TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2018

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 54 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

617 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Mammoth Lakes Town Council, and Kim, you're super happy over there, right? Yes. All set together? Yes, okay. So let's, we have a roll call of the council members. Councilmember Fernie? Here. Councilmember Richardson? Here. Councilmember Salser? Hapsent. Councilmember Hoff? Here. Mayor John Wentworth? Here. Thank you very much. So, we'll have a budget workshop.

0:31 Great to have everybody here. And it's Rob or Dan. Who's up? I think that Rob will kick it off and then do the process. Excellent. And just for the purpose of the public, we're going to, there will be a couple breaks during the presentation for public comments. Certainly, council members, if you have any questions, we'll deal with those as we go through this. And so there'll be a couple opportunities for public comment or thoughts as we go through the items. So, Rob. Yes, thank you.

1:02 So we are continuing the process that we started on the 21st of March with our revenue projections. This process here is the preliminary budget, which is our department requested budget. Staff report goes through extensive links about the process that we've used for the numbers. And today we're going to talk about what we have today and where we are through the process.

1:33 Kind of got a good jumpstart, I think, on the budget process this year, being my second year into it, and I feel like we're in pretty good shape for where we are. We do have a bit of a shortfall. I mean, expenditures are exceeding revenue, as you can see on the screen there, about $132,000. That's not uncommon for the stage of the process as we go through this.

1:57 The way this is structured, I will talk about some general items, Dan will talk about some general items to cover the basics to introduce a lot of the budget parts. As we get to some of the key department areas, and you're going to hear from each of the department heads as we walk through briefly items about their budget. Sandra's not here, so Tom's going to cover the building department and I'll be covering the rest of her departments.

2:23 I mean, discussion, but it's really just an opportunity for you guys to ask questions, I think, of the department heads around the requests that they're making of you. As we go through the rest of it, we are going to talk about, as I said, we're a little bit further ahead, and we usually are on the preliminary ledger. We have gas tax to talk about, some measure of our review, and just a few more departments that we have for preliminary. And at the end, I have a slide that has a series of policy questions. We kind of try to.

2:50 Highlight some of the things as we walk through this process, but then as we get to the end, we'll have really things that we need and put the direction on. And so we've really got those two at the end, and I'm hoping we get through this very quickly. Like I said, not an intensive discussion, but please ask questions while we've got close to date. Good. Thank you. So, what you see on the first slide here in the beginning, this is the general fund.

3:20 We do have a refresher on the revenue side.

3:50 We talked about adding a million dollars to the TOT budget this year and really bifurcating that into two sections. We have the baseline, which is the operating TOT at 12.5 million, which is no increase over last year, same number, conservative number. And then as we normally take the TOT excess of a year, we've had over the last two years, we've enjoyed excess of some TOT revenue. We've been able to do some one-time things with those, one-time things with those.

4:18 For this process, we've carved out that $1 million and we want to treat it the same way. So we're looking at the revenue that we have there at $13.5. That $1 million is carved out not only here, but in the expenditures. So when we go out through those, you'll see those. Because I needed to set them aside so that they don't get used in the overall operations. But again, as you look through just a quick review of the major revenue components, a slight decrease of around $42,000, but otherwise we're spot on. We still have

4:46 Process wise, we're still going through data collection and review and analysis. So information is coming to us and as it does come to us, we make adjustments to these, but again, not something substantial. So any questions on the revenue before we go? Nope. All right. So the first slide here is a little hard to read, but in front of you it's a little easier. Decided to take the departments for basically the general fund.

5:16 And list them out, showing what the requested budget is in total this year, and a percentage of the total overall budget that it represents, and then an analysis of what last year's adopted budget was. So when we started last year, I'm going to start current fiscal year, 17, 18, that's our adopted budget before any changes were made to it. And really for comparison purposes, apples for apples.

5:44 And then you can see the variance next to that. And that's kind of what we're going to dive into when we look at information in the next couple of slides and certainly with the department discussions. You'll notice I'll call it out here. The transfers out with a significant increase of 22%. That's where I held side the funds of the extra million that we did. So it's really just a placeholder for the most part and not a lot of access. Maybe we'll get to that detail.

6:13 Real quick, general services. What's that? The previous, yeah, that one, department 416 general services, the variance at 323. How much, what is general services? So general services is expenses within our offices that are not tied directly to a specific department. So it really crosses all of those. And that particular line item is a significant savings in the insurance. So CGPIA gives us the insurances for the...

6:41 For the years, and what we believe is something about three years ago fell off, if you will, but it lowered our insurance significantly, and that's what's in that line of it. Okay, cool, thank you. Workers coffees within the departments, but this would be general liability, property, promotion, just some basic ones like that. Next thing that we see is you go through the departments, when I show the department slides, you're going to see some details.

7:11 It's broken down into payroll and other department expenses. So I kind of want to use this slide to talk the most about payroll side. And there'll be one other element that the department heads can talk about, and that's really allocation of time. But in looking at this, and this is no additional increase in bodies or headcount, if you will. This is our existing folks. And the salary top line would be the wage. That's going up 3.85%.

7:41 That's a mixture of, there's a 2% COLA that takes effect on July 1. So that's, you know, 2% of that number, essentially. And then the rest of it would be folks who are working their way through the salary levels and schedule as they learn and gain experience and they increase that until they're capped out. So that would be the merit increases as well as that 2% COLA, but the majority would be 2% COLA. But so that top line item just being salaries alone,

8:11 And then the benefits are the ones that are broken down below. And I wanted to show the benefits broken out as they are. So classic would be a PERS classification of folks that were prior to the Reformation Act, I think it was 2013 or 2013, where PEPRA, go ahead. That's fine, yeah, it's that 12, 13 year when the legislature changed the status.

8:36 And classified either somebody in a classic status, basically you've been in the program prior. PEPRA stands for, but it's basically being hired after that. And there's a different formula. They took a lot of the authority away from local agencies to restructure those then and said, this is where you will now be from a state law perspective. And again, that was done in trying to get a handle on some of the PERS unfunded liabilities.

9:03 At the state level as much as across all the various agencies. So that's basically without affecting existing employees. Yeah, held harmless at this point going forward. So anyway, you'll see a lot of discussions between the different categories, classic and PEPRA, and then we have two categories within the town of miscellaneous employees and safety employees. And so those are standard definitions and discussions you'll see throughout.

9:32 The different budget processes and stuff as it goes into the developments. Rob, can I walk you back one slide for a clarification? Sure. So bottom right corner, we've got a total general fund variance of $1925.121, 9% increase. The vast majority comes in the transfer route, which you already articulated. The line below that, the subtotal increase, the $677.4.

9:58 Is it fair to say that, you know, that's kind of the net general cost increase department-wise from last year to 18-19, or excuse me, 17-18 to 18-19? The vast majority of that is if we have no headcount change, that's just additional costs that we incur, mostly health, retirement, et cetera. That's correct. And you'll see a piece of that in the tourism and the transit side also, some of the couple of transfers out in there. Sure.

10:30 Okay, so typically net no change. We're still looking at a $500,000 to $600,000 personnel cost increase. The personnel cost was around $500,000. Okay. $1 million carve out and we kept the commitments to it. Transit. Up above that line in the 677 is the tourism. Yep. So that $180,000 in the line right above that is the portion of that million. Sure. So if you take that out, then you're really down to $500,000.

11:11 The net effect is based upon that and certainly by the insurance reduction for the year. Otherwise, you're spot on with that. It's right about that. 540 is just an annual Y over Y personnel cost increase. And again, this year that was given part of that cold comparison. Sure. I think if we look at this, we continue to look at how do we come forward with a very conservative approach to our budget, both on the revenue side, as we touched on in the previous meeting, as well as again here.

11:43 We're not seeing wild, you know, increases on that based on even the last couple of good years. So we want to keep that relatively conservative. And on the staffing side this year, we did have discussions internally and some departments will kind of say where they're at tonight and stuff. But the direction of myself on the front of that was not to add new bodies this year, seeing where we were at.

12:10 Holding that line at this point, we'll talk about how we're adding capacity in some part-time positions, but I don't think we're ready. Last year we added two positions, one in the police department and one shared between parks and public works, and so this year the direction was not to come in with a bunch of body requests, because frankly, given the conservative nature of the revenue side and some other unknowns, there would not be a recommendation really from my perspective.

12:38 And so the discussion you guys are having, I'm looking at the staff report on page four, second paragraph from the bottom. These are the numbers that are the data behind the second paragraph from the bottom that talks about just the annual cost increases with no net gain in staff. This is what happens pretty much easier.

13:03 That's the net year-over-year thing that we need to be anticipating. Sorry, I'm sorry. Again, from that bit of a COLA this year, it may not happen every year. That's a negotiations issue. Sure. COLA is that. And each one of these fees, as you walk through, the different ones, they come to us. I don't believe this is a static sort of increase on a manual basis. There's some problems throughout the process, but there'll be some discussion on an annual basis that these things go up.

13:28 The first being my second year and doing it and really having that good historical what reference did these guys usually increase at would be, you know, we'll gain them. Sounds good. Thank you both. Yep. So first assignment, if you talked about classic and HEPRA, the miscellaneous employees and safety. Safety is only the police department and everybody else is only the miscellaneous employees. Those categories, I'm showing you the percentages like classic miscellaneous employee of 11.56. That's the percentage of the employees' cost.

13:58 For the pound for that particular item. So, for retirement for a classic, this lens plays 11.56% of their annual salary. And you can see the comparison of those showing, for the most part, they climbed about 4.5 to 4% through the curves, both classic and PEPRA, with the exception of the safety for PEPRA, which is only 1.24%. Unfunded liability, that's the, that's

14:28 The delta between the actual cost it will take from the retirement of these employees and what's being calculated from contributions that we provide and then earnings that CalPERS makes with their investments. It's kind of a three-legged process. They do investments with an expected rate of return. It was 7.75%. But they've been

14:53 Missing those for a few years, and so they're trying to back them down, but they cannot back them down quickly to a lower level because it would bankrupt us all, because it's really, you know, an intricate balance. So this unfunded viability is designed to make that up, and that increases, as you can see, it's fairly significant on average, about 10% this last year. So those are some significant numbers, and so roughly about 1.6, 1.7 million that will pay this year in that unfunded liability.

15:23 And real quick, is this the, when we talk about the unfunded liability of the town, is that represented in here, or is this just what we're dealing with year over year to try to? Year over year, I mean, it's in the budget in there in the PERS cost. So what we do on the PERS is, as Rob mentioned, the three pieces of that. You have the town share, which is noted in here in the 5% each. Employees also have a percent that they pay their check, either it's 8% or 9% or 11% for PD that they pay.

15:52 And then the unfunded, what PERS did a couple years ago was they used to just roll this into one rate, so this would be like 18% instead of 11%. Instead of doing a percentage, they came back and said because of the salary volatility, said you're going to pay 1.x million or whatever our share is. And so that's the flat dollar amount now, so it doesn't matter what our employee base or what our salaries go up and down on for that unfunded liability.

16:19 And that ties in, I think, if you look, and this all ties back to the actuaries, actuaries, that PERS will do, and say, if everybody in your agency who's eligible is to retire, you know, they plan that out and they live X, this is what your unfunded liability would be. And that number ranges somewhere between 14, 15 million, depending on what assumptions you make on the earnings rate that PERS utilizes.

16:47 We pay this on an annualized basis and it comes through and I say a couple years ago a purpose changed that to basically take that in front of liability and put it back on the agencies because before if your salary didn't grow or you cut back on staff that piece of the allocation would go down accordingly. It's now a fixed cost regardless of what you do in your own side. Now every year it gets looked at again and it can go up and down based on that as well. That's a little bit of a conversation for another day probably. Yeah.

17:16 Yeah, it's a big nut and it's an important cost of a employee if you want. Okay, thanks. Yeah, I've gotten down to the health insurance. There's three categories. We have a single employee, an employee and a spouse, employee plus one, if you will, and an employee and a family, like two or more. And these are the rates, these are the annual costs of insuring those different entities. As you can see, the employee alone went up almost 11% this year, but the other two were being the same.

17:47 Worker's Conf, one of that, one of 11%. So all these numbers together, really just to talk about, we do know we have payroll increases, where is it coming from, and try to be transparent about that. When you look at the department level detail that we're going to talk about a little bit later, you'll see the healthcare, you'll see these impacts of cost on employees, and you'll see movement there. You'll also see when there's significant dollar changes, sometimes it's when

18:16 We've made different allocations of time. So, for example, some of the departments, primarily like Stuart Grady, who have people that work within different areas, from snow removal to maintenance to, I mean, they can decide how much time is spent in each one of those categories. And so it'll be a fluctuation in the salary there, but it's really more assignment than it is anything else. And we're going to spend more time in this area. So it's assignments.

18:42 So you'll see some movement around there. But as you have questions about those, I have one in my department I'll speak to as well. But I really wanted to talk to this specifically up front to try to get clarity around the cost of payroll and why it's increasing. OK, good. Any questions on that? Next slide. One second. We're going to get through this slide, and then we'll do questions to the public. Thank you. Yep. And as we try to go through, this particular slide here shows

19:13 Just kind of the major expense items that were new and unique to this year's budget. Just really kind of shine a spotlight on all the other areas, both up and down. And we'll kind of go through, I'll briefly go through these, and then I think during the department level discussion there'll be a little bit of a deeper dive on that. But we have those compliance contracts, that's an incremental $50,000 that wasn't in.

19:39 Our adopted budget last year, and we put it into the modified budget as we went through the year, but it was not even adopted. We talked earlier about the insurance premiums, the general liability, property, and pollution, reducing 311,000. That was a big help. Computer support services, that's increasing just about 22,000. Maybe we'll talk a little bit more about that, but it's really a dedicated resource for radios, probably a person.

20:04 Police dispatch services, that's going to have 31%, $90,500. A lot of security payroll increases that are going on within the county and that in the sheriff's office, particularly, and a little bit about call volume distribution, that's how those are allocated. The police facility, that's going down 33,000.

20:25 We're in a new building and no longer leasing the building. It's not a net adjustment, certainly against the payment, but the payment was in last year's budget numbers as well as far as the for the new facility, but this is a net reduction. The $25,128 parks and trails, that's simply, we were charging an expense there to pay another area within our general fund, and we just decided to eliminate that, so it's really not a net adjustment, but it's

20:55 Building Division, Tom Perry will talk a little bit more about that, but $130,000, $100,000 of that being in contract, and $30,000 in specific design, plan designs, which is a part of the policy question for later on. Housing programs, $100,000, and $75,000 of that being the housing element update. And then a Civic Spark employee matching funds of $25,000 will be as part of the policy discussion.

21:22 Engineering Public Works. We had an additional 30,000 we have for contractual services. And these are based upon the volume of projects that we've got going on out there and some potential overflow and other sort of surveys that may be necessary to perform those functions or parking, trails, signage, et cetera. Then transit services, there's a proposed Meridian Minaret connection to the village. That's another 25,000.

21:49 That's built into the numbers that we talked about today. That'll be a policy question. The tourism business development, the 180, we talked about that being their portion of the million dollars allocation. That's just to give you a highlight of here's the big big dollars. Gas tax, that's the contribution from the gas tax is fairly complicated. This one is the transfer out from general fund.

22:15 To support the activities that go into gas tax. We're anticipating, based upon a much lighter snow year this year, that the revenue generated from snow removal reimbursement will be fairly light. And so we have to make that up within the general fund because a lot of the items are still remaining as cost. And we have to be sort of vigilant about potential for high snow cost. So we kind of build a budget based upon an average year of snowfall when we're going to get a reimbursement, which is a below average year.

22:45 And then the rest of them are really the transfer out components, which we've already kind of talked about, housing reserves component, transfers reserve component, and then where I wanted to hold aside the funds that would be available to the town, that's at 688,461. Those are basically set aside. We're going to put some more on REU. That's about a $250,000 request to maintain on policy, and then just some other projects for the year. So. Good.

23:14 We kind of wanted to take a break at that point, and I think we wanted to do the questions. Yeah, real quick. So, Council, any questions on this first section here? No. No? We good? Okay, public thoughts, comments, questions, please. If you could, because we're on television, they want to see your beautiful face. Come on up here. So, I just feel like the general fund projected expense part, equaling costs, let's put numbers to that, not just percentages.

23:47 You have to tell the public how much you're spending in per retirement, not just percentage on it. Because total payroll has got to be $11 or $12 million. And the layman's not going to be able to read this thing and figure that out. So you probably have those numbers offhand. You could probably not have to share them with it. It's a good thought. Thank you. Total payroll is just over $10 million.

24:17 All in, but that's good feedback. I did it because this is when we're building the overall salary structure and salary benefit worksheet, those are the numbers that we kind of start with and good input though. We can do that. Thank you. As we come back on the next round of budgets too, but we'll break this out. Like, here's our total payroll. Here's our total O&M. Here's our total capital. We're missing some of you. We haven't gotten into details like in a lot of our assessment districts.

24:47 We don't have the capital budget in here yet. So there will be some other building blocks that will come in this in the next round. And there will be some of that breakout in that showing total salaries, total benefits, total. And there will be that by fund as well to show that layout of how the costs are spread across the organization. The primary focus today, early on mentioned, is really on the general fund, which drives a lot of the other elements.

25:13 And a couple of the other major funds that we need to have that discussion on. Once that's much more firm enough, it's easier to go back in and say, OK, here's our capital side. Here's the other. I think we have 20-some funds. Yeah. I think it's just important. The budget, the basic discipline that we use, the nut of the town, these annual increases, I think to Ted's point, being able to spell those out in dollars and cents, how we allocate one-time money that comes in from TOT,

25:43 Overages, we hope. That feeds into general conversations about how we're going to add bodies to the organization. Right now we know we need to get to something on that TOT input level that's sustainable and reliable enough to be able to do that. But this is a key driver in that. And so I think to Ted's point, I think it's really important to keep highlighting what that's all about. Okay, anybody else? I've seen none. So we're going to move on now. This is going to be department by department. Is that right? Yes.

26:14 Well, we decided to start, when we start the department discussion, Dan and I are going to talk about these first two, which is town administration and finance, and then Nate County, who's part of our team as far as supporting us in the IT world. We're going to talk about some of the IT components of that. But we decided to start by showing sort of the structure, the organizational chart, if you will, of how we're built.

26:46 So real quick on this, I mean, it's a manager's office and the director reports there with the assistant to the town manager and the town clerk's office. And then it drops into the total admin, which Rob will touch on. Also, if you're not on that, you know, we have the town council in there. That budget may change somewhat ultimately based on elections and what people elect from an insurance standpoint. There's a difference from what the current council is. We don't know that obviously at this point.

27:17 Our legal services department is basically a rollover. That is for Andy Morris, who is a town attorney at Element in there and his contract. And then the other element is mainly for outside counsel on a number of specialty areas that is not Andy's forte, if you will. A lot of that is like in our personnel side.

27:42 We also end up picking up a number of, you know, I'll say, almost

28:12 Town-wide, but not quite items in there. We pick up the cost of some of the, you know, Forest Service permits. There's some of the community meeting costs and different things of that. We also pick up our circulating, what we pay for.

28:35 Recycling Services. There's a contract and they have about $35,000 for those services and things like that. Otherwise, it's pretty much a rollover budget. Now and again, there's not a home for something. It'll either end up in the manager's office or in general services. It's kind of the two places that end up more of the catch-all components if need be that fall into that, both categories.

29:00 So we'll, for example, and I will talk about it later, but in here we did put some dollars in for the contractual with potential funding on a joint position between the town, the county, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation to support floor service work. So there's $20,000 would be a misbudget for that just in terms of the holding where we put it type of an element.

29:21 The town's court budget is pretty much a straight rollover budget. The fluctuations in that department are generally tied, frankly, to the election, where you'll have it up between one year and down. And what we've done to level that off is try to put a dollar amount each year the same, $9,000 based on some history. And so the extent that we don't spend that, we'll carry it over. Otherwise, you tend to have one year with the spike and one year with nothing.

29:48 And then, so the year you have nothing, it looks like you have savings, so you tend to spend it somewhere else. So trying to smooth some of those things out, and so you'll see that in the clerk's budget, as an example. Now we have a couple of areas where we'll do that and try to smooth stuff out for three years to make that happen. So, otherwise, that's very much a little over budget in those areas. A couple of the policy statements that we'll talk about that gets carried there from the direction of the council.

30:17 Otherwise, it's really a staff-driven office is there. Okay. So, anything in here? It doesn't sound like there's any of the council, the public, anything that's a flag for any specific attention or discussion? No, that's the one. Talk about it later. Well, that's why I'll carry dollars in there. We're going to do strategic planning and development of the council. Right. We funded there at that point. Okay. Okay, good. Yeah, okay.

30:47 Okay, good. So finance, we had a couple of things. You'll see a switch of employment. The employee is going down 90,000 and then human resources up 125. That fluctuation is moving an employee from finance who was under that for our payroll, moved it into human resources. So our human resource department now kind of covers all the payroll benefits more inclusive than it was before where it was accounting and

31:16 Human resources, performing those functions. Some of the major significant items, we've got the inclusion of those compliance of $50,000. The other thing I tried to do in going through my budgets is was to challenge myself in areas where we can draw down. So there areas where we really have opportunity or some room to reduce the budget cost. And we've done that, but we can. We also have a lower level of recruiting expense expected for this coming year. We've got a major position. Last year we were going after the lieutenant level position.

31:45 Get together open recruitment. So now it's just really what we need to fill vacancies that may occur throughout the year. So we've kind of drawn that down. Some of the trends that we expect to impact us for the coming year, we do have revenue and enforcement activity from post compliance. We're opening quite a few cases on those, so there's going to be some impact on that. So it should be offset, but it's going to impact the staff for sure. And I want to talk about that from the standpoint of.

32:12 You know, trying to build in excess capacity through these efficiencies in process development without getting new employees being able to perform more to have room to do other things in the process of that. I also want to talk a little bit about the seasonality of the work. You know, for us in finance, really, the fall is probably the biggest time of year. For me personally, it's the spring where we're doing the process, but in the fall, we've got closing out the year, we've got the audit process.

32:39 And those things that come in, the fund balance discussion and things like that that come up. Revenue team, we have BTC renewals, business tax certificate renewals, TOT certificates are going to be renewed this year as a major project we're doing. So that's a heavy impact December through January. And then HR will set some gear in procedures and then Springtown hires. Some of our major goals we're planning to do, reissuing TOT certificates to all folks that carry those in the town. We're going to do some legal requirements under the

33:08 You know, under our TOT dollars because of those compliance, because of our work in that area, we need to do some refinements there. We're going to do some education and training. We have some really cool ideas about that, which you guys will hear in the coming months. And then introducing the audit program, going to ACH payments and accounts payable, so issuing fewer checks, reducing costs, implementing an AR module for Cassell. So we'll be doing some real, to set up really.

33:35 More manual billing processes we'll be doing, automated, and then enhancements in document imaging. So those are some of the things that we're working on for the coming year in finance. So the only other area within town administration and HR would be the information services. As we talked a little bit about, there's a bit of an increase in there in total of about 37,000, which 21 of that is specifically one to one position for radios, but I'll let you take it. Thanks.

34:06 So just generally, broadly first, I'll just say the budget for IT is right around just over 2% of the town's budget. That's kind of right in the general lane of best practice. I think typically they say between 2% and 4%. I think part of the reason it's maybe on the lower end of that is because the staffing is outsourced, so that's obviously saving the town money. I think in general, we're funded appropriately, and so that's just providing some context.

34:34 Really, the budget's, you know, complies with two main pieces, kind of staff and stuff, or personnel and infrastructure. Rob referred to the personnel side, so as you probably are aware, the county contracts in the county, we have a five-year contract for IT services. The contract's actually sunsetting in October, and we're back with it. As part of that process, we've been discussing sort of the scope of services that we're providing,

35:03 What is currently sort of wrapped into that, or the current contract, essentially the equivalent of one FTE from our team, the wide service of the town, the management and administration side of that, which is my time, some of our finance staff's time to deal with various aspects in the finance side of the NCGIS services piece.

35:26 I think that in general, looking at that, we feel like that's probably appropriate and numbers are outright on that. But one of the things that we are starting to work into, and we have started to kind of scratch the service on this last year, is communication and radio. So we've been doing a bunch of work with the police department, as well as a lot of the other response folks in the county, and we're recognizing there is an increasing need to really dedicate

35:55 Not only time, but also dollars on the capital side to what is a 25-plus-year-old system. So the county in December authorized a new position on the IT team. It would be a communication specialist. That position is out for recruitment. And we foresee, you know, roughly 20% or so of that position being related to doing various work in town, being otherwise.

36:21 We don't really know the exact amount of dollars on that, so we just threw a normal amount in relative to that. So that's the 21 roughly that Rob was referring to. On the infrastructure side, that makes up the rest of the 37. There's a couple of key pieces that are in there, you know, really back into that as a whole is licensing, so all the compliance that we need for software that's running across the environment, PC replacements, we replace.

36:49 20, 25 PCs a year out of the entire fleet just to keep those current. So those numbers are relatively flat. This year we're going to need to upgrade the database that basically runs a lot of the core applications across the organization to sell being one of them. We've been told by that vendor that there is a need to bring that up to a more modern standard. So there's some money in for that, as well as a little bit of money in to kind of

37:18 So that's kind of what's in the 37th. I'm happy to answer questions, though. Sure. Questions? No. Just for the public, what we'll do, we're going to go through all the department presentations. At the end of that, we'll take some questions on the whole thing. So thank you very much.

37:50 So the organizational chart for the police department was 12 sworn. Members, thanks to the council last year. Three non-sworn. We currently have one level one reserve and hoping to add three more here in the future. But as you can see by the chart, police chief and executive assistant will introduce in a future council meeting, Heather Johnson.

38:18 One officer is dedicated to the Mullen County Investigative Unit, but sometimes if you're in the staffing levels, you need to

38:49 So looking at my budget, some of the things that are different from last year to this year.

39:17 Attraction services have been actually overspending, so we increased that number from $40,000 to $50,000. That includes background and internal investigations through the outside sources, either a central group or Terrence Mark, former sergeant group, MLTB does background investigations, as well as former chief Chris Carter, when we have too many backgrounds to do, he'll help us out as well. So that, the next big increase is the $92,000 increase for dispatch services.

39:47 Uh, it's 114,000. The dispatch service cost from London County Sheriff's increased to $114,000 last year. And there's a formula that has been in place for several years in how to do the charges for that. So they take the total cost of dispatch services, which this year they anticipate $607,000. And then they take the total calls for service for Monon County Sheriff's and Mammoth.

40:15 And based on percentages, how much we owe of that. So this year we had, they used last year's numbers as the calculation. This year we had 48% of the calls for service. We increased about 600 calls where Northern County Sheriff's decreased their calls and they're about 52%. So that's the overall increase to the $91,500 to the budget. And it's something we can't control per se.

40:42 We can't afford to do our own dispatch services. Going down the list, just slight increases. A couple of the bigger increases are mainly looking at communications equipment. Last year, we prevented maintenance and mobile units, which changed drastically. This coverage, the quality of the communication work,

41:15 I mean, there are numerous times where we couldn't hear each other just being in the same town. And now, after that's been done. So, I mean, start doing that on a regular basis. Handhelds every two years, but mobile units and police cars every year. So, that's the increase there. Also, our equipment takes 18. So, we anticipate having to replace, but we want to have a, we want to hold off as long as we can so we can have a county-wide commitment as to the new radio systems that are going in place.

41:42 Is there some kind of sheet that you guys have that I'm missing? Because I just have

42:11 Just this when it comes to the case. Yeah, it does have a summary sheet. We'll have it. Is it not? We don't have details for you right now. We did not. Those things are still moving around with some things, so we don't have all the detail printouts. Well, yeah, I'd like something more than just like that. We'll end up with all the printouts that turn around so you can look at by line. So the numbers that are in here, Rob, the relationship back to page five, which is the payroll analysis of rising costs,

42:44 These are, is the numbers that are being represented here, are they, this is sort of an overview of that, and this is what it is specifically each department, correct? Okay. So we're not double. Yeah, rather than, exactly, right, rather than have, because it is fairly complex, as Ted was pointing out, department level, to understand the detail of what's impacting there. Right. That's why we wanted to talk about it in a broad sense. Right. That's the same numbers I'm talking about, the impact showing that.

43:12 Okay. All right, good. Any questions in the council? No? You know what? I do have some questions. Going back, you know, to the police services. So I guess maybe I'm a little bit off track here, but I would imagine that you had a pretty good amount of overtime last year. So currently this year, we're at $191,000.

43:42 And that is basically because their staffing levels are so low, we have someone go out on vacation for training, we have to backfill that. We also have injuries and other unforeseen things that, you know, we have to backfill that staffing levels are so low. But if we have more officers, we need to get away about having these as much overtime when someone goes out injured. And to answer your question too, so there's $240,000 in the budget for overtime, which is the exact same number we had to start last year.

44:13 And we're going to come in pretty close to that, I think, for... We can go back to 16, 17, and we spent 305,000 overtime that year, and that was because we had two guys out for several months from surgeries, and, you know, can't control that. But we also are trying to minimize the overtime by utilizing the level one reserve in lieu of amount of overtime, and then when we have the level two reserves come on, they can do transports so that we don't have to pay the officers the four-hour minimum overtime.

44:43 The reserve officers' salary made for men is $20 to $30. So it's a letter of two. The letter of one is $25 to $35. Okay, good. As much as I can. Okay, so thank you for that. So moving on now? Yeah. Okay. Tom. That's right. Thank you. So I'm just going to walk you through the old child. I know you've probably met. I know you have all met.

45:17 We have seven full-time employees. You can see they're kind of across the organizational chart there is defined. We have myself as the director, Warren is the parks manager. We don't have a recreation manager that's currently vacant and unfunded. Warren is our program facilities coordinator. We have two recreation supervisors.

45:42 One on the right, you can see there on that far right chart is John Connelly, and he oversees all that recreation programming, which is kind of a major function of the department. And the other supervisor there in the middle is between Belly and Sheep oversees the programming of the facilities, which is Mammoth Ice Ranch, Whitmore Pool. And then Warren on the far left oversees two year-round parks maintenance staff, that's Warren and Juan. Juan is the recipient of our spirit amendment for originally.

46:11 Congratulations to him, and then he oversees five seasonal staff as well, five seasonal staff. Quickly on our budget, you know, each year we go through a strategic planning process with our Recreation Commission, this is our plan, in our second year right now, so as best we can, we try to align our budget with the strategic plan to make sure we kind of fund and support all the programs that we're looking to implement throughout the year, and then as a

46:39 An annual process we go through that evaluation of our Precursion Commission as well as a very productive process. In regards to trends that we may see affecting our budget to come, there's certainly a minimum wage issue. If you look at the seasonality of our business, because we're all interrelated, John's team, we bring in about 18 to 20 councillors, sports officials, umpires, and so forth every summer.

47:09 Which is kind of the recruitment process now, so we're kind of heavily with that. Pat on the programming side brings in 14 pool staff, wintertime is, you know, 14 ice rink staff, and then Warren brings in five parks maintenance staff. So, you know, there's 40 seasonal employees coming in this summer by June, you know, so that's a big bump. So if you kind of look at the minimum wage issue right now, it's $11 by 2022, it'll be $15 an hour, right? So that kind of increases the slide.

47:36 All the way up and down the structure of our employees. So that's just something that we, again, are just going to be building into the budget that Rod kind of, Rod touched on briefly as well. Stewardship, you know, a lot of the strategic plan, we talk about stewardship and being environmentally friendly, sustainable, conscientious with our best practices and procedures. So that's something that we kind of look to each year to try and implement. A lot of the impact there from a budget perspective is always it's more expensive.

48:04 When we reach from a product, we do try and make that choice. And that's something that was identified in the strategic plan. And then kind of the smart park concept, which is kind of really utilizing technology is a big part of what we're doing. We're kind of touching on that a little bit with our deferred maintenance program, updating all our water irrigation management systems to be cloud-based so we can kind of manage the water usage, turn them off and on from a phone, from iPad, and then switch them off as any problems with water loss and so forth.

48:32 And we really see, you know, our forecasting about 10 to 15 percent reduction in water usage this summer. So anyway, so there's some trends that we see kind of broadly. We talked about seasonality a little bit about our department. You know, we went through our big kind of open house with our products. You know, so for instance, the demand there in effect to the department is, you know, we opened up our summer camps and programs, you know, on the first, you know, Monday of April.

49:00 We reserve 480 spots of the 882. We bring in about 70% of our revenue on that one day, you know, for those programs, so it's a significant impact. It's a crazy time. And the challenge there that we face is, you know, once all those, you know, spots are filling, you know, within that first week we had 130 people on our waiting list.

49:24 So we are seeing just overwhelming demand, you know, year after year. So, you know, one of the ways that we can kind of deal with that demand here is just seasonally, you know, look at bringing in a couple more seasonal employees, but really we're going to get to a limit with what we can do with our resources and facilities, you know, with our vans and equipment and so forth. So that's just something that we're just seeing that will be addressed, you know, in the future. We really want to utilise, hence, the multi-use facility as kind of a hub for parks and recs camps.

49:53 We can still take care of our week-long, you know, summer camp participants, but also look at kind of augmenting that with kind of a day camp situation. You can kind of take, you know, 10, 20, 30 kids in a day camp situation that will hopefully alleviate that demand because the demand is really, if you look at it, for about a three to four week period, right? So, you know, after July 4th and middle of July, everybody's here, everybody wants all the services. So many, not only our visitors, you know, sorry, not only our residents here, but our visitors are really looking for this camp.

50:22 It's a great experience for their kids. That's just something that we're seeing in the future. We really want to kind of tie that with our strategic plan. It's how we're addressing it in the future. And that's something that we kind of keep updating Council each year. So our seasonality is significant. You know, we can talk about all the numbers there. Changes in our procedures that affect operations. You know, we have a program facilities manual now. We're starting to kind of...

50:50 Streamline our process, you know, trying to create a one-source document that helps us manage a lot of our parks and facilities and ordinances. And one of those is kind of being, you know, taking back that Banner Bank, Banner Program, the Streetland Post Banner Program. So that's a big part of kind of what we do now, kind of coordinating with Manifax Tourism. Just quickly on some functions, I just pulled together a little spreadsheet that talks a little bit about, to give a sense of kind of our 6.1% of the general fund.

51:18 That's kind of what we represent in Parks and Recreation. If you look at it from a whole, 33% or a third of that is providing a recreation program, as we talked about. About 45% is based on maintenance, so parks, fields, facilities. 15% is operating our multi-use facility year-round. And then our budget also funds the fish stocking program, which is augmented by Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

51:44 So this year we're still looking at stocking the same number of fish in the lakes basin, which is actually equal to the entire county-wide program. So we're going to drop just under 20,000 pounds of fish in the lakes basin, which is the same number of tonnage across the county. So that's significant. It's a great program. We also fund our eSports funding program there and also the 4th of July fireworks. I do want to say just on a big picture stuff, you know, a third of the expenses are offset by revenue.

52:13 So again, we can generate our own revenue or support on funds other than general funds for our products and services. And just wrapping up quickly, you know, a major work plan this year for us is really delivering the deferred maintenance program. We're trying to keep that separate to the existing budget as best we can. We'll have a little bit of overlap, so meaning a lot of the work is being performed by contractors, so the work this evening and the item for the Whitmore Pool upgrades as a contract.

52:39 Tennis courts, bleachers, you know, all that work is really a contract basis because we just don't have the staff and the resources to provide that in-house. So that's kind of the bigger work this year. So we're bringing in staff a little bit earlier to get ahead of our operations. And then the other big project this year is kind of our playground installation as well. So we're trying to work staff around with our volunteers to kind of get that community build going as well. So it's a significant year for parks and recreation. You know, we're seeing increased

53:09 You mentioned at the end there that kind of your overall blended average cost recovery is about 30%.

53:38 I think your department's unique in that sense that you have the ability to do some cost recovery. Can you talk a little bit about how you've kind of landed at that figure? What is the goal? What is the range that you're in? There's a lot of talk in the public about facilities and programs. Should they have 100% cost recovery? Can you talk to us a little bit about the philosophy behind kind of arriving at that cost recovery level? Absolutely.

54:05 Part of an existing kind of council policy, philosophical direction, and certainly an ordinance, you can cite that as well, that's in broad terms, it provides the subsidies of up to 80% for our youth programs. So we want to make sure each and every child, youth in our community has access to a program's facilities and affordable nature. On the adult side, that subsidy is less, it's about 20%. So in a way, we're having the adult subsidized kids programs. On the facilities, we see it at about 20% or 30%.

54:34 There's one of our, sorry, our subsidy's about 70%, so it's 20%, 30% cost recovery. A lot of the facilities go up and down based on that, based on fees, seasonality. If you look at the ice rink this year, I mean, the budget of expenses is around $200,000. We bought in about $100,000 already. So again, you know, higher cost recovery, but depending on the season, that'll fluctuate. Pool's pretty consistent, just with its location, that runs at about a...

55:02 And I really think the takeaway from that is certainly, you know, you'll hear the Recreation Commission reiterate this time and time again, you know, as best we can, our number one metric is really visitation. You know, we want to make sure that the facilities are building and staffing and supporting and programming.

55:31 Seeing high visitation from certainly our community and our visitors. So that's our number one metric. So once you get into ROI, it gets a little bit of a difficult situation because if it's more ROI driven, the cost of entry is going to increase and then you're going to have less access and more barriers for our community to use our facilities. Again, I'm just not sure that's the best interest of our community. Historically, which way are we going?

56:00 Are you static or on cost recovery? Cost recovery. I think we're pretty static. I think we're pretty static. I think, you know, we only do a very meager, you know, CGR increase in every one of us. So we're just trying to keep up. So it's pretty consistent. I'm not seeing really going to change here. And I think that's a good thing. You know, we scholarship. We get a lot of kids that need the camps and the programs. But it's pretty consistent. And we price our programs accordingly. We do a lot of good research.

56:27 Right. With our peer results and make sure that our community, if we're seeing some response, like our softball leave, for instance, you know, we were seeing a lot of issues with our softball, so we're going to hold that really good price, make sure we can get the community involved and engaged, you know, because we did see that decline last year. So we really want to make sure, you know, price is not that barrier. It's really about participation. And you feel pretty good overall about hovering around that 30% cost recovery level.

56:54 I think it works out really well. It's something that might be coming up as we look to the new larger facility, but I think where we're at right now, it's a great balance of visitors and our local residents being able to access those facilities. Yeah, so it's certainly not the goal of the existing facilities or potential future facilities that they need to have a 70, 80, 100% cost recovery to warrant them as part of your program. And that's really a council?

57:23 Yeah, I think you're right on that. Park side and stuff, given who we're servicing, and this is not unique to Mammoth Lakes, but the goal is not to have them cover all their costs, or you would become very focused on those who could use those facilities, and you would have a large portion of your population that you would be basically pricing out of those services. And for the park and rec side, I would say that is just the opposite. That really, especially for the younger

57:53 We want them engaged in those services. Our goal would be really truly, how do we not turn anybody away? That is a very positive thing for youth. I mean, previous life doing this, one of the biggest supporters of our rec program was their juvenile probation officers. They saw the kids engaged in that level, weren't engaged in other things. And so, as we look at that, how we bring our community and the facilities.

58:17 We really don't want price to be a barrier. This is a core service we provide. If you can make a lot of money on this, I think the private sector would be in doing it. So it's not really price-driven. The other element is, due to know that we see that swings a little bit, is really seasonality in the ice rink this year. With the lower snow levels, but not covering the ice rink with snow, it did very well. Last year, not the same in some of those issues. So it is seasonal that way, and again, it depends on some of the other...

58:45 Camps and stuff, and we can do more of them, but again, that's not 100% cost recovery either. And I think it's designed that way on purpose, and I think from an element of serving the community, that is right on target. Okay, good. Any other questions? Thank you, Stuart. Next. Next is community development, so we're going to start with Tom Perry. Okay, thank you.

59:14 We have a Community and Economic Development Director, who is Sandra Moberly, who is responsible for planning and economic development commission. And under that is myself, a building official, senior planner, Sandra Absinthe Capacity. Under Sandra, we have an associate planner with Traxler, and two assistant planners, Kim Cook and Noah LaBrock. Under myself, a building official, I have the permit technician, Diana Jacobson.

59:42 Our code compliance officer, Shween Sanders, our plans examiner engineer, Tom Malloy. And not included on this organizational charter, what's not shown here is that there's two contract inspectors out there that work directly under that cover the majority of the inspections in town. They're under contract with CO2 technical services. Then under the permit tech, we do get an intern and then that intern will report directly to Dynagip Center for the technician.

1:00:10 Looking at the building division budget, most items here are identical from last year or have a very slight increase. The two items that have gone out of most ways are some payroll expenses and also contract services. Some of the expenses associated with the increase in payroll expenses are attributed mainly to certain expenses like health insurance premiums, workers' comp insurance, personal retirement, as well as a few.

1:00:38 Staff increases average for staff during the next fiscal year. And that difference is, that increase is 32,167. And contract services has the biggest increase in here. And that basically is a couple things going on with contract services. When I looked at my budget at mid-year, I noticed that our activity was up a whole lot more than last year. It was up 57% from last year at that time.

1:01:07 So I knew I had to do something to get some more money in that budget because I was going to go in probably soon. So as I look at it, I talked to Rob and programmed in an addition to that budget to get us up to speed as to where we have to be to make budget this year. But given the way activity is going out there, I just get a definite increase in activity next year. So what led to that, you know, basically that 230, getting to 230 would be an increase.

1:01:37 In activity from last year, this year it is what we need to be for this year with another 20% on top of that, kind of a risk number, but I just want to be prepared. It's really a lot of activity out there right now. Also included in that contract services item, it's a $30,000 placeholder for prescribed assignment of the engineering designs. If you're not familiar with those, these are the signs that basically need or.

1:02:04 They are funded through the town to a private architecture engineer that are pre-engineered in nature, such as decks, LPG protection covers, stairs, snow rails, things like that, where the applicant would have to pay the expenses like engineering or the pre-engineer the designs they could use. So the intent is to save the applicant time and money from that also hopefully encourage people to confirm some stuff. We use that in

1:02:31 Thank you. Thank you.

1:03:01 That's kind of what I'm shooting for. So about $30,000 plus the what we had to get up to speed from last year to this year plus an anticipated increase in building activity to get us to that $260,000. That's it. Okay. Good. Any questions from Council? I'm going to talk a little bit more about Senator's other categories for her. So in the Planning Department there is $14,000 for a Caltrans grant intern.

1:03:34 So the interim working with Kim on the housing safety conservation element update, which is another $75,000 expense you'll see under the housing programs. And so this position would help with that and their time will be fully reversible for LTC and the Caltrans grant. The other thing that at this time there's no contracts out there, but if there is any contracts, there will typically be a sequel contract with a lot of the entitlement work.

1:04:02 And so it's going to be significantly impacting staff. On the housing element, you'll see there's a bit of a switch between planning and housing. That's really the shift of assignment and time, putting Ruth to work in the housing area more this coming year. So that's a little bit of a switch there. We also have $25,000. That $100,000 is $75 associated with the housing safety and conservation element update.

1:04:30 And then the $25,000 is for a Civic Spark employee, which is like a fellowship level employee. And that's just a matching fund component of that. Most of it will be coming from a grant. And that would be basically helping to implement the housing action plan. Additionally, the housing element update and also will be completed during this year, which will result in increased staff costs for the department. So that was some of the things that they were anticipating as far as trends.

1:04:57 We talked about increases in the entitlement activity, which will trickle down to the building permit activity, which Tom just talked about. Currently, planning staff fully committed to existing projects and state mandates for, like, the housing safety element update, which gives them very little time for them to work on new programs and assignments. So, according to large entitlements, are submitted, and we probably receive assistance from outside, but consider increasing staff.

1:05:24 The other major items, really nothing, you know, from seasonality to the building division season. Most customers during the spring and summer months, obviously, when they're done with the building. Planning really doesn't have a seasonal. They just basically just see how things come in as they meet them. And as far as, you know, goals and things that have changed, there's no real policy changes that are impacting that, but, you know, major long-range planning project would be the 1890th fiscal year to include an update on the housing element and related general payment updates, but that's.

1:05:53 Okay, good. Any questions? No. Moving on then to... Are we on to the big enchilada? Well, I was trying my best, and out of 26 or whatever, I only had one name I couldn't play in, so I looked it up. Well, good. We do want to be a little mindful of time. I'm not going to miss what I'm saying. I felt pretty good. Good work. Good.

1:06:20 Really, what we try to build ourselves around is flexibility, because certainly with fleet services and road services, we have no idea, we have no idea if we're going to have last winter or this winter. One of the things I wanted to point out that I actually talked to Dan and Rob about earlier is when I got here about four years ago, I did a projection of, okay, where are we going? How do we need to change what we're doing? Flexibility was key. The road department used to do a lot of paving six, seven, eight years ago. We did zero. In fact, we're surplusing our paver.

1:06:48 We've only got about 25,000 out of that. We haven't used it in four or five years, so that's, you know, that's going to go away, but we're doing a lot more for the community as a whole, and hopefully people will see that between the roads and everything else. Our pavement index is even going up just through cracks and patching and things like that we're doing besides the major stuff. The airport, you know, same kind of thing, it's much more static. On the other hand, we have two major impacts year over year. One is the weather, certainly.

1:07:17 Second is, if not the number of flights necessarily, although that has changed quite a bit, but it's really the essential of those. When Alaska went earlier in the day at 10 something, and then all of a sudden it's coming in late at 845, for leaving at 845, that creates a certain stress on staff. We're doing fine there. Fleet services.

1:07:39 We're taking on more obligations from us and from others, but we're managing to maintain that just fine. Actually, it's the only place where we have an open position right now. We have to have one mechanic who moved on. So that's the only one I'm happy to say in 20 some positions that we have an open spot. We are pretty as soon as possible because it does put a lot of stress on staff. The buses don't go away and summer's coming. It gets worse during the summer.

1:08:04 Engineering is probably the place, and over the years, we've made the biggest change in terms of flexibility. When I got here, we were in what I would call true engineering department. They did some project management, but they did a lot more stuff in-house and really did that. That is, in my view, not a good way to move to be flexible and nimble in a small organization. If you only have four people, they have to be nimble, they have to be able to manage consultants and projects better, and we've come a long way. They're going to be bought into that program.

1:08:32 Changes over last year. We have one policy issue to discuss later about a part-time assistant for a lot of happens at the garages to help get paperwork to get him out on the floor more and be able to build more hours and do that type of thing. You know, he shouldn't be doing a lot of paperwork. He should be taking a lot of other stuff. We'll talk about that a little later. That's just about it in terms of the changes. Over the four years, and I want to mention this because we talk about trends all the time.

1:09:01 In the entire public works organization chart, and since the 14-15 year budget, which was adopted shortly before I got here, we've changed in engineering one full-time intern to two seasonal interns. In the fleet, we have no changes, but we're recommending now maybe a 10 or 12 hour a week intern type of a part-time person to help with paperwork. In the road department, we have

1:09:29 That we see in the entire main storm. We have now a hybrid position that we share with the arts and rec and that we'll see how it works out this summer. Now that she'll have advantage on last summer he came on and immediately got hurt. So we didn't have him. So other than that, no changes and nothing at the airport. The only real significant change is we added trails and that's not technically Joel and his group, his assistant during the summers in public works.

1:09:55 So I wanted to mention that. Other than that, we really had no changes over the four years in terms of just a couple of part-time and some real changes in what we're doing on a daily basis. In terms of salaries and benefits, Rob's gone through that in pretty good detail. The real fluctuation we see there, frankly, is how many capital projects we're doing and how much we can charge to that project.

1:10:16 We run significantly on other people's money, as you know, and we talk about capital projects. Later on in the budget process, you'll see that 98% sometimes our capital projects are funded by state funds, ATP grants, step funds, FAA funds. We do have a share of that. But the salaries change depending on where they go, depending on the allocation.

1:10:38 We guess as best we can at the beginning of the year. We haven't got it within 10% yet because a project will come up. Something will happen that we do council direction or guidance or an FAA project happens or doesn't happen. But that doesn't affect the overall bottom line. It's just kind of where it's allocated. Again, there's a couple of other things that we'll talk about later in terms of the policy stuff, the transit services.

1:11:04 Really have been a rep line that we want to talk about. It has to do with some parking issues I'll get into a bit later. But other than that, I'm ready for any questions. There's a lot of us that we don't control. We keep it static. As you can see, over four years, we've made very few changes and we try to be as flexible as possible. Any questions from Council? No. The CIP program, where does that live? I mean, that's in here and it's moving forward. And I think we talked about seeing a review of that coming up maybe this year.

1:11:33 Right, we've actually done a preliminary analysis of that to make sure that we have the any additional funds or our shares that we have covered in the budget. It's not part of this because it's focused on grateful stuff. I don't know, Rob Dan. Yeah, the next next round with the county budget will be bringing in a list of the capital programs out there. Okay. And we are prepared for that. Certainly we have just as many projects this coming year as we did last year between.

1:12:02 DAPT closure that are at sidewalk, finishing upper main, lower main sidewalk, and all the rest, and we're prepared to describe those in great detail. Okay. And Diff, I know we've, the council, many years ago, took a, I think, a very appropriate stance with the town relative to Diff, but as things may start be moving around and changing, I'm assuming that those are maybe policy things, but things we maybe need to address systemically to make sure.

1:12:28 Doing the right thing by that. Okay. So any other questions here? No? Okay. So let's, that was the last apartment, correct?

1:12:53 So let's go through that, and then we want to get an opportunity for some public input or feedback as required, and then we'll get into the policy things.

1:13:20 Otherwise, you're really just kind of showing where the debt details are, which there'll be more sight on that for a minute, but it's fairly consistent. I've got gas tax, that increase we talked about, 328 operations for air services down about 13, and then my million dollars, the million dollar holdover reserve, both housing, transit, and town funds. Next item I want to talk about is the gas tax fund category, and I think we'll take a break now or after this.

1:13:50 Yeah, let's do it after this. Okay. So gas tax, we try to break down the different categories of revenue at the top of that. You know, based on the name of the fund itself, I think that most of the revenue comes from the gas tax itself. If it's not, it's a restricted revenue fund, meaning that we can only spend those revenues for certain items. But the general fund does contribute 62% of the actual

1:14:14 Cost of operating this department. It is in balance. You'll see that the revenue expectation of 3.9Million equals the expenditures. We basically balance with the funds. And so we do anticipate the snow removal to be 1.1Million. That is an estimate. Last last year, we're around 1.8Million. And that's driven off of the prior year's actual cost of snow removal.

1:14:39 So the current year we're in now was fairly soft. So that's, I say it was fairly soft. It was fairly soft through February and then it got exciting for March and then before. But the other thing you'll see in there is the gas tax SB1 funds at $146,000. That revenue is specifically for projects for road construction, road projects. We're carrying that in a transfer out down below just dollar for dollar. We're basically, that money is going to come in.

1:15:07 And we're just going to go out to fund projects. So we're holding that down in the transfers out section down below. The other thing I try to do is break out just where we're spending money from street maintenance, road vehicle, patient, snow removal, vehicle replacement, et cetera, where the cost of that department comes from, that is designed to break out. And then very, very little bit, the $100,000, we have to transfer that out. That's the A portion of the gas tax for snow removal that comes in.

1:15:35 That is attributed to the assessment districts who perform some of the activities, but that's gas tax in a very concise nutshell. Excellent. Thank you. Any questions from Council in this last bit here? A couple of quick questions. So the MLLA settlement, I had a question from someone. Hey, did we complete the refinancing of that item? Yes, that would be the airport judgment bonds now versus...

1:15:59 Correct. So, but going forward, the number is still going to be $2 million a year. Yeah. It's not going to be one. Yeah, the recommendation is to continue the $2 million to go into there. It goes into our debt service capital fund. And that would actually free up about $135,000 to $150,000 a year. Right. Then that would be held for capital projects and some of those elements. To the extent that we can do that, we think that's a good use of those funds. Right. Through that process. Okay. Okay. The other question is, we've had,

1:16:28 Council's had a discussion about SB1. Certainly LTC, we took a lot about that. I'm just thinking going forward it might be useful at some point to establish a value to the community and the council of what SB1 is delivering to us as a community. What kinds of dollars that we're getting out of this that's actually going to our bottom line capital projects that might be helpful going forward. So if there's no other questions from up here, any thoughts or questions from the public on representations from the departments? Okay, good. Hearing none. So next.

1:16:57 Okay, we're going to go into the next items. Just really spend not a lot of time on them, but your question is you're kind of curious for the most part because the process for Measure R and U are that recommendations come from NLR. So those, the road being for NLR, we're going to be discussing this is on May 8th. So expect to have some more more things coming back. What I presented for me today

1:17:23 On the revenue side, we have HDL who projects our sales tax revenue as well as revenue we expect to get the measure R. And so that's 1.35 million for the year. That's up a little bit, actually kind of where we're going to end up this year. We're always conservative on those numbers. We draw back from the projection a little bit so that we don't overdo it. But looking at the anticipated expenditures against the revenue 1.3, we should have another 175,000 or so in that account.

1:17:52 As far as fund balance available for recreational uses. Real quickly, the MLR agreement of 192,000. Some of these items are just ongoing annual. We've rolled them over year over year from MLR's recommendation. There's 300,000 fund trails, which goes into 15 designated specifically for trails. And then on the bottom there, you'll see there's multi-use financing payments that we get debt that we issued this year, the 5.5 million senior bond.

1:18:21 That payment for this year is 612,131, and that ends up the entire expenditure for Measure R. Measure U has a projected revenue of 900,000 committed expenses, currently 971, so it should generate a significant amount of 728,000. You'll see, we put a little footnote in there about the programming and special projects that we have.

1:18:45 Called out, those are carryover numbers for prior year, but that is subject to our approval process and then some other incidental for transit services for certain special operations that we do throughout the year, some contracts, equipment and audit services. So not a great year to measure our review, but we'll talk more about that on the tentative budget process, but any questions on that? Then we're going to go into the debt.

1:19:14 Fund line 90, which is debt service and future capital, I think I was talking about that a minute ago, and I listed out here what our actual operating debt payments are for the year, and you'll see that the, we'll change the name on that with the bond issuance for the MLI settlement payment for this year, which reflects slightly, but it's 1.868Million. As I showed you before, we're recommending to transfer the 2Million. That's going to kick down around 130.

1:19:42 We've got some questions for you on later. And then the debt obligation specific to measure R of the 612, just calling out our total debt, 3.216, almost 3.217 million for the year. Good. So then we've arrived. If there's any questions of the nature of R and U, we kind of went quickly over that because it'll come back through the Amos Lake Recreation.

1:20:12 Major Yu is light in there. Ultimately, there are some questions coming in. Long-term commitment. That's what we have. Mac and things of that nature. But at this point, as Rob mentioned, these are kind of the ongoing items there, but there will be potentially some changes on these pending what comes back from MRR recommendations, that policy structure they need to recommend back to the town council for that before that's final. But we did want to give you a feel for what's kind of that core

1:20:42 Funding level there and then to have that discussion. Trails, $300,000, that was a five-year commitment. Yeah, five-year commitment on trails. Trails will also have, we put last year dollars in there for capital projects, so if that budget comes back, there's about $305,000 for capital work.

1:21:03 Or that EIR of the type or EIR in the front end. But that'll come back after that recommendation from Anisex Recreation, and then we'll bring that forward for council discussion or confirmation of modification based on those recommendations. And we're in year two, which year? I think this is year one. I think this will next year will be the second year for that additional five year. Oh, it was? Okay. So, yeah. We did have five years as we rolling into it again. Okay.

1:21:32 Thank you. Yeah. So now we've arrived, there's no question, we've arrived at that sort of policy discussion input request section that we put on the one slide here. And some of these things we just got through talking about, just kind of come back and maybe generate some additional input for us. I've indicated on here whether or not the dollars have been included in the budget that you see, the budget numbers that you see.

1:21:59 And these would certainly also be the area where we can do some budget balancing, perhaps on day 32. We're going to come back to that with a tentative shot. We'll retent it back in balance one way or the other, but we'd really like to get input on from Council on these processes and we can walk through them. So the first item on that, the Joint Physician Forest Service, Mullen County, there's really multiple funding streams for that. Mullen County has outdated 50,000 of that.

1:22:28 Yeah, so basically on that one is whether or not we can continue to move forward with the proposed joint position.

1:22:54 I think one of the challenges we're seeing in this has just been in the last two weeks, some pretty significant shifts in the Forest Service and their structure. We had a meeting the other day and talking about this. And in the Inyo National Forest, and when you look at the Mammoth District and the Mono District, the two that we work with here, they are going to be about 50% or less of full-time employee capacity. They are losing people, either retirements, et cetera. They have

1:23:23 Other people going out on detail assignments for 120 days. For example, their full permitting department will basically be vacant for a period of time. Two of them on detail and one of them retiring. One of the elements of this position we've looked at is how can they help with that permit side and help us and, for example, the film permitting as well. They see that as a real challenge. Margie DeRose, who is still an acting ranger, they have not filled that position.

1:23:51 We will have a new annual supervisor on the end of the month. But very concerned about a lot of the operational stuff is going to be very, they don't want to say no to things, but to actually get the proper permits through is going to be problematic. We've talked about doing stuff like in letter agreements or narrowing that down. So we're at one point looking at the position here, and it's modified quite a bit. At one point it was looking at a Forest Service position. It was also looking at the town.

1:24:20 Centric position. Or now the question would be is do we actually put it out of the MLR umbrella in terms of some of the grants and fundraising and some other elements that way, as well as in having a larger contribution in terms of funding the program and the position. But we're seeing a change in the Forest Service dynamics here that frankly are really concerning for the stuff that we need to move through, the things we're working on, and to not have that staff on the Forest Service side.

1:24:50 It's going to be problematic. We have a meeting coming up shortly to talk about access to Red's Meadow, for example. They're having challenges. How do they staff the entrance booth? Things of that nature. So they're facing some real challenges that are going to impact us one way or the other. We're meeting Friday on opening the site's basin area. So there's some real challenges there, but right now, really the question, I guess, to Council on this is to continue to move this forward.

1:25:18 We do have a position and description pretty well done. We'll take an agreement between the town, the county, and an MLR for the position itself. But right now, trying to limit the impact on the town's general fund. That's why you see a $20,000 allocation there. Major U, as you note, there's a fair amount of capacity in there still to absorb some of these dollars going forward. Longer term, Major U will have larger commitments with arts and culture in particular.

1:25:45 So just to, so Dan, do you want to just give a, how do you want to do this? So I mean, I think if we can go through all these at once, or if you want to take them one at a time on some quick consensus items, we could do that. Either way. What's a pleasure, Council? How do you guys want to do this? You just want us to kind of walk through them all real quick? I'd do that. Yeah. So why don't you give a summary of each one of these things, and anything that stands out, we'll flag on it. I'll make it real quick here. The other, Council of Development that, you know, we have $15,000 for treaty planning. Some years we've spent more, some a little less. But I think we're going to need that, especially with the relevant.

1:26:14 I'll see the new council coming on board. To do that, the special events funding, this is the third year of a three-year commitment at that 125 level. Again, it's on there because that could be as a policy question. The community support events, we do the Historical Society, we're recommending 13,000. Last year it was 12,500. They made a request in for 25,000. We said that's not on the budget at this point.

1:26:41 Either the tenant or the final, they can come in and make their pitch if you wish to increase that. And then we've been on claim just the support for the town cleanup day, the fishing derby work, and the pops in the park is really becoming almost town functions in there. The dollar amount moves around a little bit, so that's why they're kind of lumped together in there under that 9, 750. I think those are all projects we need to continue, but you could not do town cleanup, for example, which is a good thing.

1:27:10 The building plan designs, Tom mentioned that these would be the pre-designed buildings, if you will. There's $30,000 there for that. You could hold that off and depend on where we're at down the road with excess funding if we have it and look at it at a different time. It's very nice to have and something that would be beneficial to our building community, but it is an added program that would be for this year. We added in the public works side.

1:27:38 Dealing with street signage on Main Street in the project there, we're not sure at this point whether the grant will cover signage, so we put some dollars in there for that. The other side to that, we've had an ongoing back and forth of do we have some dollars just for repair and maintenance of our wayfinding signs around town with maps. Potentially a portion of this could help in that area, but also get us to be kind of a new program there, so whether or not we want to continue it or fund it.

1:28:04 The estate funding, that's really for looking at a connection between Meridian and going up Minaret to the village. We've been trying to deal with the parking issue at the village. One of the options Grady's team came back with was to look at being able to park down along the wood side, if you will, in Minaret there. One of the challenges, and also we're getting requests from people off of Gray Bear and stuff, is for a transit component. Could we add that in? It'd probably be a summer.

1:28:32 Solution in the winter, it doesn't work as well. But we need to sit down with Esther and say, can we deviate over the current route to make a run up Minaret and do a loop around the village and back down again? To assist at that, we can park somewhere between 50 to 75 cars maybe along Minaret, give or take, in that area there. That's really a transit budget item, but there is within that transit budget to do that. We mentioned the Civic Spark position.

1:28:59 If we're successful in that application, that would start in September, I believe, as an 11-month program. We currently have that in the housing budget, so it's not a general fund, so to speak, but if there's concern over that. And then the last piece is the capital element, where we take the $2 million payment for the airport judgment bond refinancing, leaving the $132,000, a little less in the budget. The recommendation there is $15,000 each year. We're trying to build our...

1:29:28 Technology account there. So as Nate mentioned earlier, we have a little bit of replacement program. We either get things that are unknown or we need to do a larger upgrade. We actually have funds available versus looking for them elsewhere at that point. We're way behind in that area, so we don't want to be there again. And then the last is the future capital fees. We used to carry additional funds there. We used that for PD and we used it for the Shushi Rest Purchase.

1:29:55 So starting to add some stuff back in there. We know that the building roof on the ESTA building, our parks maintenance building, is going to need repair sooner than later. And that is unfunded. So this would be the way we start setting that in here for when most things happen. We actually have some dollars set aside for those unknown planned capital expenditures. Or if we know they're coming, we can do a couple years' work. But we built previous budgets on that $2 million payment.

1:30:23 And if we can leave that flowing into here, it's a way to supplement, if you will, our capital fund, if you will, in a way that isn't necessarily taking operating dollars from previous years and budgets and say, hey, now we're going to increase the transfer out there. It makes us live on where we were before as an option. So these kind of weigh that out. Some of these are pretty easy. I mean, you can make an option to reduce them or not. That helps us.

1:30:48 The larger degree would be used to $132,000 deficit in the general fund. We will be walking back through that again. There are some, you know, small revenue issues or some other expense things. We're finalizing a couple expense, internal expenses like for vehicle replacement in there. So we will be able to, we'll come back with the tenant budget. We close that gap. But for example,

1:31:11 If we want to take our building plan design and say push that off and if we have additional dollars, look at it then. That's a $30,000 fix. Not necessarily recommending that element there, but that's kind of a decision discussion on this page. It would be looking after some areas in here that, yes, we definitely want to continue to move them forward. Or, yeah, bring us back a recommendation on a reduction or elimination of one of these. We can do that. Okay, so what I'd like to do, because this is a...

1:31:37 It's a little informal. There's not a staff report behind all each of these things. Any questions from Council to Dan on these, which you've heard? I'd like to hear from the public if they've got any thoughts on these items as they were presented. Then we'll bring it up and we'll kind of provide some direction to staff at this point. So any questions on any things Dan's presented here? Technical kind of a nature. No? Okay. Any thoughts on the public? Okay. Hearing none. Who's got a thought? Some. Okay. Go ahead.

1:32:10 Just kind of on the list there, walking through for me, I'd be inclined to support the Civic Spark position. I think that's a really creative utilization of funds to get some work down on housing, which is a priority. I would definitely be supportive of additional funds into the transit budget for the connector. I think that's a creative solution to some parking issues.

1:32:36 Also targets an area where we have a transit gap as well as new residential coming in there that could benefit from a stop. Good with signage. I'm very supportive of putting some money towards plan designs. That's something that came out of the housing action plan and I think something that we should do. That's a big complaint often is the time and energy and stuff that needs to go into plan checks.

1:33:04 Expediting and streamlining that I think is a really good use of our dollars. I'm definitely supportive of events funding. I think that's one of the better things that we support as well as the support events. I'm fine with both of those as recommended. I think absolutely it's a non-negotiable to have some strategic planning for the new council in there, so I'm good with that.

1:33:29 You know, my position on this Forest Service joint position has really been the same throughout this whole process that I think it has merit. And I just wanted to see it. It was more of a process issue for me. I wanted to see it in a broader context of our budget and how that would balance against other priorities and needs. You know, staff's done that and brought it as part of our budget recommendations. So I'm comfortable with supporting that. To me, you know, if we're looking at a gap of 132, which is...

1:33:56 Relatively small number on a $22 million budget, but in the effort to balance, to me, I would go right towards the bottom area, the $116 and the $15, allocating the savings from the settlement. I agree with the approach of continuing to budget for $2 million there.

1:34:18 But I think if we're looking for an area to balance, I don't see it coming from anywhere else for me. That would be the area that I would target. Good. Thank you. Shields or Cleland? So you go along with everything except the bottom one. I actually, quite honestly, I go along with everything. You know, I look at, in light of what's going on in the Forest Service right now, I think that position takes on new...

1:34:50 I see that as something if

1:35:19 The people in Hollywood or the film world can't get into Mammoth. They're going to go other places. So I think that could be a revenue generator. Especially to piggyback off the success we've had with our film festivals that have started and stuff. Yeah. Right. Which is a good point. So I don't have a problem actually with anything. I like the idea of future capital.

1:35:48 Kind of going into reserve. So I don't know that I'd pull that out of the $132,000 or whatever that is. I'd kind of put it in there kind of as a sidebar, okay, if we need it for other things. Special events funding is the one I would, you know, I know that's a political commitment and I go along with it and I think special events are very important. I'm just wondering if there's other ways to get those monies.

1:36:18 I think for me,

1:36:49 I think your point's valid on whether at some point we reevaluate where special events funding comes from, but I think the commitment was made, so to me that's not something I'd be interested in touching at this point. And I didn't really finish what I was trying to say with that last piece, I guess, for me.

1:37:10 Maybe that could be a first place where there's an add back in if there's an overage. I mean, we talked about if we have additional revenues, where do those things go? I mean, that could be laced in as a priority potentially. But if we have to go to this list of things to balance the budget, which I know we're not at that point today, but that would be first choice for me. Okay. Thank you. Cleland. The ESTA funding, I'd hold off on that for a while.

1:37:39 With the connector, even though it makes sense, ESTA is going through a great deal of changes at the moment, and I could kick that down the road a little bit. Special events funding, I agree, I think that should be coming from someplace else. However, the building plan designs, I do want to keep that in unless there isn't any call for it.

1:38:08 I thought that was a pretty neat concept to have the pre-design plans. I'd rather get that done sooner rather than later if there is indeed people who are looking for that type of pre-design plans. And I'd like to keep the future capital in there so that

1:38:38 So that we still have that available. Because I think there are some things that we're going to need sooner rather than later. So that's where I stand. Good. Thank you. I'm very good with what I've heard from the fellow council members. I think I'm a little bit kind of on the shield side of things. Let's see what you guys do in terms of where we're at with the gap. I think we've got some policy decisions coming up in the next couple of meetings before we get to the final budget that may inform some of this.

1:39:08 But I think the kind of direction that you guys provide I think is useful and good. Do you use work for you guys? Yeah. Can I just back up for one question that I didn't ask Rob? The prior slide, the 990 debt service fund. So you basically laid out 3.2 in debt. As a ratio of our overall budget.

1:39:38 You know, in that 22, 23 range. Percentage of debt to overall budget, I mean, can you give us some feedback for, you know, whether you think that's low, high, spot on? Yeah. Usually, yeah. Right. Okay. I would say what that's reflected a lot was in the S&P review. Yep. That's one of the things they look at is what is that debt ratio to your revenues, et cetera. Sure. And when we came back with an A rating and an A plus at this point.

1:40:17 That was one of the factors they do look at and that reflected in that. Over half of that debt is something that we don't really have. Right. Yeah, it's just, you know, that's a conversation that's had a lot in the public discourse. So I think that's something that's good for us to touch on because, you know, I think people that really do understand our budget know that our, you know, debt to income ratios is

1:40:47 I would add to that, kind of as we go forward, is the relative ease with which it's possible to understand our budget and our financial profile, which I think is pretty straightforward. But I'm thinking we could talk a little bit at some point about looking at known costs to the nut, things like the minimum wage increase, things like where PERS and those kinds of things are going that may be one of

1:41:17 Not a whole lot of relatively predictable things that we can use to help make budget decisions going forward to the degree to which they are predictable. It may be helpful to have some of those things in there to help inform policy decisions going forward. Anyway, so let's finish up, Dan. We've got one slide left. Yeah.

1:41:45 Digging out of snow banks and putting flowers on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. One is if that's a priority for this year again. I wish it would be coming out of next year's budget or the decision we need to make to move forward with that. And the other piece would be really looking at it next year and identifying some of that element for a year from now. I don't recall we're going to tear it up lower Main Street so I think we've got one more year of potential beautification projects there. But getting that now so staff can just be ready to go do that work if that's...

1:42:14 The pleasure of the council versus waiting until the middle of June. So we appreciate that. That's one. The Old Mammoth Field Assessment District funds a portion of that. A portion comes out of general funds slash streets in terms of the main street piece. We have some dollars there that we can't allocate into that in the current year. Next year, it's just a matter of knowing that and we can build that in if that's the priority. Do you want to deal with that first before you do this stuff? Any thoughts from council about?

1:42:44 The flowers and the spring structure. How long do the flowers last last? Not long. Well past July 4th. I mean, I think it has a big impact on July 4th. And the ones on Main Street because we have some watering system that wanted it better than the ones on Old Mammoth and they're also trampled more. And I'm all about beautification, but, you know, I think we need to, as a community and as a town, own it.

1:43:15 And our problem is, you know, our businesses out there on Main Street say, hey, just give us the $50,000 plants and plants. Well, my suggestion is all those businesses get to digging and weeding out and making it beautification on their own. That's my, I saw this done in Aspen, and that's why I'm like this. In June, mid-June, the whole town comes out, they buy out a color spot.

1:43:45 Deal, and they drop off the plants, and a guy's actually kind of designed where the things go. The whole community comes out, and they plant the plants. And there's, you know, it's community involvement. It's kind of like cleanup day. I think we need to, hey, we'll spend the money, but you guys got to help us out here, in my opinion. We did have some of the watering and stuff last year, but we didn't get much feedback in terms of, hey, if we provide flowers or the business and plant them, that did not.

1:44:12 Well, I think last year the request came at there was a certain kind of drama and urgency to it having to do with the snow year. And I think that's fine. That makes sense. But I think there really is a need here to fold this into a program. I'd love to hear some of the proponents last year who were quite adamant about this need to be done. I'd like to get with those folks and figure out how we turn this into something that we can leverage the town's resources and start.

1:44:39 I think the other piece is to look at last year there was this sense that, well, we had this huge wreck in winter. Droughts are gone forever. We're never going to have to worry about that anymore. And I think here we are back with what we saw this winter. And I don't think we're out of the drought business yet. We did not rebuild all the water systems because of that. Exactly.

1:44:59 So let's start getting into a little bit of a sustainable, ongoing year-over-year beautification kind of a program consistent with what responsible water usage is going to look like. I mean, I'm supportive of having the dollars there probably as an item, but I think it needs to be something where we really need to have some engagement with folks about how we're going to do good work with this. So, you know, I would concur with all that. I think there should be funding and a plan for this year.

1:45:27 I also think we should build it into the budget moving forward, but, you know, I agree with Shields completely that if we're not articulating a better plan that's going to have better buy-in, then kind of what's the point? So, but I think, you know, now we're having this conversation in April, you know, we've got to get out in front of this so that we're not, you know, backed up against the wall again in June or July. That's why it's here. Any thoughts from you? I think beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

1:45:56 I don't go down Main Street and just throw up. I guess a lot of people do because it does come up a lot. However, I do think that we should be moving in the direction that Shields says and people. And because I know it can be done because other places are doing it. If you go down Old Mammoth Road, some people have taken a pun themselves.

1:46:20 They're not needing the money. I think it can be replicated. I think some of the things have been brought up in the past with movable planters and some of those things we should be moving in that direction to keep putting out $50,000 for flowers a year. I mean, daffodils, plant the bulbs in the fall and see what you get in the springtime. At least it'll work on one side of the street. Just seems like a lot of money for a little

1:46:50 Color. Are we just talking about the flowers right now? Yes. Okay, we're not talking about the airport. Okay, so, yeah. Okay, so, I mean, it's, they're flowers. You know what? If we have so much money, we can put $50,000 a year into flowers? Well, then, cheers to us. However, it wouldn't be where we are right now. We may have to have a couple of years where, you know, learn to look at something else.

1:47:18 Except for a lack of flowers. We can start looking at stuff. Some of that flowers, some of it staff costs, and then some of that will be the old Mammoth Road Assessment District picking up part of that cost. Okay, that's good. So, sprung structure? Yeah, the sprung structure, the airport, we have the option to be able to buy the structure versus doing the annual lease payment. I'm ready to complete the details on that. Right now, that lease payment is part of the operating budget, which is a pretty significant transfer for general fund overs.

1:47:44 If we were to purchase it out of the reserves within the airport capital side, then we would not be transferring $20,000 over for a lease payment this next year as a budget balancing, but also ongoing that way. And if we don't utilize the sperm structure at the airport, there are other applications with some of the other town areas where it could be relocated and utilized effectively for a number of years as well. Okay. Any thoughts from, or Grady, go ahead, sorry. No, that's really interesting. It's basically a two-year payback to all of them. Yeah.

1:48:14 Thoughts? Yes? Yeah, what other places would we be able to use the spring structure? Whitmore? Whitmore. Oh, I thought, not illegal? Yes, there's a tent farm there. Tent farm there. Right. We can look at the courtyard for storage.

1:48:36 Dan and I had this conversation earlier. I mean, I think there's multiple places we could use it in the future, which was important to me, and also it's a three-year payback, so I think it's a no-brainer for me. What's the life of the structure? It's probably, well, how long have they been up at Little Eagle? Oh, oh, this is one at Little Eagle. Oh, okay, so this is, okay, it's the same one. It's in great condition.

1:49:06 Oh, okay. No, I was just wondering if it was, as long as it's the same, I've seen how long we've had that temporary structure at Eagle. I would lean toward going ahead and purchasing it, frankly. Sure, so would I.

1:49:34 Okay, so finally, the staff discussion piece. Yeah, we touched a lot of the part-time support interns we've been utilizing. With the exception of the fleet part-time position, the others are built kind of into the budgets and our capital. This is how we've been expanding some of our capacities with part-time and trying to really be very judicious of how we do that. It does give us flexibility in the engineering side particularly and even some of the grant funding and planning.

1:50:03 The fleet position would be the only new one, and that's the real estimate. Mentioned earlier, managing the paperwork. We need to build that in, and we'll do some stronger estimates of what we think will cost us there. Ideally, that has a potential for some payback. If the fleet manager is able to spend time on the floor, then that's billable hours out. The others are built in right now. We'll spend more time on this than the tenant. But on the fleet part-time position, right now, if there's a

1:50:32 Support be able to move that forward to the need and the operational side. Then we'll go ahead and build that into the tentative budget. If not, we'll leave it out. Could you, so just for clarification, the billable hour piece of this means that... What happens to that is if it frees up our fleet manager, then he spends time working on a fire truck or on a school bus or on the ESTA buses and helping our mechanics.

1:50:56 That time then gets billed out to those other agencies. Right. Okay. And so that does bring dollars back in. Last year, I don't think he billed any time. Oh, okay. Tied up between very little time. One small thing I want to add, too, is that when during the winter, especially, he's busy.

1:51:14 Any thoughts on this? I'm supportive. You know, I think these are all supportive.

1:51:43 Good creative uses of expanding our capacity without, you know, large additional body staff encumbrances and payroll. So I'm supportive. Good. Shields, yes. Yeah, yeah. And it's part-time, too. Yeah. So it gives us flexibility. Flexibility. I'm good with that. Okay. Yeah, me too. Okay, good. So I think we're done. Thank you all for some good work. If there's any thoughts on the public.

1:52:13 Stacey, thank you. I have pictures on my phone. I live in Oklahoma and they're growing anything in gardens here. It's very difficult. Either you have to keep treating the soil that is very dry, you're constantly watering it, the animals are going to eat it. And I have a flower garden that can all fake flowers. And you cannot tell the difference unless you actually go up and touch them.

1:52:41 So it might be something for you guys to consider because you make one purchase of a bunch of thick flowers and all you have to do is pretty much store the pots and the flowers wherever you're going to store them. And the public is not going to tell the difference unless you take a ladder and go up and touch the pole wherever you guys hang there for or whatever you do. And it really is a good way to conserve water as well. And Ben Franklin's got a great selection. Excellent. Thank you very much. Thank you. Anybody else?

1:53:08 Okay, so with that, we're going to close out this workshop. Again, thanks to staff. Thanks all of you for sitting this thrill of your week, as I know it was for us. Actually, it was pretty thrilling. I kind of like this kind of stuff. I would point out that Jamie Gray is out this week. Pam's filling in on the clerk side of things. Pam is out for another matter. So the Granica system is going to stay live as we do this transition we're changing over. So mics are on and all that kind of stuff. And we will get back to work here in about...

1:53:38 It's 6.05. Six minutes. All right, are you ready? Good evening, everybody. Good evening, everybody. We're now meeting this evening for this regular meeting of the Town Council, Town of Mammoth Lakes. Get cozy. You know, it's going to be fun. Wednesday, April 18, 2018. We're a little short-staffed on the clerk side of things.

2:07:17 And for a variety of different reasons. And I'm wondering, Dan, if you could call the role. That's the role that you're playing here. Yes, I will be. So I was going to note that. Thank you very much. For roll call, Councilmember Colin Fernie. Here. Shields Richardson. Here. Councilmember Bill Sauser. Mayor Pro Tem, Cleland Hoff. Here. Mayor John Wentworth. Here. Thank you very much for that, Dan. I've asked the illustrious John Helm to lead us this evening in the Pledge of Allegiance.

2:07:51 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, John. And we will all understand why that's special here shortly. So our next item now is going to be public comment. So this is an opportunity for the public to address the council and items that are not otherwise on this evening's agenda. Mr. Baccia.

2:08:24 Mr. Mayor, Council, staff, members of the community, Rich Baccia, the Rotary Club of Mammoth Lakes is pleased to announce we're hosting a candidates forum on Monday, April 30th, starting at 5.30 here in Suite Z. The goal of the forum is to provide the candidates with the opportunity to discuss their views on different town, school, and county issues.

2:08:45 5.30, we'll have County Superintendent of Schools, we have both candidates have confirmed. 6.00 p.m., Town Council candidates, all six candidates have confirmed. And at 7.15, our County Supervisors Districts 1 and 5, four of the five candidates have confirmed their attendance. Strategic leadership at all levels is more important now than ever before. Please join us. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Yeah.

2:09:13 Mr. Mayor, if I can make a comment. We've received several comments related to the condition of our flags flying over town offices here. We have followed up with the owners of the mall who's responsible for that. At a minimum in that condition, just at a minimum to take those down. Our goal obviously would be to have good quality flags up, but to have them.

2:09:34 Kind of in torn condition is not acceptable. So we've asked that that would be addressed. We've done that a while back and I've reconfirmed that today again that we'd like to see that addressed. Good. Thank you very much. So just to be clear, those flags are not under the control of the town. Correct. The flags are associated with the building and the building management, correct? Correct. They're not, yeah, they're not part of the town of Mammoth Lakes responsibility. Excellent. Thank you very much. One other.

2:10:00 Aside, the town attorney, is he, will he be joining us? The town attorney will be joining us. He's gotten pulled into a telephone conference call regarding a lawsuit in the town of Truckee. Okay. So he's in the middle of that. When he's free, he will be, he's in the building here, so when he's free, he will be. But, and you will be providing the clerk services, is that correct? I will be providing the clerk services at this point as well as. Well, we're not going to trust you for the legal services. I'm not going to do the legal services. We'll let you do the clerk services. Okay.

2:10:28 All right. Thank you very much. So any other public comments? Again, hearing none. So we'll move on now to any additions to the agenda this evening. Dan, I don't believe we have any. None. Okay. Thank you. Reports from commissions and or departments. Mr. Dutton. Grady Dutton, Public Works. Just one comment. We do have our annual Lakes Basin Reds Meadow Road opening meeting with the...

2:10:52 U.S. Forest Service this Friday morning. As soon as we understand what's going on up there, we'll let everybody know. I'm sure the Forest Service will put out a press release as well. Our preliminary look over the gate, if you will, is that it's certainly a heck of a lot better than last year.

2:11:06 And we are ready to offer to the Forest Service that, with their permission, of course, we're ready to start on Monday, if necessary, to move snow and get it cleaned up. We do not know what their assessment is yet, so I certainly am not speaking for them. But we are meeting on Friday, and as soon as we have any word, we'll make sure we get it out to the public, because the fishing opener is the 28th. Excellent. Thank you. Questions? No. Thank you. Mr. Rathje. Thank you, Councilmembers.

2:11:36 Just wanted to take a moment to announce that we're on year 10 with the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Trail Days events. And so with the 10th season in mind, I just wanted to announce the dates so people could save the dates. June 2nd is National Trails Day. We'll have our first event. And we're not exactly sure yet, right? So I'm going to announce all four dates.

2:12:03 Get them on your calendar, and then we'll come forward with further details in the future. July 14th is the second day. August 11th is the third. And September 15th is the Great Sierra River Cleanup in the Lakes Basin. We do that each year. Encourage you to join us. Each event takes place between 8.30 and 1 p.m. in the afternoon. Free bagel breakfast, great lunch. And we plan on...

2:12:30 Just like last year, doing work on new trail construction minus the trail days cleanup, people were very excited to be working on new trail projects last year. It was a lot of fun, and we encourage everyone to get out and implement what we're calling sustainable recreation. As you heard earlier, Forest Service could use a little help these days, and the more people that show up on these events, the more help we can devote to these great causes. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you very much.

2:13:02 Evening, Council, Mayor, members of the community. Stuart Brown, Parks and Recreation Department. Just a quick update, Town Cleanup Day. It's May 12th. It's a big day for the community. I want to make sure everyone has the opportunity to grab some bags, which are available in the town offices right now and at the Mammoth Disposal Transfer Station. So come and grab your free bags, complimentary bags, maximum of five per person or property or individual or organisation. So the more people, the better.

2:13:31 Do also want to say that information will be out this weekend in the green sheet. So that's on Friday. So all the information will be there. And then you'll see some larger page information regarding the Town Cleanup Day stations closer to the event, which was Saturday, May 12th. Any questions from Council? Any questions for Stuart? No. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. Anybody else? Department, staff, anybody?

2:14:00 Okay, thank you. So now we'll move on to public presentation. We're very pleased to be able to welcome our friends and colleagues from the county for a voter outreach information presented by Mono County Clerk Recorder Registrar. Clerk Recorder Registrar, is that right? Yep. Okay. Shannon Kendall and Mono County Assistant Clerk Recorder Registrar Helen Nunn. Thanks for coming down.

2:14:24 Good evening, Councilmembers. Thank you for letting us come. We were hoping, I know there's not a lot of people in the room, but we figured over Granicus and maybe the TV we could reach a lot of people in Mammoth. This is a very general, basic voter outreach information presentation. It's going to touch on important dates and various things that are coming up rather quickly at this point. And just to begin with,

2:14:47 Just we want to say that this is we're offering this as information only. I'm going to interrupt you one second. Could someone maybe tweak that monitor a little bit? Thank you. Sorry. There we go. Thank you very much. Yeah. Thank you. So we're not here to endorse any candidate or contest. We're unable to discuss anything that's on the ballot. We're really just here to provide useful tips and information to voters that will enhance their voting experience, both by mail and in person. So just a little disclaimer.

2:15:21 A reminder about Election Day is Tuesday, June 5th. All the polls around the county open at 7 a.m. and they close at 8 p.m. And a reminder of where our polls are located, we have the Walker Community Center, Bridgeport Memorial Hall, the June Lake Community Center, Mammoth Lakes High School, Crowley Lake Community Center, and Chalfont Community Center. And for Mammoth, of course, we have all five of your precincts within the high school, so we've made it more convenient that way.

2:15:48 I think this will be about the third election that we're doing at the high school, and it seems to work out really good. Voter registration. Some people may be wondering if they are registered to vote. Easy way to tell is just give us a call at our office at 760-932-5537. There's also a Secretary of State website, a little, you just put in your name, and I think you have to put in, I don't know if it's your...

2:16:12 Last four of your social, or I think that's what it is. Anyways, and it will let you know, and that's at votersstatus.sos.ca.gov. So if you're not sure if you're registered, there's easy ways to check. And a reminder that the deadline to register to vote is midnight on Monday, May 21st, so there's still time for people to register to vote if they have not. And there's easy ways to register to vote. You can go to the SOS website at registertovote.ca.gov.

2:16:40 And that's the fastest method. We now interface with VoteCal. It's the system of record for the state, and it's immediate. It's actually real time. So as soon as we push the button to accept the registrations in, as long as nothing's missing, it's immediate. So that's the fastest way to do it. And then, of course, you can still request a paper form from our office. They're at the library. They're at schools. And then you would just make sure to return that back to our office in person or by mail. So pretty easy to register to vote.

2:17:10 And we are really trying to get this information out to everybody. Has anybody moved since the last election? Even if you have stayed at the same P.O. box, but your physical address has moved, and this is especially important in Mammoth, your precinct may have changed. And there's no way for us to know that unless you notify us. You can re-register to vote. That's easy. You can just go in and re-register with your new address. And also...

2:17:35 We just sent out residency confirmation postcards. I think we did that back in March. We're required to do that by law to every single voter. And if your mailing address is incorrect, you never got the postcard. And they get returned to us. And if they're returned to us, which we got quite a few back, one thing, we have to pay for them for every single one that's returned. And secondly, you know, we don't have the right information. So that's a concern to us. So I would say if nobody, if, you know, anybody here did not receive their postcard.

2:18:02 Or if you're listening on Granicus and you didn't receive your postcard, please contact us because we probably have your mailing address incorrect. And so, yeah, you must contact us by telephone or in writing. You can re-register to vote. Now, if we did receive your postcard back, there's a possibility that we will inactivate you in the system, which doesn't mean you cannot vote at the polls, but it means you will vote provisionally. So don't be surprised if – because that's the only way we can clean up the rules. So we're just trying to get –

2:18:31 You know, people to so we can correct it so that in elections going forward, you know, we'll save money on postage and everything else. So we're really biting the bullet this time and inactivating people. But you can still vote at the polls. And we're hoping if people don't receive their card or they haven't received their guide, they're going to let us know and we can correct it prior to the vote by mails going out. And again, if you voted provisionally at the last election, definitely contact the elections office so that we can correct your information.

2:19:00 And I'm going to turn it over to Helen. I did want to mention we have some handouts in the back that have all of this information as far as the websites and the phone numbers and everything like that that you can pick up. There's little cards back there. A little plug, we're looking for poll workers for Mammoth still. I think we need five or six or seven. We'll take as many as we can get. So if you know anybody that would be interested in volunteering to be a poll worker, you do get a stipend, so you get paid for it. It's not a ton, but...

2:19:25 But it's a great way to get involved in your community and, you know, offer service and you learn a lot and I think most of the people that do perform as pool workers enjoy the experience. So, again, just have them contact our office. We can get them signed up. We have some trainings coming up shortly so the sooner the better if anybody's interested or if you know of anybody. I think that's my part and I'm going to turn it over to Helen and then if we have questions at the end. Thank you for having us. Helen, an assistant registrar.

2:19:53 So this year, brand new for this year, is conditional voter registration. It's very similar to on-site registration other states have had in the past. It's basically if you miss the 15-day cutoff to register to vote or update your information, you still have the opportunity to register, but it must be done in person in the office in Bridgeport. The good thing about that is that we will register you, hand you a ballot right then. You can vote at our counter.

2:20:23 We hold it until election day to make sure that a second vote hasn't come in in another county somewhere in the state, and then your vote will be counted. So even if you miss the 15-day cutoff for the registration, you still have the opportunity to register and vote. It's just a little bit more technical. The time period for that is literally 14 days prior to election day. It is May 22nd through and including the day of the election, June 5th.

2:20:54 Two basic ways to vote. Voters are either registered to vote in person at their polling place, or they are registered as permanently by mail. The voter can change their status at any time. They just need to contact us either by phone, in writing. It's a basic application. Once the voter's information guide goes out, there will also be...

2:21:15 A request on the back panel of that guide to request to become a permanent vote-by-mail voter. Right now in the county, we've got about 50-50, 50% of the polling plays, 50% by mail, and every year we see those numbers going more and more in favor of voting by mail. I've heard some concern that vote-by-mails are not counted. That is absolutely not true. We start counting them immediately. They are definitely counted.

2:21:42 The vote by mail request period is May 7th through May 29th because we are prohibited after May 29th from mailing out vote by mail ballots and at that point the conditional registration comes in and we can hand a ballot over the counter. Vote by mail ballots can be dropped off at any Mono County polling location regardless of what precinct you happen to be in. They're put into a locked box. They will be counted that evening. Vote by mail ballots mailed

2:22:13 Have to be, well, vote by mail either have to be dropped off in the elections office or at the polling location no later than 8 p.m. on election day, or they can also be postmarked on election day and received in our office no later than three days later. So even if you're traveling, you can still drop them off at your local post office, and as long as we get them three days later, it still will be counted. The state...

2:22:38 Voter Information Guides with all the state races will go out from Sacramento between April 26th and May 15th. And your local voter information guides with all the local races and measures will go out, they are scheduled to go out on April 26th. So again, to reiterate what Shannon said earlier, if you don't get that voter information guide within, say, a week and a half to two weeks tops after April 26th, we may have your mailing address wrong. Give us a call.

2:23:07 Go on the state website, check your voter registration, and make sure what they have is correct, or just we can do the same over the phone. This year we are very excited to announce we have new equipment for our elections. If you've ever voted at the poll in Mono County, you'll know that sometimes our scanners would give you little hiccups and beep at you and pull the ballot out and flip it over. This year we have all new equipment.

2:23:34 I like to joke that this equipment is very pretty, but it really is. We're very, very excited. It is so user-friendly. It's going to create such a better voting experience for the voters, a better working experience for the poll workers. Very excited to start our training for our poll workers next week to see what their reactions are going to be. The technology is very user-friendly. It's very secure.

2:24:00 All of our local security measures are on par with the state requirements, which are very high. And we just want to reassure every Mono County voter that this election process is safe. We are protected. They are protected. Shannon and myself are dedicated and devoted to handling the elections efficiently and accurately. And again, just reiterating our elections contact info. Our phone number, if you're listening.

2:24:29 Our email address is elections, plural, at mono.ca.gov. Our website is www.monocounty.ca.gov backslash elections. Shannon is our registrar of voters. Her email is skendall at mono.ca.gov.

2:24:55 I am Helen, the assistant. My email is hnun at mono.ca.gov. And our Secretary of State's website, www.sos.ca.gov backslash elections. And again, I want to remind everyone, we do have our handouts in the back of the room.

2:25:15 We are looking for poll workers. We've got our little business cards with our basic number on them. Just if you want to contact us for any questions elections related, we'll be happy to help. Our handout in the back has basically all of this information repeated so that you have something in writing. And we are also going to make sure that that information is available on our website so that you don't feel like picking up the phone. You don't even have to do that.

2:25:39 Yes. Yeah, thank you. And that's pretty much all we have to present. But, of course, if anybody has any questions, we're... Thank you very much. Thanks to both of you for coming down. Any questions from the council? Yeah, I have a question. How much is the stipend? I think it's... What's the hourly rate? I want to say it's 10 an hour. Something like that. It depends on what position you have. The poll workers get... Like, we have poll workers, of course, and then we have inspectors, one at each...

2:26:04 Precinct. And then we have two coordinators at the Mammoth. And the Mammoth ones, which we already have those positions filled. So it's really not a ton of money. It's like nine, maybe nine bucks an hour. And they can work all day. They can work half day. You know, we're willing to work with whatever time we can get from people. Oh, okay. And there's snacks. Oh, and there's... Sign me up. And there's aesthetically pleasing voting equipment. Yes, pretty equipment. Okay, thank you.

2:26:33 Just a couple quick questions. Does the state of California require that there's a paper analog ballot that goes in combination with the electronic procedure? Is there an analog record of the votes that were cast? Yes. Like a digital scan? Is that what you're asking? There's a physical, non-digital object that records the vote. Yes. Yes, there is.

2:27:00 We have our new equipment. So basically at the polling places, you'll have the paper ballot that you feed in and then it gets put onto a CF card. You know, all the results, it's going to be tabulated on the CF card that will end up back at our office. But in our office, the tabulators actually have, we have an adjudication process now. So yes, every single ballot then will be scanned. We can actually pull up ballots, which will help like when you have to duplicate a ballot and things like that. We will have an actual.

2:27:29 Copy of the ballot. Once we handle those ballots once, we should not have to handle them again. We should have, you know, a copy, a digital copy of every single ballot. So that's pretty exciting. That's going to help a lot. And I think, you know, keep things very clean. Okay. And these are the same systems that will be used in November, I'm assuming, right? Yes. Okay. I hope so.

2:27:48 Okay. We're in big trouble. Yeah. And finally, a provisional, if you vote with a provisional ballot, what is the status of that? I mean, explain that a little bit. So in past years, yeah, this is a good question. So in past years, we have had these edge machines, okay? And that's basically a machine that was certified by the state, then decertified, and then they said, oh, well, you can use them for your provisional ballots. And so that's what we've had at the polling places for years and years and years. Basically, they have a touchscreen. You had to put in one of those little cards, blah, blah, blah.

2:28:18 We're doing it different this year because with the new equipment, we're going to actually issue each voter a paper ballot. So they'll get a ballot for their precinct. They'll mark it. It will go into a special envelope that's their pink and they're just for provisionals. They'll go into a locked box. They will come back to our office. We do. I will say we do not process provisionals on election night. That will happen maybe a day or two afterwards because we have to make sure that everybody that voted is allowed to vote. You know, there's not a duplicate something or.

2:28:47 You know, they're not registered. If they're not registered to vote, then it's not going to count. So the status, meaning that those get counted probably within two or three days after the election, and then we will put out another official report that will tell you with those ballots added in for what counts. Right. Yeah, so. Good. I think, and finally, was there a question we had about dates for certification? Yeah, for certifying the election, I think you have 30 days. I think it's 30 days. I don't have that date.

2:29:17 Right off the top of my head. But it can be done sooner pending. It will. I mean, well, I'm not going to say that too quickly, but it should be done well before the 30 days. The things we have to do, though, are, yes, process the provisionals. Any vote-by-mails that come in three days past Election Day, those won't be in the semi-official tally. They'll be in the official tally. And then, of course, we have to do our 1% manual hand count. And so we just have to have the time to do that. But, yeah, I would anticipate going to the board with this.

2:29:46 You know, the certification before the 30 days is up. That's our goal. Okay, thank you very much. Very much appreciate you guys coming down. And, you know, everybody from the public, they've given out all of their information. It's all right there. Yep, and if you don't know, if your address is wrong, we need it fixed because we just want to clean up the rolls. And we're able to do it over the phone. We can do whatever. We'll help however we can to get it right. So we just don't like people disappointed at the polls because if we don't have the right mailing address and they go to...

2:30:15 Or physical address is worse. Then they can't vote in the machines, which of course we want them to be able to do. So we just need to clean things up. Excellent. Thank you very much. Yeah. Thank you. Did you guys just break the computer? No, I'm trying. I was just going to get this off of here. But did you want us to switch it back to off of presentation for you? Oh, you got it? All right. All righty.

2:30:41 Because you're going to, you need to take it off. I know this because I do it. Yes. Thank you. Thank you guys very much. Very much appreciated. Okay, next we're going to move on to a council presentation. And this is the Certificate of Appreciation to Retiring Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, John Helm. Thank you. If I could invite Brian Picken, our transit manager, and John to join me for a couple minutes.

2:31:11 I'll let Brian describe John's career here lately, and John wants to say a few words as well. But just on my behalf, or on John's behalf from my viewpoint, I first met John in my job interview. And he obviously did a great job. Somehow I got the job. But anyway, that's where I first met John. And every interaction I've had with him in almost four years has been positive, whether it's dealing with gray line issues, very frankly, and sore subjects and things like that. He's handled them all professionally.

2:31:39 Been very succinct, been very clear, very concise, very professional, and a great demeanor. And so I've really enjoyed working with him for the last three and a half years. Sorry he's moving on. Completely understand it. And with that, I want to turn it over to Brian for a second, because Brian is our Transit Manager, as well as Airport Manager. Works with John on an almost daily basis on routes and service and all sorts of things. Thanks, Grady. Mayor Wentworth, Councilmember, is Brian Picken Airport.

2:32:06 Airport and Transit member. I've known John for about 10 years, and it's just been a pleasure. I think every now and then you get lucky, and you just get somebody who has a lot of expertise, a great personality, ability to work with all different types of people, somebody who really listens to the public, and who really tries to do his best every day. I just have a lot of respect for him. Some of the things I've worked with him on are refining the JPA,

2:32:34 Which we did some time ago. The Town of Mammoth Lakes contract itself and lease for the transit center. During his time here, he's probably increased service to the Town of Mammoth Lakes by hundreds of hours. More stops, more lines, making Gray Line used to be half a year, went to year round. Adjusting Purple Line, Gray Line routes, Lakes Basin route,

2:33:03 Putting bike trailers on the Lakes Basin route, which has really been a really good thing. Adjusting the blue line so that it, there was no interruption of service between day and night services. Working with the red line, you know, all the lines, all the services. During this time, John also took over or did a contract with Mammoth Island Ski Area so that Essa and

2:33:33 And the Reds Meadow, so that it was sort of a seamless entity. So if you're riding on a bus, it was ESTA. He also worked with Mono County, Inyo County, City of Bishop, and to provide better service really to the whole region and really created a regional transit system from Palmdale to Reno Airport. And that really was a good thing.

2:34:02 Mammoth Lakes is now nationally known as a place where you don't need to have a car when you come here. You can get out of your car and not get back into it for a week. We've got some national recognition for that. I guess to sum it all up, he's been a great person to work with. He's always very calm, well informed, works well with everybody, and I think he's going to be missed by everybody. I'm going to miss him.

2:34:32 And I just want to thank him for all his service. Thanks, John. I don't do this great, but Grady, thank you, and Brian, thank you very much for the kind words. I just have to say it's been my distinct honor and privilege to be a part of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority for these past year, 10 years, and to be a part of bringing, from the inception of the authority, and bringing it to the place that it is today, truly a regional service provider, as Brian pointed out.

2:35:07 But particularly in the community of Mammoth Lakes. And that said, I need to take a moment and step back from accepting these kind words in recognition to say a big, big thank you to the entire community of Mammoth Lakes, Town Council, Town Staff, and the citizens of Mammoth Lakes for unfailingly supporting transit service in the area. And I can tell you absolutely that that

2:35:34 Support and the services that we, the extensive year-round services that have been developed during that period of time make this community a much better place. And it's really thanks to the entire community and town government for being supportive of that. So again, it's been my honor and privilege to have been involved like this. I greatly appreciate the recognition this evening.

2:35:56 I look forward to seeing everybody around the area in the future, just not during the summer months. John, thank you very much. On behalf of the community, the council, staff, everybody, we've really enjoyed having you here. You've done great work. And because you've done great work, it is our honor to present you with a certificate of appreciation. And perhaps we could gather down here, and the photographers will gather around, and we will memorialize this moment. Thank you. Okay, let's go down here. You want us down there, too?

2:36:35 Thank you, John. Thanks again. And you're not leaving town tonight. We look forward to seeing you around in some, I think maybe an LTC meeting or two before you go. Maybe a couple LTC meetings before you go? Great. Okay, good.

2:37:27 You haven't seen the last of John Helm. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay, so we're going to move on now to item number four, approve the proclamations, declaring April 2018 as Child Abuse Prevention and Sexual Assault Awareness Month. And who do we have here?

2:37:47 Hi, I'm Giselle Kenny. Thank you, Town Council and Mayor, for having me here. I thought I would start off with some statistics on state and national sexual assault, as well as child abuse, and then we can go through the proclamations. So in California, there is an estimated 2 million female survivors of rape alone.

2:38:10 There is an estimate of 8.6 million survivors of both genders of sexual assault other than rape. 3 million are male survivors and 5.6 million are women survivors. Nationally, it is 1 in 5 women have been raped in their lifetime. 1 in 2 women have experienced sexual violence, which equates to more than 53 million individuals on the national level.

2:38:34 Child abuse, 37% of children in the U.S. are reported to CPS by their 18th birthday. The highest rate of child abuse is in children under than a year old. In 2016, it is estimated that 1,750 children died to abuse, and neglect is the most common form of abuse. Four out of five abusers are the victim's parents.

2:38:57 Those are the basic statistics. We have a couple events going on. April 25th is Denim Day, so please wear your pants to show support. As well as on April 25th at 9 a.m., the Mono County Office of Education is putting on a Children's Memorial Flag Raising event, and that will start at 9 a.m. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you very much. Does anybody from the audience like to add anything to this? Those are sobering statistics, and thank you for sharing those with us.

2:39:27 Yeah, sorry. I just wanted to add, you know, I appreciate you guys making this month the awareness for both of these horrendous acts. It takes awareness first in order to address these issues, so thank you. Yes, thank you very much, Giselle. So I'm going to read some excerpts from both of the resolutions, and then do we vote on this?

2:39:49 Okay, good. So I'm going to read. I'll read extras of both of the resolutions. I'll do a motion to move both of them forward. So the first is a proclamation of the Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, declaring April 2018 as Child Abuse Prevention Month, whereas approximately five children die every day due to child abuse and neglect.

2:40:10 And whereas in 2015 there were 4 million child abuse referrals made, and whereas children are vital to our community's future success and quality of life, as well as being our most vulnerable assets. Whereas Wild Iris requests public support and assistance as it continues its effects to bring real hope for ending child abuse in the town of Mammoth Lakes and creating a future where all children can live free from abuse. Now therefore be it proclaimed.

2:40:37 That in recognition of the important work done by Wild Iris and all victim service providers, let it be resolved that the Mammoth Lakes Town Council proclaims April 2018 as Child Abuse Prevention Month. So that's that. I'll read the second one and then we'll entertain a motion and vote on that. A proclamation of the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, declaring April 2007, April 2018, a little typo there on the staff report, April 2018 is Sexual Assault Awareness Month.

2:41:07 Whereas rape, sexual assault, and sexual harassment harm our communities and statistics show that 1 in 5 women and 1 in 71 men all experience sexual assault during their lifetime. And whereas child sexual abuse prevention must be a priority to confront the reality that 1 in 6 boys and 1 in 4 girls will experience a sexual assault before age 18. And whereas young people experience heightened rates of sexual violence and youth ages 12 to 17 are 2.5 times as likely to be victims of rape or sexual assault.

2:41:36 Whereas Wild Iris requests all residents of Mammoth Lakes to pledge to join advocates and communities across the country in taking action to prevent sexual violence. Now, therefore, be it proclaimed in recognition of the important work done by Wild Iris and all victim service providers, let it be resolved that the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, State of California, hereby designates the month of April 2018, the Sexual Assault Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. So I would entertain a motion to...

2:42:03 I'll make a motion that we approve the proclamations declaring April 2018 as Child Abuse Prevention and also Sexual Assault Awareness Month. Thank you. Is there a second? I'll second. Thank you. All those in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. Do you need a roll call or no? It's up to you. We don't have to on this one. Okay. So all those in favor say aye. Aye. Opposed? Nay. The motion is agreed to unanimously. So Giselle, if you come up here, we'll give you these beautiful proclamations.

2:42:33 Make sure I get the right ones. Oh, that's a different one. Okay, good. Who's taking a picture of this one? This is important. John helps nice, but this is important. All right, moving along. Okay, so now we're moving on to item number five, in which we're going to approve the proclamation recognizing April is Distracted Driver Awareness Month. And who would like to speak to this?

2:43:23 I would. Thank you, sir. Good evening. Yes, distracted driving takes on many forms. It's not just cell phones and texting. It's eating. It's reaching for something that's fallen. It's putting on makeup. There's a variety of things. And when we're driving, we should be driving, and that should be our primary thing that we do. If you're on the freeway, 70, 80 miles an hour, within a second, you can travel about 500 feet.

2:43:46 That's quite a ways. So any time you take your eyes off the road that things can happen and just want to make everyone aware that there's all forms of distracted driving. Also, CHP takes this month really seriously. Not that we don't, but we want compliance more than enforcement in Mammoth, but CHP up and down 395, that's going to be their cup of tea. So just let the public know, everyone know that put the cell phone down, think about not eating and use your

2:44:16 Hands-free devices. That's one of the best ways to utilize your phone in your car. Thank you. I think just to add to that, we had a very interesting LTC meeting in which the horrific accidents that happened over the last couple of months was on the agenda. We had a very good discussion about that.

2:44:30 And part of the discussion was the fact that distracted driving means a lot of different things these days. And there's a lot of discussion about what happens when you're driving, your device is streaming, telling you where you are on a map, you're listening to music, you get into a canyon or something, and all of a sudden the stream gets broken because you've lost your cell service.

2:44:48 All of a sudden, you're distracted. You're distracted in the hazard area where driving requires a maximum amount of attention. I think that this thing really takes on a whole level, whole other levels of importance and seriousness, especially when it's not just as simple as maybe you're talking on a phone or texting, doing things you shouldn't be doing, thinking all the data and all the stuff that your device is doing while you're driving, and that may be a component of distracting you as well. It's a very interesting conversation. I thank you very much for bringing this forward. So I'll read an excerpt from this, and of course, I have a lovely prop.

2:45:17 So, whereas distracted driving is any activity that could divert a person's attention from the primary task of driving, and whereas all distractions endanger driver, passenger, pedestrian, and other road user safety, and whereas distracted driving occurs any time drivers take their eyes off the road, their hands off the wheel, and their minds off their primary task of driving.

2:45:40 And whereas the best way to end distracted driving is to educate all California citizens about the dangers it poses, and now therefore be it resolved that the Town Council of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the State of California hereby recognizes April as Distracted Driving Awareness Month in the Town of Mammoth Lakes and calls this observance to the attention of all citizens and encourages all citizens of Mammoth Lakes to increase their awareness of the dangers of distracted driving and promise to protect each other on the road through distraction-free driving behavior.

2:46:09 Thank you. So I would entertain a motion to adopt this resolution, this proclamation. I'll make a motion that Council approves the proclamation, recognizing April is Distracted Driver Awareness Month. Second. The motion is second. All those in favor? Aye. Any opposition? Hearing none, the proclamations agreed to unanimously. Chief, you can come forward and we'll give you this beautiful document. This chair will come forward and take pictures.

2:46:55 Okay, so now we're moving on to the staff presentation. The council will receive an update on the Mammoth Creek Park West Community Multi-Use Facilities Project. We could have one moment while our assistant, assistant, assistant, town clerk gets it set up. Brady, this is you. Yes, Stu, you can do the keyboard or are you coming over? No, absolutely. Thank you.

2:47:31 I'm not going to go directly to the staff report. Instead, we have a PowerPoint. We tried to get it on Granicus again this afternoon, but again, due to staff changes and staff issues, we weren't able to do that. I do have some handouts which cover that if you'd like a paper copy. Otherwise, I could do it up here. Okay. Thank you. Perfect. Thank you.

2:47:59 To jump, I guess, to the punchline is the bid opening for the multi-use facility project that we've been working on now for basically three and a half years is next Wednesday. We actually had it scheduled for Monday the 23rd to make sure that we got a couple of addendum out and clarifications that some contractors had last week. We're moving it to Wednesday. That's very typical.

2:48:22 In fact, it's probably atypical if a large project doesn't have at least one delayed bid opening. It's just two days. We'll still be before you on May 2nd with recommendations. But what we thought we'd do this evening, and I discussed this with town staff, is go through some of the history. I know we've all heard it before, but there are some members of the public who have not. We hope to provide a very concise history of how we got here today.

2:48:43 And talk about some of the things you'll be looking at next week and how staff has prepared for the May 2nd town council meeting. So again, some of this you've heard before, but a lot of this will be new to some people in the community who haven't been to 31 different town council meetings where this information has been sort of evolving, I guess is the right word, over time.

2:49:08 With that, tonight you're going to hear a little bit on background and history, our site selection process, some of the preliminary design work, programming and preliminary design, public outreach, DIR, and then we'll get you up to speed with where we are today, how the design has evolved the last few months due to some very, very positive programming input. And again, this will all be posted on the website tomorrow, so it'll be available for the public as well as what they can see tonight during the presentation.

2:49:37 Again, this has been before Town Council in actual formal agenda items 31 times. That doesn't count the playground. That doesn't count various site issues. It does count things where we were talking about site selection, about design, about the LA Kings. I actually have behind me a notebook that's twice the size of this that's full of just the council agenda items and staff reports, not the EIR, not the construction documents, everything else. The point is this has been an exhaustive effort to get to this point.

2:50:07 First item up there, 2014. This all started late 2014. I got here in June. I heard about the ice rink and the melting ice in August and how terrible it was going to be. We spent a couple months looking at, frankly, it looked like we were going to string sheets across the top of the ice rink, any way to cover the ice to extend the season. We did that for a few months.

2:50:30 And then staff was asked to come back to Town Council with some ideas about the ice rink. Is it in the right location? Should we move it? What kind of project should it be, very frankly? We entered into some discussions with the school district and came to Town Council on July 15th of 2015 with a recommendation. Hey, we think we should move the ice rink over to Mammoth Creek Park West exactly as it is now.

2:50:56 You know, grab up the boards as best we can, get whatever plexiglass isn't completely broken, bring it over and install it at Mammoth Creek Park. Town Council didn't agree with that, actually. What Town Council instead did was ask us to go back to a subcommittee of, actually a group of MLR and the Recreation Commission and Town Council member and say, look, take a serious look at this. Don't just...

2:51:18 Tumble down the road, just don't have a knee-jerk reaction, but instead take a very solid look at the whole process, look at various sites throughout town where it might be, look at what amenities might be placed with that and come back to us.

2:51:31 I'll skip a little bit, but in that first meeting, we actually talked about temporary covers. We talked about location. We talked about complementary uses. And in October of 2015, we came back to Town Council, the Recommission and MLR group, let's say. It wasn't actually staff. We put together the staff report, but it was a recommendation from that group about what to do with the multi-use facility.

2:51:54 In 2016, we had seven items that came back. And the last one of that, I'll get to some milestones in a second, but the last item is that was that the council approved that concept that was brought forward by that group, if you would, of MLR and Rec Commission and gave direction to staff of how we should move forward with preliminary design and environmental documentations.

2:52:17 2017 came before you 10 times. Various items, the last one being the initial discussion on the Kings, which was actually postponed in late December, but it was before you very briefly. The IR was certified during 2017, and we got direction to proceed with all the final working drawings. 2018, four more items. So the key thing is this next sheet, which is the milestones. December 2014, the project.

2:52:44 Was somehow stretch a cover over the existing ice rink. That was the project. July of 2015, the project was sent to a group of MLR and rec commission to say, look, see where it should be, what it should be, what kind of complementary uses might work with that facility. October, the town council accepted that recommendation. That recommendation was basically a 30,000 square foot.

2:53:08 Roof closed in on two sides over an Olympic-sized ice rink. Actually, I think it became Olympic-sized in December. In October, it was still NHL-sized with the complementary use of a community center and a reenactment or a revisioning, if you will, of the existing playground to include more inclusive components. On April 2016, the council, in a formal action, approved the project description that went forward into the EIR process.

2:53:36 It, frankly, I would say only took 13 months to get from acceptance of a project description for a certification of an EIR. We would like to have been a little bit shorter, but if you ask around other municipalities, I think that was pretty quick, frankly, to do that in 13 months. Since that time,

2:53:54 We've completed plans and specs late last year. You awarded the site work contract, which we're anticipating doing a notice to proceed on that sometime in May. And on May 2nd, we're going to come back to you for consideration of the award. A lot of these next ones you've seen a few times, so I'm not going to spend a lot of time on. Again, this package will be available to the public.

2:54:15 But the history, it was actually in some of the facilities plans for the county, and it was for the very first ones in the town in 1988, which said we need an ice rink, it's a high priority. This is the 1999 site plan for the project that actually went through an EIR, which was not certified, it did not proceed. It was very interesting just a few days ago just to take a look back at this, and I encourage you all to do that when you have a chance, because

2:54:40 It is not at all like what we're doing today. It is not the same project. It is an open-air rink, which would have had the same issues with the weather that one we have today. It has much more impacts on the neighbors, and it does have a community center, but it has a lot of other activities there that really won't work. A couple of quick shots of the existing facility, and I'll ask Stu to just go ahead and walk through this, because this is what your staff has been operating for the last few years, Stu.

2:55:07 Yeah, just a really brief background. This is kind of your Google view of the map of the airport, sorry, of the ice rink currently at the school district there. This is our existing facility as we operate it today. I mean, you can just take note on the left-hand side there of all the blankets that we have to cover the ice with on the edges and the corners, and we rope it all off. And this is kind of during our Christmas period, during our highest visitation area, and we're already into mitigating and controlling the ice surface to make it safe for our users. So it's a real challenge.

2:55:37 Top right photo is pretty much all of last year. And then the Kings are low bags. That's kind of how we welcome our tournaments and groups to our facility. So not the greatest. This was during Christmas time. Again, during our peak time. These are the people waiting to kind of get on the ice right after we finished our tournaments and people lined up. And this was what it was like for two weeks during the holidays. So extremely, extremely busy time. Just gives you a brief update on how we went.

2:56:06 Last year on performance and how busy it was. So over 10,000 people visited that facility in pretty much three months. As you can see, we didn't open in November, had a few days in March through March 3rd, I think, or the 4th. And you can see the red is this year and the blue was last year. So a significant increase from previous visits. And this is our 10 year or plus history of being in that location, 2007.

2:56:31 Through 2009-10 was when we were on that site, but it was not a permanent facility. We essentially put the dasher boards up and the glass up and down every year, so it was very labour intensive. 2010-11 was when we actually installed a concrete slab, so we didn't operate that year, and then you can see successive years since that time have been fluctuated based on snow, but again, the biggest year was when we had the most demand, the latent demand for that facility was...

2:57:00 Over 11,000 people, and again, last year was 10,000, so good visitation. Thank you. As I said, that rec commission MLR group looked at six different sites within towns. They were asked to look at locations that were town-owned and managed. In addition, the EIR looked at three alternatives, one the Civic Center site, one the bell-shaped parcel, and one of reconfiguration of the project on that site.

2:57:27 After the site was selected, again by town council, we set about a site planning study. We actually brought three very different alternatives to the community. We had a site walk. We had a session in here with Charette's.

2:57:42 It came down to alternative A being the selected one. It was then slightly modified based on comments from the community about the distance from the west property line, about the playground, about parking, about a few other things. And this is the alternative that was then sent on for the environmental analysis. After we'd done, again, a scoping, if you will, of what the project should be, a multi-use facility, rec zone, ice rink.

2:58:08 And after we've done a site selection process, and by we I mean definitely the community staff was facilitating it at best. And third, after getting into some of the site design issues, it was considered and presented to town council that the programming really should drive the design of the facility. We did not have at that time and didn't ever have through that part of the process a set budget. It was, look,

2:58:32 If we're going to do this, let's see what the community needs are, see what the municipal and visitor needs are, and let's design a facility for that and then see where we go from there. So, Stu? Yeah, so we've talked numerous times about planning your park process, and it was specifically about Mammoth Creek Park. This kind of just gives you a brief overview. I won't spend a lot of detail with it, but the output really of that two-year planning process through the Recreation Commission.

2:58:58 Was to develop these playbooks. And the playbooks really kind of dictated the community's desired programming in and around that facility. So it was all to do with three areas, one being the ice rink itself, the summer rec zone, and then the community centre. We also took into account the design considerations relative to the relationship between the activities.

2:59:19 The complementary aspect, and that was a big part of why we wanted to integrate the facilities and include a community centre with the ice rink and how they can kind of work with and for each other during kind of year-round operations. And then we also looked at how efficient economies of scale, storage space, and how we can kind of, you know, design that facility that it met all those needs. These were the goals. I don't have to read them all, but these were the goals that were developed by the Recreation Commission two years ago relating to the Mammoth Creek Park process.

2:59:48 Again, really the takeaway here is the main one we think was number four really to kind of create that recreation destination for the community where all of these amenities could be centralized that would make it far more convenient and accessible for our community.

3:00:03 To utilize these recreation activities, programs, amenities, and such that, you know, the project now is grown to being an inclusive playground. It's grown to being that natural play area and how we integrate the natural play spaces in the creek. So to really create that kind of that area that, you know, the community will really be proud to call their park. So it's kind of that town within a park concept. Again, there's a quote from our chair of the Recreation Commission.

3:00:31 So I really wanted to make sure that the programming informed design. And then plan your park process included all that activity and that programming input. So you can see it was very extensive.

3:01:03 It was advertised early in March. We had a non-mandatory pre-vid conference on April 11th. So if we don't do those non-mandatory, because some of these car brakes don't want to miss a good bid. It's just not, you just don't want to make that mistake on mandatory conferences.

3:01:26 It's not a good idea. Even at that, we had almost 15 people here in the room. We've had over 30 companies pull plans for the project. Some of them suppliers, some of them subcontractors. We think we have five or six general contractors that are serious about taking a look at the project. We've got afternoon tonight, how many vids are we going to get? One, three, six.

3:01:48 You just never know until bid day next Wednesday. If we get four or five, we'll be, you know, we'll be pretty happy because that'll tell us, tell us some numbers about what this thing's going to cost. The bid opened, and we said, actually, again, we can have an agenda today, and we have another one going out tomorrow. Every question that a contractor asks of these means, we note, we put them in writing, we send them to everybody for another plan to be over.

3:02:13 Yeah, so I'm just going to run through kind of the changes that have been made.

3:02:39 To the design of the facility based on the programming. So we'll kind of start with the year-round community-based programming first. And the process has been to continually evaluate and revise the playbooks. And it's been an organic, progressive process, as we've talked about.

3:02:56 And it's consisted really of looking at last year's visitation to the rink, last year's kind of use of that facility. It was probably the best baseline we could look at in regards to the use of that facility. None of the programs were impacted really whatsoever from weather, apart from the ice surface itself, but were able to really enhance the use of that facility through our curling leagues, drop-in programs, free Olympic curling sessions, the lesson programs, you know.

3:03:23 We're hugely popular. Youth hockey, adult hockey actually had a night that they can actually play on. They needed more people because John's got a short line and needs a bit more, you know, ice time. But anyway, it has been a very progressive process and we've continued to visit facilities, talk to folks and really kind of truly understand how we can continue to refine the design of the facility so it works for the desired programming.

3:03:50 That's something that we've really seen clear with a lot of the facilities that we've visited. So just maybe talking about winter ice, which I kind of did before, really the change has been to really look at...

3:04:04 Providing an ice surface that has variable and different ice characteristics. Different ice activities have different ice temperatures. Hockey's certainly harder. Figure skating's certainly softer. Everybody's in between. Figure skating, because of their jumps, their picks, and, you know, all their activities, requires a thicker ice surface.

3:04:22 And other surfaces a little bit thinner. So we really needed to find a refrigeration system that could kind of provide the varying degrees of those characteristics. We also looked at kind of an opportunity to extend the operations of the facility up into at least September through May. That was a period of time that came forth through kind of some discussions with our partners and so forth that there was an opportunity to be able to kind of make ice during a warmer period of time.

3:04:50 And that meant kind of some revisions to the design. And then we talked about kind of what we went through this year in regards to programming. And you can see the list of the desired programming right now. So just looking at kind of how we went about and did that, the photo on the left there, that big image, is the Olympic ice sheet at the Toyota Sports Centre. They have three different rink sizes. They have kind of a smaller...

3:05:15 A rink they use for kind of recreational skating. They have an NHL rink, which is the official training site and venue for the LA Kings. And the Olympic ice sheet, which is this one here, is their largest sheet, which hosts a lot of the junior programs, which is this team right now. This is kind of a squirt team. And also, this is the figure skating site. So all the figure skaters are on this side of the ice. And that's the size of an Olympic ice sheet. That's 100 feet wide by 200 feet long.

3:05:41 And that's what we're proposing here because it has such a variety of uses for not only winter but summer that I'll get to. The other one you can see on the top right is Anaheim Ice. That's part of the rink. That's again, they have two sheets, NHL and Olympic ice sheet. And then you can see some winter programming here from curling. Again, looking at the size of the ice sheet, Olympic size, we'll be able to get three sheets for curling. At the moment we're running two and we...

3:06:06 Have more demand than we actually have the size of the sheet. So that was kind of how we went about kind of looking at the programming on the Olympic sheet. In regards to programming as well, we have a consultant that we're working with, American Sports Entertainment Company, that have a desire to kind of program the facility.

3:06:25 Work with us to program the facility on a year-round basis. That's kind of looking at LA Kings branded programs in the wintertime. And then summer LA Galaxy branded programs from their soccer center, which is also part of their facility down there is what they operate and maintain. And I'll have some images there to show you as well. We also talk to a lot of groups. A big part of this facility is really making sure that we can...

3:06:48 Have the amenities needed for larger groups and tournaments. So if we're really looking at hosting large regional, sorry, reasonable and regional and national tournaments, not only in wintertime, but in summertime. Summertime, as we'll talk about, I'll show you some slides, have some really specific needs that need to be provided to be able to host those events and tournaments. And tournaments, as you know, in our community, are a big part of driving our visitation. We are a recreation-based area, and that's a big part of, you know, what we're trying to provide here as well.

3:07:17 Summer demand for our parks and recreation services. We had a workshop with council previously and we were already exceeding kind of the demand for our summer camps. By the end of our first week when we opened our summer camps, we were having 130 kids on a waiting list. You know, we just, we're really struggling fulfilling demand. So how can this facility help us meet the demand now or also in the future time? So that's something that we've taken into consideration. And then community centre uses. You know, what we're seeing right now.

3:07:45 With our reservations for our community centre is growing and growing. You know, the demand continues, but it's a very difficult centre to programme, as we all understand. These are just some of the images. Again, images worth a thousand words. This is the LA Galaxy Soccer Centre. They have, I believe, six futsal fields, or kind of courts, is kind of what they call them, using a sport court.

3:08:10 They have four volleyball courts on the back area, and they also have table tennis going on, and then this TOCA kind of technical-based skills system they have here as well. So that's a little bit of the sense of kind of what we kind of look at in a summer programming time, not only for our, certainly our residents, but certainly for our visitors looking at bringing these groups up.

3:08:30 You know, for this facility, the Olympic size multi-use facility will be able to cater to three of these footsaw courts, which is important. So that's three footsaw courts, three volleyball courts, three basketball courts, nine pickleball courts, one full arena soccer court, soccer field court facility, and then the community centre can host table tennis and so forth. So it's a really expanding program. This is the pavilion up in Bend, Oregon. We took a site visit up there last year.

3:08:59 This is kind of how they operate it. Again, it's a very similar facility. It's an indoor-outdoor facility. You can see this is their summer uses. They have the same. They have four volleyball courts. Again, they wish they had a larger surface to play on. But you can also see the Parks and Recreation Program here with their kind of skate facilities and also, you know, their basketball amenities. And this day camp concept is kind of really what we're looking to mirror here as well.

3:09:26 This is kind of how we've kind of evolved through the process. If you remember, a couple of years ago, we had a facility design that was kind of an open-air facility, very unusable.

3:09:38 Not conditioned, not very comfortable. So we're looking at kind of updating the facility so it actually has a sense of arrival, has a vestibule area, and it's all conditioned space. And a big part of working again with the operators of a lot of these facilities, really want to make sure there was a conditioned space for families, gatherings, groups to come in and actually in a nice controlled environment, watch the activities that were going on and not sit outside like we currently do.

3:10:05 You know, clenching a hot chocolate and only lasting about 10 minutes. So again, it's a far more desirable experience. This was the kind of the last of our elevations for the facility. You can see it has that indoor-outdoor feel and a lot of the feedback that we receive from our communities that have a desire to come up here, particularly hockey, is every facility in Southern California and pretty much around the nation is fully indoors.

3:10:32 You know, the attraction for this facility right now is it's outdoors and that's a big attribute that we have. And they really felt strongly when we talked to a lot of these groups to try and keep this indoor-outdoor. And certainly from our perspective, you know, we have these majestic views that we want to make sure we have an experience and have our guests kind of, you know, be part of as well. So that kind of shows you the indoor-outdoor nature of the facility. And on the far right there, you can see the windows for the community centre.

3:10:59 Real quick, Stu goes through the next few things. He's going to talk about some of the design changes that do have cost implications. The refrigeration system is number one. Some of the locker rooms and showers and things are number two. There's a couple of others. But I just want to assure you that they weren't by any means added willy-nilly. There was a serious amount of discussion on the refrigeration system. That itself probably went on for two months. And we have also...

3:11:26 We considered making a deductive alternate to the bid. The problem with doing that is it would have cost us $40,000 to $50,000 to design a completely duplicate system to include in the bid. So as staff, we thought, you know, let's do our best with this. If it doesn't work out, we can go back and redesign, and I'll talk about some of the alternatives later, but it didn't make a lot of sense to spend that much money on an alternative design that we may not need. But the focus here is on what were the design changes that have cost implications.

3:11:56 Thanks, Stu. Yeah, so we talked about programming and forming design. So here's the design amendments to match the programming needs. And then right at the end of the presentation, we'll get into kind of the cost implications, as Grady said. So here's your refrigeration system here. So the programming determined through not only our local community and certainly our expected visitors and guests at the facility and renters that we needed a more reliable, consistent ice surface. You know, really looking at, you know,

3:12:25 Creating an extended ice surface from essentially September if needed, but essentially it's from October through to kind of mid-April and if we can through May. So we've looked at that system to provide that opportunity. And again, you know, what we're really seeing in our climate, I know there's a climate workshop next week, you know, we experience unreal conditions in January, February. That chiller over there, honestly,

3:12:52 Didn't really keep up. We had to cover it with blankets and all the rest of it. So even if you got a prepackaged unit and put it in that facility, it probably wouldn't be able to keep up with those unreal climate variances that we're seeing. So we've really kind of looked at having a system that provides that full, almost guaranteed ice through the period of time that we're looking at.

3:13:14 So we looked at a different system. It's a custom-designed chiller package and refrigeration system. As I said, it's been spec'd for the facility, but we have some alternates. And as a change to that, it required a larger mechanical room. We thought the room was large at 25 feet, but it had to be 30 feet, apparently. The skid for the system is that large. So we had to kind of do a quick redesign there. And that was the design services that was before Council on February 7th.

3:13:44 The locker room, showers, storage and restrooms. This is an area, again, that we looked at the facility. The original facility, I'll show you some site plans. You can see how it was designed and the changes we've made. So I don't want to spend too much time in here again. But programming, this is what we currently have. If you can call it, you know, a good kind of amenity, that would be great to hear. But honestly, we have one undersized changing room.

3:14:12 Some small restrooms, basic concessions and so forth. That's how we currently operate in three months. So we looked at, you know, designing a locker room situation where we had four locker spaces of really a bare minimum size of about 250 square feet. Typically they range from 250 to kind of 500 essentially. And then typically what you find in most facilities you'll have for each locker room you'll have an adjoining shower space as well.

3:14:39 But what we were able to do here was kind of combine the two locker rooms and in the middle kind of put a shower cubicle. It's a joint shower area, one kind of ADA restroom and then two sinks. So all we've really done is basically provide the opportunity to have the ability to host these tournaments events with four locker rooms and then two adjoining shower spaces and complementary storage. And that was basically it.

3:15:06 Other designs that we've kind of incorporated since we presented six months ago on these, a lot of these items that you're seeing here have been through the Recreation Commission each month. So we've been kind of working with our Recreation Commission on programming. As again, we've really made revisions and updates to the storage, not only the location, the number, the size and the flexibility, we want to make sure that all the storage spaces have flexible uses. So we really kind of looked at where they were and how they...

3:15:34 Complement each of the uses and the designs. The lighting package really was designed to ensure that there was even lighting throughout the entire surface, not only for wintertime but certainly in summertime. So that was revised to make sure it's a good standard. And then we currently the way we manage our ice groomer in the snow and the ice shavings from the facility right now is roll up the garage door, drive the Olympia outside and dump the ice.

3:16:03 Not the most efficient system. So what we're really designed here is an indoor snow pit that is heated through the chiller in the refrigeration system so that the groomer would basically come into that room, sit over the grate, dump it snow, and then it would be heated from the source of the refrigeration chiller system, would melt, and then just run through the sewer system. So a far more efficient and certainly better system that we've kind of designed there.

3:16:30 You can also see we've designed the parking lot really to kind of create this drop-off zone and enhance circulation. What we found when we visited a lot of these facilities, a lot of the parents with their kids are really just dropping them off, right? So they're not really parking a lot. So really what we designed was kind of a turnaround, a drop-off point that they can kind of come in, drop, grab their gear and head inside with no impact to kind of the parking and the circulation and certainly the pedestrian access to the facility.

3:16:56 And then, you know, what we looked at here, originally, one of the facilities at Anaheim Ice had these great sliding viewing windows, and what you're able to do is kind of pull the windows apart. Would have been a great opportunity in summertime to kind of open up that facility. But what we realized was, how many times are we really going to do that? So we kind of...

3:17:17 You know, made a design choice at that time to say, you know, we love the big viewing windows, but for that additional cost, let's go ahead and focus on putting the right floor in the community centre. So the community centre flooring right now, instead of being a laminate floor, actually has cushioned material, which then meets the demand of the programming, which is kind of looking at those, you know.

3:17:39 Gymnastics, tumbling, you know, any type of, you know, interactive kind of sport, yoga or anything would have a, you know, more, you know, enjoyable floor to use. So that was kind of the change there. This just speaks to the kind of the revised site plan. We saw the original one from 1999. It's a bit confusing, but you can see the enhanced parking lot was kind of reorientated. I believe there's about 108 parking spots in here, you know, fully built out. And you can see the little,

3:18:09 Turning circle, the drop-off area right on the left-hand side of your screen, which would gain you direct access into the facility. Well, Stu goes to the next one. The parking lot was reconfigured because if you've been in that parking lot, you realize that it's actually been in our plan to rebuild it very soon anyway. It's one of the worst in town. There's some serious gaps in it. And we thought rather than...

3:18:34 Then grind it down and rebuild in that same configuration. We'd get a lot of traction and make it work a lot better to just go ahead and reconfigure it. It works a lot better. More spaces in a smaller area. No more spaces than was designed, but a lot more compact. Just to orientate everybody where my little mouse is, that is the existing restroom right here. So that stays. And then you can see this space here is the new inclusive playground that we're going to be installing this summer.

3:19:04 Hopefully cutting the ribbon on July 4th. So that's kind of the reorientation of the playground. So it's kind of got spun 180 degrees. Just moving on. I mean, this is kind of where we started in 2017. Actually, well, we started in 2016. But this was the version in August of 2017. This site basically, you know, very similar in design, same footprint. The footprint hasn't changed since we've been through this process.

3:19:30 It's always been the Olympic ice sheet. It's always been a 2,500 square foot community centre, lobby space, concessions area. But really, again, as we focused on was kind of the support areas. That was kind of the locker space, as you can see on the far left. So we had, in this design, we had six locker spaces, but there was no adjoining kind of restrooms or those amenities that could really facilitate that activity. And then you can see the bottom here was the chiller space, mechanical and so forth. And on this next one,

3:19:59 I'm not an architect. This is kind of Stu's sheltered workshop. But I grabbed a sheet. I'm just going to kind of walk you through some of the highlights. This is the latest site plan. The yellow down here, you can see these are the four locker spaces. And you can see what the big change is using this wall on this side of the building. So typically, ice rinks, you would actually see all of the support spaces on the long side of the rink. So because we didn't orientate it that way,

3:20:28 We're using the two sides, the two short ends and half of that long side for the support spaces. So you can see there the two, sorry, the four locker spaces. The pink area, which is very apt for adult hockey players, would be the adjoining showers, toilets and the sinks. The other pink little space here is kind of a family restroom, which is accessible for

3:20:56 Obviously anybody in the facility. Here's the other family restroom in the community centre. The orange spaces are the new storage spaces that we kind of put in. We actually had more storage in more areas than what we found. We had to redesign it based on the mechanical needs. So we have one little storage space here. This area on the corner is specifically for the equipment, the summer storage and the skate sharpening area.

3:21:20 This orange space here is for a multi-storage space for a lot of the equipment, youth hockey, umpires, referees, and so forth. This storage space right here and the main lobby area is again for all our kind of summer, winter gear, equipment, staff space, data storage, janitorial stuff, space. And then these are the storage spaces for the community centre.

3:21:42 And storage is a big thing. It's always kind of under-designed, but we want to make sure this was really kind of taken care of in the facility. Again, a lot of the sites that we did visit were really kind of undersized on storage. The green spaces here, this was kind of what we added, a little office space for staff here. Again, this is the new vestibule area, so this is all conditioned space. These are the big viewing windows. And then there's the red bits, a snow pit that we talked about, and the blue is the chiller.

3:22:12 So that's kind of the changes, if you will, on a really low-tech option there. Here's just some latest renderings that we're kind of working through. This is kind of as you would enter into the facility from the vestibule. On the left-hand side is kind of the staff space. Again, very flexible space for winter and summer. All our skate storage are on racks, so they'll be basically moved in and out of the facility. Nothing's really being inbuilt there permanently.

3:22:38 On the end is our concession space. On the right when you come in is our restrooms and storage. And really you can see your eye is drawn to those large viewing windows straight into the facility, which is again elevated above the rink surface. So it's 30 inches above the ice surface or the Olympic sheet. So you've got to kind of look down into that area. And the height also helps the...

3:23:00 The portable tilt and roll bleachers so the people aren't looking into people's heads and so forth. You have unobstructed viewing into that facility. So that's kind of how it looks coming in. This is kind of spinning around again looking at that kind of staff check-in space area there. That's kind of backed up to the corner so there's two access ramps into the ice sheet itself in the Olympic facility and then the door right over here is into the community centre space.

3:23:31 And let's just walk right over in there. So this is how you would walk into the 2,500 square foot community centre space. This is just showing right now, tables, chairs, obviously has different configurations. There are the windows on the downside. This right-hand side is 18 feet high ceiling. On the left is 12. So you can see it's got plenty of height, plenty of availability, good cushion flooring, great multitude of uses. And again, this is from the other corner, from the window corner looking back towards.

3:23:59 The entrance to the facility. A couple of things to note here is this roller door is into the concession space. So if you're hosting an event that you want to have access to a fridge, kitchen, water, whatever it may be, we roll up that little roller door. There's a little shelf and you can kind of pass through food.

3:24:19 Drinks, you know, whatever you need, which is a big part of the design and the programming from the playbooks. And then you can see this large wall here is what we're really looking at kind of showcasing video projection, you know, any type of those uses for that community center space. That's kind of how it looks there. Just some really good renderings. Thanks, Stu. And I think that's me.

3:24:40 Yeah, I'll try to wrap up the rest pretty quickly, but this really now deals with what we're going to be looking at on May 2nd. The changes that Stu's described, again, I think they were very thoughtful in terms of what they meant to the programming. If it turns out later that we can't do all those things, we'll come back to you and let you know any change that we have to make later, what that does to that programming so that we know what we're getting. It won't just be...

3:25:04 And we tipped the chiller out. The chiller itself, it's about $350,000 in additional costs, not just for the oversized chiller, not oversized, but upsized chiller, but also for the additional room and the piping system that went along with that. The locker rooms, restrooms, showers, the changes that he showed that were inside, it's actually under the large middle roof, but they still have to have their own ceiling, is another $350,000 and the other...

3:25:29 Smaller changes added up over time to about 150. So they were some pretty significant changes. But as Stu described, he really fought hard for them because they mean a lot to the programming. And again, if it ends up that we can't do it, we'll let you know what the programming changes have to be. The other cost thing, and again, I asked earlier tonight, what do you think the cost change is going to be based on these steel tariffs and things?

3:25:54 We don't have any idea, very frankly. It could be 10% of the whole project, 25% on steel materials. It's really a materials-only cost.

3:26:03 But the industry as a whole is very nervous about it. They don't know how to bid it. I guarantee you that right now and through Wednesday of next week we will have hopefully four to six general contractors who are also very nervous because they have to bid this thing and give us a hard bid. They're having subcontractors and suppliers that won't hold bids for even 30 days, and they're having to negotiate a price that they will hold for 45 or 60 days or longer. So it's very difficult for them.

3:26:31 When the bid's open next week, then we'll finally have the cost estimate. You know, I've said it before, and I, you know, it's a very serious issue. I will be very surprised if we get a bid spread of less than 20%, which means on a project like this, two bidders could be two or three million dollars different.

3:26:48 So, I mean, again, that's why I've been saying all this time we don't know. This tariff issue is a significant one, and we don't know what the impacts are going to be. Just because the steel, as an example, could come from Canada, which might be a non-tariff country, that doesn't mean that all the prices in the country aren't going up regardless. And it doesn't affect just steel. It's aluminum. It's a lot of supplies. It's a lot of materials. The 2x4 metal studs are in a lot of the walls. All those things can be affected. I mean, we could guess we'd be wrong.

3:27:17 We're going to leave it up to the contractors to tell us that. Real quick on the cost estimate. I'm going to go back very, very briefly because I've heard a lot about this project in the community from a lot of different people over time, of course. One of the main things that it was, gee, it was a project and the cost just escalated and that's how it worked. It is not at all how it worked. And I think when I went through the milestones, again, for the public's benefit, those listening and seeing this later, they'll understand that, hopefully.

3:27:47 When this project started, it was put a roof on the rink as it was and make it as cheap as possible. I appreciated, I'll mention Jeff because he's, Jeff Posey's been a strong supporter of this project for a long time now, but his friend in the steel industry said he could do it for $800,000.

3:28:04 My guess is today he'd be very nervous about that and probably say it would be twice that to do that, but that was the original concept, just put a roof on it. When it came over to Mammoth Creek Park West, we did a quick guess and said, well, you know, we just don't know. Maybe it's a million and a half. The first real estimate we did was about $2.3 million, $3 million to just bring it over and put, again, a roof on it, open on all four sides and not at all what the community ended up asking for.

3:28:31 When the committee, the group of MLR and Rec Commission took a look at it, the first cost assessment we came back with actually on December 21st of 2016 was $10.6 million. That didn't include the environmental work of the attorneys that we hired to make sure we got through that process cleanly, but it was $10.6 million. If you add that in, it was about $10.8 million. So in a year and a half.

3:28:58 Yes, it's changed 20%, 25% possibly, but it isn't something that's, gee, we changed the whole project and it just continued to escalate in cost. We actually took that cost estimate, we did some value engineering on that and got it down to about 9.5. That's where we were for about a year. We had the issue with the roof, the butler building roof, which we, you know, we've beat that one to death, but that was, you know, frankly an issue we had with some contractor and supplier that...

3:29:26 Had an estimate that was off by a million bucks. Very serious. But in October of last year, we came before you with the first couple of lines here. We noted all the preliminary work we'd already done and the cost moving forward at $12 million. That was the target that staff set about trying to reach in terms of fundraising. The additional cost, and that's the best estimate we have right now for those facilities Stu just walked through, gets us to that total today.

3:29:54 And that is including all the fees, including the environmental work, the CEQA, building permit fees, everything. And just as an aside, when we come before you on May 2nd, we're also going to recommend that the town waive, to the extent possible, some of those building permit fees. It doesn't make sense to pay ourselves for something. We certainly have to pay for the outside plan check and everything that we need to, but as we did with the police station, we'll ask for that. So that's our best estimate today.

3:30:21 Bottom line is, in summary, I'm not going to read that, but since you've seen this last, we continue to refine the programming. Stu went into the reasons why. If it turns out that for some reason we can't afford the $350 for a chiller, we have to spend $40 to redesign, that'll affect our programming. If it turns out that we can't afford an Olympic rink and we have to go back to NHL and we have to do a redesign, we'll come back before you and tell you that. But we'll know next Wednesday what the costs are going to be.

3:30:50 The cost estimates are the best we're going to get right now. When we come back, and again, I also have heard a lot about how this isn't well thought out. We didn't put a lot of time into it. Again, I can assure you between staff reports, EIRs, you know, you name it, there's been an absurd number of hours spent on this project.

3:31:11 The project itself is based on a base bid, which is all in. Everything, the community center, the parking lot, everything. That's what we're going to recommend an award on based on the cost.

3:31:21 The two deductive alternates that are in the package, one is to leave the community center as a shell only, no lights, no plumbing, you know, barely drywall, no fixtures, no flooring, you know, no doors except what's required for exiting, and no use of that facility. We don't know what the precise impact of that's going to be. We hope that several hundred thousand dollars that should help. Another one is...

3:31:47 The parking lot itself. If we don't build the community center initially, then we don't need that many parking spaces so we can make do with what we have in one of the previous...

3:31:57 Presentations, I think it was about a year ago, we actually presented what could be a possible, you know, first view of that project, which is a roof and a rink, the existing parking lot, appropriate AD access and everything else. Nothing that we want to recommend, but again, we're going to bring forward to you some alternatives for you to consider. Possible other savings, as I said, the chiller itself, some of the locker rooms, restrooms.

3:32:23 You know, Stu's described how essential they are to the programming that's been identified, but if they can't work, we'll come back and let you know what the programming would have to change to meet that. Process itself, again, it all depends on the number. We're all very interested in that, but it's very common in larger projects, and when I say common, I don't mean the majority of the time, but let's say one out of 10, one out of 15, that's not a fair...

3:32:51 Statistic, but it's a guess. Very often a project will come in, you do have to reject all bids and re-advertise. You do have to go back and redesign. A good example is even on a small concrete project with cement and concrete prices the way they are, we came before you about a month ago and rejected a bid for $197,000 on some concrete curbs on Meridian. We redesigned that. We took out about 20% of the scope and reduced the price by about 30%. So we got a bid today of $150,000.

3:33:19 Which matches with our 146 that we had in the funding we're going to get out of SB1 for this year. That happens a lot. As I said, the only true experts are the contractors. They're going to tell us next Wednesday, and I would be amazed if the low to high bid spread wasn't at least 25%. I'd be happy to be that way. We get a good number.

3:33:43 You know, you reject all bids and re-advertise based on questions or comments. You can redesign the project. You can phase it differently. There's a lot of different ways to handle that, but we are prepared to analyze that as quick as we can and come back through May 2nd with some recommendations. We won't just show you the numbers. Last one, really, if you have any questions, our goals today were to provide a clear and concise summary of this three-year-plus process, provide a summary of the public engagement throughout,

3:34:13 Five or six, but dozens of meetings with a lot of different people, talk about our current programming and provide a description of what we're prepared to do on May 2nd. With that, I'll close to answer any questions. Again, we want to do this tonight so that we don't have to go through this on May 2nd. On May 2nd, we can talk about alternatives, funding sources, and things like that.

3:34:35 Good. Thank you very much for this very thorough, very exhaustive presentation. We appreciate it. I think it's of the public's interest to get a presentation at some point that is, you know, this provides this historic perspective, provides a real overview of where the project is, how we got to where we are.

3:34:55 And so I'm going to request, there's no formal action I think requested from here this evening, but if there's any questions from any of the council members of a technical nature, maybe some thoughts on some funding things. I know some folks have been involved in the king side of this. We can deal with some of those. Then any thoughts or comments from the public, and then we'll kind of wrap it up and see what happens for May 25th. Any council members with some questions or thoughts? Can you go back to the viewing of the entrance slide?

3:35:25 No, sorry. Like when we're in the building. Ah, the lobby. Yeah, lobby. Thank you. That one. So you had mentioned something today about a potential suggested redesign of the viewing windows. Can you just articulate that a little more? And, you know, is there still a viewing window from that lobby area? It's just you wanted to reduce the sliders. Is that correct?

3:35:52 Yeah, so the original design was to have about a 40-foot-long glass sliding window that enabled you to look into the facility. But, you know, when we went back and looked at the programming, it was like, well, really, what we're really trying to do is make sure there's clear, visible access viewing areas into the facility, not really too concerned with the sliding because it was going to be conditioned inside and not conditioned on the Olympic rink size.

3:36:21 So why would you want to open up a window when everyone's nice and cool and comfortable and so forth? So we made that decision to remove the sliding viewing windows and replace that with the appropriate community center flooring instead. And what the architects did, they actually kind of enlarged that viewing window here you can see right in the middle, like a big postcard size there that now lowers the kind of viewing area, gives you kind of really unobstructed views. And then for, you know, disabled wheelchair devices, you can see they just wheel right up.

3:36:51 And have access to kind of, you know, sit, reside and be comfortable. There'll be power and USB ports in those areas as well that they can have that. It's not a slider anymore, but there's still a viewing window. It's sealed and it's actually a tempered glass. As you know, there's things that kind of fly around at that little area. So we want to make sure it's a full tempered, safe environment that's fully conditioned. And I think that's the point with this community center space in the lobby. It's a fully air conditioned condition.

3:37:20 Again, a big part of the design and a big part of what we were hearing from the programming folks. Perfect. Makes sense. Thanks for clarifying. Good. I think before we go to any kind of public thoughts or comments, I'm wondering if, Dan, from the funding, there's been some discussion about a variety of different possible alternative funding partnerships. The LA Kings has been one of them. I'm wondering if you could give any kind of an update of where that stands at this point.

3:37:47 Yeah, to what we know to date, we have gone through a lot of different funding scenarios, including debt and use of major RNU funds and some other restricted funds, as well as Town General Fund. One of the elements early on, we had discussions with the LA Kings, and we were looking at trying to partner with them, in part because of what they bring to the programming of the facility. More recently, working through a number of different agreements and those types of issues, it came to our attention through the group working on it that the Mammoth...

3:38:16 Resorts was also looking at a sponsorship program there for advertising, and the Kings had a program there where about basically half of the value of the sponsorship program could be returned back into the communities, and so we began to pursue that and look at that. The key element that was twofold, the first one being, is it a good marketing decision for Mammoth Resorts? That's the decision they have to make in terms of the creative they do, in terms of the audience they're reaching.

3:38:45 Then secondly to that was, you know, what value needed to come into it. And so we were looking at a $2 million overall purchase to get there. And the third piece of that was adding a piece from the community side, working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism in the town. Through that, there's a potential for a million dollar reinvestment back into the community. We're hoping to have that type of agreement done by this point in time. We have...

3:39:12 To my knowledge, it has not been signed yet that the Mammoth Resorts Kings leveled that agreement. We did have a meeting with representatives from Mammoth Resorts recently. One of the concerns they did raise on the agreement was actually looking kind of back to the beginning of this process in terms of the location. Early on, they had asked a question about having this on the shady rest site. At that point in time, we did not own or control that site, so it really wasn't considered heavily in the...

3:39:40 Allocation of sites to look at and then obviously the final decision process. More recently they have asked are we willing to look at a reconsideration of the location in terms of their partnership with the Kings and those dollars coming back in on that side of it. Again, kind of a strong belief from their perspective that that would help anchor downtown and it would create other benefits in that area for that purpose.

3:40:06 The discussion was held, and so actually we would bring that up at this meeting or the next one, and they're more than willing to come and comment or submit us a letter of comment expressing their perspective in terms of the location of the site. Now that we do own the shady rest parcel, you know, that could be a site consideration. It would obviously delay the project.

3:40:27 The other side of that was some of the preliminary planning work that the mountain had paid for and had done by Hart Houghton. I actually looked at that site and identified it as a potential much larger facility in terms of a community facility there. Again, with the goal of how do you anchor downtown and create other synergies around there, but it was much more than what's presented here. So that is still in discussion in terms of the agreement side. We are really trying to look at, say, if it's a good marketing component.

3:40:55 They should be looking at that from that perspective, probably less so from the community reinvestment side. And the last discussion was we anticipated potentially something this week, but we have not heard that any agreement has been signed off or reached at this point. And I know a number of the Mammoth Resort folks are out of town this week or someone would have been here this evening on other business matters. Okay. And so that funding, that King's thing is not in place yet.

3:41:22 Correct. We have some funding of that nature. That's still to be approved if it's there, so we are not necessarily counting on it at this point. Okay. I'm just wanting it worth, at some point, maybe this evening, to have a little better understanding of what the nature of this confusion seems to be about the relationship of the Hart-Howerton study, the representations that were made in that thing, and how it applies to this project, and maybe help sort out some of the confusion from the Mammoth Resort's perspective, the town's perspective of this issue of the siting of the project.

3:41:50 I don't know if anybody's got anything to add to that. I mean, I'm happy to shed a little light just from my perspective as somebody that's been pretty involved in this, but, you know, it's my understanding without really having any direct conversation with Mammoth Resorts that they did pose that question. Are you asking for any council perspective or direction on the siting of the facility at this point? Yeah, I mean, if it's something that council wish to reconsider, I mean, depending where the bids come in, we might say we don't want to regardless, but...

3:42:18 That is an option now that we do own the property. If you want us to take a look at a different location at this point in time, that could be done. It would delay the project, obviously, if you go back to that process. You'd have to redo some of the EIR work, et cetera, those elements as if that goes in the... Shady rest parcel has always been talked about of having some level of a community amenity there of some sort. It's kind of an undefined level. But, yeah, if that was a direction from the council to say, yes, maybe it's pending bids, but...

3:42:48 Take a look at an alternative site. We could do that. Again, it would delay the project in part because as you look at the environmental work, it would need to look at that as well as whatever we end up from a housing development site there. So most likely you'd be out a couple of years in that process at least. Okay. Well, let's maybe save that for deliberation. We'll just see if we have some public comment we can provide. I know there's no...

3:43:08 Direction requested from Council this evening, but maybe some thoughts. I think we're all concerned and we're interested what the bid and what that's going to look like. And I think we want to make sure that that decision or those choices, if they come back to Council, that they're digestible, that there's going to be a clear way forward, however this goes. I think Council maybe can provide some insight into what that might look like. So at this point, is there anybody in the public here who has any thoughts or comments on what you've heard this evening on this project?

3:43:41 This is just a minor point, but Ted Carlton. So when we approve the site work for the site contract or whatever, so what happens if the thing just doesn't get built? Is that contract just, is there like a kill clause or something in it, or how does that work? Actually, we approve the contract, but we've never provided a notice to proceed.

3:44:03 So at any time we could just cancel. We've been in communication. That happens to be the contractor that does significant work for us all over town. We have a good relationship. They're basically waiting to see if it doesn't happen. We don't move forward. We don't provide a notice to proceed. There's no penalty. It just goes away. It is involved, however, to be very clear, with the playground. Some of that site work is grading for the playground. So we'll have to talk to them about that.

3:44:31 Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else, any thoughts or any ideas to add to this? All right, thank you. So there were a couple letters, I think, that were submitted to Granicus that were, you know, good thoughts and good comments. I think it's at this point, we're just kind of setting the stage for what decisions will need to happen at the meeting in May. So at this point, I just turn it open up to Council. Any thoughts to add? Happy to take the lead. Go ahead. Cool. Yeah.

3:45:01 First of all, thanks to staff for a thorough report. I mean, I think as we're kind of approaching the finish line here, if you will, it's good for us to have a little background on how we arrived here. So that was super thorough and very helpful for both us and the public. You know, I think...

3:45:20 There's kind of one issue here, which is the bid. I think that it's an unknown at this point. Hopefully in a week we have good news, and I think we'll just have to evaluate how we proceed based on the bids that come through. I guess this question of citing has been posed. From my personal perspective, that's absolutely something I have zero interest in entertaining. I think that it completely...

3:45:46 This discredits the process that we've been through. This go-around over the last three or four years as somebody that's been pretty involved in that process, there was a very significant process put in place. A lot of players came together to make those type of decisions, a lot of public engagement, both good and bad. And I think that the idea of going back on multiple years of work on this go-around,

3:46:16 You know, a community planning process that goes back to 1999 and actually well before that would be, you know, not a smart decision on our behalf. So I think for all the merits that that group chose the site, none of that has changed for me. So personally, Dan, if you're looking for some direction on that, I think that is a perspective from the outside that really doesn't take into consideration.

3:46:45 The entire process and all the work that's gone into getting us here with this specific site. So that's not something I'm personally willing to entertain at all. I know that a lot of that from at least

3:46:56 You know, the resort's perspective comes from the Hart-Howerton planning process. You know, that was a really good effort that was done on behalf of the community. I think it's important to note that that's not an approved document. There's a lot of things in that plan that are fantastic ideas and things that probably should be implemented, things that we're already working on trying to implement, but that's not an adopted plan. There's also a lot of suggestions and citing.

3:47:25 Thought process through that that has no CEQA work behind it, doesn't take into consideration a lot of factors that would need to be considered before moving on some of those things. So I think whether that was suggested or not in the Hart-Howerton plan doesn't have a huge impact on my decision for proceeding with siting of the facility. I did take some time to reach out to...

3:47:50 Some people over at Hart Howerton, I had a long conversation with Aaron Ashley, who you guys will probably remember did the presentation. He was gracious enough to take my call, and we spent about an hour on the phone after they did that presentation. I was trying to just really understand a lot of the process behind arriving at some of those suggestions, and one of the things that we talked about at length was a suggestion to cite.

3:48:15 You know, the multi-use facility over at Shady Rest, which is one of their suggestions. And basically the premise of our conversation was I was having a hard time personally understanding the rationale behind that suggestion. You know, to me, looking at all my experience in other peer resorts, et cetera, I was trying to frame my own head around a place that had seen, you know, downtown revitalization as a result of siting, you know, that type of facility in the downtown corridor.

3:48:45 I can't think of anywhere that's done that has that in place personally. Also, you know, anywhere that, you know, where they saw that intended effect of revitalizing a downtown. So I was trying to understand how a municipal ice rink and community center could really have that intended effect. And the conversation that we had is, you know, what he explained to me is that was really a broader goal of citing a huge

3:49:13 You know, recreation center for the community. You know, their thought wasn't necessarily that, hey, you put an ice rink down in the Shady Rest parcel, all of a sudden it's just going to revitalize downtown. Their thought was, you know, that could be the first in a number of anchor facilities, you know, a $50 million plus project on Shady Rest, you know, that would include an ice rink, an aquatic center, a community center, maybe a daycare, you know, it would be an all-inclusive gym, everything.

3:49:42 Kind of the whole setup of the community from a recreation perspective would be anchored there. I think that's a fantastic idea if I thought that that was even within the scope of possibility. I don't think we're in a position to be putting a $50 million plus all-inclusive recreation facility on that site. I think that doesn't take into consideration the workforce housing needs over there.

3:50:08 I don't think it's in the scope of what we're looking to do. So that was kind of the conversation that I had to follow up with Hart Howerton on that suggestion. To me, that's reaffirmed the fact that this is the right siting for this facility as we have it planned, because I think that the suggestion there maybe wasn't articulated fully, but I think that's a much more grandiose.

3:50:35 I'm sure that, you know, infrastructure, transit facility, I'm, I'm.

3:51:04 You know, speculating at this point, but I think some of those things are going to be the component of what components of what the community wants for that site. But I'm not willing to take that leap to say that the community is going to get behind a 50, 60 million dollar all-inclusive recreation center on Shady Rest. So that's just a little further articulation that I've had, you know, following up with Hart Howerton that was helpful and informative for me. And I think that that.

3:51:31 You know, reinforces my perspective that we've gone through the correct process here and that I'm not interested in kind of pulling a 180 on that at the 11th hour. Thank you very much, Colin. It's pretty helpful. Anybody else? Shields, any thoughts? If you remember, I have a hard time remembering what I did too, but I was against it. You know, I thought the siding, if we could...

3:51:59 You know, get Mammoth Creek Park East, but that wasn't available. And I had a problem the way the original project was sitting on west, and we reorientated it. And when we did that, it made all the sense in the world for me. Shady Rest was never an option, in my opinion, quite honestly. I just, this is a, you know, 80% of the time it's an ice rink.

3:52:28 Residential setting, and not to say this isn't near residential, but in a residential setting, ice rinks don't really go very well, in my opinion. So I think it's gone through the process, like Colin said, through the public process. I think we've vetted this thing every which way from Sunday. I'm a real believer in, you know, if we're going to do it, do it right. So I'm looking forward to...

3:52:55 My question is, at what point, when the bids come in,

3:53:24 What's going to be the breaking point? I mean, seriously, are we already talking about 13 million right now? That's the number with steel to be determined? And you threw out something like $300,000. How much do you really think the steel is going to cost to build this? Because if I'm correct, if it's...

3:53:53 Bugger the location right now. That's not the problem. We can't afford this if it was anywhere. So at what point are you guys going to choke and realize we can't do this? This is not financially feasible. This keeps going up and up. The steel, why is that TB, is that just, are you talking, when you say steel, are you talking about the bids that come in?

3:54:19 In that specific instance, I'm just talking about the impacts of the recently enacted steel tariffs effect on materials and steel only. That was done on March 23rd. The industry has no idea what that means yet for this project. Again, it could mean $100,000. It could mean a million dollars. We really don't know, and the contractors don't know. They're studying it right now. But the roof is made out of steel, correct? That's correct. And that's going to be the first portion that gets built.

3:54:46 So we're talking not just about the ice rink, we're talking about the whole project. How many feet is that? The whole roof? No, that's correct. It's a massive, it's a very large steel structure and it could have a significant impact. I'm not...

3:55:03 Pulling any punches here tonight by any means. We don't know. Well, I feel like kind of you guys are. This is like so nice. It's like I'm in a place and I'm being shown all these really cool things, but I know my pocketbook cannot back this up. We're at $13 million and the steal. At what point are people going to realize this does not work financially for this town right now? Well, Cleland, with all due respect, that's a decision of the council.

3:55:31 There's no sense in having staff speculate a week before a bid comes in on what exactly it's going to be. If the bid comes in, then we'll evaluate how we're going to proceed, and that's a decision of the council. That's not staff's decision. What I would like to see is I would have liked to see some kind of ballpark figure for the steal, because even if you just went with the lowest price right now, the prices aren't going to go down.

3:55:57 I don't think that makes any sense to just speculate and throw a number out there when we'll know in a week. Well, yes, when you have over $13 million that we can't even afford right now. That's your perspective, and that's fine. But I think when we actually have a solid bid, then it's up to the five members of council to decide how to proceed. And it could be, you know, more. We just don't know. Then we'll discuss it at that time. Yeah, and I think that what's interesting about the steel thing is, you know, for those...

3:56:25 Those of us who watch national trends and national politics, we have a project here that's a huge steel project. The president has announced these very specific tariffs and nobody knows what that's going to look like. And we're going to have kind of a front row seat to say, well, hey, Mr. Trump's tariffs have just put a 25% premium on a project. Be kind of interesting to know. But I think to Colin's point, the decision point is going to be in May.

3:56:55 So we're all looking forward to that, and we will all make decisions on that week in May. I think a little bit, to your point, Cleland, about being seduced by what we're seeing, I am reminded of in a previous iteration of the town of Mammoth Lakes when there was discussion about a $40 million recreation center. And the rendering for that center was a sort of a Sharpie drawing on a napkin.

3:57:22 And it was nice to talk about it, what it would look like, but someone would say, well, what's this thing going to look like? And this drawing on a napkin was rolled out, and you kind of went, well, you know, this is insanity. I think that project accrued the appropriate kind of type of reputation because there was no effort or process behind it to realize what something like that would actually look like. And I think that as a council and as a community, I think we're very fortunate.

3:57:50 To have a staff and a community that rose to the occasion with this project and worked very, very hard and very, very diligently to deliver a vision for this facility and what it could look like that is at a level of excellence. It's aspirational.

3:58:08 And I have to say the people I've talked to in the community the last couple of weeks who three and four years ago would remind me how ridiculous and insane even thinking about something like this was who now come up to me and say, well, you know, we went to a meeting last week and we saw some drawings and we saw some stuff and, wow, this is really cool. This is really nice. This is something we would really like for this community. But did Jenna hear the alternatives?

3:58:33 I'm just talking to the ability and the capacity of this community to articulate a vision for itself of a facility that it would like to see and it would like to get behind and support. Now, look, we're up against ridiculous headwinds. And I'm concerned that that's what's going to come back next week. The bids are going to come back. They're going to be way beyond our grasp. And as a community, we're going to have to say, OK.

3:59:01 Where are we going from here? And we'll make those decisions in May. But at this point, I just want to commend the staff, the community, and all of us for the work we've done to be able to articulate this project. Excuse me. One second. If I could finish, please. If I could finish. To create and articulate an inspiring Cleveland, you don't need to be snarky. You really don't. It's this body. Okay, we'll just wrap it up, okay? This body, this deliberative body works with mutual respect for its members.

3:59:28 So let's just, allow me to finish, and we don't need any cheap comments, let's just get through this, okay? To create an aspirational vision for this community I think is really important, and I think this is a great effort everybody's done. We will look forward to the first week of May, and we'll make decisions appropriate at that time, and we'll see where we go. So I'm sorry, do you have a thought? Okay, yes. You always bring up, you act as though I do not appreciate the work that's been put in. Yes, I have.

3:59:56 Yes, they have a plan from 1999. Do you know how many plans that there are in there? For everything from swimming pools to you name it, we have a plan for it since 1984. It's been in our history. I could care less where it goes, whatever. It's not going to look like this. I'm really surprised at this number. And Dan, I talked with you earlier today. This number was not at 13 million today.

4:00:29 No, the staff report has been that 13 whatever the steel number is unknown. So I'm a little bit going, oh, wait a minute. All of a sudden now it's 13 million? No, the staff report has been, you know, since it came out it's always been a little over 13. We've identified. So I'm not crazy in that. We've identified 11 to 12 million in potential funding to date.

4:00:56 Without some of that still has to be approved and it's unknown yet for sure. So at 13X in here, yeah, that funding has not been identified. That was what we had asked about that earlier and walked through that. So there's X dollars in funding identified. If the bid was to come in at this level or higher than what's in here, yeah, that's a whole other conversation at this point because we have not identified that level of funding at this point.

4:01:23 And where is the money included that we already have to, where in this is it added what the, the one million, million seven in total. Is that in there or is that something that next paperwork I get I'm going to have 13 with one and a half. That's in the total bid estimate there in that process.

4:01:49 So it is in that total number. So it's a total project cost. I'm sorry. I'm a mom. I'm used to saying we can't afford this. And I'm not trying to be a killjoy. I'm not trying to take anything away from this town except for the misconception that this is something that we can, even with this price tag, I look to the future of how we're going to keep this going. And it's just getting way out of control. So that's all I'm going to say. Of course. We'll wait for the bid.

4:02:19 Yeah, so I think for the benefit of the public that's here for additional items on the agenda, we're not being asked to make any direction tonight. I understand that this specific issue is a lightning rod for the community, and it's controversial, and people are impassioned about it, but thank you to staff for providing this information, and really the time for us as a council to make some decisions around this is going to be the meeting in May, and everybody's entitled to their opinion and their vote associated with that.

4:02:48 So thank you all very much. I think one, just to the issue about the siting and the Hart-Howerton thing, it might be useful at some point when you're in conversations with Mammoth Resorts, if we can maybe get this clarified, maybe put this to bed at some point, just so that we're not churning and going round and round in this King's Deal and leverage and siting and all that kind of stuff to maybe get some clarity on that. Yeah, I mean, I think it's good to have some consensus and direction from the council if you feel like you got that sufficiently. But for me personally, that conversation is a non-starter. Yeah, I would agree with Colin.

4:03:18 Okay, good. So thank you all very much for this. And let's maybe take a five-minute break, and we'll get back here by jobs time, 8.10, and we'll move on with the agenda, the consent agenda, and we shall proceed from there. Number seven, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of April 4, 2018. Item eight, award contract for the Whitmore Pool Mechanical and Minor Infrastructure Improvement Project. Item nine, approve by resolution the 2018 youth sports funding allocations.

4:10:10 Item 10, adopt a resolution approving the 2018 project list to be submitted to the California Transportation Commission, CTC, for funding from the road maintenance and rehabilitation account, RMRA funds under Streets and Highway Code Section 2034. Item 11, accept payments approval report number 18-48 in the amount of $105,645.78. Any items here that council members like to pull? No, staff? No, staff. Public, anything?

4:10:39 Okay, seeing none, so I would entertain a motion on the consent agenda. We approve consent agenda items 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11. I'll second that. Thank you. Any further discussion? Hearing none, roll call please, Dan. Yes, Councilmember Fernie? Yes. Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Hoff? Yes. Mayor Wentworth? Yes. I'm going to abstain from item number 7 as I was not here. Thank you. The motion passes.

4:11:11 Thank you very much. Moving on to policy matters, item 12, resolution of intent to renew the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District. Dan, we'll start with you. I believe Mr. Urdi is here to help us out with this as well. This is coming for you as a way to renew the current Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District.

4:11:30 If you recall, a month ago or so, Council had a discussion on this in order to time it in working with our budget process. There was a request to bring the resolution of intent forward on April 18th today. That allows us to be able to move this forward through the next couple of months. In June, it would be through the approval process if everything moves as projected.

4:11:52 We needed to know that for our own budget projections and looking at revenues as well as from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, obviously, and their budgeting process. So getting it here today now, it's before you. So there's two items here I need to highlight in particular. First, this is a resolution of intent, so it just starts the process. There will be an additional public meeting, additional public hearing, then ultimately a resolution of formation, assuming that it continues to support through that process to move forward.

4:12:20 The other element for the resolution of intent to come forward, at least 50, I think it has to be just over 50% of the businesses being assessed in terms of the value and the calculation process. They have to submit a petition in favor of the resolution of intent to move this forward. Mammoth Lakes Tourism has put out the petitions. They did come forward into the town today.

4:12:46 And both of our town clerks are out for various reasons tonight, but the MLT did meet with Pam Kobylarz, who is the assistant clerk and acting clerk today. She's out this evening for other reasons. And the determination was that there is 61.13% in favor of a vote in the petitions coming forward, so the town council can move forward with the consideration of the resolution of intent.

4:13:16 to move the project forward. There has been a lot of discussion about the T-bid and some modifications proposed as it moves to the process. I'll let Mr. Urdi from MLT speak to that.

4:13:29 For us, for the town perspective, ultimately town council goes through this based on those requests. As mentioned, you'll have additional meetings and hearings on the item as it does proceed forward. We also have a proposal to enforce some modifications, again, that we'll have Mr. Urdi speak to in his presentation. So as it, the MLTB...

4:13:51 M-L-T-B-I-D. It is being pursued under the 1994 Business Improvement District Law. It struts that up. I would note that we are one of the unique TBIDs in the state. I think we're the only one that has the scope in terms of the tourism-related businesses to look at retail and restaurants and hotels and ski resorts.

4:14:10 Etc. in terms of that involvement. So it's aggressive in that way and kind of innovative. It is a way to enhance the marketing promotional elements of the community. It also is in the business plan. It is a funding mechanism to support commercial air service into the region here. So unless there's a particular question from the staff side moving this forward, I would invite Mr. Urdi to come up and do the formalized staff presentation from Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

4:14:37 And we also have a representative, Gina from Civitas, is here as well, has been a consulting firm working closely with MLT on the project coming forward. Excellent. Thank you very much. Mr. Urdi. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Council. John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So I wanted to just go through a little bit of the reason why we formed the TBD back in 2013. And just to give you an idea, when we formed that back in September of 2013,

4:15:14 We were the 80th TBID in the state of California. And when we did so, we thought, okay, this is going to be great, it's going to be a leg up. And what we found is that now, as of today, there are 101 tourism business improvement districts in the state of California. And so, really, one of the things that we've done with this is, yes, we've seen some good success from it, but we need to use this to compete with the other 100 TBIDs in the state to make sure that we're still getting our share. Really, the goal was to drive visitation and...

4:15:40 So we're up to nine months out of the 10 that we set the goal for.

4:16:08 And I think the next one to reach the million dollar month will probably be October. One of the biggest things that we want to highlight here was that we have focused on the shoulder seasons. And I think a lot of people have looked at it and said, well, we've been successful because it snowed. And I think when you look at the all-time highs for the month of May, the all-time high has gone up 71%. The all-time high for TOT for October has gone up 62%. And the all-time high for November has gone up 85%. So those are three of the months that we don't have a million dollars, but we're seeing huge growth on those.

4:16:37 On those months. So when we set the TBID up back in September of 2013, we were asked when would we see the results of the TBID. And the response was really that we would see it 12 to 18 months from when we started to spend the money. We started to spend the TBID dollars in May of 2014. June of 2015, just 13 months later, we started shattering every month's TOT record.

4:17:02 And when I say shatter, they were everywhere from 17% to 65% as a high, and really the average was around 35%. So the results were fantastic. Another thing to note is that from fiscal year 2004-05 through 2014-15, the average collection was 10.5 million. So for those 10 years, the average was 10.5 million, and we just kind of lollygag between 9 and 11 million, 10 million, 9 million, 11 million, right back through those.

4:17:31 In fiscal 16-17, we hit $18.1 million, which is 74% ahead of the 10-year average prior to the T-bid. And what I wanted, I actually ran some numbers which I hadn't run before, because on the bottom of our 10-month viability sheet, I show the impact and how much direct spending and lodging you have to have to get $100,000 in TOT. So we were up $7.6 million in TOT over the 10-year average.

4:18:00 So for every $100,000 increase in TOT, that means about $770,000 in direct spending at our lodging properties. So when we were up $7.6 million ahead of the 10-year average, that means that we had more than $58 million more in direct spending at our hotels. $58 million. That blew me away. I mean, that's a big number. And really, that means that over the 10-year average,

4:18:26 We had more people coming. We had longer stays. We had higher ADRs, average daily rates. So we saw the demand up and the basic law of economics, supply and demand. So if we have people demanding it, we're able to charge appropriately. And I think that's where we've seen the rate increases in the summer really help us. Even this year in 2017-18, we've had a fairly lackluster winter. Up through February of 2018, we're 2% behind last year's ridiculous record.

4:18:56 We're $275,000 off of that. I expect March and April will be slightly behind last year because of the momentum that we had last year, but it's been busy. The ski area was parked at F yesterday down the hill. It's pretty amazing. And we're about $3.8 million ahead of budget this year for TOT. So TBID Part 2.

4:19:17 As the Town Manager mentioned, we have 61.13% yes votes. That's 79 businesses, and out of the 79 businesses, it's actually 31 of the top 40 businesses, and many of those in the top 40 that didn't vote yes are some of our bigger corporates, the Vons, the Rite-Aids, places like that that are harder to get traction with.

4:19:38 So he also mentioned that we had some adjustments to the management district plan. I think the management district plan as it sits right now, we have not changed any of the rates. So we're still 1% on lodging, 1.5% on retail, 1.5% on restaurant, and 2% on the ski area. We were looking at a 10-year renewal. After talking to a number of different business members in town, we actually are going to make the recommendation at the resolution of formation that we actually drop that to the five years. So instead of it being a 10-year renewal, it'll be a five-year.

4:20:07 So that would be 2018 through 2023. We also looked at it, and Mammoth Mountain has voluntarily offered the 2%. When we first put this together in 2013, the ski area was not part of the conversation. It was on lodging, restaurant, and retail. The ski area came to the plate and said that we're willing to put in $2 million, or excuse me, 2%, which we want to see go towards air subsidy as a voluntary piece.

4:20:32 Their percentage will remain the same moving forward, but because Altera is selling their season passes without tax, without assessment, without fees associated, they've asked to remove the season pass. So season pass revenue, $400,000 or $500,000 worth will be removed from this because right now if you buy an $899 pass, it's $899. It's not $899++++. And that doesn't matter whether you buy it at Steamboat or here or wherever.

4:20:59 So again, with that being voluntary, we had no problem with that. It will result in $500,000 roughly less revenue to Mammoth Lakes Tourism annually. So the other adjustment that we've made was to say that we're anticipating raising $4.5 million annually, $2.17 million to marketing, $2.15 million to air subsidy and marketing, and $90,000 to reserve, and then $90,000 to the Town of Mammoth Lakes for collecting, processing, and remitting those funds to Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

4:21:28 Also, as Sound Manager mentioned, next steps, we have a public hearing on May 2nd and then a final public hearing on the 20th of June with the idea that resolution of formation would happen at that point and that the TBUD would go into place September 1 of 2018 through August 31st of 2023. Any questions? Excellent. Thank you very much. So, John, I think we're taking you as kind of a staff presentation, so any questions of a technical mixture for John before we get any public comment or thoughts?

4:22:00 Nothing here? Shields? No. Anything? No? A couple questions for you. Yeah. Anything you'd like to share for the board's, MLT board's deliberation of this that would be useful for the council to hear and understand? I think we went through a lot of different conversations and I think we talked about, you know, most of my board members were part of the steering committee as well. We ended up with about 28 people, business leaders in town that were part of the steering committee that decided to keep the rates where they were.

4:22:31 And I think that when we went through the process, we did talk about the inclusion of everyone. You know, we talked about making sure that the mountains still remained involved, even though it's voluntary, and that the impact has been substantial. So I do have a few board members here, if you care to... No, I just want to make sure there's anything happening as part of the deliberation. I mean...

4:22:51 Colin is on our board as well. This has been something that we started the renewal process with anticipation of some challenges here or there. We started it back a year and a half ago. So we've been working on this for really close to 18 months with the idea that it's going to be renewing in the next four months, really. So we don't have to leave enough room. I don't think from my perspective there's anything that came out of the board deliberation on it that's really...

4:23:19 You know, of note, you know, as John already articulated in his presentation, it was really as we've already planned for with the two suggested changes. And I think the overall board.

4:23:35 Sentiment on those specific changes was that we were in agreement with those as proposed. Okay, good. A couple other things. As you know, there's discussion about reliable regional air service and there's a very interesting series of proposals coming forward about what that might look like. I just want to make sure that MLT is, from a legal, from an outreach perspective, prepared to do the right...

4:23:58 Thank you.

4:24:20 It has gone from $2 million to $2.15 million, and that's really to focus on the subsidies. We did explore the possibility of being able to utilize dollars down the road in Bishop, and at that point we looked at the Measure A dollars as not being available, and then when we looked back at the TBID dollars, there was an amendment to the 1994 law back a few years ago, I guess, that said that you could spend money outside of the district, but it was only on specific things. It was specifically on marketing, which is...

4:24:50 What we do. And it was also on wayfinding signage to direct you to the district. So for us to be able to go down to Bishop Airport and spend $2 million to put a fence up, that wouldn't cut it with a T-bid as well. So our commitment is that moving forward, we're always part of the conversation because we're part of the service conversation, the air service side. And once, if something is going to happen down the road in Bishop, we can start to look at marketing in Dallas.

4:25:16 We can start to look at subsidizing a flight from Denver. So that's when we can start to come into play. But until the airport down there is ready to accept commercial service, we're not going to be a player. My guess would be that if...

4:25:31 Just to say, if it's ready for service in 2022, we may look at the fiscal year before that to start spending money in whatever market that we're potentially going to go into so that there's awareness for the destination. I just think it's going to be important as various ideas get entertained as we move forward with this that MLT, from the perspective of the Mammoth Lakes T-Bid, that board members, staff can be sure to make appropriate, you know, legally.

4:25:55 And I think, finally, in terms of the term, going from 10 years to 5 years that have been talked about, I'm hopeful, I'm going to make the assumption that the board is anticipating that what's in the current proposal

4:26:17 When we get to the end of the five-year term, there may be tectonic changes to ensure that we can move forward with this TBIT for another renewal if it's a desire of the businesses involved in the district, that we're anticipating future opportunities. And we're not doing anything in this iteration that's going to bind us in any way going forward. And whatever kinds of things happen with Altera, with the new corporation in town, that we're not precluding any opportunities for things we may need for future success down the road.

4:26:47 No, we're definitely not precluding things, and obviously it's our major source of funding for Mammoth Lakes Tourism to market the businesses in the community. So we're obviously looking at the future. I would have liked to have seen us go with 10 years to lock in that marketing for the next 10 years for the community. But with five years, we will do what we need to do. Obviously, next time around, we'll have to go back and do the same thing. So every time we renew the TBID, we have to go out and get the petitions done. So if the businesses in town don't feel that they're getting the return on it, then I'm sure.

4:27:17 I'm sure we'll see that as a response to the petitions. Great. Okay, thank you very much. At this moment, if there's any comment from the public, thoughts on the TBID? There have been some public comments registered via Grana, because I'm sure we've all read them. The proponents aren't here to speak on those behalf, but we've seen those. Okay, so with that, let's bring it back up here and deliberate this and move to an action on behalf of the Council. Does anybody want to get started?

4:27:46 I can. Sure, please, thank you. I guess as the council's representative on MLT, I'll kick it off. You know, I think I've been fairly vocal since moving to this town that this type of TBID, whatever iteration it may come from, is something that I'm supportive of personally as a business owner in town. This is something that, you know, I've put my support behind as a business owner.

4:28:17 As a council member, I think, you know, John did a very good job of kind of walking through the history and the facts and all that. I think it's pretty apparent to most that we've seen success as a result of this. I think it would be foolish to say that the success we've seen over the last, you know, three, four years is attributable to any one entity. But I think it would also be foolish to say that

4:28:46 The institution of the TBID has not had a piece of that success. So it's something that I'm tremendously supportive of. Like John already mentioned, I would have been very comfortable with moving forward on a 10-year basis, but it wasn't a hill to die on for me. I'm absolutely comfortable with, you know, moving it forward at five years, you know, re-evaluating at that time, you know.

4:29:10 What the landscape of the community and the needs of the business community is going to look like five years from now, I'm not sure. So I don't think it hurts us to move forward for five years and then reevaluate. As far as the other suggested change, you know, pulling icon passes off the TBIT assessment, you know, that was the nature of some of the comments that have come through. I've had some, you know, chatter about that in the community.

4:29:34 For me personally, that makes all the sense in the world. I think if we're looking at a conglomerate pass that is not a local in-market deal, it only makes sense to me that there wouldn't be an assessment on that. Obviously, if people are in-market and enjoying services as part of the community, going to restaurants, patroning businesses.

4:29:54 Purchasing Lyft tickets at the window, they're in market and therefore should be subject to the TBID just like anyone else. But if somebody's purchasing a pass that can be used all over North America, it doesn't make sense to me that a local Mammoth assessment would be put on that. And also it was always a pass through to the guest anyway. So really the savings is going to the guest who's purchasing the pass rather than anyone else, which is a pass through to begin with.

4:30:21 So fundamentally, I have no problem with that suggestion as well. So as a business owner, as a council member, as a MLT board member and all the various hats that I wear, this is something that I'm very supportive of moving forward with. My business is a tiny little microcosm of the broader scope of business in the community, but we've definitely seen some positive results.

4:30:47 Through all the variety of efforts that we're doing in the community over the last five years. Our season when we came here nine years ago was really November to April.

4:30:58 We never had staff beyond that or staff before then. This year we were able to start a number of our employees as early as September 1st, so added a couple of months to the season for us. We're also pushing for the first time to the end of May. So we took our season from what was six months to nine months, and I think that the TBIT is definitely a part of that.

4:31:21 So I think the intended effects that we're having on pushing out shoulder seasons and driving visitation has come to fruition. And I think that's all I have to say, but, you know, I'm inclined to support it. Good. Cleland Shields? Go ahead. I, too, support it. Numbers don't lie. And I think the numbers that John quoted relay that fact.

4:31:52 You mentioned something, John, the tectonic effect of five years. And I think in the next five years, you're going to see some big changes. I was more for the 10-year, trying to go for the 10-year, but I totally understand, you know, the situation that Mammoth is in right now. You know, maybe five years does make sense. So, but I'm very supportive and want to move it forward. Thank you. Cleland. Nothing at this time. Okay.

4:32:25 So I support this. I think that this is a key component of how this town is financed and how we need the revenue from TOT to move this thing forward. I think as we move forward with this and this thing becomes hopefully in place for another five years, I think we're all very interested in understanding how we can build on the success.

4:32:49 of what the TBID is bringing us. I think that from as long as I've been on council, we started off with a very uncertain environment. Coming out of the bankruptcy and things like this, I think we're seeing certain indicators of a certain kind of stability in our financing and the revenue coming into the town, which can allow us to start considering things about staff physicians, police officers, things like that. I think the TBID is part of that.

4:33:15 And I think I'm very much interested in moving this thing forward, but also looking down the road how we start building on the success of the program to date. So. I do have maybe a question slash comment. Seems to me that this has been used a little bit in, I don't know the words when you're trying to pull one over on somebody, but it's been a bargaining tool for support on the TBID or not on the TBID.

4:33:44 Since more than half the money goes to the airport, I'm a little bit curious how that is going to move forward in the future. Because if you look at the airline industry, I'm not going to be surprised in five years if we have Uber Air, is what I'm calling it. I think that it's going to change, like we have the Jet Suite X that's flying in. There's other companies that are doing that. They're just going to get it cheaper, better.

4:34:13 Commercial Airline, meh. I think that the airport decision is a very big part of the T-bid since a lot of money goes there. So, and then my other thing is, and correct me if I'm wrong, Andy and Dan, have we not asked just, and this is a little bit of a side subject, but aren't there some things that MLT has promised us in the last year or two that we've asked for?

4:34:42 In exactly how they're running, and we haven't seen it yet. So I appreciate the TBID dollars. However, I do not have a lot of, I'm very curious to see where all that money is actually being used. And frankly, I'm hearing that, you know,

4:35:07 I think there's some Brown Act violations that I've been told of and some other things and that kind of worries me as an entity and I kind of hesitate to give an entity all this money from a T-bid where I'm just not at a level where I just am all gung-ho about how they're spending our money. So take that for what you will.

4:35:32 Well, I think if these are potentially important things to consider, I think that if maybe if you want to talk with the town manager and maybe you guys can go into this a little bit deeper, if there's things we need to hear or know about, we should certainly bring those things forward. I think your points around air service are absolutely valid, and I think...

4:35:52 That's probably why it makes some sense, I suppose, to have this be a five-year time frame. And we are in a very kind of uncertain environment with, you know, a new acquisition and purchase. And, you know, this is one of the most significant shifts in the history of the ski industry and what this thing is going to look like, what Altera Mountain Company and the competing icon pass and all that is going to look like three, four, five years from now, I think is pretty up in the air at this point.

4:36:19 I would totally agree with you that just like the taxi industry was ripe for disruption, for being just horrendous for so many years, I think the airlines are right there too. And, you know, whoever's going to figure that out, whoever figures out Uber Air is going to be a very rich individual.

4:36:40 But I think that industry is ripe for some disruption. So I think our specific regional environment is pretty up in the air at this point. What it's going to look like for Mammoth Yosemite and anything down in Bishop in the next couple of years is a little bit up in the air at this point. So I think we kind of stay the course. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. And I think we've seen some success over the last four years that I've been on this council.

4:37:06 I anticipate that to continue for the next four or five years, but evaluating where we're at in the next five years is probably a good thing and how air plays into that. I think most of our peer resort communities have come up with some mechanism or another to support and subsidize air service, and whether it's a TBID or a chamber fly steamboat program or whatever it may be, it has a lot of different iterations, but I think...

4:37:33 The fact that we are contributing as a business community to air services is accurately placed. You know, as far as the Brown Act stuff, I mean, you know, I know. If I could, I just want to, I mean, that's a consideration. Obviously, the item in front of us is not germane. Sure. I realize that. So that's, but if that's something that you want to discuss with the town manager.

4:37:55 Just 30 seconds on that. You know, I think we did make an effort as we went through that strategic planning process to kind of daylight a lot of our NGOs. You know, now all the meetings are held in Suite Z and published on Granicus, and I think those things are positive moves in the form of transparency. I'm certainly not the Brown Act police, but as somebody that has a little bit of knowledge with it, I don't know exactly what you're referring to, but for my...

4:38:20 You know, experience serving on the board over the last year or so. There's nothing that I can think of that would hint to that. But I think John's right. You know, if you have a concern, let's just address it with Dan. It wasn't you. Yeah. Just FYI. Sure. Okay. So I guess any other thoughts on this or discuss this any further? Okay. So I'll entertain a motion then for the item in front of us. I'm happy to provide a motion.

4:38:49 That the Town Council approves the resolution of attention for the renewal of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District. Second. Thank you. Any further discussion? I'm hearing a request for no more further discussion. Dan, a roll call vote, please. Yes. Councilmember Fernie? Yes. Councilmember Richardson? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Hoff? No. And Mayor Wentworth? Yes. The item is agreed to 3-1.

4:39:15 Okay. We'll move on now to item number 13, authorize the mayor to execute purchase agreement for right-of-way necessary for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. Grady. Thank you. The town council has previously authorized an offer to the Mammoth Creek Condominium Association for a piece of right-of-way. They have accepted that office. The vote was not unanimous, but it was nearly so. I think I reported that at a...

4:39:46 At a prior meeting, the documents have been prepared. There is a draft of an agreement in your packet. It has been revised very slightly. Our outside counsel has taken a look at it. Andy? Yeah, in ways that nobody would care about. I'm sorry, just before you, is there a map of this project? It's not, there's nothing in the staff report. Is there a map or something that could be projected or no? Yes, it is in the final agreement. That's correct.

4:40:11 There's nothing we can look at this evening or no? Absolutely. I have copies of it. I'll grab it. I'll go ahead and describe it, and I'll grab the copies that show the actual exhibit. Great, thank you. It's something the survey actually had a title issue on it, but the map is in there, and it's ready, and he'll change that on Monday, and it'll be ready to record. But yes, there's a map that shows the actual right-of-way that we're acquiring. In general, it's from the, it's on the south side of,

4:40:34 Mammoth Creek from the north side of our future pathway all the way to Old Mammoth Roads. We're picking up quite a bit of area there. Suffice to say that we have received that agreement. We think it's reasonable. We'll provide that to you in just a second. We actually have a check cut for that right away at this time once the mayor is, you know, if you authorize the mayor to sign that agreement.

4:40:58 We'll have that done, and we'll do an exchange, if you will, once the document and the deed is actually recorded, then we'll exchange that for the check itself. The actual deed has a legal description, and there's an exhibit attached as well that shows the alignment of the path and the area to be obtained.

4:41:42 Okay. There's a legal description that goes along with that. So I'll just pass this down. I was about to say is exhibit A. Yeah, it's fine. I don't think it's in our... It's like we're like a jury. Exhibit A. Correct. Okay, that's not very helpful. I've seen it on another map. So this is not... There's a second conversation about another segment to make the complete...

4:42:13 That's correct. The complete right-of-way necessary to construct the extension of the town loop through this area, correct? Yes, the discussion of two metal lane, which you've also seen at closed session, is ongoing. Okay. And that hasn't been completed yet? No, I think they've set a date, but we're waiting for that. Okay. Okay, good. Anything more to add? No, that's really it. It's in keeping with all of our previous discussions and with your previous offer or authorization to make the offer. Okay.

4:42:43 Any questions for Grady? No? I'm sorry, Andy, do you have a... Nope. Nope? Okay. So if this goes through and we acquire this, I'm assuming the town's not going to do anything on this particular piece of property until we have some understanding of what's going to happen with the adjacent piece. Is that correct?

4:43:07 That's correct. We actually will have the action to take everything to CTC and Sacramento to the Transportation Commission.

4:43:15 I want to say the first meeting in June, assuming we get the remainder of the property as well, which we expect to do that. At that point in time, we'd be authorized to proceed to advertise the project. Certainly, we wouldn't suggest building half of it. We want to clear up the other right-of-way first. Yeah, I'm just glad you came back in the room, Dan, because I think it's the great kind of work the Public Works is doing to identify these things, nail them down, bring them forward. But we have to...

4:43:40 Then integrate them into a holistic system involving signage, construction, map updates, all kinds of stuff like that. Absolutely, yes. Okay. Any other questions for Grady? I have one for Andy. Okay, go ahead. Andy, feeling good about this? Yeah, I'm feeling really good about it. It's a pretty standard purchase and sale agreement. I didn't draft this one, but I have reviewed it. It's typical. The HOA is happy with it. I'm happy with it. Grady's happy with it. I think everybody's happy. That's what I like to hear. Thank you.

4:44:09 Good. Thank you very much. So any thoughts or comments from the public on this item? Okay. Hearing none. Deliberation. Oh, deliberation. I was going to make a motion. Well, we can make a motion. Go for it. I'll go ahead and make a motion that we authorize the mayor to execute purchase agreement for right-of-way necessary for the Mammoth Creek Gap Closure Project. I'll second. I'm happy. Thank you. There's a motion and a second. Any further discussion?

4:44:38 Hearing none, roll call please, Dan. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, the item is agreed to 4-0. So with that, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Nothing from me. Nothing from Cleland, nothing from Shields, Colin. Just a couple. Okay. On Thursday, April 5th, I went to the Mammoth Voices meet and greet lunch. They were hosting Kirk and Stacey Adler.

4:45:11 So thank you to them for putting on that series. It was really informative and helpful. Just encouraging people to get involved, start to get to know your candidates. It seems like the race, which has been eerily quiet, is maybe starting to heat up a little bit. You know, I was really encouraged to hear that we do have a couple of upcoming debates. One is Rich already talked about with Rotary, so that's great.

4:45:39 Also, Paul and Kathleen Rudder have stepped up again to put on another one at the Sierra Center Mall, so they'll announce details on that, but get to know your candidates a little bit. In that vein, I did go to a meet and greet that was hosted by Jennifer Burroughs, candidate for town council. She was gracious enough to put that on and also have a number of other candidates that spoke, including our mayor. So that was cool to have, what was it, six different candidates at the same thing?

4:46:06 And so a couple of those things, looking forward to continued development with that, and that's it for me. Okay. I've been absent for a while. I want to thank Mayor Pro Tem, Hoff, for filling in while I was going and running a very effective, wonderful meeting. Thank you very much for that.

4:46:22 April 2nd, I attended a conference in San Francisco, the Integrated Climate into Adaptation Resiliency Program Technical Advisory Council. This is the climate change body that I serve on. A couple things that are germane to us, they're publishing a website called resilientcalifornia.org, which...

4:46:40 Sacramento is defining our counties and how we are exposed to climate change programs going forward. It's open for a comment period to the end of the month. If anybody's interested in taking a look at it, we should get some comments in that because we need to get some feedback as to how Sacramento defines our county and defines our town. The Office of Emergency Services was there, and they were very interested in the work we're doing with the CEPA grant.

4:47:01 As you may have heard, CAL FIRE has lots and lots of money that they're looking for ways to use that. And I think the role that our town, our community plays as a bridge between a federal landscape and state programs could be some very significant opportunities there. They're very interested in following up on that. The next meeting will be in late June.

4:47:19 I'm the only elected official that's part of this body. I'm the only representative from anybody from the east side of the Sierra. And frankly, they're very receptive to our perspective. And I think we hear a lot about the alienation going on in the state with rural California wanting to secede for the rest of the state. I think that's a road that we don't want to be going down. And I think everything we can do to help bridge those gaps is going to be important. I then attended a conference in Colorado with the Forest Service Sustainable Recreation Conference. This is leadership from Forest Service, Park Service, BLM, and others.

4:47:48 Leadership of a woman named Leslie Weldon, who's number two in the Forest Services in attendance, along with a lot of leadership from Washington. They are very aware of the work that's going on with this partnership with Mono County and the town and the two forests. Very much encouraging for us to keep doing that. It gives us, gave me real insight into the challenges of being a United States federal bureaucracy, a 20th century model.

4:48:10 Looking at how they're going to adapt and change and engage for the 21st century. And frankly, there's going to be major institutional struggles. And I think it's going to be really important for local communities and regions like ours to create agreements with public land managers so that we can start working with them so that they don't just sink either under their own weight or do lack of federal funding.

4:48:31 And leave us holding a bag with a lot of decaying infrastructure and a lot of things that are going to inhibit our ability to be successful, the kind of recreation amenities that we offer. So that was, I think it reinforced the work that we're doing here. It's really critical that we proceed with this stuff.

4:48:46 Then went to the Mountain Venture Summit in Telluride, Colorado. This is an event that actually Scott McGuire and some local folks are actually putting on with some contacts they have in Telluride. Rusty Gregory was the opening speaker, and it's very interesting to hear him say yet again that Altera's business model is predicated upon their visitors coming to having authentic mountain experiences in authentic mountain towns. And suddenly opening the door for...

4:49:11 Cooperation and engagement between the Altera Mountain Company and these local communities, which is ambitious. It's going to be interesting to see how the follow-through works on that and how these authentic mountain communities are going to engage successfully with this quite interesting, large new corporation. Luis Benitez, who's the Director of Outdoor Recreation in the State of Colorado, gave another very inspiring speech. He was here for the Winter Recreation Summit a couple years ago.

4:49:33 But this is really an articulation of the mountain communities across the Intermountain West and across Canada for certain, that we are part of this conversation, we are a community in this world, and it's very encouraging to really have a home with all these fellow communities. Some have broadband, some don't, all have housing crisis, some don't, and to share notes on these things.

4:49:53 It's exciting to hear this conference will be coming to Mammoth next year, February 27th to March 1st. That's going to be a very interesting thing. It's going to be a great opportunity for all of us in the region to engage with these stakeholders as they come here. I attended the LTC meeting. I'm sorry you couldn't make it, Shields. It's an interesting meeting. Great discussion about those horrific accidents and this question about causes and distracted driving kind of really ropes to the top as to maybe a cause perhaps.

4:50:17 There's questions from the LTC about air service because air service falls within the purview of the LTC and there's questions coming up from Monroe County. So as we go to the ESCOG meeting tomorrow and we start getting into these conversations regionally, there's going to be a lot of people with a lot of questions who are going to want to hopefully go to a single point of contact to be able to tell people what's going on and some of the members are kind of concerned about that. Attended the MLH board meeting. New board members were seated, which is a very good move forward. I was a little, sorry.

4:50:47 What's that? Can you go over the names? Of the new MLH board members? Yeah. I don't have them with me. Okay. I was a little disappointed to hear, as advised in the staff report, that there are 10 applicants, but only five interviews. Had some questions about that. I think it's also important for the council to, as part as we go forward with a potential contract with MLH, to understand that the governance structure is called a CHOTO for MLH, and it's a governance...

4:51:14 Tool that allows MLH as a nonprofit to be able to access federal funding, which is an important opportunity, but it also means that the elected representatives who sit on that board cannot vote on board members. They cannot be involved in the recruitment or the seating of...

4:51:27 The board members on that board. And that may be something to think about how we square that with what's in the Community Housing Action Plan, the recommendations for having an NGO that's really reflective of the community and the value for that. I think as a board member, I ask the question as to whether the value proposition in terms of MLH delivering to the community, do we get more money out of being able to access those federal funds?

4:51:47 Or will we get more money and resources if we could have a more representative or a more robust kind of membership of the community from businesses and things like that? It's an open question. I'm looking forward to getting with the town team, which includes you and me and town staff, to start really focusing on the contract proposal at MLH. That's going to be very important going forward. I showed up for the Dusty Dinkelman Duathlon.

4:52:10 At Tamarack on closing day, I was one of two people that showed up. It's a combination skate, skiing, fat bike race. It's pretty cool. The Eastern Sierra Recreation Partnership met this week. Dan was in attendance. And I cannot say enough about Margie DeRose, the current acting district ranger who is...

4:52:29 Cobble together a very complex challenge cost share agreement for the town, the county, the two forests to consider, and we're 95% of the way with that, and I hope that that will be in front of us at our next council meeting. She also shared, as Dan shared earlier, the staffing levels at the Ranger District of Mammoth will probably be about 50% this summer.

4:52:47 And there's going to be a lot of people who are going to get really hot and have a lot of problems with that. And that's frankly coming from priorities coming out of the administration. They're prioritizing resource extraction and timber usage, meaning that the recreation staff or recreation forest service like ours are at the low end of the priority scale. We heard that the regional forest or Randy Moore is encouraging us and others in this position to somehow get to the Secretary of the Department of Agriculture.

4:53:14 I think we could certainly make a pitch that there's potentially $500 million coming out of the state of California that could be spent on federal public lands. We're in a unique position to do this. This would further the objectives of the Secretary of the Trump administration to make these things happen. But I think when you – I've never heard something like that from a regional forester. I think it's sounding a certain kind of alarm bell that says it may be something that we need to act on. So that was pretty interesting. And then we've got an ESCOG meeting tomorrow.

4:53:44 Which hopefully we'll be able to make. And next week, the Chamber of Power Lunch, the Aspen, the Mayor of Aspen, Steve Skadrum, will be here. And I would encourage everybody to go. And I think it's really exciting to be communicating with our pure mountain communities, not as, well, gee, we want to be like you or be you someday. It's really sister to sister, brother to brother, comparing the notes of what it means to be a mountain community and the kinds of struggles and challenges and opportunities that we have. So I would encourage everybody to come and check that out.

4:54:10 I do have one more thing to add since you said that. Sure. The ESTA meeting that was planned for this week is canceled for reasons. And then also the CPT, the Collaborative Planning Team meeting, that is also, I think, maybe due to lack of a quorum with everybody's schedule right now. So just FYI, those meetings will not be happening. Okay, good. Thank you. All right. With that, I think we're done. So we will adjourn to our next meeting, May 2nd.

4:54:40 4 p.m., Dan? Yes. 4 p.m., okay. Thank you all very much.