TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2018

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 1 hr 6 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

135 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:50 He emailed me and said he was going to see. Good afternoon. I would like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, February 28th. Roll call, please. Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Eckert. Here. Vice Chair Vanderhurst. Here. Chair Callahan. Yes. Can we rise for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.

2:44 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. First order of business is public comment for anyone wishing to speak on an item not on the agenda. And I hear crickets. So no public comment today. We'll close the public comment period and move on to our first...

3:06 Order of Business, which is a public hearing to consider recommending to Town Council approval of Zoning Code Amendment 17-001 to amend the Town's cannabis regulations. And Nolan is giving our report today. Great. Thank you. So just a real quick kind of overview of how we got to this point. Prop 64 was passed in November 2016, which legalized recreational cannabis for adults and also allowed

3:37 for additional cannabis retailers and other uses to be established. Since 2016, staff has been working on the regulatory framework for cannabis. Our workshop was held February 6th with the town council to walk through the proposed regulations and provide an opportunity for public feedback and input. Comments received at that workshop were incorporated into the regulations being considered today.

4:04 And on February 7th and the 21st, the Town Council held a workshop specific to the cannabis tax ordinance and the proposed ballot measure for the June ballot. On the proposed tax rates that were approved via resolution on the 21st included a range of 1% to 8% for retailers with an initial rate of 4%.

4:29 A range of 1% to 4% for manufacturers, cultivators, and distributors with an initial rate of 2% and a range of 1% to 4% for testing labs with an initial rate of 1%. And then today the PEDC is considering the proposed land use regulations. They are being asked to provide a recommendation to the Town Council. Upon the action of today's meeting,

4:58 On March 13th, the Town Council will then be considering the cannabis regulations. That item is proposed to be an urgency ordinance, which if adopted, they will allow the regulations to become effective immediately. The Town's proposed cannabis regulations and requirements follow closely with the state regulations and requirements. At the state level, there are three agencies tasked with the licensing and regulating commercial cannabis activity.

5:32 They're responsible for retailers, distributors, and testing labs. You have the California Public Health Manufactured Cannabis Safety Branch. They're responsible for the manufacturers that make the cannabis products. Then you have the California Department of Food and Ag Cannabis Cultivation Licensing Division. They're tasked with cultivation and track and trace system.

5:57 In addition to just creating the regulations, they also have an enforcement arm for all the cannabis industry. It's similar to the alcohol beverage control. So real quick, are there any questions from the commission or public on the overview or how we got to this point? Nope. Nope. Great. So now, as you're going into the regulations within the packet, they're in the resolution, exhibit A, B, and C.

6:29 So at the January 17th and February 6th Town Council workshops, three different buffer scenarios for where cannabis retailers could be located were presented to the council. The three options were developed with the cannabis working group during meetings the end of 2016. The consensus from, or 2017, I'm sorry. The consensus from the council was to proceed with option C, which would require cannabis retailers to maintain a 600-foot buffer from schools, daycare centers,

6:58 in youth centers, in public parks, and require a 500 foot separation between cannabis retailers. The separation requirement would apply to all cannabis retailers and is not specific to medicinal or adult use retailers. Option C was the most restrictive of the three options and was developed based on the analysis that staff did of peer resorts in Colorado and a review of those issues they encountered.

7:23 In Colorado, the issues arose from having retailers too close to one another and not from having too many retailers in the market. Under this proposed scenario, cannabis retailers could be located in the two locations where they currently are, on Laurel Mountain and in the Outlet Mall along Main Street, and then a small area here on Center Street, an area at the south end of Laurel Mountain, a small area here,

7:53 Near Oak Tree, and in this corner here near Old Mammoth Road and Tavern Road. Under this scenario, just based on the map area alone, there is potential that five to six retailers could be established in town, but when you look at the uses that exist in these locations and the lack of available space, a maximum of one to two additional retailers would be the likely result. They're saying in here,

8:23 Throughout this area, you already have other uses that would conflict or restrict a cannabis retailer from establishing such as condos, apartments, any establishment that sells alcohol or tobacco products, a town-owned property, and then you do have this one blue parcel up here that I didn't talk about because that is the post office property. Okay. I have a question just regarding the daycare centers. How do you determine which

8:54 Of the daycare center, which daycare providers you have included? It's the state licensed daycare centers. So in-home daycare centers don't? Those ones are specifically excluded from it. Okay. At the state regulations. I was just curious. Yeah. What was the problem in the peer resorts where if it wasn't that they had too many retailers that they were clustered or what was the issue? So one specific was Telluride where they've historically had

9:20 Four retailers since they originally created even medicinal ones over the last decade. Over the last year, a new one opened up that was directly beneath one of the other ones. And then you started to have some impacts of loitering and just a concentrated amount of people going to those two stores. Also the two stores, the one existing one did not like the new one opening up directly beneath them. That's really not kind of...

9:48 Something that we would look at from the land use regulations more just on, you know, do we want these spread out throughout town or clustered in one area? And also in Vail, they took the approach to prohibit them in the town of Vail, but then directly outside of Vail, within the unincorporated area, which is five minutes from their downtown, they have six to eight cannabis retailers in a one block area. And there's just a lot of traffic and others going right to that specific spot.

10:15 And then it's all going back into Vail. So their prohibition was really not very effective. Okay. And Nolan, the village wouldn't be considered a commercially zoned area. Is that correct? No. So any changes to the village would require an amendment to the North Village specific plan. Then within the village commercial area, there's a daycare center right there in the middle of it. And then the community center would be considered a use center as well, which with these buffers would...

10:46 Take out that whole area. And so that daycare is a state licensed daycare. It is a state licensed daycare. Looking at kind of the buffers, it didn't, based on what would be restricted, it didn't really make sense to go through a specific plan amendment to consider allowing it within the North Village specific plan area. Because of those two buffer radiuses. There's a pre-existing retailer and a subsequent daycare center comes in. Are they going to have a problem renewing?

11:16 No, they, it's, when they go for licensing at the state level, that's when the, whatever's existing at that time, when they go for their initial licensing. So if one were to locate, if a daycare center is to relocate next to a cannabis retailer, that cannabis retailer is essentially grandfathered, as long as they don't move to a different location there. What if they wanted to expand?

11:44 Expand to another space or expand. Like adjacent space or add on to their permit or something. Would it preclude them from doing something like that? I do not believe so. I mean, our regulations wouldn't preclude them from doing that. And the state regulations, since it still would be the same license, it would just be an expansion of their premises or their kind of approval. It's not a new license then. Okay. So this table here is just elaborating on the

12:16 For within the commercial zoning districts, which uses would be allowed? Within the downtown and Old Mammoth Road districts, the only commercial cannabis activities that would be permitted are adult use in medicinal cannabis retailers. Cannabis businesses would remain prohibited in the mixed lodging residential zone as they currently are today. Also, cannabis delivery to consumers in cultivation, manufacturing, distribution, and testing facilities would be prohibited within the commercial zone.

12:46 I'll discuss this a little further in detail. Some allowance for minimal cultivation and manufacturing that's accessory to a retailer. That's consistent with what we currently allow. The retailer uses would be limited to the areas in blue that were shown on the previous map. The text in the table on this one just shows what the proposed changes, the additions and deletions. It's important to note that medical marijuana cooperatives, that text has been deleted throughout the zoning code.

13:16 Use is no longer supported by the state regulations. They've gone away from the cooperative model and now it's just medicinal retailers and adult use actions. So are there any questions on the uses? So then moving on to the industrial zone. For this zone, the recommendation was to just use the state buffers of 600 feet from schools, daycare centers, and use centers.

13:48 As shown on the map, none of those buffers would impact or restrict the areas in the industrial zoning district. These uses did not include the public parks buffer or separation requirement from one another since all the uses in this zone are not open to the public and no direct sales to the public are permitted so you wouldn't have the impact of someone going into one of these establishments purchasing their cannabis and going to Trails End Park to the skate park which is adjacent to it.

14:18 The map here does show the locations of the existing approved businesses in the industrial park. You have a manufacturing facility right here. You have a storage facility over here. And then you also have another manufacturing facility here. These were approved over the last year and a half by the commission. And this area in green is one that an application has been submitted for, for a cultivation facility.

14:45 But then the moratorium was imposed by the town council, so that application is currently on hold. Hey, Nolan, I apologize. Would you mind bouncing back to the previous map that shows the buffer zones? The one that goes, the block of, I think there's like six spaces in blue along Laurel Mountain Road. Sure. Are those across from Sierra Nevada? Yes. So that is, there's Sierra Nevada here. Yeah. And so. Aren't those apartment?

15:15 You have apartments and condos, so really the only space in here that one might possibly be able to locate in that space availability and landlord authorization would be in the body shop kind of gym building here on the south end. And then kind of a similar scenario exists in this thing where I really kind of...

15:39 Available spaces would include either the Century 21 building or the mixed-use buildings here on Tavern Road. The others have uses that really preclude any cannabis retailer. Okay. Thank you. So once again, this is just the table showing for the industrial zone, the proposed uses. Medical marijuana co-ops have been, again, struck out from the table. Then clarifies that.

16:09 Proposed or allowed uses would be cultivation, non-volatile manufacturing, distribution and testing. Volatile manufacturing would be prohibited. Volatile manufacturing is any use of basically a flammable material for the extraction that includes butane, hexane and propane. The CO2 and ethanol.

16:35 are considered to be non-volatile solvents, so those would be allowed, and that's the solvents that the current manufacturers actually utilize. One uses CO2 and one was approved for ethanol. And just a quick note, the other kind of zoning text changes would be addition of the references for personal cannabis and cultivation and use within the accessory uses and structure for residential code section, the addition of

17:11 Section 17.52.085 for commercial businesses and .086 for personal cultivation and use. 17.52.160 would be deleted because that's being replaced by the two previous sections. And then section 68.100 for use permits just includes a reference to the commercial businesses section for the use permit requirements.

17:44 So for 17.5, 2.08 file, I'll just highlight really the ones that differ from what the state regulations are. As I said earlier, most regulations follow along with the state and match up with what they're requiring, and we really don't have discretion over those. So for the permits, the town will require a use permit. That's in addition to the state license. They also require to get an annual commercial cannabis permit. The rationale there is the use permit is

18:15 And it runs with the land. It's an entitlement that's issued and they're difficult to revoke or modify. A commercial cannabis permit gives the town the authority to kind of review how they're operating on an annual basis and any issues with law enforcement or other issues that have arisen will be easily identified in that annual review.

18:34 Also with the annual permit, it allows the town to conduct financial audits and compliance audits of the businesses. The costs for those will be included in the commercial cannabis permit. Just to add in, as a note, the town has completed audits for the two existing businesses. That was a question that's come up at commission a couple of times.

18:58 So we had an auditor out here a couple weeks ago. They've gone through all the paperwork and they're preparing those final audits for us. So we are moving forward with that at least to kind of set the stage for the next step in this cannabis project, I guess. Was that paid for by the operators? No. The town had to pay for it. We hadn't been collecting anything to fund those, but however, we will be doing that in the future.

19:28 Within these regulations, the prohibited activities, again, would be delivery of cannabis to consumers, outdoor cultivation, manufacturing using volatile solvents and operating without all required permits or licenses.

19:41 With regards to outdoor cultivation, thought was that the growing season here is very short for any outdoor crops. And with cannabis, you have additional public nuisance impacts with odor and the potential for additional theft. So the recommendation from the working group and from the PD was to prohibit outdoors that everything remains indoors. So this is for Section D. These are regulations specific to cannabis retailers. Once again, these are the ones that are just defer or

20:14 So, as I said earlier, minimal cultivation and manufacturing as an accessory use would be permitted within a retailer. The difference here from the town is that we would require it to be accessory to the primary use, primary retail use and restrict the operations to the rear of the site and outside of public view. So, within a retail establishment, it would have to be kind of in the rear of the site, basically behind a closed wall.

20:42 It's similar to how we, what we require currently for microbreweries within the commercial zone, except those can, those don't have to be hidden from the public view, but are required to be kind of in the back of the site within that. And so that this, these two uses are consistent with what we currently allow for medicinal Mammoth Lakes Wellness is approved for cultivation and manufacturing at their site.

21:10 And the location requirements, as discussed earlier, would include that public parks buffer and the separation requirement. On the next one, the responsible cannabis retailing education requirement. This is something the county health department advocated for. This would be similar to what's required for alcohol bars and restaurants where their servers have to go through.

21:34 Responsible beverage training so they can learn how to check IDs, recommend safe dosages in products for consumers. This would be an annual training they're required to go through. Next one is advertising requirements. The state requirements are basically impossible to enforce. They limit advertising to areas where at least 71.6% of the audience could be reasonably expected to be over 21.

22:02 Which I have no idea how they're going to enforce that. The town's regulations take it a step further and just say that all advertising materials and signage can include cannabis or marijuana, the words or any depiction of plant material. That's what is in our existing regulations and carried over to the new ones. Then the last one that's different with the operating hours, the state allows cannabis businesses to operate from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m.

22:31 The current regulations restrict the dispensaries Monday to Saturday 11 a.m. to 6 p.m. and Sunday 11 to 5 p.m. The proposed hours have been relaxed a little and are proposed to be 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. These were discussed with the two retailers. They were supportive of that. They felt the current ones really were too restrictive and we agreed with them but felt the state ones were a little too expansive.

22:59 Also, the 9 to 9 is consistent with what's being recommended for deliveries by any local distributors to allow shipments to occur during non-operating hours. Sorry, 9 to 9? 9 a.m. to 9. You wrote me something about 7 to 10. Is that different?

23:18 That was for the, yeah, the 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. would be for the cultivation, manufacturing, distribution. Dust reel. Yeah, and the industrial. I see that now. Okay, so retail, you're suggesting 9 to 9. And so, yeah, with that 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., any of the local distributors could deliver then from that 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. window or after the 9 p.m. so that they're not, and that was discussed at the town council, those, the 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. came out of that so that they could, you know.

23:47 Reasonably deliver to the local businesses in compliance with the regulations and not be breaking them every time they're delivering. So for cannabis cultivation, manufacturing, distribution, and testing, the majority of the regulations follow along with the state. For cultivation, again, it's indoor cultivation only. And then for all the other, all four uses, the parking requirements and the operating hours would be the same for all these businesses.

24:17 The parking requirements due to the unique operations and the potential for a larger number of employees for these types of businesses. It gives the planning director discretion to require additional parking beyond what the zoning code requires or the implementation of alternative parking provisions if it's determined that the use or number of employees will have an adverse effect on the surrounding area. This did stem from one of the

24:45 The use permit that was approved just for storage, it's for about a thousand square foot storage facility that they were proposing to have ten employees working in. That one only had one parking space and that is why the use permit that was approved was only for storage and not any additional operations but based on the zoning code they would have only had to provide one parking space and I felt that really didn't satisfy kind of what these demands might be in the industrial park.

25:14 And then, again, proposed operating hours for these, they could operate on indoor operations, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, but anything on the exterior would be limited to 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., so that's addressing the receiving and distribution activities that would be potentially causing any impact for adjacent businesses or any of the other nearby areas. And then just the remaining sections of this, 17.5, 2.085,

25:47 Address additional findings and conditions of approval that are specific to use permits for cannabis businesses. The application requirements just expand what's currently in our regulations so that it's clear what they need to provide for their use permit. And then the grounds and procedures for revocation and modification. Use permits does, in order to modify or to revoke it, does have to come back to the Planning Commission as a public hearing. So it just lays out what the grounds are that they may get

26:17 their use permit revoked, and then just the enforcement arm, it clarifies that any violation is a public nuisance and will be dealt with in accordance with the enforcement chapter of the municipal code. So that is kind of the completion of the commercial cannabis business section. Is there any questions from the commission or public? I've got a really quick question, Nolan.

26:50 I apologize. I probably should know this before I ask it. Can you just briefly explain one more time to me and maybe to everyone else the reason behind the emergency ordinance? The urgency ordinance proposed for March 13th? Correct. In other words, why is this being fast-tracked? So the urgency ordinance, one, it's when you talk to any of the operators, you talk to PD, they feel there's kind of a

27:20 The black market has grown significantly, not just since January, but over the last really year and a half of there's a lot of product out there that's not being sold or provided through any legal means. And part of that, when you talk to the operators, is that they can't get their adult use licensing. They're turning away, in their mind, hundreds of clients a day. I don't know if that's the truth, but turning away a large number of

27:48 Potential customers that are then going to purchase their cannabis on the black market. So by fast tracking and letting these become effective immediately, they can then pursue temporary licensing from the state for adult use. There is some language in there addressing how they have to get their temporary license and what they have to do to comply locally, but then they can not turn those customers away. So really it's to minimize the public threat due to the increase in the black market. Got it.

28:18 Because the alternative would be the public hearing on the 13th, a second reading at a following council meeting, and then it would become effective 30 days later. Got it. And PD is on board with this expedited? They've been involved in all the working group. They've been involved in the writing of the regulations and have reviewed all the pieces that are pertinent to the PD with them all throughout the process. Got it.

28:48 One other quick question, and I apologize for taking time here. Just looking at the buffer map that you've presented to us today, it definitely appears that the two existing medical providers have a significant advantage over any competitor that may come into the marketplace just by their existing locations. Was that ever taken into account that these two existing medical license holders would be given an economic advantage?

29:18 By expediting this? Not so much an economic advantage for those two specific ones. I mean, it would allow them to convert to begin their adult use sales. It's the same kind of rationale as, you know, anyone who submits their use permit ahead of somebody else or begins operations will have some advantage over someone who comes in at a later date. And the only alternative would be basically force them to close.

29:48 And then say, okay, now everybody's going to come in for a new use permit. Right. Have you had any applicants come in and say they can't find any place outside the buffers and ask for any kind of a variance or? Not yet. I know one who is looking early on and this is more just kind of.

30:12 Hearsay, not anything formal. They were looking in Sierra Center Mall, and then they found out that it's across the street from a daycare center, so it wouldn't be permitted anyways, regardless of what the town imposed, since that was the state-imposed buffer from the daycare center. So Sierra Center Mall, the little blue boxes down at the bottom of Old Mammoth Road, just south of, or below Meridian, is that not Sierra Center Mall? No.

30:42 That is kind of the south end of Oak Tree Lane. Got it. So Sierra Center Mall would be in the green buffer? Yeah, Sierra Center Mall can't, because there's the daycare center at the church on the corner. Got it. Okay, so then moving on to 17.5, 2.086. This is for personal cultivation and use. It's important to note for this that the town cannot prohibit.

31:18 So just a quick kind of going through this proposed regulations are consistent with the state.

31:48 They'd allow persons 21 years and age or older to cultivate, possess, and use cannabis. They are permitted to possess up to 28.5 grams of dried cannabis flower, 8 grams of cannabis concentrate, and up to 6 living plants. Once again, consistent with the regulations for commercial cultivation, outdoor cultivation would be prohibited and would require indoor only.

32:18 And that indoor only is required to be within a dwelling unit or in an accessory structure located on a parcel with one single family residence. The Town Council was supportive of allowing greenhouses to be used as accessory structures so long as they meet all the security and setback regulations.

32:34 Greenhouses are currently considered an accessory structure in residential zones. It's also important to note that the six plant limit is per dwelling unit and not per individual within the dwelling unit. So if you had five people living in a house, they're not all of a sudden permitted to have 30 plants. It's still just six plants per dwelling unit. And then the safety and security measures, they're intended to minimize the impacts to the residents and the community.

33:03 And require the area to be, cultivation area to be secured, require building permits for the installation of lighting and ventilation systems, require that the residents remain as a residential unit and all the amenities that come with the residential unit, including sleeping areas, kitchen, bathrooms, remain inoperative. And also just specifies that landlords do have the ability to prohibit cultivation within any rental units.

33:31 The town's not gonna really enforce, you know, get between a landlord and a tenant, but it just clarifies that the landlords do have that ability to prohibit the use in their rental units. And then also it discusses enforcement of this. Enforcement or violations would be complaint-based, similar to any other violation of the zoning code, and code enforcement does have the ability to issue fines for any violations.

34:02 So for the personal use, are there any questions from the commission? What is there if a neighbor has a complaint or a problem with either odors or humidity being ventilated into a setback or whatever that's bothering them next door? So any complaints would be submitted the same as any other code enforcement complaints so they can submit a form. We also have online submittal now for code enforcement.

34:32 to the code enforcement officer, and then we'll be investigated. If it's deemed to be a public nuisance, then action can be taken. Is there written criteria for what constitutes a nuisance in that case? It's a little broad. I mean, and that's, again, on purpose to really be following along with what the state has. They made it very difficult and clear that cities cannot go in and say no. They have to be reasonable. From what we've seen, I mean, it's

35:00 Got to be fairly blatant. That's from talking with other cities. Most of the issues that arise are blatant kind of violations where it's an entire house that's been converted to a grow and it's not the person with one to six plants. So that concludes the presentation on the land use regulations. As indicated in the packet, chapter 5.38, which currently addresses medical marijuana cooperatives, has been revised. Since that chapter is not...

35:34 Does not apply to land use and zoning regulations. The commission is not being asked to provide any recommendation on that and is included kind of as a reference purposes to for how the land use regulations would be enforced and implemented on an annual basis. So with that, that concludes the presentation and are there any questions from the commission and or public? Did you go through just a couple of

36:07 Maybe quick points about the peer resort comparison that you looked at. Do you have a way to summarize basically how our regulations compare? Sure. So looking through, there's seven resorts looked at, tried to focus on resort communities that primarily businesses, ski resorts that

36:35 You know, don't have a large population base, but are close to major population centers. They see this kind of large influx of visitors. And so with that dynamic, it's very hard to come up with, you know, some cities, and Mammoth has in the past, restricted the retailers to two dispensaries. There really is no criteria for what that magic number is of how many retailers a community can support. Mammoth went with two, looking at

37:04 The ones in Colorado, Aspen, there's currently six in Aspen. There's news clipping from all the different operators of Aspen saying, do you feel that the market should be capped? And all of them said no. They think the open market is the best approach and that those who are successful at operating a business will be the ones that survive and those that aren't the same as really any other business.

37:31 And then Telluride, as I discussed, had the number they always had, one that opened up directly underneath it, started to just cause some problems with too many in one specific area. The other ones looked at, Vail, as I discussed, they prohibited it, but...

37:51 They're being pretty kind of closed-minded to think they don't have cannabis in their community since you can take a bus five minutes outside of Vail downtown and go to six or seven dispensaries right next to one another. Those dispensaries also have LUMOs that go to the hotels in Vail to pick up customers. Oh, to pick up the customers as opposed to delivering the product. Yeah, because they don't allow delivery in...

38:16 But they can pick up customers and take them outside and then bring them back in. And then the other ones that looked at, I'm blanking on the name without pulling up the report, but there's one that had kind of a fairly small commercial zone similar to ours, but they didn't have any restrictions on where they could be. But based on having a small area, they all ended up being kind of in a one to two block radius. There's about three of them within.

38:48 Thank you.

39:23 Buffer between them or separation requirements that we could avoid the issues Telluride encountered. And really no peer resorts within California because everyone's still trying to figure it out. Yeah, as we said before the meeting, Truckee's still in the process of developing theirs. South Lake Tahoe is not, they have one medicinal facility, they're not at a point allowing adult use yet. Where? Nothing in,

39:52 Bear Mountain, I do not, Big Bear City, I have not seen anything from them. And then kind of right outside the Tahoe area, you do have dispensaries in Nevada and Carson City and Reno in those areas. Did you have any questions? No. Anything else? Okay. Are there any, we can move on to questions and comments from the public if anyone out there has any questions. John, Sarah. Okay.

40:31 Then we will close the public portion and let's move on. Since this is a public hearing, we do need to make the findings. Can you just re-summarize the findings that you have up on the screen there? Sure. So the findings for zoning code amendment include that the amendment is internally consistent with the general plan, is not detrimental to the public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare of the town.

41:00 It's in compliance with provisions of CEQA. It's internally consistent with the other provisions of the zoning code. So with regards to the general plan, all the proposed uses are in areas that are consistent with the land use designations for those zones. So you kind of have the industrial uses within the industrial zoning and then the commercial uses within the commercial zones. In regards to public interest, health, safety, and convenience, really,

41:29 The basis for all this is to minimize the black market and reduce illegal sales and distribution of cannabis so by legalizing it you're providing means for the public to get access to it you're also since all that product is required to be tested you're ensuring that all the product that's going to the marketplace meets strict criteria set by the state. With regards to CEQA within the cannabis regulations they created a

41:57 a specific exemption for cannabis regulations for cities to utilize the requirements for that exemption to qualify was that any future approval for any cannabis business is a discretionary, requires discretionary approval.

42:16 So by us requiring a use permit, that is a discretionary permit, which then triggers additional environmental review of those subsequent permits, and that the regulations were adopted prior to, look at the exact date as a date in 2019 is when that exemption will, is when that exemption will go away. July 1st. Yeah, July 1st, 2019 is when that exemption will no longer be available. And the last one, internally consistent with

42:47 The zoning code, again, similar to the general plan, it's in all areas that the uses are consistent with what those zones would allow, and so that's really where the consistency for the, or internal consistency comes from there. Okay. Thank you. From my end, I think it's clear that Nolan and the staff have done a good job of crafting these amendments, you know,

43:20 With consistency. Yeah, and clearly the findings have been met. Are we opening up discussion now? Discussion or motion. I think the only thing that makes me a little bit uncomfortable, and clearly it's a product and a service that the community wants. As everyone knows, it's a legal product. It's something that the town's going to gain revenue from on a tax.

43:47 From a tax basis, it just feels looking at the buffer zones in that one diagram you had that we are effectively giving this business to two operators and closing the door on anyone else just by the lack of other viable locations. So that I'm a little bit apprehensive about. And that's due to the language that says a 500 foot separation between the businesses? I get 600 between the businesses, 500 from...

44:16 500 between businesses, 600 from schools, daycare centers, youth centers, and public parks. And just the 600 from schools, daycares, public parks, that's a state requirement? The schools, daycare centers, and youth centers is a state requirement. The council and working group were supportive of the public parks because they felt that of all the kind of

44:45 Sensitive uses, that's really the one that could see the most impacts by having a retailer directly next to it. With someone going to it and then going right, if it's right adjacent to a park, to go use their products. So that's a slight addition that we've placed on the state requirements. Correct. But then the 500-foot buffer between businesses. That's a complete town discretionary requirement.

45:13 So that one, in our current regulations, the 500 feet is what applies for between current dispensaries. That's why we continue to utilize that one. One note, you know, those regulations aren't set in stone, so those could be if six months, a year down the road, we're finding that nobody can find any additional space to operate. The 600 feet from public parks, the 500 feet between them could be relaxed or amended as well. So I tend to agree with Michael that I don't want to see us

45:43 Ordaining the existing proprietors to the exclusion of somebody else. My feeling generally is that government really shouldn't be messing with businesses any more than they have to. It would be my feeling if we can reduce that 500 down to, I understand where somebody doesn't want a new shop opening up upstairs or downstairs, but 500 feet is quite a ways. You know, if that could be like 250, and then if it becomes a problem, it can be modified as opposed to

46:12 If we leave it the way it is now and it becomes a problem, it can be modified. Some people probably just won't go through the effort to do it and they'll go somewhere else. Right. Sure. So I don't have a graphic showing that, but you can kind of visualize, you know, this purple buffer here is a 500-foot buffer from there. So, I mean, if you were to divide it in half, you would open up some additional areas that a business could open or operate in.

46:39 And Nolan, I'm just also curious, particularly in the parcel that's in the outlet mall there, is it standard practice for you to create the buffer based on the outlines of the entire parcel versus the tiny little postage stamp that the actual business occupies? So yeah, within that, fortunately, especially since those aren't condoized, it's one complete parcel.

47:09 And a definition within ours and at the state level is to measure from the parcel boundary in a straight line. Okay. In discussions with council and with, you know, in the workshops with business owners and the public, was there any discussion about reducing that 500-foot separation? Not in the working groups or with the operators. The operators saw these maps. They're supportive of

47:40 You know, when it first came up a year and a half ago, one of the options was to just use the state buffers and I think the public and some of the others felt that was relaxed too much that it would open up far too many areas, especially if there was no requirement for separation between them because you could

48:07 Essentially have a proliferation of retail establishments. The council level, with the working group, they said, okay, it was 500 feet, let's continue to utilize that unless there's real good reason to change that one. Like I said, further analysis, I mean, you can, like I said, visualize what that would do, kind of what areas that would open up. So for

48:36 This area really the only areas that, additional areas that would be gained would be some areas on Center Street, because when you go kind of across the street from the outlet mall, I believe within 250 feet, you're going to have most of the kind of commercial sites within there. You're still in the hotel part, yeah. Yeah, it might open up the post office site, but I don't know how that'll work with.

49:00 The post office if they're supportive of it. I mean, it would open up Main Street. Then it would open up some on, yeah, Laurel Mountain and really I think it's mostly on Center Street, Laurel Mountain and a little within the Tavern. The tavern, but the northeast kind of corner which is the Rite Aid area, Rite Aid Plaza area. Looks like it could open up like where Nick and Willie's is too. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I believe that would open up that parcel.

49:40 So, I mean, if that is the recommendation or the commission, we can include that as the recommendation from the commission of 250 feet or any other buffer that's... It just seems to me that the 500 feet is a little bit arbitrary. So, I mean, I don't know how we objectively and scientifically go about picking a number out of thin air for...

50:04 for what the buffer zones should be. I wasn't really around when the 500 foot came about in the first place. That was arbitrary. It was 1,000. And then at the... It was 1,000. I do remember hearing that. At the meeting to write the resolution for the voter, it went to 500. I can sympathize with the upstairs-downstairs guy, but it just seems 500 is quite a bit. It is. It's just shutting the door on any competition whatsoever. I'd like to see that reduced to some...

50:33 I would be in support of that as well. I feel that we have some consensus there. Nolan, would you be looking for us to suggest a number or is that something that we could put to staff and to council? What's the process here, guys? Well, I think if the commission wants a reduced setback or a reduced buffer, if you have a number, if you're thinking, you know, 250 feet, we can bring that forward to council.

51:01 I think we'd prefer to have something from the commission so that we can kind of take that to them, rather than a staff kind of coming up with a different buffer. Would that just be a modification in a motion? Yeah, you would be making a motion to recommend approval of this to the town council with the recommendation that they reduce the buffers between businesses to 250 feet or 200 feet, whatever distance you think is appropriate. Yeah, it would be this recommendation.

51:30 Scratched out, recommended by staff, and just be as modified. To reduce the buffer. Okay. Like I said, if you have a number, you know, at the, if you stay 250 feet at the Town Council, it would be presented with kind of both options showing what additional areas this would open up and why that's a benefit for, you know, the markets that there's additional spaces to operate in. Okay. So I guess it's maybe up to the three of us to

52:03 Again, come up with an arbitrary number below 500. Yeah, an arbitrary number below 500 and just looking. When you're going to the edge of a commercial parcel, it's like you said, it's not the front door of the place, it's the edge of the property. So the smaller the number, the better. I'm just trying to think of a way to do this that isn't quite so arbitrary. Can you remind me, in the code, isn't there a minimum

52:37 Sort of standard, a minimum parcel width or parcel size? Or is that just apply to residential parcels? It's for all, it depends on the zoning. It does. I'm just wondering if we can somehow tie the buffer zone to... The average size of a parcel? Maybe not the average, but two or three times the minimum parcel width that's in the code, then it...

53:08 It's a little less arbitrary or subjective. A formula. Yeah. And only because we'd be saying, okay, well, likely to have at least one or two neighbors in between businesses. The minimum lot width is 75 feet. So if you went three times that, you'd be 225. Mm-hmm. In all of the commercial zones. So in the zones that we're talking about.

53:42 So three times that at 225 means... We're coming back to 250 again. Yeah, we're coming back to 250. Yeah, 225 or 250. Okay. Greg, would you be in support of... 250 works for me? Amy? Mm-hmm. Yeah, to me. And I think it... I'd like there to be an understanding that, I don't know, how we came up with some kind of logic for a number. I don't know.

54:14 Greg, would you like to make a motion? I'd like to make a motion that we accept staff's recommendation with the modification of 250 feet instead of 500 feet between businesses. I'll second that. Okay. Jamie, can we have a vote, please? Aye. Vice Chair Vanderhurst? Here. Yes. And a day. Yes. All right. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you very, very much. Thank you.

54:49 Thank you for the patience and the hard work that went into that. Okay. Moving on, I would just like to pull the approval of the final tract map from the consent agenda up to a business matter, just so that we can have a brief discussion here in the meeting. So that item is approval of the final tract map 17-001, the Mountainside Amendment, and Haislip Hayes will be reporting.

55:25 Hayes, I think you were going to report on what the snow storage issues, how we've resolved those. I'd be looking for the commission to ask any questions about the final map application. The things I just really wanted to touch on briefly were regarding the snow storage on the parcel and the location of the trash dumpster.

55:53 In particular because there had been some comments and questions from the public about those two items in the past, and I wanted to just bring it back for discussion. Not discussion, but just for resolution, rather. Absolutely. First, the trash dumpster is in the same location that was approved in the original map. This is the second time this has come forward with the revisions, so that has not changed. It's still on the opposite side of the property from the original.

56:20 The person that had it took issue. So on the north side of the property, adjacent to the Forest Service parcel where Canyon Lodge is? Correct. And we have taken a really deep look at the snow storage plan that was proposed. We vetted it through our operators to make sure that it was actually feasible. We double, triple checked all the calculations and we were satisfied that what was proposed is actually feasible and actually works for the law.

56:48 And if I remember correctly, the snow removal and snow storage was the primary driver behind the amendment? Is that the right word? The slight change in the building footprint or building layout? Is that correct? The applicant felt that it was important after seeing what happened the previous year with incredible amounts of snow that we needed to create a little bit more separation between the buildings to create some more snow storage.

57:18 went through the process to move his property lines for the building footprint to facilitate more snow storage. Okay. And the town and the applicant are happy with the way that's gone. Have you heard any other questions or comments from...

57:37 members of the public? We have not. I can say on behalf of staff that we are satisfied and feel that the final map is consistent with the tentative tract map and the applicant is here if you have any questions for him specifically. I don't have anything other than what we've just talked about. Do you want to come up, John, please? I think it would be wise for the Planning Commission or the staff or whoever to

58:16 Look into the fact that trucking snow is prevalent in every condominium project commercial area. Right now it's only, I think, legalized in a commercial zone. And yet, I don't know of a project that didn't have to truck last year. So I think it should be allowable to include trucking in our CC&Rs.

58:41 For all our projects we include in the budget, it's hard to do with the department, well, Bureau of Real Estate, to include that in a budget, but we managed to do it. But I think it, maybe you should look into the fact that it should be a viable option for something other than a condominium project, not a single family dwelling, but for condominium projects, apartments, that sort of thing, multiple zoned. That's the only input I have. Thank you, John.

59:11 So if I remember correctly, trucking of snow or having a plan to truck snow is an accepted method to meet the code requirements for snow storage in a commercial property, but not currently in a residential property. Correct. And, Sandra, wasn't there a committee or a group that was kind of working on some snow storage issues?

59:35 Well, the Mobility Committee has snow storage. The walk, bike, ride identifies snow storage as one of the action items. And really, that action item has...

59:45 The Public Works Department is handling that, working on that. So I think this is one of the items that we can add, and I'm just adding it now to our list of cleanup for zoning codes. So just something to look at the next time we clean up the zoning code to take a look and see if we think that's feasible and then include it in the next cleanup. So we'll put a note to do that and look at it the next time. Great. I think because the last time when we did talk about this, I think we sort of agreed that we should at least address it. So we will do that. Okay.

1:00:13 Thank you. I don't really have any other questions. I don't. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, John. Thank you for staying. All right. Next item is our, the consent agenda, which consists now only of the minutes from our December 13th meeting. Do you guys have consent? Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah, yes, I would say that it sounded like we had consensus to this. Yeah, I just wanted to make sure. Sorry.

1:00:49 There wasn't a motion needed, right, because it was moved into business? You just really pulled it from the consent. It's still a consent item, but you just pulled it to discuss it. Got it. Okay. So I'd like to make a motion to approve the minutes of the December 13, 2017 meeting. Second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Yes, motion passes to approve the minutes 3-0. And all right.

1:01:21 Is that approved or consent? Yes. Yes. Approved. Thank you, John. Any reports from members of the commission? Who wants to start? I really don't have one. I've been out of town, so. All right. Well, welcome back. Thank you. We had a meeting of the Mobility Committee last, was that last week, correct? Last Wednesday, yep. Yeah. Commissioner Burroughs and myself attended, as well as the other stakeholders that.

1:01:51 Represent the different town, county, NGOs, Forest Service, Caltrans. I thought it was a very productive meeting. The basic goal of the meeting was to help prioritize about 23 different ongoing projects or future projects, prioritize them based on available funding, prioritize them based on the amount of need within the community.

1:02:21 And also prioritize them based on the partnership levels within the different organizations that were represented there. Did I miss any? No, I think that's correct. Yeah. And I said it at the Mobility Committee meeting. I came away very, very energized from the amount of partnership demonstrated between different organizations, whether federal, state, or local, that haven't always played well in the sandbox together.

1:02:50 So it was very encouraging. Great. And it was well run. Thank you, Sandra. Thanks. That's it. Anything else? Okay. Great. Let's see. On my end, we had a design committee meeting on January 16th, which seems like so long ago. A couple of items. We reviewed the proposed exterior artwork for the grocery outlet, if you remember. That was a requirement.

1:03:22 For some of those exterior panels where they were unable to meet the transparency requirements, so we asked for some sort of artwork. So we got a first submission from an artist for that, and we asked for a few changes, but overall the concept was sort of revolved around local scenic views that we all might know and recognize.

1:03:51 And so we'll be looking to see a revision of that sometime in the next month or two? I think if we're meeting next week. Is it on that one? I couldn't remember. Okay, so maybe next week. And they also brought forward their design for their monument sign, which looked fairly standard for the grocery outlet, if you've seen any of their...

1:04:17 You know, their standard logo. However, we did need to remind them that we don't allow backlit signs, and so they have to, they're coming forward with a revision on that as well. Then the other item we reviewed were proposed exterior modifications for the old McDonald's building. That lot did sell, and the new owner is looking to open up a Starbucks in that location.

1:04:46 So they will be doing some minor exterior modifications, mostly removing some of the Swiss chalet-like detailing and a new coat of paint and a new either one or two outdoor seating areas. So I think that will be coming to the commission at your next meeting for consideration. And that's going to be the 14th? Correct. That's all I've got on my end.

1:05:21 Okay, so the Vice Chair Vanderhurst already reported on the Mobility Committee meeting. I thought it was a good meeting as well. We crossed some things off the list. We identified some priorities. And the town has applied for grant funding for some of those items. So I think we'll be moving forward with some of those items in the near future.

1:05:44 And then just a quick note that the town, as you know, is in escrow for the shady rest parcel, and we anticipate that that will close by the end of March next month. So it's really exciting, and we'll kind of take a look at the future planning for that after we close escrow, kind of figure all of that out, but it will be a very collaborative process. The commission will be involved, the public, council, but we're really excited about taking possession of the property.

1:06:12 Hopefully in about a month. And that's all I have. Unless there's any questions. I don't have any, no. Okay, no. I just, I wanted to mention, I just realized today when I drove by it that the Catholic Church Parish Hall has started construction. Yes. So that is exciting. It's well underway. Yeah, yeah. That's all I've got.

1:06:41 Okay, well, then in this case, we will adjourn to our next meeting, which is at 2 o'clock on Wednesday, March 14th. What else was on the agenda on the 14th besides the McDonald's?