TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 2 hr 7 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

277 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Our meeting today to order of Wednesday, November 17th, and if we could please have a roll call, Karen. Can you do the pledge first? We usually call to order and then we do the pledge. Call to order. That was, you just did call to order. Oh, I'm sorry. That's what it was. Please join Commissioner Clark in the pledge. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands.

0:31 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Now we can do roll call. Please, Karen. Commissioner Clark? Here. Commissioner Hinton? Here. Commissioner Hinton? Here. Commissioner Hinton? Here. Here. All right, now it's time for reports from the Commission. Commissioner Clark? Nothing. Commissioner Hinton?

0:57 I have two things. One, I found out on CNBC last night on an excellent report on water that it takes two and a half gallons of water to produce this sheet of paper. And that's not the water required to grow the tree. That blew me away. And the other thing I have to report on is this is maybe a Misery Loves Company item, but I'm still trying to process the reality.

1:23 of the fact that in Reno, the Siena Hotel, which was built in the last 10 years, had to file for bankruptcy, and the entire hotel, the restaurant, at least 100 feet of river frontage, the parking lot, the property, the casino, the escalators, the elevators, all the rest of it, went at bankruptcy auction for $3.9 million. I am just blown away by that. And that's...

1:51 The reality, at least in Reno, Nevada, that a hotel and all that goes with it could go for $3.9 million. The world has changed. So those are my items. Thank you. Well, I'll just report that we have done a few more meetings on our zoning code update. Commissioner Dyken, Sandra, Mark and I, we've done. So to date, we have done Lions Club, Rotary, Morning Day.

2:21 The Chamber, the Chamber Board, the Board of Realtors last week, Contractors Association, Future of Mammoth and the Advocates, and the Lodging Association as well. I think that's all of them. And we have one more meeting left, which will be now on December 7th, and that's going to be with the Village Merchants and their association up there. One thing I wanted to say, Mark, is we haven't contacted the Restaurant Association. Perhaps we should do that.

2:50 Since we're going to go through December. But meetings have been very well received by the folks there, getting a lot of input from them, and hopefully they're giving us input on the website and through written comments as well. Is the input pretty positive? You know, it has been. For instance, the Board of Realtors brought up the fact about real estate signs. You know, we talked about the sign ordinance and how, you know, what we can do. What we told them was really it's not, you know.

3:16 The five of us, we're not realtors. We don't really know what their needs are. So they now have a committee of two of their board putting together what they feel would be good for them for their signage, which will help. So things like that are coming out of it, which is really good. That's wonderful. Pretty much positive except for the I like blondies comment. Yes, there was the I like blondies comment on the PowerPoint. Before it was torn down. Although you notice they didn't say that about the back of it. No.

3:45 And that is all I have for today. So we'll move on to comments from the public. And this is a time for anyone from the public wishing to address the commission on anything not on our agenda. We will also have a lot of time at the end of the meeting. Also for the public and for those streaming with us live, we do have two presentations. Two of them canceled on us, Jim Smith and Howard Pickett of Mammoth Mountain. So those will not be happening today. We'll let you know when they will be on the agenda next.

4:15 All right, then, we will move on to our presentations, and we have Mammoth Lakes Tourism, their game plan, and we have the director, executive director, John Urdi with us. Welcome, John. Good afternoon, thanks for having me. Basically, what I want to do today is just walk you through a little bit of the game plan that we have for Mammoth Lakes Tourism and where we hope to take the organization and the health pro of the town. So, we're going to start off with a little bit of fun here. I am not a guru.

4:50 As some have mentioned. This is definitely something that is not a one-man show. This is something that I need everybody's help in making Mammoth Lakes as successful as possible. I thought the seat was a mountaintop. I'm also not a savior, so in that sense, same thing. We need to put everybody together. This is St. John from the Book of Kells, so I am definitely not that what I am as a passionate skier, athlete, outdoors person.

5:20 My kids down in Yosemite, so definitely family guy and diehard Red Sox fan, so that's who I am. No, no, no, please, please. Enough of the good stuff. So walking into the game plan here, really just want to go over what our goals are here across the board for short term and long term and some of the priorities don't get us there.

5:47 On the objective side, some of them are fairly basic, just to continue to expand the awareness for Mammoth Lakes, get that word out there as far and wide as possible, focusing on a lot of the things that just haven't been focused on. I think the natural beauty of the area, the skiing, the fishing, the hiking, the pieces that have been really focused on are great, but I want to focus on the things that we have that have not necessarily been focused on, things like the high altitude training and really making sure that folks out there know what's happening in this area and why you should come here.

6:17 Developing the four-season side of things, the Insider Guide, which has been distributed throughout town for the last few years, when I came here, I noticed that we had a winter version and a summer version. And to me, that was a huge missed opportunity to cross-sell the seasons so that when we had the 1.5 million people here skiing in the wintertime, they weren't seeing what we had to offer in the summertime. And coming from four-season resorts across the country, I'm amazed in the summertime how many people used to come up to my ski area in New Hampshire.

6:47 And say, so what are all these other lifts for? They didn't really realize it was a ski area. They just thought there was alpine slides and water slides and all the other activities. So being able to cross-sell the Four Seasons is a huge focus. And then things like TOT, obviously, increasing occupancy is the main goal of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Research is a big thing. We talked about it even yesterday at an events group meeting, making sure that we know who our guests are, why they're coming, where they're coming from, and what they're doing while they're here.

7:17 Branding of Mammoth Lakes in general. I've been working with an agency out of Seattle that did the brand mark for the resort a few years back, and they have all of our data from the previous research that had been done. So we are working at rebranding Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and at this point Mammoth Lakes Tourism will most likely work as our working name, but our name will probably end up being Visit Mammoth as we move forward.

7:46 So we're working with them on the marks, et cetera. Redefining marketing and sales outreach, really just looking at everything that's been done in the past, and not just settling for display advertising, but really doing some things that are a little bit more progressive with the online world, as well as some of the other pieces that we can do through networks that we have, promotions across the country, just, again, gain more awareness and exposure for the region. Expanding our scope.

8:13 Right now, obviously with the flights coming out of San Francisco starting in mid-December, that's a huge focus for us and we'll continue to expand those places into really places like Las Vegas and up into Portland, Oregon where we still have the flights coming in. Collaborating with local stakeholders is a huge one and making sure that we're all working and pulling in the same direction. So that was one of the great things with the event meeting yesterday is it really seems that

8:39 That the general consensus is that we need to make sure that we promote everything that the area has going on. So if somebody can't make it for one event, that they know there are other events that they should be here for. And then promoting the activities collectively, that's, as I just mentioned. Priority since I came on board about three and a half months ago, really looking at all of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Agreements, Contracts, and Services. And amazingly, I've gone through and...

9:05 Looked at a lot of things that we had out there and so far between equipment leases and some of the agreements that we've had, I think we're probably up around the $40,000 in savings mark at this point. Even just doing things as simple as taking all of our vacation planners and making them bulk mailing, we'll probably say it's about $15,000 a year. So some of the simple things, but maintenance contracts, equipment leases, I think right now we're looking at even just our

9:34 Copy or release, we saved about $6,000 on renegotiating that. Hiring key staff positions, right now I've added Whitney Lennon has joined us as our marketing manager. She came on board about a month and a half to two months ago, done a phenomenal job. She's really taken the ball with the publications and a lot of the co-op advertising that we've been doing. I've got an interactive marketing manager who's joining us on Monday, hired him from Heavenly, so Mark Ruddock will be joining us there.

10:02 With the focus on the website, obviously, with email marketing, SEO, SEM, and all the other interactive world, social media. Priorities continuing here is, again, we talked about the rebranding of Mammoth Lakes and just making sure that we ask the right questions and ultimately what we want to find out from that is what our brand essence is and what our brand represents and what it makes people feel when they come here. So we can come out of that with, you know, really the end game is to come out with a brand book that tells us

10:34 What our logo looks like, what our colors are, and then to maintain that brand consistency in everything that we do. Understanding the key regional, national, international markets and their opportunities, you know, we've gone up, this fall we really wanted to get out with an aggressive message to target, again, places like San Francisco with the idea that you don't have to spend the five hours, six hours, seven hours driving to Tahoe, hop a plane, fly here. Fortunately, I think that we've got a great setup where we've got a 66 passenger plane.

11:03 Which really shouldn't be that difficult for us to fill for a good portion of the year. So I think what that will do is it will also help us set up for opening up other regional markets with people like United. You know, they'll see the success of that route and hopefully we can start working with them on things like San Diego, potentially Las Vegas, etc. Redefining the marketing and sales efforts, we've talked about this a little bit. I think a lot of it is really focused on measurable things that we can track because we want to know what's working and what's not working.

11:34 And I think in the past, things have been across the country, you've been seeing people spending their $10,000, $20,000, $30,000 on full-page glossy magazines. That's really not the direction that we're headed in. We are looking at opportunities that make sense for us. We did a full-page ad in a publication in the South Bay area. Part of it was that they had a six-page article on Mammoth.

12:00 And the household income for the magazine, the medium, was about $125,000. So we wanted to make sure that they knew. And the article was fantastic because it told the story of, why are you driving to Tahoe? Why are you driving to Tahoe? Basically, it was talking to the South Bay Area. And at the time, it was talking about the Horizon flight out of San Jose. But it did also mention that we were having the San Francisco flight. So there are some targeted places that we'll reach out there. Social media, we just started a Facebook page for Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

12:29 I guess it's about two months ago now, and we're approaching 1,000 people on the list. I have a little challenge going from the Mammoth Brewing Company guys that said if I can get to 2011 fans by January 1, 2011, that they'll give me some beer for a party. So we're going to have a little party. You're all invited. Cross-selling seasons, we talked about that, and that's one of the biggest things. I want to make sure that when we do have folks in town, whether it's winter or summer, that they know that there's a whole other...

12:59 Avenue to coming to Mammoth. So we can get people here in the off seasons and also in the summer or winter season, depending on when they're here. Again, on the electronic side, focusing on the email distribution and really getting that out there so that we can target more of the online opportunities with

13:20 Banner advertising, search engine optimization, paper clicks, the whole nine yards so we can get people to come this way. Some of the pieces that we're doing right now we're working with OnTheSnow.com, which is one of the, it actually is the largest snow sports website from a standpoint of people searching for snow reports and vacation destinations. And what we've done is we've really targeted people that live in San Francisco, San Jose.

13:47 Los Angeles, San Diego, and Las Vegas that are looking for vacations, but also anybody who's searching on Lake Tahoe. So if they're in Chicago or Boston and they're looking for a trip to Lake Tahoe or they're looking at the snow report for North Star, they're going to see our ad pop up in front of them. So working very closely on some strategic geotargeting. Again, this is a mock-up of the visitor's guide that will be coming out in, oh, I guess we're probably going to get this in-house about

14:16 distributed about December 15th. We have taken, again, in the past there had been a summer guide and there had been a winter guide. The summer guide had done 50,000 pieces and the winter guide had done 20,000 pieces. We've actually taken that 70,000 piece and made it 120,000 pieces with the idea that we're going to distribute that farther and wider than it's been distributed in the past and I just signed off on ordering some specific.

14:43 Display racks for these so that we'll have them in 50 locations around town so that people can pick them up while they're here with the idea that it's their resource once they're in town. Are those the front and back cover? That is the front and back cover, yeah. Same guide? Same guide. It's one piece. Very good. So, and also in the way that we did this, instead of printing 50,000 of one and 20,000 of the other, because we're printing one piece, it's not actually going to cost us a whole lot more to print 50,000 because of the economies of scale. So I think we've added

15:12 I think the original, the summer guide was the biggest, it was 76 pages, and I think that we added maybe 16 pages to make it a four season piece, because there were a lot of crossover pages, maps, some of the things that didn't change season to season. So this is an exciting one. We're also going to be taking this to ski shows, travel shows, because when we're going to something like the Fred Hall fishing show, you've got a lot of people that know the area, and handing them the vacation planner, which is really for people who don't know the area, doesn't do us a whole lot of good.

15:41 When we can hand them this and they can see exactly what they are going to do when they get here, I think that's going to be another nice piece. We're also going to make this digital as well as the vacation planner so you can actually flip through it on the website. My plan is also to take not necessarily this piece but the vacation planner and make it as an app so people can actually download the vacation planner while they're here. The action plan, again, filling all the open positions at this point. I'm still on the hunt for the right salesperson to help us with some of our efforts.

16:14 And I'm very happy with the other two hires that we have. And we did have most of the information services team did stay with us from the transition from the town. So continue to review the operations and how we're running things, really treating this as a true startup. You know, it's something we've taken and we've looked at it from the most basic level all the way up to our planning. So developing the key Mammoth Lake stageholder relationships.

16:44 This is something we've been working on and I think it's been going very well. I feel that we have support from everyone that we've met with, which is great. I think when we talked again yesterday with the events committee or the lodging group or even just the restaurants and some of the other businesses in town, it seems like when I've made this presentation that the direction is something that people are bought into and understanding what we're trying to accomplish. So it's exciting.

17:11 Developing the brand is going to still take a little bit longer. I'm guessing that we'll have a launch of the new brand for the summer, for next year. It'll probably be something that will happen late spring. Creating a detailed line item budget is proving to be a little bit more challenging because it's something we're kind of building on the fly at this point. I definitely want to make sure that we have that lined out so that we know exactly where the money's going and the results that are coming from it. But it's something that will take probably a year cycle to really...

17:40 Completely identify. Looking at the key market opportunities, we've really focused on that piece. Continue to meet one-on-one with everybody in the community that I need to know and need to know some history with. It's been very informative to sit down with folks. Elizabeth, you called me, I think, the first week I was in town. It was a great opportunity to sit down. Tony, you and I sat down. Rhonda has been really helpful on the sales side as well. So knowing the history of where things have been and what has worked and what hasn't worked has been really helpful in that.

18:09 Working with the chamber on the local service training program, we've got a meeting on Thursday at the college, 5.15 to 7.15 to continue to discuss that. And then collaborate with local businesses on outreach. And one of the things that we're doing, and at this point it's full, I think we've started off by offering a social media training and hiring a guy out of Fresno to come over and do the social media training.

18:35 We had set it up as we were going to do one session from 8 to 12 with basically starting at the beginning and going up to some intermediate and the response was amazing. We pretty much, while it's a free program, we pretty much sold it out in the first three hours. So I added a one to five session and that is now full. So we definitely have a good response to that for tomorrow. Audit and redevelop the website again with this new interactive manager coming on board next Monday.

19:02 It's going to be a fantastic opportunity for us to really make that a very active website for us. Moving forward, working on really just making sure that we're ready to rock for next summer. The 2011 summer plan will be a major focus. And then working with the Air Commission, Mammoth Lakes Tourism is looking to take the lead on the airport, meaning that we're going to work to bring in the flights and also to explore other funding opportunities for the subsidies.

19:35 Marketing partnerships and sponsorships, I think this is one of the places that I see a lot of opportunity. As Mammoth Lakes Tourism alone, I'm not sure that we could bring in huge dollars, but with working with everyone from, again, this events group and the Mammoth Track Club, the Mammoth Track Project, some of those places, it opens up the opportunity for us to sell a sponsor a much bigger package because we can give them much better exposure. Working to leverage all of our assets is a huge piece of the partnerships.

20:05 And that's part of the outside funding, exploring all the options for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, whether it's grants, partnerships, a lot of the co-op marketing that we've been doing, so we've been doing LA Times, San Francisco Examiner, SkyWest Magazine is doing an article on Mammoth in their January, February issue, so we're doing a co-op with that. So there's a lot of those places where we're looking to just extend our reach. The tracking and the metrics to show the growth is really going to be an important one because we want to make sure that we can show the impact that we're making.

20:35 So everything that we're doing is as trackable as possible. The budget and the planning schedules, as I mentioned, that's going to be an ongoing process just to figure out when and where things hit. And then we are looking at agency options. At this point, we have hired Chris Lyman, who is the PR agency that's actually doing the Mountain, the Westin, I believe, Mono County. So working with Chris and, again, working with him on focusing on things that maybe not, that haven't been focused on in the past.

21:04 And making sure that people know who our athletes are that live here. And some of the other stories, obviously Steve Searles is a character that has quite a stage out there and being able to highlight that that's Mammoth is huge. So quick story on that too. I spent a few weeks ago, I went back to the New York Marathon with the idea that I wanted to work with a lot of the different...

21:28 Different marathons across the country as well as some of the big track clubs across the country to encourage them to come out and do some high altitude training. And it was great, the response that we had from the Boston Marathon, the New York Marathon, the Chicago Marathon, the Houston Marathon, the Atlanta Track Club, people like that. It's great because there's no conflict. There is no high altitude training. I don't think you can count Buck Hill and Atlanta as a high altitude training. So we've had some great response to that and so hopefully that will help us with some of those shoulder seasons as we can do.

21:57 Running camps here in June and September, so trying to fill the shorter seasons. So that's that. I appreciate the time, and we have, I think, nothing but opportunity here. So John, and for the commission, we did have an events committee meeting yesterday, and I didn't give you an update on it earlier, because I know John would be touching on it. Could you tell them about the funding sources and how you've re-orchestrated that? Because I think everyone up here has...

22:23 Yeah. You know, an event they work with or something. Yeah, absolutely. In the past, there's been a strategic fund that hovered around $50,000 that was available for what I call grants for any of the different events in town. And I think they may have ranged from $1,000 to $5,000 and maybe a little bit more. So when I came on board, we decided that we would take the funding from that.

22:47 and keep it within Mammoth Lakes Tourism with the idea that instead of just putting them, sending them off into the individual events, that we would actually act as the clearinghouse to make sure that we promote all of the events. So there may be something along the lines of mammothmusic.com where we have everything listed and we've got posters going into shops down south, doing the same with the running events, etc.

23:13 So right now the event group really at this point, Stuart and I, Stuart Brown and I are going to be heading up the group and really focusing on how we can leverage each event so that it's the old rising tide floating on the boats. It's pretty exciting and it seemed well received. Yeah, I think it was very well received. Any questions? Elizabeth? Yes, I've got some questions. Thank you very much, John, for that update. That was great. Other than the high altitude training, what do you see as possible events for September, October?

23:43 And May and June, late May and June. Well, you know, it's interesting because at this point I'm trying to stay out of the event creation business. But in your experience, what sort of things work? And stay in the event promotion business. You know, it's interesting because there are some opportunities, there are some promotions even that can be done out there. I've worked with groups in the past that have done programs called Harvest the Holidays where it's really the fall season after, really after Columbus Day until...

24:13 Almost Christmas, you know, up to Christmas, where you try and put together specific packages and different programs. I was involved in Denver, Colorado, and we had the Mile High Holidays, which were, everybody came up with a $52.80 program based on the elevation for Denver, which actually, when I was driving to Reno to fly out for the New York Marathon,

24:35 I kept looking at the signs for $3.95 thinking I'm going to put a dollar sign on it and we're going to go out and tell everybody or ask all the logic community to come up with a $395 deal and it'll be a year-round promotion that we can put out and it can be stay395.com and it could be that the Westin decides to put together a package that's one night but it includes skiing and massages and food and this and it could be that it's the Motel 6 says you can stay for a week for $3.95.

25:00 So I think that's one of the places that I think we can brand that. And it's definitely the 395 icon for this area is definitely one that resonates. And I think it's not a seasonal thing. It's something that can continue on for a year-round basis. Because I know in October I saw a lot of senior citizens wandering around Mammoth looking for things to do, you know, traveling after school was back in session. And that's a lot of the international market as well. Oh, yeah. In September, October, if you...

25:25 Weren't hearing people speaking German, you weren't listening because there was plenty of them here. And so the international market continues to be a strong one because of our location to Yosemite as well as all the offerings that we have here. So we'll continue to work. We have an agency in Australia and an agency in the UK that we work closely with. And we're going to start to work a lot more closely with Discover America, which gets the word out for us as well.

25:47 And today, Tioga's still open. It's November 17th, and it's over 50, you know, so there really are opportunities. Very true. What is the background of Whitney Lemon? What is her experience? Whitney actually, she had spent a, she came to Mammoth in 2001 or 2002 and had been here for quite a while, went back, got her MBA in Arizona. She had worked for the radio station here, and she also worked for the 1849 condos.

26:12 And had gone back, got her MBA, was living back in D.C., doing some consulting with AOL and a few other companies, and just really, I refer to Whitney and many others as boomerangs, because they seem to leave here, but they can't stay away. And she definitely is one of those, and so she couldn't wait to get back here. At this point, she's probably working 16 hours a day. I tell her I don't want to get emails from her at 3 in the morning, but I do. But she's making things happen, which is fantastic.

26:40 That's good. Who's doing the design work on the planner? Is that local? Yeah, Laura. Laura's still doing it? Yeah, Laura's still doing the work. Laura Patterson. Yeah, Laura Patterson. And we've got a few, we actually had to bring in a few extra freelancers as well because we've got so many things that we were trying to accomplish. But it's all local. With these emails you're sending out, how do you capture people? How do you get them to look at the Mammoth email? On which?

27:04 You're sending out one of your points there. I'm missing a couple pages in my packet, but you said email messages and trying to pull people in, but how do you get them not to delete that as spam? Well, you know, I think we try and keep it compelling. The big key with email marketing is it has to be pertinent, it has to be timely, and it has to be relevant to what they're looking for. So we are going to continue to try and segment that as much as possible as well. Our database right now is about 20,000 people, and we want to be able to segment that to say, okay, we've got all these people within the...

27:33 The LA DMA, and we want to talk to all those people and say, hey, we're going to be at the ski show next week, whereas somebody in our database from Chicago could care less that we're going to be at LA. So keeping it as relevant as possible is big, and segmentation is important. We can target certain age groups, as much information as we have, we can target.

27:53 I was new to the whole concept of branding when we did our peer resort tour to Aspen, and I was just fascinated with Aspen leaves on everything, and I thought, oh, that's wonderful, why can't we do something like that? But now I know that branding is a lot more than a logo. It is. You mentioned the 395 connection, you mentioned, there was another one in there. What are some other components of branding Mammoth? Well, the brand essence of Mammoth is everything from the scenery to the people.

28:18 It's the characters that we have in town. It's the look, the feel, the vibe, the big focus on the service is a huge piece because a lot of your branding is how people perceive your resort area. And if people walk away thinking, oh, great skiing or great sightseeing, but we didn't get treated well, that hurts your brand pretty hard. Oh, yeah. So there are a lot of components, and it's much more than just hiring a designer to throw a logo together. It's really finding out what...

28:47 The destination needs to people and how it makes them feel and what that translates into for an image and colors and the whole nine areas. So it's pretty in-depth. I completely regranded my resort back in New Hampshire and it was a great process because what I thought our resort was and what my team thought our resort was, we were off. And so when we went out, my opinion of what things are doesn't matter. It's really, it's the people that are coming here that we need to listen to and figure out what they feel this place is all about because...

29:15 I can feel one thing and it's not what the world feels. So it's too important to listen to everybody. I'm really glad you came today because this is very helpful. Thank you. Excellent. Any other questions? Any other questions from the commission? I want to thank you, John. Thank you. I've sent out page suggestions to my 800 plus friends on Facebook and my pages that I have. Absolutely. We've got to get to the beer party. Exactly. You're all invited. And I just want to say, you know,

29:42 Myself and actually Commissioner Dew when we both began our civic journey in this town as tourism commissioners and I won't speak for Rhonda but for myself and she probably will agree it's great to see somebody that's finally breathing some life into our soul. I appreciate that. It's just great everything you've been doing in our conversations. It gives us a lot of good positive thoughts for the future. We'll continue on that route. Thank you. Thank you.

30:11 All right, then, as I said, our next two presentations with Jim Smith and Howard Pickett have been canceled. And, Mark, do we have a new date for them? Tentatively, your next meeting on December 8th. Okay. And so they'd be presentations again in the front. And this is part of your continuum of progress reports on your destination, resort, community, and economic development strategy program. Great. All right, then. We'll move on to our consent agenda.

30:39 I'd like to pull this item. Okay. Go ahead, Elizabeth. There's a correction on the first page, which is page 8 of our packet. The second paragraph under reports from the commission, I remember clearly, and I'm sure Tony does too, Chair Barrett concurred with my comment on the really nice paint job on the Lutheran church. Right. So, where it says comment on the Newsweek article, it should say the paint makeover on the church.

31:08 Which is referenced in the first paragraph. That's my only correction. Any other corrections? All right, Elizabeth, do you want to make a motion? I move that the minutes of October 13, 2010 be approved as amended. All in favor? Oh, I'm sorry, second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Motion passes? I'll abstain because I was not here. Motion passes for...

31:38 Chair Barrett. Yes. The Newsweek article was about Carmel, Indiana, you will recall, on roundabouts, and that's where I moved from, and it was quite a feat to get the roundabouts, first of all, put in the ground, and then having to reconfigure because people were

32:00 Trying to, anyway, it was a good experience and it is the roundabout capital of the world. We have lots. So that happened while you were there? Oh yeah. I was there for 30 years. So long ways after that, what's the buy-in like among the population there? The people began to accept and like roundabouts. So it was a matter of adjusting and first of all, they were too open.

32:31 So we had to, they had to go back and reconfigure and make them tighter because people were buzzing through them, which was not what they were supposed to be doing. It was to facilitate traffic flow, and it wasn't. So it was a learning process, but a very healthy one. All right, we've on public hearings. We have none today. We'll move on to our business matters. Zoning code update, Chapter 17.60 on application processing and fees.

33:01 This will be with Sandra. This is one of three that we'll be doing today. Sandra. Thank you. This report focuses on four different chapters of the zoning code update, applications, processing, and fees, administrative responsibility, appeals, and public hearings. And staff did the research and looked at our six comparison codes and came up with recommendations for each different chapter.

33:27 If you'd like, we can, I can do my whole report, and then we can talk about the chapter all together, or if you want to just go one by one. How about if we go one by one, because I think as you all know, Jay and I sit on that committee, so, you know, we're going to be more interested in hearing about the thing you have to say. We've already reviewed this, so if that's fine, if you could do chapter by chapter? Sure. Okay. That would be good, Senator. All right. So the first chapter was Applications, Processing, and Fees. Basically, this chapter covers the authority for land use decisions.

33:56 How an application is processed and the fee requirements. Our current code has this information, however, it's spread amongst all the chapters. So we looked at our comparison codes and consolidated all the information in one chapter, which is similar to what our other codes do. And so we had a couple questions on this chapter for you. The first question

34:18 is on page 15 of the packet and in the past the commission has expressed a desire to lower the level of review for permit decisions and staff just wanted to know if the review authority which is within the review authority table in the applications processing and fees chapter on page 20

34:39 If any of those should be modified to lower the level of review. We did discuss this with the zoning code users group and they thought that what was shown on this page was appropriate. So they didn't recommend making any changes. However, staff thought we would like to ask the commission this as well. Does anyone have any comments or suggestions, changes to that? I do. Elizabeth? This didn't acknowledge the planning commission subcommittees.

35:03 Which I think have been really useful with some preliminary design review, colors, signs, that sort of thing. And I think lowering the level of review, that makes sense. You know, it's more expeditious and more efficient. But why weren't the Planning Commission subcommittees acknowledged? The subcommittee structure doesn't live within the zoning code update. The subcommittee...

35:26 Process is something that the Planning Commission and the town choose to do by policy and procedure, not by law. So we would continue all of the subcommittees until they're no longer lenient, which I don't know what that would be. But this effectively places the decision-making actions at either the director level or the full body of the Planning Commission. And so it doesn't change or supersede any of the subcommittees.

35:56 And most codes, I'm not aware of any zoning codes that establish by law a subcommittee process, actually a committee because the commission is the commission. That's true. That's true. And so you still have all of that flexibility and this doesn't change it. Well, then in conjunction with that, number three talks about the community development director can approve minor changes to projects. Of course, you can't define minor. It has to be sort of ambiguous.

36:26 You know, this zoning code is going to be in place for a long time, and we're still working with the 1986 zoning code, and I'm thinking down the road, future community development directors, do we want to have some kind of escape clause so that that isn't the sole authority of the community development director if perhaps someone were to, you know, join the staff in Mammoth who had a very urban point of view and saw things differently than maybe the community does as represented by the citizens on the Planning Commission.

36:55 Do you understand what I'm saying? We talked about that in the zoning code user group meeting about this, and we discussed it a while and batted around it, but the conclusion we came to was there really isn't any way you can define that, but like you say, you're right, it depends on the community development director, the person in their position, and the solution is if they're not doing it right, council tells them that, and they correct it. And the commission has the ability to like council when they're not doing it right.

37:24 So that's the escape clause. Yeah, you know, I'm talking down the road. I'm talking just total faith in you. I guess you said you're wasting my mark. No, total faith in you. This is way down the road. The role of the director, not only to interpret the code, but one should have a little political acumen and be able to navigate the treacherous policy waters that we live within. And if you can't, you shouldn't be doing this job.

37:51 If a director or a planner, whoever the decision maker is, isn't able to figure out when to call on the assistance of a committee or when to bring an item to the full planning commission, that's a personnel issue. That's not a zoning code issue. Okay. Well, I'm satisfied with that. Okay, along those same lines, Mark, I guess my concern, it talks about

38:20 Colors, elevations, exterior materials, etc. Could you elaborate elevations? Now, is that ground elevate? You're not talking heights, you're talking... No, an elevation. The building wall. Yeah, the building elevation. So if somebody wanted to change from a certain kind of stone to a very similar kind of stone, you know, I think that would be what we were talking about.

38:45 I mean, I assumed it was elevation was topography, no? No. Elevation is the architectural drawing reference to the drawing of the building facade. It's not height or topography. Okay. Thank you. And could you give us an example, please, of a major change?

39:05 I think a major change would be where someone, where a condition of approval was changing that would make, maybe the commission made a decision based on some condition of approval or something like that. We typically would look at this, we usually talk to the chair, this is our current practice, we talk to the chair, because there is a policy of the commission that allows us to make minor changes. So we talk to the chair and say, do you think this is something that we should bring to the full commission? And so that's usually how we've handled these changes in the past.

39:34 You know, so basically a big change that would, you know, I think affect the way the commission had made their decision. Maybe they wouldn't have made the decisions that way. Would a good example for Commissioner Clark be like the cuppies where that use was a major change, it was a use change, so which was a major change? From use? That, you know, was a... I'm trying to give her something to get her arms around. I think, you know, we get this, we handle this frequently, and so if we have a building design that's been reviewed and completed...

40:03 And they move, maybe they extend a porch a little bit out, you know, a foot or two. Compare that to somebody who wants to add a story of a building. That's major. And then when you go through your review of the project, you're considering the composition of the project and your policy considerations are obvious to us. You know, we all know the building height and density and major elements of architectural design.

40:29 You know, those are big things. And so that's what major really means. And the staff is very well practiced at interpreting that. Thank you. And I think it's worth emphasizing that what we're saying here is that this is the way we've been doing it. And this really isn't a change from the way we've been doing it. Okay. Justifying. Some of you have been doing it longer than I have. So thank you.

40:59 So item, we kind of went, we did question one and question three. So question two identifies an application review sequence in section 17.60.060. And staff just basically wanted to know if that should be more detailed or if this general outline was appropriate. We did discuss this with the zoning code users group and they did feel that this, what's shown in the code.

41:25 Is appropriate. They didn't think any more detail would be appropriate in the code. Mr. Clark? No. I agree. Mr. Kenney? Oh, I'm sorry. I didn't hear my name. How would incentive zoning... That was just an example is that there's probably going to be a process for that and should it be included in here or should that just be part of our application materials?

41:55 Which is, I think, what the zoning code users group agree, that that should all be more detailed in our application materials and not in the code. That definitely makes sense to me. Yeah, that's where I think it should be. And Sandra, just to clarify, I don't, this is one of the places where the goal of making the process more understandable to the applicant is at the forefront. I don't think there was something like this in the old code. There was.

42:23 Information on it in the old code, but it was not very clear. Right. Okay, so the next chapter was the administrative responsibility chapter. This chapter is included in our comparison documents. It's not included in the zoning code now. There are references to the planning commission in chapter 2.32 of our municipal code.

42:47 Staff thought that this would provide a clear picture of the types of projects that are considered by the Community Development Director and Planning Commission, and we didn't have any questions for you on the chapter, but if there's anything to discuss, we'll take notes. Questions, comments? I'm sure, just to confirm, that as you go through this, you're searching for inconsistencies, searching out inconsistencies and contradictions and all the problems that people have complained about. That's what, yeah. Okay. We have lists.

43:15 lists of issues, and we go through all those lists to see if there's anything that relates to each chapter, and basically right now we're kind of dealing with the administrative type chapters, and so basically it's just kind of the broad user friendliness that we're dealing with right now. Once we get into commercial, residential, we'll have a lot of detailed issues that have come up that we can deport to you on. Just to clarify that more too, I think we're not taking the old code and taking those ambiguities and

43:42 It consists that we're not addressing those. We're addressing the general plan with the new code. So is that a good way to... Right. And, you know, we have lots of information from previous processes about what's wrong with the code. This other code users group gives us more information of what's wrong with the code. And so when you see this information drafted, it's addressing those hosts of issues. But it's not just a reworking of the old code.

44:11 You know, it is completely fresh and new and it's not a rework at all. Yeah, you're not going to be able to... That was an excellent way to do it. That's great. Yeah, you're not going to be able to take the old code and go page by page and see strikeouts. That's not what we want to do. Good, good. Yeah, it was very cumbersome and frustrating. We wanted to match the general plan of 2007. Excellent. Excellent. Thanks. So the next item is Chapter 17.92, Appeals. And...

44:38 Based on our comparison codes, we expanded the current appeals chapter to outline what actions can be appealed and basically the process for appeals.

44:48 And we also did include several items that were issues from recent appeals, just basic information. One question that came up in a previous appeal was, does it have to be noticed in the same manner as the original hearing? That is in state law, but we put it in our code just so it's very clear. We can quickly find that information. So staff just had two questions on this chapter. First was, we maintained our current 15-day appeal period.

45:12 Although some of our comparison cities, I think two out of the six have a 10-day appeal period. So staff just wanted to see if the Planning Commission agreed that we should maintain the current 15-day appeal period. Any comments? Comments? Anybody has a comment? What's wrong with the 10 days? I mean, that seems more expeditious to me. What are the drawbacks of a 10-day period? Appellants may not have enough time to pull together all the information to file an appeal.

45:43 Let's say somebody lives with, like today we have a meeting and something is approved and they don't really hear about it until next week sometime. Their 10 days is up very shortly after that. So the 15 days is just more for the community to give them the opportunity to voice their objection to it if they have to. I didn't notice, is it clearly spelled out those are calendar days, not business days? Yes. It says calendar days, okay. Okay, so I'll go with that.

46:11 And then the second item was the current appeal section requires an item to be referred back to the planning commission if the town council makes modifications. And so staff reviewed all the comparison codes and most of the codes make that optional by the town council that they can optionally, you know, refer it back to the commission. And so staff included that and just wanted to confirm in the commission that this is appropriate. And that just goes to like a de novo, is it what it's called?

46:42 Kind of hearing that the council does the item. Basically, when it's appealed, it's brand new, and they're not taking what we did. They're listening to everything and making a new decision based on the material over again. It was my recollection of our rationale was that there are some instances, and you can come up with examples, where everybody would agree it wouldn't make sense, that it would just be a rehash of the very same thing. Whereas there are other instances where it's

47:12 Is very necessary. So the point was not to waste time in every instance when it's not always needed. Right. And he gives the council the opportunity to say before this back to Planning Commission. Any other questions, comments, consensus? Yeah, I was really sort of flummoxed by this. In line three of item two there on page 16, Sandra, did you mean to say modifications to a Planning Commission decision upon appeal?

47:40 Is that what I wrote in. Is that what you meant to say? Probably, yes. Okay, because I'm trying to remember when an item was appealed to council and then council sent it back to us or the council did the planning. I just, I'm really, I can't think of an example. This just doesn't work in my head. I need some, maybe a specific example. With the appeal process.

48:08 What it typically allows is once the Planning Commission has held the public hearing and made an action, an appeal may be filed, and then the Town Council holds a new, entirely new public hearing on the matter. So to date, no appeal has been upheld while I've been here, and the Planning Commission's decision has been made, or has been upheld.

48:34 Yeah, okay. So it's an awkward word. If you uphold the appeal, then you're reversing the Planning Commission reaction. But if you uphold the Planning Commission? So, and then the point of having a phrase in the code that allows it to go back to Planning Commission, it's really intended to allow for an introduction of a new item.

49:00 And so, you know, let's say there was an appeal going on, it's a new hearing, and there was something that wasn't thoroughly considered by the Planning Commission, then in that situation, the Council could refer it back, but they need not. Elizabeth, I think maybe going back six, seven, maybe even eight years ago now? No.

49:20 I'm getting old, honey. I know. I'm just remembering back on my council days, and there was, I believe it was a bluffs issue. Yeah. And we had a lot of issues. When it came to lot coverage using pavers that are porous versus poured cement. Oh, yes. Turf blocks. And we sent it back to the commission to go back over it again. We didn't make a decision. We sent it back to you. Okay. And that's where a lot of the policies came up on the bluffs.

49:49 Okay. Then I think what's confusing me is what kind of modifications would council make to a Planning Commission use permit decision? They could. Let's say you approved the project at a certain height with a certain number of stories and the town council said no, we want less, then you should review again the use permit because it's a substantial change to the project. Or potentially should. The council said that itself.

50:16 One caveat is that when we do our analysis and bring something forward, we're careful to make sure that we've covered everything that we can think of for your consideration so that there's a very low risk of having new information. So Elizabeth, like on the Ritz-Carlton project, when it came forward, you were on the commission, it was approved, it went to council, height, density, massing, it was appealed.

50:46 And when we sat on council, we heard it as a de novo hearing again, and we upheld the Planning Commission decision. And we let it move forward. What we could have done is said, no, we want this height, less density, and sent it back to you on the commission. And had you reworked it, if so, it didn't come back to us. That makes sense. Yes, it does. Rhonda, what do you think? Having gone through something close to this not too long ago, it's...

51:17 It's hard to see when that would actually happen. It would, because what it is, is if they're upholding an appeal, you're not talking, rejecting that project, it's abandoning item. But I, so I don't think, one thing I was reading this to be, is not that you mandate it go back. It's allowing, if it's appropriate, but it's rarely that it's appropriate, but you certainly don't want to mandate that because then it's,

51:46 They're doing our workforce, as you pointed out earlier, and then what's the point? Okay, I'm good with this. Okay. We'll move on, Sandra. Thank you. Thanks. The final item is the public hearings chapter, and currently this information is within our code, however, it's kind of distributed between all the different use permits, variances, different chapters, so we consolidated it all into one chapter, and we did include some clarification items.

52:14 Based on some issues that have arisen during recent public hearings. And we didn't actually have any questions for the Planning Commission on this chapter. Any comments? Any comments on that? I've got a general question. Can these updates to the Municipal Code be adopted section by section, or do we have to wait until it's all done? Because this is so much better than what we have now. I mean, it's just so clear.

52:44 Yeah. All of these other related sections have specific definitions that need to be crafted. Okay. And so, and as you see these in chapter headings, they're not complete articles yet. And so, you know, we're skipping around a little bit. And so, although we'd like to, I think it would be more cumbersome than it would be efficient.

53:12 Yeah, okay. But let's also say, Elizabeth, too, that this isn't, even though we haven't codified it yet, and it won't be yet, staff is not, I mean, in my opinion, they're not going strictly by what we've had in the past. They're applying a lot of this because it's already there. It's just now this is a different way of looking at it. Okay. So some of it's going on still. Mm-hmm. Or they come to myself as a chair, they ask a question, and we can decide if it comes to the commission.

53:42 No, I'm really pleased with how this is going. This is, that was a good thing to start from scratch. And that concludes my presentation on those items. And just a note, don't put too much weight on the chapter numbers as they may change throughout this process. So maybe just try to think of it in terms of the item because we were kind of changing things around a little bit so the numbers might.

54:04 Be modified a little bit. And Jennifer, are you just looking for consensus on each of these? That's great, right. They were going in the right direction. Right. So do we have consensus on this first amendment? Absolutely. Okay, let's move on to our next one, which is number six, which is chapter 17.72. Jen, it's yours. Welcome. Nice to see you. Yes, thank you. Thank you. This chapter is for the zoning code update for variances.

54:29 We haven't had too many variances come forward over the past few years. So variances briefly are a relief that is allowed by state law to prevent what would otherwise be a complete prevention of use for properties that have physical conditions such as smaller lot size, unusual topography, things like that, that creates hardships for development on that property.

54:59 So the variance chapter is taken pretty closely from state law, which applies to all the other California codes, and so in looking at our comparison codes when drafting this chapter, they were all very similar, and there wasn't a lot of gray area or flexibility there. We did bring this chapter to the zoning code users group, and there were no suggestions for specific changes, and staff doesn't have any specific questions for planning commission either.

55:29 On this chapter, so no specific direction, but if you have any comments or questions, we'd be happy to take those. Questions or comments? Variances only apply to peculiar physical characteristics. Yes. Nothing else. Yes. Yeah, I think it's important to note that since 2005, we've had four. Yeah. Applications. Okay. Jan, do you... And we only approved two of those. Go ahead. Is there questions? Sure. Page 54.

55:59 Minor modifications and edit. Can you give me an example of that purpose? Page 54, bottom. Yes, the handwritten 54. So that's actually speaking to adjustments.

56:18 Adjustments are different than a variance, and adjustment is an administrative... Oh, I'm sorry, I may be ahead of you. I was just flipping through and finding where I had Mark. Are we ready for adjustments? Adjustments is going to be coming up next. Next meeting. No, your next meeting. Okay. Yeah, December 8th. So we'll keep them close together. Yeah, it's just that this was all part of one. It could be a little confusing because it was part of a past planning commission agenda. Oh, so we're not... No, you're only looking at variances on page 53 and 54.

56:47 Okay, well, it said agenda item 6, so. Yeah. It's these two pages, it was just attached at the bottom. Yeah. And we've got that for you. Okay. It's your ahead of the game. Yes, yes. Sorry about that. Sorry about that. Okay, then. Do we have consensus on this item? Okay. It's good. Very good, thank you. Let's move on, Jen. Number 7, zoning code update 17.96. Yes, thank you. This is the draft zoning code update chapter for development agreements.

57:17 Development agreements like variances are also regulated by state law. So there are certain provisions in here that are required by state and aren't included in other California codes. We did look at including some clarifications and revisions based on our recent experience with the Snow Creek Development Agreement, which was helpful in reviewing this chapter and updating it. We did also bring this chapter to the Zone and Code users group last week.

57:46 And the items that we discussed with the zoning code users group were certain things that we have in our current zoning code that are not included or required by state law or included in other comparison codes that we used for review. So our discussion included looking at those certain items and seeing whether they were appropriate to continue to include or if there were some revisions that may be more helpful in applying this chapter in the future.

58:16 Some of those items included clarification on what the development plan is, which is required with the development agreement application. Another item that was discussed was whether or not a development agreement application should be accepted by the town council before it's processed, and that is a question that we have here for you today. And the other two were that the code previously required

58:43 that if a development agreement term of longer than seven years is approved, then there would have to be exceptional findings of unusual circumstances or exceptional circumstances made for a development agreement of longer than seven years. We did, since state law allows 20 years and no other codes had that provision and in the past we have approved development agreements at 20 years, we did revise that section of the code.

59:10 to provide a commensurate or proportional relationship to the term and the benefits provided. And the other unique thing about our code was that we require that a specific time schedule be included in a development agreement. State law includes that as an optional content. And what we've included is rather than requiring the specific time schedule, we've required a general phasing plan.

59:38 So that we get an idea of schedule still, but maybe not in depth that can be difficult or unreasonable with some of these larger scale projects. So with that, the only question we had posed that we didn't really have consensus with or specific direction with the users group was whether or not town council should accept development agreement applications before we go through negotiations and hearings.

1:00:08 To weigh the options of that, there were feelings that it was positive to have council accept it to get sort of some general feedback and early input from town council before money and time on both the town and developer side could be in theory wasted spending time on a development agreement that council in the end may not approve and then the other flip side of that is potentially that council may

1:00:38 I think Jen, correct me if I'm...

1:01:05 Mixing this up with a different part of the discussion, but I think there was a concern expressed also against this requirement because it introduces more time and expense for the applicant. Do you remember that discussion? Yes. Yes. Questions, comments? Jen, can you give an example of exceptional circumstances? It would justify a longer term. What's examples of exceptional circumstances for a development agreement?

1:01:36 Well, we did make exceptional circumstances findings for the Snow Creek Development Agreement considering the scope and size of the project that the development agreement would be subject as well as the current economic climate. What the current chapter proposes instead of that finding is on the bottom of handwritten page 78. So the change proposed there on page 78

1:02:07 Would be the change to say the term or duration of the agreement has a commensurate relationship to the benefits provided. You see the difference, Elizabeth. In the discussion with the user group, the question was, what's so magic about seven years? That below that, you don't need anything exceptional. For seven years and one month, you do up to 20 years. And the response was, well,

1:02:34 Doesn't it just make sense to tie it to whatever that period is, be it one year or seven years or 20 years? Okay. Okay. No, I understand. I had two more things. I hope I haven't lost them as I keep moving my pages around. Page 21. No, I'll stick with Jen's item. Someplace here it says should, and I think it should say shall. All right, I've lost it. I just said it.

1:03:07 Do you remember what the context was? So we can find it. Excuse me, I just misplaced it. I was just moving these pages around. It should do something with the town, and it seems like it should say shift, and I've lost it. Let's go back to page 21 if we could, even though that was the last item. Could we do that, Chair Barrett? Under concept review on page 21, it says... That's the last item we're going back to? Yeah, because it's the same problem.

1:03:35 Is that okay? Sure. I know it's sort of weird, but it's okay. Are we just getting consensus? D, yeah, hand number. D, concept review. And it says prospective applicants and agents are encouraged to request a concept review prior to completion of project design, et cetera. And we found every single time that when we have a workshop on the concept, on the idea, that we end up with a much better project and a lot less hassle for the developer.

1:04:03 Could we make that language stronger? Either strongly encouraged or are urged or more than just are encouraged? Could we make that verb stronger? Required is the only other thing you can say. I mean, are you going to require it or not? Because if you're encouraged to do that, based on it, you get a better product. But if they're not going to do that, then they're going to say...

1:04:29 Suffer the consequences of what that is, but unless you're ready to require that of every project and everyone's, you know, then it's subject into what are you going to have, what's the cutoff on the guideline? Yeah, I see what you're saying, but it seems to be, based on my experience here, that it always turns out better when we do that. Why not require it? I don't think that's one risk. It's a difference between always and almost always. There still may be instances where it wouldn't.

1:04:59 And why required in that instance and require them to go to that extra expense if there comes up the case when it really doesn't result in better. And you may be right, but the feeling was that that ought to be left open for that reason. Could we say are generally required? Is that enough? No, you're either required or you don't. You do or you don't.

1:05:21 Huh, because I think that saves a lot of money. You can say strongly encouraged. I mean, but that's more kind of just for your satisfaction to say it. It doesn't change it legally. It doesn't change it legally from strongly encouraged to encouraged. What's the commission thing? I'm fine with it the way it is. I mean, I think that's what our, with the group and...

1:05:40 I think it's got to be the developer's decision. I mean, frankly, I mean. And if it doesn't work for them, they have to go back to the drawing board and it's going to cost some more money. That's it. Besides, it doesn't occur to them to do that, so. But I guess. Oh, yeah, it does. We encourage them to do that. That's true. That's true. Yeah, appropriate projects. Okay, so we have consensus on item seven. Should or fell, because they were talking about the other one.

1:06:07 Regarding, so are you saying that the application must be accepted by town council? So this is, here it does happen. Oh, on page 73. Where are you, Rhonda? I thought that's first. Well, you're talking about the issue that's number one on page 74. Right, it's on page 74. That's what you're saying. That's the question. Yes. Should the town council continue to accept development agreement applications, or should they be notified to provide area input?

1:06:44 Yes. Okay. So shall we blur Sharon? I guess when you say accept that is what you meant when you said it incurs extra expense, et cetera, but I have no problem with notification doesn't have a problem. I mean, that doesn't incur expenses, does it? Well, it can, but not necessarily. If notification makes the council aware of an issue and they want to know more,

1:07:16 It could, but not necessarily. Okay, I guess I prefer notification then. I prefer notification. You too. Absolutely. The earlier the input, the better. Right, there you go, consensus. And then on page 77, I found the should. You found the should? I found the should. The should and so the shall, or shall and so the should? I don't know, but anyway, Commission, what's your pleasure here? Under review process and public hearings. What page, Elizabeth? Page 77, handwritten.

1:07:44 I think she's talking about the very bottom number. It's in the middle pre-application procedure, and it says prior to submitting an application, the applicant should hold preliminary consultations with a community development department. Shouldn't that be shall? This is the same idea. It's the same issue. Yeah, it's the same issue. It's wordsmithing that's not. I just want to pound him over the head and say, you know.

1:08:12 Just go talk to them and save yourself a lot of money and hassle. Okay, well, I tried. Let's hope they're all... If you go down to see public hearings on number one, and you look how shall is used there, second sentence. That's after all, you know, the process has begun, so then it shall begun. But up here, it's purely up to them. That's true, that's true. Okay. Okay, so we have consensus on that, Jim. We'll move on to... Thank you.

1:08:41 Oh, for the zoning code. Great. You're doing a great job. All right, then. Thank you, Jen. And we'll move on to number eight, our trail system master plan, environmental impact report, and a public scoping meeting. And we've got Ellen with us. Thank you, Ellen. Ellen, you're probably planning to do this, but can I ask a question before you get started? For the benefit of the public, can you clarify, in the EIR world, the difference between scoping, initial study, draft, and final?

1:09:20 For an EIR. Because I think, I mean, these are all important legal documents, and I just, I think that's really important for people to understand. Yeah, all of those are components of the California Environmental Quality Act process, and the way in which those terms are applied depends on the extensiveness of the environmental review that's being conducted. Every CEQA review, with the exception of

1:09:49 Projects that are found to be categorically exempt for some reason are required to prepare what's called an initial study, which when you know you're going to go on and prepare an environmental impact report is really a screening document. It's a preliminary identification of the issues that ought to be studied in your much more extensive environmental impact report. In some cases where

1:10:11 You're going to prepare what's called a negative declaration for the project with sort of a lesser level environmental review because usually it's a smaller scale or fewer issues are involved. That initial study will actually contain all of the analysis in depth to study the project. So in this case, because we're writing an EIR, the initial study is that screening document. It's there to identify the scope of issues that should be addressed in the EIR.

1:10:35 And the scoping process is the opportunity for the public to review that initial study, understand the scope of issues that have been preliminarily identified and provide input on any additional topics that should be addressed. So scoping comes after the initial study? In this case, the initial study is released with a notice of preparation that says we've done an initial study and that has told us that we need to prepare an EIR for this project.

1:11:04 And then that's released for public review, which is the period that we're in right now. And that's called the scoping period. And that scoping period is an opportunity to provide additional input on the scope of issues for the IR. That's why it's called scoping. Okay, so for the public, when the scoping meeting is held, and it's a funny noun turned into a verb or whatever, but what it means is if there's any environmental impact concern about this particular issue, it needs to be raised in that issue, in that meeting.

1:11:33 And by law, the EIR is required to address all the issues that are raised in what they call the scoping meeting. Isn't that right? It's not quite true. The scoping meeting is another opportunity within the broader scoping period to provide comments. That's true. Okay. So, you know, you have a live presentation. I'm able to give, you know, and provide verbal comments, really. So it's certainly unrestricted to comments that are received during the scoping meeting. We will accept.

1:12:00 Emphasize this. Written comments, email comments, faxed comments, and verbal comments at this meeting, verbal comments at this meeting from anybody that cares to raise an issue that they feel is of concern. But an issue that's raised after that period closes is not required to be addressed. It could come up on comments on the draft EIR, but generally speaking, in that draft EIR, you wouldn't address all the issues raised during the scoping process. Okay.

1:12:30 Good. So there's, you know, and I think one reason why I wanted to have this little PowerPoint presentation is it shows that there are, in the CEQA process, many opportunities, particularly when you're writing the IR, a number of opportunities for public input and comment throughout that process. So this is certainly

1:12:48 Not the only opportunity for input. We expect to receive comments during the scoping period, and we also expect to have people provide comments when the draft EIR is released in a couple of months. Good. I think that was helpful. It was helpful. Yeah, it's complicated. So while Helen, or sorry, while Helen is doing that, we will, after a presentation, then we will take comments from the public before the commission. Okay.

1:13:32 And if you are going to be providing comments, there are cards in the back, if you could fill those out so that Karen, our clerk has your name.

1:14:01 For while we're streaming. No, we have our plans up. So the purpose of the California Environmental Quality Act is fundamentally to provide information to the public, to decision makers about the potentially significant environmental effects of a project to disclose those impacts and document them. It applies to any project for which a government agency has a discretionary approval. It looks at potential impacts on the environment and it...

1:14:29 Importantly, in doing that analysis, identifies mitigation measures that may avoid or reduce those potential effects. Very briefly, just the secret process includes preparation of an initial study and NOP. We have a 30-day period which began on October the 29th, which will run through December 6th, actually slightly more than 30 days to allow for the Thanksgiving holiday.

1:14:57 And this scoping meeting is held during that 30-day period to solicit verbal comments or written comments for people that prefer to provide input in that forum. We're having that meeting here with the Planning Commission simply because the Planning Commission will be reviewing that EIR as well as the Draft Trust's Master Plan and making a recommendation to the Town Council on its adoption. So it's a good opportunity to introduce you to the project in this process as a first step.

1:15:27 As well as to the public. The scoping information is incorporated into the draft EIR, for which there's a 45-day public review period. And during that time, we will hold a study session, again, to solicit comments from the public on that draft document. And based on comments that we receive, responses to comments will be prepared, that will be published, any changes or corrections made to the draft EIR will be included.

1:15:55 And that will be the document that is originally brought back to the Planning Commission and Town Council for certification. This is just a, I won't go through all of these steps here, but all of those orange dots are opportunities for public comments, and they include opportunities to comment by mail, fax, email, verbally at this meeting, opportunities to comment on the draft EIR when it's circulated for 45 days.

1:16:23 As well as public hearings on the project itself. So there are a number of opportunities. And I think throughout the process, if issues do come up, certainly those can be addressed, even if they happen outside of the sort of formal opportunities for comment as well. So just very briefly,

1:16:44 We did conduct an initial study with our consultants to develop that, looking at sort of a screening level at the kind of fairly high level at the issues that are likely to need to be addressed in the EIR and the range of environmental issues. CEQA includes a checklist of issues that's quite extensive. It's 16 different environmental topics that are covered and went through that checklist, considered based on the project description that we developed.

1:17:09 Where impacts are likely to occur and which of those impacts ought to be addressed in the EIR. So that's really the point of this meeting. The initial study identifies three types of impacts.

1:17:24 Impacts that don't exist, that there are no impacts and don't need to be further analyzed or studied in the IR. And those are really things for which there is no possibility of impact. And the good example is agricultural resources. We don't have any farms and fields here in Mammoth. It's quite easy to say there's not going to be an impact on that resource because we don't have any of that resource here in town, so we're able to dismiss it quite easily. Then it also looks at impacts which

1:17:52 There may be an impact that it's going to be less than significant because of the scope or scale or other factors that come into play. And finally, issues that are potentially significant where the thresholds of significance of impacts identified in CEQA may be exceeded in a variety of topic areas. So generally speaking, that issue is quite, or that review is fairly broad.

1:18:17 And with the understanding that the EIR is going to provide the detailed analysis necessary to really make those detailed conclusions. This, based on the initial study that was prepared for the Trust and Master Plan, issues to be addressed are those that are listed here, and really it's the majority of issues that are in the CEQA checklist. The three or four that were dismissed were, in fact, agricultural resources,

1:18:46 Mineral resources, population housing, just because there won't be any displacement or removal of housing as part of this project or any significant growth inducing effects since we expect that this will serve really our existing visitor base and future visitors without in and of itself inducing new population growth and utilities in terms of placing demands on the water and wastewater system and so on due to the nature of the project.

1:19:15 Briefly, the schedule, the comments on the initial study are due on September the 6th, approximately a 30-day period for that. We do expect the draft to be out of February of next year. It took us a little bit longer than we'd expect it to really sort of hash out some of the details of the project description, so we're, I'd say, a little bit behind schedule, but generally on track to our target of adopting the

1:19:44 Final EIR and the Trail System Master Plan in April 2011. I went through all of that without really talking very much about the project itself, and there's a quite extensive project description in the Notice of Preparation that was distributed. I think an important point to note in there is the Trail System Master Plan draft was released in February of 2009, and as

1:20:09 You're probably aware there has been significant work primarily under the help of MLTPA to go out in the field and to begin to refine and further develop some of the ideas that were very kind of sort of initial really in the trail system, very preliminary in the trail system master plan. And in particular that work has focused down in the Sherwood area looking at the trail system down there, staging.

1:20:37 Opportunities, linkage opportunities, and a variety of components of the trail system that are in that very critical interface area between the urbanized town and the urbanized areas and forest lands around the town's boundary. And ultimately, the trail system master plan envisions a comprehensive trail system for the entire

1:21:00 Municipal boundary, not just the urban growth boundary, and that will ultimately be looking at trail system components in the shady rest area, in potentially the Knolls area, and in the lake space, in addition to the Sherwin's area, all of which are together with the urbanized trail system are important parts of the overall system and the vision for it. So the trail system master plan, EIR, will be looking at all of those components.

1:21:29 Principally on a programmatic level, which means looking at this as a broad program of trails, many of which we understand that there will be additional work to refine alignments to determine exactly where things should go and how they should be designed, but all of those facilities develop within the parameters and policies that are guidelines that have been established in the trail system master plan.

1:21:52 In addition to that program level review, there's a series of nine projects which we worked with, MLTPA and town staff worked together to identify which we're calling priority projects, which are those that we foresee as being brought forward in the next one to five years, depending on some funding availability and so on, that appear to be the most, some of the most important and most viable.

1:22:19 The EIR, to the extent that we can, will be looking at those nine projects at a more detailed project analysis level that we think will enable those projects to be implemented immediately without any significant amount of additional CEQA review. It's important to understand that there are many of those

1:22:47 Trusts and component, particularly for Sharp, are down in land that Forest Service manages and administers, and there is a MEPA process that needs to happen, that will have to happen after the CEQA is completed, and a Forest Service approval process, but notwithstanding that, essentially those projects are shovel-ready from a CEQA perspective and can move forward in the short term. So to that extent,

1:23:13 Being a sort of a combination of program, a long-range planning document environmental study and focusing on some of these short-term projects, the EIR will be really a very good basis to move forward and allow for effective implementation of the trail system over the next several years. Any questions or comments? Okay. Any questions for Ellen before? I'd like to get if there's any comments from the public first.

1:23:43 I can ask my question after the comments. Okay. All right, then. What we'll do at this time is take comments from the public. If there's anyone wishing to make a comment, please come forward, state your name. If you have your card filled out, that's appreciative. Thank you. John? Good afternoon, John Wentworth with MLTPA. I just wanted to initially thank Ellen and the...

1:24:09 Community Development Department, all the very hard work that's gone on so far with a pretty complex project, I think you can all imagine. I don't have any question or comment. At this point, we've been involved in the process so far. We may have some technical things prior to December 6th in the mapping, representation, and that kind of stuff. I do have a general question of staff, which we don't have to get into right now, but in terms of, in the Trail System Master Plan, there are other

1:24:34 There's mention of sidewalks and other kinds of facilities, and I'm just a little bit interested in terms of how staff or the Planning Commission envisions other commissions or other bodies being involved as this whole effort comes forward. The idea of getting to an adoption in April of 2011, which was obviously a very good goal to get to, but there may be a need for other commissions to be involved in this.

1:24:57 I think we would also anticipate that there could be some updates to the plan itself that don't have anything to do with CEQA, have more to do with design guidelines, based on things that are already being implemented. There's a full chapter about signage and wayfinding, and there's a lot of work that's gone into all that, and those may come in as amendments. I don't think they'll have any environmental implications. But that's my only sort of vague question at this point. Mark? A couple of different points. In community development,

1:25:26 Not the department, but what we do. We are successful by building relationships and collaborating with all of the relevant commissions. So the general plan, the resort strategy, this document, and all the others that will come forward should be reviewed, certainly by this one in particular, by the Recreation Commission, the Mobility Commission, the Planning Commission, and ultimately the Town Council.

1:25:57 We'll adopt those. One of our challenges has been in the past, and with the Community Facilities Funding Committee, is that too many of the documents have been developed in a silo mentality, and in one little niche of the town department, and they haven't been broadly vetted, more consolidated and composed. So the mobility plan will probably include the bikeway plan.

1:26:26 Which is updated on a more frequent basis because of the grant requirements. It'll also include the street network and the sidewalks. And then all of the plans we have, tiering from the general plan, which is the fundamental document that we all work within. In breadth of goals, policies and actions, the master plan documents and the neighborhood district plans add greater detail.

1:26:54 Other documents, particularly design guidelines, design manuals, and specifications, those, as you know, live in a different place. They're typically adopted by resolution, and the intent is that those are updated more frequently. The color guidelines, for example, that the Planning Commission uses, they change relatively frequently. The broader the document, the higher level it is, the less it should change.

1:27:24 And so as we're driving to complete the mobility plan, the arts plan, the trails plan, the bikeway plan, and develop neighborhood district plans and the resort investment public facilities element, staff, which is principally the recreation staff, public work staff, and community development, are working hand in hand with

1:27:49 Advocates and clients like MLTPA and the commissions appointed and elected officials of the town and the public. So when this document in particular was drafted, it contains information about the cross-section of Main Street, for example. So we'll probably take that information out of this document and keep it poised in the Main Street plan and the mobility plan.

1:28:18 Some of the documents that John just referenced, the wayfinding specifications, they may be an attachment, they may be adopted as a separate document, but they all need to integrate together and implement one another. So April is our target date. We've got an awful lot of work to do. The trail system master plan is one of the more complete master plans that has been developed. It's very comprehensive, and so it's easier.

1:28:48 The Park and Recreation Master Plan has few standards to it, so it will be a very high-level document that effectively updates the existing parks and recreation element of the general plan, which we did not update with the general plan process. So, as we get closer to completion of the CEQA document, then we'll start deploying staff resources, working with MLTPA and the commissions and other interested members of the public.

1:29:17 To final those documents to get them into the state where they need to be in terms of they have what they need and they don't have what they don't need so that they're clear, concise, and actionable. Thank you, Mark. Anyone else from the public wishing to make any comments? Okay, any comments from the commission that you'd like to make note of? Commissioner Park? No. Commissioner Tanney? Secret related comments. Yes, secret related.

1:29:48 Okay. Well, I've got a mix of comments here. I was really surprised at the number of potentially significant impacts, considering this is not, you know, a village or a, you know, hotel or something like that. That surprised me.

1:30:04 Were you the one who identified the impacts and then passed those on to the agents, the group in Irvine that prepared this, or did they come up with those? No, they, the PCR consultants prepared the checklist, which staff reviewed. You know, I think the answer to your question is that the initial study in this instance is, it's better to be more conservative than less in terms of your analysis, because you're just trying to really highlight the things that may be an issue, which you don't.

1:30:32 In the absence of information to the contrary, it's probably, it's better in this, the initial study in this forum to be more conservative in terms of identifying potential impacts. Some of those will likely be downgraded or maybe revised based on that additional analysis, but typically an initial study that's prepared in advance of the hour is more conservative than less.

1:30:55 That's why I asked you to clarify initial study. Yeah, that's good. I haven't, you know, read every word in this plan, but in the overview, I only saw one mention of motorized, and that was in terms of a rescue.

1:31:15 Or patrolling, you know, snowmobiles for that. Where does it talk about motorized use of the trail system? It did talk about how most of that is outside the greater metropolitan Mammoth area. I think that there's a whole set of issues about motorized use of different, you know, whether it's snowmobiles in the winter or, you know, ATVs and motorcycles in the summer that are really management issues. Generally speaking, because it,

1:31:45 Typically makes sense for the secret to analyze a worst-case scenario unless, you know, motorized vehicles are currently prohibited or there's a policy that's been forwarded to say that other areas should be restricted to motorized. The assumption is that if the Forest Service permits motorized use of trails in those areas that that will continue. So, you know, again, it's sort of a worst-case scenario, maybe more restrictive in the future, but...

1:32:12 Some of these communities don't know that information yet as to where those restrictions might be because they're not established or identifying policy at this point. Has vandalism-proof signage been considered? You can't make it vandalism-proof, but vandalism-clean-uppable signage been considered? I think that's something that's in the design guidelines. In terms of CEQA, I'm not quite sure where that would fit in. It might be a recommendation in terms of maintenance that, you know, non...

1:32:41 Graffiti-able, you know, methods are used for signage, so it may be a discussion point, I'm not sure it's necessarily a secret impact or something that may arise in the analysis. I'm asking, I happen to be in Reno this weekend and I walk the river walk with my husband from one end to the other and this wonderful signage, all kinds of history and, you know, just very well done. Every single one has been vandalized. It had a huge...

1:33:05 Spike and graffiti and vandalism and it's just it's awful just awful so I hope that that will be considered for the I was at the Lake Mary bike path that was when what staff came to the Planning Commission to inform us of what was going to be happening in terms of signage that was the Lake Mary bike path right and we hadn't had any review Planning Commission will have design review

1:33:32 For the signage and wayfinding for this, I know this is a sequel, but. You've already done that. When you reviewed the Lake Mary bike path signage criteria. Because it's the same. That was the leading edge effort to set the criteria. And John and Ray Jarvis and his crew have installed various forms of art and now they're getting it to a place where after it's been tested, it can be filed. For example,

1:34:01 The method that the graphic material is placed on the signage, they're working through how to make it something that is affordable but changeable as the system grows over the first few years and can be maintained over time, which includes not only vandalism and cuts and marking, but just wear and tear by getting blasted by.

1:34:31 The sun and weather. Oh, sure. Okay. Good. So that design review still applies that we've already done? Yes. Good. Okay. Those are all my questions. Thank you. Any other comments? No secret. Okay. Great. Thank you all. Just to reiterate, the comment period is open until December 6, 2010. I would certainly encourage anybody listening to this.

1:34:58 Broadcast today to contact me with any questions and to submit comments. We have a section on our website. The information is all on our website as well if you want to submit comments and look up information there too. So, back till December 6th. Thank you, Ellen. Thank you. All right, we'll move on to our last item, number nine. It's preparation for our joint workshop this evening with the council. Great. So,

1:35:29 The agenda bill, which is the draft, well, it's actually the agenda bill that was distributed through the town council packet is on your agenda item so that you guys can review and discuss your format. I have a draft PowerPoint presentation on my desktop right now, thinking that perhaps either the chair or Rhonda and Elizabeth can come view it and see if it would help facilitate your discussion.

1:35:57 A PowerPoint based on this? Absolutely. No, just this first thing. Mark and I discussed it the other day that it would be good to have a PowerPoint that Mark could just run through for us during the workshop because we have very limited time and there's a lot to go through. And kind of, if I may, Mark? So kind of what we talked about doing was, Rhonda was very eloquent when she brought up the what, why, and where.

1:36:26 She's nudging me. So what I'm kind of thinking of doing is we could open this workshop today, have Rhonda address that, and then go into the PowerPoint. That way we can move into questions in any kind of direction from the council without going through everything that they should have already read. Now council has a copy of this agenda bill? Yes. Yeah. Okay. That's good. So it's all gone. We're racing to get it dead so we can get it done.

1:36:50 Okay. So with the time. You look at that hour period. I'm looking at 60 minutes. Well, I don't even look at that. I'll look at 50 because by time you get seated, the clock starts ticking. What the chair asked was if I could take the major headings in a few words and create a PowerPoint slide for each subject item so that you're using that as your outline to keep on time. There's no new information. It's an amount of this. And one of the challenges you'll have is you.

1:37:20 Drop into a discussion. You might find an interesting subject like a gateway signage heating up all of your time. No, we don't want to do that. Right, and my thought was by doing this, we give the council, they've already read this, we can address it, then if we could get through this entire meeting to the point where we can get questions from them, we can run through everything first, have them wait for any questions so we don't get hung up on.

1:37:45 It keeps them on point. It keeps us on point. It keeps everything together very concise, and that gives us the time we need for questions from them and direction. When I think of all the things we want to discuss in 60 minutes, it's really... Right, so if we just kind of go through, have wrong to do that little kind of spiel at the beginning, if you would, and then do this PowerPoint, go through it all in great succession, does very rapidly, and then it gives us, you know, hopefully 20 minutes of time.

1:38:12 At that point for them to have questions of us and discussion. Have you seen the PowerPoint, Tony? We've discussed it, yes. Rhonda, do you want to see it before we go through it? Sure. Yeah, I would like to see it before 5 o'clock. That'd be good. Okay. Any other comments on this on the workshop? For the joint meeting? Yes, I have a comment. Okay. I have read the draft rec strats document and I'm curious and I haven't been able to find out about this and wonder if you want to talk about it today.

1:38:44 The Recreation Commission, if I can find the page, I'm having trouble finding pages today, has all these things that they are planning for, which I think is wonderful, all kinds of recreation activities, but they're also planning for something that I thought was part of our job, which is performance venues and event sites and sort of part of our overall planning for the town, and I wondered,

1:39:12 Nobody from planning was involved in this. It was the Recreation Commission and two council members. Is this something you would like to bring up today? Or do you think it's off point? We have our events facilities committee that I sit on for this planning commission where we have been discussing that. With the organizations, right? It's in coordination with rec strats. So there is that discussion ongoing right now. So all this about, it's these last...

1:39:38 Last three categories, not special events, but it's really, it's the facilities, you know, where they should go and how we can make it happen. And arts and culture, I just didn't know why that was under the recreation. What we've had is in rec strats, you've got, there's seven categories, seven buckets that we've discussed that's going forward. That involved a number five, I believe, was the recreation facilities, number seven is arts and culture.

1:40:05 We had a discussion yesterday with our events group that, you know, perhaps we could combine those because one says regional recreation, one says regional recreation or arts and culture. You know, you don't build a facility, you don't build a church for Easter Sunday, and you don't go out and try to build something you can't maintain. There has to be O&M costs, and we've had that discussion as well. So I think your question, as I'm hearing you,

1:40:32 Regarding rec strats and planning commission, I think that is all being handled in the council direction, has been that rec strats, it's the belief that events are part of recreational activities and part of the bigger picture, so combining it all is what rec strats is doing. So, you know, buildings on the ground, venues, that's going to be under the recreation commission? Because it seems like that's what we're supposed to be doing. No, we would be

1:41:01 Well, that would come to us, but I think, Mark, do you want to? I think that rec strats is... Because from the draft report, it's not clear. Rec strats is actually a little bit higher up. It's like 36,000 feet instead of 6,000. I think the thought is, by focusing on the subjects, whether they're the right subjects or not, how do the particular users, the people who truly care and want to advocate those types of facilities,

1:41:32 How do they come together to, in a sense, sign up and say, yes, this is an important facility to us? Separately, we can all wave our fingers as much as we want, but if it's not financeable, it's not financeable. And I think the focus, a way to think about this is that the neighborhood district planning effort is focusing on what, why, and where, and that's coming up from the bottom.

1:42:02 The focus group and the community workshops help inform that. And you're down to looking at a few catalyst sites. And then the work of the Capital Facilities Funding Committee and the resort investment element, that's going to set more substantial policies that guide facilities. And ultimately the council will have to adopt policies.

1:42:33 That guide their decision making. And as you recall in that community facilities committee work, return on investment. How do we actually measure the return on a facility that has public investment in it? How do you focus on visitation first? And I think those are principles that are already outlined in the general plan and in the resort strategy.

1:43:01 And so the work of the Planning Commission happens to be moving from the ground up, and the idea of the rec-stract program is way up here, and there is a belief that there are potential funds, high-level funds through the USDA, through Forest Service, that may be tapped into for some of those facilities. But essentially...

1:43:25 I don't think that the community has yet developed that essential sense of policy. Should we have a policy which we presented last time, and you asked us to follow up on, if you can't operate it, should you build it? Is a particular facility, does it become an unfunded liability once it's built because you haven't dedicated the revenue stream for maintenance and then also replacement?

1:43:56 And essentially our capital improvement program does not yet have the idea of an asset management plan or a dedicated asset management fund geared to those facilities. And with every facility, whether it's a sign or a segment of trail, the day that it is created is the day that you're maintaining it. Whether you're removing graffiti or resealing it or putting up a new sign.

1:44:23 I think that's key.

1:44:54 And I think in terms of a way that you might present what your work program efforts are is to make sure that we are truly coordinated and that we don't continue an ad hoc disjointed approach where a commission or a body is pursuing something aside from the others. Okay, that's exactly why I'm confused about who's responsible for what.

1:45:20 I mean, Rhonda so well articulated it. We've got to think about the what, why, and where before we think about the how. And so I just am trying, are we all talking to each other? Even though this rec stress, the recreation strategy is, you know, way up here. It's all encompassing. Who's responsible for what? I'm glad you're the liaison with the events committee because as chair of the Planning Commission, that's good. So planning is involved. But I just want to know what we're responsible for.

1:45:50 You know, I think... And I'm sort of... I was really confused when I read the rec strats draft report. I thought, how do we fit in? You know, I just wasn't sure what our job was anymore. That would be a good time to have that conversation with the council because... Tonight? That's why you're meeting with them. Yeah, I would like to bring that up. You made the district planning efforts. Look at the... Look what you produced through the Main Street, the downtown concept for Main Street.

1:46:19 You've got a place-based strategy that's dealing with every aspect of mobility, and we held workshops with mobility, and we held workshops with the community. It includes trails. It includes the aspects of economic development. It includes an events park kind of facility. And we certainly have more work to do, but remembering that rather than sticking things in places, we should be defining places.

1:46:50 Exactly. That's where you're headed and that's what your work program is. And so how you maintain and embed it in your work programs actually is outreach and collaboration and partnership. Perhaps you reinforce that and if we can find ways to make it stronger, that's great, making sure that we have commissioned membership and focus groups and community meetings as well as the separate workshops.

1:47:19 That's useful. We had workshops with the Art Commission, the Recreation Commission, and the Mobility Commission on the downtown program. Their comments were brought forward to you and then carried forward to the town council. And those comments resulted in changes and improvement of all of those plans. So that's a good theme subject. So what if we, on that PowerPoint, Mark, just add the last slide and put rec strats in.

1:47:48 And we can have Ronda start off. Yeah, you can start off with this on the PowerPoint, go through it briefly. We can end up with rextrads, and you can address that, Elizabeth. That would be great. But very specific to counsel on your questions, so we stay on point. I think it's a setup for that question. Otherwise, it comes out of the blue. But the whole point of when...

1:48:14 We decide, we're asking those questions of what is appropriate, where is it appropriate, and then it appears the rec strat says, we're telling you what it's going to look like, and nobody has really decided that that's what you need, and do you need it in that place? So that's where we're really working to, is this what you still want us to continue on? Because...

1:48:41 Someone may decide that this is the hot thing, we're going to do it, and then everybody runs to that side of the street and we're behind it. Then you have something that is unfunded. That's how we avoid an unfunded liability from doing that type thing here. So that's where we all have to be coordinated in this effort to make sure that it does have, we identify what it is. We also say, why is this important to the community? Why is this important to the economic development?

1:49:11 And our investment in, you know, our preparation for reinvestment. How does this fit? They need to, it needs to be stepped back to, this is how it, this is how it relates to that. Okay, where would be the best place for that? Now, now it gets down to what rec strats actually is identifying there. So they can identify, we think that with this, that hex is the right thing to do. Why?

1:49:40 Yeah. And we're, you know, so you have to turn that conversation around. I think what your PowerPoint will be a good setup for this type of thing and that it is a little confusing because we found, as we've found in other things, if you involve everyone, we all start from the same point, then we're going to have a better product and we won't be sending it back. And if I want to see what I'm asking if I could.

1:50:08 We have EPS under contract, and they're doing a bunch of work force. One is they're looking at our development forecast principally to make sure we understand what our reasonable development forecast is, and then tearing from that, the revenues that we can expect reasonably now at this time, what kind of projects we should be, how do we size our projects now, and what are our housing requirements, and

1:50:37 Many of the fiscal financing issues that will be explored through this process, they're going to be dealt with by Mr. Kieser. And so it will be part of that, which is follow-up to the Community Facilities Funding Committee and is embedded in the resort investment public facilities element. For instance, at our meeting yesterday, let's give you an example. We've had three meetings now, Mark? Three.

1:51:04 You know, what came up yesterday too, it actually came out at a previous meeting, we talked about event sites, facilities, and you know, it was brought up, we've got Mammoth Lakes Art Center, it's sitting there, they're trying to get it going. If you don't have the interest of folks using it, if we're not invested into it, it's going nowhere, that's what's been happening. Well, it's already got a roof, so why are we looking for other places right now? We need to be focusing on that. For instance, during the winter,

1:51:31 These summer events, Sierra Summer Festival, Jazz Jubilee, the other events that go on, why not during the winter do you use the Arts Center for a night to do a fundraiser? And you bring in, you know, Sierra Summer Festival brings in somebody, a small, you know, three-piece group or something. You do a fundraiser there. Jazz Jubilee can bring in a jazz group. So you start using the facilities you have to really see what you're going to need in the future. Okay, I've got another question of the commission. Let's just go back up to the higher level.

1:52:00 Who makes the recommendations for policy? Does it work with serial workshops for the different commissions and then it comes to us? Does it work with joint commission workshops where we talk about it and, you know, decide what policy recommendations should be? Ron Reckstrats. Yeah, Ron Reckstrats doing the what, yeah, the what, why, the big on the why, the where, and then the how.

1:52:25 Where does that come from? I know, that's what I want to ask tonight, but how does the commission feel about that? Or do you want to wait and hear what council says? I think we should hear the council, because I know I've heard from some council members on it, but I think the whole commission needs to hear. I think the best question is, how does the town and the community develop the most effective strategies? How to do that. Okay, that's good. If we had done the downtown program in a different way,

1:52:55 It would not have been as successful. We had to break the general plan and redo it with all of the commission input to gain community input. And so figuring out the best way to do it to achieve success, consensus, support, practicality, feasibility, you know, that's... And that's what you're asking. I'm not... It's...

1:53:23 This is success, practicality, feasibility, financeability, and looking at where are the best locations for these before you've even decided what this is. And or that keeps you from jumping ahead. And I guess that with the rec strat proposal, for lack of a better term, it seems like it's disconnected. And we have to go back and connect it. And I guess your question would be is,

1:53:52 How do we start right off the bat to always have it connected? And what are their recommendations? Because it's going to be, some are going to have different feelings than the others, and we just don't want to be working on two different projects with the same zeal that we can't support, because we really don't have the resources to support those things.

1:54:17 Perhaps what your conversation with the council is, is maybe you have three sections. One is your section, and you wrote this report, you and Rhonda, rethinking your priorities, making sure they're right. That's a big section, because that represents some sense of a policy shift in how this has been established previous years. The next is your work program.

1:54:46 You're moving in your every way is generally on schedule. And then I think maybe your third section is, is everybody moving in the same direction? And are you on path? And is rec straps good in whatever way it's delivered? Or should it be done in a different way? And caution not to let rec straps.

1:55:10 As a subject, eat your entire meeting. Oh, no, that should be the thought, that almost should be food for thought at the end of the meeting. Yeah, remember, it's, it's, uh, Maripotown Bacon and Rick's, Rick Wood, who are on Rick Strats for the council. So, what, if we're successful at this, we won't have to ask this question at all. Because we will have guided...

1:55:32 The answer. We will have guided them to where that answer, it'll be answered for us. So if we, if we look at, because that's what this was written in mind was making sure that there was continuity in everything that we did. And those answers, you'll be able to tell what it is. If, if it is completely vague and we've, we have a split decision, that's when we do the question is answered because it may be.

1:55:56 Some people fill this, and some people fill that, and we're just looking for clarity on where we should spend our time and energies and the limited resources that we have. So I think by going through the PowerPoint and looking at this, we will be able to insert this type of question without being as specific to this, because that did not come through us first, and there's always a tendency to say, why didn't you come to us first? The same way Council says every single thing should have come to us first.

1:56:25 But it's designed to prep this. And that's where we're looking for it. So you've done this level of preparation, and we will link this back to the number one thing, which is, does it increase visitation? And it has to be held up against that mirror every single time to, is it going to increase our visitation? Because that's the standard that we hold. Is this project worth doing? Well, I retract my initial question of who's in charge of what.

1:56:55 To, you know, we've all got to be on the same, you know, working together and agreed, and that's why we're having this joint meeting, so. And to make sure, to ensure that we are, you know, following, you know, that we're doing what everybody thinks we should be doing. Exactly. Well, thank you for the discussion. Any further discussion on the five o'clock workshop? In the next hour? And so you two will go over to Mark. Yeah. It sounds like it'll be, you know, helpful. Don't have to go into the detail of this.

1:57:26 It can stimulate conversation, but keep it on point. Exactly. All right, then. Appreciate matters? None of it? Director's report? I'd like to add on, the only thing I want to report is the event organizers group. Is that the third or the fourth meeting? Third meeting. Third meeting. So this is actually a very interesting organization, and I don't think it's a threat or a challenge to rec strats or anything else.

1:57:56 The group has now met a number of times. They've had Stu Brown, Ray Jarvis, myself, and John Ruggler-Gruger in attendance at some or all of the meetings. And the group has, I think, coalesced and understands that they can improve the events and festival climate of this town. And I think that what they see is...

1:58:23 Events have long been important to the economy and also the overall quality of life of Mammoth. And they think that perhaps by developing a business plan they could be more effective, especially in terms of improving the economy. It has suggested that perhaps they should set a goal of having X number of progressive meetings start entering into the shoulder season.

1:58:50 And that as a body of people who are doing similar and related things, that perhaps they could work with the town in some support role, and Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and both parties, Stu and John Urdi, have agreed to chair and support this continued effort. Can they develop a more effective coordinated schedule? Can they share resources and doses and volunteers?

1:59:16 Can the marketing promotion be taken up maybe three or four notches? And I think we all know that there are communities that are well known as events and festival communities, and their economy is dramatically affected to the positive by those events. And so I think this coordinated effort could result in some meaningful change to the community.

1:59:45 to the event sites, using the existing ones more, and preparing for the future. And that work rolls directly into the neighborhood district planning efforts that the Planning Commission is working on, understanding them as the appropriate uses, catalysts to the commercial areas, and taking advantage.

2:00:11 More of what we have, like Canyon Lodge. So the group seems to have coalesced, and I think it's a very positive step. And in closing, I think that as an economic development strategy for the town and implementing the resort strategy, this is an important effort. And I think they see themselves...

2:00:36 And also the historic role that the town has played in supporting that as something that's important to continue. Does the group represent all types of events from, you know, athletic or recreation events to music to performance? No. And there is a very big difference between the sports council and those people that are doing soccer to those people that are doing true performances, craft festivals.

2:01:03 I'll forward the meeting notes to you. Oh, I'd be interested to see, yeah. Yeah, basically, we've had Ken and Flossie, Michelle Tomoye from Mammoth Mountain, Kathleen Calderon, Mike Hoover with Village Fest. We've had Matthew, Mark Deeds, and Angela there with Mammoth Rocks. We have Kama Newbury there with Mammoth, and Don Perute with Mammoth Lakes Arts Center. Which would be Sierra Classic Theater.

2:01:31 That group, you know, any dramatic performances represented? John from the Forest Service, Sean and Joyce Turner, and then of course Sean represents Recreation Commission, and I represent Planning. Kathleen, Mike Hoover. Yeah. So it's basically the core of the summer events that happened. Like yesterday, we had a discussion about

2:01:54 With the funding switching over to MLT for marketing and if there was, you know, additional funding from council, how do you, how does an event organizer go forward for that money? Well, they need to demonstrate what they bring in TOT, what benefit do they bring to town? And, you know, we talked about Telluride, Park City does it to where it's...

2:02:15 A formula based basically like incentive zoning, but it's based on what does your event do for investment in the town and future investment strategy. So, you know, we brought up that perhaps these event organizers can be together and come up with a standardized form that they use that answers everything, that it makes it empirical for when they go to the council, they can say, this is what we bring to town. This is the benefit. This is the help we need.

2:02:42 Okay. And they can use the same thing as I brought up yesterday. They can use that for Mammoth Mountain because there is a disconnect still going on with events between what Mammoth Mountain and the other event organizers, the use of mountain facilities, the future, and we need to bring that together. That's kind of my goal, I think, after yesterday's meeting that we really need to bring that together because that is the future. It's how it's going to really work. Oh, that's good. I think if you're looking for funding, you have to do it pro forma. Exactly.

2:03:11 What is this going to add? How are we going to recoup this investment? Or is it purely a philanthropic offering? Which there's nothing wrong with that. But having those expectations that it's going to be something else.

2:03:28 That's where we get in trouble. And is it really worth the investment? And can we build on that? And, you know, for years we tried to do what John is bringing before was to take those funds, those limited funds, and take them away from operation of these events into marketing these events. And if you're making this as the marketing entity, anyone that has the ability to market on their own.

2:03:54 Will only enhance it, but where is the place that you look for all of this? It is in this one spot, because big organizations that have more funding, if you're looking at what Sean does, they will be marketing on their own, but then they want to also cross over to where everyone else will see them. A fledgling may not be able to do that, and to bring all of these together is much stronger than everybody trying to do it individually, because it just doesn't work. And John brought up, you know.

2:04:23 Following on that, like John Broderick, when he first moved to town, he went and he started picking up brochures on Sierra Summer Festival, Jazz Jubilee, Village Fest, Mammoth Rocks. So he has all these different brochures where it all could be down to one. One piece of collateral material that tells you everything so the visitor knows when they pick it up from A to Z what's happening in our season.

2:04:47 So the other thing that John's done, like I know for Village Fest since I'm involved with that, he was out there from the time we started on Saturday until the ending it, went to 11 o'clock, but 11 o'clock, and he was talking to people about where they came from, how they heard about the event, and he's committed to do that for all the events this summer too, so that assists the event organizer in knowing who their market really is. Is it our second homeowner? Is it people coming just for that event? Is it because they're here that they know about the event?

2:05:16 So they're not doing surveys of audiences. It's not just him going around and talking to people. It's him talking to people at the event. But some have organized surveys and some don't because operationally those are huge things. But maybe that's what you can take off the operational people's plate. Because you can give a great party, but if you don't, nobody knows it. It's a party for just the...

2:05:43 Just the host. And that's what we want to avoid because it takes more hosts to put this on. There's no attendees left that aren't working it. And that's the hard part. And that's where growth is. So when it comes back to answering that question, does it increase visitation, that's what you really have to hold it up to. Or are we getting more participants, more people to pull this off?

2:06:11 But nobody, there's nobody left to come and see it. Those are the hard things, and that's what most events suffer from, and you know, why they end up failing because they get so big in operations, but they can't expand their market. But those are very important things when you're looking at performance venues. Oh, absolutely. Good, I'm glad that meeting is going well. Anything else, Mark? Okay, no future meetings.

2:06:40 Now's the time for public comment once again. I'll open it up. No one's seen, no one here. Close it. And we will adjourn. Well, actually, are we adjourning to the regular meeting or to the workshop? We're just adjourning to our regular meeting. We have the workshop, though. Yes. Okay. All right. Thank you all very much. Thanks for putting up with my coffee.