Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2018
Mammoth Lakes Recreation
· recording 3 hr 25 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
453 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:04 Okay. It's an order. Thank you. Okay. Do we have to plug in or no? No. We're good. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Awesome. Do we have any public comments out there? Yes. Come on up to the microphone, please. And introduce yourself. Thank you.
1:53 Hi, I'm Marisela Rosales. I'm here on some time for myself, but I'm also here on behalf of Latino Outdoors, and I am really excited to be here. It's a beautiful ski town. I am working with Matt currently on a project here in Mammoth Lakes in May, so stay tuned for that. And I'm hoping that I can be of support with the Latino community here in any way that I can. Excellent. Thank you. We're pleased to have you. Thank you.
2:21 Yes. Did you have fun on the hill today? Yes. All right. You didn't fall? Oh, you weren't trying hard enough. That's awesome. Awesome. Hello, MLR, Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. I just wanted to quickly share a couple of things out of our commission meeting this morning. Some of the things like the park update and the...
2:50 project update are on your agenda so I can comment on those as they come up. But I also wanted to mention that we spent some time this morning reviewing our CIP and major maintenance list. We're very excited to now have a column of completed items on that for
3:04 The first time in at least the six years I've been on the commission, so that's very exciting. But there are definitely some MLR and Mammoth Lakes Trail System have a column, some donation opportunities. So it was great, you know, Matt was there today, and I know that, you know, our staffs will continue to work together on that, so thank you. And then I also just wanted to mention that our youth sports funding program application period is open, and we will host our workshop with the organizations on Tuesday, March 20th, right here in Sweet Z.
3:33 And the applications are due on the 23rd. Can you give me 30 seconds on that or 20 seconds? What is the youth sports funding program? Sure. So the youth sports funding program is the commission makes a recommendation to town council for the allocation of funds provided through the town's general fund and through Mono County to enhance and augment our youth sports organizations. You have to be a nonprofit to apply. There's plenty of information on the Parks and Rec website.
4:01 Or you can direct any questions to Kat Kelly at Parks and Rec. Cool. So it's a great program. We're really happy to have all those partners providing things like AYSO soccer, swim team, all those programs. Sweet. Deadline is when, you said? March 23rd. March 23rd. Thank you, Betsy. Yeah. Cool. Thank you. Betsy, I just wanted to say thank you. We had a...
4:21 Great workshop about the playground, the inclusive playground between MLR and rec commission and staff, and that was very helpful for us. We've already had some forward movement, so thank you very much. No, we're really, really excited to be moving forward on that project, hopefully just the first of many. All right. Thanks. Okay. Any other public comment before we get going? Okay. Any additions, changes, comments to the current agenda? I do have one.
4:53 Dan's going to speak to one in a second, but I'd like to make a motion just so we can accommodate the mayor's presentation that we move item 6C on the agenda before items 6A and 6B. Okay. So that would be, we just want to talk about Prop 68 before we do the presentation on the Eastern Sierra Rec Coordinator, just because it helps give it some context. Yep.
5:18 Okay. And then Dan would like to speak about item 7B, the funding for the theater. Okay. All right. Sounds good. Do we need to formally approve that through motion? One second. Yeah, we're good. Yeah, okay. Let's, oh, you want to go now? Okay. Yeah, because regarding to your agenda, item 7B with the, for the Mammoth Lakes Repertoire Theater, it's not to the,
5:48 validity of the item there and the support there, but it's more toward process on this and sorry to do this. I've had just started some meetings with Matt on this, so not his fault here either. Under the ordinance approved for Measure U, when it talks about allocating those funds, it requires at least a one public hearing that comes in where these items can be discussed, and a public hearing is different than a public meeting.
6:13 The Measure R allocation, for example, that you have on your agenda for the town, under Measure R, it requires a meeting where you can take public input. Measure U requires a formalized public hearing. You know, you don't have to do the 10-day notice in the paper and those types of things, but it actually should be agendized as a public hearing versus just an item on administrative agenda. So, and I was just trying to check. I don't believe the allocation to the theater was part of the adopted budget.
6:41 So you're not just moving dollars around. There was discussions in a broad category of $300,000 allocated to the MAC for future operations and in that the theater element. But if you actually look at this, the action tonight would actually be a recommendation on the expenditure of additional funds for the theater to go to town council for amendment into the budget accordingly. And so it's such that in reading through the ordinance stuff, I believe that it would be prudent to follow
7:09 That requirement there to actually have a public hearing on the item versus just a agenda item. In the past, I know some of these, a lot of times we've done the public hearing as part of the overall allocations process and we've actually, I think at one point even did a notice in the paper for it, but it requires that, it's just a nuance of the Major U ordinance was approved by the voters. It requires at least one public hearing to spend dollars that way. And historically, if we've taken stuff out of the budget, not just
7:38 Moving stuff around within it that's actually been adopted. We've come back with a public hearing on that so people know that they could show up and make comment accordingly if they're watching the agenda. So again, it's nothing to do with the value of the item before you. But process-wise, I believe you're much better served if you follow that public hearing process as called out in the voter-approved ordinance. So I would make that recommendation that that item be
8:06 Continue to an item where you could actually call it out that way. I don't know the timing and the need for the funding for the theater. And we can work with Matt in terms of the language on the agenda where it need to be a public hearing, formally open it, take comment. And when you do that, also the other side of the public hearing process, if it's the applicant,
8:24 They can talk a lot longer if they choose. You don't cap them to three minutes or five minutes. And that process. But also that puts the public on notice that there's going to be a discussion on the allocation of additional funding out of Measure U to a particular purpose. I could pull that section of the code up. Does that apply then to 5B? 5B is a Measure R allocation.
8:52 So the requirement there is you have to take public input, not conduct a public hearing. Why the two were written different, I have no idea. So you're okay on 5B, you have to just open up to take public input to the allocation there. So sorry about that, but it was just caught at the end. No problem. Thank you, Dan. So thank you. What the staff will do is staff will reconvene with the folks in the theater.
9:18 Find a time that's convenient for them, reconvening with the board, find time that's convenient for you guys, and at the earliest convenience, we'll try to have a separate public hearing. Yeah. Yeah. Makes sense. Give 10 days of those for that. Okay. All right. So I think we need to vote for the changes, amendments in the agenda. So we'll be removing 7B from the agenda for this evening? Yes. Okay. Do I have a motion? I'll make a motion to remove 7B until a later date. Okay. Second. I'll second it. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Aye.
9:48 Motion passes. Okay. Moving on then. Let's take a look at the minutes from the last board meeting. We did not have a January meeting, so it's been a little while. Does anybody have any amendments or need for clarification? If I didn't notice anything, I would move to approve the board meeting minutes of December 5. I'll second that. Okay.
10:22 All in favor of approving the minutes? Aye. Okay, so approve. And let's move on to Form 700. That's conflict of interest disclosures. Matt, are you just presenting those to us for completion? Yes. So we are required to complete these Form 700 statement with economic interest.
10:50 So just go through them. I've attached those forms in your packet. You can fill them out digitally. And then I was hoping to get those forms back by the 28th so I could give them to our town staff. If you have any difficulties filling those out, just let me know. Either I'll help you or Jamie Gray will help you. Okay. Great. Great. You're going to help me? As much as I can. No, I'm kidding. Some of us, it's easier. That form's easier than others.
11:19 I think it's important that on the form, if you are, like, with council or, like, on another board, you can fill out one form and list multiple agencies on it so you don't have to fill out the same form for each role. That's right. Okay. Anything else on Form 700 from anyone? Okay. Financial reports. We'll first review the 17-18 year-to-date report. The attachments in your packet. Matt, any?
11:50 Callouts here? No, we're doing well. MLR is currently just under 1% on our revenue budget, and we're running under 27% on the expense budget. Again, due largely to the money we saved in July and August for staff, but things are tracking in line, so we're good there. Board members, anything that you're seeing? Any questions about the report?
12:24 No? Okay. There was a question. You were talking about the expenses. If I was looking at it correctly, it was showing that we were higher on expenses with budget. I'm trying to get back to which of the 196 pages. Lower. Lower. Lower. Lower. Yeah, we're $46,713 under right now. Okay. And you said that's mostly attributed to the staff? Yeah. So in July and August, I didn't come on board to the end of August, so we saved some money on the ED salary and then
12:52 Just some other expenses that were in line, just kind of housekeeping stuff. But for everything since then on the budget, we're tracking pretty spot on. And so then with that, that's not, is that considered dollars where you will spend in the future or is that just dollars that they're gone and passed and they're not going to get reallocated somewhere else? Given that it's for salary, I probably, I'm not inclined to spend it, you know, I mean, unless there was a compliant reason to spend it somewhere else.
13:20 We could certainly bring that to the board and talk about that. But, you know, I went through, Tom and the board were very generous in giving me time to set my budget for the rest of this fiscal year. And I think we've got most of the things in there that we need to accomplish our goals. So if there's something outside of that, certainly, like I said, I'll bring that to the board's attention. But right now, I'm trying to stay pretty close to what we have budgeted. I mean, I consider it a bit of a buffer, you know, not just.
13:49 Money we can kind of, you know, it's a bit of a savings right now if we have a good reason to, yeah. Do we have, so the money that we brought in annually through the taxes was $337,000 for this year?
14:06 I'm sorry? Right here, the $112,000, the $225,000. Yes. For the R&U. Is that number pretty consistent year after year? It is. That's the money that we receive through Measure R. And that's another reason why I wouldn't just, because it's coming out of two buckets. So, I mean, I can't just go and spend it on something else. Right. So, you know, we have to be conservative with that. But, yeah, we're kind of limited in what we can do. But, yeah, that's the money to your question is yes.
14:34 Every year it's been pretty consistent. I can't speak to, you know, maybe Dan can, but, you know, in terms of, it doesn't vary too much. Okay. Any other comments, questions about the 17-18 year-to-date budget? Was there anything on fundraising and our goals on fundraising?
15:02 Bringing that in the budget aspect? Do we budget that fundraising dollars? It does, and it comes in towards the end of this fiscal year. We start to see a ramp up of that, and then because we first had to acquire some of the tools, and those are now mostly in place, we started looking at doing some fundraising, primarily fundraising for admin this year, and some smaller kind of entree into our capital projects. For example, we
15:30 Most definitely be fundraising for the playground. If we can get kind of our ducks in a row, maybe for the bridge. But that will be more towards the end of the fiscal year, so we won't see that recorded in the year to date. I know it was back in December, but the spend that was asked for for the software for being able to do fundraising, did that get spent? It did. Yeah, that was out of that bucket that came, and I believe that came out of general funds, so that's two different bucket pools of money. Okay. Thanks.
15:56 And there's a web redesign and a little brand work being done right now. So basically tool set, a kind of refresh of the branding, basically in preparation for fundraising campaigns. And just overall, I feel like the way Matt's handling expenses and the way that he's...
16:18 Planning to run these campaigns on the expense side, it's pretty conservative, which I'm fine with. I think that's kind of stylistically where you're at. I'm here to convince him to be more aggressive if he needs to, you know, in terms of spending. We've got money for three years basically to ramp up. So I'll be watching that, you know, kind of how much we're spending versus how much we're getting back against that spend. So I guess stay tuned. We're about to
16:48 You know, hit campaign mode, and it's starting to get exciting. Okay. Let's move on then. 990 is complete. It's here in your packet. I've reviewed it. Match reviewed it. I guess for this item, I'll just take any, assuming board members reviewed it before the meeting. Any questions, comments? That's good. Okay. It's been filed, right?
17:19 Shipped. Okay. On to capital projects. Let's get an update on the park. What do you have planned, Matt, here? Are we going to get an update from Stu? Yeah, Stuart. Okay. Evening, Board. How are you? Good. Thank you. Great. I'll kick off kind of the update that we provided to the Commission this morning, apprised you of the action that the Commission took as well, and then Dan's going to follow along and talk a little bit more about the LA Kings Partnership and the funding and the package that we're looking at.
17:59 Bringing forward for that facility. So the update today was essentially the project is in plan check. So it went to plan check down in Southern California. They provided us with 17 pages of review items. So we're working through those. Still on schedule for a bid launch or technically to advertise the bid on March 20th for that package.
18:26 And we have one final review with our consultants next week down in Southern California at the TSC. So we're meeting with Brad and his group to look at that one more time before we go live with the bid. The schedule is still the same and it's as follows. So we're looking at advertising the bid March 20th. At this time we're looking at being before council on May 16th with that bid award. And then subsequently May is kind of the time we're factoring in for the grading, July construction.
18:53 And then Spring 2019 for, yeah, probably Spring 2019 is kind of looking at kind of the first phase of the construction, sorry, completion of the project. In regards to the partnership deal, amazingly, we've got everybody to the table once again, which is very exciting. The Mammoth Resorts deal expired on March 1st and we got commitment with all parties, I think the day before or two days before, to conceptually agree.
19:24 to that sponsorship commitment, which is big news. So that's very exciting. We're very eager to kind of get that agreement executed. We were before commission, as I said this morning, commission voted 4-1 in support of the partnership with the Kings. The one no vote was just a commissioner not quite up to date or uncomfortable with the total financing or the total facility itself.
19:53 So anyway, we are at a 4-1 vote for moving forward with that partnership with the commission. So I know we've talked about the partnership as well. Dan's going to talk a little bit more about the details of how we're presenting that. It's before you this afternoon, looking for a recommendation as well for council. Mammoth Lakes Tourism will address this item tomorrow afternoon, and then we'll be before council tomorrow night for the resolution.
20:18 Very eager to get that done as we talked about. So just to reiterate, it's a million dollar donation to Mammoth Lakes Recreation, specifically, that's your agreement. I believe Scott's been in contact with Matt working through those agreements, so they're all kind of being drafted. Not yet, but I will reach out with him. Yep, I gave you your email address, so he's all good.
20:35 We've been working with the Kings as well on the management support agreement, so that's being kind of drafted, the term sheet's being reviewed back and forth with MLT, Mammoth Resorts, there's an MOU that's being drafted, it's around for review between Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Resorts as well, so there's a lot of pieces that we're kind of working together, and there's also a press release kind of getting drafted in anticipation of that release and announcement, so very exciting.
21:00 At this time, you know, we haven't really nailed down the branding or the naming rights. At this time, it's really just designated as the official training centre of the LA Kings. So that's kind of the language there. They'll have some other activation items in the facility as well. We'll get through that. And obviously, the largest size of that that we're really excited about from the Commission's point of view is really the long-term programming and sustainability of that facility through that partnership. As I said, the Commission formalised an action this morning.
21:30 And then we just updated the commission on our ongoing fundraising slash advertising package with our buyer board program. We're up to about 12, 13 vendors working as hard as we can to get those up and get them out. We closed the ice rink on Sunday. It was just getting very challenging keeping that facility open.
21:53 Staff did a great job. We applauded our ice rink team. I think they did an amazing job. It was actually the first season that we've ran pretty much full programs. All lessons went off. Every night was curling night, you know, so we didn't miss one of those. And as visitation and revenue went, it was certainly probably our best revenue season, I think, ever at that facility. It was just under $100,000 of revenue that facility bought in in three months. So it does go to show it.
22:21 It is a very much needed amenity in our community. And on the visit side, we were about 1,000, a little bit over 1,000 under our record of 11,209 back about 10 years ago. Anyway, so we're working with several vendors and our partners in the community to get those boards up. They'll be up for summer, next winter, and then any advertiser that is with us while we're at the existing site gets the first pick of their location.
22:50 at the new facility, so pretty exciting. So that's the update on the park project. Looking at the letter of agreement between Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the resort, there's clear understanding of what the financials are and the advertising side of it, but there's nothing in there specifically about kings coming here and content here. Is that contractually obligated or is this still we're paying the marketing and they're giving us a million dollars? Do we have anything about kings formally coming here in a written agreement?
23:18 Yeah, so that's actually part of the term sheet. So that's part of the Mammoth Resort's term sheet. It's not part of the MOU. Okay. So I know Tom can speak to that a little bit more, but there were elements of the activation items, and then there was two other items. Sorry, three other items. One was the donation. Four items. One was the donation. One was the kind of branding of that facility. Third one was really looking at the management support agreement, and the fourth one was LA Kings pre-season camp.
23:47 So there is that kind of understanding in that term sheet, and that term sheet is between Mammoth Resorts and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I have the copy of the term sheet here, and so I'd love to see a copy of that, because there's nothing in the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Agreement with the Mountain that says anything about camps or Kingscoming here or naming. It's only about advertising in their facility and the financial obligations of $100,000 a year to advertise down their support from MLT. So if there is something that...
24:15 Yeah. Contractual obligation of the Kings providing something in the community here. I've not seen it yet. Yeah. I don't know if that's been circulated to the MLT board yet. I mean, the term sheet's still going back and forth. So I, you know. It's going back and forth, but it's done. So that's what I'm asking. Well, those are three, again, three different elements. So there's three components to this. One is just the advertising deal, right? Just thinking of that one. One is the donation.
24:43 That comes to us. And then the third is kind of the management contract in the program. They're different contracts. They're all three different contracts. Right. And so the reason why I'm asking this is that tomorrow night, tomorrow, Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board is going to approve that $100,000 funding. And it's a little, to me, it seems that the Kings are in a pretty good position where they're getting the money yet. Do you have a contract that you're definitely getting the million dollars? Or is that still to follow? Because if we're going to sign a contract that they're definitely getting the $100,000 a year,
25:10 Before we have a contract that says for sure we're getting a million dollars or for sure they're doing contracts here, that seems a little cart before the horse to me. Are they contingent? Yes. And right now, the Mammoth Lakes Tourism one has no contingencies in it that I see between Mammoth Lakes Tourism and the resort. So I haven't seen any contingencies that cover us in case the king said, you know, we're out. I think there's contingencies. There's required contingencies both ways. I mean, they also obviously need to know that we can build.
25:40 the facility as well before they enter into this partnership and that we have our ducks in a row on the capital side too. So I think that conversation's still a little bit in play and you bring up a good point. I think it's valid to bring up at your board meeting. Yeah, I mean, they've got all the money from us without actually having us having certain young what we're going to get back from them yet. That seems a little concerning. Yeah, I don't know if I'd characterize it quite that way and maybe Dan, you can speak to
26:10 To the question two. Again, it's Dan Holler, town manager. Good question, Scott, but I think one of the details you're asking for is actually in the agreement between Mammoth Resorts and the LA Kings that we will not be a party to for that side of it, the term sheet that was put together, the laying those details out. That, for example, references they will enter an agreement with Mammoth Lakes Recreation, a 501c3 agency.
26:41 For the donation of a million dollars over a three-year period. Comes in, it has specific dates for a $500,000 payment, $250,000 and $250,000. It calls out the other elements you're talking about of a camp. If they do a camp, then we work with them in terms of subsidizing some of the rentals or housing for the team and those types of things. That will be specifically in the agreement between Mammoth Resorts and the LA Kings, the way I read the term sheet.
27:08 The term sheet is referenced in the MLT agreement to them, but the MLT buy is truly for the marketing, not for the other stuff, not for the visitation of the kings, et cetera. That's in a separate agreement, and then there will be, once we execute that, then they can pursue Matt for the agreement with MLR. And a good example of that would be the agreement for MLR.
27:31 Cannot reference the ad buy, because then it's quid pro quo, and then it has implications for taxes and donations. So they'll have a separate agreement and separate over, they're bifurcating that between the two arms of the company, if you will, and stuff. So we've been trying to work it through, and we've had some of the same questions of when and how, and ultimately to try to move that forward, and the timing has been really tight. I think Stu mentioned the current agreement.
27:58 Expired March 1, so we'll miss a couple of games. I'm not sure if we got them bonused in or not. And then starting up with the MLT tourism component, once we actually have an agreement in place and start the payment for that with the LA Kings. The other oversight company, and that's been AEG as well, so we've been working with both parties to pull that together. So a lot of those detailed elements are part of a separate agreement.
28:26 Have R&A monitor, frankly, MLR's name on it. So. A lot of partners, a lot of moving parts. I mean, on the King's side, there's basically three groups that we're working on, not to mention the multiple groups on our side as well. Real quick, the last point, and it's in the agreement that Tom referenced, is the commitment to build the facility.
28:49 That would be one of the challenges, obviously. And so as we've been looking at putting it together and looking at the funding, we have about $9.1 million that's been committed to date. The King's Agreement would put another million into that pot, the $10.1 million. And then we've been working through on the town side looking at some additional funding and a variety of sources here will be coming through the budget process here shortly, some amendments in that area this year and looking into next year.
29:17 And then also we will be coming in with another request through Mammoth Lakes Recreation for a smaller portion as well. We're trying to get to $11.5 to $12 million number in the bank. As Stu mentioned, we're anticipating bids to go to town council in May. And so we're hoping that we get decent bids and we can award the full project. There's been a lot of push not to award a portion of the project.
29:44 We will have some bid alternates on it, and if we can work that through, we just don't know what that bid's going to be. We'll get another cost estimate updated on March 13th, and then bids will be shipped out or the bid package will go out on March 20th. And so we're working through that to say, do we have enough money in the bank, frankly, to award the bid or commitments for that? Discussion again with Matt on that going, yes, we're looking at fundraising. I can't...
30:13 Order bid based on what might happen. To the extent it comes in, that can offset some of the other allocation of dollars. Ideally, I'm assuming the request would be is offset the major R&U dollars that would impact that. But in order to bid, we'd need to have that full package put together. And right now, we've identified about 11.5 million. That does include some additional R&U funding.
30:35 What's the additional that you expect to be? Expected to be $50,000 on Measure R, which is looking at what I would call larger than anticipated revenue coming in. First six months of the year, it's $70,000 over budget. The projected year end is projected to go higher than that, so it's not impacting any current operations. The Measure U side, what we looked at was...
30:59 The $300,000 that was allocated into the MAC side of that to some degree and some of the fund balance in there over and above the commitments there. But again, keeping that as a one-time allocation, here would be a one-time allocation to capital project. It'd be obviously a different project. And then as it goes forward, ultimately, agreement with the town and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and Kernan College most likely for funding the operation of theater up to that $300,000 level.
31:27 Going forward once it's constructed. So there's a gap in time on that, but we've been trying to make sure that $300,000 didn't get committed to operating items. And so then you get to the point where you need it for the theater and you go, well, it's already being committed over here to another purpose. And so there's adequate revenue within the funds there to do this, but it'd be those two pieces. You could move a little more out of R, a little less out of U, but that would be once we get...
31:56 That next step in will be coming forward for those discussions. So it's been a very interesting process trying to get to that much higher number than anticipated. But the King's Deal is a part of that. Again, multiple agreements, but a lot of work has gone into that. And I know Tom and your team, the Mammoth Resorts has been a key element to that. A lot of moving parts and a lot of good work too. Remind us of the total amount that you need.
32:27 To go to bid. Well, we're estimating, we'll go out and get bids on March 20th. My goal would be to have, right now, if everything lines up, we'd have 11.5 million in the bank. We'd be looking potentially to, we're still doing some analysis to get that to 12. At that point, you start to say, okay, are we going to bid the whole thing or not? If it came in above that, that would be a May 16th decision point for town council. Okay.
32:54 So it would be nice to have a full $12 million sitting there committed. It's a multi-year construction project, so if some of it crosses the fiscal year, we can do that. But having that money committed would be very important. We can't recommend a bid that we don't have funding for. All right. Any questions for Dan specifically? Okay. And we're basically looking for a recommendation from the board, right? Not tonight. Not tonight. No.
33:23 Okay. We'll be going into town council. We'll probably be looking for our recommendations as we get closer to bid so we have an idea of our fundraising goals. Okay. So that was just information? Yes. Okay. Got to know the number. Yeah, got to know the number. Yeah, right. Okay. I was, I think I was talking more about the King's. Yeah, we don't have a dog in that hunt, so I kind of figured, you know. Well, we'll be a, no, you're right, we'll be a contracted party. Right, but, you know.
33:54 Since there's no outlay for us, I don't know, I mean, it's up to, yeah, Dan. I think the only question, you don't have to have a formal motion and stuff tonight, but as town council will be hearing the agreement with the Kings and commitment of money tomorrow night, it would, you know, we can say we presented the MLR and they're looking at it, I guess, for lack of a better term, be coming back later. We asked the rec commission, they took a formal motion, say yes, they support.
34:19 The agreement going forward. You could have the same thing or just be a consensus if you want. But it would be nice, pick on our council representative, if Member Richardson could report back that MLR was supportive of the agreement would help us just in thinking moving it through the town council process as well. So either by consensus or form a motion if that's appropriate. If not, that's fine. We can let them know that we presented the information. That'd be coming back later for other pieces with you all.
34:49 Thank you. I mean, I would, I, we haven't had a conversation about that piece of the park for, you know, specifically, I don't think, as a full board for a while, if really at all, beyond just kind of sharing whispers, I think. So, I mean, I know for those of us who've been involved in it, I would love to try and move to some kind of a consensus statement.
35:14 Moving into the town council meeting tomorrow night. But I'm curious as to where the other board members are on this deal. If you need some more information, some more context from an MLR point of view. I mean, I would share with you that we believe, Matt and I, who have kind of had a seat at the table, that
35:34 This is very much a cornerstone, this part of the deal for our efforts in fundraising, that it not only brings a million dollars to the table and, you know, it takes a little bit of pressure off of R&U, even though there's going to be another ask of R&U, but also is kind of an anchor fundraising piece against which we'll have a much easier time, you know, bridging
36:02 Whatever gap remains. And also bringing on, and we also feel like we have excellent support from their foundation side. And they're hooking us up with their sponsors and starting to make contacts available to us in the hockey community specifically that would benefit our efforts. So we think it's a big kind of piece of our...
36:29 relationship to this overall project. And we'd be happy to answer any questions that you guys have about the deal or how it's kind of gotten to where it is. Well, I heard $500,000, $250,000, so that $1 million is not going to be in one chunk. So how can that be actually thrown into the $11 million number that we're talking about that we need for the fundraising aspect of building this, correct? My understanding is that it's
36:58 It's going to be written into a contract, Dan. So, I mean, we can count that. Fundraising is not, you know, we haven't had a commitment. If we had a pledge from a donor, let's say I met with a donor, a prospect, a donor who's like, I'm pledging this amount and we had that in writing, perhaps we could count that back. So, I think that would be the primary difference there. The town's still going to need to fund that million dollars while waiting for that.
37:24 Contract to come in at $500, $250, $250, given the fact that that contract's going to start. Depends on how the bill goes. Right. That was kind of my, it's not money in the bank. We're talking 2019, right? Yeah, well, it starts. Uh-huh. But it takes a while. Yeah. Yeah, it's. And I can't tell you what the timing is. We're going to have to wait. It's not a bidding issue. It's a cash flow issue, as you point out. That's right. To reiterate Tom's point, I will say that the Kings partnership
37:54 would be a foundational cornerstone for our fundraising efforts, especially in Southern California. Not only are they going to be working with us to identify potential funding sources, but I think that it's going to give us some other outside leverage that we can use. And so that's money that does go directly back to offset if we have to, you know, take some, from timing, take some money out of
38:20 Let's say R.N.U., that we want to backfill that money. Ultimate goal from my standpoint is to make sure that we're not digging into kind of our resources here internally, that we're trying to pull all that money from external funding. Is there a strategy in place for taking what happens to the Kings and looking at that facility when it's non-hockey season or bringing up a well-known soccer team of the Shady Residence?
38:45 Yeah, you want to speak to that, Stu? Because Stu's actually have some great work towards that direction. I feel like that's a good, talking about being a cornerstone piece. The community's talked over, you know, what's the 10-year plan getting ready for 2028 in the Olympics? It seems like we have the Kings, we have other regional teams, we have the high altitude, we have the facility. It seems like a really good way to start that from a fundraising standpoint, and then we can leverage that as a marketing opportunity in advance of major games. It's a shame it's all coming down to kind of this.
39:13 One meeting with action tomorrow night because there has been so much going on in the last two years. So we apologise. I know there's a lot of questions. A lot of great questions. So the management support agreement with American Sports Entertainment Company, that organisation manages the Toyota Sports Centre on behalf of the Kings. They manage 16 rinks around the country. They also manage the LA Galaxy Soccer Centre. So, you know, we've been down there twice already and the way we're kind of configuring our amenity over here is the Olympic ice sheet.
39:39 On the Olympic size, because of that reason, we can fit three futsal courts, three volleyball courts, arena soccer, you know, and so forth. So really the goal right now is to, with this management agreement, it's a year-round management agreement, right? So it's providing programming, and we've actually got a list of services and camps and programs already kind of factored in as part of that agreement. So we kind of know a dollar figure that they're bringing to the table already. That was absolutely 100% in addition to what we're currently doing.
40:07 From a sustainability and programming point of view, that's kind of where we are from the commission's point of view. It's extremely intractive, extremely beneficial. You're working directly with the King's hockey development staff. I mean, they're building programs specifically for this rink. In the summertime, you know, if you tapped into LA Galaxy Soccer Centre, we were down there and it was, they had a soccer tournament on for the, you know, 8 to 12-year-olds playing futsal. I think they had like 10 futsal courts. They had that going from, you know, dawn to dusk. They had six volleyball courts going at the same time.
40:36 Even had table tennis back in the corner. So, I mean, that's kind of the opportunity that we're facing. So we really want to make sure that, you know, we're building something that we know we can program. And that's kind of been the discussion, certainly through the commission and certainly through ASCC, this company, to make sure what we're programming is what we can deliver and what the facility can provide, you know. So that's really been the real change over the last three months. I mean, just this chiller package situation, you know, the Kings want to bring their team here for pre-season camp.
41:05 Holy cow, right? I mean, how do we make sure we can have ice, you know, in September, right? So that whole chiller spec has changed. How do we make sure we're bringing, you know, adult hockey teams from all over the country, we have sufficient locker space and showers and those basic amenities for them. So that's kind of been the biggest shift in the kind of the design, making sure that, you know, programming is 100% driving the design of that facility. So, yes, with good assurance, I can just...
41:31 Say right now that we've spent a lot of time over the last two years essentially getting to this point. And I said it's just been a shame that we're here right now, you know, looking at a decision to execute this agreement. It's just, it's been a pretty challenging kind of road to get to this point. But it's, like I said, I mean, I'm not shy about changing. It's a real game changer for the community, right? I mean, you're not only bringing a multi-million dollar year-round facility to the community, you're bringing, you know, a national franchise brand with developed and approved and, you know, you know,
42:00 Phenomenal programming. Hopefully that answered your question, Scott. I would say international. International? There you go. Yeah, without question. They're playing in China now too, right? We're talking about one of the premier sports brands in the world and they're interested in our little community and, you know, kind of putting in to our new facility and it's really exciting and their interest hasn't wavered through. One bit. They got the vision early on and
42:30 I think it's a pretty incredible development separate from the million dollars. I mean, just the brand affiliation and the support of that organization through to the galaxy, through to the summer stuff that's possible is really, hopefully, a really long-term partnership that just keeps growing. I think to Matt's point, too, is that it also opens up a lot of pathways for fundraising.
42:59 Without question. Might not be there. Cool. So are we in a position now to make some kind of a consensus statement before town council tomorrow? I mean, I'm certainly supportive of it as a, you know, in terms of priming the pump and getting us going as a cornerstone fundraising piece. I mean, I think that they're, you know, my only reluctance, and I certainly
43:27 Trust you guys to negotiate a deal that's beneficial to the community, but my concern would be that we get starry-eyed, we give this big international sports franchise the farm, and where's the community benefit? If they're going to be, in terms of programming, let's be sure that we still have some community space for programming, let's be sure that there's not exclusivity in terms of naming. I mean, you guys know all this, but those are the pieces that I would eventually like to see.
43:57 I think that point's well made. I'm confident in the numbers. I'm confident, I mean, on the mountainside, we've seen the advertising value, you know, in that market from the very beginning where we wouldn't have already executed a contract with the Kings and agreed to go six years. So that makes a lot of sense.
44:19 It's about what happens on the ground at our facility, and that's our responsibility as a board is to make sure that this remains a bedrock community facility. So point very well made. And one of the points I think that's important is that I think MLR has been very consistent in maintaining that we want to see the complete build move forward. We don't want to see this thing chunked up because certainly while, you know, we...
44:47 Absolutely need a nice facility. We, as much if not more, need new community space with the center. We need the outdoor rec space. And so I think this affords us our best opportunity to do that without pushing it out and jeopardizing some of those projects, frankly. And I would remind the board that I think our kind of strongest early point of advocacy
45:12 as it relates to this project was about insisting that the community center be a piece of that from the very first kind of joint committees that got together and we started to try to get a two-for-one as we described it. And I think that's still very much our responsibility to speak up for that. Any... Betsy, do you want to add a comment? Yeah. Sorry, Betsy.
45:40 Oh, I do, and I'm sorry to interrupt your deliberations. I appreciate the conversation, but I, Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission. I did just want to say that, you know, the Recreation Commission is the, you know, advisory body to the council for community recreation. These are questions that have come up at commission. These are questions I've often asked staff as they've moved through this process in terms of, do the kings understand that this is primarily a community facility?
46:04 It's my understanding and what the commission has been told is that, yes, that is well understood. And, you know, just on a personal note, I'm very proud that, you know, the programming that we devised that informed the design of the facility took the interest of an international, you know, incredible sports franchise. So on the commission side, we just feel very confident that we can make this all work and that it is a community facility first. And I'll just say for my part in the negotiation, Stu has,
46:34 made that point loud and clear at just about every meeting that it's community first, big brand second. Thank you. So what do we want to, how do we want to achieve consensus here? Do we want to craft a statement of some kind? Do we want to just, in terms of parliamentary procedure, what do we want to do? We could say that the Mammoth Lakes Recreation supports the
47:12 Dan, do you have a suggestion? Oh, I mean, it could be pretty simple. I mean, if it's just a consensus of the MLR board here, what I'm hearing is that you support in concept, the agreement that's moving forward between MLT, Mammoth Resorts, and the town for the bringing the Kings into the agreement.
47:31 And for funding the facilities. It can be pretty simple. It doesn't have to be. Okay, let's do something like this. It can be really short. Yeah, that we support the town partners entering into this agreement with the Los Angeles Kings with the understanding that the community center portion of the build will not be sacrificed.
47:58 Community access. Well, Stu gave me this language here that perhaps we could say Mammoth Lakes Recreation supports the proposed partnership, will directly contribute to the completion and long-term year-round programming, operations, and sustainability of the community multi-use facility. I like the way Tom had it. Same thing, but it just adds that community benefit. Yeah, I'd like to add that. I think that's important. That's kind of what's resonating.
48:30 with the board up here. I'm going to want that with your edit. Okay, yeah, let's add the community piece to that statement. Okay, so can you, let me just write that down again real quick. So what was that, Tom? What I said was Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board is in favor of the town partners entering into the
49:00 proposed agreement with the Los Angeles Kings provided that the community center portion of the build is not sacrificed in the deal. Or should we just say the full build? The full build, including the community center.
49:28 I think it goes back to Betsy's comment, which is it's integral that this is a community center first that happened to be built well enough to attract the kings. It was not a facility built for the kings. They were going to let the community come into this. It happened to have a little room attached to it. If the kings are going to allow us to have the funding to put a chiller in, which actually can also expand our own seasonal programming or mitigate having to close the rink in March, that's great. That's an added benefit, but we're not putting the chiller in only so, hey, it's only going to get turned off their coming up.
49:57 I think that's the kind of mindset that we should have. I also think it gets back to the question for Stu and council and town managers making sure that the operation of this facility and the money to fund the operation facility also needs to be there along with outside sponsors. So I'm excited to hear the idea of a chiller, hearing that it had to get shut down right now, but if that thing only gets turned on when the big dogs come up with their...
50:25 With airplanes to pay for it getting turned on, the rest of the time we have that sitting there because no one wants to pay to actually operate it for the community, we've failed, in my view. I think that's a healthy perspective, you know, moving forward. Okay, so we have consensus with this statement. Let's go ahead and move on then to the inclusive playground. Do we have consensus? Do we have consensus? Yes.
50:55 Can I say yes? You can say yes. I can say yes, but can I mean yes? Yes. Okay. We have official consensus then. Thank you. All right. Let's move on. Who's going to update us on the inclusive playground? Is that Stu again? Mm-hmm. Okay. And just a reminder, I think just about everybody here was at the joint workshop, right? So I think we're all, yeah.
51:25 We're up to par, Ms. Beebe. Matt, can you send me that? Yes. Thank you for your support. Thank you for your work. It's a big deal. We really want to make sure we can do this all together, and yeah, everyone's buying into it, so thank you. Good questions. So really quickly on the inclusive playground, just presented this item this morning as well to commission. We kind of reiterated the action that council took on February 7th. I'm not too sure if I'm familiar with that, but they authorized staff to purchase the playground structure.
51:56 Came in a little bit cheaper. Work with Mammoth Lakes Recreation on the ad hoc committee and so forth as, you know, a little beta test for working together as kind of a great idea and good project management. Authorised staff to submit the special event funding request for the inclusive playground surfacing, which we did. We've submitted the NRPA Disney Play Spaces grant applications that's been submitted and then council allocated up to $75,000 of funds for the project as well to complete the project.
52:23 So as far as the details, we had a great meeting, as you know. We really, you know, defined our roles, responsibilities, which is great. I think we know where we're at. What staff have done is actually just put together a little project list that we can kind of all keep track of, and I just keep sending that to Matt. And then we'd like to actually get the ad hoc committee again together after we come back from conference next week. And really what we're looking at there is to affirm...
52:50 One, the playground schedule itself, so when you're looking at the community build, what are the details, what's happening on each day, you know, what resources do we need and so forth, when can we kind of really lock that in. We want to make sure now that we can commit to the playground surfacing and so forth, so we're kind of working through that timing. One of the action items here is actually get a banner out on that site March 23rd, playground coming soon, you know, just create some awareness in the community, it's exciting times, we can...
53:20 Maybe put it on the snow now. It's not going to go on the grass. It's kind of cool. We actually have our, and the timing, why that's important, on the 23rd is we have our Easter egg hunt and play day on March 30th at Mammoth Creek Park. So we're kind of really starting to program that facility more and more. So that's kind of the timing. We are working on kind of joint communications plans between MLR and the town. Our responsibility is really the community build. So you'll start to see a lot more information awareness, public outreach coming out about that.
53:49 And then we're really looking into May for the playground work and that's going to be part of the larger project. So again, really the update is that we're just working through multiple checklists. Betsy has a copy of that task list if you want to see it. It changes, it gets updated, it's a very organic, dynamic document. We want to make sure we're all staying on top of our tasks and deliverables and our roles and responsibilities with this project.
54:17 And again, the plan at this time, pending our schedules, is to kind of see if we can make that July 4th ribbon cutting. At this time, we have enough information back and enough bids back from the vendors that we are comfortable with the funding that we have, the contingency we have in place to get that project done. Very exciting. And then just quickly, I know Matt's going to probably speak about it quickly, but we're able to get the sales deck out. I know Matt did a
54:47 Phenomenal job. I didn't know if you wanted to show it. So that was the presentation to Rotary about the funding for the inclusive components. So that's a big part of that project as well. So we're really excited to see, you know, the larger service groups get behind the community build and the project. Do you have the deck to show? Thank you for that. I can show it on my left. Yeah, we put a deck together for Rich, who's graciously kind of stepped up and Betsy appeared before Rotary and we've given it to them.
55:16 Along with the outline of the budget. And so then we're also kind of using a modified version of that deck to do a hard print deck, which we'll take out. And I think MLR will be pitching funding to at least one organization or company in March and then possibly two, but one in March, definitely two by April.
55:44 Those will probably be $25,000. I'm expecting $25,000 asks, maybe more. So we're hoping to kind of, if we can secure this pretty quickly, we'd like to get this locked up, put to bed, and start moving forward, especially now that the full build's kind of in play and start moving our efforts to that. Can you remind the board what the total gap is less the $19,750 that we're considering tonight? I think the initial total ask was $75,000.
56:14 Right. So we're looking at about just over $50,000. Yep. Okay. If we can do more, we can do more. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, the goal for that project, too, is if, you know, if we secure these additional grants or additional funding, you know, again, it would be a great way to kind of broaden the inclusive nature of that facility and that playground if we can kind of increase the...
56:37 The surfacing and the access, you know, so any wheel device could get on and get in and around the playground. So at the moment we've got one little section and then the rest is the engineered wood fibre. But again, you know, with playgrounds you really want to make sure, you know, you broaden as much access as you can. So like the skate park, how you have the squares where everybody from the community comes in and donates, what are we going to do for this park so the community can contribute to it? I think the community build is probably the biggest thing.
57:04 And the donor acknowledgement, I believe we talked about actually trying to get a large, you know, plaque wall, donor, you know. Okay. Yeah, I mean, those are some of the things that's a great question, but I think what we want to do is be smart about this because we have, this is going to be one element of a larger complex. So we, you know, how we acknowledge our donors so that we do it in a way that is integrated with that effort, I think is important. So we'll continue to have those discussions.
57:34 You know, I think what's exciting about this specific project is that the community build is a way to engage the community on a very tactile, hands-on level, which I think plays into our strategy of creating advocates in the community. So then we go out and ask for the big money to do the big project. I've said this many times. It's like, when I'm down there and I'm going to start soliciting money, the first thing that those people are going to do is pick up the phone and call their friends at Mammoth and be like, hey, what's this park project going on? And if people up here are like,
58:04 You know, don't know about it or lukewarm on it. I'm not going to get very far. But if they're like, oh yeah, we were just out there last week and we built this playground and it's rad, that's going to create a lot of enthusiasm. And so I think that's really where the community is skinning the game at this point. That's where we need to direct that effort. And Stu, what are you valuing that in-kind contribution, the community build at? $70,000. $70,000. Yeah. I like the way this.
58:32 The kind of mixes where the community focus is on that build and then you're going after maybe a couple larger donations. Yeah, because I think we can close that pretty quick and I think, you know, getting the community for the bricks and stuff like that, that's really going to be, I think, critical when we do the big build, kind of closing in that last mile of fundraising. Big build mean the park and dental and the facility. Yeah. Now they're skilled workers, right?
59:02 Yeah, that's right. Such as it is. Hat, fist. Okay. Good to go. Tool belt. Tool belt. This won the definition. Yeah, you got it. Just out of curiosity, I mean, we're talking about doing a build while we're pitching to do another larger build. I mean, the consideration from a construction standpoint of resurfacing and building this park and then having to build the multi-use facility around it, has that been part of the bid process of this can't be moved, this can't be touched?
59:29 What's the interruption to that? I mean, doing this now versus doing it when it's closer to the multi-use facility being done? Abigail will ask that same question today at the commission. So public safety is number one. You know, we are required with the grant to get this up, you know, in a shorter period of time as possible. So we can't really push it. If we had to push it, we'd be pushing it two years. So really what we're trying to do is get it up and get it ahead of, you know, the rest of the project. Because of the grant. Yeah. Okay. But space construction who have been awarded the site work, you know, that...
59:58 Contract is basically on hold until we get further along with council action. So the plan and part of that contract is they're actually taking care of the removal of the playground, the excavation of the playground, in addition to their work on the site work for the larger facility. So that's all of the timing kind of getting built into the process now. And then Grady kind of talks about this great wall. You know, it's like a looky-loo wall with little holes and stuff that...
1:00:21 You know, the kids can come in and look, you know, from the playground into the site. Obviously, if we've got cranes moving around, steel beams and so forth, you know, we'll close the park. But, you know, again, we just want to get a jump on it, you know. So for Matt's talking about fundraising initiatives and programs, wow, look at the runs on the board that we've had. Look at this phenomenal inclusive playground we've built. It's, I mean, this playground park project is just going to be epic, right, or iconic. But anyway.
1:00:47 Sorry, that was a sorry slip. Okay, any other questions for Stu? Thank you, Stu. So Matt, can you walk us through, I know you're essentially recommending that we approve this out of our impacts to our, the finances of our
1:01:13 Your rationale for this recommendation. Right. So originally, you know, when we started talking about this, I was, you know, I tend to be a bit more protective about our new money. I like to kind of keep the integrity of those pots intact. And so I was like, well, let's just throw it in with the fundraising. But in talking with Stu, there are some timing considerations where, you know, if we don't get some of these elements.
1:01:43 done, specifically in this case, the surfacing, we stand to incur additional costs, and some of those costs can be considerable. So my thought was, hey, then if that's the case, then let's get them the money they need to commit to this now, and then we'll backfill that. So that's why I'm looking at kind of approving this $19,750.
1:02:08 to them. And then my goal, again, is not just to stop at doing the $50,000 for the gap. We want to raise as much money so that we can put this money back into R and make sure it goes out. So you'd love to kind of backfill this? Absolutely. That's my plan. And I'll remind the board, too, in terms of the idea of an inclusive playground in this town. I mean, we were, in our first year of existence, supportive of an inclusive playground, actually to the tune of
1:02:38 Half a million dollars out of our, that's before bonds were floated and parks were designed and so forth. But just in terms of context, the dollar figure that we're looking at here. How is the determination made? Because I heard something about, I mean, if more than the 50 is raised,
1:03:03 Does it do we automatically backfill or do we add components to the park? Because there were elements where it was like, oh, if we raise a little more, we can do we can put more surfacing or we can do some extra elements. So when and how is that decision made? Well, I mean, I'm working with the proposal that Stu gave to me that was approved by rec commission. So, you know, if there's going to be something above and beyond that, then.
1:03:31 I think we need to have a discussion about how those will get funded. But right now, I think the plan is to fund what we have in front of us. And then if there's additional scale, then we'll talk about it then. Okay. Yeah, I think from a process, if it's funded, get to that threshold, if we exceed it, and there's other opportunity, then the decision can be, well, we can either put that money back in the bank or we can spend on the other things. But there has to be a determination made at that time. Yeah.
1:03:59 That makes sense. My guess is those dollars will be much more difficult. People want to, you know, gift their money to something very physical and specific in the park, not repay. And there's already been some early enthusiasm. Yeah, we, you know, obviously, as I mentioned before, Rich and Rotary seem like they're very excited. We've had a town staff member, I'm not going to call him out by name, who's committed to buy.
1:04:25 A playground element. So I think it's pretty exciting. It's one of those things where if we have to have, you know, a jumping off point for the larger project, this is a perfect place to do it just because I think there's so much value to it for the whole of the community. Again, it's not just, you know, kids are going to be a central part of it, but as Betsy reminded me last week, this is really inclusive for everybody of all abilities. And I think it really puts a great face on this project.
1:04:55 Stu, sorry, I should ask you this when you were up earlier. Is there, since our workshop, are there any new risks to this timeline beyond kind of just the simple compression of the timeline? Okay. It's fine. Yeah, no, it's fine. Okay, I just didn't know if anything had transpired in between. Four feet of snow. Yeah, right? Exactly. Maybe more. Five.
1:05:24 At the park. Any further discussion? I'll entertain a motion if we're feeling strong about this. I'll make a motion to support the funding as requested with the caveat that once the full project is completed, if there are funds above that, they either return back into the measure where it was allocated from or could be allocated under review at a future time.
1:05:53 Yeah, and I think that's actually covered under donor intent. We couldn't use it for anything else. Okay. Because we're making specific asks for this park, so it's not like, yeah. I was saying that we would be looking at this 19 is basically being a loan out of MLR, potentially. Right. In lieu of not having the donor now. Right. The way I understand what you've proposed is that this is effectively
1:06:19 MLR is effectively making a loan. So if someone does make a donation above and beyond that, or does it say just a straight, it's gone? Because you're talking about coming back in. So if it's coming back in, that sounds like a loan. Does that make sense? I mean, I personally feel like we should make this allocation just as if it were out the door. The language about it coming back in goes away. I think so. But, you know, to your point, I mean, if we do raise monies above and beyond that are specific to
1:06:48 The park, I mean, I guess it's- Well, it's actually specific to this playground. To the playground. So it's restricted to this, is my point. We can't use it for anything else. So it can't come back in. So the idea of the money coming back in if we raise above and beyond it is a moot point. Well, no matter what, if we raise, I mean, it'd be different if we got like two million. I'm just throwing it out there, right? All right. But let's say that if there was something grossly over that, that we, hey, we couldn't ever build a park to that budget.
1:07:15 Then that would be my job to actually manage it and say, hey, look, we can only accept this amount and we take more. We're only going to accept what we can take in to complete this project for this specific task. So that would include the $19,750 that's coming out of R. And if there was more and we reach out to staff and say, OK, well, what other elements? Is there anything else we want to do to this? Great, we could go to that. But if it's something beyond that, then it's restricted. We wouldn't accept that.
1:07:44 Well, I think it depends on the donor. Yeah. We will certainly try to direct into the rest of it, but I mean, yeah, there's donor intent that we have to follow. So then if I'm hearing you correctly, once that 19 is approved, it's gone because we can't ask a donor to backfill it. It's not alone coming out. No, you can backfill it because that money is being used for the surfacing. Okay. You see what I'm saying? So if it had been used for something else, then yeah, we couldn't. But no, since it's been used for surfacing, it absolutely can backfill that.
1:08:13 I think in principle we all agree that if you can convince a donor to put another 19-750 onto the check, for that purpose, let's do it, but I don't think we need the language in the motion tonight, right? I mean, it has to be earmarked for the purposes, either physical, you know, actually funding.
1:08:41 Progress on the project or the backfill. It can't be anything else. Yeah. I mean, hey, if we keep going and maybe even funds the pizzas for the community build, I mean, we'll take all the money we can get until we can't take any more for the park. And then at that point, then we'll move them to somewhere else. But yes, we'll backfill every dollar, especially money that comes out of our reserves. Okay. So do you want to craft another motion? Do you want to stick with the one you said before?
1:09:11 I'll make a motion that we approve those dollars coming out of our reserves to fund this program. Okay. To the tune of $19,750. I'll second it. Okay. Any further discussion? Okay. All in favor of the... Any public comment? Public comment? Anyone? Two thumbs up. Thank you. Okay. All in favor...
1:09:44 of the motion? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. Okay. So I think we're, I've lost my agenda, but I think we're at the bridge, are we? Yes. Okay. So just a quick update on the bridge at Horseshoe Lake needs repair from last year. I think we talked a little bit about this before. We, MLR, is continuing to work with MLTPA staff.
1:10:16 And the U.S. Forest Service to develop the scope of work and cost estimate. And once we do that, then we can start putting together a campaign. So that is ongoing. I don't have a specific timeline for that, but it is on our work plan, and we are having those discussions. Okay. Questions, comments? I just ask, is there any timing you want to get this done by? John, do you have an answer for that?
1:10:49 I think that the first step is going to be to get an engineering assessment of exactly what is needed up there. Okay, that hasn't been done. It hasn't been done. It's under the snow. MLR really started stepping up once the so-called winter started happening. So we need to get an engineering assessment. It's kind of an idiosyncratic structure. Figure out what's involved with that. It's going to be tough to get Forest Service staff because of their time commitments.
1:11:15 It will follow the deliberate steps. It should be a relatively kind of a winning project to raise funds for. I think it would be very important to try to get that in place before the summer season really hits because you guys have all been on this bridge. You know what we're dealing with here. You kind of look at it. It makes this dip. And you go, well, that's a little weird. It still functions. But I'm sure structurally, for a lot of reasons, it's not safe. And I'd hate to get in a situation where the Forest Service would want to shut it down.
1:11:43 For some safety reasons. So I think that the MLTS team is working on that. They've got all eyes on that. And it's being pursued with all deliberate haste. Okay. Cool. Any other comments, questions? No. Matt, you have anything else? No. Okay. Okay. Let's move on to advocacy.
1:12:09 First up, Eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator position. We're actually going to take- Did we move the- Oh, sorry. Thank you, thank you, thank you. Apologies to the Mayor. Go ahead.
1:12:21 Good evening. I'm standing here in front of you, not as an elected representative of the town, but as a board member of MLTPA. MLTPA is working as part of what's called a Sierra Task Force with the Sierra Business Council. Steve Frisch will be here tomorrow night making a presentation in front of council, also the Placer County Land Trust in pursuit of endorsements for Prop 68. So I'm just going to run over a couple things real quick with you from this perspective. I may come back.
1:12:51 For another item as an elected official, but for this time I'm just sharing with you guys some information about this stuff. So I make this very simple. There's a lot of detail. There's a huge, enormous statewide effort behind both of the things I'm talking about. But for our purposes, I just want to keep this simple and easy to digest because the opportunities are very clear for us. There are two water bonds.
1:13:16 Headed for the voters in California. First is called Prop 68. That will be in the ballot in June. And the item for you this evening is for MLR to endorse that proposition. The second is something called the California Water Bond that will be on the ballot in November of 2018. Prop 68 is a $4 billion bond.
1:13:38 It's focused on drought, water, parks, climate, coastal protection, outdoor access for all act. $142 million specified for this Sierra for forest restoration, watershed health, and conservation. These funds can be spent on public lands. They can be spent for municipal projects. $142 million. I would add primarily that's going through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. The water bond in November is an $8.8 billion bond.
1:14:06 Primarily focus on water supply and water quality. $350 million is specified for the Sierra for watershed restoration and water supply improvements. $492 million is coming towards this. It's coming at us. And we're in a prime position to access these dollars. This is a graph that SBC put together that gives you some sense of all the bond issues that happened over California in the last decade or so.
1:14:36 I mean, we're looking at between the yellow and the green order of magnitude that has never been seen. It's five times what the region got from Prop 84. If you guys, I know you're all tracking your bond issues in the state of California and what they were worth and when they happened. Twelve times what the region got from Proposition 1. And the immediate return on investment, the ROI, has more than ever has been proposed for the Sierra. And I would add, just from an experiential perspective, MLTPA, when we were first getting started, we wrote a grant.
1:15:03 Back in 2006, I think, to the Sierra Nevada Conservancy that had just been formed, and they were awarding money from Prop 84, I'm pretty sure it was Prop 84 dollars, I think it was Prop 84, and it was about, it was all about water, water health, you know, water, clean water, all the rest of that kind of stuff.
1:15:21 And we wrote an application for funding for the Trail System Master Plan update, the logic being that good trails, good recreation amenities that are well-built, well-managed, well-maintained improve water quality because you're mitigating sediment issues, you're mitigating parking issues, you're mitigating people just having a negative effect on the landscape. And a good friend of mine and ours, Mike Schloffen, we asked him for a letter of support from the Forest Service, said, you're crazy.
1:15:49 Why are you wasting my time with this stuff? It was me and one other person in my apartment running a grant for $150,000 wrote it. Sure enough, we were awarded that grant, which got the trail system started in a big way. So even though it says water, remember that the Lakes Basin is a key water resource for the state of California. We all live in a whole water area. So we have almost an unlimited number of opportunities to access these dollars.
1:16:17 This is also return on investment for local projects. And these are, I won't go into details with this because we can spend hours talking about all this stuff, but for your portfolio.
1:16:25 You know, we look at half a billion dollars of projects that clearly fit within the portfolio of Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The walk, bike, ride program, which I'll talk about a little bit with some help from staff here in a second. And the regional public-public partnership that we're working on with Mono County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Humboldt-Toyabdi National Forest, and the Inyo National Forest in the shared position. That's how all this stuff comes together. And it's a unique.
1:16:53 Opportunity. And I know it's certainly a goal of Council for capital investment, to bring capital investment to this community. Please endorse Prop 68. Thank you. Can I ask you a question? Of course. So looking at Prop 68, no offense to you guys, I don't tend to trust my government that much. A little bit of carrot and stick. So everything sounds great, but there's two sentences in the language from Prop 68 that I was curious if you and your knowledge of it might be able to help me out with.
1:17:21 Great. I just lost the which of these 700 pages. Effectively, in the very first beginning, it talks about $540 million of Prop 68 going to water sustainability and flood mitigation. In my language, that oftentimes means dams. I'm curious if you know where LADWP stands on this and what kind of dollars they're going to be looking at to be able to create water reservoirs, more dams, any of that as part of this, because the language around water sustainability
1:17:47 Holding water, drought resistance in Southern California gives me a little pause and concern that there's like, oh, there's these shiny parks and lots of bike access. And then there's this other thing that's in it that's like, huh, like that sounds like the classic language of we're going to build more reservoirs. So my understanding, my understanding, Steve Fish will be here tomorrow night. I'm certainly asking these questions as part of his presentation. My understanding is that Prop 68, there is no damn money involved in Prop 68.
1:18:13 There is some question about dams in the $8 billion bond that was asked the other day on a conference call, but again, Frisch replied to that, there is no money for dams in that bond either. I think what matters to us is, in Prop 68, the $142 million that's...
1:18:30 Targeted at the Sierra. Most of this money will be going through the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. These are legitimate concerns. Certainly from a statewide perspective, these are things to consider. I know I spoke with some folks from the Sierra Club today. They're supporting Prop 68. The jury, I think the statewide Sierra Club is not supporting the bond, the water bond on the ballot in November. But I think local representatives of the Sierra Club
1:18:54 Appreciating how much value that's going to bring to the Eastern Sierra, they're going to probably split off from their statewide leadership and support it. That's my understanding. How far along are we just kind of building out a rough
1:19:09 Roadmap to the $142 million in terms of projects. Well, you've got, within your portfolio, you've got, the environmental work is happening right now for about 28 projects in the Sherwins. About 10 of them, I believe, will be done through a categorical exclusion, which means they will be shovel-ready projects. My understanding from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy is the applications for these funds will go out probably in the fall if the bond passes.
1:19:36 So there's a bunch of projects from there that are going to be ready. If you look at the walk, bike, ride program, which is being very aggressively pursued, and now that we have a working relationship with our local district ranger and local forest service, it's going to be many orders of magnitude easier to identify projects with them.
1:19:56 That it may not be new projects. They don't require a high threshold of environmental review and analysis. They may be improvements or just basic infrastructure maintenance. You look at the Horseshoe Lake parking lot, for example. That's not going to require a whole lot of environmental review or analysis. It's already a disturbed site. But the thing is, it's falling to pieces. I think that the public-public partnership we're putting together with the Forest Service and with Mono County, this is going to get us into a very unique...
1:20:22 I don't want to say the environmental committee, but the public lands community are still looking, have not...
1:20:38 The other piece that in talking with some folks at Sierra Nevada Conservancy,
1:21:08 You know, I don't know if we fancy ourselves a super sophisticated place, but we have the ability to do the environmental work, the CEQA work, the NEPA work. A lot of our peer communities in rural California don't have those tools. It's a huge threshold for them to be able to do the kind of environmental work necessary to be able to apply with shovel-ready projects. And we're going to be able to apply with shovel-ready projects.
1:21:33 That gives us a huge advantage with all this stuff, plus with letters of support from one, maybe possibly two national forests. Okay. What's, just reading the tea leaves in terms of the politics of these measures? I think Prop 68 is, there's, what I've heard, what I've been told is that it's polling well and they're confident it's going to pass. If you'd see the emails I'm getting from all the statewide campaigns and the Sierra Task Force and all this stuff, there's no shortage of
1:22:03 Effort and resources that's going into this thing. It's getting what it needs to prevail. We'll see what the voters think, but the initial word is good. The other bond was a voter-initiated bond, meaning that it did not come from the legislature. It was put on the ballot through a collection of signatures. And let's see what happens with Prop 68, and then we'll move on to the next one. They are two very separate
1:22:29 Propositions. They address very separate needs. It sounds like they're very similar, but the language and where the money is delegated and where it's focused goes to very entirely different sets of concerns. So they're compatible, essentially. Yes. At the end of the day, they're compatible. California is a kind of ridiculous way of funding things, but given California, they are a complementary. Any other questions for the mayor? And just to clarify, tonight we're only going to be voting on Discipline 68. Right.
1:22:58 Yeah, we'll come, you know, we'll see what happens in 68, we'll come back if the other one gets in the thing, we'll look at that one and see what that's up and see what to do with that one. Are we going to execute anything to demonstrate our support? Is this, are we signing on to a letter? Is that what's going on? What's, well, what's the ask? There's a form, there's a form, very simple form that you guys, staff could fill out, you send it in, and then you guys will be listed on the, on the. Got it, okay.
1:23:24 Pages of endorses. It's pretty amazing how much like Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes, it's a nice thing to kind of keep us on certain radars. $142 million will do that. Right there, yeah. Okay. Discussion, guys? I would move to endorse Prop 68 as Mammoth Lakes Recreation. A second. Second. Betsy, did you want to make a comment? Yeah.
1:23:52 I would. I want to thank John for the great presentation.
1:23:56 This may help you guys in your decision making, although it sounds like you're good. The commission has actually been tracking this since it was legislation in the Assembly and in the Senate, and we've been supportive. We actually sent a letter that we're happy to share with you guys. But I also wanted to mention that 10 years ago, the funding to build our current multi-use facility actually came from a very similar bond. There's also some per capita that guarantees that even though we're kind of a rural area, that we would receive some funding that can also be put toward things like
1:24:23 Deferred maintenance in our parks. So I'll just throw that on top of the excellent presentation. Great. Thanks. Okay. So we have a motion and we have a second. Second. Second. Okay. Any further discussion here? Any public comment? Okay. All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Motion passes unanimously. MLR is officially in support of
1:24:56 Proposition 68. So then a quick discussion. 501c3s are allowed to do a limited amount of advocacy in support of ballot measures that are supportive of their mission. So what I propose is that the restrictions are we can't obviously ask voters to
1:25:19 Take specific calls in action. What we can do is try to keep it education focused. So I propose that we do some town hall style meetings, invite people to come out. We have some speakers talking about the benefits of Prop 68. Ask any questions. If there's concerns, certainly people, you know, there's at least one person I can think of on council that has some, you know, valid concerns about how these things are getting financed. Certainly invite them to come up just so we can kind of have all viewpoints. I think what would be great if we could,
1:25:49 Pen an op-ed for the local paper. Perhaps a board member would be great to have that just because we want to keep these as low to zero cost as possible because there are some of the thresholds that determine that are the percentage of staff time, which I'm sure will be well below that, and then money will be well below that too. But if we can keep staff time, there is going to be some staff time costs, but if we can keep any kind of financial costs down, then we'll do that. And then the last one, probably work with Paul and some of the other radio owners.
1:26:19 to try to get on and maybe do some on-air discussions. I am supportive of those efforts, all three that you laid out, for sure. Okay. Sounds good. And once you kind of get a plan and timeline, just share with the board. Yeah, absolutely. Okay. All right. Moving back then to 6A. Yes. Update on the...
1:26:48 Coordinator position, the Eastern Sierra Recreation Coordinator position. So, John, or Dan, whoever. Yeah, just give you guys a brief update on this. So, I've been working, and Shields has been joining me now recently. It's great to have you part of that, those conversations. This started with a Town Council, Monroe County Supervisors Joint Meeting to talk about recreational opportunities in the Eastern Sierra. And it's led through a number of different meetings, and it's led to
1:27:20 Everything kind of really coming together. There are three tracks to this. The first is a funded agreement, a challenge cost share agreement, for you guys who know Forest Service agreements, between the Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest, the Inyo National Forest, Mono County, and the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:27:40 That agreement has been drafted. That will be reviewed. The working group is going to meet next Monday to kind of review that. This effort has gotten specific staff support from the Washington Office of the U.S. Forest Service because they recognize that these types of on-the-ground partnerships are the key to the future of the agency. So they're lending the support to make this kind of thing happen.
1:28:02 So that's moving forward. The second thing is discussion about the shared position, and that's gone through a number of different iterations. And council has requested some very deliberate...
1:28:14 consideration of the position. They've wanted to know, we've wanted to know job description, salary ranges, sort of technical things like that. These things have moved forward. They will now be included as part of our budget deliberations for next year. One thing that's really occurred to me in a meeting, I think that Matt and Tom and I, I'm not sure whose JEDI was working which way, but we all came to realize that
1:28:41 The perfect home for this position is really in Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And that's due to a couple things. The first way to illustrate this very briefly is Walk, Bike, Ride is a planning initiative that the council's been working on for a couple years. It's a critical part of the future for us as a destination. And the fundamental idea of Walk, Bike, Ride, if you look at this, is this is the town's urban core.
1:29:09 Urban growth boundary. This is where all the private property exists. But the town itself is a much larger proposition. 75% of the landscapes within our municipal boundaries are federal public lands. And the fundamental idea of walk-by-ride is to say for the town as a community, let's enlarge our focus a little bit. Let's go from looking at this to looking at this. This is the planning area of the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:29:33 This is a boundary within which we have some authorities, we have the ability to work with in this landscape, but it very significantly involves the county and very significantly involves federal public land agencies because most of that landscape is federal public lands. And when I show this at the last meeting we had to Bob Gardner, the chair of the Monaco County Board of Supervisors, was there and looked at this, and just going from this to this was a real aha moment for him.
1:30:01 And it should be for all of us too because we're now looking about ourselves and our community as this. And what's important about this as it relates to the position that we're talking about is that if everything out there is federal public lands or a national monument or it's got a bunch of different forests in it and a county, all of our ability to work and do things on this landscape is going to have to be permitted. It's going to have to go through a...
1:30:28 A contractual relationship with federal public land agencies. The town has a variety of permits. We have permits for snow storage areas, for trails, for culverts, for roads, for all kinds of stuff. I'm not going to characterize the state of those permits this evening, but if you look at the list and how many of them are current, that gets counted on one hand and maybe only a couple fingers.
1:30:54 The numbers of the permits that are expired or no one knows where they are, well, that gets into both hands and both feet. That's the kind of situation that we cannot be in if we're going to be, you know, engaged with this landscape for the betterment of the community. So that position is specifically focused at helping to facilitate that through that partnership agreement with International Forest, Mono County, and the HT to facilitate and identify how do we start working stewarding
1:31:24 And doing good things with this landscape for the benefit of our community, for the benefit of the public that comes to visit here. That's tied in obviously with the great marketing that's coming out of MLT. This is the product. This is why they're coming here. And we want to be good stewards of this. So that's what that position is fundamentally about. And I think it's appropriate to advise that with the change in the staffing at the local ranger district, we're looking at a whole new set of horizons. I'm sure the previous district ranger had a
1:31:53 Had a consistent, coherent management philosophy. It was not conducive to the kinds of partnerships they're looking at right now. The positions being flown over there, there'll be a new district manager over there at some point, but the current staff that's there that we're working with is really bending over backwards and doing everything they can to facilitate these types of partnerships and to make this vision that the town has to make this work. And coincidentally, MLR is here. And you guys, the original inspiration for setting this body up was
1:32:23 That. And you guys are this, the same way that Betsy and the municipal folks, they know what they're doing, they know what that's all about. And you start getting both of these things working, you have all cylinders firing. And that really starts to get us to realize the true potential of this place. So I just wanted to share those graphics with you, and if you have any questions, I'm more than happy to answer them. Okay. Thanks, John. Questions for John, specifically? Comments? Matt, anything from you on the position?
1:32:54 Pulling it into MLR? I mean, I will say that the position, since it was proposed, I mean, it was on the table when I got here, but, you know, it was very preliminary and it's kind of worked its way through now to being very close to fruition. I think it will be a tremendous asset for MLR and what we're trying to do. I think, as John says, there really is no hard boundary.
1:33:22 From the experiential side of recreation. There's nothing out there. You're on the trail and you're like, oh, well, I guess I've got to turn around here. So providing our guests that experience, this is something that has to happen. And I think our goal of taking what we're trying to do here in Mammoth and then eventually with the eastern Sierra of the county and scaling that out, this is also a big piece of that. And so I'm absolutely
1:33:51 In support of the positioning concept. You know, when we had the discussion and all of a sudden now it's in the realm of coming to MLR, you know, I'm excited about it. I have concerns about it. I think one of the concerns that I have is that we've got quite a bit on our plate with the projects and things going out. At some point I probably will, especially when we start moving into heavy duty fundraising.
1:34:20 Probably be spending a lot of time, you know, in Southern California and elsewhere working with donors and donor cultivation down there. This scope of work for this project, I'm still kind of ramping up on, so there's a learning curve for me. So, you know, I want to be cognizant of that fact that, you know, in managing this position, I want to be able to be in a position where we can provide some management. Certainly it's going to be taking direction from a lot of our partners, but...
1:34:48 At the end of the day, it falls to us. So I want to be sure that we are doing a good job and so we're not getting ahead of ourselves there. So those are the things I think about. Again, those aren't like deal breakers or souring me on it. Those are just things that understanding and trying to be a good manager, I want to look at and I want to make sure that we go into it with our eyes open.
1:35:12 That's kind of the big thing for me. There's other elements, smaller things like housekeeping. Where are we going to put them? We're already kind of tight and squeezed in MLT. We have to figure out a solution for that. That's relatively small. Funding absolutely is an issue, and I don't know whether John or Dan wants to speak to that. How's that going to be funded? I mean, that was kind of what pushed this conversation out of the town context and under us.
1:35:40 In a big picture, as John says, from 68, I mean, there's a lot of money out there, and I think this position will eventually be eminently fundable from an ROI standpoint, but the near-term cost, I want to make sure that we are not depriving other opportunities, especially things that we fund through, like allocation and Measure U stuff. If this means that, you know, some of our partners don't get funded, and when we get down there, I mean, we have
1:36:09 We have big funding requests already from allocations this year, only a finite amount to give out. You know, anything that affects that, that's a conversation we have to have as well. I just want to add just two quick, sorry, two quick technical things. The first thing is, this is, the county has committed funding for this position, and the idea is the county would be two days a week working for the county, three days a week working for the town.
1:36:33 The second thing I would add is the scope of work of this is pretty specific. It's around the town's interest is in permit management, you know, getting all of our stuff cleaned up, but then starting to look at leveraging opportunities, looking at these kinds of dollars. The third thing I would add is that this is really intended to be incubated between Mammoth Lakes and Mono County and the two forests up here.
1:36:57 I'm the chair of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments. We certainly represented this as something that if we can get this together up here, this easily, you know, becomes part of a regional, the regional baseline for the recreation stuff. And I think these discussions we're having about airports and moving air service, there's a lot of things about this that really start to frame what this region actually is for the long term. I just wanted to, I forgot to give you those points. Great, thanks. Just an operational question. So the funding for your role and how that's funded through MLR.
1:37:26 If you have 20% of your time is managing this person, is there any conflict with where those dollars coming from? Do you have to think about salary considerations for your time and the obligations to this for managing something that's for the county if it's two days a week and those are roles there? I'm just curious about what that constraint looks like. That's a good question. I don't know if Rob's still here or if Dan wants to speak to that. I mean, I will say one thing before Dan gives kind of a more technical answer.
1:37:55 Just in terms of mission, you know, we were in the endless crafting of our mission statements and our documents. We were very careful to talk about regional advocacy and impact. We were also very careful to talk about partnerships and being kind of the leading edge of driving new partnerships, both in the community and regionally. So it's, I think you're right in terms of due diligence to,
1:38:25 Understand, are we capable of this balance? I mean, that's our whole portfolio. We're arts and culture. We're recreation in town. We partner with municipal recreation providers. But we also have this regional component. So I think it fits right in there in terms of his alignment with our organization's mission. I don't know if there's any obstacles on the technical side. Dan, yeah, come on up.
1:38:53 Can I add to that also? Why would we put this underneath MLR and not the town? Well, I think just to extend what I was suggesting about our mission, I think the idea is if you buy into the NGO kind of framework, our role is to really extend the impact of the town in ways that government itself and its kind of packaging can't do, right? And I think
1:39:20 Those are two very appropriate places to do that is expanding regionally and with partnerships. I think that's something that is starting to prove out that our organization is starting to create partnerships that, frankly, town staff would never have the time to build on their own. And to be frank, I mean, there are some cost considerations that if this position goes under the town, there's cost considerations that...
1:39:48 You know, and their scrutinizing of it, some of the options were to kind of create two lesser positions or other options that maybe would have affected the overall effectiveness of this position and compromised it. So by having it under MLR, there is some cost savings. You mean in terms of employment? Yeah. And that would still allow this position to be the robust kind of scope that it was intended to be.
1:40:18 Dan, do you want to? I think there's three different elements of the funding sources. One is, as John mentioned, for that work that's in the county side, the county's funding that. They have a $50,000 allocation that they've been looking at over a period of time of a three-year commitment to be able to fund the position and hopefully successful in that time frame and it goes forever, if you will. The other side to that would be there would be some contribution from the town, probably in the $10,000 to $15,000 level, for some of the work on permits that are not directly recreation-based.
1:40:48 Some of them might be mobility or they might be, you know, the trails-based stuff, but the elements and also as John is showing in the graphic here, that outreach into a broader planning area as well. We always struggle with how much can we spend technically outside of our municipal boundaries. We have to show that it's a benefit directly back to the town. Some issues that way and concerns there. The other side of that would be, you know, the...
1:41:12 On the general fund side, we've already made a contribution into MLR, so that could be utilized if need be. It's an offset against what we're already doing for the executive salary. The other side for these types of positions, any type of fundraising, this is a nice part that could be done by Mammoth Lakes Recreation coming in for operations, unless somebody is restricting that in the donation. Frankly, if it's about growing this recreational offering that we have, then there's no restrictions on that type of funding.
1:41:41 It becomes much more as part of, as Tom was talking about, as part of the mission of the organization. So our funding does get restricted. Again, the RNU voter initiatives, very clear, here's what you can spend the money on. So we need to work within the concept of those, concept of local government, what we can do. And then as a nonprofit NGO delivery model, the idea there is if you have other dollars coming in, you know, here's a dollar donation, then
1:42:09 That is freed up to really say how do we broaden that scope of this recreational offering that we're doing. Then obviously with the county dollars that comes into play as well. Some grants will have admin time in them, some do not. If you get those elements up, that can offset some costs too depending on the type of grant and what you're doing that way. So I think we can work around the funding issues, frankly, work through that. I think there's options to make that work. If I understand you correctly in leading the conversation with
1:42:38 The discussion on Prop 68, if this person sat under MLR and they were writing a grant or some funding out of Prop 68 that was countywide, if they were a town employee, they couldn't really be able to do that because it's outside the jurisdiction of the town. It would be much harder for us to write a town grant that's being spent in the county, correct. Unless we're funding with county dollars, part of that. But yes, that is correct. What are the naysayers saying to this position, people who don't want to...
1:43:06 I wouldn't say that I would say I haven't heard people say don't do the position. When the town looked at it originally, we were looking at doing the full funding for it. The issue was there that it needs to come back as part of our budget process, and how does it compare against other needs in the town? Is that more important than a code enforcement officer or admin staff or a police officer or patching potholes? So it goes into a much larger context of priority setting.
1:43:33 And that element of it. So, I mean, it can still go through that process. That's where it was headed initially. We had some conversation. John and I had some. And then with Matt briefly in terms of does it fit better over here to just take that issue off so it's not a doesn't have the same competition, if you will, for priority settings that we'll have in town. That would be I don't think people are opposed to the concept. It's is it more important than when it comes to hiring this person? How does that process work?
1:44:02 We would assist as need be with MLR doing the hiring. You'd have a regular outreach program requesting interested applications. You go through the interview process. Hopefully you find somebody who's very qualified to step in, put together an interview panel, et cetera. We can work together pretty easily. We've done a handful of them.
1:44:22 That's what I'm kind of wondering. Is this going to be like a board thing or is this a you thing? No, absolutely. We'll have the board involved. Board involved. Yeah, it wouldn't be a full board. And we have the job description. So I think just probably what might work is maybe we should create an ad hoc committee, what I'd recommend. And then we have an ad hoc committee. Use that. Make sure we go through the job description again to make sure it's tailored to our needs as well. And then answer some of the questions regarding bandwidth, responsibilities, things like that.
1:44:51 and see where we land and then work with the town and the county to open up that search. Does this role exist in any other county that we know of? Not right close to it. It's across the country. I think there's probably some examples out there, but I don't know of any that are right here in California this tight. There's some across the country that's been done, I believe, but not. There are a couple. I've seen a couple of examples of this, I think, in Utah.
1:45:20 They have some examples of this kind of thing, which is about, it's kind of a combination economic development, look at all the great stuff we have here kind of position. Frankly, we're on the cutting edge of a lot of things on public lands issues, and so we're blazing a lot of new ground. This is entirely consistent with the Sustainable Recreation Policy coming out of the Forest Service. This is consistent with leadership direction coming out of Washington, D.C. That's probably why there's a focus on what we're doing, so we're blazing some trails here.
1:45:50 I ask because I think the attention that Colorado and Wyoming and the others have gotten for having their offices of outdoor recreation. So we talk about fundraising and the idea of this, my view is the idea of this sitting under MLR does put us in a position of being very on the cutting edge. Ideally, this would be a position that would be funded out of Sacramento and would sit on that side of the hill with regional offices. I think we're a long way from seeing that. So as a county and a community to do that first and do it under an arm that can go fundraising, I think it's a really unique opportunity for us to get.
1:46:18 Even some media around that effort from this small community doing something pretty proactively. Yes, and there is a conversation about the State Office of Outdoor Recreation. I think it's on your agenda later. We can talk about that a little bit. I would advise also that Stacey Corliss and Bob Gardner are back in D.C. right now at the National Association of Counties where they've established an outdoor recreation caucus as part of the National Association of Counties that, again, the Forest Service and Federal Public Land Managers are supporting.
1:46:46 Based on the examples that we're setting out here to start changing the conversation around in rural counties. And this, we put this whole package together. It's like, look what the Eastern Sierra is doing. And I think we can all imagine what, if this works, it gets into Inyo, this airport thing, as we're pursuing that. This is, you know, the lost land of the Eastern Sierra of California that's now falling in between a very...
1:47:12 proactive, engaged outdoor recreation movement in the Intermountain West. We're getting lost between them and the coast. But this is the road that we're going to get on to stand ourselves up to play that unique role that we play already in the outdoor recreation community. Thanks, Ryan. So back to the short-term funding. I might get the ROI thing for sure. The short-term funding, we're talking...
1:47:37 50 from the county for three years, 15 or 20 from the town, and then are we looking at 15 or 20 coming from R or U? Is that the general scenario? That's, well, Dan just stepped up, but that was my understanding that we're going to be pulling money from not R, but from U. Okay. I'm thinking we would benefit us to...
1:48:05 Kind of walk through our projections again now that, I mean, when we floated the bond, we had a kind of very developed picture of how that would affect us for the next three to five. I can't remember what the time horizon was, but now with some of these other changes that have happened since then, I think we should go through that same exercise. I agree. I mean, Heather and I have talked about this quite a bit because, you know, just looking at you,
1:48:33 My kind of back of hand math, especially with all the kind of commitments that are now starting to pop up, we could burn through that money in easily from the next few years, if not less. And so I have some concerns about it. And the problem with you is that it's not as, it's more dynamic than ours. Ours is pretty stable. I met with Dan yesterday and we talked about this. You have some variability to it. And I don't know if you can add anything to that, but I looked at some of those trend lines and since it's utilities tax, you know.
1:49:04 Okay. What had me concerned, and I was talking to Matt about, is that we've got these multi-year allocations that we're giving people those three years, and then we've got new commitments coming in, or asks coming in, and then we're going, some people are asking for multi-year funding for another three years. And then if we continue to give these people multi-year funding, it's burning our reserves, what we can give to, you know, one-time event or special events, and eventually, and then with this position also, it's going to burn out a lot of our money. So how do we have longevity? Where do we see ourselves with having funds in three years from now for allocations? And that was part of the...
1:49:33 I want to have another discussion about these multi-year allocations, why it was put into place. I understand some parts of it, but this right here kind of puts a bump in the road. I think we're asking the right question. I'm feeling from the board, just from the conversation, that this is to pilot something like this. It's a fantastic opportunity that really aligns perfectly with a portion of our mission.
1:50:02 But we have to do so with making sure that we have management capacity and that it's fiscally responsible. And look at this position. I mean, what's the long-term plan? How is it going to be self-funded? Because that's really what it needs to be. That's where the ROI comes in. I truly believe this position is a...
1:50:25 A ROI type position. Yeah. I think it's a massive magnifier if it's done correctly. If we really think it through. No question about it. I think it needs to happen. I'm going to just figure out financially how do we do responsibly. I mean, I'm looking at the concerns we're bringing up just as things we need to solve for. Not so much barriers to anything, but things we need to internally solve for. I mean, and I think it's, there's no question that the position will bring
1:50:53 ROI in from a macro level, but from a specific level, you know, when the past, when I've done fundraising and it's grant fundraising, like especially private, there you can write in administrative. If it's donations, you can do, or if it's password, you can take administrative costs. I'm not sure how that works when we're talking about government grants coming in for projects that, for a position that we own. We can't write in an administrative, to my knowledge.
1:51:22 Maybe you can, maybe you can't. I don't think so. But I just want to make sure that we have, again, we go into all these things with our eyes open. Well, it depends on who's benefiting. Yeah. Okay? And there's going to be a lot of people benefiting or organizations or governmental. So I think you go back to them and say, wait a minute, you know, this position right now is costing you $50,000, but it's making you $200,000. You know, you need another $25,000 from you guys. I think that's a way to go about it.
1:51:53 Correct. So what kind of action are we looking for? No action. Just information only? Just information only. Again, well, if there is an action maybe that we decide to create that ad hoc committee, I think that would be prudent. Okay. Sorry, I don't see Dan here, but I think if you want to assign some people to do it, I know with Shields, we've got a meeting coming up on the 19th that's going to be laying out this, again, with the partners involved in this, representatives from the HT, Humboldt-Toyabe, Inyo National Forest.
1:52:25 Washington Office of the Forest Service, Mono County. Matt, you guys were at the last meeting, but I would encourage, you know, to delegate someone to coming regularly to those meetings because it's coming together and it's going to be headed for council, you know, in the near term. And so it'd be good to...
1:52:41 Get this all figured out so we can move forward with this. I would love to be a party to those meetings. It's just the last two or three have been on Wednesday mornings, and I'm dead on Wednesday mornings. This one would be the 19th. Well, I'm sending out all the notices, so let me know who I should be sending it to from your board so you guys get it. And people can call in and things like that. It's fairly loose, but the people need to be there, tend to be there. Okay. All right. Further discussion? Public comment?
1:53:14 All right, let's... So do we have to agree to... I don't think we were going to take any action. No, not to create an... Oh, you mean to basically assign board members to the meetings and a committee? You were talking about a search committee for the position, right? Well, I think for the whole thing. That would include search. Yeah. But we just have an ad hoc committee. The reason it's ad hoc is it will have a finite... Yeah, yeah. Okay.
1:53:42 Okay. You don't need DEVA vote to create an ad hoc committee, to my understanding. Okay. Let's, maybe you and I work on that. Okay. We'll contact board members. But I'll ask, is there anybody who would very much like to be on that committee? Okay, Scott. Perfect. Great. Follow? There we go. Solved. Okay.
1:54:10 Looks like we're getting an update on mobility. Walk, bike, ride. Is that coming from John? No, I'm just going to give a quick update. Do we want to take a break? I know that we're kind of at... Yeah, and we still have a good bit to get started. Let's take a little five-minute break. Yeah. Okay. Mike's on. We are back in session. So I think that concluded the... Wait a second. I'm sorry. We were about to start in on the walk, bike, ride.
1:54:46 And Matt, do you want to kind of bring us up to speed on both where the project as a whole is and what our role, our emerging role is looking like? So on the walk, bike, ride document that I distributed to you, the items that are kind of in yellow are the high priority items. And so we just had our
1:55:14 Second mobility committee meeting. So mobility committee is a subcommittee under walk, bike, ride. It's where this, this, and this document I distributed is the kind of action steps. And so you'll see that there's lead agencies and partner agencies. And so the CED has sent people out and said, okay, you know, kind of work on your areas and we'll come back for the mobility committee and report.
1:55:43 The last mobility committee, they took off some items. Those are the items that are highlighted in blue. So those are the ones that have been tabled for now for various reasons. The yellow were the ones that have been identified as high priority. And then the ones that are in pink are the ones that MLR are leading on. And so of the remaining ones that MLR are leading on, we're kind of dividing, conquering with the MLTS staff and crew.
1:56:13 Or partners, I should mention. So the loop trails, transit hubs are being led by MLTS, and Joel's been working on that. And then long distance hiking hub, bike share, pilot, and bike share, which are kind of combined, and e-bikes are being led by MLR.
1:56:40 At the last committee, we've made actually significant progress in the bike share pilot. I spoke with South Lake Tahoe about their pilot that they just completed last summer. I don't want to go too deep into that, but basically it was a very big success. The ridership in South Lake Tahoe actually exceeded per capita the ridership in Seattle. There were more people utilizing those bikes.
1:57:05 The things that stood out to me was the average length of ride was under nine minutes and less than a mile. And so what that tells me is that people were using it for transit. They weren't using it to kind of go out and do all-day rides. I think part of that is just by design. The bikes themselves were hard tires, single speed. And so, you know, one of our concerns from the get-go was we didn't want to, if we did adopt a bike share pilot, we didn't want to do anything that cannibalized opportunities for our local businesses.
1:57:35 In talking with Councilman Bustianos down in Southern California, his district, which is kind of in that Harbor Gateway, they also do a bike share pilot. They've had very similar results where the bikes were being used for a very short duration. Theirs was a little bit longer, but usually within about a mile. So heavy transit use. I asked both folks that, you know, how was it for maintaining the bikes, losing the bikes?
1:58:05 Tahoe wasn't a problem at all. They said most of the bikes were, you know, fairly well kept up. There wasn't a lot of vandalism. There was a little bit, but not much. Didn't lose a lot of bikes. What they do is, and these are both hubless, meaning that people can take the bike and leave it wherever they want. And then at the end of the day, line bike staff would come and collect them and then put them at these distribution points where most people were picking them up and they kind of track that stuff. All these bikes have GPS on them. I should mention that both Harbor Gateway and South Lake Tahoe use line bike as their principal partner.
1:58:34 I also talk with the city of Long Beach. They use a different partner and they use a hub system where the bikes have to be collected from and put back into specific hubs. Their usage was moderate as well, but they didn't have the same kind of stellar results and they have to pay for that. The ones in South Lake Tahoe and Harbor Gateway, almost no cost, I think zero cost to
1:59:03 Those communities, Line Bike paid for it. And the kind of interesting part was when I did an investigation and Line Bike only charges a dollar for every 30 minutes. And how you do it is you go and you take your app and that unlikes the bicycle and then you just take it and then when you're done you close the app and you do it. And so I talked to a representative from Line Bike and I'm like, how do you make money off that? That just seems counterintuitive. You guys are doing all this work, you're collecting the bikes, you have to replace all the broken ones and da-da-da-da. I'm like, how is this even profitable?
1:59:30 And he's like, oh, he kind of hemmed and hawed, but basically what I ended up gleaning from him is that they're selling all the data. So all the usage, all the stuff, the apps and everything, they're basically an information company, and Line Bike's just a way that they collect that information. And so I thought that was pretty clever. So there's definitely interest on their part to work with Mammoth Lakes. They understand the visitation that we get.
1:59:55 And so I think what we want to do now in this step of process is take this information, then I'll regroup with Ken Brangle from the Chamber side on all these conversations with the exception of the one in Long Beach and kind of put those findings together, go out and meet with some key partners, maybe the folks at Footloose or some other people who are renting bikes and say, here's what we found. We don't see that there's going to be
2:00:19 A lot of opportunity for cannibalism. We think that people aren't going to take a line bike and ride it up the trail with a leg spacing. They're not going to take it for an hour or a half day or all day. What they could use, though, is they could be used by a lot of our employees to get back and forth to work. Parking is always a consideration. If this is something that can facilitate that, then that's going to be great. So we'll get their feedback. We want them to punch some holes, and then we want to be in a position where we can come back, report to the Mobility Council, and eventually get that in front of Town Council. I think that's critical.
2:00:49 Having a community little sit down with the retail stakeholders. Absolutely. E-bikes is not quite as far along, although we've had made some movement. We've actually been working with the folks over at People4Bikes, and they've done a lot of advocacy and outreach for e-bike usage. Obviously, the conflict there is that it's motorized, and how does that work with trail, with Forest Service especially?
2:01:15 We have a call with them on Friday. They actually are, there's a potential for them to put some money in to help us kind of build out a program and figure out what we want to do. You know, I think the challenge with e-bikes is that the technology there is developing so rapidly that, you know, from an, already from a distance, you couldn't tell like a lot of these off-road e-bikes from a normal enduro bike.
2:01:41 And so this idea that, you know, we're going to somehow be able to police them, you know, especially the class ones off trails, I think is probably unrealistic. So we really need to get ahead of it and develop a plan. So I think they're going to help us with that. And then obviously MLTS is very involved as is Forest Service they've been sitting in and we have to have those conversations. I think that for your and my conversation, we also need to figure out and connect with Caroline Casey and the folks up at the mountain, figure out what you guys.
2:02:10 Kind of plan of attack is. And then plan already built and submitted. Oh, really? Yeah. Those conversations should probably happen now to align everybody. Perfect. Yeah. Because we don't want to be in a position where you guys are doing something and we're doing something else because then the public's going to be like, why can we do it here and not here? So there needs to be alignment on that. So I'll try to schedule that meeting as soon as possible. Interesting. I guess the folks.
2:02:35 From Bosch are going to be out at this trails conference I'm going to. So maybe we can talk to them as well. And then the last thing was the long distance hiking hub. I had a conversation with a representative from the PCTA, the Pacific Rest Trail Association. Very interesting conversation. Wasn't very helpful. They didn't have a lot of hard data, surprisingly. I was like, well, you know, how many hikers are you getting on the GMT and the PCT? Are we talking to Justin?
2:03:03 I spoke to, okay, I can't remember his name off the top of my head, but, and, you know, he had some numbers, but they weren't something that was really verifiable. What he did say that I thought was interesting is that there is kind of a fairly big gulf, a knowledge gulf, from basically Kennedy Meadows all the way up to Tahoe. So this whole range of the Sierra, there's like a knowledge vacuum, even though this is like one of the most traffic sites and people are really psyched about it.
2:03:33 And he didn't really know why that was, and it would be kind of interesting to find that out. You know, we talked about a little bit about the resources here at Davidson Guesthouse. So what we're trying to do is basically do a needs assessment. What needs are out there? And then once we identify those needs, kind of put them into three categories. Needs that we can address with existing infrastructure, needs we can address with maybe some modifications to existing infrastructure, and needs that we would have to build new infrastructure for. And then take that back to...
2:04:02 Mobility committee and then get that in the walk, bike, ride plan. So that's kind of where we are with walk, bike, ride. Great. Cool. Well, I'm stoked that we're taking lead on a couple of these things, independent of other partners, too. I know we're all working together, but I happen to be excited about the ones that we're involved in as well.
2:04:26 You know, to your point, e-bikes is, I do believe we're going to get to a point where they will be completely indistinguishable from just, you know, traditional pedal bikes and it's something we've got to get ahead of. Right. You know, something that we should be out front on and, you know, whatever the strategy looks like, it's got to be forward thinking. Especially the class ones, I think that's going to be the big deal if we can kind of figure out a way because
2:04:52 I mean, just look at the Lakes Trail, what an incredible asset that is, is if we're sending people up there, I mean, we want to be able to do it legitimately, so, yeah. Cool. You mentioned funding. Was that funding through e-bikes? Is that funding through bikes? Yeah, for people for bikes, I think that is funding to help support kind of some fact-finding and advocacy.
2:05:15 Just try to get some information. We did ask them, and if you want to, Scott, if you want to sit on the call, we're having one on Friday with Alex from People for Bikes. We asked him what communities are doing it well, and he mentioned some communities out in Colorado, I think maybe Durango, but he's so far been the most helpful. They've been working, like I initially reached out to Giant, who I have some partnerships with, but they actually, the deck they sent me.
2:05:42 Was from People for Bikes. So it was really good that we kind of just all connected on that. So they have a lot of good information that we'll probably get a big download on on Friday. Actually, I have another question. Just conceptually, I think I'm missing something. You were saying there are kind of two models for the line bike program. One is hub-to-hub. Yeah, one is hub-to-hub and one is non-hub. So how do you...
2:06:10 You kind of unlock the bike with an app. Yep. And you pay as you use. But if you're not kind of re-hubbing it as such, how do you? As soon as you close the lock, it communicates with the app and shuts the timer off. The lock on the bike. The lock on the bike. Got it. But you can leave it anywhere. Yeah. And then they have stuff that can unlock the bike anywhere. So you're unlocking the bike, not unlocking some mechanism that it fits. I understand.
2:06:39 So if they want to ride down to Rock and Bowl, and there doesn't need to be a hub there. They can just leave it there. You know, and so I think for us, that's a great advantage. Well, most, you know, people that are coming up here to recreate are going to ride an e-bike around here, you know, to go up and down the mountain. So I see that, you know, like you said, the single speed or whatever will be more for the local, you know, point to point. Or certainly locals, and I think in the summertime... I'm sorry, have you ridden up Main Street?
2:07:09 I'm sorry, have you ridden that Main Street? Main Street's tough, but I think just kind of there's a little different South Lake Town. Yeah, it is, a little different, that's my point, I'm likely.
2:07:18 Main Street, riding your bike up Main Street. That is not easy. That's what I'm saying. Yeah, right? Yeah, but, you know, for locals. This is not, like you said, South Lake Tonto. The Village is not the same as riding through Kings Beach. No. No. Exactly. We're hardy folks. Riding up to, like, Liberty Bar, and then riding out to Rock and Bowl, and that kind of L with the condos mixed in would be kind of where they, where both the community and the visitors, the summertime visitors, would probably take most advantage of it. They're not going to ride it up Main Street, certainly not up to the Lakes Basics.
2:07:48 In that aspect, I think there's very, very little. Yeah, Snow Creek Athletic Club. Yeah. So, maybe, yeah. I don't need you to be on the call, but as you start talking about funding through People for Bikes, I'd like to just have a side conversation with you about that. Okay. And maybe some opportunities for you on some fundraising requests through them. That'd be great. Some insights on that. Yeah.
2:08:12 We should probably share that with John because they're kind of, he's got a little bit closer relationship than I do. I've just been sitting on the calls, but yeah. Yeah, their primary funder has a house here in Mammoth. Oh, really? Yeah. That's good to know. Okay. Yeah. I'll make sure we get you close to that. Okay. Thanks, Matt. Anything else on walk, bike, ride? Okay. Moving on, an update on Corp, California Outdoor Recreation Partnership.
2:08:43 So, I think there were, who was out there? David and Scott and myself and John was out there as well at the Corp meeting in Denver. And so, you know, there was, it was an interesting meeting. There was, Steve Barker, was there at that meeting? Barker, Steve's kind of in.
2:09:04 Championing, I think, a lot of that and supporting Kenji on the effort so far. Yep. And then I can't remember the two gentlemen's names from REI, but they were pretty high up the food chain there. The guy that came in at the end is, I forget his name, but he's been relatively new the last couple of years. He's the head of environmental affairs for REI. And so they've gone on. Environmental affairs and public relations, I think they've combined those two together. Yep. And then Callum was there for OIA. So I think the conversation at that point...
2:09:33 is twofold. One, is the organization going to be Big Ten or is it going to be industry driven? And then, you know, how are we going to fund this? Because it just seems like it's kind of slow rolling right now, which is the volunteer. I don't know if we came out of that meeting with any discernible movement. I did have a follow-up meeting down in Laguna Beach with Kenji making my pitch for Big Ten because my concern is that, you know, I understand that
2:10:02 Having an industry-led organization will get it out of the station faster, but I think what happens is there's a knowledge gap because NGOs, land managers, they have that kind of fingertip feel of what happens on the ground, and so as these policies get created, there's disconnects on what may be actually needed.
2:10:22 But there is that, again, these are slow-moving, laborious things because you're trying to build consensus out of a lot of different stakeholders, especially in this case. And so my information from John, who had met with Steve Barker, and I think you had heard the same thing, is that they were, sounds like they're leaning towards doing a industry-led lobbying group, and that's the way it's going to go, so probably won't be Big Ten. Was there, I had a call with those guys.
2:10:50 I was in during the summer and I was kind of unclear which hat I was wearing. Mountain hat, MLR hat. Sure. They were understandably more interested in the mountains participation. Because they want money. Exactly. They were looking to create kind of a steering committee structure. Is that still the case, that they have some kind of core, and you were mentioning REI? I think they do, but there's, I think the challenge with doing it industry-led is that it's,
2:11:21 Rooted in an outdoor industry association from five years ago mindset. And if you look at the OA numbers and the state of California from a recreation opportunity, things that we saw, at least I thought were glaringly missing that is no one had gone and talked to the surf industry. No one had gone and talked to the sport fishing and the scuba diving industry on the coast. When you start talking about outdoor recreation in the state of California,
2:11:45 and engaging the coastal communities. Like, it's great that there's, you know, and I'm obviously I'm biasing. I put my outdoor industry hat and the product I had and there's great sides of that. But I don't know that going out and trying to get, you know, Columbia to leave Portland and move to San Francisco, which is more of an industry approach to bringing business in, is the same as going out and saying collectively.
2:12:07 What is the value of outdoor recreation in the state of California? Who provides outdoor recreation? What's the economic benefit to the communities? And how do you start to focus on outdoor recreation? And that's where I think Colorado's done a really good job with what they've brought in with Luis is they've said across the whole scope, this is what it looks like. This is what the culture of that feels like. You go to Silicon Valley, there's a culture of tech. If the state thought about a culture of outdoor recreation, which we're known for, for health and wellness and all those other things.
2:12:34 Then the industry component, I think the industry component tends to follow that. So if you start with the industry component, you leave a lot of people away, but if you make the big tent, the people are going to come into it because it just makes sense where they're at. I mean, I appreciate where they're going, but it's like, I think, a little prematurely, they came up with the name, they came up with the logo, and they had all the stuff that was there. It's great, but it was like, there wasn't a really clear, okay, what does success look like? And that was like,
2:13:03 That seemed a little crazy to me. I would absolutely agree with that. That kind of was my pitch to Kenji is I'm like, look, you know, you guys have a lot of success in, you know, Colorado, Wyoming, some of these other places. And I go, California is a completely different beast. Number one, you cannot even talk about recreation in California without including the coast. That is recreation. That's the big driver. And, you know, for whatever reason, they thought they were going to get money from SEMA. And I'm like, I popped that balloon.
2:13:30 I'm like, look, you're talking about an industry where every one of those companies are teetering on the edge of bankruptcy. So they're not going to give you anything. And so, you know, they are going to go. But no outreach to Surfrider. Huh? But no outreach to Surfrider. They did. Yeah, Chad's been working with them. But, I mean, they're not in a position. Chad, the most they can write is a $5,000 check, right? So it's like, I'm not quite sure how they're going to get this to sail through as an OIA thing without,
2:14:00 Having that coastal representation. But I think, be that as it may, the conversation that we want to have, and I think this does play in with us pursuing things like this public-public position, is that what can we do here to make sure that we have a voice in this movement to establish Iraq in our state?
2:14:21 So, and meanwhile, it continues independently of Corp. I mean, there's a, there's, there's new, you know, it's newly named legislation that's the same as what was last year, but it's up again. Now it's, now it's AB 1918. It was, we signed on in support of AB 907 last year. Now it's AB 19, sponsored by Eduardo Garcia. AB what, 1919? 1918. 1918. How was that?
2:14:48 Email chain just went around. So we're still signed on to that. We'll be signed on to the new letter as MLR. Yeah. You've already talked to Doug. Yeah. I reached out to Doug and said, keep us on the letter. Right. And I, there was a, actually, I'll take a look right after this, but there was a follow-up from them, I think, maybe asking us to do something. I've got to get another mailing list. I'll email out to them. But, yeah, if you get anything for that to me in the meantime. Okay. Yeah.
2:15:15 So there's no real formal role for us with Corp right now? I don't think so. But I think, I mean, for what we've talked about here, we're in a great position to try to give the Eastern Sierra a voice. I mean, this is a big, big...
2:15:32 component of that, I think, right? I also think that between MLT, MLR, MLTPA, the county, the Forest Service, that as an entity in Eastern Sierra's, we're much, much farther along and much better positioned than where Corp. is, where the rest of the state is, and that
2:15:47 We're better off focusing our attention on making sure what we need to do here in this county, in this region, you know, and working with Inyo and working with the greater Tahoe, eastern Sierra area and looking at some of the stuff coming out of western Nevada. If we build something strong there and we can look at that, then we can fold that in as maybe in more of a leading role and idea for the rest of the state and own that versus trying to get all these disparate groups to try and come together on the coast. I think we're better off like we have our own thing here.
2:16:16 That we understand and that we've got to jump on. That makes perfect sense to me. Yeah, and we're not going to get caught up in other agendas. Yeah, and the bill is something we can advocate for. We don't have to be part of any broader coalition in order to do that. You know, as that gains steam, we can change our position. Well, it sounds like we're already getting noticed for some of this work. Yeah. So, let's keep running. Okay. Thank you. Any other comments on Corp?
2:16:44 Okay, moving on to our entrepreneurship bucket. Update on allocations. So I'll just give a rundown of kind of where we are and then, you know, we started to have a conversation during the break that we probably should have now. I'll give it first and then you can jump in if that's okay, if you have anything to add. So here's where we are. Allocations workshops, MLR hosted five.
2:17:09 workshops in the month of January covering a variety of subjects, how to fill out the forms, budgeting, things like that, finances. Emily did an amazing job on that, so she deserves some just, you know, big pats on the back for pulling that together. We had a lot of positive feedback. Attendance was, you know, some of them were okay, some of them were a little low, but I think it was just nice to be able to say, hey, we're out there. I assume that moving forward, it sounds like more people will probably participate that. In terms of applicants, six organizations,
2:17:39 Applied. Total amount requested for this next cycle is approximately 98, almost $99,000. But we have about $51,000 budgeted to award. So there's some work to be done by the committee. Programs applying for multi-year funding are two, Sierra Classic Theater and Forest Island Residency. First allocations committee meeting.
2:18:08 To deliberate will be March 8th at 9 a.m. They'll be reviewing Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association, Friends of the Inyo, Southern Mono Historical Society's applications. The next committee meeting will be on March 15th at 11 a.m. to review Forest Island and Sierra Classic Theater applications. And then they're looking to have a recommendation by the end of March for board approval in April so that we can have recommendation to town council by May.
2:18:39 Yeah, it's going to be, like you said, Emily did a lot of work. She answered a lot of questions. She was getting drilled by a lot of people. She had, what, six different open sessions with people who were going to ask questions to try to make this process as streamlined as possible. I picked up my folder today, so I've got some homework to do before Thursday's meeting. And like I said, it's going to be interesting once I kind of get into it to see the multi-year aspect and look at the long-term budget. That's one of the reasons why I was asking earlier.
2:19:08 Are these funds from you and R pretty consistent on an annual basis so that we can kind of look out for the next three to four years about what's going to be realistic for funding? Right. So R is, you know, Dan can talk to this. We had a great meeting yesterday about that. R is certainly more consistent because it is a, is it sales tax? Is that? It's a transaction use tax. Transaction tax, yeah. I was calling it a sales tax, but yeah, it was a transaction use tax. And then you,
2:19:37 Is perhaps not. I don't know if you want to speak to that or. Yeah, the Measure R is a TUT, a transaction use tax, which is similar to the sales tax. It tends to generate a little bit more than sales tax just because of the way it applies to the use of property in the town. For example, if Member Richardson was to buy a truck somewhere and he's going to use it here, he would have to pay that extra half cent for Measure R on the purchase of that vehicle because it's being.
2:20:09 Because it's being used here in Mammoth Lakes. And so that tends to run about 55, 56% of what our sales tax would run for the town is the 1%. So there is a distinction before what we refer to as a sales tax for the practical point of it. And it's pretty consistent in terms of what it does. The utility user tax, which supports Measure U, it goes to certain commodities there. And that'll fluctuate based on, you know, I think gas was up, you know, propane and stuff was up last year because of cold weather.
2:20:38 It moves around more. It's more flexible for gas, electricity, and telephone, I believe, are the three that go into that. So it depends on what those things are doing in the marketplace. There's a whole process, like for cell phones now, how you get a piece, but it's state law a while back was trying to allocate out some funds that way based on these types of measures, utility user taxes. So it's less consistent and a little harder to project. It runs $800,000, $900,000 a year.
2:21:09 The Measure R sales tax slash TUT tax will run 1.2 to 1.4 right now. I think right now we have budgeted 1.4. 1.250 I think is budgeted and the projection right now is 1.4. Is there another time where it's going to come on to the ballot again? No. That one-time vote that's... Forever unless a group of voters wanted to change it, they'd have to go... It did sense that once and then...
2:21:36 I remember when we voted for it, so I didn't know if it was going to expire or anything. Now, the utility user tax was going to expire, I think, was a deal or change, and so the vote went forward. So both of the votes are... You, yeah. Yeah, both of the votes put those in place until such time that the voters would change the game. And I, just also to answer your question about, you know, is that allocation stable over the next three to five years? Prior to the bond measure, we did a whole kind of...
2:22:06 Forecasting exercise and Dan and Rob came and kind of gave us projections. Here's the bond measure. Here's what we're continuing to kind of portion off for allocations. Here's for the theater once it's built and there's a commitment to contributing to operations. And this allocation was flat.
2:22:31 It was flat and stable. We held it flat on purpose and it stabilized it. To the extent you have growth, could you allocate a little more out? But I think, as Tom's saying, it's a relatively stable dollar amount that's committed into the various of those uses. We do the same thing with special events for the town looking at, here's a flat dollar amount.
2:22:48 You're working through. So let's say we get through this process and we're like, okay, here's where the funds are, here's what we've put out, here's the multi-year aspects, here's what we're going to have left over for next year. Can we then come to you and say we're going to need more for next year because our budget's gotten so small on multi-year? Well, I mean, it has to come out of the same pot. Yeah, it's U. And so once you go to U and say we've spent X dollars on performing arts theater, we've spent X dollars on core operations that are, you know, you're doing an audit, etc. And then we're doing X dollars for
2:23:17 You know, allocations for programming. Once you're out and when that pot's empty, you're empty. And the idea, the conversation was, you know, leave it flat. I mean, we were trying to make space to float the bond and do the park project, obviously, but also that eventually there would be a fundraising component, right, that would help to grow our overall ability to allocate.
2:23:44 Now, when you were, while you were outside, after you stepped out, we had a conversation that we'd like to do another forecasting kind of exercise like that, given that we've made some changes, there's going to be some more, a different kind of structure to ask. Yeah, we'd love to come in and work through that with the budget process and spend that time and take a look at, you know, two, three, four years out where this year is looking like it'll end and then what that looks like.
2:24:13 If you have excess dollars, yes, you could allocate those in the future, but that doesn't mean that that sets the new bar for allocations. That would be so caution. Then the other side of that with Measure U, you know, the ballot language talks about recreation, mobility, and arts and culture, and there's no allocation between those that are set by the voters. But, you know, people look at that differently. But those are the types of things you can fund, and you can put it all into one or evenly split or as it is now.
2:24:42 Mix and match based on the priorities that are coming forward. And speaking of priorities, I mean moving forward, and you guys have been doing your work kind of forecasting with us with the assumption that we wouldn't touch that allocation, that flat allocation pot, that that would persist and we try to kind of use money around that to finance other things. Right. I think one of the concerns that we're looking at is that, you know,
2:25:10 Especially with multi-year funding, we keep whittling down that amount. And we call this bucket entrepreneurship for a reason. I mean, we want to be trying to create opportunities for people to advance new ideas and moving this town forward. And so I think we need to, as we go through this exercise of reevaluating, really challenge ourselves to make sure that we are committed to doing that.
2:25:36 Not just looking at you as this kind of pot where we can, hey, we need to backfill this. Great. Even if we fundraise and we do do that, it's just I'm uncomfortable with that. I want us to be able to have something that is sustainable and hopefully sustainable meaning growth. And can pilot programs. And not just kind of sustain multi-year programs out where you're already allocated out. But the other thing kind of on the back end of that is
2:26:04 People coming out of the groups and producers coming out of the three-year cycle. The expectation is, right, that we've helped them develop to a point where potentially they wouldn't have to come back, right? That's exactly right. So they're coming out of the program, which leaves room for somebody to come back in. Right, and that's one of the things that we talked about a lot is that we want this, for me, I see this allocations process as more than just funding. It's got to be mentorship. It's got to be true partnership, whether it be promotions, because...
2:26:32 To your point, I think that in a perfect world, they come in, we help pilot in some cases, get to them a point. This is why we ask them for their financials and their business plan so we can see like, hey, how are you going to support and monetize this thing? Because we need to, these things need to fledge. We need to kick Baby Bird out of the nest so we can make room for new projects coming in. And this can't just be a line item on people's budgets. And I think right now it's kind of- Yeah, it's gotten to that point. And I agree, you have to manage the expectations. Yeah.
2:27:01 Going forward. I know you just picked up your packet from Emily, or maybe you've already reviewed some of them, the quality of the application. Have we seen an improvement year over year? I can't speak to that. I can just say from my conversations with them, I think that our applicants are earnest and they are thinking about dynamically how they can either scale.
2:27:28 their programs or how they can position it so that it can be sustainable. So I, you know, I can't say what they're looking like this year, but I can say that it feels like we are pushing in that direction and we're getting some response back. Great. Other questions, comments? Did you want to talk about public hearing? Yeah, I mean,
2:27:55 So Dan, to kind of bring it back to your mention of needing to do a public hearing on the MAC allocation, we had a discussion about this at some point last year or maybe the year before. I've gone back and looked at the ordinance language again and just to kind of read it out loud in the record.
2:28:16 The committee, which is us, shall annually conduct at least one public hearing where it takes public testimony as to how tax revenues collected under Measure U should be expended. So that's the clause. And in pretty lengthy discussion, whenever that was last, last year or two years ago, I felt like the board came around to the idea that we really ought to get to a place where we're doing one
2:28:45 Annual Measure U public hearing that isn't just about, okay, this specific allocation we're going to have a public hearing on, but rather looking strategically at these things that Heather's mentioning, at sort of the broader expenditure sustainability of Measure U to say,
2:29:05 Why are we setting aside $51,000? Which portion of it is going to a bond? And to have the whole big picture as part of the public hearing rather than saying, let's talk about this one allocation as a public hearing and then six months later do another public hearing about these three allocations. Because I feel like we've done that in the past and I feel like we go down this rabbit hole where the public isn't...
2:29:28 Doesn't really have the broader context, and it's very hard to, and you end up really just having a public hearing about one particular project, which I think is not the intent that I read in the ordinance. You have a thought on that? Yeah, I can address that. I had a discussion with the town attorney prior to the meeting just to kind of walk through that section the other day. And while, yeah, you have the big picture on that stuff, but if people want to come in and make comment and have a discussion over where the dollars are actually going,
2:29:57 I mean, you can turn around and say, yeah, we're going to give it, you know, the theater, period. We're going to give it to recreation. We're going to do, you know, mobility pieces. And you can add it very broad to that. But as a public member, I don't know if I'm supporting or opposing or getting up and asking, do I get up at that point and say, I want $20,000 for my project? When do I get to have to be a applicant, if you will, in that public hearing process to say, here's where I think that money should go very specifically?
2:30:25 And then the proposal tonight, you looked at a three-year allocation. When you set the big picture, I don't think you're having that discussion that we're committing $200,000 a year for programming for three years to these agencies. And so think about what the public's looking at. The big picture I think is good to do. I don't disagree with you. But as you come back into it from a public person coming in and say, well, when do I ask for this and when do I get to get up and compete?
2:30:54 But isn't that separate? I don't think it is. You're talking about the applicant, though, right? Multiple applicants. When you had this on the agenda, if it's a public hearing, I could come up and say, I don't think this is a good thing, and you should be splitting this with me, because I'm doing the other film festival, or I'm doing the other arts. Why can't I get up and argue for you spending this dollars on me versus having the one-off applicant coming in outside of that process? I'm not saying that they are, but...
2:31:23 Come in and go, I'd like to have a three-year deal. And I don't have to go through a public meeting process. I don't have to have a public hearing about it. I can come in, if you will, any time and make these requests. And I think what the whole idea and the ordinance and kind of some history of how we've treated that was when we do these things, yeah, we want to have that opportunity, at least for the public to be here. Because you come in, you could have one person ask for the full, would you say, $100,000 or $98,000 that's available.
2:31:51 Great. And you say, you're the only one here? Great. We're going to give it all to you. So there wasn't a public process on the actual expenditure of those dollars. You've done a public process on, I'm going to allocate them by category, but the actual expenditure of them, and then we go to town council, the recommendation is to do specifically $50,000 for the theater, $40,000 for fill in the blank. And so when they allocate it, they do that process.
2:32:21 Public hearing and an agenda item, essentially. I mean, we've largely found, I get what you're saying. You're saying there's got to be a public forum for applicants who've already, through a public process, applied for funding to actually stand up and say, I don't agree with your decision. Why? Explain to me. Here's my argument. We've...
2:32:46 That has been the sum total of our public hearing to date, and we've found it highly unproductive. But I understand, yes. So is that a public hearing, though? I mean, or is that type of circumstance okay to, when we deliberate on allocations as an agenda item, to open it up to the public, including all the applicants?
2:33:13 The public hearing distinctive and why they did the ballot measure this way, I have no idea. Measure R is much simple because it says you have to provide for public input. You do that as an agenda item. The differential with the public hearing is really, one, you can notice it in the newspaper if you want, the ordinance does not require that. It says it has to be a public hearing. That means on your agenda you will have it called a public hearing regarding the allocation of measure U funds for this purpose, whether it's one, two, or, you know,
2:33:43 Allocations for programming. But you would have that detail. So I could look at it and say, oh, they're going to give all these dollars away to these particular agencies. I haven't had a chance to come in and make my comment. Which is what we did the first few years. It was a very separate allocation. Now, you can take it. You can piecemeal it out. I mean, you do the process. As David mentioned, I think you do. We're going to set aside $115,000 for programming. Great. And you have a hearing related to that.
2:34:11 I think when you come in and say, now we're going to take that 115 and we're going to allocate it between these 5, 6, 7, 8, 10 people, in the past at least, and I think the direction would be as more openness on that as the spirit of the language there, you are now actually going to allocate that money out for very specific purposes. And that should be a public hearing process. Anybody has a right to come in and make their case. Because having not been part of the process in the past.
2:34:39 Yeah, we've done that. And like you'll see an amendment come back to the town council that says we're amending the budget to allocate these dollars to these particular agencies by a specific dollar amount. Therefore, then we can go enter into those agreements with them. And so there's a couple step process to that. Okay. Allocations committee is going to go through this applicant process and come back with a recommendation. Right. If the review of that recommendation to the board was a public hearing.
2:35:07 Which it has been in the past. Separate from the board meeting. Yes. I think we rolled it into a board meeting the last time or two. But the first two years, it was a very separate hearing. Here's the process. This is the recommendation. It's a public hearing. The allocations committee could then make changes if they felt necessary after that point back to the board.
2:35:30 And that would then... From the public hearing process there. Then if the whole board's going to hear it, you don't have to agree with their recommendations. That's why I say when it hits the agenda here... Yeah, it was a full public deliberation where the allocations committee made recommendations, the board deliberated, then the public had a chance. Each applicant had a chance. I think the first year or two, we would call out applicant by applicant. Do you want to defend? Do you want anything to add?
2:35:59 And I think what we're trying to get to here is that it was very micrological. It was very just focused on, you know, he's getting this, you're getting this. But I understand what you're saying, that there's got to be a public forum for that. I think we almost need to have two separate, you know, hearings. One, where we do get the kind of input from the public at a macro level about our strategy, you know, and how we're,
2:36:29 Approaching the administration of that allocation of Measure U in general, but also the, you know, how we're defining that allocation set aside. Because there's just no room for that when you've already...
2:36:43 When you're already deliberating on the dollars and cents to have some strategic conversation in the middle of... You have the strategic conversation, say we're going to allocate $100,000 to programming, great, that's good, and people, okay, we understand that, but I'm also waiting for the hearing, when do I come in and ask for my money? Yeah, so I think it's two things. I think we want the public to have input on, hey, allocations committee, you've been giving all your money to performing arts, what about...
2:37:10 Over here. Or, you know, hey, that's such a small piece of the pie compared to something else. Strategy input versus allocations. I mean, I guess my, so one question that I have then is that I feel like there have been allocations of a larger nature that aren't part of this allocations process that we've done without public hearing. We've had them in public meetings, but for example, the MAC allocation.
2:37:38 Right. Was not done with a public hearing. It was done in a public meeting, in a public forum, but it was not done with a hearing setting. When we, as a board, decided we have 51,000 whatever to allocate toward programming, that was done in a public meeting just like this, but it was not done as a public hearing. And that's, I hate to say that. And if I were in the arts community and applying every year, I would want to have a hearing on, well, I mean, because what
2:38:07 It's pretty clear about, you know, we need to have a hearing on how Measure U is being expended. And yes, maybe that's at the $10,000 level, but it's also at the $900,000 a year level. And we've done, like we did the big allocations across that. I'll say right now, if you look at the town's budget, how it's allocated those dollars, there's not $300,000 sitting in there for the MAC. Right. We talked about that, there's like $2.5 million for the MAC. It's sitting in a fund balance reserve.
2:38:37 But that hasn't gone through a formal process to say, yes, now we'll write a check. And so it's big picture stuff. It's a budgetary set aside. And the easiest stuff on this here is just on the agenda you call, we will conduct a public hearing on the allocation of X. I'm going to open the hearing, staff, applicant if they're here, or multiple applicants if they're here. Great. We're going to close the public hearing, bring it back. You guys deliberate. It's not a...
2:39:04 Ongoing conversation at that point. It's what recommendations do you want to make? You deliberate, you do that. Then that goes up to town council for final decision on do we agree. So you're saying that every time we recommend an allocation of Measure U, we need to have some time set aside for public hearing. I would actually structure it that way. That just takes any issue off the table. People going, you didn't follow that and you were specifically spending those dollars this way.
2:39:33 Wow. So we need to do that before we put our recommendation to town council? Yeah. You do it before then? Yeah. Which means we're going to do it the next three weeks? Whatever. Well, whenever we're done with your guys' recommendations, I think it comes back to this board. And we have that as a public hearing. Public hearing. Public hearing. And then we can roll in, shearer's request in with that, and then we do it all. So we can do that in April, possibly? Yeah. So it gets in front of the town council in time? Yeah. And so the other element on these you'd look at, especially if you're doing multi-year allocations.
2:40:02 I can't recall if it's under you or ARB. It talks about dealing with money that hasn't been designated or committed. And so the question here, you do a three-year allocation, that gives people an idea of what they're going to get going forward. Generally, council will do that on an annualized basis because it's not a contractual relationship at that point. So the future council could turn around and say, no, we're not going to allocate the money for that this year. It's binding future elected bodies is what it is.
2:40:31 Right. Deals with. But having, I don't mind the three year, I don't mind the three year deal because you're not really entering into that agreement, I don't think it says in the town standpoint going, we are now committing for three years to pay these dollar amounts. It's more of a, what? But it's not, it's a planning tool, it's really nice. Here's our first year allocation, great. We know we're at the next two years and so you're not, public carrying process would be nice. Hey, we've already committed 55,000 for this particular use. We're not re-debating that issue. I mean,
2:41:01 So I can still get up and complain about it, that's their right, or get up and support it. No, that's a distinction that we should be mindful of, the difference between a contract and a three-year.
2:41:14 Commitment, budgetary, funding, planning. Yeah, exactly. Because I think we've all determined that that's a really important tool for us in terms of giving kind of a time arc to these projects. I think it's a good idea, frankly. We've done that like with Measure R. We've done that with the trail system. We're going to commit $300,000 a year. Every year we reconfirm that in the budget. Every year we reconfirm it in the budget.
2:41:38 Well, we're kind of doing that with people that got multi-year last year. They had to give us essentially an update for this year. So there's three parties. So that should be part of the year. It is part of it. It's part of my binder. There's three people that are kind of like giving me an update of where they are, and it's part of that process. Okay, to ensure their second year gets activated. Correct. Yeah. But you should feel like formal action. And you're taking action, though, to allocate that money. Correct. I don't think it's an absolute automatic.
2:42:03 They came in and said, yeah, we spent the money on a pizza party. Right. That's the point of showing their financials or P&Ls. We sit there and go through it and say, you didn't spend your money like you said you were going to, and you didn't put on a production like you said you were going to. And then you could actually use work. Yeah, exactly. And you want to keep that capability. And again, in some ways, I'm sorry, it's a matter of maybe form over function in some cases, but it's just, if you're doing this stuff, just put it as a public hearing. Yeah.
2:42:33 From public here. Great. You have 50. Great. So they just come in. I think it's simple. And then there's no real question then of the process. I think it's just cleaner. Okay. Appreciate the clarification. And that, like I said, I did have a discussion with Andy about it too. And he goes, well, if you're going to do it, err on that side of follow it. I appreciate that. Then you don't get challenged later. We don't want to be challenged.
2:43:04 And again, when you get into this stuff, it gets fun because if I didn't get funded, it's because you don't like me, not because I don't have a good project. Sorry, I heard those comments been there, so. Well, we're trying to make it as transparent and equitable as possible. Sorry for the confusion on it. I didn't think it really. No, sorry. As long as we can clarify to those that were here earlier so that they understand the process. So direction to staff would be not, I mean, obviously this is, we're going to go to the, to the,
2:43:34 kind of project-specific hearing the next time we meet in April, but for the next year, we'll also want to schedule that strategy hearing and invite the public in to have that conversation with us. Is that what I'm hearing from the board, that we want to kind of do both? I believe so. I mean, I think that makes sense to have a hearing on the bigger picture. I do too. Get input from the public. And by next year, I think it's actually this year, though, in advance of
2:44:04 Of budgeting? Yeah. Yeah, for sure. And invite all our stakeholders in to... And it's a good opportunity for everybody to get a sense of where is this money coming from? How much do we have? What's the annual revenue look like? What percentage of it is already allocated? Why are you managing it the way you're managing it? And talk a little about the philosophy of what we're trying to do with this.
2:44:27 Program to begin with is saying, hey, this is an incubator. This is moving in. But it's also good to hear from the producer's side of what their feedback is of why they feel that they need to maybe have it within three years. For sure. Because people are going to have different output. Everybody's got different settings of being able to have ticket sales or being free to the public or it's, you know, see what the restrictions are. And I think it's also an opportunity to present.
2:44:51 What we have leveraged or what has been leveraged in terms of those expenditures from the previous year, right? To be able to say, well, this was what was allocated. This is, you know, these are the matching funds that were brought to bear. These are the volunteer hours that were brought to bear. So everybody can really get a sense of what we're up to here. Great. Okay. I think that was a healthy debate.
2:45:17 Moving on then, we've tabled the theater funding. We have a plan for that. We're going to roll it into the public hearing. The Forest Service Theater. So we've been having ongoing meetings and conversations with the folks at the U.S. Forest Service. Initially it was myself, David, and Emily met with Jeff and Leah. You know, we think the Forest Service Theater is a great venue.
2:45:48 Probably underutilized for sure. But it does need some help, some improvements to really kind of program it the way it should be programmed. So we talked a little bit about that when I think the directive out of that meeting was for Jeff to go back and talk with folks at the Forest Service to kind of see what their temperature was on it. We've subsequently had a meeting last week with Deb Schweitzer. And so she seems
2:46:15 Amenable to working with us to partner. You know, her concerns were a little bit of programming. I think that, you know, coming directly from the top and the top being national is that, you know, they want to be conservative on how that venue is programmed. I don't have a problem with that at all. I don't think we have a problem with that at all. We want to make sure that the stuff goes in there as appropriate for that venue. But I think we have to get a game plan of how we can
2:46:45 You know, what we need to do, how much it's going to cost. So to that end, I think the suggestion was that we maybe bring in an outside consultant. We think someone from outside the area to do a needs assessment on what the actual kind of requirements would be. I think they've had some conversations. Someone came in and I think gave them an assessment. I thought it was a little bit high. They were talking like $10,000 for a projector. And that was like for a projector that could do, you know.
2:47:12 Blu-ray quality for some of these film festivals. And I'm like, okay, well, that's great. But, you know, how many of those are going to come into town? So what's the kind of ROI versus what you're going to fill that theater with, with a showing of this versus programming throughout the year? Can we get away with, you know, a projector that's maybe lesser, but still meets the needs, AV, all that stuff. And so once we kind of get a number there, I think what we want to do is then kind of work with them to
2:47:40 Whether that's through applications or Measure U funding or something, figure out how we can work with them to fundraise for that and then concurrently work with Forest Service staff. It's with Andrea, and I can't remember Andrea's last name, but she's here at the office of Mammoth to do the scheduling. So we still have to go through the permit process, the special use permit process, but try to kind of streamline that so people have an understanding of
2:48:09 Here's what's appropriate, here's what we're looking for, and kind of here's what the process is. One just maybe suggestion. I know MLF is doing some surveying for the MAC, and it's a kind of needs assessment. Obviously, you're talking about very specifically, hey, what equipment do we need? What improvements do we need to the venue? But I would...
2:48:37 I would think that some of their survey data might inform those decisions. They're going out and saying, you know, what kind of entertainment do you want? What would you want to see on a stage? I even dropped a link to that in our last month's newsletter to our whole database, pass holders and our paid guests. So I don't know what kind of engagement they've gotten with their survey, but there should be some interesting findings that might help.
2:49:03 Yeah, I'll reach out and yeah, if we can kind of share information, that would be great. I think this is, what we were talking about was pretty specific to the structural needs, you know, of the facility, but I think from a, maybe a 30,000 foot perspective, certainly that would be helpful. Maybe identify a niche that we hadn't thought of that, oh, you know what, that's appropriate to this theater. I think there's going to be some partners, private partners that are going to come in.
2:49:31 You know, the film festivals and what have you. Yeah. They're coming in and saying, hey, look, you know, we'll make that, you know, $2,500 difference up to get a Blu-ray or something like that. And the trick, the one real challenge with this facility is that it's federally managed, right? Right. And so you've got, you know, we've been trying to figure out how to broker kind of, you know, can one organization, we can't do it because of our constraints.
2:49:59 Is there an organization, can ESEA operate the theater and manage it basically for the Forest Service and be able to be, you know, or does the Forest Service every time there's an event and that has to have to make the call as to whether it's appropriate or not? And if it ends up being that, then I question whether, I question the value of us going down that rabbit hole too much. I mean, I don't know.
2:50:27 I think it's tricky. It's like, I mean, if I understand correctly, like, doesn't the Forest Service have some opinions that, like, a film in there that was benefiting POW, we're talking about climate change, that that would be considered inappropriate content now in the current Forest Service? No, no, they've, they just want to, I mean, I think what's in play here is whether they need to be that arbiter every time.
2:50:51 I mean, if it's a benefit, they've had no problem in the past with it being a benefit for power, a benefit for a mountain biking organization, or a benefit for the ski team, but they want to have that one special use permit with that organization each time. Which makes it kind of impossible. They've had independent films in there before. Yeah. Oh, yeah. But they had a special use permit with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation for that film festival. And where we ran into...
2:51:19 Where we ran into problems was when ESEA had an umbrella agreement over the course of the whole year and then ESEA partnered with Friends of the Inyo or ESAC to do a fundraiser, then the Forest Service was saying, well, now, wait a minute, we didn't approve that particular content. I mean, is it that hard to kind of have a stakeholder grouping where
2:51:49 The Forest Service is at the table, and we figure out what the schedule is going to look like over the course of a year, and we go through production by production, event by event, and they do get a thumbs up, thumbs down, but it's pretty telegraphed. It's at the beginning of the season. It's in full cooperation with the partnership you just mentioned.
2:52:15 I don't know. Is that really the other model? There are a lot of different models for doing it, and they are, as we've heard from the mayor and as we've been hearing for the last several years, and as I just heard back in D.C., they're really pushing to try and have community stakeholder organizations that are managing federal facilities, and they like the idea of partnerships. But here we are on the ground, brass tacks, like how do you actually do it? And we haven't solved it yet.
2:52:44 But my impression from the last meeting was they, Deb indicated that Forest Service would still manage that process and have to go through Andrea. They were definitely amenable to dialoguing with us to figure out, you know, how we could make that more streamlined and efficient. But they also said to some degree their hands are tied is that the process is the same coming down for every place.
2:53:07 And so, again, I think this is an ongoing conversation that we need to have. So it's a special use permit every single event. And that's really what we're tripping up on, right? That there's that added layer of trust. It's not feasible. I mean, if we're looking at it as a community facility to be programmed, you know, when...
2:53:29 There's the opportunity to have such and such author speak about this or a certain fundraiser and it's being done in this piecemeal fashion. Then it's no longer the way that we'd like to operate, which is looking holistically and strategically at community benefit. How do we program out that theater and the communications of that theater so that people can plan ahead so that you can at any given moment know what's happening in that theater?
2:53:56 And there isn't really a scenario or it's a difficult scenario where what you just described happens, where the community plans out and we take advantage of opportunity and it's just as much, it's just, hey, here's your permit. They would have to trust their partner in order to make that happen. And I think that's their, for their perspective, they're probably more than happy to surrender that. I get what Dave's saying, to some degree, I agree with that. It would be much more beneficial.
2:54:24 Beneficial for the community to be able to go and say, hey, here's what the calendar is and here's what it looks like. I just get the sense that they're kind of approaching it more as an ad hoc and it's going to be completely reliant on the partners. I've never been through the special permit process. I don't know how difficult that is.
2:54:47 It's not terrible. It's just hard to know. And, you know, every new organization, they're like, well, who do you have to contact? And Lawson's out of town now. And, you know, it's like... Well, I think that's what they're supposed to do is streamline that part. Right. And there's such a mandate from the federal level to streamline that. So I'm just trying to take advantage of that opportunity. And, you know, when we're... I just... I feel like we're in this position where we're talking about spending a ton of money on a 300-seat theater when we can't quite program a 100-seat theater.
2:55:17 And where we have, you know, there are facilities in this town. Well, is there a step that gets us to trust? Is there a step that gets us, you know, to some level of collaboration where we don't have to kind of spend out and we don't have to fully commit, but we can take a measured step towards that? Sure. I mean, I think that's why the needs assessment is important.
2:55:41 That's what we're doing right now. Yeah, we have to say, okay, what's the priorities of all the things that need to be done? Can we baby step it? And I think we do that concurrently with trying to program. I'm going to talk a little bit about some of the events that we want to do in there. And if we can show some kind of demonstrative movement in terms of, hey, we're able to program this, I think we'll get some trust back. I think that's the big thing right now. It sounds like there was this big chasm of trust.
2:56:09 Between the previous management and where it is now. And I think if we can kind of meet them halfway and say, look, we're able to do stuff that you guys are going to be stoked on, that we're going to be stoked on, it's going to benefit the community. And they see the value of that. They see the value of earning that trust back to, you know, forest service and public facilities. Then maybe that will go towards trying to get this streamlined, this process, you know. It seems like we'd benefit by doing similar to what we were talking about with the allocations committee, which is going to them and saying,
2:56:38 Here's our content. We need whatever, you know, we need, we need, we want 50 nights in the theater and 10% are going to be in this subject and 20% are going to be in here and 40% are going to be in here and when the, when those things come in, the program is in general buckets like what we've talked about allocations and if the Forest Service says, okay, well, we're good with that and then you have to go to a specialty so something's going to fall out of one of those buckets.
2:57:01 Does that make sense? Yeah. Like, if you could get the Forest Service to at least sign off on, like, at least, like, hey, like, this is the type of content in these general buckets, and we'll come back to you if something's going to deviate from the bucket, and we're going to show you what goes into those buckets, but we're, if it fits that general framework, we're not going to come back every single time for every single individual. Before we go from bang our heads against the wall, why don't we just ask them first?
2:57:22 Just go to the source and say, what is it that you want? I agree. That's what we're doing right now. I think we're trying to formulate the question. The question is how to do it and just how can we, you know, what is it that you want to see from us? I go along with the needs assessment.
2:57:37 Yeah. Because they don't have any money to do any improvements. Not only do they not have money to do improvements, if she somehow found money somewhere in her budget and did an improvement, she'd be bounced out of a job. Oh, I heard they don't have money for a light bulb right now. They literally have zero. Yeah, it's that crazy down there. Yeah, like nothing. So I'm just like, I mean, my heart kind of breaks from a little bit, you know, because you've got this really bitchin' theater down there that's got great ambiance.
2:58:02 Sound sucks, but it's like, it could really be something cool, right? It'd be a great kind of counterpoint to what, I mean, this is no snap, the Edison does great stuff and it's awesome for what it is, but I don't know if I want to have like an outdoor film festival or something there. This place is vibing, but it needs some partners to make it maximize its potential. I think it's worth our effort to try and get that relationship kind of put together the way.
2:58:31 It needs to be, and to solve for your question, I like where you were headed there. It's like, wait a second, is there a way that approvals can happen and satisfy the Forest Service, but where it isn't kind of just... General. Exactly. So they feel good about the overall content plan from a strategy level, but they don't have to get into the myopic level of what's the film, what's the event, who's the producer, it's...
2:58:56 It's in this bucket. It's in that bucket. That feels like good content. Which is not a new concept for them, right? They already have a partnership built into the forest plan with Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association to run their bookstores on public land. And they're not micromanaging which books Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association is putting in the bookstore. So it's not a stretch. So walk back to the next steps then. I know there's a needs assessment, but
2:59:24 Kind of answering these relationship questions. How do we solve for that and what kind of conversations? The next kind of meeting that we were planning on having is to meet with Andrea, who's the person here locally who has been processing those permits and programming just to kind of get her feedback and then kind of see like, hey, what's in there, what doesn't, and then figure out how we can develop a game plan for that. Okay. All right. Thanks for the update.
2:59:54 Moving along, events bucket, MLR events. So we are working on two, possibly three events in the next couple of months. The first one's coming up on April 24th. We're partnering up with the Chamber of Commerce. They are bringing in Steve Skadron, who is the mayor of Aspen, to talk about their efforts to move the towns for sustainability. They're going to be doing that at one of their lunchtime events.
3:00:22 So my thought was kind of in observation of Earth Week, we would show and screen Saving Snow, which is a new movie talking about climate impacts on winter sport or mountain towns. And then I've reached out to Andy Wirth, see if he wants to come down and talk about what's going on at SQUA. We'd love to have some representation by the mountain or by town officials. And then we would put a panel together and then...
3:00:52 Whether it's David or myself or someone, moderate that. I think that would be a great evening event. And then the second event would take place on May 15th, and that would involve Marisela, who was here earlier to introduce herself. We want to do an event with a partnership with, again, the Chamber of Commerce and Latino Outdoors. So what that would be is that Marisela would do a lunchtime presentation with the business community to talk about
3:01:20 How we can do a better job of getting like the Latino community perhaps move from back of house to front of house. That's probably one of the critical first steps in trying to engage them with the kind of the general sense of recreation is that, you know, think about it like, you know, they're there doing stuff there. You don't see them doing fitting boots. You don't see them.
3:01:48 Pushing out rentals, you don't see them even, I don't know, selling lift tickets, right? And it creates these like microaggressions. I mean, Marysheva is super smart. She's like a sociology degree and just all kinds of studies and stuff. And she was just dumping all this knowledge on me. I was just like, wow, I've never thought about that, but it makes totally sense. So we want to share that with the business community, which I think is going to help them in trying to kind of franchise their workforce and stabilize some of that stuff.
3:02:14 And then on the evening event, we want to have a companion evening event, which would be geared towards the Latino community themselves. They would show a movie called Estamos Aquí, which means, you know, we're here. And it talks about Latinos recreating in the outdoors. And so that would be held, hopefully, at the Forest Service Theater, done in Spanish. So we're going to advertise that in the Spanish newspaper and other places.
3:02:42 All these things are not meant to be like, hey, we arrived. These are just first steps to kind of foster those dialogues. And I think that plays into kind of the goals that we talked about when I first got here is that, you know, I would take it as a personal failure if we did all these things, built these great facilities, and they were only servicing, you know, 60% of our town. We've got to figure out how 100% of this community can feel welcome in these facilities. What's the relationship with Latino outdoors? I mean, are they...
3:03:11 Grant funded? Do they turn into consultants of some kind? What's their mission and their mandate? We talked a little bit about this. I mean, their mission is just to outreach. And they're actually a grassroots organization that has a chapter structure. I don't know how many chapters they have, but they have it nationwide. And so one of the things we talked about is this might be a first step to actually establishing a chapter here in the Eastern Sierra, probably located here in Mammoth.
3:03:41 And what an incredible resource that would be. Think about it. Because, you know, if we want to do outreach, we're working with them in partnership. They're working in the communities. They're kind of communicating up to us what the needs are. We're trying to franchise in and try to do, hey, here's where we want to do in the scoping. I think that that would be an amazing kind of first step to that. So if we could start this partnership and then use that to leverage, you know, getting a chapter here, certainly getting, filling that seed on their board that we've allocated for.
3:04:09 Representative for the Latino community. I think that's kind of our short-term goals right now. Yeah. Okay. That'd be stellar. Yeah, it's awesome. That's fantastic. I'm really stoked that you've pursued this. Cool. Yeah. And then the last one, I'm trying to hound, I have a buddy, Shane Anderson, who used to be a professional skier, but now he's a filmmaker. He turned, he's an avid fisherman. He's made some amazing movies talking about fishing. He just released a movie called A River's Last Stand, which is about the Eel River and some of the pressures on that.
3:04:39 We'd like to maybe try to pull a showing of that, maybe tie it in with fishing opener. And then again, maybe, you know, I don't know if we want to do a panel discussion or just a Q&A with the filmmaker, but again, have something where it's a conversation starter talking about our rivers and some of the impacts. I mean, I don't know if we want to get too deep into it, but, you know, over the weekend, the administration just announced that they want to do some significant rollbacks to clean water protections, which is just, I mean.
3:05:08 Makes my mouth drop, but I think our goal... It's also, you know, the 50th anniversary of Wild and Scenic Rivers. Oh. So we've got a couple of those in our yard here. Awesome. Yeah, that would be great too. So I think what our goal is, is try to use these events that are hubbed around recreation to talk about some of the impacts. And again, this goes back to our goal here as being, not only like moving actual recreation forward, but being thought leaders. And so I think I'm pretty excited about it for MLR. That's awesome. Yeah. Okay.
3:05:37 That's exciting stuff. Any other comments on events? No. Okay. Let's move on to committee reports. Executive committee, the executive committee met, what, last week? Which is kind of our plan to do. The executive committee will meet kind of in between board meetings. And I don't really have much more to report. I mean, I think everything's pretty much...
3:06:04 Revealed itself in this board meeting that we discussed. I think we maybe discussed fundraising in a little more detail, and we discussed board composition and nominations, which is coming up in a committee report. So I think I'll just hand it on over to David, and you can talk about the nomination committee, or Matt, whoever wants to address it. So we're doing an open session? Is that how we... Yeah. Okay.
3:06:32 You talked about that's appropriate, but yeah. Okay. Yeah, so you've seen in your board packet Catherine Taft's CV. She came to us recommended by a fellow by the name of Ben Weissman who owns the house next to me who's tapped into this big New York, LA art scene. He's a professor at CalArts and a couple other of the sort of underground arts community here in the moment.
3:07:03 So I've been kind of hounding them to give me some nominations, and Catherine was one of them. And it seemed kind of pie in the sky, but Matt went down and talked to her, had lunch with her. She's super excited. She comes up pretty frequently. And then Heather and I had a conversation with her on the phone and kind of spelled out a little bit about, you know, she talked about her experience. She's definitely tapped into the arts community, I think, bi-coastally. She's a great writer.
3:07:31 She's also, I think, tapped into the money community a little bit down in Southern California. And Heather and I talked a little bit about what we envisioned for an arts and culture seat on this board and how we felt like we've got enough of a locally based working board that I think these next seats and that one in particular.
3:08:00 Would have a real strategic focus on where we take Mammoth Lakes and where we take MLR in terms of arts and culture and being a seed that would be really tasked with looking at grant opportunities, raising money for arts and culture and establishing a strategic path forward. And she was all about it. She was really excited about it. I just thought she was extremely bright.
3:08:24 She's way tapped in more than I even understood the art world to be. Just listening to her talk was fascinating. Like you said, everything from grants to just maybe bringing some different artists to Mammoth. And also what we talked about before, having conduits into other communities I thought she'd be fantastic for. And her background's more, I mean, forgive me, it's been a few, I saw her CV when you guys were interviewing her. It's more
3:08:53 exhibit curation and management and art history and she's a, it looks like she writes a lot. She's an art critic. Yeah, she's an art critic and I think in terms of helping us define kind of a broader strategy for the arts community, I think that's the kind of Yeah, and she's really brimming with ideas and experience with other towns that have started different arts residency programs and how that's impacted the town.
3:09:23 She's also Deputy Director of LAX Art, which is a non-profit, so she's got strong non-profit experience, which is great. She also is from Colorado. She grew up in Boulder and spent some time in Vail working for the area there. It's interesting. So she gets ski towns, and she also told me, which I thought was amazing, there is this very kind of
3:09:48 Interesting nexus of skier artists in Southern California that she's pipelined in with. So I was like, really? But she says they're very into skiing and they're very into art and some of them are pretty active in funding. So I thought that, hey, wow, that's awesome. Does she have a place up here? She comes up with this guy, Ben Wiseman, who shares a place.
3:10:12 They put a bunch of money into it. His partner on the property is one of the richest artists in America. And we haven't heard of him here. Has Matt knocked on his door yet? This is our way in. Yeah, right? Cool. I'm looking at her CV.
3:10:35 She seems ideal. The fundraising side, the non-profit side, the culture critic side to it. She's interested in the mountain town, but she doesn't have a vested interest in the bias that would come with almost everyone that's in this town that would have those qualifications is likely in one of our allocations requests. So the fact that she could bring a perspective to that from the curation side, really being thoughtful about what that variety looks like, she seems ideal.
3:11:01 That's, I agree. That's something Matt and I have talked about a lot when we were trying to, when he did his board matrix and we were talking about seating somebody for arts and culture and we're like, everybody here in town has their handout for, you know, funding from us and has a kind of vested interest in whatever little, I don't want to, you know, it's not.
3:11:22 I started squabbling. But we've also said that we want to be. Fight for resource. That we want to be bigger besides within our own town, right? So this gives us that outreach. Totally agree. And tap into something that we've never touched.
3:11:36 The ability for her to be a potential mentor or resource for people from in town to get the benefit they'd have from having someone that had that bigger perspective from another place into the community would be really beneficial. And maybe connecting some of the art that happens here or whether it comes out of Forest Island maybe into a broader network. Totally. It can kind of go both ways. We can get it down there and then we can get a big Jeff Koons installation at Main Lodge. There you go.
3:12:05 Okay. Well, judging from the commentary, I think I'm ready to take a motion. Anybody want to present one? Make a motion to invite her onto the board. Okay. To nominate her to the board. Is she nominated by the committee? She's been nominated by the committee, so we just would approve her. I'd make a motion to approve her for the board. Okay. I second. Okay.
3:12:35 Any further discussion? Public comment? All in favor of the motion, say aye. Aye. Now, how do we get her here next? Motion passes unanimously. Okay, so nice. You'll not quite know tomorrow. Maybe you can want to reach out to her. Yeah, for sure. I'd love to.
3:12:57 Okay, I have my computer just died, so I think next is... Allocations committee. Allocations committee update, and we have a new allocations committee. Do you want to talk about how it happened? So, you know, we... Allocations committee, we obviously lost Terry and Drea off, and so I reached out to Rhonda Dugan, who I've known for a long time, and she's a 25-year resident at...
3:13:25 Ten years on the planning commission, working back then with Tony Barrett, so they're familiar with kind of bringing art to the community. Long-time member of the lodging community, and she's currently GM of Turnkey Vacation Realms, and see if she wanted to kind of participate on the committee to just help basically Heather out, you know, because we needed three people on there. So she agreed, and so I think we're fortunate to have her. So she's been working with Heather.
3:13:55 And we'll be very active in the process moving forward. Great. All right. Any other updates from allocations? I mean, we spent a lot of time talking about allocation planning for the hearings. Nothing else to add? No. No, that's it. Is that helping with the agenda? Executive Director report? Yes. So very quickly, I will tell you that one nice kind of bit of news is last week we officially received our gold level status.
3:14:25 for transparency on GuideStar, which is, you know, I think always very helpful for funders and people want to know that, hey, if they're giving to an organization that this organization operates with a high degree of transparency and are prudent with their money, not to brag, but there's not very many other nonprofits in town that have that level. Most of the other ones, I think, are maybe at silver or bronze or not even there. So, and we're hoping to get to platinum sometime this year.
3:14:54 Which will be the highest. Web design is progressing. We're getting ready to send them down a big package of content. So I'd say we'll be hoping to have some mods for you guys to look at some betas maybe as soon as end of this month, which should be exciting. And we're working with...
3:15:13 Town staff and our other partners to make sure that kind of it's in line with the goals and objectives that were set at Momenta so that, you know, there's some coordination with what's being disseminated across the board here in town by the different agencies and nonprofits. And we're confident that that's going to progress well. And then I will be at the California Trails and Greenways Conference at the end of the month. I'll be there for quite a week. I'll be there Tuesday to Saturday.
3:15:41 And then we're board members. Board member reports. Shields, you want to start off? I have none, but I'll make the report tomorrow evening. Yep, yep. I'll send you a book. Great. Great, thanks. My only thing would be, I think, most of the things MLR-related that I've been working on and working with Matt have kind of been discussed today. But I just, you know, Saturday was kind of a harrowing day for a little while. You know, if you were on the mountain, if you were...
3:16:10 Up on the fourth floor and then maybe even out in the probe line. And there's been, you know, an avalanche at Squaw, some deaths. Somebody just, a roof shed took somebody skiing back at Diamond Peak, I think today, maybe it was yesterday, just skiing back to their condo. It's just a reminder of, you know, what we, human beings were not naturally meant to live in places like this without, you know.
3:16:38 A great town infrastructure, all the people plowing the roads without a fantastic operations team up on that mountain. I just, I can't say enough about how pro, and I was sitting there listening to the radio for, you know, a couple hours, how pro the reaction was up there. And, you know, we're learning and we have some takeaways, you know, some things we could definitely do better. But I just wanted to give a shout out to that team.
3:17:07 I don't know, it was interesting that day, there was kind of a strange vibe in the morning, a little aggro and a little uncertain. I think the weather was unsettling, people in the crowd mixed with the weather, and then after that event, there was just kind of people in the town, the guest base, everybody kind of understood. There was a very different vibe there the next day. Sunshine had something to do with it, of course, but an interesting experience, and I think just gave...
3:17:35 gave me some perspective, and I think a lot of other people, and certainly this kind of stuff that David writes about kind of came to mind. So just a little comment about that. Can I read you something? This landed on my radar just because this person tagged Mammoth Lakes Recreation in it, but this was a post that I saw on...
3:17:54 Instagram from an account called For the Love of Mammoth. It says, Dear Mammoth Mountain, I want to commend you. I continue to be pleasantly surprised by your staff and standards. Over 60 years ago, my parents started taking their family to enjoy Mammoth year-round. I've never felt as strongly about my commendation as I do now. The recent storm and subsequent event were handled exceptionally. I was confident that the mountain staff had my best interest and safety in mind at all times.
3:18:21 Additionally, at no point was there a sense of panic or stress about the situation. I believe that a real tragedy was avoided Saturday because of the superior quality of your crew. I will continue to enjoy Mammoth Lakes with my own family for many years to come. Thanks, everyone. That's perfectly stated, and I think there was a lot of that. So that's all I've got. Were there any lessons in communications? Yes, there were lessons in communication. We, from a PR standpoint and through social,
3:18:51 We were kind of on the spot, in resort, letting people know in the moment who are, you know, we have this television system that we actually can control from up in the marketing department. We've just never thought of it as an emergency messaging kind of channel, you know. And so there were a lot of lessons like that. Our website didn't get updated. Probably we don't really have a place.
3:19:17 For that kind of messaging on our website, apart from like above the trail status page, which you'd have to click through to. So yeah, we had a bunch of learnings from that. I think from a PR standpoint, I mean, as you can imagine, with all the social, you know, everybody was all of a sudden, media was just, it was just.
3:19:38 Trying to keep up with the phone calls, LA Times, everybody on the phone 20 minutes after the incident, right in the heat of the emergency. And I think our team, I was right there, handled that very well. But in terms of just getting to the guest who was in Tusks or in Broadway, kind of still wondering what was going on, that, I think there's some takeaways there without question. Yeah, on the app. Again, we've never,
3:20:08 We never understood those as emergency channels, and I think we have an opportunity to do so. So there's conversations going on right now about that. And it's nothing we, you know, it's stuff we can leverage, things we already have, if we just have a procedure. So I think that was the takeaway for me anyway.
3:20:27 And did it work well with the town? Like, did, for people who were, like, on their way up? You know, so... We don't need to go down on radicals. Yeah, yeah. Well, I think there was, you know, I think some people would maybe say that we were over, we were a little conservative in terms of holding traffic back, but we were just keeping it open for emergency traffic. I was down at the mill when they turned it into a triage center, and I will say that the...
3:20:53 The cooperation between our staff and all of the kind of town groups, rescue groups was exceptional. I mean, everybody just kind of fell into roles very easily and there was really terrific management of that coordination. And the thing was, it was visible to the guests. They were witnessing it. It wasn't like it kind of happened.
3:21:18 Out of eyesight. There were guests up in the probe line. There were guests there on site. There were guests down in the mill, basically being asked to take their beers and leave as they created a triage center and guests seeing the emergency vehicles. And so, you know, it was, again, there's a, we're doing a full on kind of top to bottom investigation, both in terms of how it happened, you know, how to prevent it, but also of our response.
3:21:47 But I think overall from within the company and without it was a pretty, you know, people were very appreciative of how professional everything went down. There were a lot of flashing lights coming up from down south too, which is cool. Yeah. I mean, it was like hands on deck. Yeah. Yeah. It was great. I can't speak to, and you might have even been asking more or less about our outbound communication and more about the coordinated.
3:22:15 kind of reaction. I mean, I'm curious. I'm a little less versed. I was in Costa Rica, so I just got texts from friends and then read the LA Times thing. There was a little jive in there about, like, you know, they couldn't get information until 20 minutes later or whatever. I thought your guys' social media was fully on point. It was exceptional. One of the guests that was there is the chief of Montecito Fire, who had left Santa Barbara for the first time.
3:22:43 Since the floods. He came up with his family on Friday and spoke highly of what he witnessed. Nice. That's really cool to hear. Awesome. All right. Moving on, David. Report? I don't really have anything. Okay. That's good. MLT board meeting is tomorrow. We'll provide a review of this. We're going to go through and look at the stuff with the Kings tomorrow as part of that.
3:23:10 And then a lot of the conversation there is ongoing with the relationship between the mountain and town and what happens with the airport. It's kind of top level of mind of what happens moving forward. With TBID coming up for renewal, the big question there comes up that it's council has asked for the intent on April 18th. So MLT, the TBID, and town and the resort have really have five to six weeks of notice.
3:23:39 Put something together. That becomes a big question. Yeah. Yeah, that's big. Mine is will be in a binder for the next three weeks. And thank you in advance for doing that work. It's a really big part of what we do here. I didn't already have a wine problem. Okay, I think with that, does anybody have additions, suggestions for future agenda items?
3:24:07 We did mention kind of another forecasting exercise with Dan and Rob. Let's get that kind of scheduled or just figured out how we want to accomplish that and present it. That would be mine. Anybody else?
3:24:23 Okay. With that, let's adjourn this long meeting. We had been, like, within the two-hour, my two-hour target for a while. This was a big one, and we're going to every other month now. What's the next step for the Eastern Sierra Recreation coordination position? What's going to be the next step from here? More meetings. More meetings. Well, we're going to put together that ad hoc.
3:24:48 So, yeah, I'll reach out to you, and I think Scott and Shields. I would love to be a part of that, but it looks like. You've reached your limit on committees that you can be in. I know. And those Wednesday mornings, man, that's what all my, I'm meeting to death. That's on the 19th is that meeting, right?