Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2017
Mammoth Lakes Recreation
· recording 43 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
75 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:19 Are we good to go? Good to go. Okay. So let's go ahead and, it's 5-0-8. Let's go ahead and call this board meeting to order. Do you want to do a roll call, Emily, please? Yes. Tom Johnson. Here. Gary Mortgage. Here. Harry Stallick. Yes. Brian Churex. Here. Rachel Asha Schreier. Heather Schoudmire. Present. Cool. Thank you. All right. So any public comment?
7:58 Okay, no public comment. So we have, I think we have allotted here like 40 minutes to go into closed session. I don't think we're going to take that long. We're going to go ahead and adjourn into a closed session and then we'll come back out. We'll report whatever action was taken in the closed session and then we'll hit the rest of the items on the agenda. Sound good? Yep. All right, let's adjourn.
8:42 Closed session and come back into open session. So I'd like to report out kind of we've actually had how many closed session board meetings now? Four. Four all related to our search for our new executive director. A little bit of background just for the record. We engaged a search firm called Forest Group.
9:11 to help us with this search. There was a very long list of candidates vetted, contacted, considered. This process took about a month, I think, the first preliminary kind of phases of the search. We whittled down to four top-tier candidates. All four were interviewed.
9:38 via Skype with our search committee, which was formed by members of this board and a couple individuals outside the board. And then we whittled down to three from that four. We flew two of them out and one didn't have to fly in, but we entertained them here for each for two days. And those candidates met
10:05 Kind of a cross section of community leaders. Met board members, town manager, different town council members, rec department representatives, rec commission representatives, representatives from the arts and culture community. Each candidate also met the full board in closed session and gave a presentation on fundraising.
10:34 Each being one of the main deliverables for the new Executive Director. We whittled down further and we have a candidate that we would like to announce. His name's Matt McClain. Matt has lived in Mammoth before. He worked for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area as a
11:02 Director of Sales. He had a number of jobs there, but I think he left as the, I believe, the National Sales Director for the Mountain. Moved on to Telluride from there, has had a, and then started a non-profit career that spans Protect Our Winners, Surf Rider Foundation, and his post, his current post is the Catalina Conservancy. Matt has, and we'll make, I don't know if the,
11:31 His CV was included in the agenda package. It wasn't, was it? We'll make that available, some background. But Matt has deep experience in the nonprofit sector. He has bona fide the whole toolkit when it comes to sales and marketing. He's also been on the board of a number of...
11:56 non-profits as well as president of board of a non-profit. So he spent a lot of time in our space. He knows Mammoth deeply. He owns a house in Crowley and has been involved in some major fundraising as well, as did all of the candidates that we vetted and interviewed. Really, that was the main bar. We have a, with our town contract, we have a
12:25 A deliverable of raising $2 million out of this organization over the next three years. And one of our main focuses was making sure we got a candidate who could measure up to that goal. And I would say for the record, too, that none of the candidates, I mean, that's a big number for this town, and none of the candidates we talked to even batted an eye at that number and had been involved in fundraising efforts.
12:54 Much larger than that. So we are very excited to bring Matt on. There's a contract that was published with the agenda packet and that contract has been negotiated. Basically the process after we vetted our candidates and had interviews, our search committee met and then the executive committee
13:21 kind of set some benchmarks for compensation. I will say, kind of before we start talking about the contract and ratifying it as a board, that range, the compensation range is, it's higher than we were certainly compensating our last executive director. It was, it's higher than the number
13:46 We entered the process with, but it became very clear very early on during the search and working with our search firm that any candidate with the kind of experience that we were looking for, especially in fundraising, was going to be in this range. And that was true for all four of the candidates that we ended up selecting, and it was true for candidates deeper down kind of in our process.
14:14 So we made the appropriate adjustment. And I think the thinking in the search committee was, A, you get what you pay for. B, we are making a leap of faith here, both as a community and as an organization, with this fundraising effort. And if money comes in the door, a few thousand dollars on the margin, we're all aware that it's taxpayer money. So it was not
14:45 It was duly discussed and considered. But if we are able to hit that deliverable, then a few thousand dollars on the margins isn't really that big a deal. And when we looked at the comp sets that we were dealing with outside of our town and outside of this region, this is very much a median kind of package. So we feel like the package is
15:14 Commensurate with the goal that we've set ourselves here. And we feel like we have the candidate who is up to the task of raising that money and also scaling the organization over the next three years to meet those goals. So that's my kind of preamble. I would open up to the board for discussion both about the candidate.
15:43 Some remarks maybe or some direct discussion about the contract. And I'm looking for ultimately a motion to approve the contract or to amend it. So having served on the search committee, great candidates. It's very, very encouraging to see the number of quality candidates that we have come forward that potentially wanted to be here to pursue our goals as an organization.
16:15 And I think that this choice is a very solid pick for us moving forward. And I think it's going to be very influential for us in how the organization moves ahead and how we're going to take quicker steps. And I think we realized over the last while that it says we're going to move much faster than what we have done. And I'm very excited about this choice overall. I do have one comment on the contract when we get to that, but I'll leave it there. Okay. Other comments, questions?
16:42 Yeah, I don't really have much to add. I would just echo that I think it was a deeply inspiring process. I mean, it was a national search. We really, I don't think, left any stones unturned. And I was personally really impressed with the caliber of people that we were able to attract. And as you said, to see that they were fired up to come to Mammoth and do this job. And I feel like it shows that we've already come quite a ways. And they all reacted really positively to our strategic.
17:12 plan. They all came to the table with really good ideas and, as you said, bona fide experience in a number of areas. So I think this is a great leap forward for us and I'm super excited. You know, I would say I would echo all of that. And I guess, you know, yeah, it's a big number, but...
17:34 I guess I would say that, you know, if we were hiring an executive director at a lesser number that did not have the experience that we had, we'd have to be hiring another person. So we're really filling a lot of areas for, with the fundraising and a director. So, you know, because of that, I'm okay. There's some significant deliverables that we're bringing Matt in to accomplish, and I'm excited, I think, that, you know, we're...
18:03 We're moving in the right direction that he is capable of doing that. I agree also. I was part of the process of interviewing three different candidates. I thought we were extremely thorough. I thought you guys did an amazing job of taking all the candidates around to all the different players in the community. And I thought it was a very thorough job. I know that the number seems kind of big, but I'm not shocked by it based on what's out there. And I think that you have to pay for what you get.
18:29 So I'm super excited. And knowing Matt, I think he's going to bring the energy that we need to get to the next level. So I'm stoked. You had something you wanted to? Well, I'll put it this way. I'll make a motion. Okay. That way we can bring a discussion. I move that we authorize the chair to execute the contract with Matt with addition of the
18:52 Addendum of our existing new contract that we have with the town as a backup for deliverables on this contract. Which is, which is, uh, it says exhibit on there. Labeled exhibit A. If we can add that as the exhibit A for that is. So the town contract becomes exhibit A. Becomes exhibit A. Okay. Well, I would, I would say we should also develop a list of organizational deliverables on top of that because there are other elements that, that we'll expect. Okay. Okay, so, so, uh,
19:19 So we would mutually create. Exhibit A to include the town contract. Town contract and a mutually developed list of organizational deliverables between the board and the executive director. Yeah. Okay. Did you catch that language? We could actually repeat the actual motion. Okay. Exhibit A is to include the contract. So we would move that we authorize the chair.
19:52 To execute the contract with Matt. To add the town as deliverables, town contract, as well as a mutually derived list of. Mutually developed? Mutually developed list of deliverables. Of organizational deliverables. Of organizational deliverables. Thank you. Don't ask me to repeat again. So we have a motion? I'd second that motion. And we have a second. Okay. Any further comment from the board? No, I think we've.
20:30 Any public comment? Okay. All in favor of the motion? We should do a roll call. Okay. Yeah. Yeah. Let's do a roll call. Tom Johnson? Yes. Gary Morgan? Aye. Drea Perry? Terry Stellick? Yes. Brent Turex? Yes. Heather Schadmutter? Yes. Rachel Ashley Schreier? All right. Motion passes. Congratulations to this organization. I think we've got to...
21:09 A really strong person coming on board. Very excited. Okay. Let's move on then. Let's see, where are we? I'd like to make another motion to approve the minutes as May 2, 2017, as distributed. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion passes. Okay. So let's take a look now at, there's attachment number three.
21:42 Is proposed calendar for future board meetings? Yeah. It's staying the first Tuesday? Yeah. I mean, well, look, we can change that around. I have to say, and this may be true of a couple items as we move forward here, but to me, I would prefer to table this. I mean, I don't feel...
22:09 We should approve a whole slate of a year's worth of meetings without our executive director in the room. I feel like that's something to think about, that we should maybe think about our next meeting and then from there put on the agenda consideration of what our meeting schedule is. And I would agree with that for two different reasons. One is I'd say our normal course of business is the first Tuesday of the month, but for me personally, my plan at this point in time is to step off this board and
22:39 I have another representative from MLT here, so I don't want to speak for somebody that may be coming on in their schedules. Okay. I also think it's, I think I'd like to consider the whole scope of work and determine whether we actually need to have monthly meetings or whether there are specific meetings around allocation schedules or, you know, there may be another way to approach. And there's been, I've had a number of conversations with Matt about
23:09 Board staff relations and board composition. And I think we're going to need as a board, in fact, what I would maybe recommend is let's, and I've already worked this out with Rich, we don't have anything pressing. We both kind of
23:28 Agreed that maybe taking a July board meeting off the table was smart given the transition and that we don't really have an executive director moving. We have our program administrator clearly, but I think we could all take a breath. This has been a heavy lift for us. So I'm okay with that. And then maybe August becomes kind of more of a workshop with the new ED kind of to talk about.
23:56 Board relationships and composition moving forward. Does that maybe sound right? That sounds great. Okay, so then I will communicate with Matt and we'll figure out what to do in August and then we'll set a calendar and maybe revisit schedules and times. I mean, David and I have talked at length about, you know, trying to get to the point where we're meeting quarterly.
24:21 You know, and then it's just more... Because another element that came up in interviews was, as we discussed board composition and board development with the variety of candidates, there were suggestions about, you know, when we get to a place where we need to bring in a different kind of board member who may not be in Mammoth Lakes, you know, how do we accommodate that kind of person? You know, someone who may be...
24:50 helping to bring in big funds but isn't willing to meet once a month to talk about administrative duties. I just want to say that we just need to not lose track. We do have the last allocations that we need to do that was a multi-year funding that we didn't do the first go-round. So, you know, it may even be something that we can have a workshop and then we can have a short agenda that we can even talk about that so that it can be brought to council either the end of August or first part of September.
25:19 So that these folks are not then hitting the next funding cycle that we kind of clear that air and before we start moving forward. For sure. And it may be that we accumulate enough things by August that need board action that we have to have a kind of an agendized meeting.
25:37 And then our annual meeting is in October, so there needs to be some organizational meetings or committee meetings probably in there with the new ED and all that. But I agree that we should get ED's input on kind of the way forward, and we'll handle what we need to handle in August, but we'll kind of take a breath in July. Okay. And then I guess my only question would be how does the transition work for our program administrator?
26:07 Over the course of July. So we have a, I'll let Emily chime in on this too, but Rich and Emily have developed a transition plan that kind of lists all of the tasks that need to be taken care of. Actually out beyond just July, right? Correct. It goes until September. So if you'd like I could just briefly speak to that. And I just want to ask you one question. Is that something, I mean if something comes up where you feel that we need to have meaning.
26:35 That you can contact Tom and we can call a meeting. We just have to do it in the proper posting time. Absolutely. The biggest thing that I'll be working on is our website and really keep reading content and redeveloping our website so it has a stronger voice and it looks, not saying it doesn't look professional now, but having a cleaner message so that when the executive director steps into place.
27:05 And we bring our website to fundraising events and organizations who are interested in bringing their money into MLR. We'll have a very clear message there. So I think that that's an important piece. I'll also be working with the Parks and Rec Department a little bit with our bench donation program. I'm also working with John Wentworth for his Momenta project.
27:29 helping to pull together the different organizations and their own content and also distributing content. So that has a lot to do with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and the kind of work that we're doing. A big thing tonight that I would love for you all to look at will be later, but it's approving the program administrator as a check signer for the organization. That will save us a lot of time, especially as I work with Sarah Ward in our accounting.
27:58 So that'll be also a very important piece. And my assumption would be that you and Matt would connect, I mean, whatever his kind of first official availability becomes in July, that you guys would connect and, you know, on your workload, on kind of what your vision is for the website and all that stuff. Absolutely.
28:20 And I'm looking forward to talking with him further. I mean, I'm kind of craving projects right now as we're going into a period where there's not as much happening in terms of administrative projects, so this is going to be a really fun time. Yeah, I would just, I would hope that that program of work that you've developed with Rich, you can share with Matt as soon as possible and have a phone conversation about that. Why is it appropriate to reach out to Matt? You know, after the contracts.
28:49 Actually executed. Sounds great. So I will tonight be in touch with the folks from Forest and I'll also be in touch with Matt and then I'd imagine it'll be pretty swift. My understanding is he wants to execute quickly too so he can kind of take care of what he needs to take care of in his current situation. He might have some ideas of how these things are set up as well that he wants to share and you guys can collaborate with us. Absolutely. And Emily, maybe
29:19 Why don't you circulate the transition task list with the rest of the board so that, you know, Terry brought up the allocation. You know, maybe there's a few other things that other board members are touching but haven't made it in the list. Allocations is definitely on the list as well. Yeah, as we've talked about. Okay. Cool. Okay, so no action required on this one.
29:48 I'll talk to Matt as soon as I can about framing August just so we know with plenty. I mean, it's summer and people are, as we can tell right now, schedules are tough. And I think as Matt's coming on board, I think that it's really important that there's a meeting, you know, that he's introduced and they have that conversation. Is that August? Is that September? I don't, you know, but anyways. I think you're right. Okay.
30:18 All right, moving on. Okay, so we do not have Rich here to walk through the budget stuff, April expenditures, and the big one here is C, is considering approving an operating budget. A and B, I don't know if anyone had any comments on them. The only thing I'd mention is, you know, we obviously went over from the search.
30:47 You know, we did not budget, have a line item in the budget for the search. So it's like over six grand, seven grand. But as we've done, you know, over the entire course of the year, we are spending nothing on the business, on office. I mean, we are way under budget in those categories. So it balanced out. So we're still, you know, in the black in terms of the budget for the month.
31:17 It should be noted that that's a problem when you're not spending allocated funds against marketing and some things that push your organization forward. So that's something I want to rectify moving forward too. And that's why we're going the direction we're going. Exactly. But it ended up working in our favor to cover some of the search. So if anybody, nobody has any comments on? Okay. So C, I think, does require some, here's what I'm thinking for C.
31:46 We need a budget just to plug in to move forward for Sarah for July and August so she can match expenditures to budget line items. I want the ED to have, and this is always a kind of living document, right? It can always be changed. If we take action tonight to approve this budget or make some changes to it,
32:16 We can turn around and amend it the next meeting. So once the ED looks at the budget and wants to rejigger kind of allocations towards fundraising, there's nothing really in here about fundraising. There's just kind of... I'm kind of the same way. I'm willing to go forward with the budget as distributed, but I'd like our ED to be able to come back with budget and say, you know what, I'll move these funds around or I want to change this or...
32:40 You know, in order to be, I don't want to hamstring them into a budget that in five months from now they go, well, you didn't give me money to print any materials. Absolutely. That's so fundamental. Yeah. And just a couple of notes on the budget. I mean, you see in there the, you know, the 192 is there, the 225 is there for our income. Well, we're going to have to figure out a system for staff to, you know,
33:06 Count hours, basically aligned with fundraising and then other administrative duties. So there's going to have to be a process around that. Matt and the board are going to have to figure out how much of that unrestricted money do we want to allocate up front? Do we want to front load to build the pipeline? Or do we want to be conservative? There's going to be a lot to say about that moving forward. And I think that's the conversation you have with Edie.
33:32 Totally agree. So we can do this as a draft and adopt it. I don't even know that we need to adopt the budget today. We can say that we can use these figures so that we have a budget moving forward. But when the ED comes in, that we will revise the budget and bring a finalized budget to the August meeting or first meeting in September that will give us a...
34:01 Okay, I'm fine with that. We don't know what our carryover is yet. That's not reflected in this budget right now. It could be as much as $20,000, I'm hearing from Rich. There's like a $7,000 payment to Forest Group that's not reflected here either. But beyond that, it's based on a three-year floating average, the expense items. So, you know, there are no real radical changes here from last year.
34:30 Okay, so what do we need to do? Do we need to make any motion to, or should I just direct Emily to share this budget, to go ahead and tell Sarah to plug in numbers for now? Now, is she, I mean, how does that work in terms of, I mean, when you say plug in numbers, I mean, I don't want to have a town finance person go through an entire fiscal year's worth of plug in numbers and then have to change it if we know that that's likely going to change.
35:01 You know what, in the system it's going to, it'll just roll that over. So I would say let's roll over the previous year's budget in making the adjustments for the salaries and that type of thing. And the grants. And the grants. And then what we'll do is then bring that back for approval in August or September. Well, but there's changes compared to rollover. I mean, the reality is she's just going to type in...
35:27 Month or two months of stuff in the book. She can go back and change those numbers again once we have a final budget. But she's just going to put it in and say, okay, in July, here's what your budget is, here's not. I don't know about rolling it over because that's last year's and everything's changed. Everything's changed, but I guess it's nice probably for Matt to come in and say, where were you? What am I coming in from? And then you can start, you know, building your budget from there. And the numbers can definitely change.
35:55 If there's a glaring number that's in here that was very short or very high, then you could make those adjustments, but anyhow. I'm just asking, I guess, can we approve two months of that budget of fiscal year as a draft, or do we really need to do a whole fiscal year budget approval? Well, I don't think we're doing a budget approval. I guess that's my point, is that you're not doing a budget approval. I think we're...
36:22 Approving to kind of stay status quo for the moment until our new ED gets in here and we'll rework the budget and then bring it back to the board. We're approving a draft. Yeah. I mean, I guess that's what I'm looking at. So it's as opposed to staying status quo that we're, you know. This is why I wish Rich was here so he could tell us. Well, you know what they need as well. So basically, yeah. I mean, she has all the numbers. Okay.
36:52 You know, I think that if we're... So basically to move forward, this budget as presented is fine moving forward with the understanding that we're going to, that the new ED will come in and craft a formal budget. But this will give us a working budget so that we can move forward. And we can, we're not hamstrung as an organization, so we can...
37:24 Accept this as a draft budget, but something that we will use for July until the new ED is here and can rework. Do we need, that's just a consent? I think that sounds like a consensus item, right? Okay. I like the sound of that. Okay. Moving on. Agenda here. One thing I did want to mention, I meant to mention this when we were talking about board meetings.
37:56 Just to acknowledge, we talked about this in closed session a little bit, that we intend to have a reception for Rich on July, tentatively on July 11th in lieu of a board meeting. That's a Tuesday night. Depending on if the schedule allows. Well, we'll talk to Rich and I think that was an important piece of that. So I think we need to talk to Rich and Emily. Okay. And we'll find it.
38:22 Yeah, because it's the intention of the board to have a reception for Rich after the 4th of July holiday. I think that would be lovely. Yeah, because he's going to be out of town for a little bit after 4th of July. Okay. So we'll have to check. So we'll just check. We'll set something up in July. Sounds good. Okay. All right. Review and consider. So moving on. We don't have our town council liaison here.
38:52 Oh, I'm sorry. Thank you. Check signing. Ah, the check signing. I don't, does anybody have any reservations about making our program administrator? Okay. I actually am okay for the absence of our director that I think that we need to, you know, give Emily that authority to sign checks. But I do have a problem with you have your ED and your, not that I don't trust these folks, but this is, we have to be fiscally responsible. And you need to have a board member and you need to have.
39:24 Your director signing those checks. I think that Emily, in lieu of that, we can possibly do that, or there's going to be two board members that are going to have to sign those checks, which I have no problem with either. But I think just with being fiscally responsible, we do not have that. You have to have the double signing with the board and the...
39:46 Staff. And I'd add to it from the standpoint, if we carry insurance for fiduciary responsibility that covers the board, it doesn't cover Emily in my understanding of overall, and no offense to Emily overall, but we are responsible for the organization and to delegate that authority down, and I have a big concern about that as an organization. That's just, I think we have protocol, the town's been through many things in the past where
40:09 Stuff has happened, and I hate to bring in history, but I just think we want to be very judicious on our execution of particularly checks. Now, go back to the question mark that we jumped into. What's the need here? We have a request to add Emily, but what's the real need? Is the need more Emily just in the interim without the ED?
40:36 I think for optics and legal responsibility, I think we should have
40:59 I mean, I'm around for the next month. I am too. You're around. I'm happy to stop by. You know, you line up checks. We'll sign them. I brought some tonight. Two officers. Is one of them to me? Yes. A reimbursement? Okay. Thank you. I serve as treasurer for MLT. There are certain requirements. Somebody's expense. Someone's double-checking that. So we make sure that it's a good public process. I was pretty sure this would be the outcome. Yeah. Okay.
41:25 Cool. That's our agenda, folks. So I will open up requests for future agenda items moving forward. No, I look forward to that workshop and hammering out those deliverables and talking about board development and getting Matt going on the ground. And this is a big day for this organization. And I want to thank everybody.
41:54 here. This was actually kind of the core. These were the core folks here. We had participation from other board members when they were able to, but these were the folks who were showing up at everything, and I really appreciate your guys' time and energy and your thoughtfulness in the process. It's mattered, and I think we got a good product out of it. I hate to overplay it, but to me, it's the most valuable decision we're going to have. I think it's that important.
42:22 Okay, with that, we'll adjourn. Thanks, guys.