arm and the town has essentially been the policy and regulatory arm. And those two roles didn't collide except on a couple of occasions when
10:02 We were asked to opine on the regulatory side. But in general, you guys control the zoning, you control the decisions about grant applications through the town, those kinds of things. And we are the ones who are out doing the development, looking for the opportunities, making that stuff happen. It's harder for us. So anyway.
10:30 Before we get too deep into the weeds, that's my issue. And I don't know if anybody else has any other issues that they'd like to discuss out of these. So I want to say one thing to that issue, which is in terms of the sequencing and the timing of this, that those are entirely legitimate questions. And they are questions that need to be resolved.
10:59 going forward. And if you look at one of the questions here in the agenda bill, one of the, as you know, MLH and the town, we don't have a contract in place between the two organizations that is, I think, satisfactory to all parties. And I think that that's something that we need as we go into a new era now with housing and the unique kinds of demands.
11:23 That are coming to housing. I think Council Member Fernie and I in the town look forward to engaging with MLH on a contracting discussion that's going to be primarily informed by the strategic, the action plan work that's happening, that's underway right now. And I think that I was one Council Member, I'm looking forward to seeing what comes out of that effort so that we can write a contract scope of work and deliverables that's consistent.
11:51 That's what's coming out of an action plan. And I think the other piece about this is to really reemphasize that the way that the town and all of our partners are going to deliver these very important services, whether it's for housing, transit, or for recreation, we have to work together to deliver this stuff. We cannot work as individual fiefdoms and silos. We have to be leveraging each other's capacities and resources.
12:21 And I think that this is something that we're looking forward to going through the strategic, the action plan process and figuring out what comes out of that and writing a contract that reflects that so that we can move forward in a way that's going to deliver housing for the community because ultimately that's the ultimate thing that we have to do together is deliver housing for the community.
12:43 And so, in terms of the sequencing of this, those questions are legitimate and important questions. But I think, Council Member Ferney and I think that from our role, from a fiduciary role, the Council for Public Money, these kinds of issues, that getting the, you know, we're looking at getting $817,000 to housing from Measure A, and currently it's at $542,000.
13:10 So we want to go back, recalibrate, reset things based on what came out of the debacle of the bankruptcy and all that kind of stuff. Get that set up first and then all these other questions, engage with these questions going forward. Okay, well anyway, back to the first question. I still don't know if the other board members have other questions. Sure. And this is the time I'm ready to sink my teeth into this one. No, I think I...
13:39 Let's do it now because I think it's really important that when MLH steps up with this agenda item next week that whatever it is you guys want to say, it's clear and it's focused and it's giving very specific comment to the council on this item because I think it's important that the council have a clear and focused decision and come to make a good decision. I think we're getting a lot of distractions and stuff. It could be difficult to do that. So do we have any other? Sure. There's the public comment too, but you take that whenever you want.
14:12 Pardon? There's a public comment as well, but you obviously take that whenever you feel appropriate. I appreciate it. You know, various fiefdoms and juggling and the money's out there. Everybody's cost is most important to them. Tourism, of course, has been those that my concern is that how the money is allocated. And clearly, tourism is the first.
15:11 Lou, can I ask you to step up to the microphone? Yeah, sure. I think, is that on? No, it's not on. I don't think it's turned on, so push a little power back. There we go. Thankfully. My question or concern really centers around the chicken and the egg.
15:41 Which comes first? The tourism and driving the tourists here? Or is it that we need to create the housing in order to facilitate the visions for an enhanced town and the visitors that will come with this enhanced vision that the mountain and Aspen Corp and whatnot have? And clearly the mountain is
16:09 of the belief, the management is of the belief that with development, dollars will then be allocated for housing. And I think that that's where we're going to be in trouble, that we need to create the housing, which will dovetail with the construction and the enhancement that the mountain visualizes, whether it's
16:38 Up at Eagle Lodge or tearing down the main lodge, whatever the case might be, we don't have the staff and we don't have the staff to facilitate the vision that the mountain has. And if we don't have the staff, we certainly don't have the housing. And so if we're going to be successful at creating this enhanced vision for our town, we have to have the housing paramount first in the allocations of money.
17:07 And you somewhat stated that you and Fernie are of the belief that this is an important topic. You alluded that the other female council member wasn't so in favor of monies being allocated. So I'm just concerned that you're throwing some money back towards housing, but it's just a pittance. And that we
17:38 Really need to think about reallocating the whole formula, possibly, so that, again, the chicken and the egg formula or chicken and egg discussion is such that housing is the first component that needs to be addressed. Do you want me to address that just a little bit? I don't want to, because this is a meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, so I think we probably want to stay focused on those issues. But the... But your point is that you want to go back to your council members and you want to have a clear vision.
18:09 to present to them or to answer questions. I want to make sure that the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board has an opportunity to discuss this item as it affects housing and so that the comments or the questions or whatever it is that Mammoth Lakes Housing wants to advise of the council is clear and focused because I think we don't want to, I don't want to risk not getting the additional $300,000 or whatever year it is.
18:34 I want to make sure that that happens. In the larger context, which we won't get into a whole lot here, the reason that tourism gets more money is it has to do with being consistent with the voters' intent. Right. I understand that. And so the council, if we go through these questions as part of why honoring what voters voted originally, I think once we get these things recalibrated,
18:54 Down the road, in consultation with a variety of partners, in consultation with identifying community needs, there's an opportunity to maybe do something with these things, but we have to do it together and we have to do it not arbitrarily. I think that Council Member Ferney and I feel like this is probably as far as we're willing to go with this particular question, with this item, now. But then down the road, there may be other things to do, but we wanted to address this first. Because you feel that's your best...
19:22 Possible success is asking for just that amount. It's an important place to start. And we've heard, I've sat on this board now for, I don't know how long, but we've heard repeatedly that this issue of the Measure A money not going to housing was a real problem. Yep. And we believe that it is. And so we think we want to start with an initial step. Let's make things whole, consistent with the voters' intent from the late 80s and 90s. Let's start with that. Let's do some housekeeping and then...
19:50 Get this thing moving forward. But this is just the first step. There will be many other steps. And as you're aware, there's this action plan housing thing that's going on right now. There will be policy items coming back to the council in the fall. That's going to really inform, I think, what the horsepower is that we're going to need to be able to try to successfully take this stuff on. So this is a first step. And you're thinking that that horsepower will inform the general public?
20:17 Better? Or Council more fully? Everybody. These are open public meetings. Jennifer can give you more information about that. They're all open public meetings. And all this stuff will happen in public sessions and public meetings. Thank you. Thank you. John, the town manager's agenda bill identifies on page 6, $330,000. Hang on, hang on, hang on. Give me a second. Page 6. Is that PDF page 6?
21:01 It's his agenda bill. Is it the handwritten number or is it the, where'd you get that from? Was it, was that in the packet? Down at the summary. Okay. Give me one second. Let me pull that up. Yeah, it should be, oh no, that's right. The staff, look at the staff report. So number six at the bottom of the page? Yeah. Well, it's under the summary. Tourism gets. Right. It's reflective of that. Yeah. Except that it says guaranteed base allocation 3-3.
21:55 Which is it? I mean, the town manager is saying it's $3.30 for housing, and up here, it's talking about $8.17. So we're talking about, from the high level, the program areas from Measure A, tourism, marketing, and housing. So this would reallocate to $8.17 to housing. This is not to the MLH current contract. It would be...
22:23 The housing, the tax dollars going to housing would be 817. We're not talking about, with this agenda item, we're not talking about contracts with NGOs. And that's, I mean, you... So who controls the difference between the 330 and the 817? The Town Council. Town Council. So we have to, if we want to buy a commercial...
22:50 piece, and we need $500,000, we come to the council and ask? Correct. And the difference between, so if I look at, you have a 2017-18 budget of $12,500, and I'm just using these as numbers. You're projected for $16,17 at $17,500, which would generate about $1,300,000 for one point TOT. Sure.
23:20 So looking again back at 16 to look again back at or looking forward at 17, 18, you know, that's 330,000. So every time we want to do a purchase or anything else, we need to come before council and ask. If anything that's beyond what the 330, which that's what's in place currently, right? If we go through the strategic process,
23:49 We come up with a plan that says this is how we're going to really start to try to tackle housing on a long-term committed basis on behalf of the community and that would need to change and that informs the contract between the town and MLH, then that can change. But the funds would be in a reserve account held by the town. And this goes to two things. The first thing is if you look at the 12-5, what we've seen over the last couple years is
24:17 The town budgeting how much TOT money is going to come to the town in a very conservative way. And the last two years, the actual money that's coming in has been off the charts. That's a nice thing. The idea that it's important for the public and for the tax dollars to not have a mechanism whereby just because a lot more TOT comes in, it automatically goes out to contractors. That doesn't provide...
24:45 Council Member Ferney and I feel it does not provide an appropriate level of oversight for that public money when in MLT's situation, which is not MLH's situation, MLT's situation, you have reserves of public money, you know, kind of piling up in their bank accounts that that board would say, well, we can't even spend all this money, what are we going to do with it? So the council's got to look at that and say, that's not...
25:07 That's not an appropriate state of affairs for MLT, for the public, for the council. We've got to recalibrate that. We've got to rebalance that kind of stuff. So it's coming out of that sort of motivation to make sure that we're not putting NGOs in a position where they're building up large reserves on their balance sheets that are not accessible, not easily accessible by the public. Well, I think there's a couple things, because this is my point.
25:36 I actually think that, one, this year is anomalous. I mean, we hope it's not, but so far it's anomalous. Well, the last two years, I mean, it's, you know. But what MLT may or may not do with its reserves really should have no bearing on MLH. And, you know, we actually have identified projects where we can spend money, but we don't.
26:06 Necessarily have access to the money either because it wasn't allocated. Well, primarily because it wasn't allocated to housing. It didn't wind up in the housing reserve. But even more so, we don't have really the flexibility. And when we do have reserves, we use those for housing-related purposes. And having a large cushion, say a million-dollar cushion, gives us the ability to deal with a project. Because, you know, you can't go out and buy housing
26:35 You know, $50,000 reserve. It's just, it's useless. Right, but is it a problem, though, if the money is held by the town, if MLH identifies a project and says, we want to access those funds? It's a problem for two reasons. Well, yeah, I'd say two. The first one is, it's just one more step in the process. And if we're in the
27:04 Position of Negotiating. That's something we do in closed session. It's price and terms. If we have to go to you and say, here's how much we need, it's now out of closed session. And so it does deprive us of immediacy and flexibility. But another concern, and it's actually, I have to go to page five of the staff report.
27:37 The reserve account may serve as a cushion against economic declines. A reserve for project and program funding by the town and or our partners, which implies to me that the town can dip into the reserve, which means we can't count on it. And the next one says NGOs, JPA, or the town may propose to use the funds for projects and programs, the area of dedicated revenue, which means, once again, parties other than MLH.
28:07 May actually be able to propose against that reserve. Sure. But that becomes a problem for the same reason. If we're trying to do strategic planning long range and we don't actually know that there's a reliable source out there because somebody else could come in and use it for some related purpose, then it hamstrings our ability to do effective long range strategic planning because
28:36 We don't know what's going to be there. Even if it's in the account today, we don't know that it'll be there two years from now. And certainly, as you know from the trails, building up some capital reserves for construction eventually gives you the power to do something significant. Sure. And you mentioned oversight. And obviously you're on the board.
29:06 Council has a seat on the board. The council has a level of direct oversight. And they also have the ultimate power that if it turns out that we're not following the mission, not being effective, whatever, we can turn the spigot off. We also have the audit, the annual audit. Yeah. I mean, there's a bunch of points, and it's a public meeting. And when we do our budgeting, when we're doing our prioritization, the public can be here and watching.
29:37 Be part of the process. It's not like it's behind closed doors. So, my sense is, and I wish I had a PowerPoint. Mr. Baccia played something for Rotary the other morning with Colin Powell on leadership. And there was a segment where he said, if you're going to be an effective leader, councils, you need to delegate.
30:08 And you need to provide resources. If you can't provide the resources, don't delegate. Right. And I think these are all very important points. And I don't want to... I think that they all need to be addressed. And I would say there are two perspectives on this. There's the contractor and there's the contractee. And I think that we're coming out of a very long and difficult and very dark period with the town. And I think...
30:34 If we go back to the decisions the previous council made back in 2011, 2012 with the options they had in front of them, given the bankruptcy and all these other kinds of things, they made decisions at the time that made sense at the time. It's five years later. We're in a different era and we're in a different age. And I think that our desire and motivation with this is to start now addressing the demands and the challenges of a new era. And I think that
31:04 These are all important and significant issues that will need to be addressed. But what we have to do is we have to do this one step at a time. And nothing in this with the reserve policy, I don't think what you're actually talking about is a reserve policy. I think when we're talking about a reserve, we're talking about an operational reserve. There were two, like I said, there were two components. One was the operational reserve. And I think that's something we need to work through and make sure it's appropriate level. Sure.
31:33 The other is the reserve that the town is holding for other uses. And that's the one we were just discussing. Sure. And I think that the particular case of housing, and I think, again, what's going to come out of this strategic process, this action plan project that we're going through, these types of things should be incorporated into that discussion so that when we're looking at this at the end of the day, it is a holistic
32:01 Action Plan that leverages the resources that MLH has to bring to the table. It leverages the authorities that the town has to bring to the table so that we are working together to deliver housing for the benefit of the community. And honestly, over the years, really up until the lawsuit, that's how we worked. Exactly. I understand. And it worked very well. So I think we can get back there. Okay, so what the point is, you hit the key point, we have to get back there.
32:28 If that's what I've learned in life, in my limited experience in life, you never get back to anything. You're always going forward. So what this... So I think we can do better. Okay, so this proposal is, this proposal is to start the step to defining the capacity that this community will have to deliver housing on behalf of the community. So this is the first step. So again, Mike, you can, MLH can do whatever it wants to do at the council meeting next week.
32:58 But I would just encourage to understand that we're taking this one step at a time. Questions. Sure. Because I get that. One is, does that mean that MLH should not be suggesting at the council meeting that the full amount be allocated to the NGO rather than held on reserve? You can do, MLH can do. Otherwise, I think, at least for myself, I'm in total agreement with this.
33:26 Well, I think what might make sense is to say, and I don't want to put any words in anybody's mouth, but say we understand that this is a step, that this is a step that's part of a larger process that's trying to get us to effectively deal with the housing challenges that we have in this community. And this is a step.
33:45 It's totally appropriate to point out that we think that issues about the differentiator between an operational reserve and a reserve and a capital fund to be able to do things, that these are details and things that need to be worked out. But I would caution on making those kinds of concerns contingent upon the council supporting taking this step. Because I think what I'm sharing with you is that nothing that's in this agenda item
34:14 is going to be, you know, it's not locking anybody into something for the next five years. So what's the strategic objective to keeping the capital reserves in the town and how does that best serve development of housing? Because we haven't had a discussion about how it would not
34:40 How it would not serve the interests of housing. And at this point, as one council member, I have an obligation ultimately to the taxpayers. This is all the taxpayers' money. And I think if there's ever a question of deferring on one side or the other for transparency, for accounting, and be able to give a full accounting where things are at, I'm going to go on the side of being transparent and providing the mechanisms of accountability to the public. So if we start off with this...
35:06 And this is how this thing proceeds. If coming out of the Strategic Action Plan process, it's determined that in order to be effective for housing, these reserves have to be directed in a different manner. And there's a very specific rationale that makes sense as to why that makes sense, and that's going to further the interest of housing. We will have that discussion, and these things can be addressed at the appropriate time. Unfortunately, trying to address all of this, the kinds of things you're bringing up now,
35:34 In terms of this one agenda item, it's not digestible. We won't be able to take on all of these things at once. I see it as being relatively simple, so I guess I'm... But anyway, because it gets back to the goal of what's going to enable housing, enable us, this NGO, assuming you're in agreement that we're really the development arm.
36:00 Well, that's another question, because you pointed out something in your letter about competing authorities, and we had, there are, the MLH has a closed session item that they're pursuing a project, the town has a closed session item, we're pursuing an item, we obviously can't talk about these things, but it's not clear to one council member, I think to the council as a whole, is exactly where the authorities for these kinds of things lie. And this is part of...
36:25 That's a huge concern to me. I understand that. It's a huge concern to me. And I think this is something that in the contracting, in getting a contract in place, again, coming out of this action plan, this strategic process, to really make clear who is doing what so that we can deliver housing for the community. And I'm not convinced that we have that. I don't think we have that in place right now. I think we did. Yeah. When? Oh, we did. Prior to the...
36:50 I'd say prior to the airport litigation. Okay, that was, what year was that? I think it's documented in the draft report we received. I think it's documented in the, every dollar that we received in TOT, we've turned into $8.50 by leveraging it. It's the 113 units we've built. And all of that is not an MLH legacy.
37:12 That's a town and MLH legacy that we have done together. I don't think your first statement about like silos, I don't think that's true. I don't think that was a problem. Silos actually, you know, there's two ways of looking at silos. And that is saying, well, if my responsibility is legislative and your responsibility is development, then we're in silos. And I don't actually agree with that. I mean, I think if we're communicating and we understand.
37:40 It's, you know, just like, you know, you don't want the sales manager wandering down onto the manufacturing floor and starting to tell people what to do. You do have to have some division of roles, but ultimately everybody knows you're building a car. And so likewise, you know, I don't think that we're talking silos when we say clearly defined roles. No, we're not. But I think that
38:08 I've been on the council since, what is this, 18, so since 2014. It's as, you know, any exercise in democracy is an effort in continual, persistent, and ongoing reinvestment in that process. And I think that we are at that point now where we have to revisit, reinvest,
38:37 And do the work necessary to set up a delivery mechanism for housing for the next, you know, decades. And we're just at that point. And I think it's...
38:50 I don't, I think it's really important to do that. So I think that this is a step in that process. And I think it's important, I think these are all, you know, intelligent, perfectly legitimate issues. And nothing about this, if this thing is adopted, nothing in adopting this doesn't preclude any of that. So, by adopting this, we are not committing to the town holding the,
39:20 What I'll call a capital reserve. Yes. If we pass this, if this passes, any excess number, any TOT number that comes in, in excess of the contracted amounts that the town contracts with parties to deliver services, any excess funds will go into accounts in the town, in the town's budget that clearly say how much...
39:42 What the balance is of these accounts. And just let me finish real quick. So the contracts that the town holds with parties who are delivering these services, the value of these contracts will be guaranteed. So we're not going up and down like this. It's a steady, reliable stream of funding coming to our contractors to be able to deliver these services. That further discussion about
40:07 If that, if it's going to impair the delivery of housing for the community, to maintain that reserve in that account, and that's demonstrated through this action plan process, it's clear that that's, we have to make changes to that policy in order to further the interest of housing, and the council agrees to do it, then that's something that's entirely possible. And so you don't want to have...
40:33 This discussion in front of the whole council? I would prefer not to. I think it would be, I think, again, if MLH, if you guys think this is important and this is kind of a hill to die on and you want to do that, you're entirely within your rights to do that. I just, I worry that...
40:48 I'm looking at this, I think, Fernie and I are looking at this from, we're going to do this in steps. We're going to do this in bits and pieces. And the issues you bring, there are a lot of very important issues that you're bringing up. And they're very important that these, and this, I'm looking through the contractual process that we need to put together with MLH, that in that process, we need to get into these issues and figure all this stuff out. So would you say then, would it be fair to say publicly?
41:15 Mm-hmm. That this allocation of the surplus T.O.T. to the capital fund is a temporary placeholder. It could be. I mean, and actually say that to the, I mean, not, I actually think that's an unnecessary step, but. No, I wouldn't, I would say I. My concern is you use the word commitment, and when I see the council adopt this, I see it as a commitment to the town holding the capital reserve.
41:42 Well, it's not a commitment forever. And it's pending some further. Fiscal year. Well, it could be. But again, we're going to have an action plan and report coming out in the fall. And if one of the recommendations coming out of this report that says in order with all the various components.
41:57 That are the recommendations that come to council for a 21st century housing policy that's going to deliver housing to the community. And it says you need to do this, that, this, that, and the other, and that's part of that? Well, then, of course, that's where we'll go. So would the council be willing to refrain on committing any of those funds to any particular project until such time as that housing reports come out?
42:26 I think that any... The town has contractors for a reason. So if we contract with MLT, there's a reason why we do that. We trust in their expertise. They're doing great things. We're going to work closely with them about the... I was asking if you're going to have to say we won't spend the housing money until after the report is out. We will not... So we know that whatever expenditure is in line... We will not spend the housing money...
42:55 Outside of a serious and specific consultation with MLH until this report is completed. And that's part of these two closed session items. I reached out specifically.
43:08 To MLH into the town to get appointees from both bodies so we can have this communication and make sure that we're talking with each other. So I would commit that there will be no spending of any money going into that reserve account for housing purposes absent a specific and detailed dialogue and conversation with MLH, yes. Would you state that in front of the council? Sure. And I would state that for MLT and MLH and for ESSA. It applies for all three.
43:40 My concern is just that wheels are moving, things are happening, people are looking for funding sources, and we have doable projects on the table that we may or may not be able to fund because we don't know what other claims are on money. Right, and I look at this, again, from this higher level in terms of delivering housing for the benefit of the community. So if the town, we've got a limited amount of money,
44:11 So the town's looking at a project, MLH is looking at a project, let's get together, let's see who's doing what, let's see what's in the best interest of the community, and work together to make the determinations of where the best place is going to be spent with limited funds we have in the interest of pursuing these projects.
44:29 That would be a standing commitment from myself. I can only commit myself, but I will say this to the council as part of, with any one of the contractors in any one of these service areas, we're not going to go do something absent a fully engaged consultation with the contractor we have who's delivering these services. I've probably dominated the conversation. I'd like to turn it over to some of the other board members. So one of the things that I'm just kind of thinking of is,
44:58 You know, the purpose of like NGOs is to make sure that regardless of where the town council or the state may be, that there is a certain aspect of something being taken care of. So for instance, with Mammoth Lakes Housing, we mainly focus on affordable housing that will help maintain workers within the town so that they can afford to live here.
45:18 Where we're at, whereas like Town Council, who also is looking for housing opportunities, sometimes it may be mixed use, market rate, and so that may take away from a lot of the low income workers that are working here, and if, if, so, I guess what I'm getting at is if we're sharing a reserve, you know, not allowing us, I mean, I hate the term, but it's the only one that's coming to my mind, if we're, if you're not allowing us to necessarily be on a loose leash to constantly fight for this affordable housing, and you guys also have yours,
45:47 Like, your own reserve that doesn't necessarily affect us to be able to also look for market rate housing multi-use, then that's when our heads could butt. When we come together and you say, like, let's, not you necessarily, but town council says we really want to, let's say for instance, let's shady rest track, you know, there was discussions of making it multi-use, not necessarily all affordable housing, and we come in and we say, but we need this money for affordable housing, we have a 264 housing deficit, and that's when we butt heads, that's when
46:16 We could be doing an injustice to the community. And that's where I get concerned when we have a limited reserve that, like, we have a 200, within this it says 204,000 personal reserve of the TOT. Yeah, like an operating reserve, right? Yeah, and then it, well, the operating is 330, and then we have the 204. The 330 is contract. Contract, yeah.
46:37 That's a guaranteed contract. And then the operating reserve, we could get the semantics of this, right? The operating reserve is like 25% or something like that. Yeah, it's like working capital, so we can...
46:47 Yeah. Yeah. And then the rest goes into the other one. And that would be, think of that, the thing that goes into the town would hold is the capital fund. Think of that as the capital fund. Yeah. That's a better way to look at it, probably. But that's just, I mean, that's the one concern that I have is, of course, everybody wants housing. We all know, town council knows, everybody knows in this town that we need housing, that we have a deficit. And Mammoth Lakes Housing is there to fight for affordable...
47:13 Housing for low-income workers. And so that doesn't necessarily align with everybody else who's looking for market rate housing. But we have to make sure that there is good affordable housing. And if we're having to share that reserve, we could easily, because in the end, we don't necessarily make all the decisions. We're more advocates than we are going out there and just being like, no, we got to do this first. We could get over, we could get...
47:36 Overrided by, I don't think that's proper grammar, by the town council and it could go to market rate and then we could not be fully fighting for affordable housing. Yeah, and I think what we really have to do is we have to be working together. We're doing a disservice to the public. If MLH is kind of saying we're going to do this, the town's saying we're going to kind of do that, we're doing a disservice to the public. So we have to get on the same page with what it is that we're doing.
48:04 And I think that, again, I'm looking to the strategic process to really to look at a cohesive, coherent program, an action plan for housing where what the town's going to be doing, what MLH is going to be doing is going to be clearly understood. The roles and responsibilities are going to be clear. The public, their expectations are known because they can see, okay, this is what you guys are implementing. We don't really care whether the town's doing it or MLH is doing it.
48:31 Someone else is doing it, but at the end of the day, the policy that the council adopts, this is the thing that we are doing. Because at the end of the day, the only people that the public can hold accountable is the council. The council can't say, well, MLH, we think you're doing a terrible job and I'm not going to vote for you guys anymore. The public accountability goes through the council. And we have to maintain that accountability in such a way so if the town is screwing something up,
49:00 If the town government and its contractors are screwing something up, the vote of the public means something. They can say, look, this council, you're screwing this up. You're not delivering the housing program. That's the only people they can hold accountable is us. They don't have any way of holding an NGO accountable. The only way they hold an NGO accountable is through the council and through the town. So we've got to do this in such a way that we...
49:22 Ensure that the public accountability is in place, that the public money is doing what it's supposed to be doing, and at the end of the day, we're delivering on behalf of the community. And I think we're at a point now where this is a very good time to be doing this, to be bringing all this stuff together because the challenges we're facing are pretty unique. When you look at the stuff with the nightly rentals and all this kind of stuff, this is stuff that didn't exist three years ago. So it's a good time, I think, to be re-evaluating this.
49:49 Re-evaluating the program and figuring out how we're going to work together to do this. I guess, I mean, I'm also thinking about this as, like, the idea of NGOs in general. I mean, like, I'm just going to throw out there, domestic violence. Not every politician who goes into the state is thinking we have to allocate X amount of money to domestic violence. You know, many people come in for ag purposes or business purposes, housing purposes, but we have these NGOs that are set up within the state to make sure that regardless of what
50:20 you know town council or representatives may be thinking there's still domestic violence being taken care of because there are plenty of people in the state right now who don't care about domestic violence but thank goodness we have hundreds and hundreds of NGOs across the state that are helping victims and I think that's the same thing with housing right now is that if we leave it to where
50:41 We're like the NGOs are on a tighter leash. They're not necessarily, you know, this could change. The reserves could change because you're saying it's a political commitment. It's not getting written into any like stone or anything. So let's say in five years, town council is like, oh, we're no longer considering housing anymore. We need to focus on something else that could screw us over.
51:02 Two years later. And so it's important to be able to allow NGOs to do what they need to do to fight for what they're fighting for. And if there is an issue where their reserves are building too much, similar to what you've been saying with MLT, that sounds like it needs to be a reassessment of that individual NGO, not necessarily trying to rein in all NGOs at once. Well, I'll offer just a couple of thoughts because I've kind of been in this position and Bill and I...
51:27 You know, we've looked at this from a number of different perspectives. But it gets to be very challenging when you're an advocate and you're also a contractor. And at that point, it's a very tough thing to figure out how do you serve both masters at the same time. Now, your heart and your passion is going to tell you, man, I've got to advocate for this thing. I've got to, you know.
51:48 I've got to go to that council, they're a bunch of runes, they have no idea what the hell they're doing, they're not serving the public, and I want to advocate quite passionately for what I'm trying to do. That's how I got into all that. I understand that completely. But when you start, when your organization is now under contract to the party that you're...
52:07 You know, that you may have a disagreement with, it becomes a fine balance. And I think what you have to do is you have to find a way to say with the resources and the legal authorities of your partner, in this case the town, how do you most effectively work together to deliver the program that
52:24 You're trying to do. Because you're in a unique position. Not only are you an advocate, but now you've got a reliable budget, you've got staff, you've got capacity, you've got things that you can do to make all this stuff happen, and you've also got a partnership with a town that has taxing authority, that has CEQA authority, that has all kinds of state-mandated authorities, that if we leverage these things appropriately, we can deliver on behalf of the public that we're intended to serve. So I appreciate, I've been in that position, I know exactly what that's like.
52:54 But when you become a contractor, which is what MLH is or MLT is, you're in a different position. And the charge is between the contractor and the party you're contracted to, to effectively deliver. That's our charge. That's what we have to do. I don't think it's actually all that different. When you look at the state policies, right, you pass general funding for housing. Well, the state...
53:22 Doesn't administer that in the capacity of the electorate. No, they delegate it to their Housing and Community Development Department, and they expect their Housing and Community Development Department to advocate for policies that support housing. And they still send them funds to do the good work that the legislations, legislators, the town council, if you will.
53:44 As, you know, authorized them to do. So I don't think there's an inherent conflict there. I think that actually works. Well, I think when a small town like this, I think when the policy of the council changes, I mean, if the council, and if we want to get to it, I can walk you through why we're laying out the questions the council of the way is designed to be laid out. The council could say of Measure A money, we don't want to honor the political commitments of Measure A anymore. That's entirely within the authority of the town to do that.
54:11 The town could say, we don't think marketing is worth a damn anymore. We're not going to spend any money on it. We have the legal authority to do that. And so the degree to which a somewhat adversarial relationship is created between a contractor to the town, when you're wrestling with this advocacy versus contracting role,
54:31 You can get into a situation where you're not going to be ultimately delivering the thing that is you're trying to deliver. And I think in a small town like this, the idea that the council is going to, one, we can't give you enough money to be a completely all-inclusive housing program. And we can't give you the resources and the authorities to do all that kind of stuff. That's not how, in a small town like this, that's not how this is going to work.
54:57 And so we have to work together. I mean, we have to work together to deliver this stuff for the community. Yeah, I wasn't alluding that we wouldn't be working together. No, I'm just saying to, that the point is that that's where we have to be striving, that's got to be the goal. Well, yeah, I'd like to get, you know, even though you say we can't go back there, but I'd like to get back there. I mean, that's where we were. I'd like to go forward to a place that looks like that. Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so, because I know that that's been successful.
55:28 I can't imagine where our community would be today if we hadn't worked together. I understand that, but I'm also looking at federal trends, federal trends of things like all those grants that you guys were so successful, just did a great job of getting. Well, we did, the town and Mammoth Housing. Understood, but that whole world may not exist. I mean, it doesn't look like it's going to exist. But that doesn't change.
55:50 No, it doesn't change at all. We're in a process now of having to reinvest in it. We have to reinvest in it. We have to reinvest into it given a completely different set of circumstances and challenges that we have to face that didn't exist even a couple years ago. And this agenda bill, I think, is the first step in getting us on that road to start to get to where it is we want to go.
56:15 I think what's really confusing about the agenda bill is that on page six where it outlines the commitments to, it says programs but primarily implemented through the NGOs. Tourism and transit are funded at the political commitment level and those are the NGOs where Mammoth Lakes Housing is not and it's not really explained why that's the case.
56:44 When the intent of the process says that it's to minimize the impact on each entity, but this actually perpetuates the hardship that was placed on MLH during the settlement at this allocation amount. So I think a better explanation of why this agenda bill was presented in this way and why the NGOs are treated differently would probably help us understand it. Okay, so let me offer you a little bit of thought on that. When MLT was set up,
57:13 There was a tussle about how much of the Measure A dollars would go to MLT as an outside organization and contractor and how much of those dollars would stay in the town. And it was a pretty significant tussle at the time.
57:33 And the commitment that was made at the time was that all of the measure A money that was in the town, the town was using for its own internal marketing department, all of those dollars would go to MLT. That was the deal that was made at the time. Then we get into the bankruptcy and all that kind of stuff. The decision that the council made at the time was, we're going to honor that
57:56 commitment to MLT because we believe that the only way we're going to get out of this mess that we're in is to market this place to try to bring in more dollars. So that's why that stayed the same way that it stayed to right there. So the proposal here is to not make any change to the status quo for that. The only real change we're talking about is the reserve accounts that if money comes in in excess of their guaranteed contractual amount, it will go into the town, into their capital fund.
58:24 Housing, as you know, at the time, the decision made of the council was to do this number, to do that allocation right there. That the measure A money is $542,000. $300,000 and change of that's going to MLT. The balance of that is now is paying off some loan, making some loan payments, which will be finished next year. So when the council's making the decisions, they weren't concerned about NGOs. They were concerned about
58:52 Again, from this high level, where are we going to allocate the dollars in these revenue streams at the time of 2012? And the decision they made was, we're going to give money, the money is going to be maintained to marketing, and housing is going to take a hit, because remember, this is the middle of the housing crisis, and there was, you know, no one had any interest in a house anywhere, and that...
59:15 The council time said it is not wise to be putting the money into that. And the money for transit, that's a time and materials basic arrangement. The town can hire as much of us as they want. So we're five years later. We're in a different situation. So now the time is, and the proposal is, to recalibrate, to get things back to, so we're back to parity. So housing and transit, each in the original intent with the voters getting a single point, now housing and transit would be at parity.
59:44 And your question about, well, what about MLH? Why is MLH not, why is that money not automatically flowing to MLH? It goes to the point that Bill and I have just been talking about. This agenda item does not preclude that happening, right? But the point is, the first step we want to take is to recalibrate the allocation measure A money to the program areas as the voters originally intended. So that's the first step.
1:00:09 Why aren't other NGOs getting less money also then? MLT is actually getting a little less money. They're getting a little less money and, you know, the council, Fernie and I still believe that marketing, I think we'll see what the council says, but marketing is still really important. The issue of the T-bid, obviously marketing has a huge capital fund to work with, which is the T-bid, but if there's going to be a seismic reallocation of Measure A money.
1:00:36 Something to say, well, look, we don't think that $2 million should be going to marketing with a contractor. We want to cut that way back. That's a very, that's a huge, big deal. That is not the topic or the subject of this agenda item right now. We're not near that. Again, the motivation with this... I don't think we are proposing that. No, I don't think you are either, no.
1:00:58 I think I know that the kinds of things I'm hearing from you, Bill, which again are important things that have to be dealt with, are things that are going to happen that need to be addressed, and we'll get into those. I'm thinking through
1:01:09 The contracting process with MLH through the strategic plan that's happening, that thing is going to inform what that should look like. And I would certainly, I will reiterate that commitment that none of the money that's going into these accounts held by the town will be spent on any of those project areas absent meaningful consultation with the contractors that we currently have that are working on fulfilling those things. Does that answer your question?
1:01:34 Not really. Okay, so tell me, we'll try one more time, but we're not going to. In the staff report, it says the guaranteed base allocation to the tourism program primarily implemented through Mammoth Lakes Tourism is $2,259,000. Right. The guaranteed base allocation to MLH is $330,000. Right. So, again, the question of the council is not how much money are we giving to NGOs.
1:02:01 That's not the question. Well, I'm just wondering why they're being treated differently. Because, again, that's not the question in front of us. The question in front of us is reallocating measure A money to the program areas. It's not the subject. I get that it's not the subject, but why in the staff report is it outlined that way? Yeah, if it's not the subject, why did the staff report be written that way? Okay, so ask that question again. I don't understand. If it doesn't matter.
1:02:32 And the guaranteed base allocation is going to be the same across NGOs, program areas. Why is housing being treated differently? Because the issue of giving, of increasing the contractual amount going to housing is not something that we have explored with this agenda item. So when we met with, we met with the MLT board. We said, what do you guys need to just keep doing what you're doing? And they said 2.5%.
1:03:02 No, they said their current contract amount is about the numbers that we proposed was that. And they said, okay, I mean, they're not, you know, there's not, we're not dealing with happy campers all over the place, but they said, look, we can continue to provide the services that we're doing at that. Okay, fine. When we had the conversation with MLH, the conversation was, what is your current
1:03:23 Amount that you're operating under. Is that a sufficient amount to continue doing what you're doing for right now? Yeah, okay, it's not ideal. This isn't where we want to be at the end of the day, but for right now, this is okay, and we'll put this stuff in place moving forward. So that's why these numbers are in here. Again, this does not, and the two other things in the agenda bill are to, we have a new contract with MLT coming up to renegotiate that, and we need to get a contract in place with MLH that's meaningful, and that that's,
1:03:52 Part of the council action is to go forward. Once we get these things reallocated, so the programs are made whole, then we have some money to actually negotiate with. If we don't pass this and we stick with where we're at right now, then there's no money that could potentially go to MLH. It won't happen because there's no money to put it there. Because, again, the status quo is currently this, 542, 732. And that's...
1:04:16 The MLH contract plus the debt service we're paying on some grants that will be paid off the next year. I guess that makes sense. It's just confusing the way it's written because it says guaranteed base allocation. So if this passes, is this the guaranteed base allocation or is it based on a contract that will be negotiated later? Okay, so what he means by the guaranteed base allocation is that these numbers
1:04:40 For an operational perspective, each one of the contractors can count on these numbers, meaning that if the TOT fluctuates and goes up and down, that's not your concern, there will be, I'm just saying, but that's, that when I, That's kind of a negative, it doesn't even apply to MLH. I understand. That applies to the other NGOs. Of course, but again, for the council, we have to look at all of them at the same time, and we're looking at this. We don't have to, per se. I mean, really, you said that the focus of this was housing.
1:05:08 Well, the intention behind this was to make this recalibration, to get from 542, to do what we could do, to get to 817. That's what we're trying to do here. And we appreciate that. Yeah, that's... So, you know, I'm yet to be convinced of the need to hold off on the other. And in fact, I see a risk in holding off on the other, simply, and maybe it's just history, that, as I mentioned in my email,
1:05:40 In the past, the town, one of the prior council members, it was around when 2002A was enacted, said, one thing I don't want to see happen is this money to be siphoned off for administrative purposes of the town that they had to do anyway. And that certainly happened probably to the tune of several hundred thousand dollars over the years. And so my concern is as long as it sits over there in reserve.
1:06:09 It's still a target. I understand. I think the degree to which we stayed mired in the past and we look at the past of this community as the model for how we're continuing to go forward, I will not serve on your council. And I'm just making this point. But this isn't about being mired in the past. This is about learning from the past. I have learned from the past. I have learned from the past. And I'm sitting here with an item that is looking to redress the mistakes of the past.
1:06:36 Well, again, you guys can go in front of the council, and what I'm advising you is that this is a complex issue. There are many pieces to it, and I believe that as one council member, I've made representations of guarantees of trust, the extension of trust, and looking to a number of different processes that can ultimately help to deliver housing to this community, because right now, we are not doing that.
1:06:59 And I take responsibility for that as a town. We are not delivering housing for the benefit of this community. So this is the first step in putting a program together that will. And I think your commitment that you made, that the council will make that commitment, that they will not touch these funds for any purpose until such time as there has been either negotiation or closure on the housing policies, you know, that alleviates my concern somewhat.
1:07:28 Somewhat. Somewhat. Okay. Again, if we're going to go with buts and somewats and maybes and that kind of stuff, that's fine. I really hope we can get to a new era and a new way of doing business because, frankly, we are not going to be able to deliver services for housing or for transit or for marketing or for recreation if, again, this tension of being an advocate versus being a contractor doesn't get really effectively...
1:07:57 Engaged and dealt with to the degree that we're working together to provide these resources for the public. And I just argue that we have been very effective as a contractor even when we have been advocating for a larger program than the town was ultimately willing or able to produce. So I don't think that that, I think if there's an obstacle to our advocacy is the concern on the part of the council not wanting to hear it.
1:08:28 Because, as I said, we've been very aggressive and very successful, despite disagreeing with the council on some of the policies. We've delivered a lot of housing and a lot of leverage. I understand. And you're referring to an era that I'm not intimately familiar with. I'm only intimately familiar with the three years I've sat on council and where I think we are at today. That's what I'm focused on. And to your point, I'm looking at the future and how do we get to...
1:08:55 A better and more effective way. So what do you see as the steps and the ultimate objective? The steps are, I would hope that this item passes next week. As written. As written. The next step from the housing perspective is that this strategic process, this action plan process is fully engaged and is a full, robust process with community buy-in that we come out of this thing with a series of
1:09:25 policy recommendations to the council that speak to a coherent and cohesive plan and action plan to implement housing and that the council adopts those recommendations but the recommendations as presented to council are then reflected in the MLH contract and so the contractor and the town are on the same page and we put together a work program where everybody's effectively working together to deliver the program.
1:09:55 Putting on your board member hat on this board, are you comfortable saying that that is the most effective way to quickly and efficiently deliver housing? Yes. I don't see any alternative. I mean, if we don't, if this, I mean, if we don't, fine, if people don't want to pass this and move the Measure A money, then we're just sitting where we are right now. But, you know, my question is, is it more effective and more efficient than going ahead and providing the full allocation to the NGO? Yes. And why?
1:10:26 Because I think that A, housing is not, as a beneficiary of Measure A dollars, housing is not alone. That from the council's perspective, we have to be balancing the political commitment made by previous councils, made to the voters on these items. We have to balance the interests of these three program areas. So we have to do that. And I think that
1:10:56 There's a significant need to rebuild the understanding of the working relationship between the contractor, MLH, and the town. I think there's an enormous deficit right now, and it's hindering the ability of that relationship to work effectively, deliver housing for the community. So I think we start with this. There will then be Measure A money that's available.
1:11:18 To the housing program. And then we have a strategic process in front of us can inform what should be in various contracts, various agreements, and we can put together a program to move the thing forward. So then when we are, because we're discussing like, and then in the future we would set up a contract between the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing. Right. Would that be the time where we could try to renegotiate the base operational of 330? Sure.
1:11:46 But that's going to be informed by this strategic process. Yes, of course. But just because, like, I think that's also one of my main concerns is because that's been our operating budget due to the Great Recession. You know, I think it would be helpful to move it back up. Of course.
1:12:01 That's why this process is so critically important because it has to inform everybody. This is what everybody's role and responsibility is to move this thing forward. And as Jennifer said many times, this is a community-based process. So the community hopefully has got buy-in to this. Everybody says, okay, this is how we're going to try and take this thing on and then sign the monies, do the things where we've got to put them, and then off we go. Those are my thoughts. I mean, when I'm looking at this, that's how I'm seeing trying to move this thing forward.
1:12:40 16, 17, and if the TOT comes in, I'm just using that as a way to talk numbers. Sure. If the TOT comes in at 17,500, you know, and if we're lucky, you know, 17,18 comes in at 17,500. So that's why I'm using that number. So I'm looking, I'm just being, you know, very
1:13:09 Blunt about it. Okay, Mammoth Lake Housing has a $330,000 budget. We have a loan of $200,000 that is going to be paid off in September. You take out $144,000 for the airport litigation. The reserve, you want to have a reserve there, but we also have a reserve in our own budget. So we have two reserves there, the $204,000. So that comes to about $870,000. Using one
1:13:38 The one point of the 13% of $17,500, it comes to about $1,350,000. So there's $550,000 left over. So I'm trying to figure out who controls what. So when I look at this, the $540,000, you know, the loan and the thing.
1:14:07 When that loan disappears and we go back to the 896th. This one. Yeah, right, 817. So, 330 contract. Now, that loan is, let's assume that a loan is paid off and the litigation is taken out of the 961. So, what I'm looking at is, does, who controls the difference between the 330
1:14:35 And the 817, about $450,000. Do we have the first, I guess, the right to access that? Don't get me wrong, the council oversees it all. Sure. But, I mean, you know, obviously in the $2,259,000 there, I mean, that's not their contract. I mean, obviously there is funding for different purposes, just as
1:15:02 The difference between our contract and the H-17, that money can be utilized for a down payment of assistance or created a whole new program. A year or two ago, we presented a funding idea of using 2002A money to help 150, 180% AMI, a loan program. So, I mean,
1:15:31 Is the difference between that contract and that 817, that is part of, I mean, you want to utilize that money for, with a partner, other than Mammoth Lake Housing? No. Okay, then, because in the agenda bills, you talk about partners several times. I think that's a general use of the term partner. I wouldn't take that as being, you know.
1:15:58 So we would come to you and say, okay, this is our program. We want 200,000 to people at 200% of AMI because of doctors and management and everything else. And then, okay, and you guys disagree. Now what? Well, I mean, that's obviously a problem. I would look at it, what I'm looking at is that we
1:16:25 The money's in the, the town's holding the funds. We go through the strategic action plan process. We identify a series of mutually shared goals and objectives that, hang on, that says so that when MLH comes back to the town and says, okay, A, there's been some rebalancing of the contract amount to fulfill the MLH role, the plan to move the thing forward. MLH comes back and says, okay,
1:16:51 One of the identified strategic things we want to do is X. We can put together a program to deliver X. Council, please fund X. And I don't know what would happen. I don't imagine what would happen if the council would say, no, we don't want to do that. There would have to be a rationale.
1:17:18 MLH would say, look, we've agreed to this action plan. These are the components in the action plan to make these things happen. We'd like to access this money to do that. I don't know why the council would say no. Well, the question that I had was if the council is making other plans, other uses, other commitments, we come in and they say, well, no. And we say, well, why not? And they say, well, we can't tell you because we're in, you know. Well, that can't happen.
1:17:47 That the communication, a lack of communication cannot be a rationale or reason not to do something.
1:17:55 So, what has to happen is probably the interface, I don't think it's sufficient to have one council member, I mean, I can take information, advise the council, all the rest of it. There needs to be a working relationship between the staffs of the town and MLH that's like, this is what we're working on, these are the things that are moving forward. So that there's active and ongoing communication between the parties. Now, if the recommendation comes out of the strategic thing that says, look, you need to set up an NGO, MLH,
1:18:24 Give them all your money and put a contract together that looks like this and leave them completely the hell alone and that's how this is going to work. Okay, well then maybe that's what we'll do. But I think as a council member right now, when a project comes to us, to the council, there is no frame of reference as to what that project is and how it fits into achieving a variety of strategic goals.
1:18:52 I think the program, I think the town's responsible for this, has been so abused since the settlement coming out of the lawsuit when the housing program was basically running on fumes for the last five years. It hasn't been coherent.
1:19:08 And I think this process that we do with the strategic, this action plan process has got to define goals and objectives and things we're going to meet so that the council and the contractor are on the same page to try to achieve these things in what order of priority they're trying to do it. And then we communicate, we work together to bring these things forward. And so there can't be a situation where it's like,
1:19:29 Something gets in front of the council and, well, that's a good idea, but we don't want to do it. Well, why don't you want to do it? Well, because we're doing something else. I mean, that's just idiotic. That's irresponsible. That kind of situation cannot happen. And we have to meld the two organizations together. When I say cannot, you mean it's something we should not allow to happen. We should not. If that happens, we're failing.
1:19:51 Past tense, I can't relate. We're on the same page. That is in both of our interests to say if that happens, it's a failure. I mean, that would represent a colossal failure to me. Okay, you keep talking about action plan, but I mean, we have an opportunity because a piece of property just came up, the commercial piece, and you're aware of it. Sure. And we're trying to move forward on that. These are closed session items, right? Pardon? These are closed session items, correct?
1:20:20 I'm talking in general. Okay. And I don't believe it. We've directed Jennifer to have a serious discussion with a property owner. That's all. What was on the agenda bill? It said we were negotiating on a property. No, I think it's close. It was a close session discussion. Yeah, price and terms. Okay, whatever. Anyway, so, I mean, now...
1:20:45 You know, if there's promise money that's given, I mean, you know, where is Jennifer's authority? Does she have to come back, go into closed session with the town council? You see the difficulties. We have to figure this out. It's difficult, but we got to figure it out.
1:21:01 We have to figure this out. And I spent several, you know, an hour on the phone with the town attorney last week. How are we going to do this? We can't have two Brown Act bodies going off on their own closed sessions talking about committing dollars coming out of the same pot and they're not talking to each other. That's one of those, we've got to figure that out. That's ridiculous. From my perspective. Let me use a more concrete example. I'm trying to...
1:21:25 I'm throwing difficult issues at you so that we can begin to understand, okay, how is this going to work through the process? So Tom Hodges got up and he's talked about many units on the Arrowhead project. I mean, he did that at there. And, you know, if Tom comes to the town council and asks for housing money for that, but we disagree with the use of that, this board votes to say no on it, how is that resolved?
1:21:54 I think what would happen in that scenario, that the proposal coming from a third party, it either comes to you guys, it comes to the town. It comes to us first. Okay, let's say it comes to MLH first. Okay. Just say, someone walks to the door and says, I've got something I want to do, blah, blah, blah. So MLH through the communication mechanism established with the town, you know. Then, okay, so then we're going to be meeting with you.
1:22:22 Let's take that single project, which might or might not be good. That's not the issue. Sure. So he's talking about, you know, infrastructure, costs, and everything else, and he wants participation, and he wants the support from Mammoth Lake Housing. So we look at the project, and we agree or disagree, and the next step is, okay, so we disagree with the project because we feel that it doesn't meet.
1:22:46 It doesn't meet all the needs that are outlined there. So we disagree with the project. Now he moves it forward to the town council. The town council controls the money. So now what happens when we make a recommendation not to go forward? And I think that if the absence of a strategic plan and an action plan that clearly identifies things that we're trying to do together, it underlines how we...
1:23:16 So is it appropriate? We're having a workshop.
1:23:45 Right. Next Wednesday. Mm-hmm. And I will be there. We're having a workshop with... Yeah, council, right? No, that's the 19th of July, I think. Oh, I thought you said it. No, it was the 23rd. The council's having a workshop. We're having a workshop. We're having a workshop on this agenda item next week. Yeah. So we're having a preview of that today, and you can come back. You can do it. By the way, I said the issue, the thing that given...
1:24:15 Where we stand. And perhaps multiple potential claims on the existing housing money that's going to come in this budget year to be set aside. And when I go back and make the same pitch to the whole council, which is if you're not going to give the full allotment to MLH because we have yet to have a strategic plan.
1:24:47 in place that says we should, then I would argue you should not give any of the money to anybody until such time as that plan is completed. And would the county, is that going to fly with the council? I can't, I can't speak for the council. Well, I think I'll probably make that pitch. I just want to point out one thing real quick. There's no, there's no way, wait a minute, Jennifer, Jennifer, one second. An action plan.
1:25:13 I mean, the thing is that you have people walking through the door that create this opportunity. How does an action plan incorporate these opportunities? So Lou Margherlies walks through the door and wants down payment assistance on two employees that are actually at 150% of AMI. I mean, that's an opportunity to address that particular issue.
1:25:42 And so it comes to our board, then it goes to the town council. It seems like everything keeps funneling up to the town council, you know, you have ultimate responsibility. For 10 years, the NGO, Mammoth Lake Housing, was utilizing these funds, leveraged $44 million and got 130, 40 units out there.
1:26:09 So I'm not too sure, you know, the action plan was opportunity also because when a developer walked through the door and said, I can do this, Kitzbühel Apartments or whatever it happens to be, then we responded and certainly were in communication with the town manager because
1:26:32 The account was there, the money was there, and then the idea of preventing it to, sometimes Clark would get up and explain it to the council, and the council would, if there was any questions or anything, but it was the communications that happened, and the NGO was pretty much independent, and going back,
1:27:02 The NGOs are much more focused on those and also much more steeped in what is actually taking place and how to best leverage. Trying to come back to the council and try to explain, wait a minute, this is a good deal and this is why, or this is not a good deal. The mini units on the Arrowhead Apartments is not good because we can leverage the money better someplace else.
1:27:30 So you want all that to come back to the council? Well, no. I think there's obviously housing. This is a very technical world that this is. And it doesn't make any sense to bring things back to the council that are in this sort of minutiae of the technical detail and all the rest of it. But if there's a framework, I know I appreciate there's a housing element, but the council, I don't think you can count on the council being fully fluent in the housing element.
1:27:53 They should be. Right. But I think, again, we come out of this action plan, we're reinvesting in this process, we're reinvesting in a program that has been very successful in the past, and you establish some things so that when something comes back to the council, it obviously goes to the town manager, but the council understands what you're talking about. So it's like we've got five program areas we want to work in, we want to invest dollars in to make these things happen. Council and MLH have agreed to these things.
1:28:18 Council, this is item number three in your list. It's down payment assistance. We found a way, consistently with the goals and objectives we've agreed to, to provide this thing and to make it happen of good value to the community. You know, we're here to, you know, I don't know how it would work, but we have to get those things figured out so that they're working. As I mentioned in the memo, the intent of creating Mammoth Lakes Housing was to keep the council from having to act as the housing authority. Yeah. And that was a choice by the council. They recognized that
1:28:46 It was an area that they would rather delegate. And that's a question, I think, again, in this strategic, because I think those things are gone now. Well, but that one's not gone because we're still here. I understand that, Bill, but from an operation, we have a dysfunctional relationship. The town is not delivering.
1:29:07 Housing as effectively as we can. And I think there are some issues between, and we're looking to how to work with our contractors and work with our NGOs to make these things happen. We have to reinvest in this now. Again, I mean, democracies are like this. You have to reinvest in these things. So we have to do this again. We have to look forward, and we have to set up a mechanism whereby, look, if the recommendation coming out of this action plan is that
1:29:32 Mammoth Lakes Housing is the contract of the town needs to operate with a level of autonomy. They need to be funded accordingly. Let's put that in front of the council. Let's put it to a vote and let's see where that goes. But right now, I don't think we're anywhere. I think we're just in mishmash land. I think what the council hears from MLH, frankly, is we can't do anything until we get the Measure A dollars restored.
1:29:54 I mean, that's, that's, I think, what the council generally kinds of hears. Until the measure eight dollars are restored, we really can't be effective, we can't do anything. Okay. I mean, clearly, if that's the message the council's getting, they're not watching, they're not listening, because we have successfully provided projects since litigation. I'm just, as your liaison to the council, I'm advising you what the council is hearing.
1:30:18 And I would think... I would appreciate you helping the message. Good. Thank you. So I'm trying to relay information to get a sense of where everybody's at in this conversation. So I think it will be very helpful to advance the conversation to perhaps say, okay, this is a good thing to get the measure A for housing restored, get that restored, and then we can start looking at step-by-step building an effective relationship, a working relationship that's going to deliver housing on behalf of the community.
1:30:48 Well, I do think financing is important. I do think that's already in our draft report we're seeing that. And I think that's going to follow through. And nobody can provide housing without funding. And to think that we would sit here and twiddle our thumbs and not be requesting the full funding.
1:31:08 Seems short-sighted because we know that's how we get to producing what our community needs and we know that's how we produce our mission is with that funding. That's how we historically have been successful. So I don't think that's a bad message that they're hearing. I think that's an appropriate message and I think it's going to be even louder and clearer once they hear it from somebody else and not us. It's some reason coming from us. It seems to be more punitive to you than if it comes from a third party.
1:31:37 You know, contractor, which is already in there. I mean, in there. So I think, I think it's going to be Measure A and probably more. Sure. It very well could be. Yeah. But I'll just advise you, the Council has heard, I've sat in these meetings, Council Member Fernie heard in this meeting and heard pretty consistently that if the measure, and even Council, you know, Chair Stapp has said this directly, unless those Measure A dollars are restored,
1:32:01 Why we even, you know, why we, you know, we'll do what we can, but it's somehow, it's somehow a representation of bad faith that the town has not restored those measure A dollars. It's something that's been hanging over like a cloud over this conversation the last couple years. We don't need to belabor that because we all know why that's true, that it hangs over like a cloud. No, I'm not sure. Tell me, tell me why, tell me, Bill, because maybe I don't understand that. Because going back to the history you don't want to go back to.
1:32:30 Mammoth Lakes Housing, or not Mammoth Lakes Housing, Housing as a program area since the litigation has been essentially the forgotten stepchild. Good. So now the council has heard that, and now we're taking an action to redress that. Life is not perfect.
1:32:49 We don't get everything we want for Christmas, but I think this is an important first step to advance this thing and move this thing forward. We never get everything we want for Christmas, but this isn't even that. Okay, but I'm advising you, as your council representative, that if the council hears from the MLH board, well, this is nice, but that is not an effective way to proceed politically in this conversation. No matter about this being nice, but it is.
1:33:19 If you agree that housing is a critical priority, then you should be taking strategic steps to deliver as much housing as you can, as quickly as you can. And in our opinion, or my opinion, since the others haven't taken a vote, in my opinion, the structure that's being proposed, even if it's an interim structure, is not the most efficient way to get from A to B.
1:33:47 Okay, well you're free and welcome to say that. Yeah, I think that that has to be a question we all ask ourselves every time we look at any kind of a policy or recommendation of a policy, expenditure, how does this action move forward our ability to provide housing? You say our, who are you referring to? The community. Okay, good.
1:34:12 Absolutely. Always. I mean, everything we do is thinking about how do we house the community. And I say we, I mean MLH, and I hope that the town shares that intention because those actions have ramifications. There's always consequences. And is this action the best action to produce that housing, like Bill said, quickly?
1:34:36 Or is there a better way to do it? Because we should always be striving for the strongest and best, most efficient way to produce housing for our community. Right. And I think that the thing to really keep it, again, this is the counsel I'm offering to this body, that this is happening in a political context. Right? Everything is political. So I'm just advising you of where the perception of the counsel may be.
1:35:03 And I'm advising you that it would be in the interest of housing on behalf of the community, qualify whatever things you want to say, say the things you think are important, but I think it would be detrimental to housing on behalf of the community to look at this proposal and say, well, this is nice, but we'd like to put a bunch of qualifications in here. And I would say also that the fact that the council representatives have heard this, have heard that the primary goal
1:35:33 A primary need for housing in the community was to restore this. I think it's an important thing, again, you have a relationship with somebody, say, okay, thanks for hearing us. Thanks, you know, thanks for doing this. Thanks for bringing this thing forward. We think this is great. I'm not, I'm not, look, I'm not trying to put any words in anybody's mouth, but this is a good first step. I believe that that was where I started the whole discussion, actually. No, exactly. So I'm just, so it's good to have all. But saying.
1:35:59 Yeah, overall, I think you're making the right direction, but this one step, I think, is incomplete. I don't think there's anything wrong with saying that. No, there's not, but I would encourage you to be pointing to the next steps, to say, let's start looking at what the next steps are, that on behalf of housing and the community, we have an expectation that the strategic action plan process is going to be fully engaged with, that
1:36:27 The representations made from council representatives to the NGOs that none of the money that's sitting in these capital accounts will be spent absent full consultation and dialogue with the contractors who are providing these services. These are the kinds of things for certainly in housing case as an interim space that these are important. I think there's a way to frame this in a way to bring the kinds of things you're bringing forward and not
1:36:55 You know, not get council members who may don't spend a lot of time thinking about this stuff inadvertently kind of confusing them or putting a position of saying, well, how come they're not grateful? How come the advocates for housing aren't grateful that this is being done? That's the thing I'm kind of cautioning about. It's life. Say whatever you want to say. I'm sharing with you as your liaison to the council things that you may want to say. Is there any action that we're supposed to take tonight? No. No.
1:37:27 Will there be a new staff report? I don't know. That's a good question. I don't think so. I don't think so. I'm sorry. I was asking if there would be a new staff report. There was a pretty...
1:37:45 Complicated staff report at last week's meeting, and I was wondering if it would maybe be just kind of tidied up a little bit. I think that it's not perfect, but I think that trying to change it, I'm not convinced it would get that much clearer and more focused. And I think there may be a new PowerPoint presentation, but again, I'm not convinced that that's going to make things, hopefully make things a little bit more clearer. But there's a lot of stuff in this. There's a lot of technical kinds of things, and we're just trying to keep it as focused and as clear as possible.
1:38:15 You've mentioned capital funds. I mean, so you pay, you know, on a monthly basis, the $330,000. You've set aside $200,000. We paid the litigation, the $144,000, all of these different things. So is there going to be a housing fund that Mammoth Lake Housing can access, identify from that 1% or that one point of the TOT? Yes.
1:38:42 Okay, so that will be in your budget that identified. Yeah. So, and that's going forward, 17, 18, or the five? It's going forward. So, what happens to last year's money, just out of curiosity? The last year's money, it's status quo. So, whatever you guys have in your accounts. What are you guys doing with the XSTOT? For this year? For 16, 17. For 16, 17. Do you have any idea what that money went to? We haven't decided yet.
1:39:12 So it could go to housing? Could go to housing. I mean, it is a priority. Yeah, well, again, I defer to the town manager. He's looking at identifying how much money there actually is that's discretionary, and I have to understand how much of the money that's in those areas is going to flow into to fund these capital, I'm calling them capital accounts, in the town. It's going to go directly into those accounts, so it's not going to be discretionary to the town to say,
1:39:41 So creating this line item in the budget, you can, because of the 5 million excess in TOT, you could take that 1% of the 13th to 1.13th and start funneling that into a housing? It will. It will go into a capital account. You keep calling it a capital account. Why is that a line item account? It's probably semantics. It's semantics. I was just trying to, because we're using reserve for two different...
1:40:10 We're using the word reserve for the operating reserve for a contract with a contractor and also using it to mean the capital stuff. So I'm trying to make the distinction between the operating reserve and a capital account. But the housing reserve fund would not strictly be limited to capital, or would it? No, it could be, it's intended to be for projects.
1:40:35 Whether it's capital or whatever. I mean, I don't know if you call like a housing assistance program capital, but it'll be for projects. So, so this program, programs and capital projects, it's a program. I don't know what the right word to use is. We get buried in that stuff. But yeah, the, the, if should this pass, then the excess funds out of TOT that are designated to those, per those points, the overages
1:41:01 would go into these accounts held by the town that would not be spent by the town for anything other than transit, housing, and marketing.
1:41:13 And should the funds be spent, they will be spent in consultation with an identified contractor that the town has that's working on that program area. Okay, so historically, just John, just for your benefit, historically, those monies were in those account, those line items, and Mammoth Lake Housing had direct access through the manager to pull those funds this. Now, don't get me wrong, we were constantly updating
1:41:42 The Town Council. And, you know, letting them know, by the way, this is, this is where, you know, but the manager was overseeing it. And it was more an informational item for the Town Council rather than a decision-making item. And I don't know, I don't know.
1:42:00 Again, this is new. This is being done in a new way. I'm not, I think what matters is that the money goes somewhere in a place where it's not going to, the concern, again, this is coming a little bit of the MLT situation, but the overages on the contract amount are not just flowing into NGOs without any accountability or sense of purpose of what they're being used for. Yeah, there was always accountability.
1:42:25 Not only public, not only the fact that we had a council member on there, but also the town manager was overseeing it, and there was almost a monthly, the Mammoth Lake Housing staff person was constantly...
1:42:44 Coming up to the podium and explaining what was happening. Right, but the current situation we're in right now, again, you talk about the past, we're going back to 2012. Yeah, I'm looking forward to it. So the housing is right, the status quo, it's capped at three, the contract amount for MLH is capped at three, whatever it is, and there's loan payment and that thing gets paid off. We don't know what happens. We don't know what we're doing.
1:43:10 So we have, this is again the first step in figuring out what it is that we're doing to rebuild the housing program, to get this, get everybody up on their feet so we can really deliver this stuff for the community. Have you seen the budget yet? For? For the 17-18, I mean it's due July. Yeah. The town? Yeah, we have not looked at it. Is there a specific line item? Well, this hasn't passed yet.
1:43:33 Yeah. So if this passes, yeah, there will be a specific line item that will say in whatever language you want. Housing, capital, whatever. Measure A housing, measure A tourism, measure A marketing. Reserve. Whatever, yeah, whatever it's called. The critical thing during this interim period is going to be if there are alternate proposals for use of the money, that MLH is consulted as early as possible. Sure. Because once an idea gains some momentum. Mm-hmm.
1:44:01 It becomes a little bit harder to deflect. Sure. And the only item that I've seen coming to the council level is the closed session item that we're discussing. And that's why I reached out and we figured out some way to start communicating and talking about it. I mean, Tom Hodges, he hasn't come to the council. No one's come to us asking for any money yet, so there's nothing else that... I'm not a definitive source, but there's nothing else on the radar that I see right away. I just hope that if...
1:44:36 Anyone came up with a housing proposal of any sort that you send them our way first.
1:44:44 Sure, and I will do my best. Unless you don't control that. I'll do my best as the council liaison, but I think, I know that Jennifer and you guys have been working with staff, you guys have been meeting and talking about a lot of stuff. I'm assuming that the flow of information back and forth is efficient and effective and good. So I don't get involved in that level of things. I'm assuming you guys are talking to each other. And if you see something, you're going to talk to Ruth, and Ruth sees something, she's going to talk to you, and we're going to communicate.
1:45:12 Communication is our best friend for all this stuff. Absolutely. It absolutely is, because otherwise you just trip over things you don't want to trip over. Giselle, any questions? Bill? No. Jennifer? No, thank you. Patricia? Public? Yes. Yep. On digesting all that, what you guys were just talking about, it sounds like to me that there's the $800,000 you want to pass in the budget for the housing.
1:45:54 But there's some stipulations that you're not too comfortable with on accessing that $800,000. And I want to back up and say that they have been very successful in helping our daughter get a place, get housing in this town. So I think the MLH has been very successful. And I'm sure there's a lot of stories like that. So to keep that success going, I think that budget sounds great. When it passes,
1:46:25 They need access to it by not having to come, it sounds like to me, not having to come to the council to get approval for a housing project. If they think that it's a good project and all five of them vote yes, go to the town manager, he says yes because he has confidence in them or do you think it's more
1:46:50 In your best interest or the town's best interest and the public's best interest to get the approval by the council when they all five think it's a good project. I think this is very much an interim situation and I think that we're going to figure out how we work together to deliver the kinds of successful programs that MLH has been doing and continue to do that into the future. We're in a little of a, it's a recalibration step.
1:47:16 We got to do. And certainly this is not an effort of the town to assert some kind of authority over housing and say, well, no, you know, there's some, there's no, there's no financial malfeasance going on here. There's none of that kind of stuff happening. What we're doing is we're trying to get, we're trying to get more money back in the pump and MLH has been at an enormous disadvantage for
1:47:39 Five years. And we've got a whole new set of challenges, so we've got to figure out how we're going to do this going forward. So this is, I'm looking at this as very much of an interim situation, and I'm looking for what's coming out of this strategic housing thing coming out of this to help us, to chart us on that course going forward so these guys can effectively perform and deliver the kinds of things that benefit. From what I hear you're saying and they're saying, and then that other meeting we went to up at the brewery.
1:48:09 Housing is number one. We've got to get more housing for the people that live here now that are looking. We have, you know, two supervisors that are looking for housing. They're threatening to go to Bishop to find affordable housing because everybody's jacking the price up here. And so I think the goal with everybody is to get more housing. Yeah, absolutely. So more money. Yeah, we'll start here. We'll get more money and then we'll start.
1:48:41 And that's voting Wednesday, next Wednesday? Next Wednesday, yeah. And so we need to talk to our other council members about this, or do they know about this? They should know about it, but they, yeah, if you support this thing, call them up. Tell them what the hell's wrong with you, support this thing. Give them more money, okay. That's what I would suggest. Further discussion? If not, we're adjourned.
1:49:14 Good, thank you very much. Thank you. Was your book over here for a reason? No, it's for you. We've got some for the board members to read.