Town Council
· recording 5 hr 57 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
792 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:37 Oh, really? Do you go and shower and shave and all that? Yeah, good. Thanks. Appreciate that. I showered and shaved, too. Yeah, did you? Yeah, you look for a skin. Do I? Oh, okay, good. I did not. Hey, dare you to keep your... Yeah, no, you were looking so clean, shady, when you hang in. Yeah. It was like, you're as smooth as a baby's look. Well, just say you had LASIK. I just started that day right. Okay. The way rumors get started. We bantered.
1:07 Are we prepared to proceed? Done with banter. Danny, you ready? You're the mayor. Yeah. I'm taking the consensus of the participants. Okay, ladies and gentlemen, we're going to convene this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, June 6th, and we're going to have a workshop on a budget, so Jamie, if you could call the roll, then we'll get into the workshop itself. Here. Here. Yep. Here.
1:39 Here. Thank you all very much. So we're going to get started on this fiscal year 2018-19 final budget workshop. Dan, looks like this is your show. Yes, thank you. It appears that Rob Patterson was going to do this, and he had a family emergency, so he's out of town. So we worked on a lot of this together, and so we're working through it. So I'll be walking to the presentation. Cindy Myra will be joining us shortly as well. She had a doctor's appointment this afternoon.
2:10 I guess as soon as we get a question, should that be necessary. For the budget workshop, we're really focused on the actual budget piece. I think you have a copy of the PowerPoint. We'll be using the walkthrough. The item in the agenda, there's a formal public hearing that also looks at some of our policies. Those will be discussed as part of the public hearing process and not so much of the workshop. If there is a question on those, obviously, we can't address them here as well.
2:39 PowerPoint. We'll mainly walk through the budget pieces and where we're at today in terms of recommendations of moving forward. Dan, do you have any points where you need input? Yeah, we walk through it. We'll touch on those just as we go. Just refer to you when there's a good stopping point. Correct. There'll be a couple points, too, that I want public input. Right. Council and public. And so let us know when you... I think Rob has a slide for me, decision points that I do not have.
3:11 Okay. So with that, and for me it's easier to stand here and actually go to read the top of the slides. One of the first elements in here I wanted to add in, and this isn't part of the packet that was on Granicus, but we did take a look based on some comments at previous meetings. We got an allocation of larger than anticipated TOT revenues back in 16, 17, and the important piece of this, a lot of this goes to capital projects, which
3:41 Went through the year and will actually be part of the capital funding going into the next year. So I won't spend a ton of time on this. I think it walks through a lot of the, where we had an $11.65 million TOT budget. We ended up with larger than anticipated money, about $6.9 million by the end of the year. We'd come to council on a couple different time periods looking at the allocation of that.
4:10 The pie chart there, the little graph kind of shows you where those funds went to. The unassigned fund balance was things that were not committed at the end of that fiscal year. Ultimately, those funds were expended on the acquisition of the parcel, so they're not available at this point. They went into that project acquisition. We had a lot of money go to infrastructure, and there's detail if you want that, but some of that is going in the projects in the current year.
4:35 As well as working into next year some of the road work and other different projects that way. We had the allocations to tourism, to housing, and to transit as part of a political commitment. Okay, I want to just hold you right there because I want to make sure that the semantics of this. Yes. Because on this sheet we've got a housing reserve, a transit reserve, and just a tourism. Right. It's a tourism. And this, for 16, 17, that was all passed through to tourism. Okay. It's not a reserve.
5:02 Right, the reserve started the next year? Started that fourth quarter, so that beginning of the next year is when we started the tourism reserve. Okay, so that going forward, those excesses of the public's edification, those are referred to as those specific reserve accounts? Correct. So anything over the base allocations for tourism, which is, you know, we have $13.5 million in base budget, so that's all allocated out to tourism, MLT. Any excess over that would be held in a reserve.
5:31 And then allocated accordingly. Transit has, I can touch on these briefly with that. Transit has the TOT allocation here. They also have just about $100,000 in transit fees that come in each year. Between the two of those, we fully fund our contract and any adjustments that get made. Anything left over goes in that transit reserve, which is also, we've in the past allocated a portion of that to vehicle replacement in the transit side of the vehicles that the town owns.
5:58 The housing reserve is the same element. Again, this started 16, 17 at the end of the fiscal year. And so the extent that there was some dollars left in there that were not committed to housing, which included, I believe at that point, debt repayment for the help loans and also the regular payments in terms of staff time and the MLH through that process, so those reserves were there. Some of those housing reserves, again, were also committed and utilized when we acquired the parcel.
6:29 So this was the end of 16-17, and were those excess dollars allocated across these. A lot of that went into the snow-related issues there. We had a lot of additional expenses related to that. We've actually gotten very little back in reimbursements from the state. Federal government mainly because the declaration by the state was a rain, not snow. So that was a little flustered element there.
6:57 And so this kind of shows you that that gives the larger anticipated excess TOT of $6.9 million. There was other elements in the budget overall at the end of that year, but this is where those TOT dollars were allocated out to. Some of that infrastructure improvements, again, are continuing as we go into this year. Next year, you'll see $300,000 there for town facility updates. That went into the...
7:21 Really the parks and rec side, the majority of that's been spent, but that went to improvements at the pool, it went to improvements at Shady Rest Park, and there's been some other elements there where they've gone in and fixed a lot of deferred maintenance. It wasn't new build stuff. We did put new bleachers in, for example, at Shady Rest, which were required to meet ADA standards and things of that nature, so a lot of those dollars went into there. And then a small amount went into operating there.
7:48 Expenses just in terms of the budget balancing process. So I just wanted to note that because a lot of the times in one of the elements in the resolutions of the budget, there is the ongoing appropriation of like capital funds because they don't usually line up very well with their fiscal years. And so you spend projects and do that work and continues to move forward so you can actually get projects done and not have to do them on a July 1 to June 30 schedule, which frankly didn't work.
8:16 An example of that right now is Upper Main Street. That work's ongoing right now to be completed. The project started two years ago. We took the light bulbs down and did the work, and now we're doing the sidewalk. Part of it, we had dollars in here, too, and part of this was a match to that fifth grant, for example, and $270,000 went in to match that project so we could complete it accordingly. Those types of elements there. So I just wanted to kind of give a brief highlight of that, because every year this tends to work across.
8:43 Fiscal years and sometimes multiple fiscal years in terms of the budgeting and mainly in the capital side of the house, but it does happen. So any questions on this? It's a brief overview, kind of a high level. This is focused on the TOT side. When we do the wrap-up every year in the fall when we complete our audit, we provide the software detail. Here's the changes in the budget and information from the auditing standpoint. If there's questions on this, I can answer those. If not, I'll continue on.
9:11 I do have one question about the snow-related impacts. I realize the water versus the snow, but is that done with? Are we not going to get any more reimbursements for our claim for that? We had some dollars in, but not a lot. Recent ELC training, one of the Cal OES folks suggested we should appeal it again. Were we doing that? Because the denial letter we got was very, very clear.
9:41 The declarations specifically stated a rain event, and they're requesting for a snow event. So our question is, do we go through the effort to try to, I think we've been to denial, so. Oh, okay. This will be the last, I want to do it. Okay, thank you. Dan, the first full fiscal year was on Measure A, recalibration was 1782. Correct. The year we're ending here.
10:08 Yeah, and the recalibration, and I'll touch on that and some of the budget stuff because it was important how some of the dollars shifted there and were able to provide additional funding in areas. Correct. So we kind of had one quarter element there. And the only difference we did on that was on the NLT side that tourism was to do the full transfer route because they'd already made commitments with contracts and those types of issues. So it wouldn't be problematic. Any other questions on this one?
10:36 John, up to you. Pause if you want to have a public comment. The public comment on this initial piece here. Okay. Proceed, please. So the budget information, this is kind of just a real general overview, just a reminder. We looked at things and we'll talk about a fund, general fund, gas tax fund, etc. Each fund has its own set of departments.
11:02 You know, difference accounts down to objectives in terms of what we utilize. We also have activity code to be assigned to things to help us track time and billable components. And then like in our capital projects, we also have a job code in our systems. You won't see that in the budget, but that's the internal accounting process so we know how much time we're spending in different areas as we assign those projects to. The general fund gets most of the focus because it is the most
11:31 Flexible fund, if you will. It's the largest fund, but it also is the one that can go to any, you know, governmental purpose. All the other funds either have a legal restriction, like gas tax going to use for certain things, the measure R, measure U, or there is, you know, a council policy restriction. In some of the debt funds, for example, we have some capital dollars in there for IT replacement. That's a council commitment of those funds versus a legal requirement.
12:00 Good financial management in a lot of areas that way. So it walks through that structure. So when we get into the heavy detail in the staff report all the back, you'll see fund, you'll see department, and you'll see line item detail. And then from the accounting side, we can go deeper than that right on in the activities of jobs so we can track staff time and projects and things of that nature. And then the other side, each fund, it has its own set of accounts.
12:25 Works through that. And then within, though, each of those have a fund balance if there's any dollars that are unspent. And real quickly, just how those work is restricted. Like in our debt service, we have a reserve to pay a debt payment if we were not able to make it. That is a legal restriction on that money. You can't use it for anything else. You get used to make the last payment in debt, for example. There's committed funds where only for those purposes that the Town Council has set it for.
12:53 General Fund, the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty. You have committed those dollars for that purpose. Therefore, they sit there until such time that their requirements are met that the council sets for those. There's an unspendable reserve. In some cases, we have an internal loan. So in the garage fund, there's this, you know, I can't remember the number of the top. I had $3 million sitting there of an asset that's unspendable because it's an IOU.
13:21 From the Town Fund over, so you'll see things that are unspentable. That could be like an inventory account as well, either at the airport or a vehicle service fund. The assigned would be something where we have actually, it doesn't really meet those other standards, but like I mentioned, our debt service, we've assigned a reserve there for IT or technology or improvements in the future. That's not a legal requirement, but it's assigned to that purpose, and so we hold it to that.
13:48 More like in the airport, we have moved money from the general fund over for capital projects, which again could be shifted back out of those general fund dollars. But the assignment's gone into there and you all could make a decision to spend it differently. Then lastly, the unassigned would be those dollars that are truly available for the commitment or user. You know, in the general fund, it could be just an uncommitted fund balance that you could do that with.
14:14 And so we work through all of those elements, and the goal on this is all of these is to have a balanced budget ultimately, where our expenditures are equal to or less than our revenue, or revenues are greater than our expenditures, which then would fall into that fund balance component if you have excess dollars, and it just matters of which category do they fall into within each fund. And then on top of that, I think I mentioned the restrictions in the fund itself also have to be taken into consideration, like measure our dollars are restricted for measure our uses.
14:45 So we walk through that piece of that. And so when we look at our fund balances, this is a real preliminary projection as we look at fund balances by the various funds, the larger ones in terms of what happens here. You know, in the general fund, we have the reserve for uncertainties, economic uncertainties there. The estimated 2019 is very soft and it really doesn't do a lot of analysis on where we're going to end up at June 30.
15:13 It's based on the amended budget today. Walking through that. The operating reserve and the general fund, that's what those dollars are just based on what was remaining from the budget standpoint with the additional allocation of a million dollars in TOT money. And so this here, you'll see the housing reserve there. It'll sit there, so that's projected what we're looking at in that housing reserve as mentioned earlier. The transit reserve is sitting there, and then the tourism reserve would be in there. And the tourism reserve...
15:42 It has $675,000 that was committed out of that reserve for the LA Kings deal. Part of that has been moved and spent. But the timing of the way this chart shows it, wouldn't pick up that at this point. Because it's looking at year end and then moving in, so that activity isn't reflected there. The other example of that is like in Major U, there's a printout there showing there's $3.3 million in there, but two and a half of that has been committed to the
16:14 Back facility to the Parks and Culture Facility there at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And so that's where you'll see how some of these reserves fall into the various categories that we're looking at in those areas. I won't walk through every single one of these, but after you look at that, that plan changes in this current year budget, you'll see some of that. The estimated 2018 budget, which some of that will be changing based on actions that have been taken. But the idea was to give you a picture of kind of how that reserve component and the fund balance works.
16:44 You know, you drop on down there, you'll see like the airport fund balance that has 1.3 million. The majority of that is general fund dollars or maybe a little bit of PSC, passenger facility charges in there that are, you can have those for reserve, but if you do, those are restricted to airport improvements only that are defined on your airport layout plan, for example. That would be one of those very much restricted by law type of service.
17:09 The Vehicle Service Fund, again, that's what I mentioned, there's a large number there, but part of that includes $3.4 million in debt, so it would be an unspendable reserve, that type of piece today. So this kind of gives you a snapshot of why those reserves, again, we come back in once we have this year closed, we have a 60-day approval period for July and August, and so then usually it's October once we get into the audit, get everything cleaned up, and we come back in and say, now here's our pre-audit projected fund balances.
17:39 Once we know all the activity is closed out from one year to the next in that structure. So kind of a rough overview, but kind of give a picture of what we're at in front balance reserves. Again, it's a cleanup after each year. So a lot of times in the budget, we don't try to do a hard estimate on those, but we know we have a couple of months now with bills that are still going to come in and be paid and those types of elements until we get into the fall timeframe.
18:07 Okay, so maybe further on the next thing. Yeah, I was going to pause here if you have any questions on the fund balance. Any questions? I'll be able to be there, so. Are we there yet? I was underneath the notes that estimated the commitment to the LA Kings. Is that still in the works, or where are we with that? You've actually made one payment. We may have made the full 675 payment. That was a commitment.
18:37 For the year's worth of activity that went on, and we're still in conversation with it in Frankfurt for undoing. Oh, okay. So that's past? Yeah, but that is gone. Yeah, that's gone. Good. Public, any thoughts on any of this? Yes, Brent, please come up. No, please come up. Thanks. Just a quick question again in regards to the tourism reserve, because you've got 632 from the town to the end of April. I've got 865-409 from the town documents.
19:09 We're just not sure if they're matching up with the right amount of reserve. But that's estimated at the end of the year, and we're already at $865,000. We should be like $980,000 by year end. Well, yeah, real quick, he's talking about the TOTS going to be huge here. This is off of the budget amendment. We amended the budget to $16 million. We did not go any higher than that. So we do not have any other dollars committed at this point in town in the reserve because we have not recognized that additional revenue. We did not recognize any budget.
19:37 We're only through the third, end of the third quarter. So this here is an estimate based on the budget, but not on this command today because they don't recognize it. No, but that says estimated balance. I just want to make sure because you've got a couple hundred thousand dollars more money. Yeah, we understand that, but that's off of the budget number, not off of the action. No, I just want to make sure you're using the right numbers when you're making a decision. Sure, thank you. Thank you. Yeah, we're not asking for the decision of the payment of those reserves at this point because that will be a true up that happens.
20:06 Sure, but these reserves here, these are the ones that are called. This is where they live. This is what they're called. Correct. And I think I also appreciate the terminology around the fund balances. Yes. Any else from the public? No? Okay. So now we're going to get into total revenues, correct? Yeah. So next piece on this is how do we balance out the budget. This is a big picture on the first start here. Then we're getting some of the funds. Our overall revenue picture.
20:34 And here you'll see some information that walks through kind of the actual for the last couple of years. The adopted budget, now again, if we're updating this later, we would show an amended budget in there. There will be one more round of amendments that hit that as we wrap up the year. So you'd have an amendment budget and the proposed 2018-19 budget. And so this walks through all the various larger revenue categories that we deal with on a town-wide basis.
21:01 And again, as I said earlier, most of our focus is on the general fund and then the gas tax and maybe a couple other larger funds. But when you talk about the town's budget, on a revenue side, you're looking at almost $39.9 million in terms of the actual budget. We talk a lot about the general fund, which is in the 22 range, or the X million in gas tax and those pieces. But as you're looking at adopting, the budget is that larger number in terms of the budget.
21:29 So this here gives you a picture of all the funds. I'm not going to walk through all the different sources here. We have a question on it. We can answer that. But the idea was these are all the different large categories, if you will, of revenue that fund the overall town operations, not just the general fund with most of the discussion topics. Same thing below, you'll see the total appropriations of all funds. Again, it's a combination saying here's your total budget. You know, it's total appropriations are 44.
22:01 Almost $0.7 million, which then we'll net over that saying there's transfers out, and so they just get double counted in terms of the map. And then we do the pass-through of the TBID dollars. For the most part, there's $90,000 that get contracted back for 2% and come back into the town. But that'll give you your total proposed budget total. So when we look at just a big picture, this gives you that $40 million.
22:29 The budget that you're dealing with, not just the small pieces, but we deal with it in the small bites because of the funds and the restrictions. So this is just kind of that overview of that. And the next one down, this here is the all revenues. You'll see the $39.886 million there. And then in the total proposed budget, $44.6 million is the total appropriations.
22:57 Show the impact of the transfers and the past decisions that come into that. But the actual appropriation would be that 44.7 million. Okay. Any questions on, do you want to get one more? Yeah, let me finish this last chart and we'll open up the info comment. I actually like this one. It's a lot of information in a crammed piece of paper here. The combined fund statement, it really allows you to walk through and look and say, what does the town's budget look like broken down by fund?
23:26 Right at the very top, you have your general fund. There's $22.7 million in revenue coming in. And it's all going out with the exception of $1,052,721. So that would be a change in fund balance there. If remember, we committed the extra million into there for various purposes. And it's a little bit higher than that because of the way the transit reserve works because there's other dollars for transit that comes in. And that makes an additional commitment there.
23:56 And so you can walk through that. If there's a negative, the question should be asked, why is it going down? If you look at the Measure R trails, you can quickly see there's a fund balance change of $265,000. So the question would be, why isn't that budget balanced? The trails budget has set aside dollars for capital projects. And so this year, the recommendation is to commit $265,000 of the capital reserve.
24:26 into the budget to be expended for those capital purposes. And so as this pops through there, it gives you an idea of if it's a positive number, okay, you're actually growing your fund balance, if you will. If it's negative, the question should be, why are you utilizing that fund balance? And the uses should only be where we have a planned use of that, or for whatever reason, that fund is upside down, and we're saying you've got to use reserves to balance the budget.
24:53 You can expand the chart out of the final budget and actually include your beginning and ending fund balance numbers as well once we finalize those up and that gives you a kind of a one-page snapshot of here's your total budget and what's happening from a big picture standpoint. So pause there on the funds and the fund balances and kind of the big picture and we'll start to dive into some of the more detailed stuff. Good. Public, any thoughts or questions?
25:26 Just out of curiosity, the capital, the 373 on the capital projects, what that's for? Yeah, that would be going into projects. I think it's probably multiple projects with a 300 account. Right. So that's where, I was saying early, like the money from last year we put into reserves, we're spending it this year. I couldn't tell you exactly which detailed projects without putting a lot of details. It's probably, it's in Public Works Parliament? Oh, absolutely. Yeah, it would be our, probably the road projects or the, uh.
25:55 Stuff that could be part of the $300,000 in the park site. Yeah. But that would be dedicated reserves and we're planning to spend them all the time. Often your capital fund, one year you might see a big jump in, and then next year you'll see a massive... And when you're looking at these things between the expenditures and revenues, there are no... I mean, if you're looking for balance numbers between revenues and expenditures, you're not going to see that here, right?
26:21 Correct. A couple of the funds you'll see an even one, but the main thing you're looking at is the fund balance going up or down. Yeah. It's going up. Generally, that's what we're striving for. That means our expenditures are less than our revenue. If we're utilizing it, then that's... We're getting some of the balancing detail and some of that's balanced with transfers out of some of the individual funds. Okay. Everybody happy? Good. Public's okay? Big overview stuff at this point. Okay. All right. So all funds employees. Yes.
26:50 We talk a lot about, in terms of adopting a budget, maintaining our core service levels, and for the large degree, that means your core staffing levels. In terms, we are a public service agency, so most of our work is related through bodies, whether that be our own core staff, or whether that's a contract service, but hopefully we're putting items on the ground, or we're doing different levels of service out to the community.
27:16 And as you note, full-time employees were at 66. I think that's where we ended last year. It's the same thing. We had two bodies added last year. No new full-time employees were proposing the budget for this year. So we were at that same level. If you go back in history, at one point, I think it probably might have been, the FTE number was about 130, where FTE will be about 80 as we go into this next year.
27:40 Our core service level is our full-time staff component that really is augmented by part-time. And I think over time we've relied more and more on that part-time level to meet services. We really see that in the recreation programs and part just because they work. We have some great folks coming in, college students, other people in town and different, and we get to honor one of them this evening. Anyway, some great, great kids coming in. I guess they're kids now, I can say that. Young men and women.
28:10 Coming to work for us, they do a great job in terms of those programs and the camps that we have are, I think they're all still oversold or waiting lists, those types of elements. The other place we've really backfilled is in our public worksite and snow removal. Each one of these FTEs, the part-time equipment, try to get to a 2,080 employee hours. So we have the three full-time equivalent, which means six part-time people that staff our snow removal.
28:38 The challenge of that at times is keeping six positions filled. I think a year ago we ended up with five most of the year, 34 at one point. So, you know, that ends up, usually I'll end up with the savings in the budget that stays away and falls down to the fund balance that we do. But trying to staff that with the part-time is both, it's generally less expensive but also much more flexible. I need snow operators versus needing, you know, somebody to be out in the airport or you need...
29:05 Somebody on parks or other maintenance areas. It gives you a lot more flexibility in how you staff. Similar to, frankly, how we use some of the NGO. You know, we can contract something out and be very flexible to staff up, staff down quickly, which is simpler with these staff than it is with full-time. The challenge otherwise becomes a full-time staff that will really have the history, the knowledge, and you're training them, and they're there, and they do have flexibility. Our snow plow operators are the same people.
29:33 Out-painting the streets, making them beautiful for the summer. And so there's a lot of, uh, crossover that way, obviously. But staffing is relatively light. Uh, there are definitely some areas of, uh, you know, where we'd love to see more staffing in the future, but not in this budget. I think as we look across this, too, you'll notice, uh, into the next page, we take all the staffing, and it does get split across the various funds. And so the general fund has the lion's share of our staff in it.
30:02 But if you walk through gas tax or major R, major U, et cetera, you go through the airport and all the funds, you can kind of see how the staff gets allocated out. And a lot of it is there's some people that are 100% in these and other staff, all your management staff, I can't remember, I think Brady gets split up about six or seven different ways through different work program areas. And so when you get down to the end of it, and it's on the next page actually, you just kind of see the total. So we are just over $11 million in total.
30:31 Personnel costs, again, across all the various funds that work through that component. We're about just under $8 million in the general fund in total labor costs. And we'll talk about some of that in detail. So you take that 66 or that 80 FTE and it gets allocated across all these different areas. And right now it's our best guess in some cases where these people will be working.
30:59 Throughout the year, things change. We end up with another capital project or we end up with another grant or we have something else comes up. We will shift people around accordingly where we need them to work. The hard part, we try to manage that through is not putting a bunch of people back into the general fund that we don't have budget for. We have to move things around. But we brought on a couple of interns this year in particular to help with capital projects and to help with some grant work.
31:27 So that's been a real benefit, but it also is getting them up to speed. In the budgets, the recommendation here in the preliminary was to come through with the Civic Spark position, which is an 11-month contracted position that we pay $25,000 for that we actually get an 11-month employee to work on housing issues. I think that's a great leveraging of funds that way. We have some other interns in community and economic development.
31:54 Public Works working on projects as well. They're primarily grant funded. The challenge on some of that is you come in and go, I really like this person to spend a few hours over here in the general fund and okay, we'll make that work. So there's some small adjustments throughout the year we end up making to actually be efficient and not say, sorry, I know you'd love to work on this project and we need you to, but you can't. So we try not to do hard notes in those areas. So let me pause there real quick.
32:24 Well, one more chart, and then we will. So the labor cost to all funds, if you look at the salary and wages, health insurance, and PERS retirement, that's about 94% of our total labor cost in those three areas. You could see a musician, you may be able to notice off the top of your head. Our PERS retirement, the 2.2 million, about a million of that, Cindy, is, and that total runs about 14 to 15 million. I don't know if you might say that.
32:57 Oh, it's roughly $1.1 million in the unfunded liability, and it is, our total unfunded liability is around $14 million. That question comes up, and that'll change every year, depending on how well PERS does in the market. Right now, stocks have been going pretty well, so hopefully they are having a good way to return. Who knows after another month or two.
33:24 So we look at that, so the other 1.1 million is actually a percent he's been charged to silence. And so that goes through that process. And every year we get an actuarial report, actuarial report in, says here's your unfunded, here's your employee share, and work through that. So that's a big cost. Health insurance, again, tends to move upward on a regular basis. Different levels, averages somewhere between 3 and 8 percent the last few years.
33:54 It stayed pretty even this year. So it goes around for labor costs. I like that because you look at that total budget in terms of operations, just how about $11 million is mainly three areas within our budget. So if we're actually going to grow staff and deal with issues, those areas drive a lot of that. How do we put revenues in there that are consistently able to grow as well as those cost components?
34:24 And then the last piece with the staffing I just wanted to touch on is... Dan, before we get to that, because there's a... I want to kind of keep apples to apples a little bit. So any questions on kind of this breakdown of detail of labor and how it's... I got a couple questions. When we've been looking at the budget over the last couple of years, there's an annual around labor, around the staffing for the organization.
34:53 There's an annual kind of a bump that seems to be the predictable increase that happens. And is that in the 5% range annually? Well, yeah, on average, I think this year it's just under 5%. It depends on what labor is doing based on negotiations and contracts. And then herds and medical are the other two primary drivers for that. I think this year it went up just under $500,000, if I remember correctly. Correct. That is correct. Or something between labor and...
35:22 And this has been over, I mean, as long as I've been on the council the last three or four years, I mean, it's a pretty predictable thing. It's five, six percent a year in this.
35:52 A lot of people miss the importance of that. That means that as a business, if you will, because we're in the business of collecting taxes and stuff, we have to have an annualized about 3% growth. And you talk to any economic predictor and he will tell you that that's not sustainable. So that's why it becomes so important for us to hold the line on FTEs while all of us sitting here would love to hire a lot more people in a lot more areas.
36:21 Just this annual increase all by itself in the next five or six years, unless we raise our number of people coming here substantially, is going to use up what everybody's currently seeing as a surplus. So it does not become a surplus. It becomes a tactical piece so that we can get through the next five to ten years without having to get rid of employees and such.
36:45 That's why I wanted to bring that up. So that as we, for the public and for future council members, I mean, this is the thing that it's there every year. This is the thing that's continuing to grow. And so you have to be balancing this against visitation, quality of life, quality of experience, all the rest of these kinds of things. It comes back to this piece right here. And for me, it really comes back to you. I mean, that core group of people is what's maintaining the current service levels. Oh, yeah, for sure. So if you want to expand and say, we want more.
37:14 Fill in the blank. It impacts these numbers. It means, okay, how sustainable is that over the long term? Well, and I think as we went through our first kind of most recent round of employee negotiations, you know, that was a pretty clear directive from the council that our goal is to retain and protect our full-time employees. And so the degree to which we can resist budgeting
37:42 To, you know, prior year exorbitant actuals, you know, it puts us in that position where if we, if we just went last year and said, hey, we had a, we had a banner year for 16, 17, let's budget to 18 million dollars, we would be up a creek this year in the sense that we're not going to hit that threshold, then we would have to start laying bodies off and going into that slash and burn mode and to kind of dovetail off that, I mean, I was going to save these comments for later, but Bill, you kind of segued, I mean,
38:12 If you look at this initial slide that you provided for us, that's what allows that to happen, is really kind of flipping that mentality and saying, you know, what do we need in order to provide service levels rather than just budgeting to a prior year actual? That's what puts us in a position to have an unassigned general fund balance of $2.5 million that therefore allows us to purchase the parcel.
38:37 Otherwise, we could be sitting here 20 years from now having that same conversation. You know, it's the same thing that allows us to allocate $300,000 in one time deferred maintenance to our parks and those type of things. So, you know, I think that's something that our council's been disciplined on and I would really like to see that trend continue. You know, putting money into reserves, which was our first priority to get that foundation. The second piece is, you know, allocating things to one time.
39:06 Well, the other thing is also...
39:36 Yeah, I think, I mean, that's a very good articulation of the budgeting philosophy that this council's had for the last four years, the last two years. These are the dynamics we've invested with, this is where it's currently at, and I certainly would, I think it's...
40:03 I think it's working. I think it's challenging, but I think it's working, and I think it's, I hope we all stick with it. One other thing, again, on the unfunded liabilities with PERS. This is something that's floating out there. It's a scary monster. I think at some point it would be helpful to have a presentation to Council and the public in a non-dramatic way, but to give a full representation of what it is, what does it mean in the larger context of the state, other agencies.
40:33 Counties, towns, things like that. And just so we all kind of understand what that is, what that means. It's not kind of something we're going to trip over, but so we're all kind of aware about this. What we'd like to do in that, we've actually had the discussions coming back, both made with kind of the overall debt discussion. And definitely that falls into that category. It's not something we've entered into, if you will, for debt issuance, but it's definitely an obligation we have. And there's some other things of that nature that would be good to get a good handle on that.
41:02 It kind of transcends multiple years, and some of it, some unknowns that we have control and some we don't on that, but you're right. That would be a good overview of that, and it would be an hour of discussion probably on its own from the whole debt picture and some of what we're telling you. Okay. Any public thoughts or comments on this? Okay, sorry. So, Dan, now we're on to all funds. Oh, I'm sorry. Please, come on. Kirk Stapp.
41:35 I applaud the Council on their budget and the budget priorities and everything else and how they've utilized the one-time monies and everything, the reserves, the capital set-asides and everything else. My one concern, though, is when you talk about staffing level, reading some of the previous agenda packets on the budget and the staffing levels,
42:01 From what I understand, community development has one quarter of one individual to work on the parcel. And that's going to be huge. So you might want to look at, you know, okay, if this parcel is going to go forward and housing is the priority, then what's the staffing level that needs? And you might be asking, you know,
42:26 The Community Development Director or whoever it happens to be, what do you need to make sure that that project goes forward and you have the staffing to get it to go forward? Right now I would have to say that with one quarter, I think Ruth is the one quarter individual that's going to try to handle this, we're going to get upside down or procrastinate on actually getting that to move forward. Thank you. Thank you very much.
42:55 And, you know, I think just to clarify, I think that's a very good point. You know, there's kind of this idea out there, you know, if that's going to become a priority, you've got to put your money where your mouth is. And I think that has occurred. You know, a $6.5 million investment in that parcel is the largest single investment in housing in the history of the town. So obviously that took place to actually get that to bear fruit. You know, that's what we went through with the whole housing.
43:24 You know, strategic planning process. And I think, you know, there were some recommendations that came out of that as far as additional capacity. We've already taken some steps in that direction. You know, we do have the Civic Spark person who's going to be coming on, working specifically on housing initiatives. So that's already been taken care of. We've also, you know, walked through this budget with, you know, the consideration of an additional housing coordinator.
43:53 You know, we closed on that parcel a number of months ago. We've already taken a couple of steps to add additional capacity to that, but I think your point's well taken. Yeah, I think we'll get to the next slide. We start talking about, we'll get into this a little bit, so maybe just go on with that. Yeah, if there's no other questions. Yeah, any other questions or, okay, yeah, please. So one of the issues that's touched on in that, and I wanted to touch on this as a labor concern and staffing and be able to need to,
44:21 Planned projects and daily operations. Kind of joke about it, but it's real. We don't have a lot of staff sitting around going, man, I hope somebody gives me something to work on today. So we have staff allocated out based on the projects. Just one second. Is there like a radio? There's something going. We'll just email it and try to get it fixed. It was doing that for two hours. Oh, really? Yeah.
44:46 Okay. Sorry. Campaign hallucination. We're not losing it. It's there. You're not the only one. Can I turn it up? It may be more entertaining than Dan. It could be, yeah. You can do a soft shoe here. You still stay focused on the town managers? Talk with my hands more. Our staffing levels and stuff, as Kirk mentioned, we have about a quarter of a person assigned to the housing department in there. Really, that's working on current programs. That's not really focused on the parcel.
45:16 Excuse me, the work on the parcel is really being led by Grady and a team of people looking at that, and that's just being part of their general fund assignment. So when I say the staffing is fully allocated, looking at people, it's, they're working on that, here's a new assignment, yeah, fit it in. We have an SB1 grant, a planning grant for coming up. We're working on one, we have one coming. Both of those have a commitment of in-kind time.
45:42 And so we're committing, I don't remember the number, Sandra, $20,000 in the water. So if you look at $50,000 committed to those grants, one, that helps us in our finances. The other hand, most people aren't available to work then if you have a large project company, do we fall behind in the grant work or do we not process plans timely? You know, we balance through that and Sandra works in overtime. She's smiling at least.
46:11 The element there, and so as we get additional projects in, it's something we're looking at. How do we manage that in the current staff load? Because what happens on that, either other things get set aside, not worked on, things get dropped, or things get done poorly, or it's like, yeah, we can do that, and really you start stambling. It's really not a good position to be in a lot of cases. Given some elements coming, you know, if we get a large development project coming in and Snow Creek's working on some elements.
46:40 That's going to, you know, impact staff. We have some of the grant work we have going on capital projects. That's going to impact what we're doing. That's kind of programmed in right now. If we have another big winter like we did last year, that really put a wrench in a lot of things. Brought a lot of extra money in, but a lot of extra costs and, you know, timing our mission. Prop 68 passed. There's $142 million in the Sierra Nevada Conservancy dollars coming in. Okay, do we have people who can put grants together and actually implement those?
47:10 How do we end up taking on those types of capacity options? We get some opportunities for some capital improvement programs, grants, or other elements that come into play. The concern is we are very constrained on staff time to take on a lot of major work. It's been asked before from the dais. And as we get into August, September there and start to work on priorities for the town, we want to really be able to walk through that and say, here's kind of our staff capacity. Here's where we're at. Here's what we're committed to.
47:39 Here's how we're adding extra capacity to Civic Spark. Here's how we added an intern to help with this. But if we had to free up somebody for another $50,000 commitment to a grant, who would that be and how would we do that? We want to be able to walk through that detail with you as we get into that as you look at priorities and elements. And again, I don't mind being really tight on staff and we don't mind pushing people hard to get things done, but at some point something breaks and either that, hopefully it's not staff breaking, but
48:09 We end up, the frustration becomes, what's that? No, they're like a willow. They bend in the wind, great, just what do we need to get done? But what happens to that, though, is something either doesn't get done correctly or gets done poorly or it just doesn't get the intention it needs, and that's frustrating on the professional side that we work with. We have a wood innovation grant that I'm kind of taking a lead on. It's frustrating in time, not having enough time to really make it, working with consultants and stuff to make that move forward as quickly.
48:39 But all of that's there, and that just put additional pressure. You're aware of it. I just wanted to highlight it here because we're not asking to add a lot of capacity in the budget other than some of the interns we've brought on in order to meet some of these key project issues. I just want to commend staff for the work product you guys are putting out. I think that's the reality of 2018.
49:06 That, you know, especially public institutions are being asked to do more with less. So, you know, people that have been in the town for a long time maybe are being asked to do the work that before two or three people were performing. So, you know, I think we recognize that. We appreciate it. I think staff's doing a tremendous job with the resources they have. And I think we're also doing a very good job of, you know, seizing opportunities when we can to outsource and work on a contract basis with people.
49:35 You know, if you have an inflow of a lot of building permits and we get backed up, you know, the ability to outsource that and get caught back up rather than bring on additional bodies that we may not have a need for six months or a year from then is a smart way to handle that backlog. So just want to commend staff on the job you guys are doing and the resources we have. Thank you. We have a lot of solid employees, very talented. And on the other side of that coin, for the newly elected council members out there because we're losing some of ours here,
50:05 And for those of us sitting here, that top line is very important, that current staff is fully allocated. Every time we ask for something extra from staff, gee, I'd sure like to see this for the next meeting. Not that we shouldn't do it, but we've got to think hard about it, because every minute we add to their toll, they have to pull off of one of the other priorities we set. And we're creating an untenable situation, so just from me to you, we have to be careful about doing that. These are a lot of things sometimes.
50:34 We can get on the phone and get that information on our own. As I tie this back as a budget document, it does tie back to that management ability, how do we move people within budgets? How do we achieve the priorities that are set? And some things it's like, hey, this would be a really great project to go work on, but if it's really not a priority, great, then don't work on it. It gets set aside. In our day-to-day operations, a lot of it never makes it up to the council level, so it definitely has to get done if we're going to make things work. So real quick, any other questions?
51:04 on this item. Any thoughts from the public on this? Just one point, Dan, I think we're going to be going into priority setting in August? Correct. So I think it's kind of to Bill's point. I think we've, this priority setting process is really important. Something that this council put into place and something we want to be doing and institutionalizing going forward. It's going to be very helpful to get an inventory or something that says, okay, staff is fully allocated. Great.
51:34 What does that mean? What are people working on? So, to your point, Bill, if we, council always says, look, this thing is more of a priority than this thing, we know what, you know, what, we know what the costs, what the implications are of doing that, and I'm hopeful that as we get into that this summer that we can pull that together, and it's a standardized kind of a document so we can be able to set those priorities and make those decisions.
51:56 And the last round where we did that, did some priority setting, that did help because some things did get pushed. Yeah, for sure. And said, okay, we're focusing on these areas. Yeah, so, okay. Now I'll dive into the general fund summary here. Again, a lot of this you've seen, so I don't plan to spend a lot of time walking through these. The general fund really hasn't changed much. It gives you a little history there on the key revenues. About 61% of our general fund revenue in total comes out of that TOT pot, be that.
52:24 T.O.T. direct revenues or whether it's the assessments or the work we're doing in compliance, one-time payments for those types of pieces that come into play. 15.5% is property tax and 10.9% is sales tax. So the three of those drive 87.5% of our budget. So if we're going to move bodies and we're talking about costs that from the general fund, 80% of your budget comes from three revenue sources.
52:54 That then we focus on how do we grow those? How do those move? And the other option, of course, to start to look at other options out there, the revenue sources. California cities are relatively limited, other than going out from a voter approved tax measure, those types of elements that way. It kind of gives you just a big picture of where these major revenue sources are. I mentioned earlier, as somebody mentioned, like the building component.
53:20 This year we have a really solid growth in building permit fees, a lot of small projects, a lot of activity going on. That's an up and down which does help us because we can manage that with contracts to some degree, but that is a chunk coming into our general fund this year. The grant money helps. That's an offset of say $50,000 of staff time. Next year if we don't have those, that has to get absorbed back into the budget because those are full-time regular employees for the most part working in those areas, not 100%.
53:49 Dan, can you clarify, on the top line, TOT, baseline and projects, we've got 13.5, the baseline is 12.5. Correct. And then there's a million dollars additional there for our NGO partners that are on a points basis, transit, tourism and housing. Correct.
54:13 For their allocation, should they be working off a 13.5 budget or a 12.5? So for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, they are working off the 13.5 element because we have a pass-through to them of the base dollar amount. Right. Both transit and housing are contracted for a dollar amount. Correct. And so they would be working off the contracted dollar amount. Plus.
54:38 Plus additional potential reserve. Everything else would go to reserves for housing and for transit. And if we do more than $13.5, tourism would have an additional reserve. Now there's, we end this year, we'll have some reserve dollars there too. But for, and again, a little bit different just the way the contracts originally were set up with tourism as a full pass-through. Transit depends on the contract we enter into with ESTA. But we still set aside the extra dollars. And part of that million would go into.
55:07 If we added a bunch of service, we'd spend it. Otherwise, it goes in that reserve. The housing is the same way. There'll be a housing piece in there. Right now, that's earmarked, committed into trying to work on the parcel or not to be paying for the purchase of the parcel. But that's a simple answer is they should be operating off the $13.5. Well, the $13.5 of the MLT, the others will be off the contracted dollar amount. But the $13.5 will end up...
55:34 Good. So the graphic is the same? Yeah, this just shows you the percentage by kind of pie chart to get a feel for that. We are reliant on people coming up and spending the night and paying TOT. That didn't get picked up in the discussion. I think Bill says we are a resort community. We're kind of reliant on other people coming up and having a great time and going home with just enough money to come back again.
56:06 So from that piece of it. The expenditure side of the general fund kind of walks through, again, the major components on the salary side, 6.7 million, I'm sorry, 7.9 million for 18-19. You can kind of see the growth of the last few years there. A couple of bodies added in, but some of that's just basic growth. And then down below in the packet, the next part down, the other non-
56:35 Personnel-related items kind of work through that piece there. The transfer out number is primarily debt and snow removal. There's a couple, and there's also, I guess, the airport's the other larger piece there, which are the transfers out in the budget. Each year that'll bounce around a little bit depending what comes in when we end up moving dollars to get the larger that anticipated TOT comes in, so we move money over to capital, we move it into roads or...
57:03 Somewhere else that'll move around each year. That's why you'll see some larger numbers in previous years there that happened. So, but this is kind of the big picture, you know, by major category, your expenditures within the general fund to be able to walk through those. And then you've seen this before, so I'll go kind of quick, but this was the departmental allocations. The general fund, again, as we talk about fund 100, the general fund.
57:28 You see each department, their totals. And if you go back to the detail in the report, you could actually go into each department and say, well, how much is salary? How much is each little wine item within that budget? But I think we're getting to the point in the presentation where this is kind of another way of presenting data. Right. Right? I mean, we're kind of reframing the same data and facts, just as presenting it in a different fashion. And so we had big picture, all funds, then we got to drill down to general funding that continues to funnel down into more wine items.
57:58 In detail there. And so, again, I wasn't going to spend a ton of time on this issue before by departments. You'll see some changes over time. Some of that's cost. And sometimes we're trying to allocate better between departments to where things belong. And so you'll see some movements that way. I think last year, like, we took our community support dollars out of the council budget and put it in the general services because it's more of a broad item. Those types of elements.
58:25 The summary kind of walks through the various departments and how they're funded. And again, it's like Public Works is here at $1.6 million, but that does not include what they're spending over, you know, Public Works and the road yard or the capital side, how they're allocated across those other funds. But this is the general fund portion that supports that area. And again, this would be like tourism business development, that's really the...
58:51 MLT work there. You'll see the other pieces that fall into this. So if there's particular questions or comments or something related to the general fund, again, you've kind of seen this before, so I wasn't going to spend a ton of time on it. But if there's a question or if there's comments from the public related to the general fund detail, it's here. And then this is, I mentioned that transfer out. It's mainly debt and a little bit to the gas tax fund in the airport.
59:19 Okay. So the last couple years, you'll see in here a housing help loan that we paid back on behalf of MLH in terms of that over a few years. We had two different loans out. And so you'll see that where there's nothing this year. Okay. So general fund, any comments or questions or I call it comments. Thoughts, questions? Just make a comment. You know, I like the presentation. Being an old accountant, I look at the variance and
59:48 That is what I concentrate on to form questions about the budget. So, I appreciate the presentation on that. By the department. If you look at the general service, for example, that mainly decrease there was actually reduction in insurance. A couple years ago, we had a big bump up in insurance. I think Monter County IT just arrived.
1:00:19 So any other thoughts on this or any thoughts on the public? Council, hopefully you can get that thing. Council bus. So a couple things. Wait, wait, wait, wait. Moment of silence. Is it gone?
1:00:43 Yeah, I didn't know what bus is. Is it gone? Yeah, it's gone. Yeah, it's gone. Thank you very much. Thanks. Thank you. That is so frustrating. So someone had their iPod connected. Oh, my God. Yeah. Yeah. Into that monitor. It's good to know. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Jamie. Thank you, Mono County IT. Have a nice day. I've been listening to that for three hours now. Could have just. Five hours now, Colin. Pulled that out, yeah.
1:01:13 Just a couple things. Dan, you're doing a good Rob impersonation today. Very granular on this one. It just came up as you're talking about it, but credit card fees out of curiosity. Do we as a town use any for giving like school spirit pays or now foundation? We may be regulated who we use for a processor, but just wondering if we have an opportunity to give back to our schools to that. It doesn't cost us any more money, but just as a thought for us on who we use. I have no idea. It just came to me as we were talking about it. That's a great question.
1:01:42 Just as a portion as chair of MLT, and I didn't know where to ask this, but I'll put it into here as an overall, we have this joint
1:01:51 Joint bucket funding that's part of our agreement with the town, and we're overall dollars that go together, and we agree on certain things that are beneficial for the town. I'm here on behalf of MLT, and I recognize I can do it at different times, but I thought as you were doing budget, I'd present it now and ask for three things from that joint fund. One, there's been a request for fish stocking from overall, and we think that the appropriate uses of dollars, of $50,000 of those dollars, to be used as a joint fund, and that MLT and the town council could agree to that and use that for the
1:02:20 Part of our fish stocking. Two, the Hayden Historical Society has presented, and they did last year, I don't know if you're familiar with it, the trolley program in regards to having individuals on the trolley which are ambassadors and kind of represent a certain kind of a fun culture that exists on the trolleys. And they're asking for $15,500 from...
1:02:43 us and us being MLT and we're asking the town to be able to share part of that in the joint fund bucket as well and utilize those funds from a period of June 8th through September 9th.
1:02:53 For putting in there. They did receive some funding from Measure U, just to be clear, of $7,500. So they're asking for additional so they can add additional bodies for that. And the MLT board agreed with that. But we're asking to potentially share those dollars on the joint fund. The third is we have an events position that we're planning to bring on board as part of conversation and where we want to go forward with MLT. And we looked at it as a joint benefit for the community as well. And there may be other things that...
1:03:20 Reside around that, but that's approximately $115,000 as well for the events position. Now, I recognize that these are one-time requests and there are certain things that we can go around with those. Right now, the fund, as we have showing from the town, it's $865,409. There's certain commitments for the King's Deal, but there's certainly funds available there, but we're asking for the town's consideration that we potentially use some of those.
1:03:43 Just for the Council's benefit, because we discussed this earlier.
1:04:12 So the request is $180,000 for those three items out of a remaining $265,000 that's currently uncommitted? That is what I show for my number. It says $265,000, and we're asking for $100,000. That's not counting that it's anticipated to grow another $800,000 in its next budget year when we don't have any other requests coming forward at this point in time. But these are items that came before our board meeting today that I'm bringing forward to you guys.
1:04:38 Okay. Thank you. And I know that we can request this anytime, but I thought during the budget timeframe, and it may not be appropriate here right now, but I just wanted to bring it up now because we're talking about it and we want to be as transparent as possible on request. Okay. Good. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Okay. Anything else? Okay. Can you clarify that initial question on our merchant processor? I'm sorry. Do you know that answer? Or Cindy? We do not currently.
1:05:08 We use express bill pay for the most part. We do have some small credit cards that come in through the front counter, but we use express bill pay for our business tax and people that are paying online, and they pay that fee to us. In order to pay with a credit card, they pay that fee to us, and it comes to us as a revenue, but no, we don't have anything set up that's going to the schools or any other charitable thing at this time. We can look into it, though. Yeah. It might be a suggestion, you know.
1:05:36 That merchant processor business is kind of like a bunch of options. Careful. I'll be careful of my work. Cautious. Cautious.
1:05:45 They're always coming to you with the better deal, right? Right. But we switched over to school spirit pays based simply on the fact that, you know, you get solicited on a weekly or monthly basis with different people with different programs, but we thought that that had some merit for us. So that might be a, yeah, a black tie. And I'm not sure it can work through express bill pay and how, what our contract is with how business tax and TOT is now paying online.
1:06:12 But I'll certainly ask the question. Yeah, maybe something to look into. Yeah, I don't know if our system will do it or not. I can get you in contact with the rep if you'd like, and you can kind of walk through some of those details. We have to walk through through our third-party processors. Sure. Yeah, that's what I'm suggesting. Maybe we just do the intro if you're interested in looking to do it. Yeah, good. No, it's a good observation, a good opportunity. Okay, so gas tax? Yeah, the next, oops.
1:06:42 Yeah, the transfers yourself. Yeah, the other stuff on this, again, you've seen the gas tax budget before this comes in. This is our road budget, basically. You'll see a little bit of a surplus in here. That's trying to estimate what the actual payments are going to go to the general improvement districts for snow removal support. I would not suggest that it actually gets utilized elsewhere at this point because we don't know how big a winner we're going to have. So it's kind of a guess on money coming in and out and what we think it is.
1:07:11 Some of the estimates, Cindy runs these all the time for us looking at that. And then we can get pretty good, but usually it's after the fact of the winter. So it does provide some cushion. And originally we plugged in 100,000 transfers in there. Based on some analysis, it's in the $30,000 range. But again, as we don't know what the winter holds, I would suggest that that stay held in the gas tax for those purposes. It walks through the details here. If you have a question on it, I'd be glad to address those.
1:07:40 Again, it's mainly gas tax, and then there's a general fund dollars. The SB1 money that comes in, you'll see the note here. We ultimately have to be careful how we track that and use it for projects and account for it separately for state requirements. We actually have to put in projects and come back through that, but you will see a project here funded out of SB1 funds as well. So there is a relationship as a nexus between SB1.
1:08:04 And local projects that we're dealing through the gas tax program. Yes, we are getting stuff on the ground funded out of SB1, the additional gas tax dollars. Okay, and I think it's important. I'm not sure what the numbers statewide were for the, was it 69? It was pretty high. It was pretty high. I know locally it was in the 70s or 80s, I think, but I think it's just something for all us to be aware how important.
1:08:26 That SB1, not only the grant, the two grants that is in community development right now, but also the resources it gives us for our local transportation infrastructure. So just a thought on that one.
1:08:38 Okay. Just the pie chart, you'll see that. It kind of walks through the various allocations we're at. Again, the majority of our dollars in here goes into snow removal and operational side. So the other elements is a lot of our road rehab is the other dollar amount. We put approximately $580,000 a year into road rehab. Some adjustments here from how it falls out there for street maintenance and stuff.
1:09:02 The chart allocations of it. But you'll end up with trying to do that for roads. You'll also see that road money, if we don't spend it, it stays within the road fund. Often that ends up becoming a piece that we use for capital projects that are related, part of our sidewalk work or a larger, you'll save the money over a couple of years for a larger project, for example. I think in the capital improvement projects, if you add it up, you'll see 1.2 million come out of road rehab.
1:09:28 Part of that was one-time money allocated over to the road department for that work, and then part of it is the dollars coming out from, like, this year we didn't have a major road project because we had all the sidewalk work coming in, knowing they're going to have matching dollars and those types of things. So while it's identified for road rehab, it may end up going into other road-related capital, sidewalks, curb, gutter, roads, those types of elements. Okay.
1:09:57 So a lot of these specialty funds I'll kind of go kind of quick through, but you've seen a lot of this before, so. Okay, I'm sorry, I'm just, there's an incident going on in town. I'm just getting some messages about that. Yeah, we had a shooting up on Hillside Road. I can't say much about it, but altercation, it sounds like, between roommates. Okay. Okay. So, other duties are assigned. Thank you, Sandra.
1:10:31 So this is coming from the District Attorney's Office. Approximately 11.25 a.m. on Wednesday, June 6th, Mammoth Lakes PD and the Mono County District Attorney's Office responded to a 911 call from an individual who had been shot in his residence located on Hillside Drive in Mammoth Lakes. Upon arriving on the scene, they were met outside by the reporting party who had been shot in the stomach. The reporting party indicated that he was shot by another male in the residence but was...
1:11:00 Able to wrestle control the gun away from him and return fire. The reporting party was transported to Mammoth Hospital and stabilized for transportation to Reno. Law enforcement has secured the scene and is waiting for a forensic team to arrive to process the scene. The other individual remains in their residence and is presumed dead. So, tragedy here in town. Well, thanks for sharing that. There's still ongoing activity. Yeah, thanks.
1:11:32 Yeah, I know the techs are flying, and I'm sure social media is lit up with that, so. Okay. That's what we know. That's what we know, and that's what we can say, right? Correct. Okay. So. Okay, so. Any gas tax question? If that, I'll jump in. Measure R, measure U of the next two. I'll hit a couple of these, and you can get a question to measure gas tax. Gas tax, I'm sorry, please. Yeah.
1:12:01 I wonder if we could get some clarification on the town gas tax going to Main Street just because I thought that was a state road. On the Main Street work that we're doing there, the sidewalks will ultimately be a town responsibility for maintenance and taking those on. Almost all of that is funded out of STIP, the State Transportation Improvement Program. The current Upper Main Street, we had a match going into that.
1:12:30 For $270,000 in our match, plus we had a developer match going into that project. As we look at sidewalks on Main Street, again, we'll end up, I think, with some town dollars matching. Some of that work, Grady, if I remember correctly, going into that. So the sidewalk work ultimately becomes ours. Actual pavement out there is Caltrans, and so they maintain that. But the sidewalk and areas become the towns.
1:13:00 It's Main Street, five-block maintenance. Yeah, it's Main Street maintenance. Yeah, we do that, the small amount there. That's actually for the promenade, the brown and green mixture, probably more brown than green another month, but it's the promenade area there that'll go into that maintenance. Yeah, and so the project, so there is a, I'm assuming to your point, there's a distinction between how gas tax or SB1 funds
1:13:28 Would flow through Caltrans to 203 versus money coming to the town on stuff that's not state highway stuff. Yeah, the 69-5 there is really dollars that go to maintain the median, if you will, the areas there that's our responsibility. So, Dan, how do we deal with that if we go back to the large winter that we have had and we know that we had to bail Caltrans out and do a lot of snow removal on Main Street?
1:13:57 Do we just count those as local roads and seek reimbursement in the normal way? Or do we go through some process to bill it back to Caltrans for? It just goes into our snow maintenance budget. Into our snow maintenance budget, yeah. Thank you very much. It's the benefit of our residents. But we get the normal gas tax reimbursement on that. Yeah, our cost element to snow reimbursement goes into that if we spend it there. We don't ask for a separate reimbursement for that work from Caltrans on that, for the snow.
1:14:26 That's correct. We don't ask for a separate reimbursement. It was in the same budget. Okay. Anything else on gas tax? Okay, good. So Measure R? Yeah, Measure R has two funds, one for trails and one for operations. Works through that.
1:14:46 These dollars are held by the town. If we want to expend them, it goes through a referral process through Mammoth Lakes Recreation. They have to make a recommendation back to town council, which you can either accept or not accept. Modify as you see fit. And so we really administer the funds. I think the staff report we mentioned about MLR admin, but really it's MLR recommendation that comes back to us. The details here, I'm not going to walk through it. You can read that.
1:15:14 I think the one element, again, as I mentioned earlier, in the trail side, we are using some reserve dollars, looking at some capital work, some planning, hopefully some NEPA work, and then followed on some hard construction work for our trail system. It also incorporates the debt service payment related to $5.5 million in bonds we did for the multi-use facility. I can answer questions here, otherwise, if... No, Measure Arn. Public, any thoughts, questions, Measure Arn? Okay, Measure U.
1:15:44 Same thing, this goes through Mammoth Lakes Recreation, comes back through. The programming is really the allocations out to various community groups, be it the theater or be it the various arts and culture elements, and then kind of walk through it. The other thing for Measure U that really helps a lot of our events is that allocation to transit, noted by Brent earlier in terms of Measure U for different...
1:16:08 Activities and programs in here, that's been a real benefit in terms of helping those out. So not a lot of allocations to measure you to date. You're really looking at that ultimately, as I mentioned earlier in reserves, there's two and a half million for the MAC project. And also longer term looking at the potential of up to an annual allocation of $300,000 for O&M work with the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center. Again, that'll come to you as a formal agreement ultimately.
1:16:38 And how we work through that kind of add up to account. But to help with the O&M of that would be coming from a Measure U allocation. Okay. Any Measure U questions? Public, any Measure U thoughts or questions? Okay. Airport operations. Yeah, the airport gets broken into kind of two areas looking at our overall O&M side. And then if we have capital projects which are primarily grant funded, you'll see a couple of those in there looking out with the fence project.
1:17:08 Sorry, I'm spacing one. Thank you, the segmented circle. They want us to take the hard upper stuff down and pave it and make it a concrete circle and paint it accordingly for safety reasons there. The airport is also, we do the transfer in from the general fund, so you see the revenue piece there that goes in to help support that operations. Obviously, we will be reevaluating and look at the airport budget.
1:17:33 One of the revenue sources is from air service. They rent the terminal, if you will, for their space there. With Alaska leaving in November, depending on what type of replacement, if any, we get in for air service, that would potentially impact our budget activity there. And so that's something we'll be watching and monitoring, the impact that may have on us going into the year. Any questions on this? I think we're all concerned.
1:18:02 I think there's two different elements that would happen on that. There would be
1:18:30 Either we would not, we would end up letting go some part-time staff if we did not have the work requirement. The challenge becomes just even with the United coming in, if it just stays with the one service, we still have to meet a minimum level. And to do that, we may not be able to shift staffing back. We'd look at that. We'd look at some of our other cost elements that are in there and manage that out.
1:18:53 And then lastly, we would take a look, if we had to, it would be coming back. If we can't reduce our cost side, you would be looking at a potential little larger increase, transfer out from the general fund to back that up. What neighborhood does that transfer out look like? I would have to spend more time looking. I don't think it'd be huge because you're looking at a good chunk of the year, but through November we'd be covered. And the true up for this fiscal year is going to be happening in? September, October.
1:19:22 We would be able to look at it at that point. We had to be setting some stuff aside at that point to maybe cover something like that? Correct. Yeah, and I don't, there's not a lot of operating reserves in the airport area, if I remember correctly, that we could tap some of those, some of those are general funds we put over so you could tap some of those dollars there. You have some capital. Yeah. Capitals that are not restricted, right? We have some unrestricted capital. Yeah. So those dollars could go in to offset the operating if need be. Okay.
1:19:50 But it's a concern that we need to stay on top of. Well, more than operating, though, as I understand it, in November when Alaska leaves, a lot of the hardware infrastructure we have to handle the United flights goes away with them. And potentially that could affect our budget as well because those are not cheap pieces. So I don't know what fund or what... Well, I think Alaska provides a lot of that equipment. They do.
1:20:15 They'll take that away. Right. That's what I'm saying. Whoever else comes in that requires a bidet. Potentially. We don't know what that contract would look like or what they would require. At this point, we don't anticipate funding that equipment to support a commercial air service. But just something to bear in mind, it is a potentiality that we could have to do that and alter our own budget to...
1:20:39 Keep the place going. Yeah, there's a lot of, I'm not trying to be an alarmist. I'm not trying to be an alarmist, but there's some stuff that, yeah, we've got to keep our eyes on that. Correct. Okay. Any thoughts on the public on the airport? Okay. Capital projects. Yeah, so the Fund 300 capital projects, as I mentioned earlier, this kind of lays out the ones coming into the current year. The vast majority of our projects have had some work in previous years.
1:21:09 And including the current year, it walks through the major ones there. And don't be surprised if down the road we end up with additional projects coming in. It tends, because again, it doesn't flow well July 1 to June 30. It gives you a feel for that. And the current year expense estimates at $3.7 million. Ultimately, we end up approving it appropriately if we have the full project appropriated or if the funding's there.
1:21:36 That transfers over. The budget is really what we think we're going to spend this year, which almost best guess today will probably be wrong at some level, just given capital projects and how they work. We've left the multi-use facility here. It's to be determined. It's been a project. We had dollars originally committed into there.
1:21:54 But given the bids that came in, et cetera, and looking for additional direction from town council, we've left that blank in terms of trying to estimate a dollar amount at this point in that one. But there's the various projects here. I think the vast majority of these, they've all been to you at one point or the other already. Some of our underway as we speak to be completed.
1:22:15 Glad to touch on any of these, or I should say Grady would be glad to touch on any of them if there's questions related to any of the capital projects there, or if you were expecting to see something else in the list, we can address that. Any questions from up here? The SB1C and G, what does that stand for? Curbs and gutters. Curbs and gutters, okay. So that's another SB1 thing that's coming.
1:22:39 Okay. Last month we took, yeah, that's for the heart on the ground. We have SB1 grant, planning grants. Okay. And then we have another, I believe one more SB1 down the road funding-wise. Another question, sawmill cutoff drainage? Yeah, that's the drainage work where we, last year we had a lot of the, after the sawmill, the flooding, we're starting close to the visitor center, that area and kind of working upstream to how do we address some drainage issues. There's, we had some flooding out there. Right.
1:23:05 So hopefully this project... And how much of that is ours versus... Because the Forest Service, they just dug up... They'll be doing water lines and... Are these things related? Is it a... Are we working together? No, we flooded out the visitor center last year. We did. I don't know if that was ours or part of theirs, but... Yeah. Anyway, we had a...
1:23:20 But there is definitely drainage issues out there, and so this is really on ours kind of, because ultimately the majority of the town drains out there and ends up out in Murphy Gulch, I believe. Okay. So this is starting to work backwards to correct some issues. Okay, one other thing on the Mammoth Creek Gap, I had a conversation with Forest Service folks that there is some Forest Service, they indicated there's some Forest Service land you may or may not be aware of over as part of that.
1:23:46 Mammoth Creek Gap closure from the park along, just running along Old Mammoth Road. They indicated that there's some Forest Service property in there. You're probably aware of that, but I just wanted to make sure you aware of that. Yeah, we've actually worked both on the road, and there's right where the join comes together, there's like a four foot. Yeah. We'd actually worked through that with them at one point in terms of getting clearances to put that path through. Okay.
1:24:16 And my last thought on this is CIP. We were going to get a, I don't know if it's coming up, then hopefully next year or the next coming months we'll see a CIP presentation. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Sorry. Yes, please. This would be the capital improvement programs that kind of in the operating budget side of it. Yes. The five-year CIP obviously looks out differently. Yeah. Look forward to seeing that when that's appropriate. Jennifer.
1:24:41 Yeah, thank you. Similarly, I'm having troubles with some of these terms. I don't know, just could you entertain me and explain to me what concrete improvements Meridian Shady is? Okay. Yeah, on Meridian, there's actually some curb and gutter work, and the Shady is the work out at Shady Rest Park. We actually had to do some concrete work out there in terms of setting the bleachers and things of that nature, and I believe there are some other improvements, too, that went out there as well.
1:25:11 In terms of work at Shady Rest Park. It's also the sidewalk right here by Union Bank, that little piece of sidewalk. Yeah, right. That's our gravel path. That little piece as well. We lumped in a bunch of different concrete things to get a little bit of price. They were three different places around town. Okay. So this is kind of a Public Works project name that covers a lot of different geographies, but that's where it is, yeah. Yeah, so the Shady is Shady Rest Park. Got it. Okay. And then Meridian there up and down some of the curb and gutter.
1:25:39 Okay. Any other questions on these obtuse naming conventions for these capital projects? Nope. Okay. Thank you. So development impact fees. Yeah, so this is kind of just a picture in terms of what we expect kind of coming in from the various impact fees. We don't have a lot of expenditures on that because they tie to actual projects if and when they come forward as dollars are accumulated for projects.
1:26:06 So this is kind of a touch, just a reminder, they're out there. We have that as development comes forward. They do end up paying various fees in. It walks through the numbers. I won't, unless there's questions on them. It's similar to our assessment districts. Last meeting, I think it was, you said a whole bunch of hearing dates for these and stuff. And so the assessment districts worked the same way. We come back in. It's all restricted revenue to that particular district.
1:26:30 There's a variety of assessment methods that go into that. And this one here, you'll see some uses in fund balance where we have a lot of money set aside. So we're doing capital projects or there's a debt payment or some cases we set in money in there for a lot of these for snow removal. All depends on how much we do in a year. And so a lot of times you'll have a zero assessment or a small assessment depending on.
1:26:52 The actual activity in those districts. So back to the diff fees real quick. Do we know when we're going to be going back and taking a look at the fees? Well, part of it in the fee resolution on these, you have these going up by the cost of construction as referenced in the engineering news record, ENR. So there's a built-in increase there. As we go back and review the capital program, that would come back and say, okay, are the fees status for that?
1:27:18 I just, I think, because the last time we, when we revisited, we, you know, reviewed, reset the diff fees, you know, things, a lot of things have happened economically since then. I just want to make sure that, I think we all want to make sure that they're current, they're, if some big project comes in, we're good, and our fees are going to cover the mitigation. Then the other side of this that's not on here is that housing in lieu is actually a trust and agency fund, so it's sitting in the balance sheet with dollars there. We actually don't put it into a fund because it doesn't have, it gets used in different ways.
1:27:47 For that, and that would be the other one that would be under review, take a look at those fees and say, do they need to move or not, based on looking at the other report. It doesn't have an automatic CPI component on that one. It's one we'll look at in terms of the project elements there. Yeah, I think these are things we've got to take a look at. Just, I mean, if we've learned anything else from the multi-use facility, from the bids coming in, how...
1:28:08 You know, what it takes to build and do things up here. I think we need to be not just pulling something off the shelf for increases, but looking at the actual cost of construction and businesses. I'm looking, I think we'll be looking forward to. And I would hope when we look at the housing mitigation and housing issues, now that we have the parcel, that we can take a look at how we can best use that and get developers to build there versus just paying into a fund. Oh, sure. That doesn't adequately build what we need. Exactly, right.
1:28:37 Yeah, that's a very good point. We've talked about that in the past. Okay, sorry. Last thing on the fee, the other thing I'd note here, we do collect fees on behalf of other folks that we have no control over other than as a collection agency. The fire district, the library, and for the child care facilities, we collect fees for those and we pass them through upon request from those agencies. They'll have a project that's defined in the program and request.
1:29:01 And just as a general historical observation, the diff fee program, this is not your dad's diff fee program, right? This is your mom or your dad's diff fee program. This is a, you know, after the settlement and all those things we went through and the council, really the town has really completely reoriented how we perceive diff, what we do with it. This should be the expectations and efficient straight ahead program that should pay for the cost of mitigating projects. Okay, sorry. So where are we now, Dan?
1:29:30 Are you done with assessment districts? Assessment districts, same comment. I commented on them briefly. Unless there's a particular question on it, it's restricted revenue comes in, pays for things within each district, if we need to increase rates or not. And you'll see a lot of use of fund balance here because some of them have built up reserves larger than what's recommended. And each year you go through a hearing process on these. Thoughts or questions? Yeah, Dan.
1:30:01 Explain the variance there, the change in fund balance. I mean, there's a... Yeah, for most of those, there's either a capital project that was planned, and so it's going into capital investment for that, or in some cases, it had a large enough reserve already, so we're going to spend down fund balance, because it doesn't need to just continue to generate a larger balance in a lot of these areas for what the money... So we wouldn't have to go back to the three large ones there and reassess?
1:30:31 No. Okay. And so that goes through each with the hearing to look at those. And a lot of these, for the drought years, actually built up some pretty good fund balances because we didn't have a lot of snow removal. So then we're drawing some of that down instead of doing assessments. So it's a timing thing. Yeah. Thank you. Any thoughts from the public on assessment districts? Okay. Vehicle Replacement Fund. Yes. Cindy?
1:31:01 He has more expertise than I do. Awesome. Okay. So the vehicle replacement fund, we have a vehicle replacement fund, and we, every year, set aside dollars to replace our equipment and vehicles. As you know, we borrowed a significant amount of money when we... I wasn't prepared to talk.
1:31:28 Pay legal fees basically for these. We have the legal fees. So we borrowed money and we have a plan to pay that back over the next 10 years. So right now, and we use our vehicles until they really die. I mean, they're worthless when we're done with them. But when we do replace them, we have them split out into divisions. So I've got a snow removal and street maintenance division.
1:31:57 Just a snow removal division. I've got just a street maintenance division. It's all based on how the vehicles are used. Some of these funds are restricted based on the funding source because we do get gas tax money for the snow removal equipment at the same 50%. So we have a life of what we think the life of the vehicle will be, and we set our replacement dollars based on
1:32:21 The life of the vehicle. And then we'll look within the fund. We can fudge a little bit within their division to purchase something that we need to purchase if the money's there and, you know, work with the fund that way. But each piece of equipment is actually assigned a dollar value. And we review on a regular basis. We may have bought it for one price, you know, but 15 years later.
1:32:47 It's another price. So we constantly review what those dollars are that are going to be needed for future replacement. So there's not ever really 100% funded for any one piece of equipment because we up it each year to account for the fact that it's going to cost us more to replace it later. Okay, great. Thank you. So you'll kind of see in the chart as it walks through there the divisions, replacement cost estimates, how much we have in fund balance.
1:33:14 Then cash available, and that's the difference on that really is that debt issuance between the borrowing that happened. So Cindy, when we have a vehicle that has, because we do, and much to our credit, use our vehicles past their expected life expectancy, when the vehicle reaches that life expectancy, then we stop adding to the vehicle replacement fund for it except for the inflationary? That's correct. Right. And a lot of times we'll even take that piece of equipment.
1:33:43 Or vehicle and say, hmm, what other department can we, maybe it can't be used in the PD anymore. You know, they might need something better, but can parks maintenance use it? Can engineering use it? Can somebody else use it? So we definitely move our vehicles around. Sometimes they just can't leave town anymore, but they can still get around. We have a trade down program there. So some vehicles are, yeah, if you have to go past the airport, get a different one.
1:34:13 So, but, and we really do that to how do we manage that and how much do we need? And again, depending on the time of year, a lot of the vehicles will sit for a good part of the year and so we don't want to be, you know, throwing good money after bad, if you will. And if we sell one of those vehicles and get revenue from that, does it go specifically back? It goes specifically back into that division that sold the vehicle. Or for example, we had a police car, was it rear-ended by a Tesla? Tesla looked a lot worse than the police car.
1:34:39 Anyway, I think we got $31,000 back in insurance for that. And so that went back into the police department replacement fund. Any liabilities in the state from CARB? I know the county had to really wrestle with that. We've actually been in front of that. Our fleet maintenance guys have done a really good job with that in terms of timing and knowing what we have to meet. We haven't got a, we're not horribly behind, if you will. They deal with that quite a bit. I know there's
1:35:07 Mechanics have quite a bit of challenge with that on the bus systems because they'll clog up and it basically shuts them down and so they can limp home to get fixed. But we are on top of the car requirements, much more so than the county was. Yeah, there's the California Air Resources Board so that all the vehicles have to be conforming with certain particulate emission standards. Yeah. So we've been standing on that. Sometimes you look at the timing of buying stuff because of that too. Yeah, okay. We have that.
1:35:35 Any questions, sorry, any questions of the public on vehicle replacement fund? I was going to say that we have a couple that we are looking at replacing next year. We have two police vehicles buying two new expeditions would be the idea. One's a replacement completely. The other one was trying to keep one of our older ones as a backup vehicle. So when we do have one in an accident, we can actually have a different vehicle to pull back in. We had another one that hit a deer, and I haven't.
1:36:03 I figured out if we're actually going to have to replace that one or if it's fixable yet. So we ended up doing two replacements. The other side of that and the admin side is looking at doing replacements there. And what we started a year or two ago was really looking at, I'll say, more of a quality used vehicle. We've had a couple good successes with that. And so we're out there doing that now. There's some different auction websites, really other agencies, et cetera, that Fleet Maintenance is looking at or they're looking at trade-ins that come out of like a,
1:36:33 Hertz or Enterprise in the car rental business back into the dealerships and stuff like that. And so I know we're having that discussion and looking at those. And so again, this is pretty much of an estimate in terms of some of the replacement side, looking for the larger little smaller vehicles. And again, as we do that, the other ones we have would then trade back down. And so some of the much older vehicles would be the ones getting pushed out on the bottom, if you will, to go to auction. And so if we do surplus a vehicle out, we...
1:37:02 Hopefully it has some life in it or value in it because we'll surplus it. I think we had one case we actually had to pay somebody to haul it off. So we do tend to use them down quite a ways in terms of that element. But we also do make sure, I mean we joke up that a little bit, but our mechanics are great. And if a vehicle, if they don't feel it's safe, we don't drive it. So that's the other caveat there. It's anything we're driving, they've said yes, it's safe to be on the road here. So they may say don't drive it for a long distance for other reasons.
1:37:31 So comfortable from that perspective. And so in the budget, we would have $180,000 plus the $20,000 contingency because we just don't know on some of those. I know we took a look at the brand new expeditions that are competing, I think, with the Chevy Suburbans. All the bells and whistles, they run $71,000 before you put any police stuff on them. So we're looking for a stripped-down model. Okay, good. Okay, so we get done with this? Yeah. So debt service. Debt service.
1:37:58 Again, you've seen this before, really, we've got one more year in the drainage improvements debt that was a state loan. The lease revenue bonds, the work we did for the police station and the bell-shaped parcel, the refinancing on that. Annual payment, bond issue for MLLLA settlement. The garage service loan, as Cindy mentioned, we have a payment back every year. This is slowly paying that, borrowing back the garage fund. And then there's reporting fees and things we have every year for debt.
1:38:27 And then the major R bond issue. So overall, a relatively stable debt picture for the town. Again, obviously that settlement payment continues to be a big chunk of revenue every year that goes out the door. A little less than it was, but it still has a big nut until 2035, I believe. So it's not going anywhere quickly. Okay. Any questions from council? I think it's important just for the MLLA thing.
1:38:56 I tend to refer it as the $2 million check. I just think it's so important for the public. Again, not to be alarmist, but we had a very good discussion here about how we budget, the basic mechanics of how we're doing these things, and this is all because of that.
1:39:17 Fundamental item. And we're doing great. I think it's amazing to see how we've kind of come back and the great work we're doing. But let's not get crazy here. We still have to make that payment every year. And if you want to add to that, I mean, we don't talk about it much. We have that debt payment now, that $2 million check. That $340,000 payment also was a result of the cost of that litigation. Okay. And so those rolled together. If we didn't have that, those would be operating revenues. Yeah.
1:39:43 That would go into that. And then on the airport side there, I think there was about another $100,000 that we lost in lease revenue that went back to... So it's $2 million, it's still $2 million plus, even though we financed this. Yeah, that we're tied into... $2 million five. Yeah, so the $340 is a 10-year supplement on that, and the other one is out to $2035, whatever that distance would be. Any questions from up here on... No, once we do this, it's Fund 990 and...
1:40:10 That's as high as we go. Okay. Any public thoughts or questions on debt service fund, 990? Okay, good. That would wrap it up. The only comment I think I got, if you want to, as we go into the public hearing, we'll do a short version of this. Okay. I didn't hear a lot of information coming back in terms of modification or changes. If you want, we can address some of the requests from MLT related to the...
1:40:37 Joint bucket, if you will, at that point, if you wish to amend anything other than the budget from that perspective. I just, I, I, I, I'm a little, come back later. Well, I'm just concerned about, I mean, the level of altitude that we're at, and we just have a very nice high level review of everything, and I would just be a little cautious, I mean, I'm not saying personally one way or the other about the merits of what's being proposed, but how do we, how do we fit that into, you know, it's almost a policy level kind of discussion, so.
1:41:05 I would agree that tonight is probably not the time to bring that forward. Yeah. I would like to see a staff write-up on it. Exactly. Yeah, some staff backup and stuff. Yeah. Well, I think, you know, however the council and Dan, however you guys feel appropriate, I think the reason that came up is because MLT approved a budget document today, and that was part of the discussion around that. So at whatever time is appropriate, I don't think matters or what context. So if it was done at the next meeting, would that?
1:41:34 Would that be okay? Yeah, for sure. All right, so maybe let's – Yeah, there's no knee-jerk knee here. Yeah, exactly. No, certainly not. I don't want to get down into – get out of this altitude, get down to that kind of stuff. So I'm taken from it from actually when we get into the public hearing, at least from this discussion. I don't have any major amendments that need to come forward tonight. Okay. So if there's that in the public hearing, there may be other requests, and if there are, we can address those. Okay. I think, you know, maybe just –
1:41:59 On this specifically, I mean, that kind of the direction as we established the joint bucket was, hey, MLT, go through your process, establish some items that you think are worthy of consideration, bring them before the council. But we didn't really articulate.
1:42:13 Beyond that of, you know, what would be the correct process to do that. So maybe we could provide some guidance on that or, hey, the request has kind of come in, so let's agendize it for the next meeting, do some analysis, that type of thing. I think what I'm kind of hearing is let's agendize that for the first meeting. Yeah, we need to do it for the 20th pending. That's going to be a... 20th might be a tough meeting. If not, it could be the first meeting in July that we have. But I don't think it impacts the budget operations that they've adopted, but...
1:42:40 Definitely impacts some of it. Also, MLT was saying, look, these are things that maybe get done this summer, so you don't want to be delaying it on and on. Yeah, I mean, it's relatively time sensitive, but that's what I was just kind of looking at. I mean, obviously, fish stocking is a summer thing, and the request around the trolley is actually to extend it out. I mean, the Measure U funding, the 7,500, kind of gives them July 4th, but they're proposing to do it for an elongated time period that would start.
1:43:09 You know, they're like, well, we're ready tomorrow if we have funding and run that through September. So there is a bit of a time-sensitive nature around it, but it's not like it has to happen tonight. Okay, so let's maybe Dan, you and John can get together and figure out what's the best way to bring this forward. We're interested. We want to discuss about it, but do it in the right way. Okay. Okay, so if there's anything, thoughts from the public on a scintillating, somewhat noise-infected budget discussion.
1:43:38 If there's nothing else, then I think we're going to take a break, and we'll be back here at 6 o'clock to get started with our regular meeting. Thank you all very much. Thank you. My story has been offended. No, not offended at all. Okay. Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to this regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for June 6, 2018.
1:45:20 I would like to ask Linda Salcido, she who garnered the most votes in the recent Town Council election, to lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank you, Linda. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Linda. Congratulations. You and Kirk. You.
1:45:53 And to me, yes, but I don't know if I congratulate myself. Congratulations to you. Yeah, thank you. Okay. Yeah, thank you all. Thanks, everybody, for participating in that. I think we'll turn to public comments first. And, Dan, you've got a couple updates to share. Yeah, if I may on one, some of you may be aware we had a shooting earlier today in town. I just wanted to note the...
1:46:17 Press release from the District Attorney's Office. I know there's a lot of scuttlebutt going out and about, but hopefully this will clear up some of it. I'll tell you what we do know, what's going on. It was 11.25 a.m. today. The Mammoth Lakes Police Department, Monaco County District Attorney's Office, responded to a 911 call from an individual who had been shot in his residence located on Hillside Drive in Mammoth Lakes. Upon arriving at the scene, they were met outside by the reporting party who had been shot in the stomach.
1:46:47 The reporting party indicated he was shot by another male in the residence but was able to wrestle control the gun away from him and return fire. The reporting party was transported to Mammoth Hospital, stabilized, and transported to Reno. Law enforcement has secured the scene. They were waiting for a forensic team to arrive to process the scene. They're in the process of doing that now. The other individual remains in the residence time is presumed dead.
1:47:13 They did go into the residence and in fact the person was deceased. I'm sorry, what was that last sentence? The person is deceased. The officers did go into the residence. They had to get a search warrant process to go in. So at this point the scene is? It's secured. It will stay that way all night. It is a crime scene so it will be secured for some time to come. But there's no additional?
1:47:39 Activity of any violent nature going on? Correct. No, there's nobody running around with a gun, for example. Okay. I know people are concerned about something. It's, yeah, it's secured. Well, it's sad and difficult news, but thanks for sharing that. And then, I guess on a, I'll say a little, maybe a happier note, real quick is just touching on some of the election activity as it impacts us and the things that we work with and partner with. I'm just kind of going off of the preliminary. None of this has been certified or final, so.
1:48:08 The superintendent of schools, I'm not even sure if that's very close to call, Stacey Adler is up by basically 20 votes to win that race. Supervisor District 1 for Mono County, Jennifer Hauferty is 68% of the vote cast for her, so assuming that holds, that would be a win in the primary and no runoff. For Supervisory District 5, Stacey Corliss.
1:48:34 Just over 71% of the vote, so she would have the same issue as a straight winner for that seat. For Town Council, you've already noted, just Mr. Wentworth, Ms. Salcido, and Kirk Stapp are the top three vote getters in the current numbers, so those three would be moving into the Town Council.
1:48:57 Proposition 68, which the town did vote to support, this is statewide, that's the parks, water, et cetera, bond, passed with a 56% vote at this point across the state. That actually will bring some dollars into the Sierra Nevada region, and I believe it's a $200,000 minimum allocation into the town of Mammoth Lakes and $400,000 into the county.
1:49:21 Proposition 69, which secures the use of gas tax funding for the purposes of which it was enacted for, passed with 80.4% of the vote at this point. Proposition 70 was a no vote, 63.6%. And Dan, just to be clear, the numbers you're reading are from the county? No, that's the statewide numbers. Those are the statewide numbers, okay. I've got both here, but...
1:49:46 I went and pulled the state information to look at those. They may have changed a little bit because they were still updating websites. So 69 passed with 80% of the vote? Yes. Wow. Proposition 70 was a no vote, 63%. Proposition 71 was a yes vote at 76.8. The county votes are close to these, actually. A little bit percentage point off and a different a little bit.
1:50:12 Proposition 72, a yes, 83.3. The other two tax measures in special districts here, Measure A in the fire district, required a 66.67% approval. It did not attain that, so it failed. It did have a support in...
1:50:32 The town of 59.87%, but it needed the two-thirds plus to pass. Measure B for the schools, which needed a 55% or better support to pass, did pass with 62.6. So the bond measure, measure B, passed for our school district. And there was two cannabis questions on the ballot, one for the town of Mammoth Lakes and one for the county. Both of those passed, the Mammoth Lakes at the 82.8.
1:51:01 Two percent in measure D for the county at 79, almost 0.8 percent. Although the town measure will be wiped out completely if a particular ballot measure that's likely to hit the November ballot is passed by the voters. Sorry, for the cannabis tax? Yeah. Yeah, there's an especially pernicious ballot measure that is...
1:51:21 Awaiting signature verification, and they're hoping to get it on. The proponents are for November, and if it passes, it will retroactively invalidate all general taxes passed during 2018. Oh, it's that thing. That one, yeah, the business roundtable push, yeah. And this is happening in Sacramento? Yeah, statewide initiative. Where is Sacramento? Well, it's statewide. This was a... Where is this place? Yeah, this was initiated by the business roundtable. It wasn't a state initiated. And they have a...
1:51:49 Requisite number of signatures to be verified at this point. They're still verifying the signature numbers, but it's expected that they will have enough signatures. That measure is primarily backed by the beverage industry in response to the number of soda taxes passed in California cities. Okay, we're not going to go there. Thank you very much. Thank you, Dan. Any additional public comment this evening? Plastic bags all over again. Shira, nice t-shirt. Thank you.
1:52:17 So I wanted to give a wrap-up report on the film festival and the end of the year of my season. So as you know, we hired PR firm BWR, which is a very well-known PR firm in Hollywood. And from the media that they brought, I just kind of want to go over some of the impression numbers that we received. From variety.com, they did a...
1:52:46 They did three different posts that got 6.5 million impressions each. We had some smaller media like LATFUSA, that's Los Angeles Television and Film USA. They have about 13 million. AwardsDaily.com had 701,000, almost three quarters of a million. FilmFestivals.com had 55.
1:53:12 Variety.com, again, I said they had three. Movie Maker Magazine had almost 150,000 impressions. The Facebook page for Variety that they did, their post, got 1.2 million. Their Twitter page got 2.1 million. Lindsay Barr from Associated Press, just on her own personal Twitter account, stated she's feeling Mammoth Lakes Film Festival. She really loved it, had a great time.
1:53:42 She had over 4,000, and KCRW had half a million. Our biggest impressions was from IMBD, which had 187,484,000 impressions. So with that said,
1:54:02 The festival, you know, really grew tremendously this year. Last year we had 80 filmmakers, this year we had actually 140. Some of those filmmakers came from Israel, Sweden. We had two different films that attended from Australia, which equaled three, actually four filmmakers, because two each. India, the Netherlands, Mexico, Canada, Poland, and many other places.
1:54:27 They came from all across America also. We added two panel discussions this year, which had a huge turnout. Our Fridays Meet the Press panel had 75 filmmakers in attendance in the Saturday morning. From production to distribution panel had 100 filmmakers present, which I was so happy because I was so nervous about them.
1:54:46 We hired BWRP, our firm, and they had a hand in getting Variety, Vanity Fair, Associated Press, Huffington Post, The Wrap, Movie Maker Magazine, and many other media at the festival, covering and participating in the fest. This year, we had more North American and international premieres and West Coast premieres than ever. We had films like Damsel, Love, Gilda, White Tide, and many more, which are going on to major distribution through Netflix, and Magnolia Pictures picked up Damsel and Love, Gilda.
1:55:16 We gave our Sierra Spirit Award to Academy Award winning actress Melissa Leo and had a very engaged Q&A. It actually got a little controversial at one moment, but I think I brought it down. We had over 342 room nights just from the people that we brought. So that doesn't include the people that actually came to the festival that weren't part of our filmmakers or jury and press people.
1:55:44 We had 285 pass holders, which all attended about 4 to 10 screenings each. And then we had 300 non-pass holder participants that all went to about 1 to 2 screening each, so that comes to about 600 participants.
1:56:00 I'm very happy with the outcome of the festival. I think it's going to grow tremendously again next year. Just with hiring BWR, we do have a two-year grant to hire them and keep them on, and they loved it so much. A lot of the press that came were even asking some of their other people, they're like, can you get Shira to bring us back? And Vanity Fair was one of them who really wants to come back, and they all just had such a great time.
1:56:27 I'd also like to give a wrap-up for the MLRT season. So last year, we're kind of wrapping up our entire season, and the film festival is part of that season. So our 2017-18 season, we had a record-breaking year in attracting the highest number of audience attendants since 2009. We also partnered with two other performing arts organizations, a co-production with Sierra Classic Theater, Last of the Red Hot Lovers, and a co-production with the Eastern Sierra Symphony with A Night of Cabaret.
1:56:56 And both co-productions proved to be a huge success. We produced so 15 separate events. Our audience numbers reached more than 8,100. And we had more sold out nights than ever before where our average capacity was always at about 81%.
1:57:16 And this year's success could not have happened without the support and generosity of all our donors and patrons. And we are truly making a community more fulfilling place to live. And I want to thank the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Recreation, Measure U for the support that they gave. And we're really looking forward to our 2018-19 season. So thank you all for all your support. I really appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Shira. Thank you, Shira. Okay, who's going to top Shira?
1:57:50 No applause. I'm Ken Bringle, Executive Director of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Just want to remind everybody about the customer service training we have going tomorrow and Friday. It's free training for frontline staff. If those of you who were able to attend last September, we had Joe Zulaika, who's kind of a management employee training expert.
1:58:16 She's returning for kind of a 2.0 version. Going to be talking about, with the front line, talking about burnout and resilient tactics, how to get, if you're getting beat up all day long, how you overcome all that. And that is free. Both the front line sessions are free. And then we have for managers and supervisors and owners, we have Thursday training on value alignment.
1:58:44 Having, looking at the values of your business and having your employees look at their values and how they all tie together. The, the, that includes a luncheon is $25 for members and $35 for non-members. The management luncheon will be tomorrow from 11.30 to 2 and this is all at the Village Lodge Grand Sierra meeting rooms.
1:59:07 And then the frontline staff is 3.30 to 6 tomorrow and then Friday morning 9 to 11.30. So I've got some extra copies. I'll put them in the back. If anybody wants to take them with them, they'll be there. But we really encourage everybody to send their frontline staff and help us with our customer service training. Thank you. Excellent. Thank you. Anybody else? Greg Newbury, I just wanted to take this opportunity to thank you so much for your support on Measure B.
1:59:42 Individually and as a group. I don't know how many times all of us use your names saying the Town Council supports it. Bill's name I used over and over again. Bill Sauser supports it. It's got to be good. So I really think you played an instrumental part in the passage of Measure B in Forest Schools. And I just wanted to say thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Hello. Brandon Brocio. Local. Almost.
2:00:19 Just want to say congratulations to everyone that ran. John, congratulations. And also thank you so much for Shields and Colin. Loved having you guys up there. One quick topic. I know I'm beating a dead horse here, but I actually have some vested interest in Old Mammoth Road now. Can we try to get a plan together so we can get a consistent look on getting a little bit of
2:00:49 Just landscaping on that road. As a business owner, I'd feel comfortable paying for it and making it uniform to my property, but that might not be uniform to the property next to me, so on and so forth. And then all of a sudden we end up with like a hodgepodge of everyone doing their own thing. So we could put a plan together just to get it on paper. So if somebody asks anybody at the town office, hey, yeah, use X, Y, and Z material, X, Y, and Z bush.
2:01:16 If you put something alive in, water it, that'd be great. That's all I was going to say. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, anybody else? Evening. Council, Mayor, staff, community members, I'm honored to be here before you to recognize an outstanding individual. Mr. Hayden Manator is going to come up and we'll kind of talk a little bit about Hayden for his diligence and hard work saving life at the Whitmore Track last week.
2:01:54 We're going to have Aidan come up. With me as well is paramedic Mike Shahar. So Mike's going to come up. Mike was the... Thank you. Mike was the responding paramedic who had a really easy job once he got there. Thank you.
2:02:20 And then Cassandra Mance is here. We're going to talk a little bit about after the presentation, a little bit about the AED program throughout the town and the county. And it's also very fitting and ironic that June 1st to the 7th is actually National CPR and AED Awareness Week. So very fitting. Just a little bit of background kind of on the incident if you're not kind of aware what happened. This was on May 29th, Tuesday a week ago, approximately 7.30. Visiting member of the Mammoth Track Club.
2:02:47 Experienced a heart attack at the track. Medical personnel who were actually training with the club at that time commenced CPR and then bystanders were sent to the Whitmore Pool, as I know that was open during that time for lap swim to request the use of the AED. Hayden, so our new assistant aquatic site coordinator at the Whitmore Pool, responded, grabbed the first responder bag, the AED, and within six minutes assessed the patient, deployed the AED by delivering a shock.
2:03:17 Heart rhythm was re-established and then Mike and his paramedic team arrived shortly thereafter assuming control of the situation. So, I mean, that's a pretty big deal. So Hayden's pivotal involvement in helping save a life is truly to be graduated and recognised and is so much indicative of his knowledge, maturity and composure under pressure. It's also a testament to the life-saving capabilities of the AEDs.
2:03:41 And the immeasurable value of regular in-service training undertaken by all Whitmore Pool staff, Parks Recreation staff and so forth. In summary, the town could not be proud of Hayden's response to his incident and ultimately contributing to saving a life, which not many times you can actually say that. So truly honoured. So Hayden did a great job. Or he says he's just probably doing his job. I get it. That's a hell of a job. We really appreciate it.
2:04:09 I would ask that at this time the Mayor and Council maybe pose for a photo with Hayden in front of the dais and then we'll have Mike and then Cassie talk a little bit about the program that's ongoing. Stu, I never take photos but I never take this one. Thank you. Better be on the front page.
2:04:46 All right, Colin, turn around. All right, Stu, come on. Rest closer like you need it. Hey, Colin, stand up. All right, thank you. Thank you. Stand up a little longer. Cassandra Manns, Human Resources Manager. I just wanted to take this opportunity, obviously,
2:05:18 To not only show my support for Hayden and say what a wonderful job he's done, but also just to reiterate some of the stuff that Stu said and give you a little bit of an update on the town's AED program. The program was implemented in 2014. At that time we placed about 10 AEDs in various town-owned locations, obviously Whitmore Pool being one. Since then we've had...
2:05:42 Obviously, two very courageous employees who have had to administer an AED. One time, unfortunately, too late to save a life, but the most recent time, obviously, a huge success. If you've ever had any experience operating an AED, you'll know that they're pretty user-friendly and that they give pretty clear automated instructions as soon as you turn them on. However, I have a feeling that operating them...
2:06:03 Isn't actually that easy when you're under that kind of pressure. So every year we offer CPR training and that contains an AED component. We offer that to all of our employees, including our temporary and seasonal employees. And I certainly understand that this type of training can often seem pretty mundane and it can often be considered, like any training, a significant expense that the town has to absorb. But it's great to see so many town employees eager to participate and become trained and certified. And obviously this commitment pays off greatly.
2:06:33 I pulled up the map here. We've been working with Mono County IT to work with GIS and have our AEDs pinned on this map. We've only got a few up there now. We've got lots in other locations, but everyone has access to this, and eventually everyone will be able to have a look and see where all of our AEDs are all over town.
2:06:53 Something else I just wanted to touch on briefly, the cost of the AED equipment. It's not just a one-time cost. The equipment requires maintenance, replacement batteries and pads. We've been lucky enough to be able to absorb this into our regular budget, and we are certainly committed to continuing to do so. However, as the recent event has shown...
2:07:10 It's crucial that we have AEDs in as many town locations as possible, and so I'd like to consider slowly developing our program to incorporate more equipment and more locations, and to continue to place such a heavy emphasis on training for employees and helping them to feel comfortable using the equipment. So I hope to be able to look at perhaps potential grants and other sources of funding for something like this, but most importantly I just wanted to reiterate the town's commitment to continuing to invest in the program.
2:07:37 Since the town implemented our program, the Mammoth Lakes Police Department was able to obtain funding for some new AEDs, and I was hoping to have Lieutenant Hulman here to talk briefly about the new equipment that they have obtained and how they're managing their program. But as you know, duty calls tonight. So I hope you'll be able to come back to council at a later date, hopefully with the police department and provide a more thorough update and let you know about any progress that we can make and hopefully be able to show a more detailed map with...
2:08:06 All of our many AEDs that we're going to have over town. Thank you very much. They invited me just to speak a little bit about AEDs, and I just want to touch on a couple things. Obviously, what we have with the AED program, it's called the chain of survival. And so, as with any chain, if any of the links are broken, it's not going to work correctly, right? So, fortunately for us, the chains of survival happened the other day, right as they should have. We got early bystander CPR.
2:08:35 Hayden was the second link in that chain, and he was able to bring the AED and attach it properly, and he was able to defibrillate the patient. Then we were able to come and do what we do to continue on that chain of survival. Obviously, the AED program that you guys are implementing, as well as the one in the county, is going to make a big difference for us. I have a couple cold, hard facts for you guys, and that's basically anyone that goes into sudden cardiac death.
2:09:02 Typically has about six to eight minutes previous to brain death. So you have a six to eight minute window to get there, begin CPR, and get a defibrillation going. So, you know, being that we're in an area that has so many square miles, obviously most fire departments will cover about roughly four square miles in the city. Since Melinda County's 1,200 square miles, we're pretty rural. So if you divide that up amongst our four departments, or our four medic units,
2:09:30 You know, we ultimately have about 300 square miles along with the volunteer departments to cover per section. So it's going to be really up to the community to help us keep this link in the chain of survival going by getting that early bystander CPR and getting the AEDs around the county. So what I would say is I just would encourage anyone to take a CPR class because, you know, CPR is scary.
2:09:58 And everyone thinks about the stranger that they're doing CPR on, but in a small community like this, chances are it's going to be your friend, your neighbor, or your family. So everyone get CPR trained and let's keep this AED program rolling because what's going to happen is it's going to enable us to do our job. Good. Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. Thanks, guys. Thank you all. Congratulations. Well done. Nice job.
2:10:29 Just a quick update on the patient, Jerry. Andrew Castor's been in touch with him, with Dina. He's recovered, he's out of renown, and he's probably going to be welcomed back to the track very shortly. Awesome. Amazing recovery. So thank you very much. Nice work. Thank you all very much. Any further public comment this evening? Okay. So we'll move on then to any additions to the agenda. Dan? No, there's no additional additions. Okay. And then so reports of commissions or departments. Who's going to go first?
2:11:06 We got some questions. Up here comes Joel. Thank you. Good evening. Thank you, Councilmembers. Joel Rathje, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Trails Coordinator. Just wanted to report out some good information about this past weekend. We had the biggest Trail Day event in the history of the Trail Day program over the last 10 years. We had about 110 volunteers show up. We painted bathrooms. We did trail maintenance, cleaned up litter, and all kinds of things. It was really good.
2:11:35 Also, July 14th is our next event. We have not chosen a location, but mark your calendars, July 14th, we'll have another trail day event. And then switching gears a bit, on the e-bike subject, just want to give a brief update from our last report out on the agenda a few weeks ago. You provided direction to engage with the Forest Service.
2:11:59 And we're doing that. Also, we have mobilized and placed signs all throughout the non-motorized trail system at all entry points. We've been coordinating with stakeholders like MMSA and Forest Service. I do have a strong draft of a one-sheet fact sheet that we're going to share with all the stores, agencies, anyone who wants it. It will articulate very clearly where people can go.
2:12:27 What facilities they can use and things like that so that people have clarity when they go rent an e-bike or ride an e-bike. So that's forthcoming. I need a couple more approvals from stakeholders on that handout, but it's a real strong handout. I'm hoping it'll land on Friday or so. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. Any questions for Joel? It's fair to say that this e-bike program is going to be an ongoing...
2:12:55 Sort of rapidly changing thing over the course of the summer, I would imagine. Is that fair to say? Yeah, I think we'll be responding to things as they arise. It's sort of a unique thing, not completely unique in America, but we are in the forefront of the introduction of the technology. Okay, good. All right, well, thank you very much. Thank you. Yep.
2:13:20 Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. Just to follow on Joel's e-bike item, we will be having a Mobility Committee meeting on Tuesday, June 12th at 1 o'clock in the Town and County Conference Room. The group will be discussing e-bikes, and Joel will be giving a presentation on e-bikes.
2:13:38 And Mammoth Lakes Recreation will also be giving a presentation on a bike share program, ideas for bike share programs. So that's next Tuesday, the 12th, 1 o'clock in the Town and County Conference Room. Sandra, do you anticipate any further policy needs from the council in terms of e-bikes and bicycles on sidewalks and those kinds of things going as part of this whole thing? This is all living within the walk, bike, ride program, correct? Right, right. I mean, I think that's probably a question better addressed.
2:14:04 By Joel, because I think he's kind of taking the lead on the e-bike policies and those types of things, and I don't know if you want to respond, Joel. Excuse me, what was the question? I'm just wondering about, we're dealing with e-bikes on sidewalks. I know they're legal, and this will be part of your roll-up, but I'm just wondering, as part of the Walk, Bike, Ride program, looking at the e-bike thing, the status of e-bikes on sidewalks. I don't imagine you have a policy yet, but this may be something that may need to come back to Council for some clarification.
2:14:35 I just, I don't know, but I'm hoping that we're going to be dealing with this with as much alackery as possible. My understanding of present policy is no bike is allowed on sidewalks. We see them all around, but my understanding is that bikes in Mammoth Lakes are not allowed on sidewalks, whether e-bike or non-e-bike, it's a bike. Okay, we'll look forward to getting that cleared up as we go forward because this is going to be something, this is a tsunami that's coming our way. We want to be, we want to be,
2:15:04 On the right side of things and looking forward to this walk, bike, ride effort and getting some clarifications for policy going forward. One thing I could add to that is that Caltrans informed us a couple weeks ago at the LTC meeting that they do defer to local municipalities and counties on how we regulate sidewalks. Okay. So there is some discretion for council to make some policy decisions? Correct. Okay. Good. Thank you. Anything else? No, that was it.
2:15:29 Good. Thank you. And my understanding is that there's some relatives of town staff that actually have some e-bikes sitting, not being used in a storage unit somewhere in Southern California that maybe if we could get them up here, staff would have access. It's possible. It's a possibility. I'm working on it. Okay, good. All right. If anybody's going to Southern California, get in touch with Sandra. Thank you. Yeah. Thank you. Hypothetically. Hypothetically. Hypothetically. Hypothetically. Okay. Any other reports or commissions?
2:15:58 Sorry, reports from departments or commissions. Stuart Brown again, Parks Recreation Department. Thank you. Couple of items. Summer is here. With summer comes a new playground. If you've driven past Mammoth Creek Park recently, you notice the playground's not there anymore. It's okay. Don't panic. We're putting in a new one. We start on June 11th. Probably seeing the flyers around town. We have posters, flyers, a lot of information. We have a great sign-up genius being...
2:16:23 Great, great response from our community. Really want to thank everybody for contributing either their time, their in-kind, their donation. Matt just said there's $3,000 raised just through the, you know, the little community fundraising program, which is fantastic. Thank you. So each and every additional money is we'll be able to kind of expand that playground, make sure we can add the accessible surfacing and all the inclusive components that the community desires. So if you're still interested in contributing to the build, you get a beautiful high visibility t-shirt.
2:16:52 We'll feed you lunch, and you can wear the T-shirt at Halloween. We start on Monday, June 11, so it's coming up quickly, and then we'll wrap up on June 22. Just a couple of other items. The Whitmore Pool opens to the public for the full season on Saturday, June 16. So with our opening comes a free swim day. So if you want to come down after noon, come on down there. That'll be great. Just a couple of other items as well. Tennis Court Rehabilitation Project finishes tomorrow.
2:17:19 So those courts will be opened up this weekend to the public. So if you want to get up there and actually, you know, enjoy a beautiful, smooth surface, that would be a good opportunity. And then Shady Rest Park, if you've been out to the park, thank you for everybody's patience and understanding. Those projects are wrapping up as well this week as well. So with summer right around the corner, we're very well prepared for the influx of our many visitors and our wonderful community. Good. Thank you. Any questions for Stu? Good. Thank you very much. Any other commissions or departments?
2:17:50 Okay, seeing none, I guess we're going to move on now to an introduction, and Dan, you're going to be introducing somebody. Multiple duty this evening. Officer Logan McCutcheon, come on up if you want, Logan, and you can have the rest of the folks from the department come up with you too. Our officers are a bit busy, so he's on his own. I think he's used to that.
2:18:25 Don't use anybody we got from the department here. So you've met Officer McCutcheon before, or Logan. He was sworn in as a reserve officer back in January of this year.
2:18:38 And then we had a recent resignation, so we had a vacancy department, and so he was on our hire list from that, and we'd already had a good test run to know that he was going to be a great officer for us, and so we brought him on for full time into the department. He was raised in Ventura County, and his mother has told us, and mom and dad are here, so that he wanted to be a first responder ever since he was a young man.
2:19:04 He actually had a response a few hours ago, but he's here instead. Thank you. Some of the issues, all of our officers were called out earlier on that. He's been coming to Mammoth Lakes since he was a year old. I think his parents had something to do with that. They're longtime visitors from Mammoth and love the area here and are glad to have their son here give them another reason to come and visit up here in God's country.
2:19:31 He was very happy and was brought on to MLPD as a reserve and then obviously filling this position. He had a stint with Los Angeles PD prior to that and also, excuse me, a couple other stints and first responders. He tried as being an EMT. Is our paramedic still here? Okay, get the better job. In terms of moving in with the police department there.
2:19:56 And then also Santa Barbara PD for a stint also back in 2016. So it's exciting to have him here. He takes a lot of enthusiasm in his work, his professionalism. He's had a little bear incident. I think he was chased by a bear at the Shiloh Inn one evening. Looks like he didn't get the best of you.
2:20:19 Fortunately. And then also he has received a letter of accommodation already from his for superior performance as a reserve officer and coming on in February a year a few months back. It actually his work resulted in a felony criminal charges being upheld and filed. Continues to represent the department in the town with pride and you'll notice he gets up here he has a great smile so that helps us in our tourism economy as he
2:20:47 People are glad to pay their tickets when they're given one. Several of our officers are obviously the chief and lieutenant and some of our sergeants would love to be here this evening and have actually planned on being here, but obviously duty takes priority, so they are out doing their deal. But we do want to welcome Officer Kutchen in as a full-scale officer versus reserve officer, so I'm going to say congratulations.
2:21:19 Town Clerk will swear you in, and I believe your mother is going to change out your badge and give you a real one, and be able to bring you on as our officer here, and you can introduce your mom and dad once that's complete.
2:21:48 Thank you, ma'am.
2:22:26 I'm waiting for the ouch. Thank you, sir. Thank you, sir. Good to see you again.
2:23:19 Thank you so much. Give Logan a chance to say a comment and formally introduce his parents. Okay. To everyone here, thank you, Town Council. Thank you to the city. Thank you to everyone here. That was my father, Charles, my mother, Colleen. Like they said, we've been coming up here since I was crawling around. I'm very grateful to be here. The town speaks for itself.
2:23:59 Met more people in the short amount of time I've been here than I think any other place in my life. So thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Welcome. So we're going to move on now to item number three, a staff presentation, a presentation by Mammoth Lakes Tourism related to Alaska Airlines' announcement of discontinuation of service to Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers, so I can keep this succinct.
2:24:38 Back on May 17th, with very short notice, we had a conversation with Alaska Airlines, where they informed us that they'll be discontinuing our service with the Q400 after our summer service ends November 30th. Basically, what they mentioned was that they're phasing out the Q400. It doesn't just affect Mammoth Lakes. Sun Valley, Idaho, Pascoe in Bellingham, Washington, as well as Eugene, Oregon, are also affected by this retirement of the planes. And really, it's the only...
2:25:06 And so the E-175 is not good for the elevation and the heat, nor does it have the RNP, which we've talked about in the past, the navigation setup.
2:25:32 So last fall we had a meeting up in Seattle with Alaska, Kent Myers, who's our air consultant, myself and Eric Clark, and we had been hearing more about the phasing out of the Q400. At that time we had also heard about the staffing challenges that they had with pilots.
2:25:50 At that point, so we went up to have a meeting with them. At that point, we were basically told that we probably had about five years with the Q400 before it was going to get phased out. They also felt that because we're a subsidy market, because we pay the subsidy, that that would give us a little bit more time with it. Obviously, it didn't. So at this point, we've had discussions with multiple airlines, multiple of the legacy carriers, the large airlines out there, to basically work on our
2:26:17 I've got a couple questions. And I, you know, this is
2:26:49 You know, we're going to have, as the town, we're primarily in the airport business. That's primarily what we do. The air service is something that MLT and others get involved with, and that's appropriate. But obviously, we're going to, you know, this may have budgetary effects. We talked about this data in the budget discussion. And it's obviously, I'm sure it was a shock to you and your organization, certainly a shock to us and a shock to many people in the community. And as we try to absorb this shock and try to figure out kind of what's going on,
2:27:19 There are a couple things that I think just need to be kind of pointed out. I think that it's a little disappointing that the notification, I mean, this was out in the public, there's a lot of rumors flying around, and it really took a while to get an official notice out. And I think it will be, as we get into these kinds of events, this causes a lot of angst and concern the community, I think.
2:27:41 Probably trying to be more proactive and get some messaging out to the public sooner I think would be helpful. I think there's also an ongoing kind of conversation about as we move into these discussions about air service and Bishop and doing these kinds of things to really understand for the public's benefit who owns the air service program.
2:28:00 I'm not asking to necessarily answer that question now. But it's very important with the kind of money, and we'll be talking about the T-bid later, to really, for the public to feel that there's accountability somewhere, that there is someone who, there's an organization that owns this thing. And when things get difficult and surprise announcements happen, we're not dealing with, well, it's this or that or somebody else. And I would just, you know,
2:28:27 Advise the board and MLT to, as we move into these discussions, to help clarify for the public and the council, everybody else, who really owns the air service program, especially as we get into, if we do the feasibility analysis and there's some possibility of moving things to Bishop, that it is clear not just to the citizens of Mammoth Lakes, but to the entire region, who owns the air service program, who's accountable for it, what are going to be the financial expectations and those kinds of things.
2:28:53 I certainly appreciate you coming here today and talking and sharing this with the community and the public. But I think as we go forward, there's going to be a variety of different discussions going forward and to help us all really understand and be clear about how this works and who's responsible for what. Sure. Yeah. That's fair. Any other thoughts or questions? No? Thank you. Thank you very much. All right. Yep. Okay. So we'll move on now to the consent agenda.
2:29:22 And so I will read the items in the consent agenda. I'll try to do it in a way that is understandable. If anybody from council, the public wants to pull an item, just let us know. So number four, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of May 16, 2018.
2:29:38 Number five, award the annual contract for publication of legal notices to the sheet. Number six, approve a one-year extension of the agreement with Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access, MLTPA. Number seven, adopt the resolution authorizing the temporary closure of Canyon Boulevard between Hillside Drive and Lake Murray Road for the Mammoth Motor Bash on June 23, 2018 between 11 a.m. and 10 p.m. Number eight, adopt the resolution authorizing road closures for the Mammoth Half Marathon to be held on June 17, 2018. Number nine, adopt the resolution authorizing
2:30:08 Temporary Closure of Main Street, South Frontage Road adjacent to the luxury outlet mall for Skip's Farmer's Market between the hours of 3 p.m. and 8 p.m. each Wednesday beginning July 4th and ending October 24th, 2018. Number 10, adopt the resolution providing for a reimbursable grant of $90,000 to support the 2018 Bluesapalooza Mammoth Festival of Beers event to Mammoth Brewing Company. Number 11.
2:30:32 Accept payment approval report number 18-54 in the amount of $193,238.87, $18.15, $423,513.39, and in the report number 18-56, the amount of $164,229.67. So those are the items for the consent agenda. Does anybody wish to pull anything? Yeah, I'd like to pull number 10. Number 10, okay. Anybody else?
2:31:02 No public staff. Okay, so Jamie, I would entertain a motion from the council to... I will make a motion to approve consent agenda items 4 through 9 and 11. I'll second. Thank you. Any further discussion? I will recuse myself from a vote on number 6. I serve on the board of directors of the MLTPA Foundation.
2:31:32 Any further discussion? Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The ayes have agreed to unanimously with one recusal on number six. So item number 10, Shields. Yeah. Thank you, John. The reason I wanted to pull that is I wanted to give props to Mammoth Brewing Beers for what they did last year. They came and asked the town for money.
2:32:02 Paid it all back. So I just want to give a shout out to Sean Turner over there and Mammoth Brewing. And that's why I'm going to ask that we approve this particular consent agenda item. But I just wanted to pull that out and say thank you very much because that shows a lot of class for doing that, Sean. So I'd make a motion to approve item number 10.
2:32:29 The consent agenda. Good. Thank you. I'll second. Any further discussion? Hearing none, roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Item is agreed to 5-0. So we'll now move on to the public hearings. And the first one is number 12, approve the resolution declaring the results of majority protest proceedings and renewing the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District.
2:32:57 And staff, is this Dan or is this John? Yeah, I'll do a quick introduction and then the details, the MLT staff and board members that are here can speak to it as well as need be. On April 18th, the council received a submission of a written petition to move forward with the formation. They had more than 50% of the businesses in favor of...
2:33:20 Basically extending the T-bid starting in September 1st, I believe it would be the first date for a five-year, initially it was a 10-year period, their recommendation at this point is for a five-year period to move forward. Based on that, receiving that initial approval process, the resolution of intent was approved, information was mailed out to all the various business regarding
2:33:42 The other steps, one was a public hearing to receive any comments that the council has held, and then for this formalized public hearing today where the item would be considered by town council if the resolution of formation is adopted by the council and it would move forward with an effective date of September 1, 2018 and extend through August 31, 2023. So we're in that process now. The assumption would be that, again, you have to have
2:34:12 Majority support of 50% or more of support of it, and there's actually a negative checkoff in terms of the language you'll see there, but to have that. Once per year, if there's an issue on that, the anniversary of MLTB renewal, there could be a 30-day period which businesses could challenge that at that point in time if they, again, in that total of 50% or more. So there is a check each year that businesses can do as well as in the approval process going forward.
2:34:40 In addition to the resolution, you do have a staff report that provides information prepared primarily through Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and then also the resolution and district management plan that also has additional information related to the proposal. The review of this was done partly by outside counsel Michael Colantano, I believe, is the attorney in the firm Civitas, if I'm saying the name correctly, who have worked on numerous
2:35:09 Types of assessment districts and stuff. So we have that outside review as well as Mr. Morris from the town attorney side. The proceeding process to go through this is you open the public hearing and go through that process. You'll need the clerk to get you information related to the number of petitions received in opposition or not. So there's a process that we can follow through that. But I would invite, unless there's particular questions of
2:35:37 Kind of the introduction, I'd invite John Urdi to speak to the details that are in the staff reporting the information, and then I know there's a number of board members from MLT if they wish to speak as well. Okay, so I think what I'll do is I'll open the public hearing. Yes. And, John, you can speak as kind of the staff representative of this, but there may be questions for town staff and town legal as well, and we'll just lump that in as part of the staff. And, Jamie, if any particular procedural things you want me to make sure I cover as we go through this? No. No? Okay.
2:36:06 Good. So we're going to open the public hearing. And, John, tell us what we need to know. Okay, again, thank you. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So back when we put the initial TBID in place back in 2013, we had the opportunity to – we felt that it was an opportunity to gain ground on our competitors in the state. At that time, we were the 80th TBID in the state of California. There are now, I believe, 101 in the state. And what we found when we put it in place was not only –
2:36:32 When we thought we were going for something that was going to give us a leg up, it was really something to keep us competitive with the remainder of the state. So the folks in Los Angeles are trying to get everybody from San Diego and San Francisco to come visit them. Everybody in San Diego is trying to get Los Angeles to visit them. And we're all competing for the same folks. So when we put this in place, we had anticipated that we would see results. When we were asked about that, we anticipated that we would see results from the spending within 12 to 18 months of when we put the money into the marketplace.
2:37:00 So the TBID went into place on September 1st of 2013. We started spending the funds in May of 2014. Fast forward 13 months to June of 2015, we started breaking all of our TOT records by month, minimum of 20%. Some of them broke the record up to 30%. And that kept on for really for three years. And we saw the increased impact.
2:37:25 The 10-year average for our TOT collection for town from 2004-5 to 2014-15 was $10.5 million a year. So it was pretty steady. It was $9 million here, $11 million here, $10 million. It just kind of bounced back and forth between those numbers. And when we got to fiscal 2015-16, we saw a spike to $15.7 million. Last year, we saw the spike to $18.1 million. Right now, through April,
2:37:49 We're at 16.1 million. So this year, even though we have two more months left to the end of the fiscal year, it's our second best TOT year ever. So we've seen this nice pattern. Obviously, this winter, we did not have the best snow, but we still had the results. I think when you look at the off-season, if you look at the months that are still under the million dollars, they're still under a million dollars, but they're growing leaps and bounds as we move forward. So big opportunity there, and we continue to see that impact.
2:38:18 So with the management district plan that we're asking to approve tonight for the resolution of formation, as I've mentioned in a couple of previous meetings, we do have some adjustments to that. After talking with the business community, we took the 10-year term that we were looking for and dropped it down to a five-year term. So basically we're asking for the five-year term from September 1, 2018 through August 31, 2023. The other thing that we did was based on the
2:38:44 Recent acquisition of Mammoth Mountain and the addition of the Icon Pass, which they're selling at all of the 13 resorts that they own and another, I think, 10 resorts on top of that. They're not charging taxes on top of that when they're selling them at any of the resorts. The 2% that the mountain contributes has been voluntary. I think that's one of the things that we need to make sure everybody understands is that when we put this together in 2013, we originally came out saying we want to do lodging, restaurant, and retail.
2:39:12 All of our businesses live and die on tourism. And then the mountain came in and said, listen, we're willing to throw in 2% if it goes towards air service. And at the time we put in the 2%, they paid it on lift tickets, ski school, and season pass revenue. Because it's voluntary, they came back to us this year and they said, listen, because of the ICON pass and what we're doing around the country, we want to exclude the season pass. So I think that that was one of the major changes.
2:39:35 The estimate moving forward on the T-bid is that it will raise $4.5 million. That's the other change. We originally had said that it would raise about $5 million. But taking out the season pass, we've reduced that down to $4.5 million. I think that we have good opportunity to bring that number up. I think one of the biggest things with that is that if we don't...
2:39:54 Even though we're not getting the 2% on season passes, I think the amount of people that we're going to be having visit us from other places around the country, whether it's Steamboat or Jackson Hole or the resorts back east or on the Icon Pass, they're not homeowners here. They're going to be staying in lodging. They're going to be eating at restaurants. They're going to be buying their souvenirs to go home. So I think in the long run, it's going to equal out. I think if we just look at some of the numbers that they reported for folks coming in the month of April. So Mammoth Mountain made the Icon Pass valid after April 9th.
2:40:23 And I believe the number that Mark Brownlee gave me was about 16,000 people that had icon passes that showed up that were not previous California pass holders. So again, those folks coming in helped our April number go to $1.2 million. You know, again, our second best April ever. So I think there are a lot of opportunities there. But those are the three major changes that we made to the district plan. We're comfortable with the changes. We're comfortable with the budgets that we're working with. And we'd love to have the support for the resolution formation.
2:40:52 Good. Thank you very much. So we're going to do a little, give council an opportunity to ask any questions of you and of town staff. And then after that, we'll move on to representations for those speaking in favor and we'll go through the regular public hearing process. So any questions for council of either John Urdi or town staff? I have comments that could easily be questions. Do they have a technical nature or do you rather say these for deliberation? No, they would be more of a technical nature, I believe. Okay. Senor.
2:41:22 Mayor. One of the things when I've taken complaints on this is that the appeals board, if you're going to appeal your classification as to whether you're a tourist-related or a local-related business or appeal something else with the TBID, is that the people who collect the money are making the decision whether or not you have to pay. That seems to me like we need a non-biased
2:41:49 Arbitration Board or whatever you want to call them for those rather than people on the Tourism Board. That would seem to me to be a conflict of interest. Nothing we have to deal with tonight because you can change these rules at any time, but I would like to see that addressed and looked at and see how we could change that for an unbiased. As an example, when we have someone not pay their taxes properly, they can appeal it to the town and then we have someone like the police chief who's unbiased lead that.
2:42:19 Something there would be good if we could work on that just so that it looks a little more fair because obviously you're receiving the money. You're going to want every penny. Anyway, it just looks bad. The TBID, if a majority of businesses want to, they can terminate once a year. What is the town's spot on that? Can we do the same thing if we see it as not working properly?
2:42:49 Are we allowed to enter into that or is it just the business to business relationship? We don't have the ability to terminate it midstream. Okay. The budget, if I understand this correctly, we actually have to approve their budget on an annual basis and we have the ability not to approve that budget and I won't go any further down that stream but
2:43:17 Yeah, the scope of the town's ability to require changes to the budget is an ongoing argument that I'm having with Civitas at my day job, which also has a T-bid. So I would say that that's unresolved. Okay. And, John, how is the voting done? Did every business involved get a ballot? Or, as some things have been done in Mammoth in the past, did you go out and find your 60% and the biggest business owners and get their buy-in thereby?
2:43:47 Just so that the people out there understand. Absolutely. No, there's a process that we follow as far as mailing to all of the affected businesses. So every business that's in lodging, restaurant, retail, and the ski area, they were mailed the information and they were mailed the petition. And so the way that the percentage works, the percentages work based on what percentage you've paid into the T-bid. I think last year was the example. So if we collected $5 million last year and business A contributed $500,000, then they had
2:44:16 You know, that portion of vote. So it's all weighted by the amount that you're paying in. No one business can vote in a T bid. So there's no business, there's no one business if they control, I'll use the mountain as the perfect example. The mountain has 60 plus percent of all revenue that comes into town for the T bid. They can only vote 40%. They're maxed out at 40%. So out of the 87 businesses that voted for it, they made up only 40% of that. And the total vote was 61 point.
2:44:45 1-3, somewhere in there. So we had 21% on top of the mountain. So again, you can't just vote in a one business bid. If we look at that in terms of as the local council race just went, one vote per person instead of proportion for the amount of money you put in, how did that vote come out then? Well, this is an assessment, so it's not factored in that way. But you know how many businesses? 87 businesses. Right. Right.
2:45:15 And you know how many of those businesses voted for versus against? No. I think we had maybe a dozen people that commented negative. So at that point, I think we probably had 87 that voted for. So we do have a good buy-in across the board? I think so. Well, and I think the other side, and I don't have the number completely off the top of my head, but I think out of the top 40 businesses, I think we had about 33 of them that voted in the affirmative. All right. I'm done. Okay. Any other questions, Colin? Questions? I have some comments, but no questions or anything. Okay.
2:45:45 Good. Good. Comments, no questions. Okay. A couple questions. The air subsidy, which is a significant piece of this, and I'm just playing out some worst-case scenarios. I support this. I think it's important to move forward, but I think these are the kinds of questions we need to deal with. What happens if the parties who are recruiting another air partner
2:46:10 They're not successful. Let's say we go for a year or two and there is no airline willing to fly in here other than, say, United or even that falls apart. What happens to those dollars that are committed to the air subsidy? Do they go into a bank account somewhere and they're restricted for that use or how does that work? Well, in the way that it works, so we have $2.15 million set aside for air subsidy. The scenario that you're talking about I don't see happening. However, if it does, the board, the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, who's the guide,
2:46:40 The governing board for the TBID can either redirect those funds, they can hold on to them to say that they're for future air service, but at that point that would be a discussion that we would have to have if there were.
2:46:50 Available funds. In the past, you know, two years ago, two years ago in winter, we had a subsidy of $647,000, so we had $1.5 million budgeted, that money went back into the air program. Last year we did $1.1 million on the subsidy, we had $1.5 budgeted, that got redistributed back into marketing for our San Francisco flight. So in the past, it's been reinvested into air service. And like I said, to your point, I'm not sure that we'll have that scenario, but that's something that we would have to look at. The other side is that the
2:47:19 Board has the opportunity to move up to 20% of the entire budget on an annual basis. So at $4.5 million, that would be $900,000 that they could move out of air or they could move into air. So they have the discretion to move up to 20% on an annual basis. Okay. Just to be clear, just for the public certification we talked about before about who owns air service, this
2:47:43 The MLT board serves as the board that's making decisions to the allocations of funds to the TBD, correct? Correct. Okay. And if I could, Andy, just ask, in terms of the towns, just to help define this for the public, the town is not involved in this. The town, and if you could speak a little bit to the town's role in this, the town's liability, if there would be any legal issues and how that all works. Sure. The TBD law is set up so the town really has very little role.
2:48:12 Other than deciding whether or not to establish or renew the T-bid. The T-bid law says there has to be a committee, in this case it's MLT, that is going to make all the decisions about how to expend the money. The town is not liable if they decide to expend the money in ways that are not really allowed by the law or if someone just runs off with the money in the middle of the night. It's not a town liability. The town's role really is limited to just establishing the T-bid.
2:48:40 And then handing it over to them, and then they have to make the decisions, and they have to make sure that their expenditures are consistent with the law. Okay, and so then as we say we get into these discussions about air service as opposed to airports, but air services involved with Bishop and these kinds of what are going to be some interesting conversations down the line. The MLT board is responsible and liable for decisions associated with the TBID for this next five-year period.
2:49:07 Correct? That's correct. And if the public has questions or concerns about what is happening with the TBID, they need to be going to the MLT board. That's a place they need to go to have these conversations. That's correct as well. Okay. And the MLT board is a Brown Act functioning board. It's a public body, and the public should know that they have the opportunity to go to make any kind of questions.
2:49:30 They should address those to the MLT board. Yeah, Brown Act body and also subject to the Public Records Act. So in some ways, MLT has to operate with a lot of the same transparency that the town does. Okay. And finally, I'm assuming that the board of MLT has the requisite and the appropriate legal representation as we go into these discussions about air service maybe moving around to make representations to the community, to stakeholders in the entire region as to what is the appropriate use of funds.
2:49:59 In the Mammoth Lakes Tea Bid that may or may not be engaged with discussions about moving air service to Bishop or anything else, it's going to be the responsibility of MLT, the board, and your staff, and your legal counsel to be able to make those representations, certainly to the town, but to the public and everybody else. Correct. Yep. Okay. Okay. Well, those are my questions. And if there's no other questions, we can move on now to those folks who are interested in speaking in favor.
2:50:28 of this item. I'm assuming that's MLT board members and members of the public. Please, step up. Sean Turner, Mammoth Lakes Tourism board member. And just as a point of clarification, so you're asking for those that are speaking for
2:50:47 Renewal of the T-Bid, and then are you going to ask for those that are against? Yes. It's proponents, and then those folks may want to speak. That's just a part of the public hearing process. Okay. All right. Well, Sean Turner, Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. I'm going to speak in favor of the T-Bid. I think that, as John pointed out, it has been highly successful in breaking records year after year, month after year, and bringing to town exactly the people we've been looking for.
2:51:14 Tourism dollars coming to town. I think that what is critical going forward is that we do discuss exactly how the TBID dollars are spent.
2:51:27 And I hear loud and clear from our community questions and concerns, in all honesty, about how the TBID dollars are being spent. And I personally am committed, speaking as one board member, that I very much welcome and am excited about the opportunity to go in-depth with regard to the
2:51:52 Aligning our strategy of tourism to our region, not just Mammoth Lakes, but the entire eastern Sierra with what Town Council is trying to do as well. We as a community, as we get into this strategy discussion, the other thing that I've made clear during board...
2:52:12 I will speak personally, again, as an individual board member, that I am
2:52:38 Four, seeing more TBID dollars go specifically to tourism-related infrastructure. We do, and again, speaking as a board member, single board member only, that I personally am for these kind of things, but I've got to say that the staff of MLT has done exactly what we have asked them to do to date, which is bring people to town. And frankly, they've done a great job. We've broken records.
2:53:06 I would like to encourage and state openly and publicly that I am very much in favor of renewing the TBID process. How those dollars are spent is going to be something that I very much want the public to be involved in board meetings and speak their mind as we go forward with this strategic alignment process. Thank you. Good. Thank you very much. Hang on. Are you speaking in favor?
2:53:32 I'm speaking because I'm confused, John. Okay. You made this presentation where it sounded like council or you as a representative of council are saying that council is going to kind of cop out and let other people decide how the TBIT dollars are spent. Is that what you're saying? I'll defer to legal council. Well, no, I think we are working on the advice of council. We're trying to make it clear to the public who has the discretion to determine how the money is spent.
2:54:02 And so I would defer... That's fine. Look, I just think that council, as the putative leaders of the community, I would think that you would have some sort of input in this discussion aside from head over to the MLT board meeting and hopefully Sean and everyone else will listen and we'll kumbaya and we'll come up with a decision as to how to spend the money. The buck supposedly stops there, not out here. So I'm just kind of wondering why you're abdicating...
2:54:30 This responsibility to really have input. It's an excellent question. And when the council deliberates, I think we'll have some insight on that. And actually, I think that Andy can answer that to a certain extent. Yeah, sure. There are legal things we can and cannot do. Yeah, I mean, once it's formed, the council doesn't really have much of a role. That's just the way the law is set up. It's been one of the criticisms of the law, actually. The council can decide, as you're deciding whether or not to renew the T-bid.
2:54:58 How much specificity you want to see in terms of the expenditure plan. So if you think there's not enough information, you can ask for more. I mean, you could defer a decision on approving it tonight if you're so inclined. If you think you need more information, you can ask for more transparency. You can ask for more details. You can ask for more emphasis on things. You can ask for whatever you want. But ultimately, once it's formed, it's really going to be up to MLT to decide. Okay. Let's keep, let's come back to this. And these are good questions. Let's continue with the pro.
2:55:30 With the proponents, please. Mr. Mayor, Council, Brent Truax, Chair of MLT, also Managing Director for the Sierra Nevada Resort and Spa. When we were doing this before as a conversation, I'll reiterate my points from a business leader. That is, one of our goals was to increase our off-season traffic and to increase the availability to keep staff busy, occupied, and employed.
2:55:54 And this has been a very successful program from our standpoint. I mean, seeing the 10 months out of the year of $1 million TOT has a direct impact on the businesses I operate and the ability for me to draw good employees, to keep good employees, and retain good employees. It's important as a community for us to understand how important that is. The cost of one employee to turn over is about $5,000 every time I have to hire a new staff. Every time I don't have to do that, there's a direct impact on us available to operate and, in turn,
2:56:23 Provide better customer service in a community where sometimes we struggle with our customer service. And it's important that we understand that there's multiple impacts on different levels. On the second part, and we were talking before in the budget meeting here, there's a reality in terms of the TOT is generating 70% of the revenue for this community. There's a need. And unless I'm mistaken, and I see the events today, and we had a very horrific event.
2:56:48 If we all feel that we have enough staff at any time and we're always struggling with those things and where the money's going to come from doing those things, I don't know where else you're going to get it until we change something future down the road. Maybe with a new supervisor board and some new members there we can readdress the property tax portion and re-look at that. But I don't see that happening anytime soon. TOT has a significant impact on this community.
2:57:09 TOT is what drives our economy. We are a tourist-based economy. Without those dollars, without those revenues, those CalPERS that you were talking about earlier, those benefits that you need to pay for that raise 3% to 5% every year, they need to be paid somewheres. And I believe that the increase in TBIG, and I'm talking about what Dan said earlier in regards to those additional dollars that you were able to put back some to reserves and to other areas to help fund certain things and potentially our housing needs in this community, is all relevant and driven by that TOT dollar.
2:57:37 So I highly support that from an overall standpoint and encourage this town council to approve this tonight. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else wishing to speak in favor? Hi, Brandon Brocia, owner of Blue Handcrafted Foods and the eatery at Mammoth Maroon Company. I just want to walk you guys through a little story about a business that opened six years ago in this town, and it was 900 square feet. It's called Blue.
2:58:13 I was very fortunate to make it through the driest years that this town's seen in a long time and operate and be able to grow. The one thing that I will say and give kudos to MLT on is that I didn't have to dump tons of money into drawing people into this town. They did. You guys appointed them too.
2:58:44 It was great. They've been supporters of small businesses in this town. They've been supporters of bringing business to this town. And without that, I can't say for sure if I would have been successful. I know that I was leveraged at that point. That's where I lead to today. I've grown into a bigger business, a bigger footprint, great partnership with one of the biggest companies in town.
2:59:15 Truly, me and my wife have truly seen the benefits of MLT and T-Bed in town. We were proponents from the get-go. She's a marketing director, was the marketing director for the Westin. She said it was a no-brainer, and I do what she says. Smart man. But, yeah. But it came to fruition. Our spend on advertising, sorry, Ted, is very little.
2:59:44 Because we know we have that generating advertising for us. And it just doesn't stop. And it actually grows. And it grows. And I think that when we're moving forward, yeah, you can talk about how they're going to spend the money, who's going to direct the money. We need to have that motor lubed and going and keep driving tourists into this town.
3:00:13 I can't imagine a business in town that hasn't seen the positives of MLT since they were put in place. If they haven't, they're probably doing something wrong. I'm just saying that as a business person. That being said, I will have something to say on the negative aspect. And I think it's just a simple matter of fact that the voices should not just be a board. It should be the voices of the business.
3:00:42 In Mammoth, the ones that are actually taking those revenues in and handing them over, because I think that's actually going to drive the direction, because at some point, things cap off, and we've got to start, okay, we've spent the money there, and we've spent the money here, and as a business owner, you don't just keep flooding the gates with money that, oh, well, it made sense to spend it last year. It might not make sense to spend it this year, or spend it in a different way. So I'll talk to that again. So that's my two cents. Thank you.
3:01:10 Now, Brent, do you wish to speak to that later? Well, if nobody else has something. That's okay. Yeah, come back. Come back. Okay, so I agree on the way that the TBID is collected. I agree on the air service. I think that's an amazing way for us to get tourists up here and get a little bit of positive out of that. I think that there could be better spend.
3:01:38 On some of that money, I think about how much money goes into air service. And if you just take a fraction of that, like even what they don't spend some years and just put it into a little bit of infrastructure for tourism in town, that's the missing piece. I mean, as a local and a business owner in town, you don't just put the flyers out there. You got to paint the trim on the building. You don't just put money into the radio station. You got to polish the windows.
3:02:07 You know, you have to put the signs up outside to say, come into my business and keep them clean and keep them organized. So I think it's it's just it rounds up a little bit more. And I think actually it would create a great synergy. I think a lot of people in town don't see the tangible. I mean, it's there. I mean, you can see it in the numbers. That's very tangible. But, you know, something.
3:02:32 They can actually drive down the road and see. We don't need the ticker going with how much is generated. We need the new sign that says, go up to Devil's Postpile. We need the brochure that says, hey, from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, keep your car doors rolled up and don't put food in your car, whatever it might be. Just have that little bit of touch on our tourism, and it could go a long way.
3:02:59 So that's my only negative on MLT right now. Appreciate it. Thank you very much. You're welcome. Very insightful. Thank you. Anybody else wishing to speak in favor? Hi, Lynn, I'm a huge proponent of TPIT. I think it's an excellent means to pass through a collection from our tourists.
3:03:21 Thank you so much.
3:03:50 Was that 50% of funds that were allowed for sales, marketing, and public relations could be also applied to something or could include something called development of tourism-related infrastructure, which we're hearing a little bit of that theme and some of the other business owners that have just stepped forward.
3:04:07 So, you know, when you look at $5.2 million is what I saw in the 2017-2018 budget is what would be collected just in TBID, you know, 50% of those funds are about $2.6 million. So when I was looking at that total budget, though, I also noticed that about $1.7 million was spent this past year for 21,000 airline passengers, 21,278.
3:04:32 And that has occurred for the last several years, and that's been allowed and authorized and permitted. Well, we were just looking at, and I know that the multi-use facility slash ice rink slash community center has been talked about, it's been presented, but I think it's a great case to discuss because we already know some of those numbers. We know some of those projections. We know some of the actuals. And some of those numbers, if we look at that, the ice rink brought in about 10 and a half thousand.
3:05:00 People just in the two and a half months it was open, you know, hopefully not enough sun and not too much snow, but, you know, for that period. So, you know, just in projections, we're looking at 13,000 to 15,000 visitors for the ice rink. We're looking at about 4,000 for the community center and then a few thousand for the multi-use facility in the summer. So when we round that, that's about 20,000.
3:05:22 Tourists and locals that we're catering to. This doesn't include the Mammoth Kings programming. That would increase that number by about 20%. So let's just throw around 24,000 persons. So now we have 21,000.
3:05:33 Airline passengers that are flying in at $1.7 million, and that seems to be a great use of those funds. But yet when I presented to MLT, can we please use some of those funds towards a roof over the ice rink? I was told by the director and a few of the board members that that wasn't where they wanted to use those funds. So what Ted brought up I think is an important issue. When does compliance?
3:05:58 When does that become of concern? And how do we do the reinforcement there? I just want the funds to be used reasonably and what's been sold to the business owners when we originally adopted the T-bid. And, you know, even at the time of renewal as well, happy to collect this from our tourists and to utilize those funds. But we also need tourism-related infrastructure. We need a pool. We need a conference center. And I don't want to hear that we don't have funds because we do. It's just about where they're being at.
3:06:27 So that's really my push at this time. Appreciate it. Good. Thank you very much. Anybody else? Good evening, ladies and gentlemen. John Morris. I'm a treasurer of the MLT, also chairman of the Lodging Association and director of operations at Snow Creek. Highly in favor of the TBID. I actually want to address several comments that were just made. Obviously, I'm in favor of the TBID. Anecdotally from business, it's...
3:07:01 Been great for Snow Creek over the last years. And there was something in the paper recently that said something about good snow years. Since the T bid's been in effect, I believe at least three of the five years were not good snow years and pretty awful snow years, actually. And we still continue to increase TOT and so forth. So that's the purpose of the T bid. A huge portion of it and MLT in general, obviously, is to generate business in the off seasons, midweek.
3:07:29 And during the summertime, and to weatherproof ourselves, essentially. I've gone on and on about that, so I won't discuss it. I do want to address a couple of comments. One comment that Brandon made regarding the board makeup. I just want to make sure everybody understands that the MLT board is made up of representatives of the entire community. We have lodging, retail, restaurant, Mammoth Mountain.
3:07:54 Town Council, Chamber, and at large positions. And each one of those seats represents a segment of the community. And our job is basically, my job as a lodging seat, is to talk to the folks in the lodging association and say, what do you think? Are we doing the right thing? Should we be doing something different? Should we be focusing on something else? We bring those comments back.
3:08:18 to the board at our meetings and we discuss it and we implement those comments and so forth into partially into our budget discussions. And so we do try to represent cross sections of the entire community. We've always tried to do that. Another thing is that another comment was regarding
3:08:40 So MLT does have reserves, and we have reserves set aside for special projects, but things like wayfinding. We've had money in reserve for wayfinding for a couple years now, and we're simply waiting sort of for the powers that be at the town to tell us when we're ready to go on something like that, and we're happy to put money into that. And we do recognize that there are things in town that people want to see the T-bid money go towards, and we agree with that.
3:09:08 So we do have funds and projects and reserve set aside for specific projects. Sorry if I'm jumping from one thing to another. It's just writing notes. Another thing to go back to Ted's comment, which I understand his concern of a disconnect between the Town Council and MLT and the TBIT. I understand what he's saying there. And just so Ted and the public know, one of the things that we do, we have done,
3:09:36 Several times this last year, if I can remember correctly, is we've had several meetings with all the different NGOs, with the Town Council, all getting together, making sure that our strategic partnerships and everything were aligned, discussing where we're going, how funds should be allocated, where funds are needed, what priorities are, and that sort of thing. And obviously a good portion of what the TBID funds, how the budget is developed.
3:10:03 Is in alignment with these other NGOs and the Town Council and the strategic alignment. So it isn't simply just a decision that MLT makes willy-nilly. We want to be in alignment with everything else, make sure that those funds are being spent appropriately. And when I say appropriately, I mean collaboratively within the community. So I think that was it. One other comment just on air.
3:10:29 I do want to say that part of the management of air subsidy, I know it seems like a big number, but one of the things that MLT has tried really hard to do is keep the cost per passenger on the air subsidy to a reasonable amount, and we've worked really hard on that over the few years. Yes, we want to see more employments, that's very true, but we're also cognizant of the fact that there is a limited amount of funds to be spent, so they have to be spent responsibly.
3:10:58 So I think that was it. I hope you guys do approve the TBID. I think it's been great for the community. I think most people see that. There's always great room for discussion. And I think all of the board members are always happy to discuss with the media or the public or whoever wants to talk about it within our roles and discuss other things that the TBID could be used for, whether it's appropriate or not. We're always open to that. So try to be as transparent as possible.
3:11:28 Thank you, guys. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you very much. Anybody else wishing to speak in favor? Anybody else? Anybody wishing to speak with an opposition or any kind of general comment? Okay. Hearing none. Sure. I have received some complaints. When board positions open on MLT, maybe MLT can send a press release to the paper so we can announce that if people are interested,
3:12:02 In applying that they can do so. Good. Okay, thank you. Okay, so I think what would be appropriate is to maybe, I've got some further questions for staff, kind of, again, sort of a technical nature before we get into a deliberation. So if any other council members have any questions, maybe.
3:12:28 And we'll go through that process and then bring it back and then we'll deliberate. I'm assuming we can avail us as a council while we're doing that. Any questions? I've got a couple, but do you guys have any questions? Okay. So I'm wondering if you could speak to the questions that Ted brought up. And I'm asking this in the context of we just had an election. There's a new council that's going to be seated probably at the next meeting. The town is engaged.
3:12:54 In a priorities prioritization process that we're going to be doing at an annual or every two year kind of an effort. And I'm wondering if you could, Andy, if you could speak to the town has a contract with MLT for Measure A money, right? And it's all the NGOs, the expectation of the council will be refining our process and articulating our priorities in such a way that they can be reflected. Any council's priorities could be reflected in those contracts with those NGOs that reflect the priorities of the council.
3:13:23 What is the difference between the measure A, the contract for measure A money and the kinds of questions Ted's bringing up in terms of the TBID? Yeah, it's a really good question. They're very, very different because the measure A money that's...
3:13:37 Simply a contract. The town can negotiate for whatever it wants from the MLT in terms of deliverables or process or reporting or anything else. Town money and you can completely tell them how you want them to spend it and if they're willing to agree to that then we put it in the agreement and then you have a lot of control. The TBID process is very different because it's not a contract as such. The TBID law, as I mentioned, simply says that there's this management district plan, the council gets to decide whether to
3:14:05 Form or renew the district. And then after that, our responsibility is essentially to send them the money. And their responsibility is to make expenditures that are consistent with the plan and consistent with the requirements of the law. And just as a brief refresher, in case anybody hasn't been following the nuances of this, the law says that all the expenditures of TBID money have to be for the benefit of the people who are paying the assessment. And Mammoth, that means
3:14:31 The lodging community, restaurants, retail. So it's a very broad base. And so it's a little bit easier here to justify certain types of expenditures as benefiting the people who are paying them than it is in some other communities where perhaps it's only lodging, where it's really about heads and beds and sort of driving tourism generally is a little bit tougher to justify. So it's just two very different sort of legal environments.
3:14:57 And a lot more direct control with the measure A dollars and the contract with MLT. But you're not without some control over the TBID because you can decide whether or not to renew it. And if you want to try to attach conditions, you could work something out with MLT perhaps about what kinds of things the town would like to see them spend the money on. I mean, that can be done. It's just that the TBID process by itself...
3:15:22 Doesn't really contemplate that ongoing role. So if you want to have a little more oversight, we'd have to work something out on the front end. Right, which is where we are tonight. Right. Okay. So just by example, if the council, say, wanted to address Mr. Sauser's question about appeals and things like that, or board representation or those kinds of things, are those the kinds of things that's appropriate for the council to get involved with or no?
3:15:51 I think that you can, yes. The TBID law is a little bit vague on whether or not you can sort of unilaterally dictate changes to the management district plan, which is the governing document for the TBID, from the dais tonight. It appears that there's nothing that says that you can't, but since I just became aware of this issue half an hour ago, I haven't managed to find a definitive answer. So if that's something that you would really like to do is change the...
3:16:18 The management district plan either to change the composition of the body at MLT that's overseeing this or to change the appeal process, you might consider postponing the decision. Yeah, and I just, I'm exploring this because I think the kinds of questions that Ted has brought up and the community has brought up are important.
3:16:34 And what I'm very personally very interested in hearing is representations from the members of the board that understand that I think we all understand the importance, the critical importance of having a marketing, a discrete independent marketing organization that can do the kinds of things, that can drive the kind of traffic and generate the TOT that's critical to our survival as a community. But I think there's an interest from a variety of different people to start really refining how
3:17:02 I think it's important to be legally understanding what exactly is the role that the council can play, what's an appropriate role for us to play, what's not an appropriate role for us to play.
3:17:31 How if we set it up now for a five-year renewal period and the council would be two more passes of priorities that new councils may want to radically change that, understanding that once this thing is initiated, we can't, we don't have really any jurisdiction over it. Is that fair to say? The way the TBID law is set up, it doesn't really contemplate jurisdiction.
3:17:52 But it could be possible to get MLT to make some kind of commitment about how they would spend the dollars. You could get them to agree to some kind of meet and confer process periodically, every year, every couple of years, and get them to agree perhaps to take into consideration what may be kind of different council priorities, again, within the confines of the legal requirements for how they spend the money. Okay. So I'm thinking that if we really, if the new council, and we're only here for another...
3:18:19 But the new council takes this priority setting process seriously, reflects its priorities in its contract with MLT for the Measure A money. That becomes a representation of the elected folks in the public of what the expectations are for MLT and how this is going to work. And I'm thinking that's probably the appropriate way to kind of handle this, rather than getting into the minutia of starting to mess around with the management plan and that kind of stuff. That's not...
3:18:45 I don't think we're in any position to do that kind of stuff tonight. And just to clarify, I think that the management district plan is really more kind of the structure of how this is going to be run. It doesn't necessarily dictate how the funds are going to be spent other than within the broad confines of the law. So the management district plan is not a budget. It is not a detailed roadmap for how the dollars are going to be spent.
3:19:08 The law requires MLT to have a budget every year, and that's really where the detailed decisions are made. So if the council thinks that you want to have perhaps more oversight or more input than you've had, it doesn't really require amending the management district plan. Something like changing the appeal process or changing the board of composition would.
3:19:27 Okay. And just, I think we'll probably close this technical part of this and we can get into deliberation, but I did go to the MLT board meeting this afternoon and made sure to advise the board of the discussion that this council had back on the 16th about the need to be really aligning, as John pointed out, you know, really taking this the next step where the priorities of the council...
3:19:47 Are documented, they're expressed, and they find their way into the contracts with the NGOs so that there's public accountability. The public can say, look, this is who was elected. These are the kinds of things we expect to see happen. We can bring these things together. Are there any further technical questions that we would want to deliberation? Okay, so I'm going to close the public hearing. Before you close the public hearing, if you want to have any council discussion, do that. But you need to call for any final protest from the business.
3:20:17 Okay. Okay, so I'm going to request for any... Is there any final protest from related businesses? Seeing none. So then I'm going to close the public hearing. We will deliberate.
3:20:45 We still have the eye. If we wanted to continue, we could as part of our deliberation, right? Yes. You're saying yes? Okay. You're the lawyer. Okay. So I'm going to close the public hearing. Yeah, but he's from Tahoe. It's okay. That's all right. We need to have mercy on these people. Their snow lines are going up. Let's deliberate, shall we? Thoughts? I'm willing to go first and give you my total thoughts on TBID. When Mr. Urdi first came to town to take over the helm at Mammoth Lakes,
3:21:14 Tourism. We all remember where we had been in the political games that had been played with Measure A. One of the first things I told him was that he needed to find a way to collect some money outside of the normal political process of the town of Mammoth to protect our tourism industry because those dollars had been played with by previous councils and used for things that I thought were inappropriate. And that's what this does. I trust that the people on the board, while I don't agree with them a lot of the times,
3:21:44 The people on the board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism have the best interest of Mammoth at heart, the same as those of us that sit up here do. So this takes at least some of this out of the political vagaries of what Mammoth has or hasn't done. I think we've learned the lessons from that. We lost some tourism because of how the dollars were misspent, and we now have that back. So while I...
3:22:08 Have told him and will continue to speak with him and the board members. I meet with several of them on a fairly regular basis. Things that I would like to see change, like the appeals process, I think that moving this forward and approving it tonight is the correct thing to do. It has helped us. You can see the difference. And I believe that as a council, if we have real problem with how they're spending TBID,
3:22:38 Because we do have control over a lot of other funds, that we have the leverage, if necessary, to get it done. So I have no qualms about voting to reauthorize this tonight. Okay, good. Let's go next. I agree with Bill. Okay. I mean, basically the community spoke. I didn't see anybody really against it. It has been doing its job.
3:23:07 You know, to go back to square one and, you know, try and reinvent the whole new thing again, I think would take too much time and effort and get caught up in a minutia that wouldn't be good for our community. So I think it is doing its job. I think there should be some tweaks, and I think they realize that. So I'm inclined with Bill to move this forward. Okay. Cleland?
3:23:35 I'll hear from you. Okay, Colin, go ahead. Colin first. You know, obviously, I'm a council member. I am currently the representative of the council on MLT. Well, I was until 3 p.m. today. I'm also, I own multiple businesses in town, so, you know, kind of throughout my comments here, I'll kind of meander between those different roles. But, you know, I think
3:24:04 As has already been very well articulated, as a business owner in town, it's very apparent to me the positive effects of this. I think the T-bid is one component of the success we've seen over the last five years, six years, whatever it may be. You know, there's a lot of factors, but I think it's a significant factor and one that I'm not willing to play around with getting rid of.
3:24:30 I've seen a lot of positive benefits as a business owner as a result. You know, when I came here in 2009, it wasn't called a TBIT at that time, but that was something that I advocated, that the businesses in the community need to step up and join together. That's probably the socialist in me. That we all need to have, you know, as an entirely tourism-dependent economy, that we all need to step up to the plate and contribute.
3:24:58 To helping to drive visitation. You know, I talk about Steamboat a lot. That's the area I came from before. But, you know, whether it's a TBID and Steamboat, it's a fly Steamboat program through the chamber. All the businesses there contribute specifically to air subsidy. That's one way that they've looked at doing it. They actually have a ballot initiative that's going.
3:25:20 Well, it probably just happened. Or maybe it's on the November ballot about an air tax in Steamboat. You know, that's a community that's really bought into that. But all the businesses in the community kind of got behind that. You know, one of the things that I struggle with a little bit in this community is this idea that decisions made need to be for life.
3:25:38 And I think we have that attitude sometimes, there's that perception out there, and that's something that I really fundamentally disagree with. We have to be nimble enough as a community to look at things on at least an annual basis, if not more frequently.
3:25:55 As has already been stated, I think the direction to MLT in 2012 when we were in a crisis point was very, very clear. We need to grow ourselves out of this crisis. We need to drive visitation. We need to drive revenue. I think it would be...
3:26:11 Really difficult to argue that that hasn't been executed to a very high degree. So kudos to John, you and your team for knocking that out of the park. Some of what I'm starting to hear in the community, in the ether, some of the comments that have been brought up today is in 2018, are we at a different place? Do we need to reevaluate whether that's the sole and chief focus moving forward? And maybe that's not the case.
3:26:37 So I think we need to be able as a community to kind of have some of those conversations about tourism-related infrastructure and the guest experience when they get here and all those type of things. So I think it's encouraging to hear that those conversations are going on at the board, around in the community, and I think that's really going to be something for the next council to address. That has already been done.
3:27:01 To a certain degree. You know, MLT has about $1.25 million in reserves currently. They've been allocated to four specific areas. We've talked about this before. Events venue, airport, conference center, and wayfinding. So I think we need to get to a place where we can start to expend some of those funds rather than hold them in reserve. But it's difficult. I mean, we don't have an opportunity to spend $350,000.
3:27:29 We have money set aside for a conference center. That is not ready to go. So, you know, there are conversations that are being had about how can we expend some of those dollars to tourism-related infrastructure, and that was kind of the discretion of the board that they felt those were the appropriate places to put it. So, you know, I think that
3:27:59 As far as the management plan, I don't think there's any need for us to get in and mess around with that. I think it's, I'm content with the way things are. I think the two adjustments that are being asked, you know, no T-bid on ICON passes in a five-year time frame are very reasonable and I'm supportive of that.
3:28:18 And I think hopefully in the next five years we can figure some of that stuff out. I mean, we're having this conversation right now about the TBID and MLT specifically, but this is no different than conversations we're starting to have with MLR and MLH and all of our, and ESTA and all of our partners.
3:28:34 You know, in 2012, we needed X from you. In 2018, has that changed? And I think, you know, our service delivery model with our NGOs is relatively new. It's something that I support wholeheartedly. But we've got to establish that push-pull. And I think that we heard loud and clear from the community that, you know, maybe...
3:28:57 We needed to rein that in a little bit and have a little bit more accountability. Kind of to Ted's point, you know, whether we really have the legal jurisdiction over the exact expenditures, that's not a huge concern of mine, but certainly as the direct line of communication with the community, it is incumbent on the council to advocate for what we're hearing in the community and communicate that. And probably the best way to do that is through the council's representative on the board. So I think we need to continue to do that. We need to hear that.
3:29:27 You know, I think I look at the last 10 years of our air service program specifically as kind of a trial period. You know, you were kind of asking who owns this. I think that's a difficult question to answer because we as a community own this. MLT certainly plays a big part. The mountain plays a big part. The town council in the town plays a big part. But so does the community and the business owners in the community. And as a whole, I think we as a community, the last 10 years,
3:29:57 You know, we haven't executed to the degree that we need to. So I think we've learned some things from that. I'm hopeful in this next fine beer time period that we figure a lot of that out, what that means for MMH Airport, how Bishop factors into everything. You know, we talk.
3:30:14 Consistently about regional, reliable air service. We haven't executed on that to this point. So the five-year time frame I think makes sense. You know, hopefully in the next five years we can suss some of that stuff out. But I think it would be – I don't think it's really our role to –
3:30:33 The votes are in. So I think that's our role is to move this forward and approve it. It's also something that I want to do regardless. As a business owner in town, I think it's tremendously important to our continued growth and success as a community. So I'm absolutely comfortable advocating it. And I think we just need to have an open line of communication about what our needs are.
3:30:57 From the Town Council, from the community are of MLT moving forward, how the T-bid factors into that in the next five years. And I'm hearing a willingness to have that conversation, so that's encouraging. Good. Okay. My comments. One to Andy. Even though it says they're design created and governed by those who will pay the assessment, I see why the businesses say they pay the assessment.
3:31:24 But let's be honest. The people are paying the assessment. Rite Aid doesn't charge it on to their customers. They may hike the prices up. Most places do the paperwork, and they turn in their money. So I wanted to point that out, that I think that that's a little bit a strange way to put it out, that the businesses are paying the assessment.
3:31:47 It's the public. And I've noticed in the rooms that it's always the same people who are coming in here and talking about the TBID. What I'm hearing out in the community, people are not that fond of the TBID.
3:32:00 And also, the people who are not fond of the T bid, a business person told me the other day, they said, well, my choice was to either sign the petition, or whatever they called it, or not. I guess the person didn't even know that they could send a little handwritten note saying, you know, I don't approve the T bid. I'm not totally against the T bid, but I do want to point out a couple of things. The past two years, going into the third year of being on town council now, I have been hearing people say that, you know,
3:32:30 Recreation, we're bringing so many people here and we're building this and you can have sent many articles on that there is a big trend of people going to places such as Mammoth, anywhere in the wilderness on the west coast. People are looking for that. I don't think that we had Yosemite have a big increase in their
3:32:57 I don't think it was because of our T bid. I think that that was more organic. It's a move. People are looking for this type of thing. That said, on the current town council, it will be changing within the next month. I think waiting would be the correct way to go ahead with this because we do have, and this could actually be something, we have two people who are on the list and most likely sign the petition.
3:33:27 For the T-bid, so you know that they are supporting that, you will pretty much have a town council where no one has a business that will benefit nor not benefit from that in the future. I think that if it's going to be a five-year contract and here we are a month away from having new town council members, it's going to be very easy for people to step away and go,
3:33:55 Not my problem. So I would prefer to wait until the new council was seated to talk about this more. I'm not even going to get into things about the contract with MLT, but I can tell you, in case we travel in different circles, people are not thrilled with some of the things that you brought up and said today, how great things are. I think it's a little bit rosier picture.
3:34:21 So we don't have the contract with MLT in place, number one. We don't know what's going on with air service. I think today, if we make this decision to go ahead with the TBID, I think that we are doing a great disservice to a lot of people. That said, I'm not against the TBID, but I am against the way it's going around. And you want to talk about politics, this has gotten to be one of the most hot.
3:34:49 Thank you. So I'm going to
3:35:16 Thank you.
3:35:32 Moving forward with this, this is not going to tie the hands from a policy perspective from the new council. I think that it would be, frankly, irresponsible not to move forward with this, given the things that I've heard.
3:35:46 Which are a couple things. One is that the council needs to ensure that its priorities and its values are reflected in the contracts with the NGOs. I believe in the NGO system. I think you've very eloquently said why that's so important. But we've been working on this the last couple years, that in those contracts and in those agreements, the public can feel confident that the values that the elected officials were elected on are reflected in the deliverables and the things that...
3:36:14 We expect to see. Again, the MLT board advising them today of what the deliberation we had on the 16th, direct the town manager and staff to say, look, this is coming and we need to be on the same page with this. Conversations I've had with members of the MLT board lead me to believe that they are receptive to this and that they want to work effectively, not just with the town and the council, but with the community.
3:36:35 To round this thing out. And I think your point about the organic nature of visitation with public lands and these kinds of things is an actual phenomenon. And we have to start thinking about over-tourism.
3:36:46 We have to make sure that the product that we have here is one that's going to speak for itself in a way that it inevitably can. I mean, no one's going to argue with the power of this place as a draw to compel people to come visit here. But we have to really get into the business now of striking the right balance. I think your observation about where we were at, you know, when this thing started, I think when this country, you and I started here four years ago, you know, we'd just come out of one of, we were close to an existential situation with the town, with the community going forward.
3:37:16 And again, MLT to John and his staff, the numbers have produced. The town has had the TOT revenue. We've budgeted responsibly, and we're doing okay. But we have to strike this balance. So I'm looking for the process of the contracting process with MLT and with the other NGOs going forward, the prioritization process that a new council is going to be doing in August or September, and the willingness, I think most importantly, is the willingness of the members of the board who clearly understand the need to be
3:37:45 With what MLT is doing to be reflecting the values and the best interests of the community and to start to really modify what it is MLT does in a way that it has deep buy-in to the community so the people that you're talking to can say, look, we understand what they're doing. We understand the value of this. We understand how important it is for the community. The town, with writing a $2 million check every year, we're not actually going to be able to deliver any services if we're not bringing that stuff in. Let me finish real quick. So I'm comfortable with moving forward with this.
3:38:14 And one last thing I'll point out is the state of Colorado, Visit Colorado, the tourism, the analogous organization state of Colorado is integrating into their marketing campaign a leave no trace component that's telling people when you come to Colorado, this is how you do it. This is how you play in Colorado. And I think we're ripe to start thinking about
3:38:40 You know, No Small Adventure's been a great campaign, very successful, but look, when you're coming to Mammoth Lakes,
3:38:46 This is how you do this. This is the ethics of what it means to be in an environment like this. This is how to engage with a unique place like this. I think these are the kinds of opportunities we've got in front of us now. I think it's going to be very interesting to explore those things. So I'm sorry, you had a comment. Oh, no, I was just going to say that over-tourism is an issue that we could be facing. So at what point do we tell MLT, oh, stop advertising. We have too many people. But I just want to...
3:39:14 Reiterate that there is nothing that is going to prevent this that's to go ahead in a month. I don't see the urgency and I'm very a little bit uneasy with the fact that this is going to be maybe one of the last town council meetings that we will have.
3:39:35 This group, I think we have one more afterwards, why this is coming forward at this point and has to be done right now and chosen where I believe that it should be something that, and people watching this maybe will have some feedback and they'll go, yeah, you know, why don't you wait? I like to get things done, however, in this one, please, let's, let's, let's.
3:39:59 Put it forward because it makes me feel as though my fellow council members are scared that this is not going to go through. I feel that this is almost a forced move. Cleland, honestly, I feel like your argument is one of the most articulate I've heard from you. I think a lot of what you said was spot on. I think there is concern out in the community. I hear that too. I don't think.
3:40:25 You know, anybody's under any impression that things are being handled perfectly. And I think it's going to be an ongoing process of tweaking that. I think everything that you said is very valid. There's a lot of, you know, trends going on with people, you know, wanting to get outdoors. And that's certainly a component of the success we've seen. I think, you know, all of all of what you had to say, I think, is very valid. Just for me, from my perspective, the petition's been out.
3:40:51 That's been established. To me, it's not really up to the council necessarily to say, do I like this or do I not like this? I think it's our job to move this forward, and that's why I'm comfortable doing that. It's not going to change the petition a month from now. It's not going to change the petition. I guess what I'm saying, I guess I would prefer to see people who...
3:41:14 I mean, I would almost say that you would both have to recuse yourselves from this topic because you have businesses that depend on tourism and you are getting a lot of, this is a very good thing for you. I think that that's a little bit different and it would be nice to have people whose businesses or interests in the town, while still supporting this, it's not going to change their bottom dollar.
3:41:43 And I do believe that the town council that we have coming in, unless they have businesses I'm unaware of, I think you would have a much more open conversation that's not just based on, you know, who is this really going to help? I would take a little bit of exception to that because I look at this as the TOT that's generated.
3:42:07 Provides the revenue that makes it possible for the town to budget to deliver services. And I think I would be careful about, I'm happy and I value having businesses, you know, the full spectrum of the community represented on the council. And I would just, I would say that it's in the community's interest and the town's interest to be generating, it's not a personal.
3:42:29 And I certainly recognize I'm a business owner. Bill is as well. I mean, can you speak to that a little bit, Andy? I mean, we've talked about this before. The fact that some of you on the diet, some of the businesses, does not preclude you from voting on this because this is not a conflict of interest under the state's conflict laws. I understand. Because of something called the public general exception, which says that if a big enough chunk of the businesses in town are going to be affected the same way as you as business owners.
3:42:56 Then the law says, well, okay, you don't really have a conflict. And in this case, because just about every business in town would, in fact, be affected the same way as your respective businesses, that exception kicks in. You don't have a conflict. I mean, Mayor Pro Tem, Hoff could...
3:43:13 You may be addressing more of the perception of conflict rather than actual conflict. No, I was. It's the perception. But I'm just trying to put this in the big picture. We are talking now about something that we are going to have different people up here. We don't have a contract with MLT at this moment. Well, we need to move forward with that. And the air service is going to be such a bigger issue to get air service in here.
3:43:42 I don't think that we're doing anything tonight that is going to
3:44:13 You know, bind the ability of the next council to be able to really inform the contract, the deliverables, the working relationship with MLT. I think those are the things we're going to be focused on. Brian, I think that this thing is sufficiently important that we should probably move forward with it. I'm with you, John. I mean, I think it's our role to certify a petition, and I think that's a totally separate deal then.
3:44:36 You know, the new council's role in establishing a new contract and that work in that relationship. There'll be plenty of work to do there. Yeah, I'm comfortable. Okay, so I think we kind of, I think the horses, I think we're beat up. So is there anybody who would like to make a motion? I will make a motion to approve the resolution declaring the results of majority, Dan, you gave it to me, the results of majority protest proceedings and renewing the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District.
3:45:05 I'll second that. Thank you very much. Any further discussion? Okay, hearing none, roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Yes, the item is agreed to 4-1. We're going to take a quick break. Bill, would you like a break? Yeah. Okay. We'll take a quick, according to the clock that's always wrong, we'll take an eight-minute break. 8-15. 8-15. You know sitting's the new smoothie.
3:45:54 Colin Fernie, please report to Bill Sauser. Are you out there somewhere? Information desk. Yeah. Please pick up the white courtesy telephone. Where's Bill? Oh, look at that. He's actually hiding. You can't see him. I know. I don't know how he did that. Not what I said. Oh, no, no. You know, that was...
3:46:20 I could see where it was going, but I wanted to get on record, so then when I'm right down the road, people go, hey, remember, Leland, stop that. Sure. You know what? I have some extra new ones. I just figured I'd wait until the last couple of meetings to make it grow out. I'm going into Huffington. That was spot on. Okay, good. Thank you. I appreciate that.
3:46:48 Alright, let's do this. Alright. Okay. So we're back. Clock that's always wrong says 8.15, so we're in good shape. Item number 13. I think it's 8.18. It's pretty spot on.
3:47:12 Okay, the clock that's always wrong is 819. All right, well, deferred appropriate respect to the clock that's always wrong. Yeah, I think you're going to have to give that up. Yeah. Okay, item 13, consider the approval, consider approval of zoning code amendment 18-001 to amend the standards for halo light signs within municipal code chapter 17.48, including the consideration of the addendum to the 2011 town of Mammoth Lake sign code update mitigated negative declaration.
3:47:42 And Ruth? Yes, thank you. Thank you. So this is a proposed zoning code amendment to the signs chapter to address a really specific issue, which is the allowed size of halo lit signs. And this came about as a result of previous requests for halo lit signs and another request that we're expecting for a new business in town.
3:48:10 So halo lit signs are signs illuminated by concealing the light source behind three-dimensional opaque letters, numbers, or other characters of a sign, resulting in a nighttime perception of a halo around the silhouette of each sign character. So this type of sign lighting has a relatively low light emittance. And halo lighting is distinct from other types of...
3:48:36 Internal illumination, which are typically prohibited in town, such as backlit signs. The zoning code currently permits halo-lit signs that are a maximum of 20 square feet, and the amendment proposes to allow halo-lit signs as large as the applicable sign type.
3:48:55 So we regulate sign size based on the length of the building along the street frontage. And then there's maximum size signs for different kinds of sign types. So for hanging signs, there's a maximum sign size of 8 square feet, projecting signs 12 square feet, and then monument and wall signs are allowed up to a maximum of 30 square feet. So the proposed amendment to halo lit signs would instead of
3:49:25 Basically creating a different maximum size for signs using halo lighting would just allow signs using halo lighting to have the otherwise applicable maximum sign size. We hope it's a little more intuitive to use. So these are just examples of existing and proposed halo lit signs in town. So the Mammoth Lakes PD has a halo lit sign. Morrison's is a relatively new halo lit sign. They've got red lighting.
3:49:55 CJ's, although it doesn't appear very well in this picture, has sort of a mix of colors, some yellow, green, I think there might even be some red in there. Vons is a halo lit sign, 53 up at the Village. And then we've got a proposed sign from the grocery outlet that would also be a halo lit sign. Question. Are you done? I'm not quite done, but I just want a clarification. Vons.
3:50:24 You consider that a halo lit sign? It is a halo lit sign. It's not a backlit? It's not backlit. The lighting is actually set behind opaque letters and shines just around the outside. That picture is pretty terrible, so it looks more like a backlit sign. Yeah, I just want a clarification on that. Okay, thank you. No problem.
3:50:49 So the staff recommendation is to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approving zoning code amendment 18-001 as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Thank you. So I failed to open the public hearing before your presentation, so I'm going to open the public hearing now. Thank you. Public hearing is open. Questions from council to staff? Yep, makes sense to me. What was the size of the...
3:51:21 Madam Police Department sign. I think it was right around 20 square feet. Let me pull up the table on the staff report. 14 square feet. 14 square feet. Any other questions? Is there a proponent for this item in the room? Anybody wishing to speak publicly on this item? Anybody wishing to speak against this item? Okay. With that, I am going to
3:52:00 Close the public hearing. And, council, please deliberate. I appreciate staff bringing this forward. I'm all for more flexibility. I think the halo lit signs around town look fantastic. Agreed. So, two thumbs up. Okay. Shall I make a motion? Please. Please.
3:52:23 I wasn't even ready to do that. Sorry about that. I didn't make a motion that we waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal co-findings and approved zoning amendment 18-001 as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission or as modified by the Town Council. I second. Any further discussion? Hearing none, roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes.
3:52:52 Yes. Yes, the item is agreed to 5-0. Moving on now to item 14, approval of appropriations, limit, investment policy, debt policy, reserve policy, and annual budget for fiscal year 2018-19. So I'm going to, as this is a public hearing, I'm going to open this public hearing appropriately now for the presentation by staff. Did I hear you say the short presentation by staff? I did not say that. You're doing okay.
3:53:28 There's a number of items before you as we look at the annual budget here. The first four items deal with a number of policies that inform the budget. That includes our investment policy, our reserves policy, our debt policy, and the first item will be appropriations limit. All of those fit into that. I would recommend that as we deal with each of these individually, you can take an action then to approve them because ultimately they all inform the final budget in that process.
3:53:57 Most of these you've seen before, so we won't spend a lot of time. There's a summary slide on these. The first one is the appropriation limit. That was put in place in 1979. It's by Proposition 4, also often referred to as the GAN limit. It basically puts a cap on how much tax revenue a local agency can raise. There's a calculation process you go through each year to make sure that we don't exceed that.
3:54:22 Cindy's been involved in the preparation of these, so if there's detailed questions, I'll defer to her. But each year, we take a look at how much tax revenue we have. There's certain adjustments this gets made to it. It goes up by the change in population and CPI. There's a couple factors you look at. Bottom line for us in doing the analysis, and there's the detailed information in your packet, but the limit for FY 2018-19 would be
3:54:49 $25,242,524. The amount subject to that is at the $15,389,517 level, so we're well below that tax limit. But you have to go through the calculation each year and approve the limit accordingly. The recommendation is to adopt the resolution establishing the Town of Mammoth Lakes Appropriations Limit for fiscal year 18-19. Okay, so a couple just procedural things.
3:55:19 We're going to do this all in the context of one hearing, or do we have to have like five different hearings? I think one is fine, but if you want to have separate ones, you can. Okay. I'm just to counsel. My proposal is to do this as one public hearing. We'll just go with that one. Okay. Housekeeping item.
3:55:37 There are, in terms of outstanding budget items that the council was involved with getting us to this point. There was a discussion about the Hayden Cabin Museum and the trail system signage stuff. And do you want to make a representation? I'll touch with those on the budget versus this here. Right now, that would just be the appropriations limit. If I could walk through each of these resolutions, you can take action on those or not, and we can come back. And those items would not impact this.
3:56:04 The appropriations limit. Okay, just if it's any information for council to understand where those in the, excuse me, the MLT items, those will be, we're going to deal with those at a subsequent meeting, correct? Yeah, I believe that was the direction. I will highlight that again in the budget. Okay, I'm just, before we go through this whole thing and lock everything in, so I'll make sure there's not any outstanding stuff we've got to deal with. So, okay, so we've heard a staff presentation on the first of these resolutions. Any further questions for staff?
3:56:33 I'll make a motion that council... Hang on, public comment. Any thoughts from the public on this? One good, bad, indifferent, hearing none. Bring it back for deliberation. I'll make a motion that council adopts a resolution establishing the town of Mammoth Lakes appropriations limit as presented for fiscal year 18-19. Second. Thank you. Any further discussion? Muttering some staff over there, anything we need to know about? No.
3:57:03 Okay, good. So we have a motion to second. Any further discussion? Nope. Okay, roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, the item is agreed to 5-0. Move on to the next item, number two, adopt a resolution, reaffirm the Town of Mammoth Lakes investment policy for fiscal year 2018-19. Any staff? Yes, so each year of the last few years, we've brought this back forward to council to review our investment policy.
3:57:34 Last year, I don't think there's any changes. The last one was made in 1617. I got the dates right there. Where we increased the amount of money that we could invest in the Mono County investment pool. So we currently have a limit of $5 million. We have basically the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty invested at that level. Holds it there.
3:57:57 Primary difference, our other main investment tool is LAF, the local agency investment pool, investment fund. The differential that we look at these each year is on interest rates and earnings. The last few years, the Mono County pool has done substantially better than LAF. The last report we saw, they're getting much tighter. LAF is actually doing better than it has for a while, so within a half percent or less, they were almost a full point difference. Both are still relatively low.
3:58:26 Overall scale. But what we have done on that, and that was a question a while back in the budget hearing looking at what we're budgeting for interest in income, the two levels that impact that is the investments we make and then also obviously the amount of money invested. So the investment policy really looks at and looks at the various items and the areas where we can invest dollars. And while there's a number of items laid out in the resolution that we can invest into,
3:58:50 Currently the only two investments that we actually utilize is LAF and the county pool. That's correct. For investment of town funds. Okay. Any questions? Yeah. I would say the elements on that is security, liquidity, and then looking at rate of return. So those priorities. Okay. Any questions for staff? No. Nope. Okay. Thank you. Any thoughts on the public? Good, bad, or indifferent?
3:59:18 Hearing none, deliberation amongst members of council or a motion if that is desired. I'll just make a comment. I sit on the Treasury Committee and I believe they're very conservative. I think the return on our investment for the security is actually very, very good right now. Like Dan said, it's kind of gotten a little tighter, but I think we should feel very safe where we are.
3:59:47 One point I'll bring up is that there's been representation that the Federal Reserve is going to be, you know, potentially raising rates pretty methodically over the next year and a half. Would that have any effect on it? Yes. Yes, it will. Okay. Over time. We buy into bonds, but it's the decision of the Treasury Committee to hold till maturity instead of trading them. Right, right. So we always get our value out. Okay.
4:00:15 Is that anything we need to watch going forward? No, you may be aware of it. You always do. Right. And we have quarterly meetings, so it's actually, I think it's well run. I think it's good policy. Okay. Okay, good. Well, with that, I will make a motion. Okay, please. To adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes investment policy for fiscal year 2018-2019. I'll second. Okay, we have a motion to second. Any further discussion?
4:00:46 Hearing none, roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, item is agreed to 5-0. Moving on to item number three, adopt a resolution reaffirming a town of Mammoth Lakes reserve policy for fiscal year 2018-19. Yes, it's last year we had a fair amount of discussion related to our reserve policy last couple years. I think the town has had an informal policy at one point of a 25% reserve.
4:01:14 And other elements of that nature. Last year, we really tried to break it into three categories of reserves for the town, still looking at that overall 25% level, but it was broken into the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, which is a 16% level of our income, looking at the general fund, an operating reserve, which would be 9% of the general fund revenue, and then a contingency reserve, which is a budgeted $100,000.
4:01:44 Within the operating budget. The reserve policy continues that same allocations at this point. The reserve for economic uncertainty is currently funded fully at the current balance of 3.425 from the last year. It would be moving up to 3.65 to maintain that full funding.
4:02:05 The budget incorporates out of the extra $1 million of TOT dollars that we've allocated in the budget, we touched on the workshop and in previous hearings, that $225,000 of that would go into the REU to maintain that 16% level. The operating reserve has some dollars from the last...
4:02:24 A couple of budget amendments that went in, the modifications, there's $302,000 there. At this point, we're not recommending any additional dollars from the operating budget. That would be addressed again with any larger than anticipated revenue and or savings as we look at finalizing out the current year. So that would currently be at a lower level than the 9%. It's only 15% of what we're trying to get to. So that would be about a $1.9 million or so.
4:02:53 Goal target there. And then the contingency as part of the operating budget is fully funded at $100,000. So the question before council, if you're satisfied with the continued allocation between the types of reserves or looking at those percentages, there's been discussions in the past in terms of the reserve levels. We think they're conservative in one sense, but the sense that we have strong discipline and not utilizing them for other than the purposes identified, it represents a
4:03:22 A healthy way to move forward in terms of preparing for any unknowns as we go into the future. Okay, thank you. And I'm assuming what you've represented, Dan, might be reading of the resolution that's reflected in the resolution, correct? That is correct. Okay. Any questions for staff? Any thoughts or comments from the public? Hearing none. Deliberation? Potentially a motion.
4:03:48 Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion to adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town Amendment Lakes Reserve Policy for fiscal year 1819. Thank you. Second. So we have a motion to second. Any further discussion? I just think this is a really smart policy that we've established. Absolutely. So I think this is something that this council should be proud of in conjunction with the work staff's done. I think this is really solid.
4:04:10 Cool. Yeah, it's exciting. Cool. It's more exciting than this other stuff, yeah. Nice. Okay, any further discussion? No. Right on. Jamie, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The item is agreed to 5-0. Moving on to item number 4, adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes debt policy for fiscal year 2018-19.
4:04:37 Yeah, I think this is the first time in terms of doing a review of it. The law changed in January 2017 that requires towns and others who are issuing debt to follow guidance provided in Government Code Section 8855. I think that's aye.
4:04:55 A section there and it has certain standards, it has to be met within the debt policy. When we did the last bond issue, once that was brought to our attention that we needed to have that, we put together the initial debt policy, brought that forward. It touches on a number of the different types of debt and different limits on that. The one addition that we've added in there is a little bit of language related to internal debt.
4:05:16 That was not there before, and we do have a current internal loan with that. Just in terms of having a policy that covers the different types of debts that we do use, it was prudent to be able to add that piece in there. It provides really basic language. I don't need to, it's in the packet if you want to read through that, but allows us to do an internal loan and set the terms and conditions of it, which is also required in other portions of government code. And so the idea here, it does help us
4:05:45 As this is one of the elements when we go forward for debt, it'll be a question is do you have a debt policy in place? What does that look like? And this really does meet the minimum requirements of the government code. Other agencies can have a much larger one or much more detailed and get into more minutiae when you do a lot of debt issuances. We don't really do that much, frankly. And so the recommendation would be to move forward with the
4:06:13 Policy is proposed with the one addition with the statement on the internal debt. Thank you. Any questions for staff? So this is just kind of general policy. It doesn't provide any specific metrics or framework. Correct. Some of them have got into that requiring coverage ratios on debt or looking at total maximum debt to retirement.
4:06:39 Terms and those types of elements. And usually that's when you're dealing with a lot more geo-debt. Often you also will have other enterprises, like you'll have water and sewer and stuff like that. So you're dealing with a much larger bond portfolio. And so there will be a lot more metrics that people would tie into that. We do have a couple things. I know a refunding. You have to have a minimum of a 3% net present value savings before that moves forward. So it is pretty general to meet the minimum requirements of the government code.
4:07:08 So I think there's no need to go into any further detail in this specific area. I think we've kind of started to have some of those conversations as a council about where our debt ratio is at and that level of comfort. I mean, there's those questions and concerns out in the community. So I'm fine as long as we continue to have that check-in. I don't think it needs to be here, but I think that's just something we should continue to check in on. No question. Okay, any other questions for staff?
4:07:38 Any comments from the public? This is your opportunity, good, bad, or indifferent. Okay, hearing none, I would just, again, going back to days gone by when the town had so many internal loans, the public got frustrated and said, we can't make any sense out of this budget process and how the people, how the hell you guys are Kentucky in business. So I'm very grateful to see this, and I'm grateful that it's...
4:08:07 We're nice, simple, clear, easy to understand. And so I appreciate this. Any further deliberation or thoughts? Cool. Cool. Okay. I'll go ahead and make a motion that adopt a resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes debt policy for fiscal year 1819. I'll second that. Thank you. Any further discussion? Hearing none, roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yep.
4:08:37 Yes. Yes. Item is agreed to 5-0. The final item of this hearing, adopt a resolution approving the annual budget for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for fiscal year 2018-19 as presented or the Council directed modifications. Council directed modifications, sorry. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Where do you want us to be working off for this, Dan? It's the second PowerPoint.
4:09:02 That was handed out. It's very similar to the one we went through at the public hearing, so I will go fairly quickly through the majority of the slides. There'll be a couple to highlight again as part of the hearing process. Yeah, sorry. Before I dive into the detail on it, I think there was three items I wanted to touch on related to the budget, if there's any request to do modifications or not, and then we could touch on where that would happen.
4:09:36 Mona County Southern Historical Society requested a consideration of a $15,000 allocation versus a $13,000 allocation. The other question came up on that is ownership of the Hayden Cabin. My understanding from discussing with one of the historians from the Historical Society is that that cabin is owned by the Forest Service. It has a small area for their use permit that the cabin sits on.
4:10:03 And then some of the other area falls into the town's overall park special use permit.
4:10:09 What we're recommending on that is to leave the actually budgeted allocation at $13,000. We will reach out, if not already done so, to the historical society. If they have a particular project where they're needing some additional funding for, to make that a formalized request and then to take a look at that and say, how do we want to help with that project? And whether that's another $2,000 or $3,000 or $4,000, whatever that number may be or less, to be able to tie that into a project versus
4:10:37 Just bumping this up on a project basis. Next year, I'm assuming we'll have a similar request to look at bumping this up at some level. The highest amount that the Historical Society has received from the town that we could identify was $15,000, I think on three different occasions, three or four. How much? 15 was the maximum. That was reduced on a couple different times, and it was reduced down fairly substantially, I think, to 10 through the restructuring under the settlement discussions.
4:11:05 And slowly we've kind of added some dollars back into there over time. Right now this year was $12,150. We looked at originally starting this budget at $12,500 and so the recommendation then was a bump at the $13,000. And so we would not be recommending moving it back at this point. If you wish to do that we could do that. But we'd rather work with them on a project base and say what is it that you really need to invest in versus just a straight grant. As I remember they talked about a roof.
4:11:36 Yeah, they have a couple, they have roof, they have some electrical work, they've come in for some permits, they were asking for a waiver, I think it's like $200 a permit fee, so it wasn't much, but we'd much rather sit down with them and say, okay, what exactly are you looking at and work with it? What specific project? Yeah. Okay. So that would be one. The other one was a request coming from Mammoth Lakes Recreation, the trails group, looking at setting aside money for a trail program.
4:12:02 For signage repair, both our internal to the town, like some of our MUPS and maps and upgrading that and some other areas. This has actually been an ongoing question in terms of the maintenance of the signs. We have not established a formal program actually to do that. The request here again is initially, I would suggest you look at this as a, again, larger than anticipated funding. Here's a program, what does it look like? Let's set it up. What does it look like over time?
4:12:30 So here would be initial allocation of money, assuming we have additional funding of X dollars, be that the $26,000 ask or give or take, depending on the program. And then the request at that point in time is what makes sense for a reasonable dollar amount on an ongoing basis then? Is it $5,000, $10,000, $15,000, $20,000 and tie it to a program that's developed and so we can have a more focused issue versus kind of a shot. We're updating signage over time. Yes.
4:12:59 Maintaining things. Maintaining, right. Makes sense. It would be a maintenance program that we'd need to look into. So one time it might be a little higher to get caught up and then lower if necessary. But we really don't have that well-defined. And I'd rather have a defined program. And, Dan, the existing annual allocation we have, this would not be eligible for that, correct? You lost me. Well, I was going to point out that because, like, the metal signs are on the ground.
4:13:27 We're acquired through a contract with the town through R and other outside means. Measure R money cannot be used to maintain that stuff because it's a supplanting issue. So it can't come out of the development of what the need is, the work done to create the messaging, do the maps, do all that kind of work, that can come out of the TRAILS program. But the actual physical thing. But it's got to be new development. Yeah, it's got to be because otherwise it's a supplanting issue.
4:13:55 Part of that goal, too, is not to take these ongoing maintenance projects and start to layer those on Measure R or Measure U. If we can keep those for that reinvestment in our product into the trails or into the facilities. Otherwise, at some point, you have no dollars left for expansion there. You're doing maintenance. Ultimately, we may get there, but on these smaller items like this, I think they're probably more appropriately
4:14:21 Built into a maintenance program with the general fund and then you're not worried about was this constructed by Major R and is it eligible? It takes that issue off the table so you're not just the accounting and tracking and et cetera for that type of issues. Yeah, I just want to clarify that. Okay. So neither of those items have been increased or put into the budget. So clarification there. Then last one from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the request earlier in the
4:14:48 Part of the workshop was to request a use of reserves out of Mammoth Lakes Tourism for, I think, three different programs. One was an update in the fish stocking, the storytelling with the historical society group and the trolleys, and the third one was related to special events. Based on the comment earlier, we would come back either to your next meeting.
4:15:16 Based on discussions with MLT and the timing that's required to consider that. The other option on that obviously goes into the larger discussion are those items that you would rather have funded directly out of measure A dollars on the front end versus out of a joint bucket, but that would be a discussion at that point in time. I would just request that as those get developed that MLT consult with MLR because
4:15:40 What's happening on the trial is we had a guy, there's a guy from the Wilderness Society who's a national recreation, Paul Sanford, who's here a week or so ago. And they're looking at how with our unique wilderness opportunities here, how could they maybe, how could we integrate that in with the visitor experience? And there may be some opportunities coming out of that to, you know, just, I don't know, just take the program and build something out of it. And so MLR, Matt's familiar with that, maybe get those people talking to each other a little bit about how that might work. And I think, you know, just
4:16:09 My role as the MLT representative, I mean, I think, you know, looking at a program like fish stocking or looking at the storyteller program, I think that's, you know, they're great and their investments and the experience and all that kind of stuff. I would suggest that we probably have maybe a more detailed conversation as a council with MLT regarding the events position because there seems to be a lot of conversation about that in our meetings, a lot of moving parts, you know, whether
4:16:38 The town continues to fund that 125 in perpetuity, whether that dries up at some point, whether that's a Measure A obligation, whether that's a joint bucket, you know, eligible thing. So I think we've on this council for three or four years now pushed to find a home for events because we see the value and the importance in it. I think MLT is willing to take that on and that's probably the right place to do it. But there's.
4:17:06 You know, if the $125,000 goes away, if we're talking about one position, if we're talking about two positions, if we're talking about allocating additional dollars to our events, I mean, there's, you know, it could be anywhere between, you know, $100,000 and $350,000. So I think from a budgeting perspective for MLT, we need to have a very specific and direct conversation, Council MLT, about...
4:17:29 How we feel about events funding moving forward. That was one of the three things that Brent brought up. Correct. You know, I mean, it's something to say, hey, does this need to be something that we factor into our ongoing budget at MLT? Is it a Measure A obligation? Is it something the town's going to be willing to continue to fund?
4:17:44 Or is it eligible? You know, they're looking to get some guidance from the council on how we feel about that specifically. And I would imagine that's going to go, that would go to the contract. That's one of those things we put in the contract. Yeah. So I think, you know, those requests maybe come back at a later date, but I also think we just need to have a more detailed conversation specifically about events funding moving forward. On the events, for sure. I mean, that's not baked all the way. Right. And it needs to be. And I think making some of those strategic decisions.
4:18:12 At MLT, who they hire, what level, how many positions, those type of things need some council direction on the front end. But, you know, I personally, the storytelling, you know. I think it's so cool. It is. It's great. And it's a great thing for the visitors. If we wait on that, then it's going to be we don't have a meeting on July 4th. I don't think you guys are going to make any decisions on the 20th.
4:18:40 So we're halfway into December before that. And I go, why wait? How much are they asking for on that? The storyteller would be $15,500. And then the fish stocking is $50,000. So I think those are... They have $40,000 allocated. Correct. But that may come out of the budget and full obligation go to the joint bucket.
4:19:10 What about the storytellers? So the storytelling, there's currently 7,500 that was allocated from Measure U. That basically gave them a pretty limited time frame that they could operate this program. It's a six-hour program from like noon to six on two buses going through the Lakes Basin.
4:19:36 So they're paying people to do the time for Friday, Saturday, Sunday. What the ask is looking at that budget to try and blow that program out to like June through, you know, I think they said September, sometime in September. That's the additional ask would be a 15-5 ask. So let me make a recommendation. So I think that's somewhat time sensitive. Just to clarify on the fish stocking. Is that time sensitive?
4:20:04 Ish, you know, because we are starting to get into summer and people are going to start to come up for fishing. We're already into the season. They are currently allocating $40,000 out of the budget, but the discussion today was maybe that gets reinvested back into marketing, which took a little bit of a hit if the full 50 can come out of the joint bucket, just to be clear. It's not a 10 ask, it's a 50 ask. Let's get some staff reports and some items and we'll do it the next time. But I think...
4:20:30 Again, I want to... We're actually funding some of that, so that's not... The first couple drops are covered. Right. So I just think, to Shields' point, though, I think the events conversation is maybe a little bit more detailed, whereas the other one, I think we can get a staff report at the next meeting and provide some direction. Okay. But I just want people to be aware of that, that that conversation needs to be had.
4:20:54 And I think the fish stocking is hugely important. I think that the storytelling went over huge last year and needs to be continued. But there's confusion. Is it 7,500? Is it another 15? Is there 10 for fish stocking so that we can put back in? So I need the answers to those before I can make a... We'll bring that forward. That'll be part of the report. In writing, and then we can all hash that out. Yeah, but the only thing I say is, you know, it'd be July 18th before...
4:21:24 Well, but I think – We could bring something back to your next meeting. Yeah, the 20th weekend on the front end of our meeting. Yeah, or the back end. We can look at those two items specifically, the storytelling and the first time. We can do either with the old or the new council. Yeah. Yeah, I would imagine you guys would be supportive of that. I would – I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I would like to see – does anybody have a copy of the storytelling? Because I know that we were talking about that last year.
4:21:49 I was under the impression that it did not happen, that they reserved those funds for this year. So if there is anybody that has video, I am totally unaware of that, and I did not have one person anywhere say to me, oh, they have storytelling on a bus. So there is obviously everybody else knows about it, but I don't know how I missed it.
4:22:15 It seems as though somebody would say, hey, you've got a really cool thing here in town. So maybe that just needs to be better advertised or if anybody has any examples of what they did last year. So that would be nice. Yeah, maybe if that could be part of what it is. You can ask. I don't know. I did not witness it. So. OK, so you have a presentation, Dan. Is there anything else? Those were the items there, the modifying of this. And so I'll kind of go through the budget process relatively quickly because you saw it in the workshop. Right.
4:22:43 Again, a lot of it will be a review, but fund types, the different types of way of the budget, how it gets structured, fund, accounts, you know, you know, the detail levels, and then what we do accounting-wise with activities or job codes that we walk through with that. Each fund has its own set of accounts, its own accounting thing, and then it goes into the total budget.
4:23:05 A lot of discussion earlier, but kind of on how our fund balances work. There's definitely different classifications of fund balance, what you can use with them, whether it's legally restricted, whether it's committed, which is very specific, determined by formal action of the council, unspendable inventory, receivables, those types of things. The assigned amounts, how are we sitting that very specifically, again, to meet a criteria that's not committed or restricted, but we assign it to a particular purpose.
4:23:34 And then obviously the unassigned with those dollars that would be available in each fund for the legal purposes that the fund is created for. Kind of a snapshot of some of the funds and the dollars available. This is based on the current modified budget. It's not a representation where we'll be at the end of the year. We will not know all of those fund balance until we actually close out the year, which happens in that after July and August, which is our accrual period.
4:24:02 And then it would be in the September-October timeframe before we have all of our fund balances funneled out. Several of the funds do carry fund balances, some of them very substantial, like in our vehicle replacement program. Some of those do have commitments in them. Measure U, for example, $2.5 million for the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center. Again, that was a commitment by council. You could change that commitment down the road, but right now as we do elements, we identify that as a committed fund balance.
4:24:31 A few others in there as well. Before I jump into the revenue side, just any follow-up questions on the fund balance component? I'm going over that pretty quick. We spent time in the workshop, so I just want to make sure if there's any questions that came to mind. Are we good? No. Some people shake their heads. I think we're good. The next two slides really take a look at the overall budget, total revenues.
4:25:00 Where we're coming in with a proposed budget of 18-19 of $39,868,715. And then for our total appropriations in all the funds, ultimately at $44,669,009. And so that would be, if you talk about what's your total budget, we often know which number do you utilize. Usually it's that appropriation number, so you could say your total budget's just under $45 million.
4:25:28 For that. That includes transfers and some other elements in there, but that's a true representation of the appropriation authority that's granted in terms of all the detail and the line items of the budget. This here includes all the various revenue sources and all the funds. So that's a total picture there for those elements. The one piece that wouldn't be in there would be a trust and agency fund where we have like cash on deposit for a particular purpose. If we don't use it, we'd actually have to give it back.
4:25:57 Those types of issues. So those are held separately. The other one where this all comes together is in the combined fund statement. This actually allows you to walk by every fund. I think there's 37 funds the town utilizes. And it walks through that big picture. Here's total revenue. The transfers in and out, the movement between the funds. And then total resources, which would be the transfers in and the new revenue. And then your expenditures.
4:26:26 And then those expenditures are augmented by the transfers again, in and out, moved over from one fund to another, total appropriations there, and then it highlights the change in fund balance at that point, and ultimately when you finalize this with hard fund balances, you'd know what your totals were, and that would be part of a future element as we close out the fiscal year. So I'll pause there, just again, big picture on terms of total funds there and the total dollars.
4:26:55 If you walk through those, those totals kind of tie back up to those sheets before so you can kind of link the dollars back together as need be. So any questions for Dan? So if I'm looking to see the balanced budget numbers, where do I find that? So the balanced budget issue, if you look on this combined fund statement, you turn around and say, we have total resources in the general fund of $22,791,152. Our total appropriation there,
4:27:25 It's $21,738,431. Right. So we are actually going to spend a little less than we're bringing in. Okay. That's a good sign. So we actually have a fund balance increase of $1,052,721. Okay. That is primarily generated by the revenue side where we've committed additional million dollars in TOT revenue to go to our various housing, tourism, transit, and dollars that were set aside for REU for fund balance. Right.
4:27:53 And then there's some dollars there that you could allocate in the future to a project. And that's based on a $13.5 million. Yeah. Operating revenue is based on $13.5. Operating revenue. Spence is based on the $12.5. Correct. Yeah. Correct. Okay. Good. Thank you. So, good question. If you look across one of these where it's zero change in fund balance, that would be a perfectly balanced. Yeah. Right.
4:28:18 But there's a rationale for why it is. Correct. In some cases, you'll see a use of fund balance. For example, in the measure R trails, you'll see a $265,000 use of fund balance. Those are dollars that were previously set aside for capital purposes, capital projects. We're actually recommending $265,000 be appropriated for that purpose out of that fund balance. Okay. Everybody happy? Any questions from the public? No?
4:28:48 Okay, all funds employees? Yes, the budget supports 66 full-time town employees, and then 13.8 equivalent FTEs of part-time. The part-time employee on an FTE would be 2,080 hours. That core services the town provides is really tied to that 66 employees. You know, that's public works, police, admin, et cetera, in that amount.
4:29:14 And then the part-time employees do both their way for us to add capacity in particular areas, and a lot of it has become part of our core service delivery capability. For example, in snow removal, the three positions shown there were equivalent of six part-time positions that supplement our full-time staff. Without those six positions, we would be providing a substantially lower level of service in snow removal, for example.
4:29:41 It does fluctuate depending on being able to keep bodies on board and stuff. It's been as high as six, as low as four in terms of the last couple of years. On the other side, you look at the capital projects where we have a .6 position there. That is a dedicated intern coming in to work on those capital projects, which actually frees up other staff time and adds capacity to the engineering department to be able to meet their requirements.
4:30:06 And then some of the others, obviously, in there, like in our rec programs, our parks maintenance, which is more of a summer-focused effort and those types of things, where we actually have the service levels tied to that part-time, mainly because of the way the services are provided and demands there. Our parks programs, for example, rec programs are seasonal in nature, so we hire the seasonal employees.
4:30:28 And so we have a total count of just under 80 FTEs, 79.8, 66 full-time men and women committed to doing quality service here in the community. As you saw at the beginning of the meeting, one of our part-time seasonal employees, Hayden, who saved a gentleman's life at the track. That's pretty exciting in my book. And then also the new police officers and issues going on in our community tonight. So we applaud the people who do our work. It's tight.
4:30:57 In terms of our staffing levels, and each department could probably tell you areas where they could use additional support. But we did bring this budget in this year, really trying to keep it tight and not move our full-time employee number up. We did add a couple of the intern positions that were tied to different funding, some of those for grants and capital being the two areas. The other piece to this then is how is our employees funded? How do we allocate them across?
4:31:27 They cross funds from the general fund on down to garage services. There's actually two pages in your packet. You'll see that. And again, a lot of our employees will be allocated across different departments, particularly in Public Works. Some of the community development folks, they'll be charged in a variety of areas. And so we do our best guess at the beginning of the budget year of where we think people work in time. We look at histories.
4:31:53 That's not always correct. Like this last winter, for example, we had more people allocated in the snow removal. We didn't have any snow. I think it was for almost three months. So they were working on other projects, but they weren't assigned to a snow-related expenditure. So the general fund actually had higher cost because there wasn't snow removal. Two years ago, it was just the opposite. Big snow, we got a lot of people doing that. And so we try to allocate based on it.
4:32:21 Normal year if there is such a thing anymore with some of the changes going on in our climate elements. But this lays that out. So again, this will change throughout the year. So one of the issues in the budget, we do end up working within the budgets to keep people busy and do work as the priorities that are called out and those types of things. But you'll see our total personnel across all funds just under $11.1 million. And it does highlight the various areas that they're funded in. Again,
4:32:52 Salaries, wages, health insurance, and PERS being the three largest areas of cost for our employee base. The PERS retirement account, $2.2 million cost is split about equally between a long-term liability with PERS of about $14 million and then the annual allocation that we get from PERS in terms of the percentage charge to employees. Any questions on just the allocation of labor and a big picture there and number of employees? Questions?
4:33:23 Nope. Nope. I think we're good. Won't spend as much time on this, but I did want to highlight again just some of the labor concerns. Things are pretty tight as we come in to look at a priority-setting element later this summer. We'd be looking at just how tight these areas are and how we have people assigned. And a lot of times the things that we look at grants and really going after those, when we get one, that means often our match is not cash, but it's in kind.
4:33:49 Which means hours of time committed. And so we do have to work through those issues and where those priorities are. As they mentioned, somewhat facetiously but real, we don't have a lot of employees wondering what they're going to do the next day. There's a fair amount of work going and people do do a great job of stepping up and helping in different areas. I.E. that's why we're doing this this evening as Rob had a family emergency and we're happy to backfill.
4:34:16 He had probably had more notes on this than I do. The element there, though, I think is really that constrained capacity makes for some tough decisions down the road. Do we add bodies? Do we add part-time? Do we contract out and manage those? Do we say no to something? There's some other grants. We're going to have a great opportunity for money coming into the region. How do we get the capacity to manage that element to the extent we have opportunities for those? Questions on that one at all? Then we kind of, you know, go from the overall big picture down to the general fund.
4:34:48 The general fund gets the most scrutiny, the most discussion, and frankly provides the highest level of services in terms of most of those 66 employees are funded out of our general fund. We have total revenues in there of just under $22.8 million. TOT is the primary of that, about 61 million, or 61%.
4:35:09 The total revenue comes out of TOT between assessments and charges and everything. The real operating budget number that we work with is that $12.5 million in actual TOT revenue coming in. Some of the others we will really try to manage because they're up and down. They're not guaranteed. They're based on our compliance issues and enforcement issues. The other two elements rounding out for just over about 86% of the total budget is sales tax and property tax.
4:35:37 Both of which we have influences over, but they're all tied to the health of our economy and what happens in those areas. So when we look at growing our general fund, at this point, the primary growth area has been really in the TOT revenue. Property tax, you know, can only go up by 2% per year plus new growth, but also you saw a few years back, economy goes down, property tax goes down. Sales tax, again, is a function of how much activity going on in the community.
4:36:09 As that relates to our employee budget in the general fund, your $7.9 million in personnel cost, you know, that 11-some that's total, the majority is in the general fund. You can see, again, the allocations there by the various categories that turn into those dollars. And you see in the general fund, that's where we saw the increase in salaries. A question this evening was looking at that growth.
4:36:36 This is the easiest one to calculate. If you look at this, you'll see a 5.4% growth year over year, about $410,000. And so as we look at the revenue opportunities to keep pace with the growth of cost of services, and we have other cost elements that go up too, just like any other business, if it's fuel or energy or contractual issues or insurance issues to deal with. But in terms of this one here is a primary driver for that. So how do we look at sustainability over time?
4:37:06 Both as we have to add additional bodies as well as maintaining our current workforce is a critical issue as you look at a long-term picture within the town. The other items driving cost outlined here. Again, I won't walk through them all, but you can walk through that pieces in that portion of the budget as well, which is just over in the operating side of that $13.7 million in the bottom of the slide. There you see that.
4:37:36 And so this kind of lays out those detail areas where you can see this doesn't include all the transfers. Well, it has the one line up for transfer out, which goes to a variety of places. You'll know it in a moment. And then we go down from the big picture of the fund down to the department level. So this is the one you can take a look year over year at the various departments, where are those expenditures going? Some of it's pretty linear. Some of it, again, as we move bodies around, that'll impact that. If you move somebody at one point, we move somebody out of finance into payroll or into HR, so there'll be a shifting of a body in the department.
4:38:06 Or there will be, again, general services or pretty good savings in insurance. You see a savings there. Other departments, you'll have the bump-ups. You also get changes in departments from status of employees. For example, if somebody has a family and their insurance amount changes or vice versa, they end up single again. You could have an insurance change, those types of things.
4:38:28 Those will drive some of the cost elements there. So this here kind of is a snapshot of the general fund departments. The detail providing your packet really walks through each line item in the departments. Dan, can you go back one slide to general fund expenditure employees? So looking down at that, you know, most of that $410,000 increase from a percentage basis at least is temporary wages, which makes sense to me.
4:38:56 Health insurance and PERS are pretty significant. We've talked about that at length. The other one would be workers' comp insurance. I know it's a more nominal dollar number but a higher percentage. Is that just as a result of general trends and increases? Do we have claims that are impacting that? What's the status of that? Claims do affect that, and they usually have a look-back period, and so then we get a...
4:39:24 They tell us basically what our workman's comp is going to be at the beginning of the year. We pay it all on July 1st. And so based on the activity of claims, and we're in a pool, it's not just the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're in a pool of other people, so it is also dependent on what other municipalities are doing as well. So it'd be relatively unlikely that that pool would go without a claim for a three- or a five-year time frame. That's correct. If you look at the actuals for...
4:39:54 15, 16, 16, 17. Yeah. Good? Yeah. Yeah, and it's driven by claims. It can be just, it's a number of smaller ones, and you could have a couple of have a larger, it's... Yeah, sure. I do have a question on general fund expenditure summary by category. Miscellaneous expenses. That went down quite a bit. I'm just curious what you're... My guess is that... Did I just look at the actual? You're right.
4:40:34 I'm just wondering if you pulled some out of it. I'd have to go back and do the detail in there for you, but it looks like we tied to the, I don't see it called out separately, it would be the insurance component that we did see a pretty good drop on, so. Okay. The liability insurance, I think would be the majority of that. Okay. Good. That was the departmental, and then here's kind of the pie chart summary of the various departmental areas within the general fund.
4:41:13 And again, it's no surprise here, the largest component really being our police department side, which is almost, well, it's all general fund. There are some dedicated grant dollars that come in that can only be used for police services, a COPS grant, for example, from the state each year of $100,000. And then they do have some revenues they generate as well, but it is one of those core services cities provide, and it's a good chunk of our change.
4:41:42 The transfers out, mentioned that earlier, this is primarily for debt and some capital, but the transfers out go into the various debt components. You see that here. And then the other major, two other major ones would be our general fund contribution into gas tax and to the road maintenance fund and to the airport.
4:42:05 $2.2 million into gas tax and $644,000 to the airport, transfers out from the general fund to support those. The airport went down a little bit this year for some of the operating costs, as you'll notice that, and the gas tax actually went up a little, so in terms of those dollars. And the gas tax transfer, the really impact on that depends on what we get from our snow reimbursement, which is always a year behind. So this very light year, that means next year less.
4:42:32 The current year we're in, we actually got a pretty good bump from the heavy snow the previous year. So it runs a year behind in that reimbursement component. And that would wrap up the general fund side of this. If you have any questions on that, if not, we'll kind of jump through some of the larger special revenue funds. Questions? Good. Questions from the public? Thank you. Gas tax is one of the other largest funds and also one of the more other, I'll say, important funds in terms of core services because this really is our road maintenance and our snow removal.
4:43:03 Two elements that we take a lot of pride in in terms of having a great system for moving a lot of snow on a regular basis. And also from a community standpoint as well, you know, some neighborhoods will complain of the conditions of the roads. Overall, we're actually in pretty good shape. And we hope to continue that by continuing to make those investments and keeping elements going that way to where we have an annual allocation going into that road fund for that element to maintain.
4:43:31 One of our core infrastructure elements. And so, again, without walking through a lot of detail there, we do have some new money, SB1 dollars coming into this fund doing projects, and then it's the actual gas tax revenue, snow removal payback, and then the general fund.
4:43:50 Are the primary funding sources for this. Again, a lot of different elements go into this because it's not just, I'll say, road maintenance and stuff, but it's also our striping program. It's blowing out culverts. It's the curb and gutter cleanup and things of that nature that our public works crew does a great job with. Questions on gas tax? Nope. Public? Nope. So, nope. The other major, couple major funds are restricted revenues. Measure R, which is a transient,
4:44:22 Transaction and use tax, or TUT, versus a pure sales tax, and there's some distinctives there, but basically the sales tax for Measure R will do about 55% of what the 1% sales tax is coming into the town. It'll fluctuate a little bit on that, but it's pretty close to that number. Revenue projected is, excuse me, would be coming in in that one point,
4:45:00 Three or so level in terms of revenue coming into Measure R. We have an ongoing transfer out to the Trails Fund. We create a separate fund to track the Trails dollars so they got retained over time. So the Measure R, the Fund 215, only has that transfer in. And then we did, last year, we did a one-time funding for capital. And so again, that would be the other expenditure there, as I noted earlier, that $265,000.
4:45:29 Showing excess in there, which would be the capital work that's going into that. Thank you. So the expenditure side also shows the debt payment for the bonds were issued to support the multi-use facility. Kind of the, I guess the sister to that is Measure U. We often refer to them together, Measure R and U. Again, a utility user tax generates between $800,000 and $900,000 a year. About $900,000, I believe, is in the budget for revenues, for
4:46:05 Measure U. A lot of that not committed in the annual budget here in terms of the operating budget, but looking at down the road, a lot of commitment to this fund. The one element in here in the budget does have $70,000 looking at a joint position with the Eastern Sierra Recreation Partnership. And then also down the road, we would have support again for the MAC coming out of reserves and looking at ongoing operational support for that facility.
4:46:35 The Measure R has a similar element in there. We've talked about it in some of the discussions. It's not budgeted there, but ultimately with the multi-use facility, looking at up to $75,000 or so ongoing support for that facility operationally. That would come in for actual actions as those projects come forward. But we keep that in mind as you look at what you're putting into these funds. Any questions related to RU or gas tax or the other restricted fund there?
4:47:06 No, I think we're good. If not, the next big one is the airport. It includes a $644,000 transfer from the general fund and also revenue generated at the airport. Any of the revenues generated from the airport are restricted to airport purposes. We get a passenger facility charge for each passenger in planes there.
4:47:33 Those are restricted to capital projects as defined in our ALP, airport layout plan, and can only be used at the airport, along with the other revenue sites. That's something in the FAA, we deal with them a lot. They're very clear that the revenue generation goes back into the airport. For that, we do have capital dollars in there. Some of those are general fund dollars that have been committed there for the time being. Pending long-term discussion on the airport, that may change with the council discussion.
4:48:02 The other large area is really our capital improvement program. The items here listed are the proposed projects in the current operating budget. The expenses for 18-19 is the estimated expenditures in each of those areas that we anticipate in 18-19. I almost guarantee you those will shift around and move a little bit, maybe a little higher, a little lower, depending on the actual projects, the bids, and then just the timing as we look at our fiscal year.
4:48:32 A lot of the capital projects definitely extend across that June 30, July 1st number. But this is our estimate now. When we set up the budget, the capital project funding becomes continuously appropriated. So if we do know we have dollars here and the project's going, we move then to meet the project timing, which often we can't always control. So that element's there. And we spent some time earlier kind of walking through some of those elements. And the SB1C and G is curb and gutter work.
4:49:02 And then we walk through a lot of our smaller funds. We have a number of development impact fees. This is a revenue element to this. At this point, we do not have any of the money budgeted. It would actually come with a project that would be eligible for the money at the time of the approval of the project, and we would ask for the allocation of the funds to be used accordingly.
4:49:23 The town has a number of assessment districts or benefit assessment districts that are funded by the assessments on the properties. Again, used primarily for snow removal. There is some road improvement elements or sidewalk or beautification, i.e. Old Mammoth Road, areas that can be utilized from these various funds. Again, we spent a little more time earlier on those. Unless there's a question, I'll move right on through.
4:49:49 Our vehicle replacement fund, we've spent time on this in the past. It's broken out by division. We do set aside money based on the cost of each vehicle, but within a division that may move around based on the piece of equipment that needs to be replaced. You may recall this last year, we bought a new blower loader. It was $750,000 for that piece of equipment, so we do set aside a lot for those things, and we tend to use them
4:50:19 Longer than what their normal useful life is. Again, looking at in the budget, it would be acquisition of a couple of police vehicles and two administrative division vehicles in terms of the allocation of $200,000 for that purpose. Lastly, Fund 990 is our debt fund. This walks through each of our debt payments that we do have.
4:50:43 Also, within the 990 fund, we have a reserve in there currently of about $45,000 that goes to our technology and other upgrades in town. And so that's usually a mid-year element. We'll put dollars aside for that. That's a committed reserve from the council, one that, again, could be moved accordingly down the road. But we don't want to fall behind in that. The town's gone through that several years ago and being able to stay up-to-date in a lot of those technology areas, I think, is an important element in how we provide services.
4:51:10 So with that deep breath, and that would conclude our presentation on the budget. The budget resolution is presented, walks through the actions there, allows us to make any typographical changes and things of that nature. And then the actual adoption would include the line item detail that is in your packet. That would represent the adopted formalized budget, which goes by fund, by department, and then by line item. Thank you, Dan. Thank you.
4:51:39 Okay, so any questions on Dan's presentation we just heard? I have some. Any thoughts or comments from the public? Please, come forward. Just a question on your development impact fees. In 2015, you reduced them substantially, about 75%. Is this still reflective of that reduction? Yes, it is. Thank you. Thank you. Anything else?
4:52:19 Okay, so with that, deliberations, motions? I will make a motion to adopt a resolution approving the annual budget for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for fiscal year 1819 as presented. I'll second. Okay, any further discussion? I think we've seen this enough. I just, real quick, just for...
4:52:50 I think some items that I tracked going through here. At some point in the future, a presentation on the PERS, outstanding PERS obligations. Correct. The labor concerns, that that be documented for council priority setting in a way that we can understand what's going on with that. The credit card for charity, wasn't that part of this? Yeah, that question came up. We'll review and see whether that... Okay, is there any options with that?
4:53:15 I think the concerns about the airport is associated with air service that may be something we need to be keeping an eye out in the fall. And the DIF review potentially coming up in the CIP presentation. Those are just things we kind of track to everyone so we don't lose those going forward. And one more miscellaneous expense if you could just. Yeah. Okay. Any further discussion in addition to that? No? Jamie?
4:53:45 The roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. The item is agreed to unanimously. Dan, thanks to you. Thanks to Rob. Thanks to Cindy. Thanks to the whole team. As thorough as it can get, I would say. Thank you. I'll mention just on that, too, the department's put a lot of effort into these and they build them. Thanks to all departments, all those people in the cheap seats over there. Thank you all very much. Excellent job. Thank you. Okay.
4:54:14 Now we're moving on to item 15, fiscal year 2018-19 master fee schedule update for Town of Mammoth Lakes. This is still a public hearing, so I will open the public hearing. And staff, please. Thank you. Yeah, each year we come forward looking at the fee schedule. We walk through the various categories, usually by departments. This year there's actually very few changes that are being recommended. The staff report kind of walks through and touches on those.
4:54:44 We look at fees in a number of ways. In some cases, we want to have full cost recovery, and it's actually like an accounted type deal. We'll get a deposit in, we'll charge against it, we'll track time. Others are, I'll say quasi-full cost. We'll do an average of the time and effort spent on something and have a flat dollar amount. Other areas, we actually go in and say we are going by choice subsidized.
4:55:07 Our fee structure. That's mainly in our like our rec programs where we want the participation. It's not so much about the dollar generation. So that's anywhere from a 20 percent on average, maybe up a little higher on some of the adult elements for recreation. And then we do have the building department, building division fees, which are pretty much cost recovery. A lot of it's formula driven as it looks at the cost of construction as a way to do that. A few years ago we modified how that worked.
4:55:34 Trying to level out some of the fee issues that were there. The attachment kind of walks through that. We do not have a PowerPoint on this. The administrative fees, finance fees, the really only change there was adding in one that was discussed as part of the cannabis work. The auditing process, there would be a $4,000 annual fee. That is for two audits per year, which are estimated at $2,000 each. So that fee would come into that.
4:56:02 The Parks and Recreation Department had a number of changes which you approved earlier. This is one, again, it gets out of sync because of fiscal years, but we do put it back into the fee schedule each year as well. There were no changes in the airport fees, so no recommended modifications there. The public safety fees, just a couple of minor things there in terms of new with the concealed weapon permits. They're outlined in there.
4:56:26 There's a $10 increase in the processing and a $5 increase in the renewal cost and that's to reflect the time that requires us to go through that process. And then there's a vehicle inspection fee that the police department performs and there's a $20 increase in that given the amount of time that officers or others end up spending on that program. The public works engineering had no changes in their fees. The community economic development fee program
4:56:55 Had no changes in theirs. Then the building division is updated on the valuation table, so that table gets updated so the fees then are adjusted accordingly through that process. The other element here is the development impact fee schedule. They will go up by about 3%, I believe it was, based on the cost index.
4:57:18 Report in the Engineering News Record, or ENR, and that is a way of tracking cost increases. So the fees that the town controls will go up that 3% for the diff schedule. And that would be it. The fee changes are very few. Thank you very much. Any questions for Dan? I have one question. Okay. Dan, on the building division fee schedule, page 4, item 11. Rooftop solar energy systems.
4:57:52 Yes. My simple question is why are we charging fees for rooftop solar energy? Actually, it's a fee structure that actually is set by government code. This is the, it's a maximum fee that you can actually do. I mean, you could do it for free, but we do have to inspect and go through the process that we do have a cost for those permits. But the dollar amounts that are here are actually set by state law. Okay.
4:58:20 That's my question, and I'll have some comments on that, too. Okay. Any further questions for staff? Any thoughts or comments from the public? Hearing none. Okay, we shall deliberate. Yeah, I think all this stuff's pretty benign for me. I mean, I look through the entire fee schedule. It all seems, you know, reasonable and similar to the past. I just personally, I think if we're trying to incentivize solar.
4:58:50 Which is now going to be part of the required energy usage around the state. That's one that I personally can't support. I think we need to probably drop those, period, if we're going to incentivize that as a community. So I'm comfortable with everything else, but not comfortable with fees for rooftop solar. Okay, so today I was in a meeting of the 100% Renewable Group.
4:59:16 And we had a good discussion. Kirk was there also. And I think what I'm hoping that they start to come forward with is a pretty specific series, an analysis of what the town does as an organization, what are the kinds of things that we can actually do. I can support what you're saying.
4:59:38 But my question to staff would be if say a proposal comes forward from that group in the coming months, can we go back and say as part of the package for looking for incentives and things like that to make this whole thing work, could we then do what Councilmember Fernie's recommending at that point or do we have to deal with this now?
4:59:57 No, you can do it at that point in time and reduce the fee. This is if someone comes in to put solar on there. We actually, you know, you're basically saying we're willing to have the general fund subsidize this type of permitting process. Right, so what I would like to do is to... If it's part of a larger package, that would probably be easier to... To have the whole, hang on, to have the whole thing come to us as a package. Right. And let's look at what these things are and then let's look at how we can use that as part of a tool to put a whole thing together. I totally understand where you're coming from, but I just think that...
5:00:26 We know that's going to be part of the renewable energy package. That's something that we have in abundance here, and I'd rather get out in front of it. And that's precisely what I'm saying, Dan, I think, is that those type of things we should be subsidizing. I mean, if you look at the solar energy infrastructure out there.
5:00:46 That's part of the package is people offer, you know, rebates, incentives, you know, zero interest loans, those type of anything we can do to incentivize solar energy. So that's the only one that just jumped out at me is something that I have an issue with. Sure. Bill, you had a thought or what does our fee pay for? I'm assuming there are things that cost us money and hence we have a fee. So I become uncomfortable.
5:01:16 I have a problem.
5:01:45 With doing that. I just, you know, I can understand where you're coming from, maybe a permitting fee or something like that, but the way this is structured with $450 plus $15 additional per kilowatt generated above 15 kilowatts. Right, which would make no sense. That to me is like, that's kind of punishing you. That's why I was asking the question when we're covering that fee. Yeah, so what, yeah, so this, the fee here is actually set.
5:02:14 It was set by state law requirement, looking at it. Understood as a maximum, you said that, right? Yeah, it's a, you can't do your, so you can't exceed reasonable costs. So we do the permitting, we have to do the inspections. You know, we do that process like we do for any building permit. So basically here, if we were to calc it out, and I think we've looked at it, it probably cost us more than this to do. That's why we've set it at the. To do what? To do the permitting process.
5:02:40 It's a permit. It's a building. You look at the structural of how it's built. You look at those elements. You look at the electrical components and then the actual construction. And so we do have a cost to the town of doing that. And again, could you turn around and say it can't exceed the estimated reasonable cost? And if you want the reasonable cost to be zero, we could do that. I'm just failing to understand why there would be additional fees.
5:03:07 For additional energy revenue generation, I mean, an inspection of an electric residential rooftop system, there's time associated with inspecting that, but if you're producing additional energy, that doesn't cost. I think it's more complex than that in how you look at the energy. I think it's probably the electrical side of it. As you generate more, what does it actually take to deal with that issue with your connection back to the grid? It's what you put on your home. It's how does it go in?
5:03:37 It still doesn't address my philosophical issue. Yeah, no, I understand the philosophical questions. I'm saying you can address that by not charging it. That's where I'm at. Or if you wanted to, you could have a plot. Understood. Motion. Okay. Wait a minute before you start. I just, I'll wait. I could go either way, quite honestly. Yes. You know, it's not a big, big number. I mean, if we're talking thousands of dollars, you know, I got an issue with that for sure.
5:04:09 I understand the incentivized nature of it. It makes a lot of sense to me. But I think what we have to do is, over time, come back and really look at this and say, hey, are we making money on this thing or are we just covering cost? And if we're just covering cost, I'm okay with that. We should not be making money. My estimation would be we're probably losing.
5:04:39 Well, yeah, but I'd like to, you know. We can nail that down. I mean, what's the typical residential rooftop solar system? How many kilowatts does it produce? I do not know. I don't either. Huh? I don't either. Yeah. I'm just curious. I mean, is it 25? So is it 10 times 15? Another 150 bucks? But for each kilowatt that it, for each kilowatt you add to that.
5:05:04 It's not free. There are extra panels. There are extra things for inspectors to look at. So there's a reason for the fee to go up with the extra kilowatts. I'm not debating that. I'm just looking at total dollars. What are we talking about? Are we talking another $150? Are we talking another $1,500? I've got to say, I totally support what you're saying. And if philosophically you would not want to move forward with this, I understand that. I would want to see a recommendation coming from
5:05:34 That group that's consistent with our general plan, all kinds of other things, and put together a well-thought-out, reviewed package of incentives that will tie in with the 2020 things, we can really do something with this. So I think that's fair. I mean, to be honest, this is something that I would like to start to educate myself on more at this point. I don't really know that much about it, to Shields' point. I don't know if it's $150 or $1,500.
5:06:01 So I'd be comfortable moving the fee schedule back with the caveat that this item specifically is brought back for council consideration with a little bit more detailed research. Philosophically, I'm okay with us taking a hit on this specifically. I don't need cost recovery on something that we're trying to incentivize. The whole movement of trying to go green is predicated on taking a hit.
5:06:28 And incentivizing people financially. Yeah, and I think if you could further find that a little bit, just to say that the council has identified this as an opportunity to work with this group to say, look, we're willing to put this thing on the table. Let's figure a way to put a package together that's going to be really useful. Fair enough. So I'm happy to make a motion that we move the fee schedule tonight as proposed with the understanding that this specific item will be...
5:06:56 We'll bring it further and brought back for consideration. Second. Okay. Two seconds. Do we have a third? Any further discussion? Jamie, roll call, please. Yeah. Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes. Item is agreed to 5-0. Thank you for that. Yeah. Appreciate that. Okay. Now moving on to policy matters. We're going to receive an update on Mammoth Creek Park West community multi-use facilities.
5:07:44 Just a very brief introduction while they're setting up. At the last council meeting we were asked to come back if we had, if we thought we had significant information to share with you and also to sort of plan a way forward. We spend a lot more time with the architects and with contractors and the like over the last couple of weeks and I'm going to turn it now over to Hayes and Stu to walk through that. They have some suggestions already on some of the design issues, some of the approach issues, delivery methods.
5:08:12 Thanks, Grady. Again, I apologize for this not being included in the packet. We're adding information up into the last minute, so I think probably this will be the last time that this happens. I think going forward we'll be able to include the presentations in the packet. Today's presentation outline, Stu's going to give a brief introduction. We're going to go over some of the goals and objectives from our last meeting. We're going to talk about delivery method.
5:08:40 And then we're going to go through some project alternatives and programming. We're going to talk about the current design, some potential sequencing and phasing, what redesign would look like. And then we're going to talk about some need for council direction. With that, take it away, Stu. So I just want to kind of hit the pause button for a sec, maybe a minute or so. Just kind of walk through, again, we've been working on this project for about three years. These were the project goals that the Recreation Commission identified and established about three years ago.
5:09:10 And we just wanted to put it up on screen because now more than ever they're still relevant, right? They're still going to, still, you know, a high need now and certainly in the future. And I just wanted to cover, again, kind of the key kind of deliverables and the goals of the project. Quality of life was certainly kind of the top one there and quality of life because it's Hayes' birthday today and he's here this evening with us, so appreciate it. Thank you. Anytime.
5:09:37 And the other one was complementary multipurpose year-round indoor and outdoor recreation, right? So the key words here is multipurpose year-round indoor and outdoor. Social interaction, recreation, destination, you know, we've been speaking on those, you know, frequently. Healthy, active lifestyles for all ages, passive enjoyment in that creek setting. So, again, still top of mind, right? Those goals don't go away. They're clear as ever. So let's roll to the next page. What I wanted to hear is kind of cover...
5:10:05 Three components of this project, right? So community centre is really kind of where we went to with a complementary facility. Community centre programme provides all these different activities.
5:10:19 We've been out in the community for the last kind of couple of months. It's been interesting listening to all the forums and all the discussions. Seems to be a lot of misunderstanding about kind of what we're proposing for our projects. I just want to hit that pause button again and just make sure everyone's clear on what we're proposing here. So again, this is that laundry list of the playbook items that were developed by the community. Again, two and a half thousand square foot space, you know, social interaction that was the project goal.
5:10:43 Programming, year-round, community, complementary space to support the operations of the year-round recreation centre. So these haven't changed. They're all still here. And all these identified programming items are still important as ever. So let's roll to the next one. Summer programming. Let's just jump back a page. So I know a few people have seen this slide. This is basically the overlay for an Olympic ice rink.
5:11:11 Or Olympic sheet, 20,000 square feet, 100 by 200. We went with this distance because of these programming choices. So if you look at this, you can kind of see the grey. The grey is a basketball court. It's a futsal court. It's a volleyball court. Pickleball court. There's nine pickleball courts. There's a multitude of programming available. Arena, soccer, futsal. It is fully programmed. There's probably, if you flip to the next slide as well, we'll just kind of keep moving.
5:11:40 All those activities will take place in that facility, right? So the way we're really looking at this, if you kind of think about a big picture, it's the year-round Alpine Recreation Centre, right? You know, when people think it's just a multi-dimensional, you know, rink and facility, it's got that, but this is the summer choice. And all these activities here, if you look at number one, home for our parks and recreation programs, as we mentioned briefly today, there's 200 kids on our waiting list. That number goes up every summer. You know, we're just not going to...
5:12:10 We realise, you know, any type of accommodation for all these kids that get in our programmes unless we have a facility that can meet those needs, free summer drop-in camps, and you can see all those different activities that have been programmed in that space. Wintertime, as you know, I think this is probably where the community has a better understanding of it.
5:12:28 Pretty traditional Olympic ice sheet in all the activities we can do. Grady kind of had a good idea about kind of listing, you know, what we currently do, what we're able to do in the future with this facility. That's something we certainly want to consider. But essentially all these programming choices that I'm listing up here, there's about 50 to 60, you know, different programming activities, you know. So this year-round recreation centre is going to, you know, provide that community so many different choices, so many different activities.
5:12:54 From free to pay to play to tournaments to leagues, you know, whatever we want to look at it, it's meeting the community, it's meeting our visitors' needs. So again, let's just flip to that last page. And again, the park setting, again, we don't want to call it that acronym of that.
5:13:09 Multi-use facility. It's the park project. You know, it has all of those elements that you find in a typical park. You know, we have a beautiful, inclusive playground going in. We've got a beautiful creek setting, natural play area. And then we're combining that with a high-quality, complimentary year-round recreation facility that we think will kind of really work well in our community setting. So I just wanted to hit that pause button just to make sure we're all clear. I know we are all clear. I just want to make sure the community's here and everyone.
5:13:35 Watching online, really understand kind of what we're proposing in our facility. Thank you. Betsy wanted to jump in or we kind of keep rolling along? Let's roll. Okay, thank you. So Stu and I decided to take a pause there because there's a common thread here. The programming has influenced the design. The community expectations have...
5:14:00 And while we're talking about alternatives, redesign, rescoping, whatever the case may be, we wanted to reflect on that and remember that what we've done, what we've provided as a solution to all of these needs has been driven by these community conversations. So just a quick review from our last meeting. Staff had a commitment from our design team to deliver a project that meets the expectations of the community and is financially viable.
5:14:31 The goal is to maintain initially all the features of the project that support the programming and to maintain our design aesthetics and importantly to share our results with our partners. We talked a bit about project delivery at our last meeting so I won't belabor these other design methodologies but it's clear that the path forward for this and future projects will need to consider alternative delivery methods.
5:15:00 So we've considered an RFQ for construction management services. The idea is that this is just a screening process to establish a pool of service providers, a bench, if you will, of firms that can help us deliver projects. We'll evaluate these firms based on qualifications only initially, and that any future work will require a specific proposal for a specific project. Initially, there's no commitment to contract for future work. It's basically just to put them on the bench.
5:15:33 So we've discussed this a little bit further internally, and the idea is that this will help us because we will have a representative that will help us in project development initially. They'll bring expertise to the table. They can, importantly, act as a liaison to contractors, help us with bidding, helping us with negotiations, value engineering, change orders. They can provide services for day-to-day management. If you step out of just the multi-use facility, this is a bench that could help us deliver
5:15:59 We believe it will definitely bring some cost savings. It will help us with schedule. It does bring some flexibility to our agency, and it helps to mitigate risk with the cost of a project. So when we're talking about sharing information with our partners, we've had some conversations in the past about working together. And Grady and I have had some one-on-one conversations, and we've convened some meetings with our partners.
5:16:29 And we've got an idea, and it's, I don't think I've seen this done. I did some research around state, and I don't think this approach has been taken, but we're proposing working as a community for this RFQ process. And we have the support of, you know, Mono County and their projects, Mono County Office of Education, Mammoth Unified School Districts, and the Mammoth Lakes Foundations have all come together and decided to work together to propose.
5:16:58 One RFQ for the community. The idea is instead of the town putting forth an RFQ for just the multi-use facility and the county putting together a proposal for, say, the jail, we're competing for resources. We're looking for the same pool of contractors to support us. Instead, we are looking to work together to maybe find a common manager that can help us bring some economy of scale to the projects.
5:17:28 Help us incentivize larger construction management firms to help us bring these projects to fruition. So instead of a CM firm looking at a $15 million project, a CM firm is looking at a community working in solidarity towards $150 million plus in projects. I think that'll bring larger firms to the table and also help our partners to deliver projects at the same time.
5:17:56 So we're looking to bring that forward as what we're calling a community multi-jurisdictional request for qualifications. So switching gears a bit, project alternatives. So we continue to evaluate the current design, and that has no real changes to aesthetics, no impacts to programming. It's in line with our bids that we received.
5:18:22 We continue to refine the specifications and plans, but at this time it does not appear that the town has sufficient funding to support this alternative. As it stands right now, and we have been spending a significant amount of time with the contractors, subcontractors, and our consultants,
5:18:44 Working backwards from our low bid of 19-8, steel adjustments, we believe realistically there's about $2.448 million in savings. That's looking at the tonnage adjustment that we talked about at the last meeting, making some adjustments to the tapered steel and so forth. We went through a number of these alternatives. We've put a number to that now based on the real bid, and we believe conservatively, and I'll express these numbers, we're being very conservative with this.
5:19:12 About $2.4 million. We found about $360,000 in electrical adjustments. We made some material changes to the interior based on information we received. We believe that looks like a half million dollars plus or minus in savings. And then some exterior changes, changing some materials, again, based on information we received, about $750,000. Our current total right now lands at about $16,200.
5:19:40 With an all-in project cost at $17,700. We're also assuming a neutral, no cost savings from a construction manager. Again, being very conservative, we could bring them on. We do believe there's probably a million dollars in savings that a construction manager could realize. But to be conservative, we think that it's also going to cost us about $750,000 for the purpose of this conversation right now. We're just going to say that's cost neutral.
5:20:12 So discussing an alternative delivery method, sequencing or phasing, this does not change the overall vision of the project and the goals of the project, but it does impact programming as a function of time. We would work towards a defined budget initially for phasing, and we would look to work with the record commission and the community to determine that phasing, because it does impact programming. As we said, the common thread here is,
5:20:42 The programming has influenced and directed the design. And just for the sake of conversation, some concepts that are probably feasible, a community center and a modified rink, you know, budget for that could be $8 to $10 million. Rink and a roof alone with no community center, probably in the range of $12 million. And we believe, again, all these concepts should be vetted through a public process and the recognition providing some input.
5:21:12 And again, using a set budget. Alternative three is a wholesale redesign, rescope of the project, re-evaluating the long-term vision of the project, re-evaluating the significant design alternatives that we'd have to put forth. We may have to eliminate programming opportunities, and we will definitely have to redefine the community expectations.
5:21:35 Opportunities here all to eliminate gathering spaces, modify change viewing areas in the locker rooms, change from an Olympic rink to an NHL rink, elimination of the community center, which came after the whole rink process, and maybe returning to a pre-engineered building, which brings some significant height limitations in the sports that can be accomplished within that facility. So as it stands right now,
5:22:03 We've kind of come to an end of what we can do based on the direction we've given to date. We are looking for some consensus to move forward with the RFQ, with our community partners, but this is a decision point where we need some additional direction. Hayes, before you go on, one of the ideas of the sequencing or phasing part is that what we're saying is keep the vision and understand that the needs are still there for the entire project, but also very clearly...
5:22:29 We're not going to afford $17.7 million now or in the next year or two, certainly. So the idea is to go back into the design, certainly get some input from the rec commission about what the most important priorities are in terms of the programming and try to come back with a project that we can't afford now.
5:22:48 That leaves the door open for future expansion and future programming that we can add to it at a later date. But don't design something that precludes that. In other words, don't do something that prevents us from moving forward in the future with everything. But again, try to meet just about every programming need we can with a project that we can afford today. When Hayes said decision points, again, I've mentioned this before, but for the benefit of those here tonight, just very quickly, the first decision point was we're not staying where we are.
5:23:16 That was over three years ago. That was very clear. That was a council direction. We are not leaving the rink where it is today. It's not a viable long-term solution. The next was kind of an initial selection of Mammoth Creek Park West. But after that, the town council actually said, look, we think we like Mammoth Creek Park West, and maybe it's a rink and a roof over there, as we called it. But the direction was to go back to the rec commission and to Malar and say, look, work together.
5:23:46 Anywhere from seven to ten people, you know, a couple of you participated in parts of that process. We got a good cross-section of others and come back with a recommendation. That was done and the clear recommendation was, well, let's do this facility right, let's do it with a complementary facility of a community center. From that, we worked to get the initial...
5:24:06 Initial project description in 2016, did the EIR and got that in 2017. So there have been a lot of checkpoints here. This is another one where we certainly recognize we can't meet all the goals, can't meet all the programming needs because we don't have...
5:24:21 Yeah, I think you kind of...
5:24:42 Touched up on a few of these points. Like I said, in order to move forward, we're going to need some direction on an alternative. And whether it's one of the three or a combination thereof or something completely different, it's the council's pleasure. I also posted a couple key dates coming up that are an opportunity for us to engage. And again, in order to move forward, we're going to see a set budget and understand what the expectations are. With that, that concludes my presentation. Available for questions. Okay.
5:25:13 Any technical questions for staff that may help frame or inform our deliberations? I got a couple, but anybody else want to go? Technical questions. Technical questions. I have a question. I like the idea that you guys have come up with regarding a coordinator, a GC guy. Makes a lot of sense. But I wouldn't limit it to, you know, public. I'd go out through the private.
5:25:47 And I would imagine the mountain would want to partake in that too. So I think it's a great idea. We have a lot of projects kind of on the books that hopefully we'll get going. And I think if you guys get together and get a round table, it makes a lot of sense.
5:26:06 And so to that, I agree with that. I think if staff could come back with an analysis of the nature of public-private interests, could they work together in something like that? How would it be framed? What would their MOUs involved? How would that be set up? I think that would be an important thing to look into.
5:26:24 Well, I'm going to address that briefly. Frankly, with an RFQ process that an agency does, we would do one blanket RFQ request for qualifications for construction management services. We would engage the public, quasi-public.
5:26:38 I'm not sure we'd want them to have a quote vote because they don't
5:27:08 Do that anyway, but have them involved in the process. I don't think it needs an MOU or anything because they're just basically would take a list that we come up with and say, okay, great. We've now gone through this process. We've got insurance from three to five groups and the private entities can individually go select. The private's going to be the, I mean, ultimately the big numbers. Absolutely. Absolutely. And one thing we've struggled with for years is
5:27:30 Getting that firm up here. We've been able to get somebody interested in doing the Wounded Warrior Center. They're close to signing an agreement on that to do that, and we want that type of activity and for the larger companies to be interested. So I don't think it needs a formal MOU, but certainly engage everybody. I don't want to skip the deliberation. It's a good thing to ask. Any other technical questions? I've got a couple. Just to frame this up, how much money do we have right now to build this project?
5:27:59 Right now in the bank, we've got just over, and this would be the all-in numbers, we've spent some, but just in terms of the revenue that we're looking at, we have just over $9.1 million actually in cash. I believe you can support up to a $13 million project. Okay, so that's the number, $13 million. Okay, another question is, without being pejorative, what percentage of this structure involves structural steel?
5:28:30 80%? Well, are we looking by size, weight? The roof on top of the direct zone, the rig facility is a steel building, so that's predominantly steel and certainly the highest amount of the cost, but if you had to pick a number, I'd say 80% in terms of... So I would like to, obviously, with what's going on internationally right now, with steel and aluminum, this is a highly volatile, problematic...
5:29:00 I don't know if this is the kind of time to go building a building that's 80% steel. So I would appreciate some sort of recommendation or insight from staff as to what your sense of what's going on with all this and how that affects this. I think that's a good point. I personally would say, okay, I like the phasing aspect of it.
5:29:27 If you take the community center off, are we at $13 million? Or would you have to go back? The other scenario I look at is, okay, just go back to the architect and say, we got $13 million. What can we build for that? I mean, just kind of cut to the chase, if you will. Yeah, and factor in that volatility as part of that analysis. One other question, so HMC committed to work for free, correct? They stood up here, and I would hope that they're going to continue to do that.
5:29:57 When you mentioned partners, I think it's important to know who those partners are and to document who those partners are. I do think it's important to have some kind of memorandum of understanding. Each one of these projects are in various stages. The counties, they're going to build a building. They're not going to build a building. The MAC, I'm not sure exactly where it's at this point, but you've got a bunch of different things in different stages. I'd like to understand the viability of that.
5:30:23 Who's where? But those are my set of technical questions. And at this point, is there any public comment or public thoughts on this, what we've heard tonight? I promise I'll be really, really brief. Betsy Truax, Recreation Commission Chair. And I just wanted to say that, you know, the commission just remains supportive of addressing the needs identified in the process that Stu spoke about, which are also aligned with needs in, you know, the Parks and Rec Master Plan and other adopted town documents.
5:30:53 Really, at this point, the commission would really hope to look to staff for additional information about these alternatives, which we could then work with the community to figure out how we can deliver something with the resources that we have and what programming we could deliver. And I know there are a number of people watching online tonight and at home, and I really want the community to understand that I think we as a commission, and I know the staff all feel very strongly that we should be able to do something for the $13 million that...
5:31:21 Yeah, the town manager just mentioned. So it's our hope that we can figure out how to deliver something that works. So thank you. Well, you know, in that, I would make sure that the programming keeps driving this thing. You know, don't keep cutting, cutting, cutting to where it doesn't make any sense. Exactly. I mean, it still needs to work. It still needs to meet the needs that, you know, that we've identified, you know, with the community and, you know, but at the same time to manage, you know, the expectations about, you know, what we can.
5:31:51 We can accomplish. Okay, thank you. Anybody else? Somebody help me out. This is just a general question. We had an initial design for the police station that people refer to as the Taj Mahal. What was that? $23 million was that number? Yeah, it was in the 14 plus million for the police station. So 14 plus is the police station and then we had the Taj Mahal.
5:32:22 Parking facility with an ice rink on top of it up at the village. What was the number on that? The ice rink one, I think, at the time was a little over $17 million. $17 million. Okay. Thank you. It was real nice. Sure. Any other public comment on this? Okay. So let's figure out a way to provide some direction. I just realized a question that I had. I know at one point that it was brought up that when the roof is built that it's 30,000 square feet.
5:32:52 Was that just for the rink or is that encompassing the potential community center as well? The entire facility is 43,000 square feet. The rink alone, I can't see that number on that sheet right there, but it's a little over 30,000 if I remember correctly. Oh, okay. Because I know that's got to be built in kind of like one chunk in the very beginning.
5:33:18 Are we capable of starting off with the 30,000 square feet and then adding the other portion? So even though it has to be built at once? Yeah. We asked the architects if we could separate the community center from the ice rink. One of my first questions when the steel bid came in and the steel number started to come in is like, can we switch to wood on the community center? Is there any reason we have to build this out of steel?
5:33:47 And so we went through an exercise to see if that would work, and absolutely, yes, we can. We can separate the facilities and break them apart, and you would still retain the overall look and feel. No one's going to know walking between one building and another. If you're walking from a steel building to a wood building, the roof line would be the same. So architecturally, it would look the same. Oh, okay. I think clearly that's a great question.
5:34:13 If you don't mind, that kind of leads me into some of my disjointed thoughts on this. But first of all, I appreciate staff's attention to this. The fact that we've had significant work done every two weeks, you're coming back to us with, you know, looking for direction. I very much appreciate that. I appreciate that you understand that kind of...
5:34:34 This council has an urgency to try and move this forward before we are completed. I think this council has been really productive. I think we've completed a lot of things. That's something I'm proud of. There's obviously plenty more things that we could have done, but this is one of the things that will be a regret for me that we're coming to the end of our term and not being able to bring this to the finish line. That being said, I'm motivated to do everything I can until I'm off council.
5:35:04 Continue to be engaged with this, you know, prior, you know, post being on council, because this is something that I think is really important for the community. I think if we take a step back, the need hasn't changed. We have a community center that is, you know, defunct, that is non-functional. We have an ice rink that does not function the way that it is currently.
5:35:26 You know, as we've articulated in going back through the process, we went through a whole extensive, you know, research and vetting process to arrive at the need for this park project. None of that's changed. That being said, you know, that's why I kind of ask those questions around the old 14 plus million dollar police station. If we...
5:35:48 We had a need for a police station. We came up with a $14-plus million design. That did not get built. When we came back this second time around, we had a $3 million facility that we approved. That was the budget, was $3 million. We were able to go out and design a $3 million facility. We came in pretty much right on budget, you know, very small variance. That thing got built.
5:36:12 Same deal with a $17-plus million parking facility with an ice rink on top of it up at the village. It's a beautiful design, as you said. We didn't have the funds to do that when we came back and we approved a $500,000 parking project up below the Westin that's made a huge difference, right? So I think for me...
5:36:34 It's pretty simple to go back to the drawing board. $13 million is the number. When you walk through all the work that you did to say, take this exact design, this exact process, let's scale back whatever we can, and it comes out at 17.7, that's a no. And I think that we can't afford that. We've got to work within the constraints of that $13 million budget that we have established, and what can we get for that?
5:37:00 I love the idea that you came up with this community CM. That's a really creative way to look at executing a lot of projects that are important to the community that have been in the pipeline for a long time. So I love that. I'd love to see that explored. You know, just a couple of things. Total budget for me is $13 million. So let's see what we can do for that. I think some of the things that we've talked about pulling out initially.
5:37:28 There was significant savings looking at parking lot. I think that's a really smart thing to leave out of phase one. We don't really know what the demands of the facility are going to be. And I think as we get in, we have a facility, people start utilizing it. We'll start to see where those pain points are. And then that can be an opportunity to go back and say we need to do X, Y, or Z from a parking perspective to make it function.
5:37:54 We have MLR. We went out and we found an executive director that was really, you know, a lot of the focus for that hire was fundraising capabilities. I've had conversations with them. They are ready to go out and fundraise for this facility.
5:38:11 Felt like they needed a project that was concrete that could be sold. And the conversations I've had with them is they feel like raising funds for the community center piece is an easier sell for them. So I think, again, to me, this project doesn't make sense without the complementary nature, but I think that's a really smart target focus for some fundraising efforts to say, hey,
5:38:35 We'll figure out how to build this thing. We'll frame it in. We'll leave it kind of bare bones. Go raise a million bucks. Go raise a million and a half bucks to complete that and have the community feel pride in that community center aspect to say, hey, we raised $70,000 for the IT in here and we raised $50,000 for all the furniture in here. Whatever it may be, I think that's a very viable thing for us to do.
5:39:01 I do think we've been resistant at this point to looking at NHL versus Olympic. I think at this point we have to look at that as an option and what savings could be associated with that. I know that that changes some of the programming, but we still get a lot of the programming out of it.
5:39:19 It's hard to say at this point without that type of facility, do we need to be able to run three volleyball courts simultaneously? I don't know if we have a need for that. We might. But I think that's one of the things that should be a consideration up front. So those would be my higher priority adjustments. You also mentioned kind of looking at a prefab type thing and what the savings would be there. You know, maybe that impacts programming a little bit. You know, thinking in my head from a futsal, soccer.
5:39:49 Hockey, most of the things that we've talked about, tennis, I don't see how that really impacts the programming. Maybe it would be a volleyball impact, I'm not really sure, but I think we need to look at what that cost savings would be and kind of the cost-benefit analysis of that programming change.
5:40:06 The things that I don't think that we should really look to as a first phase change or elimination would be the chiller. I think that we've got some interest from the Kings as far as bringing up preseason camp. That high altitude training component I think is really important to this facility and the functionality that that...
5:40:28 More robust chiller gives us. I think should really be a last, last resort as far as an elimination. The other thing that I really think should be a last, last resort as Shields kind of articulated is the locker room setup of elimination. If we look at eliminating that, that really diminishes the functionality of the facility. You cannot host tournaments without that. And that's a big piece of this for me.
5:40:55 From a direction perspective, I think it's pretty clear $13 million is the number. What can we do to get a facility there? Locker room elimination and chiller.
5:41:06 Restructuring would be the last on the list for me. And the ones that I mentioned first, which would be parking lot, community center fundraising, structural changes, whether that's prefab and NHL versus Olympic should be the first things that we look at. And as Cleland kind of let in, I think it would be really smart since the lion's share of the cost.
5:41:28 Overrun was associated with steel and that kind of custom huge span steel roof. If we can look at kind of bifurcating out those two facilities and then how we kind of maybe go with a more wood on the community center side of things or the entrance or whatever that may be, anything that we can kind of build separately but then tie back together from a functional perspective, I know you guys can handle that. That I think will eliminate a lot of the cost.
5:41:57 That's where I'm coming from, and I will stop talking. Thank you very much. Thank you. So I think we'll turn to the other council members who kind of aggregate this, but I think we want to come up with a kind of very specific, clear direction you're looking for, and we'll get to that. So, Bill, anything you want to add to that? I think looking at the $13 million and seeing what we can get, incredibly important. I think programming is incredibly important. So I would, if we have to go to an NHL size, but I would prefer seeing the larger because
5:42:25 Even if ICE fails, it gives us a better facility that we can repurpose for other things. It just works. I am interested in both seeing what we can get for 13 and what it looks like if we phase it to some extent. And now I'm going to go off on a tangent myself a little bit, and I shouldn't because I was wanting a short meeting.
5:42:52 And there are people watching this out there in TV land, but I'm hearing complaints all the time about how town staff lied to us. They told us we were going to have a $2 million rink. Now we've got a $15 million rink, and it's hard for me not to, you know, hit somebody. The fact of the matter is, I was not in favor of adding, and Grady and I had this conversation many times,
5:43:19 Community Center facility in it at the get-go because we couldn't afford it. But we took it to the public, and what we have here is what the people of the town of Mammoth Lakes asked us to build. Are there people against it? Of course there are. There's going to be people against anything we do. But we gave everybody the opportunity, and the overwhelming support was to build this facility. So I'm still looking for a way for us to get there, to go from steel to wood. I don't care if we use trees around the ice rink.
5:43:49 Whatever we can do to bring the cost down. But this is what the town of Mammoth expects us to deliver, or the majority of them anyway. So to me it is important, the functionality of this is hugely important. So I would really love to see both what do we get for 13, how much of the functionality can we keep, and what does a, because this is going to be a two or three year construction project anyway.
5:44:17 It's going to be phased just by how long it's going to take us to build it. What does that actually look like? And then if we have to go over 13, what are we talking about to get to the end of this project? And remember, this is not an ice rink. This is a drop-in zone for kids after school that's going to have staff there to protect them, but without their parents looking over their shoulders. This is multifaceted. This is something this community has needed.
5:44:46 Going back to the 60s. So I bring me the options. Okay. Shields, anything? No, I'm totally in agreement with everything that's been said. Okay. Cleland? I think I said that earlier. I did, I have more of a question. If we drop off certain things, such as the chiller, the locker rooms, are we still going to be able to negotiate anything with the LA Kings?
5:45:14 Or is that pretty much something that they're going to be looking for? Oh, so I guess to Stuart. I think that would have a very significant impact. Did you want the short answer? Yeah. So that would have a big impact. And then just bouncing off Bill saying about the safety, that is one thing that does concern me about having the locker room would be great to, you know.
5:45:41 Entice the Kings to come here. However, and then it would also be useful for the kids who are playing hockey. However, if we're going to go ahead and say that we're looking after the safety of our local kids, we need to figure out a way if we're going to have locker rooms where kids will actually be protected. Because in other locations, there have been adults that have taken advantage of children in locker rooms. And so it's not just the...
5:46:11 Actually having the locker room, it's kind of like, what are the bigger implications of that? So I just wanted to point that out as well. Okay, Stuart, do you have any response on the kinks thing? I think we kind of answered that, and I don't think the demand would be diminished. And we have talked briefly, Cleland, it's a great question about safety, and we've talked about how those locker rooms would function in summer. So for our summer camps and programs,
5:46:35 Those kids would have that locker space and the way the facility is designed, it's segregated, right? So the public space is, you know, near the lobby and then, you know, our space is down by the summer camp. So that's basically where we would be with our councillors and our kids. So that's kind of our initial kind of thoughts on how we would kind of operate the facility for our camps in summer and vice versa in wintertime. Unfortunately, this has been kind of a project that this council's been, you know, driving for a few years now.
5:47:03 It's ultimately the final thumbs up is going to come down to the next council, but I think it's incumbent on us to do what we can and staff to do what we can to deliver a project to the next council within the budget constraints and try and package it up in a nice bow and say, hey, this is three years of effort and time and energy and community need.
5:47:25 You know, I think this has so much more implications than a single project. For me, it's about starting to have a different culture in this community about what is acceptable and what isn't. And frankly, our recreation facilities are unacceptable. Okay, so if I could just wrap it around the clock. And if we don't, if we don't produce on this, I'm worried about the long-term implications. I think if we can set a different standard.
5:47:53 That that has a lot of implications moving forward. Okay. Understood. I just want to, let me just, I'm going to, I want to get my two cents in here. I want to get on the next item. Okay. Because we got to get done here tonight. So quickly. Okay. Is this million from the LA Kings included in that 13 million? There's a couple of options for that to where it, we looked at a fundraising slash LA Kings for a million.
5:48:18 But that 13, that includes a million dollars of unfunded? It's unfunded. It's either fundraising or Kings. Okay. Thank you. I'm done. Okay. So a couple things. No one should be under an illusion that that Kings deal for a million dollars exists. The Mountain has not proved to be a reliable partner with this project, so that should not be considered. We need to cut to the chase. $13 million.
5:48:43 We cannot churn this project. So REC Commission, everybody else, you've got to bring something back here that's buildable. The next time we look at this thing, it goes. My original interest in this had to do with appropriate land use, getting it out of the schools where we could build a child care facility, which is a critical priority for this community.
5:49:02 That's my origin story for this thing, moving it and getting it built. I'm not interested in a lot of loose ends kind of a project. I need somebody to come back here. Maybe someday you could build another building. But whatever is going to get proposed and budgeted gets built, it's finished, and it's completed, and we have it, and we live with it. I think also the values of including the programming with the design is critical.
5:49:24 And you guys have to work with that. But you need to take an ax to this. This is not friendly time. This is you got to go in there with alternative three and you guys whack at it and do whatever you got to do to bring something back that is buildable and we can move on with this. Personally, I'm going to run out of patience if this turns into a churn effort because we're spending money on this while we're redesigning and reworking it, doing all this kind of nonsense. And the community is going to get fed up with it.
5:49:47 And I think, Bill, I hear everything you're saying, but we need to bring this to closure and bring a project that we can build. So those are my thoughts. So I think unless there's anything else, I think I don't want to try to aggregate all these comments. I think you've heard what's from us. Is there any specific direction that you're lacking? Nope. Good. All right. Okay, good. I think we're all saying pretty much the same thing. That's the budget. Let's deliver a project within that budget. Yeah, and if it doesn't come back.
5:50:17 And it doesn't work, it's going to go on the shelf. I mean, because remember, we're doing this in the context of an international trade war on the cost of steel. So I just say that, that this is not exactly the right time. I mean, it's a difficult time to be proposing to build a project like this. Okay, any final thoughts or comments? Okay, let's move on then. So we've got seven minutes. Reds Meadow Road Improvement Project. Thank you.
5:50:46 The item before you is consideration of the Reds Meadow Road Improvements Project Initial Study Mitigated Native Declaration, Response to Comments and Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. The Central Federal Lands Highway Division, CFLHD of the Federal Highway Administration, FHWA.
5:51:05 In cooperation with the Forest Service, Inyo National Forest, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, National Park Service, Devil's Post Pile National Monument are proposing improvements to Reds Meadow Road. As you know, Reds Meadow Road is about 8.3 miles long, provides access to campgrounds, parking areas, trails, trailheads, Minaret Vista, Devil's Post Pile, and Reds Meadow Resort.
5:51:26 The proposed project includes reconstruction widening of the upper 2.5 miles to two lanes and rehabbing the existing two-lane pavement in the lower 5.8 miles of the road. The NEPA process was completed by FHWA and included the preparation of a draft and final environmental assessment along with a finding of no significant impact. The CEQA process included preparation of an initial study.
5:51:52 Checklist to ensure that all potential environmental impacts were addressed by CEQA. The analysis of the impacts associated with the construction and implementation of the project resulted in less than significant impacts after mitigation measures were included.
5:52:08 And this document includes mitigation measures for aesthetics, biological resources, tribal cultural resources, and utilities and service systems. Staff recommends that the Town Council choose option one and adopt the Reds Meadow Road improvements project initial study MND response to comments and mitigation monitoring and reporting program. And I'm available to answer any questions that you have on this item. Thank you very much. Any questions for Sandra? The comments.
5:52:38 There's a number of comments in here from the superintendent of the Devil's Postpile National Monument. I'm assuming that those comments are public comments. They can be used for a variety of different conversations with the National Monument outside of just these comments on the CEQA document. Is that correct? They could be. Okay, because these are public, fully public documents. Okay, comments. All right. Any thoughts or questions from the public on this item? Okay, thank you. Deliberation?
5:53:09 I make a motion that the Town Council adopt the initial study of mitigating negative deck response to comments and mitigation, monitoring, and reporting. I'll second. We have a second. We have a second. Any further discussion? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
5:53:38 Yes. Item is agreed to 5-0. Thank you very much, Sandra, for taking on that work. Very much appreciated. Number 18, Town of Mammoth Lakes response to the interim report of the Monro County Grand Jury. Yes, Mr. Mayor. The Grand Jury report basically requires us to respond within 90 days of receiving it. We're well within that time frame. There was two items addressed by the Grand Jury as it relates to Town of Mammoth Lakes. One of those deals with TOT and enforcement and ongoing work.
5:54:04 And they dealt with the idea of doing more audits. The final recommendation was to do two audits, one of a larger
5:54:12 Remitter and a smaller remitter. And while we don't necessarily agree with, hey, we should be out doing all these audits to do the two audits, we agree with that recommendation, and that's been part of our work program to move forward. The second item dealt with a public records request complaint that they found that we actually complied, so obviously there's no recommendations there that it looks like we did what we were obligated to do. And the response back, basically, there's a draft letter in the staff report.
5:54:38 to take a look at and make those basic statements. Here's the findings. We either agree with it or we agree in part in terms of the TOT issue and that we will be moving forward accordingly. And the recommendation would be that unless there's some editing work would be to authorize the draft letter to be sent to the court providing our statements. And I'll also ask if Andy has anything to add. He reviewed the item as well to make sure that we're
5:55:07 Doing it correctly. Good. Thank you very much. Any questions for Dan or Andy? Dan, so that recommendation around the audits, that's something that staff's comfortable with because that was really essentially part of the work plan anyway. That's correct. Okay. Any further questions for staff? Any thoughts or comments from the public? Hearing none, what is the pleasure of counsel? I'll make a motion that Town Council authorizes the town manager to send the letter providing the town's responses to matters regarding the town of Mammoth Lakes.
5:55:38 And the Mono County Grand Jury 17-18 Interim Report. Second. Any further discussion? I have a motion to second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Council Member Fruden? Yes. Council Member Fruden? Yes. Council Member Fruden? Yes. Yep. Yes. Yes, the item's agreed to 5-0. So, ladies and gentlemen, I would propose, since we're right here at the witching hour, that we defer our Council Member reports for this week and what happens between now and then to our next meeting. And also,
5:56:07 Provide an opportunity for Councilmembers Richardson and Fernie to provide your Councilmember report, but maybe some thoughts and reflections on your time here in the Council, and that we do all that at our next meeting, which will be June 20th. Okay, yeah, sure. Give me some time to prepare. Yeah, give me all time to prepare. Yeah, that sounds great. Does that sound okay? Yeah.
5:56:31 Thank you. I'm not willing to even bore myself tonight if I cancel my report. According to the clock that's always wrong, it's 1028. I think it's right, actually. Look at that. It's right. Oh, it's good. It's right. Sometimes it's wrong. And with that, I would consider, I guess, a motion to adjourn. So moved. Seconds? Second. All those in favor, say aye. Aye. We're gone. Thank you all very much. Thank you.