TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2018

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 15 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

273 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Thank you.

0:47 Thank you.

1:27 Okay. Good afternoon, everyone.

1:54 I'd like to call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, April 11th. Roll call please, Jamie. Commissioner Burroughs? Present. Commissioner Chang? Commissioner Eckert? Present. Vice Chair Vanderhurst? That's not me. Chair Canelo now? Yes, I'm here. Thank you. Can we rise for the Pledge of Allegiance, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag.

2:25 of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. All right. Thank you. Our first item today is public comment. Is there anyone in the public who would like to speak on an item that is not on today's agenda? Please come up to the podium. And not seeing anyone, we will just close the public comment period and move on to item number one.

3:02 Our first public hearing, which was continued from last month's meeting, is to consider approval of the use permit 17-004 for the establishment of a three guest room bed and breakfast inn to operate within the rural residential zoning district at 70 Carter Street, including funding the project consistent with the previously adopted addendum to the initial study mitigated negative declaration. And Kim Cook will be our contact.

3:43 This item was continued from the last public hearing due to a noticing error in the software we used to create our mailing lists. So we did re-notice the application. There were a significant number of additional property owners who were notified. So we believe that that issue has been remedied. So the use permit application before you was submitted to the town by Zachary Salam on December 1, 2017.

4:11 Zachary is the son of the property owners and is one of the bed and breakfast managers that would be living on site. The proposed use is a three guest room bed and breakfast inn located at 70 Carter Street. The bed and breakfast inn is proposed to be operated within the existing single family residence and an existing detached secondary dwelling unit would serve as the primary residence for the property owner or manager.

4:42 An access bridge is proposed off Tamarack Street to provide a new primary means of access to the site that meets the required fire protection district access. And I'll go into more detail later on in my presentation. You can see the proposed bridge access on the lower portion of the page from Tamarack Street. The project site is located within the rural residential zoning district, which allows bed and breakfast inns that are approved through the use permit process.

5:12 The subject property is in approximately 2.87 acres and features an existing 2,247 square foot three bedroom single family home shown here and a 1,152 square foot detached secondary dwelling unit with a single car garage. The property is a well neck

5:36 well recognized property within the community because it features a wetland meadow that occupies the majority of the property visible from Old Mammoth Road and Tamarack Streets. The use permit application process as it relates to permitting new bed and breakfast establishments is intended to ensure the compatibility between the bed and breakfast inn and adjoining residential uses. The zoning code establishes specific use standards for

6:04 for new bed and breakfasts and I'm going to go through each of these standards and identify how the proposed use meets the requirements. The first is exterior appearance. The exterior appearance of the structure housing the bed and breakfast in is a residential in a residential zoning district shall not be altered from its original single-family residential character except for those structural modifications necessary to comply with the applicable

6:33 requirements of the California Building Code. The existing single-family home and detached secondary dwelling are not proposed to be modified on their exterior. There are some interior improvements proposed for the primary dwelling in order to create more, put up additional walls to create space between the existing guest rooms.

7:01 The second requirement for fire safety is that the bed and breakfast inn shall meet the requirements of the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District and the California Building Code. Staff has worked with the applicant and the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District to address emergency vehicle access needs for the site. The initial requirements from the fire district required an easement for emergency vehicle access on Carter Street, which is a requirement that has been required for other private roads in town.

7:29 When we approached the applicant with this requirement, they indicated that the Carter Street Association may not agree to grant an easement for emergency vehicle access. So in order to ensure that they're able to meet that requirement, they revised their site plan to provide an access bridge off Tamarack Street. Additionally, in reviewing the new access bridge, an issue related to the traveled way of Tamarack Street came up.

7:59 Our engineering staff has worked with the applicant to determine the best method for addressing right-of-way dedications for Tamarack Street because there is a discrepancy between the actual traveled way where the road exists currently and the recorded right-of-way location. So the actual road, a large portion of the road is within the boundaries of the subject property.

8:29 So our engineering staff discussed options with the applicant regarding the dedications of portions of the property along Tamarack Street and they determined that a grant deed for the traveled way would be transferred to the town and this solution would reconcile the town right of way with the actual road location and would relieve the property owner of property tax paid for the area covered by the road.

8:53 As well as any potential liability that they might incur with that road being located on their property. This condition of approvals included number 27 to satisfy the Public Works right-of-way requirements for both Tamarack Street and Old Mammoth Road. And again, this came up as part of the review of the new bridge access from Tamarack Street. The third requirement related to guest rooms is the number of guest rooms shall be limited to five rooms.

9:24 The proposed bed and breakfast is for three guest rooms total, and that meets the requirement. The fourth requirement for internal access requires the main or primary access to guest rooms shall be within the bed and breakfast inn or the guest room shall be located in an approved detached living area. All of the proposed guest rooms are located within the primary single family residence and are all accessed from within that structure.

9:57 The fifth requirement for on-site parking requires that on-site parking shall be provided at a ratio of one space for each guest room plus two spaces for the on-site owner or manager of the bed and breakfast inn. Five parking spaces are provided on the site. This is a photo of the parking area adjacent to the secondary dwelling unit.

10:26 The upper left-hand corner shows an area to the west of the dwelling unit which would provide the on-site manager's parking. There's one exterior space identified and one interior space provided within the garage. The lower right-hand photo shows a parking pad on the east side of the secondary dwelling unit which provides three 10-foot by 20-foot parking spaces which meets the required parking for

10:55 The bed and breakfast. The sixth requirement for on-site management requires the bed and breakfast inn shall be the primary residence of the bed and breakfast inn owner and manager. The application indicates that the secondary dwelling unit will be the primary residence for the bed and breakfast manager. Number seven, provision of meals. The bed and breakfast inns may serve breakfast to guests only where authorized by the Mono County Environmental Health Department.

11:29 And meals shall be limited to registered guests, registered overnight guests only. The narrative provided with the application does indicate that the applicants intend to serve breakfast to their guests, and that will trigger the requirement for the applicant to obtain the Mono County Health Department approval. This has been included as condition of approval number 20. Requirement number 8 for signs.

12:00 It says that signage shall be allowed for bed and breakfast inns in compliance with Chapter 17.48. That's our sign ordinance of the code. We included condition of approval number 21 requiring that they comply with our sign ordinance because at this time no sign is proposed for the bed and breakfast. The last land use standard is for transient occupancy tax.

12:26 The Bed and Breakfast Inn shall be subject to all applicable provisions of Chapter 3.12, transient occupancy tax, and shall maintain guest registers to ensure accurate occupancy records. We've included Condition of Approval No. 16, requiring that a business tax certificate is obtained for the transient occupancy use. For CEQA, we did review the project.

13:00 for compliance with CEQA, and in making the CEQA determination for this project, staff utilized prior CEQA documentation that was prepared for the property related to a previous application for a tentative parcel map to subdivide the parcel into two lots. The CEQA document approved for that application was an addendum to the initial study and mitigated negative declaration that were prepared for the original grading permit associated with the single-family home and detached accessory structure that were constructed at the site.

13:31 The project in the context of this application is a change of use of the single family residence to a bed and breakfast inn and the construction of an access bridge off Tamarack Street, which is not substantially different than the project previously analyzed. Alone, the change of use of the single family residence to a bed and breakfast inn would be categorically exempt from further CEQA review pursuant to the CEQA guidelines. The bridge access off Tamarack Street

13:58 was previously analyzed at the same general location on the property, and this site plan illustrates the previously reviewed map for the tentative parcel map, which was analyzed under the previous CEQA document, and we can see the bridge access in the same general location as is currently proposed.

14:27 The bridge access off Tamarack Street was previously analyzed at the same general location under the addendum to the initial study mitigated negative declaration and the adopted mitigation measures applicable to the construction of the access bridge will continue to apply. Additionally, there are no changed conditions or new items of information that would suggest the existence of new or more significant impacts that would result from the construction of an access bridge from Tamarack Street.

14:57 Staff has determined that the minor modification made in this application to the location of the access bridge to better align with the existing paved driveway would not result in any additional impacts or increase the severity of impacts identified in the addendum to the initial study mitigated negative declaration, nor are there any changed conditions or new items of information that would suggest the existence of new or more significant impacts. So we have made the finding that the adopted addendum

15:26 is applicable to the potential impacts associated with this use permit, application, and the proposed construction of an access bridge off Tamarack Street. The project is subject to the mitigation measures included in the Addendum's mitigation, monitoring, and reporting program, which have been included as conditions of approval for the project. We have received two public comments from property owners who received the public notice.

15:51 That was in response to the original public notice that we published for the March 4th meeting. We have not received any additional public comments prior to this meeting. Based on the analysis presented, it is staff's opinion that the required findings to support the requested approval can be made, and staff recommends approval of use permit 17-004 with the conditions of approval included in the attached resolution.

16:25 The applicants are here if you have any questions for them and I'm happy to answer any questions. Okay, great. So would the applicant like to come up and speak? We're good. Oh, okay. Absolutely. All right. So we will take any questions we have up here prior to moving on to the public. Jennifer, do you want to start on your end? Any questions for staff? I just want to confirm that

16:59 This area is zoned for the bed and breakfast and that it doesn't violate any short-term housing and nightly rental. Yes, it is zoned correctly for bed and breakfast inns with a use permit. I know that Measure Z also addressed this in the language that specifically allowed bed and breakfast inns within the rural residential zone with a use permit. Okay.

17:31 Thank you. Okay. No question at this time. Is the unit, the structure that's being divided into bed and breakfast units, is that currently rented to an outside party? Is that Community Housing Act? It's not currently being rented on a transient basis. I'm not aware of whether it's being rented on a long-term basis, if the applicants can speak to that. Okay. Anything else going?

18:12 I had a question and just, sorry, it must not have been, I'll come back to it if I have to. I don't know what it was. Okay, we'll move on to any questions or comments from the audience. If you would like to speak, please come up to the podium and announce your name. For the record, please. My name's Lance Bauer and I'm one of the other three occupants of that Carter Street.

19:01 And so you have my map and you can get an idea about how the maintenance agreement works and how the snow removal works. Really, I just have three main concerns. One is snow removal on Carter Street. You know, I get the parking thing and we spent a couple hours with staff and we talked about

19:31 How difficult it might be with one car parked in front of the garage door to move some snow through. Could you put back up the two pictures of the driveway? So where between the little bobcat and the vehicle you can see an open space. And so historically we have moved the snow down Carter Street.

20:04 and out into the meadow and as as the portion that's the responsibility of that property the the portion of the snow that I'm responsible for goes down and you can just see the beginning of the asphalt in the right hand corner that's the beginning of me and my snow goes off to the right

20:27 On the other side of those trees, on the very right-hand side. So really what we're doing is we're dividing the snow that falls on the road into halves. I take half, they take half. If for some reason the blade that's coming down Carter Street can't get through, I end up with all the snow. Like last winter, it was insane. I couldn't tell you how high the pile was. It was high.

20:55 It's essential that that throughway is maintained so that snow can go to the meadow because I don't have the room or the inclination to take all the snow for the road. According to the maintenance agreement, it's not all my responsibility. It's divided. As you see in this little picture, you can see that Area C is divided in half.

21:24 So I'm responsible for half of that area. See, that snow is my snow and I've got to deal with it. So snow removal is one of my concerns and I'd like to see some condition applied that that area doesn't get blocked, that the historical way we've dealt with the snow is maintained rather than it's all going to fall on me if that area is blocked.

21:53 And the maintenance agreement goes along with all that. The other thing I'd like to see is a sign required at Carter Street and Tamarack intersection that tells potential guests they shouldn't be using Carter Street. That goes hand in hand with the maintenance agreement.

22:19 According to Area C, I'm responsible for half of that maintenance of that asphalt. If there are people driving down Carter Street going to the bed and breakfast, I'm becoming responsible for maintaining a benefit to their business. I don't think that's appropriate at all. So, yes, I understand the bridge is going in. Yes, I understand people for the first time may miss that, especially if they're coming at night.

22:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

23:20 Maybe it says Carter Street private driveway, maybe Carter Street no outlet, I don't know, something. And then something about if there's going to be increased maintenance and shouldn't fall on the homeowners, the other three homeowners that aren't benefiting from the use of the driveway in some commercial way. Any questions for me?

23:51 Just for clarification, Mr. Bauer, you're saying between the bobcat and the vehicle, that's where you normally push the snow towards? That's where our snow removal, Jerry Wu does the blade work. He comes straight down the driveway from Tamarack, drives basically in a straight line. It's a very straight shot. It's an easy do. He drives straight out into the meadow between the propane tank and the structure.

24:21 Ton of room. Goes straight out and just builds a ramp. And that's where that portion of the snow goes. And then I take my portion. I think that photo on the left is looking this direction. I take my portion and dump it in between some trees on my property. But if there's no snow going out to the meadow, it all falls on me. Because there's no room. Jerry can't leave it on their property.

24:50 At least in their driveway. That's not going to work for them. And if this is going to become, you can see the garage door. So there's going to be, that's the one, two, three, that's the fifth parking space for the proposed use is right where that black vehicle is. So you can see it's already getting smaller just by permanently parking a vehicle there. Jerry can still get through there, but if it gets constrained anymore.

25:16 By maybe the Bobcat being parked there or another vehicle or something else, then Jerry's got nowhere to go with all that snow. And it's not just my snow. It's snow that's fallen on Carter Street. If they're going to use it, or in any case, just the owners of the property are using the road. So it's half theirs, essentially. And you said there is a maintenance agreement between the three homeowners?

25:46 All four. That was that second piece of paper I gave you. It's just one page of the CC&Rs that says there are four lots. Yeah, I highlighted that one portion. Yeah. So that it says that basically we're each responsible for a fraction of the driveway for maintenance and snow removal. It's the way it's always been. Right. So, I mean. So it's like a 30 page. I don't know if you guys ever saw a copy of it. Right.

26:19 So your snow removal and maintenance agreement, it being part of the CC&Rs, and the CC&Rs were in existence when the property owners bought the property. Travels with the property. Yeah, travels with the property. So, I mean, to me, it seems like it's in the best interest of the property owner to follow the CC&Rs. It does. But here we are, and now they're proposing a secondary use for the property. And my concern is that

26:48 That's going to go by the wayside, and I'll tell you why I believe that. If you put up the map for Dan Hinkle, please, if you look closely at that, you won't see any designated snow storage. I've been a home builder here for 40 years. When I propose a house, a new single family house in Mammoth Lakes, I have to show snow storage and the percentage. It's part of the code.

27:18 It's not on there. I think this is an excerpt from a parcel map from 2011. And understand that this parcel map is not that parcel map, but the fact that it was not shown there and it's not shown on the new one, it's kind of like nobody's talking about it or looking at it, but it really is critical because by the time you add

27:45 Two cars over here and another car over there and another car there, you've taken away all the paved surface, making it even more difficult. Hais, have you worked with the property owner on their snow storage strategy? Yeah, when you're talking about snow storage for just the applicant itself, they have the entire meadow for snow storage. They have, frankly, ample snow storage for... They have ample space, but as far as, I mean, their strategy of how it relates to parking as well as...

28:15 As far as just their personal property, yes. They have the ability, just like any other unit, to move the vehicles out of the way, push the snow out into the meadow. There's a couple ways they could blade it out. We don't see any real restrictions on that private use and what's being proposed. The Carter Street, portion of the Carter Street is going to become town's property. No, Carter Street. Carter Street was vacated. You saw us. Okay.

28:46 Got it. Okay. So there are four owners, part each of the CC&Rs, and so four people responsible for the maintenance and the snow removal, depending on where you live. Understood. On the road. Mr. Barrow, how long has this snow on Carter Street been going through that gap? Historically. So it started with when Ron Tinsley and Marcia Jarvis owned the property, first owners.

29:14 It's been going out there. X number of years, what would X be? Oh, 20, because we moved in right after the road was paved. We delayed our escrow to wait till the road was paved, so that was 1999. Have you talked with the applicant about there's no storage strategy? I mean, yeah, it's not fully understand. Briefly, the snow removal contractor, it's kind of like it's his deal. I can't.

29:45 Negotiate for him. And for whatever reason, there is no deal. So it's kind of like it's been separated out. And that's fine. I don't care. As long as that access is maintained, that's fine. I think I completely understand what you're saying. And I think what you're asking for with regards to cooperation from the applicant is reasonable.

30:13 Thank you.

30:43 Creating that business, you can protect the other three property owners that are responsible for that road and mitigate that expense, that additional expense. I'm not actually sure if that's true, if that's something that we can require. However, it does seem like something that perhaps you could bring up with the property owner as something that could be in their best interest as well. Okay.

31:12 If you guys don't think it's your deal, I think, you know, just as an interested party standing back, I think it is. So we would allow a sign, a directional sign to the bed and breakfast. And I think that just kind of looking at the map, maybe the best location for it is at that bridge so that, you know, people see that.

31:36 And will turn as they're coming down the street there. So they are allowed one sign. And Steve and I talked about that, and it works for me. Not so great for him, because the sign's going to be probably directed at his house, and if it's lit at night, then it's just one more thing. Because he's across the street and up just a little. So, I mean, it works for me, but I take him into consideration too. But, you know.

32:07 It's something you guys can kick around. Appreciate your time. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Any other question? No. Thank you. Thank you. If this pathway has been used for 20 years for snow storage, is there anything that would be construed as a prescriptive easement for snow storage to continue there? And would that be a problem if that's the department?

32:31 I don't think so. I mean, this is all a private maintenance agreement that the town isn't a party to. So I think that if all of that is described in this private maintenance agreement, that's all been agreed to by those property owners and how the snow is moved. I'm not sure if I haven't read the CC&Rs if that's described in there. But I don't think it would be considered a prescriptive easement, no. Okay. Anyone else from the public would like to come up and speak? Can I speak? Absolutely. Yes.

33:11 Can you state your name for the record, please? Yeah, Dave Billingsley, Stephanie Carter Street, Mammoth Lakes. So, they can't see that. Lance, Lance, the stuff you're talking about with snow storage, yes, historically, I understand that the snow has been pushed, collated from Carter Street into the meadow. This map that we're looking at, the tentative parcel map that we inherited,

33:40 When we purchased the property and then went through the process of extending just to keep our option open, we have no intention of fulfilling that lot split now. One of the conditions, and I don't know if you have that in front of you, was that we had to demonstrate that there was legal access to parcel two, which is this parcel from Carter Street.

34:08 And we spoke about that and they said that we don't have legal access to parcel two. So, you're saying we don't have legal access to parcel two, but we need to allow Carter Street snow to be stored on there, on parcel two. Well, we'll put it another way. The snow that falls on Carter Street,

34:33 It needs to go somewhere on parcel one or parcel two. It doesn't matter to me. It can go on parcel one, and I told Jerry that.

34:41 And the method of snow removal is not stipulated in the CC&Rs. You got... Excuse me, Dave. I don't want to get too far off track here, but I just want to reiterate that the maintenance agreement for snow storage that's part of the CC&Rs is really not something that we can debate up here. That's good. Pursuant to the bed and breakfast, we'd be happy to...

35:06 And the signage issue, we would be happy to build, once we have access off Tamarack Street, we would be happy to build, to close off Carter Street access, to build a wall across the Carter Street access to the property. Happy to do that. Okay. Thank you, Dave. Would anyone else like to, oh, please. My name is Steve Schwind, I live at 86 Tamarack Street.

35:49 across the street directly from the home. I first wanted to speak to the B&B, but today we gave you copies of some internet marketing for this property called the Yosemite Toad Inn at Old Mammoth Camp. And I know we're discussing approval for commercial use as a B&B, but

36:20 I found this interesting, maybe you will. It's a little small, but the problem is they're marketing this also for camping in a two-acre meadow and for an RV and vans plugging in. When we met with the town staff, I don't know if you're aware of this, but we had no idea this was being approved and we didn't have an opportunity to discuss that.

36:52 And what is troubling, this is a comfortable camping experience in an extraordinary, convenient location. Lay your tent down on a two-acre flat meadow. And then the land is equipped with a bathroom. Must be the bathrooms inside buildings. The campground land is not equipped with a bathroom. Fire pit and showers. The land is not.

37:24 Equipped with a fire pit and showers. But then, there is also 500 square feet of paved parking with electricity for vans slash RVs. That's not calculated in the parking that you've been presented. And this is on Google and the internet. We found it on hipcamping.com just the other day. So, it makes it, I'm opposed to a

37:56 Campground in the middle of Tamarack Street, even if one campsite or one RV. I would be inclined to say that that does not fall within the definition of a bed and breakfast, but I just would like to. Well, I'm bringing this up. It's like FYI, we don't know about this. We just found out about it. Interesting, huh, folks? Is this something that you have spoken with the applicant about, or I think the applicant would like to say something in response, but.

38:22 No, this is the first time it's been brought to our attention, and it's not something that we would be able to approve as a part of the bed and breakfast operation, and it's not permitted to advertise your transient use before you have a use permit, and this type of transient use would not be permitted here. Would you like to just, I saw you raising your hand earlier as the applicant. Could you come up to the podium, please?

39:00 No, it's not an active thing. Would you mind just coming up and stating that for the record because this is being recorded and televised? It would be very helpful. Yeah. Okay. David Billingsley, 74th Street. What Steve's talking about is a listing on hipcamp.com. We bought this place in roughly Halloween of 2015. So around Christmastime, we were celebrating Christmas at the house and talking about potential usage.

39:34 For the property. Oh, we could list it on Hip Camp and have people camp there. Filled out the Hip Camp. They have an application form or something like that. It's an online camping thing. They took all the information. They posted that. We have never, it's not an active listing. I could do that for anybody's property to say, hey, we want to rent this place out for campers.

40:02 We've never pursued permitting for that. We have no intention of applying for permitting for that. It's random internet fodder that I created, but just on a whim at Christmas time sitting around. But you see why we have red flags? Yeah. Okay. No, that makes sense. No, I agree. And I'm glad that you can answer the concern.

40:30 Thank you. So again, like, I guess, send Poncho a message. I mean, that's active. You could get messages on this about it. So whether it was done three years ago or now, it's still active marketing and non-permitted use. So I don't know how you do that. I mean, do I go through the town process of, you know, anonymously file a complaint with the TOT folks?

41:00 People who watch this stuff, I mean, I believe, Dave, that it's not functioning, but somehow you shouldn't be finding this out here as Mammoth or Yosemite towed in at Old Mammoth Camp. We can follow up on that and have it. And talking about 12 spaces, 12 people can come and do it, and it's like, whoa, that's more than three parking. So I think it's a concern that needs to be dealt with and ended before you approve anything. I think that's something that can be addressed, though, outside of the use permit process.

41:30 Great. Okay. Well, and then I just wanted to touch base on, I realize that a special use permit is allowed under measure Z, measure Z, and it also, a special use permit does not have to be approved. And so I just am voicing my opposition to having a bed and breakfast across from my house.

41:57 Even though Measure Z allowed for the loophole of special use permits. For 37 years, I've been in Mammoth and residents have been against nightly rentals in neighborhoods. And so my wife and I have been against nightly rentals in neighborhoods, whether it's RR or the neighborhood zone that we are. So I'm concerned about that. So I'm expressing my opposition.

42:27 And it seems that people are against having a bed and breakfast. The ones previous were approved prior to Measure Z. And I don't think that should be a precedent in light of Measure Z. And so I guess I'm asking the Planning Commission today not to substitute your judgment over and against the judgment of the residents.

42:59 On Tamarack Street, it's clear the residents don't want a B&B in our neighborhood. I'm asking you not to substitute your judgment over ours. And then I'm also asking you not to substitute your judgment over and against the larger community of Mammoth who overwhelmingly voted on Measure Z. Please do not substitute your judgment over and against the residents of Mammoth who do not want nightly rentals in residential neighborhoods.

43:32 Please do not go against the intent of Measure Z. It's clearly intended to prevent nightly rentals in residential neighborhoods, which we are. And so I've lived here 37 years and all I've heard about is no nightly rentals in residential neighborhoods. Fortunately, Measure Z got on the ballot in time to prevent the town council, three members substituting their judgment.

44:01 Over and against the entire community. So I guess my appeal is please do not substitute your judgment over and against the opposition to the B&B and then please do not substitute your judgment over and against the people of Mammoth who do not want nightly rentals in neighborhoods. You do not have to recommend approval of this special use permit as staff asks. Please listen to us. Please hear us. Thank you.

44:31 Thank you. Any other comments or questions from the public? Stacey Corliss speaking as a resident of Old Mammoth. I just want to remind everyone that obviously we've heard that the bed and breakfast concept is permitted, but we do have two examples of currently, I think still currently operating bed and breakfasts in Old Mammoth, one on Hill Street and one right on Old Mammoth Road. And then we do have the Pine Cliff Manor property. I think that's zoned.

45:16 Something else, it's not rural or residential, but it effectively functions in the same way for short term. The Pinecrest Resort? Yeah, on Woodman. So to me, what we're really hearing here, there are quality of life issues, and if those can be addressed, the town has a quality of life.

45:35 Thank you. That was my question. You're welcome. So I think, again, framing and in my professional experience in dealing with land use issues, everybody gets really nervous when there's some change proposed to a use in your neighborhood. But sometimes when we get at it through short-term rentals or not, we lose sight of what really the issue is, and that's quality of life.

46:04 If some of the concerns of neighbors and residents can be addressed through the town's quality of life ordinance or simply, in our meetings, I always encourage people to actually talk to their neighbors. I think everybody who's spoken today, I know them all in some capacity and are all decent, kind, smart people who could talk to each other and figure these things out. Thank you. Thank you for reminding me about my question earlier. I just want to get back to that. So I just wanted to confirm with you that if

46:33 The use permit is approved here and the applicant pulls a business tax certificate and a transient occupancy tax certificate that then that would trigger the inspection process that the town approved and how it relates to the quality of life ordinance? Yes, it would be subject to the quality of life ordinance. Okay, and the things that are covered in the quality of life ordinance are things such as outward appearance and noise and...

47:02 Traffic and parking and things like that, correct? Safety. Safety, basically, basic safety. And those are all things that are enforceable by the town code compliance officer? The, it's enforced by the, we have inspectors for the transient occupancy certificates, so an independent inspector does those inspections. And then the finance department, we have a TOT revenue team, they kind of,

47:30 Take complaints on any TOT issues and respond to those. And sometimes those are passed off to a code compliance officer depending on what the complaint is, but the TOT... It gets routed to the appropriate department within the town. Okay. Any other comments from the public? Or if the property owner or applicant would like to say any final additional words? Okay. So then I will...

48:15 Officially close the public hearing portion and that opens it up for deliberation or any final comments up here on the dais. Greg, can you start on your end at this time? And specifically, we should definitely address the CEQA issue, which was, you know, the environmental as it related to the bridge and then the municipal code. Well, a couple of things that I see on this particular community.

48:44 If this isn't going to qualify for bed and breakfast, nothing in this town of the world. It's a big piece of property. I wouldn't want it next to me on a quarter acre lot at the same time. I can't see how we can allow an established use for local folks to get chopped off by business. So I think we should put something in here that requires them to make peace or continue to allow historical use whatever access to that meadow.

49:17 I've done enough snow removal to know that these guys are going to want access, need access to that metal at some point in the future. And if we're approving something that the access is underneath cars, it can be adjusted, but it's a huge pain behind. So there should be some, or I'd like to see some accommodation for that. I'm assuming that whatever the court that may have come up at Christmas time.

49:47 This is only going to be allowed for three units inside the building. There's never going to be any RV use or tent camping or new rooms for tents or anything else out there. So those are quite two big issues. Paul? I know staff and I had a conversation about this. First of all, has the applicant read all the conditions listed on the resolution?

50:24 And I just want to go back real quick because since I have public works here, so condition number 30, it talks about the Tamarack Street needs to accommodate a 28-foot turning radius on either side of the bridge. Can you visualize that for me? What does that look like? I'll do my best to explain this. So the applicant will be required to demonstrate

50:53 To the satisfaction of the Public Works Department that an apparatus with a turning radius of 28 feet can make the turn from Tamarack Street onto the bridge. Now, that can be done a number of ways, but typically what they will do is take a turning template, which shows a number of radii for the overhang of the apparatus.

51:15 The wheel track for the apparatus, and they will have to overlay that onto the map in scale to show that the equipment can actually make the turn. Okay. And this is handled at the building, more at the building permit process stage of the... Okay, yes. Now, given the position of the bridge, has there any point in time the water level will go above or...

51:45 To my knowledge, the water level does not rise that high, but the engineer of record will have to demonstrate that the bridge works hydrologically, and they will have to pull the records from our drainage maps, drainage plans, and show that that bridge does not impact the flow of water that has historically run through the property.

52:16 Last question. I think I read somewhere here that the check-in time is until 10.30 or 10 o'clock in the evening. What happened after 10 o'clock if the guests show up due to weather delay, traffic delay and things? What happened?

52:38 So that was part of the narrative the applicant put forward, their recommended hours of operation. We ultimately did not include that as a condition of approval in this final version. Understanding that, you know, travelers from LA often show up later than 10 p.m., it'd be a difficult thing to enforce, and we wouldn't want to set them up for failure. Okay. Okay. All right. That's all I have. Thank you.

53:13 I definitely have some concerns that the, which the residents around the proposed bed and breakfast have discussed and they're valid and I would like to see some further discussion amongst you guys to try to resolve these issues. I recognize that we cannot enforce CCNRs and we don't really have a say over that in previous.

53:42 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

54:14 Provide a use permit for this. So that's all I have to say. So I can respond to the comment about the tent camping. If that were to occur on the site after a use permit was obtained, it would be grounds for revocation if it was ever brought to our attention and there were complaints related to that. And there is a process for revoking use permits if they don't comply with their conditions. Okay. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.

54:49 I appreciate everyone that's come out to hear, to listen and to speak and to voice their concerns and share with us their general knowledge of the neighborhood and the properties. I think it's very important that

55:07 All of you as direct neighbors, whether you're adjoining properties or across the street, maintain good relationships with each other. And I think it's within this particular property owners and applicants' best interest to maintain good relationships with all of your neighbors. And, you know, I think we all understand that there are, you know,

55:29 Delicacies associated with maintenance agreements and snow storage and CC&Rs and things like that, but unfortunately that is just not something that we have the ability to do much about, but I have faith that you all as Mammoth community members can come to some sort of amicable agreement about that. Again, I believe it's within this applicant's best interest to...

55:55 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

56:26 the use permit, whether the use permit meets the zoning code and the general plan, etc. I agree with Greg that I think this property is just about as suited as any in Mammoth for a bed and breakfast. Given the

56:44 the corner location and the separation from other adjoining parcels with the street and given the size of the property. I think it's important to understand the distinction between the type of transient rental that a lot of us come to think of insofar as VRBO and Airbnb and things like that is a little bit different than a bed and breakfast operation which is at

57:11 Required to have the property owner or manager as a full-time resident on site. This isn't three units that are going to be peripherally maintained by a property management company that only operates from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. This is a situation where the units are going to have oversight essentially 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

57:40 Within, you know, within reason. So I think for that particular reason, it's distinguished a bit from the items that were discussed in Measure Z and, you know, the typical short-term nightly rental situation. So with that being said, I don't really have any more comments. I'm happy with the work that the staff has done with the applicant. And I think we can,

58:13 Move forward if anyone would like to make a motion. I'll make a motion to adopt the attached planning PDC resolution making the required sequel and muni code findings and approving use permit 17-004. Do you have a second? I can't second, can I? As chair? Yes. I can? Okay, then I'm going to second that. However, it sounds like we might be split.

58:52 A bit. Is there any, do we need to have any further discussion up here? I guess, because I've been Googling this, the Yosemite toed in, and there's a lot of stuff on the internet about it, and it's not just this, and it's not even open yet. There's like a whole Instagram page on it, there's a Facebook page on it, and I gotta say, it's a little concerning. For something that's not open, it's not even approved, and it kind of feels a little shady to me, and I have an issue with that.

59:26 So I don't necessarily feel like I want to approve this at this time. Are you going to say something? Well, I was just going to say that, I mean, we're aware of this issue, and then we'll look at additional items online and follow up on enforcement actions for that. And it's really, like I said, handled by the TOT department. It's not really related to the findings for the use permit, but it is something we'll follow up on. Okay.

1:00:01 All right. I meant to ask one question regarding signage, and I know they haven't applied for a sign yet. You had mentioned, I think, that they are permitted to have one sign for the property? Yes, we can have. Sorry. If they were to request an additional sign to be located at Carter Street or maybe at or by the bridge to help address the issue of

1:00:35 Thank you.

1:01:05 Fall within that category. And then, yes, that could be approved through that process. Just wanted to confirm really quickly. Thank you. While Kim's looking that up. I mean, I don't think we can place that as a condition of approval on this use permit. We can, from the dais, you can...

1:01:53 And I have to say that, you know, if we make any recommendation or insist,

1:02:23 The parties to do certain things just because historically that's what happened. It's almost like we're overreaching our authority in telling people in this town what to do. I guess there's some sort of imply easement in this particular case given what the residents of Carter Street have done in the past.

1:02:56 But I think it's difficult for us to simply just make that a requirement or a condition. Right. Yeah. I mean, hypothetically, if the property owner wanted to truck away all of the snow that falls on their shared portion of Carter Street, it's within their right to do so, I would imagine. I mean, but again, there's a maintenance agreement that's a private document between the property owners.

1:03:26 And if they wanted to make any revision to that, it's, you know, that's something that they all, you all need to discuss amongst themselves. Yeah, we don't really have a saying with that. And I also want to say that what Commissioner Burrell just pulled up on the internet certainly is a questionable behavior, but at the same time, it's difficult for us to just,

1:04:04 And I think that, and that's why we have enforcement units and policies

1:04:38 I agree. Again, as Sandra mentioned, it doesn't really have any effect on the

1:05:14 The actual municipal code findings and the CEQA findings that we are being very objectively asked to evaluate. You're right. So we've talked about it. We've brought it up. That's something that staff has the ability to follow up on. We did just talk about the possibility, the ability of the owner to have an additional sign to help direct traffic, which I think will help address some of the neighboring property owner's concerns. So with that said, I believe we still have a motion on the table.

1:05:44 Which was seconded. Okay. Can we do a roll call vote, Jamie? Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Becker? Yes. Chair Gallin? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you all. That concludes that item and we will then move on to the next public hearing. Pardon me. Is this one mentioning?

1:06:21 This one is Majestic Pines. Item number two, public hearing number two, is to consider approval of a variance number 18-001 to allow a five-foot front yard setback for a garage and a reduction in the required number of parking spaces by one space for the reconstruction of a single-family residence that was destroyed by a fire located at 763 Majestic Pines Drive. And it includes finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA.

1:06:51 Pursuant to the guidelines, section 15303, new construction of small structures. Nolan is going to be our staff contact. Chair, we had a request from one of the members of the public who wanted to speak on this item to take item three out of order. We haven't actually talked to the applicant yet about that, but there was a request from a member of the public. We wanted to bring it up as an option or as something to do.

1:07:21 to ask the applicant whether they would be okay with that. If not, we can continue on with the public hearing. If they are okay with that, we could take item three out of order and have item two after item three. So I'm not sure which person is the applicant for this item. So you're saying that a member of the public has asked for us to consider item number three, the Manzanita project first?

1:07:49 The applicant, the member of the public would like to provide comments on this item, the variance. However, they aren't able to make it to the meeting at this point, and they think they'll be here in about 20 minutes. That was the request. Oh, okay. We are not required to grant the request. However, I wanted to give that information to the commission and to the applicant for the variance to see if they would be willing to consider that. If not, the commission can start the public hearing now.

1:08:17 I think if we start the staff report and move on to questions from up here, that hopefully that person will be here by then, and if not, and we're still considering the item at the time that that person gets here, can we? We can talk about it. We can talk about that then. Okay, thank you. Thanks. Great, thank you. Variance 18-001 is requesting approval of a five-foot setback.

1:08:52 for a garage and a reduction in the required number of parking spaces by one space for the reconstruction of a single family residence that was destroyed by a fire in April 2017. The property is located at 763 Majestic Pines Drive and it's zoned residential single family.

1:09:11 is within the low density residential two is the land use designation. Original residence was constructed in 1999 and once again it was destroyed by a fire in April 2017. The residence is proposed to be reconstructed with the same footprint, size and appearance as it was prior to being destroyed and will not require any additional site grading or site disturbance due to the proposed reuse of the existing foundation driveway and retaining walls.

1:09:41 The variance is required for the rebuild of the residence due to changes to the zoning code that have occurred since the residence was originally built in 1999. Prior to 2014, lots that were either steeply upsloping or downsloping were permitted to have a garage with a five-foot setback if the criteria outlined in the zoning code was met. This five-foot setback allowance authorized the original residence to have the five-foot setback.

1:10:08 During the zoning code update, this setback reduction was discussed and the consensus from the review authority was to remove the allowance for downsloping lots and keep the allowance for upsloping lots. The issue centered on the difficulties that steeply downsloping lots had with meeting the unenclosed parking requirement. The proposed residence complies with the unenclosed parking space requirement because it has a 10 by 20 foot parking space located adjacent to the garage and is

1:10:36 completely within the subject property. With regards to the parking, the parking standards that the original development was subject to required four parking spaces for the residents, of which a minimum of one of those was required to be enclosed and one unenclosed.

1:10:53 The current zoning code requires five parking spaces for residences between 5,000 and 6,999 square feet and requires a minimum of 50% of those spaces be enclosed and have one unenclosed parking space. The proposed residence has three enclosed parking spaces and one unenclosed parking space for a total of four spaces.

1:11:20 A variance is a site-specific exception to a land-use development standard in order to compensate for a special circumstance related to a property. The steepness of the lot, which has a downward slope of approximately 22% throughout the property, qualifies as a special circumstance. A standard 20-foot setback would push the structure further back on the property and require additional grading, which would cause additional site disturbance in the rear of the property in the area adjacent to the Mammoth Creek open space corridor.

1:11:49 Additionally, a shift back on the property would increase the overall average height of the structure since the vertical distance from the street to the ground increases as the slope drops down. Here on the screen, these are just some photos of the existing infrastructure on the site. In the photo on the left, you can see the downsloping nature of the property. You can also see the existing foundations, retaining walls, and driveways that remained after the fire.

1:12:21 The reduction in parking allows for the reuse of the existing driveway and foundation and protects the steep slope since no additional grading or site disturbance is required. The house is a four bedroom house and the provision of four spaces is consistent with the number of bedrooms. There is a secondary dwelling unit within the structure and pursuant to the municipal code no additional parking is required for the secondary unit since the structure is within a half mile of a transit stop. Another finding

1:12:50 Required for the approval of a variance is finding that the approval of the variance does not grant a special privilege inconsistent with the limitations upon other properties in the vicinity. The three houses to the west of the subject property were all approved with a reduced setback for garages and the number of parking spaces at those residences is consistent with the number of parking spaces proposed for the subject property. Here on the screen you have the three properties located to the west of the subject property.

1:13:20 And the setbacks for these, again, that's the setback from the property line, not necessarily the street, range from 5 to 10 feet. And these all have unenclosed parking space in various configurations. The property here on the left has it kind of in this section here. The middle one has it right adjacent to the property line in the front. And this property has their space here adjacent to the garage. One public comment has been submitted for the project.

1:13:51 The comments raised in the letter include, one, Majestic Pines Drive is unsafe in this area, two, the structure is within the town's 10-foot snow storage easement, and three, occupants of the structure routinely parked outside of the garage and encroached into the setback. The photo on the right is from the intersection of Valley Vista Drive and Majestic Pines Drive, and in the distance, the driveway bridge is visible.

1:14:19 The letter states that vehicles regularly slide from this intersection and get close to the subject property. The proposed five-foot setback for the garage is from the property line and not the edge of the driving lane. From the edge of the driving lane to the front of the garage is approximately 20 feet, which you can see here on the left image. This is the edge of the driving lane, you have right-of-way, and then the property line, and then

1:14:48 Approximately right here is where the garage, the front of the garage would be. Because of this distance and the distance from Valley Vista, the likeliness of a vehicle sliding into the structure appears to be unlikely. Staff did contact Mammoth Lakes Police Department to inquire if there had been any accidents in this area over the last 10 years and there were not any reports of accidents as a result of winter snow and ice conditions. The only report was for a vehicle that

1:15:17 Accidentally drove down the hillside after the fire had destroyed the residence. Additionally, the residence was in existence in this location for the previous 15 years and neither the structure or the driveway bridge has been hit by any vehicles. The second statement said that the structure would be within the town's 10-foot snow storage easement. As previously noted, the setback is measured from the property line and not the edge of pavement.

1:15:48 Majestic Pines Drive has a standard 60 foot right of way. There is approximately 15 feet of right of way between the edge of the driving lane and the property line that the town uses for snow storage. The property owner is not permitted to store snow within the town's right of way and the proposed structure is not within this area at any point.

1:16:08 And the third statement in the letter is that vehicles routinely parked outside the garage and encroached into the right of way. The town has a winter parking prohibition which prohibits parking of vehicles in the right of way which will obstruct or hinder snow removal operations. Parking within the right of way during winter is illegal and the violator can be fined if a complaint is made and the responding officer witnesses the vehicles parked in the right of way. Just as an additional

1:16:38 Item to reiterate this, condition of approval 23 states this winter parking prohibition for the applicant to acknowledge. With regards to if the owner has parked there or not, the owner has stated that they did not park within the right-of-way and they acknowledged and understand all the proposed conditions of approval. Fortunately, the applicant is not able to be here today. He did indicate his contractor would be in attendance.

1:17:06 I'm not sure if he is or not. The required findings for the application include that the project is consistent with CEQA and the municipal code findings for a variance. The project was found to be categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to CEQA Guidelines 15303, which exempts the construction of new single-family residences.

1:17:33 The resolution makes the required variance findings and staff recommends approval of the variance. With that, that concludes my presentation. Are there any questions from the commission? Just, if you can just remind me, the change in 2014 that eliminated downsloping lots from the allowance to have five foot setbacks, that still applies to upsloping lots?

1:18:13 Correct. There still is an allowance for upsloping lots if they meet all the criteria. Okay. And the real rationale for keeping the upsloping lots was due to the cost to construct on upsloping lots with cutting into the hillside. Into the hillside? Did you have a question? I have a question for the contractor. Okay. So do you have the plan of the

1:18:55 Of the building with the site plan basically? Yes. I just wanted to clarify and just to see in front of us that the portion of the house that they're requesting the reduction in setback to five feet is for the single car portion of the garage only? Correct. So it's effectively 20 or so, 25, not even 25, 20 or so feet wide?

1:19:43 Not even. It's more like 10, 12 feet wide. Yeah, it's about 10 feet wide in this portion here of the interior space, so wall to wall would be about 11 to 12 feet. And just confirming that that is essentially what was in existence prior to the fire. Yes, it is. The only changes, they actually are, it's not shown on here, but on the building permits, proposing to pull the deck pierce.

1:20:16 Slightly back to the back of the property just to provide some additional snow storage areas there. Oh, so they want to increase their snow storage. Great. We don't hear that very often. Okay. Can you just talk a little bit about this particular property and being adjacent to the open space, the Mammoth Creek open space behind it?

1:20:46 Sure, so the area in the rear of this property backs up to their property, a small sliver that belongs to the Aspen Creek condominiums, and then you have the town multi-use path and Mammoth Creek. On that area, at least the Mammoth Creek portion has the open space corridor, and as anyone who's used that path knows, the area is largely undisturbed, with the exception of the path, and pushing the structure further back.

1:21:16 Would cause additional disturbance in that area adjacent to the open space area. Okay. Additionally, with the reuse of the foundation, it's not going to require additional grading or bringing equipment down into the lower portions of the property. Right. So they're essentially asking to reuse all of the existing foundations because any change to location of the structure would mean that.

1:21:49 They'd have to rebuild all their foundations. That's correct. Which is a significant portion of the expense of building, constructing any building. Okay. Any questions for staff? No? I would just like to clarify, if you could just clarify something for me. You said that the garage was how it was prior to the fire. Correct. So I just want to clarify, were there setbacks? Was it in the exact same place?

1:22:30 As it was before? Yes. The new plan is going to be in the exact same place as it was before. Correct. So it would have a five-foot setback for the portion of the garage that sticks further out, and then the next portion of the garage is approximately 20 feet from the property line, and the actual residence or habitable area is back here, which is approximately 36 feet from the property line. And the previous zoning code allowed a five-foot setback as of right?

1:22:58 Outright. Right. Because of the downsloping. Right. Nature of the lot. So they didn't have to go through a variance process previously for this because it was permitted. But since it changed, that's why we're doing this all over again. So they're not really changing anything. We just changed. Correct. So we have to go through the process. Yes. Because we changed the code. Just wanted to confirm that. Right. Is there anyone in the audience that would like to speak on this topic? I know you said that it sounded like.

1:23:33 Somebody might be coming to try to speak? I think it was the author of the letter that we walked through. So I think the commission can finish the public hearing. I mean, if there's any concerns, we can meet with the author after the meeting. Okay. And then with no additional comments from the public, we'll close the public hearing period.

1:24:05 Any deliberation up here? To me, this seems like, as Nolan mentioned earlier, the definition of a variance is very site-specific consideration. Site-specific, correct. And I think one thing in particular that differentiates this down-sloping lot from other down-sloping lots in the town that might be asking for the same thing is the adjacent open space and the town path behind it.

1:24:38 I think it makes a lot of sense for the owner to want to preserve that as much as possible as well as the fact that they would like to preserve their existing foundations. And I think allowing them to do so is reasonable and falls within our ability and within the code. Yeah, I drive right by this house every time I go to my house.

1:25:10 Okay. I've never seen anybody embedded in it. I've seen one car in 27 years off the side of the road there and it wasn't on this lot. Okay. That part of the argument, I suppose it's theoretically possible, but no more than any other icy street in Mammoth. So my gut feeling is I'm just glad that was their house that burned down, not mine. And if I was the one that was coming up here to rebuild my house and they told me that

1:25:39 I couldn't rebuild what I had before because my house burned down. I think that's just adding insult to injury. And anything we can do to help them get back on their feet, we should do. I think that puts it very nicely. Thank you, Greg. I echo Greg's sentiments on that one. Then I don't know that we need to have much more conversation up here. Can I make a motion? Absolutely. Okay. I'd like to make a motion to adopt the attached PDC resolution.

1:26:13 Making require sequel and municipal co-findings and approving variance 18-001. I'll second that. All right. Vote, please, Jamie. Commissioner Norris? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Ehner? Yes. Chair Callahan? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you. Okay. And with that, we'll move on to item number three, public hearing. To consider approval of the Mancineta Creek project,

1:26:45 Before I finish, Greg, we'll see you after this one's over. Greg has to recuse himself from this item, which is the Manzanita Creek Project tentative tract map 18-001, design review 18-001, and adjustment 18-001. For a five-unit condominium project located at 131 and 145 Manzanita Road, include...

1:27:09 Including finding the project categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to guidelines 15332 infill development projects. And Nolan will be presenting this one to us again. Great, thank you. And can the commission see the materials board and thing here? Do you prefer I hand them out? Yes, I can see it. Thanks. The Manzanita Creek project is a five-unit condominium project located on two parcels at 131 and 145 Manzanita Road.

1:27:44 The two parcels will be merged as part of the project. The project requires approval of a tentative tract map for the subdivision of the units into condos, design review for the exterior appearance of the structure, and an adjustment for a 20% reduction to the front, rear, and north side yard setbacks. The proposed setbacks would be 16 feet for the front and 8 feet for the rear and north side. The site has an existing town path along the southern boundary

1:28:14 And a seasonal drainage channel that crosses the site. The proposed project was found to be consistent with all of the applicable municipal code requirements for the RMF-1 zoning district and the supplemental multifamily project standards with the approval of the adjustment. The project is requesting approval of an adjustment for the setbacks and an allowance for the trash enclosure to be partially located within the front yard setback. Manzanita Road is a substandard street in this area.

1:28:46 With regards to width, and the town is requiring a 10-foot irrevocable offer of dedication along Manzanita Road, and as previously indicated, there is an existing drainage channel and town path along the southerly portion of the property, which renders approximately 25% of the site unusable, and the combination of those items severely reduces the size of the developable area of the site.

1:29:13 Here on the screen you have the IOD area here along Manzanita Road and the 16-foot setback request and then on this one shows the location of the drainage channel and then the edge of the parking and structure to the north of it. With the adjustments,

1:29:37 To the setbacks, the proposed project design fits within the site and avoids disturbance of the drainage channel area. The project is requesting the allowance for the trash enclosure to be partially within the front yard setback. The zoning code allows trash and propane tanks to be within the front setback if adequate screening and protection is provided. The enclosure will match architecturally with the building and will be screened on the west and south side through the planting of additional trees.

1:30:09 The propane tank will be protected from vehicles by the enclosure. The proposed location was chosen because it will have the least interference with snow removal and storage. This location was reviewed by Mammoth Disposal and indicated that the location is acceptable, but if given the option, they prefer a more direct path of travel. The conditions of approval indicate the final alignment of the enclosure is subject to review and approval by town staff and Mammoth Disposal.

1:30:39 Now it just slightly skew the trash enclosure and possibly the entrance but would not move it to another location. The design committee reviewed the project on March 18, 2018 and recommended minor changes to the project. The committee was supportive of moving the project forward to the commission upon staff's determination that the comments had been addressed. The recommended changes included wrapping the wood siding around to the north elevation to break up the building mass.

1:31:09 and incorporating faux chimneys on the roof to break up the mass of the roof and shield the roof vents from public view. Those changes have been incorporated into the design. The other changes that have occurred since the design committee reviewed the project is the board formed concrete. It is proposed to be core 10 steel. The metal roof will be a dark charcoal asphalt composition roof rather than metal.

1:31:34 Here on the rendering, these portions shown here kind of on the pop-out will be the core 10 steel rather than the board formed concrete. The roof material was changed because there were some concerns about snowshed encroaching under the neighbor's property and the asphalt comp roof will retain more of the snow on the roof whereas with the metal roof the snow would easily slide off. The staff report and the resolution further describes the project's consistency with the design guidelines.

1:32:06 The project was found to be categorically exempt from CEQA pursuant to Guideline Section 15332, which is the exemption for infill development projects. The project qualified for this exemption because it is consistent with the general plan. It is located on an approximately half acre parcel within town limits. Previous environmental studies done for the construction of the path found that the site had no value as habitat for endangered, rare, or threatened species.

1:32:34 The project is below maximum density and is required to conform to all requirements for noise, air quality, lot coverage and public work standards for drainage. Therefore, it will not impact traffic, noise, air quality or water quality. The site has all existing utilities adjacent to it and can be extended to the site and all public services can be provided. And finally, it was determined that none of the exceptions listed in CEQA guidelines section 15300.2 are applicable.

1:33:06 The required findings for the application include that the project is consistent with CEQA and the findings for the tentative tract map, design review, and adjustment can be met. The resolution makes the required CEQA state subdivision map act and municipal code findings and staff recommends approval of the project. With that, that's anything I have on this project. The developer for this, Mark Lehman, is present and can answer any questions that you have for him as well.

1:33:39 Would you like to say anything? If there's any questions. Okay. Any questions? I don't have any questions. Sorry. I don't have any questions. This was presented to me at the design committee, and I just wanted to make a comment that I appreciate you bringing this project forward and adding more housing into our community. So thank you. Any questions, Paul? No. Not on this one. Could you just explain the

1:34:12 The irrevocable offer of dedication again? Sure. That means exactly? The irrevocable offer of dedication for streets, no storage purposes, is to accommodate the substandard street policy that the town enacted a number of years ago. A number of streets in the Sierra Valley sites are of inadequate width to properly create a...

1:34:38 That's standard roadway of 24 feet wide. So they enacted a policy that requires staff to request at any time a project is developed, a 10-foot offer of dedication, so that eventually, someday in the future, the town can accept all these offers of dedication and build a street that meets town standards. Okay. So that effectively decreases the property size slightly, and then their setback...

1:35:07 would then start from that new line? Correct. But it doesn't, it's not a grant deed at this time? It's not a grant deed. It belongs to them, but it moves the start of their setback line? Correct. I do have a question on that. I understand that the town does not have to have 70 IODs if they don't want to. In this case, it is, however, you said it's required that the IOD

1:35:39 is being offered in this case, then that 10-foot area, who's going to maintain that space if the town doesn't want to accept this or in the event that the town does not accept the IOD? So the offer of dedication is just that it's an offer.

1:36:05 It cannot be revoked. So for the time being, the property still is under the control and ownership of the property owner until such time that the town executes the document. All land responsibility lies with the property owner. Thank you. I don't think I have any other questions. Does anyone from the public would like to speak or ask questions about this item? Okay. Well then,

1:37:06 We'll close the public hearing portion and then any final comments, deliberation up here? Jen, it sounded like you said your piece. I said what I had to say. I'm excited for a couple more units of housing to be in this town because we greatly need it. The trail that's been taken over by the town or by the four sales? The town currently has an easement for that trail as it is. So the town maintains that trail.

1:37:44 We have an easement for it. Currently the easement actually is over the entire property. The easement doesn't define where the trail is. So as part of the tentative map, we clearly define what portion of the property has the trail easements that benefits the town and that we know where it is and benefits the property owner and that he knows what area he can't touch. And I'm assuming that's going to happen sooner than later or we have no timeline as to.

1:38:15 So the trail exists now as a soft surface trail. And correct me if I'm wrong, Hayes, there's no improvements proposed for that in the near future. We don't currently plan to make any additional improvements. We did install a culvert and aggregate base and grayed out the path. I want to say that was about six or seven years ago to provide the access to that part, to the shady rest parcel from.

1:38:46 Manzanita. The HOA property owner, they don't have to maintain this section? No. Right. Okay. I see. It's the town's responsibility. Right. And the final easement will be recorded with the final map as defining that clearly that the 20-foot section. Okay. So that will happen at the time of the final map? Correct. Final map. Okay. All right. Okay. And I just want to ask the applicant

1:39:15 That they have read and understand and agree to all of the conditions of approval? Yes. Okay. May I make a motion? Absolutely. Okay. I'll make a motion to adopt PDC resolution, making it require CEQA, State Subdivision Map Act, and Muni Code findings, and approving tentative tract map 18-001, design review 18-001, and adjustment 18-001. I'll second that.

1:39:50 All right. Jamie, vote please. Commissioner Burroughs? Yes. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Chair down. Yes. Motion passes 3-0 with 1 abstention or recusal. Thank you very much. I wish you luck. I think it would be a nice addition to the street and the neighborhood. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Our next item is a business matter, the Unmet Transit Needs Workshop.

1:40:24 And John Helm from Eastern Sierra Transit Authority will be presenting. Good afternoon, Commissioners. John Helm, Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. I don't have any visuals for this one. I appreciate the opportunity to spend just a few minutes with the Commission this afternoon. The Mono County Local Transportation Commission conducts a community outreach process each year to gauge

1:40:55 Potential unmet transit needs within Mono County. They conduct this process through RPAC meetings in the various communities throughout Mono County. Some years in the past, because the LTC meets in Mammoth Lakes and because that body conducts an unmet transit needs hearing process, it has been considered that that is the process and the outreach that's conducted within the Mammoth Lakes area.

1:41:22 On other years, and this is an example of that, the LTC has directed and requested that a separate process and opportunity for residents and visitors to Mammoth Lakes to comment on unmet transit needs be conducted in conjunction with the Mobility Commission or currently the Planning and Economic Development Commission, which is what we're doing here this afternoon. Just as a quick reminder or recap for the commissioners,

1:41:51 The state requires, with the use of state funding, that transit planning agencies and within Mono County, that is the LTC, conduct a process to reach out to the community to determine if there are unmet transit needs. If the transit planning agency is not using transit funds for other than transit uses, for example, roads and bridges, there isn't a technical legal requirement to have an unmet transit needs hearing.

1:42:21 The LTC thinks it's a good practice and I support that as well to reach out on at least an annual basis to each of the communities and determine if there are unmet needs. This has been taking place throughout this spring. In fact, there was a preliminary presentation of the findings from those sessions to the LTC this past Monday. The final report will be presented next month at the LTC meeting for consideration and adoption by that body.

1:42:50 as to whether there are unmet transit needs and whether those are going to be addressed and met. The other process is just because someone at one of these public outreach meetings

1:43:05 Raises a comment and says, I would like to be able to go from A to B on transit, and it doesn't exist now, doesn't necessarily mean that that's going to be fulfilled and funded. There's a process to determine whether or not such requests are reasonable to meet, and there are things, whether there are resources available to meet it, whether the service would be likely to be cost efficient, and they measure that by meeting the minimum 10% fare box recovery ratio so that

1:43:34 Fares would cover 10% of the operating costs of whatever service. And also that there are existing Transportation Development Act funds, state transit funds available for the purpose. And it can be a matter of a zero-sum game. Basically in Mono County now, all of the TDA funds are used and being used currently for transit. And if there are expansions of service, that can mean that

1:44:00 Some other service might have to be cut back or reduced in order to fund some new service. So these are all of the factors that the LTC uses in weighing whether or not a request is reasonable to meet or not. Like I say, the preliminary results matrix was presented to the LTC this past Monday, and the second Monday of May, I'm not sure what date that is, will be the next LTC meeting.

1:44:27 And the final report will be presented for consideration at that time. So that's a little background on what the unmet needs process is, but the goal of this session is to receive any input from the community that there may be regarding potential unmet transit needs in the area.

1:44:50 Don't all jump up at once. All right. When you say the unmet area, you're talking about the town only, or are you talking about countywide? I mean, yeah, countywide. Countywide. Countywide. Countywide. Right. Okay. John, when you were in earlier, there was talk about the Old Mammoth Run not going all the way to the end of Old Mammoth. Right. And what degree of...

1:45:19 I think there are at least two issues that you may be addressing there. One is just routine transit service for that area.

1:45:49 And currently the buses can't and don't go beyond Snow Creek Athletic Club because there's not an adequate place to turn around, except for Red Fur, and there's been contention about whether or not buses should be allowed on Red Fur Drive. So that's been the big challenge there.

1:46:07 We are working and moving ever closer to a long-term solution to that by developing a turnaround, a bus turnaround at Old Mammoth Road and Woodman so that the bus, routine buses, Redline in the winter and the town trolleys the rest of the year would provide regular frequent service, fixed drought service to the area out to the turnaround at Woodman. The other matter is

1:46:31 As I understand it, there has been a request in the past for access to recreation from the way upper parts of Old Mammoth Road, Laverne Drive, basically, and Old Mammoth Road. That is a separate issue, I think. That's not something that I believe warrants or merits 20-minute frequency, seven days a week, 365 days a year.

1:46:57 Likewise, there's an issue with infrastructure in terms of inadequate turnaround in that area, but it is something that Walk, Bike, Ride and some of the other programs are looking at on a longer term perspective to try to develop to bring in. But that would be, in my view, a much less frequent service to service a specific recreation demand. Did I answer your question? Well, what I was actually getting is help. Obviously, there's not enough to make you do it now.

1:47:27 So is it something that is, we have a third of the demand we need, we have 1% of the demand we need? I think that it's, again, and I don't want to deflect the question, but I think it's a bigger, the recreation access matter is a bigger question than just transit, because it's access to recreation and is the community, is Mammoth Lakes Recreation going to expand opportunities in that area, which would...

1:47:57 Create expanded demand for transit and that ideally all of those things would work together and we would address that. That planning process and demand estimation has not been completed in my understanding, but it's not for a lack of interest in the future and it's clearly articulated in documents such as walk, bike and ride and I think staying on a number of people's radar. Has your current working group?

1:48:28 Identifies any major unmet needs? I would answer that no, but the key word in your question was major? Correct. Yes. I would say no. I'm not aware of and I've not, nothing's been brought to my attention that I would.

1:48:51 Classify that. I will mention there were a couple of comments made at the LTC meeting on Monday that we're considering and taking a look at. One was to expand or improve the capabilities, bilingual capabilities of the dialer ride service in Mammoth Lakes to improve transit opportunities.

1:49:14 For individuals with limited English proficiency. And we're taking a look at that. I mean, that could be an unmet need. That could be preventing individuals from accessing basic life necessities if they can't use a service because they can't communicate with the dialeride service. Another comment was raised regarding increased frequency of service between Mammoth Lakes and Bishop. The comment was made, increasingly there are

1:49:43 More employees having to find housing in the Owens Valley and the Bishop area. Currently, there are four round trips a day weekdays, which is a pretty good level of service on the weekdays, but there is no public service on Saturday or Sunday, and that was part of the request that a lot of employees either work in the service sector on weekends, or if they want to access recreation in the Mammoth Lakes area,

1:50:12 But may not have an opportunity on public transit. So that is another potential unmet need that we're taking a look at that would affect the Mammoth Lakes area. I'm assuming that because it's a separate county, you can't simply just make that decision yourself. Well, the Mono County LTC could make a determination that it is an unmet need because there isn't any service.

1:50:42 That could be determined that the ridership would provide the 10% minimum fair box amount and some of those other things. But it would be likely to be coordinated with the Inyo County LTC as well as a need there. Thank you. Anyone from the public like to come up? Good afternoon.

1:51:12 Stacy Corliss, this time speaking as a member of the Board of Supervisors representing District 5 here in Mammoth. And I do, John already mentioned it, but I do want to state for the record that I think transit in Old Mammoth, west of Snow Creek Athletic Club, is an unmet need given the limited status of the current transit in place. I know a solution is in the works, but this does impact.

1:51:38 Children and seniors, people with limited access to transit. So we need to find a permanent long-term solution that works for our community out there. And I know there's concern from residents of Red Fur about the turnaround at Woodman and getting their kids there to meet to the school bus or some kind of public transit. So no easy solution out there, I know. Okay. Thank you, Stacey. Thanks. Thank you. I think, is there anyone else? Jennifer?

1:52:12 Good afternoon, Jennifer Halfordy, community member, and I am here to talk about the Purple Line. So I live in the Sierra Valley Sites, home of, well, the Purple Line is an expansive route. It goes all over Mammoth. It hits by the schools, the library, the hospital. It goes through Sierra Valley Sites, Vons, up to the

1:52:41 Village, so, and it's the only year-round route, as far as I can tell, in Mammoth. And if you know anything about the Sierra Valley sites, it is really populated, densely populated, which works really well with transit when you have a lot of people, and especially low-income people and seasonal employees that don't always bring a car.

1:53:06 One of the things that I'm here to request is that I think that route needs another line, or not another line, but another bus, because right now it's only every 30 minutes, so that's twice an hour, but I think it's the highest used route, at least certainly highly used from when I use it and what I see.

1:53:30 So I would request that that route be increased to every 20 minutes, so three times an hour. As I said, that is a high-low-income concentrated area with a lot of families and children, but also people without cars, as I mentioned. So I think it hits all of the major necessities, which is a criteria for a lack of need or for...

1:54:00 I can't remember exact terminology but why there might be missing services that includes medical, dental, social services, shopping, schools, food and the library. So it really does encompass everything that we're talking about if there is a lack of service or a shortage of service I would say.

1:54:21 I also want to just make a couple of other comments. The e-comment was not up for this meeting, so I'm making a presentation for somebody who couldn't come or a public comment for somebody who couldn't make it and couldn't make an e-comment on Granicus today. The yellow line. So this person lives in that area. The yellow line is only a winter service, so there's no bus service. Can you remind us? Yeah.

1:54:48 The yellow line is over by Chair 15, Majestic Pines, Kelly Road, that area. They only have service in the winter, and then they're high and dry the rest of the year. That's it. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you. Tom Hodges, VP of Development for Mammoth Mountain, but I'm actually here speaking as president of the Sierra Star West Community Association. I'm president of the board.

1:55:20 And that association oversees Sierra Star Parkway in West Bear Lake Road in Sierra Star, right in the middle of Sierra Star. And at our last association meeting, the homeowners, so we're, the association, there's members of all the individual condo associations there, so there's the woodwinds, I always want to say sunstone, not sunstone. Solstice. Solstice, thank you. Great fun. The home, yeah, the homes that,

1:55:50 John Hooper developed, and then the future hotel that'll be there. So I'm speaking on behalf of those landowners or property owners, and they're strongly requesting that you consider adding a stop at the intersection of Minaret and West Bear Lake, East Bear Lake. And maybe it can be accommodated on the existing route that just goes on Minaret Road between Meridian and Main Street. It could be accommodated.

1:56:18 And again, there's also, I'm not speaking on behalf of the homeowners, but you know, there's 35 new homes across the street now on the east side of Sierra Star as well, and just anecdotally, John Hooper mentioned me, yeah, his homeowners are expressing that interest as well. So it seems like a logical place in as much, particularly, well, year-round really, but summertime when you have the, at least there'll be some, you know, the Shakespeare Festival, there's the potential winter festival that'll be happening this coming year.

1:56:48 And as well as the Arts and Crafts Festival, I think are the permitted events for that site that Mr. Winters owns, Sam Woods, the former Sam Woods site. So I think there's some other greater public interest in that as well. And I think another angle on it potentially as well is, you know, discussions about parking opportunities for the village. In particular, there's a challenge for employee parking in the village.

1:57:16 The shoulders of Minaret Road coming down from Main Street actually are unrestricted parking on the shoulders there and could be a good solution to provide parking for employees in the village. And so, you know, having a bus stop, you know, preferably in both directions would provide an opportunity for people to park down there, be able to hop the bus to get up because there is a little bit of a gray, you know, hill going up on Minaret as you get up to the village there.

1:57:43 So anyway, just would suggest that you consider that it might be able to be accommodated on, you know, one or two of the existing routes, depending on the season, I suppose. Great. Thank you. Thank you very much. Tom? Well, unless there are any other questions, I also will mention that I have made notes on all the comments that have been received today, as is the case with all the RPAC meetings as well, and all the comments are submitted to the LTC members for their consideration. So there is a process that

1:58:19 The public input is documented and part of the record. Great. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. John, before you leave, I just wanted to let the Commission know that this is likely the last time that you'll see John Helm here as the Eastern Sierra Transit Director, Executive Director. Yes. As you're retiring in the next month, correct? Yes. Oh, my goodness. Congratulations.

1:58:43 Let the Commission know that and thank you for your service and I've really appreciated working with you and wish you best of luck on future endeavors. Thanks, Sandra, and thanks to the Commission. It's always been a pleasure. Thank you. Thank you for all your hard work. All right. All right. Our next item is regarding the Mammoth Lakes Trail System naming conventions. Staff would like to request continuance of that item to the next meeting. Okay.

1:59:17 We will continue this to the next meeting and move on to our consent agenda, which consists of minutes from our previous meeting, March 2018. I make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Can you say that a little louder? I'm sorry. I make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. All right, motion passes 3-0.

1:59:46 All right, that wraps up all of the official business. We have individual commissioner reports. Greg, do you want anything to... No, I've not done a lot, so I haven't really done anything here. Okay. I just have a comment about the trash that we have directly below us in this complex. Right in front of a Starbucks and just this whole walking area.

2:00:18 I took a couple photos over the weekend and I said, wow, this is what our tourists see. It's not very pleasant when you walk by that particular area. I walked by earlier today, it was better, but I'll be happy to forward you the photos. I think the property owner needs to do a better job on maintaining

2:00:49 A visible location like this. Well, thank you. That's a good comment. That's all I have. Okay. Thank you. Thanks, Paul. Let's see. We have had a few design committee meetings. I have it. I have it right here, too. Go ahead, Jen. Would you like to talk about our design committee meetings? Thanks, Sandra. Okay. So we had a committee meeting.

2:01:22 She says here that we approved it on March 6th, but we've had a design committee meeting since then, but I can't remember the exact date on that, do you? No. March 27th. March 27th. Okay, so we reviewed a single family residence plan up in the Bluffs, and it's going to be a beautiful home. We also reviewed the layout of that five unit condo, which was

2:01:50 Exciting to see a new housing project in town. And I'm glad it's moving forward because I think it'll benefit quite a few people. And it'll be a nice addition to that street. It'll make it prettier. Let's see. We also met with Matthew Lehman to discuss the artwork on the grocery outlet. And we've really been struggling with this the last few months, just trying to find

2:02:19 Some artwork that represented our community in lieu of windows and I think that we've made some progress this time and I look forward to seeing what the artist has to bring back and we also reviewed the design for 160 Commerce Street from Mr. Calvert who is the applicant and he was just adding on kind of a

2:02:48 Yes, just a couple items.

2:03:19 Vice Chair Vanderhurst, seats on the commission will be up at the end of July, I think. And so, yeah, so just a notice on kind of the procedures for that, we published these vacancies in the paper. We would encourage you both to apply for that, those vacancies. The applications are due on June 11th.

2:03:44 For the vacancies on the commission. And then the council schedules interviews on the 20th. And approximately on July 18th, they would conduct the interviews and appoint the members to the Planning and Economic Development Commission. After that, usually at your first meeting in August is when you choose the chair, vice chair, those types of things, appointments to committees. So once the members are appointed, then you would, at your following meeting, choose the vice chair and chair.

2:04:11 And committees. So just a note on that. It's a little ways away, but coming up. Also a note on the candidates forum. I wanted to provide you with information. We just found out that the...

2:04:24 The Rotary Group is going to be providing a candidates forum. It would be Monday, April 30th at 530 here in Suite Z. So they will have a forum for the Mono County Superintendent of Schools, Town Council candidates, and Supervisor Districts 1 and 5. So I just wanted to make you aware of that and encourage you to attend if you'd like.

2:04:49 And then the chamber has also scheduled a meet and greet the following day, Tuesday, May 1st, which will provide people the opportunities to have kind of one-on-one discussions with the candidates. The forum is really intended to be kind of a quick summary of the candidates' positions, those types of things. And then Tuesday, May 1st would be more, you know, if you wanted to talk to the candidates about their viewpoints or anything. So any questions on that?

2:05:16 And then the only other items, I had just a couple updates on development activities in town. We will be issuing a building permit for a remodel at Canyon Lodge, which will be taking place over this summer. It sounds like the mountain is going to be doing it in two phases, so the first phase would be completed this summer and with the intent of having it open.

2:05:39 in the winter. And then the second phase would be conducted next summer. The grocery outlet, we issued the building permit for the shell of the building.

2:05:48 And then we're in plan check right now for the tenant improvements, which is all the interior work of the building. So we'll likely see some construction activity kind of pick back up on that site shortly. And Starbucks, we think that the approval for the exterior work at Starbucks is in the next week or so. We'll be issuing the building permit for that. And then we're anticipating the...

2:06:14 Submittal for the interior work at Starbucks soon, which would be issued as soon as it makes it through that process. So there's some construction activity that's going to be kind of occurring in our downtown area this summer, and it should be exciting to see those projects move forward. Is there any questions on any projects or anything? Michael had mentioned last time that if we will have the opportunity to hear about a canyon design, is that just an architectural design? It's all interior work.

2:06:44 So it's just a building permit. So there isn't, it wouldn't come to commission unless at some point there's changes to the exterior of the building. Why would they do that? He wanted you to try me. We actually went through a review with the Forest Service. So keep in mind that Canyon Lodge is within our permit boundary on Forest Service lands.

2:07:14 So it's not subject to design review by the town, but we separately went through design review, so to speak, NEPA review with the Forest Service. So it effectively was just, it was approved at a ministerial level. There is a slight change to the exterior. We're going to add, we're going to expand the entry into the building with a little pop-out to

2:07:40 We also have to accommodate

2:08:08 Handicap parking, ADA accessibility, which will require regrading of the whole front portion of the parking lot that's up the first kind of 100, 150 feet from the building, sort of where the drop-off zone is, and so we're going to formalize a transit stop with the raised curb and island, and then also our sort of parallel drop-off zone across the front of the building, so some new flat work and all new asphalt.

2:08:35 And regrading to accommodate the ADA parking that will be up against the bank where it is today. So that's essentially the extent of the first phase. And then the second phase of the project is quite extensive. It would include pretty extensive renovations of the interior spaces, including the lockers, the third floor lobby, a repositioning of the bar.

2:09:04 And then pretty much, at least right now at the moment, this got, you know, subject to fine-tuning budgets and so forth, we're looking at a full renovation of the fourth floor. That would, new kitchen, new food court, and new restrooms that don't exist today on the fourth floor. So, it's a very, very exciting project. We think it's going to have a huge impact on our guests' experience, very positively, we think.

2:09:30 You know, we're talking about spending over 15 million bucks. So it's a large project. Wow. Will you be upgrading the rest in the restrooms? Yeah. Yeah, yeah. The whole building's... We'll become... You know, we have to address accessibility to the whole building. Okay. And so we actually have done a couple of restrooms in the past to create accessibility, but we'll have to fully vet all those out to meet all current building code requirements. So, yeah. So it's going to be a pretty exciting renovation. This is going to be...

2:10:00 Upgraded look and feel to it for sure and I think a lot, you know, real exciting ideas for the fourth floor with respect to the food court and the food service up there. Great. So, yeah. Will the mountain bike trails coming out of Canyon still be usable in the summertime? Yeah. You won't be able to come bombing down next to, like, ski patrol from the bottom of Chair 16. They'll have to...

2:10:28 We would probably, you know, obviously we'll put appropriate construction barricades and controls in, but to come down, I forget the name of the trail that comes down by Osterhoff at the bottom of the parking lot, that would still be accessible, so there'll be ways around it one way or the other, but the focus of that work will be, you know, we'll likely barricade off the parking area where the work obviously is going to be, you know, under construction, so. Can I have some competition with the condos across the street? Yeah, right, right. Top of Rainbow, John Hooper's project.

2:10:58 I mean, we won't be inhibiting access along up Rainbow and up to Lakeview and Davidson. That'll all be open. It'll just be the immediate area of the parking lot. So, okay. Amber, as long as I'm here, real quick, so they're a big, exciting project. We're constructing this summer as a zip line off the top of the mountain. I heard that. You could not be any enough to go on. Does it go off, like, where Climax is? Yeah.

2:11:26 Up there? Yes. So you'll walk out, you'll exit the gondola out through where, you know, where you come out to ski in there, but you'll just keep going through the ski patrol room, or that's the ski patrol room now. You'll exit out a door there off on a gantry onto the launch ramp, and you'll be fitted up. There's going to be two parallel lines, so two people can go at once, and you'll, the first span will go from top of Climax all the way down to the top of the knoll adjacent to Chair 1.

2:11:55 And then you'll have to come down from the landing tower, short path to the second launch. It'll be just at the break over of that knoll, you know, just west of Gravy Chute there. And that span will go all the way down and land next to the gondola building at the bottom. So, you know, speeds in excess of 50 miles an hour, 55 miles an hour, something like that to be, you know, worked out in the fine tuning of the ride at the end. And you'll be able to ride in two positions, either in a seated harness.

2:12:24 Which will be a little more pedestrian, or you can ride Superman in a prone position. So, yeah, it'll be pretty exciting. Just, you know, we have a lot of winds up there. Will that impact it at all? There'll be parameters, yeah, that we wouldn't operate over certain wind speeds for sure. There'll be anonometers on the towers and stuff. We'll keep track of all that. Very rigorous operating requirements. We'll be updating permits from the state DOSH office.

2:12:52 They administer all amusement rides as well as the Forest Service and their tramway engineer. So, yeah, it's all very, very regulated and a lot of detailed operating parameters that women's safety regulations will be following, of course. It freaks me out just riding the gondola up there because there's that big drop, but I think it's going to be pretty cool. I know my kids will love to do that. That sounds cool. It'll definitely be an attraction.

2:13:19 Yeah, you know, certainly going to get some exciting, you know, interest, I'm sure, out there. There'll be a lot of interest across the state. Would there be a victim actuated break? What's that? Would there be a victim actuated break? No, no, it actually is. The rider doesn't have to break in any shape or form. It's all automatic.

2:13:42 It's got a magnetic eddy current trolley that kind of does limit top speeds and then controls the speed at which you come into the landing and there's some automatic braking elements as you come into the landing to control your braking and stopping to the platform. So all very, very safe and no rider skill required. Do you anticipate that being open at all during this? Yeah, I'm sorry. So our schedule is to have it open for Labor Day weekend.

2:14:12 And then we would operate it for the month of September. And, yeah, it depends on business levels. We might extend that, it depends. But we would not operate it in the wintertime. Right, yeah. In fact, we're actually going to, we're designing the ride so we can take the lines down during the winter. I was going to ask if the cables stay or. Yeah, there's a lot of issues that presents for winter operations that we have to remove the cables. Avalanche control. Yeah. Between icing issues and also it conflicts with our avalanche control program, so.

2:14:41 Okay. Well, awesome. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks. Exciting and scary. All right. So our next meeting is on May 9th. Do we know if everyone's going to be here? I haven't heard that anyone's going to be absent from May 9th. I have to get back to you. My eighth grader has a field trip to LA that I'm supposed to chaperone, and it's around that time. I can't remember exactly what days. So I'll get back to you now. Okay. So then,

2:15:11 Barring any other unusual circumstances, we will adjourn to the next meeting to be held on Wednesday, May 9th at 2 o'clock p.m. here. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you.