Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2017
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 50 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
375 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:36 All right, welcome everybody, we're going to start the meeting, order it, 1-0-3, that might count. John Morris, I am here. Kirk Schottmeyer, here. Venturex, here. Michael Ledesma, here, sir. Colin Ferney, here. Sean Turner, good afternoon. Eric Horsell, anything? Eric is not going to join us today, we have Joni representing the Mountain Forest. Okay, hey Joni, how are you?
2:17 And Mr. Rudder is not here yet, don't know him. Not yet. Can you hear everybody? And Scott, if you don't. Scott is not going to make it. Scott is not going to make it. He was intending to call in, but unfortunately did not make it. All right.
2:30 Do we have any board member comments, reports, or agenda additions for today? Yes, sir. Mostly self-serving. You're always good like that. I'm not talking about a golf course. But for those that are following, the Disabled Sports does each year a Sierra Cycle Challenge, and I'm raising money for Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra and the National World Warrior Center. If I feel so inclined, I encourage everybody to go to my first giving page and donate a lot of money. Secondarily, though,
2:59 If you're watching this weekend, because we're the inaugural supporters of it and continue to be very strong supporters of Gimme Shelter, Donna Richards has put that together for the last four years, a great benefit for the community, which raises a lot of needed dollars for those people that are in need. And if you also want to contribute to Gimme Shelter, I highly encourage you to do so. It provides a lot of benefit. We've had staff in the past that have taken advantage of that, and it provides a much-needed aspect for this community. Thanks, Brent. Anybody else?
3:29 You know, I'm going to make a comment. I'm not sure if it was public comments or anything, but I said this during the Chamber of Commerce mixer. Not as many people here today, but Blizz Blizz is three weeks, two days away. And something that I just want to say is that we could not put on an event of this size.
3:45 Without the help of this community, it's absolutely tremendous. And as I said during the Chamber of Commerce mixer, we are always looking for Mammassadors to assist us with that event because it is so critical that we host so many people from out of town, 5,000 to 7,000 people, filling in to key positions like event information or walking the line. So if there is anyone who is interested or any of your staff.
4:10 Colin, you've done it before. There's been others of you who have assisted with that, and I thank you so much for that. So it's all I want to say. Thank you, John. Any other comments? Yeah, I got one. I was present for last meeting. I was attending IPW with Michael Vanderhurst. And a very productive show. Kind of funny that it was in Washington, D.C., because certainly that was a theme throughout.
4:36 But with an informal poll, I think everybody should know that international numbers are down in some segments in some countries, and it has less to do with our current political leader in chief that a lot of countries are not so happy with, and more to do with foreign exchange rates. So that's kind of a little takeaway, other than it was a very busy and productive show. Thanks, Kurt. Anybody else?
5:08 All right, we're going along to public comment. Do we have anyone here like to make a comment? Yes, no, maybe? Okay, one once, one twice. All right, sold. Let's go on to approval of minutes. So we're first going to approve the minutes from our special May 24th meeting. Do we have a motion to approve? I'm happy to make a motion with one minor edit. Okay. Item six from the minutes.
5:42 Item 1A talking about overview measure A funding discussion. About four sentences in it says funds would still belong to MLT and MLT would be able to make recommendations of how to spend funds. I believe we need to strike the first part of that sentence out and just have the sentence read MLT would be able to make recommendations. Okay. Because ultimately those are public funds. Correct. Yep.
6:16 So that would be mildly edit. We'd be happy to make a motion as amended. Can you slide a little bit? All right. Make a motion. Do we have a second? I'll second if I get an amendment to the Lord as well. On special events, second bullet point under my comments. It may be a verbal translation, but I think my goal there was to say that I don't want us to be putting on events per se, not so much as that we shouldn't have a
6:48 bringing new events to town. I don't, that was my non-intent if I did say that, that was incorrectly stated, but I was trying to say that we should, MLT should not be necessarily creating the new events and running events versus not bringing new events to town. Okay. I'm happy to amend my motion to include those changes as well. Okay. Second. Any other comments or discussion on that? There's one little thing there under item four. Item four.
7:20 Not that it's a big deal, but we continue to pursue a car that John Urdi does not, that does not, that's not correct, credit card, I'm assuming. Pursue a car. Card. Pursue a card. Okay. Add a D. Sounds good.
7:39 I can pursue a car, too. Good catch. We are pursuing cars. All right, so. Motion as amended. Amended, amended, amended. All right, any other typos or any other comments? All right, so we have a motion, we have a second. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Okay, motion passes. Next, let's quickly go through the minutes of June 7th meeting.
8:07 We have a motion to approve those minutes. I'd be happy to make a motion unless anybody has any adjustments. I abstain. Do we have a second? Second. Okay. Any discussion? Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Anyone opposed? Motion passes. Minutes are approved. Excellent. All right. One abstention. Oh, one abstention. Thank you. All right. Let's go on to new business.
8:36 First item is MLT Board Executive Committee nominations. So basically, my term as chairman is up, and I have served two terms. So we need to basically reform our executive committee, both chairman, who is myself, Kirk Schallmire was the vice chairman.
9:02 Brent Trax was the treasurer, and Michael Ledesma was the secretary, so we need to refill those positions. Let's start at the top, if we don't mind, with the chair. Do we have a, does anybody want to nominate, I don't know, can you nominate yourself? I guess you could. You could volunteer. Does anybody want to make a nomination for chair? I will, go ahead. Our vice chair, Kurt Schadmeier. Kurt, okay.
9:33 Anyone else? Does anybody else? You have to politely decline. Okay. I would like to nominate our treasurer, Brent Turex. Anybody else? Like to nominate anyone? All right. You are nominating our treasurer into the executive director. Yes, we are the, no, the chairman. Chair. Chairperson. Chairperson. Chairperson. Wow. See ya. I'm going on vacation.
10:02 This is effective at the end of your term, right? John is done with his term, so we cannot serve at this point. Gentlemen, you've both been nominated. Would either one of you like to say a few words on your behalf? Declining accepting issues before we vote. I think that's fair. Go ahead. I'm very flattered for the nomination. I certainly always want to be part of the process.
10:33 But I might not be able to have the time commitment to chair the board, so I would decline. That was too short. There's already enough wind in here, Paul. All I say is that I'd like that I'd be more honored to serve, and I would maybe even hope from the standpoint that Mr. Schottmeyer might serve as vice chair still if we get to that role.
11:04 All right. So, Mr. Truex has been nominated and Mr. Schaubmeyer has declined nomination. Let's vote for Mr. Truex. All in favor of Brent assuming the chairmanship? Aye. Anybody opposed? Okay. Abstain. Abstain. All right. Congratulations. You are now the chairman. All right. Let's go on down the line. So, vice chairman. Do we have a nomination for vice chairman?
11:33 I will nominate Kirk Schallmeyer to reassume the position of Vice Chairman. Anybody else? Nominations? Don't ask him to say anything. That didn't work out well. Kirk, would you like to make any comments? Kirk, you've been nominated for the Vice Chairmanship. As mentioned previously, always want to be part of the process. I'll accept that nomination. And that worked out better. Very good. All right. Nomination. Anybody else?
12:02 All right. All in favor of having Kirk retain his position as vice chairman? Aye. Anyone opposed? Very good. Now, the position of treasurer has been vacated by Brent, who is now our chairman. Do we have a nomination for treasurer?
12:19 I will be happy to volunteer for Treasurer if no one else is interested because I've done it before and I'd be happy to do it again. I nominate John Morris. Anyone else? All right. Do we have, so let's just vote on that. Myself or Treasurer? All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Excellent. Finally, Mr. Ledesma has been our secretary. Would anybody like to make a nomination for secretary going forward?
12:46 I nominate Michael Ledesma. He's done a terrific job, and I think we should continue that work. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Reddick. Do you have any concerns, Mr. Ledesma, the secretary's situation? We're good. Excellent. Nice deferral. I like that. I accept the nomination of the secretary. All right. Excellent. Anyone else? Good for your resume. All in favor of Michael Ledesma retaining the secretaryship.
13:14 Aye. Anyone opposed? Excellent. Our executive committee is now set. Thank you, guys. We budgeted 10 minutes for that. It took five. Perfect. Even better. All right. Item number two. Much more of a biggie. Events discussion. There's a piece on the event discussion that we've been having. I've had a conversation with a number of the board members here just about, yes, events outlined.
13:42 I've had conversations with a number of board members about where we are with the process, and I think where we are right now is that MLT is willing to take on the position, but I think that there are a lot of things that need to be settled as to exactly what this position is doing, where the funding is coming from. In a brief conversation with the town manager, it seems that the town is willing to bring over the $125,000 that's been distributed in the past, but not necessarily contribute towards the position.
14:11 That's something that needs to be discussed because, again, since we've taken a hit with the budget, we definitely don't want to take more of a hit by adding a position and possibly operating expenses or additional funding into distribution. So I've gone through at the request of some board members. I've looked at a number of other destinations, and they vary wildly.
14:32 They vary from the governance, they vary from the amount of funding, they vary from the source of funding, they vary for the distribution of funds. A place like Breckenridge puts a million dollars towards events, including a quarter million dollars that goes to the mountain for the due tour. They put on their own Oktoberfest that raises $450,000. And they also have the opportunity with their event steering committee to decline events.
15:01 So if we had someone come into town and say, hey, we want to do a whiskey festival in September, the group could say, hey, we've got a whiskey festival, we don't want to take this event on. So there are a lot of moving pieces to this, and I think that the best bet, as I've recommended here, is that we put together an ad hoc group of two members of this board, two members of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber Board, and one person from the town, which would probably be Stu Brown, to really flesh out the details as to what we're funding, how we're funding it.
15:30 Where it's going, Truckee put a TBID in place just last year, and they support events that run from April 1st to June 15th, or September 15th to December 15th. So there are a lot of moving pieces out there, but I think if we can put together this ad hoc committee, determine exactly what we want an executive director to do, then we can build the job description, we can build the actual events platform, the funding sources, and how we're going to pay for this. Because I still think we want to talk to the town about...
16:00 Some funding from the town for this position. We are willing to take it on, but I don't think we necessarily should be adding $100,000 to $200,000 worth of expenses to our budget each year for the position. So I think we're willing to contribute a portion, but I think that we just need to have a little bit more give and take on that. What I presented you here is just really my initial reaction as to where we should go with this. On the back side, you'll note there are a number of questions, some of which
16:29 Talking to a number of board members, we've answered. The position would live technically within the Chamber of Commerce, but it would report to me, not to the Director of the Chamber. We have a brand new Director of the Chamber. He's got his own focus he needs to focus on. I think having it live within the Chamber makes sense because it is a local community effort. I do think that based on our conversations as a board, we're talking about a mid-level staff person versus the person who's going to go out and get Willie Nelson on the stage for us.
16:56 We've talked about being able to hire that out through outside agencies. That was one recommendation from Eric Forssell. When we want to look at bringing in a bigger event, we can start to look at agencies out there that can suggest or recommend or bring us people to put on stages or events that we can come in, call them canned events, things that are already out there. Do you want questions now? Yeah. So you're recommending that we actually go with the mid-level, not because I remember we talked about this. Do we go small?
17:25 Right. You're kind of aiming more for the smaller, I mean to call it smaller. Coordination position more. More of a coordination position. Okay, let's discuss that, but that was just a quick question. Yeah, and we've discussed it before, and I think, I guess, you know, when we looked at it, I think that one of the challenges is that if we go and try and bring someone in who's going to bring in bigger events, that's going to be time-consuming.
17:48 All time consuming, I think, if they're going to be out there doing that, then it's going to leave all of the other pieces that we've talked about, whether it's a system with permitting or marketing or even coordination of stanchions and stages and sound systems and whatever else. I think it's going to be too much for one person, and I'm not sure that we're in a spot right now where we need to add a second position to handle coordination while somebody else is out running around trying to get bigger acts. That's why I think we look at outside agencies that could potentially
18:17 pitch us and say, hey, we've got an opportunity to bring wanderlust here. Can you handle 10,000 people on September 20th? Yeah, that weekend. I think that's probably a better use of our time and effort. In a situation like that, because, you know, one of the big questions, by the way, John, I thought this was very well prepared. Thank you for your own staff to ask a lot of these questions. You know, one of the big questions down here is, do we want Special Events Committee the right to refuse assisting?
18:45 I mean, we can't necessarily say, no, you can't come here, but we can certainly say, we're not going to support you on this. And I think that's something we need to, that's why I want to get this group together. As you and I talked, there are, there are, I looked at 10 different destinations and all 10 different destinations were, had different protocol for handling all of these different pieces. You know, we've got a situation right now where we've got the Mammoth Film Festival that wants to come in in February and Mammoth Lakes Film Festival in,
19:14 May is not happy about that. So I don't know how much power this organization has as far as saying, hey, it's great that you want to bring this. I think I even put in here that maybe we need to set up a time frame that says another whiskey festival has to be six months away from the current whiskey festival. Once everybody sobers up. Yeah, sober up time. But if it's a film festival, there has to be this much duration before the next one because right now it's whatever it is, four months, five months, three months, whatever. So I think that's where
19:43 Again, trying to sit down and trying to determine all this by myself is not what we need to do. I think we need to sit down and say, okay, how restrictive do we need to be? How restrictive can we be? And there's a lot of concern out there that we have a ton of alcohol events. Is that something that the next alcohol event comes in and say, we've already got every kind of booze covered now? And I think that's part of this committee to determine the guidelines. Would you anticipate that
20:12 This person, the event coordinator, would be part of that committee, or would be separate from it? I mean, would they be sort of like board, executive director, and there would be a group, and then, I mean, I think ultimately, ultimately, I think so. The committee that I'm looking at is ad hoc. I think it's probably a few months to really set up the position, probably even hire the position, and then once the position is hired, it becomes a staff report, just like Whitney or Lara or Michael.
20:37 Or Ken. Ken's a great example. It would become just like Ken where the events person would come in and give a presentation on a monthly basis to this board. John, I'm a little frustrated here. You said you looked at 10 different destinations. They all did it differently. And that's kind of tantamount to saying, so therefore, there's nothing to gain from any of this because they're all over the map.
21:05 That doesn't set well with me at all. That's not what I'm saying. Well, okay, but that's how it came across. Okay. I don't think we need to be reinventing the wheel here. I suspect out of those 10 destinations that you looked at, as opposed to board members, and I really think it should be board members, I bet that some of them are more successful than others.
21:29 And I bet that we don't really need to reinvent the wheel. There's an awful lot of input that you're not giving us right now. You're asking the questions about, well, what do we do next, without the input on what those other destinations did that was successful. And I'll bet that some destinations were much more successful than others. We've all heard about Breckenridge and how successful they are. They seem to be a ski area of our size.
21:55 But much more successful than we are, and their public infrastructure is, you know, renowned throughout the West, infrastructure that we don't have that we're now building piecemeal. I really think that before we tackle the questions, we need to have more background in what works and what doesn't. So my recommendation is and was that we put together this committee.
22:20 and review all of those pieces. Because if I were to go in there, I would say that I love the fact that Truckee does April 15th to June 15th, September 15th here. I love the fact that Breckenridge has control over what comes in. So I'm not saying disregard all of those. I'm in fact saying I think we need to make a Frankenstein out of all of them and say, okay, this works well, this works well, this works well, and then build our program from that with this steering committee.
22:42 That's the recommendation. And I think that sounds like a good procedure. It seemed like we were getting into a discussion of specifics and how we were going to do this and how we were going to do that. And that would be, from what you're saying, inappropriate because really you need to have this two-person...
22:59 ad hoc group from the board here that would go out and do that analysis and come back with recommendations for the board. And that is my recommendation is that there's two members from this board, two members from the chamber board, one member from the town, and we look at all of these and bring in whoever else we want to bring in, and then we take all the best things from it and we build our program. And we say, okay, we're going to fund $250,000, we're going to fund events through this time and this time, we're going to get more funding, this type of event is going to get more funding, whatever it is, that's the decision of this ad hoc group.
23:28 Once those decisions are made and once we have the baseline, then that ad hoc group goes away and that person reports it. This document today is talking about this event manager and what role he's going to occupy, what his salary is going to be, so forth and so on. Those sound like conclusions that have to be drawn after this work by the ad hoc committee is done. Absolutely. This is just a draft. This is me putting out information.
23:57 Okay, so. And my guesstimation as to what this position could do or have for responsibilities and based on a mid-level position what it probably would have for a salary level. But again, that is something that I want. Whether it's going to be a mid-level position, low level or high level would be a product of the work that this four-person, four-person board? Five-person. Five-person, thank you. Would do and come back with suggestions. Okay. But our board here.
24:24 would make, draw those conclusions from this ad hoc group. That stated fairly, because it sounded like we were getting into a discussion of specifics about this event manager, and that made me nervous, because I feel like we're operating in a vacuum here, unless everybody else knows all about how Breckenridge and all these other places work. No, my whole intent was to form the ad hoc committee, to have that determine all the different directions, to look at all the different pieces that we have. Nothing is set in stone here, nothing is even, it's,
24:53 It's a first draft of thoughts. It's not even a recommendation to that level. Okay. Sorry if I misappropriate it. I have a quick question for you. So just in thinking about, because it's kind of a two-pronged approach, a larger entity that might, you know, a promoter type situation that would bring, and again, I know everybody else does it differently, but are those typically
25:23 Retained companies, or are they ones that work off of, they get a cut of what they bring in? Because obviously there's funding there, and if you, like you say, if you eat what you kill, then... I don't know how it would work in our case. In previous cases, I think I've explained before, with my experience being an entity, not a non-government organization.
25:47 I could work with promoters and say, okay, we're going to cover the cost, then you're going to make the next 10%, we're going to make the next 10%, guaranteeing them a certain amount. So I think there are different levels. I think that's another piece that we need to look at here is what are we looking for from an outside agency? What are realistic events? Are we looking at William Morris Agency? Are we looking at Live Nation? Are we looking at Joe's event promotion company that can be a little bit? If I can make a comment, because we did a lot of research last year before we settled in on Mountain Sports International.
26:15 to assist us. Ultimately, we chose not to use them this year only because they were expensive. They were the top. They were professional. Loved working with them. Would do it in a heartbeat if we had it in the budget. And it works both ways in that you can do a commission. Obviously, they need to be very forthcoming with whoever they're talking about. If they do bring it to town, that they're getting some kind of that. Or we could retain them. And that's what we actually did with MSI and chose not to go forward with any other event.
26:44 I thought there was an excellent suggestion by Eric Forssell in the last meeting as well. I'm kind of torn between the mid-level position or doing something that's much bigger, and there's a lot of pros and cons that probably should be discussed in the ad hoc committee. But, yeah. And I think there'll also be an evolution. I think this, to me, is a starting point. If we decide in 12 months or 18 months that we either...
27:10 Have a person that can take on more responsibility or that we have time to take on more responsibility and we can go out and beat the bushes for a Tough Mudder or whatever else is out there, then this position could evolve or this position could run its course as a coordinator and we say, okay, we still want to have a coordinator, but we want to hire somebody in-house to do this because it's too expensive for us to have an MSI type company on board.
27:34 In 18 months, we decide that we're going to bring somebody else on board at that level. But I think that for right now, I think that our best bet is to figure out how to walk before we run. And again, that's where I want this ad hoc committee to discuss that. So in general, as I look at it, I have no objections to foreign committee, but my concern is time. Because I don't make sure this gets turned around in a relatively timely manner to make a recommendation coming back. I want to set, we'd like to look at settings that are pretty tough.
28:00 Brandner saying, okay, what do we need response back? What's it going to be? Because otherwise it's going to be six months, come back. Because some of these things are still never going to get fully resolved by the time we get. You know, there's going to be ongoing questions based on who comes in. Yeah. How much do we want to take on still? What's going to happen? What's the town have? Absolutely. You know, tons of barricades. Do we store the barricades? It's not the most important thing, but those things will all keep circling around until someone makes a decision. Yeah, and I think there are a lot of internal questions, you know, are we willing to fund this thing if the town doesn't come back with a dollar?
28:28 I mean, obviously, we've got $125,000, which has been committed in the past to dole out to events. If we don't have any operating dollars from the town, does that add to our budget? Do we take that from reserve? Do we set a three-year time limit for taking it out of reserve? There are a lot of things that need to be discussed with this. So my recommendation is this ad hoc group is probably a four to six meeting group where we can lay out some work.
28:55 Give a lot of homework so you can read all the different, at least the ones that we've looked at. And if there are other ones that we want to bring to the table, if Missoula, Montana has a great event program, let's look at it. But we kind of looked at Park City, we looked at our competitive set of destinations that we should look at as to how they run things. And a place like Truckee, which is pretty small, but they have a great program in place, I think.
29:22 Yeah, this is something, I mean, we're going to miss, obviously, the summer season of 2017. Yeah, no question. But fall is a great time, I would think, to really dive into this. Yep. And there are a lot of decisions, there are a lot of questions in here, and again, I thank you for outlining many of them.
29:39 Well, and, you know, I don't want it to seem like I'm passing the buck, but it got to the point where I added more questions than I had answers for, and I just, it's something we really need to get together and have a conversation about with a more succinct group and make those decisions as a group, not just me. I'll say that I really think we're on the right direction here, especially after answering these questions and obviously being in the thick of it myself, three weeks, two days. You know, and also going down this list of questions to be asked,
30:09 I'm going through my entire to-do list just on everything that needs to be happening and looking at a lot of these things sure would be helpful and we're already trying to decide what we're going to do for 2018 season. So in doing that, the timing is right, I feel like, for the fall, especially when we're looking at corporate sponsors. Those guys want to be making decisions in November. Decisions in November, research.
30:37 September and October. So I think we're on the right track. I would like to see us go forward with this quickly. With regard to the town, you bet I think that we should talk about the general fund. Having said that, I'm very pleased that this is under the auspices of Chamber of Commerce slash tourism. I think we can drive this project much better than anyone else.
31:04 Yeah, and I have no question that when we get into this that we will own it and we'll make it work. And just to clarify, the 125 is technically general fund money. It's just we're looking at the operating side being another piece that we need to justify because, again, if we hire a position at $40,000, $50,000, $60,000, whatever it is, even up to $100,000, I mean, what are we looking at for total costs and then do we have any sort of operating budget for this? So are we talking about another $200,000 that we want to put in there? Do we want to look at funding?
31:34 Other events to a certain level. I mean, we've had opportunities with a couple of events that have come in lately that we may have looked at committing some dollars to. So it's good timing because we've got a number of things coming up. We've got a great opportunity even with the mountain, with the Grand Prix this winter, where we've inherited not only the half pipe, but we've also inherited the slope style team naming for the Olympics. But it brings in that many more people, which means that
31:59 The hotel rooms in town during a peak time need to get subsidized. We've been approached on that, not formally, but with a discussion point. So, you know, when we look at the TV coverage and the exposure and all these other pieces, I don't want us just to be thinking about spring, summer, fall. We do need to talk about how do we expand events in winter? What do we support with the mountain or what do we support so that we have other events other than just the mountain in the wintertime? So there are a lot of questions out there and, you know, you guys may end up committing $500,000 to this program. I don't know.
32:28 Well, certainly the walk-before-we-run approach is the prudent one. If we tackle the whole thing all at once, it will not work out for us. We'll make too many mistakes. And in our public environment, there's not a lot of room for mistakes. So starting small and getting questions answered, you say the ad hoc group will meet four to six times.
32:56 and so forth. I don't know about that part. I mean, I think we have a great deal of work to do to get up and, you know, sufficiently informed to know how we want to do things. We also need to face the political reality that this organization needs to be out front in bringing stuff to Mammoth in a way it hasn't been in the past because we're getting flack from the town council and the public at large.
33:26 In that we're not sufficiently visible here for all the money that we acquire from the town. I mean, we have a huge budget, and yet for, you know, the locals who are here in town, they don't see what we do, because they live here, and we do stuff elsewhere. And politically speaking, I don't think it's, I think it's fair to say that's not working well right now. Town council, Colin accepted, you know, was looking at us like a big fat turkey they want to slice up, and
33:56 You know, we just, we don't, you know, we don't have any political currency in Mammoth because people in Mammoth can't see what we're doing. Even the business people don't get it. And if the business people don't get it, then who does? Hopefully this will be an opportunity to turn that around, or one opportunity. I think it's a huge opportunity. We have to step very carefully. But if it's an opportunity that we handle properly,
34:22 People, instead of being opposed to this organization, people will be supportive of it because they'll see that we're supportive of the town. And it's up to the board to figure out how the hell to do this. I mean, we can't just pile everything on John and say it's up to John. That's not the way it's supposed to work.
34:45 We've got to make these foundational decisions ourselves. Yeah, and I think the important thing about that is establishing, once we get this group together, is establishing a timeline because realistically for anybody, as we're sitting here right now, for anybody to think that we are realistically going to be able to get a large somebody to be here next summer, that ship is going to sail really soon because those things are a year in advance for the most part. Now that being said, I think the idea of getting a
35:14 Group together, putting a deadline before the holidays, you know, before Christmas, you know, not too much before that because everybody's busy and we, like you said, we want to get it done but we don't want to rush. We need enough time to be able to vet this stuff properly and get it, you know, get it done and then so if we're, if the recommendation comes back by Christmas time then you start looking for a person to hire who knows how long that takes. So realistically having
35:41 Any sort of a plan of moving forward, I guess what I'm thinking in my mind is step A is, if it's going to be this, is the person who's going to coordinate with the current events and take over this position that's been somebody that needs to assist Sean and needs to assist Michael with his event and Kirk with his event and anybody else. Make sure you've got the steps in line. How are you doing with this? Assistance, in-town assistance. That's got to be step one. If that can be by
36:10 Spring 2018, or late winter, hopefully, whatever winter is this year, if that sort of procedure can be in place and the plan is going forward, I think that's a win right there. Now, anybody from the community that thinks that, well, you haven't brought U2 here yet, it's gonna, that kind of stuff does not happen overnight, and again, we need to walk before we need to crawl first, and, you know, the last thing you want to do is try to jump out there and get some big monster event and completely blow it.
36:39 You know, that's a big...
36:41 That's part of my concern about only hiring a coordinator position. Well, and let me preface that too. One of the things that I did not put in here but that needs to be known is that the one event venue that we've invested some funding into is planning on hiring a promotional person to book the venue. So I think that's part of that as well. I don't want to duplicate those efforts. I would assume that they're going to be out there trying to program that site with whoever they can get in here. And again, I don't think that we need to duplicate it. I think that for now, what we need to do is take on
37:10 Take on the role that's been currently empty but being facilitated with the disbursement of funds and all these other pieces and determine how much more than that this position is doing. So with that being said, I mean, I'd suggest that we start conversations
37:28 End of August, early September to have the first meeting of this group just based on how crazy everything's going to be until then. But I wouldn't want to go a whole lot further than, you know, kind of the week after Labor Day to get together and really have the discovery session. I'll provide you with all of the information that I have and we can seek out other places that we think are doing it right and we can see what they do. And then at that meeting I'd like to formulate, I'd like to look at these questions but I'd like to formulate all the other questions that we need to have.
37:57 So that we can start to answer those questions as we move forward as to what are we looking for for the town from funding? What are we going to add to funding from this? And all those different things that we need to line up for the future. Sean, I just want to say I agree with you. I would like to look at those things concurrently. I'm just saying that from your experience, too, that the timeline for often for getting larger groups in and so forth, it's a bigger, there's a bigger lapse there. Oh, for sure. So, you know, if best case scenario, if we had.
38:25 Things line up in the wintertime, the chances of being able to get someone within four to six months, a larger, bigger deal is going to be a little bit sketchy. The other thing that I've experienced, I just want to throw this out there, is that I was talking with somebody else about an event that they weren't sure if they should try and do it for this fall or just wait until next year. And my comment was, you know, get the first annual under your belt.
38:50 Even if you have 20 people, just get the first annual under your belt so that it's done. And so many of these events, it's easier to grow an already established event than it is to start a new one. And so, again, it sounds like we're starting to get into details that really maybe the ad hoc committee should really start diving into. Because as far as making a decision whether or not we go with a mid-level position or something much more big picture,
39:19 That decision, a recommendation needs to come out of the ad hoc committee. It's still all for discussion. As far as what you're asking for us to do today, it sounds like is... Approve the ad hoc and appoint two members of this board to that committee. And then from there we can discuss the time frame, but I think probably the week after Labor Day is realistic to try and get everybody together without people pulling their hair out. You know, I think that's exactly the right procedure.
39:49 John, you scared me when you said, oh, we better watch out, you know, if we want to plan a big event for next summer, we won't be ready. We'd screw it up. I mean, just, you can ask Sean. Sean, if you started out today. He's awesome. He tried to, you know, do bluesapalooza at the level you're at now, you know. But having said that, guys, I got to tell you, I sure would like to share a stage with somebody next year. Right.
40:19 Yeah, but Sean, that's, respectfully, that's an obvious connection. It's something that a mid-level or a high-level person would all agree to and say that clearly makes sense, you know. So I'm an advocate and second what John Morris had to say about
40:39 And what you had said, Paul, as well, you know, walking before we kind of run. Because let's not forget, I mean, our history of events in this town went from the Fireman's Picnic and the Sears Summer Festival to having an entire summer with events on almost every weekend with the juggernaut in the middle of it all, which used to be, and I was there for your very first event, which was very, very, very small.
41:09 You know, I think that we've already built the momentum in this town to where it's become a diving board. So from here we can spring further, for sure. I don't think we need to get in the person from...
41:27 You know, the event guru, whatever it might be, that sounds very costly to me. I don't think it's even necessary. Starting off smaller and focusing on event facilitation and structure makes way more sense for the existing events that are here and for small ones that are wanting to do the first of. So, anyway, I don't want to beat that up because I think we're getting too far ahead. I totally agree.
41:56 with what you're doing there, John. Thank you for these things. Let's get an ad hoc thing to go. So I have a couple of quick comments, questions, and then I'll try and push this forward. I had a couple of things highlighted in here that were questions for me, but I think we'll just, you already clarified this, but I did want to clarify in a write-up that says that funding for events would continue through Measure U dollars. That's not currently the case. It's Town General Fund, actually. So I just wanted to make that clarification.
42:34 Measure U still did support events this year, though, so it's not technically... It's doing... Well, the 125 that was allocated... The 125 allocated, but Measure U did support... Right, but this says a 125 allocation... Yeah, I agree, but it's partially true, but yeah. And the last thing I'm going to say is, you know, a direction from the council, I think, you know, we're already aware of this kind of back-and-forth conversation about, you know, there's a need to support the dollars for the actual events, and then...
43:03 Potentially we're going to have a position here that's going to need O&M support. So I think we have to have further discussion on that. I'm only one vote of the council. I'm not sure how the council feels about that. But I've kind of telegraphed that to the council that we need to have that discussion. I think we need to have that back and forth. From the council level, we've said for two years that we're just looking for a home for this because I think we all acknowledge how important events have become to our year-round success.
43:31 So I appreciate the fact that MLT and the Chamber are willing to step up to the plate as a home for this. So I think if we have a willing home for it, we'll be able to figure out the details. As far as the ad hoc, I would be happy to volunteer my time for that. I think if I want to be outside of MLT as a council representative or kind of a hybrid role, both MLT and council representative, I think it would be helpful to have somebody on there representing the council simply based on the funding piece.
44:00 So I would be happy to volunteer my time unless the board feels otherwise. I think that would be beneficial for us. So let me try this way. I'd like to make a motion to this board. I've got one more comment or just kind of thought, and that's would we want to consider involving Mono County at all? The reason why I ask that is because we have a venue that can accommodate 5,500 people.
44:29 If we did want to, I think that there is tremendous opportunity, and it doesn't provide camping. The other possible venue in town that could provide camping is maybe the RV park, if that long-term strategy were to come to fruition. And I honestly believe that that is one of the biggest challenges to holding events in town, is that we do not offer a camping element, and yet we are a gateway community to the High Sierra.
44:59 So in saying that, you know, we got lots of BLM, DWP, Forest Service, well, we don't even talk about the Forest Service land right now, but, and I don't know, I don't know if they could contribute a financial, I'm not looking for financial contribution from the county, but in some ways I would like to have them, I'm just throwing this out there. And I think that's something we can talk about at that ad hoc committee as to how far and why we want this. I assume you're talking about having a specific event venue with
45:28 camping directly adjacent, because we have 2,000 campgrounds in town, but they're not directly adjacent to an event venue. Yeah, so many of the festivals that I see... Yeah, that was ours. I mean, Targhee, we had a whole tent village. Yeah. Yeah. But I think involving, bringing this, I think that's part of that ad hoc committee as to how far out are we going to bring this thing, because we've done that before where, with the Eastern Sierra Fishing Coalition, we started with Mono County, we added Inyo County, I mean, we've...
45:55 There are a lot of those things that we just need to discuss, and it may be that we say, okay, for this year, we're going to keep it here, but then we can start to look forward. But again, ad hoc committee can decide this thing, and we can discuss, and we can kick it upside down and backwards. We can bring the county in. I mean, when we did the TBID, we brought the county in. We talked about having it be countywide, and we ended up saying it's not, you know, we need to step aside from the county to put this thing together. So I think that's a, there are a lot of discussion points that we'll have. And then, you know, I would be very interested in this committee as well. Okay.
46:26 It sounds like we have two people addressing and representing the board. And if you want a third, I'd be happy to. Okay. I don't want to get too big with the committee. I think that if we can keep it, because one, you guys are all busy, and two, I don't want to get too many people involved, and then we'll talk about it at our chamber board meeting tomorrow. We can have Ken and Brent, I won't be there, so if you can speak to this and throw it out for the nomination for the chamber board to bring two people to the board as well, or this ad hoc committee.
46:53 and let them know that we're probably looking at post-Labor Day to have the first discovery meeting. So I'd like to make this official and make a motion on this. I'll move that we establish a two or a three-person. He wrote it down. Give me a second to read it. I'm sorry. You keep mentioning it. I didn't hear you. He's been trying to get to it. I can do it. And you can fill in the words where I've missed the appropriate adverbs.
47:21 Even substantial. His new position is going to his head already. I move to support the creation of an ad hoc committee to consist of two members of Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, two members of Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce Board, and one authorized town representative to review and recommend the creation of an event position to be housed within the Mammoth Lakes Tourism slash Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce oversight and to report back by the November board meeting.
47:50 of this year on their recommendations. I think that's realistic. I would hope it would be October board meeting, but is that too ambitious? I did, but I think that's ambitious. If we're going to meet our first meeting in early September, that's going to be a tough slog. I was going to say September, but I just don't know if that's on or before November. I mean, that's a month. That's less than a month. And I think we've got a lot of discussion to have, and I'm not sure. I have a question, a technical one on ad hoc committees.
48:22 So let's say we establish that and it's calling and it's showing. Can you sit in on this kind of thing? Yeah. Is that good? Yeah. Because I think, you know, your example is a good one. Do you include Mono County? It's perhaps something that I wouldn't have thought of at that very moment and everybody's got something. And I think we always consider them whenever we're talking about almost anything that we do.
48:46 We talk about how they can be involved, so I don't think that that's outside of the realm of conversation. The one thing that I would mention is, and I don't know if this, if you would be able to serve as the town role or whether we do want to have someone like Stu as rec director involved as well, but that's, again, something we could. I think that makes sense. I mean, Stu's been in the details of, you know, producing the process, so I'm happy to kind of sit in whatever capacity. I think there has to be, and you may have been going there for.
49:14 voice at the table for non-ticketed events, which is the vast majority of events that happen. With a lot of respect, I respect you being at the table, but your one event, is that the right, you know, is that enough input, I should say? Because it is good input and the right input, but is it enough input to represent all of the events in the community? The only comment I'd make to that, and this is a political line,
49:44 Minefield in saying something like this, because as my position on Recreation Commission, when we used to be having to deal with all the applications that came forward from Measure R and Measure U dollars, I even hesitate to say this, but it really is the ticketed events that bring people to town. And, you know, Michael, you and Kirk, your events are ticketed in the sense if you want to be drinking. So I think that, well, actually for tastings, right?
50:11 For tasting, yeah. So, you're right. The non-profits, key, critical, they actually, I'll say from a recreation commissioner's side, they provide a huge community benefit, and that's something that we always try to look at is, what is the community benefit? Is it bringing tourism dollars to town, or is it taking care of our locals? And so many of those events...
50:33 Need to do at least one of them. It's commitment and animation, and I think that those are covered in the 125,000, so I think historically we will have to have that discussion as to what continues to go on here and what goes there and what's new and what's carried over, but I don't think there's any question that we would have them as a major part of the discussion. And Michael, I wasn't trying to say that that's why they shouldn't be there, but just more of a...
50:56 Well, I think the other side of it, too, I think when we start to look forward, if we decide to commit another $100,000 towards things, we can define that $100,000 as commitment events, as, you know, it's the next kamikaze, it's the next half marathon, it's the next bluesapalooza, it's the next whatever we know is going to fill beds at a time when we need them, and, you know, again, we can be very restrictive on those funds. I would say traditionally that...
51:21 A good group size for an ad hoc would be five to nine. So if the board feels that it needs to go beyond five members to get better representation, I'm comfortable with that.
51:30 And if we want to add one more person. That's why I actually wanted to suggest, I was kind of going there, is that, you know, call in if it might be worth it to have a town councillor in his position. I think Stu Brown would be very effective at that table. But if we wanted to add a town councillor position and one representative from Mono County, then you've got seven. I mean, I'm trying to shoot for an odd number. I don't know if that's... My biggest concern, though, is we've been kicking this ball down the field for a long time. I'm trying to get something moving.
51:58 I get it. I mean, I'm fine. I mean, everybody has a voice, and bringing those people in, and if this committee is proactive enough, we'll bring media enforcers into discussions, but where do we stop again, and where do we just keep beating us back down the road? And I've got to be careful with what I say, because I wasn't trying to necessarily change that as much as just throughout these ideas. With that in mind, two things, Sean. I mean, you used the term political minefield, and that's something that we have to be sensitive to. Events are always a headache in there.
52:28 In terms of everybody wants a piece of the action for their particular event, whether it's going to bring people here or to town or not. So I think we have to be careful of that, very careful. And I think that I would not involve Mono County or the Forest Service or BLM or anybody like that right now, just because you're at the formation stages. And if you keep it smaller,
52:55 You're able to get more focused and get moving easier. If you have so many different points of view, you can't come to any conclusion. You just be hamstrung before you start. But the thing I want to point out that I think we really need to keep in mind is in the end, this whole effort will be a product of this board and the responsibility of this board, not Mono County.
53:22 or any other organization, it's going to be up to us to get this thing done. So to the greatest extent possible, it should be a small enough group that we can manage it, and the contingent from this board should take a leading role in what goes on as the ad hoc committee and subsequently there too, because I just hate to see it get to the point where everybody else is so well represented, our voice gets lost, and then we're stuck with the responsibility of carrying out somebody else's goal.
53:52 I'm going to bring back, sorry to jump in, but I'll do my own point of order because do we have a second on my motion as my question to sort of move forward or not? Well, do we need names attached to it? No, I'm not doing the same. We recommend that and then come back to names as a second portion. That way it's barricading the question and then I'm selecting members of the board. Is the board comfortable with it being five, two from here, two from chamber and one from town? It could easily go to seven if there's interest. I would suggest six or seven and just to get that, whether it's
54:21 A third ad hoc member from this board or just a third seat just that represents somebody like Kirk or Kathleen Calderon, somebody that represents a larger scale but non-ticketed event. So Mike is volunteering? I would volunteer for the board, but Kirk would be...
54:42 Great on that as well. I don't have a problem. Again, these are all suggestions. I started off with one member of our board, one member of the chamber, so now I went to two. I don't care if we go to three. I think the more input that we have, that's great. It's just if everybody has the time to be able to get together, and I do like the point of view that we have from multiple angles, I think that's great, and I think we can also get a very good sampling from the Chamber of Commerce board as well. So I think that's, if we went to three members from this board, I'm not going to lose sleep over it.
55:11 I think it's just if everybody can commit to the time. Right. That's fair. You know, is this something we could alternate and share? Yeah, maybe. I mean... Maybe that? It is ad hoc, so you can... Yeah, that's kind of what I was alluding to with being involved in it, but, you know, we have two events coming up later in September, and then I got some personal obligations.
55:37 My wife's birthday, October. So, you know, I just want to be true to this committee if I'm part of it. Personal time is a commodity and I get that. It's a limited resource. That's why I say perhaps, you know, maybe you and I share that. Looks fine because our events are very similar. We're like-minded on the issue.
55:57 I think the idea of having seven people makes more sense because you're talking about doing something in a very, in a small period of time and everybody's busy so there are inevitably going to be people that have to miss a meeting here and there so that way you'll have hopefully at least five at every meeting. The chances of getting seven at every meeting is a little dicey when you try to have four to six meetings in two months.
56:19 to bless certain kinds of events versus others. No. This is about deciding the foundation of an organization going forward. With input from different processes. Oh, input's good. I just would hate to see this devolve into, you know, is ticketed or non-ticketed more important. That's not... I don't think that's... I don't think that's... A voice, yeah. No, that's great. Matters. And the fact that you guys want to be involved is great because you'll give good...
56:46 My only concern is if we grow it, I think we should grow more board representation because we're the ones funding it. That's my only concern. The thought that I had that three people from this board might not be a bad idea is that this board is going to have that responsibility to the extent that it has three people and can to a certain, I hate to use the word, dominate the discussion, but you know.
57:08 Have some influence on the discussion. If we're going to take on the responsibility, I'd like to see this board have, you know, tremendous influence in the outcome. Well, and again, there's nothing that says you couldn't put four, two, and one. Oh, easy. No, seriously. I mean, there's no, again, the suggestion that I threw out there was two, two, and one, but it can be formatted however we want it. If both Kirk and Michael want to be on this committee and this ad hoc committee to discuss this, then we can get two people from the Chamber of Commerce. I don't think the Chamber's going to be disappointed if they don't have three seats at the table.
57:37 I think it's going to be just another great opportunity. But I think it should be. I mean, if we're going to go to. No, I know, but that would be, I'm saying four, two, and one, or three, three, and one. Those are. I would suggest three, two, one, and one. Three from MLT, two from chamber. I'm sorry. One. Three, two, one, and one. One from the town, and then through that seventh person. I think we should, if we do that, we should define what that person is right now. So that could be a representative from Mono County. That could be a representative from the Planning Commission.
58:11 I just don't want it to go too broad. I mean, we still need to figure this thing out pretty tight. Let's start with five and get going with it. And then if more people sit in, that's okay. I don't know. Well, yeah, it's going to be public, right? Yep. So as many people can sit in and want to. Yeah. Yeah. So where are we? Two, two, and one? Did your motion have a number in it, right? Yes. It did.
58:52 2-2-1. 2-2-1 was a motion. 2 from MLT. Did your motion get a second? No, it did not. That's my point of order. Second the motion. All right. So we have a motion. We have a second. Any other discussion? So is there a question? Oh, we asked the question. So are we suggesting that I modify the motion to another board member? Are we good with 2? 2-1-0-3. 2-2-1, that's... Two Mammoth Lakes Tourism, two Chamber, one Town. Okay, and our two... We can amend this thing. Of course. In a nice meeting. Yeah.
59:34 Let's just get rolling. Okay. Okay. So we have a motion. We have a second. Any other discussion? All in favor of the motion? Aye. Opposed? Okay. So are you assigning two people or no? So now I'm going to make a second one. Okay. No, go ahead. So I'm just trying to figure out this way. I would move that we move to appoint Colin and Sean as the MLT representatives.
1:00:17 At this point in time. And if the town decides that Colin is the town representative, they would appoint another board member to fill that position. Because maybe having Stu there is not a committee member, but maybe town council member is there and Stu is just there to be part of that conversation as informational. Stu, like me, staff? Yeah. No, no, let the town decide that, what they want to do. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay, I'll second that. Any other discussion? All in favor? Wait. Wait.
1:00:51 Repeat the motion again. You had some discussion. My motion was to appoint Sean and Colin as the board positions. And if the town decides that Colin is the town representative, we appoint another board member because he would be representing the town, and we would need one more board member to fulfill our two-member board positions on the committee. I would like to offer an amendment to the motion. I'd like to amend the motion to state that in the event that
1:01:21 Assuming Colin remains a representative of the board on the ad hoc committee and Sean is on the committee, in the event that either one of them is unable to attend a meeting that Kirk and Michael be alternates, designated as alternates, and that one of them occupy that position in lieu of the board member that can't appear. The official seat. Pardon me? The official seat, not just being there as public. Right. Right. We have an amendment to the motion.
1:01:53 All right, so we have an amendment to the motion. Do we have a second to the amended motion? Second. All right, all in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Okay, motion passes. Excellent. Thank you. I think we're headed down the right path. And so just from an operational standpoint, John, you're going to be...
1:02:22 Supporting to make sure that happens? How do we make sure this thing gets close? Yeah. I'll be coordinating all of them. Okay. So again. I don't know if it would be you or is it going to use Ken? No, I think Ken and I will be involved in the meetings, but I'll do the coordinating as far as when we're getting together in the ringleader, I guess. Well, this way, if Michael or Kirk would attend meetings, perhaps, and be up to speed, and then if there's a day when one of the guys is not present, you guys could easily step in.
1:02:50 But you could also offer your input all the way along, and we'd have that. I'm envisioning that day, it comes back November, hopefully there's a recommendation for us to have a position, dollar volume, all this type of stuff, and we may not like it even then. Well. I'm just saying, hopefully we've got enough input from everybody. Fair enough, fair enough. But proceeding cautiously and carefully with the most amount of information and the most amount of thought.
1:03:18 Will undoubtedly produce the best result. And I just see this as terribly sensitive because if we screw up, the media will be just all over us. And if we do it right, we'll occupy a new position in town. Well, I think the ad hoc committee can report at our October meeting. So if we have a September meeting, we'll have multiple, I'm hoping to have multiple ad hoc committee meetings in September. The members of the ad hoc committee can report back to the full board in October the progress. And then November we can come back with a full-blown.
1:03:48 Recommendation. We won't even be able to appoint anybody tomorrow because we don't have an agenda for all action, so we won't even be able to get anybody until August. Great. Okay. All right. Okay. Moving on. The next fund project. Budget. Okay. In your packets, we've got a bunch of information I sent out to you the other day. The first sheet we want to start with is the budget progression sheet that really just shows where we are compared to where we were in 2010-11. Let's label it as B2 budget.
1:04:17 No. And again, down at the bottom, you'll see the projection for 2017-18. You'll see the percentages made up. Notice that our G&A, which includes our wages, benefits, payroll, taxes, and overhead, is under 14%, which industry standards 20 to 26%.
1:04:42 Then if you look down through there, marketing is 76.5% of our budget, so when people ask where the funding is going, it is definitely going into the marketing of the organization, of the town and our amenities. Sales number below that, communications as well. Michael is on vacation, so I'll be representing Michael's piece on the international budget. We did have some changes there, pretty easy to explain, but for the most part.
1:05:06 So based on what we have for total expenses that we want to propose to you, our total estimated revenue, there is a shortfall. In the right-hand column, you'll see that a good chunk of that shortfall is reinvesting the savings from air subsidy. So right now the air subsidy is coming in at 1.08 something, 1.086 something.
1:05:27 And that means that we have $1.51 million budgeted, so that leaves us with an additional $423,744 that will go into air service marketing moving forward. So we're basically rolling those funds over. So that's a big chunk of that $980,000. The other piece, the $556,831 would come from our TBID reserve. Our current TBID reserve is at $2.75 million on TBID.
1:05:55 We feel that there's an opportunity to strike while the iron's hot. We've had two consecutive successful winters and summers, and we feel that we should really be adding gas to that fire and that there's an opportunity to do that now. We do have the funding within the reserves to do that. The biggest thing that I do with the entire team is the entire budget is zero-based.
1:06:18 So we're not just taking what we did last year and repopulating it. We're looking at everything and saying, okay, what worked, what didn't work, what worked well that we should throw more money into. And so everything being zero-based takes it back to square one. So there's no just changing dates on things and saying this is what we did last year. John, real quick, could you just reiterate one thing you said at the beginning just so it's...
1:06:38 public record, that you said that wages and overhead were at 14% and the industry standard is what? 20 to 26. Okay, so we are well under what we are spending as a percentage of our budget is well under the industry standards. Absolutely. That gets out into the public that that is the proper. Yeah, 14% is anemic. Okay, I do want to ask some questions along those lines. 20 to 26% is the industry standard, is that what you said? Now, is that for
1:07:07 Organizations that do their own marketing. We obviously contract hours out. You know, I think it includes that. I think it includes agents. Like when I had the ski industry, I had my wages and my benefits were in the 20 to 26 percent range. I still had outside agency. So we're low even with outside agency. Okay. I got to tell you just one of my concerns, and I just want to put this out here because, you know, anybody in the audience would see this as well, is that while the wages, benefits, and payroll taxes are
1:07:36 are decreasing as a percentage of the total. They're actually increasing by about $110,000, and as you pointed out, we are going to have a shortfall of $980,000 there. I'm just wondering how we go about kind of explaining this, and if you could talk a little bit about the wages benefit and payroll taxes a little bit. Good segue. Let's go to the next page. Okay. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Go ahead. Before you get there. Yeah.
1:08:04 So this basically tracks back 2011 to 2017-18 proposed. Yep. 11-12 through 15-16 we were budgeting for a reserve. Yes. And then 16-17 and proposed moving forward budgeting for a shortfall. Correct. Can you just kind of...
1:08:26 Discuss philosophically that shift. Yeah, the idea was to build the reserve to the point where the board wanted us at, $1.2 million, which was the reserve at the time. We built up to that reserve, and that's when we stopped building the reserve in. We were very pertinent in the, I mean, if you look at the 13, 14, 12, 13, through 15, 16, those were the drought years, and what happened was we built in the reserve, and we ended up basically not walking away with any reserve. Right.
1:08:56 For all intents and purposes, using that reserve because we ended up shortfalling on the TOT. And so we built the reserve, but we never built it up. So we finally built that up just in the last few years. So that, the simple answer is 16, 17 moving forward, you achieved beyond the reserve. We're well beyond the reserve right now. So we feel that there's, yeah, we feel that there's an opportunity to actually get out and spend some more money and get to the point where, you know, when we first hired Marion Carson, we had given them a number that we felt that we would be at. And up until last year, we weren't at that number.
1:09:25 You know, we wanted to be able to place as much marketing out there as we could, and because of the shortfalls, we were falling quite a bit short of what we wanted to get out there. Okay? So is that projected to last year, what, three years into it? I mean, yeah, that was one of my observations, too, is that we're running a deficit. So now, I mean, if you do that, we're spending on, you know, relying on a reserve.
1:09:53 You think we're going to get, what, three, four years out? And in those three, four years, ideally, hopefully, we have banner years again and be able to continually fuel that reserve, but what if we don't? And at that time, then, we've got to make some big cuts. Well, right now, the only reserve we're really spending towards operating right now is TBID. And right now, the TBID, with this year's reserves coupled with the money that's in the bank, even if we were to go moving forward,
1:10:23 Obviously, we have the benefit of going year by year. We're not estimating we're going to overspend the next five years by $500,000. In fact, I think that the revenue that we're projecting here is low.
1:10:35 So I think there's actually even opportunity there. One of the things we look at is we saved $400,000, $423,000 on this winter subsidy. That doesn't mean we're going to save it next year. So it's fully budgeted at $1.5 million next year. Now if we come in at $1.2 million next year, there's $300,000 that gets back into the mix. So this is something that's on a year-by-year basis where we feel our comfort level as to what we can overreach, that we can do it safely.
1:11:03 We're not going to go out there and say, let's spend $2.75 million more next year and have the risk of eliminating all of our reserve. So at the very least right now, when we're looking at the reserve itself, you're looking at taking $556,000 out of $2.75 million. It's going to leave us with $2.25 million in the reserves. So once we get to the end of this fiscal year and we see what happened with this summer, next winter, and all that, we may be short, we may be over. We either build that reserve back up or we don't build for, or we don't.
1:11:32 Ask for more money next year on top of what we estimate for revenues. The 980 is above and beyond what we anticipate for revenues based on the 2.259 that we've been capped with the town and what we're anticipating at 5.29 with the TBID. Now this year we'll end up the TBID at 5.8, 5.9. So we're still budgeting, I wouldn't say ridiculously conservative with the TBID revenue next year, but we're budgeting conservative. So even if
1:12:01 Even if we have a shortfall of TBID revenue next year, if the mountain goes to 900,000 visits next year and we lose 300,000 bucks, we're still probably within an acceptable amount that we won't lose 300,000 bucks. And to play that scenario out that he kind of articulated, let's say down the road, reserves depleted, still kind of operating at a slight deficit.
1:12:30 Where would be the first place that cuts would go in? Would that go into marketing? Would that go into wages and benefits? Where would be the first place to cut to close that gap? You know, realistically, we'd be backing off the marketing dollars. I mean, if you look, we've got $6.7 million on the marketing line right now. At the fact that we're 14% G&A.
1:12:50 I believe in human capital. I think that what Laura does, she can do even if she doesn't have as much money to work with. I would hate to see us look at any reductions in staff since we're already fairly lean and mean, but I think we would probably look at some of the programs. The budget that's presented here is because we see opportunities.
1:13:10 And we see opportunities to expand on things like our search engine efforts that have done very, very well for us. I think we've got $238,000 more put into it this year because it's giving us a huge return. So I think we would see those things scale back. And I also think that if we start to get to the point where we see that we've had multiple bad years in a row, then you'll start to see us budget again where we're looking at building reserve into the budget. So literally, if we anticipate that we're going to have
1:13:40 $8 million worth of revenue, and we get to that point, I'll give these guys $7.5 million to budget, and I'll leave that cushion. Like I said, a few years there, we used that cushion, so we ended up being right where we should be with the budget, we just didn't build any reserve. Now we built up the reserve. Thank you.
1:14:02 Actually, I've got a couple more questions, and I guess before we move on, if that's okay. Okay. Can you explain, and I think I know the difference, but essentially marketing and sales difference that you've got? Yeah, sales is Michael's world, and sales is the international, mainly the international piece where he's traveling to Australia, New Zealand, UK. And then also in his world is the actual local sales. I think his title, I can't even remember his title. It's Director of International...
1:14:29 Sales and marketing. Sales and marketing. So he's doing all the, like he does all the visitor guide sales locally, but his main effort is on domestic and international sales, meaning groups and FIT and tour operators and travel trade and media. Is his salary coming out of his sales budget or out of his? No, it's out of the wages and benefits. The entire team is in wages and benefits. So the wages and benefits represents? All the staff. Any staff do you have right now? Well, it includes the Chamber of Commerce. I think there's eight of us now. Okay.
1:14:58 Nine of us. One other question along those lines. I may know the answer on this, but some of the programs that we're participating in, like the banner program on the street, the money that would go towards that comes from the reserve or out of this budget? That's to be determined. Do you mean like moving forward or? Well, yeah, we're looking at the 17-18 budget. Or traditionally, where does it come out of?
1:15:25 Well, it was paid by the town the last time we did it, so we wouldn't necessarily have it budgeted. I think that's still something that we need to determine. Yeah, it's included in this budget now. It's included in the marketing side of the budget. So it's coming out of marketing dollars. How much do we write a check to Mary and Carson for to disperse as they do? Or is that part of, you know, when you say marketing, how much of this marketing budget is going to Mary and Carson? I think our contract is 3.5 now.
1:15:52 Well, yeah. Are you asking how much they're making or are you asking how much we're committing to them? And it may be easier if we like. So, you know, if we were looking at a banner program and you're saying that it is coming out of this marketing line item? Yeah. Is that right? Mm-hmm. Any idea what that number is that's going towards?
1:16:14 The road banners is about $10,000. Well, I know that. I know that. That's minor, right? But is there any other programs or anything else that we are investing in currently that might be considered, I guess, non- Well, Marian Carson out of that $6.69 million is about $3.5 million. Okay. Do you mean like infrastructure-wise? Maybe that's what I'm asking then. You're talking about the signs we do on the trolleys and things like that?
1:16:39 Well, no, because I can say that more of a marketing. You know, something that I actually am going to want to discuss as we go forward, I'm hearing a lot of things, for instance, like what MLR has the opportunity to do, to actually create product that does help drive people to this town. And this is going to be a discussion not at this meeting here, but I am definitely going to want to support those efforts. Just a little bit more, and this is my own personal one board member's opinion.
1:17:09 coming forward on this, but this is something that I'll want to entertain as we go forward. Now, what we're trying to approve here is the budget for 17-18, and I'm certainly not going to introduce any last-minute projects specifically, but I guess I'm just asking with regard to things for little...
1:17:27 banners on the street or signs on the trolley. I just want to confirm that that's coming out of the marketing budget. Yes, that's included there. I guess I'm, I guess I'm, and I don't know if we need to get into it, but I'm confused by the MLR comment. What, are we talking about supporting the outdoor performing arts center, or the performing arts center? That's, that's, that's capital, that's, that's reserves, that's part of our strategic plan. So that's what I don't know with the, um,
1:17:53 Do you have earmarked the convention center and things like that, which would drive visitation? Well, and there's a good example for that. If we were to do an earmark for the convention center, where would that come out of? It's in reserves. It's all a reserve that we've approved, and actually we're going to officially approve that later on. Okay, I think that's what I was asking. Yeah, we have our four strategic initiatives that we've talked about. We've talked about the outdoor events center, we've talked about the airport, we've talked about the wayfinding signage, and we've talked about the...
1:18:21 The Conference Center. And we've got those earmarked in reserve. So when I say that we've got $1.5 million in the Measure A reserves, that's where that money is. Okay. Now if there are new projects from MLR that we wanted to consider supporting, then that needs to be presented to the board and added to the strategic initiatives, because right now we've got four. Yeah. And I'm not prepared to do that at this time. Yeah, and I don't think this is...
1:18:49 Time for it either. But I think that moving forward, if there's something that we feel that we want to discuss adding to that, because we have talked about it, we've talked about housing. You know, is housing something we want to earmark dollars for moving forward? Because again, the other side of it too is now we have a separate bucket that's going to start accumulating dollars that we're working with the council on assigning those dollars.
1:19:08 The multiple accounts to work with. There's an opportunity coming up. John, I'll talk with you a little bit later because I do want to make sure that it's presented in the right opportunity, in the right time. Yep. And it would be more in 2018 anyway. Okay. So these are just, I'm just asking those questions just so that I can get an understanding for you. I don't think it would be part of our operating budget. I'm not proposing it should be. Okay. Okay. Cool. At this time. All right. Anything else on just the budget progression sheet? The document that...
1:19:38 Question Sean started asking, you were starting to go to taxes and payroll, and then we go? Right, that's where I'm going on to the next page. Your segue to brutally interrupted. Right. The page that I asked you guys to focus as much as you possibly could on was the variance, the budget variance page. That's this one. Back at our last meeting, we were asked to explain any variance up or down of 10%, and so that's where this document came into being. So this first page is really my world with the
1:20:08 wages, benefits, overhead, and then we go into Whitney's, and then we'll go through. So, Sean, to answer your question, when we talk about the staff wages, the $108,000 increase is 15%, and if you look in the right-hand column, we added the one full-time year-round position. Basically, when we promoted Jessica into a full-time year-round position with the Chamber of Commerce, we backfilled her position with our wonderful Emily over here.
1:20:38 So we have a full-time position, salary, and benefits, as well as the anticipated 4% increases for folks, performance-based increases that we do annually with performance reviews, and then payroll tax increased by about 15%. So that's what makes up that $108,000, that $15,000 variance in wage. And an increase in director's salary for chamber? Correct. Did I put that in there? Yeah. It was in the notes.
1:21:09 So that's how I want to go through the process so we can explain that that was a 15% increase and this is why. And so if we can go through, feel free to jump in on any line item that we're talking about and ask questions about it. Are there any questions on that one? Okay. On the benefit side, we did, again, the increase was 17%, adding that one full-time year-round position and then also just the annual gouging that we get from our insurance company. It made up that $12,000 increase.
1:21:41 Our 401k matching fund went up by $6,000. The other thing I will ask you to do is when you look at the percentages, also look at the dollars because a lot of these things go up by a fair amount, but they're nothing, even, you know, $600 is nothing to think about. So $6,000 in the matching fund, we actually have increased participation in the 401k program. So our new employees have joined in and even some of our long-term employees have joined in.
1:22:05 The 6,000 is the money we spend if everyone took advantage of it. That's the money we spend based on who's in the program right now. Now, if anybody else jumps into the program, that can go up, but right now, that's based on where we currently are. Moving to overhead, the legal services actually went down.
1:22:30 $50,000 because most of the TBID renewal legal fees were in this past fiscal year. So even though we tabled the resolution of intent with the TBID into this fiscal year, most of the funding that we had for Civitas out of Sacramento was budgeted in last year. That's why legal is far lower than it was last year. So that's the only difference there.
1:22:52 Some of these things as we move forward, I don't necessarily think I need to go line by line, but please ask if there are questions. Some of the things like the insurance lines that you'll see in here, some of them we had lumped into one place and we've broken out. So I've actually added line items. All of the detail for these is found in these documents. So the line item detail that we do, this is a format that I carried with me from American Skiing Company.
1:23:22 If you have any questions about every last single dollar, it will tell you. It doesn't just say domestic travel shows. It says MTS, ski tops, and the meeting and group shows. It tells you exactly where and exactly when it's going to be budgeted. So this detail really talks to all of these pieces. So there really is no, there's full transparency. There's no, there are really no miscellaneous lines. There's no slush funds. There's no.
1:23:47 You know, padding, it's here. So if Michael's got membership in Visit USA in Italy, we know that's going to cost us $2,000 in July. So one of the things that I strive to do is continue to add detail to this. And so that's where that commercial auto insurance looks like it went down. It really didn't. It's just it's bundled with our director and officers. So I split them out. So John, we...
1:24:10 If I recall correctly, a couple years ago, we looked at vehicles, because if I'm not mistaken, most vehicles were driving around a couple hundred thousand miles. Correct. At one point in time, we were looking at a acquisition or a partnership. I don't see anything that's budgeted for any vehicles. Look, the second line from the bottom, vehicle lease. So the vehicle lease actually goes up from what I did have it budgeted last year to lease a vehicle. We never did. So there's actually an increase this year over what I had budgeted last year, because now we really do need to get rid of the truck and the expedition.
1:24:40 So there are actually two, both of our vehicles need to be replaced. I have had conversations with Jeep. I'm trying to get them at the very least to do a friends and family lease for us. But I also want to bring them on as a partner. And I think that part of this event conversation lends very well for us to talk to them as a bigger partnership. Does that include vehicle wraps too? That does not include the vehicle wrap. So I think that's, it's something that we would have to
1:25:09 We would have to find the money for that one. I did not. We would fully wrap them. You know, at this point, I'm still, my goal is to work out a partnership with Jeep, and I have to figure it out before these vehicles die because we need vehicles. I don't want to just go out and lease vehicles because public perception is that we're just out buying new vehicles. That's not the case. One, we need them. Two, we want to have it be part of a partnership.
1:25:33 In the conversations I've had with Jeep, the hope is that we can bring them on as a $50,000 partner, have that be part of the, that would be where we would use the money for the wraps, but have them be the official sponsor of Mammoth Lakes Tourism and have them, you know, tied into different places, so it's a revenue opportunity. Does that include board members? Of course, yes. We could look into that. John, can you explain bad debt expense? Bad debt's just the write-off at the end of the year and we don't collect, and it's not.
1:26:03 It's a very small number and it's something that we, in fact I just got an email earlier today from our accountant saying that we have one person that owes us $150. So it's minimal. It's an AR. Correct. It's non-collectible. If you look in things like our building repairs and maintenance.
1:26:22 We had one furnace blow up last year, and then we found out the other one was never really put in properly, and it's destroyed, so we need to replace that one. Hence the reason that the boardroom is always a meat locker. We have two furnaces. One was working halfway, and the other one wasn't working at all. So the plan is this fall to replace that one that wasn't working. So that's why there's an increase there.
1:26:47 So we can see increases in office electricity instead of a decrease then, I guess. And these are, again, these are increases based off of last year's budget. Now, looking at actual, we spent four grand last year on the one furnace. Now we've got to spend another four grand this year. So this is above and beyond last year's budget and not last year's actual. A lot of the other pieces in here, I don't think there's anything unless there's something that jumps out at anyone.
1:27:14 A lot of these, like a lot of the red numbers going down are based on the P&L, based on what we actually spent this year. You know, we just basically look at it and say, okay, we budget for X, we spent X minus 1, let's budget for X minus 1.
1:27:28 And on the air subsidy measure A, so this was a determination that TBID can cover 80% in the remaining 20 years. So on measure A, on the TBID, excuse me, on air subsidy, John called me this morning and asked the question because if you look at the top line and the bottom line of page 2, it's air subsidy. Whitney and I had a miscommunication as to, I asked her, we talked about moving some money around, but basically when we look at a year-over-year comparison, it's budgeted at the exact same amount.
1:27:57 And the reason that one showed that it was lower was that Whitney actually went in and budgeted the actual for last summer, but I don't want to budget the actual in case we end up higher. So we'll always budget 1.51 in winter out of TBID, and then we'll always budget 500,000 in summer out of TBID, and then we've always cushioned it at 265,000 out of Measure A for summer, which gives us 765,000 for...
1:28:24 The summer flight, which it hasn't been in a few years, but we want to be padded enough. And then also out of that $7.65 is the anticipation that Mono County is going to contribute there, the $50,000 that they've contributed for the last four or five years at this point. So there is, in the revenue line of the Measure A budget, you'll see that there's a $50,000 line item for the county to participate. And I'll be doing a presentation to them on August 15th. We always ask for $100,000.
1:28:52 We used to get 85, but got knocked back to 50,000. So we'll go in again looking for the full 100,000 in support. But that, just my general question was on the 80-20 split. That was done based on surveying flight utilization? Yes. 80% is local. Is out of town? Yeah, 80% is out of town. 20% is local. Correct. Measure A eligible. Correct. So, Don, I'm still, I'm sorry, I'm still a little bit confused as to,
1:29:22 The difference between that Measure A, air subsidy, $161,000 plus, and the measure, and the TBID air subsidy, negative $292. So what happened was Whitney took the 20% out of the 1.5 in the winter, put it into Measure A. Okay. And then she reduced the summer subsidy to go from $265 down to the actual this year, which is like $134.
1:29:48 Something like that. So that's where the positive is. Now that's not happening. That's where the gap happened. Okay. But I don't want us to budget air subsidy to actual because I don't want to get screwed. I mean, we could easily go in and say, okay, you know what, we budgeted 134 in Measure A for air subsidy and we need 265 and I can come back to you guys and say, hey, we've got to pull it out of reserve.
1:30:07 I don't want to do that. We tend to have a savings in that every year, but I'd rather budget the amount that we think we're going to pay. We budgeted $1.51 million for last winter. We're going to write a check this week for $1.083 million for this winter, which is that $434,000 that we're going to reinvest into the TBID. And then the same with the summer dollars. We can reinvest them because we didn't spend them last year.
1:30:32 But I'm not going to unbudget, I'm not going to budget down because I don't want us to get to the point where I have to come back to you and say, hey, we only budgeted $634,000 and subsidy came in at $800,000 so we need $170,000 out of reserve. I'd rather have us built into the operating budget. Okay, that makes sense. Makes sense? Yep. Okay. So this goes into the marketing portion of the budget variances and just a friendly reminder of the process that we take when we're developing this.
1:31:00 You know, we start in February where we're putting together the strategy for this and we presented it to this board, I believe in April. You bring in the meeting all those budget numbers in in May and create the plan to support that strategy and this is what you get. In this past year, Jen and I worked together to combine the marketing and interactive departments because really they're interchangeable. It's just marketing now. There is no such thing as interactive specifically.
1:31:29 I mean, there is, but we're ahead of the time now. We've also cleaned up the code of accounts, and then we've further defined expenditures, as he explained. So starting in the research for Measure A, and I'm more than happy to go through each of these line items, is that the process we'd like to go through? Is everyone comfortable with that? It's going to be. The highlights is where I was, Sarah, because I think you did a nice job of breaking, this is what I was looking for, saying, okay, what's the difference?
1:31:56 Got a little, got a little, uh, shogging on with removing accounts around, so that's making a little bit more confusing, because, you know, like, even down the Adobe, whatever it was, 200 dollars or whatever, like, okay, uh, either way. Well, the thing is, we're right, we're, we're, we're putting things in the right place, so moving forward, you won't see this much movement.
1:32:16 Right, yeah, so next year it will not be this. Right, but we've got this last year, this year, next year, my concern is I look back three years and stuff's going to be changed categories, that's my concern. So we look at it going, okay, we spent $100,000 more over here.
1:32:30 Actually, we may not have, because three years ago, it was posted differently. So that's my concern is looking back. We can keep tabs on it as we move forward, because there are things that will shift. It won't be easy, because it is a transition, but we will have all the backup data to be able to explain it. Well, like Sean has asked Mary Carson before, but that fee that you put Mary Carson on, I suppose, social media, there's a lot of things that are all buried in there that can get a little confusing, depending on how you look at it.
1:32:57 For me, going back to your question, I'm just looking at highlights because I'm looking, okay, air service was a little confusing to me. I got the research. To me, it was more, if you want to go through that, I have questions because there's a couple, like, research was just high from my standpoint. If you have $50,000 additional, got it, we have more, but I'm thinking to myself, okay, as a percentage of revenues increase, an extra $50,000 for research, does that make sense? And I don't know. I mean, that's where I'm, and there's a couple things.
1:33:26 That makes sense, but like guidebooks, you're $20,000 less than guidebooks, TBID, and I'm thinking content doesn't really joke about it. Do we want to start on one of these line items and then go down from there? Or shall I just go through this document? And again, what we did was based on what the request from the board was, we put in anything above or below 10%. If you want to pull out certain pieces of this to talk about, because again, some things could be up or down.
1:33:55 You know, gas is down 70%. It's $2,800. I'm not sure we're saving $2,800. So I think if you want to pick things, we can either go through it at a high level and you can interrupt as needed. We can go through it fast. Or you can pull out and say, hey, what's the $41,000 more in contract services? Yeah, like on this page here, I have one question on the measure of the lodging. That's the only question I have on that page. So backing up to the research, did anyone have any questions about that?
1:34:23 For 12-5? Okay. Or branding, promotional items? We're going through Measure A and then we'll go through Measure T-BID next. Contract services, reducing subscriptions, lodging. Lodging went up quite a bit. The ADRs have skyrocketed. Yeah, that's a misprint, isn't it? 200 to 325? No. Yeah. Because we're on average 235.
1:34:45 Well, no, no, no, I'm sorry, we're talking about our travel to New York City or Los Angeles or San Francisco. So it's based on our travel. Last year we estimated that the average would be $200 including taxes. I missed the mark big time. $325 is going to cover us on the average. Sometimes it comes in at $143 and then sometimes it's...
1:35:08 Right up there at 350. Well, I'm just trying to understand, because we're all looking, you know, for us lodging people, we're looking at those rates, and they haven't done that much in the major metropolitan oil markets, just trying to figure out what change. We didn't buy that. We used the star report to take a look at it, to have some backup data, if you'd like me to send that to you, but that's just based on the actual. I'm not disagreeing with that. You go down to LA, good luck finding room for 200 bucks. I mean, that's. And that's exactly what happened. Last year, we thought we could, and we found out we can't. But last year, there was only one section. We've been doing this for a couple of years. I'm just wondering why last year, we were off so much as.
1:35:38 As much as my question as going the budget forward. Because I don't think $200 is a tough one. And my only subset was, I mean, I signed off on everybody's expenses last year. You know, by law was pretty judicious, but we set standards in regards to where people are staying because right now we're allowing it to book out. Do we need to be saying, okay.
1:35:58 And Brent, we are really prudent. We do competitive shop. I mean, part of the challenge is certain things that I question myself and I look up and go, ooh, this is a good rate. $3.25 was cheaper than $6.25 in the hotel next door. Well, and like even our, like with this California, this California always books Terranea. You know, they book the Ritz of Happening Bay. I mean, a lot of times we don't have an option. And they get us a group rate, but it's still $300.
1:36:22 I'm not suggesting we do it for the second, but I'm just down the road looking at saying, do we set some standards? Because I'm not looking for us to stay in Motel 6 either. That's not my goal, to save two bucks to have a... And I think it's tough too, especially with Michael when he's off in London and you can't get a room for less than $4.50. Well, and this is my lodging budget. This isn't Michael's. Oh, this is you. This isn't the London or Hong Kong. This is like just California here. This is me too. Yeah, okay. I'm in here as well. Right, the two of us.
1:36:52 You know, definitely I have a one sheet. I mean, these are the things that we're restricting and I make my team work for this. I mean, lodging is not an easy process in our office. Is it, did you have anything else to add to that or something? No, I just want to look at what that standard is and how we. Okay, so moving on to the next set. Keep in mind, so now our research budget is right around $150.
1:37:20 annually. And with the increase of our budget, we did increase the number of times that we're in market. We have a third wave now for fall. And so that goes up incrementally. I've also introduced a conversion ROI research study on our own channels that we haven't done in the past. So that's an additional charge for our websites, social media, visitor guide, trade shows, to just measure their effectiveness moving forward. Does this include
1:37:48 SMARM? This is SMARI. This is SMARI. It's the SMARI research. It's the visitor profile every other year. It's the air quant study every other year. It's the awareness. It's all the stuff that we present to you, and it's all critical data for us. Like Whitney said, you know, it's great that we're doing the fall media, but we need to know if it's working. Yeah, and you would know it. There's the research behind that.
1:38:07 Better than anyone that like the reason you stay on top is you do constant R&D and measure where you're at. And so, you know, we go out every time after an ad campaign to measure awareness and ROI. And then at the end of the year, we do ROI. And then every two years, we do the visitor profile. And now I've added this additional layer for the conversion study. Printing, we've moved everything.
1:38:32 into one bucket, so there's one of those things. You know, our demand is just going up. We just have more visitors in market, and, you know, we also have more resources for our business community. Our town maps have increased to annual order from, you know, we used to do 20,000 a year. We're getting close to 200,000 a year now. We can't get them away fast enough. I know. And you can't come get them fast enough. Sticker demand is gone.
1:38:58 Way up, visitor guide demand. I have a thought on a sticker too. And it's funny, you know, and I have to say this because when I first came on board, there was actually a policy that we wouldn't give lodging properties more than two pads of maps. Of 25 maps each. And we basically said, I'm sorry, what? And we changed that and we started ordering a hell of a lot more maps. If you're going to give them to all your customers, then we need to print them, not, you know.
1:39:22 Have a desk copy that you show them where they're going to go. It's ridiculous. And then in addition to that, we do have two additional print pieces. We now have a cooperative piece that we do with the eastern Sierra region that's from Inyo, Bishop, Mono County, and ourselves for the Sierra fishing map as well as a fall color map. So we have a couple additions there. And then, Sean, this is where your road branders have been added into as well that you had a question about. So we reserved in the road branders in our budget. Yeah.
1:39:51 That was a discussion that we had with Stu.
1:39:55 Sue's Brown Department, and we're going to make that shift, and that transition's in process in September. Yes, that is in process. Well, we're, yes, yes, he's made it. There's conversations. Yes, that was finalized by him to move those dollars over, and so we'll be moving forward in that. Do you have any foreign language? Yeah, yeah. You know, so that would be Michael Vanderhurst's budget line item, and. I looked already.
1:40:24 You are appointed that way. So that will be at International. Okay. But domestically, we rely primarily on Visit California's pieces, and then we also have a translation service on our site. It's Google Translate. And when we tested that first wave of international, you know, having the translation on there, we tracked it to see where people were going, and they were still reading it in English from the international nation. So that really made us,
1:40:55 You know, take a step back. Like, do we want to convert a bunch of pages, you know, traditionally? Or is this good enough? Because the traffic to the English pages were actually higher from those international markets. So that was really interesting research. As you see guidebooks, again, we've taken this down, you know, and moved these dollars to be more focused on our content online and our social.
1:41:17 Which is, you know, social channels, that's really how people are starting to shop. That native is gaining a lot of attention and content and everything. Everybody is coming to our website and so I've just shifted those dollars out of the guidebook. Are those two different publications, guidebook and visitor guide? Yes, so guidebooks are external. So that would be our publication, I mean our advertisement and Visit California's visitor guide. And then previously we... That one's going down.
1:41:46 No, that one's still in there. But our visitor guide budget is going up. Visitor guides are going up. Right. In the other categories. Yes, two different categories. Visitor guides are under printing. Guidebooks are where we are purchasing. One quick question. That's a budget item that I increase that I like to see. The printing of the visitor guides, the demand being so high, doubled. Are those being mailed to people? They are as well. So we've got...
1:42:13 I believe we've got 10,000 for fulfillment that we're averaging a year for our online distribution where people are just downloading it from our website. We're right around...
1:42:25 5,000, but those are starting to pace at the same pace as our mail request, and then the rest of them are distributed, I want to say, and then we distribute them locally as well. What's the process for mailing? Does somebody call the visitor center and say, could I get one of those mails? You know, they do. Email request, call request. And we also have a sign-up sheet on our Visit Mammoth site. I see. We drive, on the website, we drive people, we have a digital page-turner version. We drive people to that as much as possible.
1:42:53 But Emily's still mailing hundreds and hundreds and hundreds a week around the world. Those of us with an AOL account. You didn't get your latest CD in the mail. Well, it's a little different when you can have that to carry around. All right, guys. So then also going to...
1:43:15 So as you can see, the newspaper is a new line item, and that is specific to local marketing. Previously, I'd clumped our local marketing in our incidental line because we typically break this out throughout the year, but I've just designated based on the actuals for the past few years. And this will include anything from seasonal marketing to air promotion to industry messaging, radio. Again, this is
1:43:45 half of this is through Marion Carson. This was lumped under one line item for Marion Carson. So remember before we had the marketing and the interactive budgets and breaking out the Marion Carson contract was it just made it really difficult.
1:44:04 to share with everybody. Now that we've combined those budgets, we are actually breaking it out into the line items for where Marian Carson will be spending those dollars. And then remember, we optimize during our campaigns and then also afterwards, and so there will be a shift, like maybe there's less dollars in out-of-home, more dollars in online content. You always are optimizing and adapting to...
1:44:26 The effectiveness of your campaign. Television, again, this is a local line item for our local marketing, and it's brand new. Giveaway promotion, all 800 bucks. Increased cost and legal supported giveaways. Out of home, again, that number used to be included in that Marion Carson overall contract number. Those are billboards for those who don't know what out of home is. Yes, sorry. Domestic consumer experiential.
1:44:55 This number is up $100,000. So this would be, again, previously the Marion Carson numbers were built in that one. The experiential includes that big fish. So previously we had a $12,500 budget per show. With the introduction of the virtual reality video, we are estimating that those costs are going to come in at $25,000 per show. So that's the result of that increase.
1:45:24 $25,000 per show. So previously, it was $12,000 for the big fish, and that includes loading in, paying dryage, paying labor, and then for the conference center itself, but then also for the staff who's setting it up, and then the people who operate it and interact with the people. It's about a four-day process. So, did you have any other questions about that?
1:45:53 No, it's not cheap. Anything to do with a conference center and union labor is not cheap. So I was taking one opportunity to just take the fact of virtual reality because you're having an information booth. The only thing I'm sad is it's junk too much. I'm at a nice little run down the mountain and all of a sudden I'm snowbilling. Well, that was just a teaser. That was a teaser. Yes. I was like, yeah. I think a lot of you saw them in virtual reality. I'm having a good time cruising down the mountain and all of a sudden I'm...
1:46:21 Yeah, I think Sean saw it. I think Paul, you saw the virtual, yeah. Yeah, that was the teaser. They barely cut it in time for that event. So coming into... And that will not be how that looks for our conference room. Like I want... Because the virtuality is not... It's not impressive when you see people doing it. You know what I mean? Like I'm looking at you, you've got goggles on. Now they've got this new technology where you're walking into a dome and you're not wearing something. You are in the environment. And so...
1:46:49 That's the style we're going to go into. Just stay tuned. We don't have all the details yet. So travel and entertainment. Again, the Marion Carson budgets were, this is where I'm moving, Marion Carson as well as miles travel. Any other big things in here that we want to talk about on this page? Question on this. I know it's a new line item, but can we get any kind of comparison as to what?
1:47:18 We spent on travel entertainment through the Marian Carson numbers. Yeah, I can get that for you, definitely. Okay. Well, I guess it's probably not a 100% jump. It's just breaking it out. So it's probably not a...
1:47:35 Major jump, it's just breaking it out from one lump number into five different line items. I guess, and I need information as much as if there's just any wild variances. There's not wild variances with them. Typically when you increase, like, it's kind of like the research, when you increase your ad spend, now you have to build in that research section. When you build in...
1:47:59 Another ad spend in a virtual reality. That means that we have more on-site meetings or more time together or they're here filming. And so that's where those numbers come from. Okay. So it's all part of a, you know, a bigger formula. You now introduce video. They're going to have to come here on-site and produce it. So that's where that reflects. Yeah, and if I could just go to a larger question. So in general, are we planning to do basically the same amount of trade shows we did last year?
1:48:27 We are doing the same shows. I see a slight staff of changes and you got some lodging, but we're not looking at any significant change in trade shows in that situation. No. I don't know all that details in your detailed budget. And I can definitely... And Sean, to your point, instead of it being a $500,000 line item with a bunch of stuff included, it's now five different line items with...
1:48:50 It broken out so that it's more clear. And I update all those actuals on a monthly basis so once I get done with this year's fiscal I can get that to you and then you would definitely have the 2016-17 to 17-18 comparison. Under sales. Does anyone else have any questions? Should we just flip forward to sales? Okay. We should be wrapped with this by 3.30.
1:49:25 Did anyone else have any questions about marketing? Okay, moving on to sales. Question on sales right off the bat. Anticipated cost increase, larger number of fans, which is great, and also solo ownership of cost. Where are you? Sales, fame, trips, T, about halfway down, 12.5. Yeah, so let me explain the sales in general.
1:50:00 So in the past, what we've done is we have split the cost of multiple agencies around the world with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So we have a $35,000 agreement in Australia with Gate 7. We would pay $17,500. They would pay $17,500. Currently, with the mountain in transition with ownership, they're not signing any agreements. So what we've done is we have budgeted to maintain the relationships and pick up the portion so that we're whole with the idea that we have seen so much
1:50:29 Growth with our international markets and with these agencies that we don't want to lose traction. So there's a very good chance that there could even be upwards of $100,000 recaptured after the mountain goes through their transitions. You know, we may go back with Gate 7, Black Diamond. You know, we've got a number of these relationships. I think we're splitting of year reps in China and South Korea as well. And so it's really...
1:50:54 Right now it's a stopgap measure in case we can't get these agreements signed moving forward and split with the mountain. We don't want to lose the traction so we're picking up the full tab. The other side of it too with the FAM trips is that in the past we've worked with the mountain to say hey we've got this trade group coming in or this rider coming in and we've been able to either get comped or at least industry rates and what we're looking at now is if we have to buy everything this year
1:51:23 because of the transition that we're prepared. So if you have to get a full run on that stuff. So I guess that was my question was just kind of a quick elaboration on what specifically you kind of partner with in Mammoth, is that like in kind of lift tickets, et cetera, et cetera. Yeah, it's everything from the actual agency fees to hosting in market. And specifically with the fam trips though, it's like lift tickets, what else are we picking up this additional cost on?
1:51:51 Lodging, it could be lodging, meals, rentals, ski school, anything that we've in the past had a relationship with the mountain on. And again, this is a precautionary measure. We don't think this is where it's going to end up, but we want a budget to make sure that we don't go backwards if for some reason, if the mountain decides that they're going to partner up and say, okay, we're going to have a California division and we're going to have a sales team and they're going to do their own thing and you guys are doing this piece here. I don't see that happening, but
1:52:21 Who knows with new ownership? Johnny. He's just protecting ourselves. I don't see that happening either. There we go. Good to know. So that's really the biggest thing on the sales side are those relationships and the agency fees and then what it's going to take. The other thing in here, you'll see the native language videos.
1:52:43 Basically, in the past, we've created a French video, an Italian video. It's our Welcome to Mammoth Lakes video. Sandra Di DiMizio does the Italian version. Jeff Guillory has done the French version. We're moving forward and doing a Mandarin and German and a Portuguese version. I have no idea who the hell is doing those. German, maybe? Not me. I think Stacy Corliss was. That's right. Here we go. I'm a little rusty. No. Mandarin? So like a combination of Mandarin and...
1:53:10 Never mind. Yeah, I don't know. Portuguese, what's that? Portuguese is Brazil. Yeah, Portuguese is Brazil. Oh, I knew that. And it's great to have those out there. I mean, they've been very useful when I went to Italy to speak on the mountain biking piece, and I was able to present the Welcome to Mammoth Lakes video in Italian. It was, one, they were all floored at Sandra's accent and being able not to sound like an American.
1:53:39 Helps when you grow up Italian. Did the mountain give you any idea of when they would perhaps be able to... You know, they're going to have to get their sale closed and then they're going to have to figure out exactly... I talked to Eric Forssell last night about consolidation because, again, I went through this with American Skiing Company. It's not fun. I feel for Joni and the crew up there because they're looking at everything from their accounting systems to sales teams to all this. So I'm guessing that we're probably looking at the fall.
1:54:07 Whether they're going to be able to participate. I just thought they may have given you some kind of rejection. No, honestly, everybody that we've spoken with is pretty in the dark themselves. So I don't think that we have, it's not that they're holding information from us. They don't know. Well, I think one of the big, our fiscal year, this year's fiscal year is odd. It's based on the timing of the operation. So it starts in November and ends in October. With the new company, there's a good chance we'll have to alter our fiscal year. But once we start budgeting, that'll be the real true story. Right.
1:54:40 Like I said, it's really challenging. What calendar is the new company on? They close their August to July. Yeah. Not fun. Yet to be named. Yet to be named company. So, yeah. So at this point, what we don't want to do is we don't want to go backwards with the opportunities that we've built. One thing I'll say with the team, you know, with Michael, Lara, and Whitney, is our longevity in these positions.
1:55:11 is huge. The writers all know Lara, all the marketing people know Whitney, and Michael can walk into any room in any country and they know exactly who he is. And on the sales side, that relationship piece is massive and we don't want to see us go backwards with any of these things and say, we can only pay $17.5 and we're only going to do this and we're only going to do that. We want to continue the momentum because it's been really working. Yeah, we've optimized these contracts based on the competitive analysis of who else is operating in these countries. So if anyone wants to volunteer for the Mandarin
1:55:41 Video, let us know. Good, perfect. Any other questions on sales? Moving on to PR? Or moving backwards? Yeah, I was going to move backwards. I'm sorry. Search engine marketing. Sorry, I just caught up to the 1,074% increase. That was actually something that was, this is not something that, well, it was.
1:56:08 It's not a new line item? No. So this was one of those messy codes that we had in our accounting. We had combined our search engine marketing and our search engine optimization, and we wanted to break those out. So previously those were combined, and then again this was part of the overall Marion Carson contract. And I don't know if, you know, we were talking
1:56:34 Brent was talking about how you refer back to those interactive and marketing budgets to compare all of these. I have updated all the actuals in our previous years. So we do have all this to reference to. And I can send out the 2016-17 budget. So we're not really up 1,000%. That's just because of how it's been separated out. Okay, because there's other line items. From the primary contract. There's other line items that say it was previously in the Marian Carson, but. Like the social media.
1:57:03 Under TBID. Yeah, I'm asking these questions as far as, you know, this amount of increase that we're having, that's pretty dramatic, but you're saying that it's not really that much? No, it was, well, one, we have increased the contract amount, so it will increase, but previously, yes, so this is a new line item, because previously it was in that overall Marian Carson budget line item. There was a line item last year for $1.87 million for Marian Carson. Okay.
1:57:32 That included these lineups. That included everything that Marion Carson did. That had to be broken out. That has to be trackable. So moving forward, you'll be able to see search engine marketing next year, compare apples to apples. Right now it's apples to oranges. You know, we had four budgets that we were working with. Now we're down to the two, and it's been cleaned up. Whitney, if you were to compare apples to apples, and the search engine marketing was broken out last year, how would that number compare to this number?
1:58:01 I would have to take a look back at, because we've increased their budget, so then everything increases incrementally. But that would, if you had that number from last year and this year, then you, instead of having 1,070. Yeah, it's not going to be 1,000. Yeah, it's something that would be reasonable with the incremental budget or the incremental contract that we've awarded them now. Exactly. Exactly.
1:58:29 What are some examples of SEM? Search engine marketing is, you know, when you're, you know, when you're all of a sudden getting these, like, hey, you, you like shoes, and you're like, wait a minute, how did I just find shoes? It's those keywords that you see and you click through. So that's search engine marketing. The display is under the display in native, which is right below it.
1:58:58 But it's also based on clicks. It's not based on, like, just flat-out ads on pages. The flat-out ads are a part of the display, native, and video advertising. Got it. And the SEM is solely what you just mentioned. It's those, it's those. That, like, data mining kind of the getcha. Based on questions, isn't it? Yeah. What your search engine, what you're searching. What you're looking for, it pops stuff up in front of you and you wonder how that only knows. Your birth date and your social security number is. What size shoe you wear. Yeah. Big brother. Big brother stuff.
1:59:27 It's okay. It's anonymous. Don't worry about it. I'm sorry. And then that goes for the social media as well. So, and we did increase. Now, you will see in the last two years, we really, we started to delve heavier into that paid space. We did, we were not there three years ago, and that's due to our increase in budget to Marian Carson. That's why it's an increase.
2:00:04 Yeah, you can measure anything from likes to shares to conversion to, yeah, how many people? The paid part of social media so much of that is how many people click through Mammoth Package because we're selling actual products. Conversion.
2:00:28 Oh no, that's why I got research, to measure that. And you know when Josh gets up and talks about the reports on, so we have a social, that's tracking, that's how you're measuring it, and we've got a platform that we use that pulls in all that good data. It's emotional intelligence, do you see the ad, do you feel all warmth inside?
2:00:56 All right, if there's nothing else, we can move on to PR and Lara's world before she has a baby. Any minute. If she had the baby now during working hours, does that work out? Yeah, it could be. It could be. So encouraging. So smart. An encourager. That is such a big saving for you. We've got to add to the budget. Don't anybody say push. John, don't be rude. Yeah, we're good. We're good. Any kind of upset. We don't want you to upset.
2:01:24 So mine are pretty straightforward. I don't know if anybody has any questions. The first one, sponsorship, we secured another writers conference for next June, and this one's pretty exciting. It's the freelance council for SATW. So it's only writers and photographers that were coming next year. They're not allowed to bring spouses. Other PR people aren't allowed to come. It's solely writers.
2:01:50 And photographers. And let me go back to the conversation we just had about relationships. So we've hosted the Western chapter, the Midwest chapter, or the Mid-States, and we've always had to go out and get, we've always had to put a proposal in. Because of what Lara has done in the last ones that we've hosted, we didn't put a proposal in. They came to us and said, we're coming.
2:02:15 I mean, it's a huge opportunity, a huge feather in her cap to say that we didn't even have to put together the proposal to say this is why you should come here versus going there. They said we want to go there, which is pretty cool. That doesn't happen. So yeah, 20 grand is a pretty small price to pay, seeing as how we usually get articles that are worth at least 50 out of it. And I'm expecting even more since these will all be riders. And then the second one, promotional.
2:02:43 In the crib social media channels, we're just finding that the content that we've been producing, blog posts, and then also Josh has a bit of a budget to promote social media posts. That's really working, so we just bumped that up a little bit. The people that use the crib, are they obliged to give us some content? That's the trade-off. That's the conversation. I mean, they don't sign anything, but we send them a...
2:03:16 page that says, this is what we expect. And these are the tags we want you to use and all that. Yeah. And they're always really happy to do it. Always alright? Yeah. I haven't had anybody be like, nah, I'm not gonna. I'm not gonna take a free place because you want me to take a free place. It works out well. You never know. You never know. I don't think we've had anybody ever say that they weren't gonna do it. Nope. And in fact, we've expanded more with interviews with these people and all these other things to really get more out of it. And we still have not had any pushback.
2:03:44 Might be hard to schedule them sometimes, but no pushback. Again, the budget detail. So these were the variances, as we talked about. All of the budget detail is in the two other documents for both TBID and for Measure A, line by line, as detailed as you should need. But if there are things that aren't detailed enough, please feel free to ask whoever's department it falls within. If it falls within Whitney's world, just ask for clarification.
2:04:15 Marketing's got three pages in both budgets on where we're going with every single dollar. So in general, for instance, if I look at Measure A, go to the second page where it says last year's total $194,000, this year $170,360. Correct. Obviously, we've got some legal expense, a little bit more expense, but in general, when we're looking at those big cost changes on the variance sheet, that's because of how we reposition most of those. In reality, our budget for expenses is down.
2:04:44 Right. So that's the other side is that if you want to know what any variance is, what we did was I went into the Excel sheet and I added those three columns. So everybody put in last year's numbers and it calculated the dollar difference and the percentage difference. So if you wanted to see anything that was even a 4% increase or 4% decrease, like if you want to look at top line accounting services, you know, accounting services went up 4%.
2:05:14 So it went up $1,500. And that was based on actual for this year. So we've got $36,000 budgeted for this year. We did $34,500 last year. So you can look at any line item and see where we were last year. Measure A. Apparel changed 1%. Expenses goes down 12%. If I just take gross numbers. But I do have one question. What I'm leading to is I got one question here that I don't understand on particularly the expenses. It's a $300 question. Volunteer accent, $300. Oh.
2:05:42 So this is a whole new insurance policy that we have to have. So for the last five, seven years, our staff has been taking people out on the mountain and hiking. And if we have a writer come in from New York Times, we take them out. We actually have not been covered from an insurance standpoint on that. And so even with our ambassadors, this is a new insurance policy that covers our ambassadors to take someone out. It was a conversation I had with Robert Beach from down in Bishop.
2:06:12 in the kind of in the early spring when we were just kind of wrapping up all of our winter hostings and he said that in the world of insurance we were considered ski guides if we took someone out onto the hill and we put ourselves in a huge liability spot by being ski guides whether it was Laura or me or Michael or whoever.
2:06:35 So we are working on a policy now moving forward that will cover us for that because he said, well, you can stop doing it or you can hire the mountain to do it. I said, well, we'll hire the mountain to do it. It'll cost us a fortune because we have a ton of people coming in here and frankly, the mountain probably doesn't even have enough people to take care of what we need. So this is something we need. And so we're still working with him on that policy, but that's exactly what it is. It's a brand new thing that we were not aware of.
2:07:02 So that's a liability policy we're talking about? Yeah. Okay. Can we have, for the ambassadors themselves, we have work comp coverage? We have, we're working on that as well because of the idea of whether they are paid or unpaid and, yep. Still have to have that work comp coverage. Right. But that's why this volunteer policy comes in. That's where this volunteer policy comes in because most of our ambassadors are truly volunteers. Yep. Yep. But you still have to have coverage. Yep, exactly. And that's where, that's where the conversation with Robert Beach came from.
2:07:32 And Robert's on top of that stuff. He has very much so. So you've got comm coverage for the ambassador program and other volunteers, and you have liability coverage in case one of the ambassadors trips a person. Although on the mountain, if they get hurt on the mountain, there's very little exposure there. Yeah, right. But if they get tripped here in town going down the stairs... But if they're with us and they get hurt on the mountain, that's where it starts to get a little... I'm sorry? If they're with us on the mountain, they get hurt.
2:08:01 That's where we're guiding them technically according to them. So it's something that we need to deal with Robert Beach. We don't need to get into it here, but it's something that, and he and I literally had an hour and a half conversation on the phone about it because neither one of us knew what the hell to do with it because he's never had to face it. And, you know, obviously the mountain's covered by themselves and we just fell into this weird purgatory in between there. It's 300 bucks. Yeah.
2:08:27 What if Paul gets a paper cut? We already talked about it too much. Well, that's a good point. Good point. Excellent. What if you get a paper cut? Yeah, well, skiing liability is a specialty that I used to pursue when I practiced law. Yeah. Pursue in the most positive way, right? Pursue in the most positive way, right? Well, if you call suing the hell out of the mountain every chance I got, yeah.
2:08:52 All right. So are we good with the budget? We're getting close on time here and just want to make sure we approve the budget because we're all going to be held to be answering questions. So I want to make sure we're all comfortable with it. Yeah, go ahead, Paul. I have one line item. Let me find it. It's buried in here somewhere.
2:09:22 Which budget? Measure A or TBID? Measure A or TBID? Hey, you know, you get buried in information and there's so much stuff that's fine in it. Okay, here it is. Air Planners, LLC. Air Planners is our consultant out of Vail, Colorado. That's Kent Myers. These are the people that have been helping us to get more emplanements? Those are the guys that help us try and get the right times.
2:10:02 with the airlines. He works with us on the airlines. How long have we had them on? They've been with us, well, they've probably been with the mountain before us. We seem to be having a problem in that area. Well, he can only do so much to convince the airlines. Well, no, I don't mean specifically with times of embarkation, but with just emplanements as a whole. Well, his role with us is very little on the emplanement side.
2:10:32 It's more on the relationships with the airlines and relationships with and getting all the data and getting us the flight information and all the passenger counts and all that other info. I hear what you're saying. Theoretically, though, if that's all done right, that would encourage a claimant, though. I'm not sure that they're directly correlated. He works with the airlines to make sure that we don't get screwed on a flight time out of San Diego. I'm not sure. Yes, yes, it would. If we can get the airline to give us a 5 o'clock flight out of San Diego, it should increase in claimants. But again,
2:11:01 The fact that they come back and tell us to pound sand and it's a 130 flight, you know, there's not as much control over that. No, no, I understand that. Yeah, and we do have a line item in here for working with Embark Aviation on the marketing plan. That's in the variance side. It's probably $41,000. And that's really, right now, they're gearing up towards helping us with the fall service.
2:11:25 helping us promote the fall service, and really a lot of what we're relying on with them is the local marketing and relationships in town, getting the lodging properties to have the right stuff on their websites and all those different pieces. Does Embark Air help us with marketing at the other end? Yes, yes. And Embark is made up of a number of guys that have worked with our market for years with Alaska Airlines.
2:11:53 So it's a new company that they formed outside of Alaska Airlines. Where's that line item that you're looking at, Clay? Oh, it's that, well, the pages aren't numbered, which, by the way, it's under marketing measure A, it's number 630. It's under contract services, like the third thing down. Yeah, contract services. And that contract is laid out and the backup data, were they given that the last monthly meeting?
2:12:31 The Embark, the different contracts and numbers that we had for marketing department. Okay. I can send that out where it goes through the details, but. Is this the $2,500 a month? Well, it's the $2,500 a month plan, and then below it is a different amount for a different agency of $8,000 in July, and then it seems to be $3,000 across the rest of the year. And then the answer brings fish stocking.
2:13:01 Isn't where we stock the fish, it's where we buy it from, right? Correct. Yeah. Wait, what? What did she just add? Yeah. No, that's the company. We're stocking somebody out in the valley. All right, any other comments regarding the budget? No, I'm going to make a motion. Yeah, you want to make a motion to it? Yeah, I'm going to make a motion to approve the budget as distributed. We're measuring it for TBID. Do we have a second?
2:13:33 Any more discussion? Okay, all in favor? Aye. Opposed? Excellent. Budget is accepted. And just a side note, I'll upload the actual budgets from last year in our board documents, as well as the backup information for this budget, just so you have it on hand. I've got a deck, of course. It would be really helpful, because when I look at the Dropbox files, the dates on them, some of them have great dates, some of them don't. Let me fix that.
2:14:03 So just so much. Yeah. Oh, absolutely. I will take care of that for sure. I have to figure out how to do that myself. If not, I'll hand, I'll hand, I'll hand number and post name. No. I know. In fact, if you send me more stuff, you have to send in the camera with it. Okay. Well, let's move on quickly to the next item. It's the MLT controlled reserve, reserve earmarks. Yeah, you have a, you have a copy in your packet there. You know, last time we talked about these, I think that,
2:14:33 You know, this is still going to be a fluid document. This is still going to be a fluid process because I think things are going to come up that we're going to want to change. But for now, the numbers that I threw out at the last meeting were what I suggested for proposed earmarks for the capital expenditure. What I did put in here was I put in a line item for the air service strategy. We've received all the RFQs. We are actually, I'm in the process of getting back references on the company that we want to go with.
2:15:01 And we keep that ball rolling. So I've actually put this number in here as part of our reserves to pull that potentially $60,000 out to do the 10-year strategy plan. I figured it's good to put it in here now. But roughly this is where we are with funding. And last time we...
2:15:21 We approved the earmarks, but I think we wanted to have a more formal process. It is on the agenda to vote on, so we can actually say these are rough ideas of the earmarks, and once we come down to actually cutting checks, we can determine where we're going. On this topic, I know that MLTPA has submitted something to the town today with the wayfinding signage process to basically manage the process. I think that the...
2:15:45 The proposal that came in was something like $37,000 to actually manage the entire process. That doesn't include the actual signage, but that is something that I have asked.
2:15:55 MLTPA to forward to the town that the town can then forward back to us and say, hey, is this something that you would be willing to pick up this portion as well as XYZ down the road? So my suggestion is when we get that from the town that we put together a formal MOU with the town and we finalize the number, whether it's the 350,000 that we have listed on here or it's more or less. But I think we're going to take them as case by case basis. Same thing with the airport.
2:16:22 Funding. You know, we can do an MOU potentially this fall and write a check for either the amount we've got listed here or we can write more or we can write less. These are not set in stone. This is just saying this is roughly where we feel these funds should go. Very fluid document as far as I'm concerned. And as far as other projects can be added to this throughout the year as we feel necessary? Correct. Yep. Yeah, and I left the special events position in there because if we do not
2:16:51 Have any financial support coming back from the town, we may want to go into this fund and say, okay, we're going to commit XYZ over the next three years towards this position, and it'll come out of this fund. So, again, it is a very fluid fund, and like you said, we can add or subtract. We can decide that the conference center is not a game that we need to be even playing in right now, and we can redistribute those funds as needed. So just to clarify, the 1.85 is...
2:17:19 Using the $250,000 or the $300,000? Using the $300,000 number that was actually committed. No? Wait, what? So, up above the special events venue is $250,000, proposed year mark. We committed $300,000. Which number are we using in that $185,000? The committed's gone. Don't worry about that. The $185,000 is the rest of it. Okay, that's my rephrase question. We're looking to commit another $250,000 to the...
2:17:44 Special Events Venue Fund. Again, blank number. I just put a $250,000 in there as potential support moving forward. That's support moving forward. The $300,000 has already been committed. Correct. Correct. And that's exclusive of the $300,000 that's already been removed. I still think we have a little bit of clarity with the redistribution of whether...
2:18:14 reserves, or overages through Q4 are coming to us, or whether it's just through Q3 and the rest of it's going in? Q4. Okay, so that may adjust this number slightly, but it shouldn't adjust it hugely. Q4, 16, 17. Right. So if we end up at 18 million on a budget of 11.6, or yeah, 11.6, yeah, that's, I don't know if that is, 4.5 point, probably another million bucks, so it's roughly the.
2:18:47 Roughly the number that I have here. So, again, very fluid document, so what you're voting on today is just to have the earmarked dollars for now, and they can be adjusted as you see fit. So those four are what we've previously discussed, special events menu, airport, center wayfinding, and the only additional earmarked dollar would be the air service strategy? Correct. And the terminal? No, terminal's in there. Terminal's in there. Terminal's always been part of the discussion. How does that...
2:19:22 Play into the game if we are reconsidering the strategy. This is just earmarked, isn't it? It's just earmarked. So I think that once we get the full strategy and if for some reason, you know, I can't imagine that the terminal isn't going to keep moving forward here. I mean, just point blank. So I think we're still going to obviously want to see that because we need a terminal now for the current flights we have, let alone future flights. But that's a discussion point that we can have right up until we decide to write a check.
2:19:50 And we can determine whether that's a big check or a small check. Because the other side of it, too, is that I think from our capital standpoint, I think it would be hard for us to spend dollars in Bishop. Yeah, fair enough. Do you have any kind of anticipation as to when we might spend money on special events, venue we've already done, airport terminal, TBD, but...
2:20:14 Wayfinding, is that something, where are we in the process? Well, you got that proposal. Yeah, so we got the proposal from MLTPA, went to the town. That's the planning document that Hais, Haislip will have. Haislip Hayes, Haislip Hayes will have. And then what I've asked for is that if the town...
2:20:33 presents that to us, that they present us with, hey, we've got these planning documents or planning process and we've got this much infrastructure. And if we say we're going to commit $350,000 to it, then we commit $350,000. If $37,000 is to pay for TPA and $322,000 is for actual signage, then that's our commitment. And they can go back to the mountain, they can go to Snow Creek, they can go to whoever else they think should be funding things because of the directionals.
2:21:00 And they can come up with a remainder at that point. Or we could go back and say, you know what, if the project is $750,000, we want to throw $500,000 in to make it that much further down to the finish line. Again, very fluid. I'll make a motion that we approve the proposed earmarks as stated here on the document you've given us, John, with the understanding that they are simply proposed earmarks.
2:21:29 And we are not voting on anything else. They are not in any way finalizing monies that we may or may not spend in the future. I'll second that. Any discussion for the discussion? The only one that I brought up last time, and I've been trying to figure out a way to word it. I think there's an opportunity for us to take significant advantage of the signs that are approved down by the airport and potentially...
2:21:56 Do a much better signage welcoming people to Mammoth Lakes. There's two different sign spots that have been approved down there. They're still approved at this moment. So I was trying to figure out a way to say wayfinding signage slash signage. But I don't want to get... I think for purposes of this, I think it could fall into that bucket if that's what we felt. I think there's an opportunity there. I don't know if it makes economic sense because we haven't looked at it in...
2:22:21 I think it all falls to the town from the planning standpoint anyway, so I think what we maybe want to do is go and ask that that be part of the discussion, the bigger discussion. So if it's not part of phase one, two, or three of the signage program, that it becomes phase four. Because I just think that, you know, you've got 26,000 people a day driving by there, having a decent sign that says, versus that little thing in the woods, that says we're actually a town up here versus something else would be significant impacts on the visibility of this community.
2:22:46 I think when we hear back from the town, whether it's a proposal or whether it's a request, that we ask if that's part of it, and if it's not, we ask that it become part of it. I'd argue the reverse side. We're saying that we're trying to also do our standpoint of saying we as a board want certain things to happen. This is visitation. I think we push it the other way in saying we would like to see the town do this and not wait for the town to come back because we could be five years before the town comes back a little bit. Well, I assume we'll see the wayfinding proposal in the next.
2:23:11 month at the very latest. Yeah, but that's going to be self-contained, and I already know that's not going to incorporate that signage. I'm just trying to leverage out a little bit more, saying there's opportunities for us to increase visitation. Yeah. And it may not be, there may be other requirements around that someone says, comes back, go, oh, by the way, if you do this, you've got to, I don't know. Okay. You've got to fly planes 10 feet high, right? Who knows? Right, to the extent that the proposal that John is talking about doesn't include
2:23:41 what you've just described, then the board should... So I went back to the portion of trying to find out wording that would fit under the wayfinding signage, because in some ways it is wayfinding, it is one of lakes. I was just trying to change the verbiage there slightly so that it could incorporate other things such as that. I think that falls within the wayfinding signage. I think we just have to better define, you know, if it's outside of Phase 1, 2, 3 that we currently know about, then we need to define it and say that that's part of our commitment is to help fund that.
2:24:11 be part of the program if we put this dollars in. I'm not sure it changes this. And should we have a need to spend money, specifically to actually spend money in a particular direction, such as you've described, this in no way inhibits us or limits us. Absolutely. I'm not worried about that. Okay. So we have a motion. We have a second. Any more discussion? All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? All abstained. Abstained. Thank you.
2:24:40 Okay, motion passes. Excellent. Alright, MLT Legal Counsel. Can you take that one if you want? Sure. Or I can take it? Well, no. So, Paul can take it. No, it's okay. I think I can fumble my way through it. So, our former legal, current? Still under contract? No, resigned. Former Legal Counsel Jim Reed has retired, going to do bigger and better things. John and Paul and myself met with Tim Sanford.
2:25:12 And had a discussion with him about being our new attorney and for the board mostly to go over contract issues that we have. It's what Jim was doing. Basically the same thing Jim was doing, really no different.
2:25:28 Leave. He is interested. We have not sent him a proposal yet, is that correct? No, no, no. We had the conversation and he's interested in taking us on and I think that we feel that he would bring to us what we need. So basically our contracts really consist of contracts with the town, with the county, and with the mountain. Whether it's around air service or other, like our current agreement that expires next June, it would be something that we need the legal counsel involved in. It would also include things like the MOU that we did with
2:25:58 Dirk Winter for the investment in the wood site. If we do commit a check to wayfinding or airport or whatever else, we'll need an MOU to make sure that we're very clearly defined that we're putting $500,000 towards the airport. It's not for road rehab or whatever.
2:26:14 So it really comes down to the legal sides on agreements. If we have things related to the TBID, Civitas is our attorney of record out of Sacramento. Last time around, we also incorporated a specialty attorney for municipal revenue law, Michael Culentuno out of San Diego. And so I think if we have specific things that come up that are outside of Tim's purview, that we would look for specific counsel for them.
2:26:40 And this will be especially, I don't need to mention, especially important as we go through our contract renegotiation with the town, looking at it line by line, seeing what sort of things they, you know, how it's worded and what expectations, what sort of deliverables are going to be put upon us that may change, may not change. That's going to be something that's going to need to be looked at very, very carefully. So... Does Tim have some of those relationships? I mean, if we were to look at contract with him on something, he can... Yeah, in fact, he...
2:27:09 I think we can always ask him for his input, but I think if there's specialized needs, we're probably going to have other resources as well, whether it's Visit California or Cal Travel or some of those other boards that we participate in that could help us, because there are a lot of very specific things, like especially with the TBID, there are very specific things that we use Civitas for because of that knowledge. We also had a good discussion with him about potential conflicts, and it didn't seem...
2:27:39 Tim didn't seem concerned that he would have to recuse himself in too many instances. It seemed like it was a pretty good fit. Yep. So our recommendation, I guess we are the legal nominating committee, it would be to get under contract with Tim. I've had, you know, 30 years of experience at all of ours. Tim's, you know, been here a long time, very experienced, quality guy, knows what he's doing.
2:28:11 The price is right. What number do you quote to us, Tom? $3.95. And what have we been paying? $4.25. Oh, see. So we have an immediate $30 savings. But, you know, the point is that Tim's good at contracts and he has good discretion, low-key kind of thing that we need in terms of those specific roles. We do have those come up, and we definitely have them come up with the town and
2:28:47 The Woodside. The special event center and all of that. And it got remarkably complicated towards the end. We really needed, I think, more help than we had at the time. It'd be good to have Tim there and to be able to jump on things. Yep. And it was, and that was a situation where the need for it was a little bit unanticipated. Yeah. It created need. It created its own need. Yeah.
2:29:20 The storm kicks up in the summer afternoon. All of a sudden it was in our faces and everything had to be done within minutes. Yeah. Or risk the sale. So we don't want to have that happen again. So do we have a motion? Anyone would like to make a motion? So moved. Okay. Do we have a second? Second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Anyone opposed? Opposed. Okay. Opposed. Okay. All right. Appoint new MLR representative.
2:29:56 Representative. Brent. Brent asked to put that one on there. Yep. So the last two years, thanks to Mr. Ledesma, I've been serving on the MLR board, and I think that it's time for a transition there. And I have told the board, MLR, that I've stepped off after the last meeting. MLR has successfully gone through and transitioned and hired an executive director as your prior friend of the paper.
2:30:24 I think MLR is a position to move forward, but I would like to personally step back away from that and allow the board member to step on that board. It's my recommendation as a part of that that whoever gets elected that goes to the first meeting and comes back because I think the MLT should take a stronger proactive role and make a statement of what they would like to see that representative do on the MLR board because the MLR board has currently been functioning at a state where they're trying to now raise dollars and get certain
2:30:53 priority projects move forward. I don't think they're in disagreement to where we want to be as well, but I think that we've got to be more assertive from a public standpoint that that's we either support or don't support or where we want to go with this board with some of these items. And I think it's up to us to be a little bit more verbal on that so publicly that that represented on the MLR board that says this is the board wants me to pursue these goals while I'm here. And so...
2:31:18 I believe that there's several different portions. I would like to make a recommendation and nomination, if so allowed, but I think that it's important that we have somebody that's, one, has some time, but two, also understands what's happening in the community and is invested in the community and those events that take place. You know, there's potential aquatic centers, there's potential MAC facility, there's multi-use facility, there's a number of other things that are coming down the road that are...
2:31:44 Pretty exciting in many ways, but it's going to take someone to be involved in that and be pertinent to those conversations. So with that, I would nominate Sean Turner to be on the MLR board. And I'm doing that with all due seriousness from the standpoint of many people may want to be part of it.
2:32:10 I think it's important to have somebody that has knowledge of what's happening in the community that can jump right in because this is not a position, I believe, where someone who's not familiar with some of the detailed specifics going on and some of those related to events, they're going to be struggling to catch up quickly. And I know that you've got a ton of work coming forward and I know that Kirk has no desire to do this.
2:32:35 Well, that's because I'm very good friends with the new director, so I think it's... Well, that could be better. Maybe I've changed my mind now. No, but I think it's important. I put that as a suggestion, but I think that it's time for a transition there, and it's been a lot of good work. It's been a lot of hours, but now those things have changed a lot. The board has gotten itself much better focused, much better organized, and I think with the executive director coming on board...
2:33:03 To me, I envision much more that we have here. We've got a very strong ED. That person gets their feet wet. They'll change how the board operates. And the bad part may be is the board members may be looked at how to raise money. And they're going to be trying to leverage those individuals and say, OK, can you introduce us to to find some of these dollar sources? So I think that's a full expectation of anybody that comes on that board. You know, if I can just say this, I think what's happening over at MOR is
2:33:31 Great. You know, they're doing things that on the recreation side, recreation commission side, we're much more about programming. Whereas MLR really is developing the products that in this, what is it, the third largest industry in America is outdoor recreation. There's a statistic that I heard recently and here we are at the cutting edge and the MLR has just got...
2:33:54 The opportunity, especially now with the new executive director, to just launch this forward. And so that's why I made the comment earlier that if tourism can do anything to really assist the product development is kind of the way that I look at what MLR is doing is absolutely fantastic. I have expressed an interest in being on MLR board. I don't, I would need to resign from.
2:34:16 Recreation Commission. I don't think it would be appropriate for me to be on both Recreation Commission and MLR. I don't know. I actually disagree with that. I don't think there's a protocol that says we would have it. No, you're right. I don't think there is. Because actually we had a... Because to me there's a synergy to exist because if you were there as part of both it's more of a timing issue for you. But it's one of the things that always comes into slight conflict with MLR and Rec Commission is who does what.
2:34:46 And by having some of that overlapping representation, because the reality is probably Terry is not going to serve past her term this year, it helps have that overlap so people can say, no, this is our role, this is your role, and keep people on the same centered path without overlapping. Yep. Okay. Well, we have a motion. I'll second the motion. Before we go forward.
2:35:08 We're still having a discussion. I'm just curious. I mean, I am very interested. I would really want to review my time commitments. Did you and I talk about doing this here at this meeting? I don't know if we did. Oh, really? Okay. Thanks for throwing that on me. I'd be curious, though. Does anyone else have desire in MLR? Michael. Michael, don't be attacking your hat there. I've served my time. I'd be curious. Do we need to make a decision today?
2:35:38 Brenda has to put it on the agenda, so I don't know what the timing is. The next meeting is not going to be until August. There will be no July meeting. The next best meeting will be August, and that may be even delayed a little bit because we're looking to get Matt into place, so that might even stall for a period of time after that. So really, they want to have the first meeting when Matt comes into place, and there's really not, you know, it's a little bit of a holding pattern right now until he's here. Yeah, fair enough. And I'm sorry to be equivocating here, just during our,
2:36:07 This meeting put it on the spot here. But, you know, I would want to make sure... Sometimes it's what you do with good people and you want them to serve and revive the world. Well, and I am. I'm very interested, but at the same time, I need to make sure that my time commitment allows me to really participate on, you know, these three entities now. The other person that I think should be considered for this position would be Scott McGuire, who's not here. That's pretty cool. And he's a strong candidate as well, you know, especially with his background.
2:36:37 So if I could ask, I'd prefer that we either table this or at least just give me some opportunity to think about this because I am interested. I really am. But at the same time, I don't want to make a commitment without being responsible with regard to my time. Why don't we bring it back to the August 2nd meeting? I'm looking for transition. We're going to need somebody to speak as a voice for MLT on that.
2:37:05 Yeah, I mean, I think McGuire would be a good one. I think, I don't know whether he, his travel schedule, I mean, it's hard for him to get to things, so I think if we can talk to him and, I think, revisit it in August, works for me. I mean, it won't be much happening, but if stuff comes up, I just want to make sure we have a voice of MLT represented.
2:37:28 And to your point, you know, you're right, Terry Stalick was actually the Recreation Commission representative to MOR there for the first year, I think, right? Mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Daniel Stroud, too. There's plenty of presidents. Yeah, okay. Good help. Okay. Now we might want to, and just to discourage him, I might want to ask Scott if he's, if he was interested in his time commitments, too. So, yeah, let's, why don't we table that till, till August. Okay. And you can think about it, Sean.
2:37:54 Thank you. Again, I'm highly supportive of what MLR, especially with their new ED, want to make sure we are supporting them absolutely as much as possible. I can see many more things coming down the road and some synergy, even with fundraising, that is going to be interesting to how to address. I don't think there's a roadmap for it. All right, great. Well, we've rocketed through things. We have just one more section of financial reports. Yep. Just quickly through here, I'm going to hand out the latest.
2:38:25 TOT reports. Good news. The latest good news with TOT reports. You know, they speak for themselves. They continue to skyrocket. I think that we've talked about the month of May being, frankly, to me, kind of a shocker to be, you know, for all intents and purposes, we're almost double where we were two years ago. You know, last year was the record at 526,000.
2:38:50 Thought we would have a struggle to get to that this year, and we've blown it out of the water by more than 26%, almost 27%. Well, you know, what's really interesting to look at, just if you go back and look at May, is that, you know, starting in 2000, if you look at 2000 and... Well, really, if you look at 2000 and...
2:39:08 2015, I guess it is, and go backwards. There really wasn't a whole lot of change there for five, six, seven years, and just to see that jump in the last two years is really impressive. Well, and I think that's been part of the discussion in the last two years has been the investment with the TBID, and I think that with the past close, I was concerned about that. I think the ski area had a great May. I'm not sure you had 10,000 people budgeted on Memorial Day weekend, but I think that it's definitely...
2:39:36 Giving us opportunity to potentially hit the $18 million mark this year. We're $820,000 away from that mark. I was blown away by May. Maybe I'll be blown away by June. Talking with a number of properties, it seems like June wasn't as strong as last year. But I think even if we're off by 20%, we're going to be pretty close to beating that $18 million mark, which is pretty ridiculous.
2:40:02 All the important information is in the yellow box at the bottom to show that we're 14% ahead of last year's record, we're 55% of the budget, and then we're already 47% ahead of the year-end number, which, again, I anticipate that that's just going to continue to grow. So good food for thought there. Any questions on TOT? TBID, at this point, we are up just over a million dollars compared to what we had forecasted.
2:40:27 As I mentioned before in the budget conversation, my guess is that we'll be roughly $5.8, $5.9 million on last year's budget of $4.6, almost $4.7. So TBID's doing well. We will budget $5.29, so just shy of $5.3 for next year, which I still think is very attainable. I'm sorry, what's our percentage of over budget on TBID, approximately? 25% probably.
2:40:56 Right now, probably 25%, maybe a little bit higher than that. Moving into the cash flow and our CDARS, the cash flow, we have $1.29 million in the Measure A checking account. We have the $5,009 in the savings account. We have $2,689,551 in the TBID checking account. That will go down by $1.08 million. We'll write a check for the winter air subsidy out of that this year.
2:41:26 And the TBID savings account is still up to $5,005. So all in all, the CDARs, we just reinvested. Last year, we started these on July 27th. We had one that was a million dollars that we put in for a year. We had one that was a half a million dollars that we put in for a year. And then we had one that was a quarter million dollars that just came up the other day. I've changed all those to 13 weeks, so we have more flexibility. So to your point, Sean, when we talk about those earmarks, at this point,
2:41:55 The difference between putting them in for a year and putting them in for 13 weeks or even four weeks, the percentage, we're not making enough money to make it worthwhile on these things, so I'd rather have them available sooner than tie them up for a year and all of a sudden we say we want to invest 500,000 bucks in something and we don't have access to it because there are pretty steep penalties if we decide to pull money out. Yeah, we go from like .00.
2:42:16 So I'm trying to avoid the four weeks. We had a lot of things in four weeks, but it sends me to the banks every four weeks to sign off on paperwork. So I think 13 weeks is that sweet spot. So we would have money available at this point, 13 weeks from the 27th, so basically August 1st.
2:42:36 We have access to those funds as needed. And we will, when I get back from vacation, we'll look at the current bank balances and determine what we need to put into those CDARS to protect them. Because again, those, just as a refresher, those certificates of deposit are protected. They're all under $250,000 FDIC limit. So we have that million dollar investment is probably within six funds.
2:43:05 So it protects us on each of those funds up to a quarter million bucks. That's the whole point of putting them in there. So I sent the P&L reports out the other day. Our final year-end P&L won't be probably ready until close to the end of August maybe because at this point we won't even get the June numbers until first, second week of July. And then we've got some settling to do with our auditors up in Reno. And so we'll have the final P&L for the year probably by the end of August.
2:43:33 And then we also still have to settle up with the town on the true-ups that are currently owed, which is probably going to be $800,000 or so. All right. Any questions on that? And then I think the key takeaway is you've got a lot of good information in there. Again, it goes back to that yellow box at the bottom of the TOT sheets, but continuing to kick some butt. And from what I've been hearing as far as July and August, I think we're in good shape there, and I think that the momentum will carry us very well through the fall.
2:44:07 One quick thing. Brent and I are, the two of us are on the John's Review Committee. Is there anybody else that could potentially help with us? It's nice to have three people. It should be a relatively quick meeting. And I was just waiting for the fiscal year to end so we can get all the, you know, not that we kind of know. I was going to say, I'm not sure we're going to drop below. No, I don't know, but just to be official. So is there anybody else that might be able to do?
2:44:37 To be, to help with John and I, just, I mean, with Brett and I, sorry. Okay, great, thanks. Appreciate that. We'll get that done in the next, in the next month. Last bit of detail I'll give you on that $1.086 million for air subsidy. That was $422.621 for United.
2:44:55 So 422,000 for United, 513,000 on Alaska, and 150,000 with JetSuite X. So they all came in right around where, I mean JetSuite came in exactly where we thought it was going to come in. Alaska did pretty well in both markets. I think the cancellations killed us. And United Airlines, one of the things, we're working with them because one of the things that I struggle with is that when we have a cancellation because of weather, obviously we had quite a bit of weather here.
2:45:22 We are currently, they charge us $3,700 for the opportunity cost of that airplane not flying. That amounted to about $96,000 this year. So $96,000 for not flying. So we are working with them on how we can change that a little bit, but I'm not sure that they're too much of a movable object, so we'll see what we can do. So just with that, John, there was one of the flights the other day, they downloaded people, not because of us, but because of LA. That was a new one on me.
2:45:51 So we lost a couple passengers, not because we were anything up here, but because of the LA and temperature as well as the shorter runway in LA. So we lost five people on one of the flights. Yeah, we've got a number of different things. Air traffic control, obviously the pilot shortage is killing us with timeouts on staff. It's not, you know, this winter was predominantly weather.
2:46:13 But we still had a handful of mechanicals. We had a handful of air traffic control where they somehow can't get all the planes on the ground. I understand in LA because they're down a runway, but San Francisco isn't down a runway.
2:46:25 All things that we're continuing to work on with them. But at this point, moving forward for this winter, our plan is to maintain the current schedules that we have. The only thing that we're still contemplating, and I'll bring back to you, is the potential of working with JetSuite X, probably out of San Jose. They were potentially going to add Orange County, but they're still having struggles getting in there, physically getting their planes in there. They want them to go to a gate versus going to a general aviation, and they don't want to do that.
2:46:52 But I think the San Jose conversation has a lot to do with the new family of season pass holders up there from Squaw and Alpine that potentially we could have flying down here. So still to be determined, but again, probably looking at the same sort of risk that we had this year on that and falling within the 1.5 million. But that'll be something that we can talk about down the road if it comes to fruition. And so the subsidy structure again is MLT's on the hook for the first 1.5 in the winter. Yep. Matt picks up beyond that. Correct. And MLT's on the full hook for the summer.
2:47:22 Full hook, yep. Yep, and summer's been hovering between $500,000 and $700,000. And we get $7.65 budget, just to be safe. And we didn't meet the $1.5 for the winter. That's where the $423,000 extra is getting reinvested. And the spring service that we went back to four days a week, it accomplished exactly what we had hoped to. The month of May alone was up 1,117 passengers. Load factor was...
2:47:51 Was fairly comparable with the amount of people that came into town. So divide that in half and that's roughly what came into town. So 550 people arrived, 550 people left. So even though it cost us a little bit more money, it accomplished what we wanted to get people in and out of town. We're looking at potentially seven days for the fall as well. We unfortunately can't adjust the fall schedule now because they've already got it scheduled out. When we asked them about the time frame, they said we'd already missed it.
2:48:19 And that was a month, two months ago. So they need a certain amount of time to schedule all the planes and pilots and everything else. So we're still on four days for the fall, but I think that moving forward, that's something that we really should revisit, make sure that we have a seven day a week, 365 days a year. Actually, you know, not buying our own planes, but one of the things that we are, that is possibly out there is to actually work with an airline to white label a plane.
2:48:50 Have them operate it and have us just basically run it. Then we can pick whatever the hell time we want to fly it. But the two companies that are potentially out there for us to do that are very successful on the East Coast. Unfortunately, they're not far enough west yet to work on that. Because we actually looked at that to potentially replace the Alaska Airlines not so great time in San Diego this year. And it just wasn't something that they were prepared to be able to work on. Interesting. One last comment I'd like to make before we adjourn is because I
2:49:20 Seem to think that we're not going to see Mr. Turner on August 2nd because I think he might be a little busy. So I just want to wish you all the best with your, I know it's a monstrous undertaking and it's always something I enjoy. So best of luck. I hope everybody here will get a chance to go and I hope it just cranks for you, Sean. Three weeks and two days to the hour. Three and four minutes or whatever. Four and six minutes. Good luck. All right. Do we have a motion to adjourn? I moved. We have a second.
2:49:47 Second. All in favor? All right. Great. See you next month. Thanks for coming, Johnny. Thanks, Johnny. My last question is outside of the boy or girl. We don't know.