Town Council
· recording 3 hr 42 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
505 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:58 Okay, good afternoon. Welcome, everybody. This is the regular town council meeting for Wednesday, February 7th. And we'll start with a workshop. We'll do our pledge and that's definitely at the regular meeting. And the workshop is regarding the cannabis tax ballot measure and the council's review and discussion of potential items to be part of that measure. So with that, would go the roll call vote, please, Jamie, to make sure we're all here.
2:28 Here. Here. Here. Bill's kidding. He's all here. So, good. So, Rob, is this you? Yes. Okay. Okay. Thank you. So, just a little bit of a process about how we're going to go through this. We have HDL here as our industry representatives, our industry experts, if you will, David McPherson.
2:54 Who will be walking through a presentation about the industry and some of the work that they're doing. And he'll talk about their extensive knowledge and just some things that they're seeing. Then he'll kick it back to us. We'll talk a little bit about our methodology and approach to the recommendations that we've made. And then we have four questions that we would like to address and have you guys address and decide policy on. Okay. And those, the four questions you're referring to, just for council's edification.
3:19 On the agenda action sheet, there are four bullets listed under the paragraph, starting with staff is working to prepare a ballot measure, and there's four bullets underneath, though. The third bullet may be two separate questions, but those are the questions you'll lead us through that you'd like direction on, correct? That is correct, and we also have them at the end of the slides here, too, so we can leave them up in front of folks, but those are the correct questions we'll have. Okay, good. And I'm happy to see...
3:44 Our friends from Mono County here, and we'll certainly give a chance, you guys, I know, hi guys, you went through your session with HDL, everybody seems to be, I don't see any blood or anything, it looks to be in good order, so there'll be plenty of opportunity for you guys to offer your feedback, because we work together to come up with a policy that's going to work for all the residents of the county. So, HDL? Yes, so, David? Thank you, good afternoon. David McPherson, HDL, I'll just clarify when he says industry.
4:15 Expert. We're government. But that's the case. Rob, am I using the arrow on this? Yes. Okay. And this kind of just gives you, we represent 400 cities and counties. You're actually a client of ours for other services. We appreciate that. But more importantly, our expertise is we're former regulators from Nevada, from Nevada, Colorado, and I was actually the first person in the country to tax and regulate the industry when I was in Oakland from the beginning.
4:43 What we're here today, and I think, you know, there's a lot of shifting parts that go on to developing a regulatory and a tax ordinance, and today we're in the education mode, trying to look at that, and Mayor, you had mentioned about the collaboration with the county, so that's part of the slide, is it's not only with the county, but it's your other stakeholders involved with that, and so we are where we are with that.
5:06 So as we move through this and through that process in the next couple weeks as we have to go to get a resolution to put them out, get out the ballot and then eventually to the election. The first thing I want to really part of is really the focus of our meeting this morning because I think it's important as policymakers as you develop a tax measure is you understand some of the moving parts and we kind of work in silos a lot of times and it's important to understand
5:36 Where this industry has gone, when we were in a black market to a gray market, as we come into a regulated world, and really how the economy is changing in this, just like, you know, I like to use the analogy of the Ubers and the AirBs of the world, of where hotels and taxis were impacted by this, whereas the economy changes for this industry regulating, it changes. So today in the market, CDFA, which is the agency over the cultivation side of things, when they did their
6:04 Their big impact report, they had determined that the consumer demand in California today is 2.5 million tons, which seems like a lot, but maybe not a lot, but what we know what's already permitted, which is almost 700 businesses permitted just in this month as we've transitioned to January 1st, is that we know what is already permitted is going to create over 4.8 million tons.
6:34 Just in 700 businesses. However, bigger than that, because of all the other illegal businesses and businesses that aren't going to come into the regular world, that the production through their report, and based on where we understand, is there's going to be 13.5 million pounds being produced annually. And that's why we have a black market. Just to be clear, are you talking, did you misstate tons and pounds earlier? You're correct, it's pounds. Pounds, okay, good.
7:03 I did say tons and I meant pounds. I apologize. So I want to paint that picture because when we talk about why there is going to be a black market and there's an oversaturation of product and what does that do to a regulated market in a business model from beginning to the end all the way to the consumer and will the consumer come and buy a product in a regulated market?
7:25 So there's more figures about what we estimate down the road that CDFA from regionally anticipated that was going to be permitted for cultivation. And then this kind of just breaks it down what regions are going to be receiving that. In your case, you're not a big player in the market when it comes to cultivation and manufacturing as a county or as a city. And so how that impacts your businesses that are going to be.
7:50 Regionally based, but having to get down the hill to move the product to market to the bigger population. And then this is kind of really some of the breakdowns of the volume of takeaways from that. So this chart, your pie chart, what CDFA did at the beginning in 2016 is they went out and did a survey of everyone that had an interest or that was already existing. They said either you're in business, even a black market, gray market, or consideration of that.
8:22 And so when the response to the survey is they didn't do it for each city because they didn't want confidentiality, they just kind of did it by counting. But what I wanted to point out here is that you can see where there's not a whole lot of numbers over that, even if this number has grown to two or three times, we're really talking about a market of 25 to 35 businesses that would be in the region consideration. Now on this chart, it didn't even show dispensaries, so obviously the poll results didn't reflect that, even though you have two here.
8:51 So what does this mean to the business as a policy decision as you determine tax rates and what does that mean to them and to you? Because at the end of the goal, it's about sustainability on both sides to make sure that it works for both sides. So the first thing I want to make sure in point, and earlier we talked about outreaching, educating about, you know, if the county did a tax.
9:13 You know, and the voters of all the county are and how that impacts you and vice versa. If you did a tax, how people will perceive it about voting for both of them. And I think one of the other issues is they also have to be educated and be aware that this is not a tax on them. This is a tax on the businesses that are going to be potentially allowed into the city. And therefore, that message needs to get across as well, that just like a TOT, and you are a big TOT world, that this is on the businesses.
9:43 And not on them as they vote. So these are various taxes. And as the Prop 64 came in place, you have both the traditional
9:54 Because of the retail side, you still have the sales tax side. On the other end, where it's just the wholesalers, you do not have a retail, I mean, there is not a sales tax element in there. But one of the things that are a misconception of is that the medicinal side or medical side is exempt from the tax because Prop 64 says it is. But when we get to another slide, we're going to talk about really how minor that is and that exemption in people that are eligible.
10:22 But I wanted to share on this slide here about the gross receipts. We're going to go a little more detail on the breakdown of this, but it's just the various touching points of this. And as we talk about the retail sacks of Prop 64, the 15% tax, which when we get to the end, you're going to see an accumulative chart. And then you have a cultivation tax that they're being taxed on their flower and their leaves that they may have before they even get it to market as a cultivator. So this is the slide I was referring to.
10:52 On the medical side, there is an exemption for sales tax at the state level and at the local level, but only for those individuals that have the H&S 11362.71 card. The last time we checked in the county, they only had registered less than a half a dozen people that were eligible for that.
11:15 And the reason I pointed out, it's really to the minimus that people are going to be exempt from the sales tax side of it from the medical side if that's the only that you're going to be permitting. And then the local tax, which is why we're having this conversation today. There's some people that are in the perception that, oh, we can't do a local tax because at the state level that's not the case. You will have a tax in place to address that.
11:43 Here's that tax when we look at considering developing the tax. These are all the burden costs that are going to be new to a business that was thriving before, but now we're going to be taxed. So you have the 15% excise tax that's going to be billed on to the consumer buying it out the door along with that sales tax. And then on the front end, they're going to have the cultivator that's paying these taxes of an excise tax that's going to be...
12:11 Taking in from the distribution center on these tacks, so they're going to be hit per ounce of flour that goes out the door. And then when they move it through a distribution center, they're going to be charged that markup just to move a product, and then traditionally they were moving it themselves, and now you have another business that's going to take a piece of their pie. And then the state's got permits now, and then you're going to have local permits associated with an annual cost recovery to regulate the industry.
12:42 So with that said, just after this morning we talked about it, and Mayor, you were there, to where they're going to do as far as direction from the county. Same with you. Theirs is the opposite, so they needed a two-thirds vote or a four-fifths vote to move it to a general tax. You don't have that restriction of the decision made as far as which tax you do. But on the general tax, it's a 50 plus one.
13:07 We've had seen three special taxes move forward between 2016 and now, and all three of them had failed for various reasons. The highest one that got close enough was Sacramento had one on cultivation. They were going to earmark the funds, especially for education and addressing youth issues.
13:29 And it only got 64%, so it was all or none. They have 200 cultivators that they're not being able to tax, so they could only get the cost recovery fees associated with that and then get the tax. So that's something to keep in mind, and you get more flexibility. Use the money as you see fit in a general tax versus a special tax. It's got to be earmarked specifically for one purpose.
13:53 This is the outcome of 2016 of the ballot measures. You can see both north and south, they were very successful. Again, we only saw three or four that failed, and they were all the special tax ones that did that. Tax measures that came last March and last June, there was only about six of them. They were all successful. The closest one to you was Cal City that did theirs. They were all very successful and made those margins of over 50% very easily.
14:23 So I know the focus is going to be on the retail side or the gross receipt element of things, and we'll focus on this, but I just wanted to share with you, and staff wanted me at least bring your attention of options on the cultivation side, and this is really only for cultivation of square footage, and that's only because in the days, being a city versus a county,
14:45 You know, outdoor versus indoor girls, you're going to be in unique different situations. Their focus was different than what yours would be on that. So I won't go into the detail of the square footage element, but there's options for that if you want me to come back and have more of a conversation on the square footage of that. But I know we were going to focus on the gross receipt today. So with that said, gross receipts options for you. The flat tax is not necessary.
15:12 You know, that's the bare minimum one of that. We recommend that you have an initial rate and not to exceed. So if you do a flat tax, where we've had some cities, they put a hard number on it, and they wanted to move down to some of their businesses that were impact, they couldn't. They have to go back to the voters. At the same time, if you wanted to move it up, you want to have a little bit of flexibility in there and the ability to do that, and just having a flat rate doesn't do that.
15:36 So, as we mentioned, our recommendation and what we're suggesting to recommend to you is you have an initial rate that's a comfort zone in today's environment, but that you have some kind of flexibility to move it up a little bit as you see that. I want to remind you that, remember, in gross receipts, it's like inflation, that as inflation goes, gross receipts go up.
16:01 So today's gross receipts will change over time so it has its own progression through that. It's not a stagnant number like a flat tax, I mean like the cultivation tax rates would it be. And then you can have adjustments of CPIs or rate increases. Now, one of the things that we've done...
16:22 From last year's ballot measures, because we weren't in a regulated world was, is that we were recommending that there be a three-year freeze to let the industry that's still building buildings out, trying to get regulated, trying to figure out what they're doing and get investments to get their business up and running, that we recommended at that point a three-year freeze on whatever rate that is. In your case, you've got a smaller amount of numbers. You've already got two retailers up and running.
16:49 You know, doing a lower number than three is not necessarily a bad thing, but having something where they have at least transitioned through everything to get them through. Because also keep in mind, the regulations at the state level right now are emergency regulations. They could change in a year from now. We probably anticipate probably 10%, 15% change in that, but nothing significant that we've seen happen every six months that we just recently went through.
17:18 So this is really the meat and potatoes of our conversation this morning, which I want to share with you. And do they have hard copies of this, Rob, by chance? Well, just our hard copy is the producer price is at $800. Not $1,000. Is that? Okay. For the purpose of this discussion, it's not going to matter if it's $100. It's going to have it consistently the same. I think the bottom liner is still in the 29 percentile liner. But the discussion we'll have to do that. So I think we had a bad copy that we had in the tax rate that I think the one you had.
17:48 At the bottom was at eight and a quarter total. So I wanted it to reflect more on the retail side of this. So with that said, really what we're looking at to share with you is so when we did ballot measures two years ago, the price per pound for indoor grow was $2,000 a pound. Today's market for indoor grow is roughly around $1,640 and as low as $1,220 depending if it's a mixed light type of a grow. But what you're seeing is a trend in a different direction.
18:16 We also see that in 18 months from now is why we gave $1,000 using it for this scenario. And this is $1,000 a pound is where we see the product going in 18 months because we'll have a saturation of market. And within three years, when all the big players get up and running and have their big facilities going that are being built out,
18:37 The price is going to plummet again a little bit, almost $800 a pound. And I'm talking specifically you for indoor growth since that's kind of the primary where you're going to be. So with that said, if you look at when you start dropping in the numbers of the tax measures, Prop 64 automatically created a nine and a quarter ounce tax.
18:56 In there, so if you add the fee on a batch in there from a testing lab, and then that product moves to a manufacturer to create oils for it, and they mark it up 20%, and you have a tax associated with that, and then the distributor marks it up 30% to move the product for them, and you tax it on there, and then once the retailer gets that product and he doubles the price, that he has it, you know, over a little $2,000 a pound to $4,000 a pound to move it to market.
19:26 Now he's got to compete with black market is where do I price it at so I can compete with a black market by getting someone to come into my retail establishment because now when he or she sells it, they have the 15% excise tax built on that and they still have the sales tax on there.
19:45 So the goal at the end of the day, like in alcohol, is to keep it under 30%. That seems to be the pain point. We saw what happened in Washington, where they got up to 38% to 42%, and they basically, they were having people selling it illegally. As they brought it down a little more, people were more willing to do that. We also saw the same effects in Colorado, but Colorado has different tax rates, but they did bring it down significantly as well, as low as down to 8%.
20:14 Fortunately, ours constitutionally 15% is hard locked until another ballot measure goes out or proposition goes out to bring that down so the locals can get more money to that. So right off the bat, the state's getting 25% of this, even though you'll get 1% of the sales tax. So really, what do you have to work with? You're in that range where it's been an acceptable range between 4% and 6% that really...
20:40 At the end of the day, drives for the consumer willing to buy the product. The reason I bring that up is because what I've done, and these are numbers, by the way, are not set in a recommendation as far as
20:51 Specifically for what you're going to set it at. I threw numbers in for a range to just give you that how I got to 30% and whatever way you move this depending on where you're looking at it to get it there to figure out am I encouraging black market? Am I going to make my businesses sustainable? And am I taxing them too high or too low that we're in a comfort zone with that?
21:14 So right here, if I'd like to stop, if you've got questions at this point, it might be a good time to do that because a lot of this is going to drive the conversation, I believe. Good. Thank you. I've got a couple of questions. Anybody else got questions so far? John, normally you have a long list, so let's hear yours first. And then if I need to ask anything, I will. Okay. I just got a couple of questions. You mentioned the – it seems like you're kind of factoring in a black market competition back somewhere around the wholesale.
21:43 Piece of this. I think, I mean, we're all assuming that the state is, with the excise tax money they're taking, that they're going to effectively police this market, and that the black market coming at the wholesale point is going to be minimal. Are you not thinking that? Are you thinking that it's... No, what I'm, what you've got to remember, I showed you their demand's 2.5, right? Sure. And we know already they're producing 4.5. So what we're already seeing happening is,
22:13 You have manufacturers and retailers are standing relationship from buying futures. They say, instead of me buying it at $1,500 a pound, I'll do a five-year contract with you and buy it at $1,000 a pound. And you have growers that traditionally have been up even at the triangle, which is Mendocino and Humboldt and Trinity, that we're getting $2,000 a pound. Now that there's more of a legal market, even the retailers are saying, wait a minute, you're selling something to me at this.
22:39 This same quality that I can get for this person for half the price, I'm now about getting the price. There is way too many growers, and that way me as a retailer can get picky and choosy, so all those cultivators and manufacturers are fighting to be, and I'll give you an analogy, there's only 40 spaces on a shelf.
23:01 You've got 15,000 business fighting for those 40 spaces on a shelf. But are those 15,000 businesses legitimate? Are they licensed by the state? Over time it will, but even in today's market, there's 700 businesses that are already producing enough for the whole state. Okay, so you're assuming that this is all the process of these businesses becoming legal over time, but even still that's affecting...
23:21 It's already affecting it, yeah. And again, even with 700 businesses, it's already affecting it, Mark. And they're going to get up and running over time. Okay. The big players that are driving this whole production haven't even built out their million square foot facilities. They're still in places that are, we already know of thousands of permits that are not up. They're going through their planning stages right now. Okay. And the other, at the bottom line, you mentioned that the range that we have to work within to keep it below that.
23:50 30% threshold was, what, 4 to 8% or something? What I'm saying is the state's already taken 25, right? So when you look at, when you start examining something, what is going to be acceptable threshold? When we look at statewide, what we've done just since Prop 64, that there is industry that are making their decisions of where they go that is in that range of anything under 6% because you have venture capital saying, I can go buy property cheaper here, I can get my product to market easier here.
24:19 And my taxes are lower long term. All those things come into place plus getting people to work at their facilities. So they take all that in consideration when they've got options. When there was only 20, 25 cities before November of 2016, people would give their first boring to get in one of those agencies. But now that there's 125 agencies and we've got...
24:44 15 times more product out in the market. It's a crash to the bottom of who's going to get stuck with the gold pans and shovels versus how are people going to be competitive. Okay, good. So that's a combination of everything. All right, thank you. Any other thoughts or questions? I feel you guys good. I had one thought. You said that the tax, and it's important we get that out here, is on the seller, not on the user. But in the end, the user pays the tax. So while it is
25:14 Not aimed at him. He is the one that's going to pay it. So it does play into the whole scenario. Correct. The tax for the purpose of the ordinance is on the business. But at the end of the day, both of them feel the brunt of it. Because if I have less people coming to my facility as a result of that because people go to the black market or find an alternative, at the end of the day, nobody wins in that scenario. So it's just a matter of being mindful of that. Sorry, go ahead.
25:42 When you're talking about the tax rate being at 30% or 25% or wherever that is, is that the total tax after we've taxed the tax on the tax because we're taxing the wholesaler and then that tax stays in place and the tax at the retailers? Because in what I had looked and read, it looked like that just with what California is doing, the end cost has a 34% total tax.
26:10 Right in it. Am I missing the... Well, that's kind of what we built into this. This one is why, again, if you take the nine and a quarter, which is a percentage, you take the sales tax and the excise tax, that alone is at 25%. So that's part of already built into this model to do that.
26:30 So at the end of the day, it's where do you want to be when you create those rates? Not only an initial rate to kind of see where it is, to kind of let them up and running, but giving you flexibility so that you've got some movement. You know, if they become, they do very success, they're very successful, you want to have a little flexibility down the road, you don't have to go back to the voters to try to do something. At the same time, if they're struggling and
26:55 You can see that as the economy struggles in their businesses and you have some opportunity to be flexible on the other end to that. So I have another question on that. So if we use an NTE tax rate so that it is a flexible rate, we can then choose to either go up or down? That's correct. You just can't go higher than what the voters give you permission to do, but you can always go down. If in the ballot measure we say we are going to have an NTE of X,
27:24 But we're going to start at Y. Does that lock us into Y or can we then reduce that?
27:31 So whatever you put initial rate, it doesn't matter what it is because that initial rate or whatever you do, not to an exceed. It's really about the not to exceed because in the ordinance itself, which we just had a conversation, is you as council have the authority to always reduce at any degree. You can even exempt a section. You have the authority to do that and bring it back up to the point where the voters give you permission to do. You just can't go be on.
27:57 What the voters give you permission to do. And as long as you can all categories. So this has to do with discussion, which we haven't got to the adult side versus the medicinal side, because if you did just medicinal and all of a sudden some change down the road and you choose to do that, you know, on the adult side, you want to have the flexibility and not have to go back to the voters, even though you may not do it at this point in time. Thank you. Okay. Okay, thank you. Before we, any thoughts on the public, what we've heard so far?
28:31 Good afternoon, Council Staff, Robert Calvert, Mammoth Lakes Wellness. I just made some notes on your slideshow. Thank you very much, David, for your slideshow. I've been in this business for eight years. I was first permitted for the retail location here in Mammoth Lakes, and we just had our worst year. We're down 25%. So one of your slides, you talked about the size of the business in California. I have always...
28:55 It's talked about Mammoth as being a very unique market, and this is not, this is very unlike the San Fernando Valley, Southern California, as we all know in many aspects of business that we all are, many of us work in. So it's a very, very unique market. I appreciate your professionalism, and I think you have a lot of good things to say, and thank you for your time. So what you've stated, Bill, Councilman Sauser,
29:25 Yes, the consumer is going to be paying the tax, because I can tell you right now, I can't absorb any more taxes. I'm for a tax, but there is a tremendous amount of taxes. I think it's taken a tax expert to really operate how we're going to move through each and every tax that we have to calculate into our final price that we are offering to the consumers.
29:52 The consumer will be, I can tell you that, because I can't absorb any more taxes. So one thing that is very challenging for us here, and it was spoken about in some of the slides, is that we're very limited here on our ability to purchase products, and especially with all the new retailers and the new companies that are being licensed, we are limited due to our location as far as
30:22 How are we going to get deliveries here? UPS doesn't really deliver, but cannabis products right now. So it is a challenge. We are in a very remote location. So we may not have access to a full menu of products from distributors. So we may be forced as retailers to pay a higher price. And it's a very challenging situation right now that I'm facing.
30:48 Back to the experts on the tax. What about the 15% tax that we are paying as a retailer to the wholesalers? I see the 9.25 per ounce and the 275 on trim. Right there, 15%. 15%. Now, that's a state excise. But if you're bringing me product and it's cartridges or edibles, I pay a 15% tax on that.
31:18 Mark it up to sell to the consumers. I also have to charge the 15% California excise tax along with the state sales tax. And then there's probably going to be TBID. We're going to have to somehow track our consumers if they're coming in. So that's something else to consider. TBID on top.
31:37 I was able to prove that early on when the TBID first started because we were able to track where all of our patients were coming from. Now, I don't know how we're going to be able to track that. We will be able to scan a driver's license. But whether or not a majority of our customers are locals or tourists, that's going to have to get to be decided. And so the TBID is going to be applied on top of that. So something to consider, additional tax. So we've got taxes.
32:06 Coming in every way at us. So those are my notes for now. Thank you. Thank you very much. I'm sorry, sir. There's a couple more thoughts from the public here. I just want to remind everybody we're going to we're trying to get through this by six. So we'll want to hear from everybody, but we do want to try to get done by six. Janet Dutcher, Finance Director for Mono County. Our board met earlier today with David's assistance to review our
32:35 Proposed tax ordinance and tax structure. And if it's appropriate this time, I can give you an update on the results of our meeting. We met for two hours to... I'd like to wait until David's finished with his presentation. I'm not sure he's quite done yet. Okay. Would you just... I'll be here for the duration of the meeting. Just let me know when you'd like me to get up and provide... We're looking forward to that information. I just want to make sure that David gets done. Thanks. Thank you very much. David, please proceed.
33:05 I think what the gentleman was referring to is the distribution of the markup. It's not a tax, but it's obviously a cost that he's being charged for the distribution element of that. So with that said, we did just try to look around of where you're at. Obviously, Janet's going to talk to you about what the outcome is, but similar range in the conversation that where we started at, there was no action taken direction other than cultivation is going to be at one element of that.
33:33 So we were trying to look at comparisons to you. You know, we looked at South Lake Tahoe. South Lake Tahoe hasn't come up with a tax yet other than their general business tax at this point. We're trying to look at someone that's more of a similar to you that we just didn't find because most of them have a ban activity. Closest we can find is a beach city that's a county that kind of has a similar scope of Santa Cruz and where they're at. They're at 7%. They've been there for a long time, but they have put it, again,
34:01 They were a 2014 ballot measure when 10% was more of the common, and there were tourists with some college universities there. But what I did want to share with you is where things have gone since then is that range statewide, either what industry and what agencies are putting it at, even though they may have some of them, because they're also doing development agreements, some of them that actually took a piece of dirt and built out the development agreements, and so the average with all that kind of components is in the four to six range, which is
34:31 Which is going out statewide. And where we were $15 to $25 a square foot for the majority of those that were first movers, that price has come down significantly to the $6 to $10 a square foot in the cultivation element of that. Which $10 is a roughly about a 4% comparison. So you'll know where that is in the gross receipt side.
34:55 So the mechanics of other issues is this is a cash industry. So how we're looking at it, I think we're a little farther along as far as technology and forensic can be able to do that. We're more comfortable with how to address the concern of cash. It's more procedurally that we will work or staff as part of the implementation element of this. So those issues that you were in the past, always a concern. And you've had retailers in town already. So it's not like what it's like if they're going to get.
35:24 The taxing element of the frequency of that, we built that into the tax ordinance as well with a monthly quarterly to do that. So it gives the staff the opportunity to get the money in a little earlier and make sure that it's cash, it's not concerns of something happening to the business.
35:50 So procedure step. So the next step, and I'll move this over back to Rob, is developing the business tax ordinance, which we've preliminary draft have been looking at, and then the resolution component of this. So with that, I'll turn this back over to Rob. Thank you very much. Thanks.
36:10 So some of the things that were discussed, as staff, we try to narrow the focus and the questions that we asked of council, and we took into consideration some of the prior discussions that council has had on this topic and narrowed down. For example, the question about whether this would be a general tax or a special tax, I think that question has been addressed by council, and at least unofficially, that we want to go with the general tax. So that question is not being asked of you today, but it's certainly on the board.
36:37 The Board, if you want to discuss it and make that determination. But we really, really kind of narrowed down. We tried to give a range of tax rate recommendations that would allow for future growth, because as it's been demonstrated, this industry is going to be brand new, essentially. It's developing rapidly.
36:59 If we have to go to voters for a tax initiative and to set that maximum level, we don't want to have to go back to voters if we've missed it at some point in the future. So we want to make that range tall enough so that we could develop if it's a very strong industry in, say, five to ten years. So that will be a question that is asked of you today. What is the cap or not to exceed rate?
37:22 For retail. And then what is a not to exceed rate for what I'm calling supply chain taxes, but they're the distribution, manufacture, cultivation taxes. And we're kind of grouping those into a secondary group because those are certainly less than the retail side, but something to be considered. So that's kind of a frame up, if you will, about the elements, and then we can walk through them individually.
37:48 If you'd like or if you have any questions at this point, we can address those as well. Yeah, I think what I'd like to do is maybe put the, do you have slides of the specific questions you're going to want the council to address? What's that? Yeah, the four questions. And I think what I'd like to do is put those up or make sure we're familiar with those and then go back out to the public and the county wanted to maybe speak to what your conversation was like today so as we start going through this, we've got some information from the county folks, see where we're at with that.
38:16 John, I would ask to hear from the county prior to dealing with the four, so I know what their thoughts are. Yeah, that's the idea. So, John, should we walk through the four questions just as a summary review? Okay. We'll preview the questions, and then we've got that, then we'll go out to the public and the county, and then we'll come back and do our deliberation. Can we just real quickly take the temperature of the council, make sure everybody's okay with going the direction of general tax versus special tax? Sure. I know that was an assumption that was made. Is that consistent?
38:46 That's where my brain is. Thank you. Okay, so four-question review. Four questions. Number one, should cultivation businesses be taxed at a rate per square foot of canopy or by gross receipts? If it's the rate per square foot of canopy is preferred, what should that rate be? Second question. If a gross receipts tax is preferred for cultivation, does a maximum rate...
39:11 Of 10% for retail and 5% for cultivation, manufacturing and distribution cannabis businesses give the town enough flexibility to adapt the changes to the cannabis industry and address the town's needs over time. If not, what range would be more appropriate? Question three, does the council wish to have the ordinance that goes to the voters establish a starting tax rate or would that council prefer to establish that later? If the voters are going to be asked to approve one or more initial tax rates,
39:39 For the various businesses, what tax rate goes into effect? What should that tax rate be? Fourth question. Do you want to establish an annual maximum rate of increase for each respective tax? Okay. Thank you. I guess any thoughts on the public? Mona County, Jay, if you want to give an update or we can do that now. And there'll be an opportunity to speak to each one of the individual questions as we go through as well. Janet Dutcher, Finance Director.
40:19 So our board met starting at 1 o'clock this afternoon earlier today, and we did a presentation of what the proposed ordinance is, different provisions that are in there, and looked at the fiscal impact of the various permitted licenses we might have in the county. And from the county's perspective, we're expecting anywhere from 1 to 5.
40:45 Cultivators, anywhere from zero to two dispensaries or retail outlets. So you can see that the makeup of our commercial cannabis in the unincorporated area of the county is very different than what you might see here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're expecting a mix of outdoor cultivation as well as indoor, probably more outdoor than indoor, whereas here in the town you're looking at only indoor cultivation.
41:14 So we proposed or posed four tax policy questions for our board. And I'd just like to run through those questions and what the results were.
41:26 The first question was, should the cannabis tax be a general tax or a special tax? And it was unanimous with our board to have a general tax, although there was support to have an advisory board process to look at spending priorities, whether that's through the budget process or through some directive that advises this is how we'd like to spend the tax, knowing that we're recovering our costs related to the unregulated market.
41:55 The second question was who pays the tax? Is it countywide or the unincorporated? We explored some of the advantages and disadvantages of both, but all four board members agreed that it's important to have flexibility and local control, and so while the ballot may be a bit confusing and we'll look to some mechanisms to minimize that impact,
42:21 All members of the board agreed that it would be unincorporated only so our taxes would be separate, but we agreed that there needs to be collaboration and similarity between your taxing scheme. I hate calling it that. Sounds illegal. That's fine. Call it a taxing scheme. And our taxing structure so that we're not encouraging or discouraging operators to locate in one jurisdiction versus another.
42:50 The one thing about a countywide tax, it would require some kind of revenue sharing agreement so that the county's office...
43:01 Office of Auditor-Controller would collect the tax, and then it would have to be some method of then splitting it apart. And it was noted in our meeting that our impacts from the unregulated market, which is what we would spend this tax on, is not necessarily the same as what the town is, which was another reason to keep it separate. The third policy...
43:27 Question, which I was expecting most of our conversation to be on, is one of your policy questions that you have up on the board here, and that is, should cultivation be taxed on a square footage basis or a gross receipts basis?
43:45 Our canopy tax, the square footage, is based on the permitted square footage, and we noted that we have learned from others that have gone before us. Thank you. And our square footage is set very low so that we can encourage easy entry into this market. We want these operators to help us in the depressed.
44:06 Areas of our county where economic growth is stagnated or even declining, providing jobs and housing for our citizens. So we don't want the local tax to be a barrier to entry into the market. So we've set the canopy tax very low at 50 cents per acre for an outdoor grow.
44:28 We did a little education in understanding that we're using the tax framework to account for the type of facility that a cultivator might have and the different layers of how we can increase the tax based on
44:47 The number of harvests that they might get per year and so you'll see that the tax rate escalates as they're growing indoors whether with a combination of natural lighting and artificial lighting all the way up to complete artificial lighting which is currently set at $2 per square foot. From a county perspective one of the things that we talked about with the canopy tax is that it's a stable, reliable, predictable
45:13 And so just like our property tax revenue that we count on every year to fund ongoing salaries and benefits, the canopy tax would too be a staple that we can count on to be reoccurring and fund reoccurring expenses. Whereas a gross receipt tax, which is at the mercy of the wholesale rate in the market as well as a number of other factors, might be a bit volatile. It's more like TOT and sales tax, which makes it a lot
45:42 And so all of our board agreed.
45:52 That the canopy tax was the right approach. And surprisingly, we actually had operators, growers, cultivators in the audience who agreed with that. And the one comment that they had is the nursery piece of it, whether that should be on grocery seats, because they're looking to use a nursery to develop strains and branding and do research which might not necessarily draw grocery seats, and therefore your tax becomes regret.
46:21 Thank you.
46:27 The last tax policy that we had was based on the tax rate, and we started to have a discussion in that, wanting to align our tax rates with the town of Mammoth so that we don't create some kind of green belt where an operator chooses to locate in one jurisdiction or the other. Our tax rates currently, as they are proposed, are at a minimum level, which is in the neighborhood 27 to 28 percent.
46:57 Thank you.
47:06 30% mark. In fact, 29.98%, so it's two percentage points short of 30%. And at that point, we ran out of time because of other meetings, and so we will return to our board on Tuesday to complete our discussion on the tax rates, which was the last piece of our discussion to move forward. Excellent. Thank you very much. And the meeting on Tuesday, that won't be Mammoth probably, right? Okay, but you'll have the video will be set up and all that?
47:35 And you can remote in from the CAO conference room across the way. Good. Thank you very much. Chairman Gardner.
47:45 Bob Gardner, Chair of the Mona County Board of Supervisors. Very quickly, Janet did a great job summing up our discussion this afternoon. We did make progress on three of the four items, and we'll return next Tuesday. The one thing I just wanted to underscore was her emphasis and your comments this afternoon, Mayor Wentworth, to try to work together with the town and be as consistent as possible so that we don't have confusion and, frankly, for the consumer as well as the business, the industry, have as much consistency as possible.
48:14 We do have some differences there, so there may be some reasonable reasons to take a different approach just given the difference between the county and the town in that regard. But on the retail side, I would hope that we could perhaps meet in the middle on some of the issues on the rates so that we have as consistent an approach as possible and perhaps even model for other jurisdictions a better way to go. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Okay.
48:40 Good. So, Rob, question number one. Yeah, so just to kind of frame up question number one and how we address it in the staff report and maybe even some of the information that was provided to us by Mono County's team, our cultivation business is not, that's kind of their main area. Our main area is our retail side. So our cultivation businesses, we're recommending in the staff report that we go gross receipts because it's actual transactions that have occurred.
49:10 I agree with staff that for here and as a business person,
49:39 Gross receipts make sense. I don't want to pay a per square foot tax if I am running in the red every year. I can't do that as a business. So with the gross receipts, it is tied into my viability as a business, and that only makes sense to me. Okay. Colin? I feel pretty strongly, actually, that it should be gross receipts. You know, just doing some research and looking into specials.
50:04 On the issue, I mean, if you are taxed on a canopy basis, you know, some of the issues that growers have run into cultivation businesses, if you have a weather event or some sort of pesticide or something that gets in and ruins your entire crop, you still have to pay that same tax rate. So I'm with Bill, absolutely. I understand the comments that were made and kind of the consistency and predictability of that. But I think absolutely it should be on a gross receipts basis for the town.
50:34 Okay. Yeah, I do as well. Yeah. So thank you. So the direction there is gross receipts. Thank you. Question number two. So for question number two, this is probably the meat of the discussion, and this would be the not to exceed rate for two particular areas. One would be retail sales, and so let's focus on that at the moment. In our staff report and recommendation, we threw out a range not to exceed of 10%.
51:02 To address some of the discussion, and I know Monroe County did not arrive at a final number or have the time to today, but their not-to-exceed number was 6%, so the difference that we are right now is somewhere of a 4% range, and I think what was suggested is a meeting in the middle, something maybe to consider then would be a not-to-exceed of 8% that I think potentially they could arrive at as well.
51:29 And have a consistent on the retail side. That's where we do have, while we have probably more opportunity for retail, they do have opportunity for retail in their area. So the discussion right now, let's focus on retail sales not to exceed tax. Okay, so is everybody clear? And so there can be, the bottom could be nothing. I mean, the tax could be in place and we could agree that we want to, we don't want to.
51:56 We could start with zero, but the high end would be? And it's really to, because we have to go to the voters for this particular question, is what is going to be the maximum that we can tax? And so consideration needs to be given for whether or not that rate will be passable, if you will. And so that's something that's very important to consider. And so it's really just what is the maximum, yes. Okay, and the question's about
52:24 Whether it goes up automatically annually, that's a further... Yeah, that's later on, and I do think that's an important discussion to have in conjunction with the not-to-exceed rate because I think it's... We'll start with the NTE, the ceiling at the NTE. So, Shields, let's start over at this end. Okay. No, actually, I don't mind the 10%, and I don't think we should start there. It's a not-to-exceed, especially since we don't know what the cost of, you know, all this is going to be.
52:54 You know, if we're sitting there and this is, you know, costing our town 8% of grocery seats to run this thing, it doesn't make a lot of sense. We have to come back. I'm just saying it gives us opportunity to look at it and work with our retailers. I like that not to exceed, but when I say that,
53:18 I'll go down to number four. I think if we freeze whatever number we come up with for a certain period of time to allow us to find out and work through those costs, I think we'll have a better idea. So I think the flexibility is something, and higher is actually a better number because you don't want to come back and go, geez, we're losing money on this thing. You've got to go back to the voters again. You get a bite at the apple, you know, and we might not.
53:47 Get a second bite. So I don't have a problem with the 10%, quite honestly, because it's not to exceed. I think the truth of the matter is, is when we get down to, hey, what tax are we going to charge this time, that's where we're going to, you know, start with, so. Okay. Cleland, any thoughts? The maximum at 10% and 5% for cultivation, that works for me, along with Shields. And I, well, we'll talk about the
54:16 The minimum rate later, correct? Yeah, sure. Yeah, sure. So, Bill? My take's completely different. If we can't get this passed, wanting to collect 10% makes no difference. We're going to collect zero and sales are going to go on and we're going to have to regulate it anyway. If I was going to be an opponent to the tax, the first question I would ask the voters is, have you ever seen a government agency who could tax to 10% not get to that 10%?
54:47 In my life, I haven't seen it. So I'd be able to kill the ballot measure right off the bat. And by adding another 10% onto what appears to me to be 34% already being taxed, do we continue then to price it at a point where we drive it underground? I would rather have legal sales, if they cost even a little more than the black market, than the black market. We need to get rid of the people selling drugs in Mammoth because they sell far more than just...
55:15 I think the other way, excuse me, I think the other way is I think people that might not
55:45 Look at it and go, hey, you know, are we going to, you know, be able to handle this? I think they're going to look and say, hey, you know, if we're really having a problem, we can go to the 10 percent. But I don't think we're starting there. I don't think, you know, if we sell it properly that, you know, you have to say we're not starting at 10 percent. We're starting somewhere way below that. This is a not-to-exceed number. I still, if I was going to be in opposition to it, I think I could get my 52 percent to keep it from going.
56:14 So for me, a 5% on initial as an NTE and then a lower starting point makes it very easy for us to get it passed. Not easy. No tax in this time is going to be easy to pass.
56:31 But I believe it gives us a better opportunity to get it passed and at least collect something. A lot of people are looking at this as a cash cow. I'm looking at the volume in the report here, the amounts that they are estimating three different people are going to do, I think are way overblown. If we triple the best year ever done by the two businesses in town, if we triple that, each business still comes in way under performing there. So I think that...
56:59 Being able to keep them viable and everything else, being able to pass the tax measure so we can actually collect something. So what's a number, a high-end entity? 5% is what I would do. On the retail? On the retail, yeah. I would probably start at 1.5% or 2% and then increase it as we can. By having it at 10%, if we see the businesses are real successful, the amount of money we collect is going to go up regardless of what the percentage is.
57:27 Do we really feel like we then want to dip a little deeper into the business man's and de-incentivize him by being able to go to 10 percent? I just I'm very comfortable with the 5 percent knowing that it takes it up to almost 40 percent of the total cost as taxes. I wish the state would have given us a lot more wiggle room because frankly I'd love to see 10 percent. But I think the state has sort of taken a fire hose to us.
57:52 And prevented us from going there if we want to see this tax pass. See, that's the thing. I think we're going to have to go back to this date. I mean, as consumers and say, hey, you're taking way too much because we have to enforce it. Right. I think in the next 10 years, this whole thing is going to change so much that we're going to be swimming in this issue every year for the next who knows how many years. So I'm very comfortable at a 5% starting with one and a half or two.
58:20 And then building to that 5% as the businesses become more successful, not on a consumer price index or anything else. Are you saying 5% for retail and for cultivation? 5% for retail, I would do cultivation at 3%. Okay. Because remember that 3% is going to be taxed again. I understand. At the 5% level when we get there. So that becomes an issue for me. Okay. Thank you. Colin.
58:45 You know, I think this discussion a little bit for me is the blind leading the blind. I'm not sure. I think we're all kind of in the dark a little bit on this. I don't have a strong inclination. You know, off the cuff, 5% and 10% as a staff recommendation seem relatively reasonable to me. I'm hearing Bill is...
59:06 Comfortable at a much lower level. To me, the overarching concern for me is what was already articulated by the Board of Supervisors. I think the most important thing for us moving forward, whether it lands at...
59:17 You know, a maximum tax rate of 10, 8, 6%, whatever we come up with, I'm relatively comfortable with. For me, consistency across the county and the town is the most important piece. So if I'm hearing from the county that a 10% level is kind of out of the comfort zone for the county, I'd be more inclined to come down to a level that they're comfortable matching, you know, and if that's 8%.
59:43 You know, maybe that works and maybe that kind of sits in the middle of where Bill's coming from and where Shields and Cleland are at. I could easily go six. I'd have a hard time going eight because I don't think we can pass it. And again, that's just my take on what I'm hearing out there. I just, you know, for me, that's my largest overarching concern is just keeping consistency throughout the county because I think that's a very real thing that if we're at a higher tax rate than the unincorporated, people will just move.
1:00:11 You know, you'll have these clustering of businesses elsewhere. Okay. All right. So I'm very grateful for your comments. That's kind of why I was thinking the same thing. I think that if we kind of split the difference here, I would propose eight on the high end of the retail, but I think, Bill, you've got a good point of the cultivation, bringing that down maybe like to three, because that's going to be a very specific kind of local thing. Eight and three or eight and four?
1:00:39 Eight and four. I could do eight and four. Even numbers. None of it's a hill for me to die on. I'd just like to get some feedback from the county. Sure. The passage of 64 in the county, what was that? What percentage? Does anyone know? It was pretty high, I think. I think it was 65%. All right. Well, I don't think that, you know, that'd be an issue. I think the 50 plus one is going to be, I mean, you got, you got. Remember, people are going to be telling them that they don't have to pass any tax.
1:01:12 And it's still going to be legal to buy and use. So I'm still looking at it from a standpoint of what can we get by the people so that we can collect at least something to offset our expenses. Otherwise, for the first two years, we're collecting squat and still have to have the businesses. So I think just if we can do this, I think we're at eight and four. Does that sort of a consensus number that work for everybody or we can vote on if we like?
1:01:41 Again, for me, it's not to exceed. So, you know, if it meets with the county and we can work together with the county, I'm not tied to 10 and 5, but 8 and 4, I wouldn't go any lower. Yeah, I got you. Can I ask for just a little representation from the county on, I know it was kind of tough, it was like, well, we didn't really get to it, but. Is there an elected out there or a CAO? What are they going to say?
1:02:17 Good evening, Council. Leslie Chapman, CAO. So yes, we did not get to a vote on that, but there was quite a bit of discussion about aligning with the town. And so if you guys give a little and we take a little, I think that would be 8%. I would be happy to make that as a staff recommendation for the board on Tuesday. Our range was from 4% to 6%.
1:02:46 So if we bump the range from four to eight, I think that we could sell that to our board in the interest of aligning ourselves with your council. And lastly, again, that's not to exceed, you guys are voting on not to exceed. Not to exceed eight. So our measure actually has a low end and a high end. Got it. And then the other point of clarification I wanted to make, just...
1:03:10 In case it comes up at another time is that we have provisions in our canopy tax for disasters or failed crops or, you know, having an acre of growing space but only growing a half an acre, those sorts of things. So giving them relief. What's that? Giving them relief. Yes, that's correct. And then we have a general provision that basically gives our board the authority to give relief for unexpected items too.
1:03:40 And the last thing I wanted to add, one thing that I really like about what's been incorporated into our ordinance at this time is, yes, we have a maximum rate, but that maximum rate is indexed based on the CPI for the Western District after three years. So you can set your maximum lower, but then anticipate that you're going to have a higher maximum later on.
1:04:08 Moves with the economy. It can never go down, just like taxes, but it does go up as a CPI. You know, if it goes up 2%, then your rate's going to go up 2%. Okay, is that something we'd like to maybe add to our, just add a CPI, an indexing piece of the time? I am far more comfortable in setting up some way to meet with the businesses and judge their success and gauge our taxes on that. Yeah, and I agree with Bill. I mean, over time.
1:04:38 Again, we don't know what the costs are going to be with this whole thing. I wouldn't mind putting a CPI in there if that's what it takes, but I think we're going to have to work with the businesses. We want them to be successful. Absolutely. We're just talking about the NTE, and I think if we put that CPI thing in there so that that's consistent with what the county's doing. One of my problems with the CPI is...
1:05:06 Sort of like tipping. Every time a price goes up, the amount we collect goes up. So our price index increases with the increase in the retail sales cost. So how you tie your percentage of tax, you can tie it to need, I understand that. You can tie it to success of the business, I understand that. But tying a tax to the CPI to me somehow makes no sense. We're getting an increase in tax every time the CPI goes up.
1:05:33 It already builds that in for you. But our costs on our end, I mean, we have costs on our end that are going up at the same rate. I mean, it's just trying to keep everything tracking together. Well, that should be covered by the cost of the retail rate. So, Bill, I'd like to clarify something. Janet's recommendation for that CPI increase was only for the not-to-exceed rate to increase. It didn't talk about the annual rate.
1:05:58 Actually being charged of the businesses, that would be a council decision and a later on discussion. It's really to allow growth in that not to exceed number in the future. Okay. So I think what I'm hearing here again is 8-4 with the CPI attached to the high end, and that would be the consensus from this board here for reconciliation with the county in case things need to be discussed further there.
1:06:29 Can I have to, sorry, I just didn't catch it if you did, but if we're calling, if we're cleaning the way in on that, just trying to get a full consensus from the council or not, from that high end with the CPI issue with the eight plus CPI. Set that as a motion. I don't know if we need a normal vote. We're just looking for directions. I'm just trying to get a feel. You'll come back ultimately. I'm just trying to get a feel whether or not it was. I don't think we need a motion. No, no. I'm just trying to get the consensus of the people I didn't hear. Eight and four. Eight and four now. Are you okay, though, with the CPI increasing to the top of the eight?
1:06:58 And the four, I guess. And do you want to establish a time at which point that CPI engages? The county's recommendation is after three years, that maximum not to exceed number would start to fluctuate with CPI. Comfortable with that. Comfortable with that, consistent with the county, I think is kind of the goal on that. Yeah. I'd say two, but okay. Thank you. Are you good? Yeah, the CPI tied to both the four and the eight? Yes. Yes. Thank you. Okay, good. So next question.
1:07:32 Oh, you already moved it. Okay. I'm not used to having someone move the slides for me here. So does wanting to start the established the opening rate discussion. So that's item number three. Does the council wish to have the ordinance that goes into effect establish a starting rate for each? And again, having one within the retail side and then one within the cultivation and distribution. So opening rates. Okay.
1:08:01 My thought on this is that I would like to not go out with a starting rate so that the council, if we wanted to set it at zero, we could set it at zero. I think we've got to find out more information before we set it. Yeah. And so the question that goes to the voters is we're not locking in something out of the box, out of the gate. As a starting rate. As a starting rate.
1:08:25 So, again, and John, you've run two very successful campaigns to get the voters to vote on things. And having a little more specificity, I believe, helped your cause. So in this case, while I'm not all that comfortable setting a starting rate, it seems to me whoever's going to, someone is going to have to be the proponent.
1:08:46 Well, I think I think, you know, saying that we're going to start at one and a half percent and then build based on success and CPI and everything else to eight percent makes it
1:09:16 Potentially more palatable. Well, I'm thinking also what I've heard from our local businesses and from a lot of folks is a desire and interest to establish successful businesses here in town. And I think what we've heard from the businesses is the challenges that they've got from a supply chain perspective, from trying to do something that I think is important for our visitation community with a lot of very complex logistical things to deal with out of the box. And I think that
1:09:41 I think having the ability to start it off basically at zero. Whoever the proponent is, this will be a campaign issue, obviously. I think it would reinforce the idea that the council is saying the first step is to get our businesses stood up, operating, and successful without any impediment coming from us. And then give it some time. Let's get these things up on their feet. And then the tax is there. If things are working, then we can start.
1:10:10 The Council, at its discretion, can start taxing it as it starts working. That would be, I just think, I think. So you're suggesting a 0% starting rate? Yes. For a period of time? Until the Council determines that the businesses are functioning and operating and it's appropriate to start taxing.
1:10:29 So, John, if I can interject something on the starting rate. So, two things to consider. In David's presentation, he discussed what sort of a palatable rate is and a standard rate that's been throughout California, and that's what the 4% recommendation had come in. So, that's one element. The other one is, obviously, if we're not collecting any tax, that, you know, some of this is recovery for the impended cost of actually having more activity in town, if you will.
1:10:57 The third point would be on our fourth bullet point there we try to give a little bit of caution and sort of comfort to voters in that we could establish a rate of increase on an annual basis saying not to exceed even on an annual rate. So if we have a starting point you can also say that that starting point will be
1:11:18 Froze for the couple of years for that developmental stage that you're discussing. But then also beyond that, it wouldn't exceed maybe a half percent or one percent on an annual basis at council direction so that people will understand it's not going to jump from maybe two percent or three percent to ten percent next year. It's going to have to go up in a very controlled manner. Okay. Well, I'll defer to council. That's my sort of... I think we have to start at...
1:11:45 Starting rate. Okay. Well, what's a number you like? Personally, the one I keep coming back to as a low is one and a half. I'm comfortable at one and a half. I'd be comfortable at two. And I would use that for both. I could go with one and a half. Yeah. I was thinking one. Can you do one? Well, it's certainly easier to calculate. So, guys, you know, I think we're missing a little bit of the boat here, quite honestly. There's costs involved here.
1:12:15 And if we're taken out of the general fund to make this happen, you know, there's going to be some problems with our constituents going, wait a minute, you're just funding this. So we have to work with the people that are going to be in business. We have to work with our enforcement groups, our administrative groups, our fees, and figure out what that is. And so I'm all right with establishing it later, but understand, you know,
1:12:45 It's not going to be zero and I don't think it's going to be one. Sure. Okay. So I think what we have to do is, you know, if we want to establish it later, you know, get that information so we can make a more informed decision. Or if we want to start right now, I'd much rather err a little bit on the higher side saying, okay, if the max is eight, let's start at four. And we can always go down. No, we can't go down.
1:13:14 If the voters approve it at 4, we can't go down. Unless you have language in there saying that. Right. We can always put language in there. Right now, the idea of the freeze, if you will, for however many years we're going to look at, two or three years, is not to go up. We could put language in there saying, look, hey, if we're finding out that this is not working for...
1:13:40 Our business is here. Yeah, let's drop it. I think we can put language in there. So I think it's very important that we get this right as best we can with the information going forward. Yeah, I think I agree. I don't have, none of us have the information there to know. That's right. So I think what we need to try to do is to set the sideboards on either end, knowing that that's not what it's going to be.
1:14:07 But it gives us, you know, it gives us something that we can take to the voters. It's going to make sense that understanding that the voters will vote on that. And then as we work with businesses, we get a better understanding of what's going on. Then we can set things appropriately. So I'm open to whatever a number is that we'd set the bottom at. That's going to be something that's not going to set the top. You can always go down. OK, I don't understand this question about being able to go down. Could staff explain how that works?
1:14:33 I would call it more of a starting rate than a bottom. So you're kind of letting the voters know what your intention is of where you want to start that rate when it goes into effect. But the ordinance would be written in such a way that you could opt to lower that rate in the future if it's determined that it's not beneficial to the businesses. So do we have to give you a recommendation of not what our proposed starting rate is, but what the floor rate is?
1:15:01 Minimal rate is. I think we're more interested in a starting rate at this point unless the council is interested in setting a floor. Because I don't have any information. We don't have information to be able to set that out-of-the-box rate. That's just not in front of us. But in talking to people in the industry and talking to people around town and other areas where it is legal, I would be comfortable, as I said, at one and a half.
1:15:27 I could go as high as 2. I would not be, I would be very uncomfortable going as high as 4 to start. Yeah, I'm not comfortable with 4. I'm comfortable with the 2, understanding that from the perspective of the ordinance, that's where it's never going to go, it's not going to be below that. Well, no, no, no, well. You could draft it where you could. It could go down to 0.
1:15:48 So what is the language of the voter going to say? Because that starts getting confusing. To Bill's point about tax measures, you have to be very, very clear. I will also want to add that we as a council cannot, we are limited in terms of what we can do in terms of advocating for this. And there is no group out there that I imagine is going to be running to support this. So we have to be very, it's got to be, what's going to be on the ballot language is going to be as much as we can probably do to advocate for this. What I'm hearing Dave say is that, you know,
1:16:17 It's between 4% and 6% is where we can play. Is that right? To be around the 30% range? So, if I may, since you direct that. So, the initial rate is kind of, I think, to address the Councilmember's concern about someone going in the opposite. There isn't a reasonable rate, as you indicated, for certain. We've been talking mostly about dispensary in that 40%.
1:16:44 Four to six percent is a tolerance level to give you flexibility. But you really have five categories that have different pain points. And so, for example, if you're going to try to encourage a testing lab, and if you don't have a testing lab, you can't get any product to market. So, you know, you don't want someone, you're trying to encourage someone to get here. We've used a range from an initial rate to one percent not to exceed two and a half percent because you got to.
1:17:09 You've got to drag someone up this hill to hope that they'll come here. So you want to make it, and they don't have the same, they're not a plant touching business, you're trying to encourage them and distributors. You heard the retailer indicate that you can't get anyone to come up the hill. So having a rate that's smaller for them, even though you have a higher range, having an initial rate of 1% for testing labs, 2% for distributors to get them up here so they'll help you out.
1:17:38 Is it a good something that they know a known, and that's not, that's a tolerant level no one's going to argue with. When it comes to cultivation, same element of there, you know, we kind of, Rob, we can go back to the accumulative chart because it kind of gives an example of what are acceptable initial rates or conversations with that if you look at here, not so much for the cultivator here, but, you know, if you did 2% for a cultivator as an initial rate,
1:18:04 That's a minimum base for an indoor that's going to be comfortable and no one's going to really scream and holler about that. Same with the manufacturer. If you start at a 2% initial rate or 2.5%, you're going to be okay. When you talk about a retailer, back to your concern, you know, 2.5% they would love to see, but I think no more than 4%, you're not going to get people screaming. It's when you move.
1:18:29 Farther beyond that. So they at least have a known initial rate, because if you're trying to encourage others to start, they know what that is, and then they also know their worst scenario, and they also know that they may have one to three years, depending on how you set that, to kind of stabilize in there as a known entity for doing performer plans and business plans and figuring out their costs associated. Okay, thank you. So I think if, let's just say that we did it, say, 2.5%.
1:18:55 Again, the question I have for staff is I don't understand how we put something out to the public that says it's minimum of 2.5%, but yet the council still has the discretion to lower it. I'm wondering if you could speak to that. Well, because it's not a minimum. Two things are being introduced here. We're either talking about establishing a base rate, starting rate. An initial rate. Or we're talking about establishing a floor. I mean, we need to...
1:19:23 We need to look at which one we're being asked to do here. Exactly. So if you could, staff could talk to this, that'd be helpful. Well, okay. We need to think about what you want to submit to the voters because that's going to dictate what you can and cannot do. You could ask the voters to approve something like a tax that shall not be, I mean, it shall be no less than 4%, no greater than 8%. Then you can be anywhere within that. You can ask the voters to approve a tax that's an initial tax of 2 that the council can raise to 10.
1:19:51 You can do kind of whatever you want, but just bear in mind that the question that you ask the voters to approve is going to dictate your policy choices later. So again, so if we say the minimum is two and a half percent, whether it's four or whatever, that question goes to the voters. We cannot go below that. Is that correct? If that's how it's worded, yes. Okay, so that's... But if we call it a starting rate, then we would have the flexibility to go lower.
1:20:15 Whatever, we could say the floor is zero. Hang on, hang on, let's hear from the lawyer. If you want to have a range, you need to ask the voters to approve a range. Right. I don't want a range. I want to be able to tell the voters we're going to start at 2% and we're going to hold that for two years or whatever that is. Not even hold it. I don't even want that. I want the flexibility. The only reason I see in putting the minimum in there is so we're telling the people to start with.
1:20:45 We're not going to start with a maximum. So that we can't go down if it isn't prudent to go down. You have to have a maximum. And if you want to have a minimum, then you've created a range. We have three things here. We've talked about a not to exceed. We talked about eight and four. Then we have a starting rate. Starting rate, we're still in discussion on that. Whatever that starting rate is, if we want to put language in there that says, look,
1:21:13 That starting rate, if it's not working for the first two years of our freeze, everybody's worried about it going up, okay? We can say, gee, it's not working. We can actually back down to whatever the floor is going to be, and my suggestion is that floor be zero. Okay, and I'm okay with that, and I would say that the range, we set the range, that's the question in front of us, establishing the range, and I'm good with zero to eight, and then we can then go to the next question, which is the starting rate.
1:21:42 Which we can say that could be that could be to the voters. Our starting rate is going to be X. Right. That becomes our political commitment, not something we're actually legally bound with. If you're talking about a range of zero to eight, then the question for the voters would be, shall the town impose a tax of not greater than eight percent? Yeah. And then if you want to say and for the first year or two, it'll be two percent. You could say that. OK. And we could. So if we could stay within that.
1:22:11 That freeze period, the tax will not go up, but it could. You can ask the voters to approve that, yes. Yes. So let's start with this range question, and then let's come to what's going to be the... I'm more comfortable with the range not having zero, starting with one to ten, because if I saw something that said zero...
1:22:34 And it was on a ballot. I would just go, like, fun, that's going to stay at zero. And that would worry me more than having a base. That's just me. So then how about the range is one to eight? So I'm comfortable with that. Okay. Okay. So let's establish our range is one to eight. Okay. Is that staff good with that? We're good with this?
1:22:57 I suppose. I mean, do we really have the information in front of us right now to be making this call? Well, the range, again, it's the range question. The starting rate, the starting rate question is the next question, and that's a legitimate question. Because I don't believe... I don't think we have the information. I don't believe we have the information for a starting rate, and I don't think we need to, we do not need to advise the voters what the starting rate is going to be. Correct? We could just say the range will be this, and that will be the council's discretion. You can if you want to, but you don't have to.
1:23:26 Oh. Right. Okay. So we could just go to the voters with a question and say, shall we impose a tax from 1% to 8%? But we don't have to advise the public what the starting rate's going to be because, frankly, we don't have the information to know what that's going to be. That is actually a better thing because it's simpler to the voters. It's clear that's what it's going to be. And then the question would be, well, what's the starting rate going to be? And then we do the research and we determine what it's going to be and then we set it. Yeah.
1:23:56 A basement of zero. Okay. So, you know, I'm relatively comfortable, I suppose, with establishing a one to eight range. And then as far as, you know, when I was taking notes on this, I had just a huge question mark over number three, because I'm not sure that we really have the amount of information we need. But for the fourth one to jump ahead.
1:24:19 I would think that it makes sense to establish an annual maximum rate increase of 1%. Okay, so let's do this. Let's get through what we can do here, which is we've established the range, which is the question, the language would be in the ballot. There's a second part to this question. So, John, if I may, one of the things that we as staff had gone through this much deliberation is similar to what you did in the preparation of what we would present to you.
1:24:49 With a 0 to 8%, and I think Andy said... It's 1 to 8. Okay. With the staff looking for a not-to-exceed rate, without providing a starting point, and then in conjunction with an annual maximum, I think that you leave it open for people to provide, it could end up at the highest end they want. Okay, good. So wait, but the question we've, you've got direction from here, 1 to 8.
1:25:19 Okay. Now, it's 6 o'clock, and do we want to move on and just finish this workshop up, provide direction, or do we want to postpone this to a later date? I don't know if we can postpone it to a later date. Yeah, let's just keep rolling. Okay, so where we're at is 1 to 8 is the range, and now we'll move on to the next question. So what's the next question for us? Real quick on that, I'm assuming the, I think we'd write it this way, that for the retail it's 1 to 8, for the manufacturing on the side would be a 1 to 4. Right.
1:25:48 Okay. Correct. It's a clarification. Okay. So what's the next? Just to clarify, the way that gets worded on the ballot will be, shall there be a tax of not exceeding 8%, shall there be a tax of not exceeding 4%, and then language in there allowing the council to reduce the tax at any point to a level not below 1%. Correct. That's great. That's how that goes. That's it. That's that. Okay. Yes, sir. Mayor, may I, the language in the draft and amendment that we provided
1:26:13 The question is really what you're doing in the maximum. It's an analysis, I think, that will reflect your concerns about they assuming that you can go on the higher. There's a section in there, an amendment or appeal section of the draft that we have prior to says,
1:26:28 That you will have the authority to make that decision to drop it or raise it at any time or exempt anything as long as you don't go any higher than what the voters give you permission to. Correct. So the language of 75 words, you want to make it very simple. The detail is in the ordinance, but the analysis of the attorney that we put together to summarize it will clarify your concerns of anyone that's reading that or tries to use it against you of those different rates.
1:26:57 And that will address your concerns of ability and flexibility. Good. Okay. Thank you very much. So now the next question, and Rob, let me see if I get this right, is does the council wish to establish a initial starting rate? Does anybody have any thoughts on that? Based on the way Andy just said it, I don't think we need to establish. And I would agree with that. I still, and it goes back to my...
1:27:27 10% being too much in order to get the thing passed because if it doesn't pass, we're collecting nothing. So I am more than happy to go with the will of the council if everyone thinks we don't want to establish that and we can get it passed at that. I just have my reservations about whether we can or not as our lovely finance, well not lovely, our very masculine finance director over there was alluding to earlier.
1:27:53 That it's easier to get it passed if we establish that rate that we're going to start at. You know, and I'm sensitive to those comments, absolutely. I mean, that's been in my head, you know, thinking about this is, you know, if you're going to a ballot measure and just saying, well, it's not going to be above eight, but we don't know what it's going to be.
1:28:09 You know, people's minds are going to run. That being said, I don't feel like I have the information in front of me today to make an informed decision on what a starting rate would be, which is why I'm more comfortable with establishing a range, saying it's not to exceed X and it's not going to go below Y and it's not going to increase by more than 1% annually. I think that gives the business...
1:28:32 Stability, the ability to plan for things moving forward. You're not going to hit them with a 7% increase on a YOY basis, which gives the business some stability. But to a large degree, this is the new California gold rush. Everybody's piling in.
1:28:49 The free market will self-regulate. If there's an oversaturation of product, if there's an oversaturation of businesses, they will go under, and the more successful businesses will continue to proceed moving forward. So I think in the long run, this is going to be a healthy and sustainable business. I mean, in our packets and our information, we've been given the three dispensaries in Steamboat, which is a very similar town to this, made $10 million last year.
1:29:18 I'm not really willing to hear this argument that this is not going to be a viable industry moving forward. I think it will be. There's going to be some flux and a self-regulation period, and then moving forward, it's going to be sustainable, I believe. So what I'm hearing from up here is there's no desire to establish, to make a representation as part of the ballot measure of a rate coming out of the box. You know, unless somebody feels strongly about that, I don't think that I can. Okay. All right, good. So that's...
1:29:47 So I understand that just as we work through the ordinance and look to this at some point, you know, election or whatever, you're not going to have the information you're probably looking for to set a minimum rate. So at some point. We'll have more information. Well, not a lot because we're not going to have no idea where our costs are. I mean, that's the same as making a political commitment. As it goes to the ballot, you know, it's no different than making a political commitment to say with the information in front of us, as this hits the ballot, this is the range or this is the rate we're thinking about starting at.
1:30:17 I don't think it makes sense for us to dictate that to the Ballard Initiative. At some point, otherwise, whatever the default would be, that would be a different question. Yeah, I think when we have to shield this point about engaging with the businesses and engaging with a sense of what the costs look like, then there will be an agenda item with information that says, okay, look, this is what this thing is looking like, and then we can set it.
1:30:39 So I'm sorry, Liz, you had a thought on this? Thank you. I just wanted to state one more time, since my marching orders from my board are to try to align with the town, the reason that the Mono County chose 4 to 6 percent was because of the market research shows that 30 percent is what the market will bear, which you mentioned earlier. And so the reason we chose those two, that range, was because at 4 percent,
1:31:05 It's about 26% total tax. When you go to 6%, that's 29.9%. So that was why we chose that range. We don't think for one minute that when we collect the tax, whatever that tax is going to be, that it's going to cover all of our ancillary costs of, you know, additional behavior health services, law enforcement, all the things that you can't get through the permitting and the regulation fees.
1:31:33 And so I just wanted to mention that one more time before you make your final decision. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay, so let's move on now to, I guess, the final question, which is the escalation not to exceed on an annual basis. Is that the final question? It is, but I think posed in this particular environment where the discussion has gone, that it may be confused with
1:32:00 Not to exceed that could increase by that amount on an annual basis. That question was posed with a thought that there would be an established starting point and then that would be the point that would grow from and that's kind of where so I'm just I'm cautioning you that that's a little bit confusing that question as it's posed now with no determined starting point. Rob, I'm
1:32:23 I guess I'm going to respectfully disagree on that because at a particular point we are going to have to establish the starting rate, at which point this question becomes relevant, that you can establish a kicker beyond that, that whatever that established first rate is, 3%, 4%, 2%, that it cannot increase by more than 1% on a YOY basis. So that's the way I read that. And we know now that the starting rate is going to be at least 1%.
1:32:52 At least one, not more than eight, whatever it lands on, it then can't increase on a Y-over-Y basis by more than one percent. Right, and I think having the amount of increase it can have helps the proponent again go out to the public and say they wouldn't even have put this in if they were going to start at eight percent. Right. So at least it gives them that. It's the only thing that makes me a little more comfortable about not.
1:33:18 Establishing the start rate at that one and a half. So, Con, are you suggesting not more than 1% year over year? I mean, I'm comfortable with that. I want to get everyone else's perspective. I'm good to that. You good with that, Cleland? Yeah, I'm just a little bit confused about the three-year freeze. I mean, is that an easy enough thing to say after three? I mean, then you would really need a lot more information.
1:33:46 No, I go along with Colin. Yeah, no, I like where Colin's coming from, but just where does that come in then? It doesn't. It doesn't? Yeah, so it doesn't look like you would have a freeze in the first couple of years. The freeze would be the CPI increase, but not two. Okay. But I think when the council comes back and establishes that initial rate, that will be part of those discussions to figure out. Yeah, or you can leave it there. You don't have to increase it anything in a year. It's a maximum. Exactly, right.
1:34:15 It gives you the ultimate flexibility. Right. And do you look perplexed? He has to write it. I'm just thinking about how to write it. That's all. Okay. If I could just add something, too, regarding a maximum annual increase, there's two ways that that could be crafted in the ordinance. One would be that the rate shall increase by a certain percentage.
1:34:36 Every year automatically and the other option would be that the council will evaluate the tax on an annual basis and may choose to increase it up to a certain amount each year.
1:34:52 One more clarification that a few of you have spoken about and we didn't directly ask it in our questions, but is this idea of a freeze for a certain number of years after the tax is established, is that something that you're interested in including in the ordinance or just include a maximum annual increase and that will address any of those concerns? Maximum annual increase. Okay, so have we, does staff have sufficient direction to proceed?
1:35:23 Yes, we do. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Any final comments from the public before we go? Good evening. Stacey Courtless, Mono County Board of Supervisors. I appreciate the consideration of working together. I just want to advise, based on the end of your discussion, it does sound like we're going in pretty different directions. Even though the board hasn't made its final decisions based on our discussion today, I couldn't imagine that the board would be comfortable with anything.
1:35:51 Less than 4% for retail manufacturing, at least for those two. So I think this is going to end up being very confusing to the voters. There will be two different ballot measures on the same ballot that the citizens of Mammoth Lakes will be voting on. So it's sort of the fate of Mono County cannabis businesses could be in the hands of Mammoth Lakes voters. So again, I just urge us to try to work together, if our staffs could work together,
1:36:21 Some common language. I will, and our staff will definitely take this all into consideration during our discussion on Tuesday, but based on our discussion today, it looks like we're going in different directions. So I hope we can resolve it and get this much-needed resource passed for our jurisdictions. Stacey, just to clarify what we've got you. So the representation to us is that you guys were looking at a maximum rate between 4% and 6%. Are you now representing that you were looking at a...
1:36:49 A floor of 4%. Our staff recommended to set a minimum rate. So I think that's one place where it'll be different. And if I heard what you were saying, you're looking at starting even below 4% initially. We didn't say that. We haven't said that. Potentially. Yeah. So just, I just, you know, again, just urging that we, and based on our board's discussion, I wouldn't imagine that that's something that would go, you know, we want to.
1:37:15 Set clear rates so that our businesses know what they're getting into. We're in a little bit of a different situation. We have new businesses starting. We don't have established retailers or cultivators. And I think that we all appreciate that the political will is there and that both the board and the council wanted to figure this out the best we can. And again, these are recommendations to staff this evening. The final item does not come back to us until March.
1:37:45 I'm sorry. February 21. February 21. So there's a little time to kind of digest this and kind of figure out where we're at. And I think if there's reasonable suggestions that can come from both parties back to both agencies, I think they'll certainly be considered. Thanks. Much appreciated. Okay, sure, of course. Okay, anything else?
1:38:06 Just a couple quick final comments. Working for both sides, which you stated earlier, I appreciate that. I appreciate Council's efforts and staff's efforts to help our businesses be successful. I do support a tax, so please understand that I do have my support on this. Moving forward, I will do whatever I can. Starting out lower, as we have more information and we educate ourselves.
1:38:31 This will certainly become, more light will be shed on this industry as it will change from year to year. So as far as Councilman Richardson's comments on enforcement, we have provided, there haven't really been many problems, but as far as, Paul Rudder made a comment one time that he has more problems with tenants selling napkins than he does with us selling cannabis. So education, Councilman Fernies,
1:39:00 Comment on blindly and the blind. Yes, I'm willing to provide as much information as I can to help educate. And then regarding a cap, you know, is there, that hasn't really been discussed as far as a cap on gross sales. As we get further, if the business is very successful, would there be a sliding scale where taxes would be less as sales go up? Something to consider.
1:39:28 Thank you very much. Thank you very much. Thanks. Are you willing to be the proponent? You're for it. I'm willing to work together to help the town, and I have always made that very clear. So, yes, call on me and let's sit down and, you know, I mean, I play a role here. I'm a piece of the puzzle. And together, let's complete this puzzle. Thank you. Thank you very much. I think, so I think we're wrapped up with this. I think that there are a couple outstanding issues.
1:39:58 Again, the desire of both the board and the town to work together, if there's things we can reconcile, things that we certainly haven't anticipated to get that stuff cleaned up. I think there was also discussion at the county level about the nature of the ballot language. I think in their discussion about understanding it made more sense to do two separate taxes, I think we agree with that. I think there's a logic for that. But I think as we start crafting ballot languages and things like that to make sure that this is as...
1:40:26 Clear and direct to the voters as possible, I think is in everybody's interest. So with that, I think we will adjourn this workshop. We'll take maybe a couple minutes break just to reset. Five minutes. Sorry we ran over folks. This is a complex issue, but we're trying to do the people's business. And we'll see you back here in five minutes. Thank you very much. Okay, good evening. Thank you all for your patience. And thanks, council and staff and the audience for a very interesting, good discussion.
1:42:01 We're going now to move on to our regular agenda for the regular meeting. And Jamie, let's call the roll again, shall we? Make sure we're all here. Here. Here. Here. We are all here. That's good. I've asked Grady Dutton to lead us in the pledge this evening. To the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation.
1:42:36 Under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Grady. At this time, this is the time for public comment for items that are not on this evening's agenda. If anybody's got a comment they'd like to share, please come forward. Good evening. I'm Jennifer Halfordy, and I have submitted my signatures for nomination to run for District 1 Board of Supervisors in Mono County.
1:43:11 I want Mono County to be a place that everybody can live, that fosters strong communities, good decision making for all people. I have worked for the past 20 years to make Mono County a better place from raising two bright and strong daughters, working in literacy and affordable housing. My focus has been and continues to be how to help ensure everyone can live their best life here, surrounded by the beauty of Mono County.
1:43:42 As District 1 Supervisor, I will bring honesty, compassion, collaboration as I work to tackle the changing environment and needs. With your support, I look forward to hearing from you and working with you. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks for stepping up, Jennifer. Anybody else? Matt. Good evening. Matt McLean, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I just wanted to give the board an update.
1:44:13 I attended last week, or two weeks ago, excuse me, outdoor retailer SIA show in Colorado. Outdoor retailer recently moving out there. This was the first show that they held in Colorado. Used to be held for a number of years in Salt Lake City, but in response to policies on two national monuments out there, the outdoor industry decided to move the show, so that was a pretty big deal.
1:44:41 It attracted the show, attracted over 1,000 brands and 29,000 attendees. Some speakers, some illustrious speakers at the event, Governor John Hickenlooper from Colorado, author and activist Paul Hawken, and then from the town of Mammoth Lakes, I was excited to see Mayor John Wentworth, Councilmember Colin Fernie, MLT and MLR Board Member Scott McGuire, and MLR Board Member David Page, all were out there.
1:45:10 All of them actually participated in at least one meeting with myself and some of our partners, so that was great. Some of the organizations that I met with out there, Pacific Crest Trail Association, Outdoor Industry Association, Conservation Alliance, Snow Sports Industries of America, Latino Outdoors, the Wilderness Society, and then also sat in with a new work group, Corp.
1:45:34 Which is working to establish an Office of Outdoor Recreation here in California. So it's just a working group right now, but it was a great meeting that we're hoping to participate more in. Some companies that I met with that are specifically interested in working with the Town of Mammoth Lakes and MLR, Cliff Bar, REI, GSI, Keen Footwear, Danner Boots, Merrill Footwear.
1:45:59 Joan Snowboards, Osprey, and then we also had a meeting with A&E TV who may be interested in some projects that we're working on. There was also some interesting sessions. In the past, a lot of the sessions were geared more towards like retailers and manufacturers talking a lot about merchandising, production cycles, things like that. More and more, I haven't attended this show in about three years. Last time I was there, I was with Powell.
1:46:26 This year, I was excited to see that there was a number of presentations and seminars, including both of the keynotes were specifically on issues such as climate change and public land use. So I'll just give you a rundown of the ones that I attended. Filling the void, taking on global warming when our country isn't, participation and why it's everyone's responsibility, project drawdown, hope for climate solutions.
1:46:51 Weekend Warriors and Wannabes, the changing face and need of today's outdoor consumer. Conservation in the West. And monumental decisions, what's next for our public lands. So, again, I haven't been there in a while, but one of the things that I was excited to see that there was a lot of nonprofits beyond just the kind of ski and winter nonprofits. There was a lot of land managers, land trust, public.
1:47:16 You know, resource managers in attendance. Most of them were from Colorado, understandably, a few from Utah. Unfortunately, I didn't see anybody else from California. Our hope is that we do get a larger presence from some of the NGOs here in California, some of the land managers here in California. And I would encourage any of our counterparts from town staff, whether it be Rec or Joel or anybody else, if they're thinking about going to the show, it was definitely well worth our while. So we appreciate the support from the town that we got as well.
1:47:46 Thank you very much, Matt. Thanks, Matt. Anybody else? Hi, good evening. Hi, my name is Jimmy Donnell, a long-time resident here in Mammoth Lakes. I'm here to just say I think the town's doing a wonderful job with the new mountain bike trail system and the new coordinator that you guys are proposing for the Inyo County, excuse me, with the town and the county.
1:48:19 And the National Forest, I believe it's been a long time overdue for extra outdoor activity besides skiing and off-road motor use. Your trail coordinator, Joel, I believe has done a great job just in the last few years that he's been here. So I just wanted to say
1:48:48 I think that you're all headed in the right direction as a cyclist and I think there's a lot to in the next few years we could have world-class mountain biking and road riding here with all of your help and the way that you're all headed. It seems like you're all headed in a really positive direction.
1:49:15 And as a citizen here in Mammoth Lakes, I'd just like to say thank you. Good. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Anybody else? Okay. With that then, we'll move on to additions to the agenda. Dan, I believe you have an item? Yes. Two items here in terms of modifying the agenda. One is...
1:49:40 I would like to request that we pull item 12 off the agenda this evening. It's the transition plan to establish the foundational structure describing the housing action plan of Live, Work, Thrive. Given where we're at in the development of this, I think we need some additional time to work with staff, the two council members that were Wentworth and Council Member Fernie in working with MLH and staff and some collaboration efforts there with some of the reps from Mammoth Lakes Housing, which allow us both for more
1:50:08 Robust report to come back and as it feeds into the ultimate contractual arrangement with MLH. So if we could pull this item tonight, that'd be appreciated. I think it'd be premature otherwise. And then also we request to add an item. We're recommending that an urgency item be considered by the town council to add a following closed session item to the agenda pursuant to government code section 54954.2b2.
1:50:36 This will require a four-fifths vote by the council to add the item. The item is to hold a conference with its representatives in regard to a property acquisition at 96 Metal Lane under Government Code Section 5495 6.8. Negotiating part is be myself and Grady Dutton representing the town, who is the prospective buyer of property, and Mammoth Creek Homeowners Association, the prospective seller of property, and we would be negotiating price and terms.
1:51:06 The payment of that. And so this would require formal action by the council to add it to the agenda. And just to clarify, that's also, it would also go on the agenda not only as real proper negotiations but also as pending litigation since this is an eminent domain matter that we have pending. We received a settlement proposal from the HOA yesterday.
1:51:26 And this is why there's a need to take immediate action. Well, there's a need to take immediate action because we'd like to get back to them very, very quickly so that we can stop the imminent domain process if at all possible. And the second prong that it has to be satisfied in order for you to add to the agenda is that the need to take action came to your attention after the agenda was posted. And again, we just received the settlement proposal yesterday. So that was after the agenda was posted. So if four of you concur that we should talk about this in closed session, you can add it to the agenda.
1:51:55 Excellent. Thank you very much. Any questions for staff? Not hearing any. I will make a motion that someone can second and we can vote on that's consistent with the desire here. So I will move that pursuant to Government Code Section 54954.2b2, the Council hereby determines that there is a need to take immediate action, that the need for action came to the attention of the Town subsequent to the agenda being posted as specified in Subdivision A, said item being,
1:52:24 The council will hold a conference with this representatives in regard to property acquisition pertaining to property 96 Meadow Lane, APN 040-0201-000-000, negotiating parties Dan Holler and Grady Dutton, representing town, prospective buyer, Mammoth Creek Homeowners Association, prospective seller, under negotiation price in terms of payment. Second. And pending litigation. Still second.
1:52:53 Thank you. Any further discussion? Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, the item is grade 250. Thank you very much. We will then move to any reports from commissions and or departments.
1:53:15 Thank you. Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Two updates for the Council. Next week, the Planning and Economic Development Commission will hold their regularly scheduled meeting. That's next Wednesday, February 14th, here in Suite Z at 2 o'clock. They will be considering the cannabis regulations that the Council discussed yesterday afternoon. And they will also be receiving a presentation from Mono County Office of Ed.
1:53:40 Also, staff has scheduled the second Mobility Committee meeting, which is the committee of the Planning and Economic Development Commission. That meeting is scheduled for February 21st. That's a Wednesday. It'll be 1 o'clock in the town and county conference room. And that is a public meeting. And the staff's intent is to present scopes of work for each of the walk, bike, ride action items at that meeting and allow the committee to discuss those action items.
1:54:08 Excellent. Thank you very much. Any thoughts for Sandra? Nope. You're free. Thank you. Thank you. Grady Dutton. Thank you. Grady Dutton, Public Works Director. Just one quick item. Although the road maintenance folks would much rather be managing snow and pushing it around, we are taking this opportunity to do a lot of crack ceiling all over town, if you see that. And the reason I mention it is it's not just fill-in work.
1:54:30 Because this summer was so short, we got to do very little. And it actually, nothing extends the life of a road than the little things you do on an annual basis. And I just wanted to let you know that it's not fill-in work, and it's certainly not downtime work. This is very important, and it will extend the life of many of our pavements for a number of years. That's it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks. Anybody else? Stuart? Good evening. Stuart Brown, Public Information Officer and Parks and Recreation Director.
1:55:00 Just have a public information item, some Parks and Recs news. So I just do want to remind the special event producers in the community, if they want to submit a funding application, it closes on Friday. That's February 9th. So make sure everybody's aware of that. Secondly, on the Parks and Recreation front,
1:55:18 A couple of new programs underway that I'd want to make the community aware of. The Adult Volleyball League is underway tonight. It's a new program that we've instituted. We started with a drop-in program a couple of weeks ago with six people. The next weekend we have 33 people. And now we have seven teams playing every Wednesday night at the middle school. So that's a great new program.
1:55:38 We continue with midweek programs of adult indoor soccer on Sunday night. Curling league's going great. A couple of folks in here at that as well. And then looking ahead, March 27th at 5 o'clock was the Recreation Open House. And then once again, a reminder for the community, we open all our programs on April 1st for summer, which is, yeah, right out the window. Mammoth Ice Rink.
1:56:02 It's a real struggle. We're limping along. We remain open. We've gone to kind of limited hours. We open typically later in the afternoon, just maintain our quality of ice. So we're open through March 4th. And finally, in celebration of the Winter Olympics, it does start on Friday, we're offering a free Olympic curling clinic. So you can come along, learn how to call, or, you know, join us in a match play competition. And that's from 5 to 7 p.m.
1:56:29 So that's this Saturday Olympic free-calling clinic. Very much the rage. And then finally, the Recreation Commission has a special meeting tomorrow. There's a workshop with Mammoth Lakes Recreation to define the roles, responsibilities, and expectations of the new playground project. So any questions? Any questions? Thank you very much, Stuart. Thank you. Anybody else? Any other commissions? Dan? Sorry, Mr. Mayor, I just...
1:56:54 Jumping the gun a little bit here, but item number two on your agenda introductions needs to be pulled as people are ill, out ill. Oh, okay, good. Sorry to hear that. Okay. Anything else? We're good. Okay. Thank you very much. So we'll now move on to the public presentation. Mono County Child Care Needs Assessment Presented by Inyo Mono Advocates for Community Action Incorporated. I believe this is a half-hour presentation. If we can allow some time for discussion, that'd be great.
1:57:24 Hi, I'm Queenie Barnard. I'm the Mono County Child Care Council Coordinator, and I work for IMACA Inyo Mono Advocates for Community Action. Nancy Mahana is also a council member, and she's also a Mono County public health nurse. So I'll just jump right in here, and we're kind of just going to trade off.
1:57:42 On different slides, just depending which one. So first, for those of you who don't know about the Mono County Child Care Council, primary mission of the local child care planning council is to plan for child care and development services based on the needs of families in the local community. Every county has a child care council.
1:57:59 Our council recently had a strategic planning retreat, so we revised our vision and mission. So our new vision is all children in Mono County will be supported to reach their full potential, and our mission is that we'll actively lead a community-wide effort to develop and sustain accessible, high-quality, affordable child care and education.
1:58:18 So the members of the Child Care Council is comprised of a couple different groups. They're child care providers, consumers of child care, community members, public agency representatives. So as you can see, we have representation from a couple different agencies there. One member that I wanted to note, Dee Turgenson with First Five Mono County, is no longer a council member, but she was involved when we did this child care needs assessment, so I did want to leave her on the slide there.
1:58:46 So we do have a current vacancy on our Child Care Council if anybody is interested in joining. So now I'll take it over to Nancy Mahana who will get into the meat of the Child Care Needs Assessment. Thank you.
1:59:06 I am very interested in child care. In 1995, we adopted four children, and for many years, we paid $1,500 in child care every year. My husband worked five...
1:59:22 I worked 40 hours a week. I worked 32 hours a week. And we traded off Friday and Monday. And we had an 11-hour-a-day nanny in those other middle-of-the-week days. And it was a time that was pretty wild.
1:59:42 Child care needs assessment began in the fall of 2016, and we finished it in about May of 2017. So this is how we went about it. We did online and paper survey, and then we asked people if they wanted to be interviewed about their child care needs, and then 15 people came forward. We also did focus groups with the Peapod group, which is a children's play and learning group that is carried on around the county.
2:00:11 We also did child care provider and business employer surveys. And also we interviewed all of you. So we ended up with the consumer survey. Let me see down, page down. Okay. We ended up with 178 parents.
2:00:38 And these are the areas you can see we ask them, well, where do you live, where do you work, and where is your child care taking place? And so these three columns represent that.
2:00:53 We also ask them, do you have child care or do you need child care or do you anticipate needing child care? And you can see by far the greatest need is among the infant years and there's several reasons for that. In the first place, a child care provider can only care for four infants at a time unless they have other assistance or they can care for more if they have more.
2:01:16 So,
2:01:38 When is child care needed? During the low season, such as summer, families are traveling, so they don't need child care. So the providers cut their hours back, but that also means they cut their employees, so the employee hours are cut and the employee's income goes down.
2:01:55 It puts a burden on the businesses because when there's less child care, then their people can't work. And so you can imagine if you have a child that's maybe 8, 10, 12, and then you have to go to work and they're off all summer, what are you going to do with them? So that's a huge issue. And in the middle school,
2:02:18 The after-school programs, it's like there's a lot of stuff for kids up to fifth grade, but sixth, seventh, eighth grade, there's very limited options in the summer for parents.
2:02:30 So I've interspersed a few quotes here from the survey, and one of the employees wrote, often child care providers take days off as the same days off as schools, and we're still open for business. And another one is child care is not open early or late enough for her to work a normal schedule, which is another issue. And those of you that are familiar with some of the town programs that are summer,
2:02:58 Like, for instance, they had a program going where they had from 9 to 4, they had camps. And then on Wednesday or Thursday, rather, then they went on an overnight trip, but they didn't start till noon. And, you know, so the programs that are offered by the town frequently do not help provide child care during the summer, even though they're great camps. So going to the next slide. So are employers flexible around child care needs?
2:03:28 You can see that some of them are, some of them aren't, but the employers say that they do accommodate child care problems and they sometimes allow people to bring their children to work, but once again, that is a health and safety issue to have your kids running around at work, depending on what it is. So why is it so difficult to obtain child care?
2:03:55 No child care means you have to take time off without pay because most people don't have benefits or many people in the tourist industry don't have benefits. So the school breaks align with the busiest tourist days of the year. And so once again, that's in a problem. So a quote from a woman is, my daughter has to have two jobs to make ends meet. Even if she could find care, she can't afford it on her income.
2:04:24 How much does child care cost? So Queenie is going to talk about this, but I just want to draw your attention to the current waiting list, and this is not something from the needs assessment. It's something that we did in the last two weeks. So go ahead, Queenie. So we gathered this information from a couple different...
2:04:47 Providers in the area, so we have the Husky Club, Mammoth Elementary, After School Husky Club, Mammoth Kids Corner, located off Forest Trail, Mammoth Lakes Lutheran Preschool, the Mono County Head Start State Preschool, so there's five of them, Benton, Bridgeport, Colville, Lee Mining, and Mammoth Lakes, and I also included the IMACA subsidized child care program. And like Nancy said, as you can see, the wait list, it's...
2:05:10 Pretty wild. There's a wait list for all age groups and as you can see as well, the Lutheran Preschool, their rates with a minimum wage increase, they are planning on increasing their rates and Kids Corner does typically increase their rates every year as well. Something I wanted to note about the Mono County Head Start in state preschools is you'll see that Mammoth Lakes currently has four
2:05:33 Families on the wait list. And the Mammoth Lakes Head Start State Preschool actually has one slot available, but none of those four families are income eligible. And that's where it gets...
2:05:43 Kind of weird with the Head Start and State Preschool Income Eligibility. State Preschool Income Guidelines are based off of state median income ceilings, whereas Head Start Income Guidelines are based off of the poverty guidelines published by the federal government, which is much lower than the SMI, the state median income. So just to give you an idea, a family of four in order to be income eligible for the state.
2:06:06 So that's something that is just,
2:06:36 Pretty wild to think about is the income ceilings. And another thing is I had a story of a I had a client on my subsidized child care program who recently received a raise and that would have put her over income so she wouldn't be eligible for my program anymore. So what she ended up doing was cutting her hours down to three days a week instead of five days a week in order for her to still be eligible and get her child care covered because
2:07:01 Comparing three days a week of work and getting her child care covered versus working five days a week but having to pay all of her child care out of pocket, she brings home more income working three days a week. So just something to consider and that impacts employers because instead of having a full-time employee working five days a week, now that employee can only work three days a week.
2:07:32 Help me with this, Queenia. So you can see there's certain percentages of what the income is of the people that were the child care consumers. So this is based on the 178 interviews that we did. So 79% of them are not eligible for Head Start. And yeah. So anyway.
2:07:54 So, you know, I think it's really significant that parents report spending a third of their income on child care, and if they have more than one child in child care, they may spend over half of their income on child care.
2:08:10 So who are the child care providers? Who's providing the child care? So of the 27 respondents, 60% are fluent in English. And I think it's important because, you know, in order to be an assistant teacher or a teacher, you have to take college classes.
2:08:28 Given that conceptual language is like at the final acquisition of English, how can you expect a child care provider who has language challenges to take a college class at the community college? I took two classes last spring in child development, and there's no way that I can see that somebody with language issues is going to be able to take that successfully.
2:08:54 So looking at the hourly income, this data indicates that 83% of providers make less than $20 an hour. And of course, this value will depend on who shows up and who doesn't and who's paid their bills.
2:09:14 So why become a child care provider? And, you know, as a nurse, I remember back in the 60s, people used to say, well, you need to be a nurse because that's the altruistic thing to do and we don't need to pay you because you're doing it because of who you are, because this is what something you want to do to help society. And I can't help but see that child care providers at this point in time in our history are in the same situation.
2:09:38 You can see all the comments they made about why they are child care providers, which are very incredible. They really want to see the kids learn, and they really enjoy taking care of the kids. So, Queenie, I think you were going to talk about this one. Yeah, so the child care provider suggestions for change, more infant and child care providers and teachers, going along with Nancy's comment, better access to college classes.
2:10:11 There's 12 early childhood education or child development units required in order to be a teacher. Encourage high school students to go into the child care field, more child care facilities, more support for child care providers in general. And then the last one was a big one is address insufficient, unaffordable housing in the area, which I think is something that just...
2:10:29 You know, the whole area is thinking about. So a couple stories we've actually heard about current teachers or providers who've had to move out of the area because they can no longer afford housing. We had an infant teacher at one of the centers who her lease was ending and the landlord decided that he wanted to Airbnb instead of continuing to lease so she could not find any other affordable housing so she ended up leaving the area. We've heard a couple stories about that or about potentially hiring providers from outside the area.
2:10:59 But they can't find affordable housing, so they end up having to turn down the job offer. Another point about the insufficient housing is that we've had two prospective potential child care providers come to us interested in opening up a family child care home, but their landlord
2:11:18 Won't allow it. However, by law, a property owner or landlord is not allowed to prohibit a person from opening a family child care home. However, because of the lack of affordable housing, a lot of these folks don't want to cause any waves with their landlord and push back, so they don't say, you know, that's illegal, I'm going to sue you for it, so they just drop it. So that's something else to keep in mind is they don't have any other options, they don't want to push it.
2:11:50 The next slide shows what parents are interested in when they're looking for child care. So this is what they care about when they're looking for child care. So our next part of the survey was the employer survey, and you can see where all of the businesses that were surveyed are from. And 25 of the businesses have employees that require child care.
2:12:20 Lack of child care impacts the local businesses. You can see that there's absenteeism. The child care hours are inconsistent with business needs. But you can see that there's a variety of other times when child care are needed when it is not available. Because basically, it's very difficult to find child care at the times that are not 8 to 5, Monday through Friday. So that's a huge need.
2:12:51 So, what has changed since we finished the survey? The Mono County Office of Education opened a preschool with 10 slots, and some of them including special needs on the elementary school campus. One person has become a child care provider, however, informed her families this week that she was moving to Swell Meadows, and if they wanted to continue with child care in Swell Meadows, that she would, but you can imagine...
2:13:18 Given where people live and work, that that probably isn't going to be practical. And the Kids' Corner had three parents frantically calling for child care this week because she was leaving.
2:13:30 So Mammoth Hospital is considering becoming child care providers, but when I spoke with them this last week, they said, well, we can't use the facility we have, we're going to have to build. So imagine how long that's going to take, like two or three years to get another child care center that Mammoth Hospital can use. And three child care providers as of last spring left the area.
2:13:56 So when we talked to all of you and the Mono County Board of Supervisors, we found a few interesting things, and one of the reasons we're here to talk to you today is that very few of you have experience with child care and also...
2:14:14 But you do understand that it is too costly and that it lacks availability and alternative hours. And so when we asked you, well, what do you feel like your responsibility is, the answer was we can help make it affordable. But then we have to think, well, how can we do that?
2:14:31 Provide support through policy. What policies are we going to implement to do that? There aren't even children going into, or there aren't even students going into child care because of the compensation. And when the lady at the director of the Lutheran preschool called the Cerro Coso to find out who was taking child care classes, no one from Mono County was taking child care classes online.
2:14:57 And just to listen better, and very few of you all had a limited knowledge of how First Five, AMACA, and Office of Education, what the relationship with child care was. So what are the questions moving forward? I'm going to read these because this really affects the family health, it affects the economic health of our community. How do we assist families with the expense of child care?
2:15:26 What policies, if enacted, would support the cost and availability of child care?
2:15:57 So what can we do about it here and now from this point forward? First of all, I encourage you to read the stories from the parents that are in the back of the 15 parents that are in the back of the child care needs assessment, which you have in your board packet. And just to recognize that while child care issues are not...
2:16:20 All only about does the child have care. It's about the business and the economy of this community. Realize that infant care is nearly absent. Most people that have infant care have their mother come up. If their mother's still working, then they try to make do or one of the family members takes time off.
2:16:39 Working parents of preteen children want to have supervised after-school programs. Any risk and resiliency research will tell you supervision is extremely important for kids, especially the 6th through 8th grade, because that is the time of experimentation, especially between 8th and 9th grade as well.
2:16:58 The recommendations then would be to include on-site child care in all plans for affordable housing and include child care center plans in the county and town civic center and be open to policies that augment income to provide for child care options. And so there are some policies out there. I know that there's, I don't know if it's Vail or Aspen, they had like a one percent, one cent.
2:17:22 Childcare, half-cent childcare tax, all of that money goes directly to childcare. And that certainly is, we need to, as a commission, look into some of those other possibilities. So as a quote from one of the business owners said, as the area grows from business expansion, our elected leaders need to make sure that the infrastructure is in place to handle more people and more children.
2:17:52 Kind of finishing up here, this is our updated strategic plan, and it's included in your meeting packet as well. So I just wanted to pull out the three main objectives that we developed. So develop and implement a career pathway program for future child care providers to increase participation in early childhood education slash child development college courses, ensure that a minimum of 50% of children 0 to 12 years old with parents in the workforce have a child care slot, and increase both home-based and center-based options that provide an age-
2:18:22 So as I mentioned, that strategic plan has a couple more details there about our strategies and our action plan.
2:18:33 And then just this image, hoping you'll see it more around the area, but this is our Child Care Quality System logo, and it's what quality early care means. So just a simple infographic, so low teacher-to-child ratios and small group sizes, age-appropriate learning activities, engaging in safe learning environments, activities that support physical, social, and emotional growth, and qualified staff with professional development opportunities.
2:18:59 And lastly, if you or anybody you know is interested in becoming a child care provider, please send them our way to the IMACA office, 625 Old Mammoth Road. We can help them with startup costs up to $500. It can add up application fees, just getting their house ready for inspection, whether it's getting a fence to gate off their fireplace, things like that. So we're hoping that a little incentive will get people thinking about it. And also in your packets is a provider recruitment flyer as well as a...
2:19:28 The steps to becoming a provider, and it's not as daunting as it seems. So if anybody's interested, definitely let them know about the opportunity and send them our way. Thank you so much. Thank you. Excellent presentation. Any questions or any? Yes, let us first commend you and thank you for an excellent, thorough presentation. I think here in the town, we always appreciate the kinds of unique efforts that the county provides and making sure that we're all aware of what's going on out there for the public health.
2:19:59 Sector and things like your presentation this evening. Any thoughts or questions from Councilmembers? No? There are a number of initiatives that are coming forward from the town that may not seem related on the face of it, but the multi-use facility behind you, there's a connection to that, and the child care facility. I know the Shady Rest parcel, we haven't talked about any planning for that, but there are opportunities over there that may lend itself to that.
2:20:31 The town is pursuing a very ambitious housing action plan that may fit into these kinds of opportunities. I figured it's a great time to come to you. It's a great time to be learning about this. I think that also when we talk about generating higher wages and income for people in Mammoth Lakes and certainly in all of Mono County, the changing nature of our recreation environment is going to be very important, and I think we've seen some very encouraging trends in terms of what the Public Lands Partnership has to offer for
2:21:00 Thank you very much.
2:21:31 With that, we'll move on to the consent agenda. And I will read the items. And then if anybody wants to pull anything, let us know. Number four, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of January 17, 2018. Number five, approve the minutes of the special meeting of January 22, 2018. Number six, authorize architecture and engineering design services for the community multi-use facility amendment to existing agreement with HMC architects.
2:22:00 Number seven, approval of a resolution authorizing the town manager or his, her, or her designee to enter, execute an RGA, restricted grant agreement contract with Caltrans for the Mammoth Lakes Climate and Resiliency Strategies and General Plant Update Grant Program. Number eight, accept payment approval report numbers 1834, 1835, 1836, and 1837. And I believe that's it. Anybody wishing to pull anything? No? Anybody from the public?
2:22:30 Not hearing any, so I would entertain a motion then on the consent agenda. Happy to make a motion. Council approves consent agenda items 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8. Second. Thank you. Any further discussion? Hearing none. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes, with the no vote on consent item 6. Okay. Yes. The item is agreed to.
2:23:01 5-0 with the vote noted by Member Hoff. Thank you very much. We'll move on now to policy items. First item is number nine, consideration of proposed joint town-county-eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator position. Dan. Thank you, Mayor. The item before you, we've talked about it at least once or twice before in concept. There's been a substantial amount of work looking at ways to enhance.
2:23:27 How we interface with the national forest partnerships across the town and county lines, looking at ways to enhance recreational opportunities within our county and really within the region here on a broad scale. Also, there's been a lot of discussion about the kind of change at the Forest Service level and what it means to have partnership agencies and agreements in place and how we work through that. We've been growing in our relationship with the Forest Service at the town level.
2:23:55 The proposal before you outlined an option to look at a jointly funded position between the town and the county. Say the position was developed also in consultation with the Forest Service at the Mammoth Ranger District as well as the Humboldt-Tiobe and at the Inyo supervisor level. So it's gone through a number of different levels of review and discussion on that.
2:24:21 I think the idea of the program and the concepts laid out has gained a fair amount of solid support in terms of what it can make and makes a difference in how we interface and the things we look at. And, of course, we're looking at longer term in terms of funding opportunities if we have the right things in place for that. A lot of that is shovel-ready projects, be that through federal programs, potentially through some future state programs, depending on some bond issues going forward to state level.
2:24:50 A lot of this is outlined in the report, so I'm not going to walk through all the detailed details with you. I will touch briefly on the, as initially structured, the funding element looked at about $142,000 a year. That assumed salary and some dollars for operating costs. The county has allocated $50,000 for this effort within their current year budget.
2:25:13 So the town would need to look at committing the remainder, $92,000. This would be broken based on our recommendations and review of a general fund contribution and the potential for a request to Mammoth Lakes Recreation for a recommendation for utilizing Measure R and U funding, probably with a heavier look at Measure U funding, just because of the breadth of the
2:25:36 Potential work that can be accomplished doesn't have quite the same restriction as Major R does for this type of program. This really is a matter of council policy and direction, how you want to go forward, so staff doesn't really have a hard recommendation on this item. You have three options that have been laid out in the staff report. One would be to move forward at this point in time.
2:26:01 The other would be looking at it more in terms of a budgetary item, looking at it in that process, and we can move forward with additional information at that point. Or you may provide a direction not to pursue or any combination thereof, if you will, as we look at moving this forward. I'd be glad to address any, you know, the technical issues or other processes in here, I must say.
2:26:25 Our HR manager, Cassie Mance, has done a lot of work in terms of the potential job description. Rob has been involved in the finance director in terms of this as well in the financing side. And again, a lot of input from a variety of agencies and individuals involved with the concepts. I think the concepts inside of that has a lot of community support and how we're looking to that is really a matter.
2:26:49 It's a timing and financial support really for the council to take a look at and ultimately the structure if this is something you wish to see move forward at this point in time and or as part of our upcoming budget process. With that, I'll answer any questions or leave it for council discussion and public input. Thank you, Dan. Thank you very much. Any questions, technical, those types of questions for Dan?
2:27:15 Just a couple of points of clarification. So this is a shared position between the town and the county. And the town's primary interest in this is for things like permit management. I know that the town, obviously, I think 75% of our landmass is federal public lands. And we have a whole couple pages of lists of permits with the Forest Service that are not being managed properly, expired, things like that in terms of the integration.
2:27:42 Sort of a fundamental interest of the town as opposed to being a on the ground, you know, dirt turning type of position. Is that fair to say? That's correct. We have a fair amount of work to do in that area. There's the number of permits from the port service side and even a longer list from the town side that we've worked through that are, I mean, they're technically working because we have an operating plan, I think, for most of them and we pay the fees, but the actual permit themselves have been expired in some cases for several years.
2:28:10 And the idea is probably over the long term to set up a programs of the town, the permits with the Forest Service can be managed as annual operating plans on an annual basis, which would reduce bureaucratic and staff time to deal with expired things and that kind of stuff. If we get a longer permit term, a lot of them, that would be helpful as well. Okay. And the general fund ask for this position? On the layout that's here, it'd be $67,000. Okay. Again, you can modify that somewhat if you wish to use more of other restricted funds.
2:28:38 With the expectation funding from the county's commitment and also funding potentially for more on you. Okay. So I'll open up to the public. Any public comments or thoughts on this? Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers. Tony Dablino, Assistant CEO with Mono County. Just wanted to come up and say a few things about it. First, you know, the county has a...
2:29:06 Thank you.
2:29:28 Interest really culminated in this assignment of $50,000 or appropriation of $50,000 this year earlier, rather earlier in 2017. And we were going to be working through to try to put somebody in place to start working on these types of things. You know, the county does not have somebody doing the good work that Joel's doing in our organization. And so I think we are kind of heading in that direction. And really the opportunities that emerge surrounding this.
2:29:55 This position and some of the different funding streams that are available and this involvement, engagement of the agencies, you know, and them being so interested in us showing this coordination together, this regional coordination between agencies really just seemed like a unique opportunity for us to move it forward and to try to do something together with the town. So our board did direct us to pursue this in December. It was at the Joint Town-County meeting.
2:30:21 It was discussed anyways at that time and we received clear direction to appropriate that $50,000 towards the creation of a position and we've been working with some of the town staff since that time and just kind of refining the job description, the agreements and what have you. And so I think it's safe to say at this point that our board is hopeful that the council is going to agree this is a good idea and that it will be moved forward tonight. Thanks. Good. Thank you very much.
2:30:48 Thank you, Stacey Corliss, Mono County Board of Supervisors. Tony summed it up really nicely. I just want to start out by thanking Mayor Wentworth for his leadership in getting this position created at the county, encouraging the county to really look at outdoor recreation as not just something optional for local government to get involved in, but to really look at it as the town has, as a necessity, as a wise investment. Mono County is
2:31:18 Almost 95% public land. Agency budgets are dwindling. Visitation is on the increase. The county's hoping that you'll approve this now or at least look at it in your next budget cycle and that we can really move forward together. People recreating on our public lands don't know where the town administrative boundary ends and where the Mono County...
2:31:45 Area begins and working together, leveraging resources and also the tremendous funding opportunities that are ahead of us with Proposition 68 and other funding resources. We're stronger together and I hope we can move forward with this soon. And thanks again. I also want to thank Town Manager Holler and Town Staff for all the work they've done on this. Thanks. Good. Thank you very much.
2:32:15 Good evening, Matt McLean, Mammoth Lakes Recreation. I just want to mirror what Tony and Stacey said, that we see this opportunity as an incredible asset for what we're trying to accomplish at Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Believe that it will help us scale the work that we're doing and will be an incredible complement to what staff and our local organizations are doing on the ground. So thank you very much for your support and thank you very much for staff for their work on this. Excellent, thank you. Anybody else?
2:32:46 Okay. Seeing none. Who wants to start this off? I'm more than happy to start it off. I'm not really, but I will. I have no one over the past 35 years has pushed the town or county stronger to get into the Forest Service and work with them and work with each other for recreation than I have. Flat out. I am sure of that.
2:33:16 That being said, the town has already done a whole lot of things to get there. We created MLR, which was going to be all things non, what do we call it, recreation, municipal recreation. Management level positions, a lot of money going to that, doing good work, but the money is being spent. We hired Joel, who's doing a job that is incredible.
2:33:43 And because of some conflicts with the Forest Service, we put a piece of our town manager's time into that. And between the two of them, I think Mammoth has already come up with a solution for our end of this. To me, and I'm going to not go through all my notes here unless it becomes necessary later, and I'll pull out the big clubs. I don't believe we can afford another management-level position.
2:34:09 To fill something that, yes, it took me 35 years to get the town to this place with your help. You and I have fought this battle together. But I would prefer to move Joel into that. We already have him at that, our trails coordinator, who has a great relationship with the Forest Service and continue to use a percentage of our town managers because Forest Service loves dealing with the decision makers. And then in the budget process, look at perhaps a hybrid position or a trails
2:34:38 Person, which could cost us far less money to do some of the on-the-ground work that we're having our management-level people do today. It just makes more sense. A few less chiefs and a few more Indians on the ground. I'm excited about what this can do. This still allows us to use the Mono County money coming in to help with Joel and put a piece of his time on the county piece.
2:35:04 And then take our savings from that and move that down into this piece plus some Measure U money. And then we also have someone if we create a hybrid position who can do snow removal when necessary in the winter or do the snow removal on the paths but do other things that we need. So we've got one hybrid position already. But I see we could do this and still move the trails forward and continue a relationship instead of segueing into a whole brand new one from the town's perspective.
2:35:34 That we have already spent a whole lot of time, effort, and money creating. And that being said, I think that that works and gives us far bigger bang for the money than going out and hiring yet one more management-level position. When I think about hiring somebody at that level, I think about the town staff sitting here in the room and who potentially I'm going to give a pink slip to so that I can afford this position.
2:36:01 So I believe this is a way to leverage the county money to do them good and to fulfill our needs all at the same time. Okay, good. Thank you. I'd like to probably hear from other council members, just get a kind of general sense of where we're at in terms of whether this position is proposed as a good idea, something we want to pursue. I think, Bill, that's interesting insights. I think there's some sort of technical HR kinds of issues in there that I think before we would even want to move forward, we want to get a sense from councils that generally speaking is whether this is something we want to pursue.
2:36:31 Colin? Sure. You know, first, I want to thank the county for kind of stepping up to the plate here, putting this in front of us. I think it's incredibly exciting that we now have these types of initiatives that we can work on together, and, you know, the relationship between the town and the county is, you know, the best it's ever been. So I think from that perspective, this is something that's very exciting to me.
2:36:58 You know, I don't think my perspective has really changed on this. You know, we've seen this a couple of times. We've talked about it. For me, the position has merit. You know, I see kind of the larger scale opportunities that we have out of this. I love the opportunity to kind of work in conjunction with the county and leverage funds. I think there's a need there.
2:37:23 That our recreation economy is our entire economy here. You know, the national forest and the budgets and all the tapping in Washington is really retreating from a lot of those responsibilities. So I think it's a game that we need to get into. That being said, I think we've been very deliberate as a council over the four years that I've sat up here about hiring additional bodies.
2:37:49 You know, I think I'm much more comfortable personally with one-time capital expenditures than long-term encumbrances. You know, I think this is very similar to the process we went through with our last budget cycle.
2:38:02 When we had that first round speaking to staff, there was a whole host of positions that came before us. We need a position here, we need a position here, we need a position there. When we went back and really established as part of the context of the budget, we were really able to hone in on kind of the two positions that we felt were most critical at the time and that we felt comfortable funding from a budget perspective.
2:38:29 That is kind of where I lie with this position as well. I think as a one-off, it's difficult for me to prioritize whether this sits above an additional housing position, which is something we've talked about, an additional police officer, which is a need that we all know we have, whether we need an additional body in public works to implement all the work that we're doing.
2:38:52 I'm much more comfortable moving forward with option two. I think, again, this position has merit for me, and I love the opportunity to work in conjunction with the county on this, but I can't responsibly approve a long-term budgetary encumbrance without it being part of the broader discussion of our budget moving forward. And I think we're approaching our next budget cycle pretty quickly here.
2:39:18 If we were to pull the trigger on something like this tonight, we may be able to get somebody in place, you know, in the July timeframe. If we're to hold off for a few months, maybe that pushes it out to the fall in preparation for next summer. And I think either way that works. So, you know, I definitely want Dan this to be part of the consideration for the budget moving forward. But I think that has to be a council decision as part of the broader context of the budget rather than just a one-off.
2:39:47 And I think that's sage insights on a number of fronts. I think also it would be nice to be thinking about bringing a position on in a timely fashion, but I think given the nature of a lot of the work as developed in the job description, it is administrative. I'm not sure that work on the ground is going to be as a critical component of this, and I think if we're looking at this in the context of a larger budget discussion, I think those things make sense.
2:40:16 And so I think, I mean, I obviously want to hear from everybody in this, but I think the idea of the job description, I think you're comfortable with that and how it's laid out in here. And I think that what I'm hearing from you is a desire to have this discussed as part of the competing needs, perhaps, in terms of the town's budget issues going forward. Yeah. Okay. Shields? Yeah, John, I want to thank you for bringing this forward. It's been great, and I want to commend the county for stepping up.
2:40:46 But I'm with Colin on this. I think we need to go through a few more steps, you know, kind of ferret it out, go through the budget cycle, really understand a little bit more. It's tough to find those right people. It takes time. And so I think we need a little bit of that time and a little of that budgetary discussion to do that.
2:41:11 I'm good with the option two on this. Good. Okay. Again, and you're comfortable with the agenda packet as presented in the job description? Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. Okay. Cleland? Where to start? Okay. I've been hearing both sides from people in the community. I think this is a great job. I agree it's going to be very hard to find the right person. I have...
2:41:40 Never been very supportive of bringing anybody new on for anything during my course here. Just even like tonight, we were going to swear in a reserve officer, however, there was an illness. Well, they couldn't be here, but what if something bad had happened and somebody's out sick? I do not like the way that the police department, so I know that's a different subject, but I do think that
2:42:10 Part of the public perception is this is going to be kind of a policeman out in the woods kind of job. So I think that needs to be clarified to people exactly what that's going to cover. But then I really like what Bill said because
2:42:30 Joel is someone that if I had been around, I probably wouldn't have voted for his job, but I'm so impressed with what he has done that it would be something I would be curious to see what he could do with his connections and get things moving.
2:42:52 Not very supportive of getting right now another high level person who's making a lot of money. And it's not even so much the money, it's all the insurance and all the retirement and everything that gets involved in that. So I guess at this point, I would have to say I'm leaning more towards option two and just waiting to see if we can.
2:43:19 It just comes down to money in my mind. I do think that this job does give a chance for us to make some more money in some aspects of it. I don't like the name that it's a recreation, the Eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator, because I think with that position, a lot of it will be not so much recreation.
2:43:48 The land's more than just recreation. So, yeah, I'm not real hip on the title there. I think it should be something that gives a little bit better idea of what we're trying to accomplish with it. Okay, but again, I just wanted, as I mentioned with Shields and Colin, you're comfortable with the job description that's presented.
2:44:10 And the agenda item is, and I want to just, I want to speak and commend all the folks from the Forest Service. I mean, the development of this job description was a collaborative effort at the Forest Service, Mono County staff, Mammoth Lakes representatives. It really was a group effort to come up with how this thing's been put together. I just have a little bit of trouble with the fact that I don't want it to end up something that's going to end up just solely concentrating on recreation. I don't want people to worry about
2:44:40 If they're just out doing something in the wilderness that they're going to have someone come along and, you know, cite them, which is a valid fear of the people in public. Just to be clear, that's not, I mean, people say all kinds of things. That's certainly not something, it's not in the job description. It was never, that was never a discussion of any of the people involved in developing the position. Not a trail cop. And I actually, I did hear that as well. Like, I have no idea where the basis for that, you know.
2:45:09 perspective came from, but I did hear that as well. So I think, you know, allowing some time to really educate the public on what the intent of this position would be. You know, I know both, you know, Bill especially and maybe Cleland as well are potentially coming at this from a different perspective than I am, but I still think it's valid to say that if we really evaluate this in the context of our budget and our budget constraints and our priorities around staffing,
2:45:38 Maybe some of that stuff can get sussed out. I know that when we went through the last budget cycle, there certainly wasn't a hybrid recreation public works position that was initially proposed. And that kind of became and came to light as we went through those discussions. So, you know, maybe there's some merit to some adjustment to the role. Maybe there isn't. But I think either way.
2:46:01 Having it as part of the broader context of the budget is the way that needs to go from my perspective. Yeah, I want to say one thing before, and excellent discussion, I think it's important for the council to understand that speaking, it's not probably appropriate for us to be speaking in terms of names of staff and things like that. I think it's helpful to be talked in terms of positions. That's kind of helpful, but I think I want to make sure that we're not identifying personalities and things like that. No problem.
2:46:27 We'll leave his name out of it. I am not opposed to the position, obviously. I'm not opposed to what it can do. The county from their side needs this position as a new position. I'm saying that I believe we've skinned this cat, and with just some changes, not only can we accomplish this through the process, but we can, without spending as much, amplify the value.
2:46:53 Of what we can do with the Forest Service, with all the trailheads and the trails and the maintenance necessary and everything else. So I just don't want to, I'm trying to caution, let's not get locked into one method of delivery, but let's look as well as with the budget, how we can deliver this for our constituents. So what I'm kind of hearing is option two, that their support.
2:47:20 From the council as to the job description is presented as the general scope of what this position is tended to do for the town's interest as well as the county's interest. There's an interest in having, I would suggest, the town manager look a little bit at how the position is structured from the town perspective and to bring back whatever recommendations the town manager might have for that. But other than that, to recommend this.
2:47:46 This position be considered as part of a general budgeting process going forward whenever that comes forward in the coming months. Is that sufficient direction for you, Dan? Yeah, yeah. We can definitely build it into the budget. That perspective is one of the options for the town consideration. And we can look at some variations in terms of delivery model. So unless there's further discussion, I'll move as such. I do have another question about this. So how do you go about finding, say this goes ahead and
2:48:14 Are we going to hire somebody who's going to go out and headhunt for us basically to find? I would defer to Dan. What would the recruitment process be? At this point we would use, I'll say, more of a standard process, but where you would focus your recruitment would be a little different maybe than what we do for an engineer or for a...
2:48:32 Parks Maintenance Person or something. What I'm saying is would we have to pay for... No, we would do it in-house. You would do that in-house. It has costs associated, but no more than what we do for other management-level positions in the town. So that would not be a... The cost there would not be... We wouldn't go hire a headhunter, for example, to do that work, no. Okay, so... So as eloquently articulated by our mayor here, I will move as such. Okay. Jamie's grinning.
2:49:03 If I can paraphrase it. Unless you want to crack the motion. I'll take a crack at it. The motion would be to pursue option two with the understanding that council has accepted the job description and the other components of the agenda item as presented.
2:49:28 Council is also requesting that the town manager review the structure of the position relative to the current staff structure that we have in the town and make a recommendation as appropriate and that this item be considered as part of the town's larger budget process going forward. I would just add general position because, you know, as we go through the budgetary process, you know, there might be a couple tweaks here. Sure, sure. Understood. And I would...
2:49:57 I'm not sure that we need to leave the job description while I have no problem with it for that specific. If we create this, as I might suggest, one off, the job description would then be tweaked between two different positions. And so I don't know that I would love to hear you amend it so that this doesn't become written in stone. Well, I would, I would. So we can amend it as necessary.
2:50:19 As necessary, I would advise that this job description was a collaborative effort of representatives of the Inyo National Forest, the Humboldt-Tayabi, Morrow County, so there's buy-in to this job description. I've got it, and I think we can get buy-in to, I just don't want to see it written in stone, so this is absolutely what it has to be, and if we say it that way, I believe it does. That's why I entered general.
2:50:42 Job description. We will move forward with this job description if we, as part of our discussions with budgeting and things like that, if we need to make some changes to it, we will debate that at that time. Oh, but what are you saying? That it could be jobs, plural, rather than job? You're saying it may be modified slightly if we do a different type of delivery method? And I heard that in the motion, so I'll second that. Okay. Motion is second. Any further discussion? No.
2:51:12 Oh, good. Okay, roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. The item is agreed to 5-0. Thank you all very much. Thank you to our friends from the county for coming down. And with that, we will move on to... Playground. Item number 10, Approved Funding for the Mammoth Creek Park Inclusive Playground. And that would be Stuart. Thank you, ma'am.
2:51:47 Members of Council, staff, I just want to thank the Council for the opportunity to be here this evening with this great project for the community. I also do want to say that, you know, the new playground will really define, you know, when we talk about our vision, really defines what it means to be the best alpine recreation community in the country. I mean, this inclusive playground will be the first truly inclusive playground in the entire eastern Sierra.
2:52:10 Incorporating those research-based best practices and will also serve as a national demonstration site. So it's a big deal. I mean, this is a great, great playground. They'll do great things for our community. I'm just going to walk through the staff report. I'm not going to spend a lot of time. I'll kind of finalise the recommendations at the end, if that's OK. There's several attachments in the document as well. A lot of those reference the playground images on the wall.
2:52:38 Which have been up for quite some time. We've been through a few reiterations, so I can kind of walk you through a little bit of what that is. Also in that staff report is kind of a final attachment outlining the project cost, so we can kind of walk through that a little bit as well, just to define kind of what we're talking about here, what's kind of in the cost that we're asking for, what's being changed, and then finally we'll kind of go through the final recommendations before you.
2:53:04 So this project started about four years ago. It went through a lot of the community discussion with our Plannual Parks. It also kind of went through Mammoth Lakes Recreation Process when they were talking about the Shane's Inspiration Project, and at that time there was about $500,000 allocated to this project and since being moved into kind of capital projects.
2:53:24 Most recently, you know, it's been part of the Recreation Commission discussion for about two years. And then when we submitted this grant opportunity last year, we received notification of our success and receipt of the award on September 18th. Since that time, we've been working with Game Time, Great Western, our reps to really kind of hone in on the project.
2:53:48 What we wanted kind of in the project, what we wanted out of the project, and that process included a lot of kind of community engagement, and we hosted a very, I think, productive workshop in this room about three months ago to kind of define that. So it's really been a very much community-centric, community-driven project. So where we got to this project was when we originally got the first quote for the complete installation of the playground, it was about a $430,000 project. Obviously that wasn't realistic.
2:54:18 So we've been working over the last six months to really kind of drill down and define based on those community needs what we think is a very still inclusive playground with all the components but something that's scalable for our community and reasonable in cost. So as you work through and you look at the spreadsheet in the back there, we've got it down to the project cost of around $319,000 and then includes many of the items and the
2:54:46 Total project costs just for the structure itself was just about $226,000. So with the grants that we received, $100,000, your council match some existing funds, we have whittled that project cost down to about $75,000. So, you know, over the last six months, I really want to commend all our staff, the commission, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and kind of really kind of drilling down to, you know, get something that we believe is deliverable for the community.
2:55:16 A couple of items that we went through with the Commission over the last several months. We presented this concept to them each month. It's been a standing item probably for the last year. Most recently, on January 9th, we presented what we believe was kind of that total project cost package. And then yesterday, the Commission did endorse and unanimously pass and recommend these motions that you have before you this evening. So it has kind of the full endorsement of the Commission.
2:55:46 They are very interested in, as we all are, on how to really bring this to the fruition in the timeline that we've defined. We've devised and we've created a number of implementation strategies that are in your package to bring this project forward. One of those is a local community fundraising effort. One of those is what's called a supervised community build. This project is pretty unique in regards to if we wanted to have
2:56:12 Game time come in and professional certified installers, it would be $84,000 to put that playground in the ground. It's a heavy cost. What we've been able to do and what we really are looking forward to engaging the community in is the supervised community build, which would bring that cost down to the town of only $10,000. It would, however...
2:56:33 Require 10 to 15 skilled folks a day for a 7 to 10 day period. But we believe that the community is up for that challenge. So that's something we're willing to take on. We're also, one of those recommendations is to submit a Measure R slash Measure U special project.
2:56:48 Special project application for the inclusive tile. The original project had a $50,000 pour in place material for a playground. If you're familiar with that product, it's seen in the schools right now. It's kind of poured in place. It's about a foot deep.
2:57:03 They had kind of encompassing about half the size of the playground area. What we came back and said, well, let's look at kind of enclosing certain structures for the tile surface so anybody in a wheel device can come from the multi-use path, move straight into the surface, get up and get around the playground itself for a cost of only $20,000, which is kind of a recycled rubberized tile laid on concrete. So that's something we believe is more sustainable for our environment.
2:57:33 So we're looking at kind of submitting that request. And then we do have another grant opportunity that we're looking at submitting in the next month. It's called a Meet Me at the Park. It's actually an NRPA. It's a national grant application process. Extremely competitive. Only award 25 projects across the country. But we feel like we want to at least participate in that process. You never know how these projects will be received as well.
2:58:02 And finally, before I kind of move on to those five recommendations, the installation timeline is laid out in front of you. It's on page 192. Lots of moving parts, but we believe we can, with your approval and direction this evening, move into a lot of the pre-planning. As I said, the first workshop and the first item that we want to kick off is that special meeting tomorrow evening with the commission.
2:58:28 Mammoth Lakes Recreation. That's really to help us with this kind of multi-project work through who's doing what, the roles, responsibilities and expectations of each of those organizations. I think it's really important as we move through because it does take a community to build these projects.
2:58:44 So the schedule's laid out that we would be removing the existing playground in May, preparing the site, installing the structure and that community build process in June, doing all the tile, installing the wood, engineered wood fibre in June, and then if everything goes well, we would be cutting that ribbon on July 4th, which would be, you know, a great, great moment for the community, probably right before the, you know, Pops in the Park event, after the parade, but...
2:59:13 Don't want to get ahead of ourselves, but we do want to kind of put a pretty aggressive timeline out there so we can kind of keep everybody on task. So before you, we have five recommendations. One of those is to authorise staff to purchase the new inclusive playground structure, and that's in the amount of $126,000, $766.25, and we have those monies in hand. The second one is to authorise staff to work with Mammoth Lakes Recreation on the local community fundraising program.
2:59:42 And supervised community build option. Three is to authorise staff to submit a special projects funding application in the amount of $20,000 to Mammoth Lakes Recreation for the inclusive playground surfacing. Four is to authorise staff to submit the 2018 NRPA Disney Play Spaces grant application. And finally, allocate up to $75,000 of uncommitted reserves from the fiscal year 2017-18 mid-year budget to complete the installation of the playground.
3:00:11 We believe by July 4th. So in a nutshell, that's about four years encapsulated in about, you know, five minutes. Hopefully you've done a pretty good job. Happy to answer any questions. I know Betsy, Chair of the Recreation Commission, is here. Matt's also here from Mammoth Lakes Recreation, so happy to answer any questions. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. So any questions from Council? Go ahead. I don't. Oh, you don't. I was going to ask.
3:00:41 Looking at the timeline, is the reason why we're being a little dyslexic about building in that area right now, when do you have to use the funds, the grant funds? What's the date for that? Yeah, so, that's a good question, thank you. So, the original grant application specified that the playground had to be in the ground in March.
3:01:11 So we received an extension on that based on our typical winter environment. And they've given us through summer to install the playground because there is a kind of research component they want to use and incorporate in their findings. So right now we do have a little bit of latitude with the grant, but the expectation is to have this installed by summer. And what's the probability of the cost increasing?
3:01:41 For the playground. Yeah, so the playground already includes an increase of $7,500 that was factored in that we were aware of at the time. So we've already included that in our estimates here. But we're still needing $75,000 of uncommitted reserves from the town. That's to install the playground. So the structure itself was $226,000.
3:02:06 And then the remaining funds, if you can kind of walk through that little spreadsheet there, we've taken out the inclusive components because we believe that would be a good fundraising opportunity. So the unfunded balance is about $75,000. Okay, now, how do you see it playing out with the, if the multi-use facility is going forward? There's going to be a lot of construction going on, I would imagine. I don't know, trucks going back and forth.
3:02:34 Kids have already proven that they like the rocks better than the play equipment that they have there. I think the noise, the dust, the dirt, some of the other aspects is going to, it just makes, if that's going to be back there, it makes a lot more sense to build back there and then build the front section. Do you really not see any kind of conflict with
3:03:03 Perhaps a very major construction going on. How many feet away from the playground? I'll answer the question, I think, in a general term to say that public safety has to be the number one priority from the town's perspective.
3:03:21 So if there's any, yep, absolutely. So if there's any risk to any of the public, you know, based on the construction, you know, that we'll do what we need to do to make sure that, you know, everybody's safe in that park. Would that include up to closing the park until the construction's done? That could include temporary time, you know, again, until we, you know, firm up that schedule. You know, it could include any of those items. It's probably a bit premature to kind of specifically speak to those, but if we keep top of mind as public safety and then at some point that...
3:03:48 Playground might have to be partitioned off, fenced off, secured, you know, during a site grading period of time, then that's what it would take. Make a playground and then build a cage around it, so that's... Public safety's first, so whatever we deem is necessary at that time, but, you know, and, I mean, you know, a little bit of this project, as you know, is all Mammoth Creek Park, so, you know, this playground is a major component, you know, of that facility, so we'll do whatever we can to it.
3:04:17 Make sure everybody's safe. Those are my questions. Good questions. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions over here? I have statements, but no questions. For deliberation. Okay. I've just got to, in terms of how the funding is laid out here, if, I mean, what happens, is the opening date dependent upon a successful grant application to Disney? Nope. Okay. Is it dependent on a successful application to Measure R and Measure U? Nope.
3:04:48 Okay. So even if those additional funding sources don't come forward, do you think we could hit all these things and still get the thing on by July 4th? Yes. All right. Thank you. Those are my questions. We're good here for the moment. Any thoughts from the public? Good evening, Council. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. I really want to commend staff for all of the work that they've done on this project.
3:05:16 Obviously, I'm very much in favor, but the commission is very supportive. The Mayor Pro Tem actually brings up good questions. When we were considering whether or not to apply for the CPRS and Game Time grant, we actually had conversations with, you know, with Hayes as the project manager for the multi-use facility about, you know, is this feasible that we could put this in and then, you know, have this other large project going on at the same time? And his answer to that was yes. So I'm pretty comfortable that we can accommodate.
3:05:46 You know, temporary closures, whatever we need to do, since we did receive the grant, and we do need to move forward with installing the playground in order to not lose that $100,000 and the national demonstration site designation.
3:06:00 The only thing I really want to add is just coming out of Plan Your Parks, we had a lot of advocates really excited for the community benefit of this project. We were initially looking at a Shane's Inspiration, really large-scale project. I think this is a good way to deliver something suitable for our community to meet those needs without spending $500,000 to $1 million. Any questions? I don't think so. Any questions? No. Good. Thank you very much. Anybody else?
3:06:27 Seeing none, we'll bring it back up here for thoughts. I guess, Bill, you got some thoughts? I do. I'm excited about the community build part. I had a family member get me involved with, and I think it may have been the same company, with a community built park in Sacramento that was probably a hundred times the size of what we're doing here. I took a friend over for our two days of volunteering and stayed for five. It is a huge community builder.
3:06:55 If you can get the people to come out and get committed to it. So I'm really excited to see that go forward. That's my positive. Now, you know I've got to have a negative here, too. So I am fully in favor of this. This needs to move forward. This is something that goes back a whole lot of years. This isn't new. However, the 75,000, we keep seeing this uncommitted reserves. So for everything that we have committed and are being asked to commit to those uncommitted reserves,
3:07:25 We have to maintain a three-year average of incomes over the next five months to have this uncommitted reserve. If we don't achieve that, it really isn't there, and we're going to start pulling out of other reserves to meet this. So I would like, for one, at this point, until we go through the budget process, to quit allocating things to uncommitted reserves. If you go out and do a five-year average, we will not meet our budget expectations at this point.
3:07:54 So, that's my take. The finance director is still back there. So, yeah, hugely important project. I want this thing to move forward. I would even be willing to make the motion on it, being from recreation, but I'd just caution us moving on to other things outside of the budget cycle. We're killing ourselves. Okay. Okay, anybody else, Colin? Any thoughts?
3:08:18 I think fair statements there. I want to thank Recreation Commission MLR staff for doing a tremendous job on this. I mean, this is something we've been looking at pretty seriously for a number of years. If my memory serves correctly, when we really started this conversation with Shane's inspiration, that price tag was around a million dollars. So I think the merits of this project are absolutely there.
3:08:45 And I think that staff and all those partners have done a great job of going out and seeking and securing this grant, which makes this possible with scaling this to a reasonable project that we can implement. I think the concern...
3:09:03 You know, that you brought up, Bill, is very valid. But I think I'm comfortable moving forward with this as a one-time expenditure. Cleland, I think the comments you had as well are valid, you know, thinking about just the construction cycle. But to me, you know, we have an existing playground there. We're going to do the work to upgrade it and make it inclusive, regardless of whether we leave an existing playground or whether we add an inclusive, you know, feature playground.
3:09:31 If it warrants closing that portion of the park for a time period, then that's going to be the case either way. So I don't think that's a reason to not move forward with this, especially based on the constraints of the grant. So, you know, I think this is a really exciting thing for the community. I think us moving this forward is honestly kind of a no-brainer from my perspective. So I'm good with it. Good. Thank you. Shields? I'm very supportive. I say let's get it done. $75,000.
3:09:59 We'll find it someplace, and I'm excited about the community build aspect of it. I think it could be something that would really bring our community together. I look forward to seeing all you guys there. I'm going to be there. I'm not very handy, but I'll be there. I'm not very capable anymore, but I'll probably be there. We'll both be there. I would love for people just...
3:10:21 On everything that we're doing, going back to the $75,000 and the unallocated funds. I mean, seriously, we have got to start really just nickel and diming ourselves to death. That is just my main concern about the playground is it's just another thing that we don't have the funding.
3:10:40 That everything starts out and it's like, oh, it's going to be funded and then once again we're just short on yet another project. So I'm very supportive, especially because it's going to have access for children who wouldn't normally be able to go to the playground as it is now. So I'm very much in favor of that. But you do also have to realize, too, that due to some of the ADA, during that time the playground has been getting money.
3:11:07 We just put new equipment in there eight years ago, seven years ago. And so, you know, that's going out. So I just want people just to realize that it's, you know, these things, they're great ideas, but they're all costing us money that we may or may not have. Okay, thanks. I support this.
3:11:31 I'm hearing the next item is going to be the budget item, and I think that in our discussion of budget going forward this evening, I think that we're all looking forward to a very engaged and open and thorough discussion of the budget going forward, and I think that when we look at
3:11:55 I plan on making a motion on the whole thing.
3:12:23 We can? Okay. So, Bill, if you'd like to make a motion. I would like to make a motion to authorize staff to purchase the new inclusive playground structure in the amount of $126,766.25, authorize staff to work with Mammoth Lakes Recreation in the local community fundraising program and supervise community build options, authorize staff to submit a special project funding application in the amount of $20,000 to Mammoth Lakes Recreation for inclusive...
3:12:51 Playground servicing. Authorize staff to submit the 2018 NRPA Disney Play Spaces grant application and allocate up to $75,000 of uncommitted reserves from the fiscal 17-18 mid-year budget review process to complete the installation of the national demonstration site playground.
3:13:16 And Bill, I'd like to second that. I'd like to add just two things. One is I'm wondering, I'd like staff to come up with dates for the community build, a proposed date program for that. I mean, we've been struggling through the momentum process and other things to get a calendar of what the summer events look like, but maybe a date range of when that's going to be proposed so people can schedule around that so we can leverage the resources for that.
3:13:38 And also just a friendly, I know this is important to staff as well, but when projects come forward for consideration by council, that they are all in numbers. We're not looking at a bid number that things may get added on next to what I think is certainly going forward in a current situation that the council is really being presented with all in budget numbers. That's not part of the motion, though, is it? I would add those two things to the motion. The other one is more just a direction and comment. We're really not doing anything at that point, so.
3:14:08 The adding in identifying dates to the community build is fine. The other one would not. Okay, fine. Let's just stick with dates for the community build. Are you willing to amend? If you're comfortable with that. We need dates. I'll go with that one. All right. So we have a motion, a second. Any further discussion? Hearing none. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Farney? Yes. Councilmember Richards? Yes. Councilmember Salzer? Yep. Yes.
3:14:34 Yes, motion is agreed to 5-0. Thank you, staff. Thank you. Need a break? We'll take five minutes, and then we'll crunch numbers. Thank you. Crunch numbers. Crunch numbers. Not eat anything so I don't throw up. Do you need some food? No, I mean, crunching numbers. And we're going to move on to, we're going to talk budget. Okay, so we're going to move on now to the second quarter fiscal year 2017-2018 budget review.
3:15:19 Rob. Yes, thank you. So I handed out what is my staff report, which somehow was in the printed copy that I received, and I do apologize for that. I'm certain that since I'm a numbers guy and words are a challenge for me at times, I'm certain it was my fault why they didn't get in there, but you all have a copy of it now, and I hope that it provides you good reading later on.
3:15:45 So yes, part of this, the budget discussion or our budget procedures require that we come and discuss them four times a year with council. And that's just good practice. I think especially based upon the fact that we do budget conservatively on our TOT number in the beginning of the year, I think it requires us to be very nimble and react to changes as they come through the year. So what you have
3:16:15 Before you is what I think is a conservative number. I know I've heard some comments tonight about that. We can certainly discuss it a little bit further. But we've had a very, very strong performance year to date. So the numbers that I put here in front of you, I'm requesting that we authorize another million dollar, we realize an additional million dollars for budgeting TOT dollars.
3:16:41 And Bill did quote some numbers.
3:17:10 That Dan had put together, we'd done some review on this, that the average for the last five years is around 7.4 million, leaving in total the very strong years of the last two years. If I take the top and the bottom out of that number, it drops to about 7.1 million. In order to hit our budget of 14.9, we need 6.9. So we would have to have a pretty strong drop even below those averages.
3:17:39 For the next few months. In discussions with some of the lodging community in some of our meetings, they anticipate January to be fairly strong. February is also, bookings are not too bad. Beyond that, we don't really have a good sense. So I think some of our stronger months, there's opportunity, but I don't believe that going out at 14.9 is reckless. I believe that to be good.
3:18:10 So on that discussion on this particular, is there any further comments you guys would like to do? I'd like to kind of make this an interactive as we go through. Just one observation is the money, the additional million dollars, this is realized, TOT, we're essentially putting it in the bank because it's already been realized. Yeah, when I talk about, it's sort of realizing it so that we have it available, if you will. And that's kind of what, when I talked about being,
3:18:39 Being nimble on our conservative budget is when we realize things are doing well, we need to react to it. It's not a projection. This is based on actuals. That is correct. Based on actual projections. No. No. So it does rely on the rest of the year hitting the original $12.5 million budget. That is the only assumption that's in there. Otherwise,
3:19:06 The months that we've had so far are what we're realizing. Right. So the money isn't in the bank. It will be in the bank if we hit our budget projections. Not really. No, not really. The money is in the bank. It goes away if we don't hit our budget projections moving forward, potentially, if we have to balance back against it. But it's in the bank, and it's realized as of today. Bad things can happen going forward. But as we're sitting right now,
3:19:36 It's in, it's realized, it's there. Right. We'll see what happens going forward. Exceeded our estimation of the first six months. Yeah, exactly. I understand that. However, when I look out my door, I see brown. Understood. February, March, April could be. I think February as a whole. I'm really concerned about March and April because they're down months anyway. Okay, so Rob, I think we're good with that. Perfect. Moving on.
3:20:09 To additional revenue, so I'm talking about revenues at this point, so TOT obviously the largest one. When we went through this review, we like to be fairly conservative in realizing other funds unless they're really significant. So what I have in front of you is not all of our revenue excesses over budget, but these are the ones that are fairly significant and need to be realized. So when we come back in the third quarter, there'll be more
3:20:37 discussion around additional revenue items, hopefully at that point, as well as a deeper dive into some of the expenses. But right now, these items are truly taking us to where we have actual dollars over budget. So there's no estimations in these. These are truly items that have exceeded our budget.
3:20:57 You can see that the details that are out there and the reasons behind them, a lot of it is the TOT enforcement efforts are going very strongly. And then the building division, our building permits are up. And in discussion with the community development team, they do anticipate that now and in the future as opportunities come for building. So all in, our general fund revenue increase is $1.324 million, the million dollars being TOT.
3:21:26 And then the remainder being these smaller amounts. I don't think I have it on the slide, but I will talk about the TOT excess. The measure A, the political commitments, requires that those dollars in excess of our budgeted TOT be allocated to reserve accounts specific to transit, housing, and tourism. And I do have that, I think, on a summary slide here.
3:21:56 I am requesting that we sort of authorize and realize those numbers in that. So you'll see some of that in a little bit. Still in the general fund, we have some expenditures and some capital projects to discuss. Again, really sort of looking through.
3:22:18 Based on the fact that we have a lot of brown out there and not much white, we haven't spent a lot on our snow removal, which, if you remember this time last year, we were talking about how much we were in excess on that. So we do have budgeted dollars associated with those that we should expect some savings in, which, of course, if it's for snow removal solely, it does remain in Fund 210 in order to be used for that purpose in future years.
3:22:45 In all general areas we have, we should expect to see some savings and expense because we just haven't had a lot to do. The one area of note, I discussed the building permit. So the building division has anticipated a need for, and this is contract services where we hire out people to do the inspections and some of the other work around plans and reviews. We've got a shortfall in that.
3:23:13 Budgetary item. We think $57,000 will get us through the end of the year. So that's the loan expense item that I'm bringing forward to you today to review. The other two items or three items are capital projects, the first one being the police facility. Now, the police facility itself is not yet
3:23:36 In closeout phase, I mean, we're working on, it's really, it's an final phase of closeout, but there's some outstanding items that we're working on and that are under discussion with the contractor for resolution. And so that will be, that needs to be finalized before we close this out. But the approved budget and the bid award, we think we need another $250,000 to accomplish that. So that is in front of you today, which is a $250,000 request.
3:24:04 For the police facility. We have Volcom Skate Park, which we had on a previous closeout report, and we had a couple of trailing invoices or identified items that had come in, so there's another 3,000 associated with that. So capital projects that are current, it's $253,303 as a request. And then just moments ago, you discussed the $75,000 for Mammoth Creek Park.
3:24:34 And I'm bringing that forward here as well. So that's with the $75,000. So total capital projects, it's $328,303. Any questions on that? In the general fund recap, I'm bringing forward, you know, we've discussed revenues. So the million dollars in TOT, the $324,000 and other revenues. Here's where I discuss the allocations. Transit receiving another $156,923, as well as housing and tourism, the $433,846.
3:25:07 So that total allocation 747,692. And then the expenditures that I just discussed, the 57,000 general fund for building division as well as capital projects of 328,303 brings that total request to 385,303. The net unallocated additional general fund revenue is 191,004. So those are dollars that we have realized that are
3:25:37 Not being asked to be allocated. Some of the conversations we had earlier about the general, the, the TOT expected receipts going forward, this 191 is a little bit of a cushion in that as those dollars are in the bank currently, so when I talk about hitting the budget of 14.9, we've got maybe 200,000 or so of wiggle room because that number is already in the, in the bank. Hope that makes sense.
3:26:06 Any questions about this general fund recap? Rob, on the allocation section, transit, housing, tourism, that 747 is going to the joint buckets? Correct, that's the reserve. Specifically for the tourism, joint bucket, housing, transit, correct? That's correct. Thank you. One other item to discuss then is the gas tax revenue.
3:26:31 Gas tax is one of those interesting things. We look at the expenses of last year's snow removal, and that affects the dollars of available revenue we will receive as a reimbursement this coming year. So when we went through the budget process, we did realize some money, but we are fairly conservative in that as well. We just went through an audit with our
3:26:55 The State Comptroller's Office, who came by, did a thorough review of all of our expenses, and we have great reviews, by the way. They loved the accounting process, not to toot my own horn, but really Cindy Myrold's responsibility to handle that. She did an excellent job with it. We ended up realizing another $406,148 in revenue. So that's an adjustment we need to make to the budget for this year, and that's a real positive one.
3:27:23 That has some allocations as well because of the different assessment districts that do snow removal. So I've highlighted those there before you. That's another $59,000 that are just funds that are going to be allocated to those of budget assessment districts. But net increase in general in the gas tax fund balance of $346,502. That's available for road rehab, snow removal, future items like that.
3:27:53 And then just this one final sort of staff recommendation to try to wrap it all up for you. It's really just realizing the revenues that we discussed, the expenses that we talked about for general fund, and then the gas tax revenue. That's really it for discussion purposes. And that's on the staff recommendation. And that's the presentation.
3:28:18 So real quick, on the last slide, the difference between the revenue increase, expenditure increase is the 191-004? That's correct. And where will those dollars live? So each of these dollars were highlighted in here at budget adjustments associated with where they will go. The 191 lives in fund balance, which is just undesignated sitting in general fund 100. That's fine. Okay. Thank you. Any questions from Council?
3:28:47 Nope. Any thoughts or comments from the public? Hearing, seeing none. Let's provide a motion. Is a motion needed? Yes. Yes. Anybody want to make a motion? I'll make a motion to receive the second quarter budget report and adopt proposed resolution amending the fiscal year 17-18 budget as recommended on attachment A, budget adjustments. Thank you. Is there a second? I'll second.
3:29:21 Thank you. Any further discussion? Hearing none, Jamie, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item is agreed to 5-0. Thank you very much. Once again, I think we all want to commend staff on the straightforward, simple, easy-to-digest way this is presented. I know there may be some difficult decisions, but at least I think we can know that we're going to get the information in a...
3:29:50 Not necessarily easy to digest for them, but a way that helps make a decision-making clearer. So thank you for that. Thank you. I commend them. I have been looking at this town's budget since long before I became a council member. And finally, as a business person, I can almost understand what's going on through them. So this is huge. I don't want to swell anybody's head, but thank you. No, it's a very big and important improvement. So item number 12 was pulled.
3:30:20 So then we are at item number 13, Councilmember Reports. Who wants to start? Kick it off. Okay. Only a couple of items for me. On Monday, January 22nd, the mayor and myself join staff for just a follow-up meeting on some cannabis stuff. You know, I just want to...
3:30:45 Thanks, staff, for pulling this stuff together and putting an aggressive timeline together. I know this is urgent for us to address, and Nolan especially has done a tremendous amount of work to get us up to speed and move this thing forward, so looking forward to that over the next couple of weeks. And then, as was already mentioned tonight, I did attend the OR show in Denver for about a week.
3:31:12 At the end of January and you know I'm there for a little bit different perspective than the outdoor public lands discussions mostly on a business perspective but John and I did have a chance to catch up and go over some things so it was it was interesting for me as somebody that's gone to that show for
3:31:32 I guess 10 years now. It's always been very, you know, ski industry focused. And now, you know, with the blending of SIA and OR, it's got a whole different feel to it. A lot of discussion around, you know, climate change and public lands and advocacy, which was a cool piece to add to that. So really productive week. Got to spend a few days in Denver handling business and at the show and then a couple of days on snow at Copper.
3:32:02 For the outdoor industry, and that's it for me. Excellent. Thank you. Bill? I have had several meetings with staff on the cannabis issues and others as well, and I do commend them and thank them for their time. I attended the LAFCO meeting today, and it was far more contentious and long than I ever would have imagined it could have been with what was before us, but we got through it, and the water district has annexed the two parcels out here for Snow Creek 8.
3:32:33 So that is a done deal. Okay. Is it? Is it? Good. Shields? Yeah. On January 24th, I attended Hannah DeGuey's farewell deal. It's the chief's assistant or rep's assistant. On the 25th, I attended the wounded warrior lunch up at the mountain, which was very well attended, but I didn't get to spend the whole time there because
3:33:02 Also that day and the next day spent some time with the FAA, which was in town, visiting the Mammoth Airport and Bishop Airports. And then on the 6th did the cannabis workshop here. So that's all I have. Good. Thank you. Cleland. Okay. On the 19th, there was an estimating and not much to report out of there.
3:33:26 Kirk was there. Was there anything I'm missing that I should be talking about there? Then on January 25th, there was a CPT meeting. And if anybody ever wants to go to a really fun meeting, it's an open meeting, a public meeting. And we get everybody from Caltrans to the different Forest Service, BLM.
3:33:51 Town, County, you get to, from Pickle Meadows we even get reports and it's a really good way to see what's going on with all the entities and how we're working together. And everybody seemed to be in a pretty good place. One thing I have to say that fascinated me is the Marines that are in Pickle Meadows. At some point you've got to ask the head guy there.
3:34:20 Doug about what he puts those guys through because it was quite interesting to see some of their cold weather training. Cold weather training. So I guess that's not too political, but it was really neat. And then I guess that's it. Okay. I'll go through my usual kind of list. January 24th, I attended a meeting with the Governor's Office of Planning and Research. This has to do with it.
3:34:50 Climate Change Technical Advisory Council that I've been asked to participate in. I'm there on behalf of the town. They'll be covering travel expenses, but not some other stuff. I'll talk with town staff about that. Same day, I attended the Sierra Nevada Conservancy as having a strategic planning review, which is pretty interesting, and it fed into some things. I'll talk about the outdoor retailer.
3:35:13 Things that happened there. I also met with the new Director of the U.S. Department of Agriculture's Rural Development Program. This is Kim Dolbo-Van. And in that item, we were talking about that recreation position. There's a very interesting report in there that makes a nexus between partnerships between U.S. Forest Service and rural counties and how that can privilege us to leverage and access significant opportunities with USDA rural development. They're sitting on a portfolio of about 200 and some odd billion dollars worth of stuff. So that's kind of interesting.
3:35:42 Outdoor retailer. I was there from the 25th to 28th. I covered the airfare of the town and helped out with some lodging and some incidental travel expenses. Met with the chief of the Forest Service, Tony Took. Attended with Matt the item on the outdoor recreation partnership to get an outdoor recreation director in California. Met with the Wilderness Society about opportunities to engage the wilderness things around the town of Mammoth Lakes.
3:36:09 They may be coming down here in mid-May to start doing an assessment of what our opportunities look like and maybe we get some support for the already designated wilderness areas. They're interested in pursuing that. Met with some economists from PAL, Protect Our Winters, who are making presentations to the governor of Colorado about the fate of the California ski industry, which I thought was kind of interesting, especially in light of the fact that the consistent refrain from people there at OR was, well, where's California?
3:36:34 Where is California? We got Wyoming, Utah, Montana, all the intermountain states are organized and they're rallying behind their outdoor recreation economies. And the question is, where is California? Which I thought was kind of interesting. The SNC advised that they may be looking at the Eastern Sierra as being kind of a recreation, kind of a test case. I think some of the work we're doing with these partnerships could feed into that, which could help leverage money not only out of the state. All these SB 5, Prop 68 monies will be going through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. That could be some big opportunities for us.
3:37:03 I think the degree to which we're demonstrating partnership and doing that kind of stuff could help us with those things. Went to a bunch of Colorado marijuana retail outlets. I saw Colin at a bunch of them, but I won't talk about that. Research? Yeah, R&D. R&D. Attended the LTC meeting on the 29th. Chairman, sorry, Supervisor Stump gave some advice on Larry Johnson's condition, which is not sounding good. And he's requested that...
3:37:30 At the appropriate time that the town council consider a resolution acknowledging his service and those kinds of issues, but I'm sure we'll get that at the appropriate time to deal with that. Wendy Sigimura is the acting head of the county's community development department. Mono County is doing a bunch of county line adjustments. You want to go back to LTC and tell me you're the chairman? Oh, yeah. Mammoth Lakes is now the chair of the LTC. Shields is, yeah, pointing at me, so I get a couple of gavels.
3:37:59 Mona County is pursuing county line adjustments with Madera down in Devil's Post File, which is significant to us. It's been since for years. Yeah, so the road, the flap grant we've got down there, that's going to be important. And the town is applying for a sustainable community grant with Caltransit. I think we're probably in the cusp of getting that. This will help with the walk, bike, ride thing for transit hub development and those kinds of things. That'll be helpful.
3:38:27 Attended the TOT meeting, which was interesting. The numbers, again, it's interesting what's going on with that so far year-to-date. It's going to be interesting what happens forward, but so far it's interesting. Attended the U.S. Forest Service ID team meeting with Joel, members of the TRAILS team. There's just been, as you saw, the announcement of the paper, John Regalberger has been reassigned.
3:38:48 There's new staff there and the entire, I don't know, was there with Sandra, there was 10 different Forest Service staff people in the room looking at that Sherwin Area Recreation Plan and moving forward that aggressively and we may be building a lot of trails out there for many years to come, which is interesting. Attended the MLH board meeting where we reviewed the MLH monthly status report.
3:39:10 The Mammoth Lakes Housing Year in Review, Review of the Board Input Opportunities Timeline. Jennifer has announced that she is running for the Board of Supervisors, and I think the MLH Board will be interested to, we may be having a special meeting once it's clear what the slate of candidates is like, whether she runs unopposed, whether she runs with, to help deal with the secession issues with MLH.
3:39:35 There was a lot of discussion about the MLH contract with Town of Mammoth Lakes, and I appreciate the town manager who's pulled the item we're looking at tonight. I think the town needs to, we need to do some regrouping around that, and I think MLH may need to do that as well. I think housing is such an important thing that we need to do everything we can to get it right. And there's an update of the procurement of the shady rest parcel, and Mr. Stapp gave a nice kind of an overview of what's involved in doing those kinds of things, which was interesting.
3:40:03 I was with all of you on the cannabis regulatory framework thing. I really, again, appreciate staff's work and all of our work. We got through that thing pretty efficiently, and I think the research that Colin and I were doing in Denver, I think this all lines up nicely. Is that blue air research? What's that? Nothing. We'll talk about it. Today I attended the Long Valley Hydrologic Advisory Committee. Sandra was there also.
3:40:28 The Water District has made representations that there's new data and new information informing what's going on. I'm not a scientist. I don't know exactly what was going on, but I didn't hear anything today other than there's still a lot of scientific data gathering and disputes going on. It's not clear that, you know, so that saga continues. And then I was at the Marlowe County presentation on the tax issue for cannabis.
3:40:56 And I think it's, you know, it's difficult for the county to be doing one thing in a couple hours and we're doing it a couple hours later, but I'm confident that we can all work together and kind of reconcile what we can reconcile with the county and come up with a program going forward. So that's it for me. One more thing. Sure, of course. Go.
3:41:15 Cleland mentioned the people from the Mountain Warfare Training Center. And just by dumb luck, I stumbled across a Weather Channel program the other day that was a documentary on the Mountain Warfare Training Center. I've spent some time up there on my machine, if you will, and I have also met with a couple different commanders from up there, and what they do is incredible. And I don't know if you can look it up in their archives and stream it or not, but if you don't know what they do and how they do it,
3:41:44 Very informative program to see, yeah. That was Weather Channel. That was, I believe that was the Weather Channel, yeah. Yeah, it was way amazing, yeah. Okay. Good, thanks for that. I could not do what any of those people thought there, believe me, and never would have been able to. Okay, so I believe that's the last item of the regular agenda, is that correct? We need to adjourn to a closed session. We'll now adjourn to a closed session. So thank you all very much. Thanks for coming. And our next meeting will be February 21st.
3:42:14 February 21st. So thank you all. They got really lucky when they filmed that thing.