Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board · 2018
Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board
· recording 2 hr 39 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
376 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:28 I would like to add one thing to the agenda, which is just a distribution under item 6, new business.
0:58 And to talk about three seats that are up currently and discussion of our process for June seats that will be coming up for the board. And then also under six, I've got some additional information just about strategy I'd like to distribute at that point in time and discussion for a future board meeting. Is there any other additions to the agenda or changes? Okay, with that, board member comments and reports. Kirk? Really good March. That's about it. Great.
1:32 All things considered. No report. No report. Just Snow Creek Golf Course Season Passes are on sale. Hopefully all of you guys saw that little postcard in your box the last few days. So if anyone's interested. And we are, again, as I mentioned, there is cooperative stuff going on between us and Sierra Star. So come play golf. Any dates on driving range yet? Driving range, well, if it stays like this, it won't be too long. As soon as it melts, we'll open.
2:01 and definitely Memorial Day weekend for the course, for sure, unless Mother Nature has other ideas, but yeah, that's it. Mr. Ledesma, I have nothing to report. Mr. Ritter. I have nothing to report, but I would like to thank the person who does the minutes. I wasn't here at the last meeting, and I know that doing the minutes is one of those...
2:25 Unsung efforts that people don't get credit for. The minutes were tremendously helpful to bring me up to speed, and I appreciate that someone took the time and the effort. Thank you, Emily. And with that, actually, Emily asked me to remind everybody to speak up because some of the language before was a little muddled, and she wants to make sure she can hear you correctly. Thank you, Emily.
2:50 I likewise would like to echo. Thank you very much for the prep that went into this month's meeting. Very helpful. One comment that I do want to say is that, especially coming out of the Recreation Commission this morning and just in the last month, spending the time on the youth sports funding that we provide, I am reminded of just how many of our youth sports groups bring people to town through tournaments. And definitely look forward to carrying that forward into today's strategy conversation. Thank you.
3:21 It's funny. No report, just a question, maybe Eric, when you do your Mammoth Mountain update, if we could just get an update on lodge closings and that kind of stuff. You got it. Cool. I have nothing to add for today. So with that, we'll go to public comment, and I'll open up to three minutes or less for anybody that would like to make comments that are not currently on today's agenda or plan for discussion today. With that, I'll close public comment.
3:49 Okay, go to minutes. Did everybody have a chance to review the past minutes? Obviously, Mr. Rudder found it very useful. There was a lot of conversation there, but... I'll let go of that. We were the two that missed it, so I'll abstain, but they were very thorough and hopeful. I move we approve the minutes as stated. Second. Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? I'll abstain. Okay. Okay, new business. So,
4:21 My goal here today is, as we discussed and as I put out to everybody, there's some strategic decisions that we need to give directions to staff. And my goal here today is to make sure that we come to some conclusions on certain...
4:34 questions that are before us. Part of that is our general operating agreements in general saying what are we directing staff to do, what's our general guidelines that we're trying to achieve from an overall standpoint and to agree to those. I'm not looking to spend an hour on each one of these but I do need to make sure that we affirm what we have in the direction that we're giving staff because I'm jumping ahead a little bit. The plan is on May 1st
4:58 For the board to meet with all of our partners in the marketing and PR and everything else that's coming to town, for those who can make the first, and spend basically a whole day going through every single line item detail. And the second will be our strategy conversation. And this is later in minutes, but just jumping ahead to where I'm trying to get to. If we...
5:17 Need to, I'm looking for June as a decision date. If we have to go to July, I'm not afraid of that, and I want to make sure we've answered everybody's question on strategy, and we all understand where we're going, and we're giving appropriate direction that we feel comfortable with moving forward. Any questions on that from an overall standpoint? Okay, so with that, really the first part is reaffirming in terms of our 10 months of viability in our marketing plan.
5:42 Right now, if we look at what we've given direction to staff from an overall standpoint in our agreements from the board, is we said we want to support efforts that get Mammoth Lakes to at least 10 months of economic stability. And economic stability we defined as a million dollars minimum TOT in 10 of 12 months. And before I come back to that, I just want to go, because this relates right back to our marketing plan. Because right now we have four major components of our marketing plan.
6:11 Generate a minimum of $1 million transient occupancy tax per month for 10 out of 12 months of the year. Have a consistent visitor base to sustain occupancy levels and employment base year-round. Support air service and drive utilization. Provide stable and consistent annual visitation to attract new investment and develop opportunities to the market. Okay, with that, it passes and go back to overall. I'm going to just take these one at a time.
6:39 Make sure we have general agreement or if we want to modify or change any one of these. So let's come back with our overall 10 months of economic stability. There's a page that's attached in here that shows what the average is, what we've done over the last several years. Did everyone get that MLT's overarching goal page? Can I ask them questions about that? Yep. Yep. The peak years were 16 and 17, so I assume then that means that
7:08 Well, it's probably a little bit early to tell, but is 18 down from 17? Yeah. Yeah, except for, you know, you look at the, you know, obviously right now we're only into three months into 18. We haven't broken any of last year's records at this point, but we're not far off of them. You know, even December of 2017 was only, it's less than a half a percent off of the record. And then January was off 6%, and then February was off.
7:37 12% I think it's in our future stuff. But this is basically showing you the peaks. So the comparison sheet that you have, the one sheet, what I did was I took the sheet that we developed when we first put this together in October of 2015 and then the most recent five-year averages and the most recent records. And so what you're looking at is that the new records.
8:00 And then what the growth has been since 2015. So if you look at the December number, the all-time high is 2.37 million. It's up 422,000 from when we started this in October of 2015. So that was the point of doing this one-sheet comparison versus giving you two sheets and having you try to figure out all the red ink that I have on there. Fair enough. Yeah. So what I'm looking for is to make sure we haven't changed what direction we're giving from that standpoint of
8:28 Are we still at 10 months as our objective or as 11 months? Do we change our base from a million to any other number, higher or lower? Is there reason to do that or are we holding steady with this as our current direction of what we're trying to achieve from an overall standpoint? A 10-month economic stability and is economic stability a million dollars? So that's really what I'm asking for right now from the board is agreement that that's where we want to be or are we saying to John, hey,
8:55 You've done so well. We want 11 months now. We haven't quite got to the 10 months. I mean, we've still got some work to get to October. I think March we're going to set another record, is my prediction, for TOT. And October, still got some work to do there. I don't know. We're not quite there yet. Because I look at stability being, we do it consistently, not just one year, but are we stable enough that we can do this on a regular basis of 10 months?
9:21 Because if you remember, for those that were on the board in 15, we spent a lot of time saying, what is our goal? At that point in time, we had six months under, you know, basically at a million dollars. And we said, wow, let's set a goal for 10. Let's try to make sure that we get to 10. We're getting pretty close to that. Now, again, we may change next year and say it's 12 or it's 1.25 is our new number. But I'm looking for a consensus for this board saying, all right, that's from an overall driving force, that is our first objective.
9:51 Personally, I'm very comfortable with sticking at a million. I think it's reasonable. I think it represents a good metric for success. I'm also pretty comfortable staying at 10 months. I think, unfortunately, it doesn't really fall from the 1st to the 31st. I think, really, it's more like October 15th to November 15th that's soft. But I think, you know, again, May 15th to June 15th as well. But I think to have kind of two shoulder months, if you will.
10:19 Wherever those fall in the calendar is pretty reasonable. And I think to come from six to nine or ten is a lot of progress in the last few years. And I think it's a good goal for us to continue to work towards. I think something to look at on this sheet, if you look at the lower right where you're talking about the months that are still below a million bucks, you know, it's great that we've grown all the, we've added the three months into the
10:47 million plus club, and we've seen some strong growth in all those months in their all-time highs, but I think the biggest thing is when you look at May, October, and November, even though they're still not a million dollar month, their percentage growth over where they were is two, three times more than what our growth in the months that were already successful. So when you see the all-time high for October growing from whatever it was, 385,000 to 612,000,
11:17 That difference of $234,000 is a huge jump in a slow month. So even though the real dollars aren't huge, the percentage growth has been phenomenal. My concern, just to comment, is that we have several months that are well over a million dollars, and I would like us to have a goal that said that 10 months of...
11:36 $1 million each is fine with four or five of those months being at $2 million or greater. Because if we set that standard at $1 million per month, we could lose half of December, January, and February and still meet our goal and risk losing $3 million out of our budget. So I think that if we said, you know, it's a 10-month goal with the understanding that at least four of those months should be over $2 million is a stronger basis in reality what we need moving forward.
12:03 Makes sense. I think we should have KPIs that we can actually measure against month by month, so in addition to 10. That was a comment I was going to echo, is that I've heard comments within the community that there's, you know, we are trying to ramp up these shoulder seasons and let's continue to do that, but that we can still pack in the times when we're bringing people to town as it is. I would echo what Scott said, but I'd even go to five.
12:28 I go five months. I go ten months of a million and half of those at two because if you look at where July is, July and August are our next to hit two million and we're not that far off. We're only roughly 50. December through March plus July. I don't know if we need to name them. I don't know if we need to name the months, but I think it's reasonable to go five and five. Five at two million and five at one million. That seems like a reasonable goal that's achievable. Yeah. Probably. Well, let's split that. General, is that two levels?
12:57 Good with everybody in terms of looking at it that way? Yeah, I'll just jump in and say that I agree with everything that's been said from everyone, but I would also point out that there's a couple months that are just barely over a million that we're saying, hey, we've accomplished it. And I look at it this year saying, might not get June, given the situation. September's on the border there, too. Might not get April. Yeah. We've got to be cognizant of that as well.
13:27 I agree with the goal setting. Well, I'd like to add that, you know, into what you said there, Scott, I think it's important to do, to split it between a million and two million, because what's not stated on here is an all-time low. So if you look at December, January, February, March, all these months where we're over two million, it's important to acknowledge how bad it can possibly be. And, you know, that totally brings relevance to...
13:56 to that thing as it relates to marketing. If we have a poor snow year, what then, what does that look like? Yeah, I mean, sure, we might be able to achieve a million, and to your point then, we've done our job if that's how it's defined, but, you know, two million is definitely a better benchmark for those months. Okay. Ten months, five at one, five at two. Brent, I don't take any argument with any of that, but I'm really glad.
14:24 That we have this focus on May, October, and November. Because one of the most difficult things for business people is to deal with ramping up employees and everything else. And then having these shoulder months, you know, you've got the, what do you, you have to get rid of all those employees and it's hard on the employees and it's very hard on the business people. Getting, I would suspect, and you know, I'm a walking accountant, but that
14:53 In terms of profit and efficiency and everything else, that ramping up those three months by half a million dollars to a million will have a greater impact on people's bottom lines than increasing the big months from like one and three quarters to two.
15:14 I may be wrong about that, but I have a strong suspicion that achieving that $1 million goal for May, October, November would be a huge, huge benefit to the business community in this town. It's difficult to say, Paul, I hear what you're saying, but there's an economies of scale issue that comes in, and like, just for example, in lodging.
15:34 I don't have to hire more people because I'm doing 25%, 20% more business. But then if I get to a bottom level, I have to have a certain number of people to do X. So there is a floating scale in there. I see what you're saying. It does go both ways. It's interesting. I don't know whether it would be better one way or the other. More is better no matter what. More is better. More is better no matter what. One of the purposes of the TBID was to try and round out the shoulder seasons because if a restaurant or lodging property can maintain
16:03 X number of staff more every spring and fall and you're not having to retrain people and you're not losing people, that's a huge benefit for the businesses. So even if it is just going to a million bucks during those times, it may mean, it may be the difference of laying off three people versus laying off eight people. And that's, I think that really is a great thing about our focus is that here it is in real black and white and as an organization we have a real
16:30 identified goal of bringing those months up. And I think if we do that, we've done the community want a hell of a service. Well, we're missing one thing in black and white is there's no deadline. So you can have a goal and there's no deadline for it. So I think if we're talking about an overarching goal and we're talking about the 10-year renewal on TBID, I'd like us to set a real-term, near-term goal of five months at $2 million and five months at $1 million. But we should ideally be saying
16:58 12 months at $1 million and half of those at $2 million in five years or eight years. As we start talking about strategic plans and what that looks like long term, what does that look like? Because this could be a goal that is slowly, incrementally moving towards it and we would achieve that goal and not keep pace with inflation over the next 10 years. So what's our deadline for that? So let's come back to that. Let's get to numbers first and talk about that as a deadline. So what I'm hearing is
17:27 5 at 1, 5 at 2. My question is, and I'm going back to Eric's comment, we've got like July at 1.4. That's a big jump. Are we setting a, that's going to come back to your conversation, Scott, in regards to timing. By which time do we get to? July's at 1.7? July's at 1.7. Sorry, 1.7. But like June and a million, August 1.5. Is 2 a number that we're comfortable with?
17:56 From that standpoint of five, or do we split it into a third category and say there's three at two, two at one, seven, five? I'm just asking, do we need to split that out anymore? I like the five at two. I think goals should be aspirational. Even if they're not achievable? I don't think anything is out of the realm of achievability either. I mean, I don't think it's unreasonable, and I think it should be aspirational. It should be something we're pushing towards. July is achievable. So are we good with two and one?
18:27 Okay, let's come back to Scott's in terms of, he's asking, so time limit on these items, in terms of what's our goal to do this by? So let's open that up for, in terms of, what's your suggestion, Scott, in terms of deadline on this? So we're saying five years, ten years? I would say, given the growth numbers, I'd say five. Five years is, you know, that's, I think it's realistically achievable, achievable, given, obviously, we
18:57 That includes having decent winners. I know we're trying to weatherproof ourselves to an extent, but actually, in case in point, you look at this winner, and I'll be very quick about this, but you look at this winner and how close we were to the record years this year versus 13, 14, 14, 15, the last two really awful years we had, how far away from last year we were. So I think that speaks to...
19:23 How well the marketing and everything else is going that we're going to, unless we have a completely disastrous winter for some reason, this year was obviously very light, but I think most of us did well. I mean, without March is really about as bad as it can be. It didn't snow for December, January, February, period. Good point. And we have the second best January in history. Go figure. The mountain's doing a tremendous job of making a great product on the hill. I think the marketing is bringing people to town.
19:53 You know, this is completely anecdotal, and I haven't heard this directly from the business owner, but I was speaking to an employee last night who works at Shelter, so it's interesting to kind of look at the thought process behind a brand new business. I think five years ago, a business like that would have not even considered, you know, really trying to push it during the shoulder season. What he relayed to me last night, and this could be wrong, because I haven't spoken to Hammer on this, but he said they're planning to be open 11 to 11.
20:18 their full hours the entire shoulder season. Like, I think, you know, they're a brand new business, whether they, you know, retreat from that will be yet to be seen, but the fact that they're even contemplating doing that, I think, is a testament to where we've come in the last five years. Well, we've heard that from, sorry, I think five years is a reasonable, looking at the five-year average and looking at where we were five years ago to where we are today, it does set that goal of,
20:44 Five months at $2 million, five months at $1 million in the next five-year period of time. Building towards that makes sense. I think five years is an effective goal because in five years it's likely that this board will probably have most of the same members. In ten years that's very unlikely. So we'll have people here in five years to take responsibility for the outcome. I kind of see it differently. I think that it's...
21:14 You have five months that are already at two million, you have four that are already at a million, so you're really saying get May to a million and that accomplishes the goal in five years, is that what you're saying? It's four at two, right? You get all-time high versus average. Four at two, and the lowest one's two-fourths of the budget. Okay. I mean, I can go along with that. I would never do it that way in my business. I would use each month with a percentage growth opportunity for each one because...
21:41 You could, you know, have no growth in those $2 million years and I guess celebrate that. But for me, I would put all months in, have a goal for them. It seems like if we leave two months out, they'll be forgotten. But as John said earlier, if you look at the growth, 71, 61, and 85 percent, there's opportunity there. So for me, I would attach a percentage.
22:07 Goal to each month and include all 12 months. Well, at this stage now, we have to go for a 12-month cycle. Now, you know, October's never going to be July, but it can be a lot better than it is, and we're seeing that kind of growth, so why not include it and measure it and not, you know, stick it off, forsake it somewhere else where we just kind of, you know, out of sight, out of mind. 10 months. I think you can solve that with having a gross number as well.
22:35 What's that? You can solve that by having a gross number as well. Yeah, exactly. It's a minimum of five months at $2 million, a minimum of five months at a million dollars and a gross number of. Right. Yes. But over five years, I'd like to see 70% growth every month. Or perhaps you could tie it to occupancy rates to see if there is room for the growth in it. I mean, yeah, you can.
23:02 The correlation between ADR and occupancy in a busy month like, say, January, you could have the same occupancy in the higher gross, but, you know, it could go the other direction, too. Yeah, and I think that comes with supply and demand. I mean, obviously, that's the most basic principle of economics, and I think we've done that with summer where properties are finally realizing that, oh, we don't have to give it away. Your dad doesn't put the sign out that says I've gone fishing and, you know, take a key.
23:29 At this point, we've got people coming in that are paying higher rates because you're 85% occupancy and the last 15% you're able to charge more. So I think creating that demand is creating that increase in ADR, which ultimately, even if we don't bring another person to town, if we're getting $5, $10, $20 more out of each room, if you can sell it, then it's obviously demand for it. And that's probably easier to focus on versus per se.
23:56 percentage increase, because if you're at 85%, let's say, can you realistically bring out up to 95%? I kind of question that. So, I mean, then we're sort of saturated at a certain level, given any particular month. So that gives you an indication as to what kind of room there is to grow from that point. One of the things that's interesting is if you look at the change. Yeah, maybe, you know. If you look at the, sorry, if you look at the changes, the percentage changes, I mean, really.
24:23 The changes since 2015 are early all over the map, the percentage growth change. So it's not as if MLT has only grown shoulder seasons. I mean, every month is seen growth. So I think the only thing I would caution is, again, our focus was to really grow those dead months so that we wouldn't have the issues with the employments, to even things out, to balance them. So all I'm saying is that I still want to...
24:51 I still would like to see us focus on those dead months so we don't have those issues so you're not having to lay off half your staff and retrain them two months later and all that stuff. And I think Paul's point is that that helps. Michael, I think your point is absolutely valid. I mean, we budget the exact same way at our business. I mean, we don't do it on a month-by-month basis. It's a blended why-over-why increase that we're focusing on. But I think the only reason maybe to move in the opposite direction of what you said, which has a lot of validity to it, is
25:20 to help to be in alignment with a lot of the strategic documents coming out of the town. You know, I mean, really where that was born from originally was a lot of the strategic planning process, you know, through the NGOs and through the town council and all that kind of stuff. And those were some of the kind of key terms that came out of that work. So I think that's really where this is tiering from. And so that would be the only reason that I would be inclined to go.
25:42 So I'm going to bring it just back to come back to the five years versus other time frames for a second. So I'm just trying to make sure we get consensus on that and come back to this from that standpoint. Are we good with the five years overall? Because I want to ask John the same question saying, are you good with five years? Because you've got to achieve this. But any more conversation before we go back to John and saying, are you good with? I've got a comment along those lines. First of all, you know, we're setting these goals. Are we deciding this now or are we going to take this time over May?
26:11 We're giving direction so that John can come back with a budget that says, given these as parameters, this is what I can do going forward. So we're trying to set the parameters. Because my suggestion is going to be that we give John the direction saying, all right, we're saying five and two, but give us an idea what each month looks like. Give us a five-year, break that down by the months and where we think we can grow and kind of delineate that. But I don't think we need to go into that minute detail today.
26:34 But I think we can give John, but I want to make sure John's comfortable with where we're going because if John raises a red flag and says, I can't get you quite there, I want to make sure we're cognizant of that before we move forward. I'm comfortable with five. Five? Okay. With that, I'll go back to you, John, in terms of how do you feel about that in terms of your ability and your team's ability, really, to achieve that. I think it's good. I think the one word that I'd throw in there is that we go to sustainable two million, sustainable one million.
27:03 Because I think the one thing you look at June, the peak there at $1,500,000 for June was two years ago. Last June we did $995,000. You know, last April we set the high mark at $1.5 million, $1.6 million. We're not going to see that for a while. You know, that's that. So, but again, I think that this April with Easter falling in, you know, really early April, I think we're going to probably be struggling to get.
27:29 900,000 this year. So they're not sustainable million dollar months. We've hit a peak of million, but I think the key word is to get us to sustainable million dollars. Because there are some months that, you know, September, I think September is sustainable at a million bucks now. I think we'll see a million bucks moving into September moving forward. April and May are kind of those months that are snow dependent. November is also kind of snow dependent.
27:53 Because it's really, that's where we've talked about some of the other facilities that we need in order to weatherproof ourselves. May and October are going to always be challenging because we don't know whether we're skiing or we're golfing or we're, you know, in the middle of rainstorms. So I think those are the months that are really still flexible. I do think that we have focused on the fall, we'll continue to focus on the fall. I do think that even though May is showing up as the highest non-million dollar month, again, that was last year.
28:22 That was last year when we had probably 100% of the mountain open. But I do think that October is the one that even though the growth in November has been strong, again, that's based on snow. I do think October is the next sustainable million dollar month. And realistically, is that sustainable in three years? Probably.
28:42 So I'm not afraid of the five-year. I think that we can probably bring it to you earlier than that. I do think that when we talk about the strategy of moving forward, we've gone from a quarter million bucks in marketing fall. We increased it last year. We're probably looking to increase it this year so we can keep that going with the same idea of having Gomez's not lay off 10 people, lay off five people. And I think the more that we can build those shoulders, the more that we also build the community where you get people here.
29:12 Living here versus saying, well, it's the end of the ski season, I've got to move back to Southern California. Now all of a sudden you've got people working here, spending money in the community, being part of the community, and I think that was a big strategy with the TBID, and obviously with the months that we've added, I think we're getting there. I was about to say exactly what John just said. All of these record years, except for one, are 2017. Repeating those in the future,
29:42 Could be a significant challenge. I mean, you know, they're all there in one year for a reason. And so it creates a certain amount of instability. That's on one side of it. And John's point, John and John's point about weatherproofing, building up those shoulder season months is really the critical part of weatherproofing. You can't, you know, you can't help it if the snow doesn't fall. But if we have strong Octobers and Novembers, that would be an offset.
30:10 Meanwhile, the flip side of that is, it may be that the Icon Pass comes along and knocks all of this into a cockcat, and every month is over $2 million, and all we need from the mountain is an Icon Summer Pass. We're seniors. Perfect. We're seniors. We're seniors.
30:37 I'll kind of defer to the pleasure of the rest of the group regarding if we want to establish an overall gross or a percentage growth basis, but I'm comfortable with five years, I'm comfortable with five at two and five in a million so far. 30% growth for five years, is that reasonable overall? The only thing I was going to ask is that we revisit the goals after we get through some of the strategic planning because, you know, there are some opportunities coming along.
31:06 Can really help these shoulder seasons, you know, and thinking specifically of the seven months of ice programming that we're hoping to accomplish with the ice rink, you know, that's a great opportunity right there. So I guess the only thing I'm asking is that we revisit these goals one last time after we have the opportunity to go through the strategic plan over the next month. These goals would be to inform staff to be able to create their strategic plan towards these goals, correct?
31:31 Yeah, so we'll work off of these goals to build the plan, and then if there are adjustments we want to make after that, that's all. And what I'd ask from that standpoint is when we go through and you look at that, John, and you take those months, because you're going to do your budget by month, we take a look at those and say, what does that look like? Because we're trying to look ahead saying, okay, is 2.4 become 2.8, or does that stay at 2.4 in May increases down the road? So we'd be looking for your input in terms of where months are going to go.
31:58 Based on achieving this as a five-year goal. Does anybody feel strongly about needing to establish a gross number or a percentage growth? I think it's a great idea, but I think you could do it via those months that are not included, and it doesn't have to be a part of the aspirational goal that aligns with the other documents you were referring to. So you can have both. It could be a more detailed portion of the plan.
32:27 But I think it's important to have. I think Michael's point is a good one. I don't think you have to do it by gross. I think you want to do it by month. I think we can do that. I mean, obviously, there are factors out of our control, whether it's weather or ADR. You know, because, again, I think that we can affect the supply and demand, but we can't affect the fact that a property charges 20% more because of the fact that they realize they've got the demand. But we can definitely put together goals that we set from our side.
32:57 And then the plans that we'll present to you will come back with, you know, this is what our focus on fall is. This is what the effort looks like. This is what the budget commitment is. That's why we wanted to do this as here's the plan. Here's the budget associated with it. And then we can say here's what we anticipate for September, October, November. Yeah, because life's going to throw us curveballs. We're going to get down the road and all of a sudden we've got a fire or something and changes. If we wanted to add a gross, I mean, just because it's a round number and it's not that far off, just throw it out there. Sustainability at $20 million.
33:27 I mean, we're at 18 right now, right? Well, 18.1 was last year. We'll probably be 16, 5, 17 this year is my guess. So off of our record, it's only a 10, it's a 12% increase off of an all-time record year. Looking at increasing these other months, that's in a five-year period, that's a pretty, I would say it's not necessarily a lofty goal, but if we wanted to throw a number in there for gross, 20 million is a nice round number. Anybody object to that? I mean, that's something to shoot for.
33:55 I'm okay with shooting for a number, but I'd kind of like to see what that average is. If we go up, what we're saying with five and two, what does that mean? Is that a bigger percentage or lower? I don't know. Off the top of my head, because it seems a little low from a goal standpoint. It does. But there are going to be those fluctuations within. I mean, if we get the five and ten, excuse me, the five and two and five at a million, you know, some of those that are at two million might come.
34:22 Just whatever. It may come down from 2.6 million in January to 2.4 one year. It's still over two, but we're looking for that, and we're still looking for an aggregate. I mean, if we are, if we care about that. I don't know if the group does or not. Do we care about it gross? Like I said, I'm fine with what everyone wants to do. Aggregate?
34:44 That was an indifferent sort of yes. All right. So five and two. So we could say this. So 20 million is kind of a, as they're planning, and we'll see it as they develop final numbers on that. Can I make a motion that we set our goal as a $20 million annual total goal with five months being at $2 million and five months being at a million dollars minimum, and the deadline for that goal would be five years from now. Okay.
35:11 Is there a second? I second. Okay. Any discussion on that as a goal? Okay. All those in favor? Aye
35:34 So if we come back to our marketing plan, and it's one of the things that I just want to make sure we've covered, and if there's anything else as a generic overall arching principle. So if I take out what we just discussed with our economic stability, we have three key criteria that are still there. Have a consistent visitor base to sustain occupancy levels and employment base year-round. Support air service and drive utilization.
35:59 Provide stable and consistent annual visitation to attract new investment and develop opportunities to the market. Do you want to modify that, add, attract? From the standpoint, we're giving our overarching principles as direction here of what the goal is at the end. My challenge with those overarching principles is there's no metric to be measuring success against those the way we are with the dollars and actually having something that's set there, whether it's visitation. What does success look like?
36:28 They're vague enough that we can argue semantics within the community of what success actually is. So I think having set KPIs against those three things is going to be key. I think the intent is right. I think we need to have something that's measurable against those so that we can say that success has either been met or not.
36:48 So let's split that up. That's just my opinion. I don't know if other people agree, but I think having something that's measurable again, so this is going to be key. Well, in some of that, when we talk about the stable, consistent annual visitation, we only do the visitor profile and the visitor volume. Whitney, are we doing visitor volume again every two years, like visitor profile? So we do that every two years, so we don't necessarily have that as an annual method. It could be biannual. I just think we need to be able to set a number that says this is what that looks like.
37:19 I think it's the right. Do we want to look at visitor volume? It's more to bring quality gas versus quantity. I think that becomes a million-dollar question. I think for my years in the ski industry, everybody always looked at skier visits, but I would much rather have 20% less skier visits and 30% more revenue. So I think that there is a question of is visitor volume a
37:49 The right metric, or is it the spend per visitor, or is it the total? Can you read that second? What would have been bold point two, or is the first one that you listed? Have a consistent visitor base to sustain occupancy levels and employment base year-round. So that to me sounds like that's a goal that's a specific number of people, whether it's dollar spend or not. Yeah, that's a tough one. Sorry. Go ahead, Wendy. Can you come to the microphone, please?
38:21 Sorry about that. It could be based in occupancy nights because we've seen how the visitor has stayed. Remember, they used to come one night, two nights. Now we're seeing those longer stays. So that's what we want is a guest who will come, stay longer days and spend more money in our community. Right. And that's where I think that having a goal there that says, you know, that if it, I don't know what the number is now, but if the current number of visitors is an average of 2.4 nights. 2.4 nights.
38:51 So I think we should have a goal that's associated that says success looks like this so that it's actually measurable so that when we get that data every two years, right now, that's an unmeasurable goal because there's no specific target set against it. Measurable is fine. Just overarching strategy, something that I have been thinking about lately is just how much I appreciate wanting to attract people who want to live here.
39:23 You know the old adage of I live your vacation. That's certainly not something we want to advertise. But at the same time, I do like the overall, all the components that come along with that is that as we go forward in this 21st century and
39:38 commuting from or telecommuting, whatever the case may be, is that we have the opportunity to really create a desirable place to be that really fits into us as locals as far as how we live here, as well as attracting visitors that want to come here. So that's a little bit different. I mean, that's literally a fourth aspect that I just even want to throw out there. I think Scott's comments about being able to measure all these goals is critical. That was something that I just came into this document from an overarching perspective.
40:07 For me, it's, you know, being in lodging is kind of that catch the way too. What's a successful month look like for me? I measure my total revenue. I'm looking at what am I doing? Am I more profitable or not based on what I had come to the property? So total number of people is not as important to me to a certain degree, but if that's our goal from MLT, what is that parameter and what are we trying to achieve? Are we saying there's a max occupancy to the town? Are we trying to say that we should...
40:35 Increase, you know, only have 2.4 million, and that's what we should achieve as an overall, or are we saying 2.4 or 2.5 is our base, and now we're looking to increase that to 2.9. I think we need to define what is this. I would look to you guys in lodging for that, because it's, I do think that that.
40:51 That point is talking about people here. So what's the metric where you guys would feel like it's successful? Is it the average dollar spent per night? Is it the number of nights that someone spends on average? Is it the number of people that come to town? Is it a gross number? But I think if you're going to direct staff to go out and do something, they need to know what the goal is, what's considered, because even in our conversation here, we have this big variance, right? So if they're going to say, you know, John and staff are going to have a different direction to go do something if the goal is purely number of people crossing 203,
41:21 versus the number of dollars people spend in town that raises the average nightly rate. We need to be able to set that as a goal for them so that staff can say, okay, this is how we go forward over the next five years to achieve that. And it's a difficult thing to say because, speaking from the lodging side, if you have somebody, I mean...
41:38 If you have somebody here for one or two nights versus five nights, your marginal profit is way higher on a five-night stay because you're doing, you're no cleaning, you're doing less for them and they're more self-sufficient. So from that standpoint, definitely from lodging, it's a longer stay. From restaurant standpoint, you know, I don't know. I mean, if people are here for five nights, how often are they going to go out during that stay versus if you have a whole lot of two-night stays, are those folks more likely to go out?
42:01 All the time we're here because of the fact that it's new people coming to town and they want to go out and eat. So I, you know, that's a difficult thing to say. Different sectors, I think, do perform better based on the guest and what that guest is doing. So it's a little difficult. Well, it depends on where they stay. But I would, to Scott's point, I would say I think we have to really clearly define visitor is that because visitor is more important to me than TOT nights because people driving up and down the,
42:31 You know, 395 might come in and have lunch and drive out. They didn't stay, but retail and food and beverage can benefit from that. And then you have campers. Campers are a good chunk of business between June and September. Tired of the s'mores and the hot dogs, come into town and have a meal or two, sometimes multiple meals on a week camping trip. So is visitor, does visitor mean someone that, like you said, crossed, you know, exited the 395 and came into Mammoth?
43:01 Purely an overnight stay at a hotel. I think the metric that will help us establish this goal is length of stay. And length of stay is one thing in the wintertime, it's another thing in the summertime. If we're able to take those one-night visitors that come on a tour, you know, through the Triangle, through the national parks and so forth, and get them to say it.
43:26 A second night, you know, we've really achieved something there and impacted visitation quite substantially. Same thing in the wintertime, if we're looking at that, as you know, we're looking at air service to help us increase our length of stay because those people commit earlier, stay longer, and so forth. So I think the visitation number, whatever it may be, is the metric that we could use to help with all of this.
43:51 And I think if you look at the marketing plan, just to throw it out there, on page 26, we do have the current average nights, which is late to stay, party size, spending per day, and total trip spending. So we do have the metrics in here. We can look at them year over year over year. We can set the goals based on moving forward. I think one of the things that I would caution us, and Eric and I talk about this a lot as it relates to air, is I think we have to be careful because I think
44:19 I've always said the Mountain, if the Mountain wants to do 2 million skier visits and that's the only metric, they can sell $69 lift tickets and hit 2 million skier visits next year. They're going to provide a terrible experience and they're not going to have the right guest experience and it's going to be all on Saturday and Sunday and not midweek where we need it. I think the same thing we've talked about with air service. I think it's always been the focus on the number of employments and again, we could hit 50,000 employments, we could hit 100,000 employments, but we could go out there and have
44:47 20% load factor and $5 million in subsidy. So I think we have to be careful as to setting numbers because we can achieve numbers. It's just it may be at the detriment of experience or other things. So that's my two cents there. I think if you have this metric, this is a great number that if we talk about having somewhat by season by those months that you say you have an average number of nights and you have an average spend and that's a goal and you can create a strategy around that. You know, like if currently
45:15 Our average winter guest is 3.1 nights and they're spending on average $481 a day and you set that goal at four nights or $3.5 and $600 and you can create a strategy around that that you want to attract events or things that are going to raise higher ticket prices. What they're going to spend there, how does that all go up, supply and demand might drive some of that. But then we have something that we can measure success against. It says, hey, we set this as our goal.
45:40 Now we can go back to the team. They built their strategy to it. And as a board, we can then say, OK, how are we working towards that goal? And is this working right? It's interesting because it could be other caveats. If we go to 3.5 nights, it may be that we're filling midweek, which actually drives the per day down. Can I try something here? So we're looking at overarching business objectives, right? In bold, it says make Mammoth Lakes a strong year-round destination. That's fine. As we go down into these four bullets, I think there's some redundancy there.
46:08 There's some lack of specificity there. And, you know, if you look at, for example, Bullet 2 and Bullet 4, have a consistent visitor base is the first part of Bullet 2, provide stable and consistent annual visitation. Those are essentially the same thing. The byproduct of that is to be able to sustain occupancy levels, employment base year-round, and to attract investment and development opportunities in the market. I think those can be consolidated to one bullet.
46:38 So we'd be looking to provide a stable and consistent annual visitation in order to attract investment and development opportunities, sustain occupancy levels, and year-round employment. Then, if that's our overarching goal, we could have some bullets to Scott's point that are actually a little bit more tangible out of that. Bullet one, you know, generating a million...
47:02 TOT for 10 out of 12 months, and we just broke that out into 5 and 5, but that could be a bullet that falls under that overarching goal. Supporting air service and driving utilization could be a bullet that falls under that overarching goal, and I think if our overall goal is, you know, a stable and consistent annual visitation, we need to establish a KPI for that that measures success, because it's too nebulous at this point.
47:31 I think Colin's really hit the nail on the head. The thing that I think is a killer for businesses in town is instability, having things go up and down radically, and that happens in tourist town. Finding ways to weatherproof and avoid that instability, I think, is the key to keeping businesses alive, because it's very hard to plan for a tremendous number of tourists
47:59 One year and then not very many the next year. Focusing on having as one of our major overarching strategies creating stability with a number of bullet points underneath that to say how we're going to get to stability I think is the right way to go. And we've articulated that very well from a TOT standpoint. We've not done so with air service or consistent visitation. So I think if we kind of just reframe the way that this is worded, bulleted,
48:29 You know, the language that we're using, I think it will be a lot clearer. The TOT numbers, does that talk about consistent visitation? Yeah, and I think that pulls underneath, you know, down into a bullet underneath that overarching goal. I mean, and, you know, I know I was just throwing a bunch of stuff out there, but I could, you know, articulate exactly what I'm saying there and see if that's palatable. Can you read the air service one again? So what I was going to say is, you know, leave business objectives and make Mammoth Lakes a strong year-round destination.
48:58 I would say up top it says provide stable and consistent annual visitation in order to attract investment and development opportunities in the market, sustain occupancy levels, and provide year-round employment. So that would be the overall goal. Underneath that would be bullets that would be, you know, generate a million of...
49:20 Generate a minimum of $20 million in overall gross TOT in five-year time frame with five months at two million and five months at a million, or yeah, five and five. The second one would be support air service and drive utilization, and we have to establish what, you know, a metric for that, what success looks like in five years. And then the third piece would just be to establish some sort of visitation metric that we...
49:49 Have a success, and that would be kind of the third bullet underneath it. So I like where we're going, but a question on it. So employment, we don't do any, do we have any studies in the town? It's county. It's county, as good as we got it. I'm just saying, that's a byproduct of our efforts. Right, but it'd be nice to be able to measure if we're being successful as we're putting in there, if we can get it from the county, if they have employment. But the county doesn't do it. I mean, the county does it, again, I hate to call on Whitney, but I think the county only does employment stuff every few years, if not five years, studies.
50:18 Because the second part is also new investment. How do we calculate new investment in the community? I'm just trying to make, if we've got metrics, how do we break that down to... I think if our pieces of the goal are visitation-based, air service-based, and TOT-based, if we establish a metric for those three things, we've done a sufficient amount in this, you know, and some of those other things will be byproducts. What is air service, TOT? Air service, TOT, and...
50:45 Visitation. So visitation, we talked about a KPI that was both average spend and nights. Okay. Yeah, visitation is effort. And for air service, I think it's an employment question and it's a subsidy or reduction of subsidy questions. Well, that's what we're going to come to the air service's question of what we want to give direction on that one. Let's hold for air service, but let's go back. I think, though, because the question that you brought up, Scott, was we're going to have this and have KPIs.
51:11 We need to at least have something, even if we aren't doing it ourselves, that we can measure and say, okay, we've got employment, we're actually being successful, keeping employees here, and we've created new investment in the community. This may not be all resolved in terms of how we get that information. It would be nice to know in three years, okay, we have 12 new businesses, started businesses in town. It may not be directly related to us, but it's an after effect of what we've done to promote the community and promote the great location that we're in.
51:33 So we're trying to find out what our least common denominator is on this, right? Because, I mean, we're looking at it with different hats on. We're talking about TOT and saying what kind of, you know, dollars generated from that. We haven't really talked about TBID dollars because that's relevant to restaurants and retail and stuff. And so that would be a way to justify it. And we're talking about development opportunities as a measurement to measure the success.
52:00 Of all this. I mean, really, what you need is like a gigantic turnstile at the bottom of 203, and you count how many people come into town for any given reason, whether it's development, TOT, TBID spend, and then, you know, how many come in and how many go out? You know, we're beating it up a lot here, and for good reason. I mean, that's not it, but, you know, what is our common denominator in this thing? What's most important? Do you think it is?
52:28 the measurement of the tax dollars because that's the most relevant to a budget. Money is always the easiest metric to measure. Let me add two words to what Colin said. Provide stable and consistent annual visitation and growth.
52:47 Yeah, and I think that's spoken to with the $20 million in the five months of $2 million. Well, it is, but you wanted a statement of overarching strategy, and growth is part of our overarching strategy. I don't want to beat this to death, but I'm trying to be cognizant of Scott's point that I think is valid that we need a KPI established for these things, and I trust you and your team to go back and establish what the metric is for those things, but I think if we just kind of reword it and reestablish it, it'll flow. Yeah, yeah, I got it written down. Okay.
53:13 So my only question is, do we need a KPI for investment and employment? That's my question to the board. If not, we'll move on. But do we need to figure out if there's any resource for that? Or does a byproduct, if we can get a measurement, that's great. I don't believe you do, because I think that that's the intent of what the three measurable things we go to. I would second that with Colin. I don't think we do either, because I guarantee you, if we accomplish the rest of it, those two things will grow. Just trying to make sure we're following the same logic that we've started. Okay. So with that, I'm going to say no metrics.
53:42 On employment and or investment. Now let's come back to the air service because I think one of the questions that we've come around on this board several times is what is our air service? Is it load factor? Is it subsidy? Is it visitors? What's our objective here in terms of we're going to bring more people to Mammoth as a total?
53:59 Are we saying within a certain budget to John saying, okay, given $2 million a year, we want the most number of people that we can possibly get here, or we want the highest load factor that we possibly can on planes to also reduce our cost for employments, et cetera? So to me, I think we need to find that and just give direction to the staff and say, what's our objective here so you can plan that marketing accordingly? Well, and I think that Eric hit it with the cost per passenger because I think, again, if you start talking about employments, again, we can probably get you...
54:27 50,000, 100,000 employments if you want to drop $5 million on air service. So we have to be very careful that just because we want to get people to the market, we have to be very smart about it. And I think we've taken a little bit of heat because we've reduced the amount of available seats coming in. We've increased the load factor and we've kind of flattened down on 25,000 employments a year. But, you know, we're also not paying, I think our peak for subsidy was a few years ago at $3.3 million.
54:55 So again, is it worth $3.3 million to go out and get 28,000 people instead of 25,000 people? So I think that's where we have to be careful about the chicken and egg of responsible air service. Same thing, it's the same idea of the mountain getting to 2 million visits by charging nothing and just having overrun of people. I agree with that, Patrick, and I think you can pair it with the fact that we're trying to look at the average spend per night and so forth. I mean, obviously,
55:23 We think that that visitor has a higher spend on average per night. And that's going to be one of our metrics too. So we can utilize both those to define success in the air service. And I think when we talk about the third bullet of the visitor profile, I'll call it that, with the average nights and the party size and the spending per day and all of that, I think what we need to do is we need to take those numbers on page 26 and we need to say, okay.
55:47 Here's our drive market. Here's our fly market. And we do that throughout here as well. We see that the air passenger spends 31% more than the drive passenger. So I think it's important to say, okay, this is what the drive market looks like. This is what the air market looks like. And to Eric's point, we want the fly market because they are going to stay longer and spend more. And so I think we set the metrics on both of those. And I think that's a good way to look at it. Sorry, I lost a point on a little bit with you, Eric. I got the spend, but what was the other criteria that you were seeing?
56:16 Is there a KPI for measurement? The average spend is what I was saying. So you've got the cost per passenger, so how much you pay in subsidy per person that you have coming in, and then you pair that with the average spend that they have while they're here. So hypothetically speaking, for simple math, if the average person coming up here spends $400 a day and it costs us $100 to get them here when they drive,
56:45 And the person that flies in costs us $300, but they spend $800 when they're here. Flight people are, they're efficient. They make us more money when they come in per person. That would be a good metric to measure. Just being able to, like, have something really simple. Like, okay, like, we made $500 off of every person that flew here. That's my ROI. Having a really simple, like, I think that just for the purpose of having KPIs, like, the simplest ROI. What did we spend and what did we get for that? And did that meet that goal is the best way to do it. I think if it's overly complex,
57:16 It becomes, it's hard to drive a strategy around it. Can we, I don't know, maybe this is foolish, but can we start out with some sort of budgeted or conceived subsidy amount versus a budgeted or conceived emplainment amount and, you know, then match reality to that to see, you know, as we go along to see how it works out? I mean, theoretically, there's some reasonable amount to spend on subsidy.
57:45 There's a reasonable amount of passengers to expect from the subsidy.
57:50 And theoretically, we could establish that as our baseline and go from there and... I think that's kind of what we're saying. And we have that established in the budget. And that's what I'm saying, like, without the board getting into strategy, if we set a goal of saying this is what our ROI is, it's up to John's team to say, hey, look, it might cost us 10 times as much to fly someone from Dallas and bring a long-haul flight in here, but they're going to spend 12 times as much as someone we fly up from LA, so we're going to go do that because that's going to be the most effective ROI. That's their strategy decision from the staff, but from the boards that we say...
58:19 Here's what the expectation is. This is the goal. How you get to that goal, the most efficient way to get to that goal is up to the staff's decision, but the board would set that as the parameter. This is what the expectation is. Okay, but we have to have some parameters to start with. That's what we're talking about. And I think this is only kind of tangentially related, but...
58:37 It's just something that I kind of want to put out there for board consideration that I think the only thing that we need to be cognizant around this is that we, to this point, really haven't established a solid baseline for air service. So, you know, looking at those metrics as far as, you know,
58:55 ROI and reduction to subsidy and all those type of things I think are absolutely good long-term goals for us. But I think we need to recognize that we've got a very long-established, very well-traveled, very well-known drive market here. We do not have that on the air service side of things, so we may need to take it in the chin a little bit on the air side of things to get things up and running until we can start to establish some of those more reasonable metrics. So I just think... Well, that goes back where Mike...
59:25 Thinking is in terms of like all of a sudden in the off season, we're running one flight or no flights or two flights, there may be in order to build it, you may come back and say, this is where am I going to, but I may have to change how the flights are, or even if it's Alaska versus somebody else. I'm not saying we do, but just what those metrics are as part of your equation just to get to the best performance. I mean, I use the parallel very often, you know, when we look at ESTA, right? You know, when Michael, he's here, when he goes out and he sells Mammoth,
59:53 On an international basis, one of the things that he uses as a sales pitch is, hey, you don't need a car. You can fly into Mammoth. Everything's easy. You can walk places. And we've got this fabulous transit system that can take you around seven days a week from morning to night. If we were to look at those utilization numbers and say, you know what? Ridership just doesn't really work on a Tuesday and Wednesday. So we're going to pull the bus service on a Tuesday and Wednesday. The whole thing falls apart.
1:00:22 Because we can now no longer tell people you can come here without a car because if you're here on a Tuesday and Wednesday, you're SOL. So I think that as we start to establish that baseline of air service and make sure that everything works, you know.
1:00:38 We look at those things with ESTA as well. It's like, how's our ridership doing? What are our numbers looking at? Do we need to add more buses during peak times? But at least establishing that minimum baseline threshold, I just don't even think we're there yet with air service. So, you know, it's just something that I think we need to be cognizant of. And I know it's only kind of partially related to what we're talking about right now. But that's true, Colin, because there's a difference between efficiency and availability.
1:01:02 Right. I mean, those two things are, and we could be as efficient as possible with what we, you know, and have two flights total, and look how efficient we are, but we're, like you said, we don't have two flights per day. If we're going to go out and say, you can fly to Mammoth from so-and-so, we have two flights every day, 365, that's got to be a baseline. And if that makes us a little inefficient to start with, well, that's, we might have to bite that bullet. And that's why I think sitting against KPIs is something that's measurable again, like we said, you know, five years out, like that, what's the strategic plan, like we should set that goal.
1:01:31 This is where we want to be in three years or five years, not the expectation that that's a goal that's going to be achieved in the next 12 months. I think there needs to be a long-term investment, a long-term view to those goals so that when we go through and we look at our strategy and our budget for the next year, we're not just thinking this year, we're thinking about this is an investment in year two, three, four, five, and that's the strategic plan we're talking about versus like, well, you spent this on air service and we didn't get that this year. It's like, well, that's a new point we're going to talk about for our long-term view.
1:02:00 Sorry, Paul. I think, Colin, to your point, which is a good one, especially about air service, that when we're working with the FAA, we're giving them forecasts of emplanements. So emplanements is kind of like the gross number, if you will. We've talked about the efficiencies already, but I think emplanements is a really important overall factor to try and help us establish that.
1:02:27 The baseline. And I think that might be the metric that establishes that and gives you the consistency that we're looking for too, you know. So what do we do at the Mammoth, if you do in planements and cost per passenger as it combined, that, you know, good marketing without subsidy necessarily could be a really good cost per passenger if there's high demand where people are flying up because of access to flights. And you get in planements and you get your cost.
1:02:56 You'd be looking at through both of those two lenses. Yep. And spent. What Colin was talking about was optics to the visitor, how the transportation system looks to the visitor, and that's obviously a very important part of it, but there is a flip side, and that's optics to our local residents. As an organization, we've had a hard time enunciating air service to...
1:03:20 the local population. I think that's something we need to clarify and come up with a way to put it out there to the public to say this is how air service figures in so everybody can understand it because it's a sore point for this organization. We get a lot of negative feedback, especially from our local media and we need, as a marketing organization should, we need to find a better way to put out the optics to the locals.
1:03:46 So the locals feel comfortable with the money that we're spending and what we get in return. Okay, and I think that's something we direct staff to come back with, but I'm just going to wrap up air as an overall. We're talking about employments, cost per passenger, versus as a comparison, what the tolls spend by those people that come by air service. That's a comparison that we're seeing. John, do you have any, you're good with that as a metrics? Yeah. Okay. Does Embark Aviation have any?
1:04:15 Goals or recommendations or precedents for setting? Embark will be at our strategy meeting. Okay. Yep. Really part of the conversation. I think one of the things, and it's funny because the more successful we are at getting people from further markets, the less, the more money it costs us. So if somebody originates in JFK and they fly to Los Angeles and they hop our flight, we actually have to pay more, we get less money off of, less revenue off of that person than we do if somebody hops a flight in LA and goes direct here. We get 100% off of the direct from LA, but if they start in,
1:04:45 JFK, most of the money is going to go to JFK. Really? Just on the flight? On the flight, on the cost of the flight itself, which is actually one of those catch-22s because it's actually, we want that person from JFK because they're going to be in the market spending more, but the subsidy is actually going to go up. We saw that with July last summer where we had more passengers, but our cost was higher.
1:05:07 And we asked Alaska, and they said, well, you've got a heck of a lot of people originating in different markets coming through. So if they start somewhere other than direct flight from LA, which we get 100% of that revenue towards our subsidy, we may only get 30% of the revenue if somebody starts from somewhere else, but they're going to stay longer and spend more in the market. So it is a little bit of a catch-22 where our subsidy may go up, but we actually have more people spending more money. I think the point, Paul, is to make sure that the people in the community understand why it's worth it.
1:05:37 Why it's worth it to spend the money, and if, like Scott said earlier, if we bring in a guest that's spending X times more, yes, it costs us more to get them here, but they're putting this much more into the community, and you've got to be able, as a business person, hopefully you can see that, that it's worth to spend that guest, because that, they're going to give you that marginal profit. I just don't think that's a message we've completely gotten across yet. Well, and I think we struggle with the consistency of service. That's the hard part.
1:06:03 Well, I was just going to say, one other goal that I've kind of been thinking about is, and I don't know how quantifiable this is, or maybe we actually include specific target markets that we want to be
1:06:16 Hubbed with, want to be linked with. Thinking of the game that my kid plays with the different islands, that the more islands you connect with each other to build a culture, the more you win the game. I'm just kind of thinking, you know, whether it's Las Vegas or other hub markets that we want to go after just brings in more people that are to the area. And I don't know if that's something that Embark Aviation would recommend or not. I think we have to define hub.
1:06:40 Because Vegas isn't a hub as far as an air market goes. If you're talking about it as just a general market, we have been marketing in Las Vegas. It's just, you know, when we look at air service itself and you're talking about a hub, there aren't a lot of connections through Vegas. That's not a hub. So like even with Alaska, Los Angeles isn't a hub for them. So that's why we end up with more point-to-point versus having them have a ton of flights that come in. Whereas San Francisco is a hub for United and we have 50% people originating in San Francisco and 50%.
1:07:09 coming from Chicago or Newark or Houston or wherever. So I just want to come, because the way I'm reading this and the way my intent is is that we're saying to staff, we want the best performance on employments, what is our cost per passenger and what's our dollar spend. Whether that means it's Vegas, Chicago, New York, doesn't matter. We're saying come back as part of our conversation on the first with embarking why certain airports may make sense down the road or not.
1:07:35 But there may be, going to Colin's point, we may be presented with something that says, if you really want to do this, you're going to spend an extra million dollars in Chicago because a million dollars in Chicago is going to generate as 20 million dollars here. I don't know. I'm just making that up. I'm just saying that's what we're saying to staff is come back with that as part of our performance. So we're looking at it as part of our strategy. Fine. So, because I want to move on because we've got several other key points I want to make sure we get to today. So, what I'm hearing is, Colin, I think, is everyone's agreeing that we've reorganized how we've got the structure on that and bullet point those down below.
1:08:05 Clip that language. They would agree on the generation of the million dollars a year. They would define that. We've split out the occupancy, employment, investment, and annual visitation as separate bullet points from that, as well as air. Air then defines as cost, employments, and spend, as well as the spend by visitors and room nights and length of stay by visitors is our other initial criteria. Did I miss anything on that?
1:08:36 Well, can we add TBID, or is there a reason why we don't have TBID as a business objective and measurable? We can add whatever we want to add into. The only reason I say that is because when I look at the numbers, it doesn't track TBID doesn't track. Like, for example, in my business, July is my latest month. And yet, you know, by almost a million dollars, December is bigger than July for TOT.
1:09:06 I think you're looking at total expenses. I think your room nights, where you're looking at TOT for December, the room cost is probably double, if not triple. So ADR has a lot to do with that. ADR is a huge amount to do with that. But I'm just saying, they don't track each other, so TBID, is TBID not an important data point, or is it just we've kind of trowed that ground and it doesn't make sense?
1:09:33 You were talking about on page 26, that metric that you were talking about using for a service does not include TBID? Yeah, that's all. So we would have that included. Yeah, but I think what Michael's point is saying, we have this. He's trying to capture the retail spend. Yeah, what's our spend? All the spend is not TOT. It's not a hotel. We can probably track.
1:09:55 Sales tax increase? Sales tax, probably. That's probably the only way we can track anything outside of lodging. We can probably track the sales track. Are you saying it's not on the same level as December? July should be a two-point? No, no, he's saying if people spend more. July is by far the biggest month, where here, you know, January, February are bigger months, right, than July. Well, I think your price in July is the same price in December, probably, on your food? Correct. So you're doing more people.
1:10:23 The thing is we're doing in December, the cost for lodging is that much higher. It's not the same as it is in July. It's getting there, but it's not there now. So if ADR in December is $350 and ADR in July is $200, that's the difference in why December and July on lodging look different. The summer number has been creeping up, which you see in this number, but I think that we're still getting that demand where it's still not going to be the winter levels yet.
1:10:53 But again, based on supply and demand, it should be creeping up. But I think what he's simply saying is that if we're just tracking TOT, because of that ADR fluctuation, it's not maybe an accurate representation of how many bodies are coming through town. And another metric to look at would be sales tax because that covers the spend in town. To Kurt's turnstile analogy, I agree with that.
1:11:19 You just don't catch the day visitors, the triangle, right? The people that are shooting up to Yosemite from Death Valley, you don't get...
1:11:25 The day trippers you don't get, the campers you don't get any of that. And I heard you say, Michael, I'm putting words in your mouth now, but I heard you say, shouldn't we use TBID as the metric, not sales tax? Actually, establish TBID as a metric. It seems like you could kind of get... You're talking about collections? Well, I'm saying if TBID is... That's what I'm calling. I thought that's what I heard. If TBID was $4 million... It's exactly because there isn't anything that's TBID that isn't sales tax, right?
1:11:53 If there was a difference, then yeah, I would default to TBID. But either way, as TBID or sales, what I was hearing was, why don't we have a goal for TBID increase as well? Not just TOT, but why are we saying TBID should go up 20% in over five years or 12% or whatever it is, setting a metric for our growth for TBID? That's what I thought I was hearing initially. I'm just saying TBID is an important data point to measure because it's very, very different than TOT, and especially in the summer. In fact, almost exclusively in the summer, fall.
1:12:24 Very, very different. You can have TOT flatten out and TBID on a trajectory that's much higher. And night stay is not the only thing that we're looking to increase. That's your point, is that day traffic is a big part of it and we want to increase that too. To Scott's point, I think page 26 incorporates, when we're talking about the visitor spend, the average visitor spend or even by season, that incorporates all of our efforts going into it. I think if you want to look at the TBID growth over five years and you want to set
1:12:54 And obviously we set a budget for TBID every year and that's kind of the goal. This year's goal is 5.29 million. My guess is we'll probably come in at about 5 million. So we have it set by month. Because it just seems like it's more than half our budget from an overall standpoint that we should be saying how are we going to grow TBID from an overall standpoint. Some of that comes from TOT, but there's another factor on that. Exactly.
1:13:22 There's going to be a percentage that comes in in addition to that. Setting a goal for TBID separate from TOT makes sense. And together they would roll up in this metric on page 26. I didn't look at those numbers as have any suggestions on what that should be. Well, one of the things we're going to do up to our May 1st meeting is every Monday Whitney's going to start sending out information to everyone that we're going to give it to you in bite-sized chunks so that you can eat it for the next month. And one of the things we can send out is the full
1:13:49 the full tracking of TBID since its inception. So you can look at just retail or just restaurant and see what every year and every month has done. And on this sheet, there's way more detail than you probably want. You know, on this one, it's really just the year-over-year growth, or in our case, in a couple of these factors. John, what's our highest on TBID, T-date, year-to-date? Last year at 5.89. 5.89. Okay. And this year's budget's 5.29.
1:14:18 5.29 is this year's budget, and we're probably going to come in at 5, maybe a little bit shy of 5. If TOT is at 20, what would, relatively speaking, what would TBID be at? I mean, would we want to go for 7? Well, again, TOT at 20, it probably puts TBID. So that's 25% or a little 30% of it? Yeah, I mean, it could be 6 million.
1:14:43 Consistently, if it's a two, if it's a 20. Well, it was almost six last year when we were at 18.1 million. Okay, so 5.8 is a percentage of 18 and then 20. It's roughly a third of what our TOT is. 6.5. In general. So it'd be like, if we set a goal five years from now, 6.5. I like where you're going, Michael, just to attach it to the 20 million, whatever it is, that's the goal.
1:15:07 Because we've already established the 20 million, right? And then you break it down to be a month so that you can see the variation of it. I propose 6.5 if those numbers work out. Yeah, it's about 6.8. 20 million. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. And do you want to set it by each category? Or do you want to just set it as a top line number? I think we do top line and you come back with how you split that out. Okay. Okay.
1:15:44 We're kind of throwing a number out here real quick without, I just want to make sure we verify this. There you go, John. We'll give you a number. It's about 6.5. Yeah, about 6.5. If peak was 18.5 and it goes to 20, that's like roughly an 8% increase and same on 5.9 peak would go to 6.4-ish, 6.5. Okay.
1:16:10 Could we start at 6.5 and come back, John, in terms of just clarifying and make sure we aren't throwing a number out here that's just not achievable? Okay. We're going to wrap up on the market plan portion. And we clear on those general objectives because we've still got some criteria here that I need to help with. Okay. There is one caveat on the T-bit stuff that we'll talk about when we get to the T-bit renewal. Which just happens to be the next discussion. Hey. Brent, real quick. I'm sorry. Did you say at one point we were going to discuss the elections?
1:16:39 Yes, I'm going to add that in as at the end of six new business. All right, thank you. I just got to remind you. Yes. Okay. Great. Thanks. All right. Are we on TBID? TBID. Renewal and update discussion. Okay. Again, I'm going to talk about my recommendations that will move us forward to getting this solidified. You guys feel free to shoot holes in it, talk about it, push it out. With the TBID renewal, obviously, we're still on pace to do the resolution of intent.
1:17:10 on April 18th at the council meeting. What that means is that by next Monday I need to turn in the resolution of intent as well as the agenda bill to the town clerk's office and then I need to finalize all the petitions and get those to the town clerk probably anytime before the 18th so we have a little bit of time to get that together. Our public hearings have put us out through May 2nd, June 6th and then a resolution of formation on June 20th.
1:17:42 And so one of the things that we've been looking here, and some of the stuff that is written on the agenda is contrary to what I'm going to throw out here as recommendations. One of the things that we've heard, and I think you've even talked to some of the board members about it, is people have been questioning why we're looking at a 10-year renewal. So when you put a TBID together, you can do it only for five years. When you renew, you can go for five or 10 years. My goal was to go out and say, let's lock in for 10 years. Let's make sure that we have the funding for, one, the organization, and two, so that we know that we've got that funding locked in.
1:18:12 We've heard a lot from businesses in town as to why we're doing 10 years versus renewing for another five. So I think that in the process here, I think the recommendation was instead of it being from 2018 to 2028, I would recommend that for this section we go five years. We go to 2023 and lock in at five years and then we reevaluate as we move forward. There might be...
1:18:36 New changes down the road in Bishop. We've talked about airport. I've had a lot of conversations with the mountain. TBID law restricts use of the TBID dollars outside of the district to marketing and directional signage towards the district. So right now the district is the town of Mammoth Lakes and then there's an island around Mammoth Yosemite Airport. So that's all part of the TBID district.
1:19:01 We've also worked with the town on infrastructure side and our Measure A dollars can't be used down the road. So we are looking at really continuing to support air service via subsidy and marketing to the tune of $2.5 million moving forward for the five years of this TBID. That's the plan at this point is to continue to focus on marketing and subsidy. If for some reason Bishop Airport becomes viable in two years, three years, five years, we can use those dollars to market in
1:19:31 Dallas or Phoenix or Seattle or wherever we end up going and we can also use it for portions of the TBID, excuse me, portions of the subsidy that we can show are coming to Mammoth Lakes because the TBID, as you know, has to show a specific benefit to the people that pay into it. So obviously we can't just pay 100% of a TBID going into, or a subsidy going into Bishop when somebody gets off the plane and goes to Death Valley or somebody gets off the plane and stays in Bishop or goes to Yosemite, so at least we can say, okay, X number of people are coming here.
1:20:01 That's way down the road. That's all stuff that we can talk about when we actually would need to talk about that. But for now, our commitment is to $2.5 million towards current air subsidy and current air marketing. And not legal for infrastructure. Not legal for infrastructure. The only legal use for it outside of the district is marketing, which we do. And they made an amendment to the 94 law that said there was a district that wanted to put a welcome sign outside of their district.
1:20:31 And so they amended it so that they could put this welcome sign outside of their district. So it's very legal as to what you can do. So you could put a sign at the Bishop Airport that says Mammoth goes this way and you could have a bus service that brought someone to Mammoth. Absolutely. But you couldn't build the terminal that people sat in while they waited for the bus. Correct. Correct. And I think that at this point, because Bishop, there's still a lot of question marks and we still need to know the cost and the timing and everything else.
1:20:56 That's going to be a decision for this board to make when we get to that point. So when we get to the point of needing to market or needing to subsidize Bishop Airport, then we can talk about the concept of moving dollars within the TBID as it stands. The way the management district plan is written, this board has the capabilities of moving 20% of the budget on any annual basis.
1:21:19 But again, we don't have to worry about that right now. It's something down the road. We'll continue to focus on our air service here. We'll continue to look at new markets. We'll continue to look at expanding our markets. We'll continue to look at marketing our markets better. But for right now, we're really focused on Mammoth Yosemite. The other piece that we looked at, so with the ICON task,
1:21:39 No, I'm going to save a question. Thank you. With the ICON pass, Altera is selling the ICON pass. Right now it's at $599 and $899. There is no tax added to that. There is no assessment. There is no civic fee. It's $899 or $599. With that in mind, we've had a request from Mammoth Mountain to remove the season pass from the TBID. So instead of having that pass along as it has in the past, we would look to remove that from the current.
1:22:06 plan. In the past, we had received funds on lift tickets, season passes, and ski school revenues. Moving forward, the idea would be to continue to collect 2% on lift tickets and ski school, but to exclude the season pass portion, and thus we would actually reduce our, we've been currently spending about $3 million on air service. We would reduce that focus for now to $2.5 million. So we won't have the revenue coming in, but we won't have the responsibility of
1:22:36 Right now it's $2.91 million that we spend. So we would be looking at $2.5 million. So the reduction in season pass revenue flowing through to us would also mean that we would take that out of our current commitment. So you're saying in the last couple of years we've received $400,000 to $500,000 in season pass revenue on the mountain and that would go away? And our budget would be reduced. So the anticipation is that
1:23:03 The idea is that we're going to receive roughly $5 million a year when we have the season pass in there. Now we would receive roughly $4.5 million a year, but we would have a half a million dollars worth of commitments that we've had in the past that wouldn't be there. Does somebody else pick up that $500 or that just comes out of the air service budget?
1:23:22 I think the general plan is that ultimately, you know, one of the things that we've talked about is making sure that Altera and Mammoth Mountain have a commitment to air service, and that's to be determined, but I think that if our concern... Yeah, I'll jump in on that, John. You know, so as we progress through here, I'm just going to restate for clarity that we support TBID, and especially as it's related to help us solve the regional air service situation that we have.
1:23:52 And as you know, we think that where the answer is to that is looking at commercial service down in Bishop. So if TBID can support that, which it can, as John just went through in terms of subsidy and marketing, we then look at this and say, okay, we have a situation now where the ICON Pass is not charging the TBID for various aspects of our business. Can we take that out?
1:24:19 And then we would look at saying, okay, we can spend that money on infrastructure because that's our money, our commitment, and we can figure out a way with, you know, to be determined how we can make a public commitment to spending that money to help us solve the regional air service solution. So that's the further thought behind that as we've gone through this.
1:24:44 So if we're talking about a five-year renewal, does that mean that Altera is going to make a commitment to spend $2.5 million that they'd be saving on TBID into infrastructure in Bishop and not be asking that of this organization? I'm not going to put a number on it, Scott, because there's so many variables to it with relation to how are we getting paid for the ICOM pass. Right now it's based on...
1:25:03 You know, usage and what is that going to be versus, yeah. So the number that John just referenced was kind of our historical past usage number. So going forward, we do want to make a commitment at a 2% level, but we don't know what that dollar is. So just want to take away the dollar of that. And that will be on us.
1:25:25 to do that and obviously it can't be through TBID because you can't use it as infrastructure and if we need infrastructure down there we want to help solve the regional air service problem. So there would be no improvements to Mammoth Airport infrastructure? In terms of a...
1:25:44 That is our position. I'm not saying that that's, you know, where it is. We don't think you should improve the terminal at this point. We do think you should do the wildlife fence. We think you should do the windsock. You know, so there's improvements that should be done at Mammoth, but we don't think it needs an investment in a terminal. The town council decision where they go with that. Okay, thank you. Yep.
1:26:12 So those are the proposed changes. We would have, I've got a document that I'm going to send to our attorneys in Sacramento. The one thing that we were looking at was with the changes to the management district plan, we aren't changing anything upward, so we're not changing any, we're not increasing any percentages, we're not changing any length of term out longer, so our attorney's going to get back to us whether we need to go back out to re-petition or not.
1:26:38 So right now, if we make these management district plan changes, it could be that we can continue on right now as is. If they come back, they can make these changes to the management district plan probably by tomorrow afternoon. If we need to go back out to petition, because as you know, we need to get 50.1% of the assessed businesses to petition for this.
1:27:02 So if we have to go back out to petition, we would just have to get those done by the 18th of April. If we don't, we're already at 57%, I think, on the approval with the Mountain's participation. And we could easily go to resolution of intent April 18th, and then ultimately resolution of formation on June 20th. And then the TBID will go back into place for five years from September 1, 2018 through August 31st of 2023.
1:27:29 And then we would just have to do the renewal process in five years versus ten years. So just to clarify what you just said there, so it does not trigger a need for re-petition potentially if the rates aren't changed and the time frame isn't changed. So the reason that the original intent was to go back to petition was because it was going to be a ten-year time frame.
1:27:52 The rates had always been proposed to stay the same. Well, and there was question mark of some of the rates changing, so I think that with that it would have triggered a repetition. John Lambeth, who's our attorney, will look at that and see if that does trigger a repetition or not. It may very well, and I will look to all of our board members to, one, get your own petitions in, but also to help to secure the petitions needed to get us to that, you know, more than 50% so that we can present to town council by the 18th. You know, in talking with the town clerk,
1:28:22 The resolution and the agenda bill, I've updated those for the most part to be able to submit for that. Those are due next Monday. And then if we need to do the repetition, we would just have to have the petitions verified by the town clerk by the 18th with the idea that that night it would come to you, Colin, as a council member with the resolution of intent saying that we've achieved 57% petition approval and we can move forward.
1:28:50 How many times is it allowed to renew without going back to petitions? Is it just once? It goes back to a petition every time it renews. So in 2013 we petitioned and then back in this year we petitioned. It basically, when you renew it basically becomes setting up a brand new TBID. It's not just an addendum, it's not just an add-on. I thought you just said if it stayed at five years it wouldn't.
1:29:12 Potentially would not have to go back out to petition. Meaning that we already went to petition last spring. You already sent your petition to me last December. Okay. So we already have the folder from the initial piece. If there were major, major changes to the Management District Plan, I would have to go back out, throw the folder away, and start from scratch again. So when I say I don't have to go to re-petition, I already have your petition in hand. And we could always get more businesses, or we could have businesses that say, hey, we don't support it now, we want to pull this out.
1:29:42 Yeah, I got you. And the two changes you're suggesting are dropping it from the petition period in the spring would be dropping it from 10 to 5 years. Correct. And then pulling MMSA off the merchant pass, or I'm sorry, off the... Pulling CC pass out of the 2%. So 2% was lift ticket, season pass, ski school, it would just be lift ticket and ski school. You know, John, just to be clear, the previous district plan didn't highlight season pass. Right. It just says lift ticket.
1:30:11 So, we were paying season pass, but the actual plan does not, it says gross lift ticket sales. That was basically your volunteer. Well, yeah, and that's important to note. I think John just hit it on the head. So, when we put the TBID together in 2013, we were looking at lodging, restaurant, retail, and at the time, the ski area came to us with a voluntary 2%, and that voluntary 2% was committed towards air subsidy. So, roughly, we collect roughly
1:30:36 $2 million a year from that 2%, and it happens to be we commit $1.5 million in winter and $500,000 in summer towards air subsidy. So that voluntary amount that the mountain came to us with is committed to air. And if we did these, Eric, then the mountain would be supportive of the TBID as John just outlined? That's right, yeah, exactly. There's some follow-up that we have to do and look at the budget and the cost-sharing agreement, but that's correct. Okay, so that would...
1:31:06 Kind of put to bed a lot of... That's right. And we currently, we do a cost-sharing agreement every year with the Mountain in regards to the air subsidy and what the season looks like and how much we're committed to. My suggestion with Eric was if we come up with this solid number of air subsidy every year, we could even have it be a...
1:31:26 A long-term cost-sharing agreement for the life of the TBID, so it could be a five-year agreement, and if we had anything to change on it every year, probably the flight schedules would be an amendment to it, where it would just continue on, but that would be where we commit our 2.5 million towards air, including marketing. I mean, I think that...
1:31:44 The change to the five years makes sense. We're talking about setting a five-year goal for air service, a five-year goal for TOT, a five-year goal for TBID, and having renewal for five years. If that's something we get those numbers and we run those in April when we go out for renewal or whatever that period of time is, we'll be able to go back and say, these are the goals that were set. This is the five-year, the TBID. Here's how we've progressed to those goals or exceeded those goals. This is why those two align, I think, quite well to be able to say this is where it is. To be able to go back out and say, this is what the goal was based off of
1:32:14 staff guidance for lodging for that period of time. This is what it was for restaurants. It was for retail. You actually be able to show your goal, show your efficacy towards those goals when you go back out in 2023. Makes sense. I think I support those changes. So at that point, I'd look for a motion and approval to move forward with that. I'll make the motion to move forward with the suggestions of the reduction though.
1:32:38 We're removing the 2% for lift tickets and changing it to season passes and the change from 10 years to five years. Second. Second. Okay. Any discussion on that? All right. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Anybody opposed? All right. Okay. Thank you. All right. I'm moving this along because I want to make sure we get this done for 3 o'clock. I'm going to hold this pretty hard to a 3 o'clock close today. But there's a number of things that... Sorry? We're going to 3 or 3.30?
1:33:05 Three. Three. Okay. So let me go back because I did mention during the discussion about the five-year goals. The one thing this does is when we talk about the five-year goals and we talked about 6.5, the baseline was 5 million. Now the baseline is 4.5 million. So that obviously has to factor in. So that's when I brought that up. The whole point was that our baseline won't be 5 million. Our baseline will be 4.5 moving forward. And we'll adjust this accordingly. And that'll be part of those goals that we present. Okay. Sorry. Yep. Sorry.
1:33:34 All right, so item three. We've got a number of things here, and I'm looking for direct input from the board in terms of what we want to do on some of these items. Because if you look at it from an overall standpoint, we're capped at 2.26 million in Measure A. We're going to be about 4.5 in TBID. So we've got several things that are on the table that we need to kind of give direction for for the staff to come back with.
1:33:55 Number one, from an overall standpoint of the chamber, we had allocated a temporary amount of dollars to get through to this year, but in the budget, that's $37,000 that was going towards website redevelopment, service training, mobile app, etc. And the question mark is, do we want to keep that increase into the budget for next year, or modify that, or...
1:34:17 Add or subtract? Yes. And let me preface this by we do have all of our team here, so if there are questions specifically, obviously we talked about the chamber information before, but if there are other questions about it, Ken can answer those, and we have others that can answer any of the other questions that we move on. I have a specific question on this, without trying to derail it. I'm curious why the community engagement manager position doesn't sit under chamber, and that's a place where I think that there's...
1:34:39 So we'll come back. I understand it. So I think there's a 37,000 dollars to support you. In general, I think that our chamber, I would like us to see more support for our chamber, more and more and more stuff. So it's like, I think the more we can do for our internal businesses here, the better we are. And that's a role that community engagement manager, to me, seems like it would also center chambers. When I support that, I would like us to actually find more there. Because I think the more we can do internally to lift our own businesses here,
1:35:09 One thing I don't see that I don't understand clearly with our chamber, and this is going back to your marketing plan, is that where is the resource where it says in the chamber, if you remember the chamber, you get support for marketing from Mammoth Lakes Tourism? It's not really clear on what that is. If I'm a member of chamber and I need help and support like web and things that are listed there, what does that actually mean? Like does Laura Kaler help me write a press release? When you're saying support from MLT. So if you go through your marketing plan?
1:35:37 one that you guys sent us, and it talks about the relationship between the chamber and the marketing plan and how there's support there. There's some things in there where it says in that chamber that you, where Mammoth Lakes Tourism provides support to members of the chamber. It's not really clear what that means. We actually provide support to the chamber staff. Mammoth Lakes Tourism does not necessarily do something specifically for a chamber member. Technically, I mean, granted, up until we got recalibrated a few last spring or last fall,
1:36:06 Every business in town was a member of Mammoth Lakes Tourism because they all paid business license tax. Now we have everybody a member of Mammoth Lakes Tourism because they're part of TBID. We don't have any preferential for the chamber people at this point other than potentially moving forward. We may say as a chamber member you get X dollars off of your ad in the visitor's guide or whatever it is. The support that I think that we provide is to Ken and Jessica as far as internal support for helping them with
1:36:35 different programs. Okay, and that's where that 37 would go specifically? The 37 would go specifically to the chamber to operate. They're a totally separate business. They're their own 501c3? 6? You've got both. They're their own 501c6. They just happen to be within our umbrella. So the 378 that we're looking for here is to support their functions, again, with building their website, which dire need to rebuild the app, the service training, and Ken can talk to any of those.
1:37:03 But there's not, the 378 is more our support of that organization versus us going in and doing anything for them. So let's say it's the website. When I go through and I read the way that it's written in the marketing plan, it sounds like MLT should already be providing that support for the marketing. So are we giving them dollars and then they're giving it back to us to help them with the marketing plan? I'm not clear on what that is. No, so they can go out and hire a web developer to build their website. We do not have internal capabilities to build their website. So what we're looking at is the funding that we're looking to grant them.
1:37:32 In addition to what we currently grant them is to accomplish those things that they need. They need a new website. We don't build websites. Okay. Do you understand why I'm looking at the marketing plan? No. Okay. No, so there's no, we support them internally as much as we can, but again, the 37,000 is really for them to go out and do what they need to do to get their business to the next level. And that's right now, that's the website.
1:38:02 the app, and then our service programs. So that's specifically where the 37.8 would go to? Ken, why don't you? I guess I jokingly wanted to ask, what does this buy in us? Well, that's exactly it. After Scott's comments, I thought the price went up. So, the 38.7 is the additional... 37.8. 37.8, excuse me.
1:38:33 Part of it is we're the $10,000 for the customer service. We're now going to fit in person is where we're primary on that. And we have $2,500 a quarter. The reality is one of the speakers we're looking at coming this fall is going to be $5,000. So the $10,000 helps us bring in a customer service training people. The website, as we said, after we developed the website and making sure we keep it up.
1:39:03 Is another 10,000. And then we're paying for 6,000. We're asking the MLT to help cover half of our technical assistant budget where we start going out and getting our business members to be able to come and get free technical assistance on marketing. We have a number of consultants. We're going to have to increase that. We don't have as many as we need, but we want that.
1:39:32 We have changed also, as you know, the power lunches. We've tried to increase those. We had $6,000 for additional expense for power lunch. We've changed how we're paying for those so that we can go to people like Michael and say, you don't have to do it at a loss. You can actually maybe make a couple bucks and stuff. So we charge 20, we're going to give them 20, but we're going to need additional dollars like this next.
1:39:59 April 24th, we're flying in the mayor of Aspen. He's coming in to talk about climate change. Some of those, some additional resources there. And the final 5,800, which is just what was left of that, is for event marketing. We've got the 4th of July parade. We've got the expo coming up. And probably the one that we'll spend the most of that on is the virtual job fair. We want to start doing one in the spring and one in the fall.
1:40:28 And so that adds up to the 37-8 that we've asked for additional dollars. Thank you. And we discussed that back in one of our board meetings, talking about the interim funding that we gave the chamber, and then we told you we'd come back with this. So I figured we should throw it on here as one of those added pieces. Did you find that, Scott? Because I haven't seen... I'm trying to find it. I think if we reference it in the marketing plan here, it's just because it's a symbiotic relationship internally. Okay. I just wanted to clarify that. Yeah. All right. So...
1:41:03 I'm looking forward. Yeah, we're not charging the chamber or anything, sorry. It's a service fee. All right, I'm looking for the board to say incorporate into the budget or not going forward. That's what I'm looking for in this. Specifically the 378. 378 at this moment. Do you need a motion? I would prefer a motion, yes. I'll make a motion to increase the support to Mammoth Lakes Chamber 378 as written. Second. Okay, any discussion on that? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed?
1:41:32 Okay, motion carries. All right. Our conversation last time was special events. And I said to go right back, and here's the portion that I want to make sure of. We've had this conversation ongoing for a period of time. I'm looking to say, do we move forward as is, hold, or modify? Now, I look at it as several different portions. One is we can say we're committed to where it is. It's going to be $375,000 as the steering committee had recommended. Yes? $225,000. $225,000. But there was $125,000 that we were talking about as a potential. From the town.
1:42:04 Well, that we'd have to carry after, yeah, that's right, this year. Potentially carry after this year, you're right. Yeah, I'm sorry. So you come back and saying, okay, do we move forward with this position? Do we hold the position pending, you know, now we have a conversation on TBID, we're moving forward in that direction, is now time to move forward, or do we wait until full strategy on the 5th, Amanda's 1st, make any more recommendations on moving forward?
1:42:29 Or do we pare this back down and say, given that we've got a little bit less dollars, et cetera, we aren't having as much savings, do we modify the position and move forward? We're talking about special events in the position. So we initially, just where it stands, we initially approved the two people plus dollars associated with that was approved, and we said pending TBID, it's on hold. Now we're talking about TBID renewal. The question I want to be able to give back to staff is saying, move forward, modify.
1:42:56 Kill, whatever. I just want to be clarity in terms of what are we going to do with this thing so it's not just sitting out there. So to set this up, obviously we've talked about this before. You have the budgets in front of you that we proposed for the full 2018-19 season, the fiscal year, and the total is $225,760. That's two positions, that's benefits, that's...
1:43:19 An operating budget of $24,000, and then we also had $50,000 in additional investment based on the idea that the town would provide $125,000. Now, the way that the town has positioned it is three years ago, two years ago, they assigned $125,000 out of the general fund for three years. 2018-19 is the third of those years. So we are looking at right now, if we put this thing together, if we hire...
1:43:48 A position or multiple positions, we would have the $125,000 grant money for next year, but we would not have that money moving forward. So either we need to go back to council or back to the town and say we need to extend that $125,000 for another three years, or we need to say that this is no longer $225,000, it's $350,000 if we end up absorbing $125,000 after next year. We could also take the $50,000 out and say that it's $125,000, we're not going to pad it.
1:44:15 Moving forward. Just to be clear, the 18-19 year is the third year? Yes. Yes, thank you. So there's one year left that we would, at that point, inherit for the distribution. So the distribution for this year, Stu, myself, Ken, Rob Patterson, and Dan Hollerick, we did the allocations for this year that we're in for summer. The next year's allocations would come into our...
1:44:41 our mix, but then after next year, so fiscal 1920, there wouldn't be that 125. Right now, the way it stands, there wouldn't be that 125. I think we have to say that if we're willing to take on the 175 to 225, we need to go back and say, hey, council would like to see those dollars continue so it's a partnership versus us going from 175 to 300,000 because we have to absorb the 125 out of our budget.
1:45:07 So, John, are you looking for a resolution of the board? I'm looking for direction from the board to say... So, the things that we're talking about here, we need to know because I need my team to go back in the next month to build the budget based on what we're talking about here. So, if we're going to absorb these, one of the other pieces is we do still have some funding in reserves, but again, I think that there's a certain amount that we have to be careful with because right now we have Measure A reserves that are, once they're gone, they're gone. We've got the joint bucket with the town and then we've got...
1:45:35 TBID reserves, which are somewhat restricted but can be used as backfill. So, John, does this funding help you reach the goals that we've talked about? I think it would. I think that if we add the events positions, I think if we can enhance those and we can start to look at, you know, one of the things I'm a huge supporter of is if we can get events going pre-4th of July, post-Labor Day, and midweek winter, or winter in general, I think that that can help us get to those numbers, yeah.
1:46:04 I'm of the opinion that the events role is probably one of the most important places that we invest in this next year. And there's, I would, I would rather see us cut in other areas to make this work and have this position in place than to not have it and not fund it, even if it means the full 350. Well, and the question is, would you, and it wouldn't be 350 next year. It would be 350. It would be 225 for.
1:46:27 225 is what we're talking about this year, and that's with us adding another $50,000 in. We can always say that in year one we're not going to add that $50,000 in because we've already seen we've got some reductions to our income right now. You have a ton of options here, and I didn't write them all out. You can say we can hire one person. You can say we can table the $50,000. You can say that we can cut the operating budget down. You can say a lot of different pieces there.
1:46:51 You can say we can take it out of reserve, so there's not necessarily let's cut other things, let's look at what, ultimately in the grand scheme of things, you have to look at what we're going to be asked to add, and then are we willing to take $500,000 out of TBID reserve to fund those things so that we're whole and we're not cutting, cutting. And I'll add one more to that, or, and we could add, and going back and saying we have a shared bucket with the town, and we request that $125,000 comes out of that going forward, so after 1819,
1:47:17 125 would be shared with the town, but we need to make sure town council and us do a joint decision on that one, but that's one possibility to fund that additional money down the road. For me personally playing Eeyore, worst case scenario, everything is on the table of MLT. We pay the 50, we pay all of it, it's awful, and I still think that this is one of the most worthwhile things for MLT to support, that actually having an organization that supports events in this town, recruits and draws new events, helps the events that are here get through the permitting process, all the things we've talked about with the job description.
1:47:47 I think this is one of the most valuable things that's going to help us increase attendance here in town, especially in the shoulder seasons. So I fully support doing whatever we can to get this moving forward because we've been talking about it for four months, six months and gone nowhere. I'd rather this board and the team take on all the risk and get it moving forward. And the upside is we get support from town to know things move forward, but at least it's moving forward. And we need to clarify, we've been hiatus because we didn't know what was happening with the budget. It wasn't because we weren't.
1:48:16 My team wasn't moving forward with it. It's still been looking to move forward. Can I ask, Scott, because I appreciate that point of view. And when you look at it from a metric standpoint, you think that what it will do will drive visitation? Is that the metric that you think that investing here that we'll see the ROI back in?
1:48:43 I think we have one single event that happens in this town that anybody outside of Mono County actually cares about. And it'd be nice for us to actually have a few more. I like it like I'm going to Telluride tonight. And Telluride's got a half dozen to a dozen events that draw in tens of thousands of people because they invest in that infrastructure. And in Mammoth, we have Looza Palooza. And if you're not coming, and no discredit to anyone else that has events here in town, but 99% of the other events in this town.
1:49:09 Don't reach outside of our neural network. And I think that having more... They enhance the stay while you're here, but they don't necessarily draw you. I don't know how many people actually get in a car, get on a plane to come to an event. People are getting on a plane from Germany to go to Telluride to go see blues music, right, or to go see bluegrass. It's like, we need to have that here if we want to be able to have people come here. And the events is something that's, you know, I think that, you know, Oktoberfest is great, and we get some people to come up for it, but, you know, if we had support for that kind of thing, like, people...
1:49:37 We'll be coming from all over. We just haven't gotten there yet. I think the more we could actually push that in this community, and it offers some resiliency for us. Those are things that people could really engage in in September, October, no shoulder periods. I agree. I was just curious from your perspective. Yeah, Scott, I agree with you 100%. What I'd like to see, John, I guess, is, again, worst case scenario, because we do have some options. We've got some reserves. With the joint bucket, I'd have to...
1:50:03 get a little more clarity on an average year, a good year, how much TOT goes into that, and then we'd have to have, you know, discussion with council about commitment to that. But I agree with you, Scott. I think if we look at worst case scenario, MLT long term or short term, three years, five years, absorbs three, 325, 350? 350. What does that do to the other aspects of our marketing program campaign in general? What do we sacrifice? And do we
1:50:32 As a group agree that cutting, if we have to cut whatever it is we have to cut since there's not an unlimited bucket here, what does that look like? But I agree with you, Scott, and I've been a proponent pushing this for years and years too that we, you know, we need to have more events. We need to support more events. We need to have more things going on in town to keep the interest of our guests and to attract them in addition. So I agree with that. You know, I agree with Scott on the impact of these big events.
1:51:03 They're brand building for men. They get our name out there in a way that a small event doesn't. However, I think that if we vote the money in advance and then go hat in hand to the town council, that's a terrible negotiating position. I'd much rather see us go to the town council first and see if we can't get the town to chip in their share. And if they won't, then it's always something we can take up. But I don't feel that...
1:51:32 The time involved to go to the town is so critical that we would lose that much by going to the town first before we vote on this thing. Well, and I think when we built this program, we were under the impression that we had that funding going forward. And then when we came down to the 11th hour, it was, oh, there's only one year left on that funding. So I would agree that it should be a caveat to say we're willing to take on our 225 if we've got this commitment for, and we're not looking, we don't have to be five years out, it can be another three years and then we can figure out how to fund that piece.
1:52:01 It could be another two years and we can figure out how to fund that piece. But I just feel like we're stepping up at $225,000 or whatever we end up with, including $50,000 additional for the events. And again, I think the additional is we've talked about that additional being for those commitment events or pre and post busy time and having that be an attraction to say, okay, sure, if you want to bring your event in September, October or May or early June, great, we've got an extra pot of $50,000.
1:52:29 So I think that the question marks that I have for you, because I know we're going to keep moving, is, is this one or two positions? If we, for now, do we leave the 50 in there? If we leave it in, we're going to be responsible for it moving forward. We can't put it in for next year and then take it out the year after and go 175 back to 125. Do we take that out and stay at 125 next year, figure out negotiation with the town on the future of 125 and add it back in? Because again, we've got a lot of things that are adding up here and we can either add
1:52:58 $150,000 this year, or we can add $225,000 this year. Make a suggestion. I'd support us going forward in hiring this one position and having a caveat that the hiring of the second position and the funding of the $50,000 is contingent on an extension from town. Yeah. Did you just make a motion? I just, I'll make it as a motion, so my motion is from budget is that we approve one position and that the
1:53:27 Hiring of the second position and the $50,000 additional would be contingent on an extension beyond the 18-19 season from town. Okay. Is there a second on that motion? Second. Okay. All right. Let's have a discussion on that. Sean, would you like to weigh in here? Yeah. I do, actually. I think this is the most important ROI we can get on this board. And I, it's funny, I had a similar discussion in my private business along something similar here, is that our job is to increase
1:53:56 Increase tourism to this town, thereby increasing revenue. And I think we should own this not only from a budgetary perspective, but even from a strategic perspective. And if town council, that's why I don't want to necessarily be holding this back based on what town council is going to do. Town council is all crazy. Would you like to go further on this? That is on the record.
1:54:24 I understand. I think I know where you're going with that, and that's why, if more than anything, I want to make sure that we are really pushing this project forward. I mean, Stu Brown reminded me, or just the fact that we've gone through the youth sports funding just recently, and how many of those groups bring tournaments to town that fill up hotel rooms and restaurants. There's just one more component of it that I wasn't even thinking about. I've just recently been reminded of just how much.
1:54:51 This position can really help that. So I'm going a long way here in saying that I'm ready to jump feet first fully into two positions. If we only do one position, I think that keeps some work on Stu and the recreation side for just kind of moving, you know, as far as the application process goes. And Stu, I got to give you and your staff great credit because frankly, I think you do a great job. We're talking about moving that over here so that it's all within one department.
1:55:21 But I hope I expressed enough support there for let's just get this thing done. You know, hearing that, I think, I don't know if it needs to be a motion, but the direction that you were originally seeking was should we include this in the budget? And I think you should include everything in the budget at this point in time. It doesn't...
1:55:43 There's a motion on the table to approve one thing in particular for a spend, but the direction for the budget, I think you should include everything. Meaning both positions? So I'm saying, and that was my intent, was that we have, the budget is fully there for the full amount, and move forward with hiring that first person.
1:56:04 But don't spend the $50,000 or the second position. Put it in your budget, but don't spend it until we know or have at least some confirmation. If town comes back and says, no, we're not doing it, it's still in your budget and it can still be spent. Okay. Can or cannot. So it's kind of two parts, which is move forward with the hiring of leadership of that role and put the full thing in your budget, but don't spend the $50,000 and hire the second position until you know status.
1:56:33 From town. And it could still come from our board. Plus you want the leadership of the world to hire the next person. But we don't need to wait. My point is we should not wait for town and council to hire that one position and that there's the caveat that it's also not necessary for that funding to come from town, but at least hold off until we find out what's going on with town. Does that make sense? It does. I think that that additional, I mean, you're talking about an additional $100,000 if we...
1:56:57 If we budget both positions and budget the 50, we're talking about another $100,000, that wouldn't be in the general marketing budget. Yep. Or come back and say you're going to take from reserves to do that. Yep. There's many avenues. And you know what? I just want to say this. It's what Paul said about coming from a position of strength for negotiating. Yes. I think Colin answered it pretty well with his quick problem. All right.
1:57:23 We should just do exactly what Scott and Eric just suggested. So bouncing from you to you to you, I think we're on a good track. All right, so with that, I'm going to come back to, we've got a motion in a second, any more conversation on this motion? Yes, if I may. And, Sean, I appreciate your enthusiasm, and I appreciate Colin's comment. I still think that if we've got to negotiate with the town,
1:57:48 And if we just vote the money in advance, we've just undercut ourselves tremendously. I think Scott's motion was a good way of threading the needle. But there is one technical thing that I really don't understand, and maybe you can help me with it. The first position is the guy who's supposed to go out and get the big event. The second position is the person who's supposed to help implement the big event. And work with the little events. Right, okay.
1:58:17 It seems to me there's going to be a lag there. In other words, the first guy, when he gets hired, isn't going to have the big event the next day. There's going to be some lag period of weeks, days, months, what have you, when the second person isn't needed right away because we don't have the big event to work on. So it seems to me that a delay in hiring the second person wouldn't be harmful anyway, unless I misunderstand what you've written here, John. I want to be careful about what I say because of the position I'm in.
1:58:47 You've already said it. Now you're going to do that? I think it coded too. I say that all the time anyway. I think another way to potentially think about that is somebody needs to fund that position. So if the town is putting money into the pool, if you will, then maybe MLT takes on the hiring of that position. If the town is withholding that money, then maybe some of that role resides back within the town.
1:59:18 Usually there are savings in dollars or there's a savings in staff output is one way to think about it potentially. So you're cutting the deal, Colin. I mean, I have an opinion on this and I will save it for council discussion among, you know, the five council people, but, you know, I've been pretty involved in the events process and I don't have a problem with the motion that's on the table.
1:59:48 I mean, I think you're talking about the lag time. I think if you hired this person in 30 days, if you magically found the right person, hired this person in 30 days, they're not going to be able to get a big event or anything here until, at best, spring of next year. Spring of 19. I mean, it is the work that needs to be done to put together an event like that. And that's why it's like, for me, there's an impetus of, I think we need to have this person on the ground as soon as possible.
2:00:15 Because we can't really afford to lose shoulder seasons of 19 to this if we're talking about a five-year goal of building up our shoulder seasons. The sooner we have this moving, the better off we are. Having said that, though, the first person. We're talking about the first person. First person. Any person. Any person. We haven't been talking about this for four months. We've been talking about this for four years. Yeah, at least four years. You know that I've been on council.
2:00:40 You know, but, and having said that, I think you're right on, is that it's going to take a little bit of time if we're, you know, point number two is developing and attracting one to three major new events in Mammoth Lakes within the next three years. Yeah, earliest is going to be spring of 19. Point number one here, though, is assisting the development, maintenance, and growth of existing special events in Mammoth Lakes. You know, I'm just thinking, here we are four weeks away from Blueza, or four months this weekend from Blueza Palooza, and I'm going through my checklist that happens at four months out, three months out,
2:01:10 And I'm just looking around at other special events that are going on. And just the amount of coordination that an individual can bring to assisting, whether it's Margarita Fest, Oktoberfest, Bluza Bluza, all these others, whether it's sponsorships, shared expenses, you know, there's so much that this individual can do to herd us cats into really a driving force that...
2:01:35 I think they've got their work cut out for them right away. All right, so I'm going to call the question, unless there's more, because we've already initially approved direction on this before. We have motion and second on the floor. Everybody clear about the motion? Read the motion again, please. Do you have it, Emily? Do you want me to repeat it? Yes. So the motion is to fully put into the budget the entire events program, $50,000, person A, person B, in the budget. And approval to move forward with...
2:02:04 recruiting person A, the lead position, and then pending the funding of the $50,000 not contingent on whether we get something from town. If it doesn't, nothing comes from town, the board can still approve those dollars, but the budget is there. So that means that if the town doesn't come back with anything, John's team has to carve that out of the budget. If it comes back and that $125,000 comes back in, then there can be a reallocation that goes back where they see fit. Is that me? Okay. And you?
2:02:33 And we got a second on that one? Somebody seconded it.
2:02:35 No, it was it.
2:02:37 Second.
2:02:37 Clear on a second. Yep.
2:02:38 Okay. So we'll call the question.
2:02:41 All right. All those in favor say aye.
2:02:42 Aye.
2:02:42 Aye.
2:02:43 Am I opposed?
2:02:44 I'll abstain.
2:02:45 Okay. All right.
2:02:47 Okay.
2:02:48 Okay. Community Engagement Manager and...
2:02:51 Laura's going to talk to that one.
2:02:59 Good afternoon.
2:03:01 So...
2:03:02 This is my approach to the local marketing program that we've been talking about for
2:03:12 a couple years.
2:03:13 It's two pieces.
2:03:14 In your packet, there was a proposal from Heart and Mind Strategies, and then there's this Community Engagement Manager. So the idea is we would work with Heart and Mind to work with the community, survey the community, talk to them about how they think MLT is doing, benefits they're getting from MLT, how we can improve, what they like. So Heart and Mind has it laid out.
2:03:43 In three different types of surveys, we can pick and choose from those surveys, we can do all three, and so that would be the first piece. And what we get from them would be a strategy that would then help this community engagement manager implement what the community is looking for, the local marketing program, again, that we've been talking about for a couple years and just hasn't had it.
2:04:13 The guns behind it again. So, we'd like to just move it forward with these two pieces. Any questions? Go ahead. Sorry. Go ahead. No, I'm just saying if you can stay up there in case we have questions. I might have missed it, but could we have a little better articulation of what that community engagement role would do? Yeah, so there, I think there was a job description. But a lot of what it would do, it would work a lot with
2:04:49 on local marketing and PR. So he's a liaison with local media, which can speak to, you know, fish stocking in town. It would also work with Michael when he's on the road and he has fans in town, you know, be someone that could help him out hosting those fans, showing that in the local community. And then again, a part of what they would be doing.
2:05:19 Would come out of my recommending. Really just a lot of our local efforts, like even just the coordination of the Olympians, the coordination of different programs in town and any local advertising that we do do. So I think the reason that it's not a chamber position is it's truly the liaison between Mammoth Lakes Tourism, what we do.
2:05:43 externally, communicating it locally, and then also making sure that we have those touch points local. A few years ago, we talked about all the different pieces that we should be doing locally from a marketing standpoint, and we don't have the people to execute it at this point. And to Paul's point earlier, the error messaging that the local community, you know, we're not necessarily communicating that well, this position could, you know, help with that. So, I just like that.
2:06:08 I struggle with the idea that we're going to spend, there's a request to spend $115,000 for a consultant to tell us what we're not listening to from our community and then hiring a $60,000 a year position to tell the community what we're already doing. That seems to me to be pretty narrow-minded. Honestly, I think that the proposal itself lacks understanding of where the community's at already. That's a lot of money to spend if people are asking questions about what we're doing.
2:06:37 It just seems odd to me. When I say this, I want to try and not be overly blunt. The idea of spending $120,000 to hire a consultant to hear from people in town that MLT spends money and people don't understand why we're spending money seems to be a tone-deaf proposal in and of itself.
2:07:03 I think there's enough clarity of what's being said in town already that that misses the mark. But is there? Yeah. Do we really know? Because, I mean, we hear the handfuls of, well, everybody thinks this, and we need to get the baseline. The whole idea of the heart and mind is to get the baseline and figure out where we truly are at because I think that it could be argued that- There's a lot we could do. I think there's a lot of listening that could be done by this organization and by members of this organization well before we go adopt $120,000 to get a survey from people. From a third party versus the organization.
2:07:32 You know, I have to say, I had the same exact concerns that Scott has. We're proposing to spend $115,000 to ask the community what it thinks about what we're doing. I think the optics of that would be a disaster.
2:07:52 We would get so lambasted in the press and everywhere else, and the people in town would go nuts thinking we spent $115,000 of their money to ask them how they feel about us. If I can say something, though, actually in support of this position, because you're right, and you both bring up very good points about, and now I understand where the heart and mind, I saw the heart and mind proposal.
2:08:20 document here at the end of this, and I kind of wondered where it fit in. So you're right. I think that the optics, I think that we've got enough feedback that we can hear what the community is trying to tell us. At the same time, though, I will say that I don't think that we as a tourism department do a good enough job engaging the community, my business included, of making sure that we are speaking in a unified voice. I think that if we are able to bring
2:08:49 Together, many of the independent businesses, so that we are speaking with a more unified marketing, we could do more, we could be more effective than Marian Carson is. And so I actually like the overall idea of the community engagement. I disagree with necessarily, or I have trouble with the heart and mind proposal that's on the table. To play devil's advocate, this did come from board direction. Absolutely.
2:09:20 I'm sorry, Colin? This did come from board direction. Okay. So, just to put that out there. I'm not so negative about the community engagement management. I think there, you know, there's a role to play there and it could be useful. But I'm wondering with respect to the hearts and mind survey, I don't really agree with Sean. I think there's lots of stuff we need to know. But I'm wondering if we couldn't ask those questions with an in-house person.
2:09:51 I think there's arguments. Is it too close to it? It is absolutely too close to it. You think that somebody coming from the outside is going to get answers that somebody in-house wouldn't? Absolutely. Really? Unbiased conversation. Unbiased conversation, third party. The board did ask for, so what the board asked for and what we have here I think are fair, are not quite the same thing. What the board asked for was the ability to engage the community and understand what's happening there.
2:10:23 So somewhere between someone putting together a survey monkey and an entirely new role in a $115,000 contract I think is the reality of what the board asked for. So there's a big difference between those two. I do think that we talked about having a third-party person engage the community. I think the scope of what's being done here and to create an entirely new position around that to me seems a little over-reactionary. I have some sticker shock based on the specific proposal, but I actually have more issue with
2:10:53 the position than I do with the proposed third party survey. Alright, so Michael, do you have anything in? I think everybody that works within the MLT organization is a community member and it's incumbent on us to engage with the community. I'm not sure that we need a...
2:11:15 I'm just struggling with where that role fits in the organization. Let me speak quickly to the role. Let me speak quickly to the role. I think one of the things that we've talked about is that our GNA is 14% of the total budget. It's at least 12% below the average. We've always talked about the fact that we have our staff. Our staff is succinct. We have seven people on MLT staff. We manage a fairly sizable budget within that.
2:11:41 And I think when we switched gears a couple of years ago and we lost Christy Osborne, Whitney took on two roles, I think we've got a lot of need for that local focus that we haven't felt that we've been able to commit. And that's where that position comes in. And I think the heart and mind piece is to set the baseline of where are we? Because, you know, I hear on a regular basis, oh, you know, businesses hate us. Well, we did $18.1 million last year. Does every business hate us?
2:12:09 I talk to a lot of people that are pretty psyched about what we're doing. I think when we talk about the sample size of who hates us, what is it? Who thinks we're doing a fantastic job? Does 75% think we're doing a fantastic job? Is it 80%? I think that's where the heart and mind piece comes in. The proposal is a proposal. We can scale that back. We can narrow it down. We can talk about it. But it is important to have a third party come in and do this for us. It's just like anything else. If you do, in the world of research, if you do an intercept survey,
2:12:37 Versus meaning that if I talk to you directly or if I hand you a survey, you're going to lie like hell on the survey that I hand you. Or actually, I'm sorry, you're going to lie like hell to me, but you're not going to lie on the handwritten one. No, I'm not, Doug. Because people will tell you the story they think you want to hear versus what you're going to get from a third party. And I think that's where we...
2:13:03 Again, from board direction, we've said, okay, we need to focus on this local community, and how do we better engage it? And a lot of what the community manager piece is, is managing all of those local pieces that we just either don't have the time or don't have the staff to deal with. And I think that's why it's critically important. Instead of looking at it as, you know, we're spending a hundred, it's an investment in the community to really get a clear picture of what they want. So that's just another way to look at it.
2:13:35 I'd like to just make sure I weighed in for the board that wants to weigh in. Yeah, my issue with the whole thing is, again, I think what John said is, I question the volume of naysayers, and I question spending that much money to, I'm just going to say it, to appease, I think, a relatively small number of people. There are going to be a small number of people who are going to
2:14:04 Be unhappy with anything that you do. And at what point do you draw that line? And at what point do we say to our community members, we're going to spend...
2:14:12 A couple hundred thousand dollars to listen to a very, very small segment. Unless I'm completely missing the boat and what you guys are hearing is totally different from what I'm hearing because I'm not hearing all that negativity out there. I'm hearing small amounts of negativity from a small sector which I have heard for 30 years. And I think that our growth and what we've done in this community has been excellent and I think the numbers speak for itself. Can we do better? Absolutely. But the volume of what's being proposed here seems...
2:14:42 I agree with Scott as far as, and whoever else said it, that it seems like it's out of whack as far as the total amounts, and necessarily needing that robust a position for what's being proposed to achieve. I'm just very cautious with adding additional bodies, and we just approved one or two positions in a special events role, which I'm highly supportive of.
2:15:11 I'm just not sure I'm there to take that leap to add that many additional bodies. I feel like I need some more understanding of how that fits within the organizational role. We're talking about two different issues, and I know they're related because the heart and mind establishes a baseline, right, for this new role to come in and be effective. Is that correct? Did I hear that correctly?
2:15:38 Piece of it, right? Like, the heart and mind is trying to engage the community and see kind of what's the PR problem, if you will, and then that will inform a piece of that position. I don't know that I'm supportive of that piece of that position. If there's more to the role that I'm not understanding, that's one thing, but I don't know. I understood that the board wanted to see more input from others that might have strategies or...
2:16:07 You know, opportunities to go after. And I don't think the heart and mind survey allows, will be successful in that. I think it will instead just say, do you like MLT or not? And if we're comfortable with the goals that we're out there and have established and what we're trying to reach, then I don't see the need for the heart and mind.
2:16:31 I did want to separate that. That's why I started asking if it's two different issues from the role of the community manager versus the heart and mind thing. But I have a hard time supporting the heart and mind strategy. Yeah, we would have. So when you start to hold this official board to hold Sarah there. Okay, sorry. Yeah, it's a little pricey, but, you know, you've got to start somewhere again, too. So, I mean, I don't.
2:16:56 dispute that a third party opinion is not necessary or important. I think it is. But, you know, I mean, are we hiring this position to be a, who's the gal asked, Huckabee Sanders, is it Sarah Huckabee Sanders, so if somebody can take the heat for what's going on here on a PR basis, or just to add to the team. I'm sensitive to what you said, John, and I think that, yeah, you know.
2:17:24 This is a pretty robust budget, and maybe you need another hand on here, especially to replace another body. I get that. That kind of happens in everybody's organization, ours included. Yes, Whitney? Yeah, I was just going to add, it's exactly what Kurt was saying, is that the community engagement piece is a separate. You know, we haven't adjusted for this increase in budget.
2:17:46 And so we're looking to shift some of these responsibilities to a no role because we haven't added any positions. And I've taken on another million and a half in responsibilities. It's a lot. And so, you know, to strengthen these local pieces that we've all voiced is a priority for us. We would need to bring another person on to do justice. And that goes for Laura's pieces as well. I mean, we're just growing quick. Okay. So where do we want to go here?
2:18:15 You know, as far as the position is concerned, I mean, I'm a believer in somebody wearing lots of different hats, so as long as you're getting good value for money, then, you know, I personally don't have a qualm with that. So you make a motion to...
2:18:28 Move forward with the position? No, I'm just offering an opinion. Again, we're trying to inform the budget, right? We're not necessarily approving. We're not, this is not, to incorporate in the budget and plan. I get confused when we go to motions like that though. I'd like to make a comment and I'm not sure it's time for a motion just yet as much as what Scott made the suggestion in the last part was putting the position in the budget, whether or not we do the heart and mind. You know, my comments are that I think that there is
2:18:57 I don't think it's a very, very small portion of the local community that has problems with what tourism is doing. I think it is significant enough out there that it does need to be addressed. I think that it is something that we can hear as long as we're opening our ears to what the community is saying. I do feel that engagement is not happening currently enough with the local community.
2:19:23 These are just my perspective all the way around with regard to what the answers are. I'm going to ask some more questions when we get into the next subject about where we're strategically placing our priorities and our dollars. And some of that may fall into what this position may hold. So having said that, I don't want to table this. So I'm looking forward to be...
2:19:49 The goal of this meeting is to have you guys tell us what we are and aren't budgeting, and I don't want to get into a situation where we're tentatively budgeting things, because if we're tentatively budgeting things, we don't know our final dollar amount, then it's a terrible way to budget. So I'm looking for this board to give direction to staff saying where do we want to go. And I'm going to wind us down here in about six minutes, so I've got to move us on a couple of things I've got to hit before we finish. Do you want to split it? Do you want to go ahead? Or do you want to say no? That's kind of what I'm hearing.
2:20:21 So let me ask a clarifying question. Let's say we split it and we say we want to put the new role into the budget. Does that mean we're approving the new role now or are we saying you could put it in the budget but don't bother putting the study into the budget? My feeling that is that we'd be saying to John, put that budget amount for the new position in the budget.
2:20:48 and that the study would not be incorporated in their version of the budget. We could always change that in a month from now if we decide that it's mandatory, but we're trying to give clear direction to the staff to incorporate a budget so that we know exactly what to put into there. You were more clear than I was. I'm supportive of the position, not necessarily of the study. Do you want to make the move to put that in the budget? Sure. Okay, is there a second on that? I second that. Okay, any more discussion on that? Okay, I call the question. All those in favor?
2:21:17 All those opposed? Aye. Thanks for your support. I'm not incorporating. Okay, I'm going to move on. I'm not saying it doesn't have merit for me, but I'm not prepared today. The world can change, and we have the ability as a board, but we've got to kind of, one of our goals that everybody asks is give clarity and clarity to the budget, because we keep going down the road, and we change our minds consistently. I guess we would like clarity to be clear. Yeah, we just want to be...
2:21:44 What is? So right now, right now, it's not incorporated into the budget. Okay, I'm moving on to the next, which is... One moment before you move on. I don't think the board is saying, don't ever bring this up again. No. I think that we should consider this in the future, John. You know, in some, you know, perhaps whether it's a change or a further discussion, this is a brief discussion. It could be an important position.
2:22:08 I don't want you to put it aside and say, boy, I'm never going to go back to that again. I think we should look at it again. Well, we'll continue to push it because we feel that it's an important position from our standpoint. So let's talk about it sometime in the future. Can I ask a favor of staff? Could you guys write a job description for your board members because I read this community engagement manager role?
2:22:27 And a lot of what's in here is actually what I think is the job description of those of us on the board. We're talking about hiring someone to go to a lodging meeting or go to a community events meeting. I think that's what our role is supposed to be. And the lack of a job description for board that we're held accountable to means that the staff is looking for someone to try and do the work that they expect us to do. To a large degree. That's what I think. I can say, John, but I just think that to me, this is just an overview of saying, okay, we asked.
2:22:55 Let's back up. We asked the staff to come up with saying we want more engagement. Let's discuss what Scott was saying. We did. We did, absolutely. But it goes back to us being clear about what we're asking for to make sure when we come, outcome, we're all kind of like shaking our heads going, oh, that's expensive. We asked for it. I'm just trying to make sure we're very clear about what we're asking for so we don't keep changing down the road because I guarantee you we're going to sit in a second and say, well, we're going to change this and this based on this now. And I'm trying to move us along. We're never going to be perfect in our decisions.
2:23:25 But we're trying to make the best information that we have and make a good decision. And I'm not saying to John and team that, you know, I think your points are very valid about, you know, your operations and staff costs relative to budget. I mean, I'm very sensitive to that kind of stuff. And if you guys feel like you're stretched too thin, you need another body to fill in and plug some holes, like, I'm receptive to that. I'm just not clear.
2:23:50 where this role fits and if it's just somebody to go out and be a megaphone to the community, I'm not sure I'm supportive of that. So I've got a table of conversation on that because I've got to a couple of things I need to get to. One is reserves. So the next one is we looked at what we have right now. Sorry, I've got to go. And we have reserves that we've set aside and we put a special events venue at $250,000, the airport at $500,000.
2:24:16 Conference Center at $250, and Wayfinding Signage at $350. Where is this? Is this on the agenda? Further on, it's item 636. And it was attachment into the agenda. Yes, it is. Okay. Sorry. Thank you. And the question mark is, we can leave it as is, is there a need to be looking at how we do those, or are we saying to John, you know, we're authorizing you to take $300,000 out of reserves to plan into your budget,
2:24:48 So let me clarify, too. What do you have for earmarks? You've earmarked Measure A. Sorry, yes. There are no earmarks on TBID. TBID has $2.5 million in there. I think my suggestion with the TBID side would be for our team to come back at the May 1st meeting to make suggestions of backfill from TBID. I think the idea here is to talk about the Measure A reserves and what's available there and what we want to do with it. I think just as another update, I met with Hayes Haislip last week about the wayfinding signage program.
2:25:17 That's potentially going to be something that goes on the ground next spring. I think our commitment there is good. I think anything else is fully negotiable. But once these reserves are gone, these are the reserves we control. These are not the joint bucket. Once these reserves are gone, they're gone. This pile won't be replenished at all. So you have a finite 1.25 million that you can assign and you can reassign 15 times before we actually pay anything out. But we set these earmarks up so that they at least had homes for now.
2:25:44 But if we have a surplus somewhere and we could replenish the reserve that way, right? No. Because the surplus now goes into the joint bucket with TOT, this is not the same bucket, this is the leftover reserve that we have in our control, not the two-key system. The $2.5 million is always going to be in our control because that's the TBID overage. So the question mark right now is, I'd like to put placeholders on them.
2:26:11 Do we need to move them around at all? Do you see any reason to put more into special events? Or it sounds like Wayfair signage, is $350 going to be enough with what? I think that's our commitment. I think the whole program is probably going to be in the $800,000, $900,000 range, but I'm not sure that we need to fund the whole thing. Nor do I think that the town... For the Wayfair need specifically. Yeah. And you're saying we do need placeholders on all of this? We already have them currently.
2:26:36 For A, not for TBID. For A, at this moment. With TBID, though, the recommendation is going to be coming back and saying, based on our inclusion area of different positions, it's probably going to be pulling some of that reserves back into the operational budget and to see what that does as an overall standpoint, is there any other reserves that we want to take from or modify at that point in time. Right now, I'm specifically looking at A saying, do we want to change special events venue, Mammoth Lakes Airport and the Conference Center allocations at this point in time.
2:27:05 Do you see any reason to shift any of those allocations at this moment? I'm fine with where they are. I just want to make sure we as a board understand that we're holding those monies in those categories and we aren't going to be able to replenish, but we can move these around any way we want to. These are being spent now. These are just the bucks. Just placeholders. I think at this point there's no point in making very much deviation. I don't see a need to really spend.
2:27:27 That on the terminal without a plan, but at this point in time, it's just buckets they sit in and it's not being spent. There's no need to change them for Measure A. And that's why I just want to make sure we agree on that as they leave it as it is. Are you looking for a motion? I don't need a motion to change anything, so I'm not looking to change anything. Okay. So with that, we'll leave where it is at this point in time. We can change any. This is not a hard one from our standpoint to change based on need. All right, shared bucket with the town. And we brought this up as part of the other conversation events position.
2:27:57 But we have the six-year deal with the Kings right now that's going to take $600,000 out of that shared bucket, which is basically already there. We've probably got about another, what, $50,000? We've got $643,000 in that bucket. $643,000. So we've got $43,000 additionally. So as part of this going forward, we should utilize those dollars. And the question was, do we go back and ask for that as part of the events? Is that where we're asking for events money to come from for that shared bucket? Or anything else that we wanted to kind of...
2:28:24 push from our standpoint going forward with budget because we do have to agree with the town on this bucket. It's a joint bucket that we both have to agree on the expenditures to move forward. I'd like to see town can make their commitment of 125 and stick to it and not have it come out of that reserve bucket and take that additional 43 and match the 50 that we're putting in to actually fund bringing events to town or other marketing opportunities to specifically go after that. So it'd be that 43 plus the 50 we have and have a have a
2:28:53 close to matching bucket that was in reserve for events is necessary for being able to bring people in and that the 125 is completely separate to their original agreement and they stand behind it. I'd recommend not committing the 43,000 at this point because it's going to continue to grow.
2:29:05 And I think what we need to do is we need to figure out where we come out with the town. I thought I'm sure we have to ask them to commit to it. No, no, no. It's just in the bucket. It's the only thing that's committed right now. There's 643,000 in there. We've earmarked the first 600,000 to go to the King's deal. There's no need to earmark anything moving forward. We don't need to earmark. If we wanted to, we could go out and say, hey, we want to propose to the town council that if we know that they're not going to pay the 125, then say, okay, for...
2:29:29 43 is going to grow, or take the money to support the events positions themselves. I would rather that 43 not be used for that, and town asked us to move forward to this, and they made the original 125 commitment, and just because council decided to backtrack doesn't mean that we should dip into that reserve bucket. That's my opinion. I don't want to give them that out. Yeah, I agree. Agreement? Okay, so no action on that one. We'll just seek to resolve the 125 directly.
2:29:57 We've got a couple positions that are coming open. So there's three positions that are coming open. We have two lodging and Scott's position that are coming up in June. Information went out today to all the folks in the Lodging Association. There are two positions. Mine is up. Mine's a three-year. Kirk's up. His is a two-year. Both of us are interested in serving. So we've asked anybody in the Lodging Association that meets the criteria to submit a letter of interest to...
2:30:25 to MLT no later than May 15th. Once we receive those, there'll be a vote between May 15th and May 28th. The lodging folks can vote one vote per entity. Then MLT will tabulate those votes and we will have the results of those at our next lodging association meeting, which is May 29th. And then we'll bring the results of that back to the board at the June meeting. So those are the two lodging.
2:30:52 And for the open position for Scott's, our goal has always been to promote the position, form an ad hoc committee, which we'll do at the next meeting, and interview anybody, and proceed from there for recommendations back to the board for that position. So that will officially nominate the commission of the ad hoc position, we'll nominate the next one, but we'll basically give direction to staff to go ahead and promote the position as open, and anybody that wants to be there for qualifications to apply for that position. One thing that I have as an overall, also part of
2:31:22 Our strategy is I just want to look at two different things here. I'll give these a pass out. So I've got, I asked John to do our play handbook as well as I was looking through it and saying we don't really have a code of conduct for ourselves as well from another standpoint. And I'm not looking for action today, but I am going to be looking for action at the next meeting. I think it's just part of our strategy we should overlook and say in our handbook we outline certain policies, for instance vacation pay. Are we in line with where we need to be with vacation pay for
2:31:51 ourselves and organization. Is there other things that we need to look at modifying as part of our process and strategy to modify, to attract the best employees that we have, to modify certain policies that we have within the organization? I want to be careful. I want to set the guidelines to what we're doing and have John implement them, but at the same time, I notice in looking through, we don't really have a code of conduct for ourselves.
2:32:14 And I think it's important that we operate with a code of contact and understand what's the obligations of a board member. I have a very shortened version here. I'm willing to go for a longer one, but I think it's a conversation we need to have amongst ourselves and be able to say what is the expectations of a board member and what we do. It's very common. All the other boards I sit on, we basically have a very similar type document. I've seen 100 of these, but I'm open. I just want to...
2:32:36 Put that out there for a conversation so that next board meeting as we think about where we want to be, is there any policies that we want to change? And I am going to be looking for the board to sign off on a code of conduct for everybody from ourselves going forward and how we behave and how we do our things and what's our responsibility as a board member. But going back to the handbook, I also want to make sure that if there's need to be...
2:32:57 Adjustments, and I'm not suggesting any as part of this. I just think that we're looking at strategy. We need to look at what we're doing. Are we providing the best atmosphere and best location for people coming to work for MLT? You know, the world changes. You know, let's face it. John, you and I have faced our housekeepers. We fight for 25 cents. You know, it may be time that we have to say, you know what, we need to add a vacation day or we need to give John authorization to give a couple vacation days to somebody that he feels has done a good job.
2:33:23 But that has a cost to it, and I want to make sure as we look at a global strategy, we're saying, okay, we want to give you the tools to be successful in running the organization. So I'm not looking for action on that. I just want everybody to review that, and we'll be bringing that up for conversation and any modifications on the May 2nd meeting. With that, we have the May 2nd meeting. With that, we have the May 2nd meeting. Sorry? Can you send them digitally? I send them digitally as well. I'll send them to Geo John, and we can put on minutes with that for everything.
2:33:48 Can I ask a question briefly? Yes, sir. Great. You know, my private business just went through this exercise, revisiting the employee manual after three plus years. Is this the existing employee manual then? It's the existing employee manual. Okay. May 1st. I'm going to be very short on this one. If there's any questions, go ahead and ask them. But basically, we're going to have all of our partners in on May 1st. I've heard back from two people that can't make it. Is that correct still?
2:34:19 Because I cannot make it. Because it will be an official board meeting. Otherwise, we have enough to make sure John notices it because we'll have a quorum of the board there. I think it's important. It's going to be a long day. So understand what the commitment is. You're talking six to eight hours of time frames with the individual partners. I was just looking for Stu Brown because that's our recreation commission day. This is priority. So I'll just need to explain that to them. Because I just want to make sure we maintain a quorum throughout the day so we don't lose a quorum.
2:34:48 Not that there will be no planned action per se, but it's going to be a lot of conversation, and this is going to be a lot of information. Eight to four? Roughly. Location TBD still? I think we're Weston at this point, because Sweet Z wasn't available for the full stretch, so obviously. Weston is comfortable. And as I mentioned, I'm sorry, as I mentioned, Whitney's going to be sending out every Monday, there'll be a doc that goes out that'll inform, and we'll post those as well. Okay.
2:35:18 I did have a question, if I may, real quick. The four partners here, great. Glad to have all four of them will be there. Great. And I saw the breakdown, the percentages, the overlapping pie charts for what is spent on paid media. I can't remember what they're in here. Can you tell me, tell us briefly or if email, what percentage of our budget goes to Mary and Carson, Miles Partnership, Lyman, Embark? So I'm going to put that as part of our regular.
2:35:47 That's part of what Wendy's going to put out. Let's incorporate that into. Let's split that out. Great. And maybe just some key roles. You know, I know what Marian Carson does. I'm not entirely sure I'm familiar with what Miles' partnership does. All of our website. What's that? All of our website development. Okay. It'd be great to just, you know, bullet point. What we'll do is part of those Monday communications, we'll do a bio. We'll talk about what they do. We'll talk about what we pay them annually and what they place for media. How's that?
2:36:16 Okay, thank you, perfect. All right, with that, no departmental updates at this point in time. John, financial reports? Yeah, just quickly, on the TOT and TBID side, you can see down at the bottom, we've got, let's see, where am I here? You've got these in your packets. So February came in at $2.14 million. It was $392,000 behind, excuse me, ahead of budget, and it was behind last year by $335,000, which is 13%.
2:36:43 We may grab a little bit more on that, but probably not too, too much. TBID for February preliminarily came in at $653,000. That's $150,000 behind budget. And for the year to date, we're $250,000 behind budget. So still maintaining very well compared to where we could be with the lack of winter until March. March numbers should come in strong. I think it'll be interesting to see where TOT and TBID fall for the month of March.
2:37:10 Cash flow in T-Bit, or excuse me, cash flow in CDRs, we talked about that. Measure A has 1.25 million in the CDs. T-Bit has 2.5 million in the CDs. We're renewing those at this point on a 13-week basis, so they're protected. They're all in accounts that are less than 250,000, so they're FDIC protected. Checking account as of today has measure A at 1.7 million.
2:37:32 TBID checking account has $522,000, and savings in Measure A is $5,010, and TBID is $5,006. And the checking accounts for both TBID and Measure A, just we had a couple of large checks. We had a Marion Carson check that went through.
2:37:49 For all their placements, that was $400 and some odd thousand. And then we also paid the $845,000 for last summer's subsidy last week. $510,000 of that came for TBID. And the remaining $335,000 came for Measure A. $35,000 of that will get reimbursed by the county. And then P&L reports went out as well. Mr. Clark. Colin asked earlier for a quick update as to what our base area schedule is going to be.
2:38:19 Canyon and Eagle will remain open until I think it is April. I'm going to get the date wrong. It's that Sunday. So it's April 16th. They'll remain open through April 16th. And at that point in time, we'll still remain open, you know, well into Memorial Day, past Memorial Day up at Main Lodge. The lifts that will service up there are one, two, three,
2:38:48 23 gondola, and sometimes five for the camps that we have, but high performance camps more so. So that will be kind of how we ratchet it back down to do the spring service. June's this Sunday, right? Is that correct? June's this Sunday, that is correct. Okay. Can we ask how the sales of passes are going with the new icon pass? You can ask, yes. And I can tell you they're ahead of forecast. Okay.
2:39:20 So we're pleased with that. Because I see that the epic pass is now giving you like six bring a buddy passes with it. We don't want that. We need lipstick around. We don't want that. Don't have that. All right. We've got takeaways at the bottom. Anything else before we wrap up? All right. With that, we're going to adjourn the meeting. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thanks, everyone. Thank you.
2:39:47 Right now. Yeah, fine.