TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2017

Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board

· recording 1 hr 41 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

216 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:54 What does? Ladies and gentlemen, please take your seats. Paul, we're going to get you in the 21st century. Kicking and screaming. Colin, I spent a lot of time here at Mammoth. Electricity is something new to me. You're not kidding. All right, everybody. Let's call this meeting order. Begin with roll call. Brent Turex. John Morris. Here.

1:26 Kirk Schaubmeyer here, Michael Ledesma, Colin Fernie, here, Sean Turner, Paul Rudder, here, Sean's here, Sean Turner, Mr. Turner's here, Scott McGuire, do you believe we have a quorum? Item number three, board member comments, reports, agenda additions. I just have two things real quick. First, I know you're going to elaborate on this, Kirk, but I'd like to congratulate John and staff for their excellent award.

2:04 recent award for the best website, and I know Kirk's going to talk about that, but you guys do an incredible job, and it's great for you guys to have that recognition. We appreciate all the work you guys do. The other thing is just a quick plug for Snow Creek, and we have a fall golf pass that is now on sale. It's $250 for right now until the end of the season. All you can play with a cart. So you play once a week and it pays for itself. So come out and play some golf. How much is it? $250. $250 for like six weeks.

2:33 So very cool. Yeah, pretty good. Anyway, that's all in my world. Excellent. Sean? No, I don't think so. Okay, Paul? I'm good. Good? Good. Well, I'd like to welcome Eric Clark. And I'm sorry, I forgot you in the roll call there. My apologies. That's quite all right. No problem. Replacing Eric for a sale on the board. And I... So it's official?

3:03 Yes. Okay. Official. Very good. I would also like to welcome Matt McLean, Director of MLR. He's also in the room. And I'm going to elaborate a little bit more on this here award. This is the U.S. Travel's Destiny Award for the Best Destination Website. It's awarded by a panel of third-party judges. The finalists for this destination website were...

3:32 Visit Bucks County, Philadelphia area, and Washington, D.C. And some notes from the judges regarding this. They thought that Mammoth Lakes did an excellent job developing their unified website and brand by clearly integrating the needs of their target audiences. From the content to the visual cues, everyone, rather, everything points back to an authentic destination brand with very clear experiences to offer consumers.

4:04 The homepage in particular makes you feel like you've just jumped into an exciting outdoor adventure vacation. MLT team involved, we have Whitney Lennon, Christy Osborne, Megan Miranda, Josh Ray, Jessica Kennedy, and Adina Ingram, bloggers and content contributors, Betsy Truex, Monica Perel, Mike McKenna, and hopefully I don't butcher this, Jason Applinup. Is that correct? That's it.

4:35 And also Miles Media. And Miles Media. Miles Partnerships, yes. John, how many people participated, tried to get this award? You know, out of all the awards that were in there, there were 265 destinations, or 265 submissions overall. And then within this category, there were a dozen, including places like, as we mentioned, the finalists of Washington, D.C. I think Seattle was in there as well. So some pretty big players. And most of the awards, we were also up for

5:05 for our brand campaign. And with the brand campaign, they did budgets under $2.5 million, $2.55 million, and $5 million to $10 plus, I think. And with this category, there was no budget limitation. So this was up against pretty hefty budgets, yeah. Fantastic. Congratulations. Pretty exciting. That's great. 265 applicants. Total for all awards, yeah. I'd like to add two more things to the comments. Did they give you a vacation?

5:36 Yep, right here. Perfect. Also, a little thank you to, a big thank you to all those that attended the Rock and Rye event last weekend. It was a successful endeavor. And then also, today we're under a time crunch, so I'm going to try to keep this one on track. We have a town workshop at

6:03 245. 245. It's the walk, bike, ride workshop. Any other comments? Agenda additions? Very good. Okay. Going into public comment. Hello. My name is Matt McLean. I'm the new executive director of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. For those of you who don't know me, this is kind of my second time go around at Mammoth. I was here in the late 90s and early 2000s working up in the ski area. I've been working.

6:38 over in Telluride since then, as well as about 15 years in various nonprofits in Southern California, but I'm excited to be here now working with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and look forward to working with tourism to promote and enhance recreation here in our community. So just wanted to get in front of you, introduce myself, and look forward to working with you. Welcome. Thank you. Anybody else? Maybe I won't have to control the time on this one. Minutes.

7:20 Approval of past meeting minutes from August 2nd and our special meeting of August 7th. Any comments? I'll make a motion to approve both the minutes of the special meeting or our Wednesday, excuse me, August 2nd and Monday, August 7th meetings as is. I'll second that. So moved. Yeah. Here's where you say all those in favor. All those in favor? Thank you. Aye.

7:55 Let me also disclaim this. I'm not super well versed in the parliamentary procedure here. You will be totally on top of this in no time at all. If I can do it, anybody can do it. It passes unanimously. New business. In the last couple of meetings we've talked about the thresholds that Mammoth Lakes Tourism has on contracts and some new contracts and some other pieces that we've recently...

8:24 adopted the biggest thing being the air strategy plan most recently. I just handed out a piece that I put together in the last few days just to try and outline a jumping off point for us to discuss this. And so right now we have a few different processes that the board is involved in. We all participate in the spring meeting with our three agencies, so Marion Carson, Miles Partnership, and with Lyman PR. So those are our three big outside players.

8:53 They're also our three biggest contracts that we have. And so the board participates in that strategic development and direction meeting with the idea of walking out of there knowing where we're going from our messaging and what our targets are, et cetera. From that, we develop a line item, very detailed budget. So the budget we went over back in, I think, our June 6th meeting, every line item is very clear as far as out of home. So billboards are $255,000.

9:23 When they're up, when they're paid for. So I think we've got a lot of the major places where we spend money covered. Now, within things like the Marian Carson Agreement, we have all of our ad buys. So whether it's display advertising or it's billboards or any of those pieces, radio even, they're all outlined in the budget. We don't do specific contracts with Marian Carson. That's just part of our overall agreement with them is that we have X number of dollars.

9:53 We develop the budget based on that. The board approves the line items as they are. So I don't think we have to get into that sort of detail, but we can discuss that as well. Moving forward, what I'd like to do with those meetings. So when we have the meeting in the spring, that strategy meeting dictates the budget. So when we go from talking about where we're going for fall marketing, the budget is then created based around that.

10:17 So once we know what our messaging and our avenues are going to be, then we develop the budget. My goal would be to have that conversation, have a preliminary budget available at that point if possible, and then have a final budget proposed to you the next month at the board meeting to fully go in consort with the plan that we have set. So a couple of recommendations here that

10:44 When we have contracts in excess of $25,000, I think that was a number that I've heard at the last few board meetings, that our staff, the MLT team would present those probably at least a month in advance of signing those contracts. So I'll use Michael as an example. We've got a partnership where we split international agencies with the Mountain.

11:05 And something like Avia Reps, which is our rep in China and South Korea. Michael, during his monthly board meeting report, could get up and say, we are in the process of finalizing our agreement or our renewal of our agreement with Avia Reps. It's $25,000. They help us with travel trade, fam trips, and media. And then that hopefully educates the board as to what that $25,000 contract is.

11:30 Get into something where we need more detail. We can always take that. That's why I want to give a little bit of cushion. So we presented a month or two prior to when it's actually going to be signed or needs to be signed. So if there's any discussion or deeper dive that we need to go, we can do that. I think that the board should review any new unbudgeted contracts. The perfect example is exactly what we just went through with the air strategy plan with Mead and Hunt. So if we have something that comes up that's not within the budget that you've approved,

11:58 or outside of the strategic planning that we talked about with the agencies, then we can set up an ad hoc committee, we can review it, take it back to the board for full approval so that everybody's fully understanding what that's all about. Would that have a dollar figure attached to it as well or just anything that's not? Well, good point. I would say you can set that as well. Maybe that's the same $25,000 or more if it's an unbudgeted piece. Typically, if it's an unbudgeted piece, it's probably going to be a fairly hefty piece. So if you want to set a limit to that, that's fine too.

12:29 Or just leave it discretionary to say that if it's over a certain amount. Okay. I just wonder whether, I think that's all good, but I personally, I wonder whether item, where item number one is even necessary. Because as far as I'm concerned, I personally, I feel that when we, when we look at the budget.

12:47 The budget includes all of the contracts that are going to be going for the next year. I think at that time it's appropriate if anybody has any questions regarding any of the contracts, what they include, why we do them, whatever, we should ask those questions because they're set in motion and they go for a year. I agree that I think new...

13:04 Unbudgeted contracts, new opportunities, those are definitely important for us to talk about. And if there is something outside of the budget that's different, I think that's important. But, you know, to me, I mean, our meetings are difficult to get through in a couple hours anyway. And to me, the idea that every meeting when there is a contract that's already in the budget that's going to come up, to have to discuss it again.

13:32 It seems just to me to be redundant. I would not be in favor for having to do that every month. I think that we could expand when we do start discussing the budget and we do get that information in advance, then that's the opportunity to really dive into it. And if anybody has any specific questions about specific contracts, that's the appropriate time to talk about it, set the budget in motion and go from there. And stay with it until we have any mid-course corrections that you want to make.

13:58 Plus or minus whatever new things, that sort of thing. And I mean, that's just my spin on it because I just, I feel like that that's the time to do that and not necessarily every month when we have something new come up with something that's already there. Something that's already been approved. It's already been approved because that's the thing is we made it a point we talked about approving the budget and approving the budget means approving everything that's in the budget for the next year.

14:20 I would agree, and I think that if we do go with the staff presenting, it's not something that we need to get in depth to. It's more of a heads up that we're signing the Alvia Reps contract. I wouldn't, I mean, I agree with you 100%, but I think that it wouldn't be that difficult for us to just say, hey, we're on this path where 99% of these things are being renewed. They're not new contracts, so they're not. I guess as long as it doesn't bog us down too much, that would be fine, but.

14:44 Certainly renewing brings up fewer questions than a new contract. Arguably, if we're renewing, we already know about it. On the other hand, for the 100,000 plus ones, I mean, you know, there's nothing to discuss about the town's fee to fee, that's just what it is. But I think that it behooves the board, when we're spending, you know, north of 100K, to have some, maybe an understanding of those expenditures that are greater than we can.

15:13 inject into a budget discussion. And maybe not, I don't know. Well, I think that's one of the reasons that I recommend that we try and have that budget discussion and the strategy session at the same time. Because when we have Marian Carson here and they're talking about what they're doing, you know, I think we've talked about it. Our agency fees, we have $15,000 a month in agency fees to do $4 million worth of work. So we can discuss it at that point.

15:38 Because that is an automatic, that's a renewing contract that we have every year with a new scope of work to it. So we can discuss it at that point. I think that should cover it. You know, if we decide that we're going to start looking at other agencies for whatever reason, then we can take that to a much bigger place. And I put that as number four is just a, if we have major changes in any of the core agencies, then yeah, we should have a bigger discussion in direction. Well, I think to the extent that we're, you know, once again, that we're spending that kind of money.

16:08 And it really, in Marion Carson's case, you know, we're paying them to move a whole lot more money. That's something where the board should really understand it in depth because that's really what the whole organization is about. And those items are lined, those items are broken down into individual land in the budget. In the budget. Can we discuss that? Is it possible to basically wrap those large contracts into

16:36 One discussion when we do the, you know, when we have the presentations and so forth. I mean, I'm not quite sure what the timing is on some of these things, but it would be nice. I agree with Paul. I mean, I think that those are things to have a good understanding of. It would just be nice if we could do that sort of at one time of the year rather than kind of having to have that same conversation over and over again if possible. Sure. I think it's possible to do it at the strategy session. If not, it can be part of that follow-up finalization of the budget. But it makes sense to have it as a strategy.

17:03 Well, I think we can talk about what the agencies are bringing to the table. We may just not have all the final numbers at that point. And then that would be something that could be presented for the final budget approval. In theory, we've gotten some terrific presentations from staff as to how we're doing with our marketing.

17:21 You know, with the grass and everything. It would be great to have those presentations before we had the discussion about the ad agencies and what they're doing so we have a background of understanding are we doing well or are we not doing well? Because then, you know, that would obviously bear on do we want to continue with that agency or not. Well, I think what we can do is we can talk about that strategy session and have kind of a year to review.

17:51 Brief before we get into the coming year. Right. And we can talk about the successes and we can talk about what we felt didn't succeed and we can move and... Well, you know, the board doesn't want to be trying to decide these things in a vacuum. We need to have input from staff about, boy, we really like how this worked out or we didn't like how that worked out and, you know, so we can get staff's impression of are we going in the right direction or not and then...

18:19 You know, we can make informed decisions about what we're doing next. And we get that intel pretty regularly, and a lot of that comes into the presentations that we do here on a regular basis, talking about things that worked, didn't work, tweaked. All I'm saying is we've had great presentations, but if they could be just before these...

18:39 discussions about the contract, then they'll be fresh in our minds. I mean, as good as the presentations are, six months later, I'm not going to remember the details. Yeah, I think if we can do a year in review, and then we can talk about the future, and then we can talk about direction. I mean, that makes sense, right? So, the other pieces that I had here, number three was the board to identify areas of special interests that require board approval outside of the pre-approved budget.

19:08 Planning meeting, which is what we just talked about. And again, that goes back to the ad hoc committee that we formed for the air strategy plan. And I think that if we say that air is something that when we have a contract on air that the board talks about it, then that's a specific area of focus. And then we can talk about it, whether it's our consultant or whether it's the agreement with Mammoth Mountain that we have to pay the subsidy or whether it's Mono County, the agreement we have in Mono County to be participants.

19:38 or whatever, the strategy plan. I think that's a good recognition of the fact that air is hypersensitive in this community, and we should, as a board, be up to speed at all times on air, what we're doing, what money we're spending, where we're going, what we think about it, what we plan for the future, because, you know, when I circulate around the community, that's what people are interested in. And the board can identify those special interest places? Well, I think it would also go to any of our strategic...

20:05 initiatives, too, like if we're going to appropriate more money for an event site or whatever it may be. I mean, obviously, we need to know why we're doing that and what specifically those funds are going towards. So, yeah, I think that makes perfect sense. Right. Are you looking for a motion? Sure. So, yeah. Go ahead. A couple quick thoughts. So, I would support, you know, looking specifically at the recommendation, I would support item four as written.

20:31 I think that's a big part of our business. So if we have any major changes in a core agency partnership, that should be a discussion for us. So I would support number four as written. I would support number three as written. I appreciate you adding that in. That was kind of based on what we had talked about at the last meeting, that we do have these areas of specific interest that maybe we want to elevate to a higher discussion like TBID or air service or those type of things. I would...

20:59 Second, John, on the idea that I'm into striking item one from the recommendation. And I would support item two, but I would say that we need to put a dollar threshold to that. I'm personally not into micromanaging, and I know that things are going to come up across the course of a year. I think you and your team should have discretion to go out and spend $500 without that having come to...

21:24 Back to the board. So I would suggest that we put a dollar figure, you know, knowing, and maybe we can put this in the verbiage that if there are specific things that you would like to discuss or things that you think are of special interest, even if they're below the threshold, we can bring them to the attention of the board, you know, at your discretion. But I think we should put a dollar figure to item two. And I'm comfortable with 25K, but I'd be looking for the board to say if we'd like that to be lower or higher.

21:53 But I think looking at all these things that we have in that $25K plus category, if we're going to add those in outside of the original discussion, I think that's a good threshold for me. So that would be my recommendation personally. I support what Colin just said about item number one, except I wonder if when these contracts come up or whatever, we could have them on kind of a...

22:20 consent agenda format like they have at Town Council to where, you know, okay, yay, unless somebody has some particular interest in those items and then they say, oh no, I want to discuss blah, blah, blah. That way the board has looked at it, has, you know, acknowledged it and moved on without spending any time unless somebody has some particular interest in it. But that way it doesn't get swept under the rug either. I'm totally good with that suggestion. I mean, I think it works well at Town Council. Yeah.

22:50 It's like, hey, this is the course of our business. As long as nothing's out of whack, we're good with it. Yeah, if everybody's comfortable with it, yay. Yeah, the only other piece that I've put in there, there are a couple of things on that list that just happen to fall in the threshold of this, but like our brochure distribution, I don't know that, I mean, again, if we put it on a consent agenda, it doesn't matter, but it's really just an operating piece. It's not a different contract to think about. No, and...

23:15 Oh, like the printing of the visitor guide. You know, there are a handful of things that don't necessarily fall. I just put them on here because they fell in that threshold. No, but I think that, you know, board has an oversight responsibility, but we can solve that with a consent agenda where these things go, you know, that's fine. And then, you know, it can't be said that we haven't paid attention to our board obligations of financial oversight.

23:44 Okay. But we do it in a certain sense of manner. Do you want me to try some language then? Well, what limit do you want to put on two? I would suggest $25,000. That would be fine. So I would say four stays as, three stays as is. The board reviews any new unbudgeted contracts that come out after the budget has been approved and locked down in excess of $25,000. And then for item one, you know, MLT team includes contracts.

24:13 as a consent agenda item during monthly board reports. And when do you want to identify those areas of special interest? Are they, I mean, we kind of need a list of what to bring you. Yeah. I mean, obviously we know that air is something that we should bring you, but what are the other special interest areas that would come up that we want to identify? Well, I mean, special interest, you're referring to number two? Number three. Number three. Anything that we think is a particular interest to the board or the community that...

24:39 That warrants an elevated discussion. I think most of those are going to end up being over $25,000, whether it's talking about events, whether it's talking about air service, whether it's talking about TBID. So they're probably going to be covered off by the other number two. Yeah, I would think that if there was something regarding air service that was a $20,000, to me that's not going to be a, I mean, I'm not saying $20,000 is nothing, but in the grand scheme of things, that's not a major new direction necessarily that we can.

25:05 Really probably need to, just because it's air service. John, 25,000 here, 25,000 there, the next thing you know, you're talking about real money. Just kidding. Yeah, again, you know, I mean, it's difficult because areas of special interest, to me, it's more those areas of special interest that are above and beyond a certain amount of money because, I mean, everything you do is a special interest. Well, let's assume that something comes up.

25:34 It doesn't meet the threshold, but it involves the outdoor event in space. I think the board might like to hear about that, just because it's good for us to know what's going on with that. That's a sense of a matter. Something to do with the town conference center. You know, those are hot button issues. You know, I think our...

26:02 Managing Director is sufficiently sensitive to what's a hot button issue that we don't have to, you know, we don't have to micromanage him. He can, when he thinks something is sensitive to the board or the community, he can bring it up. And, you know, let's use, as Colin said, let's not micromanage, let's use John's expertise to alert the board to, oh, you know, this is happening. And even if it's not a discussion, just a heads up, that's a good thing. Then we're informed and we know what's going on.

26:30 All right, so then let's refine this a little bit more, and then I guess call a motion. Motion to call? I had one. I'm not sure if I still do. There are only 12 contracts that are between $25,000 and $100,000 on an annual basis. There really are. I mean, the other contracts that we have are under some of those other contracts. Like I said, we have $255,000 in billboards, but it's a contract through Marian Carson, so I don't think we need to get into that minutia. It's actually all part of the line item budget that you had.

27:01 You know, there's some big ticket items. Display advertising is pretty sizable. Search engine marketing is pretty sizable on their own, but they all fall under the Marian Carson contract. Could we, how does this sound? How about if we add language into number three that would be new or additional expenses that have to do with any of our strategic initiatives? Because that covers air service events. Sorry, I'm drawing a complete blank right now.

27:29 Conference. Conference and signage. And those are the main things we've identified that we want to be involved with and so forth. The other stuff is, in my opinion, is more operational. And I think to Paul's point, if we feel that it's something that's going to have controversy or questions behind it, we'll bring it. I think that's fair. You better add to what John said, and or matters at the discretion of the management director. Okay, that's fine. That's just, you know.

28:03 Is it sufficient? Yeah, I think that's a sufficient motion. You know, if everybody's on the same page, understand where we're going with that. Eric, do you have any comments on that? No, I agree with what's been said. So I'll second that. Okay. All right. John, you got the verbiage and all that? Emily, you got the verbiage? Yeah. I got some more in here, so we'll compare it. I've got a bunch written down here. I can't write that fast. Yeah. Okay.

28:31 All right, all in favor? Well, in the way, again, I want to hear the verbiage. Sorry, I heard a second here, but I want to hear it specifically. All right. So item four remains unchanged. So the board ad hoc committee is involved in any major changes to core agency partnerships. Item three is, John, you want to run with that? Yeah, I can say the executive director identifies areas of special interest that require board approval outside of the pre-approved.

29:00 Budget Strategy Planning Ad Hoc Committee may be formed. Okay, I'm good with that. And then item two would say the board reviews any new unbudgeted contracts that come up after budget has been approved and locked down in excess of $25,000. And then item one would say MLT team includes any contracts during monthly board reports as a consent agenda item to inform and educate the board.

29:29 as well as answer any questions about those contracts. So we're not putting a dollar limit on number one? No, because those are all going to be discussed at our strategic meeting and budget allocation where item two addresses anything that comes up outside of that original discussion. Okay. You can keep the 25 in there. I mean, it's not a big deal. Yeah, and so these contract discussions are coming up on a monthly basis as they're being reviewed or one time during the...

29:58 Year during the strategic process? Well, they're always, for the most part, you will see them in the strategic process. You'll see them line itemed in the budget. And what this is saying that we would also basically throw a flag up that in October, Michael's going to sign an agreement with Black Diamond in the UK. It's going to be on a consent agenda. It refers back to the fact that it's budgeted.

30:19 And it would just say that we're spending, you know, our portion of the Black Diamond Agreement is $25,000. And the goal would be to have that on the agenda the month prior to it needing to be signed in case there's questions. It's kind of a consent agenda. No, I get that. I just want to make sure that language is included. Yeah, you're going to get, I mean, at this point, you're going to get it multiple times. You're going to see things two, three times in the process.

30:42 Like I said, all of these agreements, if you look at the budgets that I handed you guys, it's all aligned out. If you look at Michael's international agencies, it's going to tell you exactly who, how much, and when we pay them. Emily, you got that? Got it. Okay. So I'm good with the motion and the second, you know, personally, on that. All in favor? Aye. Motion passes. Next item. Well, I think this is a good step for the board.

31:15 It helps to regularize our procedures and it gives, you know, shame. And this is a good segue too for the next conversation because we have our, I sent it out, it was posted with the agenda packet, our commercial agreement with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Basically the way that our agreement works is that Mammoth Mountain Ski Area actually handles all of the direct contracting with the airlines.

31:45 So with Alaska Airlines, with JetSuite, and with United. And so Mammoth Mountain actually holds the contracts with those. They also hold the liability insurance that's required with those. And with at least United and probably JetSuite, the line of credit, showing that they can cover the funds as needed. And they also end up paying United and JetSuite, United up front, JetSuite, kind of as we go.

32:09 And so what happens at the end of the year, we get the full reconciliation from the airlines as to the subsidy cost for each one. It goes through the accounting department up the mountain and then it comes back and we cut a check for the amount. And so this is really, again, one of those places where it's a renewal. This year's contract, really the only change that we have in it is the addition of JetSuiteX. Eric and I work on when summer ends and winter begins and when summer begins and winter ends as well.

32:39 dates within this cost sharing agreement. I saw that update, that makes sense. Yep, and then this also explains that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is responsible for the first 1.51 million in winter and responsible for the entire summer subsidy. So again, to go back to things like JetSuiteX, if we were to add a new root this year, as long as it falls within the 1.51, that's still our cap. We aren't adding anything at this point, but...

33:05 Then the summer is all of our responsibility, and this even recognizes that Mono County, any participation that we can get from Mono County is welcome as well. The participation from Mono County tends to diminish what our obligation is? Yeah, it's been $50,000 a year for the last, I want to say four or five years. It was $85,000 for a couple of years, and then this year we asked them again for $100,000 worth of support, and they have their budget meetings next Tuesday.

33:34 The percentages that Mammoth Mountain Ski Area has paid has changed over the years, hasn't it? That they've paid? Yeah, and I guess what I'm asking is, has it always been that MLT has paid the first $1.5 million? Since the TBID. Okay. That's part of the TBID ruling. But the Management District Plan outlines that we're $1.5 million, $1.51 million in the wintertime, all of the summer subsidy. What was it before the TBID? It was me with a tin cup.

34:01 Trying to get as much money out of the town, the county, the mountain, and whatever else we had. So there was not an agreement with the Mammoth Mountain Skier before the TBID? No, because we didn't have a committed amount at that point. The mountain was contracted with the airlines specifically and upheld that liability to the airlines individually. There wasn't another party to it. We're looking for a motion here too.

34:29 Yeah, again, this is one of those contracts because, you know, typically we end up paying out, you know, a fair amount of money between the contract. It's been lower than the budgeted amount. You know, we've been 1.5 million, this year was 1.1. Last year was, I think, 800,000, 600,000, so it was well below the number. But we do this annually. So we do the contract annually, we have the agreement annually, we change the dates so that they reflect the summer and the winter, the new dates as we move forward, and any new routes that we plan or add.

34:59 I'll make a motion to approve the contract with MSA, the air service contract, as written. Second. All those in favor? Discussion. Any further discussion? Go ahead. No, go ahead. Okay. So if JetSuiteX adds another town, they would expect additional subsidies for that, right?

35:28 There would be a minimum guarantee. Yeah, I'm sorry. Okay. But that, you know, that would basically, once we're at our 1.51, it would fall on Mammoth. Yes. And that's when we added JetSuite last year. That was one piece of understanding that we had to make sure was clear that we could add 15 more routes if the mountain comes back and says, hey, we want to add JetSuite in...

35:52 San Jose and Orange County and Carlsbad and all these other places, that's great. We're still capped at the 1.5 as long as we feel that's worth our effort even up to the 1.5. The flip side is that the mountain decides what routes or airlines to add. No. We do it together. Eric and I work very closely together with Kent Myers, who's our air.

36:14 Supplier Consultant. And we actually also work very closely with Grady at the town because the other piece of it is we can't add more flights than can be handled by the staff at the airport. And we've even talked about, you know, if we had a jet suite flight, can we add it at 8 a.m.? And the airport says, well, we don't have people in there to take care of runways and blah, blah, blah, blah, so it's going to add this cost. So it's a major discussion. So it's not just the mountain saying, hey, we want to fly here. So the bottom line is any changes to service is a joint discussion. Correct. Okay. I just...

36:44 Yeah, I don't have an ax to grind. I just didn't know how it worked. Yeah. And, you know, presumably this is not the place for this discussion. I'm comfortable with all the contract stuff. But at some point we will have, you know, when we get the consulting work back, we'll have a broader board discussion about air strategic direction in general. That's going to be a much broader discussion than just this board. That'll be town, mountain, maybe even Nino County at that point. Sure.

37:09 But we'll do that separately. This is just really renewing the contract. This is service. Yeah, this is air service. The strategic plan is... The strategic plan, I mean, it could come out and tell you that if you paint the airport purple, it's going to make a difference with wind. But, you know, that has nothing to do with us on our regular contracting here. Now, if we get down the road and we start to say, okay, Inyo County looks like it's an opportunity and XYZ is going to happen down there, then we have to...

37:34 Add that in. And effectively, the only change Y over Y is adjusting the summer dates. Adjusting the summer dates and then adding in the JetSuite X language. Really? All right. Yep. Well, the summer, just the start and end of season dates, yes. Yeah. Okay. Any further discussion? Yes. Good job. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. I'll abstain. You want abstention? All right. Hey, that was within time. What do you know? There you go.

38:12 The next piece is a conversation I had with Mayor Wentworth the other day regarding kind of going back to our discussion about the recalibration efforts that he and Colin put together and really talking about the future of the shared bucket, let's call it that. And so as we start to move into the new fiscal year, the monies from the previous fiscal year right up until Q4 will go into our reserve, but this new bucket is going to start accumulating funds

38:42 You know, July was well over budget. That'll start accumulating dollars in our favor, and that's something that he would like to get together a group to talk about the direction and the priorities and where those funding mechanisms are going to go. So we want to appoint a couple members from this board to participate in that conversation, and that'll be an ongoing committee, I would imagine. I think it's probably something that's going to meet. My guess is it may meet quarterly, but more likely maybe twice a year. I think that's to be determined.

39:11 Since I've been involved in those discussions to some degree, I'd be happy to volunteer for that. And, you know, I'm going to be part of that discussion as well, but I can do that on the town council side. I don't know if you wanted me to do both roles. So just get a second board member there. Okay. And Ledesma was involved in the initial conversations, but I'm not sure whether there's anyone else that wants to throw their hat into the conversation or? I'd like to nominate Ledesma.

39:39 There you go. I'll second. Nominate the guy who isn't here. That's what happens when you miss a mistake. He was involved in the process, so I think that makes sense.

39:51 And again, I don't think it's going to be a huge burden on time. He may not remember, but he told me. He'll remember when you tell him. He's a financial strategy genius. Yes, he is. Remember that time? Guess what? Any further discussion on that matter? No, I think the only thing to add to that is, you know, in addition to having conversations moving forward about how we allocate those dollars that go into that bucket, you know, I think it's going to be important for the board.

40:19 And Council to have those continued discussions about the actual allocation of the dollars that we've earmarked for those specific purposes. So, you know, as we've set money aside for wayfinding, you know, we need to have a joint conversation about actually getting to the point where we implement that and spend those dollars. So I think the strategic direction that we've already discussed and allocated dollars for will be a part of that discussion as well. And I think associated with that, we had a meeting today to talk about wayfinding and I think we'll have Hayes.

40:48 from the town, do a presentation to the board, probably in December, at our December board meeting, which may have some dollars attached to it, because we've got dollars set aside, and he'll be explaining the whole project, what it's going to take, the phases, the timeline, and the budgets needed, and then I think that's an opportunity for us to say, okay, we're going to set aside X, Y, and Z, whether it's, it's probably going to be at the January meeting after he makes that presentation, but that'll better inform the board. Okay. Okay. So,

41:20 Want to vote on those two? Yeah, make a motion that we appoint John Morris and Michael Ledesma as the two board members to the Town Council MLT Financial Strategy Panel. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. TBID appeal panel, John, do you want to? Sure. So we had the TBID appeal panel was myself, Kirk, and Paul, and we met briefly to discuss two TBID appeals. One is

41:53 Josh Slater, who is the bear carver, he is taking a hiatus from carving but wants to stay involved, wants to pay into the TBID and is well, well under the $50,000 threshold for Tier 3 but wants to stay involved, wants to keep his business license so he is willing to volunteer basically to pay $50 Tier 3 to stay in and we have supporting documentation that

42:19 That states that. So that would be case number one. We want to vote on these single one by one. So our recommendation would be to allow... Does he have an official? Is it Bear Carver? Bear Carver? Official name of the company? Is it Bear Essentials? Bear Essentials? No, I think. I think I would not. Bear in mind. Bear in mind. Bear in mind. Bear in mind to be at tier three at this point. That would be our recommendation. Discussion? Any further discussion? Do we need a motion for this? Yeah, do we?

42:52 I don't know if we do or not. Call each one. Okay, so the second is Ridge Marino. It's an athletic base layer company. Same sort of situation. They're well under $50,000, and there's still some determination as to exactly how much of their sales are wholesale or not, but their gross is well, well under the $50,000 cap. And again, same situation. They're looking to pay $50 for Tier 3 at this point, and our recommendation would be to accept that.

43:20 Is that their local sales level? Yes, local. Gotcha. Yeah, their internet stuff is... Right. So whatever they do here locally, physically in the location is what they're talking about. Okay. So those are the two appeals that we had, and our recommendations are to accept both of them at the Tier 3 level. Any further discussions, questions? I'll make a motion that the board approves both applicants' Tier 3 and $50 fee. Second. All those in favor? Aye.

43:54 Aye. Item number six. It's all you. Executive Director, performance review and discussion and vote. All right. All board members received a review. They got it all back, tabulated those, and we have the findings. I do believe that everybody received an email copy. Sorry, I don't have

44:36 One in print for you now. Got a question here with the slash. What does the two different numbers mean? Okay, the one on the left is the average of the board members, and the one on the right is John Urdi's assessment. Okay. And then also on the bottom with how it's written there, you kind of go in order of, for instance, looking at three biggest opportunities to focus on next year.

45:21 In order of mention, I kind of made some hash marks and see where things were obviously across the board here. And so these were the highlights. And the second one, I think hopefully that makes sense, what was done well and what needs improvement. Probably read them off if you want. Yeah, if you'd like, I can certainly do that. Well, let's start then with three biggest opportunities to focus on next year.

45:54 So in the order of mention, we have transparency slash local influencers, tone of MLT and local media. Then came air, events, wayfinding, TBID renewal and shoulder seasons as the most popular picks. But has the board done well and what needs improvement? What we've done well, we felt that we've helped MLT succeed.

46:24 and not micromanage. Felt that we were good with oversight. What we felt that needed improvement was to be more active. Many felt that we needed more oversight. Also, stronger in decision-making and to be more assertive and act as ambassadors for our constituencies. Should we go with any questions on that or you just want me to keep on reading through? Yeah, let's just finish it up and we'll go back. Sounds good.

46:56 What would you like to see from the board in the future? The comments were the board should be more active, action making, more involvement, and then we should also provide clear direction and communication. And lastly, what do you see as John Urdi and or Mammoth Lakes Tourism's key accomplishments? And these were all across, not so much across the board, but basically equal in ranking. The website.

47:26 Global recognition by visitors and industry, the consistent visitation in the shoulder seasons, TOT, I think it speaks for itself, and overall it was a good team. Do you want to go through the results on this or do we have to? I guess my only comment would be I think that most of these, you know, I don't know how many were, 20 checkpoints, most of them were fairly close.

48:02 I guess my one question would be is how is it not a five on increased TOT receipts? That's 4.61 from the board. I gave myself a five on hitting 18.1 million. I gave you a five, John. What's your number, John? Thank you, Colin. Just under business results, increased TOT receipts. John, this is like a review on Amazon. You know, you'll get 150 people who give it five stars, and there's always a couple of people out there going, oh, no, you know.

48:30 I'm sorry, we'll hit $25 million next year? Is there one board member that had a bad year? John, I think that, you know, you have definitely increased TOT. Your entire team has done an outstanding job in increasing TOT and increasing visitation. Visitation is up across the West. And, you know, the question that does come back regularly is, could it be more?

48:52 And I don't think that you should take that as any kind of insult whatsoever. Again, huge accolades, and anytime anybody asks, how is MLT doing, look at the results. We've broken records year after year. But with regard to asking why isn't it a perfect 100% score, you know, the question is always going to be there. Can we do more? Yeah, it was more tongue-in-cheek, but I just figured that we'd be.

49:16 No, agreed, and I'd like to second what you said there, Sean. I think in tabulating some of these things and averaging up, it's kind of like the Olympics. You know, you can't just come out and give the first competitor a 10 because what if the next one's better? Then where do you go? So anyway, that's my five cents on that. Got it. 10 plus. I think the other thing is not so much can we do better. I'm sure we can. But can we do better at a...

49:45 Getting the town to understand the relationship between the increase in TOT and MLT's efforts. I think we have a lot of room to improve there. Yeah, and that was in my self-review. That was probably the biggest thing that I said was still in need of improvement is really just getting that message out there. And I know that that's a big concern of the board or a big effort of the board. And I think it also goes back to the board member comments or the...

50:13 What the board should be helping us with is that ambassador piece. So I agree and I think that that's a major piece. We've had the discussion as a team. We're hosting the community coffees on a monthly basis now to talk with people about things. We have the open houses that we've been doing over the past few years. You know, the new five and five email that goes out. So we're trying to get that word out there and I think we're always open to more other ways to get it out there. So I think that we recognize that that's a big piece that we need to.

50:42 Start focusing on more? Yeah, I mean, it's always, it's foolish to attribute the successes to any one thing. I mean, obviously, there's lots of different factors involved with how, why we, as a town, are doing better and businesses are doing better, but it is important for the community to understand MLT's part of that and how MLT does push that agenda forward and helps to grow, along with, you know, other things that are, some factors that are beyond our control. But certainly, you know, MLT plays a large role in that.

51:11 And I think that answers the three biggest opportunities piece, the transparency, local influencers, tone. You know, the air, obviously we're working on the 10-year strategic plan for air events. We'll set the meeting for that group to convene in the next few weeks. Wayfinding, obviously we're down the road with that, and TBID renewal is now less than 12 months away.

51:33 And shoulder seasons, we've gone from six months of a million dollars to nine months of a million dollars with, I really do think that October is our next million dollar month, whether it's this year or next year, it's going to come pretty quick. Yeah, I think, you know, my just comments in general, you know, as someone that's done a lot of different evaluations and different organizations and directors, I think, first of all, this is a really well done document. I mean, I think it's well laid out.

52:00 It's easy to kind of follow, and I think it does a good job of assessing. You know, one of the things that I always look at, you know, when we're evaluating Dan or something is when he does his own self-evaluation of the areas where we're off, right? And, you know, I looked at that too. And most of these fall within a pretty close range. The two that were about a point off were...

52:27 Under organizational, develop staff through timely and consistent goal setting, evaluation, coaching, and if necessary, correction. The board had it at 3.97. John had it at a 5. I'm going to respectfully disagree with the board on that one. I believe I had that at a 5 as well. I think that's one of John's strengths. I think that you do create a good team.

52:53 You know, I've talked to a lot of your staff members. They enjoy working for MLT. They don't feel like they're micromanaged by you, but they feel like you set consistent goals, let them do their job, and check in with them when necessary. So, you know, I think maybe the board.

53:09 That's my personal opinion was off on that one. The other one where we had a fairly large discrepancy was under business results, 2.78 versus four and the increased awareness and usage of air service. I would actually kind of tend to fall in the board category there. I had that as a two. And I think that that is an area that we as a board acknowledge that we are not doing a tremendous job with is the air service component. And I think we're putting the...

53:37 pieces together to move that forward and improve that. But I think that's an area where we need to improve. And really, you know, across the board for me, you know, most of the scores were pretty strong, fours and fives, a couple threes here and there. But, you know, that was the only two I gave out under business results was the air service side of things.

53:57 And then the only other two I gave out, I believe, across the board period was the media public awareness. I think that's an area where we need improvement as an organization. I think there's a lot of people in the public sphere that remain skeptical or uninformed, and I think that's a significant challenge for this board moving forward to improve that. So those were kind of the two major areas of improvement for me, and I just thought it was interesting that we had kind of a discrepancy there under the business results as far as the difference.

54:27 Yeah, and I may have scored myself too high on that, but I think that, you know, the piece I was focusing on there more than was the minimizing of the subsidy cost with us being at, you know, less than half of our budget two fiscal years ago and then, you know, 60% of our budget this year for winter being able to minimize that cost while still, you know, being fairly consistent with the, I mean, obviously we want to bring a lot more people in here, but.

54:53 Yeah, and I think that's a fair statement, you know, that if you were focusing on the minimizing subsidy costs of that, that might be a different score than the increasing awareness and usage of air service, and that's where my focus was, and that's why I scored it a two. So I think, you know, maybe we could work on the verbiage for that specific item, because those are...

55:13 Almost opposing ideals a little bit. But, you know, for me personally, my focus was on the first half of that, which is why I scored it differently. But I think it's good to see that the board and John are relatively on the same page around, you know, areas for improvement and areas where we're doing things well. Well, I think we really recognize that one of our, that probably our biggest challenge has been how do we...

55:38 How do we move air service forward? And obviously we're taking those steps now. I agree. To really look at that and say before we renew the TBID and put X amount into for 10 years, are we absolutely going in the right direction, in the right place with the right components and stuff? And that's a strong statement going forward. So that's good. We are working with Embark Aviation. They're here Friday for a full sit down with us to really hash out where we're going next year with them.

56:04 I think one of the areas that I highlight is one of John's strengths is under organizational. I give a five for creating and maintaining appropriate staff with the skills to execute key responsibilities. Personally, I think that's just a major strong suit for the organization. I think you've hired really good people and they do their job really well and everybody kind of understands their lane and executes. The other thing that I just thought of worth note was

56:33 I think increasing TOT receipts was a five for me, and I think we've just done an incredible job being a part of the whole community, increasing the shoulder season visitation and TOT receipts, but we're definitely a part of that. And the last one that I just wanted to kind of give you kudos for is I gave a five under financial management for town contract. I think that was...

56:56 Not an easy process. And I think you did a really good job of navigating that process, you know, protecting MLT's interests at the same time, you know, recognizing that we have broader community needs. And I think that that could have been a really, really, you know, potentially a contentious process. And I don't think it was. I think you did a really good job of kind of navigating that process. So I just wanted to give you kudos for that. But that's all I had for mine.

57:26 I think Colin's summary was excellent. It really covered the point. I think there's a lot of agreement among the board as to what Colin was focusing on. Obviously, the thing that gets our go to air service, getting that right, that's where the organization and the board need to focus on short-term and long-term. And if there's something out there that affects the public more than air service, I don't know what it is. They're very sensitive to that.

57:56 Something struck me, though. And the other point, of course, was, you know, how do we get our message out there better to the local public? Something that John said kind of struck me. He said, well, you know, there are a lot of factors in our success besides MLT, which is true. But I think we're at a point now where we can go to the public and say, you know, some people said it was gas prices, and other people said, well, it's not a lot last year. But we're at a point now where we've had so many years.

58:25 of success, of increasing record year, year after year after year. After a while, you can't point to outside factors and say, oh, it was the gas prices or it snowed this year, because that was only one year out of many now. We've got to get out there and get our message to the public saying, gee, we've got five record years. We've gone from six months to nine months. That's a big deal. But I don't think the public knows it.

58:53 And months like June and September and October really don't have a whole lot to do with snow. Not generally. Not generally, never know. And that's the point. Our future, our base income is dependent on the winter months and skiing, but our future is tied up in moving to those 10, 11 months of full usage because, I mean, that's where we really succeed or fail.

59:22 We have all that infrastructure in place for 12 months, pay all that overhead for 12 months, and only by finding a way to use that infrastructure and overhead can we ever really experience success. I mean, I thought Michael Ledesma gave a very moving presentation when he said, you know, I hire all these people in June, and then I gotta let them go in September. And I hire all these people in November, and I gotta let them go in April.

59:48 I mean, that's, you know, tremendously rough on everybody. The effort the Mountain puts into hiring and firing people must be just enormous. And every business in town. I mean, Colin probably hires a zillion people in the fall and lets them go in the spring. Expanding our income to cover 12 months, if, you know, if this organization accomplishes that.

1:00:14 That's a very big deal, but if we don't do a better job of getting the word out, I mean, I think it's very important because our funding is totally dependent on the approval of the public. If we don't have the public understanding what our function is, sooner or later, we'll get tripped up. I think our continued happy existence and funding, I mean, look at the town council.

1:00:41 You know, they start looking, gee, we need money for this and that, and let's look at MLT, because gosh, they got some money. That's natural. I'm not criticizing Colin or the council. That's a natural thing to do, and when you have a lack of understanding about the contribution this organization makes, it leaves us wide open to getting hit for that. Yeah, and I think that's very well articulated. That's why I put that as a two, because I think the...

1:01:07 The PR piece of that communication effort has not been something that we've executed well as a board. And, you know, John, I know you heard me whine about this in the past, and I do because I think it's kind of, you know, it doesn't pop up on a regular basis. It's not like a contract that comes up every year, but it's something that's lurking out there that we've got to deal with and deal with it successfully to guarantee our success moving into future years.

1:01:37 Otherwise, we become everybody's target for, gosh, we need money for housing, let's take it from MLT. These organizations do need money, and they're worthy organizations, but if we're the Christmas tree, sooner or later, I'll be back. I think the board's done a great job of focusing on the things that are actual issues and congratulating you where you've done good stuff and focusing on the things that need improvement.

1:02:04 You know, a double TOT next year would be nice, but we don't need to focus on that. You're doing that. We focused on the stuff that we really need to, and it's the board's responsibility, so I think we've done a good job of that. You know, I'd like to add to that. I mean, the success of this organization kind of parallels the exercise of this assessment.

1:02:29 In that, you know, we've just discussed many things, many contributing factors to the success and solvency of this town. You could say snow, you could say this, you could say that. But it's a slow-moving machine. Over the course of years, you know, this is an average rate of return, and it's steadily gone up. Next year could be a little bit down, hopefully not too much. Gosh forbid, it would be nice to go back to back to back. But it's just...

1:02:59 You know, it's easy to focus on some of those little things, but overall that gets kind of lost in the wash when you look at it. And if you have some consistent growth, I think that's really the proof of the success. I mean, I think I could be off on the numbers. There's a lot of numbers in my head at all times. But if you look at the, you know, average from 2010 to 2015, I think it's like 10.3.

1:03:28 So actually, I've looked back to, if you go from fiscal 04-05 to fiscal 14-15, the average is 10-4-49. Right, so 10-3, 10-4, and then the last couple years have been 15-7 and 18. So something is happening as a community where we're pushing that out, we're getting better shoulder season visitation, we're driving better yield and better ADRs. I mean, those are all positive things over the last couple years, I think.

1:03:55 You know, if you look back at a bad snow year in 2011, I mean, we were in serious jeopardy of being down in the $9, $10 million TOT range. I think we've raised our basement as a community. So, you know, there's going to continue to be volatility. There's going to be, you know, highs and lows. But I think we've raised kind of the low end, which is a really critical thing because that's when...

1:04:20 I mean, fortunately, I've sat on a council where we haven't had to deal with that, but that's when you get into slash and burn mode. I mean, if we go back to $10 million in TOT, we're going to have some significant challenges and have to make a lot of hard decisions, so I don't want to see that happen again. I think that was the year that I always look at is 2012-13, the mountain had gone. I think they had lost about 300,000 or 400,000 visits, and we missed budget by

1:04:51 300,000 bucks because we're not a one-trick pony anymore. And I think that was really one of the biggest things that we talked about when I came on board here seven years ago was that, you know, we can, we can, we have to, we have to be able to survive not having a good winter. It's weatherproofing. Yeah, weatherproofing is important. And I think John's right about that. And I think, though, that when you look in the crystal ball to the future, what you'll see is that our, you know,

1:05:22 John has fixed a lot of things with our presentation of the outside world. And he's going to continue to do that, and that's great, and that will continue to rise in TOT and so forth. But if you say, you know, how long can we keep going up? I think the answer to that is we can keep going up only if we start to do a better job of improving our infrastructure here in town.

1:05:50 We need that outdoor event. Well, we've got our outdoor event space. We need that to work. We have to do more about Main Street. There are a lot of things physically about Mammoth that are not consistent with a high-producing tourist town like a Park City or a Telluride or whatever. And we have to fix that stuff.

1:06:19 It's not possible for the individual businessman acting on his own to do that. We have to provide the think tank ability to help the whole town, townwide, to figure out how to deal with those things. Sidewalks on Main Street are going to be a huge step forward. And getting rid of the Mammoth 405, you know, running up Main Street.

1:06:43 You know, that huge highway, that's going to help. But we have to look at stuff like that and help the town and the town council to work out solutions because if we don't do it, where else does it come from? You know, we don't have a town organization like MLT that, you know, the future of Mammoth. We don't have an organization. We are that organization.

1:07:04 We've got to figure out that stuff. And I think that's where our Achilles heel is, is that we've got infrastructure issues that we have to look at hard and figure out how to fix. Our list of four items is great. Outdoor events, the conference center, signage, and airport, those are critical stuff that this organization can make a huge contribution on and has. I mean, this organization was critical in seeing to it that the outdoor...

1:07:31 Event Center happened. I don't think, I think it's, is it fair to say, John, it would not have happened without us? I think it's very fair to say. So, you know, that's what we're supposed to be doing, and I see it becoming more and more critical. As John fixes the stuff that he can do with marketing, it's going to fall back on us to fix the internal town stuff that marketing can't fix, because John can get millions of people here, but if they don't like what they see, they ain't coming back. Well, I think it's important to recognize that

1:08:00 I think my opinion is that the main function is to keep driving the revenues so that the revenues are there available to be able to do those. You know, we can make recommendations as a board, but the council, the manager, and the town are the ones that have to actually implement these things. But it's really critical, obviously, without the funds, those things can't get done. And that's one of the nice things we've seen. Sidewalk improvements, the parking lot, the various things we've talked about over the last year or so. Those infrastructure improvements have been in part.

1:08:29 you know, been able to be accomplished because there have been more funds available because the town gets, keeps 65 or whatever percent of the increased TOT. John, there are those who would argue that we have poured a huge amount of money in terms of TOT into the town's coffers and it's about to be spent on a facility that there are those who would argue won't contribute to our terrorist economy and that could mean that this board hasn't been sufficiently

1:08:57 vocal or communicative to avoid that sort of thing. And I do think that's where the board could come in handy because I think when we look at, you know, with the increases that we had this year with the town hitting, you know, just shy of $18.1 million, I think there's a lot of, there are a lot of folks looking to MLT to solve the visitation problems, whether it's toilets, trails, housing, whatever it is. I think this board does need to look at the fact that the town was $6.5 million over budget.

1:09:26 And there needs to be discussion that says that if we have problems with toilets, the town's keeping four and a half million dollars roughly of that money. We need to start addressing the things that are giving us the success, the issues that come with the success. The byproduct of being so successful is we have issues with not having enough restrooms in the lakes basin or we don't have enough parking somewhere. I think people are coming to MLT to solve that problem and I think that the funds...

1:09:50 The larger funds go to the town. I think it does need to be very vocalized to the town that, you know, if we're going to continue to invite people to come here, we need to answer these questions because God knows that the town's probably got a list 52 pages long of deferred maintenance of a roof on a shack at Whitmore. You know, I mean, but I think we really need to be very vocal to say if we want to continue to invite people here, these are the problems that we're seeing from the increased visitation. These are some of the solutions that could come from it.

1:10:17 And I've had that conversation with Colin, I've had that conversation with the mayor, because, you know, how much is it to build a new restroom in the lake space? And is it 50 grand? 60 grand? I have no idea. But with the money that we have right now, that needs to be considered. If we want to continue to invite the amount of people we are, then we need to start that facility fixing. The town is, the town council is constrained to the extent that

1:10:45 The town population has to understand that connection. And we're the ones who have to go out there as ambassadors to get people. The council can't do that. We have to go out there as ambassadors to get people to understand the connection between having tourist-oriented facilities and having TOT income. And once people understand that, they can give, in effect, the OK to the town council to spend money on those things. But until that understanding is out there, there's huge pressure to spend it on a whole bunch of other stuff.

1:11:16 So I think the board has a tremendous role to play in ensuring the future not only of MLT but of Mammoth as well. Gentlemen, I'd like to interject here. I want to keep us on track. I believe we have half an hour left of this meeting. And I'm concerned that we're not going to address all the other issues. Do we have any further discussion?

1:11:43 Yeah, I just got a couple of comments. And, John, you know, I gave some high marks on some things and lower marks on others. I'm glad to see that we're all kind of within the same ballpark. I did want to make a comment with regard to the marketing plan. You know, one of the first questions that I was looking for here was the quality of the marketing message. And we don't have that on here as a ranked...

1:12:10 Question. And I'm wondering if how difficult it is, you know, it was nice having last year's results to be able to look, have we improved or have we not improved? But is that something that we can add into for future years? I guess I'm, I'd wonder what we're looking at, because I mean, we do all of the awareness studies and the ROIs. I don't know what, what, what specifically you're looking for. Let's talk about that. You know, I've made it clear that I'm not a big fan of no small adventure.

1:12:38 And the response has come back as that's your opinion. You need to trust the experts. Got it. At the same time, we are a board of directors of local business owners who do have a vested interest in what our message is going out there. And whether it's determined by an LA firm in LA or whether we're able to utilize 20-something influencers in our social media message.

1:13:02 At the same time, I think that we do have a responsibility as well as an honest opinion, whatever you want to call it, that goes into what we want said about our town. So whether it is a comment of, I would like to see something other than no small adventure, then that's something that I would like MLT, the staff of, to at least hear.

1:13:28 And, you know, it's not necessarily being critical of the staff of MLT, but maybe being able to pass that message on to Marianne Carson or whoever is coming up with the expressions, hashtag no small adventure. So I think that it's quite appropriate to be able to ask the question, what do you think of the quality of our marketing message? Now, let me just finish up. Can I ask it of the nine-member board? Yes, please. And let me just, and let me be clear on that. We just got a great...

1:13:56 recognition for how our message is put out there into the public. We just got the best award for a website in the United States. Yeah. Rock on for us. That's great. And congratulations again to staff for MLT and everything that we've done with really putting that message out there. But I would actually like to focus more on can we get some kind of comments to you in this kind of review here?

1:14:25 that says what is the quality of our marketing message? Sure. Absolutely. I mean, we're welcome to the input. I think that my response would be with the research that we do on the awareness of the campaign, the successes of the campaign, from a branding standpoint, you don't want to change your messaging every two years because then you lose traction. More than happy to take any opinions and comments.

1:14:47 As well, I hope that the board recognizes the awareness results from around the country that are not our opinion, that are not Marion Carson's opinion, that show that the program works and people will recall it and it's obviously produced the results. Could they be higher? I'm sure anything could be higher. I think switching the message would be a mistake, but that's just...

1:15:09 Branding and marketing 101. I understand. And you know what? Again, I want to be very clear. I trust the experts very much. But at the same time, I don't think that it's inappropriate for the nine board member made up of community business owners to be able to weigh in on what the comments or what the actual marketing message is. And again, it's no slight against the staff at MLT. It's merely just asking for that kind of opinion.

1:15:36 One other comment that I did want to ask is on the create marketing plan and secure approval prior to the start of each marketing season. My understanding on that was that we create, and what I guess I read into this, is that we do see a budget strategy and it's more budget oriented. Really at the beginning or going, I guess at the end of the fiscal year that we're talking about, approving the budget going forward into the future years.

1:16:05 When you say secure approval prior to the start of each season, this is referring more to the approval of the overall strategy in the budget. So the meetings that we have with Marian Carson, Miles, and Lyman, the one where they present all of the different strategies moving forward, and that's the first step, and then the second step is approving the line item budget. Okay.

1:16:27 So I don't necessarily see that as securing approval for what the marketing message is, but more along the lines of what the strategy might be or what the budget might be. And I just, I think I could use a little bit more clarification in what that grading scale would be. Okay. I didn't create this document, so. Okay. Who did create this document? That was going to be one of my questions. I think, I think it might have been around for years. I think it might have been about five years ago. So one very quick comment on that.

1:16:57 I put a question mark. Other business, one no answer, two to four retail restaurant lacking. I have no idea what that means. So we might want to edit that one. Down there in a community business. Other business. I could only come up with a question mark. Oh, by the way. I'm guessing those were old notes from a previous review.

1:17:21 So I gave that a... When a question was, I'd like to interject that when a question was not answered, I excluded that from... The average? The average. And so divided by the amount of responses. You didn't give it a zero there. I did not give it a zero. No. To further dilute. Yeah, I mean, these are created by the board. You guys can review these and change these and adjust these as you see fit. John, no small adventure. Was that from staff or was that from Marion Carson?

1:17:50 That was from a combination. So that Marian Carson came to town and interviewed frontline staff around town. You know, bartenders, hotel owners, everybody, locals, and really got a feeling from everyone. Went through an entire process that came up with this being California's Mother Nature's playground. And then from that, decided that the No Small Adventure campaign fit well because everything's outside your door. The whole idea is that there's so much to do here that...

1:18:17 It's all within a mile of wherever you're standing. And so the No Small Adventure campaign came out of that. If we wanted to have a discussion about it, that would be appropriate to have when Marian Carson was here. I think that would be more appropriate to have way, way, way before that. Because at that point, the strategy session, they're presenting the strategy for the year, not a time to throw them a curveball and say, hey, we want to change the campaign. Okay, so.

1:18:44 That's what I wanted to understand. When is the appropriate time to discuss it? Well, and I think that we've had the No Small Adventure campaign now for four years, I think, five years, maybe, four years. And I think that the idea now would be, OK, let's take a look at it and see. I mean, the results have been excellent, I think. But let's look at, is it time to renew it, review it, or throw it away, or what's the deal? And I don't think that that's unfair to ask. OK, but what I'm saying is, when do we discuss that, assuming we're going to?

1:19:13 Sooner than later. Sooner than later. Okay. Given Sean's interest in it, and I think the board's general responsibility on it, it's something you would calendar for us. We definitely could. I think the things to keep in mind is that we've got a lot of investment into art. We've got a lot of investment into design time that we don't want to shift gears too early. No, we don't want to change anything willy-nilly. Right. And while on one hand, you and I have talked about it, I have some concerns.

1:19:43 You can't argue with success, but you can understand success, you can talk about it, you can discuss it. You know, that's one of the board's jobs is to look at our major strategy and, you know, be comfortable with it or not or make fine-tuned adjustments or make no adjustments. So if you would put that on the calendar sometime, we could talk about it. Yeah, I mean, my suggestion, again, would be sooner than later. I'd even try and see if there's something we could do in December to get Marion Carson here to...

1:20:11 Have that conversation and just either reinforce Wyatt.

1:20:15 Makes sense to continue where we're going or why we have two more years of success with this and then we should shift gears. You know, there's got to be a little bit of planned obsolescence into it so that this isn't the campaign that's going to do this forever, but it's just a question of how long does it need to have a useful life so that it doesn't cost us money. You said something earlier that I really want to be clear on too. I love the analytics that come out of Marion Carson and, you know, what's the success rate. Smari. Smari. Smari.

1:20:41 Whatever it is. I mean, I really do appreciate being able to read what's being effective, that kind of thing. So I just wanted to be clear on that. It's just, you know, we may have disagreements on what do we do with that information. So, anyway, that's my one stay in. I know we need to move on. John. Very good. Just to weigh in on that one, too. I agree with Sean that the board should have a connection to any tagline that we're going to have with our company or what we're searching with our business.

1:21:10 And I think probably every three to five years, I think it's probably revisited. I've been a part of these discussions before, even much larger scales, and nobody ever agrees on what that tag is necessarily going to be, so you will never get 100% buy-in. But I would just say for No Small Adventure and all the other tags that we've used over the last 48 months, I've liked all of them.

1:21:37 No Small Adventure for me personally has been phenomenal. I wouldn't change a thing. Now, from where we started to where we are, now do we change that at the five-year mark? Because it's getting stale, different issue. But I just want to go on record as saying I've really resonated and connected with No Small Adventure and all of the kind of like the cartoon, visit transparency characters we've done and the tags that have gone along with them.

1:22:05 Yeah, and we can work with Marion Carson and get their thoughts on when we should be considering a relaunch or a change or new focus. Yeah. It might be that it is five years and that's a useful life of the campaign, but we can definitely follow up with them. Very good. Shall we move on, gentlemen? I was going to say. So where are we now? With items six and seven, have we, I think we've exhausted the time on that aloud. Do you want to,

1:22:37 I'm sorry? How did you get six and seven? What did I do? He's on six. Well, yeah, we were on six. No, I know, but how did you? Never mind. Oh, how did I get this? I'm missing a dot. Yeah, you are. You got something more than I do. All right. That's nice. Welcome, Eric Clark's not on mine. Welcome, Eric Clark. Ah, there we go. And just to be clear, I did not participate in the review. Yes, absolutely. So I couldn't add any comments to that, but have some thoughts for the next meeting. Sounds good.

1:23:08 So then item six is actually item seven. Yeah, I mean, I don't think there's a need for executive session unless you talked about everything here. Shall we go into the presentation? We have to cover a couple things in finance. If Josh can do lightning round? Or do you want to do financial and end that? Speed dating, Josh. Make it brief.

1:23:43 But I am excited to present this presentation to you guys. We've seen a lot of substantial growth in our social program in the past year. And I'll be comparing last year quarter four to this year quarter four in the numbers that you're going to see. But again, big, big growth for us this past year. Just as a refresher, these are the channels that we're active on. These are the channels that I'm engaging with on a daily basis. And then I've broken it down to we have the Visit Mammoth channels on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter.

1:24:13 and crib channels as well. Those are specific and separate channels themselves. And then both the crib and visit Mammoth content come underneath the YouTube channel. Okay, and these are our social media goals for each channel broken down. In the past year with the website launch, we really wanted to bring more focus to the website, drive more visitation to the website, and of course more traffic. And one way to do that was through including links and URLs into our posts on Facebook and on Twitter.

1:24:43 And we've seen huge growth in website traffic, and you'll see that broken down in the next slide, and very excited to share that with you. But yeah, these are the goals broken down in each channel specifically. We've gone over this in previous presentations in the past, and if you guys have any questions about this presentation, we can hold them until the end. That way I can make sure I get through them. So this is our social media scorecard.

1:25:09 And this is, again, this is the piece that I'm very excited to show you guys. And it just really breaks down the big numbers, the big growth that we've seen in the past year when you're comparing quarter four last year to quarter four this year. Quarter four on the top there, 48,000 fans, 410 down to 97,000 fans in quarter four. Posts, we've increased the amount of posts that we're posting to each channel substantially. You'll see 939 last year, 1,600.

1:25:33 Posts this year. Megan, Miranda, and I are working together. She's creating web driving posts that are stemmed from our content on our blog program, and so that is specific to the web driving posts, and those are for our Facebook, Twitter, and now we're doing Instagram with the launch of Instagram stories and be able to link out from there. Messages received, these are messages that I'm interacting with on a daily basis. Sometimes I wake up to 400 messages on Sprout, which is the analytic program that we're using to engage with, schedule out, and report from.

1:26:03 And then you can see the growth in impressions. Those are eyes on each of the posts. And engagement, substantial growth in engagements as well. Those are people liking, commenting, sharing that content. So again, big number there. And the one that I'm most excited to share with you guys is the link clicks. Again, we have trained our fans and followers to click through to URLs. And you see that here in the past year, growth from 5,998 to 59,000 link clicks in the past year.

1:26:33 award-winning website now, so very proud of that number. These are the demographics that are most engaged with our channels for the Visit Mammoth specific channels. Last quarter and quarter three, noticed that we had a little bit of a skewed number from men and women engaged with men coming in at a higher number in that specific 25 to 34-year-old range, but we made a goal of evening out those numbers and

1:27:01 Quarter 4. You can see that every channel except for YouTube has brought down to a closer range, and we're proud of that as well. This is a crib scorecard, again, specific to the crib channels. YouTube is going to be the same on this slide as it was on the slide before, but these numbers are specific to the athletes, media, and followers that are engaged with the crib social channels. So this is going into the Facebook-specific scorecard. So these are the numbers that

1:27:34 or broken down from that first initial scorecard of the overall channel growth. As you can see from quarter four last year to quarter four this year, the growth in followership, and you see growth in every category here except for engagement, and I'll attribute that to increasing the posts quite a bit. You'll see 196 posts.

1:27:54 Now 582 posts. More engagement, sometimes people are missing stuff, but more people are seeing it. The issue is, how do we keep the quality as high when you're putting out that much content all the time? So it's something that we're continually looking to optimize and make sure that we increase that engagement moving forward. But again, link clicks is something that I want to highlight on this slide, and seeing that 1,000% growth is pretty incredible.

1:28:24 This is a Crib Facebook scorecard. Again, growth in every category here on this channel. Last year was the first year that we assigned a content calendar and a plan with the Crib, put goals in place for where we want to be. Laura and I sat down and figured out what we needed to do to get those channels going. They were kind of stagnant. We didn't have content coming out consistently, and as you can see, that has changed quite a bit from last year. Okay, so here we are on the Instagram scorecard.

1:28:57 We signed on to Sprout for our analytics, like I mentioned earlier, back in December. They're not able to go back due to the Instagram analytics and the way that they store that data. Sprout is not able to go back and pull the data from last year. So this is more of a snapshot moving forward into any other future reports. We should have those numbers for you guys.

1:29:16 It's a matter of time and Sprout being able to keep track of that data. But this is our most engaged with channel organically. You'll see the average engagement per post. So I can post one photo right now and on an average we'll pull between about 1,600 likes on that post. And that's likes and comments as well. So definitely the fastest growing channel in our program and our most engaged with. And then this is our Crib Instagram scorecard and same issue with Sprout.

1:29:46 But moving forward, we will have those numbers. Okay, moving on Twitter. So again, growth in every category. Very proud of that. The followership, Twitter, and we've talked about this in previous presentations as well as what is the value to Twitter, and we've broken it down to the ratio of time spent.

1:30:08 On Twitter, the ratio of value that we get from it, when you look at that with link clicks, 3,707 link clicks. Most of those link clicks are to blogs onto our website. So 3,700 people in the last quarter on our website engaging with a blog, reading a longer piece of content, hopefully then spending more time on our website. Is value enough for us to continue moving forward with Twitter? We've got a couple other programs where we work with Mono County Tourism and Visit Bishop on doing Twitter chats, and typically we focus on a specific subject when it comes to, say, the dog days.

1:30:38 Visiting Mammoth Lakes in the summertime or with your dog or fall colors coming up, we'll do a Twitter chat with them, answering questions, it's an opportunity to engage that audience on Twitter. Okay, and then again, overall growth on the Crib Scorecard and just like the other channels, this has a more consistent content or consistent schedule when it comes to content being posted and more goals and plans put in place to

1:31:07 to keep these channels growing, especially as the crib closes in November, Laura and I sit down typically in early October and figure out what our plan is for the winter, how do we keep content going out and keep those channels growing in the off-season. Okay, and then YouTube. So this is an interesting one here. This is the one where you see the numbers drop. And I want to touch bases on that. Last year, quarter four, we had a lot of focus on Marian Carson campaign ads, or campaign videos, specifically the No Small Adventure videos. And those videos were...

1:31:36 posted on the YouTube channel, highlighted on the No Small Adventure landing page, as well as we had videos, short little snippet videos of the line drawings on the YouTube channel as well that we were focusing a lot of efforts on driving people to watching. So what we've also done with this past quarter was take a step back, look at all the content we had on our YouTube and do a basic...

1:31:58 Brief audit of how can we make this content better? How can we re-edit it? How can we give it new purpose, new life? And how do we support the website? So we have all these blogs with amazing content, but how can we embed those videos now to add more content to the website? So we're in process of cleaning up the video program. We haven't been producing a lot of new video content for our YouTube channel.

1:32:20 And that's due to reassessing, optimizing, and then moving forward and expanding on that program and getting these numbers back to where they were last year. So that is overview of the social media program. You guys have any questions? Thank you. Josh, the message I got was you need to focus

1:32:54 More on improving your presentation to women to get them more interested in what we're doing here at Mammoth. Do you see that? Are you focused on that? I'm not sure I understand completely, but are you talking about the demographic slide here? Yeah, well, you had indicated that, you know, our weaknesses with attracting women. Yeah.

1:33:16 And it wasn't like it was a 90-10 or 80-20. It was between like the 70-30, 60-40 more or less. We wanted to bring that back down to a place of how do we serve content that might cater to women specifically. And dog stuff typically works. It just comes down to figuring out like, not that dog stuff works, but figuring out what kind of content we can post to round out, you know, towards maybe not this high intense adventure.

1:33:42 Style of content, but maybe it's more soft adventure. And so we've come together as a team and figured out, you know, what, especially with working with Megan on supporting the blog content, you know, how do we round out the style of content that we're sharing? You know, me being a 24, almost 25 year old male, personally, I fit into the bracket that we were speaking to the most. So how do we round that idea out when I'm the one on the channel, right? So that's basically what we came to as a team and tried figuring out how to.

1:34:11 assess, and based off the numbers, we've been able to successfully do it. Well, I hope you do that because I think that there are two ways in which women are extremely important to Mammoth, and one is that they tend to spend more than guys, and the other is that they tend to be decision makers in families as to where the vacation is taken. So that I think it, you know...

1:34:34 No disrespect to the 24-year-old guy graphic, but I don't think those are the people who propel the financial side of the market. So I think that having a better balance with women is critical to our financial interests. Absolutely. Get those women up here, Josh. Thanks, Josh. Yeah, thank you guys. Thanks for your time.

1:35:21 Okay, because of our timing, we'll skip the department updates. Sorry, team. Going in, I handed out the TOT and TBID results. Just quickly, July, TOT came in 2% higher than last year's record at $1.749 million. Budget was, again, fairly low, so we're well ahead of that budgeted plan at this point. And TBID was also right on track with previous year.

1:35:47 Cash flow checking account has $1,374,447 in it. Measure A savings account is $5,992. TBID checking has $1.142,455 million, and then the savings is $5,005. John and I will get together because we do need to start looking at what our cash flow needs are for the next few months, but then also what's going to go back into the CDs so that they're protected from the FDIC standpoint.

1:36:15 P&L Reports, I sent you out the draft of the June numbers, but again, we are still waiting for about $800,000 from the town in TOT True Up for the last fiscal year to be able to close those books. So I sent a note to Rob Patterson this morning wondering when we could see that, but otherwise I think we're in pretty good shape. I think we've also collected all of our accounts receivable that we were owed this year, which is again, I think, a good thing for an organization of our size.

1:36:47 Any questions on the financials? Yeah. I think we didn't finish item number six on new business. And I don't know if it's something that we should break into the executive session based on the amount of time remaining in this meeting or if we can hammer things out here in five minutes' time. And that was to...

1:37:18 Finish the discussion regarding the Executive Director Performance Review and vote on it. What I would suggest, Mr. Chairman, is that because there are several components to this, one is the bonus, and the bonus is based on metrics from last year, which is pretty much a set in stone thing, I think, that's appropriate to...

1:37:40 Speak to the results of that because those are metrics. Regarding any issues regarding salary changes or changes to metrics, bonus metrics, I think those should be discussed in the executive session at next month's meeting if we can because I think those are more further discussions that should be done in the executive session. Okay, I'd agree with that. Any input on that? So, say that again, the compensation discussion would be at a...

1:38:12 Future meeting in front of the board? Yeah, I think that that makes sense. I mean, there are always some discussions, too, as if the board, we talked about this last year, we didn't make any decisions, but whether there are any, is there a desire to make any changes in salary structure and or changes to bonus metrics going forward? Obviously, John's review ending at the end of this year, the bonus structure was based on specific metrics that we did for last year, so those...

1:38:40 We evaluated, myself, Kirk, and Brent evaluated his performance based on those metrics for the fiscal year ending in June. But if there is a desire on the board to make any changes to those going forward, either there are or not, but if there, I know there was a discussion in that last year of potentially looking at air service metrics and so forth, but those are discussions we should probably have perhaps an executive session along with any, you know, any other changes. I would suggest we do that next month.

1:39:11 Personnel matters should be an executive session. Yeah, I would think so. So then, help me through this one here. We have a little, I guess, a motion on this? Move to put any further discussion of personnel matters relative to our executive director to an executive session to be had at some time in the

1:39:44 Immediate future adjacent to a board meeting? Sure. Any further discussion on that? I'll second that. I'll second that. All in favor? Aye. Okay. All right, then. So it is a Mammoth Mountain Ski Area update. Eric Clark, 30 seconds. We're done skiing. Thank you. That's all.

1:40:24 Grand Fondo coming up, obviously a great event for us and hopefully for the town too. We look forward to it. That's it. That was quite a long year. Yeah, exactly. In a very short summation. Thank you so much. Any further discussion on that? No? I believe that... Next meeting is October 4th. Yeah, next meeting is October 4th. Yours truly won't be there. I will be out of town, but I...

1:40:58 I'm confident we will have adequate representation unless everybody else knows their schedule. Should be there. That's at 1 o'clock? I think so. Will you send out the invite, huh? If we're good with that, then I think... Move to adjourn? Yeah. I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Very good. Thank you very much, everyone.