TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2018

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 2 hr 45 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

367 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:09 We're waiting for Tom, I apologize.

0:47 Very important business to discuss this. Turn on our lights. I'll call to order the Mammoth Lake Housing Board of Directors, Monday, July 2nd. Roll call. Patricia, do you want to go around and, or just, everybody is present. Tom Hodges called and said that he would be slightly, slightly late.

1:24 We'll move to the workshop. Jennifer, do you want to open this? And then I need to make a couple of comments. Sure, thank you. So as you may recall from our meeting on June 11th, there was a consensus amongst the board members for a workshop on the community housing action plan.

1:51 And we discussed, that's a pretty broad topic, so we discussed looking at the near-term strategies. As part of that, since the Community Housing Action Plan lives with the town, town coordinated with the town, or staff, MLH staff coordinated with town staff for a report, so we just weren't going into this without understanding where the town was.

2:19 On implementing the community housing action plan. So there's a report included in here as well as the 14, okay great, the 14 near term strategies. A couple of the things that we wanted to make sure to provide that weren't included in your packet were actually the 14 items just not in the format that they were presented but just in a summary table from the action plan.

2:48 Which Patricia's handing out now, as well as the timeline, which you'll see, for implementing the strategies. That timeline is for all of the strategies. I think there's 26 of them, but the 14 are included in that timeline. So, we have here Appendix C, which is really more of a detail of what

3:13 The consultants and the housing working group and the public put together as far as the 14 near-term strategies and what that looked like. What was the action? What were the issues? So there's a little bit more detail than just the title and who leads and who supports. So I thought that was worthwhile sometimes.

3:35 It's good to kind of see what does that mean in detail. So that's included here. As I noted in my cover sheet, I put them in priority rank. The group, the public, the consultants, the plan includes a priority rank as well. And so they're in that order, the 14 items that you have.

4:00 I think this is an opportunity for the board to talk about the strategies. Obviously, these are going to relate back to our contract, which is on the agenda tonight with the town, but the board hasn't had the pleasure to talk about the strategies, and we adopted, the board adopted the foundational structure, if you remember, in February of this year.

4:26 And the two key items for MLH within the foundational structure were to expand our board and to work on the contract. And the one we've done, we've expanded our board and the contract is in process. So this is an opportunity to go above and beyond just the foundational structure but to look at the strategies.

4:53 I think the community is eager for some housing and these strategies should get us there as a community. This is a community housing action plan. So with that, I'll turn it over to the president. Well, before we go too far into this,

5:10 I want to make an announcement and name of transparency is that I'm going to obviously I can't put something on the agenda because I have not been sworn in as a town council person but as soon as I am sworn in or I will ask the town manager who can also put something on the town council agenda but a workshop for this group.

5:34 And the town, and the town. So, especially the town council. And to provide this kind of information, as well as the housing action plan, a discussion about that. And obviously, Chodo has come up. And if you remember this document, the current, you know, the cost.

5:53 If you look at all of our different documents that we have out there, there's different costs to them. And I have looked at what you have provided the Planning Commission as to your workload. And, you know, it was a very clear presentation or at least an outline, a chart of that.

6:18 Which was quite, I was shocking, the number of things that you don't have the staff to be able to address.

6:26 At least that's what it indicated in there. So there's a lot of different documents and a lot of discussion I think that needs to take place as to priorities, as to budgets, as to staffing ability to get some of this stuff done. And so I will be asking first the town manager and then I will take the initiative to

6:52 At least discuss with the council the idea of having, we haven't had one in several years by the way, a joint meeting with the town council where some of these issues can be discussed and laid on the table so that both sides seem to understand and hopefully embrace a direction. Any questions of me? Well yeah, I just want to make clear that

7:23 The Community Housing Action Plan is a plan that was adopted, accepted by the Town Council, and I think, for all intents and purposes, this is the document that the town is using to move forward for community housing. And you may reference, I'd be interested to see what this thing looks like, but I mean, as a candidate, I ran on three action plans. This was one of them, and the voters certainly...

7:46 Supported that, and so I look forward to understanding exactly who's going to organize that workshop, how that's going to be presented, and how that's going to be consistent. Well, obviously, I work with the town manager. You always do. So creating an agenda, but also Jennifer will work with the town manager setting up the agenda. The agenda is driven by the different action plans, the housing action plan and everything else. You have budget issues, you have priority issues, and you have staffing issues.

8:14 And a lot of those are addressed in the Community Housing Action Plan. So I'm hoping, I'm just hoping that the conversation, we're not going to start, you know, kind of riffing all this stuff. This is a very specific focused effort. I hope we can stay focused on it. John, it says that, you know, this will be funded. So the town manager needs to say, yes, that is going to be funded or not. Is there going to be staff time available to do these things?

8:39 We'll have that conversation, hopefully, and you can certainly talk to the town manager and help shape the, but I still believe that we need to have, we have not had a meeting between the town council and this board. It's a new board, and we need to lay out some of the issues that have come up since the last meeting. Okay.

9:05 If we move to the outline, if you looked at it closely, it gets a little confusing when you look at it in your binder, by the way. The near-term housing action strategies, does anybody want to make any comments about that particular item? Which item are you referring to?

9:29 Pardon? Which item are you referring to? I'm talking about near term, the very first one in the packet. Okay. The near term housing strategy in place by the end of 2020. Okay. So I had a chance to meet with staff this morning just to clarify a couple things. It's a little confusing to me reading through the packet to make sure I knew what was going on here. So the first thing is that the 14 near term strategies

9:54 Which is not including the original packet, just for all members of the board to understand, it's these 14 listed right here, right? There's 14 items right there, right? These guys. So that's what this is referring to, is those 14 items. Referencing, yes, yes. And it's... Right, but I think it's important to understand the issue of prioritization because...

10:17 The housing working group, which we're all kind of a part of, had some discussion about prioritization, how things would be prioritized. And if you look at the housing action plan itself, it's more properly reflected in this thing, which is on the back of this, which is not just the priorities, but the sequencing that goes with it also. So the way that these things are presented in the agenda packet, it's a little confusing that

10:41 The things that are in the agenda packet are in a certain kind of prioritized order, because I don't think they necessarily are, or I'd like staff to explain how if this is in some kind of prioritized order, I'm having a hard time reconciling the order of the items that are in here with what's in the action plan itself. These documents that were shared with you came from Appendix C of the action plan.

11:07 And if you'll see at the top on the first page, actually page two of your packet, there's a priority rank in the corner, in the upper right-hand corner. So short-term rental was priority number one. That's why it's got the most votes. That was a process done through the action plan. This is not something I created or MLH created. This is part of the action plan. Right. But it's a little confusing because if you look in the plan itself, if you read the plan from the beginning,

11:39 It doesn't, I couldn't find any reference of this priority ranking. And I remember it being as part of the housing action, but I may be wrong that the group did some priority ranking, but then it was sort of maybe that's not exactly the way it wanted to be presented. And what's in the plan itself is in probably this list here. I mean, this is more, it's sequential. I think they all cross over. I don't think you can pull one out and be like, oh, this is superior to this. They all interrelate and talk to one another.

12:07 Okay. Well, I just want to make sure from the board's perspective, it's kind of clear the way that the, as the council's engaged with this, we haven't, the council hasn't voted to prioritize, you know, we've done some things, it's in the second part of the report, some actions that we've taken, but in terms of really establishing a set of priorities and sequencing for how things are going to proceed. These are the near-term items, and they are, were prioritized in Appendix C through the process.

12:32 And they're presented 14 items in the priority rank that was in Expendix C of the accepted plan by the Town Council. Okay. I just want to make sure that there's not a sense that the Town Council has gone back to prioritize these things as well. No, I think we all recognize the Town Council has not done any prioritization. The only time the Town Council has talked about the action plan was in December when they accepted it. No, that's not true. We've talked about it a lot since then. And the Council has taken very specific actions.

12:59 Purchasing Shady Rast, doing a number of other things, which is a news report, so we can talk about it until we go through, but I'm a little concerned about it. The windows are in there. I understand, but a little bit of a sense of a parallel. I don't want to be thinking in terms of parallel processes, hopefully, as we go through this.

13:13 I think that the sense of the priority was that the community and the housing working group voted for these items. If you read through the appendix C, you'll see that that's really what drove the ranking was the community's participation and buy-in on these items and the housing working group's buy-in on them. And then we did the sticky dots.

13:32 So maybe the way to think about the ranking is that there's a lot of community support for these items. And so the number one item, short-term rental, and I think we could all agree from just our conversations in the community, there's a lot of energy around addressing this issue. Right, so just to clarify, so specifically the priority rankings came out of, for instance, the open house they did at the brewery. I believe so. Yeah, yeah.

13:59 I didn't do this. This is part of the consultant's work. But just to give an example, when we talk about community participation. Yeah, I think that actually it was the Sticky Dot event that happened here. And I think that the feedback from that open house solidified.

14:20 What they heard through the sticky dot. I think if they saw something drastically different, like there was community input during the open house that varied, this is my recollection, then they would go back and check that and be like, oh, why are we hearing something different here than we heard here? But there was consistency. Questions of Jennifer? My approach to this was a little different, partly because I might be wearing a new hat here very quickly.

14:51 So when I went through it, I underlined all the different parts that takes funding, which means that the council has to make that decision, and staff time. And so I've looked at Sandra's outline of available staff.

15:10 And so if you look just even at the first page on that first one, include providing rent guarantees and property management. That's staff time, that is money. If you look down below, again, Housing Authority manage the units, that's staff time.

15:27 Or we hire a consultant to do it. Or we hire our current individual that is taking care of our units. Family and Intercultural Resource Center, again. And then it talks about Summit Foundation's specific initiative grants to finance the program. Cost is about $2,500 a unit a year so far. So when I went through and read each one of these different sections,

15:55 I looked at the cost and the staff time because I think that needs to be presented when we look at prioritization, you know, to the council. Otherwise, you know, it's great to look at these issues here but there's funding and there's staff that needs to be put behind it or it's not going to happen. Yes, there's the priority and it's great to look at the language here but the reality is there needs to be

16:25 You know, funding, and there needs to be staff time to make these things work. That's what has to be presented to town council. That's why I would like to see the town council and Mammoth Lake Housing and certainly the town manager come together and look at, okay, here's the priorities, but here's the cost. Here's the staff time. So as I read through each of these, I identified what I considered, you know,

16:54 Funding and staff issues, as well as the priority issues. The short-term rentals, you know, I mean, that's a focus issue that needs to be a lot of interest brought to, but if we're going to use that as the number one priority, then we need to have a discussion with the Town Council about budgeting. So I'm opening it to discussion from the rest of the board.

17:24 So are we intending to go through these sort of systematically one by one? No, it's up to the board how you want to do it. I went through each one and we can jump around or we could look at priorities ourselves as to what do we think. If you look at the topics, you go from near-term housing strategies and then you move to

17:52 future land acquisition. I applaud the Town Council for their purchase of Shady Rest. And, you know, so if you begin to go through these, but if you're looking at, again, you know, Shady Rest is one piece of property. And if you look at the language in here, they're looking at

18:12 You know, other pieces of property that might or might not be available. The third item is, you know, homebuyer's assistance, something that Mammoth Lake Housing does now and has been very successful at. So I don't know how you want to move, if we can move through them one at a time? Well, that's what I thought we would. I thought we'd kind of go through it. I think Jennifer's point is they're more or less fall in the party ranking that was in the...

18:41 Housing Action Plan itself. But to be clear, what Jennifer, these are prioritized by sticky dot exercise. It was done by, I mean, that's what the prioritization is here. That's worth what that's worth, but it's not. Well, I think that this is a community housing action plan, and I recognize that the town owns this document, but.

19:02 What makes this document so special is the fact that it was a community process. And to just brush that aside because it was a... No, no. I'm not discounting that at all. I just want to make it clear that we talk about priorities to understand the level of prioritization that went into it. Public engagement, there's a sticky dot exercise. Beyond that, it has been prioritized.

19:23 Yeah, it was public engagement, which was great. Sure. Yeah, it's extensive. I mean, it was a nightmare. I think, you know, again, I think to John's point, I think this is a critical summary document for all of us to have wrapped around because it was sort of a first pass of who would be sort of the lead and who would be support role for these different items and that this certainly then plays in eventually to finalizing the contract with the town for Mammoth Lakes Housing, right? Yes.

19:53 There could be staff added to Mammoth Lakes Housing that would take on this program and be able to implement it. But there would need to be an estimate of what that effort would involve and how many man hours it would take in addition to all the other things that are on the list to figure out to do. So anyway, I'm not presupposing any outcomes to this, but I think it's a healthy discussion. There was a workshop and we wanted to just kind of go through these things and talk through them. I think the other thing I would suggest in some of these,

20:22 Is that, you know, we should consider a pilot program in some cases on some of these things and just say, hey, let's test the waters. It's not like, you know, I can just see us getting ourselves bound up and, oh my God, that's, you know, we don't have, you know, two full-time employees, we can't figure this out and we never get started on it versus let's identify some available funds and

20:49 In the case of short-term rentals, I mean, I'll jump right in. It's just, hey, can we, you know, we've got a really good example in Summit County that they've had success implementing a program like this, and we could use them as a model, and let's find a little bit of money, and let's not get too overzealous on our initial goals, but, you know, could we find five units to convert, you know, and that's just, and then we'll learn some things, right? We'll learn how.

21:17 How does that work with these people? What's going to take it to get them to the table to convert from a short-term to a long-term rental? Just the mechanics of what it's going to take to do that and manage it and understand, and then that will inform us in a larger reach and larger program, maybe down the road. But I think in all the workshops I've attended, I think there's a pretty broad recognition that there's a lot of unoccupied units in town that are either

21:47 Used very infrequently by out-of-town owners, or they've been converted to Airbnb units, which I think you guys did a great job in recapping some of these statistics in here, which were astounding when you really looked at the numbers. It was amazing how many units have converted to Airbnb in the last few years. And so what would it take to get somebody at the table to consider a long-term rental, right? I just want to point out, if you look at the master sheet, if you will, with the 14 items on it, and you look at that,

22:17 Relation to page five of the handout in the packet. Matching roomies to second homeowners and amnesty for non-permitted short-term rentals. Those two are the short-term items that are called out in the near term. So there's other short-term rental items, but specifically

22:42 It's short-term to long-term incentive roommate match and short-term to long-term incentive amnesty. Those are the two program areas, if you will, that are in the near term. It's just so that we're staying focused on the near-term strategies. There you go. I just... Right. I think the other thing to point out about that is the assignment of who... And again, I'm a little... Because this was...

23:07 Appendix C was done before the final assignment of roles and responsibilities, I think, was done. So there's assignments in here about who and when. And I don't know if those are consistent with what's in the final plan. But I think, to your point, Tom, I think it's critically important that this be a coordinated effort. And that...

23:24 It's identified who are the lead agencies and who's going to be doing what and how everybody has to work together to make things happen. Mr. Tam, if I could just one thing. There's a really aggressive, throbbing, rumbling thing that's going on underneath this side of the table, and it's kind of distracting. I'll try to deal with it, but at some point we may have to reconfigure the tables because it's really distracting. Wait a minute. There's a feedback loop?

23:51 No, no, no. There's like air conditioner running that's rumbling the floor a little bit. Oh, okay. Okay, I've got, I unplugged the TV. No, no. Okay. Just trying to find a place where it's not so distracting. It's kind of nausea, actually. Do you want to, or does somebody want to move this table over to there? Or can we come out here? Well, it's going to be, it's not going to be good for you, so. I don't find it annoying. I'm okay for it, but if I'm moving around, that's what I'm doing. Okay. You want to scooch down this way? I'm okay, but, yeah.

24:20 Yeah, I can. Okay, how does the group want to proceed? I mean, everything you said, I think this is, you're absolutely right, Tom. I mean, this is something that we need to explore. It takes budget and it takes staffing. And so, you know, that again lands in the town council in their, you know, they have the budget and they don't have the staff.

24:49 If you looked at, if you looked at. Nobody has a staff. Yeah. Right? Yeah. We know that. To John's point with that is one of the things I wondered if we could discuss is who, or find the answer to who is the champion for each of these. You know, we know that people are in here, but then like the chamber is no longer on this one. So when it's a little bit in flux, is.

25:13 Is somebody willing to step up, sort of? Why is the chamber no longer on this? Because they have said they did not want to be, that they didn't have the capacity to be involved. But I think in terms of capacity, I don't think we should be discounting people just because they may or may not have a capacity. I think let's leave it here for the moment and then let's not make any assumptions. My concern then is they've vocally said they don't want, they can't do it.

25:40 So how does it get done? Because I'm with you. At this point, we have a really exciting plan, and I'm looking to the next step of sort of, we have this, there's people's names on it. How then are they sort of held accountable to taking the next steps? How are they, if it's Mammoth Lakes Housing, I sure hope that it comes up on our board meetings, and we're talking about these things regularly, like, hey, these are our tasks. But I'm not sure if it's outside of our realm.

26:06 How we move it forward. Sure. And I guess my thought would be, you know, if it is the chamber, do we re-approach them then if we don't want to take them off the table? And how do we do that? Because I'm with you. I think let's try some things and see what works. And, you know, certainly there are roadblocks and money time staff, but let's try to come up with a little something that we can do and get a little win and say, hey, that worked great. Let's expand. I mean, you know, matching roommates, the second homeowners, I mean, it's

26:35 There's definitely, you know, there's time involved there, but a lot of it is sort of a database management process, and I just think back to when I was in college, and you go to the one board, and it's like, I'm looking for a room, where is it, and that's what you do, right? So it wasn't super complicated.

26:50 I looked at it as like older people who might live in town who might need a sort of property manager who lives on site. So suddenly, you know, you work that out with a roommate and you've gone, hey, perfect, this person can live maybe even cheap or rent free, but they'll do their shoveling. They'll shovel for you or they'll do things. I mean, I think it's exciting. You could help people in various ways, maybe outside of what we might see. Right. So, yeah, I mean, that one is, it seems like it could just be a bit of...

27:18 PR work and some outreach. Just, I don't know. I don't know. I know we've tried some things in the past like postcards and ads in the paper, but you've got to start somewhere. Yeah, I thought about even some kind of little social event. Talk to a condo complex who has a common area and you could say, hey, we're going to do this thing and come and chat with us and I don't know. But yeah, getting the word out there. Right. How does, let me ask you quick.

27:48 How does the Mountain do it, Tom, through their housing and they match? Do you know? Well, we have a staff accommodations department with an office and they basically just keep track of who's got availability and when somebody comes in, they match them up. I mean, you know, obviously mostly with our units that we have. And in some cases, if people say, hey, you know, I've got an extra room, you know, I can accommodate a ski instructor for the season kind of thing. And how many people are in that department?

28:18 In our staff accommodations? The ministerial, there's like three folks, and then there's a staff of housekeepers. And there's always someone on site, right? Who lives on site? Yeah, generally we'll have a manager in each of the individual properties that at least can contact our ministerial folks. But, yeah, so, I mean, I think these are great ideas. These two in particular, matching roommates.

28:50 I think just have to try to figure out what's the best way to start taking a stab at it. I mean, it seems like it's, you know, again, just sort of balancing the staff hours, whether it's MLH. I mean, it seems to me like this could live in MLH. And then amnesty for non-permitted short-term rentals, I mean, that's really an enforcement.

29:15 opportunity or option that the town would have to administer for people who get caught not paying their taxes, if I understand that correctly, right? It's just saying, hey, if you're, you know, there's a number of these cases come up in front of the council on a routine basis and you say, okay, we'll give you amnesty and excuse your penalties if you agree to go to a long-term rental. Yeah. Right? Right. That's the premise. Yeah.

29:42 So that really seems like not a lot of effort there because you've got somebody who's violated and you give them an option and they can say, okay, I'll do it. Well, with host compliance now, there's more of these coming to the forefront, I believe, with that enforcement mechanism. Right. So that would really be a policy decision for council to have to decide on.

30:06 And then the other part of it would be the short-term rental conversion is, you know, the rent subsidy kind of thing, and that's a lot bigger program, but, you know, I would recommend that we try to figure out a way to implement a pilot program on that, that, again, maybe earmark, you know, if they said, the Summit County said about $2,500 in subsidy a year per unit, is that what it is? Is that what, I'm reading that correctly? Are there grants that do, like, rent subsidies for affordable housing? Have you seen any?

30:34 There's tenant-based rental assistance programs, yeah. Oh, okay. And through those grants, it would be like if you were to apply for it, you would get the funds and then you would be able to administer those monthly, is that? Mm-hmm. It's really laborious, but yes, I know Tuolumne County offers them. Mm-hmm. Yeah, I mean, again, in terms of getting some bang for the buck in the near term, it seems like that's a good program because it's going to take us a while to deliver

31:05 Stick some bricks, you know, on the parcel that's several years away. In the meantime, if there's an opportunity to get some of these existing units converted back to long-term rental, that's a win for everybody. So those, that program, the property management program, I think is what you're talking about. Right. It's scheduled for 2020, the mid-year 2020. Okay. According to the timeline. I got you.

31:34 I'm just trying to stay focused on. So then I sort of come back to, because I looked at as well, what were sort of policy-based strategies that were free, not needing maybe, you know, certainly still taking staff time, but not needing hard cash. And so I guess, and maybe to John and Kirk as our council people on here.

32:00 How does that, and maybe it's what you were talking about, Kirk, but how does this question of, say, the amnesty for non-permitted units, how does that come before council for a discussion? Well, there's two, I believe, Tom, taking your

32:19 arguments right there and saying, okay, if we want to have a joint meeting with Town Council and bring some of these things forward that we think that we need to do, and where does the funding come from? Well, the Town Council just adopted a budget, but in that budget, there's about 4 million of excess TOT that has not been discussed yet.

32:42 So there is the potential to request some of those TOT dollars, excess TOT dollars. Actually, it's probably going to be about five. They budgeted 13.5 million, and it looks like about 17.5 million is going to come in. So there's a four million dollars that the council has not discussed as to where those dollars might go.

33:08 That's one of the reasons I want to argue or I'm pushing for the idea of meeting. Then taking your comments that you just made and saying, hey, let's try 10. Let's see if we can get 10. 10 would be $25,000. And for this program.

33:29 And see if that worked. Do we have the staff time? Do we have all of those things need to be brought forward in some sort of organized fashion so that the town council can say, do we have the budget? Do we have the staff time? And staff needs to engage in this too. Again, I go back to what was presented to the Economic and Planning Commission as to Sandra's work program. And I look at it and I say,

33:58 If we're going to try some of these things and it's going to impact her, what's those impacts going to be on her current work schedule? So there's a lot of moving parts to this. Should we move on to the next item? Yeah, we got 20 minutes. We got started late and yeah. Okay, so future land acquisition and development.

34:21 So a lot of this has been, well, I say a lot, there's two components in this in the near term. One is the acquisition of Shady Rest, and the second is MMSA Lodestar. And so with having Tom on the board, maybe he can speak to this one a bit. This had MMSA as the lead. I thought we could talk about that since we do talk about Shady Rest quite consistently at the board level, and we know that that's moving forward.

34:53 No pressure. No pressure. So, I mean, just to educate everybody, there's a property that mountain owns over on Lodestar Drive, which is sort of approximately the golf course there around the second hole. And we acquired it in early 2004, something like that. There's currently eight units there that were developed.

35:20 Two-bedroom and two-bedroom loft, four two-bedroom loft, four two-bedroom units with understructure parking. And then there was an understructure parking garage or partially subterranean garage that was already constructed for an additional 16 units that has never been constructed. So presently, we house long-term sort of mid-management employees in those units to just

35:49 Provide for that niche in our employment template, employee template. And yeah, presently there's nothing in the capital for that, but it's certainly something I can bring to Altera and have discussions about that. The peculiarity of that site is it is in the resort zone.

36:17 So there's other ways it could be approached, in my view. And, you know, it could potentially, the whole property could be developed as a resort property. And then maybe there's a way to flip, you know, proceeds from sale as resort property that could be used towards development of housing on the parcel, for example. I mean, there's other ways you could look at it.

36:47 But yeah, I mean, it's something I can certainly bring to the table. We also have an acre adjacent to the parcel on Arrowhead Drive that is also, we actually have put that in our requested plan to Altera to develop that site, possibly as tiny homes. That site is multifamily or residential multifamily too.

37:17 site, RMF2, so it allows for 12 units per acre, and I think the tiny homes would... I think you can get double density. Yeah, I think you, well, I think depending on the size of a tiny home, would be a half a unit, so potentially you could put about 24 units on there, when we looked at it with Darren Dinsmore, and so that's kind of what we put together as a nexus of a proposal to Altera, to consider that as a potential employee housing development site, which I think in terms of

37:47 In our near term, I think, might make more sense initially here for us to invest in that site. The other option there is that that site, I think, in the past, we've Mammoth, speaking for Mammoth Mountain Skier, have said that that could play into the larger look at the overall parcel site, Shady Rest Parcel site, of inclusion into that and development into that site, you know, add another acre to the 25.

38:16 If it makes sense, it might be an opportunity for a road circulation to enter in from there. Anyway, but still develop the site for housing. Is the foundation still good? Is that foundation still viable? Yeah, as far as I know, we had it evaluated. It's been five, six years ago by a structural engineer that it was still okay at that time.

38:44 Are you speaking about the one on Loadstar? On Loadstar, yeah. Yeah. That foundation now is 20 plus years old. It is. And I actually have lived in those places and they're very large. But Tom, my question to you, there's a big cement slab right next to it. Is that, at one time they were putting golf courts and parking them underneath that slab. Is that also something that...

39:08 That is the, that's the piece. That's the, that's the 16 additional units that would be developed on top of that. Oh, okay. Yeah, that's actually a garage underneath there, yeah. Okay. Yeah. Questions on this? You know, I guess the other question I have is, you know, I'll throw it out there, not to be controversial, but, you know, what about, what about the bell-shaped parcel? Why aren't we talking about the bell-shaped parcel? And I know it's been, you know, it's,

39:39 Acquired, condemned, or by the town, whatever, and converted to open space, but I don't understand why we have 20 acres of open space in the middle of our limited footprint of our community, and we're surrounded by millions of acres of national forest, and quite frankly, I think it's a prime site. It was always resort zone before that. It was always earmarked for development, and in my view, that site is an ideal site for the missing middle housing development for purchase.

40:09 type housing product for our workforce. So I'll just say that from the, it's not, you could probably speak to how that was addressed in the committee housing action plan, but it's not a recommendation of this plan. And I think we've done a really good thorough community vetting. We've got plenty of things to do with this.

40:24 If someone wants to bring this up as a tangential discussion, fine, but I think it's probably better to stay focused. Just to clarify, I'm not 100% certain that it's not in the plan. I think it might be like a Tier 3 site, which you'll see on the timeline is much further out, but I'm not 100% sure. I don't have the whole plan. I'm really focused tonight. I'm just searching through it right here. Okay, you don't see it. Okay, fair enough. So I think it was a little too controversial for the group to even attack. Yeah, I mean, you know, and that's the other thing. I think we all recognize that.

40:54 As you look at the schedule of tasks, you know, the reality is if we can be successful at a few to start and start picking away, and that was, we wanted to say everything wants to be at the beginning, but there's just no way to achieve it, right? So we do have to be strategic about implementing what we pick. The plan, or the process included adequately zoned sites for housing, not any site that we just wanted. I would also just, for the board,

41:22 If you go into the community action plan itself, there's some really good maps. They're not in the council, sorry, in our board packet, but if you look in the actual plan itself, there's some really good maps. Right. So just to give you a little background, some folks around it wanted an open space, and so the council ceded to their request and made it open space. It was not a

41:52 It was not a 5-0 vote. It was a 3-2 vote to do that. It's 17 actual acres, and then you've got that little wetland through there. Depending on which survey you look at, I mean, you lose three acres to two acres. In regards to...

42:13 You know, bringing that forward at a council level, the question is that, you know, the impact on the surrounding neighborhoods. If you put resort back on top of that and you sold that property, then you would have dollars that could be transferred to something else. Private developers have looked at that piece of property and drooled on it. For years now. And, you know, it's in the middle of town. Yeah, we get deer on it.

42:38 And we did a bear once in a while. But, you know, it is still located in the middle of town. So there's a discussion at a council level that needs to take place on that. Further discussion on future land acquisition for development? To me, this is a lower priority. This has been done. We have the parcel. Let's focus on that. Yes. Right. Good point. Okay. Homebuyer assistant, Jennifer.

43:09 Sure. So this and renter assistance were ranked item three out of the 14 strategies for near term. It's both the community program and the employer program that are identified on the list of 14 items of near term strategies.

43:36 The action calls for MLH to administer in the town to fund a program for people over households earning over 80% AMI up to 200% AMI. And similar to what I think Tom and I have been saying and others I'm sure, you know,

43:56 250,000. Let's just start with a little pot. Let's just do a little pilot project and see how it goes. It talks about locating the draft guidelines MLH put together several years ago. Let's take a look at those. Let's do some outreach and get going on a small program. There was a lot of interest in this program. And then the employer program is...

44:16 Really trying to garner public-private partnerships and encouraging employers to continue to offer programs similar to the Water District. I know the Mountain has a program. I think the hospital's been considering it, but I don't think they're acting on it, but they've talked about it a little bit. So that kind of project. And having MLH, the chamber, or an employer working group kind of work together on an employer model program.

44:46 So those are the two items called out as near term. Questions? Not a question, but I think this would be, you said it, Jennifer, this would be a great place for a pilot program and a great place for Mammoth Lakes Housing leadership. I mean, I guess when I approached this exercise, I thought, okay, as an organization, Mammoth Lakes Housing, looking through these and

45:12 Giving some feedback to council. I think the idea of a workshop is great. You know, not just kind of kicking it around and saying it's great to hear what everybody thinks of it, but ultimately coming to some kind of consensus of what we think as an organization are the top priorities in this already prioritized list. And I think this would be great for a pilot program. And just to piggyback off that real quick, we are a leader on here. Yeah.

45:38 And again, MLH to administer town to fund. But we would say, hey, town, fund this one. And there is $70,000 in the revolving loan fund. I believe that if I remember reading correctly. Well, that's different. That's for deed restriction retention. That's deed restriction. This is a new program. But could those dollars be moved?

46:00 Or identified for. Well, that's something we could let the town figure out. Yeah, the town needs to look at that as to if there's $70,000 there, then can we, you know, access those. I mean, you don't want to underfund another program, though, just to, like, fund a different pilot program. Because we've, I mean, last year, in the last fiscal years, we used so much of that money for deed.

46:27 So many deed restricted homes. Oh, I know. And it's really integral to our community to keep those. Well, it's the county that is supporting it. Yeah. This is tangential, but I would say there's interest on, it seems to be on the Board of Supervisors for trying to put more money into the revolving loan. Oh, perfect. Still sort of an investigation, so. And I would think that our new member of the Board of Supervisors, who, by the way, the governor appointed to the Board of Supervisors today, would agree. So, that's a future discussion.

46:58 So there needs to be some coordination between staff and the county and everything to see if we can actually access this program or implement this program. If we're able to have a workshop or if the council is just able to have a workshop, our minutes will reflect an interest maybe. I don't know if that's just, that's kind of what you were saying. Yeah, and I don't know if we'll have time to do it today, but to me what would seem to be a productive outcome of this workshop would be, here's Mammoth Lakes Housing's

47:30 Thoughts and recommendations on these priorities. And whether that's done in a future workshop with council or in some kind of formal communication to council, that's what I'd like to see us do. Further discussion on homebuyers assistant? Then we'll move to renter assistant. Comments? The renter assistants and the homebuyer assistants are, is it pretty well flushed out?

48:06 Sort of the rules and regulations of how to do it, did that happen in the action plan, so that there's still some, like even if we got money for things, there would still be some time needed to sort of put the parameters in place, or I was just thinking for the, well for like the home buyers about if they get a house for cheap, if it's not deed restricted, how does it stay?

48:34 Affordable, things like that. Those would have to be fleshed out in the guidelines, and because it's locally funded, there's flexibility in designing that program. So take a little time as well. But generally, it's said to kind of model it after what we've been doing. The community around homebuyer assistance is just expanding it above to higher incomes. Right. Okay. So you have, there's a model already. And I kind of see this renter assistance tearing into the

49:02 Eventually into the short-term rental conversion, right? I mean, isn't that, I mean, we're basically talking about some level of subsidy to convince somebody that they'll be, you know, make as much money doing a long-term rental as a short-term rental and just an observation. This was really modeled, this was to be modeled after a program that MMSA was looking at doing. Yeah. I mean, you know, like this past year where we went and rented some properties in Bishop.

49:31 It effectively was a subsidy to the employees. They paid a much lower price than what we had to pay to rent the overall properties that we had to provide a short-term need for several months during the peak of the season. It was very successful in the end of the day. But again, I think the approach of not necessarily have to get a huge

50:02 Funded program to start, but again, test the waters with a pilot program and see what the benefits will be. And again, it's just trying to take advantage of existing units in town, right? I think that's the point, and that's where our opportunities lie in the near term, in my view. This is really about the...

50:24 Discussion here was about helping get people in the door with their deposit, their first month. It can be really hard on folks that don't have the reserves to do that. You know, AMACA does offer a program for low-income people to help with their first month's rent and deposit. We at Wild Iris also do that. So there are some programs already out there. Right. Further discussion? Let me ask a question here.

50:55 With AMACA, is the public pretty aware that they can provide that service, that they provide that service? How do you guys advertise and let them know other than us? I mean, I don't work for AMACA, so I'm not necessarily sure, but I know that their funds can go pretty quickly, so I would say they're pretty well used. They're not sitting vacant. I think they're a constant referral for people struggling with housing. We tell them to contact AMACA. You guys do.

51:23 Yeah. In Mono County, behavioral, social services, we all are aware of each other's programs. Further discussion? If not, we'll move to housing mitigation regulations and inclusionary zoning. This is very controversial because developers are not happy with the whole idea of inclusionary zoning and they come out of the woodwork. Yeah.

52:02 Don't get me started. Well, I'll just point out a couple things to the board in that when inclusionary zoning was in place in Mammoth, we had one master developer in town, InterWest, that had 80% of the development property aggregated under

52:30 Under their use or their development plans. And it made it a little bit easier to implement this program because they had a lot of land to work with. So, you know, Interwest owned the whole golf course, all the properties from the golf course. They had the village, Juniper Springs area, a number of pieces of land around there, some stuff up the canyon. So, for example, they ended up

52:57 Developing the San Joaquin Villas and the Chutes were kind of the two big development units that they developed to provide for the inclusionary, satisfying the inclusionary zoning or housing requirements. The problem now today is that all that land has been, you know, was given back to the banks, it's been resold in pieces and there's not one

53:26 developer who owns a large proportion of the land, of the development land. So what that then implies is that you have to build those units in the case, say, for example, in the East Village. That guy only owns the East Village partially, he owns five acres there. You say, okay, you build it into that development. I personally think there are some issues with trying to put locals housing in these resort zones where it's largely, you know, transient type use.

53:56 And to be quite frank, these developers are gonna do the cheapest way they possibly can, and it's gonna be either in the basement with a small window to the outside. I mean, it obviously has to meet the code standards, but it's gonna be the least desirable place in the property. And anyway, I think the idea is that if you get the fee in lieu, you can better leverage that.

54:25 Whether it's town or MLH or whoever the affordable housing developer is going to be for the community to obtain grants to match against that and develop housing in better suited sites such as the parcel and what are other parcels that may become available to us in the future with also developers and or

54:53 We're developing or figuring out what to develop. One, we get to pick what we want, what we need to develop, not just them slamming in a couple of units in the back corner of their development isn't necessarily going to fulfill the right, if you look at our needs assessment, the kind of products that we need, understanding that. But then you also have, in some cases, I've had a discussion with a couple of outside developers who specialize in affordable housing development.

55:21 You know, and then all of a sudden you've got some money to offer these people to help subsidize them to go build the right products that we need in the right places. So, in any event, that's, those are just some kind of high level opinions I have about inclusionary housing. So let me summarize. This is both inclusionary and housing mitigation.

55:41 So there's two parts to it. So let me summarize Tom's inclusionary. He doesn't like it. I don't like it. I don't like it one bit. So that take, put that on the table. And the other is the housing mitigation or the housing mitigation fees. Right. And those, I think, need to be looked at again at the council level. Yeah. And I'm not talking about the developer fees. I mean, there's a balance between

56:06 The housing mitigation fee, which we need housing, and the developer fee, which impacts new development. So I think there's two discussions there. But when you look at, again, you know, if housing is a crisis, then we need to implement the full housing mitigation fee. So my only two cents on that is, you know, here we are and there still hasn't been any real development in town.

56:33 Of any significance. I mean, John Hooper's doing some homes, right? Grocery outlet. Grocery outlet. But not on the scale that we saw in the 2000s yet, right? I mean, there's no tower cranes in the sky here. That said, I mean, I think that the fee needs to respond to the market, and I think it's something the council needs to revisit from time to time and look at. I mean, it's, you know, should new development bear the full burden of providing the housing we never developed?

57:03 From all the other developers in town who build out this community. I think that's unfair, patently unfair. But so, you know, my view, too, is we want to incentivize development in this community. It's good for us in the long run. We have a master, we have a general plan that we aspire to build out the community. And, you know, we should follow the general plan.

57:29 I think to unnecessarily burden new development is going to disincentivize that work to ever happen. And so it can be short-sighted. So my only, let me finish, Kirk, I'm sorry, let me just, one last thought, because I know I'm dominating the floor here. But, you know, are we better served to, you know, my feeling is, is there a better way to obtain funding through the annuity that's created by new development in the case of creating transient bed base?

57:58 Vis-a-vis a dedicated larger proportion of TOT to go towards housing programs. And I think in the long run, that's a more sustainable flow of funds for housing because development happens and it doesn't happen. We've had a drought of development for the last 10 years. That's not generating much money to speak of, whereas TOTs only continue to grow. That would continue to develop. If we had a

58:24 You look at other communities like Aspen and so forth that are generating $4 million a year to housing through tax measures. I think that's a more productive way to create funding for housing than to try to think we're going to get all this money from developers. That's just my feelings. So you made a couple of comments, but on housing fees, the housing fees are new development. They don't go back and say, hey, we got a $230 million.

58:51 Unit housing gap. And so guess what? We want the new developer to also pick up the costs on that. No. The fees are based on, you know, what's generated by new development, not what's passed. So I think that just needs to be clear out there. In regards to new development, I mean...

59:12 We've lowered our DIF fees. We've lowered the mitigation fees. We've given away density and height and setbacks and everything else, trying to encourage new development. I mean, we really, I think we have, the council has really reached as far as they can possibly go to try to...

59:31 Incentivize somebody to pull the trigger on a big product. Don't get me wrong, I mean, the airport litigation, but more importantly, I think at this particular point in time, Airbnb and everything else is competing against some of those products that might be looking at that settling down before new development comes forward. But, I mean, this council has bent over backwards to try to get a

1:00:00 You know, some of the new, the big product come in, and it hasn't happened. Hooper's gone forward, this year we have Chuck Landy doing, I think he's done about 20 units now, and those are very popular, so those things are happening, and maybe now is the time again to look at what we're doing and what we're trying to incentivize.

1:00:27 Yeah, yeah, I don't disagree, and I think the Nexus study that was conducted at the time, or that was prepared that the council adopted the new fees to, it spoke to a lot of those issues. So, you know, again, it needs to respond to the marketplace and should be revisited. I don't think anybody said that those were all cast in stone forever. But, yeah, there's some philosophical discussions to be had there. To me, this is, I mean, I think town will be revisiting this soon. It's not on the agenda.

1:00:58 With the fees? And the housing mitigation ordinance updating. Yes. I mean, it seems to me that we should weigh in on that at that time. We're getting pretty technical. Good points are being made, but I don't think we're going to figure it out. I would anticipate the town's going to be looking at the diff fees and the housing fees. This is a new world. It's nice to hear you guys talk. I'm hearing echoes from many, many, many years ago. The town has...

1:01:23 Reconfigured its DIF program to be legal, to be appropriate. The housing fees have been recalibrated as well. I think my expectation as a council member, the town will be revisiting these fees on a regular basis to ensure that they do what they're supposed to do. So that's coming up. Sure. We are past our workshop time. What is the pleasure of the board? Do we want to work our way through these? Or at least give Ruth a chance to

1:01:53 If she has anything she wants to add to the discussion, the podium's open. I think just to be fair, I'm not sure the staff had an expectation they were going to be giving a presentation today, so I just, I would encourage members of the board to look at the documents that were provided by the town that are in the workshop packet. I think they're pretty self-explanatory. I think they speak for themselves. And I don't, I, if you want to hear something, fine, but I don't think it was the town staff's expectation that they were going to be making a presentation today. Yeah.

1:02:24 I would mind just weighing in briefly on a couple things, just looking through them real quick and throw a couple thoughts out there and then we can conclude. I don't know if we have a very lengthy agenda besides this. We have four other items we haven't gotten to, just to say. Yeah. Of the four seats. We got through ten. Is it the pleasure of the board that we'll work our way through these? Not hearing anybody in opposition, then let's move to employee assisted housing.

1:02:53 Oh, my only thought would be if we had members of the public to make public comment who maybe wanted to do that and leave. I don't know if we're able to drop and change like that. On this specifically? Just for our regular 6 o'clock meeting. Oh, it's on our agenda? This is. Public comment is on our agenda. Yeah, yeah. But if we can make that happen now. I don't know if anybody has any. So if they weren't planning on staying. You're talking about the general public comment? Yeah. Yeah, if somebody wanted to just come and speak and not.

1:03:20 You know, I don't know. At this time, I'll open the podium for anyone that wants to make comments on what the upcoming agenda, any agenda item. Well, no, they can't comment on the agenda item. No, there's how many things that aren't on the agenda. Just public comment, yeah. Yeah. Just public comment. It would happen at the beginning of our meeting. Nope. Then we'll move to employer-assisted housing. Comments? I have to find the paperwork again.

1:03:56 Page 21. Thank you. The only thing I'd point out is there's a number of things here that has, again, this was, these were done sort of midway through the process. I don't represent all the final things, but lead agencies, the chambers mentioned here repeatedly, there's different, a bunch of different organizations, just maybe keep that in mind. So as we go forward to understand who's going to be doing what kinds of roles. Wasn't this published with the...

1:04:31 The plan that was agreed? It was, and this is really, if you look at that. I just want to make, there were assignments made, but who's going to be leading things, and so nothing's locked in stone. Yeah, and that's what helps also create the community part of this, that there's implementation responsibilities spread across the community, not just the town and not just MLH. This is, again, why it's called a Community Housing Action Plan.

1:05:00 Track those things as we go through these things. And so that was really my, I mean, I spoke already about, you know, items in here that had the chamber leading them. My question, I guess, now is do we have any other groups that we can think of that MLH could approach to help with things? You know, when I think of groups in town, are there groups of employers? Like I believe there's an old Mammoth Row.

1:05:27 business group. You know, maybe that's something that we could go to them, or is there a lodging association has a lot of business owners? Is that, you know, are there other groups that could take on some of these projects? I'm not willing to give up on the chamber, just so you know. Okay. Then what's our best, and I know Ken is here, what's our best approach to revisit with them? Is it some sort of meeting with a few board members?

1:05:56 And staff, or how do we, do you have any ideas? Well, I think that my recommendation is, let's just go through these things. I didn't mean to derail it in a conversation. Let's just keep kind of going through these things and get through this. But just be mindful that as we get into this thing, implementation, that people did step up, they volunteered, they wanted to be part of things. And as we go forward, let's figure out what's good. And ultimately, I'll come back to the comments at the end of this. This is the town's plan. The town is accountable for the implementation of this. So if there are groups that are participating or there's issues,

1:06:25 There should be an expectation that the town is going to reach out to people, try to bring people to the table, try to find solutions, try to figure out ways to get everybody to the table to make this thing happen. So then my question, I guess, with that is, how do we know

1:06:39 What those plans are and a timeline for that? Or is it already? It's, well, it's, we'll, we'll get to, I mean, these are, there's a lot to talk about, but let's get through these things and we can start, there'll be plenty of time to talk about it. So, I don't know, plenty of time is already. I was going to say, I feel as though we've waited since December and there are more things that I want to see, you know, and I guess I look to that, what can Mammoth Lakes Housing do to help? Can they be the ones who reach out? Mammoth Lakes Housing want to reach out to the chamber and have a conversation with them and kind of go through these things and where the chamber said, but we want to take a lead in this.

1:07:08 Further that conversation, that would be an excellent thing to do. Or other organizations as well. I mean, I guess I would throw that out there if that's something that we want to approach. I mean, one thing that I kind of think of is what might be helpful to get people involved is if we were, since we're considered the support with the Home Buyer Program of maybe kind of coming up with like a plan of like what this could look like so that like no businesses are just saying, yeah, we'll do this without any idea of what.

1:07:35 It's going to really entail. And so if we were able to, if when we have the power, or not the power, but the time of, oh my gosh, staff time in order to do something like this, but, you know, kind of like sit there and kind of plan out like what it would look like, what it would require, so then that if the Chamber of Commerce or anybody else wanted to look and be like, oh, I'm really interested in this program to see exactly what it would look like, that would probably help move it in a direction.

1:08:05 Further discussion on the employee-assisted housing? We'll move to federal and state grant loans, CDBG, home, USDA, rural development. Taxes dedicated to housing? Taxes dedicated to housing? Page 23. Oh, I'm sorry, I'm sorry. I turned too many pages. Oh, yeah. You know, taxes dedicated to housing, I have a, just a...

1:08:33 Comment on this. I know at the time of the workshops that we were doing, the thought was, hey, could we dedicate another point of TOT to housing specifically? But I would suggest that Town Council should take a hard look at the revenues that are being generated by TOT and that maybe there's enough money currently being collected through TOT. It's just a question of allocating it specifically to housing.

1:09:03 I mean, we have this surplus we've been generating in revenues from TOT the last several years consistently. You know, from a budgeting standpoint, I think the council's been very conservative, and rightfully so, in their projections, but we've been beating it pretty darn good, as you just pointed out earlier, Kirk, that to the tune of $4 million potentially this year. And, you know, if housing's the number one priority for this community, well, then...

1:09:31 Council, it's up to you guys to dedicate more money to it. You got a big war chest there, let's start spending it. And I agree with Tom on that, a half a percent to one percent, and considering how much TOT we have, and that's kind of the point I made in the last meeting also. It would be really nice to have a little bit more money from the TOT. Yeah, I mean, you know, I think I read the book that you provided me that I still have to finish.

1:09:59 You know, that Aspen's generating, I think, $4 million a year in different tax measures for housing, right? You know, we're at, through measure A, we're only at $817,000 a year dedicated to housing. You know, we got, and I think everybody concluded through the housing workshop, it's up to our community to fund housing. We have to put some real money into it. We can't sit here and think we're always going to find grants.

1:10:27 You guys do a fantastic job. In the existence of MLH, they've acquired over $40 million in grants, but a lot of those programs have dried up on the federal level, and there's challenges there. And I think it's up to our community to put our money where our mouth is. I'll tell you two things to that. The first thing is I think there's a lot of housing is an existential crisis in the state, so I think we need to keep...

1:10:51 Close Eye and all kinds of things happening out there beyond just what we're doing locally. I think you're right, the federal environment certainly has changed. I think one thing about the council and budgeting is, I think you used the word discipline. The council's been very disciplined over the last four years about how money is allocated and how it's spent. We have a very unique and very challenging economic environment. Certainly we want to get, I'm not speaking for the council, but certainly it's an opportunity to get funds into housing. But we have to maintain.

1:11:20 Discipline, and we have to do it in a way that we make sure that the money that's being spent is going to achieve results that mean something. So just the idea of just, well, let's just get some money for housing. I think we're all got to make sure we figure out how to do this in such a way that's going to produce results. I would completely agree. And I think the council has been disciplined. But if you're looking at this particular year, 17-18,

1:11:48 $817,000 will be dedicated to housing. About $330,000 goes to the Mammoth Lake Housing contract. So that other money and the loans have been paid off. So those dollars are gone. For the airport litigation, $144,000.

1:12:10 is set aside to for the $1.8 million that they're doing. So that leaves in the excess TOT, one point of the 13 points is about $300,000. So those are the dollars that the council looks at, we'll be looking at for this particular year. And again, wait a minute, you've got shady rest at the parcel, sorry. You've got the parcel out there and

1:12:41 You know, they just, that $6.5 million, where did all those dollars come from? And do some of their, if they were, they pulled, they did pull money out of reserves, is those reserves have to be replenished. So right now, the council's got some balancing to do on their budget. Right, right. And that's a valid, absolutely valid point. I mean, that was a huge strategic purchase by the town.

1:13:10 For the community, for housing, and I think the community needs to recognize that 6.7 million, right, that's land you need for housing, so that was a significant investment by the community, by the town council, so. I think there needs to be more clarity on the 1% before anything is taken for the public. Right. As to, wait a minute, what happened to all the excess TOT over the last couple of years? What happened, you know,

1:13:39 There needs to be a better picture before, because in one of the strategic goals is that Mammoth Lake Housing is supposed to go out there and get 2% of the 13%. And without having a clear picture to be able to actually go talk to the business community and the lodging community and that sort of thing, it just isn't going to happen. I mean, there's too much opaqueness. Yeah, absolutely. I think you have to get clarity on that.

1:14:09 And certainly, you know, we don't want to overtax our guests. Yeah. And, you know, I think you just don't arbitrarily just throw another point at TOT without understanding all those metrics very clearly. Yeah. But I think that's largely going to be an initiative driven by the council. And I'll just add the Board of Supervisors is looking at something like that. Your TOT right now is a couple points below ours. So that would be, if we could jointly work together. I think it would be a good thing to partner on. Yes.

1:14:42 Raising revenue is key. So, to me, that's essential to look at. And again, I think for local revenue, again, something that can bring consistent revenue is in for housing year in, year out, regardless of the economic climate to a degree. So, you know, it's a good thing. Further discussion on tax dedicated to housing? I do have one more thing to say.

1:15:13 About the TOT, it was a really good year last year for rentals because it was such a good snow year. But we also have to think about, even though it's a half a point to 1%, what if we don't get the visitors in and we don't get the TOT? And if we have a fire or if we have a drought. So those are things to consider also. Well, I'll complement our...

1:15:39 Our sitting town council, because they've put a reserve for economic uncertainty, it's up to $3,650,000, and it looks like they are trying to fund a secondary funding reserve. So it would cover if absolutely no money came in. I mean, literally, they could go probably for four months.

1:16:07 Paying for everything if nothing came in, which is not a realistic scenario. Right. Unless the volcano went off. But a fire could also. Yeah. And four months in reality really isn't. I mean, if something like a fire or a drought continued for many years. I'm just saying that could be a scenario. We would be obviously contacting the federal government and being recognized as a disaster.

1:16:35 Further discussion on tax dedicated to housing? Hopefully I'm not skipping anything. We'll move to federal and state grants and loans. Jennifer, you want to give us a little bit on that? So this is really, the action is to continue to use state public funds, track new resources. This is a shared lead support.

1:16:59 Between town and MLH staff, depending on the project, the resources, etc. But basically continue using the funding, consider dedicated staff to work specifically on acting as an ombudsman for housing projects, so really kind of shepherding the grant application and LIHTC process between town and developers.

1:17:33 Questions? Keep going after them. I mean, it's free money. So, accessory, secondary, dwelling units. This is a promote under that. There are other things related to accessory dwelling, but this item, near-term item, is about promoting ADUs.

1:17:56 Outreach to second homeowners, website and postcard mailings, any other ideas, but really getting the word out there. This is something that I mentioned to the town council when they voted two months ago, I think maybe, a month ago, to

1:18:15 Reduce their fees for accessory dwelling units only until the end of this year, so time is of the essence to really try to get out there and promote this. I would elevate this to be a pretty high priority because I think it's kind of low-hanging fruit. Questions? I think the council needs to maintain the lower fees. Oh, go ahead.

1:18:43 Sandra Moberly, Community Economic Development Department. But the diff fees that were temporarily reduced will be codified in the upcoming diff ordinance. So that's a piece that what the council had given us direction on. We will fit into that diff ordinance and they can have a discussion about that for the discussion. So that is kind of a little bit of a separate piece kind of to the rest of the component that's discussed in that housing action plan. So just a comment. The fee will be codified for the rest of the year.

1:19:14 The fee is already codified for the rest of the year, but it will be part of the ordinance. Once that diff chapter is updated, we will eliminate the temporary fee. It will become permanent. Oh, so it's not temporary. The only reason we made it temporary is because we had to actually write the code section and we didn't have that ready. So that's what we're doing right now is drafting that actual code language. It will basically mirror...

1:19:39 At this point, mirror what the council has given us direction on and approved. There was some discussion about it, so it could be different, but ideally, that would be kind of the minimum that they would look at as part of the kind of the diff ordinance. Just to clarify. Thank you, Sandra. Further discussion? Hi, I'm Patrick Taylor from Alpine Corporation. I wanted to talk a little bit about your tax dedicated to housing.

1:20:10 Aspen has a very robust affordable housing program, and they charge 1.5% on every transaction that goes directly to housing. Every sale, that 1.5%, no matter what size it is, is dedicated to housing. That's Colorado. California doesn't allow a real estate transaction tax. So we have to look at other funding sources.

1:20:42 Okay. Was that on real estate or was that on real estate? On real estate. So each sale, a $5 million house, I mean, it brings in a lot of money for their housing program. The whole state of California doesn't allow that? That's right. The state of California will not allow us to. They were grandfathered in. So further discussion?

1:21:08 On the accessory dwelling units, I think this is a great thing, but I just don't know how to get these people with these 5,000 and 6,000 square foot houses. There's one that's going in on the bluff that's 17,000 square feet, and if they're not utilizing, I mean, first of all, I don't know how big the family is, but 17,000, you would think that they'd want a caregiver unit, I mean, or somebody at least making sure that

1:21:38 That there hasn't been any pipes that have broken or anything else. But I don't know how to reach out to these people in these 10,000 square foot houses and to get them to be realistic that we get cold snaps, we get all kinds of different things that are happening up here. And if you're not having somebody look at your house, I mean, the damage can be pretty substantial.

1:22:02 I mean, you know, my feeling on the accessory dwelling units, too, is that there's applicability to all single-family residential neighborhoods in the community, so even just modest homes have potential to have an accessory dwelling unit, and I think what might be helpful is if, you know, if maybe the town, maybe Mammoth Lakes Housing, but if somebody put together a little pro forma, if you will, to explain how a homeowner

1:22:31 Could develop an accessory dwelling unit and realize it as a good investment for their home property, right? And just sort of go through the financial side of it. I think that would be helpful for a homeowner to look at and go, oh, wow, I can do that. And these are the fees. It sort of mocks up the model for them and what the prototype is that they can follow and whether they put a unit over their garage or a unit in their backyard. Or in their garage, convert part of their garage.

1:23:00 Yeah, LA, the city of LA just did this in collaboration with UCLA and they did a pilot program and a pilot actually project where they funded an ADU to be built at a home in Highlands Park and they have a guidebook.

1:23:22 And yeah, it's LA, so their guidebook's probably a lot bigger and more robust than ours needs to be, but I think the town, the region could look at doing something like that. It talks about from, you know, like a check the box, this is how long it takes to get your permit, these are the things you're going to need, this is the cost for the permits, you know, just something that gives people a sense of how to move forward, some framework, because it seems daunting from here, right? Yeah, I mean, you know, an average homeowner has no idea how to do that.

1:23:52 And it doesn't have the time to even spend thinking about it, right? I mean, it's like, there's only so much you can do in a day, right? You know, the last thing I was thinking, how am I going to tackle this task, right? But if it's something sort of laid out the playbook, it makes it a lot easier to, as a homeowner, to go, oh, well, this could be a great, you know, passive income opportunity for me, and this is how we can, you know, implement it.

1:24:17 Somebody in the audience? Ted? I just believe that Dr. Taylor is absolutely correct and you misled him. You can absolutely have a real estate transfer tax in California. Just look it up on your phone. He was talking about an Aspen, a point and a half on any real estate transfer would go into this pot of money. So I don't know what you're talking about, but I think he's right. Jennifer, I mean, I've been under the impression for the last 15 years that we...

1:24:47 Couldn't access that. Yeah, I was under the same impression from a study that East Bay Area Economics did for the city of Sacramento that that couldn't be done. But maybe it was for charter cities. You have to be a charter city to do it. But in any case, it was not something that seemed accessible to our region. But I don't know if it was the state of California or a charter city.

1:25:16 But I'd have to go back and look. I'm not just going to Google it, but I will look at the document that a specific housing entity put together, a study for Sacramento County on this.

1:25:29 We will research that. I mean, if it's available, then certainly I want to explore it. Absolutely. But we are a general law city, and charter cities, depending on how the charter is written, they can incorporate different aspects into the basic charter, from the makeup of council, the number of council people, and everything else. So it depends on how the charter is written.

1:25:55 As to what they, they, I'm not saying, I'm just explaining that we will research it. It just seems like something that, that we, not something that we're, it is embarrassing. All right, we'll move from accessory dwelling units to zoning for affordability. Yeah, I'll provide a couple comments on this. I think that,

1:26:38 Again, so, you know, as the town, as the community, we look at what our opportunities are to develop housing, and, you know, we look at what land is available and so forth. You know, the area that we have a lot of airspace available is in the commercial districts in the downtown and Main Street and Old Mammoth Road with the, with the,

1:27:04 New commercial zoning ordinance with the floor air ratios allowed in those areas. There's a lot of airspace that could be developed, redeveloped, you know, properties could be redeveloped and take advantage of that airspace. So this is one of the things that we had in the workshop was if the town could create an affordable housing overlay in the commercial zone that would provide an incentive for developers to

1:27:31 Potentially develop workforce housing units above their commercial ground floor commercial development. And so, you know, it wouldn't take a lot of effort, in my view, to create the overlay. However, you'd have to, you know, pair that up with incentives. I mean, what would be that incentive package, right? It's not going to do any good if there's not a carrot there to dangle and say, hey,

1:27:59 We can provide these incentives for you if you would consider building workforce housing units above your ground floor retail development. There are things, for example, you could potentially look at maybe offsets with commercial parking. It might be an opportunity as a town looks at whether they're going to create district parking and develop some parking reservoirs in the downtown district.

1:28:27 So that if you did provide those housing units, you would get credit or offset. You wouldn't have to build your commercial parking on site. You could take advantage of the town constructed parking garage to fulfill your commercial parking needs. Anyway, the bottom line is the developer's only going to do it if it pencils. And it's got to be at least neutral to them on some level.

1:28:54 That's going to take a little bit of work to figure out what could be the incentives you could provide, but there truly is a lot of opportunity there, and just to figure out how to unlock that opportunity with something, you know, and the thought was to put this overlay zone on there for workforce housing, and that's tied to incentives on some level. Maybe that's in the long term, it's, you know, if we have this dedicated local tax revenue.

1:29:23 Let's say all of a sudden we're generating $4 million a year like Aspen. Well, okay, all of a sudden we're saying, well, we're putting $2 million a year towards this incentive overlay zone, and that's a pot of money that could go to fund something in the future to be, you know, incentivize a developer to redevelop a property. I would just add that the community, the downtown revitalization plan dovetails nicely with this, and there's a lot of opportunities that are very specifically detailed out in that, and I'm thinking that for this item, to be looking at that, there's a great way to bring those things together to move this stuff forward.

1:29:51 Yeah. And again, there could be, this could be another opportunity for a pilot program, you know, where you just really focus a small amount of money to get one or two little properties. I know, to John's point, in the downtown revitalization, Darren Dinsmore, he had a little prototype commercial property. In fact, they developed one up in Truckee, downtown, a three-story unit with ground floor commercial and a unit above or two units above. And so, you know, I think there's ways to start.

1:30:21 Taking a stab at this stuff, and again, just maybe bite-sized pieces to start, and maybe we can start to get some traction. Further discussion? I agree. I mean, obviously, you need to work with your panel on this. Ruth, do you have anything you want to add? You have questions? All of us. Does the board have any questions? Why don't we take a five-minute break, and then...

1:30:57 We will start on the rest of the agenda a little bit late. The Mammoth Light Housing Board is back in session. The podium is open for public comments. If there are no public comments, we will move to approval of the June 11 regular board meeting. Any corrections, deletions? If not, can I have a motion? I'll move to approve. Then moved. I'll second.

1:32:00 Moved and seconded twice. Tom seconded it. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes. Was there any abstentions? No. Agenda item 6, update and discussion of Mammoth Lake Housing, Town of Mammoth Lake draft contract. Jennifer? Yeah, thank you.

1:32:27 The board requested this item be put on. We don't have any draft to share with you. The committee's still reviewing the Mammoth Lakes Housing Ad Hoc Committee, still reviewing the document. We received it soon after our last board meeting, or shortly after, and due to scheduling and such. Our committee got together on Friday, went through the deliverables, outlined some comments and questions, and staff's going to work back through those.

1:32:56 We'll reach back to our ad hoc committee shortly. This is a short week with the holiday in there and such, but we'll hopefully get back to them this week. I would say by next week we would have responses probably from our ad hoc committee and able to schedule another meeting with the full committee, the town committee, and the Mammoth Lakes House committee to review comments and suggestions on the draft.

1:33:27 It's come to our attention that the town would like to wait to approve the contract until after the town does their strategic planning in August.

1:33:41 I think that's scheduled in August. I haven't seen a date yet, but that's kind of what we've heard. Nothing real formal. But we continue to work on it and move through it. Right now we're working on some analysis on time and cost with the deliverables. And I know that Giselle, or excuse me, Lindsay and Tom were both at our meeting on Friday. So if they have anything to add, please feel free to. Yeah. Yeah, I think what I,

1:34:13 sort of instructed Patricia and Jennifer was to look closely at what the time demands would be for the proposed activities and just have a good understanding of what that time commitment is and make sure it balances with their availability and can measure it with the level of compensation that is being proposed. Now, that said, I don't think necessarily that tails should wag the dog and that if there are

1:34:43 The activities that are appropriate for Mammoth Lakes Housing to work on and execute, you know, strategically that they're the right entity or we're the right entity to perform those, then so be it. And then I think just an understanding of what time it takes to do that. So, like, for example, a lot of these programs we're talking about, right, it's pretty easy and quick to see that, oh, my God, you need a body to start organizing this and, you know, to set it up initially and then

1:35:11 To maintain a program, that's more time. That's going to be more staff. So, you know, at one point, Mammoth Lakes Housing had, what, four staff members? Five? Five. Yeah. So, and housing's a top priority for our community. Maybe we need more staff, you know, depending on what the scope of work is. So, I think it's, you know, I just felt like there needs to be an awareness of what is.

1:35:38 What the town would like to see Mammoth Lakes Housing do and start putting some actual budgets in terms of hours to that and then equate that to what we have for staff availability, perhaps that means there needs to be staff added in the future. So we're just going to go through a little quick exercise on that and get a better handle on what that would imply. And I think, you know, it does, in my mind, I think it is all going to kind of dovetail together with the

1:36:07 If, you know, the town wants to update the strategic planning in August and so forth, I mean, that kind of makes sense to me. And then just understanding where maybe that division of roles with housing, whether, you know, there's more town staff or more staff on Mammoth Lakes Housing, you know, as a community, we're working together to further achieving the goals, right? From the podium, please. I'm just curious.

1:36:43 As to, does the Housing Authority staff work directly with the Community Development Department? We're in constant communications and we're carrying out the general plan. I'm not sure what you're, what do you mean? I'm just wondering how closely they work together. Well, closely. Grants, yes. Depending on the subject, on the matter, we work closely. On affordable housing, specifically. Yes, yes.

1:37:12 So you have an ongoing, so they're helping each other? Yes, as things arise, yes. And how about the county? Yes. I mean, there's less staff at the county, I think, that are, well, now it's probably about the same amount of staff. Yes, absolutely. Everybody's cooperating to try to help create the affordable housing? Yes. I'm just curious, because Aspen's a great model. You might really want to take a look at what they've got going, because they've got the city and the county.

1:37:43 And the Community Development Department, they're all working together in conjunction and they're getting their affordable housing done. Developers like my company, we're going in there, we're buying properties, we're building units. That doesn't take a long time. They've got their system to where it gets done. That's great. Thank you. I think to Patrick's question a little bit is just that in the past, Mammoth Lakes Housing actually functioned as a

1:38:12 Workforce housing developer for a period of time before the recession and has since, you know, pared back and has gotten away from that. And so the question is, moving forward, you know, I think it's recognized that somebody needs to develop housing units, workforce housing units, and the question is who's going to be best suited to do that, whether the town's going to take the lead on that, and or

1:38:41 Work with third party developers such as yourself to help develop the right products that the community needs. And so I think that those are the kind of the questions that we're grappling with as far as just the roles and responsibilities as it relates to the workforce housing strategy and plan. Further discussion on this agenda item? And we will move to accept the transition plan for the executive director position. Agenda item 7. Jennifer?

1:39:18 Yeah, thank you. So last month at the meeting, the board gave staff direction to move forward with appointing Patricia to be the acting director for Mammoth Lakes Housing and then to backfill that. Her position with a temporary person was the direction and then to come back with a transition plan. So what does that look like? Patricia and I have put together a transition plan.

1:39:50 To do such a thing and noting that my last day is August 5th and we've been working through Sierra Employment Service on temporary staffing, working with them, giving them plenty of heads up on what we need, what does that look like, who can fill that role and we have got an interview scheduled.

1:40:15 To look at some people that they're recruiting to do that kind of work for Mammoth Lakes Housing, in my absence, and then Patricia's elevated role, temporary elevated role. So all of those things I noticed would be pulled from the contract labor line item.

1:40:36 Because we're reducing wages out of the salary and wages line, that those funds that would normally be paid from that line item could be moved over to the contract labor. We did this when Patricia was on maternity leave. Everything we're looking at with relations to that is similar or maybe less pay, I would imagine, than what we're paying Patricia currently, since it's a temporary role.

1:41:02 With different benefits and such. It's a contract labor, not an employee. California broker's license, that's something that I currently hold for the organization. It's an important piece of the work we do, I think both now and then also looking forward. When I took over the role for Pam Hennedy,

1:41:27 Almost six years ago, I was not a broker. I was a licensed agent. And in the interim, Pam held the broker's license for Mammoth Lakes Housing. We had a contract with her to do that while I pursued my broker's license, which took, I think, about six to seven months. So I put in here that I could do that pro bono for the time being until Patricia could get that secured. And then at that point, we could transfer it over to her.

1:41:58 Working through the California Coalition for Rural Housing, just working with their board on their process. I'm not exactly sure how that would work, if that's something that they would want to just appoint. Patricia, I don't think so. They have a nominations committee and they have a process. But working through that process, we're going to be working on that. The Sherwin Plaza Three Homeowners Association. These are the things that we need to work on through our transition plan. Mammoth Lakes Housing owns the commercial condominium, which we are in.

1:42:28 I serve on the board for that, and it's a good thing, I think, to have the representation of the organization on the board. It doesn't take hardly any time at all. It runs really smoothly, but it's something that I think we just need to change some paperwork in order for that to happen, basically signing checks. Email contacts, just getting things set up to transfer emails and contacts and those kinds of

1:42:58 We've been working through some of the things that Patricia maybe would need assistance on in order for a smooth transition. By and large, we have a pretty

1:43:13 Well, we have a small office and we have a lot of shared information. And so I don't see there being gaps, but I'm certainly there and helping Patricia where I see things that might be looming. Bank signature cards is a big one. I am one of three signatories on the bank accounts for Mammoth Lakes Housing. Our policy requires two signatures. Historically, that's typically been myself.

1:43:40 And, or the EDU at the time, whoever that is, and Kirkstapp, but with me leaving, we'd need to change that, remove me, and add our acting director until a new director's brought on. So the staff recommendation is for the board to approve the transition plan.

1:43:57 With any modifications, and to approve adding Patricia as a signatory for the three account, or the four accounts, I think it is, or is it five? One, two, three, four, five, five accounts noted here. Questions of staff? It's just a direction, or do you need a, it says recommendation, do you want just a motion on this, or is this just accepted? Staff direction, approving the recommendation.

1:44:32 And I'll make a motion to improve the recommendation. I'll second. Been moved and seconded. Further discussion? Yeah, I'd like to, I had a chance to check in with staff on this today. I'm wondering if staff could come back with a document to the board that specifically details what our financial obligations for staffing are at this point, what was budgeted, what we anticipate this is going to cost in the context of a budget going forward. I don't,

1:45:04 The numbers, I don't have any problem with the numbers, but I would just think it would be helpful for the board to understand how much money do we have to work with, what Patricia's compensation is, how it fits into that, how much money we have available for temporary contractors, so just going forward we understand kind of where we're at. Just to give, I did do some research on it, Jennifer's gross salary is $117,000.

1:45:27 96 a year. Patricia's is 59,772. If Patricia does this for, takes the position temporarily for six months, it'll be 15,600 more. So her gross in six months, that would be, you know, half of her salary plus 15,600. But I think you're right. We need to look at the budget to make sure that

1:45:56 You know, that we're staying within the budget. But I did take the time to look at this. If six months does transpire before a new Executive Director comes on, it would be $15,000. But we would not be paying. We would not be paying. Sorry, General.

1:46:20 So that would be cut, that would eliminate approximately $55,000. So $15,000 gets us $55,000. Again, my request to amend the motion is not to, I didn't have any problems with the numbers, they seem to be fine with me, but for the board to understand what have we got, what are we spending, so that we need to make decisions down in this period of transition. That's an information piece. Well, I'd like to have it amended to the board.

1:46:44 Yeah. What is the fiscal impact? So my request is part of the motion to have that added to the motion so that we go forward with this, we go forward, but a document comes back to the board that lays all that out. I made the motion, but I understand what your information, how would that, providing that information change this motion? Just because I'm requesting that we add to the motion a request for the document as I've described it to be made available to the board.

1:47:15 As further staff direction. Yes, further staff direction is part of this motion. Then I'll amend my motion. And I'll second the amended motion. So the motion has been amended and seconded. Those in favor? Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Motion passes unanimously. We'll move to agenda item 8.

1:47:43 which is review and direct staff on the reserves and allocation of the physical year 17-18 support and revenue over expenditures. Thank you. So this was something that came out of our budget discussion when we were adopting the budget for 18-19 last month and these are our projected

1:48:10 Revenue and support in excess of our expenditures from this past fiscal year. Again, these are non-actual forecasted surplus support and revenue proceeds. It's just now July 2nd, so things are still coming in. We haven't had our audit yet, so I would just caution you to note that.

1:48:39 46,000 is a rough number. It could change. But there was also a request to have information on our reserve accounts. And so you'll see those here. We have three designated reserve accounts. We have an operations risk reserve account. We have a star apartment reserve account. And we have a Sierra Manor Road property reserve account.

1:49:06 So, included in some of the suggested options, of course there may be others, but staff recommends that you consider these options for allocations of the non-actual forecasted $46,000 from last year. Those include increased operating budget line item for legal counsel due to anticipated

1:49:34 Questions around our CHOTO, our Community Housing Development Organization status, and the town contract.

1:49:42 Last year, Mammoth Lakes Housing spent roughly $17,000 on legal fees. This year, to balance our budget, we have $10,000 in there. It's possible that we could need more, I think, given some of these items. That's one option. Another is deed restriction retention. Last year, Mammoth Lakes Housing spent roughly $38,000 in deed restriction retention, and we've budgeted $25,000 in our current fiscal year.

1:50:11 Depreciation is something that we always have on our books, but we have not funded any kind of a replacement reserve for our depreciable items. So that is an option to fund something, some portion of that.

1:50:31 You know, the company laptops are eight years old. They could need to be replaced in the next five years. We have an office. So that's an option. The executive director position recruitment, we've looked at several firms ranging from $28,000 to $42,000, depending on the...

1:50:51 Board's pleasure in filling that position. That could be also a resource. When we first started talking about using a firm, I was looking at these funds as a source. So something to keep in mind, there aren't additional sources available other than this at this time for a firm should the board's pleasure be to go out.

1:51:16 And then investment in Sierra Manor Road property. This property will create long-term affordability and having funds available to leverage outside funding sources and development contingencies is a sound practice. So those are my recommendations for consideration. Questions? So the funds...

1:51:52 You're looking at $46,000 that's available? Yes. Is that correct? And then you have one, two, three, four, five different opportunities to invest that money? To spend that money? At minimum? I'm just asking. I'm just trying to establish what's going on here. So, but there's no specific recommendation from staff for any, there's no critical need. These are just potential areas that the board could put money towards, correct? Critical need. I think that if I...

1:52:25 If I was to weigh in, I would say that the legal counsel fees are a big one. I think considering that you've told us that the town's going to challenge the Chodo and your legal counsel is... To be clear, the town, I have not said that the town is going to challenge the Chodo. Oh. I want to be clear about that. Okay. We'll speak about that later. But there's some legal implications of that. Right, right, exactly. Yeah, the town is not...

1:52:53 There's been no action taken by the town to consider challenging the Chodo. I'll make that clear. I'm just looking for a recommendation from staff. Is there anything in here that are the computers falling apart? Is the printer not work? Is the roof leak? Is there something that we really need to act on immediately?

1:53:08 That's going to be important for the organization. That's going to affect the operation of the organization. Yeah, and I think the legal fees are a big one. I think that, I think you have a little bit of time on the computers. I wouldn't, and I don't think you have to do 100% in any one basket. I would never advocate for that. I would advocate for splitting them in some reasonable fashion.

1:53:29 Considering that we spent $38,000 last year. Now, I don't know of any deed restrictions coming forward, but you don't know that until you have 30 days to respond. But, you know, maybe increase that by $10,000. At least get up to $35,000 on deed restriction retention. Put another $10,000 or $20,000 into your legal fund, and then that still leaves.

1:53:53 Roughly, what, $16,000, depending on what you do on the legal fund, for maybe for director recruitment. If you feel like that's the route the board's going to go, I don't know which way you're going to go with that. Maybe that's something that should have more than just $16,000, and so that's really something for the board to decide.

1:54:15 Another question. So these funds are all unrestricted, correct? That's correct. Okay. So does MLH track its funds in terms of whether it's Measure A money or whether it's coming from grants and how it's all restricted? I'm assuming that's all tracked, right? Measure A funds, if you look at our budget, they pay for our overhead, our staffing, and our benefits. Right. But the question was, does MLH, I mean, if the president want to go to staff and say, I want to know what money do we have?

1:54:45 Do we have restrict reserves? Do we have restricted funds? Yes, they are tracked. It's all tracked that way, right? Yes. So this money is coming purely out of unrestricted funds? Yes. Okay. I don't want to get into deliberations. I'll leave that to you to tell us when we can do that. I've got some thoughts. Discussion? You know, I just, your laptops, if your computer systems are eight years old, that seems awfully old to me. And a vital tool for you guys. I just, I don't want a chance. And if you guys are really...

1:55:18 The ski area puts things out of service after about five years, generally speaking, for technology stuff, so that strikes me as something that maybe we should take on. And then I certainly think the bumping up the deed restriction retentions make some, you know, that's vital to the overall success of the programs, and I think that would certainly make a lot of sense to me.

1:55:44 Don't, and it, so then on these other, like, line items where you said you were over, like, on legal, for example, I'm trying to recall on the budget work we did last, the last time, I can't remember if there was some offsetting savings elsewhere in the budget. I'm not sure I follow your question. Well, you're saying you're over on the, on the legal counsel line item, is that what you're saying? No, I'm saying that we,

1:56:10 Spent $17,000 last year, and we have budgeted $10,000, and I could see us potentially going over that this year, given some of the documents that we may need to have reviewed. Do we have some other line item savings, if I recall? Aren't there a few wins here and there? I'm just wondering in terms of the budget detail.

1:56:31 Well, there could be some, certainly, from having a temporary, you're going to have savings there from having a temp person fill in for Patricia, and me gone and Patricia taking a smaller stipend than what would be my normal salary. So you won't have, depending on how long it takes the organization to permanently fill that position.

1:56:51 There could be some cost savings there, but that's all anticipated at this point. I would throw out just an idea is to, it's great to know we have this money. I would turn to Patricia to come back to the next meeting and look at as you're reorganizing and things are moving around. I'd like to hear some recommendations for you.

1:57:08 They're specific to the board, how much you think it's going to spend, what's critical. We don't have to spend anything. We can keep it in reserves if we need it. But I'd like to, as you start looking at the organization, because you're going to be kind of managing things, to come back with the recommendations that's kind of specific as what you think we need to do. But that's just a thought. Other than that, I don't see, you know, it's a significant period of transition for the organization. I think it's nice to be able to have, you know, $45,000 on hand that's in unrestricted reserve. Who knows what you're going to need it for?

1:57:38 And I think it may be better just to park it and leave it there as an unrestricted reserve. And if things come up, if there's legal fees, if it's computers, whatever the rest of it, but I just throw that out there. Well, I agree. I mean, just leave it there until it needs to be encumbered. Okay. So my question, so if they decided they needed, you know, new computers,

1:58:03 And it comes out to like $2,500 or something to replace the technology. Would they then come and ask for the approval of the board before buying it? Is that how we would start if we're going to leave it in the reserve before allocating it right now? Jennifer, what authority do you have? I mean, the town manager has the authority to up to $50,000. So I don't know in your job description, and I glanced at it today.

1:58:30 What authority you have to use unencumbered funds. The way we've been discussing it. It's $15,000. $15,000. So she can reach in for small expenditures. Further discussion? If not, then the direction is that Patricia will come back with her observations or recommendations. Do you want to push on that? I think it's a staff direction.

1:59:02 I thought that the direction was to leave it in a reserve account, and we didn't need Patricia to come back with anything until something arises. Is that the direction? That sounds right. Okay. No further discussion on that. We'll move to Agenda Item 9. Jennifer? So I'm going to have Patricia present this. She put this together.

1:59:37 Okay, this is a staff report regarding a notice of funding availability that we received from the State Department of Housing and Community Development on June 8th. We've reviewed the notice and CHOTOs are available to apply. 15% of the funds are reserved specifically for CHOTOs to apply for projects.

2:00:05 And the application is due August 6th. So Mammoth Lakes Housing was looking at applying for the rehabilitation of the property that was acquired in October of 2017 at 238 Sierra Manor Road into potentially 12 smaller apartments. In November, Mammoth Lakes Housing, in partnership with the town, applied for CDBG funding.

2:00:35 For the conversion of this property into 10 apartments, but as of today, we still haven't heard if that award was awarded. The application allows for rental rehabilitation projects to apply for up to $5 million, and it, well I guess so, the conversion of this property would be in compliance with the needs assessment, which cited that the town is in

2:01:05 Great need of smaller apartment units priced at 80% of the area median income or below and would help move the town towards our goal of 200 to 300 units in the next five years and also is consistent with the general plan which has a vision goal of adequate and appropriate housing that residents and workers can afford and the application requires that the board of the

2:01:35 Community Housing Development Organization approve a resolution authorizing an application for up to $5 million for this project. Discussion? Well, I have some questions first. Okay. But I don't want to, does any of us have any questions? I've got some questions. Sure, go ahead. You stated that Mammoth Lakes Housing, in conjunction with the town, applied for CDB funds. Would, if we were awarded both of these funds, would there be an issue?

2:02:07 So you can only have one or the other.

2:02:41 I don't think that would be the case, but it might just change the budget of the project. And do you guys have a preliminary budget prepared for the conversion of that property? Yes, there was a preliminary budget prepared for the CDBG application for 10 units. And what was that number? It was $3.9 million. Okay. And that included all your soft costs for architectural and permits and...

2:03:15 Yes, it includes both costs. And we know all construction budgets are always under budgeted, so you're probably going to need more money. That's all I can tell you. Yeah. Okay. John, your questions? Yeah. So when is the application due? August 6th. Okay. And will the board have an opportunity to review or see the application or the budget or anything before it's submitted? Typically, the board doesn't review the application. Okay. And our meeting is on the 6th.

2:03:46 All right. Is that standard of practice? Okay. So the question, do you know, so my understanding is that the money available statewide for this application is $10 million. Is that correct? Like Chodos across the state, there's $10 million available for Chodos. That's the pool of money for us to apply to. Is that correct? Yeah, it's 15% of $74 million. Right. So that gets 10.

2:04:13 Point something million dollars. So basically we're saying that we're anticipating putting an application for up to half of the money that's available across the state. So the way you write these resolutions is you can't ask for more later. Your resolution needs to be the highest ceiling possible. We do not anticipate asking for five million. I understand. We're looking probably more at three, one to three I would say.

2:04:44 Okay. It's a formula-driven, and once we get into the application, we'll know more, but it will not be half. Okay, I'm just saying, just so, I mean, that's what's available in the state, that's what we're, through this resolution, that's what we're authorizing, so just so we're clear about that. The other question is about the budget. So the budget that was in the CDBG application, is this the, is this, are we applying essentially for the same project?

2:05:08 No, because this is a 12-unit application. We're looking at a 12-unit application. That was a 10-unit application. Okay. And where did the two units come from? That was a product of working with the town on the application and that the town really preferred that we just used one building, not both buildings, to cut down on cost. Okay. So that was part of that. But under this application, we'd like to go for the full 12 units. Okay.

2:05:36 So this would be an application to do all the work on the full 12 units that MLH owns. Okay. So I would think that the budget, to your point, is substantially similar. I mean, there's two additional units added, but it's basically the same project. More or less, yes. Same goals, same aspirations, what their model is going to look like. It might have been helpful if, again, as a board member to say, I appreciate that, yeah, just pass a resolution to do it, but it might have been helpful to see some.

2:06:05 I don't know. Here's the budget we're basing this on. This is what was in the CDGB application. This is what we're aspiring to do. I guess as a board member, it would have been helpful to see some of that kind of stuff. So I had a better idea of what we're proposing, what it is we're trying to do. Talk to, I guess, advise the board if you could on what the coordination with the town was on this application.

2:06:28 And how closely coordinated is it? Or is it not coordinated with the town? Because this is purely an application as a CHOTO, and so there is no coordination with the town. Well, there's been no application. So we're waiting for authorization from the board to proceed. So there's no application to coordinate with on us yet. If there's direction tonight to move forward, then we'll do.

2:06:49 Town staff's in the room. They're certainly aware of it, and we can talk with them about it, but there's no coordination up to this point on this. They're aware of the NOFA because we know about similar NOFAs. We talk about these things. The town's not eligible to apply under this program right now because they just received an award last year, and there's some thresholds they must meet before they can go back in.

2:07:13 We've coordinated with the town staff on this project under the CDBG application so they're aware of the project that we're envisioning for this site. That is not an unknown quantity. That is known. But no coordination further than that has taken place as of yet on the application that hasn't begun. Sure. But once the application goes forward, what would you anticipate the...

2:07:38 What kind of coordination would happen with the town as its application is prepared, if any, because it's a CHOTO application, maybe it's not necessary. That's one question. The other question is, I'm assuming this would need to be an all-in project. MLH is applying as a CHOTO, meaning we're applying as a developer, correct? And I just wanted to have some representation of any anticipation involvement with the town, your point about budget overages and costs and all that kind of stuff. Is this a project that MLH is taking on as a developer?

2:08:08 Exclusively and specifically, that would be good for the board to know. And any thoughts you have about what role the town may or may not be playing in this as a project that MLH would be pursuing as a developer? Well, go ahead. Well, I think it's all going to depend also on whether or not the CDBG grant is funded. So I think there's still a lot of unknowns. That was a joint application with a lot of coordination and the town.

2:08:35 The town was heavily involved in that application. So I think we won't know until we find out if that was funded or not, how really the rest of this is going to proceed. So would you anticipate, let's say you get a notice like next week that the CD, I keep messing up the acronym, but that was funded. Would you anticipate withdrawing this application and not submitting an application for these funds? No, I think, I mean, I would have to look at everything, but I would believe that we would want to...

2:09:04 The additional funding for any overages we might have and maybe to complete the additional two units. Okay. Modify the application. That's why it's a good idea to put your maximum amount that you would apply for. It doesn't mean you have to apply for that. You can apply for less, but if we got the CDBG funding, then we could apply for some home funding to do the other half of that project.

2:09:30 The other building, if you will, and do the last two units, finish out that project with additional funding. That would give us the capacity to do that. So that would be strategic. Doing that, the town would play a role with the application and any requirements that would be necessary to have a competitive application, whether that's, you know, I don't know what that is off the top of my head, but if there were things that were necessary, we would coordinate with the town.

2:09:59 To complete the application on anything that's required. Okay, but if, so, and how would, would someone advise the board as, hey, the CD, we were awarded the CDGB grant, that's been approved, we are therefore going to modify the application. I'm just, the board would not know, whatever we vote on a resolution, it just goes. The applications do on the 6th, you wouldn't know that night, yes. I understand, but if things happen, if the CDGB grant comes in and it's like, oh, we want to make a change, we want to start.

2:10:27 You know, I was a board member. I would like to know what's going on. Yeah. And I think if there's a need for a meeting or if you need some authorization of the board to make a decision to do something. Sure. That that would be forthcoming from staff so we can weigh in on those things. Well, seeing that I would be still your Executive Director up until the date that this application is due on the 6th of August, and if there was board direction necessary or approvals needed, then we would come back to you.

2:10:53 Okay. So let's go back. Let's assume the CDGB grant does not happen. And this is going to be a home loan application purely for MLH. My understanding is that this would be a project that MLH will be pursuing as a developer. We are entirely at risk.

2:11:11 I mean, we own this thing, and if there's overages, if there's issues, this is all on the responsibility of MLH, is that correct? That's correct, and that is why we have a reserve account, and we talked about, we just talked about the reserve accounts, and we have a reserve account for this property, yes. Okay, but there's no budget, I mean, you don't really know exactly what we're doing, but... Well, we have a budget, yes, but we haven't been approved, the funding hasn't been approved. All of the...

2:11:40 Any overages happen as you get to them, and that's why we have a reserve account. That's why we should continue to make this a priority, because things happen in construction. We know that. And to that question, how are we staffed? How would we work as developers to develop and provide project management services?

2:12:08 How would we do this project? Yeah, and I think that's a good question. I think that the organization would look to our partners at RCAC, the Rural Community Assistance Corporation.

2:12:25 for support as necessary. We've also applied for some pre-development loan grant funding. I'm not sure that we'll be awarded that, but we have applied for some of that as well. So we're really trying to put ourselves out there for multiple opportunities for moving this project forward, right?

2:12:49 And RCAC has a grant from HUD to offer capacity building to MLH, and so they're available to do that for us on an as-needed basis. So that's something that we have available right now. Well, I'm just thinking from, like, who's going to, if this grant gets awarded, who is going to be the, how are we going to project manage a three or four million dollar reconstruction project? How are we going to do that?

2:13:16 Having been through one, I'm confident that we can do it. Yeah. Especially with the support of RCAC, should we need it at any point. Okay. Absolutely. Does the board have the opportunity, if the grant's awarded, does the board have the opportunity to reject the grant? Yes. Okay. Those are my questions. Is there a time frame in which you have to spend the funds? Three years. Three years? Okay. And if you're

2:13:48 If you receive the grant for a lesser amount than what it's going to take to do the entire project, and there's an overall funny shortfall on the project, how do you address that? I can address that. You can come to the town council and say, I can step in. And you come to the town council and you would say,

2:14:12 You know, 1% of the TOT is supposed to be, you know, leveraging for housing. So, I mean, if there is this financial hole or this gap that occurs, I mean, the backup is the town. I don't believe there's going to be a financial gap or there's going to be a failure, you know, of us not having the money to complete the project. We've been successful in the past and we haven't had to come to the town for those kinds of issues. But, I mean, the town in Measure 2002A is the backup.

2:14:42 I would just say as a board member, I would caution all of us to make any assumption that the town, without having any, you know, that the town could be counted on, or it should be assumed that the town could be serving the role as a financial backup. I think that's irresponsible. And I think if this organization is a choto, is functioning as a choto, and as a developer, this has to be perceived as being an all-in project that this organization can do. I just think it's irresponsible to say, oh, just go to the town and get a bunch of money out of the town.

2:15:12 Well, and you know, the state's not going to award this grant if we don't present a really solid pro forma. And our pro forma is solid. And so I'm confident that we can move forward. But the board will see that. I mean, we have an opportunity. You can submit the grant, but the board will have the opportunity to review budget, the pro forma, how much money we've got for grant, all the rest of it, before we make an authorization to proceed to go forward. Correct? Right? So if the board has a chance to say whether or not we want to do this or not.

2:15:41 This board has the opportunity to make that decision. Yes, this is how affordable housing projects do move forward. You put in grant applications. You try to get the funding to get your project done. Right. Yes. Yeah, as long as the board, at the appropriate time, can look at the whole thing and say, can we pull this off or not, then I think that's a reasonable position to be in. Can you remind us of other terms of...

2:16:05 Home program funding. Is there a match required? Those sorts of things. And then also remind us of what other projects MLH has done with this program. So the Star Apartments, which we have a Star Reserve for, we have actually net rent proceeds from that project, which is a significant portion of that $45,000 this year.

2:16:30 That was a project done with CDBG funding, similar in the sense that it's federal funding, some different rules here and there, but that was a project where MLH bought the property, hired a general contractor, hired an architect, and worked through the process to relocate. We actually relocated people using grant funding. We relocated them out of their apartments.

2:16:56 For the time period that it took to gut and rehab the property and then move them back into their home and leased up the remaining units that were vacant using CDBG funding. That was four units. Smaller project, yes. We didn't use any outside consultants such as RCAC to help with capacity at that time and that was a staff of two. That was Pam, Hennerty, and myself and we did that project.

2:17:26 As far as match goes, there is no match requirement under the home program. The home program is a residual receipts program, similar to our other rental properties, the Aspen Village, Jefferies, Manzanita, that you pay 50% of your residual receipts if you can afford to, if you have the cash flow on there to do that. And was the Star Apartments, was that completed with?

2:17:53 Just with funding from the grant, or is there any outside funds that was used to complete that project? That was a collaboration. There were match funds required under that program, and the town provided those. And MLH, I think, contributed some money, too, just on little overages, things that kind of popped up. Nothing too significant. I think maybe we ended up being $100,000 over budget or something pretty minor, considering we have

2:18:22 for low income units that are indeed restricted for low income people for I think 50 or 99 years.

2:18:29 So it's a really good return on investment when you think about it in the sense that this is a partnership. Should the town ever be called upon to help with this project? I'm not saying they would or that we would need to, but should they? This is the kind of partnership that I think that we would want the town to enter into because it creates long-term affordability. Things that will be here long when we're gone.

2:18:56 These should be the priorities of the community, long-term affordability. In writing a budget for the grant application, has staff done an assessment of the building from the perspective of a remodel? I've remodeled two projects in town. You never know what happens until you open it up. Typically, developers will say, we are not responsible for anything that happens once we start this project. They're not going to guarantee anything if they haven't seen it yet.

2:19:24 What kind of due diligence or effort has staff done to take a look at the building so that when you're budgeting or writing a budget, it's something that a contractor is going to look at and say, yeah, I can, you know, he or she can do it for that, for whatever, however we've got a budget. Yeah. So when we bought the property, we did due diligence on that with an inspection, an extensive inspection of the entire property. Going forward, should we,

2:19:54 You know, we're making assumptions right now based on the cost of construction per square foot in Mammoth Lakes. We're estimating, I think new development is around $3.00 to $3.50 per square foot. We're estimating about $2.75 since this isn't a new build. We have a foundation. We have walls. We're not exterior. We have certain things that we do not have to build from the ground up. So those are our assumptions at this point.

2:20:20 That would change, obviously, should you be awarded and you start moving forward. I was going to ask Tom, what are you, 275 a square foot for new construction? No, not for new. This is not new. I understand, I'm sorry, I just wanted to just say. I mean, it sounds reasonable. I haven't seen the plans, so I don't know what the details are, but I mean, yeah, the fact is you have a roof, you have walls, I don't know whether you're changing windows out, what kind of plumbing. I think you have quite a bit of electrical.

2:20:46 It's a lot of work to do for bathrooms and so forth that don't exist, right, and kitchens and things like this. Right, absolutely. So, it just depends on the building. Right, and so the budget, the Performa, has contingencies built in at, I think, 15%, 10 to 15%. You had an architect grab some preliminary plans? No. You have to be really careful. This is something we went through with the CDBG, doing choice-limiting actions, and so you can't spend money on projects prior to...

2:21:17 It's not unreasonable. I mean, it sounds like a reasonable amount per foot on a per foot basis. But, I mean, keep in mind, too, you might have some site work to do as well and paving and... Right, and that's in the budget as well. That's not the construction. That's... Further questions? Yeah, I do have another question here. My question is, why would we ever turn down this CDBG funding? Just because we think we're going to go over budget? I think

2:21:52 With her past history, it seems like we can do it and do it right. And of course, there is maybe some overspending. But with them doing it before, I just feel very confident that it can be done again. And we really should move forward on this so we can get it done. You're talking about the home? You're talking about this one? You're talking about the home thing, right? Yes, I am talking about it. Not the CDGB. Yeah, I'm sorry, the home thing. Yeah, okay. Excellent comment. Come up to the podium, please.

2:22:28 Want me to bring that podium to you? No, thank you. I'm enjoying it back. For the discussion, can I hear a motion? I'll make a motion.

2:22:46 That it is that the board approve the resolution 1807 authorized in Mammoth Lake Housing, Inc., a certified community housing development organization to prepare and submit an application for funding for their rental rehabilitation project located at 238 Sierra Manor Road for up to $5 million. Do I hear a second? Second. I second. Moved and seconded. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. All those opposed?

2:23:18 Recuse. We will move to agenda item number 10. Update on the parcel. So this is just a long-running standing item that we have on our agenda. It's an informational item. We just get a very informative report last month from town staff regarding the removal of trees and where they were on

2:23:50 Bringing forward an item to the town council, I think at their first meeting in August on public outreach. So I don't know. I haven't heard anything new. I don't know if staff has anything new to add that's happened since last month or if that's really where we are. We're still looking at the first meeting in August to have an update. Second meeting in August. Okay, thank you. So look for that on the council agenda. Tom, do you have anything to add?

2:24:25 If there's nothing further on agenda item number 10, we'll move to agenda item number 11, board member reports. Anyone? Stacey? Pardon? Oh, I'm sorry. It's been pretty loud anyway. I just wanted to note that on June 19th, the Mono County Board of Supervisors had a housing workshop. Patricia attended and participated where we discussed

2:24:59 Many of the same concepts that are in the town's community housing action plan, the county level we're calling it, are housing

2:25:06 Toolbox. And some of these concepts have been taken out through the Regional Planning Advisory Committee, Community Development Department process to get community feedback, what ideas community members liked, didn't like. So that's all still in process. The board gave some feedback on that. More significantly, I would say, and by the way, the board's very supportive of working with the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing to implement

2:25:36 The Housing Action Plan and many of the programs that everybody likes, such as short-term rental management, are things that there should be one administration. The board was very supportive and receptive to working together with the town and MLH. Our community development staff brought us, first we had a presentation on an updated version of our county housing mitigation ordinance.

2:26:06 The consultant, which I didn't write the name down and don't have it off the top of my head, but we hired a consultant funded through a CDBG grant, by the way. The consultant presented in detail the methodology behind a recommended housing mitigation ordinance. The board wasn't quite ready to move forward with that. We wanted to...

2:26:28 Get more community feedback. So unfortunately, it looks like the county once again will have to do another round of suspending, keeping our housing mitigation ordinance in suspension while we work on the new one. Because the current suspension was set to expire in August, and so staff was hoping...

2:26:51 We could bring back the updated version in July to go through the ordinance process, but we weren't ready to do that. It's a big deal, as our discussion tonight proved. Similar points were made by board members, so we'll be bringing that back. So we look forward to having Jennifer on the board for that discussion.

2:27:15 But if you're interested, I think it would be worth your while. I think maybe it was an hour-long workshop. You can go on the county's website and watch the video. But it was a good discussion. Giselle? Tom? Yeah. Just a couple things. Not so much a report as a request for the next meeting agenda. I'd like to, as a board, review the livability standards. I think you're right.

2:27:48 Just to make sure that we're in step with current trends and I know it's been a while since that's been looked at and I just think it might be pertinent as we start to discuss what types of products may be developed to meet the needs in the community and just make sure that that makes sense. I think it's just this new board member I'd like to it might be beneficial for a couple of programs as well and

2:28:16 And then just all this discussion about the Sierra Manor property, I mean, would staff be able to, I haven't even seen the plans or anything, is there, could you provide us a short presentation at the next? There's no plans, as I mentioned, we don't have plans, we have some conceptual, very conceptual drawings, because of the limitations on the funding, have to be really careful. I mean, as a board member, I'm certainly willing to lend my expertise and help and assist as I can, you know.

2:28:44 Don't have a lot of free time, but certainly can, you know, put my eyes and ears on it and help you out the best I can. So I don't know, to whatever degree, like John said, I mean, if you have whatever information you do have on it, you know, I'd love to hear more about it. Yeah, I assume the application, if it's submitted.

2:29:06 I don't know how big these things are, but maybe it's something that we could just review the application and say, look, this is what's been submitted and this is where we're at. The timing might be a little off just because of the Brown Act and the application being submitted. It's due on the 6th, our meeting's on the 6th. Sure. Well, you may just do a presentation or something. Yeah, it may not just be included in your packet. That would be the one caution I would have. Okay. Just because of the timing. I mean, for that matter, it could be the next meeting in September. Okay, okay.

2:29:33 Yeah, whenever they're logged out. Okay. Well, that seems reasonable. Thank you. That's all I have. Donna? No, I'm good. Thank you. So a couple things. One is we've discussed or we've discussed around the idea of Choteau, this group, and I've been trying to be very careful to make sure that I'm speaking as an elected representative appropriately around that discussion. And I've checked for the town council and

2:30:00 Lawyer. And it's okay to be kind of talked about this in a general sense. I want to advise the board that I'm hoping that on August 1st there'll be an agenda item in front of the town council to review what the constraints are or how we do this. What role can MLH play as a CHOTO in the implementation of the Community Housing Action Plan?

2:30:29 And it's an important thing to look at and to get the full council to take a look at it and to understand, based on the advice of the town's attorneys and staff, how are we going to do this? And this matters because the Community Housing Action Plan is a unique document in the history of the town, as far as I know. This is the first time that a whole bunch of partners in the community really looked at housing from the perspective of being kind of a crisis.

2:30:57 And we have to, it's an all hands on deck approach and we have to do everything we can to deliver housing on behalf of the community. And there's things in there that I just want to reiterate that are important. Tom, there's things that are, you brought up ideas about, well, gee, we don't quite know who's doing what and who's supposed to be doing things. That is all very specifically addressed in the Community Housing Action Plan. And it's the roles and responsibilities, and more importantly, the accountability.

2:31:25 is specifically addressed in the plan. So if the town, as the lead on this plan, fails to meet the interests and the needs of the community, the voters have the opportunity to hold the town, to hold somebody accountable.

2:31:40 To say, you're not delivering what we need. This is not working for this community. They can vote people out of office. They can call them. They can do whatever they want to do. But the plan is structured in such a way that the community has the opportunity to hold the town and its partners accountable for what actually happens. That's written into the plan. There's just a lot of discussion about that.

2:32:03 You know, the town leadership is required to evolve the housing program to the next level. These are some quotes from the plan itself. I would encourage all of you to take a look at this, the Summary of Recommended Plan Governance Needs and Roles, which is in the Community Housing Action Plan. It's on page 16. It really lays out how this thing is intended to work. The gentleman from Aspen mentioned the system in Aspen. That is clearly our aspiration. So however you engage with the community housing need or opportunity,

2:32:32 If you're entering it through a contracted partner or through the town, you're working with an ecosystem that can deliver the kinds of things you want to do. That's certainly my goal, my objective, is that the town and the community get to having a reliable, good, and effective community housing system. That's a great point. I'm glad you brought that up.

2:32:52 And so the town's housing coordinator, the town has allocated some money to hire a housing coordinator. It's critically important. There's a lot of discussion that happens here that I hope doesn't happen at the town council level, which is it's staff level stuff. We're talking as if we're staff members. And we need to be sure that the council stays in its policymaking role, its leadership and guidance role, and issues that are staff things, coordination.

2:33:17 Who does what, making all that stuff happen, is appropriately happening at a staff level. And I think I'm very much looking forward to get that housing coordinator on board with the town to help really work with staff to coordinate things going forward. And that's why the position was added as a part of the action plan.

2:33:34 The issue with the charter really has to do with this issue of board representation. It's a specific thing in the Community Housing Action Plan. It's recommended the community representatives that reflect constituents involved in planned implementation be added to the MLH board. The chamber and or small business representative for interested employers in the community is one recommendation to ensure employer interests are represented. I look at this. This is an all hands on deck.

2:33:58 There's no way this community is going to do it. If we've got one group of people over here, one group of people over there, this is going to require all the resources of this community to be successful. And we have to figure out how we're going to do this. This is not a, I'm not making a request that

2:34:14 MLH, you know, we're not going after MLH's children. That's not what this is about. It's about how does a town which is responsible for the program, how can we contract and leverage the resources we've got to deliver a community housing action plan, the plan as is described in the document.

2:34:31 And it talks about also the chain of command, establish a reporting structure with multiple involved parties. It will be necessary to define to whom each party reports. Regarding implementation management, the town housing coordinator or like position is recommended to manage and receive reports from the multiple implementing and contracting entities with periodic reports to councils described below, blah, blah, blah. So there is really something in the middle of this who's coordinating and managing all the various

2:34:57 Capacities that we're leveraging to bring this thing forward. So I just wanted to get that on your radar. The exact item isn't clear yet, but I'm hoping it's going to be on the Council agenda for August 1st, and we'll discuss some of these things. So that's what I have to say. Thank you. Thank you. Lindsay? Just one thing. I came across a...

2:35:21 An application for funding through the Eastern Sierra Community Bank through my work, and I just passed it on to staff. So I don't know if it's very much money or anything, but they specifically had a line item for if you do work for affordable housing. So maybe that will come as something as well, get some more money. My report is that working with ESTA, we are currently, I believe, six drivers short.

2:35:51 And we're having a difficult time training new people. The temporary manager, executive director, right now has communicated to me that she's very worried about

2:36:12 Making sure that, you know, we have the summer transit for the different events and everything else, and she's having a very difficult time, you know, trying to get people trained. I think one suggestion is to reach out to the town to see if they have any employees, and reach out to the mountain to see if they have people with the right driving credentials and everything. So we're kind of, you know, right now,

2:36:42 It's going to be very difficult to meet all the driving requirements and making sure that we're, I guess, meeting the town needs and trying to do everything. So we're working hard on it. She's working very hard and we're going to be reaching out to a lot of different organizations to try to make sure that we get through this summer. We will be going into closed session to talk about

2:37:11 You know, the economics of and our contracts with our employees. So it's just simply we can't compete or we're not at an hourly rate that we can keep our drivers. And so it's, I mean, the housing issue and the labor issue is becoming, it's going to hit, might hit us this summer.

2:37:41 We're working hard on it. I think we've got a good temporary executive director, and she's very conscientious, trying to get up to speed. I guess that's all I have. You're saying we all need to get trained up to drive a trolley? Each council member must get a trolley license and drive a trolley at least one day a week. No problem. We will move to the next agenda item, which is

2:38:14 The monthly status report. Thank you. So we have I've reported everything in here. I don't know if there's any specific questions. I'm going to highlight a few things. We've got 85% of our

2:38:32 Either down payment assistance, recipients, or deed restricted owners that MLH monitors, 85% of them have responded to our annual monitoring, so that's very good. I think we have like nine people outstanding. So working with, working on calling them now, really shaming them into bringing in their documents.

2:38:55 We have 71 people on our rental waiting list. This is the biggest our rental waiting list has been in quite some time, but we do have some vacancies due to some rules around income. So we are filling units, working with our property manager to do that at the Aspen Village in Jeffries and Manzanita.

2:39:20 We did fill a 60% AMI two-bedroom unit, so 60% of the area median income apartment at Aspen Village to a single mom who works in tourism and hospitality. We did close on a loan using the Town of Mammoth Lakes Revolving Loan Fund from their program income.

2:39:45 From their home program, helping a single person buy a home that's self-employed in Mammoth Lakes. You can see that the single family home price is up to $890,000, the median, as of current year to date. That's 33 homes that sold. Condominiums are at $389,000 for the median. That's 165 condos that had sold as of the end of June.

2:40:15 Mammoth Lakes Housing. We had an incident maybe three months ago where, and maybe you read about this, somebody had found a unit on MLH's website, because we have a vacant seat bulletin board, and it was a scam. And this person was doing scams to all kinds of people.

2:40:39 Having them like Venmo or wire funds for a deposit on a unit that didn't exist. So we quickly shut down our site because as soon as we removed that listing, that person came back with another listing on our site and it was predatory in nature. And Al Davis, the chief, the police were notified, the town staff was notified, the county was notified. It was a real problem.

2:41:09 And so, you know, it's one of those things that can happen. Anybody can be taken advantage of right now, it feels like, in this internet world that we have. You hear about these stories with even Airbnbs, people getting scammed.

2:41:26 We took down our vacancy bulletin board and we just relaunched it. It's on a new platform. It has a clause on there that says that this is really a service we provide, much as if you went to Facebook and you posted that you had an apartment there on the buy, sell, or trade, that it's a service we provide, but we're not claiming that these are.

2:41:49 Safe or anything of that nature. It's just a service on the internet that we provide through our platform. So that's up. We'll be tracking that to see how that works now. We're hoping that it's better and that that doesn't happen again. But you never know when those things, when somebody's going to prey upon really vulnerable and desperate people like they are right now in California and across the nation on housing. That's all I have. Questions? If not, we will.

2:42:21 So I just noted that your last day is August 5th, and the next board meeting is August 6th, so we won't have a public opportunity to say thank you. So I wanted to take a minute to say thank you for your 12 years of service to the community through Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I and town staff wish you best of luck as a board, as a supervisor, and so we appreciate it, and good luck. Thank you. I appreciate that very much, Sandra.

2:42:56 Yeah, before we adjourn, Mr. President, I'm wondering what we're going to be doing to acknowledge Jennifer's, what we as a board are going to be doing to acknowledge Jennifer's service. I'm going to buy her a couple glasses of wine. Okay, by the way, again, I would like. If you can form a subcommittee to the party, I'll do it. Yeah, okay. I would like perhaps, if you could let us know, I think we'd all like to acknowledge Jennifer's service, all the work she's done here. I don't want to let this opportunity pass without. Thank you. If you could do something, maybe pull something together for that, that'd be appreciated.

2:43:25 Mr. Chair, if I could add that today, Governor Brown announced that Jennifer has been appointed to the Board of Supervisors, so congratulations. Thank you for bringing that up. I should note that I spoke with the Board Chair today, and he has requested that I step in sooner than later, and so while my last day here with Mammoth Lakes Housing is the 5th, I told him that I would

2:43:55 Be sworn in on the 10th. That's next week's meeting. And so I'll be taking next Tuesday off, and we'll see how it goes on the 17th, whether I'll take that day off and join the board or not. It's just kind of, as I can fit it in, it's a lot, as you all know, a lot of homework to be ready for a meeting. So, thank you. Congratulations. Congratulations to Motor County. Congratulations to you. Thank you. Very excited.

2:44:28 Thank you.