Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2018
Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)
· recording 3 hr 7 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
349 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:02 I'll call the order of the Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors Meeting, Monday, May 7th. Roll call. Everyone is, Lindsay and Stacey are not here. And we'll move to public comments.
0:35 The podium is open. If no public comments, we'll move to approval of the minutes from March 19th. Any additions, deletions, edits? If I can have a motion. It's been moved. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded. All those in favor who were present? Aye.
1:00 Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item number five, approval of minutes from April 9, 2018, regular board meeting, additions, deletions, edits. Mr. Chairman, I'd like to add, if it's possible to add language, approving the new board members. It just was clear to the public that the reason that myself and Supervisor Corliss abstained was because of the bylaws of the CHOTO.
1:36 Patricia, did you get that? I guess that's clear to the public. With that addition to the minutes, any other additions? I'll make a motion to approve the agenda as amended. I'll second. It's been moved and seconded for the discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes.
2:05 We move to discussion of staff direction on succession planning for the potential recruitment of executive director position. Jennifer? So, at our meeting last month, we reviewed, by and large, the packet that's included. The board asked for some clarification and then interview, time to interview and discuss the proposals from the two.
2:32 firms, Rafa and the Forest Group. So the clarification item I just want to highlight was on the billing, the costs for the Forest Group. There was some inconsistency between was it 25% or 30%? And I included that language under option three. According to Rafa, or excuse me, the Forest Group.
2:58 The rate would be 25% would be a flat fee if we wanted to estimate the average salary, whereas 30% is used when the contract language includes language to adjust the final payment to reflect the candidate's base salary once that offer letter to that candidate has been signed. And they said that the flat fee tends to be a better deal.
3:24 We do have calls scheduled with both Rafa and the Forest Group this evening. The board requested 10 to 15 minutes to discuss questions. I asked them to give a two to five minute overview of their proposals and then an opportunity for the rest of the time for you all to ask questions and have dialogue with them.
3:51 The first folks that we're going to call will be Rafa. They are on the East Coast, and so it's 9-10 there. That would be Karen Shuler. She's the Managing Director, and I believe she has a colleague from Denver, Dave, I believe, joining in, but they weren't 100% sure last I talked to them, so I'm sure they'll let us know when we call in. So my question would be, Mr. Chairman, how do you want to go about asking questions of these folks?
4:22 I think we'll just work our way around the table. Okay. Some sort of con raffle first? Yeah. Yes. Is there a line first? Thank you. Welcome. This service is provided by three conference calls. Two, five, two, seven, four, four. If this is correct, press one. There are two participants in the conference. Please announce yourself. Hello?
5:43 Hi, Karen, this is Jennifer Halferty with Mammoth Lakes Housing and the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board. Hello, this is Karen, and I also have the board, David Erickson. Hello. Hi. Thank you for joining us this evening. As we discussed in our email, the board...
6:08 Wanted to have an opportunity to hear a little bit from you highlighting your proposal and then also I think they all might have some questions and they're going to go round robin with their questions after you're done with a two to five minute highlight if that seems reasonable. Can you hear us all right, Karen? So I think we'll make sure we speak into our microphones. Does that help? That's legitimate. Correct.
7:34 And Dave has played an important role in both of those searches. Dave, did you want to?
8:19 Sacramento in the morning for the... So I think the piece around our work that distinguishes us, there are a number of items. First, we think about success not only in terms of the person who's hired, and we have a really good track record, so almost 95% of CEO hires that are...
8:53 Hired through a RAPA-led search process day three or more years. But we also think about success in terms of how board members, staff, candidates, the community interacts with the process and that through this process we are in many ways serving as an ambassador for the organization and we want everyone who interacts with the process to come away with a really positive reflection.
9:21 on the organization. I think the other piece that's really important is that while there are some commonalities from one executive search to the next, it's really important to us that we are helping to co-create a process that is very tailored and specific to Mammoth Lakes housing's priorities, their values.
9:50 Your culture and how you want to advance the process. And so having said that, it's a little difficult to talk about the process. I know when I spoke with Jennifer, there were a number of different options that might occur. The potential that if there's an election in June, that that could be a deciding point for her transition horizon.
10:19 If that election came out in a different way, then maybe it would be the election in the fall. So I offer that to say we are here to have a conversation with you to figure out what type of process and the timing of it that best suits your needs. And I think I gave you two different work plans where we can do the full search and transition and we can talk about that.
10:47 Or we can do something more at a consulting level. So I'm going to stop there because I've sort of put a lot of information out. What is most helpful to the board in terms of discussing our proposal and our approach? Jennifer, have you provided her with a calendar of hypotheticals in the sense of June 5th? Can you say that again, please?
11:21 Can you hear me? Hello? Yes? Has a calendar been shared with you as to Jennifer's, the possibility that she can be elected on June 5 and then she would be appointed at a later date? Has that calendar been shared with you? Yes, Jennifer shared that timing with me that
11:53 Depending on what happens in the June election, that will inform whether or not she needs to wait until the fall election. She did share that with me. Questions? Sure. Hi, can you hear me okay? I can. Thank you. Great, thank you. Ignore that hockey game. It's immaterial. My first question is, I have two questions, and I'm hoping you can
12:26 address these. The first is Mammoth Lakes is a resort mountain community. And I'm wondering if you could talk a little bit about your understanding of knowledge of what you think a resort slash mountain community is. And secondly, if you could advise as to how you would address trying to recruit talent that would be a good match for a community such as ours.
12:53 With our very specific profile around outdoor recreation and health and living on an island. So thank you. Dave, do you want me to start? If you'd like, that's fine, sure. Sure. So I've not been specifically to Mammoth Lakes, so I can't speak in terms of boots on the ground experience. But when we look at resort communities,
13:25 One of the things that we often find is sort of two groups of folks in the community. They are the vacation home owners and the visitors that come and enjoy all of the amenities. And then there is often a second part of the community that's there year-round that is all of the support pieces that support that community.
13:55 And I think some of the challenges for Mammoth Lakes is I suspect that there is limited availability of affordable housing, that there's not a significant community eye potentially on that issue, and that also the location of your community
14:24 is one that's going to take, it's going to have a different draw and a different appeal than, for example, working with an organization in Sacramento, which is an urban community. And so I don't think this is an easy search. Dave, did you want to add? Yeah. I live in communities, resort communities. I'm well aware from housing.
15:32 Great. Thank you very much. Let alone the teachers and the policers and others, you know, in small business. Great. Thank you. We've got several board members here, so I'll thank you for your response. Tom? Yeah. Hi, Karen and Dave. This is Tom Hodges on the board. I work for the ski resort here, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. And I was just going to mention, I mean, this is maybe more of a statement, and maybe you guys can just feel free to comment on it.
16:46 In some of our past executive searches, we've run into trouble where we got a candidate very interested in the position, and then they got here and they didn't like the school district. They didn't feel that it offered enough diversification for their children in terms of programs, and they were worried about them getting adequate education here for their future goals in college and so forth, and they ended up turning us down.
17:15 Recently, we, as the community, advertised for an executive director for our nonprofit transit district, and they had a, I'm not sure what the cause was, but they had some finalists, and they all ended up walking away at the end for livability issues. Not just housing costs, but I think coming to realize that, like John mentioned, that we live on an island, effectively, we're three hours from the nearest big box retail shop.
17:43 We live in the high Sierras and we're subject to extreme winter weather at times. And these things affect people's ability to live here, not necessarily the applicant, but maybe their spouse or their family. So I'm just curious how you guys handle that so that you can kind of, you know, identify these issues up front with the candidates so we're not wasting everybody's time. I mean, it's a great job, but when they say, hey, I got to live in this community, it's a beautiful, it's a resort, but then again, we can get...
18:12 Three weeks straight of snow every day, and you're blowing snow in your driveway every morning, and these things can be stressful for people, so I'm curious how you weed that out. For small communities, you almost have to, in the position announcement, that a great opportunity for somebody who values and has some experience living in small communities, loves
18:54 Skiing, hiking, looking for that kind of an environment. Yeah, I think it's, the goal is to integrate information about the community early on in the process. So it's in the position profile. As we're doing screening, we're talking about the community and screening for that.
19:36 that information. You know, I can think of a search that I actually did recently. Now, it's not as isolated of a community as Mammoth Lakes is, but it's in northeast Indiana. And they were looking for people with some very particular expertise. And we simply added
20:04 to our conversation as we were screening candidates, a lot of conversation about the community and that it's a rural community and it's aging and the dynamics of that. And then we integrated into the search process itself opportunities for the finalists to not only have an interview in person, but
20:33 to bring their spouses with them and a whole tour of the community and really looking at the parts of the community that the spouse also cared about. And, you know, we have to be careful with that because marital status is not something that you're supposed to really address, except that when you're getting down to finalists, I think if a finalist comes with a package deal, let's call it,
21:02 I think you have to integrate, and it's going to involve a relocation. I think you absolutely have to integrate activities that ensure that, you know, the partner or family members that would come with the candidate are on board. Yeah, I agree. I think the important thing is just to be as transparent up front as possible so people get the full picture and, you know, understand the, you know, the highs and lows of living in this community. Right.
21:40 Other questions? Yeah, I was just getting a microphone. My name is Donna, and I've been here for almost 20 years, and Tom pretty much hit the point where I was just going to ask you the same questions, but I do have another question that Tom didn't ask, and that is, say you go through all your applicants, and actually, let's step back a little bit. Have either of you ever been to Mammoth Lakes before? If not, I've been to Yosemite.
22:13 What park were you asking if we'd been to? To our town, to Mammoth Lakes. To Mammoth Lakes, to the tech community. No. Okay. I was just curious about that. So anyhow, to get back to the original question, say Tom said we had applicants that ended up bailing out on this other job that we had offered here.
22:38 Through transit. Now my question to you is your fees. Say that exact same scenario happened. Say you've had four applicants and they came here and they ended up not wanting the job. Does that fee change when you have to start all over from the very beginning? How does that work? No. The fee doesn't change. And in fact,
23:07 If we go through a process and it doesn't yield the right candidate or the right fit, it's not really a situation where you're starting all over because I truly believe that with every conversation and every candidate that we look at and interview and have discussions, that continues to hone both your filters and our filters around what is the best fit.
23:35 So if we get to the point where we've moved a group of candidates through a series of interviews and ultimately the committee decides their next executive isn't in the mix or the candidate decided ultimately that they didn't want to take the job, we go out and renew our efforts to bring another candidate pool to you. The only additional expense is there may be an additional expense to fly a
24:05 to bring a candidate in for an interview. So the only additional expenses are the reimbursable expenses. Okay. I approve. Okay. Thank you. Right. And likewise, if a candidate leaves within the first year, we do the work without an additional charge to you. The only exception to that and
24:35 It's only occurred once, which is why we have the exception, is if the organization has not been fully transparent in disclosing financial information or other relevant information to the candidate. We had one search where the executive stepped into the position and called us within the first day to ask us if we had understood that
25:04 The organization had no money in the banks, which was not what the financial statements that were shared with the candidate actually revealed. And it turns out that they basically shared dated financial statements that hadn't reflected some major piece of funding that wasn't received. Fortunately for the organization, the executive was so passionate about their mission that he decided to stay and help them figure out
25:34 their way out of their financial trouble. Well, that's good to hear. I just also want to reiterate Tom and John that they talked about real quick here and then we can move on. There is one grocery store here maybe and then there is another small one coming in and then there is no Costco and there is no Target and it is very rural. So I'll just kind of reiterate that. Thank you for your time. Thank you.
26:05 My question is, describe your process for outreach for a candidate. I mean, what are the steps you go through to reach out for a candidate or candidates? Yeah, so part of our process is what I call passive, and that's putting job postings up on different job boards. That relies on potential candidates seeing the job posting and applying.
26:34 The more significant part of our process is pushing out through both our networks as well as your networks and following up all of those conversations and emails and just looking to get the job opportunity in front of people who probably are not looking necessarily for their next job but who would
27:05 would think about it. I think in this case, one of the pieces that we certainly would do is some additional research, looking at other communities that have similarities to Mammoth Lakes, although not necessarily in the Sierra Nevadas, maybe at other places in the Rockies, and looking for potential candidates from those communities. Dave, do you want to talk a little bit more about outreach?
27:36 Yeah. It certainly is where you find the thing in a Sierra Club. People who have a lot of the affordable housing development to people, a lot of that work is focused. Are you aware of any state organizations that focus on, California state organizations that focus on workforce housing? I'll reach various states. The National Search for the Rural Community Assistance Partnership.
29:55 And we also did some work with their regional organization, Rural Community Assistance Corporation in California. Thank you. Hi, good evening. Those are the types of groups that level in being in a small community. The mountains are... At the beginning stages of outreach, I mean, would you put a... What is your first step, should we say, in putting together...
30:52 So what we do in the first phase of the work is to get in relationship with you and to help you be really clear about where the organization is now and what's important to the organization over the next one, two, three years. So we're really trying to
31:24 align the search work with the strategic needs of the organization. So it's conversations with you all early on and likely with Jennifer and the other staff person to talk about what are those opportunities as well as the challenges that the organization is looking at and then how does that help to inform the skills and the experience and the
31:52 So the position profile is more of a marketing document. And again, we would absolutely include as part of that profile a section on the Mammoth Lakes community. And, you know, I think we need to be transparent, but I think we also need to highlight some of the wonderful aspects of the community.
32:22 As well as the remote aspects of the community. And so that position profile is that marketing document. We can use a shortened and abbreviated version of it for some job posting. But we really are looking less than having sort of a laundry list of responsibilities and more being thoughtful around
32:52 What the leadership opportunity is that presents itself. So this would be put together and then shared with the board, the Mammoth Lake Housing Board, prior to it going out? Absolutely. Thank you. Absolutely. And we would also share a search plan with the board. So you would have the ability to take a look at the recommendations we have around job posting. I think the other piece to
33:24 to help the board think about is the potential for internal candidates, potentially your other staff person, and another area of internal candidates might be board members. We've seen that in some of our searches where board members decide to apply. And so if the board thinks that that might be a possibility, we can also work with you to discuss the
33:53 Thank you. Certainly we also would be looking in the immediate region. Sometimes there are people working
34:30 Okay. Hi, this is Stacy Corliss. My question, I thank you for the very detailed proposal, and I especially think it's important for us to look at this, the concept of the transition plan and getting help with that. I think that would be really useful. But just, can you talk a little bit more about our unique timing?
35:10 and process issue that we're facing with elections and have you, I would think with non-profits maybe something like, you've dealt with something like this before and you know, yeah, how will you deal with the two sort of milestones of the elections and be able to adjust your recruitment process as needed? Yeah, so we put together a proposal that had sort of two
35:40 either a full retained search or the ability to do transition consulting and then when the search was more imminent then to add that to it. I would encourage you all to go with the transition consulting to start and one of the things that we can do is help you think ahead of time about what
36:06 The transition process will look like that will work for you. You know, what will those activities be? What can we say about timing? We can help you think about putting together a communications plan so that, you know, if there's a particular result in June, you are already equipped with messages and messaging channels in order to make some announcements around
36:35 Jennifer's horizon and so forth so that you are ahead of communications because what happens in the absence of communication is that people fill in some of the most interesting yet untrue versions of what they think is going on. So I do think that there is an opportunity in May to get some things lined up
37:05 So that if the election in June goes a certain way, you're ready to move ahead. And if it goes differently, you've done all of the thinking and the planning. Thank you. Thank you very much. I don't know that there's any other questions for board members. Thank you for your time. And I think we'll follow back up with you after the board has more discussion this evening.
37:55 Wonderful. And certainly as you all are having a conversation, if you find there's, you know, another piece of information that would be helpful to you, please don't hesitate to reach out to us. We'd be happy to be responsive. Oh, that's great. All right. Thank you all very much. Thank you. Okay. Bye. Bye. Bye. The Forest Group. This is the Forest Group. Yes, next. Right now.
39:00 This is Mary. Hi, Mary. This is Jennifer in the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors. Can you hear me okay? Hi, guys. How are you all doing? Great. Great. Thank you. Thank you for joining us. Sorry that we're running behind schedule. Yeah, no problem. I'm going to have to ask you guys to hold for just 30 seconds. I need to run into the other room and grab Adam really quick and let him know that you guys are on the line. So I apologize, but if you guys will hold on real quick for me one second. Absolutely. Thank you.
40:02 is going to be on momentarily. Can you guys hear me okay? Yep. Yes. Perfect. Hello, Ash. Hello. Hello. Hi. So, this is Jennifer, and we have, let's see, seven board members here this evening, and we talked about having, as we talked in our email conversation, about having you guys give us a brief two to five minute overview of your proposal.
40:33 And then the board is going round robin with questions for you. Does that sound like that will work for you? That'll be fine. Great. Thank you. Sure. Well, certainly happy to deliver a commercial about the forest group, but maybe I'll just sort of lose up inside of the questions that you ask. Simple. You know, that I feel like one thing that sets us, but one thing as it relates, that we guarantee work that we do for a minimum of one year.
41:56 The point of view indicates that if we are selected to do it, the kind of candidates that we're going to do. Because, as you all know, a mortgage to pay, I think, again, that's another. Our work is probably 70 to 80 percent, you know, both at the executive. Mary and I would never, only strong, be digging into, strategically digging into a set of cultural values that are, in this case, you know, becomes the face of the organization. We want to make sure we're meeting the media. Those are some of the things.
44:38 Hi, this is Giselle Kenny with the board. Can you hear me? We hear you. Okay, sorry. Is this better? A little bit, thank you.
46:28 Okay. I was just wondering if you guys have the statistic of, like, your percentage of people you hire in the Executive Director position stay more than five years or so, if you have a statistic around that. You know, I don't have that statistic at hand. I'd be happy to do some research on that. You know, it's interesting, I think, organizations have an Executive Director for minus years. In other words, you know, the key things that
47:48 Thank you. You bet. Hi, this is Stacey Corliss. Can you hear me? Hello. Yes, we can. Okay, good. My question really is around process and timing. You've seen our unique needs regarding the elections process this year. And I'm just wondering if you could, I'm not sure how to ask this question, but
48:29 Maybe describe an instance in one of your past recruitments where you've dealt with some unknowns like we're dealing with here in the timeline and process and how you helped your clients move forward with the process and get somebody hired. Hi, this is Mary. I'm going to jump in and answer that one. I am going to apologize. I think towards the end you started to get a little quiet and I couldn't hear at the end, but it sounds like the question is, you know, can we get you, what is our standard?
49:02 Timeline and Processing. Can we get unique with this type of situation? Yeah, and then just adding on to that is maybe provide an example of how you've assisted clients when there's some uncertainty, you know, help them move in the right direction toward a successful hire. So for an executive director search, I will say that these tend to take longer than our for-profit search. A typical timeline is going to be 90 to 120 days.
49:36 That said, if we have clients that need expedited timelines, we have had not an instance just like the one that you guys are particularly in where you don't know what your future is going to be come mid-June, but that said, we are just here to partner with you guys and figure out what works. If we need to articulate a timeline and work towards specific deadlines or times, I will say that we are flexible that way. We have about a four-stage process to where
50:06 Our first stage is all about getting to know you guys and identifying potential candidates and figure out other types of organizations that are similar to yours. We could start on something like that fairly quickly and at that point should we have the green light to where you guys say yes we need to hire someone then we hit the go button and we have all the research done and we can start then actively recruiting candidates and from there know that if this is an expedited timeline we would go as quickly as possible.
50:35 But honestly, a search in under 60 days is, I'd say 60 days is probably the quickest that we've ever done an executive search. Would you agree, Adam? No, I think Mary brings, you know, Truckee, for example, is an hour and a half away from us, and we live in rural Northern California. My wife and I live, you know, in a community where we have 30 river in a transient population. Housing is always a challenge. Part of me, when I look at other, you know, where you have a recreation-based experience,
51:24 And once we're there, then we put a pause and wait for results of the election or any other strategy.
52:28 A few things that you all would get out of a valuable experience, you have an internal identity that the community would see. And sources of the influential group, anybody who comes in contact, walks away from the experience of the organization, whether they win the role or not, we want them in some way more passionate than what we accomplish in writing the recruit. In those early phases that we identify, and then we would write the recruit profile, which I think would be a sort of re-exam.
54:19 Thank you. That was very helpful. Can you hear me? Hello? Yes, we can. It's a little fuzzy, but we can hear you. Thank you. This is Kirk. I'm a board member. You've already started the process of describing your outreach.
54:59 towards different candidates. So after you've created this profile, then what's the next step? Sure. After the recruitment profile, that's when we really begin for this call. And, you know, we really feel like we would need to go find us at a deep level of direct, and that means direct interviewing candidates, identifying their strengths and building out, you know, a larger set of, you know,
56:10 We have you interview them. We debrief with the candidates. We debrief with you. What is the best someone's front of the entire? Maybe that you're going to find this moment an opportunity for you as an organization to get some awesome free consulting from candidates. Give them a
57:17 One more question. Sorry, there's a lot of feedback on this. When you do your outreach, what...
58:20 Organization, housing organizations, especially in California, do you target? Great question. As Adam mentioned, this is a little bit of new territory for us. We haven't done searches in the past that are around real estate or housing. We usually focus on the outdoor industry, but where we really find our strengths are in finding you guys' cultural fit, and we know what the town of Mammoth DNA is and who is your community.
58:53 That said, to answer your question, it would take a lot of research on our end. We would need to meet with you guys. We would have some one-on-ones with your staff and the board to see, well, who do you guys see as other organizations that you look to for inspiration or influence? And do you guys feel like there are others that you know about? We would then do our own research to get this up and going, identifications, and from there, knowing, matching across your job description, try and find individuals that...
59:23 From the get-go on paper look like they would be folks who would do well in this position. And from... I'll say, you know, Jennifer, I imagine you're probably involved in, come familiar with, and, you know, Scannell, I imagine if you're looking for real estate, you know, potentially I would look at land trusts as well throughout California. And, you know, you see a lot of rural communities and rural land trusts stronger and strong strategic position in their communities.
1:00:04 They want to preserve that rural landscape if they'd like to, but from a monetary point of view. And I would lean into you in terms of what we would do, but certainly given our into land trust and NGOs. Thank you. Good evening. My name is Donna. And I just pretty much heard that a lot of talk about the position and being dedicated and someone who would really enjoy the job. But again, we are a rural community.
1:01:08 And the other half of also this job position is living here and all the challenges it takes to living in a rural community and how expensive it is. Were you going to put that out there out front about the job and ask those questions and let them know what it's like to be living in the community of Mammoth Lakes and the challenges? You know, we believe in, so we don't want any surprises at the 11th hour.
1:01:49 Okay, thank you. I'm lucky with Mammoth Lakes, if I'm not mistaken, the gentleman who took the role actually owned a con
1:02:53 Even the fact that we found that guy is a miracle for which I applaud Mary Maliff. Hi, guys. Tom Hodges here on the Board of Directors. I work for the ski resort. Yeah, further to Donna's point, I just, we just, again, sort of a comment more than a question, just, you know, I think the need to get the information out to the early on in the process, just, you know, about the particulars of living in our community, not above and beyond the
1:03:28 Financial challenges, if you will. I mean, there's just the physical issues you deal with here in the environment, you know, that we're in the high Sierra, extreme winter weather conditions, you know, can take it out on people that aren't used to it. So I think it's important to portray the realities of living here and what that involves. I think the other aspect of it is, you know, just speaking from experience at the skier where we went through a pretty exhaustive search for somebody and had it down to basically kind of one finalist.
1:03:58 They didn't like the school district and opted out. So just, you know, again, trying to disseminate that type of information early in the process so that people understand all the challenges of the fact that we're three hours from the nearest big box retail and, you know, our school district has its limitations being, you know, small and a small district and remote. These things can affect people's choices of actually making that final decision to move here.
1:04:25 One other question that I was curious about in terms of your fee and the process. So because we have had a recent experience with the recruitment of an executive director for our transportation district that ended up in nobody, everybody falling out at the last minute, if we were to encounter that scenario, how would you guys handle your fee, so to speak, in terms of, I understand, I read your proposal, you don't.
1:04:51 You know, you don't work for free, but by the same token, if we're unsuccessful after the initial search, how do you guys handle that with respect to your fee proposal? That's a great question, but so many other assets in the community, you know, beyond Mammoth Mountain itself, you know, I'm a backpacker, the Hoover Wilderness and the Eastern Sierras are extraordinary, and, you know, you've got the, I mean, you just have a, you know, ensure that we find the right person. We are, we
1:05:45 Concerns are if they have with any special needs. Those kinds of things we try to discover as we build trust with them and they build trust with us. See, nine months is that we have taken on that entire year. We end up making money as an organization and we're truthful with their research. The only time it's been completed is when there is a strategic shift in the organization. You know, if we move forward, you know, you'll have
1:06:58 Okay, so like if we had to rerun, if we have to kind of rerun that last part of the process, if we kind of came up without a candidate in the first pass, you would be willing to do that? Is that what you're saying? Absolutely. And, you know, the only time that we would talk about a fee adjustment with you is if there was just an extraordinary shift in the job description itself. Sure. Right? And then at that point, you know, certainly it becomes kind of a new search or a different search.
1:07:28 Okay, thank you. You betcha.
1:08:39 Your final inquisitor. My name is John Wentworth and I've got two quick questions for you. The first is, could you speak a little bit about your understanding of mountain resorts, mountain communities and resort communities and how these can be factors in your search efforts? And secondly, can you talk a little bit more, if you feel it's appropriate, about the talent pool that you're going to tap?
1:09:06 To try to find someone for this position, this is not something that's necessarily, as you've said, in your normal area of expertise. Thank you. You bet. People, you know, we live where we're more than 25 acres. I'm by a river. Just say that like in the world. I'm kind of a guy of the West, if you will. You know, I think we would. I think we would look at different communities from Truckee to South Lake to Vail, some of the East Coast.
1:10:10 The Rocky Mountain region as well. We know all of those patients like Vale Roots and others that we inform you, for example, if we got a ski company or research patients that you're connected to your networks and also tap into. And, you know, our action is that you hold us to that research. One of the ways that we think is that you're looking for seven of them. You can practice in terms of your own interview skills. Calibrator will actually, but you need to course.
1:11:58 Excellent. Thank you very much. You're welcome. I think that's all the questions that we have. If you have any questions of us. A ton. Not now. Exactly. A four-year-old is tonight. We are able to
1:13:26 Anything else that you need for us? Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks. Okay. Jennifer, thanks for setting this. Thank you, Mary. Thank you, Adam. Have a good night. Thank you. That was interesting. Yeah. How do you want to proceed? Do you want to just go around the table and say which of the two presentations were the strongest? If you want, I can start off. The forest group, I mean, he's really, he's very good.
1:14:17 And even though they have not the experience in this particular area, it seems like he has a process to move through that is much stronger than the other group. So that's my comment. I would, if we're going to hire outside help, then I would certainly support the forest group. I absolutely agree with Kirk. I think it's nice to have someone.
1:14:53 So I have to agree with Kirk, Kirk, K-I-R-K. I like the Forest Group. I think it's having them close to us in California I think is very important. Again, they're from a mountain resort town. They probably, I'm guessing, by the way, his answers were that he understands the challenges of living in California in a mountain resort community.
1:15:21 Though he has not hired anybody for the housing, I still think that he knows what our needs are, and I feel like he can move forward more. And I like the fact that he is local compared to the other company, Rafta. Yeah, I would concur. I mean, not that the other group wasn't good, too. I mean, honestly, they were very thorough. They were more expensive on their fee than the forest group.
1:15:51 I think that, you know, when you start evaluating the other aspects, these expenses can run up to be, could be quite expensive. The other group being East Coast based, a lot more expensive to travel. I mean, you just have to start really thinking about the practical aspects of this, right? You're going to be paying airfares from the East Coast versus somebody being able to drive down from the west side of the Sierra, right? So, I mean, these are things that will affect us in terms of cost, you know, not that we don't want to get the right, the best candidate, right, in the end of the day.
1:16:21 You know, I think we, again, in a lot of ways, like I said, I mean, I think both groups kind of admitted that, but they're really going to be looking to us to help guide them in terms of areas we'd recommend that they start, you know, reaching out to and so forth. So hopefully, you know, between our networks, the consultants we've worked with here recently, you know, we can get, do a sufficient job of getting the word out into the right channels and getting, getting the job advertised well. So,
1:16:51 You know, I think considered, I certainly wouldn't have any objection to going with Forest Group. If I can just add something, in the recruitment process, the ESTA recruitment process, we provided a stipend for people coming to Bishop for an interview, and if they're in state, it was one.
1:17:11 Monetary value, and if it was out of state, it was another monetary value, but it was set, so they knew what it would cost, and if it cost, you know, cost more than that, then they would be out of pocket. Yeah, seems reasonable. I was involved in the MLR process, and they were really good, that nimbility and ability to adjust to unforeseen things happen. They actually do that. They don't kind of lock you into boxes.
1:17:41 And I think that calibration candidate thing is a really key thing because that gives us a way to sort of let them know from the beginning, this is the ballpark we want to be in. And I think also I think it's really important that for the engagement of the board and the organization and saying, look, these are the resources, these are the places we want you to look. It helps as opposed to us just kind of sitting back passively and kind of someone showing up in two or three months and saying, here are the people.
1:18:08 You know, we're a little bit more engaged, and I think we can really make sure we're sending them to go out and find the people in their networks that are the kind of people we're looking for. Right. Oh, go ahead. I'm sorry. So I actually like Rafa more because of their focus on how they do 100% of working with nonprofits. Because I work at a nonprofit, I know how important it is to find a certain...
1:18:35 Person to run that organization and someone who's going to run a non-profit requires such a certain skill set and personality that I think it would be really integral. God, I'm struggling with my words. It would be really important for us to get an agency that really understands that importance.
1:18:56 David, I think his name was, he did say he had, like, familiar with, like, Colorado Mountain Town, so I don't think they completely don't understand what our needs are, and I think it's also really awesome how they have a great understanding of nonprofits who work in the housing world, and so I just think with their expertise and knowledge of everything that they would actually benefit us more. I agree with Kurt and Donna about what they said about the first, the second organization.
1:19:28 With the forest group? And I agree with whatever they said. Yeah, I agree that the forest group is probably a much better cultural fit, especially after the successful MLR recruitment, but I also agree with some of Giselle's points specific to non-profit executive transition, and I really liked their emphasis on transition planning, and I think we could really benefit from this.
1:19:58 My biggest concern about us, about this process is us knowing what we need. There's so many uncertainties with no pending contract with the town, what the scope of this job will be, changes on the board perhaps. So I think if we go ahead with Forest Group,
1:20:20 Maybe even take some of the elements of this transition plan concept that Rafa had and just, I mean, it sounds like sort of organically they do that in their process, but I think it would be really good for us to articulate that we might, that we would like something like that. I mean, he did, Adam did talk about more clearly identifying their specific phases and putting a dollar amount to each phase.
1:20:45 If we're going to go ahead with this, I'd really like to see that on paper and just pitch them the idea of this transition plan. Maybe I'm the only one that liked that, but I think that really appealed to me about the RAFA proposal. Maybe they could do something like that. I heard that, and I think the other thing they said is they needed to work off our...
1:21:06 A current strategic plan, which we don't have. That's the other unknown. So there's a bunch of things we're going to have to, I think your point is well made, and I think we're going to have to address all that stuff as a board for the organization before I think we can probably engage you the way I used to. Yeah, and that was the appeal, I guess, with Rafa, is that they sounded like, oh, they could get going before we knew some of this stuff, so maybe ask for a script, like, hey, we're some stuff up in the air, but, you know, if we engage you in this process, can you, you know,
1:21:35 What can you do before we know exactly what we're looking for? Yep. Or if you can at all. Yeah. Just saying that makes me think they would probably want to say, no, you need to know what you want before we can. Yeah. Right. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah, I mean, that'll be critical is just defining what we want as specific as we can, right, at the right time. But you're right. I mean, we're in an interesting period right now with the election process and the effect that that may have on the board and what's that going to.
1:22:04 You know, how's that going to play into the contract with the town? And, you know, depending on how things go, this position could evolve into something it isn't today as well. So I think it's important. I honestly think we're going to have to wait until after the election results to figure out exactly what we're going to do so we can define the position correctly. But, yeah, you make a great point. I mean, I think it is the idea of, I mean, the work that they outlined for a fairly reasonable.
1:22:33 $7,500 I think it was for the Rafa deal to go kind of help you with that pre-planning and transition plan. There's certainly, there's a lot of value there for sure. So I mean, why not ask Forest Group if they could do something like that? Yeah, yeah. Well, and the fact of the matter is they're quite a bit less on base fee, right? So maybe there's, you could ask them for a little, or we could just see whether they're willing to include that and whatever. I mean, you know, there's ways we can play it a little bit.
1:23:06 Pretty impressive, I have. Though the housing is not in here. At least I didn't see when I was going through it several times. But they have a lot of good clients. Great. So I'm just wondering, this is a pretty large, amorphous item, and I'm just wondering how you'd like to take us through this and what points of decision and discussion are... Well, I think that...
1:23:33 There's a consensus here in regards to the forest group and that there's a timing issue as well as a contract issue, getting that as well as a strategic plan and how all these different things come together and of course the election. So, you know, it's almost like June 5 is going to be...
1:23:55 I think we've scheduled for June 7 a... No, we haven't made a schedule yet. We need to talk about that under this item, actually, about moving our next meeting. I think we need to make some hard decisions, though I think they sent. And I agree if... Let me jump over to Giselle. Giselle, I think that creating a position announcement is where the board can say, no, we need this.
1:24:23 type of profile. This is where you profile the individual. So if they create a webpage or a flyer that actually goes out, I mean, it basically profiles what you're looking for. And so I think that we can address that through the recruitment process and say we want a strong emphasis on an NGO, somebody with NGO experience.
1:24:52 Yeah, I agree. I think ideally that is something that can be done within that process. I just know that there's so many things that are... God, I'm really struggling with my thoughts today. There's so many things that are...
1:25:12 That we can ask for within the profile of ensuring that someone has the characteristics that we're looking for. I just really liked the idea of having someone who had like 100% idea and knowledge of, and their focus was on non-profits, because I've seen where hiring a person who wasn't fit for a non-profit world has really hurt an agency. And so I just don't want that to happen to Mammoth Lakes Housing. We do great work here, so I don't want.
1:25:41 As to bring in someone who wants to change the culture and change, just change who we are as an organization because they don't fully understand the nonprofit that came off as if they did. Further discussion? I think the consensus, John, I don't know, the consensus is that we need to have a special board meeting right after June 5. Well, yeah, I would have liked, if I could, just the way that the item is laid out.
1:26:09 We've just had the two calls. We had discussion about there's a consensus, I think, towards the Forest Group. The next paragraph here talks about the schedule of the next meeting, so maybe we can talk about that. Maybe it's going to work through what's in the staff agenda, and that might be helpful. Yeah, so the normal meeting, regular meeting, if you will, is June 4th, but that's the day before the election.
1:26:32 I've had a request from another board member to move it to after the election just for the best use of our time getting together and be most productive. I don't know what's best for everyone. If it's later in that week or if it's the following Monday, but maybe we could all get our calendars out and see if we could find a date that works. Yeah, I think that that's important. I think first, if we all agree that it's important to have the next meeting after the election, which I would...
1:26:58 We'd like to know if that was what we want to do, and if that's true, then let's schedule a date and do it that way. Is it consensus? Everybody agrees? Yeah. So, can you give us some calendar dates? Sure. Well, and I know that some people work... People can pull up their calendars and make sure they're available. ...of that nature. What about...
1:27:18 The 6th is Wednesday. You're going to have a town council meeting, so that doesn't work. I know that Zariah works nights on Thursday, Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays. Does the 11th work? It would be that following Monday. It works for me. Yes, it works for me. It works for me. Yep. Great. 6 p.m., June 11th. Sweet Z. Good.
1:27:49 And I'll request some more information, kind of honing in on this transition and phases from the forest group, similar to what we saw from the Rafa group, and what they alluded to, just to really elaborate and provide us with some more detail. And if you can provide us, if you do win 51%, what's your calendar? What is your schedule? Oh yeah, I'll be communicating with you prior to the meeting, I would imagine, on that.
1:28:19 Okay. And I kind of just have a clarification question. Are we as a group deciding to go with an outside agency, not deciding which one yet, or we have with Forest, or are we still open to the ideas of possibly using the HR within the towns? Have we come to that conclusion yet, or are we still figuring that out?
1:28:44 I think that needs to be scheduled on the 11th to use town resources in discussion with the budget as well as Jennifer's situation. So I think we still have a lot of, and there's still the contract, and there's still the strategic plan. Some of the pieces have got to be put in place. I know, it's like chicken or egg. Yeah, okay, wait a minute. And, I mean, I think
1:29:13 Shady Rest is going to have a big impact on what role does Mammoth Lake Housing, I mean, are we just going to be partnering to go after grants, you know, with the town and the town takes the developer lead on that? What is the relationship in respect to, you know, chasing grants? I mean, cap and trade and everything else and unfortunately HUD is
1:29:41 is being decimated, so we're not going to get federal grants coming through the state. So if I could, I think back to the agenda item that we're on, I think it makes, I think it's important to move the meeting to the next, to have a discussion at that point when it's known the fate of our Executive Director.
1:30:01 If there are further discussions or further decisions have to get made based, because the election, we're all, I'm not going to assume they're all rooting for Jennifer, but we all wish her the best of luck and hope things work out well. There are other scenarios within that that the board may have to consider, and I think we can wait to deal with all those, just with the whole package of things at that meeting. I would, there are a couple things with the recruitment process that the towns with Mr. Councilmember Ferney and
1:30:27 Town Manager Hall, we've had some discussions, and there may be some things at this point. It's germane to this item that Dan may want to share with the group a little bit that might be helpful going forward. Whatever you want public comment. Pardon? Whatever you want public comment, I'd like to comment on the item. Yes. I didn't want to share with you, Dan, with your discussion. The podium is open. Thanks. Yeah, I did want to provide a couple of comments. I liked some of the discussion there, and I asked if the decision hasn't been made yet, the town is still willing to participate in whatever.
1:31:01 Capacity requested by the board in terms of the recruitment process. I do like the idea of the transition planning and that work. The other side of that, we agree that looking at an agenda item or the next board meeting after the election makes sense. There is a lot of, you know, I'll say uncertainty in terms of the board and not just Jennifer's election bid, but three members on the board that could all have a change in their election status as well following that time frame.
1:31:31 So looking at that, and also as noted, some of this will be rehashing things that have already been said, but ultimately looking at the position in some of the work on the roles and responsibilities based on being assigned by the town to MLH, be the contract work, complete that.
1:31:50 Mentioned the timeline. A couple of key issues that we're looking at, one would be continuing the CHOTO status or not, will be a question, and does anybody have that experience to understand it as you're bringing somebody on board? Excuse me. A little bit on funding the recruitment, just based on the staff report, I thought the staff report laid out it pretty good up front, just here's all the different moving parts, which was great. But as you're looking at that, if you're utilizing excess revenue from
1:32:19 That was from rents, I think, and management fees, net rents and stuff. Well, that's a policy question. Ultimately, should those funds go back into wherever they're coming out of some of those facilities? You've started a reserve fund, which is good to see in the budget for a reinvestment. And then talk more about the budget if you want under the item later on the agenda. But also just kind of looking at that overall structure for that to move forward with. Lost my notes, sorry.
1:32:48 On that sense of it, I think it's good in terms of looking at what does that structure look like. And then in the attachment material that was provided in your board packet, kind of a quick update on the opportunities, your timeline that was in there as one of the agenda attachments, looking at updating this a little bit. The first one deals with the contract.
1:33:13 Looking at a potential meeting coming up in May. I know Lindsay's on the team along with Kurt that was trying to get a time scheduled and I forgot that Lindsay was going to be out of town for this week. So looking at probably next week at the earliest, I forget, Jennifer sent me some dates when she's back in town to look at that. The other question on that, given the timeline on this, whether or not having somebody else also involved from the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board that
1:33:41 We'll be here following the election for certain. Some of you may be, some of you may have a whole new role, unknown at this point, but looking at that type of an issue just in terms of being able to move that forward in that area, so that committee structure that way. And also, you know, the strategic planning process that's planned and kind of laid out there, it raised the question whether or not to delay for the ED or not. I think that's a board call in terms of
1:34:08 That involvement. About that same time frame, the town will actually be updating its strategic planning process. That's an August-September time frame based on calendars for the dates and stuff. But that'll probably end up with some level of overlap. So being able to make sure those two processes ultimately kind of get integrated together between not just MLH's strategic plan, but we'll be requesting the same issues with our other NGOs and looking on how do you move that forward accordingly.
1:34:38 Making those lay out together from a time frame issue. So, maybe worth, you know, starting part of that discussion, but seeing how the town strategic planning goes as well. Those elements tend to fall hand in hand with each other. Hopefully, as we look forward, as mentioned, that would address some of the other shady rest, no doubt, touches on, you know, the property that MLH has acquired and other efforts within the housing action plan.
1:35:06 And then that process to move forward. So anyway, wanted to touch on those things in terms of that process. We can touch on some of the budget issues as you get to that item on your agenda. I think that's something you ought to keep an eye on, looking at some of those elements there as we are at the town level too, going through our budget process. And we'll be looking at those allocations, both the MLH as well as MLT and MLR. So all of that discussion is underway at this point in terms of the budget preparation work.
1:35:37 And I can touch on more detail on that under the appropriate agenda item. Thank you. Questions? Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. I think it's, you know, warrants kind of point out that just because of the timing or anything, we're in kind of a pickle here, you know? I mean, we're not going to, it seems like we're going to have a challenge to really set some, some, you know, to get a strategic framework in place.
1:36:07 Depending if we're going to get a new Executive Director, and the time it'll take to recruit that, and then, you know, tying in with the time of the town on trying to get all the NGOs together and align their, you know, the priorities of each of the NGOs, and anyway, it's something we all got to be fairly aware of and how we can approach it, right? Because you want to have alignment with your Executive Director and the board and everybody when we come to the table, so.
1:36:33 Yeah, I think there's, I think from the town's perspective, I think the town is committed to providing MLH the information it's going to need to make decisions. But as a council member, I don't know if I necessarily speak for the council yet, but we haven't had this question in front of us specifically, but we're not going to be waiting. The community housing action plan was accepted by the council back in December. A lot of really important work to do, and we're going to be moving forward. And so I think Dan may have some things to talk about when we get to the budget part of this discussion.
1:37:03 I serve here as the appointed representative for the council. I may not be here in June, but I want to make sure I share with everybody that the town is going to be moving forward following the community housing action plan. The needs of housing in this community are dire and existential, and we will be moving forward on those items. Well, the town, if you read the community housing action plan, one of the key things that was defined in that is that the town really owns
1:37:31 The success of the housing program in the town. And this is important because the voters of Mammoth Lakes need to be able to hold somebody accountable. If the plan is a failure, they need to be able to go to the ballot box and reject council members and leadership that's not making it happen. And so it's on the town to be...
1:37:52 To demonstrate leadership and lead the charge on this thing. And MLH is a contractor of the town. And the town, we've got to work out what the contract for service is going to be. But we need to move forward on this. And we intend to. But the input from an executive director from Mammoth Lakes Housing and everything that they know seems like it would be really beneficial. Well, we'll get to the budget item. We'll talk about that. That might become a little clearer on that item. Okay. Any discussion?
1:38:25 If not, I think the staff has a direction. I just want to touch on one thing that Dan said just to clarify the excess rents. Those are excess rents outside of our reserve accounts. We do fund, you'll see it when we get to our next agenda item.
1:38:44 Well, not the next one, but the third quarter financials. We do set aside funding for the two properties we have for reserve, capital maintenance reserves. So, and then at the last meeting, you authorized setting aside net rents from the 238s here in Manor Road to a reserve account. So, that is, money is not included there. So, I've already separated that out.
1:39:13 And so when somebody moves out and somebody else is moving in, do we tap the reserves to? We don't usually have to, but if we had to, we can. And that reserve account is specific to that property? That one is, and so is the one at Star Apartments. It's in our budget, or it's in our financials, the one for the Star, because we've had it since inception. As a landlord, I get nervous when people move in and out.
1:39:43 Oh, it can be detrimental. It's bad experiences there. I've had a few bad experiences. So have Wayne, yeah. Further discussion? We'll move to board member reports. John? I really don't have anything to report other than I'll come up in the future agenda items. The town's been working, the staff's been working, meeting on the challenges and what we're going to do to try to get this whole thing moving forward.
1:40:19 We'll talk about that in a subsequent budget item. Subsequent agenda item, sorry. Tom? Yeah, I attended town council meeting last Wednesday, along with Jennifer and Patricia and John, of course. And Kirk, you were there. I was there too. Stacy was there. So for you, those of you who weren't there, there was the accessory dwelling unit diff fee agenda item that was on the town council agenda that they
1:40:49 Approved to proceed. You guys didn't make a final decision on adopting the fee, though. The staff's going to come back with a recommendation or a final language for that, if I understood it correctly. They adopted it through the end of this year. Oh, so you did adopt through the end of this year. Okay. Okay. So, yeah, you know, afterwards, I mean, after I went back and kind of was looking at that a little bit on my own and looking at the diff fees,
1:41:20 I think the thing to be clear is that the diff fees are the ones that the town controls. It's not all the fees. So in addition to the diff is developer impact fees that are under the purview of the town. It's not the fire department fees. It's not the water district fees. It's not the housing fees, although the housing fees are excluded anyway. But what it amounted to was pretty small change because I think the current printed out the current diff schedule and
1:41:49 I just wanted to point this out because I think it's germane to future discussions about where we're going to create incentives. So a single family unit is diff fees that are under the town's control is currently the schedule is $3,081. And I think that the fee would be reduced to, based on square footage, if it was under 600 square feet, I believe it was the threshold, it would be 25% of that.
1:42:16 And I know that, generally speaking, the accessory dwelling units would be in single-family residential neighborhoods, generally speaking, which don't allow for transient rental, so they would be effectively long-term rentals, right, which we're trying to encourage. But, you know, my point would be that, I mean, the other aspect of that is if, you know, we say, hey, we'll waive those fees entirely if you provide an affordable rent.
1:42:46 Right, to some level of affordability based on the needs assessment of the community that we did here recently as part of the housing action plan. You know, just as maybe it's an opportunity. I don't know how many units in the end of the day we can manifest out of ADUs. It's going to be a tough sell, I think, in a lot of respects. You know, but it is something that could happen sooner than later if we can get a good campaign out there to get people interested in it.
1:43:14 But again, you know, I think it certainly makes sense from just the square footage why the fees were reduced, but I think we could maybe have even considered going beyond that and saying, hey, we'll waive it. Again, but it's not, it's chump change, it's a thousand bucks. So I don't know how much effect it has at the end of the day or not. But, you know, if we're trying to, one of the things that was in the action plan was we were going to try to give incentives to people to develop affordable housing. You know, we need to think through those opportunities as they arise.
1:43:43 And look at what the fees really are and what that influence can be on making somebody's decision to actually build an affordable payment or not. Anyway, just something I wanted to point out to everybody. Other than that, I'm doing my homework. I apologize. I haven't finished reading this yet, but I'm working my way through it as I try to stay awake at the end of the night. What are you telling us? You've got to finish it before. No, it puts you to sleep. But, you know, clearly we have a housing crisis. We have a dysfunctional marketplace, right? You know, we're not.
1:44:12 I mean, that's pretty clear. And, you know, the parts I thought were interesting is that you look at the case studies that the communities that they're looking at, and the one thing that caught my eye was that Aspen, you know, has a dedicated source of funds to fund their program that's locally generated through a transfer tax and a sales tax. It says raising $4.5 million per year for housing. You know, that's huge. I mean, that's where I think we're not getting anything done if we don't have money. And right now,
1:44:43 We have limited funds to create true capital to leverage for building product and or however we might just choose to leverage it to create units. So my opinion is that it should certainly be a high priority for us is to focus on how we're going to increase revenues to the housing authority. I certainly am a strong believer that we need to consider looking at the structure of TOT and whether or not
1:45:13 Money from that, and as much as there's excess revenues being realized in the current TOT generation that maybe should be allocated towards housing specifically, or we add an additional point to TOT to generate additional revenue that's consistent. That could be huge. I mean, if we can put $2 million in the bank every year, that could be leveraged at 10 to 1.
1:45:38 Depending on what programs are out there, I know things are shrinking up right now, but all the more reason why we need to be a little bit self-reliant. I think that was something that Wendy Sullivan pointed out to us, that if we're going to be successful here, and again, if you look at the huge need that's out there today and how long it's going to take to actually start getting some product out there for people to live in, we've got to get moving here, as John points out.
1:46:06 There's a lot of stuff to do, and I think identifying a funding source is going to be critical. Anyway, that's my diatribe, and nothing further to report at the moment. I totally agree with the grantee units, and to waive the fee, I'm not too sure how to make sure they stay grantee units.
1:46:38 Unless you have some sort of deed restriction or something to keep them in that housing. If we're going to try to incentivize those units, then I think just creating them would be a real asset, simply because it's more product out there. Absolutely. So I'm a big supporter of accessory units. In respect to the TOT,
1:47:05 If 2% is allocated to housing, that would be about $3.2 million a year that would be set aside for it, which is huge. But that also has a political element to it as to do you take it out of the existing 13% or do we go to 14%? I mean, that discussion hasn't taken place yet. And so that is a
1:47:35 A very strategic discussion that needs to happen. In respect to my board member reports, ESTA has selected a candidate and is in discussion with a final candidate. That decision was made today. I went to the April 24th meeting. John, I think you were pretty responsible for putting that together on climate change. I thought it was very good and very informative.
1:48:05 And I think it was just about a full house. So it was, I think it was excellent. And so I applaud you. Let's see. Four candidates. I went to the graduation of four police academy candidates that achieved their post-two graduation. They all from Mammoth and Bishop. So I think that's really important.
1:48:34 I think the police department is temporarily or working on hiring one of them, a Spanish speaker, English Spanish speaker, and so I think that's a real plus for the community. Female, very good athlete. And the town council, I attended the last town council meeting. I think when we were discussing
1:49:02 And I just didn't get up at the time. I didn't think of it. But we did have some livability standards. I think when we talk about the size of the units and everything else, we need to go back and revisit the livability standards as to, you know, what's supposed to be in each unit, even if it's at 600 square feet. And if that has to be put in sync with
1:49:28 With some of the thoughts and where we're going on unit size, then I think that needs to be adjusted. And other than that, I have nothing else. Thanks. Just a quick report. Nothing housing specific in front of the Board of Supervisors right now. A lot of other regulatory action around cannabis and short-term rental regulation. But I'm sure other candidates for local office would concur.
1:50:00 People want to see some short-term on-the-ground action around housing, so whatever we can do, the pressure's definitely on, and it remains the number one concern. I have no reports either. That's the next agenda item. If there are no other board member reports, we'll move to agenda item 8, and my housing monthly status report.
1:50:33 Jennifer? Thank you. I have a few additions to what's in the report. One of the things that occurred to me when you mentioned
1:50:45 You know, like deed restrictions, granny units, how do you make sure they maintain themselves or that they're maintained as granny units? I believe that the town requires the recordation of a deed restriction on granny units in the single family zones because both of those units, the single family home and the granny unit cannot both be rented, so there's, I believe, a restriction recorded.
1:51:14 You know, we could work with the town staff to see if maybe they could do a brief presentation about how those work maybe someday if they have time. I know they're very busy, but that might be beneficial to you all to understand how that program works within the town right now. Especially if we're looking at making tweaks to it and what is the basis, what's our baseline right now. Patricia and I walked Aspen Village last week and handed out 84
1:51:42 48, excuse me, not 85, not yet, 48 bags, town cleanup bags and door hangers, so we plan to do the rest of our 35 units this week, so get in the word out. And then...
1:51:56 Patricia has began doing our annual occupancy notices for both deed restricted units and our down payment assistance recipients. And so two thirds of those have already gone out to the folks that we have email addresses for and the rest go out snail mail this week. So that is in progress. People are already handing those in. And those are my only additions to the staff report. Are there any questions on it? All right. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item.
1:52:32 Nine, review and discussion of the third quarter financial statements for Mammoth Lake Housing and Sierra Housing advocates. Thank you. So I just want to pass out an updated balance sheet for MLH because there was an error, would you mind just taking one and passing it, that I noticed today when I was reviewing mine. It didn't come to my attention until I was looking at my printed out copy that, for some reason, five,
1:53:03 Quarters were included on the balance sheet and it should only be four quarters plus the prior change. So this one just reads better. So other than that, everything else is the same. Just a little cleanup. So the balance sheet shows a total asset adjustment of $32,567 to the positive. On here you can see
1:53:35 The risk reserve here for, at the bottom, under net assets, we have the risk reserve for MLH. So that's an MLH operating risk reserve that the board established, I want to say, maybe almost two years ago now. And then the reserve for the Star Apartments, which began, like I said, when we first started renting those units. And so we set aside money every year from the gross rents into that account.
1:54:02 For the property. So any rents that we're talking about are in excess of that. Questions? Yeah, any questions on the balance sheet? If not, we'll move to the statement of activities for Mammoth Lakes Housing. On the next page, I wanted to point out a few things under revenue. We've got the $50,000 under contributions in kind. Just to point that out, that wasn't in the budget. That's unusual. That came from the Alpers property when we purchased the property and we received a...
1:54:32 Portion of the property as a contribution to MLH in the amount of $50,000. You'll also see under refunds reimbursements what looks like $105,954 in revenue we didn't budget. That is reimbursement from the Mammoth Mountain ski area for the housing needs assessment and the community housing action plan. And so those are offset down below under expenses.
1:55:02 Under the professional fees. So professional fees is way over budget, but again, we were the intermediary. We handled that contract, so that went through our books. Any questions on the statement of activities? Okay. That's the mountain again. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Seriously. I'll be talking to us tomorrow. Then tell him thank you again.
1:55:34 And so we just established the risk reserve at the meeting last month for 238 Sierra Manor Road. That is still in the process of being developed and put into place. It will be done before the end of the fiscal year. We have to go to the bank, create a new bank account, get all our signers in the room. And then the forecast is on the next page if there's no questions on that. The forecast...
1:56:05 It's forecasting, if you look at the bottom under total other income, $173,516 in excess revenue, but there are those things we talked about at the top, well the $50,000 for sure, that isn't actually, it's an asset on the books, but it isn't cash. The $50,000. Yes.
1:56:35 So the forecast expenditure is really $123,000? Yes, it's a change in net assets, so it's not an expenditure. It's what is known as an NOI, net operating income. Questions? Further? I want to point out a few things, although we can talk about it under the budget, too, because we're going to talk about the budget next. So Mammoth Lakes Housing,
1:57:11 This is probably a good time. Well, let's go to the cash flow statement. That's the next item. We had an increase in cash flow of $40,000. We paid down our debt on Oak Valley Community Bank, and there's some other things happening there. We had accounts receivable, accounts payable.
1:57:32 For a total balance at the end of March 31, 2018 of $257,899. And then for Sierra Housing Advocates, so Sierra Housing Advocates, we call it in-house Shaw, was created as an LLC. We're a sole member of the LLC. Only MLH is the managing partner in that.
1:57:58 As a holding entity for real estate, just to kind of keep it safe and off the sides. And obviously we don't have all of our books, our accounts in there, our properties, excuse me, in there. We just sold this past year one of the last ones that was in there.
1:58:20 But when we buy property back with the deed restrictions, when we have that opportunity to do that like we have right now, and we take out a loan with the county, you'll see that on Shaw's books. Right now, under Mono County Revolving Loan Fund, under the balance sheet, you'll see $191,220. That's the loan that we took out from there.
1:58:47 Revolving Loan Fund from the county to preserve a deed restricted unit at Meridian Corp. So that property is now held right now by Shaw. As soon as it's sold, it will come off the books. The debt will come off the books. But because that
1:59:05 Those properties are held by Shaw when we need to do things, when we need to pay for, let's say, new carpet or painting or carrying costs, because we've got HOA as carrying costs, right? You know, keep the pipes from freezing, so we pay the heat bill or the electric, and there's fees associated with buying and selling property.
1:59:30 Real estate transaction fees, you've got realtor fees, broker fees, escrow fees, title company fees. So there's all these things that go along with preserving units. And the RLF covers the cost of
1:59:45 You know, buying the property and preserving it. But then MLH picks up the tab on all these other costs. This was included in the original resolution when we first established a revolving loan fund with the town back in 2013. And so those things tend to show up in the Shaw account. And so you can see right now, if you look at the statement of activities for Sierra Housing Advocates,
2:00:13 There's about 25,000 expended right now for deed restriction retention. And that's in addition to what's over on the MLH side on the statement of activities, which I think is around 10,000 is coming to mind. Let me pull it up and look at it. Right now it's at about 2,000. We're forecasting 21.
2:00:46 2,175. And then we still have expenses coming because that property that we've just bought back at Meridian Court should sell. It's set to close this month, so there'll be additional fees there. So that is one of the things that MLH does with our...
2:01:06 Funding, in addition to salaries and overhead and benefits, is preserving units. And it's that sense of collaboration between MLH, the town, and the county to really, we're all in this together to preserve these existing units. So I wanted just to highlight that because I think it's really good work. Is there any questions on the Sierra Housing Advocates financial statements or any of the other financial statements? Yeah, I just...
2:01:35 I've been on this board for a year and a half, maybe two years. I don't remember exactly, but I was certainly here when Larry Johnson was on the board and Bill Taylor was on the board. And I run a non-profit foundation myself, and I'm serving in the town council, dealing with that budget process. I know that it takes some work to translate the financials of any organization to the board in such a way that the board can make sense out of it.
2:02:01 I've relied, I would talk with Bill, I talk with you occasionally, I'm not an expert on reading these kind of very complex documents, but I think it would be the interests of the foundation moving forward to find a way to translate, which is some very dense, very complex technical information into some sort of a digestible format that I think we've got three new board members to introduce them to the financial structure of Mammoth Lakes Housing and to put together a process to make it digestible and easily done.
2:02:30 As easy as possible to understand, not just for the board, but for the public. I think, I know that Rob Patterson has done an excellent job with the town budget, making that a very straightforward, pretty straightforward, easy thing for the council members to understand, for the public to understand, and I would just encourage the organization going forward to maybe focus on that a little bit. This is very complex stuff. The nature of the mission and what this organization does is very complicated, and I think it would be helpful to...
2:02:59 It would be helpful to me as a board member, other board members, I think also the public to try to come up with a format that's something that people can make easier sense out of. Yeah, and so I will say that we have worked over the years to make it easier than it started out with, more legible over the course of years through different various board members. I recognize it is complex. It's complex business that we do.
2:03:28 And we do really try to keep the labels consistent. We try to make the labels clear that you can read them. So I don't want you to, I don't want it to be thought that we don't, we're not cognizant of that potential barrier to comprehend what this is. So we can continue to look at that and refine that. Just something to think about. Yeah, no, absolutely. We always think about it. I'm always
2:03:58 Thinking about how can we make sure that the things on just as simple as the things on the balance sheet actually tie out. So when you're looking at a title on the top on the under liabilities, it makes sense where it falls under the the asset side so that they're consistent. Otherwise, you don't know what those are. So just this month we made a change. So yeah, thank you. Appreciate that. Sure. Further questions on the budget?
2:04:32 So thank you. I think that this is a standard format for MLH budget, something we've been working on over the years. And every year we find that our revenue is variable.
2:05:05 And our operating costs are pretty consistent. Things go up on the salary side, but not anything that we can't plan for. But on the revenue side, it can be a little less known from year to year. I mean, you know what you're going into, but they can really move around.
2:05:26 If you look at our historical budgets, we've had years where we've had close to $500,000 in revenue because we've been doing a lot of grants or we have project management income. There's just various things that can impact it. But this year, we found ourselves with few active grants. Unfortunately, the county wasn't awarded their home grant application this past year.
2:05:54 So they have no operating, no active grants for housing right now. And the City of Bishop has no active grants for housing right now. We just have the one right now with the town and then some revolving loan funds with the town as well. You never know when more revolving loan funds would come up from the county or the City of Bishop if somebody should sell their home and then that would...
2:06:18 Produce an opportunity for added revenue when we handle new loans, but we budget conservatively. We budget based on what we are pretty confident that we're going to get, and if those things come up, then that just is an added NOI or something we look at in a budget adjustment later. So when we were working on the budget and we had such light
2:06:46 Contract revenue from grants, administering grants, home buyer assistance grants, we've never actually included property management fees in our budget. It's something we've been in our operating budget. It's something that's always fallen under our other line items as associated with the property managing properties.
2:07:13 And the work that goes on on that part, but not the operating operations side of the budget. But over the past year, two years, we've been working with our auditor to clean that up and bring that into our operating budget. And so that is here. It's been, it was in our audit and now it is in our operating budget this year. So I'm excited to see that. That's $26,500.
2:07:40 In management and asset, property management and property asset management fees from managing our two properties at Star Apartments and at 230 8 Sierra Manor Road, the Albers property.
2:07:56 And so that really helped this year in the budget, too, so the timing was great, because without that, like I said, our operating funds expenses don't change that much. Some years you'll see the deed restriction retention drop, and some years it's really high. We used to budget that at $40,000, and then we weren't using it, so we dropped it down to $20,000, but this year we're at about $35,000 in expenditure, so we're budgeting $30,000 next year.
2:08:25 You know, that's the one item that probably jumps around, but everything else is really consistent, and so without that $26,500 from MLH managing the properties and asset management and management fees, you know, we'd have an upside-down budget. So I think, kind of getting back to what I said earlier, this is really a demonstration of how Mammoth Lakes Housing strategically has made good investments, and it helps us.
2:08:53 Complement the work that we do with the town and our collaboration with the county and preservation of affordable housing. And, yeah, I don't know what our budget would have looked like otherwise. So, I'm sorry, where's that, how is that money, is that generated through rent? Mm-hmm. So, was it recognized before, or? Not in the operating budget. It was on our, it was on our books, but it wasn't in our operating budget. Okay.
2:09:24 So if you, I don't know, if you, you know, looked at our statement of activities, we have our revenue and our expenses, and then we have our other expenses and other revenue at the bottom of that sheet, so it's under there. Okay. And so just to be clear, the staff report on the budget is what you're presenting to us now. There's no written staff report. That's correct. And then what's the additional $100,000 in town contract services?
2:09:55 So, we've been working with the town on trying to understand the town local housing trust fund grant admin. So, if you scroll down to the bottom third of the revenue, you'll see town LHTF grant admin. Do you see that? Yeah. For $100,000 last year and the year before. And so, we've been doing that since I started at MLH. And so, it's just one of those things that we've been doing.
2:10:25 The town received a local housing trust fund grant of $2 million back in 2004-05 from the state of California, one of the few towns, communities in the state to do that, and that was used at Aspen Village. And that came with some stipulations, which
2:10:50 We're all put into play before I ever started. And remember, I started as an admin assistant. So I didn't have a lot of knowledge of it. I knew it was a thing. And then I've been working with town staff on, okay, what is this? What does it really mean? What are our requirements? And lo and behold, it's done as far as our ongoing need requirement to fund it. It was a five-year commitment to do so.
2:11:16 And so we don't have to fund that or draw that out on our books anymore. That commitment has been met according to the documents I've been able to dig up. And so now that, because what we would do is pull that out from our contract amount with the town. So the town has a contract amount, bless you, with Mammoth Lakes Housing for
2:11:41 $329,190. That's the amount. But we would pull out $100,000 every year to show that we were meeting the obligation of that grant. But now that that is not required, we've moved it up into just that full amount. So nothing's changed other than the delineation and the line items. That's really it. Sorry, go ahead. Sorry, go ahead.
2:12:14 So we worked to see where we could trim things. You know, I'm happy to see that payroll expenses are anticipated to go up 2%. I think that's pretty tight, but I think it's reasonable. It's pretty similar to what we've been doing over the past, I don't know, how many years. And then some other things have gone down 2%, 10%, 1%.
2:12:44 And again, we budget conservatively. We're very cautious about both revenue and expenses, and I think it's served Mammoth Lakes Housing well. We've been resilient through a lot of tumultuous times in town with state funding, local funding, federal funding, you name it. So if there's any questions, I'm happy to entertain them. Questions? Well, yes, I just,
2:13:19 What's the question for us tonight? Questions on the budget. Well, the item reads review and possible adoption. It's really up to the board. The policy is that we would adopt a budget by the end of June, though we'd have an adopted budget in place for July, so at the beginning of our fiscal year. So we always bring
2:13:48 The agenda, the draft agenda to you in May. And then it's really, if there's adjustments that need to be made and needs to be brought back, we can do that. Okay, so the way our schedule right now is we're going to have a meeting in June, what, 11th? 11th. So is it the idea that that would be the proposed budget, we'll come back at that meeting? It can or it could be adopted tonight. It's on the agenda that you could adopt it tonight. Okay. I have a, I don't.
2:14:18 I have a lot of questions, but I don't even know exactly what questions to ask. So I'm interested in probably getting some kind of a written document. I mean, the oral presentation is fine, but I think for myself and other members of the board, I think it'd be helpful to have a written staff report as the budget and what's in it and what's changed and what that's all about. I'd also, I think it'd be important to hear from the town manager perhaps in terms of discussions we're having in terms of the contract with the town.
2:14:45 I certainly feel as a candidate for political office at this point, it may not be appropriate for me to be part of the sort of negotiating team from the town to be talking with MLH. Just from a perception perspective, I would certainly maybe ask Mr. Stapp if he felt the same way. I would like to step out of that until the election's over just to avoid any conflicts or perceptions of conflicts and that kind of stuff.
2:15:09 And I think also maybe the town manager could share some thoughts that are the internal discussions of the town that could be useful for the board to understand as part of the consideration of the budget. I would just point out that the county also has contract income on our budget. So, yeah, I decide, Stacey, I decide that that's what I'm from the town side. It's myself and Council Member Ferney are part of that transition team that was set up back in December. And I think as we go forward with this contract agreement, I would
2:15:38 I would be wanting to recuse myself from those discussions. I think that's under a different agenda item. Okay. That's under the update. But I would because this is an action. There is a potential for action here. So I think it would be useful under this item to maybe have the town manager give some representations on some town thinking about the contract and with the contract with the town and MLH. But I think as an action item, I brought my stepping aside from the town side because there's a potential for action on this item. That's why they brought that up.
2:16:08 Okay, I just wanted to make sure that we have later, I think it's our next item, the update on the foundational structure, which the contract between the town and MLH is part of that. And so I don't know, yeah. Yeah, I'll defer if it's whether you'd like to hear maybe some information on the potential contract here, we can wait until later, I don't care. Well, I...
2:16:38 I defer to the chair. Where is it appropriate to have the discussion? Yeah, and so I don't know that by June 11th, I'll be honest, that the contract is going to be ready just from my discussion. So the budget can always be adjusted. It's not uncommon that you would have budget adjustments.
2:16:57 We don't tend to do a lot of those because we're small and we have a really small budget of $397,890. We don't have a multi-million dollar budget, but we could certainly do that if the board wanted to be in compliance with our
2:17:14 Our policies and procedures, which said that we would have an adopted budget in place at July 1 of our beginning of our fiscal year, we could adopt a budget and then if things with the contract change our, have an impact on our budget and we need to bring it back and adjust it, that's within the purview that we can do that. The budget is a road map, but it's always up for adjustments.
2:17:40 It's your best planning tool, the best foot forward at the time, given what you know. I would think we need to adjust the budget knowing that it's going to be adjusted. And it's going to be adjusted because of the contract. And it's probably adjusted based on the strategic plan or the housing plan. Basically, what does the town want, you know, the priority, prioritizing those.
2:18:09 different action items or tasks that are not only in the strategic plan but in the housing action plan. So when I look at those, I think that discussion needs to take place. But we can adopt this and then make adjustments depending on what the town council and town staff thinks Mammoth Lake Housing needs to
2:18:34 take on as part of their workload. So would you be considering to make a motion to adopt this budget this evening? Yes, I would adopt it with acknowledging that it's going to be adjusted depending on the contract and depending on the tasks that might be incorporated into the contract. Okay. I would certainly be looking forward to hearing that motion. I think before we do that, I think it would be appropriate for the board to hear some thoughts from the town manager.
2:19:02 As the contract discussions are developing. Certainly. Yep. The podium's open. Thank you. Again, Dan Holler, town manager. Variety of comments on the budget as proposed. Appreciate the fact that the conservative nature of the budget, we do the same thing with the town levels. Working through that process, I believe in the...
2:19:31 Statement of cash flows, the 257,000 of cash, I assume that incorporates the reserve numbers of the 160 and the 34,000 that were noted as well in terms of having some cash flow elements there which are important to move that forward. I think probably the most significant issue that I need to address and this has been discussed with town staff the last couple of audits from our town auditor.
2:19:57 Last year, we let him know that the contract was up and we were working through the process, etc. And that we were working to address his concerns. And if I can just read this versus trying to paraphrase what he basically requested us to look at and to address. So it's in quotes. This is from our auditor, Ralph Marcello. He says, I recommend it to the town manager, Dan.
2:20:24 That when MLH administers a grant on behalf of the town and receives part of the grant for administrative costs, that amount should concurrently reduce the town's operating subsidy. Otherwise, MLH is basically double dipping by receiving admin costs from two sources. This is an important critical issue in my opinion.
2:20:43 The Federal Inspector General would probably bring up the same issue. So he's raised that concern over the growth in fund balance and looking at those issues going, you should not be double paying for services. If part of the town contract, and so it needs to get very clear, if in the contract we're paying for grant administration and service delivery, and in the grant itself we're paying for grant administration and service delivery,
2:21:09 He's raised that concern that it'll be a double dipping issue. We did not have him put it in the regular, in our audit write-up this past year in the discussions with him that we're working through. My guess is that we'll have the same concern raised this year and whether or not that becomes a formal management write-up in our own audit, we'll wait and see and have that discussion again, obviously, but we addressed this a little bit, I want to say two years ago, Jennifer, I forget, where
2:21:37 Part of the admin costs were retained by the town for some of the costing curve there that we have to track accordingly as well. But again, in looking at that item, specifically when he's looking at a contract for services that includes grant administration, then he's seeing payment of grant dollars for the same purpose, raises a red flag. The other question we had on that dealt with the reimbursement rate, and I know staff has been working through that in terms of the amount of dollars charged for the grants.
2:22:05 By the number of hours put in by staff. The other question was raised, and it sounds like it's been addressed, was with the low-income housing trust fund set aside of the $100,000. We were looking at that and confide nothing in past contracts or agreements for those dollars to be allocated in that particular line item. I'm glad that sounds like it's been clarified. I know staff had raised that question and hadn't heard the final outcome yet, so I appreciate that, that that is going there.
2:22:34 So begin to look at that. We need to take a look at that in our audit structure that the town will be written up for a management weakness otherwise, which that's outside auditor's job. So if they write us up, they write us up. But it's something that we need to address and I need to be able to address that, frankly, at the council level as well as the staff level.
2:22:55 The other side of this is looking at a couple of different things moving forward. As mentioned earlier, we are trying to truly move forward quickly or expeditiously with the Housing Action Plan. If I use the term HAP, H-A-P, it's Housing Action Plan, so I apologize for the acronyms and that element of that. Part of that issue was taking a look at the uncertainty in terms of the organization, some of the discussions beforehand, actually looking at do we reduce the town's allocation this year by
2:23:25 In some of the neighborhood of anywhere from 50,000 to 100,000 related to a contract support for a housing coordinator. That would allow us to really allow in supporting the transition discussion had earlier looking at some of the work the town's moving forward looking at that roles and responsibilities matrix and working through what gets implemented. Obviously that changes depending on what happens in the election and those processes through that.
2:23:52 But to be able to move that forward, that would obviously impact the initial budget as projected here. Long term, it may not impact the contract ideas. You can bring somebody on for a limited term. You're not hiring full-time employees.
2:24:05 And allow you to work through that component. But it also allows us to have certainty going forward on some of the issues that have been discussed throughout this evening, and I continue to move forward that. The same thing, we'd know those types of issues, we'd know the CHOTO status for certain, and those types of questions would be resolved.
2:24:25 The end of the 17 audit, for example, I know it was called out, there was a little over $200,000 in excess revenue, restricted and unrestricted, both components in there. There is some cash flow that could be utilized in the interim piece of this. And then how do we ultimately fill some of those capacity roles ongoing will obviously be a question that we need to address. The other element I wanted to note on this is
2:24:52 You're aware of it. We'll have some support staff coming on board with the Civic Spark Fellow. I don't want to say intern because it's a fellowship. It's a stronger than that. It's a graduate level student, usually or better, that will be coming on to help fulfill some of the roles within the Housing Action Plan and working through that element. So I think that's an important element for us in terms of how do we support that position going forward.
2:25:19 The other element that I did want to mention regarding to the contract and the funding look, and I don't mean to be rude on this, but I was a little disappointed as we were working through with the town staff and MLH staff in terms of report for town council. This was to go to them on February 7th, looking at some of that roles and responsibility elements. Originally, that was a joint report going forward. I know there's a variety of issues. Jennifer requested that she not be on.
2:25:46 Included in the report presentation to town council. Given those concerns, we actually pulled the discussion on the report, assuming we would address those and move forward expeditiously. At the same time, on the 5th, there was a separate report given to MLH that kind of outlined, here's all our current duties, here's the new roles being assigned by the town, which we had not done yet, and here's the expected costs for those over time. Obviously, those are not in the budget at this point. We haven't gone through that process yet.
2:26:16 To pull that element together. But that was frustrating just in terms of negotiating process and roles and responsibilities. And it would almost seem that that report was in the works along with the other one based on the meetings being the fifth and the seventh. So not having that discussion at the council level did put us behind a little bit in the bigger picture.
2:26:40 And working through that and looking at funding and structure and what types of roles or responsibilities may be requested of MLH. And that would include looking at current issues, are some of those no longer necessary? Modification of what's being done to date. Again, that's part of the discussion, having at the staff level. What are those roles that truly we need done and which ones are those that may be being done or have been done that are no longer necessary or not something the town wishes to pay for?
2:27:09 from a contractual relationship. Again, we'd get into a lot more detail on this in the coming week or so with the contract discussion. But all of those issues begin to fall into that. On the front end of that, I do need to address the outside auditor's concerns regarding what his term double dipping on revenues and paying for the same service twice. And then also looking at how do we fund some
2:27:36 Capacity moving forward is the other critical issue that we're taking a hard look at that and could that potentially come from some of the dollars allocated to MLH ultimately at the council level decision but also through the negotiation process on the contract to be able to look at what's that impact, what would that look like within the budget elements. So not necessarily great news there but also wanted to give you a feel for the things we're looking at and trying to work through to keep things moving.
2:28:02 If we look at a contract for housing support, that will probably hopefully move forward relatively quickly. It'd be an RFQ process for contractual support and then see where that kind of rolls out to. Again, looking at probably a six-month window there to try to have that additional support on. Also, that ties into a little of the certainty at that point from the campaign standpoint and elections that are going on for the organization within MLH. With that,
2:28:30 Wanted to walk through some of those issues as their concerns and looking at very options on the budget stuff. So, thank you. I have a question, clarification question. I just want to make sure I understood something correctly. Did you say that the town is possibly thinking of reducing our contract by $50,000 to up to like $100,000? Am I correct? Yes, I did say that. Oh, okay.
2:28:59 I just want to clarify something real quick here, and I think it's just a matter of education for your auditor, and not to sound condescending, but housing grants are different from regular contract work. So Mammoth Lakes Housing's contract, and I don't know the language from the 2012 contract, which we're operating under right now, says, but I
2:29:26 Generally remember it being, you know, we would provide limited grant services. It was about applying for grants, not administering grants. So we have a separate contract for administering grants. It's actually called a sub-recipient agreement, and it falls under the federal regulations for administering federal funds. It's quite strict.
2:29:54 And so it's not double dipping because those contracts, those grants come with specific things that need to be done at the time of having that contract. And then when that contract, that grant, grant contracts are kind of, they're the same thing. You get a contract from the state saying you're going to perform these things with these monies.
2:30:16 There's a time period for each of those. Typically, it's three years, just generally. And then when that contract's over, there's no more money to pay for that. That contract, those services are done. The contract with the town is different. It doesn't pay us to administer grants because that contract's been going, those contracts don't know when we're going to get grants and not get grants.
2:30:41 The grant services are separate from the contract with the town. They've always been structured that way from as long as I've been here. So I think that there's just a little misunderstanding. I understand the structure of those and worked with those in the past with CDBG and other funds and worked in those programs for that type of element. I think what he's getting at here is when you look at the budget and you end up with excess dollars, it would appear to be that the town revenues are not being expended.
2:31:07 Obviously it's the same staff, you're not staffing up, staffing down with the grant dollars, that those funds are indeed overlapping each other. One of the questions in the contract to look at is how much carryover do you allow the unexpended town funds and those types of issues in terms of some of those to address those types of issues and we've done that with at least Mammoth Lakes Recreation NGO for example. But to look at those, he's looking at that in terms of it's the same staff doing dual work but being paid twice if you will for that.
2:31:35 Whether it's from the grant, and again, that changes every year on the dollar amount, depending on the number of grants, no doubt. But also then the town dollars, it stays constant regardless of the other revenue coming in, in terms of those dollars. So in a pure contracting world, it would be, here's the level of services we're paying for. Either we're getting all those services, or time is being spent on other tasks, and you're not getting those services, but you're still paying for them regardless.
2:32:01 A normal contracting, and again, we do have a unique relationship with our NGOs, but a normal contract, you turn around and say, you do this amount of services, the invoice would come back and say, here's the amount of time spent, et cetera, here's the payment accordingly, and it would work through that process. Again, obviously, we have a different relationship with MLH and with other NGOs, we're not asking for tons of book work just to add additional time.
2:32:28 To that, but it is an issue that's been brought up through that process, so it's something that we definitely need to address, and part of that may be discussions with MLH staff, as well as our staff, in terms of as we look at our next round of audits coming up in October, November time frame. Questions? I got just a couple comments, and I'm sorry here, so we're going to talk about the contract, is that in the agenda? Yes, it's under the next item, under the foundational structure.
2:33:02 Right. So, I mean, clearly, you know, depending on where the town's interests lie in terms of contracted services, with, you know, payroll being 70% of the budget and taking a $100,000 hit potentially on town contract services has a huge impact upon our staffing and whether we're going to have an executive director or not or how that's going to be approached. So, I think adopting the budget tonight is going to be
2:33:32 pretty challenging not knowing what the landscape looks like. I'd recommend that we just have a chance to go back and individually look at this and postpone that decision until the next board meeting and then we'll have better clarity with respect to the election results and then I'm trying to understand the timing of where we think we're going to be in the contract negotiations with the town. Yeah. Well, I think, like I say, I think
2:34:02 Just in the middle of election, I'm, unless the board has a feeling otherwise, I would want to step out of that. Staff is fully versed in all this stuff. Councilmember Ferney is a lame duck, can certainly represent the council interests. And I think if the, we can talk about the contract stuff in the subsequent item, but there's things to be discussed, and there's people who know how to talk about it, so. Yeah, I'm not comfortable. I agree with Tom, I'm not.
2:34:32 Comfortable adopting the budget with this big unknown. I agree. Further discussion? That will be carried over to June 11th. We'll move to agenda item 11. Okay, thank you. So this is a resolution expressing, MLH Board expressing their support for the Veterans and Affordable Housing Act of 2018.
2:35:22 So the state legislature last year approved placing on the November 2018 ballot an initiative for $4 billion in bond funds for affordable housing. Through last minute negotiations to get this passed, it went from a
2:35:45 What was a $3 million bond for affordable housing to a $4 million bond with an additional million going for veterans housing services. And so the governor signed it and it is now on our ballot and I am working with a cohort from the California Coalition for Rural Housing to really
2:36:12 Drum up support across the state and awareness for this initiative. You know, it has, housing is a critical issue in the whole state and really the nation, but certainly California has some of the highest growing homeless population, is the highest growing homeless population for being the fifth largest economy in the state or in the world.
2:36:41 This is one of the tools to try to help address our housing shortage. And historically, the town of Mammoth Lakes has been really successful at obtaining the bond funds through these propositions. Back in 2002, there was Prop 46, and then 2006, there was Prop 1C. And over the course of those two propositions, bond measures,
2:37:10 The town has received over $7 million to help build and create affordable housing, not just rental, but also ownership through down payment assistance programs. And some of those monies are continually recycling through like our Begin Revolving Loan Fund, for example.
2:37:32 I think, you know, the town of Mammoth Lakes, they have already supported this. They supported it when it was going through the legislature. And then again, this past November, after the governor signed it, they expressed support at their meeting for this. And so this is an opportunity for Mammoth Lakes Housing to really just articulate and kind of codify, if you will, that we support this.
2:38:00 And we think it could be good for the community. Did anybody get a chance to read the resolution? I think it's excellent. I don't know if we want to read it into the record orally. It might take some time for the people at home. Sure. I'll read it into the record. A resolution of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc.
2:38:31 Support the Veterans and Affordable Housing Act of 2018. Whereas, housing availability is an urgent issue facing families and communities across California and the Eastern Sierra region, and the cost of housing means many people and families can't afford other necessities like food, health care, and transportation.
2:38:50 Whereas, addressing the regional lack of affordable housing must be an urgent priority at a time when more than 31% of Mammoth Lakes rental households spend in excess of 30% of their income on rent. And whereas, the devastation created by the housing crisis is evident in homelessness in Mono and Inyo counties. 105 individuals on the night of January 25, 2018 overcrowding more than 170 households.
2:39:19 Households in Mammoth and 131 in unincorporated Mono County and unfilled jobs and whereas between 2017 and 2022 Mono County needs an additional 765 additional units to meet existing need and future demand 595 in Mammoth Lakes and 170 in unincorporated Mono County and
2:39:45 whereas the proceeds from the two hundred six housing bonds that help create and preserve affordable apartments and ownership assistance programs have been expended and whereas crucial federal funding from the U.S. Department of Housing
2:39:59 and urban development has declined 51% for the community development block grant CDBG and 66% for the home program and whereas last year the legislator passed and the governor Brown signed Senate Bill 3 bill that will place the four
2:40:19 Billion Veterans in Affordable Housing Bond Act on the November 6, 2018 general election and ballot, and whereas the Veterans in Affordable Housing Dedicates funding to provide safe, stable homes for military veterans, struggling families, people experiencing homelessness, and individuals with disabilities, and whereas the Veterans in Affordable Housing Act builds affordable
2:40:45 Homes for hardworking people, enabling them to live in the communities where they work and near transit to reduce long commutes and curb pollution and whereas the Veterans and Affordable Housing Act is expected to create 137,000 jobs and pump 23.4 billion into California's economy, which is an investment in California.
2:41:10 California's, Mammoth Lakes, and Mono County's priorities to build homes, create jobs, and boost the economy, and therefore be it resolved that Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors hereby supports the Veterans in Affordable Housing Bond Act on the November 6, 2018 ballot to infuse much-needed funding to support important affordable housing projects and spur housing construction statewide and in the Eastern Sierra Region.
2:41:38 Therefore, be it further resolved that Mammoth Lake Housing supports and can be listed as a member of the Veterans and Affordable Housing Act Coalition. Thank you. Are you ready for a motion? I'm ready for a motion. I'd move to approve resolution number 1805. I'll second. I've been moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item 12.
2:42:17 Okay. So this, we talked about this at the last meeting, and it was a great idea that Tom brought up about making sure that we're checking in on the community housing action plan on a regular basis. What's going on? What are we getting done? And this body, the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors, accepted the foundational structure of the community housing action plan back in January.
2:42:54 of this year, 2018. And there's very clear direction in the Community Housing Action Plan overall. It's very clearly articulated what they recommend. And in this section, there's no difference. They call out who's responsible for what, what needs to happen, to set the foundational structure within the first year to really get the action plan off and running in a positive direction. And so,
2:43:24 When we talked about this in January, we looked at the items. Some of the items, due to everybody really buckling up and meeting a ton on the nominations committee and getting great applications from the community, we've already done that. So congratulations to everyone on that. That was one of the key items, is to expand the board, and that has been done.
2:43:52 Another item that's really big and we've been talking about tonight is the contract with the town and we have been talking about that and you know there's a lot of things happening right now with the election and three members on the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors are up for election and
2:44:18 It seems like we're not going to get a draft contract before the whole board prior to June 11th. I don't think that's at all possible. The board actually created an ad hoc contract committee as well. And on that we have Kirkstaff and Lindsay Barksdale. And Lindsay's out of the country right now. She'll return on the 10th. And I know she's eager to work on this.
2:44:47 dedicated to working on the contract. So maybe there'll be an opportunity for the board ad hoc committee to meet prior to June 11th based on some of the things I heard tonight.
2:45:02 At June 11th, the board could look to change the makeup of that ad hoc committee. That could be based on, it could, it's something that I can put on the agenda and there may be a need to make adjustments or they may not be. It will depend on the outcome on June 5th.
2:45:21 And then I would hope that soon after that's been cleaned up that we can continue to move along with the town on the process and then bring something forward. Maybe in July, maybe August. It seems like there's a lot of things up in the air. I keep giving projections of when I think that the contract might be ready and I'm failing miserably at hitting that target. So I'm remissent to...
2:45:50 Yeah, and I think we should,
2:46:19 I think we should agendize the status of the Executive Director. Oh, yeah. That was a huge part of why we moved it. Yeah, yeah. So I think we should have that as a, you know, specific item. You're not going to have time to, the results are on the 5th or 6th. Yeah. We usually publish on the Thursday, so the election should be well known, I would hope, by Wednesday. Right. Yeah. And so the options there for the board, that'll be good. And then,
2:46:47 I mean, the discussions for the contract can certainly continue between now and then. I just, I want to avoid, you know, any perception of, you know, why we're in the middle of a campaign that this is, I don't know, maybe it doesn't matter. We can just, we can just keep working on it. But I think Lindsay, when Lindsay gets back, certainly if Kirk or someone wants to meet in advance of that, I mean, we're eager to have those conversations.
2:47:10 And then there may be, we may, I think there's, I would think there could definitely be something that's an outline of a draft by the 11th, I would think. But that depends on the committee and who's around, people can work and get things done. Yeah, and, you know, we usually have our legal counsel review it, and I'm not sure if there'll be time for that prior to. Just a couple comments. We haven't really talked about this, I don't know, in depth since.
2:47:39 The March meeting, when the contracting issue kind of came up, and the, I don't know if you want to call them conflicting, or the two, the town staff and MLH report were presented, and it sort of got us to this impasse. I feel like it's an impasse that Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town are currently at, but... If I could, just as an out of sequence thing, it's an impasse. Yeah, but there's a jam.
2:48:08 And I'm really uncomfortable having a contract negotiated that neither town council or the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board has discussed. And I know we talked about it before. Others see it a different way, that we need to negotiate the contract. We don't want to negotiate a contract in our public meetings. I get it. But I'm also, I'm just really, what are you, what's being presented? Is it, you know?
2:48:36 Neither the council, we don't really have direction from council specifically on particular items in the housing action plan and we've never really had specific direction from our board. If I could, I think that's one of the reasons that Lindsay Barksdale is adamant that she wants to be on the committee because she doesn't want to not be involved. So I think she would concur with your concern to have the board involved because she wouldn't want to be left out, which is why she wants to be on the committee. Does that make sense?
2:49:05 Yes and no. But I mean, it's great that she wants to be involved, but I think we all want to. Well, I know, but yeah. She and I may be expressing the same concern in different ways, but I was very uncomfortable. I was like, okay, well, let's go negotiate this before we've all, you know, yeah. And gotten your, you know, staff's professional opinions about this, so. I don't know what to do about it. I'm just, I just want to get that out there. No, I agree. Well, I just want to, I just want to reiterate that the town.
2:49:33 The way that the housing action plan describes the responsibility of the program line with the town, the town is moving forward. We're talking about it internally. There are representatives from MLH Board that can meet with town representatives to further these discussions. The town has things to discuss with the representatives that they have with the MLH Board. And if that process can continue, I would really encourage folks to do that such that we could, well, again, such that we... They're not comfortable with that, though. Okay, that's fine. Then the town is going to continue to do what it needs to do to get this...
2:50:03 This program implemented. And so. Yeah. I mean, I guess it's still, maybe it's still staff level discussions that need to, you know, I mean, there's certainly nothing wrong with that. It's really board representation. I don't want to, I don't need to be on the negotiating committee. I just want us to have a discussion of it so that we can give input to the committee members so that they can do their work. Well, that's good. And the same thing on the town side. So, I'm.
2:50:30 Probably preaching to the choir, saying stuff you guys already know, but it needs, for new members, it needs to be said. I appreciate you saying that. I think that that would leave an opportunity for us to factor that into the timeline, that the committee maybe is working on it, but they wouldn't even bring it for consideration of adoption, like that that's one of the steps in the process, that it would come to the full board after the committee has had a go at it, if you will. Does that?
2:50:59 Sound like what you're saying? And then... Not really, but that's okay. I also understand I could totally be in the minority on this. Well, I don't want to leave anybody uncomfortable, though. I just don't think... It's a pretty big deal, the contract in MLH. I mean, I don't think that this is... Well, now that they want to cut $50,000, $100,000 out of it, it's more than a big deal. I mean, it's the staffing and everything else, and it's the job description as to what...
2:51:26 What it is, the contract, what it is that they want us to do for less money. Yeah. And how do we support the town, you know, on going after grants and everything else, grant writing and all of the different funding sources that we have. So they want us to take out of, you know, different funding sources that we have created, that we utilize to buy the Alpers property.
2:51:53 So that we can create more housing. It's not like we take those funds and just buy more staff. We do use those funds that we are generating and we go after more housing. So, you know, I'm not too sure how to go forward. I'm very uncomfortable with what's being discussed this evening. You know, I don't know how, you know, when I look at this agenda bill.
2:52:17 And I look at financing, continued research, finance option and management difference, sources to achieve the action with that 2% increase in TOT, you know, for housing. I don't know if that comes out of the town's percentage or if we're going to add a percentage to the 13% now. I mean, is that a campaign issue or is that? So there's so many things that are up in the air.
2:52:43 Partly because of the housing action plan, partly because of the strategic plan, partly because of the purchase, partly because of we don't have a contract because there's too many things that are floating around out there. So and now we have a new thing, the idea of cutting Mammoth Lake Housing's staff. So I'm not too sure how to move forward at this point. I think
2:53:12 We'll have to wait till the election's over. I think there needs to be preliminary discussions on what the contract is, you know, the formulation of the contract as to what the responsibilities are. If you remember two weeks ago, the Housing Action Plan actually created a bigger budget because these responsibilities were going to be put on Mammoth Lake Housing.
2:53:40 According to the plan. I mean, there were certain things in the strategic plan. I mean, certain things went to the chamber, certain things went to Mammoth Lake Housing, certain things went to tourism, certain things to different areas. These were expenditures. These are things, if the town wants these things done and cuts the budget and staffing, they're not going to get done. So we might as well just admit right now that the housing action plan isn't going to be funded.
2:54:08 Or certain components of it aren't going to be funded. I don't know how to go forward. I agree with you. I guess the first thing is to see what happens June 5 and to have some preliminary discussions as to what, you know, the contract and the scope of the contract and the responsibilities. Who's going to take these issues on? Are we going to do anything on the housing action plan?
2:54:37 Yeah, well, I certainly agree. And we've got Shady Rest. How is the town going to move forward? According to the question and answers from Sandra Moberly that you put out there, there's going to be this somehow community meeting in which people bring input into what's going to happen on Shady Rest. And so that's another whole discussion that has to take place. Yeah, well, I mean, it certainly is difficult to have answers tonight, I think, on a lot of these issues.
2:55:09 Certainly for me, not having seen the seeing what the existing contract says, you know, that's in place now and what the potential for change is. But, you know, the sooner that that information can be shared with the rest of the board. And I apologize, being new to public service and a little naive about the Brown Act, I'm assuming we can't only have two board members to not violate Brown Act, is that why? In the negotiating committee?
2:55:34 Oh, thank you. Now that we have nine board members, we can have more. You can have a quorum involved. We have nine board members. A quorum would be five. So you could have four board members involved. So you can talk to four individuals, or three other individuals. I think to look at Tom's question, I would encourage this board to consider
2:55:57 continuing to talk with the town about the town's developing understanding of how the town is going to be implementing this housing action plan. And I would not be waiting until June 5th to have those conversations. And I think that if...
2:56:10 A new person needs to be appointed or we wait till Lindsay gets back, whatever. The town is evolving its thinking. It's preparing to do things and take action. And I would very much encourage this representation from this board, reach out to the town manager and meet with him and keep this thing going. I think it would be kind of a big waste, kind of an unfortunate and kind of unconscionable waste of time to wait till after the election to have those conversations.
2:56:38 Yeah, I mean, to any degree that we can carry forward with, at least on some level of understanding what the scale and scope is, it makes sense, right? I mean, we're in a crisis. We need to deliver units. I don't see us delivering units anywhere on the near horizon of the way we're going. So we just got to keep pushing one way or the other. We can't let some of these sequential things, you know, I mean, we can still understand a lot.
2:57:03 I got it right here. I mean, I printed out the housing action plan. I made my little Bible here with the housing action plan, the needs assessment. I flipped to the page that is the strategy matrix that shows who's doing what and to what level of involvement. And so there's some guidelines to follow here. I think that's a certain basis for discussion. I think the town is looking at the same list and looking at things that we can take, you know, one or two items that we could take bites out of that we can start.
2:57:29 The ADU discussion was part of that. I mean, we talked about that. Jennifer's comments about a public outreach campaign behind that was right on the money, but we want to be doing that. I think we all want to be doing that as part of a larger effort with a lot more things in that. And I think it'd be very helpful to have representation of the board, to work with the town, to identify what those first one or two things out of the box are going to be and how we're going to start moving forward while the MLH organization goes to the things it's got to go through. Let's give that clear direction tonight.
2:57:57 That that would be the point of meeting with the town, not to negotiate a new contract, but to figure out what the heck you're actually going to do right now to get something going faster. I think that would be great. But otherwise, my concern is, what are they, you know, if it's just this sort of churning?
2:58:13 There's no point in that either. I just rep from the town side, it's not churning. We're working very aggressively to move these things forward. But I mean, in terms of the relationship with Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town in actually getting something done. Otherwise... It'd be very helpful to have representatives of MLH communicating with the town, work with the town manager and the staff to understand where this may be going and what this is going to look like in the near future. Yeah. I'd love to, if you were, if... I don't know if we can even do that under this.
2:58:42 I guess it would just be staff direction, but giving kind of a clear direction of what we'd want to see happen in the next month and making it clear it's really not contract negotiations, but as you stated, looking at what items could be prioritized for the fastest impact and greatest impact. I don't know. Does that make sense? Just so there's something.
2:59:08 Positive and productive happening out of these talks. We're all feeling a little frustrated at this point. So I'm new to the board here, and again, I'm a little naive about process, but if I have the ability to volunteer to join the committee or participate in those discussions, I'd be happy to do so, just because I had a very thorough involvement in the housing action plan.
2:59:35 You know, I got a pretty good grip on this stuff, or, you know, fairly good grip on it, and I feel like I can contribute to the effort. I'm happy to do so. Can we do that? We can't really do that under this item, can we, or could we? I mean, I think that would be great. I don't believe we can. Does that have to come back, agendize, and be added to the committee? No, no, just, just, just. So, what I'm hearing is that this is not a. Just a talc and a vitamin. I'm sorry, I'm trying to speak.
3:00:04 This is not about an ad hoc committee, though. That ad hoc committee was about contract negotiations, and now we're not even talking about that. We're talking about prioritizing the strategies. So if Tom wants to come, we can have up to four board members come and meet and talk about prioritizing strategies. That's totally different. I think that would be a great place to start. It would be something productive. Absolutely.
3:00:31 Yeah, we've got to keep moving. We've got to push everywhere we can. We've got to make progress. We can't come back to this meeting next month and say, well, where did we go? Yeah, no, absolutely not. I'd be happy to participate in that because that's not a contract issue. So I'm more than happy the town between that committee that's Councilmember Ferdy, myself and staff, and whoever wants to come from the board, we can set up and get together and start talking about where the town's at, what we're looking at, how we're prioritizing things.
3:01:00 And just keep the dialogue going on how we get this stuff implemented. Yeah. And I think the other thing, just to point out, with respect to the budget, in terms of revenues, I mean, so, you know, there's potential we lose some money on the town contract side. You know, are there other sources of revenue, you know, as we look strategically at what our role is or what MLH is going to do strategically, you know, that we can generate other funds from other sources?
3:01:31 You know, that's something we should be thinking about as well. Jennifer, do you want to try to coordinate with the town manager to set up a meeting? I will. Tom will be involved. John, you want to be involved? I want to definitely be involved. I think we want Lindsay. Lindsay definitely want to be involved. And she'll be back on the 10th. I think, Stacey, if you could be involved, that would be great because I think the county's perspective would be helpful for this.
3:01:53 But then we're over the limit. One, two, three, four, five. Well, yeah, I guess if John's going to be a part of it, yeah. Well, I'll step out. I was just thinking you were part of it from the town side, but you can't really delineate that. I can step out. I think it's more important for the county to be at the table, and I can step out. And then have calendar. Yeah. Yeah. Donna? Yes. Okay. I'm good. All right. That's fine. I'm happy to participate then. Thank you for participating in that, Tom and Stacey and Kirk.
3:02:23 All right. Okay, great. And Lindsay. Usually you don't like to appoint people to things when they're not here, but in this case, I think we're good. We know she's keen to do this. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to agenda item 13, update on the parcel. We have a new title. The parcel, formerly known as Shady Rest or Workforce Highway, owned by the town of Mammoth Lake. Information item.
3:02:52 So I just want to say, I know a lot of us were at the town council meeting on Wednesday where this was discussed. It's the first time that the council talked about the item since they closed on the procurement of it. The parcel changed the name, temporary name. They didn't want it to be attractive. They wanted to go away as the property is developed. But it is the parcel, no longer the shady rest parcel. That's too confusing. People think you're building housing on the park.
3:03:22 So the parcel. And some of the next steps were identified, and town staff's here, so I know they can correct me because I'm going to get something wrong here for sure. But some of the next steps are updating the topo map, removing the dead trees, wetlands delineation.
3:03:41 And they've got a whole packet, I think it was in the agenda item with a PowerPoint and flow charts of what's going to happen over the course of the next 12 to 18 months. But generally speaking, the names changed. They are going to put together a public outreach plan. They're going to update some of these studies and kind of create a baseline for what's there as they move forward. Does that sound right?
3:04:09 Yeah, I think the first, I think the, there are four or five bullets, it's really about site prep and getting, getting the information that's needed to start having the, having the real development discussion going forward. I wanted to keep everybody in the loop. No, not everybody was able to make the meeting. And there was an interesting extended naming discussion. Yes. That's, that's for a drink. Nothing for a drink. Does town staff have anything they want to add?
3:04:42 Dan Holler again, Jennifer touched on the work program going out very well, the one added to that, we're looking at the utility structure, what serves the property.
3:05:00 So you know what capacities are and things of that nature. Just the other thing, I know at the staff level internally, they've started the process, basically, there's a weekly staff meeting with our core team that's involved in the process, and Grady Dutton's leading that, and we've actually charged him with the idea of being, this is as if you were the developer, and so these are very, you know, strict meetings, time-wise, everybody's supposed to count their time, how much they're working on, et cetera. It's kind of like, if you're on the other side of the counter, what does that feel like?
3:05:29 In terms of taking a project forward, and so there's a lot of pressure that way to keep it moving, looking at the various prep work on that front, and just so we know what's on the ground out there is the first step. Hopefully that'll all be done, I think it was by the end of August, to kind of have all that detail information ready to go on that nature, and then the next steps will come after that. There will be some regular updates with town council and some next step issues on that. Then overlay it on that, ultimately we'll end up putting together what's that public outreach program begin to look like for that.
3:05:58 Process. Questions we get all the time is, well, are you going to bring in an outside developer? What are you going to do? And the answer is that likely down the road at some point, but we don't know today. We haven't gone that far into that process yet. Try not to jump to the conclusion or to the end of the process so we actually work it through in a well thought out process. So we'll keep you updated as well. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you. Further discussion? Otherwise, we will
3:06:31 We will adjourn to June 11th at 6 p.m. It'll be a different world. We may all need a stiff drink come June 11th. What'd you say? I said we may all need a stiff drink come June 11th. That's right. Turn off your microphone, will you?