Other meetings
· recording 2 hr 30 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
317 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Yeah, so the push button at the bottom. Yeah. Go ahead and call the meeting to order at 9... 12? 12. Push the button to make it green so you're heard. Yeah, you're... There you go. Okay, you can hear me now? It needs to be green. What does orange mean? Yeah, it means you're not on. Okay, uh... You need to turn yours on. I'm gonna...
0:39 Call for a moment of silence in the memory of the people killed in Las Vegas and basically the people suffering. It's a real tragedy. I want to just take a moment of silence. Okay. Roll call, please. Council Member Carmichael. Present. Beth Hemelhock is absent and excused. Council Member Fowler. Present. It looks like Council Member Charles James is en route. That's what I understand.
1:34 but currently absent. Council Member Jesse Archer? Present. Council Member Jimmy Little? Here. Council Member Tina Faithwaite is en route and currently absent. Council Member Jessica Kennedy? Present. Council Member Rudy DeFeliz is now resigned from the council. Council Member Christine Osborne is absent and excused. Vice Chair Justin Norcross?
2:09 Present. And Chair Rondé. Present. Thank you. Okay, we're going to go ahead and move on to if there's any public comment today other than what's on the agenda. Anyone? I'd like to offer one. Nate Greenberg, the IT Director for Mono County. Yesterday, Race Communication turned up one gig service in the community of Levining. It's now our fourth gigabit community in Mono County.
2:42 Following Mammoth Lakes, June Lake, and Chalfont. They are very close to getting Mono City online and very close to having Crowley online. Both of those should happen hopefully within the next 30 to 45 days. That will be followed by Paradise and Swalmeadows hopefully by the end of the year. And then next year they will start work on Benton, Walker, and Bridgeport.
3:11 So it's exciting to see just some of the initial feedback from people in the community are really, really happy. And I'm really happy to have them in Crowley and hear that, but kind of the running joke is that's been being said that 30, 45 days for a long time, is that a real number now or is that? I think it's a much more realistic number now, yeah. Okay.
3:40 Around construction issues, some of which were around permitting, some of which were around winter and snow, but they mostly have construction done at this point, and they're kind of dealing with testing and things like that. And they expect to be up before the snow flies. That's my understanding, yeah. Okay, any other comments public-wise? I would just say that they have been in Crowley a lot. They've got to be getting close, for sure. I just need to let you know that I have to leave at 11.30.
4:16 Okay, so we'll try to move this moving on. Let's go to number five, and I believe that's Nate on the annual Mono Broadcast Consortium Advisory Council participation. Yeah, thank you. So in the agenda packet, you probably saw the staff report and the letter of resignation from Rudy DeFelice due to some changes at Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, which was the employer of Rudy.
4:45 And the purchase of the mountain by KSL, more or less the division that Rudy was heading up is no longer in place. As such, Rudy's role in this capacity is no longer as well. So Rudy has resigned. I have been working with the town council to replace him. And my understanding is on the 18th,
5:13 Council will be making a motion to appoint Emily Woods, who works with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, to fill Rudy's seat. I've talked to Emily. She was hoping to be here today, but she has some family that were impacted by the fires in the Sonoma County area. So she was not able to be here, but she's very excited, and I think we'll step into that role quite nicely. I've sent her our work plan.
5:41 Action plan and budget. We're going to try to get together and just sort of bring her up to speed in the next couple of weeks. And yeah, I think she'll settle in quite nicely and very quickly. Okay, with that said, we'll move on to number six, which is the agency engagement and board slash council presentation. It's Nate again and me probably a little bit. Yeah, so I'll...
6:13 Kick this off, and then I think largely what we were hoping was to kind of just workshop this and to brainstorm within the council a little bit. But I believe, if not at the last meeting, at the previous meeting, we had sort of talked about the need to better engage the agencies and to also make sure that they're very aware of where we're at as a consortium, as a council, and to really kind of get
6:42 a little better integration, I guess, between where the individual agencies are and an understanding of their priorities and sort of the immediate deliverables that are in front of us that will be coming online in the form of the website and the branding initiative and some of those things. So the idea behind this item was to start to kind of brainstorm the rough outline of what would be a standard canned presentation that could be taken to the four different elected
7:12 Boards or Councils. And then once we kind of have that more or less nailed down, we can figure out who will take ownership of each presentation. And there would theoretically be four. I think that it would make sense to wait until closer to the end of the year or potentially as late as early next year when we have some of the products that we're going to be talking about later in this meeting online. But recognizing it's going to take
7:41 a little while for us to get the actual presentation built, you know, kind of the presentation rehearsed and things like that, and then also it being put on the agenda for those bodies. We wanted to kind of kick this off now. And I'm open, you know, to whatever feedback is offered by the council. It could be that we brainstorm and workshop it entirely within the setting, or we kind of get some initial sort of framework out there, and then maybe a subcommittee picks it up.
8:10 And does some work and brings something back. So with that, I'll turn it over and see if you have anything to add, Ron, or if anybody else has questions or ideas. I'll just kind of weigh in here a second about what me and Nate have been kind of doing on the sides. We've had some meetings with different bishops. We're going to meet with them today. County of Inyo we've met with.
8:36 So we're kind of doing a side thing, but I think the whole intent of this is to have a net down just exactly what we're all going to say to each one of the groups, and it's all going to be the same so that there isn't a lot of dispensary changes on who's running it. I agree. We almost need like a script, basically, that we're all going to follow as you talk to people so that you don't say different things. Or at least bullet points.
9:11 Yeah, but not a script, bullet points is a better way to say that. Yeah, perfect way to say it. One of the questions that I hear the most often is where are these different communities in terms of connectivity and the whole thing about, you know, Mammoth Lakes is connected, but there's a hole here, and so if we can get some, an answer to that question that is not too detailed, but one that we have that we can give, you know, whether it's in a
9:38 Public presentation or just to people that we interact with daily, that would be good. Things like this Lee Vining, getting gig connectivity is fantastic and kind of a bullet point list of here's where we are with the different communities. Out of curiosity, did RACE cover all of Lee Vining, even kind of the more outlying areas of Lee Vining, or is it just basically the city center? It's more or less the downtown core.
10:04 Okay. Yeah. So if you're talking, when you're talking about the, I'm not sure what you're talking about, the more outlying areas, but like the mobile mart will ultimately get connection, but that was not part of this first. But that's not getting part of that. Not the first round. Okay. And then the houses out, you know, kind of closer to the mountains than the school, is that those neighborhoods? Yeah. They all covered as well? Yeah. Okay. Okay. Yeah. The core part of whatever that is, one square mile or something like that. Whatever you want to call that. Okay. Yeah. Nice.
10:37 It's an interesting question that I think we're grappling with as a group is those specific questions that you bring up about where is this community or where is that specific point and just to kind of springboard off that a little bit to bringing those back around to those talking points, to those bullet items such as do you know about our broadband access tool that's coming?
11:05 Do you know about our branding website? And so on. And so just tying any of these questions back around to our working goals. We sort of have our talking points, if you will. But we need to translate those into, as has been discussed through our website efforts, is considering audiences. What is the terminology? What is the language that they want to, that they would understand in delivering our four areas of?
11:33 Our four goals. Part of the process should be, what are we missing? Getting some feedback on where the holes and opportunities are. So maybe asking a question back with the question of where's this community, but where do you see the gaps to leverage the conversation to feedback into? So if we're presenting to ESCOG, if we're getting questions from the community, individuals.
12:16 Our talking points plus what are the lead questions that you're bringing up, Jimmy? What could we tease out of them? What's their perspective? It's a challenge. You have to be a lot transparent in a lot of things. We'll get excited that Lee Vining has gigabit service. And if you just say it, make that statement. It's going to open up an awful lot of other questions if you don't follow it with the next statement of...
12:46 Any further discussion? One thing that I realize,
13:26 that we have not discussed is actually presentation to the tribal leadership. I don't know if you guys think that that would be appreciated, appropriate, important. Okay. I know that it'll give me a good excuse for having come up the hill if I have something to bring back down to council.
13:52 I think, but I don't see why that presentation would be any different than the one that we're talking about here. Right, it would probably be the same with making sure that you wanted to participate in that end of it. It's good to know. Thanks, Nate. So, I apologize for my ignorance, but can we just list off the tribes that would be important to present to? Bishop, are you driving? And then you've got, if I can weigh in, on Inyo County, you've got Timbusha, Shoshone.
14:25 And then you've got Tina. Yeah, Tina, Braithwaite, and Mono County, yeah. So Benton, Paiute, Utu, Utu. And then you're going to have Lone Pine, Paiute, Shoshone, Fort Independence, Big Pine. Sorry, is that one leadership council? No, those are all separate tribes. So Lone Pine, Big Pine, and Independence? Lone Pine, Big Pine, Independence, and Timbisha. Okay, so...
14:58 And Tim is in the Death Valley region? Correct. But they have an office in Bishop. Yeah. Oh, that's nice. I know that they would be very appreciative to learn and have you guys come down and present. And we could host, too. And I'd be happy to reach out to some of the leadership and maybe secure some times that would help out. And most of them have meeting places and presentation facilities.
15:25 Does it make sense to present to each of them individually or would there be value in bringing the councils together in like one or two meetings? I think you have a tough time getting people, tribal members from the south of the county to come all the way up into Bishop or Big Pine or even to afford independence. It's a long, it's a long ways. Sure. And these are all separate self-governing communities. Right. Okay. Yeah, I ask mostly because I wonder just whether there is value in sort of economy of scale.
15:54 Types of looks at or approaches to things. I think the more personal touch that you give the tribes, the more they're going to appreciate that and want to help out. That's good feedback. And as we're getting together sort of our presentation that maybe as we go to these different audiences, that's a good reminder that we need to consider whether the unique aspects of each area, what are those challenges and how can we
16:22 Ahead of time, ask what are those issues and tie back what our work is to that particular community. Oh man, absolutely. I can't agree with you more. And like I said, I'd be happy to reach out. Not saying that I have all the answers, but having a tribal liaison, someone that the tribe would, each individual tribe can, would probably be more than happy to, you know, have a liaison for you, specifically for that reason. And then taking into account all those cultural sensitivities and how best to.
16:51 to talk to the audience. Thank you. That's excellent. You know, I want to add to that conversation, having just spoken with the superintendent, Inyo County Superintendent of Schools about the effort of this council, is that she recognizes that connectivity in the tribal areas has come to her attention over time, and that from an education perspective, that that is one of the concerns of, I would say, the public school system, which
17:19 All communities are participating in, and that's given me a new perspective recently on participating here as well. So if I can help with the education, the K-12 perspective as well as understanding, that's going to feed in how, I mean, all of this feeds back into how do we then provide that leadership across our counties from an education perspective as well. So I'd like to be in, help that conversation if I could. We'll talk offline and
17:49 Just puts you on all the correspondence. Yep. I think that raises another really interesting point, which is that when we're reaching out to these elected bodies, we should make sure that we're kind of touching on all of the different industry segments or verticals that are there. So, you know, the actual commercial side, the business, economic development piece, the government components of this are probably already obvious to most of the elected bodies, but in terms of the value to health care, the value to
18:18 The educational side, I think that message is probably important. And I think, as you said, you can probably provide really good perspective on at least the education side. I wonder, we don't really have a health care representative within this council, but we could maybe engage or reach out to try to just figure out what some of the touch points are. Nate, I'd like to comment on that. That is, you guys are on fire right now because
18:46 Kind of touching on what we did earlier, what the tribes really do appreciate is that personal touch because what they run into a lot when working with government agencies is the term consultation. And many times consultation can just mean an email was sent to the tribe and it could be to a non-operating email inbox. Or maybe a phone call was made and they spoke with a secretary. That's consultation in many terms. If we reach out.
19:13 And really go and touch on all those points you were talking about, economic development being a major one, as well as health and wellness. That's going to be huge. And I'd like to, at that point, speak on what I think the tribes can offer. If we go into this looking and starting a dialogue with the tribes as teammates, as potential partners.
19:42 I think there's a lot of advantages, many, many, many advantages that the tribes can actually bring to the table for what we want to do that might not be fully out there, especially in the economic development sector. And when we're talking about providing broadband communication to a lot of people, technology is getting cheaper and cheaper, but I believe what the tribes can offer in terms of implementation and
20:11 I don't want to say protection, but just overall safety. If we implement and work with the tribes, there are some advantages here that we will gain as our body from the tribes. Not to be too vague. So, Justin, do you feel that there, I'm not exactly sure how this works, I'm just kind of thinking out loud, do you feel that there is value or need in actually engaging the
20:45 The boards of some of the economic or sorry, some of the educational institutions as well. Or could we do that through like your interface within Inyo County and then, you know, reaching out to Stacey up here in Mono County. Right. So on the on the approach of the presentation is, you know, making that extending that offer to the education community. Yes, that's.
21:20 I can be that conduit to our education community or K-12 and not to leave out also the community college, you know, folks as well as understanding their nuances. But yes, I see, you know, looking for that opportunity to make the presentation to the board so that those respective parts of the community understand the work that's going on. And then to Jimmy's point, sort of can we solicit
21:55 You know, some feedback from those respective communities as well. I think, I mean, as I'm thinking about this more what my head was going toward originally and what the value of these presentations is sort of starting to emerge for me is much larger. I think the feedback piece, Jimmy, is huge. I think that it really can potentially help.
22:22 Drive some of the branding efforts and some of the other things that we would like to try to do in terms of consistency and understanding and value proposition and all of those kind of components that are going to be additive for us. So, you know, when I was thinking initially about presenting to four elected entities, the message is probably pretty similar and succinct, even though there's unique kind of anomalies within each. But as we start talking about the tribal
22:52 Leadership Councils, they start talking about going to school districts or the hospital districts. We either need to generalize the message so there's a can sort of one size fits all and then have a unique sort of sub plot or sub text that would be relevant to that individual board that we're presenting to. But I think you are right that
23:20 An awareness of what we're trying to do across all of those elected boards and bodies would be really valuable. Identifying areas where you're going to need some help, and more than just this board, you're talking about the interactive map or missing service or the service you have. We're going to be looking for people to say, I don't have it yet. And really getting the word out for people to flag themselves as saying, I don't have any service at all.
23:50 So using this as a mechanism to get that word out for them to self-identify so we're not knocking on every door, but they help us in that effort. Another random, well, not random, so perfect. Are we at a place where we can, especially, specifically the government entities, with the work that race has done or any of the other providers, where we can start flagging potential
24:19 I think it's a great point. It's something that I have talked to the leadership within RACE about on various levels. As the permit approval process went through in Mono County, there were some things that emerged that were the result of
24:49 policy language enacted by Leno County as part of the general plan amendment. And they were largely unintended consequences of very well-minded or intended language. So we, you know, as Justin and I had been talking about, the Provider Council and the need to get that kind of group together to elicit some feedback from people like race or sudden length that are building projects out.
25:16 That could provide really valuable information to feed into this. I think that ultimately those are messages that we should be communicating back to the agencies. They may be more relevant in Mono than they are in Inyo, based on sort of the experience that Race had, for example. I think the biggest question that I have is the timing on that. And are we going to be able to get enough information
25:46 The better question would be how much
26:14 How many more unintended consequences could occur or could be prevented if you don't at least put the bug in the ear now? Sure. So if the primer is essentially we've run into some issues and you might cite an example. Okay. I think that's a great idea. Just as you're working through your policies, your whatever it is you're working on, consider the impact it could have on this.
26:42 Whatever this is, or at least have the discussion or ask the questions. Sure. Sure. I think even if we don't have, you know, as much done as we would like to, there's still value in going back with an update every two, three months at least. I mean, even if we start it in January to all of these governmental bodies and saying, here's where we are, I feel like I hear a decent bit, you know, I heard about Digital 395, but what happened to it? What's going on? So the more we can be out there and
27:12 Managing those expectations and letting people know, you know, both the councils and the public in case they ask what's going on, we can say we were just at the Mammoth Lakes Town Council meeting last month. Here's the update from there. The better, I think. And, you know, the policy conversation, I think, kind of to broaden that to the state level, you know, maybe 1665 or whatever that is, you know, that
27:40 What are those policy level conversations at the state level taking place? And is this an opportunity to highlight those and possibly to have, you know, garner support? And then the question I have, I think, for the group is, is the advisory council, do we have the authority to take a stance on a state level policy question? Or do we need to go back to our authorizing body and ask that question before we start presenting?
28:11 You should contact your state representative and take this stance. You know, are we in that position of responsibility and authorized to do so? Yeah, I think it's a really good question and point. And honestly, I think it's something that the ESCOG has been wrestling with a little bit as well is can that entity, you know, which is essentially our leadership, even take a stance or does it?
28:41 Kind of percolate up one more layer to the actual four agencies itself. You know, I think that regarding 1665, there was a general amount of uniformity between the agencies in writing letters of opposition or trying to do what could be done. But it was, you know, it was certainly done as individual entities, I think, not under a single sort of umbrella.
29:08 As we go forward with this presentation to these different entities, the question is, are we taking a stance or should we take a stance or decide as a council that that's not our place to take a stance on 1665 or any other statewide policy level? We just have to recognize maybe that it's there, but our work is more focused on and that's what we deliver. We keep focused through our presentation. I think it's a good question in general.
29:38 And maybe this is something that could be put on as a topic of conversation for the ESCOG meeting on the 20th is, you know, relative to to become to be an advisory council, you know, how can we be as valuable as possible? I mean, does that include should it include looking out for legislation that impacts us as an entity, as a region or, you know, as individual communities and, you know, the elected
30:08 I think that 1665 was generally on the radar of the agencies already. You know, there's some interesting kind of consequences of that legislation on the region as a whole and the opportunity to build projects, but also incidentally on the consortium and the consortium fund in general going forward. So we probably should get a better understanding of what the ESCOG would like
30:38 To see and to hear and what the agencies would potentially need. And I'm not sure, I'm not going to be present on the 20th, but we could, as we start to talk about what the presentation of the ESCOG looks like, we could maybe talk about that as a bullet point. One of the points for the 20th. That sounds good, Nate. You know, I'm right there for it too, because my question is, I don't believe ESCOG wrote a letter, did they, Nate? No.
31:07 So that's why we kind of need to just fill them out more for us to jump in. Me and Nate have talked about this numerous times. I would love to have us write a letter, but is it our place yet? And I think your idea of going to them the 20th and say, we're wondering what your thoughts are on this. I think it's really a good idea for the 20th to try to put that on. And I think it's a good point, too, because there is still this
31:38 Maybe uncertainty isn't quite the right word, but this group is really the living blood of the consortium from a functional standpoint and an operational standpoint. In a lot of other state consortia, there is an actual staff, a paid staff that is carrying out the day-to-day, and in those cases, there were letters written by the executive director or president of that group.
32:08 But it's hard to say if this body that's in this room now represents that or not or whether the ESCOG would be interested in writing a letter and how the agencies feel about that. So I think this is a really good point. I mean, it's a little bit off the topic of the actual presentations, but I think that it is a relevant thing as we go back to the agencies to present on is really getting a better understanding as we get into year two and start working on.
32:36 Practical policy, you know, operational types of things where the boundaries really lie. Or, well, seeing this particular group has a shelf life that we strongly encourage them to come up with a long-term plan and solution for engagement. Well, and that's, I think that, you know, goes to the presentation is
33:00 To be very focused on what this presentation is about. And, you know, we bring up, you know, the questions of where's the connectivity at in this community and where's, you know, such and such. And are we the conduit of communication from providers or from efforts? Or if we go back to our, and I'll keep bringing back to this, our four stated goals early on as a group with the shelf life, you know, we're going to have.
33:27 It's a challenging enough time to be successful in reaching our four stated goals that we had on the onset. And so to broaden our scope to state-level policy, to even local policy to some degree, although the policy is part of it, you know, we just need to keep focused on, keep going back to what is on a document. And I would almost, as kind of a side note, advise that maybe on future meetings that we have those sort of four high-level things stated on our packets.
33:56 Is that on the front page of our packet, these are our goals, so it can continually remind us, myself included, that this is what we're working towards. And the other things, while they're important, they are ancillary to what this group at least has been charged with, with the given shelf life. That's an important point to recognize. Ultimately, those are things that these are important to live on and trying to identify some things to recommend. That's our role, is to advise.
34:26 These agencies, these are important things that we hope and encourage you to find ways to staff. Whether it be the broadband tool or policy, ongoing policy discussions or our other two points that I'm still getting those down in my mind too. In your curiosity, when we do these outreach things, I guess there are lots of communities that don't necessarily have leaders, so it's harder with them, but the tribes come to mind.
34:56 You know, I know Race Communications is putting in, and, you know, Praxis, for lack of a better term, put fiber into most of the tribal buildings, but what about the neighborhoods in the tribal areas, and what about the outlying neighborhoods? I was surprised to hear that Mono City's on Race's radar and is going to be one of the first ones to get it, actually, considering they don't even have power or water, but now they're going to have broadband. It's an interesting thing.
35:24 I just wonder if we should have a secondary packet which is, you know, kind of encourages and gives advice to whether it's a tribal community or a community that has some type of a leadership group that can go forward and actually try and, you know, petition and rally race and these other companies to bring broadband into those areas because going and talking, just using once again the tribe as an example, if we go to a tribe that has, you know,
35:53 Really nice broadband connection that comes into their tribal office, but none of their houses have it. I mean, what are you really accomplishing? It's like, oh, great, you can build your new facility that's going to be a, you know, workout center, and we're going to have media coverage, and it's going to be all great, but the common person still doesn't have internet, so what difference does it make to them? And isn't that really who we're trying to reach out to when you're outside of the...
36:18 Business sector, which, you know, is what I'm representing for Bishop, but when you look at it, even in the business sector, if the guy down the street doesn't have internet, you're going to have a hard time selling him a lot of your services, whether you're selling technology or not. Tina? So just going back and just talking on what you guys are, like, what kind of authority we have. Just to keep in mind, though, you know, what we're doing here affects all tribes in the valley.
36:47 And the tribal leaders would be happy to support. So if we just reached out to them, you know, for a support letter on this AB 1665, you know, I'm sure that they would support. And we have the authority as tribes to submit letters to, you know, anything that's going on at the state level. So just to let you guys know that. That was exactly the point I was going to make.
37:12 We do have, that's one of the things that tribes can bring to the table is a voice at pretty much any level of government within the state of California. So if we build those relationships, we can have a friendly voice. But if I may speak to what you were mentioning, I can see from that perspective, especially from the private sector, attempting to run connections out to a community like the tribe.
37:40 When you're talking about leadership to implement something like that, depending on the tribe, maybe it might not be the best approach to go through tribal government. Maybe the best approach would be to go through, say, a tribal economic development, who is their sole function is to reach out to private sector businesses and create contracts. So just off the top of my head, if we're talking about a community,
38:08 That has a broadband connection like that, but doesn't have home connections. We're actually talking about implementation. So if you're going to go to, you're not going to go to the county venue and say, hey, what's the best cost effective way to get everybody connected? You're going to go to a company that knows how to do that. So instead of going through the tribal government, as you were saying, with maybe a leadership that might be unclear to you, it might behoove us to.
38:37 Contact the Economic Development Corporations and then streamline it. We need to bring this back a little bit because now we're getting, I mean, the purpose, I think, of what Nate was talking about was to bring some folks up to speed on what we're doing, where we're going, and a little information and perhaps get some feedback. So, you know, what you're talking about is going down a very different path.
39:06 This particular item is and try to make sure that we don't water down the message. Sure, that's a good point. And like you're saying, if we do pull it back even farther than that, I think it takes it to the core of what you were talking about, Chris, and even with the tribes too, is kind of this...
39:25 Initial presentation, kind of a quick and dirty thrown together presentation that's a boilerplate that fits for everybody that we can just get out there to different communities and not just leadership because we're talking here about boards, agencies, and councils, but civic clubs, the Rotary, just anybody who wants to listen and has any valuable feedback. Something that we can quickly get out to the community and start to make our presence known and start to get feedback from them.
39:50 And just to be clear, I was using the tribe as an example. I meant, you know, all of these boards, agencies, Rotary, you know, whoever it is. But I guess I think part of the message, you know, here's what we're doing, but as much as here's what we're doing and here's how cool it's going to be when you have broadband. If you don't have that broadband, it doesn't make any difference to you. So there should be kind of a, you know, I think some aspect of that message that is, you know, encourages.
40:17 I'm not even, in the case of the tribe, just to use that once again, I just use that as an example. I'm not saying that the tribe should try and initiate their own implementation of pushing out that last mile. What I'm saying is that we should encourage them and help them or give them ideas as to how they can go to the private sector and go, hey, you should be pulling fiber, you should be like race, you should be pulling fiber to all the houses in these areas, whether that's the tribe or...
40:46 Mono City is a great example because I never would have thought they would have gone there. I mean, it's mind-boggling to me that they went out there. And what I think is going to be good here is that Tina is going to have it. So a tribe is going to have race there and on the premise. It's happening. Yeah, but you guys are only going to have that to your actual tribal center. No. They're actually running it to your houses too. They're running it to the homes. Oh, okay. Well, see, there's a perfect example. You know, that should be, I mean, and that, once again, not just the tribes, but, you know.
41:15 The Paradise, or, you know, what is it, what's the Springs, the place above Crowley, you know, I forget the name of it. You're in Aspen Springs. Yeah, above, what is it, you know, that, not Swal, the area above, there's only maybe 40 houses up there. Aspen Springs. Exactly, yeah, Aspen Springs, you know, areas like that, if there are any type of community leaders there, you know, getting them incursion, just.
41:41 Giving them advice on how they can actually rally with race or with other people and approach them because, you know, the county's not going to do that. Well, actually, I'm not sure that I agree with that last comment because the county is actively doing that across the entire... For even communities as small as like Aspen Springs? Yes, yeah. We are advocating at a leadership level, at an elected level, at a staff level for all the communities within...
42:08 So then you're saying it's not necessary for those local communities necessarily to bring leadership forward. No, I actually think that your point is more valid in another direction, though, which is that, you know, this, the topic was originally pointed at how do we engage the agencies, the elected leadership that is theoretically governing, setting policy priorities, fiduciary responsibility relative to finding ways to solve problems. I think to Jimmy's point,
42:34 The feedback piece is incredibly valuable and important for us because, I mean, we have two major prongs of our initiatives, right? One is access and one is adoption. We're simultaneously trying to focus and make effort toward both and there's always going to be this interesting combination of low-hanging fruit relative to what we can get service to relatively easily, whether that's because of
42:57 Cost, availability of grant money, you know, other things like that, as well as the stuff that is at the complete other end of the continuum that are the hardest to reach, hardest to access, most costly, et cetera, et cetera. And I think one of the things that I've been trying to wrap my head around over the last few weeks is as certain opportunities for funding, like the CASF, change, how do the strategies of the agencies and the providers change
43:27 Relative to securing funding or establishing goals and objectives that are reasonable such that we can find ways to solve access issues in hard-to-reach communities, and there are a lot of them in Inyo County. So I think that one of the things that we can potentially engage in if the agencies are interested, if the tribes are interested, is starting to work on or brainstorm around like an access toolkit.
43:56 So I think that that is a valuable point because it is, as we start to talk about,
44:25 Access to all of these other outlying communities is going to be the only way that it's going to get done is some sort of an understanding of what the strategy or roadmap is. Yeah, because nobody's ever going to make any money putting stuff into Aspen Springs. I mean, that's, you're going to need grant money to make that really happen is the only way that's happening. So, is that how Mono City got done? Is that, is that what, okay.
44:45 But lead lining was not. It was not. That's why they're up first. Well, exactly, yeah, because they could actually make some money off of lead lining. So if I could, there's kind of two tracks, and you can guide correct, say I'm off on this, but it's sharing what this council's been working on, and then the second piece is asking for that input. So are those two things as a council we could say that that's sort of what our presentation is about, and then we can tailor accordingly. Maybe the first part is,
45:15 The boilerplate, the vision, access, and adoption are four goals, branding, broadband, policy, and provider engagement, stating our challenges, I was just hearing again, cost, availability, grants, you know, as we've been discussing, share strategy and roadmaps to make the vision happen. So it's sort of like, regardless of the group that we're presenting to, it's tying in, mentioning all the different agencies that we are
45:42 Keeping in mind, you know, tribal health care, local constituency and so on. So that's cut and dry. And then we can tailor our questions to these groups with respect to what ahead of time we can presuppose out of it through a pre-engagement. Is that a fair model, fair strategy, how we can sort of boil this down to that's what this is.
46:10 We can all as a group say that's what we're going to go to. So it's not going to be one person making this. I'm not going to be making this to every single group. Nate's not going to be making this. We're all going to be able to take this and run with it. So is that to get to our agenda item? Yeah, I think that that's great. And I think that two things that your comments bring up in thinking. One is, to Chris's point,
46:35 Once we get out of this first layer of engagement or presentations to the agencies that we've listed off, there is probably value and opportunity to reach out to other NGOs and give that boilerplate presentation, not necessarily soliciting feedback as readily or heavily, but I think in terms of an awareness.
46:58 There could be value in that. Now, I don't think that that should be a priority, but it could be something that we start to look at as we get into next year and we check off these, you know, eight or nine, ten agencies. The other thing that I think is a really good point is that we may want to seed some of these presentations a little bit. I mean, we can, through the ESCOG, basically influence or have conversation with the two or two electeds from each of the four agencies so that they're at least
47:27 aware of what's coming. They can potentially give us a little bit of preemptive feedback or direction so that you're not just walking in cold and blind into a council of five or whatever it might be. And that, I think, could be valuable. Nate, you have to remember, they kind of said to us they wanted us to run with things and come back to them.
47:51 So it's a little different than what you're actually saying, going to them and trying to get their feedback of what our presentation should be. I think we should put it together, whether it's a month or two, however long it takes, and then maybe present it to ESCOG first, and then get their opinions, and if we need to tweak it, then we tweak it then. I think that's a good idea. And I gather that the feedback was more from the constituents, the public, rather than the councils.
48:20 Yeah, I mean, there could be a couple different layers. And just putting it out there that we need, just publicly saying we need feedback rather than. I think as soon as we get it to these four, that's exactly what we're going to have. We're going to have the public come over here and say, well, I think this. Exactly. So once we get our presentation down, I think it is. Tina? I just want to try to make a little suggestion. You know, there's a lot of people that don't look at our website or might not.
48:46 But everybody looks at Facebook. So maybe we could do just a Facebook for our advisory council and then, you know, have, you know, reach out to the public that way because, I mean, majority of us have Facebook, you know, and a lot of our Facebook friends are throughout the valley, you know, and if we have, like, announcements just posted on there, you know, and if you have any questions or concerns, give them a number or refer back to the website so that they know.
49:16 You know, that it's there. And it's free. You know, it's a free way to get out to the public. And, you know, not everybody has a computer, but everybody has a phone. So, just a thought. I think that's a great thing that we can maybe talk about as part of the website and just what our online presence will be in general. So...
49:38 I think, if I can butt in here, the way I see this happening is maybe we form an ad hoc committee that works on this from now until the either November or December council meeting. And Nate, I was thinking that presentation you did for the chamber several months ago, that PowerPoint presentation is probably a good place to start for us to look at that and see.
50:00 What can be pulled from that to put into, I mean, I think having a PowerPoint tool would be fantastic for me when I go to present places. Start with that and have this committee kind of like we did with the branding language. Let's just have someone take a stab at it, a committee, smaller committee, and then bring it back in November or December and see what this group thinks and see what ESCOG has to say and then go from there. I think that's great. Can we get a copy of that PowerPoint? Sure.
50:29 I think Tina's right. I think we should definitely be looking. It's probably part of the website development, but I think social media is a huge aspect, and more than just Facebook, you know, other typical things, you know, Facebook, Twitter, blah, blah, blah. We'll have those icons on the bottom of the website, but we need to get those pages set up and start trying to get, you know, people attracted to that so that we're sending out updates via social media, which...
50:56 People will check a lot more often than they're going to check the website, that's for sure. And we might get a lot more feedback in terms of where the goals are. Agreed, yeah, exactly. Than someone filling out a form. Exactly, I agree. So is that a, you know, that was an interesting comment about constituency. Are we more looking for feedback from the constituents at these presentations to boards, councils, and so on? Or are we looking for leadership comments?
51:26 During the presentation, because it's not our public meeting. We're showing up at somebody else's meeting, making a presentation. We can't take the public's input at their meeting. I'll just say that bluntly. But during that time, we need to take the opportunity to say, by the way, we have monthly meetings, and we would like to engage your feedback through digital mediums, such as Facebook and so on.
51:54 You know, engage us. Provide that feedback. Use those platforms. And so as a group, do we have in our branding or our website efforts, have we talked about Facebook, launching a Facebook page for our group that then when we go to do this presentation, we can say, here is our Facebook page. Please engage us. I think that's a really good point. Yeah. We have not.
52:24 To directly answer your question, we have not started to talk about a social media presence, but I think that it's an obvious extension and important layer to what we will be doing as part of that online presence. But I think your point is really, really good and valid that, yes, we will be trying to get input. I mean, the whole purpose of this activity is agency engagement, agency feedback. Hopefully they know as leaders what the constituents are saying, what the chief complaints and...
52:52 issues and opportunities are. If not, certainly those are things that they should be working on with their constituency. But I think that we can have a little bit of skip level engagement too through the method that you just brought up. So I mean it would be great to have more regular attendance or some attendance. It's great to have Scott here. But I think a way to get more attendance into those meetings too might be to set aside
53:18 An agenda item at each meeting whereby we'll address items that have come up on social media briefly. That might get more people here because they actually want to hear what the council has to say about that. Social media is built for engagement. I mean, we don't want to reinvent the wheel. It's made to get people to interact with each other. We could live stream. Exactly, yeah. That's a meeting. It's happening now. Also, I think... Oh, sorry. Go ahead.
53:45 I just think that if we did have, like, social media, we could, like, advertise our meeting dates, you know, direct people, you know, if you have any questions or concerns, you know, here's the number you call, here's our meeting, here's where we're going to be, you know, so that way we engage them and they know, you know, what's going on and we might have a better attendance because, like, personally, I have a Facebook page for my tribe.
54:12 For my tribal members only. And a lot of them, you know, that's how I engage with them, you know, communicate with them because, you know, if I'm having a meeting or if I have something that comes up, you know, at the last minute where I can't like send out a letter, I just put it on Facebook and they immediately respond. So, you know, like I said, not all people have computers and a lot of the elderly don't even really use social media. So I still have to, you know, send out like letters to them.
54:41 But majority of the people now, they're all, you know, cell phones and Facebook and, you know, Instagram. So that's why I just think that if we could, you know, like post our, you know, what's going on, you know, and here's our meetings, please plan on attending or, you know, if you have any issues, these are where you call. It would kind of direct them. Sure. So I'd like to step in and maybe table this just due to time. I'd like to table this and bring it up on the next session.
55:08 Talk amongst yourself if we need to. I think we've got some really good input from this little session here. For timing, should we go ahead and create an ad hoc committee so we can get rolling on this? I would say a subcommittee. I mean, it would not be a working group that would be focused on this discrete project for a short amount of time. And I think having diverse representation on that, you know, probably no more than five people, but, you know, if we could have some tribal leadership within that.
55:38 I think that would be great. I'd take the business side. Okay. So we have Chris, Jessie, anyone else interested? I'm happy to serve on it. I'm business as well, but I'm other counties. I'll serve on it if I can attend with some conference calls instead of presence. Okay. Just because I'm all over right now. I'm doing a lot of things with my tribe. I think they'd all end up... I have...
56:10 Our company has a Zoom account, so we can facilitate that if the county or the, you know, if the counties or the towns can't do so. Great. We're also spread out. I mean, I don't know where you are, Jesse, but I'm assuming you're not close either. Where are you? Yeah, so we could just do it all via, you know, Zoom meeting, yeah, which is fine. I can help arrange that too, so. Okay. Would somebody like to take kind of a leadership role within that group?
56:35 Work to schedule a couple of meetings over the next few weeks. I think that it would be great to try to bring something back in November that could be reflected on or reacted to by this council. For the social media? Yeah. Not for the social media, for the actual presentation work, for the development of a presentation to go to the agencies. I think I'll step in on it too, Nate.
57:01 Okay. So, Jesse, maybe what I was asking for is we were looking for people to go onto a subcommittee to focus on the agency engagement piece, the actual presentations that would go to the elected leadership. I thought it was more social media, too, but I'll still be in. Okay. Understood. So, Ron, then you're going to take the leadership role on that, too? That's chair.
57:26 I'd share another one already. I like giving presentations, man. I'll do it. If I can coordinate with nature, I'll try to make it work. I can do my best to coordinate. I guess what I'm trying to do is hand it off so that there is some independence of this group. I will be involved for sure. Right, right, right. Okay, great. So who has the leadership role? I'm sorry. I think it was wrong. We determined that, did we?
57:54 It's everybody. I'll help you around. How about that? Okay. There we go. We'll do a shared support to try to make it happen for sure. Yeah. So for clarification, who's all going to be on the committee just so I know? So I have Chris, Tina, Jesse, Jessica, and Ron. And for additional clarification, this is for the development of the presentation, the slide deck, the talking points that will be brought to
58:22 The four agencies and tribal leadership councils. And others. And others. Great. Okay, we're going to go ahead and move on to seven, which is about the consortium summit. I assume this is Nate again and probably me a little bit. Yeah, this is mostly a briefing, although I think that we may ask for a little bit of feedback as well.
58:50 So the California Emerging Technology Fund, or the CETF, is hosting an annual learning summit, broadband consortium summit in Sacramento. It's for all of the 17 broadband consortia in the state. They are essentially trying to get everybody together to just share ideas, information, talk about some of the emerging opportunities and issues that exist.
59:19 And really collaboratively think about how to drive adoption and reach the 98% deployment, civic engagement and leadership, and just talk about best practices and challenges and things like that. So initially I was hoping to go, but the scheduling doesn't really work out, so we basically have three seats there, and we talked internally. Justin Norcross is the incoming chair.
59:48 Be attending sort of as the point. Christy and Jessica, I think Jessica was decided you were going to be attending. And then we have a third seat that's a little bit of a question. I don't know if you'd heard back from Supervisor Griffiths or not. No, I have not yet. Okay. I did send a message, an email. It was only recently, but I've not heard back. So we'd reached out to Supervisor Jeff Griffiths from Inyo County to see if we could get an elected.
1:00:14 Leader from Inyo. Obviously, the broadband challenges down there are much more significant than Mono. We thought it would be good to have somebody from that leadership kind of role. If he's not available, I guess we could look to other electeds within Inyo or somebody else from the consortium to go and attend. And to preload that conversation that may happen, you know, if we don't have an elected official from Inyo,
1:00:46 Would there be any input or desire from any of the members here today to participate, to join in? And understanding your schedules don't allow or it doesn't work out, I understand that. Just want to understand ahead of time. So when we do put the message out that we're looking for a third, and I don't know that we have to have three? We don't have to have three. I mean, I think, you know, I think it would be great to have representation from south of
1:01:18 The counting line from Inyo County. And I think if we weight the representation there a little more heavily, that would be great as well. But I guess we'll just kind of see how things emerge. So we'll see how that goes. It's January 3rd and 4th, so we have a month or two to really nail this down. They do want registration by December.
1:01:46 I think it's mid-December, so we have a little bit of time. The other thing that, you know, for the council, and it plays into our previous conversation agenda item, is they're asking three points to be brought to or to be provided before this December registration time is major accomplishments for our group in particular, challenges.
1:02:15 And then keys to success. And so I think what I'll be looking for is the work that comes out of the presentation effort and then to poll from there. Jessica and I can work on polling from there some things that would be relevant to these three topic items that they're requesting. So that's a little bit of an impetus for that subcommittee to have before, if we could say before December, have
1:02:41 That presentation worked out to some degree that we can then pull some nuggets from there and apply it to this particular audience. And we'd be happy to make that, you know, modified presentation at that summit as well. I think that that point is great. I think incidentally, you know, just rolling this up a layer and thinking about the parties that will be present in this meeting. It's a statewide meeting again.
1:03:10 It's largely looking at bodies like this that have been funded out of the California Advanced Services Fund, which are largely focused on dealing with access issues. And, you know, it is largely understood or accepted that Digital 385 was probably the most successful middle-mile project that was funded out of the Aura funding.
1:03:35 And the CASF funding. Now, there's a lot of other successful last mile projects that I'm not trying to diminish, but certainly we wouldn't be in the position that we're in if it was not for the CASF and the funding of Digital 395. And to the extent that we are able to sort of carry the torch relative to the shoulders that we're standing on and the prior success and the previous investments from the CASF, I think that's good.
1:04:03 All the other value-added things that have been done that you were just referencing, Justin, I think that that's going to be extremely well-received and important. Do you know? Also, if you guys need a success story, you guys could use our tribe because we are in the process. They are bringing internet to every house. It's going to be right by the utility boxes, so it'll be the tribe's responsibility to take it from there to the house, but they will be at every...
1:04:31 Residents on our reservation. So I think that's very successful and we're very grateful. You know, we haven't had internet out there forever since day one. Yeah, and you know, everybody is super excited. You know, we could get satellite.
1:04:51 Internet, but you only get like 30 gigs for 80 bucks a month and, you know, a couple of Netflix movies and that's gone. So people are super excited, you know, about getting internet. Our kids are super excited about being able to use their tablets at home to do their homework than, you know, having to freeze down at the outside somewhere, you know, trying to get it. Sometimes I come in late at night and they're sitting outside of the tribal office, you know, doing their homework, so I'll let them in.
1:05:19 You know, and I'm like, well, why didn't you just call me and tell me you needed to do your homework? You know, I'd be happy to let you in. So now we've gotten, we went from our tribal office up to our community center, but it's through the beams, you know, and that cost us several thousand dollars just to do that. And now we're actually getting internet there, so we're able to put computers in there and give the kids a code so that they can go in and do their homework there. That's awesome. So it's been awesome. I think that's a great,
1:05:50 One to probably use as output and done deal that this is going to be when she gets it. I think that's a good success for us. So the thing I think I really want to focus on is challenges because that's the real work going forward, you know, too, is that, you know, we need to highlight as Nate and Tina were mentioning about our successes that, you know, we have these shoulders to stand on. So what are our challenges?
1:06:16 I would say absolutely, and I really, really wish I could be there. I would pay to be a fly on the wall because I think there could be some
1:06:46 Some very interesting, intense discussions happening at this meeting. Not to get into the weeds of the politics and the policy, but the funding, when 1665 was passed, it refreshed or renewed the funding going into the California Advanced Services Fund, which is what pays for this consortium.
1:07:08 And it pays for the California Emerging Technology Fund. It also theoretically, while it did allocate money into the infrastructure fund to build future projects, but the language surrounding that and the way that that money is actually going to be accessed or be able to be accessed by anyone other than the large incumbent providers is a bit sticky. And I think that there are a lot of consortium, consortia throughout the state that are a little bit frustrated with that because
1:07:38 The success of our individual work plans throughout the state is contingent upon money to build infrastructure. So I do think that it is a very relevant point to bring up. I have asked Gladys and Connie and others within the leadership at CETF that there be a session and conversation around strategies and thoughts relative to
1:08:07 Finding money for those projects in the future. And I hope that there is something that emerges relative to that. But yes, absolutely. And so I wonder again, you know, as opposed to the council coming, making a recommendation to go to the summit with a policy stance, rather if we highlight what our challenges are in our areas.
1:08:36 And talk about our area without talking about the statewide policies that then they can assume for themselves what the impacts are when they're having their policy level discussions. So we're just bringing the messaging. Jesse. If I may, as far as attendance to this, if we had a friend or someone who could relay these concerns on the actual
1:09:04 Digital 395 project level, Praxis level, or perhaps the CBC, California Broadband Consortium level. Would that be cool? Well, can you clarify? We were talking about people to go to this. Yes. And I was just wondering, well, let's just say maybe we had a friend to speak on our behalf from CBC.
1:09:30 Or praxis from the people who laid it in the digital 395 to talk about our challenges, but from a very high level perspective to, you know, would that be helpful? CBC will have a presence there. Right. Mike Orts should be at this summit. So I don't know if...
1:09:53 It needs to be an official agenda item, but just in case, I wonder if we could put this on for November or December, our council meeting, so that we can circle back and all of us over the next two months, month or two, can think about this and make sure that Justin and I and whoever else attends are representing all of us rather than just the segments Justin and I represent. I think that's great. Robin, are you picking that up? Okay. Yeah, and I think that this, I didn't even intend this, but it...
1:10:21 I think this dovetails really well into the prior agenda item, and those two things will work really well. So are you going to take the lead on this component then, and the presentation going to Sacramento? To use the previous strategy, we're going to partner on this, if I can. Sure. You're not going to have any time left. I have a quick question, if I can. Nate, how come you're not going? I've got a scheduling conflict.
1:10:53 Yeah, Nate, I would like to be there, but unfortunately I'm not able. And I think it's a great opportunity to, you know, force our group to take on, you know, more of the leadership role, you know, not for myself or even Jessica, but I think that's something Nate is, you know, continually trying to prompt us as a group to take on all these different items and for someone or a pair of people to take on, you know, these efforts. So, yeah, it's...
1:11:23 Thank you for not being available and allowing us to. You're very welcome. I know I think it's a great opportunity for you to learn and be immersed in those conversations that I've been immersed in and Ron's been immersed in for years. I mean, Ron purposely chose not to go because of sort of the desire to kind of incubate some other folks. So I think that there's a lot of value in that. So I'm going to ask a question of the council as a representative for Jessica and I to be there.
1:11:52 What do you as the council want to hear back from this opportunity? My thought on that would be to try to focus back on the bill that's obviously going to hurt the small guys. That would be what I would like you guys to really focus on. Because without it, the ship's going to start going down and down. You're talking about AB-16? I'm talking about actually our grant money and how is the small guy going to compete with the big guy.
1:12:25 There's got to be a mechanism they create so that race and some of these smaller companies can service our small community that most of them aren't going to want to come into. And the levels they put, the new levels are just ridiculous. Back to 1996? I mean, those are the things I'd really like to see you guys try to address. And specifically grant opportunities. Yes. Or I would broaden it and just say strategies.
1:12:54 I mean, I think that everybody's in the same boat that's going to be at this meeting. All the consortiums are all in the same boat we are. And that's why a lot of them wrote a letter. The reason why we didn't, we weren't sure we were in the position to do it with ESCOG and everything. So I think you're going to go to that meeting, you're going to have a whole lot of people want the same answer. Yeah, and I think the success story is like Tina's.
1:13:21 Are great. And I think that's what's going to get us there is figuring out how they came to that success and how exactly did we get the internet to the tribe in Benton? How, you know, what step was taken funding wise and what work was done with the provider council to create these success stories? Hopefully some councils have cracked some of it, but bringing those back with things that we immediately can tell that is possible here or that's not possible here.
1:13:49 And how we can get service to the communities that don't have it yet. So strategies to ensure competition at all levels of market forces. Correct. Correct. We're not wanting to squash the little or the big, or we're not wanting to bring up the little or the big. We just want everybody to have an equal chance to get the money. We want fair competition in our open capitalistic economy. Which is what it's been. Well, and I would hearken back to what the mission of the consortium is, right, which is it's a gigabit service.
1:14:20 Right. To our constituents. Good point, Nate. So really strategies to ensure fair competition at all levels to ensure access and adoption. Mm-hmm. I mean, that's our group's sort of access and adoption is sort of our focus. Well, it is our focus. So one of the impacts is competition. Competition. What are the strategies at other groups consortia level? So I'm going to expand on this a little bit from other consortias in the state.
1:14:51 What are their strategies to ensure competition? And then maybe that'll spark conversation at the state level as well to give input to policymakers. Well, I would caveat that just by saying, I mean, competition may be accurate because in some of these communities we have some level of service, but that level of service is pretty poor and doesn't meet the expectations or
1:15:21 So I think what we're talking about is how to step up in terms of infrastructure and quality of service where there is already some level of service given the constraints that are there relative to grant funding and the current legislation. Does that make sense? So it's a enhancement of existing services that
1:15:51 By some definitions or another may be underserved. Yes. Yes. If you use the competition approach, you're probably going up the wrong tree. You know, the broadband and the access and quality of access, it's, you know, it's a necessity like having power. And if you don't have a certain level of service to do some of your, meet the basic daily needs, we're talking about education, we're talking about, you know, the hospitals.
1:16:21 Infotainment, the medical services, there's a lot of, you know, the online presence, telemedicine that is occurring that you don't have access to. So the quality of service is quality better than a competition. And that, you know, these topics, I think tie back to the third item that they're asking for input is keys to success. I think that's kind of where we're going with this partly is like you want to hear
1:16:57 What are keys to success? And those may involve looking at market forces such as the smaller, small business provider and the larger provider. Is that, am I going down that where you're thinking, Ron, initially? Yeah, or, you know, creative funding solutions. Yeah. You know, leveraging enhanced increment finance districts or bonds or.
1:17:26 What are other entities and agencies doing in order to get around this when their projects previously were not qualifying for CASF money and likely in the future will not qualify for CASF money? How are people getting stuff built? I'd be really interested to hear also alternative technologies for bringing that broadband into difficult-to-serve areas like microwave, LTE, that sort of thing. I think that's great. Okay.
1:17:58 Let's table this and bring it up on the next meeting again and once again go around the room and work on it. I'm going to move on to eight with the service level map. So I think this can be relatively quick. I just wanted to brief everybody on the work that's been done regarding the map and hopefully we can start to get a little more
1:18:26 Buy-in behind it and we can start to actually begin to flesh it out a little bit more fully. But I'm going to just provide a tour of a couple different products that we have now and some of this will probably become more relevant once our website's actually live and we get that embedded. But I think we could start a parallel or maybe we should start a parallel effort to begin to get
1:18:52 some more data onto this map so that when our website does go live, it will be valuable. I'm going to start by just showing what Mono County has on our website. We have a broadband page that is really pretty bland, to be totally honest with you. But it provides some basic information about just sort of what we're doing with respect to broadband.
1:19:22 that we have gigabit capacity, talks a little bit about the project overview. And then we have a active running list of what broadband service is looking like in Mono County. So we build that off of this service level map that we have in Mono County that we would like to leverage for the consortium and for Inyo County as well. One thing that we
1:19:51 Produced out of that is a live, quote unquote live, broadband availability grid that basically shows by community what providers are there and at what level they're providing service. And then where sort of the future lies for each of those communities with regard to providers. And this drives people to those individual
1:20:19 So that they can figure out purchasing service or requesting connections and things like that. That same data, this is, you know, articulated in obviously a tabular manner or just a textual manner. We have that same functionality here within a interactive map and you can essentially search for a address or
1:20:46 A parcel number or something like that and come down and start to see who the providers are by community. I can click on a polygon. This polygon in this case is showing a big green blob kind of overlaid by this little cross-hatched blob and that basically represents one gig service within the green and up to six megs in this kind of cross-hatched.
1:21:19 And so if I click on these based on where I live, I can see that service is provided by Suddenlink, what the actual infrastructure type is, the speeds that you can get, and some other information on that. And you can also see that there is this other overlapping service area that is offered by Frontier, by their DSL service, and what that
1:21:50 type of services, how much speed you can get out of it, et cetera. So this, as I've said in previous meetings, is the foundation for the broadband access tool. The data that is in this will be basically rolled up into that decision-making app that helps people identify what service is available by community, ideally down to an address level. The thing that is missing from this is
1:22:19 Inyo County, currently, we need to get the provider areas by community. And then we need to, as a group, start to really get the accuracy kind of refined here. So, you know, where we started in Mono and where we still have problems is large block service areas that are covered by each provider. So this green block represents area that's covered by Suddenlink.
1:22:48 I know full well that there is a big gap, for example, down in the industrial park, which is not served by Suddenlink. That's posing a huge problem for a handful of businesses, and the town is actually trying to figure out and resolve. I know there are other gaps like this in communities where there is largely service, but I don't have a very good way to truth that stuff out. So that's where we're going to need some kind of boots on the ground and local knowledge to...
1:23:17 Improve the quality and the accuracy of this. And one of the first ways that we're going to start to try to do this, at least, is through a basic survey. We built this. This is a, I'll call it a prototype. I mean, it's alive. It's functional. We could roll it out as is. It can be tweaked. It's, you know, it's only been shared within a handful of people.
1:23:44 You guys are probably seeing it for the first time. But basically this is a pretty simple survey that asks people to tell us how their broadband service is in their place of work or their home. Basically it walks you through some simple steps. So you can go to this web address and run a speed test. This is branded with our logo, but it's basically using speedtest.net.
1:24:12 So we can run a speed test and see what kind of speeds we're getting. Once this thing is completed, you have the ability to copy a link out of here. And we're basically just asking people to complete this survey based on the information that's coming out of this speed test. And what I'm hoping to accomplish is to begin to ground truth, for lack of a better word.
1:24:43 What service actually is looking like within our community areas and its specific locations. So we're getting 81 down and 45 up. I can copy that link and come back here and fill out some information. So we're a town of Mammoth Lakes. This actually is our address. So our provider is California Broadband.
1:25:30 We're on a 100-make plan. We're supposed to be getting 100 up, and you're supposed to be getting 100 down. You might want to invert those. Okay. First thing I think about is down. Okay, that's good feedback for sure. We're actually getting, what, 45 up, and we're getting 87 down. Can you get those two fields to autofill from the... Yeah, I think I can probably do that.
1:26:05 So we can paste in this little speed test link, provide some comments, attach a file if we have something, and then basically the map grabs our location. You can use the locate me thing and scroll to the bottom and click submit. So this data flows, you know, people can share it on social media to encourage others to take the test.
1:26:35 They can see the other submissions that have come back in, and these show up as little points. So Sage to Summit took the test. They weren't sure what their plan was. This is obviously one of those points of education that we need to work on, is like, you can't complain about your internet speed if you don't know how much internet speed you're supposed to get in the first place. So, you know, what are you supposed to get? What are you actually getting? And then what I would like to start to do with this is to look at
1:27:04 Falloff rates, you know, or performance thresholds relative to supposed to be getting 100, we're actually getting 80, so we're having, you know, roughly a 20% falloff. And what are we seeing? You know, big pictures, we start to get data back, and we actually have something that's maybe a little more statistically significant by provider. And then also, hopefully these things start to highlight pockets where we have problems. So, you know, I was just informed of another one in Mammoth the other day, and...
1:27:33 So I said, start running some speed tests. Let's get some data back so that we can go to the providers and say, yeah, clearly this is not a one-time incident. This is an ongoing issue that's a pattern that we need to work with the provider to address. So I think this is something that needs to be grown. It's, I think, stable and ready to be sort of taken out and expanded upon.
1:28:00 Scott, I don't know if this is something that your guys, your team down there would be interested in trying to help populate some of the at least initial Inyo County data into. And then this is something that would be great, obviously, to take out to the agencies and say, okay, you know, as we're rolling out our website, this is one of the tools we have available. We'd love the constituents to provide feedback and to get information into this. And then that helps us, you know, better craft and understand the message and the issues.
1:28:29 Robin, does the city of Bishop and the county of Inyo have similar tools? No. They do not. So this tool we're rolling out for the entire... That's what I was going to say. Mono County is willing to share. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. You guys are willing to share that with Inyo and with the city. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Okay. So the idea is not to build a separate tool. This will be... We're going to leverage this resource for the consortium and the region as a whole. Okay. No, that would be great because we could really use that. I didn't see a place on there where it...
1:28:59 You know, we were talking about, are there holes? And I'm thinking of someone who stumbled upon this on their phone or whatever. They don't have internet. Either a comment box or maybe it's a question at the top that says, do you have Wi-Fi? And it's a yes or no. And if you do have it, you do the speed test. And if you don't, it takes them to like a comment form. I'm just thinking of people that we don't want them to fall off when they pull this up and say, well, I don't have an up or download speed.
1:29:24 How do I share my thoughts? Or link to an external forum? That's an excellent suggestion because I know in our communities there's going to be people with phones but that have no connection at all. And that will simplify the process if it just branches off. And is the gateway for that question the website? Does our website need to have sort of that fork in the road question? Right. Yeah. Yeah, I think so too. I think it does. Tina? Back to the social media because with that link,
1:29:56 If we did have Facebook, we could put that link on there and then people could just click on it. Either, you know, they do the test or they make the, you know, go to the suggestion, you know, the comment page. So. Once we get this dialed in, I can see, you know, potentially getting the message out through the schools. You know, if there's no conflict is kind of sourcing. Send a note home. Exactly.
1:30:26 Get the students to conduct these tests because I hear from students. I'm in the classroom all the time and I always ask them, you know, just offhand, hey, how's your internet? How's that working out? Oh, it's always slow in this certain part of Bishop. Or it's great, you know. Well, let's normalize that data and let's get that into the system. I'm pretty sure Eastern Sierra would be open to that because they've got a lot of problems with, you know.
1:30:51 Kids that don't have access to broadband at home. And that, I think that might feed into a conditional point in our presentation development is this broadband tool. And as we're going to our different constituencies that we consider, how do we talk about this in a way that they might appreciate and then take it for themselves and go, hey, everybody, Facebook, word of mouth, whatever it may be, you know, take this and run with it. Why does it matter? Would it be possible to utilize it?
1:31:22 Official record we already have and get feedback on and use our parcel numbers and add a checkbox on the property taxes. Do you have access or has it? So it's funny you say that. Basically what I've been working on with my developers is sort of these building block kind of components that are modular such that we can maintain but that are ultimately built on a
1:31:52 An API, an application programming interface, kind of foundational structure that all of the different applications that we utilize can leverage. So we will, in our parcel viewer, have this information as you live at, oh, you search for your parcel and you get the parcel information there. You can see the basics of the zoning and all of those types of things. Who are the service providers? What type of service do they provide? And run a speed test. Or do you live here?
1:32:21 You know, run a speed test and confirm that, you know, this is what you're actually getting. So that's one of the ideas. The other idea is to the broadband access tool. And then we have talked about through some of the workflows that happen on the website for people to go online and pay property taxes and things like that to make some of that property information a little more ubiquitous and available. So the idea would be to engage that into
1:32:50 When people are searching for properties within the tax payment screen, that there are links that send people out to those other resources as well. Well, use the tax payment itself as a tool to get feedback back and as a mechanism to get some of that, to fill in some of the blanks, to identify those holes. And are you currently being served by an ISP? And starting to get a better...
1:33:19 Mechanism to see if, you know, if we're getting a whole bunch, I'm not being served in downtown Bridgeport, and we know that both Fox, Shat, and Race supposedly serve there, we can start asking questions, well, why? Is it you're just clueless or you're clicking no because you don't know? I can certainly ask the tax collector. I mean, I think it's a question at the, you know, at the board level as well as to whether they would like to include something like that in the mailer.
1:33:47 I mean, it's a really easy way to start really specifically honing in the map, if they're serious about it. And it'd be a good question for Inyo County as well to start really dialing in specifics. My other silly question, how often is the map updated? How often do you update this information? I updated this morning when Revinding went live last night.
1:34:13 Two questions immediately came up for Bridgeport. You didn't have Fox linked on the list of providers. I just saw Shat. And when I'm looking at the map, I see Twin Lakes is lit up with Fox, but not Bridgeport in a large area that Fox provides in Bridgeport. Thanks for that. Yeah, that's probably just some little issue with some of the data behind the scenes, so I'll look at that. And I'm looking at the map, and Fox should cover an awful lot of data.
1:34:43 Bridgeport proper. In my little tiny canyon area. Yeah. I'll take a look at that. Okay. How about the cellular providers? This being a can of worms. Okay. No, no, it's actually not a can of worms. It's an interesting question. And I think it's maybe, this is something that I don't think we ever fully resolved during the last meeting when we were talking about how do we define broadband as a consortium, as agencies. You know, we talked about
1:35:14 What the federal and state definitions of that are. And we recognize that we potentially have issues with those definitions based on our communities and our needs. I think that it's widely accepted and understood that cellular providers fill an important niche. But I have maintained and I think a lot of my counterparts maintain that generally it is not a replacement for
1:35:43 Actual terrestrial-based broadband service. I would agree with you. I don't think cellular is broadband. You can get the same speeds, but it's not the same thing. I think that it is now as Verizon is moving to a no data cap or moving back to a no data cap, that could change the scope of this conversation a little bit. Is it okay for me to chime in? Sure.
1:36:16 Absolutely. In underserved or unserved areas, we have used air cars to set up networks, and it works, but it's ungodly expensive, number one, because, you know, they can't do, it works well for, well.
1:36:48 Believe it or not, it actually works pretty well for VoIP phones because they don't use a lot of data, but if you start trying to actually run a business, it's going to become prohibitively expensive way too fast. Now, I think that all being said, there is potentially value in educating people what the rough coverage areas are of these providers because in some cases it may be the only solution.
1:37:13 And it may be a reasonably viable solution, or it is a good add-on service. And it is honestly a better solution than satellite. You can pretty much, you should almost not consider satellite broadband before you don't consider cellular. So, you know, that brings up that there's existing maps by these providers, and maybe just linking to them on the group's website that, you know, as a function of, yeah, AT&T, T-Mobile, Verizon, et cetera, here's their coverage map.
1:37:43 And those maps we have access to because the state requires quarterly submittals from the carriers, and that data is made available through the same back-end services that we're pulling to present this data on the web. So it's a pretty simple additional piece just to add and throw on there. How much are those maps accurate representations and how much are they PR? You know, I think that's going to be a challenge.
1:38:12 It becomes a little bit of a rabbit hole. I think it's a little bit easier for us to ground truth and prove the coverage of terrestrial service. But wireless is an ever-changing world. I mean, I know there's a few new towers going up in Mono County. There's a new tower going up in Inyo County. So we, as agencies, rarely find out about those things. And so how are we going to actually continually maintain? I don't know. I think, I mean, we could try to
1:38:40 Get some rough coverage areas that we can better represent. But I think in that world, it's probably easier and smarter to just rely on what they're putting out and recognize that there's an element of error or lack of truth in it. So another angle on this is that this is very centric on a particular part of our communities. Initially, I was like, well, okay, how do we measure, how do we account for the schools in our
1:39:09 You know, it is a service level map, but part of our broadband access tool, I think the idea was to show to the audience that it's more than just business home connectivity, it's healthcare, it's schools and so on. So how do we build into this data to a collection? If I go to Big Pine Unified School District on campus and I run the speed test, I'm going to get, you know, a gig. I mean, they have a gig service.
1:39:39 I go to Mammoth High School and I run a speed test. I'm going to get a gig. So to fill that out, how does that play into this tool? And I would add our tribal folks in this as well is how do we frame this in a way that's not just about sort of the census designated area, which is what I interpret this to be. I think that's a great point. So to start with the tribal.
1:40:08 Question first. I mean, those are census-designated places, and I think that we should... The one reason that using that as a unit of measure or geography is important or useful is that when people are applying for grants, they typically are tying that back to CDPs. So it's a recognized unit of geography. But you're right. I mean, frankly, the tribes are missing from the list of communities, quote-unquote.
1:40:36 in this list, so we should change that. And then I think that to the extent that we have islands of glowing connectivity within an otherwise oasis of lack, i.e. a school within a community that does not have gig service having gig, we should highlight those and carve those out in the map. But I think we should also think about how in the broadband access tool we are
1:41:07 recognizing that connectivity at the educational facilities and at the health care facilities such that people could see, like, oh, it turns out in Mono and Inyo counties, every school is a gigabit school, even though the community may only have six megs. And, yeah, we should definitely advertise that. And we want to extend our libraries, too, into that conversation. Okay, I think we should just move on. Great points from everybody.
1:41:37 For sure. Now we're on to the website development. And I believe that's Nate again. I think this can be very quick. So the website and branding subcommittees met in joint a few weeks ago. We sat down with our designer, Carrie Davis, and basically relayed to her that the council had arrived at the decision to move forward with that concilium theme.
1:42:07 Carrie is engaged and is going to be working on taking our brand guidelines for the Connected Eastern Sierra brand, which is logo, color, and font, and translating that into the Concilium theme such that it looks and feels the way the rest of our brand does. She is going to be working on that over the next couple weeks. She figured it would be...
1:42:32 I don't know, probably about $800 worth of her time to translate all of that stuff over and then another chunk of money, probably about the same or maybe a little less from the developer to take that theme and get it back to us in a way that we can basically just plug it into the website. So that's moving forward.
1:42:57 Certainly by the November meeting we should have something to show all of you. It is possible that even by next Friday at the ESCOG meeting there will be some rough homepage mock-up and an internal page mock-up with that theme and the branding of that that could be shown just in a static image. I've talked with my team and we're going to host the site within our virtual private server.
1:43:26 We have acceptance there. And then the last piece is really just the content of the website itself. And that has been roughly sort of fleshed out. There's some rough kind of site map notes, I think, in the staff report. And some of this was presented at the last meeting as well. And, you know, the feedback drove most of this. But as the brand kind of rolls along, that will inform a lot of this content as well.
1:43:55 Jessica will speak about that a little bit more in the next agenda item. So I'm happy to answer questions if folks have them, but I think that we should see something a little more tangible, hopefully within the next few weeks. In the next meeting, the next website meeting, can we carve out a little bit of time for the social media element? Yes, thank you for that. Other questions or feedback or anything? Okay, with that said, we'll move on to 10, which is a regional branding program.
1:44:39 So we met, like Nate said, the branding and website committees met together earlier in, I guess about a month ago, and then the branding committee met just with Carrie Davis, our designer, just about a week or two ago. So two good meetings we had since the last meeting. What we've come up with is some immediate goals that we're looking to implement and are looking for council approval on.
1:45:09 Printing Collateral for a Pilot Program of the Branding Initiative. We've talked before with the council about the sticker project, having these connected Eastern Sierra stickers on businesses that offer Wi-Fi in a sufficient and good capacity to their customers. So that's pretty much what we've talked about before is the sticker piece.
1:45:29 It shows that they have Wi-Fi and also that they're a supporter of broadband, but having that sufficient level is key for the stickers. And looking at these businesses, looking for probably, I think we said six initially, but, you know, six to ten businesses to try out this pilot program with. In addition to the sticker on the door, they'll also have posters that will go inside the business. These posters will have Wi-Fi info. For example, when you go into Stellar Brew, it's handwritten on a card what the Wi-Fi password is,
1:45:59 The poster would formalize that and give the consumer a little bit of information about what the Wi-Fi is for, what it can do, why the business supports Eastern Sierra Broadband, that sort of thing.
1:46:13 That would just be one poster in the business. And then the other component of it is table tents, four tables, for example, in a coffee shop on each table with two pieces to those table tents. The first side would be what's in it for the customer. What can you get from this Wi-Fi? And in the sheet in the agenda packet defining consumer benefits, that's what we came up with for you can manage your data while traveling, transfer files, live video capabilities, meeting video conference.
1:46:42 What's in it for the person who's using the Wi-Fi? And then on the backside of that table card, these are both in draft stage, but would be a little bit about troubleshooting and keeping those expectations in check. So for people to know if your speed is slow, here are some ideas on why. Is it your device is too old? Is it settings? Is it, you know, whatever could be the issue. But theoretically, we want to find businesses that are already providing businesses or, you know, it could be schools, hospitals.
1:47:11 That are already providing service that serves all of the people who are in the business at once. It doesn't go slower when too many people are in there, that sort of thing. So this pilot program would be, we're looking at a run of about 100 plus stickers to get going, 10 to 20 posters and table tents.
1:47:31 The pilot program businesses, like I said, probably six to 12 businesses. See how it goes, how it takes off, and then we're hoping to grow this program from there, get other businesses interested, other businesses and places of people interaction going, and then do a bigger print run and expand the reach after that pilot program's done.
1:47:50 We're also going to do planning to do a welcome kit, which would provide information to the businesses who are our connected Eastern Sierra businesses so that they know what to provide, what will provide, what their commitment is, what our commitment is, infographics that tell the story about broadband and the Eastern Sierra and that sort of thing. We'll also be doing, as the last blue point on that sheet says, QA testing, just to make sure that we're doing the right things, make sure we have a baseline for Wi-Fi broadband access.
1:48:19 That each business will provide and whatnot. At this point, what we're looking for, which we can discuss more if you guys would like, but we're mostly looking for support from the council for this general direction we're going in. Like I said, we're still in draft. This is one side of the table cart, the little table tent. So we're still in draft mode with all of this, but we're looking for approval from the council for this subcommittee to take the reins and go forward and have the authority to print this collateral as we nail down the exact.
1:48:48 Details. Any questions at this point? Thoughts? Are we defining sufficient? And then, you know, the rules and regulations to be the get connected, cool people. TBD. See, that's the material and the plan. I don't, that's not a question for me.
1:49:18 It's the threshold to be able to get the stair and to be part of that club. And if it's gigabit service, you know, those are the, you know, or uptime or how much drop-off do you have when you say you have this level of surface for this many users or this, those are the things we have to be very careful of at the onset.
1:49:46 We set the standard this high and we find out that, well, we're not going to have this many users because of the, you know, not everyone's going to get race. We'll have access to race. And we need to make sure that it is reasonable and realistic for the businesses to, you know, be able to achieve this. I think that's more or less what we talked about at that meeting was what level do we want to
1:50:14 And we want it good enough that obviously a lot of these businesses, not a lot, I'm going to say some may not be interested in doing, but as they see this thing grow, we're hoping they'll come on, you know, get the higher speeds, pay for the extra speeds and so forth. I mean, that's the question. There must be a feeling of what good enough is if we've experienced what not good enough is. We have to put something tangible there.
1:50:43 I think what we've sort of avoided is that what's not in here is the term gigabit, and that we've removed the word, but we've still left the meaning behind it, which then leaves open what you're bringing up is what is not, and is this too exclusive maybe? Is that partly what we're... You're going to have to define, you're going to have to put a number to it. If you're saying good enough,
1:51:13 You're going to have to define that in some way. There's going to have to be a hard number, and you're going to have to be able to measure it, and it's going to have to be able to put the sticker on. These are the measurements, and metrics are going to have to meet. Same good enough, isn't it? I think you're right. Yeah, that's true. We have kicked this around, and I know that this is an alligator pit of conversation relative to...
1:51:41 The haves and the haves-nots. And I think that it's a tricky one because you can argue either side of that. So on the one hand, we don't want it to be so exclusive that there are 10 people in the program. Then the brand has no meaning. There's not enough reach. There's not enough awareness around it. And that's obviously not very effective either.
1:52:13 The flip side, if the standard is so low that the quality of service is not something that is indicative or representative of something that we feel proud about, then it waters down the value proposition behind it. So I think in one of the earliest meetings that we had, we talked about potentially there being a couple of different tiers.
1:52:40 Or, you know, a different term like partner versus just, you know, being part of the program or, you know, some way to differentiate sort of what standard, you know, or a basic level of service would be and separate that from a more premier level of service. And I know that from the standpoint of somebody who would not
1:53:10 Potentially land in the haves category, there is this potential feeling of despair, especially when they don't have the ability to immediately just pay more money to turn up a circuit. And I recognize that that is a challenge that is going to come back to this group. I think this is a challenge that this group needs to take on. I mean, that's one of our roles is to look at access issues and to try to solve those. But I feel like simultaneously...
1:53:37 You know, if we're going to continue to promote this region as having something that no other region in the country has, we need to highlight the bright spots and we need to recognize the places that we need to do work and do that work. And I think that navigating this, you know, as carefully as possible to make sure that we don't leave anybody out, but that we also make sure that we don't, you know, chop ourselves off at the knees is going to be important.
1:54:04 So let's start with the original question, what is good enough? What is the defining number which sets us apart from everyone else? I don't think it's been defined yet.
1:54:15 If I can just chime in on that, we've deployed countless wireless into coffee shops, hotels, different companies throughout all of the Eastern Sierra. And the modus operandi everywhere is, I want the least amount of bandwidth I can possibly get, and I want you to limit the speed that each individual person can get. That's what we get every single time. It's never, oh, put in a gig circuit so everybody can have as much fun as they want. It's always, you know, can I get away with just 100 megs?
1:54:44 Limit everybody to a 2 meg speed cap, and that's going to become a problem when you start trying to go, oh, our bandwidth is so great, we're so great, but all these businesses, they're not going to go, oh, well, I'll pay $400 a month for internet instead of the $160 I'm paying now just because I want to have a cool table tent that says that I'm a Wi-Fi partner with Mono County. I think it's going to be a bigger challenge than we realize.
1:55:13 I mean, I get the point of trying to encourage that, but it's almost like you have to subsidize it somehow or give them some type of motivation to actually want to go beyond that. Well, I think part of it is a business education on the value to your business of providing Wi-Fi. I mean, it's, in my mind, way worse when a business provides Wi-Fi that's not good enough. I'd rather them not even offer it. So I think that was one of our hesitations with
1:55:43 Setting a number, which we just, I think we just didn't get there, but we also maybe somewhat intentionally didn't get there because we keep coming back to, as Justin was saying, we don't want to say gigabit because not everyone needs a gigabit and what I need might just be a few megabits. It's not a big thing. And so our thought was with these consumer benefits, you know, from...
1:56:06 I keep using Stellar Brew as an example because they do have Wi-Fi that I tend to use often, but can I manage my data? Can I do a large file transfer? Can I do live video? Can I stream video? Thinking through what people typically want from it and maybe it's, I mean, it's a, I agree with your point that having a hard number makes it fair and it makes it make sense and why do you get the sticker versus not? But we didn't want to go gigabit, as Justin said, we kind of removed the word in the sense of
1:56:35 Is it usable? And who cares how fast the speed is if I can do everything I want on my phone or my laptop? Well, and that's the... There's a conflict in the adoption access question. I think that's what we're seeing here is that what I'm reading here is more about the access, which involves numbers and experience and streaming and so on, compared with the adoption effort through this branding.
1:57:00 And so, again, and I gave the, I think I've sort of alluded to this in our previous conversations that, and it came up in this conversation, is that, is this branding tool equally about adoption, helping adoption, and creating, the word ambassadors came up in the conversation, so as opposed to creating conflict and haves and haves-nots, that we're talking about
1:57:28 The adoption part of our effort as a group. So maybe if we take that in light, can we get away from the access question, we get away from the is it good enough to let's tell the story. And that's what came up through this too, is that this is an opportunity to tell the story about certain communities without creating the haves and have-nots and is this good enough question.
1:57:55 I almost feel like we need to get away from that as to more what are we trying to build going forward. What could you do, not what are you doing? I agree, and not to just to go back to it and not to be the negative guy in the room, but...
1:58:10 We put in Wi-Fi to pretty much every coffee shop in town. There's one I can think of that we haven't. And the overwhelming thing that they say is, I don't want people hanging around, screwing around on my internet. I want them to buy their coffee and get the hell out of you. But it's the truth. It's the truth. I'm sorry. That's how they feel. They don't want people sitting around watching Netflix. So, I mean, they will intentionally have us turn down the circuit and block things like Netflix and block things like Netflix.
1:58:40 You know, some of them even have us block Facebook because they don't want people sitting there screwing around. They're taking up space. They're taking up space and they're not, you know, they buy one cup of coffee and they sit there for three hours and they don't want that. Well, then they don't get a sticker. What's that? Then they don't get a sticker. Yeah, exactly. No sticker for you. Exactly, no. And so that's the problem. And the same thing in hotels. The thing that we hear all the time is, you know what? No, they don't need good internet access. They should go outside. Why didn't they stay in?
1:59:09 You know, and that's honestly the mentality that the owners of these businesses have. So that's going to be, so it's kind of hard to say, oh, you know, if you're a good boy and you give so, you know, buy a 200 meg circuit and we're going to give you a sticker. I don't know how much, you know, that's really going to motivate anybody because even if they buy the 200 meg circuit, they're still going to go, okay, we got a 200 meg circuit now.
1:59:36 We're sure that even, you know, on Christmas Day when everybody comes to buy their coffee at Stellar Brew or at the Looney Bean, everybody, all 60 people who are in here at one time buying their coffee, they can get on their phone or they can get on their computer and use it. But you know what? I don't want them hanging around, so I still want you to limit their connection to 2 megs. So even if they have a 200 meg connection, it's still going to feel like a crappy connection to that person. Which is, that's a... Do you feel like there's opportunity for a paradigm shift in any of this?
2:00:04 It's not that I don't feel there's an opportunity. I feel that we need to figure out what the motivation is for that because there is no motivation right now for a coffee shop owner to want somebody to go, oh, look.
2:00:17 Look how fast my internet is. You can watch Netflix in high definition while you drink your coffee here. They don't want that. It's finding the right markets, and it's like the workspace that was created here. Those are the kind of places where you could definitely get away with it, yes. It's like the lodging properties. It's figuring out how to turn all this bandwidth you now have into a profit center, and there's ways to do that. And it's education that we didn't have access to before.
2:00:46 Now you can do movies on demand and charge a fee for that and you can do this and you can do that. So you're taking away from people's profit centers because now they can't charge for movies on demand anymore. People have paid hotels in town. I mean, I know hotels have paid, you know, they pay $20,000, $30,000 for those in-room movie systems. And as soon as you, you know, allow Netflix, why the hell would I pay you $20 for? Allow me to paint a picture of the future. 5G cellular technologies is around the corner.
2:01:14 And this conversation will be moot. They will go to the coffee shop, they will have their cellular connection with unlimited 5G, not 4G, but 5G connectivity, and they will still sit there. The technology is not the focus and cannot be the focus. We are losing that battle in schools. We try and filter because we're mandated by the federal monies received. Yeah, but that doesn't work either, yeah. And the conversations that I have with administrators, school administrators, principals and superintendents is...
2:01:43 You know, we can put this technology in place to restrict their behavior for one day. And then they're going to turn to their cell phone. And so I'd offer the same perspective across all our communities that it's about adoption, it's about access.
2:01:58 That's what our focus has to be. It's not about the profit loss. That's what this group, and I'm just going to say it, that we have to be focused on that and not what are the repercussions. Let those businesses figure it out. Let those communities figure out how they're going to deal with it. They're unique. We can't address that. What we have to do is promote the positive adoption and access, period. I agree with that, but I guess that's where kind of giving a coffee shop a sticker because they have a 200 meg connection.
2:02:28 You are focusing on the technology at that point. You're not focusing on access. You're focusing on adoption and not even really doing that. It's asking a commitment. And so let me try and broaden this to Jimmy's original point is, you know, what's good enough? What Jimmy's going to say at his establishment is what I have now is good enough. It's not.
2:02:53 No, I mean, for today. But it's not. Because it's what you have. Let me say it is what it is. Let me rephrase that. Is that it is what it is. And you can't change that today. But let's leverage what you have today and say, yes, can you check email? I mean, can you do something? You have connectivity. That's not to be frowned upon. It's not to be the opportunity is not lost that you.
2:03:22 If you didn't have it, you have connectivity, right? Well, yeah. I mean, there's some form of connectivity. And so in these early stages of this regional conversation, that where we have connectivity, well, that's good. It's not dial-up. I mean, let's frame it that way. It's not dial-up. It is better than dial-up to some degree. Now, it's not gigabit. It's not streaming videos and so on.
2:03:49 So to try and change our conversation around this branding tool to not be focused on the haves and have-nots, but rather we have. And each person can use that in their own context to say, I do have. And it's just simply connected Eastern Sierra. It doesn't say high-speed Wi-Fi. It doesn't say high-speed. It doesn't say gigabit. It doesn't say streaming media.
2:04:14 Let the business interpret how they need to interpret in their own branding opportunities to leverage off of what we're trying to promote ultimately, access and adoption through the messaging that shouldn't be about the haves and have-nots. It's been my view through these conversations. This group is not about trying to change state policy. It's not about trying to, you know,
2:04:41 Highlight haves and have-nots. It's not trying to create division. It's about a positive thing that we have, and then leverage that ambassadorship, that positive conversation forward. I agree with you, and I guess that's my point, is I think it should be more about it's available, not necessarily we have it.
2:05:04 Not trying to get businesses to advertise, hey, we've got a gigabit connection, and forget gigabit, we've got a 500 meg connection, because they're still going to want it to be limited, but just the fact that they could have a gigabit connection if they so chose to take that, I guess is the more important message rather than trying to, I guess that's why the table tents and all that kind of stuff, I don't know how that's going to work out, because
2:05:32 I think it'd be self-defeating because even if somebody pays for a 200 meg, you know, a copy shop can get away with a 200 meg connection, you know, most likely 90% of the time. And then they put out table tents that say, we've got high-speed Wi-Fi, but they're limiting it to two megs and nobody can stream Netflix. You don't have high-speed Wi-Fi. This is a joke. Well, they wouldn't get a sticker, I think. Tina? Here's the risk. I mean, I think that Justin articulated a lot of this really well, which is that
2:05:59 We are trying to tell a story. And, you know, regionally we may need to refine what that story and that message is. But, I mean, I don't think I'm speaking out of school here when Inyo County believes that this is a potential point of leverage to diversify the economic base. But when we're bringing people from out of the region into this region, and one of the things that we are marketing, at least...
2:06:28 In Mono County around is the fact that we've got greater broadband capacity than most metro cities in the U.S. have. If somebody walks into a coffee shop and sits down and gets one meg, there's a big, big void that lives there, right? And so I think what we're interested in is not necessarily trying to force a business owner into sort of a different direction or
2:06:59 Challenge what their profit center is or question why they're making certain decisions about putting thresholds on things, but to educate them as to the value proposition that's behind having high-speed internet, not just for their immediate kind of customer base, but for the layer that's out beyond that, the impact and the value that it has on the community as a whole, and to promote or otherwise help
2:07:28 People who really are serving as ambassadors behind that at a business level and really make sure that the people who aren't doing that but could understand that there is a value proposition that is sort of missing there. And it's not going to work everywhere for sure. But, you know, I have heard from a couple of hotel owners now who basically said that
2:07:56 The actual physical cost of bringing fiber into their building to move to a dedicated symmetric circuit that would be at a reliable rate, whatever that rate may be, 100 meg, 200 meg, 1 gig, the cost of that, $30,000, $50,000, is so quickly realized either in profit loss from people who are coming and being frustrated with the quality of the poor quality of internet.
2:08:25 Or profit gain from the actual positive reviews that come out of that, that it's worth it to them. And now that's different. It's going to vary from property owner to property owner, location to location. But I think that the reality is there are people out there who are actively seeking the upgrades in order to sort of support that customer base. No, I agree. And I guess maybe I'm not articulating myself properly. I guess I...
2:08:50 I guess my point is, you know, stickers and table tents and things like that. Those are kind of things that a business owner is going to put up in their business, you know, to show that they're somehow better or bigger or, you know, however you want to put that than, you know, the guy next door. And I don't think that's really where we should be targeting. We should be targeting the business owners.
2:09:16 And then themselves and not, you know, hey, we'll give you a sticker that you can put on your window that says, you know, that you're cool. They're not going to care about that. We need to convince them as to the reasons why their profit centers will benefit from this, why they need that. And I agree with you. There are certain hotels that.
2:09:36 That do want better, you know, they are willing to pay for that. And, you know, people walk out of hotels all the time because, you know, the internet is no good. We've seen it before. That's half the reason why we end up putting new stuff in. But we put in new equipment that's all nice and great and they still have a, you know, 13 meg connection.
2:09:54 It doesn't matter, you know, so those people will absolutely adopt that, but that has really nothing to do with the end user and everything to do with the business owner. I'm going to step in here. Tina wanted to say something about 10 minutes ago. Tina? So I'm a former truck driver, and when I was driving cross-country and stopping at truck stops, you pay for internet. If you want to use the internet, you have to either buy a card.
2:10:22 You know, and pay, and they would give you access. You know, so I mean, there are ways that these businesses can make money and still provide, you know, internet services at the businesses. And as far as the hotels, you know, $30,000, $50,000 cost. So they just increased their room rate by five bucks per customer, and it's going to pay for itself anyway, you know. So, I mean, there are ways to get around, you know.
2:10:49 So when they walk into our restaurant, they don't care what
2:11:19 Service we have, just do you have internet, and can I get on your Wi-Fi, and what's your password, you know, so, I mean, we don't charge for it, you know, we have a separate, but I mean, if we wanted to incorporate that, we could do it in a minute, and pay, the bill would pay for itself, I mean, we could even probably remodel our gas station with those funds, because that's how many people walk in throughout the summer, and ask for internet access.
2:11:45 You know, so people don't really care as far as, you know, I mean, like you said, you know, can I download large files? Am I going to have, you know, access? That's it. You know, they don't care about, you know, what, how much the speed is or, you know, I mean, well, that is important, but internet is internet, you know, and access is very important. So, I mean, there are ways to recoup funds. No, I agree, and I guess that's my point is that that's kind of where we should be.
2:12:12 I think we should be directing more of that at business owners as to how they can do that. I mean, paying for internet, in my opinion, is a thing of the past. Me personally, and I think most people, I won't go back to a hotel if they try to charge me for internet. But in Benton, they won't charge you for internet. In Benton, I would pay for it, absolutely. But Benton is a very different thing. They wouldn't charge you for internet. They would just increase their roommates. And that's exactly what I'm getting at. But those are the kind of things that, as ambassadors, we should be educating these business owners on.
2:12:42 Charge 20 cents more for the cup of coffee or I know there are POS systems we've put them in for some people where when you buy a cup of coffee you do get a code for the internet and it works for one hour or whatever time frame they can set that for 20 minutes and then it turns off and if you want more go buy another cup of coffee you know and and so I mean there are ways around that but
2:13:03 I don't know that the average Joe business user is necessarily aware of or understands that there are ways beyond that, but beyond going, hey, I'm going to charge you five bucks for internet if you want it, which is just going to tick somebody off and they're never going to come back to your establishment. And our plan with this branding initiative, this pilot program, is to gather, as Justin was saying, ambassadors. And so, I mean, there's a certain level that...
2:13:29 All of us can be the ambassadors, but I think it's a lot more valuable when it comes from Andrea at Stellar Brew telling another coffee shop, here's what I've seen from offering free Wi-Fi, whatever the experience is, but if we can get six to 12 businesses that are seeing the returns on their investment to the Wi-Fi and providing that. No, I agree. That's a very good point. The tabletons and the stickers, and it's kind of a visible, we don't think people will be convinced from.
2:13:57 Some business owner walks in and says, oh, there's a table tent. How do I get the table tents? But I think it's a way for, it's a kind of a secondary piece when the bigger conversation is really between us and the business owners and then between those business owners and further businesses. Or that end users are going to choose their coffee shop based off of the fact that there's a sticker in the window saying they have. Well, they might. I mean, who knows how that will shake out long term. But I think that you guys both hit on two really important points. One is that.
2:14:26 Well, and there's kind of a third that comes out of this. The first is that I think the first idea or value proposition behind the branding initiative is the B2B piece. It's us to the business in the education component of the value proposition, right? So it's not necessarily the B2C that is happening from their level to the customer, but it's, hey,
2:14:52 You know, do you know what the value proposition is relative to providing Wi-Fi or high quality internet to your customer? We would like you to be an ambassador, an extension of the broadband consortium, the counties, the agencies who are trying to assert this message over a quality.
2:15:09 And, you know, a reliability and a standard that exists relative to broadband within this region. Would you be willing to get on board? No? Why not? Well, let's talk about what your hurdles are, what your issues are, is it access? If it's adoption, you know, we will need to put together an educational campaign around that. And we're going to hit some roadblocks and people are just going to be like, no, I have no interest in that. And you're like, okay, thank you very much. We're done. But I think we want to try to work that.
2:15:38 And try to plug some of the holes that are easy to plug. Agreed. And in talking with Phil, you know, what Phil was talking about with the bullet points too, we should be going out armed with bullet points when people go, well, I just want to get these people out of my spot after they buy their coffee, they need to go. You know, and it's like, well, if you kept them around, they might buy another cup of, you know, whatever that is, I don't know the right answer.
2:16:01 If we had bullet point answers for those kind of things, then you can give those. And if it's a very clear, concise message, then when you do get Andrea, because she's one of them that wants people out of there too. They all do. If you can get her on board with that, then she's got those same bullet points. And when she's talking to the owner of, you know.
2:16:22 The loony bean, she can go, oh, you know, blah, blah, blah, and without even thinking about it, she's going to regurgitate those same five bullet points that we gave to her originally and go, yeah, and you know what, actually, yeah, you know, I sell more coffee now because of it, you know, so. So I think that that leads to the second point, which is case studies, right? So we want to pilot this because we know we're going to not get it 100% right, but through that process, we want to get some feedback and iterate so that we don't,
2:16:52 You know, we don't just go print a thousand table tents and posters. We're going to try to figure out the things that are going to fail, fail quick, and, you know, iterate on that. And then work with those business owners on the case studies. And the case studies will flow back to the website as content. And they become part of the value proposition in the ambassador program that we're carrying, that hopefully they're carrying as well. But, I mean, I think we need to know, if we're going to be successful as a region, we need to understand
2:17:22 What are the limiters in terms of why broadband is not everywhere? Some of it we know is access. Some of it we know is education. I know people in town are still paying for T1 circuits at ungodly rates of money when they don't need to be, and there's really no good reason for them to be. So I think that's part of this. I think it's a branding thing, and it's also a feedback mechanism to us to figure out where are the pain points and how do we work toward resolving them.
2:17:50 Maybe more of a stick than a carrot kind of thing would be on the website to actually, you know, people who don't throttle their bandwidth and do meet, you know, as Jimmy said, not whatever good enough is, but we need to define that standard. They get a listing on the website as, hey, this is a spot where you can get good Wi-Fi.
2:18:09 You know, and yeah, exactly. And then people will probably go, you know what, I'll pay the extra hundred bucks a month because I want to be listed as somebody who has good Wi-Fi. I see this effort going. Honestly, I see this effort going. We're seeing a lot of coffee shops. People provide Wi-Fi and this is going to end up at a Board of Supervisors meeting. I don't see this as a healthy conversation, to be honest. This isn't good for business. It's not good for the county. The business side of it's going to work itself out.
2:18:38 For us to be highlighting that kind of stuff, you know, I'm going to look at my reviews online and see if I'm providing service to my customers. You know, we should, and we're talking about where it's connected. We should be the, how this is helping us, I think that's value added, that's positive and productive. We should be talking to businesses, why aren't we talking about the guides? You have Wi-Fi, you have the high speed, why aren't you posting the
2:19:06 High quality videos talking about your services. How are you leveraging the service that you have? So it's not just about providing access to someone sitting at a coffee shop and we're getting stuck on that for some reason. I think that was just a good example. That was just an example. We have to find a way to make this a positive constructive thing and not a ha ha gotcha.
2:19:35 Because it's going to be an ugly conversation for everyone else. And that's where, Jimmy, you know, I really felt through the branding conversations that have been happening that this is a gateway to the goals that we as a group are working on as opposed to, you know, some external measurement. And that's what this is about. This branding opportunity is to highlight the efforts to reiterate the access and adoption.
2:20:05 And the means at which we close the gap are through other tools like provider conversations, broadband tool highlighting through those messaging. But the branding piece of it absolutely has to be all inclusive because of the risk of creating division that you're highlighting. I think that's, I agree with that. Is it, we're not trying to be that decisive group between two coffee shops or two hotels.
2:20:36 Or two regions. Or two counties. I mean, that's a thought that's always on my mind, is that we have differences, but that's not the focus of this group, is to highlight the differences. It's to move forward with what is it that our objective, our goals are as a group. And that's where I feel like, you know, defining consumer benefits immediately creates a division.
2:21:05 And I want to bring Christy's point into this because she made a good point early on and Nate was highlighting, this is a pilot. And if we can keep focused on this initial branding and abstract terms that are divisive or defining or absolute, if we can take that out of the branding for this first round, then we can truly get that feedback and see where maybe we need to go. And then we can...
2:21:36 Tell ourselves maybe when we're not as a group that, you know, we didn't create divisiveness. We didn't create the haves and haves. We didn't highlight these issues. We simply promoted the message of our group and what we're trying to do. And is that the goal of branding? Well said. So I would ask Jessica, you know, as you were leading this conversation, is that fair that we can take some of the sort of the hard definitive numbers and the questions of good enough out of like,
2:22:10 Ask about our high-speed Wi-Fi. Could we just say ask about our connectivity or ask about our internet and not have a definition of level of service and leave that up to the business? I think the point was made earlier. Leave that up to those businesses to leverage that unified message across the region to then go on their TripAdvisor and their Yelp and so on.
2:22:36 Leverage their marketing, what they can do, and post those high quality videos about, I have this, I have that. Leave that up to those businesses to differentiate themselves and not get into that. Anyway, that's... Yeah, I think that's a fine way to go about it. I think as long as we are working consciously to manage expectations, I mean, I think you're right.
2:22:57 Ask us about our connectivity and then someone tells you, honestly, it's not going to be that good. Or, you know, honestly, you can do X, Y, and Z. You can't do the rest. I think that's fine. In fact, I think that's key to it. I mean, you may go expecting you can be on Netflix and you can't and that's fine as long as someone's up front with you about it. And Christy, I didn't follow on, but Christy was pointing out that this is a starting point and if we can keep it.
2:23:23 Generalized, but yet specific to our branding goals, then the next iteration, six months, a year, two years from now, can get more definitive, but for now, let's try and keep that very open. Does that help your point, Jamie, that I think is a very valid concern? Either way, that helps, and we get some feedback on answering that question. I don't have an issue with what good enough is, as long as we define that.
2:23:52 And, you know, if the, one of the challenges I also have is we're going to create a branding program and stickers and we're going to roll this out to everyone and then in a year and a half this is going to be gone and what happens to new businesses so we're creating a program that really isn't ongoing. And hence maybe why the focus on the pilot that was mentioned earlier is that at this point it's simply a pilot because we don't know what sustainability is overall particularly even to branding.
2:24:21 I mean, is that a fair perspective on the pilot approach? I mean, I think it's a risk that should be identified, and I think that the ongoing management of the program is something that needs to be raised, especially if the agencies are going to get behind it and get on board. Maybe it becomes a function of the economic development corps or commissions that are there. I think the funding is present to which collateral, probably adequate collateral, could be produced.
2:24:50 We would have enough of it in maybe not perpetuity, but for quite a while. But yeah, sure. I mean, that's a challenge that we should probably think about. If we do a good job educating the businesses, then it should take on a life of its own. I imagine if we're actually providing real value, they recognize real value. Hopefully they'll run with it on their own. Okay. I think we...
2:25:21 Move on to the call for the... Whoops. Sorry, if I could, Ron. I think that there was a question as part of Jessica's opening, which was the recommendation to authorize the ordering of the initial print run of collateral and for the subcommittee to move forward. Thanks, Jimmy. For the subcommittee to move forward with the pilot program. Do we need a motion? Yeah. We do. I'll motion to approve that. Second. Second. Second.
2:25:56 All in favor? I'll just comment with the generic, you know, leaving out the specificity, yes. You know, if we can make it not so narrow, that would be my comment. I agree. Any other comments? So who's all in favor? Raise your hand so we all know we're all in favor. 07. Just made it. Okay, so we're going to move on to the agenda items to the next meeting.
2:26:42 Mine were, I guess it could be November or December. I don't know what you think, Justin, about going through the, having an agenda item to go through the agenda for the summit and get some ideas. Should we have that in November instead of waiting until December so that we're both informed before we go? Is the question about our monthly meeting? Is that what we're addressing? Next agenda. I just wanted to add an agenda item either to November or December.
2:27:17 To have a discussion full council before you and I and whoever else goes to the summit? Yes, and that's in context of the presentation material that would be also put together. So we could have the presentation agenda item and then right after that, just similar to this one, have the agenda item for the January meeting consortium. Yes, so include that November, November's meeting agenda item. Okay. I'd like to, what was the
2:27:53 Recommendation on the social media, Nate, do we have to go back to the ESCOG to ask for permission? No, we're going to discuss it as part of the website subcommittee. Okay, because I'd like to actually have that on the next agenda to create a website, not a website, but maybe a Facebook and some social media so that we can educate the public.
2:28:18 Nate mentioned, you know, hit the ground running with, you know, trying to get information from the public on where the, they are lacking services. I mean, that would be a good spot, you know, for them to, us to post that and then they could respond, you know, by calling in or going on to the website. I've got one agenda suggestion for the next one since we had talked about it and there's people representing the private sector.
2:28:51 Maybe a short agenda item addressing how tribes can interface with the private sector. I think it could affect access greatly if we figure out a way to do that. So nothing getting into detail, but I'd like to have a conversation with Mr. Carmichael and then, you know, the rest of you, if I can reach out to you individually and then just see where we come from and then have just a short bullet point.
2:29:20 I'd be happy to take the lead on that too because I got some really creative ideas I think you guys I'd like to share with you. Any others? I mean I think it stands that we'll bring back branding and website. Hopefully we'll have something to show for that. We have a motion to adjourn the meeting. A motion we adjourn the meeting. Second. I'll second that. I'll second that. Aye. Aye.
2:30:00 Thank you all. I think it was another good session. You know, we're getting out there. For the amount of time we did this, we're doing pretty good, I think, as far as all these separate entities working really well together. Can I talk to you sometime later? Thank you. Yeah, we're getting down the road.