Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 8 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
290 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
3:06 Okay, good afternoon, everybody. Brent Trex is running a little late, so we'll get this party started. I do believe we have enough present here for Quan. Yeah, why don't you head that one up. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Hello. Here. Here. Here. Here. All right.
3:56 Item number three, board member comments, reports, agenda additions. I just wanted to ask that in the future, if we could, I'd love to get some staff memos, staff updates going into the meeting. For instance, today with regard to LA Kings, I'd like to get more detail around that. I know we're going to be discussing it. The agenda only says five minutes, but I'd love to get some ask for staff updates. Okay. Yeah, it's just a basic update today. Okay. Okay, it's not a vote then? No. Okay.
4:32 Anybody else? Yeah, Kirk, I have one thing I just wanted to bring to the board's attention. This is still kind of a little bit of a conundrum and in the works, but was brought to my attention by a colleague of mine who's a property owner who rents their property. Mono County has sent out an assessment letter to people who are renting their properties talking about assessing their interior furnishings, their furniture, televisions, electronics, bedding, barbecues, etc. in accordance with Prop 13.
5:02 To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time anybody's ever seen this letter. So we're not really quite sure exactly what it means, but if it does mean it's a change of assessment for Mono County for all people that rent their property, it could be a rather large deal. So stay tuned. We're apparently, the TOT committee folks, we're not aware of it. The folks at the town have been getting lots of calls.
5:24 They're not sure what it is because it didn't come from them. It came from the county assessor's office. So we're still trying to figure out exactly who this is intended for and what it means. But, you know, again, if it does impact rental units within the town of Mammoth Lakes, it could be an issue. I want to reach out to Barry Beck and just as a lodging association and get details and send it out to everyone. Yep. See what's going on. Because I've never seen another one. I know.
5:47 It's a little odd. The good news is used furniture doesn't have much value. My TV is worth a penny. This mattress? The 30-year-old furniture itself. Anyway, just on the radar. I'd like to add to that. I did receive that letter. It had a cover letter saying that it was brought to our attention that you are seeking short-term rental with your property, which is not the case. So before going through the process of filling out
6:17 Their information sheet, I was going to give them a call just to say, yeah, hey, what have we got going here? But yeah, I thought it too was a little bit odd and how that could affect every rental unit in this town down to the last fork and spoon, so it seemed. Kurt, you pay business property tax on the contents of the hotel, right? Yeah, that I think I know of, no. No?
6:45 Not on the inside of it, no. Okay. Yeah. No? No. X-Men. Unless that's wrapped into the current policy. Yeah. But I need to have a look into that. And that's exactly where I'm going. I would just note that the Mammoth Film Festival begins tomorrow night. There's a reception party at Cafe Restaurant 53.
7:10 Screenings, Friday, Saturday, and even Sunday morning. Awards ceremony at Canyon Lodge at 7.30 p.m. on Sunday. And closing party at Gomez's at 10. We're immediately following the awards ceremony at Canyon Lodge. And you guys are running the gondola, I understand, up until 10. Awesome. Good to know.
7:38 Kirk, if I can add one more thing. This is our last lodging association. We had a great little seminar with Clint Osler from Embark Aviation, and it was all about air service marketing and the toolkit that's now available on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Insiders Industry Insider Site. So that was great. He went over to some ideas.
7:58 Lots of great things for people in the lodging and in the community in general to help market air service, a lot of cut and paste stuff, a lot of stuff that's already done, so stuff you can add to your email or whatever social media you're doing, so that was great. We had about 15 people or so attend that and still waiting on that information from him to send out to the larger association, but it was great to see that and nice to add that to our little quiver of things that we can do and try to draw business and promote air service.
8:27 That's good. That was also done with the county, Milano County and Bishop as well. Thank you for that. Paul, Eric, anything to add? Yeah. Onward. Public comment. All right. Let's see where that's going. Can we go into the minutes, please? And the approval of last meeting's minutes. I'll make a motion to approve last meeting's minutes. Second.
9:08 All in favor then? Aye. If I said that in turn or out of turn, I'm not sure. Meetings passed there. Approval. Make a request that for future meetings if we have an action that is taken that it's bold so it's really clear in the meetings that something was very specifically done or follow up because we have the list of notes but they're very specific of this person is doing this or this thing was approved at this level so there's absolute total clarity on exactly what was done if there's...
9:36 Sometimes there's a list of dialogue, but it's not exactly clear the call to action or what the next steps were for the next person. Duly noted. Well, we have a presentation for Coach Kastner. That was the one coming. It's your time. Thanks. Good afternoon, Board Directors of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you for having me on this fine winter day in February. It's been a great winter, obviously, for us training.
10:10 here in the Eastern Sierra and just went for a run down at the Horse Corral off of Owens River Road. We have a nice 10-mile loop out there that is unfortunately very dry, but fortunately for us it is dry and nice out to train. I do want to take this time to thank Mammoth Lakes Tourism for their continued support.
10:32 Both financially and otherwise over the last five years in my tenure with the Mammoth Track Club and being the coach, the head coach for the track club. And my presentation today is just to overview of how the genesis of the Mammoth Track Club when we started back in 2001 and where it's led to today. It's sort of evolved over the years with different coaching staff and different styles of coaching and community outreach. And I just want to make sure that everybody...
11:00 on this board of directors knows and sees our value to the community and to know the goals and the aspirations for our club. So I'm going to kind of dive into my little PowerPoint presentation here. And first off, we are a nonprofit. We are a 501c3. We get...
11:23 Our status from the Roadrunners Club of America. So it's sort of an umbrella of running clubs around the country. There are other running clubs, about 200, 250 running clubs throughout the country that have been designated by the RRC as a nonprofit status. So there's obviously different streams of revenue that come into the club, and I'll outline those since we are.
11:48 Clearly transparent with that. So our board of directors, my wife is the president. I'm vice president. Our secretary is Jenny Senior, treasurer Doug Knapp, board member Rick Wood, and at-large member Liz Fleming. She had just stepped down as our treasurer. She's amazing. She's a CPA and bookkeeper by trade, so she kept the books real nice and tight, as is Doug Knapp as a CPA for multiple corporations over in the Central Coast.
12:18 So that's our structure. Annual sources of funding that come into our club on a consistent basis since 2013. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area donates two condos to our athletes, and that's valued at $94,000 per year. That's seven bedrooms, and I'm more than willing to put multiple people into a bedroom to maximize our space that we get.
12:45 Mammoth Lakes Tourism has been donating $30,000 to our club since 2013. Mammoth Lakes Town Council back in 2001 voted to fund the early days of the Mammoth Track Club as well. So there's been a consistent revenue stream coming from town since the conception of the Mammoth Track Club in 2001.
13:13 Local races usually produce between 5,000 and 10,000. That's our Footloose Freedom Mile. That's our newly added turkey trot that we do on Thanksgiving. It's a two-mile fun run. This past year we had over 300 people show up. It was a gorgeous summer day like today at Mammoth Creek Park. We had little kids joining in and it was a fantastic time. We have friends back in New York who donate. The LaFrac family donate to our club every year.
13:42 Other sponsors and events, we have a sponsor with a snowshoe company that gives product and also gives a little bit of cash. We worked, obviously, Kirk's event in the summertime and they graciously gave back funding to us for helping out and bringing volunteers.
14:07 Mammoth Hospital donates in-kind services with testing, so we do a lot of physiological testing, we do blood profiles, DEXA scans to get bone density readings on the athletes, so they donate their services as well. Pete Clark is technically our team doctor, if you will. And the athletic club, Snookery Athletic Club, donates 10 memberships to each of our athletes, so each athlete that's on our team plus coach gets a membership as well.
14:36 So that's where our sources of funding come from. And also we utilize the crib with athletes who are coming in, checking out the group. I'm either recruiting them, I put them in the crib, I get a hold of Laura or John and say, hey, is the crib open? Is there one bedroom? I got...
14:55 You know, the national champion coming in. Can you throw him or her into a room for two days? They can hang out with us. So the crib has been a very valuable asset for our club, bringing in athletes. So this is the, in 2000, the Olympic trials for both men and women. Right here, these are both the winners, Christine Clark and Rod Dehaven. This was the genesis of the Mammoth Track Club, the year 2000.
15:21 We sent a team of these two athletes to the Olympic Games in Sydney. So we sent one man and one woman. You can field three if they get the qualifying standard. So you can see 215.29 right here for the men. He had run faster than that, but 215.00 was the qualifying standard. And there's only one man in the whole country that can run that fast. Now we have about 30, which is great. The amount of depth is great.
15:50 So this was the genesis. It was kind of a low point for U.S. distance running, both on the women's side and the men's side. So a trade organization out of Santa Barbara, Running USA, came together, was pooling funding, and recruited Coach Joe Vigil and Coach Bob Larson, Dina's coach, Meb's coach. And Bob Larson was the coach down at UCLA, and he said, hey, I've had successful training camps by bringing my UCLA athletes up.
16:17 to Mammoth for two to three weeks to do some high altitude training. So it was going to be train, live in Mammoth Lakes, and utilize the Olympic Training Center down in Chula Vista, down in San Diego, as the sea level training spot. And in four short years, we went from sending one woman and one man to the Olympic Games and the marathon to putting one man and one woman on the podium in the Olympic Games and fielding a field of six total athletes. So we really raised our game.
16:46 from this spot here and bringing in the best athletes and the best coaches in the country. Brief history, so I mentioned team, it was, the original name was Team Running USA, California and when Terrence, when Coach Terrence Mahan came in in 2005, he changed the name to the Mammoth Track Club. It was much, had a nicer, nicer ring to it. So Coach Vigil and Larson in 2001, 2004, Coach, Coach,
17:13 Mahon and Larson in 2005 through 2012, and I've been coaching since 2012. World rankings, mostly Dean and Meb, but here's some world rankings per track and field news. That was at the longer distances, obviously, 10,000 marathon. We had some track athletes. Even before we had a track, we had track athletes that were ranked. This one right here, Morgan Euseni, in the 1500s, she was ranked number one in the world.
17:41 And we didn't have a track in Mammoth. She used the track down in Chula Vista down in San Diego, but we did a lot of our training up here, obviously, in Shady Rest Park and on the roads and in Bishop. So that was something we're really proud of to get her number one ranking.
17:56 Athletes who've made an Olympic team while training with the Mammoth Track Club, Dina Meb, Ian Dobson, Ryan Hall, Morgan Eustody, Jen Rines, Amy Hastings, Alistair Craig, Sarah Tarr, who's current on our roster, she represents Saudi Arabia, and Alexi Pappas, who you all met two months ago here, and she gave a little presentation. She runs for Greece. Here's our team. We've since added two athletes.
18:20 I won't run through everybody there, but that gives you a good sense of, that's out at Shady Rest. Gives you a good sense of the team. Old guy right here with gray hair. So the vision going forward.
18:33 My vision, our vision for the next two years is to get as many people to the trials and as many people to the Olympic Games as possible, whether they're U.S. or foreign. So we're going to continue to develop athletes who will be competitive at a national and international level in cross-country track and road races.
18:51 Field a roster of four to five men and four to five women who have goals of competing at and excelling in U.S. World and Olympic Championships, and give back to the community of Mammoth Lakes via public outreach and global promotion. I did give a presentation to the town council about six months ago. We had a good write-up in Runner's World magazine, which has a circulation of about two million magazines throughout the country, and it was quite a piece.
19:20 Really great colored photos of us down at the Whitmore Track and training on Benton Crossing Road, Green Church. Mammoth Track Club Pro Athletes, this is how we kind of select our athletes here. They must sign an athlete code of conduct waiver. They must be registered with the club, must live full-time in Mammoth Lakes. A lot of clubs throughout the country have satellite athletes because of their name and recognition.
19:49 So their club or their team might be based in Detroit, but one of the athletes may be living in Folsom, California, and they're corresponding via email, text, everything for training, but we would like our athletes to be here in Mammoth and be full-time residents. They must achieve our performance standards. If they drop below the performance standards, we do a review to make sure that they're making progress towards their goals and that they're benefiting our club.
20:18 Mammoth Track Club, continued contributions to the community of Mammoth Lakes. So the talks in the park have been successful for the last 13 years. We talked to about a thousand high school and college students that come to Mammoth during the summer. We've all seen them.
20:31 Out at the pavilion, out at Shady Rest Park, we'll get anywhere from 3 to 400 each time, it's usually like a Wednesday night, and we have a Q&A session with our athletes and do a panel Q&A, and I give out swag, the Mammoth Track Club shirts, Mammoth Track Club hats, and anything else, and usually the athletes stay a few more minutes and sign autographs on kids' t-shirts, so I always bring Sharpie pens and everything, so it's a real fun time. We act as a running concierge as well for runners that come from around the world.
21:01 So I'm usually the point man. They go to our website. My email's on the website. They say, hey, can I come and train with you guys for three weeks? And where do I stay? And I usually point them to John or Laura and hook them up. And we had a great contingent go-to.
21:16 Go to the Rio Olympics when I was down there with Sarah Tarr. Kuhn Neart from Belgium made the marathon team and then Alexi Pappas made the 10,000 meter team for Greece. So the four of us would get together and go for training runs in the Olympic Village. So there was this mammoth team, so to speak, even though you're representing Belgium or Greece or Saudi Arabia or the U.S., it was just this mammoth team that kind of conjugated and did workouts together. So it was kind of fun.
21:43 We produce two races. We do the Footloose Freedom Mile, which gets about 600 now. It's grown from 167 from the year 2006. So that's a real fun one. Big family event. 50% of our participants are under the age of 12, so a lot of young kids. And then we got our fourth annual Mammoth Lakes Turkey Trot. So talks in the park since 2005.
22:09 Here's a picture at the pavilion in Shady Rest. We've got the panel of athletes here. I'm usually on the side with the microphone and the PA system and everything, and it's a fun time. We get a lot of fun questions of, you know, what's your favorite run? What do you like to eat before a race, before training? So it's a good time. I'm kind of wrapping up now, but I see a real opportunity with LA 2028.
22:36 And that's just around the corner. That's only 10 and a half years away. But I think there's the possibility, a really great strong possibility of having Mammoth be a global hub for high altitude training. Not only because we have the high altitude here at 8,000 feet and our Mammoth Whitmore track down at 7,000 feet, but we have access to Bishop. And a lot of the teams right now and a lot of the countries at the national level are going to places that,
23:07 Have accommodations at high altitude, and 8,000 feet is considered high altitude, but also a training location down at 5,000, 4,500, 4,000 feet. And with Bishop just right down the street, I mean, we can get down there in 28 minutes, down to Round Valley, which is at 4,600 feet, but to live at 8,000, your body produces the hematocrit, or the red blood cell density, because it's always stressed under the conditions here of low pressure and low oxygen.
23:36 By going down to a lower altitude, you produce more power and you recover quicker from your workout. So my kind of vision is to bring athletes from around the world ahead of the 2028 Olympics and to have exposed them to the high altitude and the low altitude of Bishop. And this is our latest member, Sandy Rains. This is Mill Pond. This is LADWP land.
24:03 And it's the exact same organization that owns the land for our Whitmore track. And I'm trying to put the pieces of the puzzle together, but having a four lane or six lane high performance track down at Mill Pond to have the high altitude, low altitude contrast and having a continuous shuttle running from Mammoth to Whitmore.
24:29 down to Mill Pond and then back up and bringing circulating athletes in the spring months because we have a great spring California track season. We have races down in San Diego, Los Angeles, Palo Alto, Oakland. So for athletes to be based here, train down in Bishop, train in Mammoth and then shuttle over to the Bay Area down in Los Angeles to get their races in I think is a real
24:55 A real great opportunity, especially with LA hosting the Olympics in 10 years. I just kind of went over that, and I think that concludes it. So anyway, just to kind of wrap up, just to say thank you, and wanted to just outline kind of our purpose in town, our main vision going forward, and if anybody has any questions, I'd be happy to answer. Yes, Mr. Rudder. Andrew, I do have a question.
25:23 In the late summertime, actually getting earlier now every year, we see groups of runners running all over Mammoth, which I assume are college, you know, from their vans and college kids and high school kids that come up here. Does the Mammoth Track Club interface with those groups? They'll let us know they're coming to town, usually because they want one of our athletes to come speak to their team. So the college...
25:49 Coaches will reach out to me. The high school coaches will reach out to me and we'll try to get one or two of our athletes to meet out at Shady Rest or to go to their condos for their pasta dinners and speak to them directly. So they do reach out and they also reach out to coordinate track times down at the Whitmore facility. It's something I talk with Stu about and try and coordinate to see if there's any soccer going on. I know the Stanford coach reached out a couple years ago to me saying, hey, is it just
26:18 Is it open to the public? Is it free? And I said yes and yes, but there is a scheduled list of events that's happening down there with soccer as well. So yeah, there is a dialogue, there is interaction. I mean, it seems like, I guess the point of my question is, we have the potential to be a big training site for the nation here, don't we? But is there some organized way in which
26:47 People who would be interested in using us as a training site can get information that they need to come up here and actually do that. Do we outreach to potential users of this community as a training site? I don't actively reach out. I reach out more to elite athletes who I think could benefit from training with our team and our team could benefit from training with them. So it's well known enough where athletes will seek out
27:17 Colleges will seek out to come here, but that's not to say that any additional promotion going to a big NCAA track meet like NCAA championships and handing out flyers about, hey, here's what we have to offer in Mammoth Lakes because we have the accommodations and we have the facilities and the trails. Thank you. Andrew, a question. Other than the track facilities down in Mill Pond, how do you feel about what's here now?
27:48 for going into 2028. I mean, in terms of, I know for Olympic stuff, you've got infrastructure stuff, you've got medical, you've got different things, training centers. How much more infrastructure would really be needed here to make what you just talked about go? Right, so that's a great question because right now we're, athletes are going to Flagstaff, Arizona because of NAU and the college there. They have an indoor facility with an indoor track. So if it's,
28:16 Last winter, they have someplace to train inside. And they also have Sedona High School, which has an all-weather track. So we're sort of getting beat out a little bit by Flagstaff. Their accommodations are a little, they're less expensive, to tell you the truth. So there's bigger groups. I know that the...
28:38 Even Coach Terrence Mann, who was the coach between 2005 and 2012, he still works with a lot of the athletes from the UK, and he takes his group there because he's using monies from UK athletics to fund the training camp, so he needs a little bit more resources and also a track at 4,800 feet in Sedona. So that's, I think, the missing component. Everything else...
29:06 Here is in place and is intact and is, I think is great. Great. So yeah, so I mean that's, I'm trying to say, well what do they have and why are the athletes going there versus here and I think the one major factor is that they have a track that's lower. Now we have Bishop High School and that's on a, that's on a public high school and there's, there's issues, that's why there's, why one of the reasons, one of the main reasons we put the track down at Whitmore and not back at the high school because you have adults now coming onto the track with minors, there's that whole thing, right? So they,
29:35 And Sedona, they run into that problem too because you have like upwards of 40 or 50 athletes working out with coaches on the track and it's within school hours so they try and go down there on Saturdays and Sundays when school's not in session. So that's why I thought maybe like our Whitmore track, it's open to the public from 24 hours basically.
29:59 Andrew, with the success of the San Diego Half Marathon up here in our community, I know this isn't exactly in line with what the track club does, but curious as to your take as to why there isn't more bigger races like that here in Mammoth. Do we have the right trails to have like a trail marathon? Do we have the right roads to have a full marathon? What can we do to bring other events to town?
30:27 For us, from our perspective, it's manpower. We're a small organization. We have, you know, six board members and volunteers always want to run in the race from our organization. About seven, eight years ago, I teamed up with Bill Cockroft and we put Mammoth Ultra. We put an ultra marathon on Mammoth Mountain. It was a 25K loop and it was very successful, but we just...
30:52 It was hard to sustain because we don't have the manpower. I think running, we have great trails out in Shady Rest, obviously trail running on the mountain. It did compete a little bit with the mountain bike season, so we had to stagger. They had to delay the gondola by an hour, so there was some logistical things that we worked through, but there is the capacity here. It's just our manpower. The San Diego half.
31:16 is a much bigger organization, and they're bringing funds from their very successful San Diego half marathon in March. They're bringing that budget up into Mammoth as well, so there's definitely some, you can kind of pull from the budget to bring up the race timing equipment and to get the staff required and to be able to donate back to the different organizations that man the aid stations and everything too. So it's, from our perspective, it's manpower, essentially.
31:46 Great. But I think, you know, Sandra DiDomizio always wanted to put, you know, a marathon in town. Like, why don't we have a marathon? We need to have a Mammoth Marathon. And I'm like, and so I collaborated with Sandra and just try to get that nuts and bolts and that vision down. Right. Yep. Hey, Brent. How's it going? How are you? I just ran here from Tahoe. Nice. All right, good. Good for you. Well, thank you very much.
32:16 Thanks for your time. Thanks. Thank you very much. Thank you. Yeah, we're rolling into that right now. Okay. All right. New business. TBID Rural Update. Okay. I just want to give you guys an update because I know we've been on hold here for a little bit. We had done the petition drive back late last summer and we had a few things that we needed to iron out and I think we're still in that process. I've laid out a number of different scenarios.
32:43 We have basically once we go for the resolution of intent. So once we get the final petitions in, we're waiting on one rather large petition. Once we get the final petitions in, we bring those to the town of Mammoth Lakes. They are reviewed and accepted. Then we can go to the town council for the resolution of intent. Resolution of intent starts the whole process, which is about 60 days with public hearings and public meetings. And then the hope is...
33:10 60 days later, we can have a resolution of formation, which is really when Town Council gives the final blessing to the TBID. And so at this point, my hope is that we can get the resolution of intent on the books by no later than the April 18th meeting, which would give us the June 20th meeting would be the resolution of formation, and that would be with the current Town Council. After that, I think we start getting a little too close to the deadline for renewal. This current TBID expires August 31st.
33:39 And the TBID that we're proposing would start September 1st. I think our worst, the worst thing that could happen here is that we either don't renew the TBID at all or that we renew it and there's some sort of a lag period. So if we end up not getting it renewed for the September 1st, if we have a lag period where even if it starts October 1st or November 1st, where we have to go out and tell the businesses, okay, for the next two months you're not collecting and remitting, it would be...
34:03 Very difficult. So goal right now is to make sure that it's done well prior to the expiration date. With that being said, I think we had an update from the LA Kings last week about the partnership there. They're really kind of forcing the question to say that they really need to make a decision by the end of the month. So at this point, I don't know that we are going to be far enough down the road with the TBID at that point. So my recommendation is that we table that conversation with the Kings from our standpoint.
34:31 I am still going to meet with marketing crew from the Mountain to talk about the assets and see what we can do there with the idea that if something is able to happen that we can still at least have that conversation and be able to move this forward. But with the TBID...
34:47 The uncertainty of when the TBID is going to get renewed, I'm hesitant to commit those dollars to the LA Kings deal. Similarly, I think I'd like to put the special events positions that we've been talking about on hold. We had some challenges with some of the funding, but on the flip side, I think the same thing. Until we know that the TBID is back in place and that it's got the right funding, I'd like to put those two projects on hold at this point until we can get that more finalized.
35:14 We aren't committing dollars well down the road. Obviously, two positions is committing dollars in perpetuity. The King's Deal is a six-year deal, but if we don't have the incoming funds, I'm not sure that those would be the options that we would spend the money on. So for now, I'd like to put those on hold. Again, the goal is to get the TBID renewal, get the resolution of intent out at the latest April 18th. So, questions? Yeah, I got some.
35:47 And this is one of those places where I would love to have an update coming into this meeting. Special events. And by the way, are we covering several of these items that are kind of all wrapped up into this discussion? They're all in this discussion. Okay. Special events I'm not even paying attention to right now. I mean, I get the impression that, yeah, that's rightly on hold. LA Kings deal.
36:13 Would love to see this happen. Learned yesterday that, yeah, decision needs to happen before the end of this month. TBID renewal. My understanding is that we've got a holdup with Mammoth Mountain ski area? That's the petition we're waiting on, yes. Okay. What's it going to take to get this resolved?
36:30 Because I've not seen understanding. Can you speak any more detail? Well, I can speak to the detail that I can, you know, obviously I don't speak for the mountain, but I think that in the meetings that we've had, there have been some conversations still surrounding airports. That's the main conversation. And there has been some...
36:50 Suggestions to the town as to using some of the TBID funding towards airports which may or may not be in our best legal interest or in the best interest of the organization from a marketing standpoint. So those are things that we need to iron out and they're not easy things to iron out.
37:05 Okay. And again, I'm doing, basing all this on conversations that I've heard around, is that we cannot legally contribute TBID money towards an airport in Bishop. Is that correct? So that's not true. So I talked to our attorney last week, John Lambeth up at Civitas in Sacramento. He and I chatted last, probably last Tuesday or Wednesday. And when I asked him about that, he said, so we operate under the 1994 law, TBID law. Back a few years ago,
37:34 municipality or a group like ours wanted to build a monument outside of the district boundaries. There was an amendment made to 1994 law that said that monies from the district could be spent outside of the district. That doesn't mean that that doesn't open us up to concerns about Prop 26, which is the proposition that basically states specific benefit to the people that pay into it. So you pay into it through Mammoth Brewing Company, and if you feel that the TBID dollars are spent and it's not benefiting your
38:03 your segment retail, then people can raise questions about that in lawsuits. So there is some pretty sizable risk for us spending money outside of the district.
38:17 I don't think it's impossible, but I think we have to be very careful. I think when we originally started talking about anything down in Bishop with the TBID, we talked about being able to subsidize portions of the flight that we know are coming to Mammoth Lakes and subsidize even like the transportation where somebody's getting off a plane, getting on a bus and getting dropped off at the Westin because we know that the specific benefit of those people that we paid to fly in are coming right to town. I think that if we just cover the entire subsidy, right now we don't cover...
38:46 We cover 80% of all subsidies because 20% of our traffic is local. And so we say, okay, we're going to cover the visitor portion. Now, if we start talking about going to, in the long run, going down to Bishop, the potential for people coming into Bishop that may be going to Death Valley, may be going to Bishop, may be going to Yosemite and not coming here, I think we have to play that one very carefully, even in the scenario that I mentioned where the TBID could pay for some of the subsidy and it could pay for the transportation to drop people off.
39:16 at businesses here in town. So our attorney has expressed concern about taking TBID dollars outside of the district for things like infrastructure. Marketing, it's not a problem. We can go market flights that are coming in. And as I said, I think that we can defend paying for the portion of the flights that are coming here to Mammoth Lakes. So there are a lot of moving parts with this one.
39:40 Okay. Because I think what I heard in your comment right now is that legally we can do this, okay, just to be clear, but that it opens us up to some challenges. Right. As to how the money is spent. As to how the money is spent. Infrastructure versus service. Right. Right. Because I think, again, the TBID laws all go back to providing, they have to provide specific benefit to the people that pay into it.
40:06 And so I think that if we were to somehow put money into either the infrastructure in Bishop, people in town could say that that infrastructure at Bishop Airport isn't helping my restaurant, isn't helping my lodging property. In the bigger picture, obviously, our goal is to get destination visitors here that are going to come into town and stay at Snow Creek and spend money at the brewery and buy lift tickets and do all that. That's the goal. So I think that if we were able to segment it out to say, okay, we're going to estimate that if we have...
40:34 Just throwing this out. If we have one flight a week from Chicago coming in, we're going to assume that out of the 150 seats that we're going to be 65% are going to be coming to Mammoth Lakes. And so that's what we can come out of the gate subsidizing. We can track that over the course of a year and we can say, okay, that number is really 82%. Whatever it is, we can justify that because, again, it's coming to this town where the people that are paying into it should have the opportunity to get that business.
41:00 Okay. That's the stickler. Because like I said, we can spend marketing dollars in Chicago to get people here. We can pay certain amounts of subsidy. We can pay for transportation to drop them off at the front door here. But I think if we try and do anything that's blanket, the feeling from the attorney is that that's going to be where we get into potential issues. So, Sean, just from the Mountain's perspective, when looking at the TBID and looking at the air service as well as air,
41:31 Airport structure.
41:32 We feel that the dollars that we contribute, that we really want that going towards air service, and we think that there's a huge potential to develop our air service to what we originally wanted it to be, and that is a destination air service where we're bringing people in here for four or five nights. They're coming from not just Southern California, but they're coming from Chicago, Atlanta, Houston, Dallas, wherever it may be where you could have a long-haul flight.
42:02 Flight land in here. Ever since we've been talking with Mead and Hunt, we've been trying to figure out what is that strategy and what is the five to ten year strategy? How can we grow our skier visits from 1.2 million to 2 million? And with our new affiliation with our company, we know that we have a lot of season pass holders, you know, if we're successful at doing what our strategy is.
42:28 You look at the Epic Pass, they have over 750,000 Epic Passes out there. So we have to look at our access strategy and say, how can we bring more people to Mammoth Lakes? And we think that the air service is one of those areas that we could do that. There's other areas that we have to focus on as well. But so when we look at the TBID and the reason why it's been held up is because we want to really understand what that air service strategy is going for.
42:57 Board. The FAA was here, you know, for a couple days and it was rather informative. They shared a lot of information with us. They're very supportive of us looking at the different airports.
43:13 You know, our perspective at this point in time is how do we develop the commercial air service at Bishop and how can we use a funding mechanism like TBID to help us in those efforts. So we're really looking to see how we can push this forward.
43:32 rather quickly. Previously it was can we do it in five years, can we do it in ten years, now we're thinking can we do it in two to three years. One thing that we've learned over the last year is that it's going to be really hard to develop our air service here in Mammoth any further than what it is now.
43:51 So that's the reason for the holdup. And we're trying to figure out how can we use this funding mechanism and all the dollars that we put in there to help build that service. Okay. Can I ask you a question on that? Yeah. So we have a TBID that's due for renewal now. And from what I understand, you know, let's say we're optimistic and, you know, county is able to raise funds and that the FAA can make that airport fully compliant in three years.
44:20 We're not going to have a strategy that is intact and in place, I don't believe, in the next six months. Is the Mountain comfortable with holding up TBID and potentially bankrupting that TBID market for the town of Mammoth Lakes in absence of that strategy? We would like to see us work towards that strategy. We want to actually get there.
44:41 We want to put something in place. Can you rewrite the TBID to incorporate moving towards that two to three year strategy down in Bishop? And just a note on that, if we do anything to the management district plan, so if we make any change to it, we have to go back out to petition, which in the grand scheme of things, I think that we could go back out and get the signatures that we need.
45:06 in a two to three week period, but it's still, with the timelines that we're kind of bumping up against here, it really is shrinking the window. And we started this process a year ago. John, you know, I'm listening to what Eric is saying, and it's making sense to me. I think there's kind of an undercurrent there, and Scott as well. It seems like there's an undercurrent there that
45:30 The Mountain understands full well what can be accomplished in the time period of the TBID now as opposed to three years from now, but is looking for some kind of commitment from this organization that we are going to move forward to try to accomplish this incorporation of Bishop into our transportation scheme. I don't think, Eric, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think what you're saying is
45:57 We're not going to go for the TBID unless we have a commitment from the FAA. That's not the point right now. No. No, you're looking for some kind of, and by you I mean the Mountain and its various executive functions. I'm just a representative. Right. I mean, it seems to me the Mountain is looking for some kind of commitment from this group that we're willing to head in that direction.
46:22 And that we see daylight. Because if we said, oh, no, Eric, there's just no way we can do this under the TBID laws and so forth and so on, the mountain would have to look elsewhere and consider other alternatives. I think that, I think, you know, and looking at it from the standpoint of a lawyer, I think the way you phrase it becomes very critical. If you say,
46:49 Well, we're going to spend money on building a fence around the Bishop Airport, and someone says, well, I run a restaurant in Mammoth, how does that fence around the airport benefit me? Well, that's not the question. The question is, we have a terrible problem here with cancellations. I just experienced that. I had a trip planned with airline connections out of Los Angeles, and the Alaska schedule fit perfectly.
47:16 I was so thrilled. And with a discount, the round-trip ticket was $139. That's less than I pay in gas to drive my avalanche to LA and back. I was just thrilled. And of course, that afternoon, they canceled the flight because it was too windy or they didn't like the color of the sky or some damn thing. It's not like it was snowing last week, right? And my frustration level with dealing with Alaska is up here, everyone I talked to,
47:45 feels exactly the same, including obviously the mountain, that their frustration level with trying to have a consistent service that will attract people, that people can depend on. Because if you're coming from Chicago, this cancellation crap isn't going to fly. You cannot schedule a trip from Chicago for a bunch of people and say, oh, you know, we didn't light the color of the sky this week, we're canceling your flight today. You can't do that.
48:11 I think, you know, and you and I have talked about this, and I have, in fact, asked you to agendize it, and, you know, maybe you do, maybe you don't, but I'm going to talk about it anyway, and I don't see Rich Baccia here, so I'm not afraid of being arrested.
48:28 I think, unless someone... I'll see how far we go, because I may call point of order, but go for it. I'm not asking for a vote. I've made this on the agenda, so just... Well, I think it's on the agenda. We're part of the conversation right now. Let's go. You know, air service on the agenda, and we're discussing air service. My point was with John that this organization needs to decide where it's going, and your response was, if I can state correctly, well, our concern is
48:58 Air service, not airports. And my feeling was, you know, the two are inextricably combined. And this organization needs to have a position on airports because we're spending millions of dollars on subsidizing air service. And if the plane doesn't have a place to land, it's a waste of money. And right now, kind of the situation we're facing. So I think that
49:28 You know, and obviously you have good legal talent available in Sacramento, but I suspect, you know, if you, depending on how you put the question, it's, I believe, been established beyond a reasonable doubt that cancellations are inimical to having a productive air service, that Bishop is a solution to that.
49:49 Based on what? That's where I think the piece that we're missing, we're missing facts. We don't know how long Bishop's going to take, we don't know how much it's going to cost, and we don't know how much it's going to reduce the case. Let me rephrase that with one word. Bishop is a potential solution to that in a world where there is no other potential solution. And we all agree to that. And I think that if we gave the mountain a rousing vote of confidence that this organization would do everything it can to
50:18 implement that potential solution in the face of a lack of anything else, and not to the destruction of the airport in Mammoth, but in concert with, because I know that there are concerns about, you know, gutting air service in Mammoth, and I don't think we should do that either, but I'm not sure that the mountain is looking for that. They are. No, not in that definition. Be careful as to how that's said.
50:43 Commercial air service, we believe, belongs in Bishop. That's what we're saying. TSA-controlled commercial air service. I'm sorry? TSA-controlled commercial air service, because technically Jet Suite X is commercial service. That's exactly right. Where we think that the Jet Suite X, the Wheels Up, those types of scheduled charters could easily fly in here and provide a great service for our Southern California. They'd have a hell of a beautiful FBO that's sitting there empty.
51:10 TSA moves out, right? Yep. But the, so, and when we look at this, there's no way we want to interrupt service for any kind of, so we're not looking to gut it, and that was appropriately said, we're not. John said we were, but we're not at all. We're trying to transfer it to Bishop, and we don't know all the answers to that, but we want to start putting our resources to that.
51:40 I'm sorry, I'm going to interrupt for just a second because as being part of that FAA meeting that was down in Bishop's conversation, my takeaway was a little bit different from the FAA officials that came in and I spent several time talking as well. I know a lot of people have good follow-up conversations. It's interesting to me from the other standpoint of saying we may have the best of both worlds because you have a location where you have an airport 10 miles away from town.
52:05 As well as a potential long-haul airport that could be developed down the road down in Bishop. And there's a synergy that might exist between both of those. The challenge, though, is that we go through and we hired Hartmead, which gave a preliminary report, a draft. But what is the true cost of developing the Bishop Airport? You know, we're trying to be asked to jump into certain things without some answers about where I want to know.
52:27 to give recommendations to the board and everybody else in the community saying what's the best relationship, what is good air service down the road? Is it $40 million to develop Bishop Air Support into a full service? When I've got one of the county commissioners sitting behind me as we're riding around the bus, speed six if we call that, riding around the airport, you realize how much real estate's there, but you also realize there's a lot of work that needs to be done at the airport. What does that truly cost?
52:53 You know, these are the type of things that haven't been answered by, that I've seen yet answered. You have a question? I think there's a difference between intent and dollars. And we keep getting into this as an organization, right? Like, the intent, we would like to support the idea of kings, is a lot different than here's a check where there may not be a facility at all. And that's where I think we keep running the problems, is when you have the intent.
53:18 I'm happy to raise my hand and say I intend to do something. That's a lot different than saying here's a check out of the coffers that is now gone and the other side of that falls apart. We have no muff. We have hundreds of thousands of dollars out to support a deal with kings. Where does the benefit come back in? This community tends to run fast and then slips upon its due diligence. We make a commitment to market bishop and Inyo County can't afford to do the work that needs to be done.
53:45 I've heard upwards of $40 million to make that airport ready. And whether or not that can be done in three years, I've heard scales as high as seven years. I have a high doubt that seven years from now, $40 million is going to come out of anywhere for an airport in Bishop. So until those things are done, I think there's a big difference between you're saying, hey, Eric, we would love to work with Mammoth Mountain and we promise we're going to commit to you to do that. That's a very soft handshake versus the, we are going to write a check for $2 million over the course of two years for this amount guaranteed out of this funding.
54:14 Because as soon as we make that commitment, those funds are not available to do things when all the other stuff falls apart out of our control, and then we don't have those funds available for our community. And that's a big difference. I want to make sure you understand that what we're talking about is we're talking about making a dollar commitment, not a we agree that the airport should be there and we support you. That's two different things. In fact, that was the point I wanted to make was I hear all these numbers.
54:40 A couple weeks ago I heard that absolutely FAA would not allow two airports. Now that's gone away. There's so much information floating around that can't be absolutely ascertained. That's pointless. To say, well, we're not going to have any interest in Bishop because it might cost $40 million. That's a number. A number with no evidentiary support whatsoever. It's just a number that somebody pulled out of the air as far as I'm concerned.
55:09 I don't think, once again, Eric, correct me if I'm wrong, that Mammoth Mountain is looking for a financial commitment from this organization at this time for anything down at Bishop. They're looking to see where this organization wants to go. If Mammoth Mountain has to fight us, then, you know, being in the TBID might not make sense for them. But conversely, this organization is in a position to say, and I think it's a board decision,
55:36 To say, we should look very, very hard at Bishop. We should do all the analysis necessary. We should see what it's going to cost, who's going to pay for it, etc., etc., etc. I think that's a commitment that this organization could make without making any financial commitment whatsoever. That's where we are. That's where we are, but at the end of the day, though, the mountain is asking for us to make financial commitments and write checks to Bishop.
56:00 So we haven't asked to write a check to Bishop yet, but I'll reiterate that we are looking to see, okay, how can we develop a funding mechanism to help transfer that airport into a working commercial airport? We don't know the answer to it yet. You know, it is an intent, but we're not saying this is the amount we want. One of the discussion points that came up was could we...
56:29 Much like, so go back to the original season passes in the amount of, we pay 2% on our season passes, and that was originally dedicated to go towards air service.
56:42 Okay, so what we're looking at here is when we rewrite the TBID or looking at the renewal, what bucket of money can we create out of our contribution, out of others, or whatever we want to look at that will go towards air service? And let me say not air service, but it could be air infrastructure or it could be air service. So it would be a bucket of money that you could spend towards that.
57:10 Would it be fair to say that there's opportunities to look at that would increase that bucket of revenue to be utilized? Yeah, I think that's, you know, we look at that and we look at how do we contribute the resources that we have in this organization to that. So if I may, Paul, I think there are certain agreements that we all have. We all think that we need destination traffic.
57:34 We all think that requires mainline aircraft. We all feel that Bishop Airport is the best opportunity for that. Those are the agreements. I think there are some disagreements as we get further down of whether Mammoth Yosemite Airport should continue any sort of commercial service or if it all should move down the hill, transition down the hill eventually. I think those are the places that come into question. As far as funding, I actually have come up with...
57:57 Three pages of ways that this could be funded that it's not written back into the TBID. It could be the joint bucket that we have with Town Council. It could be an increase on the TBID with Mammoth Mountain. For every 1% that we have on that, the mountain portion is about $750 to a million bucks a year. So that can be recommitted. If it's directly funded by the mountain, it can be recommitted specifically for something. I think those are the places that we just have to figure out.
58:24 Again, I have no idea how long it's going to take. I have no idea how much it's going to be. We all agree that it's a solution down the road or a potential solution down the road. I had a call with Mead and Hunt today talking about doing a complete boots on the ground review of Bishop Airport and looking at all the runway length strengths, facilities, all the things that they need. Give us a timeline, give us a cost so that we actually have an idea of what we're actually funding. I think moving forward, there are bigger pieces of this puzzle. Even if the airport's 40 million bucks, if we add
58:53 Call it three or four destination markets, and we're talking about Chicago and Dallas and Seattle and Houston. It's probably going to cost us $2 million a year in marketing in each one of those markets to fill those planes, not to mention the subsidy on the other side. This could be a $10 to $20 million a year operating program, let alone the cost of opening an airport. There are a lot of factors that still haven't been dialed in. So I think when we look at this and we look at the 10-year life of the future TBID, we need to look at the total cost of air.
59:22 Whether it's infrastructure at Bishop for the next two years or three years, and then after that those dollars get reinvested into subsidy or transportation or marketing, it's a big piece. But on the flip side, there's also a huge piece that Altera and Mammoth Mountain have to make sure that they're committed in from the standpoint of those marketing dollars, those subsidies, those transportation costs. This is not a cheap program moving forward. So what I'm saying is that there are just a lot of moving pieces.
59:47 We all have the same goal. We want to get the TBID renewed. I think that the funding solutions or funding options that I've put on paper, some of them may work, some of them may not. So I think we're all moving towards the same thing. It's just right now we've got the TBID looming to get it signed and it's the question mark about which one of these things is going to solve the problem. John, I'm not resonating with you for this reason.
1:00:15 I don't think the issue is what it's going to cost to market Dallas or wherever down the road. That's not the issue right now. I doubt that the Mountain is looking for a commitment on our marketing Dallas. The Mountain wants something from us. I'm not entirely clear what it is. You say yes, he says no. But I think that we need to know that, and it's the Board's job.
1:00:37 to see if we can work something out that is satisfactory to the mountain, that works for this organization and so forth. And I think, you know, you're talking about, well, if this happens and Bishop becomes fully functioning, then we'd have these financial commitments to make and we have some difference of opinion as to what the future of Mammoth is and so forth. But I think that's all future.
1:01:01 That there's something that needs to be done right today to give the mountain the comfort level it needs. I'm not clear what that is, but I'm not clear that it requires all those different pieces to be lined up in a row that you're talking about. Well, I'm not comfortable, as your executive director, I'm not comfortable committing anything today that I don't know what's going to cost me in five years. So if Paul asks you a simple question, you're on this board.
1:01:26 And you're not clear from the MLT standpoint and you're not clear from the Mountain standpoint. So how in the hell should our team make any decisions when the board can't even understand either side of it and make educated decisions? If you're not clear on either side, I don't think we should be having this conversation until there's total clarity because the board should not be making decisions when there's a question when we're asked to vote and it says it's going to be this or it's going to be that, the board's obligation is to know exactly what that is. And if it's not clear from MLT and it's not clear from Mammoth,
1:01:54 Nothing happens. And if that means the TBID lapses, I'm fine with that. I am tired of this organization, this town, making knee-jerk decisions on what we think might be. Facts. This is what is required from MLT. This is what the Mountain wants. We get there. It's up to your two departments to make that happen. And then the board can make a decision. And outside of that, it's speculation and it's optimism. And then we end up broke. We cannot do that. So I'm going to jump in here from the standpoint of, you know, we're talking about hypotheticals here.
1:02:24 Base groundwork is we need regional air service and air service that comes in. What does that look like? We've had some very good conversations recently, but I think there's some dialogue that needs to continue with the Mountain and with MLT to say, okay, what does this really look like? Because what I read in between is the Mountain wants to open the door saying, okay, how can we potentially look at the TBID as a potential funding source for helping with the Bishop Airport?
1:02:49 We want to figure out how do we continue having air service and move those forward. I disagree with you from the standpoint of Scott. I think the TBID lapse is a very bad choice for our area. I think there's a reason we're doing well this winter with the fact that we have really not much snow for the last, I don't remember the last snowstorm, no, but we're actually doing quite well, down by 1.1%. I mean...
1:03:09 There's a direct tie to our spending for marketing in order to maintain a certain level of economic prosperity within this community. I think there's a dialogue that happens, and I think we're splitting this apart by having this conversation. To me, it's more about, okay, do we support air service or not? What does that look like? And maybe there's things that, as we've had this dialogue, that there's, you know, what if there's an additional million dollars a year that comes up from the TBID that the mound's willing to...
1:03:36 Help and other people is willing to help. And we say, okay, we're willing to put another million dollars in to help Bishop get to where it needs to be. Until those conversations have finished, I don't have anything to bring to the board as a dialogue that says, here's an answer today. All we're doing is speculating about, oh, cancellation rate. Why is the cancellation rate less than 2% or better than Eagle this year? So I don't know what the cancellation rate would be in Bishop because we don't fly commercial flights in Bishop. So we're guessing. Can we get a quick comment?
1:04:02 Just to bring it back to the two topics that we were talking about, granted, and it's an important conversation, but again, as Scott alluded to, there's a ton of information out there that, again, we're talking about a lot of speculation. I'm hoping what we can agree, and I agree with John on the first two things, because of the fact that the LA Kings Partnership and the special events
1:04:23 positions, our future funded positions, since we do not have the TBID inked at this point and we're looking for a 10-year TBID, those two things should be put on hold until the TBID is solid because if a TBID is not solid, neither one of those two things is happening more than likely, right? So great segue because I also like, because I want to move us to number three on this point because I think it addresses part of what is the discussion here. So let's come back to that for just a minute in terms of do we have any?
1:04:52 Coming back to the Kings and special events, I'm not looking for a vote on it, but is there a concern, and I'm going to come back to the air service, I'm not, do we need that? Do we need, in order to put the Kings and the special events on hold, do we need a vote? We need at least a consensus of everybody to say, we're addressing staff not to move forward with that at this point in time until TBID, so I'm not looking for a vote, staff direction is what I'm looking for at this point in time.
1:05:18 Okay, I'm going to actually back up a lot of what Scott said and come back to my original comment is that that's why we need updates coming into this meeting because let me finish on this. There was an important meeting in the FAA last week. The sheet covered it just as far as from a perspective of we don't know what's going on. I as a board member don't know what came out of that meeting. I would like to see some updates.
1:05:42 Eric, I'm supportive, frankly, personally, this is just speaking for myself, of looking at the Bishop Airport. I think it makes sense as far as TSA-controlled commercial air service down there. I'm supportive of us helping...
1:05:55 Support doing this if we legally can and if we're not going to have any challenges. But what we need is we cannot be making this decision in a vacuum. So pause there. I'm going to go back to John's portion. You're coming to my point on number three, and I'll bring you right back into that. Okay, if you don't, I'm going to bring us back. Is this King's? No, actually, this is part of the conversation. The King's and special events. I'm looking for consensus for the board at this point in time to give direction to the staff to hold on doing anything with that at this moment. Is there disagreement with that at this second?
1:06:25 Yeah, I got some follow-up questions to that. How are we going to, what is going to be the process for making a decision when it comes towards if we are able to do a deal with the Kings? Because our next scheduled meeting is in March. Well, unless, in my opinion, unless we get the TBID signed off on and to the point of resolution of intent in the next three weeks when kind of the deadline for the Kings comes around, I'm not looking to put it on the agenda. I'm not, if we go from
1:06:53 We have an $8.75 million budget this year using reserves. If we lose the TBID, we have to go back to the town because we'll be locked in at $2.259 million for our budget for the year. And there's no way in hell I'm going to recommend signing off $600,000 on the Kings over six years or that I'm going to sign off on a quarter million bucks plus on the events position for six years. To be clear, that is our decision. Is that correct? That's what I'm asking. That's why I said it's my recommendation. Thank you. That's what I want to be clear on.
1:07:21 We're going to be in a much different world than we are right now. I heard you say you're not going to sign off on that, and I wanted to be clear that it's the board's decision. It's your decision. I'm looking for direction from the board to give it back to staff, and that's the recommendation that I'm asking for the board to say. I think at the present time, putting it on hold,
1:07:38 is the only sensible thing to do. I don't know that there's any disagreement. Well, that's right. You can't spend money you don't have, so. That's no problem. What I'm looking for, what I'm looking for is I want to make sure that we as board and for that matter the entire community is informed on what the potentials are because I keep hearing these rumors, you know, this game of chicken that's going on and I don't, that's the wrong way of phrasing it and so we need to be crafting the message that is not only being discussed at this board but out there in the community as well.
1:08:08 So what I'm looking for is not only very informed updates coming into these meetings, but what is the process for being for the decision that's going to be made. And I understand how you just outlined that. I'd love to see it in writing. Well, and I think at this point, it's still clear as much. That's the problem. That's why I'm giving you an update to say this is where we are. That's why I want to put these on hold. Yes, it's your decision. Can we get to those two real quickly, though? I'm sorry? There's a difference between the two, which is we'll go through this scenario. Worst case scenario, TBID does not renew.
1:08:36 And we do not do anything with the Kings. That opportunity goes away. That is separate from events and shouldn't be bundled with it because the opportunity still exists with the board that we could come back here in March. The TBID has not renewed and the vote goes forward to still fund the events program. So the events program is not in the same time constraint. You can delay that events program and still fund it no matter what happens with TBID if that's the will of the board. Absolutely. The difference with...
1:09:03 The King's is it is a moment in time, it is a three-week window, and that's the difference. I think looking at them as separate things, like putting events on top of the King's thing is not really fair because the events program getting funded does not go away on March 1st the same way the King's Opportunity does. Agreed. There's two other pieces to the King's puzzle, correct? There's the town and the mountain. Are we in concert with those other two pieces or are we separate?
1:09:32 In terms of the financial contribution, because all three things have to happen for the deal to happen. So from the Mountain perspective, we are waiting to get the updated term sheet from the Kings. John was working with Jamie on that.
1:09:44 But given this confusion with the TBID renewal, we said, okay, let's put it on hold because we don't know where it is. And from our perspective that's reported to me is that, you know, is there this deadline? Of course they want to put the deadline in as the King's organization and say, we want to have a decision by three weeks. But they're talking about sales. They're talking about selling advertising. If we can get through this and they haven't sold the advertising.
1:10:14 and to somebody else, we could certainly go back and ask them if they want to do the deal. So I think that the moment in time that they defined isn't necessarily mean that we couldn't ever come back to this. And I'm not asking to table this based on the Kings, I'm asking to table this based on the TBID.
1:10:30 Yeah. Because it's committing us for six years at $100,000 a year moving forward where we don't know what we're going to have for funding. And if we have $2.25 million. But I think it's an important note to know that we could still come back to the Kings if we get the TBID work out. Absolutely. But like I said, and I'm not saying we can't go back to the Kings. I'm saying that I'm...
1:10:47 recommending we put it on hold until the TBID is dialed in. Because I don't want to spend, like Kirk said, I don't want to spend future dollars that we don't have. And I just want to clarify, our resolution with the Kings was based on the joint funds that we have with the town. We will not have any joint funds if we don't have a TBID. It won't exist. There is no $100,000 a year to pull from that joint funds. And my only point was that if we decided to just separate them, as Scott pointed out, and move forward with the Kings, put the event position on hold.
1:11:13 It would be possible that your position, the Mountain's position of putting on hold would kill the deal. We wouldn't have a deal to go forward with anyways. I don't want to say kill the deal. We all three have to be together with it. And I don't know where the Mountain stands on moving forward with it. My concern is actually what the Board's concern was when we first talked about this, is that I don't want to move forward if we don't have the TBID supported. Got it.
1:11:35 And again, it's the board's decision to, I'm making recommendations. To Scott's point, the special events in the LA Kings are not conflated in any way. No. Two separate matters that will require two separate votes. Making two recommendations on them. Just for discussion, there's not. They're bundled for the purposes of saying they're bundled. But I just like knowing that Sean's sensitive to special events, like putting them on hold does not mean that they both die. That one doesn't go away completely. No, it's on hold for now. My rolling of the ayes be noted on Kranicus.
1:12:04 I'm sorry if you're saying that. All right. Just glue down. Any other discussion on that? So everybody okay with recommendation and direction to staff at this point in time at two separate events that the special events and the Kings deals, those two items, will be put on hold at this moment? Yes. To be brought back at appropriate times, each individually, not necessarily together? Yes. I just want to say that, you know, again, I consider the LA Kings deal a heck of an opportunity that I don't want to see go away. You know, special events, in my mind,
1:12:34 Heck, summer's already here. I don't mean to say it like that. That's not as important to me as this LA Kings deal is a great opportunity that I would love to see us, the three partners here, make this deal happen somehow, someway. I would too. So come back. I apologize. I put you on hold for the airport because let's come back to the airport discussion for Bishop because one of the things that number three is, is there's this
1:13:00 Sorry, I wrote the right official name of the joint. Miwag. The Miwag Air Working Group. So there's a Miwag group which represents parties from Inyo and Mono County who are working on information. And one of the things that we needed, and I think it's apparent from our conversation here, is more information. And we had information started from the Inyo County and their consultant, from what we did at Heart and Mead.
1:13:24 But we really need some hard numbers to make a decision. So part of where we're going to number three is saying in order to come back to this board and say what does air service look like and where do we end up, we really need, I hate to say it, we need to do a little more study and get a little more information. What is the actual cost? What are we actually recommending from that standpoint? So we all have an informed decision. And the recommendation here is that we point two board members to this group to relay information so we can pursue
1:13:54 An actual understanding of what is that cost going to be. I sat and I was sitting with Eric and we were driving around the airport and I said, this was a very informative session. I wish we'd done this two years ago. And I was informed that they've been trying to do this for a while. Who's that? I was the one that answered the question. John and I went down and spoke John Urdi.
1:14:16 with the team down there, Kevin Carinchio, and their consultant that they had hired, and they were outlining what they needed to do to get a Part 139 certification. And as John very correctly alluded to, we've always asked him, well, how long, how much?
1:14:36 And that's been a difficult thing to answer. But what has occurred during that time frame is that they've been working with the FAA, and the FAA has been saying, you've got to do this, you've got to do that. And it was very clear that they've accomplished what the FAA has wanted them to do. And in the meeting, they even handed over a certain document, the airport certification manual, that now they have facts and figures that the FAA
1:15:05 FAA is going to go back and assess along with the airport layout plan and probably provide a lot of the information that we seek. So that's in process, but that's taken two years to get there. And in that process, there has been stress testing. There has been all this information that is provided to the FAA. So now they'll...
1:15:31 They haven't looked at those stats and those figures, you know, from a detailed perspective. It's just been in discussion, but now that they actually have the ability to go look at it and comment. So that's part of what it is. And so they were us going down trying to figure out what the opportunity is, and they've made that kind of progress. And to your point of the talking about?
1:15:58 Getting more information, the discussion around, there's $30,000 that's left that was originally approved by the board for funding and being able to use that. So that was my second part. Can I make a point? Yes, sir. So you're not joining, I'm not asking to have representation with Miwog. Correct. That's a governmental group. Correct. What I'm asking for is to have representatives from this board with me when we have meetings with either MMSA or with the town when we're talking about this process. Because Miwog is a pointed group that's official body. And you can attend the Miwog meetings.
1:16:25 But you're not part of the, you're not part of the dais. It's just, it's more to be, just make a clarification. Because going back to Scott's point is, as part of this dialogue, we had spent a certain amount of money with Hartmeet. We didn't spend all the dollars that we had anticipated was going to cost us. There's a portion whereby we may come back to the board and say some of the money should be utilized to finish up clarifying what does this cost, what does this actually mean, and whether it's Hartmeet or another consultant, try to get to the right data so we can have an informed decision.
1:16:55 That's kind of really the end result in terms of how we need it. But with that so that we have not only staff representation but board representation at these meetings so that we can relay back to what is being discussed so we have an informed decision going forward because we're in this time crunch. We're trying to get a TBID renewed. We're trying to pass information. There may be some solutions that are out there but we need to have
1:17:24 conversations in terms of what is the final cost of doing Bishop? What does that mean? And what does that mean for TOTAL air service? I'm sorry, but maybe I'm not understanding completely. Are you actually trying to develop this information about the airport prior to the time period in which we need to get our TBID moving? There are components within that that I believe we need in order to have the TBID resolved and renewed.
1:17:52 Without that information, let's just say, for instance, that Bishop needs only $5 million to get operating. And everybody's throwing out $40 million and it's only $5 million. Are we willing as an organization to say there's a way to help fund to get $5 million there? What if they come back and they say it's $60 million to get it done? Well, okay, but you're thinking that we're going to have that kind of information within some very short and foreseeable time period. I don't know the total.
1:18:22 It's a little time frame, but a lot of information's been handed over. Well, the TBID has a time frame. There is, and my impression is that there are going to be certain things that we are going to be asked to commit to in order to get the signatures for the TBID. So, I think, to your point. Well, that's what, I was just saying things about being unclear. Boy, that's what I'm unclear on, is what we're going to be asked to commit to to get the TBID moving again.
1:18:51 with the cooperation of the Mammoth. That's what we're in conversations with now and that's why I'm asking to have two more board members or two board members joining me in these conversations so that it's not just me sitting in a room representing the organization. To your point, Sean, this is your board.
1:19:05 So, Paul, as it's related to that, there's no way we're going to get the information as to what Bishop is, the final details of that and what the check writing is. I think what is important to understand is that we want to move the air service to Bishop, right? And we want to create an infrastructure that could help us do that. So, as we look at the TBID and when TBID was originally created,
1:19:35 Same goal was there. We want to create an infrastructure that would help us deliver air service to Mammoth. We didn't know how much that was going to be at that point in time, but we know that we want to move our resources in a different direction to create air service in Bishop. So as we look at how the TBID is written,
1:19:55 What is the infrastructure that you can provide? And to be clear, to try and provide some more clarity to it, in some of the discussions we were, what if we were able to ascertain $3 million of funding, you know, on an annual basis to do that? Right now, the budget is $6 to $7 million for TBID. What if $3 million of that was put into an air bucket, either service or infrastructure?
1:20:24 It could go to service here in Mammoth Lakes because we don't know how many years it's going to happen, but we want to see more funding. Eric, if I understand what you're saying correctly, let me just confirm it. Yeah. There's this bucket, and the money in that could be used to subsidize air service in a fashion that we're doing now. Yes. Or it could be used to do something down in Bishop, depending on the legal constraints, et cetera, et cetera. Yes.
1:20:54 Monies in addition to subsidizing air service for some other use such as Bishop, but monies that are presently devoted to subsidizing air service, some of that might be used in a different direction. No. Sorry, if I'm clarifying on that, our current air service support is under $2 million. $1.6 last year, and we're talking about $3 million. We're talking about potentially doubling the dollars. But wait.
1:21:24 I just want to understand where Eric's coming from. I think you're going to as we have a certain allocated funds within that could be adjusted to spend more on air service than what's being spent today. Is that sure? Well, that's a different question. It's in addition to the $2 million that we currently have set aside. That's a different question. And that'll be for this board to decide when the parameters of that become clearer, which they are at this very moment are not.
1:21:56 Terribly clear. Is it fair to say that? I mean, quite honestly, if the discussion were limited to the money that the mountain puts in today that is used to subsidize air service in the mountain, said, oh, I'd rather use that money to do something in Bishop, I don't know that anybody would violently oppose that. If it's additional monies, that's a whole different question. But knowing the parameters of that question would be critical to being able to make the decision.
1:22:23 That's a really good point, and I think that if we evaluate that, so the Mountain last year put in over $3 million throughout the TBID process, all our lodging, retail F&B, and our lift tickets. So is there a way to rewrite that that says this is how you get your $3 million out of the budget? Well, it's a discussion. Yeah. It's a discussion. And I'm sure that once, as Scott
1:22:52 pointed out so emphatically, and I would not support letting the TBID go, no disrespect intended, but it's a discussion that once we know what the boundaries are, what the mountain is in effect requiring, we can as a board make that decision. But it's important to clarify it.
1:23:12 I'm sorry if I seem to be belaboring things, but I got confused when you're talking about how much it's going to cost to develop Bishop Airport. I think that's a number that we won't know for a long time. No, and if we try and create the infrastructure to help do that right now, that's one thing, but if we're actually trying to get that answer before we make a decision, we'll never get it. Okay, thank you. That's where I got confused. So you're going to talk about what our next steps are here.
1:23:42 So as part of this conversation, and as I was pointing back to our item number three, there's conversations with what's happened with Mammoth Mountain and also potentially attendance to the meetwalk as a visitor only, that I'm recommending that we have a couple board members partake in those conversations with Mr. Urdi so that we can report back to the board about that information and what those conversations are so we can answer this question to move ourselves forward. I think...
1:24:10 Personally, I think there's an opportunity to have to clarify these conversations, but I think we all want more information and we all know how to best address and answer this question so we can vote as the board move forward or not move forward. So I'm putting out there that we need two representation, two people to represent the board.
1:24:27 I did, an executive committee, bring that up, and I did say I have a high interest in this airport function. I have a certain interest myself to be there and to be part of the conversations, trying to move air service forward. Mr. Lesma came forward also as a party, but I'm bringing it to the board from the standpoint of opening it up. If somebody wants to be there as part of that, I'm opening it up fully so that we can say...
1:24:52 I think at least two people, be there as part of those conversations, will help clarify what that information is. So I'm bringing the same, we would like to recommend that we appoint two people to join John in any conversations with the Mountain for air service, as well as when possible, attend the Miwog groups and any other air service means, it might not always be jointly, but even separately where time allows, to make sure we all have the same information.
1:25:17 And another point of clarity, just that the conversations really are between the mountain and the town, and obviously Inyo gets involved there. We're being brought into it from that standpoint of the request for funding. We're really not, it's still, the town is working with Inyo, the town is working with Mammoth Mountain, and Mammoth Mountain is working with all three. At the end of the day, it reflects our budget. At the end of the day, it reflects our budget.
1:25:42 Budget and our commitment here, so I believe we need board representation as part of these conversations. Colin's not here. We could nominate him. Counsel's probably a little sticky. I know, I know. Sticky piece. This may be going on after he's done. Yeah, very many too, but I'm opening it up for if anybody else wants to serve. I'm trying to make sure we've got people that are both informed. I'll go ahead. I'm excluding you, sir. Mr. Fox. I got the fox in the N.S. Yeah.
1:26:14 And I don't think we should have more than two just because the meetings are not massive meetings to begin with. Well, you can have more than two. We can have up to four. No, more than two board members. We can have up to four. As long as it's not the majority of the board. Just like you can have three council members in a meeting, you can have two. Can that rotate, John? I really thought on that basis we were limited to two, but I'll defer. No, the council's limited to two because they only have five members.
1:26:42 We're limited to less than a majority of the board. You're right. We're a much larger, more experienced group. So I'm looking for approval for that. If somebody else put the name on the table, I don't think it is with our guidelines that we would... If you guys have interest, Mr. Clark is part of that. No, obviously I'll get to be a part of it too and represent both entities. Because going back to the overall is information back to this board to make an informed decision. That's what I'm trying to do.
1:27:12 Yes, sir. I'll do it if you need somebody. No, I've, so, with that. You can't have three. Right, you can't have three, but. You can have three. Yep. Yep. So, but we can work with, I'm okay with that, because that way it'll allow us a third to, to rotate. Yeah, more than as many as we can legally have. So, all right, so, everybody okay with that? So, we're going to decide on three people. We're going to decide on three people.
1:27:44 Great. And we'll work within them to attend and have information. Again, the only thing I'm going to ask for is that we get as good updates and info as possible coming out of these meetings, the FAA meeting. I'd still love to get an update just written so that there's no accusations later on of, oh, we told you that. I know it's on Granicus. But it would be great to have written updates and memos coming into these meetings so that we know what's going on.
1:28:13 And so that we can actually explain to the community what we know. What I'm thinking, Brent, is that if we have three, then, and John has suggested that two would be a good number, that that way...
1:28:29 You know, depending on availability. Well, because there's going to be some last-minute meetings that will pop up that we need to jump into. We can have people attending, you know, just the two, but depending on availability. See what I'm saying? But just so you understand, with that, I plan to make sure that we're all on the same page sharing information so if someone misses something, we all know what's going on. So we can go back to the board and say, here's what the current situation is. But I think that's a way to ensure that we always have two. Yep.
1:28:58 Sean, you know, I attended both of those FAA meetings, and obviously I have a different perspective, you know, as what the information I was trying to gather, but I did take some notes. If you want me to distribute those notes, I'd be happy to. You know, that's great, and I guess what I'm looking for is I feel like this is a staff job to make sure that we are being informed, and I just want to be clear that, you know, on these minutes of February 7th here, that
1:29:26 I, as a board member, do not want to be put in a position where I'm coming into these board meetings getting a verbal briefing and expected to make a vote on such short notice. And, you know, the Recreation Commission and Recreation Department, I've got to give them great...
1:29:42 credit for walking into those meetings very well informed. And I just want to make sure that we are being properly briefed so that there is no deadline, that our backs are up against a wall and need to make a decision after a verbal. But just to clarify that, that's why there's no vote on the TBID or anything else. There's no backup information today because we're just trying to get information. So I understand, but I just want to make sure we structure this in a way and provide information that's not just...
1:30:09 There's recommendations by staff and what we would need to do and those type of things. There's still some things that are evolving here. So, you know, I'm just, we got a lot of points to cover. It's a lot going on. Totally get it. And that's why it makes those written memos that much more important. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.
1:30:26 Let's go back to new business number two. I'm going to move us along. Yeah, number two hopefully can be fairly quick. Last month, Ken Brangle gave an update on budget for the Chamber with a request of some additional funding for the rest of this fiscal year, and then obviously we can deal with additional funding for the Chamber for the future fiscal year. But right now, there's an ask for $18,900 for the remainder of this fiscal year, the 2017-18 fiscal.
1:30:51 And we didn't have it on there as a vote last week, so I wanted to bring it on for a vote here. So per minutes of last meeting, we all kind of shook our heads, but we couldn't vote on it because we didn't have it on the agenda for last month's meeting. So the request is for the $18,000 to increase the Chamber of Commerce's budget for through to the end of June. And what's that money going to be used for? It's being used to start website redevelopment. It's being used for a business retention and expansion survey, which is in motion now.
1:31:21 and the app that the chamber has released. That's for this year. And then the total for the total request for the new budget year looks like $31,400, and that's increasing on a few of those as well, including peak performance and the business assistance program. So the ask right now is on $18,900. That's an old agenda. Yeah, and I guess that's...
1:31:47 No, I remember this from the minutes, and, you know, I'm not going to have a problem with this again. Just wanted to be clear. Any motion to look forward on this one? We officially move. Move to add the supplemental funds as requested. Second. Second.
1:32:09 Any discussion? So this wouldn't be a six-year commitment, John? No. This is a four-month commitment at this point. We can live with those. The recommendation is four months. Exactly. All right. Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Anybody opposed? Okay. Obviously, when we present the budget, we will hopefully know where we are with the money coming in. Because that will make a lot of sense.
1:32:34 Vehicle partnership, I can just talk on this very quickly. We don't need to get into too much. I'm working on proposals right now with some of the major car companies. We have the expedition that we have has 203,000 miles on it. I had it worked on the other day because it's definitely not got a whole lot of life left in it. And the truck has 166,000 miles on it. We've budgeted the last two years.
1:32:58 lease money into the budget, and we haven't gone out and leased a vehicle because I want to actually have a partnership with a company versus just going out and leasing a vehicle. And so I think that we're moving forward potentially with either a Southern California dealer group or some individual dealers down south to work on not only a partnership but fleet pricing for us to either buy or lease vehicles. I wish it was Tesla, but the roadsters are all in space.
1:33:27 Just as a separate side question though, John, if that were to occur, would there be any potential for businesses to tie into that? You know, it's one of the things that I'm bringing up is to actually see, I've talked to Grady at the town about them having access to fleet pricing. I've talked to Al Davis about fleet pricing and then also I'd like to talk to, I'd like to have that available if hotels want to buy transit vans or if businesses want to buy.
1:33:50 Other transportation vehicles we can get on fleet pricing. I think that would be great. I don't know whether that's something that they're willing to open up, but obviously to have everyone running around in Ford Transit vans or Chevy trucks or whatever, they'll enjoy that exposure. So that's what we're working on right now. My proposal is fairly close to being done. I just have to outline really the deliverables that we'll give them back. But the hope is that we can sign someone on for a $50,000 to $100,000 partnership.
1:34:19 That's the goal. That's a great way to do it. Sounds good. All right. International update. Well, because I originally talked about whether we want to talk about lease or purchase, I'm not going to worry about that this month. Good afternoon, gentlemen. Michael Vanderhurst, Director of International and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I'm going to give you a presentation on where we are with our international markets.
1:34:52 In our international agencies, I'll try and keep it a little bit succinct because I know we're going over time-wise a bit, but this will be a little bit of an update on 2017 and what happened out there around the world with Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So first we'll go back to 2016 to kind of set the template for our discussion. The 2016 international spend was just under $5 million. Again, this is all...
1:35:18 transactions that we track through Visa View. So these are only Visa transactions that occur within our zip code, the 93546. 2016, we had a 10.4% growth year over year over 2015. And you can see the two graphs I put on there, some of the bigger markets.
1:35:39 Again, this is spend. This isn't populated. This isn't the number of people, the number of visitors coming in. There's really no way for us to track that. This is spend on visa only. But it gives you a really good look into who's coming and how much they're spending and the markets that show a lot of growth. So you can see France, China, UK, Germany, a lot of the Western European.
1:36:04 Visitors are still coming in really good numbers and spending quite a bit of money here in Mammoth Lakes. So that's where we'll start the discretion and we'll transition now to 2017. So 2017, we actually had another 10.6% growth over 2016 with the spend in our zip code.
1:36:26 of just under $5.5 million. So a very, very good amount of growth from year over year. And I put California and USA next to it so you could kind of get an idea where we stand against the rest of the nation and against Visit California. So internationally, visits to the USA were actually down 4% in 2017. We were up 10.5%. International visitors to California in 2017 were basically flat.
1:36:55 They had a 0.4% growth into California, and Visit California can track that through the port of entry, so the people that are coming into California through port of entry. Again, this is a little bit apples to oranges because we're tracking spend. They can actually track the number of visitors that are coming in. But it gives you a little bit of idea that we are performing pretty well considering on a national level and on a state level, visitation is down from all international markets. And that's calendar year? Correct.
1:37:24 This is all, yeah, thanks for pointing that, that is all calendar year. So now I'm going to go into each one of our markets, our international markets, where we have representation and...
1:37:34 I provided a little bit of a snapshot to see how we did in 2017. First one is the UK. We share a contract with Mammoth Resorts. The company is called Black Diamond. TT is travel trade. PR is obviously public relations. So our contract, our shared contract represents we have account managers for PR and travel trade. Black Diamond also has the Visit California contract so we can piggyback a little bit on that California messaging in the UK.
1:38:01 The UK market is traditionally a winter market, it's traditionally a ski market, but we have seen a very nice increase in the summer and fall visitation numbers from that market. The dollar is still relatively weak against the pound, but it is gaining strength, so we are still viewed as somewhat of a value destination for the UK traveler. Obviously plenty of lift into California and Las Vegas from the UK, so we benefit from that.
1:38:28 The spend in our zip code from the UK was down 5.2%. That doesn't necessarily mean less travelers. It just means less money being spent in our zip code. So there's a couple different ways we can look into that. And then the PR value in 2017 from the UK, this is from the media placements we've had. This is from the social influencers that we've hosted.
1:38:53 Our agency put together the value of that, and it was a little over $24 million in the UK for media exposure that we gained there, which is a huge number. Like I said, the contract we share with Mammoth Resorts, so it's a very, very influential market for us, and it's always been a traditional, strong winter market that we're seeing a lot more summer. France.
1:39:19 So we're part of an organization through the state of California called the High Sierra Visitors Council. It's us, it's Yosemite, it's Tahoe, it's the city of Bishop, and we are represented as kind of a block of destinations called the High Sierra. The agency we have there is called MNO, Travel Trade PR. Again, they have the Visit California contract, so we piggyback on that California messaging.
1:39:43 Bit different market. This is more of a summer-fall market for us, but they are a very strong market in those two seasons. Plenty of lift into California. Air France just started a new flight last year into SFO that's performing quite well. So as most of you guys know, with our international, especially summer-fall travelers, they tend to go on what's called the loop.
1:40:08 or this California western road trip where they like to get in the Mustang convertible, see the desert national parks, Vegas. We catch them on their way either in or out of Yosemite. They'll go to the coast, San Francisco, down Highway 1, LA, and that's kind of the loop. And usually LAX is their port of entry. Very popular with the French travelers. We saw a 14, a little over 14.5% growth in spend.
1:40:34 from this market, which is a very nice bump. And then our agency, the agency there had media placements that were a little over $3 million in value. And that's not, the $3.3 million is not for all of the High Sierra. That's just specifically for Mammoth Lakes messaging in the French market. Germany, we have a solo contract there. So that's one that MLT carries by itself for travel trade and PR.
1:41:05 MSI is the name of the company. They also represent us in Austria and Switzerland. They also hold the Visit California and Brand USA contracts. So again, we can piggyback on that California messaging as well as the inspiration of the Western road trip with Brand USA. Brand USA also made a huge international push the last two years for the national parks, Yosemite being one of the...
1:41:30 Prominent, featured national parks in all of that messaging, so we definitely benefited from that. Summer, fall market, a lot of lift into California, Las Vegas. This one was interesting. You can see the spend was down a little over 7%. This market, I think, clearly we saw a decrease in visitation from the German market, mainly because of our current political situation on a national level. It's called the Trump slump.
1:42:00 was a country that took a lot of issue with the way our government handled things on an international scale, and a lot of the German travelers in 2017 chose Canada over the United States. There was a couple factors going into it, one being, like I said, our current political situation, and then Canada was also celebrating its 150th anniversary as a nation, so they put a huge amount of money and effort and PR into
1:42:26 into Europe to get visitors into Canada. So that probably is one of the two of the stronger reasons that explain kind of the drop in spend from this market. But again, we still had some great media exposure, $3.4 million in market from a PR standpoint. Italy, again, is another solo contract that we carry for travel trade and PR. Again, it's a summer and fall market for us traditionally.
1:42:55 You can see we had a really nice bump in spend in our zip code from this market, a little over 12%, 12.5%. And our agency there had got us placements, TV, traditional print, and social media, a little over $300,000 worth of value. So considering this contract that we carry with Masters Consulting is at about $15,000 annually, to get $326,000 in media exposure is of great value.
1:43:25 Australia, New Zealand. This one is obviously one of my favorite slides to put up here. The first thing you see is, you know, obviously we share this contract with Mammoth Resorts. We actually, this contract is under the header of California Snow, so we share this contract also with North Lake Tahoe. I don't know what that contract will evolve into going down the road. It may morph into something else, but for the 2017, those are the partners involved.
1:43:52 If you looked all the way down to the annual spend, there was a 71.7% growth in annual spend in our zip code, which is phenomenal. Really, really strong rebound. 2016, we had actually seen a 12% decline in spend from this market. So to bounce back that strongly, I think, is fantastic.
1:44:16 A lot of it had to do with how active we are in this market, not only MLT, but also Mammoth Resorts. Eric and his sales team down there are very, very active, so we work very well with them. You can see the PR value there was a little over $1.7 million in U.S. dollar. Again, that's in the major East Coast markets of Sydney, Brisbane, and Melbourne. So just out of curiosity, because it's not a great exchange rate, is that...
1:44:45 You still feel that's mostly from our placement and our presence within the market? I do. The way we kind of position Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain down there is as a unique destination where you can combine half your holiday on the snow, half your holiday in Vegas, half your holiday on the snow, half your holiday in San Francisco, half your holiday on the snow, half the holiday at Disneyland if it's a family. It's a very unique product that we can roll out down there.
1:45:12 In all honesty, Whistler can't do that. They can't position themselves in that way. Most of the Colorado resorts can't do that way. Can't position themselves in that manner. And really our main competitive competition down there is Japan. And so if Japan comes out of the gate with good, good snow, the Australian market goes to Japan.
1:45:33 If we come out of the gate with really good snow or good messaging, then we get a fairly large share of that market, which last year, obviously, we did, 2017. Does that answer your question? Yes. China. So, we share this contract with Mammoth Resorts. The name of the agency is Avia Reps. It's a huge international company that has offices in just about every market in the world. They also have the Visit California and the Squaw Valley contracts.
1:46:04 in China. So there's some interesting potential for that going down the road. Again, maybe flashing back to that California messaging in China, that inspirational California resort. So that'll be up for discussion probably in the next calendar year. New market for us. We just signed this contract last year with Avia Reps, the shared contract with Mammoth Resorts.
1:46:27 The big push here is obviously Beijing is hosting the 2022 Winter Olympics. So the next three Olympics are in Asia. Obviously Korea has this next week it starts the Winter Olympics. Tokyo is the host for the 2020 summer and then Beijing 2022. So we're really trying to promote Mammoth Lakes as not only that unique California experience but also Mammoth Resorts as we're
1:46:53 The place Olympic athletes are made, where they train, where they hone their skills, and you can come and play on the mountain the same way that they do. So plenty of lift out of China, and then we've talked about this before, that the Chinese traveler now has a 10-year visa waiver.
1:47:12 So it used to be traditionally you had, if you were a Chinese visitor, you had to get a new visa every year. It was a huge pain in the hiney for those folks. Now one visa is good for 10 years. So you're seeing repeat visits, repeat visits. And then the annual spend out of this market, it's kind of a misleading figure, even though it's down 9.5%. Again, this is visa, and most Chinese travelers don't carry a visa.
1:47:38 So it's a hard number for us to really, really drill down on. They carry what's called union pay. It's affiliated with the Discover card. And Discover does not have a program where we can track the spend. It's also a cash-carrying visitor. So there's a lot of cash transactions, which make it tough for us to track as well. And the data from California visitation is that China's up significantly to California, correct?
1:48:07 When they track visitation more so than spent. Actually, the number out of Visit California for 2017 is they're down. Oh, really? They're down almost 22% out of China right now. And we'll find out next week. Visit California has their big annual summit next week, Outlook Forum. I'm sure we'll figure out. They'll explain to us their thoughts on that big drop, but they are down. That's right. That's the same thing we talked about last time about BrandUSA.
1:48:36 The numbers are down, but the dollars are not decreasing at the same that the Chinese market spends more, so that even though there's double-digit declines in the visitors that are coming, it's single digits because they're actually spending more proportionally. Was that, did I not answer? No, you did. You absolutely answered it. Thank you, Scott. South Korea, another new market for us. We share the contract again with Mammoth Resorts, Avia, same company, different agents, different offices, different staff.
1:49:07 This is an interesting one. We kind of are positioning Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain as more of an add-on to a traveler that's already coming to LA or San Francisco. There's a large amount of business travel that happens between Seoul and LA, Seoul and San Francisco. So we are positioning Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain as a pleasure.
1:49:30 Or an add-on. If you're coming over for a business trip, add three or four days, come skiing, add three or four days, go fishing, golf, mountain biking, whatever it may be, and come visit us in Mammoth Lakes. And it seems to be resonating with this market. It really does. So we'll definitely see some interesting numbers coming out of this one.
1:49:52 Annual spend down 8.5% in 2017, but again, it was a new contract, so we're just kind of getting our feet under us right now, but we had some great PR hits in South Korea, so that's it on South Korea.
1:50:08 Scandinavia, you can see there's a huge list of the different markets that this company represents us in. Atlantic Link is the name of the company. A new contract for us again, solo contract, we carried it alone. They also have Visit California and they represent Yosemite National Park. So we definitely share the messaging with Yosemite. Summer, fall traveler, they're again going to do the road trip that we've talked about with some of the other European markets. Good lift into California and we saw a nice little
1:50:38 bump in the spend in our zip code in 2017. We also had some great, great media placements in the tune of a little over $500,000. Quick question on that. When you say that they have a contract with Yosemite National Park, are you referring to the park or the concessionaire? No, so the park is actually represented by a DMO on the west side called Mariposa. Okay.
1:51:04 They have a contract with Atlantic Link. So Mariposa is the one doing the promotions for Yosemite National Park from a DMO perspective. Thank you. So we work in concert with that DMO to promote Yosemite as a destination. Obviously, we're a little bit more biased. We want people staying here on the east side and visiting Yosemite, using us as a hub. But they also, Yosemite typically focuses on winter, the DMO.
1:51:33 They don't really focus a lot on summer because they don't feel they need summer business. They actually are trying to discourage folks from visiting Yosemite in the summer, whereas we say stay in Mammoth, visit Yosemite in the summer, but stay with us. They're focused, like John said, a little bit more on winter. So it's a nice dual message between the two of us. And then some of our smaller international partnerships, much smaller scale in Belgium and the Netherlands, but you can see both of them had a nice little bit of growth in the spend in our zip code.
1:52:05 Potential future markets that we've kind of talked about a little bit. Mexico, Canada, Brazil, Spain, India. I threw down the growth in the spend from each one of those markets in our zip code for 2017. You know, obviously the first two kind of jump out at you a little bit, the Canadian one especially. I think the Canadian traveler is a traveler that would also come to us year-round.
1:52:31 Especially Eastern Canadians, they do want to ski, and they do want to ski in good weather because they don't have it back there. The Canadians also really are road trippers. They like to visit destinations in North America summer and fall. So I think that one's got potential. India, I really kind of haven't got my head around quite yet. We're going to find out, I think, next week. Visit California is going all in on India.
1:52:58 I mean, China's still their number one market they're investing in, but India has definitely jumped into a strong, strong second place with them for Visit California for dedication of their resources. I don't think we see a huge amount of Indian national traffic at this point, but we could down the road, and what I don't want us to do is get left at the station when the train leaves, which it will with Visit California.
1:53:28 We'll definitely have to come back after talking with our counterparts at Visit California and kind of see where we fit into that big scenario. So just to paraphrase in that way, so we got Trump slump from other countries, but from Canada and Mexico, we got Trump bump. I'll leave it at that. Just move on, move on. But you also have to understand the way California is positioning itself as a destination. California is positioning itself as very anti-USA right now. We are unique.
1:53:57 We're accommodating everyone. Everyone is welcome. I've showed you guys this slide before, and I know we're kind of up against time constraint here, so I'm more than happy to send this to you guys digitally, and you can look at it in a little bit more detail. Nothing here is going to jump out at you as out of the box craziness. It's the stuff that talks about our strong suits.
1:54:18 Strategies. You guys have heard me talk about this before. We're on the road. We work really well with our partners on a state level, national level, and then our bigger partners here in destination. We also work very, very closely with Modal County and then the High Sierra Visitors Council. Future opportunities. Again, I'll send this to you guys, and you can look at it in a little bit more detail. The ICON Pass is going to be intriguing, the way that that works for us going forward.
1:54:48 Mammoth is one destination of many now, so our job will be, hey, don't go to Steamboat, hey, come to Mammoth instead, you've got the Icon Pass, come visit us. So we'll have to see how we do that. And that's it. Thank you, Michael. I apologize for being so quick, but I'll send this to you guys. I apologize for that. Thank you, gentlemen.
1:55:10 Thank you. All right, John, if we can kind of keep... Yeah, I'm just going to, for department updates, I think I'm going to stick to a quick marketing update and then have Laura do an update here. And then if you have questions, you can ask me on other things and we can table until next month. But right now, Whitney is out dealing with some family challenges with her folks. So we've got virtual reality is working out well at the trade shows. We've got, I think, our last trade shows next weekend, the Bay Area Travel Show. I think that's the final one for the season before the fishing shows, which we do in March.
1:55:38 Strategy meeting that we have typically is a board meeting, and that'll be in April, so we're working on that. The goal is to have the strategy meeting and the budget meeting at the same time so that you can understand how the budget and the strategy fit together. Our summer marketing kicks off next week, and then our winter marketing is going to run through the end of the month, and our summer marketing is not because it's warm outside. It's actually when we have originally set to get that word out because of the windows that people are booking.
1:56:06 And then we're doing usability studies on the website. Request for the strategy meeting in April. Can you provide us with the strategy in the budget in advance to read so that we don't show up and listen to a conference call and have to make decisions after scrambling through a speaker with Marian Carson? They'll be here. I think having that in advance that we can actually review and use that session to ask questions instead of getting informed and then having to make decisions would be helpful. I will support that request. Thank you, Scott. Okay. Laura?
1:56:39 Briefly, I emailed you all last week. We are officially in escrow on a condo for the crib, so fingers crossed we're supposed to close by February 20th. We already have athletes lined up for March, so just really excited to be able to put them in the new space. Once we close escrow, we're going to do a little get-together, invite the board over so you can see the unit and see where the dollars went. And then the other thing I had was
1:57:07 We have been working with the Mountain. We are going to put up a banner for our athletes out in front of Footloose. There are some restrictions with the IOC Rule 40, so it will be kind of a generic banner, but we wanted to do something to, you know.
1:57:28 Say we're proud of these people. So it won't list their names. It won't have their images. It's just going to say cheer on Mammoth Lakes. Are we not supposed to list names if I got banners ordered? I'm not in here. Well, I think, you know, it's a weird gray line. You know, the mountain can't do anything because they actually sponsor the athletes. The town is technically not a sponsor of the athletes. So that's...
1:57:52 We're okay in doing it, so I would say you're probably fine because you're not an official sponsor of the athletes, but. We're following the mountains guidelines just so we don't get anybody in trouble. We don't want any. We wind up with seven. Five. Five. Yeah, so all three women in the U.S., Half Pipe, Sean White and Stacey Cook. Yeah. Stacey is going even after her. We had a crazy crash the other day. We haven't seen it. We went super sideways on that one. Yeah. So that's it for me.
1:58:20 Thank you. I'm going to skip chamber update because the chamber is on our next presentation for next month. Air service update I can give really quickly. Our blended cancellation right now for the year is 6.23%. I wish we had snow and it might be a little bit higher. San Francisco is at 4.3%, San Diego is at 4.3%, Los Angeles is at 6.7%, and JetSuiteX has not canceled and, as far as I know, have only diverted once to Bishop this year.
1:58:49 So again, lack of weather means that we have low cancellation rate. Right now for Los Angeles through February 6th for the year, we are up 2,945 round trip passengers. For San Diego, we're up 1,071. San Francisco is up 188 and Burbank with Jets Week X is up 147. So we're up 4,351 total round trips compared to last year.
1:59:15 Unfortunately, our December subsidy numbers came in, and even though we were actually ahead of last December, the cost structure and a few other things, the effective rates were lower, so our subsidy was actually higher in December. Even though we had more passengers, we had them at a lower rate, and we actually had more available seats because we didn't have as many cancellations. So the December subsidy was up substantially, probably $100,000, something like that. Pretty close. When do we drop down to one flight?
1:59:45 That would be April 15th or somewhere in there. And just one note though, January was surprising to me to see that it was 9% cancellation. Yep. Yeah, we had 9.1. In total for all, with JetSuiteX not having a single cancellation. Yeah, we had 12.9 out of San Francisco, 10% out of San Diego, 9.8 out of Los Angeles. They all were weather and they were all really wind related.
2:00:15 We had some howling winds there for a while. Moving on, financial reports? Yep, financial. TOT, I can hand out the TOT reports. But just quickly, we, for the year over year, we are, for December, we were only down $25,000, 1.1%, second best December ever.
2:00:38 And the TBID for the month of December, it was down 1.3% to budget, and that was only, that was less than $10,000. And year to date on the TBID, we are $2,867 behind our budget, and that's 0.14%, so not even a quarter of a percent that we're behind, so. We need to talk about your budget. What, being accurate? Yeah. Not being, yeah.
2:01:04 Actually, you know, we budgeted $5.29 million on the TBID this year. Last year's actual was $5.875. So we actually did, we were conservative, but the year before was $4.606. And then cash flow in the CDARS, we have $1.25 million in Measure A, and $500,000 of that is being cashed out tomorrow for the CRIB.
2:01:27 And then the TBID, we have $2.5 million that are in there. A million dollars of that will be coming back out to support the increases to the budget this year. So $500,000 of that was the savings on air service last year. The other $500,000 is what we committed to the budget this year, above and beyond. So that will go down to $1.5 and the Measure A budget will go to $750. The bank balances right now, we have $1.982 million in the checking account.
2:01:52 For Measure A. And again, it seems a little inflated, but we're getting paid quarterly by the town now, so we're not getting paid monthly. So back in January, they wrote us a check for $1,200,000 for the December, January, February timeframe. The savings account has $5,010 in it in Measure A, and TBID has $411,000 in checking and $5,000 in savings. And yeah, the quarterly payment from the town was $1.227 million.
2:02:21 And then the P&L reports I sent out yesterday, there are a few things in there that are timing, but for the most part I think we're right on track with everything the way that we had set it out, but we have some timing on Marion Carson bills, which tend to be hefty chunks of money that we pay out. Not a large discrepancy, but looking at the December numbers you sent out, lodging was up over budget plan for December, but restaurants were down. Yeah, restaurants were down $46,000.
2:02:50 Does something happen? Is there something we should be doing as an organization to make sure people are going into our restaurants in town? Yes. I'm curious if there's something happening, like are we finding that people are, you know, last year because of weather, people were more likely to go out and spend? I'm just curious where that's coming from, if there's any indication. Well, I mean, anecdotally, from my property, from the standpoint, just like on Sundays, people leaving, December, people just got up and left.
2:03:12 Last year, people hung around, they might have gone skiing for the morning, they had breakfast in the morning, but just as one small portion, breakfast has been very slow on departure days, no one's hanging around, they're all getting out of here.
2:03:24 They're not waiting for weather. I think it's really interesting because in December, people were saying the opposite, that people were here in town and spending more time in the restaurants. That's what we were feeling. And to see it come in at this is kind of surprising. That's what I heard the same. But the dollars don't match that. And I'm curious what that is. Are they spending less? We can check with the town. I think the increase in lodging is more, it's probably based on rate.
2:03:51 You know, based on the fact that we had such a killer year last year, I think my guess would be that lodging properties probably took ADR up fairly substantially for the holidays this year. So that may be where we're seeing a bump there. There was three strong weeks this year too, you know, of the holiday period with high ADRs. Plus people booked early and we held them into their bookings. Yeah, so we were down 9% on restaurant. I can check with the town and make sure that that's...
2:04:18 The numbers do fluctuate, so next month you may see it move, like even looking at the TBID numbers for November on the December report, they moved quite a bit. So it may be also some late payers, things like that. I mean, it's not going to make up $46,000, but it might be some of those things. Yep. Any other questions there? Mr. Clark, I hear there's some news at the Mammoth Mountains. Excuse me.
2:04:47 Altera Mountain Company. I think the last time we got together, the company's been named, since the last time we've gotten together, the company's been named, also come out with the Icon Pass. Pretty exciting in that sense. And, you know, I'll share with you now that the whole concept of bringing those companies together was about being inclusive and going out and having that kind of pass product. That was one of the reasons.
2:05:16 Things that they were looking at when they were underwriting the opportunity of the new company. And so it's really great to see it come to fruition and exciting to have that many people affiliated with our company. And indeed, as Brent, there's been another announcement today that the PR went out and it's been leaked out previously by the man himself in various meetings.
2:05:43 Rusty Gregory is the new CEO of Altera Mountain Company, so he'll be the head of that, take us into the future, not the temporary, where we had a temporary. The temporary CEO was head of asset management for KSL, and he'll be returning to that position. So he'll still be involved and on the board as well, but Rusty will be leading the charge.
2:06:10 For it, and he'll be located in Denver, but his home will always be here in Mammoth. Something we start to look at, and we're very proud of the fact that Eric Fursell's the CMO, Rusty's the CEO, Bruce Burton is the head of IT, Tammy Innocentis is a big part of the company, Emily's going to be a big part of the company, Jimmy's going to be a big part of the company.
2:06:40 Ron Cohen. Ron Cohen, yeah. Thank you very much. Sorry. So a lot of our leaders are stepping into leadership roles for the big company. Great. Is Ron taking a position with Altera? Yes. Ron is the, let me see if I can get this right, the Assistant Deputy Counsel for Altera Mountain Company. Wow. Great. So will he be located in Denver as well? He's located here in Mammoth.
2:07:10 And they're kind of, the way they're separating their legal duties is kind of more regional. So there will be somebody in Denver, they'll be, Ron will kind of represent California, so forth. So that's why. And then, you know, just going to, obviously, not as much snow as we want. Last year we had a lot more snow, but we're...
2:07:36 To let you know that through January 28th, we were only 0.5% down in our skier visits to the previous year. So marketing does help. And I'm not one of those that says all you need is snow because I think you do need marketing. And it shows in a year like this, like you were making the point earlier. Unfortunately, that's not the same thing for Bear and Snow Summit. They're down 29%. Ouch.
2:08:07 Ski visits are only down 0.5%. Can you speak to revenue? Revenue looks good. I won't be as specific, but very similar. Great. Good. Thanks, sir. Yep. You guys, takeaways at the bottom. Anybody, board comments before we close out here? That's me, March 7th. Thank you, everybody, for your time today. Appreciate it, and have a great afternoon. Thank you. Thank you.