TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2017

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

387 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:44 I think that clock is fast. I mean, it was nice for them to put that just out here. Almost. You know how sometimes you make your screen go black? That's why I just assumed you did. No, because that would be black. Is that the way you want? No, thank you. It's not the way I want. Do you want us to wait? You can start. You guys ready? Yeah. All right.

2:29 Good afternoon, everyone. I would like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, August 9th. Roll call, please. Present. Mr. Chang. Here. Mr. Eckert. Present. Vice Chair Mayerhurst. Here. Chair Kellerman. Yes, here. Paul, would you like to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Yes, of course. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic of the United States. One nation under God.

3:03 Thank you. We will start today's meeting with a public comment period. This is the time for anyone who wishes to speak about an item that is not on today's agenda can come up to the podium, please. Good afternoon, Chair Callinan, Commissioners, Shireen Sanders, Code Compliance Officer for the Town. I just wanted to give you a brief update on code enforcement efforts. Coming out of the long, endless winter,

3:44 We're seeing a lot of issues with mold and substandard housing, kind of roofs falling in, windows broken, things like that, as well as some encroachment issues. You know, there was nowhere to put any of the snow. So we're dealing with a lot of those issues, as well as...

4:02 An ongoing basis, abandoned furniture, but we've been working with the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. A couple of officers have been helping me out at night and during the day to try to clean up certain areas of town and get rid of a lot of the blight out there. A lot of unpermitted building, it is the season, so we've got quite a few cases of...

4:25 Working without a permit, placing a lot of stop work orders. Good news is everybody's coming in and getting their permits once they realized that they needed them. And then lots of signs and banners, temporary banners, seeing flutter flags up again. So I'm monitoring those as well. Other than that, I'm working with the county on a lot of these substandard housing issues and mold issues.

4:54 Trying to get a speaker from Monterey County to come out, hopefully in September, to put on a workshop for the county, the town, and maybe property management companies, HOA managers, and just get information out there about substandard housing issues and things like that. So I'll keep you posted on that. Great. Any questions? Can you just elaborate a little bit about the substandard

5:24 Yeah, so mold is probably the most common one that we're seeing and we didn't really have an ability to enforce that until January of 2016 when the Senate passed a bill listing mold as a substandard housing condition and we do uphold all of the housing laws as well as the California Building Code and so while a lot of these issues

5:53 Tend to fall under landlord-tenant rights and our civil matters. There are some such as mold or if you don't have proper heating or sewage and basic things that we can enforce through the municipal code. Thank you. Thank you. If I could from the table. Grady Dutton, Public Works Director, just a quick update on Main Street.

6:22 Actually, I'll mention a couple of things. One is on the Upper Main Street sidewalk project. We've had a CMS board and some traffic control out there for several weeks. Caltrans finally got us approval to the subcontractor.

6:36 For the design of the specific wall, they had to have some middles and things about 10 days ago, so they'll be out there demolishing the old timber wall starting August 21st, and they will complete all the work this season, so you'll end up with a new wall and a sidewalk from Mountain Boulevard all the way to Minaret by the end of this season. It's a quick update. One other thing I wanted to mention on Lower Main Street, as long as we're here,

7:00 Everybody's heard somewhat at least about SB1, the transportation bill that's in the state of California that was supposed to provide more funds for road maintenance and other projects. Well, last year we actually submitted an ATP, an active transportation program grant for about two and a half million dollars for a portion of the lower Main Street sidewalk project, which is anticipated to start next summer because we didn't have enough money to do the whole thing.

7:26 Well, as it turns out, it was quite not fortunate, but it's a good thing we did, because this new ATP program this year takes advantage of the SB1 funds, and you're only eligible if you had something you submitted last year and were unsuccessful. So we resubmitted it a few weeks ago. We'll hear about the 1st of September, and that could provide up to $2.6 million additional dollars for the

7:52 Easterly into Main Street, Lower Main Street, and that'll help us do more of the improvements that are envisioned in the Main Street plan and in coordination with Walk, Bike, Ride. Great. Thank you. Great. Thank you. Grady, would the Lower Main Street continue on the bike path on the same side of the street as Upper Main Street? There are several phases with the bike paths and the mups throughout town. Lower Main Street would include a full eight-foot-wide sidewalk on both sides of the street.

8:22 filling in any gaps all the way to Old Mammoth Road. On the south side, it may even be wider than that to create more of a promenade and maybe a bicycle path off of Main Street on that side. That's what we're going to be working on and working through walk, bike, ride on. So what we'll end up with is either a MUP or a sidewalk from Minaret Road all the way to Old Mammoth on both sides with the exception of the

8:48 Upper part on the south side of the road, which there is no sidewalk there yet and no MUP, but Caltrans is actually looking at that and they might take that on as a project themselves in a couple of years. Great. Thank you. You bet. Thank you. Any additional public comment from the audience? All right, then we will close the public comment period and move on to our first public hearing. Continued from July 12th, our 27...

9:19 July 12, 2017 meeting. This item is to consider approval of an amendment to the mountainside project tentative tract map 17-001, design review 15-001A, and adjustment 17-006. A 16-unit townhome project located at 413 Rainbow Lane, including finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to guidelines section 15332 infill development projects. And Ruth is our contact.

9:48 Thank you. There was a PowerPoint to go along with my presentation, but the screens don't seem to be working, so I will go through my presentation regardless, and if anyone would like a closer look at the exhibits, maybe we can put them up on the small computer screen, and people can view them if they'd like. Apologies.

10:14 So this is the public hearing for the amendment to the mountainside project. It consists of tentative tract map 17-001, an amended design review, design review 15-001A, and adjustment 17-007. As you mentioned, this is a continuation of the public hearing that was noticed for the July 12, 2017 Planning and Economic Development Commission hearing, or meeting.

10:44 The project is located at 413 Rainbow Lane. It's a 16-unit townhome development. Each of the units are three stories, approximately 2,000 square feet, with three bedrooms and a two-car garage. 14 of the units are in seven duplex buildings, and there are two standalone units, again, totaling 16 units total for the project.

11:10 The vehicular access is off of Rainbow Lane, and the pedestrian access also leads to Rainbow Lane through the western side of the property. The original approval for the mountainside project was approved by the Planning and Economic Development Commission back in April of 2015, and the entitlements associated with that original project were tentative tract map 15-001, design review 15-001,

11:37 Variance, 15-001, use permit, 15-001, and adjustment, 15-001. That project was subsequently appealed by a neighboring property owner, Mr. Plander, and the council reviewed that appeal and reaffirmed the commission's approval on June 3, 2015.

11:59 Since that time, the applicant has begun tree removal and grading work, and they've been issued a limited grading permit. The purpose of this amendment is to improve the snow storage management on site by increasing the distance between the individual buildings.

12:18 After this winter, the applicant felt that it was necessary to increase that distance to allow for more adequate passage of snow storage equipment and just to increase the capacity of snow storage between those buildings. That amendment requires a new tentative tract map to accommodate that new site plan, and so that new entitlement is tentative tract map 17-. Woo-hoo. Woo-hoo. Okay. Did he kick it? It's a miracle.

12:48 Let's catch up here. Just one second. Thank you, Neil. Let's see. So that's the aerial imagery. These photos were taken in 2016, so after some of the tree removal and site work had begun, but it's not a current image of the property. And I think this is the slide we're on. So again, so the purpose of this amendment is to improve the snow storage management on the site by increasing the distance between the buildings. The other...

13:25 component of the project is removal of several of the side pop-outs on those buildings, again, to improve the access and passageway for snow storage removal equipment. So the amendments or the entitlements triggered by this amendment are tentative tract map 17-001, the amended design review 15-00A, and an adjustment. These entitlements supersede

13:52 Or will supersede the original tentative tract map, 15-001, and the original design review. But other entitlements will remain in effect from the original project. And those include the original variance, which reduced the front yard setback and increased some of the building heights, the original adjustment, which increased building heights, and the original use permit, which allows transient use of those units.

14:21 This is an exhibit demonstrating the increased distance between the buildings with the new tentative tract map. You can see on the left is the original tentative tract map showing the pop-outs on the side of the building as well as the reduced width between the buildings. With the elimination of the pop-outs and the adjustment of the entire project, it increases the overall separation between the buildings.

14:49 to approximately 17 to 20 feet, depending on the particular buildings on the site. This is an overview of the new tentative tract map. You can see it's very similar to the original project, but the entire project has shifted two feet to the western property line, requiring the adjustment to the western property line setback. This is a depiction of the purpose of the amended design review.

15:22 On the left, it's a very slight change, but on the left, there is a pop-out of approximately one and a half feet on the left side of this building, and that pop-out has been removed on several buildings as a part of the proposed amendment to the overall project. While the pop-out and the depth of that pop-out's been removed, it will still be articulated, and you can see that there's really no difference when looking

15:50 Straight at that building. There's really only a difference when you're looking from the side. The overall design and elevations of the buildings won't be modified as a part of this project. This perspective is from the original approvals. As a part of the original project, staff had determined that the project was categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Guidelines 15.332 infill development projects because the following criteria were met.

16:27 Consistent with the general plan and zoning code. The proposed development occurred within city limits on a project site of no more than five acres. The project sites have no value as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species. This was documented by a biological resources assessment, which was attached to the staff report. Approval of the project would not result in any significant effects related to traffic, noise, air, or water quality, and the project site can be adequately served by utilities and public services.

16:58 The project was originally noticed for public hearing with the commission for July 12th. The day before that public hearing, we received a letter from Ronald and Joan Plander, the property owners adjacent to the project on the east side at the Courchevel, in the Courchevel Association, and they were the original appellants for the original project.

17:26 They raised several concerns that staff felt like they needed additional time to address. So at the July 12th meeting, we requested continuance of this project and that's what we're here today to discuss. So the staff report published on August 3rd last week included the revised maps and addressed the issues raised by the public comment letter. The three central issues raised in the letter were the location of the dumpster,

17:53 The snow storage calculations and the snow storage location and design. And I'll go through each of those issues, discuss what Mr. Plater's concerns were and what staff's response was. So in regards to the dumpster location, with the original project approval, the dumpster had been located on the east side of the property adjacent to the Corsheville condominiums. As a condition of approval of that original project,

18:23 The applicant agreed to work with staff to relocate the dumpster to the west side of the property. We did find a suitable alternative location on the west side of the property, which was approved as part of the grading permit that the applicant is now working under. Mr. Plander was concerned that with the adjustment and the overall revisions to the map, that Mammoth Disposal might not still consider that west side of the property.

18:49 an appropriate location for the dumpster. We had conversations with Mammoth Disposal as a part of this application, and they have approved the dumpster location as shown on the plans on the west side of the property. The second issue raised by Mr. Plander were the snow storage calculations. And based on the letter and the analysis of the original project, staff did determine that the snow storage requirements were not met.

19:20 Either with the original application or with the current application that was moving forward to commission on July 12th. We determined that the error made in the calculation was the admission of the driveways into the garages. The applicant had not included the individual driveways leading to the garages in the calculations as the driveways were also the location of uncovered parking spaces which were not required. And so to address that error in calculation,

19:48 The applicant proposes to use lot one for snow storage for lots two through 16 and tell such a time that a snow storage plan can be approved for all lots by the Community and Economic Development Department. So I'll walk through the condition language associated with this proposed solution and then I'll show you a map of how snow storage is proposed to be accommodated. So the condition language that we worked on with the applicant and the attorney

20:17 reads that lot one building area and associated access and parking shall remain available for snow storage and in a stabilized, graded, and permeable condition, satisfactory to the public works department and otherwise unimproved until such a time that a snow storage area plan is provided for the entire project, lots one through 16, in accordance with the municipal code and approved by the town of Mammoth Lakes Community and Economic Development Department.

20:44 No building permit shall be issued for lot one prior to such approval of a snow storage area plan. At such time that a snow storage area plan is approved and prior to the construction of lot one, the dumpster will be moved to the west side yard setback area. Lot one, while used for snow storage, may not be used for parking. If an approved snow storage area plan and certificate of occupancy for lot one are not issued within three years of the approved

21:09 of the approval of the final map, the lot one building area and associated access and parking shall be restored with native vegetation to condition satisfactory to the public works and community and economic development departments. Let's see. So this exhibit, which I believe is page or sheet two of the tentative tract map, shows how lot one will be used to accommodate snow storage for lots two through 16 on an interim basis until lot one is constructed.

21:41 The department, the community economic and public works departments will not issue a building permit for lot one until a snow storage area plan that meets the requirements of the zoning code is approved by those departments administratively. So this is essentially an interim snow storage plan until the construction of lot one.

22:04 The third issue raised in the letter was the location and design of the snow storage, and we reviewed the snow storage plan and determined that it does meet all the requirements of the Municipal Code for snow storage. Snow storage is located near the sides and rears of the parking area and driveways. It's located to maximize solar exposure to the greatest extent feasible. It's located so that snow moving equipment is not required to enter public streets.

22:31 It preserves sight lines for vehicles entering and exiting driveways. It is located in areas readily accessible and substantially free and clear of obstructions. It does not block any required access, sidewalk, trail, or public path. It is not located in parking areas that are counted towards meeting the parking requirements. And it is not located in any required landscaping areas that are not planted with landscape tolerance of the snow storage or native vegetation.

23:06 The required findings to approve the amendment to the mountainside project are as follows. Is the proposed project consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act, CEQA? Is the proposed project consistent with the State Subdivision Map Act? Can the findings be met for design review permit pursuant to municipal code chapter 17.88? And can the findings be met for an adjustment pursuant to municipal code 17, chapter 17.64?

23:35 Staff's recommendation is to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA, State Subdivision Map Act, and Municipal Code findings, and to approve tentative tract map 17-001, design review 15-001, and adjustment 17-007, with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. The applicant is here to answer any questions, as well as staff. Thank you. Great, thank you.

24:06 John, would you like to say anything? I'm John Hooper. I brought this project to you. As you know, it was approved a year or two ago, and after this revision of the project is basically because of the last winter and the amount of snow that fell and driving by projects like Gateway that were buildings were 10 feet apart and noticing that snow remained there

24:45 Two months after it stopped snowing. So the idea here was to get the buildings further apart and to increase the, really, the viability of the snow removal areas. Although, after looking outside, maybe we'll burn down before it snows again. Well, let's hope not. Because this is the smokiest I've ever seen it.

25:10 What we've done is, at the expense of the unit, we've deleted the pop-out floor area, but as far as the architectural integrity of the buildings, it remains, because we still have a pop-out, we still have the roofline, the California roofline. So that gave us about three or four feet more area between the buildings. Then what we're asking for was a two-foot variance into the setback on the Forest Service side.

25:38 Which would be to the west to get us a little more room and we moved the buildings on either side of the entry driveways a foot or two closer to that because we're able to and that gave us with the present design it gives us anywhere from 15 and a half to 17 or 18 feet versus 10 or 12 13 feet before and as far as the snow storage issue I'm not going to say much because probably you'll have questions and

26:08 Ruth explained it as well as I could. But the snow storage, just so that we don't impede any sort of timetable or construction this year, I'm willing to, on an interim, just temporarily not deal with building unit one for snow storage. We were very, we weren't off much with what we did by separating the buildings, but we were off a bit and we were able to get that snow storage

26:38 in between some of the back buildings by ramping and using that huge area that's to the south for snow storage by blowing the snow. But I'm not going to build Unit 1 for probably a year or two, so that's why the interim request to not be able to build Unit 1 until we get a snow storage plan that's approved by the town, by Public Works.

27:08 Also, any snow storage plan for any commercial building in town involves snow hauling. And yet, for some reason, that didn't get integrated into multiple family. And yet, as you all know, I would think that there isn't a project in town that didn't haul snow. So I've requested that the town look into making it, creating a regulation that allows you to

27:35 Involve snow hauling with your snow removal plan because it's real life. It happens every time that we have a winter like this. That's another direction that I'd like to see the town go because as you all know, even the gentleman who's peeled it last time in Courchevel, they hauled snow all the winter like we all did. So I would also incorporate snow hauling with any snow storage plan that I have.

28:02 And that's about the size of it. So if you have any questions, I'd be glad to answer them. Great. Thanks. Thank you. I have a quick question, and I'm not sure if it's really for Ruth or for you, John. I'm just looking at the map where you show the cross-hatching for the snow storage areas. Is there a particular reason why that sort of center space between lots five and six?

28:32 The snow storage extends all the way to the south perimeter of the buildings, yet the other ones don't. It seems to me like you could increase your snow storage area by continuing that area between the buildings. There must be a reason. You have a good point, and that's probably what we will do, because the retaining wall on the south side, we can extend all the way along the back of those units and pick up snow storage. And then we also took the radius of snow blowers on a

29:02 You don't care, but it's a 928. It's a piece of snow equipment that can blow snow and figured out what degree of ramp it could get up and it could get up in between the buildings and blow it up to 50 feet in that south area that we've left as open space. So you're right, we could, but there...

29:21 There were so many different solutions to the problem. We just decided to, on an interim basis, because that's what we will do, is use that area for snow storage, because we won't be building on that until probably late next year. So the difficulty that I'm understanding on that south side of the building is the pretty fairly extreme upslope. It's steep. That's correct. Picking the right buildings to go between would be

29:49 Part of what we decide to do to solve the problem. And Chair Callinan, currently the area that shows extended snow storage to the south, there is no retaining wall impeding the collection of snow there, whereas there are retaining walls. Is that dark line? There are currently retaining walls between the other units. Thanks. So that could ultimately be revised. Okay. John, how high are those walls?

30:20 They go anywhere from five feet up to about eight and a half or nine feet. You can blow over that easily. Given that you have additional areas that you can utilize for snow storage in the future, what I don't understand is if lot one is currently used for storage, it's being proposed to use for storage for lot two through 16, if you take lot one away in the future,

30:56 Will the additional available snow storage area, will that be sufficient? More than sufficient. Okay. And has staff done that type of calculation? So that a year later that we don't run into any issues? Will you restate that question? I'm not sure.

31:19 I understood. I think that's the purpose of the condition, right, is that we would have a snow storage plan that would look at adding that lot one or building that building and how that snow storage is going to be accommodated throughout the property. The capacity that's served by lot one. Got it. Yeah, so the capacity that's served by lot one will be addressed by condition of approval number two. We'll review a snow storage plan that accommodates that current capacity at lot one elsewhere on the property or possibly

31:48 With a zoning code amendment to allow off-site hauling for residential uses. I think there's a couple of different directions. Without any zoning code amendments, are we certain that we can achieve a sufficient amount of snow storage in the future if we decide to build lot one and not have to make any other changes? I'm not going to assure certainty, but without a snow storage plan that meets town requirements,

32:19 Mr. Hooper will not be able to construct lot one and that area will remain to be used for snow storage. So the risk essentially is on the applicant to provide a snow storage plan that meets the requirements for all of the lots. Otherwise, he's not able to develop lot one and it will remain the snow storage area for the project. Okay. You know what?

32:47 Technical answer to that, a real life answer, is that there is room in between the buildings around the south side to drive a piece of equipment in and blow it over into that huge open area on the south. So there's no problem with the fact that there is room, steep or not. Greg, as you know, the snowblower we use blows snow 50 feet.

33:10 If it's only five or six of the wall, it's not going to be there. Yeah, so we have the room. It's just determining which area in between which buildings, once we start the construction of that retaining wall, we'll be better suited for that. That's mainly the reason. And in real life, we will be using lot one as snow storage because we phased it to build the east side first.

33:33 So that's, in fact, what will happen. It'll be interim snow storage anyway. This just gave us more than one option as to exactly where to put the snow. But the answer is I can't build it until I come up with a viable plan. The permit won't be issued until then. Of course, you know, the point of my question is simply that I wanted to make certain that both parties understand, you know, when Lot 1 comes around.

34:03 You know, we're not going to run into that issue again. And so it's not fair for the developer and, you know, if we don't actually look at this, you know, this situation at this moment. Now, the snow, so the snow storage area between the buildings facing Rainbow Lane, my understanding is that for

34:35 For muni code or zoning code, you can't blow snow over the wall and land it on the street? Correct. It's prohibited to store snow or push snow through a public right-of-way. Okay. With 16 feet, 13 to 16 feet, will that give you enough room for either the snowblower or cat to make that rotation in that area? They wouldn't rotate. They would push it.

35:05 Okay. Until they were died, they couldn't push anymore and keep continuing back. Remember, part of what I want to let you folks know is that after last winter, snow hauling is part of what we do, and that's got to be taken into consideration in not only commercial projects, because it is now. It's just that multiple, we have a duplex on

35:31 Across from the west and we had to haul from a duplex. So it's got to be allowed in more than just commercial areas. It's got to be allowed in multi-residential because that's what you do. So snow hauling will probably be part of my solution and has been for over 40 years for any project I've done. We haul routinely except for the five years before this last winter. That's something that happens in every project I've seen.

36:00 And that will be part of what I bring forth as a solution in my snow storage plan. Okay. Just a follow-up question about the dumpster location on the west side of the property. I know originally you were showing it all the way over to, I believe, within the setback area. And you're currently showing it quite a bit further in, which I understand makes perfect sense for the interim construction while you're working on the east side. Just as long as it's clear that that dumpster

36:34 location has to be moved at such a time that lots 10, 2, 3, 4, and 10, 11, 12 are built, correct? In order to actually utilize the snow storage area of lot one, that dumpster enclosure doesn't work. Correct. You know, what I originally brought, excuse me, go ahead. No, that's okay.

36:57 I was just going to note that that is a part of the condition of approval. Okay. That the dumpster location during the interim when lot one is used for snow storage will be at the boundary between that snow storage area and the project driveway.

37:10 And then at the time that lot one is constructed, that that dumpster location move all the way back to within the western side yard setback. And we reviewed and discussed and looked at maps with Mammoth Disposal, and they reviewed both the interim location while lot one is being used for snow storage, as well as the ultimate location within the western side yard setback. Okay, so you're suggesting that there is enough room for equipment to maneuver around that dumpster?

37:41 Correct. Basically using those parking spaces in front of the garages to get around it? Is that what I'm understanding? Correct. Using parking and driveway areas for the maneuvering of stow storage equipment is fairly standard practice because those are the paved areas in which they have to move their equipment. As long as there aren't cars in those parking spaces. Correct. And those are not required parking spaces for the project. Those uncovered parking spaces providing access to the driveway are not.

38:13 Required parking for the project. The garage parking spaces almost entirely satisfy the parking requirements for the project. Okay. I'm just curious. I mean, logistically, those, everything except, you know, hypothetically, everything except lot one has been built. The trash enclosure is there. Lots 10 and 2 are rented out and have cars parked in the driveway while they're out skiing during the day. How does...

38:43 Snow removal equipment come in and maneuver around the trash enclosure. It's a practical issue, I think, that affects every project in town is moving car locations in order to accommodate snow storage removal equipment. But there aren't any prohibitions for that scenario in the zoning code. Okay. We've supplied far more parking than is required because that's, again, real life. You always need more parking than you think you should. Right. I understand. But real life is also that there's going to be cars there.

39:13 You know, your snow removal company is trying to do their best to get rid of the snow. It would be at the end of the driveway and they could pull in with cars parked there and then back out and get out. So I'm sure that there's more than one location for that dumpster for its final location that will easily work.

39:33 If I could add just a comment, that is very typical in projects like this throughout town. Where I live, again, it's a 12-unit place. We actually posted on doors to say we need to clear out all the parking spaces this time this winter. It was very unusual, and we had people park off-site for a few hours and do it. So it's typical throughout town, especially in a winter like this, and Public Works has reviewed this, and we're satisfied that it works. It's a logistical issue for the future HOA, but it's something everybody in town deals with.

40:03 Okay. Once they get towed a couple of times, they won't do it again. Or lose a fender. All right. I have a few questions for staff, not necessarily for the applicant. Thank you. Thank you, John. Thank you. Let's see here. Page 23 of the document that we have received. 23 of the staff report, Paul? Correct. Talks about housing mitigation fee.

40:54 Under special planning condition number 31, per unit, the cost of mitigation fee is $23,000, and the total project fee is $325,000. When I did the calculation for 16 units, that's $375,000. And I understand lot one is not being billed, so we are still one short, it seems. How does that work?

41:32 At the time of the original approval of the project, it was considered that the standalone units, and I can't quite make out the unit numbers, but the units on the western side of the property could be considered to be single family residences because they were standalone units. And so they were exempt from paying housing mitigation fees. The applicant... I'm sorry, hold on one second. There's a tentative tract map on this. Correct. So technically this is a condo map.

42:02 Or a townhome map? It's a planned unit development is the ownership. So are you saying that PUD has an exemption where a single family home on that map does not require you to pay mitigation fee? I'm saying at the time of the original project submittal and approval, it was considered that those standalone units could be considered.

42:32 Single family units and would pay fees associated with them being single family units. That fee program is no longer in place and the option here is for the applicant to pay the current housing mitigation fees, which are substantially less than the fees outlined in this report. So it's likely that the applicant will pay the current fees. The current fee schedule would not

42:58 permit those standalone units to be considered single family units, so they'll pay the same fee per unit regardless of what the dollar amount is outlined in this special condition. However, you're saying that the current dollar amount is significantly less than what's listed here? It is significantly less, but that option was provided for in the original project, so correct. Condition number 53, which is on page 25.

43:32 Talks about all easement and dedication shall be informed and content acceptable to Public Works Director. Are there any IOD on this that have been dedicated to the town? I don't believe there are. I think the roadway right away is plenty as it is, but just as a standard condition that's in the project. Okay. Are there any off-site improvement agreements according to condition number 56? None that I'm aware of.

44:15 Okay. On page 28 talks about the grading permit, encroachment permit, that unless they meet the requirement from number 73 through 99, they're not able to get grading permit. However, I just heard earlier your presentation that some sort of a conditional grading permit had been issued. So does that mean any of those, some of the condition have been satisfied?

44:45 From number 73 through number 99. Condition 73. From number 73 through 99. This is on page 28. From a public works perspective, I have to look into that because the staff that issued that permit is not here today, but I'm going to suggest that.

45:08 They certainly would have reviewed the conditions and in order to issue that grading permit, they needed to make sure those conditions were satisfied. I can double check that if you'd like and let you know, but I'm satisfied. Yeah, the applicant had begun work under the approval of the original project and then while in the process of working under this limited grading permit, come in with this amendment. So that grading permit was issued under the original project approval, not under this amendment. The project is,

45:37 Basically on pause until the approval of this amendment. Right now the project is? No other permits will be issued until this amendment has been processed. I got it. Okay. Let's see here. Okay. That's all the questions I have. Thank you. Great. Thanks. Any additional questions for staff or for the applicant up here before we move on to the public? I don't. I don't either. Okay. Okay.

46:11 Does anyone in the public have any questions or comments? If you would please come up and state your name for the record. Hi, my name is Ronald Plander. I do own the unit right next to the project. Once again, I feel the project is just too many units, too big of units for the property that he's building it on. I think he came, I believe he just said that the original calculations were just slightly off.

46:45 You know, he was calculating the area that needed to be removed was 10,200, and the staff now says 15,410. I don't think that's slightly off. I really believe he was trying to pull a fast one over you guys. It's surprising that staff didn't pick up on it earlier. You know, he's now proposing to build Unit 1 by, you know, trucking out snow. I don't know what the code is, but I believe that was kind of a no-no in the past.

47:15 That you try not to have that happen. He's talking about bringing in big snow blowers to blow the snow up on this hill. I don't think that's a good idea. And the other thing I got a problem with is that he says the whole reason he's doing this new tentative map was to increase the distances between the buildings. But if you look on the back row, they're actually closer together. You can look at the map that was approved two years ago. And this map.

47:44 Between buildings one and two, it was originally 15 feet, now they're 14.6. Between three and four was 14.6, now it's 14.5. Between five and six, it's both 14.5, 14.5. And between seven and eight, it was 15, and now it's 14.5. So the buildings are actually closer together, and yet unit one is two feet closer to Canyon Lodge.

48:13 So mathematically, I don't know how that works. How did he decrease the distance between those buildings, and yet he's two feet further to the west? You know, once again, I just think, and the other problem I have with this new plan, I don't know if it was pointed out, this new plan includes removing three more trees right by my unit. So I'd like to know how these units are two feet closer to Canyon Lodge, and yet the units are closer together.

48:51 Would you like me to address the question regarding the... If you can, that would be great. So with the removal of the pop-outs, the distance or the accessible distance between the buildings has increased. It's the combination of the adjustment and the removal of the pop-outs that increases the distance between the buildings for the purpose of the passage of snow storage equipment. Okay, but aren't the buildings still closer together than they were before? I don't believe that they're...

49:20 They're closer together with the removal of the pop-outs. No, because you look at the plans, it doesn't include the pop-outs. The arrows goes from the foundation of one building, the foundation of the other one, and they're closer together now, and yet he's two feet closer to the property line. The distance between the buildings calculated as a part of the original project was with consideration of the one-and-a-half-foot pop-outs. Okay, so therefore- So that distance has increased if you consider the removal.

49:50 of the pop-outs. So Ruth, what you're saying is that the distance, he's saying that the distance between the foundations is the same or smaller. You're saying the distance where the loader's going to go through at the pop-out level is more open because the pop-outs are gone. It is more open. There may be slight variations in the distance between the foundations that may, yes, that may result. It doesn't matter if your foundation is here. If you have a pop-out up here that's three feet closer, you now have more room than you used to. Right.

50:19 No, I agree that he'll have easier to, without the pop-outs, you can get equipment and more. But how did the foundations get closer together, and yet he's closer to Canyon Lodge? It's got nothing to do with the pop-outs. So, I'd like to have that answered. And I, you know, it's a drag now that we're going to lose three more trees up there. And I think it's silly to bring in big snowblowers. I'm sure that they're not very quiet. Those are my comments. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you.

51:04 I'm sorry, was there any more public comment? Please. First of all, I resent being accused of trying to pull a fastener over on somebody. You folks have known me for quite a little bit of time. I was trying to make this project better. The buildings are not closer together. That's just not true. You're listening to this gentleman tell you they are and they are not. You can't move two feet towards a sideline.

51:42 And have these buildings closer together. They're not. We actually moved the buildings closer to the entry, too. So that's just incorrect. Again, I really resent being accused of pulling a fast one. After this winter, my point was to make this project a better project by getting rid of the pop-outs, by getting a little more distance between the buildings. That's what I was doing. I could have left that map in place and done none of this. This just cost me time.

52:12 So that's my position on it. Thank you. Thank you, John. He's saying these buildings are not closer together. Look at the two maps. Look what the numbers say. Can the staff look at them right now? We'll see who's the liar here. Is it possible that there's just a difference in the notation? I don't have side-by-side comparisons right here in front of me. We can look at whether or not there are maybe one or two

53:01 There may be areas where the foundation placements, as Commissioner Eckert noted, may

53:30 Be six inches closer or in some kind of minimal distance closer to each other. But with the removal of the pop-outs, staff did analyze the distance between each and every building separation, and they have overall increased. And the pop-outs and the accessibility for the snow removal equipment is what we focused on. So if commission requested, we could look into whether or not the actual foundation distances.

54:00 Have increased between every building, but I'm not sure that that's what's most relevant to the discussion. The overall distance to accommodate the snow storage equipment has increased between each building. Okay. Just a quick question, I'm sorry. Is the footprint of each building, they have reduced, right? Didn't John earlier talked about the living area where the footprint has reduced?

54:28 Because of the upper level popouts were eliminated, then the footprint at, I think those upper levels was perhaps reduced, but not necessarily, I'm understanding the foundation footprint. Okay. Correct. Okay. Correct. The overall building plans have not been modified other than the removal of the popouts. Okay. The most important thing that I see here is that regardless of the fact that a mistake was made previously, that you are all here

55:02 confident in the current snow storage requirement calculations, the snow removal requirement as well as the snow storage requirement? Correct. We are confident that the current map addresses the snow storage requirements for lots 2 through 16, appropriately conditions the construction of lot 1 on the approval of a new snow storage management plan that accommodates snow storage for all of the lots, and that there are

55:32 appropriate triggers in place for staff review to move the project forward in the phasing proposed. Were the three trees that he referenced being removed now still being removed originally with the original approval or has this amendment caused those three more trees to be removed? I will admit I have not counted the number of trees to be removed in a comparison between the two maps. There is no

56:01 limit on the removal of the number of trees as a part of approved building or grading plans. So it may be the case that there are three additional trees proposed for removal as a part of this new plan to accommodate the increased snow storage. Does that answer your question? No. Okay. But overall, I mean, I think what we've got is a developer who is willing to take a risk on having a lot become

56:29 I agree. I would just like to say while this particular scenario seems a little bit unusual for us to consider

57:03 sort of this piecemeal snow storage plan. I don't feel like it's unreasonable given also combined with the reduction in the setback by two feet on the west side. I don't think it's unreasonable given the particular characteristics of this site being as sloped as it is to the south for one and considering that because of that slope

57:34 The developer has, you know, I think smartly locate, chosen to locate the buildings in a location on the site that disturbs the site as little as possible. I think, I really do think that our applicant is acting in the projects and, you know, the prospective, you know, investors or buyers' best interests in trying to make this a better project.

58:06 It sounds to me that he is amenable to the conditions of leaving this lot one vacant if absolutely necessary. Understandably, that's not an ideal situation for him. And it seems likely that a solution will come forth. But I feel comfortable with the language that staff has developed in conjunction with our town attorney. I agree. And the applicant has clearly

58:36 voiced his understanding with the conditions of lot one being this temporary snow storage solution going forward and then once their more permanent plan is in place and the permit for developing lot one will be assessed and he has clearly voiced his understanding of that. I'd also like to just quickly mention the strong reputation that this applicant has in the community as a developer of a high

59:06 He's a very valued partner in this community in terms of development, so I just want to get that on the record. I do understand the concerns of the neighboring property owners, and not just the one who's spoken here today, but others as well. And I'm glad that you've come to voice your concerns. This is the appropriate venue for doing that. I do, however, feel that our applicant has done the best that they can to respond.

59:44 to the concerns and act in the best interest. As far as the tree removal, Ruth, is there not a provision in the conditions that trees be replaced as part of the final landscaping plan? We don't require tree replacement or mitigation unless it was required. Otherwise, there's maybe some kind of

1:00:12 Environmental Mitigation and Monitoring Program. So, no. Okay. If it's okay with commissioners, I would like to make a motion. You may do that. Okay. I would like to make a motion to adopt the attached planning and economic development commission resolution making require CEQA state subdivision map act and municipal code findings and improving

1:00:46 Tentative tract map, 17-001, design review, 15-001A, and adjustment, 17-006.

1:00:56 Six or seven?

1:00:57 Seven.

1:00:57 No correction.

1:00:58 007.

1:00:59 My apology.

1:01:02 I'll second the motion.

1:01:06 Jamie, can we have a vote, please?

1:01:07 Mr. Burroughs?

1:01:09 Yes.

1:01:09 Mr. Chang?

1:01:10 Yes.

1:01:11 Mr. Eckert?

1:01:11 Yes.

1:01:12 Vice Chair Banger?

1:01:13 Yes.

1:01:13 Chair Calumet?

1:01:14 Yes.

1:01:15 Motion passes 5-0.

1:01:16 Thank you all very much.

1:01:19 Thank you.

1:01:22 Moving on to our next public hearing to consider recommending to the town council approval of general plan amendment 17-001 to amend the land use elements institutional public land use designation description to allow ancillary housing for institutional uses and to allow performing arts and cultural facilities and physical wellness and rehabilitation facilities. Again, Ruth has our report. And I've got a compliment. Oh, I have to recuse myself from this. Okay, thank you.

1:02:05 Both of them? They are both conflicted. Oh, okay. Or looked it out to what location, I guess? Thank you. This is a request for a general plan amendment to the institutional public designation in our general plan's land use element. The proponent for this application is Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Short background, what is the general plan? The general plan is a state-required document that consists of policies for development for the town.

1:02:43 There are required elements prescribed by the state which address specific areas, issue areas, including land use, open space housing, mobility, safety. The particular element that's proposed to be amended is the land use element. The land use element of the general plan describes the principles and requirements for the physical development of the community. The current description provided for the institutional public land use designation, which is proposed to be amended.

1:03:13 is as follows. This designation allows institutional uses such as schools, hospitals, government offices and facilities, museums and related uses. Residential uses are not permitted with the exception of employee and student housing that is accessory to the college. The maximum density for accessory housing is four units per gross acre and subject to the HDR1 development standards.

1:03:41 The institutional public land use designation is highlighted in yellow on this map. The primary area is the area where the college is currently located. Also encompasses the school properties, what's known as the McFlex parcel, the hospital, other areas on the eastern edge of town. It also includes the Trails End Park, the community center near the village, as well as Fire Station 1 on Main Street.

1:04:14 The proposed amendments, I'll read through the proposed amendments and then talk about what the purpose is of those amendments. So the proposed amendment would read, this designation allows institutional uses such as schools, hospitals, government offices and facilities, museums, performing arts and cultural facilities, physical wellness and rehabilitation facilities and related uses.

1:04:38 Residential uses are not permitted with the exception of employee housing that supports and is ancillary to the allowed institutional uses and student housing that is accessory to the college. The maximum density for housing is four units per gross acre and subject to the HDR1 development standards. As a part of this amendment, a footnote in the buildout table would also be required to be amended.

1:05:03 And that would read, the general plan allows housing ancillary to the institutional uses and accessory to the college within the IP land use designation at a density of four units per acre. The Kern Community College District and Mammoth Lakes Foundation own approximately 57 acres of land and have constructed 36 units of student housing. The build-out table is pretty much impossible to read on this screen, but you can see the highlighted portion at the bottom is where the amended footnote.

1:05:34 would be located. The density, you can see that the density in the build-out table wouldn't be changed. It's just the reference to what the allowed uses are in the build-out table would be modified in accordance with the amendment to the description of the institutional public land use designation in the land use element.

1:05:57 The purpose of the amendment is to allow for a wider range of housing uses to support the allowed institutional uses or the primary uses in the IP designation. Those uses include schools, the college, hospital, library, government agencies. That can include the town, county, fire district, for example.

1:06:19 And then the secondary purpose of the amendments is to clarify the allowance for the proposed Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center, the MAC, and the Wounded Warrior Center projects. Staff determined that the project is exempt from CEQA pursuant to the general rule, which applies to projects where there is no possibility that the activity in question may have a significant effect on the environment.

1:06:44 Because there was no change in density and there was only a change in the proposed allowed uses, accessory to the primary uses, it was determined that the project is exempt under this general rule. We did receive two public comment letters. The primary concerns raised in the letters were that the affected agencies and organizations weren't appropriately notified or a part of the proposal.

1:07:14 that there was not alignment with the Parks and Recreation Master Plan and other planning documents, and concern over the future use, specifically of the Trails End Park and the Community Center properties. We received both of these letters yesterday. We haven't prepared a formal response, but as a part of the discussion, staff is happy to answer those questions that Commission might have regarding those letters. Excuse me. We need to finish the staff report, and then we'll open it up to the public. Okay.

1:07:48 The required findings for the project are consistency with the California Environmental Quality Act and findings in accordance with the general, with the pursuant to Municipal Code Chapter 17.112, which addresses amendments to the General Plan and Zoning Code. The recommended action from staff today is to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, make the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings, and recommend to the Town Council approval of General Plan Amendment 17-001,

1:08:20 As recommended by staff or with modifications. And the representatives from Mammoth Lakes Foundation are here and I'm happy to answer any questions as well. Okay. At this time, if a representative from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation would like to speak before we open it up to questions. Good afternoon, Madam Chair, Commissioner, staff, members of the community, Rich Baccia, Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Our goal in this project is to maximize community benefits for the Mammoth Lakes Foundation property.

1:08:57 We have three main objectives. Number one, the performing arts and culture facilities. The current IP assumes the theater is a college component. The proposed amendment permits it to be operated separately from Cerro Coso Community College. Number two, to provide wider community housing options in addition to the college students. A, student housing is not fully occupied for students at this point in time.

1:09:22 B, the proposal would allow local entities such as the hospital to house visiting nurses and doctors and other government agency part-time employees in the unused rooms. Housing is a concern in this community. Number three, physical wellness and rehabilitation facilities. The Wounded Warrior Center supports the growth and development of the Wounded Warrior Center and the current housing limitation would restrict its use. Three simple things. We'll focus on the foundation property. We appreciate your support of this request.

1:09:50 I'm available for any questions if you may have any. Thank you. Thank you, Rich. Thank you, Madam Chair. Any questions for staff or for the applicant? Yes, I do. For either. This staff report talks about advocates of Mammoth. And my apology, I do not know who they are. Can we get a little history on this group? Sandra? It was a group of concerned citizens.

1:10:28 That had organized in town that came, you know, spoke on a number of different projects, kind of with it really looking at environmental concerns and build out in town, really looking at not overbuilding the town. I haven't heard from any members of the advocates in a number of years, so I don't think that they're organized anymore. And at the time, they felt that the land was only appropriate for accessory student and faculty housing, but no further than that.

1:11:00 Did I get that correctly based on the document? You did. When researching the adoption of the 2007 amendment to the general plan, it was determined that staff had originally proposed allowing affordable and workforce housing in the IP designation, but there was concern at the time from the advocates based on potential

1:11:28 Potential densities, as well as the type of use proposed, and it was limited then to student and faculty housing accessory to the college. Okay. So this is not the first time that this kind of amendment has come forward. Okay. Zoning code amendment 15-02 and GPA 15-02. This happened back in 2015, of course, right?

1:11:57 Correct. So the reduction of projected units went from 250 units to 229 units. That was simply because of the amendment incorporated with the FAR's amendment, right? Correct. So that was due in part to a change to the build-out methodology used for the current build-out table that's in the general plan.

1:12:27 Those 250 units, I don't believe that that estimate was based on the density as applied to the vacant land available, whereas the current build-out methodology is a simple calculation based on what is the vacant, non-entitled, not otherwise assigned land, what is the density allowed on those properties. And so in the IP designation,

1:12:54 Okay. The potential for workforce housing for this particular area.

1:13:28 Really was designated for employee housing for the most part, right? And students. Really nobody else in town have the ability to access this. Or Mammoth Lakes Housing Authority, they don't have the ability to access these units as well. Is that a correct assumption? Under the proposed amendment?

1:13:57 Under the proposed amendment. Under the proposed amendment, the housing could be developed to support any of the uses allowed in the IP district. So it could potentially be housing to support the government agencies in town. It could be to support the fire district. It could be to support hospital employees, library employees, school district, college. But these are all nonprofit entities. Correct. These are entities that are otherwise allowed.

1:14:26 They have no access to this at all. Am I correct? Correct. Okay. And the intent there, if you don't mind, is to maintain the character, the overall character of the IP designation so that the housing that's allowed is, as stated in the language, sort of ancillary or accessory to the permitted uses. That was the intent of the proposed amendment, was to allow.

1:14:55 Increase flexibility to the workforce population without modifying the overall character of what the IP designation is intended for. Okay. One of the documents in the, and I don't believe my fellow commissioners have the opportunity to see this document yet, is the, is the Mammoth Lakes Community Housing Action Plan that was dictated back in July 27.

1:15:25 And I just want to read this section of it. Currently 60%, and this was done by the current consultants for this working group. And the document says currently 60% of the units are occupied by students, another 30% by seasonal employees and interns. And since 2011, units have housed a couple of college employees, a few K-12 teachers, interns, hospital residents.

1:15:56 In the summer when students have left, they rent to various camps, athletic, athletes, film, festival, etc. Mammoth Lakes Foundation sees a need for more housing, but not for students. They are in discussion with an area partner to purchase part of the building for local employees. They have undeveloped land that could be used for future housing.

1:16:21 It will require GM general plan amendment to allow housing for other purposes. Now with that said, when they talk about 30% of seasonal employees here, if the applicant can address that a little bit, are we talking about the hospital, the government entity seasonal employees, or are we talking about seasonal employees for the town, seasonal employees for the mountain?

1:16:49 Would that be faculty, though, as well? Maybe they're seasonal just on the school year? It doesn't have any explanations. So that's why I was... Thank you, Paul. The seasonal workers who speak of the folks that meet the government agency definition could be...

1:17:12 Staff employees at the school district, hospital employees specifically, usually at short term. I'll give you an example. We have a doctor coming to do an internship program December through January, about five weeks. They need a place to stay for those five weeks. So the units are not being used by the students at that point. We are then using for those types of purposes. Okay. I'm sorry, Rich, if I may just...

1:17:36 Keep you up here for a little bit, just in case you know something that... I've got my technical advisors in the room, too. Okay, great. And I apologize, it's taking me a little while, because I think this is truly an important issue, not just for this particular designation, but for our community housing effort that we're trying to, you know, the problem that we're kind of trying to solve. Now, with this plan, I'm assuming that the applicant have some sort of

1:18:06 Conceptual idea or design or concept, schematic concept as to what you're going to do when you get this approval. Are you looking to simply using the existing units, trying to fulfill those, trying to fill those units to 100% occupancy or are you looking to develop additional units in this area?

1:18:37 And if so, what are those, who can qualify for those units? Okay. I would probably chunk this in three phases. Phase number one, expand the opportunity to provide housing in the student departments for other folks that meet that IP designation. That's number one. Number two, make sure we have the language in the amendment right now to support the growth, the building of the Performing Arts Theater and the Wounded Warrior Center.

1:19:05 Phase number three, beginning to look at other possibilities to support the work plan that we have right now with Mammoth Lakes Housing. And we're looking at probably the next five to ten years. And we believe this is an imperative conversation community-wide. You know, you can't get good employees if they don't have employee housing. So how do we look at this? Phase one, let's maximize that student apartments at this point in time. Phase two, let's make sure the language is there for the Performing Arts Theater and the Wounded Warrior Center. And phase three, let's begin to look at, as we work with that,

1:19:34 Work Group right now, what other opportunities we have for housing in this community? Would that other opportunity, Rich, be deed-restricted type property or would it be market rate? Haven't even gotten that far down the road, Michael.

1:19:48 Right now, I'm just short-term. How do I maximize those student apartments? You know, we're about 60% booked at this point. How do we use that to support other entities? And we're looking at breaking ground for the Performing Arts Theater probably in 18 months, opening in spring of 2020. You know, working with Kathy for the Wounded Warrior Center. Those are our two big thing that's going to take us five years out. We're hoping that once we work with the Housing Works Plan right now, we're actively involved in that process. We'll step back and say, what's the next step in this process? Haven't gotten that far down the road.

1:20:17 And I know you've been very active in participating with the Workforce Housing Group at this moment. And one of the questions I wrote down was, how does this benefit our working class here in this community? As you know, based on the consultant study, well, you don't even need to look at the study. You'll know that 40 to over or close to 50 percent of our workforce here are in the accommodation and hospitality and food service industry.

1:20:46 And that's a big group, right? However, this particular designation, change of designation, doesn't really, we're hoping that somehow that can cover some of these folks, can help some of these folks with this change of designation, but I see that maybe this designation might be

1:21:17 Thank you.

1:21:34 Apple concern that you can think about in the future. Right. Absolutely. And that's where we'll focus on. How do we maximize the student apartments? Part of the gateway plan right now. If we have vacant rooms, how do we support the local government agency? With this town staff, educational staff, hospital staff, I gave you an example of how we're supporting that now. I mean, that's our primary.

1:21:54 We have to look at this holistically. You know, what's the common vision based on the greater good for this community? Housing is there. That's why we're going to be active with this work group. We're looking forward to continue to engage in the process, looking at the town council recommendations on November 15th. You know, Mammoth Lakes Foundation, it is foundation property. We have 50-plus acres. How do we maximize that parcel to support the greater good? We haven't really fully thought that out, but this is the first step in that process. What's the reason behind such a low occupancy in the student housing?

1:22:25 Say that question again? Your student housing occupancy in that area? The 60% student? Correct. So right now, based on, I'm looking at numbers from last year, it's about 60%. Right. Right now, we're going to open up. Why is it so low? Well, that's what we're working on. We're looking at.

1:22:45 We're opening school in the next week. Students will start arriving on August 14th. We're beginning to look at what those numbers look like. We need to do a better job of recruiting students, number one, to live in those houses. Market that so people understand what we have to offer. To me, it's an apple that needs some polishing. And I think we've done some things over the last couple of months. Deanna Campbell at the college, Brett, our manager, to maybe increase the number of...

1:23:12 Thank you. Thank you, sir. May I add something in response to one of your questions about providing housing opportunities for our service sector? I think one of the considerations that we could make would be that if we were able to create, or if the town or Mammoth Lakes Foundation or some other entity were able to create additional housing opportunities,

1:23:45 for the designated workforce population addressing this amendment on those vacant properties in the IP district, that it would then create openings in the housing market throughout town, create additional, any additional units created on this property would then create vacancies elsewhere in town that could

1:24:09 Provide additional housing opportunities for that service sector that you mentioned. And it may also be, you know, as a part of this housing action planning process that there are other general plan and zoning code amendments that may address the concerns that you have about the capacity in these different land use designations and zoning districts to serve additional density or housing types. Well, I think, and I appreciate that. I think, you know,

1:24:39 And I'm glad that the applicant had the opportunity to bring this forward. And I see that this is definitely a prime area that can resolve some of our issues here or our housing, community housing issues. With that said, the letter that was from the comments that we received,

1:25:07 talked about the lack of park and rec areas that by utilizing this space for anything else that would really create some sort of deleterious effect for the people in this community for their recreational activity.

1:25:37 Can we get, if it's okay to have Park and Rec talks about what their view on this is? Stuart Brown, Parks and Rec Director. I believe the change in designation would still require any use permit to come forward. I think that was the assumption from staff. So I don't know if this is automatically going to open any type of issue from a Parks and Rec point of view. This hasn't been addressed through the commission, but that's my understanding from

1:26:15 Staff, I don't know if Ruth just wants to cover that. Sure. So the general plan amendment creates the allowance for additional uses on that community center parcel but doesn't prescribe or require that those uses be put in place. So any potential development or project on that community center site would require additional zoning code, possibly North Village specific plan amendments.

1:26:42 Use permit, design review, several other processes which would require public involvement. I think another... Can I throw in a quick question here? Yeah. I didn't interrupt. Just sort of related to that housing use, I think I don't want to lose sight of the fact that you're not proposing to change the current density limit of four units per acre.

1:27:15 Correct. Correct. At least not at this time. Correct. I think, just thinking a little bit realistically about what four units per acre is an extremely low density for this town. I mean, that's less dense than our typical single family home neighborhood with the majority of the single family lots in this town being about two tenths of an acre. So when we look at the example of the existing

1:27:45 Student Housing for Saracoso College, and they've got 40 or 39 or something units. That fits in the four units per acre category because that building is on a 10 acre lot, which is pretty unusual for around here. So I just wanted to put that a little bit in perspective. We're not at this moment talking about changing a land use designation that is all of a sudden going to result in

1:28:15 I was just wondering if staff could maybe explain to me and maybe to the commission and the public if it was ever considered for

1:28:52 There to be a general plan amendment to the IP parcels individually as opposed to the IP land designation as a whole. We did discuss the possibility of creating different allowed uses within the IP district for the different physical areas of that land use designation. Sorry, just trying to get to the map here. So you can see there's four

1:29:22 There's four areas designated institutional public, the community center parcel, the fire district location, the primary location on the east side of town, and then the Trails End Park. There may be a way mechanically to do that. It's not necessarily advisable to have one land use designation with

1:29:51 Distinct allowed uses. It would probably necessitate or it would probably be recommended that we create new land use designations to accommodate that if we think we have different areas within the IP district with different needs. So it would be something that we could consider possibly somewhat separately from this application. Question right now? Okay.

1:30:30 I have a little bit of a question that I was just looking at and it kind of pertains to the build out calculation for the IP district or land use designation. The new build out states the potential possibility for I think 229 units and that is at a density of four units per acre. Four units per acre as applied to the land, as applied to vacant land. As applied to

1:31:01 Vacant, unentitled. Vacant land that is otherwise not entitled. So that comes out to about 57 acres. Correct. There's clearly more than 57 acres of land within the institutional public land use designation. Correct. Do you have a sense of, I don't know, can we visualize what parts of that land use designation were actually, are not otherwise entitled or are considered vacant or buildable for?

1:31:36 It's really just the lands adjacent to the college. So the build-out table doesn't prevent other properties from being developed or redeveloped at that density. But density, according to the adopted build-out methodology, was only applied to these vacant or, again, otherwise not entitled or assigned properties. So density, for example, wasn't assigned to properties owned by the Forest Service. Okay, so the RV park, for example,

1:32:05 Which is currently located in the institutional public land use designation. There is no density applied. There's no density applied to that. There's no density applied to the actual hospital and the actual school and the actual library parcels because they're already occupied and developed. Thank you. If I may just go back to this park and rec question real quick. In 2006, there was a deficiency of 10.48 acres of rec creational acreage.

1:32:46 By 2025, deficiency will be at 27.67. Is this a study done by the town or by Park and Rec? So that's the level of service standards that was presented in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. Thanks for letting me comment on that. There's a couple of distinctive points. One is total acreage and one is developed acreage.

1:33:14 I think you want to kind of pick on those two points. We have upwards of 75 total acres of land. Of that land, 32 acres is developed. So really the goal for Parks and Recreation and our Recreation Commission is to develop the outstanding acreage. Are you talking about land owned by the town?

1:33:35 Town owned or managed. Town owned and managed. So that includes the existing parks, it includes Whitmore, it includes the bell-shaped parcel. And town owned parcels, correct. So we have a total of 74 in our, 74.9 acres. Okay. And it includes shady rest. Correct. Managed, because it's managed. Correct. Town owned and managed. You get, yeah. So our goal, you know, while those numbers look kind of concerning, I think the goal here is to kind of dig into and say of those total acres that we might be deficient, the goal to really kind of

1:34:05 Solve that problem is to develop the existing park adres we have and that's kind of really the goal that the Commission's kind of focused on and certainly the build out and what we kind of recommended in the amendment that we recently made in December and that was kind of that overriding decision I think we were before you in December about and I think we talked about the same thing so that would be kind of our response to

1:34:28 To the response from Patton, we very much agree that it's obviously not in the best interest to lose any kind of parks and recreation facilities and certainly open parks and I don't think the intent of this rezoning is intended to do that. Thank you. I don't have any other questions. Any further questions before we open it up? I do not. Okay. Any members of the public that would like to speak? Please come now is the time. You can come up to the podium and please state your name. Yes, please.

1:35:09 Do you mind just introducing yourself for the record, please? Thank you. I'm Carolyn Caputo Didrickson. I'm a retired real estate broker. I've been here since full-time, since the beginning of 89. I live in the Knolls. That gives you a clue of why I'm concerned, okay? I got this email.

1:35:39 And it came in, oh, after three o'clock on Monday, and I just didn't deal with it yesterday because I wanted to come here and see who everybody was and introduce myself. So thank you for that. I do have a major computer system and I would like to be kept abreast. I am concerned about

1:36:03 The email that I got late on Monday, which talked about coming to the commission and a public hearing application. I don't want to have cars. I live on St. Anton Circle, 282. I'm on the sunny side of the street, if you will. And I really want to preserve the atmosphere that exists.

1:36:35 in the Knolls and for them to send me something was incredible but I wanted you to know who I was, how you can reach me, keep me abreast of what's going on because I'm very interested in what happens to the future and I'm not keen on the idea of having you know a community center park. I think we have to be really astute.

1:37:02 Thank you.

1:37:32 gmail.com. I will give you my email is carolyn at carolyn2010 at npgcable.com. So put that in your memory book or pad or what have you. Keep me abreast of what's going on because I really want to save some of the goodness of Mammoth. I mean, people leave our town and they come back.

1:38:03 Because they haven't found the environment they're interested in living. And with your development out near the college, I think that's a very important item to focus on right now. Because real estate-wise, only 30% of the people are one-time livers. Most of our clients are second homeowners.

1:38:32 A thing we have to deal with, and I think with the college here, it's a good college, kids are going there, kids from our high school are going there, so that's the reason I'm here, to sing the song that I think is the best, and I want to be kept abreast of what's going on, and I can be helpful in understanding the whole matrix, if you will. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you.

1:38:59 Carolyn, if I may, the spelling of your email, is it L-I-N-E or L-Y-N for Carolyn? L-Y-N. L-Y-N. Thank you. You are on the list. Yeah. Thank you very much.

1:39:40 Thank you very much. Thank you. Any additional comments or questions from the public? Hi, I'm Reinhard Albrecht. I live at 913 Forest Trail, better known as the Innsbruck Lodge. I've been managing that for over 30 years now. And I'm just sort of curious, what does the Mammoth Lakes Foundation want to do with the community center property? I'm not... I just want to know exactly what they're... What does the foundation want to do with the property at the community center?

1:40:26 We'll let Rich answer that one. We are only focused on the Mammoth Lakes Foundation property. We have no interest in the community center whatsoever. We'll just focus on the Mammoth Lakes College facility.

1:40:45 We're looking at building the Performing Arts Theater, a 300-seat theater in about three years. It's going to be a great addition to this community. We're looking at maximizing the student housing right there. We're looking at maximizing what we're doing to support the community college. As you know, every one of our high school kids that wants to stay home, that doesn't have the curiosity to explore the world, we pick up their tuition and their books to stay home and earn their associate's degree. We're trying to polish that apple at this point in time. We're focused on this. This IP thing is much bigger than us at this point in time.

1:41:14 No interest in the community center. Mr. Brown with the Parks and Recreation does a great job with what they're doing in park stuff, and I don't think there are any conversations right now of any making any transitions with that, and if that's something that's on the table, there'll be many, many public meetings, there'll be lots of public discourse, but right now we'll just focus on the property, the community, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, south of Meridian. You know, it's a very little piece down there. I'm going to give you my card, and I would love to have you walk out there with me. We could walk around and show you all the great stuff we're doing.

1:41:42 Okay, did I answer your question, sir? Yes. Thank you very much. So now, it's back to the story. What are your plans with the community center or the town's plans? Yeah, I'll just jump in. We provide updates to the community through our Recreation Commission monthly as well, and I provide kind of an update for our department. We are currently, and we've struggled this year to actually

1:42:11 Repair those tennis courts. It's been a real challenge. But we're on schedule to repair them this fall and then it just didn't make much sense to repair them and have another long winter on the court. So we're going to invest probably $25,000 in those courts in the spring. We're also working with the Knowles Owners Association to come down and do kind of a clean-up project with the park as well. So Sandy and I are kind of coordinating that with our parks maintenance division and then we're actually adding some directional signage.

1:42:39 To limit kind of the thoroughfare from, you know, the park through to the Knolls Association. So we've got those signs going in and we're working with the trails coordinators on putting that in. So that's kind of the immediate short-term goals and that's kind of what we're focused on at this time. So nothing long-term, any long-term ideas or? We are programming it day-to-day and we want to just get as many people in that park and that facility as possible. It's a great, great, great facility and very high-density area.

1:43:10 We are proud to have that as part of our kind of network of trails and parks in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay. All right. That's it for me. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, guys. Absolutely. My name is John Armstrong. I'd just like to ask the commission if you have entertained any proposals or have any strategic planning to turn the community center land into parking structure or employee housing.

1:43:47 I'd defer to staff on that one. The walk, bike, ride project, or I guess planning process, showed some conceptual ideas of parking there, but the project, the walk, bike, ride isn't a...

1:44:04 It's only a guiding document. It's not actually adopted. So there's some different ideas that we've discussed for that community center parcel, but there's nothing concrete, nothing that we've actually said this is what we're going to do with that parcel at this point. Have you had landowners or developers from the North Village area approach your department with proposals or interest in turning that land into employee housing or

1:44:33 parking structure. Not that I'm aware of. I don't know if you've heard anything. There actually have been some discussions with at least one of the proposed developers, Mr. Will Gustafson, about

1:44:47 At least doing a preliminary planning study for a parking structure in that area, which might include a portion of the community center site. He actually came to town council and town council has said, look, if he puts up X amount of dollars for that planning study, then the town would kick in some money as well. So that has been discussed at town council in open session. It has not happened yet. In fact, the only action that I'm aware of, of discussion of any parking on that site was actually proposed by the Knowles and MMSA who got together and had sort of a

1:45:16 Community meeting. I think the town was invited, but we didn't sponsor it or actively participate to talk about some options for that site. That's really as far as it's gone so far, but it is in discussion. Who knows where it goes? That's reality. I would like to suggest that as we move forward as a community with the subjects of parking and employee accommodation in our town, that

1:45:45 While we have the urgency and the human and economic need for those two things to take place, we also have other needs that affect the people who visit, who play and who live in this town to preserve the parks and the buffers that parks provide between high intensity retail and commercial activity and with neighborhoods of the people that live and work and power this community.

1:46:15 I would urge the Commission to explore the human values of our parks and the great value that they provide for all of us. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You're absolutely right. Ruth, can I just clarify, or maybe have you clarify, that in regards to the question of employee housing on the community center parcel, according to the terms of the suggested amendment to the IP, they would not be eligible.

1:46:45 Is that not correct? Correct. Under the proposed amendment, the housing would be limited to employees of the allowed uses in the institutional public land use designation. So again, hospitals, schools, library, college, government agencies, et cetera. Under the current amendment, it would not be permitted to build what you call capital A affordable housing.

1:47:11 designated for specific income levels that that be the only purpose for that housing. It would have to be in alignment with the proposed amendment at this time. Thank you. So theoretically associated with one of those uses but not necessarily adjacent to or anything like that. So the only reason that the community center property is even part of this discussion is because it happens to be designated institutional public

1:47:42 Just like the Mammoth Lakes Foundation parcel is. Correct. So that's why this whole discussion is happening. But nobody at this time is proposing using that parcel, the Community Center parcel or the Forest Service parcel adjacent to it for housing. And even if such a project were considered, it would have to come through an extensive level of review by...

1:48:11 The town staff, the planning commission, the town council, and the general public. Correct. Thank you. May I make a motion? You may. Unless we have any other questions? I just wanted to sort of ask for the record, the reason that the proposal before us is for an amendment to the general plan rather than the zoning code, can you just clarify that for me?

1:48:57 Right. But the reason behind proposing to amend the general plan rather than the zoning code, my understanding is that the land use designations in the general plan supersede the zoning code, and so this sort of creates a, I don't know, a broader umbrella. There's a hierarchy of what you could call government.

1:49:34 Or governing documents. So the general plan in our community sits at the top in terms of land use allowances. So in order for a use to be permitted in any district or land use designation, we need to first create that allowance within the general plan. Okay. I'm not sure I got at what the heart of your question was. So there isn't a need to modify the zoning code.

1:50:06 To accomplish what? There is a need? There is not a need. Right. So the goal of the amendment can be accomplished just by amending the general plan. There isn't a need to amend the zoning code because the uses that we're talking about are already allowed in the zoning code. They already are allowed in the zoning code. Right. Okay. And am I just to understand that the reason for making the amendment to include

1:50:44 The rehabilitation facility and the Performing Arts Center specifically is really an item of clarification. Correct. It's a cleanup. The interpretation could be made without the amendment that both the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center and Wounded Warrior Center would be permitted uses because they could be considered related uses to what's permitted there currently or allowed there currently. But given that these projects are moving forward,

1:51:16 It makes sense to clarify those allowances at this time. To include them explicitly. Right, exactly. Okay. I think including adding those specific uses makes some sense. I think it's pretty common sense that those uses fall within the broader category of institutional public. And given that any major change to the housing use,

1:51:51 would have to go through a very extensive further level of review and what they're asking to or what they're proposing is actually quite a minor change to allow housing for those uses already allowed. I feel comfortable with that, that we're not kind of overreaching or making too broad of a stroke here. I definitely

1:52:20 Understand the concerns of the public, specifically with regards to the parks, parcels that are part of the institutional public land use designation. But I feel that the provisions already within our code protect those areas sufficiently that the level of review required to make any major change is going to make sure that everybody is involved in a sufficient manner.

1:52:52 I agree. 100%. And I would like to make a motion. Okay. To adopt the attached PDC resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal co-findings and recommending to Town Council approval of General Plan Amendment 17-001. I'll second the motion. All right. Vote, please, Jamie. Mr. Chang? Yes. Vice Chair Vandiver? Yes. Chair Callender? Yes. Motion passes 3-0.

1:53:25 Thank you. Thank you very much. Do we have Commissioner Eckert? Did you see him back there? Okay. Crack the whip. Okay. As soon as Commissioner Eckert joins us, we can move on to our business matter workshop to discuss proposed cannabis regulations. Thank you all for being patient. Thank you. Good to be back. All right. Our staff report is from Nolan today. Great. Thank you.

1:54:46 So today's workshop for cannabis primarily focuses on the proposed land use regulations since the PEDC really is tasked with enforcing zoning and land use regulations and reviewing those items. A little background just on cannabis regulations in town. In 1996, California passed the Compassionate Use Act, which allowed the use of medical marijuana for qualified patients.

1:55:15 Fast forward 10 years to June 2010, the town voters adopted Measure M, which allowed up to two medical dispensaries within the town limits. Two dispensaries were established in late 2010, and a replacement for one of those was established in 2012.

1:55:34 In September 2015, California legislator adopted the Medical Cannabis Regulation Safety Act, also known as the MCRSA, which established a regulatory framework for medical cannabis. This was the first framework adopted by the state. Prior to this, it was up to really each city or local agency to adopt their own framework for the regulations. Following adoption of the MCRSA,

1:56:02 The town adopted an ordinance to clarify where cultivation was allowed to be. That ordinance indicated cultivation for medical purposes was allowed in the industrial zone and with limited cultivation as an accessory used to an established dispensary. Since adoption of that ordinance, three use permits have come forward or been approved for various forms of cultivation.

1:56:29 In November 2016, the voters adopted Proposition 64, which legalized marijuana use for adults 21 years and older and allowed non-medical retail sales and cultivation beginning in January 2018. In June 2017, so about a month ago, California legislator adopted the Medicinal and Adult Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act.

1:56:57 Also known as the MAUCRSA. So this item combined the MCRSA and what was approved under Prop 64 into a single set of regulations. And also really combined all the licensing for both uses and the requirements that the requirements would be similar for medicinal and adult use. So since

1:57:26 Then, and also really since November, staff has held a variety of meetings with stakeholders and held a public workshop in April 2017. Approximately 25 members of the public showed up, provided input on what the town was doing. And so those meetings and input helped form the basis for the proposed regulations.

1:57:47 So staff are proposing a number of new regulations pertaining to recreational cannabis use and some updates to the existing regulations for medical use. Current town regulations limit the number of dispensaries within town to two. The proposed regulations expand this allowance to four licensed premises, of which no more than two of those could be medicinal cannabis. Since the allowance for two dispensaries was adopted by the voters, a change to that number would require a new vote.

1:58:16 By allowing four premises, two additional retailers would be permitted to enter the market. I do want to clarify that it does not prohibit any of the current dispensary owners from obtaining another license and opening another premise in town. And so for cultivation and manufacturing, there is currently no limit. When they adopted the ordinance, they allowed medicinal cultivation just in the industrial park as a blanket.

1:58:47 Approval. We are proposing a limit of four to ensure adequate space would remain in the industrial zone for other industrial uses and that they would not be entirely displaced by cannabis businesses. The locations where cannabis uses would be permitted remain similar to the existing regulations. Retailers would be limited to the commercial zones. We also would allow a micro business use.

1:59:15 That is a retailer that also permits limited cultivation and manufacturing using non-volatile substances. This is similar to what the town currently permits and also similar to what Mammoth Lakes Wellness has previously been approved for. All other cannabis cultivation, manufacturing, and other related uses would be limited to the industrial zone. Also, all uses would require a use permit. Also, from talks with

1:59:42 Council members and others at this time were not proposing to allow testing facilities. There's some concern, which is the way product would be coming to the testing facilities and others that they weren't sure they felt comfortable recommending that use. The proposed buffers from other uses would use the state required 600 feet from schools, daycare centers, and use centers. So on the map here, the blue parcels are where cannabis uses would be permitted.

2:00:13 Also, the two existing dispensaries are shown in purple. That buffer is a reduction from what is currently required by the Towns Municipal Code and the State Code. Town requires 1,000 feet from schools, parks, and libraries for businesses in the commercial zone. And the state has, again, the 600-foot buffer from schools, daycare centers, and youth centers. If we kept the current regulations, this is what that would look like.

2:00:45 Area of eligible parcels actually shrinks from what's currently allowed. And again, there would be no further restrictions on the industrial zone, but uses would be really restricted to those areas really in the downtown zone along Main Street. So again, with just the 600-foot buffer, it does open up some additional areas on the south.

2:01:07 area of the Old Mammoth Road District, as well as in the downtown area around Main Street and Old Mammoth Road. Again, this doesn't mean there's adequate space or landlords could choose whether they want to rent to cannabis businesses. There's some additional land use regulations about ground floor usage limited to about 75% of the ground floor could be a cannabis business. That came through about a year ago to the commission, that change.

2:01:37 For the ground floor businesses, maybe two years ago. That's for all ground floor businesses. What's that? That applies to all ground floor commercial. Yeah, in the zoning code, there's, when you look at the allowed land use table in the commercial chart, there's ones with the footnote of one, so it's kind of a generally like active commercial businesses are allowed on the ground floor, and then there's some, you know, more for housing, other uses that are limited in where they can be. Right.

2:02:09 With the new state regulations and the requirements for security measures, staff has determined that there does need to be an annual cannabis business renewal fee that covers the cost of administering and implementing the cannabis regulations. In the current regulations, there is discussion that the police department is supposed to conduct an annual audit of the businesses. There was never an established system or fee for implementing or conducting that audit, and that has never happened.

2:02:37 So again, this fee would cover staff costs, financial audits, and regulatory audits. It's likely the town would contract with an outside agency for the audits. And under the state law, those costs can be covered 100%. So basically, we can set the fee at whatever the cost will be. We can't set it higher, but we can recover 100% of those costs. Based on conversations with some of the consultants, it seems unlikely that the state's going to

2:03:06 Be organized enough to really ensure local compliance initially. I've heard anywhere from two to three years before they're really coming in locally to do any kind of inspections of facilities. Also with the financial audit ensures that the proper amount of taxes are being paid. Cannabis businesses are primarily cash business and so kind of some oversight to know that any taxes are being paid are being paid at the correct amount.

2:03:39 Staff are proposing prohibition on outdoor grows, except for limited use for qualified medical patients and primary caregivers. Really, the climate of Mammoth is not conducive to outdoor grows. We have no agriculture zones, and it would really lead to a lot of conflicts and security concerns amongst neighbors.

2:04:01 Those limited uses would be subject to setback and other security requirements and require an affidavit be provided to the police department certifying that all the cannabis grown is for either personal or medicinal uses only.

2:04:19 Under Prop 64, personal cannabis was legalized for adults 21 years or older. Adults can now possess up to 28.5 grams of marijuana and or 8 grams of concentrated marijuana products. They can also smoke or ingest the products. However, the town's public smoking ban does apply to the use. And there are additional state requirements for distances from schools. Residents can also cultivate up to six plants inside the residence.

2:04:46 Staff are not proposing any additional regulations on the personal use. Regarding taxes, staff is still in the process of determining what an appropriate local tax might be. Under Prop 64, it did establish a number of taxes that are state taxes that we have no say or control over. Those include a 15% excise tax on all sales of cannabis.

2:05:15 And a cultivation tax, again, that's for medical and recreational use. Also, recreational cannabis is subject to the state sales tax. In the regulations, they exempted the medical ones in limited cases where the user has a medical card in those items. Also, in addition, we would have that kind of annual business renewal fee that would come in.

2:05:44 There's pros and cons to each taxing and it's a much larger conversation between

2:06:14 That's going on between council members, board of supervisors, county staff, as well as consultants about what that rate might look like locally. Also, the soonest local tax could be adopted would be the general election in November 2018. So that concludes the presentation on the proposed regulations. And up to the commission, we can walk through each question that's been posed in the staff report, or we can have a general discussion and then answer questions.

2:06:45 I'll leave it up to the commission on what they prefer. I think if we just kind of go through person by person and I think if we try to go question by question we'll end up off topic and all over the place. Yeah, good idea. So they all kind of relate to each other so I think we can do this in a semi-orderly fashion here. I just have to start with a couple of questions more kind of about the history a little bit.

2:07:22 The vote that took place in 2010, I believe, that was relating to the number of medical dispensaries, is that correct? So the vote established the number of medical marijuana cooperatives. Cooperatives. And so with that, the original proposal was for three.

2:07:47 Either three or four dispensaries, and then it ultimately went to the voters at two. Came in at two. And did that vote have anything to do with the buffer zones, or was that separate? So when it came through originally at four, there was a buffer zone of 500 feet from all schools, parks, and libraries.

2:08:08 Not limited to just the commercial zone. That was a state requirement? No, that was just a local requirement. Okay. So it's 500 feet, but it also applied to then, took out a lot of the industrial zone, some of the other commercial zones. When it ultimately was adopted, it was reduced to two cooperatives, and the buffer was raised to 1,000 feet, but it only applied to commercial zones. So the 1,000-foot buffer was a component of that vote?

2:08:36 Actually, no, the only components of the vote, sorry, were the two cooperatives and the 500-foot buffer between uses. The 1,000-foot buffer was established just in the adoption of the ordinance from commissioning council. Okay. So just hypothetically, in order to change that 1,000-foot buffer, we don't need to go back.

2:08:59 There's no vote required? No, the only vote required would be for changing the number of medical cooperatives slash dispensaries or the 500-foot buffer between medical dispensaries. The 500-foot separation? Separation, yes. Okay. Do you know, is there any other precedent in town where we limit the number of business licenses for a specific business type? Industry. Or industry? Alcohol, perhaps?

2:09:32 No, there currently is no cap. I mean, alcohol, there isn't. The state ABC limits number of licenses for, say, beer and wine for restaurants or for liquor for restaurants, but local ordinances do not. So there's nothing on the books that says Mammoth Lakes can have X number of liquor stores? No, just at the state ABC level, and that's county-wide. They say this county's allocated.

2:10:00 X of this type of license. That's complicated and convoluted. Yeah, it's based on population numbers. Right. No limit on the federal level as well because you have to get a federal license as well for alcohol. No, you only have to get a state license for selling it locally if you're a restaurant. Right. Okay. So for any other business type in town,

2:10:26 If a property owner decided that they wanted to open a business and they complied with all the other zoning code requirements, they could. Correct. We could have 15 grocery stores and 300 liquor stores if property owners decided that that made sense for some reason. Correct. Do you know what was, are you able to summarize what the overall reasoning was behind creating the thousand?

2:11:02 Increasing the buffer zone to 1,000 feet within the public schools and yada yada. I wasn't around when this came about back in 2010 or when, so I don't have that history. Yeah, I read through the staff report that when it came to commission, it had a 500-foot buffer. Somewhere in the discussion at the commission is when it was changed to 1,000 and the way our minutes are written, it's not really any insight. It was just...

2:11:31 Staff presented this, commission discussed and proposed a thousand foot. Okay. I'm not sure. Sorry, I didn't mean to ask a difficult question. No, I don't remember the exact discussion. I'm sure that it was concerns with the separation from those sensitive, considered sensitive uses and the facilities. Okay. I don't remember the exact discussion. Right. But as it was written, if I understand correctly, it had to do with schools, daycare centers.

2:12:00 in place at the time that that business was looking at that? Yeah, so schools, parks, and libraries in place at the time that business was established. It said in 2010, the state didn't have any regulatory framework for medical uses, so it was up to local agencies. I know they looked at what other cities were doing. Other cities had anywhere from, I think, 500 to 1,000, so they said, okay, let's put this, and then, like I said, at commission, it was...

2:12:27 Bump to the 1,000, but again, there's no, that time there's no kind of state requirement for what that buffer looked like. Now the state buffer is 600 feet, but again, only from schools, daycare centers, and youth centers. And again, those are at the time someone was to establish. And is there any effect on a new or relocation of a school or a daycare center? What happens if one of those wants to move to a location within

2:12:57 The 500 feet of... So the schools, daycare centers, and youth centers can move to an established, move right next to an established cannabis use. There's no requirement that they stay away. But it wouldn't trigger the cannabis store to have to relocate. No, because it's at the time when they obtain licensing. So I guess right now, between now and when the state starts issuing licenses, it's kind of a gray area that's an unknown as to...

2:13:25 What the state, you know, how the state would look at that. But come once the state starts issuing licenses, if a business is established already and a school or a daycare was to move next door, that wouldn't impact their ability to operate. I don't know if it would impact if they wanted to change license types of the state, how the state would deal with that. Okay. Nolan, the regulation fees that you had mentioned in a previous slide to cover staff costs, staff time, auditing,

2:14:01 Yeah, we would write it in a way that it really triggered when they come in for the renewal of their business tax certificate. You know, there's always been this kind of audit in the code, and it just was written in a way that required the police department to conduct this audit, which the police department really wasn't.

2:14:30 trained to do financial auditing. And really the intent of this fee would be cover, you know, allow staff from either planning, building, police to go out and make sure all the security measures are being adhered to and the other operational standards. And on the financial side, as well as the regulatory audit to ensure that they're complying with all the state laws and paying their appropriate amount of taxes based on their finances. How current are we on audits of the existing?

2:14:59 We have never done one, to my knowledge. Can we put something in there that the town has to pay a fee if they don't get it done and that the business cannot renew unless it has been done, so they do get done? Well, that's the thing. If we do establish a fee, it does require us to actually act on it, and that fee has to be set to basically cover just the cost of what's being done. So to establish a fee, we need to look, okay, what is this financial audit going to cost? Okay, that's with the fee. What is any regulatory audit?

2:15:29 Put that in. Okay, how many staff people do we think are going to go to the inspection and what is their rate for setting that fee? I'm not so much concerned about what the fee is, is whether or not the audit's getting done at all. They're not at all. They're not yet because there's no fee. There's no staff. So there's no budget for the staff to do it.

2:15:54 Really did not, there was nothing holding them or even a procedure set up to do it. Just said police department's going to conduct this financial audit. So this would provide funding for the town to do it and would also shift, it sounds like, the role from the police department to the finance department for the financial portion and then for the regulatory to the planning and building divisions. We're telling the public these are getting done and they're not. I don't think we've ever...

2:16:23 I mean, we've been pretty open at all the meetings. The police chief has been open as well, saying he has never conducted one. I don't think there's ever been word that they were being done. All right, Nolan, I got a few questions for you. How did you come up with, if you can go back to the first proposed regulation page, it talks about the number of dispensaries or permits, licenses.

2:17:01 How did you guys come up with the number four? So, as I said, currently there's the two established medical businesses. We felt to say, okay, the only two that can continue operating are the two current ones. They can now go recreational and medicinal and then basically exclude any other, you know, business person who wants to come in and operate a business. We feel the town's really not in that role to say, you know.

2:17:29 It's just a hard number of two. That's all that can be here. Really, the market should more dictate what that market looks like. Okay. From what you just said, the market should dictate why are we putting a number here? It's just a suggestion at the moment. I think I'd like to hear from our business owners on that.

2:17:53 Once we finish our questions up here. Okay. Yeah, I know from the business owners, they'd like, they have a much different outlook. They think two is a great number and not allow any new ones to come in. Again, it's talking with council members, talking with other staffers. It was like, okay, should we expand that? Is that an appropriate number? We felt it was based on, especially with the reduced buffer, there does open up some additional areas.

2:18:22 When you look at kind of the spaced out of the liquor stores currently, I mean, you have A-Frame Liquor, Mammoth Liquor, Country Liquor, as far as true liquor stores that are evenly spaced out throughout the commercial zones. With that lower buffer, ultimately kind of follow a similar kind of pattern that they'd ultimately be spaced out and no business is going to necessarily want to open a competing business right next door to somebody else. But you have plenty of restaurants.

2:18:51 That offers alcohol. Correct. There are plenty of restaurants that offer alcohol. Everywhere in between. Correct. So, if you feel, if staff feels that perhaps market should dictate, should we make such a proposal? The reason I say that is because you're making a proposal already when this is simply a workshop. Correct. This is...

2:19:26 A starting number. I mean, we can go higher, we can go lower, we can eliminate the number altogether. Okay. But I think in a workshop, if you just put out nothing, then we'd have nowhere to start either. Okay. Just a starting point for the conversation. And it's based on, you know, the workshop that we've had previously with the public, based on staff analysis. So this isn't just kind of something we just kind of came up with. I mean, this is based on analysis we've done. Previous discussions. Right. And the public workshop as well, so.

2:19:56 Okay. I read somewhere about the amount of taxes a municipality or local government should tax this particular industry. And your proposal was anywhere between 6 or something? 46%. 46%. Yeah. So yeah, that's looking at a number of cities have already adopted taxes. And they range

2:20:27 Anywhere like from, I think I've seen 1% up to one city at 20%. And that was a city that really didn't want the use, so they said, okay, we're going to put it at such a high tax, someone does want to come in, we're going to get a lot of taxes. The statewide average from all those is between 4% and 6%. That's on top of state sales tax. That's on top of, yeah, that's on top of the state excise tax and state sales tax. So with those combined, if you had a 4% tax,

2:20:57 I mean, you'd be about 28% here. So you have 15% excise, 8.5% sales tax, and then an additional 4% there. So somewhere I read it was that the industry would have still a step, almost a 30% or approximately 30% tax to be for them to be still continue to be profitable, at least on the recreational side, right? Right. I mean, that's...

2:21:21 What we've heard, again, it varies. We've heard if you go too high, it's going to force it under the black market. There is incentive for local agencies to get some taxes back beyond just the minimal sales tax that we get locally. So let's say, assuming that we have two additional rec facilities or recreational marijuana facility, cannabis facility, with the four,

2:21:52 4% to 6% tax, plus the fees that you are collecting, annual fees that you're collecting, from those two entities, or would it be four entities? It'd be four entities. Four entities. Will that be sufficient to do all the tax compliance, public safety related issues, consumer safety issues of various enforcements?

2:22:21 and compliance related activities that are required, will that still be sufficient to pay for that? Have we done a study on that? We haven't done a study on that, right? No, and that is part of what the ongoing work is. There was talks with town and county partnering on getting a consultant, and I believe the county does have that consultant on board. I'm not sure where the town is participating in that, but they do come in, they look at, you know, okay, what are you,

2:22:51 They kind of started a big pitch like what do you want to get from the taxes and then break it down to what that tax rate should be locally and what those fees would be. Okay. I was going to say the 15% state one, we really don't get any of that back locally. It's broken down in the code as to what that 15% does go to. Some of it does come back to the local CHP office for development of impaired driving and some other.

2:23:20 Items, but most of it stays at the state level. Yeah, because they're getting approximately $3 million allocated for that, right? Yeah. But that doesn't really apply to us at all. No. On the local level. Okay. And thus far, I mean, when they adopted the medical regulations, they at that time chose not to apply to collect sales tax or any other taxes on those uses, or they chose not to collect any local tax on those uses back in 2010.

2:23:49 So from what I read, there are about 10 different licenses, and I'm switching gears here now, excuse me, 15 or 16 different licenses that are available, which includes a testing license. Correct. Are we saying that we're excluding testing facility only, and all the other licenses are permitted in this area? I understand that, you know, space-wise, we probably don't have.

2:24:17 Yeah, so when you look at the license types, there are a variety of ones that are specific to outdoor, so obviously we're not permitting any of the outdoor license types since we're prohibiting outdoor cultivation. And then when you look at the indoor ones, as you go up in type, it's based on an increase in size. It's not that we wouldn't permit the larger ones, but there really is not, there isn't a parcel, say, for a large,

2:24:47 Make a cultivation site in the industrial zone. Okay. Why is it that we don't want testing facility again? Thus far talking with council members as well as the police chief, they just did not feel comfortable with, I don't know if it's the unknown or... I know, but what are the unknowns, I guess? Really how the product's coming in. You have all the different manufacturers, cultivators sending product in, small samples, all that product going back out.

2:25:17 But do we know what the current business that we have here in town? We don't know where the products are coming from. So for the current businesses, at least once the state does it, they have to have it coming from a licensed distributor. They can be their own distributor, but it has to still come through a distributor that has to be licensed. And so they have to be bonded. They have to have paperwork as to what they're, like the shipping paperwork as to what's being loaded in the truck, as well as there's reports on how they're transporting that material.

2:25:48 I understand that currently the new bill, the trailer bill, at least according to the Senate bill, the Senate floor, they're not, there's no transportation license anymore, right? No, there's just a distributor license. Right, okay. Which they can, before they had to be a separate entity, now they can, a cultivator can have a distribution license or a manufacturer can have a distribution license so they can distribute their own products. Okay.

2:26:20 I have a couple things, but I think I would like to hear from the public before we give some of my opinions on this. I have a question. Just a little more clarification. The annual taxing. Taxing or fee? The annual fee. That can only be used for the regulation.

2:26:49 The inspection each year? I mean, it can be used for whatever we establish it to be used for, but it's then limited to those uses. So if we say, okay, the fee is going to cover one inspection by the facility of planning, building, and police, as well as a financial audit and regulatory audits, that's what that fee would then cover. So if you did a flat fee for that, could you make it so

2:27:20 Okay. All right. Thank you. Is there anything in the January law?

2:27:50 That would be, that would allow the equivalent of a, our dispensaries are analogous to a liquor store. Is there anything that would go along as a bar or an entertainment area that would allow consumption on site? So I'm not as clear on the on site stuff. There was some stuff in the code which would allow like a smoking bar to be established. It wasn't.

2:28:16 Very clear, though, what type of license, anything else that would be. Currently, though, within town, at least the public smoking ban does apply to private businesses that are open to the public. So that includes indoor. It's why you couldn't establish a hookah bar in town that's open to the public. That's a statewide law. That one is a local, I mean, there's the local no smoking in a bar, but you can't have, like, a cigar room or something that's open to the public. Thus far, our public smoking prohibition has

2:28:46 Banned those uses. And supplied to hookah bars. Like a hookah lounge you can have even though the state says you can't smoke in a bar. And our local smoking prohibition has thus far. Susan, their local, in this instance, the local prohibition is more strict than the state law. That only covers consumption by smoking. Yeah. Yeah, and so there was some

2:29:27 Some interest at the workshop from one person who wanted to open essentially a cannabis spa that you would eat edibles or use topical lotions in the spa treatment that contained cannabis products. Part of that, I think the kind of consensus was, you know, more on the regulation side of, you know, if someone's consuming edibles on site, I think there's still that unknown as to how that impacts them. You know, alcohol, it's fairly clear, like, how that...

2:29:56 Impact someone, and police know how to regulate it. Someone's eating edible on site, they really don't know how to regulate it, and the police department didn't feel comfortable, yeah, as this on-site consumption use is. Right. Okay. It's complicated. Yeah. Interesting. Do you have any questions before we hear from the public? No. Would anyone like to come up and comment or ask questions?

2:30:29 Good afternoon, Commissioner. I'm Robert Calvert. I've been involved in the cannabis industry here in the town of Mammoth Lakes since the inception in 2010. I run Mammoth Lakes Wellness, and then I also represent fluids manufacturing that just got permitted for operating an extraction facility in the industrial park. So again, I want to thank town staff for their tremendous efforts and professionalism in everything that they've been doing with all the reports.

2:30:55 When I received Nolan's report the other day, I was very impressed with the completeness of it, the thoroughness, the thorough job that he has done. So thank you to Nolan and his staff. Today, prior to starting the meeting here, I had an opportunity to meet a couple of the other business owners here in town. A couple things. I'm just going to go through my notes here. Commissioner Chang, I appreciate your comment about the market-driven

2:31:25 Comment regarding the number of shops. And I'm going to speak for all of us that we were talking here earlier. Four is way too many in this town. And for opening four retail stores. And I commented last time at the workshop in April that my advice was to go slow here. And I think the town has really done a wonderful, wonderful job. And again,

2:31:54 I believe that the town of Mammoth Lakes can be looked towards as a model that other towns can look to to help establish their guidelines and their regulations on how to do this the right way. And I believe if you go ahead and issue permits for four retail stores, I believe you're setting the industry up for disaster here in town and those businesses. We can always add a couple more. There's been a lot of talk about audit, and I'm all in favor of the audits.

2:32:23 In any way that I can continue to operate in a professional manner, which I believe my reputation has held strong, that I'm willing to contribute in any way that we can make this easier. It seems to be a big topic of discussion and let's get it done. So that could be put to rest and it's an annual thing.

2:32:46 I will continue to work with staff in helping to implement some sort of regulation process so that can be done. I mean, I remember when we first tried to renew our licenses back in 2011, Chief Dawson was on staff, and it got put off. And I was very concerned about it. And it got put off, and it got put off, and it got put off. And here we are today talking about it. So I'm on board with it. When it's time to get it done, let's get it done. And it's not an issue anymore.

2:33:17 And a lot of your questions and concerns will be answered. So as far as going slow, let's go slow. I mean, we can always, we start off what Don Wright and I had discussed is give us the opportunity to apply for an adult use, it's called adult use recreational permit. And if we pass and we have

2:33:43 Met all the regulations and all the guidelines that are required by town staff and by town police. Allow us to open up as a recreational adult use store in conjunction with medicinal. Let's see how that goes for a year. You're not going to be able to start taxing until November of 2018. At that time, we should have approximately, not a full year of business under our belt, but almost, depending on when we...

2:34:11 Get started with adult use. And then at that time we can audit, we can review. I know that the town as it sits right now, the business that's coming in our door and in Mammoth Green's door, it's not enough business to qualify for stores here in town. It may. One of our associates here that's in the industry asked a very good question. Is there lines at our door?

2:34:41 I don't have a line at my door at Mammoth Lakes Wellness. There's hours that go by during the middle of the day. I have two people on staff. No one comes in the door. Hours. Okay? I don't know how, it's a difficult business to run in this town. And I believe that we're under the scrutiny and the judgment that we're just rolling in the dough. And again, the audit will answer those questions and those concerns and it'll make it clear. One of the comments I have is maybe we need to open another Rite Aid.

2:35:13 Fortunately, we're opening another market here in town because the lines are so long. But I don't even want to go to Rite Aid. I was telling them, I was like, hey, I don't even want to go to the market. I look at my kids and say, hey, we've got to eat leftovers. I mean, because I don't want to go to the market. So anyways, so that's, I'm serious. So go slow. Maybe after 2018, we can audit. We can say, hey, is there another need, is there a need for another one in here? Is the line out the door? Was that my timer? I'm sorry.

2:35:39 You've gone over. I think you've been sort of speaking. You've all kind of collaborated on some of these permits is my understanding. So I'm happy to let him keep going. I will state, though, that I do have a hard five. Hard five. I'll make it real quick. As far as if you did issue permits for an additional couple places, either in town or in the industrial park, because I know that's one of the areas, and we spoke about that at the Planning Commission meeting regarding, no, the workshop.

2:36:09 Finding space is going to be very difficult. So whether it's a retail store in town for an adult use space or more spaces in the industrial park for commercial grows or extraction or distribution, finding space in this town is very, very limited. There's a comment, there's something in there about taxing on gross sales or a set per square foot. I would say tax on gross sales.

2:36:39 If we have a slow month and our tax is set on square foot basis, it could hurt us. So, I mean, the way I see it is the additional taxes are going to be paid for by the consumers, by the patients. I'm sorry, can you repeat that again? What did you say prior to that? As far as the taxes on... What could hurt you?

2:36:58 Taxing, whether it's a local tax, would it be, one of the things that I was reading was, is it going to be based on gross sales or is it going to be based on a per square foot basis how large our facility is? I would recommend gross sales. For the slow month, your taxes represent a slow month. And then all this talk about taxes, banking is still, is a huge challenge in this industry.

2:37:24 Tremendous challenge. If you read the articles or the article on the paper. Because of the federal regulations? Well, federal regulations. I know there are bills that are before the Congress right now addressing it, and I've heard like 44 bills or something like that, but there's a tremendous amount of talk about banking. In this state, in the Golden Triangle, if there's four counties up in Northern California, there's 65,000 growers.

2:37:52 Okay, how are they going to pay their taxes if they can't bank? Okay, I have a tremendous challenge in this community paying the taxes that I need to pay. In that article, which is in the sheet, the two local banks refuse to operate or accept any money from cannabis businesses. So, anyways, that's all I have on my notes right now. If you have any questions, I'm happy to answer anything. Robert, real quick, one question on the number.

2:38:19 Would you be supportive or feel it would work if, say, there's a maximum of four, but based on certain population number thresholds? So if, you know, the population exceeds this threshold, then we would say, okay, we would issue up to a third license. So limit it to two based on X amount of population. Population of the town, you're saying? Yeah, population of the town. How often is the population of the town assessed? Ten years. Ten years. Ten years.

2:38:47 That or, I mean, there's a number of ways you can look at it. You know, population is just one example, but other parameters you can track consistently. For example, right now for condo conversion, it's based on the annual vacancy rate would allow future condo conversions for the next year. Well, the only issue with the population is that's kind of more of a static number, and we do have a rather large influx of visitors that come that would be consumers of these stores, and they...

2:39:15 Would not be part of the 8400? Sure, based on, you know, estimated tourists in the previous year. I mean, there's different ways you could word it as supportive of some kind of system like that. So I'd say, okay, currently two are permitted up to a maximum of four based on some criteria. I do believe that, well, one of the tactics, and I'll get right to it, TBID hasn't been brought up, I believe, in any of this. And initially when TBID came online,

2:39:46 I was able to establish that a majority of our patients were within the local parameters, so we were waived having to pay the TBID, but I think with the adult use, I believe that the adult use and records can be kept, maybe not on the adult use so much because we're not going to be checking patients in, where in the medicinal format we are keeping records in-house.

2:40:13 Where the patients are. So the adult use may be a little bit more difficult to track whether or not it's going to have to be held subject to the TBID tax. But I do believe that my feeling is that adult use will have a majority of people coming in the door that are outside of this area. So, yes? Seems reasonable. Robert, if I heard you correctly, you suggested to staff that

2:40:42 To let your entity or the other entity here in this room to be the other two adult use retailer. Am I correct? Yes. I didn't say let. In conjunction with your medicinal medical marijuana licenses. That is the, yes, in so many words. I can clarify exactly what I said, but yes. So that would cover the two medical?

2:41:14 and two adult use, right? Okay. One of the Senate bill, I mean, the analysis that I saw was the monopoly excess concentration is a provision about unfair competition law. So assuming that if we allow you to do that, or we agree, excuse me, allow is not a right word, but agree that, you know, that's the path that we should go down, then

2:41:46 Your two entities essentially becomes the monopoly of this town. What are your thoughts about that? Well, actually, Mammoth Lakes Wellness did have a monopoly on the business here in town at one time. We'll see. It was during the 2012 period, I believe, if that's correct. But that was in medical. It was in medical. But at the time, it was strictly for adult use. Yeah, that was brought up in our discussion out here in the hallway prior to the meeting here.

2:42:16 Certainly people are going to come in and say, hey, they're trying to corner the market here. Cornering the market of a small business is, in my mind, a small amount of business, in my mind, is not a monopoly. If this was a multi-million dollar industry in this community, I could understand it. I would say, hey, absolutely. Issue permits for two additional locations in this town so we have a total of four. And that's where an audit would answer a lot of these questions and it would clear up a lot of these.

2:42:45 So-called ideas about what it is and how much business we're doing. I mean, I've talked with the chief of police and he's like, someone should be following, I don't need to mention the business, but somebody's making cash runs down to Bishop with a significant amount of cash that doesn't even shed light on the amount that we are handling. So now, from your business perspective,

2:43:14 And I saw this program about in Colorado where this one dispensary or grower, they were probably one of the top grower in the country. And when people go to Vail, Denver, that is the first stop. And so you don't, given that if we start recreational facility adult use here, you don't see that as a potential

2:43:43 Mark it to capture? Or you don't see that happening? Well, if I could have a crystal ball, I probably wouldn't want one. But I think there is going to be an increase in business. I don't think it's going to be so much that can support four adult use stores in town. It's my understanding that the two medical locations in town can apply for an amended use permit.

2:44:14 And offer medical and adult use. And in addition to that, proposed is two more just only adult use. I strongly urge commission to really think hard and strong about this. Start off slow. If it becomes such a gangbuster business in this community, I'm on board. Let's provide as many options as we can for the people that come to our community. I mean, we want people when they come here to have a wonderful experience. So when they leave,

2:44:43 They tell more people about our community and they come back and they bring their friends back and they bring their other family members back. That's what we want in all of our businesses. So I think I've established a solid reputation and I believe the same goes for Green Mammoth.

2:45:07 I do not agree with the fact that we're trying to establish a monopoly or set up a monopoly on this industry. Combined, I don't know Green Mammoth's number, but I'm thinking combined, we're doing less than $2 million a year. I've got four employees. I pay workers' comp. I pay a tremendous amount of rent to be in the luxury outlet mall.

2:45:31 There's general liability insurance. I mean, anybody that owns a business knows all the expenses. And we're just trying to operate like any other business in this town. And it's expensive. So go slow. And I just want to be clear, you know, I wasn't insinuating that. No, I'm just, yeah. This is simply a Senate bill's analysis that I saw in particular that talks about a monopoly of a specific area.

2:46:01 Really, at this point, it's more of a perception than anything else. Sure, sure. I mean, I want to help make the perceptions, anything that I can help provide, and the rest of the gentlemen that are in this business, in this community, in addition to what I'm providing, what they can provide, help make the picture as clear as possible. And I think it will become more clear over time, especially, again, when the audits come into play, and when the permits are issued for

2:46:30 Adult use. I don't really know how much, I don't know if a store in town that's only adult use can keep its doors open. I really don't know. I don't think we're going to have lines out the door here in town of Mammoth Lakes. You know, you read about what happened to our neighbors in Nevada. People were lining up at midnight. You hear about lines that are out the door all day long in Colorado. I have always said that the town of Mammoth Lakes is not like the San Fernando Valley.

2:46:59 You know, a lot of the collectives down there are doing a significant amount of business, and they're unregulated. You know, we're under the microscope here. There's only two of us. We're in a small town. So Chief Watson told me, operate as though you're being videotaped and recorded 24 hours a day. That's how I operate. And that's how I'm going to continue to operate. Above board, by the book, compliant. So go slow. Allow us to...

2:47:29 Submit, allow us, when I say us, Mammoth Lake Smallness and Green Mammoth to submit applications, get approved for adult use, allow us to open our doors, see how it goes here. If it's just too much for us to handle, issue another permit. Bring somebody in that's qualified, that can open another location, in the right location, and do it right. Continue to do it right. Don't set this up for disaster. Thank you. All right.

2:47:57 In the interest of time, Sandra and Nolan, I know we're not looking for any specific action here, but just sort of a general consensus on where we stand, and then what's the next step? So next step, I mean, if there was general consensus on the proposed regulations, would really then be drafting the actual ordinance to come forward for a public hearing, or if it's the desire of the commission to really have it come back to another workshop, we can also do that as well. I personally would like

2:48:29 You know, some more time to think about this and maybe talk to staff where if we have to have a workshop, you know, that's great because I think, you know, there's definitely a lot of things to think about. We're not getting a regulation pounded out in the next eight minutes. Right. You know, from safety's perspective, from the applicants, from the owner's perspective, their profitability perspective, you know, certainly we want our business owner here to succeed.

2:48:59 I heard some things from you guys that I didn't really expect to hear, not knowing anything about the cannabis business, so I appreciate you guys coming, and it's very useful. I kind of agree that it'd be nice if we could kind of do this again, sort of a round two, workshop round two, and then, did you want to come up quick, just quickly? Okay. And Nolan, if you could invite somebody from MLPD to maybe be part of the workshop. Yeah, we invited the chief, he had a prior,

2:49:30 Engagement here is already committed to at this time. It might be interesting to hear somebody from the county as well on what they're doing and what their thoughts are. Apologies. Commissioner, thanks for having me. My name is Mark Costello. I'll keep this real fast. I made some notes off the proposed regulations. First off, lab testing requirements. Right now, distributors have to hold the product. Then it has to be lab tested. The lab has to then go gather, secure the product. Then the product has to be transported to the lab via the distributor.

2:49:59 So if we have to work with labs that are five hours away, I mean, think of the cost increase. So that could be incredibly problematic for anybody producing products. Then moving on to taxation. Combining the 15% state excise tax with the cultivation tax, along with the local cannabis taxes, the price on products are going to skyrocket. And ultimately, they're going to get to a point where they're so high that it's going to drive people back into the black market.

2:50:28 Furthermore, it's unclear how many businesses are going to survive the new state regulations, and a lot of that depends on being compliant with their cities, and cities have all put small numbers of cultivation and small numbers of actually producing products into their regulations, so it's going to be a lot harder for retailers to get product. Those prices are going to skyrocket and there will be bottlenecks. This happened in Arizona, this happened in Nevada, a lot of other states.

2:50:58 Last, my suggestion in the consideration of the taxation is to think of cannabis as a medicine and a health supplement, not a cash crop. Just because people are consuming it without a medical card does not mean it's not helping them. I mean, I know tons of people right now that use cannabis on a daily basis for needs that will not get a medical card because they don't want to be put on a list or they don't want to have that associated with their name in some way. So just think about that when you're considering the taxation.

2:51:28 Thank you, guys. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So real quick, it sounds like most... Sorry. Come on up. Commissioners, thank you. I'm Don Wright from Green Mammoth. Before, I don't see what's going to happen. When I went out and talked to Nolan before this meeting started, my sales were at $1,200. And you break that up again, it's not that much. Some days are slow, some are busy, you know.

2:52:01 There was 18 people that came through my shop. You split that up. I'm paying four people to sit around for nine people to come in. Recreational, I'm sure it might get busy. We never have a line. Audits, I, you know, back in 2013, I emailed Mark Moskowitz about starting my renewal process and never got a reply back. Didn't know what to do about it, so I just, I'm not going to close my doors. Just keep going.

2:52:32 So anytime you guys want to do audits, that's fine. I mean, yeah, it's all a cash business. Somehow I lucked out and got a bank at Bank of America, and it's horrible because it's always broken. You get to work with an ATM. I deposit cash into an ATM every night, and it's horrible. I don't know. That's about it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Real quick, I know, Michael, you have to leave soon.

2:53:01 So it seemed like most of the talk was on the number of businesses. Was there any thoughts on the buffers or the outdoor grows or any of the other items? I think if we can wait until the next time. Yeah, I think the table doesn't come back. Can we do that? Sure. Rather than rushing through it all here? I mean, I don't know that there's anything, you know, out of the extraordinary that we have to talk about.

2:53:32 I think it would behoove us all to, you know. Digest and. Yeah. Bring it back. So. Thank you though, Noah. You're thorough. Yes. Unless, are you looking for some direction between now and maybe the next meeting or. Possibly. I mean, we can regroup, talk with, I mean, we know where the operators stand. What some other cities are doing, provide, I mean, more options. I guess what.

2:54:05 What do you guys need to further your discussion? I would love to hear the opinion of PD, whether they think it should stay at two or four or unlimited. I would love to hear Chief Davis' opinion on the number. I'd like to also hear, you brought up the county earlier, I'd like to hear from the county as well, a representative, county supervisor. And I'm just sort of curious, if we were to enable

2:54:38 Either the finance department or the PD or someone to actually conduct an audit on currently established businesses. Would that give us any kind of information that would be useful in drafting some regulations? Just on their annual sales kind of figures? I mean, the annual sales we have from their business tax certificate, it's about total about $2 million combined. So it's about $1 million each is what we've showed kind of average.

2:55:04 We need to have some sort of mechanism. If these guys have been going seven years waiting for us to come through and do our part to audit them, that's not their fault. That needs to be addressed. Like we shouldn't be creating these new regulations in a dark, in a black box. It would be nice to have some data and some information before we just blindly move forward. And I don't know how that happens. If town council has to allocate some funding, I don't know what has to happen.

2:55:38 I think that's something we can look into and bring back a further discussion on that at the next workshop. Great. Thank you. Well, thank you all for coming and listening and providing your thoughts. We really appreciate it. Very eye-opening. Yeah. Thank you. Then quickly, moving on, we've just got some business items. Selection of our Planning Commission officers and committee appointments.

2:56:12 So very quickly, this is your opportunity to select a chair, vice chair, design committee. The commission does this every year in August.

2:56:25 Some years there are new commissioners and so that's the opportunity for people to move around. So basically the staff report explains the process and we would recommend that you appoint or I guess, yeah, appoint members to the chair, vice chair and the design committee. Is it a motion type procedure? It can be a consensus. Okay. I would like to throw out the idea of Amy retaining the seat as chair. I think she's done an amazing job.

2:56:54 When Amy and I first came on this commission, there was actually three other people with quite a bit of institutional knowledge and the three of them exited rather quickly and Amy stepped into the void and has done a very, very admirable job. So I would like to nominate Amy to remain as our chair. I'll second that. Thank you. And I agree because I think we need consistency and I think we need to have, you know,

2:57:24 We can't constantly changing that leadership in any organization here in this town, you know, really, for that matter. So I think if we can have that consideration, Amy has done a great job. Very level-headed. So very insightful. Is it going to load?

2:57:45 Do I get a comment? Absolutely. I'm supportive of Amy too if she wants to do it. I know you have a lot of stuff coming up. So it's if you want to. You all butter up now. This winter is going to be interesting. I'd be happy to stay on. I think I can manage to squeeze it in. Muscle through. Yes. It's been very rewarding and interesting and I'd be happy to thank you all. Okay. We have consensus.

2:58:15 Second. No, you guys did that already. Oh, yeah. That's what you guys said. Okay. So do we need a second? No, you guys did that. Okay. Frank was the second, you were the motion. Got it. Okay, all right. So, all in favor. Aye. Thank you. As far as Vice Chair, I would love to see Michael continue on, if he's willing and interested. I think he's been very supportive. I would be honored to do it, but.

2:58:47 I would love to hear what the other three commissioners have to say about it. Don't know. You got my consensus. I'm good with it. Works for me. No one wants it. Okay. I'd be happy to do it. Thank you very much. I appreciate that. Thank you. Good job, Michael. Thank you. So just a design committee, which is currently Chair Kellan. Currently Jen and I. Okay. I've been enjoying it, but that doesn't mean that I have to continue. It's all yours.

2:59:19 I know you two are sort of involved in the housing. That's good enough for me. It's an ad hoc thing. And the housing is going to get busy. It's going to get busy, I think. Yes, and I think it's going. Lots of reading. Yeah. Do you guys still want to do the housing? Yeah. I do. Okay. I think it's important to, you know, just, you know, they have that point of contact. Okay, great. At this moment. So can I just make a motion that everyone retains their current?

2:59:47 Seats on the subcommittees. Is that how we go with this? Sure. Put to a vote? Or a second? Second that. Aye. Aye. Aye. There you go, Jamie. There you go. Sounds great. All right. Thank you, guys. Yeah, thank you. Oh, can we move on to the consent agenda? Very quickly. I'd like to make a motion that we approve the consent agenda. I'll second that. All right. All in favor? Aye. Aye.

3:00:20 Great. I'm going to skip my commissioner report. I really don't have anything to say anyway. I know, Michael, you have to go. Yeah, I'm going to skip mine as well. Is there anything absolutely pressing that we need to? So pressing is that the council, town council, would like to have a joint workshop with the commission on September 6th, which is council day. It's a Wednesday at 3 o'clock. So from 3 to 5, maybe 3 to 6, but to talk about downtown revitalization, walk, bike, ride,

3:00:51 Those two work efforts. So I wanted to let you know if you know that you are available or are not available right now. I will be here. I will be available. I should be here. Good. Okay, so all five of you. Okay, so I'll send an email out so everyone has that and I can send a meeting request so you have that on your calendars.

3:01:12 So that will be the next time that we see each other, I guess. And just quickly on the grocery outlet, the appeal period for CEQA expires on August 25th. So we still have a couple more weeks before we find out if we receive a lawsuit on CEQA for grocery outlet. Two more. Two more. But the council...

3:01:33 Upheld the Planning Commission's decision and denied the appeal to Council, but now there was an additional 35-day period for the CEQA. Correct. My understanding is the property closed escrow. I didn't know that. That's good. That's all I have. Okay. Oh, I guess I have to do the rest of my part. All right. So at this time then, I will adjourn our meeting to our next regularly scheduled Planning and Economic Development Commission.

3:02:04 Commission meeting for Wednesday, September 13th at 2 o'clock. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.