Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2017
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 1 hr 41 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
205 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Yeah, we can do that.
0:29 That's the way I'm talking to my computer. Oh. All right. Everyone ready? Yes. Okay. Thank you for coming. I'd like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, October 11th. Could we do roll call, I think, or pledge of allegiance? I always forget which comes first. Commissioner Eckert? Here. Commissioner Chang? Here. Chair Kalanen?
1:09 Here. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Here. Commissioner Burroughs? Present. Please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Greg, would you like to lead us? Okay. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, univisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right, we'll start with a public comment.
1:41 A public comment is a period for anyone to come up and speak on an item that is not on today's agenda. Come on up. Good afternoon, Chair Callahan, Commissioners, Shereen Sanders, Code Enforcement Officer for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I just want to give you a brief update, what's going on out in the world here. About two weeks ago, I spoke at a workshop presented by the Mammoth Lakes.
2:11 Housing Association, along with the California Rural Legal Assistance Organization, it was a workshop for landlords and tenants and detailed their rights and responsibilities. We had pretty good turnout in the morning with landlords, not as much for tenants, but we're hoping to do something similar in the future, and the town is trying to sponsor something in the beginning of next year based on substandard housing specifically.
2:40 I'm also working with Lieutenant Hugelman, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department and the District Attorney's Office to expand our solid waste protocol. The DA is giving us help with prosecuting cases of repeat offenders for trash bills and feeding of wildlife. Tis the season, we're seeing a proliferation of more unpermitted building. I think people are trying to get ahead of
3:09 The winter, maybe skipping a few steps. And a little more abandoned furniture and debris around the neighborhoods as people are getting ready to move in for the season. Also working with a number of businesses in getting rid of their temporary business signs and getting their permanent signs placed. Any questions? Great. Thank you. Thank you. Good afternoon, Commissioners. Nice to see you all.
3:45 I'm Mickey Brown. I'm here today representing Mammoth Voices. I think most of you know Mammoth Voices is a gathering now of 50-some participants. We meet twice a month and our whole purpose is to have a forum of civic discourse on relevant issues in the town and also to promote education. We feel really strongly.
4:09 That historically we always wait too long to start preparing for our election cycle because Christmas happens and Martin Luther King and then we have to recover, right? So now it's February 1st and everybody looks at each other and says, oh, who's going to run for council? Well, it's too late because as you know, most of our votes are decided by absentee ballots that go out in May. So we have started a program called June 2018. Are we ready?
4:36 And the first part of the program is just to go out and really start talking about our June 2018 elections. Our second part is we're doing a three series that are going to be on three Monday evenings starting October the 30th from 7 to 9 p.m. at the Fort in the Sierra Center Mall. And the purpose of the series is to give what we call the lay of the land. So the first Monday night will be on the town of Mammoth Lakes.
5:04 And NGOs. And our keynote speaker is sitting over there at the staff table. Sandra will be helping us that night along with Dana Stroud. The second night will be, so the next Monday, will be on...
5:23 Mona County and Special Districts. And then the third one will be on how to run a campaign. And Colin will do the first part about how to put a campaign together. And the second part will be the how to file and to keep within the fair practices. So we're really excited about the second part of our program. And then the third part is we're going to do a mentoring program for anybody that would like to run for office or for any appointed positions.
5:52 So you can really help by starting to invite people to consider running for council or start considering running for commission seats if any of you are deciding, I know two of you are up, if you decide you're not going to rerun because the whole purpose is to really get more people in our community involved so that we have a broader base of representation. And one key note is that Mammoth Voices is a nonpartisan group. Not me particularly, but the whole group is.
6:21 Does anybody have any questions? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Haisl Hayes, Engineering Manager. Just a quick update on construction activities. We've pretty much completed our road rehabilitation program for the summer. That's the trail slurry, microsurfacing, reconstruction of hillside. We just have some light cleanup to do and shoulder backing. Police station is...
6:51 Just about complete. We've had our ribbon cutting, just a couple punchless items and then we'll be out of there. We are still working on the sidewalk on Main Street. The structural components, the retaining wall should be complete on the 15th of this month. We are going to continue working on that project until weather shuts us down. If the weather holds, we could be completed by November 15th is what we're projecting. That's of course weather dependent. We will have to come back next
7:20 Spring to do some asphalt patching because we're not going to, the plants will be closed by the time we get to that work. So our hope is to be operational for this winter, but we'll see what this winter brings us. That's great. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Any additional public comment? Okay, seeing none, I will close the public comment period and we'll move on to our first business matter, the Winter Transit Service Workshop. And our contact is John Helm.
7:54 Good afternoon, Commissioners. John Helm, Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. I'd like to take this opportunity typically at this time of year to talk about our transit services and particularly any upcoming changes that we're considering or proposing for the winter season. It's clearly a seasonal economy here in the town of Mammoth Lakes and our services do change during the course of the year slightly from winter to summer. We have a few items that I wanted to go over with the Commission today.
8:38 Just as an overview, two modifications to the purple line. I'll discuss those a little bit more in detail in a moment, but to travel northbound on Manzanita through the Sierra Valley sites, and then also to use an alternating piece on the very eastern part of the route, servicing the elementary school college and the RV Park and Visitor Center. Secondly, I wanted to talk about a little bit, again, to revisit a relocation of Stop 81 on Lower Lakeview Boulevard.
9:07 This summer prior to the winter to make sure that that's acceptable where it is or to see if we need, if we get direction to revisit that. And then lastly, I want to provide an update on service to the Old Mammoth Road area west of Snow Creek. That's the area that was impacted by the cessation of the Gray Line at the beginning of last winter. There are some discussions underway involving ESTA staff, Town of Mammoth Lakes staff to
9:34 Look at a solution that would allow us to bring service back to that area. So I'll have an update on that. So beginning with the Purple Line route modifications, what we're proposing is to modify the routing that is in place right now and that has been in place for the Sierra Valley Sites area for that route for quite some time to have the route travel northbound between Meridian and Main Street on Manzanita.
10:03 And then to travel southbound on the way back to this point along Lupin Street. It'll probably be easier to explain looking at the maps. Historically, we cut over on Dorrance to Lupin and then went north on Lupin because our entrance and exit to Main Street was at that entrance from the frontage road that's just west of Lupin. So it made sense. We were going that way toward the village anyway, both coming and going from the village.
10:35 And so it made sense to kind of go up Lupin that way to do that. Last year at this time we proposed to the commission and put into place at the beginning of the winter season a modification for safety reasons where we actually now enter and exit Main Street at the frontage road entrance at Manzanita. And the reason for that is it's a lot less steep. The entrance from that frontage road entrance west of Lupin is quite steep trying to get onto...
11:02 Maine, and it was difficult for the buses to get started in inclemented weather and slick roads. So this has been a big improvement for us safety-wise, but partway through this winter, we kind of looked at the map and we looked at what we were doing and said, you know, this doesn't really make a lot of sense to zig over on Dorrance to Lupin, up to the frontage road, back to Manzanita and get on. The other thing that drove this is the Purple Line route is...
11:28 A very tight route. It's 30 minutes from start to end to make the complete loop from here from the Vons parking lot back to the Vons parking lot. And if everything goes well and the roads are clear and hardly anybody gets on, you can make it in 30 minutes. If any of those things go bad, then you get behind and it's difficult to catch up. So every minute that we're able to gain in terms of scheduling and design of this route really can help.
11:56 Long explanation, but what we're proposing is to go to move those two stops that are northbound on Lupin over to a corresponding location on Manzanita. The route will just go straight up Manzanita again on Main Street. When it's coming back here from the village, it'll turn down just as it does now and travel south all the way on Lupin just as it does now. The second proposal along the Purple Line route is to do something that we experimented with this summer, and we feel that it was a success.
12:29 And that being a modification to add a little time to that route. I mentioned that it's very, very tight. And it got tighter last winter when we added a piece of the former gray line, the piece going down to the college and wrapping around wagon wheel and by the elementary school to the purple line route. That wasn't formally a part of the route. But it was an important area to be serviced. Lots of ridership from that area.
12:56 And the only route that we had that could accommodate it at all was the purple line. So we just added it on. But realistically, it was adding too much time to that route, and we were consistently getting behind and not having any opportunity to make it up during the day. So we experimented last summer, and we had it alternate between going down to the skate park on one run, and then not going to the skate park, but going to the RV and visitor center the other run.
13:26 The rest of the route, the entire rest of the route is serviced every run, every 30 minutes. But those two destinations were serviced only every 60 minutes. So again, a map may help. But what we're proposing to do here is we have a departure every 30 minutes. So from here on the hour and on the half hour. We're proposing is the on the hour departure. We'll travel down here, down Meridian.
13:53 Pass the college, turn on wagon wheel, and then come back by the school. And the reason that that's being proposed that way is to have the school's bell times, particularly in the afternoon, they won't be met, but it's the departure from Vons that most closely meets that.
14:14 The bell times are somewhere between 40 and 50 minutes after the hour, and this route will be there just a few minutes past the top of the hour. So it would be a little bit of a wait, but it would be 30 minute longer wait if we did it on the 30 after the hour departure, if that makes sense.
14:32 And then the 30 minute after the hour departure, what we're proposing, and this is what is actually a slight modification from what was in the original packet, but I had further discussion with our staff and they were thinking, gosh, to do that whole college piece and wagon wheel and elementary every run.
14:53 If we do that and the RV and the visitor, we think we're going to get too far behind in that run. So we're proposing that that be done only every other. So it would depart here at Vons, go out, turn left on Sierra Park, go by the high school, go to the RV park visitor center, and then return to the route and go back out. What we found last summer is every run went by the college. And the one that went by the college and the RV park
15:21 Would tend to get a minute or two behind, but the other run that just went to the skate park would pick up a few minutes. So over the course of an hour, we were able to stay on time. And we are thinking that will be the case this winter if we put this into place and are able to do this. Again, one of our problems last winter, now, last winter was a doozy, and on-time performance was impacted by a lot of things.
15:49 Even had we not had the 200% of normal snowfall or precipitation amounts, we don't think that we could have stayed on time regularly on the purple line. And when you have a route like that that is that tight, anyway, every minute you get behind, if you get behind two minutes on your first run, then you start the next one two minutes late, and you get behind a minute on that, now you're three minutes late, it just keeps compounding. And when we would get 15 to 20 minutes late, we were so far off schedule, we just...
16:17 Miss a whole loop, wait to get back on schedule and start again. But we think that this is a modification of the route that will allow us to maintain reasonable on-time performance. So those are the two service change proposals that we're coming forward with presenting to the commission today, looking for feedback from the commissioners and from the community on that. But in discussion with town are intending and then based...
16:47 On the feedback we get today, we'll bring that to the ESTA board and to the town council and plan to look at potentially implementing this with the beginning of the winter season, which is basically when the red line starts just before Thanksgiving. So one other point that I wanted to discuss with the commission today, last year, right before the beginning of the season, in fact, this map will probably help, but we moved stop 82.
17:18 From its former location, the red dots here are the former location, the yellow dots are where these stops are currently located. So 82 was here, which I'm showing with the pointer, on Lakeview right across from Mammoth Estates. This is the trolley? This is the trolley and the blue line. Any route that operates there coming down Lakeview. With the completion last fall of the new town parking lot adjacent to the Westin,
17:47 And the transit stop that was constructed in association with that. We moved stop 82 to that location and we rerouted the route so it doesn't go down that last little segment of Lakeview but instead turns right on Hillside and travels down Hillside past the new parking lot to the new stop 82. When we did this, this was gone. 81 then was the last stop on Lakeview.
18:16 Which was up here, right at the entrance to Canyon Ski and Racket and Mammoth View Villas. To accommodate this impact on Mammoth Estates, we moved this stop about 100 to 150 feet north on Lakeview to this location. In so doing, we did hear from Canyon Ski and Racket and Mammoth View Villas last year, concerned about the additional distance, walking distance for their guests, residents and guests to that stop.
18:47 We replied and were in the midst of, by the time that the comments came in, we were really in the midst of almost the holiday season and then we were in the midst of 40 days and 40 nights of snow. So we diplomatically put it off until another time and that other time really is now. And this is the opportunity to revisit it. If we need to relocate it, it's certainly something that can be considered. But the reason that it was moved north there was to try to make it more equidistant between
19:16 All the properties there and specifically to minimize or reduce the negative impact on Mammoth Estates. So anyway, that is that issue and I did want to revisit it in response to the concerns that Canyon Skin Racket had raised. And last but not least, options for service on Old Mammoth Road. As I mentioned, the
19:44 The Gray Line was discontinued in December of last year. And that really impacted two areas. One is the area we were just talking about here on the east part of Meridian down to the skate park because the Gray Line serviced that. And none of the other routes did at that time. But we accommodated that by adding that section through the college and turnaround on wagon wheel to the purple line.
20:14 It provided service to it, but it negatively impacted the Purple Line and our wait times, but there was service. The other area that was really most impacted was the area on Old Mammoth Road west of Snow Creek Athletic Club. The Gray Line used to turn around, travel out Old Mammoth Road and turn around at the base of Red Fur Road and come back. And so this entire area had service every 30 minutes from 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. year-round.
20:43 And that was a piece that we just could not find a solution to last year. But we have not forgotten it, and that's probably my primary point today. I want to let the commission and the community know that we have not, and we're continuing to try to look for a solution. The real issue is a turnaround point. But we need, as we've modified this route,
21:08 The trolley route, which provided service, again, the reason for that change was for the first time ever we provided service year round and into the night to this entire Meridian corridor area. And that was a gap in our service that was identified in our last short range transit plan with a recommendation that we find a way to provide service to that area. That was proposed to the commission and town council and the ESTA board last fall and put into place.
21:38 In December, where now the trolley provides year-round service to that area day and night, 365 days a year. It's supplemented during the daytime hours, in the winter when the gray line runs, but anyway, there's consistent service to that entire area. So that was the benefit that the change of the gray line
22:02 brought about, but the negative is the impact on these folks and visitors who are out in this area of town. Our problem, though, is the trolley route, which is on this map illustrated in the maroon line and the red line, which is illustrated in the red line on the map, are serviced by larger style buses, not our small cutaway buses that used to run the gray line, but rather
22:31 The buses that are, whoops, the buses that are shown at the bottom of this picture here, the trolleys and the 40-foot transit coaches. And they need some significant room to turn around. There isn't any place, viable place, further, right now, further out from Club Drive and where we turn around at Snow Creek Athletic Club to accommodate those vehicles.
22:56 But we've been in discussion with town staff. We have a potential idea that's being discussed to identify and develop a turnaround location further out Old Mammoth Road that could allow us to provide service with the trolleys and with the red line. And that would be 365 days a year, day and evening service to that area. So it's not a done deal. I want to make sure that the commission and the community is aware of that.
23:24 And there are many hoops that will need to be gone through and completed to make it happen, but it's definitely a possibility in that we are working to see if we can make happen. So that's the update regarding that. I will make one other editorial comment, if I may. I receive emails and I receive comments, and in fact, I notified a number of people about this discussion at today's meeting and the fact that it was going to be on the agenda today.
23:52 Who had expressed concerns about the loss of service in the Old Mammoth area last year. And invariably the emails are titled something to the effect, bring back the, excuse me, bring back the gray line, or please bring back the gray line. Well, 95% of the area that was serviced by the gray line has continued to be serviced by transit, whether it be the trolley, the red line, the green line.
24:20 Or one of our other routes, the purple line, which we expanded to that. It's really not bring back the gray line. What they're asking for, and legitimately, I get it, because they used to have service and they don't right now, is service to Old Mammoth Road. So that really, semantically, is more accurate to what we're wanting to address here. But I'm cautiously optimistic that...
24:44 The plans that are being discussed may be able to come to fruition and that we may have soon as service there sooner rather than later. So actually, let me go back. So this is the area, generally speaking, where we're looking at.
25:03 Potentially developing and having a turnaround that can accommodate the trolleys and the 40-foot transit coaches. If that is the case, we would do away with the turnaround at Snow Creek Athletic Club. We'd just have a stop along Old Mammoth Road somewhere there for folks that want to go into Snow Creek. And we would just travel out to this area, turn around, and head back. And it would be as or more efficient and effective than what we're doing right now anyway.
25:33 So to recap, two modifications on the purple line that we're intending to put into place this winter to travel northbound on Manzanita and then southbound on Lupin and then also to alternate service here on the east end between the college loop on one of the runs and then the RV visitor center on the other run.
25:53 Also, the comment to determine from comment from the community or the commission if stop 81 needs to be re-looked at, the location of that stop, and then the quick update on the service out to Old Mammoth Road. That concludes my presentation. I'd be happy to answer any questions or address any questions. Thank you, John. Questions from up here, and then we'll open it up to the public. Yep. If that works for you. Let's start over here.
26:22 How much longer would it take just to make a loop around Redford instead of doing a turnaround at Snow Creek? Well, I mentioned that many of our routes are tight on time, and they are, the Red Line in particular in the winter. We think that that adds potentially five more minutes, and once you get to that point and start up that residential street,
26:51 How much have that increased since?
27:29 Your last year's presentation. Actually, I think year over year, the purple line decreased slightly, but I think that is a function of last winter and our challenges just operating and our challenges being on time with the route. On stop 81, are you able to move, keep the former stop 81 and then
28:01 Move the existing 81 down further right before you make your right turn in two. Technically, yes, I would advise against it because I feel that they are too close. When we start to get stops so close to one another, it reduces the efficiency of the route to the point that you're just stopping every five seconds. On the purple line, if you add another additional bus, so instead of doing it,
28:36 Every 30 minutes. You do it every 20 minutes. What's the cost on that? What's the additional cost to having it? As a ballpark, and this is a rough off the top of my head, $100,000 to add an additional, $80,000 to $100,000 to add an additional bus? Per year. Per year. John, you mentioned that the Purple Line runs, right now, it runs every 30 minutes, and it's a really, really tight schedule.
29:14 I'm just sort of curious why the mindset of adjusting the route to fit into what is seemingly kind of an arbitrary schedule rather than adjusting the schedule to fit what would be a more appropriate route. Like, for example, if you went to the skate park and to the visitor center on every trip and it makes it a 35-minute trip instead of a 30-minute trip, is there...
29:41 Am I missing something? I know it's a little more convenient to think of, the purple line runs on the 30 and on the hour, but there's nothing written in stone saying that that has to be the case, is there? There is not, although the points you're mentioning are points that we consider in the design of our routes and the timing. One thing, if we did, as you're suggesting, and it became a 35 or a 37 or a 40 minute loop,
30:11 As opposed to the 30, that's a diminishment of service because it's longer every run and at every stop between buses, longer than 30 minutes, somewhat longer. The other thing is it is difficult. I mean, say it was 35 or 37 or whatever, you would have to have every time posted at every stop. As opposed to right now, we can say the bus stops here at 24 and 54 minutes past the hour type thing. I understand that.
30:40 And so far as looking at it as a diminishment in service, it is to a certain extent, but then it might not be if you consider that you can go to the skate park and go to the visitor center on every trip instead of every other trip. So that would be an increase in service, really. For those two destinations. Right. I understand that it's a trade-off. I don't know anything about the philosophy of public transit.
31:12 One thing is you really do need to try to keep it simple in order for folks to be able to understand the schedule, understand when the bus is supposed to be at this stop. And I rarely have seen systems that have schedules where it's a different number of minutes past the hour every time the bus comes by, just for that reason, because it's so confusing that people look at it and go, oh, I can't.
31:40 I can't figure it out. They'll see this huge timetable just for one stop and get confused. Okay. Did you have a question following up on that? It looked like you had something else to say. No? Okay. Okay, moving on to the Lakeview Boulevard. Okay. Where is stop number 80, the one that comes before the stop that you've moved? It is... Go back and I can...
32:18 If I can, the distance from the red 82 to the red 81, it's roughly that distance further back up Lakeview. I mean, that seems logical, so okay. I mean, I don't know how you choose. Which stop is better? Probably if you go back to the former 81, you'll hear more comments from the Mammoth Estates people.
32:46 We may well. And I don't know if there's a representative today from Canyon Skeen Racket or Mammoth Estates or Mammoth View Villas, but we may hear some comment today regarding that. Okay. What's the ridership from there in the wintertime? It's pretty high. Again, that area is served by both the Blue Line in the winter, which goes village to Canyon Lodge and back, which is a very busy route.
33:19 And the trolley in the evening. One of the comments that I did receive from the gentleman at Canyon Ski and Racket was that in their opinion, the ridership was low from Mammoth Estates. We don't keep specific statistics by stop. We just don't have the resources to be able to do that. So I don't have a definitive number.
33:46 The share. But both of those are busy routes, the blue and the trolley through that area. You're saying one of the property owners, property management, saying the ridership is... In their opinion, the former Stop 82 and ridership from Mammoth Estates, in that person's opinion, was relatively low. I don't have any specific comments about the gray line. I'll be interested to see what some of our members of the public have to say. So, thank you.
34:20 I've got a couple of quick questions. Okay. John, the relocation of Stop 81 from the former red to the current yellow, what would be your best guess as to the actual distance? Is that like half a block? Is that a, I mean, no mammoth blocks are a little bit wonky, but. It'd be a half of a fairly short block. Half of a very, of a fairly short block. Fairly short. I think it's, I think I paced it off and it's about 150 feet, I think. And the reason you relocated.
34:46 81 to the current location is it's more centrally located for more condo complexes. Am I correct in that? Correct. That was the intent. Okay. The other question I had, John, was concerning the possible expansion of the red line up Old Mammoth Road. With the elimination of the turnaround at Snow Creek,
35:09 And the possible extension of the red line that goes up Old Mammoth Road, how many stops are you envisioning from Snow Creek up? I'll answer that by saying roughly the number that we had previously when the gray line was in place there. So I want to say that would be, there's one at Aspen Village for sure that would be there. There would be probably a new one at Snow Creek itself or by the fire station.
35:39 So it would be Fire Station, Aspen Village, and then two or three more going up, I would believe. Got it. And the turnaround, the possible turnaround that you guys are investigating right now, would that be below the Redford Loop or above the Redford Loop? Below. Below the Redford Loop, okay. And just to reiterate what you had mentioned, John, this would be year-round red line service, is that correct?
36:09 Accurately, it would be year-round transit service with either the red line during the day in the winter months or the town trolley. Got it. And day and night. Day and night. Got it. Thank you, John. Just looking for some clarification, is there not going to be a route at the skate park anymore or a stop at the skate park anymore? We've never served the skate park during the winter.
36:36 There is, and it's getting service right now, but it's alternating. It has service every 60 minutes right now. Okay. So during the summer it's still going to stay there? Correct. Okay. Basically it's when there isn't snow on the ground. We have a soft transition date in the fall, and it's when it gets covered with snow we stop going down there. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions up here before I open it up to the public? No.
37:07 Any members of the public would like to comment or ask questions? Thank you. If you could please just state your name for the record. Good afternoon. My name is Dawn Schultz. I'm an Old Mammoth resident and I have had many conversations with Mr. Helm over last year. We are not only residents of Old Mammoth, we're a business owner, we own the Edelweiss Lodge on the corner of Waterford and Old Mammoth. So last year when the bus route did change, it not only affected us personally for our child and getting to school, but it affected our business and we had to change.
37:41 Our website, our brochures, our paperwork, because we're no longer directly accessed to a bus stop. My big concerns and questions that we did bring up last year was continuing it through Red Fur and why it couldn't continue through Red Fur versus building an entire pullout and a change around. But as it sits right now, listening to Mr. Helms' presentation, a couple things that kind of occurred to me that bothered me a little bit is we're worried about stops that are 200 feet apart up by canyon.
38:08 But if you measure from where the bus stops at Snow Creek to the center edge of Redford, it's a mile long. If I remember from last year at City Council, our town plan is to have a bus stop and bus service within a quarter mile to all residents of Mammoth. There is no service and there has not been service to an entire mile and a quarter of permanent residents, which...
38:34 10% of the residents, 20% of the residents, I don't know what population we are, but it's quite large, and we have no bus. We're very concerned about making sure our visitors that are in the busy parts of town get service. The smaller parts of town or the residents don't. Not only for that, but also Meridian has three lines a day that runs up and down at three, so on most days at any point, if you want to get from Vons,
39:00 Up to Eagle to go ski or anywhere else around that and you are lucky enough to live in that part of town, you have a million bus options. But again, one whole piece of town has no bus options. The gap in service is frustrating to say the least. We have, you know, we made changes in our lives as much as all of our neighbors have and we carpool and take turns but our kids don't have a ride to school anymore. They can if they want to walk in the winter.
39:30 And we want to let our children walk on Old Mammoth down to Snow Creek four or five blocks on a road that's scary with just one car, let alone our kids walking on it because the sidewalk isn't plowed. And at one point we were keeping a partial service for the Gray Line, but in February when the snow got really bad, they decided, they being the town, decided the stop in front of Aspen Village was no longer going to be used and it became snow storage.
39:58 So, I mean, it's a compounding issue, and I understand that the entire town needs bus service, but I think when we look at how we're going to spend the money and who gets it, I don't really think it's fair to say Meridian's going to get a ton of service, everything up by Canyon gets a ton of service, we're going to go by this spot 15, every 15 minutes because it's busy, but you're going to take an entire chunk of town that's almost a mile and a quarter long and give them zero. So, that's my... Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, Sarah Vigilani.
40:34 I want to echo what Dawn said, and John, thanks so much for not letting this issue drop. I really appreciate you guys caring about it, but I couldn't agree more with everything what Dawn said. It's just like, the town is four square miles. Like, let's have bus service to the main area where residents live. And plus, the gray line went to the hospital. And so it's connecting the main area of residents to the hospital. So, and the school.
41:00 And Vons, you know, so it was a pretty important line. And I just think we could be more creative with reinstating it for $80,000 to $100,000. I think we're all paying that right now by sitting in this room on our salaries and benefits. So $80,000 to $100,000 for a bus is not, we're not talking about a lot to connect so many people to the bus. And even if the ridership is low, the fact that people were on it every day.
41:25 So I just, I really want to see the Gray Line come back, not just, I think anything would be good, but the Gray Line specifically. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Kevin Graves, and I'm just a new resident to Mammoth, but we chose where we were going to live, and we fitted out our budget to be twice what we had budgeted, not just because things were kind of expensive in Mammoth, but also because we could fit it in with the transit.
42:05 So my wife and I both work at the mountain and we've run into a lot of people on our walks in the evening that also work at the mountain. And I think there needs to be some consideration for the people who do serve the tourism in this town. And so in our position, we can either walk a mile to Snow Creek or we can walk a mile to Eagle Lodge.
42:31 And depending where we're going to be deployed that day, hopefully we can get to work on time. So, you know, I think what John outlined about a creative solution is really hopeful and optimistic, and I think it makes a lot of sense. I don't have enough experience to comment on the gray line, but, you know, even if we have service on the hour so we can get home and so we can go to work, that's huge. But to have no service,
42:58 Means I'm either carrying cross-country skis to go to work or, you know, to get there, or I'm skiing down to Snow Creek. And there's times when that might be a pleasure, and then there's times when it might not. So I think that just, you know, representing or further representing some of the people who live in that, it's something, some kind of solution needs to be brought forth. Thank you.
43:28 Good afternoon, Commissioner. Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors, representing District 5. The Old Mammoth area that we're discussing with this transit issue is in my supervisorial district, so I've been trying to help the residents be aware of this issue and help express some of their concerns. And one, I think we made some excellent points this afternoon, and I really appreciate your consideration of this issue and ESTA's and look forward to finding a solution for transit in Old Mammoth.
43:57 One thing I wanted to point out as this relates to your planning tasks is in the walk, bike, ride plan, which is excellent. I fully support that. There are kind of multimodal
44:12 Options shown in Old Mammoth, like the trail at the end of Tamarack or the Mill City tract area, recreation points accessed from there, yet there's no public transit shown in walk, bike, ride in that part of Mammoth. So not only does public transit meet the goals, you've heard about this afternoon, about the needs of residents, of school kids getting to school, people getting to work.
44:38 This also really fits into what you're trying to do with walk, bike, ride and connecting recreation access to town and that is that that's a missing mile or two right there so consider that as well and just
44:52 Really making sure that the transit works, timing of it for the people that want to use it. I would really encourage the town and ESTA to consider forming some kind of focus group with many of these folks, like Dawn, who've come to numerous meetings and expressed their concerns. They all seem pretty willing to me to participate in the process, so I'd encourage you to get their feedback before coming up with any final plan, and I would respectfully request, too, that this commission recommend to the town if that's within your...
45:21 Thank you. Thank you. Any other comments from the public?
45:43 I'm Stacy Powell, speaking as a private citizen. I live in Old Mammoth, and I may have mentioned this the last time I was up here. I unfortunately, in my old age, am suffering from vertigo, and there are many times where I cannot get behind the wheel of a car, and I was counting on the gray line to be able to walk out there at the Sherwin Street bus stop to be able to get to town, to get to meetings, to do whatever I had to do, and for the gray line to not be there anymore, it's been a huge inconvenience. So for medical reasons, I would like.
46:13 to see that gray line reinstated, even if it's every hour, you know, starting at 6.30 to 7.30 to 8.30. Even the 7.30 route could get the kids to school, could do whatever. It doesn't necessarily, from my opinion, have to be every half hour, but even every hour would be great. So, thanks. Thank you. Any other public comment? Okay. Thank you all very much. I just wanted to say that we also received a letter, I think from a...
46:49 A resident in Old Mammoth. No. Oh, okay. There was one that... So, sorry. We'll just bring it back up here for any other further comment or questions from John. John, last question. I know it's tentative right now, but if there was going to be service along Old Mammoth Road via the kind of combo of redline trolley, would that be in place before the winter?
47:28 This coming winter? Unlikely. That would take a lot of things happening very quickly and perhaps even a late start to winter. So in order to accurately temper expectations, I would say that would be unlikely before this winter, given the timing. Unlikely before this winter, if the solution is to use the larger scale buses. Correct.
47:59 Is there any consideration still on the table of if, you know, if Town Council were to adequately fund one of the smaller bus routes that you could bring it back for the winter, for this winter? We could do that. I will kind of remind the commissioners, the arrangement with Eastern Sierra Transit Authority and the Town of Mammoth Lakes is a contractual one.
48:24 And we operate the transit service under a contract. We use the state and federal monies that the town receives through the LTCs for transit service here, along with funds that the town makes available from TOT collections. If the town came to ESTA and said, we would like you to operate X service to Old Mammoth Road beginning in November or December or whenever, we can and will do that. I would caution the...
48:52 Commissioners, as I would caution Town Council, again, we put together a service like that last winter to provide some service morning and evening to get kids to and from school and to get employees down into town where they could either go to work or catch other routes to get to work. And it was very, very lightly used, almost not used. But yes, to answer your question, technically, yes, we could do that. Okay.
49:24 What's lightly used mean? Can you quantify that? And again, I'm working from memory, but I think we had many days without any passengers. I think maybe we averaged two passengers a day on six runs, you know, three in the morning. Just for the old Mammoth? Old Mammoth Limited is what we call that route. Yeah. Was that less than what the ridership on the Gray Line had been?
50:02 Do you think it had to do with the schedule? Well, it's far less than what the ridership on the gray line was, but the vast majority of the ridership on the gray line before it was discontinued was from and within parts of town that are serviced by the purple or the red or the trolleys or the green line. So there continued to be service in those areas. But ridership, we did sample ridership by stops the last few months before the discontinuation.
50:32 West of Snow Creek and ridership was very low from that area at that time as well. Part of the reason, earlier you mentioned that the main reason is not because of funding, it was because of the turnaround. Am I correct? So really was the logistics or the transportation logistics.
51:07 It's two things, if I may, and funding was part of it. The expansion of service to the Meridian Corridor, which was accommodated through the modification of the town trolley route, required additional funds. It was an expansion of service. It was an expansion of a service area and service hours to that service area, and that required funds. As we modified, as we looked at that modification, we overlay the map, and we could see that the
51:36 The existing gray line was duplicated by one or more of the lines, trolley, red line, green line, purple line, throughout town, except in that old Mammoth area. So funding was part of it, and the funds that were used to pay for the former gray line were used to fund the expansion of the trolley service to the expanded service area.
52:02 The other aspect of it, though, is a logistical thing, in that we don't have a means to get the buses turned around. I mean, if there were last winter, if there were today, if there were tomorrow, we could modify the town trolley and the redline route almost immediately to begin service to that area. And as opposed to turning around at Snow Creek, we would turn around somewhere below Redford.
52:27 And that could be implemented as soon as that turnaround was able to be developed. If I might also, while I had a moment to sit down there, I was working off the top of my head. Actually, the gray line is 11 hours of service a day, or it was, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., 365 days a year. And at the contractual rate, that would be not 100,000, but 180,000.
52:59 To fully replace that route. But again, it would be very counterproductive because 95% of that would be duplicative of other services that are already out there. But we're not replacing it, we're simply just extending. No, but in terms of comments that were to just bring back the gray line as it was, that would be 180,000 if we ran 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. 365 days a year.
53:29 But it would overlap the town trolley route and the red line route and the green line route in almost all the most of the service area. The cost would not be that much if we're just talking about extension of that. Oh, if we can change the turnaround from Snow Creek to further out Old Mammoth Road below Redford, there's no cost. Got it. It's a zero cost. Okay. I personally think that
54:02 The cost even of $180,000 should not be a breaking point for us as a town. I mean, I think we as a town are charged with providing a public service to not just our residents but our visitors as well, but maybe even more importantly our residents and the children that live out there. I mean, I think this goes hand in hand with all of the other mobility issues that we've had.
54:27 Come before us as well as, I mean, it's also tied in with the housing problem that we have. Historically, the Old Mammoth area has been an area for, you know, at least somewhat affordable housing for both residents and seasonal employees alike. And I think something that they are all looking for is the opportunity for public.
54:51 Public transit. And if we are not able to provide that public transit, we are just shooting ourselves in the foot by limiting the locations that the people that we need to run this town are able to actually live. I'm a little disappointed that this hasn't been figured out as far as, you know, having a solution that is ready to go for this winter. You know, this has been on the table for almost a year. But if you say that the
55:18 The potential solution of either finding a turnaround or looping through Red Fur with one of the larger buses is an option, then I am 100% fully in support of recommending that the council move in that direction. That's just where I stand on it. It seems like even last winter was a gnarly winter, but realistically, less than 10% of the days in the year, it snows.
55:46 So if you can do Red Fur as a loop on any day that it doesn't snow to where the snow is blocking you from doing it, you can provide service out there for 90% of the time and you just indicated you can do it for no increased cost. I don't understand why this has taken so long since February to come up. Well, part of it is because Red Fur is not the desired route or turnaround. But it's the only thing you can do before winter because you're not going to build a turnaround anywhere else. If you're going to provide service to those people this winter, it has to be at Red Fur. Right.
56:15 But as I pointed out, that adds enough additional time to the route that that creates challenges of its own. I disagree. One other point I will make is... I think you can sacrifice a couple of minutes on a route and maybe you have to change your schedule and post a full day-long schedule instead of just saying that the route is running around every hour, every half hour.
56:47 I will also mention, and I'll preface this by saying it has been a few years, but when there was a discussion of service, of transit service traveling on Redford Drive regularly, like every 30 minutes, it was very vocally presented to town council no, in no uncertain terms, that the residents at that time, and I will acknowledge it's been a few years, did not want a bus every 30 minutes traveling up their street.
57:16 And that was the gray line that operated 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. What we're proposing here is our full town transit services, which is 7 a.m. until the early hours of the morning. So that's another consideration. And a full-size bus. Pardon me? And a full-size bus. And a full-size bus or trolley. Well, I understand you're not going to please 100% of the people 100% of the time. None of us can do that.
57:45 So maybe there's some kind of compromise and maybe that full-size bus only makes the red fur loop every hour instead of every half hour. I don't know. But I think it's important and crucial for us as a town that service to that area is restored for this winter. As do we at ESTA and as...
58:08 Does the town staff that I firmly believe. And that's why we're continuing to look at this. We're trying to develop a site that will turn around basically on Old Mammoth Road so that we're not impacting the residential street. And I get the fact that Old Mammoth Road really west of Snow Creek is closer to a residential street than not, but it's not as residential as Red Fur or Sherwin or any of the other true residential streets out that area.
58:37 Have you talked to the people that live in the houses directly in front of where you would propose to have the bus turn around on Old Man? It's one of the things that's being looked at, yes. I don't know. Public transit on a public street. This is true. I agree that we need to get service back into that area sooner than later. What is the next step here? Is this something that you...
59:14 Need to work up some more numbers or some more schedules or something and then take this to council. Sandra, we're not really being asked to... It's a workshop. Right, it's just a workshop, so yeah, no formal action will be taken, but I think that what I heard John say is that he's going to take it to the ESTA board and then to the council. So I think passing all of these comments on to the board and the council would be appropriate.
59:44 Okay. And I need to convey to the commissioners and to the community that we are actively working to develop meetings, discussions with the powers that be that are involved in a decision that could ultimately lead to the development of this turnaround. We're not sweeping this under the rug by any means. We're trying to move forward as diligently as we can. But I also want to temper the expectations of the community that it's not something that's that easy and that's going to come about overnight.
1:00:14 But we are actively working toward that. And we appreciate you doing that. But I think at the same time, it's a critical need for us in the past, currently, and also to complement what the walk, bike, ride program that we're trying to achieve. We've got to come up with something much sooner than later.
1:00:45 Public transportation is just so essential to what we're trying to accomplish here in this town, trying to get people off the car so they have opportunity to use the public transportation. And certainly we're not here to criticize your department specifically, just simply I think whoever is involved in this,
1:01:21 Got to make that decision ASAP. And like what Madam Chair just said, $180,000, in the scheme of things, it's not a lot of money. I mean, for crying out loud, our MLF budget just went up by $1 to $2 million here. So I'm sure we can certainly
1:01:57 Ask the councils to appropriate something out of it to mere needs. Sandra, is this something that can be added to the list of topics for the mobility working group? The mobility committee? Yeah, definitely. Well, it sounds like you definitely hear a consensus of opinions up here. Thank you very much. I know it's not an easy situation, but we appreciate you.
1:02:37 You know, trying to work towards a favorable solution sooner rather than later. Okay. I appreciate the Commission's consideration of this, and as Sandra pointed out, we'll definitely be sharing this input with my board and with town staff and council as appropriate. Great. Thank you very much, John. Thank you. Thank you, John. All right. Moving on to our next business matter, which is to consider the approval of the Major Design Review 16-
1:03:13 011 for the Town of Mammoth Lakes Multi-Use Facility, located at 686 Old Mammoth Road. Our staff is Nolan. I think we can proceed. Great, and just a quick item before we get started. An updated resolution was handed out to the Commission. Reflects expanded CEQA findings in the document. Copies of that have also been provided in the back of the room. I'm sorry, what was that last?
1:04:31 Additional copies are in the back of the room for the public. Great, thank you. Consideration of major design review 16-011 is the design review component of the multi-use facility project. Previous components included site and use programming, environmental review, and allocation of funding for the project by town council. The project site is located at Mammoth Creek Park West at 686 Old Mammoth Road.
1:05:02 The site is zoned public and quasi-public and is within the open space land use designation. The overall size of the site is approximately five acres and the current uses on the site include a playground, grass open space areas, picnic areas, a 44 space parking lot and trail connections. The scope of the project includes development of an Olympic size ice rink and associated 30,000 square foot roof that is partially enclosed on two sides.
1:05:33 Also construction of an attached community center that includes a 2,500 square foot multi-purpose room, lobby and ice rink viewing areas, lockers and restrooms, office space for recreation staff, and a concessions and rentals area. That area will also include a warming kitchen that the multi-purpose room can use. The project includes an additional 36 space parking lot and relocation of the existing playground.
1:06:01 Along with relocating the playground to the east of its existing location, new equipment that is accessible and inclusive will be provided, which will be usable by all groups. The overall project is being constructed to the west of the existing park amenities. The relocation of the multi-use facility began in April 2015 when Town Council directed staff to provide recommendations on possible locations that the multi-use facility could be relocated to.
1:06:32 Staff analyzed all town-owned properties, including the existing community center parcel, the bell-shaped parcel, Trails End Park, the park and ride site, Civic Center parcel, and Mammoth Creek Park West. Shady Rest and Mammoth Creek Park East were not included in the site selection process, since those are located on Forest Service property, and due to the existing use restrictions on those sites, the town would not be permitted to construct the project on those properties.
1:07:01 In October 2015, Town Council accepted the recommendation from the Malta Use Facility Working Group to relocate the Malta Use Facility to Mammoth Creek Park West and authorized the contracts for environmental review and project design in January 2016. Environmental review commenced in January 2016. The final environmental impact report, or EIR, was certified by the Town Council in May 2017.
1:07:29 Also in May 2017, the Town Council allocated the funding for the project. Initial project design began in March 2016 and the final project design was submitted in August 2017. The PEDC Design Committee reviewed the initial design at a design committee meeting on August 31st and provided feedback on the site design and the proposed materials and colors. Town staff and the architects incorporated those design changes
1:07:57 The revised project design and materials were submitted on September 15th. The design committee reviewed the revised design materials on September 21st and provided a recommendation to move the project forward to the PEDC for design review consideration. As noted earlier, the town council previously certified the EIR for the multi-use facility project. Along with that, the mitigation monitoring and reporting program was adopted.
1:08:27 The EIR found that the project would not result in any temporary or permanently significant and unavoidable effects on the environment and found that all potential impacts would be less than significant with mitigations incorporated. Pursuant to the CEQA guidelines and the California Public Resources Code, no subsequent environmental review was required for the design review portion of the project since one, the design review approval was contemplated in the EIR,
1:08:56 and the potential environmental impacts were evaluated in that EIR. Two, no substantial changes to the project are proposed which would require revisions to the EIR due to new significant effects or an increase in the previously identified effects. Three, no substantial changes have occurred with respect to the circumstances under which the project is being undertaken have occurred. And four,
1:09:23 As noted earlier, the project is with
1:09:55 within the open space land use general plan designation. This designation is intended to maximize recreation opportunities, protect sensitive environmental resources and includes uses such as parks, athletic facilities and community gathering spaces. The proposed project is consistent with this designation because it will provide a recreational opportunity
1:10:19 within an existing park, and is cited to protect and not impact the nearby Mammoth Creek Corridor. The project was found to be consistent with all applicable general plan vision statements, goals, policies, and actions for the community design element and the parks element. The project is within the public and quasi-public zoning district and was found to be consistent with all applicable standards and permitted uses.
1:10:49 That includes setbacks, building height standards, parking standards, and the permitted uses. The use of the site and the proposed project was found to be consistent with the public parks and playgrounds use classification and the uses permitted outright in the public zone. Some of the allowed uses include playgrounds, sports and recreation facilities, and food concessions and community centers within the facility.
1:11:20 Minimum front, side, and rear setbacks in the public zone is 20 feet. The proposed project has a front setback of 300 feet, side setbacks of 30 and 127 feet, and a rear setback of 93 feet. The building was cited the maximum distance from the nearby residential uses and environmental resources while still achieving the project goals of including an Olympic-sized ice rink and associated community center.
1:11:49 The building has a maximum height of 35 feet from finished floor, which is consistent with the zoning code and what was analyzed in the project EIR. Additionally, the grading cut on the western side of the project will drop the building down approximately 4 feet from existing grade along the western edge, and there is an existing 14-foot landscaped berm on the western side of the site, which will further shield the building from the adjacent uses to the west.
1:12:19 The zoning code does not specify the required number of parking spaces for recreational uses and indicates that the parking requirements shall be established by special review. The parking needs for the project were determined by looking at the anticipated programming of the site and the historical usage of the existing ice rink and community center. Based on the scale of the development proposed, it is determined that 80 parking spaces would be sufficient for the normal usage of the site.
1:12:48 The 80 parking spaces are achieved through usage of the existing 44 space parking lot and the additional 36 parking spaces proposed. During special events such as hockey tournaments, additional parking will be provided offsite. The location is required to be identified in their special event permit application. In addition to the vehicle parking sites, 14 short-term bike rack spaces will be provided and three long-term spaces will be provided on the inside of the building.
1:13:21 The site design component of the design review process analyzed the overall siting of the project. The building was sited to preserve the existing park amenities and maintain a maximum buffer between the project and adjacent residential uses and the environmental resources of Mammoth Creek. Additionally, the building was sited so that the views out of the building to the south and east would capitalize on the expansive views of the Sherwins.
1:13:46 The north and west sides of the building are enclosed in order to minimize light and noise impacts to the adjacent residential uses. The massing of the building is broken up through variations in building materials and colors. As noted earlier, the north and west sides of the building are enclosed and the south and east sides are open. The design guidelines recommend that long uninterrupted ridgelines be broken up.
1:14:12 Due to the design of this building as an ice rink and the need for a large uninterrupted interior space, there cannot be any interior support columns. Any change in roof height or variation in the ridgeline would require additional support features which cannot be achieved with this type of building. The design committee reviewed the ridgeline and agreed with staff that the ridgeline cannot be altered because of the nature of the building design and intended uses.
1:14:39 The proposed materials include Corten steel, split-face CMU block, hardy board siding, metal louvers, exposed structural steel, and a zinc gray metal roof. The colors selected are all earth tone colors and are intended to complement the natural environment. The design guidelines recommend that when a metal roof is used, it should be dark and muted and have a matte non-reflective finish. Due to the use of the site as an ice rink,
1:15:08 Interior of the structure needs to maintain a cool temperature and a dark roof would greatly increase the radiant heat transfer to the interior of the structure and compromise the ice. The proposed roof color does achieve the matte non-reflective color and will achieve the goal of creating a covered ice rink that is usable for up to six months a year since the lighter color will reduce the heat transfer to the ice.
1:15:34 The design committee reviewed the various roof colors proposed and selected the zinc gray color because it met these objectives. The findings that the commission are asked to make include finding the project consistent with the California Environmental Quality Act and the findings for a design review permit pursuant to Municipal Code 17.88.
1:15:59 Based on the staff's review and analysis completed as per the EIR certification process, staff's recommendation is to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving design review 16-011 with conditions as recommended by staff. And with that, that completes my presentation.
1:16:25 Myself and Hayes from Engineering as well as Stu Brown are available for any questions that the commission might have. Great. Thank you. Any questions? We start on this end this time. I'm going to defer that for now. I'll wait as well. Okay. I don't have any questions. Can you go back to the open space? This one. This here says maximize recreation opportunities.
1:17:20 Community gathering spaces. And what I'm about to ask might deviate from this design review. What's the Hispanic population here in this town? I don't know the population, but there's definitely a high Hispanic population. 30, 40, 50% probably. Because I would imagine at least. Somewhere in there. I wouldn't even begin to guess.
1:18:11 Has staff or recreation, Mammoth Lakes Recreation Task Force, during this entire process, have they ever engaged the Hispanic community about this entire plan?
1:18:42 I'm looking to Stu Brown for direction on this one, since really our component of the project was the design review of the structure, and so related to Stu Brown as far as their kind of general outreach went. That's why, because you presented this, so that's why I said it may not be appropriate for me to ask the question, this particular question, so, and I can understand, you know, we can certainly talk offline. Yeah, that might be something better.
1:19:10 Handled outside of this meeting. I just want to remind everyone that this item before us here as the Planning Commission is really limited to the design of the building and the site. Okay. And that's fine. As far as it's how it fits within our zoning code and the design guidelines. Which are my question? I would comment, though, if I may. You may. Thank you. Not directly, but, you know, the programming, you know, the essence was really to try and make sure we design from the inside out.
1:19:40 Right? So if you think about the outside and what you're reviewing, it was really the result of, you know, the programming and the intense kind of, you know, outreach through the community to really understand what was going to happen inside. So I think hopefully that might give you some kind of sense in the playbooks that were developed, you know, described and articulated those uses, which then informed the design of the facility. And I appreciate that. Yeah, generally. And the inclusiveness.
1:20:09 Was really through the outreach of all the workshops that we held. So, you know, they're all available, many, right? So we had a wide net. We invited everyone to participate and, you know, the playbooks of kind of how we inform that design of that facility. So I'm happy to answer any of the questions. And then the playground grant we can follow up on later, but that's something that was another process that we went through to, you know, analyze the park project itself. So good. Happy to answer.
1:20:38 Thank you. So just a reminder, what we're really here to discuss or decide is, you know, does this project fit within the CEQA guidelines, within the zoning code, within the design guidelines that have been adopted by the town? And any questions such as whether this is an appropriate project for the town to pursue or the site or the budget really is something that needs to be deferred up further on to the council. Question number two.
1:21:09 You use historical data for your proposed number parking spaces that you have. When you say historical data, you're talking about historical usage. How is that relevant to the programming in the future? Potentially, you're going to have quite a bit of people there, right? So how the numbers, the logic doesn't make sense to me.
1:21:43 Are you able to use a historical number? It seems, you know, to me seems a bit skewed. Sure, I'll look to Hayes, but I will add in. So the historical usage really kind of provides some baseline data for usage of the ice rink and usage of the existing community center up in the North Village area. And when you look to programming needs, they looked at, you know, all the different programs that would go into the site and worked to ensure that usage that would bring a large amount of people
1:22:13 You necessarily overlap with one another because if you had those, you would create conflicts on the site. And so that's part of what went into that. But again, I'll refer to Hayes. He worked directly with HMC Architects on that kind of programming and looking at the parking needs. Thanks, Nolan. Kind of elaborating on what Nolan said, we looked at a number of factors. There's no direct guidance.
1:22:37 on how to provide a parking number. There's no standard guidance on this. So we worked with our architects. We worked with the Recreation Commission. We worked with Stu to understand the playbooks and the programming and what that meant as number of users at one time, the transition periods between different uses that were programming. We looked at mode split. We looked at how many parents may just drop off their children or during adult recreation.
1:23:06 How many would park? And so we used a number of factors to try to figure out exactly what that parking number needed to be to meet the programming of the facility as you see here. I will mention that this is not the full build out, that we do have an expansion for this project, additional square footage that would also require additional parking.
1:23:26 We're not looking at special events. We're taking those one off because a hockey tournament is a much different scenario than an open skate or gymnastics. So we took into consideration a number of factors when determining the appropriate number of parking spots for this phase. Thank you. That's all I have. So in English, the historical use was a baseline for your projection that you're giving us. Correct. Great.
1:24:09 I don't particularly have any questions. I've seen this several times as a member of the design committee, as has Jennifer. So unless we have any other questions for staff, we'll just see if anyone in the public has some questions as well. Oh, I'm sorry. So the revision of this design, the proposed budget that I saw on the paper, that's what this updated design.
1:24:43 Have in mind? Yes, that's correct. None of the square footages or the project size did not change as part of the kind of revisions that were made from August to September. It was really just changes in colors and materials. And so those changes did not really alter the overall cost of the project. It does not. Did not, no. It changed, for example, the original roof color was a really light, almost white, and it
1:25:15 Went to a zinc gray, same material, same manufacturer. The CMU block was a lighter color gray and went to a darker color gray. Originally it was proposed to have natural wood cedar siding that was stained and would require ongoing annual maintenance. So it was proposed to go to a hardy board siding with a cedar color just to reduce that ongoing maintenance cost.
1:25:42 I believe that was the extent of the kind of material and color changes that occurred. So it didn't increase the cost in that phase of the project. Thank you. Okay. Are there any members of the public that have questions regarding the design of the building and the site? Okay. Well, seeing none, we will disclose that public comment, period, and bring it back up here.
1:26:15 As I mentioned, I've seen this now several times as a member of the design committee along with Commissioner Burroughs. And I just want to say that I think that staff and the architects and the design team have done really a fantastic job of taking what could really be an ugly, boring metal building and really incorporating it into the design guidelines that we have.
1:26:46 We've set as a town to make it something that is attractive but also utilitarian and as budget-friendly as possible given the scope of the project. I think that the input that we have given them as far as the materials and then being able to see this materials board here is very helpful and I personally think that
1:27:19 As aesthetically, as far as the site and the building, we've headed down the right direction. I have a really quick question, maybe more of a clarification, Nolan, if you wouldn't mind. In the mock-up that we received in our packet, it shows a fence that goes around the main building. Is there a material on the display board that is actually going to be the material used for the fence?
1:27:50 There is. The black fencing on the materials board is what will be used. And on this site, just for clarification, it is along the southern edge of the building. It really provides the kind of security on that kind of open side of the building. And so, yes, the material shown there is what will be used. It's not a chain-link fence. It's more of a, I don't know the exact word for it, but kind of a wire fence there.
1:28:21 Thank you. It's a giant step up from your standard chain link fence, but yet still provides visibility and security as well, it seems to me. And it blends into the overall project really, really nicely, I think. I understand the need for a fence. And as long as we've been told that it will hold up to our weather situations, I think it's a good solution.
1:28:55 Well, Madam Chair, are you, anybody else have any questions? Anybody may be interested in putting forth the motion? I'll make a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt, may I? Yeah. Absolutely. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution, making it require sequel and municode findings and approved major design review 16-0, excuse me, 16-011.
1:29:25 with a condition as recommended by staff. I'll second the motion. Okay. Any more deliberation before we go to a vote? Nope. Nope. Okay, can we have a vote please, Kim? Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chairperson Callanan? Yes. Commissioner Vanderhurst? Yes. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you all very much.
1:30:01 Okay, that concludes our major business matters for today. We do have an item on the consent agenda to approve the minutes of the regular meeting, our past meeting of September 13th, 2017. I would like to make a motion to approve the consent agenda and the regular meeting, the minutes from the regular meeting of September 13th, 2017. I'll second that. And we have a second. All those in favor? Aye. All right. Passes 5-0.
1:30:33 Okay. Commissioner reports. Greg, do you have anything you want to say? Okay. I made a few words today. Yep. Other than the housing working group that we're working on at this moment, actually, all the, we're pretty much finished with all our meetings. And at this moment, I think we're waiting for
1:31:05 The final document to be issued, to be presented, and that will be available on November 14th? We're having a joint meeting with the council on November 15th. On November 15th, yes. That'll be presented, but the document will be available for review before that meeting. And unfortunately, I will not be able to attend that meeting. Okay. Greg, will you be? Unless it's snowing, I'll be there. Okay. But I think it's going to be
1:31:43 A lot of great information for the community to consider. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you. Let's see. We had a design committee meeting where we did the final review of the multi-use facility, which we just discussed. Did we have one or two? Design committee meetings? I can't remember. No, I think just one. Ruth sent us an email here. I'm looking at the summary.
1:32:21 We also talked about the monument sign, the new monument sign for the Sierra Center Mall, which has been a work in progress for a while, so we should see that changing sometime soon. That's on the main street. That's on Old Mammoth Road here right across the street. Yeah, they're going to add the business names of the majority of those ground floor businesses. I see. And we looked at the monument sign for Footloose, not the one on Old Mammoth Road, but the one on Laurel Mountain Road.
1:32:51 Which they have installed. And we had some minor changes to the design of the parish hall at St. Joseph's Catholic Church. So that project is ongoing and it sounds like that might come back to us again with some minor design aesthetic changes. So that's really all I've got. I think the only thing I'll throw in on my end is just a reminder to the community for the
1:33:25 The Downtown Revitalization Action Summit that is being held October 17th, which is next Tuesday from 1.30 to 3.30 at Rafter's Restaurant. It is open to the public, although it is hosted by the chamber. It is open to the public. I would highly encourage anyone who is not up to speed or is up to speed and has thoughts and opinions to attend. Darren Dinsmore, I believe, will be there making a presentation.
1:33:55 And it should be a very interesting couple of hours. That's October 18th? That is October 17th, Tuesday of next week. I have nothing to add. Amy, you pretty much summarized everything pretty well for me, so thank you. Yeah, you're welcome. And just to follow up on Mickey's presentation about the Mammoth Voices, June 2018, Sandra, you said we have got two of the seats will be up for...
1:34:28 It's not election, reappointment next June. Right. So two of the commission seats. But the, I think the group is not just looking at commission and council. They're looking at trying to fill all seats. They're going to provide all information on all the different seats. Right. Board of supervisors, school board. Yeah. The boards of the MGOs. Yeah. Water district boards. Right. And foundation boards and things like that as well. So it's just, it's an overall.
1:34:56 How to get involved in various aspects of the community, of which this is one. Yes. So, that's great. And I would like to really encourage my fellow commissions here and also the community to really engage the majorities here in this town, especially the Hispanics community. One of the reasons...
1:35:27 I brought up what I just said earlier during our design review meeting was I went to but a dozen Hispanic residents here in town and I asked them, do you know anything about multi-use facility? No one knew what I was talking about. No one. Not a single person.
1:35:58 I was really shocked by it. So here we are, you know, trying to decide things, both on the commission level and also on the council level. We're making decisions and while we may, certainly it's at the, to the benefit of everybody here in the community, however, somehow we have, half the community do not know what we're doing.
1:36:36 So this is great. So I just want to be able to see if we can get more of these guys to participate. Yeah. That's a very good point. Anything that any of us can do to increase the communication throughout and around the town and decrease the spread of misinformation in particular will be greatly appreciated. Sandra?
1:37:10 Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Just following on Vice Chair Vanderhurst's comment, the downtown revitalization workshop is next Tuesday. The Chamber has asked for people to RSVP on their website. It's a free event, but they're trying to get an idea of how many people they'll have. So if you go on the Chamber's website, it's on the main page. And they're also...
1:37:34 Darren Dinsmore will also be the speaker at the Power Lunch, too. There is a fee for the Power Lunch, but that's from 12 to 1, and then the summit starts from 1.30 to 3.30. I sent to everyone an email. We are not having a joint meeting with the council next Wednesday, the 18th. We were going to have a joint meeting to talk about the airport terminal.
1:37:54 But just they couldn't get it scheduled for the right time. But they are having a workshop on snow management and parking. You're welcome to attend or listen online. Also, we've canceled the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for November 8th. We won't have a quorum. We think we might not have a quorum. So we've canceled that. So when we adjourn, the next regular meeting would be December 13th.
1:38:22 Although we have, I have polled the commission to find out if we can have a quorum for a joint meeting with the council on November 15th. And as long as Commissioner Eckert is there, we'll have a quorum for that item. And that's later in the afternoon. Yeah, so. You won't be there on the 15th, but you will and the two of you will.
1:38:47 Well, I'm sorry. What was the date? November 15th. November 15th. I will be here. You said you would. Yeah. Okay. I have no idea. And let's see. Next Monday, the 16th.
1:39:02 Is the police station open house from 4 to 6 p.m. There will be a free barbecue, a tour of the police station. They'll also have a panel discussion with a Mono County Superior Court judge, lawyers there, a panel discussion with some attorneys, a panel discussion with some police and sheriffs and probation and some different displays and those types of things. So please come out, take a look at our new building.
1:39:31 Looks pretty good. We're still kind of finishing it up out there, though. And then finally, the other last time I had was I sent an email out to the commission about some training that we're offering on October 27th. That's a Friday. It's not a commission meeting, a formal commission meeting. It's really just training for any boards, commissioners, council members.
1:39:51 Kind of talking about how to run a meeting, ethics, civility, those types of things. So this is our first, the first time we've offered a training like this. And I think we would like to offer it once a year for, you know, new members and whoever would like to attend. So I'd welcome any comments that you have, things that you'd like to talk about as a group or things you think we can.
1:40:14 Include in the training and maybe that's after the training. You know, if you go to the training and say, hey, I'd really like to talk about this type of thing. We're trying to make it tailored to our commissioners and council members and board members. And I think it'll be very useful and we will provide snacks and lunch. And that is all I have. I think the training is a great opportunity of my only regret is I'm out of town. I know.
1:40:44 But I think, thank you for offering that, Sandra. I think it's going to be very beneficial, not only to us, Town Council, and then all the boards of the NGOs. Correct. Yep. Thank you. Great. Well, unless there's anything else, I think that's all we've got for this session, and we will be back in December. So then with that, I will adjourn to our next regularly scheduled meeting.
1:41:17 Thank you. December 13th at 2 o'clock. Thank you.