Town Council
· recording 3 hr 59 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
166 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
2:27:17 Yeah. Okay. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. Welcome to this. Town Council of Lakes, February 20th, 2017. I'm wondering if you would lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands under God. Thank you, Stacey. Let's have a roll call. Here. Here. Here.
2:28:13 The other piece of this is if you
2:30:35 If you have some links to share with council members of that social media that you're referring to, that would be helpful. And I think as a general matter, I think we'll just, Dan, we can talk about agendizing this. I think the other piece is we would love to hear from the Devil's Postpile staff down there if they have any role to play in this or not. But I think certainly that shuttle, you know, we're getting into the federal game.
2:31:04 I appreciate you bringing that up. I think it's a very valid conversation for us to have as springs and falls are starting to push out.
2:31:33 Do we need to make some adjustments to that service time frame? So thank you. Yes, thank you very much. Anybody else wishing to speak in public comment? Okay, seeing no other folks interested. Any additions to the agenda this evening, Dan? So let's move on then to staff presentations. This is the presentation on road maintenance and rehabilitation account RMRA funds under streets. Sure, I'm sorry.
2:32:06 Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Let's do reports and commissions first. I'm sorry. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Good evening. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission, and I've brought my teammates to the statewide health initiative and to thank MS3.
2:33:03 We'll have a long time. We'll have a long time.
2:34:23 Thank you. We'll move on then to the staff presentations.
2:35:10 And do I need to read this again? No? I'll read it. Let me read it again. Presentation of the development of the rehabilitation of the R-A-F-A-
2:42:49 But this thing is moving so fast, they're fast tracking it that I'm not surprised at it. Yeah, the guidance is changing regularly. The schedules just changed just a few weeks ago. And I am simplifying some of these procedures because it's pretty complex. So I'm trying to simplify it just to get a basic point across. According to the workshop, we have to submit, this is really quick, but we can submit any project that might be eligible and the budget sheet for that.
2:43:18 Yeah, welcome to working with the state.
2:43:50 The paperwork that came out last week directed municipalities to put forth the list for adoption is put like one sheet for receiving a resolution amending budget through the that will be acceptable to the CTC then we at the end of the year.
2:44:28 If I, just to be clear, I think what we're going to do is if there's any questions for staff, if there's any public comment, we'll do that, and then we'll try to come back and give you some idea of what kind of projects for help for your list. So any other technical questions? No, I've got a couple. Mammoth Lakes is an exceptional place for a lot of reasons. One is certainly our altitude, snow, the effects on our road surface. Is there anything that you are that indicates that we need to be,
2:44:59 You know, proactive about the guidelines not fitting what's going to be appropriate for Mammoth Lakes. Yeah, we're watching very carefully how they define certain programs so that if we need to adjust our terminology to match their terminology to be eligible for projects, we're on top of that. Okay. Dan and I were talking about that earlier about a couple of programs that popped up that
2:45:23 We think if we change some terminology, we may be eligible for programs coming down the road. But granted, the guidance literally hasn't been created yet for some of these programs, so we're kind of just forecasting what may happen. And you mentioned the California Transportation Commission. They were up here in town last week. We had a very good workshop with them, and I hope that maybe there's a good line of communication if some of those things come up to help us with some of those things. Eligibility, this is state infrastructure. Correct. Is Red's Matter Road?
2:45:53 Once that is completed, would something like that be eligible? It would be eligible once we have it. So infrastructure that we would take on through FLAP grants and that kind of stuff would be eligible? Would be eligible, yes. Okay. And are these annual allocations out of SB1? Is that fair to say going forward? Right. They've given some preliminary guidance, and my numbers are based on that. That's all subject to change depending on how many municipalities apply for money.
2:46:22 How many, how much they collect in fees. So they're just forecasted number no different than, than STIP funding or F-STIP or something similar to that. Okay, but there's no set in SB1? Nothing, no. Okay, this is, this is part of California's transportation program going forward. Good, thank you very much. However important to note that there are several groups in the state who are probably going to end up working together trying to get this on the ballot to overturn this.
2:46:51 A voter referendum. Okay, we're not going to talk about them right now, are we? No, it's just important to remember, while everybody that was a presenter at the conference we were just at is excited about these dollars, they're fast tracking it, trying to hit the road with it so that it doesn't get overturned. Important to remember that this, at this point, isn't something that we can put in the bank. No, I understand.
2:47:14 But it's also clear that this is not intended to supplant local resources. It's additive. And I think certainly, we get into the deliberation about this, I think it's very important that we act consistent with the legislation, that we not wander from that, that we do what it's intended to do. And we'll see what happens. There are other funds in the state that will have additional funding because of this as well.
2:47:42 The boat and waterways and the Cal OHVMR. Sure. All are going to probably be beneficiaries if this thing stays as it currently is. Sure. Good. Hayes, you mentioned in kind of some direction and guidance sidewalks. For our viability of our applications, is new sidewalk development something that you feel is viable or is it mostly deferred maintenance on existing sidewalks? Like I said, we can use it for...
2:48:11 Do you think that that would diminish our viability for funds if we were to go that route? Absolutely not. This is an allocation. We're guaranteed this money. Starting, I believe, December.
2:48:33 They're going to begin depositing money in our coffers on a monthly basis based on a number of formulas under a number of different programs. So the funds, we're going to start receiving them automatically here shortly. And we can use them and report on them however we please within those guidelines. Okay. Good. Okay, so any thoughts from the public on these opportunities to help inform Council's direction? Not seeing any, so I'll bring it back here to...
2:49:03 I'll get started and you guys can fill in. I think it's important, at least in this initial round, to stay as true to the language and the intent of the legislation as passed and signed by the governor. Let's start with that. I think it's important for the taxpayers and certainly the taxpayers in Mammoth Lakes to understand when something like this happens, it's going to go back and do what it was intended to do. So that would be my two cents to get started.
2:49:29 Well, there's a second piece of this that is the competitive grant as well, and if I understand it, there's going to be a certain percentage set aside specifically for rural counties and cities. So those are programs besides the dedicated that we're going to get regardless.
2:49:47 Because, I mean, is that, do you want those, I mean, October 4th is coming up pretty quick. So what we're focused on right now is the RMRA dollars for the local, that's the allocation, and to your point, Bill, the competitive rural component, the town applied for that ATP funds, active transportation program funds earlier this year. We were not successful in our application, but we did go out for some funding under that program, and we'll continue to do so as the guidance comes out.
2:50:16 I think really the focus this evening was to look at basically the $125,000 coming this year if there's a preference between kind of the street work, curb and gutter, overlay, rebuild, kind of how do we really get it on the ground and take a look at that. There's other pieces of this as it rolls out. We'll stay on top of that. You may see other grant applications come forward, et cetera. But this one here, we do have to get that to you on the 4th.
2:50:41 We can narrow the discussion down here to be helpful. I don't have any strong preference personally. I mean, I think staff has lined out in our plans, so I'd be looking for a recommendation from you guys as far as where the first dollar should be spent. Okay. I would echo that. Streets that are falling apart, of course, first, but incomplete sidewalk projects, you guys need to bring us a list for us to prioritize for you then. Okay. I just didn't want to make this look like a staff-driven
2:51:11 So, item number three.
2:51:40 The minutes of the regular meeting of September 6, 2017. Item 4, adopt a resolution establishing 2017 and 2018 compensation schedules for limited-term employees. Number 5, approve the parcels collectively as the East Village parcels from the InterWest Development Agreement and authorize the town manager to sign the partial release of development agreement.
2:52:01 Number six, adopt the resolution authorizing the vacation of an offer of dedication to the town of Mammoth Lakes of a portion of 111 Burner Street for the purposes of public right-of-way and snow storage. Number seven, accept payment approval reports number 1812, 1810, 1732, 1813, 1733, 1814. And I believe that's it. Does anybody wish to pull an item? Seeing none, anybody from staff, public, anybody want to pull anything? Seeing none, I would entertain a motion.
2:52:32 Mr. Mayor, I be happy to make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7. I'll second that. Thank you very much. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The consent agenda is agreed to 4-0. Okay, we'll now move on to a public hearing. And the public hearing, I will open the public hearing.
2:52:59 And the public hearing is to consider approval of general plan amendment 17-001 to amend the land use elements, institutional public land use designation, and build out table. And staff, I'm assuming that's Sandra? Ruth? Ruth. Thank you. Ruth. Thank you.
2:53:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:54:17 ...described in the land use element. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ...
2:54:59 The proposed amendments unfold. The first is public comment. So any technical questions from the council on this item? Okay. I'll ask a couple. If something comes up, just let me know. The first question is kind of a question for Andy and Ruth, perhaps. You mentioned three. You've heard three letters of comment that are in the packet. I've received
3:00:55 There's no hard requirement that people get comments in by a certain amount of time, but it's up to the council to decide how much weight to give a comment that you receive while you're on the dais or that you...
3:01:25 That you otherwise haven't really had adequate time to review and consider. Okay. All right. So just, but it is more helpful perhaps to the public and the council if these comments are delivered in a timely fashion. Staff can provide some analysis of it to provide, you know, some thoughts to us. So I would just encourage people to get comments in, you know, timely fashion.
3:01:49 And I wanted to also point out that I appreciate the comments about the other agencies and their involvement in this. I think as we start looking at things like housing, community housing, EIFD, you know, public infrastructure investment, the role of fire districts, water districts, and others, I think it's going to be a great opportunity to bring all that together as we start looking at these things that will affect the community as a whole. And so I appreciate it. I think that was a Sandy Hogan's letter. I appreciate those comments and those thoughts.
3:02:18 I'm going to take a little bit of a chance here and ask Ruth and or Sandra if you could, just for the public's edification, there's been a lot of comment about, well, you're making a change in this land use element that's really being driven by a proponent that's over here but would have effects in other places in the town. And it's been proposed that, well, why don't you take that land use element and break it into pieces?
3:02:44 And make it more specific. And I'm wondering if you could make a representation as to the approach the council is considering tonight versus doing an alternative approach in terms of the relative protection that the public would have for the public.
3:02:59 For the landscape that's in question. My sense is that it's six of one, half dozen another. That there are protections in place if we were to make a change this evening. There's still plenty of tools and process involved to keep unanticipated things from happening. But if you could maybe comment on that in a simple and straightforward way. If it's too complicated, let me know. We'll just move on. But I'm wondering if that's something we could represent. Okay. Challenge accepted.
3:03:24 So, yes, that comment has been raised. I think that was raised in some of the other letters as well. How can, or is there a way to separate the proposed amendment presented here by Mammoth Lakes Foundation from affecting the community center site and the Trails End Park? So those properties are all, oh, thank you. So those properties are all within the IP land use designation, and to do that, we'd really need to
3:03:51 Amend the land use designations for those other sites. And I think that would really be best considered under a separate application or proposal from the proponents who are most interested in that process. I think that would require kind of a larger discussion about what is the most appropriate land use designation for the Trails End Park or the Community Center site, given the potential.
3:04:18 And then to answer the other part of your question, any future development on any of these properties, Mammoth Lakes Foundation property, the Trails End, Fire District 1, whichever it may be, would require additional public processes, whether it's design review, use permits, environmental analysis, potentially subsequent zoning code amendments.
3:04:46 There is no development proposal that could move forward without some other application or process that would come back before our decision makers. Okay, good. Does that sort of make sense? I mean, it's sort of 6-1. That was my sense of that. So, okay, thank you. With that, applicant, Mr. Boccia, would you like to address the public? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council, staff, members of the community. Rich Boccia, Mammoth Lakes Foundation.
3:05:18 Our goal is to maximize the community benefits from Mammoth Lakes Foundation property and to provide an option for affordable housing in Mammoth Lakes. We have three main points this evening. A, focus on building the arts and cultures facilities. We are currently working with the town staff on the environmental review process. The current institutional public IP designation assumes the theater is a component of the college.
3:05:44 The proposed amendment permits it to be operated separately from Cerro Coso Community College. The college supports this direction. B, to provide wider community housing options in addition to Cerro Coso Community College students. We currently have 41 of the 59 beds filled in the South Gateway student apartment complex. The expanded institutional public IP designation would allow local entities such as the hospital,
3:06:11 The schools, the library, and other government agency to lease these unoccupied rooms. C. To create physical wellness and rehabilitation facilities such as the National Wounded Warrior Center in partnership with Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra. The current housing limitation restricts its use. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation Board of Directors appreciate your support of this expanded IP designation which will provide options for affordable housing for the identified entities.
3:06:40 Thank you very much. Thank you very much. And you'll be available here in case you want to... Answer any questions, Mr. Mayor? Yes, sir. Okay. Thank you very much. So with that, I think we'll turn it over to public comments. So any member of the public wishing to comment on this item, if you could limit your comments to five minutes, that'd be great, but please come forward and say your piece. E.L. Smudgen. I'm on the Board of Directors with the Trails Homeowner Association. I don't know that I'm...
3:07:16 Opponent or a proponent of the proposed change, but it seems like this is being fast-tracked, and the 300-foot limit on who had to be notified seems rather narrow because a lot of people think that changing the designation could affect property values of the whole trails, assuming that it's not a positive effect that it has.
3:07:46 The other thing is my understanding that the Wounded Warrior Center was already going down the road, getting half the design done, so I would assume that this shouldn't impact that, that this was probably kind of thrown in there to get sympathy from some of the residents. We don't understand why this would include just public employees. Why not civilians and everybody? It seems we have the shady rest parcel.
3:08:19 That no one's mentioned for development for low-income housing. And that's about all I have there on my notes. But the concern is, is there something hidden in the woodwork here that maybe has to do with expanding this whole thing into just typically low-income housing?
3:08:45 I think, yeah, that's a good question. I wonder, staff, if you could speak to that specifically in terms of the type of housing that would be appropriate in this land use designation that will not change. The intent of this application was not to modify the overall character of what's been allowed for the institutional public land use designation, which is why the housing is specifically being proposed to be permitted for employees of the uses that are already allowed.
3:09:15 Such as the hospitals, schools, college, et cetera. Initially, it was just for, like, professors, right, that were going to work at the college. Right. So, yeah, there is a bit of history to housing on this site. So, originally, the working group that worked on the 2007 general plan
3:09:40 Had proposed that housing of all types be permitted within the IP land use designation. During the public hearing stage of adoption of the 2007 general plan, there was a group called Advocates of Mammoth that fought strongly against that. They had concerns related to density and sort of the quality of the housing that would be permitted in this designation.
3:10:09 As a result of their concerns, it was scaled back to allowing just housing for students and faculty. But it had always been considered for a wider range of housing opportunities. So this application sort of brings it halfway back to allow housing still within sort of the character of those uses allowed by the IP designation and not
3:10:38 Sort of a no restrictions affordable housing scenario. The other thing that I had on my notes here is when the court was going to be put up there, you know, that was kind of a slip it in thing and that got everybody excited. I guess I'm just, I don't understand the urgency. I'd like to have a chance for the, for somebody to come and talk to the trails homeowners meeting and explain the goodness of this before it becomes law.
3:11:09 Good. Okay, thank you very much. Thanks. Please. Hi, my name is Michael Bowes, and I'm a resident of the trails also. I've been a resident of Mammoth for 14 years, and I have some comments regarding this proposed change. The first thing is that this change, as has been expressed in one of the letters that you received, will affect all the IP zone lands in town. And as Ruth said, the land usage designation would have to be changed for
3:11:45 The park areas, the community center, and also the trails and park, if those were to be used for some function of like the affordable housing or something like that. But I would say that that should be changed first. Why shouldn't we do that first before we apply this blanket change to all the IP properties? So that's my first point. And my second point is that
3:12:09 I have talked with many of the trails residents. I have yet to find anyone who understood this change or understood better what the ramifications were. Most of them, they read the document if they received it at all, which most did not. And their understanding of it, the way it was worded, was to believe that this would be used exclusively for, for example, employee housing that would be associated with the Wounded Warrior Center or the MAC.
3:12:35 And my understanding from Ruth is that this actually, as she just said, is intended perhaps for a broader workforce housing to be built on the foundation. Right. I just want to be clear there, and I want to make sure that that point is clear. This is not, this will not open up IP for workforce housing or community housing as a general proposition. It is constrained to
3:12:58 The types of housing that Ruth mentioned. Right. The district. So it's not, I just want to make sure that we're not, because that's not what this is about. I know, it's institutional public. Correct. Of course, as we all know, things evolve over time. That's the first step. Then the next step will be to open it up to a wide, wide spectrum of housing. I mean, that's the concern that we have as citizens, that that's the way these things happen. And then they'll say there's no actual effect because we already have the housing there.
3:13:26 There was not enough time for notification, in my opinion. The written notification of these meetings were sent out only to residents within 300 feet of the IP property, and these were mailed out on September 7th, 13 days ago. There were two ads placed in the newspaper on the 10th and the 17th, 10 days and 3 days before the meeting. A lot of the people I've tried to contact are going to be out of town or could not attend this meeting. They were very concerned about it.
3:13:51 Frankly, myself, when I read the description of the letter, I didn't think there was anything to worry about until I went to the website and I read the report and then I talked to Ruth and I learned more about what was going on. So I really think this is happening way too quickly. In 2007, as Ruth said, the advocates had basically advocated that we not make exactly this change. And, you know, a lot of...
3:14:15 Time and energy by a lot of people was put into coming up with the general plan in 2007. And now in the course of a few days, we're trying to change this. And I think that's, we should at least give more time for more public comment. Also, my understanding is as of the planning and economic development commission report on August 9th, there was no official input from any of the agencies involved. Typically, the agencies would take months to work through all the issues and come back with their official input.
3:14:44 So I think at the very least we should wait for that to find out whether this even makes any sense. I mean, we may have had discussions with them. That's not the same thing as analyzing all the aspects of the proposal. Another thing is that the trails has been assured for many years by the Mammoth Lakes Foundation that their intent is to develop their campus strictly for educational purposes. As a matter of fact, before my time, I'd heard that they
3:15:14 Had assured the residents of the trails that they would never build anything on the north-facing slopes of the properties. As E.L. pointed out in 2007, they tried to sell off part of the land for the municipal courthouse. So that there definitely diminished our trust in their motivations. At this point, I'd like to just read what the mission statement is.
3:15:42 The Mammoth Lakes Foundation. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation supports higher education and cultural enrichment in the eastern Sierra. Their vision statement is that Dave McCoy's vision to cultivate higher education in the arts in the eastern Sierra is shared by many. Our goal is a permanent college campus and facilities for academic studies, appreciation of the arts, and student housing in Mammoth Lakes, period. There's no mention there about workforce housing. As far as I know, there's never been any mention of that in a public forum before where the
3:16:09 Public, like, for example, the residents of the trails have been informed that they have these plans. The problem is, is although it may be stated that it is only the least unoccupied rooms, once this change is made, then they have the ability to develop that land if they wish to. Thank you. If you could wrap up, that'd be great. Sure. I'd just like to say the last thing is that this is the largest contiguous block of land we have in the town. It's a unique thing that we have. It's a precious resource. We don't know the direction that ski towns are going. We're perhaps...
3:16:39 Suffering from global climate change. Things, the dynamics are going to change dramatically in the economy in ski towns. I think we should preserve this land until we're absolutely sure what we need to do with it. That could be 20 or 40 years down the road. Good. Thank you very much. Thank you. Hi. Tim Flynn, Trails resident, contractor, realtor, business owner, community member. Hello, everybody. Yeah, I would just...
3:17:10 Urge the council to pump the brakes on this and just let us, let us, I just got an email from him at five o'clock and I got home and opened up my email and saw this and I just, I'd like to just reiterate what they've all said. You know, I understand there's an urgent need for, you know, affordable housing and absolutely we need to look at affordable housing options but this parcel, I mean,
3:17:40 The highest and best use? I don't think so. I think we need to definitely notify this a lot better and just take it easy and table this, please. I just would urge the council to table this. Let the residents and people of the trails and the entire community walk that parcel, walk that bike path. I mean, the views on that.
3:18:10 That are incredible. It would be a travesty to develop apartments and stuff like that on that. The college has done a great job. Those properties are well-designed and beautiful and on those south-facing slopes. The dormitory is okay. I get sent the council agendas all the time, and from what I read from the council agenda, I was under the impression that they were just changing.
3:18:39 The use of the dormitories, you know, that the dorms were going to be available for use as, you know, housing for other members like what Mr. Boccia said. As far as a land use designation and a land use change, you know, that it's like a blanket policy, I think that needs to be properly vetted. So thank you. Good. Thank you very much. Thanks. Anybody else?
3:19:11 Now, Evan, are you speaking as a proponent? Because I want to give the proponent an opportunity to speak to this, but I want to make sure the public comment's been exhausted first. Any other public comment? Lisa Wiles, trails resident, long-time resident of the town, and just one.
3:19:36 Council to know that I'm feeling duped and railroaded by Mammoth Lakes Foundation with their application and being a big financial supporter to the foundation. I'm kind of taken back by what they want to do and would really like to urge Council to give it some thought and weigh the consequences heavily. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Any other public comment?
3:20:18 My name is Thomas Altenbach. I'm a resident of the trails along with my wife and our family. We're very fortunate to be living there. And I'd just like to say that we really enjoy our house and we enjoy our view, which is directly at the college, directly faces the college, along with some of our neighbors who are also here. And just because our house is 350 feet away from the new project does not mean we can't see it.
3:20:47 And we did not know anything about this until today as far as what the impacts will be. And seriously, to say there are no environmental impacts, the view is an environmental impact. You just can't discount that out of hand. So I'd like you to consider that. Yes, thank you. Okay, any other public comments, thoughts? Yes, please, come up.
3:21:22 I'm Tom Alton, Mark's wife. He's a nuclear engineer. And we moved here from Livermore, California. We fell in love with Mammoth. And we believed that Mammoth was going to be a, we knew that Mammoth was going to build a college here. And we knew where it was going to go when we were building our home. And we've accepted the landscape, the way it's changed it, they changed it, and it fits in. Any other buildings will deface.
3:21:47 What we can see and what we can enjoy. But the most important thing is the wounded warriors are being trampled on because that's the impression that I got, that this housing was going to be for the wounded warriors, our veterans, and now it's going to be for public use for low incomes and stuff. That's what I'm understanding. There's a lot of confusion. So that's why we have to back up and back off on this and understand what is really the intent to be deceived.
3:22:14 By the Council, by the Foundation, is really going to destroy the community. Okay, I understand. I think you're taking a little bit of liberty of what's going on with this process, but thank you very much for your comments. Thank you. Okay, any other further public comment? Okay, so Mammoth Lakes Foundation, you and or whoever wants to speak, please come forward. Thank you. Evan Russell with Mammoth Lakes Foundation, and I've been involved from...
3:22:47 The very inception of what's taken place over there. And I'd just like to say that the comments that were made, some were very inaccurate and some were very much misinformed. There is no land change going on here. There are no buildings that are being proposed to be built. That'll have to go through a whole separate process. All we're trying to do is take the existing beds,
3:23:17 That we have in the student housing building and expand the use of those beds so we can maximize the potential going into this next winter. We have people that are talking to us now that would like to move into the building that are looking for housing in town that can't find it. There is no additional impact that's taking place on this at this point in time.
3:23:44 There's no hidden agendas. We have no building plans to do anything different. We had an approved conditional use permit to add a second student housing building. And a few years ago when Kathy Copeland was looking for land for her project, we said we would forego that building if she could design a facility that fit into the footprint of the already approved building.
3:24:14 So we've moved forward with Kathy on that project. If she finds her funding, you know, so be it. You know, and I'm not here to argue this thing, but the original EIR that was approved on this project had 350,000 square feet of buildings in it on the 86 acres of the South Gateway. Spread out, but there was a lot more buildings that were shown and have been shown in past master plans that
3:24:44 Go on all parts of the property. We're not asking for any of that now. That'll go through a separate process. When we come forward with the MAC process, which is a different proposal that'll come before you at some time in the near future, that'll go through a CEQA review that'll have plenty of public comment attached to it.
3:25:09 We're in the process of working with Design Workshop, which is a land planning group out of South Lake Tahoe that will come in and do a public discussion about how does that area around the foundation building and the MAC building and the streets and things, how does that all come together? And the MAC project will go back to design review through this public process again.
3:25:37 So that's the next thing that we're talking about building that hopefully will start the next year, year and a half. But what we're asking for now is just a system to be able to go in. Here's a perfect example is the hospital is in great need of finding housing for employees they have. We would like to do a deal with the hospital so they can use that building. We're not building anything additional. We're just going to maximize
3:26:07 Those rooms. You know, we're happy to talk to the trails. I don't see this as an issue that is going to take a lot of thought. We all know that there's a housing crisis that's getting worse by the month here, and we're asking for something pretty simple. If this is a difficult issue to deal with,
3:26:33 Wait until you find yourself 300 to 500 beds short and the employers in town can't open their doors because nobody's going to work them.
3:26:42 We, as Rich said, we have 41 beds occupied now. We actually have 59 beds and two beds for managers in there. We'd like to see those things full. That's our whole purpose in asking for this change. And none of us really thought this was a big deal. I mean, we work with the trails people all the time. We've let them use the building for their association meetings. They all know us. They know Rich, myself, Shira. If somebody had an issue, they could have picked up the phone and said,
3:27:12 What is this all about? We're over there, and somebody's got somebody worked up over things that are not the case. It's not part of what we're asking for. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much. One comment, sir, Mr. Mayor. There were a couple of comments about lack of prior notice. The same notice went out to these residents for the August 9th Planning Commission meeting. Same letter, same format, same information. So this has been on the table now for a good six weeks. Thank you, sir.
3:27:42 Thank you very much. Please, quiet, quiet, quiet, quiet, quiet. I'm going to bring this back for council deliberation and potentially some questions to the applicant. So I have an initial question, Rich, which is, Rich, to the foundation, is there any immediacy, is there a time pressure that you have on this at this point? John, yes.
3:28:19 You know, we're working with Gary Myers at the hospital right now on being able to use this space, and he's got people coming and going all the time now. He's trying to allow this to go through his system to see if this can be a viable place for them to be able to house hospital employees that they'd like to bring in the community. And the longer we stretch it out, the farther it puts that option down.
3:28:44 We're not trying to solve the...
3:29:10 Affordable housing. Sure. And this isn't about affordable housing because our housing probably is not what you would consider affordable for the rates we have to charge because of the facility that we build over there. Oh, understood. Understood. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, so who wants to start this off and let's review and discuss this? I am a little bit curious as well because I feel that maybe I've been operating under
3:29:41 A misconception about this because with the MAC, this property was going to be for upper management type housing. This is not something that was going ever to be for affordable housing. So the people who are saying, you know, I have a few more questions, I feel their pain because
3:30:06 That is something I thought, and I guess I quite don't get what the issue is about that area because if we are going to have homes that are going to be for people who do earn more money, but that was always my impression of that land use was the housing, there was going to be a portion, it's so far down the road because there's other things that need to get built out.
3:30:34 Before that's even going to be crossing our paths. So I am a little bit curious about the urgency of it making the decision right now. And I also do not like the fact that we have to include the other areas with that same land use designation. So there you go. Bill, Colin? This is a tough one for me. I am, as someone who's been in Mammoth,
3:31:04 Longer than any of you in the audience. I am finding it incredibly ironic that the people who are occupying land that was the first land trade made with the Forest Service specifically to create workforce housing are arguing against workforce housing across the street. I would love to ask you all, how many feet from your house does it need to be now? And it's not just you. I get this all the time in Mammoth.
3:31:33 This is a great idea. Not here. I bought my house in 1969. It was zoned R1. There were no apartments there. All the lots on my street were half acre. I got apartments going in across the street from me within the next year. Things change as the town changes and the needs change. I just spent two days in our local hospital. Thank God they found housing for the people who are working there or maybe I wouldn't be sitting here.
3:32:03 I don't see anything here that alters the land use to the point where we're going to have the concern of creating straight-up workforce housing on any of these sites. We're not going to take out Trails End Park in favor of an apartment building. I don't see anyone on council who would ever do that. The same with the college site. I don't see us...
3:32:28 Using that as straight-up workforce housing. It's going to continue to be industrial purposes, hospital, town. We need to be able to house our employees. It is across the street. We want to talk about view sheds. Again, kind of ironic. Your houses are where I played as a kid. There used to be a huge boulder out there that was full of holes that we just absolutely loved. So things change.
3:32:54 Good. Thank you, Colin.
3:33:20 You know, just a couple of thoughts. You know, I appreciate everyone coming out. I appreciate the comments. I think we hear time and time again that communication is something that people would like to see improved or have issues around. You know, I think that's something we can take as a council and a town staff and continue to try and get better at that, but I think that that's something that we frequently hear regardless of the level of communication that occurs.
3:33:47 I think that we're going through a pretty significant process right now as a council to address workforce housing needs. You know, John and I sit on that committee. A lot of people in the audience and around the community have been involved in that. And I think if we come out of that effort with an unwillingness to look at some creative solutions for workforce housing, it's going to be a waste of everyone's time.
3:34:15 To utilize 18 units that are currently underutilized and just open that up to a couple of different uses does not seem unreasonable to me. I can understand some of the concerns, but I think frankly this kind of idea that there's some nefarious plot behind this is misguided. I think that all of these uses are IP currently.
3:34:42 So we could have built student housing instead of Trails End Park. It doesn't mean that just because it's an allowed use, that's what's going to be the ultimate use of a project. As has been stated multiple times, if somebody wants to come forward with a proposal, that's going to go through the public process. All I'm hearing right now is the utilization of some existing units that are underutilized currently, and I think it's a creative solution and one that...
3:35:11 We should consider. So I don't have a large concern around this. I appreciate the concern that's been brought before us, but I don't necessarily share it. Good. Thank you. You know, this, on the face of it, it sounds, you know, sounds kind of weird. It sounds bureaucratic, sounds weedy, sounds, you know, what is this thing?
3:35:35 And I shared probably the concern, well, I'm going to have to do some work to figure out what this is. I'm going to have to do a little due diligence to figure out what's going on with this thing. So I talked with folks. I watched the Planning Commission session, which is available on Granicus, which is available for folks to watch. And I came away with it from that session and in conversation with staff and others that
3:36:03 This is a relatively minor change. And I think to Colin's point, it really is about looking at we've got a bunch of dormitory space sitting there that's being underutilized. It seems like this is a good opportunity to get professional folks in this place to make this happen. The other part of it is I'm very much satisfied that should any other use
3:36:29 be proposed on any of these other IP pieces of property. The public will have full public opportunity to get involved in that, to weigh in on that, to talk with council in advance, and to make your representations known. I'm very sympathetic. I mean, when I'm hearing, it sounds like this is, boy, this could be a really terrible thing, but it doesn't square with
3:36:55 You know, the due diligence that I've done, the research I've done, my conversation with staff, my understanding of what's proposed, I don't see any of those things happening. And so I'm not, if those concerns were valid and these things were potentially going to happen, certainly I would feel differently, but I don't see us going down that road. And I think to echo what Colin said a little bit, you know, we've got some very big things happening in this community.
3:37:22 They're coming forward in the coming months. And I want to really encourage everybody to not come to a council meeting and say, I didn't know anything about this. Folks, you know, we're here. We all have email addresses. I mean, the Planning Commission meeting was thorough. It was an hour-long session back in August. And it's not as represented and as described.
3:37:47 And I would just encourage all of us, things are going to be changing in this community in pretty significant ways going forward. We do have a housing crisis. We're investing a lot of time and resources to try to address this. And there's going to be the need for us to work together as a community to try to address these kinds of things. So, I mean, I was considering, well, gee, maybe we should maybe put a final decision off.
3:38:12 For a month and give the foundation a chance to work with folks to understand what's going on with this. I'm pretty confident that at the end of the day with that process, there's not none of these things that are being advertised as being nefarious and double handed and all kinds of stuff will come to light. So I don't necessarily see a need for that. I mean, I think the long and the short of it is housing isn't allowed use in the IP designation today. Sure.
3:38:40 Decided to proceed in that fashion, we could have built student housing on all those IP land designated areas. The decision was made to not do that because it wasn't the highest and best use for the land. I don't see how that changes if you allow a hospital employee or a government employee to live in that housing as opposed to just a student or faculty member. And if we put it back into the larger housing discussion, someone brought up this idea of, well, what does it mean for community housing?
3:39:09 If we start, if hospital folks and people like that can live in this area, well, what it means is it takes the pressure off of what's available in the open market for housing, and it makes more housing opportunities available. This is just the kind of stuff we're going to have to be doing. If we're going to succeed and have a future as a community, we're going to have to have these discussions and start moving things around a little bit so we can accommodate the needs of the community across all spectrums.
3:39:35 So those are my thoughts. I don't know if we want to have any further discussion, if we want to entertain a motion. Okay, good. I'd be happy to move that Council adopts the resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving General Plan Amendment 17-001 to amend the land use elements to institutional public land use designation and build out table as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission.
3:40:04 Okay, I want to, before I hear a second, I want to do a technical thing. I want to close the public hearing, which I did not do. So I'm going to close the public hearing, and then if you could restate your motion. So moved. Thank you. So is there a second then? Second. So I have a motion to second any further discussion. Hearing none, roll call, please, Jamie. Mr. Murray? Yes. Mr. Melzer? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempo? No. Mayor Pro Tempo? Yes. The item is agreed to 3-1.
3:40:34 Thank you all for coming out. Your concerns are certainly heard. If there are going to be any other future efforts on this property, it will go through a public process, and I look forward to hearing from you and seeing you well in advance of all that. So thank you very much. This brings us... Sir, take a five-minute. Okay, we're going to take a five-minute break and then move on to the closed session. Thank you. Session agenda. We're going to move on to Councilmember Reports, and after that, we'll move into closed session.
3:41:37 Department had reports. Sorry? Department reports. Department reports, okay. I've got to highlight my agenda better. Okay, so Councilmember reports. Who wants to start? I will certainly go if you want me to. Please. I'll try to keep it all brief. Yep. Several of us from the town did attend the California League of Cities Conference in Sacramento. Very informative. Some of the presenters were great. Some of them, as the transportation...
3:42:08 Commission were a little confusing, but I think we represented our area well. Then we went and toured some of the potential new structures and things for housing in Truckee because I've heard a lot about them and hadn't seen them yet. Our attorney joined us for a good deal of that and that was a good experience and I'm looking forward to using that knowledge.
3:42:33 In the future. Good. Excellent. Thank you. And I will just bounce right off that and say I was in, oh, there's no, okay, so I was in attendance at that? Oh, I was in attendance as well, and I second everything that he said on that, that it was really interesting getting to see people in local government, again, find out what they're dealing with and what we can take from them and use, so, and Truckee is indeed a very neat place to see, so, very productive trip.
3:43:03 Good, thank you. Colin? I don't have a ton to report. I was doing a peer resort tour of my own up in Whistler, Canada.
3:43:11 So spent the week up there on business and just got back. A couple things for the public, for the council. Our housing working group is continuing to meet. We have two meetings this week. Tomorrow evening from 5 to 8 here in Suite Z. And then again Friday morning from 8 to 11 a.m. Those are not public sessions, correct? They're not public. No. Okay.
3:43:41 I was unaware. So just letting the public know that we are continuing to meet. And so we've got those two meetings this week, and that's all for me. Good. Thank you very much. There's a fair amount of stuff I'm not going to bore people with, but August 23rd, 25th, I attended a climate change action conference in San Luis Obispo that was very illuminating on a number of different fronts.
3:44:07 I think that's going to be very important that the town put together a climate change policy in order to make sure that we are going to be properly exposed to all the funding opportunities coming out of the state. And I'm working with some folks. A woman named Diana Mattson is going to be coming down here from Truckee to attend the Lahontan Water District Board meeting in Bishop.
3:44:30 And I'm going to be talking with her Friday afternoon and maybe setting up a meeting with the town, with staff, maybe a council member or two to start getting a sense of what kinds of things we need to put in place so we're going to be properly exposed to all that money coming out of Sacramento. I attended a meeting of the Inyo Motor Broadband Consortium Advisory Council that they've been struggling to get a quorum, but when they're getting it, it's working well moving forward.
3:44:53 An LTC meeting on September 11th. It was primarily about getting ready for the CTC meeting, which happened that week. Attended an MLH board meeting. The CTC, this is a California Transportation Commission meeting, workshop here. Staff did a great job. I think they really, they left here with a very...
3:45:12 I think positive, informed, and well-disposed impression of Mammoth Lakes. And I think as we get into the decisions they're going to be making about SB1 and things like that, I think we did a very good job of representing the town and the region. That was a very interesting meeting. The Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District meeting I attended on the 14th. There's some interesting things coming out of that with the CD4 project and some monitoring wells, which I'll talk about in a second.
3:45:39 I attended both the housing workshops that you would not be able to attend on the 14th and the 15th. I went to the Lakes Basin Cleanup on Saturday. Basin's pretty clean, looking pretty good. It's hard for that place not to look good. I attended the Inuamono Broadband Consortium Regional Branding and Website Committee meeting yesterday, and so there's going to be some product coming out of that pretty soon. Stickers and windows.
3:46:07 Good information on what Digital 395 is and really start getting it out into the adoption and get everybody using this stuff properly. So it's exciting to see that moving forward. The town's investment in that branding effort is paying off. That's going to be the basis of the look and feel and the brand for that whole effort. So it's a good thing we did that. That's getting put to good use. I attended the Cannabis Working Group this morning. It's very interesting. I think a key takeaway from that is start making the separation between the retail cannabis.
3:46:33 I think it's going to be very important moving forward how we start putting that whole thing together. Two things coming forward that I've talked with Dan about the Lake Space and Fuels Reduction Project, which has been kind of floating around out there. The NEPA is complete, but the Fire District is going to be the lead CEQA agency on that, and I think
3:47:03 The comments are due by October 10th. I think it's going to be very important that we do not see a repeat of what happened with Panorama Dome a couple years ago. They did a fuels cleaning thing out there. They wiped out all the trails. They had a problem with the contractor. The place just got trashed. I don't want to be too editorial about it, but it got really badly abused. And I think we want to make very sure that we move forward with this thing, that working together with the Forest Service and other agencies, it's a key part of our...
3:47:29 We don't want to just give it a number two buzz cut and call it good. I think we want to be smart about that. And the other thing is this CD4 monitoring wells project, which is comments are due. There's a NEPA scoping letter that's out. Comments are due October 3rd.
3:47:44 CD4 is now going to put monitoring wells within our municipal boundary. And I think this gives us a unique opportunity perhaps to get some standing and some leverage with that process. And so we need to work getting some comments together for Gath. There's going to be a presentation at the Monroe County Collaborative Planning Team on the 26th.
3:48:00 About that whole winter recreation thing that's happening out there. I'm assuming town staff's going to be there to be able to represent. We now have a contract with Mormat to plow that road. So all that's kind of moving forward. And I think with the county putting some money aside for recreation position, I think we can start, you know, getting some good work done with all that. So that's, those are my two bits. So staff, come face the music.
3:48:27 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just a quick update, the Planning and Economic Development Commission met last Wednesday, September 13th. They did continue the Old Mammoth Place development agreement that was scheduled for a public hearing last week, but because of the comments that came out of the workshop on September 6th, they continued it. They didn't continue it to a date certain, so it'll be renoticed in the paper and everything. All the mailings will be sent out again when we determine what date it'll come back to commission.
3:48:56 They did recommend approval of a zoning code cleanup and a general plan cleanup item that will be for the council on October 18th. And they also formed a mobility committee in response to the September 6th discussion as well. So we're working on putting together that committee and having our first meeting to talk about goals and how we're going to move forward with that. And that's all I have. Any questions?
3:49:23 Congratulations. Thank you. Can you please advise the Council on your promotion? Thank you. I was promoted last Monday from Community and Economic Development Manager to Community and Economic Development Director. Wow. Thank you so much. Nice job. Well done. Madam Director, when do you anticipate that the responses to the questions that were brought up by the PEDC and the Council on that old Mammoth Place proposed development agreement?
3:49:52 Would be forthcoming, do you think? Well, we have all of the comments identified. We're working to put together all of the responses. So it's probably a couple weeks. Some of it is maybe...
3:50:04 Further analysis is needed, and we will have to spend some time putting together that analysis. Because there were some recommendations or requests for financial analysis, which is going to take some time to put that together. But in the next couple of weeks, we'll have that document available. Okay, I just want to make sure that we don't create the false impression. Even though we're continuing the public hearing, that's more for technical purposes, that the community doesn't have a sense that this is...
3:50:28 My sense is this is not imminent to come back and to look at this again. This might be in the new year probably by the time we get to this. I would anticipate that. There is a lot of work to do on this project. Good. And the other just as a little takeaway is the walk, bike, ride. We even heard it tonight. Those things that are in the walk, bike, ride thing, they need to get...
3:50:46 Into people's hands and people start working on this stuff pretty quick. There's a bunch of these things. I know for the snow management workshop, there's a bunch of things in there that overlap with this stuff. So very exciting. Thanks for putting it together that group. And those are my questions. Thank you. Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works. Three things real quick. On the airport, we are interviewing the proposed consultants for the architecture and engineering this Friday. We have four that we're interviewing.
3:51:11 The submittals for the environmental work that are actually due tomorrow. I think it's by 4 o'clock. We already got three submittals on that. So we're looking forward to a good turnout there as well.
3:51:21 Two projects in town, quite visible. One is Upper Main Street. Please take a look and on the weekend, you know, walk by and actually take a close look. It's a really interesting project how they're putting soil nails and gunite into the thing and they'll end up looking, the wall will look something like the lakes basin wall, very similar to that. They will be done with the wall in about three weeks and then the sidewalk will progress from there and hopefully the last thing will be the bus stop which will be relocated.
3:51:47 We put a new spot. The last one is the police station. Had a good conversation with Sarah today. Yes, it will open very soon. Operational by October 2nd. We've been cutting, I believe it's October 5th. And a further ceremony a couple weeks later with the court because they're going to do a little walkthrough. If you go over there now.
3:52:06 Please check with us or check with the site superintendent. If you want to take a look at it, let us know first because it is an active construction site. It is a contractor site. It's not really ours, so we're very respectful of their need. The other day, I think there were 37 people in there at once trying to finish up because there's a lot of little details as in any construction project right at the end. Thank you. Questions, everybody? Got a couple.
3:52:37 There's conduit. There's a lot of crews out there working on stuff. And I just want to make the council aware that public works staff has identified there's some undergrounding efforts going on and that these guys are picking up with that, looking for opportunities to make sure that if there's any trench work happening, we're getting conduit on the ground for digital 395. That's sort of floating around, but I hope that's going to come back to us, hopefully with a dig once policy.
3:53:01 We'll give staff some leverage to make sure that those things happen. But thank you for paying attention to that stuff. The airport, the Mammoth Inyo Air Working Group, which is a subcommittee of the ESCOG, there's a meeting, I think, coming up maybe in October, first couple weeks of October. I think that it's very important to understand that it's certainly, I think,
3:53:24 My expectation, I think Councilman Richardson's expectation that at those meetings that Mammoth Lakes Tourism will be there, that represented from the mountain will be there, so that we're all meeting as a group to really beat up and go over reliable regional air service. There's a bunch of discussion at the Mono County Supervisors' meeting about the recreation position. Money was moving around fast and furious and some money got taken out of the air subsidy.
3:53:49 But I think in my conversations with some of the supervisors, it's very important for them to understand, okay, if you don't put something in the subsidy this week, understand that you need to be president and part of these discussions with that regional air group. There may be some reconfiguring going on, but I think we're looking to get Monro County's participation to be more substantial, more meaningful over the long term. I think it's very important to have them be part of that.
3:54:15 Mammoth and Yo Air Working Group. We're looking to have that in the middle of October. It might be up here in Mammoth rather than down in Bishop just for scheduling reasons. And tomorrow we're having our regular air service group meeting. And part of the reasons we have that is to have MLT and the mountains representative there to make sure they understand what their expectations are for that next group meeting. Because it's got to be everybody regionally talking about this stuff. And finally, the police station sounds like things are in pretty good shape and there's going to be a ribbon cutting.
3:54:44 October 5th, after the next council meeting, so just so you guys all know about that. And I think it would be nice if at the next council meeting, October 4th, a representation about status of budget, timing, all that kind of stuff. There's a lot of kind of not so well-informed things flying around that I get in the email ether that it would be nice to have representation of public works staff in the town as to how that thing will actually come. And the best I want to do at this point is to state that it's very close to on budget. I mean, it's within...
3:55:12 One or two percent, frankly, of the overall. But when you're negotiating final changes that close out of a project, that's something we need to finish before we want to be able to announce that.
3:55:23 And we're on schedule from what I understand, basically, right? Yes, we had 58 weather delays we gave them. The lease runs out December 31st. We've already started to move a few things over. Yes, we'll be paying rent for a couple of months. It's $5,700, I believe it was, per month. Okay. I looked that up today.
3:55:43 As I described earlier today, too, it's not like a restaurant where you can say, we're just going to close for a week and take care of this. You don't close the police station. So it will be a transition a little bit at a time over the next couple of weeks. Good. And I very much appreciate your forthrightness when we're talking to the public about these things, but I think having that information out in front, whatever it is, is going to be important. Absolutely. Thank you. Those are my questions. Thank you. Anybody else? John, if I may. Sure.
3:56:09 Last few meetings here a while back, we were talking about refinancing potentially the judgment from the Mammoth MLLA legal action, and one of the key elements on that was going through a rating process to look at what our debt rating would be. That's been completed. Tuesday morning, we were formally notified by Standard & Poor's that the rating assigned is an A.
3:56:32 From the long-term rating to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for judgment obligation bonds, and the outlook is stable. Okay, can you just repeat that for the member, the person in the audience who's still with us? No. You know, getting that rating on the bond, it's pretty exciting. It's an A slash stable, if you will, but it's so, their rating sign is it's an A long-term rating to the Town of Mammoth Lakes judgment obligation bonds, or the bonds we wish to issue to take out the...
3:57:01 That's the money that we're currently paying. And the outlook is stable, which is good for that. The report goes through and they identify a lot of elements there. Based on that, that was nice. We're looking at pricing bonds mid-October, the 11th and 12th timeframe. And again, everything holds. We're looking at annual savings of $100,000 plus or minus, hopefully plus. But that'll be a good, I think it's over the life, it's about a little over 2.2 million in savings.
3:57:30 To the town. So we're very pleased with that. And the fact that we're able to achieve that rating surprised myself. So we heard about it on Friday at the League of Cities meetings. We had a little happy dance going. So we'll not repeat that here. My understanding is you were at the Lions Club today. Is that right? Lions Club. Yes. So it's the Lions first. Correct. Good.
3:57:54 We shipped it out to staff and council first. I think those of us in Sacramento heard it first. But it was not for public consumption at that point. Until they got their formal report out to us. But it was really good news, moving from a C rating with the bankruptcy to an A at this point in time and the steps in between that, I think it's...
3:58:14 Maybe it's the finance side, you know, Rob maybe, but we were stoked. I mean, to be able to get that type of rating was huge, so. Great work. Anyway. In five years to come from a. I'm stoked. Dan's stoked. Maybe it doesn't show, but I'm stoked. That's going to be the title of an article. I'm seeing a headline. Yeah. I think that's pretty remarkable. Five years to go from a C junk bond rating to an A is pretty remarkable.
3:58:43 Something's going right. That's exciting. A lot of hard work by a lot of people, but it was great to have that. Well done. Congratulations. Good job. Much more than we anticipated. So with that, thank you. Good. Thank you. Thank you very much. Sorry. I was going to announce employee promotion. Oh. However, that's already been done. So, Sandra, congratulations again on moving from the manager to the director level for the community economic health department. I think she was sufficiently flustered and embarrassed right up here. That's why we're doing it again. Good. So, well-deserving.
3:59:14 Yep. Thank you. Good. So we're good. I think we'll move now. We will close and adjourn the regular session of this council meeting and move into a closed session. Thank you all very much. Yeah, all of you. Yeah. There's a lot of hurt right there. Yeah, I was about to say. Yeah. Right there. Good quote.